TRANSCRIPT

Q3 2023 — Fixed income call transcript

Q3 2023PDF · 18 pages158 KB
1
Deutsche Bank AG
Deutsche Bank Q3 2023 Fixed Income Conference Call
Friday, 27 October 2023 | 15:00 CEST
Transcript
Speakers:
James von Moltke, Chief Financial Officer
Richard Stewart, Group Treasurer
Philip Teuchner, Investor Relations

-- 1 of 18 --

2
RICHARD STEWART
Slide 1 – 2023 YTD results reflect resilient performance
- Thank you, Philip, and welcome from me
- It’s a pleasure to be discussing our results with you today which show
continued progress on the path to our targets in several respects
- Let me start with the key highlights of our resilient performance over the
first nine months on slide 1
- We delivered operating leverage of 4% on an adjusted basis, with
revenues up 6% and adjusted costs up 2%
- As a result, our pre-provision profit for the first nine months was up 5%
year on year to 6 billion euros
- Our post-tax RoTE was 7%, and would have been nearly 9%, excluding
nonoperating costs and with bank levies apportioned equally across the
year. This reflects progress on our path to meet our 2025 target of above
10%
- In addition, we continue to reap the benefits of disciplined risk
management and a high quality loan book: provision for credit losses for
the first nine months remained in line with our full year guidance, at 28
basis points of average loans
Slide 2 – Balanced revenue mix and continued franchise growth
- Let me now discuss the growth and balance across our business, on slide
2
- The Corporate Bank delivered a post-tax RoTE of 17% over the past nine
months. Strong revenue growth, combined with flat adjusted costs
driven by tight expense discipline, produced operating leverage of 24%
- Our momentum with key clients is encouraging: we saw an increase of
around 40 percent in incremental deals won with multinational corporate
clients which will drive future revenues
- In the Investment Bank we have a well-diversified business portfolio,
supported by our leading Financing business which contributed 2.2
billion euros, or approximately 35% of FIC revenues, year-to-date

-- 2 of 18 --

3
- Turning to the Private Bank, the business grew revenues, attracted
inflows of 22 billion euros supported by new money campaigns, and
made further progress in streamlining our distribution channels
- Finally, we also grew volumes in Asset Management
- Assets under Management grew by 38 billion euros, including 17 billion
euros of net inflows in the first nine months of 2023, driven by strong
inflows into Passive, including Xtrackers
- To sum up: we delivered revenues of 28.5 billion euros in the last twelve
months, up over 6% versus the equivalent prior period. We also see
forward momentum from net inflows, investments, and business wins
with key clients. Our businesses are strongly complementary and well
balanced
- All of this supports our view that we will continue to grow our franchise
and exceed our revenue growth targets
Slide 3 – Continued accelerated execution of strategic agenda
- Now let me turn to the progress we’re making to accelerate the execution
of our Global Hausbank strategy, on slide 3
- With a compound annual revenue growth rate of 6.9% over 2021, we are
well on track to outperform on our revenue growth target of 3.5 to 4.5%
- And we will continue to benefit from the higher rate environment which
drives sustainable performance in the Private Bank and Corporate Bank
- We continue to make progress with further initiatives that are expected
to drive fee income
- We are confident that the new entity ‘Deutsche Numis’ will enable us to
take added advantage of an expected pickup in corporate finance
activity
- With 38 billion euros of net asset inflows in the first nine months, we
expect the growth of our assets under management to drive fee income
in future quarters
- On operational efficiencies: our existing savings measures are largely
proceeding in line with or ahead of plan. This includes streamlining of
front-to-back processes and headcount management. We are also
optimizing our distribution network, and have reduced branches by more
than 90 over the first nine months of 2023

-- 3 of 18 --

4
- This enabled us to keep our adjusted costs essentially flat compared to
the prior year quarter, despite absorbing inflationary pressures and
investments in growth and controls. And we continue to work on further
measures
Slide 4 – Strong deposit momentum
- Slide 4 provides further details on the development in our loan and
deposit books over the quarter
- All figures in the commentary are adjusted for FX effects
- Loans have been essentially flat across businesses during the third
quarter as well as on a year-on-year basis
- Underlying this yearly trend, loans have declined due to lower client
demand in interest rate sensitive segments as well as due to more
targeted and selective balance sheet deployments, offset by focused
growth in FIC
- On deposits, we have seen significant inflows of 14 billion euros or 2% in
the quarter
- This was driven by a strong client re-engagement in institutional
segments following the market events in the first quarter, resulting in a
stable year-on-year trend
- This trend has been particularly pronounced in the Corporate Bank,
where we saw growth primarily in term deposits
- In the Private Bank, deposits remained essentially flat as inflows in the
International Private Bank were partially offset by outflows in the German
retail business due to continued macroeconomic headwinds
- For the remainder of the year, we expect a stabilization in our deposit
book around current levels and materially above the previously
communicated 600 billion euros guidance, as recent growth in term
deposits exceeded our previous forecasts
Slide 5 – Stable businesses maintain deposit margins
- Moving to the net interest margin development on slide 5
- Average interest earning assets were up 6 billion driven by the recovery
in deposit balances in the third quarter

-- 4 of 18 --

5
- At the group level NIM is down 12 basis points of which approximately 5
basis points relate to accounting effects held in the corporate center
which are offset in non-interest revenues and have no impact on total
revenue. This is the same effect we discussed with you in the first quarter
- Net interest margin in the Corporate Bank declined by approximately 25
basis points due to lower lending income and a higher cost of liquidity
reserves. However, net interest income on the corporate deposit books
remained strong in the quarter
- Net interest margin in the Private Bank remained broadly stable in the
third quarter with increased mortgage hedging costs offsetting the
ongoing strong margins in the deposit books
- Overall, our deposit betas continue to outperform our models and we
expect NII to remain broadly stable in the fourth quarter
Slide 6 – Sound liquidity and funding base
- Moving to slide 6, highlighting the development of our key liquidity
metrics
- The liquidity coverage ratio at quarter-end was at 132% due to pro-active
steering towards our target level and in line with our previously
communicated guidance
- The daily average LCR over the last 3 months has even slightly increased
to 136%, demonstrating our sound liquidity profile
- The stock of 210 billion euros HQLA, which is mainly held in cash and
Level 1 securities, has increased by 6 billion euros, reflecting the strong
deposit growth in the third quarter
- The surplus above the regulatory minimum slightly decreased by about
4 billion euros to 51 billion euros quarter on quarter, mainly driven by
almost 7 billion euros of TLTRO repayments, including the early
prepayment of 3 billion euros maturing in December 2023
- For the fourth quarter we remain committed to support growth in the
business while aiming to maintain the LCR around the 130% target level
- The net stable funding ratio was slightly up quarter on quarter to 121%,
again mainly reflecting the strong momentum in our deposit book
- This represents a surplus of about 105 billion euros above the regulatory
requirement

-- 5 of 18 --

6
- The available longer-term stable funding sources for the bank remain
well diversified and are supported by a robust deposit franchise, which
continues contributing about two thirds to the Group’s stable funding
sources
- Targeted deposit campaigns in the Private Bank as well as strong deposit
momentum in the Corporate Bank also supported our NSFR
- We aim to maintain our funding mix in 2024, with the remaining TLTRO
of 15 billion euros being gradually replaced and we note that we do not
have further material TLTRO repayments this year
Slide 7 – CET1 ratio increase due to optimization initiatives
- Turning to capital on slide 7
- Our third quarter Common Equity Tier 1 ratio came in at 13.9%, a 19 basis
points increase compared to the previous quarter
- Regulatory changes, principally from the go-live of newly approved
wholesale and retail models, resulted in a decline of 38 basis points,
slightly below the low end of our previous guidance
- Optimization initiatives generated 27 basis points from lower Credit Risk
RWA, principally reflecting improvements in our data and certain process
changes
- A further 19 basis points of ratio support came from diligent risk
management in our businesses
- And a 11 basis points increase came from strong organic capital
generation, that is net income, offset by deductions for the share buy-
back, dividends and AT1 coupons
Slide 8 – Effective capital management driving improved outlook
- As mentioned, regulatory changes led to a reduction of 38 basis points in
our Common Equity Tier 1 ratio
- With the go-live of the newly approved wholesale and retail models, the
ECB has completed the review of approximately 85% of the relevant
portfolio, and we expect only limited ratio impact from the remainder
- In the first quarter of this year we announced a targeted 15 to 20 billion
euros RWA reduction by the end of 2025 through several capital
optimization initiatives

-- 6 of 18 --

7
- We accelerated some of the data and process optimization initiatives into
the third quarter which brings the cumulative RWA reductions to date to
10 billion euros
- The work we have done over the past several months gives us the
confidence to increase the original target by 10 billion euros to 25 to 30
billion euros
- Lastly, let me touch on our Basel III estimates
- The latest review of our impact assessments indicates an RWA increase
of only around 15 billion euros versus 25 to 30 billion euros we had
previously guided
- The majority of the improvement comes from lower Market and Credit
Valuation Risk charges delivered out of the FRTB transformation
program
- Credit risk estimates are still under review and remain dependent on final
CRR3 legislative text
- Overall, let me highlight that estimates are based on our interpretation of
current draft regulation and therefore remain subject to change
Slide 9 – Capital ratios well above regulatory requirements
- Our capital ratios remain well above regulatory requirements as shown
on slide 9
- The CET 1 MDA buffer now stands at 278 basis points or 10 billion euros
of CET1 capital
- The quarter on quarter increase of 16 basis points reflects a 19 basis
points higher CET1 capital ratio and a 3 basis point reduction from a
higher countercyclical capital buffer in the United Kingdom
- Our total capital MDA buffer further increased due to lower RWA
reducing our AT1 and T2 capital requirements; it now stands at 300 basis
points
Slide 10 – Leverage ratio at a stable level
- Moving to slide 10
- At the end of the third quarter our leverage ratio stood at a comfortable
4.7%, flat to the previous quarter

-- 7 of 18 --

8
- A 2 basis points decline was due to lower Tier 1 capital, in line with CET1
capital movement
- A 6 basis points increase of the leverage ratio resulted from lower
leverage exposure driven primarily by a regulatory clarification on the
treatment of specific cash pooling structures
- FX effects contributed a 3 basis points decline
Slide 11 – Continued high loss-absorbing capacity
- We continue to operate with a significant loss-absorbing capacity, well
above all our requirements, as shown on slide 11
- The MREL surplus, our most binding constraint, increased by 5 billion
euros to 17 billion euros over the quarter
- This includes an increase of 3 billion euros from higher eligible liabilities
and own funds and an increase of 1 billion euros from lower RWA net of
the increase in the countercyclical capital buffer requirement in the
United Kingdom
- Our loss-absorbing capacity buffer stands at a comfortable level and
continues to provide us with the flexibility to pause issuing new Eligible
Liabilities instruments for approximately one year
Slide 12 – Issuance plan almost complete
- Moving now to our issuance plan on slide 12
- With year-to-date issuance of 13 billion euros, we have largely completed
our issuance plan for 2023. We expect our full year issuance volume to
land in the 14 to 16 billion euro range
- Issuance this quarter will be in senior preferred and covered bond format,
both relatively inexpensive sources of funding for the bank
- It is too early to provide concrete guidance regarding our 2024 issuance
plan but depending on market conditions, we may consider some pre-
funding of 2024 requirements during the fourth quarter
- You may have seen our announcement on 11th October of a consent
solicitation for our 4.789% USD AT1 security
- This transaction endeavours to transition the coupon reset mechanism
from IBOR swaps to SOFR swaps. To encourage investor participation,
we are paying a fee of 50 cents

-- 8 of 18 --

9
- In the event the transaction fails, we expect the security’s fallback
language to result in the usage of the last available fixing of 4.201%. We
note that this fixing is below current and forward rates for the next reset
date in April 2025
- The registration and instruction deadline is on the 31st October, followed
by the voting period from the 1st to 3rd November. On 6th November,
we will either announce the results or convene an adjourned meeting
Slide 13 – Summary & outlook
- Before going to your questions let me conclude with a summary on slide
13
- We remain focused on delivering positive operating leverage, as we drive
our revenue growth initiatives and execute our cost reduction measures
- We now expect full year 2023 revenues to be around 29 billion euros
- Provision for credit losses is expected at the upper end of the 25 to 30
basis points range of average loans for the full year
- Our balance sheet proved its resilience with a deposit increase to well
above 600 billion euros
- And finally, our capital position and outlook has substantially improved
through RWA measures we have implemented
- With that, let us turn to your questions
Question & Answer Session
Brajesh Kumar Team, hi. Thanks for doing this call. Brajesh from Soc
(Societe Generale) Gen. I've got three questions, if I may. The first one on
net interest income. Can you explain why group NII has
not moved much over the whole year, in fact? Also, how
should we think about NII 2023 going forward? Second,
on issuance, Richard, I know you talked about increased
senior issuance plan, but why are we including senior
specifically? And talking about prefunding for FY 24,
any particular capitalplan you have? Finally, given your
improved capital outlook, can you give us some update
around your capital distribution plans? That’s it from
me.

-- 9 of 18 --

10
Richard Stewart Thanks very much for the question and thank you for
joining on a Friday, almost the weekend. The NII
question first of all. At a group level reported NII is
heavily impacted by our use of derivates to hedge our
cross currency and basis risk by our trading books,
particularly rates derivates. These positions can create a
symmetry between accounting net interest income and
non-interest revenues, which are flat at total revenue
level. And the size of the offsets varies depending on
market conditions.
This offset between accounting classification for our
hedging is kept in our corporate centre to allow a clean
economic view of the NII in our Private Bank and
Corporate Bank segments. As you can see, the NII in
these two businesses is up about €2 billion in the nine
months year-to-date when compared to the equivalent
period last year. We expect to see NII relatively flat in
both businesses in the fourth quarter, as the underlying
deposit NII in both segments remained strong in this
year and also in Q3 and betas continue to outperform our
models.
We do expect betas to converge over the course of 2024,
resulting in a modest decline in net interest income, but
a much smaller magnitude than the increase we've seen
over the last two years. So, a bit of an accounting
conversation there, but hopefully the overlying trend is
clear to you.
On the issuance side of things, if I understood correctly,
why senior? It's a combination of both senior and
covered bonds, but it's just to complete our issuance
plan for this year. That's the spot we should think is the
sweetest from a funding perspective. Then in terms of
guidance, I think we just want to make sure, why would
no decision be made around what we might do for any
prefunding. We obviously are always opportunistic, as
markets allow. But as we go through our planning
process for 2024, we see what the shape of the balance
sheet looks like, we may take an opportunity in Q4. We
just didn't want you guys to be surprised by that.
The last question, outlook for next year, I think was your
question. There again, as we just go through that
planning process, we haven't really formulated a view as

-- 10 of 18 --

11
to what our needs will be for next year. But I guess the
guide will be that you've seen in the last few years, which
is somewhere between 15 billion to 20 billion, if I had to
put a gun to my head today. But again, we'll refine that
as we go through our planning process. That’s that we’re
thinking to ourselves. I'll note also that, as you are all
familiar with, we don't have any Tier 1 or Tier 2 calls next
year either, so just to reiterate that point.
Then on the capital distribution plans, your last question.
As we have mentioned in our analyst call on Wednesday,
we see outlook improvements regarding capital
efficiency, which we expect to free up an additional €3
billion of capital from now through 2025. The RWA
optimisation efforts came out better than expected,
along with that improved outlook. We continue to be in
discussions with the regulator regarding a revised
capital plan. And subject to that dialogue, we would
expect a good proportion of the incremental capital to be
distributed.
At the same time, we continue our strategy to invest in
growth and fee-related revenue businesses across
divisions. Our technology investments are already
paying off and we do believe that we have a market-
leading position in many areas, such as payments. I hope
that gives you a bit of visibility as to what we’re thinking.
Brajesh Kumar Sure, thanks. Very clear.
Daniel David Good afternoon. Congratulations on the results and
(Autonomous) thanks for taking my questions, I've got three. The first
one is just on the US office CRE. I know that it was stated
at about 5 billion in Q1 and that’s gone up to 8 billion.
Can you comment on what’s driven the increase? The
second one is just on CET1. I note that the expected loss
deduction in CET1 jumped from half a billion in Q2 to 2
billion in Q3, but that looks like it's been compensated by
the deduction which has dropped from 1.1 billion to 0.3
billion. Can you just comment on what’s driving that and
is that CRE related as well? And then finally, just to round
off on the CRE. You've got 5.7 billion of modified US CRE
loans. Would these by Stage 2 and is the modified
classification similar to criticised as the US banks report?
Thanks.

-- 11 of 18 --

12
James von Moltke Daniel, thank you for your questions. It's James here. On
the US office, first of all, we went through what I'd call a
redefinition of the disclosure we were providing at the
middle of the year to try to give you a clearer view of what
is non-recourse, how does it compare to the NACE
disclosure, and then what within that is CRE and within
CRE, US and US office. And in that redefinition we,
among other things, redefined what we used to call a
focus portfolio, now we’re referring to it as our stress test
portfolio.
The increases were, among other things, just a wider
perimeter lens, if you like, that we were looking at. We
were particularly focused on IB before and we expanded
that perimeter lens, if you like, include Corporate Bank,
but also other corporate portfolios. That redefinition
gives you a higher level of US office exposure. It's not
connected to the expected loss number, the shortfall
that you're referring to, so it's not a CRE issue. I refer to
it as a recognition of some double count between the
models that have now been updated to reflect the
approved models, so the retail wholesale models.
Finding some double count between what those models
are now capturing and the EL numbers previously,
including for non-performing exposures.
Then on the 5.7 billion, it's a mixture of Stage 2 and
Stage 3. So, it's not all in Stage 3 because some of those
loans are performing when they’re modified or
extended, so the definition of a portfolio that is in that
5.7 doesn’t neatly fit into the IFRS staging.
Daniel David Thanks for the detail, I appreciate it.
James von Moltke Thank you.
Robert Smalley Hi. Thanks very much for doing the call and taking my
(UBS) questions.
I have three today. First on asset quality, it seems that
changes in provisioning, the swing factor is more model
driven that anything else. From that, can we imply that
your bottom-up type of analysis still isn't focusing on any
particular set of credits or credits that are an issue, and
it is just model driven that's causing changes in the
provision. If you can take out the microscope, are there
any microtrends in there that you're starting to see

-- 12 of 18 --

13
provision wise?
Secondly, on Tier 2, you mentioned that there's no Tier 2
maturities next year. Your Tier 2 spreads are
considerably wider than your peers. Can you say that
you won't do any Tier 2 issuance next year and maybe
that could be helpful in tightening that up? Then third,
looking out a little bit further, on the MMR, the
mandatory reserve requirements that the ECB is talking
about, talking about raising that. There's no
remuneration for that now, they changed that to zero.
Could you talk about the impact on net interest income
there and on liquidity, given you can't use that on the
LCR calculation? And I realise it's early days and we don't
have numbers, but just wanted to get a feel on what you
were thinking and if this in negotiation with the ECB or
are they still thinking it over there? Thank you.
James von Moltke Thanks, Robert. Thank you for joining us this afternoon,
as well. Yes, the answer is it was all model driven, the
release in Stage 2. By the way, the 100 million was both
the net and the gross, I would tell you. There was some
additional Stage 2 improvement from forward-looking
indicators offset by portfolio parameters in the quarter,
but the net was the same as the model-driven release.
And I'd, by the way, also highlight that the allowance
remains 5.7 billion. It didn't actually change a great deal
what our allowance looks like.
In terms of bottoms up, there wasn’t any noteworthy
changes in the portfolio in the quarter. If I think about,
for example, the upgrade, downgrade activity, forward-
looking metrics in the portfolio, there really wasn’t
anything to note. I would characterise it as a quarter in
which the microtrends, as you say, were essentially
stable to maybe slightly improving over the quarter.
Which is encouraging, given where we are in the credit
cycle. I'll leave Richard with the other two questions you
asked.
Richard Stewart This question was on Tier 2, then I'll take the MRR
question. Tier 2, again, we’re still working through that
funding plan as I mentioned, so I wouldn't rule it out. I
think in previous years we've done a billion to a billion-
and-a-half in prior years. No decision’s been made, as we
just work out what the shape of the balance sheet looks

-- 13 of 18 --

14
like for next year. What I would say is around your idea
about tightening the spread, just given where things are,
obviously that’s something which we’re cognisant of. I
think interestingly enough, when we issued our dollar
Tier 2 back in February, it actually tightened the Tier 2
market rate, so I think that's something else that we have
to think through.
On the MRR side of things, take it a few different ways.
As we mentioned at the last FI call, the move that was
announced, zero to 1% move impacted us around 50
million in revenue per quarter. I think it's more the
authorities will come to their own decision. But I think
we, along with our peers, are pointing out that the impact
of what these decisions actually mean from both a
liquidity perspective and also an interest rate risk
management perspective. As you can imagine, we’re
pretty vocal around whether this is an appropriate form
of monetary policy. The impact on liquidity is the fact
that we have to withdraw the reserve requirements
against our liquidity, so we’d have to replace that
liquidity for every 1% change, to put things in
perspective. If the LR was moved by 1% or something,
that would have a commensurate impact on our HQLA
Holdings, which will need to be replaced.
Robert Smalley Thank you very much for the detail from everyone and
again, thank you for doing the call. Greatly appreciate it.
Lee Street Hello. Good afternoon, all, and thank you for taking my
(Citi) questions, I have two. Firstly, on slide 11. Just to
envisage shifting round the mix of preferred senior and
non-preferred senior uses of MREL and TLAC
compliance or do you think that'll stay in line of where we
are currently?
Secondly, I think you were quite clear saying that you
expect most of your additional conduct to Tier 1 to be
used for capital return. The amounts that aren't used for
that, in which divisions would you be looking to deploy
that? Or to put the question another way, divisionally,
where do you see the best return on your marginal unit
of capital, to the extent you're going to extend your
capital across your divisions at the current time? That’d
be my two questions. Thank you very much.

-- 14 of 18 --

15
Richard Stewart I think in terms of issuance shift, it's relatively simple.
We'll see it as a similar mix to next year’s as previous
years. The uplift we get from the LGF methodology from
Moody’s, for example, and where we are with capital
means that we probably need less SNP at the margin
and senior preferred we still see as an attractive source
of funding. But we’re not seeing a substantial change in
our mix going forward.
James von Moltke Lee, in terms of where to put the capital to work, we look
at it both by externally reported segments, but within
those segments, at a more granular portfolio level. What
I would say is that in terms of the mix of business, our
capital allocation is trying to move capital to the
Corporate Bank and the Private Bank, in particular. But
they're in essence constrained by the market
opportunity, so the ability to lend within our risk appetite
and thereby, grow risk weighted assets, really is the
thing that drives their capital usage, and we want them
to grow within that risk appetite.
We’re also supporting the Asset Management business
with additional capital, for example seed funding for new
investment strategies and products, so there's some
amount that goes to Asset Management. Where we
attempt to manage and, if you like, constrain capital from
an allocation perspective is the Investment Bank. That's
a business mix call, but also a discipline call because it's
a business in which you can, in a sense, put unlimited
capital to work and you need to preserve that discipline.
What’s really gratifying is the business embraces that.
Under Fabrizio, Ram and Mark’s leadership they
absolute, and their teams embrace the ideas around
efficiency of deployment. And as I say, at a more
granular portfolio level where we look at it, so within the
businesses, there can be capital allocation and efficiency
measures below the reported segment.
The one other thing I would just add, I think you started
your question with a reference to AT1. We look at the use
or the deployment of the leverage balance sheet, as well
as the risk weighted asset balance sheet. We look at that
comprehensively and obviously the greatest degree of
flexibility in terms of committing leverage resources
within the envelope that we’re comfortable with is
typically in the Investment Bank. Hopefully that captures

-- 15 of 18 --

16
your question totally.
Lee Street That is very helpful. Thank you both.
James von Moltke Thanks, Lee.
Adam Terelak Afternoon, all. I thought I'd take some time outside of the
(Mediobanca) equity quarter, ask on a different topic, and that's the
digital euro. We've been asking all the banks in Europe
around what they see as the risks, the opportunities from
the implementation of digital euro, so we just wanted to
get both of your thoughts on that, as well as what’s
baked into your forward planning at this stage or
whether it's a bit too early to say. Thank you.
James von Moltke Adam, thanks for the question. It's a topic that, by the
way, it's James again, interests me as well intensely. In
short answer to your last part of the question is really
nothing built into the forward plan. It's too early to think
about timing and specific impact implications of a digital
euro.
But if I take the question in a few parts, first of all, there
is a pretty high degree of engagement, certainly that we
at Deutsche Bank engage in, both directly and through
industry fora on this topic. One is, by the way, at the CFO
level. I and a group of my peers have been quite
engaged, but also Christian and his peers at an
association level quite engaged with the authorities on
this topic. We recognise that it's both an opportunity for
the financial sector, for Europe, for the sovereignty of
the euro, and a risk to the sector.
As you can imagine, we’re very vocal in pointing out
where we see the risks, including to liquidity in stress, to
the business model of banking in payments. To the
extent that, in essence, private market solutions are
displaced by official sector solutions. And conceivably to
credit formation. If you basically take the banks out of
the business of money creation and credit formation,
you're potentially unleashing some forces on the
economy that are hard to predict. There are a number of,
as I say, opportunities and risks that we see associated
with the digital euro, and we’re very engaged in that
dialogue.

-- 16 of 18 --

17
By the way, that's true looking both at the digital euro
from a retail perspective and from a wholesale
perspective. In fairness, we see a lot of use cases in
wholesale, in particular, which we would embrace. In
retail, it's interesting exactly what the use cases are that
improve on the world as it is today. In either case, I just
want to be clear, we are supportive, certainly as a firm
and we think as an industry, of the initiative. But we think
the initiative needs to be very carefully crafted and
constrained, in order to avoid some of the unintended
consequences around liquidity, credit formation, and
what have you. I hope, Adam, that captures the essence
of the question you had.
Adam Terelak Just one follow-up would be on the cost of
implementation.
James von Moltke Again, too early to say. In fairness, we’re investing a ton
in our payments platforms as things stand, so I would
think of it as really just a diversion of or channelling of
money that we spend anyway on payment systems,
rather than in increment. We’re also investing in the
European Payments Initiative as a shareholder and some
of that investment would go through industry platforms,
rather than directly through us. But again, today it
wouldn’t be a feature in our planning, so much as in the
future, when it's more clear exactly what the system
would look like. I will say the payment space is changing
all the time.
As you know, this year was the implementation of
ISO20022, so a pretty big payment system initiative
went through the industry already this year. Just to give
you an example, in any given period there's a fair amount
of work going on, on the technology side by the banking
industry to support the evolution of the payment
infrastructure in the world. That’s something we’re very
committed to, given it's a very core part of the service we
provide to the economy and our clients.
Adam Terelak Brilliant. Much more than I was expecting, thank you.
James von Moltke Thank you, Adam, appreciate the question.

-- 17 of 18 --

18
Disclaimer
This transcript contains forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements are statements
that are not historical facts; they include statements about our beliefs and expectations and the
assumptions underlying them. These statements are based on plans, estimates and projections as
they are currently available to the management of Deutsche Bank. Forward-looking statements
therefore speak only as of the date they are made, and we undertake no obligation to update publicly
any of them in light of new information or future events.
By their very nature, forward-looking statements involve risks and uncertainties. A number of
important factors could therefore cause actual results to differ materially from those contained in
any forward-looking statement. Such factors include the conditions in the financial markets in
Germany, in Europe, in the United States and elsewhere from which we derive a substantial portion
of our revenues and in which we hold a substantial portion of our assets, the development of asset
prices and market volatility, potential defaults of borrowers or trading counterparties, the
implementation of our strategic initiatives, the reliability of our risk management policies,
procedures and methods, and other risks referenced in our filings with the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission. Such factors are described in detail in our SEC Form 20-F of 17 March 2023
under the heading “Risk Factors.” Copies of this document are readily available upon request or can
be downloaded from investor-relations.db.com.
This transcript also contains non-IFRS financial measures. For a reconciliation to directly
comparable figures reported under IFRS, to the extent such reconciliation is not provided in this
transcript, refer to the Q3 2023 Financial Data Supplement, which is available at investor-
relations.db.com.
This transcript is provided solely for information purposes and shall not be construed as a solicitation
of an offer to buy or sell any securities or other financial instruments in any jurisdiction. No
investment decision relating to securities of or relating to Deutsche Bank AG or its affiliates should
be made on the basis of this document. Please refer to Deutsche Bank’s annual and interim reports,
ad hoc announcements under Article 17 of Regulation (EU) No. 596/2014 and filings with the U.S.
Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) under Form 6-K.

-- 18 of 18 --