SUPPLEMENT
Q4 2023 — Supplement
Q4 2023PDF · 28 pages899 KB
Financial Supplement
Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2023
1
-- 1 of 28 --
Table of Contents Page
Consolidated Financial Highlights 3
Consolidated Statements of Operations (unaudited) 5
Consolidated Balance Sheets (unaudited) 6
Loans and Deposits 7
Average Balance Sheets, Annualized Yields and Rates 8
Mortgage Banking Fees 10
Segment Financial Highlights 11
Credit-Related Information:
Nonaccrual loans and leases 15
Loans and Leases 90 Days or More Past Due and Accruing 16
Charge-offs, Recoveries, and Related Ratios 17
Summary of Changes in the Components of the Allowance for Credit Losses 19
Capital and Ratios 20
Non-GAAP Financial Measures and Reconciliations 21
The information in this Financial Supplement is preliminary and based on company data available at the time of
the earnings presentation. It speaks only as of the particular date or dates included in the accompanying pages.
The Company does not undertake an obligation to, and disclaims any duty to, update any of the information
provided. Any forward-looking statements in this Financial Supplement are subject to the forward-looking
statements language contained in the Company’s reports filed with the SEC pursuant to the Securities Exchange
Act of 1934, which can be found on the SEC’s website (www.sec.gov) or on the Company’s website
(www.citizensbank.com). The Company’s future financial performance is subject to the risks and uncertainties
described in its SEC filings.
2
-- 2 of 28 --
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS
(dollars in millions, except per share data)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$/bps % $/bps % $/bps %
SELECTED OPERATING DATA
Total revenue $1,988 $2,014 $2,094 $2,128 $2,200 ($26) (1%) ($212) (10%) $8,224 $8,021 $203 3%
Noninterest expense 1,612 1,293 1,306 1,296 1,240 319 25 372 30 5,507 4,892 615 13
Profit before provision (benefit) for credit losses 376 721 788 832 960 (345) (48) (584) (61) 2,717 3,129 (412) (13)
Provision (benefit) for credit losses 171 172 176 168 132 (1) (1) 39 30 687 474 213 45
NET INCOME 189 430 478 511 653 (241) (56) (464) (71) 1,608 2,073 (465) (22)
Net income, Underlying1 426 448 531 560 685 (22) (5) (259) (38) 1,965 2,425 (460) (19)
Net income available to common stockholders 159 400 444 488 621 (241) (60) (462) (74) 1,491 1,960 (469) (24)
Net income available to common stockholders,
Underlying1 396 418 497 537 653 (22) (5) (257) (39) 1,848 2,312 (464) (20)
PER COMMON SHARE DATA
Basic earnings $0.34 $0.85 $0.93 $1.00 $1.26 ($0.51) (60%) ($0.92) (73%) $3.14 $4.12 ($0.98) (24%)
Diluted earnings 0.34 0.85 0.92 1.00 1.25 (0.51) (60) (0.91) (73) 3.13 4.10 (0.97) (24)
Basic earnings, Underlying1 0.85 0.89 1.04 1.10 1.32 (0.04) (4) (0.47) (36) 3.89 4.86 (0.97) (20)
Diluted earnings, Underlying1 0.85 0.89 1.04 1.10 1.32 (0.04) (4) (0.47) (36) 3.88 4.84 (0.96) (20)
Cash dividends declared and paid per common share 0.42 0.42 0.42 0.42 0.42 — — — — 1.68 1.62 0.06 4
Book value per common share 47.87 44.75 45.44 45.84 44.03 3.12 7 3.84 9 47.87 44.03 3.84 9
Tangible book value per common share 30.91 27.73 28.72 29.44 27.88 3.18 11 3.03 11 30.91 27.88 3.03 11
Dividend payout ratio 124 % 49 % 45 % 42 % 33 % 7,412 bps 9,053 bps 54 % 39% 1,450 bps
Dividend payout ratio, Underlying1 49 47 40 38 32 200 bps 1,700 bps 43 33 1,000 bps
COMMON SHARES OUTSTANDING
Average: Basic 466,234,324 469,481,085 479,470,543 485,444,313 493,293,981 (3,246,761) (1%) (27,059,657) (5%) 475,089,384 475,959,815 (870,431) —%
Diluted 468,159,167 471,183,719 480,975,281 487,712,146 495,478,398 (3,024,552) (1) (27,319,231) (6) 476,693,148 477,803,142 (1,109,994) —
Common shares at period-end 466,418,055 466,221,795 474,682,759 483,982,264 492,282,158 196,260 — (25,864,103) (5) 466,418,055 492,282,158 (25,864,103) (5)
1 These are non-GAAP financial measures. For further information on these measures, refer to "Non-GAAP Financial Measures and Reconciliations."
3
-- 3 of 28 --
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS, CONTINUED
(dollars in millions, except per share data)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$/bps % $/bps % $/bps %
FINANCIAL RATIOS
Net interest margin 2.90 % 3.03 % 3.16 % 3.29 % 3.29 % (13) bps (39) bps 3.09 % 3.10 % (1) bps
Net interest margin, FTE1 2.91 3.03 3.17 3.30 3.30 (12) (39) 3.10 3.10 —
Return on average common equity 2.96 7.50 8.00 9.11 11.56 (454) (860) 6.90 9.02 (212)
Return on average common equity, Underlying2 7.41 7.82 8.97 10.01 12.15 (41) (474) 8.56 10.64 (208)
Return on average tangible common equity 4.72 12.00 12.42 14.38 18.46 (728) (1,374) 10.92 13.91 (299)
Return on average tangible common equity, Underlying2 11.84 12.51 13.93 15.80 19.40 (67) (756) 13.53 16.41 (288)
Return on average total assets 0.33 0.78 0.86 0.93 1.15 (45) (82) 0.72 0.96 (24)
Return on average total assets, Underlying2 0.76 0.81 0.96 1.02 1.21 (5) (45) 0.88 1.13 (25)
Return on average total tangible assets 0.35 0.81 0.89 0.97 1.19 (46) (84) 0.75 1.00 (25)
Return on average total tangible assets, Underlying2 0.78 0.84 0.99 1.06 1.25 (6) (47) 0.92 1.17 (25)
Effective income tax rate 7.59 21.51 22.09 22.97 21.16 (1,392) (1,357) 20.76 21.93 (117)
Effective income tax rate, Underlying2 22.25 21.69 22.51 23.25 21.37 56 88 22.48 22.19 29
Efficiency ratio 81.13 64.21 62.34 60.90 56.36 1,692 2,477 66.97 60.99 598
Efficiency ratio, Underlying2 63.77 63.08 58.86 57.84 54.42 69 935 60.81 57.51 330
Noninterest income as a % of total revenue 25.16 24.44 24.14 22.81 22.92 72 224 24.12 25.04 (92)
Noninterest income as a % of total revenue, Underlying2 25.16 24.44 24.14 22.81 22.92 72 224 24.12 25.33 (121)
CAPITAL RATIOS - PERIOD-END (PRELIMINARY)
CET1 capital ratio 10.6 % 10.4 % 10.3 % 10.0 % 10.0 %
Tier 1 capital ratio 11.8 11.5 11.4 11.1 11.1
Total capital ratio 13.7 13.4 13.3 12.9 12.8
Tier 1 leverage ratio 9.3 9.4 9.4 9.4 9.3
Tangible common equity ratio 6.7 5.9 6.3 6.6 6.3
SELECTED BALANCE SHEET DATA
Loan-to-deposit ratio (period-end balances) 82.30 % 84.03 % 85.17 % 89.83 % 86.69 % (173) bps (439) bps 82.30 % 86.69 % (439) bps
Loan-to-deposit ratio (average balances) 83.54 85.46 88.73 89.76 87.74 (192) bps (420) bps 86.83 86.77 6 bps
Full-time equivalent colleagues (period-end) 17,570 18,214 18,468 18,547 18,889 (644) (4) (1,319) (7) 17,570 18,889 (1,319) (7)
1Net interest margin is presented on a fully taxable-equivalent ("FTE") basis using the federal statutory tax rate of 21%. The FTE impact is predominantly attributable to commercial loans for the periods presented.
2These are non-GAAP financial measures. For further information on these measures, refer to "Non-GAAP Financial Measures and Reconciliations."
4
-- 4 of 28 --
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS (unaudited)
(dollars in millions)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$ % $ % $ %
INTEREST INCOME
Interest and fees on loans and leases $2,144 $2,166 $2,132 $2,047 $1,893 ($22) (1%) $251 13% $8,489 $5,968 $2,521 42%
Interest and fees on loans held for sale 18 20 20 15 16 (2) (10) 2 13 73 67 6 9
Interest and fees on other loans held for sale 4 8 12 5 10 (4) (50) (6) (60) 29 57 (28) (49)
Investment securities 339 290 267 266 258 49 17 81 31 1,162 840 322 38
Interest-bearing deposits in banks 171 111 100 69 75 60 54 96 128 451 128 323 NM
Total interest income 2,676 2,595 2,531 2,402 2,252 81 3 424 19 10,204 7,060 3,144 45
INTEREST EXPENSE
Deposits 974 898 723 550 396 76 8 578 146 3,145 651 2,494 NM
Short-term borrowed funds 7 8 22 6 2 (1) (13) 5 250 43 23 20 87
Long-term borrowed funds 207 167 198 203 159 40 24 48 30 775 374 401 107
Total interest expense 1,188 1,073 943 759 557 115 11 631 113 3,963 1,048 2,915 NM
Net interest income 1,488 1,522 1,588 1,643 1,695 (34) (2) (207) (12) 6,241 6,012 229 4
NONINTEREST INCOME
Service charges and fees 104 105 101 100 105 (1) (1) (1) (1) 410 420 (10) (2)
Capital markets fees 87 67 82 83 98 20 30 (11) (11) 319 368 (49) (13)
Card fees 70 74 80 72 71 (4) (5) (1) (1) 296 273 23 8
Trust and investment services fees 68 63 65 63 61 5 8 7 11 259 249 10 4
Mortgage banking fees 57 69 59 57 54 (12) (17) 3 6 242 261 (19) (7)
Foreign exchange and derivative products 43 48 44 48 35 (5) (10) 8 23 183 188 (5) (3)
Letter of credit and loan fees 42 43 43 40 41 (1) (2) 1 2 168 159 9 6
Securities gains, net 9 5 9 5 4 4 80 5 125 28 9 19 211
Other income 20 18 23 17 36 2 11 (16) (44) 78 82 (4) (5)
Total noninterest income 500 492 506 485 505 8 2 (5) (1) 1,983 2,009 (26) (1)
TOTAL REVENUE 1,988 2,014 2,094 2,128 2,200 (26) (1) (212) (10) 8,224 8,021 203 3
Provision (benefit) for credit losses 171 172 176 168 132 (1) (1) 39 30 687 474 213 45
NONINTEREST EXPENSE
Salaries and employee benefits 667 659 615 658 633 8 1 34 5 2,599 2,549 50 2
Equipment and software 215 191 181 169 170 24 13 45 26 756 648 108 17
Outside services 174 160 177 176 170 14 9 4 2 687 700 (13) (2)
Occupancy 125 107 136 124 110 18 17 15 14 492 410 82 20
Other operating expense 431 176 197 169 157 255 145 274 175 973 585 388 66
Total noninterest expense 1,612 1,293 1,306 1,296 1,240 319 25 372 30 5,507 4,892 615 13
Income before income tax expense 205 549 612 664 828 (344) (63) (623) (75) 2,030 2,655 (625) (24)
Income tax expense 16 119 134 153 175 (103) (87) (159) (91) 422 582 (160) (27)
Net income $189 $430 $478 $511 $653 ($241) (56%) ($464) (71%) $1,608 $2,073 ($465) (22%)
Net income, Underlying1 $426 $448 $531 $560 $685 ($22) (5%) ($259) (38%) $1,965 $2,425 ($460) (19%)
Net income available to common stockholders $159 $400 $444 $488 $621 ($241) (60%) ($462) (74%) $1,491 $1,960 ($469) (24%)
Net income available to common stockholders,
Underlying1 $396 $418 $497 $537 $653 ($22) (5%) ($257) (39%) $1,848 $2,312 ($464) (20%)
1 These are non-GAAP financial measures. For further information on these measures, refer to "Non-GAAP Financial Measures and Reconciliations."
5
-- 5 of 28 --
CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS (unaudited)
(dollars in millions, except par value)
PERIOD-END BALANCES AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2023 CHANGE
Dec 31, 2023 Sept 30, 2023 June 30, 2023 Mar 31, 2023 Dec 31, 2022 September 30, 2023 December 31, 2022
$ % $ %
ASSETS
Cash and due from banks $1,794 $1,395 $1,689 $1,283 $1,489 $399 29% $305 20%
Interest-bearing cash and due from banks 9,834 14,005 9,878 6,691 9,058 (4,171) (30) 776 9
Interest-bearing deposits in banks 405 324 284 320 303 81 25 102 34
Debt securities available for sale, at fair value 29,777 25,069 24,755 23,845 24,007 4,708 19 5,770 24
Debt securities held to maturity 9,184 9,320 9,520 9,677 9,834 (136) (1) (650) (7)
Loans held for sale, at fair value 676 749 1,225 855 774 (73) (10) (98) (13)
Other loans held for sale 103 99 196 1,000 208 4 4 (105) (50)
Loans and leases 145,959 149,746 151,320 154,688 156,662 (3,787) (3) (10,703) (7)
Less: Allowance for loan and lease losses (2,098) (2,080) (2,044) (2,017) (1,983) (18) 1 (115) 6
Net loans and leases 143,861 147,666 149,276 152,671 154,679 (3,805) (3) (10,818) (7)
Derivative assets 440 522 719 569 842 (82) (16) (402) (48)
Premises and equipment 895 878 876 866 844 17 2 51 6
Bank-owned life insurance 3,291 3,275 3,263 3,244 3,236 16 — 55 2
Goodwill 8,188 8,188 8,188 8,177 8,173 — — 15 —
Other intangible assets 157 167 175 185 197 (10) (6) (40) (20)
Other assets 13,359 13,613 13,022 12,873 13,089 (254) (2) 270 2
TOTAL ASSETS $221,964 $225,270 $223,066 $222,256 $226,733 ($3,306) (1%) ($4,769) (2%)
LIABILITIES AND STOCKHOLDERS' EQUITY
LIABILITIES
Deposits:
Noninterest-bearing $37,107 $38,561 $40,286 $44,326 $49,283 ($1,454) (4%) ($12,176) (25%)
Interest-bearing 140,235 139,636 137,381 127,868 131,441 599 — 8,794 7
Total deposits 177,342 178,197 177,667 172,194 180,724 (855) — (3,382) (2)
Short-term borrowed funds 505 232 1,099 1,018 3 273 118 502 NM
Derivative liabilities 1,562 2,109 2,270 1,704 1,909 (547) (26) (347) (18)
Long-term borrowed funds:
FHLB advances 3,786 7,036 5,029 11,779 8,519 (3,250) (46) (4,733) (56)
Senior debt 5,170 5,258 5,258 5,263 5,555 (88) (2) (385) (7)
Subordinated debt and other debt 4,511 5,060 3,813 1,813 1,813 (549) (11) 2,698 149
Total long-term borrowed funds 13,467 17,354 14,100 18,855 15,887 (3,887) (22) (2,420) (15)
Other liabilities 4,746 4,500 4,345 4,284 4,520 246 5 226 5
TOTAL LIABILITIES 197,622 202,392 199,481 198,055 203,043 (4,770) (2) (5,421) (3)
STOCKHOLDERS' EQUITY
Preferred stock:
$25.00 par value, 100,000,000 shares authorized for each of the periods presented 2,014 2,014 2,014 2,014 2,014 — — — —
Common stock:
$0.01 par value, 1,000,000,000 shares authorized for each of the periods presented 6 6 6 6 6 — — — —
Additional paid-in capital 22,250 22,231 22,207 22,183 22,142 19 — 108 —
Retained earnings 9,816 9,856 9,655 9,416 9,159 (40) — 657 7
Treasury stock, at cost (5,986) (5,986) (5,734) (5,475) (5,071) — — (915) (18)
Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) (3,758) (5,243) (4,563) (3,943) (4,560) 1,485 28 802 18
TOTAL STOCKHOLDERS' EQUITY 24,342 22,878 23,585 24,201 23,690 1,464 6 652 3
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND STOCKHOLDERS' EQUITY $221,964 $225,270 $223,066 $222,256 $226,733 ($3,306) (1%) ($4,769) (2%)
Memo: Total tangible common equity $14,417 $12,930 $13,630 $14,247 $13,728 $1,487 12% $689 5%
6
-- 6 of 28 --
LOANS AND DEPOSITS
(dollars in millions)
PERIOD-END BALANCES AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2023 CHANGE
Dec 31, 2023 Sept 30, 2023 June 30, 2023 Mar 31, 2023 Dec 31, 2022 Sept 30, 2023 December 31, 2022
$ % $ %
LOANS AND LEASES
Commercial and industrial $43,826 $46,753 $48,038 $50,450 $51,836 ($2,927) (6%) ($8,010) (15%)
Commercial real estate 29,471 29,486 28,947 28,999 28,865 (15) — 606 2
Leases 1,148 1,218 1,294 1,417 1,479 (70) (6) (331) (22)
Total commercial 74,445 77,457 78,279 80,866 82,180 (3,012) (4) (7,735) (9)
Residential mortgages 31,332 30,983 30,769 30,362 29,921 349 1 1,411 5
Home equity 15,040 14,729 14,487 14,135 14,043 311 2 997 7
Automobile 8,258 9,290 10,428 11,535 12,292 (1,032) (11) (4,034) (33)
Education 11,834 12,134 12,246 12,634 12,808 (300) (2) (974) (8)
Other retail 5,050 5,153 5,111 5,156 5,418 (103) (2) (368) (7)
Total retail 71,514 72,289 73,041 73,822 74,482 (775) (1) (2,968) (4)
Total loans and leases $145,959 $149,746 $151,320 $154,688 $156,662 ($3,787) (3%) ($10,703) (7%)
Loans held for sale, at fair value 676 749 1,225 855 774 (73) (10) (98) (13)
Other loans held for sale 103 99 196 1,000 208 4 4 (105) (50)
Loans and leases and loans held for sale $146,738 $150,594 $152,741 $156,543 $157,644 ($3,856) (3%) ($10,906) (7%)
DEPOSITS
Demand $37,107 $38,561 $40,286 $44,326 $49,283 ($1,454) (4%) ($12,176) (25%)
Money market 53,812 53,517 52,542 48,905 49,905 295 1 3,907 8
Checking with interest 31,876 33,355 35,028 34,496 39,721 (1,479) (4) (7,845) (20)
Savings 27,983 29,139 29,824 29,789 29,805 (1,156) (4) (1,822) (6)
Term 26,564 23,625 19,987 14,678 12,010 2,939 12 14,554 121
Total deposits $177,342 $178,197 $177,667 $172,194 $180,724 ($855) —% ($3,382) (2%)
7
-- 7 of 28 --
(dollars in millions)
QUARTERLY TRENDS 4Q23 Change
4Q23 3Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22
Average
Balances Interest Rate Average
Balances Interest Rate Average
Balances Interest Rate Average
Balances Interest Rate Average
Balances Interest Rate
INTEREST-EARNING ASSETS
Interest-bearing cash and due from banks and deposits in banks $12,387 $171 5.43% $8,005 $111 5.42% $6,915 $75 4.22% $4,382 $60 1 bps $5,472 $96 121 bps
Taxable investment securities 41,497 339 3.25 39,271 290 2.95 38,770 258 2.66 2,226 49 30 2,727 81 59
Non-taxable investment securities 2 — 2.66 2 — 2.68 2 — 2.39 — — (2) — — 27
Total investment securities 41,499 339 3.25 39,273 290 2.95 38,772 258 2.66 2,226 49 30 2,727 81 59
Commercial and industrial 45,433 706 6.07 47,658 750 6.17 52,311 652 4.89 (2,225) (44) (10) (6,878) 54 118
Commercial real estate 29,460 476 6.32 29,353 467 6.23 28,735 382 5.19 107 9 9 725 94 113
Leases 1,185 10 3.54 1,250 12 3.56 1,422 12 3.25 (65) (2) (2) (237) (2) 29
Total commercial 76,078 1,192 6.13 78,261 1,229 6.15 82,468 1,046 4.97 (2,183) (37) (2) (6,390) 146 116
Residential mortgages 31,146 276 3.55 30,838 267 3.46 29,677 246 3.32 308 9 9 1,469 30 23
Home equity 14,889 302 8.04 14,589 286 7.77 13,869 204 5.84 300 16 27 1,020 98 220
Automobile 8,752 94 4.24 9,849 103 4.16 12,692 125 3.90 (1,097) (9) 8 (3,940) (31) 34
Education 11,971 156 5.17 12,147 156 5.11 12,929 148 4.54 (176) — 6 (958) 8 63
Other retail 5,133 124 9.64 5,107 125 9.67 5,464 124 9.02 26 (1) (3) (331) — 62
Total retail 71,891 952 5.27 72,530 937 5.14 74,631 847 4.52 (639) 15 13 (2,740) 105 75
Total loans and leases 147,969 2,144 5.71 150,791 2,166 5.66 157,099 1,893 4.75 (2,822) (22) 5 (9,130) 251 96
Loans held for sale, at fair value 1,047 18 6.79 1,204 20 6.72 1,179 16 5.32 (157) (2) 7 (132) 2 147
Other loans held for sale 219 4 7.72 321 8 9.01 557 10 6.70 (102) (4) (129) (338) (6) 102
Total interest-earning assets 203,121 2,676 5.20 199,594 2,595 5.13 204,522 2,252 4.35 3,527 81 7 (1,401) 424 85
Noninterest-earning assets 20,532 20,568 20,448 (36) 84
TOTAL ASSETS $223,653 $220,162 $224,970 $3,491 ($1,317)
INTEREST-BEARING LIABILITIES
Checking with interest $31,788 113 1.40 $33,545 126 1.49 $36,952 77 0.82 ($1,757) (13) (9) ($5,164) $36 58
Money market 53,003 444 3.32 52,057 415 3.17 50,228 208 1.65 946 29 15 2,775 236 167
Regular savings 28,455 123 1.72 29,516 123 1.65 29,780 58 0.78 (1,061) — 7 (1,325) 65 94
Term 25,492 294 4.59 21,604 234 4.29 11,378 53 1.83 3,888 60 30 14,114 241 276
Total interest-bearing deposits 138,738 974 2.79 136,722 898 2.60 128,338 396 1.23 2,016 76 19 10,400 578 156
Short-term borrowed funds 491 7 5.63 506 8 6.21 262 2 3.83 (15) (1) (58) 229 5 180
FHLB advances 5,751 83 5.62 4,023 56 5.54 8,818 82 3.67 1,728 27 8 (3,067) 1 195
Senior debt 5,217 57 4.34 5,259 56 4.33 5,397 55 4.05 (42) 1 1 (180) 2 29
Subordinated debt and other debt 4,720 67 5.71 3,920 55 5.43 1,812 22 4.59 800 12 28 2,908 45 112
Total long-term borrowed funds 15,688 207 5.22 13,202 167 5.02 16,027 159 3.91 2,486 40 20 (339) 48 131
Total borrowed funds 16,179 214 5.24 13,708 175 5.07 16,289 161 3.90 2,471 39 17 (110) 53 134
Total interest-bearing liabilities 154,917 1,188 3.04 150,430 1,073 2.83 144,627 557 1.53 4,487 115 21 10,290 631 151
Demand deposits 38,390 39,728 50,706 (1,338) (12,316)
Other noninterest-bearing liabilities 7,123 6,813 6,347 310 776
TOTAL LIABILITIES 200,430 196,971 201,680 3,459 (1,250)
STOCKHOLDERS' EQUITY 23,223 23,191 23,290 32 (67)
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND STOCKHOLDERS' EQUITY $223,653 $220,162 $224,970 $3,491 ($1,317)
INTEREST RATE SPREAD 2.16 % 2.30 % 2.82 % (14) (66)
NET INTEREST MARGIN AND NET INTEREST INCOME $1,488 2.90 % $1,522 3.03 % $1,695 3.29 % ($34) (13) ($207) (39)
NET INTEREST MARGIN AND NET INTEREST INCOME, FTE1 $1,492 2.91 % $1,526 3.03 % $1,699 3.30 % ($34) (12) ($207) (39)
Memo: Total deposits (interest-bearing and demand) $177,128 $974 2.18 % $176,450 $898 2.02 % $179,044 $396 0.88 % $678 $76 16 bps ($1,916) $578 130 bps
AVERAGE BALANCE SHEETS, ANNUALIZED YIELDS AND RATES
1Net interest income and net interest margin is presented on a fully taxable-equivalent ("FTE") basis using the federal statutory tax rate of 21%. The FTE impact is predominantly attributable to commercial loans for the periods presented.
8
-- 8 of 28 --
(dollars in millions)
FULL YEAR 2023 Change
2023 2022 2022
Average
Balances Interest Rate Average
Balances Interest Rate Average
Balances Interest Rate
INTEREST-EARNING ASSETS
Interest-bearing cash and due from banks and deposits in banks $8,531 $451 5.22% $6,195 $128 2.04% $2,336 $323 318 bps
Taxable investment securities 39,437 1,162 2.94 35,639 840 2.35 3,798 322 59
Non-taxable investment securities 2 — 2.68 3 — 2.33 (1) — 35
Total investment securities 39,439 1,162 2.94 35,642 840 2.35 3,797 322 59
Commercial and industrial 48,693 2,956 5.99 50,002 1,942 3.83 (1,309) 1,014 216
Commercial real estate 29,206 1,804 6.09 24,746 1,026 4.09 4,460 778 200
Leases 1,305 46 3.53 1,521 46 3.00 (216) — 53
Total commercial 79,204 4,806 5.99 76,269 3,014 3.90 2,935 1,792 209
Residential mortgages 30,660 1,052 3.43 27,759 876 3.16 2,901 176 27
Home equity 14,475 1,092 7.54 13,057 555 4.25 1,418 537 329
Automobile 10,374 429 4.13 13,729 507 3.69 (3,355) (78) 44
Education 12,333 621 5.04 13,047 560 4.29 (714) 61 75
Other retail 5,171 489 9.46 5,483 456 8.31 (312) 33 115
Total retail 73,013 3,683 5.04 73,075 2,954 4.04 (62) 729 100
Total loans and leases 152,217 8,489 5.53 149,344 5,968 3.97 2,873 2,521 156
Loans held for sale, at fair value 1,160 73 6.26 1,767 67 3.77 (607) 6 249
Other loans held for sale 339 29 8.43 1,188 57 4.71 (849) (28) 372
Total interest-earning assets 201,686 10,204 5.02 194,136 7,060 3.61 7,550 3,144 141
Noninterest-earning assets 20,535 20,925 (390)
TOTAL ASSETS $222,221 $215,061 $7,160
INTEREST-BEARING LIABILITIES
Checking with interest $33,960 446 1.31 $36,127 142 0.39 ($2,167) 304 92
Money market 51,178 1,494 2.92 48,410 320 0.66 2,768 1,174 226
Regular savings 29,266 433 1.48 27,524 100 0.37 1,742 333 111
Term 19,320 772 4.00 8,330 89 1.07 10,990 683 293
Total interest-bearing deposits 133,724 3,145 2.35 120,391 651 0.54 13,333 2,494 181
Short-term borrowed funds 746 43 5.70 1,584 23 1.47 (838) 20 423
FHLB advances 7,431 383 5.09 5,659 149 2.60 1,772 234 249
Senior debt 5,335 231 4.33 4,631 144 3.11 704 87 122
Subordinated debt and other debt 3,087 161 5.21 1,788 81 4.44 1,299 80 77
Total long-term borrowed funds 15,853 775 4.86 12,078 374 3.07 3,775 401 179
Total borrowed funds 16,599 818 4.89 13,662 397 2.88 2,937 421 201
Total interest-bearing liabilities 150,323 3,963 2.63 134,053 1,048 0.78 16,270 2,915 185
Demand deposits 41,581 51,717 (10,136)
Other noninterest-bearing liabilities 6,711 5,553 1,158
TOTAL LIABILITIES 198,615 191,323 7,292
STOCKHOLDERS' EQUITY 23,606 23,738 (132)
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND STOCKHOLDERS' EQUITY $222,221 $215,061 $7,160
INTEREST RATE SPREAD 2.39 % 2.83 % (44)
NET INTEREST MARGIN AND NET INTEREST INCOME $6,241 3.09 % $6,012 3.10 % $229 (1)
NET INTEREST MARGIN AND NET INTEREST INCOME, FTE1 $6,258 3.10 % $6,023 3.10 % $235 —
Memo: Total deposits (interest-bearing and demand) $175,305 $3,145 1.79 % $172,108 $651 0.38 % $3,197 $2,494 141 bps
AVERAGE BALANCE SHEETS, ANNUALIZED YIELDS AND RATES
1Net interest income and net interest margin is presented on a fully taxable-equivalent ("FTE") basis using the federal statutory tax rate of 21%. The FTE impact is predominantly attributable to commercial loans for the periods presented.
9
-- 9 of 28 --
MORTGAGE BANKING FEES SUMMARY
(dollars in millions)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$/bps % $/bps % $/bps %
MORTGAGE BANKING FEES
Production revenue $11 $19 $23 $18 $12 ($8) (42%) ($1) (8%) $71 $84 ($13) (15%)
Mortgage servicing revenue 37 35 34 37 40 2 6 (3) (8) 143 147 (4) (3)
MSR valuation changes, net of hedge impact 9 15 2 2 2 (6) (40) 7 NM 28 30 (2) (7)
Total mortgage banking fees $57 $69 $59 $57 $54 ($12) (17%) $3 6% $242 $261 ($19) (7%)
Pull-through adjusted locks $1,412 $2,397 $2,870 $2,078 $1,665 ($985) (41%) ($253) (15%) $8,757 $13,413 ($4,656) (35%)
Production revenue as a percentage of Pull-through
adjusted locks 0.78 % 0.79 % 0.79 % 0.90 % 0.72 % (1) bps 6 bps 0.81% 0.63% 19 bps
RESIDENTIAL REAL ESTATE ORIGINATIONS
Retail $958 $1,146 $1,260 $1,011 $1,103 ($188) (16%) ($145) (13%) $4,375 $8,951 ($4,576) (51%)
Third Party 1,214 2,285 2,350 1,333 1,652 (1,071) (47) (438) (27) 7,182 12,019 (4,837) (40)
Total $2,172 $3,431 $3,610 $2,344 $2,755 ($1,259) (37%) (583) (21%) $11,557 $20,970 ($9,413) (45%)
Originated for sale $1,595 $2,815 $2,874 $1,651 $2,044 ($1,220) (43%) ($449) (22%) $8,935 $15,073 ($6,138) (41%)
Originated for investment 577 616 736 693 711 (39) (6) (134) (19) 2,622 5,897 (3,275) (56)
Total $2,172 $3,431 $3,610 $2,344 $2,755 ($1,259) (37%) ($583) (21%) $11,557 $20,970 ($9,413) (45%)
MORTGAGE SERVICING INFORMATION (UPB)
Loans serviced for others $97,420 $97,603 $96,591 $96,346 $96,698 ($183) —% $722 1% $97,420 $96,698 $722 1%
Owned loans serviced 31,640 31,436 31,636 30,827 30,135 204 1 1,505 5 31,640 30,135 1,505 5
Total $129,060 $129,039 $128,227 $127,173 $126,833 $21 —% $2,227 2% $129,060 $126,833 $2,227 2%
MSR at fair value $1,552 $1,620 $1,524 $1,496 $1,530 ($68) (4%) $22 1% $1,552 $1,530 $22 1%
10
-- 10 of 28 --
SEGMENT FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS - CONSUMER BANKING
(dollars in millions)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
CONSUMER BANKING1 4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$/bps % $/bps % $/bps %
Net interest income $1,086 $1,067 $1,023 $1,011 $1,014 $19 2% $72 7% $4,187 $3,649 $538 15%
Noninterest income 265 278 268 256 256 (13) (5) 9 4 1,067 1,063 4 —
Total revenue 1,351 1,345 1,291 1,267 1,270 6 — 81 6 5,254 4,712 542 12
Noninterest expense 905 905 875 857 831 — — 74 9 3,542 3,255 287 9
Profit (loss) before credit losses 446 440 416 410 439 6 1 7 2 1,712 1,457 255 18
Net charge-offs 82 67 68 63 57 15 22 25 44 280 174 106 61
Income (loss) before income tax expense (benefit) 364 373 348 347 382 (9) (2) (18) (5) 1,432 1,283 149 12
Income tax expense (benefit) 95 97 91 90 98 (2) (2) (3) (3) 373 328 45 14
Net income (loss) $269 $276 $257 $257 $284 ($7) (3%) ($15) (5%) $1,059 $955 $104 11%
AVERAGE BALANCES
Total assets $73,334 $72,964 $72,583 $71,872 $71,688 $370 1% $1,646 2% $72,693 $68,027 $4,666 7%
Total loans and leases2 66,906 66,641 66,289 65,570 65,619 265 — 1,287 2 66,356 62,523 3,833 6
Deposits 118,474 117,979 115,847 115,578 117,164 495 — 1,310 1 116,980 114,482 2,498 2
Interest-earning assets 67,524 67,273 66,933 66,251 66,338 251 — 1,186 2 66,999 63,289 3,710 6
KEY METRICS
Net interest margin 6.40 % 6.28 % 6.12 % 6.20 % 6.07 % 12 bps 33 bps 6.25 % 5.77 % 48 bps
Efficiency ratio 67.08 67.18 67.74 67.70 65.39 (10) bps 169 bps 67.42 69.08 (166) bps
Loan-to-deposit ratio (period-end balances) 55.52 55.81 55.35 56.37 54.91 (29) bps 61 bps 55.52 54.91 61 bps
Loan-to-deposit ratio (average balances) 55.88 55.71 56.44 56.25 55.14 17 bps 74 bps 56.07 53.18 289 bps
Return on average total tangible assets 1.47 1.51 1.43 1.46 1.59 (4) bps (12) bps 1.47 1.41 6 bps
1 During the third quarter of 2023, the Company’s indirect auto and certain purchased consumer loan portfolios were transferred from Consumer Banking into a new Non-Core segment. In addition, the Company revised its funds transfer
pricing ("FTP") methodology relative to the funding of Non-Core assets, with the FTP charge based on a marginal high-cost funding waterfall approach. Prior period results have been revised to conform to the new segment presentation.
2 Includes loans held for sale.
11
-- 11 of 28 --
SEGMENT FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS - COMMERCIAL BANKING
(dollars in millions)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
COMMERCIAL BANKING 4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$/bps % $/bps % $/bps %
Net interest income $551 $560 $584 $597 $595 ($9) (2%) ($44) (7%) $2,292 $2,103 $189 9%
Noninterest income 196 180 207 201 198 16 9 (2) (1) 784 845 (61) (7)
Total revenue 747 740 791 798 793 7 1 (46) (6) 3,076 2,948 128 4
Noninterest expense 324 325 315 331 318 (1) — 6 2 1,295 1,223 72 6
Profit (loss) before credit losses 423 415 476 467 475 8 2 (52) (11) 1,781 1,725 56 3
Net charge-offs 65 67 71 47 12 (2) (3) 53 NM 250 46 204 NM
Income (loss) before income tax expense (benefit) 358 348 405 420 463 10 3 (105) (23) 1,531 1,679 (148) (9)
Income tax expense (benefit) 89 88 100 101 105 1 1 (16) (15) 378 375 3 1
Net income (loss) $269 $260 $305 $319 $358 $9 3% ($89) (25%) $1,153 $1,304 ($151) (12%)
AVERAGE BALANCES
Total assets $72,758 $74,997 $77,546 $78,891 $79,591 ($2,239) (3%) ($6,833) (9%) $76,028 $74,919 $1,109 1%
Total loans and leases1 69,899 71,898 74,295 75,734 75,773 (1,999) (3) (5,874) (8) 72,937 70,992 1,945 3
Deposits 46,962 47,221 45,494 48,966 52,303 (259) (1) (5,341) (10) 47,155 49,898 (2,743) (5)
Interest-earning assets 70,267 72,275 74,687 76,130 76,097 (2,008) (3) (5,830) (8) 73,321 71,276 2,045 3
KEY METRICS
Net interest margin 3.11 % 3.07 % 3.13 % 3.18 % 3.10 % 4 bps 1 bps 3.12 % 2.95 % 17 bps
Efficiency ratio 43.44 43.93 39.76 41.47 40.18 (49) bps 326 bps 42.10 41.50 60 bps
Loan-to-deposit ratio (period-end balances) 146.09 145.77 150.41 162.54 141.44 32 bps 465 bps 146.09 141.44 465 bps
Loan-to-deposit ratio (average balances) 147.64 150.96 160.89 153.33 143.49 (332) bps 415 bps 153.12 139.65 1,347 bps
Return on average total tangible assets 1.48 1.39 1.59 1.66 1.80 9 bps (32) bps 1.53 1.76 (23) bps
1 Includes loans held for sale.
12
-- 12 of 28 --
SEGMENT FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS - NON-CORE
(dollars in millions)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
NON-CORE1 4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$/bps % $/bps % $/bps %
Net interest income ($45) ($41) ($28) ($15) $19 ($4) (10%) ($64) NM ($129) $378 ($507) NM
Noninterest income — — — — — — — — — — — — —
Total revenue (45) (41) (28) (15) 19 (4) (10) (64) NM (129) 378 (507) NM
Noninterest expense 28 30 33 32 31 (2) (7) (3) (10) 123 136 (13) (10)
Profit (loss) before credit losses (73) (71) (61) (47) (12) (2) (3) (61) NM (252) 242 (494) NM
Net charge offs 24 20 13 21 19 4 20 5 26 78 52 26 50
Income (loss) before income tax expense (benefit) (97) (91) (74) (68) (31) (6) (7) (66) (213) (330) 190 (520) NM
Income tax expense (benefit) (25) (24) (19) (18) (8) (1) (4) (17) (213) (86) 48 (134) NM
Net income (loss) ($72) ($67) ($55) ($50) ($23) ($5) (7%) ($49) (213%) ($244) $142 ($386) NM
AVERAGE BALANCES
Total assets $11,776 $13,113 $14,456 $15,686 $16,752 ($1,337) (10%) ($4,976) (30%) $13,745 $18,121 ($4,376) (24%)
Total loans and leases2 11,701 13,010 14,395 15,620 16,683 (1,309) (10) (4,982) (30) 13,669 18,048 (4,379) (24)
Interest-earning assets 11,726 13,010 14,395 15,620 16,683 (1,284) (10) (4,957) (30) 13,675 18,048 (4,373) (24)
KEY METRICS
Net interest margin (1.54) % (1.24) % (0.77) % (0.40) % 0.47 % (30) bps (201) bps (0.94) % 2.10 % (304) bps
Return on average total tangible assets (2.42) (2.03) (1.53) (1.30) (0.54) (39) bps (188) bps (1.78) 0.78 (256) bps
1 During the third quarter of 2023, the Company’s indirect auto and certain purchased consumer loan portfolios were transferred from Consumer Banking into a new Non-Core segment. In addition, the Company revised its funds transfer
pricing ("FTP") methodology relative to the funding of Non-Core assets, with the FTP charge based on a marginal high-cost funding waterfall approach. Prior period results have been revised to conform to the new segment presentation.
2 Includes loans held for sale.
13
-- 13 of 28 --
SEGMENT FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS - OTHER
(dollars in millions)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
OTHER1,2 4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$ % $ % $ %
Net interest income ($104) ($64) $9 $50 $67 ($40) (63%) ($171) NM ($109) ($118) $9 8%
Noninterest income 39 34 31 28 51 5 15 (12) (24) 132 101 31 31
Total revenue (65) (30) 40 78 118 (35) (117) (183) NM 23 (17) 40 NM
Noninterest expense 355 33 83 76 60 322 NM 295 NM 547 278 269 97
Profit (loss) before provision (benefit) for credit losses (420) (63) (43) 2 58 (357) NM (478) NM (524) (295) (229) (78)
Provision (benefit) for credit losses — 18 24 37 44 (18) (100) (44) (100) 79 202 (123) (61)
Income (loss) before income tax expense (benefit) (420) (81) (67) (35) 14 (339) NM (434) NM (603) (497) (106) (21)
Income tax expense (benefit) (143) (42) (38) (20) (20) (101) (240) (123) NM (243) (169) (74) (44)
Net income (loss) ($277) ($39) ($29) ($15) $34 ($238) NM ($311) NM ($360) ($328) ($32) (10)
AVERAGE BALANCES
Total assets $65,785 $59,088 $57,788 $56,262 $56,939 $6,697 11% $8,846 16% $59,755 $53,994 $5,761 11%
Total loans and leases3 729 766 748 773 760 (37) (5) (31) (4) 755 736 19 3
Deposits 11,692 11,250 11,908 9,806 9,577 442 4 2,115 22 11,170 7,728 3,442 45
Interest-earning assets 53,604 47,035 45,482 44,550 45,405 6,569 14 8,199 18 47,691 41,522 6,169 15
1 Includes assets, liabilities, capital, revenues, provision for credit losses, expenses and income tax expense not attributed to our Consumer Banking, Commercial Banking, or Non-Core segments as well as treasury and community
development.
2 During the third quarter of 2023, the Company’s indirect auto and certain purchased consumer loan portfolios were transferred from Consumer Banking into a new Non-Core segment. In addition, the Company revised its funds transfer
pricing ("FTP") methodology relative to the funding of Non-Core assets, with the FTP charge based on a marginal high-cost funding waterfall approach. Prior period results have been revised to conform to the new segment presentation.
3 Includes loans held for sale.
14
-- 14 of 28 --
CREDIT-RELATED INFORMATION
(dollars in millions)
AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2023 CHANGE
Dec 31, 2023 Sept 30, 2023 June 30, 2023 Mar 31, 2023 Dec 31, 2022 Sept 30, 2023 December 31, 2022
$/bps/% % $/bps/% %
NONACCRUAL LOANS AND LEASES
Commercial and industrial $294 $242 $280 $297 $249 $52 21% $45 18%
Commercial real estate 477 470 352 140 103 7 1 374 NM
Leases 3 3 3 — — — — 3 100
Total commercial 774 715 635 437 352 59 8 422 120
Residential mortgages1 177 190 201 216 234 (13) (7) (57) (24)
Home equity 285 268 251 240 241 17 6 44 18
Automobile 61 62 51 50 56 (1) (2) 5 9
Education 28 23 22 23 33 5 22 (5) (15)
Other retail 39 38 31 30 28 1 3 11 39
Total retail 590 581 556 559 592 9 2 (2) —
Nonaccrual loans and leases 1,364 1,296 1,191 996 944 68 5 420 44
Repossessed assets 14 15 11 14 16 (1) (7) (2) (13)
Nonaccrual loans and leases and repossessed assets $1,378 $1,311 $1,202 $1,010 $960 $67 5% $418 44%
NONACCRUAL LOANS AND LEASES BY PRODUCT2
Commercial $774 $715 $635 $437 $352 $59 8% $422 120%
Retail 604 596 567 573 608 8 1 (4) (1)
Total nonaccrual loans and leases $1,378 $1,311 $1,202 $1,010 $960 $67 5% $418 44%
ASSET QUALITY RATIOS
Allowance for loan and lease losses to loans and leases 1.44% 1.39% 1.35% 1.30% 1.27% 5 bps 17 bps
Allowance for credit losses to loans and leases 1.59 1.55 1.52 1.47 1.43 4 16
Allowance for loan and lease losses to nonaccrual loans and leases 154 160 172 203 210 (6%) (56%)
Allowance for credit losses to nonaccrual loans and leases 170 179 193 229 237 (9%) (67%)
Nonaccrual loans and leases to loans and leases 0.93 0.87 0.79 0.64 0.60 6 bps 33 bps
1Loans fully or partially guaranteed by the FHA, VA and USDA are classified as accruing.
2Nonaccrual loans and leases by product includes repossessed assets.
15
-- 15 of 28 --
CREDIT-RELATED INFORMATION, CONTINUED
(dollars in millions)
AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2023 CHANGE
Dec 31, 2023 Sept 30, 2023 June 30, 2023 Mar 31, 2023 Dec 31, 2022 Sept 30, 2023 December 31, 2022
$/bps % $/bps %
LOANS AND LEASES 90 DAYS OR MORE PAST DUE AND ACCRUING
Commercial and industrial $6 $4 $2 $21 $21 $2 50% ($15) (71%)
Commercial real estate 40 3 — 63 1 37 NM 39 NM
Leases — — — — — — — — —
Total commercial 46 7 2 84 22 39 NM 24 109
Residential mortgages1 256 217 257 314 319 39 18 (63) (20)
Home equity — — — — — — — — —
Automobile — — — — — — — — —
Education 2 3 3 3 4 (1) (33) (2) (50)
Other retail 29 21 20 23 22 8 38 7 32
Total retail 287 241 280 340 345 46 19 (58) (17)
Total loans and leases $333 $248 $282 $424 $367 $85 34% ($34) (9%)
1 90+ days past due and accruing includes $243 million, $216 million, $256 million, $309 million, and $316 million of loans fully or partially guaranteed by the FHA, VA, and USDA for December 31, 2023, September 30, 2023, June 30, 2023,
March 31, 2023 and December 31, 2022, respectively.
16
-- 16 of 28 --
CREDIT-RELATED INFORMATION, CONTINUED
(dollars in millions)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$ % $ % $ %
CHARGE-OFFS, RECOVERIES AND RELATED RATIOS
GROSS CHARGE-OFFS
Commercial and industrial $24 $25 $17 $55 $21 ($1) (4%) $3 14 $121 $68 $53 78%
Commercial real estate 49 49 62 4 — — — 49 100 164 2 162 NM
Leases — — — — — — — — — — — — —
Total commercial 73 74 79 59 21 (1) (1) 52 248 285 70 215 NM
Residential mortgages 3 1 1 1 1 2 200 2 200 6 5 1 20
Home equity 4 3 3 2 2 1 33 2 100 12 9 3 33
Automobile 31 28 24 30 27 3 11 4 15 113 93 20 22
Education 35 27 26 23 24 8 30 11 46 111 78 33 42
Other retail 60 58 56 56 51 2 3 9 18 230 179 51 28
Total retail 133 117 110 112 105 16 14 28 27 472 364 108 30
Total gross charge-offs $206 $191 $189 $171 $126 $15 8% $80 63% $757 $434 $323 74%
GROSS RECOVERIES
Commercial and industrial $3 $3 $2 $3 $5 $— —% ($2) (40%) $11 $17 ($6) (35%)
Commercial real estate 1 1 — 1 — — — 1 100 3 1 2 200
Leases — — 1 3 — — — — — 4 — 4 100
Total commercial 4 4 3 7 5 — — (1) (20) 18 18 — —
Residential mortgages 1 2 1 — 1 (1) (50) — — 4 6 (2) (33)
Home equity 5 6 6 5 6 (1) (17) (1) (17) 22 37 (15) (41)
Automobile 14 13 16 15 14 1 8 — — 58 57 1 2
Education 5 5 4 5 5 — — — — 19 19 — —
Other retail 6 8 7 6 7 (2) (25) (1) (14) 27 27 — —
Total retail 31 34 34 31 33 (3) (9) (2) (6) 130 146 (16) (11)
Total gross recoveries $35 $38 $37 $38 $38 ($3) (8%) ($3) (8%) $148 $164 ($16) (10%)
NET CHARGE-OFFS (RECOVERIES)
Commercial and industrial $21 $22 $15 $52 $16 ($1) (5%) $5 31 $110 $51 $59 116
Commercial real estate 48 48 62 3 — — — 48 100 161 1 160 NM
Leases — — (1) (3) — — — — — (4) — (4) —
Total commercial 69 70 76 52 16 (1) (1) 53 NM 267 52 215 NM
Residential mortgages 2 (1) — 1 — 3 NM 2 100 2 (1) 3 NM
Home equity (1) (3) (3) (3) (4) 2 67 3 75 (10) (28) 18 64
Automobile 17 15 8 15 13 2 13 4 31 55 36 19 53
Education 30 22 22 18 19 8 36 11 58 92 59 33 56
Other retail 54 50 49 50 44 4 8 10 23 203 152 51 34
Total retail 102 83 76 81 72 19 23 30 42 342 218 124 57
Total net charge-offs $171 $153 $152 $133 $88 $18 12% $83 94% $609 $270 $339 126%
17
-- 17 of 28 --
CREDIT-RELATED INFORMATION, CONTINUED
(dollars in millions)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$/bps % $/bps % $/bps %
ANNUALIZED NET CHARGE-OFF (RECOVERY) RATES
Commercial and industrial 0.18% 0.18% 0.12% 0.40% 0.12% — bps 6 bps 0.23% 0.10% 13 bps
Commercial real estate 0.66 0.65 0.86 0.05 — 1 66 0.56 — 56
Leases (0.04) — (0.22) (0.85) (0.06) (4) 2 (0.29) (0.03) (26)
Total commercial 0.36 0.35 0.38 0.26 0.07 1 29 0.34 0.07 27
Residential mortgages 0.02 (0.02) — 0.01 — 4 2 — — —
Home equity (0.04) (0.08) (0.08) (0.07) (0.12) 4 8 (0.07) (0.22) 15
Automobile 0.77 0.60 0.30 0.51 0.42 17 35 0.53 0.26 27
Education 1.00 0.72 0.68 0.57 0.59 28 41 0.74 0.45 29
Other retail 4.13 3.95 3.84 3.81 3.21 18 92 3.93 2.77 116
Total retail 0.56 0.46 0.41 0.44 0.39 10 17 0.47 0.30 17
Total loans and leases 0.46 % 0.40 % 0.40 % 0.34 % 0.22 % 6 bps 24 bps 0.40 % 0.18 % 22 bps
Memo: Average loans
Commercial and industrial $45,433 $47,658 $49,770 $51,993 $52,311 ($2,225) (5%) ($6,878) (13%) $48,693 $50,002 ($1,309) (3%)
Commercial real estate 29,460 29,353 29,115 28,892 28,735 107 — 725 3 29,206 24,746 4,460 18
Leases 1,185 1,250 1,352 1,436 1,422 (65) (5) (237) (17) 1,305 1,521 (216) (14)
Total commercial 76,078 78,261 80,237 82,321 82,468 (2,183) (3) (6,390) (8) 79,204 76,269 2,935 4
Residential mortgages 31,146 30,838 30,566 30,075 29,677 308 1 1,469 5 30,660 27,759 2,901 10
Home equity 14,889 14,589 14,340 14,073 13,869 300 2 1,020 7 14,475 13,057 1,418 11
Automobile 8,752 9,849 10,997 11,937 12,692 (1,097) (11) (3,940) (31) 10,374 13,729 (3,355) (24)
Education 11,971 12,147 12,430 12,796 12,929 (176) (1) (958) (7) 12,333 13,047 (714) (5)
Other retail 5,133 5,107 5,155 5,290 5,464 26 1 (331) (6) 5,171 5,483 (312) (6)
Total retail 71,891 72,530 73,488 74,171 74,631 (639) (1) (2,740) (4) 73,013 73,075 (62) —
Total loans and leases $147,969 $150,791 $153,725 $156,492 $157,099 ($2,822) (2%) ($9,130) (6%) $152,217 $149,344 $2,873 2%
18
-- 18 of 28 --
CREDIT-RELATED INFORMATION, CONTINUED
(dollars in millions)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$ % $ % $ %
SUMMARY OF CHANGES IN THE COMPONENTS OF THE
ALLOWANCE FOR CREDIT LOSSES
Allowance for loan and lease losses - beginning $2,080 $2,044 $2,017 $1,983 $1,980 $36 2% $100 5% $1,983 $1,758 $225 13%
Allowance on PCD loans and leases at acquisition:
Commercial — — — — — — — — — — 99 (99) (100)
Retail — — — — — — — — — — 2 (2) (100)
Total Allowance on PCD loans and leases at acquisition — — — — — — — — — — 101 (101) (100)
Charge-offs:
Commercial 73 74 79 59 21 (1) (1) 52 248 285 70 215 NM
Retail 133 117 110 112 105 16 14 28 27 472 364 108 30
Total charge-offs 206 191 189 171 126 15 8 80 63 757 434 323 74
Recoveries:
Commercial 4 4 3 7 5 — — (1) (20) 18 18 — —
Retail 31 34 34 31 33 (3) (9) (2) (6) 130 146 (16) (11)
Total recoveries 35 38 37 38 38 (3) (8) (3) (8) 148 164 (16) (10)
Net charge-offs 171 153 152 133 88 18 12 83 94 609 270 339 126
Provision (benefit) for loan and lease losses:
Commercial 86 146 122 103 46 (60) (41) 40 87 457 192 265 138
Retail 103 43 57 64 45 60 140 58 129 267 202 65 32
Total provision (benefit) for loan and lease losses 189 189 179 167 91 — — 98 108 724 394 330 84
Allowance for loan and lease losses - ending $2,098 $2,080 $2,044 $2,017 $1,983 $18 1% $115 6% $2,098 $1,983 $115 6%
Allowance for unfunded lending commitments -
beginning $238 $255 $258 $257 $216 ($17) (7%) $22 10% $257 $176 $81 46%
Allowance on PCD unfunded lending commitments at
acquisition — — — — — — —% — — — 1 (1) (100)
Provision (benefit) for unfunded lending commitments (18) (17) (3) 1 41 (1) (6%) (59) NM (37) 80 (117) NM
Allowance for unfunded lending commitments - ending $220 $238 $255 $258 $257 ($18) (8%) ($37) (14) $220 $257 ($37) (14)
Total allowance for credit losses - ending $2,318 $2,318 $2,299 $2,275 $2,240 $— —% $78 3% $2,318 $2,240 $78 3%
Memo: Total allowance for credit losses by product
Commercial $1,425 $1,425 $1,370 $1,326 $1,267 $— —% $158 12% $1,425 $1,267 $158 12%
Retail 893 893 929 949 973 — — (80) (8) 893 973 (80) (8)
Total allowance for credit losses $2,318 $2,318 $2,299 $2,275 $2,240 $— —% $78 3% $2,318 $2,240 $78 3%
19
-- 19 of 28 --
CAPITAL AND RATIOS
(dollars in millions)
AS OF FULL YEAR
DECEMBER 31, 2023 CHANGE 2023 Change
Dec 31, 2023 Sept 30, 2023 June 30, 2023 Mar 31, 2023 Dec 31, 2022 Sept 30, 2023 December 31, 2022 2023 2022 2022
$ % $ % $ %
CAPITAL RATIOS AND COMPONENTS
(PRELIMINARY)
CET1 capital $18,358 $18,360 $18,381 $18,370 $18,574 ($2) —% ($216) (1%)
Tier 1 capital 20,372 20,374 20,395 20,384 20,588 (2) — (216) (1)
Total capital 23,608 23,682 23,748 23,720 23,755 (74) — (147) (1)
Risk-weighted assets 172,601 176,407 179,034 183,246 185,224 (3,806) (2) (12,623) (7)
Adjusted average assets1 219,591 215,877 217,264 217,998 220,779 3,714 2 (1,188) (1)
CET1 capital ratio 10.6 % 10.4 % 10.3 % 10.0 % 10.0 %
Tier 1 capital ratio 11.8 11.5 11.4 11.1 11.1
Total capital ratio 13.7 13.4 13.3 12.9 12.8
Tier 1 leverage ratio 9.3 9.4 9.4 9.4 9.3
TANGIBLE COMMON EQUITY (PERIOD-END)
Common stockholders' equity $22,329 $20,864 $21,571 $22,187 $21,676 $1,465 7% $653 3% $22,329 $21,676 $653 3%
Less: Goodwill 8,188 8,188 8,188 8,177 8,173 — — 15 — 8,188 8,173 15 —
Less: Other intangible assets 157 167 175 185 197 (10) (6) (40) (20) 157 197 (40) (20)
Add: Deferred tax liabilities2 433 421 422 422 422 12 3 11 3 433 422 11 3
Total tangible common equity $14,417 $12,930 $13,630 $14,247 $13,728 $1,487 12% $689 5% $14,417 $13,728 $689 5%
TANGIBLE COMMON EQUITY (AVERAGE)
Common stockholders' equity $21,209 $21,177 $22,289 $21,702 $21,276 $32 —% ($67) —% $21,592 $21,724 ($132) (1%)
Less: Goodwill 8,188 8,188 8,182 8,177 8,171 — — 17 — 8,184 7,872 312 4
Less: Other intangible assets 163 173 181 192 199 (10) (6) (36) (18) 177 181 (4) (2)
Add: Deferred tax liabilities2 421 422 422 422 424 (1) — (3) (1) 422 413 9 2
Total tangible common equity $13,279 $13,238 $14,348 $13,755 $13,330 $41 —% ($51) —% $13,653 $14,084 ($431) (3%)
INTANGIBLE ASSETS (PERIOD-END)
Goodwill $8,188 $8,188 $8,188 $8,177 $8,173 $— —% $15 —% $8,188 $8,173 $15 —%
Other intangible assets 157 167 175 185 197 (10) (6) (40) (20) 157 197 (40) (20)
Total intangible assets $8,345 $8,355 $8,363 $8,362 $8,370 ($10) —% ($25) —% $8,345 $8,370 ($25) —%
1Adjusted average assets include quarterly average assets, less deductions for disallowed goodwill and other intangible assets, net of deferred taxes, and the accumulated other comprehensive
income impact related to the adoption of post-retirement benefit plan guidance under GAAP.
2Deferred tax liabilities relate to tax-deductible goodwill and other intangible assets.
20
-- 20 of 28 --
NON-GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES AND RECONCILIATIONS
(dollars in millions, except per share data)
Non-GAAP Financial Measures
This document contains non-GAAP financial measures denoted as Underlying. Underlying results for any given reporting period exclude certain items that may occur in that period which management does not
consider indicative of the Company’s on-going financial performance. We believe these non-GAAP financial measures provide useful information to investors because they are used by our management to evaluate
our operating performance and make day-to-day operating decisions. In addition, we believe our Underlying results in any given reporting period reflect our on-going financial performance in that period and,
accordingly, are useful to consider in addition to our GAAP financial results. The following tables present reconciliations of our non-GAAP measures to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures.
Other companies may use similarly titled non-GAAP financial measures that are calculated differently from the way we calculate such measures. Accordingly, our non-GAAP financial measures may not be
comparable to similar measures used by such companies. We caution investors not to place undue reliance on such non-GAAP financial measures, but to consider them with the most directly comparable GAAP
measures. Non-GAAP financial measures have limitations as analytical tools and should not be considered in isolation or as a substitute for our results reported under GAAP.
21
-- 21 of 28 --
NON-GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES AND RECONCILIATIONS, CONTINUED (dollars in millions, except per share data)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$ % $ % $ %
Noninterest income, Underlying:
Noninterest income (GAAP) A $500 $492 $506 $485 $505 $8 2% ($5) (1%) $1,983 $2,009 ($26) (1%)
Less: Notable items — — — — — — — — — — (31) 31 100
Noninterest income, Underlying (non-GAAP) B $500 $492 $506 $485 $505 $8 2% ($5) (1%) $1,983 $2,040 ($57) (3%)
Total revenue, Underlying:
Total revenue (GAAP) C $1,988 $2,014 $2,094 $2,128 $2,200 ($26) (1%) ($212) (10%) $8,224 $8,021 $203 3%
Less: Notable items — — — — — — — — — — (31) 31 100
Total revenue, Underlying (non-GAAP) D $1,988 $2,014 $2,094 $2,128 $2,200 ($26) (1%) ($212) (10%) $8,224 $8,052 $172 2%
Noninterest expense, Underlying:
Noninterest expense (GAAP) E $1,612 $1,293 $1,306 $1,296 $1,240 $319 25% $372 30% $5,507 $4,892 $615 13%
Less: Notable items 345 22 73 66 43 323 NM 302 NM 506 262 244 93
Noninterest expense, Underlying (non-GAAP) F $1,267 $1,271 $1,233 $1,230 $1,197 ($4) —% $70 6% $5,001 $4,630 $371 8%
Pre-provision profit:
Total revenue (GAAP) C $1,988 $2,014 $2,094 $2,128 $2,200 ($26) (1%) ($212) (10%) $8,224 $8,021 $203 3%
Less: Noninterest expense (GAAP) E 1,612 1,293 1,306 1,296 1,240 319 25 372 30 5,507 4,892 615 13
Pre-provision profit (GAAP) $376 $721 $788 $832 $960 ($345) (48%) ($584) (61%) $2,717 $3,129 ($412) (13%)
Pre-provision profit, Underlying:
Total revenue, Underlying (non-GAAP) D $1,988 $2,014 $2,094 $2,128 $2,200 ($26) (1%) ($212) (10%) $8,224 $8,052 $172 2%
Less: Noninterest expense, Underlying (non-GAAP) F 1,267 1,271 1,233 1,230 1,197 (4) — 70 6 5,001 4,630 371 8
Pre-provision profit, Underlying (non-GAAP) $721 $743 $861 $898 $1,003 ($22) (3%) ($282) (28%) $3,223 $3,422 ($199) (6%)
Provision (benefit) for credit losses, Underlying:
Provision (benefit) for credit losses (GAAP) $171 $172 $176 $168 $132 ($1) (1%) $39 30% $687 $474 $213 45%
Less: Notable items — — — — — — — — — — 169 (169) (100)
Provision (benefit) for credit losses, Underlying (non-
GAAP) $171 $172 $176 $168 $132 ($1) (1%) $39 30% $687 $305 $382 125%
Income before income tax expense, Underlying:
Income before income tax expense (GAAP) G $205 $549 $612 $664 $828 ($344) (63%) ($623) (75%) $2,030 $2,655 ($625) (24%)
Less: Income (expense) before income tax expense
(benefit) related to notable items (345) (22) (73) (66) (43) (323) NM (302) NM (506) (462) (44) (10)
Income before income tax expense, Underlying (non-
GAAP) H $550 $571 $685 $730 $871 ($21) (4%) ($321) (37%) $2,536 $3,117 ($581) (19%)
Income tax expense, Underlying:
Income tax expense (GAAP) I $16 $119 $134 $153 $175 ($103) (87%) ($159) (91%) $422 $582 ($160) (27%)
Less: Income tax expense (benefit) related to notable
items (108) (4) (20) (17) (11) (104) NM (97) NM (149) (110) (39) (35)
Income tax expense, Underlying (non-GAAP) J $124 $123 $154 $170 $186 $1 1% ($62) (33%) $571 $692 ($121) (17%)
Net income, Underlying:
Net income (GAAP) K $189 $430 $478 $511 $653 ($241) (56%) ($464) (71%) $1,608 $2,073 ($465) (22%)
Add: Notable items, net of income tax benefit 237 18 53 49 32 219 NM 205 NM 357 352 5 1
Net income, Underlying (non-GAAP) L $426 $448 $531 $560 $685 ($22) (5%) ($259) (38%) $1,965 $2,425 ($460) (19%)
Net income available to common stockholders,
Underlying:
Net income available to common stockholders (GAAP) M $159 $400 $444 $488 $621 ($241) (60%) ($462) (74%) $1,491 $1,960 ($469) (24%)
Add: Notable items, net of income tax benefit 237 18 53 49 32 219 NM 205 NM 357 352 5 1
Net income available to common stockholders,
Underlying (non-GAAP) N $396 $418 $497 $537 $653 ($22) (5%) ($257) (39%) $1,848 $2,312 ($464) (20%)
22
-- 22 of 28 --
NON-GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES AND RECONCILIATIONS, CONTINUED
(dollars in millions, except per share data)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$/bps % $/bps % $/bps %
Operating leverage:
Total revenue (GAAP) C $1,988 $2,014 $2,094 $2,128 $2,200 ($26) (1.39%) ($212) (9.70%) $8,224 $8,021 $203 2.53%
Less: Noninterest expense (GAAP) E 1,612 1,293 1,306 1,296 1,240 319 24.60 372 30.00 5,507 4,892 615 12.58
Operating leverage (25.99%) (39.70%) (10.05%)
Operating leverage, Underlying:
Total revenue, Underlying (non-GAAP) D $1,988 $2,014 $2,094 $2,128 $2,200 ($26) (1.39%) ($212) (9.70%) $8,224 $8,052 $172 2.13%
Less: Noninterest expense, Underlying (non-GAAP) F 1,267 1,271 1,233 1,230 1,197 (4) (0.30) 70 5.82 5,001 4,630 371 8.00
Operating leverage, Underlying (non-GAAP) (1.09%) (15.52%) (5.87%)
Efficiency ratio and efficiency ratio, Underlying:
Efficiency ratio E/C 81.13% 64.21% 62.34% 60.90% 56.36% 1,692 bps 2,477 bps 66.97 % 60.99 % 598 bps
Efficiency ratio, Underlying (non-GAAP) F/D 63.77 63.08 58.86 57.84 54.42 69 bps 935 bps 60.81 57.51 330 bps
Noninterest income as a % of total revenue,
Underlying:
Noninterest income as a % of total revenue A/C 25.16 % 24.44% 24.14% 22.81% 22.92% 72 bps 224 bps 24.12 % 25.04 % (92) bps
Noninterest income as a % of total revenue,
Underlying B/D 25.16 24.44 24.14 22.81 22.92 72 bps 224 bps 24.12 25.33 (121) bps
Effective income tax rate and effective income tax
rate, Underlying:
Effective income tax rate I/G 7.59% 21.51% 22.09% 22.97% 21.16% (1,392) bps (1,357) bps 20.76 % 21.93 % (117) bps
Effective income tax rate, Underlying (non-GAAP) J/H 22.25 21.69 22.51 23.25 21.37 56 bps 88 bps 22.48 22.19 29 bps
Return on average common equity and return on
average common equity, Underlying:
Average common equity (GAAP) O $21,209 $21,177 $22,289 $21,702 $21,276 $32 —% ($67) —% $21,592 $21,724 ($132) (1%)
Return on average common equity M/O 2.96% 7.50% 8.00% 9.11% 11.56% (454) bps (860) bps 6.90 % 9.02 % (212) bps
Return on average common equity, Underlying (non-
GAAP) N/O 7.41 7.82 8.97 10.01 12.15 (41) bps (474) bps 8.56 10.64 (208) bps
Return on average tangible common equity and
return on average tangible common equity,
Underlying:
Average common equity (GAAP) O $21,209 $21,177 $22,289 $21,702 $21,276 $32 —% ($67) —% $21,592 $21,724 ($132) (1%)
Less: Average goodwill (GAAP) 8,188 8,188 8,182 8,177 8,171 — — 17 — 8,184 7,872 312 4
Less: Average other intangibles (GAAP) 163 173 181 192 199 (10) (6) (36) (18) 177 181 (4) (2)
Add: Average deferred tax liabilities related to
goodwill and other intangible assets (GAAP) 421 422 422 422 424 (1) — (3) (1) 422 413 9 2
Average tangible common equity P $13,279 $13,238 $14,348 $13,755 $13,330 $41 —% ($51) —% $13,653 $14,084 ($431) (3%)
Return on average tangible common equity M/P 4.72% 12.00% 12.42% 14.38% 18.46% (728) bps (1,374) bps 10.92 % 13.91 % (299) bps
Return on average tangible common equity,
Underlying (non-GAAP) N/P 11.84 12.51 13.93 15.80 19.40 (67) bps (756) bps 13.53 16.41 (288) bps
Return on average total assets and return on
average total assets, Underlying:
Average total assets (GAAP) Q $223,653 $220,162 $222,373 $222,711 $224,970 $3,491 2% ($1,317) (1%) $222,221 $215,061 $7,160 3%
Return on average total assets K/Q 0.33% 0.78% 0.86% 0.93% 1.15% (45) bps (82) bps 0.72 % 0.96 % (24) bps
Return on average total assets, Underlying (non-
GAAP) L/Q 0.76 0.81 0.96 1.02 1.21 (5) bps (45) bps 0.88 1.13 (25) bps
23
-- 23 of 28 --
NON-GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES AND RECONCILIATIONS, CONTINUED
(dollars in millions, except per share data)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$/bps % $/bps % $/bps %
Return on average total tangible assets and
return on average total tangible assets,
Underlying:
Average total assets (GAAP) Q $223,653 $220,162 $222,373 $222,711 $224,970 $3,491 2% ($1,317) (1%) $222,221 $215,061 $7,160 3%
Less: Average goodwill (GAAP) 8,188 8,188 8,182 8,177 8,171 — — 17 — 8,184 7,872 312 4
Less: Average other intangibles (GAAP) 163 173 181 192 199 (10) (6) (36) (18) 177 181 (4) (2)
Add: Average deferred tax liabilities related to
goodwill and other intangible assets (GAAP) 421 422 422 422 424 (1) — (3) (1) 422 413 9 2
Average tangible assets R $215,723 $212,223 $214,432 $214,764 $217,024 $3,500 2% ($1,301) (1%) $214,282 $207,421 $6,861 3%
Return on average total tangible assets K/R 0.35 % 0.81% 0.89% 0.97% 1.19% (46) bps (84) bps 0.75 % 1.00 % (25) bps
Return on average total tangible assets,
Underlying (non-GAAP) L/R 0.78 0.84 0.99 1.06 1.25 (6) bps (47) bps 0.92 1.17 (25) bps
Tangible book value per common share:
Common shares - at period-end (GAAP) S 466,418,055 466,221,795 474,682,759 483,982,264 492,282,158 196,260 —% (25,864,103) (5%) 466,418,055 492,282,158 (25,864,103) (5%)
Common stockholders' equity (GAAP) $22,329 $20,864 $21,571 $22,187 $21,676 $1,465 7 $653 3 $22,329 $21,676 $653 3
Less: Goodwill (GAAP) 8,188 8,188 8,188 8,177 8,173 — — 15 — 8,188 8,173 15 —
Less: Other intangible assets (GAAP) 157 167 175 185 197 (10) (6) (40) (20) 157 197 (40) (20)
Add: Deferred tax liabilities related to goodwill
and other intangible assets (GAAP) 433 421 422 422 422 12 3 11 3 433 422 11 3
Tangible common equity T $14,417 $12,930 $13,630 $14,247 $13,728 $1,487 12% $689 5% $14,417 $13,728 $689 5%
Tangible book value per common share T/S $30.91 $27.73 $28.72 $29.44 $27.88 $3.18 11% $3.03 11% $30.91 $27.88 $3.03 11%
Net income per average common share - basic
and diluted and net income per average
common share - basic and diluted, Underlying:
Average common shares outstanding - basic
(GAAP) U 466,234,324 469,481,085 479,470,543 485,444,313 493,293,981 (3,246,761) (1%) (27,059,657) (5%) 475,089,384 475,959,815 (870,431) —%
Average common shares outstanding - diluted
(GAAP) V 468,159,167 471,183,719 480,975,281 487,712,146 495,478,398 (3,024,552) (1) (27,319,231) (6) 476,693,148 477,803,142 (1,109,994) —
Net income per average common share - basic
(GAAP) M/U $0.34 $0.85 $0.93 $1.00 $1.26 ($0.51) (60) ($0.92) (73) $3.14 $4.12 ($0.98) (24)
Net income per average common share - diluted
(GAAP) M/V 0.34 0.85 0.92 1.00 1.25 (0.51) (60) (0.91) (73) 3.13 4.10 (0.97) (24)
Net income per average common share - basic,
Underlying (non-GAAP) N/U 0.85 0.89 1.04 1.10 1.32 (0.04) (4) (0.47) (36) 3.89 4.86 (0.97) (20)
Net income per average common share - diluted,
Underlying (non-GAAP) N/V 0.85 0.89 1.04 1.10 1.32 (0.04) (4) (0.47) (36) 3.88 4.84 (0.96) (20)
Dividend payout ratio and dividend payout
ratio, Underlying:
Cash dividends declared and paid per common
share W $0.42 $0.42 $0.42 $0.42 $0.42 $— —% $— —% $1.68 $1.62 $0.06 4%
Dividend payout ratio W/(M/U) 124 % 49 % 45 % 42 % 33 % 7,412 bps 9,053 bps 54 % 39 % 1,450 bps
Dividend payout ratio, Underlying (non-GAAP) W/(N/U) 49 47 40 38 32 200 bps 1,700 bps 43 33 1,000 bps
24
-- 24 of 28 --
NON-GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES AND RECONCILIATIONS, CONTINUED
(dollars in millions, except per share data)
QUARTERLY TRENDS FULL YEAR
4Q23 Change 2023 Change
4Q23 3Q23 2Q23 1Q23 4Q22 3Q23 4Q22 2023 2022 2022
$ % $ % $/bps %
Other income, Underlying:
Other income (GAAP) $20 $18 $23 $17 $36 $2 11% ($16) (44%) $78 $82 ($4) (5%)
Less: Notable items — — — — — — — — — — (31) 31 100
Other income, Underlying (non-GAAP) $20 $18 $23 $17 $36 $2 11 ($16) (44%) $78 $113 ($35) (31%)
Salaries and employee benefits, Underlying:
Salaries and employee benefits (GAAP) $667 $659 $615 $658 $633 $8 1% $34 5% $2,599 $2,549 $50 2%
Less: Notable items 32 5 14 16 15 27 NM 17 113 67 110 (43) (39)
Salaries and employee benefits, Underlying (non-GAAP) $635 $654 $601 $642 $618 ($19) (3%) $17 3% $2,532 $2,439 $93 4%
Equipment and software, Underlying:
Equipment and software (GAAP) $215 $191 $181 $169 $170 $24 13% $45 26% $756 $648 $108 17%
Less: Notable items 37 6 4 4 2 31 NM 35 NM 51 10 41 NM
Equipment and software, Underlying (non-GAAP) $178 $185 $177 $165 $168 ($7) (4%) $10 6% $705 $638 $67 11%
Outside services, Underlying:
Outside services (GAAP) $174 $160 $177 $176 $170 $14 9% $4 2% $687 $700 ($13) (2%)
Less: Notable items 13 7 21 27 17 6 86 (4) (24) 68 113 (45) (40)
Outside services, Underlying (non-GAAP) $161 $153 $156 $149 $153 $8 5% $8 5% $619 $587 $32 5%
Occupancy, Underlying:
Occupancy (GAAP) $125 $107 $136 $124 $110 $18 17% $15 14% $492 $410 $82 20%
Less: Notable items 20 2 30 18 2 18 NM 18 NM 70 5 65 NM
Occupancy, Underlying (non-GAAP) $105 $105 $106 $106 $108 $— —% ($3) (3%) $422 $405 $17 4%
Other operating expense, Underlying:
Other operating expense (GAAP) $431 $176 $197 $169 $157 $255 145% $274 175% $973 $585 $388 66%
Less: Notable items 243 2 4 1 7 241 NM 236 NM 250 24 226 NM
Other operating expense, Underlying (non-GAAP) $188 $174 $193 $168 $150 $14 8% $38 25% $723 $561 $162 29%
25
-- 25 of 28 --
NON-GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES AND RECONCILIATIONS - SEGMENTS1
(dollars in millions)
FOURTH QUARTER 2023 THIRD QUARTER 2023
Consumer
Banking Commercial
Banking Non-Core Other Consolidated Consumer
Banking Commercial
Banking Non-Core Other Consolidated
Net income (loss) available to common stockholders:
Net income (loss) A $269 $269 ($72) ($277) $189 $276 $260 ($67) ($39) $430
Less: Preferred stock dividends — — — 30 30 — — — 30 30
Net income (loss) available to common stockholders B $269 $269 ($72) ($307) $159 $276 $260 ($67) ($69) $400
Return on average total tangible assets:
Average total assets (GAAP) $73,334 $72,758 $11,776 $65,785 $223,653 $72,964 $74,997 $13,113 $59,088 $220,162
Less: Average goodwill (GAAP) 542 770 — 6,876 8,188 542 770 — 6,876 8,188
Average other intangibles (GAAP) 98 35 — 30 163 103 39 — 31 173
Add: Average deferred tax liabilities related to goodwill and other
intangible assets (GAAP) 26 10 — 385 421 24 12 — 386 422
Average tangible assets C $72,720 $71,963 $11,776 $59,264 $215,723 $72,343 $74,200 $13,113 $52,567 $212,223
Return on average total tangible assets A/C 1.47 % 1.48 % (2.42) % NM 0.35 % 1.51 % 1.39 % (2.03) % NM 0.81 %
Efficiency ratio:
Noninterest expense (GAAP) D $905 $324 $28 $355 $1,612 $905 $325 $30 $33 $1,293
Net interest income (GAAP) 1,086 551 (45) (104) 1,488 1,067 560 (41) (64) 1,522
Noninterest income (GAAP) 265 196 — 39 500 278 180 — 34 492
Total revenue (GAAP) E $1,351 $747 ($45) ($65) $1,988 $1,345 $740 ($41) ($30) $2,014
Efficiency ratio D/E 67.08 % 43.44 % NM NM 81.13 % 67.18 % 43.93 % NM NM 64.21 %
SECOND QUARTER 2023 FIRST QUARTER 2023
Consumer
Banking Commercial
Banking Non-Core Other Consolidated Consumer
Banking Commercial
Banking Non-Core Other Consolidated
Net income (loss) available to common stockholders:
Net income (loss) A $257 $305 ($55) ($29) $478 $257 $319 ($50) ($15) $511
Less: Preferred stock dividends — — — 34 34 — — — 23 23
Net income (loss) available to common stockholders B $257 $305 ($55) ($63) $444 $257 $319 ($50) ($38) $488
Return on average total tangible assets:
Average total assets (GAAP) $72,583 $77,546 $14,456 $57,788 $222,373 $71,872 $78,891 $15,686 $56,262 $222,711
Less: Average goodwill (GAAP) 540 766 — 6,876 8,182 538 763 — 6,876 8,177
Average other intangibles (GAAP) 109 41 — 31 181 115 43 — 34 192
Add: Average deferred tax liabilities related to goodwill and other
intangible assets (GAAP) 23 11 — 388 422 23 12 — 387 422
Average tangible assets C $71,957 $76,750 $14,456 $51,269 $214,432 $71,242 $78,097 $15,686 $49,739 $214,764
Return on average total tangible assets A/C 1.43 % 1.59 % (1.53) % NM 0.89 % 1.46 % 1.66 % (1.30) % NM 0.97 %
Efficiency ratio:
Noninterest expense (GAAP) D $875 $315 $33 $83 $1,306 $857 $331 $32 $76 $1,296
Net interest income (GAAP) 1,023 584 (28) 9 1,588 1,011 597 (15) 50 1,643
Noninterest income (GAAP) 268 207 — 31 506 256 201 — 28 485
Total revenue (GAAP) E $1,291 $791 ($28) $40 $2,094 $1,267 $798 ($15) $78 $2,128
Efficiency ratio D/E 67.74 % 39.76 % NM NM 62.34 % 67.70 % 41.47 % NM NM 60.90 %
26
-- 26 of 28 --
NON-GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES AND RECONCILIATIONS - SEGMENTS, CONTINUED1
(dollars in millions)
FOURTH QUARTER 2022
Consumer
Banking Commercial
Banking Non-Core Other Consolidated
Net income (loss) available to common stockholders:
Net income (loss) A $284 $358 ($23) $34 $653
Less: Preferred stock dividends — — — 32 32
Net income (loss) available to common stockholders B $284 $358 ($23) $2 $621
Return on average total tangible assets:
Average total assets (GAAP) $71,688 $79,591 $16,752 $56,939 $224,970
Less: Average goodwill (GAAP) 491 804 — 6,876 8,171
Average other intangibles (GAAP) 121 46 — 32 199
Add: Average deferred tax liabilities related to goodwill and other
intangible assets (GAAP) 7 4 — 413 424
Average tangible assets C $71,083 $78,745 $16,752 $50,444 $217,024
Return on average total tangible assets A/C 1.59 % 1.80 % (0.54) % NM 1.19 %
Efficiency ratio:
Noninterest expense (GAAP) D $831 $318 $31 $60 $1,240
Net interest income (GAAP) 1,014 595 19 67 1,695
Noninterest income (GAAP) 256 198 — 51 505
Total revenue (GAAP) E $1,270 $793 $19 $118 $2,200
Efficiency ratio D/E 65.39 % 40.18 % NM NM 56.36 %
27
-- 27 of 28 --
NON-GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES AND RECONCILIATIONS - SEGMENTS, CONTINUED1
(dollars in millions)
FULL YEAR
2023 2022
Consumer
Banking Commercial
Banking Non-Core Other Consolidated Consumer
Banking Commercial
Banking Non-Core Other Consolidated
Net income (loss) available to common stockholders:
Net income (loss) A $1,059 $1,153 ($244) ($360) $1,608 $955 $1,304 $142 ($328) $2,073
Less: Preferred stock dividends — — — 117 117 — — — 113 113
Net income (loss) available to common stockholders B $1,059 $1,153 ($244) ($477) $1,491 $955 $1,304 $142 ($441) $1,960
Return on average total tangible assets:
Average total assets (GAAP) $72,693 $76,028 $13,745 $59,755 $222,221 $68,027 $74,919 $18,121 $53,994 $215,061
Less: Average goodwill (GAAP) 540 767 — 6,877 8,184 388 616 — 6,868 7,872
Average other intangibles (GAAP) 106 39 — 32 177 88 30 — 63 181
Add: Average deferred tax liabilities related to goodwill and other
intangible assets (GAAP) 24 11 — 387 422 6 2 — 405 413
Average tangible assets C $72,071 $75,233 $13,745 $53,233 $214,282 $67,557 $74,275 $18,121 $47,468 $207,421
Return on average total tangible assets A/C 1.47 % 1.53 % (1.78) % NM 0.75 % 1.41 % 1.76 % 0.78 % NM 1.00 %
Efficiency ratio:
Noninterest expense (GAAP) D $3,542 $1,295 $123 $547 $5,507 $3,255 $1,223 $136 $278 $4,892
Net interest income (GAAP) 4,187 2,292 (129) (109) 6,241 3,649 2,103 378 (118) 6,012
Noninterest income (GAAP) 1,067 784 — 132 1,983 1,063 845 — 101 2,009
Total revenue (GAAP) E $5,254 $3,076 ($129) $23 $8,224 $4,712 $2,948 $378 ($17) $8,021
Efficiency ratio D/E 67.42 % 42.10 % NM NM 66.97 % 69.08 % 41.50 % NM NM 60.99 %
1 During the third quarter of 2023, the Company’s indirect auto and certain purchased consumer loan portfolios were transferred from Consumer Banking into a new Non-Core segment. In addition, the Company revised its funds transfer pricing
("FTP") methodology relative to the funding of Non-Core assets, with the FTP charge based on a marginal high-cost funding waterfall approach. Prior period results have been revised to conform to the new segment presentation.
28
-- 28 of 28 --