TRANSCRIPT

Q3 2024 — Transcript

Q3 2024PDF · 40 pages245 KB
1
Deutsche Bank AG
Deutsche Bank Q3 2024 Analyst Conference Call
Wednesday, 23rd October 2024 | 11:00 CEST
Transcript
Speakers:
Christian Sewing, Chief Executive Officer
James von Moltke, Chief Financial Officer
Ioana Patriniche, Head of Investor Relations

-- 1 of 40 --

2
CHRISTIAN SEWING
Slide 2 – Strong 9M performance provides confidence in full-year ambitions
- Thank you, Ioana, and a warm welcome from me
- I’m delighted to be discussing our third-quarter and nine-month results
with you today. These show our ongoing strong operating performance,
further reinforcing our confidence in our 2024 ambitions and 2025
financial targets
- I’m particularly pleased that our continued, intense client engagement
has supported momentum in all businesses. This enabled us to
generate revenues of 22.9 billion euros in the first nine months, putting
us well on track towards our goal of 30 billion euros for the year
- We recorded the third successive quarter of adjusted costs at 5 billion
euros, in line with our 2024 guidance, underpinning our forward
trajectory
- We are pleased with the settlements we achieved in August and
September in the Postbank takeover litigation matter, equivalent to
around 60% of the total claims by value. This resulted in a litigation
release that supported our reported pre-tax profit of 2.3 billion euros,
up over 500 million euros year on year, and our reported post-tax return
on tangible equity of 10.2% in the third quarter
- For the first nine months, our reported RoTE stood at 6%. Excluding the
Postbank takeover litigation-related impact, RoTE was 7.8%, up from
7% in the prior year period
- Asset quality remains stable, despite the sequential increase in our
provision for credit losses, which James will go through in more detail
- Importantly, we expect provisions to reduce towards more normalized
levels going forward, particularly in expectation of improvements in
Commercial Real Estate over the next quarters
- Our CET1 ratio of 13.8% reflects our strong organic capital generation
- This puts us on a clear path to distribute capital to our shareholders as
planned, and we have now sought authorization from the ECB for our
next share buyback
- Let me now discuss in more detail some of the drivers of our nine-
month results on slide 3

-- 2 of 40 --

3
Slide 3 – Disciplined execution driving continuously improving performance
- Disciplined execution of our Global Hausbank strategy is driving
steadily improving performance and operating leverage
- Pre-provision profit grew by 17% year on year to 7 billion euros in the
first nine months, with operating leverage of 5%, both excluding the
Postbank takeover litigation-related impact
- Growth was driven by both revenue momentum and cost discipline
- Nine-month revenues grew 3% year on year with around 75% of
revenues coming from more predictable income streams
- Reported noninterest revenues were up 14% year on year, with
continued strong growth in commissions and fee income of 9%. This
demonstrates that our strategy of growing our capital-light businesses
is paying off
- At the same time, net interest income in our key banking book
segments remained stable, and better than anticipated at the beginning
of the year
- We remain focused on expense discipline, keeping our adjusted costs to
15.1 billion euros, or 5 billion per quarter, as we continue to offset
inflation while allowing for investments by delivering savings from our
Operational Efficiency program
- Our cost/income ratio excluding Postbank litigation-related impacts
improved to 69% from 73% year on year
- Now let’s look at the franchise achievements across our businesses, on
slide 4
Slide 4 – Ongoing momentum across businesses through focused growth
strategies
- The Corporate Bank increased the number of deals won with
multinational clients by 18% compared to the first nine months of the
prior year
- We also had strong momentum in commissions and fee income, which
grew by 5% across all regions
- At the same time, NII remained resilient, supported by continued
pricing discipline and deposit growth of 8% year on year
- In the Investment Bank, we increased activity so far this year with our
priority institutional clients by 11%, demonstrating the ongoing

-- 3 of 40 --

4
commitment and focus of our business and coverage teams in
supporting our clients
- Nine-month revenues in Fixed Income & Currencies were up 5% year on
year, supported by a 5% increase in Financing revenues, even
compared to a strong prior year; looking at the third quarter, FIC
demonstrated a strong performance and was up by 11% year on year
- Origination & Advisory grew revenues by 58% and increased its global
market share year to date compared to the full year 2023, while we
maintained our number one ranking in our home market
- The Private Bank sees further momentum with 27 billion euros of net
inflows, and grew noninterest revenues by 5% year on year, driven by
higher margin products and volumes across both client segments
- The division continues to transform its Personal Banking unit with
around 50 branch closures year to date and more to come. The
business also announced a further optimization of our Deutsche Bank
branch network in the quarter, which will start next year
- Asset Management grew assets under management by 67 billion euros
year to date to 963 billion euros. This was boosted by continued strong
inflows into our diverse product suite, which should support future
revenues
- The Group also made progress on its sustainability strategy including
ESG rating upgrades. In October, S&P’s Corporate Sustainability
Assessment was upgraded to 66 and is now within the top decile of the
financial industry. The MSCI rating was upgraded to AA from A
- Let me turn to our progress against our strategic objectives on slide 5
Slide 5 – Continued execution across strategic pillars
- Our third quarter results demonstrate our continued progress across all
three pillars of our Global Hausbank strategy
- Starting with revenue growth, our well-diversified and complementary
business mix delivered a compound annual growth rate of 5.6% since
2021, in line with our upgraded target range, and we expect it to
increase from here
- For the remainder of the year, we anticipate continued momentum in
commissions and fee income driven by ongoing high client engagement
and our franchise strength, while NII remains stable

-- 4 of 40 --

5
- This gives us full confidence in reaching our revenue ambition of 30
billion euros for the full-year 2024, providing a strong step-off into 2025
- Moving to costs, we continue to deliver on our Operational Efficiency
program, having completed measures with delivered or expected gross
savings of 1.7 billion euros, almost 70% of our target, with around 1.5
billion euros in savings already realized
- We have made further progress on workforce reductions, including 600
FTEs in the third quarter, bringing the total number to more than 90%
of the 2024 year-end target
- The achieved progress to date and efficiencies still in the pipeline will
support our adjusted cost run rate for the remainder of 2024 and
further reductions in 2025 to meet our objective of around 20 billion
euros in noninterest expenses, while continuing to invest in business
growth, technology and controls
- Lastly, we delivered a further benefit of 3 billion euros of RWA
equivalent reductions in the third quarter, driven by data and process
improvements. This brings total RWA equivalent reductions from
capital efficiency measures to 22 billion euros, which puts us in sight of
our end-2025 target range of 25 to 30 billion euros, more than one year
early
- We expect to achieve further reductions from securitizations as well as
data and process enhancements, and we continue to work on finding
further incremental optimization opportunities to exceed our target
- Let me conclude with a few words on our strategy, on slide 6
Slide 6 – Global Hausbank strategy continues to deliver growth and
profitability on the path to long-term ambitions
- Our operating performance in the first nine months shows that our
Global Hausbank strategy positions us well to serve our clients’ needs
and continues to deliver growth and profitability. We have firm
confidence in reaching a RoTE of at least 10% next year
- To be clear, our focus remains on us, our strategy and financial targets,
unlocking further value for shareholders through the measures we have
underway
- Looking at revenues into 2025, we expect continued franchise
momentum and our capital-light businesses to drive further growth,
harvesting investments we have made and are still making

-- 5 of 40 --

6
- In the Corporate Bank, we expect further growth in commissions and
fee income from our investments in our fee-based institutional
business, as well as our payments platform
- FIC is expected to show further improvement into next year, benefitting
from our investments into the franchise, in both existing and adjacent
businesses, as well as continued strength in Financing
- In O&A, we have a clear value proposition to our clients, supported by
our investments, which should help us to further increase our market
share in what we expect to be a growing market environment, with
further benefit of new hires still to come
- At the same time, the Private Bank anticipates growing noninterest
income, mainly from investment products predominantly in Wealth
Management & Private Banking, further supported by NII
- Within our Asset Management business, we expect to benefit from
higher assets under management levels this year, which should lead to
an increase in management fees in 2025. Additionally, we anticipate
positive flows into the Alternatives business and continued growth in
Passive, including X-trackers
- These drivers underline our confidence in achieving our revenue goal of
32 billion euros in 2025
- Turning to costs, we have taken decisive actions to put legacy items
behind us, substantially reducing our risk profile, and driving
restructuring measures in order to clear the path to 2025, and we
continue to focus on controls to future-proof the franchise, which will
help us reduce nonoperating costs
- The delivery of operational efficiencies is expected to further reduce
adjusted costs over the coming quarters
- Together, we are confident these measures will bring us on a path to
around 20 billion euros of noninterest expenses in 2025, which will also
support delivery of robust operating leverage
- We expect credit costs to reduce towards more normalized levels in
2025, largely driven by the expected continuation of the positive
development for CRE provisions and the benefits of interest rate
reductions flowing through into the economy, providing us with a much
cleaner slate into 2025
- We remain dedicated to creating value for our shareholders and
confident that with achieving our financial targets, we can also maintain
our trajectory to increase distributions beyond our original goal of 8
billion euros in respect of the financial years 2021 to 2025

-- 6 of 40 --

7
- Given this continued progress, we have now sought authorization from
the ECB for our next share buyback
- To sum up, we remain focused on our Global Hausbank strategy, and
with our business momentum and all the progress made, we have clear
line of sight on our target of a RoTE of greater than 10% for 2025
- With that, let me hand over to James
JAMES VON MOLTKE
Slide 8 – Key performance indicators
- Thank you, Christian and good morning
- As usual, let me start with a few key performance indicators on slide 8,
and place them in the context of our 2025 targets
- As Christian mentioned before, we are on track towards our objectives,
and we expect further improvements over the coming quarters
- Our liquidity metrics also remained strong; the liquidity coverage ratio
was 135%, above our target of around 130%, and the net stable funding
ratio was 122%
- In short, our performance in the period reaffirms our franchise strength
and our confidence in reaching the 2025 targets
- With that let me turn to the third-quarter highlights on slide 9
Slide 9 – Q3 2024 highlights
- Group revenues were 7.5 billion euros, up 5% on the prior year quarter
- Noninterest expenses were 4.7 billion euros, down 8%, benefitting from
a partial release of the Postbank takeover litigation provision following
the settlements in the third quarter. A provision of 547 million euros
remains in place for the outstanding plaintiff claims
- The settlements achieved in August and September enabled us to
release around 440 million euros of Postbank-related provisions in the
quarter which were partially offset by charges of around 90 million
euros related to other legacy litigation items
- Nonoperating costs were positive 302 million euros in the quarter,
including a net litigation release of 344 million euros and restructuring
and severance charges of 42 million euros

-- 7 of 40 --

8
- We generated a profit before tax of 2.3 billion euros, up 31%, and a net
profit of 1.7 billion euros, up 39% to the prior year quarter
- Our tax rate in the quarter of 26% was impacted by the aforementioned
litigation effects
- In the third quarter, diluted earnings per share was 81 cents and
tangible book value per share was 29 euros and 34 cents, up 6% year on
year
- Let me now turn to some of the drivers of these results
Slide 10 – Net interest income (NII) / Net interest margin (NIM)
- We remain well positioned to continue delivering strong net interest
income over the coming years, so let me start with a review of our NII on
slide 10
- NII across key banking book segments was 3.2 billion euros, and our
trajectory continues to outperform our guidance from earlier in the year
- Compared to the prior quarter, higher deposit volumes and loan margin
expansion offset expected beta convergence in the Corporate Bank,
although reported NII includes lower levels of CLO recoveries than in
the prior quarter. Private Bank was stable sequentially, reflecting
ongoing strength in deposit revenues
- Our base case remains that our quarterly NII run rate will continue to be
broadly stable and we reiterate that we expect full-year banking book
NII to remain in line with the 13.1 billion euros reported in 2023, despite
absorbing a headwind of around 150 million euros versus 2023, from
the discontinuation of the minimum reserve remuneration
- Our hedging strategy has positioned us well for a declining rate
environment, as outlined on page 32 in the appendix
- Our hedge portfolio stabilizes our income by extending the tenor of
interest rate risk, but it also protects us against a drop in interest rates,
and to that end we have increased the notional of our hedge portfolio
over the last 12 to 18 months in response to the slower-than-expected
rise in deposit betas
- The weighted average maturity of our hedges is around 5 years. Based
on current forward rates, we expect the income from the hedge book to
grow by 300 to 400 million euros each year as we roll maturing hedges
- As such, we expect the hedge portfolio to provide a long-term tailwind
to our revenues at current forward rates

-- 8 of 40 --

9
- With respect to 2025, more than 90% of the income is locked in with
existing positions already
- With that, let’s turn to adjusted cost development, on slide 11
Slide 11 – Adjusted costs – Q3 2024 (YoY)
- Adjusted costs were 5 billion euros for the quarter, in line with our
guidance
- Savings from streamlining our IT platform and lower spend for
professional services were offset by higher costs for compensation and
benefits, which increased by 4% year on year
- The increase reflected wage growth as expected, higher performance-
related compensation and increases in internal workforce after our
targeted investments throughout 2023, partially offset by further
workforce optimization
- Let’s now turn to provision for credit losses on slide 12
Slide 12 – Provision for credit losses
- As Christian mentioned, I will elaborate on the headwinds which have
persisted this year, but let’s start with this quarter’s provision for credit
losses, which was 494 million euros, equivalent to 41 basis points of
average loans
- Stage 1 and 2 provisions were on a moderate level, as various portfolio
effects largely offset increases from softer macroeconomic forecasts
and overlay recalibrations in the third quarter
- Stage 3 provisions increased sequentially to 482 million euros mainly
driven by the Private Bank, including transitional Postbank integration
effects
- Provisions in the Corporate Bank remained stable and included the
gross impact from a larger corporate restructuring event, which had
already impacted the second quarter
- Investment Bank provisions were slightly lower sequentially, given the
anticipated and substantial improvement in Commercial Real Estate in
the quarter, including a negative impact of 23 million euros from the
expected CRE loan portfolio sale, which is underway and where we
have gained pricing visibility

-- 9 of 40 --

10
- Let me now take you through some additional detail on our provisions
on slide 13
Slide 13 – Provisioning trends
- This year, we faced several headwinds, which negatively impacted
provisions and our full-year guidance, but which we do not expect to
persist into 2025 at all, or in the same magnitude depending on the item
- First, the transitional effects from the Postbank integration led to
longer-than-expected impacts across our internal collection and
recovery processes, but we expect these to fade over the coming
quarters
- Second, we have been dealing with two relatively fast-paced larger
corporate events, impacting year-to-date provisions at a level unusual
compared to historical standards. However, the pre-tax impact was
mitigated by around 70%, as these loans benefitted from credit-
concentration hedging
- And lastly, our full-year CRE provision run rate has been at a cyclically
higher level, but has now substantially declined quarter on quarter, as
envisaged. We continue to see more signs of stabilization, which
supports our confidence in a gradual reduction in future provisions
- In general, we maintain tight underwriting standards and continue to
conservatively manage our loan book which includes managing single-
name concentration risks through comprehensive hedging programs,
including our recently issued Significant Risk Transfer transactions,
which bring the total notional volume of hedges to 41 billion euros
- Our regular and comprehensive portfolio reviews, including close
assessment of trends at the sub-segment level and deeper dives into
more vulnerable sectors, show that overall credit quality remains stable;
forward-looking indicators such as rating migration and trends in our
non-investment grade portfolio and watchlist ratios do not suggest a
noteworthy deterioration in asset quality
- We also see broadly stable developments in our domestic market, as
outlined on page 38 of the appendix
- Our 220-billion-euro German loan book is low risk and well diversified
across businesses, and 70% of the portfolio is either collateralized or
supported by financial guarantees. We also have more than 12 billion
euros in hedges

-- 10 of 40 --

11
- More than three quarters of the book is in the Private Bank, of which
around 90% consists of low-risk German retail mortgages
- Our corporate loan book is well diversified and of high quality. Exposure
is predominantly to multi-national corporates and MidCaps, with almost
70% of loans rated investment grade
- Importantly, early warning indicators in Germany remain robust; the
number of limits subject to our watchlist remains largely unchanged
since the end of last year and we do not observe any significant, broad-
based rating deterioration across the portfolio
- In summary, our portfolio is holding up well and adjusting our reported
gross provisions for offsetting effects from recoveries through hedging,
which are captured as revenues, our pro-forma year-to-date net
provisions would have been around 34 basis points
- We continue to expect a sequential reduction in provisions, towards
more normalized levels as we go into 2025
- Before we move to performance in our businesses, let me turn to capital
on slide 14
Slide 14 – Capital metrics
- Our third-quarter Common Equity Tier 1 ratio came in at 13.8%, 30
basis points higher compared to the previous quarter
- The increase was largely driven by CET1 capital, reflecting strong
earnings net of deductions, and an approximately 790-million-euro or
22-basis-point positive effect from the adoption of the Article 468 CRR
transitional rule for unrealized gains and losses
- Risk-weighted assets increased for market risk and credit risk. The
credit risk RWA increase was driven by model impacts and business
growth, mostly offset by reductions from capital efficiency measures
- Lower operational risk RWA were driven by the partial release of the
Postbank takeover litigation provision
- At the end of the third quarter our leverage ratio was 4.6%, flat
sequentially, as higher leverage exposure driven by securities financing
transactions and trading assets offset an increase in Tier 1 capital in line
with the CET1 capital development
- With that, let’s now turn to performance in our businesses, starting with
the Corporate Bank on slide 16

-- 11 of 40 --

12
Slide 16 – Corporate Bank
- Corporate Bank revenues in the third quarter were 1.8 billion euros,
essentially flat year on year, as normalization of deposit margins was
mostly offset by higher deposit volumes, growth in commissions and
fee income, and increased loan NII
- The 5% increase in commissions and fee income in the first nine months
reflects the impact of our growth initiatives and shows good progress to
offset the normalization of deposit revenues
- In the third quarter, commissions and fee income was 4% higher year on
year, reflecting growth in our Institutional Client Services business, and
essentially flat compared to the seasonally strong second quarter
- Deposits increased by 7 billion euros in the quarter and are 23 billion
euros higher year on year driven by higher term and sight deposits
across currencies
- This growth was partially driven by certain client accommodation
activities, which we expect to normalize in the fourth quarter
- Provision for credit losses was at 126 million euros, in line with the
previous quarter, and increased significantly year on year driven by
higher stage 3 provisions and the non-recurrence of a one-off model
change in stage 1 and 2 in the prior year. Higher stage 3 provisions
included a larger corporate restructuring event, which had already
impacted the second quarter and was partially covered by risk
mitigation measures
- Noninterest expenses were slightly higher year on year driven by front
office investments and higher internal service cost allocations
- This resulted in a post-tax return on tangible equity of 13.1% and a
cost/income ratio of 64%
- I’ll now turn to the Investment Bank on slide 17
Slide 17 – Investment Bank
- Revenues for the third quarter were 11% higher year on year on a
reported basis, driven by improvements across both FIC and O&A
- Revenues in Fixed Income & Currencies also increased by 11%, driven
by significantly higher Credit Trading and Emerging Markets revenues
and supported by stable performance in Financing

-- 12 of 40 --

13
- Credit Trading showed strength in the Distressed business and
continued performance in Flow, reflecting investments made into the
franchise
- Emerging Markets demonstrated year-on-year growth across regions
- Foreign Exchange revenues were higher, with continued strength in
Spot, while revenues in Rates were lower in a market environment that
continues to be uncertain
- Moving to O&A, revenues were significantly higher than in the prior
year, with increases across business lines reflecting a growing industry
fee pool
- Debt Origination revenues were higher, driven by increased industry
activity across Investment Grade and Leveraged Debt
- Advisory revenues were strong and materially higher year on year, with
the business benefitting from prior period investments
- Noninterest expenses and adjusted costs were both essentially flat year
on year, with the impact of strategic investments offset by lower
infrastructure allocations
- Provision for credit losses was 135 million euros, or 52 basis points of
average loans. The previous year quarter materially benefitted from a
provision release from model changes
- Turning to the Private Bank on slide 18
Slide 18 – Private Bank
- Revenues in the quarter were 2.3 billion euros, essentially flat, with
noninterest revenue growth of 7% year on year
- The decline in NII was driven by continued higher funding costs from
the impact of minimum reserves, the Group-neutral impact of certain
hedging costs as well as a negative episodic effect from our lending
books, mainly in Personal Banking. Excluding these effects, third-
quarter revenues in the Private Bank would have been up 4% year on
year
- Personal Banking continues to record higher deposit revenues in
Germany which were more than offset by the aforementioned impacts
weighing on the net interest income
- Wealth Management & Private Banking grew revenues by 5% to 1
billion euros, driven by higher lending and investment revenues,
partially offset by lower deposit revenues

-- 13 of 40 --

14
- We continue to see good business momentum with net inflows into
assets under management of 8 billion euros in the quarter mainly in
Wealth Management & Private Banking
- The Private Bank continues the transformation of the Personal Banking
business in Germany with around 50 branch closures and further
workforce reductions in the first nine months of the year. Savings have
been offset this quarter by higher infrastructure cost allocations and
higher compensation expenses, including wage inflation, as well as
continued residual expenses for service remediation
- As announced in the fourth quarter of 2022, the refinement of our
methodology to allocate infrastructure costs resulted in Group-neutral
year-on-year expense shifts between the businesses, noticeable this
quarter in the Private Bank; however, even including the allocations,
adjusted costs were down 2% in the first nine months, compared to the
prior year period
- Looking ahead, we foresee the Private Bank to resume the cost
reduction path next quarter with residual costs for service remediation
to continue to taper and further benefits from ongoing transformation,
including from the integration of the IT platform and further branch
closures
- As I outlined earlier, credit quality of our domestic and international
portfolios remains high. Loan loss provisions this quarter still included
40 million euros of transitional Postbank integration effects which
should cease
- Let me continue with Asset Management on slide 19
Slide 19 – Asset Management
- My usual reminder: the Asset Management segment includes certain
items that are not part of the DWS stand-alone financials
- Profit before tax improved by 54% from the prior year period, reflecting
operating leverage from higher revenues and stable noninterest
expenses
- Revenues increased by 11%, driven by management fees of 626 million
euros. This growth from both Active and Passive products reflected
increasing average assets under management from market
development and net inflows

-- 14 of 40 --

15
- Performance and transaction fees were significantly lower driven by the
impact of real estate valuations and lower transaction volumes in
Alternatives
- Noninterest expenses were 1% lower, while adjusted costs were
essentially flat compared to the prior year
- Lower non-compensation costs, particularly in IT, offset slightly higher
compensation and benefits costs
- Assets under management increased by 30 billion euros to 963 billion
euros resulting in record-high assets under management levels. The
increase was attributable to positive market appreciation and net
inflows
- The positive net inflow trend for Passive continues, with a further 10
billion euros gathered in the quarter, resulting in over 27 billion euros of
net inflows year to date
- Active Fixed Income contributed with net inflows of 10 billion in the
quarter, more than offsetting net outflows in Active Equity, Multi-Asset
and Alternatives products
- The cost/income ratio for the quarter declined to 67% and return on
tangible equity was 18.9%, both improving from the third quarter last
year
- Moving to Corporate & Other on slide 20
Slide 20 – Corporate & Other
- Corporate & Other reported a pre-tax profit of 424 million euros
compared to a pre-tax loss of 202 million euros in the third quarter of
2023, primarily driven by a provision release in the Postbank takeover
litigation matter of around 440 million euros
- Revenues were positive 157 million euros; this compares to positive 35
million euros in the prior year quarter. The increase was driven by
valuation and timing differences, which were positive 295 million euros,
reflecting partial reversion of prior period losses and impacts from
market moves
- The pre-tax losses associated with legacy portfolios were 142 million
euros driven primarily by provisions for legacy litigation items
- At the end of the quarter, risk-weighted assets stood at 34 billion euros,
including 13 billion euros of operational risk RWA. In aggregate, RWAs

-- 15 of 40 --

16
have reduced by 8 billion euros year on year, mainly reflecting a change
in the allocation of operational risk RWA
- Leverage exposure was 36 billion euros at the end of the quarter,
slightly lower than the prior year quarter
- Finally, let me turn to the Group outlook on slide 21
Slide 21 – Outlook
- Our ongoing performance demonstrates the successful execution of
our strategy
- Our revenue trajectory remains on track to 30 billion euros for this year,
on the path to our goal of 32 billion euros in 2025
- Looking at the fourth quarter and starting with the Corporate Bank, we
expect revenues to remain essentially flat sequentially, as growth in
noninterest revenues compensates for lower deposit income
- In the Investment Bank, we expect a strong performance across our
businesses in FIC, compared to the fourth quarter of 2023
- We are encouraged by our fourth-quarter pipeline in Origination &
Advisory, which is higher year on year and suggests positive
momentum for the remainder of 2024, both sequentially and year on
year
- The Private Bank is expected to grow revenues sequentially driven by
higher NII
- Finally, we expect Asset Management to grow revenues as the
momentum of the last six months carries over and further accelerates
into the fourth quarter, with potential upside from performance fees
- We expect to further reduce our adjusted cost run rate closer to 4.9
billion euros in the coming quarters to allow us to achieve around 20
billion euros of noninterest expenses in 2025. The reduction should
come through a combination of ongoing cost discipline and benefits
from our efficiency and tactical measures
- We expect reported provision for credit losses for 2024 to land at
around 1.8 billion euros, higher than our prior guidance, but we
continue to expect an amelioration will follow next year, as the
transitory headwinds we called out will pass, leading to a reduction
towards more normalized levels

-- 16 of 40 --

17
- Our robust operating performance in the third quarter, including the
ongoing work in putting legacy items behind us, helps us lay the
foundation for delivery in 2025
- Furthermore, our strong capital position gives us a good step off for our
2025 and 2026 distribution objectives
- And as Christian said, our full focus remains on the execution of our
own strategy
- With that, let me hand back to Ioana, and we look forward to your
questions
Questions & Answers
Anke Reingen (RBC) Yes, thank you very much for taking my questions. The
first is on loan losses. When you talk about 2025 and
towards a more normalized level, is that closer to 30
basis points? And then what should give us the
confidence that the loan losses can come down in Q4
and 2025? You show us slide 13. Should the Postbank
integration and the large corporate events almost drop
out, or drop out in 2025? And when you gave us 2024
guidance, and we've been looking, sorry to say, but at
two quarters of upward revision, what did you
underestimate when you previously guided for 2024?
And then, second, on the buybacks. Yes, great to hear
you applied for approval, but can you be more specific
on the amount? Should we use slide 24, where you talk
about the 50% increase year over year as a potential
indicator of your request at this time? And what does it
mean for potential additional buybacks in calendar year
2025? When do you think you can make a decision?
And is that a function of the loan loss charge guidance
as well?
And maybe that's an opportunity to say something
about the still outstanding settlements post the
Postbank ruling today. Thank you very much.
Christian Sewing Thank you, Anke. It's Christian. Let me start, and as
usual, James will add to all your questions. But let me
start with the share buybacks, because that also goes
into the direction of the most recent ruling of the
Cologne court.

-- 17 of 40 --

18
First of all, with the share buyback after the full
provisioning of the Postbank litigation case in April, we
always said we want to show to you two clean quarters,
Q2, Q3, which we did. And even without the release
which we recorded in the third quarter for Postbank, we
have shown a record quarter for Deutsche Bank in the
third quarter. And that gave us then the conviction and
the clear path now to apply for a share buyback. By the
way, I think with the 13.8% CET1, this is also a nice
step-off which gives us the confidence for the
application.
With regard to amounts and timing, we always do it like
in the past. We keep that discussion with our regulator,
but I can tell you that there is full confidence, with
James and myself and the management team, that
based on the step-off of 13.8% CET1, based on the
trajectory of our operating results, we are convinced of
our distribution of above € 8 billion for the time zone
between 2021 and 2025. So nothing changed.
Also, what I would like to emphasize is that today's
ruling, you have just seen that, is not actually affecting
our share buyback because we provisioned that amount
in full. And also, in our capital plan going forward, we
did not assume further releases. So, in this regard, of
course, we don't like the ruling, and now we have to
analyze it and think about potential next steps.
But for the capital plan going forward, and for the share
buyback, this has no impact because we are fully
provisioned. And in this regard, we remain convinced
and confident that we can deliver above the € 8 billion.
For us, it was important to show two good quarters and
solid quarters in terms of operating performance. And I
think we see that, from a revenue point of view, from a
cost point of view, and hence with the underlying result.
Let me briefly go over to the loan loss provision
question, because I understand that that obviously
raises some questions on your side. I really think it's
important that we look into the composition of the loan
loss provision and what really drove the number to €
494 million this quarter.
And yes, we said that we see in the second half of 2024
a decreasing trend. Let me explain why this did not

-- 18 of 40 --

19
happen. Number one, I know you are looking with
concerns to Germany and Commercial Real Estate.
With regard to both items, to be honest, I see a robust
portfolio quality.
In particular, if I look at the Corporate Bank side and the
Private Bank side and the underlying loan loss
provisions in Germany, we don't see any material
change. We don't see any material change in the
portfolio composition. If you look at indicators like up-
versus downgrades, if you look, like additions to watch
lists, this is not a concerning trend.
Now, what increased in the Private Bank is still the
result of the backlog in the Postbank operations, that
actually we thought that this comes earlier down. It will
come down. We even will see some bookings, i.e., in
terms of that we will see releases of certain reserves in
2025. So the trend is coming down, and we will see
releases, but we hoped actually for a faster reduction in
this regard during the year 2024. So that is one item.
The second item, I think, which is underlying positive is
on Commercial Real Estate. If you look at the
underlying portfolio composition, the trend is coming
down. It's for the first time that Commercial Real Estate
provisions have come down quarter over quarter.
And it would have come even more down if we wouldn't
have done the portfolio sale, where we got the first
mark, and where actually we booked an additional
provision from the portfolio sale with a low double-digit
number. That is obviously capital accretive.
But overall, the Commercial Real Estate provisions are
coming down. And that is again something which we
forecasted at the start of the year, but to be honest, we
thought that this is already happening in Q2. Now it is
coming in in Q3.
And the third item is one larger loan loss provision in
the south of Germany for a corporate name, which is,
though, significantly hedged. So if you see the net loss
position which we have from that, it is far less than the
gross loan loss provision which we have booked in Q3.
That was also, by the way, a name where we already
booked the first loan loss provision in Q2.

-- 19 of 40 --

20
So if you take these three items, the Postbank item,
which will come down, and we even see reversals of
bookings in 2025, if you see the underlying rate in
Commercial Real Estate, and on top of that, if you look
at the one name where we had gross loan loss
provisions, but which was significantly hedged,
actually, we see also with regard to 2025, and that was
what James was referring to in his prepared remarks, a
normalized run rate for loan loss provisions of € 350
million.
And that is where we see, based on the portfolio quality
we have, the trend going. And in this regard, I do think
that we have seen now in this quarter the peak of the
loan loss provisions, with that number coming down to
approximately € 350 million per quarter in the 2025
year.
Anke Reingen Thank you. Can you come back on the capital, on the
buyback? So should we look at the 50% increase? And
is the plan still to potentially top up in the course of
2025? Thank you.
James von Moltke So Anke, you referred to page 24 in the appendix. And
yes, that lays out the path that we broadly wish to
follow to deliver on the promises we've made. As I say,
the € 8 billion to us is a number that we think we’re
confident we’ll exceed. We’re not going to go into
precise euro numbers at this point, but I think slide 24
lays out a good path.
As it relates to incremental buybacks next year, it's very
early to make that determination. As we've talked
about, there are lots of moving parts in a capital plan
under the best of circumstances. Next year, we'll have
CRR III coming due in two phases, changes in the
environment, potential upside in areas like, for example,
the sectoral buffer that's been applied in Germany to
mortgages. So lots of moving parts that, at this point,
one doesn't want to get ahead of. So we'll make that
decision much later in 2025 than today's application.
Anke Reingen Okay, thank you very much. Thank you.

-- 20 of 40 --

21
Flora Bocahut Yes, thank you. Good morning. Thank you for taking my
(Barclays) questions. I have one on NII and one on cost, please.
So on the NII, could we come back, please, to the drop
we saw this quarter in the Corporate Bank? It's led the
banking book NII to be just € 3.2 billion this quarter.
And I think the full year guidance, you have implied it
will be again about that level in Q4. When I look at slide
32, and it's useful, thank you very much for putting in
that slide, I see you've locked a significant part of the
hedge income already for the next two years. So that's
very reassuring. I also see that you've used a ten-year
swap that would be 2.3% to 2.5%. And that makes
sense based on today's curve. But the risk here is rather
to the downside. So the question here is also, the light
blue column, the contribution from the rollover of the
hedges, if the ten-year swap would go towards, say, 2%
or 2.2%, would we still see the rollover contribute
positively in the next two years on top of what you've
locked already? So that's for NII.
And then the second question is on cost. I think you
were saying before, James, that to make your guidance
for 2025 cost, you would need to get adjusted cost
quarterly run rate down towards € 4.9 billion. Now,
obviously, you’ve just had three quarters in a row where
you've met the guidance for this year at € 5.0 billion. So
maybe could you talk a little bit into the capacity for you
to get there already in Q4, and what gives you the
confidence that you can get towards the € 4.9 billion
quarterly run rate for adjusted cost next year? Thank
you.
James von Moltke Thank you, Flora. Happy to answer those questions. So
on the NII disclosure that we provide, you're right.
There's, of course, some risk on the rollover of the
hedges. We like that we've locked in 90% for next year.
And yes, we use the implied forward curve to look at
what the future might be. The dark blue is, as I say,
what's locked in for the next several years.
Remember, of course, that the gap is against hedges
that are rolling off that were essentially at zero or very,
very low. So the idea that there may be a little bit of
downside in the light blue bars, that's true. But the
quantum is against very low hedges put in many years

-- 21 of 40 --

22
ago, as much as ten years ago, in that rollover.
And that actually goes to the first part of your question,
which is the Corporate Bank. Yes, we had in the series a
low point in the Corporate Bank, but actually, there are
some hedges that now roll off in the fourth quarter in
two chunks. And that gives us some good visibility into
the trajectory for the Corporate Bank.
If I think about the two businesses separately, we think
we may have passed the low point in the trajectory for
Private Bank already now in Q3, and we'll be passing
that low point in Q4 for the Corporate Bank. It's
obviously early to make that judgement, and we'll see
how everything plays out, including the balance sheet
growth, deposit growth betas and what have you. But
we think we're on a path now to be rising in 2025, not
just because of the benefit of the long-term hedges. So
it's an overall quite encouraging picture, as we see it.
Going to costs, yes, absolutely, we're focused every day
on managing the run rate down. And I think we've said
in the past, towards € 4.9 billion. That remains our
objective here. The trajectory in the first three quarters
of this year has been encouraging. And even in the third
quarter, I can point to some things that are of a non-
recurring nature in the third quarter, I’d say. So I think
we're close to, or at, the € 5 billion level. But we need to
continue working it down from this point. And that is
the full focus of the firm.
We have the projects and the initiatives in place to do
that. So for us, it's just about additional delivery of our
operational efficiency program. We've talked about it in
the past. It’s optimization initiatives in Germany. We've
announced some more actions on the distribution
network in Germany. We've been investing in
technology, and we're harvesting some of the benefits
of that.
I think we have a very successful track record now on
workforce optimization, because what you see in the
overall headcount, as well as the compensation and
benefits line, is the impact of reductions in force that
we've implemented, reinvestments, both in the front
office in technology and controls, all of which we've
managed within the run rate.

-- 22 of 40 --

23
And we think we've got a whole raft of initiatives of a
strategic nature underway to deliver further on those
run rate improvements, as well as tactical steps that
we've been taking throughout the year and will continue
to take to ensure we deliver on the objectives. Hope
that all helps, Flora.
Flora Bocahut Yes, that's very clear. Thank you very much.
Kian Abouhossein Yes, hi. I've got two questions. One is relating more
(JPMorgan) specifically, a question on the Article 468, the CRR III.
You’re using these transitional rules. I’m just trying to
understand the dynamic on the OCI, it’s about 20 basis
points on your capital. So just to understand, first of all,
the dynamic, but also your decision process or why
you’re taking the benefit.
And then second question is related to your 2025
revenues. You need to grow revenues just under 7%
from € 30 billion to € 32 billion. Even if you adjust for
the € 300 million delta on your hedges, clearly it’s quite
an upward-sloping curve in terms of revenue growth in
a more difficult German environment. And maybe you
could just outline a bit how we should think about your
assumptions in a more difficult German environment,
and I'm not sure what your German environment
outlook is, in 2025 in terms of reaching that € 32 billion,
especially, again, Corporate Bank 2025 and Private
Bank 2025.
Christian Sewing Thank you, Kian. Let me start with the revenues, and
James is then going to your capital question. First of all,
before we talk about 2025, I think it's very encouraging
that we have full sight on the € 30 billion for 2024. And
again, I think we have established a track record in
achieving our revenue guidance for the last years.
And if I look where we stand at the end of the third
quarter, how actually October started, in particular on
the trading side, you just heard James talking about the
potential low point in NII in the Private Bank, then also
where equity indices are and what that potentially
means for performance fees and Asset Management,
we are super confident that we can achieve the € 30
billion, which is obviously the right jump-off for your
question regarding the € 32 billion.

-- 23 of 40 --

24
Now, when we come to the € 32 billion, the first item is
again a continuation of what James outlined on the NII
side. Because everything that we can see from our
forecast, given our hedging profile, but also in
particular looking at our deposit growth, which we see
in the Corporate Bank but also in the Private Bank, we
do feel that, just from an NII across the bank, and in
particular carried by the Corporate Bank and by the
Private Bank, we do see an upside of approximately €
300 million to € 400 million on the NII side.
By the way, Kian, that does not include the expected
growth on the Financing volume, in particular also in
Chetan's business, in the Investment Bank. So when I
look at the forecast, just from the Financing part in that
area and the NII part, obviously my starting position is
then € 500 million up, i.e. € 30.5 billion.
And now let's go through the businesses and, in
particular, look at the investments which we have done
over the last 18 months to move the businesses, in
particular in the non-NII area. There's, of course, the
Investment Bank, and there, the O&A business. You
have seen with the last quarters that we clearly
outperformed the market. We have grown market
share. Not everybody, who we hired over the last 18
months is yet obviously running at full speed, so this is
still to come.
So we expect, in the O&A business, further market
share gains. And we also expect that 2025, with all
indications we have from our mandates which we see
for Q4 and Q1 already, this will be a year with actually
higher fees for the banks. And that means if you have a
higher market share, which we already increased by 50
basis points year to date, we will obviously benefit. So
we do believe that just in the O&A business, we see
upside of another € 500 million towards the number
which we are printing for the year 2024.
Then we have invested, and you have also seen over
the last years actually, to compliment here Ram Nayak,
we have seen constant increases in market share in the
FIC business. I think we have done a terrific job over
there. Now, if you follow Ram's planning going forward,
obviously we have an eye in certain business areas like

-- 24 of 40 --

25
Credit, but also from a regional point of view, we
invested quite significantly over the last nine months
into our US franchise. So I would say, with the market
shares which we definitely also won again in Q3, with
the investments we have done in that business, there is
also further increases to come from the FIC business in
the Investment Bank.
Then let's turn to the Private Bank. So I talked about the
NII profile. But obviously the biggest lever which we
see in the Private Bank, and there we see actually
already a good momentum is on the Wealth
Management side. But if you look at the assets under
management, which are increasing steadily, I think
we're at, year to date in the Private Bank, approximately
€ 27 billion of net inflows into assets under
management, we will obviously benefit from that next
to the NII I described before.
Similar, by the way, on the assets under management in
Asset Management in Stefan's book. So that, I also
clearly expect a three-digit million increase in revenues
in Asset Management next year.
And that leaves me with the Corporate Bank. I think the
Corporate Bank in itself is a success story. This is, in the
meantime, so to say, at the heart of the bank. Quarter
by quarter, we are increasing the mandates we get from
our corporate clients around the world. There is clearly
the trend of the corporates around the world to go for
at least one alternative to the US banks. They would like
to have the European alternatives. With the network we
have and the investments we have done in our payment
platform businesses, as well, into our digital offerings,
we can see further increases in the fee business there.
So all in all, starting actually at € 30.5 billion with the
hedging profile on the NII side, and looking at the track
record, I'm very confident that the € 32 billion is a
number which we can achieve.
And last but not least, if I really think about 2025, if you
think about the walk and the normalized costs we have
on the loan loss provision, clearly reduced costs on the
legal side, James was just talking about all our efforts
and also progress we are doing on the operating cost
side, and we will have less restructuring costs, to be

-- 25 of 40 --

26
honest, Kian, but you know me personally, we don't
even need € 32 billion of revenues in order to go to the
10%. But that doesn't mean that I'm trying to put a soft
touch on the € 32 billion. I think you have heard my
absolute conviction that € 32 billion is definitely
achievable.
James von Moltke And Kian, just to touch your OCI filter, the CRR III rule
that we're taking advantage of. I think the short answer
is, because it's there. The time value of capital in our
ratio, especially as we're often measured against a
distance to MDA, appears to us to be valuable. And
hence the decision to take advantage of that
transitional arrangement.
Remember that the 22 basis points could be a lower
number when the time comes that the transition benefit
is over. So the passage of time in the book of securities
that are generating those unrealized losses will see
some attrition, and then the interest rate environment
will change. So it's a number that may be considerably
lower than 20 basis points when that transition period
ends. And therefore, we think it's valuable for our
shareholders to be able to redeploy that capital during
that 18-month period.
Kian Abouhossein Very clear. Thank you.
Chris Hallam Yes, morning, everybody. Just two for me. So first, on
(Goldman Sachs) M&A, does the current M&A situation in Germany
impact at all how you think about your banking strategy
in the home markets, the competitive landscape in
Germany, or how you would prioritize organic versus
inorganic growth?
And then the second, in O&A, it looks like you lost some
share in the quarter. Your share was trending up 70
basis points in the first half, and now I think you're
calling it up 50 basis points versus 2023. So just what
are the moving parts there? Is that just mix? And does
that change at all how you think about the composition
of O&A revenues into next year, obviously
notwithstanding the answer you just gave to Kian?
Christian Sewing Thank you, Chris. Let me take the first one, and James
is taking the second one. On the M&A side and on the
specific potential situation you're referring to in

-- 26 of 40 --

27
Germany, that does not change our strategy at all. I
think we have a very solid and a very good footprint in
Germany, both in the Private Bank as well as in the
Corporate Bank.
We have worked on two sides in Germany to make that
even more attractive. You see all the work which is done
by Claudio, in particular in the retail bank, to make this
business more efficient. We know that there is work to
be done, but I can see how Claudio is focusing on that
to have an efficient platform to offer digitized products
to our retail clients. And honestly, quarter by quarter,
also with the feedback we get from the clients, we see
clear improvement.
On the corporate side, I think, again, what I said before,
it was the right decision to establish ourselves with an
own Corporate Bank and to make sure that we are, so
to say, the bank for German Mittelstand family-owned
clients and obviously the large clients, to support them
domestically, but in particular, when they go abroad.
And in this regard, we feel that we are rightly
positioned, and with all the efficiency program, we can
see that the profitability in the German business on
both sides is further increasing and will further
increase.
Now, whenever it comes to these kinds of potential
items, to be honest, Chris, we shouldn't underestimate
the opportunities for us. Because at the end of the day,
it creates uncertainty. It creates uncertainty with the
other institutions, but in particular also with the clients.
And we are ready to act. And this is what we
established over the last three to four years, both in the
Corporate Bank and in the Private Bank. And in this
regard, we have a clear strategy. That is delivery of
2025, 10%. And in this regard, whenever there is an
opportunity to gain market share domestically, we will
do this.
James von Moltke And Chris, to your question about O&A market share,
you're correct that Q3 was a little lower than the year to
date. And that was mostly mix, and particularly that
leveraged debt capital markets was a smaller part of the
wallet in Q3. We're actually encouraged by continued
year-on-year improvement in our M&A market share,

-- 27 of 40 --

28
where some of the investments are beginning to bear
fruit. And that's particularly on an announced basis
rather than a booked basis.
If I look to what we would estimate the market share to
be in the fourth quarter, based on the forward look of
our pipeline and estimates of next quarter, we think
we'll be back in the 2.5-2.6% range, where we've been
this year. And that's an encouraging step-off into next
year.
Chris Hallam Okay, thank you. That’s very helpful.
Giulia Aurora Miotto Yes, hi, good morning. Thank you for taking my
(Morgan Stanley) questions. I have two, and both fairly longer dated. So
the first one is on the Postbank integration. If we take a
step back, why is this still a topic? By now, I would have
expected the bank to be fully integrated, the IT to be
merged. So when can we essentially stop talking about
this and really see a step change in the cost on the
Private Bank?
And then my second question is on private credit. This
is becoming incrementally a topic. US investment banks
were talking a lot about this in Q3 results. How do you
approach private credit? Do you see it as a potential
disruptor to some of your lending business? Do you see
it as an opportunity to grow fee businesses by
partnering? Yes, any comment on the private credit
side? Thank you.
James von Moltke Sure, Giulia, it's James. I'll take both, and Christian may
want to add on the private credit side. Look, Postbank,
the recovery from the operational disruptions that took
place in last year's third quarter has taken us longer
than we expected.
Among other things, we were extremely focused on
ensuring that we closed out the backlogs of processes
that were adversely affecting our clients. That was our
focus. It was also the BaFin's focus as they looked at
the problem set. And hence, collections was an area
that we waited longer to focus on improving.
We've now made those investments, and we've hired
the people, we've trained the people, and that
collections process is getting closer to normal. That
took us longer than we expected this year, no question,

-- 28 of 40 --

29
which is why it's had the impact on the CLP guidance
that it did. But given where we are right now, and being
up and running on that process, I think we feel much
more comfortable that we're at the end rather than that
there's still risk.
The other thing is a little bit in the details, but the last
model conversion of a portfolio from Postbank onto the
DB systems and models on the risk side, that took place
in the third quarter. That also influenced that number of
€ 40 million. So why is it a topic? The longer-term
impact of the operational disruptions, that is coming to
an end, as well as the models.
On private credit, we see it more as an opportunity than
as a threat. Obviously, there's a degree to which the
banks face the risk of disintermediation, but I think that
downside is more than offset by the upside of, frankly, a
growing market, a growing ability to place risk in the
marketplace and thereby increase our origination
business model, fees on origination, and expand loan
origination beyond what the capital on our balance
sheet supports by itself.
We also see opportunities in collaboration with private
credit firms to do more, collaboration with our own
asset manager, DWS, to do more, as DWS builds its
strategies in private credit. So we aim to be here a
participant, not just as an originator, but also as a
partner and a participant in managing private credit.
So it is a change in the market. It is a disruption to some
extent, but one where strategically, we at Deutsche
Bank feel we're actually well positioned on a relative
basis, globally and particularly in Europe, to be a
beneficiary.
Giulia Aurora Miotto Thank you. Can I just check on Postbank? So now the IT
system is fully integrated, you have just one, or are you
still running a parallel one?
James von Moltke No, at this point, everything has moved over, and the
remaining work is really archiving and what have you.
One system. Interestingly, there's some future
opportunities. This is actually one of the cost benefits
that we see, and revenue benefits going forward.
Postbank has actually jumped out ahead of Deutsche

-- 29 of 40 --

30
Bank in some of its digital properties, and the
investments we're making this year, going into next
year, would actually help us catch up and accelerate
further the Deutsche Bank side of that equation.
So in a sense, there is more opportunity to be serving
customers in a leading way, competitively, in this
marketplace in both brands, now that we have the hard
work behind us. And by the way, most of the synergy
value captured, a little bit more still to come in Q4 and
Q1.
Giulia Aurora Miotto Thank you.
Stefan Stalmann Yes, good morning, gentlemen, and thank you very
(Autonomous) much for taking my questions. I wanted to ask, please,
you're mentioning that you're clearing the path for 2025
targets, acting decisively to address legacy items. Does
it hint at any elevated one-offs potentially coming in the
fourth quarter, let's say on restructuring expenses?
The second question I wanted to ask is on this
upcoming portfolio sale in US Commercial Real Estate.
Can you give us a rough sense of what the notional of
that portfolio is, and are those stage 3 loans, please?
And if I may, just a quick third question. You mentioned
these credit-concentration hedges and the benefits
from them. Could you let us know in which P&L items,
which revenue items and which divisions we would find
these hedge benefits, please, and how large they are?
Thank you.
James von Moltke Stefan, thanks for the questions. I'll take all three, and
again, Christian may want to add. I'd say it's too early to
tell on your question of is there anything extraordinary
that we may book in Q4.
And the reason for that is when I think about litigation,
for example, what's in our control and not, either
analytically or in actual settlement activity, is always
hard to tell. But certainly, and I think we've been
consistent in messaging on this, we want to put
ourselves in a place where we no longer have surprises
like the Postbank takeover litigation item for
shareholders.
Equally, we're in the planning process, restructuring

-- 30 of 40 --

31
and severance. We're still working towards our € 400
million budget for the year. You've seen that we did less
than we expected in Q3, and so there may be a bit of a
catch-up in Q4. If there are additional tactical measures
that we identify, we may go a little bit further there.
Another area I might point out is real estate. We're
always looking at our real estate portfolio, and to see
where we can optimize further. In all of those areas, too
early to say what actions we could find to take place.
But I think it's a signal of a company always looking for
ways to optimize, improve our run rates and then
deliver on promises, in a sustainable way, by the way,
deliver on our promises for next year.
On the CRE portfolio, it was approaching, but not quite,
€ 1 billion that we put in the market. Of that, a little bit,
approaching 40%, was stage 3, and then the rest a mix
of performing and stage 2. We were encouraged,
frankly, by the pricing that we saw.
Remember that when you're doing a portfolio sale, the
€ 23 million we book, is it telling us our marks weren't
right or simply that we're placing somebody else's cost
of capital for our own? I think more the latter. And given
how close the marks on the stage 3 elements are to our
bookings, we see that as encouraging and further
evidence of our view that Commercial Real Estate has
at least found a floor and is stabilizing.
That transaction, incidentally, I hope we were clear, but
we have not closed on that transaction, but we have
now booked to where we think it leads us in terms of
marks. So that's overall encouraging.
On the hedges, it's in both CB and IB. And in a couple
of those exposures, they were shared across the two.
We call them concentration hedges. Well, we have a
programmatic policy to ensure that our concentrations
don't exceed certain levels. When they do, in terms of
the underwriting, we sell those exposures away into,
typically, CLO structures, sometimes other structures.
The accounting has an asymmetry and produces
revenue. Actually, net interest income was smaller this
quarter, a little bit more in the first half. In total, over the
course of the year, that's amounted to about € 200

-- 31 of 40 --

32
million. So only 30% of the losses actually went to
capital, given the benefit of the hedging. And I think it's
a sign of the prudence that goes into that
programmatic hedging that we do.
And actually going back to Giulia's question, it's an area
where the growth of private credit is obviously helpful,
because we see improvements both in capacity and
pricing in the market into which we sell away the risk
that we're talking about. Hope that all helps, Stefan.
Stefan Stalmann Very helpful. Thank you very much, James.
Matthew Clark Hi. Actually, it's a similar question on the hedges. So
(Mediobanca) there's a commentary of Group-neutral hedging in
Private Banking revenues as a drag this quarter. So I'm
just wondering where, within the Group, is the
offsetting benefit there? Thank you.
James von Moltke Thank you. Treasury was, or Corporate & Other, where
the offset last year was. So what we did was, there was
what I think of as hedging of the convexity of the
mortgage portfolio, which we historically had kept in
Treasury.
This year, the decision was to push that out to the
business where we think it appropriately belongs, and
where, by the way, one of the reasons to do that was
the hedge programs that we're able to implement have
improved. So that was the trigger for the change.
And so that's meant that Private Bank on the surface
has had a year-on-year comparison that's worse, both
on revenues, by the way, and on costs, than the, I'll use
the word, underlying performance would show. So it's
been a noisy quarter for PB, but in areas that at least
two of which are Group-neutral, either on the cost side
with other segments, or in this case on the revenue side
with Corporate & Other.
Matthew Clark Thank you.
Jeremy Sigee Hi there. Thank you. A couple of follow-ups. A lot's
(BNP Paribas Exane) already been talked out. Firstly, on the US CRE, I just
wanted to check something that I think you implied. But
on slide 37, you've shown the quarterly CLPs have now
stepped back down to € 68 million. I think you're
implying that that's the new run rate, we stay around

-- 32 of 40 --

33
that level going forward.
And I guess it's a positive really that your modified
loans are now € 13 billion out of the € 15 billion. So it
implies you've worked your way through pretty much
the whole portfolio. And I guess that supports that
outlook. So first question is really just, are we now
expecting to go forward at that € 68-million-ish run
rate?
And then the second question, I just wanted to press
you a bit more on the M&A topic. You were commenting
this morning on the newswires, James, about Deutsche
Bank positioned to play a leading role in European
consolidation. The industrial logic makes sense, but
you're just not ready right now. And I just wondered
how you view the scenario of someone like
Commerzbank tying up with a different bank and
effectively becoming unavailable. What remaining
optionality would you have? Where else would you see
opportunities for consolidation and for Deutsche Bank
to play a leading role?
James von Moltke So Jeremy, thanks for the questions. So more or less,
the answer is yes. If we had printed in Q2 what we did
in Q3, I think we would have been congratulated for the
foresight. But we are absolutely seeing a trend here.
And it's based on the items that we've talked about for a
while, so relative stability and valuations, which you see
in the loan-to-value, the interest rate environment,
obviously the external indices that you've seen, and
now, having tested the market with the loan sale, also
the results of that market check.
As you also alluded to, inside the € 68 million is € 23
million that you can also think of as a bring forward, and
so the underlying run rate was even better. Look, I don't
want to promise a number, I think, having leaned out a
little bit far in Q1 about Q2, but the direction of travel is
there, and all of the drivers that I referred to are there
and visible.
And as it relates to the modifications, you're correct.
Look, some of this portfolio will have been modified and
then have its new maturity and come up for an
extension a second time. So it's not impossible that it
grows beyond the € 15 billion, just as a metric. But it is

-- 33 of 40 --

34
the case that we've been through the lion's share of the
maturity profile and potential for modification.
And as we said last quarter, the list of projects where
we see scope for new defaults is obviously declining, so
the number of loans where we see a risk in that there
are modifications or defaults in the next 12 months
declining significantly. So all of those things to us are
encouraging.
Given you referred to my comments, I'll go quickly, and
Christian may want to add. I think our language on the
strategic environment in Europe has been consistent
throughout. Deutsche Bank, I don't think it's a God-
given right, but given the business that we do, our size,
our home market and our global capabilities, we think
we're well positioned to play a leading role in time.
We've also been consistently clear that we didn't see
that time as having come. And that remains the case
today. We've been consistent in our messaging that as
we look to 2025, executing on our strategies, delivering
profitability, demonstrating its sustainability,
demonstrating the growth will do more for our
shareholders, considerably, than anything that's
inorganic. And so I think I want to just emphasize the
consistency of our language, but also, over time, the
ambitions we have for the organization. But it’s all over
time.
And one last note to just make to your question. Our
opportunity set changes, no question, if, in fact, the
combination that is mooted does take place. But it’s
one of a number of opportunities that one could
consider. I don’t want to be drawn on what those look
like, or when, but as you can imagine, we’ve given
thought to the question you posed over the years.
Jeremy Sigee Thank you.
Tom Hallett Hi, thanks for taking my questions. Firstly, when I look
(KBW) through your fourth quarter guidance for the core
businesses, I still seem to be coming out short, relative
to your € 30 billion guidance, unless trading revenues
come in well over double-digits and the same for O&A.
So it feels like you expect the Corporate Centre to
continue to positively surprise. Is that a fair

-- 34 of 40 --

35
assessment? And into next year, how does the € 500
million Valuation & Timing differences which we’ve
seen year to date feed into the revenue guidance for
next year?
And then secondly, it’s a bit of a broad-based question,
but there’s a general consensus that as long as rates
stay between 2% to 3%, everything is fine. But if rates
fall below 2%, it’s a different story. So how would you
see your interest rate sensitivity changing the further
below 2% we go? Thank you.
James von Moltke Thanks, Tom. In Q4, I’d say, well, one thing that is not
built into the guidance, but we refer to, is potential
performance fees on the Asset Management side,
which the way they are accounted for, they’re not
certain until the year is done and final.
We do see, as you say, sequential growth in O&A.
That’s encouraging, and that would help against the €
7.1 billion that we’re looking at for Q4. And if I just walk
forward the momentum we’ve had so far in FIC markets
this year, that should also produce, I think, a very solid
quarter and contribute to the run rate. So we’re
encouraged there.
Look, the Corporate & Other lines are hard to predict
just by their nature. Valuation & Timing, the nice thing
this year, really in the third quarter… Remember, in the
first quarter, we had some losses in Valuation & Timing
that were because of their short nature. Actually, the
pull to par happened very quickly.
There is some longer-dated pull to par that we can
already see going forward. It’s not a big part of what
we’re planning for 2025. And overall, I’d say 2025
would probably be a reversal, to some degree, from
2024. But it's always hard to predict what goes in those
lines, and they're very market dependent. Hope that
helps square the math.
Tom Hallett Yes, that’s good enough. Thank you. And then on the
rates, sorry, the 2% to 3% falls below 2%?
James von Moltke Yes, look, it’s always hard to predict. But as I said to the
question earlier, obviously we would like for these rolls,
the hedge to roll at 2% or more. To be fair, that's what
the market expects in terms of a terminal rate in euros.

-- 35 of 40 --

36
Remember, though, that this is long-term rates. And so
the scenarios of a steepening curve, especially as you
see less liquidity in the market, maybe higher fiscal
deficits and other things, you could actually in the long
end, even in scenarios where the short goes down
further, see higher long-end rates. So it's not just the
level, but also the shape of the curve.
And we look at this hard in Treasury, in our in our ALCO
and ALM processes. How do we lock in as much of the
future, not just simply by rolling ten years, which is a big
part of it for sure, but also by thinking about option
structures and other things that can protect specific
curve shapes over time? So I don't think of it as totally
linear in terms of our exposure to that environment.
Christian Sewing And Tom, just one addition to that. Also think about,
outside the rate sensitivity, actually what kind of
investments which we have done over the last 18
months actually in the non-NII business, and exactly for
that reason, in order to be really diversified from the
revenue streams.
That was the reason why we invested into Wealth
Management, the fee business part of the Corporate
Bank, and obviously in the O&A business. So I do
believe that even if this would come, then, I refer to
James’ comments but also the strength of the bank in
the non-NII business, which is clearly significantly
improving.
Tom Hallett Okay, thank you.
Piers Brown Yes, good morning, everybody. I've just got one final
(HSBC) one. It's just a modelling question in terms of some of
the moving parts on capital into next year, items that
we discussed last quarter. But if you could just tell us
whether there's any update to the Basel IV guidance. I
think I had about € 7.5 billion, 1 January 2025, and then
another similar amount with FRTB at the beginning of
2026. And then if there's anything to update on the
leverage finance reviews or on the EBA AVA technical
draft. I think those are two other potential moving parts
for next year. That'd be helpful. Thank you.
James von Moltke Thanks, Piers. No, not much in the way of new news.
Still, our estimates, € 15 billion in total split basically 50-

-- 36 of 40 --

37
50, is still about right. So next, the Q1 impact is
operational risk related. Q1 2026 would be FRTB
related. The OCI filter item that I talked about with Kian
would also be a feature then, whatever that number is
in 2026. So those are the build items that are still left
ahead of us.
I think, as I say, there's also the possibility of things
taking place that give benefits against that future. I
mentioned the sectoral buffer against mortgages in
Germany, conceivably a delay in FRTB. So the nature of
the beast here is that it's a bit of a moving target. But
with all of the things that we can see right now, we feel
very comfortable in our path.
On the AVA item, which I take to be the question, so the
EBA Q&A on additional valuation adjustments, I'm not
aware of any movement there. I know there was an
exposure draft, as I might call it, a lot of feedback for
the industry, but there hasn't been a reissuance of that.
We do obviously have very strong views about the ideas
that were laid out in the EBA draft. That would be a
headwind to our current expectations and capital plan.
But we also think that those ideas were excessively
conservative and would argue strongly around that.
Was your question, though, also more broadly about
the leverage lending review with the ECB? There wasn't
much really to update there either, I have to say.
Piers Brown Yes.
Christian Sewing Well, we should only say that we are still waiting,
actually, for the final report. I think, given all the
discussions over the summer, we can only tell you that
the number came substantially down. And to be honest,
we feel very comfortable with the exposures we have.
And now we have to wait for the further debate with the
ECB.
Piers Brown That's fine, yes. No, I was actually referring to… I think
we've mentioned in the past there was a 15-basis-point
add on to your CET1. And I think the way I’ve modelled
it is to assume that goes out in the form of higher RWA
or some form of capital reduction.
James von Moltke Yes. No change today to that. As you know, we were
given five basis points back a year ago, which we took

-- 37 of 40 --

38
to be a good sign in terms of where we were on a
relative basis. But no change to that.
Piers Brown Okay, that's great. Thank you very much.
James von Moltke Thank you, Piers.
Andrew Coombs Good afternoon. Firstly, just a quick clarification. I think
(Citi) in the revenue walk from € 30 billion to € 32 billion, you
talked about € 300 million to € 400 million incremental
NII in PB and CB from deposit growth. Can I just
confirm that that's the case, and that the € 300 million
from the structural hedge tailwind is then on top of
that?
James von Moltke So Andrew, no. Just to be clear that we would expect,
ballpark, € 200 million in each of the larger deposit
businesses next year. And that ties to the disclosure
around the hedges. That number is before any benefits
of growth in the balance sheet, whether loans or
deposits or spreads on either of those two things.
So that's why I think, in Christian's comments, we see
upside in NII, not just from the rollover, and let's say
that € 300 million to € 400 million depends a little bit
still on the interest rate environment, but then
incremental NII benefit next year from all those other
factors. So I hope that clarifies.
Andrew Coombs Okay. And then as a follow-up to that, I always thought
the hedge wasn't allocated evenly between PB and CB.
So interested in anything you can say on the hedge
allocation. And then more broadly, just the deposit
margin trends that you're seeing both currently, but
what you're also assuming going into next year as well.
Thank you.
James von Moltke Yes. So you're right that typically, the longer-term
hedges, especially the euro hedge book, is more in the
Private Bank than the Corporate Bank. As it happens, in
this year-on-year comparison, the Corporate Bank had
a larger dollar hedge on, which is the same hedge I
referred to earlier that's rolling off in Q4.
So there's an unusual uplift from a three-year US dollar
hedge, that the Corporate Bank is benefiting from that
evens out the mix next year. On the… Sorry, what was
the second question? I’m just blanking for a second,

-- 38 of 40 --

39
Andrew.
Andrew Coombs Sorry, no, it was just on deposit margin.
James von Moltke Yes. Sorry for the blank. We still plan, arguably with
conservative views on deposit margins and beta
behavior. Now, the scope for upside from conservative
assumptions there naturally has diminished, because
we've gone through the upswing and now the
beginning of the downswing of the cycle.
We're not seeing anything in terms of behavior today
that would suggest more pressure on the banks in
terms of pricing. And so that's encouraging. But as I
say, the scope for over-earning at this point in the cycle
is obviously less, I'm going to say, in beta terms, single-
digit percentages rather than double-digit percentages
that we once had.
Disclaimer
This transcript contains forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements are statements
that are not historical facts; they include statements about our beliefs and expectations and the
assumptions underlying them. These statements are based on plans, estimates and projections as
they are currently available to the management of Deutsche Bank. Forward-looking statements
therefore speak only as of the date they are made, and we undertake no obligation to update publicly
any of them in light of new information or future events.
By their very nature, forward-looking statements involve risks and uncertainties. A number of
important factors could therefore cause actual results to differ materially from those contained in
any forward-looking statement. Such factors include the conditions in the financial markets in
Germany, in Europe, in the United States and elsewhere from which we derive a substantial portion
of our revenues and in which we hold a substantial portion of our assets, the development of asset
prices and market volatility, potential defaults of borrowers or trading counterparties, the
implementation of our strategic initiatives, the reliability of our risk management policies,
procedures and methods, and other risks referenced in our filings with the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission. Such factors are described in detail in our SEC Form 20-F of 14 March 2024
under the heading “Risk Factors.” Copies of this document are readily available upon request or can
be downloaded from investor-relations.db.com.
This transcript also contains non-IFRS financial measures. For a reconciliation to directly
comparable figures reported under IFRS, to the extent such reconciliation is not provided in this
transcript, refer to the Q3 2024 Preliminary Financial Data Supplement, which is available at
investor-relations.db.com.
This transcript is provided solely for information purposes and shall not be construed as a solicitation
of an offer to buy or sell any securities or other financial instruments in any jurisdiction. No
investment decision relating to securities of or relating to Deutsche Bank AG or its affiliates should
be made on the basis of this document. Please refer to Deutsche Bank’s annual and interim reports,

-- 39 of 40 --

40
ad hoc announcements under Article 17 of Regulation (EU) No. 596/2014 and filings with the U.S.
Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) under Form 6-K.

-- 40 of 40 --