Unaudited figures CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Year ended 31 December 2023 -- 1 of 130 -- - 2 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 CONTENTS CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 4 PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2023 4 STATEMENT OF NET INCOME AND CHANGES IN ASSETS AND LIABILITIES RECOGNISED DIRECTLY IN EQUITY 5 BALANCE SHEET AT 31 DECEMBER 2023 6 CASH FLOW STATEMENT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2023 7 STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY 8 NOTES TO THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 10 1. SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES APPLIED BY THE GROUP 10 1.a Applicable Accounting standards 10 1.b Consolidation 14 1.c Translation of foreign currency transactions 18 1.d Financial information in hyperinflationary economies 19 1.e Net interest income, commissions and income from other activities 19 1.f Financial assets and liabilities 20 1.g Insurance activities 33 1.h Property, plant, equipment and intangible assets 38 1.i Leases 39 1.j Assets held for sale and discontinued operations 40 1.k Employee benefits 40 1.l Share-based payments 42 1.m Provisions recorded under liabilities 42 1.n Current and deferred tax 43 1.o Cash flow statement 43 1.p Use of estimates in the preparation of the financial statements 44 2. IFRS 17 AND IFRS 9 FIRST TIME APPLICATION IMPACTS 45 3. NOTES TO THE PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2023 48 3.a Net interest income 48 3.b Commission income and expense 49 3.c Net gain on financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss 50 3.d Net gain on financial instruments at fair value through equity 50 3.e Net income from other activities 51 3.f Operating expenses 51 3.g Cost of risk 52 3.h Other net losses for risk on financial instruments 61 3.i Net gain on non-current assets 61 3.j Corporate income tax 61 4. SEGMENT INFORMATION 62 5. NOTES TO THE BALANCE SHEET AT 31 DECEMBER 2023 67 5.a Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss 67 5.b Derivatives used for hedging purposes 69 5.c Financial assets at fair value through equity 72 5.d Measurement of the fair value of financial instruments 73 5.e Financial assets at amortised cost 83 5.f Impaired financial assets (stage 3) 85 5.g Financial liabilities at amortised cost due to credit institutions and customers 86 5.h Debt securities and subordinated debt 86 5.i Current and deferred taxes 88 -- 2 of 130 -- - 3 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5.j Accrued income/expense and other assets/liabilities 89 5.k Equity-method investments 89 5.l Property, plant, equipment and intangible assets used in operations, investment property 90 5.m Goodwill 91 5.n Provisions for contingencies and charges 95 5.o Offsetting of financial assets and liabilities 96 6. NOTES RELATED TO INSURANCE ACTIVITIES 99 6.a Net income from insurance activities 99 6.b Reconciliation of expenses by type and by function 101 6.c Investments, other assets and financial liabilities related to insurance activities 101 6.d Assets and liabilities related to insurance contracts 104 6.e Risk sensitivity 108 7. FINANCING AND GUARANTEE COMMITMENTS 110 7.a Financing commitments given or received 110 7.b Guarantee commitments given by signature 110 7.c Securities commitments 111 7.d Other guarantee commitments 111 8. SALARIES AND EMPLOYEE BENEFITS 112 8.a Salary and employee benefit expense 112 8.b Post-employment benefits 112 8.c Other long-term benefits 119 8.d Termination benefits 120 8.e Share-based payments 120 9. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 122 9.a Changes in share capital and earnings per share 122 9.b Minority interests 125 9.c Legal proceedings and arbitration 127 9.d Business combinations and loss of control or significant influence 128 9.e Discontinued activities 130 -- 3 of 130 -- - 4 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Prepared in accordance with IFRS as adopted by the European Union The Board of directors of BNP Paribas approved the Group consolidated financial statements on 31 January 2024. The consolidated financial statements of the BNP Paribas Group are presented for the years ended 31 December 2023 and 31 December 2022. In accordance with Annex I of European Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/980, the consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2021 are provided in the Universal registration document filed with the Autorité des Marchés Financiers on 24 March 2023 under number D.23-0143. On 18 December 2021, the Group concluded an agreement with BMO Financial Group for the sale of 100% of its retail and commercial banking activities in the United States operated by the BancWest cash-generating unit. The terms of this transaction fall within the scope of application of IFRS 5 relating to groups of assets and liabilities held for sale (see note 9.e Discontinued activities) leading to isolate the “Net income from discontinued activities” on a separate line. A similar reclassification is made in the statement of net income and changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity and in the cash flow statement. Following the receipt of regulatory approvals, the transaction was finalised on 1 February 2023. PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2023 In millions of euros Notes Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Interest income 3.a 79,542 41,082 Interest expense 3.a (60,484) (20,149) Commission income 3.b 15,011 14,622 Commission expense 3.b (5,190) (4,457) Net gain on financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss 3.c 10,346 9,352 Net gain on financial instruments at fair value through equity 3.d 28 138 Net gain on derecognised financial assets at amortised cost 66 (41) Net income from insurance activities 6.a 2,320 1,901 of which Insurance revenue 8,945 8,759 Insurance service expenses (6,786) (6,619) Investment return 10,254 (12,077) Net finance income or expenses from insurance contracts (10,093) 11,838 Income from other activities 3.e 18,560 15,734 Expense on other activities 3.e (14,325) (12,752) REVENUES FROM CONTINUING ACTIVITIES 45,874 45,430 Operating expenses 3.f (28,713) (27,560) Depreciation, amortisation and impairment of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets 5.l (2,243) (2,304) GROSS OPERATING INCOME FROM CONTINUING ACTIVITIES 14,918 15,566 Cost of risk 3.g (2,907) (3,003) Other net losses for risk on financial instruments 3.h (775) - OPERATING INCOME FROM CONTINUING ACTIVITIES 11,236 12,563 Share of earnings of equity-method entities 5.k 593 655 Net gain on non-current assets 3.i (104) (253) Goodwill 5.m - 249 PRE-TAX INCOME FROM CONTINUING ACTIVITIES 11,725 13,214 Corporate income tax from continuing activities 3.j (3,266) (3,653) NET INCOME FROM CONTINUING ACTIVITIES 8,459 9,561 Net income from discontinued activities 9.e 2,947 687 NET INCOME 11,406 10,248 Net income attributable to minority interests 431 400 NET INCOME ATTRIBUTABLE TO EQUITY HOLDERS 10,975 9,848 Basic earnings per share 9.a 8.58 7.52 Diluted earnings per share 9.a 8.58 7.52 -- 4 of 130 -- - 5 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 STATEMENT OF NET INCOME AND CHANGES IN ASSETS AND LIABILITIES RECOGNISED DIRECTLY IN EQUITY In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Net income for the period 11,406 10,248 Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity 596 (2,183) Items that are or may be reclassified to profit or loss 367 (2,381) - Changes in exchange differences (109) 1,041 - Changes in fair value of financial assets at fair value through equity Changes in fair value recognised in equity 244 (754) Changes in fair value reported in net income 27 (120) - Changes in fair value of investments of insurance activities Changes in fair value recognised in equity 4,665 (19,962) Changes in fair value reported in net income 558 (1) - Changes in fair value of contracts of insurance activities (4,573) 18,102 - Changes in fair value of hedging instruments Changes in fair value recognised in equity 146 (1,459) Changes in fair value reported in net income 22 14 - Income tax (283) 1,062 - Changes in equity-method investments, after tax (162) 136 - Changes in discontinued activities, after tax (168) (440) Items that will not be reclassified to profit or loss 229 198 - Changes in fair value of equity instruments designated as at fair value through equity 232 (57) - Debt remeasurement effect arising from BNP Paribas Group issuer risk 45 515 - Remeasurement gains (losses) related to post-employment benefit plans (173) (102) - Income tax 11 (81) - Changes in equity-method investments, after tax 114 (83) - Changes in discontinued activities, after tax - 6 Total 12,002 8,065 - Attributable to equity shareholders 11,479 7,572 - Attributable to minority interests 523 493 -- 5 of 130 -- - 6 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 BALANCE SHEET AT 31 DECEMBER 2023 In millions of euros Notes 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 1 January 2022 IAS 29, IFRS 17 and 9 ASSETS Cash and balances at central banks 288,259 318,560 347,883 Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss Securities 5.a 211,634 166,077 191,507 Loans and repurchase agreements 5.a 227,175 191,125 249,808 Derivative financial instruments 5.a 292,079 327,932 240,423 Derivatives used for hedging purposes 5.b 21,692 25,401 8,680 Financial assets at fair value through equity Debt securities 5.c 50,274 35,878 38,915 Equity securities 5.c 2,275 2,188 2,558 Financial assets at amortised cost Loans and advances to credit institutions 5.e 24,335 32,616 21,751 Loans and advances to customers 5.e 859,200 857,020 814,000 Debt securities 5.e 121,161 114,014 108,612 Remeasurement adjustment on interest-rate risk hedged portfolios (2,661) (7,477) 3,005 Investments and other assets related to insurance activities 6.c 257,098 245,475 282,288 Current and deferred tax assets 5.i 6,556 5,932 5,954 Accrued income and other assets 5.j 170,758 208,543 177,176 Equity-method investments 5.k 6,751 6,073 5,468 Property, plant and equipment and investment property 5.l 45,222 38,468 35,191 Intangible assets 5.l 4,142 3,790 3,659 Goodwill 5.m 5,549 5,294 5,121 Assets held for sale 9.e - 86,839 91,267 TOTAL ASSETS 2,591,499 2,663,748 2,633,266 LIABILITIES Deposits from central banks 3,374 3,054 1,244 Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss Securities 5.a 104,910 99,155 112,338 Deposits and repurchase agreements 5.a 273,614 234,076 292,160 Issued debt securities 5.a 83,763 65,578 64,197 Derivative financial instruments 5.a 278,892 300,121 237,635 Derivatives used for hedging purposes 5.b 38,011 40,001 10,076 Financial liabilities at amortised cost Deposits from credit institutions 5.g 95,175 124,718 165,698 Deposits from customers 5.g 988,549 1,008,056 957,684 Debt securities 5.h 191,482 155,359 150,822 Subordinated debt 5.h 24,743 24,160 24,720 Remeasurement adjustment on interest-rate risk hedged portfolios (14,175) (20,201) 1,367 Current and deferred tax liabilities 5.i 3,821 2,979 3,016 Accrued expenses and other liabilities 5.j 143,673 185,010 146,520 Liabilities related to insurance contracts 6.d 218,043 209,772 240,118 Financial liabilities related to insurance activities 6.c 18,239 18,858 20,041 Provisions for contingencies and charges 5.n 10,518 10,040 10,187 Liabilities associated with assets held for sale 9.e - 77,002 74,366 TOTAL LIABILITIES 2,462,632 2,537,738 2,512,189 EQUITY Share capital, additional paid-in capital and retained earnings 115,809 115,008 107,938 Net income for the period attributable to shareholders 10,975 9,848 9,488 Total capital, retained earnings and net income for the period attributable to shareholders 126,784 124,856 117,426 Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity (3,042) (3,619) (1,021) Shareholders' equity 123,742 121,237 116,405 Minority interests 9.b 5,125 4,773 4,672 TOTAL EQUITY 128,867 126,010 121,077 TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY 2,591,499 2,663,748 2,633,266 -- 6 of 130 -- - 7 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 CASH FLOW STATEMENT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2023 In millions of euros Notes Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS17 and 9 Pre-tax income from continuing activities 11,725 13,214 Pre-tax income from discontinued activities 3,658 823 Non-monetary items included in pre-tax net income and other adjustments 8,495 21,838 Net depreciation/amortisation expense on property, plant and equipment and intangible assets 6,245 6,465 Impairment of goodwill and other non-current assets (32) 91 Net addition to provisions 3,646 3,193 Variation of assets/liabilities related to insurance contracts (6,240) (837) Share of earnings of equity-method entities (593) (655) Net income (expense) from investing activities (3,600) 265 Net expense (income) from financing activities 506 (1,192) Other movements 8,563 14,508 Net decrease related to assets and liabilities generated by operating activities (58,119) (88,712) Net decrease related to transactions with customers and credit institutions (7,751) (46,438) Net decrease related to transactions involving other financial assets and liabilities (32,712) (30,212) Net decrease related to transactions involving non-financial assets and liabilities (14,297) (10,063) Taxes paid (3,359) (1,999) NET DECREASE IN CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS GENERATED BY OPERATING ACTIVITIES (34,241) (52,837) Net increase related to acquisitions and disposals of consolidated entities 9,520 366 Net decrease related to property, plant and equipment and intangible assets (2,216) (2,529) NET INCREASE (DECREASE) IN CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS RELATED TO INVESTING ACTIVITIES 7,304 (2,163) Decrease in cash and cash equivalents related to transactions with shareholders (8,698) (2,578) Increase in cash and cash equivalents generated by other financing activities 4,022 11,828 NET DECREASE (INCREASE) IN CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS RELATED TO FINANCING ACTIVITIES (4,676) 9,250 EFFECT OF MOVEMENT IN EXCHANGE RATES ON CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS (3,506) 1,030 NET DECREASE IN CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS (35,119) (44,720) of which net increase (decrease) in cash and cash equivalents from discontinued activities 9,909 (11,935) Balance of cash and cash equivalent accounts at the start of the period 317,698 362,418 Cash and amounts due from central banks 318,581 347,901 Due to central banks (3,054) (1,244) On demand deposits with credit institutions 11,927 10,156 On demand loans from credit institutions 5.g (12,538) (9,105) Deduction of receivables and accrued interest on cash and cash equivalents 163 156 Cash and cash equivalent accounts classified as "Assets held for sale" 2,619 14,554 Balance of cash and cash equivalent accounts at the end of the period 282,579 317,698 Cash and amounts due from central banks 288,279 318,581 Due to central banks (3,374) (3,054) On demand deposits with credit institutions 8,352 11,927 On demand loans from credit institutions 5.g (10,770) (12,538) Deduction of receivables and accrued interest on cash and cash equivalents 92 163 Cash and cash equivalent accounts classified as "Assets held for sale" - 2,619 NET DECREASE IN CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS (35,119) (44,720) -- 7 of 130 -- - 8 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY Capital and retained earnings Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity that will not be reclassified to profit or loss In millions of euros Share capital and additional paid-in-capital Undated Super Subordinated Notes Non- distributed reserves Total Financial assets designated as at fair value through equity Own-credit valuation adjustment of debt securities designated as at fair value through profit or loss Remeasurement gains (losses) related to post- employment benefit plans Discontinued activities Total Balance at 31 December 2021 26,347 9,207 82,110 117,664 840 (267) 549 (125) 997 Impacts of IAS 29 1st application in Türkiye (39) (39) - Impacts of the transition to IFRS 17 (note 2) (2,619) (2,619) - Impacts of the transition to IFRS 9 (note 2) 2,420 2,420 258 258 Balance at 1 January 2022 26,347 9,207 81,872 117,426 1,098 (267) 549 (125) 1,255 Appropriation of net income for 2021 (4,527) (4,527) - Increases in capital and issues 5,024 (4) 5,020 - Reduction or redemption of capital (2,430) (123) (2,553) - Movements in own equity instruments (157) (1) (151) (309) - Remuneration on undated super subordinated notes (374) (374) - Impact of internal transactions on minority shareholders (note 9.b) 1 1 - Movements in consolidation scope impacting minority shareholders (note 9.b) - - Acquisitions of additional interests or partial sales of interests (note 9.b) - - Change in commitments to repurchase minority shareholders' interests (2) (2) - Other movements 4 4 - Realised gains or losses reclassified to retained earnings 322 322 (326) 3 1 (322) Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity - (187) 383 (10) 6 192 Net income for 2022 9,848 9,848 - Balance at 31 December 2022 26,190 11,800 86,866 124,856 585 119 540 (119) 1,125 Appropriation of net income for 2022 (4,744) (4,744) - Increases in capital and issues 1,670 (2) 1,668 - Reduction or redemption of capital (4,983) (17) (5,000) - Movements in own equity instruments (5) 2 (218) (221) - Share-based payment plans (8) (8) - Remuneration on undated super subordinated notes (654) (654) - Impact of internal transactions on minority shareholders (note 9.b) (21) (21) - Movements in consolidation scope impacting minority shareholders (note 9.b) - - Acquisitions of additional interests or partial sales of interests (note 9.b) 1 1 - Change in commitments to repurchase minority shareholders' interests 9 9 - Other movements (4) (4) - Realised gains or losses reclassified to retained earnings (73) (73) (34) (8) (4) 119 73 Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity - 304 35 (105) 234 Net income for 2023 10,975 10,975 - Balance at 31 December 2023 21,202 13,472 92,110 126,784 855 146 431 - 1,432 -- 8 of 130 -- - 9 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 BETWEEN 1 JANUARY 2022 AND 31 DECEMBER 2023 Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity that may be reclassified to profit or loss Total shareholders' equity Minority interests (note 9.b) Total equity Exchange differences Financial assets at fair value through equity Financial investments and contracts of insurance activities Derivatives used for hedging purposes Discontinued activities Total (4,335) 122 1,811 1,019 608 (775) 117,886 4,621 122,507 165 165 126 48 174 533 533 (2,086) 12 (2,074) (2,199) (2,199) 479 (9) 470 (4,170) 122 145 1,019 608 (2,276) 116,405 4,672 121,077 - (4,527) (133) (4,660) - 5,020 34 5,054 - (2,553) (2,553) - (309) (309) - (374) (374) - 1 2 3 - - (136) (136) - - - - (2) (157) (159) - 4 (2) 2 - - - 980 (633) (1,607) (768) (440) (2,468) (2,276) 93 (2,183) - 9,848 400 10,248 (3,190) (511) (1,462) 251 168 (4,744) 121,237 4,773 126,010 - (4,744) (179) (4,923) - 1,668 316 1,984 - (5,000) (5,000) - (221) (221) - (8) 1 (7) - (654) (3) (657) - (21) 21 - - - (90) (90) - 1 (12) (11) - 9 (225) (216) - (4) (4) - - - (239) 153 490 34 (168) 270 504 92 596 - 10,975 431 11,406 (3,429) (358) (972) 285 - (4,474) 123,742 5,125 128,867 -- 9 of 130 -- - 10 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 NOTES TO THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Prepared in accordance with IFRS as adopted by the European Union 1. SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES APPLIED BY THE GROUP 1.a APPLICABLE ACCOUNTING STANDARDS The consolidated financial statements of the BNP Paribas Group have been prepared in accordance with international accounting standards (International Financial Reporting Standards – IFRS), as adopted for use in the European Union1. Accordingly, certain provisions of IAS 39 on hedge accounting have been excluded. Information on the nature and extent of risks relating to financial instruments as required by IFRS 7 “Financial Instruments: Disclosures” and to insurance contracts as required by IFRS 17 “Insurance Contracts”, along with information on regulatory capital required by IAS 1 “Presentation of Financial Statements” will be presented in chapter 5 of the Universal registration document. This information is an integral part of the notes to the consolidated financial statements of the BNP Paribas Group at 31 December 2023. Section 4 of chapter 5, paragraph Exposures, provisions and cost of risk provides, in particular, IFRS 7 information on credit risk exposures and related impairment broken down according to whether the underlying loans are performing or non-performing, by geographic area and by industry. • Since 1 January 2023, BNP Paribas Group’s insurance entities have applied IFRS 17 “Insurance Contracts” published in May 2017, amended in June 2020 and adopted by the European Union in November 2021, including the exemption provided for in Article 2 of regulation 2021/2036 regarding annual cohorts. The transition date for IFRS 17 is 1 January 2022 for the purposes of the opening balance sheet of the comparative period required by the standard. As the Group deferred the application of IFRS 9 “Financial Instruments” for its insurance entities until the entry into force of IFRS 17, therefore they apply this standard from 1 January 2023. In addition, the entry into force of IFRS 17 brings into effect various amendments to other standards, including IAS 1 for presentation, IAS 16 and IAS 40 for the valuation and presentation of real estate assets, IAS 28 for exemptions from the equity method and IAS 32 and IFRS 9 for own equity instruments and other securities issued by the Group. Finally, the amendment to IFRS 17 “Initial application of IFRS 17 and IFRS 9 – Comparative information” published by the IASB in December 2021 and adopted by the European Union on 9 September 2022 allows insurance companies applying IFRS 9 and IFRS 17 for the first time simultaneously to present 2022 comparative data as if IFRS 9 was already applied, using an “overlay” approach. The Group applied this optional approach for all financial instruments, including those derecognised in 2022, for both classification and measurement purposes. - Transition from IFRS 4 to IFRS 17 IFRS 17 applies retroactively to all contracts outstanding at the transition date, i.e. 1 January 2022 due to the mandatory comparative period. Three transition methods may be used: a full retrospective approach and, if this cannot be implemented, a modified retrospective approach or an approach based on the fair value of the contracts at the transition date. 1 The full set of standards adopted for use in the European Union can be found on the website of the European Commission at: https://ec.europa.eu/info/business-economy-euro/company-reporting-and-auditing/company-reporting_en -- 10 of 130 -- - 11 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The majority of entities controlled by the Group have applied the modified retrospective approach and, to a lesser extent, for some portfolios, an approach based on the fair value of contracts at the transition date. As a matter of fact, not all the necessary information was available or was not sufficiently granular, in particular due to systems migration and data retention requirements, to apply a full retrospective approach. Moreover, the full retrospective approach would have required reconstituting management’s assumptions and intentions in previous periods. The objective of the modified retrospective approach is to achieve a result that is as close as possible to the result that would have been obtained through the retrospective application of the standard, based on reasonable and supportable information available without undue costs or effort. Thus, the entities concerned applied the modified retrospective approach to most portfolios of existing contracts, whether in Protection or Life/Savings, according to the principles below. For Protection contracts valued according to the general model, the principle of the modified retrospective approach consists in reconstituting liabilities at the initial recognition date based on their valuation at the transition date, by retroactively reconstituting movements between the two dates with simplifications: - cash flows at inception are estimated by adding the actual cash flows recorded between the two dates, to the amount at the transition date; - the original discount rate can be determined with interest rate curves simulating those at the date of first recognition; - the changes in the adjustment for non-financial risk between the inception date and the transition date can be estimated based on release patterns observed on similar contracts. For liabilities for remaining coverage that are reconstituted in this way at the inception date, the contractual service margin at inception (if any), less any acquisition costs paid in the interim period, is amortised based on the services provided in the period prior to the transition, in order to determine the amount of the remaining contractual service margin at that date, less any remaining acquisition costs. When contracts are grouped into a single group on the transition date, the discount rate on that date or an average rate can be used. The effect of the change in the discount rate on liabilities is recognised in the profit and loss account, unless the option to split financial changes between profit and loss and shareholders’ equity is retained. Choosing this option requires the amount carried in shareholders’ equity at the transition date to be recalculated from the inception rate for the liability for remaining coverage and from the rate at the date of claims occurrence for the liability for incurred claims. Where such reconstitution is not possible, the amount shown in equity is zero. For the purposes of this reconstitution, the simplifications mainly covered the following: - reconstitution of the annual cohorts or consolidation into a single group of contracts at the transition date according to available data; - the reconstitution of fulfilment cash flows and unamortised acquisition costs; - the release of the risk adjustment between the date of issuance of the contracts and the transition date; - discount rates (the rate at inception in the case of a reconstitution by annual cohorts or an average rate in the case of a consolidation into a single group of contracts at the transition date); - the amount transferred to changes in equity that may be reclassified to profit or loss at the transition date in respect of changes in the discount rate, that was reconstituted based on historical rates or reset to zero if such a reconstitution is not achievable. For Protection contracts valued according to the simplified method, the reserves for remaining coverage were generally determined at transition from the previous reserves for unearned premiums, net of acquisition costs. The incurred claims reserves arising from these contracts consist of expected cash flows and risk adjustments for non-financial risks at the transition date. When cash flows were discounted and for portfolios for which the disaggregation option of financial changes between profit and loss account and shareholders’ equity has been chosen, the amount carried in changes in equity that may be reclassified to profit or loss at the transition date in relation to changes in the discount rate was reconstituted based on the historical rates or set to zero if such a reconstitution was not achievable. -- 11 of 130 -- - 12 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 For Life/Savings contracts valued under the variable fee approach, the modified retrospective approach also consists in reconstituting the liability at the inception date, starting from the liability at the transition date. However, for these contracts, the standard provides that the contractual services margin at the transition date is determined using the following approach: - the realisable value of the underlying assets at the transition date is first diminished by the fulfilment cash flows (discounted cash flows and risk adjustment) at that date; - to this amount are added the income received from the policyholders and changes in the risk adjustment, less the acquisition cashflows paid during the interim period; - the contractual service margin net of the acquisition costs initially reconstituted is then amortised until the transition date to reflect the services provided to that date, as well as the remaining acquisition costs. The main simplifications in implementing this approach were as follows: - existing contracts were grouped according to the planned post-transition segmentation, without a breakdown in annual cohorts, in line with the election of the exemption provided for by the European regulation; - for general funds common to participating and non-participating contracts and to equity, the underlying assets were defined on the basis of the breakdown used to calculate policyholders’ participation; - the contractual services margin at the transition date was reconstituted: o based on the fair value of the underlying assets less fulfilment cash flows at the transition date; o by adding the historical margins which were rolled over up to the transition date, using the same approach as that to be used after the transition, taking into account the “over- performance” on assets, and; o deducting any remaining acquisition costs; - the amount recorded in changes in equity that may be reclassified to profit or loss at the transition date as an adjustment for accounting mismatches was determined using the fair value of the underlying assets recognised in equity at the transition date. Finally, under the fair value method, the contractual service margin at the transition date was determined as the difference at the transition date between the realisable value determined without taking into account the amount payable on demand and the fulfilment cash flows. This approach was used on some non-material portfolios when the modified retrospective approach could not be implemented. For these portfolios, the fair value was estimated based on a Solvency 2 valuation and, in the particular case of a recent business combination dating from 2018, based on the amount allocated to the contracts during the acquisition price allocation process. - Transition from IAS 39 to IFRS 9 Financial assets and liabilities of insurance entities are managed by portfolios corresponding either to the insurance liabilities they back up or to the own funds. The business models were therefore determined according to these portfolios at the transition date to IFRS 9 (see. note 2 IFRS 17 and IFRS 9 First time application impacts). - Amendments to other standards related to IFRS 17 The Group also applied the changes in IAS 40 and IAS 16 resulting from IFRS 17, leading to the measurement of property held as underlying assets of direct participating contracts at fair value through profit or loss. It also applied the amendments to IAS 32 and IFRS 9, making it possible to maintain on the balance sheet financial assets issued by the Group that are held as assets underlying direct participating contracts and are measured at fair value through profit or loss. Business combinations (including goodwill) prior to the transition date were not modified except for the cancellation of specific intangible assets under IFRS 4. • In relation to the IBOR and Eonia rates reform, at the end of 2018 the Group launched a global transition programme, involving all business lines and functions. The aim of the programme was to manage and implement the transition from the old benchmark interest rates to the new ones in major jurisdictions and currencies (euro, pound sterling, US dollar, Swiss franc and Japanese yen), while reducing the risks associated with this transition and meeting the deadlines set by the competent authorities. The Group contributed to market-wide workshops with central banks and financial regulators. -- 12 of 130 -- - 13 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 In Europe, the Eonia-€STR transition, which was purely technical given the fixed link between these two indices, was finalised at the end of December 2021 while the maintenance of Euribor on a sine die basis was confirmed. Publication of JPY synthetic Libor was discontinued at the end of 2022. Regarding synthetic GBP Libor, the publication of the 1-month and 6-month settings ceased in March 2023, thereby only leaving the 3-month setting, which will subsist until March 2024. In the United States, the decision was taken to continue publishing the USD Libor until mid-2023, and a legislative solution was passed at the federal level in the first quarter of 2022 to address legacy US-law governed contracts. In early April 2023, the FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) announced its decision to compel ICE BA (as benchmark administrator) to continue publication of 1-month, 3-month and 6-month USD Libor after 30 June 2023 and until 30 September 2024, using a synthetic methodology. Through the implementation and execution of a detailed transition plan, the Group finalised its migration to the new reference rates. In September 2019, the IASB published “Phase 1” amendments to IAS 39 and IFRS 7, amending the hedge accounting requirements so that hedges affected by the benchmark interest rate reform could continue despite the uncertainty during the transition of the hedged items or hedging instruments to the reformed benchmark rates. These amendments, endorsed by the European Commission on 15 January 2020, have been applied by the Group since 31 December 2019. In August 2020, the IASB published “Phase 2” amendments to IFRS 9, IAS 39, IFRS 7, IFRS 4 and IFRS 16 introducing several changes applicable during the effective transition to the new benchmark interest rates. These amendments allow for changes in the contractual cash flows of financial instruments resulting from the IBOR rates reform to be treated as a simple reset of their variable interest rate, provided, however, that such changes are made on an economically equivalent basis. They also allow the continuation of hedging relationships, subject to amendments to their documentation to reflect changes in hedged instruments, hedging instruments, hedged risk, and/or the method for measuring effectiveness during the transition to the new benchmark rates. These amendments, adopted by the European Commission in December 2020, have been applied by the Group since 31 December 2020 to maintain its existing hedging relationships which have been modified as a result of the transition to the new RFRs. • Further to the Pillar II recommendations of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) in relation to the international tax reform, the European Union adopted on 14 December 2022 the 2022/2523 directive instituting a minimum corporate income tax for international groups, effective 1 January 2024. To clarify the directive’s potential impacts, the IASB issued on 23 May 2023 a series of amendments to IAS 12 “Income Taxes”, which were adopted by the European Union on 8 November 2023. In accordance with the provisions of these amendments, the Group applies the mandatory and temporary exception not to recognise deferred taxes associated with this additional taxation. Based on the available information, the impact of the Pillar II reform are expected to be non-material for the Group once adopted. • In France, changes resulting from the pension reform enacted on 14 April 2023 constitute a change in post-employment benefits, based on IAS 19 § 104. The non-material impact of this change was recorded in the profit and loss for the period. The introduction of other standards, amendments and interpretations that are mandatory as from 1 January 2023, in particular the amendments to IAS 1 “Presentation of Financial Statements”, IAS 8 “Changes in accounting estimates and errors” and “IAS 12 Income Tax”, had no effect on the Group’s financial statements at 31 December 2023. The Group did not early adopt any of the new standards, amendments, and interpretations adopted by the European Union, when the application in 2023 was optional. -- 13 of 130 -- - 14 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 1.b C ONSOLIDATION 1.b.1 SCOPE OF CONSOLIDATION The consolidated financial statements of BNP Paribas include entities that are controlled by the Group, jointly controlled, and under significant influence, with the exception of those entities whose consolidation is regarded as immaterial to the Group. Companies that hold shares in consolidated companies are also consolidated. Subsidiaries are consolidated from the date on which the Group obtains effective control. Entities under temporary control are included in the consolidated financial statements until the date of disposal. 1.b.2 CONSOLIDATION METHODS Exclusive control Controlled enterprises are fully consolidated. The Group controls a subsidiary when it is exposed, or has rights, to variable returns from its involvement with the entity and has the ability to affect those returns through its power over the entity. For entities governed by voting rights, the Group generally controls the entity if it holds, directly or indirectly, the majority of the voting rights (and if there are no contractual provisions that alter the power of these voting rights) or if the power to direct the relevant activities of the entity is conferred on it by contractual agreements. Structured entities are entities established so that they are not governed by voting rights, for instance when those voting rights relate to administrative tasks only, whereas the relevant activities are directed by means of contractual arrangements. They often have the following features or attributes: restricted activities, a narrow and well-defined objective and insufficient equity to permit them to finance their activities without subordinated financial support. For these entities, the analysis of control shall consider the purpose and design of the entity, the risks to which the entity is designed to be exposed and to what extent the Group absorbs the related variability. The assessment of control shall consider all facts and circumstances able to determine the Group's practical ability to make decisions that could significantly affect its returns, even if such decisions are contingent on uncertain future events or circumstances. In assessing whether it has power, the Group considers only substantive rights which it holds or which are held by third parties. For a right to be substantive, the holder must have the practical ability to exercise that right when decisions about the relevant activities of the entity need to be made. Control is reassessed if facts and circumstances indicate that there are changes to one or more of the elements of control. Where the Group contractually holds the decision-making power, for instance where the Group acts as fund manager, it shall determine whether it is acting as agent or principal. Indeed, when associated with a certain level of exposure to the variability of returns, this decision-making power may indicate that the Group is acting on its own account and that it thus has control over those entities. Minority interests are presented separately in the consolidated profit and loss account and balance sheet within consolidated equity. The calculation of minority interests takes into account the outstanding cumulative preferred shares classified as equity instruments issued by subsidiaries, when such shares are held outside the Group. As regards fully consolidated funds, units held by third-party investors are recognised as debts at fair value through profit or loss, inasmuch as they are redeemable at fair value at the subscriber’s initiative. For transactions resulting in a loss of control, any equity interest retained by the Group is remeasured at its fair value through profit or loss. -- 14 of 130 -- - 15 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Joint control Where the Group carries out an activity with one or more partners, sharing control by virtue of a contractual agreement which requires unanimous consent on relevant activities (those that significantly affect the entity’s returns), the Group exercises joint control over the activity. Where the jointly controlled activity is structured through a separate vehicle in which the partners have rights to the net assets, this joint venture is accounted for using the equity method. Where the jointly controlled activity is not structured through a separate vehicle or where the partners have rights to the assets and obligations for the liabilities of the jointly controlled activity, the Group accounts for its share of the assets, liabilities, revenues and expenses in accordance with the applicable IFRS. Significant influence Companies over which the Group exercises significant influence or associates are accounted for by the equity method. Significant influence is the power to participate in the financial and operating policy decisions of a company without exercising control. Significant influence is presumed to exist when the Group holds, directly or indirectly, 20% or more of the voting rights of a company. Interests of less than 20% can be included in the consolidation scope if the Group effectively exercises significant influence. This is the case for example for entities developed in partnership with other associates, where the BNP Paribas Group participates in strategic decisions of the enterprise through representation on the Board of directors or equivalent governing body, or exercises influence over the enterprise’s operational management by supplying management systems or senior managers, or provides technical assistance to support the enterprise’s development. Changes in the net assets of associates (companies accounted for under the equity method) are recognised on the assets side of the balance sheet under “Investments in equity-method entities” and in the relevant component of shareholders’ equity. Goodwill recorded on associates is also included under “Equity-method investments”. Whenever there is an indication of impairment, the carrying amount of the investment consolidated under the equity method (including goodwill) is subjected to an impairment test, by comparing its recoverable value (the higher of value-in-use and market value less costs to sell) to its carrying amount. Where appropriate, impairment is recognised under "Share of earnings of equity-method entities" in the consolidated income statement and can be reversed at a later date. If the Group’s share of losses of an equity-method entity equals or exceeds the carrying amount of its investment in this entity, the Group discontinues including its share of further losses. The investment is reported at nil value. Additional losses of the equity-method entity are provided for only to the extent that the Group has contracted a legal or constructive obligation or has made payments on behalf of this entity. Where the Group holds an interest in an associate, directly or indirectly through an entity that is a venture capital organisation, a mutual fund, an open-ended investment company or similar entity such as an investment-related insurance fund, it may elect to measure that interest at fair value through profit or loss. Realised gains and losses on investments in consolidated undertakings are recognised in the profit and loss account under “Net gain on non-current assets”. The consolidated financial statements are prepared using uniform accounting policies for similar transactions and other events occurring in similar circumstances. -- 15 of 130 -- - 16 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 1.b.3 CONSOLIDATION RULES • Elimination of intragroup balances and transactions Intragroup balances arising from transactions between consolidated enterprises, and the transactions themselves (including income, expenses and dividends), are eliminated. Profits and losses arising from intragroup sales of assets are eliminated, except where there is an indication that the asset sold is impaired. Unrealised gains and losses included in the value of financial instruments at fair value through equity are maintained in the consolidated financial statements. By way of exception, amendments to IAS 32 and IFRS 9 allow intra-group assets to be retained in the balance sheet if they are held as underlying components of direct participating contracts. These assets are measured at fair value through profit or loss. These are: - own shares by amendment to IAS 32; - financial liabilities issued by the entity in amendment to IFRS 9. These provisions are applied by the Group’s insurance entities that issue direct participating contracts, the underlying elements of which include securities issued by the Group either directly or through consolidated investment entities. • Translation of accounts expressed in foreign currencies The consolidated financial statements of BNP Paribas are prepared in euros. The financial statements of enterprises whose functional currency is not the euro are translated using the closing rate method. Under this method, all assets and liabilities, both monetary and non-monetary, are translated using the spot exchange rate at the balance sheet date. Income and expense items are translated at the average rate for the period. Financial statements of the Group’s subsidiaries located in hyperinflationary economies, previously adjusted for inflation by applying a general price index, are translated using the closing rate. This rate applies to the translation of assets and liabilities as well as income and expenses. Differences arising from the translation of balance sheet items and profit and loss items are recorded in shareholders’ equity under “Exchange differences”, and in “Minority interests” for the portion attributable to outside investors. Under the optional treatment permitted by IFRS 1, the Group has reset to zero all translation differences, by booking all cumulative translation differences attributable to shareholders and to minority interests in the opening balance sheet at 1 January 2004 to retained earnings. On liquidation or disposal of some or all of an interest held in a foreign enterprise located outside the eurozone, leading to a change in the nature of the investment (loss of control, loss of significant influence or loss of joint control without keeping a significant influence), the cumulative exchange difference at the date of liquidation or sale is recognised in the profit and loss account. Should the percentage of interest change without leading to a modification in the nature of the investment, the exchange difference is reallocated between the portion attributable to shareholders and that attributable to minority interests if the entity is fully consolidated; if the entity is consolidated under the equity method, it is recorded in profit or loss for the portion related to the interest sold. 1.b.4 BUSINESS COMBINATION AND MEASUREMENT OF GOODWILL • Business combinations Business combinations are accounted for using the purchase method. Under this method, the acquiree’s identifiable assets and liabilities assumed are measured at fair value at the acquisition date except for non-current assets classified as assets held for sale which are accounted for at fair value less costs to sell. -- 16 of 130 -- - 17 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The acquiree’s contingent liabilities are not recognised in the consolidated balance sheet unless they represent a present obligation on the acquisition date and their fair value can be measured reliably. The cost of a business combination is the fair value, at the date of exchange, of assets given, liabilities incurred or assumed, and equity instruments issued to obtain control of the acquiree. Costs directly attributable to the business combination are treated as a separate transaction and recognised through profit or loss. Any contingent consideration is included in the cost, as soon as control is obtained, at fair value on the date when control was acquired. Subsequent changes in the value of any contingent consideration recognised as a financial liability are recognised through profit or loss. The Group may recognise any adjustments to the provisional accounting within 12 months of the acquisition date. Goodwill represents the difference between the cost of the combination and the acquirer’s interest in the net fair value of the identifiable assets and liabilities of the acquiree at the acquisition date. Positive goodwill is recognised in the acquirer’s balance sheet, while negative goodwill is recognised immediately in profit or loss, on the acquisition date. Minority interests are measured at their share of the fair value of the acquiree’s identifiable assets and liabilities. However, for each business combination, the Group can elect to measure minority interests at fair value, in which case a proportion of goodwill is allocated to them. To date, the Group has never used this latter option. Goodwill is recognised in the functional currency of the acquiree and translated at the closing exchange rate. On the acquisition date, any previously held equity interest in the acquiree is remeasured at its fair value through profit or loss. In the case of a step acquisition, the goodwill is therefore determined by reference to the acquisition- date fair value. Since the revised IFRS 3 has been applied prospectively, business combinations completed prior to 1 January 2010 were not restated for the effects of changes to IFRS 3. As permitted under IFRS 1, business combinations that took place before 1 January 2004 and were recorded in accordance with the previously applicable accounting standards (French GAAP), had not been restated in accordance with the principles of IFRS 3. Specificities relating to insurance contracts acquired through business combinations are set out in note 1.g.2 in the paragraph “recognition and derecognition”. • Measurement of goodwill The BNP Paribas Group tests goodwill for impairment on a regular basis. - Cash-generating units The BNP Paribas Group has split all its activities into cash-generating units2 representing major business lines. This split is consistent with the Group’s organisational structure and management methods, and reflects the independence of each unit in terms of results and management approach. It is reviewed on a regular basis in order to take account of events likely to affect the composition of cash-generating units, such as acquisitions, disposals and major reorganisations. - Testing cash-generating units for impairment Goodwill allocated to cash-generating units is tested for impairment annually and whenever there is an indication that a unit may be impaired, by comparing the carrying amount of the unit with its recoverable amount. If the recoverable amount is less than the carrying amount, an irreversible impairment loss is recognised, and the goodwill is written down by the excess of the carrying amount of the unit over its recoverable amount. (3) As defined by IAS 36. -- 17 of 130 -- - 18 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 - Recoverable amount of a cash-generating unit The recoverable amount of a cash-generating unit is the higher of the fair value of the unit less costs to sell, and its value in use. Fair value is the price that would be obtained from selling the unit at the market conditions prevailing at the date of measurement, as determined mainly by reference to actual prices of recent transactions involving similar entities or on the basis of stock market multiples for comparable companies. Value in use is based on an estimate of the future cash flows to be generated by the cash-generating unit, derived from the annual forecasts prepared by the unit’s management and approved by Group Executive Management, and from analyses of changes in the relative positioning of the unit’s activities on their market. These cash flows are discounted at a rate that reflects the return that investors would require from an investment in the business sector and region involved. 1.c T RANSLATION OF FOREIGN CURRENCY TRANSACTIONS The methods used to account for assets and liabilities relating to foreign currency transactions entered into by the Group, and to measure the foreign exchange risk arising on such transactions, depend on whether the asset or liability in question is classified as a monetary or a non-monetary item. • Monetary assets and liabilities3 expressed in foreign currencies Monetary assets and liabilities expressed in foreign currencies are translated into the functional currency of the relevant Group entity at the closing rate. Foreign exchange differences are recognised in the profit and loss account, except for those arising from financial instruments designated as a cash flow hedge or a net foreign investment hedge, which are recognised in shareholders’ equity. • Non-monetary assets and liabilities expressed in foreign currencies Non-monetary assets may be measured either at historical cost or at fair value. Non-monetary assets expressed in foreign currencies are translated using the exchange rate at the date of the transaction (i.e. date of initial recognition of the non-monetary asset) if they are measured at historical cost, and at the closing rate if they are measured at fair value. Foreign exchange differences relating to non-monetary assets denominated in foreign currencies and recognised at fair value (equity instruments) are recognised in profit or loss when the asset is classified in “Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss” and in equity when the asset is classified under “Financial assets at fair value through equity”. 8 Monetary assets and liabilities are assets and liabilities to be received or paid in fixed or determinable amounts of cash. -- 18 of 130 -- - 19 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 1.d F INANCIAL INFORMATION IN HYPERINFLATIONARY ECONOMIES The Group applies IAS 29 to the presentation of the accounts of its consolidated subsidiaries located in countries whose economies are in hyperinflation. IAS 29 presents a number of quantitative and qualitative criteria to assess whether an economy is hyperinflationary, including a cumulative, three-year inflation rate approaching or exceeding 100%. All non-monetary assets and liabilities of subsidiaries in hyperinflationary countries, including equity and each line of the income statement has been restated on the basis of changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI). This restatement between 1 January and the closing date resulted in the recognition of a gain or loss in its net monetary situation, recognised under “Net gain on non-current assets”. Financial statements of these subsidiaries are translated into euros at the closing rate. In accordance with the provisions of the IFRIC’s decision of March 2020 on classifying the effects of indexation and translation of accounts of subsidiaries in hyperinflationary economies, the Groupe has opted to present these effects (including the net book value effect at the date of the initial application of IAS 29) within changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly through equity related to exchange differences. Since 1 January 2022, the Group has applied IAS 29 to the presentation of the accounts of its consolidated subsidiaries located in Türkiye. 1.e N ET INTEREST INCOME, COMMISSIONS AND INCOME FROM OTHER ACTIVITIES 1.e.1 NET INTEREST INCOME Income and expenses relating to debt instruments measured at amortised cost and at fair value through shareholders' equity are recognised in the income statement using the effective interest rate method. The effective interest rate is the rate that ensures the discounted value of estimated future cash flows through the expected life of the financial instrument or, when appropriate, a shorter period, is equal to the carrying amount of the asset or liability in the balance sheet. The effective interest rate measurement takes into account all fees received or paid that are an integral part of the effective interest rate of the contract, transaction costs, and premiums and discounts. Commissions considered as an additional component of interest are included in the effective interest rate and are recognised in the profit and loss account in “Net interest income”. This category includes notably commissions on financing commitments when it is considered that the setting up of a loan is more likely than unlikely. Commissions received in respect of financing commitments are deferred until they are drawn and then included in the effective interest rate calculation and amortised over the life of the loan. Syndication commissions are also included in this category for the portion of the commission equivalent to the remuneration of other syndication participants. 1.e.2 COMMISSIONS AND INCOME FROM OTHER ACTIVITIES Commissions received with regards to banking and similar services provided (except for those that are integral part of the effective interest rate), revenues from property development and revenues from services provided in connection with lease contracts fall within the scope of IFRS 15 “Revenue from Contracts with Customers”. This standard defines a single model for recognising revenue based on five-step principles. These five steps enable to identify the distinct performance obligations included in the contracts and allocate the transaction price among them. The income related to those performance obligations is recognised as revenue when the latter are satisfied, namely when the control of the promised goods or services has been transferred. -- 19 of 130 -- - 20 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The price of a service may contain a variable component. Variable amounts may be recognised in the income statement only if it is highly probable that the amounts recorded will not result in a significant downward adjustment. Commission The Group records commission income and expense in profit or loss either: - over time as the service is rendered when the client receives continuous service. These include, for example, certain commissions on transactions with customers when services are rendered on a continuous basis, commissions on financing commitments that are not included in the interest margin, because the probability that they give rise to the drawing up of a loan is low, commissions on financial collateral, clearing commissions on financial instruments, commissions related to trust and similar activities, securities custody fees, etc. Commissions received under financial guarantee commitments are deemed to represent the initial fair value of the commitment. The resulting liability is subsequently amortised over the term of the commitment, in Commission income; or - at a point in time when the service is rendered, in other cases. These include, for example, distribution fees received, loan syndication fees remunerating the arrangement service, advisory fees, etc. Income from other activities Income from property development as well as income from services provided in connection with lease contracts is recorded under “Income from other activities” in the income statement. As regards property development income, the Group records it in profit or loss: - over time, when the performance obligation creates or enhances an asset on which the customer obtains control as it is created or enhanced (e.g. work in progress controlled by the client on the land in which the asset is located, etc.), or where the service performed does not create an asset that the entity could otherwise use and gives it enforceable right to payment for performance completed to date. This is the case for contracts such as VEFA (sale in the future state of completion) in France. - at completion in other cases. Regarding income from services provided in connection with lease contracts, the Group records them in profit or loss as the service is rendered, i.e. in proportion to the costs incurred for maintenance contracts. 1.f F INANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES Financial assets are classified at amortised cost, at fair value through shareholders' equity or at fair value through profit or loss depending on the business model and the contractual features of the instruments at initial recognition. Financial liabilities are classified at amortised cost or at fair value through profit or loss at initial recognition. Financial assets and liabilities are recognised in the balance sheet when the Group becomes a party to the contractual provisions of the instrument. Purchases and sales of financial assets made within a period established by the regulations or by a convention in the relevant marketplace are recognised in the balance sheet at the settlement date. 1.f.1 FINANCIAL ASSETS AT AMORTISED COST Financial assets are classified at amortised cost if the following two criteria are met: the business model objective is to hold the instrument in order to collect the contractual cash flows and the cash flows consist solely of payments relating to principal and interest on the principal. -- 20 of 130 -- - 21 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Business model criterion Financial assets are managed within a business model whose objective is to hold financial assets in order to collect cash flows through the collection of contractual payments over the life of the instrument. The realisation of disposals close to the maturity of the instrument and for an amount close to the remaining contractual cash-flows, or due to an increase in the counterparty's credit risk is consistent with a business model whose objective is to collect the contractual cash flows (“collect”). Sales imposed by regulatory requirements or to manage the concentration of credit risk (without an increase in the asset’s credit risk) are also consistent with this business model when they are infrequent or insignificant in value. Cash flow criterion The cash flow criterion is satisfied if the contractual terms of the debt instrument give rise, on specified dates, to cash flows that are solely repayments of principal and interest on the principal amount outstanding. The criterion is not met in the event of a contractual characteristic that exposes the holder to risks or to the volatility of contractual cash flows that are inconsistent with those of a non-structured or “basic lending” arrangement. It is also not satisfied in the event of leverage that increases the variability of the contractual cash flows. Interest consists of consideration for the time value of money, for the credit risk, and for the remuneration of other risks (e.g. liquidity risk), costs (e.g. administration fees), and a profit margin consistent with that of a basic lending arrangement. The existence of negative interest does not call into question the cash flow criterion. The time value of money is the component of interest - usually referred to as the “rate” component - which provides consideration for only the passage of time. The relationship between the interest rate and the passage of time must not be modified by specific characteristics that could call into question the respect of the cash flow criterion. Thus, when the variable interest rate of the financial asset is periodically reset at a frequency that does not match the duration for which the interest rate is established, the time value of money may be considered as modified and, depending on the significance of that modification, the cash flow criterion may not be met. Some financial assets held by the Group present a mismatch between the interest rate reset frequency and the maturity of the index, or interest rates indexed to an average of benchmark rate. The Group has developed a consistent methodology for analysing this alteration of the time value of money. Regulated rates meet the cash flow criterion when they provide consideration that is broadly consistent with the passage of time and does not expose to risks or volatility in the contractual cash flows that would be inconsistent with those of a basic lending arrangement (example: loans granted in the context of Livret A savings accounts). Some contractual clauses may change the timing or the amount of cash flows. Early redemption options do not call into question the cash flow criterion if the prepayment amount substantially represents the principal amount outstanding and the interest thereon, which may include reasonable compensation for the early termination of the contract. For example, as regards loans to retail customers, the compensation limited to 6 months of interest or 3% of the capital outstanding is considered reasonable. Actuarial penalties, corresponding to the discounted value of the difference between the residual contractual cash-flows of the loan, and their reinvestment in a loan to a similar counterparty or in the interbank market for a similar residual maturity are also considered as reasonable, even when the compensation can be positive or negative (i.e. “symmetric” compensation). An option that permits the issuer or the holder of a financial instrument to change the interest rate from floating to fixed rate does not breach the cash flow criterion if the fixed rate is determined at origination, or if it represents the time value of money for the residual maturity of the instrument at the date of exercise of the option. Clauses included in financing granted to encourage the sustainable development of companies which adjust the interest margin depending on the achievement of environmental, social or governance (ESG) objectives and disclosed in Chapter 7 of the Universal registration document, do not call into question the cash flow criterion when such an adjustment is considered to be minimal. Structured instruments indexed to ESG market indices do not meet the cash flow criterion. In the particular case of financial assets contractually linked to payments received on a portfolio of underlying assets and which include a priority order for payment of cash flows between investors (“tranches”), thereby creating concentrations of credit risk, a specific analysis is carried out. The contractual characteristics of the tranche and those of the underlying financial instrument portfolios must meet the cash flow criterion and the credit risk exposure of the tranche must be equal to or lower than the exposure to credit risk of the underlying pool of financial instruments. -- 21 of 130 -- - 22 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Certain loans may be “non-recourse”, either contractually, or in substance when they are granted to a special purpose entity. That is in particular the case of numerous project financing or asset financing loans. The cash-flow criterion is met as long as these loans do not represent a direct exposure on the assets acting as collateral. In practice, the sole fact that the financial asset explicitly gives rise to cash flows that are consistent with payments of principal and interest is not sufficient to conclude that the instrument meets the cash flow criterion. In that case, the particular underlying assets to which there is limited recourse shall be analysed using the “look-through” approach. If those assets do not themselves meet the cash flow criterion, the existing credit enhancement is assessed. The following aspects are considered: structuring and sizing of the transaction, own funds level of the structure, expected source of repayment, price volatility of the underlying assets. This analysis is applied to “non-recourse” loans granted by the Group. The “financial assets at amortised cost” category includes, in particular, loans granted by the Group, as well as reverse repurchase agreements and securities held by the Group ALM Treasury in order to collect contractual flows and meeting the cash flow criterion. Recognition On initial recognition, financial assets are recognised at fair value, including transaction costs directly attributable to the transaction as well as commissions related to the origination of the loans. They are subsequently measured at amortised cost, including accrued interest and net of repayments of principal and interest during the past period. These financial assets are also subject from their initial recognition, to the measurement of a loss allowance for expected credit losses (note 1.f.5). Interest is calculated using the effective interest method determined at inception of the contract. 1.f.2 FINANCIAL ASSETS AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY Debt instruments Debt instruments are classified at fair value through shareholders’ equity if the following two criteria are met: - business model criterion: Financial assets are held in a business model whose objective is achieved by both holding the financial assets in order to collect contractual cash flows and selling the financial assets (“collect and sale”). The latter is not incidental but is an integral part of the business model. - cash flow criterion: The principles are identical to those applicable to financial assets at amortised cost. The securities held by the Group ALM Treasury in order to collect contractual flows or to be sold and meeting the cash flow criterion are in particular classified in this category. On initial recognition, financial assets are recognised at their fair value, including transaction costs directly attributable to the transaction. They are subsequently measured at fair value and changes in fair value are recognised, under a specific line of shareholders’ equity entitled “Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity that may be reclassified to profit or loss”. These financial assets are also subject to the measurement of a loss allowance for expected credit losses on the same approach as for debt instruments at amortised cost. The counterparty of the related impact in cost of risk is recognised in the same specific line of shareholders’ equity. On disposal, changes in fair value previously recognised in shareholders’ equity are reclassified to profit or loss. In addition, interest is recognised in the income statement using the effective interest method determined at the inception of the contract. -- 22 of 130 -- - 23 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Equity instruments Investments in equity instruments such as shares are classified on option, and on a case-by-case basis, at fair value through shareholders’ equity (under a specific line). On disposal of the shares, changes in fair value previously recognised in equity are not recognised in profit or loss. Only dividends, if they represent remuneration for the investment and not repayment of capital, are recognised in profit or loss. These instruments are not subject to impairment. Investments in mutual funds puttable to the issuer do not meet the definition of equity instruments. They do not meet the cash flow criterion either, and thus are recognised at fair value through profit or loss. 1.f.3 FINANCING AND GUARANTEE COMMITMENTS Financing and financial guarantee commitments that are not recognised at fair value through profit or loss are presented in the note relating to financing and guarantee commitments. They are subject to the measurement of a loss allowance for expected credit losses. These loss allowances are presented under “Provisions for contingencies and charges”. 1.f.4 REGULATED SAVINGS AND LOAN CONTRACTS Home savings accounts (Comptes Épargne-Logement – “CEL”) and home savings plans (Plans d’Épargne Logement – “PEL”) are government-regulated retail products sold in France. They combine a savings phase and a loan phase which are inseparable, with the loan phase contingent upon the savings phase. These products contain two types of obligations for BNP Paribas: an obligation to pay interest on the savings for an indefinite period, at a rate set by the government at the inception of the contract (in the case of PEL products) or at a rate reset every six months using an indexation formula set by law (in the case of CEL products); and an obligation to lend to the customer (at the customer’s option) an amount contingent upon the rights acquired during the savings phase, at a rate set at the inception of the contract (in the case of PEL products) or at a rate contingent upon the savings phase (in the case of CEL products). The Group’s future obligations with respect to each generation (in the case of PEL products, a generation comprises all products with the same interest rate at inception; in the case of CEL products, all such products constitute a single generation) are measured by discounting potential future earnings from at-risk outstandings for that generation. At-risk outstandings are estimated on the basis of a historical analysis of customer behaviour, and are equivalent to: - for the loan phase: statistically probable loans outstanding and actual loans outstanding; - for the savings phase: the difference between statistically probable outstandings and minimum expected outstandings, with minimum expected outstandings being deemed equivalent to unconditional term deposits. Earnings for future periods from the savings phase are estimated as the difference between the reinvestment rate and the fixed savings interest rate on at-risk savings outstanding for the period in question. Earnings for future periods from the loan phase are estimated as the difference between the refinancing rate and the fixed loan interest rate on at-risk loans outstanding for the period in question. The reinvestment rate for savings and the refinancing rate for loans are derived from the swap yield curve and from the spreads expected on financial instruments of similar type and maturity. Spreads are determined on the basis of actual spreads on fixed-rate home loans in the case of the loan phase and products offered to individual clients in the case of the savings phase. In order to reflect the uncertainty of future interest rate trends, and the impact of such trends on customer behaviour models and on at-risk outstandings, the obligations are estimated using the Monte-Carlo method. Where the sum of the Group’s estimated future obligations with respect to the savings and loan phases of any generation of contracts indicates a potentially unfavourable situation for the Group, a provision is recognised (with no offset between generations) in the balance sheet in “Provisions for contingencies and charges”. Movements in this provision are recognised as interest income in the profit and loss account. -- 23 of 130 -- - 24 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 1.f.5 I MPAIRMENT OF FINANCIAL ASSETS MEASURED AT AMORTISED COST AND DEBT INSTRUMENTS MEASURED AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY The impairment model for credit risk is based on expected losses. This model applies to loans and debt instruments measured at amortised cost or at fair value through equity, to loan commitments and financial guarantee contracts that are not recognised at fair value, as well as to lease receivables, trade receivables and contract assets. General model The Group identifies three “stages” that each correspond to a specific status with regards to the evolution of counterparty credit risk since the initial recognition of the asset. - 12-month expected credit losses (“stage 1”): If at the reporting date, the credit risk of the financial instrument has not increased significantly since its initial recognition, this instrument is impaired at an amount equal to 12- month expected credit losses (resulting from the risk of default within the next 12 months). - Lifetime expected credit losses for non-impaired assets (“stage 2”): The loss allowance is measured at an amount equal to the lifetime expected credit losses if the credit risk of the financial instrument has increased significantly since initial recognition, but the financial asset is not considered credit-impaired or doubtful. - Lifetime expected credit losses for credit-impaired or doubtful financial assets (“stage 3”): The loss allowance is also measured for an amount equal to the lifetime expected credit losses. This general model is applied to all instruments within the scope of IFRS 9 impairment, except for purchased or originated credit-impaired financial assets and instruments for which a simplified model is used (see below). The IFRS 9 expected credit loss approach is symmetrical, i.e. if lifetime expected credit losses have been recognised in a previous reporting period, and if it is assessed in the current reporting period that there is no longer any significant increase in credit risk since initial recognition, the loss allowance reverts to a 12-months expected credit loss. As regards interest income, under “stages” 1 and 2, it is calculated on the gross carrying amount. Under “stage 3”, interest income is calculated on the amortised cost (i.e. the gross carrying amount adjusted for the loss allowance). Definition of default The definition of default is aligned with the Basel regulatory default definition, with a rebuttable presumption that the default occurs no later than 90 days past due. This definition takes into account the EBA guidelines of 28 September 2016, notably those regarding the thresholds applicable for the counting of past-due and probation periods. The definition of default is used consistently for assessing the increase in credit risk and measuring expected credit losses. Credit-impaired or doubtful financial assets Definition A financial asset is considered credit-impaired or doubtful and classified in “stage 3” when one or more events that have a detrimental impact on the estimated future cash flows of that financial asset have occurred. At an individual level, objective evidence that a financial asset is credit-impaired includes observable data regarding the following events: the existence of accounts that are more than 90 days past due; knowledge or indications that the borrower is experiencing significant financial difficulties, such that a risk can be considered to have arisen regardless of whether the borrower has missed any payments; concessions with respect to the credit terms granted to the borrower that the lender would not have considered had the borrower not been in financial difficulty (see section Restructuring of financial assets for financial difficulties). -- 24 of 130 -- - 25 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Specific cases of purchased or originated credit-impaired assets In some cases, financial assets are credit-impaired at initial recognition. For these assets, no loss allowance is recorded on initial recognition. The effective interest rate is calculated taking into account the lifetime expected credit losses in the initial estimated cash flows. Any change in lifetime expected credit losses since initial recognition, positive or negative, is recognised as a loss allowance adjustment in profit or loss. Simplified model The simplified approach consists in accounting for a loss allowance corresponding to lifetime expected credit losses since initial recognition, and at each reporting date. The group applies this model to trade receivables with a maturity shorter than 12 months. Significant increase in credit risk A significant increase in credit risk may be assessed on an individual basis or on a collective basis (by grouping financial instruments according to common credit risk characteristics), taking into account all reasonable and supportable information and comparing the risk of default of the financial instrument at the reporting date with the risk of default of the financial instrument at the date of initial recognition. Assessment of deterioration is based on the comparison of the probabilities of default derived from the ratings on the date of initial recognition with those existing at the reporting date. There is also, according to the standard, a rebuttable presumption that the credit risk of an instrument has significantly increased since initial recognition when the contractual payments are more than 30 days past due. In the consumer credit specialist business, a significant increase in credit risk is also considered when a past due event has occurred within the last 12 months, even if it has since been regularised. The principles applied to assess the significant increase in credit risk are detailed in note 3.g Cost of risk. Measurement of expected credit losses Expected credit losses are defined as an estimate of credit losses (i.e. the present value of all cash shortfalls) weighted by the probability of occurrence of these losses over the expected life of the financial instruments. They are measured on an individual basis, for all exposures. In practice, for exposures classified in stage 1 and stage 2, expected credit losses are measured as the product of the probability of default (“PD”), loss given default (“LGD”) and exposure at default (“EAD”), discounted at the effective interest rate of the exposure (EIR). They result from the risk of default within the next 12 months (stage 1), or from the risk of default over the maturity of the facility (stage 2). In the consumer credit specialist business, because of the specificity of credit exposures, the methodology used is based on the probability of transition to term forfeiture, and on discounted loss rates after term forfeiture. These parameters are measured on a statistical basis for homogeneous populations. For exposures classified in stage 3, expected credit losses are measured as the value, discounted at the effective interest rate, of all cash shortfalls over the life of the financial instrument. Cash shortfalls represent the difference between the cash-flows that are due in accordance with the contract, and the cash-flows that are expected to be received. Where appropriate, the estimate of expected cash flows takes into account a cash flow scenario arising from the sale of the defaulted loans or groups of loans. Proceeds from the sale are recorded net of costs to sell. The methodology developed is based on existing concepts and methods (in particular the Basel framework) on exposures for which capital requirement for credit risk is measured according to the IRBA methodology. This method is also applied to portfolios for which capital requirement for credit risk is measured according to the standardised approach. Besides, the Basel framework has been adjusted in order to be compliant with IFRS 9 requirements, in particular the use of forward-looking information. -- 25 of 130 -- - 26 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Maturity All contractual terms of the financial instrument are taken into account, including prepayment, extension and similar options. In the rare cases where the expected life of the financial instrument cannot be estimated reliably, the residual contractual term is used. The standard specifies that the maximum period to consider when measuring expected credit losses is the maximum contractual period. However, for revolving credit cards and overdrafts, in accordance with the exception provided by IFRS 9 for these products, the maturity considered for measuring expected credit losses is the period over which the entity is exposed to credit risk, which may extend beyond the contractual maturity (notice period). For revolving credits and overdrafts to non-retail counterparties, the contractual maturity can be used, for example if the next review date is the contractual maturity as they are individually managed. Probabilities of Default (PD) Probability of Default is an estimate of the likelihood of default over a given time horizon. The determination of the PD is based on the Group’s internal rating system, which is described in chapter 5 of the Universal registration document (section 5.4 Credit risk – Credit risk management policy). This section describes how environmental, social and governance (ESG) risks are taken into account in credit and rating policies, notably with the introduction of a new tool: the ESG Assessment. The measurement of expected credit losses requires the estimation of both 1-year probabilities of default and lifetime probabilities of default. 1-year PDs are derived from long term average regulatory “through the cycle” PDs to reflect the current situation (“Point in Time” or “PIT”). Lifetime PDs are determined based on the rating migration matrices reflecting the expected changes in the rating of the exposure until maturity, and the associated probabilities of default. Loss Given Default (LGD) Loss Given Default is the difference between contractual cash-flows and expected cash-flows, discounted using the effective interest rate (or an approximation thereof) at the default date. LGD is expressed as a percentage of the Exposure At Default (EAD). The estimate of expected cash flows takes into account cash flows resulting from the sale of collateral held or other credit enhancements if they are part of the contractual terms and are not accounted for separately by the entity (for example, a mortgage associated with a residential loan), net of the costs of obtaining and selling the collateral. For guaranteed loans, the guarantee is considered as integral to the loan agreement if it is embedded in the contractual clauses of the loan, or if it was granted concomitantly to the loan, and if the expected reimbursement amount can be attached to a loan in particular (i.e. absence of pooling effect by means of a tranching mechanism, or the existence of a global cap for a whole portfolio). In such case, the guarantee is taken into account when measuring the expected credit losses. Otherwise, it is accounted for as a separate reimbursement asset. The LGD used for IFRS 9 purposes is derived from the Basel LGD parameters. It is adjusted for downturn and conservatism margins (in particular regulatory margins), except for margins for model uncertainties. Exposure At Default (EAD) Exposure At Default (EAD) of an instrument is the anticipated outstanding amount owed by the obligor at the time of default. It is determined by the expected payment profile taking into account, depending on the product type: the contractual repayment schedule, expected early repayments and expected future drawings for revolving facilities. Forward-looking information The amount of expected credit losses is measured on the basis of probability-weighted scenarios, in view of past events, current conditions and reasonable and supportable economic forecasts. -- 26 of 130 -- - 27 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The principles applied to take into account forward-looking information when measuring expected credit losses are detailed in note 3.g Cost of risk. Write-offs A write-off consists in reducing the gross carrying amount of a financial asset when there are no longer reasonable expectations of recovering that financial asset in its entirety or a portion thereof, or when it has been fully or partially forgiven. The write-off is recorded when all other means available to the Bank for recovering the receivables or guarantees have failed, and also generally depends on the context specific to each jurisdiction. If the amount of loss on write-off is greater than the accumulated loss allowance, the difference is recognised as an additional impairment loss in “Cost of risk”. For any recovery once the financial asset (or part thereof) is no longer recognised on the balance sheet, the amount received is recorded as a gain in “Cost of risk”. Recoveries through the repossession of the collateral When a loan is secured by a financial or a non-financial asset serving as a guarantee and the counterparty is in default, the Group may decide to exercise the guarantee and, depending on the jurisdiction, it may then become owner of the asset. In such a situation, the loan is written-off against the asset received as collateral. Once ownership of the asset is effective, it is recognised at fair value and classified according to the intent of use. Restructuring of financial assets for financial difficulties A restructuring due to the borrower's financial difficulties is defined as a change in the terms and conditions of the initial transaction that the Group is considering only for economic or legal reasons related to the borrower's financial difficulties. For restructurings not resulting in derecognition of the financial asset, the restructured asset’s gross carrying amount is reduced to the discounted amount, using the original effective interest rate of the asset, of the new expected future flows. The change in the gross carrying amount of the asset is recorded in the income statement in “Cost of risk”. The existence of a significant increase in credit risk for the financial instrument is then assessed by comparing the risk of default after the restructuring (under the revised contractual terms) and the risk of default at the initial recognition date (under the original contractual terms). In order to demonstrate that the criteria for recognising lifetime expected credit losses are no longer met, good payment behaviour will have to be observed over a certain period of time. When the restructuring consists of a partial or total exchange against other substantially different assets (for example, the exchange of a debt instrument against an equity instrument), it results in the extinction of the original asset and the recognition of the assets remitted in exchange, measured at their fair value at the date of exchange. The difference in value is recorded in the income statement in “Cost of risk”. Modifications to financial assets that are not due to a borrower’s financial difficulties, or granted in the context of a moratorium (i.e. commercial renegotiations) are generally analysed as the early repayment of the former loan, which is then derecognised, followed by the set-up of a new loan at market conditions. If there is no significant repayment penalty, they consist in resetting the interest rate of the loan at market conditions, with the client being in a position to change lender and not encountering any financial difficulties. Probation periods The Group applies observation periods to assess the possible return to a better stage. Accordingly, a 3-month probation period is observed for the transition from stage 3 to stage 2 which is extended to 12 months in the event of restructuring due to financial difficulties. For the transition from stage 2 to stage 1, a probation period of two years is observed for loans that have been restructured due to financial difficulties. -- 27 of 130 -- - 28 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 1.f.6 COST OF RISK Cost of risk includes the following items of profit or loss: - impairment gains and losses resulting from the accounting of loss allowances for 12-month expected credit losses and lifetime expected credit losses (“stage 1” and “stage 2”) relating to debt instruments measured at amortised cost or at fair value through shareholders' equity, loan commitments and financial guarantee contracts that are not recognised at fair value as well as lease receivables, contract assets and trade receivables; - impairment gains and losses resulting from the accounting of loss allowances relating to financial assets (including those at fair value through profit or loss) for which there is objective evidence of impairment (“stage 3”), write-offs on irrecoverable loans and amounts recovered on loans written-off; It also includes expenses relating to fraud and to disputes inherent to the financing activity. 1.f.7 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH PROFIT OR LOSS Trading portfolio and other financial assets measured at fair value through profit or loss The trading portfolio includes instruments held for trading (trading transactions), including derivatives. Other financial assets measured at fair value through profit or loss include debt instruments that do not meet the “collect” or “collect and sale” business model criterion or that do not meet the cash flow criterion, as well as equity instruments for which the fair value through shareholders’ equity option has not been retained. Finally financial assets may be designated as at fair value through profit or loss if this enables the entity to eliminate or significantly reduce a mismatch in the measurement and accounting treatment of assets and liabilities that would otherwise arise if they were to be classified in separate categories. All those financial instruments are measured at fair value at initial recognition, with transaction costs directly posted in profit or loss. At the reporting date, they are measured at fair value, with changes presented in “Net gain/loss on financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss”. Income, dividends, and realised gains and losses on disposal related to held-for-trading transactions are accounted for in the same profit or loss account. Financial liabilities designated as at fair value through profit or loss Financial liabilities are recognised under option in this category in the two following situations: - for hybrid financial instruments containing one or more embedded derivatives which otherwise would have been separated and accounted for separately. An embedded derivative is such that its economic characteristics and risks are not closely related to those of the host contract; - when using the option enables the entity to eliminate or significantly reduce a mismatch in the measurement and accounting treatment of assets and liabilities that would otherwise arise if they were to be classified in separate categories. Changes in fair value due to the own credit risk are recognised under a specific heading of shareholders’ equity. -- 28 of 130 -- - 29 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 1.f.8 FINANCIAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY INSTRUMENTS A financial instrument issued or its various components are classified as a financial liability or equity instrument, in accordance with the economic substance of the legal contract. Financial instruments issued by the Group are qualified as debt instruments if the entity in the Group issuing the instruments has a contractual obligation to deliver cash or another financial asset to the holder of the instrument. The same applies if the Group is required to exchange financial assets or financial liabilities with another entity under conditions that are potentially unfavourable to the Group, or to deliver a variable number of the Group’s own equity instruments. Equity instruments result from contracts evidencing a residual interest in an entity's assets after deducting all of its liabilities. Debt securities and subordinated debt Debt securities and subordinated debt are measured at amortised cost unless they are recognised at fair value through profit or loss. Debt securities are initially recognised at the issue value including transaction costs and are subsequently measured at amortised cost using the effective interest method. Issued bonds redeemable or convertible into own equity may contain a debt component and an equity component, determined upon initial recognition of the transaction. In this case, they will be qualified as compound financial instruments. In this respect, the Group has elected to record contingent convertible bonds issued, without maturity, when convertible into a variable number of own shares on the occurrence of a predetermined trigger event (e.g. a decrease in the solvency ratio below a threshold), as compound instruments, to the extent that the coupons on these bonds are paid discretionarily. Equity instruments The term “own equity instruments” refers to shares issued by the parent company (BNP Paribas SA) and by its fully consolidated subsidiaries. External costs that are directly attributable to an issue of new shares are deducted from equity net of all related taxes. Own equity instruments held by the Group, also known as treasury shares, are deducted from consolidated shareholders’ equity irrespective of the purpose for which they are held. Gains and losses arising on such instruments are eliminated from the consolidated profit and loss account. When the Group acquires equity instruments issued by subsidiaries under the exclusive control of BNP Paribas, the difference between the acquisition price and the share of net assets acquired is recorded in retained earnings attributable to BNP Paribas shareholders. Similarly, the liability corresponding to put options granted to minority shareholders in such subsidiaries, and changes in the value of that liability, are offset against minority interests, with any surplus offset against retained earnings attributable to BNP Paribas shareholders. Until these options have been exercised, the portion of net income attributable to minority interests is allocated to minority interests in the profit and loss account. A decrease in the Group’s interest in a fully consolidated subsidiary is recognised in the Group's accounts as a change in shareholders' equity. Financial instruments issued by the Group and classified as equity instruments (e.g. Undated Super Subordinated Notes) are presented in the balance sheet in “Capital and retained earnings”. Distributions from a financial instrument classified as an equity instrument are recognised directly as a deduction from equity. Similarly, the transaction costs of an instrument classified as equity are recognised as a deduction from shareholders’ equity. Own equity instrument derivatives are treated as follows, depending on the method of settlement: - as equity instruments if they are settled by physical delivery of a fixed number of own equity instruments for a fixed amount of cash or other financial asset. Such instruments are not revalued; - as derivatives if they are settled in cash or by choice by physical delivery of the shares or in cash. Changes in value of such instruments are taken to the profit and loss account. -- 29 of 130 -- - 30 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 If the contract includes an obligation, whether contingent or not, for the bank to repurchase its own shares, the bank recognises the debt at its present value with an offsetting entry in shareholders’ equity. 1.f.9 HEDGE ACCOUNTING The Group retained the option provided by the standard to maintain the hedge accounting requirements of IAS 39 until the future standard on macro-hedging is entered into force. Furthermore, IFRS 9 does not explicitly address the fair value hedge of the interest rate risk on a portfolio of financial assets or liabilities. The provisions in IAS 39 for these portfolio hedges, as adopted by the European Union, continue to apply. Derivatives contracted as part of a hedging relationship are designated according to the purpose of the hedge. Fair value hedges are particularly used to hedge interest rate risk on fixed-rate assets and liabilities, both for identified financial instruments (securities, debt issues, loans, borrowings) and for portfolios of financial instruments (in particular, demand deposits and fixed-rate loans). Cash flow hedges are particularly used to hedge interest rate risk on floating-rate assets and liabilities, including rollovers, and foreign exchange risks on highly probable forecast foreign currency revenues. At the inception of the hedge, the Group prepares formal documentation which details the hedging relationship, identifying the instrument, or portion of the instrument, or portion of risk that is being hedged, the hedging strategy and the type of risk hedged, the hedging instrument, and the methods used to assess the effectiveness of the hedging relationship. On inception and at least quarterly, the Group assesses, in consistency with the original documentation, the actual (retrospective) and expected (prospective) effectiveness of the hedging relationship. Retrospective effectiveness tests are designed to assess whether the ratio of actual changes in the fair value or cash flows of the hedging instrument to those in the hedged item is within a range of 80% to 125%. Prospective effectiveness tests are designed to ensure that expected changes in the fair value or cash flows of the derivative over the residual life of the hedge adequately offset those of the hedged item. For highly probable forecast transactions, effectiveness is assessed largely on the basis of historical data for similar transactions. Under IAS 39 as adopted by the European Union, which excludes certain provisions on portfolio hedging, interest rate risk hedging relationships based on portfolios of assets or liabilities qualify for fair value hedge accounting as follows: - the risk designated as being hedged is the interest rate risk associated with the interbank rate component of interest rates on commercial banking transactions (loans to customers, savings accounts and demand deposits); - the instruments designated as being hedged correspond, for each maturity band, to a portion of the interest rate gap associated with the hedged underlying; - the hedging instruments used consist exclusively of “plain vanilla” swaps; - prospective hedge effectiveness is established by the fact that all derivatives must, on inception, have the effect of reducing interest rate risk in the portfolio of hedged underlying. Retrospectively, a hedge will be disqualified from hedge accounting once a shortfall arises in the underlying specifically associated with that hedge for each maturity band (due to prepayment of loans or withdrawals of deposits). The accounting treatment of derivatives and hedged items depends on the hedging strategy. In a fair value hedging relationship, the derivative instrument is remeasured at fair value in the balance sheet, with changes in fair value recognised in profit or loss in “Net gain/loss on financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss”, symmetrically with the remeasurement of the hedged item to reflect the hedged risk. In the balance sheet, the fair value remeasurement of the hedged component is recognised in accordance with the classification of the hedged item in the case of a hedge of identified assets and liabilities, or under “Remeasurement adjustment on interest rate risk hedged portfolios” in the case of a portfolio hedging relationship. If a hedging relationship ceases or no longer fulfils the effectiveness criteria, the hedging instrument is transferred to the trading book and accounted for using the treatment applied to this category. In the case of identified fixed- income instruments, the remeasurement adjustment recognised in the balance sheet is amortised at the effective interest rate over the remaining life of the instrument. In the case of interest rate risk hedged fixed-income portfolios, the adjustment is amortised on a straight-line basis over the remainder of the original term of the hedge. If the hedged item no longer appears in the balance sheet, in particular due to prepayments, the adjustment is taken to the profit and loss account immediately. -- 30 of 130 -- - 31 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 In a cash flow hedging relationship, the derivative is measured at fair value in the balance sheet, with changes in fair value taken to shareholders’ equity on a separate line, “Changes in fair value recognised directly in equity”. The amounts taken to shareholders’ equity over the life of the hedge are transferred to the profit and loss account under “Net interest income” as and when the cash flows from the hedged item impact profit or loss. The hedged items continue to be accounted for using the treatment specific to the category to which they belong. If the hedging relationship ceases or no longer fulfils the effectiveness criteria, the cumulative amounts recognised in shareholders’ equity as a result of the remeasurement of the hedging instrument remain in equity until the hedged transaction itself impacts profit or loss, or until it becomes clear that the transaction will not occur, at which point they are transferred to the profit and loss account. If the hedged item ceases to exist, the cumulative amounts recognised in shareholders’ equity are immediately taken to the profit and loss account. Whatever the hedging strategy used, any ineffective portion of the hedge is recognised in the profit and loss account under “Net gain/loss on financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss”. Hedges of net foreign currency investments in subsidiaries and branches are accounted for in the same way as cash flow hedges. Hedging instruments may be foreign exchange derivatives or any other non-derivative financial instrument. 1.f.10 DETERMINATION OF FAIR VALUE Fair value is the price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants in the principal market or most advantageous market, at the measurement date. The Group determines the fair value of financial instruments either by using prices obtained directly from external data or by using valuation techniques. These valuation techniques are primarily market and income approaches encompassing generally accepted models (e.g. discounted cash flows, Black-Scholes model, and interpolation techniques). They maximise the use of observable inputs and minimise the use of unobservable inputs. They are calibrated to reflect current market conditions and valuation adjustments are applied as appropriate, when some factors such as model, liquidity and credit risks are not captured by the models or their underlying inputs but are nevertheless considered by market participants when setting the exit price. The unit of measurement is the individual financial asset or financial liability but a portfolio-based measurement can be elected, subject to certain conditions. Accordingly, the Group retains this portfolio-based measurement exception to determine the fair value when some group of financial assets and financial liabilities and other contracts within the scope of the standard relating to financial instruments with substantially similar and offsetting market risks or credit risks are managed on the basis of a net exposure, in accordance with the documented risk management strategy. Assets and liabilities measured or disclosed at fair value are categorised into the three following levels of the fair value hierarchy: - Level 1: fair values are determined using directly quoted prices in active markets for identical assets and liabilities. Characteristics of an active market include the existence of a sufficient frequency and volume of activity and of readily available prices; - Level 2: fair values are determined based on valuation techniques for which significant inputs are observable market data, either directly or indirectly. These techniques are regularly calibrated and the inputs are corroborated with information from active markets; - Level 3: fair values are determined using valuation techniques for which significant inputs are unobservable or cannot be corroborated by market-based observations, due for instance to illiquidity of the instrument and significant model risk. An unobservable input is a parameter for which there are no market data available and that is therefore derived from proprietary assumptions about what other market participants would consider when assessing fair value. The assessment of whether a product is illiquid or subject to significant model risks is a matter of judgment. The level in the fair value hierarchy within which the asset or liability is categorised in its entirety is based upon the lowest level input that is significant to the entire fair value. -- 31 of 130 -- - 32 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 For financial instruments disclosed in Level 3 of the fair value hierarchy, and marginally some instruments disclosed in Level 2, a difference between the transaction price and the fair value may arise at initial recognition. This “Day One Profit” is deferred and released to the profit and loss account over the period during which the valuation parameters are expected to remain non-observable. When parameters that were originally non- observable become observable, or when the valuation can be substantiated in comparison with recent similar transactions in an active market, the unrecognised portion of the day one profit is released to the profit and loss account. 1.f.11 DERECOGNITION OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND FINANCIAL LIABILITIES Derecognition of financial assets The Group derecognises all or part of a financial asset when the contractual rights to the cash flows of the asset expire, or when the Group transfers the asset – either on the basis of a transfer of the contractual rights to its cash flows, or by retaining the contractual rights to receive the cash flows of the asset while assuming an obligation to pay the cash flows of the asset under an eligible pass-through arrangement – as well as substantially all the risks and rewards of the asset. Where the Group has transferred the cash flows of a financial asset but has neither transferred nor retained substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership of the financial asset and has not in practice retained control of the financial asset, the Group derecognises the financial asset and then records separately, if necessary, an asset or liability representing the rights and obligations created or held as part of the transfer of the asset. If the Group has retained control of the financial asset, it maintains it on its balance sheet to the extent of its continuing involvement in that asset. Upon the derecognition of a financial asset in its entirety, a gain or loss on disposal is recognised in the profit and loss account for an amount equal to the difference between the carrying amount of the asset and the value of the consideration received, adjusted where appropriate for any unrealised gain or loss previously recognised directly in equity. If all these conditions are not met, the Group retains the asset in its balance sheet and recognises a liability for the obligations arising on the transfer of the asset. Derecognition of financial liabilities The Group derecognises all or part of a financial liability when the liability is extinguished, i.e. when the obligation specified in the contract is extinguished, cancelled or expired. A financial liability may also be derecognised in the event of a substantial change in its contractual terms or if exchanged with the lender for an instrument with substantially different contractual terms. Repurchase agreements and securities lending/borrowing Securities temporarily sold under repurchase agreements continue to be recognised in the Group’s balance sheet in the category of securities to which they belong. The corresponding liability is recognised at amortised cost under the appropriate “Financial liabilities at amortised cost” category on the balance sheet, except in the case of repurchase agreements contracted for trading purposes, for which the corresponding liability is recognised in “Financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss”. Securities temporarily acquired under reverse repurchase agreements are not recognised in the Group’s balance sheet. The corresponding receivable is recognised at amortised cost under the appropriate “Financial assets at amortised cost” category in the balance sheet, except in the case of reverse repurchase agreements contracted for trading purposes, for which the corresponding receivable is recognised in “Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss”. Securities lending transactions do not result in derecognition of the lent securities, and securities borrowing transactions do not result in recognition of the borrowed securities on the balance sheet. In cases where the borrowed securities are subsequently sold by the Group, the obligation to deliver the borrowed securities on maturity is recognised on the balance sheet under “Financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss”. -- 32 of 130 -- - 33 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 1.f.12 O FFSETTING FINANCIAL ASSETS AND FINANCIAL LIABILITIES A financial asset and a financial liability are offset and the net amount presented in the balance sheet if, and only if, the Group has a legally enforceable right to set off the recognised amounts, and intends either to settle on a net basis, or to realise the asset and settle the liability simultaneously. Repurchase agreements and derivatives that meet the two criteria set out in the accounting standard are offset in the balance sheet. 1.g I NSURANCE ACTIVITIES 1.g.1 I NVESTMENTS RELATED TO INSURANCE ACTIVITIES IFRS 9 is applied in the same way as other Group entities (see note 1.f). Investments of insurance activities include investment property which are measured at fair value as underlying assets of direct participating contracts. 1.g.2 I NSURANCE CONTRACTS The Group applies IFRS 17 to insurance contracts issued, reinsurance contracts issued and held, and discretionary investment contracts issued (if the entity also issues insurance contracts). The main IFRS 17 contracts issued by the Group correspond to: - contracts covering risks related to persons or property, and - life or savings contracts. These contracts are described in note 6.d “Assets and liabilities related to insurance contracts”. - Prior separation of components covered by other standards and not closely related When insurance or investment contracts with discretionary participation include components, which would fall within the scope of another standard if they were separate contracts, an analysis must be carried out to determine whether these components should be accounted for separately. Thus: - an embedded derivative is separated from the host insurance contract and accounted for under IFRS 9 when its economic characteristics and risks are not closely related to those of the host contract; - an investment component corresponds to the amount that the insurer is required to repay to the insured in all cases whether the insured event occurs or not. It is separated from the host insurance contract and accounted for under IFRS 9 when it is distinct from the host insurance contract and when equivalent contracts could be sold separately in the same market or legal area. It is not separated if it is closely linked to the host contract. Changes in a non-distinct investment component (and in particular related payments) are not recognised in the profit and loss account; - a promise to transfer to the policyholder distinct goods or services other than the services of the insurance contract is separated from the host insurance contract and accounted for under IFRS 15. - Insurance contracts An insurance contract is a contract under which a party, the issuer, assumes a significant insurance risk for another party, the policyholder, by agreeing to indemnify the policyholder if a specified uncertain future event, the insured event, is detrimental to the policyholder. An insurance risk is significant if, and only if, an insured event can cause the insurer to pay significant additional amounts in any scenario, excluding scenarios that are devoid of commercial substance. A contract transfers a significant insurance risk only if there is a scenario with a commercial substance in which there is a possibility that the issuer will incur a loss based on the present value. -- 33 of 130 -- - 34 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 - Investment contracts with discretionary participating features Investment contracts do not expose the insurer to significant insurance risk. They are within the scope of IFRS 17 if they are issued by entities that also issue insurance contracts. Discretionary participation is defined as the contractual right to receive, in addition to an amount that is not at the issuer’s discretion, additional amounts that are likely to represent a significant portion of the total benefits provided under the contract, the timing or amount of which is contractually left to the issuer’s discretion and that are contractually based on the returns arising from a defined set of contracts or type of contract or on the realised and/or unrealised investment returns from a defined set of assets held by the issuer, or the result of the entity or fund issuing the contract. Accounting and measurement - Aggregation of contracts Insurance contracts are accounted and measured by groups of contracts within portfolios of contracts covering similar risks and managed together. Groups of contracts are determined according to their expected profitability at inception: onerous contracts, profitable contracts with a low risk of becoming onerous, and others. A group of contracts may contain only contracts issued no more than one year apart (corresponding to an annual “cohort”), except where the optional exemption provided for in the European regulation applies (for life-savings contracts). For creditor protection insurance (CPI), personal protection insurance and other non-life risks, the Group uses the following discriminatory criteria when constructing portfolios of homogeneous contracts: legal entity, nature of the risks and partner, distributor. The reinsurance contracts accepted shall follow the same principles. For life and savings contracts, the Group uses the following criteria for insurance portfolios: legal entity, product and underlying assets. Savings and retirement contracts are classified in separate portfolios (including in the period prior to the transition) due to the existence of a risk of longevity in retirement contracts. For reinsurance contracts held, the Group uses the following criteria: legal entity, underlying item and partner. A portfolio can sometimes correspond to a single reinsurance treaty. - Recognition and derecognition A group of insurance contracts (or reinsurance contracts issued) is recognised from the earliest of the following dates: the beginning of the period of coverage of the group of contracts, the date on which the first payment of a policyholder in the group becomes due (or, in the absence of such a date, when the first payment is received) and, in the case of a group of onerous contracts, the date on which the group becomes onerous. A group of reinsurance contracts held is recognised from the beginning of the period of coverage of the group of reinsurance contracts held or, if the reinsurance was contracted in anticipation of the coverage of an underlying group of onerous insurance contracts, on the first recognition of that onerous group. On initial recognition of portfolios of insurance contracts acquired as part of a business combination or a separate transfer, groups of contracts acquired are treated as if the contracts had been issued at the date of the transaction. The consideration received or paid in exchange for the contracts is treated as an approximation of the premiums received for the purpose of calculating the contractual service margin at initial recognition from this amount. In the case of a business combination within the scope of IFRS 3, the consideration received or paid is the fair value of the contracts at that date. For onerous contracts, the excess of the fulfilment cash flows over the consideration paid or received is recognised in the goodwill (or the profit resulting from an acquisition on advantageous terms) if it is a business combination and in a separate transfer, in the profit and loss account. For profitable contracts, the difference is recorded as a contractual service margin. In addition, an asset for cash flows related to acquisition costs must be recognised, for its fair value, for the acquisition costs related to the renewal of existing insurance contracts or for the acquisition costs already paid by the acquired company for future contracts. An insurance contract shall be derecognised when the obligation it covers is extinguished, by payment or maturity, or if the terms of the contract are amended in such a way that the accounting treatment of the contract would have been substantially different if those amendments had originally existed. The derecognition of a contract entails the adjustment of the fulfilment cash flows, the contractual services margin and the coverage units of the group in which it was included. -- 34 of 130 -- - 35 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • General measurement model (Building Block Approach – BBA) The general model for the measurement of insurance contracts is the best estimate of the future cash flows to be paid or received necessary to meet contractual obligations. This estimate should reflect the different possible scenarios and the effect of the options and guarantees included in the contracts within the limit or “contract boundary”. The determination of this contract boundary requires an analysis of the rights and obligations arising from the contract and, in particular, of the insurer’s ability to change its price to reflect the risks. This leads, for example, to the exclusion of tacit renewals if the tariff can be amended or to the inclusion of such renewals if not. Cash flows are discounted to reflect the time value of money. They correspond only to cash flows attributable to insurance contracts either directly or through allocation methods: premiums, acquisition and contract management costs, claims and benefits, indirect costs, taxes and depreciation of tangible and intangible assets. The cash flows estimate is supplemented by an explicit risk adjustment to cover the uncertainty for non-financial risk. These two elements constitute the fulfilment cash flows of the contracts. A contractual service margin is added representing the expected gain or loss on future services related to a group of contracts. If the contractual service margin is positive, it is shown on the balance sheet within the insurance contract’s measurement and amortised as the services are rendered; if negative, it is recognised immediately in the income statement. The original loss (or “loss component”) is monitored extra-accounting to allow for the subsequent recognition of the insurance service revenue. Acquisition costs are deducted from the contractual service margin of the group of contracts to which they relate. At each reporting date, the carrying amount of a group of insurance contracts is the sum of the liabilities for the remaining coverage which include the fulfilment cash flows related to future services (best estimate and risk adjustment) and the contractual service margin remaining at that date, and of the liabilities for incurred claims which include include the best estimate of the cash flows and the risk adjustment, without any contractual service margin. The assumptions used to estimate future cash flows and the non-financial risks adjustment are updated, as well as the discount rate, to reflect the situation at the reporting date. The contractual service margin is adjusted for changes in the estimates of non-financial assumptions related to future services, capitalized at inception rate, and then amortised in the income statement for services rendered over the period in the insurance service revenue. In the case of contracts which become onerous, after consumption of the contractual service margin, the loss is recognised in the reporting period. In the case of onerous contracts that become profitable again as a result of favourable changes in assumptions, the contractual service margin is only reconstitued after offsetting the loss component The release of expected fulfillment flows (cash flow estimates and risk adjustments) for the period, except for the amount allocated to the loss component, is recorded in insurance service revenue. The change in estimates related to past service is recognised in insurance service expenses. The Group includes the change in the adjustment for non-financial risk in its entirety in the insurance service result. The Group records in equity the effect of the change in the discount rate. The expense of unwinding the discount is recorded in “insurance financial income or expenses” based on the initial rate (the inception rate for the liability for remaining coverage, and the rate at claims occurrence date for the liability for incurred claims). The difference between the value of liabilities discounted at the rate fixed at initial date and the value of those same liabilities estimated using current discount rate is recognised in equity. The effect on liabilities of changes in financial variables, in particular the indexation of benefits under the contract, is also recognised in equity. Creditor protection insurance (CPI), personal protection insurance and other non-life risks are measured either according to the general model or, if the conditions are met, using the simplified approach. The same treatment applies to reinsurance contracts assumed or held. The discount rate is based on the risk-free rate adjusted for the illiquidity of the liabilities. The risk adjustment is determined using the quantile method. The coverage unit used to amortise the contractual service margin is derived from the risk premium earned during the period. -- 35 of 130 -- - 36 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Measurement model for contracts with direct participation features (Variable Fee Approach – VFA) Direct participating contracts are insurance or investment contracts for which: - the contractual terms specify that the policyholder is entitled to a share of a clearly defined portfolio of underlying assets; - the insurer expects to pay the policyholder a sum corresponding to a substantial portion of the return on the fair value of the underlying assets; - the insurer expects that any change in the amounts to be paid to the policyholder is, in a substantial proportion, attributable to the change in the fair value of the underlying assets. Compliance with these conditions is monitored on the underwriting date and is not reviewed later. For these contracts, for which the insurer has to pay the policyholder an amount corresponding to the fair value of clearly identified underlying assets, less a variable compensation, a specific model (called the “Variable Fee Approach”) has been developed by adapting the general model. At each reporting date, liabilities related to these contracts are adjusted for the return earned and changes in the fair value of the underlying assets: the policyholders’ share is recorded in the contract fulfilment cash flows against insurance financial income or expense and the insurer’s share corresponding to the variable fee is included in the contractual service margin. The contractual service margin is also adjusted for the effect of changes in cash flows that do not vary according to the returns on the underlying assets and that relate to future services: estimation of cash flows, risk adjustment, changes in the time value effect of money and changes in the financial risks that do not result from the underlying assets (for example, the effect of financial guarantees). Changes in the fulfillment cash flows that do not change in connection with the yields of underlying assets and that relate to past service events are recognised in the profit and loss account. Due to the mechanism for allocating the change in the value of the underlying assets between the policyholders and the insurer, the result of these contracts is in principle mainly represented by the release of the fulfilment cash flows and the amortisation of the contractual service margin. When the underlying assets fully support the liabilities and are measured at fair value through profit or loss, the financial result under these contracts should be nil. The Group has chosen the option of reclassifying in shareholders’ equity the change in the liabilities related to the underlying assets that are not measured at fair value through profit or loss. Life and savings contracts meeting the above definition of direct participating contracts are valued using the variable fee approach. When these contracts include a surrender value, it meets the definition of a non-distinct investment component and changes in that investment component (including related payments) are therefore not recognised in the income statement. The Group has chosen to apply the option introduced by the European regulation not to divide the portfolios of participating contracts based on intergenerational mutualisation by annual cohort. This option is applied to insurance contracts and investment contracts with discretionary participation that are eligible to the variable fee approach, euro mono-supports or multi-supports including a euro fund, for which the policyholders’ profit-sharing is mutualised between the different generations of policyholders in France, Italy and Luxembourg. As a result of this choice, the assessment of the onerousness is made on the basis of the portfolio and not on the basis of the annual cohorts. The contract boundary includes future payments as long as the applicable pricing is not modifiable (e.g. acquisition or management loadings), as well as the annuity phase in service when contracts provide for a mandatory annuity. The discount rate is based on the risk-free rate, extrapolated over the duration exceeding the period for which observable data are available and adjusted by a liquidity premium on the basis of the underlying assets to reflect the illiquidity of the liabilities. The risk adjustment is determined using the cost of capital method including future payments without considering the risk of mass lapses. The coverage unit used to amortise the contractual service margin is the change in savings due to policyholders (determined at present value), adjusted to take into account the impact of the real return on financial or property assets compared to the actuarial neutral risk projection. -- 36 of 130 -- - 37 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Simplified measurement model (Premium Allocation Approach – PAA) Short-term contracts (less than one year) may be measured using a simplified approach known as the premium allocation approach, also applicable to longer-term contracts if it leads to results similar to those of the general model in terms of liability for the remaining coverage. For profitable contracts, the liability for the remaining coverage is measured based on the deferral of premiums collected according to a logic similar to that used under IFRS 4. Onerous contracts and liabilities for incurred claims are valued according to the general model. Liabilities for incurred claims are discounted if the expected settlement of claims takes place one year after the date of occurrence. In this case, the option of classifying the effect of changes in the discount rate in equity is also applicable. The Group has chosen the option of deferring acquisition costs over the coverage duration and therefore present them as a deduction of the deferred premiums. Liabilities for incurred claims are discounted if the expected settlement of claims takes place after one year from the date of occurrence. The discount expense is recognised in insurance financial income or expenses as in the general model. In this case, the option to classify the effect of changes in the discount rate into equity is also applicable. The Group has retained this option for the liabilities for incurred claims. At each reporting date, the adjustment of liabilities for remaining coverage and for incurred claims is recognised in profit or loss. Creditor insurance (ADE), personal protection insurance and other non-life insurance contracts, and reinsurance contracts assumed or held, are measured using the simplified approach if the conditions are met. • Treatment of the reinsurance The reinsurance ceded is also treated according to the general or simplified model, but the equivalent of the contractual service margin represents the expected gain or loss on the reinsurance and may be positive or negative. If a reinsurance contract immediately offsets the losses of an underlying group of onerous contracts, the reinsurance gain is recognised immediately in profit or loss. This “loss recovery component” is used to record amounts that are subsequently presented in net income. In addition, contract execution flows include the reinsurer’s risk of non-performance. Reinsurance contracts held are measured by the Group using the simplified approach or the general model. Presentation in the balance sheet and in the profit and loss The Group has chosen to present the investments of insurance activities and their results separately from the financial assets and liabilities of banking activities. Financial income or expenses from issued insurance contracts are presented separately between the profit and loss account and shareholders’ equity for portfolios for which this breakdown has been deemed relevant, as allowed by the standard. For the Protection contracts liabilities measured under the general model and for the liabilities for incurred claims arising from contracts measured under the simplified model, this choice for portfolios classification was made by taking into account both the effects in the profit and loss account of the undiscounting of the liabilities and the accounting treatment of the assets backing them. For contracts measured using the variable fee approach, this choice was made to offset any accounting mismatch that may exist in the profit and loss account between the effect of changes in fair value from insurance or investment liabilities and that from the underlying assets when these are not recognised at fair value through profit or loss. Insurance contracts may be distributed and managed by non-insurance entities of the Group that are remunerated as such by commissions paid by insurance entities. The measurement model for insurance contracts requires projecting in the contract fulfilment cash flows the acquisition and management costs that will be paid in the future and presenting in the profit and loss account, the release of the estimated costs for the period on the one hand, and on the other, the actual costs. For commissions between consolidated companies in the Group, the Group restates the internal margin on the balance sheet and in the profit and loss account (in the breakdown of insurance liabilities and the related results between cash flows and contractual service margin) by presenting as insurance service expenses the portion of the general expenses (excluding internal margins) of the banking entities that can be attributed to the insurance activity. The internal distributors’ margins are determined based on standardised management data for each of the related networks. -- 37 of 130 -- - 38 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Effect of accounting estimates in interim financial statements The Group has elected under IFRS 17 to record in its annual financial statements the effects of changes in accounting estimates relating to insurance contracts issued or held, without taking into account estimates previously made in its interim financial statements. 1.h P ROPERTY, PLANT , EQUIPMENT AND INTANGIBLE ASSETS Property, plant and equipment and intangible assets shown in the consolidated balance sheet are composed of assets used in operations and investment property. Rights-of-use related to leased assets (see note 1.i.2) are presented by the lessee within fixed assets in the same category as similar assets held. Assets used in operations are those used in the provision of services or for administrative purposes, and include non-property assets leased by the Group as lessor under operating leases. Investment property comprises property assets held to generate rental income and capital gains. Investment property is recognised at cost, except for those held as underlying assets under participating direct contracts (as amended by IAS 40), which are measured at fair value through profit or loss and presented in the balance sheet under “Investments related to insurance activities” (see note 1.g.1). Property, plant and equipment and intangible assets are initially recognised at purchase price plus directly attributable costs, together with borrowing costs where a long period of construction or adaptation is required before the asset can be brought into service. By way of exception, property occupied by the holder entity that is an underlying component of direct participating contracts is measured at fair value (by amendment to IAS 16). Software developed internally by the BNP Paribas Group that fulfils the criteria for capitalisation is capitalised at direct development cost, which includes external costs and the labour costs of employees directly attributable to the project. Subsequent to initial recognition, property, plant and equipment and intangible assets are measured at cost less accumulated depreciation or amortisation and any impairment losses. The depreciable amount of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets is calculated after deducting the residual value of the asset. Only assets leased by the Group as the lessor under operating leases are presumed to have a residual value, as the useful life of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets used in operations is generally the same as their economic life. Property, plant and equipment and intangible assets are depreciated or amortised using the straight-line method over the useful life of the asset. Depreciation and amortisation expense is recognised in the profit and loss account under “Depreciation, amortisation and impairment of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets”. Where an asset consists of a number of components which may require replacement at regular intervals, or which have different uses or generate economic benefits at different rates, each component is recognised separately and depreciated using a method appropriate to that component. The BNP Paribas Group has adopted the component- based approach for property used in operations and for investment property. The depreciation periods used for office property are as follows: 80 years or 60 years for the shell (for prime and other property respectively); 30 years for facades; 20 years for general and technical installations; and 10 years for fixtures and fittings. Software is amortised, depending on its type, over periods of no more than 8 years in the case of infrastructure developments and 3 years or 5 years in the case of software developed primarily for the purpose of providing services to customers. Software maintenance costs are expensed as incurred. However, expenditure that is regarded as upgrading the software or extending its useful life is included in the initial acquisition or production cost. Depreciable property, plant and equipment and intangible assets are tested for impairment if there is an indication of potential impairment at the balance sheet date. Non-depreciable assets are tested for impairment at least annually, using the same method as for goodwill allocated to cash-generating units. If there is an indication of impairment, the new recoverable amount of the asset is compared with the carrying amount. If the asset is found to be impaired, an impairment loss is recognised in the profit and loss account. This loss is reversed in the event of a change in the estimated recoverable amount or if there is no longer an indication of impairment. Impairment losses are taken to the profit and loss account in “Depreciation, amortisation and impairment of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets”. -- 38 of 130 -- - 39 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Gains and losses on disposals of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets used in operations are recognised in the profit and loss account in “Net gain on non-current assets”. Gains and losses on disposals of investment property are recognised in the profit and loss account in “Income from other activities” or “Expense on other activities”. 1.i L EASES Group companies may either be the lessee or the lessor in a lease agreement. 1.i.1 G ROUP COMPANY AS LESSOR Leases contracted by the Group as lessor are categorised as either finance leases or operating leases. • Finance leases In a finance lease, the lessor transfers substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership of an asset to the lessee. It is treated as a loan made to the lessee to finance the purchase of the asset. The present value of the lease payments, plus any residual value, is recognised as a receivable. The net income earned from the lease by the lessor is equal to the amount of interest on the loan and is taken to the profit and loss account under “Interest income”. The lease payments are spread over the lease term and are allocated to reduction of the principal and to interest such that the net income reflects a constant rate of return on the net investment outstanding in the lease. The rate of interest used is the rate implicit in the lease. Impairments of lease receivables are determined using the same principles as applied to financial assets measured at amortised cost. • Operating leases An operating lease is a lease under which substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership of an asset are not transferred to the lessee. The asset is recognised under property, plant and equipment in the lessor’s balance sheet and depreciated on a straight-line basis over its useful life. The depreciable amount excludes the residual value of the asset. The lease payments are taken to the profit and loss account in full on a straight-line basis over the lease term. Lease payments and depreciation expenses are taken to the profit and loss account under “Income from other activities” and “Expense on other activities”. 1.i.2 G ROUP COMPANY AS LESSEE Lease contracts concluded by the Group, with the exception of contracts whose term is shorter than or equal to 12 months and low-value contracts, are recognised in the balance-sheet in the form of a right-of-use on the leased asset presented under fixed assets, along with the recognition of a financial liability for the rent and other payments to be made over the leasing period. The right of use assets is amortised on a straight-line basis and the financial liabilities are amortised on an actuarial basis over the lease period. Dismantling costs corresponding to specific and significant fittings and fixtures are included in the initial right-of-use estimation, in counterparty of a provision liability. -- 39 of 130 -- - 40 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The key hypothesis used by the Group for the measurement of rights of use and lease liabilities are the following: • the lease term corresponds to the non-cancellable period of the contract, together with periods covered by an extension option if the Group is reasonably certain to exercise this option. In France, the standard commercial lease contract is the so-called “three, six, nine” contract for which the maximum period of use is nine years, with a first non-cancellable period of three years followed by two optional extension periods of three years each; hence, depending on the assessment, the lease term can be of three, six or nine years. When investments like fittings or fixtures are performed under the contract, the lease term is aligned with their useful lives. For tacitly renewable contracts, with or without an enforceable period, related right of use and lease liabilities are recognised based on an estimate of the reasonably foreseeable economic life of the contracts, minimal occupation period included; • the discount rate used to measure the right of use and the lease liability is assessed for each contract as the interest rate implicit in the lease, if that rate can be readily determined, or more generally based on the incremental borrowing rate of the lessee at the date of signature. The incremental borrowing rate is determined considering the average term (duration) of the contract; • when the contract is modified, a new assessment of the lease liability is made taking into account the new residual term of the contract, and therefore a new assessment of the right of use and the lease liability is established. 1.j ASSETS HELD FOR SALE AND DISCONTINUED OPERATIONS Where the Group decides to sell assets or a group of assets and liabilities and it is highly probable that the sale will occur within 12 months, these assets are shown separately in the balance sheet, on the line “Assets held for sale”. Any liabilities associated with these assets are also shown separately in the balance sheet, on the line “Liabilities associated with assets held for sale”. When the Group is committed to a sale plan involving loss of control of a subsidiary and the sale is highly probable within 12 months, all the assets and liabilities of that subsidiary are classified as held for sale. Once classified in this category, assets and the group of assets and liabilities are measured at the lower of carrying amount or fair value less costs to sell. Such assets are no longer depreciated. If an asset or group of assets and liabilities becomes impaired, an impairment loss is recognised in the profit and loss account. Impairment losses may be reversed. Where a group of assets and liabilities held for sale represents a cash generating unit, it is categorised as a “discontinued operation”. Discontinued operations include operations that are held for sale, operations that have been shut down, and subsidiaries acquired exclusively with a view to resell. In this case, gains and losses related to discontinued operations are shown separately in the profit and loss account, on the line “Net income from discontinued activities”. This line includes after tax profits or losses of discontinued operations, after tax gain or loss arising from remeasurement at fair value less costs to sell, and after tax gain or loss on disposal of the operation. 1.k EMPLOYEE BENEFITS Employee benefits are classified into four categories: - short-term benefits, such as salary, annual leave, incentive plans, profit-sharing and additional payments; - long-term benefits, including compensated absences, long-service awards, and other types of cash-based deferred compensation; - termination benefits; - post-employment benefits, including top-up banking industry pensions and retirement bonuses in France and pension plans in other countries, some of which are operated through pension funds. -- 40 of 130 -- - 41 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Short-term benefits The Group recognises an expense when it has used services rendered by employees in exchange for employee benefits. • Long-term benefits These are benefits, other than short-term benefits, post-employment benefits and termination benefits. This relates, in particular, to compensation deferred for more than 12 months and not linked to the BNP Paribas share price, which is accrued in the financial statements for the period in which it is earned. The actuarial techniques used are similar to those used for defined-benefit post-employment benefits, except that the revaluation items are recognised in the profit and loss account and not in equity. • Termination benefits Termination benefits are employee benefits payable in exchange for the termination of an employee’s contract as a result of either a decision by the Group to terminate a contract of employment before the legal retirement age, or a decision by an employee to accept voluntary redundancy in exchange for these benefits. Termination benefits due more than 12 months after the balance sheet date are discounted. • Post-employment benefits In accordance with IFRS, the BNP Paribas Group draws a distinction between defined-contribution plans and defined-benefit plans. Defined-contribution plans do not give rise to an obligation for the Group and do not require a provision. The amount of the employer’s contributions payable during the period is recognised as an expense. Only defined-benefit schemes give rise to an obligation for the Group. This obligation must be measured and recognised as a liability by means of a provision. The classification of plans into these two categories is based on the economic substance of the plan, which is reviewed to determine whether the Group has a legal or constructive obligation to pay the agreed benefits to employees. Post-employment benefit obligations under defined-benefit plans are measured using actuarial techniques that take demographic and financial assumptions into account. The net liability recognised with respect to post-employment benefit plans is the difference between the present value of the defined-benefit obligation and the fair value of any plan assets. The present value of the defined-benefit obligation is measured on the basis of the actuarial assumptions applied by the Group, using the projected unit credit method. This method takes into account various parameters, specific to each country or Group entity, such as demographic assumptions, the probability that employees will leave before retirement age, salary inflation, a discount rate, and the general inflation rate. When the value of the plan assets exceeds the amount of the obligation, an asset is recognised if it represents a future economic benefit for the Group in the form of a reduction in future contributions or a future partial refund of amounts paid into the plan. The annual expense recognised in the profit and loss account under “Salaries and employee benefits”, with respect to defined-benefit plans includes the current service cost (the rights vested by each employee during the period in return for service rendered), the net interests linked to the effect of discounting the net defined-benefit liability (asset), the past service cost arising from plan amendments or curtailments, and the effect of any plan settlements. Remeasurements of the net defined-benefit liability (asset) are recognised in shareholders’ equity and are never reclassified to profit or loss. They include actuarial gains and losses, the return on plan assets and any change in the effect of the asset ceiling (excluding amounts included in net interest on the defined-benefit liability or asset). -- 41 of 130 -- - 42 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 1.l SHARE- BASED PAYMENTS Share-based payment transactions are payments based on shares issued by the Group, whether the transaction is settled in the form of equity or cash of which the amount is based on trends in the value of BNP Paribas shares. • Stock option and share award plans The expense related to stock option and share award plans is recognised over the vesting period, if the benefit is conditional upon the grantee’s continued employment. Stock options and share award expenses are recorded under salary and employee benefits expenses, with a corresponding adjustment to shareholders' equity. They are calculated on the basis of the overall plan value, determined at the date of grant by the Board of directors. In the absence of any market for these instruments, financial valuation models are used that take into account any performance conditions related to the BNP Paribas share price. The total expense of a plan is determined by multiplying the unit value per option or share awarded by the estimated number of options or shares awarded vested at the end of the vesting period, taking into account the conditions regarding the grantee’s continued employment. The only assumptions revised during the vesting period, and hence resulting in a remeasurement of the expense, are those relating to the probability that employees will leave the Group and those relating to performance conditions that are not linked to the price value of BNP Paribas shares. • Share price-linked cash-settled deferred compensation plans The expense related to these plans is recognised in the year during which the employee rendered the corresponding services. If the payment of share-based variable compensation is explicitly subject to the employee's continued presence at the vesting date, the services are presumed to have been rendered during the vesting period and the corresponding compensation expense is recognised on a pro rata basis over that period. The expense is recognised under salary and employee benefits expenses with a corresponding liability in the balance sheet. It is revised to take into account any non-fulfilment of the continued presence or performance conditions and the change in BNP Paribas share price. If there is no continued presence condition, the expense is not deferred, but recognised immediately with a corresponding liability in the balance sheet. This is then revised on each reporting date until settlement to take into account any performance conditions and the change in the BNP Paribas share price. 1.m P ROVISIONS RECORDED UNDER LIABILITIES Provisions recorded under liabilities (other than those relating to financial instruments, employee benefits and insurance contracts) mainly relate to restructuring, claims and litigation, fines and penalties. A provision is recognised when it is probable that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle an obligation arising from a past event, and a reliable estimate can be made of the amount of the obligation. The amount of such obligations is discounted, where the impact of discounting is material, in order to determine the amount of the provision. -- 42 of 130 -- - 43 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 1.n C URRENT AND DEFERRED TAX The current income tax charge is determined on the basis of the tax laws and tax rates in force in each country in which the Group operates during the period in which the income is generated. Deferred taxes are recognised when temporary differences arise between the carrying amount of an asset or liability in the balance sheet and its tax base. Deferred tax liabilities are recognised for all taxable temporary differences other than: - taxable temporary differences on initial recognition of goodwill; - taxable temporary differences on investments in enterprises under the exclusive or joint control of the Group, where the Group is able to control the timing of the reversal of the temporary difference and it is probable that the temporary difference will not reverse in the foreseeable future. Deferred tax assets are recognised for all deductible temporary differences and unused carryforwards of tax losses only to the extent that it is probable that the entity in question will generate future taxable profits against which these temporary differences and tax losses can be offset. Deferred tax assets and liabilities are measured using the liability method, using the tax rate which is expected to apply to the period when the asset is realised or the liability is settled, based on tax rates and tax laws that have been or will have been enacted by the balance sheet date of that period. They are not discounted. Deferred tax assets and liabilities are offset when they arise within the same tax group, they fall under the jurisdiction of a single tax authority, and there is a legal right to offset. As regards the assessment of uncertainty over income tax treatments, the Group adopts the following approach: - the Group assesses whether it is probable that a taxation authority will accept an uncertain tax treatment; - any uncertainty shall be reflected when determining the taxable profit (loss) by considering either the most likely amount (having the higher probability of occurrence), or the expected value (sum of the probability- weighted amounts). Current and deferred taxes are recognised as tax income or expenses in the profit and loss account, except for those relating to a transaction or an event directly recognised in shareholders’ equity, which are also recognised in shareholders’ equity. This concerns in particular the tax effect of coupons paid on financial instruments issued by the Group and qualified as equity instruments, such as Undated Super Subordinated Notes. When tax credits on revenues from receivables and securities are used to settle corporate income tax payable for the period, the tax credits are recognised on the same line as the income to which they relate. The corresponding tax expense continues to be carried in the profit and loss account under “Corporate income tax”. 1.o CASH FLOW STATEMENT The cash and cash equivalents balance is composed of the net balance of cash accounts and accounts with central banks, and the net balance of interbank demand loans and deposits. Changes in cash and cash equivalents related to operating activities reflect cash flows generated by the Group’s operations, including those relating to financial investments of insurance activities and negotiable certificates of deposit. Changes in cash and cash equivalents related to investing activities reflect cash flows resulting from acquisitions and disposals of subsidiaries, associates or joint ventures included in the consolidated Group, as well as acquisitions and disposals of property, plant and equipment excluding investment property and property held under operating leases. Changes in cash and cash equivalents related to financing activities reflect the cash inflows and outflows resulting from transactions with shareholders, cash flows related to bonds and subordinated debt, and debt securities (excluding negotiable certificates of deposit). -- 43 of 130 -- - 44 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 1.p U SE OF ESTIMATES IN THE PREPARATION OF THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Preparation of the financial statements requires managers of core businesses and corporate functions to make assumptions and estimates that are reflected in the measurement of income and expense in the profit and loss account and of assets and liabilities in the balance sheet, and in the disclosure of information in the notes to the financial statements. This requires the managers in question to exercise their judgement and to make use of information available at the date of the preparation of the financial statements when making their estimates. The actual future results from operations where managers have made use of estimates may in reality differ significantly from those estimates, mainly according to market conditions. This may have a material effect on the financial statements. This applies in particular to: - the analysis of the cash flow criterion for specific financial assets; - the measurement of expected credit losses. This applies in particular to the assessment of significant increase in credit risk, the models and assumptions used to measure expected credit losses, the determination of the different economic scenarios and their weighting; - the analysis of renegotiated loans, in order to assess whether they should be maintained on the balance- sheet or derecognised; - the assessment of an active market, and the use of internally developed models for the measurement of the fair value of financial instruments not quoted in an active market classified in “Financial assets at fair value through equity”, or in “Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss”, whether as assets or liabilities, and more generally calculations of the fair value of financial instruments subject to a fair value disclosure requirement; - the assumptions applied to assess the sensitivity to each type of market risk of the market value of financial instruments and the sensitivity of these valuations to the main unobservable inputs as disclosed in the notes to the financial statements; - the appropriateness of the designation of certain derivative instruments such as cash flow hedges, and the measurement of hedge effectiveness; - impairment tests performed on intangible assets; - the estimation of residual assets values under simple lease agreements. These values are used as a basis for the determination of depreciation as well as any impairment, notably in relation to the effect of environmental considerations on the evaluation of future prices of second-hand vehicles; - the deferred tax assets; - the measurement of insurance liabilities and assets, and investment contracts with discretionary participation, by groups of contracts, on the basis of discounted and probability weighted future fulfilment cash flows, based on assumptions that can be derived from market or entity-specific data, and the recognition of the results of such contracts on the basis of the services rendered over the coverage period; - the measurement of uncertainty over income tax treatments and other provisions for contingencies and charges. In particular, while investigations and litigations are ongoing, it is difficult to foresee their outcome and potential impact. Provision estimation is established by taking into account all available information at the date of the preparation of the financial statements, in particular the nature of the dispute, the underlying facts, the ongoing legal proceedings and court decisions, including those related to similar cases. The Group may also use the opinion of experts and independent legal advisers to exercise its judgement. -- 44 of 130 -- - 45 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 2. IFRS 17 AND IFRS 9 FIRST TIME APPLICATION IMPACTS • IFRS 17 and IFRS 9 first time application impacts on the balance sheet at 31 December 2022 In millions of euros 31 December 2022 IFRS 17 and 9 1st time application impacts 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 ASSETS Cash and balances at central banks 318,560 318,560 Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss Securities 166,077 166,077 Loans and repurchase agreements 191,125 191,125 Derivative financial instruments 327,932 327,932 Derivatives used for hedging purposes 25,401 25,401 Financial assets at fair value through equity Debt securities 35,878 35,878 Financial assets at amortised cost Loans and advances to credit institutions 32,616 32,616 Loans and advances to customers 857,020 857,020 Debt securities 114,014 114,014 Remeasurement adjustment on interest-rate risk hedged portfolios (7,477) (7,477) Investments and other assets related to insurance activities 247,403 (1,928)(a)(c)(d) 245,475 Current and deferred tax assets 5,893 39 5,932 Accrued income and other assets 209,092 (549) 208,543 Equity-method investments 6,263 (190) 6,073 Property, plant and equipment and investment property 38,468 38,468 Intangible assets 3,790 3,790 Goodwill 5,294 5,294 Assets held for sale 86,839 86,839 TOTAL ASSETS 2,666,376 (2,628) 2,663,748 LIABILITIES Deposits from central banks 3,054 3,054 Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss Securities 99,155 99,155 Deposits and repurchase agreements 234,076 234,076 Issued debt securities 70,460 (4,882)(e)(c) 65,578 Derivative financial instruments 300,121 300,121 Financial liabilities at amortised cost Deposits from credit institutions 124,718 124,718 Deposits from customers 1,008,054 2 1,008,056 Debt securities 154,143 1,216 (c) 155,359 Subordinated debt 24,156 4 24,160 Remeasurement adjustment on interest-rate risk hedged portfolios (20,201) (20,201) Current and deferred tax liabilities 3,054 (75) 2,979 Accrued expenses and other liabilities 185,456 (446) 185,010 Technical reserves and other insurance liabilities 226,532 (226,532)(a)(e) Liabilities related to insurance contracts 209,772 (b) 209,772 Financial liabilities related to insurance activities 18,858 (e) 18,858 Provisions for contingencies and charges 10,040 10,040 Liabilities associated with assets held for sale 77,002 77,002 TOTAL LIABILITIES 2,539,821 (2,083) 2,537,738 EQUITY Share capital, additional paid-in capital and retained earnings 115,149 (141) 115,008 Net income for the period attributable to shareholders 10,196 (348) 9,848 Total capital, retained earnings and net income for the period attributable to shareholders 125,345 (489) 124,856 Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity (3,553) (66) (3,619) Shareholders' equity 121,792 (555)(f) 121,237 Minority interests 4,763 10 4,773 TOTAL EQUITY 126,555 (545) 126,010 TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY 2,666,376 (2,629) 2,663,748 -- 45 of 130 -- - 46 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The transition from IFRS 4 to IFRS 17 leads to the removal through equity of assets and liabilities of insurance contracts recognised in accordance with the previous standard net of deferred tax effects: insurance liabilities, reinsurance assets held, and deferred policyholders’ participation arising from “shadow accounting”. Receivables and payables related to insurance or reinsurance contracts were not cancelled but are included in the new measurement of insurance liabilities and assets. The main impacts linked to the first time application of IFRS 4 and IFRS 17 at 31 December 2022 are: (a) The removal of insurance assets and liabilities recognised under IFRS 4: • on the assets side, - EUR 5.2 billion within “Investments and other assets related to insurance activities”: - EUR 2.3 billion linked to reinsurance assets held, mainly mathematical reserves, and - EUR 2.9 billion in respect of deferred profit-sharing arising from shadow accounting. • on the liabilities side, - EUR 221.6 billion of insurance contract liabilities previously recorded as “Technical reserves and other insurance liabilities”, (b) The recognition of “Liabilities related to insurance contracts” for + EUR 209.8 billion, including: • the best estimate of future fulfilment cash-flows together with the risk adjustment and the contractual service margin measured in accordance to IFRS 17; • other assets and liabilities linked to insurance contracts (mainly policyholders’ receivables and payables). The methods used at transition date for the measurement of the insurance contracts are described in note 1.a “Applicable accounting standards” – Transition from IFRS 4 to IFRS 17. (c) The application of the amendment to IFRS 9 enabling the recognition in the balance sheet of financial assets issued by the Group that are held as underlying items of direct participating contracts and are measured at fair value through profit or loss. Consequently, “Investments and other assets related to insurance activities” increased by + EUR 2 billion, against, on the liabilities side, an increase of + EUR 0.8 billion in “Issued debt securities at fair value through profit or loss” and + EUR 1.2 billion in “Debt securities at amortised cost”. (d) The Group also applies the amendments to IAS 40 and IAS 16 resulting from IFRS 17, leading to measure at fair value through profit or loss of the buildings held as underlying items of direct participating contracts and recognise + EUR 1.6 billion within “Investments and other assets related to insurance activities”. (e) “Financial liabilities related to insurance activities” previously recorded as “Issued debt securities” for + EUR 5.7 billion or as “Other insurance liabilities” have been combined under the same line. (f) The application of IFRS 17 and IFRS 9 results in a - EUR 0.6 billion impact to equity attributable to shareholders, net of tax effect at 31 December 2022. -- 46 of 130 -- - 47 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023  IFRS 9 and IFRS 17 first time application impacts on “Investments and other assets related to insurance activities” In millions of euros 31 December 2022 (IAS 39/IFRS 4) Reclassifications Total reclassificatio ns to IFRS 9 categories IFRS 9 impacts (insurance entities) IFRS 17, IAS 16 and IAS 40 impacts 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Available-for-sale financial assets at fair Held-to-maturity financial assets at amortised cost Other reclassificatio ns Remeasureme nt (phase 1) Impairment adjustments (phase 2) Debt securities Equity securities Debt securities Loans and receivables Financial instruments at fair value through profit and loss 125,640 7,694 9,497 101 165 325 17,782 276 2,015 145,713 Financial assets at fair value through equity 104,961 (7,694) (9,497) 967 255 (15,969) 93 (60) 89,025 Financial assets at amortised cost 4,044 (1,068) (165) (29) (1,262) (1,629) 1,153 Equity-method investments 342 (228) (228) 114 Investment property 7,257 1,562 8,819 Reinsurer's share of technical reserves 2,277 (2,277) Policyholders' surplus reserve - assets 2,882 (2,882) Assets related to insurance activities 651 651 Investments and other assets related to insurance activities 247,403 - - - - 323 323 369 (60) (2,560) 245,475 Financial assets and liabilities of insurance entities are managed by portfolios corresponding to the insurance liabilities they back up or to the own funds. The business models were therefore determined according to these portfolios at the transition date to IFRS 9. Under the business model and cash flow criteria, debt instruments are largely classified according to the “collect and sell” model, except for those representing unit-linked contracts, debt instruments held by consolidated UCITS and managed at disposal value, which are measured at fair value through profit or loss. Certain specific assets are designated as at fair value through profit or loss. Most equity instruments are measured at fair value through profit or loss, except for certain assets backing own-funds and non-participating contracts portfolios, which are measured at fair value through equity. Non-consolidated funds classified as available-for-sale financial assets under IAS 39 have been reclassified at fair value through profit or loss. The treatment of derivatives remains unchanged, including for hedge accounting, for which the principles of IAS 39 continue to be applied by the Group (see note 1.f.9). -- 47 of 130 -- - 48 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 3. NOTES TO THE PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2023 3.a N ET INTEREST INCOME The BNP Paribas Group includes in “Interest income” and “Interest expense” all income and expense calculated using the effective interest method (interest, fees and transaction costs) from financial instruments measured at amortised cost and financial instruments measured at fair value through equity. These items also include the interest income and expense of non-trading financial instruments the characteristics of which do not allow for recognition at amortised cost or at fair value through equity, as well as of financial instruments that the Group has designated as at fair value through profit or loss. The change in fair value on financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss (excluding accrued interest) is recognised under “Net gain on financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss”. Interest income and expense on derivatives accounted for as fair value hedges are included with the revenues generated by the hedged item. Similarly, interest income and expense arising from derivatives used to hedge transactions designated as at fair value through profit or loss is allocated to the same accounts as the interest income and expense relating to the underlying transactions. In the case of a negative interest rates related to loans and receivables or deposits from customers and credit institutions, they are accounted for in interest expense or interest income respectively. In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Income Expense Net Income Expense Net Financial instruments at amortised cost 66,886 (48,617) 18,269 34,795 (15,405) 19,390 Deposits, loans and borrowings 59,019 (36,827) 22,192 30,749 (11,652) 19,097 Repurchase agreements 681 (1,295) (614) 274 (83) 191 Finance leases 2,480 (109) 2,371 1,763 (102) 1,661 Debt securities 4,706 4,706 2,009 2,009 Issued debt securities and subordinated debt (10,386) (10,386) (3,568) (3,568) Financial instruments at fair value through equity 1,856 - 1,856 738 - 738 Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss (Trading securities excluded) 243 (1,454) (1,211) 59 (279) (220) Cash flow hedge instruments 3,897 (1,741) 2,156 3,025 (1,450) 1,575 Interest rate portfolio hedge instruments 6,660 (8,600) (1,940) 2,465 (2,965) (500) Lease liabilities - (72) (72) (50) (50) Total interest income/(expense) 79,542 (60,484) 19,058 41,082 (20,149) 20,933 Net interest income notably includes an expense of EUR 938 million due to the adjustment of economic hedges consecutive to the changes in the TLTRO terms and conditions mentioned below. Net interest income includes funding costs related to Global Markets, whose revenues are mainly accounted for in “Net gain on financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss” (see note 3.c), as well as to Arval, whose income from operating leases is presented in note 3.e. The evolution of the net interest income is therefore to be analysed in conjunction with those observed for these lines. -- 48 of 130 -- - 49 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Interest income on individually impaired loans amounted to EUR 342 million for the year ended 2023, compared to EUR 287 million for the year ended 2022. The Group subscribed to the TLTRO III (Targeted Longer-Term Refinancing Operations) programme, as modified by the Governing Council of the European Central Bank in March 2020, in December 2020 and in October 2022 (see note 5.g). The Group achieved the lending performance thresholds that enabled it to benefit from favourable interest rate conditions applicable for each of the reference period, namely: - over the two special interest periods (i.e. from June 2020 to June 2022): the average deposit facility rate (“DFR”) -50 basis points, or -1%; - over the next period (i.e. from June 2022 to November 2022): the average of the DFR between the TLTRO III initial date of subscription and 22 November 2022, i.e., for the main draws, -0.36% for the June 2020 tranche and -0.29% for the March 2021 tranche; - over the last period (since 23 November 2022): the average of the DFR between 23 November 2022 and the redemption date. The average effective interest rate for the latter period was 3.15% (1.64% until 31 December 2022 and 3.31% for the year 2023). This floating interest rate is considered as a market rate since it is applicable to all financial institutions meeting the lending criteria defined by the European Central Bank. The effective interest rate of these financial liabilities is determined for each reference period, its two components (reference rate and margin) being adjustable; it corresponds to the nominal interest rate. The addition of the last interest period in October 2022 is part of the European Central Bank’s monetary policy and is therefore not considered a contractual amendment according to IFRS 9 but a revision of the market rate. 3.b C OMMISSION INCOME AND EXPENSE In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 according to IFRS 17 and 9 Income Expense Net Income Expense Net Customer transactions 4,997 (1,250) 3,747 4,772 (1,172) 3,600 Securities and derivatives transactions 2,483 (1,965) 518 2,051 (1,561) 490 Financing and guarantee commitments 1,155 (189) 966 1,181 (100) 1,081 Asset management and other services 5,176 (367) 4,809 5,425 (385) 5,040 Others 1,200 (1,419) (219) 1,193 (1,239) (46) Commission income and expense 15,011 (5,190) 9,821 14,622 (4,457) 10,165 - of which net commission income related to trust and similar activities through which the Group holds or invests assets on behalf of clients, trusts, pension and personal risk funds or other institutions 3,133 (360) 2,773 3,248 (376) 2,872 - of which commission income and expense on financial instruments not measured at fair value through profit or loss 3,133 (453) 2,680 3,048 (370) 2,678 -- 49 of 130 -- - 50 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 3.c N ET GAIN ON FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH PROFIT OR LOSS Net gain on financial instruments measured at fair value through profit or loss includes all profit and loss items relating to financial instruments held for trading, financial instruments that the Group has designated as at fair value through profit or loss, non-trading equity instruments that the Group did not choose to measure at fair value through equity, as well as debt instruments whose cash flows are not solely repayments of principal and interest on the principal or whose business model is not to collect cash flows nor to collect cash flows and sell the assets. These income items include dividends on these instruments and exclude interest income and expense from financial instruments designated as at fair value through profit or loss and instruments whose cash flows are not only repayments of principal and interest on the principal or whose business model is not to collect cash flows nor to collect cash flows and sell the assets, which are presented in “Net interest income” (see note 3.a). Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 In millions of euros Financial instruments held for trading 13,801 (2,023) Interest rate and credit instruments 8,948 (6,014) Equity financial instruments 3,184 (3,268) Foreign exchange financial instruments 5,452 5,898 Loans and repurchase agreements (4,515) (1,326) Other financial instruments 732 2,687 Financial instruments designated as at fair value through profit or loss (3,985) 11,328 Other financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss 565 143 Impact of hedge accounting (35) (96) Fair value hedging derivatives (1,247) (9,123) Hedged items in fair value hedge 1,212 9,027 Net gain on financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss 10,346 9,352 Gains and losses on financial instruments designated as at fair value through profit or loss are mainly related to instruments for which changes in value may be compensated by changes in the value of economic hedging derivative financial instruments held for trading. Net gain on financial instruments held for trading in 2023 and 2022 includes a non-material amount related to the ineffective portion of cash flow hedges. Potential sources of ineffectiveness can be the differences between hedging instruments and hedged items, notably generated by mismatches in the terms of hedged and hedging instruments, such as the frequency and timing of interest rates resetting, the frequency of payments and the discounting factors, or when hedging derivatives have a non-zero fair value at the inception date of the hedging relationship. Credit valuation adjustments applied to hedging derivatives are also sources of ineffectiveness. Cumulated changes in fair value related to discontinued cash flow hedge relationships, previously recognised in equity and included in 2023 in profit and loss accounts are not material, whether the hedged item ceased to exist or not. 3.d N ET GAIN ON FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH EQUITY In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Net gain on debt instruments (56) 9 Dividend income on equity instruments 84 129 Net gain on financial instruments at fair value through equity 28 138 Interest income from debt instruments is included in note 3.a Net interest income, and impairment losses related to potential issuer default are included in note 3.g Cost of risk. -- 50 of 130 -- - 51 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 3.e N ET INCOME FROM OTHER ACTIVITIES In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Income Expense Net Income Expense Net Net income from investment property 54 (28) 26 58 (30) 28 Net income from assets held under operating leases 15,787 (12,103) 3,684 13,134 (10,365) 2,769 Net income from property development activities 488 (416) 72 773 (653) 120 Other net income 2,231 (1,778) 453 1,769 (1,704) 65 Total net income from other activities 18,560 (14,325) 4,235 15,734 (12,752) 2,982 3.f O PERATING EXPENSES In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Salary and employee benefit expense for banking activities (17,775) (16,877) Other operating expenses for banking activities (11,221) (11,026) of which external services and other operating expenses (8,865) (8,611) of which taxes and contributions (1) (2,356) (2,415) Insurance activities non attributable costs (note 6.b) (758) (713) Reclassification of expenses incurred by internal distributors attributable to insurance contracts 1,041 1,056 Operating expenses (28,713) (27,560) (1) Contributions to European resolution fund, including exceptional contributions, amount to EUR 1,002 million for year ended 2023 compared with EUR 1,256 million for the year ended 2022. Taxes and contributions, including those related to insurance activities, amounted to EUR 2,442 million for the year ended 2023 (compared to EUR 2,510 million for the year ended 2022). Expenses directly attributable to insurance contracts are presented in “Net income from insurance activities”. These costs consist mainly of distribution commissions paid for the acquisition of the contracts and other costs necessary for handling the contracts. They are included in the fulfilment expenses within the “Insurance service result” (see note 6.a). Expenses attributable to insurance contracts include the operating expenses incurred by the Group banking networks to distribute insurance contracts. Related costs are assessed on the basis of the commissions paid by the insurance entities to the internal distributors less their margin. These costs are excluded from “Operating expenses” to be included in the contracts fulfilment cash flows through the “Reclassification of expenses incurred by internal distributors attributable to insurance contracts”. Operating costs not directly attributable to insurance contracts are included in “Operating expenses”. Reconciliation by type and by function of insurance activities operating expenses is presented in note 6.b. -- 51 of 130 -- - 52 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 3.g C OST OF RISK The general model for impairment described in note 1.f.5 used by the Group relies on the following two steps: - assessing whether there has been a significant increase in credit risk since initial recognition, and - measuring impairment allowance as either 12-month expected credit losses or lifetime expected credit loss (i.e. loss expected at maturity). Both steps rely on forward-looking information. Significant increase in credit risk At 31 December 2022, BNP Paribas revised its criteria for assessing the significant increase in credit risk in line with the recommendations issued by the European Banking Authority and the European Central Bank. Previously, except for the consumer credit specialist business, the credit risk deterioration was mainly evaluated based on changes in the internal credit rating, an indicator of the average 1-year probability of default through the cycle. In order to fully consider forward-looking information, the new criteria use the probability of default to maturity, which is derived from the internal rating, incorporating the expected consequences of changes in macroeconomic scenarios, as the main indicator. Under these new criteria, credit risk is assumed to have significantly increased, and the asset is classified in stage 2, if the probability of default to maturity of the instrument has increased at least threefold since its origination. This relative variation criterion is supplemented by an absolute variation criterion of the default probability of 400 basis points. Furthermore, for all portfolios (except for the consumer credit specialist business): - the facility is assumed to be in stage 1 when its 1-year “Point in Time” probability of default (PiT PD) is below 0.3% at the reporting date, since changes in probability of default due to credit downgrades in this zone are not material, and therefore not considered “significant”; - when the 1-year PiT PD is greater than 20% at the reporting date, given the Group’s credit issuance practices, the deterioration is considered significant, and the facility is classified in stage 2 (as long as the facility is not credit-impaired). In the consumer credit specialist business, the existence of a payment incident during the last 12 months, potentially regularised, is considered to be an indication of significant increase in credit risk and the facility is therefore classified in stage 2. The table below shows a comparison between the previous and the new criteria for assessing the significant increase in credit risk: -- 52 of 130 -- - 53 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Credit risk is assumed to have increased significantly since initial recognition and the asset is classified in stage 2 in the event of late payment of more than 30 days or restructuring due to financial difficulties (as long as the facility is not credit-impaired). Since 31 December 2023, performing corporate clients placed under credit watch are systematically downgraded to stage 2. In the first half of 2022, the internal ratings of the Russian counterparties (including the sovereign rating) were systematically downgraded to take into account recent events, thus leading to the transfer of their outstandings to stage 2. However, given the Group's limited level of exposure to this country, this deterioration had no significant effect on the cost of risk for the period. Forward-Looking Information The Group considers forward-looking information both when assessing significant increase in credit risk and when measuring Expected Credit Losses (ECL). Regarding the measurement of expected credit losses, the Group has chosen to use 4 macroeconomic scenarios by geographic area covering a wide range of potential future economic conditions: - a baseline scenario, consistent with the scenario used for budgeting; - a favourable scenario, capturing situations where the economy performs better than anticipated; - an adverse scenario, corresponding to the scenario used for the Group’s quarterly stress tests; - a severe scenario corresponding to a shock of magnitude greater than that of the adverse scenario. The link between the macroeconomic scenarios and the ECL measurement is mainly achieved through a modelling of the probabilities of default and deformation of migration matrices based on internal rating (or risk parameter). The probabilities of default determined according to these scenarios are used to measure expected credit losses in each of these scenarios. The Group’s setup is broken down by sector to take into account the heterogeneity of sectoral dynamics when assessing the probability of default for corporates. Forward-looking information is also considered when determining the significant deterioration in credit risk. As a matter of fact, the probabilities of default used as the basis for this assessment include forward-looking multi- scenario information in the same way as for the calculation of the expected losses. -- 53 of 130 -- - 54 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The weight to be attributed to the expected credit losses calculated in each of the scenarios is defined as 50% for the baseline scenario, and: - the weight of the three alternative scenarios is defined according to the position in the credit cycle. In this approach, the adverse scenario carries more weight in situations at the upper end of the cycle than those at the lower end of the cycle, in anticipation of a potential downturn in the economy. - the weight of the favourable scenario is at least 10% and at most 40%. - the total weight of adverse scenarios fluctuates symmetrically with the favourable also within a range of 10% to 40%; with a severe component representing 20% of this weight with a minimum weight of 5%. When appropriate, the ECL measurement can take into account asset sale scenarios. Macroeconomic scenarios The four macroeconomic scenarios are defined over a three-year projection horizon. They correspond to: - a baseline scenario, which describes the most likely path of the economy over the projection horizon. This scenario is updated on a quarterly basis and is prepared by the Group Economic Research department in collaboration with various experts within the Group. Projections are designed for each key market of the Group (France, Italy, Belgium, the United States, and the eurozone) using key macroeconomic variables (Gross Domestic Product - GDP - and its components, unemployment rate, consumer prices, interest rates, foreign exchange rates, oil prices, real estate prices, etc.) which are key drivers for modeling risk parameters used in the stress test process; - an adverse scenario, which describes the impact of the materialisation of some of the risks weighing on the baseline scenario, resulting in a much less favourable economic path than in the baseline scenario. The GDP shock is applied with varying magnitudes, but simultaneously, to the economies under consideration. Generally, these assumptions are broadly consistent with those proposed by the regulators. The calibration of shocks on other variables (e.g. unemployment, consumer prices, interest rates, etc.) is based on models and expert judgment; - a severely adverse scenario, which is an aggravated version of the adverse scenario; - a favourable scenario, which reflects the impact of the materialisation of some of the upside risks for the economy, resulting in a more favourable economic path. The favourable shock on GDP is deducted from the structural adverse shock on GDP in such a way that the probabilities of the two shocks are equal on average over the cycle. Other variables (e.g. unemployment, inflation, interest rates, etc.) are defined in the same way as in the adverse scenario. The link between the macroeconomic scenarios and the measurement of the ECL is complemented by an approach allowing to take into account anticipation aspects not captured by the models in the generic approach. This is particularly the case when unprecedented events in the historical chronicle taken into account to build the models occur or are anticipated, or when the nature or amplitude of change in macroeconomic parameter calls into question past correlations. Thus, the situation of high inflation and the current and projected level of interest rates correspond to aspects not observed in the reference history. In this context, the Group has developed an approach to take into account the future economic outlook when assessing the financial strength of counterparties. This approach involves projecting the impact of higher interest rates on customers’ financial ratios, notably considering their level of indebtedness. Credit ratings and associated probabilities of default are revalued based on these simulated financial ratios. This approach is also used to anticipate the effect of lower prices of commercial properties. -- 54 of 130 -- - 55 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Baseline scenario Global activity decelerated in 2023, in a context of tight financial conditions and still high inflation. Global GDP is expected to grow by 2.8% on annual average (compared with 3.3% in 2022), mainly reflecting weaker developments among European economies. In the eurozone, activity growth is expected to have decelerated to 0.5% in 2023 (while, as of 30 June 2023, it was expected to reach 0.7%), reflecting much less dynamic domestic demand (both in terms of consumption and investment). The US economy has proved more resilient than initially anticipated and is assumed to grow by 2.3% in 2023 (while, as of 30 June 2023, it was expected to grow by only 0.9%). In 2024, economic conditions are expected to be sluggish among advanced economies, with growth rates slightly below 1% in both the eurozone and the US. While inflation has receded at a quite rapid pace in the course of 2023, it has remained significantly above central bank targets in many countries. This high inflation environment has pushed central banks to implement the most pronounced monetary tightening in recent decades. The main central banks (European Central Bank, US Federal Reserve) may have completed their monetary policy tightening cycle by the end of 2023. They are expected to keep their monetary stance broadly unchanged for a few months. Both short-term and long-term interest rates have reached levels not seen since the years 2000 and are expected to remain relatively high for some time. Tight financial conditions should thus continue to weigh on activity in 2024. The graph below presents a comparison of eurozone GDP projections used in the baseline scenario for the calculation of ECLs on 31 December 2023 and 31 December 2022. -- 55 of 130 -- - 56 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Macroeconomic variables, baseline scenario at 31 December 2023 (annual averages) 2023 2024 2025 2026 GDP growth rate Eurozone 0.5% 0.8% 1.6% 1.7% France 0.9% 0.8% 1.5% 1.6% Italy 0.7% 0.8% 1.2% 1.3% Belgium 1.1% 0.9% 1.5% 1.6% United States 2.3% 0.7% 2.0% 2.1% Unemployment rate Eurozone 6.6% 6.8% 6.6% 6.2% France 7.3% 7.6% 7.3% 6.7% Italy 7.6% 7.7% 7.6% 7.4% Belgium 5.6% 5.9% 5.8% 5.5% United States 3.7% 4.4% 4.2% 3.6% Inflation rate Eurozone 5.6% 2.8% 2.1% 2.2% France 5.8% 2.6% 2.2% 2.2% Italy 6.2% 2.9% 2.3% 2.3% Belgium 2.4% 3.2% 1.6% 2.1% United States 4.2% 2.6% 2.1% 2.1% 10-year sovereign bond yields Germany 2.51% 2.58% 2.50% 2.50% France 3.06% 3.13% 3.05% 3.05% Italy 4.33% 4.58% 4.50% 4.50% Belgium 3.15% 3.22% 3.14% 3.14% United States 4.04% 4.19% 4.00% 4.00% Adverse and severely adverse scenarios The adverse and severely adverse scenarios are based on the assumption that certain downside risks will materialise, resulting in much less favourable economic paths than in the baseline scenario. The following main risks are identified: - Geopolitical risks and globalisation developments. Geopolitical risks have increased significantly in recent years, contributing to a fracturing of the global economy. Geopolitical tensions can weigh on the global economy through various channels, including shocks on commodity prices, financial markets, business confidence, supply chains and trade. Such developments are susceptible to lead simultaneously to higher inflation developments and weaker activity, complicating the task of central banks. The growing use of international sanctions also increases the possible magnitude of consequences of such events. - A greater impact of tight monetary conditions. The marked tightening of monetary policy in response to high inflation over past quarters has led to much higher short-term and long-term interest rates than in previous years. This has already weighed on activity, notably through weaker developments in most interest rate sensitive sectors, in particular the real estate sector. These negative consequences could extend further given the usual delays between the increase in rates and its effect on the economy. In a more unfavourable economic context, tighter financial conditions, combined with weaker activity developments could lead to weaker trends (than assumed in the baseline scenario) regarding credit, investment, residential and commercial real estate prices, and lead to higher default rates. - More fragile public finances. The fact that debt-to-GDP ratios are high increases risks related to public finances in an environment of high interest rates and weak growth. These combined developments could give birth in some countries to market tensions (widening sovereign bond spreads) and affect activity through several channels (higher interest rates, reduced government spending, higher taxes). -- 56 of 130 -- - 57 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The adverse and severe scenarios assume the materialisation of these identified latent risks from the first quarter of 2024. While downside risks are shared by the adverse and the severely adverse scenarios, the impacts are assumed to be markedly higher in the severely adverse scenario, due to both more pronounced direct shocks (e.g. higher commodity prices) and the development of a negative spiral between key driving factors (e.g. activity, public debt, bond yields, equity markets). Among the considered countries, GDP levels in the adverse scenario stand between 7.8% and 11.1% lower than in the baseline scenario at the end of the shock period. In particular, this deviation reaches 9% on average in both the eurozone and the United States. In the severe scenario, GDP levels stand between 11.6% and 16.2% lower than in the baseline scenario at the end of the shock period. This deviation reaches 13.2% in both the eurozone and the United States. Scenario weighting and cost of risk sensitivity At 31 December 2023, the weight of the favourable scenario considered by the Group was 33%, and 12% for the adverse scenario and 5% for the severe scenario. At 31 December 2022, the weight of the favourable scenario was 34% and 16% for the adverse scenario (the severe scenario was introduced in the first half 2023). The sensitivity of the amount of expected credit losses for all financial assets at amortised cost or at fair value through equity and credit commitments is assessed by comparing the estimated expected credit losses resulting from the weighting of the above scenarios with that resulting from each of the two alternative scenarios: - an increase in ECL of 23%, or EUR 1,150 million according to the adverse scenario (22% at 31 December 2022); - a decrease in ECL of 12%, or EUR 600 million according to the favourable scenario (7% at 31 December 2022). Post-model adjustments: Post-model adjustments are made when system limitations are identified in a particular context, for instance, in the case of insufficient statistical data to reflect the specific situation in the models. Post-model adjustments are also considered to take into account, where applicable, the consequences of climatic events on expected credit losses. • Adaptation of the ECL assessment process to factor in the specific nature of the health crisis: Conservative adjustments were taken into account when the models used were based on indicators that show unusual levels in the context of the health crisis and the support programmes, such as the increase in deposits and the decrease in past due events for retail customers and entrepreneurs. For the consumer credit specialist business, a conservative adjustment had been considered in 2020 for loans that benefitted from a moratorium. In 2021, this adjustment was reversed in connection with the satisfactory return to payment observed on these loans. However, a conservative adjustment was made to compensate for the atypical level of late payments. These post-model adjustments were reversed in 2022. • Adaptation of the ECL assessment process to factor in the significant rise in inflation and in interest rates: Additional adjustments were made in 2022 to take into account the effects of inflation and interest rate hikes when this effect is not directly estimated by the models. For example, within the consumer credit specialist business, adjustments were considered for the categories of customers most sensitive to the gradual decline in the level of their net income. Part of these adjustments were integrated into the models in 2022 and in the first half of 2023, leading to a decrease in the post-model adjustments. All of these adjustments represent 4.5% of the total amount of expected credit losses at 31 December 2023, compared to 6.1% at 31 December 2022. -- 57 of 130 -- - 58 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Cost of credit risk for the period In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Net allowances to impairment (2,596) (2,440) Recoveries on loans and receivables previously written off 250 343 Losses on irrecoverable loans (561) (717) Act on assistance to borrowers in Poland (189) Total cost of risk for the period (2,907) (3,003) Cost of risk for the period by accounting category and asset type In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Cash and balances at central banks (5) (6) Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss (31) (28) Financial assets at fair value through equity 3 14 Financial assets at amortised cost (2,904) (2,853) Loans and receivables (2,912) (2,845) Debt securities 8 (8) Other assets (2) (17) Financing and guarantee commitments and other items 32 (113) Total cost of risk for the period (2,907) (3,003) Cost of risk on unimpaired assets and commitments 517 (570) of which stage 1 122 (511) of which stage 2 395 (59) Cost of risk on impaired assets and commitments - stage 3 (3,424) (2,433) -- 58 of 130 -- - 59 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Credit risk impairment Changes in impairment by accounting category and asset type during the period In millions of euros 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Net allowance to impairment Impairment provisions used Changes in scope, exchange rates and other items 31 December 2023 Assets impairment Amounts due from central banks 21 5 (6) 20 Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss 108 30 (24) (6) 108 Financial assets at fair value through equity 130 (3) (6) 121 Financial assets at amortised cost 18,511 2,620 (3,273) (143) 17,715 Loans and receivables 18,381 2,627 (3,264) (133) 17,611 Debt securities 130 (7) (9) (10) 104 Other assets 43 (14) 1 30 Total impairment of financial assets 18,813 2,652 (3,311) (160) 17,994 of which stage 1 2,074 (60) (2) (46) 1,966 of which stage 2 2,881 (347) (41) (64) 2,429 of which stage 3 13,858 3,059 (3,268) (50) 13,599 Provisions recognised as liabilities Provisions for commitments 980 (69) (1) (27) 883 Other provisions 450 13 (44) (32) 387 Total provisions recognised for credit commitments 1,430 (56) (45) (59) 1,270 of which stage 1 326 (47) (10) 269 of which stage 2 338 (25) (12) 301 of which stage 3 766 16 (45) (37) 700 Total impairment and provisions 20,243 2,596 (3,356) (219) 19,264 Change in impairment by accounting category and asset type during the previous period In millions of euros 31 December 2021 Net allowance to impairment Impairment provisions used Changes in scope, exchange rates and other items 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Assets impairment Amounts due from central banks 18 5 (2) 21 Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss 121 15 (28) 108 Financial assets at fair value through equity 140 (14) 4 130 Financial assets at amortised cost 20,196 2,371 (4,187) 131 18,511 Loans and receivables 20,028 2,326 (4,106) 133 18,381 Debt securities 168 45 (81) (2) 130 Other assets 59 (7) (3) (6) 43 Total impairment of financial assets 20,534 2,370 (4,190) 99 18,813 of which stage 1 1,891 223 (4) (36) 2,074 of which stage 2 2,748 87 (3) 49 2,881 of which stage 3 15,895 2,060 (4,183) 86 13,858 Provisions recognised as liabilities Provisions for commitments 958 32 (15) 5 980 Other provisions 467 38 (56) 1 450 Total provisions recognised for credit commitments 1,425 70 (71) 6 1,430 of which stage 1 230 94 2 326 of which stage 2 374 (33) (3) 338 of which stage 3 821 9 (71) 7 766 Total impairment and provisions 21,959 2,440 (4,261) 105 20,243 -- 59 of 130 -- - 60 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Changes in impairment of financial assets at amortised cost during the period In millions of euros Impairment on assets subject to 12-month Expected Credit Losses (Stage 1) Impairment on assets subject to lifetime Expected Credit Losses (Stage 2) Impairment on doubtful assets (Stage 3) Total At 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 2,035 2,860 13,616 18,511 Net allowance to impairment (63) (339) 3,022 2,620 Financial assets purchased or originated during the period 691 294 985 Financial assets derecognised during the period (1) (405) (490) (726) (1,621) Transfer to stage 2 (371) 2,121 (199) 1,551 Transfer to stage 3 (74) (990) 2,258 1,194 Transfer to stage 1 288 (860) (86) (658) Other allowances / reversals without stage transfer (2) (192) (414) 1,775 1,169 Impairment provisions used (2) (41) (3,230) (3,273) Changes in exchange rates (16) (7) (80) (103) Changes in scope of consolidation and other items (16) (57) 33 (40) At 31 December 2023 1,938 2,416 13,361 17,715 (1) including disposals (2) including amortisation Changes in impairment of financial assets at amortised cost during the previous period In millions of euros Impairment on assets subject to 12-month Expected Credit Losses (Stage 1) Impairment on assets subject to lifetime Expected Credit Losses (Stage 2) Impairment on doubtful assets (Stage 3) Total At 31 December 2021 1,867 2,714 15,615 20,196 Net allowance to impairment 212 102 2,057 2,371 Financial assets purchased or originated during the period 683 234 917 Financial assets derecognised during the period (1) (390) (388) (822) (1,600) Transfer to stage 2 (133) 1,773 (212) 1,428 Transfer to stage 3 (65) (665) 1,806 1,076 Transfer to stage 1 63 (502) (36) (475) Change in the significant increase in credit risk assessment criteria 29 (280) (251) Other allowances / reversals without stage transfer (2) 25 (70) 1,321 1,276 Impairment provisions used (3) (3) (4,181) (4,187) Changes in exchange rates (6) (30) 104 68 Changes in scope of consolidation and other items (35) 77 21 63 At 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 2,035 2,860 13,616 18,511 (1) including disposals (2) including amortisation -- 60 of 130 -- - 61 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 3.h O THER NET LOSSES FOR RISK ON FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS In 2023, the Group modified its accounting policy relating to the risk of loss of cash flows on financial instruments granted that are not linked to the counterparty’s default, such as legal risks calling into question the validity or enforceability of such contracts. The effect on expected cash flows due to these risks is now considered as a change in the contract’s cash flows, in accordance with IFRS 9 B5.4.6, and is recorded as a decrease in the gross value of the asset. It was previously recognised separately in accordance with IAS 37 in "Provisions for risks and charges” (see note 5.n). Expected losses on derecognised financial instruments, as is the case when loans have been repaid, continue to be recognised in accordance with IAS 37. The corresponding expected and realised cash flow losses are now presented in "Other net losses for risk on financial instruments”. In 2023, the expense thus recognised mainly related to mortgage loans in Poland amounting to EUR 450 million (compared with EUR 157 million at 31 December 2022, presented as “Revenues”) and foreign currency loans issued by BNP Paribas Personal Finance amounting to EUR 221 million (compared with EUR 130 million at 31 December 2022, presented as “Revenues”). 3.i N ET GAIN ON NON- CURRENT ASSETS In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Gain or loss on investments in consolidated undertakings (note 9.d) 29 (257) Gain or loss on tangible and intangible assets 139 7 Results from net monetary position (272) (3) Net gain on non-current assets (104) (253) According to IAS 29 in connection with the hyperinflation situation of the economy in Türkiye, the line “Results from net monetary positions” mainly includes the effect of the evolution of the consumer price index in Türkiye on the valuation of non-monetary assets and liabilities (- EUR 563 million) and on accrued income from the Turkish government bonds portfolio indexed to inflation and held by Turk Ekonomi Bankasi AS (+ EUR 291 million, reclassified from interest margin) in 2023 (respectively - EUR 434 million and + EUR 431 million in 2022). 3.j C ORPORATE INCOME TAX Reconciliation of the effective tax expense to the theoretical tax expense at standard tax rate in France Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 in millions of euros tax rate in millions of euros tax rate Corporate income tax expense on pre-tax income at standard tax rate in France (1) (2,875) 25.8% (3,180) 25.8% Impact of differently taxed foreign profits (56) 0.5% (61) 0.5% Impact of dividends and disposals taxed at reduced rate 131 -1.2% 54 -0.4% Impact of the non-deductibility of taxes and bank levies (2) (369) 3.3% (300) 2.4% Impact of previously unrecognised deferred taxes (tax losses and temporary differences) 432 -3.9% Impact of the hyperinflation in Türkiye (202) 1.9% (188) 1.6% Other items (327) 2.9% 22 -0.2% Corporate income tax expense from continuing activities (3,266) 29.3% (3,653) 29.7% Current tax expense for the year to 31 December (3,063) (2,844) Deferred tax expense for the year to 31 December (note 5.i) (203) (809) (1) Restated for the share of profits in equity-method entities and goodwill impairment. (2) Contribution to the Single Resolution Fund and other non-deductible banking taxes. -- 61 of 130 -- - 62 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 4. SEGMENT INFORMATION The Group is composed of three operating divisions: • Corporate & Institutional Banking (CIB) which covers Global Banking, Global Markets and Securities Services; • Commercial, Personal Banking & Services (CPBS) which covers Commercial & Personal banking in the eurozone, with Commercial & Personal Banking in France (CPBF), Commercial & Personal Banking in Italy (BNL bc), Commercial & Personal Banking in Belgium (CPBB) and Commercial & Personal Banking in Luxembourg (CPBL); Commercial & Personal banking outside the eurozone, which is organised around Europe-Mediterranean, to cover Central and Eastern Europe and Türkiye. Lastly, it also covers specialised businesses, (Arval, BNP Paribas Leasing Solutions, BNP Paribas Personal Finance, BNP Paribas Personal Investors and New Digital Businesses like Nickel, Floa, Lyf); • Investment & Protection Services (IPS) which covers Insurance (BNP Paribas Cardif), Wealth and Asset Management (BNP Paribas Asset Management, BNP Paribas Wealth Management and BNP Paribas Real Estate), Management of the BNP Paribas Group’s portfolio of unlisted and listed industrial and commercial investments (BNP Paribas Principal Investments). Other Activities mainly include activities related to the Group’s central treasury function, some costs related to cross-business projects, the residential mortgage lending business of Personal Finance (a significant part of which is managed in run-off), and certain investments. They also include non-recurring items resulting from applying the rules on business combinations. In order to provide consistent and relevant economic information for each core business, the impact of amortising fair value adjustments recognised in the net equity of entities acquired and restructuring costs incurred in respect to the integration of entities, have been allocated to the “Other Activities” segment. The same applies to transformation, adaptation and IT reinforcement costs relating to the Group’s savings programmes. In addition, Other Activities carry the impact, related to the application of IFRS 17, of the reclassification as a deduction from revenues of the operating expenses “attributable to insurance contracts” of the Group’s business lines (other than Insurance) that distribute insurance contracts (i.e., internal distributors), in order not to disrupt the readability of their financial performance. This is also the case for the impact of the volatility on the financial result generated by the recognition at fair value through profit or loss of assets backing insurance entities’ equity or non- participating contracts. In the event of divestment connected to this portfolio, the realised gains or losses are allocated to the revenues of the Insurance business line. Inter-segment transactions are conducted at arm’s length. The segment information presented comprises agreed inter-segment transfer prices. The capital allocation is carried out on the basis of risk exposure, taking into account various conventions relating primarily to the capital requirement of the business as derived from the risk-weighted asset calculations required under capital adequacy rules. Normalised equity income by segment is determined by attributing to each segment the income of its allocated equity. The capital allocation to segments is based on a minimum of 11 % of weighted assets. The breakdown of balance sheet by core business follows the same rules as the breakdown of the profit or loss by core business. -- 62 of 130 -- - 63 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 In order to be comparable with the presentation format used since 1 January 2023, the year ended 31 December 2022 of this note has been restated for the following effects as if they had occurred on 1 January 2022. - Following the sale of Bank of the West on 1 February 2023, it was decided to apply IFRS 5 standard relating to groups of assets and liabilities held for sale to the management income. As a result, the contribution of Bank of the West in 2022 and the capital gain related to the sale in 2023 are both presented separately. Accordingly, in the profit and loss account, profits and losses are reclassified on a separate line “Net income from discontinued activities”. - Since 1 January 2023, the Group has applied IFRS 17 “Insurance contracts”, as well as IFRS 9 for its insurance entities (see note 1.a). The main effects are: o operating expenses deemed “attributable to insurance contracts” are recognised in deduction of revenues and no longer booked in operating expenses. These accounting entries apply only to Insurance and to Group entities (other than in the Insurance business line) that distribute insurance contracts (i.e., internal distributors) and have no impact on gross operating income; o the impact of the volatility on the financial result generated by the recognition at fair value through profit or loss of assets backing insurance entities’ equity and non-participating contracts is presented in “Other Activities”. Accordingly, “Other activities” revenues reflect, for 2022, the impact of volatility relating to the unfavourable market context; o capital gains from the Savings activity are now integrated in the contractual service margin and are recognised over the entire duration of insurance contracts. Accordingly, Insurance Revenues recorded a decrease for 2022 due to the impact of capital gains which offset the impact of volatility on the 2022 financial result. - Internal transfers of activities and results were made, particularly at Global Markets (following BNP Paribas’ acquisition of Exane, which closed on 13 July 2021) and within Commercial & Personal Banking in Belgium (e.g. transfer of some individual clients, SMEs in particular to the corporate segment in relation with the commercial reorganisation). These changes have no impact on the Group’s results as a whole but only on their analytical breakdown in 2022. -- 63 of 130 -- - 64 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Income by business segment In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 First half 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Revenues Operating expenses Cost of risk (1) Operating income Non- operating items Pre-tax income Revenues Operating expenses Cost of risk Operating income Non- operating items Pre-tax income Corporate & Institutional Banking 16,509 (10,823) 63 5,749 (5) 5,744 16,404 (10,691) (325) 5,387 10 5,398 Global Banking 5,822 (2,918) 74 2,978 6 2,984 5,181 (2,841) (336) 2,004 4 2,009 Global Markets 7,996 (5,798) (13) 2,185 8 2,193 8,636 (5,781) 11 2,866 4 2,870 Securities Services 2,691 (2,107) 1 586 (19) 567 2,586 (2,069) () 517 2 519 Commercial, Personal Banking & Services 25,917 (16,059) (2,920) 6,938 156 7,094 24,931 (15,514) (2,497) 6,921 410 7,331 Commercial & Personal Banking in the eurozone 13,259 (9,233) (986) 3,039 12 3,051 12,948 (8,976) (726) 3,246 42 3,288 Commercial & Personal Banking in France(2) 6,251 (4,576) (484) 1,192 1,192 6,361 (4,530) (245) 1,587 26 1,613 BNL banca commerciale(2) 2,646 (1,745) (410) 491 (3) 488 2,548 (1,676) (464) 408 3 410 Commercial & Personal Banking in Belgium (2) 3,784 (2,618) (84) 1,081 10 1,091 3,577 (2,502) (36) 1,039 10 1,049 Commercial & Personal Banking in Luxembourg(2) 577 (294) (8) 275 5 281 461 (268) 19 213 3 216 Commercial & Personal Banking in the rest of the world 2,631 (1,657) (44) 930 100 1,030 2,321 (1,650) (152) 519 289 808 Europe-Mediterranean(2) 2,631 (1,657) (44) 930 100 1,030 2,321 (1,650) (152) 519 289 808 Specialised businesses 10,027 (5,168) (1,890) 2,969 44 3,012 9,662 (4,888) (1,619) 3,155 80 3,235 Personal Finance 5,163 (2,998) (1,600) 565 65 630 5,387 (2,922) (1,373) 1,092 28 1,121 Arval & Leasing Solutions 3,869 (1,501) (167) 2,201 (14) 2,188 3,438 (1,395) (146) 1,897 60 1,957 New Digital Businesses & Personal Investors(2) 995 (669) (123) 203 (8) 195 837 (571) (100) 166 (9) 157 Investment & Protections Services 5,590 (3,566) (13) 2,011 148 2,159 5,813 (3,552) 5 2,265 266 2,532 Insurance 2,090 (808) 1,281 113 1,394 2,016 (794) 1,222 117 1,340 Wealth Management 1,603 (1,196) (3) 404 4 408 1,512 (1,183) 3 333 39 372 Asset Management(3) 1,897 (1,561) (10) 326 31 357 2,284 (1,576) 2 710 110 820 Other Activities - excl. restatement related to insurance activities (1,060) (1,551) (812) (3,422) 190 (3,233) (278) (1,163) (185) (1,626) (36) (1,662) Other Activities - restatement related to insurance activities (1,081) 1,041 (40) (40) (1,440) 1,056 (384) (384) of which volatility (40) (40) (40) (384) (384) (384) of which attributable costs to internal distributors (1,041) 1,041 (1,056) 1,056 Total continuing activities (3) 45,874 (30,956) (3,682) 11,236 489 11,725 45,430 (29,864) (3,003) 12,564 651 13,214 (1) including “Other net losses for risk on financial instruments”. (2) Commercial & Personal Banking in France, BNL banca commerciale, Commercial & Personal Banking in Belgium, Commercial & Personal Banking in Luxembourg, Europe- Mediterranean and Personal Investors after the reallocation within Wealth and Asset Management of one-third of the Wealth Management activities in France, Italy, Belgium, Luxembourg, Germany, Türkiye and Poland. (3) including Real Estate and Principal Investments. -- 64 of 130 -- - 65 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Net commission income by business segment In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Corporate & Institutional Banking 2,214 2,304 Global Banking 1,784 2,037 Global Markets (975) (1,230) Securities Services 1,405 1,497 Commercial, Personal Banking & Services 6,777 6,792 Commercial & Personal Banking in the eurozone 5,019 5,059 Commercial & Personal Banking in France (1) 2,875 2,896 BNL banca commerciale (1) 1,043 1,047 Commercial & Personal Banking in Belgium (1) 1,014 1,028 Commercial & Personal Banking in Luxembourg (1) 87 88 Commercial & Personal Banking in the rest of the world 442 448 Europe-Mediterranean (1) 442 448 Specialised businesses 1,316 1,285 Personal Finance 776 743 Arval & Leasing Solutions 54 41 New Digital Businesses & Personal Investors (1) 486 502 Investment & Protections Services 1,850 1,987 Insurance (368) (388) Wealth Management 749 768 Asset Management (2) 1,469 1,607 Other activities - excl. restatement related to insurance activities 21 139 Other activities - restatement related to insurance activities (1,041) (1,056) Total Group 9,821 10,165 (1) Commercial & Personal Banking in France, BNL banca commerciale, Commercial & Personal Banking in Belgium, Commercial & Personal Banking in Luxembourg, Europe-Mediterranean and Personal Investors after the reallocation within Wealth and Asset Management of one-third of the Wealth Management activities in France, Italy, Belgium, Luxembourg, Germany, Türkiye and Poland. (2) including Real Estate and Principal Investments. -- 65 of 130 -- - 66 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Assets and liabilities by business segment In millions of euros, at 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Asset Liability Asset Liability Corporate & Institutional Banking 1,136,691 1,309,407 1,136,501 1,302,279 Global Banking 176,822 241,346 183,096 239,352 Global Markets 921,650 917,780 913,848 908,354 Securities Services 38,219 150,281 39,557 154,573 Commercial, Personal Banking & Services 790,648 703,270 843,217 798,966 Commercial & Personal Banking in the eurozone 552,876 559,503 546,268 584,747 Commercial & Personal Banking in France 236,866 244,563 235,614 255,334 BNL banca commerciale 94,164 81,275 94,230 93,880 Commercial & Personal Banking in Belgium 192,423 202,447 189,119 204,538 Commercial & Personal Banking in Luxembourg 29,423 31,218 27,305 30,995 Commercial & Personal Banking in the rest of the world 59,282 55,409 141,356 138,231 Europe-Mediterranean 59,282 55,409 59,132 55,360 BancWest 82,224 82,871 Specialised businesses 178,490 88,358 155,593 75,988 Personal Finance 108,791 29,003 94,906 24,412 Arval & Leasing Solutions 65,086 22,245 56,668 17,789 New Digital Businesses & Personal Investors 4,613 37,110 4,019 33,787 Investment & Protections Services 289,711 317,405 280,400 309,513 Insurance 257,133 243,510 244,774 231,500 Wealth Management 25,495 68,984 28,242 74,563 Asset Management 7,083 4,911 7,384 3,450 Other activities 374,449 261,417 403,630 252,990 Total Group 2,591,499 2,591,499 2,663,748 2,663,748 Information by business segment relating to goodwill is presented in note 5.m Goodwill. • Information by geographic area The geographic split of segment results, assets and liabilities is based on the region in which they are recognised for accounting purposes, adjusted as per the managerial origin of the business activity. It does not necessarily reflect the counterparty's nationality or the location of operational businesses. - Revenues from continuing activities by geographic area In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 EMEA 37,922 37,675 Americas (North and South) 4,286 3,818 APAC 3,666 3,937 Total Group 45,874 45,430 - Assets and liabilities, in contribution to the consolidated accounts, by geographic area In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 EMEA 2,148,461 2,188,593 Americas (North and South) 255,099 304,829 APAC 187,939 170,326 Total Group 2,591,499 2,663,748 T -- 66 of 130 -- - 67 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5. NOTES TO THE BALANCE SHEET AT 31 DECEMBER 2023 5.a F INANCIAL INSTRUMENTS AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH PROFIT OR LOSS FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH PROFIT OR LOSS Financial assets and financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss consist of held-for-trading transactions - including derivatives, of certain liabilities designated by the Group as at fair value through profit or loss at the time of issuance and of non-trading instruments whose characteristics prevent their accounting at amortised cost or at fair value through equity. 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 In millions of euros Financial instruments held for trading Financial instruments designated as at fair value through profit or loss Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss Total Financial instruments held for trading Financial instruments designated as at fair value through profit or loss Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss Total Securities 202,225 549 8,860 211,634 157,138 1,273 7,666 166,077 Loans and repurchase agreements 224,700 2,475 227,175 186,968 4,157 191,125 FINANCIAL ASSETS AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH PROFIT OR LOSS 426,925 549 11,335 438,809 344,106 1,273 11,823 357,202 Securities 104,910 104,910 99,155 99,155 Deposits and repurchase agreements 271,486 2,128 273,614 232,351 1,725 234,076 Issued debt securities (note 5.h) 83,763 83,763 65,578 65,578 of which subordinated debt 735 735 675 675 of which non subordinated debt 83,028 83,028 64,903 64,903 FINANCIAL LIABILITIES AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH PROFIT OR LOSS 376,396 85,891 462,287 331,506 67,303 398,809 Detail of these assets and liabilities is provided in note 5.d. • Financial liabilities designated as at fair value through profit or loss Financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss mainly consist of issued debt securities, originated and structured on behalf of customers, where the risk exposure is managed in combination with the hedging strategy. These types of issued debt securities contain significant embedded derivatives, which changes in value may be compensated by changes in the value of economic hedging derivatives. The redemption value of debt issued and designated as at fair value through profit or loss at 31 December 2023 was EUR 89,910 million (EUR 71,721 million at 31 December 2022). -- 67 of 130 -- - 68 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Other financial assets measured at fair value through profit or loss Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss are financial assets not held for trading: - debt instruments that do not meet the criteria defined by IFRS 9 to be classified as financial instruments at “fair value through equity” or at “amortised cost”: - their business model is not to “collect contractual cash flows” nor “collect contractual cash flows and sell the instruments”; and/or - their cash flows are not solely repayments of principal and interest on the principal amount outstanding. - equity instruments that the Group did not choose to classify as at “fair value through equity”. DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS The majority of derivative financial instruments held for trading are related to transactions initiated for trading purposes. They may result from market-making or arbitrage activities. BNP Paribas actively trades in derivatives. Transactions include trades in “ordinary” instruments such as credit default swaps, and structured transactions with complex risk profiles tailored to meet the needs of its customers. The net position is in all cases subject to limits. Some derivative instruments are also contracted to hedge financial assets or financial liabilities for which the Group has not documented a hedging relationship, or which do not qualify for hedge accounting under IFRS. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Positive market value Negative market value Positive market value Negative market value Interest rate derivatives 133,500 105,976 150,122 125,215 Foreign exchange derivatives 119,094 118,126 134,382 129,274 Credit derivatives 8,427 10,320 7,294 7,731 Equity derivatives 24,067 38,027 22,602 27,291 Other derivatives 6,991 6,443 13,532 10,610 Derivative financial instruments 292,079 278,892 327,932 300,121 The table below shows the total notional amount of trading derivatives. The notional amounts of derivative instruments are merely an indication of the volume of the Group’s activities in financial instruments markets, and do not reflect the market risks associated with such instruments. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Exchange- traded Over-the- counter, cleared through central clearing houses Over-the- counter Total Exchange- traded Over-the- counter, cleared through central clearing houses Over-the- counter Total Interest rate derivatives 1,327,902 13,518,963 7,740,827 22,587,692 1,442,663 12,349,668 5,254,166 19,046,497 Foreign exchange derivatives 57,625 173,339 8,980,659 9,211,623 40,292 130,148 7,610,392 7,780,832 Credit derivatives 357,964 465,403 823,367 464,228 518,926 983,154 Equity derivatives 1,130,554 638,904 1,769,458 1,177,728 535,465 1,713,193 Other derivatives 119,024 84,251 203,275 133,820 95,722 229,542 Derivative financial instruments 2,635,105 14,050,266 17,910,044 34,595,415 2,794,503 12,944,044 14,014,671 29,753,218 As part of its Client Clearing activity, the Group guarantees the risk of default of its clients to central counterparties. The corresponding notional amount is EUR 1,197 billion at 31 December 2023 (EUR 1,187 billion at 31 December 2022). -- 68 of 130 -- - 69 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5.b D ERIVATIVES USED FOR HEDGING PURPOSES The table below shows the notional amounts and the fair value of derivatives used for hedging purposes. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Notional amounts Positive fair value Negative fair value Notional amounts Positive fair value Negative fair value Fair value hedges 1,148,308 19,409 33,808 1,103,455 24,213 36,872 Interest rate derivatives 1,139,647 18,516 32,617 1,094,689 23,955 36,525 Foreign exchange derivatives 8,661 893 1,191 8,766 258 347 Cash flow hedges 241,125 2,233 4,138 213,866 1,126 3,070 Interest rate derivatives 66,134 896 1,760 59,641 429 1,602 Foreign exchange derivatives 174,426 1,270 2,312 153,811 664 1,416 Other derivatives 565 67 66 414 33 52 Net foreign investment hedges 2,648 50 65 1,719 62 59 Foreign exchange derivatives 2,648 50 65 1,719 62 59 Derivatives used for hedging purposes 1,392,081 21,692 38,011 1,319,040 25,401 40,001 Interest rate risk and foreign exchange risk management strategies are described in chapter 5 – Pillar 3 of the Universal registration document (section 5.7 – Market risk – Market risk related to banking activities). Quantitative information related to foreign currency borrowings used for net investment hedges is also mentioned in this chapter. The table below presents the detail of fair value hedge relationships for identified financial instruments and portfolios of financial instruments that are continuing at 31 December 2023 : Hedging instruments Hedged instruments In millions of euros, at 31 December 2023 Notional amounts Positive fair value Negative fair value Cumulated changes in fair value used as the basis for recognising ineffective- ness Carrying amount - asset Cumulated changes in fair value - asset Carrying amount - liability Cumulated changes in fair value - liability Fair value hedges of identified instruments 405,307 9,539 13,084 (582) 133,418 (6,571) 154,708 (7,030) Interest rate derivatives hedging the interest rate risk related to 398,328 8,653 11,932 (491) 129,967 (6,575) 151,227 (6,948) Loans and receivables 20,674 487 449 88 20,886 (82) Securities 162,254 7,826 2,383 6,369 109,081 (6,493) Deposits 24,158 123 222 (203) 20,487 (201) Debt securities 191,242 217 8,878 (6,745) 130,740 (6,747) Foreign exchange derivatives hedging the interest rate and foreign exchange risks related to 6,979 886 1,152 (91) 3,451 4 3,481 (82) Loans and receivables 2,069 687 737 (11) 2,055 10 Securities 1,405 184 193 8 1,396 (6) Deposits 833 6 21 4 846 3 Debt securities 2,672 9 201 (92) 2,635 (85) Interest rate risk hedged portfolios 743,001 9,870 20,724 (10,261) 233,224 (3,803) 228,527 (14,009) Interest rate derivatives hedging the interest rate risk related to (1) 741,319 9,862 20,685 (10,263) 231,609 (3,801) 228,527 (14,009) Loans and receivables 339,035 6,302 1,938 3,780 231,609 (3,801) Deposits 402,284 3,560 18,747 (14,043) 228,527 (14,009) Foreign exchange derivatives hedging the interest rate and foreign exchange risks related to 1,682 8 39 2 1,615 (2) Loans and receivables 1,682 8 39 2 1,615 (2) Total fair value hedge 1,148,308 19,409 33,808 (10,843) 366,642 (10,374) 383,235 (21,039) (1)Are included in this section the notional amounts of hedging derivatives and of swaps that reverse the interest rate positions, thus reducing the hedge relationship, when the hedged item still exists, for respectively EUR 93,839 million for derivatives hedging loans and receivables and EUR 177,833 million for derivatives hedging deposits. -- 69 of 130 -- - 70 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The table below presents the detail of fair value hedge relationships for identified financial instruments and portfolios of financial instruments that are continuing at 31 December 2022 : Hedging instruments Hedged instruments In millions of euros, at 31 December 2022 Notional amounts Positive fair value Negative fair value Cumulated changes in fair value used as the basis for recognising ineffective- ness Carrying amount - asset Cumulated changes in fair value - asset Carrying amount - liability Cumulated changes in fair value - liability Fair value hedges of identified instruments 332,749 11,155 12,711 1,500 114,741 (12,204) 122,280 (10,588) Interest rate derivatives hedging the interest rate risk related to 325,470 10,992 12,376 1,487 110,376 (12,128) 119,694 (10,540) Loans and receivables 19,827 613 171 527 18,394 (541) Securities 131,460 10,297 1,258 11,521 91,982 (11,587) Deposits 8,081 31 291 (375) 7,878 (388) Debt securities 166,102 51 10,656 (10,186) 111,816 (10,152) Foreign exchange derivatives hedging the interest rate and foreign exchange risks related to 7,279 163 335 13 4,365 (76) 2,586 (48) Loans and receivables 2,619 95 64 35 2,410 (42) Securities 1,957 55 12 34 1,955 (34) Deposits 64 - 30 2 76 2 Debt securities 2,639 13 229 (58) 2,510 (50) Interest rate risk hedged portfolios 770,706 13,058 24,161 (11,240) 204,827 (8,877) 310,192 (20,063) Interest rate derivatives hedging the interest rate risk related to (1) 769,218 12,963 24,149 (11,292) 203,490 (8,830) 310,192 (20,063) Loans and receivables 346,924 9,243 162 9,680 203,490 (8,830) Deposits 422,294 3,720 23,987 (20,972) 310,192 (20,063) Foreign exchange derivatives hedging the interest rate and foreign exchange risks related to 1,488 95 12 52 1,337 (47) Loans and receivables 1,488 95 12 52 1,337 (47) Total fair value hedge 1,103,455 24,213 36,872 (9,740) 319,568 (21,081) 432,472 (30,651) (1)Are included in this section the notional amounts of hedging derivatives and of swaps that reverse the interest rate positions, thus reducing the hedge relationship, when the hedged item still exists, for respectively EUR 121,183 million for derivatives hedging loans and receivables and EUR 103,261 million for derivatives hedging deposits. An asset or a liability or set of assets and liabilities, can be hedged over several periods of time with different derivative financial instruments. Besides, some hedges are achieved by the combination of two derivative instruments. In this case, the notional amounts add up and their total amount is higher than the hedged amount. The first situation is observed more particularly for interest rate risk hedged portfolios and the second for hedges of issued debt securities. As regards discontinued fair value hedge relationships where the derivative contract was terminated, the cumulated amount of revaluation remaining to be amortised over the residual life of the hedged instruments amounts to EUR 1,143 million in assets at 31 December 2023, and to - EUR 166 million in liabilities, for hedges of portfolios of financial instruments. At 31 December 2022, these amounts were EUR 1,399 million in assets and - EUR 138 million in liabilities. Regarding hedges of identified instruments, the cumulated amount of revaluation remaining to be amortised over the residual life of the hedged instruments amounts to EUR 105 million in assets at 31 December 2023. At 31 December 2022, this amount was EUR 111 million in assets. The notional amount of cash flow hedge derivatives is EUR 241,125 million at 31 December 2023. Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity amount to EUR 189 million. At 31 December 2022, the notional amount of cash flow hedge derivatives was EUR 213,866 million and changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity amounted to - EUR 245 million. -- 70 of 130 -- - 71 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The tables below present the notional amounts of hedging derivatives by maturity at 31 December 2023 and at 31 December 2022 : In millions of euros, at 31 December 2023 Maturity date Less than 1 year Between 1 and 5 years Over 5 years Total Fair value hedges 328,104 487,495 332,709 1,148,308 Interest rate derivatives 323,853 483,325 332,469 1,139,647 Foreign exchange derivatives 4,251 4,170 240 8,661 Cash flow hedges 176,330 52,161 12,634 241,125 Interest rate derivatives 30,565 28,999 6,570 66,134 Foreign exchange derivatives 145,532 22,832 6,062 174,426 Other derivatives 233 330 2 565 Net foreign investment hedges 2,648 - - 2,648 Foreign exchange derivatives 2,648 2,648 In millions of euros, at 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Maturity date Less than 1 year Between 1 and 5 years Over 5 years Total Fair value hedges 382,063 430,968 290,424 1,103,455 Interest rate derivatives 378,055 426,364 290,270 1,094,689 Foreign exchange derivatives 4,008 4,604 154 8,766 Cash flow hedges 142,568 51,041 20,257 213,866 Interest rate derivatives 18,178 30,041 11,422 59,641 Foreign exchange derivatives 124,223 20,753 8,835 153,811 Other derivatives 167 247 414 Net foreign investment hedges 1,719 - - 1,719 Foreign exchange derivatives 1,719 1,719 -- 71 of 130 -- - 72 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5.c F INANCIAL ASSETS AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH EQUITY In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Fair value of which changes in value recognised directly to equity Fair value of which changes in value recognised directly to equity Debt securities 50,274 (585) 35,878 (866) Governments 23,334 (207) 18,682 (350) Other public administrations 16,188 (117) 9,921 (197) Credit institutions 7,388 (248) 3,816 (302) Others 3,364 (13) 3,459 (17) Equity securities 2,275 767 2,188 623 Total financial assets at fair value through equity 52,549 182 38,066 (243) Debt securities at fair value through equity include EUR 109 million classified as stage 3 at 31 December 2023 (EUR 108 million at 31 December 2022). For these securities, the credit impairment recognised in the profit and loss account has been charged to the negative changes in value recognised in equity for EUR 102 million at 31 December 2023 (EUR 100 million at 31 December 2022). The option to recognise certain equity instruments at fair value through equity was retained in particular for shares held through strategic partnerships and shares that the Group is required to hold in order to carry out certain activities. During the year ended 31 December 2023, the Group sold several of these investments and a net gain of EUR 9 million was transferred to “retained earnings” (EUR 267 million for the year ended 31 December 2022). -- 72 of 130 -- - 73 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5.d M EASUREMENT OF THE FAIR VALUE OF FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS VALUATION PROCESS BNP Paribas has retained the fundamental principle that it should have a unique and integrated processing chain for producing and controlling the valuations of financial instruments that are used for the purpose of daily risk management and financial reporting. All these processes are based on a common economic valuation which is a core component of business decisions and risk management strategies. Economic value is composed of mid-market value, to which valuation adjustments are made. Mid-market value is derived from external data or valuation techniques that maximise the use of observable and market-based data. Mid-market value is a theoretical additive value which does not take account of i) the direction of the transaction or its impact on the existing risks in the portfolio, ii) the nature of the counterparties, and iii) the aversion of a market participant to particular risks inherent in the instrument, the market in which it is traded, or the risk management strategy. Valuation adjustments take into account valuation uncertainty and include market and credit risk premiums to reflect costs that could be incurred in case of an exit transaction in the principal market. Fair value generally equals the economic value, subject to limited adjustments, such as own credit adjustments, which are specifically required by IFRS standards. The main valuation adjustments are presented in the section below. VALUATION ADJUSTMENTS Valuation adjustments retained by BNP Paribas for determining fair values are as follows: Bid/offer adjustments: the bid/offer range reflects the additional exit cost for a price taker and symmetrically the compensation sought by dealers to bear the risk of holding the position or closing it out by accepting another dealer’s price. BNP Paribas assumes that the best estimate of an exit price is the bid or offer price, unless there is evidence that another point in the bid/offer range would provide a more representative exit price. Input uncertainty adjustments: when the observation of prices or data inputs required by valuation techniques is difficult or irregular, an uncertainty exists on the exit price. There are several ways to gauge the degree of uncertainty on the exit price such as measuring the dispersion of the available price indications or estimating the possible ranges of the inputs to a valuation technique. Model uncertainty adjustments: these relate to situations where valuation uncertainty is due to the valuation technique used, even though observable inputs might be available. This situation arises when the risks inherent in the instruments are different from those available in the observable data, and therefore the valuation technique involves assumptions that cannot be easily corroborated. Future Hedging Costs adjustments (FHC): this adjustment applies to positions that require dynamic hedging throughout their lifetime leading to additional bid/offer costs. Calculation methods capture these expected costs in particular based on the optimal hedging frequency. Credit valuation adjustment (CVA): the CVA adjustment applies to valuations and market quotations whereby the credit worthiness of the counterparty is not reflected. It aims to account for the possibility that the counterparty may default and that BNP Paribas may not receive the full fair value of the transactions. -- 73 of 130 -- - 74 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 In determining the cost of exiting or transferring counterparty risk exposures, the relevant market is deemed to be an inter-dealer market. However, the determination of CVA remains judgemental due to i) the possible absence or lack of price discovery in the inter-dealer market, ii) the influence of the regulatory landscape relating to counterparty risk on the market participants’ pricing behaviour and iii) the absence of a dominant business model for managing counterparty risk. The CVA model is grounded on the same exposures as those used for regulatory purposes. The model attempts to estimate the cost of an optimal risk management strategy based on i) implicit incentives and constraints inherent in the regulations in force and their evolutions, ii) market perception of the probability of default, and iii) default parameters used for regulatory purposes. Funding valuation adjustment (FVA): when valuation techniques are used for the purpose of deriving fair value, funding assumptions related to the future expected cash flows are an integral part of the mid-market valuation, notably through the use of appropriate discount rates. These assumptions reflect what the Bank anticipates as being the effective funding conditions of the instrument that a market participant would consider. This notably takes into account the existence and terms of any collateral agreement. In particular, for non- or imperfectly collateralised derivative instruments, they include an explicit adjustment to the interbank interest rate. Own-credit valuation adjustment for debts (OCA) and for derivatives (debit valuation adjustment - DVA): OCA and DVA are adjustments reflecting the effect of credit worthiness of BNP Paribas, on respectively the value of debt securities designated as at fair value through profit or loss and derivatives. Both adjustments are based on the expected future liability profiles of such instruments. The own credit worthiness is inferred from the market- based observation of the relevant bond issuance levels. The DVA adjustment is determined after taking into account the Funding Valuation Adjustment (FVA). Thus, the carrying value of debt securities designated as at fair value though profit or loss is decreased by EUR 198 million at 31 December 2023, compared with a decrease in value of EUR 160 million at 31 December 2022, i.e. a + EUR 38 million variation recognised directly in equity that will not be reclassified to profit or loss. INSTRUMENT CLASSES AND CLASSIFICATION WITHIN THE FAIR VALUE HIERARCHY FOR ASSETS AND LIABILITIES MEASURED AT FAIR VALUE As explained in the summary of significant accounting policies (note 1.f.10), financial instruments measured at fair value are categorised into a fair value hierarchy consisting of three levels. -- 74 of 130 -- - 75 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 In millions of euros 31 December 2023 Financial instruments held for trading Instruments at fair value through profit or loss not held for trading Financial assets at fair value through equity Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Securities 171,172 30,482 571 202,225 1,205 1,079 7,125 9,409 44,707 7,095 747 52,549 Governments 80,933 14,291 10 95,234 225 225 19,919 3,367 48 23,334 Other debt securities 19,776 15,747 439 35,962 327 363 380 1,070 23,218 3,515 207 26,940 Equities and other equity securities 70,463 444 122 71,029 653 716 6,745 8,114 1,570 213 492 2,275 Loans and repurchase agreements - 224,512 188 224,700 - 913 1,562 2,475 - - - - Loans 8,441 8,441 913 1,562 2,475 Repurchase agreements 216,071 188 216,259 - FINANCIAL ASSETS AT FAIR VALUE 171,172 254,994 759 426,925 1,205 1,992 8,687 11,884 44,707 7,095 747 52,549 Securities 102,913 1,955 42 104,910 - - - - Governments 69,811 398 70,209 - Other debt securities 9,670 1,544 41 11,255 - Equities and other equity securities 23,432 13 1 23,446 - Borrowings and repurchase agreements - 270,854 632 271,486 - 1,973 155 2,128 Borrowings 4,846 4,846 1,973 155 2,128 Repurchase agreements 266,008 632 266,640 - Issued debt securities (note 5.h) - - - - 14 60,132 23,617 83,763 Subordinated debt (note 5.h) - 735 735 Non subordinated debt (note 5.h) - 14 59,397 23,617 83,028 FINANCIAL LIABILITIES AT FAIR VALUE 102,913 272,809 674 376,396 14 62,105 23,772 85,891 In millions of euros 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Financial instruments held for trading Instruments at fair value through profit or loss not held for trading Financial assets at fair value through equity Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Securities 130,589 25,744 805 157,138 1,643 1,495 5,801 8,939 32,727 4,395 944 38,066 Governments 59,860 10,136 28 70,024 - 16,785 1,770 127 18,682 Other debt securities 16,454 14,695 630 31,779 1,152 500 333 1,985 14,496 2,412 288 17,196 Equities and other equity securities 54,275 913 147 55,335 491 995 5,468 6,954 1,446 213 529 2,188 Loans and repurchase agreements - 186,170 798 186,968 - 1,274 2,883 4,157 - - - - Loans 6,428 5 6,433 1,274 2,883 4,157 Repurchase agreements 179,742 793 180,535 - FINANCIAL ASSETS AT FAIR VALUE 130,589 211,914 1,603 344,106 1,643 2,769 8,684 13,096 32,727 4,395 944 38,066 Securities 97,367 1,716 72 99,155 - - - - Governments 57,949 92 16 58,057 Other debt securities 13,183 1,581 47 14,811 Equities and other equity securities 26,235 43 9 26,287 Borrowings and repurchase agreements - 230,303 2,048 232,351 - 1,472 253 1,725 Borrowings 6,952 6,952 1,472 253 1,725 Repurchase agreements 223,351 2,048 225,399 Issued debt securities (note 5.h) - - - - 4 46,628 18,946 65,578 Subordinated debt (note 5.h) 675 675 Non subordinated debt (note 5.h) 4 45,953 18,946 64,903 FINANCIAL LIABILITIES AT FAIR VALUE 97,367 232,019 2,120 331,506 4 48,100 19,199 67,303 Fair values of derivatives are broken down by dominant risk factor, namely interest rate, foreign exchange, credit and equity. Derivatives used for hedging purposes are mainly interest rate derivatives. -- 75 of 130 -- - 76 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 31 December 2023 Positive market value Negative market value In millions of euros Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Interest rate derivatives 734 131,382 1,384 133,500 714 103,334 1,928 105,976 Foreign exchange derivatives 18 118,300 776 119,094 16 118,065 45 118,126 Credit derivatives 7,663 764 8,427 8,697 1,623 10,320 Equity derivatives 15 21,177 2,875 24,067 659 31,222 6,146 38,027 Other derivatives 586 6,365 40 6,991 607 5,769 67 6,443 Derivative financial instruments not used for hedging purposes 1,353 284,887 5,839 292,079 1,996 267,087 9,809 278,892 Derivative financial instruments used for hedging purposes - 21,692 - 21,692 - 38,011 - 38,011 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Positive market value Negative market value In millions of euros Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Interest rate derivatives 873 147,853 1,396 150,122 503 122,659 2,053 125,215 Foreign exchange derivatives 33 133,628 721 134,382 35 129,204 35 129,274 Credit derivatives 6,382 912 7,294 6,822 909 7,731 Equity derivatives 6,760 13,512 2,330 22,602 9,177 13,290 4,824 27,291 Other derivatives 1,295 12,158 79 13,532 843 9,629 138 10,610 Derivative financial instruments not used for hedging purposes 8,961 313,533 5,438 327,932 10,558 281,604 7,959 300,121 Derivative financial instruments used for hedging purposes - 25,401 - 25,401 - 40,001 - 40,001 Transfers between levels may occur when an instrument fulfils the criteria defined, which are generally market and product dependent. The main factors influencing transfers are changes in the observation capabilities, passage of time, and events during the transaction lifetime. The timing of recognising transfers is determined at the beginning of the reporting period. During the year 2023, the main transfers between Level 1 and Level 2 are related to the reclassification of equity derivatives from Level 1 to Level 2 due to the reassessment of the observable nature of the associated valuation parameters. DESCRIPTION OF MAIN INSTRUMENTS IN EACH LEVEL The following section provides a description of the instruments in each level in the hierarchy. It describes notably instruments classified in Level 3 and the associated valuation methodologies. For main trading book instruments and derivatives classified in Level 3, further quantitative information is provided about the inputs used to derive fair value. Level 1 This level encompasses all derivatives and securities that are quoted continuously in active markets. Level 1 includes notably equity securities and liquid bonds, shortselling of these instruments, derivative instruments traded on organised markets (futures, options, etc.). It includes shares of funds and UCITS, for which the net asset value is calculated on a daily basis, as well as debt representative of shares of consolidated funds held by third parties. -- 76 of 130 -- - 77 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Level 2 The Level 2 stock of securities is composed of securities which are less liquid than the Level 1 bonds. They are predominantly corporate debt securities, government bonds, mortgage backed securities, fund shares and short- term securities such as certificates of deposit. They are classified in Level 2 notably when external prices for the same security can be regularly observed from a reasonable number of market makers that are active in this security, but these prices do not represent directly tradable prices. This comprises amongst other, consensus pricing services with a reasonable number of contributors that are active market makers as well as indicative runs from active brokers and/or dealers. Other sources such as primary issuance market, may also be used where relevant. Repurchase agreements are classified predominantly in Level 2. The classification is primarily based on the observability and liquidity of the repo market, depending on the underlying collateral and the maturity of the repo transaction. Debts issued designated as at fair value through profit and loss, are classified in the same level as the one that would apply to the embedded derivative taken individually. The issuance spread is considered observable. Derivatives classified in Level 2 comprise mainly the following instruments: - vanilla instruments such as interest rate swaps, caps, floors and swaptions, credit default swaps, equity/foreign exchange (FX)/commodities forwards and options; - structured derivatives for which model uncertainty is not significant such as exotic FX options, mono- and multi-underlying equity/funds derivatives, single curve exotic interest rate derivatives and derivatives based on structured rates. The above derivatives are classified in Level 2 when there is a documented stream of evidence supporting one of the following: - fair value is predominantly derived from prices or quotations of other Level 1 and Level 2 instruments, through standard market interpolation or stripping techniques whose results are regularly corroborated by real transactions; - fair value is derived from other standard techniques such as replication or discounted cash flows that are calibrated to observable prices, that bear limited model risk and enable an effective offset of the risks of the instrument through trading Level 1 or Level 2 instruments; - fair value is derived from more sophisticated or proprietary valuation techniques but is directly evidenced through regular back-testing using external market-based data. Determining whether an over-the-counter (OTC) derivative is eligible for Level 2 classification involves judgement. Consideration is given to the origin, transparency and reliability of external data used, and the amount of uncertainty associated with the use of models. It follows that the Level 2 classification criteria involve multiple analysis axis within an “observability zone” whose limits are determined by i) a predetermined list of product categories and ii) the underlying and maturity bands. These criteria are regularly reviewed and updated, together with the applicable valuation adjustments, so that the classification by level remains consistent with the valuation adjustment policy. -- 77 of 130 -- - 78 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Level 3 Level 3 securities of the trading book mainly comprise units of funds and unlisted equity shares measured at fair value through profit or loss or through equity. Unlisted private equities are systematically classified as Level 3, with the exception of UCITS with a daily net asset value, which are classified in the Level 1 of the fair value hierarchy. Shares and other unlisted variable income securities in Level 3 are valued using one of the following methods: a share of revalued net book value, multiples of comparable companies, future cash flows method, multi-criteria approach. Repurchase agreements mainly long-term or structured repurchase agreements on corporate bonds and ABSs: the valuation of these transactions requires proprietary methodologies given the bespoke nature of the transactions and the lack of activity and price discovery in the long-term repo market. The curves used in the valuation are corroborated using available data such as recent long-term repo trade data and price enquiry data. Valuation adjustments applicable to these exposures are commensurate with the degree of uncertainty inherent in the modelling choices and amount of data available. Debts issued designated as at fair value through profit or loss, are classified in the same level as the one that would apply to the embedded derivative taken individually. The issuance spread is considered observable. Derivatives Vanilla derivatives are classified in Level 3 when the exposure is beyond the observation zone for rate curves or volatility surfaces, or relates to less liquid markets such as tranches on old credit index series or emerging markets interest rates markets. The main instruments are: - Interest rate derivatives: exposures mainly comprise swap products in less liquid currencies. Classification is driven by the lower liquidity of some maturities, while observation capabilities through consensus may be available. The valuation technique is standard, and uses external market information and extrapolation techniques. - Credit derivatives (CDS): exposures mainly comprise CDSs beyond the maximum observable maturity and, to a much lesser extent, CDSs on illiquid or distressed names and CDSs on loan indices. Classification is driven by the lack of liquidity while observation capabilities may be available notably through consensus. Level 3 exposures also comprise CDS and Total Return Swaps (TRS) positions on securitised assets. These are priced along the same modelling techniques as the underlying bonds, taking into consideration the funding basis and specific risk premium. - Equity derivatives: exposures essentially comprise long dated forward or volatility products or exposures where there is a limited market for optional products. The marking of the forward curves and volatility surfaces beyond the maximum observable maturity relies on extrapolation techniques. However, when there is no market for model input, volatility or forward is generally determined on the basis of proxy or historical analysis. Similarly, long-term transactions on equity baskets are also classified in Level 3, based on the absence of equity correlation observability on long maturities. These vanilla derivatives are subject to valuation adjustments linked to uncertainty on liquidity, specialised by nature of underlying and liquidity bands. -- 78 of 130 -- - 79 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Structured derivatives classified in Level 3 predominantly comprise hybrid products (FX/Interest Rates hybrids, Equity hybrids), credit correlation products, prepayment-sensitive products, some stock basket optional products and some interest rate optional instruments. The main exposures are described below, with insight into the related valuation techniques and on the source of uncertainty: - Structured interest rate options are classified in Level 3 when they involve currencies where there is not sufficient observation or when they include a quanto feature where the pay-off is measured with a forex forward fixed rate (except for the main currencies). Long term structured derivatives are also classified in Level 3. - Hybrid FX/Interest rate products essentially comprise a specific product family known as Power Reverse Dual Currency (PRDC) when there is material valuation uncertainty. When valuation of PRDCs requires sophisticated modelling of joint behaviour of FX and interest rate, and is notably sensitive to the unobservable FX/ interest rate correlations, such products are classified as Level 3. PRDCs valuations are corroborated with recent trade data and consensus data. - Securitisation swaps mainly comprise fixed-rate swaps, cross-currency or basis swaps whose notional is indexed to the prepayment behaviour of some underlying portfolio. The estimation of the maturity profile of securitisation swaps is corroborated by statistical estimates using external historical data. - Forward volatility options are generally products whose pay-off is indexed to the future variability of a rate index such as volatility swaps. These products involve material model risk as it is difficult to infer forward volatility information from market-traded instruments. The valuation adjustment framework is calibrated to the uncertainty inherent in the product, and to the range of uncertainty from the existing external consensus data. - Inflation derivatives classified in Level 3 mainly comprise swap products on inflation indices that are not associated with a liquid indexed bond market, optional products on inflation indices (such as caps and floors) and other forms of inflation indices involving optionality on the inflation indices or on the inflation annual rate. Valuation techniques used for inflation derivatives are predominantly standard market models. Proxy techniques are used for a few limited exposures. Although the valuations are corroborated through monthly consensus data, these products are classified as Level 3 due to their lack of liquidity and some uncertainties inherent in the calibration. - The valuation of bespoke CDOs requires correlation of default events when there is material valuation uncertainty. This information is inferred from the active index tranche market through a proprietary projection technique and involves proprietary extrapolation and interpolation techniques. Multi-geography CDOs further require an additional correlation assumption. Finally, the bespoke CDO model also involves proprietary assumptions and parameters related to the dynamic of the recovery factor. CDO modelling, is calibrated on the observable index tranche markets, and is regularly back-tested against consensus data on standardised pools. The uncertainty arises from the model risk associated with the projection and geography mixing technique, and the uncertainty of associated parameters, together with the recovery modelling. - N to Default baskets are other forms of credit correlation products, modelled through standard copula techniques. The main inputs required are the pair-wise correlations between the basket components which can be observed in the consensus and the transactions. Linear baskets are considered observable. - Equity and equity-hybrid correlation products are instruments whose pay-off is dependent on the joint behaviour of a basket of equities/indices leading to a sensitivity of the fair value measurement to the correlation amongst the basket components. Hybrid versions of these instruments involve baskets that mix equity and non-equity underlyings such as commodity indices, or foreign exchange rates. Only a subset of the Equity/index correlation matrix is regularly observable and traded, while most cross-asset correlations are not active. Therefore, classification in Level 3 depends on the composition of the basket, the maturity, and the hybrid nature of the product. The correlation input is derived from a proprietary model combining historical estimators, and other adjustment factors, that are corroborated by reference to recent trades or external data. The correlation matrix is essentially available from consensus services, and when a correlation between two underlying instruments is not available, it might be obtained from extrapolation or proxy techniques. These structured derivatives are subject to specific valuation adjustments to cover uncertainties linked to liquidity, parameters and model risk. -- 79 of 130 -- - 80 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Valuation adjustments (CVA, DVA and FVA) The valuation adjustment for counterparty credit risk (CVA), own-credit risk for derivatives (DVA) and the explicit funding valuation adjustment (FVA) are deemed to be unobservable components of the valuation framework and therefore classified in Level 3. This does not impact, in general cases, the classification of individual transactions into the fair value hierarchy. However, a specific process allows to identify individual deals for which the marginal contribution of these adjustments and related uncertainty is significant and justifies classifying these transactions in Level 3. The table below provides the range of values of main unobservable inputs for the valuation of Level 3 financial instruments. The ranges displayed correspond to a variety of different underlying instruments and are meaningful only in the context of the valuation technique implemented by BNP Paribas. The weighted averages, where relevant and available, are based on fair values, nominal amounts or sensitivities. The main unobservable parameters used for the valuation of debt issued in Level 3 are equivalent to those of their economic hedge derivative. Information on those derivatives, displayed in the following table, is also applicable to these debts. Risk classes Balance Sheet valuation (in millions of euros) Main product types composing the Level 3 stock within the risk class Valuation technique used for the product types considered Main unobservable inputs for the product types considered Range of unobservable input across Level 3 population considered Weighted average Asset Liability Repurchase agreements 188 632 Long-term repo and reverse-repo agreements Proxy techniques, based amongst other on the funding basis of a benchmark bond pool, that is actively traded and representative of the repo underlying Long-term repo spread on private bonds (High Yield, High Grade) and on ABSs 0 bp to 152 bp 30 bp (a) Interest rate derivatives 1,384 1,928 Hybrid Forex / Interest rates derivatives Hybrid Forex interest rate option pricing model Correlation between FX rate and interest rates. Main currency pairs are EUR/JPY, USD/JPY, AUD/JPY -16% to 52% 8% (a) Hybrid inflation rates / Interest rates derivatives Hybrid inflation interest rate option pricing model Correlation between interest rates and inflation rates mainly in Europe. 10% to 32% 29% Floors and caps on inflation rate or on the cumulative inflation (such as redemption floors), predominantly on European and French inflation Inflation pricing model Volatility of cumulative inflation 1.3% to 11.7% (b) Volatility of the year on year inflation rate 0.5% to 2.8% Forward Volatility products such as volatility swaps, mainly in euros Interest rates option pricing model Forward volatility of interest rates 0.5% to 1.0% (b) Balance-guaranteed fixed rate, basis or cross currency swaps, predominantly indexed on European collateral pools Prepayment modelling Discounted cash flows Constant prepayment rates 0% to 18% 2% (a) Credit derivatives 764 1,623 Collateralised Debt Obligations and index tranches for inactive index series Base correlation projection technique and recovery modelling Base correlation curve for bespoke portfolios 29% to 99% (b) Recovery rate variance for single name underlyings 0% to 25 % (b) N-to-default baskets Credit default model Default correlation 48% to 84% 49% (a) Single name Credit Default Swaps (other than CDS on ABSs and loans indices) Stripping, extrapolation and interpolation Credit default spreads beyond observation limit (10 years) N.A. 99 bp Illiquid credit default spread curves (across main tenors) 3 bp to 2,824 bp (1) 76 bp (c) Equity derivatives 2,875 6,146 Simple and complex derivatives on multi- underlying baskets on stocks Various volatility option models Unobservable equity volatility 0% to 122% (2) 30% (d) Unobservable equity correlation 15% to 98% 50% (c) (1) The upper bound of the range relates to building, retail and services sector issuers that represent an insignificant portion of the balance sheet (CDSs with illiquid underlying instruments). (2) The upper part of the range relates to 7 equities representing a non-material portion of the balance sheet on options with equity underlying instruments. Including these inputs, the upper bound of the range would be around 196%. (a) Weights based on relevant risk axis at portfolio level (b) No weighting, since no explicit sensitivity is attributed to these inputs (c) Weighting is not based on risks, but on an alternative methodology in relation with the Level 3 instruments (present value or notional) (d) Simple averaging -- 80 of 130 -- - 81 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 TABLE OF MOVEMENTS IN LEVEL 3 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS For Level 3 financial instruments, the following movements occurred during the year ended 2023: In millions of euros Financial assets Financial liabilities Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss held for trading Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss not held for trading Financial assets at fair value through equity TOTAL Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss held for trading Financial instruments designated as at fair value through profit or loss TOTAL At 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 7,041 8,684 944 16,669 (10,079) (19,199) (29,278) Purchases 812 1,442 154 2,408 - Issues - (5,229) (5,229) Sales (903) (1,791) (162) (2,856) (54) (54) Settlements (1) (3,019) (98) (66) (3,183) (3,323) 1,355 (1,968) Transfers to Level 3 2,797 36 2,833 (1,799) (359) (2,158) Transfers from Level 3 (3,347) (90) (3,437) 2,527 429 2,956 Gains (or losses) recognised in profit or loss with respect to transactions expired or terminated during the period 981 486 (1) 1,466 (3,421) (757) (4,178) Gains (or losses) recognised in profit or loss with respect to unexpired instruments at the end of the period 2,233 (5) 2,228 5,669 (12) 5,657 Changes in fair value of assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity - - - Items related to exchange rate movements 3 (67) (18) (82) (3) (3) - Changes in fair value of assets and liabilities recognised in equity (14) (14) - At 31 December 2023 6,598 8,687 747 16,032 (10,483) (23,772) (34,255) (1)For the assets, includes redemptions of principal, interest payments as well as cash inflows and outflows relating to derivatives. For the liabilities, includes principal redemptions, interest payments as well as cash inflows and outflows relating to derivatives the fair value of which is negative. Transfers out of Level 3 of derivatives include mainly the update of the observability tenor of certain yield curves, and of market parameters related to repurchase agreements and credit transactions but also the effect of derivatives becoming only or mainly sensitive to observable inputs due to the shortening of their lifetime. Transfers into Level 3 of instruments at fair value reflect the effect of the regular update of the observability zones. Transfers have been reflected as if they had taken place at the beginning of the reporting period. The Level 3 financial instruments may be hedged by other Level 1 and Level 2 instruments, the gains and losses of which are not shown in this table. Consequently, the gains and losses shown in this table are not representative of the gains and losses arising from management of the net risk on all these instruments. SENSITIVITY OF FAIR VALUE TO REASONABLY POSSIBLE CHANGES IN LEVEL 3 ASSUMPTIONS The following table summarises those financial assets and financial liabilities classified as Level 3 for which alternative assumptions in one or more of the unobservable inputs would change fair value significantly. The amounts disclosed are intended to illustrate the range of possible uncertainty inherent to the judgement applied when estimating Level 3 parameters, or when selecting valuation techniques. These amounts reflect valuation uncertainties that prevail at the measurement date, and even though such uncertainties predominantly derive from the portfolio sensitivities that prevailed at that measurement date, they are not predictive or indicative of future movements in fair value, nor do they represent the effect of market stress on the portfolio value. -- 81 of 130 -- - 82 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 In estimating sensitivities, BNP Paribas either remeasured the financial instruments using reasonably possible inputs, or applied assumptions based on the valuation adjustment policy. For the sake of simplicity, the sensitivity on cash instruments that are not relating to securitised instruments was based on a uniform 1% shift in the price. More specific shifts were however calibrated for each class of the Level 3 securitised exposures, based on the possible ranges of the unobservable inputs. For derivative exposures, the sensitivity measurement is based on the credit valuation adjustment (CVA), the explicit funding valuation adjustment (FVA) and the parameter and model uncertainty adjustments related to Level 3. Regarding the credit valuation adjustment (CVA) and the explicit funding valuation adjustment (FVA), the uncertainty was calibrated based on prudent valuation adjustments described in the technical standard “Prudent Valuation” published by the European Banking Authority. For other valuation adjustments, two scenarios were considered: a favourable scenario where all or portion of the valuation adjustment is not considered by market participants, and an unfavourable scenario where market participants would require twice the amount of valuation adjustments considered by BNP Paribas for entering into a transaction. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Potential impact on income Potential impact on equity Potential impact on income Potential impact on equity Debt securities +/-6 +/-2 +/-8 +/-3 Equities and other equity securities +/-68 +/-5 +/-56 +/-5 Loans and repurchase agreements +/-20 +/-42 Derivative financial instruments +/-586 +/-576 Interest rate and foreign exchange derivatives +/-218 +/-227 Credit derivatives +/-94 +/-98 Equity derivatives +/-271 +/-245 Other derivatives +/-3 +/-6 Sensitivity of Level 3 financial instruments +/-680 +/-7 +/-682 +/-8 DEFERRED MARGIN ON FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS MEASURED USING TECHNIQUES DEVELOPED INTERNALLY AND BASED ON INPUTS PARTLY UNOBSERVABLE IN ACTIVE MARKETS Deferred margin on financial instruments (“Day One Profit”) primarily concerns the scope of financial instruments eligible for Level 3 and to a lesser extent some financial instruments eligible for Level 2 where valuation adjustments for uncertainties regarding parameters or models are not negligible compared to the initial margin. The Day One Profit is calculated after setting aside valuation adjustments for uncertainties as described previously and released to profit or loss over the expected period for which the inputs will be unobservable. The unamortised amount is included under “Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss” as a reduction in the fair value of the relevant transactions. In millions of euros Deferred margin at 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Deferred margin on transactions during the period Margin taken to the profit and loss account during the period Deferred margin at 31 December 2023 Interest rate and foreign exchange derivatives 194 113 (140) 167 Credit derivatives 174 175 (124) 225 Equity derivatives 426 166 (211) 381 Other instruments 10 140 (139) 11 Financial instruments 804 594 (614) 784 -- 82 of 130 -- - 83 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5.e F INANCIAL ASSETS AT AMORTISED COST • Detail of loans and advances by nature 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 In millions of euros Gross value Impairment (note 3.g) Carrying amount Gross value Impairment (note 3.g) Carrying amount Loans and advances to credit institutions 24,434 (99) 24,335 32,716 (100) 32,616 On demand accounts 7,252 (6) 7,246 11,000 (8) 10,992 Loans(1) 12,267 (93) 12,174 15,767 (92) 15,675 Repurchase agreements 4,915 4,915 5,949 5,949 Loans and advances to customers 876,712 (17,512) 859,200 875,301 (18,281) 857,020 On demand accounts 46,733 (2,752) 43,981 42,963 (2,844) 40,119 Loans to customers 780,638 (13,593) 767,045 788,971 (14,354) 774,617 Finance leases 48,842 (1,167) 47,675 42,574 (1,083) 41,491 Repurchase agreements 499 499 793 793 Total loans and advances at amortised cost 901,146 (17,611) 883,535 908,017 (18,381) 889,636 (1) Loans and advances to credit institutions include term deposits made with central banks. Contractual maturities of finance leases In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Gross investment 53,562 45,602 Receivable within 1 year 15,771 13,278 Receivable after 1 year but within 5 years 32,539 28,068 Receivable beyond 5 years 5,252 4,256 Unearned interest income (4,720) (3,028) Net investment before impairment 48,842 42,574 Receivable within 1 year 14,057 12,176 Receivable after 1 year but within 5 years 29,999 26,396 Receivable beyond 5 years 4,786 4,002 Impairment provisions (1,167) (1,083) Net investment after impairment 47,675 41,491 -- 83 of 130 -- - 84 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Detail of debt securities by type of issuer 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 In millions of euros Gross value Impairment (note 3.g) Carrying amount Gross value Impairment (note 3.g) Carrying amount Governments 62,659 (11) 62,648 59,961 (23) 59,938 Other public administration 16,288 (2) 16,286 15,686 (2) 15,684 Credit institutions 10,318 (2) 10,316 9,062 (2) 9,060 Others 32,000 (89) 31,911 29,435 (103) 29,332 Total debt securities at amortised cost 121,265 (104) 121,161 114,144 (130) 114,014 • Detail of financial assets at amortised cost by stage 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 In millions of euros Gross Value Impairment (note 3.g) Carrying amount Gross Value Impairment (note 3.g) Carrying amount Loans and advances to credit institutions 24,434 (99) 24,335 32,716 (100) 32,616 Stage 1 23,673 (19) 23,654 32,439 (11) 32,428 Stage 2 679 (13) 666 191 (10) 181 Stage 3 82 (67) 15 86 (79) 7 Loans and advances to customers 876,712 (17,512) 859,200 875,301 (18,281) 857,020 Stage 1 777,190 (1,906) 775,284 761,930 (1,998) 759,932 Stage 2 74,214 (2,399) 71,815 88,095 (2,839) 85,256 Stage 3 25,308 (13,207) 12,101 25,276 (13,444) 11,832 Debt securities 121,265 (104) 121,161 114,144 (130) 114,014 Stage 1 120,991 (12) 120,979 113,602 (27) 113,575 Stage 2 94 (5) 89 387 (10) 377 Stage 3 180 (87) 93 155 (93) 62 Total financial assets at amortised cost 1,022,411 (17,715) 1,004,696 1,022,161 (18,511) 1,003,650 -- 84 of 130 -- - 85 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5.f I MPAIRED FINANCIAL ASSETS ( STAGE 3) The following tables present the carrying amounts of impaired financial assets carried at amortised cost and of impaired financing and guarantee commitments, as well as related collateral and other guarantees. The amounts shown for collateral and other guarantees correspond to the lower of the value of the collateral or other guarantee and the value of the secured assets. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 Impaired financial assets (Stage 3) Collateral received Gross value Impairment Net Loans and advances to credit institutions (note 5.e) 82 (67) 15 Loans and advances to customers (note 5.e) 25,308 (13,207) 12,101 7,720 Debt securities at amortised cost (note 5.e) 180 (87) 93 Total amortised-cost impaired assets (stage 3) 25,570 (13,361) 12,209 7,720 Financing commitments given 889 (96) 793 263 Guarantee commitments given 769 (218) 551 135 Total off-balance sheet impaired commitments (stage 3) 1,658 (314) 1,344 398 In millions of euros 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Impaired financial assets (Stage 3) Collateral received Gross value Impairment Net Loans and advances to credit institutions (note 5.e) 86 (79) 7 1 Loans and advances to customers (note 5.e) 25,276 (13,444) 11,832 7,651 Debt securities at amortised cost (note 5.e) 155 (93) 62 14 Total amortised-cost impaired assets (stage 3) 25,517 (13,616) 11,901 7,666 Financing commitments given 898 (73) 825 198 Guarantee commitments given 820 (243) 577 135 Total off-balance sheet impaired commitments (stage 3) 1,718 (316) 1,402 333 The following table presents the changes in gross exposures of stage 3 assets (EU CR2): Gross value In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Impaired exposures (Stage 3) at opening balance 25,517 28,165 Transfer to stage 3 8,632 6,125 Transfer to stage 1 or stage 2 (2,166) (1,672) Assets written off (3,769) (4,827) Other changes (2,644) (2,274) Impaired exposures (Stage 3) at closing balance 25,570 25,517 -- 85 of 130 -- - 86 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5.g F INANCIAL LIABILITIES AT AMORTISED COST DUE TO CREDIT INSTITUTIONS AND CUSTOMERS In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Deposits from credit institutions 95,175 124,718 On demand accounts 10,770 12,538 Interbank borrowings (1) 54,825 104,135 Repurchase agreements 29,580 8,045 Deposits from customers 988,549 1,008,056 On demand deposits 542,133 592,269 Savings accounts 152,636 162,354 Term accounts and short-term notes 292,491 253,210 Repurchase agreements 1,289 223 (1) Interbank borrowings from credit institutions include term borrowings from central banks, of which EUR 18 billion of TLTRO III at 31 December 2023 compared to EUR 67 billion at 31 December 2022 (see note 3.a Net Interest Income). 5.h D EBT SECURITIES AND SUBORDINATED DEBT This note covers all issued debt securities and subordinated debt measured at amortised cost and designated as at fair value through profit or loss. • Debt securities designated at fair value through profit or loss (note 5.a) Issuer / Issue date Currency Original amount in foreign currency (millions) Date of call or interest step-up Interest rate Interest rate reset Conditions precedent for coupon payment (1) 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according IFRS 17 and 9 In millions of euros Debt securities 83,028 64,902 Subordinated debt 735 676 - Redeemable subordinated debt (2) 18 16 - Perpetual subordinated debt 717 660 BNP Paribas Fortis Dec. 2007(3) EUR 3,000 Dec.-14 3-month Euribor +200 bp A 717 660 (1) Conditions precedent for coupon payment: A Coupon payments are halted should the issuer have insufficient capital or the underwriters become insolvent or when the dividend declared for Ageas shares falls below a certain threshold. (2) After agreement from the banking supervisory authority and at the issuer’s initiative, redeemable subordinated debt issues may contain a call provision authorising the Group to redeem the securities prior to maturity by repurchasing them in the stock market, via public tender offers, or in the case of private placements over the counter. Debt issued by BNP Paribas SA or foreign subsidiaries of the Group via placements in the international markets may be subject to early redemption of the capital and early payment of interest due at maturity at the issuer’s discretion on or after a date stipulated in the issue particulars (call option), or in the event that changes in the applicable tax rules oblige the BNP Paribas Group issuer to compensate debt-holders for the consequences of such changes. Redemption may be subject to a notice period of between 15 and 60 days, and is in all cases subject to approval by the banking supervisory authorities. (3) Convertible And Subordinated Hybrid Equity-linked Securities (CASHES) issued by BNP Paribas Fortis (previously Fortis Banque) in December 2007. The CASHES are perpetual securities but may be exchanged for Ageas (previously Fortis SA/NV) shares at the holder’s sole discretion at a price of EUR 239.40. However, as of 19 December 2014, the CASHES will be automatically exchanged into Ageas shares if their price is equal to or higher than EUR 359.10 for twenty consecutive trading days. The principal amount will never be redeemed in cash. The rights of the CASHES holders are limited to the Ageas shares held by BNP Paribas Fortis and pledged to them. Ageas and BNP Paribas Fortis have entered into a Relative Performance Note (RPN) contract, the value of which varies contractually so as to offset the impact on BNP Paribas Fortis of the relative difference between changes in the value of the CASHES and changes in the value of the Ageas shares. Since 1 January 2022, the liability is no longer eligible to prudential own funds. -- 86 of 130 -- - 87 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Debt securities measured at amortised cost Issuer / Issue date Currency Original amount in foreign currency (millions) Date of call or interest step-up Interest rate Interest rate reset Conditions precedent for coupon payment (1) 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 In millions of euros Debt securities 191,482 155,359 - Debt securities in issue with an initial maturity of less than one year 75,743 58,342 Negotiable debt securities 75,743 58,342 - Debt securities in issue with an initial maturity of more than one year 115,739 97,017 Negotiable debt securities 30,592 18,503 Bonds 85,147 78,514 Subordinated debt 24,743 24,160 - Redeemable subordinated debt (2) 21,662 22,419 - Undated subordinated notes 2,852 1,509 BNP Paribas SA Oct. 85(5) EUR 305 - TMO - 0.25% - B 254 254 BNP Paribas SA Sept. 86 (5) USD 500 - 6 month- Libor + 0.075% - C 248 255 BNP Paribas Cardif Nov. 14 EUR 1,000 Nov. 25 4.032% 3 month-Euribor + 393 bp D 998 1,000 BNP Paribas SA Aug. 23(6) USD 1,500 Aug. 28 8.500% CMT + 4.354% E 1,352 - - Participating notes 225 225 BNP Paribas SA July 84 (3) (5) EUR 337 - (4) - 219 219 Others 6 6 - Expenses and commission, related debt 4 7 (1) Conditions precedent for coupon payment B Payment of the interest is mandatory, unless the Board of directors decides to postpone these payments after the Shareholders’ General Meeting has officially noted that there is no income available for distribution, where this occurs within the 12-month period preceding the due date for payment of the interest. Interest payments are cumulative and are payable in full once dividend payments resume. C Payment of the interest is mandatory, unless the Board of directors decides to postpone these payments after the Shareholders’ General Meeting has validated the decision not to pay out a dividend, where this occurs within the 12-month period preceding the due date for payment of the interest. Interest payments are cumulative and are payable in full once dividend payments resume. The bank has the option of resuming payment of interest arrears, even where no dividend is paid out. D Payment of the interest is mandatory, except for cases of regulatory deficiency, in agreement with the regulator, or of suspension of payments. Interest payments are cumulative and are payable in full, once coupon payments resume, or, if these events occur before, when the issuance is redeemed or when the issuer is liquidated. E Payment of the interest is at full discretion and could be cancelled in whole or in part if the relevant regulator notifies based on its assessment of the financial and solvency situation of the issuer. Interest Amounts on the Notes will be non-cumulative, once coupon payments resume. (2) See reference relating to "Debt securities at fair value through profit or loss". (3) The participating notes issued by BNP Paribas SA may be repurchased as provided for in the law of 3 January 1983. The number of notes in the market is 1,434,092. (4) Depending on net income subject to a minimum of 85% of the TMO rate and a maximum of 130% of the TMO rate. (5) As from 31 December 2023, these securities are no longer eligible to prudential own funds. (6) The instruments issued by BNP Paribas SA in August 2023 are contingent convertible securities classified as financial liabilities in accounting and eligible to Additionnal Tier 1 capital (see note 1.f.8). -- 87 of 130 -- - 88 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5.i C URRENT AND DEFERRED TAXES In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Current taxes 2,942 1,685 Deferred taxes 3,614 4,247 Current and deferred tax assets 6,556 5,932 Current taxes 2,725 2,042 Deferred taxes 1,096 937 Current and deferred tax liabilities 3,821 2,979 Change in deferred tax by nature over the period: In millions of euros 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Changes recognised in profit or loss Changes recognised in equity that may be reclassified to profit or loss Changes recognised in equity that will not be reclassified to profit or loss Effects of exchange rates, consolidation scope and other movements 31 December 2023 Financial instruments (1,559) (49) (476) (46) 63 (2,067) Provisions for employee benefit obligations 754 136 - 53 (46) 897 Unrealised finance lease reserve (577) (24) - - 2 (599) Credit risk impairment 2,632 (285) - - 5 2,352 Tax loss carryforwards 564 184 - - (16) 732 Other items 1,496 (280) (15) 5 (3) 1,203 Net deferred taxes 3,310 (318) (491) 12 5 2,518 Deferred tax assets 4,247 3,614 Deferred tax liabilities (937) (1,096) In order to determine the amount of the tax loss carryforwards recognised as assets, the Group conducts every year a specific review for each relevant entity based on the applicable tax regime, notably incorporating any time limit rules, and a realistic projection of their future revenue and charges in line with their business plan. Deferred tax assets recognised on tax loss carryforwards are mainly related to BNP Paribas Fortis for EUR 132 million at 31 December 2023, with a 2-year expected recovery period (unlimited carryforward period). Unrecognised deferred tax assets totalled EUR 541 million at 31 December 2023 (of which EUR 491 million of tax loss carryforwards) compared with EUR 1,585 million at 31 December 2022 (of which EUR 1,331 million of tax loss carryforwards), amount restated according to IFRS 17 and 9. -- 88 of 130 -- - 89 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5.j ACCRUED INCOME/ EXPENSE AND OTHER ASSETS/ LIABILITIES In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Guarantee deposits and bank guarantees paid 119,187 156,077 Collection accounts 773 282 Accrued income and prepaid expenses 5,400 6,839 Other debtors and miscellaneous assets 45,398 45,345 Total accrued income and other assets 170,758 208,543 Guarantee deposits received 87,612 124,055 Collection accounts 3,124 2,907 Accrued expense and deferred income 8,265 10,849 Lease liabilities 3,058 3,075 Other creditors and miscellaneous liabilities 41,614 44,124 Total accrued expense and other liabilities 143,673 185,010 5.k EQUITY-METHOD INVESTMENTS Cumulated financial information of associates and joint ventures is presented in the following table: In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 31 December 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Share of net income Share of changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity Share of net income and changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity Equity-method investments Share of net income Share of changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity Share of net income and changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity Equity-method investments Joint ventures (49) (64) (113) 1,784 19 - 19 1,445 Associates (1) 642 16 658 4,967 636 53 689 4,628 Total equity-method entities 593 (48) 545 6,751 655 53 708 6,073 (1) Including controlled but non-material entities consolidated under the equity method. -- 89 of 130 -- - 90 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The carrying amount of the Group’s investment in the main joint ventures and associates is presented in the following table: Country of registration Activity Interest (%) 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 In millions of euros Joint ventures Union de Creditos Inmobiliarios Spain Retail mortgage 50% 256 327 BoB Cardif Life Insurance China Life Insurance 50% 240 232 Genius Auto Finance Co Ltd China Speciliased loans 25% 290 195 Pinnacle Pet Holding Ltd United Kingdom Insurance 25% 393 181 Associates AG Insurance Belgium Insurance 25% 462 416 Bank of Nanjing China Retail banking 14% 2,813 2,757 Allfunds Group Plc United Kingdom Financial Services 12% 312 318 5.l P ROPERTY, PLANT , EQUIPMENT AND INTANGIBLE ASSETS USED IN OPERATIONS, INVESTMENT PROPERTY In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Gross value Accumulated depreciation, amortisation and impairment Carrying amount Gross value Accumulated depreciation, amortisation and impairment Carrying amount Investment property 785 (299) 486 827 (298) 529 Land and buildings 11,317 (4,633) 6,684 11,507 (4,704) 6,803 Equipment, furniture and fixtures 7,007 (5,321) 1,686 7,177 (5,400) 1,777 Plant and equipment leased as lessor under operating leases 45,720 (10,567) 35,153 38,817 (10,658) 28,159 Other property, plant and equipment 2,338 (1,125) 1,213 2,318 (1,118) 1,200 Property, plant and equipment 66,382 (21,646) 44,736 59,819 (21,880) 37,939 Of which right of use 5,978 (3,322) 2,656 6,000 (3,294) 2,706 Property, plant and equipment and investment property 67,167 (21,945) 45,222 60,646 (22,178) 38,468 Purchased software 3,853 (3,145) 708 3,690 (3,035) 655 Internally developed software 6,908 (5,398) 1,510 6,345 (5,000) 1,345 Other intangible assets 2,547 (623) 1,924 2,367 (577) 1,790 Intangible assets 13,308 (9,166) 4,142 12,402 (8,612) 3,790 • Investment property Land and buildings leased by the Group as lessor under operating leases are recorded in “Investment property”. The estimated fair value of investment property accounted for at amortised cost at 31 December 2023 is EUR 702 million, compared with EUR 736 million at 31 December 2022. -- 90 of 130 -- - 91 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Operating leases Operating leases and investment property transactions are in certain cases subject to agreements providing for the following minimum future payments: In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Future minimum lease payments receivable under non-cancellable leases 10,718 8,221 Payments receivable within 1 year 4,570 3,613 Payments receivable after 1 year but within 5 years 6,105 4,582 Payments receivable beyond 5 years 43 26 Future minimum lease payments receivable under non-cancellable leases are payments that the lessee is required to make during the lease term. • Intangible assets Other intangible assets include leasehold rights, goodwill and trademarks acquired by the Group. • Amortisation and provision Net depreciation and amortisation expense for the year ended 31 December 2023 was EUR 2,224 million, compared with EUR 2,284 million for the year ended 31 December 2022. The net increase in impairment on property, plant, equipment and intangible assets taken to the profit and loss account for the year ended 31 December 2023 amounted to EUR 19 million, compared with EUR 20 million for the year ended 31 December 2022. 5.m G OODWILL In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Carrying amount at start of period 5,294 5,121 Acquisitions 260 215 Divestments (7) (15) Impairment recognised during the period - (28) Exchange rate adjustments 2 1 Carrying amount at end of period 5,549 5,294 Gross value 8,639 8,413 Accumulated impairment recognised at the end of period (3,090) (3,119) -- 91 of 130 -- - 92 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Goodwill by cash-generating unit is as follows: In millions of euros Carrying amount Recognised impairment Acquisitions 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Corporate & Institutional Banking 1,275 1,215 - - 67 - Global Banking 277 279 Global Markets 549 490 67 Securities Services 449 446 Commercial, Personal Banking & Services 3,058 2,894 - (19) 166 215 Arval 633 608 23 96 Leasing Solutions 147 148 Personal Finance 1,432 1,291 (19) 143 61 Personal Investors 562 564 New Digital Businesses 220 220 61 Other 64 63 (3) Investment & Protection Services 1,213 1,182 - (9) 27 - Asset Management 197 190 9 Insurance 299 281 18 Real Estate 404 402 Wealth Management 313 309 (9) Other Activities 3 3 - - - - Total goodwill 5,549 5,294 - (28) 260 215 Negative goodwill - 277 Change in value of goodwill recognised in the profit and loss account - 249 The Group carried out a detailed analysis of goodwill to identify whether impairments were necessary in connection with the health crisis. This analysis is based in particular on the assumptions of economic scenarios (see note 3.g). The cash-generating units (CGU) to which goodwill is allocated are: Global Banking: Global Banking combines financing solutions to corporates, all transaction banking products, corporate finance advisory services in mergers and acquisitions and primary equity activities. Global Markets: Global Markets provides investment, hedging, financing and research services across asset classes, to corporate and institutional clients – as well as private and retail banking networks. The sustainable, long-term business model of Global Markets connects clients to capital markets throughout EMEA (Europe, Middle East & Africa), Asia Pacific and the Americas, with innovative solutions and digital platforms. Global Markets includes activities of Global Macro (Foreign Exchange, Global Rates, Local Markets, Commodity Derivatives), Global Credit (DCM Bonds, Credit, Securitisation) and Global Equities (Equities, Cash Equities et Prime Services). Securities Services: Securities Services provides integrated solutions for all actors involved in the investment cycle, sell side, buy side and issuers. BNP Paribas is one of the major global players in securities services. Arval: Specialist in vehicle long-term leasing and mobility, Arval offers corporates (from multinational companies to small and medium companies), employees and individuals tailored solutions that optimise their mobility. Leasing Solutions: BNP Paribas Leasing Solutions uses a multi-channel partnership approach (sales via referrals, partnerships, direct sales and banking networks) to offer corporate and small business clients an array of leasing and rental solutions, ranging from equipment financing to fleet outsourcing. -- 92 of 130 -- - 93 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Personal Finance: BNP Paribas Personal Finance is the Group’s consumer credit specialist. Through its brands and partnerships such as Cetelem, Cofinoga, Findomestic, AlphaCredit or Stellantis Financial Services, Personal Finance provides a full range of consumer loans at point of sale (retail stores and car dealerships) or through its customer relation centres and websites and mobile applications. The business line, in some countries outside the domestic markets, is integrated into the BNP Paribas group's retail banking. Personal Investors: BNP Paribas Personal Investors is a digital specialist of banking and investment services. Based in Germany and India, it provides a wide range of banking, savings and long and short-term investment services to individual clients via the internet, and also on the phone and face-to-face. In addition to its activities destined to private clients, Personal Investors offers its services and IT platform to independent financial consultants, asset managers and FinTechs. New Digital Businesses: they include the account management service “Nickel” and Floa since January 2022. Nickel is open to all, without any conditions regarding income, deposits or personal wealth, and without any overdraft or credit facility. This service, which operates in real time using the latest technology, is available through over 10,000 points of sale in France, Spain, Belgium, Portugal and Germany. Floa offers consumers split payments, mini-loans and bank cards. The company is a partner of major e-retailers, key players in travel and FinTechs, for which it develops tailor-made services. Already leader in France in payment facilities, Floa is present in Spain, Belgium, Italy and Portugal. Asset Management: BNP Paribas Asset Management is the dedicated asset management business line of the BNP Paribas Group and offers services to individual investors (through internal distributors – BNP Paribas private and retail banking – and external distributors), to corporates and to institutional investors (insurance companies, retirement funds, official institutions). Its aim is to offer an added value based on a broad range of expertise throughout its active management of equities and bonds, its activity of private debt, private asset and real asset management and its multi-asset, quantitative and solutions division. Insurance: BNP Paribas Cardif, a world leader in personal insurance, has designed, developed and marketed savings and protection products and services to protect individuals, their projects and their assets. BNP Paribas Cardif also offers products in damage insurance, health insurance, budget insurance, revenue and means of payment insurance, unexpected event protection (unemployment, accident, death, theft or breakage) or the protection of private digital data to meet the evolution of customers’ needs. Real Estate: BNP Paribas Real Estate serves the needs of its clients, whether institutional investors, corporates, public entities or individuals, at all stages of the life cycle of their property (from the conception of a construction project to its daily management). Wealth Management: Wealth Management encompasses the private banking activities of BNP Paribas and serves a clientele of wealthy individuals, shareholder families and entrepreneurs seeking a one-stop shop for all their wealth management and financial needs. Goodwill impairment tests are based on three different methods: observation of transactions related to comparable businesses, share price data for listed companies with comparable businesses, and discounted future cash flows (DCF). If one of the two comparables-based methods indicates the need for impairment, the DCF method is used to validate the results and determine the amount of impairment required. The DCF method is based on a number of assumptions in terms of future revenues, expenses and cost of risk (cash flows) based on medium-term business plans over a period of five years. Cash flow projections beyond the 5-year forecast period are based on a growth rate to perpetuity and are normalised when the short-term environment does not reflect the normal conditions of the economic cycle. The key parameters which are sensitive to the assumptions made are the cost of capital, the cost/income ratio, the cost of risk and the growth rate to perpetuity. -- 93 of 130 -- - 94 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Cost of capital is determined on the basis of a risk-free rate, an observed market risk premium weighted by a risk factor based on comparables specific to each cash-generating unit. The values of these parameters are obtained from external information sources. Allocated capital is determined for each cash-generating unit based on the “Common Equity Tier One” regulatory requirements for the legal entity to which the cash-generating unit belongs, with a minimum of 7%. The growth rate to perpetuity used is 2% for mature economies in Europe. For CGUs implemented in countries with high levels of inflation, a specific add-on is taken into account (calculated according to inflation rates disclosed by external sources). The following table shows the sensitivity of the valuation of the Personal Finance cash generating unit to changes in the value of parameters used in the DCF calculation: the cost of capital, the cost/income ratio in terminal value, the cost of risk in terminal value and the growth rate to perpetuity. • Sensitivity of the main goodwill valuations to a 10-basis point change in the cost of capital, a 1% change in the cost/income ratio in terminal value, a 5 % change of the cost of risk in terminal value and a 50-basis point change in the growth rate to perpetuity In millions of euros Personal Finance Cost of capital 10.3% Adverse change (+10 basis points) (150) Positive change (- 10 basis points) 154 Cost/income ratio 46.4% Adverse change (+ 1 %) (372) Positive change (-1 %) 372 Cost of risk (1,719) Adverse change (+ 5 %) (504) Positive change (- 5 %) 504 Growth rate to perpetuity 2.0% Adverse change (-50 basis points) (218) Positive change (+50 basis points) 246 Concerning the cash-generating unit Personal Finance, there would be no need to depreciate even by using, for the impairment test, the four most unfavourable variations in the table. -- 94 of 130 -- - 95 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5.n P ROVISIONS FOR CONTINGENCIES AND CHARGES • Provisions for contingencies and charges by type In millions of euros 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Net additions to provisions Provisions used Changes in value recognised directly in equity Effect of movements in exchange rates and other movements 31 December 2023 Provisions for employee benefits 6,117 1,473 (1,243) 246 (84) 6,509 of which post-employment benefits (note 8.b) 3,160 174 (296) 253 (93) 3,198 of which post-employment healthcare benefits (note 8.b) 83 5 (2) (7) (1) 78 of which provision for other long-term benefits (note 8.c) 1,546 391 (367) 1 1,571 of which provision for voluntary departure, early retirement plans, and headcount adaptation plan (note 8.d) 270 314 (105) 3 482 of which provision for share-based payments (note 8.e) 1,059 589 (473) 5 1,180 Provisions for home savings accounts and plans 47 1 - - 48 Provisions for credit commitments (note 3.g) 1,430 (56) (45) (59) 1,270 Provisions for litigations 1,172 411 (337) (241) 1,005 Other provisions for contingencies and charges 1,274 104 (174) 482 1,686 Total provisions for contingencies and charges 10,040 1,933 (1,799) 246 98 10,518 In 2023, the Group modified its accounting policy relating to the risk of loss of cash flows on financial instruments granted that are not linked to the counterparty’s default, such as legal risks calling into question the validity or enforceability of such contracts (see note 3.h). The effect on expected cash flows due to these risks is now considered as a change in the contract’s cash flows, in accordance with IFRS 9 B5.4.6, and is recorded as a decrease in the gross value of the asset. It was previously recognised separately in accordance with IAS 37 in "Provisions for risks and charges” (see note 5.n). Expected losses on derecognised financial instruments, as is the case when loans have been repaid, continue to be recognised in accordance with IAS 37. As a result, EUR 313 million previously presented in “Provisions for litigations” were deducted from “Financial assets at amortised cost”. As of 31 December 2023, reserves related to the uncertainty on the residual value of Arval’s vehicles previously recognised as a decrease in assets were included in “Other provisions for contingencies and charges”. • Provisions and discount for home savings accounts and plans In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Deposits collected under home savings accounts and plans 14,606 16,547 of which deposits collected under home savings plans 12,426 14,409 Aged more than 10 years 6,695 6,332 Aged between 4 and 10 years 4,926 7,227 Aged less than 4 years 805 850 Outstanding loans granted under home savings accounts and plans 9 10 of which loans granted under home savings plans 4 2 Provisions and discount recognised for home savings accounts and plans 48 47 provisions recognised for home savings plans 33 42 provisions recognised for home savings accounts 15 5 discount recognised for home savings accounts and plans - - -- 95 of 130 -- - 96 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 5.o O FFSETTING OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES The following tables present the amounts of financial assets and liabilities before and after offsetting. This information, required by IFRS 7, aims to enable the comparability with the accounting treatment applicable in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles in the United States (US GAAP), which are less restrictive than IAS 32 as regards offsetting. “Amounts set off on the balance sheet” have been determined according to IAS 32. Thus, a financial asset and a financial liability are offset and the net amount presented on the balance sheet when, and only when, the Group has a legally enforceable right to set off the recognised amounts and intends either to settle on a net basis, or to realise the asset and settle the liability simultaneously. Amounts set off derive mainly from repurchase agreements and derivative instruments traded with clearing houses. The “impacts of master netting agreements and similar agreements” are relative to outstanding amounts of transactions within an enforceable agreement, which do not meet the offsetting criteria defined by IAS 32. This is the case of transactions for which offsetting can only be performed in case of default, insolvency or bankruptcy of one of the contracting parties. “Financial instruments given or received as collateral” include guarantee deposits and securities collateral recognised at fair value. These guarantees can only be exercised in case of default, insolvency or bankruptcy of one of the contracting parties. Regarding master netting agreements, the guarantee deposits received or given in compensation for the positive or negative fair values of financial instruments are recognised in the balance sheet in accrued income or expenses and other assets or liabilities. -- 96 of 130 -- - 97 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 In millions of euros, at 31 December 2023 Gross amounts of financial assets Gross amounts set off on the balance sheet Net amounts presented on the balance sheet Impact of Master Netting Agreements (MNA) and similar agreements Financial instruments received as collateral Net amounts Assets Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss Securities 211,634 211,634 211,634 Loans and repurchase agreements 462,109 (234,934) 227,175 (28,383) (181,529) 17,263 Derivative financial instruments (including derivatives used for hedging purposes) 890,604 (576,833) 313,771 (213,517) (51,325) 48,929 Financial assets at amortised cost 1,005,096 (400) 1,004,696 (676) (4,325) 999,695 of which repurchase agreements 5,813 (400) 5,413 (676) (4,325) 412 Accrued income and other assets 170,758 170,758 (40,664) 130,094 of which guarantee deposits paid 119,187 119,187 (40,664) 78,523 Other assets not subject to offsetting 663,465 663,465 663,465 TOTAL ASSETS 3,403,666 (812,167) 2,591,499 (242,576) (277,843) 2,071,080 In millions of euros, at 31 December 2023 Gross amounts of financial liabilities Gross amounts set off on the balance sheet Net amounts presented on the balance sheet Impact of Master Netting Agreements (MNA) and similar agreements Financial instruments given as collateral Net amounts Liabilities Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss Securities 104,910 104,910 104,910 Deposits and repurchase agreements 508,548 (234,934) 273,614 (26,113) (231,737) 15,764 Issued debt securities 83,763 83,763 83,763 Derivative financial instruments (including derivatives used for hedging purposes) 893,736 (576,833) 316,903 (213,517) (41,756) 61,630 Financial liabilities at amortised cost 1,084,124 (400) 1,083,724 (2,946) (26,145) 1,054,633 of which repurchase agreements 31,269 (400) 30,869 (2,946) (26,145) 1,778 Accrued expense and other liabilities 143,673 143,673 (46,631) 97,042 of which guarantee deposits received 87,612 87,612 (46,631) 40,981 Other liabilities not subject to offsetting 456,045 456,045 456,045 TOTAL LIABILITIES 3,274,799 (812,167) 2,462,632 (242,576) (346,269) 1,873,787 -- 97 of 130 -- - 98 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 In millions of euros, at 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Gross amounts of financial assets Gross amounts set off on the balance sheet Net amounts presented on the balance sheet Impact of Master Netting Agreements (MNA) and similar agreements Financial instruments received as collateral Net amounts Assets Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss Securities 166,077 166,077 166,077 Loans and repurchase agreements 334,401 (143,276) 191,125 (27,377) (147,368) 16,380 Derivative financial instruments (including derivatives used for hedging purposes) 980,162 (626,829) 353,333 (228,379) (64,980) 59,974 Financial assets at amortised cost 1,003,650 1,003,650 (966) (5,198) 997,486 of which repurchase agreements 6,742 6,742 (966) (5,198) 578 Accrued income and other assets 208,543 208,543 (44,982) 163,561 of which guarantee deposits paid 156,077 156,077 (44,982) 111,095 Other assets not subject to offsetting 741,020 741,020 741,020 TOTAL ASSETS 3,433,853 (770,105) 2,663,748 (256,722) (262,528) 2,144,498 In millions of euros, at 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Gross amounts of financial liabilities Gross amounts set off on the balance sheet Net amounts presented on the balance sheet Impact of Master Netting Agreements (MNA) and similar agreements Financial instruments given as collateral Net amounts Liabilities Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss Securities 99,155 99,155 99,155 Deposits and repurchase agreements 377,352 (143,276) 234,076 (27,376) (184,013) 22,687 Issued debt securities 65,578 65,578 65,578 Derivative financial instruments (including derivatives used for hedging purposes) 966,951 (626,829) 340,122 (228,379) (44,335) 67,408 Financial liabilities at amortised cost 1,132,774 1,132,774 (967) (6,500) 1,125,307 of which repurchase agreements 8,268 8,268 (967) (6,500) 801 Accrued expense and other liabilities 185,010 185,010 (57,443) 127,567 of which guarantee deposits received 124,055 124,055 (57,443) 66,612 Other liabilities not subject to offsetting 481,023 481,023 481,023 TOTAL LIABILITIES 3,307,843 (770,105) 2,537,738 (256,722) (292,291) 1,988,725 -- 98 of 130 -- - 99 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 6. NOTES RELATED TO INSURANCE ACTIVITIES 6.a N ET INCOME FROM INSURANCE ACTIVITIES The various income and expenses of insurance contracts are broken down in the “Net income from insurance activities” as follows: - “Insurance revenue” include revenue from insurance activities related to groups of insurance contracts issued. Insurance revenue reflects the provision of services relating to a group of contracts in an amount corresponding to the consideration to which the insurer expects to be entitled in exchange for those services; - “Insurance service expenses”: actual charges attributable to insurance contracts incurred over the period, changes related to past and current service, amortisation of acquisition costs, and the loss component for onerous contracts; - “Investment return”; - “Net finance income or expenses from insurance contracts” include the change in the carrying amount of insurance contracts resulting from the undiscounting effect, and the financial risk including changes in financial assumptions. In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Insurance revenue 8,945 8,759 Insurance service expenses (1) (6,786) (6,619) Investment return 10,254 (12,077) Net finance income or expenses from insurance contracts (10,093) 11,838 Net income from insurance activities 2,320 1,901 (1) Insurance service expenses include attributable expenses which amounted to - EUR 3,723 million for the year ended 2023, compared to - EUR 3,641 million for the year ended 2022 (see note 6.b). • Insurance service result “Insurance service result” includes: - “Insurance revenue”: for contracts under the variable fee approach and under the building block approach it represents the release of fulfilment insurance contracts cash flows over the period (excluding changes in investment component and the amount allocated to the loss component), change in the non-financial risk adjustment, amortisation of the contractual service margin for services provided over the period, the amount allocated for the amortisation of acquisition cost, and experience adjustments related to premiums. For contracts under the variable fee approach, the amortisation of the margin on contractual services is determined after adjusting the difference between the real-world expected financial return and the risk- neutral projection. The main financial assumptions underlying the calculation of the real-world expected financial return are those adopted by the Group over the horizon of the strategic plan. Beyond this horizon, the interest rate and return assumptions used are determined in line with those underlying the risk- neutral projection. The recovery of insurance acquisition cash flows corresponds to the portion of the premiums that relate to recovering these cash flows and the same amount is recognised as an expense on the line “Amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows”. For contracts under the simplified measurement model, revenue represents expected cash-flows over the period. - “Insurance service expenses” include incurred and past claims expenses of the period (excluding repayments of investment component) and other expenses that have been incurred related to insurance activities. Other insurance service expenses include the amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows; changes that relate to past services and changes that relate to future services. This line includes also the operating expenses and depreciation and amortisation attributable to insurance contracts. - “Net expenses from reinsurance contracts held” are service expenses from reinsurance net of amounts recovered from reinsurers. -- 99 of 130 -- - 100 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Contracts not measured under the premium allocation approach 5,435 5,489 Changes in the liability for remaining coverage 2,221 2,145 Change in the risk adjustment 122 102 Contractual service margin 1,825 1,828 Recovery of insurance acquisition cash flows 1,267 1,414 Contracts measured under the premium allocation approach 3,510 3,270 Insurance revenue 8,945 8,759 Incurred claims and expenses (3,928) (3,591) Amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows (2,612) (2,678) Changes that relate to past service 249 151 Loss component recognised in profit or loss (62) (75) Net expenses from reinsurance contracts held (433) (426) Insurance service expenses (6,786) (6,619) INSURANCE SERVICE RESULT 2,159 2,140 • Financial result “Financial Result” includes “Investment return” and “Net finance income or expenses from insurance contracts.” “Investment return” includes net income from financial instruments and from investment properties. “Changes in fair value of underlying items of direct participation contracts” reflects the changes in value of underlying investments for the amount which was not recognised directly in equity, and excluding the portion of these changes adjusting the contract service margin. “Other insurance financial expenses” measured under the general model and under the simplified model represent the change in technical liabilities arising from financial risks (discount rates variations, forex rates, time value and financial variations expected in the contracts) for the amount which was not recognised directly in equity. In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Net interest income 2,376 2,698 Net gain on financial instruments at fair value through equity (432) (574) Net gain on debt instruments (445) (598) Dividend income on equity instruments 13 24 Net gain on financial instruments at fair value through profit and loss 9,040 (14,073) Cost of risk 24 22 Investment property income (672) (79) Share of earnings of equity-method investments (6) (3) Other expenses (76) (68) Investment return 10,254 (12,077) Changes in fair value of underlying items of direct participation contracts (9,940) 11,968 Other insurance financial expenses (153) (130) Net finance income or expenses from insurance contracts (10,093) 11,838 FINANCIAL RESULT 161 (239) -- 100 of 130 -- - 101 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 6.b R ECONCILIATION OF EXPENSES BY TYPE AND BY FUNCTION In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Commissions and other expenses (2,494) (2,217) Expenses incurred by internal distributors (see note 3.f) (1,041) (1,056) Salary and employee benefit expense (778) (728) Taxes and contributions (86) (95) Depreciation, amortisation and impairment of property, plant and equipment and intangible assets (32) (63) Total expenses by type (4,431) (4,159) Acquisition cash flows incurred over the period 2,562 2,483 Amortisation of acquisition cash flows (2,612) (2,678) Total expenses by type adjusted for acquisition cash flows amortisation effect (4,481) (4,354) -Insurance contracts attributable expenses (see note 6.a) (3,723) (3,641) -Insurance activities non attributable costs (see note 3.f) (758) (713) Acquisition cash flows over the period are deducted from total expenses and amortised over the coverage period of the contracts. 6.c I NVESTMENTS, OTHER ASSETS AND FINANCIAL LIABILITIES RELATED TO INSURANCE ACTIVITIES  Investments and other assets related to insurance activities In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Derivative financial instruments 1,658 1,728 Derivatives used for hedging purposes 36 - Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss 156,758 143,985 Financial assets at fair value through equity 89,139 89,025 Financial assets at amortised cost 1,267 1,153 Investment properties 7,491 8,819 Equity-method investments 89 114 Assets related to insurance activities (note 6.d) 660 651 Investments and other assets related to insurance activities 257,098 245,475 • Financial liabilities related to insurance activities “Financial liabilities related to insurance activities” comprise unit-linked investment contracts without discretionary participating features. Those contracts are measured under IFRS 9 at fair value through profit or loss. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Derivative financial instruments 1,138 1,502 Derivatives used for hedging purposes 152 348 Deposit at fair value through profit or loss 1,063 1,148 Debt representative of shares of consolidated funds held by third parties 5,802 5,675 Investment contracts without discretionary participation feature - Unit-linked contracts 8,427 8,255 Other debts 1,657 1,930 Financial liabilities related to insurance activities 18,239 18,858 -- 101 of 130 -- - 102 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Measurement of the fair value of financial instruments The criteria for allocating instruments to each level of the fair value hierarchy, the measurement methods, and the principles governing transfers between levels are those presented in note 5.d for the Group’s financial instruments. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total Financial assets designated as at fair value through profit or loss 85,585 56,294 14,879 156,758 83,905 46,913 13,167 143,985 Equity instruments 79,269 41,846 14,779 135,894 77,484 34,083 13,127 124,694 Debt securities 6,316 13,740 41 20,097 6,421 12,317 24 18,762 Loans 708 59 767 513 16 529 Financial assets at fair value through equity 81,018 8,106 15 89,139 80,167 8,663 195 89,025 Equity instruments 646 646 210 210 Debt securities 80,372 8,106 15 88,493 79,957 8,663 195 88,815 Derivative financial instruments 2 1,678 14 1,694 - 1,709 19 1,728 FINANCIAL ASSETS MEASURED AT FAIR VALUE 166,605 66,078 14,908 247,591 164,072 57,285 13,381 234,738 Financial liabilities designated at fair value through profit or loss 8,741 5,923 628 15,292 7,205 7,213 660 15,078 Deposit at fair value through profit or loss 1,063 1,063 1,148 1,148 Debt representative of shares of consolidated funds held by third parties 2,625 3,177 5,802 1,881 3,794 5,675 Investment contracts without discretionary participation feature - Unit-linked contracts 6,116 1,683 628 8,427 5,324 2,271 660 8,255 Derivative financial instruments 127 977 186 1,290 - 1,485 365 1,850 FINANCIAL LIABILITIES MEASURED AT FAIR VALUE 8,868 6,900 814 16,582 7,205 8,698 1,025 16,928 Level 1 includes notably equity securities and liquid bonds, derivative instruments traded on organised markets (futures, options, etc.), shares of funds and UCITS, for which the net asset value is calculated on a daily basis. Level 2 includes equity securities, government bonds, corporate debt securities, shares of funds and UCITS, and over-the-counter derivative. Level 3 includes units of funds and unlisted equity shares which are mainly company shares and venture capital. -- 102 of 130 -- - 103 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Table of movements in level 3 financial instruments For financial instruments in Level 3, the following variations occurred during the period: In millions of euros Financial assets Financial liabilities Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss Financial assets at fair value through equity Total Financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss Total At 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 13,186 195 13,381 (1,025) (1,025) Purchases 2,179 9 2,188 - - Sales (771) (47) (818) - - Settlements (194) - (194) 214 214 Transfers to Level 3 1,193 - 1,193 - - Transfers from Level 3 (569) (136) (705) - - Gains recognised in profit or loss (129) - (129) - - Items related to exchange rate movement (2) - (2) (3) (3) Changes in fair value of assets and liabilities recognised in equity - (6) (6) - - At 31 December 2023 14,893 15 14,908 (814) (814) • Financial assets at fair value through equity In millions of euros, at 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Fair value of which changes in value recognised directly to equity Fair Value of which changes in value recognised directly to equity Debt securities 88,493 (5,154) 88,815 (10,261) Equity securities 646 70 210 11 Total financial assets at fair value through equity 89,139 (5,084) 89,025 (10,250) The option to recognise certain equity instruments at fair value through equity was retained in particular for shares held through strategic partnerships and shares that the Group is required to hold in order to carry out certain activities. During the year ended 31 December 2023, the Group sold several of these investments and a net gain of EUR 26 million was transferred to “retained earnings” (EUR 59 million for the year ended at 31 December 2022). • Investment properties fair value The fair value of investment properties amounts to EUR 7.5 billion at 31 December 2023, compared with EUR 8.8 billion at 31 December 2022. The entire non-listed real estate portfolio is appraised by one or more independent third parties. Experts have professional rules for carrying out these assessments. For buildings that are directly held, experts use three main methods: - the method by which similar transactions are compared; - the rate of return method (rate applied to a rental basis); - the discounted cash flows method. The final value retained by the expert may be a compromise between these three methods. -- 103 of 130 -- - 104 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 6.d ASSETS AND LIABILITIES RELATED TO INSURANCE CONTRACTS The main insurance contracts issued by the Group are: - contracts covering risks related to persons or property: creditor protection insurance (CPI), personal protection insurance and other non-life risks, and reinsurance contracts accepted from other insurers for these types of risks. These contracts are measured under the general model (building block approach - BBA) or the premium allocation approach (PAA) for contracts with a duration of at most one year; - life or savings contracts: single and multi-support contracts, with or without insurance risk, including a discretionary participation, and unit-linked contracts with a minimum coverage in the event of death. These contracts are measured under the variable fee approach (VFA). The insurance contracts issued by BNP Paribas Group entities cover risks of death (guarantees in the event of death), longevity (guarantees in the event of life, for example life annuities), morbidity (guarantees in the event of disability), disability, health (medical coverage), unemployment, civil liability, and property damage. Life or savings contracts are considered to be insurance contracts if they include a survival risk (in the case of retirement contracts with a mandatory annuity) or a death risk (in the case of unit-linked contracts with a minimum death guarantee and savings contracts with a guarantee of an additional amount in the case of death). Savings contracts invested in a euro fund, and multi-support contracts invested in unit-linked assets and in a euro fund are considered as investment contracts with discretionary participating features under the variable fee approach. Insurance and reinsurance contracts issued and reinsurance contracts held are presented on the assets or liabilities side of the balance sheet according to the overall position of the portfolios to which they belong. 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 In millions of euros Assets Liabilities Net (Assets) or Liabilities Assets Liabilities Net (Assets) or Liabilities Insurance contracts not measured under the premium allocation approach 22 215,689 215,667 8 207,543 207,535 Insurance contracts measured under the premium allocation approach 84 2,354 2,270 126 2,142 2,016 Reinsurance contracts held 554 (554) 517 87 (430) Assets and liabilities related to insurance contracts 660 218,043 217,383 651 209,772 209,121 -- 104 of 130 -- - 105 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Tables below show movements in carrying amounts of insurance contracts and do not include reinsurance contracts held. • Movements in carrying amounts of insurance contracts - remaining coverage and incurred claims Insurance contracts issued, excluding reinsurance contracts In millions of euros Remaining coverage Incurred claims Total net liabilities excluding loss component loss component NET (ASSETS) OR LIABILITIES AT 1 JANUARY 2022 236,471 93 3,354 239,918 Insurance service result: (income) or expenses (24,419) 60 21,793 (2,566) of which insurance revenue (8,759) (8,759) of which insurance service expenses 2,381 60 3,752 6,193 of which investment component (18,041) 18,041 - Net finance (income) or expenses from insurance contracts (2) (29,773) (172) (29,945) Total changes recognised in profit and loss and in equity (54,192) 60 21,621 (32,511) Premiums received for insurance contracts issued 25,895 25,895 Insurance acquisition cash flows (2,186) (2,186) Claims and other service expenses paid (21,997) (21,997) Total cash flows 23,709 - (21,997) 1,712 Other movements (551) (1) 984 432 NET (ASSETS) OR LIABILITIES AT 31 DECEMBER 2022 (1) 205,437 152 3,962 209,551 Insurance service result: (income) or expenses (30,502) 23 27,887 (2,592) of which insurance revenue (8,945) (8,945) of which insurance service expenses 2,335 23 3,995 6,353 of which investment component (23,892) 23,892 - Net finance (income) or expenses from insurance contracts (2) 14,617 2 65 14,684 Total changes recognised in profit and loss and in equity (15,885) 25 27,952 12,092 Premiums received for insurance contracts issued 26,128 26,128 Insurance acquisition cash flows (2,285) (2,285) Claims and other service expenses paid (27,454) (27,454) Total cash flows 23,843 - (27,454) (3,611) Other movements (371) (7) 283 (95) NET (ASSETS) OR LIABILITIES AT 31 DECEMBER 2023 (1) 213,024 170 4,743 217,937 (1) Including receivables and liabilities attributable to insurance contracts for a net asset of EUR 549 million at 31 December 2023, compared to a net asset of EUR 501 million at 31 December 2022. (2) Including finance income and expenses recognised directly in equity. -- 105 of 130 -- - 106 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Movements in carrying amounts of insurance contracts not measured under the premium allocation approach – analysis by measurement component Insurance contracts issued not measured under the premium allocation approach, excluding reinsurance contracts In millions of euros Present value of future cash flows Non-financial risk adjustment Contractual service margin Total NET (ASSETS) OR LIABILITIES AT 1 JANUARY 2022 217,803 1,260 18,598 237,661 Insurance service result: (income) or expenses (372) (172) (1,493) (2,037) of which changes related to future services - new contracts (1,587) 99 1,551 63 of which changes related to future services - change in estimation 1,387 (160) (1,217) 10 of which changes related to current service (2) (34) (77) (1,827) (1,938) of which changes related to past service (138) (34) (172) Net finance (income) or expenses from insurance contracts (3) (29,882) (39) 36 (29,885) Total changes recognised in profit and loss and in equity (30,254) (211) (1,457) (31,922) Premiums received for insurance contracts issued 22,690 22,690 Insurance acquisition cash flows (911) (911) Claims and other service expenses paid (20,557) (20,557) Total cash flows 1,222 - - 1,222 Other movements 651 (1) (76) 574 NET (ASSETS) OR LIABILITIES AT 31 DECEMBER 2022 (1) 189,422 1,048 17,065 207,535 Insurance service result: (income) or expenses (1,674) 550 (839) (1,963) of which changes related to future services - new contracts (1,164) 90 1,107 33 of which changes related to future services - change in estimation (447) 602 (121) 34 of which changes related to current service (2) 32 (103) (1,825) (1,896) of which changes related to past service (95) (39) (134) Net finance (income) or expenses from insurance contracts (3) 14,510 8 51 14,569 Total changes recognised in profit and loss and in equity 12,836 558 (788) 12,606 Premiums received for insurance contracts issued 22,621 22,621 Insurance acquisition cash flows (892) (892) Claims and other service expenses paid (25,994) (25,994) Total cash flows (4,265) - - (4,265) Other movements (204) (3) (2) (209) NET (ASSETS) OR LIABILITIES AT 31 DECEMBER 2023 (1) 197,789 1,603 16,275 215,667 (1) Including receivables and liabilities attributable to insurance contracts for a net asset of EUR 501 million at 31 December 2023, compared to a net asset of EUR 504 million at 31 December 2022. (2) Including an experience adjustment that amounted to +EUR 38 million for the year ended 2023 and to -EUR 33 million for the year ended 2022. (3) Including finance income and expenses recognised directly in equity. -- 106 of 130 -- - 107 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Expected amortisation schedule for the contractual service margin The schedule presents the amortisation of the contractual service margin to be recognised over time in profit or loss for protection contracts under the general model and for saving contracts under the variable fee approach. For the latter, it considers the over performance of financial assets compared to a risk-neutral measurement. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Less than 5 years 6,734 6,793 5 to 10 years 5,183 4,709 More than 10 years 4,358 5,563 TOTAL 16,275 17,065 • Discount rates and adjustment for non-financial risk The table below presents the average discount rates used in the measurement of savings and protection contracts for the main horizons of the euro curve. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Savings Protection Savings Protection 1 year 4.00% 3.36% 3.64% 2.67% 5 years 2.96% 2.32% 3.60% 2.92% 10 years 3.03% 2.39% 3.56% 3.07% 15 years 3.10% 2.47% 3.50% 3.07% 20 years 3.04% 2.41% 3.29% 2.85% 40 years 3.04% 3.10% The difference between the Savings and Protection yield curves is equal to that of their respective illiquidity premium. - For savings contracts measured under the variable fee approach, the discounting rate consists of the risk-free rate, extrapolated over the duration exceeding the period for which observable data are available and adjusted for a liquidity premium determined based on the underlying assets and reflecting the illiquidity of liabilities. The risk adjustment is determined according to the cost of capital method, including future payments and excluding massive lapses. It is measured within a confidence range of 60-70%. This one corresponds to a level of confidence of 65% at 31 December 2023 (64% at 31 December 2022). - For protection contracts measured under the general model and for liabilities for incurred claims under the simplified approach, the discounting rate consists of the risk-free rate adjusted to reflect the illiquidity of liabilities. The level of confidence used in determining the adjustment for non-financial risks for the main countries is 70% (based on the quantile method). -- 107 of 130 -- - 108 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 6.e R ISK SENSITIVITY • Market risk: rate risk and asset value variation Sensitivity of financial assets and liabilities, on the profit or loss and on equity to a variation of +/- 50bps of interest rates and to a variation of +/- 10% of the equity market and real estate market. The table below presents impacts before tax: In millions of euros 31 December 2023 Potential impact on income Potential impact on equity related to investments (1) related to insurance contracts Net impact related to investments related to insurance contracts Net impact +50 bps variation of interest rate risk (225) 206 (19) (3,662) 3,330 (332) -50 bps variation of interest rate risk 239 (220) 19 3,662 (3,330) 332 +10% variation of equity market 1,834 (1,760) 74 61 61 -10% variation of equity market (1,834) 1,760 (74) (61) (61) +10% variation of real estate market 1,062 (1,031) 31 37 37 -10% variation of real estate market (1,062) 1,031 (31) (37) (37) (1) Excepted financial assets representing unit-linked contracts. The sensitivity was measured for most significant countries, i.e. France, Italy and Luxembourg. For savings contracts measured under the variable fee approach, changes in the value of underlying financial assets are largely offset by changes in the value of liabilities, as contractual service margin is positive. Potential impacts on profit and loss and equity are mainly due to non-participating contracts and to assets backing insurance entities’ equity. • Liquidity risk The table below presents the schedule of the present value of future cash-flow for all insurance contracts excluding reinsurance. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 1 year 7,094 5,966 1 to 2 years 6,274 5,358 2 to 3 years 6,179 5,263 3 to 4 years 6,074 5,165 4 to 5 years 5,598 4,756 5 to 10 years 19,511 21,237 More than 10 years 148,819 143,321 TOTAL 199,549 191,066 -- 108 of 130 -- - 109 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 For participating contracts, amounts payable on demand correspond to surrender values of saving contracts. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Amount payable on demand Carrying amount Amount payable on demand Carrying amount Participating contracts 197,551 212,297 197,330 203,833 Non-participating contracts 70 5,640 147 5,718 TOTAL 197,621 217,937 197,477 209,551 • Underwriting risk by geographic area The table below presents liabilities related to insurance contracts, excluding reinsurance contracts, by country of issue. They include the present value of future cash-flow, the contractual service margin and the risk adjustment for non-financial risk. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 France(1) 158,470 148,401 Italy (1) 23,236 25,870 Luxembourg(1) 28,158 27,022 Other Europe(1) 1,492 1,454 Asia(1) 6,055 6,250 Latin America(2) 526 554 TOTAL 217,937 209,551 (1) Savings and protection (2) Protection only Sensitivity of underwriting risk measurement, on the profit or loss and on equity to a variation of 1% of mortality rate, of 5% of lapse rate and 5% of ultimate loss rate. Sensitivities to non-financial risks are presented excluding reinsurance contracts and assuming that all other variables remain unchanged. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 Potential impact on income Potential impact on equity Savings Mortality rates (1% increase/decrease) - - Lapse rates (5% increase/decrease) -/+2 - Protection Ultimate loss rate (5% increase/decrease) -/+94 - -- 109 of 130 -- - 110 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 7. FINANCING AND GUARANTEE COMMITMENTS 7.a F INANCING COMMITMENTS GIVEN OR RECEIVED In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Financing commitments given - to credit institutions 3,650 4,235 - to customers 365,821 382,746 Confirmed financing commitments 328,678 347,650 Other commitments given to customers 37,143 35,096 Total financing commitments given 369,471 386,981 of which stage 1 353,147 343,339 of which stage 2 14,857 18,745 of which stage 3 889 898 of which insurance activities 578 1,477 of which financing commitments given associated with assets held for sale - 22,522 Financing commitments received - from credit institutions 69,596 66,554 - from customers 3,185 2,221 Total financing commitments received 72,781 68,775 of which financing commitments received associated with assets held for sale - 9,272 7.b G UARANTEE COMMITMENTS GIVEN BY SIGNATURE 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 In millions of euros Guarantee commitments given - to credit institutions 63,132 60,357 - to customers 127,203 118,427 Property guarantees 2,403 2,285 Sureties provided to tax and other authorities, other sureties 66,791 65,294 Other guarantees 58,009 50,848 Total guarantee commitments given 190,335 178,784 of which stage 1 177,315 165,549 of which stage 2 11,701 12,120 of which stage 3 769 820 of which insurance activities 550 295 The Group’s annual contribution to the European Union’s Single Resolution Fund may be partly in the form of an irrevocable payment commitment (IPC) guaranteed by a cash deposit of the same amount. Where the resolution of an institution involves the fund, the fund may call all or part of the IPC received. The irrevocable payment commitment is qualified as contingent liabilities. A provision is established if the probability of a commitment call by the fund exceeds 50%. Since this probability is estimated to be below this threshold, no provision was recognised by the Group at 31 December 2023. These commitments amounted to EUR 1,261 million at 31 December 2023 (compared with EUR 969 million at 31 December 2022). Cash provided as collateral is remunerated and recognised as a financial asset at amortised cost. -- 110 of 130 -- - 111 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 7.c SECURITIES COMMITMENTS In connection with the settlement date accounting for securities, commitments representing securities to be delivered or securities to be received are the following: In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Securities to be delivered 23,159 17,325 Securities to be received 21,384 17,263 7.d O THER GUARANTEE COMMITMENTS • Financial instruments given as collateral In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Financial instruments (negotiable securities and private receivables) lodged with central banks and eligible for use at any time as collateral for refinancing transactions after haircut 87,881 132,938 - Used as collateral with central banks 20,560 67,792 - Available for refinancing transactions 67,321 65,146 Securities sold under repurchase agreements 519,731 371,552 Other financial and similar assets pledged as collateral for transactions with credit institutions, financial customers or subscribers of covered bonds issued by the Group (1) 323,491 239,761 (1)Notably including "Société de Financement de l’Économie Française" and "Caisse de Refinancement de l’Habitat" financing. The fair value of financial instruments given as collateral or transferred under repurchase agreements by the Group that the beneficiary is authorised to sell or reuse as collateral amounted to EUR 726,703 million at 31 December 2023 (EUR 523,321 million at 31 December 2022). • Financial instruments received as collateral In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Financial instruments received as collateral (excluding repurchase agreements) 350,947 326,198 of which instruments that the Group is authorised to sell and reuse as collateral 187,021 192,274 Securities received under repurchase agreements 467,822 336,799 The fair value of financial instruments received as collateral or under repurchase agreements that the Group effectively sold or reused as collateral amounted to EUR 377,078 million at 31 December 2023 (compared with EUR 307,886 million at 31 December 2022). -- 111 of 130 -- - 112 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 8. SALARIES AND EMPLOYEE BENEFITS 8.a SALARY AND EMPLOYEE BENEFIT EXPENSE In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS17 and 9 Fixed and variable remuneration, incentive bonuses and profit-sharing 13,445 12,995 Employee benefit expense 3,856 3,429 Payroll taxes 474 453 Total salary and employee benefit expense for banking activities (note 3.f) 17,775 16,877 Salary and employee benefit expense of insurance activities (note 6.b) 778 728 Total salary and employee benefit expense 18,553 17,605 8.b P OST - EMPLOYMENT BENEFITS IAS 19 distinguishes between two categories of plans, each handled differently depending on the risk incurred by the entity. When the entity is only committed to paying a fixed amount, stated as a percentage of the beneficiary's annual salary, for example, to an external entity handling payment of the benefits based on the assets available for each plan member, it is described as a defined-contribution plan. Conversely, when the entity's obligation is to manage the financial assets funded through the collection of contributions from employees and to bear the cost of benefits itself or to guarantee the final amount subject to future events, it is described as a defined-benefit plan. The same applies if the entity entrusts management of the collection of premiums and payment of benefits to a separate entity but retains the risk arising from management of the assets and/or from future changes in the benefits. • Main Defined-contribution pension plans for Group entities The BNP Paribas Group has implemented over the past few years a wide campaign of converting defined-benefit plans into defined-contribution plans. Thus, in France, the BNP Paribas Group pays contributions to mandatory state and complementary pension schemes. BNP Paribas SA and certain subsidiaries have set up a complementary defined-contribution pension plan under a company-wide agreement. Under this plan, employees will receive an annuity or a lump sum on retirement in addition to the pension paid by mandatory schemes. Since defined-benefit plans have been closed to new employees in most countries outside France, they are offered the benefit of joining defined-contribution pension plans. In Italy, the plan introduced by BNL is funded by employer contributions (4.2% of salaries) and employee contributions (2% of salaries). Employees can also make additional voluntary contributions. In the United Kingdom, the employer contributes 12% of salaries for the majority of employees; employees can make additional voluntary contributions. In the US, the bank matches the voluntary contributions made by employees, within certain limits. The amount paid into defined-contribution post-employment plans for the year ended 31 December 2023 was EUR 791 million, compared with EUR 720 million for the year ended 31 December 2022 (including amount paid by entities which are insurance companies). -- 112 of 130 -- - 113 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The breakdown by major contributors is determined as follows: Contribution amount In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 France 386 353 Italy 106 90 UK 62 64 Türkiye 39 26 Hong Kong 29 26 Luxembourg 30 28 USA 27 25 Others 112 108 TOTAL 791 720 • Main defined-benefit pension plans for Group entities and indemnities payable on retirement - Defined-benefit plans In Belgium, BNP Paribas Fortis funds a defined-benefit plan, based on final salary and number of years of service, for its management and employees who joined the bank before its pension plans were harmonised on 1 January 2002. Actuarial liabilities under this scheme are pre-funded at 91% at 31 December 2023 (compared with 88% at 31 December 2022) through insurance companies. BNP Paribas Fortis senior managers joining before 1 January 2015 are covered by a top-up pension plan, paying a lump sum based on the number of years of service and final salary. This plan is pre-funded at 94% at 31 December 2023 (90% at 31 December 2022) through insurance companies. In Belgium, employees benefit from a defined-contribution scheme with a legal obligation for the employer to guarantee a minimum return on financial assets invested. Thus, a provision was recognised for these schemes, as this guarantee is not entirely covered by the insurance company. In France, BNP Paribas pays a top-up banking industry pension arising from rights acquired to 31 December 1993 by retired employees and active employees in service at that date. At 31 December 2023, the Group's residual obligations for these employees were recognised on the balance sheet in full. The defined-benefit plans previously granted to some Group senior managers have all been closed to new employees and converted into top-up type schemes. The amounts allocated to residual beneficiaries, subject to their presence within the Group at retirement, were fixed when these schemes were closed. At 31 December 2023, these pension plans were funded at 264% through insurance companies (221% at 31 December 2022). In the United Kingdom, defined-benefit pension plans (pension funds) still exist but are closed to new employees. Under these plans, the defined pension is generally based on final salary and number of years of service. Pension schemes are managed by independent management bodies (Trustees). At 31 December 2023, obligations for all UK entities were 118% covered by financial assets, compared with 125% at 31 December 2022. In Switzerland, liabilities relate to top-up pension plans based on the principle of defined-contribution schemes with guaranteed returns, paying an annuity under pre-defined terms. These schemes are managed by a foundation. At 31 December 2023, obligations were 111% covered by financial assets, compared with 121% at 31 December 2022. -- 113 of 130 -- - 114 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 In the United States, defined-benefit pension plans are based on annual vesting rights to a lump sum comprising a pension expressed as a percentage of annual salary and paying interest at a pre-defined rate. These plans are closed to new entrants and have offered almost no new vesting rights. At 31 December 2023, the obligation was 87% covered by financial assets, (85% at 31 December 2022). In Germany, liabilities are mainly related to defined-benefit pension plans, closed to new employees. Under these plans, the defined pension is generally based on the number of years of service and final salary. They offer the payment of an annuity under pre-defined terms. At 31 December 2023, the obligation was 66% covered by financial assets, (70% at 31 December 2022). In Türkiye, the main pension plan replaces the national pension scheme and should eventually be transferred to the Turkish State. This plan offers guarantees exceeding the minimal legal requirements. At the end of 2023, obligations under this plan are fully funded by financial assets held with an external foundation; these financial assets exceeding the related obligations, this surplus is not recognised as an asset by the Group. - Other post-employment benefits Group employees also receive various other contractual post-employment benefits, such as indemnities payable on retirement, determined according to minimal legal requirements (Labour Code, collective agreements) or according to specific company-level agreements. In France, the obligations for these benefits are funded through a contract held with a third-party insurer. At 31 December 2023, this obligation was 127% covered by financial assets, compared with 132% at 31 December 2022. The law of 14 April 2023 changed the age and quarters criteria required to settle pension rights. The specificities of this law have been taken into account for the determination of the present value of the obligation under IFRS, with a decrease impact of its value of 22 million euros. In other countries, the obligations of the Group related to other post-employment benefits are mainly concentrated in Italy, where vested rights up to 31 December 2006 were frozen. -- 114 of 130 -- - 115 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Obligations under defined-benefit pension plans and indemnities payable on retirement - Assets and liabilities recognised on the balance sheet In millions of euros, at 31 December 2023 Defined-benefit obligation arising from wholly or partially funded plans Defined-benefit obligation arising from unfunded plans Present value of defined- benefit obligation Fair value of plan assets Fair value of reimburse- ment rights (1) Effect of asset ceiling Net obligation of which asset recognised in the balance sheet for defined- benefit plans of which net assets of defined- benefit plans of which fair value of reimburse- ment rights of which obligation recognised in the balance sheet for defined-benefit plans Belgium 2,830 2,830 (152) (2,502) 176 (2,502) (2,502) 2,678 UK 1,158 1,158 (1,365) (207) (209) (209) 2 Switzerland 1,123 1,123 (1,251) 130 2 2 France 856 52 908 (1,134) (226) (331) (331) 105 USA 146 1 147 (127) 20 (4) (4) 24 Türkiye 235 43 278 (258) 22 42 42 Italy 164 164 164 164 Germany 129 49 178 (118) 60 60 Others 334 47 381 (269) (1) 1 112 (9) (8) (1) 121 TOTAL 6,811 356 7,167 (4,674) (2,503) 153 143 (3,055) (552) (2,503) 3,198 In millions of euros, at 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Defined-benefit obligation arising from wholly or partially funded plans Defined-benefit obligation arising from unfunded plans Present value of defined- benefit obligation Fair value of plan assets Fair value of reimburse- ment rights (1) Effect of asset ceiling Net obligation of which asset recognised in the balance sheet for defined- benefit plans of which net assets of defined- benefit plans of which fair value of reimburse- ment rights of which obligation recognised in the balance sheet for defined-benefit plans Belgium 2,738 2,738 (124) (2,395) 219 (2,395) (2,395) 2,614 UK 1,067 1,067 (1,334) (267) (267) (267) Switzerland 979 979 (1,185) 208 2 2 France 845 62 907 (1,157) (250) (346) (346) 96 USA 467 64 531 (458) 73 (24) (24) 97 Türkiye 139 63 202 (295) 157 64 64 Italy 182 182 182 182 Germany 93 45 138 (98) 40 (7) (7) 47 Others 379 51 430 (313) (2) 2 117 (13) (11) (2) 130 TOTAL 6,707 467 7,174 (4,964) (2,397) 367 180 (3,052) (655) (2,397) 3,232 of which continuing activities 6,391 404 6,795 (4,635) (2,397) 367 130 (3,030) (633) (2,397) 3,160 of which discontinued activities 316 63 379 (329) - - 50 (22) (22) - 72 (1) The reimbursement rights are principally found on the balance sheet of the Group’s insurance subsidiaries and associated companies - notably AG Insurance with respect to BNP Paribas Fortis’ defined-benefit plan - to hedge their commitments to other Group entities that were transferred to them to cover the post-employment benefits of certain employee categories. -- 115 of 130 -- - 116 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 - Change in the present value of the defined-benefit obligation including discontinued activities In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Present value of defined-benefit obligation at start of period 7,174 9,060 Current service cost 181 215 Interest cost 236 100 Past service cost (25) (5) Settlements (15) (11) Actuarial (gains)/losses on change in demographic assumptions (11) 10 Actuarial (gains)/losses on change in financial assumptions 203 (1,985) Actuarial (gains)/losses on experience gaps 330 341 Actual employee contributions 24 23 Benefits paid directly by the employer (87) (101) Benefits paid from assets/reimbursement rights (453) (489) Exchange rate (gains)/losses on obligation (41) (25) (Gains)/losses on obligation related to changes in the consolidation scope (349) 41 Present value of defined-benefit obligation at end of period 7,167 7,174 - Change in the fair value of plan assets and reimbursement rights including discontinued activities Plan assets Reimbursement rights In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Fair value of assets at start of period 4,964 6,082 2,397 2,932 Expected return on assets 169 99 84 13 Settlements (14) (21) Actuarial gains/(losses) on assets 10 (938) 99 (548) Actual employee contributions 14 13 10 10 Employer contributions 60 54 131 198 Benefits paid from assets (234) (257) (219) (232) Exchange rate gains/(losses) on assets (36) (64) Gains/(losses) on assets related to changes in the consolidation scope (259) (4) 1 24 Fair value of assets at end of period 4,674 4,964 2,503 2,397 - Components of the cost of defined-benefit plans In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Service costs 155 220 Current service cost 181 215 Past service cost (25) (5) Settlements (1) 10 Net financial expense 1 6 Interest cost 236 100 Interest income on plan asset 18 18 Interest income on reimbursement rights (169) (99) Expected return on asset ceiling (84) (13) Total recognised in “Salary and employee benefit expense” 156 226 of which continuing activities 156 222 of which discontinued activities - 4 -- 116 of 130 -- - 117 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 - Other items recognised directly in equity In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Actuarial (losses)/gains on plan assets or reimbursement rights 109 (1,486) Actuarial (losses)/gains of demographic assumptions on the present value of obligations 11 (10) Actuarial (losses)/gains of financial assumptions on the present value of obligations (203) 1,985 Experience (losses)/gains on obligations (330) (341) Variation of the effect of assets limitation 216 (263) Total of other items recognised directly in equity (197) (115) of which continuing activities (197) (127) of which discontinued activities - 12 - Main actuarial assumptions used to calculate obligations In the eurozone, United Kingdom and United States, the Group discounts its obligations using the yields of high quality corporate bonds, with a term consistent with the duration of the obligations. The ranges of rates used are as follows: In % 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Discount rate Compensation increase rate (1) Discount rate Compensation increase rate (1) Belgium 3.00% / 3.60% 3.30% / 4.10% 1.90% / 3.80% 3.30% / 5.00% UK 4.40% / 5.30% 2.00% / 3.40% 3.50% / 4.90% 2.00% / 3.30% France 3.00% / 3.60% 2.90% / 3.10% 3.30% / 3.80% 2.10% / 3.65% Switzerland 1.40% / 1.60% 1.80% / 2.00% 2.00% / 2.15% 1.75% / 2.00% USA 4.70% / 5.30% 2.50% 4.90% / 5.00% 2.50% Italy 3.00% / 3.60% 3.00% / 3.10% 1.90% / 3.60% 2.10% / 3.20% Germany 3.20% / 3.70% 2.00% / 2.90% 2.30% / 3.80% 2.00% / 2.90% Türkiye 23.10% 18.80% 10.60% 8.50% (1) Including price increases (inflation) Average discount rates weighted by obligation amounts are as follows: - In the eurozone: 3.16% at 31 December 2023 (3.54% at 31 December 2022); - In the United Kingdom: 4.51% at 31 December 2023 (4.78% at 31 December 2022); - In Switzerland: 1.40% at 31 December 2023 (2.15% at 31 December 2022). The impact of a 100-bps change in discount rates on the present value of post-employment benefit obligations is as follows: Change in the present value of obligations In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Discount rate -100bps Discount rate +100bps Discount rate -100bps Discount rate +100bps Belgium 231 (168) 201 (175) UK 170 (137) 187 (147) France 88 (75) 92 (78) Switzerland 148 (119) 133 (107) USA 15 (13) 18 (15) Italy 10 (9) 12 (11) Germany 27 (21) 26 (20) Türkiye 11 (9) 13 (10) -- 117 of 130 -- - 118 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Inflation assumptions used for the valuations of the Group obligations are determined locally depending on the monetary area, except for the eurozone for which the assumption is determined centrally. Average discount rates weighted by obligation amounts are as follows: - In the eurozone: 2.27% at 31 December 2023 (2.43% at 31 December 2022); - In the United Kingdom: 2.94% at 31 December 2023 (3.03% at 31 December 2022); - In Switzerland: 1.25% at 31 December 2023 (1.25% at 31 December 2022). The impact of a +100-bps increase in inflation rates on the present value of post-employment benefit obligations is as follows: Change in the present value of obligations In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Inflation rate +100bps Inflation rate +100bps Belgium 133 148 UK 100 126 France 88 92 Switzerland 8 8 Italy 7 8 Germany 16 14 Türkiye 11 12 Variation effects of discount and inflation rates presented above are not cumulative. - Actual rate of return on plan assets and reimbursement rights over the period In % Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Range of value (reflecting the existence of several plans in the same country) Weighted average rates Range of value (reflecting the existence of several plans in the same country) Weighted average rates Belgium -0.20% / 13.20% 6.45% -18.75% / 6.30% -12.65% UK -10.50% / 5.40% 0.50% -38.30% / 0% -34.60% France 2.60% 2.60% 2.60% 2.60% Switzerland 1.70% / 2.50% 2.50% -15.85% / 1% 0.50% USA 1.65% / 5.45% 5.25% -29.75% / -16.75% -28.90% Germany -2.85% / 11.50% 9.30% -26.15% / 1.30% -11.20% Türkiye 44.90% 44.90% 40.80% 40.80% -- 118 of 130 -- - 119 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 - Breakdown of plan assets In % 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Shares Governme ntal bonds Non- Governme ntal bonds Real- estate Deposit account Others Shares Governme ntal bonds Non- Governme ntal bonds Real- estate Deposit account Others Belgium 8% 46% 19% 1% 2% 24% 8% 48% 20% 1% 0% 23% UK 12% 62% 16% 0% 2% 8% 7% 65% 13% 0% 2% 13% France(1) 8% 59% 18% 13% 2% 0% 8% 60% 18% 13% 1% 0% Switzerland 29% 0% 26% 25% 4% 16% 32% 0% 23% 21% 3% 20% USA 17% 24% 45% 0% 13% 1% 19% 18% 58% 0% 1% 4% Germany 22% 52% 0% 0% 0% 26% 25% 64% 0% 0% 3% 9% Türkiye 0% 68% 0% 6% 21% 5% 0% 59% 0% 3% 30% 7% Others 9% 22% 12% 1% 2% 54% 10% 18% 12% 2% 2% 57% GROUP 12% 43% 19% 7% 3% 16% 12% 44% 18% 6% 2% 18% (1) In France, the breakdown of plan assets reflects the breakdown of the general fund of the insurance company through which the Group's obligations are funded. The Group introduced an asset management governance for assets backing defined-benefit pension plan commitments, the main objectives of which are the management and control of the risks in terms of investment. It sets out investment principles, in particular, by defining an investment strategy for plan assets, based on financial objectives and risk management, to specify the way in which plan assets have to be managed, via financial management servicing contracts. The investment strategy is based on an assets and liabilities management analysis that should be realised at least every three years for plans with assets in excess of EUR 100 million. • Post-employment healthcare benefits The Group offers some healthcare benefit plans for retired employees, mainly in Belgium. The present value of post-employment healthcare benefit obligations stood at EUR 78 million at 31 December 2023, compared with EUR 83 million at 31 December 2022. 8.c OTHER LONG-TERM BENEFITS BNP Paribas offers its employees various long-term benefits, mainly long-service awards, the ability to save up paid annual leave in time savings accounts, and certain guarantees protecting them in the event they become incapacitated. The net provision amounted to EUR 462 million at 31 December 2023 (EUR 453 million at 31 December 2022). As part of the Group’s variable compensation policy, annual deferred compensation plans are set up for certain high-performing employees or pursuant to special regulatory frameworks. Under these plans, payment is deferred over time and is subject to the performance achieved by the business lines, divisions and Group. Since 2013, BNP Paribas has introduced a Group loyalty scheme with a cash payment, at the end of a three-year to four-year vesting period, which fluctuates according to the Group’s intrinsic performance. The aim of this loyalty scheme is to make different categories of managerial staff partners in the Group’s development and profitability objectives. These personnels are representative of the Group’s talent and the breadth of its managerial framework i.e., senior managers, managers in key positions, line managers and experts, high-potential managers, high- performing young executives with good career development prospects and key contributors to the Group’s results. -- 119 of 130 -- - 120 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The amounts allocated under this plan are linked to changes in the Group’s operational performance over the duration of the plan (for 80%) and to the achievement of the Group’s Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) targets (for 20%). These ten targets are in line with the four pillars on which the Group’s CSR policy is based. In addition, the final payment is subject to continuous service within the Group between the grant date and the payment date, provided that the Group’s operating income and pre-tax income for the year prior to payment are strictly positive. For employees subject to special regulatory frameworks, this loyalty scheme is adjusted in accordance with the CRD European Directive. The net obligation related to deferred compensation plans and loyalty schemes amounts to EUR 1,033 million at 31 December 2023 (EUR 1,017 million at 31 December 2022). In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Net provisions for other long-term benefits 1,495 1,470 Asset recognised in the balance sheet under the other long-term benefits (76) (76) Obligation recognised in the balance sheet under the other long-term benefits 1,571 1,546 8.d T ERMINATION BENEFITS BNP Paribas has implemented a number of voluntary redundancy plans and headcount adaptation plans for employees who meet certain eligibility criteria. The obligations to eligible active employees under such plans are provided for as soon as a bilateral agreement or a bilateral agreement proposal for a particular plan is made. In 2023, BNP Paribas Personal Finance subgroup implemented a voluntary departure plan in France in respect of which a provision of EUR 215 million was established. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Provision for voluntary departure, early retirement plans, and headcount adaptation plans 482 270 8.e SHARE- BASED PAYMENTS As part of the Group’s variable remuneration policy, deferred annual compensation plans offered to certain high- performing employees or set up pursuant to special regulatory frameworks may entitle beneficiaries to variable compensation settled in cash but linked to the share price, payable over several years. - Variable compensation for employees, subject to special regulatory frameworks Since the publication of the Decree by the French Ministry of Finance on 13 December 2010, and following the provisions of the European Directive CRD 4 of 26 July 2013, modified by the CRD 5 Directive of 20 May 2019, transposed into the French law in the Monetary and Financial Code by the Ordinance of 20 February 2014, and the Ordinance of 21 December 2020, as well as the Decrees and Orders of 3 November 2014 and 22 December 2020 and the delegated European regulation of 25 March 2021, the variable compensation plans apply to Group employees performing activities that may have a material impact on the Group’s risk profile. -- 120 of 130 -- - 121 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Under these plans, payment is deferred over time and is contingent on the performance achieved by the business lines, core businesses and Group. Sums will mostly be paid in cash linked to the increase or decrease in the BNP Paribas share price. - Deferred variable compensation for other Group employees Sums due under the annual deferred compensation plans for high-performing employees are partly paid in cash linked to the increase or decrease in the BNP Paribas share price.  Expense of share-based payments Expense / (revenue) in millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Prior deferred compensation plans 48 (116) Deferred compensation plans for the year 541 614 Total 589 498 -- 121 of 130 -- - 122 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 9. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 9.a C HANGES IN SHARE CAPITAL AND EARNINGS PER SHARE At 31 December 2023, the share capital of BNP Paribas SA amounts to EUR 2,294,954,818 and was divided into 1,147,447,409 shares. The nominal value of each share is EUR 2 (compared to 1,234,331,646 at 31 December 2022). • Ordinary shares issued by BNP Paribas and held by the Group Proprietary transactions Trading transactions (1) Total Number of shares Carrying amount (in millions of euros) Number of shares Carrying amount (in millions of euros) Number of shares Carrying amount (in millions of euros) Shares held at 31 December 2021 721,971 38 - - 721,971 38 Net movements 159,670 8 159,670 8 Shares held at 31 December 2022 721,971 38 159,670 8 881,641 46 Acquisitions 86,854,237 5,000 86,854,237 5,000 Capital decrease (86,854,237) (5,000) (86,854,237) (5,000) Net movements 64,888 5 64,888 5 Shares held at 31 December 2023 721,971 38 224,558 13 946,529 51 (1) Transactions realised in the framework of an activity of trading and arbitrage transactions on equity indices. Throughout the year 2023, BNP Paribas SA bought back on the market then cancelled 86,854,237 of its own shares in accordance with the decision made by the Board of Directors on 6 February 2023. At 31 December 2023, the Group holds 946,529 BNP Paribas shares representing an amount of EUR 51 million, which were deducted from equity. • Undated Super Subordinated Notes eligible as Tier 1 regulatory capital BNP Paribas SA has issued Undated Super Subordinated Notes which pay a fixed, fixed adjustable or floating-rate coupon and are redeemable at the end of a fixed period and thereafter at each coupon date or every five years. On 3 January 2022, BNP Paribas SA redeemed the July 2006 issue, for an amount of EUR 150 million. These notes paid a 5.45% fixed-rate coupon. On 12 January 2022, BNP Paribas SA issued Undated Super Subordinated Notes for an amount of USD 1,250 million which pay a 4.625% fixed-rate coupon. These notes could be redeemed at the end of a period of 5 years. If the notes are not redeemed in 2027, a US 5-year Constant Maturity Treasury rate coupon will be paid half-yearly. This issue is eligible to Additional Tier 1 capital. On 19 January 2022, BNP Paribas SA redeemed the June 2007 issue, for an amount of USD 1,100 million. These notes paid a 7.195% fixed-rate coupon. On 14 March 2022, BNP Paribas SA redeemed the December 2016 issue, for an amount of USD 750 million. These notes paid a 6.75% fixed-rate coupon. -- 122 of 130 -- - 123 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 On 17 June 2022, BNP Paribas SA redeemed the June 2015 issue, for an amount of EUR 750 million, at the first call date. These notes paid a 6.125% fixed-rate coupon. On 16 August 2022, BNP Paribas SA issued Undated Super Subordinated Notes for an amount of USD 2,000 million which pay a 7.75% fixed-rate coupon. These notes could be redeemed at the end of a period of 7 years. If the notes are not redeemed in 2029, a US 5-year Constant Maturity Treasury rate coupon will be paid half-yearly. This issue is eligible to Additional Tier 1 capital. On 6 September 2022, BNP Paribas SA issued Undated Super Subordinated Notes for an amount of EUR 1,000 million which pay a 6.875% fixed-rate coupon. These notes could be redeemed at the end of a period of 7 years and 3 months. If the notes are not redeemed in 2029, a mid-swap rate EUR 5-year coupon will be paid half-yearly. This issue is eligible to Additional Tier 1 capital. On 17 November 2022, BNP Paribas SA issued Undated Super Subordinated Notes for an amount of USD 1,000 million which pay a 9.25% fixed-rate coupon. These notes could be redeemed at the end of a period of 5 years. If the notes are not redeemed in 2027, a US 5-year Constant Maturity Treasury rate coupon will be paid half-yearly. This issue is eligible to Additional Tier 1 capital. On 11 January 2023, BNP Paribas SA issued Undated Super Subordinated Notes for an amount of EUR 1,250 million which pay a 7.375% fixed-rate coupon. These notes could be redeemed at the end of a period of 7 years. If the notes are not redeemed in 2030, a mid-swap rate EUR 5-year coupon will be paid half-yearly. This issue is eligible to Additional Tier 1 capital. On 28 February 2023, BNP Paribas SA issued Undated Super Subordinated Notes for an amount of SGD 600 million which pay a 5.9% fixed-rate coupon. These notes could be redeemed at the end of a period of 5 years. If the notes are not redeemed in 2028, a SGD SORA 5-year rate coupon will be paid half-yearly. This issue is eligible to Additional Tier 1 capital. The following table summarises the characteristics of these various issues: Date of issue Currency Amount (in millions of currency units) Coupon payment date Rate and term before 1st call date Rate after 1st call date August 2015 USD 1,500 semi-annual 7.375% 10 years USD 5-year swap + 5.150% November 2017 USD 750 semi-annual 5.125% 10 years USD 5-year swap +2.838% August 2018 USD 750 semi-annual 7.000% 10 years USD 5-year swap + 3.980% March 2019 USD 1,500 semi-annual 6.625% 5 years USD 5-year swap + 4.149% July 2019 AUD 300 semi-annual 4.500% 5.5 years AUD 5-year swap + 3.372% February 2020 USD 1,750 semi-annual 4.500% 10 years US 5-year CMT + 2.944% February 2021 USD 1,250 semi-annual 4.625% 10 years US 5-year CMT + 3.340% January 2022 USD 1,250 semi-annual 4.625% 5 years US 5-year CMT + 3.196% August 2022 USD 2,000 semi-annual 7.750% 7 years US 5-year CMT + 4.899% September 2022 EUR 1,000 semi-annual 6.875% 7.25 years EUR 5-year Mid-swap + 4.645% November 2022 USD 1,000 semi-annual 9.250% 5 years US 5-year CMT + 4.969% January 2023 EUR 1,250 semi-annual 7.375% 7 years EUR 5-year Mid-swap + 4.631% February 2023 SGD 600 semi-annual 5.900% 5 years SGD SORA 5-year + 2.674% Total euro-equivalent historical value at 31 December 2023 13,472(1) (1) Net of shares held in treasury by Group entities BNP Paribas has the option of not paying interest due on these Undated Super Subordinated Notes. Unpaid interest is not carried forward. For notes issued before 2015, the absence of coupon payment is conditional on the absence of dividend payment on BNP Paribas SA ordinary shares or on Undated Super Subordinated Note equivalents during the previous year. Interest due is payable once dividend payment on BNP Paribas SA ordinary shares resumes. -- 123 of 130 -- - 124 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 The contracts relating to these Undated Super Subordinated Notes contain a loss absorption clause. Under the terms of this clause, in the event of insufficient regulatory capital, the nominal value of the notes may be reduced in order to serve as a new basis for the calculation of the related coupons until the capital deficiency is made up and the nominal value of the notes is increased to its original amount. The proceeds from these issues are recorded in equity under “Capital and retained earnings”. In accordance with IAS 21, issues denominated in foreign currencies are recognised at their historical value based on their translation into euros at the issue date. Interest on the instruments is treated in the same way as dividends. At 31 December 2023, the BNP Paribas Group held EUR 12 million of Undated Super Subordinated Notes which were deducted from shareholders’ equity. • Earnings per share Basic earnings per share are calculated by dividing the net income for the period attributable to holders of ordinary shares by the weighted average number of ordinary shares outstanding during the period. The net income attributable to ordinary shareholders is determined by deducting the net income attributable to holders of preferred shares. Diluted earnings per share correspond to the net income for the period attributable to holders of ordinary shares, divided by the weighted average number of shares outstanding as adjusted for the maximum effect of the conversion of dilutive equity instruments into ordinary shares. In-the-money stock subscription options are taken into account in the diluted earnings per share calculation, as are performance shares granted under the Global Share-based Incentive Plan. Conversion of these instruments would have no effect on the net income figure used in this calculation. All stock option and performance share plans are expired. Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Net profit used to calculate basic and diluted earnings per ordinary share (in millions of euros) (1) 10,298 9,273 Weighted average number of ordinary shares outstanding during the year 1,200,367,337 1,232,991,607 Effect of potentially dilutive ordinary shares - - Weighted average number of ordinary shares used to calculate diluted earnings per share 1,200,367,337 1,232,991,607 Basic earnings per share (in euros) 8.58 7.52 of which continuing activities (in euros) 6.12 6.96 of which discontinued activities (in euros) 2.46 0.56 Diluted earnings per share (in euros) 8.58 7.52 of which continuing activities (in euros) 6.12 6.96 of which discontinued activities (in euros) 2.46 0.56 (1) The net profit used to calculate basic and diluted earnings per share is the net profit attributable to equity shareholders, adjusted for the remuneration on the Undated Super Subordinated Notes issued by BNP Paribas SA (treated as preferred share equivalents), which for accounting purposes is handled as dividends, as well as the related foreign exchange gain or loss impact recognised directly in shareholders' equity in case of repurchase. The Board of directors will propose to the Annual General Meeting on 14 May 2024, a dividend per share of EUR 4.60 out of the 2023 net income (against EUR 3.90 out of the 2022 net income). The proposed distribution amounted to EUR 5,274 million, against EUR 4,744 million paid in 2023. This distribution will be raised to 60% of the 2023 net income with a share buyback programme of EUR 1,055 million, subject to the customary condition precedents, including European Central Bank authorisations. -- 124 of 130 -- - 125 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 9.b M INORITY INTERESTS In millions of euros Capital and retained earnings Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity that will not be reclassified to profit or loss Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity that may be reclassified to profit or loss Minority interests Balance at 31 December 2021 4,712 15 (106) 4,621 Impacts of IAS 29 1st application in Türkiye (14) 62 48 Impacts of the transition to IFRS 17 (9) 21 12 Impacts of the transition to IFRS 9 17 (26) (9) Balance at 1 January 2022 4,706 15 (49) 4,672 Appropriation of net income for 2021 (133) (133) Increases in capital and issues 34 34 Impact of internal transactions on minority shareholders 2 2 Movements in consolidation scope impacting minority shareholders (136) (136) Change in commitments to repurchase minority shareholders’ interests (157) (157) Other movements (2) (2) Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity 6 87 93 Net income for 2022 400 400 Balance at 31 December 2022 4,714 21 38 4,773 Appropriation of net income for 2022 (179) (179) Increases in capital and issues 316 316 Share-based payment plans 1 1 Remuneration of undated super subordinated notes (3) (3) Impact of internal transactions on minority shareholders 21 21 Movements in consolidation scope impacting minority shareholders (90) (90) Acquisitions of additional interests or partial sales of interests (12) (12) Change in commitments to repurchase minority shareholders’ interests (225) (225) Other movements - Changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity (5) 97 92 Net income for 2023 431 431 Balance at 31 December 2023 4,974 16 135 5,125 -- 125 of 130 -- - 126 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023  Main minority interests The assessment of the material nature of minority interests is based on the contribution of the relevant subsidiaries to the Group balance sheet (before elimination of intra-group balances and transactions) and to the Group profit and loss account. In millions of euros 31 December 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Total assets before elimination of intra-group transactions Revenues Net income Net income and changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity Minority shareholders' interest (%) Net income attributable to minority interests Net income and changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity - attributable to minority interests Dividends paid to minority shareholders Contribution of the entities belonging to the BGL BNP Paribas group 97,504 1,922 674 766 34% 230 260 137 Other minority interests 201 263 45 TOTAL 431 523 182 In millions of euros 31 December 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Total assets before elimination of intra-group transactions Revenues Net income Net income and changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity Minority shareholders' interest (%) Net income attributable to minority interests Net income and changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity - attributable to minority interests Dividends paid to minority shareholders Contribution of the entities belonging to the BGL BNP Paribas group 95,172 1,769 587 340 34% 189 128 81 Other minority interests 211 365 52 TOTAL 400 493 133 There are no particular contractual restrictions on the assets of BGL BNP Paribas related to the presence of the minority shareholder.  Internal restructuring that led to a change in minority shareholders’ interest in the equity of subsidiaries In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Attributable to shareholders Minority interests Attributable to shareholders Minority interests TEB Finansman Internal sale of BNPP Personal Finance to TEB Holding, raising the group interest rate at 72,5%. (22) 22 Others 1 (1) 1 2 Total (21) 21 1 2 -- 126 of 130 -- - 127 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 • Acquisitions of additional interests and partial sales of interests leading to changes in minority interests in the equity of subsidiaries In millions of euros Year to 31 Dec. 2023 Year to 31 Dec. 2022 restated according to IFRS 17 and 9 Attributable to shareholders Minority interests Attributable to shareholders Minority interests Artigiancassa Spa Additional acquistion of 26,14 % of the total share, increasing the Group's share to 100 % 5 (9) Dynamic Credit Group Additional acquistion of 25 % of the total share, increasing the Group's share to 73,65 % (3) (4) Other (1) 1 Total 1 (12) - - • Commitments to repurchase minority shareholders’ interests In connection with the acquisition of certain entities, the Group granted minority shareholders put options on their holdings. The total value of these commitments, which are recorded as a reduction in shareholders’ equity, amounts to EUR 510 million at 31 December 2023, compared with EUR 361 million at 31 December 2022. 9.c L EGAL PROCEEDINGS AND ARBITRATION BNP Paribas (the “Bank”) is party as a defendant in various claims, disputes and legal proceedings (including investigations by judicial or supervisory authorities) in a number of jurisdictions arising in the ordinary course of its business, including inter alia in connection with its activities as market counterparty, lender, employer, investor and taxpayer. The related risks have been assessed by the Bank and are subject, where appropriate, to provisions disclosed in note 5.n “Provisions for contingencies and charges”; a provision is recognised when it is probable that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle an obligation arising from a past event and a reliable estimate can be made of the amount of the obligation. The main contingent liabilities related to pending legal, governmental, or arbitral proceedings as of 31 December, 2023 are described below. The Bank currently considers that none of these proceedings is likely to have a material adverse effect on its financial position or profitability; however, the outcome of legal or governmental proceedings is by definition unpredictable. The Bank and certain of its subsidiaries are defendants in several actions pending before the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York brought by the Trustee appointed for the liquidation of Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities LLC (“BLMIS”). These actions, known generally as “clawback claims”, are similar to those brought by the BLMIS Trustee under the U.S. Bankruptcy Code and New York state law against numerous institutions, and seek recovery of amounts allegedly received by BNP Paribas entities from BLMIS or indirectly through BLMIS-related “feeder funds” in which BNP Paribas entities held interests. As a result of certain decisions of the Bankruptcy Court and the United States District Court between 2016 and 2018, the majority of the BLMIS Trustee’s actions were either dismissed or substantially narrowed. However, those decisions were either reversed or effectively overruled by subsequent decisions of the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit issued on 25 February 2019 and 30 August 2021. As a result, the BLMIS Trustee refiled certain of these actions and, as of end May 2023, has asserted aggregate claims of approximately USD 1.2 billion. BNP Paribas has substantial and credible defenses to these actions and is defending against them vigorously. -- 127 of 130 -- - 128 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Litigation was brought in Belgium by minority shareholders of the previous Fortis Group against the Société fédérale de Participations et d’Investissement, Ageas and BNP Paribas seeking (amongst other things) damages from BNP Paribas as restitution for part of the BNP Paribas Fortis shares that were contributed to BNP Paribas in 2009, on the ground that the transfer of these shares was null and void. On 29 April 2016, the Brussels Commercial court decided to stay the proceedings until the resolution of the pending Fortis criminal proceeding in Belgium. The criminal proceeding, in which the Public Prosecutor had requested a dismissal, is definitively closed, as the Council Chamber of the Brussels Court of first instance issued on 4 September 2020 a ruling (which since became final) that the charges were time-barred. Certain minority shareholders are continuing the civil proceedings against BNP Paribas and the Société fédérale de Participations et d’Investissement before the Brussels Commercial court; BNP Paribas continues to defend itself vigorously against the allegations of these shareholders. On 26 February 2020, the Paris Criminal Court found BNP Paribas Personal Finance guilty of misleading commercial practice and concealment of this practice. BNP Paribas Personal Finance was ordered to pay a fine of EUR 187,500 and damages and legal fees to the civil plaintiffs. On 28 November 2023, the Court of Appeal of Paris upheld the Paris Criminal Court’s decision relating to misleading commercial practice and the concealment of those practices. As for the damages owed to the civil plaintiffs, though the Court of Appeal of Paris adjusted the calculation methodology, the majority of the damages had already been paid by provisional enforcement of the Paris Criminal Court’s judgment. An agreement was also entered into with the “Consommation Logement Cadre de Vie” association to settle the case with customers wishing to do so. Like many other financial institutions in the banking, investment, mutual funds and brokerage sectors, the Bank has received or may receive requests for information from, or be subject to investigations by supervisory, governmental or self-regulatory agencies. The Bank responds to such requests and cooperates with the relevant authorities and regulators and seeks to address and remedy any issues that may arise. In 2023, BNP Paribas premises (along with those of other financial institutions) were searched by the French financial prosecutor’s office; BNP Paribas was informed that the office had opened a preliminary investigation relating to French securities transactions. There are no other legal, governmental or arbitral proceedings (including any such proceedings which are pending or threatened) that could have, or during the last twelve months have had, significant effects on the Bank’s financial condition or profitability. 9.d B USINESS COMBINATIONS AND LOSS OF CONTROL OR SIGNIFICANT INFLUENCE Operation of 2023 • Partnership with Stellantis On 3 April 2023, BNP Paribas Personal Finance became the exclusive partner of Stellantis captive company in its financing activities across three strategic markets: Germany, Austria and the United Kingdom. This operation involved the purchase of three entities in these three countries, in conjunction with the sale of activities to various Stellantis joint ventures in France, Italy and Spain. This restructuring increased the Group’s balance sheet by EUR 8 billion, in particular in financial assets at amortised cost, and led to the recognition of a net gain on disposal of EUR 54 million and of a goodwill of EUR 143 million. -- 128 of 130 -- - 129 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 Operations of 2022 • bpost bank On 3 January 2022, BNP Paribas Fortis purchased the residual 50% stake in bpost bank. The Group BNP Paribas took therefore exclusive control of this entity and fully consolidated it from the first quarter of 2022. Consequently, this operation increased the Group’s balance sheet by EUR 12 billion at the acquisition date, in particular EUR 11 billion in financial assets at amortised cost and led to the recognition of badwill of EUR 245 million in the profit and loss account. • Axepta SpA On 4 January 2022, Banca Nazionale del Lavoro sold 80% of its stake of Wordline Merchant Services Italia (ex-Axepta Spa). The Group BNP Paribas lost exclusive control of this entity but kept a significant influence. The disposal led to the recognition of a result of EUR 204 million on the line « Net gain on non-current assets ». The residual stake of 20% was consolidated using the equity method for its remeasured value, including goodwill of EUR 41 million. • Floa On 31 January 2022, BNP Paribas purchased 100% of Floa. The Group BNP Paribas took exclusive control of this entity and fully consolidated it from the first quarter of 2022. The Group's balance sheet increased by EUR 2 billion at the acquisition date, in particular in financial assets at amortised cost. The goodwill related to this operation was EUR 122 million. • UkrSibbank In the context of the conflict in Ukraine, the Group reassessed the nature of control over its subsidiary UkrSibbank and concluded to the loss of exclusive control, and the maintain of a significant influence. This situation led the Group to consolidate the entity using the equity method from 1 March 2022. The loss of exclusive control involved the recognition of a loss on disposal of - EUR 159 million and the reclassification to the profit and loss account of cumulated changes in assets and liabilities for exchange differences of - EUR 274 million, in « Net gain on non-current assets ». The Group's balance sheet decreased by EUR 2 billion at the date of loss of exclusive control, in particular in financial assets at amortised cost. • Terberg Leasing Group BV On 30 November 2022, Arval Service Lease purchased 100% of Terberg Leasing Group BV. The Group BNP Paribas took exclusive control of these entities and fully consolidated them from the last quarter of 2022. The Group's balance sheet increased by EUR 1 billion at the acquisition date, in particular in tangible assets. The goodwill related to this operation was EUR 92 million. -- 129 of 130 -- - 130 - Consolidated financial statements at 31 December 2023 9.e D ISCONTINUED ACTIVITIES On 18 December 2021, BNP Paribas concluded an agreement with BMO Financial Group for the sale of 100% of its retail and commercial banking activities in the United States, operated by the BancWest cash-generating unit, for a total consideration of USD 16.3 billion in cash. The transaction was closed on 1 February 2023 following receipt of all regulatory approvals by BMO Financial Group. The group of assets covered by the agreement comprises most of the entities of the homogeneous BancWest set. As required by IFRS 5 related to groups of assets and liabilities held for sale, the Group’s consolidated financial statements are adapted to present BancWest separately since December 2021: • the assets are reclassified on a separate line of the balance sheet “Assets held for sale”; • the liabilities are also reclassified in a separate line "Liabilities associated with assets held for sale"; • amounts accounted for in equity for the revaluation of assets and liabilities are presented separately in the statement of net income and changes in assets and liabilities recognised directly in equity ; • revenues and expenses are reclassified in a separate line "Net income from discontinued activities" in the profit and loss statement. This income includes revenues and expenses from internal transactions with BancWest, provided that, following the sale, the Group will no longer receive these revenues or incur these expenses ; • The net change in cash and cash equivalents is isolated in the cash flow statement. The disposal realised on 1 February 2023 resulted in EUR 87 billion decrease in “Assets held for sale”. The net capital gain on the disposal amounted to EUR 2.9 billion. -- 130 of 130 --