-- 1 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 1 of 17 First Quarter 2023 Earnings Results Quarterly Financial Supplement Page Consolidated Financial Highlights 2 GAAP Consolidated Results of Operations 3 Non-GAAP Consolidated Results of Operations 4 Consolidated Financial Summary 5 Consolidated Financial Information and Metrics 6 Regulatory Capital 7 Global Wealth Management - Summary Results of Operations 8 Global Wealth Management - Statistical Information 9 Institutional Group - Summary Results of Operations 10 Stifel Bancorp - Financial Information and Credit Metrics 11 Loans and Lending Commitments - Allowance for Credit Losses 12 Consolidated Net Interest Income 13 Stifel Bancorp Net Interest Income 14 GAAP to Core Reconciliation 15 Footnotes 16 Disclaimer and Legal Notice 17 -- 2 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 2 of 17 Consolidated Financial Highlights Three Months Ended (Unaudited, 000s, except per share information) 3/31/2023 3/31/2022 % Change 12/31/2022 % Change Net revenues $ 1,106,793 $ 1,116,527 (0.9 %) $ 1,121,647 (1.3 %) Net income $ 157,539 $ 173,549 (9.2 %) $ 176,621 (10.8 %) Preferred dividends 9,320 9,320 0.0 % 9,320 0.0 % Net income available to common shareholders $ 148,219 $ 164,229 (9.7 %) $ 167,301 (11.4 %) Earnings per diluted common share $ 1.36 $ 1.47 (7.5 %) $ 1.51 (9.9 %) Earnings per diluted common share available to common shareholders $ 1.28 $ 1.39 (7.9 %) $ 1.43 (10.5 %) Non-GAAP financial summary (1): Net revenues $ 1,106,790 $ 1,116,587 (0.9 %) $ 1,121,643 (1.3 %) Net income $ 170,588 $ 184,907 (7.7 %) $ 194,195 (12.2 %) Preferred dividends 9,320 9,320 0.0 % 9,320 0.0 % Net income available to common shareholders $ 161,268 175,587 (8.2 %) 184,875 (12.8 %) Earnings per diluted common share $ 1.48 $ 1.57 (5.7 %) $ 1.66 (10.8 %) Earnings per diluted common share available to common shareholders $ 1.40 $ 1.49 (6.0 %) $ 1.58 (11.4 %) Weighted average number of common shares outstanding: Basic 108,754 109,205 (0.4 %) 108,344 0.4 % Diluted 115,390 118,140 (2.3 %) 117,223 (1.6 %) Period end common shares outstanding 106,172 106,626 (0.4 %) 105,348 0.8 % Cash dividends declared per common share $ 0.36 $ 0.30 20.0 % $ 0.30 20.0 % -- 3 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 3 of 17 GAAP Consolidated Results of Operations Three Months Ended (Unaudited, 000s, except per share information) 3/31/2023 3/31/2022 % Change 12/31/2022 % Change Revenues: Commissions $ 169,550 $ 195,909 (13.5 %) $ 168,945 0.4 % Principal transactions 115,522 159,270 (27.5 %) 125,781 (8.2 %) Transactional revenues 285,072 355,179 (19.7 %) 294,726 (3.3 %) Capital raising 60,816 73,450 (17.2 %) 56,771 7.1 % Advisory 151,063 181,396 (16.7 %) 166,935 (9.5 %) Investment banking 211,879 254,846 (16.9 %) 223,706 (5.3 %) Asset management 315,569 341,636 (7.6 %) 289,462 9.0 % Other income (2,293 ) 8,888 (125.8 %) 11,862 (119.3 %) Operating revenues 810,227 960,549 (15.6 %) 819,756 (1.2 %) Interest revenue 451,564 165,435 173.0 % 416,731 8.4 % Total revenues 1,261,791 1,125,984 12.1 % 1,236,487 2.0 % Interest expense 154,998 9,457 nm 114,840 35.0 % Net revenues 1,106,793 1,116,527 (0.9 %) 1,121,647 (1.3 %) Non-interest expenses: Compensation and benefits 651,190 673,691 (3.3 %) 647,962 0.5 % Occupancy and equipment rental 82,140 77,026 6.6 % 80,740 1.7 % Communication and office supplies 46,136 42,456 8.7 % 45,209 2.1 % Commissions and floor brokerage 14,440 15,887 (9.1 %) 13,183 9.5 % Provision for credit losses 4,920 8,240 (40.3 %) 6,028 (18.4 %) Other operating expenses 98,084 72,118 36.0 % 94,828 3.4 % Total non-interest expenses 896,910 889,418 0.8 % 887,950 1.0 % Income before income taxes 209,883 227,109 (7.6 %) 233,697 (10.2 %) Provision for income taxes 52,344 53,560 (2.3 %) 57,076 (8.3 %) Net income 157,539 173,549 (9.2 %) 176,621 (10.8 %) Preferred dividends 9,320 9,320 0.0 % 9,320 0.0 % Net income available to common shareholders $ 148,219 $ 164,229 (9.7 %) $ 167,301 (11.4 %) Earnings per common share: Basic $ 1.36 $ 1.50 (9.3 %) $ 1.54 (11.7 %) Diluted $ 1.28 $ 1.39 (7.9 %) $ 1.43 (10.5 %) Weighted average number of common shares outstanding: Basic 108,754 109,205 (0.4 %) 108,344 0.4 % Diluted 115,390 118,140 (2.3 %) 117,223 (1.6 %) Cash dividends declared per common share $ 0.36 $ 0.30 20.0 % $ 0.30 20.0 % -- 4 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 4 of 17 Non-GAAP Consolidated Results of Operations (1) Three Months Ended (Unaudited, 000s, except per share information) 3/31/2023 3/31/2022 % Change 12/31/2022 % Change Revenues: Commissions $ 169,550 $ 195,909 (13.5 %) $ 168,945 0.4 % Principal transactions 115,522 159,270 (27.5 %) 125,781 (8.2 %) Transactional revenues 285,072 355,179 (19.7 %) 294,726 (3.3 %) Capital raising 60,816 73,450 (17.2 %) 56,771 7.1 % Advisory 151,063 181,396 (16.7 %) 166,935 (9.5 %) Investment banking 211,879 254,846 (16.9 %) 223,706 (5.3 %) Asset management 315,569 341,636 (7.6 %) 289,462 9.0 % Other income (2,293 ) 8,888 (125.8 %) 11,857 (119.3 %) Operating revenues 810,227 960,549 (15.6 %) 819,751 (1.2 %) Interest revenue 451,564 165,435 173.0 % 416,731 8.4 % Total revenues 1,261,791 1,125,984 12.1 % 1,236,482 2.0 % Interest expense 155,001 9,397 nm 114,839 35.0 % Net revenues 1,106,790 1,116,587 (0.9 %) 1,121,643 (1.3 %) Non-interest expenses: Compensation and benefits 641,937 664,380 (3.4 %) 633,392 1.3 % Occupancy and equipment rental 82,039 77,009 6.5 % 80,555 1.8 % Communication and office supplies 46,134 42,448 8.7 % 45,203 2.1 % Commissions and floor brokerage 14,440 15,887 (9.1 %) 13,183 9.5 % Provision for credit losses 4,920 8,240 (40.3 %) 6,028 (18.4 %) Other operating expenses 90,051 66,661 35.1 % 86,088 4.6 % Total non-interest expenses 879,521 874,625 0.6 % 864,449 1.7 % Income before income taxes 227,269 241,962 (6.1 %) 257,194 (11.6 %) Provision for income taxes 56,681 57,055 (0.7 %) 62,999 (10.0 %) Net income 170,588 184,907 (7.7 %) 194,195 (12.2 %) Preferred dividends 9,320 9,320 0.0 % 9,320 0.0 % Net income available to common shareholders $ 161,268 $ 175,587 (8.2 %) $ 184,875 (12.8 %) Earnings per common share: Basic $ 1.48 $ 1.61 (8.1 %) $ 1.71 (13.5 %) Diluted $ 1.40 $ 1.49 (6.0 %) $ 1.58 (11.4 %) Weighted average number of common shares outstanding: Basic 108,754 109,205 (0.4 %) 108,344 0.4 % Diluted 115,390 118,140 (2.3 %) 117,223 (1.6 %) Cash dividends declared per common share $ 0.36 $ 0.30 20.0 % $ 0.30 20.0 % -- 5 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 5 of 17 Consolidated Financial Summary Three Months Ended (Unaudited, 000s) 3/31/2023 3/31/2022 % Change 12/31/2022 % Change Net revenues: Global Wealth Management $ 757,186 $ 681,725 11.1 % $ 744,341 1.7 % Institutional Group 332,613 431,363 (22.9 %) 353,882 (6.0 %) Other 16,994 3,439 nm 23,424 nm Total net revenues $ 1,106,793 $ 1,116,527 (0.9 %) $ 1,121,647 (1.3 %) Operating expenses: Global Wealth Management $ 441,077 $ 456,312 (3.3 %) $ 427,270 3.2 % Institutional Group 298,893 334,735 (10.7 %) 309,370 (3.4 %) Other 156,940 98,371 59.5 % 151,310 3.7 % Total operating expenses $ 896,910 $ 889,418 0.8 % $ 887,950 1.0 % Operating contribution: Global Wealth Management $ 316,109 $ 225,413 40.2 % $ 317,071 (0.3 %) Institutional Group 33,720 96,628 (65.1 %) 44,512 (24.2 %) Other (139,946 ) (94,932 ) 47.4 % (127,886 ) 9.4 % Income before income taxes $ 209,883 $ 227,109 (7.6 %) $ 233,697 (10.2 %) Financial ratios: Compensation and benefits 58.8 % 60.3 % (150 ) 57.8 % 100 Non-compensation operating expenses 22.2 % 19.4 % 280 21.4 % 80 Income before income taxes 19.0 % 20.3 % (130 ) 20.8 % (180 ) Effective tax rate 24.9 % 23.6 % 130 24.4 % 50 -- 6 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 6 of 17 Consolidated Financial Information and Metrics As of and for the Three Months Ended (Unaudited, 000s, except per share data) 3/31/2023 3/31/2022 % Change 12/31/2022 % Change Financial Information: Total assets $ 38,597,653 $ 35,087,698 10.0 % $ 37,196,124 3.8 % Total shareholders' equity $ 5,327,392 $ 5,054,344 5.4 % $ 5,328,471 (0.0 %) Total common equity $ 4,642,392 $ 4,369,344 6.2 % $ 4,643,471 (0.0 %) Goodwill and intangible assets $ (1,512,400 ) $ (1,449,919 ) 4.3 % $ (1,457,137 ) 3.8 % DTL on goodwill and intangible assets $ 63,455 $ 56,775 11.8 % $ 61,225 3.6 % Tangible common equity $ 3,193,447 $ 2,976,200 7.3 % $ 3,247,559 (1.7 %) Preferred equity $ 685,000 $ 685,000 0.0 % $ 685,000 0.0 % Financial Metrics: Book value per common share (2) $ 43.73 $ 40.98 6.7 % $ 44.08 (0.8 %) Tangible book value per common share (2) $ 30.08 $ 27.91 7.8 % $ 30.83 (2.4 %) Return on common equity (3) 12.7 % 15.1 % 14.5 % Non-GAAP return on common equity (1)(3) 13.9 % 16.2 % 16.0 % Return on tangible common equity (4) 18.3 % 22.3 % 20.7 % Non-GAAP return on tangible common equity (1)(4) 19.9 % 23.8 % 22.9 % Pre-tax margin on net revenues 19.0 % 20.3 % 20.8 % Non-GAAP pre-tax margin on net revenues (1) 20.5 % 21.7 % 22.9 % Effective tax rate 24.9 % 23.6 % 24.4 % Non-GAAP effective tax rate (1) 24.9 % 23.6 % 24.5 % -- 7 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 7 of 17 Regulatory Capital (Unaudited, 000s) 3/31/2023 3/31/2022 % Change 12/31/2022 % Change SF Regulatory Capital (5): Common equity tier 1 capital $ 3,280,309 $ 3,029,778 8.3 % $ 3,363,138 (2.5 %) Tier 1 capital $ 3,965,309 $ 3,714,778 6.7 % $ 4,048,138 (2.0 %) Risk-weighted assets $ 23,533,556 $ 19,958,908 17.9 % $ 23,026,900 2.2 % Common equity tier 1 capital ratio 13.9 % 15.2 % 14.6 % Tier 1 risk based capital ratio 16.8 % 18.6 % 17.6 % Tier 1 leverage capital ratio 10.9 % 11.3 % 11.1 % Stifel Bank & Trust Regulatory Capital (5): Common equity tier 1 capital $ 1,590,068 $ 1,371,166 16.0 % $ 1,620,995 (1.9 %) Tier 1 capital $ 1,590,068 $ 1,371,166 16.0 % $ 1,620,995 (1.9 %) Risk-weighted assets $ 14,462,065 $ 12,555,438 15.2 % $ 14,680,996 (1.5 %) Common equity tier 1 capital ratio 11.0 % 10.9 % 11.0 % Tier 1 risk based capital ratio 11.0 % 10.9 % 11.0 % Tier 1 leverage capital ratio 7.5 % 7.1 % 7.2 % Stifel Bank Regulatory Capital (5): Common equity tier 1 capital $ 596,152 $ 340,014 75.3 % $ 468,437 27.3 % Tier 1 capital $ 596,152 $ 340,014 75.3 % $ 468,437 27.3 % Risk-weighted assets $ 4,548,287 $ 2,668,521 70.4 % $ 4,229,316 7.5 % Common equity tier 1 capital ratio 13.1 % 12.7 % 11.1 % Tier 1 risk based capital ratio 13.1 % 12.7 % 11.1 % Tier 1 leverage capital ratio 7.5 % 7.1 % 7.1 % Stifel Net Capital (5): Net capital $ 514,500 $ 584,600 (12.0 %) $ 538,600 (4.5 %) Excess net capital $ 491,500 $ 554,200 (11.3 %) $ 516,300 (4.8 %) -- 8 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 8 of 17 Global Wealth Management - Summary Results of Operations Three Months Ended (Unaudited, 000s) 3/31/2023 3/31/2022 % Change 12/31/2022 % Change Revenues: Commissions $ 110,191 $ 130,776 (15.7 %) $ 112,644 (2.2 %) Principal transactions 51,064 45,544 12.1 % 52,913 (3.5 %) Transactional revenues 161,255 176,320 (8.5 %) 165,557 (2.6 %) Asset management 315,537 341,613 (7.6 %) 289,445 9.0 % Net interest 281,932 156,760 79.8 % 284,998 (1.1 %) Investment banking (6) 4,158 5,147 (19.2 %) 4,814 (13.6 %) Other income (5,696 ) 1,885 (402.2 %) (473 ) 1104.2 % Net revenues 757,186 681,725 11.1 % 744,341 1.7 % Non-interest expenses: Compensation and benefits 342,423 364,993 (6.2 %) 328,099 4.4 % Non-compensation operating expenses 98,654 91,319 8.0 % 99,171 (0.5 %) Total non-interest expenses 441,077 456,312 (3.3 %) 427,270 3.2 % Income before income taxes $ 316,109 $ 225,413 40.2 % $ 317,071 (0.3 %) As a percentage of net revenues: Compensation and benefits 45.2 % 53.5 % (830 ) 44.1 % 110 Non-compensation operating expenses 13.1 % 13.4 % (30 ) 13.3 % (20 ) Income before income taxes 41.7 % 33.1 % 860 42.6 % (90 ) -- 9 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 9 of 17 Global Wealth Management - Statistical Information As of and for the Three Months Ended (Unaudited, 000s, except financial advisors) 3/31/2023 3/31/2022 % Change 12/31/2022 % Change Financial advisors (including independent contractors) (7) 2,350 2,321 1.2 % 2,344 0.3 % Total client assets $ 405,988,000 $ 421,414,000 (3.7 %) $ 389,818,000 4.1 % Fee-based client assets $ 149,541,000 $ 157,910,000 (5.3 %) $ 144,952,000 3.2 % Transactional assets $ 256,447,000 $ 263,504,000 (2.7 %) $ 244,866,000 4.7 % Secured client lending (8) $ 3,393,000 $ 4,082,000 (16.9 %) $ 3,576,000 (5.1 %) Asset Management Revenue (000s): Private Client Group (9) $ 259,491 $ 293,301 (11.5 %) $ 240,446 7.9 % Asset Management 32,241 34,635 (6.9 %) 30,690 5.1 % Third-party Bank Sweep Program 11,261 942 nm 5,522 103.9 % Other (10) 12,576 12,758 (1.4 %) 12,804 (1.8 %) Total asset management revenues $ 315,569 $ 341,636 (7.6 %) $ 289,462 9.0 % Fee-based Assets (millions): Private Client Group (9) $ 131,483 138,219 (4.9 %) $ 126,043 4.3 % Asset Management 33,409 34,716 (3.8 %) 32,233 3.6 % Elimination (11) (15,351 ) (15,025 ) 2.2 % (13,324 ) 15.2 % Total fee-based assets $ 149,541 $ 157,910 (5.3 %) $ 144,952 3.2 % Third-party Bank Sweep Program $ 915 $ 5,492 (83.3 %) $ 1,984 (53.9 %) ROA (bps) (12): Private Client Group (9) 82.3 82.9 80.9 Asset Management 38.6 39.9 38.1 Third-party Bank Sweep Program 303.9 6.2 137.2 Stifel Bancorp Deposits (millions): Sweep Deposits $ 14,057 $ 22,193 (36.7 %) $ 16,628 (15.5 %) Smart Rate Deposits 10,778 429 nm 8,710 23.7 % Direct Wealth Management Deposits at Stifel Bancorp 189 56 237.5 % 43 339.5 % Total Stifel Bancorp Wealth Management Deposits 25,024 22,678 10.3 % 25,381 (1.4 %) Other Bank Deposits 3,301 1,518 117.5 % 1,736 90.1 % Total Stifel Bancorp Deposits $ 28,325 $ 24,196 17.1 % $ 27,117 4.5 % Wealth Management Cash (millions): Stifel Bancorp Wealth Management Deposits $ 25,024 $ 22,678 10.3 % $ 25,381 (1.4 %) Third-party Bank Sweep Program 915 5,492 (83.3 %) 1,984 (53.9 %) Other Sweep Cash 252 390 (35.4 %) 187 34.8 % Money Market Mutual Funds 7,434 5,899 26.0 % 6,529 13.9 % Total Wealth Management Cash $ 33,625 $ 34,459 (2.4 %) $ 34,081 (1.3 %) -- 10 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 10 of 17 Institutional Group - Summary Results of Operations Three Months Ended (Unaudited, 000s) 3/31/2023 3/31/2022 % Change 12/31/2022 % Change Revenues: Commissions $ 59,359 $ 65,133 (8.9 %) $ 56,301 5.4 % Principal transactions 64,458 113,726 (43.3 %) 72,869 (11.5 %) Transactional revenues 123,817 178,859 (30.8 %) 129,170 (4.1 %) Capital raising 56,658 68,303 (17.0 %) 51,956 9.0 % Advisory 151,063 181,396 (16.7 %) 166,935 (9.5 %) Investment banking 207,721 249,699 (16.8 %) 218,891 (5.1 %) Other income (13) 1,075 2,805 (61.7 %) 5,821 (81.5 %) Net revenues 332,613 431,363 (22.9 %) 353,882 (6.0 %) Non-interest expenses: Compensation and benefits 205,905 252,347 (18.4 %) 220,730 (6.7 %) Non-compensation operating expenses 92,988 82,388 12.9 % 88,640 4.9 % Total non-interest expenses 298,893 334,735 (10.7 %) 309,370 (3.4 %) Income before income taxes $ 33,720 $ 96,628 (65.1 %) $ 44,512 (24.2 %) As a percentage of net revenues: Compensation and benefits 61.9 % 58.5 % 340 62.4 % (50 ) Non-compensation operating expenses 28.0 % 19.1 % 890 25.0 % 300 Income before income taxes 10.1 % 22.4 % (1,230 ) 12.6 % (250 ) -- 11 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 11 of 17 Stifel Bancorp - Financial Information and Credit Metrics (Unaudited, 000s) 3/31/2023 3/31/2022 % Change 12/31/2022 % Change Stifel Bancorp Financial Information: Total assets $ 30,701,371 $ 26,115,139 17.6 % $ 29,318,421 4.7 % Total shareholder's equity $ 2,199,821 $ 1,782,875 23.4 % $ 2,071,882 6.2 % Total loans, net (includes loans held for sale) $ 20,935,133 $ 17,908,268 16.9 % $ 20,622,004 1.5 % Residential real estate 7,494,788 6,008,507 24.7 % 7,371,671 1.7 % Commercial and industrial 4,755,664 4,546,700 4.6 % 4,897,176 (2.9 %) Fund banking 4,623,423 3,109,807 48.7 % 4,182,641 10.5 % Securities-based loans 2,558,343 2,954,212 (13.4 %) 2,724,551 (6.1 %) Commercial real estate 663,325 499,825 32.7 % 675,599 (1.8 %) Construction and land 644,800 521,623 23.6 % 593,191 8.7 % Other 159,101 120,874 31.6 % 157,729 0.9 % Loans held for sale 225,365 315,427 (28.6 %) 156,912 43.6 % Investment securities $ 7,607,385 $ 7,240,149 5.1 % $ 7,624,448 (0.2 %) Available-for-sale securities, at fair value 1,624,458 1,926,144 (15.7 %) 1,636,041 (0.7 %) Held-to-maturity securities, at amortized cost 5,982,927 5,314,005 12.6 % 5,988,407 (0.1 %) Unrealized losses on available-for-sale securities (196,621 ) (95,692 ) 105.5 % (227,178 ) (13.5 %) Total deposits $ 28,325,327 $ 24,195,626 17.1 % $ 27,117,111 4.5 % Demand deposits (interest-bearing) 27,862,336 23,553,384 18.3 % 26,805,073 3.9 % Demand deposits (non-interest-bearing) 456,091 618,435 (26.3 %) 305,138 49.5 % Certificates of deposit 6,900 23,807 (71.0 %) 6,900 0.0 % Credit Metrics: Allowance for credit losses $ 152,906 $ 126,802 20.6 % $ 147,853 3.4 % Allowance as a percentage of retained loans 0.73 % 0.72 % 0.72 % Net charge-offs as a percentage of average loans 0.00 % 0.00 % 0.00 % Total nonperforming assets $ 10,749 $ 17,124 (37.2 %) $ 10,374 3.6 % Nonperforming assets as a percentage of total assets 0.04 % 0.07 % 0.04 % -- 12 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 12 of 17 Loans and Lending Commitments - Allowance for Credit Losses March 31, 2023 Loans and Lending (Unaudited, 000s) Commitments ACL ACL % Q1 Provision Residential real estate $ 7,494,788 $ 22,696 0.3 % $ 2,255 Commercial and industrial 4,755,664 55,734 1.2 % 1,458 Fund banking 4,623,423 12,943 0.3 % 1,232 Securities-based loans 2,558,343 3,117 0.1 % (40 ) Commercial real estate 663,325 11,566 1.7 % (1,331 ) Construction and land 644,800 10,317 1.6 % 1,749 Other 159,101 789 0.5 % 53 Loans held for investment, gross 20,899,444 117,162 0.6 % 5,376 Loans held for sale 225,365 Total loans, gross 21,124,809 Lending-related commitments (unfunded) 6,113,000 35,744 0.6 % (456 ) Loans and lending-related commitments $ 27,237,809 $ 152,906 $ 4,920 -- 13 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 13 of 17 Consolidated Net Interest Income Three Months Ended March 31, 2023 March 31, 2022 December 31, 2022 (Unaudited, millions) Average balance Interest income/expense Average interest rate Average balance Interest income/expense Average interest rate Average balance Interest income/expense Average interest rate Interest-earning assets: Cash and federal funds sold $ 1,989.5 $ 22.7 4.57 % $ 1,340.3 $ 1.1 0.32 % $ 1,641.8 $ 18.3 4.45 % Financial instruments owned 877.7 3.7 1.70 % 1,176.0 5.4 1.84 % 906.2 7.5 3.31 % Margin balances 831.2 14.9 7.16 % 1,089.6 6.9 2.54 % 985.2 15.6 6.33 % Investments: Asset-backed securities 6,202.4 98.8 6.37 % 5,598.6 24.9 1.78 % 6,216.5 86.1 5.54 % Mortgage-backed securities 986.6 5.4 2.18 % 1,007.3 4.4 1.75 % 1,003.6 5.4 2.15 % Corporate fixed income securities 637.5 4.1 2.61 % 773.0 5.0 2.57 % 646.4 4.5 2.79 % Other 4.7 - 2.55 % 5.3 - 1.84 % 4.5 - 2.18 % Total investments 7,831.2 108.3 5.53 % 7,384.2 34.3 1.86 % 7,871.0 96.0 4.88 % Loans: Residential real estate 7,446.1 53.5 2.87 % 5,684.6 35.5 2.50 % 7,240.6 55.7 3.08 % Commercial and industrial 4,816.3 94.3 7.83 % 4,380.0 41.3 3.77 % 4,997.7 84.4 6.75 % Fund banking 4,396.4 76.3 6.94 % 3,176.0 20.8 2.62 % 4,348.7 65.3 6.01 % Securities-based loans 2,638.0 42.5 6.44 % 2,910.7 14.4 1.98 % 2,735.5 40.0 5.85 % Commercial real estate 666.8 10.9 6.57 % 462.9 2.9 2.52 % 805.3 12.5 6.22 % Construction and land 612.6 11.5 7.49 % 525.3 4.3 3.25 % 583.7 9.9 6.77 % Loans held for sale 206.3 3.4 6.53 % 221.8 1.3 2.29 % 168.0 2.1 5.09 % Other 153.9 2.7 7.12 % 117.1 0.8 2.75 % 147.6 2.3 6.46 % Total loans 20,936.4 295.1 5.64 % 17,478.4 121.3 2.78 % 21,027.1 272.2 5.18 % Other interest-bearing assets 797.3 6.9 3.45 % 760.3 (3.6 ) (1.88 %) 770.6 7.1 3.69 % Total interest-bearing assets/ interest income 33,263.3 451.6 5.43 % 29,228.8 165.4 2.26 % 33,201.9 416.7 5.02 % Interest-bearing liabilities: Senior notes 1,114.6 12.5 4.49 % 1,113.6 11.4 4.10 % 1,114.4 10.5 3.77 % Deposits 27,138.0 137.3 2.02 % 23,129.9 0.9 0.02 % 27,267.0 98.7 1.45 % Federal Home Loan advances 5.6 0.1 4.92 % 40.4 - 0.30 % - - 0.00 % Other interest-bearing liabilities 1,164.9 5.1 1.76 % 1,559.3 (2.8 ) (0.75 %) 1,303.0 5.6 1.72 % Total interest-bearing liabilities/ interest expense $ 29,423.1 155.0 2.11 % $ 25,843.2 9.5 0.15 % $ 29,684.4 114.8 1.55 % Net interest income/margin $ 296.6 3.57 % $ 155.9 2.13 % $ 301.9 3.64 % -- 14 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 14 of 17 Stifel Bancorp Net Interest Income Three Months Ended March 31, 2023 March 31, 2022 December 31, 2022 (Unaudited, millions) Average balance Interest income/expense Average interest rate Average balance Interest income/expense Average interest rate Average balance Interest income/expense Average interest rate Interest-earning assets: Cash and federal funds sold $ 916.1 $ 11.2 4.91 % $ 549.5 $ 0.3 0.22 % $ 889.4 $ 9.4 4.24 % Investments 7,831.2 108.3 5.53 % 7,384.2 34.3 1.86 % 7,871.0 96.0 4.88 % Loans 20,936.4 295.1 5.64 % 17,478.4 121.3 2.78 % 21,027.1 272.2 5.18 % Other interest-bearing assets 57.4 0.6 3.86 % 50.1 0.4 2.87 % 55.1 0.7 4.56 % Total interest-bearing assets/ interest income $ 29,741.1 $ 415.2 5.58 % $ 25,462.2 $ 156.3 2.45 % $ 29,842.6 $ 378.3 5.07 % Interest-bearing liabilities: Deposits $ 27,138.0 $ 137.3 2.02 % $ 23,129.9 $ 0.9 0.02 % $ 27,267.0 $ 98.7 1.45 % Federal Home Loan advances 5.6 0.1 4.92 % 40.4 - 0.30 % - - 0.00 % Other interest-bearing liabilities 0.8 - 17.48 % 1.1 0.1 13.24 % 0.9 0.1 15.64 % Total interest-bearing liabilities/ interest expense $ 27,144.4 137.4 2.02 % $ 23,171.4 1.0 0.02 % $ 27,267.9 98.8 1.45 % Net interest income/margin $ 277.8 3.74 % $ 155.3 2.44 % $ 279.5 3.75 % -- 15 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 15 of 17 GAAP to Core Reconciliation Three Months Ended (Unaudited, 000s) 3/31/2023 3/31/2022 Change 12/31/2022 Change GAAP net revenues $ 1,106,793 $ 1,116,527 $ 1,121,647 Non-GAAP adjustments (3 ) 60 (4 ) Non-GAAP net revenues 1,106,790 1,116,587 1,121,643 GAAP compensation and benefits expense 651,190 673,691 647,962 Merger-related (14) (9,253 ) (9,311 ) (14,570 ) Non-GAAP compensation and benefits expense 641,937 664,380 633,392 GAAP non-compensation operating expenses 245,720 215,727 239,988 Merger-related (14) (8,136 ) (5,482 ) (8,931 ) Non-GAAP non-compensation operating expenses 237,584 210,245 231,057 Total merger-related adjustments (17,386 ) (14,853 ) (23,497 ) GAAP provision for income taxes 52,344 53,560 57,076 Merger-related and other (14) 4,337 3,495 5,923 Non-GAAP provision for income taxes 56,681 57,055 62,999 Financial ratios: Compensation and benefits 58.0 % 59.5 % (150 ) 56.5 % 150 Non-compensation operating expenses 21.5 % 18.8 % 270 20.6 % 90 Income before income taxes 20.5 % 21.7 % (120 ) 22.9 % (240 ) Effective tax rate 24.9 % 23.6 % 130 24.5 % 40 -- 16 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 16 of 17 Footnotes (1) Please refer to the GAAP to Core Reconciliation for a reconciliation of the Company’s GAAP results to these non-GAAP measures. (2) Book value per common share represents shareholders’ equity (excluding preferred stock) divided by period end common shares outstanding. Tangible book value per share represents tangible common shareholders' equity (defined below) divided by period end common shares outstanding. (3) Return on average common equity (“ROCE”) is calculated by dividing annualized net income applicable to common shareholders by average common shareholders’ equity or, in the case of non-GAAP ROCE, calculated by dividing non-GAAP net income applicable to commons shareholders by average common shareholders’ equity. (4) Return on average tangible common equity (“ROTCE”), a non-GAAP financial measure, is calculated by dividing annualized net income applicable to common shareholders by average tangible common equity or, in the case of non-GAAP ROTCE, calculated by dividing non-GAAP net income applicable to common shareholders by average tangible common equity. Tangible common equity, also a non-GAAP financial measure, equals total common shareholders’ equity less goodwill and identifiable intangible assets and the deferred taxes on goodwill and intangible assets. Average deferred taxes on goodwill and intangible assets was $62.3 million, $55.5 million, and $60.4 million, as of March 31, 2023 and 2022, and December 31, 2022, respectively. (5) Regulatory capital amounts and ratios are estimates as of the date of the Company's earnings release, April 26, 2023. (6) Includes capital raising and advisory revenues. (7) Includes independent contractors of 102, 92, and 102 as of March 31, 2023 and 2022, and December 31, 2022, respectively. (8) Includes client margin balances held by the Company’s broker-dealer subsidiaries and securities-based loans held at the Company’s bank subsidiaries. (9) Includes Private Client Group and Trust Business. (10) Includes fund networking fees, retirement fees, transaction/handling fees, and ACAT fees. (11) Asset management assets managed in Private Client Group or Trust accounts. (12) Return on assets (ROA) is calculated based on prior period-end balances for Private Client Group, period-end balances for Asset Management, and average quarterly balances for Individual Program Banks. (13) Includes net interest, asset management, and other income. (14) Primarily related to charges attributable to integration-related activities, signing bonuses, amortization of restricted stock awards, debentures, and promissory notes issued as retention, additional earn-out expense, and amortization of intangible assets acquired. These costs were directly related to acquisitions of certain businesses and are not representative of the costs of running the Company’s on-going business. -- 17 of 18 -- Stifel Financial Corp. Quarterly Financial Supplement | First Quarter 2023 Earnings Release Page 17 of 17 Disclaimer and Legal Notice Forward-Looking Statements This presentation may contain “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 that involve significant risks, assumptions, and uncertainties, including statements relating to the market opportunity and future business prospects of Stifel Financial Corp., as well as Stifel, Nicolaus & Company, Incorporated and its subsidiaries (collectively, “SF” or the “Company”). These statements can be identified by the use of the words “may,” “will,” “should,” “could,” “would,” “plan,” “potential,” “estimate,” “project,” “believe,” “intend,” “anticipate,” “expect,” and similar expressions. All statements not dealing with historical results are forward-looking and are based on various assumptions. The forward-looking statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from those expressed in or implied by the statements. For information about the risks and important factors that could affect the Company’s future results, financial condition and liquidity, see “Risk Factors” in Part I of the Company’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2022. Forward-looking statements speak only as to the date they are made. The Company disclaims any intent or obligation to update forward-looking statements to reflect circumstances or events that occur after the date the forward-looking statements are made. Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures The Company prepares its Consolidated Financial Statements using accounting principles generally accepted in the United States (U.S. GAAP). The Company may disclose certain “non-GAAP financial measures” in the course of its earnings releases, earnings conference calls, financial presentations and otherwise. The Securities and Exchange Commission defines a “non-GAAP financial measure” as a numerical measure of historical or future financial performance, financial position, or cash flows that is subject to adjustments that effectively exclude, or include, amounts from the most directly comparable measure calculated and presented in accordance with U.S. GAAP. Non-GAAP financial measures disclosed by the Company are provided as additional information to analysts, investors and other stakeholders in order to provide them with greater transparency about, or an alternative method for assessing the Company’s financial condition or operating results. These measures are not in accordance with, or a substitute for U.S. GAAP, and may be different from or inconsistent with non-GAAP financial measures used by other companies. Whenever the Company refers to a non-GAAP financial measure, it will also define it or present the most directly comparable financial measure calculated and presented in accordance with U.S. GAAP, along with a reconciliation of the differences between the non-GAAP financial measure it references and such comparable U.S. GAAP financial measure. Legal Notice This Financial Supplement contains financial, statistical, and business-related information, as well as business and segment trends. The information should be read in conjunction with the Company’s first quarter earnings release issued April 26, 2023. -- 18 of 18 --