TRANSCRIPT

Q4 2024 — Fixed income call transcript

Q4 2024PDF · 24 pages184 KB
1
Deutsche Bank AG
Deutsche Bank Q4/FY 2024 Fixed Income Conference Call
Friday 31st January 2025 | 15:00 CET
Transcript
Speakers:
James von Moltke, Chief Financial Officer
Richard Stewart, Group Treasurer
Philip Teuchner, Investor Relations

-- 1 of 24 --

2
Slide 2 – Resilient full-year results reflecting ongoing strong operating performance
- Thank you, Philip, and welcome from me
- 2024 was a vital transition year for us. We have moved past a number of
legacy items, absorbing a series of nonoperating costs, predominantly
litigation matters, which have masked the underlying strength of our
business
- However, we are now set for a clean and significantly more profitable
year in 2025, with the foundation now built for further improvements in
the years beyond
- Let me discuss our operating momentum on slide 2
- We increased 2024 pre-provision profit by 19% compared to 2023 if
adjusted for three specific litigation items, as well as the goodwill
impairment in 2023
- The specific litigation items in 2024 comprised the Postbank takeover
litigation matter, elevated provisions for Polish FX mortgages and the
de-recognition of the reimbursement asset for the RusChemAlliance
litigation matter
- Growth was driven by both revenue momentum and cost discipline
- Revenues grew by 4% year on year with around 75% coming from more
predictable revenue streams
- Adjusted costs decreased 1% year on year to 20.4 billion euros, or 20.2
billion euros excluding the pre-guided real estate measures and UK
bank levy true-up in the fourth quarter
- Excluding these items, we delivered four quarters of adjusted costs of
around 5 billion euros, in line with our plan
- Let us now look at the momentum we have created in each of our
businesses, against the goals set in 2022 on slide 3
Slide 3 – Clear traction across divisions set to deliver sustainable growth and
higher profitability
- At our investor day in March 2022, we set ambitious objectives for 2025
- With twelve months to go, our business-growth-focused strategies are
delivering strong results against these objectives
- The Corporate Bank remains at the core of the Deutsche Bank franchise
since our transformation and we have further enhanced its value

-- 2 of 24 --

3
proposition through a strengthened client franchise and investments in
technology, supported by our global network
- The division outperformed its revenue growth ambitions despite
normalizing interest rates and delivered a return on tangible equity of
13% in 2024, three times its 2021 level
- The Investment Bank is outperforming its revenue growth target and
delivered a RoTE of 9% in 2024, cementing its position as a leading
investment bank
- In Fixed Income & Currencies, we have built strong market share and
demonstrated sustained growth in Financing, which is up 12% year on
year in 2024
- We achieved significant year-on-year growth of over 60% in O&A in
2024 through considerable market share increases in a growing fee
pool
- The Private Bank continues to leverage its leading market position with
net inflows of 29 billion euros, supporting noninterest revenue growth
of 5% last year, in line with our strategy, and the division grew revenues
in line with target since 2021
- Asset Management again grew assets under management in 2024, by
115 billion euros, and surpassed 1 trillion euros for the first time,
boosted by net inflows of 42 billion euros into passive investments
- Let me now turn to the question why we feel confident in reaching our
2025 revenue growth ambitions, on slide 4
-
Slide 4 – Strong execution and demonstrated tailwinds underpin confidence in
revenue trajectory
- Since 2021, we have delivered a compound annual growth rate of 5.8%,
in line with our upgraded target range
- In 2025, we expect continued franchise momentum and our capital-
light businesses to drive further growth supported by our investments,
increasing the revenue CAGR to around 5.9%
- We have a clear roadmap towards our 2025 target
- In the Corporate Bank, we expect revenues to grow by around 5.5% or
400 million euros largely from scaling of commissions and fee income,
predominantly in Trade Finance and fee-based institutional business.
Resilient net interest income will provide further support

-- 3 of 24 --

4
- Investment Bank revenues are expected to grow by around 8% as we
see encouraging trends in the market, good levels of corporate activity
and confidence, solid financing conditions and pent-up private equity
demand
- In the Private Bank, we expect revenue growth of around 400 million
euros or 4% driven by higher NII from continued business volume
growth and the deposit hedge rollover. This will be further
complemented by growing noninterest income, harvesting benefits
from higher assets under management and growth in Investment
Solutions
- Finally, we expect Asset Management to grow revenues by around 300
million euros or 12.5%. We expect the business to benefit from the
growth in assets under management during 2024 and a strong equity
market development this year, which should boost management fees in
2025. We furthermore expect continued growth in Passive, including X-
trackers and in Alternatives
- These drivers underline our confidence in achieving our revenue goal of
around 32 billion euros in 2025 before FX benefits. At year-end FX
rates, we expect this number to be around 32.8 billion euros
- Let us now look at the path to our RoTE target, on slide 5
Slide 5 – Set to achieve >10% RoTE target via positive operating leverage
- We remain on a clear path to achieve our RoTE target of above 10% in
2025 driven by focused execution across all three delivery pillars of our
Global Hausbank strategy
- As you saw, we have a business-by-business roadmap to grow
revenues to around 32 billion euros in 2025, in line with our target
compound annual growth rate of 5.5 to 6.5%
- Operational efficiencies play a key role in keeping adjusted costs flat in
2025, and thereby reducing total noninterest expenses as nonoperating
costs normalize
- Capital efficiencies have delivered cumulative RWA equivalent
reductions of 24 billion euros, close to our end-2025 goal of 25 to 30
billion euros. In the fourth quarter alone, we delivered 2 billion euros of
RWA equivalent reductions driven by data and process improvements
- We are confident we will reach the upper end of our target range by
year-end 2025 through further securitizations and data and process
improvements

-- 4 of 24 --

5
- Delivery on these pillars gives us a clear path to a RoTE above 10% in
2025
- Firstly, the non-repeat of significant litigation items in 2024 gives us a
starting point of an adjusted RoTE above 7%. Reaching our 32-billion-
euro revenue target is expected to add more than 2 percentage points
to our 2025 RoTE
- Secondly, we expect an additional contribution of around 60 basis
points from the reduction in noninterest expenses
- Together, this would bring us already to our targeted RoTE level
- And finally, we expect a contribution of around 40 basis points from the
reduction of provisions in 2025 towards more normalized levels, in line
with our guidance with our third-quarter results
- Let us now look a bit closer into some Treasury-specific items over the
next pages
Slide 7 – Banking book NII above prior guidance in 2024
- As we said before, we remain well positioned to continue delivering
strong net interest income over the coming years, so let me start with a
review of our fourth quarter on slide 7
- NII across key banking book segments and other funding was strong at
3.3 billion euros, up sequentially and broadly flat on the prior year
quarter
- Compared to the third quarter, slightly higher deposit volumes, in
particular overnight deposits, offset the expected beta convergence in
the Corporate Bank
- Private Bank NII was up sequentially as we guided before, and FIC
Financing continued to grow its loan portfolio with a corresponding
increase in quarterly revenues
- With that, let me turn to the full year NII trends and the outlook for 2025
on the next page
Slide 8 – NII expected to further grow in 2025
- Given the stronger NII in the fourth quarter we outperformed our prior
2024 full-year guidance of 13.1 billion euros, reporting 13.3 billion
euros across our key banking book segments and other funding

-- 5 of 24 --

6
- This is about 100 million euros higher than 2023, reflecting the
resilience of our NII, even during an environment of falling rates and
beta convergence
- For 2025, we expect NII yet again to increase to around 13.6 billion
euros, a sequential increase of around 400 million euros
- This is in line with our guidance provided last quarter, but reflective of
the outperformance in the fourth quarter
- The key drivers are the rollover effect from our hedges, supported by
portfolio growth in Private Bank, Corporate Bank and FIC Financing
- Let us now look a bit closer into the contribution of the long-term
interest rate hedge portfolio on slide 9
Slide 9 – Long-term hedge contribution shields NII against lower policy rates
- Based on forward rates at year-end, we expect the net interest income
from the hedge book to grow by several hundred million euros each
year as we roll maturing hedges
- On the chart, for simplicity, we have included the average fixed rate for
Euro hedges maturing in each year, as well as the current market
implied replacement rate
- The shaded area indicates the roll-over benefit, and as we have
discussed before, the majority of our hedges are 10 year swaps, which
gives an indication of the volume to be replaced each year
- It is important to note that we also have roughly 10% of our hedges in
other currencies, notably in US-Dollar, which positively impacts the
overall hedge income
- The currency mix as well as hedges executed at higher rates indicate
that the hedge income will increase more steadily than the simple rate
differential
- With respect to 2025, that increase is around 300 million euros, with
more than 90% of the income locked in with existing positions
- In current rate conditions, we are more sensitive to the long-term rate
development and less sensitive to short-term movements in policy rates

-- 6 of 24 --

7
Slide 10 – Resilient lending while deposit growth continues
- Moving now to the development in our loan and deposit books on slide
10
- All figures in the commentary are adjusted for FX effects
- Overall, loans have remained stable during the fourth quarter as lending
activities remain subdued in some of our client segments
- Against these headwinds, our Investment Bank loan book strongly
increased by 5 billion euros in 2024, supported by strategic initiatives to
grow FIC Financing
- While we expect this trend in FIC to continue, we also see encouraging
growth potential in Wealth Management
- Moving to deposits, where our well-diversified portfolio grew by 5
billion euros compared to the previous quarter
- Within that, we have seen substantial growth from German Retail
clients driven by our deposit campaigns
- Based on this encouraging momentum, we see opportunities to further
grow in this segment in 2025
- In line with previous guidance, Corporate Bank deposits have reduced
modestly during the fourth quarter
- In the appendix we provide further granularity around the quality of our
loan and deposit portfolio
Slide 11 – Sound liquidity and funding base at targeted levels
- On slide 11 we highlight the development of our key liquidity metrics
- We managed our spot Liquidity Coverage Ratio at year-end to 131%,
representing a surplus above the regulatory minimum of 53 billion euros
- With a daily average liquidity coverage ratio of 128% during the quarter
we operated with a sound liquidity position at our targeted level
- The quarter-end stock of 226 billion euros of HQLA, of which we hold
about 95% in cash and Level 1 securities, slightly decreased quarter
over quarter and is mainly driven by asset growth in the businesses
- The surplus reduction was mainly driven by an increase in net cash
outflows

-- 7 of 24 --

8
- The Net Stable Funding Ratio at 121% reflects the strength of our
funding base with more than two thirds of the Group’s stable funding
sources coming from deposits
- The surplus above regulatory requirements decreased to 110 billion
euros
Slide 12 – CET 1 ratio remains strong
- Turning to capital on slide 12
- Our fourth-quarter Common Equity Tier 1 ratio came in at 13.8%
- CET1 capital decreased primarily reflecting the deduction of the 750
million share buy-back from excess capital
- RWA were lower adjusted for FX, driven by market risk
- The marginal increase in credit risk was driven by model changes,
largely offset by reductions from capital efficiency measures
- With respect to the CRR3 go-live, effective on 1st January 2025, our
pro-forma CET1 ratio was 13.9%
- However, the CRR3 go-live will also lead to around 5 billion euros of
RWA equivalent impact from operational risk in the first quarter; hence,
the total impact of CRR3 is a CET1 ratio burden of ~15bps, consistent
with prior guidance
Slide 13 – Capital ratios well above regulatory requirements
- Our capital ratios remain well above regulatory requirements as shown
on slide 13
- The CET 1 MDA buffer now stands at 264 basis points or 9 billion euros
of CET1 capital
- While this is 2 basis points higher quarter on quarter, reflecting the
increase of our CET1 ratio, the buffer to the total capital requirement
increased by 44 basis points and now stands at 331 basis points
- This increase was principally driven by our Additional Tier 1 capital
issuance in the fourth quarter
- Effective from January 1, 2025, our buffers over requirements are
impacted by the CRR3 go live and the increase in Pillar 2 requirements

-- 8 of 24 --

9
- On a pro-forma basis, the buffer to our CET1 requirement at the start of
2025 was 254 basis points, above our target operating level of 200
basis points distance to MDA
Slide 14 – Leverage ratio stable
- Moving to slide 14
- At the end of the fourth quarter our leverage ratio stood at 4.6%, flat
sequentially, as the benefit from Additional Tier 1 capital was offset by
the CET1 deduction for the announced 750-million-euro share buyback
and FX effects
- Following the 2024 SREP assessment, our 2025 Pillar 2 requirement for
leverage ratio remained unchanged
Slide 15 – Significant buffer over MREL/TLAC requirements
- We continue to operate with a significant loss-absorbing capacity, well
above all requirements, as shown on slide 15
- The MREL surplus, our most binding constraint, increased by 3 billion
euros and now stands at 23 billion euros at the end of the quarter
- The increase reflects higher MREL supply from new senior preferred
and Additional Tier 1 capital issuances partially offset by increased
MREL requirements from higher RWA
- Our surplus thus remains at a comfortable level which continues to
provide us with the flexibility to pause issuing new eligible liabilities
instruments for at least one year
Slide 16 – Issuance plan at € 15-20bn
- Moving now to our issuance plan on slide 16
- We finished 2024 with a total issuance volume of 18 billion euros, in line
with our guidance of ending the year at the upper end of a 13 to 18
billion euro range
- During the fourth quarter of 2024, the most notable deal was a 1.5
billion euro AT1 transaction which attracted a little over 10 billion in
total orders

-- 9 of 24 --

10
- Turning now to 2025, we expect to issue between 15 and 20 billion
euros, broadly in line with last year’s plan
- The composition is also similar to 2024, with the focus on senior non-
preferred bonds and capital instruments
- Senior preferred issuances will be primarily in non-benchmark format
- So far, we have already raised roughly 2 billion euros, predominantly via
a US-Dollar dominated senior non-preferred dual tranche transaction
issued on the 8th of January
- As you know, we have 4 billion dollars worth in AT1 instruments callable
in 2025 across three different securities. We assess call decisions based
on several factors, including capital demand, refinancing levels versus
reset, FX effects impacting CET1 as well as market expectations. This
can result in different decisions based on the features of each individual
bond
- Our focus for the first quarter is on the two instruments which have a
call in April 2025, both of which have a negative FX revaluation impact
- Based upon current markets, the 7.5s would reset to 9.204% and the
4.789s at 8.788%
- You can expect us to take a decision closer to the call date on 30th of
April this year, at the latest by end of March, shortly before the
respective final notification dates for the two securities
- Regarding the third security with a current coupon of 6%, the reset
coupon would be 8.974%. We will provide further information on this
security closer to the call date
Slide 17 – Summary & outlook
- Before going to your questions, let me conclude with a summary on
slide 17
- We believe we are on track to deliver increased revenues of 2 billion
euros to achieve this year’s revenue goal of around 32 billion euros,
which translates to around 32.8 billion euros at year-end FX rates
- We remain committed to rigorous cost management and will manage
our cost base to a cost/income ratio of below 65% for 2025
- Although this is higher than the level we were previously aiming for, we
feel good that the level of investment in 2025 positions us for
incremental opportunities and higher returns over time while also
further improving our controls environment

-- 10 of 24 --

11
- We continue to expect an amelioration of provision for credit losses in
2025 as the transitory headwinds we called out subside. This should
result in a run-rate of around 350 to 400 million euros of average
quarterly provisions, with further normalization expected in the
following years
- We have made good progress on our issuance plan with around 2 billion
euros issued in January
- And we are committed to maintaining a buffer of around 200 basis
points above our CET1 capital requirements, which we think balances
the interests of both our bondholders and our shareholders
- Our full attention remains on delivering a post-tax RoTE of above 10%
in 2025 driven by continued revenue momentum, cost control and
balance sheet efficiency
- With that, let us turn to your questions
Questions & Answers
Lee Street Hello all. Thank you very much for the call and taking
(Citigroup) my questions. I have three brief questions, please.
Firstly, just on Tier 2 capital, you've obviously got a bit
of a shortfall there, but you've got a bit extra AT1. What
do you target as the level of Tier 2 you're looking to run
with in the ordinary course of operations?
Secondly, yesterday there was some reference
mentioned to potentially dropping down a G-SIB bucket
alongside other measures. Just to be clear, if you were
to drop a G-SIB bucket, does that matter? Because I
guess you have a higher domestic requirement. So, any
thoughts there.
And then finally, thank you for the comments and clarity
on the view of how you think about calls. I guess we can
look at spread levels, work out the FX impacts. But you
also referenced the investor expectations. So if I may,
what do you believe the investor expectations are for
the bonds coming to call? That'd be my three questions.
Thank you.
Richard Stewart Thanks, Lee. Thank you for joining and a happy Friday,
last day of the month. So, yes, maybe I'll take the Tier 2

-- 11 of 24 --

12
capital piece. So first, the way we think about it, how we
think about both are the AT1 bucket and the Tier 2
bucket in combination.
And depending on the needs of the balance sheet at
any one particular point in time, then that dictates
which bucket we have a preference for. So at the
moment, we have probably a lean towards AT1, but
that can change in the future as the balance sheet
changes.
In terms of investor expectations on AT1 calls, what
we're saying there is, as you know, we've been talking
about this for a few quarters now, and we're still
awaiting our ability to communicate clearly to you guys
just because of awaiting the regulatory approval.
But how we think about investor expectations is more
where things are pricing in the market, and not to
disappoint our investors per se. And so we're cognisant
of where the market is currently trading. We're aware of
certainly the feedback we receive from investors, and
all that is something that we take into consideration in
that overall application we made. And I think maybe
James wants to illuminate on the G-SIB bucket piece
that he talked about yesterday.
James von Moltke Yes, thank you, Richard, and Lee for the question. So
yes, the G-SIB and domestic O-SII features in two ways.
One is MDA for CET1 purposes, and the same for
leverage ratio. For CET1 purposes, we reflect our O-SII
setting, which is currently 2%, against a global G-SIB of
1.5%. As our overall scoring comes down in this, our O-
SII potentially could reset downwards. As you know,
there's a European scoring that is applied. And then
there's a domestic calibration that's applied to drive to
your O-SII level.
But at a point in time when G-SIB and O-SII diverge by,
in this case, 100 basis points, if we were to slip down
from the 1.5% to 1% bucket, you might expect that the
calibration would struggle to keep us at 2%. Hence my
comment yesterday, for CET1 purposes, that there is at
least a possibility in the coming years of a reduction in

-- 12 of 24 --

13
MDA from that particular driver.
You might also have seen that there was some new
guidance issued late last year in terms of a proposed
rule change in Europe to harmonise the domestic
calibrations there, which I think gives you an indication
of the direction of travel.
On the leverage ratio, there the G-SIB has the impact.
Our minimum requirements on leverage reflect the
minimum, 3% plus half of the G-SIB amount, which
currently, at 1.5%, means 75 basis points is added to
our minimum leverage requirement. That could slip to
50 basis points if we were to go to the 1% G-SIB
bucket. So, with the full detail, I wanted to again clarify
that comment from yesterday. Thanks for the question.
Lee Street All right. Thank you very much, both, for your answers.
That is most helpful. Thank you.
Domenico Maggio Hi, good afternoon. Two from me. Are you thinking
(Jefferies) about moving away from the temporary write-down
clause into standard contingent conversion clause?
Clearly, I'm aware that this should be put up on a vote
at AGM. And the second one, whether by doing that
you would offset some potential FX losses on calling
the dollar AT1 coming up to maturity in 2025.
Richard Stewart Thanks, Domenico, and thanks for joining the call. So it
is a temporary write-down clause, to your first question.
Yes, we are looking into alternatives in this market. And
so you're right, the contingent conversion into equity
may allow debt accounting, which would be helpful.
But unfortunately, it could be a bit more challenging as
a German issuer under German tax law, as it would very
likely lead to an imposition of a withholding tax, which
makes the structure uneconomical for us. But we are
continuing to look at various alternative structures
which will allow us to solve for the various constraints
that we need to.
And then in terms of whether we offset potential FX
losses, that sort of structure, or any alternative
structure, would benefit future issuance, but it wouldn’t

-- 13 of 24 --

14
be able to do anything about existing securities.
Domenico Maggio Thank you.
Paul Fenner-Leitao Yes, hi. Thank you very much. I've got three. Actually, I
(Société Générale) had four, but I won't be greedy. I've got three quick
questions. The first is on Stage 2 loans. I noticed from
the Excel that you're running at a Stage 2… It's quite a
big jump from September to the end of December to 64
billion euros Stage 2. That's the highest it's been,
basically on this Excel, which is the highest it's been
since 2022. Can you just explain what's going on there?
Is this a German macro problem? Some colour on that
would be great.
The second question, I guess there's a little bit of a
philosophy here, but if I look at slide 3 and I look at your
RoEs, RoTEs across the business, the outlier in terms of
underperforming from a risk-return perspective, a
volatility return perspective, is the Investment Bank.
My question is, what's your internal cost of capital for
that business, and do you ever think it gets there? DB is
not the only one in Europe that's suffering from this, but
a little bit of colour on that. And I know that you guys
are under continuous strategic review. Is getting rid of
the IB at some stage something that you would look at?
And then the third question is back to AT1 calls, I’m
afraid. On slide 16, someone must have purposely put
this comment in at the end, which is bill specific
approach for AT1 calls. I think it was Lee made the
point that all of these calls are now in the money,
potentially by a considerable amount, certainly maybe
20 basis points, maybe significantly more if you do
something in dollars.
My understanding is that there is no limit to when you
can make the call announcement on these bonds. I
guess you're looking for some regulatory approval, but
you might have got that last year. The market is super
hungry for AT1. Dollars are a great market to go into.
You could probably issue it somewhere around 400.
What are you waiting for?

-- 14 of 24 --

15
And the question is, I guess the additional question is,
would it not make sense for you to say that you're going
to call, and then issue, and thus saving you maybe ten,
15 basis points? A little bit of colour around AT1 calls
would be great. Thank you.
James von Moltke So, Paul, it's James. I might jump in on the second
question around the IB and the cost of capital. Look,
strategically, no, under no circumstances. We view the
Investment Bank to be a critical part of our company
and our offering.
We talk about the Global Hausbank strategy. And for
our clients, especially on the institutional and corporate
side, but also in some respects in the Wealth
Management businesses, our businesses rely on the
capabilities of our Investment Bank, and we are a
leading player in the marketplace. So, we view it very
much to be an integrated business in our overall
offering.
To your point, post-crisis, all of the investment banks
had to struggle to rebuild their profitability and capital
utilisation, reflecting the post-crisis regulation. And so
we, like many, looked hard at the business, how you
would transform it and restructure it to meet hurdle
rates under the new requirements.
And I'll say we've come a very long way in that regard.
On a blended basis, our Investment Bank, you will have
seen 9% last year, we think it's well on its way to
meeting and exceeding its cost of capital over time.
And we're working on each of the business units within
the Investment Bank, and certainly those that are below
what we would perceive our cost of capital to be, to
improve.
And we think there are significant tools available now to
do that, whether it's on the capital side or, frankly, costs
and revenue generation. And so it is becoming more
and more efficient in its resource utilisation as we
continue to develop it and build it under the leadership
of Fabrizio, Ram and Mark. So, we're pleased with that
progress.

-- 15 of 24 --

16
In terms of differential cost of capital, just inside our
inner workings, we apply a firm-wide cost of capital
across all businesses to look at exceeding hurdle rates
for shareholder value add. But our expectations aren't
limited to the cost of capital of the group.
Obviously, many of our businesses operate in markets
and product areas that should be well above the
group's cost of capital. And so there's a differential that
we think of in terms of group hurdle rates and
expectations in individual businesses. I hope that helps
give you a sense of our thinking about all that.
Paul Fenner-Leitao It does, thank you.
Richard Stewart So maybe I’ll pick up the AT1 question. So thanks, Paul,
for the question. To unpack some of the observations
you made, so, one, around the deal-specific language,
that was something that we have mentioned in previous
earnings calls. And it's much more to flag that one of
the things which you say, that we’re in the money on
some of these calls coming due in 2025, one of the
things we’re at pains to point out is this FX translation
charge that we have as well.
So that's something that we have to think about, not
just the credit and rate markets’ valuation of the call.
And so when you think about those, then we have a
security which is callable in October. We'll make a
decision on that guy a little bit close to the time. But I'd
note the CET1 impact there from the FX effects is
relatively small currently.
And then we have two calls coming due in April, as you
know. The one is, well, both are in the money from what
we can see in the market levels today, you're correct on
that. You obviously have quite attractive reset levels.
One has different language in the sense that it's a
legacy LIBOR contract. So, these things are things that
we have to consider, about what makes economic
sense for us, based on the criteria that we've explained
a few times before.
And in terms of market opportunities to go, I agree with

-- 16 of 24 --

17
you, the market is open. Obviously, we were successful
in issuing in November when there was similar strong
demand for AT1. Just the windows for these activities,
given they’re equity securities vis-à-vis various both
internal approvals from our supervisory boards versus
disclosures versus regulators, just means the windows
isn't continuous for us. So those are some of the
reasons for why these things are presented the way
they are.
James von Moltke Richard, I'm happy to take the Stage 2 question. It's
really sovereign downgrade. So there's a Stage 2
trigger that takes place when there are downgrades,
including of sovereigns, and sometimes clearing houses
and the like and that type of thing. So typically when
you see volatility in that for us, it has to do with that
type of event. In this case, that is what happened to
sovereign downgrades in the period that impacted
Stage 2.
And to the way you phrased the question, it really isn't
Germany overall credit conditions. As we said on
yesterday's call, we are seeing very modest movements,
and by the way also in the disclosure materials, very
modest movements in the German portfolio, which is
not to say we're not watching it carefully but is to say
it's not a driver of the Stage 2 movement.
Paul Fenner-Leitao Okay, thank you. Can I just come back on one additional
question on the AT1 thing? And it's the following.
Something that comes across with my conversations
with investors, and certainly other issuers, they
perceive the FX loss as something that they just
basically have to stomach, and that it's unfair to have
investors have to second guess on FX, i.e. it's
something that you're supposed to be able to manage
without that necessarily influencing the call decision.
That's just a bit of feedback.
Richard Stewart No, thank you. I think the reason why we flag it out
there is just as people ask what our thinking is around
our call strategy, given all the constraints that we have
to think about, as I mentioned earlier, what we're saying

-- 17 of 24 --

18
is it's something else that we have to think about as an
input into that thinking.
Paul Fenner-Leitao Thank you very much.
Daniel David Hi, good afternoon. Congrats on the results, and thanks
(Autonomous) for taking my questions. I've got three, a couple on AT1
and one on Tier 2. Just following on maybe from that
last question, I just wanted to focus on FX to start with.
And that, we can debate whether investors should take
it or it's your responsibility.
What I'm interested in and what I observe is that the FX
hits have got worse as a result of FX moves recently. So
I guess my question is, with the call process, could you
have hedged against that FX getting worse, I guess
maybe avoiding a couple of extra hundred million euros
of hits? And is this something you considered ahead of
time?
The second one on AT1 is just on the bucket and where
you want to be, longer term. So it's quite healthy at the
moment, 3.2% and 85 bps of leverage. When I think
back to what you said about the first AT1 last year, you
said it was to manage our leverage ratio, given internal
demand. So how should we think about that bucket and
also what you've done in the AT1 space?
And then just briefly on Tier 2. Clearly, we saw the reg
impact, the change in Q3. And at the time, I think you
said you don't want to fill it with new Tier 2 issuance. I
just wondered if that's still the case. And if so, why don't
you want to replenish that Tier 2 bucket? Thanks.
Richard Stewart Yes, thank you very much indeed, Dan, for those three
questions. So I will go through the FX hits. So hedging,
yes, it's something that we've thought about many
times. I think the trade-off, unfortunately, is one around
an economic impact through capital, which is what the
current situation would be versus hedging and
generating mark-to-market P&L and consumer market
risk RWA. So that's just the nature of IFRS accounting
for this equity accounting that we have for this
instrument, where the FX rate is just set at inception.

-- 18 of 24 --

19
So those are the choices. From time to time, we've
considered whether hedging makes sense. But you're
right, since the second half of last year, then the Euro
has weakened against the dollar, so that as a
calculation then the FX effect has gone against us
slightly since then. So that's the hedging question.
The other one is around the bucket and internal
demand. So a couple of things there. So one is, two bits
and pieces which influence our thinking around AT1s
going forward is, in Q4, you would’ve seen on the CET1
side lower market risk RWA consumption. We expect
that to normalise back through Q1 and going forward,
just given the robustness of the Investment Banking
franchise.
And then similarly, in terms of our liability raising, both
in terms of deposits both in our Corporate Bank and
Private Bank, then that obviously brings cash onto the
balance sheet, which is leverage intensive as well. So
those two dynamics means that there's an underlying
need to have a decent weighting in that bucket.
But as I said at the outset, I do imagine that mix
between AT1 and Tier 2 will change. But for what I can
see through 2025, based on our current planning, then I
think it's going to be very similar to 2024. Does that
answer your questions, or is there another question
which I missed?
Daniel David Yes, just on the Tier 2 piece, right, so that reg change
for the value that you recognise in your capital ratios, I
think you made a comment that you don't want to
replenish it by issuance. Was there a reason for not
wanting to do that?
Richard Stewart No, I think it's more just a trade operation. Like I say, I
think just from a, what's the best instrument to achieve
our objectives from a funding and liquidity and capital
perspective, based on what we can see in our balance
sheet development and our growth, then Tier 2 we
don't think is necessarily the best asset for 2025. But it
might well be a better instrument beyond that.

-- 19 of 24 --

20
Daniel David All right, thank you. I appreciate that.
Robert Smalley Hi, good morning and good afternoon, and thanks for
(Verition) taking my question. And I'm sorry to beat a dead horse
on the AT1s, but one or two questions. In terms of FX
losses, what would be an acceptable FX loss for a call?
How would you evaluate that? And you're in a position
on that in pretty much all three.
Secondly, you have significant buffers across the
board. As you bring down capital buffers, you have
three calls this year in AT1s. Is it possible that you just
call one, two, all three, none for cash as opposed to
calling and refinancing?
And then I have a third, completely unrelated question,
but something I wanted to pick up on from the call
yesterday on the Mittelstand opportunity that you have.
You talked about making your operations domestically
more efficient to address that. But could you talk a little
bit more about what you're doing in terms of
penetration by product? A lot of these companies have
longstanding relationships that you're going to have to
compete with, and how are you doing that in terms of
product and in terms of price? Thanks.
Richard Stewart No problems, Robert, and good to hear from you.
Thanks for joining. So the AT1 question, I think how
best I can answer it, and I think I recognise it's
challenging for people who are looking at these
products day by day and looking to understand what to
put into their models in terms of how we're thinking
about these things, look, I think the way I think about
the FX loss is more at a portfolio level in a single year.
So the question becomes, what’s your acceptable level?
Do we have a number in mind? No. But that's how we
think about it, is that overall portfolio number. In terms
of which, zero, one, two, three, in terms of what could
be called, we do think about it on a deal-specific basis,
but on a portfolio level when it comes to the capital and
when it comes to overall investor sentiment.
So I can't answer your question directly or, yes, as

-- 20 of 24 --

21
transparently as you would like, just because of these
constraints we’re having to operate under and from
what I can disclose or not at this time. But yes, the way
to think about it, I think, when I look at the portfolio of
these three particular calls, given where things are right
now, is that it's a not unsociable number of capital that
we'd have to be taking in 2025.
Do we have a target around that? No. But that portfolio
impact is something we're thinking about. And then all
the other factors that I've talked about on a deal-
specific basis, in terms of documentation, in the
moneyness and market expectations, are things which
feed into the loop on that. So that's how I would answer
your question, although that might be not as satisfying
as you announced that you would like.
James von Moltke Robert, it's James. On the last question regarding the
German Mittelstand, look, obviously it is one of the
signature strengths of the German economy. And
therefore, providing banking services and having the
relationships with the Mittelstand’s obviously super
important for our bank and other banks in Germany.
And it's a competitive market. We probably de-
emphasised too much that segment, now going back a
couple of decades. But we've been rebuilding our
market position steadily over the years, and it does
absolutely represent a focus for us strategically.
Where we are especially competitive in the Mittelstand
is obviously where there are significant product
demands that are international in nature or capital
markets orientated, so International Cash Management,
Trade Finance, some of the Investment Banking
products that I talked about earlier in response to the
question, I think from Paul, around the Investment
Bank. So that is where we have a differentiated market
position. And absolutely, we wish to grow and thrive,
along with our clients, in that marketplace.
I will say, and I think the question yesterday came up at
least tangentially in connection with potential M&A
activity here in our home market, and would it create an

-- 21 of 24 --

22
opportunity for us, I think the answer to that is yes. But
obviously, events are out of our control. But certainly,
we intend to prosecute the opportunity and work with
clients in the Mittelstand, existing and new clients.
In terms of how to penetrate, look, pricing is interesting.
I think one of the SVA challenges that we have is
certain portfolios are, in fact, below hurdle. A very
competitive domestic market here. So credit extension
is in that way expensive in the German market. But it is
something that we look at carefully.
The way you interact with clients, and particularly the
technology that you put to work in that client
relationship and the connectivity and the ease of use, of
access to the services, to payments and what have you,
is a significant competitive differentiator, and it's one
that we are seeking to leverage and invest in going
forward. And so that is an important part of our thinking
as well. Hope that helps in terms of colour, Robert.
Robert Smalley That colour and Richard's colour are very helpful. And I
know you can't answer all of the questions with
specifics. So I greatly appreciate it.
James von Moltke My pleasure, Robert.
Ibraheam Radi Hello. Good morning. Congratulations for the results,
(Lazard) and thank you for taking my question. I first have a
comment, maybe from an investor perspective, is that
the expectation is absolutely that the three AT1s
callable in 2025 should be called. And as credit
investors, we would not understand that a couple of
basis points of FX impact would affect the call decision.
After that, I have two questions. Number one, on the
call rationale, what you say is that you look at the FX
loss at portfolio level in a single year. Can you give more
clarity as to what you mean, especially considering that
you consider the economics of each transaction on a
deal-by-deal basis? So is it, how to put it, a full-cap-
stack economic rationale for the call, or is it a deal by
deal? How do you reconciliate both?
Number two is regarding the leverage ratio. If you call

-- 22 of 24 --

23
the three deals this year, the excess Tier 1 drops to 5.5
billion euros from 10 billion euros. My question is, is
there a target there, long term? Thank you.
Richard Stewart Thanks very much for the call and the questions. So
what I was getting at with this dichotomy between deal-
specific and portfolio was, A, the questions which I get
asked, in a very simple format, is what is the rationale
and how should people think about it from a modelling
perspective as to the likelihood of call or non-call. And
people always expect rational behaviour with those
decisions.
And I think what we've been trying to do on this call,
and in previous calls, is to raise the things that we as a
firm need to take under consideration. Obviously,
there's things which, mathematically, people are aware
of, whether it's credit spreads, interest rates, volatilities,
and obviously the FX losses is something that we think
about.
But also, there's all of these more qualitative impacts,
which are around the investor expectations, as we're
talking about, and obviously you made your point clear
at the start. And what I was really saying about the
portfolio effect is, some of these deals have different
FX losses. One of the things we do think about overall is
the overall portfolio impact, just because in this
particular year, we have just a number of non-euro calls
coming due this year. So that's what I was trying to get
to.
And in terms of targets, we don't have a target, as in a
communicated, external target for leverage ratio. What
we do have essentially, or how we think about it, is we
like to internally think that we want to keep it above
4.5% and, over time, as we grow our business in organic
capital, move towards 5%, which is also something
which informs rating agencies’ decisions. So over time,
that's where we have an ambition to get to.
But for the next few quarters, it's going to be more
being at these sort of levels, notwithstanding the
internal demand that we see, as I mentioned earlier. So

-- 23 of 24 --

24
those are factors in terms of how we think about the
leverage ratio, the direction of travel over time, but we
don't actually have a specific target.
Ibraheam Radi Okay. Thank you very much.
Disclaimer
This transcript contains forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements are statements
that are not historical facts; they include statements about our beliefs and expectations and the
assumptions underlying them. These statements are based on plans, estimates and projections as
they are currently available to the management of Deutsche Bank. Forward-looking statements
therefore speak only as of the date they are made, and we undertake no obligation to update publicly
any of them in light of new information or future events.
By their very nature, forward-looking statements involve risks and uncertainties. A number of
important factors could therefore cause actual results to differ materially from those contained in
any forward-looking statement. Such factors include the conditions in the financial markets in
Germany, in Europe, in the United States and elsewhere from which we derive a substantial portion
of our revenues and in which we hold a substantial portion of our assets, the development of asset
prices and market volatility, potential defaults of borrowers or trading counterparties, the
implementation of our strategic initiatives, the reliability of our risk management policies,
procedures and methods, and other risks referenced in our filings with the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission. Such factors are described in detail in our SEC Form 20-F of 14 March 2024
under the heading “Risk Factors.” Copies of this document are readily available upon request or can
be downloaded from investor-relations.db.com.
This transcript also contains non-IFRS financial measures. For a reconciliation to directly
comparable figures reported under IFRS, to the extent such reconciliation is not provided in this
transcript, refer to the Q4/FY 2024 Preliminary Financial Data Supplement, which is available at
investor-relations.db.com.
This transcript is provided solely for information purposes and shall not be construed as a solicitation
of an offer to buy or sell any securities or other financial instruments in any jurisdiction. No
investment decision relating to securities of or relating to Deutsche Bank AG or its affiliates should
be made on the basis of this document. Please refer to Deutsche Bank’s annual and interim reports,
ad hoc announcements under Article 17 of Regulation (EU) No. 596/2014 and filings with the U.S.
Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) under Form 6-K.

-- 24 of 24 --