TRANSCRIPT

Q1 2021 — Fixed income call transcript

Q1 2021PDF · 17 pages166 KB
Deutsche Bank AG
Deutsche Bank Q1 2021 Fixed Income Conference Call
30 April 2021 | 15:00 CEST
Transcript
Speakers
James von Moltke, Chief Financial Officer
Dixit Joshi, Group Treasurer
Philip Teuchner, Investor Relations

-- 1 of 17 --

2
Philip Teuchner 	Thank you, Emma. Good afternoon or good morning and thank
you all for joining us today. We have made a change to the
sequence of the Fixed Income call in this quarter. Our Group
Treasurer, Dixit Joshi, will lead you through the prepared
remarks, including a short summary of our quarterly results,
before moving to the expanded Treasury section. For the
subsequent Q&A, we continue having our CFO, James von
Moltke, with us to cover your questions, together with Dixit.
The slides that accompany the topics are available for download
from our website at db.com. Before we get started, I just want
to remind you that the presentation may contain forward-
looking statements which may not develop as we currently
expect. Therefore, please take note of the precautionary
warning at the end of our materials. With that, let me hand over
to Dixit.
Dixit Joshi 	Thank you, Philip, and welcome from me. We have continued to
deliver against our transformation milestones. We are on or
ahead of our expected timeline on all key measures. We said at
the investor deep dive in December, we would focus on
delivering sustainable profitability. With revenue growth in the
quarter, up 14%, to €7.2 billion, we demonstrated what this
franchise is capable of. We generated €1.6 billion of pre-tax
profit and €1.0 billion of profit after tax. That’s our best quarter
in seven years, despite our now smaller footprint.
The 	progress 	that 	we 	have 	made 	has 	increasingly 	won
recognition in the financial markets and we are pleased with the
outlook revisions of three ratings agencies over the last months.
We remain disciplined on capital, risk and balance sheet
management, and we successfully navigated several market
events during the quarter. And, we were active in the capital
markets in the first quarter, with €7.5 billion of issuance, leaving
us well-positioned as we look to our funding plan for the rest of
the year.
Moving now to slide three which summarises the different
outlook revisions of our credit ratings over the last months. It
was 	gratifying 	to 	see 	key 	stakeholders 	recognising 	our
progress. In the first quarter, both Fitch and S&P revised their
outlook on ratings from negative to positive. This follows a
revision to stable from Moody’s, back in November last year. All
agencies acknowledge the solid execution related to our
transformation 	agenda, 	evidenced 	by 	strong 	revenue
generation and overall financial performance. We will continue
to actively engage with the ratings agencies throughout the
year as improving our ratings remains a key management focus.

-- 2 of 17 --

3
Let us look at a summary of our financial performance for the
quarter compared to the prior year on slide four. We generated
a profit before tax of €1.6 billion or €1.8 billion on an adjusted
basis. Total revenues for the group were €7.2 billion, up 14%
versus the first quarter 2020, and 33% versus the prior quarter.
Non-interest expenses were down 1% year-on-year.
As we indicated in mid-March, in line with the latest guidance
from the Single Resolution Board, the Single Resolution Fund is
expected to be expanded to over €70 billion and our estimated
assessment has been adjusted accordingly to approximately
€600 million.
We also saw an unexpected market event, which led to an
additional contribution of €28 million to the Germany statutory
deposit guarantee scheme in the quarter. Our provision for
credit losses decreased to €69 million or six basis points of
loans. Risks remain in the environment but we expect full-year
provisions to be substantially below last year.
Our improved results are supported by growing revenues and
our refocused business model, as you can see on slide five. We
have grown revenues in our Core Bank by 12% this quarter to
€7.1 	billion, 	excluding 	specific 	items. 	This 	growth 	has
principally come from Investment Bank, which has delivered
strong performance in both fixed income and currencies,
particularly in credit and origination and advisory.
Our Corporate Bank and Private Bank successfully offset
headwinds, with a combination of deposit repricing and volume
growth, and we see rising momentum in these businesses.
Asset Management delivered revenue growth, boosted by
transaction and performance fees. Over the last 12 months, that
takes our Core Bank revenues to €25 billion, a 7% increase from
the previous 12-month period, ahead of our 2022 ambitions. In
summary, all our core businesses have proven the strength of
their franchises, putting our 2022 objectives well within reach.
Let us now look at how this translates into higher profitability on
slide 	six. 	Our 	relentless 	focus 	on 	delivering 	on 	our
transformation agenda is reaching the bottom line. We have
seen a 75% year-on-year increase in our adjusted profit before
tax in the Core Bank for the last 12 months to the first quarter
and all four core business contributed.
At the same time, we continued to de-risk in the Capital Release
Unit, which nearly halved its pre-tax loss compared to the first
quarter of last year. Since we started our transformation
strategy seven quarters ago we have substantially reduced the
Capital 	Release 	Unit’s 	losses. 	We 	remain 	committed 	to
minimising the P&L impact of de-risking efforts by the unit and

-- 3 of 17 --

4
to our cost reduction plans.
Let us know turn to risk management on slide seven. Strong risk
discipline is a central pillar of our strategy across credit, market,
liquidity and non-financial risks. Provision for credit losses were
€69 million this quarter or six basis points of average loans on
an 	annualised 	basis, 	principally 	due 	to 	the 	improved
macroeconomic environment.
We continue to manage a high-quality and well-diversified loan
book, 	with 	strong 	underwriting 	standards, 	a 	robust 	and
proactive risk management framework, as well as dynamic
collateral 	management. 	We’ve 	also 	remained 	vigilant 	on
concentration risk, strict on risk appetite parameters and
proactive in risk identification and management.
Our market risk management benefits from a dynamic hedging
framework 	with 	daily 	stress 	testing 	and 	monitoring. 	Our
comprehensive non-financial risk controls contribute to robust
crisis management practices. These capabilities have not only
helped us achieve consistently contained credit and market risk
losses, but have also helped us avoid negative impacts from
external events such as the ones we saw in the quarter. We
continue to strengthen our non-financial risk management,
tightening our control environment and continuing to work on
strengthening our anti-financial crime capabilities.
Now, let us turn to the balance sheet. Slide eight shows a
summary of our net balance sheet, which excludes derivative
netting 	agreements, 	cash 	collateral, 	as 	well 	as 	pending
settlements. We have made significant progress on our balance
sheet transformation over the years.
Since the first quarter of 2019, shortly before we announced our
strategy update, we have reduced net assets by around €75
billion, as reductions in trading assets and liquidity reserves
have been partially offset by growth in our loan portfolios. We
have reduced trading assets by around €90 billion, primarily
reflecting our decision to exit equity sales and trading.
Trading assets now primarily consist of government bonds and
short-term secured financing assets in our repo book. At the
same time, we have grown our loans at amortised cost by €25
billion. Loans now account for 45% of our net balance sheet,
with around half in Germany, primarily low-risk mortgages.
Liquidity reserves continue to account for about a quarter of the
net balance sheet.
We have also improved the quality of our liabilities and funding
base. While deposits remain flat, we have optimised the quality
of our deposit base as we reduced the reliance on short-term

-- 4 of 17 --

5
wholesale 	funding 	and 	increased 	more 	stable 	retail 	and
corporate deposits. Low cost deposits continue being our main
funding source, now contributing almost 60% to our funding
sources. At the same time, our loan-to-deposit ratio of 76%
provides sufficient room to prudently grow loan balances in
coming periods.
Slide nine provides further details on the developments in our
loan and deposit books over the quarter. On an FX adjusted
basis, total loan growth in the quarter has been €4.0 billon,
predominantly in our Private Bank, where we have seen
continued 	strong 	growth 	in 	mortgage 	and 	collateralised
lending.
While we continue seeing repayments of credit facilities in our
Corporate 	Bank, 	Trade 	Finance 	is 	benefitting 	from 	the
reopening of the global economy. In the Investment Bank,
quarterly loan development has been flat, as the business
continues targeted resource deployment while keeping overall
risk appetite under control. For the rest of this year, we expect
the overall positive trend to continue as our portfolio of credit
facilities has, by now, reached a normalised pre-COVID level,
while we see good demand across our client segments.
Looking at deposits, we continue seeing high savings rates
across many European countries, resulting in €4.0 billion FX
adjusted growth in the Private Bank. In our Corporate Bank, we
have seen temporary inflows in Trust & Agency Services and
some growth in cash management deposits that were subject
to charging. For the rest of the year, we expect total deposits to
moderately reduce from current elevated levels as we continue
implementing charging agreements.
Slide ten shows the substantial progress that we have made in
passing through negative interest rates to our Corporate and
Private Bank customers. At the end of the first quarter, we had
charging agreements in place on a total of €95 billion of
deposits, generating quarterly revenues of €80 million.
At this current run rate we are already achieving our charging-
related 2022 revenue target as we communicated at our
December 	investor 	deep 	dive. 	This 	positive 	revenue
development is predominantly driven by significantly lower
than expected deposit outflows as competitors take similar
measures against the backdrop of continued negative euro
interest rates.
As you can see in the graph, we have already made significant
progress in our Corporate Bank where charging agreements are
in place for approximately two-thirds of our euro current
account portfolio. We will now generate additional revenues by

-- 5 of 17 --

6
focusing on smaller client segments with currently lower
coverage, as well as by reviewing already granted thresholds for
our existing agreements.
In the Private Bank our key priority remains to actively engage
with our customers and advise them on liquidity solutions and
alternative 	investment 	products. 	Deposit 	charging 	above
€100,000 is already in place for new accounts. Until the end of
the year we will look to find individual solutions also for existing
accounts across the German and international franchise.
Moving to slide 11, which highlights the development of our key
liquidity metrics. Our liquidity reserves remain at €243 billion,
with the majority held in cash and cash equivalents. The cash
component of the liquidity reserves temporarily increased as we
were reducing the securities portfolio.
The prudent deployment of cash into high-quality securities
remains a focus for us, reflecting our commitment to further
improve the composition of our liquidity reserves. In the first
quarter, 	liquidity 	reserves 	were 	broadly 	flat, 	as 	deposit
increases from the Private Bank and Corporate Bank were
deployed into loan growth of €9 billion, primarily in the Private
Bank.
Our liquidity coverage ratio at 146% continued to comfortably
exceed minimum regulatory requirements. As we move forward
with our transformation agenda, we are well-positioned to
support business growth and lending as demand is picking up.
Therefore, over time, we continue to manage our liquidity closer
towards our targeted levels.
Turning to capital on slide 12. Our CET1 ratio rose to 13.7%
during the quarter, benefitting from our strong first quarter net
income. This effect was offset by dividend and AT1 accruals,
equity compensation effects and higher regulatory prudent
valuation deductions.
Risk-weighted assets rose from €329 billion to €330 billion
during the quarter but were €3 billion down, excluding FX
effects. Notably, additional hedging led to lower market risk
RWA, 	and 	operational 	risk 	RWA 	benefitted 	from 	further
improvements in the internal loss profile.
These reductions outweighed higher credit risk RWA, including
a €4 billion impact for large corporates following the receipt of
a final TRIM decision from the ECB. Further, risk-weighted
asset increases from regulatory and supervisory changes are
expected to negatively impact the CET1 ratio by approximately
80 basis points in the upcoming quarter.

-- 6 of 17 --

7
Here, we see three main drivers. First, we expect the ECB to
conclude its targeted review of internal models by issuing final
decisions regarding leveraged lending and for banks and
financial 	institutions. 	Second, 	we’re 	expecting 	final 	ECB
clearance of our implementation of the EBA guideline on
definition of default. And, third, we will implement revised RWA
calculations in response to CCR2 becoming effective end of the
second 	quarter 	2021, 	for 	example, 	in 	relation 	to 	the
standardised approach for counterparty credit risk.
With our CET1 ratio of 13.7% at the end of the first quarter we
have a buffer of 330 	basis points 	over our CET1 ratio
requirement as shown on slide 13. Principally due to our
successful January 2021 Tier 2 issuance, the distance to the
binding total capital MDA level increased quarter-on-quarter by
39 basis points. Hence, we remain in a comfortable position to
absorb the upcoming RWA inflation that has been previously
outlined.
Moving to slide 14. Our fully-loaded leverage ratio decreased by
eight basis points to 4.6% this quarter. Of this decrease, four
basis points came from FX translation effects, three basis points
from increased trading volumes and net loan growth, and one
basis point from negative capital effects. Our pro forma
leverage ratio, including ECB cash balances, was 4.2%. In the
second quarter of 2021, we expect an increase in leverage
exposure of roughly €20 billion from the introduction of the
standardised approach for counterparty credit risk as part of
CRR2.
We continue to operate with a significant loss-absorbing
capacity, well above our requirements, as shown on slide 15. At
the end of the first quarter, our loss-absorbing capacity was €20
billion above the minimum requirement for eligible liabilities or
MREL, our most biding constraint.
The head room is higher than originally expected, as the Single
Resolution Board has decided on 22nd March to continue with
the MREL recognition of bonds issued under English law in
contrast to prior guidance. We expect our MREL buffer to
reduce later this year when the new MREL requirement and the
expected RW inflation become effective, but we will continue to
conservatively manage our buffer.
Even after accounting for the expected requirements change
and regulatory inflation in the second quarter, a remaining
MREL buffer of €5-10 billion would allow us to completely stop
issuing 	new 	senior 	non-preferred 	and 	senior 	preferred
instruments for up to one year or, alternatively, allow us to
absorb a further unexpected RWA increase of almost €30

-- 7 of 17 --

8
billion.
Moving now to our issuance plan on slide 16. As you can see in
the issuance and redemption summary of 2019 and 2020, we
continue to decrease our reliance on capital markets funding,
including senior non-preferred, as we continue to restructure
the balance sheet and optimise our funding sources.
Quarter-on-quarter, 	our 	senior 	non-preferred 	debt 	has
tightened by around 20 basis points in euros and US dollars,
outperforming our peers by roughly 25 basis points on average.
We used this positive sentiment to issue at favourable spreads,
contributing positively to our financial goals through lower
funding costs.
In the first quarter, we issued a total of €7.5 billion, mainly driven
by six benchmark transactions in three currencies. This enabled
us to complete 50% of the lower end of our full-year issuance
target, which we now view as a likely requirement for 2021.
Earlier this month, Moody’s has released the Request for
Comment on the updated LGF methodology. We expect the
changes, which are in line with our initial assessment, to be
implemented in the third quarter of this year. This means that
we do not expect any impact on issuance plan for this year as a
result of the Moody’s LGF metric.
In March, we raised a further €3.3 billion of funding from the
ECB’s TLTRO III programme, taking our total participation to
around €41 billion. We confirm that we have achieved the
benchmark growth of the programme’s observation period
ending on 31st March, which guarantees the programme’s most
favourable terms between June last year and this year.
While monitoring the next growth observation period from
October 2020 to December 2021 closely, we will use the
residual TLTRO participation windows to optimise our total
take-up and repayment schedule. Given the advantage of
central bank funding, it is likely that we will not issue the €3-5
billion covered bond issuances planned for 2021. As mentioned
earlier, we would guide you to the lower end of the 2021
issuance plan as a likely requirement for the full year based on
current assumptions.
Turning to slide 17, you can see highlights from a select number
of transactions in the quarter. Across all issuances, we saw
strong and diversified investor demand. On average, our 2021
benchmark order books were three times oversubscribed and
pricing continues to improve versus our peer group.
In addition to successfully executing on our issuance plan, we
were also able to make a vital contribution to Deutsche Bank’s

-- 8 of 17 --

9
sustainability and diversity agenda. We launched our second
green bond, which is also our inaugural senior preferred
benchmark issue in US dollars, and we adopted a new syndicate
structure for our most recent US dollar senior non-preferred
issue.
For the first time, 11 additional underwriters, owned and led by
diverse management teams, joined Deutsche Bank Securities to
underwrite this offering. The group of underwriters were
selected to represent 	diverse missions including certified
service disabled veteran-owned, African American-owned and
women-owned firms. This is an important step towards creating
a more diverse and inclusive financial industry and we will
continue on this path.
In conclusion, on slide 18, our balance sheet remains low-risk
and well-funded by highly stable sources, as we look to our
2022 targets. On revenues, the improved trajectory in the Core
Bank shows that we are operating at a level that puts our goals
well within reach and we see continued momentum in our client
franchise. We are actively managing our cost/income ratio to
our 2022 target of 70%.
The 	ratings 	agencies 	have 	begun 	to 	acknowledge 	our
transformation progress via positive outlook revisions and we
continue to constructively engage with them, as this remains a
key priority. We have been, and will continue to be, diligent on
risk management. Our guidance for provision for credit losses
is in a range of around 25 basis points of loans for the full year
2021.
We expect to prudently manage down our excess liquidity
towards our target levels over time but, given the attractive
TLTRO conditions, we are under no time pressure to do so. As
a result, we remain committed to our 8% group post-tax return
on tangible equity target and our profit trajectory leaves us well-
positioned to achieve this. With that, let us move on to your
questions.
Daniel David 	Hi, all. Thanks for the call and taking my questions. I just briefly
(Autonomous) 	wanted to touch upon Moody’s Request for Comment and
methodology. I’m just wondering if you could provide a few
more details on the impacts you expect and specifically focused
on your senior non-preferred rating?
The second question would be on your call strategy for your
outstanding legacy bonds in light of the recent call of the Capital
Finance Trust security. Just a few more details on that would be
great. Thanks.

-- 9 of 17 --

10
Dixit Joshi 	Daniel, hi. Good to have you on the call. Let me take both of
those. On the first one, regarding Moody’s LGF, there were six
changes that were proposed as part of the ratings methodology
of which we think two apply to us. The first is the threshold to
achieve a one notch rating uplift in the senior non-preferred.
That threshold gets lowered from 12% to 10%, that’s of tangible
banking assets. The second is this benefit will be partially offset
as the methodology now re-includes some legal entity balances
into the tangible banking asset calculation which had been
previously removed.
We’ve looked at the methodology. We’ve been engaged with
Moody’s. It is our expectation that we will not see any change to
our issuance plan, as we’d already made an assumption for
2021 in that respect. So, I hope that’s helpful.
On the second, regarding the call decision, we’ve announced
the call on 20th April, which is effective on 27 th June. This was
the legacy Tier 2 capital instrument, which loses its capital
recognition at the end of this year and that’s primary because
it’s an SPB structure. We’ve factored that in to our capital plan.
It becomes extensive funding from next year.
So, as we’ve indicated before on these calls, we will make an
economic decision around this considering the benefits the
structure brings, the roll off profile and regulatory treatment
and that was driving the decision to call.
Daniel David 	Thanks. Just on that second part, is there anything further to
add on the other securities that you’ve got outstanding? Can we
read anything into that?
Dixit Joshi 	To the extent that they qualify for regulatory capital, naturally
we’d be keeping a close eye, then, on the funding cross and the
roll off profile. As always, what you’d expect us to do is, again,
look at the economics at the time of call and look at the
replacement value or replacement cost for those instruments
and then make a call at that point.
Daniel David 	Great. Thanks a lot.
Lee Street 	Hello. Thanks for taking my questions. First up, well done on a
(Citigroup) 	really good set of results for the first quarter. Just three from
me. Firstly, looking ahead, could you see foresee a scenario
where you could consider yourselves engaged in any things like
significant M&A transactions within the next two years? Is that
something that could even be foreseen?
Secondly, obviously you’ve had quite an ongoing decline in
leverage assets over the last few years, naturally, as the balance
sheet has shrunk. Obviously, now, you’ve got a lot of TLTRO but

-- 10 of 17 --

11
then that may roll off. I suppose my question is, over the
medium-term, what should be the general trend for leverage
assets from the current level? Are we slightly higher, slightly
lower? Any thoughts there.
And, sorry, just to clarify on that Moody’s LGF comment in
response to the last question. I understand you saying you’d
already factored it into your plans but we shouldn’t be expecting
any rating changes either way as a consequence of the Moody’s
proposal that they’ve come out with, just to clarify. Those would
be my three questions. Thank you.
James von Moltke 	Lee, it’s James. I’ll take the first and ask Dixit to answer the
second two. We’ve been, I think, reasonably consistent in our
statements about M&A, which is, firstly, that we do think there
is industrial logic to consolidation in Europe but that, secondly,
our goal was to execute on our transformation strategy so as to
put the company in a better position to be able to engage in that
process both from a financial and strategic point of view and
also, by the way, in terms of having our internal operations in
the right place.
So, we continue to execute on that path. I can’t say when
opportunities will arise that make sense or when we’ll be ready
but our general view is that we will and at a point in time we
expect to participate in consolidation in the European banking
industry.
Dixit Joshi 	Lee, hi. This is Dixit here on the second and the third. On the
second, regarding leverage assets, we’ll continue to target the
4.5% leverage ratio, which is important. We’ve seen leverage
trend slightly lower through the course of this year and partly
that 	was 	a 	result 	of 	the 	transaction 	with 	BNP 	Paribas
concerning the prime brokerage business. We’ll continue to
drive loan growth, as you’ve been seeing, but again all within
the context a target of a 4.5% leverage ratio.
On the LGF front, no, we’re not expecting a rating impact at the
group level, though I’d reiterate what we’ve said previously on
the call, is that we do think our ratings overall are lagging versus
the enormous work that we’ve done on our balance sheet and
the efforts to de-risk the bank to ensure that we have strong
buffers and adequate liquidity at all points. So, naturally we’d be
hopeful that there would be more positive action on the rating
front over time as we continue executing on our strategy.
Lee Street 	That is all very helpful and very clear. Thank you very much.
Dixit Joshi 	Thanks, Lee.

-- 11 of 17 --

12
Paul Fenner-Leitao 	Hi. Good afternoon, guys. Thank you for taking my call. A couple
(Societe Generale) 	of my questions have already been answered but one hasn’t. On
supply, you’ve got maybe another €10 billion to do for the
remainder of the year. I didn’t quite get what is that you said
about MREL supply at the backend of the year. Maybe, if you
could just clarify that but also tell us whether you intend to do
another hybrid instrument. I had a sense that you might do one
Tier 2, which you’ve already done, plus another AT1, given how
much tighter your spreads are now. I’d love to get a sense of
what you’re thinking in terms of sub as well as NPS. Thank you.
Dixit Joshi 	Sure, Paul. Hi. It is not so much €10 billion to do. As I’ve
mentioned, we’ve done €7.5 billion of issuance already, year to
date, and looking at our trajectory for the rest of the year, the
prevalence of TLTRO funding, which has been quite attractive,
we think we’ll come in at the lower end of the €15-20 billion
issuance range that we’ve put out there. Where we’re likely to
see the impact is not having a need to do covered bond
issuance, 	for 	example, 	through 	the 	course 	of 	this 	year.
Certainly, don’t expect as much as €10 billion through the end
of this year.
In terms of MREL, as you’ve seen, we had net negative issuance
through the course of this year and that’s been quite intentional.
We’ve been managing down the capital markets stack. We’ve
reduced our dependency on the capital markets through the
years. Our reliance on deposit funding is much greater, at more
than 60% of all of our funding sources. We’ve also had de
minimis reliance on wholesale markets, as well. So, that’s been
a deliberate strategy over the years to reduce reliance on
wholesale funding, as well as reduce our capital market
issuance, as well.
On the last point, as always, we would earmark and outline best
efforts, what we think we’ll need to issue through the course of
this year. We’ve outlined €2-3 billion of capital markets issuance
for 2021. We’ve done €1.25 billion with the Tier 2 issuance in
the first quarter. We’re managing towards our 4.5% leverage
ratio. Depending on market conditions, which we track very
closely, we would see windows during which to issue a
combination of Tier 1 and Tier 2 instruments. Again, we have
optionality around those decisions and it will be driven partly by
market conditions at the time. So, we’re watching the markets
very closely.
Robert Smalley 	Hi. Good morning and thanks for doing this call. First, just to
(UBS) 	follow-up on Paul’s point on potential issues, particularly in AT1.
Given where you are from a regulatory point of view, would you
look to do AT1s? Would it be to optimise the P2R composition
or is there something else that would drive that? That’s my first

-- 12 of 17 --

13
question.
Second, going into the financial data supplement on page 14 on
asset quality, when I look at Stage 1, 2 or 3 loans, Stage 3 seems
to have been pretty consistent for the last couple of quarters.
Could you talk a little bit about that, how you think that is going
to break with an improving economic environment? How much
of that idiosyncratic versus troubled or identified industries?
Any other colour around that would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks.
Dixit Joshi 	Robert, hi, and thank you for joining us, as always. On the AT1
front, it would be looking at the derecognition of any remaining
legacy instruments that we have, derecognition from January
’22, so that would be a consideration for any issuance. AT1, of
course, it serves multiple purposes including allowing us to
continue to meet our leverage targets and allow for business
growth in that respect, as well. So, AT1 would be one of the
criteria. Tier 1 leverage would the other, as well. I hope that is
helpful.
Robert Smalley 	Yes.
James von Moltke 	Rob, on the Stage 3, we’ve seen a fair amount of stability, as you
can see, over the last four quarters there and I think that’s
encouraging, given the nature of the credit cycle that we went
through. It’s always hard to say whether that will continue to
plateau or stabilise around this level and when it comes down
but, in general, our perspective has been that the severity of the
credit cycle has been surprisingly benign given what we’ve lived
through and the first quarter Stage 3 numbers were quite
encouraging to us.
There was a little bit of a net release on some names and a
smaller level of new credit determining events. If that were to
continue for the balance of the year then, yes, I would expect
the Stage 3 to begin to come down. There are portfolios that
we’re watching carefully, so I don’t think we’re yet completely
out of the woods on the COVID-related credit cycle. I would
highlight commercial real estate and aviation as sectors that
we’re watching carefully. Obviously, we need to continue being
vigilant in our retail portfolios but, by and large, as you’ve heard
us comment on, we’re quite constructive about the credit
outlook, given what we’ve seen so far in this very unusual cycle.
Robert Smalley 	If I could just follow-up. It is an unusual cycle where we’ve had
a huge downturn and rebound in GDP and employment but
credit quality, in a lot of ways, has stayed stable. What does this
do for your modelling going forward and your model-driven
provisioning and how do you adjust for that?

-- 13 of 17 --

14
James von Moltke 	Well, that’s what we talked about last year. We did adjust. So,
two parts to the answer. In respect of last year’s overlay
decisions, we felt good about the approach and, in a sense, we
did adjust our models through those overlays, reducing the pro-
cyclicality in an appropriate way.
Going forward, your question is an interesting one. Are the
models well-calibrated to predict the outcome of unusual cycles
like a share V shape that we saw last year? And, they’re not. So,
of course, as in any market event, we’ve spent time looking at
models, 	back-testing 	our 	models, 	figuring 	out 	what
methodology adjustments there might be to accurately capture
a forward-looking view. I’m not sure what that’s going to leave
us with in terms of changes to the models but, in fairness, a
shape of recession like the one we lived in in the last 12 months
you’d expect to be quite unusual.
Robert Smalley 	Yes, totally agree. Thanks for that and a lot of what you’ve said
over the past 12 months has been borne out, so greatly
appreciate your comments.
James von Moltke 	Thanks, Rob. Appreciate it.
James Hyde 	Hi, James. Hi, Dixit. James, I’m going to the forward the
(PGIM Fixed Income) 	discussion we’ve had every quarter about the provisions but
this time Robert’s question has answered 80% of what I wanted.
I just wanted to clarify. There was a question about this on the
main call by Stuart Graham, I think, and this the table on page
31 of the report regarding the moratoria which shows a figure
of €8.3 billion in one category, €8.2 billion in another, and then
the government support measures.
Now, first of all, does this correspond to the thing that peaked
at about €32 billion, at one stage? I just want to understand that.
Then, there is this text that is a bit confusing saying only €1.2
billion of moratoria are still active. Can you tell us what is really
going on there? Can you compare whether that €32 billion peak
that you once gave moved to, just to understand how much
through the cycle we’re going?
Then, 	another 	question, 	given 	your 	strength, 	focus 	on
commercial real estate, I understand about the sectors you’re
watching and you should know about airlines maybe reasonably
soon, but will you have to keep some generic Stage 2-type
provisions for a long time for CRE given that behavioural
change is clearly going to take place? It’s almost another part of
Robert’s question. Are you going to have to keep a higher level
of Stage 2 for a long time? That’s it, thanks. Sorry, a bit long-
winded.
James von Moltke 	Sure. No worries, James. I don’t actually recognise the €32
billion number that you’re referring to, so we may have to take

-- 14 of 17 --

15
that offline to make sure we align. I believe the disclosure on
page 31 relates to the current balances associated with
moratoria, whether they are today active or were once active.
To the point about where do we see this going, we haven’t, to
date, seen significant cliff effects upon the expiry of moratoria,
which I think is the question people are after. In the ones that
have expired so far and in some cases even gone to voluntary
and then the voluntary has expired, we haven’t seen a dramatic
deterioration in the portfolio performance.
We’ve also talked about forbearance on specific loans and that
has included the commercial real estate sector. Our experience
in those forbearances 	has been quite good. 	Some have
extended forbearance periods which, of course, is not an
unusual 	experience 	but 	we’ve 	also 	seen 	benefits 	from
forbearance as you’ve seen projects or obligors recover and
benefit from the forbearance actions that we took.
If I boil that all down, we continue to be quite comfortable with
those, again I’ll call them cliff edge risks in the portfolio and I’m
not seeing adverse outcomes upon normalisation of credit
extension conditions.
James Hyde 	Thank you very much. Maybe I’ll correspond with Philip on the
€30 billion’ish number and what that compares to. Thanks a lot.
James von Moltke 	Yes, if you could that would be great. Then, on airlines, by the
way, on Stage 2. Yes, it is entirely possible and to be expected
that there may be a more extended period of certain obligors in
Stage 2 before full recovery and, hopefully, the migration
begins to turn in the coming quarters.
James Hyde 	Great. Thank you very much. Thanks.
Jakub Lichwa 	Hi, there. Thanks for having the call. As always, very helpful.
(Goldman Sachs) 	One question, actually, just going back to those unfortunately
legacy instruments. The paper from EBA has come out,
obviously, almost half a year ago. You must have cleared with
the regulator whether these are causing infection risk or not.
Are you able to share with us the outcome of that conversation
today?
Another 	thing, 	just 	a 	little 	bit 	more 	going 	back 	to 	the
performance, well done, first of all, but then you guys are right
now a little bit higher than probably where you wanted to be
with respect to the share of the Investment Bank as a proportion
of your revenues. I think a few years back, you were looking at
about 30%. You’re now a bit over 40%. I guess it is a question a
little bit more for rating agencies, but when you’re speaking with
them do you think you are actually hitting on those points that

-- 15 of 17 --

16
they expect to you. I are on positive outlook from Fitch and S&P,
so I’m just thinking what is the possibility there of moving a
notch higher, getting your Tier 2 into IG category? These would
be my two questions. Thank you.
Dixit Joshi 	Jakub, I’ll take the first and the last. On infection risk, not so
much a direct need for engagement on a bilateral basis. It’s a
function of the transposition into German law of the BRRD,
which for us removes any potential infection risk for these
legacy instruments. So, I think that’s fairly clear.
James von Moltke 	On business mix, it is interesting. What we think we were able
to demonstrate this past quarter was the type of development
that we have been expecting in the Private Bank and the
Corporate Bank and also in Asset Management, where an
ongoing improvement in those businesses’ profitability and
particularly in Private Bank and Corporate Bank, moving to a
point where they can grow revenues while continuing to have
discipline on expenses just, over time, improves the business
mix for the firm.
So, to your point, revenues at the Investment Bank today
represents about 40%. Would it be natural, as we’ve call for, for
it to climb closer to 35%? Sure. And, that would be welcome, in
a sense. We don’t mind outperformance in the Investment Bank
from time to time in positive market conditions, such as we saw
in Q1 but we have been building the firm towards this broader,
perhaps more balanced mix and we think we’re making good
progress in that direction.
Dixit Joshi 	On the question of rating upgrade, we’ve said this a few times
and do feel this way, that we’ve done significant work the
balance sheet through the years, whether that’s been changing
the funding mix, upgrading our deposit and risk models, strong
risk management through the period, strong tilt towards
deposit funding, a reduction on reliance on relatively expensive
capital markets funding, judicious use of excess liquidity that we
had to soak up issuances as you see through this year in terms
of net negative issuance. So, significant balance sheet work
that’s been done over the course of the last years and we do
think that ratings are somewhat lagging versus the significant
work that we’ve done. It’s very much our hope that we do see
an upgrade through time. Again, that’s largely out of our hands
but suffice to say we’ll continue executing as diligently as we
have and especially, from a funding and capital markets
perspective, continue taking actions that are conducive towards
a positive rating. I hope that’s helpful, Jakub.
Jakub Lichwa 	Yes. Thank you.
Philip Teuchner 	Thank you, Emma, and just to finish up, thank you all for joining

-- 16 of 17 --

17
us today. You know where the IR team is if you have further
questions and we look forward to talk to you soon again.
Goodbye.
Disclaimer
This transcript contains forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements are
statements that are not historical facts; they include statements about our beliefs and
expectations and the assumptions underlying them. These statements are based on plans,
estimates and projections as they are currently available to the management of Deutsche
Bank. Forward-looking statements therefore speak only as of the date they are made, and we
undertake no obligation to update publicly any of them in light of new information or future
events.
By their very nature, forward-looking statements involve risks and uncertainties. A number of
important factors could therefore cause actual results to differ materially from those
contained in any forward-looking statement. Such factors include the conditions in the
financial markets in Germany, in Europe, in the United States and elsewhere from which we
derive a substantial portion of our revenues and in which we hold a substantial portion of our
assets, the development of asset prices and market volatility, potential defaults of borrowers
or trading counterparties, the implementation of our strategic initiatives, the reliability of our
risk management policies, procedures and methods, and other risks referenced in our filings
with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Such factors are described in detail in
our SEC Form 20-F of 12 March 2021 under the heading “Risk Factors.” Copies of this
document are readily available upon request or can be downloaded from www.db.com/ir.
This transcript also contains non-IFRS financial measures. For a reconciliation to directly
comparable figures reported under IFRS, to the extent such reconciliation is not provided in
this transcript, refer to the Q1 2021 Financial Data Supplement, which is available at
www.db.com/ir.
This transcript is provided solely for information purposes and shall not be construed as a
solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any securities or other financial instruments in any
jurisdiction. No investment decision relating to securities of or relating to Deutsche Bank AG
or its affiliates should be made on the basis of this document. Please refer to Deutsche Bank’s
annual and interim reports, ad hoc announcements under Article 17 of Regulation (EU) No.
596/2014 and filings with the U.S. Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) under Form 6-K.

-- 17 of 17 --