TRANSCRIPT

Q4 2023 — Fixed income call transcript

Q4 2023PDF · 20 pages207 KB
1
Deutsche Bank AG
Deutsche Bank Q4 2023 Fixed Income Conference Call
Friday, 02 February 2024 | 15:00 CET
Transcript
Speakers:
James von Moltke, Chief Financial Officer
Richard Stewart, Group Treasurer
Philip Teuchner, Investor Relations

-- 1 of 20 --

2
RICHARD STEWART
Slide 1 – Sharpened business model with growing revenues
- Thank you, Philip, and welcome from me
- It is a pleasure to be discussing our results with you today
- We have set Deutsche Bank’s course for sustainable growth through our
Global Hausbank strategy
- We delivered business growth and improved the quality of earnings
streams with a well-balanced business mix, as the benefits of our
sharpened business model came through
- Let’s start with our 2023 performance, on slide 1
- Revenues were in line with our guidance, at around 29 billion euros, up
6% year on year
- 78% of our revenues came from recurring earnings streams in 2023, up
from 71% in 2020
- We benefitted from rising interest rates, notably in the Corporate Bank
and Private Bank
- We also focused on building out our share of fee income across all
businesses
- Our progress in strengthening our franchise has been recognized with
upgrades from all leading rating agencies, which positions us to deepen
further engagement with current and new clients
- Now let’s look ahead at our revenue pathway to 2025 on slide 2
Slide 2 – Strong revenue trajectory supported by resilient and diversified franchise
positioning
- Since 2021, we’ve demonstrated revenue momentum well ahead of our
original target growth rate, due in part to a supportive interest rate
environment
- We are confident that as interest rates normalize, we can maintain an
upward revenue trajectory
- This is supported by the expected growth in noninterest income, which
already accounts for more than half of Group revenues, and our
investments in capital light activities

-- 2 of 20 --

3
- Based on this, we are raising our revenue compound annual growth rate
target from between 3.5 and 4.5% to between 5.5 and 6.5%, for the
period 2021 through 2025, aiming to reach 32 billion euros in 2025
- We expect non-interest income growth to contribute approximately 2.5
percentage points of the total CAGR between 2021 and 2025
- This is achievable through a number of levers:
o Growing share of wallet in the Corporate Bank
o Reaping the benefits of investments in Origination and Advisory
o Building on our ongoing strong relative performance in our FIC
franchise
o Benefitting from investments in the Private Bank to expand fee
generation
o and delivering on our growth strategies, including Passive, taking
full advantage of market recovery in Asset Management
- In respect of net interest income growth, we expect it to contribute
approximately 4 percentage points of the total CAGR between 2021 and
2025
- This reflects a normalization in 2024, followed by further growth in 2025
and beyond
- Now let me turn to costs, on slide 3
Slide 3 – Reinforced cost execution supports operating leverage
- We see a clear path to costs of approximately 20 billion euros in 2025
- Over the next two years, our aim is to drive reductions across both
nonoperating costs and our adjusted cost base, by managing our run-
rate and driving efficiency measures
- We foresee reductions in nonoperating costs of around 700 million euros
from 2023 levels in the next two years
- On adjusted costs, as we have already communicated, we see bank levies
coming down by between 350 and 400 million euros over the next two
years
- The additional 400-million-euro net reduction will come from further
progress on our operational efficiency program

-- 3 of 20 --

4
- We have already executed on measures with delivered or expected
savings of 1.3 billion euros, of which 900 million euros of savings were
realized to date
- Our detailed implementation roadmap gives us confidence in delivering
noninterest expenses of approximately 20 billion euros in 2025,
providing a clear pathway to our cost/income ratio target of 62.5%
- We’re conscious that we’re operating in a fast-changing environment
and our path towards 2025 may be impacted by external factors
- We have the toolkit in place to implement additional measures which
would enable us to further flex our cost base to meet our cost/income
ratio target, even if we encounter unforeseen revenue headwinds
Slide 4 – CET1 ratio remains strong
- Turning now to the recent development of capital on slide 4
- Our fourth quarter Common Equity Tier 1 ratio came in at 13.7%, a 20
basis points decrease compared to the previous quarter
- This quarter-on-quarter reduction reflects lower capital as our net
income was more than offset by capital deductions – most notably for
shareholder dividends, AT1 coupons and deferred tax assets
- Risk weighted assets were flat over the quarter excluding FX effects
- Credit risk RWA increased over the quarter reflecting business growth
and model changes
- These increases were partly offset by capital optimization initiatives as
we continue to focus on the capital efficiency of our balance sheet
- Lower market risk and operational risk RWA more than offset higher
credit risk RWA over the quarter, reflecting lower market volatility and an
improved risk profile
Slide 5 – Capital ratios well above regulatory requirements
- Our capital ratios remain well above regulatory requirements, as shown
on slide 5
- The Common Equity Tier 1 MDA buffer now stands at 258 basis points
or 9 billion euros of CET1 capital

-- 4 of 20 --

5
- The quarter-on-quarter decrease of 20 basis points reflects the lower
CET1 capital ratio
- Our total capital MDA buffer was also impacted by 6 basis points due to
higher Tier 2 capital maturity haircuts and now stands at 274 basis points
- As announced in December, the ECB has reduced our 2024 Pillar 2
requirement from 2.7 to 2.65 percent, which increases our buffer
accordingly
Slide 6 – Leverage ratio slightly lower
- Moving to slide 6
- At the end of the fourth quarter our leverage ratio stood at 4.5%, 13 basis
points lower compared to the previous quarter
- Within that, a 7 basis points decline was due to lower Tier 1 capital, in line
with CET1 capital movement
- A 9 basis points decline resulted from higher leverage exposure, mainly
driven by trading activities and increased Liquidity Reserves from higher
deposit volumes
Slide 7 – Continued high loss-absorbing capacity
- We continue to operate with a significant loss-absorbing capacity, well
above all of our requirements, as shown on slide 7
- The MREL surplus, our most binding constraint, remained stable at 17
billion euros at year-end
- This includes a decrease of 1 billion euros from lower CET1 capital and
an increase of 1 billion euros from lower RWA
- Our loss-absorbing capacity buffer stands at a comfortable level and
continues to provide us with the flexibility to pause issuing new Eligible
Liabilities instruments for approximately one year
Slide 8 – Stable lending while deposit momentum continues
- Moving now to the development in our loan and deposit books over the
quarter on slide 8
- All figures in the commentary are adjusted for FX effects

-- 5 of 20 --

6
- Loans have been essentially flat during the fourth quarter as well as on a
year-on-year basis, driven by more muted client demand and selective
balance sheet deployment throughout the year
- For 2024 we expect moderate loan growth in all segments, while most
pronounced in Wealth Management, in line with our strategic
investments in that business
- Deposits have further increased by 16 billion euros or 3% compared to
last quarter, bringing us back to year-end 2022 levels
- In line with previous quarters, growth has again been strongest in the
Corporate Bank, with good momentum across products and client
segments
- Deposits in the Private Bank remained stable in the quarter, driven by
continued inflows from our retail campaigns and recent signs of easing
inflationary pressures
- Looking ahead, we expect moderate growth in deposits this year due to
positive business momentum, ongoing tailwinds from the most recent
rating upgrade as well as structurally lower headwinds from inflation
Slide 9 – Strong interest income in key banking book segments
- The following slides will look in some detail at the development of our
interest income, including details around our hedging
- Starting on slide 9, you can see that we reported strong absolute net
interest income across our key banking book-segments, all reporting
higher net interest income and margin versus the prior quarter and prior
year quarter
- The Corporate Bank saw higher deposit balances in the fourth quarter,
which supported higher NII and reported NIM
- Private Bank margins and NII were stable throughout 2023, as the
gradual increase in deposit betas was fully compensated by rollovers at
higher rates in the interest rate hedge portfolio
- Group NII and NIM were marginally down in the quarter, as sequential
improvements in the banking book segments and in other funding effects
were more than offset by the impact of accounting asymmetry, largely
held in C&O
- As we have discussed in prior quarters, the accounting asymmetry effect
is revenue neutral although it impacts reported NII

-- 6 of 20 --

7
Slide 10 – Structurally stable net interest income
- Let me now provide an update on the outlook for net interest income on
slide 10
- The numbers on the following slides are based on the market
expectations for interest rates as of the 26th January this year
- Our reported full-year NII of 13.6 billion euros was broadly stable for the
group in 2023 compared to the prior year, but that does not reflect the
economic contribution to group revenues due to significant moves in
accounting effects which are offset in non-interest revenues
- Focusing on our three key NII-generating-business-units, as well as other
funding costs not offset by accounting effects, we see an improvement
of just over 2 billion euros and a cumulative benefit since 2021 of over 4
billion euros
- Looking ahead on the same basis, we expect a decline of around 600
million euros in 2024, driven by the convergence of betas to steady-state
levels
- We expect this to be followed by an increase of around 400 million euros
in 2025 which brings us close to 2023 NII levels, as the beta convergence
is largely offset by the rollover of our hedge portfolios as well as balance
sheet growth
- In line with prior guidance, we expect a larger sequential reduction in the
Corporate Bank than in the Private Bank in 2024
- We expect a sequential improvement, excluding accounting
asymmetries, in the Corporate & Other segment of around 300 million
euros relating to reduced funding costs for corporate assets and lower
retained liquidity and funding costs
- We may outperform this guidance if market expectations regarding rate
cuts do not fully materialize or deposit betas increase more slowly than
expected
Slide 11 – Deposit margin offset by hedging and lending growth
- Let me provide more detail on the drivers of our NII outlook on slide 11
- As you can see on the chart, we expect deposit margins to reduce in 2024
and 2025, but that this effect will be largely compensated by our hedges
and lending portfolios

-- 7 of 20 --

8
- Deposit margins will be adversely impacted both by the expected
decrease in central bank policy rates and increased deposit betas. We
expect a 2.5 billion euro reduction in NII driven by these effects across
the two years
- We expect a 1.7 billion euro increase in NII from our deposit and equity
hedge portfolios over the same period
- While there is significant uncertainty in the market outlook, there is a
structural offset between deposit margin and hedges
- We have around 230 billion euros of long-term interest rate hedges on
our deposits and equity
- Once deposit betas have reached steady state levels, our NII will mostly
be sensitive to long-term rates as our hedge portfolio rolls over with
limited sensitivity to short-term rates unless moves are sharp enough to
re-introduce beta lags or approach the zero bound
- The third major driver of our outlook is our loan portfolio, which we
expect to provide most of our remaining NII increase. That benefit will
stem from portfolio growth and from margin expansion across all three
banking book segments
Slide 12 – Interest Rate Hedges smooth NII path
- On slide 12 we provide more details on the long-term interest rate
hedging of our deposit books
- The hedge book extends the tenor of interest rate risk, with hedges
entered with a 10-year maturity and a weighted average maturity of the
portfolio of 4 to 5 years
- We expect an additional tailwind of around 1 billion euros over next two
years relative to the full year 2023
- Roughly half of that tailwind comes from hedges already executed, the
other half from roll-over of maturing tranches
- As you can see on the chart, more than 90% of that is locked in with
existing positions
- Overall, we will continue our strategy to reduce NII sensitivity through
hedging
- In the appendix we have our regular slide on interest rate sensitivity,
which you can see has reduced versus our prior quarter disclosure

-- 8 of 20 --

9
Slide 13 – Sound liquidity and funding base
- Moving to slide 13, highlighting the development of our key liquidity
metrics
- Compared to the third quarter the year-end liquidity coverage ratio
increased by eight percentage points to 140%
- With a daily average LCR of 131% we have maintained a robust liquidity
position throughout the fourth quarter
- The spot LCR increase at quarter-end was mainly driven by deposit
growth on the back of higher client engagement in wholesale markets
following the recent rating upgrade as well as lower net cash outflows
- The stock of 219 billion euros of HQLA, of which about 95% is held in
cash and Level 1 securities, has increased by 9 billion euros in the quarter
and is a reflection of the high quality of our liquidity pool
- We prudently manage the stock of our securities via daily monitoring and
stress testing
- These are marked to market and predominantly comprise highly-rated
government bonds, SSAs and covered bonds
- The surplus above the regulatory minimum increased by about 11 billion
euros to 62 billion euros quarter on quarter
- As previously communicated, our long-term LCR target is unchanged at
130%
- In 2024 we aim to manage the LCR back to targeted levels including
remaining TLTRO repayments and business growth
- The net stable funding ratio is unchanged at 121%, reflecting our
conservative and stable balance sheet
- This represents a surplus of about 107 billion euros above the regulatory
requirement
- The available longer-term stable funding sources for the bank remain
well diversified and are supported by a robust deposit franchise, which
continues contributing about two thirds to the Group’s stable funding
base
- Looking ahead, we aim to maintain this funding mix and we have no
remaining reliance on TLTRO funding for our NSFR at year-end

-- 9 of 20 --

10
Slide 14 – 2024 issuance plan at € 13-18bn
- Moving now to our issuance plan on slide 14
- In December 2023, S&P upgraded our credit ratings by one notch,
matching the upgrades Deutsche Bank has received from Moody’s and
Fitch
- This rating action supported the bank’s spread development over the last
weeks of 2023
- Last year we issued a total volume of 17 billion euros, including 1.5 billion
dollars of pre-funding for 2024
- For this year we anticipate similar requirements as in 2023 and guide to
an issuance volume of 13 to 18 billion euros
- We have already completed around 3 billion euros, primarily driven by a
dual-tranche senior-preferred transaction issued on the 8th of January
- In addition, we announced the completion of the transition of an AT1
security with a USD LIBOR linkage to risk-free rates on the 10th of
January
Slide 15 – Summary & outlook
- Before going to your questions let me conclude with a summary on slide
15
- We have revised our revenue growth target to 5.5-6.5% over the 2021 to
2025 period, supported by investments across all business areas and a
more favorable economic and market backdrop
- We are fully focused on delivering our cost plan to maintain our targeted
quarterly run-rate of 5 billion euros of adjusted costs
- We expect provisions for credit losses to remain at around 25 to 30 basis
points of average loans in 2024
- On the capital management side we are focused on supporting revenue
growth while maintaining stable capital buffers across the stack
- And we are confident that our credit spreads have further room to
perform, continuing the positive trend we have seen in the recent past
- With that, let us turn to your questions

-- 10 of 20 --

11
Questions and Answers
Lee Street Hello, good afternoon, both, and thank you for taking
(Citigroup) my questions. I have three for you, please. Firstly, on
your revenue growth targets, within the Investment
Bank, are you able to give us a little bit of colour on
what wallet share assumptions you assume to achieve
your €32 billion goal?
Secondly, obviously, there is naturally a lot of focus on
capital return, but capital has been a source of volatility
for Deutsche in the past. So, what comfort can you give
to fixed income investors, and with that in mind, should
I think about the 13.5% common equity tier one ratio
for the full year 2025 as being your new target that
you're working with now?
And then finally, as you rightly point out, you have had a
very strong run of ratings upgrades. Just any thoughts
on your ratings trajectory from here, and if you have
any specific ratings targets that you'd like to achieve?
That would be my three questions. Thank you.
James von Moltke Hi, it's James, and thanks for joining the call. Thanks for
the questions. I'll take the first one briefly. Our overall
path on non-interest revenues over the next couple of
years, as we talked about a bit yesterday, will see
upwards of €3 billion of improvements, and potentially,
half of that would be in Origination & Advisory, with
some additional help in the Investment Bank from our
Fixed Income and Currencies platform.
One thing just to clarify, a statement from yesterday's
call, the market share growth would represent two
thirds of the Origination & Advisory and the market
wallet growth, about one third. And inside that market
wallet growth, our assumptions, in line with some
external providers, is that the Corporate Finance wallet
will grow something between 15% and 20% this year,
and next year, potentially, another 5% to 10%.
That's a recovery from two years of going backwards,
and to our mind, is reasonably in line with historical
patterns of that market cycle. So, we're reasonably

-- 11 of 20 --

12
encouraged by the signs that that is, in fact, what we're
what we expect to see. To your point about what is the
market share that underlies that?
We've been travelling around 2% market share for the
last couple of years, actually 190 basis points that last
year. And I think our assumption is reasonably
conservative. Not overly aggressive, but that we might
increase it to as much as 3%, reflecting the investments
that we've made on our platform, including Numis.
But also, reflecting, I think, an opportunity to grow,
given some of the dislocations that are out there in the
marketplace, and potentially, also recovery, particularly
in portions where the mix has been unfavourable to us.
So, we're feeling really good about the investment and
the path forward on both the market increase and our
wallet share.
Richard Stewart And then, Lee, maybe I'll take the same question. Hi, it's
Richard here. Happy Friday, and thanks for joining.
Your question was on capital, and how we're feeling
about that 13.5% ratio in 2025, and how you should
think about it. We finished the year with a 13.7% ratio,
as you know, that's 260 basis points or so ahead of our
MDA.
We've continuously increased MDA buffer over the last
few years, supported by higher less volatile earnings.
And our current level of distance to MDA puts us in a
pretty comfortable position. We've demonstrated that
we are able to manage our capital ratios consistently
above those targets, so we think that puts us in a good
place for the CRR3 go live in Jan 2025.
In terms of how we intend to use the generated capital,
as we showed on our slides yesterday, with different
purposes. So, one is we target shareholder distribution
of 50%. We firmly believe that a higher share price will
also be beneficial to bondholders, not only as it
increases the first loss absorption layer.
We intend to invest around 25% of the generated
capital into our business divisions and support their

-- 12 of 20 --

13
franchises. And then the remaining 25% can be used
for model changes, regulatory inflation, and
opportunistic business investments, any other further
distributions that management may feel we need to
make.
And this last block gives us that capital management
flexibility, which we view is important for steering. How
do we think about the 13.5% for year-end 2025? To be
clear, we have not changed our CET1 ratio target. We
target to maintain a level of a minimum of 200 basis
points above MDA.
It's not a fixed level, because as you know, that MDA
level does move around with cyclical buffers, pillar 2
requirements, and other such like. And at this stage, we
think that 200 basis points minimum level is where we
think is the right level. 13.5% is more than 200 basis
points above that expected MDA for year-end 2025.
And from today's perspective, this level seems to be
consistent for us bouncing all the other capital uses
that I just mentioned. So, hopefully, that gives you
some clarification on how we’re thinking about the ratio
right now. And then in terms of ratings, as you correctly
point out, we're pleased with the upgrade from S&P in
December.
That's the third upgrade that we have got from our
mandated rating agencies in 2023. And what that now
means is that all our counterparty ratings are now rated
single A or better, and our Tier 2 rating have moved
back to investment grade with all agencies.
And that experience wide the spread impact was more
pronounced, when that occurred in December in this
asset class, compared to the senior instruments. In
addition, we're seeing some further revenue potential in
rating sensitive divisions, such as the Investment Bank,
for example, asset based commercial paper, or in
trusted agency services businesses in the Corporate
Bank.
And then when we think about the rating outlook from

-- 13 of 20 --

14
here, I guess following two upgrade cycles since we
started our transformation journey in 2019. All ratings
now carry a stable outlook, so we don't see any racing
pressure in either direction for the foreseeable future.
With idiosyncratic improvements being reflected in
today's ratings, further upgrades will require
sustainable improvements in profitability, and higher
capital ratios. At the same time, we are carefully
managing the potential downside risks, which could
also arise from industry or macro related factors.
So, all in all, we remain in a very close dialogue with our
mandated rating agencies, but we feel we have a pretty
stable credit rating outlook from here.
Lee Street Thank you very much, both, for all your responses.
Good afternoon.
Daniel David Good afternoon, all. Congratulations on the results, and
(Autonomous) thanks for taking my questions. I've got two. The first
on leverage, and the second on issuance. With regard
to leverage, I’m just interested in how you think about
leverage. When I look at your ratio now, it looks a little
bit tight, versus the requirement.
Do you think you're constrained by leverage over CET1
or below those metrics? And also, how might
supervisory changes to an average leverage ratio asset
ratio within a period, rather than a period end metric,
affect your IB business? So, moving towards what they
have in the UK, I'm just interested in what that might do
to your IB business.
And then secondly, just on issuance. I can see, in your
plans, you've got one to two billion of AT1 and Tier 2.
Can you give a bit more detail on that? When I when I
look at your ratios, you've got a bit of a shortfall in Tier
2. So, should we think that's to fill the Tier 2
requirements? Or when I look ahead to your AT1 calls
next year, they’re quite big. Could you tap the AT1
market? Any guidance would be useful. Thanks.
James von Moltke Thanks for the questions. I’ll start briefly, it’s James, on
the leverage item, but really pass it on to Richard. I

-- 14 of 20 --

15
think we think of managing the leverage ratio is really a
resource optimisation focus. Because it is, I think, a
little bit more flexible, in terms of timing and use of
leverage, than then the risk-weighted asset profile.
And hence, whether it’s 4.5, or maybe slightly higher,
the real question is, controlling the leverage to utilise
that resource effectively, in light of both the client
demand for leverage exposure on our balance sheet,
and also, the revenue opportunity for it. So, we think it
is an optimisation question, with the principal constraint
still being on the on the CET1 to risk-weighted assets.
Richard Stewart Thanks. I'll just add to that. Our distance to MDA is
generally consistent across all of our ratios. And then in
terms of our planning, and how the Investment Bank
thinks about things, they also think about the intra-
quarter volatility, which they may or may not have,
which they factor into their business model, as well as
into how we think about our capital planning, as well.
So, as James says, it's something we can dial up and
down, depending on client demand. So, we don't
consider ourselves leverage constrained, in that sense.
Your question around issuance and AT1 and Tier 2. If
you look at our current total capital stack, and where
the regulatory requirements are, then you'll see that we
have overfilled the bucket on the AT1 side, a little bit
under on the Tier 2 side.
So, that probably gives you an indication of how we're
thinking about 2024. Obviously, we always think just
where the client demand and mechanics in the market
are at any one particular time. We are cognisant of our
Tier 1 calls coming due in 2025, but that's a long way
off right now.
So, at the moment, we're probably thinking more
towards Tier 2 in 2024, rather than AT1s. But if the
market gives us an opportunity, then that is something
we will consider.
Daniel David Thank you very much.

-- 15 of 20 --

16
Robert Smalley Hi. Thanks for taking my question, and thanks for doing
(UBS) the call. A couple of items. One, on commercial real
estate, you talked about the US, you've given some
disclosure in the slides, which is great. Talk a little bit
about the experience in Europe, and where you're most
exposed, and also, in Germany, given the economy
there.
Secondly, another issuance question. Your numbers
that you had planned for last year, the gross was right
in line, but the composition was slightly different with
more senior preferred. Could you talk about the
evolution of your thinking, and what you were
addressing with that last year, and what other tweaks
you might see this year?
And then third, your spreads have come in nicely over
the past several months, however, still wide versus
peers. You continue to deliver on your numbers. Your
issuance amounts are going to be the same year to
year, your peers are going to issue more. My question
is, you've done tenders in the past. What else do you
have in the toolbox to tighten up your credit spreads?
Thanks.
James von Moltke Thanks, Robert. Thank you for joining us. It’s James. I’ll
take the CRE question, and leave issuance and spreads
to Richard. If I use very round numbers, we reported
450 of total credit loss provisions million last year. And
that, more or less, broke down 350 in the US and 100
outside.
Within the 100, a small amount was Asia, so you're left
with some amount, considerably less than 100 million in
Europe. We are obviously cognisant that there is some
pressure, I wouldn't say stress, but there's pressure on
the commercial real estate market in Europe.
And individual projects can be under stress, depending
on where and what the investment was. I wouldn't see it
as necessarily changing that much, especially Germany,
as you say. Our view is that Germany, generally, wasn't
as frothy, although valuations, obviously, went up, and
there were some places where you've seen some

-- 16 of 20 --

17
distressed sales.
And generally, I don't think it was as frothy, nor as
concentrated a market, and therefore, we don't see the
same degree of pressure in Germany. Obviously, it's a
space we're going to continue to watch carefully around
the world, but I don't see a change, really, to the pattern
geographically, perhaps, that we had last year.
Richard Stewart Thanks, Robert. When I think about the issuance mix,
which I think is your question, we set a plan at the start
of the year, which is driven by business expectations for
how they want to deploy their balance sheets at any
one time.
I think, just last year, the composition of that balance
sheet change, which essentially, allowed us to issue
more senior preferred and senior nonpreferred, just
given what was happening on the overall portfolio, in
terms of loan growth not materialising as was originally
expected.
So, that generally drove that that mix change. When I
think about spreads, and what we can do in the toolkit, I
think about a couple of things. One is that we've always
been pretty consistent in liability management
exercises or tenders. We have used that toolbox
sporadically over the last few years, so that always
remains.
So, the way I think of it structurally is around how we
removed the beta or the volatility premium attached to
Deutsche Bank's name. That's something, which the
management is deeply focused on, and that's really
around consistent execution and sustainability of
earnings.
So, for me, that's where the opportunity really comes
from, from the spread perspective. And I think that just
comes from continued division execution, and stable
earnings growth. So, that would be my answer to your
question.
Robert Smalley Thanks very much. Very helpful.

-- 17 of 20 --

18
Alexei Lougovtsov Good afternoon. Thank you very much for taking my
(Bank of America) question. It is a follow-up on what Robert asked about
commercial real estate. My first question is about the
US. You mentioned modified, restructured, or defaulted
loans as a driver of high provisions. Could you please
tell us what locations those modified or defaulted loans
are in?
And my second question. Again, you commented on
Europe a bit. I wonder what trends you're seeing in the
European real estate loans in the light of new green
requirements for offices and rental buildings, which are
being rolled out. Would you expect greater provisioning
needs coming from some of the landlords coming in
under stress?
James von Moltke Thanks. It’s James, I'll take the CRE question. Point one
is our focus on the refinancing wave has been the US.
So, the disclosure you see on page 26 focuses on US.
The driver of crystallisation of credit loss provisions
tends to be for each loan, as it approaches an extension
or maturity date.
And hence, our greatest focus in managing this
portfolio is really anticipating those dates, working with
sponsors, to get the properties through the extension
or refinancing. And as the graphic tries to indicate,
modifications, when there is an economic split of the
costs, that tends to drive, then, a credit event for us
around the modification.
So, it's that wave focused on the United States
geographically that we're focused on. On your second,
it's actually a global comment. So, the ESG eligibility of
properties tends to be a feature of their value and
letability, not just in Europe, but also, in other
jurisdictions. And it can lead to a value loss, where
properties aren't really future proofed in that way.
It's something that we account for in our underwriting.
So, naturally, we're seeking to move the portfolio, as
much as possible, into, and underwrite new lending, in
ESG, or E, eligible properties, as we do believe that they
will hold value better, and remain attractive in the lease

-- 18 of 20 --

19
market for longer.
Alexei Lougovtsov Thank you. Just a quick follow-up. So, on the US, can
you name any specific locations? Is it Manhattan? Is it
San Francisco? Is it something else, where you now
have to provision more?
James von Moltke No. I wouldn't focus on a specific location. New York
has held up relatively well, I would say the West Coast
less so. Again, you can see our split of office exposures
on the graphic on page 26, so there's no one place
necessarily where we see the highest losses coming
from. I can say that the markets we're most focused on
the portfolio events, are San Francisco and Seattle, of
our exposure.
Alexei Lougovtsov Thanks very much.
Jeremy Sigee Hi there. Thank you. I would just be really interested to
(BNP) get a treasurer perspective on slide 12, which I know is
in the equity presentation, as well, but it's obviously a
very interesting one about the long-term hedges. I
guess, really, the question is, what should we expect
going forward beyond 2025?
Does that yield continue converging up towards the
ten-year swap, which would obviously be quite a big
upside to NII. And over what timeframe would that
happen? And are there any major offsets to that, as we
think about Group NII?
Richard Stewart Thanks, Jeremy. Thanks for your question. So, the way
to think about that is, if all the things stay the same,
then essentially, we will move towards that ten year
swap line. So, therefore, we will just roll forward the
portfolio towards the blended cost of hedges we have,
essentially, we will move towards that long term rate.
And so, that is a tailwind for us, all things being equal.
So, your assumption is correct, roughly, that is 300
million a year, which seems to be linear extrapolations.
So, there's upside beyond 2025, is the short answer.
Jeremy Sigee Thank you.

-- 19 of 20 --

20
Disclaimer
This transcript contains forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements are statements
that are not historical facts; they include statements about our beliefs and expectations and the
assumptions underlying them. These statements are based on plans, estimates and projections as
they are currently available to the management of Deutsche Bank. Forward-looking statements
therefore speak only as of the date they are made, and we undertake no obligation to update publicly
any of them in light of new information or future events.
By their very nature, forward-looking statements involve risks and uncertainties. A number of
important factors could therefore cause actual results to differ materially from those contained in
any forward-looking statement. Such factors include the conditions in the financial markets in
Germany, in Europe, in the United States and elsewhere from which we derive a substantial portion
of our revenues and in which we hold a substantial portion of our assets, the development of asset
prices and market volatility, potential defaults of borrowers or trading counterparties, the
implementation of our strategic initiatives, the reliability of our risk management policies,
procedures and methods, and other risks referenced in our filings with the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission. Such factors are described in detail in our SEC Form 20-F of 17 March 2023
under the heading “Risk Factors.” Copies of this document are readily available upon request or can
be downloaded from investor-relations.db.com.
This transcript also contains non-IFRS financial measures. For a reconciliation to directly
comparable figures reported under IFRS, to the extent such reconciliation is not provided in this
transcript, refer to the Q4 2023 Preliminary Financial Data Supplement, which is available at
investor-relations.db.com.
This transcript is provided solely for information purposes and shall not be construed as a solicitation
of an offer to buy or sell any securities or other financial instruments in any jurisdiction. No
investment decision relating to securities of or relating to Deutsche Bank AG or its affiliates should
be made on the basis of this document. Please refer to Deutsche Bank’s annual and interim reports,
ad hoc announcements under Article 17 of Regulation (EU) No. 596/2014 and filings with the U.S.
Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) under Form 6-K.

-- 20 of 20 --