ANNUAL REPORT
FY 2021 — Annual report
FY 2021PDF · 411 pages25.4 MB
Table of Contents
UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
FORM 10-K
☒ ANNUAL REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES
EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
For the fiscal year ended December 31, 2021
OR
☐ TRANSITION REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES
EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
For the transition period from to
Commission File Number: 1-8944
CLEVELAND-CLIFFS INC.
(Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter)
Ohio 34-1464672
(State or Other Jurisdiction of
Incorporation or Organization)
(I.R.S. Employer
Identification No.)
200 Public Square, Cleveland, Ohio 44114-2315
(Address of Principal Executive Offices) (Zip Code)
Registrant’s telephone number, including area code: (216) 694-5700
Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act:
Title of each class Trading Symbol(s) Name of each exchange on which registered
Common Shares, par value $0.125 per share CLF New York Stock Exchange
Securities registered pursuant to section 12(g) of the Act: NONE
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is a well-known seasoned issuer, as defined in Rule 405 of the Securities Act. Yes ☒ NO ☐
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is not required to file reports pursuant to Section 13 or Section 15(d) of the Act. Yes ☐ No ☒
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant (1) has filed all reports required to be filed by Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 during the preceding 12
months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to file such reports), and (2) has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90
days. Yes ☒ No ☐
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has submitted electronically every Interactive Data File required to be submitted pursuant to Rule 405 of Regulation S-T (§232.405
of this chapter) during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to submit such files). Yes ☒ No ☐
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a large accelerated filer, an accelerated filer, a non-accelerated filer, a smaller reporting company, or an emerging growth
company. See the definitions of “large accelerated filer,” “accelerated filer,” “smaller reporting company,” and "emerging growth company" in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act.
Large accelerated filer ☒ Accelerated filer ☐
Non-accelerated filer ☐ Smaller reporting company ☐
Emerging growth company ☐
If an emerging growth company, indicate by check mark if the registrant has elected not to use the extended transition period for complying with any new or revised financial
accounting standards provided pursuant to Section 13(a) of the Exchange Act. ☐
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has filed a report on and attestation to its management’s assessment of the effectiveness of its internal control over financial
reporting under Section 404(b) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (15 U.S.C. 7262(b)) by the registered public accounting firm that prepared or issued its audit report. ☒
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a shell company (as defined in Rule 12b-2 of the Act). Yes ☐ No ☒
As of June 30, 2021, the aggregate market value of the voting and non-voting common shares held by non-affiliates of the registrant, based on the closing price of $21.56 per
share as reported on the New York Stock Exchange — Composite Index, was $ 10,636,421,962 (excluded from this figure are the voting shares beneficially owned by the
registrant’s officers and directors).
The number of shares outstanding of the registrant’s common shares, par value $0.125 per share, was525,409,705 as of February 10, 2022.
DOCUMENTS INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE
Portions of the registrant’s proxy statement for its 2022 annual meeting of shareholders are incorporated by reference into Part III.
-- 1 of 411 --
Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page Number
DEFINITIONS 1
PART I
Item 1. Business 4
Information About Our Executive Officers 21
Item 1A. Risk Factors 22
Item 1B. Unresolved Staff Comments 35
Item 2. Properties 36
Item 3. Legal Proceedings 51
Item 4. Mine Safety Disclosures 52
PART II
Item 5. Market for Registrant's Common Equity, Related Stockholder Matters and Issuer Purchases of Equity Securities 53
Item 6. [Reserved] 54
Item 7. Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations 54
Item 7A. Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk 76
Item 8. Financial Statements and Supplementary Data 77
Item 9. Changes in and Disagreements With Accountants on Accounting and Financial Disclosure 142
Item 9A. Controls and Procedures 142
Item 9B. Other Information 145
Item 9C. Disclosure Regarding Foreign Jurisdictions that Prevent Inspections 145
PART III
Item 10. Directors, Executive Officers and Corporate Governance 146
Item 11. Executive Compensation 146
Item 12. Security Ownership of Certain Beneficial Owners and Management and Related Stockholder Matters 146
Item 13. Certain Relationships and Related Transactions, and Director Independence 146
Item 14. Principal Accountant Fees and Services 146
PART IV
Item 15. Exhibits and Financial Statement Schedules 147
Item 16. Form 10-K Summary 152
SIGNATURES 153
-- 2 of 411 --
Table of Contents
DEFINITIONS
The following abbreviations or acronyms are used in the text. References in this report to the “Company,” “we,” “us,” “our” and “Cliffs” are to Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and subsidiaries, collectively.
References to “$” is to United States currency.
Abbreviation or acronym Term
4.625% 2029 Senior Notes 4.625% Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2029 issued by Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. on February 17, 2021 in an aggregate principal amount of $500 million
4.875% 2031 Senior Notes 4.875% Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2031 issued by Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. on February 17, 2021 in an aggregate principal amount of $500
million
2012 Amended Equity Plan Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. 2012 Incentive Equity Plan, as amended or amended and restated from time to time
2020 Acquisitions The AK Steel Merger and AM USA Transaction, collectively
2021 Equity Plan Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. 2021 Equity and Incentive Compensation Plan
A&R 2015 Equity Plan Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. Amended and Restated 2015 Equity and Incentive Compensation Plan
ABL Facility Asset-Based Revolving Credit Agreement, dated as of March 13, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the lenders party thereto from time to time
and Bank of America, N.A., as administrative agent, as amended as of March 27, 2020, December 9, 2020 and December 17, 2021, and as may
be further amended from time to time
Adjusted EBITDA EBITDA, excluding certain items such as EBITDA of noncontrolling interests, extinguishment of debt, severance, acquisition-related costs,
acquisition-related loss on equity method investment, amortization of inventory step-up, impacts of discontinued operations and intersegment
corporate allocations of selling, general and administrative costs
AG Autogenous grinding
AHSS Advanced high-strength steel
AK Steel AK Steel Holding Corporation (n/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Holding Corporation) and its consolidated subsidiaries, including AK Steel Corporation
(n/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Corporation), its direct, wholly owned subsidiary, collectively, unless stated otherwise or the context indicates
otherwise
AK Steel Merger The merger of Merger Sub with and into AK Steel, with AK Steel surviving the merger as a wholly owned subsidiary of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.,
subject to the terms and conditions set forth in the Merger Agreement, consummated on March 13, 2020
AK Steel Merger Agreement Agreement and Plan of Merger, dated as of December 2, 2019, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., AK Steel and Merger Sub
AM USA Transaction The acquisition of ArcelorMittal USA, consummated on December 9, 2020
AM USA Transaction Agreement Transaction Agreement, dated as of September 28, 2020, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and ArcelorMittal
ANSI American National Standards Institute
AOCI Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss)
APBO Accumulated postretirement benefit obligation
ArcelorMittal ArcelorMittal S.A., a company organized under the laws of Luxembourg and the former ultimate parent company of ArcelorMittal USA
ArcelorMittal USA Substantially all of the operations of the former ArcelorMittal USA LLC, its subsidiaries and certain affiliates, and Kote and Tek, collectively
ASC Accounting Standards Codification
ASTM American Society for Testing and Materials
ASU Accounting Standards Update
BART Best available retrofit technology
BNSF Burlington Northern Santa Fe, LLC
Board The Board of Directors of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
BOF Basic Oxygen Furnace
CAFE Corporate Average Fuel Economy
CARES Act Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act
CECL
Current expected credit losses
CERCLA Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act of 1980
CFR Cost and freight
Clean Water Act Federal Water Pollution Control Act
CN Canadian National Railway Company
Compensation Committee Compensation and Organization Committee of the Board
COVID-19 A novel strain of coronavirus that the World Health Organization declared a global pandemic in March 2020
Directors’ Plan Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. 2021 Nonemployee Directors’ Compensation Plan
Dodd-Frank Act Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act
DOE U.S. Department of Energy
DR-grade Direct reduction-grade
EAF Electric arc furnace
EBITDA Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization
1
-- 3 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Abbreviation or acronym Term
EDC Export Development Canada
EGLE Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy
Empire Iron ore mining property owned by Empire Iron Mining Partnership, an indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs
EPA U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
EPS Earnings per share
ERISA Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended
EV Electric vehicle
Exchange Act Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended
FASB Financial Accounting Standards Board
FCA Financial Conduct Authority (the authority that regulates LIBOR)
Fe Iron
FeT Total iron
FILO First-in, last-out
FIP Federal implementation plan
Former ABL Facility Amended and Restated Syndicated Facility Agreement, dated as of March 30, 2015, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the subsidiary borrowers party
thereto, the lenders party thereto and Bank of America, N.A., as administrative agent, as amended and restated as of February 28, 2018, and as
further amended, which was terminated on March 13, 2020 in connection with entering into the ABL Facility
FPT Ferrous Processing and Trading Company, including certain related entities
FPT Acquisition The purchase of FPT, subject to the terms and conditions set forth in the FPT Acquisition Agreement
FPT Acquisition Agreement Securities Purchase Agreement, dated as of October 8, 2021, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and Anthony Soave Revocable Trust u/a/d
January 14, 1987, as amended and restated
GAAP Accounting principles generally accepted in the United States
GHG Greenhouse gas
GOES Grain oriented electrical steel
HBI Hot briquetted iron
Hibbing Iron ore mining property owned by Hibbing Taconite Company, an unincorporated joint venture between subsidiaries of Cliffs and U.S. Steel
HRC Hot-rolled coil steel
HVAC Heating, ventilation and air conditioning equipment
IAM International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers
IBA ICE Benchmark Administration Limited (the entity that calculates and publishes LIBOR)
IRB Industrial Revenue Bond
IRC U.S. Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended
ISO International Organization for Standardization
IT Information technology
JSW Steel JSW Steel (USA) Inc. and JSW Steel USA Ohio, Inc., collectively
Kote and Tek Cleveland-Cliffs Kote L.P. and Cleveland-Cliffs Tek L.P., collectively
LIBOR London Interbank Offered Rate
LIFO Last-in, first-out
LoM Life-of-mine
Long ton 2,240 pounds
LS&I Lake Superior & Ishpeming Railroad Company
Merger Sub Pepper Merger Sub Inc., a direct, wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs prior to the AK Steel Merger
Metric ton 2,205 pounds
Minorca Iron ore mining property owned by Cleveland-Cliffs Minorca Mine Inc. (f/k/a ArcelorMittal Minorca Mine Inc.), an
indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs acquired in connection with the AM USA Transaction
MMBtu Million British Thermal Units
MPCA Minnesota Pollution Control Agency
MSHA Mine Safety and Health Administration of the U.S. Department of Labor
NAV Net asset value
Net ton 2,000 pounds
NOL Net operating loss
NOVs Notices of violations
NO Nitrogen oxide
NOES
Non-oriented electrical steel
x
2
-- 4 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Abbreviation or acronym Term
Northshore Iron ore mining property owned by Northshore Mining Company, a direct, wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs
NPDES National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System, authorized by the Clean Water Act
NWPR Navigable Waters Protection Rule
NYSE New York Stock Exchange
OPEB Other postretirement benefits
OSHA Occupational Safety and Health Administration of the U.S. Department of Labor
PBO Projected benefit obligation
PHS Press-hardened steel
Platts 62% price Platts IODEX 62% Fe Fines CFR North China
PPI Producer Price Indices
QA/QC Quality assurance/quality control
QP Qualified person, within the meaning set forth in Item 1300 of Regulation S-K
RCRA Resource Conservation and Recovery Act
RI/FS Remedial Investigation/Feasibility Study
S&P Standard & Poor's
SEC U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Second ABL Amendment Second Amendment to Asset-Based Revolving Credit Agreement, dated as of December 9, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the lenders party
thereto from time to time and Bank of America, N.A., as administrative agent
Section 232 Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962 (as amended by the Trade Act of 1974)
Securities Act Securities Act of 1933, as amended
SIP State Implementation Plan
SLR SLR International Corporation
SOFR Secured Overnight Financing Rate
STRIPS Separate Trading of Registered Interest and Principal of Securities
SunCoke Middletown Middletown Coke Company, LLC, a subsidiary of SunCoke Energy, Inc.
Third ABL Amendment Third Amendment to Asset-Based Revolving Credit Agreement, dated as of December 17, 2021, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the lenders party
thereto from time to time and Bank of America, N.A., as administrative agent
Tilden Iron ore mining property owned by Tilden Mining Company L.C., an indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs
TMDL Total maximum daily load
Tooling and Stamping Cleveland-Cliffs Tooling and Stamping Holdings LLC (f/k/a PPHC Holdings, LLC), an indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs, together with its
subsidiaries
Topic 805 ASC Topic 805, Business Combinations
Topic 815 ASC Topic 815, Derivatives and Hedging
TSR Total shareholder return
Tubular Components Cleveland-Cliffs Tubular Components LLC (f/k/a AK Tube LLC), an indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs
United Taconite Iron ore mining property owned by United Taconite LLC, an indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs
U.S. United States of America
U.S. Steel United States Steel Corporation and its subsidiaries, collectively, unless stated otherwise or the context indicates otherwise
UAW United Auto Workers
USMCA United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement
USW United Steelworkers
VEBA Voluntary employee benefit association trusts
VIE Variable interest entity
WLT Wet long ton
3
-- 5 of 411 --
Table of Contents
PART I
Item 1. Business
Introduction
Cliffs is the largest flat-rolled steel producer in North America. Founded in 1847 as a mine operator, we are also the largest manufacturer of iron ore pellets
in North America. We are vertically integrated from mined raw materials, direct reduced iron and ferrous scrap to primary steelmaking and downstream finishing,
stamping, tooling and tubing. We are the largest supplier of steel to the automotive industry in North America and serve a diverse range of other markets due to our
comprehensive offering of flat-rolled steel products. Headquartered in Cleveland, Ohio, we employ approximately 26,000 people across our operations in the United
States and Canada.
On November 18, 2021, we completed the acquisition of FPT, a leading prime ferrous scrap processor in the U.S. These operations consist of 22 scrap
processing facilities, primarily in the Midwest region of the United States. The FPT Acquisition bolsters our raw materials position by securing access to prime
scrap, which will allow us to optimize productivity at our existing EAFs and BOFs.
Competitive Strengths
As the largest flat-rolled steel producer in North America, we benefit from having the size and scale necessary in a competitive, capital intensive business.
Our sizeable operating footprint provides us with the operational leverage, flexibility and cost performance to achieve competitive margins throughout the business
cycle. We also have a unique vertically integrated profile from mined raw materials, direct reduced iron, and ferrous scrap to primary steelmaking and downstream
finishing, stamping, tooling and tubing. This positioning gives us both lower and more predictable costs throughout the supply chain and more control over both our
manufacturing inputs and our end product destination.
Our legacy business of producing iron ore pellets, which is our primary steelmaking raw material input, is another competitive advantage. By controlling our
iron ore pellet supply, our primary steelmaking raw material feedstock can be secured at a stable and predictable cost and not be subject to as many factors outside
of our control.
The FPT Acquisition gives us a competitive advantage in sourcing prime scrap, as we expect to leverage our long-standing flat-rolled automotive and other
customer relationships into recycling partnerships to further grow our prime scrap presence. Additionally, FPT has 22 facilities located primarily in the Midwest near
our steel facilities, which gives us an increased advantage in logistics.
We are also the largest supplier of automotive-grade steel in the U.S. Compared to other steel end markets, automotive steel is generally higher quality and
more operationally and technologically intensive to produce. As such, it often generates higher through-the-cycle margins, making it a desirable end market for the
steel industry. Given the strong demand and market environment in 2021, we were able to significantly improve our fixed price contracts, which should benefit us
throughout 2022. Demand for our automotive-grade steel is expected to increase with pent-up automotive demand as a result of the semiconductor shortage.
Automotive customers have requested higher volumes in contract negotiations compared to the prior year, which we believe is a sign of the semiconductor
shortage easing. With our continued technological innovation, as well as leading delivery performance, we expect to remain the leader in supplying this industry.
We are the only producers of both GOES and NOES in the U.S. The recently passed Infrastructure and Jobs Act of 2021 in the U.S. provides funding to be
used for the modernization of the electrical grid and the infrastructure needed to allow for increased EV adoption, both of which require our electrical steels. As a
result, with increased demand for both transformers and motors for EVs, we expect to benefit from this position in what is currently a rapidly growing market.
We believe we offer the most comprehensive flat-rolled steel product selection in the industry, along with several complementary products and services. A
sampling of our offering includes AHSS, hot-dipped galvanized, aluminized, galvalume, electrogalvanized, galvanneal, HRC, cold-rolled coil, plate, tinplate, GOES,
NOES, stainless steels, tool and die, stamped components, rail, slab and cast ingot. Across the quality spectrum and the supply chain, our customers can
frequently find the solutions they need from our product selection.
4
-- 6 of 411 --
Table of Contents
We are the first and the only producer of HBI in the Great Lakes region. Construction of our Toledo direct reduction plant was completed in the fourth
quarter of 2020 and reached full run-rate nameplate annual capacity of 1.9 million metric tons during the middle of 2021. From this modern plant, we produce a
high-quality, low-cost and low-carbon intensive HBI product that can be used in our blast furnaces and as a productivity enhancer in our BOFs and EAFs as a scrap
alternative. We can use HBI to stretch our hot metal production, lowering carbon intensity and reliance on coke. As a result of our internal usage of HBI, coupled
with our ongoing evaluation of coke use strategies, we idled our coke facility at Middletown Works during the third quarter of 2021 and we intend to permanently idle
our Mountain State Carbon coke plant in the second quarter of 2022. With increasing tightness in the scrap market and our own internal needs for scrap and
metallics, we expect our Toledo direct reduction plant to support healthy margins for us going forward.
Strategy
Maximize Our Commercial Strengths
We offer a full suite of flat steel products encompassing all steps of the steel manufacturing process. We have an industry-leading market share in the
automotive sector, where our portfolio of high-end products delivers a broad range of differentiated solutions for this highly sought after customer base.
As a result of our exposure to these high-end markets, we have the highest fixed price contractual volumes in our industry. Approximately 45% of our
volumes are sold under these contracts. These contracts reduce volatility and allow for more predictable through-cycle margins. Our fixed contract values are
expected to dramatically improve in 2022 compared to 2021.
We are also proponents of the “value over volume” approach in terms of steel supply. We take our leadership role in the industry very seriously and intend
to manage our steel output in a responsible manner. In the fourth quarter of 2021, we elected to pull forward repairs and maintenance to match automotive demand
that was negatively impacted by the semiconductor shortage. Going forward, we will continue to use our operational flexibility to align with our “value over volume”
approach in terms of steel supply.
Optimize Our Fully Integrated Steelmaking Footprint
We are a fully-integrated steel enterprise with the size and scale to achieve margins above industry averages for flat-rolled steel. Our focus remains on
both maintaining and enhancing our cost advantage while also lowering carbon emissions. The combination of our ferrous raw materials, including iron ore, scrap,
and HBI, allows us to do so relative to peers who must rely on more unpredictable and unreliable raw material sourcing strategies.
In 2022, we intend to use more scrap and HBI in our melting processes to stretch our production of liquid pig iron from traditional inputs. The use of higher
amounts of these raw materials in our blast furnaces ultimately boosts liquid steel output, which will reduce coke needs and lower carbon emissions from our
operations. With our acquisition of FPT, we have ample access to scrap along with internally sourced HBI.
Expand our Ferrous Scrap Recycling Presence
Throughout our entire footprint, we consume a very significant amount of scrap in our EAFs and BOFs, more than half of which can now be obtained
through internal sources. Prime scrap is a byproduct of industrial manufacturing. As manufacturing in the U.S. has moved offshore and yields have improved,
prime scrap supply has been shrinking for the last 50 years. As the steel industry continues to increase its focus on decarbonization and brings new flat-rolled EAF
capacity online over the next five years, securing additional access to prime scrap will continue to be an important strategic initiative.
Our expansion in this area began with the FPT Acquisition and will continue to grow by pairing FPT's processing capabilities with our long-standing
customer relationships. As the largest supplier of flat-rolled steel in North America, we are the largest source of the steel that generates prime scrap in
manufacturing facilities. Based on this, we seek to leverage our long-standing flat-rolled automotive and other customer relationships into recycling partnerships to
grow our prime scrap presence. The FPT Acquisition allows us to optimize productivity at our existing EAFs and BOFs, as we have no current plans to add
additional steelmaking capacity.
Advance our Participation in the Green Economy
We are seeking to expand our customer base with the rapidly growing and desirable electric vehicle market. At this time, we believe the North American
automotive industry is approaching a structural inflection point, with the adoption of electrical motors in passenger vehicles. As this market grows, it will require
more advanced steel
5
-- 7 of 411 --
Table of Contents
applications to meet the needs of electric vehicle producers and consumers. With our unique technical capabilities and leadership in the automotive industry, we
believe we are positioned better than any other North American steelmaker to supply the steel and parts necessary to fill these needs.
We also have the right products to meet the growing demand for renewable energy as well as for the modernization of the U.S. electrical grid. We offer
plate products that can be used in windmills, which we estimate contain 130 tons of steel per megawatt of electricity. In addition, panels for solar power are heavy
consumers of galvanized steel, where we are a leading producer. We estimate solar panels consume 40 tons of steel per megawatt of electricity.
We are currently the sole producer of electrical steel in the U.S., which can facilitate the modernization of the U.S. electrical grid. Along with charging
networks, electrical steels are also needed in the motors of electric vehicles.
Enhance our Environmental Sustainability
Our commitment to operating our business in a more environmentally responsible manner remains constant. One of the most important issues impacting
our industry, our stakeholders and our planet is climate change. In early 2021, we announced our commitment to reduce GHG emissions 25% from 2017 levels by
2030. This goal represents combined Scope 1 (direct) and Scope 2 (indirect) GHG emission reductions across all of our operations.
Prior to setting this goal with our newly acquired steel assets, we exceeded our previous GHG reduction target at our legacy facilities six years ahead of our
2025 goal. In 2019, we reduced our combined Scope 1 and Scope 2 GHG emissions by 42% on a mass basis from 2005 baseline levels. Our goal is to further
reduce those emissions in coming years.
Additionally, many of our steel assets have improved plant and energy efficiency through participation in programs like the U.S. Department of Energy’s
Better Plants program, including their Better Climate Challenge and the EPA’s Energy Star program. With our longstanding focus on plant and energy efficiency,
we aim to build on our previous successes across our newly integrated enterprise.
Our GHG reduction commitment is based on executing the following five strategic priorities:
• Developing domestically sourced, high quality iron ore feedstock and utilizing natural gas in the production of HBI;
• Implementing energy efficiency and clean energy projects;
• Investing in the development of carbon capture technology;
• Enhancing our GHG emissions transparency and sustainability focus; and
• Supporting public policies that facilitate GHG reduction in the domestic steel industry.
Improve Financial Flexibility
Given the cyclicality of our business, it is important to us to be in the financial position to easily withstand any negative demand or pricing pressure we may
encounter. During the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, we were able to issue secured debt to provide insurance capital through the uncertain industry
conditions caused by the pandemic. Now that business conditions have improved, allowing us to generate a healthy free cash flow during 2021 that is expected to
continue into 2022, we have the ability to reduce debt, return capital to shareholders through our share repurchase program and make investments to both improve
and grow our business. We have also been able to reduce our diluted share count and effectively return capital to shareholders via the cash redemption of our
Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock during the third quarter of 2021.
We anticipate that a strong market environment and significantly improved fixed price contracts will provide us ample opportunities to reduce our debt with
our own free cash flow generation in the coming years. We will also continue to review the composition of our debt, as we are interested in both extending our
average maturity profile and increasing our ratio of unsecured debt to secured debt, which we demonstrated by executing a series of favorable debt and equity
capital markets transactions during February 2021. In addition, in June 2021, we redeemed all $396 million aggregate principal amount outstanding of our 5.750%
2025 Senior Notes. In December 2021, we increased our liquidity by amending our ABL Facility to increase the aggregate revolver commitments from $3.5 billion to
$4.5 billion. These actions give us additional financial flexibility and will better prepare us to navigate more easily through
6
-- 8 of 411 --
Table of Contents
potentially volatile industry conditions in the future. In January 2022, we redeemed all $294 million aggregate principal amount outstanding of our 1.500% 2025
Convertible Senior Notes.
Business Operations
We have a vertically integrated portfolio, which begins at the mining stage and goes all the way through the manufacturing of steel products, including
stamping, tooling and tubing. We have the unique advantage as a steel producer of being fully or partially self-sufficient with our production of raw materials for
steel manufacturing, which includes iron ore pellets, HBI, scrap and coking coal. We operate iron ore mines in Michigan and Minnesota, which produce iron ore
pellets, and a direct reduction plant in Ohio that produces HBI. Additionally, with our recently completed FPT Acquisition, we now operate scrap facilities in
Michigan, Ohio, Tennessee, Florida and Ontario. We also operate a coal mining complex in West Virginia and produce coke from our facilities in Ohio,
Pennsylvania, Indiana and West Virginia.
We believe such vertical integration represents a sustainable business model that is in the best interest of all stakeholders and the surest way to secure a
long-term competitive advantage. We are focused on securing additional access to prime scrap as the steel industry continues to increase its focus on
decarbonization and with demand coming from new flat-rolled EAF capacity set to come online over the next five years. We continue to strive to operate
responsibly and produce cleaner steel, which is the most recycled material on the planet. Additionally, our investment in the Toledo direct reduction plant, which
was completed in the fourth quarter of 2020, also helps to support environmental stewardship, as the increased use of HBI in our blast furnaces stretches liquid
steel output, which reduces coke needs and emissions. From a focus on key environmental processes, such as steel recycling and reduction of carbon emissions,
to corporate and social responsibility, sustainability is central to our values and operations.
7
-- 9 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following table lists our steel producing and finishing properties, their location and their products and services:
Property Segment State/ Province Products and Services
Burns Harbor Steelmaking Indiana Hot-rolled, cold-rolled, and hot-dipped galvanized sheet and coke
Burns Harbor Plate and Gary Plate Steelmaking Indiana Carbon steel plate, high-strength low alloy steel plate, ASTM grades
steel plate
Butler Works Steelmaking Pennsylvania Flat-rolled electrical and stainless steel, stainless and carbon semi-
finished slabs
Cleveland Steelmaking Ohio Hot-rolled and hot-dipped galvanized sheet
Coatesville Steelmaking Pennsylvania Steel plate - carbon, high-strength low-alloy, commercial allow, military
alloy, flame-cut
Columbus Steelmaking Ohio Hot-dipped galvanized steel
Conshohocken Steelmaking Pennsylvania Coiled and discrete plate, military alloy, commercial alloy, heat-treated
carbon
Coshocton Works Steelmaking Ohio Flat-rolled stainless steel
Dearborn Works Steelmaking Michigan Carbon semi-finished slabs, hot-dipped galvanized, AHSS
Indiana Harbor Steelmaking Indiana Carbon semi-finished slabs, hot-rolled, cold-rolled and hot-dipped
galvanized sheet
Kote and Tek Steelmaking Indiana Cold-rolled, hot-dipped galvanized and galvannealed, electrogalvanized
coil
Mansfield Works Steelmaking Ohio Semi-finished hot bands, high chrome ferritic and martensitic stainless
steels
Middletown Works Steelmaking Ohio Hot-rolled, cold-rolled, hot-dipped galvanized, aluminized sheet and
coke
Piedmont Steelmaking North Carolina Plasma - cuts plate steel products into blanks
Riverdale Steelmaking Illinois Hot-rolled sheet
Rockport Works Steelmaking Indiana Cold-rolled carbon, coated and stainless steels
Steelton Steelmaking Pennsylvania Railroad rails, specialty blooms, flat bars and cast ingots
Weirton Steelmaking West Virginia Tinplate, cold-rolled sheet
Zanesville Works Steelmaking Ohio Electrical steels
Our Other Businesses primarily includes the Tubular Components and Tooling and Stamping properties that provide customer solutions with carbon and
stainless steel tubing products, advanced-engineered solutions, tool design and build, hot- and cold-stamped steel components, and complex assemblies.
Refer to Part I - Item 2. Properties for additional information.
8
-- 10 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Customers and Markets
We primarily sell our products to customers in four broad market categories: automotive; infrastructure and manufacturing, which includes electrical power;
distributors and converters; and steel producers, which consume iron ore and metallics and further process semi-finished materials. The following table presents the
percentage of our net revenues to each of these markets during the year:
Market 2021 2020
Automotive 25 % 45 %
Infrastructure and manufacturing 27 % 15 %
Distributors and converters 38 % 13 %
Steel producers 10 % 27 %
The change in percentages of net revenues to each market in 2021 compared to 2020 was driven primarily by the AM USA Transaction, which increased
overall sales to automotive customers, but reduced the total percentage exposure, increased exposure to infrastructure and manufacturing and distributors and
converters customers, and drove more in-house iron ore sales, which reduced the percentage of sales to steel producers.
Approximately 45% of our flat-rolled steel shipments are sold under fixed base price contracts. These contracts are typically one year in duration and expire
at various times throughout the year. Some of these contracts have a surcharge mechanism that passes through certain changes in input costs. A certain portion of
our flat-rolled steel shipments are sold based on the spot market at prevailing market prices or under contracts that involve variable pricing that is tied to an
independently published steel index.
We sell our steel products principally to customers in North America. For the vast majority of international sales, we are not the importer of record and do
not bear the responsibility for paying any applicable tariffs.
Automotive Market
We specialize in manufacturing difficult-to-produce, high-quality steel products, combined with demanding delivery performance, customer technical
support and collaborative relationships, to develop breakthrough steel solutions that help our customers meet their product requirements. In addition, many of our
competitors do not have the capability to supply the full portfolio of products that we make for our automotive customers, such as steel for exposed automotive
applications, the most sophisticated grades of AHSS and value-added stainless steel products. The exacting requirements for servicing the automotive market
generally allows for higher selling prices for products sold to that market than for the commodity types of carbon and stainless steels sold to other markets.
The largest end user for our steel products is the automotive industry in North America, which makes light vehicle production a key driver of demand.
During 2021, North American light vehicle production was 13 million units, the same as the prior year. Production each of the past two years was down 3 million
units compared to the prior ten-year average primarily due to the global semiconductor shortage, as well as other material shortages and supply chain disruptions
resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic. This has caused several outages amongst light vehicle manufacturers despite strong consumer demand. In light of these
production outages, we have been able to redirect certain volumes originally intended for this end market to the spot market, where demand has been strong and
pricing has reached all-time highs.
Furthermore, during 2021, consumer demand for sport utility vehicles, trucks and crossovers continued to increase while demand for smaller sedans and
compact cars declined. We benefit from intentionally targeting larger vehicle platforms to take advantage of consumer preferences, and we have focused on and
have been successful in getting sourced on numerous sport utility vehicle, truck, crossover and larger vehicle platforms. As a result, a significant portion of the
carbon automotive steel that we sell is used to produce these popular larger vehicles. In addition to benefiting from our exposure to consumers’ strong demand for
larger vehicles, these vehicles also typically contain a higher volume of steel than smaller sedans and compact cars, providing us the opportunity to sell a greater
proportion of our steel products to our automotive customers.
Automotive manufacturers are under pressure to achieve heightened federally mandated CAFE standards. The CAFE standards generally require
automobile manufacturers to meet an average fuel economy goal across the fleet of vehicles they produce with certain milestone dates. As a result, our automotive
customers continue to explore various avenues for achieving the standards, including light weighting components and developing more fuel-efficient engines. Light
weighting efforts include the use of alternatives to traditional carbon steels, such as AHSS and other materials. While this could reduce the aggregate volume of
steel consumed by the automotive industry, we expect
9
-- 11 of 411 --
Table of Contents
that demand will increase for current and next-generation AHSS and that our AHSS and other innovative steels will command higher margins. We are collaborating
with our automotive customers and their suppliers to develop innovative solutions using our developments in light weighting, efficiency, and material strength and
formability across our extensive product portfolio, in combination with our automotive stamping and tube-making capabilities. We are also working with our
customers to develop steels with greater heat resistance for exhaust systems that support new, fuel-efficient engines that run at higher temperatures.
Automotive manufacturers have also been increasing their development of EVs and battery electric vehicles in order to meet the CAFE standards and
growing customer adoption of EVs. Many motors used in EVs being sold in the U.S. today are imported from foreign suppliers, but more local sourcing and
manufacturing of motors is expected to occur in the future. As the only North American producer of high-efficiency NOES, which is a critical component of EV
motors, we are positioned to potentially benefit from the growth of EVs going forward. We believe our strong foundation in electrical steels and long-standing
relationships with automotive manufacturers and their suppliers will provide us with an advantage in this market as it continues to grow and mature. Likewise, the
growing customer adoption of EVs may also increase demand for improvements in the electric grid to support higher demand for more extensive battery charging,
which our GOES could support.
The majority of our sales to the automotive market are under annual fixed price contracts. In 2022, our selling prices to this end market will be substantially
higher as a result of favorable renewals. The improved prices in our fixed price contracts were driven by stronger market conditions and our unique product offering
of automotive grade steel.
Infrastructure and Manufacturing Market
We sell a variety of our steel products, including plate, carbon, stainless, electrical, tinplate and rail, to the infrastructure and manufacturing market. This
market includes sales to manufacturers of HVAC, appliances, power transmission and distribution transformers, storage tanks, ships and railcars, wind towers,
machinery parts, heavy equipment, military armor, food preservation, and railway lines. Domestic construction activity and the replacement of aging infrastructure
directly affects sales of steel to this market. Residential construction spending surged in 2021 due to overwhelming demand for new houses. Nonresidential
construction spending was slightly down in 2021; however, the sector saw a surge in spending in the second half of the year and will likely continue into 2022 with
the passing of the Infrastructure and Jobs Act of 2021. The Infrastructure and Jobs Act of 2021 will likely also increase demand for steel products related to
renewable energy, as well as the modernization of the U.S. electrical grid. Our plate products can be used in windmills, which we estimate contain 130 metric tons
of steel per megawatt of electrical generating capacity. Additionally, we estimate solar panels consume 40 metric tons of steel per megawatt of electrical generating
capacity. We also expect to see an increase in charging stations for EVs which we will benefit from as we are the sole producer of electrical steel in the U.S.
Sales to this end market are made under a combination of annual fixed price contracts and index-linked pricing arrangements. Our selling prices under our
annual fixed price contracts will be substantially higher in 2022 as a result of favorable renewals.
Distributors and Converters Market
Virtually all of the grades of steel we produce are sold to the steel distributors and converters market. This market generally represents downstream steel
service centers, which source various types of steel from us and fabricate it according to their customers' needs. Our steel is typically sold to this market on a spot
basis or under short-term contracts linked to steel pricing indices. Demand and pricing for this market can be highly dependent on a variety of factors outside our
control, including global and domestic commodity steel production capacity, the relative health of countries’ economies and whether they are consuming or
exporting excess steel production, the provisions of international trade agreements and fluctuations in international currencies and, therefore, are subject to market
changes in steel prices.
The price for domestic HRC, the most significant index in driving our revenues and profitability of our Steelmaking segment, averaged $1,573 per net ton
for 2021, a record year that was also 174% higher than 2020. The record prices for steel products in 2021 was a result of both supply and demand factors, each
driven by a rapid recovery since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020.
10
-- 12 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Steel Producers Market
The steel producers market represents third-party sales to other steel producers, including those who operate blast furnaces and EAFs. It includes sales of
raw materials and semi-finished and finished goods, including iron ore pellets, coal, coke, HBI, scrap and steel products.
The largest component of sales to this market during the year ended December 31, 2021 was third-party slab sales, which are primarily made under a
long-term supply agreement that was initiated in connection with the closing of the AM USA Transaction.
Following the 2020 Acquisitions, production from our iron ore mines is predominantly consumed by our steelmaking operations. On a full-year basis, we
would expect between 22 million and 24 million long tons of our iron ore pellets to be consumed by our steelmaking operations. During 2021, 2020 and 2019, we
sold 4 million, 12 million and 19 million long tons of iron ore product, respectively, to third parties from our share of production from our iron ore mines. The
merchant portion of our iron ore pellet production is sold pursuant to long-term supply agreements and through spot contracts.
We also entered into the scrap business with the FPT Acquisition in 2021. FPT is one of the largest processors of prime scrap in the country, representing
approximately 15% of the entire U.S. merchant market. We believe this acquisition is a complementary addition to our footprint as prime scrap demand is expected
to grow as new flat-rolled EAF capacity is set to come online over the next five years, and the worldwide focus on decarbonization continues. We expect to be able
to leverage our long-standing flat-rolled automotive and other customer relationships into recycling partnerships to further grow our prime scrap presence.
The price of busheling scrap, a necessary input for flat-rolled steel production in EAFs in the U.S., averaged $602 per long ton during 2021, a 97%
increase from the prior year. We expect the price of busheling scrap to remain elevated throughout 2022 due to decreasing prime scrap generation from original
equipment manufacturers and the growth of EAF capacity in the U.S., along with a push for expanded scrap use globally. The expected rising price of busheling
scrap was a key strategic rationale for the FPT Acquisition.
Applied Technology, Research and Development
We have an extensive history of being an innovator dating back more than a century. From upstream research and development, to downstream
applications, we have dedicated technical and engineering resources that begin with improving customers' production and manufacturing performance to
applications for their end product use.
We have a world-class research and development team expanding our capabilities to bring new steel products to the marketplace. Rapidly evolving and
highly competitive markets for our steel products require our customers to seek new, comprehensive steel solutions, and we believe we are well positioned to
deliver the most robust solutions through our broad portfolio of offerings. Collaboration across our research groups and operations generates innovative and
comprehensive solutions for our customers, which we believe enhances our competitive advantage.
Our ongoing efforts to enhance technical collaboration at our state-of-the-art Research and Innovation Center in Middletown, Ohio, have increased the
introduction of new steel solutions to the marketplace. Creating innovative products and breakthrough solutions is a strategic priority, as we believe differentiation
through producing higher value steels to meet challenging requirements enables us to maintain and enhance our margins. We conduct a broad range of research
and development activities aimed at improving existing products and processes and developing new ones. Our innovation of steel has produced a highly diversified
steel product portfolio. As part of our underlying strategy to focus on higher-value materials and minimize exposure to commodity products, we have invested in
research and innovation totaling $17 million and $15 million in 2021 and 2020, respectively.
We have also been a leader in iron ore mining and processing technology through the application of new technology to the centuries-old business of
mineral extraction. We have also been a pioneer in iron ore pelletizing with over 60 years of experience. We are able to produce customized, environmentally-
friendly pellets to meet blast furnace specifications and produce standard, fluxed and DR-grade pellets.
HBI
We are a pioneer in the development of emerging reduction technologies, a leader in the extraction of value from challenging resources and a front-runner
in the implementation of safe and sustainable technology. We are also devoted to promoting environmental sustainability, evidenced with the development of our
direct reduction plant in Toledo, Ohio. Construction of our Toledo direct reduction plant was completed in the fourth quarter of 2020, and the
11
-- 13 of 411 --
Table of Contents
plant reached full run-rate nameplate annual capacity of 1.9 million metric tons of HBI per year in 2021. From this modern plant, we produce a high-quality, low-cost
and low-carbon intensive HBI product that can be used throughout our footprint. We intend to use more HBI in our melting process to stretch our production of liquid
pig iron from traditional inputs. The use of higher amounts of HBI in our blast furnaces ultimately stretches liquid steel output, which reduces coke needs and lowers
carbon intensity.
Carbon Steel
We focus much of our research and innovation efforts on carbon steel applications for automotive manufacturers and their suppliers. We are particularly
focused on AHSS for the automotive market, and we produce virtually every AHSS grade currently used by our customers. Our AHSS grades, such as Dual Phase
590, 780, 980 and 1180, have been adopted by our customers for both stamped and roll-formed parts, and our TRIP and NEXMET® products have demonstrated
enhanced strength, formability and opportunities for automotive light weighting in cold-stamped applications. We are also pursuing application of NEXMET 490EX
in surface-critical, exposed auto body panels as an alternative to aluminum.
Third Generation Advanced High-Strength Steel
Our third generation NEXMET AHSS products enable our customers to achieve significant light weighting in the unexposed structural components of their
vehicles. NEXMET 1200, for example, offers superior formability similar to conventional Dual Phase 600 steel, but at twice the strength level. We have expanded
the application of the NEXMET technology to our tubular products and stamped components businesses. These AHSS products allow automotive engineers to
design lightweight parts that meet rigorous service and safety requirements. The NEXMET family of steels helps our customers achieve vehicle weight savings for
ambitious fuel efficiency standards while avoiding significant capital costs required to re-design production facilities to use alternative materials.
Both galvanized and cold-rolled NEXMET AHSS are progressing through product qualification with several original equipment manufacturer customers. A
number of stamping and component assembly trials have been completed successfully, with more planned and underway. Because the timing of automotive design
and production cycles spans several years, widespread automotive customer adoption of revolutionary new material such as NEXMET AHSS may also extend over
several years. We expect that other automotive vehicle platforms will incorporate NEXMET AHSS in their designs and that NEXMET AHSS will become a strong
differentiator for us going forward.
Downstream Steel Applications
Our portfolio of steel solutions includes the operations of Tooling and Stamping, which provides advanced-engineered solutions, tool design and build, hot
and cold-stamped components and complex assemblies for the automotive market. In addition to Tooling and Stamping, our downstream operations include
Tubular Components, which manufactures advanced tubular products for automotive and other applications using carbon and stainless steels. We believe that
collaboration among our steelmaking operations and our downstream businesses can accelerate the adoption of our innovative steel products by automotive
manufacturers and their first tier suppliers.
Our research and technical experts have undertaken numerous collaborative projects that are generating robust solutions for our customers. Our expertise
in tool design and stamping capabilities has allowed us to create prototype components using our innovative new sheet materials and present customers with new
potential steel solutions. This approach has and, we expect, will continue to demonstrate to customers that they can significantly light weight automotive parts on an
accelerated timeline and in a cost-effective manner by using our highly formable grades of AHSS in place of traditional material types.
In addition, our collaborative projects are enhancing our collective knowledge and experience in the stamping of new, advanced grades of steel, advanced
engineered solutions, and tool design and build. For example, our Tooling and Stamping segment specializes in hot-stamping PHS for automotive applications. Our
experience as a leader in PHS and expertise in hot-stamping has enabled us to have greater insight into these high-growth areas and has accelerated product
development and customer adoption of these automotive light weighting solutions. Likewise, collaboration with the Tubular segment strategically advances our
mission to innovate in AHSS for the automotive industry, as we have been at the forefront of producing tubular products from PHS and third-generation AHSS. We
believe the combination of our stamping and advanced die-making capabilities, leading tube making capabilities and breakthrough material introductions will
enhance our ability to deliver innovative, steel solutions to our customers.
We have recently been awarded contracts with several customers to supply complex assemblies and stamped automotive parts. In winning these
contracts, we have been able to leverage our hot-stamping tooling
12
-- 14 of 411 --
Table of Contents
leadership, in addition to our innovative hot-stamping process, to capture new strategic opportunities and demonstrate that we are one of the few businesses in
North America that has the technical capabilities to produce a major complex assembly and stamping work of this nature.
Competition
Our Steelmaking segment principally competes with domestic and foreign producers of flat-rolled carbon, plate, tinplate, stainless, rail and electrical steel,
carbon and stainless tubular products, aluminum, carbon fiber, concrete and other materials that may be used as a substitute for flat-rolled steels in manufactured
products. Our Tooling and Stamping and Tubular Components businesses both compete against other niche companies in highly fragmented markets.
Price, quality, on-time delivery, customer service and product innovation are the primary competitive factors in the steel industry and vary in importance
according to the product category and customer requirements. Steel producers that sell to the automotive market face competition from aluminum manufacturers
(and, to a lesser extent, other materials) as automotive manufacturers attempt to develop vehicles that will enable them to satisfy more stringent, government-
imposed fuel efficiency standards. To address automotive manufacturers’ light weighting needs that the aluminum industry is targeting, we and others in the steel
industry have developed AHSS grades that we believe provide weight savings similar to aluminum, while being stronger, less costly, easier to repair, more
sustainable and more environmentally friendly. Aluminum penetration has been primarily limited to specific automotive applications, such as outer panels and
closures, rather than entire body designs. In addition, our automotive customers who continue to use steel, as opposed to aluminum and other alternative
materials, are able to avoid the significant capital expenditures required to re-tool their manufacturing processes to accommodate the use of non-steel materials.
Mini-mills (producers using EAFs) comprise about 70% of steel production and 42% of flat-rolled steel production in the U.S. Their primary raw material is
scrap metal, which has unpredictable and often volatile pricing. Due to the announced flat-rolled mini-mill capacity additions in the U.S. and increasing focus on
industry decarbonization, we expect the price of scrap to remain elevated over historical averages, providing our integrated footprint a competitive advantage. Mini-
mills also generally offer a narrower range of products than integrated steel mills, but the increasing use of pig iron and direct reduced iron have enabled them to
modestly expand their product capabilities in recent years. However, we believe mini-mills often do not have the equipment capabilities to produce the product
range that integrated facilities offer, nor do we believe they possess our depth of customer service, technical support, and research and innovation.
Domestic steel producers, including us, face significant competition from foreign producers. For many reasons, these foreign producers often are able to
sell products in the U.S. at prices substantially lower than domestic producers. Depending on the country of origin, these reasons may include government
subsidies; lower labor, raw material, energy and regulatory costs; less stringent environmental regulations; less stringent safety requirements; the maintenance of
artificially low exchange rates against the U.S. dollar; and preferential trade practices in their home countries. In 2021, finished steel imports increased 48%
compared to the prior year, as a result of a larger disparity between foreign and domestic prices, but still remain below levels seen between 2013 and 2018. We
believe this is at least partially attributable to the implementation of certain trade restrictions on imported steel over the past five years, including both targeted trade
cases and the more broad Section 232 tariffs. Modifications to these trade restrictions by government authorities could directly or indirectly impact import levels in
the future. Import levels are also affected to varying degrees by the relative level of steel production in China and other countries, the strength of demand for steel
outside the U.S., and the relative strength or weakness of the U.S. dollar against various foreign currencies. Imports of finished steel into the U.S. accounted for
approximately 22% of domestic steel market consumption in 2021.
We continue to provide significant pension and healthcare benefits to a greater number of our retirees compared to certain other domestic and foreign steel
producers that do not provide such benefits to any or most of their retirees, which increases our overall cost of production relative to certain other steelmakers.
However, we have taken a number of actions to reduce pension and healthcare benefits costs, including negotiating progressive labor agreements that have
significantly reduced total employment costs at our union-represented facilities, transferring all responsibility for healthcare benefits for various groups of retirees to
VEBAs, offering voluntary lump-sum settlements to pension plan participants, lowering retiree benefit costs for salaried employees, and transferring pension
obligations to highly rated insurance companies. These actions have not only reduced some of the risks associated with our pension funding obligations, but more
importantly have reduced our risk exposure to performance of the financial markets, which are a principal driver of pension funding requirements. We continue to
actively seek opportunities to reduce pension and healthcare benefits costs.
13
-- 15 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Environmental Matters
Our operations are subject to various laws and regulations governing the protection of the environment. We monitor these laws and regulations, which
change over time, to assess whether the changes affect our operations. We conduct our operations in a manner that is protective of public health and the
environment.
Environmental matters and their management continue to be an important focus at each of our operations. From 2017 to 2021, we invested approximately
$1 billion into our Toledo direct reduction plant, which provides a low carbon intensity raw material to our steelmaking operations. The HBI produced from the plant
requires less energy to produce compared to traditional feedstock and can be used in blast furnaces to reduce emissions by improving energy efficiency and
reducing the amount of coke required for steel production.
In the construction and operation of our facilities, substantial costs have been and will continue to be incurred to comply with regulatory requirements and
avoid undue effect on the environment. In 2021, 2020, and 2019, our capital expenditures relating to environmental matters totaled $62 million, $34 million and $9
million, respectively. Our current estimate for capital expenditures for environmental improvements in 2022 is approximately $120 million for various water
treatment, air quality, dust control, tailings management and other miscellaneous environmental projects. Additionally, we expect capital expenditures for
environmental improvements for each of 2023 and 2024 to be generally in line with 2022's estimated spending.
Regulatory Developments
Various governmental bodies continually promulgate new or amended laws and regulations that affect us, our customers, and our suppliers in many areas,
including air and water discharges, waste management and disposal, the classification of materials and products and other environmental, health, and safety
matters. Although we believe that our environmental policies and practices are sound and do not expect that the application of any current laws, regulations or
permits would reasonably be expected to result in a material adverse effect on our business or financial condition, we cannot predict the collective potential adverse
impact of the expanding body of laws and regulations. Moreover, because all domestic steel, scrap and mining producers operate under the same federal
environmental regulations, we do not believe that we are more disadvantaged than our domestic competitors by our need to comply with these regulations. Some
foreign competitors may benefit from less stringent environmental requirements in the countries where they produce, resulting in lower compliance costs for them
and providing those foreign competitors with a cost advantage on their products.
Specifically, there are several notable proposed or potential rulemakings or activities that could have a material adverse impact on our facilities in the future
depending on their ultimate outcome: climate change and GHG regulation; selenium discharge regulation; Minnesota's sulfate wild rice water quality standard;
Minnesota's mercury TMDL and mercury reduction rules; and the regulation of discharges to groundwater.
Climate Change and GHG Regulation
With the complexities and uncertainties associated with the U.S. and global navigation of the climate change issue as a whole, one of our potentially
significant risks for the future is mandatory carbon pricing obligations, whether it be in the form of additional costs for emission allowances or restriction of
production, as examples. Policymakers are in the design process of carbon regulation at the state, regional, national and international levels. The current regulatory
variety of carbon compliance schemes presents a challenge for multi-facility entities to identify their near-term risks. Amplifying the uncertainty, the dynamic forward
outlook for carbon pricing obligations presents a challenge to large industrial companies to assess the long-term net impacts of carbon compliance costs on their
operations. Our exposure on this issue includes both the direct and indirect financial risks associated with the regulation of GHG emissions, as well as potential
physical risks associated with climate change adaptation. We are continuing to review the physical risks related to climate change. As an energy-intensive
business, we have a broad range of GHG emissions sources, such as iron ore furnaces and kilns, diesel mining equipment and integrated steelmaking facilities,
among others. As such, among our most significant regulatory risks are: (1) the costs associated with on-site emissions levels (direct impacts); and (2) indirect costs
passed through to us from power and fuel suppliers (indirect impacts).
Internationally, mechanisms to reduce emissions are being implemented in various countries, with differing designs and stringency, according to resources,
economic structure and politics. The Paris Agreement to reduce global GHG emissions and limit global temperature increases to 2 degrees Celsius compared to
pre-industrial temperatures became effective in November 2016 with 196 signatory countries. The U.S. became a signatory to the Paris Agreement with a pledge to
reduce its GHG emissions by 26% to 28% from 2005 levels by 2025. The U.S. withdrew from the treaty in November 2020 and then subsequently rejoined the
Paris Agreement in February 2021.
14
-- 16 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Continued attention to issues concerning climate change, the role of human activity in it and potential mitigation through regulation may have a material impact on
our customer base, operations and financial results in the future.
In the U.S., future federal and/or state carbon regulation potentially presents a significantly greater impact to our operations. To date, the U.S. Congress
has not legislated carbon constraints. In the absence of comprehensive federal carbon legislation, numerous state, regional and federal regulatory initiatives are
under development or are becoming effective, thereby creating a disjointed approach to GHG emissions control and potential carbon pricing impacts. We intend to
remain active in the discussions related to legislative and regulatory changes at the federal and state levels.
Due to the potential variety of federal, state or regional carbon restriction schemes, our business and customer base could suffer negative financial impacts
over time as a result of increased energy, environmental and other costs to comply with the limitations that would be imposed on GHG emissions. We believe our
exposure can be reduced substantially by numerous factors, including currently contemplated regulatory flexibility mechanisms, such as allowance allocations, fixed
process emissions exemptions, offsets and international provisions; emissions reduction opportunities, including energy efficiency, biofuels and fuel flexibility; and
business opportunities associated with pursuing combined heat and power partnerships and new products, including DR-grade pellets, HBI, fluxed pellets and other
efficiency-improving technologies.
Selenium Discharge Regulation
In Michigan, the Empire and Tilden mines have implemented compliance plans to manage selenium according to applicable permit conditions. A water
treatment system for both facilities is anticipated sometime before 2028. As of December 31, 2021, included within our Empire asset retirement obligation is a
discounted liability of approximately $100 million, which includes the estimated costs associated with the construction of Empire's portion of the required
infrastructure and expected future operating costs of the treatment facilities. Additionally, included within our Tilden future capital plan is approximately $20 million
for the construction of Tilden's portion of the required infrastructure. We are continuing to assess and develop cost effective and sustainable selenium treatment
technologies.
In July 2016, the EPA published new selenium fish tissue limits and lower lentic and lotic water column concentration criteria, which may someday increase
the cost for treatment should EGLE adopt these new standards in lieu of the existing limits required by the Great Lakes Water Quality Initiative. Accordingly, we
cannot reasonably estimate the timing or long-term impact of these water quality criteria on our business.
Minnesota’s Sulfate Wild Rice Water Quality Standard
The Minnesota Governor established a Wild Rice Task Force by Executive Order in May 2018 that provided recommendations on wild rice restoration and
regulation. The existing sulfate water quality standard for lakes and streams that contain wild rice has not been applied to any of our discharge permits or enforced
historically by Minnesota. Further, the standard may be unenforceable because of legislation that prohibits the MPCA from enforcing it until the obsolete standard is
updated based on modern science.
Minnesota submitted a list of impaired water revisions to the EPA in 2020. In 2021, the EPA disapproved of Minnesota’s draft impaired waters list and
subsequently announced its proposed list of wild rice water bodies that were impaired due to sulfate under the Clean Water Act’s Section 303(d) process, which
resulted in the addition of 32 waters in November 2021. At this time, it is unknown how the MPCA intends to implement requirements to address sulfate impaired
waters.
For these reasons, the impact of potential obligations to address sulfate concentrations in certain water discharges from our Minnesota iron ore mining and
pelletizing operations is not estimable at this time, but it could have a material adverse impact if we are required to significantly reduce sulfate in certain discharges.
Minnesota's Mercury TMDL and Mercury Reduction Rules
In September 2014, Minnesota promulgated the Mercury Air Emissions Reporting and Reduction Rules, mandating mercury air emissions reporting and
reductions from certain sources, including taconite facilities. The rules apply to all of our Minnesota iron ore mining and pelletizing operations and required submittal
of a Mercury Reduction Plan to the MPCA in 2018 with plan implementation requirements becoming effective on January 1, 2025. In the Mercury Reduction Plan,
facilities evaluated if available control technologies can technically achieve a 72% mercury reduction rate. If available control technologies cannot technically
achieve a 72% mercury reduction rate, the facilities must propose alternative mercury reduction measures. One of the main tenets agreed upon for evaluating
potential
15
-- 17 of 411 --
Table of Contents
mercury reduction technologies during TMDL implementation and 2014 rule development proceedings was that the selected technology must meet the following
“Adaptive Management Criteria”: the technology must be technically feasible; must be economically feasible; must not impact pellet quality; and must not cause
excessive corrosion in the indurating furnaces or air pollution control equipment.
The Mercury Reduction Plans for our Minnesota facilities were submitted to the MPCA in December 2018. In 2020, the MPCA requested additional
information on certain plans, and we responded in a timely manner. There is currently no proven technology to cost effectively reduce mercury emissions from
taconite furnaces to achieve the targeted 72% reduction rate, while satisfying all four Adaptive Management Criteria. The Mercury Reduction Plans that were
submitted to the MPCA include documentation that describes the results of detailed engineering analysis and research testing on potential technologies to support
this determination. The results of this analysis will continue to guide dialogue with the MPCA. Potential impacts to us are not estimable at this time because the
revised Mercury Reduction Plans and additional technical information are currently being reviewed by the MPCA.
Regulation of Discharges to Groundwater
In general, states traditionally have regulated discharges of pollutants to groundwater through various programs such as wellhead protection programs and
regulations related to remediation. In April 2020, the U.S. Supreme Court held in County of Maui v. Hawaiʻi Wildlife Fund that the EPA (and delegated states) have
jurisdiction under the NPDES program if a point source discharges to groundwater and is the “functional equivalent” of a discharge to Waters of the United States.
Until now, the NPDES program in the states we operate in has regulated only direct discharges to surface waters that constitute Waters of the United States from
point sources. Although we do not anticipate that broadening EPA jurisdiction over groundwater discharges will materially adversely affect our operations, the
impact to our operations is not reasonably estimable at this time.
Other Government Laws and Regulations
In addition to environmental laws and regulations, we are subject to various laws and regulations around the world. For example, changes in trade
regulations, including tariffs or other import or export restrictions, could lead to lower or more volatile global steel prices, impacting our profitability. In addition,
health and safety regulations, including laws or regulations promulgated in response to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, and OSHA and MSHA regulations, have
necessitated, and may continue to necessitate, increased operating costs or capital investments to promote a safe working environment. We are also required to
comply with complex foreign and U.S. laws and regulations, which may include the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and other anti-bribery laws, the European Union’s
General Data Protection Regulation and other U.S. and foreign privacy regulations, and transportation and logistics regulations. The laws and regulations noted
above, as well as other applicable laws and regulations, or the manner in which they are interpreted or enforced, may require us to make material investments in
the form of additional processes, training and capital, among other things. For a discussion of the risks associated with certain applicable laws and regulations, see
Part I – Item 1A, Risk Factors.
Raw Materials and Energy
Our steelmaking operations require iron ore, HBI, coke, coal, ferrous and carbon and stainless scrap, chrome, nickel and zinc as primary raw materials. We
also consume natural gas, electricity, industrial gases and diesel fuel at our operations. As a vertically integrated steel company, we are able to internally supply a
majority of our raw materials needed for our steelmaking operations. We also attempt to reduce the risk of future supply shortages and price volatility in other ways.
If multi-year contracts are available in the marketplace for those raw materials that we cannot supply internally, we may use these contracts to secure sufficient
supply to satisfy our key raw material needs. When multi-year contracts are not available, or are not available on acceptable terms, we purchase the remainder of
our raw materials needs under annual contracts or conduct spot purchases. We also regularly evaluate alternative sources and substitute materials. Additionally,
we may hedge portions of our energy and raw materials purchases to reduce volatility and risk. We believe that we have secured, or will be able to secure,
adequate supply to fulfill our raw materials and energy requirements for 2022.
The raw materials needed to produce a ton of steel will fluctuate based upon the specifications of the final steel products, the quality of raw materials and,
to a lesser extent, differences among steel production equipment. For example, generally, in our integrated steelmaking facilities, we consume approximately 1.4
net tons of coal to produce one net ton of coke. The process to produce one ton of raw steel generally requires approximately 1.4 net tons of iron ore pellets, 0.4
net tons of coke and 0.3 net tons of steel scrap. At normal operating levels, we also consume approximately 6 MMBtu’s of natural gas per net ton of raw steel
produced. Additionally, on average, our EAFs require 1.1 net tons of ferrous or stainless scrap to produce one net ton of high quality steel. We consume
approximately 420 kilowatt-hours of electricity per net ton of steel produced. While these estimated consumption amounts are presented
16
-- 18 of 411 --
Table of Contents
to give a general sense of raw material and energy consumption used in our steel production, substantial variations may occur.
Our investment into HBI production provides us access, when needed, to clean iron units in order to make advanced steel and stainless products. This
access to our own production provides us flexibility and allows us to avoid the risks and carbon footprints of imported iron substitutes. Iron substitutes imported into
the U.S. are traditionally sourced from regions of the world that have historically experienced greater political turmoil and have lower pollution standards than the
U.S. Our investment demonstrates our raw material and company strategy in responsibly managing the risks of pricing, availability and overall carbon footprint of
our critical inputs.
Our acquisition of FPT provides us sourcing and processing capabilities for both prime and obsolete scrap. This access is critical as prime scrap demand is
expected to grow as new flat-rolled EAF capacity is set to come online over the next five years. The FPT Acquisition included 22 facilities that are primarily located
in the Midwest near our steel facilities. We plan to pair the operational footprint of FPT with our long-standing flat-rolled automotive and other customer relationships
to develop recycling partnerships that will further grow our prime scrap presence. Additionally, the FPT Acquisition furthers our commitment to being an
environmentally-friendly, low-carbon intensity steelmaker with a cleaner materials mix as we are able to better optimize productivity at our existing EAFs and BOFs.
Our investment in FPT further demonstrates our commitment to a vertically integrated business model.
Iron Ore
We own or co-own five active iron ore mines in Minnesota and Michigan. Based on our ownership in these mines, our share of annual rated iron ore
production capacity is approximately 28 million long tons, which supplies all of the iron ore needed for our steelmaking operations. Refer to Part I - Item 2.
Properties for additional information.
Coke and Coal
We own five cokemaking facilities, including two coke batteries located within our steelmaking facilities, one of which is temporarily idled. These facilities
currently provide over half of the coke requirements for our steelmaking operations and have an annual rated capacity of 3.9 million net tons. Additionally, we have
coke supply agreements with suppliers that provide our remaining requirements. Our purchases of coke are made under annual or multi-year agreements with
periodic price adjustments. We typically purchase most of our metallurgical coal under annual fixed-price agreements. We have annual rated metallurgical coal
production capacity of 2.3 million net tons from our Princeton mine, which supplies a portion of our metallurgical coal needs. We believe there are adequate external
supplies of coke and coal available at competitive market prices to meet our needs. Refer to Part I - Item 2. Properties for additional information.
Steel Scrap and Other Materials
Following the FPT Acquisition, the majority of our scrap requirements are generated or processed from internal sources, including scrap generated at our
steel production facilities. We believe that supplies of additional steel scrap, chrome, nickel and zinc adequate to meet the needs of our steelmaking operations are
readily available from outside sources at competitive market prices.
Energy
We consume a large amount of natural gas, electricity, industrial gases and diesel fuel, which are significant costs to our operations. The majority of our
energy requirements are purchased from outside sources. Access to long-term, low-cost sources of energy in various forms is critically important to our operations.
Natural gas is procured for our operations utilizing a combination of long-term, annual, quarterly, monthly and spot contracts from various suppliers at
market-based pricing. We believe access to low-cost and reliable sources of natural gas is available to meet our operations’ requirements.
We purchase electricity for all of our operations in either regulated or deregulated markets. Due to the distinct nature of these markets, we procure
electricity through either long-term or annual contracts. Some of our operations also use self-generated coke oven gas and/or blast furnace gas to produce
electricity, which is an environmentally-friendly practice that also reduces our need to purchase electricity from external sources. We also closely monitor
developments at the state and federal levels that could impact electricity availability or cost and incorporate such changes into our electricity supply strategy in
order to maintain reliable, low-cost supply. We are currently evaluating the use of renewable energy to complement our existing supply. We believe there is an
adequate supply of competitively priced electricity to fulfill our requirements.
17
-- 19 of 411 --
Table of Contents
We purchase industrial gases under long-term contracts with various suppliers. We believe we have access to adequate supplies of industrial gases to
meet our needs.
We predominantly purchase diesel fuel for our mining operations under long-term contracts with various suppliers. We believe we have access to adequate
supplies of diesel fuel to meet our needs.
Human Capital
Cliffs has a long, proven history of attracting and retaining exceptional talent. We believe our employee-centric management philosophy is the key to our
success. Even though many other employers are facing unprecedented labor shortages, we continued to grow during 2021.
As of December 31, 2021, we employed approximately 26,000 people. Approximately 25,500 were employed in the U.S. Approximately 24,000 employees
were employed at production facilities, with the balance employed in corporate support roles. The vast majority of our approximately 21,000 hourly employees were
subject to collective bargaining agreements (approximately 18,500) with various labor unions.
Labor Relations
Our labor relations philosophy is a cornerstone of our talent strategy. At Cliffs, we know thatmaintainingstrong, positive relationships withlabor
unionsiskey toourlong-termgrowth. We recognize and respect the right of our employees to freely associate and collectively bargain, and we do not engage in
harassment, intimidation or retaliation for their efforts to bargain collectively.
More than three-quarters of Cliffs’ workforce are represented by three prominent unions—USW, UAW and IAM. The hardworking men and women of
Cliffs are the lifeblood of our Company. Our employees operate and maintain our facilities and are, ultimately, responsible for safely delivering a quality product to our
customers. Therefore, we engage with our unions as business partners,and together, we have achieveda number ofsuccesses that benefit our business and our
people alike.
In 2021,laborcontracts for workers represented atour Rockport, Dearborn, Mansfield and Monessen facilities were successfullyratified. We are proud
toreportwe did not experience any strikes or lockoutslast year. Weexpectto continueproductive dialogue with our labor partnersinto 2022 asa number
ofothersiteagreementsreach expiration and will be renegotiated. This positive partnership with our unions helps us remain competitive for talent andprotects our
customers and their supply chains from disruptions due to labor disagreements.
Talent Retention
We believe that our future success largely depends upon our continued ability to attract and retain a highly skilled workforce. We provide our employees
with competitive salaries, incentive-based bonus programs that provide above-market compensation opportunities when our Company performs well, development
programs that enable continued learning and growth, and a robust benefit package that promotes well-being across all aspects of their lives, including health care,
retirement planning and paid time off. In addition to these programs, we have used targeted, equity-based grants with vesting conditions to facilitate retention of key
personnel. These tools have enabled us to increase the retention of key personnel, including our corporate and site leadership teams and critical technical talent.
Robust Employee Benefits Programs
The success of our business is fundamentally connected to the well-being of our people. Accordingly, we are committed to the health, safety and wellness
of our employees. We provide our employees and their families with access to a variety of innovative, flexible and convenient health and wellness programs,
including benefits that provide protection and security so they can have peace of mind concerning events that may require time away from work or that impact their
financial well-being; that support their physical and mental health by providing tools and resources to help them improve or maintain their health and encourage
engagement in healthy behaviors; and that offer choice where possible so they can customize their benefits to meet their needs and the needs of their families.
Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
We continue to foster a culture of diversity, equity and inclusion at Cliffs. Through our OneCliffs Way of Doing Business (our Code of Business Conduct and
Ethics), we outline our Core Values, which include Trust, Respect and Open Communication. To us, this means encouraging and accepting different views, and
supporting and advancing gender and racial diversity. Further, our OneCliffs Way of Doing Business provides that we will not make employment-related decisions
nor will we discriminate based on race, color, national origin, gender, age, religion, mental or
18
-- 20 of 411 --
Table of Contents
physical disability, veteran status, sexual orientation or any other characteristic protected by applicable law. We strive to make Cliffs a safe place to work for all.
Harassment and/or intimidation are not tolerated anywhere in our Company, and we hope our people make a career at Cliffs doing meaningful and challenging
work.
COVID-19
In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, we implemented significant changes in our operations and workplaces in the best interest of our employees, as
well as the communities in which we operate, which exceeded government regulations. This includes having all employees who could perform their work remotely
work from home when necessary, while implementing numerous safety measures for employees continuing critical on-site work at our operations.
Additionally, in an effort to best protect our workforce and the Company, we launched a vaccine incentive program in July 2021 that was developed in
partnership with our labor unions. Throughout the 45 days the program was in place, the vaccination rate more than doubled and we achieved a vaccination rate of
over 75% throughout our workforce. The initiative resulted in a payout of $45 million in total cash incentive to our vaccinated workforce. The successful vaccination
program allowed us to operate efficiently and safely throughout the remainder of 2021 and into 2022.
Safety
Safe production is our primary core value as we continue toward achieving a zero injury culture at our facilities. We constantly monitor our safety
performance and make continuous improvements to affect change. Best practices and incident learnings are shared globally to ensure each facility can administer
the most effective policies and procedures for enhanced workplace safety. Progress toward achieving our objectives is accomplished through a focus on proactive
sustainable safety initiatives, and results are measured against established industry and Company benchmarks, including our Company-wide Total Reportable
Incident Rate. During 2021, our Total Reportable Incident Rate (including contractors) was 1.37 per 200,000 hours worked.
Refer to Exhibit 95 Mine Safety Disclosures (filed herewith) for mine safety information required in accordance with Section 1503(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act.
Available Information
Our headquarters are located at 200 Public Square, Suite 3300, Cleveland, Ohio 44114-2315, and our telephone number is (216) 694-5700. We are
subject to the reporting requirements of the Exchange Act and its rules and regulations. The Exchange Act requires us to file reports, proxy statements and other
information with the SEC.
The SEC maintains a website that contains reports, proxy statements and other information regarding issuers that file electronically with the SEC. These
materials may be obtained electronically by accessing the SEC’s home page at www.sec.gov.
We use our website, www.clevelandcliffs.com, as a channel for routine distribution of important information, including news releases, investor presentations
and financial information. We also make available, free of charge on our website, our Annual Reports on Form 10-K, Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q, Current
Reports on Form 8-K and amendments to these reports filed or furnished pursuant to Section 13(a) or 15(d) of the Exchange Act, as soon as reasonably practicable
after we electronically file these documents with, or furnish them to, the SEC. In addition, our website allows investors and other interested persons to sign up to
receive automatic email alerts when we post news releases and financial information on our website.
We also make available, free of charge, the charters of the Audit Committee, Strategy and Sustainability Committee, Governance and Nominating
Committee, and Compensation and Organization Committee, as well as the Corporate Governance Guidelines, and the Code of Business Conduct and Ethics
adopted by our Board of Directors. These documents are available through our investor relations page on our website at www.clevelandcliffs.com. The SEC filings
are available by selecting “Investors” and then “SEC Filings,” and corporate governance materials are available by selecting "Investors" and then “Governance” for
the Board Committee Charters, the Corporate Governance Guidelines, and the Code of Business Conduct and Ethics.
References to our website or the SEC’s website do not constitute incorporation by reference of the information contained on such websites, and such
information is not part of this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
19
-- 21 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Copies of the above-referenced information are also available, free of charge, by calling (216) 694-5700 or upon written request to:
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
Investor Relations
200 Public Square, Suite 3300
Cleveland, OH 44114-2315
20
-- 22 of 411 --
Table of Contents
INFORMATION ABOUT OUR EXECUTIVE OFFICERS
Following are the names, ages and positions of the executive officers of the Company as of February 11, 2022. Unless otherwise noted, all positions
indicated are or were held with Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
Name Age Position(s) Held
Lourenco Goncalves 64 Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer (August 2014 – present); and Chairman, President and Chief
Executive Officer of Metals USA Holdings Corp., an American manufacturer and processor of steel and other metals
(May 2006 – April 2013).
Clifford Smith 62 Executive Vice President & President, Cleveland-Cliffs Steel (September 2021 – present); Executive Vice President,
Chief Operating Officer (January 2019 – September 2021); and Executive Vice President, Business Development
(April 2015 – January 2019).
Keith Koci 57 Executive Vice President & President, Cleveland-Cliffs Services (September 2021 – present); Executive Vice
President, Chief Financial Officer (February 2019 – September 2021); and Senior Vice President and Chief Financial
Officer, Metals USA Holdings Corp. (2013 – February 2019).
Celso Goncalves 34 Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer (September 2021 – present); Senior Vice President, Finance &
Treasurer (March 2020 – September 2021); Vice President, Treasurer (January 2018 – March 2020); and Assistant
Treasurer (September 2016 – January 2018).
Terry Fedor 57 Executive Vice President, Operations, East (September 2021 – present); Executive Vice President, Chief Operating
Officer, Steel Mills (March 2020 – September 2021); Executive Vice President, Operations (February 2019 – March
2020); and Executive Vice President, U.S. Iron Ore (January 2014 – February 2019).
Traci Forrester 50 Executive Vice President, Environmental & Sustainability (May 2021 – present); Executive Vice President, Business
Development (May 2019 – May 2021); Vice President, Deputy General Counsel & Assistant Secretary (January 2018
– May 2019); and Deputy General Counsel & Assistant Secretary (January 2017 – May 2019).
James Graham 56 Executive Vice President, Chief Legal Officer & Secretary (November 2014 – present).
Maurice Harapiak 60 Executive Vice President, Human Resources & Chief Administration Officer (January 2018 – present); and Executive
Vice President, Human Resources (March 2014 – January 2018).
Kimberly Floriani 39 Senior Vice President, Controller & Chief Accounting Officer (August 2021 – present); Vice President, Corporate
Controller & Chief Accounting Officer (April 2020 – August 2021); and Director, Accounting & Reporting (August 2015
– April 2020).
All executive officers serve at the pleasure of the Board. There are no arrangements or understandings between any executive officer and any other person
pursuant to which an executive officer was selected to be an officer of the Company. Celso Goncalves, our Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, is the
son of Lourenco Goncalves, our Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer. There is no other family relationship between any of our executive officers, or
between any of our executive officers and any of our directors.
21
-- 23 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Item 1A. Risk Factors
An investment in our common shares or other securities is subject to risks inherent in our businesses and the industries in which we operate. Described
below are certain risks and uncertainties, the occurrences of which could have a material adverse effect on us. The risks and uncertainties described below include
known material risks that we face currently, but our material risks are constantly evolving and the below descriptions may not include future risks that are not
presently known, that are not currently believed to be material or that are common to all businesses. Investors should not interpret the disclosure of any risk to imply
that such risk has not already materialized. Although we have extensive risk management policies, practices and procedures in place that are aimed to mitigate
these risks, the occurrence of these uncertainties may nevertheless impair our business operations and adversely affect the actual outcome of matters as to which
forward-looking statements are made. This report is qualified in its entirety by these risk factors. Before making an investment decision, investors should consider
carefully all of the risks described below together with the other information included in this report and the other reports we file with the SEC.
Management has identified several categories of material risks that we are subject to, including: (I) economic and market, (II) regulatory, (III) financial, (IV)
operational, (V) sustainability and development and (VI) human capital. Although the risks are organized by these headings, and each risk is discussed separately,
many are interrelated.
I. ECONOMIC AND MARKET RISKS
The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic and the resulting economic volatility has had, and is expected to continue to have, an adverse impact on our
businesses.
The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic is continuing to impact countries, communities, supply chains and markets. Responses by individuals, governments and
businesses to ever-changing developments in the COVID-19 pandemic and efforts to reduce its spread, including quarantines, travel restrictions, business
closures, and mandatory stay-at-home or work-from-home orders, have led to significant disruptions to overall business and economic activity. While vaccines are
now widely available and the economy experienced a partial recovery during 2021, due to the number of unvaccinated individuals and the novel strains and multiple
variants of the COVID-19 virus periodically being encountered on a global basis that may be more resistant to existing vaccines, it is currently unknown for how long
and to what extent consumer and business activity will continue to be impacted by the volatility caused by the pandemic.
Among other things, the COVID-19 pandemic adversely affected our businesses by temporarily curtailing certain of our end markets, and certain of our
mining and production facilities were idled for various periods during 2020 in response to the decrease in customer demand. While we were able to resume
operations at our temporarily idled facilities later in 2020 or 2021, we cannot predict whether any of our production facilities or mines will experience disruptions in
the future as a result of adverse impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic. We are also subject to risks arising out of the turbulence of the economic recovery associated
with the COVID-19 pandemic, including inflationary pressures, which may increase the costs of our labor, raw materials, energy supplies and other production
inputs, which could have an adverse impact on our results of operations and profitability.
In addition, the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has heightened the risk that a significant portion of our workforce and on-site contractors will suffer illness or
otherwise be unable to perform their ordinary work functions. While we have periodically instituted remote work policies where practical across our footprint, the
safe and responsible operation of our production facilities often requires that workers be on-site. Accordingly, during 2021, we experienced direct and indirect
workforce impacts from COVID-19 at many of our operations. We also may need to reduce our workforce as a result of declines in our business caused by any
further adverse developments in the COVID-19 pandemic leading to a downturn in the economy, and there can be no assurance that we will be able to rehire our
workforce once our business has recovered. We have experienced, and may continue to experience, supply chain disruptions or operational issues with our
vendors or logistics providers, as our suppliers and contractors face similar challenges related to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Because the prolonged COVID-19 pandemic continues to evolve, we cannot predict the full extent to which our businesses, results of operations, financial
condition or liquidity will ultimately be impacted. To the extent the COVID‑19 pandemic adversely affects our businesses, it may also have the effect of exacerbating
many of the other risks described in this ‘‘Risk Factors’’ section, any of which could have a material adverse effect on us.
22
-- 24 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The volatility of commodity prices, including steel, iron ore and scrap metal, directly and indirectly affects our ability to generate revenue,
maintain stable cash flows and fund our operations.
Our profitability is dependent upon the prices of the steel, iron ore and scrap metal that we sell to our customers. As an integrated producer of steel, iron ore
and scrap metal, we experience direct impacts of steel price fluctuations through customer sales, as well as direct and indirect impacts of iron ore and scrap metal
price fluctuations through third-party sales and the impacts that fluctuations in iron ore and scrap metal prices have on steel prices. The prices of steel, iron ore and
scrap metal have fluctuated significantly in the past and are unpredictable and affected by factors beyond our control, including: international demand for raw
materials used in steel production; availability of scrap metal substitutes such as pig iron; commodity price speculation; rates of global economic growth, especially
construction and infrastructure activity that requires significant amounts of steel; changes in the levels of economic activity in the U.S., China, India, Europe and
other industrialized or developing economies; changes in China’s emissions policies and environmental compliance enforcement practices; changes in the
production capacity, production rate and inventory levels of other steel producers, iron ore suppliers and scrap metal processors and traders; changes in trade laws;
volumes of unfairly traded imports; imposition or termination of duties, tariffs, import and export controls and other trade barriers impacting the steel and iron ore
markets; climate change and other weather-related disruptions, infectious disease outbreaks, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, or natural disasters that may impact
the global supply of steel, iron ore or scrap metal; and the proximity, capacity and cost of infrastructure and transportation.
Our earnings, therefore, fluctuate with the prices of the products we sell. Although we experienced generally higher prices for our products during 2021 as
compared to 2020, to the extent that commodity prices, including the HRC price, coated and other specialty steel prices, international steel prices and scrap metal
prices, significantly decline for an extended period of time, whether due to the COVID-19 pandemic or otherwise, we may have to further revise our operating plans,
including curtailing production, reducing operating costs and deferring capital expenditures. We also may have to record impairments on our goodwill, intangible
assets, long-lived assets and/or inventory. Sustained lower prices also could cause us to further reduce existing mineral reserves if certain reserves no longer can
be economically mined or processed at prevailing prices. We may be unable to decrease our costs in an amount sufficient to offset reductions in revenues and may
incur losses. These events could have a material adverse effect on us.
We sell a significant portion of our steel products to the automotive market and fluctuations or changes in the automotive market could
adversely affect our business operations and financial performance.
The largest end user for our steel products is the automotive industry in North America. Beyond these direct sales to the automotive industry, we make
additional sales to distributors and converters, which may ultimately resell some of that volume to the automotive market. In addition to the size of our exposure to
the automotive industry, we face risks arising from our relative concentration of sales to certain specific automotive manufacturers, including several significant
customers that previously idled certain automotive production facilities for varying lengths of time in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. In addition, automotive
production and sales are cyclical and sensitive to general economic conditions and other factors, including interest rates, consumer credit, spending and
preferences, and supply chain disruptions, such as the current semiconductor shortage. If automotive production and sales decline, our sales and shipments to the
automotive market are likely to decline in a corresponding manner. Similarly, while certain market and industry experts are predicting an increase in new vehicle
builds during 2022 as compared to 2020 and 2021, if this increase fails to materialize, our sales to the automotive market could be adversely affected. Adverse
impacts that we may sustain as a result include, without limitation, lower margins because of the need to sell our steel to less profitable customers and markets,
higher fixed costs from lower steel production if we are unable to sell the same amount of steel to other customers and markets, and lower sales, shipments, pricing
and margins generally as our competitors face similar challenges and compete vigorously in other markets that we serve. These adverse impacts would negatively
affect our sales, financial results and cash flows. Additionally, the trend toward light weighting in the automotive industry, which requires lighter gauges of steel at
higher strengths, could result in lower steel volumes required by that industry over time.
Moreover, despite our newly acquired position as the largest flat-rolled steel producer in North America, competition for automotive business has intensified
in recent years, as steel producers and companies producing alternative materials have focused their efforts on capturing and/or expanding their market share of
automotive business because of less favorable conditions in other markets for steel and other metals, including commodity products. As a result, the potential
exists that we may lose market share to existing or new entrants or that automotive manufacturers will take advantage of the intense competition among potential
suppliers during periodic contract renewal negotiations to pressure our pricing and margins in order to maintain or expand our market share with them, which could
negatively affect our sales, financial results and cash flows.
23
-- 25 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Global steelmaking overcapacity, steel imports and oversupply of iron ore could lead to lower or more volatile global steel and iron ore prices,
directly or indirectly impacting our profitability.
Significant existing global steel capacity and new or expanded production capacity in recent years could potentially cause capacity to exceed demand
globally. Although certain of our U.S. competitors temporarily shut down production capacity during the COVID-19 pandemic, much of the previously idled capacity
has been restarted, and certain of our competitors have announced and are moving ahead with plans to develop new steelmaking capacity in the near term. In
addition, certain foreign competitors, which may have cost advantages due to being owned, controlled or subsidized by foreign governments, have substantially
increased their steel production capacity in the last few years and in some instances appear to have targeted the U.S. market for imports. The risk of even greater
levels of imports may continue, depending upon foreign market and economic conditions, changes in trade agreements and treaties, laws, regulations or
government policies affecting trade, the ability of foreign producers to circumvent U.S. trade sanctions and policy (including in the market for electrical steels), the
value of the U.S. dollar relative to other currencies and other variables beyond our control. In addition, higher sustained market prices of steel and iron ore products
could cause new producers to enter the market or existing producers to further expand productive capacity, which could in turn lead to lower steel prices and
increasing prices of steelmaking inputs, such as scrap metal. Excess steel and iron ore supply combined with reduced global steel demand, including in China, and
increased foreign imports could also lead to lower steel and iron ore prices. Downward pressure on steel and/or iron ore prices could have an adverse effect on our
results of operations, financial condition and profitability.
Severe financial hardship or bankruptcy of one or more of our major customers or key suppliers could adversely affect our business operations
and financial performance.
Sales and operations of a majority of our customers are sensitive to general economic conditions, especially, with respect to our steel customers, as they
affect the North American automotive, housing, construction, appliance, energy, defense and other industries. Some of our customers are highly leveraged. If there
is a significant weakening of current economic conditions, whether because of operational, cyclical, supply chain or other issues, including further adverse
developments in the COVID-19 pandemic, it could cause customers to reduce, delay or cancel their orders with us, impact significantly the creditworthiness of our
customers and lead to other financial difficulties or even bankruptcy filings by our customers. Failure to receive payment from our customers for products that we
have delivered could adversely affect our results of operations, financial condition and liquidity. The concentration of customers in a specific industry, such as the
automotive industry, may increase our risk because of the likelihood that circumstances may affect multiple customers at the same time. Such events could cause
us to experience lost sales or losses associated with the potential inability to collect all outstanding accounts receivable and reduced liquidity. Similarly, if our key
suppliers face financial hardship or need to operate in bankruptcy, such suppliers could experience operational disruption or even face liquidation, which could
result in our inability to secure replacement raw materials on a timely basis, or at all, or cause us to incur increased costs to do so. Such events could adversely
impact our operations, financial results and cash flows.
II. REGULATORY RISKS
U.S. government actions on trade agreements and treaties, laws, regulations or policies affecting trade could lead to lower or more volatile
global steel prices, impacting our profitability.
In recent years, the U.S. government has altered its approach to international trade policy, both generally and with respect to matters directly and indirectly
affecting the steel industry, including by undertaking certain unilateral actions affecting trade, renegotiating existing bilateral or multilateral trade agreements, and
entering into new agreements or treaties with foreign countries. For example, in March 2018, the U.S. government issued a proclamation pursuant to Section 232
imposing a 25% tariff on imported steel. These Section 232 tariffs were imposed on the basis of national security and addressed imported steel that was being
unfairly traded by certain foreign competitors at artificially low prices. In retaliation against the Section 232 tariffs, the European Union subsequently imposed its
own tariffs against certain steel products and other goods imported from the U.S. Moreover, in light of the U.S. government leadership changes resulting from the
November 2020 federal congressional and presidential elections, further changes in U.S. international trade policy may be forthcoming. For example, the U.S.
government and the European Union recently agreed to a tariff rate quota system that will allow more European Union imports to enter the U.S. market free of
Section 232 tariffs. The U.S. government may also negotiate reductions or eliminations of Section 232 duties with other trading partners. If the Section 232 tariffs
are further removed or substantially lessened, whether through legal challenge, legislation, executive action or otherwise, imports of foreign steel would likely
increase and steel prices in the U.S. would likely fall, which could materially adversely affect our revenues, financial results and cash flows.
24
-- 26 of 411 --
Table of Contents
In addition, during 2020, the USMCA was implemented among the U.S., Mexico and Canada in place of the North American Free Trade Agreement.
Because all of our steel manufacturing facilities are located in North America and one of our principal markets is automotive manufacturing in North America, we
believe that the USMCA has the potential to positively impact our business by incentivizing automakers and other manufacturers to increase manufacturing
production in North America and to use North American steel. However, it is difficult to predict the short- and long-term implications of changes in trade policy and,
therefore, whether the USMCA or other new or renegotiated trade agreements, treaties, laws, regulations or policies that may be implemented by the U.S.
government, or otherwise, will have a beneficial or detrimental impact on our business and our customers’ and suppliers’ businesses. Adverse effects could occur
directly from a disruption to trade and commercial transactions and/or indirectly by adversely affecting the U.S. economy or certain sectors of the economy,
impacting demand for our customers’ products and, in turn, negatively affecting demand for our products. Important links of the supply chain for some of our key
customers, including automotive manufacturers, could be negatively impacted by the USMCA or other new or renegotiated trade agreements, treaties, laws,
regulations or policies. Any of these actions and their direct and indirect impacts could materially adversely affect our revenues, financial results and cash flows.
Although we may currently benefit from certain antidumping and countervailing duty orders, any such relief is subject to periodic reviews and challenges,
which can result in revocation of the orders or reduction of the duties. For example, during 2022, the U.S. government is scheduled to review antidumping and
countervailing duty orders on some of our key products, including corrosion-resistant steel, cold-rolled steel, hot-rolled steel and cut-to-length plate. In addition,
previously granted and future petitions for trade relief may not be successful or fully effective at preventing harm. Even if received, it is uncertain if any relief will be
continued in the future or will be adequate to counteract completely the harmful effects of unfairly traded imports.
We are subject to extensive governmental regulation, which imposes potential significant costs and liabilities on us. Future laws and
regulations or the manner in which they are interpreted and enforced could increase these costs and liabilities or limit our ability to produce our raw
materials and products.
New laws or regulations, or changes in existing laws or regulations, or the manner of their interpretation or enforcement, could increase our cost of doing
business and restrict our ability to operate our businesses or execute our strategies. This includes, among other things: changes in MSHA regulations, such as
respirable silica standards; reevaluation of the National Ambient Air Quality Standards, such as revised nitrogen dioxide, sulfur dioxide, lead, ozone and particulate
matter criteria; changes in the interpretation of OSHA regulations, such as standards for occupational exposure to noise, certain chemicals or hazardous
substances and infectious diseases; and the possible taxation under U.S. law of certain income from foreign operations.
In addition, we and our operations are subject to various international, foreign, federal, state, provincial and local laws and regulations relating to protection
of the environment and human health and safety, including those relating to air quality, water pollution, plant, wetlands, natural resources and wildlife protection
(including endangered or threatened species), reclamation, remediation and restoration of properties and related surety bonds or other financial assurances, land
use, the discharge of materials into the environment, the effects that industrial operations and mining have on groundwater quality and availability, the management
of electrical equipment containing polychlorinated biphenyls, and other related matters. Despite implementation of rigorous environmental protocols and
management systems, we cannot be certain that we have been or will be at all times in complete compliance with such laws and regulations. If we violate or fail to
comply with these laws or regulations, we could be fined, required to cease operations, subject to criminal or civil liability, or otherwise sanctioned by regulators or
barred from participating in government contracts. In addition, federal or state regulatory agencies have the authority, under certain circumstances following
significant health and safety incidents, such as fatalities, to order a mine or production facility to be temporarily or permanently closed. Compliance with the
complex and extensive laws and regulations to which we are subject imposes substantial costs on us, which could increase over time because of heightened
regulatory oversight, adoption of more stringent environmental, health and safety standards and greater demand for remediation services leading to shortages of
equipment, supplies and labor, as well as other factors.
Specifically, there are several notable proposed or recently enacted rulemakings or activities to which we would be subject or that would further regulate
and/or tax us and our customers, which may also require us or our customers to reduce or otherwise change operations significantly or incur significant additional
costs, depending on their ultimate outcome. These emerging or recently enacted rules, regulations and policy guidance include, but are not limited to: governmental
regulations imposed, modified or rescinded in response to developments in the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic; trade regulations, such as the USMCA and/or other
trade agreements, treaties or policies; changes in tariff policy, including with respect to the 25% tariff on certain imported steel imposed under Section 232; climate
change mitigation strategies and GHG regulation; selenium discharge regulation; revisions to the sulfate wild rice water quality standard and its implementation;
Minnesota’s Mercury TMDL and associated federal rules governing mercury air emission reductions; evolving water quality standards and the regulation of
discharges to groundwater;
25
-- 27 of 411 --
Table of Contents
the Regional Haze FIP Rule; and revised National Ambient Air Quality Standards, particularly for ozone and particulate matter. In addition, the Biden Administration
has indicated via executive orders and in public statements that it will propose more stringent environmental regulation, in particular related to climate change. Any
new or more stringent legislation, regulations, rules, interpretations or orders, when enacted and enforced, including any related to required reductions in, or taxes
on, levels of carbon emissions, could have a material adverse effect on our business, results of operations, financial condition or profitability.
Our operations may be impacted by the recent enactment, and ongoing consideration, of significant federal and state laws and regulations relating to
certain mine-related issues, such as the stability of tailings basins, mine drainage and fill activities, reclamation and safety in underground and surface mines. With
respect to underground mines, for example, these laws and regulations include requirements for constructing and maintaining caches for the storage of additional
self-contained self-rescuers throughout the mines; installing rescue chambers in the mines; continuous tracking of and communication with personnel in the mines;
installing cable lifelines from the mine portal to all sections of the mine to assist in emergency escape; submission and approval of emergency response plans; and
additional safety training. Additionally, there are requirements for the prompt reporting of accidents and increased fines and penalties for violations of these and
existing regulations. These laws and regulations may cause us to incur substantial additional costs.
In addition, certain of our operations are subject to the risks of doing business abroad and we must comply with complex foreign and U.S. laws and
regulations, which may include, but are not limited to, the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and other anti-bribery laws, regulations related to import/export and trade
controls, the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation and other U.S. and foreign privacy regulations, and transportation and logistics regulations.
These laws and regulations may increase our costs of doing business in international jurisdictions and expose our operations and our employees to elevated risk.
We require our employees, contractors and agents to comply with these and all other applicable laws and regulations, but failure to do so could result in possible
administrative, civil or criminal liability and reputational harm to us and our employees.
As a supplier on federal, state and local public procurement projects, including projects that may arise out of proposed or recently enacted governmental
legislation regarding infrastructure investments, we may be subject to certain stringent procurement regulations that may present compliance challenges or may
increase the costs of securing certain business. We may also be indirectly affected through regulatory changes that impact our customers, which in turn could
reduce the quantity of our products they demand, adversely impact the terms upon which they purchase or the prices for our products they are willing to pay.
Regulatory changes that impact our suppliers could decrease the availability of products or services they sell to us or could increase the price they demand for
products or services they sell to us.
Our operations use hazardous materials and inadvertently may impact the environment, which could result in material liabilities to us.
Our operations currently use, and have in the past used, hazardous materials and substances, and we have generated, and expect to continue to generate,
solid and hazardous waste. We have been, and may in the future be, subject to claims under international, foreign, federal, state, provincial and local laws and
regulations for toxic torts, natural resource damages and other damages as well as for the investigation and clean-up of soil, surface water, sediments, groundwater
and other natural resources and reclamation of properties. Such claims for damages, as well as investigation, remediation and reclamation requirements, have
arisen and may arise in the future out of current, future or former conditions at sites that we or our acquired companies own, lease or operate, as well as sites that
we or our acquired companies formerly owned, leased or operated, and at contaminated sites that are or have been owned, leased or operated by our joint venture
partners. We may also have liability for contamination at third-party sites where we have sent hazardous wastes. Our liability for these claims may be strict and/or
joint and several, such that we may be held responsible for more than our share of the contamination or other damages, or even for entire claims regardless of fault.
We may be named as a potentially responsible party at other third-party sites in the future, and we cannot be certain that the costs associated with these additional
sites will not exceed any reserves we have established or otherwise be material.
We may be unable to obtain, maintain, renew or comply with permits necessary for our operations or be required to provide additional financial
assurances, which could reduce our production, cash flows, profitability and available liquidity.
We must obtain, maintain and comply with numerous permits that require approval of operational plans and impose strict conditions on various
environmental, health and safety matters in connection with our steel production and processing and mining and other operations. These include permits and
approvals issued by various federal,
26
-- 28 of 411 --
Table of Contents
state, provincial, foreign and local agencies and regulatory bodies, with which we may not always be able to comply. The permitting rules are complex and may
change over time, making our ability to comply with the applicable requirements more difficult or potentially impractical and costly, possibly precluding the
continuance of ongoing operations or the development of future operations. Interpretations of rules may also change over time and may lead to requirements, such
as additional financial assurances, making it costlier to comply. Moreover, despite our ongoing efforts to reduce our environmental footprint and improve the
resiliency of our business model, heightened levels of regulatory oversight focused on addressing climate change and industrial activities that generate GHG
emissions, such as our steelmaking, cokemaking and mining operations, could impact, delay or disrupt our ability to obtain new or renewed permits or modifications
to existing permits.
In addition, the public, including special interest groups and individuals, have certain rights under various statutes to comment upon, submit objections to,
and otherwise engage in the permitting process, including bringing citizens’ lawsuits to challenge such permits or activities. Accordingly, required permits may not
be issued or renewed in a timely fashion (or at all), or permits issued or renewed may include conditions that we cannot meet or otherwise be conditioned in ways
that may restrict our ability to conduct our production, mining and processing activities efficiently or include requirements for additional financial assurances that we
may not be able to provide on commercially reasonable terms (or at all), which could reduce available borrowing capacity under our ABL Facility. Such conditions,
restrictions or requirements could also reduce our production, cash flows or profitability.
III. FINANCIAL RISKS
Our existing and future indebtedness may limit cash flow available to invest in the ongoing needs of our businesses, which could prevent us
from fulfilling our obligations under our senior notes, ABL Facility and other debt, and we may be forced to take other actions to satisfy our obligations
under our debt, which may not be successful.
As of December 31, 2021, we had $5,369 million aggregate principal amount of long-term debt outstanding, $1,452 million of which was secured (excluding
$175 million of outstanding letters of credit and $291 million of finance leases), and $48 million of cash on our balance sheet. On December 17, 2021, we amended
our ABL Facility to, among other things, increase the tranche A revolver commitments available under the ABL Facility by an additional $1,000 million and
exchange $150 million of tranche B revolver commitments available thereunder for tranche A revolver commitments. After giving effect to this amendment, the
aggregate principal amount of tranche A revolver commitments under our ABL Facility is $4,500 million, and there are no longer any tranche B commitments under
our ABL Facility. As of December 31, 2021, $1,609 million was outstanding under our ABL Facility, and the principal amount of letters of credit obligations and other
commitments totaled $175 million. As of December 31, 2021, the available borrowing capacity on our ABL Facility was $2,716 million.
We dedicate a portion of our cash flow from operations to the payment of debt service, reducing the availability of our cash flow to fund capital
expenditures, acquisitions or strategic development initiatives, and other general corporate purposes. Our ability to make scheduled payments on or to refinance
our debt obligations depends on our ability to generate cash in the future and our financial condition and operating performance, which are subject to prevailing
economic and competitive conditions and to certain financial, business and other factors beyond our control, including the impact of the ongoing COVID-19
pandemic. There can be no assurance that we will maintain a level of cash flows from operating activities sufficient to permit us to pay the principal, premium, if
any, and interest on our debt. In addition, any failure to comply with covenants in the instruments governing our debt could result in an event of default that, if not
cured or waived, would have a material adverse effect on us.
Our level of indebtedness could have further consequences, including, but not limited to, increasing our vulnerability to adverse economic or industry
conditions, placing us at a competitive disadvantage compared to other businesses in the industries in which we operate that are not as leveraged and that may be
better positioned to withstand economic downturns, limiting our flexibility to plan for, or react to, changes in our businesses and the industries in which we operate,
and requiring us to refinance all or a portion of our existing debt. We may not be able to refinance on commercially reasonable terms or at all, and any refinancing of
our debt could be at higher interest rates and may require us to comply with more onerous covenants, making it more difficult to obtain surety bonds, letters of credit
or other financial assurances that may be demanded by our vendors or regulatory agencies, particularly during periods in which credit markets are weak.
A portion of our borrowing capacity and outstanding indebtedness bears interest at a variable rate based on LIBOR. According to the FCA, the IBA will
permanently cease to publish each of the LIBOR settings by June 2023. It is unclear whether new methods of calculating LIBOR will be established such that it
continues to exist after such end date, and there is considerable uncertainty regarding the publication or representativeness of LIBOR beyond such
27
-- 29 of 411 --
Table of Contents
end date. The U.S. Federal Reserve, in conjunction with the Alternative Reference Rates Committee, is seeking to replace U.S. dollar LIBOR with a newly created
index, SOFR. Our ABL Facility provides a mechanism to automatically transition to a SOFR-based benchmark when all USD LIBOR settings are no longer provided
or are no longer representative. In addition, our ABL Facility includes an option for us and the agent to jointly elect to transition early to a SOFR-based benchmark,
or in certain circumstances, an alternative benchmark replacement. It is not possible to predict the effect of these changes, other reforms or the establishment of
alternative reference rates. To the extent these interest rates increase, our interest expense will increase. If sources of capital for us are reduced, capital costs could
increase materially. Restricted access to capital markets and/or increased borrowing costs could have an adverse effect on our results of operations, cash flows,
financial condition and liquidity.
If we are unable to service our debt obligations, we could face substantial liquidity problems and we may be forced to reduce or delay investments and
capital expenditures, or to sell assets, seek additional capital, including additional secured or unsecured debt, or restructure or refinance our debt, and we may be
unable to continue as a going concern. We may be unable to consummate any proposed asset sales or recover the carrying value of these assets, and any
proceeds may not be adequate to meet any debt service obligations then due. Any of these examples potentially could have a material adverse impact on our
results of operations, profitability, shareholders’ equity and capital structure.
Changes in credit ratings issued by nationally recognized statistical rating organizations could adversely affect our cost of financing and the
market price of our securities.
Credit rating agencies could downgrade our ratings due to various developments, including incurring additional indebtedness and other factors specific to
our businesses, a prolonged cyclical downturn in the steel, scrap metal and mining industries or macroeconomic trends (such as global or regional recessions),
increases in pension and OPEB obligations, and trends in credit and capital markets more generally. Any decline in our credit ratings may result in an increase to
our cost of future financing or limit our access to the capital markets, which could harm our financial condition, hinder our ability to refinance existing indebtedness
on acceptable terms, or have an adverse effect on the market price of our securities and the terms under which we purchase goods and services.
Our actual operating results may differ significantly from our guidance.
From time to time, we release guidance, including that set forth under “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of
Operations–Outlook” in our Annual Reports on Form 10-K and our Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q, regarding our future performance. This guidance, which
consists of forward-looking statements, is prepared by our management and is qualified by, and subject to, the assumptions and the other information included in
our Annual Reports on Form 10-K and our Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q. Our guidance is not prepared with a view toward compliance with published guidelines
of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, and neither our independent registered public accounting firm nor any other independent or outside party
compiles or examines the guidance and, accordingly, no such person expresses any opinion or any other form of assurance with respect thereto.
Guidance is based upon a number of assumptions and estimates that, while presented with numerical specificity, are inherently subject to business,
economic, regulatory and competitive uncertainties and contingencies, many of which are beyond our control and are based upon specific assumptions with respect
to future business decisions, some of which will change. The principal reason that we release such data is to provide a basis for our management to discuss our
business outlook with analysts and investors. We do not accept any responsibility for any projections or reports published by any such third parties.
Guidance is necessarily speculative in nature, and it can be expected that some or all of the assumptions of the guidance furnished by us will not
materialize or will vary significantly from actual results. Accordingly, our guidance is only an estimate of what management believes is realizable as of the date of
release. Actual results will vary from the guidance. Investors should also recognize that the reliability of any forecasted financial data diminishes the further in the
future that the data are forecast. In light of the foregoing, investors are urged to put the guidance in context and not to place undue reliance on it.
Any failure to successfully implement our operating strategy or the occurrence of any of the risks described in our Annual Reports on Form 10-K or our
Quarterly Reports on Form 10-Q could cause actual operating results to differ from the guidance, and such differences may be adverse and material.
28
-- 30 of 411 --
Table of Contents
We may be subject to various lawsuits, claims, arbitrations or governmental proceedings that could result in significant expenditures.
We are from time to time subject to various lawsuits, claims, arbitrations or governmental proceedings relating to commercial and business disputes,
environmental matters, government investigations, occupational or personal injury claims, property damage, labor and employment matters, or suits involving
legacy operations and other matters. For example, certain of our subsidiaries have been named in lawsuits claiming exposure to asbestos, many of which have
been dismissed and/or settled for non-material amounts. Nevertheless, it is likely that similar types of claims will continue to be filed in the future, and we could
experience material adverse judgments or incur significant costs to defend such claims or any other existing and future lawsuits, claims, arbitrations or
governmental proceedings. The insurance we maintain may not be adequate to protect us in the event of significant claims.
IV. OPERATIONAL RISKS
Our operating expenses could increase significantly if the prices of raw materials, electrical power, fuel or other energy sources increase.
Our operations require significant use of energy and raw materials. Although we are fully self-sufficient in iron ore and partially self-sufficient in coke,
metallurgical coal and scrap metal, we are wholly or partially dependent on third-party suppliers for certain critical raw materials and production inputs, including
industrial gases, graphite electrodes, chrome, zinc, coke, metallurgical coal and scrap metal. Prices for electricity, natural gas, diesel fuel, oils and raw materials
can fluctuate widely with availability and demand levels from other users, including fluctuations caused by the impact of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. For
example, increased electricity demand to the grid in response to physical climate-related risks and electrification of the economy could adversely impact energy
prices. During periods of peak usage, although some operations have contractual arrangements in place whereby they receive certain offsetting payments in
exchange for electricity load reduction, supplies of energy and raw materials in general may be curtailed and we may not be able to purchase them at historical
rates. A disruption in the transmission of energy, inadequate energy transmission infrastructure, or the termination of any of our energy supply contracts could
interrupt our energy supply and adversely affect our operations. While we have some long-term contracts with electrical, natural gas and raw material suppliers, we
are exposed to fluctuations in energy, natural gas and raw material costs that can affect our production costs. We enter into many market-based pricing supply
contracts for electricity, natural gas and diesel fuel for use in our operations. Those contracts expose us to price increases in energy costs, which could cause our
profitability to decrease significantly. As an example, our Toledo direct reduction plant is subject to changes in the market price of natural gas, which is a key input
in the direct reduction of iron ore pellets to produce HBI, and natural gas experienced a substantial market price increase during the fourth quarter of 2021. In
addition, U.S. public utilities may impose rate increases and pass through additional capital and operating cost increases to their customers related to new or
pending U.S. environmental regulations or other charges that may require significant capital investment and use of cleaner fuels in the future. In particular, the
recent decision of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia vacating and remanding the Affordable Clean Energy Rule, as well as recent executive
orders from President Biden regarding the environment and climate change, indicate that new or revised regulations under the Biden Administration could result in
rate increases from U.S. utilities.
The majority of our steel shipments are sold under contracts that do not allow us to pass through all increases in raw materials, supplies and energy costs.
Some of our customer contracts include variable-pricing mechanisms allowing us to adjust the total sales price based on changes in specified raw materials,
supplies and energy costs. Those adjustments, however, rarely reflect all of our underlying raw materials, supplies and energy cost changes. The scope of the
adjustment may also be limited by the terms of the negotiated language, including limitations on when the adjustment occurs. Our need to consume existing
inventories may also delay the impact of a change in prices of raw materials or supplies. Significant changes in raw material costs may also increase the potential
for inventory value write-downs in the event of a reduction in selling prices and our inability to realize the cost of the inventory. In addition, even though we are
partially self-sufficient in scrap metal, if the market price of scrap metal were to experience a sustained price increase, our cost to produce steel would be adversely
affected due to the higher prices we would need to pay to acquire third-party scrap metal for consumption in our operations.
Our sales and competitive position depend on transporting our products to customers at competitive rates and in a timely manner, and our
ability to optimize our operational footprint depends on predictably and cost effectively moving products and raw materials internally among our
facilities.
Disruption of the rail, trucking, lake and other waterway transportation services because of weather-related problems, including ice and winter weather
conditions on the Great Lakes or St. Lawrence Seaway, climate change,
29
-- 31 of 411 --
Table of Contents
strikes, lock-outs, driver shortages and other disruptions in the trucking industry, train crew shortages or other rail network constraints, global or domestic
pandemics or epidemics (such as the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic) or other infectious disease outbreaks, in each case causing a business disruption, or other
events and lack of alternative transportation options could impair our ability to move products internally among our facilities and to supply products to our customers
at competitive rates or in a timely manner and, thus, could adversely affect our operations, revenues, margins and profitability. Further, dredging issues and
environmental changes, particularly at Great Lakes ports, could impact adversely our ability to move certain of our products or result in higher freight rates.
Similarly, we depend on third-party transportation services for delivery of raw materials and other production inputs to us, and failures or delays in delivery would
have an adverse effect on our ability to maintain steady-state production and processing operations to meet customer obligations.
Natural or human-caused disasters, weather conditions, disruption of energy, unanticipated geological conditions, equipment failures,
infectious disease outbreaks, and other unexpected events may lead our customers, our suppliers or our facilities to curtail production or shut down
operations.
Operating levels within our industry and the industries of our customers and suppliers are subject to unexpected conditions and events that are beyond the
industries’ control. Those events, including the occurrence of an infectious disease, widespread illness or public health emergency, such as the ongoing COVID-19
pandemic, could cause industry members or their suppliers to curtail production or shut down a portion or all of their operations, which could reduce the demand for
our products and adversely affect our revenues, margins and profitability. For example, the temporary production shutdowns in the automotive industry that
occurred during 2020 as a result of the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic and associated reduction in demand for our products led to our decision to temporarily idle
certain steelmaking facilities and iron ore mines.
Our operating levels are subject to conditions beyond our control that can delay deliveries or increase the cost of production for varying lengths of time.
Factors that could cause production disruptions could include adverse weather conditions due to climate change or otherwise (such as extreme winter weather,
tornadoes, floods, and the lack of availability of process water due to drought) and natural and human-caused disasters, lack of adequate raw materials, energy or
other supplies, and infectious disease outbreaks, such as the COVID-19 pandemic. During 2021, for example, while it did not result in material financial
consequences, we experienced a severe weather event involving a tornado that damaged one of our Tooling and Stamping production facilities and a third-party
warehouse located in Kentucky, which adversely impacted our operations, destroyed some of our finished goods inventory and disrupted certain scheduled
deliveries to customers. In addition, factors that could adversely impact production and operations at our mining operations include tailings dam failures, pit wall
failures, unanticipated geological conditions, including variations in the amount of rock and soil overlying deposits of iron ore and metallurgical coal, and processing
changes.
Our mining operations, processing facilities, steelmaking and logistics operations depend on critical pieces of equipment. This equipment may, on
occasion, be out of service because of unanticipated failures or unplanned outages. In addition, most of our mines and production and processing facilities have
been in operation for several decades, and the equipment is aged. In the future, we may experience additional lengthy shutdowns or periods of reduced production
because of equipment failures. Further, remediation of any interruption in production capability may require us to make large capital expenditures that could have a
negative impact on our profitability and cash flows. Our business interruption insurance would not cover all of the lost revenues associated with equipment failures.
Longer-term business disruptions could result in a loss of customers, which could adversely affect our future sales levels and revenues.
Many of our production facilities and mines are dependent on one source for electric power, natural gas, industrial gases and/or certain other raw materials
or supplies. A significant interruption in service from our suppliers due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, terrorism or sabotage, weather conditions such as heat
waves that may be attributable to climate change, natural disasters, equipment failure or any other cause could result in substantial losses that may not be fully
recoverable, either from our business interruption insurance or responsible third parties.
A disruption in or failure of our IT systems, including those related to cybersecurity, could adversely affect our business operations, reputation
and financial performance.
We rely on the accuracy, capacity, integrity and security of our IT systems for the operation of many of our business processes and to comply with
regulatory, legal and tax requirements. While we maintain some of our critical IT systems, we are also dependent on third parties to provide important IT services
relating to, among other things, off-site content hosting, operational process technology at our facilities, human resources, electronic communications and certain
finance functions. Further, in connection with our recent acquisitions, we inherited certain legacy
30
-- 32 of 411 --
Table of Contents
hardware and software IT systems that can be supported only by a very limited number of specialists in the market, and our increased reliance on these legacy IT
systems may increase the risk of IT system disruption or failure, which could adversely affect our operations.
Despite the security measures that we have implemented, including those related to cybersecurity, our IT systems could be breached or damaged by
computer viruses, natural or human-caused incidents or disasters, or unauthorized physical or electronic access or intrusions. Though we have controls in place,
we cannot provide assurance that a cyberattack will not occur. Furthermore, despite our efforts to audit certain critical vendors’ information security controls, we
may have little or no oversight with respect to security measures employed by third-party service providers, which may ultimately prove to be ineffective at
countering threats. We may also experience increased risk of IT system failures or cyberattacks as many of our employees continue to work from home on a
periodic basis as part of our response to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.
Failures of our IT systems, whether caused maliciously or inadvertently, may result in the disruption of our business processes, or in the unauthorized
release of sensitive, confidential, personally identifiable or otherwise protected information, or result in the corruption of data, each of which could adversely affect
our businesses. For example, cybersecurity vulnerabilities could result in an interruption of the functionality of our automated manufacturing operating or health and
safety systems, which, if compromised, could cease, threaten, delay or slow down our ability to produce or process steel or any of our other products for the
duration of such interruption or lead to unanticipated health or safety incidents, which could result in reputational harm and may adversely affect our employees,
results of operations, financial condition and cash flows. In addition, any compromise of the security of our IT systems could result in a loss of confidence in our
security measures and subject us to litigation, regulatory investigations and negative publicity that could adversely affect our reputation and financial condition. Our
customers, suppliers and vendors may also access or store certain of our sensitive information on their IT systems, which, if breached, attacked or accessed by
unauthorized persons, could likewise expose our sensitive information and adversely impact our businesses. Furthermore, as cybersecurity threats continue to
evolve and become more sophisticated, we may be required to incur significant costs and invest additional resources to protect against and, if required, remediate
the damage caused by such disruptions or system failures in the future. The amount of insurance coverage we maintain may be inadequate to cover claims or
liabilities resulting from cybersecurity attacks.
The closure of an operating facility or mine entails substantial costs. If our assumptions underlying our accruals for closure costs prove to be
inaccurate or we prematurely close one or more of our facilities or mines, our results of operations and financial condition would likely be adversely
affected.
If faced with overcapacity in the market or other adverse conditions, including as a result of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, we may seek to rationalize
assets through asset sales, temporary shutdowns, indefinite idles or facility closures. If we indefinitely idle or permanently close any of our facilities or mines, our
production and revenues would be reduced unless we were able to increase production at our other facilities or mines in an offsetting amount, which may not be
possible, and could result in customers responding negatively by taking current or future business away from us if we seek to transition production to a different
facility. Alternatively, we could fail to meet customer specifications at the facilities to which products are transitioned, resulting in customer dissatisfaction or claims.
The closure of a steelmaking or other operating facility or mining operation involves significant closure costs, including reclamation and other environmental
costs, the costs of terminating long-term obligations, including customer, energy and transportation contracts and equipment and real property leases, and certain
accounting charges, including asset impairment and accelerated depreciation. In addition, a permanent facility or mine closure could accelerate and significantly
increase employment legacy costs, including our expense and funding costs for pension and OPEB obligations and multiemployer pension withdrawal liabilities. For
example, a number of employees would be eligible for immediate retirement under special eligibility rules that apply upon a steelmaking facility or mine closure. All
employees eligible for immediate retirement under the pension plans at the time of the permanent closure also could be eligible for OPEB, thereby accelerating our
obligation to provide these benefits. Certain closures would precipitate a pension closure liability significantly greater than an ongoing operation liability and may
trigger certain severance liability obligations. In addition, we are party to several joint ventures relating to iron ore mining, downstream steel processing and scrap
metal recycling, and if our joint venture partners experience financial hardships or fail to perform their obligations upon closure, we may be required to assume
significant additional obligations on behalf of the joint venture, including costs of environmental remediation and pension and OPEB obligations.
We base our assumptions regarding the life of our mines on detailed studies we perform from time to time, but those studies and assumptions are subject
to uncertainties and estimates that may not be accurate. We recognize the costs of reclaiming open pits, stockpiles, tailings ponds, roads and other mining support
areas based on the
31
-- 33 of 411 --
Table of Contents
estimated mining life of our properties. If our assumptions underlying our accruals for closure costs, including reclamation and other environmental costs, prove to
be inaccurate or insufficient, or our liability in any particular year is greater than currently anticipated, our results of operations and financial condition could be
adversely affected. In addition, if we were to significantly reduce the estimated life of any of our mines, the mine closure costs would be applied to a shorter period
of production, which would increase costs per ton produced and could adversely affect our results of operations and financial condition.
We incur certain costs when production capacity is idled, as well as increased costs to resume production at previously idled facilities.
Our decisions concerning which facilities to operate and at what production levels are made based in part upon our customers’ orders for products, as well
as the quality, performance capabilities and cost of our operations. During depressed market conditions, we may concentrate production at certain facilities and not
operate others in response to customer demand, and as a result we may incur idle costs that could offset our anticipated savings from not operating the idled
facility. For example, due to reduced demand arising out of the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, certain of our steelmaking facilities and iron ore mines were
temporarily idled during portions of 2020 and we continued to incur certain fixed costs at those facilities. We cannot predict whether our operations will experience
additional similar or dissimilar disruptions in the future.
When we restart idled facilities, we incur certain costs to replenish inventories, prepare the previously idled facilities for operation, perform the required
repair and maintenance activities, and prepare employees to return to work safely and resume production responsibilities. The amount of any such costs could be
significant, depending on a variety of factors, such as the period of idle time, necessary repairs and available employees, and is difficult to project.
We face ongoing risks relating to our recent mergers and acquisitions activities.
In recent years, we have completed several significant acquisition transactions, including the AK Steel Merger, the AM USA Transaction and the FPT
Acquisition. These recent acquisitions have transformed our business and involve a number of significant risks and uncertainties that may adversely affect us over
the short, medium and long terms, including the following:
• inability to realize anticipated synergies or other expected benefits or cost savings;
• additional debt incurred or assumed in connection with the acquisitions could limit our financial flexibility;
• diversion of financial resources to the new operations or acquired businesses;
• assumption of substantial additional environmental exposures, commitments, contingencies and remediation and reclamation projects;
• liabilities for acquired pension and OPEB obligations, which could require us to make significant cash expenditures and funding contributions in excess of
current estimates and contribution rates;
• impairment of recorded tangible and intangible asset values, including goodwill, could result in material non-cash charges to our results of operations in the
future;
• failure to successfully separate from legacy systems and to integrate acquired systems, business processes, policies and procedures;
• exposure to unknown liabilities and unforeseen costs that were not disclosed to us or discovered during due diligence;
• potential loss of key employees, suppliers or customers; and
• other challenges associated with managing the larger, more complex and integrated combined businesses.
If one or more of these risks and uncertainties were to materialize, we could experience reduced revenues, higher costs, lower profitability and other
adverse impacts to our operations and businesses.
32
-- 34 of 411 --
Table of Contents
We may not have adequate insurance coverage for some business risks.
Our operations are generally subject to a number of hazards and risks that could result in personal injury or damage to, or destruction of, equipment,
properties or facilities. Depending on the nature and extent of a loss, the insurance that we maintain to address risks that are typical in our businesses may not be
adequate or available to fully protect or reimburse us, or our insurance coverage may be limited, canceled or otherwise terminated. Insurance against some risks,
such as liabilities for environmental pollution, tailings basin breaches, or certain hazards or interruption of certain business activities, may not be available at an
economically reasonable cost, or at all. Even if available, we may self-insure where we determine it is most cost effective to do so. As a result, despite the insurance
coverage that we carry, accidents or other negative developments involving our production, mining, processing or transportation activities causing losses in excess
of policy limits, or losses arising from events not covered under insurance policies, could have a material adverse effect on our financial condition and cash flows.
In addition, the potential increase in extreme weather events due to climate change or otherwise may adversely impact our access to cost effective insurance in the
future. The risk of increased insurance costs may have greater impact where the adverse event, such as the tornado we recently experienced at our Tooling and
Stamping operations in Kentucky, results in us asserting an insurance claim, the cost of which our insurers may seek to recoup during a future insurance renewal
through increased premiums or limitations on coverage.
V. SUSTAINABILITY AND DEVELOPMENT RISKS
As our customers, competitors and investors seek to reduce their carbon footprint, transition to carbon neutrality and enhance the
sustainability of their respective businesses, we face increased financial, regulatory, legal and reputational risks and potential loss of business
opportunities because our operations utilize carbon-based energy sources and produce GHG emissions.
As described in detail in Part I - Item 1, Business - Environment - Regulatory Developments - Climate Change and GHG Regulation above, because our
operations use carbon-based energy and produce GHG emissions, we are subject to a number of risks relating to decarbonization initiatives being undertaken by
regulators and other stakeholders as part of global efforts to address the potential impacts of climate change. For example, as part of climate change mitigation
strategies, federal, state or local governmental authorities may introduce mandatory carbon pricing obligations, carbon emissions limitations, carbon taxes or carbon
trading mechanisms, any of which could impose significant costs on our operations, including causing us to incur higher energy costs, invest in costly and
potentially unproven emissions control or reduction technologies, and engage in more intensive environmental monitoring and reporting efforts. In addition,
complying with current or future international treaties and federal, state or local laws or regulations concerning climate change and GHG emissions could negatively
impact our ability, and that of our customers and suppliers, to compete with companies located in areas not subject to or not complying with such constraints. We
may also face more limited access to, or increased costs of, capital to the extent financial institutions and investors increase expectations relating to lowering GHG
emissions or reduce investments in carbon-intensive businesses. Further, increased pressure from customers or other business partners seeking to reduce their
indirect carbon footprints could result in the potential loss of business opportunities if we are unable to meet their carbon, GHG emissions or sustainability
expectations.
In order to maintain consistent operational performance and foster growth in our businesses, we must maintain our social license to operate
with our stakeholders.
Maintaining a strong reputation and consistent operational, environmental and safety track records is vital in order to continue to foster business growth and
maintain our permission to operate. As stakeholders’ sustainability expectations increase and regulatory requirements continue to evolve, maintaining our social
license to operate becomes increasingly important. Our ability to maintain our reputation and strong operating track record could be threatened, including by
challenges relating to the integration of our recent acquisitions or by circumstances outside of our control, such as disasters caused or suffered by other companies
in the steel and mining industries. Our social license to operate could also be adversely affected and claims could be made against us to the extent that
environmental factors negatively impact local communities, such as air emissions, discharges to water, dust, odors, noise and other factors that are inherent in
industrial activities like our steelmaking, cokemaking, scrap metal processing and mining operations, even if such activities are conducted in accordance with legal,
regulatory and permit requirements. If we are not able to respond effectively to these and other challenges to our social license to operate, our reputation could be
damaged significantly. Damage to our reputation could adversely affect our operations, current and prospective business relationships, and ability to foster growth
projects.
33
-- 35 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The cost and time to implement a strategic capital project may prove to be greater than originally anticipated.
From time to time, we undertake strategic capital projects, such as our recently-completed Toledo direct reduction plant, in order to enhance, expand or
upgrade our production, mining and processing capabilities or to diversify our customer base. Our ability to achieve the anticipated production volumes, revenues or
otherwise realize acceptable returns on strategic capital projects that we may undertake is subject to a number of risks, many of which are beyond our control,
including a variety of market (such as a volatile pricing environment for our products), operational, permitting and labor-related factors. Further, the cost to
implement any given strategic capital project ultimately may prove to be greater and may take more time than originally anticipated. Inability to achieve the
anticipated results from the implementation of our strategic capital projects, incurring unanticipated implementation costs or penalties, or the inability to meet
contractual obligations could adversely affect our results of operations and future earnings and cash flow generation.
We rely on estimates of our recoverable mineral reserves, which is complex due to geological characteristics of the properties and the number
of assumptions made.
We regularly evaluate, and engage third-party QPs to review and validate, our mineral reserves based on revenues and costs and update them as required
in accordance with SEC regulations. Estimates of mineral reserves and future net cash flows necessarily depend upon a number of variable factors and
assumptions, some of which are beyond our control, such as production capacity, effects of regulations by governmental agencies, future prices for minerals we
mine, future industry conditions and operating costs, severance and excise taxes, development costs, and costs of extraction and reclamation. Estimating the
quantity and grade of mineral reserves requires us to determine the size, shape and depth of our mineralized bodies by analyzing geological data, such as
samplings of drill holes, and a QP to review and validate our determinations. Estimated mineral reserves could be affected by future industry conditions, future
changes in the SEC’s mining property disclosure requirements, variation in geological conditions and ongoing mine planning. Actual volume and grade of reserves
recovered, production rates, revenues on third-party sales and expenditures with respect to our reserves will likely vary from estimates, and if such variances are
material, our sales and profitability could be adversely affected.
Defects in title or loss of any leasehold interests in our mining properties could limit our ability to mine these properties or result in significant
unanticipated costs.
Many of our operations are conducted on properties we lease, license or as to which we have easements or other possessory interests. We generally do
not maintain title insurance on our properties. A title defect or the loss of any lease, license, easement or other possessory interest for any mining property could
adversely affect our ability to mine any associated reserves. In addition, from time to time the rights of third parties for competing uses of adjacent, overlying or
underlying lands, such as for roads, easements, public facilities or other mining activities, may affect our ability to operate as planned if our title is not superior or
mutually acceptable arrangements cannot be negotiated. Any challenge to our title could delay the exploration and development of some reserves, resources,
deposits or surface rights, cause us to incur unanticipated costs, and could ultimately result in the loss of some or all of our interest in those properties. In the event
we lose reserves, resources, deposits or surface rights, we may be required to shut down or significantly alter impacted mining operations, thereby affecting future
production, revenues and cash flows.
VI. HUMAN CAPITAL RISKS
We may encounter labor shortages for critical operational positions, which could adversely affect our ability to produce our products.
We are predicting a long-term shortage of skilled workers in heavy industry and in certain highly specialized IT roles, and competition for available workers
limits our ability to attract and retain employees as well as engage third-party contractors. As our experienced employees retire and we lose their specialized
institutional knowledge of our legacy businesses and systems, we have encountered challenges and may continue to have difficulty replacing them at competitive
wages. In addition, the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in a number of workers resigning or retiring sooner than would typically be expected, and the
pandemic may continue to result in increased government restrictions and regulation, including quarantines of our personnel and potential inability to access
facilities, which has adversely affected and could continue to adversely affect our operations.
34
-- 36 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Our profitability could be adversely affected if we fail to maintain satisfactory labor relations.
Our production is dependent upon the efforts of our employees. We are party to labor agreements with various labor unions that represent employees at the
majority of our operations. Such labor agreements are negotiated periodically, and, therefore, we are subject to the risk that these agreements may not be able to
be renewed on reasonably satisfactory terms. It is difficult to predict what issues may arise as part of the collective bargaining process, and whether negotiations
concerning these issues will be successful. Due to union activities or other employee actions, we could experience labor disputes, work stoppages or other
disruptions in our production that could affect us adversely. While we successfully negotiated all of our labor agreements that expired in 2021, we have ten labor
agreements that will expire in 2022 and three labor agreements that will expire in 2023, and the outcomes of those labor negotiations are uncertain. If we enter into
a new labor agreement with any union that significantly increases our labor costs relative to our competitors or fail to come to an agreement upon expiry, our ability
to compete or continuity of production may be materially and adversely affected.
We depend on our senior management team and other key employees, and the loss of these employees could adversely affect our businesses.
Our success depends in part on our ability to attract, retain, develop and motivate our senior management and key employees. Achieving this objective
may be difficult due to a variety of factors, including fluctuations in the global economic and industry conditions, competitors’ hiring practices, cost reduction
activities, and the effectiveness of our compensation programs. Competition for qualified personnel can be intense. We must continue to recruit, retain, develop and
motivate our senior management and key personnel in order to maintain our businesses and support our projects. A loss of senior management and key personnel
could prevent us from capitalizing on business opportunities, and our operating results could be adversely affected. We are also subject to the risk that the ongoing
COVID-19 pandemic may impact the health or effectiveness of members of our senior management team or other key employees.
Our expenditures for pension and OPEB obligations could be materially higher than we have predicted if our underlying assumptions differ from
actual outcomes, there are regulatory changes or other contributors fail to perform their obligations that relate to employee pension plans.
We provide defined benefit pension plans and OPEB to certain eligible union and non-union employees. Our pension and OPEB expenses and our
required contributions to our pension and OPEB plans are affected directly by the value of plan assets, the projected and actual rate of return on plan assets, and
the actuarial assumptions we use to measure our defined benefit pension plan obligations, including the rate at which future obligations are discounted. We cannot
predict whether changing market or economic conditions, regulatory changes or other factors will increase our pension and OPEB expenses or our funding
obligations, diverting funds we would otherwise apply to other uses.
We have calculated our unfunded pension and OPEB obligations based on a number of assumptions. If our assumptions do not materialize as expected,
cash expenditures and costs that we incur could be materially higher. Moreover, we cannot be certain that regulatory changes will not increase our obligations to
provide these or additional benefits. These obligations also may increase substantially in the event of adverse medical cost trends or unexpected rates of early
retirement, particularly for bargaining unit retirees. In addition, changes in the laws governing pensions could also materially adversely affect our costs and ability to
meet our pension obligations.
We also contribute to certain multiemployer pension plans, including the Steelworkers’ Pension Trust, for which we are one of the largest contributing
employers. If other contributors were to default on their obligations to contribute to any such plans, we could become liable for additional unfunded contributions to
the plans.
In addition, some of the transactions in which we previously sold or otherwise disposed of our non-core assets included provisions transferring certain
pension and other liabilities to the purchasers or acquirers of those assets. While we believe that all such transfers were completed properly and are legally binding,
if the purchaser fails to fulfill its obligations, we may be at risk that a court, arbitrator or regulatory body could disagree and determine that we remain responsible for
pension and other liabilities that we intended to and did transfer.
Item 1B. Unresolved Staff Comments
We have no unresolved comments from the SEC.
35
-- 37 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Item 2. Properties
The following map shows the locations of our operations and offices as of December 31, 2021:
36
-- 38 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Corporate Offices
We lease our corporate headquarters in Cleveland, Ohio. We also have leased office space in West Chester, Ohio, Chicago, Illinois and Detroit, Michigan.
We own our office space located in Burns Harbor, Indiana and our Research and Innovation Center located in Middletown, Ohio.
Steelmaking
Steelmaking and Finishing Facilities
Below is a listing and description of our principal steelmaking and finishing facilities:
Burns Harbor is a fully integrated steelmaking facility located on Lake Michigan in Northwest Indiana, 50 miles southeast of Chicago. The location allows
for prime shipping access to the Port of Indiana, as well as excellent highway and railroad transport. Burns Harbor’s major production facilities include coke plant
operations, iron producing, steel producing, hot rolling, pickling, cold rolling, annealing, galvanizing, finishing and plate rolling and heat treating. The plant operates
two blast furnaces and is capable of producing hot-rolled sheet, cold-rolled sheet and hot dip galvanized sheet. Burns Harbor is capable of producing nearly 5
million net tons of raw steel annually. Burns Harbor serves key markets including the automotive, appliance, construction, converters, distribution and pipe and tube
markets.
Burns Harbor Plate and Gary Plate are located in Burns Harbor and Gary, Indiana, respectively, and are heat treating and finishing operations producing
carbon steel plate, high-strength low alloy steel plate and ASTM grades steel plate. These operations serve the construction, distribution, energy, heavy equipment,
infrastructure, military, pipe and tube, rail car and shipbuilding markets.
Butler Works is located in Butler, Pennsylvania, and produces stainless, electrical and carbon steel. Melting takes place in an EAF that feeds an argon-
oxygen decarburization unit for the specialty steels. A ladle metallurgy furnace feeds two double-strand continuous casters, which are capable of producing 1
million net tons of raw steel annually. Butler Works also includes a hot rolling mill, annealing and pickling units and one tandem cold rolling mill. It also has various
intermediate and finishing operations for both stainless and electrical steels. Butler Works primarily serves the power and distribution transformers and stainless
and carbon converters markets.
The Cleveland facility is an integrated steelmaking facility strategically located on the Cuyahoga River in Cleveland, Ohio, with access to the Port of
Cleveland and Great Lakes shipping, as well as excellent highway and railroad transport. The Cleveland facility is supplied with coke from our cokemaking
operations in Warren, Ohio. Cleveland's major production facilities include iron making, steel producing, hot rolling, pickle and cold rolling, and hot galvanizing. The
plant is capable of producing more than 3 million net tons of raw steel annually. Products made at this location are hot-rolled, cold-rolled and hot-dipped galvanized
sheet and semi-finished slabs. The Cleveland facility serves the automotive, construction, converters and distribution markets.
Coatesville is a steel plate production facility located in Coatesville, Pennsylvania, about 40 miles west of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and has access to
highways and railroads. The facility produces steel from scrap in an EAF and is capable of producing 0.8 million net tons of raw steel annually. The facility also
operates ingot teeming facilities, a slab caster, two plate mills, heat-treating facilities, quench and temper and flame-cut shape facilities. The Coatesville facility
refines more than 450 different steel chemistries and, together with the Conshohocken facility, produces some of the widest, thickest and heaviest steel plates in
the industry. Steel plate products made at this location include carbon, high-strength low-alloy, commercial alloy, military alloy and flame-cut steel. Coatesville
serves the aircraft and aerospace, construction, distribution, energy, heavy equipment, military, mold and tool and shipbuilding markets.
Our Columbus operations include a hot-dip galvanizing facility in Columbus, Ohio, and a processing facility in nearby Obetz, Ohio. These operations were
temporarily idled due to the COVID-19 pandemic and restarted during the second quarter of 2021. These central Ohio locations are able to utilize highway and rail
transport shipping access. Two zinc pots enable the transition between coatings to be accomplished in a timely manner while allowing for longer exposed runs.
The plant produces hot-dip galvanized sheet using cold-rolled coils supplied by other Cliffs facilities and is capable of coating 450,000 net tons annually. The
Columbus operations serve the automotive and distribution markets.
Conshohocken is a plate finishing facility located on the Schuylkill River adjacent to Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The area is surrounded by highway and
railroad systems that provide shipping access. Coatesville and Burns Harbor supply steel plates to the Conshohocken plant, which operates heat treat, finishing and
inspection
37
-- 39 of 411 --
Table of Contents
facilities for steel plate finishing. The Conshohocken plant has a steckel mill that is currently idled, which is capable of producing coil and discrete plates.
Conshohocken plate products are used in construction and military applications.
Coshocton Works is located in Coshocton, Ohio, and consists of a stainless steel finishing plant containing two Sendzimer mills and two Z-high mills for
cold reduction, four annealing and pickling lines, bell annealing furnaces, two bright annealing lines, two temper mills, and other processing equipment, including
temper rolling, slitting and a packaging line. Coshocton Works produces various flat-rolled stainless steel products including austenitic (chrome nickel) stainless
steel grades, martensitic (chrome) stainless steel grades and ferritic (chrome) stainless steel grades, serving the automotive, appliance, distribution and medical
markets among others.
Dearborn Works is an integrated steelmaking facility located in Dearborn, Michigan. The facility is strategically located in close proximity to the automotive
center of Michigan with access to highway, railroad and waterway transport. Dearborn's major production facilities include iron making, steel producing, a pickling
line tandem cold mill and a hot-dipped galvanizing line. Dearborn Works is capable of producing 3 million net tons of raw steel annually. Products made at this
location include carbon slabs, cold-rolled, and hot-dip galvanized and galvannealed sheet. Dearborn Works serves the automotive, HVAC, converters and
distribution markets. During 2020, the Dearborn Works hot strip mill, anneal and temper operations were permanently idled as part of our cost reduction efforts.
Indiana Harbor is one of the largest integrated steelmaking facilities in North America and is located in East Chicago, Indiana, just 20 miles southeast of
Chicago, Illinois. The major production facilities include iron making, a recycle plant, steel producing, hot rolling, cold rolling, annealing, and hot dip galvanizing
lines. Indiana Harbor is currently capable of producing 5.5 million net tons of raw steel annually. Indiana Harbor is a leader in North American development of new
automotive products and is a primary supplier of coils to Kote and Tek. Indiana Harbor serves the automotive, appliance, contractor applications, distribution, steel
producers, strip converters and tubular markets.
The Kote and Tek operations are located in New Carlisle, Indiana, and receive substantially all of their feedstock from Indiana Harbor via daily unit trains.
Kote has separate lines producing 0.5 million net tons of hot-dip galvanized and galvannealed and 0.5 million net tons of electrogalvanized sheet annually. Tek is a
continuous cold-rolling plant that is capable of producing 1.7 million net tons of sheet steel annually through a continuous descale cold mill and 1.0 million net tons
of sheet steel annually through a continuous annealing processing line. The principal customers of Kote and Tek are in the automotive and appliance markets.
Mansfield Works is located in Mansfield, Ohio, and produces high chrome ferritics and martensitic stainless steels and semi-finished hot bands. The major
production facilities include a melt shop with two EAFs, an argon oxygen decarburization unit, a ladle metallurgy facility, a thin slab continuous caster, a walking
beam slab furnace and a hot rolling mill. The thin slab caster uses an advanced technology production system to meet customer specifications. Mansfield Works is
capable of producing 0.6 million net tons of raw steel annually. Mansfield Works serves the automotive and appliance for stainless products markets.
Middletown Works is an integrated steel operation located in Middletown, Ohio, just 30 miles north of Cincinnati, Ohio with access to railroad and highway
transport. The major production facilities include a coke facility, iron making and steel producing, which is capable of producing nearly 3 million net tons of raw steel
annually. Middletown Works facilities also include hot rolling, pickling, cold rolling, electrogalvanizing, hot dip carbon and stainless aluminizing, hot dip galvanizing,
annealing, and finishing facilities. We temporarily idled the coke facility during the third quarter of 2021, as a result of our HBI use in our blast furnaces. Products
made at this location include hot-rolled and cold-rolled carbon steels, electrogalvanized steels, hot-dip galvanized products and aluminized carbon and stainless
steel sheets. Middletown Works serves the automotive, appliance, HVAC, culvert and distribution markets.
Piedmont is a finishing facility located in Newton, North Carolina, 50 miles northwest of Charlotte. The facility specializes in plasma cutting plate steel
products into blanks for machinery and automotive manufacturers and primarily serves the truck axle blank business. Additionally, it provides services such as part
leveling and just-in-time deliveries.
Riverdale is a compact strip mill that produces hot-rolled sheet located in Illinois, 14 miles west of our Indiana Harbor facility. The location allows for close
shipping access to Lake Michigan and is surrounded by highway and railroad systems. The Riverdale facility operates two BOFs, a ladle metallurgy facility,
continuous thin slab caster, tunnel furnace and hot strip mill, which are capable of producing 1 million net tons of thin-slab casting and rolling annually. The light
gauge capabilities and tight gauge tolerances are desired characteristics for line pipe and structural and mechanical tubing producers. Principal products made at
this plant include hot-rolled black bands in a
38
-- 40 of 411 --
Table of Contents
full range of grades, including high carbon and alloy. The Riverdale facility primarily serves cold-rolled strip producers who supply the automotive, saw blade and
strapping markets.
Rockport Works is located near the Ohio River in southwest Indiana near Rockport, Indiana. Rockport Works consists of a carbon and stainless steel
finishing plant containing a continuous cold rolling mill, a continuous hot-dip galvanizing and galvannealing line, a continuous carbon and stainless steel pickling
line, a continuous stainless steel annealing and pickling line, hydrogen annealing facilities and a temper mill. Utilizing innovative manufacturing technologies, the
plant incorporates automated guidance vehicles and automated cranes to move the steel through the various finishing operations. Steel produced at Rockport
Works includes a full range of cold-rolled carbon, coated and stainless steels in either the annealed and pickled or temper rolled surface condition. Product
offerings include a wide variety of AHSS. The Rockport Works hot-dip galvanizing and galvannealing line incorporates revolutionary proprietary technologies,
including induction transition heating, which provides rapid, accurate annealing temperature control. In addition, the Rockport Works line produces 80-inch sheet
steel. Rockport Works serves the automotive, appliance, HVAC and distribution for carbon and stainless markets.
Steelton is one of only three rail producers in North and South America and is located in Steelton, Pennsylvania, about 100 miles west of Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania. Steelton consists of a 150 net ton direct current EAF with ladle refining and vacuum degassing, a three-strand continuous jumbo bloom caster and
an ingot teeming facility. Steelton has an annual steelmaking capacity of 1 million net tons. Steelton produces railroad rails, specialty blooms, cast ingots and flat
bars for use in railroad and forging markets.
Our Weirton facility is a tinplate facility located on the northern panhandle of West Virginia along the Ohio River in the city of Weirton, West Virginia. The
location provides shipping access along the Ohio River, as well as highway and railroad shipping. Products made at this location include cold-rolled and tinplate
products serving the distribution and packaging markets.
Zanesville Works is located on the Muskingum River in Zanesville, Ohio. The finishing facility's products include regular GOES and cold-rolled NOES.
These specialty flat-rolled steels enable customers to create a variety of products, including generators, transformers and a host of other electrical devices.
Zanesville Works primarily serves the power and distribution transformers markets.
In the aggregate, we have annual production capacity of approximately 23 million net tons of raw steel. Our steelmaking facilities produced a total of
18 million net tons of raw steel during the year ended December 31, 2021. Due to the timing of the 2020 Acquisitions and the idling of facilities in response to
impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, our steelmaking facilities produced a total of 4 million net tons of raw steel during the year ended December 31, 2020.
Scrap Processing Facilities
Our scrap business consists of our subsidiary FPT, which has 22 locations in Michigan, Ohio, Tennessee, Florida and Ontario. These facilities are primarily
located in Michigan and Ohio, which are in close proximity to our scrap consuming steel facilities. FPT processes approximately 3 million net tons of scrap metal
annually, of which approximately 50% of total output is prime grade.
Direct Reduction Plant
Our direct reduction plant is located in Toledo, Ohio, and is near an existing dock, has rail access and heavy haul roads for operation logistics. We are
leasing the property on which the plant is located. Our Toledo direct reduction plant, which began production in the fourth quarter of 2020, produces a specialized
high quality iron alternative to scrap and pig iron. The Toledo direct reduction plant has annual capacity of 1.9 million metric tons of HBI per year, and we reached
full nameplate capacity in 2021.
Iron Ore Mines and Pellet Plants
The following information concerning our mining properties has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K,
which first became applicable to us for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2021. These requirements differ significantly from the previously applicable disclosure
requirements of SEC Industry Guide 7. Among other differences, subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K requires us to disclose our mineral resources, in addition to our
mineral reserves, as of the end of our most recently completed fiscal year both in the aggregate and for each of our individually material mining properties.
39
-- 41 of 411 --
Table of Contents
As used in this Annual Report on Form 10-K, the terms “mineral resource,” “measured mineral resource,” “indicated mineral resource,” “inferred mineral
resource,” “mineral reserve,” “proven mineral reserve” and “probable mineral reserve” are defined and used in accordance with subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K.
Under subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K, mineral resources may not be classified as “mineral reserves” unless the determination has been made by a QP that the
mineral resources can be the basis of an economically viable project. You are specifically cautioned not to assume that any part or all of the mineral deposits
(including any mineral resources) in these categories will ever be converted into mineral reserves, as defined by the SEC.
You are cautioned that, except for that portion of mineral resources classified as mineral reserves, mineral resources do not have demonstrated economic
value. Estimates of inferred mineral resources have too high of a degree of uncertainty as to their existence and may not be converted to a mineral reserve.
Therefore, you are cautioned not to assume that all or any part of an inferred mineral resource exists, that it can be the basis of an economically viable project, or
that it will ever be upgraded to a higher category. Likewise, you are cautioned not to assume that all or any part of measured or indicated mineral resources will
ever be converted to mineral reserves.
See Part I – Item 1A, Risk Factors – V. Sustainability and Development Risks - We rely on estimates of our recoverable mineral reserves, which estimation
is complex due to geological characteristics of the properties and the number of assumptions made.
The information that follows relating to the Hibbing, Minorca, Northshore, Tilden and United Taconite iron ore mines is derived, for the most part, from, and
in some instances is an extract from, the Technical Report Summaries relating to such properties prepared in compliance with Item 601(b)(96) and subpart 1300 of
Regulation S-K. Portions of the following information are based on assumptions, qualifications and procedures that are not fully described herein. Reference should
be made to the full text of the Technical Report Summaries, which are filed as Exhibits 96.1 through 96.5 to this Annual Report on Form 10-K and are incorporated
by reference herein.
All of our iron ore mining operations are open-pit mines. Additional development is underway as required by long-range mine plans. Drilling programs are
conducted periodically to collect geologic modeling data and for refining ongoing operations.
Geologic models are developed for all mines to define the major ore and waste rock types. Computerized block models for iron ore are constructed that
include all relevant geologic and metallurgical data. These are used to generate grade and tonnage estimates, followed by detailed mine design and LoM operating
schedules.
We currently own or co-own and operate five production-stage iron ore mines in Michigan and Minnesota, as well as one indefinitely idled mine in Michigan.
Following the AM USA Transaction, we now have an aggregate annual production capacity of approximately 28 million long tons of iron ore pellets, including our
85.3% share of the Hibbing mine production. Historically, our share of production capacity was approximately 21 million long tons of iron ore pellets annually. Our
iron ore mines produce from deposits located within the Biwabik and Negaunee Iron Formation, which are classified as Lake Superior type iron formations that
formed under similar sedimentary conditions in shallow marine basins approximately two billion years ago. Magnetite and hematite are the predominant iron oxide
ore minerals present, with lesser amounts of goethite and limonite. Quartz is the predominant waste mineral present, with lesser amounts of other chiefly iron
bearing silicate and carbonate minerals. The ore minerals liberate from the waste minerals upon fine grinding.
The following represents iron ore production for the last three fiscal years:
Iron Ore Production
(In Millions of Long Tons)
2021 2020 2019
Hibbing 7 2
Minorca 3 —
Northshore 5 4
Tilden 7 6
United Taconite 5 5
Total 27 17
Tonnage shown is reflective of ownership percentage during respective periods.
As announced in February 2022, it is anticipated that the Northshore mine will be temporarily idled for approximately four months during 2022.
1
1
2
1
2
40
-- 42 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following provides an overview of our iron ore properties:
All the infrastructure necessary to mine and process significant commercial quantities of iron ore is currently in place at all of our mine locations.
Infrastructure items include high voltage electrical supplies, natural gas pipelines that connect to the North American distribution system, water sources, paved
roads and highways, railroads for transporting crude ore and finished products, port facilities that connect to the Great Lakes, and accommodations for employees.
Local and state infrastructure also includes hospitals, schools, airports, equipment suppliers, fuel suppliers, commercial laboratories, and communication systems.
Labor is readily available with major population centers within 25 miles of all of our properties.
All of our iron ore mining operations grant leases, licenses, and easements for various purposes, including miscellaneous community land uses, utility
infrastructure, and other third-party uses, that encumber our properties but do not materially inhibit operations. Certain assets also serve as collateral securing
obligations under our ABL Facility and our senior secured notes. We maintain the requisite state and federal permits and are in material compliance with all material
permits.
41
-- 43 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Property (Cliffs
Ownership) Location Surface Rights & Mineral Leases Facilities & Condition History
Book Value of
Long- Lived
Assets (In
Millions)
Hibbing
(85.3%)
The property is located immediately north of
the city of Hibbing, MN in the center of
Minnesota’s Mesabi Iron Range. The mining
and processing operation is located between
latitude 47°25’48” N and 47°31’48” N and
longitude 93°04’54” W and 92°54’36” W.
Hibbing holds 30,670 acres of surface rights,
of which 1,150 acres are associated with
mineral leases.The majority of the mineral
rights are leased. The property is comprised
of 6,640 acres of mineral leases expiring
between 2022 and 2056. Leases are
maintained by making minimum prepaid
royalty payments. Mining leases routinely are
renegotiated and renewed as they approach
their respective expiration dates.
Open pit truck and shovel mine, a
concentrator that utilizes single stage
crushing, AG mills and magnetic separation
to produce a magnetite concentrate, which is
then delivered to an on-site pellet plant.
From the site, pellets are transported by
BNSF rail to a ship loading port at Superior,
Wisconsin, operated by BNSF.
Mining began in 1976 as a joint venture
between Bethlehem Steel Corporation and
Steel Company of Canada. Cliffs first
became involved in the joint venture when it
purchased Pickands Mather's 15% share in
1986. Prior to the AM USA Transaction, we
owned 23% of Hibbing, ArcelorMittal USA
had a 62.3% interest and U.S. Steel had a
14.7% interest. On December 9, 2020, as a
result of the AM USA Transaction, we
acquired an additional 62.3% ownership
stake in the Hibbing mine and became the
majority owner and mine manager.
$199
For more information, see Exhibit 96.1, the Technical Report Summary on the Hibbing Taconite Property, Minnesota, USA, prepared for the Company by
the QP, SLR with an effective date of December 31, 2021.
42
-- 44 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Property (Cliffs
Ownership) Location Surface Rights & Mineral Leases Facilities & Condition History
Book Value of
Long- Lived
Assets (In
Millions)
Minorca
(100.0%)
The property is located in the center of
Minnesota’s Mesabi Iron Range. The
Laurentian Pit is located near the City of
Gilbert, MN at latitude 47°30'0"N and
longitude 92°26’30"W, East 1 Pit is located at
latitude 47°31'30"N and longitude
92°23’30"W, and East 2 Pit is located just
west of the City of Biwabik at latitude
47°32'0"N and longitude 92°22’30"W. The
Minorca plant is located approximately seven
miles to the northeast, near the town of
Virginia, MN at latitude 47°33'30"N and
longitude 92°31.5'30"W.
Minorca holds 13,690 acres of surface
rights, of which 282 acres are associated
with mineral leases.100% of the mineral
rights are leased. The property is comprised
of 3,135 acres of mineral leases expiring
between 2035 and 2056. Leases are
maintained by making minimum prepaid
royalty payments. Mining leases routinely
are renegotiated and renewed as they
approach their respective expiration dates.
This operation includes a concentrating and
pelletizing facility, along with two open pit iron
ore mines located approximately seven miles
from the processing facilities. The processing
operations consist of a crushing facility, a
three-line concentration facility and a single-
line straight grate pelletizing plant. Pellets are
transported by CN rail to ports on Lake
Superior.
Commenced operations in 1976 as an asset
of Inland Steel Company. In 1998, Ispat
International purchased Inland Steel and, in
2004, merged with LNM Holdings and
International Steel Group to form Mittal Steel,
which in 2007 merged with Arcelor to form
ArcelorMittal. Minorca has been wholly
owned by Cliffs since 2020 with the AM USA
Transaction.
$231
For more information, see Exhibit 96.2, Technical Report Summary on the Minorca Property, Minnesota, USA, prepared for the Company by the QP, SLR
with an effective date of December 31, 2021.
43
-- 45 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Property (Cliffs
Ownership) Location Surface Rights & Mineral Leases Facilities & Condition History
Book Value of
Long- Lived
Assets (In
Millions)
Northshore
(100.0%)
The mine is located on the northeastern edge
of the Mesabi Iron Range in northeastern
Minnesota, approximately four miles
southeast of Babbitt, MN at latitude
47°40'12.15"N and longitude 91°53'1.28"W.
The processing facility is approximately forty
one miles to the southeast and immediately
adjacent to the city of Silver Bay in Lake
County, MN at latitude 47°17'38.95"N and
longitude 91°15'23.38"W.
Northshore holds 28,041 acres of surface
rights, of which 8,966 acres are associated
with mineral leases. 100% of the mineral
rights are leased. The property is comprised
of 10,356 acres of mineral leases. Some
leases do not expire until the mineral
reserves are exhausted while others expire
between 2034 and 2075. Leases are
maintained by making minimum prepaid
royalty payments. Mining leases routinely
are renegotiated and renewed as they
approach their respective expiration dates.
Open pit truck and shovel mine where two
stages of crushing occur before the ore is
transported along a wholly owned 47-mile
rail line to the plant site in Silver Bay. At the
plant site, two additional stages of crushing
occur before the ore is sent to the
concentrator. The concentrator utilizes rod
mills and magnetic separation to produce a
magnetite concentrate, which is delivered to
the pellet plant located on-site. The plant
can produce both standard and DR-grade
pellets. The plant site has its own ship
loading port located on Lake Superior.
Operations commenced in 1952 as an asset
of the Reserve Mining Company and
continued production until 1986 when
Reserve Mining declared bankruptcy. Cyprus
Minerals Company purchased the facilities in
1989. Cyprus subsequently sold the facilities
to Cliffs in 1994. $246
For more information, see Exhibit 96.3, Technical Report Summary on the Northshore Property, Minnesota, USA, prepared for the Company by the QP,
SLR with an effective date of December 31, 2021.
44
-- 46 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Property (Cliffs
Ownership) Location Surface Rights & Mineral Leases Facilities & Condition History
Book Value of
Long- Lived
Assets (In
Millions)
Tilden
(100.0%)
The property is located in Marquette County in
Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, on the
Marquette Iron Range, approximately five
miles south of the city of Ishpeming, MI at
latitude 46° 29' N and longitude 87° 40' W.
Tilden holds 21,100 acres of surface rights
and leases 2,470 acres of mineral rights
expiring between 2061 and 2070. Leases
are maintained by making minimum prepaid
royalty payments. Mining leases routinely
are renegotiated and renewed as they
approach their respective expiration dates.
Open pit truck and shovel mine, a
concentrator that utilizes single stage
crushing, AG mills, and floatation to produce
hematite concentrates that are then supplied
to the on-site pellet plant. From the site,
pellets are transported by our LS&I rail to a
ship loading port at Marquette, Michigan,
operated by LS&I.
The property commenced operations in 1974
under a partnership of Algoma Steel, Stelco,
J&L Steel, Wheeling-Pittsburgh Steel,
Sharon Steel, and Cleveland-Cliffs Iron
Company. The property has since been at
least partially in the possession of a
subsidiary of Cliffs. In 2001, Cliffs acquired
Algoma Steel's 45% interest in Tilden. In
2017, Cliffs became the sole owner of Tilden.
$219
For more information, see Exhibit 96.5, Technical Report Summary on the Tilden Property, Michigan, USA, prepared for the Company by the QP, SLR with
an effective date of December 31, 2021.
45
-- 47 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Property (Cliffs
Ownership) Location Surface Rights & Mineral Leases Facilities & Condition History
Book Value of
Long- Lived
Assets (In
Millions)
United Taconite
(100%)
The mine and offices are located on
Minnesota's Mesabi Iron Range just north of
Eveleth, MN at latitude 47°29'1.62" N,
longitude 92°32'23.69" W. The processing
facilities are located approximately eight miles
to the southeast.
United Taconite owns 14,199 acres of
surface rights, of which 703 acres are
associated with mineral leases. An
additional 145 acres of surface rights are
leased from the State of Minnesota., We
lease 100% of the mineral rights comprising
of 4,908 acres expiring between 2037 and
2066, with the exception of the State of
Minnesota mineral lease, which expires in
2027. Leases are maintained by making
minimum prepaid royalty payments. Mining
leases routinely are renegotiated and
renewed as they approach their respective
expiration dates.
Open pit truck and shovel mine where two
stages of crushing occur before the ore is
transported by rail, operated by CN, to the
plant site. At the plant site an additional
stage of crushing occurs before the ore is
sent to the concentrator. The concentrator
utilizes rod mills and magnetic separation to
produce a magnetite concentrate, which is
delivered to the on-site pellet plant. From the
plant site, pellets are transported by CN rail
to a ship loading port at Duluth, MN,
operated by CN.
The property commenced operations as an
asset of Eveleth Taconite Company in 1965
before it was purchased by United Taconite
(70% Cliffs and 30% Laiwu Steel) in
December 2003. The Property has been a
wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs since 2008.
$567
For more information, see Exhibit 96.4, Technical Report Summary on the United Taconite Property, Minnesota, USA, prepared for the Company by the
QP, SLR with an effective date of December 31, 2021.
46
-- 48 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Mineral Resources
Mineral resources are defined under Item 1300 of Regulation S-K as a concentration or occurrence of material of economic interest in or on the Earth’s
crust in such form, grade or quality, and quantity that there are reasonable prospects for economic extraction. A mineral resource is a reasonable estimate of
mineralization, taking into account relevant factors such as cut-off grade, likely mining dimensions, location or continuity, that, with the assumed justifiable technical
and economic conditions, is likely to, in whole or part, become economically extractable.
A detailed breakdown of the mineral resources exclusive of mineral reserves is presented in the table below. Mineral resources were defined and
constrained within open-pit shells, prepared by Cliffs, and based on a US$90.00/WLT pellet price, while meeting defined cut-off grade criteria and existing pellet
specifications. All mineral resource estimates were reviewed and validated by the QP, SLR.
The following represents iron ore mineral resources, exclusive of mineral reserves, as of December 31, 2021:
Iron Ore Mineral Resources
as of December 31, 2021
(In Millions of Long Tons)
Measured Indicated Measured + Indicated Process Inferred
Tonnage % Grade Tonnage % Grade Tonnage % Grade Recovery Tonnage % Grade
Total Iron Ore 1,351 22.5 1,483 23.6 2,834 23.1 31% 420 32.4
Michigan — — 135 35.5 135 35.5 36% 350 34.7
Minnesota 1,351 22.5 1,348 22.4 2,699 22.4 31% 70 21.0
Hibbing 8 19.2 1 18.7 9 19.2 25% — —
Minorca 484 22.9 317 22.9 801 22.9 33% 30 21.1
Northshore 767 22.1 391 22.4 1,158 22.2 26% 14 19.8
Tilden — — 135 35.5 135 35.5 36% 350 34.7
United Taconite 92 23.6 639 22.2 731 22.4 32% 26 21.5
Hibbing is reported at 85.3% based on our ownership level.
Reference point selected is the saleable tons based on the process recovery.
Process recovery may change based on the required saleable product mix and is reported as wet product percentage.
Mineral resources are estimated using the following cut-off grades: 25% FeT for Tilden hematite; 15% magnetic Fe for Northshore; 16% magnetic Fe for Minorca; 17% magnetic Fe for
United Taconite; and 13% magnetic Fe for Hibbing.
Tonnage is reported in long tons equivalent to 2,240 pounds and has been rounded to the nearest 100,000.
Mineral resources are reported at a $90.00/LT wet standard pellet price freight-on-board (FOB) Lake Superior, which is based on the mine planning model's three-year trailing average of the
realized product revenue rate.
Our mineral resource estimates have not been previously disclosed. The material assumptions and criteria used for the mineral resource estimates,
including but not limited to leases, permits and geotechnical pit design, are covered in more detail in Sections 11 through 13 of the respective Technical Report
Summaries filed as Exhibits 96.1 through 96.5 to this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
Mineral Reserves
Mineral reserves are defined under Item 1300 of Regulation S-K as an estimate of tonnage and grade or quality of indicated and measured mineral
resources that, in the opinion of the QP, can be the basis of an economically viable project. More specifically, it is the economically mineable part of a measured or
indicated mineral resource, which includes diluting materials and allowances for losses that may occur when the material is mined or extracted.
Proven mineral reserves are defined under Item 1300 of Regulation S-K as the economically mineable part of a measured mineral resource and can only
result from conversion of a measured mineral resource. Probable mineral reserves are defined under Item 1300 of Regulation S-K as the economically mineable
part of an indicated and, in some cases, a measured mineral resource. All mineral reserves are classified as proven or probable and are supported by LoM plans.
1
1
47
-- 49 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Mineral reserves are based on pricing that does not exceed the three-year trailing average index price of iron pellets adjusted to realized price. We
evaluate and analyze, and engage QPs to review and verify mineral reserves in accordance with our mineral policy and SEC requirements and then complete
updated LoM plans. The table below identifies the year in which the latest updated LoM plan was completed.
Mineral reserves estimates for our iron mines are constrained by fully designed open pits developed using three-dimensional modeling techniques. These
open pits incorporate design slopes, practical mining shapes and access ramps to assure the accuracy of our mineral reserve estimates. All operations' mineral
reserves have been adjusted net of production through year-end 2021. All mineral reserve estimates as of December 31, 2021 were reviewed and validated by the
QP, SLR.
The following represents iron ore mineral reserves as of December 31, 2021:
Iron Ore Mineral Reserves
as of December 31, 2021
(In Millions of Long Tons)
Last LoM Plan Proven Probable Proven & Probable Process
Reserve Analysis Tonnage % Grade Tonnage % Grade Tonnage % Grade Recovery
Total Iron Ore 638 23.6 1,682 26.6 2,320 25.8 33%
Michigan 4 35.3 516 34.7 520 34.7 37%
Minnesota 634 23.5 1,166 23.0 1,800 23.2 31%
Hibbing 2021 85 18.7 8 18.7 93 18.7 25%
Minorca 2021 103 23.6 7 25.3 110 23.7 34%
Northshore 2020 303 25.3 519 24.1 822 24.6 29%
Tilden 2021 4 35.3 516 34.7 520 34.7 37%
United Taconite 2019 143 23.1 632 22.1 775 22.3 33%
Hibbing is reported at 85.3% based on our ownership level.
Reference point selected by the QP is the saleable tons based on the process recovery.
Process recovery may change based on the required saleable product mix and is reported as wet product percentage.
Mineral reserves are estimated using the following cut-off grades: 25% FeT for Tilden hematite; 19% magnetic Fe for Northshore; 16% magnetic Fe for Minorca; 17% magnetic Fe for
United Taconite; and 13% magnetic Fe for Hibbing.
Tonnage is reported in long tons equivalent to 2,240 pounds and has been rounded to the nearest 100,000.
Mineral reserves are classified as probable if not scheduled within the first 20 years.
Mineral reserves are reported at a $90.00/LT wet standard pellet price freight-on-board (FOB) Lake Superior, which is based on the mine planning model's three-year trailing average of
the realized product revenue rate.
The material assumptions and criteria used for the mineral reserves estimates, including but not limited to leases, permits and geotechnical pit design, are
covered in more detail in Sections 11 through 13 of the respective Technical Report Summaries filed as Exhibits 96.1 through 96.5 to this Annual Report on Form
10-K.
1
1
48
-- 50 of 411 --
Table of Contents
For comparison purposes, the following represents iron ore mineral reserves as of December 31, 2020:
Iron Ore Mineral Reserves
as of December 31, 2020
(In Millions of Long Tons)
Proven Probable Proven & Probable Process
Tonnage
%
Grade Tonnage
%
Grade Tonnage
%
Grade Recovery
Total Iron Ore 822 26.2 1,596 26.0 2,418 26.0 31%
Michigan 168 35.2 418 34.8 586 34.8 34%
Minnesota 654 23.9 1,178 23.0 1,832 23.3 30%
Hibbing 65 19.7 21 19.6 86 19.7 27%
Minorca 113 23.6 7 25.3 120 23.7 31%
Northshore 318 25.3 519 24.1 837 24.6 29%
Tilden 168 35.2 418 34.8 586 34.8 34%
United Taconite 158 23.1 631 22.1 789 22.3 31%
Hibbing is reported at 85.3% based on our ownership level.
Reference point selected was the saleable tons based on the process recovery.
Process recovery may change based on the required saleable product mix and is reported as wet product percentage.
Mineral reserves are estimated using the following cut-off grades: 25% FeT for Tilden hematite; 19% magnetic Fe for Northshore; 16% magnetic Fe for Minorca; 17% magnetic Fe for United
Taconite; and 15% magnetic Fe for Hibbing.
Tonnage is reported in long tons equivalent to 2,240 pounds and has been rounded to the nearest 100,000.
Mineral Reserves are classified as probable if not scheduled within the first 20 years.
Mineral Reserves are reported at a $90.00/LT wet standard pellet price freight-on-board (FOB) Lake Superior, which is based on the mine planning model's three-year trailing average of the
realized product revenue rate.
Overall, as compared to the mineral reserve estimates as of December 31, 2020, mineral reserves estimates as of December 31, 2021 decreased by 4%,
which was driven by mining depletion. The mineral reserves of Minorca, Northshore and United Taconite as of December 31, 2021 have decreased mainly due to
depletion through mining, the mineral reserves for Tilden as of December 31, 2021 have decreased primarily due to the mine plan changes, and the mineral
reserves for Hibbing as of December 31, 2021 have increased primarily due to the mine plan changes.
Internal Controls Disclosure
We demonstrated repeated attainment of annual production and quality targets for at least 40 years at each material iron ore mine operated by the
Company. Internal controls the Company uses in its industry-standard approach to exploration and mineral resource and reserve estimation efforts are governed by
its Mineral Reserve and Mineral Resource Estimation Policy and are detailed in Cliffs’ minimum operating standards for Resource Estimation and Strategic Mine
Planning. The controls include: confirmation of drill collar locations and drill hole traces, drill logging and sample collection and security, database verification and
security, QA/QC programs, internal and third-party QP statistical analysis, third-party QP model validation, and reconciliation. Modeling and analysis of the
Company’s resources has been developed by Company personnel or third-party consultant SLR and reviewed by internal management and the external
independent QP, SLR. Reserve estimations have been completed by Company personnel and reviewed by internal management and the QP, SLR.
Drill hole collar surveying methods have evolved with advancements in technology, moving from optical methods to global positioning system, which is
currently in use. For the deposit type, all survey methods used for the collar locations are expected to provide adequate accuracy for the drill hole locations. Due to
the relatively shallow depth and vertical nature of drill holes at Cliffs’ Minnesota mining operations, downhole deviation surveys are typically not conducted. Drill
holes pierce the generally shallow-dipping, tabular iron formation at near perpendicular angles. At the more geologically and structurally complex Tilden mine in
Michigan, where drilling deeper than 500 feet is required, downhole surveys have moved from a clay-impression procedure to the gyroscopic method currently in
use.
Drill core is transported directly from the drill rig to each site’s core logging facility by either the drilling contractor or Cliffs’ personnel. Temporary core
storage is located at each site’s secure logging facility. Depending on the mining operation, unused sample reserves, parts, concentrates, and splits are securely
stored in labeled boxes or barrels at a Cliffs laboratory facility or logging facility, or via a contracted external laboratory.
1
1
49
-- 51 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Cliffs QA/QC programs are site-specific and range from in-development to well-developed, long standing protocols that involve formal procedures for the
use of crude material standards developed from on-site material, as well as regularly inserted coarse and concentrate duplicate samples, control chart analysis, and
reporting. Cliffs typically uses internal and external labs for geometallurgical analyses that are accredited with ASQ/ANSI ISO-9001:2015 for their system of quality
management. Quality sample results are monitored and enacted on where warranted. Also, Cliffs has implemented a drill campaign reporting practice to ensure
results are documented, with defined and illustrated failure metrics, outcomes of investigations, comparisons with previous year’s results, and recommendations.
The QP, SLR reviewed Cliffs QA/QC practices and provided recommendations for further work. Where QA/QC programs are still in development and prior to
resource estimation, Cliffs conducted data verification studies utilizing a suite of blind crude ore standards, and blind duplicates from historical sample reserves
within the LoM plan. Where unaccredited labs provided data used in resource estimation, check lab studies were initiated to verify analytical results. Cliffs is
currently working towards aligning QA/QC protocols at each mine to the Company’s current best practice.
Cliffs maintains exploration drill hole data in an externally-managed, access-controlled acQuire database that is backed up online at regularly scheduled
intervals to provide data redundancy and security. Certification of database integrity is accomplished by both visual and statistical inspections comparing geology,
assay values, and survey locations cross-referenced back to laboratory data and geologic logs. Any discrepancies identified are corrected by referring to hard-copy
assay and core log information archived in Cliffs' Mine Engineering department file cabinets. Prior to modeling, a secondary validation check is completed using
built-in data validation routines in the modeling software.
Cliffs performs routine drill hole database verification with every new drilling program and new block model build, including: check of unique drill hole IDs
and collar coordinates; check of assay or lithology points extending past the specified maximum depth of drill hole; check of abnormal dips and azimuths of
downhole drill hole surveys; check of negative, overlapping, and missing intervals; and check of incorrect lithologic codes and assay values.
In 2020 and 2021, Cliffs geologists completed data verification exercises within the LoM plan area for each mining operation. This was audited by the QP,
SLR to assess accuracy and completeness. Database values were checked against source documents including collar surveys, geologic logs, and assay
certificates. Data verification included collar coordinates, depth intervals of geologic units and assay samples, and results of geometallurgical analyses applied to
mineral resource estimation and mine planning.
Cliffs’ mineral resource estimates were validated by the QP, SLR using standard industry techniques including statistical comparisons with composite
samples and parallel nearest neighbor estimates, swath plots, as well as visual reviews in cross-section and plan. A visual review comparing blocks to drill holes for
key economic variables, completed after the block modeling work, was performed to ensure general lithologic and analytical conformance. Cliffs’ mining operations
have demonstrated good agreement between planned and actual product produced over more than 40 years for each operation.
Cliffs classifies the mineral resources based primarily on drill hole spacing and influenced by geologic continuity, ranges of economic criteria, and
reconciliation. Some post-processing is undertaken to ensure spatial consistency and remove isolated and fringe blocks. The resource area for each operation is
limited by a polygon and subsequent pit shell based on practical mining limits. To ensure that all mineral resource statements satisfy the “reasonable prospects for
economic extraction” requirement, in the definition of the mineral resources under Item 1300 of Regulation S-K, factors significant to technical feasibility and
potential economic viability are considered (e.g., ability to obtain permits, and legal and land tenure considerations). Mineral resources are defined and constrained
within optimized, open-pit shells, prepared by Cliffs and reviewed by the QP, SLR and based on a US$90.00/WLT pellet value and target pellet iron content.
Grade and tonnage reconciliations are run on current production versus modeled production, which provides insight on the accuracy of the modeled assay
data versus actual production for each mining operation.
For a discussion of comprehensive risk inherent in the estimation of mineral reserves, see Part I - Item 1A, Risk Factors - V. Sustainability and
Development Risks - We rely on estimates of our recoverable mineral reserves, which is complex due to the geological characteristics of the properties and the
number of assumptions made.
50
-- 52 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Coal Mining and Cokemaking
Princeton is a coal mining complex located in West Virginia that specializes in surface and underground mining of metallurgical coal to produce coke and
pulverized coal injection coal. We have annual rated metallurgical coal production capacity of 2.3 million net tons from our Princeton mine. In 2021, the mine
produced 1.4 million net tons of coal. We own 100% of the Princeton mine, which has been operating since 1995. We own 52% of the mineral rights and lease 48%
via multiple mineral leases having varying expiration dates. Mining leases routinely are renegotiated and renewed as they approach their respective expiration
dates. Princeton's operations consist of two open-pit surface mines, two underground mines, a preparation plant and two rail loadouts.
In 2021, our cokemaking facilities produced 2.9 million net tons of coke. Mountain State Carbon produces furnace coke and related by-products from its
plant in Follansbee, West Virginia, which consists of four batteries. Monessen produces furnace coke and related by-products in Monessen, Pennsylvania, which
was temporarily idled due to the COVID-19 pandemic and restarted production during the third quarter of 2021. Warren produces furnace coke and related by-
products from its plant in Warren, Ohio, and supplies its coke to the Cleveland facility. We also operate cokemaking facilities located within Burns Harbor and
Middletown Works.
As a result of our internal usage of HBI, coupled with our ongoing evaluation of coke use strategies, we idled our coke facility at Middletown Works during
the third quarter of 2021, and we intend to permanently idle our Mountain State Carbon coke plant in the second quarter of 2022.
Other Businesses
Our Tubular operating segment consists of our subsidiary Tubular Components, which has plants in Walbridge, Ohio and Columbus, Indiana. The
Walbridge plant operates six electric resistance welded tube mills. The Columbus plant operates five electric resistance welded tube mills and four high-speed cold
saws on leased property. Tubular Components shut down and ceased tube production at the Queretaro, Mexico plant in April 2021. The high-speed cold saw that
was operating at the Queretaro plant was relocated to the Columbus plant and the tube mill returned to the U.S. is replacing an existing, older tube mill currently in
operation.
Our Tooling and Stamping operating segment consists of our subsidiary Tooling and Stamping, which provides advanced-engineered solutions, tool design
and build, hot- and cold-stamped steel components and complex assemblies for the automotive market across ten plants, of which certain of these are under long-
term lease agreements, in Ontario, Alabama and Kentucky. Its facilities feature seven large-bed, hot-stamping presses, providing 13 lines of production; 81 cold-
stamping presses ranging from 150 net tons to 3,000 net tons of pressing capacity; 17 large-bed, high-tonnage tryout presses with prove-out capabilities for new
tool builds; and 149 multi-axis welding assembly cells. Construction of our new facility in Tennessee is substantially complete and the facility began producing
prototype components in the third quarter of 2021. Commercial start of production at the Tennessee location is expected to begin in the second quarter of 2022.
Item 3. Legal Proceedings
Legal Proceedings Relating to our Business
JSW Steel Litigation. On June 8, 2021, JSW Steel filed a complaint against Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., AK Steel Holding Corporation (now known as Cleveland-
Cliffs Steel Holding Corporation), Nucor Corporation and U.S. Steel in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Texas. JSW Steel alleges that the
defendants engaged in a group boycott against JSW Steel in violation of federal and Texas antitrust laws by refusing to sell semi-finished steel slabs to JSW Steel,
beginning in 2018 and continuing through the present; civil conspiracy among the defendants; and tortious interference with JSW Steel’s contractual rights and
business relations involving its vendors and customers. JSW Steel’s allegations involve the tariffs and quotas imposed on steel imports by the U.S. government
under Section 232 beginning in March 2018, which JSW Steel alleges raised the price of imported slabs, and statements made to the U.S. government related to
exemption requests submitted by JSW Steel in 2018 and 2021. JSW Steel further claims that this alleged anticompetitive conduct negatively impacted JSW Steel’s
costs, production and revenues and prevented it from pursuing expansion plans at its Ohio and Texas facilities that would compete with the defendants. JSW Steel
is seeking to hold the defendants jointly and severally liable for treble damages in an amount in excess of $500 million and other relief. We filed a Motion to Dismiss
in the case during 2021, and discovery remains stayed until the court decides our motion. We believe the claims asserted against us are without merit, and we are
vigorously defending against them.
Mesabi Metallics Adversary Proceeding. On September 7, 2017, Mesabi Metallics Company LLC (f/k/a Essar Steel Minnesota LLC) ("Mesabi Metallics")
filed a complaint against Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. in the Essar Steel Minnesota
51
-- 53 of 411 --
Table of Contents
LLC and ESML Holdings Inc. bankruptcy proceeding that is pending in the United States Bankruptcy Court, District of Delaware. Mesabi Metallics alleges tortious
interference with its contractual rights and business relations involving certain vendors, suppliers and contractors, violations of federal and Minnesota antitrust laws
through monopolization, attempted monopolization and restraint of trade, violation of the automatic stay, and civil conspiracy with unnamed Doe defendants.
Mesabi Metallics amended its complaint to add additional defendants, including, among others, our subsidiary, Cleveland-Cliffs Minnesota Land Development
Company LLC ("Cliffs Minnesota Land"), and to add additional claims, including avoidance and recovery of unauthorized post-petition transfers of real estate
interests, claims disallowance, civil contempt and declaratory relief. Mesabi Metallics seeks, among other things, unspecified damages and injunctive relief. Cliffs
and Cliffs Minnesota Land filed counterclaims against Mesabi Metallics, Chippewa Capital Partners ("Chippewa"), and Thomas M. Clarke ("Clarke") for tortious
interference and civil conspiracy, as well as additional claims against Chippewa and Clarke for aiding and abetting tortious interference, for which we seek, among
other things, damages and injunctive relief. Our counterclaim against Clarke for libel was dismissed on jurisdictional grounds. The parties filed various dispositive
motions on certain of the claims, including a motion for partial summary judgment to settle a dispute over real estate transactions between Cliffs Minnesota Land
and Glacier Park Iron Ore Properties LLC ("GPIOP"). A ruling in favor of Cliffs, Cliffs Minnesota Land and GPIOP was issued on July 23, 2018, finding that Mesabi
Metallics' leases had terminated and upholding Cliffs' and Cliffs Minnesota Land's purchase and lease of the contested real estate interests. Mesabi Metallics filed a
Motion for Leave to File an Interlocutory Appeal, which was denied on September 10, 2019. Discovery is ongoing. We believe the claims asserted against us are
without merit, and we intend to continue to vigorously defend against any remaining claims in the lawsuit.
Certain Legacy Legal Proceedings Relating to our Steel Operations . Certain of our acquired subsidiaries have been named as defendants, among many
other named defendants, in numerous lawsuits filed since 1990 claiming injury allegedly resulting from exposure to asbestos. Similar lawsuits seeking monetary
relief continue to be filed in various jurisdictions in the U.S., which cases are vigorously defended. Although predictions about the outcome of pending litigation is
subject to uncertainties, based upon present knowledge, we believe it is unlikely that the resolution in the aggregate of these claims will have a materially adverse
effect on our consolidated results of operations, cash flows or financial condition.
Legal Proceedings Relating to Environmental Matters
SEC regulations require us to disclose certain information about administrative or judicial proceedings involving the environment and to which a
governmental authority is a party if we reasonably believe that such proceedings may result in monetary sanctions above a stated threshold. Pursuant to SEC
regulations, we use a threshold of $1 million for purposes of determining whether disclosure of any such proceedings is required. We believe that this threshold is
reasonably designed to result in disclosure of any such proceedings that are material to our business or financial condition.
Information for this item relating to certain other environmental proceedings may be found under the heading Burns Harbor Water Issues in NOTE 20 -
COMMITMENTS AND CONTINGENCIES to the consolidated financial statements in Part II – Item 8. Financial Statements and Supplementary Data , which
information is incorporated herein by reference.
Item 4. Mine Safety Disclosures
We are committed to protecting the occupational health and well-being of each of our employees. Safety is one of our core values, and we strive to ensure
that safe production is the first priority for all employees. Our internal objective is to achieve zero injuries and incidents across the Company by focusing on
proactively identifying needed prevention activities, establishing standards and evaluating performance to mitigate any potential loss to people, equipment,
production and the environment. We have implemented intensive employee training that is geared toward maintaining a high level of awareness and knowledge of
safety and health issues in the work environment through the development and coordination of requisite information, skills and attitudes. We believe that through
these policies, we have developed an effective safety management system.
Under the Dodd-Frank Act, each operator of a coal or other mine is required to include certain mine safety results within its periodic reports filed with the
SEC. As required by the reporting requirements included in §1503(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act and Item 104 of Regulation S-K, the required mine safety results
regarding certain mining safety and health matters for each of our mine locations that are covered under the scope of the Dodd-Frank Act are included in Exhibit 95
of Part IV – Item 15. Exhibits and Financial Statement Schedules of this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
52
-- 54 of 411 --
Table of Contents
PART II
Item 5. Market for Registrant's Common Equity, Related Stockholder Matters and Issuer Purchases of
Equity Securities
Stock Exchange Information
Our common shares (ticker symbol CLF) are listed on the NYSE.
Holders
At February 10, 2022, we had 2,532 shareholders of record.
Shareholder Return Performance
The following graph shows changes over the past five-year period in the value of $100 invested in: (1) Cliffs' common shares; (2) S&P 500 Index; (3) S&P
SmallCap 600 Index; (4) S&P MidCap 400 Index; and (5) S&P Metals and Mining Select Industry Index. Due to the increased market capitalization of the Company,
we were included within the S&P MidCap 400 Index and removed from the S&P SmallCap 600 Index during the year ended December 31, 2021. The values of
each investment are based on price change plus reinvestment of all dividends reported to shareholders, based on monthly granularity.
2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Cleveland-Cliffs
Inc. Return
% — (14.27) 6.66 12.60 77.46 49.52
Cum $ 100.00 85.73 91.44 102.96 182.71 273.19
S&P 500 Index
Return
% — 21.80 (4.39) 31.48 18.39 28.68
Cum $ 100.00 121.80 116.45 153.11 181.27 233.25
S&P SmallCap 600
Index Return
% — 13.15 (8.52) 22.74 11.24 26.74
Cum $ 100.00 113.15 103.51 127.05 141.33 179.12
S&P MidCap 400
Index Return
% — 16.23 (11.10) 26.17 13.65 24.73
Cum $ 100.00 116.23 103.33 130.37 148.16 184.80
S&P Metals and
Mining Select Industry
Index Return
% — 20.61 (26.76) 14.70 15.97 34.94
Cum $ 100.00 120.61 88.33 101.32 117.50 158.56
53
-- 55 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Issuer Purchases of Equity Securities
The following table presents information with respect to repurchases by the Company of our common shares during the periods indicated:
ISSUER PURCHASES OF EQUITY SECURITIES
Period Total Number of Shares
(or Units) Purchased
Average Price Paid
per Share
(or Unit)
Total Number of Shares (or
Units) Purchased as Part of
Publicly Announced Plans or
Programs
Maximum Number (or
Approximate Dollar Value) of
Shares (or Units) that May Yet
be Purchased Under the Plans
or Programs
October 1 - 31, 2021 534 $ 19.66 — $ —
November 1 - 30, 2021 — — — —
December 1 - 31, 2021 — — — —
Total 534 $ 19.66 — $ —
All shares were delivered to us to satisfy tax withholding obligations due upon the vesting or payment of stock awards.
On February 10, 2022, our Board of Directors authorized a program to repurchase our outstanding common shares in the open market or in privately negotiated transactions,
which may include purchases pursuant to Rule 10b5-1 plans or accelerated share repurchases, up to a maximum of $1 billion. We are not obligated to make any purchases,
and the program may be suspended or discontinued at any time. The share repurchase program does not have a specific expiration date.
Item 6. [Reserved]
Item 7. Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations
Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations is designed to provide a reader of our financial statements with a
narrative from the perspective of management on our financial condition, results of operations, liquidity and other factors that may affect our future results. The
following discussion should be read in conjunction with the consolidated financial statements and related notes that appear in Part II – Item 8. Financial Statements
and Supplementary Data of this Annual Report on Form 10-K.
Overview
The year 2021 represented a period of record financial performance in our Company's 174-year history. The advantages of our unique, vertically integrated
business model as well as the immediate benefits of the transformational acquisitions we completed in 2020 were on full display during the year as we achieved
these phenomenal results. Our commercial actions, along with a healthy demand environment for steel, drove substantially higher selling prices for the majority of
products we sell, and we adjusted production to meet the needs of our order book. Combined with this, we believe we were able to manage costs better than our
peers due to our vertically integrated footprint, which reduces the impact of material price inflation on our major cost inputs. As a result, we produced record
revenues, record net income, record Adjusted EBITDA and record operating cash flow in 2021.
The HRC index averaged $1,573 per net ton for 2021, a record year that was also 174% higher than 2020. The record prices for steel products in 2021
resulted from both supply and demand factors, each driven by a rapid recovery from the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic. Stay-at-home mandates and fiscal
stimulus drove strong demand for consumer goods, such as HVAC products and appliances. Demand from machinery and equipment producers has also been
robust. The demand for light vehicles was also strong; however, automotive supply chain difficulties have limited the demand for steel from automotive
manufacturers. On the supply side, spot steel availability was limited throughout the year.
We expect healthy demand to continue into 2022 as we start to see the impacts of the Infrastructure and Jobs Act of 2021, growing environmentally-
focused capital projects, healthy economic conditions and pent-up automotive demand, as supply chain issues begin to show signs of waning. With strong demand
and steel prices in the U.S. reaching all-time highs in 2021, we were well positioned to negotiate our fixed price contracts, which represent approximately 45% of
our volumes, at favorable levels, which should enable us to deliver strong financial results and free cash flow in 2022, even if HRC pricing falls considerably.
1 2
1
2
54
-- 56 of 411 --
Table of Contents
As a result of our healthy free cash flow in 2021, we were able to complete several strategic and financial transactions, including the FPT Acquisition. FPT
is one of the largest processors of prime scrap in the country, representing approximately 15% of the entire U.S. merchant market. We believe this acquisition is a
complementary addition to our footprint, as prime scrap demand is expected to grow with new flat-rolled EAF capacity set to come online over the next five years
and as the worldwide focus on decarbonization continues. We expect to be able to leverage our long-standing flat-rolled automotive and other customer
relationships into recycling partnerships to further grow our prime scrap presence. Additionally, FPT allows us to optimize productivity at our existing EAFs and
BOFs and furthers our commitment to environmentally-friendly, low-carbon intensity steelmaking with a cleaner materials mix.
Another use of our robust cash flow was the complete redemption of our Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock for $1,343 million during the
third quarter of 2021. This transaction reduced our diluted share count by approximately 10%, providing a meaningful return to our shareholders. During February
2021, we executed a series of favorable debt and equity capital market transactions in an effort to extend our average debt maturity profile and increase our ratio of
unsecured debt to secured debt. We also completed additional financing transactions, including the redemption of all $396 million aggregate principal amount of our
5.750% 2025 Senior Notes in June 2021, and provided notice of our election to redeem all remaining $294 million aggregate principal amount of our 1.500% 2025
Convertible Senior Notes in December 2021, which was completed in January 2022.
In 2021, we reached full run-rate nameplate annual capacity at our state-of-the-art direct reduction plant in Toledo, Ohio. This facility produces high-quality
HBI and is the first of its kind in the Great Lakes region. While we originally expected to be a merchant seller of HBI, following the 2020 Acquisitions, we have
instead maximized the value of our HBI by utilizing it primarily in our blast furnaces, which allows us to improve costs and productivity while reducing our coke rates
and reducing our carbon emissions. As a result of our internal usage of HBI, coupled with our ongoing evaluation of coke use strategies, we idled our coke facility at
Middletown Works in 2021 and we intend to permanently idle our Mountain State Carbon coke plant in 2022.
Along with these notable accomplishments, we have been able to continue successfully navigating through the COVID-19 pandemic while preserving the
health and safety of both our workforce and our Company for the long term. The health and safety of our employees has always been our top priority. In an effort to
best protect our workforce and our Company, we launched a vaccine incentive program in July 2021 that was developed in partnership with our labor unions.
Throughout the 45 days the program was in place, the vaccination rate more than doubled, and we achieved a total vaccination rate of over 75% throughout our
workforce. The initiative resulted in a payout of $45 million in total cash incentives to our vaccinated workforce. The successful vaccination program allowed us to
operate efficiently and safely throughout the remainder of 2021 and into 2022.
We also continued our best practices from both a safety and environmental standpoint. During 2021, our safety TRIR (including contractors) was 1.37 per
200,000 hours worked. Throughout 2021, we made continued progress towards our goal of reducing GHG emissions with our increased usage of HBI and scrap in
our facilities, as well as more efficient recycling of gases at certain facilities. We are also partnering with the U.S. Department of Energy as part of the Better Climate
Challenge initiative, as we aim to build on our GHG emission reduction progress.
Recent Developments
Acquisition of FPT
On November 18, 2021, we completed the acquisition of FPT, a leading prime ferrous scrap processor in the U.S. These operations consist of 22 scrap
processing facilities, primarily in the Midwest region of the U.S. Refer to NOTE 3 - ACQUISITIONS for additional information.
Financing Transactions
On December 1, 2021, we issued a notice of redemption for all $294 million in aggregate principal amount outstanding of the 1.500% 2025 Convertible
Senior Notes. The 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes were redeemed on January 18, 2022, through a combination settlement, with the aggregate principal
amount of $294 million paid in cash, and 24 million common shares delivered to noteholders, with a fair value of $499 million in settlement of the premium due per
the terms of the indenture, plus cash in respect of the accrued and unpaid interest of the 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes to, but not including, the
redemption date per the terms of the indenture.
On December 17, 2021, we entered into the Third ABL Amendment. The Third ABL Amendment modified our ABL Facility to, among other things, increase
the amount of tranche A revolver commitments available thereunder by an additional $1 billion and exchange $150 million of tranche B revolver commitments
available thereunder for tranche
55
-- 57 of 411 --
Table of Contents
A revolver commitments. After giving effect to the Third ABL Amendment, the aggregate principal amount of tranche A revolver commitments under our ABL Facility
is $4.5 billion and there are no longer any tranche B revolver commitments. This action increased our liquidity by $1.0 billion. The increase is a result of a larger
projected borrowing base driven by more favorable market conditions.
Share Repurchase Program
On February 10, 2022, our Board of Directors authorized a program to repurchase our outstanding common shares in the open market or in privately
negotiated transactions, which may include purchases pursuant to Rule 10B5-1 plans or accelerated share repurchases, up to a maximum of $1 billion. We are not
obligated to make any purchases and the program may be suspended or discontinued at any time. The share repurchase program does not have a specific
expiration date.
Results of Operations
Overview
Our total revenues, net income (loss), diluted EPS and Adjusted EBITDA were as follows:
See "— Results of Operations — Adjusted EBITDA" below for a reconciliation of our Net Income (loss) to Adjusted EBITDA.
The results for 2021 include the FPT operations subsequent to November 18, 2021 and full-year results for all other operations. The results for 2020
include AK Steel operations subsequent to March 13, 2020, ArcelorMittal USA operations subsequent to December 9, 2020, and our results from operations
previously reported as part of our historical Mining and Pelletizing segment.
Revenues
During the year ended December 31, 2021, our consolidated Revenues increased by $15,090 million, compared to 2020. The increase was primarily due
to the addition of 12.1 million net tons of steel shipments from our Steelmaking segment resulting from the 2020 Acquisitions, along with an increase in the average
steel product selling price of $240 per net ton.
56
-- 58 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Revenues by Product Line
The following represents our consolidated Revenues by product line for the years ended:
The change in product mix for 2021, compared to 2020, is due primarily to the inclusion of full-period results for the 2020 Acquisitions. The results for 2020
include AK Steel operations subsequent to March 13, 2020, ArcelorMittal USA operations subsequent to December 9, 2020, and our results from operations
previously reported as part of our historical Mining and Pelletizing segment.
Revenues by Market
The following table represents our consolidated Revenues and percentage of revenues attributable to each of the markets we supply:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020
Revenue % Revenue %
Automotive $ 5,152 25 % $ 2,391 45 %
Infrastructure and Manufacturing 5,427 27 % 818 15 %
Distributors and Converters 7,741 38 % 722 13 %
Steel producers 2,124 10 % 1,423 27 %
Total revenues $ 20,444 $ 5,354
The change in percentages of net revenues to each market in 2021 compared to 2020 was driven primarily by the AM USA Transaction, which increased
overall sales to automotive customers, but reduced the total percentage exposure, increased exposure to infrastructure and manufacturing and distributors and
converters customers, and drove more in-house iron ore sales, which reduced the percentage of sales to steel producers.
Automotive Market
The largest end user for our steel products is the automotive industry in North America, which makes light vehicle production a key driver of demand.
During 2021, North American light vehicle production was approximately 13.0 million units, the same as the prior year. Production the past two years has been
down approximately 3.0 million units compared to the prior ten-year average, primarily due to the global semiconductor shortage, as well as other material
shortages and supply chain disruptions resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic. This has caused several outages amongst light vehicle manufacturers despite
strong consumer demand. In light of these production outages, we have been able to redirect certain volumes originally intended for this end market to the spot
market, where demand has been strong and pricing has reached all-time highs. The percentage of sales to the automotive market should increase in 2022 as fixed
price contract prices increase and volumes expand as the material shortage issues ease.
During 2021, light vehicle sales in the U.S. were 15.1 million units, representing a 3% increase over the prior year. These improved sales, combined with
continued production difficulties, brought light vehicle inventories to an all-time low of 22 days' supply during the third quarter of 2021.
57
-- 59 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Infrastructure and Manufacturing
We sell a variety of our steel products, including plate, carbon, stainless, electrical, tinplate and rail, to the infrastructure and manufacturing market. This
market includes sales to manufacturers of HVAC, appliances, power transmission and distribution transformers, storage tanks, ships and railcars, wind towers,
machinery parts, heavy equipment, military armor, food preservation, and railway lines. Domestic construction activity and the replacement of aging infrastructure
directly affects sales of steel to this market. Residential construction spending surged in 2021 due to overwhelming demand for new houses. Nonresidential
construction spending was slightly down in 2021; however, the sector saw a surge in spending in the second half of the year that will likely continue into 2022 with
the passing of the Infrastructure and Jobs Act of 2021. The Infrastructure and Jobs Act of 2021 is also expected to increase demand for steel products related to
renewable energy as well as the modernization of the U.S. electrical grid. Our plate products can be used in windmills, which we estimate contain 130 metric tons
of steel per megawatt of electrical generating capacity. Additionally, we estimate solar panels consume 40 metric tons of steel per megawatt of electrical generating
capacity. We also expect to see an increase in charging stations for EVs, which we will benefit from as we are the sole producer of electrical steel in the U.S.
Distributors and Converters
Virtually all of the grades of steel we produce are sold to the steel distributors and converters market. This market generally represents downstream steel
service centers, which source various types of steel from us and fabricate it according to their customers' needs, which also includes automotive customers. Our
steel is typically sold to this market on a spot basis or under short-term contracts linked to steel pricing indices. Demand and pricing for this market can be highly
dependent on a variety of factors outside our control, including global and domestic commodity steel production capacity, the relative health of countries’ economies
and whether they are consuming or exporting excess steel production, the provisions of international trade agreements and fluctuations in international currencies
and, therefore, are subject to market changes in steel prices.
The price for domestic HRC, which is an important attribute in the profitability of this end market, averaged $1,573 per net ton for the year ended
December 31, 2021, 174% higher than the prior year. The record prices for steel products in 2021 resulted from both supply and demand factors, each driven by a
rapid recovery since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020.
Steel Producers Market
The steel producers market represents third-party sales to other steel producers, including those who operate blast furnaces and EAFs. It includes sales of
raw materials and semi-finished and finished goods, including iron ore pellets, coal, coke, HBI, scrap and steel products.
The increase in revenues from the steel producers market for 2021, as compared to 2020, is primarily due to the inclusion of full-period results for the AK
Steel and ArcelorMittal USA operations. This was partially offset by a decrease in iron ore product revenues during 2021, as compared to 2020, primarily as a result
of the 2020 Acquisitions, as our iron ore pellet production is now predominately consumed internally and the respective intercompany revenue is eliminated in
consolidation.
The largest component of sales to this market during the year ended December 31, 2021 was third-party slab sales, which are primarily made under a
long-term supply agreement that was initiated in connection with the closing of the AM USA Transaction. Additionally, while it has fallen from peak 2021 levels in
recent months, the price of iron ore has also risen dramatically over the past year, which, along with strong demand, has been an important factor in rising steel
prices globally. The Platts 62% Price averaged $159 per metric ton during 2021, a 46% increase compared to the prior year. While higher iron ore prices play a role
in increased steel prices, we also directly benefit from higher iron ore prices for the portion of iron ore pellets we sell to third parties.
Operating Costs
Cost of goods sold
Cost of goods sold increased by $10,808 million for the year ended December 31, 2021, as compared to 2020, primarily due to the addition of 12.1 million
net tons of steel shipments resulting from the 2020 Acquisitions.
Selling, general and administrative expenses
As a result of the 2020 Acquisitions, our Selling, general and administrative expenses increased by $178 million during the year ended December 31, 2021,
as compared to 2020.
58
-- 60 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Acquisition-related costs
The following table represents the components of Acquisition-related costs:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Severance $ (15) $ (38) $ (2)
Third-party expenses (5) (52) (7)
Total $ (20) $ (90) $ (9)
Refer to NOTE 3 - ACQUISITIONS for further information on the acquisitions.
Miscellaneous – net
Miscellaneous – net increased by $20 million for the year ended December 31, 2021, as compared to 2020. The increase in miscellaneous expense was
primarily due to the acquisition-related loss on equity method investment during 2021.
Other Income (Expense)
Interest expense, net
Interest expense, net increased by $99 million for the year ended December 31, 2021, as compared to the prior year. The increase during 2021 was
primarily due to borrowings on our ABL Facility, a decrease in capitalized interest during 2021 due to the completion of our Toledo direct reduction plant in
December 2020 and the full-year interest on the incremental debt that we incurred in connection with the AK Steel Merger.
Gain (loss) on extinguishment of debt
The loss on extinguishment of debt of $88 million for the year ended December 31, 2021 primarily resulted from the redemption of $396 million aggregate
principal amount of 5.750% 2025 Senior Notes, $395 million aggregate principal amount of 4.875% 2024 Senior Secured Notes and $347 million aggregate
principal amount of 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes.
This compares to a gain on extinguishment of debt of $130 million for the year ended December 31, 2020 primarily related to the repurchase of $748 million
aggregate principal amount of our outstanding senior notes of various series using the net proceeds from the issuance of an additional $555 million aggregate
principal amount of our 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes on April 24, 2020 and other sources of cash. Refer to NOTE 8 - DEBT AND CREDIT FACILITIES for
further details.
Net periodic benefit credits (costs) other than service cost component
The increase of $156 million in Net periodic benefit credits (costs) other than service cost component primarily relates to the expected return on assets
component. The higher return is primarily attributable to the full-year effect of additional pension and OPEB plan assets acquired in the 2020 Acquisitions. Refer to
NOTE 10 - PENSIONS AND OTHER POSTRETIREMENT BENEFITS for further details.
Income Taxes
Our effective tax rate is affected by permanent items, primarily depletion. It also is affected by discrete items that may occur in any given period but are not
consistent from period to period. The following represents a summary of our tax provision and corresponding effective rates:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020
Income tax benefit (expense) $ (773) $ 111
Effective tax rate 20 % 57 %
59
-- 61 of 411 --
Table of Contents
A reconciliation of our income tax attributable to continuing operations compared to the U.S. federal statutory rate is as follows:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020
Tax at U.S. statutory rate $ 799 21 % $ (41) 21 %
Increase (decrease) due to:
Percentage depletion in excess of cost depletion (99) (3) (42) 22
Non-taxable income related to noncontrolling interests (9) — (9) 4
State taxes, net 86 2 (11) 6
Other items, net (4) — (8) 4
Provision for income tax expense (benefit) and effective income tax rate including
discrete items $ 773 20 % $ (111) 57 %
The increase in income tax expense in 2021, as compared to the prior year, is directly related to the increase in the pre-tax book income year-over-year.
See NOTE 12 - INCOME TAXES for further information.
Adjusted EBITDA
We evaluate performance on an operating segment basis, as well as a consolidated basis, based on Adjusted EBITDA, which is a non-GAAP measure.
This measure is used by management, investors, lenders and other external users of our financial statements to assess our operating performance and to compare
operating performance to other companies in the steel industry. In addition, management believes Adjusted EBITDA is a useful measure to assess the earnings
power of the business without the impact of capital structure and can be used to assess our ability to service debt and fund future capital expenditures in the
business.
60
-- 62 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following table provides a reconciliation of our Net income (loss) to Adjusted EBITDA:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020
Net income (loss) $ 3,033 $ (81)
Less:
Interest expense, net (337) (238)
Income tax benefit (expense) (773) 111
Depreciation, depletion and amortization (897) (308)
Total EBITDA $ 5,040 $ 354
Less:
EBITDA from noncontrolling interests $ 75 $ 56
Gain (loss) on extinguishment of debt (88) 130
Severance costs (15) (38)
Acquisition-related costs excluding severance costs (5) (52)
Acquisition-related loss on equity method investment (31) —
Amortization of inventory step-up (161) (96)
Impact of discontinued operations 3 1
Total Adjusted EBITDA $ 5,262 $ 353
EBITDA of noncontrolling interests includes the following:
Net income attributable to noncontrolling interests $ 45 $ 41
Depreciation, depletion and amortization 30 15
EBITDA of noncontrolling interests $ 75 $ 56
The following table provides a summary of our Adjusted EBITDA by segment:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020
Adjusted EBITDA:
Steelmaking $ 5,422 $ 433
Other Businesses 9 47
Corporate and eliminations (169) (127)
Total Adjusted EBITDA $ 5,262 $ 353
Adjusted EBITDA from our Steelmaking segment for the year ended December 31, 2021, increased by $4,989 million, as compared to 2020. The results
were favorably impacted by the operating results of the acquired steelmaking operations. Our Steelmaking Adjusted EBITDA included $232 million of Selling,
general and administrative expenses for the year ended December 31, 2021.
Adjusted EBITDA from Corporate and eliminations primarily relates to Selling, general and administrative expenses at our Corporate headquarters.
The discussion of our Consolidated Results of Operations for 2020 compared to 2019 can be found in Part II, Item 7., "Management's Discussion and
Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations," of our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2020, filed with the SEC on
February 26, 2021.
Steelmaking
The following is a summary of our Steelmaking segment results included in our consolidated financial statements for the years ended December 31, 2021
and 2020. The results for 2021 include the FPT operations
1
1
61
-- 63 of 411 --
Table of Contents
subsequent to November 18, 2021 and full-year results for all other Steelmaking operations. The results for 2020 include the AK Steel operations subsequent to
March 13, 2020, the ArcelorMittal USA operations subsequent to December 9, 2020, and our results from operations previously reported as part of our Mining and
Pelletizing segment.
The following is a summary of the Steelmaking segment operating results:
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020
Operating Results - In Millions
Revenues $ 19,901 $ 4,965
Cost of goods sold $ (15,379) $ (4,749)
Selling Price - Per Ton
Average net selling price per net ton of steel products $ 1,187 $ 947
The following table represents our segment Revenues by product line:
(Dollars In Millions,
Sales Volumes In Thousands)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020
Revenue Volume Revenue Volume
Hot-rolled steel $ 5,615 4,886 $ 386 633
Cold-rolled steel 3,186 2,790 490 682
Coated steel 5,864 5,056 1,747 1,911
Stainless and electrical steel 1,622 674 868 416
Plate 1,316 1,020 46 62
Other steel products 1,247 1,460 46 79
Other 1,051 N/A 1,382 N/A
Total $ 19,901 $ 4,965
All steel product volumes are stated in net tons.
Operating Results
Steelmaking revenues for 2021 increased by $14,936 million as compared to 2020, primarily due to the addition of sales following the 2020 Acquisitions.
Results for the year ended December 31, 2021 were also impacted positively by the increase in the price for domestic HRC, which is the most significant index
driving our revenues and profitability. The HRC index averaged $1,573 per net ton for 2021, 174% higher than 2020. The price of HRC reached an all-time high in
2021, as a direct result of favorable supply-demand dynamics driven by a rapid recovery since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. We have also
benefited from higher steel shipments due to stronger demand.
Cost of goods sold for 2021 increased by $10,630 million as compared to 2020, predominantly due to additional sales as discussed above.
As a result, Adjusted EBITDA was $5,422 million for the year ended December 31, 2021, compared to $433 million for the prior year. Adjusted EBITDA for
2021 was positively impacted by the addition of sales following the 2020 Acquisitions, the increase in the price for HRC and the higher demand for steel products,
as discussed above.
Production
Our steelmaking facilities produced a total of 18 million net tons of raw steel during the year ended December 31, 2021. Due to the timing of the 2020
Acquisitions and the idling of facilities in response to impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, our steelmaking facilities produced a total of 4 million net tons of raw steel
during the year ended December 31, 2020.
1 1
1
62
-- 64 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Liquidity, Cash Flows and Capital Resources
Our primary sources of liquidity are Cash and cash equivalents and cash generated from our operations, availability under the ABL Facility and other
financing activities. Our capital allocation decision-making process is focused on preserving healthy liquidity levels, while maintaining the strength of our balance
sheet and creating financial flexibility to manage through the inherent cyclical demand for our products and volatility in commodity prices. We are focused on
maximizing the cash generation of our operations, reducing debt, and aligning capital investments with our strategic priorities and the requirements of our business
plan, including regulatory and permission-to-operate related projects.
Following the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in the U.S. in 2020, our primary focus was to maintain adequate levels of liquidity to manage through a
potentially prolonged economic downturn. Now that business conditions have improved, allowing us to generate a healthy free cash flow during 2021, we have had
the ability to make investments to both improve and grow our business, particularly as it pertains to scrap metal. We entered into the scrap business on November
18, 2021 with the FPT Acquisition. We were also able to reduce our diluted share count and effectively return capital to shareholders via the cash redemption of all
of the outstanding shares of our Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock during the third quarter of 2021. In December 2021, we also increased our
liquidity by amending our ABL Facility to increase the aggregate revolver commitments from $3.5 billion to $4.5 billion. Additionally, we expect to be able to return
capital to shareholders in 2022 through our share repurchase program, which was authorized by our Board on February 10, 2022.
In addition, we anticipate that the current strong market environment will provide us ample opportunities to reduce our debt with our own free cash flow
generation. We also continue to look at the composition of our debt, as we are interested in both extending our average maturity length and increasing our ratio of
unsecured debt to secured debt, which can be accomplished with cash provided by operating activities. On January 18, 2022, we took action to reduce our debt by
redeeming all of our then-outstanding 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes. The notes were redeemed through a combination settlement, with the aggregate
principal amount of $294 million paid in cash, and 24 million common shares delivered to noteholders per the terms of the indenture.
In furtherance of these goals, we also consummated the following financing transactions during 2021:
On February 11, 2021, we sold 20 million common shares at a price per share of $16.12, in an underwritten public offering. We used the net proceeds from
the offering, plus cash on hand, to redeem $322 million aggregate principal amount of our outstanding 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes. Prior to such use, the
net proceeds were used to temporarily reduce the outstanding borrowings under our ABL Facility.
On February 17, 2021, we issued $500 million aggregate principal amount of 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and $500 million aggregate principal amount of
4.875% 2031 Senior Notes in an offering that was exempt from the registration requirements of the Securities Act. We used the net proceeds from the notes
offering to redeem all of the outstanding 4.875% 2024 Senior Secured Notes and 6.375% 2025 Senior Notes issued by Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and all of the
outstanding 7.625% 2021 AK Senior Notes, 7.500% 2023 AK Senior Notes and 6.375% 2025 AK Senior Notes issued by AK Steel Corporation (n/k/a Cleveland-
Cliffs Steel Corporation), and pay fees and expenses in connection with such redemptions, and reduce borrowings under our ABL Facility.
Additionally, on June 28, 2021, we redeemed the entirety of our outstanding 5.750% 2025 Senior Notes using available liquidity. Pursuant to the terms of
the indenture governing the 5.750% 2025 Senior Notes, we paid $415 million, including $396 million aggregate principal amount, plus make-whole premiums and
accrued and unpaid interest to, but not including, the redemption date.
These actions give us additional financial flexibility and will better prepare us to navigate more easily through potentially volatile industry conditions in the
future.
Based on our outlook for the next 12 months, which is subject to continued changing demand from customers and volatility in domestic steel prices, we
expect to have ample liquidity through cash generated from operations and availability under our ABL Facility sufficient to meet the needs of our operations, service
and repay our debt obligations and return capital to shareholders.
The following discussion summarizes the significant items impacting our cash flows during 2021 and comparative years as well as expected impacts to our
future cash flows over the next 12 months. Refer to the Statements of Consolidated Cash Flows for additional information.
63
-- 65 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Operating Activities
Net cash provided by operating activities was $2,785 million for the year ended December 31, 2021, compared to net cash used by operating activities of
$258 million for the year ended December 31, 2020. The year-over-year improvement was driven by improved operating results, partially offset by changes in
working capital. Changes in working capital included increases in inventory primarily related to the global semiconductor shortage and increased raw material and
production costs, as well as increases in receivables primarily related to rising prices. Additionally, we had incremental pension and OPEB payments and
contributions of $268 million, which included $118 million of deferred 2020 pension contributions in connection with the CARES Act.
Investing Activities
Net cash used by investing activities was $1,379 million and $2,042 million for the years ended December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively. During the year
ended December 31, 2021, we had net cash outflows of $761 million related to the FPT Acquisition, net of cash acquired. We had total capital expenditures of $705
million and $525 million for the years ended December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively. Included in the total capital expenditures, we had cash outflows for
expansion capital expenditures relating to the development of our Toledo direct reduction plant of $64 million and $348 million for the years ended December 31,
2021 and 2020, respectively. Additionally, included in the total capital expenditures, we spent $641 million and $177 million primarily on sustaining capital
expenditures during the years ended December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively. Sustaining capital spend includes infrastructure, mobile equipment, fixed
equipment, product quality, environment, health and safety.
During the year ended December 31, 2020, we had net cash outflows of $658 million related to the AM USA Transaction, net of cash acquired. Additionally,
during the year ended December 31, 2020, we had net cash outflows of $869 million related to the AK Steel Merger, net of cash acquired, which included $590
million used to repay the former AK Steel Corporation revolving credit facility and $324 million used to purchase outstanding 7.500% 2023 AK Senior Notes.
We anticipate total cash used for capital expenditures during the next 12 months to be between $800 and $900 million.
Financing Activities
Net cash used by financing activities was $1,470 million for the year ended December 31, 2021, compared to net cash provided by financing activities of
$2,059 million for the year ended December 31, 2020. Cash outflows from financing activities for the year ended December 31, 2021 included the redemption of all
583,273 shares outstanding of our Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock at a redemption price of $1,343 million during the third quarter of 2021, along
with $1.4 billion for repayments of debt. We used available liquidity to redeem all $396 million aggregate principal amount outstanding of our 5.750% 2025 Senior
Notes. We used the net proceeds from the issuance of the 20 million common shares, and cash on hand, to redeem $322 million in aggregate principal amount of
9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes. We used the net proceeds from the issuances of the 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes to redeem all
of the outstanding 4.875% 2024 Senior Secured Notes, 6.375% 2025 Senior Notes, 7.625% 2021 AK Senior Notes, 7.500% 2023 AK Senior Notes and 6.375%
2025 AK Senior Notes, and pay fees and expenses in connection with such redemptions, and reduce borrowings under our ABL Facility.
Cash inflows from financing activities for the year ended December 31, 2021 included the issuances of $500 million aggregate principal amount of 4.625%
2029 Senior Notes, $500 million aggregate principal amount of 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes and 20 million common shares for proceeds of $322 million, along with
net borrowings of $73 million under credit facilities.
Net cash provided by financing activities for the year ended December 31, 2020 primarily related to the issuances of $845 million aggregate principal
amount of 6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes, $955 million aggregate principal amount of 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes and net borrowings of $1,510
million under our ABL Facility. The net proceeds from the initial issuance of $725 million aggregate principal amount of the 6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes,
along with cash on hand, were used to purchase $373 million aggregate principal amount of 7.625% 2021 AK Senior Notes and $367 million aggregate principal
amount of 7.500% 2023 AK Senior Notes and to pay for the $44 million of debt issuance costs in the first quarter of 2020. The net proceeds from the additional
issuance of $555 million aggregate principal amount of the 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes were used to repurchase $736 million aggregate principal amount of
our outstanding senior notes.
64
-- 66 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The discussion of our Liquidity, Cash Flows and Capital Resources results for 2020 compared to 2019 can be found in Part II, Item 7., "Management's
Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations," in our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2020, filed with
the SEC on February 26, 2021.
The following represents our future cash commitments and contractual obligations as of December 31, 2021:
Payments Due by Period (In Millions)
Total Less than
1 Year 1 - 3
Years 3 - 5
Years More than 5
Years
Long-term debt $ 5,369 $ — $ 36 $ 3,355 $ 1,978
Interest on debt 1,497 262 453 361 421
Operating lease obligations 378 68 103 74 133
Finance lease obligations 345 105 127 47 66
Purchase obligations:
Open purchase orders 374 328 1 — 45
Minimum "take or pay" purchase commitments 8,590 2,785 2,947 1,493 1,365
Total purchase obligations 8,964 3,113 2,948 1,493 1,410
Other long-term liabilities:
Pension funding minimums 132 4 61 67 —
OPEB claim payments 613 138 242 233 —
Environmental and asset retirement obligations 655 54 76 30 495
Other 91 4 24 18 45
Total other long-term liabilities 1,491 200 403 348 540
Total $ 18,044 $ 3,748 $ 4,070 $ 5,678 $ 4,548
Refer to NOTE 8 - DEBT AND CREDIT FACILITIES for additional information regarding our debt and related interest rates.
Includes minimum railroad and vessel transportation obligations, minimum electric power demand charges, minimum diesel and natural gas obligations and minimum port
facility obligations. Additionally, includes our coke purchase commitments related to our coke supply agreement with SunCoke Middletown.
Estimates beyond five years for pension and OPEB contributions and payments are not included due to the uncertainty of future investment performance, funding legislation,
discount rates, healthcare costs, plan design and other factors. Refer to NOTE 10 - PENSIONS AND OTHER POSTRETIREMENT BENEFITS for additional information
regarding our pension and OPEB obligations.
Refer to NOTE 20 - COMMITMENTS AND CONTINGENCIES for additional information regarding our future commitments and obligations.
1
1
2
3
3
1
2
3
65
-- 67 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Capital Resources
We expect to fund our business obligations from available cash, current and future operations and existing and future borrowing arrangements. We also
may pursue other funding strategies in the capital markets to strengthen our liquidity, extend debt maturities and/or fund strategic initiatives. The following
represents a summary of key liquidity measures:
(In Millions)
December 31,
2021
Cash and cash equivalents $ 48
Available borrowing base on ABL Facility $ 4,500
Borrowings (1,609)
Letter of credit obligations (175)
Borrowing capacity available $ 2,716
As of December 31, 2021, the ABL Facility had a maximum borrowing base of $4.5 billion, determined by applying customary advance rates to eligible accounts receivable,
inventory and certain mobile equipment.
Our primary sources of funding are cash and cash equivalents, which totaled $48 million as of December 31, 2021, cash generated by our business,
availability under our ABL Facility and other financing activities. Cash and cash equivalents include cash on hand and on deposit. The combination of cash and
availability under our ABL Facility gives us $2.8 billion in liquidity entering the first quarter of 2022, which is expected to be adequate to fund operations, letter of
credit obligations, capital expenditures and other cash commitments for at least the next 12 months.
As of December 31, 2021, we were in compliance with the ABL Facility liquidity requirements and, therefore, the springing financial covenant requiring a
minimum Fixed Charge Coverage Ratio of 1.0 to 1.0 was not applicable. We believe that the cash on hand and our ABL Facility provide us sufficient liquidity to
support our operating, investing and financing activities. We have the capability to issue additional unsecured notes and, subject to the limitations set forth in our
existing senior notes indentures, additional secured debt, if we elect to access the debt capital markets. However, our ability to issue additional notes could be
limited by market conditions.
We intend from time to time to seek to retire or repurchase our outstanding senior notes with cash on hand, borrowings from existing credit sources or new
debt financings and/or exchanges for debt or equity securities, in open market purchases, privately negotiated transactions or otherwise. Such repurchases, if any,
will depend on prevailing market conditions, our liquidity requirements, contractual restrictions and other factors, and the amounts involved may be material.
Off-Balance Sheet Arrangements
In the normal course of business, we are a party to certain arrangements that are not reflected on our Statements of Consolidated Financial Position. These
arrangements include minimum "take or pay" purchase commitments, such as minimum electric power demand charges, minimum coal, diesel and natural gas
purchase commitments, minimum railroad transportation commitments and minimum port facility usage commitments; and financial instruments with off-balance
sheet risk, such as bank letters of credit and bank guarantees.
Information about our Guarantors and the Issuer of our Guaranteed Securities
The accompanying summarized financial information has been prepared and presented pursuant to SEC Regulation S-X, Rule 3-10, “Financial Statements
of Guarantors and Issuers of Guaranteed Securities Registered or Being Registered,” and Rule 13-01 "Financial Disclosures about Guarantors and Issuers of
Guaranteed Securities and Affiliates Whose Securities Collateralized a Registrant's Securities." Certain of our subsidiaries (the "Guarantor subsidiaries") have fully
and unconditionally, and jointly and severally, guaranteed the obligations under (a) the 5.875% 2027 Senior Notes, the 7.000% 2027 Senior Notes, the 4.625%
2029 Senior Notes and the 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes issued by Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. on a senior unsecured basis and (b) the 6.750% 2026 Senior Secured
1
1
66
-- 68 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Notes and the 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes on a senior secured basis. See NOTE 8 - DEBT AND CREDIT FACILITIES for further information.
The following presents the summarized financial information on a combined basis for Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (parent company and issuer of the guaranteed
obligations) and the Guarantor subsidiaries, collectively referred to as the obligated group. Transactions between the obligated group have been eliminated.
Information for the non-Guarantor subsidiaries was excluded from the combined summarized financial information of the obligated group.
Each Guarantor subsidiary is consolidated by Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. as of December 31, 2021. Refer to Exhibit 22, incorporated herein by reference, for the
detailed list of entities included within the obligated group as of December 31, 2021.
The guarantee of a Guarantor subsidiary with respect to Cliffs' 6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes, the 5.875% 2027 Senior Notes, the 7.000% 2027
Senior Notes, the 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes, the 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and the 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes will be automatically and unconditionally
released and discharged, and such Guarantor subsidiary’s obligations under the guarantee and the related indentures (the “Indentures”) will be automatically and
unconditionally released and discharged, upon the occurrence of any of the following, along with the delivery to the trustee of an officer’s certificate and an opinion
of counsel, each stating that all conditions precedent provided for in the applicable Indenture relating to the release and discharge of such Guarantor subsidiary’s
guarantee have been complied with:
(a) any sale, exchange, transfer or disposition of such Guarantor subsidiary (by merger, consolidation, or the sale of) or the capital stock of such Guarantor
subsidiary after which the applicable Guarantor subsidiary is no longer a subsidiary of the Company or the sale of all or substantially all of such
Guarantor subsidiary’s assets (other than by lease), whether or not such Guarantor subsidiary is the surviving entity in such transaction, to a person
which is not the Company or a subsidiary of the Company; provided that (i) such sale, exchange, transfer or disposition is made in compliance with the
applicable Indenture, including the covenants regarding consolidation, merger and sale of assets and, as applicable, dispositions of assets that constitute
notes collateral, and (ii) all the obligations of such Guarantor subsidiary under all debt of the Company or its subsidiaries terminate upon consummation
of such transaction;
(b) designation of any Guarantor subsidiary as an “excluded subsidiary” (as defined in the Indentures); or
(c) defeasance or satisfaction and discharge of the Indentures.
Each entity in the summarized combined financial information follows the same accounting policies as described in the consolidated financial statements.
The accompanying summarized combined financial information does not reflect investments of the obligated group in non-Guarantor subsidiaries. The financial
information of the obligated group is presented on a combined basis; intercompany balances and transactions within the obligated group have been eliminated. The
obligated group's amounts due from, amounts due to, and transactions with, non-Guarantor subsidiaries and related parties have been presented in separate line
items.
Summarized Combined Financial Information of the Issuer and Guarantor Subsidiaries:
The following table is summarized combined financial information from the Statements of Condensed Consolidated Financial Position of the obligated
group:
(In Millions)
December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020
Current assets $ 6,539 $ 4,903
Non-current assets 12,753 10,535
Current liabilities (3,222) (2,767)
Non-current liabilities (9,081) (10,563)
67
-- 69 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following table is summarized combined financial information from the Statements of Condensed Consolidated Operations of the obligated group:
(In Millions)
Year Ended
December 31, 2021
Revenues $ 19,973
Cost of goods sold (15,582)
Income from continuing operations 2,923
Net income 2,929
Net income attributable to Cliffs shareholders 2,929
As of December 31, 2021 and 2020, the obligated group had the following balances with non-Guarantor subsidiaries and other related parties:
(In Millions)
December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020
Balances with non-Guarantor subsidiaries:
Accounts receivable, net $ 199 $ 69
Accounts payable (186) (17)
Balances with other related parties:
Accounts receivable, net $ 3 $ 2
Accounts payable (7) (6)
Additionally, for the year ended December 31, 2021, the obligated group had Revenues of $139 million and Cost of goods sold of $117 million, in each
case with other related parties.
Market Risks
We are subject to a variety of risks, including those caused by changes in commodity prices and interest rates. We have established policies and
procedures to manage such risks; however, certain risks are beyond our control.
Pricing Risks
In the ordinary course of business, we are exposed to market risk and price fluctuations related to the sale of our products, which are impacted primarily by
market prices for HRC, and the purchase of energy and raw materials used in our operations, which are impacted by market prices for electricity, natural gas,
ferrous and stainless steel scrap, chrome, metallurgical coal, coke, nickel and zinc. Our strategy to address market risk has generally been to obtain competitive
prices for our products and services and allow operating results to reflect market price movements dictated by supply and demand; however, we make forward
physical purchases and enter into hedge contracts to manage exposure to price risk related to the purchases of certain raw materials and energy used in the
production process.
Our financial results can vary for our operations as a result of fluctuations in market prices. We attempt to mitigate these risks by aligning fixed and variable
components in our customer pricing contracts, supplier purchasing agreements and derivative financial instruments.
Some customer contracts have fixed-pricing terms, which increase our exposure to fluctuations in raw material and energy costs. To reduce our exposure,
we enter into annual, fixed-price agreements for certain raw materials. Some of our existing multi-year raw material supply agreements have required minimum
purchase quantities. Under adverse economic conditions, those minimums may exceed our needs. Absent exceptions for force majeure and other circumstances
affecting the legal enforceability of the agreements, these minimum purchase requirements may compel us to purchase quantities of raw materials that could
significantly exceed our anticipated needs or pay damages to the supplier for shortfalls. In these circumstances, we would attempt to negotiate agreements for new
purchase quantities. There is a risk, however, that we would not be successful in reducing
68
-- 70 of 411 --
Table of Contents
purchase quantities, either through negotiation or litigation. If that occurred, we would likely be required to purchase more of a particular raw material in a particular
year than we need, negatively affecting our results of operations and cash flows.
Certain of our customer contracts include variable-pricing mechanisms that adjust selling prices in response to changes in the costs of certain raw materials
and energy, while other of our customer contracts exclude such mechanisms. We may enter into multi-year purchase agreements for certain raw materials with
similar variable-price mechanisms, allowing us to achieve natural hedges between the customer contracts and supplier purchase agreements. Therefore, in some
cases, price fluctuations for energy (particularly natural gas and electricity), raw materials (such as scrap, chrome, zinc and nickel) or other commodities may be, in
part, passed on to customers rather than absorbed solely by us. There is a risk, however, that the variable-price mechanisms in the sales contracts may not
necessarily change in tandem with the variable-price mechanisms in our purchase agreements, negatively affecting our results of operations and cash flows.
Our strategy to address volatile natural gas rates and electricity rates includes improving efficiency in energy usage, identifying alternative providers and
utilizing the lowest cost alternative fuels. If we are unable to align fixed and variable components between customer contracts and supplier purchase agreements,
we use cash-settled commodity price swaps and options to hedge the market risk associated with the purchase of certain of our raw materials and energy
requirements. Additionally, we routinely use these derivative instruments to hedge a portion of our natural gas and zinc requirements. Our hedging strategy is
designed to protect us from excessive pricing volatility. However, since we do not typically hedge 100% of our exposure, abnormal price increases in any of these
commodity markets might still negatively affect operating costs.
The following table summarizes the negative effect of a hypothetical change in the fair value of our derivative instruments outstanding as of December 31,
2021, due to a 10% and 25% change in the market price of each of the indicated commodities:
(In Millions)
Positive or Negative Effect on
Pre-tax Income
Commodity Derivative 10% Increase or Decrease 25% Increase or Decrease
Natural gas $ 32 $ 81
Zinc 6 15
Valuation of Goodwill and Other Long-Lived Assets
We assign goodwill arising from acquired companies to the reporting units that are expected to benefit from the synergies of the acquisition. Goodwill is
tested on a qualitative basis for impairment at the reporting unit level on an annual basis (October 1) and between annual tests if an event occurs or circumstances
change that would more likely than not reduce the fair value of a reporting unit below its carrying value. These events or circumstances could include a significant
change in the business climate, legal factors, operating performance indicators, competition, or sale or disposition of a significant portion of a reporting unit. As
necessary, should our qualitative test indicate that it is more likely than not that the fair value of a reporting unit is less than its carry amount, we perform a
quantitative test to determine the amount of impairment, if any, to the carrying value of the reporting unit and its associated goodwill.
Application of the goodwill impairment test requires judgment, including the identification of reporting units, assignment of assets and liabilities to reporting
units, assignment of goodwill to reporting units and if a quantitative assessment is deemed necessary in determination of the fair value of each reporting unit. The
fair value of each reporting unit is estimated using a discounted cash flow methodology, which considers forecasted cash flows discounted at an estimated
weighted average cost of capital. Assessing the recoverability of our goodwill requires significant assumptions regarding the estimated future cash flows and other
factors to determine the fair value of a reporting unit, including, among other things, estimates related to forecasts of future revenues, expected Adjusted EBITDA,
expected capital expenditures and working capital requirements, which are based upon our long-range plan estimates. The assumptions used to calculate the fair
value of a reporting unit may change from year to year based on operating results, market conditions and other factors. Changes in these assumptions could
materially affect the determination of fair value for each reporting unit.
Long-lived assets are reviewed for impairment upon the occurrence of events or changes in circumstances that would indicate that the carrying value of
the assets may not be recoverable. Such indicators may include: a significant decline in expected future cash flows; a sustained, significant decline in market
pricing; a significant
69
-- 71 of 411 --
Table of Contents
adverse change in legal or environmental factors or in the business climate; changes in estimates of our recoverable reserves; and unanticipated competition. Any
adverse change in these factors could have a significant impact on the recoverability of our long-lived assets and could have a material impact on our consolidated
statements of operations and statements of financial position.
A comparison of each asset group's carrying value to the estimated undiscounted net future cash flows expected to result from the use of the assets,
including cost of disposition, is used to determine if an asset is recoverable. Projected future cash flows reflect management's best estimate of economic and
market conditions over the projected period, including growth rates in revenues and costs, and estimates of future expected changes in operating margins and
capital expenditures. If the carrying value of the asset group is higher than its undiscounted net future cash flows, the asset group is measured at fair value and the
difference is recorded as a reduction to the long-lived assets. We estimate fair value using a market approach, an income approach or a cost approach. For the
year ended December 31, 2021, we concluded that an event triggering the need for an impairment assessment did not occur.
Interest Rate Risk
Interest payable on our senior notes is at fixed rates. Interest payable under our ABL Facility is at a variable rate based upon the applicable base rate plus
the applicable base rate margin depending on the excess availability. As of December 31, 2021, we had $1,609 million outstanding under our ABL Facility. An
increase in prevailing interest rates would increase interest expense and interest paid for any outstanding borrowings under our ABL Facility. For example, a 100
basis point change to interest rates under our ABL Facility at the December 31, 2021 borrowing level would result in a change of $16 million to interest expense on
an annual basis.
Additionally, a portion of our borrowing capacity and outstanding indebtedness under the ABL Facility bears interest at a variable rate based on LIBOR. For
a discussion of the attendant risk, see Part I - Item 1A, Risk Factors - III. Financial Risks - Our existing and future indebtedness may limit cash flow available to
invest in the ongoing needs of our businesses, which could prevent us from fulfilling our obligations under our senior notes, ABL Facility and other debt, and we
may be forced to take other actions to satisfy our obligations under our debt, which may not be successful.
Supply Concentration Risks
Many of our operations and mines rely on one source for each of electric power and natural gas. A significant interruption or change in service or rates from
our energy suppliers could materially impact our production costs, margins and profitability.
Recently Issued Accounting Pronouncements
Refer to NOTE 1 - BASIS OF PRESENTATION AND SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES of the consolidated financial statements for a description of
recent accounting pronouncements, including the respective dates of adoption and effects on results of operations and financial condition.
Critical Accounting Estimates
Management's discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations is based on our consolidated financial statements, which have been
prepared in accordance with GAAP. Preparation of financial statements requires management to make assumptions, estimates and judgments that affect the
reported amounts of assets, liabilities, revenues, costs and expenses, and the related disclosures of contingencies. Management bases its estimates on various
assumptions and historical experience, which are believed to be reasonable; however, due to the inherent nature of estimates, actual results may differ significantly
due to changed conditions or assumptions. On a regular basis, management reviews the accounting policies, assumptions, estimates and judgments to ensure that
our financial statements are fairly presented in accordance with GAAP. However, because future events and their effects cannot be determined with certainty,
actual results could differ from our assumptions and estimates, and such differences could be material. Management believes that the following critical accounting
estimates and judgments have a significant impact on our financial statements.
Business Combinations
Assets acquired and liabilities assumed in a business combination are recognized and measured based on their estimated fair values at the acquisition
date, while the acquisition-related costs are expensed as incurred. Any excess of the purchase consideration when compared to the fair value of the net tangible
and intangible assets acquired, if any, is recorded as goodwill. We engaged independent valuation specialists to assist with the
70
-- 72 of 411 --
Table of Contents
determination of the fair value of assets acquired, liabilities assumed, noncontrolling interest, and goodwill, for the acquisitions. If the initial accounting for the
business combination is incomplete by the end of the reporting period in which the acquisition occurs, an estimate will be recorded. Subsequent to the acquisition
date, and not later than one year from the acquisition date, we will record any material adjustments to the initial estimate based on new information obtained that
would have existed as of the date of the acquisition. Any adjustment that arises from information obtained that did not exist as of the date of the acquisition will be
recorded in the period the adjustment arises.
Valuation of Goodwill and Other Long-Lived Assets
The valuation of goodwill and other long-lived assets includes various assumptions and are considered critical accounting estimates. Refer to "–Market
Risks" above for additional information.
Mineral Reserves
We regularly evaluate, and engage QPs to review and validate, our mineral reserves and update them as required in accordance with Subpart 1300 of
Regulation S-K. We perform an in-depth evaluation of our mineral reserve estimates by mine on a periodic basis, in addition to routine annual assessments. The
determination of mineral reserves requires us and third-party QPs to make significant estimates and assumptions related to key inputs, including, but not limited to,
(1) the determination of the size and scope of the iron ore body through technical modeling, (2) the estimates of future iron ore prices, production costs and capital
expenditures, and (3) management’s mine plan for the proven and probable mineral reserves. The significant estimates and assumptions could be affected by
future industry conditions, geological conditions and ongoing mine planning. Additional capital and development expenditures may be required to maintain effective
production capacity. Generally, as mining operations progress, haul distances increase. Alternatively, changes in economic conditions or the expected quality of
mineral resources and reserves could decrease effective production capacity. Technological progress could alleviate such factors or increase capacity of mineral
reserves.
We use our mineral reserve estimates, combined with our estimated annual production levels, to determine the mine closure dates utilized in recording the
fair value liability for asset retirement obligations for our active operating mines. Refer to NOTE 14 - ASSET RETIREMENT OBLIGATIONS, for further information.
Since the liability represents the present value of the expected future obligation, a significant change in mineral reserves or mine lives could have a substantial
effect on the recorded obligation. We also utilize mineral reserves for evaluating potential impairments of mine asset groups as they are indicative of future cash
flows and in determining maximum useful lives utilized to calculate depreciation, depletion and amortization of long-lived mine assets and in determining the
estimated fair value of mineral reserves established through the purchase price allocation in a business combination. The consolidated asset retirement obligation
balance was $449 million as of December 31, 2021, of which $208 million related to active iron ore mine operations. The total asset balance associated with our
Steelmaking reportable segment was $18,326 million as of December 31, 2021, of which $1,622 million related to long-lived assets associated with our combined
iron ore mine asset groups, and is inclusive of $231 million related to iron ore mineral reserves acquired through the AM USA Transaction. Depreciation, depletion
and amortization expense for our combined iron ore mine asset groups was $172 million for the year ended December 31, 2021. Increases or decreases in mineral
reserves or mine lives could significantly affect these items.
Asset Retirement Obligations
The accrued closure obligation is predominantly related to our indefinitely idled and closed iron ore mining operations and provides for contractual and legal
obligations associated with the eventual closure of those operations. We perform an in-depth evaluation of the liability every three years in addition to our routine
annual assessments. In 2020, we employed third-party specialists to assist in the evaluation. Our obligations are determined based on detailed estimates adjusted
for factors that a market participant would consider (e.g., inflation, overhead and profit), which are escalated at an assumed rate of inflation to the estimated closure
dates and then discounted using the current credit-adjusted risk-free interest rate. The estimate also incorporates incremental increases in the closure cost
estimates and changes in estimates of mine lives for our active mine sites. The closure date for each of our active mine sites is determined based on the
exhaustion date of the remaining mineral reserves, which is dependent on our estimate of mineral reserves. The estimated obligations for our active mine sites are
particularly sensitive to the impact of changes in mine lives given the difference between the inflation and discount rates. The closure dates for a majority of our
steelmaking facilities are indefinite, and as such, the asset retirement obligations are recorded at present values using estimated ranges of the economic lives of
the underlying assets. Changes in the base estimates of legal and contractual closure costs due to changes in legal or contractual requirements, available
technology,
71
-- 73 of 411 --
Table of Contents
inflation, overhead or profit rates also could have a significant impact on the recorded obligations. Refer to NOTE 14 - ASSET RETIREMENT OBLIGATIONS, for
further information.
Environmental Remediation Costs
We have a formal policy for environmental protection and remediation. Our obligations for known environmental matters at active and closed operations
have been recognized based on estimates of the cost of investigation and remediation at each facility. If the obligation can only be estimated as a range of possible
amounts, with no specific amount being more likely, the minimum of the range is accrued. Management reviews its environmental remediation sites quarterly to
determine if additional cost adjustments or disclosures are required. The characteristics of environmental remediation obligations, where information concerning the
nature and extent of clean-up activities is not immediately available and which are subject to changes in regulatory requirements, result in a significant risk of
increase to the obligations as they mature. Expected future expenditures are discounted to present value unless the amount and timing of the cash disbursements
cannot be reasonably estimated.
Income Taxes
Our income tax expense, deferred tax assets and liabilities and reserves for unrecognized tax benefits reflect management's best assessment of estimated
future taxes to be paid. We are subject to income taxes in the U.S. and various foreign jurisdictions. Significant judgments and estimates are required in determining
the consolidated income tax expense.
Deferred income taxes arise from temporary differences between tax and financial statement recognition of revenue and expense. In evaluating our ability
to recover our deferred tax assets, we consider all available positive and negative evidence, including scheduled reversals of deferred tax liabilities, projected future
taxable income, tax planning strategies and recent financial operations. In projecting future taxable income, we begin with historical results adjusted for the results
of discontinued operations and changes in accounting policies and incorporate assumptions including the amount of future state, federal and foreign pretax
operating income, the reversal of temporary differences, and the implementation of feasible and prudent tax planning strategies. These assumptions require
significant judgment about the forecasts of future taxable income and are consistent with the plans and estimates we are using to manage the underlying
businesses.
At December 31, 2021 and 2020, we had a valuation allowance of $409 million and $836 million, respectively, against our deferred tax assets. Of these
amounts, $70 million and $439 million relate to the U.S. deferred tax assets at December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively, and $339 million and $397 million relate
to foreign deferred tax assets, respectively.
Our losses in Luxembourg in recent periods represent sufficient negative evidence to require a full valuation allowance against the deferred tax assets in
that jurisdiction. We intend to maintain a valuation allowance against the deferred tax assets related to these operating losses, unless and until sufficient positive
evidence exists to support the realization of such assets.
Changes in tax laws and rates also could affect recorded deferred tax assets and liabilities in the future. The calculation of our tax liabilities involves dealing
with uncertainties in the application of complex tax laws and regulations in various jurisdictions across our global operations. The ultimate impact of U.S. income tax
reform legislation may differ from our current estimates due to changes in the interpretations and assumptions made as well as additional regulatory guidance that
may be issued.
Accounting for uncertainty in income taxes recognized in the financial statements requires that a tax benefit from an uncertain tax position be recognized
when it is more likely than not that the position will be sustained upon examination, including resolutions of any related appeals or litigation processes, based on
technical merits.
We recognize tax liabilities in accordance with ASC 740, Income Taxes , and we adjust these liabilities when our judgment changes because of evaluation
of new information not previously available. Due to the complexity of some of these uncertainties, the ultimate resolution may result in payment that is materially
different from our current estimate of the tax liabilities. These differences will be reflected as increases or decreases to income tax expense in the period in which
they are determined. Refer to NOTE 12 - INCOME TAXES, for further information.
Employee Retirement Benefit Obligations
We offer defined benefit pension plans, defined contribution pension plans and OPEB plans, primarily consisting of retiree healthcare benefits, to most
employees in North America as part of a total compensation and benefits program.
72
-- 74 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following is a summary of our U.S. defined benefit pension and OPEB funding and expense:
Pension OPEB
Funding Expense (Benefit) Funding Expense (Benefit)
2019 $ 16 $ 22 $ 4 $ (2)
2020 50 (31) 25 8
2021 163 (189) 180 86
2022 (Estimated) 4 (179) 138 72
The 2021 pension funding includes $118 million that was deferred as a result of the CARES Act.
Assumptions used in determining the benefit obligations and the value of plan assets for defined benefit pension plans and OPEB plans, primarily
consisting of retiree healthcare benefits, that we offer are evaluated periodically by management. Critical assumptions, such as the discount rate used to measure
the benefit obligations, the expected long-term rate of return on plan assets, the medical care cost trend, and the rate of compensation increase are reviewed
annually.
The following represents weighted-average assumptions used to determine benefit obligations and net benefit costs:
Pension Other Benefits
December 31, December 31,
2021 2020 2021 2020
Discount rate 2.75 % 2.34 % 3.01 % 2.71 %
Compensation rate increase 2.52 2.56 3.00 3.00
Expected return on plan assets 6.84 7.69 5.20 6.82
For the pension plans, the weighted-average expected return on plan assets for 2022 is 6.87%, an increase from 6.84% in 2021. For the OPEB plans, the
weighted-average expected return on plan assets for 2022 is 4.86%, a decrease from 5.20% in 2021.
The following represents assumed weighted-average health care cost trend rates:
December 31,
2021 2020
Health care cost trend rate assumed for next year 2.36 % 6.05
Ultimate health care cost trend rate 4.50 4.59
Year that the ultimate rate is reached 2031 2031
The discount rates used to measure plan liabilities as of the December 31 measurement date are determined individually for each plan. The discount rates
are determined by matching the projected cash flows used to determine the plan liabilities to a projected yield curve of high-quality corporate bonds available at the
measurement date. Discount rates for expense are calculated using the granular approach for each plan.
Depending on the plan, we use either company-specific base mortality tables or tables issued by the Society of Actuaries. We use the Pri-2012 mortality
tables from the Society of Actuaries with adjustments for blue collar, white collar or no collar depending on the plan. On December 31, 2021, the assumed mortality
improvement projection was updated from generational scale MP-2020 to generational scale MP-2021 for the Pri-2012 mortality tables.
1
1
73
-- 75 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Following are sensitivities of potential further changes in these key assumptions on the estimated 2022 pension and OPEB expense and the pension and
OPEB obligations as of December 31, 2021:
(In Millions)
Increase (Decrease) in Expense Increase in
Benefit Obligation
Pension OPEB Pension OPEB
Decrease discount rate 0.25% $ (3) $ 6 $ 147 $ 111
Decrease return on assets 1.00% 54 8 N/A N/A
Changes in actuarial assumptions, including discount rates, employee retirement rates, mortality, compensation levels, plan asset investment performance
and healthcare costs, are determined based on analyses of actual and expected factors. Changes in actuarial assumptions and/or investment performance of plan
assets may have a significant impact on our financial condition due to the magnitude of our retirement obligations.
Refer to NOTE 10 - PENSIONS AND OTHER POSTRETIREMENT BENEFITS for further information.
Forward-Looking Statements
This report contains statements that constitute "forward-looking statements" within the meaning of the federal securities laws. As a general matter, forward-
looking statements relate to anticipated trends and expectations rather than historical matters. Forward-looking statements are subject to uncertainties and factors
relating to our operations and business environment that are difficult to predict and may be beyond our control. Such uncertainties and factors may cause actual
results to differ materially from those expressed or implied by the forward-looking statements. These statements speak only as of the date of this report, and we
undertake no ongoing obligation, other than that imposed by law, to update these statements. Investors are cautioned not to place undue reliance on forward-
looking statements. Uncertainties and risk factors that could affect our future performance and cause results to differ from the forward-looking statements in this
report include, but are not limited to:
• disruptions to our operations relating to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, including the heightened risk that a significant portion of our workforce or on-
site contractors may suffer illness or otherwise be unable to perform their ordinary work functions;
• continued volatility of steel, iron ore and scrap metal market prices, which directly and indirectly impact the prices of the products that we sell to our
customers;
• uncertainties associated with the highly competitive and cyclical steel industry and our reliance on the demand for steel from the automotive industry,
which has been experiencing a trend toward light weighting and supply chain disruptions, such as the semiconductor shortage, that could result in lower
steel volumes being consumed;
• potential weaknesses and uncertainties in global economic conditions, excess global steelmaking capacity, oversupply of iron ore, prevalence of steel
imports and reduced market demand, including as a result of the prolonged COVID-19 pandemic;
• severe financial hardship, bankruptcy, temporary or permanent shutdowns or operational challenges, due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic or
otherwise, of one or more of our major customers, including customers in the automotive market, key suppliers or contractors, which, among other
adverse effects, could lead to reduced demand for our products, increased difficulty collecting receivables, and customers and/or suppliers asserting
force majeure or other reasons for not performing their contractual obligations to us;
• risks related to U.S. government actions with respect to Section 232, the USMCA and/or other trade agreements, tariffs, treaties or policies, as well as
the uncertainty of obtaining and maintaining effective antidumping and countervailing duty orders to counteract the harmful effects of unfairly traded
imports;
• impacts of existing and increasing governmental regulation, including potential environmental regulations relating to climate change and carbon
emissions, and related costs and liabilities, including failure to receive or maintain required operating and environmental permits, approvals, modifications
or other authorizations of, or from, any governmental or regulatory authority and costs related to implementing
74
-- 76 of 411 --
Table of Contents
improvements to ensure compliance with regulatory changes, including potential financial assurance requirements;
• potential impacts to the environment or exposure to hazardous substances resulting from our operations;
• our ability to maintain adequate liquidity, our level of indebtedness and the availability of capital could limit our financial flexibility and cash flow necessary
to fund working capital, planned capital expenditures, acquisitions, and other general corporate purposes or ongoing needs of our business;
• our ability to reduce our indebtedness or return capital to shareholders within the currently expected timeframes or at all;
• adverse changes in credit ratings, interest rates, foreign currency rates and tax laws;
• the outcome of, and costs incurred in connection with, lawsuits, claims, arbitrations or governmental proceedings relating to commercial and business
disputes, environmental matters, government investigations, occupational or personal injury claims, property damage, labor and employment matters, or
suits involving legacy operations and other matters;
• supply chain disruptions or changes in the cost or quality of energy sources, including electricity, natural gas and diesel fuel, or critical raw materials and
supplies, including iron ore, industrial gases, graphite electrodes, scrap metal, chrome, zinc, coke and metallurgical coal;
• problems or disruptions associated with transporting products to our customers, moving manufacturing inputs or products internally among our facilities,
or suppliers transporting raw materials to us;
• uncertainties associated with natural or human-caused disasters, adverse weather conditions, unanticipated geological conditions, critical equipment
failures, infectious disease outbreaks, tailings dam failures and other unexpected events;
• disruptions in, or failures of, our information technology systems, including those related to cybersecurity;
• liabilities and costs arising in connection with any business decisions to temporarily idle or permanently close an operating facility or mine, which could
adversely impact the carrying value of associated assets and give rise to impairment charges or closure and reclamation obligations, as well as
uncertainties associated with restarting any previously idled operating facility or mine;
• our ability to realize the anticipated synergies and benefits of our recent acquisition transactions and to successfully integrate the acquired businesses
into our existing businesses, including uncertainties associated with maintaining relationships with customers, vendors and employees and known and
unknown liabilities we assumed in connection with the acquisitions;
• our level of self-insurance and our ability to obtain sufficient third-party insurance to adequately cover potential adverse events and business risks;
• challenges to maintaining our social license to operate with our stakeholders, including the impacts of our operations on local communities, reputational
impacts of operating in a carbon-intensive industry that produces GHG emissions, and our ability to foster a consistent operational and safety track
record;
• our ability to successfully identify and consummate any strategic capital investments or development projects, cost-effectively achieve planned
production rates or levels, and diversify our product mix and add new customers;
• our actual economic mineral reserves or reductions in current mineral reserve estimates, and any title defect or loss of any lease, license, easement or
other possessory interest for any mining property;
• availability of workers to fill critical operational positions and potential labor shortages caused by the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, as well as our ability
to attract, hire, develop and retain key personnel;
• our ability to maintain satisfactory labor relations with unions and employees;
• unanticipated or higher costs associated with pension and OPEB obligations resulting from changes in the value of plan assets or contribution increases
required for unfunded obligations;
• the amount and timing of any repurchases of our common shares; and
75
-- 77 of 411 --
Table of Contents
• potential significant deficiencies or material weaknesses in our internal control over financial reporting.
For additional factors affecting our businesses, refer to Part I – Item 1A. Risk Factors. You are urged to carefully consider these risk factors.
Item 7A. Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk
Information regarding our market risk is presented under the caption "Market Risks," which is included in Item 7. Management's Discussion and Analysis of
Financial Condition and Results of Operations and is incorporated by reference and made a part hereof.
76
-- 78 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Item 8. Financial Statements and Supplementary Data
Statements of Consolidated Financial Position
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and Subsidiaries
(In Millions)
December 31,
2021 2020
ASSETS
Current assets:
Cash and cash equivalents $ 48 $ 112
Accounts receivable, net 2,154 1,169
Inventories 5,188 3,828
Other current assets 263 189
Total current assets 7,653 5,298
Non-current assets:
Property, plant and equipment, net 9,186 8,743
Goodwill 1,116 1,406
Other non-current assets 1,020 1,324
TOTAL ASSETS $ 18,975 $ 16,771
LIABILITIES AND EQUITY
Current liabilities:
Accounts payable $ 2,073 $ 1,575
Accrued employment costs 585 460
State and local taxes 138 147
Other current liabilities 765 747
Total current liabilities 3,561 2,929
Non-current liabilities:
Long-term debt 5,238 5,390
Pension liability, non-current 578 1,224
OPEB liability, non-current 2,383 2,889
Other non-current liabilities 1,441 1,260
TOTAL LIABILITIES 13,201 13,692
Commitments and contingencies (See Note 20)
Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock - no par value
Authorized, Issued and Outstanding - no shares (2020 - 583,273 shares) — 738
Equity:
Common Shares - par value $ 0.125 per share
Authorized - 1,200,000,000 shares (2020 - 600,000,000 shares);
Issued - 506,832,537 shares (2020 - 506,832,537 shares);
Outstanding - 500,158,955 shares (2020 - 477,517,372 shares) 63 63
Capital in excess of par value of shares 4,892 5,431
Retained deficit (1) (2,989)
Cost of 6,673,582 common shares in treasury (2020 - 29,315,165 shares) (82) (354)
Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) 618 (133)
Total Cliffs shareholders' equity 5,490 2,018
Noncontrolling interest 284 323
TOTAL EQUITY 5,774 2,341
TOTAL LIABILITIES, REDEEMABLE PREFERRED STOCK AND EQUITY $ 18,975 $ 16,771
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
77
-- 79 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Statements of Consolidated Operations
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and Subsidiaries
(In Millions, Except Per Share Amounts)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Revenues $ 20,444 $ 5,354 $ 1,990
Operating costs:
Cost of goods sold (15,910) (5,102) (1,414)
Selling, general and administrative expenses (422) (244) (113)
Acquisition-related costs (20) (90) (7)
Miscellaneous – net (80) (60) (27)
Total operating costs (16,432) (5,496) (1,561)
Operating income (loss) 4,012 (142) 429
Other income (expense):
Interest expense, net (337) (238) (101)
Gain (loss) on extinguishment of debt (88) 130 (18)
Net periodic benefit credits (costs) other than service cost component 210 54 (1)
Other non-operating income 6 3 4
Total other expense (209) (51) (116)
Income (loss) from continuing operations before income taxes 3,803 (193) 313
Income tax benefit (expense) (773) 111 (18)
Income (loss) from continuing operations 3,030 (82) 295
Income (loss) from discontinued operations, net of tax 3 1 (2)
Net income (loss) 3,033 (81) 293
Income attributable to noncontrolling interest (45) (41) —
Net income (loss) attributable to Cliffs shareholders $ 2,988 $ (122) $ 293
Earnings (loss) per common share attributable to Cliffs shareholders - basic
Continuing operations $ 5.62 $ (0.32) $ 1.07
Discontinued operations 0.01 — (0.01)
$ 5.63 $ (0.32) $ 1.06
Earnings (loss) per common share attributable to Cliffs shareholders - diluted
Continuing operations $ 5.35 $ (0.32) $ 1.04
Discontinued operations 0.01 — (0.01)
$ 5.36 $ (0.32) $ 1.03
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
78
-- 80 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Statements of Consolidated Comprehensive Income
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and Subsidiaries
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Net income (loss) $ 3,033 $ (81) $ 293
Other comprehensive income (loss):
Changes in pension and OPEB, net of tax 684 181 (35)
Changes in foreign currency translation (2) 3 —
Changes in derivative financial instruments, net of tax 69 2 —
Total other comprehensive income (loss) 751 186 (35)
Comprehensive income 3,784 105 258
Comprehensive income attributable to noncontrolling interests (45) (41) —
Comprehensive income attributable to Cliffs shareholders $ 3,739 $ 64 $ 258
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
79
-- 81 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Statements of Consolidated Cash Flows
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and Subsidiaries
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
OPERATING ACTIVITIES
Net income (loss) $ 3,033 $ (81) $ 293
Adjustments to reconcile net income (loss) to net cash provided (used) by operating activities:
Depreciation, depletion and amortization 897 308 85
Amortization of inventory step-up 161 96 —
Deferred income taxes 767 (101) 17
Pension and OPEB costs (credits) (103) (23) 20
Loss (gain) on extinguishment of debt 88 (130) 18
Other 139 (70) 93
Changes in operating assets and liabilities, net of business combination:
Receivables and other assets (858) (42) 255
Inventories (1,370) (146) (136)
Pension and OPEB payments and contributions (343) (75) (20)
Payables, accrued expenses and other liabilities 374 6 (57)
Net cash provided (used) by operating activities 2,785 (258) 568
INVESTING ACTIVITIES
Purchase of property, plant and equipment (705) (525) (656)
Acquisition of FPT, net of cash acquired (761) — —
Acquisition of ArcelorMittal USA, net of cash acquired 54 (658) —
Acquisition of AK Steel, net of cash acquired — (869) —
Other investing activities 33 10 12
Net cash used by investing activities (1,379) (2,042) (644)
FINANCING ACTIVITIES
Series B Redeemable Preferred Stock redemption (1,343) — —
Proceeds from issuance of common shares 322 — —
Repurchase of common shares — — (253)
Proceeds from issuance of debt 1,000 1,763 721
Debt issuance costs (20) (76) (7)
Repayments of debt (1,372) (1,023) (729)
Borrowings under credit facilities 5,962 2,060 —
Repayments under credit facilities (5,889) (550) —
Other financing activities (130) (115) (126)
Net cash provided (used) by financing activities (1,470) 2,059 (394)
Net decrease in cash and cash equivalents (64) (241) (470)
Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of year 112 353 823
Cash and cash equivalents at end of year $ 48 $ 112 $ 353
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
80
-- 82 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Statements of Consolidated Changes in Equity
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and Subsidiaries
(In Millions)
Cliffs Shareholders
Number
of
Common
Shares Outstanding
Par Value of
Common
Shares Issued
Capital in
Excess of
Par Value
of Shares
Retained
Earnings
(Deficit)
Common
Shares
in
Treasury
AOCI
(Loss)
Non-
controlling
Interest Total
December 31, 2018 293 $ 37 $ 3,917 $ (3,060) $ (186) $ (284) $ — $ 424
Comprehensive income (loss) — — — 293 — (35) — 258
Stock and other incentive plans 2 — (44) — 48 — — 4
Common share repurchases (24) — — — (253) — — (253)
Common share dividends ($0.27 per share) — — — (75) — — — (75)
December 31, 2019 271 $ 37 $ 3,873 $ (2,842) $ (391) $ (319) $ — $ 358
Comprehensive income (loss) — — — (122) — 186 41 105
Stock and other incentive plans 2 — (24) — 37 — — 13
Acquisition of AK Steel 127 16 602 — — — 330 948
Acquisition of ArcelorMittal USA 78 10 980 — — — 13 1,003
Common share dividends ($0.06 per share) — — — (25) — — — (25)
Net distributions to noncontrolling interests — — — — — — (61) (61)
December 31, 2020 478 $ 63 $ 5,431 $ (2,989) $ (354) $ (133) $ 323 $ 2,341
Comprehensive income (loss) — — — 2,988 — 751 45 3,784
Issuance of common shares 20 — 78 — 244 — — 322
Stock and other incentive plans 2 — (8) — 28 — — 20
Series B Redeemable Preferred Stock redemption — — (604) — — — — (604)
1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes
redemption — — (5) — — — — (5)
Acquisition of ArcelorMittal USA - Measurement
period adjustments — — — — — — (22) (22)
Net distributions to noncontrolling interests — — — — — (62) (62)
December 31, 2021 500 $ 63 $ 4,892 $ (1) $ (82) $ 618 $ 284 $ 5,774
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
81
-- 83 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and Subsidiaries
NOTE 1 - BASIS OF PRESENTATION AND SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES
Business, Consolidation and Presentation
Nature of Business
Cliffs is the largest flat-rolled steel producer in North America. Founded in 1847 as a mine operator, we are also the largest manufacturer of iron ore pellets
in North America. We are vertically integrated from mined raw materials, direct reduced iron and ferrous scrap to primary steelmaking and downstream finishing,
stamping, tooling and tubing. We serve a diverse range of markets due to our comprehensive offering of flat-rolled steel products and are the largest supplier of
steel to the automotive industry in North America. Headquartered in Cleveland, Ohio, we employ approximately 26,000 people across our operations in the United
States and Canada.
Unless otherwise noted, discussion of our business and results of operations in this Annual Report on Form 10-K refers to our continuing operations.
Acquisition of FPT
On November 18, 2021, we completed the acquisition of FPT. FPT is a leading prime ferrous scrap processor in the U.S. FPT's operations consist of 22
scrap facilities located primarily in the Midwest region of the United States.
Refer to NOTE 3 - ACQUISITIONS for further information.
Business Operations
We are organized into four operating segments based on differentiated products, Steelmaking, Tubular, Tooling and Stamping, and European Operations.
We primarily operate through one reportable segment – the Steelmaking segment.
Basis of Consolidation
The condensed consolidated financial statements consolidate our accounts and the accounts of our wholly owned subsidiaries, all subsidiaries in which we
have a controlling interest and VIEs for which we are the primary beneficiary. All intercompany transactions and balances are eliminated upon consolidation.
Investments in Affiliates
We have investments in several businesses accounted for using the equity method of accounting. These investments are included within our Steelmaking
segment. We review an investment for impairment when circumstances indicate that a loss in value below its carrying amount is other than temporary.
As of December 31, 2019, our 23% ownership in Hibbing was recorded as an equity method investment. As a result of the acquisition of ArcelorMittal USA,
we acquired an additional 62.3% ownership interest in Hibbing. As of both December 31, 2021 and December 31, 2020, our ownership in the Hibbing joint venture
was 85.3% and was fully consolidated within our operating results with a noncontrolling interest.
Our investment in affiliates of $ 128 million and $ 105 million as of December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively, was classified in Other non-current assets.
Significant Accounting Policies
We consider the following policies to be beneficial in understanding the judgments involved in the preparation of our consolidated financial statements and
the uncertainties that could impact our financial condition, results of operations and cash flows. Certain prior period amounts have been reclassified to conform with
the current year presentation.
Use of Estimates
The preparation of financial statements in conformity with GAAP requires management to make estimates and assumptions that affect the reported
amounts of assets and liabilities and disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the financial statements and the reported amounts of revenues and
expenses during the
82
-- 84 of 411 --
Table of Contents
reporting period. Our mineral reserves; future realizable cash flow; environmental, reclamation and closure obligations; valuation of business combinations, long-
lived assets, inventory, tax assets and post-employment, post-retirement and other employee benefit liabilities; reserves for contingencies and litigation require the
use of various management estimates and assumptions. Actual results could differ from estimates. Management reviews its estimates on an ongoing basis.
Changes in facts and circumstances may alter such estimates and affect the results of operations and financial position in future periods.
Business Combinations
Assets acquired and liabilities assumed in a business combination are recognized and measured based on their estimated fair values at the acquisition
date, while the acquisition-related costs are expensed as incurred. Any excess of the purchase consideration when compared to the fair value of the net tangible
and intangible assets acquired, if any, is recorded as goodwill. We engaged independent valuation specialists to assist with the determination of the fair value of
assets acquired, liabilities assumed, noncontrolling interest, and goodwill, for the acquisitions. If the initial accounting for the business combination is incomplete by
the end of the reporting period in which the acquisition occurs, an estimate will be recorded. Subsequent to the acquisition date, and not later than one year from
the acquisition date, we will record any material adjustments to the initial estimate based on new information obtained that would have existed as of the date of the
acquisition. Any adjustment that arises from information obtained that did not exist as of the date of the acquisition will be recorded in the period the adjustment
arises.
Cash and Cash Equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents include cash on hand and on deposit as well as all short-term securities held for the primary purpose of general liquidity. We
routinely monitor and evaluate counterparty credit risk related to the financial institutions in which our short-term investment securities are held. Where right of offset
exists, we report cash balances net.
Trade Accounts Receivable and Allowance for Credit Loss
Trade accounts receivable are recorded at the point control transfers and represent the amount of consideration we expect to receive in exchange for
transferred goods and do not bear interest. We establish provisions for expected lifetime losses on accounts receivable at the time a receivable is recorded based
on historical experience, customer credit quality and forecasted economic conditions. We regularly review our accounts receivable balances and the allowance for
credit loss and establish or adjust the allowance as necessary using the specific identification method in accordance with CECL. We evaluate the aggregation and
risk characteristics of receivable pools and develop loss rates that reflect historical collections, current forecasts of future economic conditions over the time horizon
we are exposed to credit risk, and payment terms or conditions that may materially affect future forecasts.
Inventories
Inventories are generally stated at the lower of cost or net realizable value using average cost, excluding depreciation and amortization. Certain iron ore
inventories are stated at the lower of cost or market using the LIFO method.
Refer to NOTE 2 - SUPPLEMENTARY FINANCIAL STATEMENT INFORMATION for further information.
Derivative Financial Instruments and Hedging Activities
We are exposed to certain risks related to the ongoing operations of our business, including those caused by changes in commodity prices and energy
rates. We have established policies and procedures, including the use of certain derivative instruments, to manage such risks.
Derivative financial instruments are recognized as either assets or liabilities in the Statements of Consolidated Financial Position and measured at fair
value. On the date a qualifying hedging instrument is executed, we designate the hedging instrument as a hedge of the variability of cash flows to be received or
paid related to a forecasted transaction (cash flow hedge). We formally document all relationships between hedging instruments and hedged items, as well as our
risk-management objective and strategy for undertaking various hedge transactions. This process includes linking all derivatives that are designated as cash flow
hedges to specific firm commitments or forecasted transactions. We also formally assess, both at the hedge's inception and on an ongoing basis, whether the
derivatives that are used in hedging transactions are highly effective in offsetting changes in cash flows of the related hedged items. When it is determined that a
derivative is not highly effective as a hedge, we discontinue hedge
83
-- 85 of 411 --
Table of Contents
accounting prospectively and record all future changes in fair value in the period of the instrument's earnings or losses.
For derivative instruments that have been designated as cash flow hedges, the changes in fair value are recorded in Accumulated other comprehensive
income (loss). Amounts recorded in Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) are reclassified to earnings or losses in the period the underlying hedged
transaction affects earnings or when the underlying hedged transaction is no longer reasonably possible of occurring.
For derivative instruments that have not been designated as cash flow hedges, changes in fair value are recorded in the period of the instrument's earnings
or losses.
Property, Plant and Equipment
Our properties are stated at cost less accumulated depreciation. Depreciation of plant and equipment is computed principally by the straight-line method
based on estimated useful lives. Depreciation continues to be recognized when operations are idled temporarily. Depreciation and depletion are recorded over the
following estimated useful lives:
Asset Class Basis Life
Land, land improvements and mineral rights
Land and mineral rights Units of production Life of mine
Land improvements Straight line 20 to 45 years
Buildings Straight line 20 to 45 years
Equipment Straight line/Double declining balance 3 to 27 years
Refer to NOTE 6 - PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT for further information.
Goodwill
Goodwill represents the excess purchase price paid over the fair value of the net assets from an acquisition. Goodwill is not amortized for financial
statement purposes, but it is assessed for impairment on an annual basis on October 1 (or more frequently if necessary).
Refer to NOTE 3 - ACQUISITIONS and NOTE 7 - GOODWILL AND INTANGIBLE ASSETS AND LIABILITIES for further information.
Other Intangible Assets and Liabilities
Intangible assets and liabilities are subject to periodic amortization on a straight-line basis over their estimated useful lives.
Refer to NOTE 3 - ACQUISITIONS and NOTE 7 - GOODWILL AND INTANGIBLE ASSETS AND LIABILITIES for further information.
Leases
We determine if an arrangement contains a lease at inception. We recognize right-of-use assets and lease liabilities associated with leases based on the
present value of the future minimum lease payments over the lease term at the commencement date. Lease terms reflect options to extend or terminate the lease
when it is reasonably certain that the option will be exercised. For short-term leases (leases with an initial lease term of 12 months or less), right-of-use assets and
lease liabilities are not recognized in the consolidated balance sheet. Operating lease expense is recognized on a straight-line basis over the lease term.
Refer to NOTE 13 - LEASE OBLIGATIONS for further information.
Asset Impairment
We monitor conditions that may affect the carrying value of our long-lived tangible and intangible assets when events and circumstances indicate that the
carrying value of the asset groups may not be recoverable. In order to determine if assets have been impaired, assets are grouped and tested at the lowest level for
which identifiable, independent cash flows are available ("asset group"). The measurement of the impairment loss to be recognized is
84
-- 86 of 411 --
Table of Contents
based on the difference between the fair value and the carrying value of the asset group. Fair value can be determined using a market approach, income approach
or cost approach.
For the years ended December 31, 2021, 2020 and 2019, no impairment indicators were present that would indicate the carrying value of any of our asset
groups may not be recoverable; as a result, no impairment assessments were required.
Fair Value Measurements
ASC Topic 820, Fair Value Measurements and Disclosures , establishes a three-level valuation hierarchy for classification of fair value measurements. The
valuation hierarchy is based upon the transparency of inputs to the valuation of an asset or liability as of the measurement date. Inputs refer broadly to the
assumptions that market participants would use in pricing an asset or liability. Inputs may be observable or unobservable. Observable inputs are inputs that reflect
the assumptions market participants would use in pricing the asset or liability developed based on market data obtained from independent sources. Unobservable
inputs are inputs that reflect our own views about the assumptions market participants would use in pricing the asset or liability developed based on the best
information available in the circumstances. The three-tier hierarchy of inputs is summarized below:
• Level 1 — Valuation is based upon quoted prices (unadjusted) for identical assets or liabilities in active markets.
• Level 2 — Valuation is based upon quoted prices for similar assets and liabilities in active markets, or other inputs that are observable for the asset or
liability, either directly or indirectly, for substantially the full term of the financial instrument.
• Level 3 — Valuation is based upon other unobservable inputs that are significant to the fair value measurement.
The classification of assets and liabilities within the valuation hierarchy is based upon the lowest level of input that is significant to the fair value
measurement in its entirety.
Refer to NOTE 9 - FAIR VALUE OF FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS and NOTE 10 - PENSIONS AND OTHER POSTRETIREMENT BENEFITS for further
information.
Pensions and Other Postretirement Benefits
We offer defined benefit pension plans, defined contribution pension plans and OPEB plans, primarily consisting of retiree healthcare benefits as part of our
total compensation and benefits programs.
We recognize the funded or unfunded status of our pension and OPEB obligations on the Statements of Consolidated Financial Position based on the
difference between the market value of plan assets and the actuarial present value of our retirement obligations on that date, on a plan-by-plan basis. If the plan
assets exceed the pension and OPEB obligations, the amount of the surplus is recorded as an asset; if the pension and OPEB obligations exceed the plan assets,
the amount of the underfunded obligations is recorded as a liability. Year-end balance sheet adjustments to pension and OPEB assets and obligations are recorded
as Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) in the Statements of Consolidated Financial Position.
The actuarial estimates of the PBO and APBO incorporate various assumptions including the discount rates, the rates of increases in compensation,
healthcare cost trend rates, mortality, retirement timing and employee turnover. The discount rate is determined based on the prevailing year-end rates for high-
grade corporate bonds with a duration matching the expected cash flow timing of the benefit payments from the various plans. The remaining assumptions are
based on our estimates of future events by incorporating historical trends and future expectations. The amount of net periodic cost that is recorded in the
Statements of Consolidated Operations consists of several components including service cost, interest cost, expected return on plan assets, and amortization of
previously unrecognized amounts. Service cost represents the value of the benefits earned in the current year by the participants. Interest cost represents the cost
associated with the passage of time. Certain items, such as plan amendments, gains and/or losses resulting from differences between actual and assumed results
for demographic and economic factors affecting the obligations and assets of the plans, and changes in other assumptions are subject to deferred recognition for
income and expense purposes. The expected return on plan assets is calculated on a plan-by-plan basis using each plan's strategic asset allocation and our
expected long-term capital market return assumptions. Service costs are classified within Cost of goods sold, Selling, general and administrative expenses and
Miscellaneous – net while the interest cost, expected return on assets, amortization of prior service costs/credits,
85
-- 87 of 411 --
Table of Contents
net actuarial gain/loss, and other costs are classified within Net periodic benefit credits (costs) other than service cost component.
Refer to NOTE 10 - PENSIONS AND OTHER POSTRETIREMENT BENEFITS for further information.
Labor Agreements
At December 31, 2021, we employed approximately 26,000 people, of which approximately 18,500 were represented by labor unions under various
agreements. We have ten agreements that expire in 2022 and three agreements that expire in 2023. Workers at some of our North American facilities are covered
by agreements with the USW, UAW and IAM, as well as several other smaller unions that have various expiration dates.
Asset Retirement Obligations
Asset retirement obligations are recognized when incurred and recorded as liabilities at fair value. The fair value of the liability is determined as the
discounted value of the expected future cash flows. The asset retirement obligation is accreted over time through periodic charges to earnings. In addition, the
asset retirement cost is capitalized and amortized over the life of the related asset. Reclamation costs are adjusted periodically to reflect changes in the estimated
present value resulting from the passage of time and revisions to the estimates of either the timing or amount of the reclamation costs. We review, on an annual
basis, unless otherwise deemed necessary, the asset retirement obligation for each applicable operation in accordance with the provisions of ASC Topic 410,
Asset Retirement and Environmental Obligations. We perform an in-depth evaluation of the liability every three years in addition to our routine annual assessments.
Future reclamation costs for inactive operations are accrued based on management’s best estimate at the end of each period of the costs expected to be
incurred at a site. Such cost estimates include, where applicable, ongoing maintenance and monitoring costs. Changes in estimates at inactive operations are
reflected in earnings in the period an estimate is revised.
Refer to NOTE 14 - ASSET RETIREMENT OBLIGATIONS for further information.
Environmental Remediation Costs
Certain of our operating activities are subject to various laws and regulations governing protection of the environment. We conduct our operations to protect
the public health and environment and believe our operations are in compliance with applicable laws and regulations in all material respects. Our environmental
liabilities, including obligations for known environmental remediation exposures, have been recognized based on the estimated cost of investigation and
remediation at each site. If the cost can only be estimated as a range of possible amounts with no point in the range being more likely, the minimum of the range is
accrued. Future expenditures are discounted unless the amount and timing of the cash disbursements cannot be reasonably estimated. It is possible that additional
environmental obligations could be incurred, the extent of which cannot be assessed. Potential insurance recoveries have not been reflected in the determination
of the liabilities.
Refer to NOTE 20 - COMMITMENTS AND CONTINGENCIES for further information.
Revenue Recognition
Sales are recognized when our performance obligations are satisfied. Generally, our performance obligations are satisfied, control of our products is
transferred and revenue is recognized at a single point in time, when title transfers to our customer for product shipped according to shipping terms. Shipping and
other transportation costs charged to customers are treated as fulfillment activities and are recorded in both revenue and cost of sales at the time control is
transferred to the customer.
Refer to NOTE 4 - REVENUES for further information.
Repairs and Maintenance
Repairs, maintenance and replacement of components are expensed as incurred. The cost of major equipment overhauls is capitalized and depreciated
over the estimated useful life, which is the period until the next scheduled overhauls. All other planned and unplanned repairs and maintenance costs are expensed
when incurred.
86
-- 88 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Share-Based Compensation
The fair value of each performance share grant is estimated on the date of grant using a Monte Carlo simulation to forecast relative TSR performance. A
correlation matrix of historical and projected stock prices was developed for both the Company and its predetermined peer group of mining and metals companies.
The fair value assumes that the performance objective will be achieved. The expected term of the grant represents the time from the grant date to the end of the
service period. We estimate the volatility of our common shares and that of the peer group of mining and metals companies using daily price intervals for all
companies. The risk-free interest rate is the rate at the grant date on zero-coupon government bonds, with a term commensurate with the remaining performance
period.
The fair value of the restricted stock units is determined based on the closing price of our common shares on the grant date.
Upon vesting of share-based compensation awards, we issue shares from treasury shares before issuing new shares. Forfeitures are recognized when
they occur.
The fair value of stock options is estimated on the date of grant using a Black-Scholes model using the grant date price of our common shares, the option
exercise price, the option’s expected term, the volatility of our common shares, the risk-free interest rate and the dividend yield over the option’s expected term.
Refer to NOTE 11 - STOCK COMPENSATION PLANS for additional information.
Income Taxes
Income taxes are based on income for financial reporting purposes, calculated using tax rates by jurisdiction, and reflect a current tax liability or asset for
the estimated taxes payable or recoverable on the current year tax return and expected annual changes in deferred taxes. Any interest or penalties on income tax
are recognized as a component of Income tax benefit (expense) .
We account for income taxes under the asset and liability method, which requires the recognition of deferred tax assets and liabilities for the expected
future tax consequences of events that have been included in the financial statements. Under this method, deferred tax assets and liabilities are determined based
on the differences between the financial statement and tax basis of assets and liabilities using enacted tax rates in effect for the year in which the differences are
expected to reverse. The effect of a change in tax rates on deferred tax assets and liabilities is recognized within Net income (loss) in the period that includes the
enactment date.
We record net deferred tax assets to the extent we believe these assets will more likely than not be realized. In making such determination, we consider all
available positive and negative evidence, including scheduled reversals of deferred tax liabilities, projected future taxable income, tax planning strategies and
recent financial results of operations.
Accounting for uncertainty in income taxes recognized in the financial statements requires that a tax benefit from an uncertain tax position be recognized
when it is more likely than not that the position will be sustained upon examination, including resolutions of any related appeals or litigation processes, based on
technical merits.
Refer to NOTE 12 - INCOME TAXES for further information.
Foreign Currency
Our financial statements are prepared with the U.S. dollar as the reporting currency, and the functional currency of all subsidiaries is the U.S. dollar, except
for our European Operations for which the functional currency is the Euro.
Earnings Per Share
We present both basic and diluted EPS amounts for continuing operations and discontinued operations. Total basic EPS amounts are calculated by
dividing Net income (loss) attributable to Cliffs shareholders , less the earnings allocated to our Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock, by the weighted
average number of common shares outstanding during the period presented.
Total diluted EPS amounts are calculated by dividing Net income (loss) attributable to Cliffs shareholders by the weighted average number of common
shares, common share equivalents under stock plans using the treasury-stock method, common share equivalents of the Series B Participating Redeemable
Preferred Stock using the if-
87
-- 89 of 411 --
Table of Contents
converted method and the calculated common share equivalents in excess of the conversion rate related to our 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes using the
treasury-stock method. Common share equivalents are excluded from EPS computations in the periods in which they have an anti-dilutive effect.
Refer to NOTE 8 - DEBT AND CREDIT FACILITIES and NOTE 19 - EARNINGS PER SHARE for further information.
Variable Interest Entities
We assess whether we have a variable interest in legal entities in which we have a financial relationship and, if so, whether or not those entities are VIEs.
A VIE is an entity with insufficient equity at risk for the entity to finance its activities without additional subordinated financial support or in which equity investors
lack the characteristics of a controlling financial interest. If an entity is determined to be a VIE, we evaluate whether we are the primary beneficiary. The primary
beneficiary analysis is a qualitative analysis based on power and economics. We conclude that we are the primary beneficiary and consolidate the VIE if we have
both (i) the power to direct the activities of the VIE that most significantly influence the VIE's economic performance and (ii) the obligation to absorb losses of, or the
right to receive benefits from, the VIE that could potentially be significant to the VIE.
Refer to NOTE 18 - VARIABLE INTEREST ENTITIES for additional information.
Recent Accounting Pronouncements
Issued and Not Effective
In August 2020, the FASB issued ASU 2020-06, Debt—Debt with Conversion and Other Options (Subtopic 470-20) and Derivatives and Hedging—
Contracts in Entity’s Own Equity (Subtopic 815-40). This update requires certain convertible instruments to be accounted for as a single liability measured at its
amortized cost. Additionally, the update requires the use of the "if-converted" method, removing the treasury stock method, when calculating diluted shares. The
two methods of adoption are the full and modified retrospective approaches. We expect to utilize the modified retrospective approach. Using this approach, the
guidance shall be applied to transactions outstanding as of the beginning of the fiscal year in which the amendment is adopted. Subsequent to the year ended
December 31, 2021, we redeemed all of our outstanding 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes; therefore, there will be no impact as a result of our adoption of this
update as of January 1, 2022. Refer to NOTE 21 - SUBSEQUENT EVENTS for further information.
NOTE 2 - SUPPLEMENTARY FINANCIAL STATEMENT INFORMATION
Allowance for Credit Losses
The following is a roll-forward of our allowance for credit losses associated with Accounts receivable, net:
(In Millions)
2021 2020
Allowance for credit losses as of January 1 $ (5) $ —
Decrease (increase) in allowance 1 (5)
Allowance for credit losses as of December 31 $ (4) $ (5)
88
-- 90 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Inventories
The following table presents the detail of our Inventories in the Statements of Consolidated Financial Position:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020
Product inventories
Finished and semi-finished goods $ 2,814 $ 2,125
Raw materials 2,070 1,431
Total product inventories 4,884 3,556
Manufacturing supplies and critical spares 304 272
Inventories $ 5,188 $ 3,828
The excess of current cost over LIFO cost of iron ore inventories was $ 124 million and $104 million at December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively. As of
December 31, 2021, the product inventory balance for iron ore inventories increased, resulting in a LIFO increment in 2021. The effect of the inventory build was an
increase in Inventories of $45 million in the Statements of Consolidated Operations for the year ended December 31, 2021. As of December 31, 2020, the product
inventory balance for iron ore inventories decreased, resulting in the liquidation of a LIFO layer. The effect of the inventory reduction was an increase in Cost of
goods sold of $30 million in the Statements of Consolidated Operations for the year ended December 31, 2020.
Cash Flow Information
A reconciliation of capital additions to cash paid for capital expenditures is as follows:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Capital additions $ 857 $ 483 $ 690
Less:
Non-cash accruals 102 (86) 15
Right-of-use assets - finance leases 50 44 29
Grants — — (10)
Cash paid for capital expenditures including deposits $ 705 $ 525 $ 656
Cash payments (receipts) for interest and income taxes are as follows:
(In Millions)
2021 2020 2019
Taxes paid on income $ 166 $ 5 $ —
Income tax refunds (16) (120) (118)
Interest paid on debt obligations net of capitalized interest 299 170 98
Capitalized interest was $6 million, $53 million and $25 million for the years ended December 31, 2021, 2020 and 2019, respectively.
1
1
89
-- 91 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Other Non-Cash Investing and Financing Activities
(In Millions)
2021 2020 2019
Fair value of settlement of a pre-existing relationship as part of consideration in connection with FPT
Acquisition $ (20) $ — $ —
Fair value of common shares issued as part of consideration in connection with AM USA Transaction — 990 —
Fair value of Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock issued as part of consideration in connection
with AM USA Transaction — 738 —
Fair value of settlement of a pre-existing relationship as part of consideration in connection with AM USA
Transaction — 237 —
Fair value of common shares issued as consideration in connection with AK Steel Merger — 618 —
Fair value of equity awards assumed in connection with AK Steel Merger — 4 —
NOTE 3 - ACQUISITIONS
In 2020, we acquired two major steelmakers, AK Steel and ArcelorMittal USA, vertically integrating our legacy iron ore business with steel production. In
2021, we also entered into the scrap business with the FPT Acquisition. We are vertically integrated from mined raw materials, direct reduced iron and ferrous
scrap to primary steelmaking and downstream finishing, stamping, tooling and tubing. We now have a presence across the entire steel manufacturing process,
from mining to pelletizing to the development and production of finished high value steel products. The AK Steel Merger combined Cliffs, a historic producer of iron
ore pellets, with AK Steel, a producer of flat-rolled carbon, stainless and electrical steel products, to create a vertically integrated producer of value-added iron ore
and steel products. The AM USA Transaction transformed us into a fully-integrated steel enterprise with the size and scale to expand product offerings and improve
through-the-cycle margins. The FPT Acquisition gives us a competitive advantage in sourcing prime scrap, a key raw material for our steelmaking facilities.
FPT Acquisition
Overview
On November 18, 2021, pursuant to the FPT Acquisition Agreement, we completed the FPT Acquisition, in which we were the acquirer. Following the FPT
Acquisition, the operating results of FPT are included in our consolidated financial statements. For the period subsequent to the FPT Acquisition (November 18,
2021 through December 31, 2021), FPT generated Revenues of $153 million and a loss of $ 18 million included within Net income (loss) attributable to Cliffs
shareholders, which included $22 million related to amortization of the fair value inventory step-up.
Additionally, we incurred acquisition-related costs, excluding severance costs, of $ 1 million for the year ended December 31, 2021 in connection with the
FPT Acquisition, which was recorded in Acquisition-related costs on the Statements of Consolidated Operations .
The fair value of the total purchase consideration was determined as follows:
(In Millions)
Cash consideration (subject to customary working capital adjustments) $ 775
Fair value of settlement of a pre-existing relationship (20)
Total purchase consideration $ 755
The cash portion of the purchase price is subject to customary working capital adjustments. Additionally, if the Company decides to make any elections
under Section 338(h)(10) of the IRC with respect to entities acquired in connection with the FPT Acquisition, the final cash consideration could potentially change.
Valuation Assumption and Purchase Price Allocation
We estimated fair values at November 18, 2021 for the preliminary allocation of consideration to the net tangible and intangible assets acquired and
liabilities assumed in connection with the FPT Acquisition. During the measurement period, we will continue to obtain information to assist in finalizing the fair value
of assets acquired and
90
-- 92 of 411 --
Table of Contents
liabilities assumed, which may differ materially from these preliminary estimates. If we determine any measurement period adjustments are material, we will apply
those adjustments, including any related impacts to net income, in the reporting period in which the adjustments are determined. We are in the process of
conducting a valuation of the assets acquired and liabilities assumed related to the FPT Acquisition, most notably, inventories, personal and real property, leases,
investments, deferred taxes, environmental obligations and intangible assets, and the final allocation will be made when completed, including the result of any
identified goodwill. Accordingly, the provisional measurements noted below are preliminary and subject to modification in the future.
The preliminary purchase price allocation to assets acquired and liabilities assumed in the FPT Acquisition was:
(In Millions)
Initial Allocation of
Consideration
Cash and cash equivalents $ 9
Accounts receivable, net 233
Inventories 137
Other current assets 4
Property, plant and equipment 179
Other non-current assets 74
Accounts payable (122)
Accrued employment costs (8)
State and local taxes (1)
Other current liabilities (8)
Other non-current liabilities (21)
Net identifiable assets acquired 476
Goodwill 279
Total net assets acquired $ 755
The goodwill resulting from the FPT Acquisition primarily represents the incremental benefit of providing substantial access to prime scrap for our vertically
integrated steelmaking business, as well as any synergistic benefits to be realized from the FPT Acquisition within our Steelmaking segment.
The preliminary purchase price allocated to identifiable intangible assets acquired was:
(In Millions)
Weighted Average Life (In
Years)
Customer relationships $ 18 15
Supplier relationships 18 18
Trade names and trademarks 7 15
Total identifiable intangible assets $ 43 16
Intangible assets are classified as Other non-current assets on the Statements of Consolidated Financial Position.
Acquisition of ArcelorMittal USA
Overview
On December 9, 2020, pursuant to the terms of the AM USA Transaction Agreement, we purchased ArcelorMittal USA from ArcelorMittal. In connection
with the closing of the AM USA Transaction, as contemplated by the terms of the AM USA Transaction Agreement, ArcelorMittal’s former joint venture partner in
Kote and Tek exercised its put right pursuant to the terms of the Kote and Tek joint venture agreements. As a result, we purchased all of such joint venture partner’s
interests in Kote and Tek. Following the closing of the AM USA Transaction, we own 100% of the interests in Kote and Tek.
91
-- 93 of 411 --
Table of Contents
We incurred acquisition-related costs, excluding severance costs, of $ 3 million and $ 26 million for the years ended December 31, 2021 and 2020,
respectively, in connection with the AM USA Transaction, which were recorded in Acquisition-related costs on the Statements of Consolidated Operations.
The fair value of the total purchase consideration was determined as follows:
(In Millions)
Fair value of Cliffs common shares issued $ 990
Fair value of Cliffs Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock issued 738
Fair value of settlement of a pre-existing relationship 237
Cash consideration 639
Total purchase consideration $ 2,604
The fair value of Cliffs common shares issued was calculated as follows:
Number of Cliffs common shares issued 78,186,671
Closing price of Cliffs common share as of December 9, 2020 $ 12.66
Fair value of Cliffs common shares issued (in millions) $ 990
The fair value of Cliffs Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock issued was calculated as follows:
Number of Cliffs Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock issued 583,273
Redemption price per share as of December 9, 2020 $ 1,266
Fair value of Cliffs Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock issued (in millions) $ 738
The fair value of the cash consideration was comprised of the following:
(In Millions)
Cash consideration pursuant to the AM USA Transaction Agreement $ 505
Cash consideration for purchase of the remaining JV partner's interest of Kote and Tek 182
Total cash consideration receivable (48)
Total cash consideration $ 639
The cash portion of the purchase price was subject to customary working capital adjustments, and the working capital adjustments were finalized during
the second quarter of 2021. We made certain elections under Section 338(h)(10) of the IRC with respect to entities acquired in connection with the AM USA
Transaction, which did not change the final cash consideration.
The fair value of the settlement of a pre-existing relationship was comprised of the following:
(In Millions)
Accounts receivable $ 97
Freestanding derivative asset from customer supply agreement 140
Total fair value of settlement of a pre-existing relationship $ 237
92
-- 94 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Valuation Assumption and Purchase Price Allocation
The allocation of consideration to the net tangible and intangible assets acquired and liabilities assumed in connection with the AM USA Transaction was
based on estimated fair values at December 9, 2020, and was finalized during the quarter ended December 31, 2021. The following is a summary of the purchase
price allocation to assets acquired and liabilities assumed in the AM USA Transaction:
(In Millions)
Initial Allocation of
Consideration
Measurement
Period Adjustments
Final Allocation
Consideration as of
December 31, 2021
Cash and cash equivalents $ 35 $ — $ 35
Accounts receivable, net 349 (3) 346
Inventories 2,115 14 2,129
Other current assets 34 2 36
Property, plant and equipment 4,017 387 4,404
Deferred income taxes — 285 285
Other non-current assets 158 7 165
Accounts payable (736) 8 (728)
Accrued employment costs (271) 5 (266)
State and local taxes (76) — (76)
Other current liabilities (453) 23 (430)
Pension liability, non-current (730) — (730)
OPEB liability, non-current (2,465) — (2,465)
Other non-current liabilities (598) (171) (769)
Noncontrolling interest (13) 21 8
Net identifiable assets acquired 1,366 578 1,944
Goodwill 1,230 (570) 660
Total net assets acquired $ 2,596 $ 8 $ 2,604
During the period subsequent to the AM USA Transaction, we made certain measurement period adjustments to the acquired assets and liabilities
assumed due to clarification of information utilized to determine fair value during the measurement period. The measurement period adjustments related to the
revaluation of the Company's previously held equity method investment, which is now being consolidated post-acquisition, resulting in a loss of $31 million, within
Miscellaneous – net for the year ended December 31, 2021.
The goodwill resulting from the acquisition of ArcelorMittal USA primarily represents the growth opportunities in the automotive, construction, appliances,
infrastructure and machinery and equipment markets, as well as any synergistic benefits to be realized from the AM USA Transaction, and was assigned to our flat
steel operations within our Steelmaking segment.
Acquisition of AK Steel
Overview
On March 13, 2020, pursuant to the AK Steel Merger Agreement, we completed the acquisition of AK Steel, in which we were the acquirer. As a result of
the AK Steel Merger, each share of AK Steel common stock issued and outstanding immediately prior to the effective time of the AK Steel Merger (other than
excluded shares) was converted into the right to receive 0.400 Cliffs common shares and, if applicable, cash in lieu of any fractional Cliffs common shares.
We incurred acquisition-related costs, excluding severance costs, of $ 1 million and $26 million for the years ended December 31, 2021 and 2020,
respectively, in connection with the AK Steel Merger, which were recorded in Acquisition-related costs on the Statements of Consolidated Operations.
93
-- 95 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The fair value of the total purchase consideration was determined as follows:
(In Millions)
Fair value of AK Steel debt $ 914
Fair value of Cliffs common shares issued for AK Steel outstanding common stock 618
Other 3
Total purchase consideration $ 1,535
The fair value of Cliffs common shares issued for outstanding shares of AK Steel common stock and with respect to Cliffs common shares underlying
converted AK Steel equity awards that vested upon completion of the AK Steel Merger was calculated as follows:
(In Millions,
Except Per Share Amounts)
Number of shares of AK Steel common stock issued and outstanding 317
Exchange ratio 0.400
Shares of Cliffs common shares issued to AK Steel stockholders 127
Price per share of Cliffs common shares $ 4.87
Fair value of Cliffs common shares issued for outstanding AK Steel common stock $ 618
The fair value of AK Steel's debt included in the consideration was calculated as follows:
(In Millions)
Credit Facility $ 590
7.500% Senior Secured Notes due July 2023 324
Fair value of debt included in consideration $ 914
94
-- 96 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Valuation Assumption and Purchase Price Allocation
The allocation of consideration to the net tangible and intangible assets acquired and liabilities assumed in connection with the AK Steel Merger was based
on estimated fair values at March 13, 2020, and was finalized during the quarter ended March 31, 2021. The following is a summary of the purchase price
allocation to assets acquired and liabilities assumed in the AK Steel Merger:
(In Millions)
Initial Allocation of
Consideration
Measurement Period
Adjustments
Final Allocation of
Consideration as of March 31,
2021
Cash and cash equivalents $ 38 $ 1 $ 39
Accounts receivable, net 666 (2) 664
Inventories 1,563 (243) 1,320
Other current assets 68 (16) 52
Property, plant and equipment 2,184 90 2,274
Deferred income taxes — 69 69
Other non-current assets 475 (4) 471
Accounts payable (636) (8) (644)
Accrued employment costs (94) 1 (93)
State and local taxes (35) 4 (31)
Other current liabilities (276) 2 (274)
Long-term debt (1,179) — (1,179)
Pension liability, non-current (473) 10 (463)
OPEB liability, non-current (400) (8) (408)
Other non-current liabilities (507) 72 (435)
Noncontrolling interest — (1) (1)
Net identifiable assets acquired 1,394 (33) 1,361
Goodwill 141 33 174
Total net assets acquired $ 1,535 $ — $ 1,535
During the period subsequent to the AK Steel Merger, we made certain measurement period adjustments to the acquired assets and liabilities assumed
due to clarification of information utilized to determine fair value during the measurement period.
The goodwill resulting from the acquisition of AK Steel was assigned to our downstream Tubular and Tooling and Stamping operating segments. Goodwill
is calculated as the excess of the purchase price over the net identifiable assets recognized and primarily represents the growth opportunities in light weighting
solutions to automotive customers, as well as any synergistic benefits to be realized. Goodwill from the AK Steel Merger is not expected to be deductible for income
tax purposes.
The purchase price allocated to identifiable intangible assets and liabilities acquired was:
(In Millions)
Weighted Average Life (In
Years)
Intangible assets:
Customer relationships $ 77 18
Developed technology 60 17
Trade names and trademarks 11 10
Total identifiable intangible assets $ 148 17
Intangible liabilities:
Above-market supply contracts $ (71) 12
95
-- 97 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Intangible assets are classified as Other non-current assets on the Statements of Consolidated Financial Position. Intangible liabilities are classified as
Other non-current liabilities on the Statements of Consolidated Financial Position.
The above-market supply contracts relate to the long-term coke and energy supply agreements with SunCoke Energy, which includes SunCoke
Middletown, a consolidated VIE. Refer to NOTE 18 - VARIABLE INTEREST ENTITIES for further information.
Pro Forma Results
2020 Acquisitions
The following table provides unaudited pro forma financial information, prepared in accordance with Topic 805, as if ArcelorMittal USA and AK Steel had
been acquired as of January 1, 2019:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2020 2019
Revenues $ 12,837 $ 17,163
Net income (loss) attributable to Cliffs shareholders (520) (11)
The unaudited pro forma financial information has been calculated after applying our accounting policies and adjusting the historical results with pro forma
adjustments, net of tax, that assume the 2020 Acquisitions occurred on January 1, 2019. Significant pro forma adjustments include the following:
1. The elimination of intercompany revenues between Cliffs and ArcelorMittal USA and AK Steel of $ 844 million and $1,499 million for the years ended
December 31, 2020 and 2019, respectively.
2. The 2020 pro forma net loss was adjusted to exclude $ 96 million of non-recurring inventory acquisition accounting adjustments incurred during the year
ended December 31, 2020. The 2019 pro forma net loss was adjusted to include $362 million of non-recurring inventory acquisition accounting adjustments
for the year ended December 31, 2019.
3. The elimination of non-recurring transaction costs incurred by Cliffs, AK Steel and ArcelorMittal USA in connection with the 2020 Acquisitions were
$93 million for the year ended December 31, 2020. The 2019 pro forma net loss was adjusted to include $93 million of non-recurring transaction cost
adjustments for the year ended December 31, 2019.
4. The 2020 pro forma net loss was adjusted to exclude restructuring costs of $ 1,820 million of non-recurring costs incurred by ArcelorMittal USA prior to the
AM USA Transaction.
5. The 2020 and 2019 pro forma net losses were adjusted to exclude $ 140 million and $129 million for the years ended December 31, 2020 and 2019,
respectively, for the impact of reversal of the fees charged for management, financial and legal services under the Industrial Franchise Agreement with the
former parent.
6. Total other pro forma adjustments included reduced expenses of $ 32 million for the year ended December 31, 2020, primarily due to decreased depreciation
expense and pension and OPEB expense, offset partially by increased interest and amortization expense.
7. Total other pro forma adjustments included an expense of $ 76 million for the year ended December 31, 2019, primarily due to increased interest,
amortization and pension and OPEB expense, offset partially by decreased depreciation expense.
8. The income tax impact of pro forma transaction adjustments that affect Net income (loss) attributable to Cliffs shareholders at a statutory rate of 24.3%
resulted in an increased benefit to Income tax benefit (expense) of $170 million and $117 million for the years ended December 31, 2020 and 2019,
respectively.
96
-- 98 of 411 --
Table of Contents
FPT Acquisition
The following table provides unaudited pro forma financial information, prepared in accordance with Topic 805, as if FPT had been acquired as of January
1, 2020:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020
Revenues $ 21,701 $ 13,549
Net income (loss) attributable to Cliffs shareholders 3,074 (526)
The unaudited pro forma financial information has been calculated after applying our accounting policies and adjusting the historical results with pro forma
adjustments, net of tax, that assume the FPT Acquisition occurred on January 1, 2020. There were no significant pro forma adjustments for the FPT Acquisition.
The unaudited pro forma financial information does not reflect the potential realization of synergies or cost savings, nor does it reflect other costs relating to
the integration of the acquired companies. This unaudited pro forma financial information should not be considered indicative of the results that would have actually
occurred if the 2020 Acquisitions had been consummated on January 1, 2019, or if the FPT Acquisition had been consummated on January 1, 2020, nor are they
indicative of future results.
NOTE 4 - REVENUES
We generate our revenue through product sales, in which shipping terms indicate when we have fulfilled our performance obligations and transferred
control of products to our customer. Our revenue transactions consist of a single performance obligation to transfer promised goods. Our contracts with customers
define the mechanism for determining the sales price, which is generally fixed upon transfer of control, but the contracts generally do not impose a specific quantity
on either party. Quantities to be delivered to the customer are determined at a point near the date of delivery through purchase orders or other written instructions
we receive from the customer. Spot market sales are made through purchase orders or other written instructions. We consider our performance obligation to be
complete and recognize revenue when control transfers in accordance with shipping terms.
Revenue is measured as the amount of consideration we expect to receive in exchange for transferring product. We reduce the amount of revenue
recognized for estimated returns and other customer credits, such as discounts and volume rebates, based on the expected value to be realized. Payment terms
are consistent with terms standard to the markets we serve. Sales taxes collected from customers are excluded from revenues.
Prior to the AM USA Transaction, we had a supply agreement with ArcelorMittal USA, which included supplemental revenue or refunds based on the HRC
price in the year the iron ore was consumed in ArcelorMittal USA's blast furnaces. As control transferred prior to consumption, the supplemental revenue was
recorded in accordance with Topic 815. All sales occurring subsequent to the AM USA Transaction are intercompany and eliminated in consolidation. Included
within Revenues related to Topic 815 for the supplemental revenue portion of the supply agreement is derivative revenue of $ 122 million and $78 million for the
years ended December 31, 2020 and 2019, respectively.
97
-- 99 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following table represents our Revenues by market:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Steelmaking:
Automotive $ 4,726 $ 2,062 $ —
Infrastructure and manufacturing 5,380 784 —
Distributors and converters 7,671 696 —
Steel producers 2,124 1,423 1,990
Total Steelmaking 19,901 4,965 1,990
Other Businesses:
Automotive 426 329 —
Infrastructure and manufacturing 47 34 —
Distributors and converters 70 26 —
Total Other Businesses 543 389 —
Total revenues $ 20,444 $ 5,354 $ 1,990
The following table represents our Revenues by product line:
(Dollars In Millions, Sales Volumes in Thousands)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Revenue Volume Revenue Volume Revenue Volume
Steelmaking:
Hot-rolled steel $ 5,615 4,886 $ 386 633 $ — —
Cold-rolled steel 3,186 2,790 490 682 — —
Coated steel 5,864 5,056 1,747 1,911 — —
Stainless and electrical steel 1,622 674 868 416 — —
Plate 1,316 1,020 46 62 — —
Other steel products 1,247 1,460 46 79 — —
Other 1,051 N/A 1,382 N/A 1,990 N/A
Total steelmaking 19,901 4,965 1,990
Other Businesses:
Other 543 N/A 389 N/A — N/A
Total revenues $ 20,444 $ 5,354 $ 1,990
All product volumes are stated in net tons.
Deferred Revenue
The table below summarizes our deferred revenue balances:
(In Millions)
Deferred Revenue (Current) Deferred Revenue (Long-Term)
2021 2020 2021 2020
Opening balance as of January 1 $ 7 $ 22 $ — $ 26
Net increase (decrease) 18 (15) — (26)
Closing balance as of December 31 $ 25 $ 7 $ — $ —
1 1 1
1
98
-- 100 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Prior to the AK Steel Merger, our iron ore pellet sales agreement with Severstal Dearborn, LLC, subsequently assumed by AK Steel, required supplemental
payments to be paid by the customer during the period from 2009 through 2013. Installment amounts received under this arrangement in excess of sales were
classified as deferred revenue in the Statements of Consolidated Financial Position upon receipt of payment and the revenue was recognized over the term of the
supply agreement, which had extended until 2022, in equal annual installments. As a result of the termination of that iron ore pellet sales agreement, we realized
$35 million of deferred revenue, which was recognized within Revenues in the Statements of Consolidated Operations during the year ended December 31, 2020.
NOTE 5 - SEGMENT REPORTING
We are vertically integrated from mined raw materials and direct reduced iron and ferrous scrap to primary steelmaking and downstream finishing,
stamping, tooling and tubing. We are organized into four operating segments based on our differentiated products - Steelmaking, Tubular, Tooling and Stamping,
and European Operations. We have one reportable segment - Steelmaking. The operating segment results of our Tubular, Tooling and Stamping, and European
Operations that do not constitute reportable segments are combined and disclosed in the Other Businesses category. Our Steelmaking segment operates as the
largest flat-rolled steel producer supported by being the largest iron ore pellet producer as well as a leading prime scrap processor in North America, primarily
serving the automotive, infrastructure and manufacturing, and distributors and converters markets. Our Other Businesses primarily include the operating segments
that provide customer solutions with carbon and stainless steel tubing products, advanced-engineered solutions, tool design and build, hot- and cold-stamped steel
components, and complex assemblies. All intersegment transactions were eliminated in consolidation.
We evaluate performance on an operating segment basis, as well as a consolidated basis, based on Adjusted EBITDA, which is a non-GAAP measure.
This measure is used by management, investors, lenders and other external users of our financial statements to assess our operating performance and to compare
operating performance to other companies in the steel industry. In addition, management believes Adjusted EBITDA is a useful measure to assess the earnings
power of the business without the impact of capital structure and can be used to assess our ability to service debt and fund future capital expenditures in the
business.
Our results by segment are as follows:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Revenues:
Steelmaking $ 19,901 $ 4,965 $ 1,990
Other Businesses 543 389 —
Total revenues $ 20,444 $ 5,354 $ 1,990
Adjusted EBITDA:
Steelmaking $ 5,422 $ 433 $ 636
Other Businesses 9 47 —
Corporate and eliminations (169) (127) (111)
Total Adjusted EBITDA $ 5,262 $ 353 $ 525
99
-- 101 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following table provides a reconciliation of our consolidated Net income (loss) to total Adjusted EBITDA:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Net income (loss) $ 3,033 $ (81) $ 293
Less:
Interest expense, net (337) (238) (101)
Income tax benefit (expense) (773) 111 (18)
Depreciation, depletion and amortization (897) (308) (85)
5,040 354 497
Less:
EBITDA from noncontrolling interests 75 56 —
Gain (loss) on extinguishment of debt (88) 130 (18)
Severance costs (15) (38) (2)
Acquisition-related costs excluding severance costs (5) (52) (7)
Acquisition-related loss on equity method investment (31) — —
Amortization of inventory step-up (161) (96) —
Impact of discontinued operations 3 1 (1)
Total Adjusted EBITDA $ 5,262 $ 353 $ 525
EBITDA of noncontrolling interests includes the following:
Net income attributable to noncontrolling interests $ 45 $ 41 $ —
Depreciation, depletion and amortization 30 15 —
EBITDA of noncontrolling interests $ 75 $ 56 $ —
The following table summarizes our depreciation, depletion and amortization and capital additions by segment:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Depreciation, depletion and amortization:
Steelmaking $ 855 $ 276 $ 80
Other Businesses 37 27 —
Corporate 5 5 5
Total depreciation, depletion and amortization $ 897 $ 308 $ 85
Capital additions
Steelmaking $ 787 $ 436 $ 687
Other Businesses 52 45 —
Corporate 18 2 3
Total capital additions $ 857 $ 483 $ 690
Refer to NOTE 2 - SUPPLEMENTARY FINANCIAL STATEMENT INFORMATION for additional information.
1
1
1:
1
100
-- 102 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following summarizes our assets by segment:
(In Millions)
December 31,
2021 2020
Assets:
Steelmaking $ 18,326 $ 15,849
Other Businesses 306 239
Total segment assets 18,632 16,088
Corporate 343 683
Total assets $ 18,975 $ 16,771
Included in the consolidated financial statements are the following amounts relating to geographic location based on product destination:
(In Millions)
2021 2020 2019
Revenues:
United States $ 18,881 $ 4,580 $ 1,505
Canada 803 602 448
Other countries 760 172 37
Total revenues $ 20,444 $ 5,354 $ 1,990
Property, plant and equipment, net:
United States $ 9,092 $ 8,647 $ 1,929
Canada 93 91 —
Other countries 1 5 —
Total property, plant and equipment, net $ 9,186 $ 8,743 $ 1,929
NOTE 6 - PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT
The following table indicates the carrying value of each of the major classes of our depreciable assets:
(In Millions)
December 31,
2021 2020
Land, land improvements, and mineral rights $ 1,291 $ 1,213
Buildings 889 703
Equipment 8,709 6,786
Other 229 151
Construction in progress 408 1,364
Total property, plant and equipment 11,526 10,217
Allowance for depreciation and depletion (2,340) (1,474)
Property, plant, and equipment, net $ 9,186 $ 8,743
Includes right-of-use assets related to finance leases of $411 million and $361 million as of December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively.
We recorded depreciation expense of $ 848 million, $298 million and $ 77 million for the years ended December 31, 2021, 2020 and 2019, respectively.
We recorded capitalized interest into property, plant and equipment of $ 6 million, $53 million and $ 25 million during the years ended December 31, 2021,
2020 and 2019, respectively.
1
1
101
-- 103 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The net book value of the mineral and land rights are as follows:
(In Millions)
December 31,
2021 2020
Mineral rights:
Cost $ 780 $ 773
Depletion (187) (142)
Net mineral rights $ 593 $ 631
Land rights $ 406 $ 361
We recorded depletion expense of $ 46 million, $8 million and $ 8 million for the years ended December 31, 2021, 2020, and 2019, respectively.
NOTE 7 - GOODWILL AND INTANGIBLE ASSETS AND LIABILITIES
Goodwill
The following is a summary of Goodwill by segment:
(In Millions)
December 31,
2021 2020
Steelmaking $ 942 $ 1,232
Other Businesses 174 174
Total goodwill $ 1,116 $ 1,406
The decrease of $290 million in the balance of Goodwill in our Steelmaking segment as of December 31, 2021, compared to December 31, 2020, is due to
the decrease in estimated identified goodwill as a result of measurement period adjustments to the purchase price allocation for the acquisition of ArcelorMittal
USA, partially offset by the increase due to the preliminary assignment of Goodwill in 2021 based on the preliminary purchase price allocation for the acquisition of
FPT. Refer to NOTE 3 - ACQUISITIONS for further details.
102
-- 104 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Intangible Assets and Liabilities
The following is a summary of our intangible assets and liabilities:
(In Millions)
December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020
Gross
Amount Accumulated
Amortization Net Amount Gross Amount Accumulated
Amortization Net Amount
Intangible assets :
Customer relationships $ 95 $ (8) $ 87 $ 77 $ (3) $ 74
Developed technology 60 (6) 54 60 (3) 57
Trade names and trademarks 18 (2) 16 11 (1) 10
Mining permits 72 (26) 46 72 (25) 47
Supplier relationships 18 — 18 — — —
Total intangible assets $ 263 $ (42) $ 221 $ 220 $ (32) $ 188
Intangible liabilities :
Above-market supply contracts $ (71) $ 14 $ (57) $ (71) $ 7 $ (64)
Intangible assets are classified as Other non-current assets. Amortization related to mining permits is recognized in Cost of goods sold. Amortization of all other intangible
assets is recognized in Selling, general and administrative expenses.
Intangible liabilities are classified as Other non-current liabilities. Amortization of all intangible liabilities is recognized inCost of goods sold.
Amortization expense related to intangible assets was $ 10 million and $8 million for the years ended December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively. Estimated
future amortization expense related to intangible assets is $13 million annually for the years 2022 through 2026.
Income from amortization related to intangible liabilities was $ 7 million in both of the years ended December 31, 2021 and 2020. Estimated future
amortization income related to the intangible liabilities is $5 million annually for the years 2022 through 2026.
1
2
1
2
103
-- 105 of 411 --
Table of Contents
NOTE 8 - DEBT AND CREDIT FACILITIES
The following represents a summary of our long-term debt:
(In Millions)
December 31, 2021
Debt Instrument Issuer
Annual
Effective
Interest Rate
Total
Principal
Amount Unamortized Debt
Issuance Costs
Unamortized
Premiums
(Discounts) Total Debt
Senior Secured Notes:
9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes Cliffs 10.57% $ 607 $ (4) $ (13) $ 590
6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes Cliffs 6.99% 845 (16) (7) 822
Senior Unsecured Notes:
1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes Cliffs 6.26% 294 (3) (39) 252
7.000% 2027 Senior Notes Cliffs 9.24% 73 — (7) 66
7.000% 2027 AK Senior Notes AK Steel 9.24% 56 — (5) 51
5.875% 2027 Senior Notes Cliffs 6.49% 556 (3) (15) 538
4.625% 2029 Senior Notes Cliffs 4.63% 500 (8) — 492
4.875% 2031 Senior Notes Cliffs 4.88% 500 (8) — 492
6.250% 2040 Senior Notes Cliffs 6.34% 263 (2) (3) 258
IRBs due 2024 to 2028 AK Steel Various 66 — 2 68
ABL Facility Cliffs 1.87% 4,500 — — 1,609
Total long-term debt $ 5,238
Unless otherwise noted, references in this column and throughout this NOTE 8 - DEBT AND CREDIT FACILITIES to "Cliffs" are to Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., and references to
"AK Steel" are to AK Steel Corporation (n/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Corporation).
Refers to Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. as borrower under our ABL Facility.
The total principal amount for the ABL Facility is stated at the maximum borrowing capacity.
1
3 2
1
2
3
104
-- 106 of 411 --
Table of Contents
(In Millions)
December 31, 2020
Debt Instrument Issuer
Annual Effective
Interest Rate
Total Principal
Amount
Unamortized
Debt Issuance
Costs
Unamortized
Premiums
(Discounts) Total Debt
Senior Secured Notes:
4.875% 2024 Senior Secured Notes Cliffs 5.00% $ 395 $ (3) $ (1) $ 391
9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes Cliffs 10.57% 955 (8) (25) 922
6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes Cliffs 6.99% 845 (20) (9) 816
Senior Unsecured Notes:
7.625% 2021 AK Senior Notes AK Steel 7.33% 34 — — 34
7.500% 2023 AK Senior Notes AK Steel 6.17% 13 — — 13
6.375% 2025 Senior Notes Cliffs 8.11% 64 — (4) 60
6.375% 2025 AK Senior Notes AK Steel 8.11% 29 — (2) 27
1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes Cliffs 6.26% 296 (4) (49) 243
5.750% 2025 Senior Notes Cliffs 6.01% 396 (3) (4) 389
7.000% 2027 Senior Notes Cliffs 9.24% 73 — (8) 65
7.000% 2027 AK Senior Notes AK Steel 9.24% 56 — (6) 50
5.875% 2027 Senior Notes Cliffs 6.49% 556 (4) (18) 534
6.250% 2040 Senior Notes Cliffs 6.34% 263 (2) (3) 258
IRBs due 2024 to 2028 AK Steel Various 92 — 2 94
EDC Revolving Facility * 3.25% 40 — — 18
ABL Facility Cliffs 2.15% 3,500 — — 1,510
Total debt 5,424
Less: current 34
Total long-term debt $ 5,390
*Our subsidiaries, Fleetwood Metal Industries Inc. and The Electromac Group Inc., were the borrowers under the EDC Revolving Facility.
Unless otherwise noted, references in this column and throughout this NOTE 8 - DEBT AND CREDIT FACILITIES to "Cliffs" are to Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., and references to
"AK Steel" are to "AK Steel Corporation (n/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Corporation).
Refers to Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. as borrower under our ABL Facility.
The total principal amounts for the indicated credit facilities are stated at their respective maximum borrowing capacities.
Outstanding Senior Secured Notes
The following represents a summary of our senior secured notes' maturity and interest payable due dates:
Debt Instrument Maturity Interest Payable
(until maturity)
9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes October 17, 2025 April 17 and October 17
6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes March 15, 2026 March 15 and September 15
The senior secured notes of each series are jointly and severally and fully and unconditionally guaranteed on a senior secured basis by substantially all of
our material domestic subsidiaries and are secured (subject in each case to certain exceptions and permitted liens) by (i) a first-priority lien, on a pari passu basis
with the senior secured notes of the other series, on substantially all of our assets and the assets of the guarantors, other than the ABL Collateral (as defined
below), and (ii) a second-priority lien on the ABL Collateral, which is junior to a first-priority lien for the benefit of the lenders under our ABL Facility.
We may redeem the 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes, in whole or in part, at any time at our option upon not less than 30, and not more than 60, days'
prior notice sent to the holders of the 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes. The 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes are redeemable prior to October 17, 2022, at a
redemption price equal to 100% of the principal amount thereof plus a "make-whole" premium set forth in the indenture, plus accrued
1
3
3 2
1
2
3
105
-- 107 of 411 --
Table of Contents
and unpaid interest, if any, to, but not including, the date of redemption. We may also redeem up to 35% of the aggregate principal amount of the 9.875% 2025
Senior Secured Notes prior to October 17, 2022, at a redemption price equal to 109.875% of the principal amount thereof, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any,
to but not including, the date of redemption with the net cash proceeds of one or more equity offerings. On March 11, 2021, we exercised this optional redemption
feature when we purchased $322 million aggregate principal amount of the 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes using the net proceeds from the underwritten
public offering of 20 million common shares. The 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes are redeemable beginning on October 17, 2022, at a redemption price equal
to 107.406% of the principal amount thereof, decreasing on each April 17 thereafter until April 17, 2025, on and after which the 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes
are redeemable at par, in each case, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to, but not including, the date of redemption.
We may redeem the 6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes in whole or in part, at any time at our option upon not less than 30, and not more than 60, days'
prior notice sent to the holders of the 6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes. The 6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes are redeemable prior to March 15, 2022, at a
redemption price equal to 100% of the principal amount thereof plus a "make-whole" premium set forth in the indenture, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to,
but not including, the date of redemption. We may also redeem up to 35% of the aggregate principal amount of the 6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes prior to
March 15, 2022, at a redemption price equal to 106.750% of the principal amount thereof, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to but not including, the date of
redemption with the net cash proceeds of one or more equity offerings. The 6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes are redeemable beginning on March 15, 2022, at a
redemption price equal to 105.063% of the principal amount thereof, decreasing on each March 15 thereafter until March 15, 2025, on and after which the 6.750%
2026 Senior Secured Notes are redeemable at par, in each case, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to, but not including, the date of redemption.
In addition, if a change in control triggering event, as defined in the indenture, occurs with respect to the senior secured notes, we will be required to offer
to purchase the notes at a purchase price equal to 101% of their principal amount, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to, but not including, the date of
purchase.
The terms of the senior secured notes contain certain customary covenants; however, there are no financial covenants.
Outstanding Senior Unsecured Notes
2021 Issuances
On February 17, 2021, we entered into an indenture among Cliffs, the guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank National Association, as trustee, relating to
the issuances of $500 million aggregate principal amount of 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and $ 500 million aggregate principal amount of 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes,
each issued at par. The 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes were issued in private placement transactions exempt from the registration
requirements of the Securities Act.
The 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes are unsecured senior obligations and rank equally in right of payment with all of our
existing and future unsecured and unsubordinated indebtedness. The 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes are guaranteed on a senior
unsecured basis by our material direct and indirect wholly owned domestic subsidiaries and, therefore, are structurally senior to any of our existing and future
indebtedness that is not guaranteed by such guarantors and are structurally subordinated to all existing and future indebtedness and other liabilities of our
subsidiaries that do not guarantee the 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes.
In addition, if a change in control triggering event, as defined in the indenture, occurs with respect to the 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and 4.875% 2031
Senior Notes, we will be required to offer to repurchase the notes at a purchase price equal to 101% of their principal amount, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if
any, to, but not including, the date of repurchase.
The terms of the 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes contain certain customary covenants; however, there are no financial
covenants.
4.625% 2029 Senior Notes
The 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes bear interest at a rate of 4.625% per annum, payable semi-annually in arrears on March 1 and September 1 of each year,
commencing on September 1, 2021. The 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes will mature on March 1, 2029.
106
-- 108 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes may be redeemed, in whole or in part, on not less than 10, nor more than 60, days’ prior notice sent to the holders of the
notes. The following is a summary of redemption prices for our 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes:
Redemption Period Redemption Price Restricted Amount
Prior to March 1, 2024 - using the proceeds of equity issuance 104.625 % Up to 35% of original aggregate
principal
Prior to March 1, 2024 100.000
Beginning March 1, 2024 102.313
Beginning March 1, 2025 101.156
Beginning on March 1, 2026 and thereafter 100.000
Plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, up to, but excluding, the redemption date.
Plus a "make-whole" premium.
4.875% 2031 Senior Notes
The 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes bear interest at a rate of 4.875% per annum, payable semi-annually in arrears on March 1 and September 1 of each year,
commencing on September 1, 2021. The 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes will mature on March 1, 2031.
The 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes may be redeemed, in whole or in part, on not less than 10, nor more than 60, days’ prior notice sent to the holders of the
notes. The following is a summary of redemption prices for our 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes:
Redemption Period Redemption Price Restricted Amount
Prior to March 1, 2026 - using the proceeds of equity issuance 104.875 %
Up to 35% of original aggregate
principal
Prior to March 1, 2026 100.000
Beginning March 1, 2026 102.438
Beginning March 1, 2027 101.625
Beginning March 1, 2028 100.813
Beginning on March 1, 2029 and thereafter 100.000
Plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, up to, but excluding, the redemption date.
Plus a "make-whole" premium.
1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes
The 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes bear interest at a rate of 1.500% per year, payable semiannually in arrears on January 15 and July 15 of each
year. The 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes mature on January 15, 2025. The 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes are senior unsecured obligations and
rank senior in right of payment to any of our indebtedness that is expressly subordinated in right of payment to the 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes; equal in
right of payment to any of our unsecured indebtedness that is not so subordinated; effectively junior in right of payment to any of our secured indebtedness to the
extent of the value of the assets securing such indebtedness; and structurally junior to all indebtedness and other liabilities (including trade payables) of our
subsidiaries. The terms of the 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes contain certain customary covenants; however, there are no financial covenants.
Holders may convert their 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes at their option at any time prior to the close of business on the business day immediately
preceding July 15, 2024, only under the following circumstances: (1) during any calendar quarter commencing after the calendar quarter ending on March 31,
2018, if the last reported sale price of our common shares, par value $0.125 per share, for at least 20 trading days (whether or not consecutive) during a period of
30 consecutive trading days ending on the last trading day of the immediately preceding calendar quarter is greater than or equal to 130% of the conversion price
on each applicable trading day; (2) during the five-business day period after any five-consecutive trading day period (the “measurement period”) in which the
trading price per $1,000 principal amount of 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes for each trading day of
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
107
-- 109 of 411 --
Table of Contents
the measurement period was less than 98% of the product of the last reported sale price of our common shares and the conversion rate on each such trading day;
(3) if we call the notes for redemption, at any time prior to the close of business on the scheduled trading day immediately preceding the redemption date; or (4)
upon the occurrence of specified corporate events. On or after July 15, 2024 until the close of business on the second scheduled trading day immediately
preceding the maturity date, holders may convert their 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes at any time, regardless of the foregoing circumstances. Upon
conversion, we will pay or deliver, as the case may be, cash, common shares or a combination of cash and common shares, at our election.
Upon the issuance of the 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes the initial conversion rate was 122.4365 common shares per $1,000 principal, with a
conversion price of $8.17 per common share. The conversion rate is subject to adjustment in some circumstances, including the payment of dividends on common
shares, but will not be adjusted for any accrued and unpaid interest. In addition, following certain corporate events that occur prior to the maturity date, or if we
deliver a notice of redemption, we will, in certain circumstances, increase the conversion rate for a holder who elects to convert its 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior
Notes in connection with such a corporate event or notice of redemption, as the case may be. As of December 31, 2021, the conversion rate was 129.2985
common shares per $1,000 principal amount of 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes.
We may not redeem the 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes prior to January 15, 2022. We may redeem all or any portion of the 1.500% 2025
Convertible Senior Notes, for cash at our option on or after January 15, 2022 if the last reported sale price of our common shares has been at least 130% of the
conversion price then in effect for at least 20 trading days (whether or not consecutive) during any 30-consecutive trading day period (including the last trading day
of such period) ending on, and including, the trading day immediately preceding the date on which we provide notice of redemption at a redemption price equal to
100% of the principal amount of the 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes to be redeemed, plus accrued and unpaid interest to, but excluding, the redemption
date.
If we undergo a fundamental change as defined in the indenture, holders may require us to repurchase for cash all or any portion of their 1.500% 2025
Convertible Senior Notes at a fundamental change repurchase price equal to 100% of the principal amount of the 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes to be
repurchased, plus accrued and unpaid interest to, but excluding, the fundamental change repurchase date.
In accounting for the issuance of the notes, we separated the 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes into liability and equity components. The carrying
amount of the liability component was calculated by measuring the fair value of similar liabilities that did not have associated convertible features. The carrying
amount of the equity component of $86 million representing the conversion option was determined by deducting the fair value of the liability component from the
par value of the notes. The difference represents the debt discount that is amortized to interest expense over the term of the notes. The equity component is not
remeasured as long as it continues to qualify for equity classification.
On December 1, 2021, we issued a notice of redemption for all $ 294 million aggregate principal amount outstanding of the 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior
Notes. Refer to NOTE 21 - SUBSEQUENT EVENTS for further information on the redemption of the 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes.
Other Outstanding Unsecured Senior Notes
The following represents a summary of our other unsecured senior notes' maturity and interest payable due dates:
Debt Instrument Maturity Interest Payable
(until maturity)
7.000% 2027 Senior Notes March 15, 2027 March 15 and September 15
5.875% 2027 Senior Notes June 1, 2027 June 1 and December 1
6.250% 2040 Senior Notes October 1, 2040 April 1 and October 1
The senior notes are unsecured obligations and rank equally in right of payment with all our other existing and future unsecured and unsubordinated
indebtedness. The 7.000% 2027 Senior Notes and 5.875% 2027 Senior Notes are guaranteed on a senior unsecured basis by our material direct and indirect
wholly owned domestic subsidiaries and, therefore, are structurally senior to any of our existing and future indebtedness that is not guaranteed by such guarantors
and are structurally subordinated to all existing and future indebtedness and other liabilities of our subsidiaries that do not guarantee the notes. There are no
subsidiary guarantees of the interest and principal amounts for the 6.250% 2040 Senior Notes.
108
-- 110 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The 7.000% 2027 Senior Notes may be redeemed, in whole or in part, at any time at our option upon not less than 30, and not more than 60 days' prior
notice sent to the holders. The 7.000% 2027 Senior Notes are redeemable prior to March 15, 2022, at a redemption price equal to 100% of the principal amount
thereof plus a "make-whole" premium set forth in the indenture, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to, but not including, the date of redemption. The 7.000%
2027 Senior Notes are redeemable beginning on March 15, 2022, at a redemption price equal to 103.500% of the principal amount thereof, decreasing on each
March 15 thereafter until March 15, 2025, on and after which the 7.000% 2027 Senior Notes are redeemable at par, in each case, plus accrued and unpaid interest,
if any, to, but not including, the date of redemption.
The 5.875% 2027 Senior Notes are redeemable prior to June 1, 2022, at a redemption price equal to 100% of the principal amount thereof plus a “make-
whole” premium set forth in the indenture, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to, but not including, the date of redemption. We may also redeem up to 35% of
the aggregate principal amount of the 5.875% 2027 Senior Notes prior to June 1, 2022 at a redemption price equal to 105.875% of the principal amount thereof,
plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to, but not including, the date of redemption with the net cash proceeds of one or more equity offerings. The 5.875% 2027
Senior Notes are redeemable beginning on June 1, 2022, at a redemption price equal to 102.938% of the principal amount thereof, decreasing on each June 1
thereafter until June 1, 2025, on and after which the 5.875% 2027 Senior Notes are redeemable at par, in each case, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to,
but not including, the date of redemption.
The 6.250% 2040 Senior Notes may be redeemed any time at our option upon not less than 30, nor more than 60, days' prior notice is sent to the holders.
The 6.250% 2040 Senior Notes are redeemable at a redemption price equal to the greater of (1) 100% of the principal amount of the notes to be redeemed or
(2) the sum of the present values of the remaining scheduled payments of principal and interest on the notes to be redeemed, discounted to the redemption date on
a semi-annual basis at the treasury rate plus 40 basis points, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to, but not including, the date of redemption.
In addition, if a change of control triggering event, as defined in the applicable indenture, occurs with respect to the unsecured notes, we will be required to
offer to purchase the notes of the applicable series at a purchase price equal to 101% of the principal amount, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to, but not
including, the date of purchase.
The terms of the unsecured notes contain certain customary covenants; however, there are no financial covenants.
AK Steel Corporation Unsecured Senior Notes
As of December 31, 2021, AK Steel had outstanding a total of $ 56 million aggregate principal amount of 7.000% 2027 AK Senior Notes. These senior notes
are unsecured obligations and rank equally in right of payment with AK Steel's guarantees of Cliffs' unsecured and unsubordinated indebtedness. These notes
contain no financial covenants.
The 7.000% 2027 AK Senior Notes may be redeemed, in whole or in part, at any time at our option upon not less than 30, and not more than 60, days'
prior notice sent to the holders. The 7.000% 2027 AK Senior Notes are redeemable prior to March 15, 2022, at a redemption price equal to 100% of the principal
amount thereof plus a “make-whole” premium set forth in the indenture, plus accrued and unpaid interest, if any, to, but not including, the date of redemption. The
7.000% 2027 AK Senior Notes are redeemable beginning on March 15, 2022, at a redemption price equal to 103.500% of the principal amount thereof, decreasing
on each March 15 thereafter until March 15, 2025, on and after which the 7.000% 2027 Senior Notes are redeemable at par, in each case, plus accrued and unpaid
interest, if any, to, but not including, the date of redemption.
ABL Facility
On March 13, 2020, in connection with the AK Steel Merger, we entered into a new ABL Facility with various financial institutions to replace and refinance
Cliffs’ Former ABL Facility and AK Steel Corporation’s former revolving credit facility. The ABL Facility will mature upon the earlier of March 13, 2025 or 91 days
prior to the maturity of certain other material debt and provided for up to $2 billion in borrowings, including a $ 555 million sublimit for the issuance of letters of credit
and a $125 million sublimit for swingline loans. Availability under the ABL Facility is limited to an eligible borrowing base, as applicable, determined by applying
customary advance rates to eligible accounts receivable, inventory and certain mobile equipment.
On March 27, 2020, we amended our ABL Facility to, among other things, provide for a new FILO tranche B of commitments in the aggregate amount of
$150 million by exchanging existing commitments under the ABL Facility.
109
-- 111 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The total commitments under the ABL Facility after giving effect to this first amendment remained at $ 2 billion. The terms and conditions (other than the pricing) that
apply to the FILO tranche were substantially the same as the terms and conditions that apply to the tranche A facility of the ABL Facility immediately prior to the
amendment.
On December 9, 2020, we entered into the Second ABL Amendment. The Second ABL Amendment modified the ABL Facility to, among other things,
increase the amount of tranche A revolver commitments available thereunder by an additional $ 1.5 billion and increase certain dollar baskets related to certain
negative covenants that apply to the ABL Facility. After giving effect to the ABL Amendment, the aggregate principal amount of tranche A revolver commitments
under the ABL Facility was $ 3.35 billion and the aggregate principal amount of FILO tranche B revolver commitments under the ABL Facility remained at $ 150
million.
On December 17, 2021, we entered into the Third ABL Amendment. The Third ABL Amendment modified the ABL Facility to, among other things, increase
the amount of tranche A revolver commitments available thereunder by an additional $ 1 billion and exchange $150 million of tranche B revolver commitments
available thereunder for tranche A revolver commitments. After giving effect to the Third ABL Amendment, the aggregate principal amount of tranche A revolver
commitments under the ABL Facility is $ 4.5 billion and there are no remaining tranche B revolver commitments under the ABL Facility. The increase is a result of a
larger projected borrowing base driven by more favorable market conditions.
The ABL Facility and certain bank products and hedge obligations are guaranteed by certain of our existing wholly owned U.S. subsidiaries and are
required to be guaranteed by certain of our future U.S. subsidiaries. Amounts outstanding under the ABL Facility are secured by (i) a first-priority security interest in
the accounts receivable and other rights to payment, inventory, as-extracted collateral, certain investment property, deposit accounts, securities accounts, certain
general intangibles and commercial tort claims, certain mobile equipment, commodities accounts and other related assets of ours, the other borrowers and the
guarantors, and proceeds and products of each of the foregoing (collectively, the “ABL Collateral”) and (ii) a second-priority security interest in substantially all of
our assets and the assets of the other borrowers and the guarantors other than the ABL Collateral.
Borrowings under the ABL Facility bear interest, at our option, at a base rate or, if certain conditions are met, a LIBOR rate, in each case, plus an
applicable margin. We may amend our ABL Facility to replace the LIBOR rate with one or more secured overnight financing based rates or an alternative
benchmark rate, giving consideration to any evolving or then-existing convention for similar dollar denominated syndicated credit facilities for such alternative
benchmarks.
The ABL Facility contains customary representations and warranties and affirmative and negative covenants including, among others, covenants regarding
the maintenance of certain financial ratios if certain conditions are triggered, covenants relating to financial reporting, covenants relating to the payment of dividends
on, or purchase or redemption of, our capital stock, covenants relating to the incurrence or prepayment of certain debt, covenants relating to the incurrence of liens
or encumbrances, covenants relating to compliance with laws, covenants relating to transactions with affiliates, covenants relating to mergers and sales of all or
substantially all of our assets and limitations on changes in the nature of our business.
The ABL Facility provides for customary events of default, including, among other things, the event of nonpayment of principal, interest, fees or other
amounts, a representation or warranty proving to have been materially incorrect when made, failure to perform or observe certain covenants within a specified
period of time, a cross-default to certain material indebtedness, the bankruptcy or insolvency of the Company and certain of its subsidiaries, monetary judgment
defaults of a specified amount, invalidity of any loan documentation, a change of control of the Company, and ERISA defaults resulting in liability of a specified
amount. If an event of default exists (beyond any applicable grace or cure period), the administrative agent may, and at the direction of the requisite number of
lenders shall, declare all amounts owing under the ABL Facility immediately due and payable, terminate such lenders’ commitments to make loans under the ABL
Facility and/or exercise any and all remedies and other rights under the ABL Facility. For certain events of default related to insolvency and receivership, the
commitments of the lenders will be automatically terminated and all outstanding loans and other amounts will become immediately due and payable.
As of December 31, 2021 and 2020, we were in compliance with the ABL Facility liquidity requirements and, therefore, the springing financial covenant
requiring a minimum fixed charge coverage ratio of 1.0 to 1.0 was not applicable.
110
-- 112 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following represents a summary of our borrowing capacity under the ABL Facility:
(In Millions)
December 31,
2021
Available borrowing base on ABL Facility $ 4,500
Borrowings (1,609)
Letter of credit obligations (175)
Borrowing capacity available $ 2,716
As of December 31, 2021, the ABL Facility has a maximum available borrowing base of $4.5 billion. The borrowing base is determined by applying customary advance rates
to eligible accounts receivable, inventory and certain mobile equipment.
We issued standby letters of credit with certain financial institutions in order to support business obligations including, but not limited to, workers' compensation, employee
severance, insurance, operating agreements and environmental obligations.
Other Financing Arrangements
Industrial Revenue Bonds
AK Steel had outstanding $ 66 million aggregate principal amount of fixed-rate, tax-exempt IRBs as of December 31, 2021. The weighted-average fixed rate
of these IRBs is 6.86%. These IRBs are unsecured senior debt obligations that are equal in ranking with AK Steel's senior notes and AK Steel's guarantees of Cliffs'
unsubordinated indebtedness. These IRBs are effectively subordinated to AK Steel’s guarantees of Cliffs’ secured indebtedness to the extent of the value of AK
Steel’s assets securing such guarantees. These IRBs contain certain customary covenants; however, there are no financial covenants.
Debt Extinguishment - 2021
During the fourth quarter of 2021, we paid in full the outstanding balance of our EDC revolving facilities for $ 55 million in aggregate principal amount and
terminated the agreements. Prior to such terminations, the EDC revolving facilities provided for up to $80 million in borrowings.
On October 15, 2021, we redeemed $26 million in aggregate principal amount of the IRBs due 2024. During the third quarter of 2021, we repurchased
$2 million in aggregate principal amount of 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes. On June 28, 2021, we redeemed all $396 million aggregate principal amount
outstanding of the 5.750% 2025 Senior Notes using available liquidity. During the second quarter of 2021, we also repurchased $25 million aggregate principal
amount of 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes.
On March 11, 2021, we purchased $ 322 million aggregate principal amount of the 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes using the net proceeds from the
February 11, 2021 issuance of 20 million common shares and cash on hand. On March 12, 2021, we fully redeemed the 4.875% 2024 Senior Secured Notes,
7.625% 2021 AK Senior Notes, 7.50% 2023 AK Senior Notes, 6.375% 2025 Senior Notes and 6.375% 2025 AK Senior Notes, which totaled an aggregate principal
amount of $535 million.
1
2
1
2
111
-- 113 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following is a summary of the debt extinguished and the respective impact on extinguishment:
(In Millions)
Year Ended
December 31, 2021
Debt Extinguished (Loss) on Extinguishment
9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes $ 347 $ (47)
4.875% 2024 Senior Secured Notes 395 (14)
7.625% 2021 AK Senior Notes 34 —
7.500% 2023 AK Senior Notes 13 —
6.375% 2025 Senior Notes 64 (7)
1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes 2 —
6.375% 2025 AK Senior Notes 29 (3)
5.750% 2025 Senior Notes 396 (17)
IRBs due 2024 26 —
Total $ 1,306 $ (88)
Debt Extinguishment - 2020
During the year ended December 31, 2020, we used the net proceeds from the offering of the additional 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes to
repurchase $736 million aggregate principal amount of our outstanding senior notes of various series, which resulted in a net debt reduction of $ 181 million. We
also repurchased an additional $35 million aggregate principal amount of our outstanding senior notes of various series and we redeemed $ 7 million aggregate
principal amount of our outstanding 2020 IRBs, with cash on hand.
Additionally, in connection with the AK Steel Merger, we purchased $ 364 million aggregate principal amount of 7.625% 2021 AK Senior Notes and $ 311
million aggregate principal amount of 7.500% 2023 AK Senior Notes upon early settlement of tender offers made by Cliffs. The net proceeds from the offering of
6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes, along with a portion of the ABL Facility borrowings, were used to fund such purchases. As the 7.625% 2021 AK Senior Notes
and 7.500% 2023 AK Senior Notes were recorded at fair value just prior to being purchased, there was no gain or loss on extinguishment. Additionally, in
connection with the final settlement of the tender offers, we purchased $9 million aggregate principal amount of the 7.625% 2021 AK Senior Notes and $ 56 million
aggregate principal amount of the 7.500% 2023 AK Senior Notes with cash on hand.
The following is a summary of the debt extinguished and the respective impact on extinguishment:
(In Millions)
Year Ended
December 31, 2020
Debt Extinguished Gain (Loss) on Extinguishment
7.625% 2021 AK Senior Notes $ 373 $ —
7.500% 2023 AK Senior Notes 367 3
4.875% 2024 Senior Secured Notes 6 1
6.375% 2025 Senior Notes 168 21
1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes 20 1
5.750% 2025 Senior Notes 77 16
7.000% 2027 Senior Notes 262 27
5.875% 2027 Senior Notes 195 49
6.250% 2040 Senior Notes 36 13
6.375% 2025 AK Senior Notes 9 (1)
Total $ 1,513 $ 130
112
-- 114 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Debt Extinguishment - 2019
During the year ended December 31, 2019, we used the net proceeds from the issuance of $ 750 million aggregate principal amount of 5.875% 2027
Senior Notes, along with cash on hand, to redeem in full all of our outstanding 4.875% 2021 Senior Notes and to fund the repurchase of $600 million aggregate
principal amount of our outstanding 5.750% 2025 Senior Notes in a tender offer.
The following is a summary of the debt extinguished and the respective impact on extinguishment:
(In Millions)
Year Ended
December 31, 2019
Debt Extinguished (Loss) on Extinguishment
4.875% 2021 Senior Notes $ 124 $ (5)
5.750% 2025 Senior Notes 600 (13)
Total $ 724 $ (18)
Debt Maturities
The following represents a summary of our debt instrument maturities based on the principal amounts outstanding at December 31, 2021:
(In Millions)
Maturities of Debt
2022 $ —
2023 —
2024 36
2025 2,510
2026 845
Thereafter 1,978
Total maturities of debt $ 5,369
NOTE 9 - FAIR VALUE OF FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
There were no significant assets or liabilities measured at fair value as of December 31, 2021 or December 31, 2020.
The valuation of financial assets classified in Level 2 was determined using a market approach based upon quoted prices for similar assets in active
markets or other inputs that were observable.
Our supply agreement with ArcelorMittal USA contained provisions for supplemental revenue or refunds based on the HRC price in the year the iron ore
product was consumed in ArcelorMittal USA’s blast furnaces. We accounted for these provisions as derivative instruments at the time of sale and adjusted the
derivative instruments to fair value through Revenues each reporting period until the product was consumed and the amounts were settled. These instruments
were classified as Level 3 assets. Upon the completion of the AM USA Transaction, the outstanding derivatives were settled as part of acquisition accounting.
113
-- 115 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following tables represent a reconciliation of the changes in fair value of financial instruments measured at fair value on a recurring basis using
significant unobservable inputs (Level 3):
(In Millions)
Level 3 Assets
2021 2020
Beginning balance - January 1 $ — $ 45
Total gains included in earnings — 122
Settlements — (27)
Settlement of pre-existing relationship — (140)
Ending balance - December 31 $ — $ —
Total gains for the period included in earnings attributable to the change in unrealized gains on assets still held at the
reporting date $ — $ —
The carrying values of certain financial instruments (e.g. Accounts receivable, net, Accounts payable and Other current liabilities) approximate fair value
and, therefore, have been excluded from the table below. A summary of the carrying value and fair value of other financial instruments were as follows:
(In Millions)
December 31, 2021 December 31, 2020
Classification Carrying
Value Fair Value Carrying
Value Fair Value
Senior notes Level 1 $ 3,561 $ 3,911 $ 3,802 $ 4,446
IRBs due 2024 to 2028 Level 1 68 66 94 91
EDC Revolving Facility - outstanding balance Level 2 — — 18 18
ABL Facility - outstanding balance Level 2 1,609 1,609 1,510 1,510
Total $ 5,238 $ 5,586 $ 5,424 $ 6,065
The fair value of both current and long-term debt was determined using quoted market prices.
NOTE 10 - PENSIONS AND OTHER POSTRETIREMENT BENEFITS
We offer defined benefit pension plans, defined contribution pension plans and OPEB plans to a significant portion of our employees and retirees. Benefits
are also provided through multiemployer plans for certain union members.
As a result of the acquisitions of AK Steel and ArcelorMittal USA, we assumed the obligations under their defined benefit pension plans, OPEB plans,
defined contribution plans and commitments to multiemployer pension plans according to collective bargaining agreements that cover certain union-represented
employees. The AK Steel defined benefit pension plans and OPEB plans acquired amounted to a benefit obligation, net of assets of $949 million based on a March
13, 2020 measurement. The ArcelorMittal USA defined benefit pension plans and OPEB plans acquired amounted to a benefit obligation, net of assets of
$3,294 million based on a December 9, 2020 measurement.
Defined Benefit Pension Plans
The defined benefit pension plans are largely noncontributory and limited in participation. Most plans are closed to new participants with only the legacy
iron ore hourly and salaried plans still open. The pension benefit calculations vary by plan but are generally based on employees' years of service and
compensation or a fixed rate and years of service. Certain salaried plans calculate benefits using a cash balance formula, which earns interest credits and
allocations based on a percent of pay.
114
-- 116 of 411 --
Table of Contents
OPEB Plans
We offer postretirement health care and life insurance benefits to retirees through various plans. The vast majority of our plans are closed to new
participants. In lieu of retiree medical coverage, many union-represented employees receive a 401(k) contribution per hour worked to a restricted Retiree Health
Care Account. Cost sharing features between the employer and retiree vary by plan and several plans include employer caps. Retiree healthcare coverage is
provided through programs administered by insurance companies whose charges are based on benefits paid. Certain labor agreements require the funding of
VEBAs, which, depending on funding levels, may be used to reimburse the employer for paid benefits.
Obligations and Funded Status
The following tables and information provide additional disclosures:
(In Millions)
Pension Benefits OPEB
Change in benefit obligations: 2021 2020 2021 2020
Benefit obligations — beginning of year $ 6,565 $ 1,021 $ 3,757 $ 255
Service cost 56 23 51 8
Interest cost 103 64 74 19
Plan amendments — — 8 —
Actuarial loss (gain) (131) 162 (456) 14
Benefits paid (456) (146) (227) (89)
Participant contributions — — 47 22
Acquired through business combinations — 5,535 — 3,528
Effect of settlement (101) (94) — —
Benefit obligations — end of year $ 6,036 $ 6,565 $ 3,254 $ 3,757
Change in plan assets:
Fair value of plan assets — beginning of year $ 5,332 $ 749 $ 783 $ 260
Actual return on plan assets 668 472 29 45
Participant contributions — — 26 17
Employer contributions 155 50 139 30
Benefits paid (454) (146) (165) (88)
Acquired through business combinations — 4,301 — 519
Effect of settlement (95) (94) — —
Fair value of plan assets — end of year $ 5,606 $ 5,332 $ 812 $ 783
Funded status $ (430) $ (1,233) $ (2,442) $ (2,974)
Amounts recognized in Statements of Financial Position:
Non-current assets $ 153 $ 3 $ 71 $ 54
Current liabilities (5) (12) (130) (139)
Non-current liabilities (578) (1,224) (2,383) (2,889)
Total amount recognized $ (430) $ (1,233) $ (2,442) $ (2,974)
Amounts recognized in accumulated other comprehensive loss (income):
Net actuarial loss (gain) $ (286) $ 164 $ (392) $ 56
Prior service cost (credit) 5 6 4 (6)
Net amount recognized $ (281) $ 170 $ (388) $ 50
115
-- 117 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The accumulated benefit obligation for all defined benefit pension plans was $ 6,013 million and $ 6,537 million at December 31, 2021 and 2020,
respectively.
Components of Net Periodic Benefit Cost (Credit)
(In Millions)
Pension Benefits OPEB
2021 2020 2019 2021 2020 2019
Service cost $ 56 $ 23 $ 17 $ 51 $ 8 $ 2
Interest cost 103 64 35 74 19 10
Expected return on plan assets (359) (140) (55) (40) (20) (17)
Amortization:
Net actuarial loss 32 27 24 3 3 5
Prior service costs (credits) 1 1 1 (2) (2) (2)
Settlements (22) (6) — — — —
Net periodic benefit cost (credit) $ (189) $ (31) $ 22 $ 86 $ 8 $ (2)
For 2022, we estimate net periodic benefit cost (credit) as follows:
(In Millions)
Defined benefit pension plans $ (179)
OPEB plans 72
Total $ (107)
Components of Accumulated Other Comprehensive Loss (Income)
The following includes details on the significant actuarial losses (gains) impacting the benefit obligation:
(In Millions)
Pension Benefits OPEB
2021 2020 2021 2020
Discount rates $ (224) $ 181 $ (117) $ 44
Demographic updates 76 (3) 3 (11)
Mortality 19 (16) 13 (4)
Per capita health care costs — — (350) (10)
Other (2) — (5) (5)
Actuarial loss (gain) on benefit obligation (131) 162 (456) 14
Actual returns on assets under (over) expected (309) (332) 11 (26)
Amortization of net actuarial gain (loss) (32) (27) 2 (3)
Amortization of prior service credits (costs) (1) (1) (3) 2
Settlements 22 6 — —
Other — (27) 8 (2)
Total recognized in accumulated other comprehensive income $ (451) $ (219) $ (438) $ (15)
116
-- 118 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Contributions
Annual contributions to the pension plans are made within income tax deductibility restrictions in accordance with statutory regulations. OPEB plans are not
subject to minimum regulatory funding requirements, but rather amounts are contributed pursuant to bargaining agreements.
(In Millions)
Pension
Benefits
Other Benefits
Company Contributions & Payments VEBA
Direct
Payments Total
2020 $ 50 $ — $ 25 $ 25
2021 163 67 113 180
2022 (Expected) 4 28 110 138
The 2021 pension contributions include $118 million in deferred 2020 pension contributions in connection with the CARES Act that were paid on January 4, 2021.
Pursuant to the applicable bargaining agreements, benefits can be paid from certain VEBAs that are at least 70% funded (all VEBAs were over 70% funded at December 31,
2021). Certain agreements with plans holding VEBA assets have capped healthcare costs. For the Cleveland-Cliffs Steel LLC VEBA, we are required to make contributions
based on earnings, and we may withdraw money from the VEBA plan to the extent funds are available for costs in excess of the cap. VEBA withdrawals are represented net
of direct payments. The amount expected for 2022 in the VEBA column reflects the contribution to be made in February 2022 for earnings in the quarter ended December 31,
2021. We do not include an estimate for contributions beyond that due to the variability of the calculation.
Estimated Future Benefit Payments
(In Millions)
Pension
Benefits OPEB
2022 $ 475 $ 180
2023 477 171
2024 451 167
2025 428 163
2026 424 163
2027-2031 1,879 823
Assumptions
The discount rates used to measure plan liabilities as of the December 31 measurement date are determined individually for each plan. The discount rates
are determined by matching the projected cash flows used to determine the plan liabilities to a projected yield curve of high-quality corporate bonds available at the
measurement date. Discount rates for expense are calculated using the granular approach for each plan.
Depending on the plan, we use either company-specific base mortality tables or tables issued by the Society of Actuaries. We use the Pri-2012 mortality
tables from the Society of Actuaries with adjustments for blue collar, white collar or no collar depending on the plan. On December 31, 2021, the assumed mortality
improvement projection was updated from generational scale MP-2020 to generational scale MP-2021 for the Pri-2012 mortality tables.
The following represents weighted-average assumptions used to determine benefit obligations:
Pension Benefits OPEB
December 31, December 31,
2021 2020 2021 2020
Discount rate 2.75 % 2.34 % 3.01 % 2.71 %
Interest crediting rate 5.35 5.25 N/A N/A
Compensation rate increase 2.52 2.56 3.00 3.00
1
2
1
2
117
-- 119 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following represents weighted-average assumptions used to determine net benefit cost:
Pension Benefits OPEB
December 31, December 31,
2021 2020 2019 2021 2020 2019
Obligation discount rate 2.32 % 3.02 % 4.27 % 2.46 % 3.28 % 4.29 %
Service cost discount rate 2.78 3.34 4.35 3.28 3.35 4.49
Interest cost discount rate 1.64 2.53 3.92 2.04 2.51 3.94
Interest crediting rate 5.35 5.50 6.00 N/A N/A N/A
Expected return on plan assets 6.84 7.69 8.25 5.20 6.82 7.00
Compensation rate increase 2.54 2.56 2.53 3.00 3.00 3.00
The following represents assumed weighted-average health care cost trend rates:
December 31,
2021 2020
Health care cost trend rate assumed for next year 2.36 % 6.05 %
Ultimate health care cost trend rate 4.50 4.59
Year that the ultimate rate is reached 2031 2031
Plan Assets
Our financial objectives with respect to our pension and VEBA assets are to fully fund the actuarial accrued liability for each of the plans, to maximize
investment returns within reasonable and prudent levels of risk, and to maintain sufficient liquidity to meet benefit obligations on a timely basis.
Our investment objective is to outperform the expected return on assets assumption used in the plans’ actuarial reports over the life of the plans. The
expected return on assets takes into account historical returns and estimated future long-term returns based on capital market assumptions applied to the asset
allocation strategy. The expected return is net of investment expenses paid by the plans. In addition, investment performance is monitored quarterly by
benchmarking to various indices and metrics for the one-, three- and five-year periods.
The asset allocation strategy is determined through a detailed analysis of assets and liabilities by plan, which defines the overall risk that is acceptable with
regard to the expected level and variability of portfolio returns, surplus (assets compared to liabilities), contributions and pension expense.
The asset allocation review process involves simulating capital market behaviors including global asset class performance, inflation and interest rates in order to
evaluate various asset allocation scenarios and determine the asset mix with the highest likelihood of meeting financial objectives. The process includes factoring in
the current funded status and likely future funded status levels of the plans by taking into account expected growth or decline in the contributions over time.
The asset allocation strategy varies by plan. The following table reflects the actual asset allocations for pension and VEBA assets as of December 31, 2021
and 2020, as well as the 2022 weighted average target asset allocations. Equity investments include securities in large-cap, mid-cap and small-cap companies
located in the U.S. and worldwide. Fixed income investments primarily include corporate bonds and government debt securities.
118
-- 120 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Pension Assets VEBA Assets
Asset Category
2022
Target
Allocation
Percentage of
Plan Assets at
December 31, 2022
Target
Allocation
Percentage of
Plan Assets at
December 31,
2021 2020 2021 2020
Equity securities 46.3 % 47.6 % 51.8 % 21.2 % 22.5 % 22.2 %
Fixed income 34.6 34.6 33.8 68.5 66.4 66.4
Hedge funds 2.2 2.2 2.2 1.4 1.8 1.8
Private equity 5.0 2.7 2.1 1.1 — 0.4
Structured credit 5.2 5.6 5.0 1.0 1.2 0.9
Real estate 5.2 5.6 3.3 1.0 2.1 1.8
Absolute return fixed income 1.5 1.7 1.8 5.8 6.0 6.5
Total 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 % 100.0 %
As a practical expedient, in accordance with ASC 820-10, certain investments that are measured at fair value using the NAV per share have not been
classified in the fair value hierarchy below. NAV is based on the value of the underlying assets owned by the fund, minus its liabilities, and then divided by its
number of shares outstanding.
The fair value of our pension assets by asset category is as follows:
(In Millions)
Quoted Prices in Active
Markets for Identical
Assets
(Level 1)
Significant Other
Observable
Inputs
(Level 2)
Significant
Unobservable
Inputs
(Level 3)
Investments
Measured at Net
Asset Value Total
Asset Category 2021 2020 2021 2020 2021 2020 2021 2020 2021 2020
Equity securities:
U.S. equities $ 1,157 $ 1,163 $ — $ — $ — $ — $ 775 $ 787 $ 1,932 $ 1,950
Global equities 617 615 — — — — 117 195 734 810
Fixed income:
U.S. government securities 140 141 310 295 — — 50 40 500 476
U.S. corporate bonds 502 512 371 466 — — 503 303 1,376 1,281
Non U.S. and other bonds — — 66 46 — — — — 66 46
Hedge funds — — — — 125 118 — — 125 118
Private equity — — — — 151 114 — — 151 114
Structured credit — — — — 315 264 — — 315 264
Real estate — — — — 313 174 — — 313 174
Absolute return fixed income — — — — — — 94 99 94 99
Total $ 2,416 $ 2,431 $ 747 $ 807 $ 904 $ 670 $ 1,539 $ 1,424 $ 5,606 $ 5,332
Includes cash equivalents.
1
1
119
-- 121 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Assets for OPEB plans include VEBA trusts pursuant to bargaining agreements that are available to fund retired employees’ life insurance obligations and
medical benefits. The fair value of our other benefit plan assets by asset category is as follows:
(In Millions)
Quoted Prices in Active
Markets for Identical
Assets
(Level 1)
Significant Other
Observable
Inputs
(Level 2)
Significant
Unobservable
Inputs
(Level 3)
Investments
Measured at Net
Asset Value Total
Asset Category 2021 2020 2021 2020 2021 2020 2021 2020 2021 2020
Equity securities:
U.S. equities $ 26 $ 26 $ — $ — $ — $ — $ 103 $ 93 $ 129 $ 119
Global equities 6 6 — — — — 48 49 54 55
Fixed income:
U.S. government securities 111 62 80 94 — — — — 191 156
U.S. corporate bonds 219 237 129 127 — — — — 348 364
Hedge funds — — — — 15 14 — — 15 14
Private equity — — — — — 3 — — — 3
Structured credit — — — — 10 7 — — 10 7
Real estate — — — — 17 14 — — 17 14
Absolute return fixed income — — — — — — 48 51 48 51
Total $ 362 $ 331 $ 209 $ 221 $ 42 $ 38 $ 199 $ 193 $ 812 $ 783
Includes cash equivalents.
The following represents the fair value measurements of changes in plan assets using significant unobservable inputs (Level 3):
(In Millions)
Pension Assets VEBA Assets
2021 2020 2021 2020
Beginning balance — January 1 $ 670 $ 212 $ 38 $ 34
Actual return on plan assets:
Relating to assets still held at the reporting date 124 8 6 2
Relating to assets sold during the period 8 6 — 1
Purchases 142 195 — —
Sales (40) (13) (2) (1)
Acquired through business combinations — 262 — 2
Ending balance — December 31 $ 904 $ 670 $ 42 $ 38
Following is a description of the inputs and valuation methodologies used to measure the fair value of our plan assets.
Equity Securities
Equity securities classified as Level 1 investments include U.S. large-, small- and mid-cap investments and international equities. These investments are
comprised of securities listed on an exchange, market or automated quotation system for which quotations are readily available. The valuation of these securities is
determined using a market approach and is based upon unadjusted quoted prices for identical assets in active markets.
Fixed Income
Fixed income securities classified as Level 1 investments include bonds, government debt securities and cash equivalents. These investments are
comprised of securities listed on an exchange, market or automated quotation system for which quotations are readily available. The valuation of these securities is
determined using a
1
1
120
-- 122 of 411 --
Table of Contents
market approach and is based upon unadjusted quoted prices for identical assets in active markets. Also included in fixed income is a portfolio of U.S. Treasury
STRIPS, which are zero-coupon bearing fixed income securities backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. The securities sell at a discount to par
because there are no incremental coupon payments. STRIPS are not issued directly by the Treasury, but rather are created by a financial institution, government
securities broker or government securities dealer. Liquidity on the issue varies depending on various market conditions; however, in general, the STRIPS market is
slightly less liquid than that of the U.S. Treasury Bond market. The STRIPS are priced daily through a bond pricing vendor and are classified as Level 2.
Hedge Funds
Hedge funds are alternative investments comprised of direct or indirect investment in offshore hedge funds with an investment objective to achieve equity-
like returns with one half the volatility of equities and moderate correlation. The valuation techniques used to measure fair value attempt to maximize the use of
observable inputs and minimize the use of unobservable inputs. Considerable judgment is required to interpret the factors used to develop estimates of fair value.
Valuations of the underlying investment funds are obtained and reviewed. The securities that are valued by the funds are interests in the investment funds and not
the underlying holdings of such investment funds. Thus, the inputs used to value the investments in each of the underlying funds may differ from the inputs used to
value the underlying holdings of such funds. Hedge funds are valued monthly and recorded on a one-month lag.
Private Equity Funds
Private equity funds are alternative investments that represent direct or indirect investments in partnerships, venture funds or a diversified pool of private
investment vehicles (fund of funds).
Investment commitments are made in private equity funds based on an asset allocation strategy, and capital calls are made over the life of the funds to
fund the commitments. As of December 31, 2021, remaining commitments total $151 million for our pension and OPEB plans. Committed amounts are funded from
plan assets when capital calls are made. Investment commitments are not pre-funded in reserve accounts.
Private equity investments are valued quarterly and recorded on a one-quarter lag. For private equity investment values reported on a lag, current market
information is reviewed for any material changes in values at the reporting date. Capital distributions for the funds do not occur on a regular frequency. Liquidation
of these investments would require sale of the partnership interest.
Structured Credit
Structured credit funds provide flexibility and access to both complex and illiquid premiums by investing across global, public and private residential,
commercial, corporate and specialty credit markets that are priced based on valuations provided by independent, third-party pricing agents, if available. Such values
generally reflect the last reported sales price if the security is actively traded. The third-party pricing agents may also value structured credit investments at an
evaluated bid price by employing methodologies that utilize actual market transactions, broker-supplied valuations or other methodologies designed to identify the
market value of such securities.
Structured credit investments are valued monthly and certain funds have an initial lock-up period and withdrawal restrictions on a semi-annual and quarterly
basis. For structured credit investment values reported on a lag, current market information is reviewed for any material changes in values at the reporting date.
Real Estate
The real estate portfolio for the pension plans is an alternative investment comprised of funds with strategic categories of real estate investments. All real
estate holdings are appraised externally at least annually, and appraisals are conducted by reputable, independent appraisal firms that are members of the
Appraisal Institute. All external appraisals are performed in accordance with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practices. The property valuations
and assumptions about each property are reviewed quarterly by the investment manager and values are adjusted if there has been a significant change in
circumstances relating to the property since the last external appraisal. The fair values of the funds are updated on either a monthly or quarterly basis. Redemption
requests are considered on a quarterly basis, subject to notice requirements.
The real estate fund of funds investment for the VEBA trusts invests in pooled investment vehicles that, in turn, invest in commercial real estate properties.
Valuations are performed quarterly and financial statements are prepared on a semi-annual basis, with annual audited statements. Asset values for this fund are
reported with a one-
121
-- 123 of 411 --
Table of Contents
quarter lag, and current market information is reviewed for any material changes in values at the reporting date. Withdrawals are permitted on the last business day
of each quarter subject to a 95-day prior written notice.
Absolute Return Fixed Income
Absolute return fixed income investments consist of a global fixed income fund with the investment objective of generating positive absolute returns over a
full market cycle. The fund's investments in securities, forward exchange contracts and futures contracts are reported at fair value on a recurring monthly basis. The
fund's trustee values securities based upon independent pricing sources and futures contracts are valued at closing settled prices. Redemptions of the fund at NAV
are permitted monthly under most circumstances.
Defined Contribution Plans
Most employees are eligible to participate in various defined contribution plans. Certain of these plans have features with matching contributions or other
Company contributions based on our financial results. Company contributions to these plans are expensed as incurred. Total expense from these plans was $55
million, $22 million and $ 3 million in 2021, 2020 and 2019, respectively.
Multiemployer Plans
We contribute to multiemployer pension plans according to collective bargaining agreements that cover certain union-represented employees. The risks of
participating in these multiemployer plans are different from the risks of participating in single-employer pension plans in the following respects:
• Assets contributed to a multiemployer plan by one employer may be used to provide benefits to employees of other participating employers.
• If a participating employer stops contributing to a multiemployer plan, the unfunded obligations of the plan may be borne by the remaining participating
employers.
• If the multiemployer plan becomes significantly underfunded or is unable to pay its benefits, we may be required to contribute additional amounts in excess of
the rate required by the collective bargaining agreements.
• If we choose to stop participating in a multiemployer plan, we may be required to pay that plan an amount based on the underfunded status of the plan,
referred to as a withdrawal liability.
122
-- 124 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Information with respect to multiemployer plans in which we participate follows:
Pension Fund
EIN/Pension Plan
Number
Pension
Protection Act
Zone Status (a)
FIP/RP Status
Pending/Implemented (b) Contributions
Surcharge
Imposed (c)
Expiration Date of
Collective
Bargaining
Agreement (d)
2021 2020 2021 2020 2019
Steelworkers Pension
Trust 23-6648508/499 Green Green No $ 88 $ 14 $ 4 No
9/1/2022 to
09/1/2025
IAM National Pension
Fund’s National Pension
Plan 51-6031295/002 Red Red Yes 16 16 — Yes
5/31/2022 to
5/15/2023
Other Plans — — —
Total $ 104 $ 30 $ 4
(a) The most recent Pension Protection Act zone status available in 2021 and 2020 is for each plan's year-end at December 31, 2020 and 2019. The plan's actuary certifies the
zone status. Generally, plans in the red zone are less than 65% funded, plans in the yellow zone are between 65% and 80% funded, and plans in the green zone are at least
80% funded. The IAM National Pension Fund's National Pension Plan voluntarily elected to place itself in the "Red Zone" in April 2019 and has implemented a rehabilitation
plan to address its underfunded status. Additional contributions will be required as part of the rehabilitation plan until the plan exits the "Red Zone".
(b) The "FIP/RP Status Pending/Implemented" column indicates plans for which a financial improvement plan or a rehabilitation plan is either pending or has been implemented,
as defined by ERISA.
(c) The surcharge represents an additional required contribution due as a result of the critical funding status of the plan.
(d) We are a party to five collective bargaining agreements that require contributions to the Steelworkers Pension Trust and three collective bargaining agreements that require
contributions to the IAM National Pension Fund's National Pension Plan.
(e) Plans that are not individually significant to our Company are presented in aggregate.
With the 2020 Acquisitions, we are one of the largest contributors to the Steelworkers Pension Trust. Our contributions exceeded 5% of total combined
contributions in 2021 and 2020. As of January 1, 2021 (the last date for which we have information), the Steelworkers Pension Trust had a total actuarial liability of
$5,960 million and assets with a market value of $ 5,998 million, for a funded ratio of about 101%.
NOTE 11 - STOCK COMPENSATION PLANS
At December 31, 2021, we had outstanding awards under three share-based compensation plans: the 2021 Equity Plan, the A&R 2015 Equity Plan and the
2012 Amended Equity Plan. On April 28, 2021, the Company's shareholders approved the 2021 Equity Plan, which succeeded the A&R 2015 Equity Plan and
made available 26.0 million new common shares plus 2.5 million shares remaining available under the A&R 2015 Equity Plan. As of December 31, 2021, there
were 28.0 million remaining shares available for grant under the 2021 Equity Plan. No additional grants were issued from the 2012 Amended Equity Plan or the
A&R 2015 Equity Plan after the date of approval of the 2021 Equity Plan; however, all awards previously granted under the predecessor plans will continue in
accordance with the terms of the outstanding awards.
On March 13, 2020, the maximum number of shares that may be issued under the A&R 2015 Equity Plan increased by 5.7 million common shares in
relation to the outstanding AK Steel stock-based incentive awards that we converted at a 0.400 rate of exchange. The converted stock-based incentive awards
include 2.0 million stock options, 1.0 million long-term performance plan awards, 0.5 million performance shares, 0.2 million restricted stock awards and 0.3 million
restricted stock units.
(e)
123
-- 125 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Stock-Based Compensation Expense
The following table summarizes the total compensation expense recognized for stock-based compensation awards:
(In Millions, except per
share amounts)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Cost of goods sold $ (2) $ (2) $ (2)
Selling, general and administrative expenses (16) (13) (16)
Acquisition-related costs — (2) —
Stock based compensation expense (18) (17) (18)
Income tax benefit 4 4 4
Stock based compensation expense, net of tax $ (14) $ (13) $ (14)
Decrease in basic earnings per common share $ (0.03) $ (0.03) $ (0.05)
Decrease in diluted earnings per common share $ (0.03) $ (0.03) $ (0.05)
The total compensation cost related to outstanding awards not yet recognized is $ 24 million at December 31, 2021. This expense is expected to be
recognized over the remaining weighted-average period of 1.4 years.
Performance Shares
The following table summarizes the performance award activity:
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Number of
Shares
Weighted
Average Grant
Date Fair
Value Number of Shares
Weighted
Average Grant
Date Fair Value Number of Shares
Weighted
Average Grant
Date Fair Value
Outstanding at beginning of year 2,452,226 $ 10.34 1,935,878 $ 15.58 1,424,723 $ 14.46
Granted 652,888 25.12 960,637 6.93 572,104 18.31
Granted - replacement awards — — 1,550,216 4.59 — —
Distributed (1,279,509) 11.74 (1,938,786) 12.23 — —
Performance adjustment 625,355 11.93 549,154 15.63 — —
Forfeited/canceled (80,490) 11.27 (604,873) 5.70 (60,949) 15.12
Outstanding at end of year 2,370,470 $ 14.04 2,452,226 $ 10.34 1,935,878 $ 15.58
On March 13, 2020, we granted 1.0 million long-term performance plan awards and 0.5 million performance shares as AK Steel replacement awards. As of
December 31, 2021, 0.2 million long-term performance plan awards and 0.1 million performance shares were outstanding as a result of qualifying termination
events that triggered accelerated performance share payouts and prorated long-term performance plan awards payouts at target. The long-term performance plan
awards are based on a three-year Adjusted EBITDA metric.
The outstanding performance shares vest over a period of three years and are intended to be paid out in common shares. Performance is measured on the
basis of relative TSR for the period and measured against the constituents of the S&P Metals and Mining ETF Index. The number of shares actually earned at the
end of the three-year period will vary, based on performance, from 0% to 200% of the number of performance shares granted.
124
-- 126 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Restricted Stock Units
The following table summarizes the restricted stock units activity:
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Number of
Shares
Weighted
Average Grant
Date Fair
Value Number of Shares
Weighted
Average Grant
Date Fair Value Number of Shares
Weighted
Average Grant
Date Fair Value
Outstanding at beginning of year 2,143,583 $ 7.12 2,147,183 $ 9.10 4,694,360 $ 4.18
Granted 678,420 17.45 960,637 4.87 572,104 11.24
Granted - replacement awards — — 200,291 4.87 — —
Distributed (642,992) 7.31 (1,101,115) 8.58 (3,058,307) 1.95
Forfeited/canceled (56,185) 9.50 (63,413) 7.31 (60,974) 9.31
Outstanding at end of year 2,122,826 $ 10.31 2,143,583 $ 7.12 2,147,183 $ 9.10
On March 13, 2020, we granted 0.2 million restricted stock awards as AK Steel replacement awards. The restricted stock awards relating to AK Steel vest
ratably on the first, second and third anniversaries of the grant. We valued the AK Steel replacement rewards at $4.87 per share using the closing price of our
common shares on March 13, 2020, the grant date.
We value our restricted stock units using the closing price of our common shares on the grant date. All of the outstanding restricted stock units are subject
to continued employment, are retention based, and are payable in common shares or cash in certain circumstances at a time determined by the Compensation
Committee at its discretion. Most restricted stock units that were granted in 2021, 2020 and 2019 cliff vest over three years on December 31, 2023, December 31,
2022 and December 31, 2021, respectively.
Stock Options
The following table summarizes the stock option activity:
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Number of
Shares
Weighted
Average
Exercise Price Number of Shares
Weighted
Average
Exercise Price
Number of
Shares
Weighted
Average
Exercise Price
Outstanding at beginning of year 2,485,808 $ 11.60 563,230 $ 10.42 563,230 $ 10.42
Granted - replacement awards — — 2,010,277 11.86 — —
Exercised (1,457,495) 10.36 (79,973) 7.01 — —
Forfeited/canceled (26,253) 36.48 (7,726) 41.04 — —
Outstanding at end of year 1,002,060 $ 12.75 2,485,808 $ 11.60 563,230 $ 10.42
Exercisable at end of year 904,574 $ 13.35 2,172,052 $ 11.86 563,230 $ 10.42
Stock options granted to date generally vest over a period from one to three years with an expiration date at ten years from the date of grant. On March 13,
2020, we granted 2.0 million options as AK Steel replacement awards. The weighted average fair value of the converted options was $0.51 per share and was
calculated using the Black-Scholes option-pricing model. Qualifying termination events resulted in vest date accelerations and reductions to the option expiration
date from ten years to three years.
The total intrinsic value of options exercised in 2021 was $ 13 million and the amount in 2020 was immaterial. For options outstanding at December 31,
2021, the weighted-average remaining contractual life was 3.0 years and the aggregate intrinsic value was $ 10 million. For options exercisable at December 31,
2021, the weighted-average remaining contractual life was 2.6 years and the aggregate intrinsic value was $ 8 million.
125
-- 127 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Nonemployee Directors
Our nonemployee directors are entitled to receive restricted share awards under the Directors’ Plan. For 2021, 2020 and 2019, nonemployee directors were
granted a specified number of restricted shares, with a value equal to $120,000, $100,000 and $100,000, respectively. The number of shares is based on the
closing price of our common shares on the date of the Annual Meeting. The restricted share awards issued under the Directors' Plan generally vest 12 months from
the grant date. The awards are subject to any deferral election and the terms of the Directors’ Plan and an award agreement.
On March 13, 2020, 0.3 million restricted stock units previously awarded to the members of the AK Steel board of directors were distributed per the terms
of the AK Steel Merger Agreement.
For the last three years, grants of restricted and/or deferred shares have been awarded to elected or re-elected nonemployee directors as follows:
Year of Grant Restricted Shares Deferred Shares
2021 58,851 13,078
2020 253,809 54,794
2019 86,477 23,659
NOTE 12 - INCOME TAXES
Income (loss) from continuing operations before income taxes includes the following components:
(In Millions)
2021 2020 2019
United States $ 3,827 $ (201) $ 313
Foreign (24) 8 —
$ 3,803 $ (193) $ 313
The components of the income tax provision (benefit) on continuing operations consist of the following:
(In Millions)
2021 2020 2019
Current provision (benefit):
United States federal $ 14 $ (2) $ (1)
United States state & local 55 — —
Foreign — (1) —
69 (3) (1)
Deferred provision (benefit):
United States federal 683 (95) 19
United States state & local 31 (11) —
Foreign (10) (2) —
Total income tax provision (benefit) from continuing operations $ 773 $ (111) $ 18
126
-- 128 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Reconciliation of our income tax attributable to continuing operations computed at the U.S. federal statutory rate is as follows:
(In Millions)
2021 2020 2019
Tax at U.S. statutory rate $ 799 21 % $ (41) 21 % $ 66 21 %
Increase (decrease) due to:
Percentage depletion in excess of cost depletion (99) (3) (42) 22 (49) (16)
Non-taxable income related to noncontrolling interests (9) — (9) 4 — —
Luxembourg legal entity reduction — — — — 846 271
Valuation allowance release:
Luxembourg legal entity reduction — — — — (846) (271)
State taxes, net 86 2 (11) 6 — —
Other items, net (4) — (8) 4 1 1
Provision for income tax expense (benefit) and effective
income tax rate including discrete items $ 773 20 % $ (111) 57 % $ 18 6 %
The increase in income tax expense in 2021 from income tax benefit in 2020 is directly correlated to the increase in pre-tax book income from the prior
period for both federal and state income tax purposes.
The increase in income tax benefit from 2019 to 2020 is directly correlated to the decrease in pre-tax book income from the prior period for both federal and
state income tax purposes. The Luxembourg legal entity reduction relates to initiatives resulting in the dissolution of certain entities and settlement of related
financial instruments in 2019. The 2019 NOL deferred tax asset reduction resulted in tax expense of $846 million, which was fully offset by a decrease in the
respective valuation allowance.
The components of income taxes for other than continuing operations consisted of the following:
(In Millions)
2021 2020 2019
Other comprehensive income (loss):
Pension and OPEB $ (206) $ (52) $ 11
Derivative financial instruments (21) (1) —
Total $ (227) $ (53) $ 11
127
-- 129 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Significant components of our deferred tax assets and liabilities are as follows:
(In Millions)
2021 2020
Deferred tax assets:
Operating loss and other carryforwards $ 379 $ 1,236
Pension and OPEB liabilities 584 228
State and local 109 132
Other liabilities 287 190
Total deferred tax assets before valuation allowance 1,359 1,786
Deferred tax asset valuation allowance (409) (836)
Net deferred tax assets 950 950
Deferred tax liabilities:
Investment in partnerships (191) (144)
Property, plant and equipment and mineral rights (641) (246)
Other assets (216) (68)
Total deferred tax liabilities (1,048) (458)
Net deferred tax assets (liabilities) $ (98) $ 492
We had gross domestic (including states) and foreign NOLs of $ 2,081 million and $ 1,407 million, respectively, at December 31, 2021. We had gross
domestic and foreign NOLs of $7,444 million and $ 1,592 million, respectively, at December 31, 2020. The U.S. federal NOLs will begin to expire in 2034 and state
NOLs will begin to expire in 2022. The foreign NOLs can be carried forward indefinitely. We had gross interest expense limitation carryforwards of $18 million and
$80 million for the years ended December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively. This interest expense can be carried forward indefinitely.
The changes in the valuation allowance are presented below:
(In Millions)
2021 2020 2019
Balance at beginning of year $ 836 $ 441 $ 1,287
Change in valuation allowance:
Included in income tax benefit (82) (3) (846)
Increase (decrease) from acquisitions (345) 398 —
Balance at end of year $ 409 $ 836 $ 441
During 2021, we recorded a decrease to the valuation allowance of $ 345 million related to the election filed with our 2020 federal tax return to waive the
pre-acquisition NOLs that are limited under Section 382 of the IRC. An offsetting decrease is recorded in the NOL deferred tax asset in the same period. These
amounts relate to a portion of the $398 million valuation allowance recorded during 2020 through opening balance sheet adjustments to reflect the portion of federal
and state NOLs that are limited under Section 382 of the IRC acquired through the AK Steel Merger.
During 2019, a legal entity reduction initiative was completed in Luxembourg resulting in the dissolution of certain entities and settlement of related
financial instruments, triggering the utilization of $1.3 billion of NOL deferred tax asset and reversal of the intercompany notes deferred tax liability of $ 447 million.
The total net deferred tax reduction resulted in an expense of $846 million, which was fully offset by a decrease in the valuation allowance. Our losses in
Luxembourg in recent periods represent sufficient negative evidence to require a full valuation allowance against the remaining deferred tax assets in that
jurisdiction. We intend to maintain a valuation allowance against the deferred tax assets related to these operating losses until sufficient positive evidence exists to
support the realization of such assets.
We also have a valuation allowance recorded against certain state NOLs, which are expected to expire before utilization. At December 31, 2021 and 2020,
we had a valuation allowance recorded against certain state NOLs of $70 million and $ 98 million, respectively.
128
-- 130 of 411 --
Table of Contents
At December 31, 2021 and 2020, we had no cumulative undistributed earnings of foreign subsidiaries included in retained earnings. Accordingly, no
provision has been made for U.S. deferred taxes related to future repatriation of earnings.
A reconciliation of the beginning and ending amount of unrecognized tax benefits is as follows:
(In Millions)
2021 2020 2019
Unrecognized tax benefits balance as of January 1 $ 107 $ 29 $ 29
Increase for tax positions in current year 4 7 —
Decrease for tax positions of prior year (66) (4) —
Lapses in statutes of limitations (10) — —
Increases from acquisitions — 75 —
Unrecognized tax benefits balance as of December 31 $ 35 $ 107 $ 29
At December 31, 2021 and 2020, we had $ 35 million and $ 107 million, respectively, of unrecognized tax benefits recorded. Of this amount, $1 million was
recorded in Other current liabilities for the year ended December 31, 2021. Additionally, $34 million and $ 2 million, were recorded in Other non-current liabilities for
the years ended December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively. An additional $96 million was recorded in Other non-current assets for the year ended December 31,
2020. If the unrecognized tax benefits were recognized, $30 million would impact the effective tax rate. We do not expect that the amount of unrecognized benefits
will change significantly within the next 12 months.
Tax years 2016 and forward remain subject to examination for the U.S., and tax years 2008 and forward remain subject to examination for Canada.
NOTE 13 - LEASE OBLIGATIONS
Our operating leases consist primarily of leases for office space, iron ore vessels, rail cars and processing equipment. Our finance leases consist primarily
of processing equipment and mining equipment. We use our incremental borrowing rate as the discount rate to determine the present value of the lease payments,
as our leases do not have readily determinable implicit discount rates. Our incremental borrowing rate is the rate of interest that we would have to borrow on a
collateralized basis over a similar term and amount in a similar economic environment to pay our lease obligations. We determine the incremental borrowing rates
for our leases by adjusting the local risk-free interest rate with a credit risk premium corresponding to our credit rating. From time to time, we may enter into
arrangements for the construction or purchase of an asset and then enter into a financing arrangement to lease the asset. We recognize leased assets and
liabilities under these arrangements when we obtain control of the asset.
Lease costs are presented below:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020
Operating leases $ 70 $ 43
Finance leases:
Amortization of lease cost 94 15
Interest on lease liabilities 9 4
Short-term leases 66 13
Total $ 239 $ 75
129
-- 131 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Other information related to leases was as follows:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020
Cash paid for amounts included in measurement of lease liabilities:
Operating leases within cash flows from operating activities $ 70 $ 43
Finance leases within cash flows from operating activities $ 9 $ 4
Finance leases within cash flows from financing activities $ 94 $ 15
Right-of-use assets obtained in exchange for new finance lease liabilities $ 50 $ 44
Weighted-average remaining lease term - operating leases (in years) 8 8
Weighted-average remaining lease term - finance leases (in years) 5 5
Weighted-average discount rate - operating leases 7 % 8 %
Weighted-average discount rate - finance leases 4 % 4 %
Right-of-use assets obtained in acquisitions are not included in this figure.
Future minimum lease payments under noncancellable finance and operating leases as of December 31, 2021 were as follows:
(In Millions)
Finance Leases Operating Leases
2022 $ 105 $ 68
2023 96 56
2024 31 47
2025 28 39
2026 19 35
Thereafter 66 133
Total future minimum lease payments 345 378
Less: imputed interest 54 108
Total lease payments 291 270
Less: current portion of lease liabilities 97 50
Long-term lease liabilities $ 194 $ 220
The current and long-term portions of our finance and operating lease liabilities are included in Other current liabilities and Other non-current liabilities,
respectively.
NOTE 14 - ASSET RETIREMENT OBLIGATIONS
The following is a summary of our asset retirement obligations:
(In Millions)
December 31,
2021 2020
Asset retirement obligations $ 449 $ 342
Less: current portion 35 7
Long-term asset retirement obligations $ 414 $ 335
Includes $293 million and $190 million related to our active operations as of December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively.
The accrued closure obligation provides for contractual and legal obligations related to our indefinitely idled and closed operations and for the eventual
closure of our active operations. We performed a detailed assessment of our asset retirement obligations related to our active operations most recently in 2020 in
accordance with our accounting policy, which requires us to perform an in-depth evaluation of the liability every three years in addition to
1
1
1
1
130
-- 132 of 411 --
Table of Contents
routine annual assessments. In 2020, we employed third-party specialists to assist in the evaluation.
The closure date for each of our active mine sites was determined based on the exhaustion date of the remaining mineral reserves, and the amortization of
the related asset and accretion of the liability is recognized over the estimated mine lives. The closure date and expected timing of the capital requirements to meet
our obligations for our indefinitely idled or closed mines is determined based on the unique circumstances of each property. For indefinitely idled or closed mines,
the accretion of the liability is recognized over the anticipated timing of remediation. As the majority of our asset retirement obligations at our steelmaking operations
have indeterminate settlement dates, asset retirement obligations have been recorded at present values using estimated ranges of the economic lives of the
underlying assets.
The following is a roll-forward of our asset retirement obligation liability:
(In Millions)
2021 2020
Asset retirement obligation as of January 1 $ 342 $ 165
Increase from acquisitions 116 172
Accretion expense 18 14
Remediation payments (29) (9)
Revision in estimated cash flows 2 —
Asset retirement obligation as of December 31 $ 449 $ 342
The increase from acquisitions for the year ended December 31, 2021 relates to measurement period adjustments as a result of the final purchase price
allocation of the AM USA Transaction.
NOTE 15 - CAPITAL STOCK
Underwritten Public Offering
On February 11, 2021, we sold 20 million of our common shares and 40 million common shares were sold by an affiliate of ArcelorMittal in an underwritten
public offering. In each case, shares were sold at a price per share of $16.12. Prior to this sale, ArcelorMittal held approximately 78 million of our common shares,
which were issued as a part of the consideration in connection with the AM USA Transaction. We did not receive any proceeds from the sale of the 40 million
common shares sold on behalf of ArcelorMittal. We used the net proceeds from the offering, plus cash on hand, to redeem $322 million aggregate principal amount
of our outstanding 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes.
Acquisition of AK Steel
As more fully described in NOTE 3 - ACQUISITIONS, we acquired AK Steel on March 13, 2020. At the effective time of the AK Steel Merger, each share of
AK Steel common stock issued and outstanding prior to the effective time of the AK Steel Merger was converted into, and became exchangeable for, 0.400 Cliffs
common shares, par value $0.125 per share. We issued a total of 127 million common shares in connection with the AK Steel Merger at a fair value of $ 618 million.
Following the closing of the AK Steel Merger, AK Steel's common stock was de-listed from the NYSE.
Acquisition of ArcelorMittal USA
As more fully described in NOTE 3 - ACQUISITIONS, we acquired ArcelorMittal USA on December 9, 2020. Pursuant to the terms of the AM USA
Transaction Agreement, we issued 78,186,671 common shares and 583,273 shares of a new series of our Serial Preferred Stock, Class B, without par value,
designated as the “Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock,” in each case to an indirect, wholly owned subsidiary of ArcelorMittal as part of the
consideration paid by us in connection with the closing of the AM USA Transaction.
Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock Redemption
We had 583,273 shares of our Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock issued and outstanding as of December 31, 2020. During the third
quarter of 2021, we redeemed all 583,273 shares of our Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock at a redemption price of $ 1.3 billion using borrowings
under our ABL Facility.
131
-- 133 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Amendment to Articles of Incorporation
On April 29, 2021, we filed a Certificate of Amendment to our Fourth Amended Articles of Incorporation, as amended, to increase the total number of
authorized common shares from 600,000,000 to 1,200,000,000.
Preferred Stock
We have 3,000,000 shares of Serial Preferred Stock, Class A, without par value, authorized, of which, none are issued or outstanding as of December 31,
2021. We also have 4,000,000 shares of Serial Preferred Stock, Class B, without par value, authorized, of which, none are issued or outstanding as of
December 31, 2021.
Dividends
The below table summarizes our recent dividend activity:
Declaration Date Record Date Payment Date
Dividend Declared per Common
Share
2/18/2020 4/3/2020 4/15/2020 $ 0.06
12/2/2019 1/3/2020 1/15/2020 0.06
Subsequent to the dividend paid on April 15, 2020, our Board suspended future dividends.
Share Repurchase Program
In 2018, our Board of Directors authorized a program to repurchase outstanding common shares in the open market or in privately negotiated transactions.
The share repurchase program was effective until December 31, 2019. During 2019, we repurchased 24 million common shares at a cost of $ 253 million in the
aggregate, including commissions and fees.
NOTE 16 - ACCUMULATED OTHER COMPREHENSIVE INCOME (LOSS)
The components of Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) within Cliffs shareholders’ equity and related tax effects allocated to each are shown
below:
(In Millions)
Pre-tax
Amount Tax Benefit
(Expense) After-tax
Amount
As of December 31, 2021:
Pension and OPEB $ 669 $ (120) $ 549
Foreign currency translation adjustments 1 — 1
Derivative financial instruments 89 (21) 68
$ 759 $ (141) $ 618
As of December 31, 2020:
Pension and OPEB $ (221) $ 86 $ (135)
Foreign currency translation adjustments 3 — 3
Derivative financial instruments (1) — (1)
$ (219) $ 86 $ (133)
As of December 31, 2019:
Pension and OPEB $ (454) $ 138 $ (316)
Derivative financial instruments (4) 1 (3)
$ (458) $ 139 $ (319)
132
-- 134 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The following table reflects the changes in Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) related to Cliffs shareholders’ equity:
(In Millions)
Postretirement
Benefit Liability,
net of tax Foreign Currency
Translation
Derivative Financial
Instruments,
net of tax
Accumulated Other
Comprehensive Income
(Loss)
December 31, 2018 $ (281) $ — $ (3) $ (284)
Other comprehensive loss before reclassifications (57) — (2) (59)
Net loss reclassified from AOCI 22 — 2 24
December 31, 2019 (316) — (3) (319)
Other comprehensive income (loss) before reclassifications 163 3 (6) 160
Net loss reclassified from AOCI 18 — 8 26
December 31, 2020 (135) 3 (1) (133)
Other comprehensive income (loss) before reclassifications 675 (2) 117 790
Net loss (gain) reclassified from AOCI 9 — (48) (39)
December 31, 2021 $ 549 $ 1 $ 68 $ 618
The following table reflects the details about Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss) components reclassified from Cliffs shareholders’ equity:
(In Millions)
Details about Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income
(Loss) Components
Amount of (Gain)/Loss
Reclassified into Income,
Net of Tax Affected Line Item in the Statement of
Consolidated Operations
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Changes in pension and OPEB:
Prior service costs $ (1) $ (1) $ (1) Net periodic benefit credits (costs) other than
service cost component
Net actuarial loss 35 30 29
Net periodic benefit credits (costs) other than
service cost component
Settlements (22) (6) —
Net periodic benefit credits (costs) other than
service cost component
Total before taxes 12 23 28
Income tax benefit (3) (5) (6) Income tax benefit (expense)
Net of taxes $ 9 $ 18 $ 22
Changes in derivative financial instruments:
Commodity contracts $ (61) $ 10 $ 3 Cost of goods sold
Income tax expense (benefit) 13 (2) (1) Income tax benefit (expense)
Net of taxes $ (48) $ 8 $ 2
Total reclassifications for the period, net of tax $ (39) $ 26 $ 24
See NOTE 10 - PENSIONS AND OTHER POSTRETIREMENT BENEFITS for further information.
1
1
1
1
133
-- 135 of 411 --
Table of Contents
NOTE 17 - RELATED PARTIES
We have certain co-owned joint ventures with companies from the steel and mining industries, including integrated steel companies, their subsidiaries and
other downstream users of steel and iron ore products.
Hibbing is a co-owned joint venture with U.S. Steel, in which, as of both December 31, 2020 and December 31, 2021, we own 85.3% and U.S. Steel owns
14.7%. As a result of the AM USA Transaction, we acquired an additional 62.3% ownership stake in the Hibbing mine and became the majority owner and mine
manager. Prior to the AM USA Transaction, ArcelorMittal was a related party due to its ownership interest in Hibbing. As such, certain long-term contracts with
ArcelorMittal resulted in Revenues from related parties, and are included within the below.
Revenues from related parties were as follows:
(In Millions)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Revenue from related parties $ 139 $ 893 $ 1,015
Revenues $ 20,444 $ 5,354 $ 1,990
Related party revenues as a percent of Revenues 0.7 % 16.7 % 51.0 %
Purchases from related parties $ 94 $ 16 $ —
The following table presents the classification of related party assets and liabilities in the Statements of Consolidated Financial Position:
(In Millions)
December 31,
Balance Sheet Location of Assets (Liabilities) 2021 2020
Accounts receivable, net $ 3 $ 2
Accounts payable (7) (6)
NOTE 18 - VARIABLE INTEREST ENTITIES
SunCoke Middletown
We purchase all the coke and electrical power generated from SunCoke Middletown’s plant under long-term supply agreements and have committed to
purchase all the expected production from the facility through 2032. We consolidate SunCoke Middletown as a VIE because we are the primary beneficiary despite
having no ownership interest in SunCoke Middletown. SunCoke Middletown had income before income taxes of $52 million and $ 41 million for the years ended
December 31, 2021 and 2020, respectively, which was included in our consolidated Income (loss) from continuing operations before income taxes .
The assets of the consolidated VIE can only be used to settle the obligations of the consolidated VIE and not obligations of the Company. The creditors of
SunCoke Middletown do not have recourse to the assets or general credit of the Company to satisfy liabilities of the VIE. The Statements of Consolidated Financial
Position includes the following amounts for SunCoke Middletown:
(In Millions)
December 31,
2021 2020
Cash and cash equivalents $ — $ 5
Inventories 20 21
Property, plant and equipment, net 300 308
Accounts payable (12) (15)
Other assets (liabilities), net (12) (10)
Noncontrolling interests (296) (309)
134
-- 136 of 411 --
Table of Contents
NOTE 19 - EARNINGS PER SHARE
The following table summarizes the computation of basic and diluted EPS:
(In Millions, Except Per Share Amounts)
Year Ended December 31,
2021 2020 2019
Income (loss) from continuing operations $ 3,030 $ (82) $ 295
Income from continuing operations attributable to noncontrolling interest (45) (41) —
Net income (loss) from continuing operations attributable to Cliffs shareholders 2,985 (123) 295
Income (loss) from discontinued operations, net of tax 3 1 (2)
Net income (loss) attributable to Cliffs shareholders $ 2,988 $ (122) $ 293
Weighted average number of shares:
Basic 498 379 277
Redeemable preferred shares 33 — —
Convertible senior notes 22 — 4
Employee stock plans 5 — 3
Diluted 558 379 284
Earnings (loss) per common share attributable to
Cliffs common shareholders - basic :
Continuing operations $ 5.62 $ (0.32) $ 1.07
Discontinued operations 0.01 — (0.01)
$ 5.63 $ (0.32) $ 1.06
Earnings (loss) per common share attributable to
Cliffs common shareholders - diluted:
Continuing operations $ 5.35 $ (0.32) $ 1.04
Discontinued operations 0.01 — (0.01)
$ 5.36 $ (0.32) $ 1.03
For the year ended December 31, 2021, basic earnings per share was calculated by dividingNet income (loss) attributable to Cliffs shareholders, less $187 million of
earnings attributed to Series B Participating Redeemable Preferred Stock, by the weighted average number of basic common shares outstanding during the period presented.
The following table summarizes the shares that have been excluded from the diluted earnings per share calculation for the year ended December 31,
2020, as they were anti-dilutive:
(In Millions)
2020
Redeemable preferred shares 4
Convertible senior notes 2
Shares related to employee stock plans 1
NOTE 20 - COMMITMENTS AND CONTINGENCIES
Purchase Commitments
We purchase portions of the principal raw materials required for our steel manufacturing operations under annual and multi-year agreements, some of
which have minimum quantity requirements. We also use large volumes of natural gas, electricity and industrial gases in our steel manufacturing operations. We
negotiate most of our purchases of chrome, industrial gases and a portion of our electricity under multi-year agreements. Our purchases of
1
1
135
-- 137 of 411 --
Table of Contents
coke are made under annual or multi-year agreements with periodic price adjustments. We typically purchase coal under annual fixed-price agreements. We also
purchase certain transportation services under multi-year contracts with minimum quantity requirements.
Contingencies
We are currently the subject of, or party to, various claims and legal proceedings incidental to our current and historical operations. These claims and legal
proceedings are subject to inherent uncertainties and unfavorable rulings could occur. An unfavorable ruling could include monetary damages, additional funding
requirements or an injunction. If an unfavorable ruling were to occur, there exists the possibility of a material adverse effect on our financial position and results of
operations for the period in which the ruling occurs or future periods. However, based on currently available information we do not believe that any pending claims
or legal proceedings will result in a material adverse effect in relation to our consolidated financial statements.
Environmental Contingencies
Although we believe our operating practices have been consistent with prevailing industry standards, hazardous materials may have been released at
operating sites or third-party sites in the past, including operating sites that we no longer own. If we reasonably can, we estimate potential remediation expenditures
for those sites where future remediation efforts are probable based on identified conditions, regulatory requirements, or contractual obligations arising from the sale
of a business or facility. For sites involving government required investigations, we typically make an estimate of potential remediation expenditures only after the
investigation is complete and when we better understand the nature and scope of the remediation. In general, the material factors in these estimates include the
costs associated with investigations, delineations, risk assessments, remedial work, governmental response and oversight, site monitoring, and preparation of
reports to the appropriate environmental agencies.
The following is a summary of our environmental obligations:
(In Millions)
December 31,
2021 December 31,
2020
Environmental obligations $ 207 $ 135
Less current portion 20 18
Long-term environmental obligations $ 187 $ 117
The increase in environmental obligations as of December 31, 2021, compared to December 31, 2020, related to measurement period adjustments as a
result of the purchase price allocation of the AM USA Transaction and the preliminary purchase price allocation of the FPT Acquisition.
We cannot predict the ultimate costs for each site with certainty because of the evolving nature of the investigation and remediation process. Rather, to
estimate the probable costs, we must make certain assumptions. The most significant of these assumptions is for the nature and scope of the work that will be
necessary to investigate and remediate a particular site and the cost of that work. Other significant assumptions include the cleanup technology that will be used,
whether and to what extent any other parties will participate in paying the investigation and remediation costs, reimbursement of past response costs and future
oversight costs by governmental agencies, and the reaction of the governing environmental agencies to the proposed work plans. Costs for future investigation and
remediation are not discounted to their present value, unless the amount and timing of the cash disbursements are readily known. To the extent that we have been
able to reasonably estimate future liabilities, we do not believe that there is a reasonable possibility that we will incur a loss or losses that exceed the amounts we
accrued for the environmental matters discussed below that would, either individually or in the aggregate, have a material adverse effect on our consolidated
financial condition, results of operations or cash flows. However, since we recognize amounts in the consolidated financial statements in accordance with GAAP
that exclude potential losses that are not probable or that may not be currently estimable, the ultimate costs of these environmental matters may be higher than the
liabilities we currently have recorded in our consolidated financial statements.
Pursuant to RCRA, which governs the treatment, handling and disposal of hazardous waste, the EPA and authorized state environmental agencies may
conduct inspections of RCRA-regulated facilities to identify areas where there have been releases of hazardous waste or hazardous constituents into the
environment and may order the facilities to take corrective action to remediate such releases. Likewise, the EPA or the states may require closure or post-closure
care of residual, industrial and hazardous waste management units. Environmental regulators have the
136
-- 138 of 411 --
Table of Contents
authority to inspect all of our facilities. While we cannot predict the future actions of these regulators, it is possible that they may identify conditions in future
inspections of these facilities that they believe require corrective action.
Pursuant to CERCLA, the EPA and state environmental authorities have conducted site investigations at some of our facilities and other third-party
facilities, portions of which previously may have been used for disposal of materials that are currently regulated. The results of these investigations are still pending,
and we could be directed to spend funds for remedial activities at the former disposal areas. Because of the uncertain status of these investigations, however, we
cannot reasonably predict whether or when such spending might be required or its magnitude.
On April 29, 2002, AK Steel entered a mutually agreed-upon administrative order with the consent of the EPA pursuant to Section 122 of CERCLA to
perform a RI/FS of the Hamilton plant site located in New Miami, Ohio. The plant ceased operations in 1990 and all of its former structures have been demolished.
AK Steel submitted the investigation portion of the RI/FS and completed supplemental studies. Until the RI/FS is complete, we cannot reasonably estimate the
additional costs, if any, we may incur for potentially required remediation of the site or when we may incur them.
Burns Harbor Water Issues
In August 2019, ArcelorMittal Burns Harbor LLC (n/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Burns Harbor LLC) suffered a loss of the blast furnace cooling water recycle
system, which led to the discharge of cyanide and ammonia in excess of the Burns Harbor plant's NPDES permit limits. Since that time, the facility has taken
numerous steps to prevent recurrence and maintain compliance with its NPDES permit. We engaged in settlement discussions with the U.S. Department of Justice,
the EPA and the State of Indiana to resolve any alleged violations of environmental laws or regulations arising out of the August 2019 event. Later stages of the
settlement discussions included the Environmental Law and Policy Center (ELPC) and Hoosier Environmental Council (HEC), which had filed a lawsuit on
December 20, 2019 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Indiana alleging violations resulting from the August 2019 event and other Clean Water Act
claims. We believe that a consent decree has been finalized and is currently pending final approvals, which requires specified enhancements to the mill's
wastewater treatment systems and a $3 million civil penalty, along with other terms and conditions. ELPC and HEC are also proposed signatories to the consent
decree. ArcelorMittal Burns Harbor LLC was served with a subpoena on December 5, 2019, from the United States District Court for the Northern District of
Indiana, relating to the August 2019 event and has responded to the subpoena requests, including follow-up requests. With the resolution of monetary sanctions
and injunctive relief requirements under the pending consent decree, we do not believe that the costs to resolve any other third-party claims, including potential
natural resource damages claims, that may arise out of the August 2019 event are likely to have, individually or in the aggregate, a material adverse effect on our
consolidated financial condition, results of operations or cash flows.
In addition to the foregoing matters, we are or may be involved in proceedings with various regulatory authorities that may require us to pay fines, comply
with more rigorous standards or other requirements or incur capital and operating expenses for environmental compliance. We believe that the ultimate disposition
of any such proceedings will not have, individually or in the aggregate, a material adverse effect on our consolidated financial condition, results of operations or
cash flows.
Tax Matters
The calculation of our tax liabilities involves dealing with uncertainties in the application of complex tax regulations. We recognize liabilities for anticipated
tax audit issues based on our estimate of whether, and the extent to which, additional taxes will be due. If we ultimately determine that payment of these amounts is
unnecessary, we reverse the liability and recognize a tax benefit during the period in which we determine that the liability is no longer necessary. We also
recognize tax benefits to the extent that it is more likely than not that our positions will be sustained when challenged by the taxing authorities. To the extent we
prevail in matters for which liabilities have been established, or are required to pay amounts in excess of our liabilities, our effective tax rate in a given period could
be materially affected. An unfavorable tax settlement would require use of our cash and result in an increase in our effective tax rate in the year of resolution. A
favorable tax settlement would be recognized as a reduction in our effective tax rate in the year of resolution. Refer to NOTE 12 - INCOME TAXES for further
information.
Other Contingencies
In addition to the matters discussed above, there are various pending and potential claims against us and our subsidiaries involving product liability,
personal injury, commercial, employee benefits and other matters arising in the ordinary course of business. Because of the considerable uncertainties that exist for
any claim, it is difficult to reliably
137
-- 139 of 411 --
Table of Contents
or accurately estimate what the amount of a loss would be if a claimant prevails. If material assumptions or factual understandings we rely on to evaluate exposure
for these contingencies prove to be inaccurate or otherwise change, we may be required to record a liability for an adverse outcome. If, however, we have
reasonably evaluated potential future liabilities for all of these contingencies, including those described more specifically above, it is our opinion, unless we
otherwise noted, that the ultimate liability from these contingencies, individually or in the aggregate, should not have a material adverse effect on our consolidated
financial position, results of operations or cash flows.
NOTE 21 - SUBSEQUENT EVENTS
On December 1, 2021, we issued a notice of redemption for all $ 294 million in aggregate principal amount outstanding of the 1.500% 2025 Convertible
Senior Notes. The 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes were redeemed on January 18, 2022, through a combination settlement, with the aggregate principal
amount of $294 million paid in cash, and 24 million common shares, with a fair value of $ 499 million, delivered to noteholders in settlement of the premium due per
the terms of the indenture, plus cash in respect of the accrued and unpaid interest on the 1.500% 2025 Convertible Senior Notes to, but not including, the
redemption date per the terms of the indenture.
On February 10, 2022, our Board of Directors authorized a program to repurchase outstanding common shares in the open market or in privately
negotiated transactions, which may include purchases pursuant to Rule 10b5-1 plans or accelerated share repurchases, up to a maximum of $1 billion. We are not
obligated to make any purchases and the program may be suspended or discontinued at any time. The share repurchase program does not have a specific
expiration date.
138
-- 140 of 411 --
Table of Contents
REPORT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM
To the shareholders and the Board of Directors of
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
Opinion on the Financial Statements
We have audited the accompanying statements of consolidated financial position of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and subsidiaries (the "Company") as of December 31,
2021 and 2020, the related statements of consolidated operations, comprehensive income, cash flows, and changes in equity, for each of the three years in the
period ended December 31, 2021, and the related notes (collectively referred to as the "financial statements"). In our opinion, the financial statements present fairly,
in all material respects, the financial position of the Company as of December 31, 2021 and 2020, and the results of its operations and its cash flows for each of the
three years in the period ended December 31, 2021, in conformity with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of America.
We have also audited, in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States) (PCAOB), the Company's internal
control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2021, based on criteria established in Internal Control — Integrated Framework (2013) issued by the Committee
of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission and our report dated February 11, 2022, expressed an unqualified opinion on the Company's internal
control over financial reporting.
Basis for Opinion
These financial statements are the responsibility of the Company's management. Our responsibility is to express an opinion on the Company's financial statements
based on our audits. We are a public accounting firm registered with the PCAOB and are required to be independent with respect to the Company in accordance
with the U.S. federal securities laws and the applicable rules and regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission and the PCAOB.
We conducted our audits in accordance with the standards of the PCAOB. Those standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable
assurance about whether the financial statements are free of material misstatement, whether due to error or fraud. Our audits included performing procedures to
assess the risks of material misstatement of the financial statements, whether due to error or fraud, and performing procedures that respond to those risks. Such
procedures included examining, on a test basis, evidence regarding the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. Our audits also included evaluating
the accounting principles used and significant estimates made by management, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the financial statements. We
believe that our audits provide a reasonable basis for our opinion.
Critical Audit Matter
The critical audit matter communicated below is a matter arising from the current-period audit of the financial statements that was communicated or required to be
communicated to the audit committee and that (1) relates to accounts or disclosures that are material to the financial statements and (2) involved our especially
challenging, subjective, or complex judgments. The communication of critical audit matters does not alter in any way our opinion on the financial statements, taken
as a whole, and we are not, by communicating the critical audit matter below, providing a separate opinion on the critical audit matter or on the accounts or
disclosures to which it relates.
Mineral Reserves — Asset Retirement Obligations, Valuation of Long-Lived Assets, Depreciation, Depletion and Amortization of Property, Plant and
Equipment and Valuation in Acquisition Accounting — Refer to Notes 3, 5, 6 and 14 to the financial statements
Critical Audit Matter Description
Iron ore mineral reserve estimates, combined with estimated annual production levels, are used to determine the iron ore mine closure dates utilized in recording
the fair value liability for asset retirement obligations for active operating iron ore mines. Since the liability represents the present value of the expected future
obligation, a significant change in iron ore mineral reserves or iron ore mine lives could have a substantial effect on the recorded obligation. Iron ore mineral reserve
estimates are also used in evaluating potential impairments of iron ore mine asset groups as they are indicative of future cash flows and in determining maximum
useful lives utilized to calculate depreciation, depletion and amortization of long-lived iron ore mine assets. Further, iron ore mineral reserve estimates are used in
estimating the fair value of mineral reserves established through the purchase price allocation in a business combination.
139
-- 141 of 411 --
Table of Contents
The Company performs an in-depth evaluation of its iron ore mineral reserve estimates by iron ore mine on a periodic basis, in addition to routine annual
assessments. The determination of iron ore mineral reserves requires management, with the support of management’s experts, to make significant estimates and
assumptions related to key inputs including (1) the determination of the size and scope of the iron ore body through technical modeling, (2) the estimates of future
iron ore prices recognizing that the price shall not exceed the three-year trailing average index price of iron ore adjusted to the Company’s realized price,
production costs and capital expenditures, and (3) management’s mine plan for the proven and probable iron ore mineral reserves (collectively “the iron ore mineral
reserve inputs”). Changes in any of the judgments or assumptions related to the iron ore mineral reserve inputs can have a significant impact with respect to the
accrual for asset retirement obligations, the impairment of long-lived asset groups, the amount of depreciation, depletion and amortization expense and the
estimated fair value of mineral reserves established through the purchase price allocation in a business combination. The consolidated asset retirement obligation
balance was $449 million as of December 31, 2021, of which $208 million related to active iron ore mine operations. The total asset balance associated with the
Company’s Steelmaking reportable segment was $18,326 million as of December 31, 2021, of which $1,622 million related to long-lived assets associated with the
Company’s combined iron ore mine asset groups, and is inclusive of $231 million related to iron ore mineral reserves acquired through the AM USA Transaction.
Depreciation, depletion and amortization expense for the Company’s combined iron ore mine asset groups was $172 million for the year ended December 31,
2021.
Given the significant judgments and assumptions made by management to estimate iron ore mineral reserves and the sensitivity of changes to iron ore mineral
reserve estimates on the Company’s recorded asset retirement obligations, long-lived asset impairment considerations, calculated depreciation, depletion and
amortization expense and estimated fair value of mineral reserves established through the purchase price allocation of a business combination, performing audit
procedures to evaluate the reasonableness of management’s judgments and estimates related to the iron ore mineral reserve inputs required a high degree of
auditor judgment and an increased extent of effort.
How the Critical Audit Matter Was Addressed in the Audit
Our audit procedures related to management’s significant judgments and assumptions related to iron ore mineral reserve quantities and the related iron ore mine
closure dates included the following, among others:
• We tested the operating effectiveness of internal controls related to the Company’s estimation of iron ore mineral reserve quantities and the related iron ore
mine closure dates.
• We evaluated the experience, qualifications and objectivity of management’s experts, including in-house iron ore mine engineers and the third-party
Qualified Person.
• For an iron ore mine subject to the Company’s routine annual assessment we evaluated management’s assessment by:
◦ Understanding the process used by management to survey and analyze the geological and operational status of current year iron ore mine
production.
◦ Evaluating the historical accuracy of management’s technical model as compared to actual iron ore mine production results.
◦ Comparing the iron ore mine plan per the most recent Technical Report Summary, updated for current year depletion, to:
▪ Presentations to the Audit Committee.
▪ Information by asset group, asset retirement obligation valuation models, depreciation, depletion and amortization expense calculations and
mineral reserve purchase price allocation valuation models.
• For an iron ore mine subject to the Company’s periodic in-depth evaluation of its iron ore mineral reserve estimate:
◦ We evaluated management’s determination of the size and scope of the iron ore body, by:
▪ Understanding the process used by management to complete research and exploration activities including mineralized resource drill
samples.
140
-- 142 of 411 --
Table of Contents
▪ Understanding the methodology utilized by management to apply the research and exploration data to the development of a technical model
of the iron ore body.
▪ Evaluating the historical accuracy of management’s technical model as compared to actual iron ore mine production results.
◦ We evaluated management’s estimates of future iron ore prices, production costs and capital expenditures (the “financial assumptions”) as included
in the Technical Report Summary, by:
▪ Understanding and testing the methodology utilized by management for development of the future iron ore prices recognizing that the price
shall not exceed the three-year trailing average index price of iron ore adjusted to the Company’s realized price.
▪ Evaluated management’s ability to accurately forecast future iron ore prices, production costs and capital expenditures by comparing actual
results to management’s historical forecasts.
▪ Evaluated the reasonableness of management’s estimates of future iron ore prices to forecasted information included in analyst reports.
▪ Evaluated the reasonableness of management’s forecast for production costs and capital expenditures by comparing the forecasts to: (1)
historical results and (2) internal communications among management and to the Board of Directors.
◦ We evaluated management’s iron ore mine plan for the proven and probable mineral reserves as included in the Technical Report Summary, by:
▪ Understanding the process used by management to develop the iron ore mine plan for proven and probable iron ore mineral reserves
applying key inputs such as the technical model of the iron ore body and the financial assumptions.
▪ Comparing the iron ore mine plan to
• Presentations to the Audit Committee.
• Historical iron ore mine plan(s).
• Information by asset group, asset retirement obligation valuation models, depreciation, depletion and amortization expense
calculations, and mineral reserve purchase price allocation valuation models.
/s/ DELOITTE & TOUCHE LLP
Cleveland, Ohio
February 11, 2022
We have served as the Company's auditor since 2004.
141
-- 143 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Item 9. Changes in and Disagreements With Accountants on Accounting and Financial Disclosure
None.
Item 9A. Controls and Procedures
We maintain disclosure controls and procedures that are designed to ensure that information required to be disclosed in our Exchange Act reports is
recorded, processed, summarized and reported within the time periods specified in the SEC’s rules and forms, and that such information is accumulated and
communicated to our management, including our President and Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, as appropriate, to allow timely decisions
regarding required disclosure based solely on the definition of “disclosure controls and procedures” in Rule 13a-15(e) promulgated under the Exchange Act. In
designing and evaluating the disclosure controls and procedures, management recognized that any controls and procedures, no matter how well designed and
operated, can provide only reasonable assurance of achieving the desired control objectives, and management necessarily was required to apply its judgment in
evaluating the cost-benefit relationship of possible controls and procedures.
As of the end of the period covered by this report, we carried out an evaluation under the supervision and with the participation of our management,
including our President and Chief Executive Officer and our Chief Financial Officer, of the effectiveness of the design and operation of our disclosure controls and
procedures. Based on the foregoing, our President and Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer concluded that our disclosure controls and procedures
were effective.
142
-- 144 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Management's Report on Internal Control Over Financial Reporting
Our management is responsible for establishing and maintaining adequate internal control over financial reporting as such term is defined under Rule 13a-
15(f) promulgated under the Exchange Act.
Internal control over financial reporting is a process designed to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the
preparation of the Company's consolidated financial statements for external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles.
Internal control over financial reporting includes those policies and procedures that (i) pertain to the maintenance of records that, in reasonable detail,
accurately and fairly reflect the transactions and dispositions of the assets of the Company; (ii) provide reasonable assurance that transactions are recorded as
necessary to permit the preparation of the consolidated financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and that receipts and
expenditures of the Company are being made only in accordance with appropriate authorizations of management and directors of the Company; and (iii) provide
reasonable assurance regarding prevention or timely detection of unauthorized acquisition, use or disposition of the Company's assets that could have a material
effect on the consolidated financial statements.
Because of its inherent limitations, internal control over financial reporting may not prevent or detect misstatements. Also, projections of any evaluation of
effectiveness to future periods are subject to the risk that controls may become inadequate because of changes in conditions, or that the degree of compliance with
the policies or procedures may deteriorate.
Management conducted an assessment of the Company's internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2021 using the framework specified
in Internal Control - Integrated Framework (2013), published by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission. We have excluded from
our assessment the internal control over financial reporting at FPT, which was acquired on November 18, 2021, and whose assets as of December 31, 2021
constituted 5% of the Company’s consolidated total assets as of December 31, 2021, and whose revenues for the period from November 18, 2021 through
December 31, 2021, inclusive, constituted less than 1% of the Company’s consolidated revenues for the year ended December 31, 2021.
Based on such assessment, management has concluded that the Company's internal control over financial reporting was effective as of December 31,
2021.
The effectiveness of the Company's internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2021 has been audited by Deloitte & Touche LLP (PCAOB
ID No. 34), an independent registered public accounting firm, as stated in their report that appears herein.
February 11, 2022
Changes in Internal Control Over Financial Reporting
There have been no changes in our internal control over financial reporting or in other factors that occurred during our last fiscal quarter that have
materially affected, or are reasonably likely to materially affect, our internal control over financial reporting.
143
-- 145 of 411 --
Table of Contents
REPORT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM
To the shareholders and the Board of Directors of
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
Opinion on Internal Control over Financial Reporting
We have audited the internal control over financial reporting of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and subsidiaries (the "Company") as of December 31, 2021, based on criteria
established in Internal Control — Integrated Framework (2013) issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO). In our
opinion, the Company maintained, in all material respects, effective internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2021, based on criteria established
in Internal Control — Integrated Framework (2013) issued by COSO.
We have also audited, in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States) (PCAOB), the consolidated financial
statements as of and for the year ended December 31, 2021, of the Company and our report dated February 11, 2022, expressed an unqualified opinion on those
financial statements.
As described in Management’s Report on Internal Control Over Financial Reporting , management excluded from its assessment the internal control over financial
reporting at FPT, which was acquired on November 18, 2021, and whose assets as of December 31, 2021 constituted 5% of the Company’s consolidated total
assets as of December 31, 2021, and whose revenues for the period from November 18, 2021 through December 31, 2021, inclusive, constituted less than 1% of
the Company’s consolidated revenues for the year ended December 31, 2021. Accordingly, our audit did not include the internal control over financial reporting at
FPT.
Basis for Opinion
The Company’s management is responsible for maintaining effective internal control over financial reporting and for its assessment of the effectiveness of internal
control over financial reporting, included in the accompanying Management’s Report on Internal Control Over Financial Reporting. Our responsibility is to express
an opinion on the Company’s internal control over financial reporting based on our audit. We are a public accounting firm registered with the PCAOB and are
required to be independent with respect to the Company in accordance with the U.S. federal securities laws and the applicable rules and regulations of the
Securities and Exchange Commission and the PCAOB.
We conducted our audit in accordance with the standards of the PCAOB. Those standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable
assurance about whether effective internal control over financial reporting was maintained in all material respects. Our audit included obtaining an understanding of
internal control over financial reporting, assessing the risk that a material weakness exists, testing and evaluating the design and operating effectiveness of internal
control based on the assessed risk, and performing such other procedures as we considered necessary in the circumstances. We believe that our audit provides a
reasonable basis for our opinion.
Definition and Limitations of Internal Control over Financial Reporting
A company’s internal control over financial reporting is a process designed to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the
preparation of financial statements for external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. A company’s internal control over financial
reporting includes those policies and procedures that (1) pertain to the maintenance of records that, in reasonable detail, accurately and fairly reflect the
transactions and dispositions of the assets of the company; (2) provide reasonable assurance that transactions are recorded as necessary to permit preparation of
financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and that receipts and expenditures of the company are being made only in
accordance with authorizations of management and directors of the company; and (3) provide reasonable assurance regarding prevention or timely detection of
unauthorized acquisition, use, or disposition of the company’s assets that could have a material effect on the financial statements.
Because of its inherent limitations, internal control over financial reporting may not prevent or detect misstatements. Also, projections of any evaluation of
effectiveness to future periods are subject to the risk that controls may become inadequate because of changes in conditions, or that the degree of compliance with
the policies or procedures may deteriorate.
/s/ DELOITTE & TOUCHE LLP
Cleveland, Ohio
February 11, 2022
144
-- 146 of 411 --
Item 9B. Other Information
None.
Item 9C. Disclosure Regarding Foreign Jurisdictions that Prevent Inspections
Not applicable.
145
-- 147 of 411 --
Table of Contents
PART III
Item 10. Directors, Executive Officers and Corporate Governance
The information required to be furnished by this Item will be set forth in the definitive proxy statement for our 2022 Annual Meeting of Shareholders (the
"Proxy Statement") under the headings "Board Meetings and Committees — Audit Committee", "Code of Business Conduct and Ethics", "Independence and
Related Party Transactions", and "Information Concerning Director Nominees”, and is incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof from the Proxy
Statement. The information regarding executive officers required by this Item is set forth in Part I - Item 1. Business hereof under the heading “Information About
Our Executive Officers”, which information is incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof.
Item 11. Executive Compensation
The information required to be furnished by this Item will be set forth in the Proxy Statement under the headings “Director Compensation”, "Compensation
Discussion and Analysis", “Compensation Committee Report”, “Compensation Committee Interlocks and Insider Participation”, "Compensation-Related Risk
Assessment" and “Executive Compensation” and is incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof from the Proxy Statement.
Item 12. Security Ownership of Certain Beneficial Owners and Management and Related Stockholder
Matters
The information required to be furnished by this Item will be set forth in the Proxy Statement under the headings "Ownership of Equity Securities of the
Company" and "Equity Compensation Plan Information" and is incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof from the Proxy Statement.
Item 13. Certain Relationships and Related Transactions, and Director Independence
The information required to be furnished by this Item will be set forth in the Proxy Statement under the heading “Independence and Related Party
Transactions” and is incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof from the Proxy Statement.
Item 14. Principal Accountant Fees and Services
The information required to be furnished by this Item will be set forth in the Proxy Statement under the heading “Ratification of Independent Registered
Public Accounting Firm” and is incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof from the Proxy Statement.
146
-- 148 of 411 --
Table of Contents
PART IV
Item 15. Exhibits and Financial Statement Schedules
(a)(1) - List of Financial Statements
The following consolidated financial statements of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. are included at Item 8. Financial Statements and Supplementary Data above:
• Statements of Consolidated Financial Position - December 31, 2021 and 2020
• Statements of Consolidated Operations - Years ended December 31, 2021, 2020 and 2019
• Statements of Consolidated Comprehensive Income - Years ended December 31, 2021, 2020 and 2019
• Statements of Consolidated Cash Flows - Years ended December 31, 2021, 2020 and 2019
• Statements of Consolidated Changes in Equity - Years ended December 31, 2021, 2020 and 2019
• Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(a)(2) - Financial Statement Schedules
All schedules for which provision is made in the applicable accounting regulation of the SEC are not required under the related instructions or are
inapplicable, and therefore have been omitted or are contained in the applicable financial statements or the notes thereto.
(a)(3) List of Exhibits
All documents referenced below have been filed pursuant to the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 by Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., file number 1-09844, unless
otherwise indicated.
Exhibit
Number Exhibit
Articles of Incorporation and Regulations of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
3.1 Fourth Amended Articles of Incorporation of Cliffs, as filed with the Secretary of State of the State of Ohio on September 25, 2020 (filed as
Exhibit 3.2 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on September 28, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference).
3.2 Certificate of Amendment to Fourth Amended Articles of Incorporation of Cliffs, as filed with the Secretary of State of Ohio on December 7, 2020
(filed as Exhibit 3.1 to Cliffs' Form 8-K on December 9, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference).
3.3 Certificate of Amendment to Fourth Amended Articles of Incorporation of Cliffs, as amended, as filed with the Secretary of State of Ohio on April
29, 2021 (filed as Exhibit 3.1 to Cliffs' Form 8-K on April 30, 2021 and incorporated herein by reference).
3.4 Regulations of Cliffs (filed as Exhibit 3.2 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by reference).
Instruments defining rights of security holders, including indentures
4.1 Indenture, dated as of March 17, 2010, between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (n/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.) and U.S. Bank National Association,
as trustee (filed as Exhibit 4.3 to Cliffs’ Registration Statement on Form S-3 (Registration No. 333-186617) on February 12, 2013 and
incorporated herein by reference).
4.2 Third Supplemental Indenture, dated as of September 20, 2010, between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (n/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.) and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee, including Form of 6.25% Notes due 2040 (filed as Exhibit 4.4 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on September 17, 2010
and incorporated herein by reference).
4.3 Fifth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of March 31, 2011, between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (n/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.) and U.S. Bank
National Association, as trustee (filed as Exhibit 4(b) to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended June 30, 2011 and incorporated herein by
reference).
4.4 Seventh Supplemental Indenture, dated as of May 7, 2013, between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (n/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.) and U.S. Bank
National Association, as trustee (filed as Exhibit 4.1 to Cliffs' Form 10-Q for the period ended June 30, 2013 and incorporated herein by
reference).
147
-- 149 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Exhibit
Number Exhibit
4.5 Eighth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 19, 2017, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and U.S. Bank National Association, as
trustee, including Form of 1.50% Convertible Senior Notes due 2025 (filed as Exhibit 4.2 to Cliffs' Form 8-K on December 19, 2017 and
incorporated herein by reference).
4.6 Indenture, dated as of May 13, 2019, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank National Association, as trustee,
including Form of 5.875% Senior Notes due 2027 (filed as Exhibit 4.1 to Cliffs' Form 8-K on May 14, 2019 and incorporated herein by
reference).
4.7 First Supplemental Indenture, dated as of March 13, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank
National Association, as trustee (filed as Exhibit 4.4 to Cliffs' Form 10-Q for the period ended March 31, 2020 and incorporated herein by
reference).
4.8 Second Supplemental Indenture, dated as of May 22, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank
National Association, as trustee (filed as Exhibit 4.6 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended June 30, 2020 and incorporated herein by
reference).
4.9 Third Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 9, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee (filed as Exhibit 4.24 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2020 and incorporated
herein by reference).
4.10 Fourth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 18, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee (filed as Exhibit 4.25 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2020 and incorporated
herein by reference).
4.11 Fifth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 22, 2021, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantor party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee (filed herewith).
4.12 Indenture, dated as of March 13, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank National Association, as
trustee and first lien notes collateral agent, including Form of 6.75% Senior Secured Notes due 2026 (filed as Exhibit 4.1 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for
the period ended March 31, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference).
4.13 First Supplemental Indenture, dated as of May 22, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank
National Association, as trustee and first lien notes collateral agent (filed as Exhibit 4.9 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended June 30, 2020
and incorporated herein by reference).
4.14 Second Supplemental Indenture, dated as of June 19, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank National
Association, as trustee and first lien notes collateral agent, including Form of 6.75% Senior Secured Notes due 2026 (filed as Exhibit 4.10 to
Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended June 30, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference).
4.15 Third Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 9, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee and first lien notes collateral agent (filed as Exhibit 4.29 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended
December 31, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference).
4.16 Fourth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 18, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee and first lien notes collateral agent (filed as Exhibit 4.30 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended
December 31, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference).
4.17 Fifth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 22, 2021, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantor party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee and first lien notes collateral agent (filed herewith).
4.18 Indenture, dated as of March 16, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank National Association, as
trustee, including Form of 7.00% Senior Notes due 2027 (filed as Exhibit 4.7 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended March 31, 2020 and
incorporated herein by reference).
4.19 First Supplemental Indenture, dated as of May 22, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank
National Association, as trustee (filed as Exhibit 4.7 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended June 30, 2020 and incorporated herein by
reference).
4.20 Second Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 9, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee (filed as Exhibit 4.38 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2020 and incorporated
herein by reference).
4.21 Third Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 18, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee (filed as Exhibit 4.39 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2020 and incorporated
herein by reference).
4.22 Fourth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 22, 2021, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantor party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee (filed herewith).
148
-- 150 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Exhibit
Number Exhibit
4.23 Indenture, dated as of April 17, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank National Association, as trustee
and first lien notes collateral agent, including Form of 9.875% Senior Secured Notes due 2025 (filed as Exhibit 4.1 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the
period ended June 30, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference).
4.24 First Supplemental Indenture, dated as of April 24, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank National
Association, as trustee and first lien notes collateral agent, including Form of 9.875% Senior Secured Notes due 2025 (filed as Exhibit 4.2 to
Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended June 30, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference).
4.25 Second Supplemental Indenture, dated as of May 22, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank
National Association, as trustee and first lien notes collateral agent (filed as Exhibit 4.3 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended June 30, 2020
and incorporated herein by reference).
4.26 Third Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 9, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee and first lien notes collateral agent (filed as Exhibit 4.44 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended
December 31, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference)
4.27 Fourth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 18, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantors party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee and first lien notes collateral agent (filed as Exhibit 4.45 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended
December 31, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference).
4.28 Fifth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 22, 2021, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantor party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee and first lien notes collateral agent (filed herewith).
4.29 Indenture, dated as of February 17, 2021, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Guarantors party thereto and U.S. Bank National Association, as
trustee, including Forms of 4.625% Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2029 and 4.875% Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2031 (filed as Exhibit 4.1 to
Cliffs' Form 10-Q for the period ended March 31, 2021 and incorporated herein by reference).
4.30 First Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 22, 2021, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the Additional Guarantor party thereto and U.S.
Bank National Association, as trustee (filed herewith).
4.31 Form of Common Share Certificate (filed as Exhibit 4.1 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended September 30, 2019 and incorporated herein
by reference).
4.32 Description of Securities Registered under Section 12 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (filed herewith).
Material contracts
10.1 * Form of Change in Control Severance Agreement (covering newly hired officers) (filed as Exhibit 10.4 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K/A on September 16,
2014 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.2 * Form of 2016 Change in Control Severance Agreement (filed as Exhibit 10.1 to Cliffs’ 10-Q for the period ended September 30, 2016 and
incorporated herein by reference).
10.3 * Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. 2012 Non-Qualified Deferred Compensation Plan (Amended and Restated effective October 26, 2021) (filed herewith).
10.4 * Form of Director and Officer Indemnification Agreement between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and Directors and Officers (filed as Exhibit 10.2 to
Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended March 31, 2019 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.5 * Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. 2021 Nonemployee Directors’ Compensation Plan (filed as Exhibit 10.2 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on April 30, 2021 and
incorporated herein by reference).
10.6 *Form of Restricted Shares Agreement for Nonemployee Directors (filed as Exhibit 10.3 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended June 30,
2021 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.7 *Form of Deferred Shares Agreement for Nonemployee Directors (filed as Exhibit 10.4 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended June 30, 2021
and incorporated herein by reference).
10.8 * Trust Agreement No. 1 (Amended and Restated effective June 1, 1997), dated June 12, 1997, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and
KeyBank National Association, Trustee, with respect to the Cleveland-Cliffs Inc Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan, Severance Pay Plan
for Key Employees and certain executive agreements (filed as Exhibit 10.10 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2011 and
incorporated herein by reference).
10.9 * Trust Agreement No. 1 Amendments to Exhibits, effective as of January 1, 2000, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and KeyBank National
Association, as Trustee (filed as Exhibit 10.11 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by
reference).
149
-- 151 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Exhibit
Number Exhibit
10.10 * First Amendment to Trust Agreement No. 1, effective September 10, 2002, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and KeyBank National
Association, as Trustee (filed as Exhibit 10.12 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by
reference).
10.11 * Second Amendment to Trust Agreement No. 1 between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (f/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc) and KeyBank National
Association, Trustee, entered into and effective as of December 31, 2008 (filed as Exhibit 10(y) to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended
December 31, 2008 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.12 * Third Amendment to Trust Agreement No. 1 between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (f/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc) and KeyBank National
Association, Trustee, entered into and effective as of July 28, 2014 (filed as Exhibit 10.15 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December
31, 2014 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.13 * Amended and Restated Trust Agreement No. 2, effective as of October 15, 2002, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and KeyBank National
Association, Trustee, with respect to Executive Agreements and Indemnification Agreements with the Company’s Directors and certain
Officers, the Company’s Severance Pay Plan for Key Employees, and the Retention Plan for Salaried Employees (filed as Exhibit 10.14 to
Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.14 * Second Amendment to Amended and Restated Trust Agreement No. 2 between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (f/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc) and
KeyBank National Association, Trustee, entered into and effective as of December 31, 2008 (filed as Exhibit 10(aa) to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the
period ended December 31, 2008 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.15 * Third Amendment to Amended and Restated Trust Agreement No. 2 between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (f/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc) and
KeyBank National Association, Trustee, entered into and effective as of July 28, 2014 (filed as Exhibit 10.18 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period
ended December 31, 2014 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.16 * Trust Agreement No. 7, dated as of April 9, 1991, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and KeyBank National Association, Trustee, with
respect to the Cleveland-Cliffs Inc Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan (filed as Exhibit 10.23 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended
December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.17 * First Amendment to Trust Agreement No. 7, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and KeyBank National Association, Trustee, dated as of
March 9, 1992 (filed as Exhibit 10.24 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.20 * Second Amendment to Trust Agreement No. 7, dated November 18, 1994, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and KeyBank National
Association, Trustee (filed as Exhibit 10.25 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by
reference).
10.21 * Third Amendment to Trust Agreement No. 7, dated May 23, 1997, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and KeyBank National Association,
Trustee (filed as Exhibit 10.26 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.22 * Fourth Amendment to Trust Agreement No. 7, dated July 15, 1997, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and KeyBank National Association,
Trustee (filed as Exhibit 10.27 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.23 * Amendment to Exhibits to Trust Agreement No. 7, effective as of January 1, 2000, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and KeyBank
National Association, Trustee (filed as Exhibit 10.28 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by
reference).
10.24 * Sixth Amendment to Trust Agreement No. 7 between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (f/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc) and KeyBank National
Association, Trustee, entered into and effective as of December 31, 2008 (filed as Exhibit 10(oo) to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended
December 31, 2008 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.25 * Seventh Amendment to Trust Agreement No. 7 between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (f/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc) and KeyBank National
Association, Trustee, entered into and effective as of July 28, 2014 (filed as Exhibit 10.34 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December
31, 2014 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.26 * Trust Agreement No. 10, dated as of November 20, 1996, by and between Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and KeyBank National Association, Trustee,
with respect to the Cleveland-Cliffs Inc Nonemployee Directors’ Compensation Plan (filed as Exhibit 10.36 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period
ended December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.27 *First Amendment to Trust Agreement No. 10 between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (f/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc) and KeyBank National
Association, Trustee, entered into and effective as of December 31, 2008 (filed as Exhibit 10(ww) to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended
February 26, 2009 and incorporated herein by reference).
150
-- 152 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Exhibit
Number Exhibit
10.28 * Second Amendment to Trust Agreement No. 10 between Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. (f/k/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc) and KeyBank National
Association, Trustee, entered into and effective as of July 28, 2014 (filed as Exhibit 10.45 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December
31, 2014 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.29 * Letter Agreement, by and between Lourenco Goncalves and Cliffs Natural Resources Inc., signed as of September 11, 2014 (filed as Exhibit
10.1 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K/A on September 16, 2014 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.30 * Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and Subsidiaries Management Performance Incentive Plan Summary, effective January 1, 2004 (filed as Exhibit 10.47 to
Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2011 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.31 * Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. 2017 Executive Management Performance Incentive Plan effective January 1, 2017 (filed as Exhibit 10.2 to Cliffs'
Form 8-K on April 27, 2017 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.32 * Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. Amended and Restated 2012 Incentive Equity Plan (filed as Exhibit 10.1 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on August 4, 2014
and incorporated herein by reference).
10.33 * Form of Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. Amended and Restated 2012 Incentive Equity Plan Non-Qualified Stock Option Award Memorandum
(3-Year Vesting – January 2015 Grant) and Stock Option Award Agreement (filed as Exhibit 10.69 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended
December 31, 2014 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.34 * Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. 2015 Equity and Incentive Compensation Plan (filed as Exhibit 10.1 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on May 21, 2015 and
incorporated herein by reference).
10.35 * Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. Amended and Restated 2015 Equity and Incentive Compensation Plan (filed as Exhibit 10.1 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K
on April 27, 2017 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.36 * Form of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. Amended and Restated 2015 Equity and Incentive Compensation Plan Restricted Stock Unit Award
Memorandum and Restricted Stock Unit Award Agreement (filed as Exhibit 10.2 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended March 31, 2018 and
incorporated herein by reference).
10.37 * Form of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. Amended and Restated 2015 Equity and Incentive Compensation Plan Performance Share Award Memorandum
and Performance Share Award Agreement (filed as Exhibit 10.3 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended March 31, 2018 and incorporated
herein by reference).
10.38 * Form of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. Amended and Restated 2015 Equity and Incentive Compensation Plan Cash Incentive Award Memorandum
(TSR) and Cash Incentive Award Agreement (TSR) (filed as Exhibit 10.4 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended March 31, 2018 and
incorporated herein by reference).
10.39 * Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. 2021 Equity and Incentive Compensation Plan (filed as Exhibit 10.1 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on April 30, 2021 and
incorporated herein by reference).
10.40 * Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan (as Amended and Restated effective October 26, 2021) (filed herewith).
10.41 Asset-Based Revolving Credit Agreement, dated as of March 13, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the lenders party thereto from time to time
and Bank of America, N.A., as administrative agent (filed as Exhibit 10.1 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended March 31, 2020 and
incorporated herein by reference).
10.42 First Amendment to Asset-Based Revolving Credit Agreement, dated as of March 27, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the lenders party
thereto from time to time and Bank of America, N.A., as administrative agent (filed as Exhibit 10.2 to Cliffs’ Form 10-Q for the period ended
March 31, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.43 Second Amendment to Asset-Based Revolving Credit Agreement, dated as of December 9, 2020, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the lenders party
thereto from time to time and Bank of America, N.A., as administrative agent (filed as Exhibit 10.42 to Cliffs’ Form 10-K for the period ended
December 31, 2020 and incorporated herein by reference).
10.44 Third Amendment to Asset-Based Revolving Credit Agreement, dated as of December 17, 2021, among Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., the lenders party
thereto from time to time and Bank of America, N.A., as administrative agent (filed as Exhibit 10.1 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on December 23, 2021 and
incorporated herein by reference).
21 Subsidiaries of the Registrant (filed herewith).
22 Schedule of the obligated group, including the parent and issuer and the subsidiary guarantors that have guaranteed the obligations under the
6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes, the 5.875% 2027 Senior Notes, the 7.000% 2027 Senior Notes, the 9.875% 2025 Senior Secured Notes,
the 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and the 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes issued by Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (filed herewith).
23.1 Consent of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm (filed herewith).
151
-- 153 of 411 --
Table of Contents
Exhibit
Number Exhibit
23.2 Consent of SLR International Corporation regarding Hibbing Taconite Property, Minnesota, USA (filed as Exhibit 23.1 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on
February 11, 2022 and incorporated herein by reference).
23.3 Consent of SLR International Corporation regarding Minorca Property, Minnesota, USA (filed as Exhibit 23.2 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on February 11,
2022 and incorporated herein by reference).
23.4 Consent of SLR International Corporation regarding Northshore Property, Minnesota, USA (filed as Exhibit 23.3 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on February
11, 2022 and incorporated herein by reference).
23.5 Consent of SLR International Corporation regarding United Taconite Property, Minnesota, USA (filed as Exhibit 23.4 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on
February 11, 2022 and incorporated herein by reference).
23.6 Consent of SLR International Corporation regarding Tilden Property, Michigan, USA (filed herewith).
24 Power of Attorney (filed herewith).
31.1 Certification Pursuant to 15 U.S.C. Section 7241, as Adopted Pursuant to Section 302 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, signed and dated by
Lourenco Goncalves as of February 11, 2022 (filed herewith).
31.2 Certification Pursuant to 15 U.S.C. Section 7241, as Adopted Pursuant to Section 302 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, signed and dated by
Celso L. Goncalves Jr. as of February 11, 2022 (filed herewith).
32.1 Certification Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Section 1350, as Adopted Pursuant to Section 906 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, signed and dated by
Lourenco Goncalves, Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., as of February 11, 2022 (filed herewith).
32.2 Certification Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Section 1350, as Adopted Pursuant to Section 906 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, signed and dated by
Celso L. Goncalves Jr., Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., as of February 11, 2022 (filed herewith).
95 Mine Safety Disclosures (filed herewith).
96.1 Technical Report Summary on the Hibbing Taconite Property, Minnesota, USA, prepared for the Company by SLR International Corporation
with an effective date of December 31, 2021 (filed as Exhibit 96.1 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on February 11, 2022 and incorporated herein by
reference).
96.2 Technical Report Summary on the Minorca Property, Minnesota, USA, prepared for the Company by SLR International Corporation with an
effective date of December 31, 2021 (filed as Exhibit 96.2 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on February 11, 2022 and incorporated herein by reference).
96.3 Technical Report Summary on the Northshore Property, Minnesota, USA, prepared for the Company by SLR International Corporation with an
effective date of December 31, 2021 (filed as Exhibit 96.3 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on February 11, 2022 and incorporated herein by reference).
96.4 Technical Report Summary on the United Taconite Property, Minnesota, USA, prepared for the Company by SLR International Corporation with
an effective date of December 31, 2021 (filed as Exhibit 96.4 to Cliffs’ Form 8-K on February 11, 2022 and incorporated herein by reference).
96.5 Technical Report Summary on the Tilden Property, Michigan, USA, prepared for the Company by SLR International Corporation with an
effective date of December 31, 2021 (filed herewith).
101 The following financial information from Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.'s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2021 formatted
in Inline XBRL (Extensible Business Reporting Language) includes: (i) the Statements of Consolidated Financial Position, (ii) the Statements of
Consolidated Operations, (iii) the Statements of Consolidated Comprehensive Income, (iv) the Statements of Consolidated Cash Flows, (v) the
Statements of Consolidated Changes in Equity, and (vi) Notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements.
104 The cover page from this Annual Report on Form 10-K, formatted in Inline XBRL.
_______________
* Indicates management contract or other compensatory arrangement.
Item 16. Form 10-K Summary
None.
152
-- 154 of 411 --
Table of Contents
SIGNATURES
Pursuant to the requirements of Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the registrant has duly caused this report to be signed on its
behalf by the undersigned, thereunto duly authorized.
CLEVELAND-CLIFFS INC.
By: /s/ K. A. Floriani
Name: Kimberly A. Floriani
Title: Senior Vice President, Controller &
Chief Accounting Officer
Date: February 11, 2022
Pursuant to the requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, this report has been signed below by the following persons on behalf of the registrant
and in the capacities and on the dates indicated.
Signatures Title Date
/s/ C. L. Goncalves Chairman, President and
Chief Executive Officer
(Principal Executive Officer)
February 11, 2022
C. L. Goncalves
/s/ C. L. Goncalves Jr. Executive Vice President,
Chief Financial Officer
(Principal Financial Officer)
February 11, 2022
C. L. Goncalves Jr.
/s/ K. A. Floriani Senior Vice President, Controller
& Chief Accounting Officer
(Principal Accounting Officer)
February 11, 2022
K. A. Floriani
* Director February 11, 2022
J. T. Baldwin
* Director February 11, 2022
R. P. Fisher, Jr.
* Director February 11, 2022
W. K. Gerber
* Director February 11, 2022
S. M. Green
* Director February 11, 2022
R. S. Michael, III
* Director February 11, 2022
J. L. Miller
* Director February 11, 2022
G. Stoliar
* Director February 11, 2022
D. C. Taylor
* Director February 11, 2022
A. M. Yocum
* The undersigned, by signing his name hereto, does sign and execute this Annual Report on Form 10-K pursuant to a Power of Attorney executed on behalf of the
above-indicated directors of the registrant and filed herewith as Exhibit 24 on behalf of the registrant.
By: /s/ C. L. Goncalves Jr.
(C. L. Goncalves Jr., as Attorney-in-Fact)
153
-- 155 of 411 --
EXHIBIT 4.11
FIFTH SUPPLEMENTAL INDENTURE
5.875% SENIOR GUARANTEED NOTES DUE 2027
This Fifth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 22, 2021 (this “ Supplemental Indenture” or “Guarantee”), among Cliffs Steel Inc., an Ohio
corporation (the “Additional Guarantor”), Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (together with its successors and assigns, the “ Company”) and U.S. Bank National Association,
as Trustee (the “Trustee”) under the Indenture referred to below.
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, the Company, the Guarantors party thereto and the Trustee have heretofore executed and delivered an Indenture, dated as of May 13,
2019 (as amended, supplemented, waived or otherwise modified, the “Indenture”), providing for the issuance of an aggregate principal amount of $750,000,000
of 5.875% Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2027 of the Company (the “Notes”);
WHEREAS, Section 3.08 of the Indenture provides that, after the Issue Date, the Company is required to cause certain direct or indirect Subsidiaries of
the Company to execute and deliver to the Trustee a supplemental indenture pursuant to which such Subsidiary will unconditionally guarantee, on a joint and
several basis with the other Guarantors, the full and prompt payment of the principal of, premium, if any, and interest on the Notes on an unsecured basis; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 9.01 of the Indenture, the Trustee and the Company are authorized to execute and deliver this Supplemental Indenture
to amend or supplement the Indenture, without the consent of any Holder.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing and for other good and valuable consideration, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the
Additional Guarantor, the Company and the Trustee mutually covenant and agree for the equal and ratable benefit of the Holders of the Notes as follows:
ARTICLE 1
Definitions
Section 1.01 Defined Terms . As used in this Supplemental Indenture, terms defined in the Indenture or in the preamble or recitals hereto are used
herein as therein defined. The words “herein,” “hereof” and “hereby” and other words of similar import used in this Supplemental Indenture refer to this
Supplemental Indenture as a whole and not to any particular section hereof.
ARTICLE 2
Agreement to be Bound; Guarantee
Section 2.01 Agreement to be Bound. The Additional Guarantor hereby becomes a party to the Indenture as a Guarantor and as such will have all of
the rights and be subject to all of the obligations and agreements of a Guarantor under the Indenture. The Additional Guarantor agrees to be bound by all of the
provisions of the Indenture applicable to a Guarantor and to perform all of the obligations and agreements of a Guarantor under the Indenture.
Section 2.02 Guarantee. The Additional Guarantor agrees, on a joint and several basis with all the existing Guarantors, to fully, unconditionally and
irrevocably Guarantee to each Holder of the Notes and the Trustee the Guaranteed Obligations pursuant to Article 10 of the Indenture on an unsecured basis.
-- 156 of 411 --
ARTICLE 3
Miscellaneous
Section 3.01 Notices. All notices and other communications to the Additional Guarantor shall be given as provided in the Indenture to the Additional
Guarantor, at its address set forth below, with a copy to the Company as provided in the Indenture for notices to the Company.
Cliffs Steel Inc.
c/o Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
200 Public Square, Suite 3300
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
Attention: James Graham, Executive Vice President,
Chief Legal Officer & Secretary
Section 3.02 Parties. Nothing expressed or mentioned herein is intended or shall be construed to give any Person, other than the Company, the
Additional Guarantor, Holders and the Trustee, any legal or equitable right, remedy or claim under or in respect of this Supplemental Indenture or the Indenture
or any provision herein or therein contained.
Section 3.03 Governing Law. This Supplemental Indenture shall be governed by, and construed in accordance with, the laws of the State of New York.
Section 3.04 Severability Clause. In case any provision in this Supplemental Indenture shall be invalid, illegal or unenforceable, the validity, legality and
enforceability of the remaining provisions shall not in any way be affected or impaired thereby and such provision shall be ineffective only to the extent of such
invalidity, illegality or unenforceability.
Section 3.05 Ratification of Indenture; Supplemental Indenture Part of Indenture. Except as expressly amended hereby, the Indenture is in all respects
ratified and confirmed and all the terms, conditions and provisions thereof shall remain in full force and effect. This Supplemental Indenture shall form a part of
the Indenture for all purposes, and every Holder of Notes heretofore or hereafter authenticated and delivered shall be bound hereby. The Trustee shall not be
responsible for and makes no representation or warranty as to the validity, execution, or sufficiency of this Supplemental Indenture or with respect to the recitals
contained herein, all of which recitals are made solely by the other parties hereto.
Section 3.06 Counterparts. The parties hereto may sign one or more copies of this Supplemental Indenture in counterparts, all of which together shall
constitute one and the same agreement.
Section 3.07 Headings. The headings of the Articles and the sections in this Guarantee are for convenience of reference only and shall not be deemed
to alter or affect the meaning or interpretation of any provisions hereof.
Section 3.08 Execution, Delivery and Validity. The Company and the Additional Guarantor each represent and warrant to the Trustee that this
Supplemental Indenture has been duly and validly executed and delivered by it and constitutes its legal, valid and binding obligation, enforceable against it in
accordance with its terms, except as enforcement may be limited by equitable principles or by bankruptcy, insolvency, receivership, administration,
reorganization, moratorium, or similar laws relating to or limiting creditors’ rights generally.
[Signature Page Follows]
-- 157 of 411 --
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Supplemental Indenture to be duly executed as of the date first above written.
CLIFFS STEEL INC., as a Guarantor
By: /s/ James D. Graham
Name: James D. Graham
Title: Executive Vice President, Chief Legal Officer
& Secretary
CLEVELAND-CLIFFS INC.
By: /s/ Celso L. Goncalves, Jr.
Name: Celso L. Goncalves, Jr.
Title: Executive Vice President, Chief Financial
Officer
U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, as Trustee
By: /s/ William Sicking
Name: William Sicking
Title: Vice President
[Fifth Supplemental Indenture – 5.875% Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2027 ]
-- 158 of 411 --
EXHIBIT 4.17
FIFTH SUPPLEMENTAL INDENTURE
6.75% SENIOR SECURED NOTES DUE 2026
This Fifth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 22, 2021 (this “ Supplemental Indenture” or “Guarantee”), among Cliffs Steel Inc. (the
“Additional Guarantor”), Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (together with its successors and assigns, the “ Company”) and U.S. Bank National Association, as Trustee and
First Lien Notes Collateral Agent under the Indenture referred to below.
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, the Company, the Guarantors, the First Lien Notes Collateral Agent and the Trustee have heretofore executed and delivered an Indenture,
dated as of March 13, 2020 (as amended, supplemented, waived or otherwise modified, the “Indenture”), providing for the issuance of an aggregate principal
amount of $845,000,000 of 6.75% Senior Secured Notes due 2026 of the Company (the “Notes”);
WHEREAS, Section 3.08 of the Indenture provides that, after the Issue Date, the Company is required to cause certain direct or indirect Subsidiaries of
the Company to execute and deliver to the Trustee a supplemental indenture pursuant to which such Subsidiary will unconditionally guarantee, on a joint and
several basis with the other Guarantors, the full and prompt payment of the principal of, premium, if any, and interest on the Notes on a secured basis; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 9.01 of the Indenture, the Trustee and the Company are authorized to execute and deliver this Supplemental Indenture
to amend or supplement the Indenture, without the consent of any Holder.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing and for other good and valuable consideration, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the
Additional Guarantor, the Company and the Trustee mutually covenant and agree for the equal and ratable benefit of the Holders of the Notes as follows:
ARTICLE 1
Definitions
Section 1.01 Defined Terms . As used in this Supplemental Indenture, terms defined in the Indenture or in the preamble or recitals hereto are used
herein as therein defined. The words “herein,” “hereof” and “hereby” and other words of similar import used in this Supplemental Indenture refer to this
Supplemental Indenture as a whole and not to any particular section hereof.
ARTICLE 2
Agreement to be Bound; Guarantee
Section 2.01 Agreement to be Bound . The Additional Guarantor hereby becomes a party to the Indenture as a Guarantor and as such will have all of
the rights and be subject to all of the obligations and agreements of a Guarantor under the Indenture. The Additional Guarantor hereby becomes a party to the
Security Agreement, pursuant to the terms of such agreement, as a Grantor thereunder with the same force and effect as if originally named therein as a
Grantor and as such hereby assumes all obligations and liabilities of a Grantor thereunder. The Additional Guarantor agrees to be bound by all of the provisions
of the Indenture and the Collateral Documents applicable to a Guarantor and to perform all of the obligations and agreements of a Guarantor under the
Indenture and the Collateral Documents.
-- 159 of 411 --
Section 2.02 Guarantee. The Additional Guarantor agrees, on a joint and several basis with all the existing Guarantors, to fully, unconditionally and
irrevocably Guarantee to each Holder of the Notes and the Trustee the Guaranteed Obligations pursuant to Article 10 of the Indenture on a secured basis.
ARTICLE 3
Miscellaneous
Section 3.01 Notices. All notices and other communications to the Additional Guarantor shall be given as provided in the Indenture to the Additional
Guarantor, at its address set forth below, with a copy to the Company as provided in the Indenture for notices to the Company.
Cliffs Steel Inc.
c/o Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
200 Public Square, Suite 3300
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
Attention: James Graham, Executive Vice President,
Chief Legal Officer & Secretary
Section 3.02 Parties. Nothing expressed or mentioned herein is intended or shall be construed to give any Person, other than the Company, the
Additional Guarantor, Holders and the Trustee, any legal or equitable right, remedy or claim under or in respect of this Supplemental Indenture or the Indenture
or any provision herein or therein contained.
Section 3.03 Governing Law. This Supplemental Indenture shall be governed by, and construed in accordance with, the laws of the State of New York.
Section 3.04 Severability Clause. In case any provision in this Supplemental Indenture shall be invalid, illegal or unenforceable, the validity, legality and
enforceability of the remaining provisions shall not in any way be affected or impaired thereby and such provision shall be ineffective only to the extent of such
invalidity, illegality or unenforceability.
Section 3.05 Ratification of Indenture; Supplemental Indenture Part of Indenture. Except as expressly amended hereby, the Indenture is in all respects
ratified and confirmed and all the terms, conditions and provisions thereof shall remain in full force and effect. This Supplemental Indenture shall form a part of
the Indenture for all purposes, and every Holder of Notes heretofore or hereafter authenticated and delivered shall be bound hereby. The Trustee shall not be
responsible for and makes no representation or warranty as to the validity, execution, or sufficiency of this Supplemental Indenture or with respect to the recitals
contained herein, all of which recitals are made solely by the other parties hereto.
Section 3.06 Counterparts. The parties hereto may sign one or more copies of this Supplemental Indenture in counterparts, all of which together shall
constitute one and the same agreement.
Section 3.07 Headings. The headings of the Articles and the sections in this Guarantee are for convenience of reference only and shall not be deemed
to alter or affect the meaning or interpretation of any provisions hereof.
Section 3.08 Execution, Delivery and Validity. The Company and the Additional Guarantor each represent and warrant to the Trustee that this
Supplemental Indenture has been duly and validly executed and delivered by it and constitutes its legal, valid and binding obligation, enforceable against it in
accordance with its terms, except as enforcement may be limited by equitable principles or by bankruptcy, insolvency, receivership, administration,
reorganization, moratorium, or similar laws relating to or limiting creditors’ rights generally.
-- 160 of 411 --
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Supplemental Indenture to be duly executed as of the date first above written.
CLIFFS STEEL INC., as a Guarantor
By: /s/ James D. Graham
Name: James D. Graham
Title: Executive Vice President, Chief Legal Officer & Secretary
CLEVELAND-CLIFFS INC.
By: /s/ Celso L. Goncalves, Jr.
Name: Celso L. Goncalves, Jr.
Title: Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer
U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION,
as Trustee and First Lien Notes Collateral Agent
By: /s/ William Sicking
Name: William Sicking
Title: Vice President
[Fifth Supplemental Indenture – 6.75% Senior Secured Notes due 2026 ]
-- 161 of 411 --
EXHIBIT 4.22
FOURTH SUPPLEMENTAL INDENTURE
7.00% SENIOR GUARANTEED NOTES DUE 2027
This Fourth Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 22, 2021 (this “ Supplemental Indenture” or “Guarantee”), among Cliffs Steel Inc., an Ohio
corporation (the “Additional Guarantor”), Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (together with its successors and assigns, the “ Company”) and U.S. Bank National Association,
as Trustee under the Indenture referred to below.
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, the Company, the Guarantors and the Trustee have heretofore executed and delivered an Indenture, dated as of March 16, 2020 (as
amended, supplemented, waived or otherwise modified, the “Indenture”), providing for the issuance of an aggregate principal amount of $335,376,000 of 7.00%
Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2027 of the Company (the “Notes”);
WHEREAS, Section 3.08 of the Indenture provides that, after the Issue Date, the Company is required to cause certain direct or indirect Subsidiaries of
the Company to execute and deliver to the Trustee a supplemental indenture pursuant to which such Subsidiary will unconditionally guarantee, on a joint and
several basis with the other Guarantors, the full and prompt payment of the principal of, premium, if any, and interest on the Notes on an unsecured basis; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 9.01 of the Indenture, the Trustee and the Company are authorized to execute and deliver this Supplemental Indenture
to amend or supplement the Indenture, without the consent of any Holder.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing and for other good and valuable consideration, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the
Additional Guarantor, the Company and the Trustee mutually covenant and agree for the equal and ratable benefit of the Holders of the Notes as follows:
ARTICLE 1
Definitions
Section 1.01 Defined Terms . As used in this Supplemental Indenture, terms defined in the Indenture or in the preamble or recitals hereto are used
herein as therein defined. The words “herein,” “hereof” and “hereby” and other words of similar import used in this Supplemental Indenture refer to this
Supplemental Indenture as a whole and not to any particular section hereof.
ARTICLE 2
Agreement to be Bound; Guarantee
Section 2.01 Agreement to be Bound . The Additional Guarantor hereby becomes a party to the Indenture as a Guarantor and as such will have all of
the rights and be subject to all of the obligations and agreements of a Guarantor under the Indenture. The Additional Guarantor agrees to be bound by all of the
provisions of the Indenture applicable to a Guarantor and to perform all of the obligations and agreements of a Guarantor under the Indenture.
Section 2.02 Guarantee. The Additional Guarantor agrees, on a joint and several basis with all the existing Guarantors, to fully, unconditionally and
irrevocably Guarantee to each Holder of the Notes and the Trustee the Guaranteed Obligations pursuant to Article 10 of the Indenture on an unsecured basis.
-- 162 of 411 --
ARTICLE 3
Miscellaneous
Section 3.01 Notices. All notices and other communications to the Additional Guarantor shall be given as provided in the Indenture to the Additional
Guarantor, at its address set forth below, with a copy to the Company as provided in the Indenture for notices to the Company.
Cliffs Steel Inc.
c/o Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
200 Public Square, Suite 3300
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
Attention: James Graham, Executive Vice President,
Chief Legal Officer & Secretary
Section 3.02 Parties. Nothing expressed or mentioned herein is intended or shall be construed to give any Person, other than the Company, the
Additional Guarantor, Holders and the Trustee, any legal or equitable right, remedy or claim under or in respect of this Supplemental Indenture or the Indenture
or any provision herein or therein contained.
Section 3.03 Governing Law. This Supplemental Indenture shall be governed by, and construed in accordance with, the laws of the State of New York.
Section 3.04 Severability Clause. In case any provision in this Supplemental Indenture shall be invalid, illegal or unenforceable, the validity, legality and
enforceability of the remaining provisions shall not in any way be affected or impaired thereby and such provision shall be ineffective only to the extent of such
invalidity, illegality or unenforceability.
Section 3.05 Ratification of Indenture; Supplemental Indenture Part of Indenture . Except as expressly amended hereby, the Indenture is in all respects
ratified and confirmed and all the terms, conditions and provisions thereof shall remain in full force and effect. This Supplemental Indenture shall form a part of
the Indenture for all purposes, and every Holder of Notes heretofore or hereafter authenticated and delivered shall be bound hereby. The Trustee shall not be
responsible for and makes no representation or warranty as to the validity, execution or sufficiency of this Supplemental Indenture or with respect to the recitals
contained herein, all of which recitals are made solely by the other parties hereto.
Section 3.06 Counterparts. The parties hereto may sign one or more copies of this Supplemental Indenture in counterparts, all of which together shall
constitute one and the same agreement.
Section 3.07 Headings. The headings of the Articles and the sections in this Guarantee are for convenience of reference only and shall not be deemed
to alter or affect the meaning or interpretation of any provisions hereof.
Section 3.08 Execution, Delivery and Validity . The Company and the Additional Guarantor each represent and warrant to the Trustee that this
Supplemental Indenture has been duly and validly executed and delivered by it and constitutes its legal, valid and binding obligation, enforceable against it in
accordance with its terms, except as enforcement may be limited by equitable principles or by bankruptcy, insolvency, receivership, administration,
reorganization, moratorium or similar laws relating to or limiting creditors’ rights generally.
[Signature Page Follows]
-- 163 of 411 --
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Supplemental Indenture to be duly executed as of the date first above written.
CLIFFS STEEL INC., as a Guarantor
By: /s/ James D. Graham
Name: James D. Graham
Title: Executive Vice President, Chief Legal Officer
& Secretary
CLEVELAND-CLIFFS INC.
By: /s/ Celso L. Goncalves, Jr.
Name: Celso L. Goncalves, Jr.
Title: Executive Vice President, Chief Financial
Officer
U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, as Trustee
By: /s/ William Sicking
Name: William Sicking
Title: Vice President
[Fourth Supplemental Indenture – 7.00% Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2027 ]
-- 164 of 411 --
EXHIBIT 4.28
FIFTH SUPPLEMENTAL INDENTURE
9.875% SENIOR SECURED NOTES DUE 2025
This Fifth Supplemental Indenture is made as of December 22, 2021 (this “ Supplemental Indenture” or “Guarantee”), among Cliffs Steel Inc., an Ohio
corporation (the “Additional Guarantor”), Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (together with its successors and assigns, the “ Company”) and U.S. Bank National Association,
as Trustee and First Lien Notes Collateral Agent under the Indenture referred to below.
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, the Company, the Guarantors, the First Lien Notes Collateral Agent and the Trustee have heretofore executed and delivered an Indenture,
dated as of April 17, 2020, as supplemented by that certain First Supplemental Indenture, dated as of April 24, 2020, among the Company, the Guarantors party
thereto, the Trustee and the First Lien Notes Collateral Agent, that certain Second Supplemental Indenture, dated as of May 22, 2020, among the Company, the
Guarantors party thereto, the Trustee and the First Lien Notes Collateral Agent, and that certain Third Supplemental Indenture, dated as of December 9, 2020,
among the Company, the Guarantors party thereto, the Trustee and the First Lien Notes Collateral Agent, and that certain Fourth Supplemental Indenture,
dated as of December 18, 2020, among the Company, the Guarantors party thereto, the Trustee and the First Lien Notes Collateral Agent (as so supplemented
and as otherwise amended, supplemented, waived or otherwise modified, the “Indenture”), providing for the issuance of an aggregate principal amount of
$955,159,000 of 9.875% Senior Secured Notes due 2025 of the Company (the “Notes”);
WHEREAS, Section 3.08 of the Indenture provides that, after the Issue Date, the Company is required to cause certain direct or indirect Subsidiaries of
the Company to execute and deliver to the Trustee a supplemental indenture pursuant to which such Subsidiary will unconditionally guarantee, on a joint and
several basis with the other Guarantors, the full and prompt payment of the principal of, premium, if any, and interest on the Notes on a secured basis; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 9.01 of the Indenture, the Trustee and the Company are authorized to execute and deliver this Supplemental Indenture
to amend or supplement the Indenture, without the consent of any Holder.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing and for other good and valuable consideration, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the
Additional Guarantor, the Company and the Trustee mutually covenant and agree for the equal and ratable benefit of the Holders of the Notes as follows:
ARTICLE 1
Definitions
Section 1.01 Defined Terms . As used in this Supplemental Indenture, terms defined in the Indenture or in the preamble or recitals hereto are used
herein as therein defined. The words “herein,” “hereof” and “hereby” and other words of similar import used in this Supplemental Indenture refer to this
Supplemental Indenture as a whole and not to any particular section hereof.
ARTICLE 2
Agreement to be Bound; Guarantee
Section 2.01 Agreement to be Bound . The Additional Guarantor hereby becomes a party to the Indenture as a Guarantor and as such will have all of
the rights and be subject to all of the obligations and agreements of a Guarantor under the Indenture. The Additional Guarantor hereby becomes a party to the
-- 165 of 411 --
Security Agreement, pursuant to the terms of such agreement, as a Grantor thereunder with the same force and effect as if originally named therein as a
Grantor and as such hereby assumes all obligations and liabilities of a Grantor thereunder. The Additional Guarantor agrees to be bound by all of the provisions
of the Indenture and the Collateral Documents applicable to a Guarantor and to perform all of the obligations and agreements of a Guarantor under the
Indenture and the Collateral Documents.
Section 2.02 Guarantee. The Additional Guarantor agrees, on a joint and several basis with all the existing Guarantors, to fully, unconditionally and
irrevocably Guarantee to each Holder of the Notes and the Trustee the Guaranteed Obligations pursuant to Article 10 of the Indenture on a secured basis.
ARTICLE 3
Miscellaneous
Section 3.01 Notices. All notices and other communications to the Additional Guarantor shall be given as provided in the Indenture to the Additional
Guarantor, at its address set forth below, with a copy to the Company as provided in the Indenture for notices to the Company.
Cliffs Steel Inc.
c/o Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
200 Public Square, Suite 3300
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
Attention: James Graham, Executive Vice President,
Chief Legal Officer & Secretary
Section 3.02 Parties. Nothing expressed or mentioned herein is intended or shall be construed to give any Person, other than the Company, the
Additional Guarantor, Holders and the Trustee, any legal or equitable right, remedy or claim under or in respect of this Supplemental Indenture or the Indenture
or any provision herein or therein contained.
Section 3.03 Governing Law. This Supplemental Indenture shall be governed by, and construed in accordance with, the laws of the State of New York.
Section 3.04 Severability Clause. In case any provision in this Supplemental Indenture shall be invalid, illegal or unenforceable, the validity, legality and
enforceability of the remaining provisions shall not in any way be affected or impaired thereby and such provision shall be ineffective only to the extent of such
invalidity, illegality or unenforceability.
Section 3.05 Ratification of Indenture; Supplemental Indenture Part of Indenture . Except as expressly amended hereby, the Indenture is in all respects
ratified and confirmed and all the terms, conditions and provisions thereof shall remain in full force and effect. This Supplemental Indenture shall form a part of
the Indenture for all purposes, and every Holder of Notes heretofore or hereafter authenticated and delivered shall be bound hereby. The Trustee shall not be
responsible for and makes no representation or warranty as to the validity, execution or sufficiency of this Supplemental Indenture or with respect to the recitals
contained herein, all of which recitals are made solely by the other parties hereto.
Section 3.06 Counterparts. The parties hereto may sign one or more copies of this Supplemental Indenture in counterparts, all of which together shall
constitute one and the same agreement.
Section 3.07 Headings. The headings of the Articles and the sections in this Guarantee are for convenience of reference only and shall not be deemed
to alter or affect the meaning or interpretation of any provisions hereof.
-- 166 of 411 --
Section 3.08 Execution, Delivery and Validity . The Company and the Additional Guarantor each represent and warrant to the Trustee that this
Supplemental Indenture has been duly and validly executed and delivered by it and constitutes its legal, valid and binding obligation, enforceable against it in
accordance with its terms, except as enforcement may be limited by equitable principles or by bankruptcy, insolvency, receivership, administration,
reorganization, moratorium or similar laws relating to or limiting creditors’ rights generally.
[Signature Page Follows]
-- 167 of 411 --
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Supplemental Indenture to be duly executed as of the date first above written.
CLIFFS STEEL INC., as a Guarantor
By: /s/ James D. Graham
Name: James D. Graham
Title: Executive Vice President, Chief Legal Officer &
Secretary
CLEVELAND-CLIFFS INC.
By: /s/ Celso L. Goncalves, Jr.
Name: Celso L. Goncalves, Jr.
Title: Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer
U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION,
as Trustee and First Lien Notes Collateral Agent
By: /s/ William Sicking
Name: William Sicking
Title: Vice President
[Fifth Supplemental Indenture – 9.875% Senior Secured Notes due 2025 ]
-- 168 of 411 --
EXHIBIT 4.30
FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL INDENTURE
4.625% SENIOR GUARANTEED NOTES DUE 2029
4.875% SENIOR GUARANTEED NOTES DUE 2031
This First Supplemental Indenture is made as of December 22, 2021 (this “ Supplemental Indenture” or “Guarantee”), among Cliffs Steel Inc., an Ohio
corporation (the “Additional Guarantor”), Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (together with its successors and assigns, the “ Company”) and U.S. Bank National Association,
as Trustee (the “Trustee”) under the Indenture referred to below.
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, the Company, the Guarantors party thereto and the Trustee have heretofore executed and delivered an Indenture, dated as of February
17, 2021 (as amended, supplemented, waived or otherwise modified, the “Indenture”), providing for the issuance of an aggregate principal amount of
$500,000,000 of 4.625% Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2029 and $500,000,000 of 4.875% Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2031 of the Company (collectively, the
“Notes”);
WHEREAS, Section 3.08 of the Indenture provides that, after the Issue Date, the Company is required to cause certain direct or indirect Subsidiaries of
the Company to execute and deliver to the Trustee a supplemental indenture pursuant to which such Subsidiary will unconditionally guarantee, on a joint and
several basis with the other Guarantors, the full and prompt payment of the principal of, premium, if any, and interest on the Notes on an unsecured basis; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 9.01 of the Indenture, the Trustee and the Company are authorized to execute and deliver this Supplemental Indenture
to amend or supplement the Indenture, without the consent of any Holder.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing and for other good and valuable consideration, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the
Additional Guarantor, the Company and the Trustee mutually covenant and agree for the equal and ratable benefit of the Holders of the Notes as follows:
ARTICLE 1
Definitions
Section 1.01 Defined Terms . As used in this Supplemental Indenture, terms defined in the Indenture or in the preamble or recitals hereto are used
herein as therein defined. The words “herein,” “hereof” and “hereby” and other words of similar import used in this Supplemental Indenture refer to this
Supplemental Indenture as a whole and not to any particular section hereof.
ARTICLE 2
Agreement to be Bound; Guarantee
Section 2.01 Agreement to be Bound . The Additional Guarantor hereby becomes a party to the Indenture as a Guarantor and as such will have all of
the rights and be subject to all of the obligations and agreements of a Guarantor under the Indenture. The Additional Guarantor agrees to be bound by all of the
provisions of the Indenture applicable to a Guarantor and to perform all of the obligations and agreements of a Guarantor under the Indenture.
-- 169 of 411 --
Section 2.02 Guarantee. The Additional Guarantor agrees, on a joint and several basis with all the existing Guarantors, to fully, unconditionally and
irrevocably Guarantee to each Holder of the Notes and the Trustee the Guaranteed Obligations pursuant to Article 10 of the Indenture on an unsecured basis.
ARTICLE 3
Miscellaneous
Section 3.01 Notices. All notices and other communications to the Additional Guarantor shall be given as provided in the Indenture to the Additional
Guarantor, at its address set forth below, with a copy to the Company as provided in the Indenture for notices to the Company.
Cliffs Steel Inc.
c/o Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
200 Public Square, Suite 3300
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
Attention: James Graham, Executive Vice President,
Chief Legal Officer & Secretary
Section 3.02 Parties. Nothing expressed or mentioned herein is intended or shall be construed to give any Person, other than the Company, the
Additional Guarantor, Holders and the Trustee, any legal or equitable right, remedy or claim under or in respect of this Supplemental Indenture or the Indenture
or any provision herein or therein contained.
Section 3.03 Governing Law. This Supplemental Indenture shall be governed by, and construed in accordance with, the laws of the State of New York.
Section 3.04 Severability Clause. In case any provision in this Supplemental Indenture shall be invalid, illegal or unenforceable, the validity, legality and
enforceability of the remaining provisions shall not in any way be affected or impaired thereby and such provision shall be ineffective only to the extent of such
invalidity, illegality or unenforceability.
Section 3.05 Ratification of Indenture; Supplemental Indenture Part of Indenture . Except as expressly amended hereby, the Indenture is in all respects
ratified and confirmed and all the terms, conditions and provisions thereof shall remain in full force and effect. This Supplemental Indenture shall form a part of
the Indenture for all purposes, and every Holder of Notes heretofore or hereafter authenticated and delivered shall be bound hereby. The Trustee shall not be
responsible for and makes no representation or warranty as to the validity, execution or sufficiency of this Supplemental Indenture or with respect to the recitals
contained herein, all of which recitals are made solely by the other parties hereto.
Section 3.06 Counterparts. The parties hereto may sign one or more copies of this Supplemental Indenture in counterparts, all of which together shall
constitute one and the same agreement.
Section 3.07 Headings. The headings of the Articles and the sections in this Guarantee are for convenience of reference only and shall not be deemed
to alter or affect the meaning or interpretation of any provisions hereof.
Section 3.08 Execution, Delivery and Validity . The Company and the Additional Guarantor each represent and warrant to the Trustee that this
Supplemental Indenture has been duly and validly executed and delivered by it and constitutes its legal, valid and binding obligation, enforceable against it in
accordance with its terms, except as enforcement may be limited by equitable principles or by bankruptcy,
-- 170 of 411 --
insolvency, receivership, administration, reorganization, moratorium or similar laws relating to or limiting creditors’ rights generally.
[Signature Page Follows]
-- 171 of 411 --
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Supplemental Indenture to be duly executed as of the date first above written.
CLIFFS STEEL INC., as a Guarantor
By: /s/ James D. Graham
Name: James D. Graham
Title: Executive Vice President, Chief Legal Officer &
Secretary
CLEVELAND-CLIFFS INC.
By: /s/ Celso L. Goncalves, Jr.
Name: Celso L. Goncalves, Jr.
Title: Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer
U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION, as Trustee
By: /s/ William Sicking
Name: William Sicking
Title: Vice President
[First Supplemental Indenture – 4.625% Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2029 and 4.875% Senior Guaranteed Notes due 2031]
-- 172 of 411 --
EXHIBIT 4.32
DESCRIPTION OF SECURITIES REGISTERED UNDER
SECTION 12 OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
The following is a summary of the terms and provisions of the common shares, par value $0.125 per share (“Common Shares”), of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.,
an Ohio corporation (the “Company”), and is qualified by reference to the Company’s articles of incorporation and regulations, which are incorporated by
reference herein and attached as exhibits to the Company’s most recent Annual Report on Form 10-K filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission, and
to applicable provisions of Ohio law.
Common Shares
The Company has authorized 1,200,000,000 Common Shares. The holders of Common Shares are entitled to one vote for each share on all matters
upon which shareholders have the right to vote and, upon proper notice, are entitled to cumulative voting rights in the election of directors. The Common Shares
do not have any preemptive rights, are not subject to redemption and do not have the benefit of any sinking fund. Holders of Common Shares are entitled to
receive such dividends as the Company’s directors from time to time may declare out of funds legally available therefor. Entitlement to dividends is subject to the
preferences granted to other classes of securities the Company has or may have outstanding in the future. In the event of the Company’s liquidation, holders of
Common Shares are entitled to share in any of the Company’s assets remaining after satisfaction in full of its liabilities and satisfaction of such dividend and
liquidation preferences as may be possessed by the holders of other classes of securities the Company has or may have outstanding in the future.
Preferred Stock
The Company has authorized 3,000,000 shares of serial preferred stock, Class A, without par value (“Class A Preferred Stock”), and 4,000,000 shares
of serial preferred stock, Class B, without par value (“Class B Preferred Stock” and, collectively with the Class A Preferred Stock, “Preferred Stock”). Under the
Company’s articles of incorporation, the Company’s board of directors can issue, without further shareholder action, up to 3,000,000 shares of Class A
Preferred Stock and up to 4,000,000 shares of Class B Preferred Stock, in each case, with such rights and restrictions as the Company’s board of directors may
determine, subject to any shares of Preferred Stock of the applicable class then outstanding.
In some cases, the issuance of Preferred Stock could delay, defer or prevent a change in control and make it harder to remove present management,
without further action by the Company’s shareholders. Under some circumstances, Preferred Stock could also decrease the amount of earnings and assets
available for distribution to holders of Common Shares if the Company liquidates or dissolves and could also restrict or limit dividend payments to holders of
Common Shares.
Ohio Control Share Acquisition Statute
The Ohio Control Share Acquisition Statute requires the prior authorization of the shareholders of certain corporations in order for any person to
acquire, either directly or indirectly, shares of that corporation that would entitle the acquiring person to exercise or direct the exercise of 20% or more of the
voting power of that corporation in the election of directors or to exceed specified other percentages of voting power. In the event an acquiring person proposes
to make such an acquisition, the person is required to deliver to the corporation a statement disclosing, among other things, the number of shares owned,
directly or indirectly, by the person, the range of voting power that may result from the proposed acquisition and the identity of the acquiring person. Within 10
days after receipt of this statement, the corporation must call a special meeting of shareholders to vote on the proposed acquisition. The
-- 173 of 411 --
acquiring person may complete the proposed acquisition only if the acquisition is approved by the affirmative vote of the holders of at least a majority of the
voting power of all shares entitled to vote in the election of directors represented at the meeting excluding the voting power of all “interested shares.” Interested
shares include any shares held by the acquiring person and those held by officers and directors who are employees of the corporation as well as by certain
others, including many holders commonly characterized as arbitrageurs. The Ohio Control Share Acquisition Statute does not apply to a corporation if its
articles of incorporation or code of regulations state that the statute does not apply to such corporation. Neither the Company’s articles of incorporation nor its
regulations contain a provision opting out of this statute.
Ohio Interested Shareholder Statute
Chapter 1704 of the Ohio Revised Code prohibits certain corporations from engaging in a “chapter 1704 transaction” with an “interested shareholder”
for a period of three years after the date of the transaction in which the person became an interested shareholder, unless, among other things:
• the articles of incorporation expressly provide that the corporation is not subject to the statute (the Company has not made this election); or
• the board of directors of the corporation approves the chapter 1704 transaction or the acquisition of the shares before the date the shares were acquired.
After the three-year moratorium period, the corporation may not consummate a chapter 1704 transaction unless, among other things, it is approved by
the affirmative vote of the holders of at least two-thirds of the voting power in the election of directors and the holders of a majority of the voting shares,
excluding all shares beneficially owned by an interested shareholder or an affiliate or associate of an interested shareholder, or the shareholders receive certain
minimum consideration for their shares. A chapter 1704 transaction includes certain mergers, sales of assets, consolidations, combinations and majority share
acquisitions involving an interested shareholder. An interested shareholder is defined to include, with limited exceptions, any person who, together with affiliates
and associates, is the beneficial owner of a sufficient number of shares of the corporation to entitle the person, directly or indirectly, alone or with others, to
exercise or direct the exercise of 10% or more of the voting power in the election of directors after taking into account all of the person’s beneficially owned
shares that are not then outstanding.
-- 174 of 411 --
EXHIBIT 10.3
CLEVELAND-CLIFFS INC.
2012 NON-QUALIFIED DEFERRED COMPENSATION PLAN
(AMENDED AND RESTATED EFFECTIVE AS OF OCTOBER 26, 2021)
This Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. 2012 Non-Qualified Deferred Compensation Plan was originally adopted as of the Effective Date (as defined hereunder) to
provide certain supplemental non-qualified deferred compensation deferral opportunities and benefits for Participants (as defined hereunder). The Company
hereby adopts this amendment and restatement to make certain changes set forth herein effective as of October 26, 2021.
ARTICLE I
DEFINITIONS
As used in this Plan, the following definitions shall apply:
1.1 “Account” or “Accounts” means the bookkeeping accounts established and maintained for each Participant under Article IV. The Account
types and the Contributions associated with each Account type are as more fully described and defined under Article IV.
1.2 “Base Salary” means a Participant’s base earnings paid by an Employer to a Participant without regard to any increases or decreases in base
earnings as a result of an election to defer under this Plan or under a plan of an Employer maintained pursuant to Section 125, 132(f) or 401(k) of the Code;
provided, however, that base earnings will be included in “Base Salary” only to the extent that had there been no such Plan or plan, the amount would have
been payable in cash to the Participant. Base Salary payable after the last day of the calendar year for services performed during a final payroll period that
spans two (2) calendar years shall be treated as Base Salary for services performed in the subsequent calendar year in which the payment is made.
1.3 “Beneficiary” means the person or persons designated or deemed to be designated by the Participant pursuant to Article VI to receive benefits
payable under the Plan in the event of the Participant’s death. A Beneficiary's right to (and the Committee's duty to provide to the Beneficiary, if any) information
concerning the Plan does not arise until the Beneficiary first becomes entitled to receive a benefit under the Plan.
1.4 “Board” means the Company’s Board of Directors.
1.5 “Bonus” means a cash bonus payable to the Participant under, as applicable, the Company’s Management Performance Incentive Plan or
Executive Management Performance Incentive Plan and such other cash payments awarded under such other incentive compensation arrangements that are
designated by the Committee as eligible for deferral under this Plan.
1.6 “Cause” means that, prior to Termination, the Participant shall have committed: (i) and been convicted of a criminal violation involving fraud,
embezzlement or theft in connection with his duties or in the course of his employment with the Company or any other Employer; (ii) intentional wrongful
damage to property of the Company or any other Employer; (iii) intentional wrongful disclosure of secret processes or confidential information of the Company or
any other Employer; or (iv) intentional wrongful engagement in any competitive activity; and any such act shall have been demonstrably and materially harmful
to the Company. For purposes of this Plan, no act or failure to act on the part of the Participant shall be deemed “intentional” if it was due primarily to an error in
judgment or negligence, but shall be deemed “intentional” only if done or omitted to be done by the Participant not in good faith and without reasonable belief
that the Participant’s action or omission was in the best interest of the Company.
1
-- 175 of 411 --
Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Participant shall not be deemed to have been terminated for “Cause” hereunder unless and until there shall have been
delivered to the Participant a copy of a resolution duly adopted by the affirmative vote of not less than three quarters of the Board then in office at a meeting of
the Board called and held for such purpose, after reasonable notice to the Participant and an opportunity for the Participant, together with the Participant’s
counsel (if the Participant chooses to have counsel present at such meeting), to be heard before the Board, finding that, in the good faith opinion of the Board,
the Participant had committed an act constituting “Cause” as herein defined and specifying the particulars thereof in detail. Nothing herein will limit the right of
the Participant or his Beneficiaries to contest the validity or propriety of any such determination.
1.7 “Change in Control ” means, with respect to any Participant, the first to occur of any of the following events:
(a) Any one person, or more than one person acting as a group, acquires ownership of stock of the Company that, together with stock held
by such person or group, constitutes more than 50% of the total fair market value or total voting power of the stock of the Company. However, if any one
person, or more than one person acting as a group, is considered to own more than 50% of the total fair market value or total voting power of the stock of the
Company, the acquisition of additional stock by the same person or persons is not considered to cause a Change in Control. An increase in the percentage of
stock owned by any one person, or persons acting as a group, as a result of a transaction in which the Company acquires its stock in exchange for property will
be treated as an acquisition of stock for purposes of this Section 1.7. This Section 1.7 applies only when there is a transfer of stock of the Company (or issuance
of stock of the Company) and stock in the Company remains outstanding after the transaction;
(b) Any one person, or more than one person acting as a group, acquires (or has acquired during the 12-month period ending on the date
of the most recent acquisition by such person or persons) ownership of stock of the Company possessing 35% or more of the total voting power of the stock of
the Company;
(c) A majority of members of the Board is replaced during any 12-month period by directors whose appointment or election is not endorsed
by a majority of the members of the Board prior to the date of the appointment or election; or
(d) Any one person, or more than one person acting as a group, acquires (or has acquired during the 12-month period ending on the date
of the most recent acquisition by such person or persons) assets from the Company that have a total gross fair market value equal to or more than 40% of the
total gross fair market value of all of the assets of the Company immediately prior to such acquisition or acquisitions.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, for purposes of this Section 1.7, any acquisition of ownership of stock of the Company by any one person, or more than
one person acting as a group, pursuant to a Business Combination shall not constitute a Change in Control. A “ Business Combination” shall mean any
business transaction such as a reorganization, merger or consolidation involving the Company, a sale or other disposition of all or substantially all of the assets
of the Company, or any other transaction involving the Company, if, in each case, immediately following any such business transaction:
(1) all or substantially all of the individuals and entities who were the beneficial owners of stock of the Company immediately prior
to such business transaction beneficially own, directly or indirectly, more than 55% of the combined voting power of the then outstanding shares of stock of the
entity resulting from such business transaction (including, without limitation, an entity which as a result of such transaction owns the Company or all or
substantially all of the Company’s assets either directly or through one or more subsidiaries) in substantially the same proportions relative to each other as their
ownership, immediately prior to such business transaction, of the stock of the Company;
2
-- 176 of 411 --
(2) no one person, or more than one person acting as a group (other than the Company, such entity resulting from such business
transaction, or any employee benefit plan (or related trust) sponsored or maintained by the Company, any subsidiary corporation, as defined under Section
424(f) of the Code, or such entity resulting from such business transaction), beneficially owns, directly or indirectly, 30% or more of the combined voting power
of the then outstanding shares of stock of the entity resulting from such business transaction; and
(3) at least a majority of the members of the board of directors of the entity resulting from such business transaction were
members of the Incumbent Board at the time of the execution of the initial agreement or of the action of the Board providing for such business transaction.
The “Incumbent Board” shall mean those individuals who, as of January 1, 2012, constitute the Board; provided, however, that any individual
becoming a director subsequent to January 1, 2012 whose election, or nomination for election by the Company’s shareholders, was approved by a vote of at
least a majority of the directors then comprising the Incumbent Board (either by a specific vote or by approval of the proxy statement of the Company in which
such person is named as a nominee for director, without objection to such nomination) shall be deemed to have been a member of the Incumbent Board, but
excluding for this purpose any such individual whose initial assumption of office occurs as a result of an actual or threatened election contest (as described in
Rule 14a-12(c) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934) with respect to the election or removal of directors or other actual or threatened solicitation of proxies or
consents by or on behalf of a person other than the Board.
For purposes of this Section 1.7, other than the definition of “Business Combination,” (x) persons will be considered to be acting as a group if they are
owners of a corporation that enters into a merger, consolidation, purchase or acquisition of stock, or similar business transaction with the Company, and (y) if a
person, including an entity, owns stock in both corporations that enter into a merger, consolidation, purchase or acquisition of stock, or similar transaction, such
shareholder is considered to be acting as a group with other shareholders in a corporation prior to the transaction giving rise to the change and not with respect
to the ownership interest in the other corporation.
1.8 “Code” means the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, and all lawful regulations and pronouncements promulgated thereunder
upon which taxpayers may rely. References to a particular section of the Code include references to successor provisions of the Code or any successor statute.
1.9 “Committee” means the committee described in Section 7.1.
1.10 “Company” means Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
1.11 “Contribution” or “Contributions” means the amounts credited to a Participant’s Accounts under Article IV. The Contribution types and the
Account associated with each Contribution type are as more fully described and defined under Articles III and IV.
1.12 “Disability” means, with respect to any Participant, that such Participant is, by reason of any medically determinable physical or mental
impairment which can be expected to result in death or can be expected to last for a continuous period of not less than 12 months, either (a) unable to engage
in any substantial gainful activity, or (b) receiving income replacement benefits for a period of not less than three (3) months under an accident and health plan
covering employees of an Employer. Without limitation, for purpose of this Plan, a Participant will be deemed to have a Disability if the Participant is determined
to be totally disabled by the Social Security Administration, or is determined to be disabled in accordance with a disability insurance program of the Company or
any Employer (provided that the definition of disability applied under such disability insurance program complies with the requirements of Section 409A of the
Code).
3
-- 177 of 411 --
1.13 “Effective Date” means January 1, 2012, as applied in the manner more fully described in Article II.
1.14 “Election Deadline” means, as applicable, the deadline established for an Elective Contribution pursuant to Article III.
1.15 “Elective Contribution” means an elective contribution made or deemed made by a Participant under Article III and allocated to a Participant
Account under Article IV.
1.16 “Eligible Employee” generally means a corporate officer of the Company, a Mine Manager of an Employer or an employee of an Employer in
“Salary Band E” or higher; provided, however, that “Eligible Employee” status: (a) shall not include any person who is an employee of a non-U.S. affiliate
outside the United States unless he or she was an employee of a U.S. affiliate in the United States and, immediately prior to his or her transfer to the non-U.S.
affiliate, was an Eligible Employee hereunder; (b) shall first become effective only as confirmed by the Company in writing, at its discretion; and (c) may be
prospectively revoked by the Company at its discretion, upon written notice to the affected individual, subject to the applicable requirements of Code Section
409A; and provided, further, that such Eligible Employee is among a select group of management or highly compensated employees (within the meaning of
Section 201(2) of ERISA).
1.17 “Employer” means the Company and any corporation or business organization during any period in which it is a member of a controlled group
of corporations or trades or businesses that includes the Company within the meaning of Code Sections 414(b) and 414(c) provided that in such Code Sections
“50%” shall be used wherever “80%” appears; but only during the periods any such corporation or business organization would be so considered under such
Code Sections.
1.18 “Employer Contribution” means Contributions credited allocated to a Participant’s Account under Section 4.2.
1.19 “ERISA” means the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended, and regulations and rulings thereunder. References to a
particular section of ERISA include references to successor provisions of ERISA or any successor statute.
1.20 “Initial Election Deadline” means December 31, 2011 or, if later, the first Election Deadline applicable to the Eligible Employee under Section
3.2 for his or her first Plan Year (or portion thereof) of eligibility thereunder.
1.21 “Initial Participation Agreement” means: (a) for each Eligible Employee who is a Participant in the Plan on January 1, 2012, the first
Participation Agreement properly completed and submitted by the Participant on or before the Initial Election Deadline; and (b) for each Eligible Employee who
first becomes a Participant after January 1, 2012, the first Participation Agreement properly completed and submitted by the Participant on or before the Initial
Election Deadline for the new Participant’s initial period of Plan participation, as described under Section 3.2.
1.22 “Investment Credit” means the deemed earnings/losses credited to a Participant’s Accounts using the applicable Investment Measure.
1.23 “Investment Measure” means the deemed investment measure or measures established at any given time, and from time to time, for
purposes of determining the Investment Credits applicable to a Participant’s Accounts. For this purpose, the deemed measure or measures may include
investment options which allow Participant direction among the alternatives pursuant to any and all rules and procedures as are or may be established, at any
time or from time to time, for this purpose by the Company at its discretion. If the Company does not establish a deemed investment measure or measures for a
given period of time, the Participant’s Accounts shall be deemed invested in a vehicle
4
-- 178 of 411 --
producing the return equivalent to the Moody’s Corporate Average Bond Yield, as adjusted on the first business day of each January, April, July and October.
1.24 “Participant” means an Eligible Employee who satisfies the requirements for participation set forth in Section 3.2 and who otherwise receives
a Contribution allocation pursuant to Article IV.
1.25 “Participating Employer” means the Company and/or any other Employer that pays compensation to a Participant.
1.26 “Participation Agreement” means, for a Plan Year, the timely submitted form for that Plan Year pursuant to which a Participant elects to
make Elective Contributions under Article III.
1.27 “Plan” means this Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. 2012 Non-Qualified Deferred Compensation Plan, as amended from time to time pursuant to Article
VIII.
1.28 “Plan Year” means the calendar year.
1.29 “Savings Plan” means, as applicable to the Participant, the Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and Associated Employers Salaried Employees Savings Plan
or the Northshore Mining Company and Silver Bay Power Company Retirement Savings Plan (or any successors thereto).
1.30 “Six-Month Date” means the first day next following six (6) months after the date of a Participant’s Termination.
1.31 “Subsequent Deferral Election” means a one-time election by a Participant to change the form and/or timing of distributions under the Plan
subject to and in accordance with the requirements of Section 6.2(c).
1.32 “Subsequent Deferral Election Commencement Date ” means, if effective under Section 6.2(c), the day next following the fifth anniversary of
the Participant’s Six-Month Date.
1.33 “Termination” or “Terminated” means the "separation from service" for purposes of Code Section 409A of any Participant or former
Participant from the Company and all other Employers, generally including the severance of such employee's employment relationship with the Company and
all Employers for any reason, voluntarily or involuntarily, and with or without cause, including without limitation, quit, discharge, retirement, disability, death,
failure to return to active employment at the end of a leave of absence (including military leave, sick leave, or other bona fide leave of absence) or permanent
decrease in service to the Company and all Employers to a level that is no more than twenty percent (20%) of its prior level, as described below. For this
purpose, whether a separation from service has occurred is determined based on whether it is reasonably anticipated that no further services will be performed
by such employee after a certain date or that the level of bona fide services the employee will perform after such date (whether as an employee or as an
independent contractor) would permanently decrease to no more than twenty percent (20%) of the average level of bona fide services performed (whether as an
employee or an independent contractor) over the immediately preceding thirty-six (36) month period (or the full period of services if the employee has been
providing services for less than thirty-six (36) months). The transfer of an employee from the Company or other Employer to the Company or another Employer
shall not constitute a Termination for purposes of this Plan.
1.34 “Valuation Date” means, for each Account, a date as of which the Account is valued for purposes of the Plan, as determined under rules and
procedures reasonably established by the Company for administrative convenience.
5
-- 179 of 411 --
1.35 “Vested” means the existence of a vested interest in an Account, as determined under Article V.
ARTICLE II
EFFECTIVE DATE
2.1 Effective Date and First Plan Year . The general Effective Date of this Plan is January 1, 2012. For the first Plan Year (2012), the following
deferrals under the Plan become effective as follows: (a) Elective Contributions relating to any Base Salary and/or Bonus earned for the 2012 Plan Year, in
order to be effective, must be elected under a properly completed Participation Agreement, submitted by the applicable Election Deadline, but no later than
December 31, 2011, or if later, as permitted under Section 3.2(d); (b) Employer Contributions relating to any such Elective Contributions (i.e., if applicable, the
Supplemental Matching Contribution) shall be credited for the 2012 Plan Year only if the requirements of clause (a), above are satisfied with respect to such
Elective Contributions; and (c) Employer Contributions relating to discretionary performance contributions under the Savings Plan, if any, shall be credited under
this Plan to the extent such Employer Contributions relate to Savings Plan discretionary performance contributions made on behalf of the 2012 Plan Year under
the Savings Plan.
2.2 Coordination with 2005 Plan. Amounts elected to be deferred and contributions or other amounts required to be credited under the provisions
of the Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. 2005 Voluntary Non-Qualified Deferred Compensation Plan, as amended (the “2005 Plan”) as in effect immediately prior to
the Effective Date, including the crediting of investment or interest credits after 2011, shall continue to be governed in all respects by the terms and conditions of
the 2005 Plan. Deferral and contribution opportunities under the 2005 Plan shall cease with respect to the periods for which Elective Contribution opportunities
and Employer Contributions commence under this Plan in the manner set forth in Section 2.1. There shall be no duplication of deferral opportunities or benefits
under this Plan and the 2005 Plan.
ARTICLE III
PARTICIPATION AND DEFERRAL ELECTIONS
3.1 Participation. Each Eligible Employee shall become a Participant when he or she properly and timely submits an election to make Elective
Contributions pursuant to a Participation Agreement under Section 3.2 or when he or she otherwise is credited with an amount pursuant to Section 4.2. In
addition, the Committee shall establish from time to time such other enrollment requirements as it determines in its sole discretion are necessary. A Participant
who ceases to be an Eligible Employee shall remain a Participant for Plan purposes, but shall have no further opportunity to elect or make Elective Contributions
and shall have no eligibility for further Employer Contributions, except as may be required under Code Section 409A.
3.2 Elective Contribution Deferral Elections .
(a) General. An Eligible Employee may make Elective Contributions by properly completing and timely submitting a Participation
Agreement made available by the Company in accordance with this Section 3.2, subject to any and all further rules and procedures as may be required by the
Company, at its discretion. If no such election is timely made for a Plan Year, the amount of Elective Contributions shall be zero for that Plan Year. All deferral
elections hereunder shall become null and void upon the occurrence of a Change in Control.
(b) Base Salary Deferral. For each Plan Year, an Eligible Employee may irrevocably elect to defer as an Elective Contribution hereunder
up to 50% of the Base Salary earned and payable during such Plan Year (“Base Salary Deferral Contribution”). The election to make a Base Salary
6
-- 180 of 411 --
Deferral Contribution for a Plan Year shall become irrevocable on the December 31st preceding the commencement of the Plan Year and the Election Deadline
for making and submitting such an election shall be such date or such earlier date as may be established by the Company at its discretion.
(c) Bonus Deferral. For each Plan Year, an Eligible Employee may irrevocably elect to defer as an Elective Contribution hereunder up to
100% of the Bonus earned during such Plan Year and payable during the next following Plan Year (“ Bonus Deferral Contribution”). The election to make a
Bonus Deferral Contribution of the Bonus earned during a Plan Year shall become irrevocable on the December 31st preceding the commencement of such
Plan Year and the Election Deadline for making and submitting such an election shall be such date or such earlier date as may be established by the Company
at its discretion.
(d) Special Rules for New Eligible Employees . In the event that an Eligible Employee first becomes eligible to participate in the Plan or first
commences employment during the course of a Plan Year, a properly completed Participation Agreement may be submitted not later than 30 days following the
later of his or her eligibility date or date of employment (the “Initial Election Deadline” under this Section 3.2(d)); provided, however, that, for purposes of this
Section 3.2(d), an Eligible Employee who was in employment with an Employer in a status other than that of an Eligible Employee is considered to be first
eligible to participate in this Plan only if the individual is not a participant in any other agreement, method, program or arrangement that, along with this Plan,
would be treated as a single nonqualified deferred compensation plan under Code Section 409A. A deferral election hereunder becomes irrevocable as of the
last permissible date for making such election, as described in this Section, and shall be prospectively applied only (i) to amounts of Base Salary to be paid for
services performed after the election becomes irrevocable and (ii) to amounts of Bonuses that are earned based upon a specified performance period equal to
the total amount of the applicable Bonus for the performance period multiplied by the ratio of the number of days remaining in the performance period after the
election becomes effective over the total number of days in the performance period.
ARTICLE IV
ACCOUNTS AND ALLOCATIONS
4.1 Elective Contributions.
(a) Base Salary Deferral Contribution . All Base Salary Deferral Contributions deferred with respect to a Participant under Article III shall be
credited and allocated to the Participant’s Base Salary Deferral Contribution Account as of the date such amounts would have been paid to the Participant
absent the deferral election or such later date established by the Company for administrative convenience.
(b) Bonus Deferral Contribution. All Bonus Deferral Contributions deferred with respect to a Participant under Article III shall be credited
and allocated to the Participant’s Bonus Deferral Contribution Account as of the date such amounts would have been paid to the Participant absent the deferral
election or such later date established by the Company for administrative convenience.
4.2 Employer Contributions.
(a) Supplemental Performance Contribution. If a discretionary Employer performance contribution percentage is determined for a plan
year under the Savings Plan (with such determination made after the end of such plan year) and such amount (expressed as a percentage of Base Salary)
cannot be fully allocated to a Participant due to the limitations under the Savings Plan imposed by Code Section 401(a)(17) and/or 415, then the portion of such
amount that cannot be allocated with respect to the Participant under the Savings Plan for such plan year shall be credited as a Supplemental Performance
Contribution hereunder and shall be allocated to the Participant’s
7
-- 181 of 411 --
Supplemental Performance Contribution Account as of the date such amount would have been received and allocated under the Savings Plan or such later
date established by the Company for administrative convenience.
(b) Supplemental Matching Contribution. From time to time, but not less frequently than once per Plan Year, a Supplemental Matching
Contribution shall be determined and credited to the Supplemental Matching Contribution Account of each “Matching Eligible Participant” (as defined below)
equal to the amount, if any, by which the Full Formula Match amount described in (1) below exceeds the Actual Savings Plan Match amount described in (2)
below:
(1) Full Formula Match. The “Full Formula Match” is the total matching contribution amount that would result by applying the
matching formula under the Savings Plan for the period on account of which the matching contribution was made (the “matching contribution period”) to the
Matching Eligible Participant’s Base Salary for such matching contribution period, taking into account: (A) the elective deferrals and other contributions that were
made under the Savings Plan and would be eligible for matching under such formula if the limitations of Code Sections 401(a)(17) and 415 did not apply; and
(B) if applicable, Base Salary Deferral Contributions made under this Plan as to such matching contribution period as if made as regular (non-catch-up) elective
deferrals under the Savings Plan, determined without regard to the limitations of Code Section 402(g).
(2) Actual Savings Plan Match. The “Actual Savings Plan Match ” is the total matching contribution amount actually allocated
under the Savings Plan for the Matching Eligible Participant under the Savings Plan matching formula for such matching contribution period.
The Supplemental Matching Contribution, if any, shall be credited on a date or dates as more specifically determined by the Company for
administrative convenience. For purposes of this Section 4.2(b), a person is a “Matching Eligible Participant” for a matching contribution period under the
Savings Plan only if he or she was both an Eligible Employee at the beginning of such matching contribution period and remained employed by an Employer as
an Eligible Employee from such date through the date as of which the Supplemental Matching Contribution is credited under the immediately preceding
sentence.
(c) Cessation of Employer Contributions upon Certain Events . In the event a Participant’s employment is Terminated for Cause, no
additional Employer Contributions shall be credited to such Participant’s Account on or after the date of such Termination. Additionally, pursuant to Section 9.12,
Employer Contributions will no longer be credited to a Participant’s Account in the event a legal action is filed in any court other than those prescribed by
Section 9.12.
4.3 Investment Credits. On a periodic basis not less frequently than once per calendar quarter, all Participant Accounts shall be credited,
positively or negatively, with Investment Credits to reflect the deemed investment performance of each such Account during the relevant period using the
applicable Investment Measure, as determined under the crediting rules and procedures reasonably established by the Company.
4.4 Status of Accounts. Anything contained herein to the contrary notwithstanding: (a) all amounts respecting a Participant’s Accounts under this
Plan, including amounts that may be determined, credited, allocated or considered Vested under the terms hereof or amounts that may be reported to the
Participant in any form, shall at all times be mere bookkeeping entries, with no actual assets or funds being specifically dedicated, set aside or otherwise
associated with such amounts; and (b) all rights of, or relating to, Participants, Contributions and/ or Accounts under this Plan shall be limited to those contained
in this Plan instrument, the Participation Agreement and other forms used to administer this Plan, with such rights and any related claims being no greater than
that of a general unsecured creditor of the Company.
8
-- 182 of 411 --
ARTICLE V
VESTING
All Accounts of a Participant under this Plan shall be fully Vested and nonforfeitable at all times.
ARTICLE VI
DISTRIBUTIONS
6.1 Time of Distribution.
(a) Distribution Following Termination . A Participant’s Accounts shall become distributable upon a Participant’s Termination for reasons
other than death or Disability, with actual distribution occurring or commencing on, or as soon as is practicable following, the Participant’s Six-Month Date, or
such later date as required pursuant to Section 6.2(c).
(b) Distribution Following Death or Disability . A Participant’s Accounts shall become distributable upon a Participant’s death or Disability,
with actual distribution occurring within sixty (60) days following his or her death or Disability.
(c) Distribution Upon Change in Control. A Participant’s Accounts shall become distributable upon the occurrence of a Change in Control,
with actual distribution occurring within three (3) business days after the Change in Control.
6.2 Form of Distribution.
(a) Lump-Sum Normal Form. All distributions pursuant to Section 6.1(a) shall be in the form of one lump-sum cash payment, except as
provided otherwise under Section 6.2(b). All distributions pursuant to Section 6.1(b) and 6.1(c) shall be in the form of one lump-sum cash payment. All lump-
sum distributions made to or with respect to a Participant under Section 6.1 shall be based upon the value of each of the Participant’s Accounts as of the
Valuation Date immediately preceding the date distribution thereunder occurs.
(b) Optional Installments. If elected by a Participant on a properly completed and submitted Initial Participation Agreement prior to the
applicable Initial Election Deadline or under a properly completed and effective Subsequent Deferral Election under Section 6.2(c), under such further rules and
procedures established by the Company consistent with the requirements of Code Section 409A, distribution under 6.1(a) shall be made in the number of
annual installments (from two (2) to ten (10)) so elected by the Participant with respect to all of his or her Accounts. The first payment of an installment
distribution elected under a Participant’s Initial Participation Agreement shall commence on, or as soon as is practicable following, the Participant’s Six-Month
Date, and the remaining installments shall be paid on each anniversary of the Participant’s Six-Month Date or as soon thereafter as is administratively
practicable. The first payment of an installment distribution elected under a Participant’s Subsequent Deferral Election, if effective under Section 6.2(c), shall
commence on, or as soon as is practicable following, the Participant’s Subsequent Deferral Election Commencement Date, and the remaining installments shall
be paid on each anniversary of the Participant’s Subsequent Deferral Election Commencement Date or as soon thereafter as is administratively practicable. All
installment payments made to or with respect to a Participant under this Section 6.2(b) shall be calculated by multiplying the balance of the Participant’s
Accounts as of the Valuation Date immediately preceding the installment payment date by a fraction, the numerator of which is one (1) and the denominator of
which is the number of annual installments remaining to be paid (including the installment for which the amount is being determined).
9
-- 183 of 411 --
(c) One-Time Subsequent Deferral Election. Subject to the further requirements of this Section 6.2(c), each Participant, on a form made
available by the Company and subject to such other rules and requirements as the Company may prescribe, may irrevocably elect to receive installment
distributions under Section 6.2(b) in lieu of an otherwise applicable lump-sum distribution method (whether applicable by election or default) or an election to
receive installment distributions under his or her Initial Participation Agreement or may irrevocably elect to receive a lump-sum distribution in lieu of an otherwise
applicable lump-sum distribution (whether applicable by election or default) or an election to receive installment distributions under his or her Initial Participation
Agreement. In order for an election under the preceding sentence to be effective, any such election: (1) must be the only election or attempted election ever
made by the Participant under this Section 6.2(c); (2) must provide that the distribution so elected shall be made or, in the case of installments, shall commence,
on the Participant’s Subsequent Deferral Election Commencement Date; and (3) the date such irrevocable election is properly made and submitted to the
Company in accordance with the rules and requirements the Company may prescribe must, in fact, precede the Participant’s Termination by at least twelve (12)
months. Any election or attempted election that is not effective under the preceding sentence is not considered to be an effective Subsequent Deferral Election
hereunder and shall be completely null and void.
(d) Automatic Cash-Out. Notwithstanding the election of installments under the preceding provisions of this Section 6.2: (1) if the combined
value of a Participant’s Accounts is less than $50,000 on a Valuation Date as of which an installment to the Participant is being determined, then the remaining
undistributed value of all such Accounts as of such Valuation Date shall be distributed in one final lump-sum distribution as soon as is practicable, but no later
than 30 days following the date the installment otherwise is or would be made; or (2) if the Participant dies with installments remaining to be paid following the
date of death, then the remaining undistributed value of all of his or her undistributed Accounts shall be distributed to the Participant’s Beneficiary in one final
lump-sum as soon as is practicable, but no later than 60 days following proper notice of the Participant’s death, based upon the value of the undistributed
Accounts as of the Valuation Date next preceding the date of distribution.
6.3 Distributions to Beneficiary Upon Death. For a distribution under Section 6.1(b) following a Participant’s Termination on account of death or
for a distribution under Section 6.2(d) with respect to a Participant who dies with installments remaining to be paid, distribution shall be made to the Participant’s
Beneficiary. For purposes of this Plan, each Participant shall have the right, at any time, to designate any person or persons, contingently or successively, as his
or her Beneficiary to whom payment under the Plan shall be made in the event of his or her death prior to complete distribution to the Participant of his or her
Account(s). Any Beneficiary designation shall be made in a written instrument properly completed and filed with the Company and shall be effective only when
received in writing by the Company. Any Beneficiary designation may be changed by a Participant by the filing of a new Beneficiary designation, which will
cancel all Beneficiary designations previously filed. If a Participant fails to designate a Beneficiary as provided above, or if all designated Beneficiaries (and all
contingent or successive Beneficiaries) predecease the Participant, or such designations are invalid for any reason, or all such Beneficiaries disclaim the
Participant’s benefits under this Plan and the Committee has accepted the disclaimers as valid under applicable law, then the Participant's designated
Beneficiary shall be deemed to be the Participant's estate. Notwithstanding the foregoing, a divorce decree, or a decree of legal separation that is effective after
the Effective Date of this Plan, shall revoke the Participant's prior designation, if any, of his or her spouse or former spouse as his or her Beneficiary under the
Plan unless a qualified domestic relations order provides otherwise. Payment to a Participant's Beneficiary (or, upon the death of all designated Beneficiaries
(and all contingent or successive Beneficiaries), to the Beneficiary's estate) shall completely discharge the Participating Employer, all other Employers, and the
Committee from all liability with respect to such benefit obligations under the Plan.
If the Committee has any bona fide doubt as to the proper Beneficiary to receive a deceased Participant’s benefit under this Plan, the Committee shall
have the right, exercisable in their sole discretion, to cause the Participating Employer to withhold such payment until this dispute is resolved to the Committee's
satisfaction. In this case, the payment shall be made no later than the end of the first
10
-- 184 of 411 --
taxable year of the Beneficiary(ies) in which the Committee and the Beneficiary(ies) enter into a legally binding settlement of such dispute or the Participating
Employer is required to make such payment pursuant to a final and nonappealable judgment or other binding decision.
ARTICLE VII
ADMINISTRATION
7.1 Administration by Committee. The Plan shall be administered by the Company, acting by and through the “Committee” comprised of those
members of the Compensation and Organization Committee of the Board (or any successor committee) who are not Participants, as long as there are at least
three (3) such members. If there are not at least three (3) such non-participating persons on the Compensation and Organization Committee (or any successor
committee), the chief executive officer of the Company shall appoint other non-participating Directors or Company officers to serve on the Committee. The
Committee shall supervise the administration and operation of the Plan, may from time to time adopt rules and procedures governing the Plan and shall have
authority to construe and interpret the Plan (including, without limitation, by supplying omissions from, correcting deficiencies in, or resolving inconsistencies and
ambiguities in, the language of the Plan).
7.2 Delegation. The Committee may appoint an individual or group of individuals, who may be an employee or employees of the Company, to be
the Committee's authorized agent with respect to the day-to-day administration of Company duties and determinations under the Plan. In addition, the
Committee may, from time to time, employ other agents and delegate to them such administrative duties as it sees fit, and may from time to time consult with
counsel who may be counsel to the Company.
7.3 Binding Effect of Decisions. Any decision or action of the Committee with respect to any question arising out of or in connection with the
administration, interpretation and application of the Plan shall be final and binding upon all persons who at any time have, have had, or may have a claim to any
interest or rights whatsoever under this Plan.
7.4 Indemnity of Committee. The Company shall indemnify and hold harmless the members of the Committee and their duly appointed agents
under Section 7.2 against any and all claims, loss, damage, expense or liability arising from any action or failure to act with respect to the Plan, except in the
case of gross negligence or willful misconduct by any such member or agent of the Committee.
ARTICLE VIII
AMENDMENT AND TERMINATION
8.1 Amendment. The Company, on behalf of itself and of each Employer may, subject to Section 8.3, at any time amend, suspend or reinstate any
or all of the provisions of the Plan, except that no such amendment, suspension or reinstatement may adversely affect any Account of any Participant, as it
existed as of the effective date of such amendment, suspension or reinstatement, without such Participant's prior written consent, unless such amendment is
deemed necessary by the Company to bring this Plan into compliance with Section 409A of the Code or any other applicable law.
8.2 Termination. The Company, on behalf of itself and of each Employer, in its sole discretion, may, subject to Section 8.3, terminate this Plan at
any time and for any reason whatsoever.
8.3 Prohibition Against Acceleration . Notwithstanding the authority of the Company to amend, suspend, reinstate or terminate this Plan and/or
its provisions under this Article and notwithstanding the interpretative authority retained under Article VII, in no event shall any such action provide for, allow or
result in an acceleration of payment or benefits prohibited by Code Section 409A, recognizing the exceptions to such prohibitions contained in Treas. Reg. §
1.409A-3(j).
11
-- 185 of 411 --
ARTICLE IX
MISCELLANEOUS
9.1 Funding. Participants, their Beneficiaries, and their heirs, successors and assigns, shall have no secured interest or claim in any property or
assets of any Employer. The obligation of the Company and other Employers under the Plan shall be merely that of an unfunded and unsecured promise to pay
money in the future. Notwithstanding the foregoing, in the event of a Change in Control, the Company shall create an irrevocable trust to hold funds to be used
in payment of the obligations of the Employers under the Plan, and the Company shall fund such trust in an amount equal to no less than the total value of the
Participants' Accounts under the Plan as of the date immediately preceding the Change in Control, provided that any funds contained therein shall remain liable
for the claims of the respective Employer's general creditors.
9.2 Employer’s Liability. A Participating Employer's liability for the payment of benefits under this Plan is exclusively contained in this Plan
instrument, Participation Agreements and other forms used to administer this Plan. Neither a Participating Employer nor any other Employer shall have an
obligation to a Participant under the Plan except as expressly provided in the Plan and his or her Participation Agreement and other administrative forms.
9.3 Nonassignability. No right or interest under the Plan of a Participant or his or her Beneficiary (or any person claiming through or under any of
them) shall be assignable or transferable in any manner or be subject to alienation, anticipation, sale, pledge, encumbrance or other legal process or in any
manner be liable for or subject to the debts or liabilities of any such Participant or Beneficiary, except as expressly required by law. If any Participant or
Beneficiary shall attempt to or shall transfer, assign, alienate, anticipate, sell, pledge or otherwise encumber his or her benefits hereunder or any part thereof, or
if by reason of his or her bankruptcy or other event happening at any time such benefits would devolve upon anyone else or would not be enjoyed by him or her,
then such assignment shall be null and void, except as expressly required by law. Notwithstanding to foregoing provisions of this Section 9.3, the Plan will
recognize, to the extent lawful, applicable and required, orders issued under domestic relations laws.
9.4 Legal Fees and Expenses . It is the intent of the Company and each other Employer that following a Change in Control no Eligible Employee or
former Eligible Employee be required to incur the expenses associated with the enforcement of his or her rights under this Plan by litigation or other legal action
because the cost and expense thereof would substantially detract from the benefits intended to be extended to an Eligible Employee hereunder. Accordingly, if it
should appear that the Employer has failed to comply with any of its obligations under this Plan or in the event that the Employer or any other person takes any
action to declare this Plan void or unenforceable, or institutes any litigation designed to deny, or to recover from, the Eligible Employee the benefits intended to
be provided to such Eligible Employee hereunder, the Employer irrevocably authorizes such Eligible Employee from time to time to retain counsel of his or her
choice, at the expense of the Employer as hereafter provided, to represent such Eligible Employee in connection with the initiation or defense of any litigation or
other legal action, whether by or against the Employer or any director, officer, stockholder or other person affiliated with the Employer in any jurisdiction. The
Employer shall pay and be solely responsible for any and all attorneys' and related fees and expenses incurred by such Eligible Employee as a result of the
Employer's failure to perform under this Plan or any provision thereof; or as a result of the Employer or any person contesting the validity or enforceability of this
Plan or any provision thereof. The Employer agrees to reimburse an Eligible Employee or pay directly to such counsel any and all reasonable costs and
expenses (including but not limited to reasonable attorneys' fees) an Eligible Employee may incur in connection with such failure to perform under the Plan with
such reimbursement to occur no later than the end of the taxable year following the taxable year in which such expense was incurred. In addition, the amounts
eligible for reimbursement during any one taxable year under this Section 9.4 may not affect the expenses eligible for reimbursement in any other taxable year
under this Section 9.4.
12
-- 186 of 411 --
9.5 Withholding Taxes . The Employer shall withhold the minimum amount of taxes which it determines it is required by law or required by the
terms of this Plan to withhold in connection with any recognition of income incident to this Plan payable to a Participant or Beneficiary.
9.6 Captions. The captions contained herein are for convenience only and shall not control or affect the meaning or construction hereof.
9.7 Governing Law. The provisions of the Plan shall be construed and interpreted according to the laws of the State of Ohio without regard to its
conflicts of laws principals unless superseded by ERISA or other federal law.
9.8 Successors. The provisions of the Plan shall bind and inure to the benefit of the Company, the other Employers, and their respective
successors and assigns. The term “successors” as used herein shall include any corporate or other business entity which shall, whether by merger,
consolidation, purchase or otherwise, acquire all or substantially all of the business and assets of the Company or another Employer and successors of any
such corporation or other business entity.
9.9 Right to Continued Service. Nothing contained herein shall be construed to be a contract of employment or to confer upon any Eligible
Employee the right to continue to serve as an Eligible Employee of the Employer or in any other capacity.
9.10 Section 409A Compliance. It is the intention and purpose of the Company that this Plan shall be, at all relevant times, in compliance with (or,
where applicable, exempt from) Code Section 409A and other applicable laws, and this Plan shall be so interpreted and administered. In addition to the general
amendment rights of the Company with respect to the Plan, the Company specifically retains the unilateral right (but not the obligation) to make, prospectively or
retroactively, any amendment to this Plan or any related document as it deems necessary or desirable to more fully address issues in connection with
compliance with (or exemption from) Code Section 409A and/or such other laws. In no event, however, shall this Section 9.10 or any other provisions of this
Plan be construed to require the Company to provide any gross-up for the tax consequences of any provisions of, or payments under, this Plan and the
Company shall have no responsibility for tax or legal consequences to any Participant (or Beneficiary) resulting from the terms or operation of this Plan.
9.11 Deadline to File a Claim under Plan; Deadline to file Legal Action . No claim for benefits may be made by a Participant or Beneficiary on
any disputed matter pertaining to this Plan unless such claim is made within one (1) year following the occurrence of the earliest event upon which the claim
may be made. With respect to any claim relating to the contents of a notice pertaining to this Plan, the Participant or Beneficiary must make such claim within
one (1) year following the date the notice was given. No legal action to enforce or clarify rights under this Plan or under any provision of law, whether or not
statutory, or any other action arising from, or related to, this Plan, may be brought by any Participant or Beneficiary on any matter pertaining to this Plan unless
the legal action is commenced in the proper forum as prescribed by Section 9.12 before the earlier of: (a) two (2) years after the Participant or Beneficiary knew
or reasonably should have known of the principal facts on which the claim is based; or (b) one (1) year after the Participant or Beneficiary has exhausted any
claim procedure applicable to this Plan. For purposes of applying the foregoing provisions of this Section, knowledge of all of the facts that a Participant knew or
reasonable should have known shall be imputed to every Participant or Beneficiary who is or claims to be a beneficiary of the Participant or otherwise claims to
derive a benefit or entitlement under this Plan by reference to that Participant.
9.12 Venue. Any legal actions, suits or proceedings pertaining to this Plan shall be brought in the courts of Ohio (whether federal or state) and the
Participant, Beneficiary, persons claiming to be a beneficiary or any other persons who claim to derive a benefit or entitlement under this Plan by reference to
the Participant irrevocably submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of Ohio courts. The Participant, Beneficiary, persons claiming to be a Beneficiary or any other
person who claim to derive a benefit or
13
-- 187 of 411 --
entitlement under this Plan by reference to the Participant waive, to the fullest extent permitted by law, any objection any such person may now or hereafter
have to laying venue in any suit, action or proceeding hereunder in any court, as well as any right any such person may now or hereafter have to remove any
such suit, action or proceeding once commenced to another court in any jurisdiction on the grounds of forum non-convenience or otherwise. In the event that
any such person resorts to an improper forum, such forum shall award the Company reasonable attorney’s fees and costs incurred by the Company to enforce
the provisions of this Plan, and such forum shall award the Company such other legal or equitable relief as the forum deems appropriate. In the event a legal
action is filed in any court other than a federal or state court located in Ohio, the Participant’s Accounts shall not be credited with any additional Employer
Contributions on or after the date such legal action, suit, or proceeding is filed.
9.13 Use of Electronic Media and Written Communications . All Plan notices and all Participant or Beneficiary notices, designations, elections,
consents or waivers must be in writing (which may include an electronic communication) and made in a form the Plan specifies or otherwise approves. Any
person entitled to notice under the Plan may waive the notice or shorten the notice period unless such actions are contrary to applicable law. The Plan, using
any electronic medium, may give or receive any Plan notice, communicate any Plan policy, conduct any written Plan communication, satisfy any Plan filing or
other compliance requirement and conduct any other Plan transaction to the extent permissible under applicable law. A Participant, a Participant's spouse, or a
Beneficiary, may use any electronic medium to provide any Beneficiary designation, election, notice, consent or waiver under the Plan, to the extent permissible
under applicable law. Any reference in this Plan to a "form," a "notice," an "election," a "consent," a "waiver," a "designation," a "policy" or to any other Plan-
related communication includes an electronic version thereof as permitted under applicable law.
14
-- 188 of 411 --
EXHIBIT10.40
CLEVELAND-CLIFFS INC.
SUPPLEMENTAL RETIREMENT BENEFIT PLAN
(as Amended and Restated Effective October 26, 2021)
1
-- 189 of 411 --
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
1. Definitions 3
2. Determination of the Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit 5
3. Payment of the Remaining Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit 5
4. General 6
5. Adoption of Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan 7
6. Miscellaneous 7
7. Amendment and Termination 8
8. Effective Date 9
2
-- 190 of 411 --
CLEVELAND-CLIFFS INC.
SUPPLEMENTAL RETIREMENT BENEFIT PLAN
(as Amended and Restated Effective October 26, 2021)
WHEREAS, Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (“Cliffs”) and its subsidiary corporations and affiliates have established, or may hereafter establish, one or
more qualified retirement plans;
WHEREAS, the qualified retirement plans, pursuant to Sections 401(a) and 415 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, place
certain limitations on the amount of contributions that would otherwise be made thereunder for certain participants;
WHEREAS, Cliffs now desires to provide for the contributions which would otherwise have been made for such participants under certain of its
qualified retirement plans except for such limitations, in consideration of services performed and to be performed by each such participant for Cliffs and its
subsidiaries and affiliates; and
WHEREAS, Cliffs has entered into, and Cliffs and its subsidiary corporations and affiliates may in the future enter into, agreements with certain
executives providing for additional service credit and/or other features for purposes of computing retirement benefits, in consideration of services performed and
to be performed by such executives for Cliffs and its subsidiaries and affiliates.
NOW, THEREFORE, Cliffs hereby amends and restates and publishes the Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan heretofore established by it,
which shall contain the following terms and conditions:
1. Definitions. A. The following words and phrases when used in this Plan with initial capital letters shall have the following respective meanings,
unless the context clearly indicates otherwise. The masculine whenever used in this Plan shall include the feminine.
B. “Affiliate” shall mean any partnership or joint venture of which any member of the Controlled Group is a partner or venturer and
which shall adopt this Plan pursuant to paragraph 5.
C. “Beneficiary” shall mean such person or persons (natural or otherwise) as may be designated by the Participant as his
Beneficiary under this Plan. Such a designation may be made, and may be revoked or changed (without the consent of any previously designated
Beneficiary), only by an instrument (in form acceptable to Cliffs) signed by the Participant and may be revoked or changed (without the consent of any
previously designated Beneficiary), only by an instrument (in form acceptable to Cliffs) signed by the Participant and filed with Cliffs prior to the
Participant’s death. In the absence of such a designation and at any other time when there is no existing Beneficiary designated by the Participant to
whom payment is to be made pursuant to his designation, his Beneficiary shall be his beneficiary under the Pension Plan. A person designated by a
Participant as his Beneficiary who or which ceases to exist shall not be entitled to any part of any payment thereafter to be made to the Participant’s
Beneficiary unless the Participant’s designation specifically provided to the contrary. If two or more persons designated as a Participant’s Beneficiary are
in existence, the amount of any payment to the Beneficiary under this Plan shall be divided equally among such persons unless the Participant’s
designation specifically provided to the contrary.
D. “Code” shall mean the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as it has been and may be amended from time to time.
3
-- 191 of 411 --
E. Code Limitations” shall mean the limitations imposed by Sections 401(a) and 415 of the Code, or any successor thereto, on the
amount of the benefits which may be payable to a Participant from the Pension Plan.
F. “Controlled Group” shall mean Cliffs and any corporation in an unbroken chain of corporations beginning with Cliffs, if each of
the corporations other than the last corporation in the chain owns or controls, directly or indirectly, stock possessing not less than fifty percent of the total
combined voting power of all classes of stock in one of the other corporations.
G. “Employer(s)” shall mean Cliffs and any other member of the Controlled Group and any Affiliate which shall adopt this Plan
pursuant to paragraph 5.
H. “Participant” shall mean each person (i) who is a participant in the Pension Plan on or after December 1, 2006, (ii) who is a
senior corporate officer of Cliffs or a full-time salaried employee of an Employer who has a Management Performance Incentive Plan Pay Band E or
above, and (iii) who as a result of participation in this Plan is entitled to a Supplemental Benefit under this Plan. Each person who is as a Participant
under this Plan shall be notified in writing of such fact by his Employer, which shall also cause a copy of the Plan to be delivered to such person.
I. “Pension Plan” shall mean, with respect to any Participant, the defined benefit plan specified on Exhibit A hereto in which he
participates.
J. “Supplemental Agreement” shall mean, with respect to any Participant, an agreement between the Participant and an Employer,
and approved by Cliffs if it is not the Employer, which provides for additional service credit and/or other features for purposes of computing retirement
benefits.
K. “Supplemental Benefit” or “Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit” shall mean a retirement benefit determined as provided in
paragraph 2.
L. “Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan” or “Plan” shall mean this Plan, as the same may hereafter be amended or restated from
time to time.
M. ”Termination of Employment ” shall mean the “separation from service” for purposes of Section 409A of the Code of any
Participant or former Participant from his Employer, generally including the severance of such employee’s employment relationship with his Employer for
any reason, voluntarily or involuntarily, and with or without cause, including without limitation, quit, discharge, retirement, disability, death, failure to return
to active employment at the end of a leave of absence (including military leave, sick leave, or other bona fide leave of absence) or permanent decrease in
service to his Employer to a level that is no more than twenty percent (20%) of its prior level, as described below. For this purpose, whether a separation
from service has occurred is determined based on whether it is reasonably anticipated that no further services will be performed by such employee after
a certain date or that the level of bona fide services the employee will perform after such date (whether as an employee or as an independent contractor)
would permanently decrease to no more than twenty percent (20%) of the average level of bona fide services performed (whether as an employee or an
independent contractor) over the immediately preceding thirty-six (36) month period (or the full period of services if the employee has been providing
services for less than thirty-six (36) months). For purposes of this definition, the term “Employer” shall mean the Employer of the Participant and any
other entity that is treated as a single employer with such Employer under Section 414(b) and (c) of the Code, provided that in such Code Sections “50%”
shall be used wherever “80%” appears. The preceding rule shall only apply during the periods any such corporation, business organization or member
would be so considered under Section 414(b) or 414(c) of the Code. The transfer of an
4
-- 192 of 411 --
employee from the Employer for whom he provides services to any entity that is an Employer within the meaning of the preceding two sentences (or vice
versa) shall not constitute a Termination of Employment for purposes of this Plan.
2. Determination of the Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit . Each Participant or Beneficiary of a deceased Participant whose benefits under the
Pension Plan payable or accrued on or after January 1, 1995 are reduced (a) due to the Code Limitations, or (b) due to deferrals of compensation by such
Participant under the 2005 Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. Voluntary Non-Qualified Deferred Compensation Plan (the “Deferred Compensation Plan”), and each
Participant who has entered into a Supplemental Agreement with his Employer (and, where applicable a Beneficiary of a deceased Participant), shall be entitled
to a Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit if he should have a Termination of Employment at a time when he is vested in his benefit under the Pension Plan. The
amount of the Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit at any time shall be a monthly retirement benefit equal to the difference between:
(i) the amount of the monthly benefit payable or accrued to the Participant or his Beneficiary under the Pension Plan, determined under
the Pension Plan as in effect at such time, but calculated without regard to any reduction in the Participant’s compensation pursuant to the
Deferred Compensation Plan, and as if the Pension Plan did not contain a provision (including any phase-in or extended wear away provision)
implementing the Code Limitations, and after giving effect to the provisions of any Supplemental Agreement, and
(ii) the sum of (X) the amount of the monthly benefit in fact payable or accrued to the Participant or his Beneficiary under the Pension
Plan and (Y) the sum of the Supplemental Pension Plan Benefits previously paid out to the Participant.
3. Payment of the Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit .
A. A Participant’s (or his Beneficiary’s) vested Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit (calculated as provided in paragraph 2) shall be
converted, six (6) months after Termination of Employment into a lump sum of equivalent actuarial value. The equivalent actuarial value shall be determined
by the actuary selected by Cliffs based on the “Applicable Mortality Table” used from time to time under Section 417(e) of the Code and other factors then in
effect for purposes of the Pension Plan.
B. A Participant’s vested Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit shall be distributed to the Participant the first day of the month following six (6)
months after Termination of Employment in the form of a lump sum payment. Plan Participants as of December 1, 2006 may elect prior to December 31,
2006 to receive payment of vested Plan benefits in ten (10) annual installments commencing the first day of the month following six (6) months after
Termination of Employment by completing a Benefit Payment Election Form. A person who becomes a Participant of the Plan on or after December 1, 2006
has the right to elect payment of his or her vested Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit in ten (10) annual installments commencing the first day of the month
following six (6) months after Termination of Employment by completing a Benefit Payment Election Form within thirty (30) days from the day in which the
person became eligible to participate in the Plan. The ten (10) annual installments shall be actuarially equivalent to the lump sum payment using the same
actuarial assumptions as used in subparagraph A of this paragraph and shall be considered to be a single form of payment.
C. Notwithstanding subparagraph B of this paragraph, a Participant may elect after the timeframes set forth above to change the form of
payment in effect with respect to the Participant’s Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit, provided that such new election is made no later than six (6) months
prior to his Termination of Employment, may not take effect for twelve (12) months
5
-- 193 of 411 --
after the election is made and shall result in the deferral of Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit payments for five (5) years from the previously applicable time
or commencement date of payment.
D. A Beneficiary of a Participant shall receive the vested Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit provided in paragraph 2 if the Participant dies
prior to his or her Termination of Employment but after he is vested in his accrued benefit under the Pension Plan. Such vested benefit shall be paid in a
single lump sum within 60 days following the date of death. If the Participant dies after his or her Termination of Employment, the Beneficiary shall receive
any remaining vested Supplemental Pension Plan Benefit not paid to the Participant at the time of death, which shall be paid within 60 days of death.
4. General.
A. (1) The entire cost of this Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan shall be paid from the general assets of one or more of the
Employers. It is the intent of the Employers to so pay benefits under the Plan as they become due; provided, however, that Cliffs may, in its sole discretion,
establish or cause to be established a trust account for any or each Participant pursuant to an agreement, or agreements, with a bank and direct that some or all
of a Participant’s benefits under the Plan be paid from the general assets of his Employer which are transferred to the custody of such bank to be held by it in
such trust account as property of the Employer subject to the claims of the Employer’s creditors until such time as benefit payments pursuant to the Plan are
made from such assets in accordance with such agreement; and until any such payment is made, neither the Plan nor any Participant or Beneficiary shall have
any preferred claim on, or any beneficial ownership interest in, such assets. No liability for the payment of benefits under the Plan shall be imposed upon any
officer, director, employee, or stockholder of Cliffs or other Employer.
(2) Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 4.A.(1), upon the earlier to occur of (a) a Change in Control of Cliffs (for purposes of
the Plan the term “Change in Control” shall have the meaning set forth in the Deferred Compensation Plan or any successor thereto) or (b) a declaration by the
Board of Directors of Cliffs (the “Board”) that a Change in Control is imminent, Cliffs shall promptly, to the extent it has not previously done so, and in any event
within five (5) business days, transfer to KeyTrust Company of Ohio, N.A., as trustee (“Trustee”) of Trust Agreement No. 7 (“Trust Agreement No. 7”) dated April
9, 1991, as amended, between the Trustee and Cliffs, a sum equal to (aa) the present value on the date of the Change in Control (or on such fifth (5th) business
day if the Board has declared a Change in Control to be imminent) of the payments to be made to the Participants under this Plan, such present value to be
computed using the assumptions and factors used in the Plan, less (bb) the (balance in the Participant’s account provided for in Section 7(b) of Trust
Agreement No. 7) as of the most recent completed valuation thereof, as certified by the Trustee under Trust Agreement No. 7; provided, however, that if the
Trustee does not so certify by the end of the fourth (4th) business day after the earlier of such Change in Control or declaration, then the balance of such
account shall be deemed to be zero. Any payments of benefits by the Trustee pursuant to Trust Agreement No. 7 shall, to the extent thereof, satisfy Cliffs’
obligation to pay benefits hereunder, it being the intent of Cliffs that assets in such Trust be held, subject to the claims of Cliffs’ creditors, to assist Cliffs in
meeting its obligation to pay benefits under this Plan. Notwithstanding the foregoing, no transfer of assets to Trust Agreement No. 7 or any other such trust or
funding vehicle shall be made if such transfer would violate the terms of Section 409A(b)(2) or (b)(3) of the Code.
B. No right or interest of a Participant or his Beneficiary under this Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan shall be anticipated, assigned
(either at law or in equity) or alienated by the Participant or his Beneficiary, nor shall any such right or interest be subject to attachment, garnishment, levy,
execution or other legal or equitable process or in any manner be liable for or subject to the debts of any Participant or Beneficiary. If any Participant or
Beneficiary shall attempt to or shall alienate, sell, transfer, assign, pledge or otherwise encumber his benefits under the Plan or any part thereof, or if by
reason of his bankruptcy or other event happening at any time such benefits
6
-- 194 of 411 --
would devolve upon anyone else or would not be enjoyed by him, then Cliffs may terminate his interest in any such benefit and hold or apply it to or for his
benefit or the benefit of his spouse, children or other person or persons in fact dependent upon him, or any of them, in the manner and at the time it otherwise
would have been paid under the Plan.
C. Employment rights shall not be enlarged or affected hereby. The Employers shall continue to have the right to discharge or retire a
Participant, with or without cause.
D. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Plan to the contrary, if Cliffs determines that any Participant may not qualify as a
“management or highly compensated employee” within the meaning of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended (“ERISA”), or
regulations thereunder, Cliffs may determine, in its sole discretion, that such Participant shall cease to be eligible to accrue further benefits under this Plan.
The Participant’s then accrued Supplemental Benefit shall be held under the Plan to be paid in accordance with Section 3 hereof.
5. Adoption of Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan . Any member of the Controlled Group or any Affiliate which is an employer under the
Pension Plan may become an Employer hereunder with the written consent of Cliffs if such member or such Affiliate executes an instrument evidencing its
adoption of the Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan and files a copy thereof with Cliffs. Such instrument of adoption may be subject to such terms and
conditions as Cliffs requires or approves.
6. Miscellaneous. A. The Plan shall be administered by the plan administrator (the “Administrator”). The Administrator shall have the sole and
absolute discretion to interpret the provisions of the Plan (including, without limitation, by supplying omissions from, correcting deficiencies in, or resolving
inconsistencies or ambiguities in, the language of the Plan), to make factual findings with respect to any issue arising under the Plan, to determine the rights and
status under the Plan of Participants and other persons, to decide disputes arising under the Plan and to make any determinations and findings (including
factual findings) with respect to the benefits payable thereunder and the persons entitled thereto as may be required for the purposes of the Plan. In furtherance
thereof, but without limiting the foregoing, the Administrator is hereby granted the following specific authorities, which it shall discharge in its sole and absolute
discretion in accordance with the terms of the Plan (as interpreted, to the extent necessary, by the Administrator):
(i) To resolve all questions (including factual questions) arising under the provisions of the Plan as to any individual’s
entitlement to become a Participant;
(ii) to determine the amount of benefits, if any, payable to any person under the Plan (including to the extent necessary,
making factual findings with respect thereto); and
(iii) to conduct the review procedures specified in paragraph 6.D.
All decisions of the Administrator as to the facts of any case, and the application thereof to any case, as to the interpretation of any provision of the Plan or its
application to any case, and as to any other interpretative matter or other determination or question under the Plan shall be final and binding on all parties
affected thereby. The Administrator may, from time to time, employ agents and delegate to them such administrative duties as it sees fit, and may from time to
time consult with legal counsel who may be counsel to Cliffs. All elections, notices and directions under the Plan by a Participant shall be made on such forms
as the Administrator shall prescribe.
B. Cliffs shall be the “Administrator” and the “Plan Sponsor” under the Plan for purposes of ERISA.
7
-- 195 of 411 --
C. Except to the extent federal law controls, all questions pertaining to the construction, validity and effect of the provisions hereof shall be
determined in accordance with the laws of the State of Ohio.
D. Whenever there is denied, whether in whole or in part, a claim for benefits under the Plan filed by any person (herein referred to as the
“Claimant”), the Administrator shall transmit a written notice of such decision to the Claimant, which notice shall be written in a manner calculated to be
understood by the Claimant and shall contain a statement of the specific reasons for the denial of the claim and a statement advising the Claimant that, within
60 days of the date on which he receives such notice, he may obtain review of such decision in accordance with the procedures hereinafter set forth. Within
such 60-day period, the Claimant or his authorized representative may request that the claim denial be reviewed by filing with the Administrator a written request
therefor, which request shall contain the following information:
(i) the date on which the Claimant’s request was filed with the Administrator; provided, however, that the date on which the
Claimant’s request for review was in fact filed with the Administrator shall control in the event that the date of the actual filing is later than the
date stated by the Claimant pursuant to this paragraph;
(ii) the specific portions of the denial of his claim which the Claimant requests the Administrator to review;
(iii) a statement by the Claimant setting forth the basis upon which he believes the Administrator should reverse the previous
denial of his claim for benefits and accept his claim as made; and
(iv) any written material (offered as exhibits) which the Claimant desires the Administrator to examine in its consideration of his
position as stated pursuant to clause (iii) above.
Within 60 days of the date determined pursuant to clause (i) above, the Administrator shall conduct a full and fair review of the decision denying the Claimant’s
claim for benefits, and shall render a written decision with respect to the claim, written in a manner calculated to be understood by the Claimant, specifying the
reasons for its decision and the Plan provisions upon which its decision was based.
E. Supplemental Pension Plan Benefits shall be subject to applicable withholding and such other deductions as shall at the time of payment be
required or appropriate under any Federal, State or Local law.
7. Amendment and Termination . A. Cliffs has reserved and does hereby reserve the right to amend, at any time, any or all of the provisions of the
Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan for all Employers, without the consent of any other Employer or any Participant, Beneficiary or any other person. Any
such amendment shall be expressed in an instrument executed by Cliffs and shall become effective as of the date designated in such instrument or, if no such
date is specified, on the date of its execution.
B. Cliffs, on behalf of itself and of each Employer, in its sole discretion, may terminate this Plan at any time and for any reason whatsoever. In the
event Cliffs elects to terminate the Plan as provided in this Section, no distribution of Supplemental Pension Plan Benefits or payment of benefits shall occur as
a result, except as otherwise provided in an amendment to this Plan, including without limitation an amendment to the Plan for the liquidation and termination of
the Plan where:
8
-- 196 of 411 --
(i) the termination and liquidation does not occur proximate to a downturn in the financial health of the Company and Affiliates;
(ii) the Plan and all arrangements required to be aggregated with the Plan under Section 409A of the Code are terminated and
liquidated;
(iii) no payments, other than those that would be payable under the terms of the Plan and the aggregated arrangements if the
termination and liquidation had not occurred, are made within twelve (12) months of the date the Company takes all necessary action to
irrevocably terminate and liquidate the Plan;
(iv) all payments are made within twenty-four (24) months of the date the Company takes all necessary action to irrevocably
terminate and liquidate the Plan; and
(v) the Company or Subsidiaries do not adopt a new arrangement that would be aggregated with any terminated arrangement
under Section 409A of the Code, at any time within three (3) years following the date of the date the Company takes all necessary action to
irrevocably terminate and liquidate the Plan.
C. Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions hereof, no amendment or termination of the Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan shall, without the
consent of the Participant, adversely affect the accrued benefit under the Plan of such Participant.
D. Any other Employer which shall have adopted the Plan may, with the written consent of Cliffs, elect separately to withdraw from the Plan and,
subject to subparagraph B above, such withdrawal shall constitute a termination of the Plan as to it, but it shall continue to be an Employer for the purposes
hereof as to Participants and Beneficiaries to whom it owes obligations hereunder. Any such withdrawal and termination shall be expressed in an instrument
executed by the terminating Employer and shall become effective as of the date designated in such instrument, or if no date is specified, on the date of its
execution.
8. Effective Date. The amended and restated Supplemental Retirement Benefit Plan shall be effective as of October 26, 2021.
9
-- 197 of 411 --
Exhibit A
Pension Plans
Pension Plan for Salaried Employees of the Cleveland-Cliffs Inc and its Associated Employers
Ore Mining Companies Pension Plan
10
-- 198 of 411 --
Exhibit 21
CLEVELAND-CLIFFS INC.
SUBSIDIARIES
AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2021
Name Place of Incorporation or Organization
Cannon Automotive Solutions - Bowling Green, Inc. Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Burns Harbor LLC Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Cleveland Works LLC Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Columbus LLC Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs FPT Services Company Ohio
Cleveland-Cliffs Investments Inc. Ohio
Cleveland-Cliffs Kote Inc. Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Kote L.P. Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Minorca Mine Inc. Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Monessen Coke LLC Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Plate LLC Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Railways Inc. Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Riverdale LLC Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Services Holding Company Ohio
Cleveland-Cliffs South Chicago & Indiana Harbor Railway Inc. Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Corporation Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Holding Corporation Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Holdings Inc. Ohio
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel LLC Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Management Inc. Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Properties Inc. Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Steelton LLC Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Steelworks Railway Inc. Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Tek Inc. Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Tek Kote Acquisition Corporation Ohio
Cleveland-Cliffs Tek L.P. Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Tooling and Stamping Company Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Tooling and Stamping Holdings LLC Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Tubular Components LLC Delaware
Cleveland-Cliffs Weirton LLC Delaware
Cliffs Mining Company Delaware
Cliffs Minnesota Mining Company Delaware
Cliffs Steel Inc. Ohio
Cliffs TIOP Holding, LLC Delaware
Cliffs TIOP, Inc. Michigan
Cliffs TIOP II, LLC Delaware
Cliffs UTAC Holding LLC Delaware
-- 199 of 411 --
Name Place of Incorporation or Organization
Ferrous Processing and Trading Company Michigan
Fleetwood Metal Industries, LLC Delaware
FPT Cleveland, LLC Michigan
IronUnits LLC Delaware
Lake Superior & Ishpeming Railroad Company Michigan
Metallics Sales Company Delaware
Mid-Vol Coal Sales, Inc. West Virginia
Mountain State Carbon, LLC Delaware
Northshore Mining Company Delaware
Silver Bay Power Company Delaware
SNA Carbon, LLC Delaware
The Cleveland-Cliffs Iron Company Ohio
Tilden Mining Company L.C. Michigan
United Taconite LLC Delaware
-- 200 of 411 --
EXHIBIT 22
The following entities are included in the obligated group as of December 31, 2021, as defined in the Annual Report on Form 10-K of Cleveland Cliffs Inc. to
which this document is being filed as an exhibit, including Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., as the parent and issuer, and the subsidiary guarantors that have guaranteed
the obligations under the 6.750% 2026 Senior Secured Notes, the 5.875% 2027 Senior Notes, the 7.000% 2027 Senior Notes, the 9.875% 2025 Senior
Secured Notes, the 4.625% 2029 Senior Notes and the 4.875% 2031 Senior Notes issued by Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
Exact Name of Issuer or Guarantor Subsidiary (1) (2) State of Incorporation or
Organization IRS Employer
Identification Number
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. Ohio 34-1464672
Cannon Automotive Solutions - Bowling Green, Inc. Delaware 26-0766559
Cleveland-Cliffs Burns Harbor LLC Delaware 20-0653414
Cleveland-Cliffs Cleveland Works LLC Delaware 04-3634649
Cleveland-Cliffs Columbus LLC Delaware 01-0807137
Cleveland-Cliffs Investments Inc. Ohio 31-1283531
Cleveland-Cliffs Kote Inc. Delaware 36-3665216
Cleveland-Cliffs Kote L.P. Delaware 36-3665288
Cleveland-Cliffs Minorca Mine Inc. Delaware 36-2814042
Cleveland-Cliffs Monessen Coke LLC Delaware 25-1850170
Cleveland-Cliffs Plate LLC Delaware 20-0653500
Cleveland-Cliffs Railways Inc. Delaware 56-2348283
Cleveland-Cliffs Riverdale LLC Delaware 74-3062732
Cleveland-Cliffs South Chicago & Indiana Harbor Railway Inc. Delaware 04-3634638
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Corporation Delaware 31-1267098
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Holding Corporation Delaware 31-1401455
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Holdings Inc. Ohio 85-4084783
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel LLC Delaware 71-0871875
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Management Inc. Delaware 51-0390893
Cleveland-Cliffs Steel Properties Inc. Delaware 51-0390894
Cleveland-Cliffs Steelton LLC Delaware 20-0653772
Cleveland-Cliffs Steelworks Railway Inc. Delaware 04-3634622
Cleveland-Cliffs Tek Inc. Delaware 36-3519946
Cleveland-Cliffs Tek Kote Acquisition Corporation Ohio 85-4304182
Cleveland-Cliffs Tek L.P. Delaware 363525438
Cleveland-Cliffs Tooling and Stamping Company Delaware 22-3639336
Cleveland-Cliffs Tooling and Stamping Holdings LLC Delaware 31-1283531
Cleveland-Cliffs Tubular Components LLC Delaware 31-1283531
Cleveland-Cliffs Weirton LLC Delaware 56-2435202
Cliffs Mining Company Delaware 34-1120353
Cliffs Minnesota Mining Company Delaware 42-1609117
Cliffs Steel Inc. Ohio 87-3972693
Cliffs TIOP Holding, LLC Delaware 47-2182060
Cliffs TIOP, Inc. Michigan 34-1371049
Cliffs TIOP II, LLC Delaware 61-1857848
Cliffs UTAC Holding LLC Delaware 26-2895214
Fleetwood Metal Industries, LLC Delaware 98-0508950
IronUnits LLC Delaware 34-1920747
Lake Superior & Ishpeming Railroad Company Michigan 38-6005761
Metallics Sales Company Delaware 84-2076079
Mid-Vol Coal Sales, Inc. West Virginia 55-0761501
Mountain State Carbon, LLC Delaware 31-1267098
-- 201 of 411 --
EXHIBIT 22
Exact Name of Issuer or Guarantor Subsidiary (1) (2) State of Incorporation or
Organization IRS Employer
Identification Number
Northshore Mining Company Delaware 84-1116857
Silver Bay Power Company Delaware 84-1126359
SNA Carbon, LLC Delaware 31-1267098
The Cleveland-Cliffs Iron Company Ohio 34-0677332
Tilden Mining Company L.C. Michigan 34-1804848
United Taconite LLC Delaware 42-1609118
(1) The address and phone number of each issuer and guarantor subsidiary is c/o Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., 200 Public Square, Suite 3300, Cleveland, Ohio 44114, (216) 694-5700.
(2) Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. is the issuer, all other entities listed are guarantor subsidiaries.
-- 202 of 411 --
Exhibit 23.1
Consent of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm
We consent to the incorporation by reference in:
Registration Statement No. 333-237324 on Form S-3;
Registration Statement No. 333-184620 on Form S-8 pertaining to the Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. 2012 Incentive Equity Plan;
Registration Statement No. 333-197687 on Form S-8 pertaining to the Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. Amended and Restated 2012 Incentive Equity
Plan;
Registration Statement No. 333-197688 on Form S-8 pertaining to the Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. 2014 Nonemployee Directors’ Compensation
Plan;
Registration Statement No. 333-204369 on Form S-8 pertaining to the Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. 2015 Equity and Incentive Compensation Plan;
Registration Statement No. 333-210954 on Form S-8 pertaining to the Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. Amended and Restated 2014 Nonemployee
Directors’ Compensation Plan;
Registration Statement No. 333-217506 on Form S-8 pertaining to the Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. Amended and Restated 2015 Equity and
Incentive Compensation Plan;
Registration Statement No. 333-237144 on Form S-8 pertaining to the Cliffs Natural Resources Inc. Amended and Restated 2015 Equity and
Incentive Compensation Plan;
Registration Statement No. 333-255571 on Form S-8 pertaining to the Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. 2021 Nonemployee Directors’ Compensation Plan; and
Registration Statement No. 333-255572 on Form S-8 pertaining to the Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. 2021 Equity and Incentive Compensation Plan
of our reports dated February 11, 2022, relating to the financial statements of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. and the effectiveness of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.’s internal control
over financial reporting, appearing in this Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2021.
/s/ DELOITTE & TOUCHE LLP
Cleveland, Ohio
February 11, 2022
-- 203 of 411 --
EXHIBIT 23.6
SLR International Corporation
22118 20 Ave SE, Suite G202, Bothell, WA 98021 USA
February 10, 2022
CONSENT OF QUALIFIED PERSON
Re: Form 10-K of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (the “Company”)
SLR Internaonal Corporaon (“SLR”), in connecon with the Company’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2021 (the
“Form 10-K”), consents to:
• the public filing by the Company and use of the technical report tled “Technical Report Summary on the Tilden Property, Michigan, USA” (the
“Technical Report Summary”), with an effecve date of December 31, 2021 and dated February 7, 2022, that was prepared in accordance with
Subpart 1300 of Regulation S-K promulgated by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, as an exhibit to and referenced in the Form 10-K;
• the incorporaon by reference of the Technical Report Summary into the Company’s Registraon Statement on Form S-3 (Registraon No. 333-
237324) and Registraon Statements on Form S-8 (Registraon Nos. 333-255571, 333-255572, 333-237144, 333-217506, 333-210954, 333-
204369, 333-197687, 333-197688 and 333-184620) (collectively, the “Registration Statements”);
• the use of and references to our name, including our status as an expert or “qualified person” (as defined in Subpart 1300 of Regulaon S-K
promulgated by the U.S. Securies and Exchange Commission), in connecon with the Form 10-K, the Registraon Statements and the Technical
Report Summary; and
• any extracts from or a summary of the Technical Report Summary in the Form 10-K and incorporated by reference in the Registraon
Statements and the use of any informaon derived, summarized, quoted, or referenced from the Technical Report Summary, or porons
thereof, that was prepared by us, that we supervised the preparaon of, and/or that was reviewed and approved by us, that is included or
incorporated by reference in the Form 10-K and the Registration Statements.
SLR is responsible for authoring, and this consent pertains to, the Technical Report Summary. SLR cerfies that it has read the Form 10-K and that it
fairly and accurately represents the information in the Technical Report Summary for which it is responsible.
SLR International Corporation
Per:
(Signed) Richard J. Lambert
Richard J. Lambert, P.E., P.Eng.
Global Technical Director
Technical Director, Mining Advisory US
th
www.slrconsulting.com
-- 204 of 411 --
Exhibit 24
POWER OF ATTORNEY
KNOW ALL PEOPLE BY THESE PRESENTS, that the undersigned Directors and officers of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., an Ohio corporation ("Company"),
hereby constitute and appoint C. Lourenco Goncalves, Celso L. Goncalves Jr., James D. Graham and Kimberly A. Floriani, and each of them, their true and
lawful attorney or attorneys-in-fact, with full power of substitution and revocation, for them and in their name, place and stead, to sign on their behalf as a
Director or officer of the Company, or both, as the case may be, an Annual Report on Form 10-K pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act
of 1934 for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2021, and to sign any and all amendments to such Annual Report, and to file the same, with all exhibits thereto,
and other documents in connection therewith, with the Securities and Exchange Commission, granting unto said attorney or attorneys-in-fact, and each of them,
full power and authority to do and perform each and every act and thing requisite and necessary to be done in and about the premises, as fully to all intents and
purposes as they might or could do in person, hereby ratifying and confirming all that said attorney or attorneys-in-fact or any of them or their substitute or
substitutes, may lawfully do or cause to be done by virtue hereof.
Executed as of the 10 day of February, 2022.
/s/ C. L. Goncalves /s/ C. L. Goncalves Jr.
C. L. Goncalves,
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer
C. L. Goncalves Jr.,
Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer
/s/ K. A. Floriani /s/ J. T. Baldwin
K. A. Floriani,
Senior Vice President, Controller & Chief Accounting Officer
J. T. Baldwin, Director
/s/ R. P. Fisher, Jr. /s/ W. K. Gerber
R. P. Fisher, Jr., Director W. K. Gerber, Director
/s/ S. M. Green /s/ R. S. Michael, III
S. M. Green, Director R. S. Michael, III, Director
/s/ J. L. Miller /s/ G. Stoliar
J. L. Miller, Director G. Stoliar, Director
/s/ D. C. Taylor /s/ A. M. Yocum
D. C. Taylor, Director A. M. Yocum, Director
th
-- 205 of 411 --
Exhibit 31.1
CERTIFICATION
I, Lourenco Goncalves, certify that:
1. I have reviewed this annual report on Form 10-K of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.;
2. Based on my knowledge, this report does not contain any untrue statement of a material fact or omit to state a material fact necessary to make the
statements made, in light of the circumstances under which such statements were made, not misleading with respect to the period covered by this
report;
3. Based on my knowledge, the financial statements, and other financial information included in this report, fairly present in all material respects the
financial condition, results of operations and cash flows of the registrant as of, and for, the periods presented in this report;
4. The registrant's other certifying officer and I are responsible for establishing and maintaining disclosure controls and procedures (as defined in
Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(e) and 15d-15(e)) and internal control over financial reporting (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(f) and 15d-15(f)),
for the registrant and have:
(a) Designed such disclosure controls and procedures, or caused such disclosure controls and procedures to be designed under our supervision,
to ensure that material information relating to the registrant, including its consolidated subsidiaries, is made known to us by others within
those entities, particularly during the period in which this report is being prepared;
(b) Designed such internal control over financial reporting, or caused such internal control over financial reporting to be designed under our
supervision, to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation of financial statements for
external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles;
(c) Evaluated the effectiveness of the registrant's disclosure controls and procedures and presented in this report our conclusions about the
effectiveness of the disclosure controls and procedures, as of the end of the period covered by this report based on such evaluation; and
(d) Disclosed in this report any change in the registrant’s internal control over financial reporting that occurred during the registrant’s most recent
fiscal quarter (the registrant’s fourth fiscal quarter in the case of an annual report) that has materially affected or is reasonably likely to
materially affect the registrant’s internal control over financial reporting; and
5. The registrant's other certifying officer and I have disclosed, based on our most recent evaluation of internal control over financial reporting, to the
registrant's auditors and the audit committee of the registrant's board of directors (or persons performing the equivalent functions):
(a) All significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in the design or operation of internal control over financial reporting which are
reasonably likely to adversely affect the registrant's ability to record, process, summarize and report financial information; and
(b) Any fraud, whether or not material, that involves management or other employees who have a significant role in the registrant's internal
control over financial reporting.
Date: February 11, 2022 By: /s/ Lourenco Goncalves
Lourenco Goncalves
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer
-- 206 of 411 --
Exhibit 31.2
CERTIFICATION
I, Celso L. Goncalves Jr., certify that:
1. I have reviewed this annual report on Form 10-K of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.;
2. Based on my knowledge, this report does not contain any untrue statement of a material fact or omit to state a material fact necessary to make the
statements made, in light of the circumstances under which such statements were made, not misleading with respect to the period covered by this
report;
3. Based on my knowledge, the financial statements, and other financial information included in this report, fairly present in all material respects the
financial condition, results of operations and cash flows of the registrant as of, and for, the periods presented in this report;
4. The registrant's other certifying officer and I are responsible for establishing and maintaining disclosure controls and procedures (as defined in
Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(e) and 15d-15(e)) and internal control over financial reporting (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(f) and 15d-15(f)),
for the registrant and have:
(a) Designed such disclosure controls and procedures, or caused such disclosure controls and procedures to be designed under our supervision,
to ensure that material information relating to the registrant, including its consolidated subsidiaries, is made known to us by others within
those entities, particularly during the period in which this report is being prepared;
(b) Designed such internal control over financial reporting, or caused such internal control over financial reporting to be designed under our
supervision, to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation of financial statements for
external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles;
(c) Evaluated the effectiveness of the registrant's disclosure controls and procedures and presented in this report our conclusions about the
effectiveness of the disclosure controls and procedures, as of the end of the period covered by this report based on such evaluation; and
(d) Disclosed in this report any change in the registrant’s internal control over financial reporting that occurred during the registrant’s most recent
fiscal quarter (the registrant’s fourth fiscal quarter in the case of an annual report) that has materially affected or is reasonably likely to
materially affect the registrant’s internal control over financial reporting; and
5. The registrant's other certifying officer and I have disclosed, based on our most recent evaluation of internal control over financial reporting, to the
registrant's auditors and the audit committee of the registrant's board of directors (or persons performing the equivalent functions):
(a) All significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in the design or operation of internal control over financial reporting which are
reasonably likely to adversely affect the registrant's ability to record, process, summarize and report financial information; and
(b) Any fraud, whether or not material, that involves management or other employees who have a significant role in the registrant's internal
control over financial reporting.
Date: February 11, 2022 By: /s/ Celso L. Goncalves Jr.
Celso L. Goncalves Jr.
Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer
-- 207 of 411 --
Exhibit 32.1
CERTIFICATION PURSUANT TO
18 U.S.C. SECTION 1350,
AS ADOPTED PURSUANT TO
SECTION 906 OF THE SARBANES-OXLEY ACT OF 2002
In connection with the Annual Report of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (the “Company”) on Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2021, as filed with the
Securities and Exchange Commission on the date hereof (the “Form 10-K”), I, Lourenco Goncalves, Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer of the
Company, certify, pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Section 1350, as adopted pursuant to Section 906 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, that, to such officer’s knowledge:
(1) The Form 10-K fully complies with the requirements of Section 13(a) or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C. 78m or
78o(d)); and
(2) The information contained in the Form 10-K fairly presents, in all material respects, the financial condition and results of operations of the
Company as of the dates and for the periods expressed in the Form 10-K.
Date: February 11, 2022
By: /s/ Lourenco Goncalves
Lourenco Goncalves
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer
-- 208 of 411 --
Exhibit 32.2
CERTIFICATION PURSUANT TO
18 U.S.C. SECTION 1350,
AS ADOPTED PURSUANT TO
SECTION 906 OF THE SARBANES-OXLEY ACT OF 2002
In connection with the Annual Report of Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (the “Company”) on Form 10-K for the period ended December 31, 2021, as filed with the
Securities and Exchange Commission on the date hereof (the “Form 10-K”), I, Celso L. Goncalves Jr., Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer of the
Company, certify, pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Section 1350, as adopted pursuant to Section 906 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, that, to such officer’s knowledge:
(1) The Form 10-K fully complies with the requirements of Section 13(a) or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C. 78m or
78o(d)); and
(2) The information contained in the Form 10-K fairly presents, in all material respects, the financial condition and results of operations of the
Company as of the dates and for the periods expressed in the Form 10-K.
Date: February 11, 2022
By: /s/ Celso L. Goncalves Jr.
Celso L. Goncalves Jr.
Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer
-- 209 of 411 --
Exhibit 95
Mine Safety Disclosures
The operation of our mines located in the United States is subject to regulation by MSHA under the FMSH Act. MSHA inspects these mines on a regular
basis and issues various citations and orders when it believes a violation has occurred under the FMSH Act. We present information below regarding certain
mining safety and health citations that MSHA has issued with respect to our mining operations. In evaluating this information, consideration should be given to
factors such as: (i) the number of citations and orders will vary depending on the size of the mine; (ii) the number of citations issued will vary from inspector to
inspector and mine to mine, and (iii) citations and orders can be contested and appealed and, in that process, are often reduced in severity and amount, and are
sometimes dismissed.
Under the Dodd-Frank Act, each operator of a coal or other mine is required to include certain mine safety results within its periodic reports filed with the
SEC. As required by the reporting requirements included in §1503(a) of the Dodd-Frank Act, we present the following items regarding certain mining safety and
health matters, for the period presented, for each of our mine locations that are covered under the scope of the Dodd-Frank Act:
(A) The total number of violations of mandatory health or safety standards that could significantly and substantially contribute to the cause and effect of
a coal or other mine safety or health hazard under section 104 of the FMSH Act (30 U.S.C. 814) for which the operator received a citation from
MSHA;
(B) The total number of orders issued under section 104(b) of the FMSH Act (30 U.S.C. 814(b));
(C) The total number of citations and orders for unwarrantable failure of the mine operator to comply with mandatory health or safety standards under
section 104(d) of the FMSH Act (30 U.S.C. 814(d));
(D) The total number of imminent danger orders issued under section 107(a) of the FMSH Act (30 U.S.C. 817(a));
(E) The total dollar value of proposed assessments from MSHA under the FMSH Act (30 U.S.C. 801 et seq.);
(F) Legal actions pending before the Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission involving such coal or other mine as of the last day of the
period;
(G) Legal actions instituted before the Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission involving such coal or other mine during the period; and
(H) Legal actions resolved before the Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission involving such coal or other mine during the period.
During the year ended December 31, 2021, our mine locations did not receive any flagrant violations under Section 110(b)(2) of the FMSH Act (30 U.S.C.
820(b)(2)) and did not receive any written notices of a pattern of violations, or the potential to have a pattern of such violations, under section 104(e) of the
FMSH Act (30 U.S.C. 814(e)). In addition, there were no mining-related fatalities at any of our mine locations during this same period.
-- 210 of 411 --
Following is a summary of the information described above for the year ended December 31, 2021:
Year Ended December 31, 2021
(A) (B) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G) (H)
Mine Name/ MSHA ID No. Operation Section 104
S&S Citations Section 104(b)
Orders Section 104(d)
Orders
Section 107(a)
Citations &
Orders
Total Dollar
Value of MSHA
Proposed
Assessments
(1)
Legal Actions
Pending as of
Last Day of
Period
Legal Actions
Instituted
During Period
Legal Actions
Resolved
During Period
Tilden / 2000422 Iron Ore 23 — — — $ 680,113 1 (2) 3 2
Empire / 2001012 Iron Ore — — — — $ — — — —
Northshore Plant / 2100831 Iron Ore 17 — — — $ 51,193 5 (3) 4 3
Northshore Mine / 2100209 Iron Ore 3 — — — $ 2,352 — 1 1
United Taconite Plant / 2103404 Iron Ore 29 — — — $ 192,631 4 (4) 5 2
United Taconite Mine / 2103403 Iron Ore 3 — — — $ 5,736 2 (5) 2 —
Hibbing / 2101600 Iron Ore 15 — — — $ 25,445 1 (6) 5 7
Minorca Mine / 2102449 Iron Ore 16 — — — $ 194,792 1 (7) 6 5
AK Coal / North Fork / 3610041 Coal — — — — $ — — — 2
Coal Innovations #1 / 3609406 Coal — — — — $ — — — —
Virginia Point No. 1 Surface Mine / 4407172 Coal — — — — $ — — — —
Low Gap Surface Mine / 4605741 Coal — — — — $ — — — —
Eckman Surface Mine / 4608647 Coal 1 — — — $ 5,879 — — —
Redhawk Surface Mine / 4609300 Coal — — — — $ — — — —
Dry Branch Surface Mine / 4609395 Coal 4 — — — $ 21,425 — — —
Dans Branch Surface Mine / 4609517 Coal — — — — $ — — — —
Eckman Loadout / 4603341 Coal 1 — — — $ 875 — — —
Roadfork Loadout / 4608278 Coal 1 — — — $ 654 — — —
Eckman Plant / 4609357 Coal 2 — — — $ 2,565 — — 1
Mine No. 35 / 4608131 Coal — — — — $ — — — —
Mine No. 39 / 4609261 Coal 76 — — — $ 693,087 4 (8) 21 17
Mine No. 43 / 4609496 Coal 20 — — — $ 108,491 2 (9) 6 5
(1) Amounts included under the heading “Total Dollar Value of MSHA Proposed Assessments” are the total dollar amounts for proposed assessments received from MSHA on or before
December 31, 2021.
(2) This number consists of 1 pending legal action related to contests of proposed penalties referenced in Subpart C of FMSH Act's procedural rules.
(3) This number consists of 1 pending legal action related to contests of proposed penalties referenced in Subpart C of FMSH Act's procedural rules and 4 pending legal actions related to
appeals of judges' decisions or orders to the Federal Mine Safety and Health Review Commission referenced in Subpart H of FMSH Act's procedural rules.
(4) This number consists of 4 pending legal actions related to contests of proposed penalties referenced in Subpart C of FMSH Act's procedural rules.
(5) This number consists of 2 pending legal actions related to contests of proposed penalties referenced in Subpart C of FMSH Act's procedural rules.
(6) This number consists of 1 pending legal action related to contests of proposed penalties referenced in Subpart C of FMSH Act's procedural rules.
(7) This number consists of 1 pending legal action related to contests of proposed penalties referenced in Subpart C of FMSH Act's procedural rules.
(8) This number consists of 3 pending legal actions related to contests of proposed penalties referenced in Subpart C of FMSH Act's procedural rules and 1 pending legal action related to
complaints of discharge, discrimination, or interference referenced in Subpart E of FMSH Act's procedural rules.
(9) This number consists of 2 pending legal actions related to contests of proposed penalties referenced in Subpart C of FMSH Act's procedural rules.
-- 211 of 411 --
-- 212 of 411 --
Technical Report Summary on the
Tilden Property, Michigan, USA
S-K 1300 Report
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
February 7, 2022
Effective Date: December 31, 2021
-- 213 of 411 --
Technical Report Summary on the Tilden Property, Michigan, USA
SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Prepared by
SLR International Corporation
1658 Cole Blvd, Suite 100
Lakewood, CO 80401
for
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
200 Public Square, Suite 3300
Cleveland, OH 44114-2544
USA
Effective Date – December 31, 2021
Signature Date - February 7, 2022
FINAL
Distribution: 1 copy – Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
1 copy – SLR International Corporation
-- 214 of 411 --
CONTENTS
1.0 Executive Summary 1
1.1 Summary 1
1.2 Economic Analysis 5
1.3 Technical Summary 7
2.0 Introduction 17
2.1 Site Visits 17
2.2 Sources of Information 17
2.3 List of Abbreviations 19
3.0 Property Description 23
3.1 Property Location 23
3.2 Land Tenure 23
3.3 Encumbrances 28
3.4 Royalties 28
3.5 Other Significant Factors and Risks 28
4.0 Accessibility, Climate, Local Resources, Infrastructure and Physiography 29
4.1 Accessibility 29
4.2 Climate 29
4.3 Local Resources 29
4.4 Infrastructure 30
4.5 Physiography 30
5.0 History 32
5.1 Prior Ownership 32
5.2 Exploration and Development History 32
5.3 Historical Mineral Reserve Estimates 33
5.4 Past Production 33
6.0 Geological Setting, Mineralization, and Deposit 34
6.1 Regional Geology 34
6.2 Local Geology 36
6.3 Property Geology 38
-- 215 of 411 --
6.3 Property Geology 38
6.4 Deposit Types 43
7.0 Exploration 45
7.1 Exploration Drilling 45
7.2 Geological Mapping 50
7.3 Hydrogeology and Geotechnical Data 50
8.0 Sample Preparation, Analyses, and Security 51
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 i
-- 216 of 411 --
8.1 Sample Preparation and Analysis 51
8.2 Sample Security 57
8.3 Quality Assurance/Control Procedures 58
9.0 Data Verification 63
9.1 Site Verification Work 63
9.2 QP Verification Work 63
10.0 Mineral Processing and Metallurgical Testing 68
10.1 Historical Metallurgical Testing and Process Design 68
10.2 Sampling and Metallurgical Testing 68
10.3 Material Characterization and Classification 70
10.4 Factors Affecting Economic Extraction and Plant Performance 71
11.0 Mineral Resource Estimates 72
11.1 Summary 72
11.2 Resource Database 73
11.3 Geological Interpretation 73
11.4 Resource Assays 77
11.5 Compositing and Capping 77
11.6 Trend Analysis 81
11.7 Block Model 84
11.8 Estimation Methodology 84
11.9 Cut-off Grade 86
11.10 Classification 86
11.11 Model Validation 89
11.12 Model Reconciliation 94
11.13 Mineral Resource Statement 95
12.0 Mineral Reserve Estimate 97
12.1 Conversion Assumptions, Optimization Parameters, and Methods 97
12.2 Previous Mineral Reserve Estimates by Cliffs 100
12.3 Pit Optimization 101
-- 217 of 411 --
12.4 Mineral Reserve Cut-off Grade 106
12.5 Mine Design 106
13.0 Mining Methods 108
13.1 Mining Methods Overview 108
13.2 Pit Geotechnical 108
13.3 Open Pit Design 115
13.4 Production Schedule 122
13.5 Overburden and Waste Rock Stockpiles 124
13.6 Mining Fleet 127
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 ii
-- 218 of 411 --
13.7 Mine Manpower 128
14.0 Processing and Recovery Methods 129
14.1 Overview 129
14.2 Processing Methods 129
14.3 Pelletizing Plant 132
14.4 Major Equipment 134
14.5 Plant Performance 135
14.6 Pellet Quality 136
14.7 Consumable Requirements 136
14.8 Process Workforce 139
15.0 Infrastructure 140
15.1 Roads 140
15.2 Rail 140
15.3 Port Facilities 141
15.4 Tailings Disposal 141
15.5 Power 145
15.6 Natural Gas 146
15.7 Coal 147
15.8 Diesel and Propane 147
15.9 Communications 147
15.10 Water Supply 148
15.11 Support Facilities 149
16.0 Market Studies 152
16.1 Markets 152
16.2 Contracts 154
17.0 Environmental Studies, Permitting, and Plans, Negotiations, or Agreements with
Local Individuals or Groups
155
17.1 Environmental Studies 155
17.2 Environmental Requirements 155
17.3 Operating Permits and Status 157
-- 219 of 411 --
17.4 Mine Closure Plans and Bonds 159
17.5 Social and Community 159
18.0 Capital and Operating Costs 161
18.1 Capital Costs 161
18.2 Operating Costs 162
19.0 Economic Analysis 163
19.1 Economic Criteria 163
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 iii
-- 220 of 411 --
19.2 Cash Flow Analysis 164
19.3 Sensitivity Analysis 166
20.0 Adjacent Properties 168
21.0 Other Relevant Data and Information 169
22.0 Interpretation and Conclusions 170
22.1 Geology and Mineral Resources 170
22.2 Mining and Mineral Reserves 170
22.3 Mineral Processing 171
22.4 Infrastructure 171
22.5 Environment 171
23.0 Recommendations 172
23.1 Geology and Mineral Resources 172
23.2 Mining and Mineral Reserves 172
23.3 Mineral Processing 172
23.4 Infrastructure 173
24.0 References 174
25.0 Reliance on Information Provided by the Registrant 178
26.0 Date and Signature Page 179
27.0 Appendix 1 180
27.1 Geometallurgical Domains 180
TABLES
-- 221 of 411 --
Table 1-1: Technical-Economic Assumptions 5
Table 1-2: LOM Production Summary 5
Table 1-3: LOM Plant Production Summary 6
Table 1-4: LOM Indicative Economic Results 6
Table 1-5: Summary of Tilden Mineral Resources - December 31, 2021 10
Table 1-6: Summary of Tilden Mineral Reserves - December 31, 2021 10
Table 1-7: LOM Capital Costs 16
Table 1-8: LOM Operating Costs 16
Table 3-1: Land Tenure 26
Table 4-1: Ishpeming, MI Temperature and Precipitation 29
Table 4-2: Nearby Population Centers 30
Table 5-1: Historical Production 33
Table 6-1: Geometallurgical Groupings at Tilden 42
Table 7-1: Summary of the Tilden Mine Drill Hole Database 45
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 iv
-- 222 of 411 --
Table 8-1: Expected Values of and 2019 Performance of Principal Variables of Martite
Master Composite Samples 61
Table 9-1: Basic Statistics of Twinned Drill and Blast Hole Samples 64
Table 10-1: Material Type Specifications 71
Table 11-1: Summary of Tilden Mineral Resources – December 31, 2021 73
Table 11-2: Tilden Mine Mineral Resource Database 77
Table 11-3: Tilden Mine Composite Statistics 78
Table 11-4: Tilden Variogram Models 83
Table 11-5: Summary of Block Model Setup 84
Table 11-6: Search Strategy 85
Table 11-7: Whittle Pit Parameters 86
Table 11-8: Classification Criteria 87
Table 11-9: 2021 Model Reconciliation 94
Table 11-10: Summary of Mineral Resources – December 31, 2021 95
Table 12-1: Summary of Tilden Mineral Reserves – December 31, 2021 97
Table 12-2: Tilden Metallurgical Constraints 98
Table 12-3: Mineral Resource to Mineral Reserve Classification Criteria 100
Table 12-4: Previous Cliffs Mineral Reserves 101
Table 12-5: Pit Optimization Results 102
Table 12-6: Pit Optimization to Pit Design Comparison 106
Table 13-1: Pit Wall Geotechnical Parameters 109
Table 13-2: Summary of UCS and BTS Test Results 112
Table 13-3: Summary of Direct Shear Test Results 112
Table 13-4: Material Properties Used in Overall Slope Stability Analysis 113
Table 13-5: Anisotropic Material Properties Used in the Weak Direction 114
Table 13-6: Final Pit Design LOM Total - December 31, 2021 115
Table 13-7: LOM Production Schedule 123
Table 13-8: Stockpile Parameters 125
Table 13-9: Volumes and Capacities of Stockpile Designs 125
Table 13-10: Major Mining Equipment 127
-- 223 of 411 --
Table 14-1: Major Processing Equipment 134
Table 14-2: Tilden Concentrator Performance 2014 to 2020 135
Table 14-3: Hemflux Pellet Quality 136
Table 14-4: Consumables 138
Table 16-1: Five Year Historical Average Pricing 153
Table 16-2: Cliffs Consolidated Three-Year Trailing Average Wet Pellet Revenue 154
Table 17-1: List of Major Permits and Licenses 158
Table 18-1: LOM Capital Costs 161
Table 18-2: LOM Operating Costs 162
Table 18-3: Workforce Summary 162
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 v
-- 224 of 411 --
Table 19-1: Technical-Economic Assumptions 163
Table 19-2: LOM Production Summary 164
Table 19-3: LOM Plant Production Summary 164
Table 19-4: Life of Mine Indicative Economic Results 164
Table 19-5: NPV @ 10% Sensitivity Analysis 167
FIGURES
-- 225 of 411 --
Figure 3-1: Location Map 24
Figure 3-2: Mineral Title Boundaries 25
Figure 3-3: Surface Rights 27
Figure 6-1: Fe Formation Locations and Relevant Stratigraphy in the Lake Superior Region 35
Figure 6-2: Chronostratigraphic Column for the Tilden Mine 37
Figure 6-3: General Geology of the Marquette Range Supergroup and Tilden Mine
Location 38
Figure 6-4: West-Facing Cross-section at 26,083,620 ft E Showing Anticlinal Shape and
Geology of Tilden 40
Figure 6-5: Basic Stratigraphic Section Local to Tilden 41
Figure 6-6: Selected Geometallurgical (code1) Groupings and Sub-groupings at Tilden 43
Figure 7-1: Drill Hole Collar Location 47
Figure 8-1: Drill Hole Sample Preparation Process 53
Figure 8-2: Drill Core Bench Flotation Test Process 54
Figure 8-3: Least Squares Regression Plots of (A) Soluble Fe by Wet Chemistry versus
Density and (B) Soluble Fe Weight Calculated from Bench Flotation Products
versus Density 56
Figure 8-4: Comparison of Empire Immersion Tonnage Factor Regression Used in Tilden
Model and Other Density Studies 57
Figure 8-5: Example of Control Charting of the Monthly Martite Master Composite 59
Figure 8-6: Absolute Difference of Coarse Duplicate Pairs 60
Figure 9-1: Scatter Plot of Twinned Drill and Blast Hole Sample Pairs on confe, Colored by
consio2 Values 65
Figure 9-2: Scatter Plot of Twinned Drill Hole and Blast Hole Sample Pairs on conphos
Colored by Domain 66
Figure 11-1: Level 1000 of the Tilden Geological Model 75
Figure 11-2: Tilden Geological Model Cross-section 76
Figure 11-3: Histogram of Sample Length 78
Figure 11-4: Radial Plot, Experimental Variogram and Model for confe Within IFCB Main Pit
Carb (340) 82
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 vi
-- 226 of 411 --
Figure 11-5: Mineral Resource Classification 88
Figure 11-6: Comparison of OK and NN Estimates by Variable and Domain 90
Figure 11-7: Comparison of consio2 Drill and Blast Hole Composites with Estimated Blocks 91
Figure 11-8: Comparison of confe Drill and Blast Hole Composites with Estimated Blocks 92
Figure 11-9: Comparison of conphos Drill and Blast Hole Composites with Estimated Blocks 93
Figure 12-1: Wet Hemflux Pellet Calculated Versus Actual Production Variance 100
Figure 12-2: Tilden Mine Pit-by-Pit Graph 104
Figure 12-3: Final Pit Shell Superimposed Over Current Topography 105
Figure 13-1: Geotechnical Design Sector 5 Example Cross-section 110
Figure 13-2: Plan Map of Pit Slope Geotechnical Design Sectors 111
Figure 13-3: Final Pit Plan View 116
Figure 13-4: Example East Final Pit Cross-section Looking West 117
Figure 13-5: Example Middle Final Pit Cross-section Looking West 118
Figure 13-6: Example West Final Pit Cross-section Looking West 119
Figure 13-7: Intermediate Pit Phase Footprints 121
Figure 13-8: Past and Forecast LOM Production 124
Figure 13-9: Tilden Mine Stockpile Designs at Full Capacity 126
Figure 14-1: Hematite Circuit Process Flowsheet 131
Figure 14-2: Process Flowsheet for Pelletizing Plant 133
Figure 15-1: LS&I Railroad and Port 140
Figure 15-2: Gribben Tailings Basin 142
Figure 15-3: Regional Electrical Power Distribution 146
Figure 15-4: Regional Natural Gas Supply 147
Figure 15-5: Fresh Water Supply 148
Figure 15-6: Process Plant and Administration Offices 150
Figure 15-7: Mine Offices and Truck Shop 151
-- 227 of 411 --
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 vii
-- 228 of 411 --
1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1.1 Summary
SLR Internaonal Corporaon (SLR) was retained by Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (Cliffs) to prepare an independent Technical Report Summary (TRS) for the
Tilden Property (Tilden or the Property), located in Northern Michigan, USA.The owner of the Property, Tilden Mining Company L.C. (Tilden L.C.), is a
wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs.
The purpose of this TRS is to disclose year-end (YE) 2021 Mineral Resource and Mineral Reserve estimates for Tilden.
Cliffs is listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) and currently reports Mineral Reserves of pellezed ore in SEC filings.This TRS conforms to the
United States Securies and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) Modernized Property Disclosure Requirements for Mining Registrants as described in
Subpart 229.1300 of Regulaon S-K, Disclosure by Registrants Engaged in Mining Operaons (S-K 1300) and Item 601 (b)(96) Technical Report
Summary. SLR visited the Property on October 24, 2019 and January 20 to 24, 2020.
The Property includes the Tilden Mine (the Mine) and processing facility (the Plant) located approximately five miles south of the city of Ishpeming,
Michigan. The Property is also immediately west of Cliffs’ Empire Property, which was indefinitely idled in 2016.The Mine is a large, operang, open-
pit iron mine and is unique among Cliffs’ US-owned operaons because the primary ore mineral at Tilden is hemate, with other minerals being
marte (oxidized pseudomorph of magnete), goethite, and siderite (iron carbonate mineral), as opposed to strictly magnete. The Property is also
unique in the world in that the hemate-dominant ore is mined at a low grade, concentrated using a selecve-flocculaon desliming and flotaon
process, and pelletized.
The Property commenced operaons in 1974 under a partnership of Algoma Steel, Stelco, J&L Steel, Wheeling-PiSsburgh Steel, Sharon Steel, and The
Cleveland-Cliffs Iron Company (CCIC).The property has since been at least parally in the possession of a subsidiary of Cliffs. In 2001, Cliffs acquired
Algoma Steel's 45% interest in Tilden L.C. In 2017, Cliffs became the sole owner of Tilden L.C.
The open-pit operaon has a mining rate of approximately 21 million long tons (MLT) of ore per year and produces 7.7 MLT of iron ore pellets per
year, which are mostly shipped by freighter via the Great Lakes to Cliffs’ steel mill facilies in the Midwestern USA, with some quanes shipped by
rail to external customers.
1.1.1 Conclusions
Tilden has successfully produced iron ore pellets for over 47 years. The update to the Mineral Resource and Mineral Reserve does not materially
change any of the assumpons from previous operaons. An economic analysis was performed using the esmates presented in this TRS and confirms
that the outcome is a positive cash flow that supports the statement of Mineral Reserves for a 25-year mine life.
SLR offers the following conclusions by area.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 1
-- 229 of 411 --
1.1.1.1 Geology and Mineral Resources
• Indicated Mineral Resources at Tilden, exclusive of Mineral Reserves, are esmated to total 135.4 MLT at a grade of 34.7% crude Fe.Inferred
Mineral Resources are estimated to total 350.4 MLT at a grade of 34.7% crude Fe.
• The 2019 quality assurance and quality control (QA/QC) program as designed and implemented by Cliffs has been helpful to understand the
precision and accuracy of sample analysis at the Tilden laboratory, which is used to support the assay results within the database and confirm
that the database is suitable for use in estimating Indicated and Inferred Mineral Resources.
• The Tilden database is adequate for the purposes of esmang Indicated and Inferred Mineral Resources.The lack of regular QA/QC sample
submissions alongside samples used to support Mineral Resources is outside of industry-standard pracce, and there are several database
integrity issues that require attention.
• There is a moderate to good correlaon of all variables between drill and blast hole twinned samples. Correlaon of iron content values
decreases for samples with high silica in concentrate values. There is a potenal high bias of phosphorus in concentrate values in favor of blast
holes. The known bias of weight recovery (wtrec) in favor of blast hole data is not observable in the paired dataset.
• The estimated block grades reflect the local blast hole or drill hole composite value, and the trends of the different variables are as intended.
1.1.1.2 Mining and Mineral Reserves
• The Property has been in producon since 1974, and specifically under 100% Cliffs operang management since 2017. Cliffs conducts its own
Mineral Reserve estimations.
• Total Proven and Probable Mineral Reserves are estimated at 520.0 MLT of crude ore at a grade of 34.7% crude Fe.
• Mineral Reserve estimation practices follow industry standards.
• The Mineral Reserve estimate indicates a sustainable project over a 25-year life of mine (LOM).
• The geotechnical design parameters used for pit design are reasonable and support previous operaons. Slope depressurizaon may be
required as part of the development of the final pit walls.
• The LOM production schedule is reasonable and incorporates large mining areas and open benches.
• An appropriate mining equipment fleet, maintenance facilies, and manpower are in place, with addions and replacements esmated, to meet
the LOM production schedule requirements.
• Sufficient storage capacity for waste stockpiles and tailings has been identified to support the production of the Mineral Reserve.
1.1.1.3 Mineral Processing
• The Tilden deposit is complex and requires metallurgical testing to classify materials as ore and waste. A standard flotation testing procedure has
been developed for material classification, resource modeling, and concentrator feed blending.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 2
-- 230 of 411 --
• The capacity of the Tilden concentrator and pellet plant is 7.7 MLT per year (MLT/y) of fluxed pellets (hemflux) from hemate-dominant crude
ore sources.
• The ore is amenable to autogenous grinding (AG), and the concentrator consists of eleven lines of primary autogenous mills for coarse grinding
and pebble mills for fine grinding, eliminating the requirement for steel grinding media.
• Pellets are indurated using a gas- and coal-fired grate drying and preheang furnace, followed by gas- and coal-fired rotary kilns for fusing and
hardening, and rotary coolers for cooling. Heat must be supplied by fuel for low-magnete concentrates, without the benefit of the exothermic
heat of reaction from magnetite oxidation to hematite during heating.
• Crude iron ore head grades feeding the Plant during 2014 to 2020 ranged from 34.4% Fe to 35.5% Fe. Iron recovery to flotaon concentrates
ranged from 69.6% to 74.8%, with concentrate grades averaging 62.2% to 63.7% during this period. Approximately 20.5 MLT of crude ore is
processed through the concentrator annually to produce 8.9 MLT of fluxed concentrate and 7.7 MLT of fluxed pellets (hemflux).
1.1.1.4 Infrastructure
• The Property is in a historically important, iron-producing region of Northern Michigan. All the infrastructure necessary to mine and process
commercial quanes of iron ore and produce and ship pellets is in place, including the Mine, concentrator, and support facilies, line power
supplies, natural gas sourced from an interstate pipeline system, local supply of coal, and diesel fuel supply from Green Bay, Wisconsin.
• The Gribben Tailings Basin (GTB) is located approximately five miles southeast of the Tilden concentrator plant and nine miles from Lake
Superior. The GTB is comprised of two, ring dike-type impoundments: the Gribben North Tailings Basin (GNTB), which encompasses
approximately 1,350 acres, and the Gribben South Tailings Basin (GSTB), which encompasses approximately 1,100 acres.
1.1.1.5 Environment
• Tilden indicated that it maintains the requisite state and federal permits and is in compliance with all permits. Various permiUng applicaons
have been submitted to authorities and are pending authorization. Environmental liabilities and permitting are further discussed in Section 17.0.
1.1.2 Recommendations
1.1.2.1 Geology and Mineral Resources
1. Complete a reconciliation study to support the inclusion of Measured Mineral Resources at Tilden.
2. Complete addional drilling to improve the understanding of the deposit at its periphery and at depth, with a focus on low drill density areas
within the 2019 LOM plan, as well as in areas with increased variability, such as the high-silica zones in the east of the Main Pit. Integrate the
downhole information from the Empire and Tilden mines into a single, valid database.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 3
-- 231 of 411 --
3. Develop a standard operang procedure for detailed logging of drill core that captures iron speciaon, alteraon, mineralogy, structure, and
lithology. Retain inial geological observaons in drill core separately from subsequent re-interpretaons based on metallurgical results or
results of neighboring drill holes.
4. Undertake a study where samples are consistently taken at shorter intervals, broken by geology, to examine how the variance of the assays is
affected and how the material-type designaon, based on a calculaon of those variables, compares against the material-type designaon of
longer samples. Sample intrusive material (dilution) too small to be segregated when modeling or mining as part of iron formation unit samples.
5. Connue work to define fault orientaons and related alteraon in the east of the Main Pit to confirm the syn-bedding and cross-cuUng
direcons of the modeled, high-silica alteraon units and invesgate alternave tools to capture drill hole informaon, including a
magnetometer and hyperspectral and x-ray fluorescence handheld devices to allow empirical measurements of magnesm (where relevant),
alteration, such as clay, and iron speciation.
6. Develop and implement a robust QA/QC program at Tilden for both exploraon drill hole and blast hole samples and incorporate analycal
aSribute data, such as grind me, starch type, and dates into the assay database, to be able to analyze results in context of changing test
protocols for performance and bias.
7. Address capacity issues at the Tilden laboratory to allow the sample analysis to be completed in a mely manner and to facilitate the inclusion of
QA/QC samples.
1.1.2.2 Mining and Mineral Reserves
1. Assess groundwater condions in the immediate vicinity of the final pit through a more focused groundwater model. The results of this
assessment should be input into an update of the pit slope stability analysis on sections cut through the current final pit design.
1.1.2.3 Mineral Processing
1. Continue specialized metallurgical testing to support resource modeling and mine planning and blending for the concentrator.
2. Plant operaonal performance including concentrate and pellet producon and pellet quality connues to be consistent year over year. It is
important to maintain diligence in process-oriented metallurgical testing and in plant maintenance.
1.1.2.4 Infrastructure
1. Priorize the compleon of an Operaons, Maintenance, and Surveillance (OMS) Manual for the tailings storage facility (TSF) with the Engineer
of Record (EOR) in accordance with Mining Associaon of Canada (MAC) guidelines and other industry-recognized standard guidance for tailings
facilities.
2. Document, priorize, track, and close out in a mely manner the remediaon, or resoluon, of items of concern noted in TSF audits or
inspection reports.
3. Assess the impacts of depositing tailings in the Empire facility, and prepare the necessary design and permitting documents.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 4
-- 232 of 411 --
1.2 Economic Analysis
1.2.1 Economic Criteria
An un-escalated technical-economic model was prepared on an aVer-tax, discounted cash flow (DCF) basis, the results of which are presented in this
subsection. Key criteria used in the analysis are discussed in detail throughout this TRS. General assumpons used are summarized in Table 1-1, with
all pellets reported per wet long ton (WLT) pellet.
Table 1-1: Technical-Economic Assumptions
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Description Value
Start Date December 31, 2021
Mine Life 25 years
Three-Year Trailing Average Revenue $98/WLT Pellet
Operating Costs $66.00/WLT Pellet
Sustaining Capital Costs (after five years) $4/WLT Pellet
Discount Rate 10%
Discounting Basis End of Period
Inflation 0.0%
Federal Tax Rate 20%
State Tax Rate None – Sales made out of state
Table 1-2 presents a summary of the estimated mine production over the 25-year LOM.
Table 1-2: LOM Production Summary
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Description Units Value
Run of Mine (ROM) Ore MLT 520.0
Total Material MLT 1,116.9
Fe Grade % 34.7
Average Annualized Mining Rate MLT/y 44
Maximum Annualized Mining Rate MLT/y 62
Table 1-3 presents a summary of the estimated plant production over the 25-year LOM.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 5
-- 233 of 411 --
Table 1-3: LOM Plant Production Summary
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Description Units Value
ROM Material Milled MLT 520.0
Average Annualized Processing Rate MLT/y 20.8
Process Recovery % 37.0
Total Hemflux Pellet MLT 192.4
Annual Hemflux Pellet Production MLT/y 7.7
1.2.2 Cash Flow Analysis
The indicave economic analysis results, presented in Table 1-4, indicate an aVer-tax Net Present Value (NPV), using a 10% discount rate, of $1,325
million at an average blended wet pellet price of $98/WLT. SLR notes that Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is not applicable, as the Property has been in
operation for a number of years. Capital identified in the economics is for sustaining operations and plant rebuilds as necessary.
The economic analysis was performed using the esmates presented in this TRS and confirms that the outcome is a posive cash flow that supports
the statement of Mineral Reserves.
Table 1-4: LOM Indicative Economic Results
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Description US$ Millions US$/WLT Pellet
Three-Year Trailing Revenue ($/WLT Pellet) 98
Pellet Production (MWLT) 192.4
Gross Revenue 18,854
Mining (2,944) 15.30
Processing (8,233) 42.79
Site Administration (547) 2.84
General / Other Costs (975) 5.07
Total Operating Costs 12,698 66.00
Operating Income (excl. D&A) 6,156 32.00
Federal Income Tax (1,231) (6.40)
Depreciation Tax Savings 209 1.09
Accretion Tax Savings 13 0.07
Net Income after Taxes 5,146 26.75
Capital (894) (4.65)
Closure Costs (57) (0.30)
Cash Flow 4,196 21.81
NPV 10% 1,322
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 6
-- 234 of 411 --
1.2.3 Sensitivity Analysis
The Tilden operaon is nominally most sensive to market prices (revenues) followed by operang cost. For each dollar movement in sales price or
operating cost, respectively, the after-tax NPV changes by approximately $56 million.
1.3 Technical Summary
1.3.1 Property Description
The Property is located in MarqueSe County in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, USA, on the MarqueSe Iron Range, approximately five miles south of the
city of Ishpeming, Michigan at latude 46° 29' N and longitude 87° 40' W. The Property is also immediately adjacent to Cliffs’ indefinitely idled Empire
Mine and processing facility. The Mine and Plant have the capacity to produce approximately 7.7 MLT of iron ore pellets annually.
Land ownership and mineral leases are held by Tilden L.C.Cliffs, through its subsidiary CCIC, owns 100% of the surface and mining rights. In addion,
Cliffs owns 100% of Tilden L.C. Tilden L.C. owns 21,100 acres of surface rights and 2,470 acres of mineral leases in Marquette County.
1.3.2 Accessibility, Climate, Local Resources, Infrastructure, and Physiography
The Property can be accessed from the west through the Tilden entrance gate near the community of Naonal Mine, located two miles south of
Ishpeming on County Road 476. Alternavely, the Property can be accessed from the east through the adjacent Empire Mine. The Empire entrance
gate is located on M-35, nine miles south of US Highway 41 between Marquette and Negaunee.
Michigan’s Upper Peninsula has a humid connental climate, typified by large seasonal temperature differences. Summers are generally warm and
humid; winters are cold and long. Precipitaon in the area averages approximately 31 in. of rain and 102 in. of snow in the winter. Snowfall in the
region is greatly influenced by the “lake effect” due to proximity to the Great Lakes. Many towns in the Upper Peninsula have recorded annual
snowfalls in excess of 350 in., and storms can quickly reach whiteout conditions and last for days.
The operaon employs a total of 967 salaried and hourly employees (including LS&I railroad staff) as of Q4 2021. The majority of the employees live
within a 50 mi radius of the Property. Marquette County has an estimated population of 66,000 people.
The Property is located in a historically important, iron-producing region in Northern Michigan. All infrastructure necessary to mine and process
significant commercial quanes of iron ore exist at the current me. Infrastructure items include administraon buildings and offices, maintenance
shops, high-voltage electrical supplies, natural gas pipelines that connect into the North American distribuon system, concentrang plant, pellezing
plant, water sources, paved roads and highways, railroads for transporng raw materials and final product, port facilies that connect into the Great
Lakes and towns where employees live.
The Property is within the limits of a topographic region known as the Superior Uplands, a part of the Canadian Shield. The Property features
elevaons ranging from approximately 1300 to 1800 V above sea level (fasl). Topography is hilly and is dominated by glacially influenced landforms.
The Property is located in the Western Upper Peninsula Ecoregion (Section IX) and characterized by a landscape
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 7
-- 235 of 411 --
featuring moraines, drumlins, lake plains, outwash channels, outwash plains, and glacially eroded bedrock ridges (Albert, 1995). Vegetaon in the
vicinity of Tilden is described as northern hardwood forest dominated by sugar maple, eastern hemlock, basswood, yellow birch, and sparse white
pine.
1.3.3 History
Iron deposits in Northern Michigan were originally described in the early 1840s by Douglass Houghton, Michigan’s first State Geologist.Exploration
and mining of high-grade iron oxides began in the mid to late 1840s, including Cliffs’ predecessors Cleveland Iron Company and Iron Cliffs Company,
which merged in 1891 to form the CCIC.Mining was mainly focused on underground, high-grade iron deposits through the end of the Second World
War, when they were almost depleted.
Extensive development of beneficiaon-grade, open pit mining began, and the first commercial agglomeraon (pellet) plant in the Lake Superior
region started operaons in 1952. Agglomeraon was a relavely new process that took the concentrate from lower-grade deposits and produced
pelletized product containing approximately 65% Fe.
AVer years of favorable experimental tesng for processing of fine-grained hemate ores, the Property commenced operaons in 1974 under a
partnership of Algoma Steel, Stelco, and CCIC.The Property has since been at least parally in the possession of a subsidiary of Cliffs. In 2001, Cliffs
acquired Algoma Steel's 45% interest in Tilden L.C. In 2017, Cliffs became the sole owner of the Tilden L.C. entity.
1.3.4 Geological Setting, Mineralization, and Deposit
The Tilden deposit is a classic example of a banded iron formaon (BIF) deposit of the Superior type and is located near the base of the Negaunee Iron
Formaon (Negaunee IF) of the Menominee Group, within the MarqueSe Range Super Group.The Negaunee IF and equivalents host most of the iron
deposits in Michigan. It is Proterozoic in age and sits on the southern margin of the Marquette trough.
The deposit is modeled to extend from surface to up to 2,300 ft vertical depth below and is comprised of alternating layers of iron oxides and iron-poor
chert in a northwest-plunging ancline; the axial surface dips steeply north, and the hinge line plunges 30° west-northwest down the center of the
Main Pit. It is fault-bounded to the south by Archean gneiss terrane; the fault contact dips steeply north and aligns with the south wall of the Main Pit
at Tilden. To the east of the Tilden deposit lies the Empire deposit (a stragraphically deeper extension of the Tilden deposit) and its historical pit.
Tilden is impacted by a higher frequency and volume of intrusions and sills northward, but is open to the west, at depth, and in some areas to the
north.
The iron formaon facies at Tilden were locally modified by clay-silica alteraon associated with faulng and intrusions, as well as by varying degrees
of oxidation throughout. Some BIF units in the south were disrupted by turbidite flows, typified by lensoidal inclusions of clastic material.
The Tilden Mine is unique among Cliffs-owned operaons because the primary ore mineral at Tilden is hemate, with other minerals being marte
(oxidized pseudomorph of magnete), goethite, and siderite (iron carbonate mineral), as opposed to strictly magnete. Tilden is also unique in the
world in that the hemate-dominant ore is mined at a low grade, concentrated using a selecve-flocculaon desliming and flotaon process, and
pelletized. Although some now-expended areas at Tilden did mine and magnecally recover magnete-dominant ore prior to 2009, remaining Mineral
Resources at Tilden
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 8
-- 236 of 411 --
are hemate-dominant. The adjacent (now indefinitely idled) Empire deposit hosted primarily magnete ore, and unoxidized magnete is variably
present at Tilden.
1.3.5 Exploration
Cliffs and Tilden Mine do not maintain detailed records or results of non-drilling prospecng methods used during inial exploraon acvies, such as
geophysical surveys, mapping, trenching, and test pits, conducted prior to Cliffs’ development of the operaon. No exploraon work or invesgaons
other than drilling and limited pit mapping have been conducted by Cliffs at Tilden.
The Tilden drill hole database consists of 382,605 V of drill hole informaon in 578 drill holes, completed from the 1950s to 2020. Annual exploraon
drilling programs at Tilden have completed zero to 42 drill holes. Of the last 10 years, nine have included drill hole programs and have averaged 10
drill holes per year. Diamond, hammer, and churn drilling have all been employed at Tilden, with diamond drilling having been exclusively used since
2008.
1.3.6 Mineral Resource Estimates
A geological model was constructed by SLR considering regional mapping, drill hole logging, and blast hole analycal results, in addion to grade
control modeling and flotaon ore coding. Data verificaon included standard database verificaon, a review of QA/QC protocols and results, and a
comparison of blast hole and exploration drill hole results.
The Tilden Mineral Resource esmate was completed by SLR using a convenonal block modeling approach, defining esmaon domains from
wireframes built in Seequent’s Leapfrog Geo (Leapfrog Geo) soVware and using a regular block model built and interpolated in Seequent’s Leapfrog
Edge (Leapfrog Edge) soVware. The general workflow included the creaon of a geological model from mapping, drill and blast hole logging, and
sampling, which were used to define discrete domains of non-iron formaon and iron formaon sub-units. Iron formaon drill hole samples were
composited, and the esmaon of six variables (crude iron and magnec iron, wtrec, and iron, phosphorus, and silica in concentrate) was completed
using ordinary kriging (OK) over five passes in iron formaon units, the first of which incorporated blast hole samples. Distance restricon of outlier
grades was applied to selected domains and variables. Blocks were classified as Indicated or Inferred using distance-based and qualitave criterion.
Canadian Instute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum (CIM) Definion Standards for Mineral Resources and Mineral Reserves dated May 10, 2014
(CIM (2014) definions) were used for Mineral Resource classificaon.Models were depleted to December 31, 2021. Esmates were validated using
standard industry techniques and were peer reviewed prior to finalization.
A detailed breakdown of the Mineral Resources exclusive of Mineral Reserves is presented in Table 1-5. Mineral Resources were defined and
constrained within an open-pit shell, prepared by Cliffs and based on a US$90/LT pellet price, and meet the following cut-off grade criteria, based on
existing pellet specifications and price contracts:
• ≥ 25% wtrec
• ≥ 25% crude iron content (crudefe)
• ≤ 0.07% phosphorus in concentrate (conphos)
• ≤ 6% to 8.5% silica in concentrate (consio2) (domain dependent)
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 9
-- 237 of 411 --
The pellet cost basis for the Lerchs-Grossmann (LG) optimization is based on a dry 61.5% Fe fluxed pellet.
Table 1-5: Summary of Tilden Mineral Resources - December 31, 2021
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Category Long Tons
(MLT)
Crude Fe
(%)
Process Recovery
(%)
Wet Pellets
(MLT)
Measured - - - -
Indicated 135.4 35.5 35.9 48.6
Total Measured + Indicated 135.4 35.5 35.9 48.6
Inferred 350.4 34.7 36.4 127.4
Notes:
1. Tonnage is reported in long tons equivalent to 2,240 lb.
2. Tonnage is reported exclusive of Mineral Reserves and has been rounded to the nearest 100,000.
3. Mineral Resources are estimated at cut-off grades of 25% crudefe, 25% wtrec, 0.07% conphos, and 6% consio2 to 8.5% consio2, domain dependent.
4. Mineral Resources are estimated using a pellet value of US$90/LT.
5. Pellets are reported as fluxed and wet, containing 61.5% Fe; shipped pellets contain 1.5% moisture.
6. Tonnage estimate based on estimated depletion from a surveyed topography on December 31, 2021.
7. Resources are crude ore tons as delivered to the primary crusher; pellets are as loaded onto rail cars.
8. Classification of Mineral Resources is in accordance with the S-K 1300 classification system.
9. Bulk density is assigned based on a regression equation related to crude Fe.
10. Mineral Resources are 100% attributable to Cliffs.
11. Mineral Resources are constrained within an optimized pit shell.
12. Mineral Resources that are not Mineral Reserves do not have demonstrated economic viability.
13. Numbers may not add due to rounding.
The Tilden operaon is currently acve and in full producon. The SLR QP is of the opinion that with consideraon of the recommendaons
summarized in this secon, any issues relang to all relevant technical and economic factors likely to influence the prospect of economic extracon
can be resolved with further work.
1.3.7 Mineral Reserve Estimate
Mineral Reserves in this TRS are derived from the current Mineral Resources.The Mineral Reserves are reported as crude ore and are based on open
pit mining. Crude ore is the unconcentrated ore as it leaves the Mine at its natural in situ moisture content. The Proven and Probable Mineral Reserves
for Tilden are estimated as of December 31, 2021 and summarized in Table 1-6.
Table 1-6: Summary of Tilden Mineral Reserves - December 31, 2021
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Category Crude Ore Mineral Reserves
(MLT)
Crude Ore Fe
(%) Process Recovery (%) Wet Pellets
(MLT)
Proven 3.6 35.3 36.1 1.3
Probable 516.4 34.7 37.0 191.1
Proven & Probable 520.0 34.7 37.0 192.4
Notes:
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 10
-- 238 of 411 --
1. Tonnage is reported in long tons equivalent to 2,240 lb and has been rounded to the nearest 100,000.
2. Mineral Reserves are reported at a $90/LT wet hemflux pellet price freight-on-board (FOB) Lake Superior, based on the three-year trailing average of the realized product revenue
rate.
3. Mineral Reserves are estimated at a crude ore cut-off grade of 25.0% Fe along with additional metallurgical constraints.
4. Mineral Reserves include mining dilution built into the Mineral Resource model and mining extraction losses by geometallurgical domain, which range from 4% to 30%.
5. The Mineral Reserve mining stripping ratio (waste units to crude ore units) is at 1.2.
6. Proven Mineral Reserves are crude ore that has been mined and stockpiled for processing during the LOM.
7. Process recovery is reported as the percent mass recovery to produce a wet hemflux pellet containing 61.5% Fe; shipped hemflux pellets average approximately 1.5% moisture.
8. Tonnage estimate is based on the end of year, December 31, 2021 topographic survey.
9. Mineral Reserve tons are as delivered to the primary crusher; wet hemflux pellets are as loaded onto lake freighters at Marquette, Michigan.
10. Classification of Mineral Reserves is in accordance with the S-K 1300 classification system.
11. Mineral Reserves are 100% attributable to Cliffs.
12. Numbers may not add due to rounding.
The pellet price used to perform the evaluaon of the Mineral Reserves in the current mining model is US$90/LT wet hemflux pellet.This price is
consistent with the Mineral Reserve price used at Cliffs’ Northshore and UTAC operaons and is supported by the current three-year trailing average
of the realized product revenue rate of US$98/LT wet hemflux pellet. Proven Mineral Reserves consist exclusively of crude ore that has been mined
and stockpiled for future processing in the LOM plan. The costs used in this study represent all mining, processing, transportaon, and administrave
costs including the loading of pellets into lake freighters at Marquette, Michigan.
SLR is not aware of any risk factors associated with, or changes to, any aspects of the modifying factors such as mining, metallurgical, infrastructure,
permitting, or other relevant factors that could materially affect the Mineral Reserve estimate.
1.3.8 Mining Methods
The Tilden deposit is mined using conventional surface mining methods. The surface operations include:
• Overburden (glacial till) removal
• Drilling and blasting (excluding overburden)
• Loading and haulage
• Crushing and rail loading
The Mineral Reserve is based on the ongoing annual crude ore producon of 20 MLT to 22 MLT producing approximately 7.7 MLT of wet hemflux
pellets for domestic consumption.
Mining and processing operations are scheduled 24 hours per day, and the mine production is scheduled to directly feed the processing operations.
The current LOM plan has mining scheduled for 25 years and mines the known Mineral Reserve.The average stripping rao is approximately 1.2 waste
units to 1 crude ore unit (1.2 stripping ratio).
The final Tilden pit is a single pit approximately 2.5 mi along strike, up to 0.9 mi wide, and up to 1,980 ft deep.
The Mine’s operaon has a strict crude ore blending requirement to ensure the Plant receives a consistent crude ore feed. The most important
characteriscs of the crude ore are the crude ore iron grade and the predicted concentrate mass recovery and concentrate iron, silica, and phosphorus
content. Operationally, blending is done on a shift-by-shift basis. Generally, three to four crude ore
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 11
-- 239 of 411 --
loading points are mined at one time with dispatch operators issuing real-time adjustments to meet specified crude ore blends for the Plant.
Crude ore is hauled to the crushing facility and either direct pped to the primary crusher or stockpiled. Haul trucks are alternated to blend delivery
from the mulple crude ore loading points. The crude ore stockpiles are used as an addional source for blending and producon efficiency. Crushed
crude ore is conveyed to a covered storage building for stockpiling prior to being fed to the concentrator. Waste rock and overburden are hauled to
one of the many waste stockpiles peripheral to the pit or to the in-pit backfill.
The major pieces of pit equipment include electric drills, electric rope shovels, haul trucks, front-end loaders (FELs), bulldozers, and graders. Extensive
maintenance facilities are available at the mine site to service the mine equipment.
1.3.9 Processing and Recovery Methods
The mix of magnete and primarily hemate ores at Tilden is unique to US iron ore mines. Typical flowsheets developed for beneficiaon-grade
magnete ores of the Lake Superior region were not applicable, as most of the iron oxide occurs as non-magnec hemate, which requires fine
grinding for liberaon. Metallurgical research conducted in the 1960s focused on creang a process that included selecve flocculaon and desliming
followed by cationic silica (SiO ) flotation.
A standardized bench-scale flotaon test was designed to simulate the Tilden hemate grinding and concentrang circuit. Results from the
standardized bench flotaon test are used to characterize rock samples as either crude iron ore or waste rock. The data are used to build a resource
model and mine plan to supply a consistent blend of ore to the concentrator. Deleterious materials impacng economic extracon are observed in the
flotation bench test, which may include clay minerals, quartz inclusions within iron oxide bands, fine goethite, and carbonates.
The capacity of the Tilden concentrator and pellet plant is 7.7 MLT/y of fluxed pellets from both hemate and magnete crude ore sources. The Plant
includes primary crushing, autogenous primary and secondary grinding, selecve flocculaon and desliming, flotaon, filtraon, drying, balling
(agglomeration), and induration. The concentrator is designed to campaign either hematite ores or magnetite ores but not in combination.
The processing of magnete-dominant ores at the Tilden concentrator ceased in 2009. Magnete ore from the Tilden was delivered and processed at
the Empire Mine from 2010 through 2016 when the Empire was indefinitely idled. Remaining Mineral Resources and Mineral Reserves at Tilden are
processed in hematite-based flotation circuits.
Mined ore is directly dumped from haul trucks into a gyratory crusher to produce a nominal nine-inch crushed product, which is conveyed to the ore
storage building ahead of the grinding circuit. Primary grinding is accomplished with eleven primary AG mills, each driven by two, 2,860 hp
synchronous motors. Each primary AG mill discharges to a triple-deck screen, producing coarse pebble for pebble mill grinding media, an intermediate
product that is recycled to the AG mill, and a 100% passing 2 mm product that feeds the pebble mills. The pebble mills are operated in closed circuit
with cyclones to produce a final grind of 80% to 85% passing 25 microns. Causc soda and slaked lime are added to the water circuit to control pH
prior to desliming and flotation.
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 12
-- 240 of 411 --
Starch and a dispersant are added to the slurry to selecvely flocculate and depress the iron oxides while dispersing the fine silica gangue in advance
of the deslime thickeners. The deslime thickener overflow, containing the waste products, is fed to the tailings thickeners, and the deslime thickener
underflow is conditioned with additional starch and advanced to the flotation circuit.
The reverse flotaon circuit is divided into twelve lines, which float silica from the iron minerals with an amine collector. The rougher flotaon
concentrate represents final upgraded iron concentrate and is advanced to the concentrate thickener. The rougher tail is scavenged in four flotaon
stages to remove entrained iron values. The scavenger flotaon concentrates are recycled to the rougher feed, and scavenger tails are pumped to the
tailings thickeners.
The iron concentrate is thickened to approximately 65% to 70% solids in the concentrate thickeners, neutralized to a pH of 7.0 using carbon dioxide,
and then filtered in a series of vacuum disc filters to approximately 11.5% weight by weight (w/w) moisture content. Filtered concentrates are either
sent directly to the pelletizing plant, a thermal drying circuit, or to a concentrate storage stockpile.
Fluxstone consisng of dolomite and calcite is delivered to site via truck and stored in stockpiles. The material is fed from a stockpile via apron feeders
and processed in two, 15.5 V-diameter x 30 V-long ball mills. The fluxstone slurry is added to the iron concentrate prior to filtering to ensure
homogenous mixing.
The unit processes of the pellezing plant include concentrate drying, agglomeraon or balling, sizing, and induraon in a grate kiln and cooler to
produce final pellets, and pellet storage and loadout.
Concentrate is conveyed from filtraon or the concentrate stockpile to the balling secon of the pellezing plant. A poron of the concentrate is dried
in a rotary dryer and then recombined with the concentrate feed to achieve 9.5% w/w moisture for balling. Green balls are produced in fourteen
rotang balling drums operang in parallel. Bentonite clay binder is added to the balling drum feed, and green balls are discharged onto a vibrang
seed screen with a two-feet-long grizzly extension for oversize removal. The screen undersize is returned to the balling drum, and the grizzly oversize is
returned to the concentrate bin or diverted to outdoor storage. The seed screen product is conveyed by a reciprocang conveyor, which distributes
the green balls over a grate feed belt.
The green balls enter a moving grate, which passes through 3.5 bays of updraV drying, 7.5 bays of downdraV drying, and eight bays of downdraV pre-
heang and are then discharged into one of two rotary kilns. Heat for the kilns is produced with a combinaon of pulverized coal and/or natural gas.
Product from the kiln is discharged into two rotary coolers, sufficiently cooling the pellets to be transported by conveyor.
Cooled pellets are conveyed directly to either a railroad load-out bin or to an outdoor stockpile with nominal capacity of 2 MLT. Pellets are loaded into
rail cars and transported to the dock facility in MarqueSe, Michigan or shipped directly to customers by rail. Pellet stockpiles are screened to reduce
fines using loaders feeding a portable screening plant. Pellet chips and fines from this process are sold as a secondary product.
1.3.10 Infrastructure
The Property is in a historically important, iron-producing region in the Upper Peninsula of Northern Michigan.All the infrastructure necessary to mine
and process commercial quantities of iron ore is in place.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 13
-- 241 of 411 --
Infrastructure items include:
• The Mine, concentrator, and concentrate pelletizing facilities near Marquette, Michigan.
• The main processing facility is contained in a convenonal, mul-level, insulated steel building. Mining offices and mobile equipment
maintenance shops are separated from the main facility and are located on the Empire Mine property.
• Power is supplied by Upper Michigan Energy Resources (UMERC) that supplies power through the exisng power grid, which is interconnected
to neighboring states and is received at its substation on transmission lines owned by American Transmission Company.
• Backup diesel-powered generators are installed at several locations to operate critical equipment should main power be lost.
• Natural gas is primarily used for firing the rotary kilns at the pellezing plant and water boilers in the concentrator. Natural gas is purchased
from Encore Energy and supplied to the site via a gas pipeline owned and operated by Northern Natural Gas (NNG), which has an extensive
interstate pipeline system.
• The Tilden pellet plant kilns are a dual fuel system with the ability to operate on pulverized coal, natural gas, or a combination of both.
• U.S. Oil supplies the Tilden Mine from its terminal in Green Bay, Wisconsin.The Mine has one 20,000 gal, above-ground diesel fuel tank and one
10,000 gal, underground gasoline storage tank.
• Fresh make-up water for the process is supplied from the Greenwood Reservoir, which is located approximately seven miles southwest of
Ishpeming and is on the Middle Branch Escanaba River.
• Process water is primarily supplied by tailings reclaim.
• Potable water is supplied by two deep well pumps located on site.
• Paved roads and highways.
• Pellets produced at the site are shipped in rail cars by the Lake Superior & Ishpeming Railroad (LS&I), a wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs, 22 mi
to the LS&I dock in Marquette, Michigan.
• Tailings are stored in the GTB located approximately five miles southeast of the Tilden concentrator plant and nine miles from Lake Superior.
The GTB is comprised of two ring dike-type impoundments: the GNTB, which encompasses approximately 1,350 acres, and the GSTB, which
encompasses approximately 1,100 acres.
• Dock facilies in MarqueSe include 50,000 LT of pellet storage and ship loaders for loading 60,000 LT-capacity lakers that transport pellets to
steel mills on the Great Lakes.
• Pellets can also be shipped using the Canadian Naonal (CN) railroad. The CN owns and operates its own rail fleet. Currently, one customer
receives direct rail deliveries by CN to Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario, Canada, a distance of 120 mi from the Property.
• Accommodations for employees.
• Local and State infrastructure also includes hospitals, schools, airports, equipment suppliers, fuel suppliers, commercial laboratories, and
communication systems.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 14
-- 242 of 411 --
1.3.11 Market Studies
Cliffs is the largest producer of iron ore pellets in North America. It is also the largest flat-rolled steel producer in North America. In 2020, Cliffs
acquired two major steelmakers, ArcelorMiSal USA (AMUSA), and AK Steel (AK), vercally integrang its legacy iron ore business with steel producon
and emphasis on the automotive end market.
Cliffs owns or co-owns five acve iron ore mines in Minnesota and Michigan. Through the two acquisions and transformaon into a vercally
integrated business, the iron ore mines are primarily now a crical source of feedstock for Cliffs’ downstream primary steelmaking operaons. Based
on its ownership in these mines, Cliffs’ share of annual rated iron ore producon capacity is approximately 28.0 million LT, enough to supply its
steelmaking operations and not have to rely on outside supply.
The importance of the steel industry in North America and specifically the USA is apparent by the acons of the US federal government in
implemenng and keeping import restricons in place. It is important for middle-class job generaon and the efficiency of the naonal supply chain. It
is also an industry that supports the country’s naonal security by providing products used for US military forces and naonal infrastructure. Cliffs
expects the US government to connue recognizing the importance of this industry and does not see major declines in the producon of steel in North
America.
Tilden L.C. ships flux pellets annually to Cliffs’ steelmaking facilies in the Midwestern USA, with some quanes shipped by rail to external customers.
For cash flow projecons, Cliffs uses a blended pellet revenue rate of $98/WLT Free on Board (FOB) Mine based on a three-year trailing average for
2017 to 2019. Based on macroeconomic trends, SLR is of the opinion that Cliffs’ pellet prices will remain at least at the current three-year trailing
average of $98/WLT or above for the next five years.
1.3.12 Environmental Studies, Permitting and Plans, Negotiations, or Agreements with Local Individuals or Groups
Tilden L.C. indicated that it presently has the requisite operang permits for the Mine and Plant and esmates that the mine life will be 25 years.
Environmental monitoring during operaons includes water and air quality monitoring. Closure plans and other post-mining plans are required to be
prepared within two years of ancipated closure. Cliffs indicated that it conducts an in-depth review every three years to ensure that the Asset
Rerement Obligaon (ARO) legal liabilies are accurately esmated based on current laws, regulaons, facility condions, and cost to perform
services. These cost esmates are conducted in accordance with the Financial Accounng Standards Board (FASB) Accounng Standards Codificaon
(ASC) 410. SLR is not aware of any formal commitments to local procurement and hiring; however, Cliffs indicated that it has a long-standing
relationship with local vendors.
1.3.13 Capital and Operating Cost Estimates
Producve and sustaining capital expenditure esmates for the remaining life of the operaon are presented in Table 1-7. The LOM capital cost
forecast is shown for the next five-year period from 2022 to 2026, which totals $314.2 million and an addional $579.9 million from 2027 to the last
year of mining in 2046. Total capital expenditures are estimated at $894.2 million.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 15
-- 243 of 411 --
Table 1-7: LOM Capital Costs
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Type Values Total 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027-2046
Total $ millions 894.2 63.5 82.9 45.7 43.8 78.3 579.9
Operang costs are based on a full run rate of flux pellets consistent with what is expected for the life of the mine. A LOM average operang cost of
$66.00/WLT pellet is estimated over the remaining 25 years of the mine life and is presented by area in Table 1-8.
Table 1-8: LOM Operating Costs
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Description LOM
($/WLT Pellet)
Mining 15.30
Processing 42.79
Site Administration 2.84
General/Other 5.07
Operating Cash Cost 66.00
Cliffs’ capital and operang costs esmates are derived from annual budgets and historical actuals over the long life of the current operaon.
According to the American Associaon of Cost Engineers (AACE) Internaonal, these esmates would be classified as Class 1 with an accuracy range of
-3% to -10% to +3% to +15%.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 16
-- 244 of 411 --
2.0 INTRODUCTION
SLR Internaonal Corporaon (SLR) was retained by Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (Cliffs) to prepare an independent Technical Report Summary (TRS) for the
Tilden Property (Tilden or the Property), located in Northern Michigan, USA.The owner of the Property, Tilden Mining Company L.C. (Tilden L.C.), is a
wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs.
The purpose of this TRS is to disclose year end (YE) 2021 Mineral Resource and Mineral Reserve estimates for Tilden.
Cliffs is listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) and currently reports Mineral Reserves of pellezed ore in SEC filings.This TRS conforms to the
United States Securies and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) Modernized Property Disclosure Requirements for Mining Registrants as described in
Subpart 229.1300 of Regulaon S-K, Disclosure by Registrants Engaged in Mining Operaons (S-K 1300) and Item 601 (b)(96) Technical Report
Summary.
The Property includes the Tilden Mine (the Mine) and processing facility (the Plant) located approximately five miles south of the city of Ishpeming,
Michigan. The Property is also immediately west of Cliffs’ Empire Property, which was indefinitely idled in 2016.The Mine is a large, operang, open-
pit iron mine and is unique among Cliffs’ US-owned operaons because the primary ore mineral at Tilden is hemate, with other minerals being
marte (oxidized pseudomorph of magnete), goethite, and siderite (iron carbonate mineral), as opposed to strictly magnete. The Property is also
unique in the world in that the hemate-dominant ore is mined at a low grade, concentrated using a selecve-flocculaon desliming and flotaon
process, and pelletized.
The Property commenced operaons in 1974 under a partnership of Algoma Steel, Stelco, J&L Steel, Wheeling-PiSsburgh Steel, Sharon Steel, and The
Cleveland-Cliffs Iron Company (CCIC).The property has since been at least parally in the possession of a subsidiary of Cliffs. In 2001, Cliffs acquired
Algoma Steel's 45% interest in Tilden L.C. In 2017, Cliffs became the sole owner of Tilden L.C.
The open-pit operaon has a mining rate of approximately 21 million long tons (MLT) of ore per year and produces 7.7 MLT of iron ore pellets per
year, which are mostly shipped by freighter via the Great Lakes to Cliffs’ steel mill facilies in the Midwestern USA, with some quanes shipped by
rail to external customers.
2.1 Site Visits
SLR Qualified Persons (QPs) visited the Property on October 24, 2019 and January 20 to 24, 2020. During the 2019 site visit, the SLR team all toured the
tailings basin, plant laboratory, concentrator and pelletizing facilities plus rail pellet loadout site, and the mine offices and operational areas.
During the 2020 site visit, the SLR geologist visited the mine offices and worked with the mine geologists to update the geological and Mineral
Resource block model.
2.2 Sources of Information
Technical documents and reports on the Property were obtained from Cliffs’ personnel. During the preparaon of this TRS, discussions were held with
personnel from Cliffs:
• Kurt Gitzlaff, Director - Mine Engineering, Cliffs Technical Group (CTG)
• Michael Orobona, Principal Geologist, CTG
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 17
-- 245 of 411 --
• Michael Koop, Lead Mine Engineer, CTG
• Scott Gischia, Director - Environmental Compliance
• Dean Korri, Director - Basin & Civil Engineering
• Sandy Karnowski, District Manager - Public Affairs
• John Elton, Senior Director - Corporate Accounting & Assistant Controller
• Tushar Mondhe, Senior Manager – Operations and Capital Finance
• Al Strandlie, Mine Geologist
• Tyson Murphy, Section Manager - Mine Engineering
• Todd Davis, Area Manager – Plant
• Kris Scherer, Tailings Engineer
• Brent Ketzenberger, Environmental Manager
This TRS was prepared by SLR QPs.The documentaon reviewed, and other sources of informaon, are listed at the end of this TRS in Secon 24.0,
References.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 18
-- 246 of 411 --
2.3 List of Abbreviations
The U.S. System for weights and units has been used throughout this report. Tons are reported in long tons (LT) of 2,240 lb unless otherwise noted. All
currency in this report is US dollars (US$ or $) unless otherwise noted. Abbreviations and acronyms used in this TRS are listed below.
Unit Abbreviation Definition Unit Abbreviation Definition
a annum LT/h long tons per hour
A ampere μL microliter
acfm actual cubic feet per minute M mega (million); molar
bbl barrels Ma one million years
Btu British thermal units MBtu thousand British thermal units
d day MCF million cubic feet
°F degree Fahrenheit MCF/h million cubic feet per hour
fasl feet above sea level mi mile
ft foot min minute
ft square foot MLT/y million long tons per year
ft cubic foot MPa megapascal
ft/s foot per second mph miles per hour
g gram MVA megavolt-amperes
G giga (billion) MW megawatt
Ga one billion years MWh megawatt-hour
gal gallon MWLT million wet long tons
gal/d gallon per day oz Troy ounce (31.1035g)
g/L gram per liter oz/ton ounce per short ton
g/y gallon per year ppb part per billion
gpm gallons per minute ppm part per million
hp horsepower psia pound per square inch absolute
h hour psig pound per square inch gauge
Hz hertz rpm revolutions per minute
in. inch RL relative elevation
in square inch s second
J joule ton short ton
kLT thousand long tons stpa short ton per year
k kilo (thousand) stpd short ton per day
kg/m Kilogram per cubic meter t metric tonne
kVA kilovolt-amperes US$ United States dollar
kW kilowatt V volt
kWh kilowatt-hour W watt
kWLT thousand wet long tons wt% weight percent
L liter WLT wet long ton
lb pound w/w weight by weight
LT long or gross ton equivalent to 2,240 pounds y year
LT/d long tons per day yd cubic yard
2
3
2
3
3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 19
-- 247 of 411 --
Acronym Definition
AACE American Association of Cost Engineers
AK AK Steel
AMUSA ArcelorMittal USA
ANSI American National Standards Institute
ARO asset retirement obligation
ASC Accounting Standards Codification
ASQ American Society for Quality
ASTM American Society for Testing and Materials
BF blast furnace
BFA bench face angle
BH bench height
BIF banded iron formation
BLS United States Bureau of Labor Statistics
CCD counter-current decantation
CCIC Cleveland-Cliffs Iron Company
CCP Conceptual Closure Plan
CERCLA Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act
CFR Cost and Freight
CN Canadian National Railroad
COA certificates of analysis
CRIRSCO Committee for Mineral Reserves International Reporting Standards
D&A depreciation and amortization
DDH diamond drill hole
DMO Department Maintenance Office
DOSS Dioctyl Sulfosuccinate
DRI direct reduced iron
DSO direct-shipping iron ore
EAF electric arc furnace
EAP Emergency Action Plan
EGLE Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy
EIS Environmental Impact Statement
EMP Environmental Management Plan
EMS environmental management system
EPA United States Environmental Protection Agency
ESOP Environmental Standard Operating Procedures
EOR Engineer of Record
FASB Financial Accounting Standards Board
FDCP Fugitive Dust Control Plan
FOB Free on Board
GHG greenhouse gas
GIM Geoscientific Information Management
GNTB Gribben North Tailings Basin
GPS global positioning system
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 20
-- 248 of 411 --
Acronym Definition
GSI Geological Strength Index
GSSI General Security Services Corporation
GSTB Gribben South Tailings Basin
GTB Gribben Tailings Basin
HBI hot briquetted iron
HRC hot-rolled coil
ID Inverse distance squared
ID Inverse distance cubed
IF iron formation
IRA Inter-ramp angle
IRR internal rate of return
ISO International Standards Organization
KEV key economic variables
LG Lerchs-Grossmann
LiDAR light imaging, detection, and ranging
LMF Laurentian Mixed Forest
LOM life of mine
LS&I Lake Superior & Ishpeming Railroad
MAC Mining Association of Canada
MLT million long tons
MR moving range
MRCC Midwestern Regional Climate Center
NAAQS National Ambient Air Quality Standards
NAD North American Datum
NESHAP National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants
NGO non-governmental organization
NN nearest neighbor
NNG Northern Natural Gas
NOAA National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
NOLA Nuclear On-Line Analyzer
NPDES National Pollution Discharge Elimination System
NPV net present value
OMS Operations, Maintenance, and Surveillance
OSA overall slope angle
QA/QC quality assurance/quality control
QP Qualified Person
RC rotary circulation drilling
RCRA Resource Conservation and Recovery Act
ROM run of mine
RQD rock quality designation
RTR risk and technology review
SDS State Disposal System Permit
SEC United States Securities and Exchange Commission
2
3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 21
-- 249 of 411 --
Acronym Definition
SG specific gravity
SMU selective mining unit
SQL Structured Query Language
SPC Statistical Process Control
SPT standard penetration testing
TMDL total maximum daily load
TRS Technical Report Summary
TSF tailings storage facility
TSP total suspended particulates
UCS uniaxial compressive strength
UMERC Upper Michigan Energy Resources
USGAAP United States General Accepted Accounting Principles
USGS United States Geological Survey
USNRC United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission
WTF water treatment facility
XRF x-ray fluorescence
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 22
-- 250 of 411 --
3.0 PROPERTY DESCRIPTION
3.1 Property Location
The Property is located in MarqueSe County, in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, USA, on the MarqueSe Iron Range, approximately five miles south of the
city of Ishpeming at latude 46° 27' N and longitude 87° 39' W. The Property is also immediately adjacent to Cliffs’ indefinitely idled Empire Mine and
processing facility. Figure 3-1 shows the location of the Property.
3.2 Land Tenure
3.2.1 Mineral Titles
Land ownership and mineral leases are held by Tilden L.C., which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs. Inial acquisions from outside pares were
accomplished by CCIC over 150 years ago and moved to the various partnerships before Tilden L.C. was established.
The Property consists of approximately 2,470 acres of mineral leases from three pares. Tilden leases approximately 2,210 acres directly from its
affiliate, CCIC.Tilden subleases approximately 140 acres from Empire Iron Mining Partnership, another affiliate which leases the Property from CCIC.
Tilden subleases the remaining, approximately 120 acres from CCIC, which leases the Property from the Chester Company (2/3 undivided interest) and
CCIC (1/3 undivided interest), as illustrated in Figure 3-2. Mineral leases include surface mining rights. Land tenure is summarized in Table 3-1.
Both Tilden subleases expire in 2061; the CCIC lease is through the life of mine (LOM).In order to maintain the mineral leases unl their expiraon,
Tilden L.C. must connue to make minimum prepaid royalty payments each quarter and pay property taxes. When mining occurs, a royalty is due per
long ton of crude ore mined or long ton of pellets produced from the crude ore mined, and payable to the respecve lessors quarterly. Royalty rates
per long ton fluctuate based on industry and economic indexes. Minimum prepaid royalty payments may be credited against royales due when
mining occurs. Specific terms and provisions of the mineral leases are confidential.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 23
-- 251 of 411 --
Figure 3-1: Location Map
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 24
-- 252 of 411 --
Figure 3-2: Mineral Title Boundaries
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 25
-- 253 of 411 --
Table 3-1: Land Tenure
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Lease Name Expiration Date
Empire Mining Sublease 6/1/2061
CCIC Mining Sublease 6/1/2061
CCIC Supplemental Lease 12/31/2070
3.2.2 Surface Rights
Surface rights consist of approximately 21,100 acres of owned property in and around the Mine, Plant, Greenwood Reservoir, and the Gribben Basin,
as illustrated in Figure 3-3. To maintain ownership, property taxes must be paid to the local government units in Marquette County.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 26
-- 254 of 411 --
Figure 3-3: Surface Rights
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 27
-- 255 of 411 --
3.3 Encumbrances
Tilden grants leases, licenses, and easements for various purposes including miscellaneous community land uses, ulity infrastructure, and other third-
party uses that encumber the Property but do not materially inhibit operaons. Certain assets of Tilden L.C. serve as collateral as part of Cliffs’ asset-
based lending (ABL) facility. Cliffs has outstanding standby leSers of credit, which were issued to back certain obligaons of Tilden L.C., including
certain permits and tailings basin projects. Addionally, Tilden has and may connue to enter into lease agreements for necessary equipment used in
the operations of the mine.
3.4 Royalties
Reference section 3.2 for royalty information. No overriding royalty agreements are in place.
3.5 Other Significant Factors and Risks
No additional significant factors or risks are known.
SLR is not aware of any environmental liabilies on the Property. Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. has all required permits to conduct the proposed work on the
Property. SLR is not aware of any other significant factors and risks that may affect access, tle, or the right or ability to perform the proposed work
program on the Property.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 28
-- 256 of 411 --
4.0 ACCESSIBILITY, CLIMATE, LOCAL RESOURCES, INFRASTRUCTURE AND PHYSIOGRAPHY
4.1 Accessibility
The Property is located close to the cies of MarqueSe, Negaunee, and Ishpeming, Michigan. The Mine can be accessed by the Tilden entrance gate
near the community of Naonal Mine, located two miles south of Ishpeming on County Road 476.Alternavely, the Property can be accessed from
the east through the adjacent Empire Mine. The Empire entrance gate is located on M-35, nine miles south of US Highway 41 between MarqueSe and
Negaunee. Sawyer Internaonal Airport, the closest public airport, is located 17 mi south of MarqueSe and serves the region with several flights daily
to major hubs in Minneapolis, Chicago, and Detroit.
4.2 Climate
Michigan’s Upper Peninsula has a humid connental climate, typified by large seasonal temperature differences. Summers are generally warm and
humid; winters are cold and long. Precipitaon in the area averages approximately 31 in. of rain and 102 in. of snow in the winter (Western Regional
Climate Center, 2015). The average maximum and minimum temperatures are shown in Table 4-1, along with the average precipitaon and snowfall.
Snowfall in the region is greatly influenced by the “lake effect” due to proximity to the Great Lakes. Many towns in the Upper Peninsula have recorded
annual snowfalls in excess of 350 in., and storms can quickly reach whiteout conditions and last for days (Albert, 1995).
The Property is a year-round operation and is not generally curtailed due to seasonal temperature changes or weather conditions.
Table 4-1: Ishpeming, MI Temperature and Precipitation
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Station 204127 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Annual
Average Max. Temperature
( F) 23.2 29.6 38.5 52.9 66.0 73.8 79.6 76.1 65.8 53.9 38.0 26.6 52.2
Average Min. Temperature
( F) 5.2 10.5 17.7 29.2 40.0 48.0 54.4 52.8 44.8 35.3 23.2 11.4 31.1
Average Total Precipitation
(in.) 1.5 1.3 2.0 2.7 2.7 3.0 3.4 3.5 3.7 3.7 2.3 1.9 31.4
Average Total Snow Fall (in.) 20.0 17.6 16.6 8.2 1.2 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.2 3.8 15.4 19.1 102.1
Average Snow Depth (in.) 15.0 21.0 16.0 3.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 2.0 8.0 5.0
4.3 Local Resources
Local and State infrastructure includes hospitals, schools, airports, equipment suppliers, fuel suppliers, and communicaon systems. The Property is
located approximately five miles south of the city of Ishpeming, Michigan, nine miles southwest of Negaunee, Michigan, and 20 mi west-southwest of
o
o
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 29
-- 257 of 411 --
MarqueSe, Michigan. Medical facilies with trauma centers are located in the cies of MarqueSe and Green Bay. Table 4-2 is a list of the major
population centers and the distance by road to the Property.
Table 4-2: Nearby Population Centers
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
City/Town Medical Center Population 2010 Census Mileage to Mine
Palmer, MI n/a 449 3.5
Ishpeming, MI ER 6,470 5.0
Negaunee, MI n/a 4,568 9.0
Marquette, MI Level II 21,355 20.0
Green Bay, WI Level II and III 104,057 167
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Google Maps
The Tilden operaon employs a total of 967 salaried and hourly employees, including Lake Superior & Ishpeming Railroad (LS&I) railroad staff, as of Q4
2021. The majority of the employees live within a 50 mi radius of the Property.
4.4 Infrastructure
The Property is located in a historically important, iron-producing region in Northern Michigan. All infrastructure necessary to mine and process
significant commercial quanes of iron ore exist at the current me. Infrastructure items include administraon buildings and offices, maintenance
shops, high-voltage electrical supplies, natural gas pipelines that connect into the North American distribuon system, concentrator, pellezing plant,
water sources, paved roads and highways, railroads for transporng raw materials and final product, port facilies that connect into the Great Lakes,
and towns where employees live. Additional details regarding Tilden infrastructure are provided in Section 15.0 of this TRS.
4.5 Physiography
The Property is within the limits of a topographic region known as the Superior Uplands, a part of the Canadian Shield. This region is more rugged than
the eastern poron of the Upper Peninsula, as it is dominated by Precambrian volcanic rocks and Archean basement rocks that were eroded down
over many glaciaon events. The Tilden Mine property features elevaons ranging from approximately 1,300 fasl to 1,800 fasl. Topography is hilly and
is dominated by glacially influenced landforms. Tilden is located in the Western Upper Peninsula Ecoregion (Secon IX) and characterized by a
landscape featuring moraines, drumlins, lake plains, outwash channels, outwash plains, and glacially eroded bedrock ridges (Albert, 1995).
Vegetaon in the vicinity of Tilden is described as northern hardwood forest dominated by sugar maple, eastern hemlock, basswood, yellow birch, and
sparse white pine. The Western Upper Peninsula Ecoregion also contains numerous bogs, tamarack-black spruce swamps, and hardwood-conifer
swamps. The bogs and wetlands include elm, green and black ash, and red and sugar maple. Upland wetlands (remnants of glacial lakebeds) support
ash, red maple, pin oak, and swamp white oak, whereas acidic,
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 30
-- 258 of 411 --
boggy sites may contain boreal flora that persist in this area as outliers of the Canadian forest, including black spruce, larch (tamarack), red maple,
several evergreen shrubs, and locally rare herbaceous plants that may grow on a mat of partially decomposed sphagnum moss (Sommers, 1984).
The soil profile in this part of Michigan’s Upper Peninsula is dominated by spodosols and histosols. Spodosols are formed in sandy material where
precipitaon is sufficient to allow large amounts of water to infiltrate the soil mulple mes per year. In Michigan, the spring snowmelt season
produces these types of conditions. Spodosols in Northern Michigan typically form under mixed forests of maple, pine, hemlock, and birch. Because of
the sandy nature of the soil, they have limited water storage capacity and are generally poor for farming. They also locally have varying horizons that
may feature abundant organic maSer, and aluminum and iron concentraons. Histosols are comprised mainly of organic materials and form in low
wetlands or bogs with reducing conditions that allow organic material to accumulate over a longer time period as compared to spodosols (Schaetzl and
Anderson, 2005).
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 31
-- 259 of 411 --
5.0 HISTORY
5.1 Prior Ownership
The Tilden Mine officially began operaon in 1974 under a partnership of Algoma Steel, Stelco, J&L Steel, Wheeling-PiSsburgh Steel, Sharon Steel, and
CCIC.The Property has since been at least parally in the possession of a subsidiary of Cliffs. Notable predecessors to the current evoluon of the
company were the Cleveland Iron Mining Company and the Iron Cliffs Company.The laSer was formed in 1865 by Samuel J. Tilden, a financier who
would become the governor of New York and a contender in the 1876 presidential election.
In November 2001, Cliffs announced the planned acquision of Algoma Steel's 45% interest in the Tilden Mine.In January 2003, Cliffs increased its
ownership of the adjacent Empire Mine to 79%, which led to the combination of the Empire and Tilden mining operations before the end of that year.
On August 27, 2007, U.S. Steel purchased Stelco and with it a 15% interest in Tilden L.C.In 2017, Cliffs purchased U.S. Steel’s interest, making Cliffs the
sole owner of Tilden L.C.
5.2 Exploration and Development History
Iron deposits in Northern Michigan were originally described in the early 1840s by Douglass Houghton, Michigan’s first State Geologist.Houghton
stated that iron deposits of unknown extent were to be found near the south shore of Lake Superior. In 1844, United States Deputy Surveyor William
Ausn Burt observed unusual variaons in his compass, which tended to behave strangely in the vicinity of certain outcrops that would later be
idenfied as a hemate-rich banded iron formaon (BIF). The first major discovery of high-grade iron oxides was in early 1845 near the present site of
Negaunee, Michigan (Sffler, 2010). The Jackson Mining Company was formed shortly thereaVer in July 1845, and iron mining in Michigan officially
began. The Cleveland Iron Company was formed in 1847 and began exploraon for iron ores just east of Ishpeming, Michigan.In 1850, the company
changed its name to the Cleveland Iron Mining Company and was granted a charter for mining, smelng, and manufacturing ores, minerals, and
metals. The Iron Cliffs Company formed in 1865 and began operaons at the Barnum Mine in 1867.By 1871, the Iron Cliffs Company owned a number
of small, direct-ship iron mines, including a mine referred to as the Tilden. There is liSle informaon regarding the original Tilden Mine, which was
focused on direct-ship ores.
Ores were shipped via the Sault Ste. Marie Ship Canal to furnaces on the lower Great Lakes starng in 1855, and tonnages gradually increased into the
laSer part of the 19 century. In 1891, the Cleveland-Cliffs Iron Company was founded through a merger of the Cleveland Iron Mining Company and
the Iron Cliffs Company. AVer World War II, the underground, high-grade iron mines were almost depleted. Extensive development of low-grade, open
pit mining began, and the first commercial agglomeraon (pellet) plant in the Lake Superior region started operaons in 1952. Agglomeraon was a
relavely new process that took the concentrate from lower-grade deposits and produced pellezed product containing approximately 65% Fe. The
Tilden Mine opened in 1974 after years of favorable experimental testing for processing of fine-grained hematite ores.
Site-standard analycal procedures of bench-scale flotaon and magnec iron determinaon by a saturaon magnezaon analyzer (Satmagan)
applied to drill core were developed prior to mining and continue to the present as described in section 8.1 of this TRS.
th
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 32
-- 260 of 411 --
Early regional geologic mapping was compiled by the United States Geological Survey (USGS) (Van Hise and Leith, 1911), and more detailed quadrangle
geologic mapping was completed in the mid-20 century (Gair, 1975; Simmons, 1974). Aeromagnec surveys were first completed in the region in the
1960s and documented by the USGS (Case and Gair, 1965).Cliffs and Tilden Mine do not maintain detailed records or results of early, non-drilling
prospecng methods used during inial exploraon acvies (ground geophysical surveys, trenching, test pits, etc.) conducted prior to Cliffs’
development of the operation in the early 1970s.
5.3 Historical Mineral Reserve Estimates
As the Property has since been at least parally in the possession of a subsidiary of Cliffs, there are no historical Mineral Resource or Mineral Reserve
estimates.
5.4 Past Production
The Property has produced pellets since 1974 and currently operates with a plant capacity of 7.7 MLT/y. Producon has been hemate flux pellets or
hemate/magnete flux since 1994. Magnete ores were processed from 1989 to 2009, and aVer 2009, remaining magnete ores were processed at
the Empire Mine prior to its indefinite idling in 2016. Table 5-1 shows the historical pellet production from the Mine and Plant since 1974.
Table 5-1: Historical Production
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Year Stripping
(kWLT)
Crude Ore (kWLT) Concentrate (kWLT) Pellets (kWLT)
Hem. Mag. Total Hem. Mag. Total Hem. Mag. Total
1974- 1989 0 198,998 6,305 205,303 81,688 1,991 83,679 72,442 1,796 74,238
1990- 1999 0 97,466 59,519 156,985 40,969 20,241 61,209 36,632 21,060 57,693
2000- 2009 0 139,884 40,371 180,255 59,636 15,560 75,196 55,268 15,149 70,417
2010 0 19,194 0 19,194 7,980 0 7,980 7,468 0 7,468
2011 0 20,850 0 20,850 8,374 0 8,374 7,794 0 7,794
2012 0 21,380 0 21,380 8,567 0 8,567 7,618 0 7,618
2013 0 20,114 0 20,114 7,922 0 7,922 7,485 0 7,485
2014 0 20,298 0 20,298 8,130 0 8,130 7,581 0 7,581
2015 0 19,661 0 19,661 7,998 0 7,998 7,631 0 7,631
2016 0 20,672 0 20,672 8,295 0 8,295 7,632 0 7,632
2017 0 21,007 0 21,007 8,157 0 8,157 7,650 0 7,650
2018 0 21,016 0 21,016 8,320 0 8,320 7,679 0 7,679
2019 0 21,500 0 21,500 8,312 0 8,312 7,708 0 7,708
2020 0 18,006 0 18,006 6,968 0 6,968 6,323 0 6,323
2021 0 21,482 0 21,482 8,238 0 8,238 7,365 0 7,365
TOTAL 0 681,528 106,195 787,723 279,554 37,792 317,345 254,276 38,005 292,282
th
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 33
-- 261 of 411 --
6.0 GEOLOGICAL SETTING, MINERALIZATION, AND DEPOSIT
6.1 Regional Geology
Essenal aspects of the regional geology in the Lake Superior region have been understood since the early 1900s, and the geologic understanding of
the area has remained relatively unchanged over the years.
Iron ores produced within the region range from high-grade, structurally controlled “natural” or direct-shipping iron ore (DSO) bodies to more
disseminated, stragraphically controlled, low-grade iron ores that require beneficiaon. The beneficiaon-grade deposits are found in a sequence of
Paleoproterozoic metasedimentary rocks overlying Archean granitic basement in the Lake Superior region.
The Palmer Gneiss represents the basement complex of Archean (2.6 Ga) granic gneiss underlying a thick sequence of variably metamorphosed
volcanic rocks and sedimentary rocks including iron formaons hosted within several stragraphic intervals. The principal iron formaons in Northern
Michigan are within the 1.9 Ga to 2.7 Ga Marquette Range Supergroup (Figure 6-1).
Paleoproterozoic rocks in the vicinity of Tilden consist of three subgroups: the Chocolay Group, the Menominee Group, and the Baraga Group. The
stragraphic sequence features shelf facies of quartzite and dolomite of the Chocolay Group underlying the Menominee Group of argillaceous rocks
and the major iron formaons. The Baraga Group is generally described as a volcanogenic unit of considerable thickness and complexity (Bayley and
James, 1973). In the area of the MarqueSe Range, it comprises sequences of turbidite, graywacke, and shale along with minor iron formaons. The
Baraga Group is roughly equivalent to the upper stragraphy of the Animikie Group in Minnesota.The Menominee Group is comprised of the basal
Ajibik Quartzite, the Siamo Slate, the Negaunee Iron Formaon (Negaunee IF), and riV-related mafic intrusive rocks. The Menominee Group contains
the 1.875 Ga iron formaons of economic significance and is correlave with the Animikie Group on the Mesabi Range of Minnesota (Figure 6-1),
which hosts several beneficiation-grade (magnetite “taconite”) mining operations.
The Menominee Group was determined to have been deposited between 1.9 Ga and 2.2 Ga by radiometric age dang (Van Schmus and Woolsey,
1975). Although the Menominee Group is stragraphically equivalent to the Animikie Group in Minnesota, units differ dramacally from one range to
the other in thickness, stragraphic details, and facies type. Sedimentary rocks were deformed and metamorphosed during the Penokean orogeny,
resulng in a wide range of metamorphic mineral assemblages and grades. The MarqueSe district, including the Tilden Mine, is one of the more
geologically complex iron mining districts in the Lake Superior region. Orogenic transpression resulted in a relavely ght, west-plunging syncline of
strata in the Chocolay and Menominee Groups (Figure 6‑3). To the north, the syncline is bounded by unconformably underlying rocks older than 2.5
Ga. To the west, the syncline opens to a thick sequence of graywacke and slate within the Baraga Group (Bayley and James, 1973). In the eastern part
of the syncline, the Negaunee IF can reach a thickness of 2,500 ft. The region along the fold axis of this syncline is referred to as the Marquette trough.
Regional structures include the Niagara Fault Zone, the collision zone between the Wisconsin Magmac Terrane, the Superior craton, and the Great
Lakes Tectonic Zone, which forms the boundary between Archean granite-greenstone and gneissic terranes (Sims et al., 1992). In the MarqueSe Range
area, deformation along the Great Lakes Tectonic Zone evolved from extension and deposition (Schneider et
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 34
-- 262 of 411 --
al., 2002). The resulng fault-bounded, shallowly west-plunging, asymmetric syncline contains a series of second-order growth fault basins that define
the detailed stratigraphic variations.
Source: Cannon, et al., 2007
Figure 6-1: Fe Formation Locations and Relevant Stratigraphy in the Lake Superior Region
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 35
-- 263 of 411 --
6.2 Local Geology
The Negaunee IF and its equivalents (Figure 6-3) host the majority of the iron deposits in Michigan.In the MarqueSe Range, the Negaunee IF reaches
a thickness of approximately 1,300 V. The Tilden Mine sits on the southern margin of the MarqueSe trough and is fault-bounded to the south by
Archean gneiss terrane, alternavely referred to as the Palmer Gneiss (Figure 6-2) or the Southern Complex (Figure 6-3). There is no formal
subdivision of the Negaunee IF, and stragraphy is generally discussed in relave terms from the boSom to the top of the unit (Figure 6-2). The
majority of the Negaunee IF consists of iron-rich carbonate, carbonate-silicate, or carbonate-oxide facies iron formaon (James, 1954; Gair, 1975)
roughly described in three zones from lowest to uppermost (Cannon, 1976). The lowest poron is interbedded at its base with the underlying Siamo
Slate and consists primarily of laminated chert and siderite. The middle poron is dominated by alternang thin layers of magnete, iron silicate
minerals, and chert. Silicate minerals are dominated by minnesotaite ((Fe ,Mg) Si O (OH) ), slpnomelane (K(Fe ,Mg,Fe ) (Si,Al) (O,OH) n(H O)),
and quartz (SiO ). The upper Negaunee IF is dominated by increasingly oxidized, hematite-jasper facies (jaspilite) iron formation. It exhibits a texture of
thinly interbedded, reddish chert and hematite (Fe O ) and marte, which is a pseudomorph of hemate occurring aVer magnete (Bayley and James,
1973).
Two ages of mafic igneous rocks occur in the Mine: syn-sedimentary sills and associated dikes and a younger dike series of Keweenawan age
(approximately 1.0 Ga) that is related to the Midconnent RiV. The older intrusions vary from fine porphyric to diabasic or ophic in composion and
texture and typically display chlorite-carbonate alteraon assemblages, parcularly in deformaon zones. The iron formaon is variably altered along
all intrusive contacts, with the type and extent of alteraon dependent on the thickness of the intrusive and the composion of the iron formaon
(Lukey et al., 2007).
Local structure is characterized by second-order, steeply inclined anclines and synclines with shallow northwest and southwest plunges. Major
structures include the large-scale (hundreds of feet) Main Pit ancline and a fault that marks the contact between Archean gneiss terrane and the iron
formation. The fold is asymmetric, with the southern limb steeper than the northern limb, with an axial plane that dips steeply north and a hinge line
that plunges 30° northwest. The fault, inially a basin-margin, listric normal fault, was reacvated and is now a reverse fault that dips approximately
65° north (Cambray, 2002). Smaller faults and folds, on a scale of one meter to 20 m, are observed in the pit to follow trends of larger, regional-scale
structures. These structures tend to reflect ducle deformaon in the Tilden Main Pit, where folds with sheared limbs are common (Lukey et al.,
2007).
2+ 3 4 10 2 2+ 3+ 8 12 27 2
2
2 3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 36
-- 264 of 411 --
Eon Group-Series-Period Formation Tilden Mine Chronostratigraphy
Phanerozoic Quaternary Glacial Sediments Overburden
Unconformity
Proterozoic
Keweenawan Series Dikes
Metadiabase 200 Series Diabase Dikes and Sills
Marquette Range Supergroup – Menominee Group Negaunee Iron Formation
500 Series
400 Series
300 Series
100 (Empire) Series
Empire Series
Siamo Slate
Palmer Fault / Unconformity
Archean Palmer Gneiss
Figure 6-2: Chronostratigraphic Column for the Tilden Mine
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 37
-- 265 of 411 --
Source: Modified from Lukey, 2007
Figure 6-3: General Geology of the Marquette Range Supergroup and Tilden Mine Location
6.3 Property Geology
The Tilden BIF deposit forms the base of the Negaunee IF of the Menominee Group within the MarqueSe Range Super Group.The Tilden BIF is
Proterozoic in age and sits on the southern margin of the MarqueSe trough. It is fault-bounded to the south by Archean gneiss terrane, with the fault
contact dipping steeply north and aligning with the south wall of the Main Pit at Tilden.
The Tilden BIF is interbedded with three disnct, syn-sedimentary, mafic intrusive sills: The Summit Mountain Sill, the Suicide Sill, and the Tilden Lake
Sill, as well as associated smaller dikes and sills. There is a younger dike series of Keweenawan age (approximately 1.0 Ga) that crosscuts bedding.
Alteraon is present along all intrusive contacts, with the type and extent of alteraon dependent on the thickness of the intrusive and the
composition of the iron formation (Lukey et al., 2007). Brittle fractures and late quartz veins cut all units.
Tilden is dominated by a 100 m-scale, northwest-plunging ancline. The hinge line of the ancline dips steeply north, plunges 30°NW, and runs down
the center of the Main Pit. The hinge line of the ancline is mapped locally coincident with the Keweenawan Dike. The Summit Mountain Sill, locally
termed the Pillar Intrusive, defines the asymmetry and orientaon of the ancline. Smaller faults and folds, on a scale of one meter to 20 m, are
observed in the Main Pit to follow trends of larger, regional-scale structures. These structures tend to reflect ducle deformaon in the Main Pit,
where folds with
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 38
-- 266 of 411 --
sheared limbs are common (Lukey et al., 2007). The orientation and geometry of bedding at Tilden is presented in Figure 6-4.
To date, there has been no formal subdivision of the Negaunee IF at Tilden, and stragraphy is discussed in relave terms from boSom to top. A
stragraphic secon, without formal names or dates, was prepared by SLR and is presented in Figure 6-5.Stragraphically, the upward mineralogical
variaon is from (marte)-magnete-carbonate-chlorite (“Carbonate”) to (magnete)-marte (“Martite”) to (marte)-microplaty hemate-goethite
(“Hematite”) and represents a transion upwards from dominantly ferrous iron (Fe ) mineralogy to dominantly ferric iron (Fe ) mineralogy (Lukey et
al., 2007). Some BIF units were disrupted during turbidite flows that manifest as disconnuous lenses of clasc material.Clasc lithology is most
prevalent along the boSom (southern) contact with the Archean gneiss. All BIF units are ferrous iron-dominant and increase in ferric iron content
upward (generally northward and westward).
6.3.1 Mineralization
The Tilden Mine is unique among Cliffs’ operaons because the primary ore mineral at Tilden is hemate, with other minerals including marte
(oxidized pseudomorph of magnete), goethite, and siderite (iron carbonate mineral), as opposed to strictly magnete. Tilden is also unique in the
world in that the hemate-dominant ore is mined at a low grade, concentrated using a selecve-flocculaon desliming and flotaon process, and
pelletized. Although some now-expended areas at Tilden did mine and magnecally recover magnete-dominant ore prior to 2009, remaining Mineral
Resources at Tilden are hematite-dominant. The adjacent Empire deposit hosted primarily magnete ore, and unoxidized magnete is variably present
at Tilden.
2+ 3+
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 39
-- 267 of 411 --
Figure 6-4: West-Facing Cross-section at 26,083,620 ft E Showing Anticlinal Shape and Geology of Tilden
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 40
-- 268 of 411 --
Figure 6-5: Basic Stratigraphic Section Local to Tilden
At Tilden, the Negaunee IF can be divided into five distinct facies:
• ClasNc Iron FormaNon (IFCL) Units: Varying thickness of interbedded slate with laminated chert, iron silicate, and siderite. Clascs have a lower
weight recovery (wtrec) due to the presence of interbedded clastic material. They are highly oxidized in the east side of the Main Pit.
• Carbonaceous Iron FormaNon (IFCB) Units: Alternang thin layers of magnete, marte (oxidized pseudomorph of magnete), iron silicate
minerals, iron carbonate minerals and chert. Carbonate material is characterized by the presence of siderite (iron carbonate mineral), low
phosphorus, and higher wtrec.
• MarNte Iron FormaNon (IFCH) Units: Thicker beds of hemate-marte-chert with intervals of magnete-carbonate. The oxidaon level
increases in the east and where proximal to intrusive sills.
• MagneNc Iron FormaNon Units: Magnete domain consisng of magnete-carbonate and magnete-silicate-chert with variable oxidaon. It is
defined principally by magnete content and is generally fresh, with some localized oxidaon. At Tilden, it is found within and defines the (now
expended) material of the CDIII Pit.
• HemaNte Iron FormaNon Units: The oxidized equivalent of the Magnete Iron Formaon prominent in both the Empire deposit and in the east
side of the Main Pit, is located stragraphically above the Summit Mountain Sill.It is dominantly composed of hemate and chert interbeds. At
Tilden, this unit has locally very high levels of silica and phosphorus in concentrate (consio2 and conphos, respectively).
The iron formaon facies at Tilden have also been modified by clay-silicate alteraon associated with Keweenawan faults in the east of the Main Pit, as
well as varying levels of oxidation throughout.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 41
-- 269 of 411 --
SLR notes that these facies represent connuums of changing iron speciaon and mineralogy due to both deposional environment condions and
later-stage alteraon and oxidaon. Clasc-bearing iron formaon units are grouped by the presence of clasc material but have varying mineralogy
resulting from the nature of formation – turbidite flows of varying energy levels occurring in different depositional environments and time periods that
remobilized sediments characterisc of that posion and incorporated transported exoc rock fragments. Drill hole logging at Tilden over me has
also inconsistently represented mineralogy according to perceived importance as well as logged abundance, and the oVen fine-grained nature of the
rock has made it difficult to define facies with confidence. SLR recommends carrying out a mineralogical study to beSer understand iron mineral
speciaon at Tilden as it relates to geology, stragraphy, and (importantly) plant flotaon, as well as connuing efforts to construct a stragraphic
section and develop a standard operating procedure for detailed logging of drill core going forward.
Tilden Mine geology is described on site using broad geological groupings as listed in Table 6-1. The primary ore-bearing and non-ore-bearing domains
are further categorized based on a variety of lithological, alteraon, and analycal (recoverable iron grade, deleterious element grades) parameters as
well as spaal references that are used for ore control purposes. Selected geometallurgical (code1) subgroupings are shown in Figure 6-6. A full
description of code1 subgroupings is included in Appendix section 27.1 Geometallurgical Domains.
Table 6-1: Geometallurgical Groupings at Tilden
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Group Name General Description
100 Lower Series Archaean-aged, non-iron formation rocks which form the south wall of the Main Pit.
200 Intrusive Sills and Dikes
Mafic rocks which vary from diabasic to porphyritic to aphanitic. All units appear to thin to the west and south. Contacts
tend to be sheared and locally oxidized. Contact metamorphism of the iron formation is minimal and, if present, results in
finer-grained iron formation. Synclinal structures and intersections with dikes have focused oxidation of the iron formation
300 Main Pit Carbonate Iron
Formation
Contains iron formation units stratigraphically below the CDIII footwall metadiabase and/or the East Pit hanging-wall
metadiabase. Includes numerous small, mafic intrusive dikes and sills.
400 Northwest Iron Formation
Domain
Stratigraphically between the CDIII/West Pit hanging-wall metadiabase and CDIII footwall. Includes numerous small dikes
and sills.
500 West Iron Formation Domain Stratigraphically above CDIII/West Pit hanging-wall metadiabase and below North Intrusive; it includes numerous dikes and
one mappable intrusive body.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 42
-- 270 of 411 --
Figure 6-6: Selected Geometallurgical (code1) Groupings and Sub-groupings at Tilden
The structural control and stragraphic upward changes in mineralogy imply a combinaon of original sedimentaon and post-deposional fluid
alteraon as the likely cause of increasing oxidaon and hydraon up-sequence. The four primary types of iron ores are centered on the anclinal axis
and trend upwards from Fe and elevated magnesium (Mg), calcium (Ca), manganese (Mn), and aluminum (Al) to Fe and decreased trace elements,
but increased phosphorus content due to weathering. Bedding changes from thick (cenmeter scale) to thin (millimeter scale) are indicave of varying
deposional condions and silica (SiO ) mobilizaon. The presence of microplaty hemate in relavely reduced (magnete-carbonate-chlorite) and
oxidized (martite-goethite) assemblages may be indicative of deposition and/or an evolving fluid system.
6.4 Deposit Types
6.4.1 Mineral Deposit
The Tilden iron deposit is an example of a Lake Superior-type BIF deposit.These types of deposits occur worldwide, represent the largest global source
of iron ore, and were deposited between 2,700 Ma and 1,800 Ma, formed by chemical precipitaon in shallow waters such as connental shelves.
Precipitaon of iron oxides was due to low atmospheric and ocean oxygen levels resulng in increased iron content in sea water. These deposits are
typically characterized by alternating layers of iron oxides and SiO -rich material such as cherts or SiO -rich sediments.
The Tilden Mine is unique among Cliffs-owned operaons because the primary ore mineral at Tilden is hemate, with other minerals being marte
(oxidized pseudomorph of magnete), goethite, and siderite (iron carbonate mineral), as opposed to strictly magnete. Tilden is also unique in the
world in that the hemate-dominant ore is mined at a low grade, concentrated using a selecve-flocculaon desliming and flotaon process, and
pelletized. Although some now-expended areas at Tilden did mine and magnecally recover magnete-dominant ore prior to 2009, remaining Mineral
Resources at Tilden
2+ 3+
2
2 2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 43
-- 271 of 411 --
are hemate dominant. The adjacent (now indefinitely idled) Empire deposit hosted primarily magnete ore, and unoxidized magnete is variably
present at Tilden.
6.4.2 Geological Model
Cliffs is using a Lake Superior-type BIF geologic model based on geologic interpretaon of the Negaunee IF and its structure derived from peer-
reviewed journal articles (Gair, 1975; Cannon, 1976; Lukey et al., 2007).
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 44
-- 272 of 411 --
7.0 EXPLORATION
Cliffs and Tilden L.C. do not maintain detailed records or results of non-drilling prospecng methods used during inial exploraon acvies, such as
geophysical surveys, mapping, trenching, and test pits, conducted prior to Cliffs’ development of the operaon. No materially significant exploraon
work or invesgaons other than drilling and limited pit mapping have been conducted by Cliffs at Tilden. Historical mapping compiled by the USGS
prior to mining is detailed in section 5.2.
7.1 Exploration Drilling
7.1.1 Drilling Type and Extent
The Tilden drill hole database consists of 382,605 V of drill hole informaon in 578 drill holes, completed from the 1950s to 2020. Annual exploraon
drilling programs at Tilden have completed zero to 42 drill holes. Of the last 10 years, nine have included drill hole programs and have averaged 10
drill holes per year. Diamond, hammer, and churn drilling have all been employed at Tilden, with diamond drilling having been exclusively used since
2008.
Completed drill hole collar locaons are recorded by the mine surveyor using a Trimble R8 GNSS receiver and TSC3 data collector.Since the 1990s,
downhole deviaon surveys have been performed, inially using a crude clay impression procedure, followed by a non-magnec reflex gyro once the
technology was developed. Drill core at Tilden is generally competent and has good recovery.
A summary of the drill hole database is provided in Table 7-1 and collar locaons are shown in Figure 7-1. Assay informaon for holes drilled in 2019
and 2020 east of the CD5 Pit area (northeast area in Figure 7-1) were not available and, as such, the CD5 area has not been included in SLR’s drill hole
summary. Downhole informaon from Empire drill holes was also not available, and the holes are excluded from the SLR Mineral Resource esmate as
well as the summary in Table 7-1. SLR recommends integrang the downhole informaon from the Empire and Tilden mines into a single valid
database.
Table 7-1: Summary of the Tilden Mine Drill Hole Database
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Drill Type Unk. 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s 1990s 2000s 2010s 2020 Total
Unknown
No. Holes 14 - - - - - - - - 14
Length (ft) 8,962 - - - - - - - - 8,962
Hammer
No. Holes 1 - - 113 10 109 20 - - 253
Length (ft) 790 - - 56,508 4,179 60,991 16,360 - - 138,828
Churn
No. Holes - - 2 1 - - - - - 3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 45
-- 273 of 411 --
Drill Type Unk. 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s 1990s 2000s 2010s 2020 Total
Length (ft) - - 554 1,401 - - - - - 1,955
Diamond
No. Holes - 29 78 51 8 10 13 109 10 308
Length (ft) - 17,471 62,948 30,352 6,430 7,120 8,589 94,987 4,964 232,860
Total No. Holes 15 29 80 165 18 119 33 109 10 578
Total Length (ft) 9,752 17,471 63,502 88,261 10,609 68,111 24,949 94,987 4,964 382,605
Notes:
1. Excludes Empire Mine drill holes.
Geology has been logged at Tilden considering five broad geologic groupings based on geological and metallurgical data, as well as approximately 30
highly specific geometallurgical domains based on geometallurgical test results, which are subsequently grouped for mine planning.
Drill core is photographed, and rock quality designaon (RQD) is recorded for all drill core. Currently, Tilden drill hole logging procedures aSempt to
capture magnec characteriscs, alteraon, mineralogy, textures, and structural informaon; however, the fine-grained nature of the lithologies can
inhibit rock-type designaon based on visual observaon, and recent drill logs are generally brief. Final lithological coding is re-interpreted considering
the results of metallurgical testing in the context of spatial and geometallurgical characteristics.
During 2020, Cliffs personnel digized details of historical logs previously available in paper format only, and this informaon has been incorporated
into the SLR modeling work. SLR recommends that detailed lithological logs that capture iron speciation, alteration, mineralogy, structure, and lithology
be collected on all drill core, and recommends invesgang alternave tools to capture informaon during inial logging, including a magnetometer
and hyperspectral and X-ray fluorescence hand-held devices to allow empirical measurements of magnesm (where relevant), alteraon such as clay,
and iron speciaon. SLR also recommends a formal separaon between inial geological observaons in drill core and subsequent re-interpretaons
based on metallurgical results or results of neighboring drill holes.
SLR notes that the density of drill hole informaon at Tilden decreases outside the current pit limits and recommends addional drilling within and
adjacent to the LOM plan area with a focus on material at depth. SLR also recommends closer spaced drilling where the iron formaon is impacted by
silica alteration, or in and adjacent to areas understood to have high oxidation but defined by older drill holes with absent conphos values.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 46
-- 274 of 411 --
Figure 7-1: Drill Hole Collar Location
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 47
-- 275 of 411 --
7.1.2. Procedures and Parameters
Prior to drilling, drill hole collars are located by a Cliffs geologist using a global positioning system (GPS) and marked with a wooden post.
The collar of each completed drill hole is surveyed by the mine surveyor using a Trimble R8 GNSS receiver and TSC3 data collector. The collar
coordinates in Michigan State Plane for horizontal locaon and elevaon above mean sea level are verified by the project geologist. Final collar
coordinates are validated in the office by the project geologist and incorporated into Cliffs’ acQuire drill hole database.
7.1.3. Downhole Survey
Downhole surveys are conducted with a REFLEX gyro MEMS tool.This downhole instrument is specifically designed for use in areas where magnesm
may be an issue. Measurements are taken every 20 V down the hole. The instrument is field calibrated using five rotaons in the field stand prior to
being used down a hole.
Prior to the gyroscopic technology being available, downhole deviaons were determined by older techniques, primarily a clay impression procedure.
Downhole surveys were not conducted on reverse circulaon holes drilled up unl the 1990s. Downhole surveys are not conducted on holes with
depths less than 500 ft. Over 75% of the holes are vertical, with most others oriented to the south and angled from 30° to near vertical.
7.1.4. Core Handling and Security
Core is transported from the drill site to the logging facility by the project geologist or by the contracted drilling company. A Cliffs geologist ensures
the following:
• The integrity of the core when taken from the core barrels to the gutter.
• Placement of core in clean, unused, waxed core boxes.
• The cores in the boxes were posioned in the correct direcon and sequence when transferred from the core barrel or guSer to the core boxes,
making sure there was no inversion during the transfer process.
• A wooden block in the core box at the end of each core run that has hole depth in feet at that specific point written on it in permanent marker.
• Idenficaon on the boxes is made on the pre-printed templates located on core box tops and on the end panels of the core box tops and
bottoms. This information includes the hole number, footage contained in the box (from-to), and the box number.
• Transportation of core to the onsite core storage facility for logging and sampling.
7.1.5 Sampling Methods and Sample Quality
The indicated depths on the blocks, marking core barrel runs in the boxes and the depths noted on the outside of the core boxes, are verified in
contractor drill reports. Daily drill rod counts are performed by the drill contactor to verify drill depth. The final depth of the drill hole is confirmed and
registered in the drill report. Hole size and final hole depth are authorized by the project geologist.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 48
-- 276 of 411 --
Core is photographed digitally, and photographs are archived on a local area network with a hole number and depth for future reference. These digital
images are backed up daily as part of Cliffs’ normal daily backup procedure described in secon 8.2. Images are acquired in an environment that
permits consistency in distance to core, lighting, and exposure. Core was not photographed before 2003.
Geotechnical core measurements include core recovery percentage and RQD. Data are recorded in an Excel spreadsheet for later upload into the
acQuire database or directly into the acQuire database.
Geological logging of the core is done by a Cliffs geologist, digitally, using acQuire for database management. Logging includes rock type, magnec
characteriscs, alteraon, mineralogy, observed textures, structural informaon, geotechnical data, and a general geologic descripon. The
interpreted metallurgical domain is included in the geological log. Hard copies of all completed drill logs are stored on site. Logging is completed
before sampling.
The core sample intervals are marked by a Cliffs geologist, and the core is split lengthwise with a hydraulic spliSer. Core has been split since 2003, with
the excepon of the 2017 drilling program, when core was fully consumed due to me constraints. Cliffs maintains a document lisng historical core
saves.
Samples are taken to represent the full height of a 45 V mining bench, broken by geological contacts. Sample lengths are dependent on the angle of
the hole, and sample beginning/end points are selected to coincide with the top and boSom of the 45 V mining benches. The sample length is ideally
the height of a mining bench at 45 V but ranges from 5 V to 70 V within a defined geological domain. The average length of sample intervals at the
Tilden is 40 V. The large range in sample lengths is due to samples matching a bench width; in angled holes the distance between bench intersecons
is greater than 45 ft.
Core is stored within a locked warehouse at the mine site before processing and is transported to the Tilden laboratory, where it is kept within the
laboratory building until processed. The Tilden Mine core storage facility is locked at all times in the absence of authorized Tilden personnel.
Each sample is labeled to include a unique idenfier including the hole number, footage interval, and bag number sequence. A tag is put inside the
bag, and a second tag is ed to the bag on a string. The sample number is a unique idenficaon number (ID) that es it to a specific drill hole and
interval and which cannot be mistaken for other types of samples. Alphabecal characters idenfy the next sample in sequence for each hole. For
example, the interval of 0 V to 45 V from drill hole 23679 would be sample 23679 0-45A; the next sample would be 23679 45-90B for the interval of 45
ft to 90 ft. All sample parts and splits are stored at Cliffs Technical Group (CTG) research laboratory facility.
7.1.6 Drilling, Sampling, or Recovery Factors
There are no known drilling, sampling, or recovery factors that would affect the reliability of the analycal results described in Secon 9.0 of this
report. Core recovery is generally very good with greater than 90% core recovered. There are localized areas where the iron formaon is oxidized to
varying degrees, which can impact core recovery and sample quality. Oxidized zones are associated with proximity to fault zones. Rock quality is
generally very good per section 7.1.1. Localized zones of poorer rock quality exist adjacent to fault zones.
SLR understands that the pracce of taking long drill core samples has been adopted to address laboratory processing constraints and recommends
addressing those constraints at the Tilden
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 49
-- 277 of 411 --
laboratory. SLR recommends that Cliffs undertake a study where samples are consistently taken at 15 V intervals, broken by geology, to examine how
the variance of the assays are affected, and how the material type designaon, based on a calculaon of those variables, compares against the
material type designation of longer samples.
The Tilden BIF is well sampled (over 90%).Unsampled intervals within the modeled BIF unit represent either BIF, intrusive, overburden, or backfill
material. By length, approximately 80% of drill hole samples logged as intrusive material within the BIF (small dikes) is unsampled, and overall, drill
hole intervals logged as intrusive represent approximately 3% of the total intervals within BIF units. SLR recommends sampling intrusive material too
small to be modeled or segregated when mining (dilution).
7.1.7 Drilling Results and Interpretation
The drilling has taken place over more than 50 years and has defined a large iron ore deposit at Tilden. It is SLR’s opinion that the drilling and sampling
procedures at Tilden are adequate for use in the esmaon of Mineral Resources. There are no known drilling, sampling, or recovery factors that
would affect the reliability of the analytical results described in Section 8.0 of this TRS.
7.2 Geological Mapping
Geologic structures are locally digitized annually from light imaging, detection, and ranging (LiDAR) data that are draped with digital orthophotography.
Fault zones are digized on the screen and verified through field observaons of bench faces. Data, including fault or joint orientaons and bedding
planes, are compiled and stored in Maptek Vulcan™ (Vulcan) mine planning soVware. The base purpose of the mapping is for monitoring of local
geotechnical zones; however, the data were used where possible to inform the geologic model (see section 11.3).
7.3 Hydrogeology and Geotechnical Data
Refer to section 13.2 Pit Geotechnical and section 15.4 Tailings Disposal for this information.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 50
-- 278 of 411 --
8.0 SAMPLE PREPARATION, ANALYSES, AND SECURITY
8.1 Sample Preparation and Analysis
8.1.1 Sample Preparation
Sample preparaon and analysis of diamond drill core and blast hole samples for use in resource esmaon is conducted at the onsite Tilden
laboratory. The Tilden-owned facility is accredited to Internaonal Organizaon for Standardizaon (ISO)-9001:2015 for its quality management
system.
Upon receipt of samples to the Tilden laboratory, drill hole samples are oven dried, crushed to -3” in a jaw crusher and to -¼ in. in a cone crusher, then
split using a Gilson SP-1 sample splitter.
A subsample from 15 lb to 50 lb is reduced to 100% passing -10 mesh with a roll crusher and then cone mixed on a five-stage, inverted cone mixer. A
50 g subsample is taken, pulverized to -100 mesh using a plate pulverizer, and further split to a 25 g sample, which is analyzed for crude iron content
(crudefe); two 10 g subsamples of the crude material are used for x-ray fluorescence (XRF) and Satmagan analysis.
A second and a third 600 g subsample of material passing -10 mesh roll crusher are collected using a riffle spliSer. One of the samples is archived, and
the second is submitted for a bench flotation test. A procedural flow chart is shown in Figure 8-1.
8.1.2 Sample Assaying and Analytical Procedures
Samples are analyzed at the Tilden laboratory. The laboratory is not independent of Cliffs. Sample analysis includes the evaluaon of head samples
and the production of a flotation concentrate. The flotation concentrate fractions undergo further analysis for various properties.
The bench flotaon test has been developed for and is unique to Tilden (procedure 0903Q0200, Figure 8-2).It has been customized to mimic Tilden’s
plant flotaon cycle. It involves grinding material in a miniature rod mill for a specific me and producing a concentrate material from a mixture of
sample, test water, causc soluon, and sodium hexametaphosphate (dispersant) within a Wemco flotaon machine. The Tilden laboratory technician
operating the machine produces six concentrate products (A to F) similar to the plant cycle, which are measured and recombined for grind analysis and
to record the wtrec. Twenty-five gram subsamples of the concentrate material are submiSed for analysis of iron content (confe) by traon method,
magnetic iron content (magfe) using a Satmagan instrument, and SiO (consio2), CaO, MgO, Mn, Al O , and P (conphos) by XRF.
The principal variables used in the determinaon of Mineral Resources at Tilden are confe, consio2, conphos, wtrec, and crudefe. The bench flotaon
test is described in more detail in Section 10.0 of this report.
Over me, several procedural changes have taken place at the Tilden laboratory, including the sample grind me, and type and amount of the starch
addive during the bench flotaon test. These changes have been iniated to align with changing plant procedures, incorporate new technology, and
address processing delays and quality issues at the Tilden laboratory and in the mine. They have been applied to drill and blast hole samples
differently, and at different mes. In addion, at some point in the past, to beSer align wtrec results in blast hole assays with plant readings that
reference natural moisture instead of the dried value from the laboratory, a standard +3% was added to the blast hole wtrec laboratory values. There
is no record of the exact timing of implementation, or whether blast hole data prior to
2 2 3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 51
-- 279 of 411 --
implementaon was affected. The impact of these procedural changes, as well as variaon in the flotaon test operaon by different laboratory
technicians (which has a large manual component that is difficult to standardize), has not been well documented or monitored despite being long
suspected of contribung to bias between sample results. Cliffs is working to enhance the sample database aSributes, which would allow the impact
of these changes to be beSer understood and quanfied, as well as decouple data manipulaon from original assay results. SLR strongly supports
these initiatives and presents some preliminary observations in Section 9.0.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 52
-- 280 of 411 --
Figure 8-1: Drill Hole Sample Preparation Process
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 53
-- 281 of 411 --
Figure 8-2: Drill Core Bench Flotation Test Process
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 54
-- 282 of 411 --
8.1.3 Density Analysis
Tonnage factors applied at Tilden are based on density values from 116 samples tested by water immersion from four material types at the adjacent,
on-strike Empire Mine (Nummela and Anderson, 1970).Bulk hand samples ranging from 10 lb to 23 lb were taken from blast paSerns with a wide
range in magnetic and soluble iron. These samples had a large variance in observed grain size, lithologic characteriscs, and mineralogy that is found in
the clasc, carbonate, and silicate facies of the Empire Mine. Samples were selected that were relavely homogeneous, visibly unfractured, and
unweathered. SLR notes that no allowance was made for jointing and fracturing. While individual immersion results are tabulated on historical reports,
exact spatial distribution of the samples has not been established.
The following regression calculation for iron formation was developed using crudefe:
Tonnage Factor (cubic feet per long ton) = 13.45 – (0.0792 * crudefe)
Average tonnage factors for non-iron formation material were also determined.
8.1.3.1 Validation of Tonnage Factor Equation
In 2021, the Tilden Mine Engineering Department undertook to compare the different onsite tonnage measurements, in part, to assess the validity of
the tonnage factor equation. Cliffs compared the following measurements representing 2019 and 2020 mined material:
1. Reported tons from the belt scale.
2. Dispatch recorded truck tons measured by onboard payload scales.
3. Predicted tons measured from the volume of material mined multiplied by the estimated tonnage factor for each lithology.
Overall, reported tons were determined to be 1.5% higher than predicted tons, although local area differences ranged from -9% to +6%. Local
variances in predicted to reported tons were explained by an overpredicon of overburden in some areas, underpredicon of in situ material (due to
underreported presence of old fill ramps) in other areas, and small inaccuracies in the topography due to overflow from higher benches.
In parallel to this validaon work, the geology department at Tilden and CTG undertook addional sampling work to further confirm that the
regression equation developed using Empire samples, which are relatively unoxidized compared to Tilden material, is suitable for use at Tilden.
A total of 217 samples of crushed -10 mesh (coarse reject) material, represenng a suite of material types, soluble iron content, and trace-element
chemistry, and selected from 22 historical diamond drill holes across the Tilden pit were collected from storage for tesng at CTG’s laboratory. The
laboratory, located in Ishpeming, Michigan, provides in-house analycal services for all of Cliffs’ iron ore operaons. The CTG laboratory is accredited
with ASQ/ANSI ISO-9001:2015 for its system of quality management. The most recent certificate renewal was completed in 2021.
Results were ploSed against crude soluble iron content (crudefe; determined using both wet chemistry and calculated methods), linear regression
lines were plotted and are shown in Figure 8-3. Comparisons considering material type and trace element chemistry were also completed (not shown).
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 55
-- 283 of 411 --
crudefe (%) by wet chemistry
crudefe (%) calculated
Source: Orobona (2021)
Figure 8-3: Least Squares Regression Plots of (A) Soluble Fe by Wet Chemistry versus Density and (B) Soluble Fe Weight Calculated from Bench
Flotation Products versus Density
The regression model determined using Tilden’s data is nearly idencal to the tonnage calculaon based on a similar pycnometer study conducted in
1970 for the nearby Empire Mine, and based on 41 pycnometer tests, and as expected, below the 1970 Empire immersion data defining the current
tonnage factor equation (Figure 8-4).
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 56
-- 284 of 411 --
Source: Orobona (2021)
Figure 8-4: Comparison of Empire Immersion Tonnage Factor Regression Used in Tilden Model and Other Density Studies
As the Empire and Tilden pycnometer sample regressions virtually overlap, Cliffs has presumed that a regression of Tilden sample immersion data
should similarly overlap with that of Empire samples, where based on similar rock types and assuming a similar porosity. These results, alongside the
volumetric analysis completed by Tilden Mine Engineering Department, support the connued use of the tonnage factor regression equaon at
Tilden.
8.2 Sample Security
Samples collected and submiSed to the Tilden laboratory are accompanied by submission forms. There is no offsite laboratory, and samples do not
leave the Tilden property.
Digital copies of drill core and blast hole analysis from the Tilden laboratory are stored in a MicrosoV (MS) Access databases with restricted access and
regular backups. There is a manual component in transferring data between different departments and users, and the system does not include
automated checks of data validity or integrity and allows for authorized users to manipulate entries. SLR understands that Tilden is in the process of
migrang to an acQuire system, which will integrate addional security and data integrity measures and is accompanied by a data verificaon process
at the point of transition. SLR strongly supports this initiative.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 57
-- 285 of 411 --
8.3 Quality Assurance/Control Procedures
Quality assurance (QA) consists of evidence to demonstrate that the assay data has precision and accuracy within generally accepted limits for the
sampling and analycal method(s) used in order to have confidence in a Mineral Resource esmate. Quality control (QC) consists of procedures used
to ensure that an adequate level of quality is maintained in the process of collecng, preparing, and assaying the exploraon drilling samples. In
general, QA/QC programs are designed to prevent or detect contamination and allow assaying (analytical), precision (repeatability), and accuracy to be
quantified. In addition, a QA/QC program can disclose the overall sampling-assaying variability of the sampling method itself.
The standard operang procedure at Tilden does not prescribe the inclusion or analysis of field, coarse, or pulp duplicate samples, and no QA/QC
samples are included with regularity alongside batches of exploraon drill or blast hole samples. An in-house reference sample, the Marte Master
Composite (the Standard), is analyzed by the Tilden laboratory monthly using the same protocols as applied to the blast holes. Results are graphed
against the average grade of the dataset, evaluated considering the range of accepted values represented by three standard deviaons (SD) of the
enre populaon of data, and compared to accepted and historical values as part of the internal laboratory QA/QC program.The Standard was
generated in the early 1980s and is based on a composite of material collected over different areas of the Main Pit at that me, crushed, mixed, and
stored in 60 gal drums, which are split as needed into batches of approximately five hundred, 600 g samples. Due to the custom nature of the bench
flotaon test and associated custom equipment, check assays at external laboratories are not performed. Coarse blank reference samples are not
relevant at Tilden and are not used. The Tilden laboratory internal QA/QC program includes equipment calibration and monitoring.
Two addional reference standards have been developed and are included as part of the ore control procedures. SLR understands that the associated
datasets at present are quite small, and that the standards are of lower quality than the Martite Master Composite. SLR did not review the protocols or
results of these reference materials.
Due to the relavely small exploraon drilling and sampling programs undertaken annually at Tilden, it is difficult to include reference material
alongside exploraon samples at a rate that is both stascally significant, as well as represenng no more than 5% of the total sample submission,
which is important as the Tilden laboratory is currently operang at maximum capacity, and the bench flotaon test is me consuming to complete
and priorizes grade control samples. As both drill and blast holes are analyzed at the same laboratory, and as blast holes are included in the Mineral
Resource esmate in a limited capacity, SLR suggests including coarse duplicate tests at a rate of 1 in 50 with blast hole sample submissions. Although
the preparaon stage of these samples is not idencal to exploraon drill hole samples, general conclusions could likely be made by reviewing these
results.
8.3.1 Metallurgical Reference Samples
Monthly Marte Master sample results are charted and tested for failures compared to previous results. An example of such control charts and test
rules is illustrated in Figure 8-5.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 58
-- 286 of 411 --
Figure 8-5: Example of Control Charting of the Monthly Martite Master Composite
Control limits are based on the common approach for Shewhart control charts. For individual samples, control limits are Mean ± 2.66 * Mean
. For the moving range charts, control limits are 3.267 * Mean . In both cases, 1σ and 2σ are / and / of the difference between the
mean(s) and control limits, respecvely. This approach is commonly used in stascal process control soVware and narrows control limits relave to
three standard deviations (SD) from the mean of the data.
When a failure is reported for a Standard test, an invesgaon is iniated by the Laboratory Supervisor. The QC Technician who performed the test is
interviewed. If nothing out of the ordinary was observed during the bench process or analysis, then associated equipment will be checked for
malfunctions using available standards and test equipment. If no equipment is found to be in error or disrepair, the Marte Standard will be run again.
This could be by the same QC Technician or by another, depending on the suspected cause and resource availability. The re-test may be monitored by
the Laboratory Supervisor. If the re-test results remain outside of control limits, the Laboratory Supervisor will consult with process engineers and
connue re-tesng and equipment evaluaon. In some cases, the Laboratory Supervisor and engineers may agree that the change is due to process
water, a change in reagent supply, or other change outside of the laboratory’s control.
data moving
range moving range 1 3 2 3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 59
-- 287 of 411 --
8.3.2 2019 Duplicate Sample Program
During 2019, 50 blind coarse reject samples represenng approximately 6% of exploraon drill hole samples since 2014 were analyzed, and results
were compared to the original assay data for the key economic variables of crudefe, wtrec, and consio2, confe, and conphos. The coarse reject
samples were accompanied by 10 blind Standard samples, which were analyzed using the drill hole sample procedure. Results were compiled in an
internal memorandum by Cliffs’ Corporate Principal Geologist, Orobona (2020).
SLR reviewed the graphs, discussions, and conclusions outlined in Orobona (2020). Figure 8-6, compiled from the Orobona 2020 report, displays graphs
of the absolute difference of the coarse duplicate pairs against the mean grades of each sample pair for selected variables. In reviewing these results,
all sample pairs with an absolute difference greater than 10%, 20%, and 30% were considered to have moderate, poor, and very poor precision,
respectively, and the duplicate campaign results were considered together when assessing the overall precision of the variable.
CONFE WTREC
CONPHOS CONSIO2
absolute difference 1% 10% 20% 30% 50%
Source: Orobona, 2020
Figure 8-6: Absolute Difference of Coarse Duplicate Pairs
The results point toward a higher precision of crude sample pairs (crudefe and crudephos, not shown) than concentrate samples that have undergone
the bench flotaon test. LiSle bias was noted; however, a slight posive bias was observed in the 2019 consio2 and conphos results, as compared to
the original
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 60
-- 288 of 411 --
analysis. Orobona (2020) noted that a 5% posive bias was also observed in the grind of samples prior to flotaon, postulang that the higher-grind
results may have contributed to the bias in concentrate samples. Specific conclusions derived from this program, and recommendaons for future
work are listed at the end of the section.
Expected values of principal variables of the Standard submiSed alongside coarse duplicate sampled during 2019 are presented in Table 8-1. The
expected values were calculated from the average value and SD of the 10 submitted samples. For each variable, material was considered to have failed
if the variable reported outside the confidence limits of ±3SD from the expected value, or two consecutive values outside ±2SD.
Table 8-1: Expected Values of and 2019 Performance of Principal Variables of Martite Master Composite Samples
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Variable Expected Value (±2SD) No. Failures Observation
confe (%) 67.4 66.6 – 68.2 0 Good performance
consio2 (%) 3.8 2.7 – 4.9 0 Good performance
conphos (%) 0.0244 0.0230 – 0.0259 0 Good performance
wtrec (%) 37.5 34.2 – 40.8 0 Good performance
crudefe (%) 35.6 35.3 – 35.9 1 Inconclusive
Although all principal variable results from the Standards show acceptable agreement with the expected value, the sample size is too low for robust
stascal analysis. Considering the small size of annual drilling programs at Cliffs, SLR recommends supporng the drill hole sample performance by
reviewing performance of the blast hole QA/QC program.SLR recommends increasing the frequency of standard submission with blast holes at the
laboratory to obtain a sample size of 25 annually.
SLR also recommends that Cliffs prepare a second reference standard, with expected values approximang the cut-off grades for deleterious variables
consio2 and conphos, in order to measure the precision of results around ore delineaon. SLR recommends that Cliffs target a submission rate of 25
annually (50 standards total) and submitting the Standards in random order and blind to the laboratory.
8.3.3 Conclusions and Recommendations
SLR presents the following conclusions and recommendations of the QA/QC program at Tilden:
8.3.3.1 Conclusions
• In the SLR QP’s opinion, the sample preparaon, analysis, and security procedures at Tilden are adequate for use in the esmaon of Mineral
Resources.
• The lack of regular submission of QA/QC samples alongside samples used to support Mineral Resources is outside of industry-standard pracce,
and improvements are warranted.
• The 2019 QA/QC program as designed and implemented by Cliffs has been helpful to understand the precision and accuracy of sample analysis
at the Tilden laboratory, which is used to support the assay results within the database, and to confirm that the database is suitable for use in
estimating Indicated and Inferred Mineral Resources.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 61
-- 289 of 411 --
• The following conclusions relate specifically to the 2019 QA/QC program results but can be applied to the assay program as a whole, with
caution:
◦ Good repeatability was observed between the coarse duplicates of crudefe, crudephos, and wtrec values at all grade ranges tested.
◦ Very good repeatability was observed in confe duplicate pairs above 61%. Low-grade or waste samples had poor repeatability.
◦ Poor repeatability of consio2 values was observed in all samples within the grade range tested (3% to 41%). Precision decreased with
increasing consio2 values.
◦ Moderate to poor repeatability of conphos values was observed, with 20% of samples returning an absolute difference greater than 20%.
Precision was observed to improve with conphos values above 0.075%. The lowest precision was observed between sample pairs with a
mean conphos value from 0.025% to 0.075%. A low bias was observed in the 2019 duplicate sample batch as compared to the original
samples analyzed from 2014 to 2018.
◦ Although precision of the med grind in the rod mill is good, a high bias in the 2019 duplicate sample batch was observed, which may
contribute to the bias observed in downstream concentrate sample variables.
8.3.3.2 Recommendations
1. Develop and implement a robust QA/QC program at Tilden for both exploration drill hole and blast hole samples.
2. Address the capacity issues at the Tilden laboratory to allow the sample analysis to be completed in a mely manner, and to facilitate the
inclusion of QA/QC samples.
3. Include coarse duplicate samples in the drill hole and blast hole sample stream at a rate of 1 in 50, and monitor results regularly. Use the blast
hole results to support small exploraon drilling programs, while considering procedural differences. Create a standard operaon procedure for
the inclusion of field, coarse, and pulp duplicate samples and develop a set of aconable, performance-based criteria. Work closely with the
laboratory to improve the precision of the bench flotation test.
4. Include field duplicate samples at a rate of 1 in 50 in the drill hole sample stream.
5. Increase the submission rate of the Standard to achieve an annual sample size of 25. Ensure submission is blind to the laboratory.
6. Develop a second reference standard with expected values approximang the cut-off grades for deleterious variables consio2 and conphos, in
order to measure the precision of results around ore delineaon. Submit at a rate of 25 samples annually, and ensure submission is blind to the
laboratory.
7. Invesgate the poor repeatability of conphos and consio2 values observed in the 2019 duplicate sample campaign, and work with the Tilden
laboratory to improve precision, with focus on values within a grade range of 75% to 125% of the cut-off grades for these deleterious variables.
8. Invesgate the low bias observed in the duplicate conphos data set, and review any long-term trends within the Tilden laboratory. Consider the
impact of grinding.
9. Include magnetic samples in future duplicate programs that assess crude magfe content.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 62
-- 290 of 411 --
9.0 DATA VERIFICATION
9.1 Site Verification Work
During 2019, a data verificaon exercise was performed within the LOM plan area. Of the 528 drill holes in the Tilden (then) MS Access database, 25
historical and recent drill holes (4.7%) were selected for data verification.
Geologic logs from ledger books and assay results in MS Excel spreadsheets obtained directly from the Tilden laboratory were compared against the
MS Access database for discrepancies in:
• Collar naming and coordinates, and downhole surveys (where available)
• Geological coding
• Analytical results
The MS Access database itself was also queried for irregular or impossible values, irregular survey deviation results, and from/to interval conformance.
Integrity issues were limited to isolated value discrepancies and minor survey differences and were corrected in the master database.
9.2 QP Verification Work
Personal inspecons were carried out by SLR personnel during the site visits, including a visit to the core shack where SLR examined examples of drill
core, inspected several examples of material types, and reviewed logging and sampling procedures. Visits were made to the operang Main Pit where
the nature of the mineralizaon was observed, stockpiles of various iron formaon material were inspected, and the blast hole mapping and sampling
procedures were reviewed.
SLR also visited the onsite Tilden sample preparaon and analysis laboratory, reviewed sample database security protocols, and parcipated in a tour
of the Plant.
During the site visit, SLR had an opportunity to inspect the site, talk to mine and laboratory personnel, and collect relevant informaon for Mineral
Resource estimation. In addition to personal inspections of core, SLR also spot-checked material-type designations against several drill core photos.
SLR completed the following data verification procedures on the provided drill hole database:
• A search for highly unlikely or impossible values in the drill and blast hole databases. These values were removed or adjusted in the database.
• A search for missing drill holes.
• A search for duplicate or overlapping samples or drill holes.
• A comparison of flotation ore coding against original logging.
• A search for odd or irregular drill and blast hole collars, and downhole survey positions.
Unsupported data was revised or removed from the drill and blast hole datasets prior to estimation.
SLR compared drill and blast hole composite samples to examine any bias present due to changing preparaon and analysis procedures over me and
between the data types. Comparisons by procedure or me were not possible due to the organizaon of aSribute data. SLR has recommended that
this information be collated within an attribute database, and Cliffs is currently undertaking to do so.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 63
-- 291 of 411 --
In order to pair blast hole samples and drill hole composites, SLR completed a nearest neighbor (NN) esmate using a search ellipse equal to the block
size of 25 V x 25 V x 45 V. Blocks esmated using both data types were considered as twin pairs. Paired data was compared using scaSer plots and
quanle-quanle (QQ) plots, both as a whole, and by individual domains. In general, the pairs demonstrate a high degree of scaSer. Basic stascs of
the paired data are summarized in Table 9-1, and small differences in mean value, in favor of either blast or drill hole data, are apparent. Blast hole
data appears to under-represent confe and crudefe (very slightly) values when compared to drill hole data, while conphos values appear to be over-
represented in blast hole data when compared to drill hole data.
Figure 9-1 presents paired drill and blast hole samples in a scaSer plot, colored by consio2 values. The scaSer shows reasonable correlaon, with few
outliers at consio2 values below 10%. Pairs high in consio2 tend to have low concentrate grades as well as poor correlation. A small bias, in favor of drill
hole results, is observed in comparing mean values of the twin pairs (62.5% versus 63.2%) and in the QQ plot (not shown). SLR notes that the bias is
still observable when values below 55% confe are removed.
Table 9-1: Basic Statistics of Twinned Drill and Blast Hole Samples
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Variable Source Count Mean
(%) CV Min.
(%)
Max.
(%)
confe BH 1,543 62.5 0.1 34.3 74.4
confe DH 1,543 63.2 0.1 17.7 68.5
conphos BH 775 0.043 0.596 0.006 0.221
conphos DH 775 0.038 1.072 0.002 0.659
consio2 BH 1,543 6.9 0.9 1.1 43.4
consio2 DH 1,543 6.9 0.9 1.6 65.8
crudefe BH 1,539 35.6 0.1 3.5 64.8
crudefe DH 1,539 36.2 0.1 19.9 55.6
wtrec BH 1,542 38.2 0.2 16.1 79.5
wtrec DH 1,542 38.1 0.2 7.1 75.5
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 64
-- 292 of 411 --
Figure 9-1: Scatter Plot of Twinned Drill and Blast Hole Sample Pairs on confe, Colored by consio2 Values
While a bias was expected in favor of blast hole data, as a standard +3% has been added to the blast hole wtrec values since an undetermined me in
the past, to beSer align laboratory results (dried) and plant readings (natural moisture), no bias was observed. This is likely due to the linear
application of the 3%, and the high degree of scatter shown overall.
The best correlaon of all variables was shown between drill and blast hole crudefe (not shown). Good correlaon of conphos values is also observed,
despite a high bias in favor of blast hole data. A scaSer plot is shown in Figure 9-2, where it is observable that pairs of conphos values in the Main Pit
Carbonate domain showed poorer correlaon than other domains and the highest overall bias. SLR notes that conphos variables represent the
smallest sample set, due to absent conphos values from older drill holes. SLR recommends repeang this analysis once this aSribute data is stored in
the database, to allow filtering of older drill holes in other variables to determine if the correlation of the different variable pairs improves.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 65
-- 293 of 411 --
Figure 9-2: Scatter Plot of Twinned Drill Hole and Blast Hole Sample Pairs on conphos Colored by Domain
SLR offers the following conclusions regarding the drill hole and blast hole twin analysis:
• There is a moderate to good correlation of all variables between blast hole and drill hole twinned samples.
• Correlation of confe values decreases for samples with high consio2 values.
• The known bias of wtrec in favor of blast hole data is not observable in the paired dataset.
• A high bias, in favor of blast holes, is observable in the conphos variable; however, overall comparison is good.
SLR offers the following recommendations regarding the drill hole and blast hole twin analysis:
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 66
-- 294 of 411 --
1. Repeat this analysis upon incorporaon of aSribute data such as year, starch type, and grind me, to determine if correlaons in paired data can
be improved following the removal of select data types.
2. Explore the bias observed in the conphos twinned data and continue to work with the laboratory to bring the datasets into alignment.
The QP is of the opinion that the Tilden database is adequate for the purposes of estimating Indicated and Inferred Mineral Resources.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 67
-- 295 of 411 --
10.0 MINERAL PROCESSING AND METALLURGICAL TESTING
10.1 Historical Metallurgical Testing and Process Design
The mix of magnete and primarily hemate ores at Tilden is unique to US iron ore mines. Typical flowsheets developed for beneficiaon-grade
magnetite ores of the Lake Superior region were not applicable in that the preponderance of the iron oxide occurs as non-magnetic hematite. Ordinary
methods of desliming and flotaon were also unacceptable due to the fine grinding required for liberaon, which would have resulted in either
excessive iron unit losses or unsasfactory concentrate grades. This necessitated the development of unique technologies for the successful
processing of Tilden’s iron ores.
Metallurgical research conducted in the 1960s eventually focused on creang a processing scheme that included selecve flocculaon and desliming
followed by caonic SiO flotaon. During this period, a multude of dispersants and flocculants were evaluated. Originally, sodium silicate was used,
then sodium hexametaphosphate, (NaPO ) , with corn starch as the flocculant. Currently, Tilden is using polyacrylic acid. This was followed by
evaluaon of various silicate flotaon systems, with the ulmate selecon of a caonic flotaon system using amine-based silicate collectors to
separate (float) the SiO minerals from both hematite and magnetite.
A description of the current process and plant performance is provided in Section 14.0.
10.2 Sampling and Metallurgical Testing
10.2.1 Drill Sample Preparation and Testing
The standardized bench-scale flotaon test was designed to simulate the Tilden hemate grinding and concentrang circuit. Data from the
standardized bench flotaon test are provided to the geologist and are used to characterize diamond drilling samples as either crude iron ore or waste
rock. The data are then used to build a resource model and mine plan, with the purpose of supplying a consistent blend of ore to the concentrator. An
illustration of the bench test flowsheet is provided in Figure 8-2.
10.2.2 Bench Flotation Test
The 600 g flotaon test sample is ground using an 8 in. by 10 in. mild steel rod mill containing 26 rods of various diameters: two 1/ in., eight / in.,
four / in., ten / in., and two / in. Total weight of the rods can range from 9,200 g to 9,500 g. Added to the mill with the flotaon test sample are
400 mL of flotaon test water, 0.25 lb/LT of glass H (6.4 mL of a 1 wt% soluon of sodium hexametaphosphate powder), and 1.5 lb/LT causc sodium
hydroxide (1.8 mL soluon, 18.7% specific gravity, 1.205 NaOH solids). The mill is placed on mill rolls designed to rotate at 54 rpm. Standard grind me
is 45 min for a flotation test sample, and grinding continues uninterrupted.
Following grinding, the sample is immediately washed out of the mill and off of the rods with flotaon test water. Without delay, the sample is
transferred into an 8 L deslime tube, and water is added to fill the tube up to the 8 L mark. The ore slurry in the tube is mixed using 12 strokes with the
plunger. pH of the slurry in the tube is measured with a pH meter; pH should be 10.0 or higher, which is typical of the normal plant circuit operang
pH (generally 10.0 to 10.5). If the pH is lower than 10.0, addional NaOH soluon is added in 0.25 lb/LT increments. Then the sample is re-mixed, and
the pH is checked again. Additional caustic dosage(s) are recorded.
2
3 6
2
1 4 3 4
1 2 3 8 1 4
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 68
-- 296 of 411 --
Starch is added at 0.25 lb/LT (3.0 mL soluon) to the deslime tube, which is then mixed with the plunger for 30 sec. Starch type is recorded. The
standard flotation test originally used Pearl starch. Since March 2015, the test now uses modified starch to match plant usage.
Sample seSling me is measured. The standard seSling me if Pearl starch is used is two minutes; standard seSling me if modified starch is used is
five minutes. If, aVer this me, seSling is not complete, as much me as is necessary is allowed before siphoning, then actual seSling me is recorded.
The / in. diameter siphon tube is inserted into the slurry. Siphoning occurs down to the 1 L mark on the deslime tube or one inch above the bed,
whichever is higher.
Flocculant is added to the slime fracon and mixed vigorously to aid seSling in a pressure filter. Slimes are pressure-filtered, then dried on a hot plate.
This is the A product. To guard against contaminang a flotaon test with the seSling aid, the pail used to siphon the slimes is not the same pail used
to empty the grinding mill.
The sample leV in the tube is washed into the Pyrex glass flotaon bowl of a Wemco Flot machine using flotaon water. The water level is then raised
up to just where the standpipe starts to change diameter. The following is added to the flotaon bowl: 1.0 lb/LT starch (12.0 mL soluon) and 0.25
lb/LT caustic (0.3 mL solution); the sample is left to condition with the air off for two minutes.
The first stage of rougher amine is added with a micro pipeSor at the standard dosage of 0.12 lb/LT (38.2 μL) for development drill hole samples. To
avoid leaving any residual amine in the pipeSe, the outside of the pipeSe is wiped off with a paper towel, with care taken not to touch the end aVer
drawing the amine into the pipeSe. The end of the amine pipeSe is then immersed into the slurry, and amine is dispensed. Following this, the pipeSe
is withdrawn, and the outside is wiped off with a paper towel. Air is turned on the Wemco flotaon machine (operated at 1,250 rpm), which agitates
the slurry and generates a froth. Froth is immediately and connuously removed using a paddle unl froth generaon diminishes. Then the air is shut
off. Flotaon water is added to the flotaon bowl, as required, to maintain a constant level. A second stage of rougher amine is added, froth is
removed using the paddle unl it diminishes again, and the air is turned off. Any abnormal froth volume is noted. Rougher amine dosage and any non-
standard reagent dosage are recorded.
The product left in the bowl is the rougher concentrate and comprises the B product. This sample is washed into a pail and saved.
Froth product from the previous step is washed back into the flotaon bowl. The level is raised up to where the standpipe begins to change diameter.
To the flotaon bowl is added 0.5 lb/LT starch (6.0 mL soluon), and the sample is leV to condion with the air off for two minutes. The froth should
be completely repulped while conditioning. This flotation simulates the flotation scavenger circuit.
Following condioning, the air is turned on, and froth is removed into a pan unl froth generaon diminishes. The product leV in the pan is the F
product (the final tailing product), which is then filtered and dried on a hot plate. Amine is added to the flotaon bowl at 0.05 lb/LT amine (15.93 μL
soluon), and the air is tuned on. Froth removed per the previous steps is Middling 1, the low-grade middling E product, which is then filtered and
dried on a hot plate. Another 0.05 lb/LT amine (15.93 μL soluon) is added to the flotaon bowl, and the air is turned on. Froth removed comprises
Middling 2, the high-grade middling D product, which is then filtered and dried on a hot plate.
1 2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 69
-- 297 of 411 --
The material leV in the flotaon bowl is concentrate recovered from the scavenger circuit. The sample is washed into a pail and filtered. This product
is the C product (the scavenger flotation concentrate product), which is then filtered and dried on a hot plate.
10.2.2.1 Flotation Test, Product Sample Preparation and Assay
Weights are recorded for each of the products. Products are separately pushed through a 30 mesh screen and forty cornered on a mixing cloth or
passed three mes through a cone mixer. Approximately 25 g of each product are dipped out into three labeled sample envelopes for archival, soluble
wet iron, and XRF analysis for % SiO , CaO, MgO, Mn, Al O , and % phos. An additional envelope is made for Satmagan analysis of the B product.
Half of each product by weight is placed in a separate pan for wet screen analysis. Products are combined in the pan and mixed in a cone mixer.
Approximately 10 g is split from this re-composited sample and analyzed by the Microtrac for parcle size distribuon. The -35 μm result is recorded.
Remaining re-composited sample is then wet-screened unl only clear water drains from the underflow, which is discarded down the drain. The +500
mesh solids are dried and weighed, and the % -500 mesh is calculated.
10.2.2.2 Flotation Test Results
The Tilden bench float test is an approximaon of ancipated plant response for the specific ore type being tested. The bench test is unique to iron
ore evaluaon techniques, and the actual flotaon of the ore is conducted manually by an operator. Automaon of the procedure is not praccal.
Variability in the results can be impacted by the operator. There are occasionally re-tests requested to compare results and idenfy retraining
requirements. Extremely high concentrate SiO values are indicave of interfering minerals that are usually in the form of smecte clays. These clays
absorb the amine, which does not allow the amine to adhere to SiO parcles (interferes). Re-tesng of these samples shows similar results. Flotaon
concentrate SiO values above cut-off grade, but lower than the extremely high values associated with interfering minerals, are usually indicave of
SiO grain inclusions within iron oxide grains. This phenomenon is geographically associated with the Eastern end of the deposit and is hypothesized to
be associated with hydrothermal alteration of the iron formation. Re-tests yield similar results. On rare occasions, a sample may be re-run with a larger
dose of amine or longer mill grind time to investigate the sensitivity of the particular ore type.
10.2.3 Recovery Estimate Assumptions
It has been empirically determined over me that the bench test wtrec requires an addional 1.8 percentage point addion to match actual plant
results.
10.3 Material Characterization and Classification
The flotaon bench test determines whether an iron formaon sample is crude ore or waste if all cut-off grade criteria are met (see Secon 13.0).
Crude ore samples can be further delineated as material types based on magnec iron content and total oxides (Table 10‑1). The modeled geologic
domain the samples fall within is also taken into consideration when characterizing ore types.
2 2 3
2
2
2
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 70
-- 298 of 411 --
Table 10-1: Material Type Specifications
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Ore Type Head Fe Conc. SiO Total Oxides Satmagan Head
Magnetic Fe Conc. Phos. Davis Tube wtrec Davis Tube Conc.
SiO Calculated Magnetic Fe
Hematite >25 <6 >94 <15 <0.07
Main Pit Carbonate >25 <6 <94.01 >15 <0.07
Goethite >25 <6 >87 and <94 <15 <0.07
Magnetite >25 <6 >24.99 <10 >20
10.4 Factors Affecting Economic Extraction and Plant Performance
Gangue minerals impacng economic extracon are idenfied in the flotaon bench test. These include interfering minerals (clay) that adsorb amine,
resulng in concentrate SiO values above cut-off values. Quartz inclusions within the iron oxide bands generally also result in bench test concentrate
SiO values that are above cut-off grade. Very fine goethite ore can result in potential filtering, crushing, and flotation issues. Therefore, this material is
mined at very low percentages when exposed. Carbonate ore and goethite ore can impact pellet quality due to calcinaon of carbonate in the former
and dehydration in the latter. Therefore, these ore types are mined at low percentages when exposed.
2
2
2
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 71
-- 299 of 411 --
11.0 MINERAL RESOURCE ESTIMATES
11.1 Summary
A geological model was constructed by SLR considering regional mapping, drill hole logging, and blast hole analycal results, in addion to grade
control modeling and flotaon ore coding. Data verificaon included standard database verificaon, a review of QA/QC protocols and results, and a
comparison of blast hole and drill hole results.
The EY 2020 Tilden Mineral Resource esmate was completed by SLR using a convenonal block modeling approach, defining esmaon domains
from wireframes built in Seequent’s Leapfrog Geo (Leapfrog Geo) soVware and using a regular block model built and interpolated in Seequent’s
Leapfrog Edge (Leapfrog Edge) soVware. The general workflow included the creaon of a geological model from mapping, drill and blast hole logging,
and sampling, which were used to define discrete domains of non-iron formaon and iron formaon sub-units. Iron formaon drill hole samples were
composited, and the esmaon of six variables (crude iron and magnec iron, wtrec, and iron, phosphorus, and silica in concentrate) was completed
using ordinary kriging (OK) over five passes in iron formaon units, the first of which incorporated blast hole samples. Distance restricon of outlier
grades was applied to selected domains and variables. Blocks were classified as Indicated or Inferred using distance-based and qualitave criterion.
Canadian Instute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum (CIM) Definion Standards for Mineral Resources and Mineral Reserves dated May 10, 2014
(CIM (2014) definions) were used for Mineral Resource classificaon.Models were depleted to December 31, 2021, with depleon predicted for
September 1, 2020 to December 31, 2020. Estimates were validated using standard industry techniques and were peer reviewed prior to finalization.
A detailed breakdown of the Mineral Resources exclusive of Mineral Reserves is presented in Table 11-1. Mineral Resources were defined and
constrained within an open-pit shell, prepared by Cliffs and based on a US$90/long ton pellet price, and meeng the following cut-off grade criteria,
based on existing pellet specifications and price contracts:
• ≥ 25% wtrec
• ≥ 25% crude iron content (crudefe)
• ≤ 0.07% phosphorous in concentrate (conphos)
• ≤ 6% to 8.5% silica in concentrate (consio2) (domain dependent)
The pellet cost basis for the Lerchs-Grossmann (LG) optimization is based on a dry 61.5% Fe fluxed pellet.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 72
-- 300 of 411 --
Table 11-1: Summary of Tilden Mineral Resources – December 31, 2021
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Category Long Tons
(Mtons)
Crude Fe
(%)
Process Recovery
(%)
Pellets
(Mtons)
Measured - - - -
Indicated 135.4 35.5 35.9 48.6
Total Measured + Indicated 135.4 35.5 35.9 48.6
Inferred 350.4 34.7 36.4 127.4
Notes:
1. Tonnage is reported in long tons equivalent to 2,240 lb.
2. Tonnage is reported exclusive of Mineral Reserves and has been rounded to the nearest 100,000.
3. Mineral Resources are estimated at cut-off grades of 25% crudefe, 25% wtrec, 0.07% conphos and 6% consio2 to 8.5% consio2, domain dependent.
4. Mineral Resources are estimated using a pellet value of US$90/LT.
5. Pellets are reported as fluxed and dry, containing 61.5% Fe, shipped pellets contain 2% moisture.
6. Tonnage estimate based on estimated depletion from a surveyed topography on December 31, 2021.
7. Resources are crude ore tons as delivered to the primary crusher; pellets are as loaded onto rail cars.
8. Classification of Mineral Resources is in accordance with the S-K 1300 classification system.
9. Bulk density is assigned based on a regression equation related to crude Fe.
10. Mineral Resources are 100% attributable to Cliffs.
11. Mineral Resources are constrained within an optimized pit shell and are exclusive of Mineral Reserves.
12. Mineral Resources that are not Mineral Reserves do not have demonstrated economic viability.
13. Numbers may not add due to rounding.
The Tilden operaon is currently acve and in full producon. The SLR QP is of the opinion that with consideraon of the recommendaons
summarized in Secons 1.0 and 23.0 of this report, any issues relang to all relevant technical and economic factors likely to influence the prospect of
economic extraction can be resolved with further work.
A summary of the key assumpons, parameters, and methods used for Mineral Resource esmates, including drilling database, geological model,
compositing and capping, density, and variography are discussed below.
11.2 Resource Database
The Tilden drill hole database consists of 382,605 V of drill hole informaon in 578 drill holes, completed from the 1950s to 2020. Assay informaon
of holes drilled in 2019 and 2020 in the CD5 Pit area were not available and, as such, the CD5 area has not been included in SLR’s Mineral Resource
esmate. Down hole informaon from Empire drill holes were also not available and are excluded from the SLR Mineral Resource esmate.SLR
recommends integrating the downhole information from the Empire and Tilden mines into a single valid database.
11.3 Geological Interpretation
Iron formaon and intrusive units were modeled in Leapfrog Geo using surface mapping and drill hole logs, with consideraon given to grade control
modeling and flotaon ore coding (code1), assay results, and noted or measured presences of magfe. Iron formaon units were disnguished to a
distance of 600 ft beyond drilling, beyond which were modeled as Undifferentiated Iron Formation.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 73
-- 301 of 411 --
Below the Summit Mountain Sill, silica alteraon in BIF units was modeled to overprint the iron formaon using a nominal cut-off grade of 10%
consio2, and oxidaon domains were modeled using a cut-off grade of 0.04% conphos, with reference to oxidaon noted in drill hole logs, and code1
logging from both drill and blast holes. SLR recommends that Cliffs connue work to define fault orientaon and related alteraon in the east of the
Main Pit to confirm the syn-bedding and cross-cutting directions of the modeled high-silica alteration domains.
Above the Summit Mountain Sill, the iron formaon is highly oxidized in all areas (Hemate Iron Formaon) apart from the Magnec Iron Formaon
unit of the CDIII Pit, and has strong silica alteraon along the more prevalent intrusive contacts.These alteraon contacts were not disnguished with
the exception of high-silica alteration along the hanging wall of the Suicide Sill in the CDIII Pit.
Following domain modeling, lithology units were back-coded with the most closely defined flotaon ore coding. The geological model at Tilden is
presented in plan and cross-section in Figure 11-1 and Figure 11-2, respectively.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 74
-- 302 of 411 --
Figure 11-1: Level 1000 of the Tilden Geological Model
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 75
-- 303 of 411 --
Figure 11-2: Tilden Geological Model Cross-section
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 76
-- 304 of 411 --
11.4 Resource Assays
The length-weighted data presented in Table 11-2 is effecve as of July 15, 2020, when the blast hole database was last exported and supplied to SLR.
Note that within the drill hole database, there are limited samples of conphos, which was not historically included as a standard test. Samples of
magfe in drill and blast holes are limited to magnetic units.
Impossible or irregular blast hole values were removed prior to esmaon; SLR recommends a thorough database verificaon exercise to remove
anomalous blast hole values from the master database.
Table 11-2: Tilden Mine Mineral Resource Database
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Name Count Length Mean CV Min Max
Drill Hole Samples
confe 6,652 266,450 61.80 0.10 12.39 69.51
conphos 3,572 149,646 0.04 0.73 0.00 0.66
consio2 6,660 266,830 7.35 0.90 1.30 65.83
crudefe 6,634 264,663 35.56 0.13 6.11 63.70
magfe 3,139 127,409 11.34 1.04 0.10 38.00
wtrec 6,659 266,780 37.27 0.26 4.00 90.00
Blast Hole Samples
confe 84,506 3,802,770 62.05 0.10 3.70 70
conphos 84,449 3,800,205 0.04 2.01 0.00 1.0
consio2 84,479 3,801,555 6.88 0.86 0.07 81.20
crudefe 86,698 3,901,410 35.30 0.51 2.00 70
magfe 15,616 702,720 26.08 0.20 0.20 45.30
wtrec 84,505 3,802,725 38.37 0.24 4.20 91.80
11.5 Compositing and Capping
No capping was applied prior to compositing.
11.5.1 Compositing
Drill hole data was composited to 45 ft, the most common sample interval length, and equal to the blast hole sample length. Unsampled intervals were
ignored during compositing for the following reasons:
• To substitute null values for deleterious elements is incautious.
• To substitute null values where iron formation is unsampled is overly conservative.
• There is insufficient informaon to be able to assign proxy values in the assay database to small intrusive dike material within the iron formaon
during compositing, and the number of these
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 77
-- 305 of 411 --
samples was sufficiently small to not be expected to cause significant bias in the overall database.
A histogram of sample lengths is shown in Figure 11-3.
Figure 11-3: Histogram of Sample Length
Table 11-3 presents the drill and blast hole composite statistics by estimation domain. SLR notes that the blast hole samples are not composited.
Table 11-3: Tilden Mine Composite Statistics
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Blast Holes Drill Holes
Count Mean
(%) CV Min.
(%)
Max.
(%) Count Mean
(%) CV Min.
(%)
Max.
(%)
IFCB Mag CDIII Pit (420)
confe 9,779 58.86 0.12 3.70 69.90 868 60.20 0.10 29.51 68.74
conphos 9,740 0.05 0.70 0.00 1.00 436 0.05 0.46 0.01 0.34
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 78
-- 306 of 411 --
Blast Holes Drill Holes
Count Mean
(%) CV Min.
(%)
Max.
(%) Count Mean
(%) CV Min.
(%)
Max.
(%)
consio2 9,761 7.64 0.71 0.98 44.82 869 6.81 0.66 1.49 31.96
crudefe 9,905 37.60 0.12 3.50 69.00 871 38.21 0.10 18.84 63.20
magfe 13,708 26.14 0.19 0.20 39.10 847 22.78 0.34 0.60 37.40
wtrec 9,778 41.66 0.30 4.90 91.80 869 39.54 0.27 7.10 78.17
IFCB East Tilden Carb (316)
confe - - - - - 122 60.25 0.11 35.10 67.66
conphos - - - - - 93 0.03 0.38 0.01 0.06
consio2 - - - - - 122 4.18 0.32 2.13 9.51
crudefe - - - - - 122 32.95 0.08 24.40 42.74
magfe - - - - - 66 7.37 1.08 0.42 25.10
wtrec - - - - - 122 40.40 0.26 12.10 65.90
IFCB Main Pit Carb (340)
confe 10,870 60.79 0.07 27.80 69.10 531 62.10 0.07 45.40 68.48
conphos 10,873 0.03 0.58 0.00 0.43 427 0.02 0.65 0.00 0.09
consio2 10,870 4.80 0.35 1.79 40.23 531 4.57 0.30 1.91 22.18
crudefe 11,033 34.03 0.09 7.00 62.00 531 33.73 0.09 16.60 41.37
magfe - - - - - 423 18.40 0.40 0.30 31.87
wtrec 10,870 42.49 0.15 15.80 89.40 531 43.88 0.17 11.70 64.10
IFCB Oxidized East Tilden Carb (317)
confe 1,348 62.70 0.06 22.10 68.70 242 64.22 0.05 39.63 68.30
conphos 1,348 0.06 0.32 0.01 0.27 210 0.06 0.65 0.02 0.40
consio2 1,348 5.25 0.77 0.07 44.12 242 4.58 0.47 2.22 22.13
crudefe 1,388 35.92 0.14 11.40 62.70 241 35.12 0.12 19.91 61.00
magfe - - - - - 115 1.03 1.18 0.20 8.54
wtrec 1,348 37.18 0.19 14.90 77.90 242 35.86 0.20 14.97 64.40
IFCB West Pit Carb (421)
confe 481 63.74 0.06 42.90 69.90 28 64.85 0.04 57.93 67.79
conphos 481 0.04 0.37 0.02 0.17 8 0.04 0.24 0.02 0.05
consio2 481 5.57 0.41 1.52 21.58 28 4.78 0.16 3.14 6.09
crudefe 481 39.85 0.07 30.00 55.80 28 40.86 0.05 36.17 45.10
magfe 181 28.24 0.18 6.60 35.50 20 29.11 0.13 21.95 33.60
wtrec 481 38.80 0.20 18.80 63.20 28 45.00 0.15 30.92 57.11
IFCB, Hi SiO , Suicide Sill HW (410) 2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 79
-- 307 of 411 --
Blast Holes Drill Holes
Count Mean
(%) CV Min.
(%)
Max.
(%) Count Mean
(%) CV Min.
(%)
Max.
(%)
confe 655 58.76 0.09 29.60 68.70 148 56.59 0.10 37.10 66.95
conphos 657 0.05 0.43 0.02 0.27 76 0.05 0.76 0.02 0.25
consio2 655 12.23 0.49 1.85 41.14 148 12.78 0.43 3.29 34.79
crudefe 667 38.99 0.11 8.70 48.10 148 38.10 0.08 25.90 49.68
magfe 448 28.63 0.11 15.70 35.50 162 25.50 0.30 1.10 35.10
wtrec 655 40.72 0.23 11.20 72.40 148 36.82 0.35 14.70 69.51
IFCH 300, Low SiO (350)
confe 29,277 63.76 0.08 13.70 69.70 1,781 64.91 0.05 23.29 69.48
conphos 29,252 0.03 0.60 0.00 0.71 937 0.04 0.68 0.00 0.35
consio2 29,266 6.31 0.94 0.19 65.40 1,781 5.15 0.66 1.49 42.83
crudefe 29,424 34.96 0.09 3.10 65.60 1,779 35.62 0.08 18.83 61.09
magfe 25 16.98 0.32 8.00 27.90 539 1.78 1.83 0.10 24.62
wtrec 29,277 38.64 0.19 6.20 88.00 1,780 36.73 0.19 8.04 67.17
IFCH 400
confe 11,050 63.05 0.07 24.50 69.80 546 63.22 0.07 38.54 68.17
conphos 11,042 0.05 0.54 0.01 0.72 239 0.05 0.84 0.01 0.66
consio2 11,046 6.73 0.80 0.74 81.20 546 7.02 0.82 2.15 42.86
crudefe 11,187 37.82 0.11 3.00 66.70 546 37.94 0.08 20.21 52.69
magfe 73 26.32 0.28 6.30 35.70 133 2.25 1.78 0.10 30.00
wtrec 11,050 36.76 0.23 8.80 79.60 546 35.26 0.22 10.42 75.46
IFCH 500
confe 2,382 59.55 0.10 17.80 68.40 626 59.80 0.10 35.44 68.40
conphos 2,378 0.09 0.51 0.01 0.89 346 0.08 0.48 0.01 0.26
consio2 2,382 8.16 0.69 0.87 45.75 626 8.42 0.73 2.00 40.76
crudefe 2,539 34.46 0.18 2.00 54.50 624 35.91 0.12 13.67 57.30
magfe - - - - - 217 1.65 2.24 0.10 26.83
wtrec 2,382 31.13 0.31 4.20 74.10 626 34.10 0.28 5.58 63.81
IFCH, Hi SiO SM Sill FW (370)
confe 736 56.67 0.15 34.00 68.00 77 58.70 0.10 32.70 67.02
conphos 737 0.05 0.50 0.01 0.45 36 0.05 0.30 0.02 0.07
consio2 736 13.80 0.83 1.67 47.40 77 12.23 0.64 2.96 38.50
crudefe 745 35.09 0.11 11.60 58.00 77 35.51 0.10 22.50 41.54
magfe - - - - - 27 0.89 0.75 0.20 2.23
2
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 80
-- 308 of 411 --
Blast Holes Drill Holes
Count Mean
(%) CV Min.
(%)
Max.
(%) Count Mean
(%) CV Min.
(%)
Max.
(%)
wtrec 736 41.73 0.27 16.80 87.50 77 34.54 0.26 10.50 53.27
IFCH/CL 300, Hi SiO2 (330, 321)
confe 6,137 59.79 0.12 15.60 68.50 710 55.46 0.14 27.64 67.60
conphos 6,131 0.04 0.52 0.01 0.90 386 0.05 0.51 0.01 0.32
consio2 6,137 11.40 0.80 0.09 54.36 716 16.68 0.60 2.61 65.83
crudefe 6,189 34.41 0.09 3.60 65.80 705 34.29 0.12 10.96 49.02
magfe - - - - - 257 1.30 1.90 0.10 21.34
wtrec 6,137 37.21 0.27 7.00 86.30 716 39.10 0.26 8.60 75.80
IFCL East Pit Clastics (320), Low SiO
confe 5,302 64.01 0.06 13.60 69.30 406 64.29 0.04 47.85 68.33
conphos 5,303 0.05 0.58 0.00 1.00 279 0.05 0.34 0.01 0.11
consio2 5,300 5.05 0.72 0.69 74.50 406 5.33 0.57 1.85 29.98
crudefe 6,041 31.74 0.20 6.80 63.20 401 33.30 0.15 19.24 57.34
magfe - - - - - 161 1.16 1.19 0.10 12.30
wtrec 5,302 34.01 0.24 9.30 77.50 406 33.98 0.23 13.80 70.75
IFCL South Wall Clastics (480, 310), Low SiO
confe 2,250 63.03 0.06 25.10 69.30 342 62.30 0.08 35.50 68.77
conphos 2,256 0.05 0.80 0.00 0.65 203 0.04 0.68 0.01 0.19
consio2 2,248 6.87 0.54 0.73 35.40 342 6.27 0.57 1.88 38.91
crudefe 2,502 33.33 0.22 9.50 65.20 304 30.45 0.23 12.21 59.80
magfe - - - - - 110 4.18 1.11 0.20 25.80
wtrec 2,250 35.40 0.29 10.50 91.70 342 30.08 0.34 8.53 80.30
11.6 Trend Analysis
Trend analysis in the form of three-dimensional contouring was completed within the BIF units of the Tilden deposit to understand overall grade
distribuons by spaal locaon and material type, to assist in variography, esmaon, and validaon, and – in the case of consio2 and conphos – to
assist in modeling.
Trend analysis of crudefe, wtrec, and confe assumed higher connuity along bedding, with the bedding following the general trend of the Summit
Mountain Sill/Pillar Intrusive.
Trend analysis of consio2 idenfied several syn-bedding and cross-cuUng structures with high connuity associated with faults and dikes in the east of
the Main Pit. Trend analysis of conphos idenfied a broad zone of increased oxidaon (elevated conphos values) in the East Pit as well as directly
adjacent to the Pillar Intrusive footwall.
2
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 81
-- 309 of 411 --
11.6.1 Variography
Variography was completed for all variables in all esmaon domains. Variograms were oriented in line with the most prominent domain orientaon
and the lowest variability determined from radial plots. In general, variogram models resembled a flaSened, or oblate sphere or ellipsoid. Model
distances ranged from 650 V to 1,200 V in the major axis, 400 V to 700 V in the semi-major axis, and from 200 V to 400 V in the minor axis direcon.
Variogram quality varied from good to low/moderate where based on a low number of composites within a domain, within a domain with variable
orientaon, or characterized using widely spaced data. A sample radial plot and variogram is presented in Figure 11-4, with variogram models listed in
Table 11-4.
Figure 11-4: Radial Plot, Experimental Variogram and Model for confe Within IFCB Main Pit Carb
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 82
-- 310 of 411 --
Table 11-4: Tilden Variogram Models
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Domain Variable Nugget Structure ½
Distance
(ft)
(Structure ½)
Trend
(°)
Major Semi
Major Minor Dip Dip
Az. Pitch
High SiO Contact Al (370) all 0.1 0.9 750 400 400 45 340 45
IFCB 340 Main Pit Carb all 0.1 0.9 750 500 275 45 0 20
IFCB CDIII Pit (420) all 0.1 0.9 900 600 200 50 335 0
IFCB East Tilden Carb (316) all 0.1 0.9 600 600 200 50 300 90
IFCB Hi SiO2, Suicide Sill HW (410) all 0.1 0.9 900 600 200 50 335 0
IFCB Oxidized East Tilden Carb (317) all 0.1 0.9 600 600 200 50 300 90
IFCB West Pit Carb (421) all 0.1 0.9 750 500 275 45 0 20
IFCH 300, Low SiO (350) all 0.1 0.9 1000 700 400 45 0 50
IFCH 400 all 0.1 0.9 900 700 200 50 335 15
IFCH 500 all 0.1 0.9 900 700 200 50 335 15
IFCH/CL 300, Hi SiO South
(330,321) all 0.1 0.9 1,000 700 400 45 0 50
IFCL East Pit Clastics, Low SiO
(320)
confe, crudefe,
wtrec 0.1 0.4/0.5 350/650 250/600 200/200 35 345 65
IFCL East Pit Clastics, Low SiO
(320)
conphos,
consio2 0.1 0.9 650 600 200 35 345 65
IFCL South Wall Clastics, Low SiO all 0.1 0.9 1,000 800 200 60 0 110
300 High Oxi conphos 0.1 0.9 1,200 800 200 60 0 180
Suicide Sill High Oxi conphos 0.1 0.9 1,000 800 200 60 0 110
2
2
2
2
2
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 83
-- 311 of 411 --
11.7 Block Model
A regularized, non-rotated block model was created in Leapfrog Edge. Block size was designed to be consistent with the Tilden site grade control
model, historical models, and the mine BH (45 V). SLR recommends exploring a larger block length in the X and Y dimensions, such as 50 V, in
subsequent updates to bring the model in line with mine selecvity. A summary of the block model setup and selected included variables is shown in
Table 11-5.
Table 11-5: Summary of Block Model Setup
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Type X Y Z
Min. Coord. 26,077,700 606,225 2,025
Max. Coord. 26,091,825 611,850 -720
Total Length 14,125 5,625 2,745
Block Size 25 25 45
Variable Description
domain Estimation domains
mine Mine 2020JUL15 material flag: insitu, mined, fill, air
confe_ok BH and DH First pass, DH subsequent
conphos_ok BH and DH First pass, DH subsequent
consio2_ok BH and DH First pass, DH subsequent
crudefe_ok BH and DH First pass, DH subsequent
magfe_ok BH and DH First pass, DH subsequent
wtrec_ok BH and DH First pass, DH subsequent
dh_confe_ok DH only OK est.
dh_conphos_ok DH only OK est.
dh_consio2_ok DH only OK est.
dh_crudefe_ok DH only OK est.
dh_magfe_ok DH only OK est.
dh_wtrec_ok DH only OK est.
bh_confe_ok BH only – estimated by crude IF domain (300, 400, 500)
bh_conphos_ok BH only – estimated by crude IF domain (300, 400, 500)
bh_consio2_ok BH only – estimated by crude IF domain (300, 400, 500)
bh_crudefe_ok BH only – estimated by crude IF domain (300, 400, 500)
bh_magfe_ok BH only – estimated by crude IF domain (300, 400, 500)
bh_wtrec_ok BH only – estimated by crude IF domain (300, 400, 500)
tfc 13.45-(0.0792 * (crudefe_ok)) for IF, Int=12.3, Ovb=17.3
tfc_inv 1/tfc
code1 best match code for reference to site grade control codes
class 2=Indicated; 3 = Inferred
11.8 Estimation Methodology
Grade interpolaon at Tilden was conducted in Leapfrog Edge using OK and hard boundaries, with progressively larger search ellipses and relaxed
criteria within BIF units. The first pass used both drill and blast hole data, subsequent passes used drill hole data only. The final conphos variable
estimated within
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 84
-- 312 of 411 --
the high-oxidaon zones below the Summit Mountain Sill overprints the general domain-restricted conphos results. Inverse distance cubed (ID ) and
NN estimates were run in parallel for comparison and validation purposes.
Search ellipses were oriented using dynamic anisotropy based on the hanging wall and footwall of the domain boundaries, except for the high-
oxidaon zone in the Main Pit, which used a flat search ellipse. The inial search ellipse, which used both drill and blast hole data, was designed to
capture blast hole data from three benches. The dimensions of the search ellipses in passes 2 to 4 reference the general drill hole spacing across the
deposit (300 V x 300 V), the composite length (45 V), and the block size. The final pass was designed to populate a small number of intersal blocks
that remained unesmated. The search strategy is detailed in Table 11-6. Esmaon runs using exclusively drill and blast holes were also performed
for use in reconciliation studies using the same strategy.
Table 11-6: Search Strategy
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Pass Source
Composites1
Search Radius
(ft)
Max.
Samples/Hole
Minimum
Samples
Maximum
Samples
General Domains
1 BH, DH 120/120/50 - 3 8
2 DH 450/450/100 3 4 8
3 DH 900/900/200 3 4 8
4 DH 1,500/1,500/300 - 3 8
5 DH 1,500/1,500/1,500 - 3 8
High-Oxidation Domains in Main Pit, conphos only
1 BH, DH 120/120/50 - 3 8
2 DH 450/450/100 3 4 8
3 DH 600/600/150 3 4 8
4 DH 900/900/200 - 3 8
Notes:
1. BH = blast hole; DH = drill hole
11.8.1 High-Grade Restriction
The influence of consio2 values above a threshold of 15% or 20% (domain dependent) in low-silica domains was restricted to a distance ellipse of 135
ft x 135 ft x 33 ft. At greater distances values were capped at the threshold, so as to restrict the influence of isolated high values due to small, localized
faults and fractures.
11.8.2 Bulk Density
Consistent with previous models at Tilden, the following regression calculation was used to assign tonnage factors to the model:
Tonnage Factor (ft /LT) = 13.45 – (0.0792 * crudefe)
3
3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 85
-- 313 of 411 --
For non-iron formation units, the following tonnage factors were assigned:
• Intrusive: 12.3
• Outlier or unestimated Iron Formation: 10.25
• Overburden: 17.3
• Backfill: 17.3
11.9 Cut-off Grade
A preliminary open-pit shell was generated using the Lerchs-Grossmann (LG) opmizaon method as a constraint in the preparaon of the open-pit
Mineral Resource esmate. The open-pit shell is based on a US$90/long ton pellet price and meeng the following cut-off grade criteria, based on
existing pellet specifications and price contracts:
• ≥ 25% wtrec
• ≥ 25% crudefe
• ≤ 0.07% conphos
• ≤ 6% to 8.5% consio2 (domain dependent)
The pellet cost basis for the LG opmizaon is based on a dry, 61.5% Fe fluxed pellet. The revenue and cost parameters for the LG opmizaon are
presented in Table 11-7. Pit slopes applied to in situ material range from 33.7° to 43.8°, depending on the domain.
Table 11-7: Whittle Pit Parameters
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Parameter Value
Pellet Sale Price US$90/t pellet
Mining Cost
- Depth Adjustment Factor (per 45ft bench)
US$2.52/t mined
US$0.02/t mined
Milling Cost US$9.50/t milled
Pelletizing Cost
General and Administration Cost
US$11.34/t pellet
US$2.72/t pellet
Sustaining Capital US$4.33/t pellet
Mineral Royalty US$1.80/t pellet
11.10 Classification
Definions for resource categories used in this TRS are those defined by SEC in S-K 1300.Mineral Resources are classified into Measured, Indicated,
and Inferred categories.
Classificaon criteria considered the spaal connuity of the different variables, and the quality and density of the samples. Final classificaon was
assigned from wireframes built to capture areas characterized by drill hole-spacing criteria as shown in Table 11-8. This work was supported by
variography, as well as a drill hole-spacing study that assigned an average distance of the three closest composite samples from neighboring drill holes
to each composite. The block model was post-processed to downgrade an area of clastic material west of the Main Pit that would have otherwise met
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 86
-- 314 of 411 --
the criteria for a classificaon of Indicated but was missing conphos values due to historical pracces that did not include conphos as a standard
measurement in exploration drill hole sampling.
Table 11-8: Classification Criteria
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Classification Criteria Indicated Inferred
Drill hole Spacing (ft) 600 1,200
Extension Beyond Drilling (ft) 300 600
Extension Below Drilling (ft) 150 300
SLR recommends compleng a reconciliaon study to support the inclusion of Measured Mineral Resources at Tilden.SLR notes that, in general, the
drill hole spacing is lower below the current topography than above, and that there is very liSle drilling outside of the 2019 LOM plan extents. SLR
recommends addional drilling to improve the understanding of the Tilden deposit at the periphery and at depth, with a focus on low drill-density
areas within the 2019 LOM plan, as well as in areas with increased variability, such as the high-silica areas in the east of the Main Pit. An overview of
classification is presented in Figure 11-5.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 87
-- 315 of 411 --
Figure 11-5: Mineral Resource Classification
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 88
-- 316 of 411 --
11.11 Model Validation
Validaon of the Mineral Resource esmate results included visual grade comparisons, reviews of block model coding, and stascal reviews of the
global accuracy of the esmated variables and evaluaon of the local accuracy through the preparaon of swath plots (not shown) and comparave
statistics (Figure 11-6). Comparave stascs between composite and block data was not reliable due to the clustered nature of the blast hole data. In
place of this, the final esmated value was compared to a NN esmate, as a proxy of the declustered input data. No reconciliaon with the short-term
model was carried out; however, SLR understands that a comprehensive reconciliation study is currently underway.
Visual comparisons between the composites and esmated block grades were conducted on vercal secons and plan views. SLR is of the opinion that
the esmated block grades reflect the local drill or blast hole composite value and that the trends displayed are as intended. Selected comparisons are
shown in Figure 11-7 to Figure 11-9.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 89
-- 317 of 411 --
Figure 11-6: Comparison of OK and NN Estimates by Variable and Domain
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 90
-- 318 of 411 --
Figure 11-7: Comparison of consio2 Drill and Blast Hole Composites with Estimated Blocks
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 91
-- 319 of 411 --
Figure 11-8: Comparison of confe Drill and Blast Hole Composites with Estimated Blocks
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 92
-- 320 of 411 --
Figure 11-9: Comparison of conphos Drill and Blast Hole Composites with Estimated Blocks
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 93
-- 321 of 411 --
11.12 Model Reconciliation
Reconciliaon results comparing actual producon results versus model-predicted values of crudefe confe, wtrec, consio2, and conphos for 2021 are
presented in Table 11-9. Model values are represented by excavated full bench voids between quarterly topographies. A factor of 0.5 was applied to all
ramp excavaons, either developing them or removing them, to simulate volumetric differences. The Actual data in this reconciliaon is dispatch-
recorded material removed from the pit and placed directly in either the crusher or the stockpile.
The models used were the budget mine planning block models, which were modified from the geological model to account for crude ore loss and
dilution.
Table 11-9: 2021 Model Reconciliation
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Period Variable Model Actual Variance
Q1
Crude Ore (kLT) 6,334 5,749 10.2%
wtrec (%) 34.2 34.5 -0.8%
crudefe (%) 38.0 37.7 0.6%
confe (%) 63.8 64.2 -0.6%
consio2 (%) 4.19 3.98 5.2%
conphos (%) 0.030 0.030 0.6%
Q2
Crude Ore (kLT) 5,753 5,755 0.0%
wtrec (%) 35.0 35.2 -0.5%
crudefe (%) 37.8 36.8 2.9%
confe (%) 63.8 64.5 -1.1%
consio2 (%) 4.20 3.99 5.4%
conphos (%) 0.036 0.031 14.9%
Q3
Crude Ore (kLT) 4,817 5,370 -10.3%
wtrec (%) 35.2 34.7 1.6%
crudefe (%) 38.6 36.4 6.0%
confe (%) 63.5 63.5 0.1%
consio2 (%) 4.44 4.15 7.1%
conphos (%) 0.030 0.033 -6.6%
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 94
-- 322 of 411 --
Period Variable Model Actual Variance
Q4
Crude Ore (kLT) 5,050 5,082 -0.6%
wtrec (%) 35.4 34.6 2.2%
crudefe (%) 39.2 37.6 4.3%
confe (%) 62.8 62.7 0.2%
consio2 (%) 4.59 4.38 4.9%
conphos (%) 0.033 0.034 -3.8%
2021 Total
Crude Ore (kLT) 21,953 21,955 0.0%
wtrec (%) 34.9 34.7 0.5%
crudefe (%) 38.4 37.1 3.3%
confe (%) 63.5 63.7 -0.4%
consio2 (%) 4.34 4.12 5.5%
conphos (%) 0.032 0.032 1.3%
The results indicate good overall reconciliaon, with consistent slight over-predicon of consio2 values and variable conphos, as expected given the
lower precision of these values as discussed in Section 8.0.
11.13 Mineral Resource Statement
A detailed breakdown of the Mineral Resources exclusive of Mineral Reserves is presented in Table 11-10. Mineral Resources defined were constrained
within an opmized pit shell based on a $90/long ton pellet price and meeng the following cut-off grade criteria, based on exisng pellet
specifications and price contracts:
• ≥ 25% wtrec
• ≥ 25% crudefe
• ≤ 0.07% conphos
• ≤ 6% to 8.5% consio2 (domain dependent)
Table 11-10: Summary of Mineral Resources – December 31, 2021
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Category Long Tons
(Mtons)
Crude Fe
(%)
Process Recovery
(%)
Pellets
(Mtons)
Measured - - - -
Indicated 135.4 35.5 35.9 48.6
Total Measured + Indicated 135.4 35.5 35.9 48.6
Inferred 350.4 34.7 36.4 127.4
Notes:
1. Tonnage is reported in long tons equivalent to 2,240 lb.
2. Tonnage is reported exclusive of Mineral Reserves and has been rounded to the nearest 100,000.
3. Mineral Resources are estimated at cut-off grades of 25% crudefe, 25% wtrec, 0.07% conphos, and 6% consio2 to 8.5% consio2, domain dependent.
4. Mineral Resources are estimated using a pellet value of US$90/LT.
5. Pellets are reported as fluxed and dry, containing 61.5% Fe, shipped pellets contain 1.5% moisture.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 95
-- 323 of 411 --
6. Tonnage estimate based on predicted depletion from a surveyed topography on December 31, 2021.
7. Resources are crude ore tons as delivered to the primary crusher; pellets are as loaded onto rail cars.
8. Bulk density is assigned based on a regression equation related to crude Fe.
9. Mineral Resources are 100% attributable to Cliffs.
10. Mineral Resources are constrained within an optimized pit shell and are exclusive of Mineral Reserves.
11. Mineral Resources that are not Mineral Reserves do not have demonstrated economic viability.
12. Numbers may not add due to rounding.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 96
-- 324 of 411 --
12.0 MINERAL RESERVE ESTIMATE
Mineral Reserves in this TRS are derived from the current Mineral Resources.Mineral Reserves are reported as crude ore and are based on open pit
mining. Crude ore is the unconcentrated ore as it leaves the Mine at its natural in situ moisture content. The Proven and Probable Mineral Reserves for
Tilden are estimated as of December 31, 2021, and summarized in Table 12-1.
Table 12-1: Summary of Tilden Mineral Reserves – December 31, 2021
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Category
Crude Ore Mineral
Reserves
(MLT)
Crude Ore Fe
(%)
Process Recovery
(%) Wet Pellets (MLT)
Proven 3.6 35.3 36.1 1.3
Probable 516.4 34.7 37.0 191.1
Proven & Probable 520.0 34.7 37.0 192.4
Notes:
1. Tonnage is reported in long tons equivalent to 2,240 lb and has been rounded to the nearest 100,000.
2. Mineral Reserves are reported at a $90/LT wet hemflux pellet price freight-on-board (FOB) Lake Superior, based on the three-year trailing average of the realized product revenue
rate.
3. Mineral Reserves are estimated at a crude ore cut-off grade of 25.0% Fe along with additional metallurgical constraints.
4. Mineral Reserves include mining dilution built into the Mineral Resource model and mining extraction losses by geometallurgical domain, which range from 4% to 30%.
5. The Mineral Reserve mining stripping ratio (waste units to crude ore units) is 1.2.
6. Proven Mineral Reserves are crude ore that has been mined and stockpiled for processing during the LOM.
7. Process recovery is reported as the percent mass recovery to produce a wet hemflux pellet containing 61.5% Fe; shipped pellets average approximately 1.5% moisture.
8. Tonnage estimate is based on the end of year, December 31, 2021 topographic survey.
9. Mineral Reserve tons are as delivered to the primary crusher; wet hemflux pellets are as loaded onto lake freighters at Marquette, Michigan.
10. Classification of Mineral Reserves is in accordance with the S-K 1300 classification system.
11. Mineral Reserves are 100% attributable to Cliffs.
12. Numbers may not add due to rounding.
The pellet price of US$90/LT wet hemflux pellet was used to perform the evaluaon of Mineral Reserves in the current mining model.This price is
consistent with the Mineral Reserve price used at Cliffs Northshore and United Taconite (UTAC) operaons and is supported by the current three-year
trailing average of the realized product revenue rate of US$98/LT wet hemflux pellet. Proven Mineral Reserves consist exclusively of crude ore that has
been mined and stockpiled for future processing in the LOM plan. The costs used in this TRS represent all mining, processing, transportaon, and
administrative costs including the loading of pellets into lake freighters at Marquette, Michigan.
SLR is not aware of any risk factors associated with, or changes to, any aspects of the modifying factors such as mining, metallurgical, infrastructure,
permitting, or other relevant factors that could materially affect the Mineral Reserve estimate.
12.1 Conversion Assumptions, Optimization Parameters, and Methods
Using the mine planning block model for Tilden, pit opmizaons and pit designs were conducted to convert the Mineral Resources to Mineral
Reserves.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 97
-- 325 of 411 --
In April 2021, a new mine planning block model, which forms the basis of the current Mineral Reserve esmate, was constructed for Tilden.The mine
planning block model is based on the Mineral Resource block model from the January 26, 2021 geologic model (tilden_rpa_block_model_jan2021_ext
_wtrec_mod.bmf) and a September 1, 2020 topographic survey projected to December 31, 2021 using actual and forecast depleon. The current
Mineral Reserve estimate is reported from the mine planning block model and adjusted for the end of year, December 31, 2021 topographic survey.
Scripts executed within Vulcan add variables for economic evaluaon and mine planning, assign mineral lease-holder informaon, and flag
geotechnical zones and in-pit backfills in the mine planning block model. Scripts also assign restricons to blocks that impact facilies areas or reside
within specific geologic boundaries, assigning blocks as restricted or waste when appropriate. The resulng mine planning block model is evaluated
using the pit optimization and Chronos scheduling packages in Vulcan.
Iron formaons at Tilden are only inially considered as “candidate” crude ore if the stragraphy comprises one of the following geometallurgical
domains (as detailed in Sections 6.0 and 27.0 of this TRS):
• 300 Series Domains – 310, 316, 317, 320, 321, 330, 331, 340, 350, and 370.
• 400 Series Domains – 400, 410, 420, 421, and 480.
• 500 Series Domains – 500.
All other geometallurgical domains are considered to be waste.
In order to be amenable to the Tilden beneficiaon process, candidate crude ore from the specified geometallurgical domains must also meet a
number of metallurgical constraints as detailed in Sections 10.0 and 14.0 of this TRS and summarized in Table 12-2.
Table 12-2: Tilden Metallurgical Constraints
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Description Main Pit East Pit
wtrec ≧ 25% ≧ 25%
Head Iron ≧ 25% ≧ 25%
Concentrate P ≦ 0.07% ≦ 0.07%
Concentrate Silica
330 Domain ≦ 7.0% ≦ 6.0%
340 Domain ≦ 8.5% ≦ 8.5%
350 Domain ≦ 7.0% ≦ 6.0%
500 Domain ≦ 6.0% ≦ 6.0%
All Other Domains ≦ 7.0% ≦ 7.0%
Notes:
1. Main Pit area defined as all material west of 26,087,000 E in the Mine site coordinate system.
2. East Pit area defined as all material east of 26,087,000 E in the Mine site coordinate system.
Candidate crude ore blocks must then meet the following additional criteria to be considered crude ore blocks:
1 2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 98
-- 326 of 411 --
• Be classified as a Measured or Indicated Resource; Inferred Mineral Resources are considered to be waste.
• Not occur within a mining-restricted area.
• Generate a net block value greater than the cost of the block as if it were mined as waste.
The mine planning block model is based on 25 V by 25 V by 45 V (XYZ) blocks. SLR notes that the block height is consistent with the mined BH
dimensions of 45 ft.
Tilden practices strict grade control procedures coupled with post-blast, in-field ore and waste zone delineations. The material type assignment of each
block is based on geologic domains, drilling confidence, and metallurgical results from grade control sampling.
Grade control samples are collected from blast holes with the enre 45 V BH composited into a single sample per blast hole. This accounts for mining
conditions such as small scale (i.e., not modeled) intrusive dikes, interfering mineral zones (e.g., smectite clays), or silica inclusions. With the use of this
controlled ore grading system, minimal diluon is expected. Ore loss is assigned systemacally within the block model on a geometallurgical domain
basis using one of the following two methods: assignment based on reconciliaon of operaonal results while mining in a specific domain, or
assignment based on observed variability from exploraon drilling of a specific domain. Ore loss values specific to each domain are used to convert a
percentage of crude ore in the domain to waste rock. The ore loss factors applied by geometallurgical domain are as follows:
• 4% Ore Loss Domains – 310, 320, 340, 350, 370, 410, 420, 421, and 480.
• 8% Ore Loss Domains – 316, 317, and 500.
• 20% Ore Loss Domains – 400.
• 30% Ore Loss Domains – 321, 330, and 331.
Tilden has a long history of plant recovery, which is used as part of the pit opmizaon. The following summarizes the empirical relaonship for
hemflux pellet production based on crude ore tons, wtrec, and concentrate iron (Conc_Fe) content:
Wet Standard Concentrate tons = Crude Ore tons x (wtrec x DDH Discount x Plant Discount)
Wet Hemflux Pellet tons = Wet Standard Concentrate tons x ((Conc_Fe + 0.4) / Hemflux Pellet Fe)
Where:
• DDH Discount = 94.0%
• Plant Discount = 97.5%
• Hemflux Pellet Fe = 61.5%
From 2015 through 2020 the equaon has reconciled within 5% annually when comparing calculated wet hemflux pellet producon to actual wet
hemflux pellet production. Figure 12-1 presents the variance of calculated versus actual hemflux pellets.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 99
-- 327 of 411 --
Figure 12-1: Wet Hemflux Pellet Calculated Versus Actual Production Variance
All Measured and Indicated Mineral Resources within the final designed pit that meet the above criteria are converted into Mineral Reserves.The only
addional criteria for Measured Mineral Resources being converted into Proven Mineral Reserves is that the material must have already been mined
and placed into stockpiles for future processing. Table 12-3 presents the criteria to convert Mineral Resource classificaons to Mineral Reserve
classifications.
Table 12-3: Mineral Resource to Mineral Reserve Classification Criteria
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Mineral Resources Criteria for Conversion Mineral Reserves
Measured Mined and Stockpiled for Processing Proven
Indicated As Scheduled Probable
Inferred As Scheduled Waste
12.2 Previous Mineral Reserve Estimates by Cliffs
Cliffs periodically updates the Tilden Mineral Reserve esmates as changes in Tilden pit development and market condions occur. The SEC-reported
Mineral Reserves for 2012 through 2020 are presented in Table 12-4. While these Mineral Reserves were not prepared under the recently adopted
SEC guidelines they followed SEC Guide 7 requirements for public reporting of Mineral Reserves in the United States.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 100
-- 328 of 411 --
Prior to the current Mineral Reserve esmate, the most recent update to the LOM plan and Mineral Reserves was in 2019.Mineral Reserves in Cliffs’
10K filings have been updated net of depletion since.
Table 12-4: Previous Cliffs Mineral Reserves
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Year
Proven & Probable Crude
Ore
(MLT)
Process Recovery
(%)
Dry Standard Equivalent
Pellets
(MLT)
2020 585 34.3 201
2019 603 34.2 206
2018 324 37.6 122
2017 346 37.3 129
2016 368 37.1 136
2015 389 36.9 144
2014 584 34.2 200
2013 605 34.3 207
2012 625 34.3 214
Notes:
1. As of December 31, 2020; Source: Cleveland-Cliffs, Inc. 10-K Filing
2. As of December 31, 2019; Source: Cleveland-Cliffs, Inc. 10-K Filing
3. As of December 31, 2018; Source: Cleveland-Cliffs, Inc. 10-K Filing
4. As of December 31, 2017; Source: Cleveland-Cliffs, Inc. 10-K Filing
5. As of December 31, 2016; Source: Cleveland-Cliffs, Inc. 10-K Filing
6. As of December 31, 2015; Source: Cleveland-Cliffs, Inc. 10-K Filing
7. As of December 31, 2014; Source: Cleveland-Cliffs, Inc. 10-K Filing
8. As of December 31, 2013; Source: Cleveland-Cliffs, Inc. 10-K Filing
9. As of December 31, 2012; Source: Cleveland-Cliffs, Inc. 10-K Filing
Year-to-year changes to crude ore tons in Table 12-4 are primarily aSributable to mining depleon. SLR notes that in 2015, significant changes to the
pellet market contributed to the decrease in crude ore tons from the previous year. This trend was reversed in 2019, with crude ore tons increasing to
similar levels observed prior to 2015. In 2021, a new Mineral Resource block model was prepared, which, along with mining depleon, contributes to
the current decrease from the end of year 2020.
12.3 Pit Optimization
Pit opmizaons were carried out for Tilden in Vulcan using the current mine-planning block model. Inputs used for the opmizaon were derived
from actual production metrics and first principles estimation for the LOM forecast.
12.3.1 Summary of Pit Optimization Parameters
Pit optimization parameters are summarized as follows:
• Wet hemflux pellet tons = crude ore tons x (wtrec x 0.9165) x ((Conc_Fe + 0.4)/61.5)
• Base-case product average price = $90/LT wet hemflux pellets
• In situ rock mining cost = $2.52/LT mined
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 101
-- 329 of 411 --
• Incremental mining cost per bench above or below +1,575 ft elevation = $0.02/LT/45 ft mined
• Crushing and concentrating cost = $9.50/LT crude ore
• Pelletizing and site administration cost = $14.06/LT wet hemflux pellets
• Replacement capital cost = $4.33/LT wet hemflux pellets
• Royalty cost = variable based on in situ crude ore spatial location
• Maximum overall pit slope angle = variable by slope sector (34° to 44° forin situ rock, 30° in overburden)
• Pit restricon = surface infrastructure to the south (i.e., the processing facilies) with the exisng southern footwall being a defined limit,
existing large waste rock stockpiles to the north and northeast
12.3.2 Pit Optimization Results and Analysis
Pit opmizaon results are used as a guide for pit and stockpile designs. Pit opmizaons were run by varying the base-case product price with a block
revenue factor. The risk profile and revenue-generang potenal of the deposit is evaluated by looking at the relaonship between crude ore and
waste rock and the associated relave discounted cash flows generated at each incremental pit (discount rate of 10% ulized for the opmizaon
analysis).
The opmizaon results are summarized in Table 12-5, presenng the pit shell results from a price range of $63.00/LT to $90.00/LT of wet hemflux
pellets. Pit shell 22 was selected as a guide for the Mineral Reserve final pit design, which is based on a wet hemflux pellet price of $72.90/LT.
Table 12-5: Pit Optimization Results
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Pit Shell Revenue
Factor
Product Price
(US$/LT wet pellet)
Crude Ore
(MLT)
Stripping
(MLT)
Total Tons
(MLT)
Stripping Ratio
(W:O)
Process
Recovery
(%)
Wet
Pellets
(MLT)
11 0.70 63.00 380 187 567 0.5 37.2 141
12 0.71 63.90 390 201 592 0.5 37.1 145
13 0.72 64.80 397 210 607 0.5 37.1 147
14 0.73 65.70 409 229 638 0.6 37.1 151
15 0.74 66.60 418 242 660 0.6 37.0 155
16 0.75 67.50 444 277 721 0.6 36.7 163
17 0.76 68.40 463 303 765 0.7 36.5 169
18 0.77 69.30 478 330 807 0.7 36.5 174
19 0.78 70.20 488 350 837 0.7 36.4 178
20 0.79 71.10 495 364 859 0.7 36.4 180
21 0.80 72.00 525 449 973 0.9 36.5 191
22 0.81 72.90 530 460 990 0.9 36.4 193
23 0.82 73.80 538 476 1,014 0.9 36.4 196
24 0.83 74.70 547 494 1,041 0.9 36.3 199
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 102
-- 330 of 411 --
Pit Shell Revenue
Factor
Product Price
(US$/LT wet pellet)
Crude Ore
(MLT)
Stripping
(MLT)
Total Tons
(MLT)
Stripping Ratio
(W:O)
Process
Recovery
(%)
Wet
Pellets
(MLT)
25 0.84 75.60 553 510 1,063 0.9 36.3 201
26 0.85 76.50 560 529 1,088 0.9 36.3 203
27 0.86 77.40 563 539 1,102 1.0 36.3 204
28 0.87 78.30 565 544 1,109 1.0 36.3 205
29 0.88 79.20 573 568 1,141 1.0 36.2 208
30 0.89 80.10 576 580 1,157 1.0 36.2 209
31 0.90 81.00 578 586 1,163 1.0 36.2 209
32 0.91 81.90 580 592 1,172 1.0 36.2 210
33 0.92 82.80 584 605 1,189 1.0 36.2 211
34 0.93 83.70 588 621 1,209 1.1 36.2 213
35 0.94 84.60 590 630 1,220 1.1 36.2 214
36 0.95 85.50 591 631 1,222 1.1 36.2 214
37 0.96 86.40 592 635 1,226 1.1 36.2 214
38 0.97 87.30 592 637 1,229 1.1 36.2 214
39 0.98 88.20 594 643 1,236 1.1 36.2 215
40 0.99 89.10 596 654 1,250 1.1 36.2 216
41 1.00 90.00 599 666 1,264 1.1 36.2 217
Note:
1. Numbers may not add due to rounding.
Figure 12-2 presents an opmizaon pit-by-pit graph showing tonnages and relave discounted cash flow results, in addion to the selected final pit
shell 22 highlighted (Revenue Factor of 0.81).
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 103
-- 331 of 411 --
Figure 12-2: Tilden Mine Pit-by-Pit Graph
As observed in Figure 12-2, at higher pit shell numbers (i.e., higher product prices) there is limited opportunity for increased Mineral Reserves and the
incremental stripping rao increases significantly. This is a result of the overall pit size being restricted by the surface infrastructure to the south (i.e.,
the processing facilities) and waste rock stockpiles to the north and northeast.
Figure 12-3 superimposes the final pit shell selection (i.e., pit shell 22) footprint over top the current Tilden topography.
As observed in Figure 12-3, the final pit shell selecon develops to the north and along strike of the exisng pit, leaving the exisng southern pit
footwall slope unaltered.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 104
-- 332 of 411 --
Figure 12-3: Final Pit Shell Superimposed Over Current Topography
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 105
-- 333 of 411 --
12.4 Mineral Reserve Cut-off Grade
The Mineral Reserve cut-off grade is a combinaon of metallurgical constraints based on geometallurgical domains applied in order to produce a
saleable product followed by verification through a break-even cut-off grade calculation. In summary, the Mineral Reserve cut-off requirements are:
• Crude ore Fe: all geometallurgical domains≥ 25%
• Crude ore wtrec: all geometallurgical domains ≥ 25%
• Concentrate P: all geometallurgical domains ≤ 0.07%
• Concentrate SiO : variable by geometallurgical domain from ≤ 6.0% to ≤ 8.5%
12.5 Mine Design
The Tilden final pit design incorporates several design variables including geotechnical parameters (e.g., wall angles and bench configuraons),
equipment size requirements (e.g., mining height and ramp configuraon), and physical mining limits (e.g., property boundaries and exisng
infrastructure). The following summarizes the design variables and final pit results. Further detail is provided in the preceding subsecons and in
Section 13.0 of this TRS.
Six separate slope sectors have been idenfied in thein situ rock. The IRA of the slope sectors varies from approximately 38° to 47°.The bench design
consists of 45 V-high mining benches, double benched to a final 90 V BH, with a 48.5° to 66.5° BFA and 35 V to 45 V catch benches (CB).The majority
of the final pit’s south wall is an exisng final wall located above slope sector 5. It was developed along the footwall of the iron formaon and acts as a
limit to the new final pit design.
Pit slopes in glacial overburden are designed at an average slope angle of approximately 30°.
Haul roads are incorporated with widths of 120 ft to support two-way traffic and 90 ft for one-way traffic. Ramp gradients are limited to a maximum of
10% to stay within the safe working capabilities of the trucks.
The selected final pit shell compared to the final pit design is detailed in Table 12-6. Pit design results are reported using the same topographic surface
projection as the pit optimization results (i.e., as per the mine planning block model).
Table 12-6: Pit Optimization to Pit Design Comparison
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Pit Crude Ore
(MLT)
Crude Ore Fe
(%)
Stripping
(MLT)
Total Material
(MLT)
Stripping Ratio
(W:O)
Pit Optimization Pit Shell 22 530 34.7 460 990 0.9
Final Pit Design 513 34.7 595 1,107 1.2
Notes:
1. Comparison totals are per the Mine planning model.
2. Crude ore is in situ tonnage; stockpiled inventory is excluded.
3. Numbers may not add due to rounding.
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 106
-- 334 of 411 --
Overall, the final pit design is a reasonable representaon of the final pit shell guide, with the excepon of the north side of the pit proximal to the
exisng (previously mined) CD3 pit. Addional waste stripping is required in this area to allow access to the CD3 backfill area while not impacng
current Mineral Resources and preserving the future Mineral Resources to Mineral Reserve conversion potential of the area.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 107
-- 335 of 411 --
13.0 MINING METHODS
13.1 Mining Methods Overview
The Tilden deposit is mined using conventional surface mining methods, with surface operations including:
• Overburden (glacial till) removal
• Drilling and blasting (excluding overburden)
• Loading and haulage
• Crushing and rail loading
Tilden Mineral Reserves are based on ongoing annual crude ore producon of 20 MLT to 22 MLT producing approximately 7.7 MLT of wet hemflux
pellets for domestic consumption.
Mining and processing operations are scheduled 24 hours per day, and mine production is scheduled to directly feed the processing operations.
The current LOM plan has mining scheduled for 25 years and mines the known Mineral Reserve.The average stripping rao is approximately 1.2 waste
units to 1 crude ore unit (1.2 stripping ratio).
The final Tilden pit is a single pit approximately 2.5 mi along strike, up to 0.9 mi wide, and up to 1,980 ft deep.
The Tilden operaon has strict crude ore blending requirements to ensure the Plant receives a consistent crude ore feed.The most important
characteriscs of the crude ore are the crude ore iron grade and predicted concentrate mass recovery, and Conc_Fe, silica, and phosphorus content.
Operaonally, blending is completed on a shiV-by-shiV basis. Generally, three to four crude ore loading points are mined simultaneously with dispatch
operators issuing real-time adjustments to meet specified crude ore blends for the Plant.
Crude ore is hauled to the crushing facility and either direct pped to the primary crusher or stockpiled. Haul trucks are alternated to blend delivery
from the multiple crude ore loading points. Crude ore stockpiles are used as an additional source for blending and production efficiency. Crushed crude
ore is conveyed to a covered storage building for stockpiling, prior to being fed to the concentrator. Waste rock and overburden are hauled to one of
the many waste stockpiles peripheral to the pit or to the in-pit backfill.
Primary pit equipment includes electric drills, electric rope shovels, haul trucks, front-end loaders (FELs), bulldozers, and graders.Extensive
maintenance facilities are available at the Mine to service the mine equipment.
13.2 Pit Geotechnical
13.2.1 Overview
The geotechnical parameters used for slope design are based on the 2020 slope angle study completed by Call & Nicholas Inc. (CNI) (CNI, 2020).The
geotechnical and haul road construcon parameters incorporated into the Tilden pit design are summarized in Table 13-1 and referenced graphically
in Figure 13-1 and Figure 13-2. Double benching is practiced, involving two, 45 ft working benches to create one, 90 ft overall BH.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 108
-- 336 of 411 --
Table 13-1: Pit Wall Geotechnical Parameters
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Parameter Unit Sector 1 Sector 2 Sector 3 Sector 4 Sector 5 Sector 6 Overburden
IRA Degrees 38.1 45.0 42.9 38.1 46.9 44.1 29.7
BFA Degrees 48.5 63.5 60.0 48.5 66.5 62.0 60.0
BH ft 90 90 90 90 90 90 45
CB ft 35 45 45 35 45 45 53
Ramp–Width - 2 way ft 120 120 120 120 120 120 120
Ramp–Width - 1 way ft 90 90 90 90 90 90 90
Ramp Gradient (Maximum) % 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 109
-- 337 of 411 --
Figure 13-1: Geotechnical Design Sector 5 Example Cross-section
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 110
-- 338 of 411 --
Figure 13-2: Plan Map of Pit Slope Geotechnical Design Sectors
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 111
-- 339 of 411 --
13.2.2 Geotechnical Data
Geotechnical data includes RQD data, contained in the Tilden drill hole database, and laboratory test results of UCS, BTS, and direct shear tests on
natural fractures (CNI, 2020). The tests performed are summarized in Table 13-2 and Table 13-3.
Table 13-2: Summary of UCS and BTS Test Results
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Rock Type Mean UCS
(psi)
Young’s
Modulus
(psi)
Poisson’s
Ratio
Density
(pcf)
Mean Tensile
Strength
(psi)
Number of Tests
UCS BTS
Intrusive
(200 series) 17,188 5.7E+06 0.26 176 1,939 13 21
Iron Formation
(300, 400, 500 series) 23,657 1.4E+06 0.12 213.4 2,673 11 22
Source: after CNI (2020)
Table 13-3: Summary of Direct Shear Test Results
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Rock Type Mean Cohesion
(psi)
Standard Deviation
Cohesion
(psi)
Mean Friction
Angle
(°)
Standard Deviation
Friction Angle
(°)
Number of Tests
Intrusive
(200 series) 4.7 4.2 19.4 4.8 13
Iron Formation
(300, 400, 500 series) 5.1 4.0 34.4 3.5 11
Fault Gouge 4.0 4.0 18.9 1.6 2
Source: after CNI (2020)
Photogrammetry data, combined with cell-mapping data collected by CNI in 2010 and 2012 was used to develop a structural model.Photographs
taken using an aerial drone were processed by CNI using Pix4D to create high-definion point clouds.The point clouds were then used to map joints
and faults and take measurements of dip and dip direction for use in defining structural domains and for input into a slope stability assessment.
13.2.3 Rock Mass Shear Strength
Geotechnical domains have been delineated from lithological contacts, lithology block models, fault traces and fault surfaces provided by Cliffs, in
addion to from previous Mineral Reserve modeling work. Lithological contacts were used to define iron formaon and intrusive rock domains, which
were further subdivided into separate geotechnical domains by the faults. Mohr-Coulomb shear strength parameters for the rock mass have been
determined using the CNI criterion, which uses a combination of the intact
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 112
-- 340 of 411 --
rock strength and fracture shear strength weighted according to the RQD for each geotechnical domain (Table 13-4).
Table 13-4: Material Properties Used in Overall Slope Stability Analysis
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Cross
Section Rock Type Geologic Domain RQD
70% rel.
Fracture Intact Rock Rock Mass (crf 0.3) – US
Phi
(°)
Coh
(psi)
Phi
(°)
Coh
(psi)
Phi
(°)
Coh
(psi)
Unit Weight
(Ib/ft )
1
300 Iron Fm - 40 34.4 5.1 44.9 3897 37.5 169 213
200 Intrusive 2 43 19.4 4.7 44.9 2829 27.8 133 176
400 Iron Fm 2 34 34.4 5.1 44.9 3897 37.2 145 213
500 Iron Fm 2 35 34.4 5.1 44.9 3897 37.2 148 213
2
200 Intrusive 3 43 19.4 4.7 44.9 2829 27.8 133 176
300 Iron Fm 3 40 34.4 5.1 44.9 3897 37.5 169 213
200 Intrusive 6 43 19.4 4.7 44.9 2829 27.8 133 176
400 Iron Fm 6 34 34.4 5.1 44.9 3897 37.2 145 213
500 Iron Fm 6 35 34.4 5.1 44.9 3897 37.2 148 213
3
200 Intrusive 4 43 19.4 4.7 44.9 2829 27.8 133 176
300 Iron Fm 4 40 34.4 5.1 44.9 3897 37.5 169 213
400 Iron Fm 6 34 34.4 5.1 44.9 3897 37.2 145 213
Source: after CNI (2020)
Strength anisotropy is also modeled to account for strong preferenal joinng in the iron formaons and intrusive rocks, which reduces the shear
strength of the rock mass in the direcon parallel to the main structure. Anisotropic strength is calculated from a weighted average of intact rock
strength (rock bridge) and fracture strength (Table 13-5).
3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 113
-- 341 of 411 --
Table 13-5: Anisotropic Material Properties Used in the Weak Direction
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Cross
Section Rock Type Geologic
Domain
Dip Range
(°) Type
Percentage
Intact
(%)
Phi
(°)
Coh
(psf)
1
300 Iron Fm - -
Joint
3.1 34.8 125.8
200 Intrusive 2 53-38 1.9 19.9 58.4
400 Iron Fm 2 55-39 3.1 34.8 125.8
500 Iron Fm 2 55-39 3.1 34.8 125.8
2
200 Intrusive 3 58-42
Joint
1.9 19.9 58.4
300 Iron Fm 3 51-35 3.1 34.8 125.8
200 Intrusive 6 49-36 1.9 19.9 58.4
400 Iron Fm 6 59-41 3.1 34.8 125.8
500 Iron Fm 6 59-41 3.1 34.8 125.8
3
200 Intrusive 4 51-35
Joint
1.9 19.9 58.4
300 Iron Fm 4 84-52 3.1 34.8 125.8
400 Iron Fm 6 84-52 3.1 34.8 125.8
Source: after CNI (2020)
13.2.4 Hydrogeology and Pit Water Management
Surface water is abundant, as the Property is surrounded by natural lakes and wetlands. While water is known to be present within the rock mass,
inflow of water from the pit walls has not been a significant challenge to operations.
Groundwater has been incorporated into the slope stability analysis using the results of 2D pore pressure modeling carried out by CNI based on the
regional phreatic surface provided by Cliffs.
All pit dewatering that is discharged off-site must first pass through the clarifier system at the Gribben tailings basin prior to discharge via a Naonal
Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES)-permitted outfall, which has a maximum discharge rate of 25.8 million gallons per day.
Water used for dust control on roads comes from pit sumps. Overall water requirements for the Mine are detailed in section 15.10 of this TRS.
13.2.5 Stability Assessment and Slope Design
Recommended IRAs, CBs, and BFAs were derived by CNI from a survey of as-built slopes using LiDAR and drone survey data, which allowed for an
assessment of achievable design parameters. The stability of the overall slope design was assessed for secons cut through the May 2019 pit surface
combined with the current Mineral Reserve pit. Analysis was performed with Rocscience’s Slide 2018 limit equilibrium soVware using the Spencer
method of slices, including the modeled (regional) groundwater phreac surface. A factor of safety (FoS) of 1.2 was chosen as the acceptance criteria
for slope stability. Three sections were analyzed through slope sectors 2, 3, and 4. Results indicate that final slopes in sector 4
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 114
-- 342 of 411 --
will be stable, while sectors 2 and 3 may require some depressurizaon to achieve a FoS of 1.2. SLR recommends an assessment of the groundwater
condions in the immediate vicinity of the final pit through a more focused groundwater model. The results of this assessment should be input into an
update of the stability analysis on sections cut through the current final pit design.
13.3 Open Pit Design
The Tilden pit design combines current site access, minimum mining width requirements, geotechnical parameters, pit opmizaon results, and
mining limit restrictions as described previously in sections 12.5 and 13.2 of this TRS.
Table 13-6 details the contents of the final pit design adjusted for the end of year, December 31, 2021 topographic survey.
Table 13-6: Final Pit Design LOM Total - December 31, 2021
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Pit Crude Ore
(MLT)
Crude Ore Fe
(%)
Waste Rock
Stripping
(MLT)
Overburden
Stripping
(MLT)
Total Stripping
(MLT)
Total Material
(MLT)
Stripping Ratio
(W:O)
Tilden 516.4 34.7 586.6 13.9 600.5 1,116.9 1.2
Notes:
1. Crude ore is in situ tonnage, stockpiled inventory is excluded.
2. Numbers may not add due to rounding.
Figure 13-3 presents a plan view of the final pit design in addion to the final waste stockpile designs. Figure 13-4 to Figure 13-6 present example
cross-sections through the final pit design.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 115
-- 343 of 411 --
Figure 13-3: Final Pit Plan View
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 116
-- 344 of 411 --
Figure 13-4: Example East Final Pit Cross-section Looking West
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 117
-- 345 of 411 --
Figure 13-5: Example Middle Final Pit Cross-section Looking West
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 118
-- 346 of 411 --
Figure 13-6: Example West Final Pit Cross-section Looking West
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 119
-- 347 of 411 --
13.3.1 Pit Phase Design
Intermediate pit phase designs or pushbacks are included in the LOM planning. The primary objecve of the phased designs is to balance waste
stripping and maintain access to specific ore types for blending purposes while ensuring haulage access is maintained over the LOM. Access to crude
ore, specifically 340 domain Fe carbonate, 350 domain Fe oxide, and 320 domain Fe clasc iron mineralizaon groups, plays a significant role in
determining the pit phasing design
Designs for each mining pit phase are largely determined by effecve minimum mining width and influence on access to crude ore. Pit opmizaon
results at lower revenue factors are also used to help guide the phase development.
Design parameters for intermediate-phase walls use decreased BFAs to account for shallower wall slopes as a result of not drilling and cleaning to the
final pit design parameters. Figure 13-7 presents the locaon of the phases within the mining area, where the surface footprint of each phase is
represented by a different color.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 120
-- 348 of 411 --
Figure 13-7: Intermediate Pit Phase Footprints
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 121
-- 349 of 411 --
13.4 Production Schedule
13.4.1 Clearing
Before mining operations commence in new undeveloped areas, it is necessary to remove any overburden material. The primary clearing and grubbing
equipment includes bulldozers, electric rope shovels, FELs, and trucks. This equipment has been successfully deployed in historical overburden clearing
operaons at Tilden. SLR notes there is a minimal amount of clearing and overburden removal remaining in the LOM plan, while the majority of the
activity will be focused in areas of waste stockpile expansion.
13.4.2 Grade Control
A strict regiment of grade control procedures are followed at Tilden, coupled with post-blast, in-field ore and waste zone delineaons to ensure a
consistent crude ore feed blend for processing. As described in Secons 6.0 and 8.0 of this TRS, the local geology is well known with crude ore types
geometallurgically binned into Fe oxide, Fe carbonate, Fe hydroxide, and Fe clastic mineral groups.
Grade control sampling is performed on every other producon blast hole from every other row drilled in the iron formaon (i.e., approximately one
third of the producon blast holes in the iron formaon) to confirm or reclassify crude ore mineral groupings and delineate ore-waste boundaries. If
the crude ore iron chemistry for the sampled blast holes is above the cut-off grade, the sample proceeds to bench flotaon tesng at the Tilden
laboratory. The results of the bench flotaon tesng are entered into a database that is available to the mine engineering and geology department.
This data is exported to Vulcan mine planning soVware, where crude ore and waste zone delineaons are made, and metallurgical grade blocks are
created using grade control software. Metallurgical grade blocks are ulized in short-range planning and uploaded into dispatch for crude ore blending
purposes. Metallurgical data from the corresponding grade block is assigned to each truck load delivered to the primary crusher, allowing for the
determination of weighted-average metallurgical qualities for specified periods.
Generally, three to four crude ore headings and/or stockpiles are mined at any one me to obtain the best crude ore blend for the Plant.
Operaonally, blending is completed on a shiV-by-shiV basis using the dispatch system for producon management and data tracking. The dispatch
operator is provided a blend schedule for each shiV detailing the acve crude ore headings and the expected specific blend percentage for each of the
headings. Each producon loading unit is equipped with a high-precision GPS, which, when coupled with the spaal grade blocks uploaded into the
dispatch system, allows the dispatch operator to monitor progress and manage mining acvies at each heading. Dispatch operators issue real-me
adjustments to meet specified crude ore blends or correct for changes in pit operang condions. As crude ore is delivered to the primary crusher, the
dispatch system tracks the tonnage and associated metallurgical grades to provide a running total to the dispatch operator. Crude ore is either
delivered directly to the primary crusher or is stockpiled in crude ore type-specific stockpiles for later use. Ore can be stockpiled for immediate
operational reasons, planned mining sequence optimization, or to ensure future consistent ore quality.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 122
-- 350 of 411 --
13.4.3 Production Schedule
The basis of the production schedule is to:
• Produce approximately 7.7 MLT/y of wet hemflux pellets for the LOM:
◦ This production rate was selected as it represents maintaining the current production assumption throughout the LOM.
◦ Limit crude ore delivery to the crusher to 22 MLT/y.
• Meet the maximum and minimum metallurgical constraints for crude ore and concentrate including carbonate crude ore type blending
restrictions:
◦ Constrain annual crude ore blend metallurgy to:
Minimum Conc_Fe of 61.5% Fe.
Maximum concentrate phosphorus of 0.040% P.
◦ Limit delivery blend of specific crude ore types to:
Minimum 340 carbonate crude ore blend component of 20%.
Maximum combined 316, 420, and 421 carbonate crude ore blend component of 10%.
• Limit total mined tons per period at approximately 62 MLT to balance the mine fleet utilization.
The producon schedule is planned yearly throughout the LOM. Scheduling is by mining blocks within the pit phases. Table 13-7 presents the LOM
production schedule for Tilden.
Table 13-7: LOM Production Schedule
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Year Crude Ore
(MLT)
Crude Ore Fe
(MLT)
Stripping
(MLT)
Total Tons
(MLT)
Stripping Ratio
(W:O)
Crude Ore
Milled
(MLT)
Process
Recovery
(%)
Wet
Pellets
(MLT)
2022 19.3 34.3 38.4 57.7 1.8 21.6 35.6 7.7
2023 21.3 34.6 40.7 62.0 1.9 21.3 36.1 7.7
2024 22.7 34.7 39.3 62.0 1.9 21.2 36.3 7.7
2025 22.5 34.8 39.3 61.8 1.8 21.3 36.1 7.7
2026 20.4 34.6 37.9 58.3 1.7 22.1 34.9 7.7
2027 20.2 34.9 38.5 58.7 1.8 21.5 35.8 7.7
2028 20.8 35.0 29.2 50.0 1.4 20.8 37.1 7.7
2029 20.6 35.4 29.4 50.0 1.4 20.6 37.4 7.7
2030-2034 106.6 34.8 113.4 220.0 1.1 106.6 36.2 38.5
2035-2039 101.1 35.0 98.9 200.0 1.0 101.1 38.1 38.5
2040-2044 102.1 34.2 75.4 177.5 0.7 102.1 37.7 38.5
2045 - 2046 38.8 35.1 20.1 58.9 0.5 39.8 35.1 15.3
Total 516.4 34.7 600.5 1116.9 1.2 520.0 37.0 192.4
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 123
-- 351 of 411 --
Note:
1. Numbers may not add due to rounding.
Recent past production (2010 to current) and LOM planned production for Tilden is presented in Figure 13-8.
Figure 13-8: Past and Forecast LOM Production
As observed in Table 13-7 and Figure 13-8, waste stripping decreases significantly starng in 2028 and is steady or decreasing over the remaining
LOM, with final-phase crude ore sources being exposed leading to decreases in required developmental stripping and overall material movement.
13.5 Overburden and Waste Rock Stockpiles
Waste rock and overburden excavated during the stripping process is placed in designated stockpiles located either around the periphery of the pit or
inside the pit in designated in-pit backfills. Overburden that can be segregated is either used in concurrent reclamaon acvies or stockpiled for
future reclamation use.
The overburden and waste rock stockpile design parameters are detailed in Table 13-8.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 124
-- 352 of 411 --
Table 13-8: Stockpile Parameters
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Parameter Unit Waste Rock Overburden
OSA degrees 22.8 20.1
BFA degrees 36 30
BH ft 50 50
Berm Width ft 50 50
Ramp–Width - 2 way ft 120 120
Ramp–Width - 1 way ft 90 90
Ramp Gradient % 10 10
Stripped waste rock excavated during the LOM plan will be stockpiled in either the CD3 in-pit backfill (CD3) to the north or the Tilden West Stockpile
(TWD).
Overburden is segregated and if not used in concurrent reclamaon acvies is placed exclusively in the Tilden South Stockpile (TSD) stockpile, which
was previously used as a waste rock stockpile. Stockpiled overburden material will be available for future reclamation activities.
The volumes for each stockpile are calculated using three-dimensional models created in Vulcan. Material-specific swell factors are used to convert the
volumes into stockpile capacity. Table 13-9 lists the maximum design volume and storage capacity for each of the rock and overburden stockpile
designs, in addition to the planned utilized capacity.
Table 13-9: Volumes and Capacities of Stockpile Designs
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Stockpile Design Volume
(Mft )
Design Capacity
(MLT)
LOM Utilized Capacity
(MLT)
Waste Rock Stockpiles
CD3 6,097 339 339
TWD 6,053 337 248
Total Waste Rock Stockpiles 12,150 676 587
Overburden Stockpile
TSD 437 24 14
SLR notes that there is sufficient overburden and waste rock stockpile capacity included in the LOM plan.
In addion to waste rock and overburden stockpiling acvies, crude ore blending constraints require crude ore stockpiling in crude ore type-specific
stockpiles. The crude ore stockpiles are active over the LOM with crude ore dispatched in and out and new accumulations of up to 3.0 MLT.
Figure 13-9 presents the full design capacities for the CD3 and TWD waste rock stockpiles and the TSD overburden stockpile.
3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 125
-- 353 of 411 --
Figure 13-9: Tilden Mine Stockpile Designs at Full Capacity
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 126
-- 354 of 411 --
In 2018, Golder Associates Inc. (Golder) assessed the current stockpiles following guidelines published by Hawley and Cunning (2017) to classify the
instability hazard as either very low, low, moderate, high, or very high. All stockpiles evaluated were classified as being a low-instability hazard with the
excepon of the TOD stockpile (i.e., the Fox Valley overburden stockpile), which is listed as a moderate instability hazard, falling on the line
differenang moderate from low risk (Shaigetz and Cunning, 2019). SLR notes there is no addional loading of the TOD stockpile in the current LOM
plan.
13.6 Mining Fleet
The primary mine equipment fleet consists of electric drills, electric cable shovels, and off-road dump trucks. In addion to the primary equipment,
there are FELs, bulldozers, graders, water trucks, and backhoes for mining support. Addional equipment is on site for non-producve mining fleet
tasks. The current fleet is to be maintained with replacement units as the current equipment reaches its maximum operang hours. The producon
equipment fleet is based on a quarterly, rolling five-year production schedule developed by the Mine.
Table 13-10 presents the existing fleet (2021/2022) and planned average major fleet requirements estimated to achieve the LOM plan.
Table 13-10: Major Mining Equipment
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Year Drills Shovels Trucks Loaders Dozers Graders
2022 4 6 17 4 7 4
2023 4 5 17 4 7 4
2024 4 5 16 4 7 4
2025-2029 4 5 18 4 7 4
2030-2034 3 5 15 2 7 4
2035-2039 3 4 15 3 7 4
2040-2044 3 3 13 4 7 4
2045-2048 3 3 10 4 7 4
Size/Payload 16 in 44 yd 320 ton 37 yd 57 yd 14 ft
Useful Life (hrs) 100,000 150,000 90,000 45,000 60,000 60,000
Example Unit P&H 120A P&H 2800 Komatsu 930E LeTourneau L1850 CAT D11 CAT 16M
The primary loading and hauling equipment were selected to provide a good synergy between mine selecvity of crude ore and the ability to operate
in variable conditions. Since crude ore is blended at the primary crusher, the loading units in crude ore do not operate at capacity.
Longer haulage distances will be realized as the open pit deepens and the waste stockpiles increase in size. As the haulage distances increase, the
waste stripping ratio decreases, helping offset the need for additional haul trucks.
Extensive maintenance facilities are available at the Mine site to service the mine equipment.
3 3 3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 127
-- 355 of 411 --
13.7 Mine Manpower
The current mining manpower is summarized as follows:
• Mine operations: 237
• Mine maintenance (excluding mine crusher): 156
• Mine supervision and technical services: 40
The mine operaons and mine maintenance manpower will increase/decrease proporonately with the change in haul trucks over the LOM. The
additional required manpower will be sourced from local communities.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 128
-- 356 of 411 --
14.0 PROCESSING AND RECOVERY METHODS
14.1 Overview
Over the years, the Tilden concentrator capacity has expanded to its current nominal capacity of 7.7 MLT/y fluxed pellets from both hemate and
magnetite crude ore sources. The Plant includes many unit operaons standard to the industry, including, primary crushing, autogenous grinding (AG),
flotaon, filtering, drying, agglomeraon, and induraon to remove silica gangue and produce a hardened pellet. The unique feature of the Tilden
concentrator is the selecve flocculaon and desliming process implemented prior to flotaon, which successfully removes slime contaminants that
would otherwise cause serious complicaons during subsequent stages of processing. The Tilden concentrator is designed to campaign either
hemate-dominant ores or magnete ores, but does not process both ore types simultaneously. The major difference between the hemate and
magnete circuits is the magnete circuit includes two separate stages of magnec separaon in the grinding circuit. This secon briefly describes the
processes currently in use at the Plant.
The processing of magnete ores at the Tilden concentrator ceased in 2009. Magnete ore from the Mine was delivered and processed at the Empire
Mine from 2010 through 2016 when the Empire Mine was indefinitely idled. Remaining Mineral Resources and Mineral Reserves at Tilden are
processed in hematite-based flotation circuits.
14.2 Processing Methods
The process flowsheet for the hematite circuit is presented in Figure 14-1, while a list of major equipment is provided in Table 14-1.
14.2.1 Comminution
Primary crushing, which is operated and maintained by the mining department, is accomplished with a 60 in. x 109 in. Allis-Chalmers gyratory crusher
operated to produce a nominal -9 in. crushed product, which is conveyed to the ore storage building ahead of the grinding circuit. Primary grinding is
accomplished with eleven, 27 V-diameter x 14.5 V-long AG mills, each driven by two synchronous motors that have a combined output of 5,720 hp.
Each primary AG mill discharges to a triple-deck screen, producing a -1.5 in. x 0.5 in. product that is used as a grinding media in the pebble mills (excess
diverted to the pebble crushers or recirculated back to the primary mill), a -0.5 in. x 2 mm product that is conveyed back to the primary mill, and a -2
mm product that is advanced to the secondary pebble mills. The -2 mm discharge from each AG mill feeds two, 15.5 V-diameter x 32 V-long pebble
mills, which are operated in closed circuit with a cluster of nine, 15 in.-diameter cyclones to produce a final grind of 80% to 85% passing 25 μm. Caustic
soda and slaked lime are added to the water circuit to control pH prior to desliming and flotation.
14.2.2 Desliming
Starch and a dispersant are added to the slurry and advanced to the deslime thickeners. At this stage, the iron oxides are selecvely flocculated by the
starch and depressed, and the siliceous slimes are dispersed and removed. Deslime thickener overflow containing these waste products is fed to the
tailings thickeners, and the seSled slimes are disposed of in the tailings pond. The deslime thickener underflow is condioned with addional starch
and advanced to the flotation circuit.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 129
-- 357 of 411 --
14.2.3 Flotation
The flotaon circuit is divided into twelve lines, each consisng of ten, 500 V rougher flotaon cells, which are used to float silica-rich tailings away
from the iron minerals with an amine collector. The rougher flotaon concentrate represents the final upgraded iron concentrate and is advanced to
the concentrate thickener. Rougher tailings are further scavenged in four stages (fiVeen, 500 V flotaon cells per line) of scavenger flotaon to
remove entrained iron values. Scavenger flotaon concentrates are recycled back to the head of the rougher flotaon circuit, with scavenger tailings
being pumped to the tailings thickeners.
14.2.4 Dewatering
The iron concentrate is thickened to approximately 65% to 70% solids in two, 150 V-diameter and two, 180 V-diameter Eimco thickeners, neutralized
to a pH of 7.0 using carbon dioxide and then filtered in a series of 9 V-diameter x 8 disc vacuum disc filters to approximately 11.5% w/w moisture
content. Filtered concentrates are either sent directly to the pelletizing plant, a thermal drying circuit, or to a concentrate storage stockpile.
14.2.5 Fluxstone
Fluxstone consisng of dolomite and calcite is received at Tilden via truck and stored in stockpiles. Material is fed from a stockpile via apron feeders
and processed in two, 15.5 V-diameter x 30 V-long ball mills. The fluxstone slurry is added to the iron concentrate prior to filtering to ensure
homogenous mixing.
14.2.6 Historical Magnetite Processing (1989 to 2009)
The magnete processing circuit is similar to the hemate circuit, with the excepon that when magnete is campaigned through the concentrator,
the -1.4 mm screen undersize from each AG mill is sent to low-intensity magnec cobbing to recover the coarsely liberated magnete. The non-
magnetic cobber tail is directed to tailings. The magnec fracon from the cobbing circuit is then directed to the secondary pebble mill grinding circuit,
which is operated in closed circuit with a cluster of 15 in.-diameter cyclones. The cyclone overflow is then sent to two stages of deslime thickening.
Thickener underflow from the second stage of desliming is processed in a finisher stage of low-intensity magnec separaon, with the magnec
concentrate connuing to a finisher thickener stage. Underflow from the finisher thickener is then advanced to silica flotaon with amine collectors.
The remaining magnetite circuit is the same as the hematite circuit.
3
3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 130
-- 358 of 411 --
Figure 14-1: Hematite Circuit Process Flowsheet
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 131
-- 359 of 411 --
14.3 Pelletizing Plant
The pellezing plant unit processes include concentrate drying, concentrate agglomeraon (balling), pellet hardening or induraon in a grate kiln and
cooler, and pellet storage and railcar loading. The pelletizing plant flowsheet is presented in Figure 14-2.
A poron of the concentrate feeding the pellet plant along with concentrate reclaimed from stockpiles is dried in a rotary dryer. The dried concentrate
is combined with filtered concentrate on the agglomeration or balling feed conveyor.
14.3.1 Concentrate Agglomeration - Balling
The balling circuit is supplied with concentrate with a target moisture content of 9.5%. Balling is accomplished using fourteen, 12 V-diameter x 33 V-
long rotary drums operated at approximately 12 rpm. Bentonite, a clay binder, is raoed to the balling drum feed and blended on the balling drum
feed belt to agglomerate the concentrate. Each drum utilizes an oscillating cutter bar, and the resulting green balls are discharged onto a vibrating seed
screen with a 2 V-long grizzly extension for oversize removal. Screen undersize is returned to the balling drum, while grizzly oversize is returned to the
concentrate bin or diverted to outdoor storage. The seed screen product is conveyed by a reciprocang conveyor, which distributes the green balls
over a grate feed belt.
14.3.2 Grate, Kiln, Cooler
The green balls are loaded onto a moving grates with a feed rate maintained to achieve a nominal bed depth of seven inches. The grates pass through
19 wind boxes. The green balls are subjected to 3.5 bays of updraV drying, 7.5 bays of downdraV drying, and eight bays of downdraV preheang. After
traversing the length of the grates, the green balls are discharged into one of two, 25 V-diameter x 160 V-long rotary kilns. Heat for the kilns is
produced with a combinaon of pulverized coal and/or natural gas. Product from the kiln is discharged into two, 10 V-wide x 66 V-diameter rotary
coolers, sufficiently cooling the pellets to be transported by conveyor.
14.3.3 Pellet Loadout
Cooled pellets are conveyed directly to either a railroad load-out bin or to an outdoor stockpile with a nominal capacity of 2 MLT. Pellets are loaded
into rail cars with 60 LT capacity in configuraons of 110 cars. Pellets are transported via rail to a dock facility in MarqueSe, Michigan or directly to
customers. Pellet stockpiles are selecvely screened to reduce fines with a loader-fed, portable screening plant. Pellet chips and fines from this
process are sold as secondary product.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 132
-- 360 of 411 --
Figure 14-2: Process Flowsheet for Pelletizing Plant
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 133
-- 361 of 411 --
14.4 Major Equipment
A list of all major processing equipment is provided in Table 14-1.
Table 14-1: Major Processing Equipment
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Equipment Qty Size Manufacturer Hp Comments
Primary Gyratory Crusher 1 60 in. x 109 in. Allis Chalmers 1000
Apron Feeders 4 48 in. x 9 ft Stephen-Adamson 5
Primary Autogenous Mill 5 27 ft x 15.5 ft Allis Chalmers 2 x 2860 Tilden 1
Primary Autogenous Mill 6 27 ft x 15.5 ft Allis Chalmers 2 x 3100 Tilden 2
Vibrating Screen 11 Model OA-160-D Simplicity 50 triple-deck (12.7mm x 2mm)
Pebble Crusher 2 MP-800 Nordberg 800
Crushed Product Ball Mill 1 27 ft x 15.5 ft Allis Chalmers 2 x 2860 Internal diameter reduced
Secondary Pebble Mill 10 15.5 ft x 30 ft Nordberg 2860 Tilden 1
Secondary Pebble Mill 12 15.5 ft x 32 ft Nordberg 3100 Tilden 2
Hydrocyclone 198 15 in. Krebs 9 cyclones per pebble mill
Cobber Magnetic Separators 27 48 in. x 120 in. Eriez Magnetite Processing Only
Deslime Thickener 24 55 ft diameter EIMCO 7.5
Flotation Feed Conditioner 12 9 ft x 9 ft Denver Equipment 15
Finishing Magnetic Separator 27 48 in. x 120 in. Eriez Magnetite Processing Only
Rougher Flotation Cells 10 500 ft WEMCO 40 12 banks x 10/bank
Scavenger-1 Flotation Cells 5 500 ft WEMCO 40 12 banks x 5/bank
Scavenger-2 Flotation Cells 4 500 ft WEMCO 40 12 banks x 4/bank
Scavenger-3 Flotation Cells 3 500 ft WEMCO 40 12 banks x 3/bank
Scavenger-4 Flotation Cells 3 500 ft WEMCO 40 12 banks x 3/bank
Concentrate Dewatering
Concentrate Thickener 2 150 ft diameter EIMCO 7.5 + 7.5
Concentrate Thickener 2 180 ft diameter EIMCO 7.5 + 7.5
Vacuum Disk Filter 42 9 ft diameter x 8 discs EIMCO 5
Vacuum Pump 3 12,100 ICFM@26 mm Hg Ingersoll-Rand 500
Vacuum Pump 14 Nash 500
Dewatering Thickener 2 450 ft diameter Dorr-Oliver 4 + 7.5
Tailing Pumps 10 16 in. x 14 in. GIW 400 Several different sizes
Gribben Booster Pump 1 16 in. x 14 in. Warman 1000
Lamella Clarifiers 2 Veolia
Flux Preparation
Flux Grinding Mill 2 15.5 ft x 30 ft Nordberg 2520 Internal length reduced
3
3
3
3
3
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 134
-- 362 of 411 --
Equipment Qty Size Manufacturer Hp Comments
Hydrocylones 3 15 in. Krebs
DSM Screens 4
Thickener 1 55 ft diameter Eimco 7.5 + 1
Plant Services
Boiler 1 200 klb Trane Murrey 350 fan
Boiler 1 200 klb Zun Boiler 350 fan
Instrument Air Compressor 3 131/2 - 8x7 Joy 200
Instrument Air Compressor 8 15-15x7 Joy 200
Instrument Air Compressor 1 ZR 750 Atlas Copco 500
Snap Blow Compressor 1 Pre-2 Series F Ingersoll Rand
Plant Air Compressor 1 TS-32-600 Sullair
14.5 Plant Performance
Plant performance for 2014 to 2020 is summarized in Table 14-2 and demonstrates that crude iron ore head grades ranged from 33.4% Fe to 34.8% Fe
over the period. Iron recovery to flotaon concentrates on average ranged from 66.0% to 72.3%, with a concentrate grade averaging 62.5% to 63.7%
during this period. Approximately 20.3 MLT (wet) of crude ore is processed through the concentrator annually to produce 8.0 MLT (wet) of fluxed
concentrate and 7.5 MLT (wet) of fluxed pellets (hemflux pellet).
Table 14-2: Tilden Concentrator Performance 2014 to 2020
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Feed (LT) 20,298,301 19,660,601 20,671,866 21,006,512 21,016,286 21,500,213 18,006,414
Fe % 34.5 33.9 33.4 34.2 34.8 34.4 34.3
Flotation Conc. (WLT; Nat WR) 8,130,162 7,998,381 8,295,261 8,156,868 8,320,062 8,312,224 6,968,367
W% (Nat WR-WLT) 40.05 40.68 40.13 38.83 39.59 38.70 38.66
W% (Dry Met WR) 38.00 37.26 37.71 38.97 40.69 36.06 37.10
Fe% (Dry Met) 63.7 63.7 63.3 62.7 62.5 63.0 63.1
Fe Dist % (Dry Met) 70.2 70 71.5 71.3 72.3 66.04 68.26
Total Tailings (Dry LT; based on
Met WR) 12,584,085 12,334,440 12,876,850 12,819,820 12,465,763 13,747,062 11,325,283
W% (Dry Met) 62.00 62.74 62.29 61.03 59.31 63.94 62.90
Fe% (Dry Met) 16.6 16.2 15.3 16 15.8 18.3 17.3
Fe Dist% (Dry Met) 29.80 30.00 28.50 28.70 27.70 33.96 31.74
Fluxstone (LT) 775,910 764,959 738,966 732,351 753,046 775,709 672,212
Fluxed Conc. (LT) 8,906,072 8,763,340 9,034,227 8,889,219 9,073,107 9,087,933 7,640,580
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 135
-- 363 of 411 --
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Pellet Plant Feed (LT) 8,907,111 8,918,098 9,002,847 8,989,704 9,068,586 9,096,377 7,489,057
Bentonite Binder (ST) 79,518 80,551 71,481 71,833 68,234 72,638 61,494
Hemflux Pellet (LT) 7,580,920 7,631,260 7,631,980 7,650,141 7,678,514 7,708,582 6,323,241
14.6 Pellet Quality
Tilden’s blast furnace (BF) customers monitor the hemflux pellet physical quality parameters closely, with Tilden pellets measured against several
physical and chemical properties outlined in Table 14-3.
Table 14-3: Hemflux Pellet Quality
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Quality Variable Typical
% Fe 61.00
% SiO 4.90
% CaO 4.40
CaO/SiO 0.90
% MgO 1.70
% P 0.040
% Mn 0.3
% Al O 0.6
% H O 1.5
BT -½” Total (%) 6
BT -½” +3/8” (%) 82
BT -3/8” +¼” (%) 9
BT -¼” Total (%) 2
BT –28M (%) 0.3
AT + ¼” Total (%) 96.5
AT –28M (%) 2.7
Comp. (lbs. Avg.) 470
Comp. (% -300 lbs) 14
Reducibility R40 0.93
LTD 93
SLR has reviewed yearly performance data for Tilden hemflux pellet producon since 2014 and noted that Cliffs has achieved these specificaons on a
consistent basis during that period.
14.7 Consumable Requirements
Major consumables for the Plant operation include:
2
2
2 3
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 136
-- 364 of 411 --
• Carbon Dioxide: Used to neutralize the slurry’s pH prior to filtering and to lower the tails basin water’s pH for management of selenium in the
clarifier discharge.
• Caustic Soda: Used to control and maintain the process pH between 10.6 and 11.5 for effective operation of deslime and flotation.
• Dispersant: Added in deslime thickeners to aid with silica slime rejection.
• Cornstarch: Added in during desliming and flotation to reduce iron losses.
• Starch Enhancer: Modifier to improve process performance.
• Amine: Chemical added during flotation to selectively collect high-silica-bearing particles into froth.
• DOSS: Dioctyl sulfosuccinate added to aid moisture control in filtering.
• Lime: pH modifier for process waters, and offsets caustic soda usage.
• Polymer Nalco: Anionic polymer added during the concentrate thickener stage to minimize iron losses.
• Polymer Filters: Flocculant added in filter lines to aid with filter productivity.
• Polymer Thickeners: Flocculant added to tails thickeners for solids collection.
• Dry Polymer: Flocculant added to the concentrate thickener for slurry densification.
• Filter bags: Filtering consists of 42 filters comprised of 80 sectors. Each sector is covered with a bag that collects solids and allows water to pass
through.
• Ferric Chloride: Used in the clarifier process.
• Fluxstone: A blend of calcite and dolomite added to the concentrate prior to filtraon to create fluxed concentrate for fluxed pellet producon.
Delivered to site via trucks in four different classificaons: summer calcite, summer dolomite, winter calcite, and winter dolomite. The winter
prefix denotes coarser material than that denoted by summer, as it is used during the winter season for improved feeding to flux grinding
system.
• Grinding Balls: Line 1 Ball Mill balls for grinding of crushed product from the secondary crusher.
• Mill Lining: Replaceable wear liner systems in grinding mills.
• Bentonite: Clay used to create green balls in balling drums for feed onto the induration grate.
Table 14-4 presents the unit rates for concentrator and pellet plant consumables.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 137
-- 365 of 411 --
Table 14-4: Consumables
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Consumable Units (LT) Rate
Concentrator
Carbon Dioxide lb/ton Crude Feed 0.775
Carbon Dioxide-Tailings lb/ton Crude Feed 0.4
Caustic Soda lb/ton Crude Feed 1.25
Polyacrylic Acid lb/ton Crude Feed 0.21
Cornstarch lb/ton Crude Feed 0.525
Starch Enhancer lb/ton Crude Feed 0.1
Amine lb/ton Crude Feed 0.15
DOSS lb/ton Crude Feed 0.28
Lime lb/ton Crude Feed 1.5
Polymer Nalco lb/ton Crude Feed 0.005
Polymer Filters lb/ton Crude Feed 0.04
Polymer Thickeners lb/ton Crude Feed 0.32
Dry Polymer lb/ton Crude Feed 0.0024
Filter Bags bags/ton Std Concentrate 0.0031
Ferric Chloride lb/ton Crude Feed 0.2117
Fluxstone LT flux/ton Std Concentrate 0.09
Grinding Balls lb/ton Std Concentrate 0.5
Mill Lining lb/ton Std Concentrate 0.8013
Electric Power kWh/ton Std Concentrate 51.011
Natural Gas MMBtu/ton Std Concentrate 0.8013
Process Fuel MMBtu/ton Std Concentrate 0.1719
Heating MMBtu/ton Std Concentrate 0.0098
Pellet Plant
Bentonite lb/ton Pellets 19.5
Electric Power kWh/ton Pellets 21.09
Process Fuel Kiln (Nat Gas/Coal) MMBtu/ton Pellets 0.8707
Process Fuel Dryer (Nat Gas) MMBtu/ton Pellets 0.0875
Heating (Nat Gas) MMBtu/ton Pellets 0.0411
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 138
-- 366 of 411 --
14.8 Process Workforce
Current processing headcount totals 399 and is summarized as follows:
• Plant operations – 160
• Plant maintenance – 180
• Plant supervision and technical services – 59
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 139
-- 367 of 411 --
15.0 INFRASTRUCTURE
15.1 Roads
Primary access to the Mine is via the Tilden Mine Access Road.This road is one mile in length, connecng the mine guard gate to County Road 476 just
south of National Mine. Once on the Property, the Tilden administraon buildings and Plant are located 0.8 mi to the east. Mining area (pit) offices are
located at the adjacent Empire Mine facility 2.75 mi to the east. Secondary access to the Mine is east of the Empire Mine facility, just north of the
town of Palmer. Further details regarding local resources can be found in section 4.3.
15.2 Rail
Pellets produced at Tilden are loaded from stockpiles either by FELs or through a train load-out pocket to rail cars and are transported by the LS&I, a
wholly owned subsidiary of Cliffs. Rail cars have a nominal capacity of 60 LT, with a train typically consisng of 110 cars. Average rail rates are 25,000
LT/d to the LS&I dock at MarqueSe, Michigan, a distance of 22 mi.LS&I owns approximately 1,000 cars and uses a mixture of owned and leased
locomotives.
Pellets can also be shipped using the CN railroad. The CN owns and operates its own rail fleet. Currently, one customer receives direct rail deliveries by
CN to Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario, Canada, a distance of 120 mi from the Property.The customer is responsible for the rail contract with CN.Figure 15-1
is a satellite photograph of the LS&I railway and port facilities in Marquette, Michigan.
Figure 15-1: LS&I Railroad and Port
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 140
-- 368 of 411 --
15.3 Port Facilities
The LS&I gravity-dump pocket dock was designed in 1910 and placed in operaon in 1912. The dock serves two primary purposes, to load ships with
iron pellets. The dock is a 1,274 V-long, 74 V-tall concrete structure comprising storage pockets with 100 gravity-feed chutes on each side of the dock
that are lowered for discharging pellets into the holds of Great Lakes iron ore freighters. The storage pockets are loaded from LS&I boSom-dump rail
cars posioned on top of the dock. There are four parallel rail lines on top of the dock with room for posioning 200 rail cars at any one me. An
automated dumper opens the clam shell boSom hatches on the cars discharging the pellets into the pockets. The storage capacity of the dock is
approximately 450 rail cars including the 200 cars posioned on top of the dock. Locomoves are used to shuSle empty and loaded cars to and from
the dock to keep the dock full for ship loading.
15.4 Tailings Disposal
CCIC operates the Mine in MarqueSe County, Michigan, which includes the Gribben Tailings Basin (GTB) located approximately five miles southeast of
the Plant and nine miles from Lake Superior. The GTB is comprised of two ring dike-type impoundments: the Gribben North Tailings Basin (GNTB),
which encompasses approximately 1,350 acres, and the Gribben South Tailings Basin (GSTB), which encompasses approximately 1,100 acres.Each
impoundment is comprised of a perimeter dam constructed in an upstream method from an original centerline structure with a keyed core from which
tailings are discharged, a Water Retenon Dam, which is constructed in a modified centerline method and which the supernatant pool is typically
impounded against, and the decant structure. The Mine first began producing iron ore pellets in 1974, with tailings disposed into the GNTB beginning
in 1977.
The GNTB and GSTB were designed and permitted as unlined facilities, with the tailings providing a low-permeability material to reduce seepage.
Typically, a tailings slurry flow of approximately 10,000 gpm at approximately 50% solids by weight is deposited in either GNTB or GSTB.The coarser
fracon of the tailings slurry typically seSles out near the discharge point and forms the beach material, and the gradaon of the tailings becomes
progressively finer with increasing distance from the discharge point. The gradation of the tailings typically varies from a silt to a clayey silt.
GNTB and GSTB were designed to have the supernatant pools located against the WRDs, and the water levels at GSTB and GNTB are controlled using
concrete decant structures. Water from the supernatant pool is not re-used in the process, but is treated and released. Water can be transferred from
GNTB to GSTB or from GSTB to GNTB, or can be conveyed directly to the GTB water treatment facility (WTF) and treated using a clarificaon process
with flow rates ranging up to 12,000 gpm before being released into the Goose Lake Outlet.
The GTB configuration is presented in Figure 15-2, and the facilities are discussed in the following sections.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 141
-- 369 of 411 --
Figure 15-2: Gribben Tailings Basin
15.4.1 Facility Description
15.4.1.1 Gribben North Tailings Basin
The GNTB is located on the northern end of the tailings basin, with the southern perimeter of GNTB forming the north perimeter of GSTB.The tailings
dam crest is currently approximately 5.4 mi long and at an elevaon of approximately 1,331 V. The dam is currently a maximum of approximately 130
ft high, and the ultimate height of the dam will be approximately 160 ft based on an ultimate crest elevation of 1,361 ft.
Foundation soils beneath GTB generally consist of natural, medium-dense to dense sands and silty sands that are well drained.
The original design for GNTB was developed by Harza Engineering Company (Harza).A series of connected perimeter dams were constructed to form
GNTB beginning during 1976 that included a seepage cut-off core and a slurry trench or silty clay cut-off trench below the dam that was keyed into
bedrock or relavely impermeable soils above the bedrock. The original perimeter dam system was constructed at that me to a crest elevaon of
1,271 V. To accommodate connued tailings storage, vercal expansions were and connue to be performed. The inial Phase 1 raise began in 1989
with construcon of upstream dikes placed on previously deposited tailings beaches generally along the east perimeter. Upstream raises are typically
accomplished in 10 V-high, staged construcon liVs at a 2H1V dike slope, which results in an overall composite downstream slope of approximately
6H:1V when the benches and dam crest are considered. The GNTB Water Retention Dams (areas where the pond is
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 142
-- 370 of 411 --
located adjacent to the dam) was raised in a downstream manner with a compacted tailings core to crest elevaon 1,331 V and will be raised from
crest elevaon 1,331 V to 1,361 V (1) in a modified upstream manner with sloping compacted tailings core over tailings placed in the GNTB in the area
around the decant, (2) an upstream manner with a vercal compacted tailings core, and (3) an upstream manner towards between the Water
Retenon Dam and West Dam. The raises will be performed in 10 V-high, staged construcon liVs unl the dam has a 30 V-wide dam crest at an
ultimate crest elevation of 1,361 ft, which will result in a maximum dam height of approximately 115 ft.
A buSress was constructed along the GNTB southeast corner of the dam (area immediately upgradient of the WTF) to elevaon 1,278 V in 2013, and
the buSress in this general area was raised to elevaon 1,292 V in 2020 to enhance the upstream dike stability. The long-term construcon design for
GNTB includes vercally expanding the upstream dike and Water Retenon Dam embankments along the basin perimeter to the Phase 9 crest
elevation +1,361 ft (GEI, 2016).
A vercal decant structure is located along the southwest corner of the GNTB (at approximately Staon 184+00), and the raises have been designed to
coincide with the raising of the Upstream Dike and Water Retention Dam construction program.
Natural sand borrow material east of Goose Lake Outlet is used for the Upstream Dike and Water Retenon Dam construcon with the excepon of
the compacted tailings core within the Water Retenon Dam secons. Tailings borrow material for the core secons of the Water Retenon Dam is
typically obtained from within the interior of the basin, in areas where the tailings material is readily accessible.
15.4.1.2 Gribben South Tailings Basin
The GSTB is located on the southern end of the tailings basin, with the northern perimeter of GSTB forming the south perimeter of GNTB.The tailings
dam crest is currently approximately 4.2 mi long (not including approximately 1.3 mi of dam common to GSTB and GNTB).With a current dam crest
elevaon of approximately 1,310 V (Cliffs, 2021a), the dam is currently a maximum of approximately 10 V high. The ulmate height of the dam will be
approximately 160 ft based on an ultimate crest elevation of 1,361 ft.
Foundation soils beneath GTB generally consist of natural, medium-dense to dense sands and silty sands that are well drained.
The original design for GSTB was issued by STS Consulng Ltd (STS) in 1997.Construcon commenced in 1997 and was completed in 2003.
Construcon of the Water Retenon Dam was performed to approximately elevaon 1,250 V on the east side, a decant structure to elevaon 1,250
V, and upstream dike to elevaon 1,230 V on the south and west sides. The design, construcon, and operaon of GSTB are very similar to GNTB.
Water Retenon Dams are constructed along the east perimeter of GSTB, with upstream tailings retenon dikes constructed along the south and west
perimeter.
To accommodate addional tailings storage, vercal expansions were and connue to be performed to a crest elevaon of 1,361 V. Upstream raises
are typically accomplished with construcon of upstream dikes placed on previously deposited tailings beaches, in 10 V-high, staged construcon liVs
at a 2H1V dike slope. This results in an overall composite downstream slope of approximately 6H:1V when the benches and dam crest are considered.
The Water Retenon Dams (areas where the pond is located adjacent to the dam) are raised in a modified centerline method. This is also performed
in 10 ft-high,
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 143
-- 371 of 411 --
staged construcon liVs, and consists of placing an outboard and inboard set of dikes at a 2H:1V slope and hydraulically placing tailings material to
form a low-permeability core between the two dikes, unl the dam is at a crest elevaon of 1,320 V (GEI, 2019). The long-term construcon design for
GSTB includes vercally expanding the Upstream Dike and Water Retenon Dam embankments along the basin perimeter to an ulmate crest
elevation +1,361 ft to match the GNTB (GEI, 2019).
A vercal decant structure is located midway along the east Water Retenon Dam of the GSTB, and the raises have been designed to coincide with the
raising of the Upstream Dike and Water Retention Dam construction program.
Natural sand borrow material east of Goose Lake Outlet is used for the Upstream Dike and Water Retenon Dam construcon material, with the
exception of the hydraulically placed tailings core material within the Water Retention Dam sections.
15.4.2 Design and Construction
Design of the perimeter dam to crest elevaon +1,271 V was performed by Harza. Vercal expansion above elevaon +1,271 V was designed by STS,
which became part of AECOM in 2007. SLR understands that Cliffs has retained GEI Consultants, Inc. (GEI) since 2010 as the Engineer of Record (EOR)
for the tailings basin. Typical EOR services include the design (i.e., volumetrics, stability analysis, water balances, hydrology, seepage cut-off design,
etc.), construcon and construcon monitoring, inspecons (i.e., annual dam safety inspecons) and instrumentaon monitoring data review (i.e.,
regularly scheduled instrumentaon monitoring and interpretaon), to verify that the tailings basins are being constructed and operated by Cliffs as
designed and to meet all applicable regulaons, guidelines, and standards. The EOR has been involved with design and construcon work at GNTB
since upstream dike construction began during the late 1980s and became the EOR in 1997 when working with STS.
GEI states that the slope stability Factors of Safety and the capacity to store the design storm event met the requirements for the tailings dam designs
that have been completed for crest elevations for GNTB and GSTB between 1,361 ft and 1,325 ft, respectively.
During the ongoing construcon of the tailings dams, field instrumentaon (such as piezometers and inclinometers) are monitored as needed, and a
summary is reported annually. Data that is collected is compared to thresholds set for each stage of design and reported using web-based, data
visualization and an instrumentation monitoring database.
SLR understands that the current GTB provides storage for approximately 15 years of tailings, based on the current tailings producon schedule, and
that Cliffs plans to store the remaining ten years of tailings producon in the Empire Tailings Basin that was operated from 1963 to 2016 (Cliffs,
2021b).
15.4.3 Audits
Third-party audits have been performed on the TSF by Golder in 2007 and 2012.The 2007 Golder audit would have had limited input to the GSTB as it
began operations in 2006. SLR understands that Cliffs plans to engage a third party audit for the tailings basin in 2022.
SLR understands that an External Peer Review Team (EPRT) was established in 2019 as part of the tailings basin design and operaons review.The
EPRB is an independent group that is not associated with the day-to-day engineering acvies performed by GEI or Cliffs, and it works with the EOR
and Owner to review design, construction, monitoring, and risk management.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 144
-- 372 of 411 --
15.4.4 Inspections
During GEI’s most recent inspecon (GEI, 2020), GEI noted that all observaons suggest the dam and dike segments are well maintained and stable,
and the conclusion of the inspecon report was that the systems are funconing as designed and are in good operaonal condion. Monitoring data
was not presented.
15.4.5 Reliance on Data
SLR relies on the statements and conclusions of GEI and Cliffs and provides no conclusions or opinions regarding the stability or performance of the
listed dams and impoundments.
15.4.6 Recommendations
Cliffs has been operang the Tilden Tailings Basin Cells since 1976, which is currently operang under the permit requirements of the Michigan
Department of Natural Resources. Upstream tailings dam raises, such as those that have been or will be carried out by Cliffs at Tilden for the GTB
vercal expansions, are typically done in low-seismic zones and can be constructed using the coarse-fracon tailings (sand) material. This type of
construcon approach, however, requires comprehensive communicaon and documentaon system, careful water management, monitoring of the
dam and foundaon performance, and the placement of tailings material to ensure that it meets the design requirements. To address these issues,
Cliffs has retained GEI as the EOR, with the EOR designaon being an industry standard for tailings management, as the EOR typically verifies that the
Tailings Storage Basin Cells are being constructed and operated by Cliffs as designed and meet all applicable regulations, guidelines, and standards.
Based on a review of the documentation provided, SLR has the following recommendations:
1. Priorize the compleon of an Operaons, Maintenance and Surveillance (OMS) Manual for the TSF with the EOR in accordance with Mining
Association of Canada (MAC) guidelines and other industry-recognized standard guidance for tailings facilities
2. Document, priorize, track, and close out in a mely manner the remediaon, or resoluon, of items or concerns noted in TSF audits or
inspection reports.
3. Assess the impacts of depositing tailings in the Empire facility, and prepare the necessary design and permitting documents.
15.5 Power
Power is received at Tilden’s substaon on transmission lines owned by American Transmission Company. Four substaon transformers have a
capacity of 90 MVA and reduce voltage from 138 kV to 13.8 kV for onsite distribution.
Installed switchgear distributes 13.8 kV power to the pit and remote pumping facilies through overhead lines and to the Plant through underground
ducts. In the concentrator and pellezing plant, power is then distributed through secondary step-down transformers to the crushing, grinding,
flotation, filtering, and thickening, and induration facilities at 4,160 V to 480 V, as required.
Backup diesel-powered generators are installed at several locations to operate critical equipment should main power be lost.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 145
-- 373 of 411 --
In August 2016, the Mine executed a 20-year special contract with the Upper Michigan Energy Resources (UMERC) that began on April 1, 2019.The
electricity under that contract is supplied through the existing power grid, which is interconnected to neighboring states (Figure 15-3).
Source: American Transmission Company
Figure 15-3: Regional Electrical Power Distribution
15.6 Natural Gas
Natural gas is primarily used for firing the 160 V rotary kilns at the pellezing plant and water boilers in the concentrator. Natural gas is purchased
from Encore Energy and supplied to the site via a gas pipeline owned and operated by Northern Natural Gas (NNG).NNG has an extensive interstate
pipeline system that travels through the Midwest and is interconnected to other major interstate pipelines. Gas is delivered to a border reducing
staon at 575 psi. Natural gas is further reduced to 50 psi with an incoming 10 in. feed line for use in plant applicaon. The natural gas line is buried
and protected by cathodic protection. Figure 15-4 is a map of the NNG pipeline system.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 146
-- 374 of 411 --
Source: Northern Natural Gas Company
Figure 15-4: Regional Natural Gas Supply
15.7 Coal
The Tilden pellet plant kilns are a dual fuel system with the ability to operate on pulverized coal, natural gas, or a combination of both.
15.8 Diesel and Propane
U.S. Oil supplies the Mine from its terminal in Green Bay, Wisconsin.Tilden has one, 20,000-gal, above-ground diesel fuel tank and one, 10,000-gal,
underground gasoline storage tank. Small diesel and gasoline fueling staons are used for small maintenance equipment and fleet vehicles. There is
sufficient fuel supply in the region to meet the requirements of the operation.
15.9 Communications
Communicaons to the facility are provided by AT&T via a direct fiber connecon to the Tilden facility for data/network communicaons. Tilden is
connected to other locaons such as Empire with a separate fiber line to that facility and a T1 connecon to the LS&I Eagle Mills facility.Network
switch
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 147
-- 375 of 411 --
connecvity is provided via gigabit connecons between the various locaons/buildings on the Property. Telephone connecvity is also provided by
dedicated phone lines from AT&T, and the phone system is provided by Avaya.
15.10 Water Supply
15.10.1 Fresh Water
Fresh makeup water for the process is supplied from the Greenwood Reservoir. The reservoir is located approximately seven miles southwest of
Ishpeming and is on the Middle Branch Escanaba River.It was constructed in 1972. The reservoir impounds 22,000 acre-V and has a surface area of
1,400 acres. It has a 26-mi shoreline and includes 13 small islands, which add an additional 11 mi of shoreline.
Water is released from the reservoir into an aVer-bay, a mini reservoir downstream of the main dam, through a four-port outlet system. Water can be
selected from one of the four gates from the boSom to the surface, depending on water temperature desired, or any combinaon of gates can be
opened to obtain the desired blend.
The diversion water is conveyed by gravity through a 30 in.-diameter x 4,000 V-long pipeline to Green Creek, which flows into the Schweitzer
Reservoir, constructed in 1963 for the Empire Mine. A permanent pumping system with three pumps (one duty and two standby), pumps the fresh
water 1.5 mi from the Schweitzer Reservoir to the Tilden concentrator fresh water head tank via a buried water line (Figure 15-5).
Figure 15-5: Fresh Water Supply
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 148
-- 376 of 411 --
15.10.2 Process Water
The majority of process water requirements are met by reclaiming from the operaon via tailings thickener overflow, reuse water basin, or decanng
and returning from the tailings basin. Reuse basin water is a combinaon of excess tailings thickener overflow water and fresh water makeup to
maintain level. Reuse water is pumped back to the Plant using twelve reuse pumps and boosted in pressure with seven reuse water booster pumps for
Plant use.
15.10.3 Fire Water
Fire water is supplied from the fresh water head tank, which holds a minimum reserve for emergency purposes. Fire water is distributed throughout
the operaon both via underground piping to external buildings separated from the Plant including the Tilden truck shop, primary crusher, and fuel
buildings, and via above-ground piping within the Plant. Line pressure is maintained by a small jockey pump, with full pressure supplied by an electric
pump should a significant amount of water be required. A backup diesel pump is provided in the event of a power outage.
15.10.4 Potable Water
Potable water is supplied by two deep well pumps located on site. Water is pumped to a head tank with the olake being boosted for use in the
operation.
15.11 Support Facilities
The main processing facility is contained in a convenonal, mullevel, insulated steel building. Mining offices and mobile equipment maintenance
shops are separated from the main facility and are located on Empire Mine property. Construcon of the facility was completed in 1974 for Tilden 1
and 1978 for Tilden 2. Substanal buildings separated from the main complex include the fresh water and reuse water pump houses, clarifier and
reagent mixing pump house, tailings thickener pump house, and Tilden truck shop. Figure 15-6 shows a general layout of buildings near the Plant and
Figure 15-7, the Empire truck shop.
Site security is provided by General Security Services Corporation (GSSC) and is managed by the Tilden Safety department.
Explosive delivery and handling is performed by contractors. There is no storage of explosives at the site.
15.11.1 Administration Buildings and Offices
Administraon offices of the facility are encompassed within the Plant footprint. Sufficient office space for human resources, finance, health and
safety, environmental, engineering, warehousing, plant operaons, and maintenance reside in the Plant; mining, geology, mine engineering, mine
operaons and maintenance reside in the Empire Mine services building. Centralized support services for payroll, informaon technology (IT),
procurement, and research are based either from Cleveland, Ohio and/or Ishpeming, Michigan.Addional finished office space is available in the
Tilden truck shop if required.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 149
-- 377 of 411 --
15.11.2 Maintenance Shops
Mining maintenance is performed primarily at the Empire truck shop for mobile equipment. This facility is equipped with a truck wash bay and has 26
stalls with associated overhead cranes, lubricaon, and parts storage. The Empire truck shop is directly connected to the mining administraon
building. Maintenance on drills is either performed in the field or at the Tilden truck shop. The Tilden truck shop is equipped with the bare essenals
and is primarily used to provide an area out of the elements for the drill repair crew and is used as the onsite drill core logging and storage facility.
Plant maintenance is provided with work-shop space at three primary locaons within the Plant footprint: concentrator, pellet plant, and main shops.
Field fiUng and fabricang is performed at the first two, with associated overhead cranes, welding, and cuUng equipment provided. The main shop is
located adjacent to the warehouse facility and provides rebuild services for primarily rotang equipment components. Large fabricaon jobs are
handled by an in-house fabricaon shop at the Empire facility or contracted to local fabricaon and machining facilies. These facilies are typically
located at Calumet (114 mi northwest) or Escanaba (67 mi south-southeast).
Figure 15-6: Process Plant and Administration Offices
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 150
-- 378 of 411 --
Figure 15-7: Mine Offices and Truck Shop
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 151
-- 379 of 411 --
16.0 MARKET STUDIES
16.1 Markets
Note that while iron ore producon is listed in long or gross tons (2,240 lb), steel producon is normally listed in short tons (2,000 lb) or otherwise
noted.
Cliffs is the largest producer of iron ore pellets in North America. It is also the largest flat-rolled steel producer in North America. In 2020, Cliffs
acquired two major steelmakers, ArcelorMiSal USA (AMUSA), and AK Steel (AK), vercally integrang its legacy iron ore business with steel producon
and emphasis on the automotive end market.
Cliffs owns or co-owns five acve iron ore mines in Minnesota and Michigan. Through the two acquisions and transformaon into a vercally
integrated business, the iron ore mines are primarily now a crical source of feedstock for Cliffs’ downstream primary steelmaking operaons. Based
on its ownership in these mines, Cliffs’ share of annual rated iron ore producon capacity is approximately 28.0 million tons, enough to supply its
steelmaking operations and not have to rely on outside supply.
In 2021, with underlying strength in demand for steel, the price reached an all me high. It is expected to remain at historically strong levels going
forward for the foreseeable future. In 2020, North America consumed 124 million tons of steel while producing only 101 million tons, which is in line
with the historical trend of North America being a net importer of steel. That trend is expected to connue going forward, as demand is expected to
outpace supply in North America. Given the demand, it will likely be necessary for most available steelmaking capacity to be utilized.
On a pro-forma basis, in 2019 Cliffs shipped 16.5 million tons of finished flat-rolled steel. The next three largest producers were Nucor with 12.7 million
tons, U.S. Steel with 10.7 million tons, and Steel Dynamics with 7.7 million tons.In 2019, total US flat-rolled shipments in the United States were about
60 million tons, so these four companies make up approximately 80% of shipments.
With respect to its BF capacity, Cliffs’ ownership and operaon of its iron ore mines is a primary compeve advantage against electric arc furnace
(EAF) competitors. With its vercally integrated operang model, Cliffs is able to mine its own iron ore at a relavely stable cost and supply its BF and
direct reduced iron (DRI) facilies with pellets in order to produce an end steel or hot briqueSed iron (HBI) product, respecvely. Flat-rolled EAFs rely
heavily on bushelling scrap (offcuts from domesc manufacturing operaons and excludes scrap from obsolete used items), which is a variable cost.
The supply of prime scrap is inelasc, which has caused the price to rise with the increased demand. S&P Global PlaSs has stated the open-market
demand for scrap could grow by nearly 9 million tons through 2023 as addional EAF capacity comes online, with the impact of the scrap market to
continue to tighten as all new steel capacity slated to come online is from EAFs (S&P Global Platts, news release, March 18, 2021).
In addion to its tradional steel product lines, Cliffs-produced steel is found in products that are helping in the reducon of global emissions and
modernizaon of the naonal infrastructure. For example, Cliffs’ research and development center has been working with automove manufacturer
customers to meet their needs for electric vehicles. Cliffs also offers a variety of carbon and plate products that can be used in windmills, while it is also
the sole producer of electrical steel in the United States. Addionally, in Cliffs’ opinion, future demand for steel given its low CO emissions posioning
will increase relative to other materials such as aluminum or carbon fiber.
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 152
-- 380 of 411 --
Cliffs is uniquely posioned for the present and future due to a diverse pormolio of iron ore, HBI, BFs, and EAFs generang a wide variety of possible
strategic opons moving forward, especially with iron ore. For instance, Cliffs has the oponality to connue to provide iron ore to its BFs, create more
DRI internally, or sell iron ore externally to another BF or DRI facility.
The necessity for virgin iron materials like iron ore in the industry is apparent, as EAFs rely on bushelling scrap or metallics. As of 2020, EAFs accounted
for 71% of the market share, a remarkably high percentage among major steelmaking naons. Because scrap cannot be consistently relied upon as
feedstock for high-quality steel applicaons, the industry needs iron ore-based materials like those provided by Cliffs to connue to make quality steel
products.
The US automove business consumes approximately 17 million tons of steel per year and is expected to consume around or at this level over me for
the foreseeable future. Cliffs’ iron ore reserves provide a compeve advantage in this industry as well, due to high quality demands that are more
difficult to meet for scrap-based steelmakers. As a result, Cliffs is the largest supplier of steel to the automove industry in the United States, by a
large margin.
Table 16-1 shows the historical pricing for hot rolled coil (HRC) product, Bushelling Scrap feedstock, and IODEX iron ore indices for the last five years.
The table includes 2021 pricing for each index, which shows a significant increase that is primarily driven by demand.
Table 16-1: Five Year Historical Average Pricing
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Indices 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 5 Yr. Avg.
US HRC ($/short ton) 620 830 603 588 1611 850
Busheling ($/gross ton) 345 390 301 306 562 381
IODEX ($/dry metric ton) 71 69 93 109 160 100
The economic viability of Cliffs’ iron ore reserves will in many cases be dictated by the pricing fundamentals for the steel it is generated for, as well as
scrap and seaborne iron ore itself.
The importance of the steel industry in North America, and specifically the USA, is apparent by the acons of the US federal government by
implementing and keeping import restrictions in place. Steel is a product that is a necessity to North America.It is a product that people use every day,
oVen without even knowing. It is important for middle-class job generaon and the efficiency of the naonal supply chain. It is also an industry that
supports the country’s naonal security by providing products used for US military forces and naonal infrastructure. Cliffs expects the US government
to continue recognizing the importance of this industry and does not see major declines in the production of steel in North America.
For the foreseeable future, Cliffs expects the prices of all three indexes to remain well above their historical averages, given the increasing scarcity of
prime scrap as well as the shift in industry fundamentals both in the US and abroad.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 153
-- 381 of 411 --
16.2 Contracts
16.2.1 Pellet Sales
Since Cliffs’ 2020 acquision of AK and AMUSA’s BF steel making facilies, Tilden L.C. ships most pellets by freighter via the Great Lakes to Cliffs’
steelmaking facilities in the Midwestern USA, and some pellets by rail to external customers.
For cash flow projecons, Cliffs uses a blended three-year trailing average revenue rate based on the dry standard pellet from all Cliffs’ mines,
calculated from the blended wet pellet revenue average of $98/WLT Free on Board (FOB) Mine as shown in Table 16-2.Pellet prices are negoated
with each customer on long-term contracts based on annual changes in benchmark indexes such as those shown in Table 16-1 and other adjustments
for grade and shipping distances.
Table 16-2: Cliffs Consolidated Three-Year Trailing Average Wet Pellet Revenue
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Description 2017 2018 2019 3YTA
Revenue Rate ($/WLT) 88.02 105.64 99.50 98.00
Total Pellet Sales (MWLT) 18.7 20.6 19.4 19.5
SLR examined annual pricing calculaons provided by Cliffs for the period 2017-2019 for external customers, namely AK.The terms appear reasonable.
It should be noted that Cliffs has subsequently acquired AK and AMUSA steelmaking facilies in 2020 making the company a vercally integrated,
high-value steel enterprise, beginning with the extracon of raw materials through the manufacturing of steel products, including prime scrap,
stamping, tooling, and tubing.
For the purposes of this TRS, it is assumed that the internal transfer pellet price for Cliffs’ steel mills going forward is the same as the $98/WLT pellet
price when these facilies were owned by AK and AMUSA.Based on macroeconomic trends, SLR is of the opinion that Cliffs pellet prices will remain at
least at the current three-year trailing average of $98/WLT or above for the next five years.
16.2.2 Operations
Major current suppliers for the Tilden operation include, but are not limited to, the following:
• Electrical Grid Power: Upper Michigan Energy Resources
• Natural Gas: Encore Energy Services, Inc.
• Diesel Fuel: U.S. Oil, a Division of U.S. Venture, Inc.
• Propane: UP Propane
• Pellet Rail Transport to Marquette: LS&I, a wholly owned Cliffs’ subsidiary
• Pellet Rail Transport to external customers: CN Railway
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 154
-- 382 of 411 --
17.0 ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES, PERMITTING, AND PLANS, NEGOTIATIONS, OR
AGREEMENTS WITH LOCAL INDIVIDUALS OR GROUPS
The SLR review process for Tilden included updang informaon that Cliffs had developed as part of its draV 2019 SK-1300 report.SLR has not had
sight of or reviewed environmental studies, management plans, permits, or monitoring reports. The original and updated informaon included in this
section is based on the information provided by the Cliffs project team.
17.1 Environmental Studies
Tilden L.C. conducted several environmental assessments for specific projects over me that have supported different aspects of its current operaon.
Each of those studies culminated in a determinaon by the relevant state and/or federal authories to grant permits to construct and operate Tilden’s
facilities. The relevant historical studies are listed below. There are no environmental impact studies in process at this time.
• Empire & Tilden Mine Impact Assessment, May 2000, to support proposed wetland impacts at both mines.
Tilden has been operang for over 45 years, with baseline and other environmental studies undertaken as required to support various approvals over
the site’s operang history. Currently, addional environmental studies, including collecng and updang baseline informaon, are undertaken on an
as-required basis to support new permit applicaons or to comply with specific permit condions. Cliffs has indicated that all water quality-based
studies site wide are being implemented per the requirements set forth in the NPDES permits
17.2 Environmental Requirements
Tilden L.C. maintains an environmental management system (EMS) that is registered to the internaonal ISO 14001:2015 standard.The ISO standard
requires components of leadership commitment, planning, internal and external communicaon, operaons, performance evaluaon, and
management review. Tilden’s connued registraon to the ISO standard is evaluated through external auditors. ISO audits are performed as required
by the registrar to maintain the umbrella cerficaon. The last audit was completed in June 2021. Compliance audits are performed as scheduled by
corporate environmental, with the last audit completed in November 2021.
The EMSRegister of Legal Requirements is used to maintain a current lisng of compliance obligaons that are applicable to the site’s environmental
aspects. Compliance obligaons are incorporated into the EMS Procedures, Work Instrucons, or other operaonal controls such as work orders,
environmental plans, and operaonal procedures that have been developed for the significant environmental aspects. Addionally, compliance
obligaons are incorporated into procedures, plans, and work orders for aspects that have not been idenfied as “significant” under the EMS, but
where incorporation of the compliance obligations is deemed necessary to promote regulatory compliance.
17.2.1 Site Monitoring
Tilden L.C. operates through permission granted by mulple permits, which are summarized in Table 17-1. The permits contain requirements for site
monitoring including air, water, waste, and land aspects
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 155
-- 383 of 411 --
of Tilden’s operaon. Those permit-required data are required to be maintained by the facility, and excepons to the monitoring obligaons are
reportable to the permiUng authority. Monitoring is conducted in compliance with permit requirements, and management plans are developed as
required to outline protocols and migaon strategies for specific components or acvies. Monitoring and management programs currently
undertaken in compliance with Tilden’s existing permits include:
• Air Quality: Management plans including fugive dust control plans, operaon and maintenance plans, and malfuncon plans; monitoring of
fugive sources and stacks, visible dust emission monitoring at the tailings facility; and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions monitoring and
reporting.
• Noise and Vibration: Blast management plans including vibration monitoring.
• Surface Water: Roune water quality sampling in receiving waters; quanty of water takings and discharges; selenium-related monitoring and
management program including collection and treatment of runoff and monitoring program at nearby streams/creeks.
• Groundwater: Roune water quality sampling at the Mine’s potable and monitoring wells in accordance with legal requirements; quanty of
potable water takings.
• Wetlands: monitoring of nearby wetlands where a potenal impact has been idenfied, including related to drawdown and/or discharge
activities.
• Wildlife: monitoring of species in accordance with specific permit conditions.
There are no specific management plans related to social aspects in place.
In terms of compliance, Cliffs received a Noce of violaon on December 17, 2020 for fugive dust events at GTB in November/December 2020.Tilden
indicated that it completed an evaluaon of its FDCP and submiSed a revised plan to Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy
(EGLE) on March 8, 2021 per EGLE request.
The State and Federal government conduct regional ecologic monitoring in the vicinity of the facility operaons. Two recent examples of such
monitoring include:
• Environmental Protecon Agency (EPA) conducted its residual risk and technology review (RTR) of the Taconite NESHAP (40 CFR 63).EPA’s final
rule (July 28, 2020) documents that risks from the Taconite Iron Ore Processing source category are acceptable, and the current standards
provide a margin of safety to protect public health and prevent an adverse environmental effect.
• The State of Michigan conducts regional watershed monitoring to assess the overall health of waterbodies throughout the state including water
quality, and macroinvertebrate and fish populaon diversity and health. The State may develop watershed management tools for water bodies
of concern such as total maximum daily load (TMDL) plans. Tilden is not currently subject to any TMDL-based load restrictions.
17.2.2 Water
Tilden L.C.’s current NPDES permit, MI0038369, authorizes to discharge treated process wastewater and treated sanitary wastewater from the GTB to
Goose Lake Outlet, which is part of the Escanaba River watershed.Cliffs indicated that Tilden is currently in compliance with all permit condions set
forth in the NPDES permit for process water discharges.Cliffs indicated these discharge oumalls have provided adequate permiSed capacity to move
water as necessary to support the mining process.
Selenium had been idenfied in the process water and stormwater runoff from the facility, causing exceedances in surface water quality standards in
certain watersheds proximal to the mining operations.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 156
-- 384 of 411 --
Capital improvements projects had been idenfied and implemented to achieve compliance with water quality standards in the receiving water
adjacent to Tilden operations.
Tilden L.C. maintains two water use permits for operations makeup water, with adequate capacity for the facility’s needs.
17.2.3 Hazardous Materials, Hazardous Waste, and Solids Waste Management
Tilden L.C. typically generates small quanes of hazardous waste and has a Small Quanty Generator status according to the federal Resource
Conservaon and Recovery Act (RCRA).Tilden generates other waste materials typical of any large industrial site and manages those wastes offsite
through approved vendors.
17.2.4 Tailings Disposal, Mine Overburden, and Waste Rock Stockpiles
Requirements for tailings disposal are discussed in secon 15.4 of this TRS. Tailings disposal is authorized by permits from the applicable regulatory
authorities. See Table 17-1 for a full list of permits.
Because iron ore geology is different from some other mineralized ore bodies, acid-rock drainage is not a concern with the iron ore bodies and
associated tailings in Michigan. Moreover, EPA itself describes the iron ore mining and beneficiaon process as generang wastes that are “earthen in
character.” Chemical constuents from iron ore mining include iron oxide, silica, crystalline silica, calcium oxide, and magnesium oxide — none of
which are Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensaon, and Liability Act (CERCLA) hazardous substances.The acid-neutralizing potenal of
carbonates in iron ore offsets any residual acid rock drainage risks, leading to pit water that naturally stabilizes at a pH of 7.5-8.5.
Tilden L.C. has implemented compliance plans to manage selenium present in the tailings basin discharge according to permit condions. It is
understood that the compliance plan has successfully managed selenium levels at or below the permit limit.
Requirements for the disposal of mine overburden and non-mineralized or lean rock are discussed in secon 13.5 of this TRS. Stockpiling of these
materials is authorized by permits from the applicable regulatory authorities. See Table 17-1 for a full list of permits.
17.3 Operating Permits and Status
Tilden operates through permission granted by multiple permits, which are summarized in Table 17-1.
While permiUng exercises always involve varying degrees of risk due to external factors, Cliffs indicated that it has a demonstrated record of
obtaining necessary environmental permits without unduly impacng the facility operaonal plan. Tilden is not aware of any permits/lack of permits
that could lead to future operational issues.
Tilden has the following permit applications pending with a permitting authority:
• Routine renewal of Tilden’s NPDES Permit with the Michigan Department of Energy, Great Lakes and Environment
• Wetland and stream impact permit for Tilden west stockpile progression (anticipated in 2022)
• Wetland and stream impact permit to support stormwater collection system upgrades (anticipated in 2022)
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 157
-- 385 of 411 --
It is understood that all required permits are in place.
Table 17-1: List of Major Permits and Licenses
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Permit No Description Type Jurisdiction Agency Status
MI0038369 NPDES Permit NPDES State EGLE Active
MI-ROP-B4885 Renewable Operating Permit (Title V) Air State EGLE Active
Permit No. 2 Part 631 Metallic Mineral Mining State EGLE Active
--- Part 35 Water Use Permit Water Use State EGLE Active
various Wells Well State EGLE / County Health
Dept. Active
4-MI-103-33- 1G-00663 Federal Explosives Permit/License Explosives Federal US Dept. of Justice Active
05-52-0032-P Rock Stock Pile Expansion Wetland and Stream State EGLE Active
97-03-0019 Stock Pile Expansion Tilden Lake Wetland and Stream State EGLE Active
13-52-0008-P GSTB Dike Elev 1395, Dam Elev 1300,
Outlet Wks Elev 1302 Dam Safety State EGLE Active
13-52-0009-P GNTB PH 7-9 Dike construction Elev
1361 Dam Safety State EGLE Active
MID083290551 Hazardous Waste Generator ID License State EGLE Active
Notes:
EGLE: Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy
USNRC: United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission
Regulatory issues with the potenal to materially impact Tilden’s current plans to address any issues related to environmental compliance and
permitting are actively monitored and disclosed in Cliffs’ 10-K; Part I Environment, which has discussion relevant to:
• Conductivity
• Selenium Discharge Regulation
• Evolving water quality standards for selenium and conductivity
• Definition of “Waters of the United States” Under the Clean Water Act
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 158
-- 386 of 411 --
• Climate Change and GHG Regulation
• Regional Haze FIP Rule
• NO and SO National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS)
• CERCLA 108(b)
• Regulation of Discharges to Groundwater
17.4 Mine Closure Plans and Bonds
Tilden’s current mine life is projected at 25 years as referenced in secon 13.4 of this TRS. Michigan’s Part 631 Rules (R 425.8) requires preparaon of
a reclamaon plan that addresses a long-range look at the mining area, including consideraon of reclamaon, minimizaon of erosion and polluon,
and esmated me to complete the plan. Cliffs has indicated that Tilden L.C. has developed a plan consistent with the Part 631 requirements and
maintains it on file. As a maSer of good mining pracce, Tilden L.C. seeks to conduct progressive reclamaon throughout its mining life to minimize
risk and costs at closure. Tilden actively reclaims stockpiles with no further planned use, consistent with the Michigan Part 631 requirements.
Cliffs performs an annual review of significant changes to each operaons Asset Rerement Obligaon (ARO) cost esmates.Addionally, Cliffs
conducts an in-depth review every three years to ensure ARO legal liabilies are accurately esmated based on current laws, regulaons, facility
condions, and cost to perform services. These cost esmates are conducted in accordance with the Financial Accounng Standards Board (FASB)
Accounng Standards Codificaon (ASC) 410.FASB ARO esmates comply with rules set forth by the United States General Accepted Accounng
Principles (USGAAP) and the SEC, and those costs are reported as part of Cliffs’ company-wide SEC disclosures.Arcadis calculated the 2020 ARO legal
obligaon Closure and Reclamaon costs associated with project deacvaon to be $52.5 million (Arcadis, 2020). The total ARO liability for Cliffs is
$56.8 million; to calculate the total ARO liability, Cliffs deducts Arcadis’ specified conngency value and adds Cliffs’ accounng policy conngency at
15% and Cliffs’ accounng policy market risk at 4%. SLR notes that there are differences between the ARO esmate and the book value calculated by
Cliffs due to the long life of the operation.
Tilden L.C. indicated that it worked with a third party to develop a site-specific esmate of actual closure and reclamaon cost, which considers likely
approaches and techniques to close the facility consistent with the requirements of its Part 631 plan. Cliffs indicated that upon closure Tilden will
implement short-term and long-term water quality treatment technologies to meet water quality standards in the receiving waters.
SLR cannot comment on adequacy of the closure costing and the closure plan based on currently available information.
17.4.1 Performance or Reclamations Bonds
Tilden currently has no outstanding performance or reclamation bonds.
17.5 Social and Community
Tilden has an agreement with Richmond and Tilden Townships to make an annual contribuon to a house-washing program. The township administers
the program for local homeowners through an area contractor. Cliffs indicated that this is a good faith gesture by Tilden to address any dust-related
2 2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 159
-- 387 of 411 --
concerns in the community. Cliffs also provides access/lease agreements with organizations for public use of inactive mine lands.
Cliffs Public/Government Affairs maintains a list of stakeholders for Cliffs iron ore mine operations.
SLR is not able to verify adequacy of management of social issues and what the general issues raised are. However, it is understood that Cliffs has a
posive relaonship with the community, and in the event of a complaint, Cliffs would work directly with affected community members to develop a
mutually acceptable resolution.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 160
-- 388 of 411 --
18.0 CAPITAL AND OPERATING COSTS
Cliffs’ forecasted capital and operang costs esmates are derived from annual budgets and historical actuals over the long life of the current
operaon. According to the American Associaon of Cost Engineers (AACE) Internaonal, these esmates would be classified as Class 1 with an
accuracy range of -3% to -10% to +3% to +15%. All unit rates are reported in WLT pellets.
18.1 Capital Costs
Capital costs were derived from current levels and work of similar scope based on the 2022 plan. Table 18-1 shows the sustaining capital cost forecast
for the five-year period from 2022 to 2026, which totals $314.2 million, or $8.29/WLT pellet. These costs include but are not limited to:
• $15.4 million environmental compliance
• $180.8 million in mine fleet replacements and additions
• $94.3 million in plant maintenance
• $23.7 million in plant and tailings basin operations
For the remaining LOM starng in 2027, an annual sustaining capital cost of $4/WLT pellet totaling an addional $579.9 million in expenditures is
required for the remaining mine life as follows:
• $261.4 million for major fleet purchases
• $318.5 million for other sustaining capital expenditures (environmental, maintenance, etc.)
Total capital expenditures are estimated at $894.2 million, or $4.65/WLT pellet.
Table 18-1: LOM Capital Costs
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Type Values LOM 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027-2046
Capital Costs
Sustaining $ millions 632.8 63.5 82.9 45.7 43.8 78.3 318.5
Major Fleet $ millions 261.4 261.4
Total $ millions 894.2 63.5 82.9 45.7 43.8 78.3 579.9
Pellet Sales
Pellet Sales MWLT 192.4 7.7 7.5 7.4 7.6 7.7 154.5
Unit Rates
Sustaining $/LT 3.29 8.25 11.10 6.16 5.73 10.17 2.06
Major Fleet $/LT 1.36 1.69
Total $/LT 4.65 8.25 11.10 6.16 5.73 10.17 3.75
A final closure reclamaon cost of $56.8 million is esmated, with $18.9 million spent annually starng in the last year of producon in 2047 and the
two subsequent years.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 161
-- 389 of 411 --
18.2 Operating Costs
Operang costs for the LOM are based on the 2022 plan. For this period, costs are based on a full run rate of flux producon consistent with what is
expected for the life of the mine. At this point in me, there are no items idenfied that should significantly impact operang costs either posively or
negavely for the evaluaon period. Minor year-to-year variaons should be expected based upon maintenance outages and producon schedules.
The 2022 Budget and LOM-average operating costs over the remaining 25 years of mine life are shown below in Table 18-2.
Table 18-2: LOM Operating Costs
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Description 2022
($/WLT Pellet)
LOM
($/WLT Pellet)
Mining 21.43 15.30
Processing 42.73 42.79
Site Administration 2.88 2.84
General/Other Costs 6.35 5.07
Operating Cash Cost ($/WLT Pellet) 73.39 66.00
Processing costs consist of crushing, grinding, concentrang, and pellezing acvies along with tailings basin disposal and shop allocaons. Unlike
Cliffs' Northshore and United operaons, Tilden only includes pellet loading costs at the mine site and does not include the cost of railing pellets to
MarqueSe port and ship loading in its operang costs. General/Other costs include producon tax and royalty costs, insurance, corporate cost
allocations, and other minor costs.
The Tilden operaon employs a total of 967 salaried and hourly employees (including LS&I railroad staff) as of Q4 2021 consisng of 141 salaried and
826 hourly employees. The majority of the hourly employees are United Steelworkers production and maintenance bargaining unit members.
Table 18-3 summarizes the current workforce levels by department for the Property.
Table 18-3: Workforce Summary
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. - Tilden Property
Category Salary Hourly Total
Mine 40 393 433
Plant 59 340 399
General Staff Organization 28 0 28
LS&I Railroad 14 93 107
Total 141 826 967
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 162
-- 390 of 411 --
19.0 ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
19.1 Economic Criteria
The economic analysis detailed in this secon was completed aVer the mine plan was finalized. The assumpons used in the analysis are current for
the me the analysis was completed (Q3 2021), which may be different than the economic assumpons defined in Secons 11.0 and 12.0 when
calculang the economic pit. For this period costs are based on a full run rate of pellet producon consistent with what is expected for the life of the
mine.
An un-escalated, technical-financial model was prepared on an aVer-tax basis, the results of which are presented in this secon. Key criteria used in
the analysis are discussed in detail throughout this report. General assumptions used are shown summarized in Table 19-1.
Cliffs uses a 10% discount rate for DCF analysis incorporang quarterly cost of capital esmates based on Bloomberg data.SLR is of the opinion that a
10% discount/hurdle rate for after-tax cash flow discounting of large iron ore and/or base metal operations is reasonable and appropriate.
Table 19-1: Technical-Economic Assumptions
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Description Value
Start Date December 31, 2021
Mine Life 25 years
Three-Year Trailing Average Revenue $98/WLT Pellet
Operating Costs $66.00/WLT Pellet
Sustaining Capital (after five years) $4/WLT Pellet
Discount Rate 10%
Discounting Basis End of Period
Inflation 0%
Federal Income Tax 20%
State Income Tax None – Sales made out of state
The operating cost of $66.00/WLT pellet includes royalties and State of Michigan production taxes.
The producon and cost informaon developed for the Property are detailed in this secon. Table 19-2 is a summary of the esmated mine
production over the 25-year mine life.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 163
-- 391 of 411 --
Table 19-2: LOM Production Summary
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Description Units Value
ROM Ore MLT 520.0
Total Material MLT 1,116.9
Fe Grade % 34.7
Average Annualized Mining Rate MLT/y 44
Maximum Annualized Mining Rate MLT/y 62
Table 19-3 is a summary of the estimated plant production over the 25-year mine life.
Table 19-3: LOM Plant Production Summary
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Description Units Value
ROM Material Milled MLT 520.0
Annual Processing Rate MLT/y 20.8
Process Recovery % 37.0
Total Hemflux Pellet MLT 192.4
Annual Hemflux Pellet Production MLT/y 7.7
19.2 Cash Flow Analysis
The indicave economic analysis results, shown in Table 19-4, indicate an aVer-tax NPV, using a 10% discount rate, of $1,322 million at an average
blended wet pellet price of $98/WLT. The aVer-tax IRR is not applicable since the Plant has been in operaon for a number of years.Capital idenfied
in the economics is for sustaining operations and plant rebuilds as necessary.
Project economic results and esmated cash costs are summarized in Table 19-4. Annual esmates of mine producon and pellet producon with
associated cash flows are provided for years 2022 to 2026 and then by ten-year groupings through the end of mine life.
The economic analysis was performed using the esmates presented in this TRS and confirms that the outcome is a posive cash flow that supports
the statement of Mineral Reserves.
Table 19-4: Life of Mine Indicative Economic Results
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Mine Life 1 2 3 4 5 6-15 16-25 26-35
Calendar Years Total 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027- 2036 2037- 2046 2047-
2056
Reserve Base:
Tilden Mining Ore Pellet Reserve Tons (millions) 192.4 184.7 177.2 169.8 162.2 154.5 77.5 0.0 0.0
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 164
-- 392 of 411 --
Mine Life 1 2 3 4 5 6-15 16-25 26-35
Calendar Years Total 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027- 2036 2037- 2046 2047-
2056
Tonnage Data:
Tilden Mining Total Tons Moved (millions) 1,116.9 60.0 62.0 60.5 60.6 60.0 460.0 353.8 -
Tilden Mining Crude Ore Tons Mined (millions) 520.0 21.6 21.3 21.2 21.3 22.1 209.6 202.8 -
Tilden Mining Pellet Production Tons (millions) 192.4 7.7 7.5 7.4 7.6 7.7 77.0 77.5 -
Inputs:
Tilden Mining Pellet Revenue Rate ($/ton) 98 98 98 98 98 98 98 98 -
Tilden Mining Operating Cash Costs ($/ton)
Mining 15.30 21.43 20.57 21.77 21.34 19.76 15.82 12.02 -
Crushing 0.80 0.87 0.69 0.81 0.80 0.80 0.80 0.80 -
Concentrating 28.02 28.58 27.49 28.95 27.98 27.98 27.98 27.98 -
Tailings Basin - - - - - - - - -
Pelletizing and Pellet Handling 13.97 13.28 12.80 12.11 14.14 14.14 14.14 14.14 -
Site Administration 2.84 2.88 2.84 2.90 2.85 2.85 2.85 2.83 -
Production Taxes 1.03 1.03 1.06 1.06 1.02 1.02 1.02 1.02 -
Royalty 5.19 5.08 5.02 5.10 5.22 5.22 5.22 5.19 -
Insurance Charges 0.36 0.34 0.35 0.36 0.36 0.36 0.36 0.36 -
SG&A Corporate Allocation 0.02 0.46 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 -
General / Other Costs (1.52) (0.55) (1.41) (1.50) (1.58) (1.58) (1.58) (1.57) -
Tilden Mining Operating Cash Cost ($/ton) 66.00 73.39 69.42 71.57 72.13 70.55 66.60 62.76 -
Income Statement:
Tilden Mining Gross Revenue ($ in millions) 18,854 755 732 728 748 755 7,546 7,591 -
Mining 2,944 165 154 162 163 152 1,218 931 -
Crushing 154 7 5 6 6 6 62 62 -
Concentrating 5,391 220 205 215 214 215 2,154 2,167 -
Tailings Basin - - - - - - - - -
Pelletizing and Pellet Handling 2,688 102 96 90 108 109 1,088 1,095 -
Site Administration 547 22 21 22 22 22 219 219 -
Production Taxes 197 8 8 8 8 8 79 79 -
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 165
-- 393 of 411 --
Mine Life 1 2 3 4 5 6-15 16-25 26-35
Calendar Years Total 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027- 2036 2037- 2046 2047-
2056
Royalty 998 39 37 38 40 40 402 402 -
Insurance Charges 69 3 3 3 3 3 28 28 -
SG&A Corporate Allocation 4 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 -
General / Other Costs (293) (4) (11) (11) (12) (12) (122) (122) -
Tilden Mining Operating Cash Cost ($ in millions) 12,698 565 518 531 551 543 5,128 4,861 -
Tilden Mining Operating Income (excl. Depreciation &
Accretion) 6,156 190 213 196 198 211 2,418 2,730 -
Federal Income Taxes ($ in millions) (1,231) (38) (43) (39) (40) (42) (484) (546) -
Depreciation Tax Savings ($ in millions) 209 5 6 7 7 7 82 94 -
Accretion Tax Savings ($ in millions) 13 0 0 0 0 0 4 8 -
-
Tilden Mining Income after Taxes ($ in millions) 5,147 157 177 164 165 176 2,020 2,287 -
Other Cash Inflows & Outflows ($ in millions):
Sustaining Capital Investments (633) (64) (83) (46) (44) (78) (177) (141) -
Significant All Material Change Capital Additions (261) - - - - - (124) (137) -
Mine Closure Costs (Incl. Post Closure) (57) - - - - - - - (57)
Tilden Mining Cash Flow ($ in millions) 4,196 94 95 118 121 98 1,718 2,009 (57)
Tilden Mining Discounted Cash Flow ($ in millions) 1,322 85 78 89 83 61 642 289 (4)
19.3 Sensitivity Analysis
Project risks can be idenfied in both economic and non-economic terms. Key economic risks were examined by running cash flow sensivies. The
Tilden operaon is nominally most sensive to market prices (revenues) followed by operang cost as demonstrated in Table 19-5. For each dollar
movement in sales price and operating cost, respectively, the after-tax NPV changes by approximately $55 million.
SLR notes that recovery and head grade sensivity do not vary much in iron ore deposits compared to metal price sensivity. In addion, sustaining
capital expenditures amount to 5% of LOM operating costs and, therefore, do not have much impact on the viability of operating mines.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 166
-- 394 of 411 --
Table 19-5: NPV @ 10% Sensitivity Analysis
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. – Tilden Property
Operating Costs
($/WLT Pellet)
$81 $76 $71 $66 $61 $56
Sales Price
($/WLT Pellet)
$83 ($345) ($67) $211 $489 $766 $1,044
$88 ($67) $211 $489 $766 $1,044 $1,322
$93 $211 $489 $766 $1,044 $1,322 $1,600
$98 $489 $766 $1,044 $1,322 $1,600 $1,878
$103 $766 $1,044 $1,322 $1,600 $1,878 $2,155
$108 $1,044 $1,322 $1,600 $1,878 $2,155 $2,433
$113 $1,322 $1,600 $1,878 $2,155 $2,433 $2,711
$118 $1,600 $1,878 $2,155 $2,433 $2,711 $2,989
$123 $1,878 $2,155 $2,433 $2,711 $2,989 $3,267
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 167
-- 395 of 411 --
20.0 ADJACENT PROPERTIES
This TRS is based solely on informaon and data from the Tilden Property.Although Cliffs’ Empire Mine is adjacent to the Tilden Property and is on
care and maintenance status, the Mineral Resource and Mineral Reserves stated in this TRS are contained enrely within the Property's mineral
leases, and information from other operations was not used in this TRS.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 168
-- 396 of 411 --
21.0 OTHER RELEVANT DATA AND INFORMATION
There is no other relevant data or information that is not discussed in this TRS.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 169
-- 397 of 411 --
22.0 INTERPRETATION AND CONCLUSIONS
Tilden has successfully produced iron ore pellets for over 47 years. The update to the Mineral Resource and Mineral Reserve does not materially
change any of the assumpons from previous operaons. An economic analysis was performed using the esmates presented in this TRS and confirms
that the outcome is a positive cash flow that supports the statement of Mineral Reserves for a 25-year mine life.
SLR offers the following conclusions by area.
22.1 Geology and Mineral Resources
• Indicated Mineral Resources at Tilden, exclusive of Mineral Reserves, are esmated to total 135.4 MLT at a grade of 34.7% crude Fe.Inferred
Mineral Resources are estimated to total 350.4 MLT at a grade of 34.7% crude Fe.
• The 2019 QA/QC program as designed and implemented by Cliffs has been helpful to understand the precision and accuracy of sample analysis
at the Tilden laboratory, which is used to support the assay results within the database and confirm that the database is suitable for use in
estimating Indicated and Inferred Mineral Resources.
• The Tilden database is adequate for the purposes of esmang Indicated and Inferred Mineral Resources.The lack of regular QA/QC sample
submissions alongside samples used to support Mineral Resources is outside of industry-standard pracce, and there are several database
integrity issues that require attention.
• There is a moderate to good correlaon of all variables between drill and blast hole twinned samples. Correlaon of iron content values
decreases for samples with high silica in concentrate values. There is a potenal high bias of phosphorus in concentrate values in favor of blast
holes. The known bias of weight recovery (wtrec) in favor of blast hole data is not observable in the paired dataset.
• The estimated block grades reflect the local blast hole or drill hole composite value, and the trends of the different variables are as intended.
22.2 Mining and Mineral Reserves
• The Property has been in producon since 1974, and specifically under 100% Cliffs operang management since 2017. Cliffs conducts its own
Mineral Reserve estimations.
• Total Proven and Probable Mineral Reserves are estimated at 520.0 MLT of crude ore at a grade of 34.7% crude Fe.
• Mineral Reserve estimation practices follow industry standards.
• The Mineral Reserve estimate indicates a sustainable project over a 25-year LOM.
• The geotechnical design parameters used for pit design are reasonable and support previous operaons. Slope depressurizaon may be
required as part of the development of the final pit walls.
• The LOM production schedule is reasonable and incorporates large mining areas and open benches.
• An appropriate mining equipment fleet, maintenance facilies, and manpower are in place, with addions and replacements esmated, to meet
the LOM production schedule requirements.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 170
-- 398 of 411 --
• Sufficient storage capacity for waste stockpiles and tailings has been identified to support the production of the Mineral Reserve.
22.3 Mineral Processing
• The Tilden deposit is complex and requires metallurgical testing to classify materials as ore and waste. A standard flotation testing procedure has
been developed for material classification, resource modeling, and concentrator feed blending.
• The capacity of the Tilden concentrator and pellet plant is 7.7 MLT/y of fluxed pellets (hemflux) from hematite-dominant crude ore sources.
• The ore is amenable to AG, and the concentrator consists of eleven lines of primary autogenous mills for coarse grinding and pebble mills for
fine grinding, eliminating the requirement for steel grinding media.
• Pellets are indurated using a gas- and coal-fired grate drying and preheang furnace, followed by gas- and coal-fired rotary kilns for fusing and
hardening, and rotary coolers for cooling. Heat must be supplied by fuel for low-magnete concentrates, without the benefit of the exothermic
heat of reaction from magnetite oxidation to hematite during heating.
• Crude iron ore head grades feeding the Plant during 2014 to 2020 ranged from 34.4% Fe to 35.5% Fe. Iron recovery to flotaon concentrates
ranged from 69.6% to 74.8%, with concentrate grades averaging 62.2% to 63.7% during this period. Approximately 20.5 MLT of crude ore is
processed through the concentrator annually to produce 8.9 MLT of fluxed concentrate and 7.7 MLT of fluxed pellets (hemflux).
22.4 Infrastructure
• The Property is in a historically important, iron-producing region of Northern Michigan. All the infrastructure necessary to mine and process
commercial quanes of iron ore and produce and ship pellets is in place, including the Mine, concentrator, and support facilies, line power
supplies, natural gas sourced from an interstate pipeline system, local supply of coal, and diesel fuel supply from Green Bay, Wisconsin.
• The GTB is located approximately five miles southeast of the Tilden concentrator plant and nine miles from Lake Superior. The GTB is comprised
of two, ring dike-type impoundments: the GNTB, which encompasses approximately 1,350 acres, and the GSTB, which encompasses
approximately 1,100 acres.
22.5 Environment
• Tilden indicated that it maintains the requisite state and federal permits and is in compliance with all permits. Various permiUng applicaons
have been submitted to authorities and are pending authorization. Environmental liabilities and permitting are further discussed in Section 17.0.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 171
-- 399 of 411 --
23.0 RECOMMENDATIONS
23.1 Geology and Mineral Resources
1. Complete a reconciliation study to support the inclusion of Measured Mineral Resources at Tilden.
2. Complete addional drilling to improve the understanding of the deposit at its periphery and at depth, with a focus on low drill density areas
within the 2019 LOM plan, as well as in areas with increased variability, such as the high-silica zones in the east of the Main Pit. Integrate the
downhole information from the Empire and Tilden mines into a single, valid database.
3. Develop a standard operang procedure for detailed logging of drill core that captures iron speciaon, alteraon, mineralogy, structure, and
lithology. Retain inial geological observaons in drill core separately from subsequent re-interpretaons based on metallurgical results or
results of neighboring drill holes.
4. Undertake a study where samples are consistently taken at shorter intervals, broken by geology, to examine how the variance of the assays is
affected and how the material-type designaon, based on a calculaon of those variables, compares against the material-type designaon of
longer samples. Sample intrusive material (dilution) too small to be segregated when modeling or mining as part of iron formation unit samples.
5. Connue work to define fault orientaons and related alteraon in the east of the Main Pit to confirm the syn-bedding and cross-cuUng
direcons of the modeled, high-silica alteraon units and invesgate alternave tools to capture drill hole informaon, including a
magnetometer and hyperspectral and x-ray fluorescence handheld devices to allow empirical measurements of magnesm (where relevant),
alteration, such as clay, and iron speciation.
6. Develop and implement a robust QA/QC program at Tilden for both exploraon drill hole and blast hole samples and incorporate analycal
aSribute data, such as grind me, starch type, and dates into the assay database, to be able to analyze results in context of changing test
protocols for performance and bias.
7. Address capacity issues at the Tilden laboratory to allow the sample analysis to be completed in a mely manner and to facilitate the inclusion of
QA/QC samples.
23.2 Mining and Mineral Reserves
1. Assess groundwater condions in the immediate vicinity of the final pit through a more focused groundwater model. The results of this
assessment should be input into an update of the pit slope stability analysis on sections cut through the current final pit design.
23.3 Mineral Processing
1. Continue specialized metallurgical testing to support resource modeling and mine planning and blending for the concentrator.
2. Plant operaonal performance including concentrate and pellet producon and pellet quality connues to be consistent year over year. It is
important to maintain diligence in process-oriented metallurgical testing and in plant maintenance.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 172
-- 400 of 411 --
23.4 Infrastructure
1. Prioritize the completion of an OMS Manual for the TSF with the EOR in accordance with MAC guidelines and other industry-recognized standard
guidance for tailings facilities.
2. Document, priorize, track, and close out in a mely manner the remediaon, or resoluon, of items of concern noted in TSF audits or
inspection reports.
3. Assess the impacts of depositing tailings in the Empire facility, and prepare the necessary design and permitting documents.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 173
-- 401 of 411 --
24.0 REFERENCES
AACE Internaonal, 2012, Cost Esmate Classificaon System – As applied in the Mining and Mineral Processing Industries, AACE Internaonal
Recommended Practice No. 47R-11, 17 p.
AECOM Environment, 2011, Final Interpretave Report - Hydrogeologic study, Empire and Tilden Mines, Ishpeming, Michigan: unpublished report
prepared for Cliffs Michigan Operations, August 31, 2011.
Arcadis, 2020. 2020 Asset Retirement Obligation Summary, Tilden Mining Company L.C., December 2020
Barr Engineering Co. (2008). Startup, Shutdown, and Malfunction (SSM) Plan, Cleveland-Cliffs, Tilden Mining Company L.C., February 27, 39 p.
Albert, D.A., 1995, Regional landscape ecosystems of Michigan, Minnesota, and Wisconsin: a working classificaon (Fourth Revision: July 1994). North
Central Forest Exp. Staon. Forest Service-U.S. Dept. of Ag. General Technical Report NC-178. Northern Prairie Wildlife Research Center Online.
http://www.npwrc.usgs.gov/resource/1998/rlandscp/rlandscp.htm (Version 03JUN98).
Barr Engineering Co., 2008, Startup, Shutdown, and Malfunction (SSM) Plan, Cleveland-Cliffs, Tilden Mining Company L.C., February 27, 39 p.
Bayley, R.W., and James, H.L., 1973, Precambrian Iron-Formations of the United States, Economic Geology, Vol. 68, pp. 934-959.
Boyum, B.H., 1964, The MarqueSe mineral district of Michigan, Instute of Lake Superior Geology Naonal Science Foundaon Summer Conference
sponsored by Michigan Technological University. Cleveland-Cliffs Iron Company: Ishpeming, Michigan, 37 p.
Call and Nicholas Inc., 2020, Life of mine feasibility level open pit slope angle study – Tilden Mine. Report prepared for Cleveland-Cliffs Inc., February
2020.
Cambray, F.W., 2002, The evoluon of a Paleoproterozoic plate margin, Northern Michigan. Field Trip Guide for the Great Lakes Secon, Society of
Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists, Great Lakes Section, 32nd Annual Fall Field Conference.
Cannon, W.F., 1976, Hard iron ore of the Marquette Range, Michigan, Economic Geology, Vol. 71, pp. 1012-1028.
Cannon, W.F., LaBerge, G.L., Klasner, J.S., and Schulz, K.J., 2007, The Gogebic iron range - a sample of the northern margin of the Penokean fold and
thrust belt: U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1730, 44 p.
Case, J.E., and Gair, J.E., 1965, Aeromagnec map of parts of MarqueSe, Dickinson, Baraga, Alger, and SchoolcraV Counes, Michigan, and its geologic
interpretation: U.S. Geol. Survey Geophys. Inv. Map GP-467, scale 1:62,000.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 174
-- 402 of 411 --
Cliffs, 2021a, Personal Communication.
Cliffs, 2021b, Personal Communication
Empire Iron Mining Partnership & Tilden Mining Company L.C., 2011, 2010 Annual mining and reclamaon report, Empire Iron Mining Partnership
Metallic Mineral Mining Permit #1 and Tilden Mining Company L.C. Metallic Mineral Mining Permit #2, March 11.
Gair, J.E., 1975, Bedrock geology and ore deposits of the Palmer Quadrangle, MarqueSe County, Michigan. United States Geological Survey Professional
Paper 769: 159
GEI Consultants, 2020, 2020 Dam Inspection Report, Gribben Tailings Basin Dam, Inventory Identification No. 00113, December 2020.
GEI Consultants, 2019, Design Documentaon Report, Phase 5 Water Retenon Dam and Decant Structure and Phase 8 through 10 Upstream Dikes
Gribben South Tailings Basin, Cliffs Michigan Operations, Richmond Township, Marquette County, Michigan Site. May 2019
GEI Consultants, 2016, Design Documentaon Report, Phase 7 through 9 Water Retenon, Dam and Phase 4 Decant Structure, Construcon, (Phase 7
Stationing 171+32 to 250+80), Gribben North Tailings Basin, Richmond Township, Marquette County, Michigan
Guilbert, J.M., and Park, C.F. Jr., 1986, The Geology of Ore Deposits, W. H. Freeman and Company, New York, pp. 715-716.
Hawley, M., and Cunning, J., eds., 2017, Guidelines for mine waste dump and stockpile design, CSIRO Publishing, Melbourne, Australia, 370 p.
Houghton, J., and Bristol, T.W., 1846, Reports of Wm. A. Burt and Bela Hubbard: Esqs., on the geography, topography and geology of the U. S. Surveys of
the mineral region of the south shore of Lake Superior, for 1845; accompanied by a list of working and organized mining companies; a list of
mineral locaons, and a correct map of the mineral region, also a chart of Lake Superior, reduced from the Brish Admiralty Survey. C. Wilcox,
Buffalo, NY, 109 p.
James, H.L., 1954, Zones of regional metamorphism in the Precambrian of northern Michigan: Geological Society of America Bullen, v. 66, no.12, p.
1455-1487.
James, H.L., 1966, Chemistry of the iron-rich sedimentary rocks, U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 440-W, pp. W1-W61.
Lukey, H.M., Johnson, R.C., and ScoS, G.W., 2007, Mineral zonaon and stragraphy of the Tilden Haemate Deposit, MarqueSe Range, Michigan, USA,
Proceedings Iron Ore 2007, pp. 123-130, (The Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy: Melbourne).
Nordstrom, P. M., 1995, Relationship of apparent specific gravity and head iron in selected Tilden core.
Nummela, W., and Anderson, G., 1970, Evaluaon of specific gravity test results from selected Empire mine samples. Internal Cleveland-Cliffs Iron
Company report. May 22, 1970.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 175
-- 403 of 411 --
Orobona, M., 2020, Exploration Quality Assurance/Quality Control campaign report, 2019, Tilden. Internal Memo.
Orobona, M., 2021, Pycnometer tesng of 217 samples of reserved -10M crushed reject from Tilden diamond drill core. Internal Cleveland-Cliffs Iron
Company report. August 3, 2021.
S&P Global PlaSs (hSps://www.spglobal.com/plaSs/en/market-insights/latest-news/metals/031821-open-market-scrap-demand-in-us-could-grow-by-
almost-9-million-mt-through-2023), 2018, Analysis: Open market scrap demand in US could grow by almost 9 million mt through 2023, news
release, March 18, 2021.
Schaetzl, R.J., and Anderson, S., 2005, Soils: genesis and geomorphology, Cambridge University Press.
Schneider, D.A., Bickford, M.E., Cannon, W.F., Schultz, K.J., and Hamilton, M.A., 2002, Age of volcanic rocks and syndeposional iron formaons,
MarqueSe Range Supergroup: implicaons for the tectonic seUng of Paleoproterozoic iron formaon of the Lake Superior region, Can. J. Earth
Sci. 39:999-1012
Shaigetz, M.L., and Cunning, J., 2019, Waste dump and stockpile stability rang and hazard classificaon for Cliffs Michigan Operaons: April 8, 2019
report to D. Keranen prepared by Golder Associates, Montréal, QC, Canada, 24 p.
Simmons, G.C., 1974, Bedrock geologic map of the Ishpeming quadrangle, Marquette County, Michigan: US Geological Survey Quad Map-1130.
Sims, P.K., Compiler, 1992, Geologic map of Precambrian rocks, southern Lake Superior region, Wisconsin and northern Michigan: U.S. Geological Survey
Miscellaneous Investigations Series Map I-2185, scale 1:500,000.
Sommers, L.M., 1984, Michigan: A Geography, Boulder, CO, Geographies of the United States.
Sffler, D.L., 2010, The iron riches of Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, Michigan State Department of Natural Resources Webpage, historical webpage
http://www.michigan.gov/dnr/0,4570,7-153-54463_18670_18793-53100--,00.html
Tilden SOP, 0903Q0200, Development Drill Core - Bench Flot Test, Tilden Sharepoint
Tilden SOP, 0903Q2701, SATMAGAN Magnetic Iron Determination, Tilden SharePoint
Tilden SOP, 0909Q0401, Sample Preparation and Fusion, Tilden SharePoint
Tilden SOP, 0909Q0501, XRF - Measuring a Sample, Tilden SharePoint
Tilden SOP, 0909Q0901, Soluble Iron by Al Wire/Titration Method, Tilden SharePoint
Van Hise, C.R., and Leith, C.K., 1911, The geology of the Lake Superior region: U.S. Geol. Survey Mon. 52, 641 p.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 176
-- 404 of 411 --
Van Schmus, W.R., and Woolsey, L.L., 1975, Rb-Sr geochronology of the Republic area, MarqueSe County, Michigan: Canadian Jour. Earth Sci., v. 12, p.
1723-1733
Waggoner, T.D., 1977, Specific gravity – intrusive waste. Internal Cleveland-Cliffs Iron Company report. October 4, 1977.
Western Regional Climate Center, 2015, Period of record monthly climate summary for Ishpeming, MI (Staon 204127), Website,
http://www.wrcc.dri.edu/cgi-bin/cliMAIN.pl?mi4127
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 177
-- 405 of 411 --
25.0 RELIANCE ON INFORMATION PROVIDED BY THE REGISTRANT
This report has been prepared by SLR for Cliffs. The information, conclusions, opinions, and estimates contained herein are based on:
• Information available to SLR at the time of preparation of this report,
• Assumptions, conditions, and qualifications as set forth in this report, and
• Data, reports, and other information supplied by Cliffs and other third party sources.
For the purpose of this report, SLR has relied on ownership informaon provided by Cliffs and verified in an email from Gabriel D. Johnson, Cliffs'
Senior Manager – Land Administraon dated January 20, 2022.SLR has not researched property tle or mineral rights for Tilden as we consider it
reasonable to rely on Cliffs’ Land Administration personnel who are responsible for maintaining this information.
SLR has relied on Cliffs for guidance on applicable taxes, royales, and other government levies or interests, applicable to revenue or income from the
Tilden Mine in the Executive Summary and Section 19. As the Tilden Mine has been in operaon for almost 50 years, Cliffs has considerable experience
in this area.
SLR has relied on informaon provided by Cliffs pertaining to environmental studies, management plans, permits, compliance documentaon, and
monitoring reports that were verified in an email from ScoS A. Gischia, Cliffs' Director – Environmental Compliance, Mining and Pellezing, dated
January 21, 2022.
The Qualified Persons have taken all appropriate steps, in their professional opinion, to ensure that the above information from Cliffs is sound.
Except for the purposes legislated under applicable securities laws, any use of this report by any third party is at that party’s sole risk.
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 178
-- 406 of 411 --
26.0 DATE AND SIGNATURE PAGE
This report tled “Technical Report Summary on the Tilden Property, Michigan, USA” with an effecve date of December 31, 2021 was prepared and
signed by:
Signed SLR International Corporation
Dated at Lakewood, CO
February 7, 2022 SLR International Corporation
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 179
-- 407 of 411 --
27.0 APPENDIX 1
27.1 Geometallurgical Domains
For operaonal purposes, the Tilden Mine is divided into geometallurgical domains, as shown in Figure 6-6. The domains are based on the
metallurgical response from bench-scale flotation tests and processing in the Plant. Wtrec, SiO content, and crude magnec Fe content determine the
domain designation. These properties are controlled by lithology (martite, carbonate, clastic, intrusive) and ore type (flot, magnetite).
The primary economic parameters are wtrec and grade of Fe (crude) and concentrate SiO. Wtrec is the percentage by weight of each ton of material
that reports to the concentrate following flotaon. The grade of Fe and SiO in the concentrate determine if the material will meet specificaons for
economic processing. Other factors that can affect the Plant operaon and pellet quality are mineralogy as related to total oxides and loss on ignion;
trace element chemistry, in parcular phosphorous (P), but also manganese (Mn), magnesium oxide (MgO), calcium oxide (CaO), and alkalis; crude
soluble, magnec, and slime Fe. It should be noted that these data are essenally all based on involved bench test results that may not directly reflect
the Plant response. The bench test is described in Section 10.2.2.
Brief descriptions of the individual geometallurgical domains are as following.
27.1.1 500 Northwest Domain
Stragraphically above CDIII/West pit hanging-wall metadiabase (250) and below North Intrusive (270); it includes numerous dikes and one
mappable igneous body, the West Intrusive (260);
• 550 Restricted to the Far West Extension, West Hemate domain is dominantly hemate-chert with mixed goethite, with weight recoveries
around 40% and variable but elevated P. Its contact with the 530 domain is defined by a thin intrusive and metallurgical change;
• 530 Hematite-Goethite domain includes flotation ore (531) and Waste Iron Formation (WIF, 532);
◦ 531 Dominantly goethite-chert with wtrec from low-30s to mid-40s and variable, but generally high, concentrate SiO and P content;
◦ 532 Oxidized marte/goethite; characterized by low wtrec, high SiO and P; low head Fe indicates original Fe formaon may have been
carbonate facies (?). Sulfate minerals are locally common in bench faces;
• 520 Magnete domain is dominantly magnete-carbonate with silicate horizons. It is locally flotaon and/or mag ore depending on liberaon
characteristics; and
• 510 Clasc interval at contact with top of the CDIII/West pit hanging-wall (250) in local (?) syncline. The 510 Clasc domain is locally flotaon
ore.
27.1.2 400 CDIII-West Pit Domain
Stragraphically between the CDIII/West pit hanging-wall metadiabase (250) and CDIII footwall (230). Includes numerous small dikes and sills,
the Keweenawan dike, and the West Pit Marker interval (240);
• 480 Footwall clasc zone along Main pit footwall (100). Consists of dominant marte clascs with coarse quartzite/conglomerate and
interbedded martite-hematite chert;
• 470 Hanging-wall zone along base of CDIII/West pit hanging-wall metadiabase (250). It is defined as waste iron formaon (WIF) due to very fine
grain size and/or oxidization;
2
2
2
2
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 180
-- 408 of 411 --
• 460 Dike domain is defined as a northeast-trending zone of chloric dikes and associated oxidized and unoxidized Fe formaon. The dikes result
in a high dilution factor;
• 450 South Hemate domain in south part of CDIII and the West pit contains flotaon ore of variable metallurgy and WIF. Dominantly thin-
bedded, fine-grained, hematite-martite-chert, although some zones may be oxidized carbonate;
◦ 451 Goethite zones within hematite domain associated with folding and faulting;
◦ 452 Goethite zone along CDIII footwall, south of Keweenawan dike. Typically, high slime Fe, the goethite zone may be oxidized
Carbonate (430) domain near the intersection of dike and footwall;
• 440 North hemate domain consists of fine-grained, oxidized, marte-hemate chert with numerous dikes. The boundary between this domain
and the Magnetite domain (420) trends northeast and dips steeply to the south. This domain is locally flotation ore;
• 430 Carbonate domain is carbonate flotaon ore with low magnete content, high wtrec, and low concentrate grade. It is fault-bounded on
north and south but apparently gradational down-dip to west to Magnetite domain (420);
• 420 Magnete domain consists of magnete-carbonate and magnete-silicate-chert with variable oxidaon and grain size. Boundaries are
relatively sharp with other domains. The domain is generally defined by magnetite content, not ore type, so it contains potential flotation ore;
◦ 421 West pit magnete domain is an isolated (?) zone of high-grade magnete in the west pit. It is defined by exploraon drilling and
blast pattern data;
◦ 422 South CDIII carbonate is magnetite-carbonate flotation ore, apparently separate from the 420 and 421 domains; and
• 410 Footwall zone is defined as the magnete-silicate body proximal to the contact with the CDIII Footwall metadiabase (230). It is typically
waste or low-grade ore due to low magnetite content or poor liberation.
27.1.3 300 Main Pit Domain
Contains Fe formaon units stragraphically below the CDIII footwall metadiabase (230) and/or the East pit hanging-wall metadiabase (200).
Includes numerous small, mafic intrusives;
• 370 Hanging-wall contact includes zones of erratic metallurgy along the base of the CDIII footwall (230) or East pit hanging-wall (200);
• 360 Transion zone between CDIII footwall (230) and the East pit hanging-wall (200). Consists of variably oxidized hemate Fe formaon and
mafic intrusives. Restricted to north side of the East pit;
• 350 Hemate-marte domain in East pit consists of various types of marte-chert. Includes intervals of magnete-carbonate Fe formaon and
thin dikes. Gradational transition over 20 ft to 50 ft;
• 340 Carbonate Fe formaon stragraphically below the hemate-marte domain (350) in the East pit. Consists of marte-carbonate-chert with
variable magnete/marte content. Defined by magnec Fe, wtrec, and total oxides. Has lower wtrec and higher concentrate grade than CDIII
carbonates (430). May be magnetite ore in part;
• 330 Clay zone is defined as the intervals of Fe formaon outlined as waste due to high SiOfrom montmorillonite (or other) interference. Does
not differentiate non-liberating hematite material. May be stratigraphically controlled. Includes some flotation ore within boundaries;
• 320 East pit clascs are mixed siliceous and silicate clascs and hemate Fe formaon. Includes oxide and carbonate intervals. A thin dike
defines the north boundary, presumably marking a fault, with the martite or carbonate domains;
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 181
-- 409 of 411 --
◦ 321 High SiO zones (6% to greater than (>) 10%) in the clasc domain reflects clay and/or Fe-silicates and/or non-liberang Fe
formation;
• 310 Footwall Fe formation domain consists of variably oxidized oxide Fe formation and coarse clastics. Typified by erratic metallurgy; and
• 311 Earthy fines are high grade (>50 weight (wt) rec and >50 head Fe), oxidized zones controlled by structures within the footwall domain.
27.1.4 200 Intrusive Domains
These domains are used for correlaon of the Fe formaon domains and structural trends and appear to be conformable at the scale of the ore
body. Generally interpreted as intrusives, they consist of mafic rocks, which vary from diabasic to porphyric to aphanic. All units appear to
thin to the west and south. Contacts tend to be sheared and locally oxidized. Contact metamorphism of the Fe formaon is minimal and, if
present, results in finer-grained Fe formation. Synclinal structures and intersections with dikes have focused oxidation of the Fe formation;
• 270 North intrusive is a poorly defined intrusive body at the top of the Northwest zone (500);
• 260 West intrusive is a poorly defined but mappable intrusive body within the Northwest zone (500);
• 250 The CDIII/West pit hanging-wall is a relavely easily mappable diabase marker unit, and along with the CDIII footwall (230) is one of the
principle stratigraphic correlations between the CDIII pit and the Main pit;
• 240 The West pit marker is a thin but connuous intrusive unit within the CDIII/West pit stragraphy (300). It is interpreted to extend from the
Foster Lake slot through the West pit;
• 230 The top of the CDIII footwall defines the base of the CDIII/West pit domain (400), while the base defines the top of the Main pit east
domain (300);
• 220 Chloric and diabase dikes and thin sills occur in all domains. The domain includes an east-west trending, 30+ V-thick Keweenawan dike in
CDIII; and
• 200 The East pit hanging-wall is separated from the CDIII footwall (230) by the Transion zone (360) Fe formaon. Along the north side of the
East pit, the base of this intrusive body marks the top of the Main pit East domain (300) for mining and planning purposes.
27.1.5 100 Main Pit Footwall Domain
• This domain consists of Archean (?) metamorphic rocks that are separated from the Fe formaon domains by an east-west trending, north-
dipping, high-angle fault;
• 121 Chloric schist is the dominant footwall rock type exposed within the pit and in drill holes. This rock may be the extension of the CDIII
footwall horizon (230) within the fault zone; and
• 111 Granite gneiss occurs south of the chloric schist (121) but is only poorly exposed in the pit. This domain has not been used in the drill hole
codes.
2
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. | Tilden Property, SLR Project No: 138.02467.00001
Technical Report Summary - February 7, 2022 182
-- 410 of 411 --
-- 411 of 411 --