TRANSCRIPT

Q1 2023 — Transcript

Q1 2023PDF · 18 pages186 KB
InComm Conferencing 	Page 1 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
First-Quarter 2023 Earnings
April 25, 2023
Presenters
Lourenco Goncalves, Chairman, President and CEO
Celso Goncalves, Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer
Q&A Participants
Emily Chieng – Goldman Sachs
Lucas Pipes – B. Riley Securities
Carlos De Alba – Morgan Stanley
Curt Woodworth – Credit Suisse
Timna Tanners – Wolfe Research
Tristan Gresser – BNP Paribas
Alex Hacking – Citi
Sean Wondrack – Deutsche Bank
Operator
This is Daryl, and I am your conference facilitator today. I would like to welcome everyone to
Cleveland-Cliffs' First-Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. All lines have been placed on
mute to prevent any background noise. After the speakers’ remarks, there will be a question
and answer session. The company reminds you that certain comments made on today's call will
include predictive statements that are intended to be made as forward-looking within the Safe
Harbor protections of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995.
Although the company believes that its forward-looking statements are based on reasonable
assumptions, such statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual
results to differ materially. Important factors that could cause results to differ materially are set
forth in reports on Forms 10-K and 10-Q and news releases filed with the SEC, which are
available on the company's website.
Today's conference call is also available and being broadcast at Clevelandcliffs.com. At the
conclusion of the call, it will be archived on the website and available for replay. The company
will also discuss results excluding certain special items. Reconciliation for Regulation G purposes
can be found in the earnings release, which was published yesterday.
At this time, I would like to introduce Celso Goncalves, Executive Vice President and Chief
Financial Officer.
Celso Goncalves
Thank you, Daryl, and good morning, everyone. Our Q1 results marked the rebound in
profitability from the trough in Q4, as we effectively doubled our adjusted EBITDA from the

-- 1 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 2 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
previous quarter. We outperformed on our three most important metrics, selling price, unit
costs and steel volumes. We guided to a Q1 implied selling price of around $1,120 per ton and
realized around $1,130. We indicated that unit costs would decline by $50 per ton and they
declined by $60. We said volumes would rise to around four million tons, and we delivered 4.1
million. Most importantly, we set the stage for another highly profitable year in 2023, which we
expect to further materialize with a much higher Q2 EBITDA and strong free cash flow
generation in the last three quarters of the year.
Q1 free cash flow was lower, largely because we invested in working capital due to strong
demand. As pricing and volumes went up, we saw higher receivables and higher inventory tons.
In Q2, we expect this trend to continue, but EBITDA will be so much higher, and CapEx will be so
much lower, that the massive amount of free cash flow coming in Q2 should far outpace any
further build in working capital.
Adjusted EBITDA in Q1 was $243 million, a 98% increase from the previous quarter, driven
almost entirely by reduced unit costs, a function of normalized repair and maintenance spend,
lower input costs and higher steel production. Our Q1 shipment volume of 4.1 million net tons
was roughly 250,000 tons higher than the previous quarter, making Q1 of 2023 our highest
steel shipment quarter since Q3 of 2021. Automotive demand was robust, service center buying
behavior has improved, and we did not have any significant maintenance outages like we did
for much of last year.
Q1 selling price of $1,128 per net ton came in ahead of expectations due to higher tonnage and
higher value-added mix in automotive. A little more than half of our sales are index-linked, with
lags generally varying from one to three months. Due to these lags, the recent rise in flat-rolled
index pricing was barely reflected in our Q1 results. This improvement is now in full force,
which will benefit our results meaningfully here in Q2 and beyond. We have been successful in
implementing several spot price increases over the past few months. We have also achieved
continued increases in our fixed price contracts for the April 1st renewal cycle. Taken together,
these improved prices will propel our realizations in Q2.
In addition, due to the same factors that drove Q1 costs lower, our unit cost should continue
their downward trend going forward. We also expect that our strong volume performance will
carry over into Q2 as the order book remains full, and we run at our configured capacity levels.
As pricing and volumes improved in Q1, particularly in the month of March, we built around
$230 million in receivables, contributing to the lower free cash flow quarter-over-quarter.
As these receipts come in, our cash flow performance will ramp up significantly in Q2,
particularly as we have already received $110 million in tax refunds here in April. This comes
after a tax refund receipt of $25 million received during Q1. Furthermore, we expect our Q1
CapEx of $188 million to represent the peak CapEx quarter for this year due to some carryover
maintenance projects from 2022. So Q2, Q3 and Q4 CapEx should each be lower than Q1. In

-- 2 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 3 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
fact, we have lowered our total expected full year CapEx range by $25 million, to $675 million
to $725 million, reflecting primarily sustaining projects.
Touching now on the capital structure. Two weeks ago, we completed a seven year unsecured
notes offering for $750 million, pricing at only 325 basis points above the comparable treasury.
This was our tightest spread on any unsecured high-yield bond ever. We took advantage of the
inverted yield curve to issue these notes, which are priced off of lower longer-term rates and
used the proceeds to pay down our ABL, which is priced off of currently much higher short-term
rates.
We have been comfortable using our ABL as an effective source of liquidity for some time given
it was nearly free money, but with the rapid rise in the Fed fund rates, this is no longer the case.
So terming some of this ABL balance out with longer-term bonds was a no-brainer. In fact, the
coupon on these new notes is effectively the same as the all-in interest rate on the ABL. The
additional liquidity provided as a result also gives us more flexibility for whatever market
conditions or opportunities may come up.
This being said, this swap of shorter-term debt with longer-term notes does not change our
capital allocation priorities. We intend to continue using the robust free cash flow we expect to
generate this year toward continued debt repayment and opportunistic share buybacks. We
still have over $1 billion in prepayable debt on the ABL and another $1.5 billion in callable
bonds. For now, the main priority for debt reduction will be to continue driving down the ABL
balance. When that has been paid off in full, we will then target redeeming our 2026 secured
notes.
As we've shown in the past with aggressive bond buybacks, even our noncallable long-dated
unsecured bonds are effectively prepayable since we can also opportunistically buy them back
in meaningful amounts in the open market. We plan to continue this capital allocation strategy
until our net debt gets down to around $3 billion. And assuming market conditions remain as
they are now, we should achieve that at some point this year.
With that, I will turn it over to Lourenco for his remarks.
Lourenco Goncalves
Thank you, Celso, and good morning, everyone. During the past quarter, order release rates
from our automotive clients were the strongest and the most consistent we have seen since
becoming a steel company three years ago. Also, service center buying behavior in Q1 came
back to more normal levels. These two factors, combined with reduced imports of flat-rolled
steel forced the buyers to increase their order levels with domestic producers.
In addition, the excess scrap and metallics inventories that were built by other steel companies
in response to the war in Ukraine were ultimately drawn down, forcing scrap prices back to
what we believe are higher but still acceptable and sustainable levels. We used all of these

-- 3 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 4 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
factors in our favor to implement several spot price increases, which have ultimately driven
index pricing higher.
Our conviction that this country's prime scrap and metallic shortage will continue to tighten
over the coming years is at the core of our strategy. Last year's strange scrap movement in the
second half of the year has been proving to be an outlier and the prime scrap market is back in
a shortage position. There is less than 20 million tons of annual prime scrap and metallic supply
in North America currently. And unless you are a producer of only rebar and nothing else, you
need prime scrap and metallics.
Our in-house production of two million tons of HBI per year at Cleveland-Cliffs is an integral
part of our own internal supply chain. We use our HBI primarily to feed our own blast furnaces
to reduce coke rate and CO2 emissions, and that results in very limited availability to sell HBI to
third parties. We anticipate that with the new electric arc furnaces coming online, demand for
prime scrap and metallics will be at 30 million tons by 2026. This will require significant levels of
imported metallics.
The largest sources of these imports up until last year were Russia and Ukraine. More than a
year after the invasion of Ukraine, that import avenue remains heavily disrupted. Said another
way, unless one is rerouting Russian supply through other countries for transshipment, which
is, by the way, illegal, they cannot get all the feedstock they need. Because prime scrap is a
byproduct of manufacturing, and we as a country, have been moving manufacturing offshore,
prime scrap supply has been shrinking in this country for over 50 years. Bringing more
manufacturing back to the United States over the coming years should help alleviate the
situation, but that will take time.
The alternative to address the scrap shortage would be additional metallics production, but
that requires iron ore. As the largest producer of iron ore pellets in North America, this plays
right into our favor. For the majority of the last three decades, flat-rolled steel production with
EAFs took advantage of cheap and plentiful prime scrap. This historical situation is changing
fast.
Greenfield flat-rolled production from EAFs also plays into our favor in the automotive market.
As some EAF start-ups have been demonstrating for a few quarters now, the metallurgical
challenge in automotive is too big for them. This fact, along with our customer service and our
R&D capabilities are the three main reasons why Cleveland-Cliffs remains the supplier of choice
to the automotive industry in the United States. That also helped us achieve annual price
increases from all and each one of our major automotive clients.
Some of this price increase will only show in our Q2 results as they are effective April 1st. Our
shipments in the first quarter to our direct automotive customers were the highest they have
ever been in our three years as a steel company and at higher prices. This was the biggest

-- 4 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 5 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
reason for our strong quarterly shipment number of 4.1 million tons and why we are running all
of our steelmaking shops at full capacity.
Our higher levels of steel production have led to the partial restart of some operations at our
iron ore mining and pelletizing swing facility at Northshore earlier this month. As you may
recall, Northshore has been totally idle since the spring of last year. We will continue to treat
that facility as our swing operation. And at this time, we still do not expect to operate
Northshore in full any time this year.
The remarkable improvement in automotive demand is a combination of the easing of their
supply chain issues and the American consumers' growing appetite for new cars. Auto sales
seasonally adjusted annual rates usually called SAAR in the United States averaged about 15.2
million units during Q1, a massive uptick after averaging 13.7 million units during all of 2022. As
such, our forecast for North America automotive builds in 2023 of 15.5 million light vehicles is
the best in four years. With one car equaling roughly one ton of steel and with Cleveland-Cliffs
representing nearly half of the flat-rolled market for automotive steel, you can do the math on
the additional volume this will bring.
The auto sales and production increases we have been seeing are further confirmation of our
view on how steel demand in the U.S. will shift in our favor. For the last couple of years,
nonresidential construction has been the outperformer in the steel market with automotive
lagging significantly behind. As you know, Cleveland-Cliffs is not a big player in non-res. That
said, given the massive backlog that has been created as a result of supply chain issues over the
past few years and with the Federal Reserve reaching the end of their interest rate hike
marathon going forward, all signs point to automotive being the outperformer.
Cleveland-Cliffs is ready to accommodate any improvements in demand from the automotive
sector, whether that be from internal combustion engine vehicles or EVs, and our clients know
that very well. At Cleveland-Cliffs, we are agnostic to whatever ways that demand materializes
over the coming years as we are the clear-cut leader in supplying steel for both types, electric
or conventional vehicles. That said, earlier this month, President Biden's administration put
forth their latest push to drive large-scale EV adoption in the United States. The proposal
includes a projection that two out of every three new cars sold in the United States in 2032 will
be electric, compared to about only 7% today in 2023. This is a structural reset that we have
dedicated our research and innovation center efforts toward since we acquired AK Steel in
March of 2020.
Put simply, due to our size as a supplier of automotive steel in the United States and also due to
our unique technical capabilities, these goals of the U.S. government cannot be reached
without Cleveland-Cliffs. We are an integral part of this transition from ICE vehicles to EVs in
the United States, regardless of whether it happens at a fast or at a slow pace. This includes our
supply of exposed body parts, structural cages, battery support and non-oriented electrical
steels for motors.

-- 5 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 6 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Regarding non-oriented electrical steels, we call NOES, and responding to growing demand
from our existing customers, we have already deployed $30 million as CapEx into our Zanesville,
Ohio facility to increase our production capacity of NOES by another 70,000 tons annualized.
We should start operating this new capacity in the third quarter of this year. Also as a reminder,
Cleveland-Cliffs is the sole producer and a well-established supplier of both GOES, grain-
oriented electrical steels and NOES in our country. That's our technology originally from
ARMCO, the A in AK Steel.
The market for these products is huge, but any new entrants to this market will have to first
learn the products and then perfect the manufacturing process. Then the rookie producer will
have to qualify these products with each one of the clients. That's not our case. We are already
in the house with all of these clients.
A couple more things before we open for Q&A. Earlier this month, we published our 2022
sustainability report. We are pleased to report that as of 2022, our absolute scope one and two
greenhouse gas emissions were already below our aggressive target for 2030 of 25% reduction,
in comparison to our emissions in 2017. That was when we made our decision to build our
state-of-the-art direct reduction plant. This early accomplishment of our target was made
possible primarily by the use of massive amounts of HBI in our blast furnaces, helped by hot
metal stretching through the increased utilization of scrap in our BOFs and natural gas injection
in our blast furnaces.
We also reported that our scope one and two emissions intensity from our blast furnace and
BOF operations in 2022 was down to 1.60 metric tons of CO2 per metric ton of steel. This
number puts Cleveland-Cliffs in the third percentile of integrated steelmaking emissions
worldwide and compares extremely favorably to the global average of 2.32 tons of CO2 per
metric ton of steel. Because of the metrological requirements and quality needs of our
automotive customer base, we remain committed to the blast furnace BOF steelmaking route,
and we will continue to work to make it less carbon intensive.
In order to further reduce these already low-emission numbers, we are pursuing potentially
high IRR projects in emerging technologies, particularly carbon capture and storage and iron
reduction by hydrogen. As things progress on these fronts, we will continue to keep you
informed.
With that, I'll turn it over to Daryl for questions.
Operator
Thank you. We will now be conducting our question and answer session. If you would like to ask
a question, please press star, one, on your telephone keypad. A confirmation tone will indicate
your line is in the question queue. You may press star, two, to remove yourself from the queue.
For participants using speaker equipment, it may be necessary to pick up your handset before

-- 6 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 7 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
pressing the star keys. One moment please while we pull for your questions. Our first questions
come from the line of Emily Chieng with Goldman Sachs. Please proceed with your questions.
Emily Chieng
Good morning, Lourenco and Celso and thanks for taking my questions this morning. My first is
just around the electrical steel market. I wanted to follow up here and understand a little bit
more about what's happening. Could you perhaps talk to the size of the nongrain-oriented and
grain-oriented electrical steel markets and growth outlook, and perhaps what electrical steel
production capacity Cliffs will have after the 70,000-ton capacity investment later this year?
Lourenco Goncalves
Sure. Well, good morning, Emily. Look, first of all, the non-oriented electrical steels are totally
associated at this point with the pace of adoption of electric vehicles. We have developed a
special product called the MOTOR-MAX, and the MOTOR-MAX is for this type of high-end
applications in non-oriented electrical steels. This investment, that was not a massive
investment. We're talking $30 million, which, by the way, has already been deployed to
produce another 70,000 tons of NOES, will take care of that. And we'll take care of that for the
time being and freeing up capacity to produce more grain-oriented electrical steels at our
Butler, Pennsylvania plant, because today, we basically do both in Butler. So we are moving
70,000 what is significant when you notice that our production capacity is around 240,000 tons
at Butler. So we are really growing our ability to supply more GOES.
GOES is related to the grid because it goes into, no pun intended, it goes into the production of
laminations and core for transformers. And transformers are utilized everywhere into the grid,
and we are, at this point, the sole suppliers of these materials. So as monies are deployed and
there are monies to be deployed coming from legislation that will free up capital to be invested
in the improvement of the grid and also in the improvement of charging stations that is coming,
we're going to have to continue to grow the production of GOES. So that's pretty much what
we have at this point. And I think we are rightsized for the pace of the growth of the market at
this point.
Emily Chieng
Understood. That's very helpful. And a follow-up, if I may, just around the cost outlook there. I
think, Celso, you mentioned there was a $60 a ton decrease in 1Q in terms of the cost profile.
And I think previously, you've also talked about further reductions in 2Q and 3Q. Do you have
any numbers as to help us frame where those numbers could land? And remind us what the
moving pieces driving those costs down on a dollar per ton basis.
Celso Goncalves
Yeah, sure. Hey, Emily. We've already decreased costs by, call it, $140 a ton in just two
quarters. And the Q1 cost reduction of $60 a ton is $10 more than we guided down $50 for the
quarter. As the inventory continues to come out, you can expect further cost reduction here in

-- 7 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 8 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Q2. Now, the magnitude won't be as great as it was here in Q1, but we're still working hard to
bring costs down. Call it, a $15 to $20 a ton reduction here for this coming quarter, Q2.
Emily Chieng
All right. That's very helpful. Thanks.
Celso Goncalves
Thank you.
Operator
Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Lucas Pipes with B. Riley Securities. Please
proceed with your questions.
Lucas Pipes
Thank you very much, operator. Good morning, everyone. My First question is also on the
electrical steel side. And Lourenco, I wondered if you could maybe frame up the project
pipeline after this year. I assume kind of capital intensity would move up somewhat, but maybe
that's a wrong assumption. And yeah, I would really appreciate color on the potential growth
opportunities after this year and what the capital intensity would look like for you or your
competition. Thank you very much.
Lourenco Goncalves
Good morning, Lucas. First of all, I would like to position electrical steels in a historical
perspective. That's always very helpful to understand. When I acquired AK Steel back in March
of 2020, Butler and Zanesville were both slated to be shut down. Actually, the first meeting that
I participate representing AK Steel happened in a steel caucus meeting in Washington, D.C. four
days before we closed. And I sat in for Roger Newport, then CEO of AK Steel. He was very kind
to allow me to be there and speak. I basically put everybody on notice that if nothing would
happen, we would just go ahead and execute the shutdown process that was slated to happen.
So long story short, we were being slaughtered by imported steel at that time. We were able to
stop that. We were able to bring back production to the United States. We were able to shut
down the backdoor production of lamination and cores coming mainly from Mexico and Canada
using electrical steels from Korea, Taiwan and Japan. So we fixed the market in a way that we
are no longer losing money. At this very point, Lucas, electrical steels is our most profitable line
of business. So we are very happy with the fact that we are growing our own capacity with the
pace of the demand.
We are not going to run ahead of the demand. We are aware that the competition will try to
participate in this market. Be my guest, it's not an easy market. It's complicated product. So we
know that a lot of the attempts will fail, and this business will come back to us. So at the right
time, we will deploy capital. It's not a priority right now. We are happy with what we have. We

-- 8 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 9 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
are happy with the expansion that we deployed in Zanesville for NOES. That will free up more
GOES out of Butler. We are in good shape for now.
Lucas Pipes
Very helpful. Thank you, Lourenco. And then my second question is also a little bit more on the
near term, and I wondered if you could comment on the second quarter pricing outlook. You
mentioned the April batch on the fixed contracts was reset very successfully, and then spot
prices obviously moved up very nicely year-to-date. So I wondered if you could comment on
what the whole package would look like on the pricing side in Q2. Thank you very much for
your perspective.
Lourenco Goncalves
Lucas, as far as Cleveland-Cliffs is concerned, the outlook is great because as you know, our
contracts with automotive and other clients, but particularly in the automotive business that's
big for us, is fixed price. So when underlying hot-rolled price in the spot market is $1,000, if I'm
selling to--and I'm making this up, just to give you the picture. So don't take the number to the
bank. But if underlying hot-rolled prices are $1,000 and my contact is $1,200, then I'm selling
for $1,200. If underlying market price is $1,400, my price for the automotive clients is also
$1,200.
Long story short, it doesn't matter where the spot price will go up or down, a lot down, a lot up,
our price with automotive slice of the business that's in the quarter was 36% of the business
will stay where it is. So we are feeling very good about that because we are protected in a very,
very important part of the market.
Celso, do you want to complement something on that?
Celso Goncalves
Yeah, sure. Hey, Lucas, just to add some numbers to that as well.
Lucas Pipes
Thank you.
Celso Goncalves
Relative to Q1, we expect Q2 average selling price to increase more than $100 a ton, call it,
$120 a ton compared to Q1, and that's largely driven by higher HRC pricing, higher slab pricing.
And then most importantly, those lags that we experienced in Q1 from the sub-$700 index
pricing environment in November, December, those all fall off in Q2. So that's why you see the
big jump in sales price.
Lucas Pipes
Terrific. This is super helpful. Really appreciate your color and continued best of luck. Thank
you.

-- 9 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 10 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Lourenco Goncalves
Thank you.
Celso Goncalves
Thanks, Lucas.
Operator
Our next questions come from the line of Carlos De Alba with Morgan Stanley. Please proceed
with your questions.
Carlos De Alba
Yeah. Good morning. Thank you, Lourenco, and Celso. Just on the--a couple of questions. One
is on CapEx. How should we think about the CapEx going forward given that it's running below
$800 million, depreciation, which a lot of time we use for reference for sustaining CapEx is
closer to $900 million, $950 million. So how do you see--for how many years do you think you
can keep your CapEx below this threshold of depreciation without jeopardizing the equipment?
So that will be very useful for the projection of cash flows.
Lourenco Goncalves
Yeah. Just to give you a color on what you have just said. The depreciation is a good reference
because it's a good average, but it's not good in short term as a reference because remember,
when we acquired the assets, they were mistreated. We had to deploy more capital than the
depreciation, and that's why we're still paying in our accounting for the higher costs and lower
production during the time that we are doing just that.
So when we average back what's happening this year, and what’s going to happen next year
with what happened last year, we'll probably go back to your depreciation number, Carlos. But
we are now in the back end of the stuff that we have already done, money that we have
already spent, and we are not going to spend again. I don't know if Celso wants to complement.
Celso Goncalves
Yeah, sure. Hey, Carlos. So if you think of 2022, we spent over $900 million in CapEx, but that
included a lot of maintenance repairs. That cycle is now behind us. So the new sustaining level
for 2023 and at least 2024 is that $700 million level. Now, when you get to 2025 and beyond,
and then you have some additional relines and things like that, it could increase again. But for
the foreseeable future, what we can see here in '23 and '24, that $700 million is a number that
we're comfortable with.
Carlos De Alba
All right. And just you mentioned, Celso, when is the next relining, just for us to have it here in
the record?

-- 10 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 11 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Celso Goncalves
Yeah, 2025 Burns.
Carlos De Alba
Okay. Great. And then my second question, if I may, on prices. The October renegotiation for
the auto--resetting for the auto contracts, how should we think about that? Is that going to be
in line with what we saw in April? Or is that more subject to supply demand conditions of the
auto sector, not necessarily the HRC spot market?
Lourenco Goncalves
Yeah. The HRC spot Carlos has been taken out of the picture in automotive. I gave each one of
our major clients the option to buy from people that sell based on that, no one took it. So now
we are in supply and demand in a true relationship type of thing. I know it's a game changer.
Yes, it is a game changer, never happened between steel companies and car manufacturers
ever. It's happening now.
I believe that the automotive company's relationship with the steel mills are at the core of why
we, a small iron ore company, were able to acquire two big suppliers of automotive steel that
are actually already consolidated from several others that went down throughout the history of
this business in the United States. That party is over. Now, we will continue to support the
automotive industry. We will continue to provide them the technical capabilities that they
need. We will continue to develop the products for the next-generation cars as we normally do,
but we want to be rewarded. On behalf of our shareholders, we need to get paid. They
understood that through the last two cycles of negotiation.
So when October comes, we'll talk again. It's too early. I'll get my shoes off when I get to the
river. Not there yet.
Carlos De Alba
All right. Good luck. Thank you very much.
Lourenco Goncalves
Thank you.
Celso Goncalves
Thanks, Carlos.
Operator
Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Curt Woodworth with Credit Suisse.
Please proceed with your questions.
Curtis Woodworth
Yeah. Thanks. Good morning, Celso and Lourenco. How are you?

-- 11 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 12 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Lourenco Goncalves
Good, and you, Curt?
Celso Goncalves
Good, Curt.
Curtis Woodworth
Not bad. So I guess with respect to the longer-term CapEx projections around the $700 million,
you also talked about potential investments in CCS as well as iron reduction via hydrogen,
which some of the numbers being postulated on some of those things are fairly significant
capital. So I realize it may be preliminary, but can you give us a little bit of insight into how CCS
or hydrogen could fit into your business model, and what maybe some of the economics could
be around that?
Lourenco Goncalves
Yeah. First indications are showing that particularly CCS could be a very high internal rate of
return project based on not only monies available to develop the project with participation of
the government, but also tax credit of up to $85 per ton of carbon capture. So this is pretty
meaningful, pretty significant. It's not a short-term deployment of capital, Curt. So there is
nothing really urgent about executing right now, but these are the numbers that we are
working with.
As far as hydrogen, we are ready. We are ready to use it. Why is that? Well, we already built the
direct reduction plant that can use hydrogen. We just need a pipe with hydrogen to connect to
the pipeline that we feed natural gas. We're starting reaching natural gas with 1%, then 5% and
10%. We can go up to 60% hydrogen in that plant. So we are ready. We just need the hydrogen.
We are working with several, not one, but several different groups to create hydrogen hubs
that can bring a cheap and plentiful hydrogen to Toledo and also Cleveland because we actually
have the technology of injecting natural gas into blast furnace.
I think that in the amounts that we use here in the United States, that's only one other country
in the world that does, it's Russia. So the other suppliers of steel for the automotive industry
throughout the entire world, Japan, Korea, Europe, Brazil, they don't have natural gas available,
cheap, plentiful, so they don't have this technique. And we do, like the Russians. So we -- in the
civilized world, we are the only ones.
So as far as car manufacturing, we are already a lot greener than the Europeans, a lot greener
than the Japanese, a lot greener than the Koreans because we inject natural gas. As soon as we
enrich natural gas with hydrogen, we're going to be really green. And we are producing massive
amounts of automotive steel. We're not producing press release with brand names. We are
supplying the massive tons that the car manufacturers produce. We haven't seen a press
release because we are seeing the massive numbers that we produce every quarter in our
financial statements. That's why you don't see brand names and press release.

-- 12 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 13 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Curtis Woodworth
Okay. That's helpful. And then, I guess, second question just on the metallic market. You talked
about, I guess, 30 million tons of prime metallic demand in three years, up from 20, I think you
said, today. And obviously, you guys are in a unique position having captive ore. And you did
the large FPT deal. What is kind of your strategy going forward to either further leverage your
metallic position? Would you look to increase your HBI potential? Do you see scope for more
consolidation in the scrap market? And kind of how do you see that fitting in? You talked about
Burns Harbor up for a reline in '25, is that capital you would spend? Or would that free up iron
ore to potentially further leverage the metallic strategy? Thanks very much, guys.
Lourenco Goncalves
Curt, look, I'm very comfortable with our situation right now using our finite resources in
Minnesota and Michigan for our own use. We like that. So if you're trying to ask me if I'm going
to build another HBI plant, the answer is no. What if you get Nashwauk? The answer is still no.
Are you considering building HBI to supply other companies? No, that horse has departed the
barn when I acquired AK Steel. I built that HBI plant to support mini-mills that I thought they
were really serious in producing flat-rolled steel with the high specifications. But actually, they
are in the business of producing rebar, wide flange beams, plate. That's all good. Good stuff,
but doesn't compete against my automotive. So I'll keep my metallic for ourselves.
FPT is the biggest buyer of prime scrap in the country. We'll continue to do this closed loops.
We are happy with what we have. We only continue to grow FPT for ourselves as well. So it's all
self-centered. It's all in closing side, Cleveland-Cliffs and everybody else will be outside looking.
Curtis Woodworth
Very clear. Thank you.
Lourenco Goncalves
Thank you.
Operator
Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Timna Tanners with Wolfe Research.
Please proceed with your questions.
Timna Tanners
Yeah, hey. Good morning, everyone. Wanted to ask a little bit about the mix in my first
question. So I know that Lourenco mentioned that the big driver of improved volumes was the
automotive market, but based off of the detail that you provided, I couldn't see a big move
coated. I actually saw the biggest movement in HRC. So I'm just wondering, is there a cadence
for maybe that ramps up more later in the year? Or is this kind of the mix that we should expect
for the balance of the year?

-- 13 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 14 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Lourenco Goncalves
Yeah. Look, we did gain hot-rolled as well. Like I said, when you allocate more to automotive
and you basically fill up your galvanizing lines producing exposed parts and high strength low
alloys for structure, cages, for EVs, things like that, you are done with your utilization of high
value-added galvanized and then you grow shipments. You are going to grow shipments where
it's easier and it's easier to sell hot rolled. So your assessment is dead on. That's where the
growth came after filling up all of our capacity of galvanized with high value-added governance.
Timna Tanners
Okay. And you're planning to continue to produce at these levels through the rest of the year?
Just to my question, I think Nucor mentioned on its call that it was going to manage volumes,
and I think other companies have said they're going to run full out, so just wanted your latest
thinking there.
Lourenco Goncalves
We are running full out to supply our automotive clients. As our automotive clients continue to
build more and more cars as the recession has been delayed one more time, and with the Fed
getting to the end of this, like I called in my prepared remark, rate hiking marathon. We are
going to see that cars will continue to be sold. And we are the ones that will benefit the most
from that. And with our other capacity allocated to the rest of the market.
We are also developing closed loop programs with our major clients in appliance and other
markets. So we are continuing to deliver more to these folks. So we're in good shape with all
that. My perspective for the balance of the year is very positive because it tags along with the
growth and demand that's coming from automotive.
Timna Tanners
Got it. And then if I could, the last question is just on the guidance you gave last quarter was for
net periodic benefit credits of $140 million, and you started out a pretty high run rate. So just
wondering if you have any updated guidance or if we should still be using that value. And
thanks again.
Lourenco Goncalves
I'm sorry, Timna, can you repeat the question one more time? I think I missed.
Timna Tanners
Oh, yeah. Oh, no problem. Yeah. So on the--just a kind of accounting question, I guess, on the
net periodic benefit credits. I have in my notes, a $140 million guided for 2023 on the last call,
but the first quarter was already $50 million. So just trying to make sure that that's still the right
value for modeling purposes.

-- 14 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 15 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Celso Goncalves
Got you. Hey, Timna, it's Celso. Yeah, I think you're missing service costs and interest costs,
which are on COGS. This nets to around, call it, $140 million after you consider that piece. It's
still $140 million.
Timna Tanners
Okay. All right. Thank you.
Celso Goncalves
No problem.
Operator
Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Tristan Gresser with BNP Paribas. Please
proceed with your questions.
Tristan Gresser
Yes, hi. Thank you for taking my question. I just have one left. It's on capital allocation. I think in
your prepared remarks, you flagged a $3 billion net debt target that you expect to reach at
some point this year, if I understood correctly. So what's the strategy after that? I think you
talked about the strong electrical steel market you find with your capacity, you find with the
metallics your supply there as well. You flagged some decarbonization needs, but are there
more investment coming? Or will free cash flow generation will be more tilted towards
shareholder returns after that, after we reach that point? And also, is the net debt-to-EBITDA
reference point you have below one time, is it still valid? Thank you.
Lourenco Goncalves
We didn't flag anything that you said that we flagged. So let's correct the record. We talked
about projects that are multiyear, and you are conflicting everything for the cash flow that we
are going to have this year and our target of getting to net debt down to $3 billion this year. So
the only thing that we said that we will do, take notice, please, Tristan. We are going to get to
net debt at $3 billion later this year, still this year. That's what we said.
The carbon capture project is future. The hydrogen project is future because we still don't have
hydrogen. The relining of Burns Harbor is in 2025. We are in 2023. So one more time. We
flagged that we're going to get to net debt, $3 billion this year. Before Santa Claus comes to
your home, you're going to be with $3 billion net debt. What else can I do for you, Tristan?
Tristan Gresser
No, sorry if my question wasn't clear then. After you get to that milestone, what's you thinking?
What's the strategy?

-- 15 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 16 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Lourenco Goncalves
Your question was clear. Your understanding was wrong. So that's why I've corrected your
assessment. But after we get to $3 billion, we will see. We haven't said anything about it. I'm
not going to tell you at this point. But usually, companies at that point, tend to increase return
to the shareholders. But return to the shareholders can happen earlier, whereas my stock price
is on sale in the stock exchange, as soon as the window opens, I might be buying stock. I myself
as CEO, I'm going to buy a lot of stock as soon as the window opens, because it's on sale. It's on
sale because people don't understand long term. They believe that three months, a quarter is
long term, it's not. In our business, it's a New York minute. Okay, Tristan?
Tristan Gresser
All right. Thank you.
Lourenco Goncalves
You're welcome.
Operator
Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Alex Hacking with Citi. Please proceed
with your questions.
Alex Hacking
Yeah, morning, and thanks for the call. I just wanted to follow up on the cost guidance. I think in
the last quarter, Celso, you had guided to maybe $60 of cost decreases in 2Q and then another
$40 in 3Q. And now we're looking, I think, of $20 in 2Q. I understand it's extremely difficult to
forecast. I guess what changed in the forecast, and should we still be expecting the cost
decreases to flow into the third quarter and potentially the fourth quarter as well? Thank you.
Celso Goncalves
Yeah, sure. Hey, Alex. Let's drill down on that because it's important. So since we gave that
guide, scrap prices, for example, have gone up around $100. So things change, right? And like I
said, we guided to $50 cost reduction in Q1, and we executed $60. So there's a little bit of pull
forward there. And we, as you said, had guided to another $60 in Q2, and now I'm saying, call it,
$15 to $20. And the bridge between that $60 and $15 is largely driven by that change in scrap.
But beyond Q2, we will see further cost reductions as well. So even though I'm seeing $15 to
$20 here in Q2, Q3 is also going to have further cost reductions, call it, another $25. So it's still
significant, meaningful cost reduction. It's just the timing, like you said, it's hard to nail down.
Alex Hacking
Okay. Thanks. I appreciate the color, and I understand. Metallics is a moving target and hard to
forecast. And then I guess just on the shipment side, obviously, extremely strong in the quarter
to auto and also outside of auto. Is there any part of that you think is restocking? Or do you
think this reflects where true underlying demand is and the weakness that we saw at the end of
last year was really just driven by destocking? Thank you.

-- 16 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 17 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Lourenco Goncalves
In our case, Alex, all the fluctuations that we are seeing are coming from end users, particularly
coming from automotive. Automotive is buying more. SAAR is higher now than it has been in a
long time. It's not back to where it should be, but the consumer continues to buy cars. They
continue to produce cars at the OEM level. They continue to push cars into the lots of the
dealers, and we continue to sell steel for them to build these cars.
So this north of 4 million tons a quarter pace that we are in right now is supported, basically, I
would say, exclusively by automotive demand in our case. All the rest is just gravy. Service
centers are continuing to operate at low levels of inventory. And if they see something different
coming next week when the Fed will speak, they probably will buy more. I am anticipating car
manufacturers continue to buy strong and service centers will be left behind if they don't start
to change their pace. It's not bad, but it's not great at this point.
Alex Hacking
Okay. I appreciate the color as always. Thank you.
Lourenco Goncalves
Thank you.
Celso Goncalves
Thanks, Alex.
Operator
Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Sean Wondrack with Deutsche Bank.
Please proceed with your questions.
Sean Wondrack
Hi. Good morning, Lourenco and Celso. Just first question - when you think about sort of green
energy and some of the opportunities you're pursuing, do you see any other tangential
opportunities, whether it's within solar or wind or even charging infrastructure that we could
look forward to in the next few years? Thank you.
Lourenco Goncalves
Yeah. Look, we sell to clients in this submarket, and we are seeing demand coming from them.
We believe that monies coming from inflation Reduction Act and the Infrastructure Bill will
support more and more investment in these areas, but at this point, it is still at the very
beginning of the development of this submarket. One thing that I believe will pick up steam
very quickly is the deployment of capital in charging stations because the states are starting to
move faster on that, and that will create more opportunities for us, not only for grain-oriented
electrical steels, obviously, but also for other types of steel because the charging stations
consume steel, not only electrical steels, like normal carbon steel that we produce and sell. So
these are mainly the best points of increased consumption that we see right now.

-- 17 of 18 --

InComm Conferencing 	Page 18 of 18 	www.incommconferencing.com
Sean Wondrack
Thank you. That's definitely helpful. And then just understanding, you've done a good job
paying down a lot of debt, and your top priorities remains debt reduction. That aside, you've
been out of M&A for a little while. Is there any opportunity or appetite for M&A or are you still
favoring organic improvement as you've laid out on the call? Thank you.
Lourenco Goncalves
Neither one or the other because M&A is opportunity. And you don't see small iron ore
company buying a steel maker and then buy another steel maker and going from $2 billion in
revenues in 2019 to $23 billion in revenues in 2022 all the time. So you probably never saw in
your life and never will in the future.
So M&A is opportunity. So at this point, I don't see any opportunity on M&A. And I did not
commit with the greenfield growth any time during this call or any time in the last two years. So
there is no real greenfield opportunity for us. For us, it's paying down debt. And once we pay
down debt, we're going to do something with the money good for the shareholders. That's all
you can get as a commitment for us at this point.
Sean Wondrack
Okay. It's very clear. Thank you very much.
Lourenco Goncalves
Thank you, Sean.
Operator
Thank you. There are no further questions. I would like to hand the call back over to you.
Lourenco Goncalves
All right. Ladies and gentlemen, thanks for being with us for the last hour. We appreciate the
interest in Cleveland-Cliffs. We will continue to keep you posted, and we'll continue to deliver
the results we are committed to deliver. Thanks again and have a great day.
Operator
Thank you. This does conclude today's teleconference. We appreciate your participation. You
may disconnect your lines at this time. Enjoy the rest of your day.

-- 18 of 18 --