TRANSCRIPT

Q3 2020 — Transcript

Q3 2020PDF · 22 pages353 KB
T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 1
Host
Elizabeth Lynn, Head of Investor Relations
Speakers
Michael Corbat, Citi Chief Executive Officer
Mark Mason, Citi Chief Financial Officer
____________________________________________________________________________________
PRESENTATION
OPERATOR: Hello and welcome to Citi's Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review with the Chief Executive
Officer, Mike Corbat; and Chief Financial Officer, Mark Mason. Today's call will be hosted by Elizabeth
Lynn, Head of Citi Investor Relations.
We ask that you please hold all questions until the completion of the formal remarks, at which time you will
be given instructions for the question-and-answer session. Also, as a reminder, this conference is being
recorded today. If you have any objections, please disconnect at this time.
Ms. Lynn, you may begin.
ELIZABETH LYNN: Thank you, operator. Good morning and thank you all for joining us. On our call today,
our CEO, Mike Corbat will speak first; then Mark Mason, our CFO, will take you through the earnings
presentation, which is available for download on our website, citigroup.com. Afterwards, we will be happy
to take questions.
Before we get started, I'd like to remind you that today's presentation may contain forward-looking
statements, which are based on management's current expectations and are subject to uncertainty and
changes in circumstances. Actual results, capital and other financial conditions may differ materially from
these statements due to a variety of factors, including the precautionary statements referenced in our
discussion today and those included in our SEC filings, including, without limitation, the Risk Factors section
of our 2019 Form 10-K.
With that said, let me turn it over to Mike.
MIKE CORBAT: Thank you, Liz, and good morning, everyone. Today, we reported earnings for the third
quarter of 2020. We had net income of $3.2 billion and earnings per share of $1.40. We continue to navigate
the COVID-19 pandemic extremely well. Credit costs have stabilized, deposits continued to increase, and
revenues are up 3% year-to-date.
As you know, last week we entered into consent orders with the Federal Reserve and the OCC, and I will
discuss how we are approaching those after I go through our business and financial performance.
Our Institutional Clients Group continues to perform extremely well. Investment Banking had another strong
quarter accessing the capital markets for our clients and Private Bank revenues are now up 9% year-to-
date. Treasury and Trade Solutions, the backbone of our global network is down only 4% for the quarter
and 5% for the year in constant dollars despite significantly lower interest rates.
Trading performance was strong as well, with fixed income and equities up 42% and 18%, respectively
year-to-date. Global Consumer Banking revenues remain under pressure due to the economic impact of
the pandemic, predominantly driven by the decline in credit card spending.
At the same time, deposits continued to increase significantly, credit costs decreased, and we saw more
investment activity from our wealth management clients. On balance, our Global Consumer Banking
franchise has shown resilience in light of the challenges we're facing.

-- 1 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 2
Our capital position strengthened during the quarter with our Common Equity Tier 1 ratio increasing to
11.8%, well above our regulatory minimum of 10%. Our tangible book value per share increased to $71.95,
up 4% from a year ago. And we remain committed to returning capital to our shareholders over time.
Turning to the consent orders. They focus on four areas that impact our risk and control environment: risk
management, data governance, controls and compliance. What ties these areas together is the need to
modernize our infrastructure, governance and processes.
We've had remediation programs in place. And while we've been making progress in these areas, we're
simply not where we need to be. While this is disappointing, we're committed to thoroughly addressing the
issues identified in the orders and modernizing our bank.
As many of you know, we've been making structural changes in accelerating investments. We've
centralized program management and learned from unsparing root cause analysis from outside firms. We're
laser-focused on reducing manual touch points, automating processes and ensuring accurate data can be
accessed quickly when we're producing management and regulatory reports.
More importantly, we're making strengthening our risk and control environment and achieving operational
excellence a strategic priority for the firm going forward. This won't be a quick or easy fix. We need to
conduct an in-depth gap analysis to ensure our solutions are tailored to the issues we face and get us to
the necessary end state. While we can't fully scope out the costs yet for a multiyear transformation, I can
tell you with certainty that we're committing all the necessary resources while continuing to serve our clients.
Importantly, we're aligned with our regulators as far as timelines are concerned, so we'll not jeopardize the
quality or completeness for speed. Collectively, these investments will not only further enhance our safety
and soundness. They'll also create a digital infrastructure that will make us more efficient, more competitive
and significantly improve our ability to serve our clients and customers. So these are investments we need
to make.
In hindsight, we should have done them faster and prevented it from coming to this. But our firm has made
tremendous progress in recent years, whether it's de-risking our balance sheet or improving our efficiency
and business performance to close the gap in returns with our competitors. Our foundation is sound, stable
and secure. Our performance during this pandemic shows the progress we've made. Achieving excellence
in our risk and control environment and our operations is necessary for Citi to take the next step forward.
Our franchise is made up of committed and capable people who make us proud every day. They've done
everything asked of them, and I know they'll continue to do so in the times ahead. Ahead of the transition
in February, Jane is driving this transformation, and the entire management team is committed to getting
Citi to where it needs to be and doing it the right way.
With that, Mark will go through the presentation, and then we'd be happy to take your questions.
MARK MASON: Thank you, Mike, and good morning, everyone. Starting on slide 3. Citigroup reported
third quarter net income of $3.2 billion, which included a modest increase in credit reserves of roughly $300
million this quarter. Reported results also include the $400 million civil money penalty in connection with
the consent orders that Mike just mentioned, which negatively impacted EPS by $0.19.
For the quarter, revenues of $17.3 billion declined 7% from the prior year. While Trading and Investment
Banking remained strong, this was more than offset by the combined impact of lower interest rates and
lower levels of activity in consumer. Expenses were up 5% year-over-year, as we continue to invest in
infrastructure supporting our risk and control environment. Credit costs of $2.3 billion were meaningfully
lower relative to the first half of the year. Our effective tax rate was 20% for the third quarter.

-- 2 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 3
Looking at year-to-date results, we delivered net income of over $7 billion, even as we increased credit
reserves by roughly $11 billion. We grew revenues by 3%, predominantly reflecting continued strength in
our Markets and Investment Banking businesses, while expenses increased 1% year-over-year, allowing
us to deliver positive operating leverage and a 6% increase in operating margin.
In constant dollars, end-of-period loans declined 4% year-over-year to $667 billion, reflecting a higher level
of repayments across institutional and consumer as well as a slowdown in draws in our institutional
businesses and lower spending activity in consumer.
Deposits grew 16% with consistent client engagement, reflecting the benefits of our global platform across
both the institutional and consumer franchises, which also serve to strengthen our available liquidity.
And three quarters of the way through the year, we continue to manage well through this crisis with
significant capital and liquidity as well as a significant cushion in the form of credit reserves.
As of September 30, our CET1 capital ratio was 11.8%, close to 200 basis points above our regulatory
minimum requirement. We have over $950 billion in available liquidity. We have more than doubled credit
reserves since the end of last year. Today, they stand at nearly $29 billion. And including the modest
increase taken this quarter, our reserve ratio was roughly stable at 4% on funded loans. And as we
discussed last quarter, we feel good about our ability to continue to support our clients as we all manage
through this crisis.
On slide 4, we provide additional detail on reserving actions so far this year. As a reminder, these reserves
include our estimate of lifetime credit losses tied to a specific base scenario as well as a management
adjustment for economic uncertainty, which provides some room in the event of a more adverse outcome.
In the first quarter, our base scenario reflected a short-lived downturn followed by a recovery in the back
half of 2020, with unemployment falling to 7% by year-end and full-year GDP close to prior year levels.
By the end of the second quarter, our base case assumed a more severe and protracted downturn this
year, but with a sharper recovery into next year. And now you can see we are expecting a somewhat more
muted and slower recovery in both unemployment and GDP through 2022.
I would note, however, that our forward-looking view on a rolling 13-quarter basis in unemployment, as an
example, is continuing to improve as we move further beyond the peak of the crisis. And our outlook for
other variables like VIX and oil prices is also important and generally improved this quarter.
So, on a net basis, we did not see a significant impact on reserves from the change in our base macro
outlook this quarter. But we did add to our management adjustment for economic uncertainty, which grew
from $2.3 billion to $3.1 billion during the quarter, partially offset by lower loan volumes and other small
items.
Today, we are factoring in a downside scenario that is more adverse relative to our base case. For example,
we are incorporating a more significant deterioration in US GDP growth rates, which is now close to 9%
lower than our base case in 2021 versus our second quarter outlook that was only 1% lower than the base
case.
So all else being equal, if the management adjustment had not changed, we would have seen a reserve
release of roughly $500 million in the quarter. Looking at the level of reserves we hold today, we believe
that we are well prepared for expected credit losses having reserved for something worse than our base
case.

-- 3 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 4
And given the lifetime nature of the CECL methodology and the conservative nature of our management
adjustment, it is now more likely than not that we'll see reserve releases and our ACL come down in 2021
to offset future losses as we continue to progress through the crisis, assuming our base case holds.
Although this may be offset somewhat as we would likely need to build additional reserves to cover future
loan growth as the economy recovers and we support our clients' needs.
Turning now to each business, slide 5 shows the results for Global Consumer Banking in constant dollars.
GCB delivered EBT of $1.4 billion. While revenues remained under pressure, credit costs were down
considerably this quarter, reflecting a small ACL release and lower net credit losses, in particular, in the US
where we're seeing a continued benefit from government stimulus and other relief.
Revenues declined 12%, as continued strong deposit growth and momentum in Asia wealth management
was more than offset by lower card volumes and lower interest rates across all regions. And expenses
decreased 2%, as lower volume-related expenses, reduction in marketing and other discretionary spending
and efficiency savings were partially offset by increases in COVID-19-related expenses.
Slide 6 shows the results for North America consumer in more detail. Total third quarter revenues of $4.5
billion were down 13% from last year. Branded cards revenues of $2.1 billion were down 12%, reflecting
lower purchase sales and lower average loans. As seen across the industry, purchase sales have continued
to recover during the third quarter, up 16% sequentially, but still down 9% versus last year.
At the same time, we're seeing an increase in payment rates, as consumers remain liquid, and we have
not yet seen stress in their overall ability to pay. So while purchase activity has improved, our clients are
also paying down more quickly, resulting in pressure on our loan balances. This is creating a revenue
headwind, but it is also benefiting cost of credit, as delinquencies and losses have outperformed our initial
expectations for 2020.
Retail services revenues of $1.4 billion were down 21% year-over-year, reflecting lower average loans as
well as higher partner payments. Net interest revenues were down 16%, as average loans declined by 10%
on lower purchase sale activity and higher payment rates.
Similar to branded cards, purchase sales recovered sequentially this quarter, up 18%, but remained down
8% year-over-year. Higher partner payments drove the remainder of the revenue decline versus last year,
reflecting the impact of lower loss expectations in 2020 and, therefore, higher income sharing.
During the quarter, we launched a new digital credit card program with Wayfair. With this partnership, we
further diversified our portfolio with a leading e-commerce retailer and now provide half of the top 10 US e-
commerce companies in 2020, with consumer credit card programs.
Retail banking revenues of $1.1 billion were down 2% year-over-year as strong deposit growth and higher
mortgage revenues were more than offset by lower deposit spreads. Average deposits were up 19%,
including 26% growth in checking. We saw continued momentum in digital deposit sales with more than
two-thirds coming from customers outside of our branch footprint. And we will continue to look for
opportunities to deepen our relationships with these customers, including through our investments in digital
wealth capabilities.
Total expenses for North America consumer were down 3% year-over-year, as we managed our marketing
and other discretionary expenses while recognizing efficiency savings and lower volume-related costs,
which more than offset incremental COVID-19-related expenses. Total credit cost of $1.2 billion decreased
23% from last year, reflecting lower net credit losses, as well as a modest reserve release.
On slide 7, we show results for International Consumer Banking in constant dollars. In Asia, revenues
declined 13% year-over-year in the third quarter. Cards revenues declined by 23%, reflecting lower activity

-- 4 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 5
levels with purchase sales down 17% year-over-year. We're continuing to see a disproportionate impact on
Asia card revenues from the decline in travel spending, including lower travel-related interchange and
foreign transaction fees. However, our strength in wealth management continued. We saw record
investment revenues this quarter, up 16% reflecting continued strong client engagement with 7% growth in
Citigold clients and 13% growth in net new money versus last year. And average deposit growth remained
strong at 13% this quarter.
Turning to Latin America. Total consumer revenues declined 10% year-over-year. Similar to other regions,
we saw good growth in deposits in Mexico this quarter, with average balances up 13%. However, deposit
spreads remained under pressure and lending revenues were impacted by branch closures and a continued
decline in the macro environment.
In total, operating expenses for our International Consumer Business were down 1% in the third quarter,
reflecting efficiency savings and lower volume-related expenses. And cost of credit declined to $392 million
with lower net credit losses and a modest reserve release this quarter, reflecting a change in accounting
for third-party collection fees.
Slide 8 provides additional detail on global consumer credit trends. As I noted earlier, credit trends remain
broadly stable to improving this quarter, given high levels of liquidity in the US, lower spending and the
benefits of relief programs. However, we do expect losses to begin to rise next year and likely peak towards
the end of 2021 as government stimulus and other programs roll off and unemployment remained elevated.
Turning now to the Institutional Clients Group on slide 9. ICG delivered EBT of $3.7 billion this quarter and
$10.8 billion year-to-date. Revenues of $10.4 billion increased 5% in the third quarter, as strong
performance in fixed income and equity markets, investment banking and the private bank was partially
offset by lower revenues in TTS, corporate lending and security services.
In the third quarter, we continued to see strong client engagement across all of our institutional businesses,
given our highly differentiated global platform, our progress in creating new digital solutions for clients and
our full-service model, which allows us to capture natural linkages that exist across the franchise.
Turning now to the results for the businesses, starting with banking. Total banking revenues of $5.3 billion
declined 2%. Treasury and Trade Solution revenues of $2.4 billion were down 6% as reported and 4% in
constant dollars as strong client engagement and solid growth in deposits were more than offset by the
impact of lower interest rates and lower commercial cards revenues.
Our average deposits were up 26% in constant dollars, and we had solid growth in underlying drivers
despite the significant macro slowdown. One example of the continued client engagement that we have
seen is in instant payments, where we are now live in 26 countries and have seen significant client demand
for these capabilities.
Investment Banking revenues of $1.4 billion were up 13% from last year, reflecting solid growth in capital
markets and continued share gains. Capital markets continued to be extremely strong, equity underwriting
in particular, which allowed us to continue to support our clients in raising liquidity through IPOs,
convertibles and follow-on offerings.
Private bank revenues of $938 million grew 8%, driven by strong client engagement, particularly in capital
markets, as well as improved managed investment revenues and higher lending. Corporate lending
revenues of $538 million were down 25% as higher volumes were more than offset by lower spreads. And
while we continue to provide new loans and facilitate additional draws, we also saw significant repayments
as we helped our investment-grade clients access capital markets, which led to the decline in end-of-period
loans.

-- 5 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 6
Total Markets and Securities Services revenue of $5.2 billion increased 16% year-over-year. And as we've
seen over the prior two quarters, we continue to actively make markets for both our corporate and investor
clients, as we help them navigate through the continued uncertain environment.
Fixed income revenues of $3.8 billion grew 18%, driven by strong performance across spread products and
commodities. Equities revenues of $875 million were up 15% versus last year as solid performance in cash
equities and derivatives, reflecting strong client volumes and more favorable market conditions, were
partially offset by lower revenues in prime finance.
And finally, in Securities Services, revenues were down 5% on a reported basis and 4% in constant dollars
as higher deposit volumes were more than offset by lower spreads.
Total operating expenses of $5.8 billion increased 3% year-over-year, reflecting continued investments in
infrastructure, risk management and controls as well as higher compensation costs.
Total credit costs of $838 million were up meaningfully from last year, although down significantly on a
sequential basis. We built $529 million in reserves this quarter. The increase is largely due to continued
uncertainty in the economic environment going forward. As of quarter end, our overall funded reserve ratio
was 1.8%, including 5.7% on the non-investment-grade portion. Total net credit losses were $326 million.
Finally, total non-accrual loans declined roughly $400 million sequentially to $3.6 billion, reflecting write-
offs and repayments across the portfolio.
Slide 10 shows the results for Corporate/Other. Revenues declined significantly from last year, reflecting
the wind down of legacy assets and the impact of lower rates as well as marks on securities.
Expenses were up as the wind-down of legacy assets was more than offset by investments in infrastructure,
risk management and controls, incremental costs associated with COVID-19 and the $400 million civil
money penalty that I mentioned earlier. Excluding the one-time impact of the penalty, the pre-tax loss for
Corporate/Other was $657 million this quarter. And looking ahead to the fourth quarter, we would expect a
similar quarterly pre-tax loss.
Slide 11 shows our net interest revenue and margin trends. In constant dollars, total net interest revenue
of $10.5 billion this quarter, declined $930 million year-over-year, reflecting the impact of lower rates and
lower loan balances, partially offset by higher trading-related NIR. On a sequential basis, net interest
revenue declined by roughly $670 million, driven by lower loan balances as well as lower trading-related
NIR. And net interest margin declined 14 basis points, reflecting lower net interest revenues.
Turning to non-interest revenues. In the third quarter, non-NIR declined 2% to $6.8 billion, given lower
levels of consumer activity, partially offset by strong trading and investment banking revenues year-over-
year.
As we look to the fourth quarter, we expect the continuation of these dynamics with both net interest
revenues and non-interest revenues down year-over-year, reflecting the impact of lower rates and lower
levels of activity related to COVID-19, as well as a normalization in trading and investment banking activity.
On slide 12, we show our key capital metrics. Our CET1 capital ratio improved to 11.8% driven by net
income. Our supplementary leverage ratio was 6.8%, and our tangible book value per share grew by 4%
to $71.95, driven by net income.
Before I conclude, let me spend a few minutes on our outlook for the fourth quarter. On the top line, we
expect to see continued pressure in consumer, reflecting the impact of rates and lower levels of activity
related to COVID-19.

-- 6 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 7
And we would also expect the low rate environment to continue to weigh on our accrual businesses in ICG.
Our Markets and Investment Banking businesses should reflect broader industry trends.
In total, we expect this to result in full year revenues that are roughly flat, with the decline in net interest
revenues more or less offset by non-interest revenues on a full year basis, consistent with prior guidance.
On the expense side, we remain focused on protecting our employees and supporting our customers. We
are making targeted investments in the franchise where we see the best opportunities for the future. And
we are accelerating investments to achieve excellence in our risk and control environment and enhance
our operations for a fully digital world. As a result, we could see expenses that are up a couple percent or
so, on a full year basis.
Turning to credit, as I mentioned already, if our macro outlook holds, we wouldn't expect additional reserve
builds. But given the remaining uncertainty, we are also unlikely to see any material releases this quarter.
And for the fourth quarter, we would expect the level of losses similar to those seen this quarter.
In summary, the environment remained challenging this quarter, but we continued to perform well. Year-to-
date, we have demonstrated the significant earnings power of the franchise. We ended the quarter with a
strong capital and liquidity position.
Overall client engagement remains strong. We grew book value this quarter, and we have remained
focused on supporting employees, customers, clients and communities.
With that, Mike and I are happy to take any questions.
QUESTION AND ANSWER
OPERATOR: Your first question is from the line of John McDonald with Autonomous Research.
JOHN MCDONALD: Hi. Good morning. Mike, I just wanted to ask a question. In terms of lessons learned
on the consent order and the need to invest here, I guess the question is why weren't these issues
addressed earlier? Was there a misread of regulatory expectations? Or was management attention and
resources just needed elsewhere and you didn't get to it yet?
MIKE CORBAT: John, over the past decade or so, I think we've done a lot of work in terms of positioning
the firm from both a financial and a strategic perspective. And I think we've made a number of investments
across areas that we felt were critical. And we're going to continue to make targeted investments.
At the Barclays Conference, Mark spoke about our next phase of our transformation. And I think as we kind
of think about that, we have always been focused in terms of how we operate. But I would say, we haven't
gone fast enough, that we feel that – again, I think if you look at COVID in the way we've come through
COVID, I feel quite proud about kind of what we've done. And what we've been able to do. Obviously, not
over.
And we've initiated a number of significant remediation projects along the way to strengthen our controls,
our infrastructure and our governance, but that being said, we didn't do it fast enough. And we've got to
move faster. And that's certainly where we're going to be focused.
I think in terms of what the expectation should be, in terms of how we're going to approach that, I think,
really four pillars that we're going to be focused on. One is the organizational component. And you've seen
us already go at that in terms of the establishment and hiring of our Chief Administrative Office and Officer,
Karen Peetz coming in. And I think creating and putting a framework around the way we'll go at this.

-- 7 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 8
I would say the strategic component, which is really agreeing on what the end state vision for our process
is. And I think being critical. As I said in my opening, we have brought people in to give us an external
assessment of, what needs to be done and where we fell short. And I think it's making sure that the work
that we do comes together across the institution.
So as opposed to simply addressing specific issues, solving holistic problems. I think there's an operational
component behind this in terms of making sure that around things like data and technology, we're driving
the proper automation, the elimination of manual touch points and other things that we've spoken about.
And I think importantly, the fourth component is the cultural piece.
And making sure that all the businesses, all the regions, all the functions, understand that it's everyone's
responsibility to get this right. So I would say it hasn't, John, been from lack of effort and commitment to it.
But I would say that we certainly could have and should have worked smarter around getting to the end
point.
JOHN MCDONALD: Okay. That's helpful and then a follow-up for Mark. Mark, obviously, with the consent
orders and the work required, additional expense and investment will be needed in the coming years. Do
you still think you can make progress closing the profitability gap to peers?
Will that still be a goal? And also if you can't do significant M&A or portfolio acquisitions, are there
opportunities potentially to slim down and simplify the company over time that could help profitability?
Thanks.
MARK MASON: Yeah. Thanks, John. So the answer is yes. I mean our intent is, over time, to continue to
narrow the gap, to continue to increase profitability, improve returns over time. And so that hasn't changed.
With every crisis, in some ways, comes a unique opportunity, and that is a unique opportunity to take a
hard look at your business model. And you see corporations around the world having to think through that
as they manage through this crisis. And similarly, we will – with the benefit of a new incoming CEO and as
well as managing through this crisis, we'll continue to look at our business model, continue to look at our
strategy and see what makes sense as we come out of this and how we can best capture opportunities to
serve our clients.
JOHN MCDONALD: Okay. Thanks. And one quick follow-up. Is it clear to you what will be deemed
significant acquisitions or portfolio additions versus ordinary course, or is that something that's still to be
defined?
MARK MASON: Yeah. It's still to be defined, but there are some things that are obvious in terms of BAU
activity, in terms of securitizations and other types of activities that we do within different parts of the
franchise. But we still have to define what significant means and get regulatory agreement on that.
JOHN MCDONALD: Okay. Thank you.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Glenn Schorr with Evercore ISI.
GLENN SCHORR: Hi, there.
MIKE CORBAT: Hey, Glenn, good morning.
GLENN SCHORR: Good morning. Just a quick follow-up on the consent. Just are the expenses going to
be inside of Corporate/Other and outside of the businesses? And then related to the question - is it clear to
you that if and when the group comes off capital return suspension that you will be able to act as any of the
other banks will act on the capital return front?

-- 8 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 9
MARK MASON: Yeah, sure. In terms of the first question, as you heard me mention before, we're spending
more than $1 billion in terms of incremental spend in 2020. That is split between Corporate as well as some
of the other businesses depending on the nature of the spend. I would expect that as we go forward, it will
be a similar dynamic. Again, depending on the nature of the spend, would be booked in Corporate/Other
or in some of the respective – or one of the respective businesses. To give a quick example, in some of the
consulting spend that we do that is meant to help scope out end state vision for a key process, for example,
we'd likely book that in Corporate/Other. It would serve to benefit the entire franchise. And so, that's just
one example.
In terms of capital actions going forward, there's nothing in the consent order that prevents us from making
capital action decisions and taking capital action decisions going forward, and so we would expect that we'd
be able to act similarly to our peers as we come out of this crisis.
GLENN SCHORR: I appreciate that. One quick one on cards, if I could. You're down double-digits, well
into double-digits in Asia and Mexico, but just overall, I wonder if you could parse out how much you think
that's the macro environment and some of the obvious that you've already spoken on? Because what we're
trying to build back to is what takes us to the other side where we have a bottoming out and building off of
bottom and that includes how you're marketing. Meaning, are promo and teasers on hold given the macro
backdrop and how you're marketing into the banking base? Thanks.
MARK MASON: Yeah. So, look, there are a couple of different dynamics that I think are important. I think
the key one you hit on, which is we're still in the midst of a crisis. And so, we're very much still seeing
pressure on purchase sales. It's better than it was in the prior quarters, but there certainly is still pressure
there. We're seeing that across the franchise.
One of the big drags this quarter you see is Retail Services. That's in part tied to the partner and revenue
sharing that we have with partners where an improved forecast in loss expectations ends up resulting in us
sharing more revenues with the partners. But the dynamic that's important to watch as this plays through
is how unemployment, how GDP evolves and what that means in the way of purchase activity starting to
pick up, and that's going to be an important factor.
We are keeping a close watch on that. We have dialed back advertising, marketing spend, BALCONs, et
cetera, et cetera. And we want to be thoughtful about when we leg back in as we see signs of things turning.
And so, we keep a close watch on that. We don't want to be late to that. And we'll be very proactive at
getting after it where it makes sense and testing it where we think we're seeing good signals that warrant
us increasing some of that spend to drive some of the future volume activity that we see. But as of right
now, we're seeing the pressure on volumes that's really a direct byproduct of the crisis we're managing
through.
GLENN SCHORR: Thanks, Mark.
MARK MASON: Yeah.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Jim Mitchell with Seaport Global.
JIM MITCHELL: Hey, good morning.
MARK MASON: Good morning.
JIM MITCHELL: Good morning. Maybe just a question, a follow-up on expenses. You guys have done a
pretty good job over the last few years sort of investing – spending on investment and offsetting with
efficiency saves. Obviously, that may not happen perfectly this year because of the incremental spend.
How do we think about that going forward? Does this ramp-up start to stabilize next year and you can kind
of get back on that path, or how do we think about beyond 4Q?

-- 9 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 10
MARK MASON: Yeah. So, look, I think that, as I mentioned, we've got an incremental spend of about $1
billion this year that has gone towards infrastructure, risk and controls. We started that incremental spend
path, if you will, in 2019. So, to some extent, in our run rate is more spend towards those types of activities.
There will be an opportunity to look at that spend - the $1 billion - and recalibrate it or point it in a different
direction or reprioritize the spend. There's some of it that is a one-year spend that we’ll have an opportunity
to spend again, so to speak, as we get into 2021, and we'll take advantage of that opportunity.
The order requires, I think, a very important step, which is that we step back and come up with a target end-
state vision for some of these key processes and the risk management controls and compliance around
them. And I highlight that step because we need to do that in order to appropriately dimension the
reprioritization of the spend we already have in our expense base and what incremental spend is necessary.
And so, we'll do that over the time period that's been allotted to us within the order. It is an investment. And
I highlight that because many of the things that Mike described in terms of automation, in terms of reduced
manual touch points, in terms of straight-through processing. Many of those things will yield benefits in the
way we run our organization, in the way we not only improve our operations, but in the way we're able to
go to market and compete and serve our clients.
And so, I do expect benefits to accrue from these investments down the line. And we will separate and
away from that, because I won't compromise the dollars needed in order to make those improvements in
those investments. Separate and away from that, we will continue to be responsible managers of the firm,
and that means ensuring that we look across the franchise to ensure that we're spending wisely.
JIM MITCHELL: Okay. That's helpful. And maybe just pivoting to NII. I appreciate the year-over-year
guidance, but where and when do you see it kind of stabilizing given where the rate picture is right now?
MARK MASON: Yeah. So, look, I mean, there are obviously a lot of factors that play through the quarter
and 2020. The combination of not only rates, but the volumes that have played through are all important
factors here, let alone the amount of liquidity that's in the market and the impact that has on the balance
sheet. I'd expect for NIR to stabilize and stay relatively flat as we go into the remainder of the year, assuming
current trends kind of play out.
We project some NIR growth on the accrual businesses as hopefully COVID diminishes a little bit. However,
as I've said before, the Markets NIR could be somewhat volatile. So, a little bit hard to predict, as you well
know. But we're looking at stabilization as we come through the end of the year here.
JIM MITCHELL: Okay. Thank you.
MARK MASON: Yeah.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Mike Mayo with Wells Fargo Securities.
MIKE MAYO: Hi.
MIKE CORBAT: Hey, Mike.
MIKE MAYO: My question is for Mike. Look, Mike, we've agreed a lot about Citi's improved resiliency. Since
you started, Citi is simpler, stronger and safer. And you can look at the CDS spreads - they were 4 times
wider than when you came in as CEO, and that's progress. But what we've disagreed on is the pace and
need for more restructuring. And so the question is, where is the sense of urgency?
Speaking on behalf of investors, people I speak with, there's a collective sense of extreme disappointment
with technology, the new regulatory order in tech, the root problems were not transparent to investors. On

-- 10 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 11
execution, you didn't go fast enough. And you said this new tech fix will take time. On the business mix,
many questions continue on why you have this global consumer footprint, which has terrible efficiency. And
returns, worst-in-class - RoTCE this quarter, 8%. Even if we give you the 12% from last year, that's still
below the 19% of JPMorgan this quarter alone. So, where is the sense of urgency? So, recognizing the
improvement that you've had with the balance sheet, but still a long way to go with strategy, why not step
aside now and have the new CEO, Jane Fraser, take over as a way to demonstrate the increased sense
of urgency? Thank you.
MIKE CORBAT: Sure. Yeah. So I would start out, Mike, by saying that I think it is important to the board,
it's important to the company that we have a real transition. As you recall, my transition was about five
minutes. And as part of this process, I did commit to the board that I'd stay throughout the year and close
out the three-year plan, which we announced in 2017. We are starting the transition now. And I think that
allows Jane to be very much involved in terms of our financial plan. And if you recall, when I started, I
thought it was important kind of going into the budget and planning process that the CEO own that. I think
I was fortunate in terms of my timing of coming in of that being the case. And I think with Jane coming in,
that will very much be the case because she will be accountable for delivering next year and into the future.
I think it's also important that Jane has taken on the transformation work and working on the gap analysis
and other related things to the consent order as part of that. By the way, Jane continues to have a day job
in terms of running Consumer. She's also overseeing our return to the office in terms of our North America
business, and I think the orderly transition is the right thing to do.
I think in terms of the accomplishments, I appreciate what you said in terms of some of the acknowledgment.
But again, kind of grounding where we started, net income increased from $7.5 billion to the end of last
year, north of $19 billion. Our return on assets went from 39 basis points to right about 100 basis points.
Our return on tangible common equity, yes, still behind our peers, went from 5% to 12%, but went a long
way towards closing that gap. We went from returning hardly any capital in 2012 to returning nearly $80
billion over the last six years and reducing our share count by about 30%.
And so, I don't think you accomplish those things without a sense of commitment and a sense of urgency.
And I feel great about the team that's in place and their commitment to that. And so, I think we have made
significant progress and I think Jane's got a foundation to build on from that. And I think she and the team
will be kind of focused on those things. And again, I think coming out of COVID, as Mark talked about here,
or as and when we come out of COVID in the environment, I think there's things that they can take
advantage of, and I think they will, and I think they'll certainly act with that sense of urgency.
MIKE MAYO: Well, as my one follow-up, what can Citi do to show more alignment with shareholders?
Because despite all those improvements, the stock is still trading at about half of book value - where it was
eight years ago since Citi was formed or since 2000. CEO comp is just shy of $400 million, when you have
worst-in-class stock price performance. So, whether it's pay in stock or – I mean, these problems didn't
come out overnight that the regulator has identified. So, it's just you're on a path, and now all of a sudden,
we find out that the engine underneath the company wasn't as strong as it should be.
And we just – I think we, speaking with the investors I speak with, feel as though shareholders are a
secondary consideration after all the other constituencies. And what symbolically can Citi do if you're not
going to step aside and have Jane take the reins sooner, what else can Citi do to show that shareholders
actually matter instead of waiting for another maybe three to four-year plan?
MIKE CORBAT: Well, shareholders absolutely do matter, Mike. And if you kind of look at throughout the
firm, whether it's the pay structure, employees and in particular, more highly paid employees getting paid
significantly in stock or stock-related type of instruments, of the different programs and scorecards being
very linked to how we perform and the things that, hopefully, over time drive share performance.

-- 11 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 12
And again, I think there's no one thing in particular. And so, I think getting those metrics right is critical. I
know the board, I know the Compensation Committee all work hard in terms of trying to create that
alignment. And again, I think from a disclosure perspective, we've been very public and transparent in terms
of the metrics and the scorecard process that leadership and broader management has held to at the firm.
MIKE MAYO: All right. If I can squeeze in one more just for Mark, as you – I mean, obviously, disappointed
with the execution, strategy, controls, transparency. But just looking forward now with the financials. As far
as the expenses, Mark, you were already asked about this, you're already spending $1 billion. You say
some of this is a one-year spend. I guess, you have to do a review, so you don't really know the exact
spending to fix these problems, but should we think of $1 billion, should we think of $2 billion, is it bigger
than a bread box?
Again, when we hear, it's not a quick fix, it's not an easy fix, it's going to take a while. People's imaginations
run wild. Is this $10 billion? Is it $5 billion? Somehow, frame this the best that you can, again, given that
you're at the early stages of a more full review.
MARK MASON: Yeah, Mike, what I would say is – look, if you look back, we have been, I think, quite
responsible at managing our investments over the past number of years. And what people should expect
is that we'll continue to be responsible around that. The second thing I'd say is that these are investments,
as I said earlier. I think they are necessary investments to improve the way we operate and our ability to
compete. And these are investments that we're going to make, right? It's hard to pinpoint a number, as
you've said. I would expect, as I mentioned earlier to an earlier question, that we will continue to increase
our profitability, we will continue to improve our returns. But I can't dimension the number for you next year
or the year after, except to say we are still running the firm. We have performed, I think, quite well through
this crisis. There is still a crisis for us to manage through, and we will continue to do that with a focus on
our clients and responsible management of our overall financials. And when we get more clarity on the
actual spend and as we get through the budget that's here and the response to the order, I'm sure I'll be
able to give you more color on that.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Matt O'Connor with Deutsche Bank.
MATT O’CONNOR: Good morning. First, thanks for taking all the questions. I guess, it doesn't sound like
Jane is on the call, which is fine. It's not surprising. But when should we expect to hear from her in terms of
the transition and kind of her thoughts on the regulatory issues and process forward?
MIKE CORBAT: Yeah. I think we should let her kind of get her feet under her and go through some of
these processes and get educated and start to form her opinions as I described. And so, we'll probably start
to introduce her on the January call in terms of maybe having more view towards a forward look. And then,
obviously, the quarter after that, she'll have the reins.
MATT O’CONNOR: That makes sense. And then understanding that there could be more kind of views in
the room, so to speak, but for now, just the thoughts on addressing the regulatory issues, is that a matter
of spending money and fixing the processes? You did kind of allude to, there could be some strategic
changes. So, is this the business model that you think Citigroup will have going forward or more structural
changes potentially coming to address the regulatory issues and better position the company?
MARK MASON: Let me perhaps try and clarify the earlier comment. So, to be clear, we have, as Mike
described, a consent order that we need to address. And I think importantly, when you look at that consent
order, it is an opportunity for us to take a step back and look at these key processes and the infrastructure,
controls and compliance activity that support them. So, that's kind of one important step that as responsible
managers of the franchise, we intend to execute against, and some of that we've begun already, and that
was referenced in the consent orders.

-- 12 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 13
Separate and away from that, what I was alluding to was just simply put the idea that we are in a crisis, and
as you go through a crisis, you learn things about your business. And as I mentioned, we talk to clients all
the time. They're learning things about their business as they manage through this crisis. We're learning
things about and identifying opportunities about our business. For example, the investments that we've
made in digital have turned out to be very wise investments as we manage through this crisis. What are the
opportunities to accelerate that type of spend as we go forward, given the acceptance of digitization has
probably been accelerated by a couple of years now.
The importance of revenue mix and growing our fee-based revenue or the traction that our wealth
management business is getting in this type of environment presents opportunities for us to look at how we
can expand that aspect of our business and business model. So, the crisis will create and has created an
opportunity for us to take another look.
On top of that, with any new CEO, I think, you would expect an opportunity for that person to take a step
back and take a look at the business that we have, take a look at the environment that we're playing into
and to make an assessment as to what the right path forward is in light of where we think the growth
trajectory is and where we think the return opportunities are. And so, that is the other leg that with Jane
coming in, in February, I'm sure she will want to take that opportunity and see what comes of that. So,
hopefully, that clarifies the point.
MATT O’CONNOR: Yes, it does. Thanks for the color.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Erika Najarian with Bank of America.
ERIKA NAJARIAN: Hi. Good morning.
MARK MASON: Good morning.
ERIKA NAJARIAN: Mark, I apologize, but I'm going to have to re-ask the question that you've been asked
many times, and I'm wondering if this could be a successful attempt. But as we think about productivity
savings versus investments in risk management for 2021, is $11.9 billion – or rather, $10.9 billion, a good
starting point in terms of how we should think about quarterly expenses as we think about the next several
quarters?
MARK MASON: Well, the expenses that we have in the quarter that you reference include, obviously, a
$400 million civil money penalty that's part of that, that's booked in operating expenses. And in terms of
2021, we're in the midst of constructing our plan right now. And so, hard for me to give you an exact number
or run rate number for you to forecast in 2021. So, sorry to disappoint, but I don't have much beyond the
way I've answered that question already.
ERIKA NAJARIAN: Okay. And I guess my second question is to Mike. And I think it's always hard to call
out competitors by name. But going back to Mike Mayo's set of questions, the questions that we as analysts
got ever since that Journal article came out, is why isn't Citigroup the new Wells Fargo in terms of regulatory
issues? And many investors pointed out that when your consent order came out last week that the asset
cap and business activity limitation for Wells actually came out two years after the consent order.
And without listing the things that you've already accomplished and perhaps just looking forward, how can
you reassure your current investors and prospective investors that you're not going down the same
laborious regulatory remediation route as one of your peers, which could clearly be impactful in terms of
business activity restrictions?
MIKE CORBAT: Sure. So, I would say one very important part of that, Erika, is what we spoke about in
terms of no widespread customer harm. The company did not profit from the activities, and you can kind of
go on with that. I think the second piece is that around customer harm and around some of those things,

-- 13 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 14
there were not just Wells Fargo, but there were kind of widespread industry deep dives into sales practices
and other pieces in here.
I think in this, you've seen, and we've talked about the four areas of focus and where we're going to be
spending our time. And we've been asked to do the gap analysis. We've obviously been at this for a while,
and we will obviously do a good extensive gap analysis. But I think we've got a kind of reasonable idea.
And again, we're open to the findings that come from that in terms of the things that need to be done. And
I think that, as importantly, in there is kind of the understanding of the process failures that got us here.
Again, no fraud, no customer harm, no benefit around that.
And if I could just go back and touch on the question that you asked Mark, I think an important way to think
about it is, historically, you've heard us kind of speak to the way that we've gone at the expense side of
things is really working hard to offset the costs that we've been putting out there in terms of some of this
transformation work.
I think the way you're going to hear us talk about it and the way you should think about it is those are
separate streams. The remediation work will cost what it will cost, but don't think as a result of that, there's
still not significant work that we recognize that we can do from a business improvement process. And so,
we're not linking the two as those necessarily being offsetting, but we will continue to work on those things
to better the efficiencies of the company away from this.
I think the second piece is that, that while we're not speaking to it, we've referenced it, I think that this work
will have – this transformation will have an ROI in terms of what this allows us to do and do differently. We
talked about from the client and customer perspective, the business process in terms of the way we
aggregate data, the way that we kind of move risk and controls through the firm in a more automated way,
we think gives us the ability not just to improve the process, but we do think that over time it will have a
return in terms of the benefits and costs that are associated with those, both directly and indirectly.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Steven Chubak with Wolfe Research.
STEVEN CHUBAK: Hi. Good morning.
MARK MASON: Good morning.
STEVEN CHUBAK: So, maybe a question for Mark pertaining to capital. One of the things that has
happened recently is that the advanced CET1 has now become your binding constraint. And one of the key
questions that we've been getting or – and was an expectation that we would see a significant uptick in
RWAs relating to operational risk. And it looks like that generally speaking, there hasn't been much
movement in terms of RWA divergence. And I was hoping you could speak to whether the impact from
recent events has fully reflected in that number, or whether we could see a further upward pressure in the
fourth quarter?
MARK MASON: Sure. Yeah – you're speaking to the civil money penalty. The answer is yes, we have
reflected our estimates of the impact in the RWA for operational risk associated with that. And just given
how it falls in terms of the level, the magnitude of the impact relative to other operational risk, there was not
a material change in the RWA as a result of it.
STEVEN CHUBAK: Got it. Okay. And then, just one follow-up, Mark, relating to discussion about
profitability targets and the need to – and the desire to close the gap with peers and that's still your intent.
This year, you've planned to do an Investor Day. It was delayed due to, well, COVID and the consent order
and a CEO transition. Does the management team intend to provide refresh targets in the coming months?
And are there any plans to actually hold an Investor Day so you could provide a more fulsome update? I
know it's challenging to answer without Jane on the call, but I was hoping to get some perspective as to

-- 14 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 15
how we should think about the timing for when we can get at least some updated targets to hold the
management team accountable to?
MARK MASON: Yeah. No, again, that's a – as you said, that's a tough question to answer. I would like to
give, obviously, Jane the opportunity to get in the seat and to work through some of the things that Mike
has referenced and I've referenced earlier. Obviously, in the fourth quarter – at least historically in the fourth
quarter, we've tried to give some context not only for full year performance, but in terms of what we're
seeing in the market going forward. We'll see how this fourth quarter plays out. And obviously, on the fourth
quarter earnings call, we'll give an updated perspective on what we think performance might look like in
2021, and also the timing for which we can give you a more comprehensive view on how we think about
things going forward.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Saul Martinez with UBS.
SAUL MARTINEZ: Hey, guys. Good morning.
MARK MASON: Hey, Saul.
SAUL MARTINEZ: So, I'm sorry, I'm going to beat a dead horse even more here with the consent order
and potential applications on costs. But I know it's hard to know what the time horizon is around this in
terms of having more color. And it's clear you want to take this seriously and you're not going to skimp, but
these processes can be expensive. And as you know, you do have to improve outcomes in the short term
and that has expenses, but build more systematic solutions to operational risk efficiencies which require
longer- term investments and whatnot.
So, with all of that, how – I mean, when do you think you will know what you're up against? And when I say
what you're up against, I mean, meaning the – not only the incremental expenses, and I'm not just talking
about 2021, but just in absolute terms, how much you're going to have to spend to fix these issues and the
time horizon to fix these issues? When do you think you'll have better handle on the multitude of different
dimensions to this?
MARK MASON: Yeah. So, let me try and go at this again. So, look, we have – we spend, call it, $42 billion,
$43 billion a year in terms of total expenses. You've heard me reference about $9 billion of that is associated
with technology and maybe half of whatever is associated with kind of compensation. But I'd highlight that
to say that we obviously have a large expense base, one that we've been managing very diligently over the
past number of years. And with that expense base, there are a couple of different areas that I think are
useful to point out as we think about the incremental need.
So, one is the $1 billion-plus in incremental spend that we've made, and as I mentioned earlier, the
opportunity to re-spend those dollars, to reprioritize those dollars. There's also a spend that we make on
the current operations and infrastructure that we make every year. And that too I think will give us an
opportunity to relook at that spend, that base and reprioritize that spend, right? So, there are multiple
categories where we can repoint, if you will, to a better approach of addressing what's been highlighted in
the order. And it's not until we kind of work through the incremental that's already in there, the base that
rolls off and gives us an opportunity to re-spend that we then are faced with, okay, what more is required
around the investment.
Now, a couple of percentage points of an increase is pretty significant in the way of absolute dollars that
can be put to work on these types of initiatives. In terms of the when, well, let me get one of them. And then
the second thing I'd highlight is, as Mike pointed out, separate and away from the required spend to address
the opportunity or the investment in infrastructure, risk and controls, there also remains opportunities for us
to look at our data centers, for us to – to look at that where we have – to ensure the right placement of
people around the organization, so our footprint, for us to look at some of the roll-off from some of the

-- 15 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 16
COVID spend that we've had to make this year. So, there are other opportunities for us to look at dollars
that we have, let alone capacity adjustments that may be warranted coming out of this COVID-19.
And so, what I'm trying to highlight is that there are many puts and takes through the budget process that
we're constructing now and the process that we will use to dimension the spend associated with this order.
In terms of timing, the order actually points out that we've got some 120 days or so to identify the gap, a
gap between our current state and an end state target, and then some 90 days or so to develop and have
a plan approved, after which we can move towards executing or continuing to execute against.
And so, that gives you some sense for how we're thinking about the timing and the dimensioning of this.
But again, I think we've got a track record now, as has been pointed out, of being very thoughtful and
responsible around investment dollars and our total expense base. And you and others and shareholders
should expect that we will continue to be disciplined and responsible as it relates to that. And again, as I
mentioned earlier, we're looking to improve profitability and returns as we do this.
SAUL MARTINEZ: Okay. No, that's helpful. And hopefully, you'll be able to succeed on that latter point.
Just a quick follow-up and a little bit more of a mundane question. I think just more of a correction or a
clarification; I think you mentioned, Mark, in the fourth quarter, that Corporate/Other pre-tax losses should
be similar to this quarter. Did I get that right because you obviously had the civil fee in that – in this quarter?
So, can you sort of clarify that?
MARK MASON: Yeah. So, ex the $400 million. So, I said roughly the $657 million that we see, excluding
the $400 million civil money penalty is likely to be the levels that we see in the fourth quarter.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Ken Usdin with Jefferies.
KEN USDIN: Thanks. Good morning. Mark, if I could go to a different topic, you mentioned that you don't
really expect NCOs to start peaking until the end of next year. I was just wondering if that's just a time shift
difference. And can you just kind of walk us through how you're expecting the loss curve generally to appear
over the next year or so? Thanks.
MARK MASON: Yeah, sure. So, again, it's – when you look across the portfolio, we're seeing payment
rates coming in higher than we expected. And consumers are proving to be quite resilient when you think
about the stimulus and the forbearance programs that have been in place. And so, as we look at loss curves
and delinquency buckets and what they're suggesting over the next number of quarters, it looks as though
at the aggregate level, we're likely to see losses towards the fourth quarter or back-end of 2021.
Obviously, assumptions around GDP, assumptions around unemployment, all of those factors come into
play, but that is, in fact, what we're seeing. That's going to vary by regions. And so, in Asia, in LATAM, we
may see that earlier, but what I was referencing in the back end was kind of when you look at the aggregate
portfolio.
KEN USDIN: Got it. Okay. And if I could follow up on a question on just taxes, obviously, when taxes went
down, you guys had to write down the DTA. And just in terms of the outlook, at least from what we know
about a potential rise to 28%, depending on the outcome of the election and the eventual plans, any ideas
of what type of impact a directional change might have to the others – to the positive in terms of either tax
rate and being able to write back up the DTA?
MARK MASON: Sure. So, hard to know exactly what happens, but in the event that we did see or we do
see a tax rate increase to 28% or so, and it went into effect in the latter part of 2021, it would likely result in
our DTA increasing by about $4 billion, so a one-time increase in our DTA of about $4 billion. It obviously
would have the impact of our rate being close to that level, our tax rate being close to that level and as a
result of that, less income, given the higher tax rate, less income contributing to the CET1 ratio.

-- 16 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 17
And then, in terms of the disallowed DTA, with a higher corporate tax rate, we would expect to return to our
usage levels of roughly $1 billion per year. So, that gives you a little bit of a sense of a couple of the moving
pieces, should that happen.
MIKE CORBAT: And Mark, I think an important nuance there is what comes out between remaining
territorial, or a reversion to global taxation. I think what people are talking about today is it would likely
remain territorial, which, again, with average global tax rate of about 25%, that would certainly benefit us in
some of the jurisdictions that we operate in.
MARK MASON: That's a good point. Yeah.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Brian Kleinhanzl with KBW.
BRIAN KLEINHANZL: Great. Thanks. Can I just ask one quick question first on the NII? I heard you saying
that it's going to be stabilizing after the fourth quarter as you look out to 2021. But can you kind of just
outline some of the factors that are leading to that stability? I mean what gives you confidence that it's
actually be stable off that level? Did you think about the potential for stimulus and maybe further consumer
deleveraging if we get stimulus in that statement? Thanks.
MARK MASON: Yeah. And so, look, again, that is based on kind of current trends that we're seeing in
terms of roughly improving unemployment and improving GDP. Obviously, there is talk of another stimulus,
in terms of its impact, we've assumed that kind of a bit later in terms of in the first quarter of 2021. It does
assume that we continue to see the purchase sales activity improve quarter-over-quarter.
We've seen some of that certainly in Q3. We continue to see that as we look even in the early days of
October. And so, that playing out would be another important factor. And then, obviously, what happens in
terms of the overall liquidity that's in the market is a factor that influences mix and the NIM as well.
BRIAN KLEINHANZL: So, maybe just second question on the NIM. I mean, if you think about the yields
on the earning asset side, I mean, are you getting closer to the trough yields as you think about the repricing
cycle? And where rates are, they stabilized at a low level, so are you kind of expecting earning asset yields
to be closer to a bottom as well? Thanks.
MARK MASON: Yeah. So, look, in terms of the NIM, we've seen some of the, obviously, the pressure from
rates. We've seen the pressure in terms of the market, in terms of the mix of assets that we have, but also
pressure in terms of the deposit levels coming in quite high with, frankly, a lack of loan demand to put that
to work. And so, subject to how that liquidity that's in the market evolves, and what happens with ultimate
asset pricing is going to have an important factor on that.
The NIM is really an output of how those NIR revenues play out and how the balance sheet evolves. And
so, a bit of continued uncertainty a little bit in terms of how some of those market factors play out, but we
see that as well stabilizing towards the end of the year.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Jeff Harte with Piper Sandler.
JEFF HARTE: Good afternoon, guys. Unfortunately, I have one more consent order kind of related
question. Do you have a feel for regulators' views on the adequacy of existing remediation projects that
have been underway, versus just not having moved fast enough?
MIKE CORBAT: Sure. So, I would say that, not have moved fast enough and not have been holistic enough,
Jeff, to use my words. And so, again, I think this gap analysis will give us a better sense of that. But again,
as I said, we've brought others in to help us look at and think about these things. And so, again, we'll see
what the final analysis yields. But I think we've got a sense of the right approach and direction.

-- 17 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 18
JEFF HARTE: Not necessarily you're starting over?
MIKE CORBAT: Boadly defined, no. There may be some more refined areas where it may make sense to
do that, but not broadly. And again, I think if you look at kind of how, as an example, we've kind of managed
through this crisis, which I think is a good real life live test, again, I think we've been able to get the data,
we've been able to make the right decisions, we've been able to act in a timely manner. But again, I think
this pandemic has shown us the accelerated move to digital and the ability to continue to work remotely or
more remotely over time and the ability to make faster and better decisions is critical. And in particular, as
I think appropriately, our regulators continue to raise the bar on the larger institutions in terms of their
expectations.
JEFF HARTE: Okay. And just kind of something fundamental, Mexico is a relatively large exposure for
Citigroup and a geography upon which the market has some macroeconomic concerns. Can you talk a bit
about the credit-related trends you're specifically seeing down in the business in Mexico? And kind of maybe
what your expectations are? Or how much things like deferrals have helped down there?
MARK MASON: Yeah, sure. So, I mean, look, Mexico, similar to other parts of the world also had
forbearance as part of the program, although, unlike the US, in Mexico, customers needed to be less than
30 days past due as of the end of February to be eligible.
And so, what we saw is that when you look at our loss rates for the quarter, you see a tick-up in Latin
America, largely driven by Mexico and the impact of those customers kind of playing through the
delinquency buckets and into losses. That said, Mexico also comes with a higher NIM, in the way of overall
performance. And we would expect for losses there to certainly come to a peak sooner than the end of
2021.
In terms of more broadly, our exposure in Mexico is about $57 billion in terms of total country exposure.
And that's down a little bit since the second quarter. At the end of the third quarter, about $30 billion of
loans between GCB and ICG in Mexico, $13 billion are consumer loans, about $16 billion are corporate
loans. And about half of that $13 billion, a little bit more than half is in credit card and personal loans.
And remember, we tend to target a higher-quality customer segment than most of our peers there, and we
price the risk accordingly. And so, we would expect for that to play out in a relatively favorable way.
And then, there's another 81% of our payroll loans in the portfolio are concentrated in sectors that have a
lower risk of layoffs like government employers and pensioners. And so, that too should be helpful as we
think about the quality of our book. And then, there's the portion that's in mortgages is – it weights towards
LTVs less than 50%. And so, that too should – speaks to the quality of our book. So, overall, we feel as
though we're appropriately reserved, and are managing reasonable levels of performance there.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Charles Peabody with Portales.
CHARLES PEABODY: Yeah. I just had some follow-up questions on net interest revenue guidance. You
kept using the word stabilization as we enter 2021. So, my first question is, does that imply further weakness
in the fourth quarter before it stabilizes?
And then the related question, on page 11, you show the mix of net interest revenue between the core bank
and then the markets related. And you saw a big drop in the markets-related net interest revenue. And I
was wondering if you can talk about what drove that. And is – which of those pieces do you expect to
stabilize first?

-- 18 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 19
MARK MASON: Yeah. And so, just to be clear, the stabilization that I was referring to is kind of as we go
into the fourth quarter. And so, I'd expect net interest revenue to stabilize in the fourth quarter for total Citi
and for many of the factors that I mentioned already.
Look, the markets revenue, as you've heard me mention before, it's really important to look at total revenue.
The total revenue there, in part because the nature of how transactions are structured with clients, impacts
whether that revenue is coming in the form of NIR and non-NIR. And so, I think it's very important to, as I
mentioned, look at total revenue there.
And our total revenue in the quarter, as I mentioned earlier, is up in terms of in total markets revenue, in
light of the strong fixed income and the strong equities performance that we saw there. And so, that part is
lower than the prior quarter as we see some of that normalization in markets take place, but still very strong
in light of the environment that we're managing through.
And candidly, as we go into a fourth quarter, with an election and in the case of Europe, Brexit and
speculation around the stimulus and uncertainty around vaccines, hard to predict exactly how customers,
clients decide to reposition their books as some of those things become clearer. And so, total revenue in
the way of markets revenue is the way we think about it. And a fourth quarter that I think will show NIR
revenue stabilizing, but keep in mind, markets performance will likely have puts and takes.
CHARLES PEABODY: And my follow-up question, let me just ask that same question about mix between
markets-related NII and core bank. Would you expect the core bank NII to actually grow in the fourth quarter
sequentially?
MARK MASON: Well, again, I would expect that our fourth quarter will show net interest revenues and non-
net interest revenues kind of down year-over-year but the aggregate of the two relatively stable.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Vivek Juneja with JPMorgan.
VIVEK JUNEJA: Thanks for taking my questions.
MARK MASON: Good morning.
VIVEK JUNEJA: Good morning. Mike, on the whole regulatory issue, it's quite disappointing to read in the
consent orders that the incentive comp did not account for risk management and the comments about the
practices that the regulators made. Given that, what changes should we expect in senior management
incentive comp? And can you talk about why you didn't prioritize risk management, which is such a
cornerstone since the last crisis? And what changes should we expect in the board as well as other senior
executives as a result?
MIKE CORBAT: So, the notion of accountability and I think what they're speaking to goes more broad than
just the executive management team. But obviously, you've got a number of work streams here. You've got
a fair number of people involved in those processes. And it's kind of taking it down and kind of making sure
that the people who are responsible for each of those processes have the appropriate weighting.
And I think the challenge comes that in many of the instances or in many of the work streams, you actually
have people that it isn't their sole job. They are a practicing expert or a practicing practitioner in terms of
the markets business or in consumer or in different functions. And we have seconded them as part of their
job into doing this regulatory work because they're the expert, they're the area through which a number of
these things would flow.
And the question is, how do you create the proper balance and proper accountability around that? So, I
don't look at it and say that it's just the executive team. I think it's striking the right balance. And so, as an
example, should someone in risk be responsible for delivering on financials of the firm, profitability,

-- 19 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 20
expenses or other pieces that are in there. And so, I think it's kind of creating the right balance to drive the
right behaviors, get the right outcomes in people in both directions properly. So, again, I think that it's – the
way it's written, it's – my interpretation is it's actually broader than the way you've described it.
VIVEK JUNEJA: Okay. And so, does that mean you'll be adding more people do you think as a result to
be able to hold some people fully responsible for this? Or how are you thinking as you look forward?
MIKE CORBAT: Well, we have, in risk and controls, we've added thousands of people since the beginning
of the year and we were adding people last year to these projects. So, without a doubt, we've been bringing
those resources and getting that expertise in. And we've tried to bring in subject matter experts from other
firms, from other industries to help us as we think about these things.
And I think we've made a number of very key strong external hires. I think we've made some very strong
internal moves in terms of people. And I think we've also moved strongly in terms of, what I would say,
single hatting people, i.e. making this remediation not just their primary, but in many case, their sole
responsibility in terms of delivering on. So, again, yes, we're absolutely committed to having the right
resources, the right expertise, the right talent and then having the right accountability around delivering
against this.
MARK MASON: And Mike, you may have mentioned, but Karen Peetz, obviously, we brought in as the
CAO and to help kind of lead in this transformation across the organization. So, as you say, we're bringing
in the people that we need and getting after it.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Betsy Graseck with Morgan Stanley.
BETSY GRASECK: Hi. Good morning.
MARK MASON: Good morning.
MIKE CORBAT: Hey, Betsy.
BETSY GRASECK: Yeah. So, like you just mentioned, Karen was brought in in June. And Mike, I know
you became CEO of the Citibank USA legal entity back in June timeframe. So, I guess I'm kind of looking
at all this thinking, you must have expected – you've been working on this for a while and I was thinking
you probably expected some kind of requirement from the regulators that you were already partially
executing on. Is that fair? Like, is this consent order might be a surprise to the Street, but is it really a
surprise to you?
MIKE CORBAT: Well, around these work streams, as we've acknowledged, we have been working on
them for a while. So, it's not like all of a sudden, we woke up one day and said, gee, we're going to go at
some of these things as de novo or new projects. So, we've been working on them for a while. And I would
say that, again, what we've been focused on is really bringing these projects together.
I would say, a historic approach that we've taken is we've gone at these, in some ways, serially or
individually. And I don't think that has yielded the outcomes that either I – either Citi or our regulators
necessarily would want. And so, as we went down this path, it became apparent to me and, I think, the
board and others that we needed to really join these processes and create a body to be able to go at it.
And I think we're very fortunate to have Karen with us, who has been through some of this and have this
expertise to be able to, I think, bring these work streams together.
Because when you think about data, as an example, data feeds through risk, data feeds through
compliance, data feeds through lots of your controls and making sure that we're taking a holistic approach
to the way that we go at and modernize our data approach is critical, such that we do it once, we do it right,

-- 20 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 21
we do it holistically. And so, again, I don't think the work or some of the work streams are new. I think the
broader, more encompassing, holistic approach in some areas is newer.
MARK MASON: And Mike, just to that point, in terms of us having started this already, again, the
incremental $1 billion we're spending, we started spending that at the beginning of the year, right? And we
spent incremental dollars in 2019 as well. And by the way, that $1 billion wasn't something that I capped. It
was what do we think is required to make as much traction as we can in the year. And we're spending that
incremental $1 billion and still managing our total expenses responsibly, right?
BETSY GRASECK: Yeah. It's an interesting point, because when I look at the stock, I'm looking at a stock
that's priced for effectively a 5% ROE, okay? And if you say, hey, that is right, because the expenses are
going to go up that much to drive a 5% ROE, that's like a $5 billion increase in expenses. And Mark, to your
point earlier, you were mentioning that you're planning on – or hoping to execute this improving profitability,
which is obviously above 5% today.
So, could you help us understand what kinds of profit improvements you think you can focus on over the
course of the next couple of years? I mean, I'm wondering what some big threads are. Is it better deposit,
core deposits that can bring down your cost of funds? Is it greater execution with your current customer
base? Is it incremental customers? I mean, help us understand what you're thinking about there.
MARK MASON: Yeah. Look, there are going to be multiple components to it, right? There are additional
linkages that we try to capture across our franchises, whether it's doing more with our TTS clients. I
mentioned earlier that, we are seeing a lot of traction as it relates to instant payment capabilities, whether
it's doing more between our capital markets business in spread products and trade lending that we do with
corporate clients in terms of unique structuring opportunities there.
And so, there are linkage opportunities across the franchise that we will continue to capture that I think will
help in the way of top line performance. There are opportunities to grow in the wealth management space.
We've seen 16% growth in investments in Asia this quarter. We think there's more upside. We think there's
more wealth growth upside in the US as well.
But there are also operational benefits from – again, when we say manual activity, when you replace manual
activity with an improved technology or an automation or straight-through processing, you remove the
manual. Removing the manual improves the quality of the output in a more timely fashion. But it also, over
time, is less costly, when you don't have those manual steps.
And so, I'd say, improved profitability, as we go into 2021 and 2022 and beyond, in part in getting both top
line, ultimately getting expense benefits from a host of activities, including capacity adjustments that we
may decide to take as we come out of this crisis, and then the other items play through as well, including
cost of credit and so on and so forth.
OPERATOR: Your next question is from the line of Gerard Cassidy with RBC.
GERARD CASSIDY: Thank you. Good morning, Mark. Good morning, Mike.
MARK MASON: Good morning.
MIKE CORBAT: Good morning, Gerard.
GERARD CASSIDY: Mark, you've given us some good detail on the consumer portfolios. Can you share
with us on the commercial side – when you look at your ratings that you give us in terms of investment
grade to BB, B, CCC, they really haven't moved very much, since the fourth quarter of 2019. So, can you
share with us, what you're seeing in these portfolios? And are the energy portfolios, and the leisure, and

-- 21 of 22 --

T R A N S C R I P T
Citi Third Quarter 2020 Earnings Review
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Copyright © 2020 Citigroup Inc. 22
hospitality, travel portfolios, still the ones that give you the most risk or you see the most risk in terms of
credit losses over the next 12 months or so?
MARK MASON: Yeah. Sure, Gerard. Let me start by saying, as you know, we have – coming out of the
last crisis, we have really adjusted our risk framework, our risk appetite. We have rethought our client focus
to ensure that we're focused on clients that can take best advantage of the breadth of our offering, but also
on the multinational investment-grade type clients. And so we have maintained a skew in terms of ratings
towards 80% or so of our portfolio being in those investment-grade names.
We've got a long history of operating in all of these sectors that you see on page 23, and we've got deep
experience through cycles and expertise in each of these industries. And that includes client selection. And
in many instances, we are banking many of the leaders in their respective industries. And it's important to
note that because I think that speaks to not only the quality of the name, but what we can expect when you
go through downturns, and it speaks to why we're so committed to staying alongside our clients and helping
them manage through the uncertainty.
When I think about some of the sectors that we point to in this crisis, we've been thoughtful about the way
we have dealt with these clients over time. So, you look at the aviation space, and our exposures there
tend to be secured. They tend to – we have extensive experience with structuring to mitigate risk there,
whether that's secured or guaranteed by export credit agencies, we've got extensive experience with
valuation of collateral there.
If you look at autos, in many cases, the lending there is in securitization vehicles. So, the risk of bankruptcy
is remote and with underlying consumer obligors in that case. You look at energy and a lot of that is reserve-
based lending, with borrowing bases that go through a periodic re-determination. And that helps in terms
of reducing exposure when oil prices fall.
And so, you look at these, you look at our activity with these clients in these sectors, our deep experience,
and we think that it positions us well to manage through this with them and certainly feel good about the
reserves that we have. And we have taken proactive actions in the pre-crisis, we went through exposure
reductions just given where we were in the cycle, and we've aggressively downgraded names that are in
impacted sectors early in the crisis and put enhanced monitoring in place. But as I mentioned, we feel good
about the portfolio we have. We feel good about the reserves that we have, and we feel good about our
ability to manage through this with these clients.
OPERATOR: I would now turn the call back over for any closing remarks.
ELIZABETH LYNN: Thank you all for joining today. Please feel free to reach out to Investor Relations if
you have any additional questions. Thank you again, and have a nice day.
OPERATOR: This concludes today's third quarter 2020 earnings call. Thank you for your participation. You
may now disconnect.
Certain statements in this document are “forward-looking statements” within the meaning of the rules and
regulations of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. These statements are based on management’s
current expectations and are subject to uncertainty and changes in circumstances. Actual results and capital
and other financial condition may differ materially from those included in these statements due to a variety of
factors, including the precautionary statements included in this document and those contained in Citigroup’s
filings with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, including without limitation the “Risk Factors”
section of Citigroup’s 2019 Annual Report on Form 10-K.

-- 22 of 22 --