SUPPLEMENT
FY2023 — Annual financial statements
FY2023PDF · 354 pages2.9 MB
annualfinancial statements for the year ended 30 June 2023 -- 1 of 354 -- 1966/010753/06 Certain entities within the FirstRand group are authorised financial services and credit providers. This analysis is available on the group’s website: www.firstrand.co.za Email questions to investor.relations@firstrand.co.za A Five-year review and economic impact B FirstRand group audited consolidated annual financial statements C Shareholders’ and supplementary information Contents -- 2 of 354 -- 2023 FIRSTRAND GROUP A Afive-year review and economic impact -- 3 of 354 -- AFive-year review and economic impact Five-year review A5 Economic impact A8 five-year reviewand economic impact -- 4 of 354 -- -A5- FIVE-YEAR REVIEW Compound R million 2019 2020 2021 2022 * 2023 growth % Statement of financial position Total assets ‒ restated 1 665 382 1 894 620 1 870 013 1 999 569 2 297 610 8 Average assets ‒ restated 1 598 634 1 780 001 1 882 317 1 934 791 2 148 590 8 Core lending advances 1 194 599 1 284 131 1 208 468 1 311 441 1 511 037 6 Average core lending advances 1 152 006 1 239 365 1 246 300 1 259 955 1 411 239 5 Impairment and fair value of credit of advances 34 162 49 380 50 618 47 734 51 072 11 Non-performing loans (NPLs) 41 349 57 281 60 705 50 886 57 432 9 Gross advances before impairments 1 239 914 1 311 095 1 274 052 1 382 058 1 590 447 6 Deposits 1 393 104 1 535 015 1 542 078 1 655 972 1 923 103 8 Capital and reserves attributable to equityholders of the group 140 407 147 774 163 262 176 426 193 393 8 Treasury shares (29) 72 25 70 145 50 Ordinary dividends 15 931 16 716 6 170 17 390 27 991 15 Total equity before dividends and treasury shares 156 309 164 562 169 457 193 886 221 529 9 Total ordinary equity 129 673 137 529 151 617 164 781 180 547 9 Assets under administration ‒ 2 001 400 2 258 429 2 282 511 2 408 453 2 765 761 8 Income statement Net interest income before impairment of advances 60 457 62 915 63 290 66 375 76 437 6 Impairment and fair value of credit of advances (10 500) (24 383) (13 660) (7 080) (10 949) 1 Non-interest revenue 45 808 41 691 45 195 48 248 55 314 5 Share of profit of associates and joint ventures after tax 1 230 29 1 538 1 491 487 (21) Operating expenses (54 043) (55 276) (57 556) (60 769) (68 749) 6 Earnings attributable to ordinary equityholders 30 211 17 021 26 743 32 761 36 366 5 Headline earnings 27 887 17 326 26 950 32 817 36 735 7 Earnings per share (cents) ‒ Basic 538.6 303.5 476.9 584.3 648.7 5 ‒ Diluted 538.6 303.5 476.9 584.3 648.7 5 Headline earnings per share (cents) ‒ Basic 497.3 308.9 480.5 585.3 655.3 7 ‒ Diluted 497.3 308.9 480.5 585.3 655.3 7 * Reclassifications of prior year numbers. -- 5 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -A6- FIVE-YEAR REVIEW continued Compound R million 2019 2020 2021 2022 * 2023 growth % Dividend per share (cents) 291.0 146.0 263.0 342.0 384.0 Special dividend per share (cents) - - - 125.0 - Dividend cover based on headline earnings 1.7 2.1 1.8 1.7 1.7 NCNR preference dividends per share (cents) ** ‒ February 381.7 374.7 253.6 270.7 52.2 (39) ‒ August 384.2 306.0 273.9 307.4 - - Net asset value per ordinary share (cents) 2 311.9 2 453.1 2 703.5 2 938.6 3 226.6 9 Shares in issue (millions) 5 609.5 5 609.5 5 609.5 5 609.5 5 609.5 - Weighted average number of shares in issue (millions) 5 609.0 5 608.2 5 608.2 5 606.7 5 605.7 - Diluted weighted average number of shares in issue (millions) 5 609.0 5 608.2 5 608.2 5 606.7 5 605.7 - * Reclassifications of prior year numbers. ** On 25 August 2022, the group’s ordinary and preference shareholders approved the repurchase of FirstRand’s preference shares at par. The scheme consideration, which included the final pro rata preference dividends, was paid on 26 September 2022 and the listing was terminated on 27 September 2022 -- 6 of 354 -- -A7- FIVE-YEAR REVIEW continued Compound R million 2019 2020 2021 2022 * 2023 growth % Key ratios Return on ordinary equity based on headline earnings (%) 22.2 13.0 18.6 20.7 21.3 Price earnings ratio based on headline earnings (times) 13.8 12.3 11.2 10.7 10.5 Price-to-book ratio (times) 3.0 1.6 2.0 2.1 2.1 Market capitalisation (R million) 384 530 213 497 300 612 349 864 384 250 - Closing share price (cents) 6 855 3 806 5 359 6 237 6 850 - Cost-to-income ratio (%) 50.3 52.8 52.3 52.3 52.0 Credit loss ratio (%) ‒ core lending advances 0.91 1.97 1.10 0.56 0.76 NPLs as a % of core lending advances 3.46 4.46 5.02 3.88 3.80 Non-interest income as a % of total income 43.8 39.9 42.5 42.8 42.2 Return on average total assets based on headline earnings (%) ‒ restated 1.7 1.0 1.4 1.6 1.7 Interest margin on average advances (%) 5.2 5.1 5.1 5.0 5.1 Exchange rates Rand/USD ‒ Closing 14.13 17.36 14.26 16.41 18.84 ‒ Average 14.17 15.51 15.33 15.19 17.73 Rand/GBP ‒ Closing 17.98 21.43 19.72 19.95 23.95 ‒ Average 18.33 19.57 20.66 20.21 21.31 Statement of financial position (USD) * Total assets ‒ restated 117 861 109 137 131 137 121 851 121 954 1 Gross advances before impairments 87 750 75 524 89 344 84 220 84 419 (1) Deposits 98 592 88 423 108 140 100 912 102 076 1 Total equity 9 937 8 512 11 449 10 751 10 265 1 Assets under administration ‒ restated 141 642 130 094 160 064 146 767 146 803 1 Income statement (USD) ** Earnings attributable to ordinary equityholders 2 132 1 097 1 744 2 157 2 051 (1) Headline earnings 1 968 1 117 1 758 2 160 2 072 1 Statement of financial position (GBP) * Total assets ‒ restated 92 624 88 410 94 828 100 229 95 934 Gross advances before impairments 68 961 61 180 64 607 69 276 66 407 (1) Deposits 77 481 71 629 78 199 83 006 80 297 1 Total equity 7 809 6 896 8 279 8 843 8 075 1 Assets under administration ‒ restated 111 313 105 386 115 746 120 967 115 481 1 Income statement (GBP) ** Earnings attributable to ordinary equityholders 1 648 870 1 294 1 621 1 707 1 Headline earnings 1 521 885 1 304 1 624 1 724 3 * Reclassifications of prior year numbers. * The statement of financial position is converted using the closing rates as disclosed. ** The income statement is converted using the average rate as disclosed. -- 7 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -A8- ECONOMIC IMPACT 2023 2022 R million % R million % Value added Net interest income after impairment 140 947 72.2 101 887 67.8 Non-operating revenue 55 465 28.4 49 604 33.0 Non-operating expenses (1 261) (0.6) (1 215) (0.8) Value added by operations 195 151 100.0 150 276 100.0 To employees Salaries, wages and other benefits 42 336 21.7 36 621 24.4 To providers of funding 104 569 53.6 60 820 40.5 Dividends to shareholders 29 110 18 228 Interest paid 75 459 42 592 To suppliers 21 055 10.8 18 790 12.5 To government 13 987 7.2 14 647 9.7 Normal tax 11 993 12 950 Value-added tax 1 595 1 420 Capital gains tax 345 - Other 54 277 To communities Corporate social investment spend 268 0.1 221 0.1 To expansion and growth 12 936 6.6 19 177 12.8 Retained income 8 375 15 371 Depreciation and amortisation 4 721 4 827 Deferred income tax (160) (1 021) Total value added 195 151 100.0 150 276 100.0 -- 8 of 354 -- E A 2023 FIRSTRAND GROUP B Bfirstrand groupaudited consolidated annual financial statements -- 9 of 354 -- firstrand group audited consolidated annual financial statements FirstRand group audited consolidated annual financial statements Audit committee report B11 Directors’ responsibility statement and approval of the annual financial statements B17 Company secretary’s certification B19 Directors’ report B20 Independent auditors’ report B25 Accounting policies B37 Consolidated income statement B105 Consolidated statement of other comprehensive income B106 Consolidated statement of financial position B107 Consolidated statement of changes in equity B108 Consolidated statement of cash flows B110 Notes to the consolidated annual financial statements B112 Company annual financial statements B327 B -- 10 of 354 -- -B11- AUDIT COMMITTEE REPORT The committee herewith presents its report in respect of the group’s financial year ended 30 June 2023. This report has been prepared based on the requirements of the South African Companies Act, 71 of 2008, as amended (Companies Act), the King Code of Governance for South Africa (King IV), the JSE Listings Requirements and other applicable regulatory requirements. The group audit committee is constituted as a statutory committee of the FirstRand board in respect of the group’s duties in terms of section 94(7) of the Companies Act and section 64 of the Banks Act of 1990 (Banks Act). The objectives and functions of the committee are set out in its charter, which was reviewed and updated during the financial year. The fundamental role of the audit committee is to assist the board in fulfilling its oversight responsibilities in areas that include internal and external audit functions, financial reporting (including the evaluation and efficiency of accounting policies), financial risk management, regulatory compliance and internal controls (including the effectiveness and adequacy thereof). SUMMARY OF RESPONSIBILITIES The effectiveness of the committee and its individual members is assessed annually by the board. The committee is satisfied that it has, during the past financial year, executed its duties in accordance with these terms of reference and relevant legislation, regulations and governance practices. Feedback was obtained from management and, external and internal audit in making all assessments. – Reviews the quality, independence and effectiveness of the statutory audit work performed by the group’s external auditors. – Recommends the appointment of the external audit firms to the board and shareholders and approves the appointment of the audit lead partners after consideration of the enhanced due diligence results. – Monitors the extent of non-audit engagements provided by the group’s external audit firms, in accordance with approved internal policies and limits. – Assists the board in evaluating the adequacy and effectiveness of FirstRand’s internal control environment (including internal financial controls and IT risk- related controls), accounting practices, information systems and internal assurance processes. – Ensures that a combined assurance model is applied to provide a coordinated approach to assurance activities by group internal audit, external audit compliance, risk and other internal control functions. – Provides independent oversight regarding financial risks, including risks relating to the validity, accuracy and completeness of the interim financial and annual financial statements (both financial and non-financial reports) and recommends these items to the board for approval. Assesses reports received on fraud and IT risks as these relate to financial reporting. – Satisfies itself as to the expertise, resources and experience of the group financial director and finance function. – Assesses and evaluates the effectiveness of the group’s risk management processes regarding compliance with applicable legal and regulatory requirements, as well as accounting policies, in the preparation of the financial statements and external financial reports. -- 11 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B12- AUDIT COMMITTEE REPORT continued COMPOSITION AND GOVERNANCE Members of the committee satisfy the requirements for serving as members of an audit committee, as provided in section 94 of the Companies Act, King IV and the Banks Act. As a collective, the committee possesses the appropriate financial expertise, related qualifications and a balance of skills and experience to discharge its responsibilities. All members are independent non-executive directors. Audit committees in the segments/operating businesses, established as management committees, support the group audit committee in the execution of its tasks. They are chaired by the same competent independent non-executive members of the group audit committee. The composition of the group audit committee and the attendance of meetings by its members for the 2023 financial year are set out below. COMPOSITION MEETINGS NOVEMBER TRILATERAL GG Gelink (chairman) 4/4 1/1 RM Loubser 4/4 1/1 LL von Zeuner 4/4 1/1 T Winterboer 4/4 1/1 ATTENDEES – Chief executive officer – Chief operating officer – Chief financial officer – Chief risk officer – Chief audit executive – Chairs of the subcommittees and other specialists – External auditors – Heads of finance, risk and internal audit The committee is satisfied that the individual members of the committee possess appropriate qualifications and the balance of skills and experience required to discharge their responsibilities. -- 12 of 354 -- -B13- AUDIT COMMITTEE REPORT continued AREAS OF FOCUS In addition to the items detailed in the specific sections that follow, the committee performed the following during the year: – Reviewed and considered the effectiveness of the internal financial controls and the going concern aspect of FirstRand and its subsidiaries, in terms of Regulation 40(4) of the Banks Act regulations (including specific approval of the list of loss-making entities and/or those with a negative net asset value). – Reviewed the report on management’s self-assessment of internal financial controls, enabling the directors’ attestation in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements section 3.84(k). – Conducted the quarterly financial analysis of the group’s performance. – Reviewed and approved the internal and external audit work plan. – Reviewed and approved the audit committee charter. – The committee received regular feedback regarding the progress of the intended transition of Ernst & Young (EY) to replace Deloitte as one of the joint auditors of the group for the 30 June 2024 financial year audit. The appointment of EY will be tabled for approval at the upcoming shareholder meeting in November 2023. – Reviewed the impact of emerging and current regulation on the group. – Reviewed and responded to the outcome of the statutory and regulatory audits. – Noted management’s response to JSE proactive monitoring of the financial statements report relating to the 2022 calendar year and additional reports issued from JSE applicable for the 2023 financial year. – The committee monitored the progress of the implementation of IFRS 17. EXTERNAL AUDIT The committee has satisfied itself as to the performance and quality of the external audit function, as well as the independence of the external auditors and lead partners of the group, as set out in section 94(8) of the Companies Act. In reaching this conclusion, the following matters were considered: – Representations made by the external auditors to the audit committee, including the ISQC1 system of quality control representations. – Independence criteria specified by the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors (IRBA) and international regulatory bodies, as well as criteria for internal governance processes within audit firms. – Auditor suitability assessment in terms of paragraph 3.84(g)(ii) and section 22.15(h) of the JSE Listings Requirements. – Previous appointments of the auditors, tenure of the auditors and rotation of the lead partners. – Extent of non-audit work undertaken by the auditors for the group (in accordance with approved internal policy limits to ensure external audit independence is not jeopardised). – Any matters arising from the closed meeting between audit firm senior leadership and the committee regarding the firm’s risk and quality processes, independently from what the audit team disclosed to the committee. – The public conduct of audit firms, for example through media reports with follow-up sessions with the external auditors. – The intention is to appoint EY as the joint auditor for the 30 June 2024 financial year end (replacing Deloitte) and KPMG Incorporated as the other joint auditor for 30 June 2026. The committee nominated EY for appointment as the external auditor for the 2024 financial year end, and reappointed PwC as external audit firm responsible for performing the function of joint auditor for the 2024 financial year. The committee ensured that the appointment of the auditors complied with all required legislation. It also approved the proposed audit fees for the financial year under review. -- 13 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B14- AUDIT COMMITTEE REPORT continued NON-AUDIT SERVICES The committee annually reviews and approves the list of non-audit services which the auditors may perform. There is an approval process whereby all non-audit service engagements above a certain threshold must be approved by the financial director, and above a further threshold be pre-approved by the chairman of the audit committee. If above the highest threshold, it needs to be approved by the entire committee. A maximum limit of 25% of the group’s annual audit fee is in place for non-audit services, in aggregate and individually, per firm. The cumulative spend for the year to date is presented to the committee on a quarterly basis to keep track of the non-audit spend as well as the nature of services. The 2023 non-audit fees were 6.05% of the audit fees. Revisions to the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA) Code, impacting non-audit services, took effect for periods commencing on or after 15 December 2022, therefore effective for the group’s financial year ending 30 June 2024. The revised provisions include new requirements that expressly prohibit audit firms and network firms from providing certain types of non- audit services to their audit clients, especially when they are public interest entities. The impact to the group is expected to be limited given the extensive governance process already in place. INTERNAL AUDIT The internal audit function’s mission is to protect and enable sustainable growth for the FirstRand group and all its stakeholders. Group Internal Audit (GIA) leverages its unique position in the group to deliver independent and objective assurance, data-driven insights and impactful advice. GIA assists executive management and the audit committee to accomplish its objectives by bringing a systematic, disciplined approach to evaluate and improve the effectiveness of risk management, internal control and governance processes within the group. The committee reviewed and approved the internal audit charter and evaluated the independence, effectiveness and performance of GIA in compliance with its charter after having done the following: – Assessed the performance of the chief audit executive and the arrangements of internal audit, and is satisfied that the function is independent and appropriately resourced, and that the chief audit executive has fulfilled the obligations of that position. – Reviewed and approved the annual internal audit plan, which was informed by combined assurance role players and aligned to the group’s strategic objectives, risks and opportunities identified by management, as well as topical issues facing the financial services industry. On a quarterly basis, the committee reviewed the status of the audit plan and approved changes made, to ensure it remained agile in its response to the changing risk landscape. – Reviewed quarterly activity reports from internal audit which covered audit plan progress, insights, opportunities for improvement, a summary of audit observations with a focus on significant matters for escalation and other matters for noting, a cumulative view on internal controls, and status updates on management’s remediation efforts to address findings raised. The group’s external auditors conducted an annual assessment of the internal audit function against International Standards on Auditing (ISA) 610 and confirmed that the work performed by internal audit was suitable for the purposes of external audit reliance. The international standards for the professional practice of internal auditing and the FirstRand group internal audit charter requires the internal audit function to be reviewed every five years by a qualified, independent assessor or assessment team from outside the group. This review was last performed by EY in 2020, with the overall assessment concluding that the activities of FirstRand’s internal audit function generally conform to the Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA) standards. -- 14 of 354 -- -B15- AUDIT COMMITTEE REPORT continued FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND FINANCE FUNCTION FirstRand maintains a strong risk culture and the effective functioning of its internal financial controls is relied upon to confirm the integrity and reliability of the financial statements. A formal attestation process relating to the effective functioning of internal financial controls within the operating businesses enables the positive attestation required from the CFO and CEO as stipulated in paragraph 3.84(k) of the JSE Listings Requirements. Where deficiencies were identified and reported, the committee assessed the significance thereof, as well as the existence and effectiveness of mitigating controls, and reviewed the remediation actions implemented. The committee is satisfied that the group has appropriate financial reporting control frameworks and procedures in place, and that these procedures are operating effectively. The committee reports that, based on a formal assessment process, it was satisfied as to the appropriateness of the expertise, effectiveness and experience of the group financial director during the reporting period. In addition, the committee is satisfied with the expertise, effectiveness and adequacy of resources and arrangements in the finance function, as well as the experience and continued professional development of the leadership team. The committee confirms that it was able to carry out its work to fulfil its statutory mandate under normal and unrestricted conditions. The committee is satisfied that the assurance obtained during the meetings, corroborated by the review of the documentation deemed necessary and by its own analyses, sustains its conclusions reached for the 2023 financial year. The committee recommended the consolidated financial statements and company financial statements for the year ended 30 June 2023 for approval to the board. The financial statements will be open for discussion at the forthcoming annual general meeting. Key audit matters identified by the external auditors are included in their report in the group’s annual financial statements. These matters have been discussed and agreed upon with management and were presented to the committee. The committee has considered the appropriateness of the key audit matters reported on by the external auditors. It is satisfied with management’s treatment thereof and the audit response thereto. CONCERNS/COMPLAINTS PROCESS An audit committee process exists to receive and deal appropriately with any concerns or complaints relating to: – reporting practices and internal audit of the group; – content or auditing of the financial statements; – internal financial controls of the bank or controlling company; and – any other related matter. No complaints were received relating to accounting practices or internal audit, or to the content or audit of the group’s annual financial statements. -- 15 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B16- AUDIT COMMITTEE REPORT continued COMBINED ASSURANCE MODEL AND RELATIONSHIP WITH OTHER GOVERNANCE COMMITTEES The committee focused on the identification of key and emerging risks, and monitored alignment of all assurance providers to eliminate multiple approaches to assurance and reporting thereon. The combined assurance model incorporates and optimises all assurance services and functions so that, taken as a whole, these enable an effective control environment; support the integrity of information used for internal decision-making by management, the governing body and its committees; and support the integrity of the group’s external reports. The committee works closely with the group’s risk, capital management and compliance committee; the social, ethics and transformation committee and the operational and information technology risk committee to identify common risk and control themes and achieve synergy between combined assurance processes. Thereby it ensures that, where appropriate, relevant information is shared and that these functions can leverage off one another. The committee is satisfied with the expertise, effectiveness and adequacy of arrangements in place for combined assurance. The committee encouraged the focus of assurance activities on key risk areas and robust discussion on emerging risks and the implication thereof for assurance providers. It fostered effective communication between first-, second- and third-line assurance providers (i.e. business, risk, compliance, and internal audit function). FUTURE AREAS OF FOCUS – Oversee the opening balance and first-year audit by EY as joint auditors for the financial year ending 30 June 2024 and the transition process with KPMG for the financial year ending 30 June 2026. – Review and monitor the group’s finalisation of the adoption of IFRS 17, which will replace IFRS 4 Insurance Contracts, including the impact on required restatements and disclosure in the financial statements. – Monitor the implementation of the amended JSE Listings Requirements. – Continue attention to the areas focused on during 2023. GG Gelink Chairman, audit committee Sandton 13 September 2023 -- 16 of 354 -- -B17- DIRECTORS’ RESPONSIBILITY STATEMENT AND APPROVAL OF THE ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS TO THE SHAREHOLDERS OF FIRSTRAND LIMITED The directors of FirstRand Limited (the company or the group) are responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of the consolidated and separate annual financial statements comprising the statement of financial position, income statement, and statements of comprehensive income, changes in equity and cash flows, and the notes to the annual financial statements as at, and for the year ended 30 June 2023. These annual financial statements have been prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards, including interpretations issued by the IFRS Interpretations Committee, the Financial Reporting Pronouncements as issued by the Financial Reporting Standards Council, the South African Institute of Chartered Accountants (SAICA) Financial Reporting Guides as issued by the Accounting Practices Committee, the JSE Listings Requirements, the Banks Act, no. 94 of 1990 and the requirements of the Companies Act, no. 71 of 2008. Simonet Terblanche, CA(SA), supervised the preparation of the annual financial statements for the year. The directors have reviewed the group and company’s budgets and flow of funds forecasts and considered the group and company’s ability to continue as a going concern in light of current and anticipated economic conditions. On the basis of this review, the directors are satisfied that it has adequate resources to continue in business for the foreseeable future and the going concern basis has been adopted in the preparation of the annual financial statements. Chief executive and chief financial officers’ responsibility statement relating to internal financial controls The CEO and CFO, whose names appear below, hereby confirm that: a) the consolidated annual financial statements of the group, which appear on pages B105 to B326, and the separate annual financial statements of the company, which appear on pages B327 to B344, fairly present in all material respects the financial position, financial performance and cash flows of the issuer in terms of IFRS; b) to the best of our knowledge and belief, no facts have been omitted or untrue statements made that would make the annual financial statements false or misleading; c) internal financial controls have been put in place to ensure that material information relating to the issuer and its consolidated subsidiaries have been provided to effectively prepare the financial statements of the issuer; d) the internal financial controls are adequate and effective and can be relied upon in compiling the annual financial statements, having fulfilled our role and function as executive directors with primary responsibility for implementation and execution of controls; e) where we are not satisfied, we have disclosed to the audit committee and auditors any deficiencies in the design and operational effectiveness of the internal financial controls and have taken steps to remedy the deficiencies; and f) we are not aware of any fraud involving directors. The group’s system of controls includes controls over the security of the website and specifically establishing and controlling the process for electronically distributing annual financial statements and other financial information to shareholders. -- 17 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B18- DIRECTORS’ RESPONSIBILITY STATEMENT AND APPROVAL OF THE ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS continued Approval of the separate and consolidated annual financial statements The separate and consolidated annual financial statements, as set out on the pages outlined above, were approved by the board of directors on 13 September 2023. It is the responsibility of the group’s independent external auditors, Deloitte & Touche and PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc., to report on the fair presentation of the annual financial statements. These annual financial statements have been audited in terms of section 29(1) of the Companies Act, no 71 of 2008. Their unmodified report appears on page B25. WR Jardine AP Pullinger H Kellan Chairman Chief executive officer Chief financial officer Sandton 13 September 2023 -- 18 of 354 -- -B19- COMPANY SECRETARY’S CERTIFICATION DECLARATION BY THE COMPANY SECRETARY IN RESPECT OF SECTION 88(2)(E) OF THE COMPANIES ACT I declare that, to the best of my knowledge, the company has lodged with the Commissioner of the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission all such returns and notices as required of a public company in terms of the Companies Act and that all such returns and notices are true, correct and up to date. C Low Company secretary Sandton 13 September 2023 -- 19 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B20- DIRECTORS’ REPORT for the year ended 30 June 2023 NATURE OF BUSINESS FirstRand Limited is a public company and registered bank-controlling company with a primary listing on the JSE (under Financial – Banks, share code: FSR) and a secondary listing on the Namibian Stock Exchange (NSX) (share code: FST). FirstRand Limited is the holding company of the FirstRand group of companies. FirstRand’s portfolio of integrated financial services businesses comprises FNB, RMB, WesBank and Aldermore and offers a universal set of transactional, lending, investment and insurance products and services. The Centre segment represents group-wide functions. Whilst the group is predominantly South Africa-based, it has subsidiaries in the United Kingdom (being Aldermore Group plc), Namibia, Botswana, Zambia, Mozambique, Tanzania, Nigeria, Eswatini, Lesotho and Ghana. The bank has branches in India, London and Guernsey, and representative offices in Kenya, Angola, New York and China. The board acknowledges its responsibilities for the integrity of this report. Guidelines as provided by King IV have been adopted in preparation of this report. The board believes that this report fairly represents the performance of the group. GROUP RESULTS Profit after tax amounted to R38 712 million (2022: R34 639 million). The operating results and the state of affairs of the company and the group are fully disclosed in the annual financial statements. DIVIDEND DECLARATIONS Dividends ORDINARY SHARES Year ended 30 June Cents per share 2023 2022 Interim (declared 1 March 2023) 189.0 157.0 Final (declared 13 September 2023) 195.0 185.0 Annual ordinary dividends 384.0 342.0 Special dividend (declared 14 September 2023) - 125.0 Total dividends 384.0 467.0 DISTRIBUTIONS ON OTHER EQUITY INSTRUMENTS Distributions of R1 119 million were made on other equity instruments (2022: R838 million). Current tax of R258 million (2022: R166 million) relating to the AT1 instruments was recognised in the income statement. -- 20 of 354 -- -B21- DIRECTORS’ REPORT continued B preference shares Dividends on the B preference shares are calculated at a rate of 75.56% of the prime lending rate of FNB, a division of FirstRand Bank Limited. Dividends declared and paid Year ended 30 June Cents per share 2023 2022 Period: 23 February 2021 – 30 August 2021 - 273.9 31 August 2021 – 28 February 2022 - 270.7 1 March 2022 – 29 August 2022 307.4 - 30 August 2022 – 26 September 2022 52.2 - Other distributions on the AT1 instruments and contingent convertible securities totalled R957 million (2022: R593 million). SHARE CAPITAL Details of FirstRand’s authorised share capital as at 30 June 2023 are shown in note 28 to the group’s financial statements. Ordinary share capital There were no changes to authorised or issued ordinary share capital during the year. Preference share capital There were no changes to authorised preference share capital during the year. -- 21 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B22- DIRECTORS’ REPORT continued SHAREHOLDER ANALYSIS The following shareholders have a significant beneficial interest in FirstRand’s issued ordinary shares. % 2023 2022 Public Investment Corporation 16.1 16.1 Black economic empowerment (BEE) partners 4.9 5.2 Royal Bafokeng Holdings 3.0 3.0 Remgro Limited 1.8 2.4 A further analysis of shareholders is set out in section C. EVENTS AFTER REPORTING PERIOD The directors are not aware of any material events that have occurred between the date of the financial position and the date of this report. -- 22 of 354 -- -B23- DIRECTORS’ REPORT continued BOARD CHANGES The following changes to the board of directors took place during the 2023 financial year. EFFECTIVE DATE Resignations TS Mashego Independent non-executive director 2 December 2022 Appointments TC Issacs Independent non-executive director 22 June 2023 DIRECTORS’ AND PRESCRIBED OFFICERS’ INTERESTS IN FIRSTRAND Closed periods commence on 1 January and 1 July and are in force until the announcement of the interim and year end results. Closed periods also include any period where the company is trading under caution or where participants have knowledge of price sensitive information. A director or prescribed officer is prohibited from using their position or confidential and price sensitive information to benefit themselves or any related party. Under the requirements of the Companies Act. 71 of 2008 (the Act), a director must use their power and perform their functions in good faith and for a proper purpose in the best interest of the company. This includes the duty to avoid a conflict of interest. Directors’ and officers’ are required to notify the board of any matter in which they have a personal financial interest or in which they know that a related party has a personal financial interest in relation to particular items of business or other directorships. At the request of the chair, declarations are tabled before commencement of each board meeting and all board members are required to declare their interests and potential conflicts in dealing with matters for consideration at the meeting. In terms of the JSE Listings Requirements, directors and prescribed officers are prohibited from dealing in any securities of the company during prohibited periods. All directors’ dealings require the prior approval of the chairman before trading in the company’s securities, and the company secretary retains a record of all such dealings in securities and approvals. Trading in securities by employees who are exposed to price sensitive information is subject to the group’s personal account trading rules. It is not a requirement of the company’s memorandum of incorporation or the board charter that directors own shares in the company. -- 23 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B24- DIRECTORS’ REPORT continued Directors’ and Prescribed Officers’ interest in ordinary shares in FirstRand Limited. 30 June 2023 Direct beneficial (thousands) Indirect beneficial (thousands) Held by associates (thousands) Total 2023 (thousands) Total 2022 (thousands) Percentage holding % Executive directors and prescribed officers A Pullinger 5 933 - 108 6 041 5 737 0.11 HS Kellan * 1 345 667 153 2 165 1 884 0.04 M Vilakazi ** 252 - - 252 - 0.00 J Celliers 447 49 - 496 426 0.01 S Cooper ** - 89 - 89 - 0.00 JR Formby # 711 890 - 1 601 1 460 0.03 EA Brown† 418 - - 418 - 0.01 Non-executive directors JP Burger‡ - 5 912 124 6 036 6 888 0.11 GG Gelink ** 102 - - 102 102 0.00 WR Jardine ** 11 232 4 247 247 0.00 RM Loubser - 1 810 2 1 812 1 812 0.03 Z Roscherr 659 - - 659 659 0.01 T Winterboer ** 15 - - 15 15 0.00 L von Zeuner ** 5 3 - 8 8 0.00 TC Isaacs **,^ - - 4 4 - 0.00 Total 9 898 9 652 395 19 945 19 238 0.35 * Has 2 000 000 debt securities in FirstRand Bank Ltd which do not form part of this calculation. ** Percentage is insignificant in relation to total issued share capital. # Resigned effective 30 September 2022. † Appointed as RMB CEO effective 1 October 2022. ‡ 900 000 shares have been pledged as collateral at a financial institution. ^ Appointed June 2023. Directors’ interests remained unchanged from the end of the financial year to the date of this report (including those of directors who have retired and resigned). WR Jardine AP Pullinger HS Kellan Chairman Chief executive officer Chief financial officer Sandton 13 September 2023 -- 24 of 354 -- -B25- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT To the Shareholders of FirstRand Limited Report on the audit of the consolidated and separate financial statements Our Opinion In our opinion, the consolidated and separate financial statements present fairly, in all material respects, the consolidated and separate financial position of FirstRand Limited (the Company) and its subsidiaries (together the Group) as at 30 June 2023, and its consolidated and separate financial performance and its consolidated and separate cash flows for the year then ended in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards and the requirements of the Companies Act of South Africa. What we have audited FirstRand Limited’s consolidated and separate financial statements set out on pages B37 to B344 comprise: ● the consolidated and separate statements of financial position as at 30 June 2023; ● the consolidated income statement for the year then ended; ● the consolidated statement of other comprehensive income for the year then ended; ● the separate statement of comprehensive income for the year then ended; ● the consolidated and separate statements of changes in equity for the year then ended; ● the consolidated and separate statements of cash flows for the year then ended; and ● the notes to the financial statements, which include a summary of significant accounting policies. Basis for opinion We conducted our audit in accordance with International Standards on Auditing (ISAs). Our responsibilities under those standards are further described in the Auditors’ responsibilities for the audit of the consolidated and separate financial statements section of our report. We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion. Deloitte & Touche, Registered Auditors, Financial Services Team – FIST, 5 Magwa Crescent, Waterfall City Private Bag X6, Gallo Manor 2052, South Africa Tel: +27 (0)11 806 5200, www.deloitte.com National Executive: *R Redfearn Chief Executive Officer *GM Berry Chief Operating Officer JW Eshun Mananging Director Businesses LN Mahluza Chief People Officer *N Sing Chief Risk Officer AP Theophanides Chief Sustainability Officer *NA le Riche Chief Growth Officer *ML Tshabalala Audit & Assurance AM Babu Consulting TA Odukoya Financial Advisory G Rammego Risk Advisory DI Kubeka Tax & Legal DP Ndlovu Chair of the Board A full list of partners and directors is available on request *Partner and Registered Auditor B-BBEE rating: Level 1 contribution in terms of the DTI Generic Scorecard as per the amended Codes of Good Practice. Associate of Deloitte Africa, a member of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc., 4 Lisbon Lane, Waterfall City, Jukskei View, 2090 Private Bag X36, Sunninghill, 2157, South Africa T: +27 (0) 11 797 4000, F: +27 (0) 11 209 5800, www.pwc.co.za Chief Executive Officer: L S Machaba The Company's principal place of business is at 4 Lisbon Lane, Waterfall City, Jukskei View, where a list of directors' names is available for inspection. Reg. no. 1998/012055/21, VAT reg.no. 4950174682. -- 25 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B26- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT continued Independence We are independent of the Group in accordance with the Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors’ Code of Professional Conduct for Registered Auditors (IRBA Code) and other independence requirements applicable to performing audits of financial statements in South Africa. We have fulfilled our other ethical responsibilities in accordance with the IRBA Code and in accordance with other ethical requirements applicable to performing audits in South Africa. The IRBA Code is consistent with the corresponding sections of the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants’ International Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants (including International Independence Standards). Our audit approach Overview Overall group materiality ● Overall group materiality: R2 545 million, which represents 5% of consolidated income before income tax. Key audit matters ● Impairment of advances ● Fair value measurement As part of designing our audit, we determined materiality and assessed the risks of material misstatement in the consolidated and separate financial statements. In particular, we considered where the directors made subjective judgements; for example, in respect of significant accounting estimates that involved making assumptions and considering future events that are inherently uncertain. As in all of our audits, we also addressed the risk of management override of internal controls, including among other matters, consideration of whether there was evidence of bias that represented a risk of material misstatement due to fraud. Materiality The scope of our audit was influenced by our application of materiality. An audit is designed to obtain reasonable assurance whether the financial statements are free from material misstatement. Misstatements may arise due to fraud or error. They are considered material if individually or in aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken on the basis of the consolidated financial statements. Based on our professional judgement, we determined certain quantitative thresholds for materiality, including the overall group materiality for the consolidated financial statements as a whole as set out in the table below. These, together with qualitative considerations, helped us to determine the scope of our audit and the nature, timing and extent of our audit procedures and to evaluate the effect of misstatements, both individually and in aggregate on the financial statements as a whole. Overall group materiality R2 545 million How we determined it 5% of consolidated income before income tax Rationale for the materiality benchmark applied We chose consolidated income before income tax as the benchmark because, in our view, it is the benchmark against which the performance of the Group is most commonly measured by users and is a generally accepted benchmark for listed companies. We chose 5% which is consistent with quantitative materiality thresholds used for profit-oriented companies in this sector. -- 26 of 354 -- -B27- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT continued Key audit matters Key audit matters are those matters that, in our professional judgement, were of most significance in our audit of the consolidated and separate financial statements of the current period. These matters were addressed in the context of our audit of the consolidated and separate financial statements as a whole, and in forming our opinion thereon, and we do not provide a separate opinion on these matters. We have determined that there are no key audit matters to communicate in our report in respect of the separate financial statements. Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter Impairment of advances Significant macroeconomic uncertainty persists in the environment in which the Group operates. Consequently, we expect management will continue to exercise judgement to ensure that the final Expected Credit Loss (ECL) is aligned to the requirements of International Financial Reporting Standard 9 – Financial Instruments (IFRS 9) and industry developments. This judgement includes the setting of macroeconomic scenarios and associated probabilities, as well as the forecasting of macroeconomic variables under the set scenarios. Impairment of advances is a matter of most significance to our current year audit due to the following: x Advances are material to the consolidated financial statements. x The level of subjective judgement applied in determining the ECL on advances. x Macroeconomic and event-driven uncertainty and its impact on the assessment of ECL. Our audit of impairment of advances included, inter alia, the following procedures to address the key areas of significant judgement and estimation in determining the ECL. We performed these procedures with the assistance of our economic, credit and actuarial experts: x Across all significant portfolios, we assessed the impairment practices applied by management against the requirements of IFRS 9. x We assessed the Group’s probability-weighted macroeconomic scenario estimates and evaluated the methodology, scenario views and associated probabilities in terms of the principles of IFRS 9. We considered whether the forecasts are sound in terms of macroeconomic forecasting principles. We reviewed the approval of these macroeconomic variables through the appropriate governance structures. This was performed through discussions with management and comparison to our own and benchmarked economic forecasts and independent market data, as well as attendance of the governance forums. x We confirmed that the latest approved macroeconomic outlook has been appropriately incorporated into the forward-looking estimate of ECL. We evaluated the impact of events and risks not included in the macroeconomic forecasts with reference to the industry environment. -- 27 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B28- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT continued Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter Wholesale advances* The areas of significant judgement and estimation include: Determination of PD, EAD and LGD x Input assumptions and methodologies applied to estimate the Probability of Default (PD), Exposure at Default (EAD) and Loss Given Default (LGD). x Through discussions with management and inspection of policy documents, obtained an understanding of the methodologies and assumptions used by management in the various ECL model components and how these were calibrated to use historical information to estimate future cash flows. x On a sample basis, tested controls over the credit risk management and governance processes when advancing new facilities, restructuring existing facilities or reviewing facilities on a periodic basis and determining credit ratings and PDs. x Evaluated the reasonability of how counterparties are grouped together with reference to similar risks (PD) or credit risk grades rating buckets. x Through discussions with management and inspection of policy documents, confirmed our understanding of the methodologies used to back-test PDs, EADs and LGDs to historical data or how these are linked to rating agencies inferred variables. x For a sample of facilities, assessed the quality of the data used in credit management, reporting and modelling for completeness and accuracy through data analytics and agreed model input data to underlying supporting documentation. x On a sample basis, assessed the appropriateness of assumptions made by management in determining the applicable macroeconomic inputs, credit ratings, EADs, PDs and LGDs in the current economic climate. -- 28 of 354 -- -B29- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT continued Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter Evaluation of SICR x Assessing whether there has been a Significant Increase in Credit Risk (SICR) event since the origination date of the exposure to the reporting date (i.e. a trigger event that has caused a significant deterioration in credit risk and results in migration of the loan from Stage 1 to Stage 2). x Selected a sample of performing advances and determined if the application of the SICR trigger was reasonable by forming an independent view based on publicly available information and management’s periodic credit reviews. Incorporation of macro-economic inputs and forward-looking information into the ECL measurement x Assessing the impact of macroeconomic uncertainty on the forward-looking econometric information incorporated into the respective models. x Ensuring consistency between forward-looking information (FLI) and the SICR assessment and ECL calculations. x Independently reperformed the ECL models based on management’s methodologies and assessed the areas of judgement within the methodology. x Determined an independent FLI assessment at an industry level to ensure the recent experience and economic outlook per industry were appropriately incorporated. Assessment of post model adjustments x Constraints in respect of the respective models’ ability to address specific trends or conditions due to inherent limitations of modelling based on past performance, the timing of model updates, specific events and changes in risk profile necessitate the raising of additional provisions as post-model adjustments. x To supplement our model reperformance and independent view, performed industry analyses for a sample of industries, and assessed a sample of individual counterparties based on publicly available information to confirm appropriateness of the assumptions applied in the post-model adjustments raised. Assessment of ECL raised for Stage 3 exposures x Assumptions used to estimate the recoverable amounts and timing of future cash flows of individual exposures, which have been classified as non-performing. * This applies to wholesale advances in C&I (South Africa and Broader Africa), as well as Centre (including Group Treasury). x In respect of Stage 3 advances, inspected a sample of legal agreements and underlying supporting documentation to assess the existence of a legal right to collateral and assessed the expected realisable value and timing of future cash flows. -- 29 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B30- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT continued Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter Retail and commercial advances** Retail and commercial advances are higher in volume and lower in value and, therefore, a significant portion of credit impairments are calculated on a portfolio basis. This requires the use of statistical models incorporating data and assumptions which are not always observable. The areas of significant judgement and estimation include: Determination of input assumptions applied to estimate the PD, EAD and LGD within the ECL measurement Management applies professional judgement in developing the credit impairment models, analysing data and determining the most appropriate assumptions and estimates. The inputs into the modelling process require significant management judgement, which include: x Input assumptions and methodologies applied to estimate the PD, EAD, and LGD within the ECL calculations. x Determining the expected value to be realised from collateral and the time it will take to realise. x Through discussions with management and inspection of policy documents, obtained an understanding of the methodologies and assumptions used by management in the various ECL model components (PD, LGD, EAD) and how these were calibrated to use historical information to estimate future cash flows and also to estimate forward-looking ECL. x Through reperformance, we tested the accurate implementation of the documented methodologies and assessed the alignment between modelled outcomes and recent actual experience. x Independently recalculated the ECL by applying our own independent assessment of the component inputs used by management. The independent results were compared to management’s results. x Assessed the appropriateness of the ECL methodology, including any refinements against actual experience and industry practice through benchmarking and evaluating alignment with the principles of IFRS 9. x Through independent reperformance, assessed the appropriateness of assumptions made by management in applying the macroeconomic inputs, credit risk grades, EADs, PDs, LGDs and valuation of collateral in the current economic climate. x Assessed the potential impact of reduced collateral values, a delayed recovery process and reduced cure from default for secured exposures by separately considering individually significant collateral, historically stressed collateral values and by quantifying the impact of potentially extended collateral realisations. -- 30 of 354 -- -B31- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT continued Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter Evaluation of SICR x The assessment of whether there has been a SICR event since the origination date of the exposure to the reporting date, considering the impact of the event driven uncertainty as well as future default rates forecast by the forward- looking macroeconomic model. x Through applying the assumptions and data included in management’s modelled client risk ratings and performance of cured accounts, assessed the accurate implementation of SICR classifications. x Tested the SICR thresholds applied and the resultant transfer of non-arrears accounts into Stage 2 for SICR. This includes comparing the volume of up-to-date accounts transferred to Stage 2 to the historical movements from performing into arrears and the impact of forward-looking expectation of default risk on these historical movements. x Tested the model ranking ability and model stability by testing the performance of client behavioural scores and other client behavioural data that drives PD estimates and SICR triggers. Determining of the write-off point x The determination of the write-off point, being the point at which there is no reasonable expectation of further recovery to be made, and application of the cure rules. x Evaluated the write-off point relative to historical post write-off recoveries to assess whether the write-off point applied by management is still the point at which there is no reasonable expectation of further recovery. x Through recalculation, we tested the application of the write-off policy, including the exclusion of post write-off recoveries from the LGD. -- 31 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B32- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT continued Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter Incorporation of macro-economic inputs and forward-looking information (FLI) into the ECL measurement x The incorporation of FLI and macroeconomic inputs into the SICR assessment and ECL calculations. x Determining and weighting of assumptions used in the forward-looking economic model to account for the forward-looking uncertainty. x Obtained an understanding of the assumptions used in the forward-looking economic model including the macroeconomic variables selected and the sensitivity of ECL components to each variable. x Tested the performance and sensitivity of the FLI model to evaluate whether the chosen macroeconomic factors, scenario weightings and model design provide a reasonable representation of the impact of the various macroeconomic scenarios on the ECL results. This included an assessment of the extent to which plausible downside risk scenarios are captured by the macroeconomic scenarios that are used to determine forward looking estimates. x Where applicable, developed an independent view to assess management’s forward-looking model by using our own challenger model and associated credit index Assessment of post model adjustments x Constraints in respect of the respective models’ ability to address specific trends or conditions due to inherent limitations of modelling based on past performance, the timing of model updates, specific events and changes in risk profile necessitate the raising of additional provisions as post-model adjustments. ** This applies to retail and commercial advances in total retail secured and unsecured, FNB Commercial, WesBank corporate, UK operations and Broader Africa. The credit impairment models are subject to formal model governance and approval. The related disclosures in the consolidated financial statements are included in: x Sections 4 and 9.4 – Accounting policies; x Note 11 – Advances; x Note 12 – Impairment of advances; and x Note 37 – Financial and Insurance risk. x Assessed, recalculated and performed a sensitivity analysis on management’s post-model adjustments relating to the impact on ECL of additional relevant information not catered for in the models. x Where applicable, we used an independent methodology to assess the appropriateness of post model adjustments and overlays to ensure that model and forward-looking risk is accurately accounted for and that adjustments are applied in a way that ensures consistency with the base models and estimates. -- 32 of 354 -- -B33- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT continued Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter Fair value measurement Valuation of complex financial instruments was considered to be a matter of most significance for the current year audit as management is required to exercise significant judgement in respect of complex valuation methodologies, as well as the determination of key inputs and assumptions. Factors such as unobservable inputs, funding costs, low levels of market liquidity, counterparty credit risk, market volatility, and economic and regulatory developments exacerbate the level of judgement required. The financial instruments impacted by management judgements, and which represent areas of most audit focus include: x Advances carried at fair value (level 3); x Derivative financial instruments (level 2 and 3); and x Investment securities valued with reference to unobservable inputs (level 3), in particular unlisted equities in C&I. The related disclosures in the consolidated financial statements are included in: x Section 4 – Accounting policies; and x Note 34 – Fair value measurements. With the assistance of our valuation experts, we performed the following audit procedures on the valuation of complex financial instruments: x Tested the design, implementation and operating effectiveness, as appropriate, of the relevant financial reporting controls, the existence of key governance structures and the general and information technology controls in the relevant technology systems supporting valuations. x Performed a risk assessment on the key components of fair value, based on complexity, sensitivity and exposure. The risk assessment was performed on curves, volatility surfaces, fair value models and valuation adjustments. x Evaluated the technical appropriateness and accuracy of valuation methodologies (including key assumptions made and modelling approaches adopted) applied by management with reference to financial instrument valuation theory, market practice and the requirements of IFRS, and for consistency with prior periods. x Assessed the appropriateness of the significant judgemental and/or unobservable inputs used in valuations, relating to funding costs, low levels of market liquidity, counterparty credit risk, and market volatility, against reasonable factors which impact the reported exit values, with reference to the best available independent information. x Considered the completeness and accuracy of management’s assessment of valuation adjustments required in terms of financial instrument valuation theory, market practice and the requirements of IFRS, as well as to respond to economic and regulatory developments impacting the portfolio. x Assessed the appropriateness of a sample of curves and volatility surfaces by reconstructing these using independently sourced market data. x For a sample of complex financial instruments, independently recalculated the fair values. -- 33 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B34- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT continued Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter x Understood and assessed the judgement applied in the recognition of revenue, specifically in relation to complex transactions such as private equity realisations or fund investments and assessed the judgement applied in determining the fair value of unlisted equity instruments carried at fair value. x Evaluated the appropriateness of the fair value hierarchy disclosures with reference to the requirements of IFRS 13 Fair Value Measurements. Other information The directors are responsible for the other information. The other information comprises the information included in the documents titled “FirstRand Annual Financial Statements for the year ended 30 June 2023” and “FirstRand Re- muneration Report for the year ended 30 June 2023”, which include the Directors’ Report, the Audit Committee Re- port and the Company Secretary’s Certification as required by the Companies Act of South Africa, which we obtained prior to the date of this auditor’s report, and the documents titled “FirstRand Corporate Governance Report for the year ended 30 June 2023”, “Chairman’s Report”, “CEO’s Report”, “CFO’s Report” and “FirstRand Material Risk Fac- tor Disclosure for the year ended 30 June 2023”, which are expected to be made available to us after that date. The other information does not include the consolidated or the separate financial statements and our auditors’ report thereon. Our opinion on the consolidated and separate financial statements does not cover the other information and we do not and will not express an audit opinion or any form of assurance conclusion thereon. In connection with our audit of the consolidated and separate financial statements, our responsibility is to read the other information identified above and, in doing so, consider whether the other information is materially inconsistent with the consolidated and separate financial statements or our knowledge obtained in the audit, or otherwise appears to be materially misstated. If, based on the work we have performed on the other information that we obtained prior to the date of this auditor’s re- port, we conclude that there is a material misstatement of this other information, we are required to report that fact. We have nothing to report in this regard. Responsibilities of the directors for the consolidated and separate financial statements The directors are responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of the consolidated and separate financial statements in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards and the requirements of the Companies Act of South Africa, and for such internal control as the directors determine is necessary to enable the preparation of consolidated and separate financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error. In preparing the consolidated and separate financial statements, the directors are responsible for assessing the Group and the Company’s ability to continue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable, matters related to going concern and using the going concern basis of accounting unless the directors either intend to liquidate the Group and/or the Company or to cease operations, or have no realistic alternative but to do so. -- 34 of 354 -- -B35- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT continued Auditors’ responsibilities for the audit of the consolidated and separate financial statements Our objectives are to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the consolidated and separate financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to issue an auditors’ report that includes our opinion. Reasonable assurance is a high level of assurance, but is not a guarantee that an audit conducted in accordance with ISAs will always detect a material misstatement when it exists. Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are considered material if, individually or in the aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken on the basis of these consolidated and separate financial statements. As part of an audit in accordance with ISAs, we exercise professional judgement and maintain professional scepticism throughout the audit. We also: x Identify and assess the risks of material misstatement of the consolidated and separate financial statements, whether due to fraud or error, design and perform audit procedures responsive to those risks, and obtain audit evidence that is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion. The risk of not detecting a material misstatement resulting from fraud is higher than for one resulting from error, as fraud may involve collusion, forgery, intentional omissions, misrepresentations, or the override of internal control. x Obtain an understanding of internal control relevant to the audit in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances, but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the Group’s and the Company’s internal control. x Evaluate the appropriateness of accounting policies used and the reasonableness of accounting estimates and related disclosures made by the directors. x Conclude on the appropriateness of the directors’ use of the going concern basis of accounting and, based on the audit evidence obtained, whether a material uncertainty exists related to events or conditions that may cast significant doubt on the Group’s and the Company’s ability to continue as a going concern. If we conclude that a material uncertainty exists, we are required to draw attention in our auditors’ report to the related disclosures in the consolidated and separate financial statements or, if such disclosures are inadequate, to modify our opinion. Our conclusions are based on the audit evidence obtained up to the date of our auditors’ report. However, future events or conditions may cause the Group and / or Company to cease to continue as a going concern. x Evaluate the overall presentation, structure and content of the consolidated and separate financial statements, including the disclosures, and whether the consolidated and separate financial statements represent the underlying transactions and events in a manner that achieves fair presentation. x Obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence regarding the financial information of the entities or business activities within the group to express an opinion on the consolidated financial statements. We are responsible for the direction, supervision and performance of the group audit. We remain solely responsible for our audit opinion. We communicate with the directors regarding, among other matters, the planned scope and timing of the audit and significant audit findings, including any significant deficiencies in internal control that we identify during our audit. We also provide the directors with a statement that we have complied with relevant ethical requirements regarding independence, and to communicate with them all relationships and other matters that may reasonably be thought to bear on our independence, and where applicable, actions taken to eliminate threats or safeguards applied. From the matters communicated with the directors, we determine those matters that were of most significance in the audit of the consolidated and separate financial statements of the current period and are therefore the key audit matters. We describe these matters in our auditors’ report unless law or regulation precludes public disclosure about the matter or when, in extremely rare circumstances, we determine that a matter should not be communicated in our report because the adverse consequences of doing so would reasonably be expected to outweigh the public interest benefits of such communication. -- 35 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B36- INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT continued Report on other legal and regulatory requirements In terms of the IRBA Rule published in Government Gazette Number 39475 dated 4 December 2015, we report that Deloitte & Touche and PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. have been the joint auditors of FirstRand Limited for 13 years. Prior to the commencement of the joint audit relationship, PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. were the sole auditors of FirstRand Limited for 14 years. Deloitte & Touche PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. Registered Auditor Registered Auditor Per Partner: Kevin Black Director: Keith Ackerman Johannesburg, South Africa Johannesburg, South Africa 13 September 2023 13 September 2023 -- 36 of 354 -- -B37- ACCOUNTING POLICIES 1 INTRODUCTION AND BASIS OF PREPARATION The group’s consolidated and separate annual financial statements have been prepared in accordance with IFRS, including interpretations issued by the IFRS Interpretations Committee, Financial Reporting Pronouncements as issued by the Financial Reporting Standards Council, SAICA Financial Reporting Guides as issued by the Accounting Practices Committee, JSE Listings Requirements, the Banks Act and requirements of the Companies Act no 71 of 2008. These financial statements comprise the statements of financial position (also referred to as the balance sheet) as at 30 June 2023; the income statements and statements of other comprehensive income; statements of changes in equity and statements of cash flows for the year ended; as well as the notes, which comprise a summary of significant accounting policies and other explanatory notes. Presentation of financial statements, functional and foreign currency Items included in the financial statements of each of the group’s entities are measured using the currency of the primary economic environment in which the entity operates (the functional currency). Presentation The group presents its statement of financial position in order of liquidity. Where permitted or required under IFRS, the group offsets assets and liabilities or income and expenses and presents the net amount in the statement of financial position, the income statement or the statement of other comprehensive income. Materiality IFRS is only applicable to material items. Management applies judgement and considers both qualitative and quantitative factors in determining materiality. Functional and presentation currency of the group South African rand (R) Level of rounding All amounts are presented in millions of rands. The group has a policy of rounding up in increments of R500 000. Amounts less than R500 000 will therefore round down to Rnil and are presented as a dash. Foreign operations with a different functional currency from the group presentation currency The financial position and results of the group’s foreign operations are translated at the closing or average exchange rate, as required per IAS 21. Upon consolidation, exchange differences arising on the translation of the net investment in foreign operations are recognised as a separate component of other comprehensive income (OCI) (the foreign currency translation reserve) and are reclassified to profit or loss upon loss of control of the foreign operation. The net investment in a foreign operation includes any monetary items for which settlement is neither planned nor likely in the foreseeable future. Foreign currency transactions of the group Translated into the functional currency using the exchange rates prevailing at the date of the transactions. -- 37 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B38- 1 INTRODUCTION AND BASIS OF PREPARATION continued Translation and treatment of foreign denominated balances Translated at the relevant exchange rates, depending on whether it is a monetary item (in which case the closing spot rate is applied) or non-monetary items. For non-monetary items measured at cost the rate applied is the rate on transaction date. For non-monetary items measured at fair value the rate at the date the fair value is determined (reporting date) is applied. Foreign exchange gains or losses are recognised in profit or loss in fair value gains or losses. To the extent that foreign exchange gains or losses relate to financial assets held at fair value through other comprehensive income (FVOCI) the following applies: ¾ Equity instruments ‒ recognised in OCI as part of the fair value movement; and ¾ Debt instruments ‒ allocated between profit or loss (those that relate to changes in amortised cost) and OCI (those that relate to changes in the fair value). Application of the going concern principle The directors reviewed the group’s and company’s budgets and flow of funds forecasts for the next three years and considered the group’s and company’s ability to continue as a going concern. Based on the projections of the impact on the group’s capital, funding and liquidity requirements, all have remained within internal targets and above regulatory requirements. -- 38 of 354 -- -B39- 1 INTRODUCTION AND BASIS OF PREPARATION continued Forecast growth in earnings and balance sheet risk-weighted assets (RWA) is based on the group’s macroeconomic outlook and is evaluated against available financial resources, considering the requirements of capital providers, regulators and rating agencies. The expected outcomes and constraints are then stress tested, and the group sets targets through different business cycles and scenarios. On the basis of this review, and in light of the current financial position and profitable trading history, the directors are satisfied that the group has adequate resources to continue in business for the foreseeable future. The going concern basis, therefore, continues to apply and has been adopted in the preparation of the annual financial statements. The group adopts the following significant accounting policies in preparing its financial statements. These policies have been consistently applied to all years presented. Segmental analysis The segmental analysis included in the segment report is based on the information reported to the chief operating decision maker (CODM) for the respective segments under the current operating business management structures. The information is prepared in terms of IFRS and certain adjustments are made to the segment results in order to eliminate the effect of non-taxable income and other segment-specific items that impact certain key ratios reviewed by the CODM when assessing the operating segments’ performance. In addition, certain normalised adjustments are also processed to the segment results. SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES 2 Subsidiaries, associates and joint arrangements Consolidation and equity accounting (section 2.1) Related party transactions (section 2.2) 3 Income, expenses and taxation Income and expenses (section 3.1) Taxation (section 3.2) 4 Financial instruments Classification and measurement (section 4.1) Impairment (section 4.2) Derivatives and hedge accounting (section 4.5) Transfers, modifications and derecognition (section 4.3) Offset and collateral (section 4.4) -- 39 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B40- 1 INTRODUCTION AND BASIS OF PREPARATION continued SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES 5 Other assets and liabilities Property and equipment (section 5.1) Investment properties (section 5.1) Intangible assets (section 5.1) Commodities (section 5.1) Provisions (section 5.1) Non-current assets held for sale (section 5.2) Leases (section 5.3) 6 Capital and reserves Share capital and treasury shares Dividends and non- cash distributions Other reserves 7 Transactions with employees Employee liabilities (section 7.1) Share-based payment transactions (section 7.2) 8 Non-banking activities Insurance activities (section 8.1) Investment management activities (section 8.2) 9 Critical accounting estimates, assumptions and judgements Introduction (section 9.1) Subsidiaries, associates and joint arrangements (section 9.2) Taxation (section 9.3) Impairment of financial assets (section 9.4) Provisions (section 9.5) Transactions with employees (section 9.6) Insurance and investment management activities (section 9.7) The accounting policies and other methods of computation applied in the preparation of the consolidated financial statements are in terms of IFRS and are consistent with those applied for the year ended 30 June 2022. The consolidated financial statements are prepared in accordance with the going concern principle under the historical cost basis, as modified by fair value accounting or certain assets and liabilities, where required or permitted by IFRS. New standards adopted in the current year Improvements to the Conceptual Framework, as well as amendments to IAS 16 Property, Plant and Equipment, IAS 37 Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets and IFRS 9 Financial Instruments became effective in the current year. None of these amendments to IFRS impacted the group’s reported earnings, financial position or reserves, or the accounting policies. -- 40 of 354 -- -B41- 2 SUBSIDIARIES, ASSOCIATES AND JOINT ARRANGEMENTS 2.1 Basis of consolidation and equity accounting Subsidiaries and other structured entities Associates Joint ventures Typical shareholding in the assessment of entities that are not structured entities Greater than 50% Between 20% and 50% Between 20% and 50% When an entity is a structured entity and control of it is not evidenced through shareholding, the group considers the substance of the arrangement and the group’s involvement with it to determine whether the group has control, joint control or significant influence over the significant decisions that impact its relevant activities. Nature of the relationship between the group and the investee Entities over which the group has control, as defined in IFRS 10, are consolidated. These include certain investment funds managed by the group, securitisation structures or other entities used for the purpose of buying or selling credit protection. Entities over which the group has significant influence as defined in IAS 28. These include investment funds not consolidated, but which the group has significant influence over. A joint arrangement in terms of which the group and the other contracting parties have joint control, as defined in IFRS 11. Joint ventures are those joint arrangements where the group has rights to the net assets of the arrangement. Separate financial statements The company measures investments in the above entities at cost less impairment (in terms of IAS 36), with the exception of investments acquired and held exclusively with the view to dispose of them in the near future (within 12 months). These investments are measured at fair value less cost to sell in terms of IFRS 5. Consolidated financial statements Consolidation Equity accounting Initial recognition in the consolidated financial statements Subsidiaries acquired are accounted for by applying the acquisition method of accounting to business combinations. The excess (shortage) of the sum of the consideration transferred, the value of non-controlling interest and the fair value of any existing interest, over the fair value of identifiable net assets are recognised as goodwill or a gain on bargain purchase, as set out further below. Transaction costs are included in operating expenses within profit or loss, when incurred. Associates and joint ventures are initially recognised at cost (including goodwill) and subsequently equity accounted. The carrying amount is increased or decreased to recognise the group’s share of profit or loss from the investee after the date of acquisition. Items that impact the investee’s net asset value (NAV) that don’t impact OCI are recognised directly in gains less losses from investing activities within non-interest revenue (NIR). -- 41 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B42- 2 SUBSIDIARIES, ASSOCIATES AND JOINT ARRANGEMENTS continued 2.1 Basis of consolidation and equity accounting continued Consolidated financial statements Consolidation Equity accounting Intercompany transactions and balances Intercompany transactions are all eliminated on consolidation, including unrealised gains. Unrealised losses on transactions between group entities are also eliminated unless the transaction provides evidence of impairment of the transferred asset, in which case the transferred asset will be tested for impairment in accordance with the group’s impairment policies. Unrealised gains on transactions are eliminated to the extent of the group’s interest in the entity. Unrealised losses are also eliminated to the extent of the group’s interest in the entity, unless the transaction provides evidence of an impairment of the transferred asset. Common control transaction There is currently no guidance under IFRS for the accounting treatment of business combinations under common control. In terms of IAS 8, the group developed an accounting policy that requires that business combinations under common control use the predecessor values of the acquiree without the restatement of comparatives. Therefore, any difference between the NAV and the amount paid (i.e. the purchase consideration) is recorded directly in equity. Impairment In the consolidated financial statements either the cash generating unit (CGU) is tested, i.e. a grouping of assets no higher than an operating segment of the group, or, if the entity is not part of a CGU, the individual assets of the subsidiary and goodwill are tested for impairment in terms of IAS 36. The entire carrying amount of the investment, including other long-term interests, is tested for impairment. Certain loans and other long-term interests in associates and joint ventures are considered to be, in substance, part of the net investment in the entity when settlement is neither planned nor likely to occur in the foreseeable future. Such items may include preference shares and long-term receivables or loans, but do not include trade receivables or any long-term loans for which adequate collateral exists. These loans and other long-term interests in associates and joint ventures are included in advances on the face of the statement of financial position and are measured in terms of IFRS 9. -- 42 of 354 -- -B43- 2 SUBSIDIARIES, ASSOCIATES AND JOINT ARRANGEMENTS continued 2.1 Basis of consolidation and equity accounting continued Consolidated financial statements Consolidation Equity accounting The value of such loans after any expected credit losses (ECL) raised for IFRS 9 where such loans are measured at amortised cost is, however, included in the carrying amount of the investee for purposes of determining the share of losses of the investee attributable to the group and for impairment testing purposes. Goodwill Goodwill on the acquisition of businesses and subsidiaries represents excess consideration transferred and is recognised as an intangible asset at cost less accumulated impairment losses. If this amount is negative, as in the case of a bargain purchase, the difference is immediately recognised in gains less losses from investing activities within NIR. Goodwill is tested annually for impairment by the group in March, or earlier if there are objective indicators of impairment. For subsidiaries acquired between March and June, a goodwill impairment test is performed in June in the year of acquisition and thereafter annually in March. For testing purposes, goodwill is allocated to a suitable CGU. Impairment losses in respect of goodwill are not subsequently reversed. Notional goodwill on the acquisition of associates and joint ventures is included in the equity accounted carrying amount of the investment. An impairment loss is reversed if there has been a change in the estimates used to determine the recoverable amount, but only to the extent that the investment’s carrying amount does not exceed the carrying amount that would have been determined if no impairment loss had been recognised. Non- controlling interest Non-controlling interests in the net assets of subsidiaries are separately identified and presented from the group’s equity. All transactions with non-controlling interests which do not result in a loss of control are treated as transactions with equityholders. Transactions with other shareholders are not equity transactions and the effects thereof are recognised in profit or loss as part of gains less losses from investing activities in NIR. -- 43 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B44- 2 SUBSIDIARIES, ASSOCIATES AND JOINT ARRANGEMENTS continued 2.1 Basis of consolidation and equity accounting continued Consolidated financial statements Consolidation Equity accounting Partial disposals and increases in effective shareholding between 50% and 100% are treated as transactions with equityholders. Non-controlling interest is initially measured either at the proportional share of net assets or at fair value. The measurement distinction is made by the group on a case-by-case basis. Interests in unconsolidated structured entities Interests in unconsolidated structured entities may expose the group to variability in returns from the structured entity. However, because of a lack of power over the structured entity it is not consolidated. Normal customer or supplier relationships, where the group transacts with the structured entity on the same terms as other third parties, are not considered to be interests in the entity. From time to time the group also sponsors the formation of structured entities primarily for the purpose of allowing clients to hold investments, for asset securitisation transactions and for buying and selling credit protection. Where the interest or sponsorship does not result in control, disclosures of these interests or sponsorships are made in the notes in terms of IFRS 12. 2.2 Related party transactions Related parties of the group, as defined, include: Subsidiaries Associates Joint ventures Post-employment benefit funds (pension funds) Entities that have significant influence over the group, and subsidiaries of these entities Key management personnel (KMP) Close family members of KMP Entities controlled, jointly controlled or significantly influenced by KMP or their close family members KMP of the group are the FirstRand Limited board of directors and prescribed officers, including any entities which provide KMP services to the group. Their close family members include spouse/domestic partner and dependent children, domestic partner’s dependent children and any other dependants of the individual or their domestic partner. Children over the age of 25 are not considered dependants. -- 44 of 354 -- -B45- 3 INCOME, EXPENSES AND TAXATION 3.1 Income and expenses Net interest income recognised in profit or loss Interest income includes: ¾ interest on financial instruments measured at amortised cost and debt instruments measured at FVOCI, including the effect of qualifying hedges for interest rate risk. ¾ interest on financial asset debt instruments measured at fair value through profit or loss (FVTPL) that are held by and managed as part of the group’s funding or insurance operations. ¾ interest income is calculated using the effective interest rate, which includes origination fees. The original effective interest rate is applied to: o the gross carrying amount (GCA) of financial assets which are not credit impaired; and o the amortised cost of financial assets which represents the net carrying amount, from the month after the assets become credit-impaired (refer to section 4.2 of the accounting policies). ¾ modified advances (derecognition not achieved) – the unamortised portion of origination fees and capitalised transaction costs on financial assets are included as part of interest income. The interest income on the modified financial asset (refer to accounting policy 4.3) is calculated by applying the original effective interest rate to the asset’s modified GCA. ¾ modified advances (derecognition is achieved) – the unamortised portion of origination fees and capitalised transaction costs on financial assets are included as part of interest income. New fees or costs charged on the new advance which are integral to the new asset recognised are capitalised to the new loan. Interest expense includes: ¾ interest on financial liabilities measured at amortised cost; ¾ interest on financial liabilities measured at FVTPL that are held by and managed as part of the group’s funding or insurance operations; ¾ interest on capitalised leases where the group is the lessee; and ¾ the difference between the purchase and resale price in repurchase and reverse repurchase agreements where the related advances or deposit is measured at amortised cost, because the amount is in substance interest. The total interest expense is reduced by the amount of interest incurred in respect of liabilities used to fund the group’s fair value activities. This amount is reported in fair value income within NIR. -- 45 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B46- 3 INCOME, EXPENSES AND TAXATION continued 3.1 Income and expenses continued Non-interest and financial instrument revenue recognised in profit or loss Non-interest revenue from contracts with customers Under IFRS 15, where a five-step analysis is required to determine the amount and timing of revenue recognition, the group assesses contracts and determines whether the fees identified in the contract relate to revenue as defined in IFRS 15. The revenue is recognised only if the group can identify the contract and the performance obligation (i.e. the different goods or services) and can determine the transaction price, which is required to be allocated to the identifiable performance obligations. Unless specifically stated otherwise, the group is the principal in its revenue arrangements as the group controls the goods and services before transferring them to the customer. Fee and commission income Fees and commissions that form an integral part of the effective interest rate are excluded from fees and commissions from customers. Fee and commission income is earned by the group by providing customers with a range of services and products, and consists of the following main categories: ¾ banking fee and commission income; ¾ knowledge-based fee and commission income; ¾ management, trust and fiduciary fees; ¾ fee and commission income from service providers; and ¾ other non-banking fee and commission income. The bulk of fee and commission income is earned on the execution of a single performance obligation and, as such, it is not necessary to make significant judgements when allocating the transaction price to the performance obligation. As such, fee and commission income, which typically includes transactional banking fees such as bank charges, interchange fees, point-of-sale fees, exchange commissions, cash deposit fees and knowledge-based fee and commission income, is recognised at a point in time. Where the distinct performance obligation is satisfied over a period of time, the fees are recognised as follows: ¾ Fees for services rendered are recognised on an accrual basis as the service is rendered and the group’s performance obligation is satisfied, e.g. annual card fees and asset management and related fees. ¾ Commission income on bills and promissory notes endorsed is credited to profit or loss over the life of the relevant instrument on a time apportionment basis. Commitment fees for unutilised funds made available to customers in the past are recognised as revenue at the end of the contract period. Commitment fees paid upfront for a future facility, where it is not probable that a specific lending arrangement will be entered into by the group, are recognised as revenue on a straight-line basis over the period for which the funds are promised to be kept available. -- 46 of 354 -- -B47- 3 INCOME, EXPENSES AND TAXATION continued 3.1 Income and expenses continued Non-interest and financial instrument revenue recognised in profit or loss Non-interest revenue from contracts with customers Fee and commission income Other non-banking fee and commission income relates to fees and commissions earned for rendering services to customers other than those related to the banking, insurance and asset management operations. This includes fee and commission income earned from providing services on behalf of third-party service providers, in effect acting as an agent. The revenue is recognised at a point in time and includes commission earned from the sale of prepaid airtime, data vouchers and electricity, and traffic fines paid through FNB channels, as well as insurance commission. The group operates a customer loyalty programme, known as eBucks, in terms of which it undertakes to provide reward credits to qualifying customers to buy goods and services, which results in the recognition of a performance obligation which the group needs to fulfil. The supplier of the goods or services to be acquired by customers can either be the group or an external third party. The group recognises a contract liability referred to as the customer loyalty programme liability, which represents the deferred amount of revenue resulting from providing these reward credits to customers. The amount deferred is equal to the maximum cash flow that could be required in order to settle the liability with the customer, as the supplier of goods and services could either be the bank itself or independent third parties. The deferred revenue in respect of which the eBucks liability is raised is recognised in the period in which the customer utilises their reward credits. When the group is acting as an agent, amounts collected and incurred on behalf of the principal are not recognised on a gross basis. Only the net commission retained by the group is recognised in fee and commission income. Fee and commission expenses Fee and commission expenses are those that are incremental and directly attributable to the generation of fee and commission income and are recognised as part of fee and commission income. These include transaction and service fees, which are expensed as the services are received. Expenses relating to the provision of the customer loyalty reward credits are recognised as fee and commission expenses as incurred. Insurance income – non-risk- related Where the group is acting as an agent, commissions and brokerage earned on the sale of insurance products to customers of the group on behalf of an insurer are recognised at the point that the significant obligation has been fulfilled. Income arising from third-party insurance cell captives and profit share agreements, where there is not a significant transfer of insurance risk, are executory contracts. Revenue is recognised when both parties have fulfilled their obligations. Insurance income – risk-related Insurance-related income represents the premiums written on short-term, long-term and vehicle-related warranty products which transfer significant insurance risk to the group, where the earned portion of the premium received is recognised as revenue. Reinsurance premiums are accounted for as expenses in the same accounting period as the premiums to which the reinsurance relates. Commissions payable, together with insurance benefits, claims and movements in insurance liabilities, provide the resultant insurance risk-related income. -- 47 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B48- 3 INCOME, EXPENSES AND TAXATION continued 3.1 Income and expenses continued Non-interest and financial instrument revenue recognised in profit or loss Non-interest revenue from contracts with customers Other non-interest revenue The group, through its various operating businesses and subsidiaries, sells value- added products, services and goods to customers. Revenue is recognised from products sold by the eBucks online store at a point in time when control of the goods transfers to the customer. For telecommunication products and services which consist of smart devices, as well as data, airtime contracts and bundled products (SIM services), revenue is recognised at a point in time when the smart device has been delivered to the customer, whereas revenue from SIM services are recognised over time, as and when the service is consumed by the customer (i.e. over the contract term). Fair value gains or losses Fair value gains or losses of the group recognised in NIR include the following: ¾ fair value adjustments and interest on financial instruments at FVTPL, including derivative instruments that do not qualify for hedge accounting; ¾ fair value adjustments that are not related to credit risk on advances designated at FVTPL; ¾ a component of interest expense that relates to interest paid on liabilities which fund the group’s fair value operations. Interest expense is reduced by the amount that is included in fair value income; ¾ fair value adjustment on financial instruments designated at FVTPL in order to eliminate an accounting mismatch, except for such instruments relating to the group’s insurance and funding operations, for which the interest component is recognised in net interest income (NII). The change in the fair value of a financial liability designated at FVTPL attributable to changes in its credit risk is presented in OCI, unless this would cause or enlarge an accounting mismatch in profit or loss. The total fair value adjustment on policyholder liabilities and non-recourse liabilities (including movements due to changes in credit risk) is included in profit or loss, since the fair value movements on these liabilities are directly linked to fair value movements on the underlying assets; ¾ ordinary and preference dividends on equity instruments at FVTPL; ¾ any difference between the carrying amount of the liability and the consideration paid, when the group repurchases debt instruments that it has issued; ¾ fair value gains or losses on policyholder liabilities under investment contracts; and ¾ fair value gains or losses on commodities acquired for short-term trading purposes, including commodities acquired with the intention of reselling in the short term, or if they form part of the trading operations of the group and certain commodities subject to option agreements whereby the counterparty may acquire the commodity at a future date where the risks and rewards of ownership are deemed to have transferred to the group in terms of IFRS 15. -- 48 of 354 -- -B49- 3 INCOME, EXPENSES AND TAXATION continued 3.1 Income and expenses continued Non-interest and financial instrument revenue recognised in profit or loss Gains less losses from investing activities The following items are included in gains less losses from investing activities: ¾ any gains or losses on disposals of investments in subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures; ¾ any gains or losses on the sale of financial assets measured at amortised cost; ¾ impairments and reversal of impairments of investment securities measured at amortised cost and debt instruments measured at FVOCI; ¾ any amounts recycled from OCI in respect of debt instruments measured at FVOCI; ¾ dividend income on any equity instruments that are considered long-term investments of the group, including non-trading equity instruments measured at FVOCI; and ¾ fair value gains or losses on investment property held at FVTPL. Dividend income The group recognises dividend income when the group’s right to receive payment is established. This is the last day to trade for listed shares and on the date of declaration for unlisted shares. Dividend income includes scrip dividends, irrespective of whether there is an option to receive cash instead of shares, except to the extent that the scrip dividend is viewed as a bonus issue with no cash alternative and the transaction lacks economic significance. Expenses Expenses of the group, apart from certain fee and commission expenses included in net fee and commission income, are recognised and measured in terms of the accrual principle and presented as operating expenses in profit or loss. Indirect tax expense Indirect tax includes other taxes paid to central and local governments and also includes value-added tax and securities transfer tax. Indirect tax is disclosed separately from income tax and operating expenses in the income statement. 3.2 Income tax expenses Income tax includes South African and foreign corporate tax payable and where applicable, includes capital gains tax, where applicable. Current income tax The current income tax expense is calculated by adjusting the net profit for the year for items that are non- taxable or disallowed. It is calculated using tax rates that have been enacted or substantively enacted at the reporting date, in each particular jurisdiction within which the group operates. Current income tax arising from distributions made on other equity instruments is recognised in the income statement as the distributions are made from retained earnings arising from profits previously recognised in the income statement. -- 49 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B50- 3 INCOME, EXPENSES AND TAXATION continued 3.2 Income tax expenses continued Deferred income tax Recognition On temporary differences arising between the tax base of assets and liabilities and their carrying amounts in the financial statements. Typical temporary differences for which deferred tax is provided ¾ Provision for loan impairment. ¾ Instalment credit assets. ¾ Revaluation (including ECL movements) of certain financial assets and liabilities, including derivative contracts. ¾ Provisions for pensions and other post-retirement benefits. ¾ Share-based payment (SBP) liabilities. ¾ Investments in subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures, except where the timing of the reversal of the temporary difference is controlled by the group and it is probable that the difference will not reverse in the foreseeable future. ¾ Cash flow hedges. Measurement The liability method under IAS 12 is used, which means applying tax rates and laws applicable at the reporting date, which are expected to apply when the related deferred income tax asset is realised or the deferred income tax liability is settled. For temporary differences arising from the fair value adjustments on investment properties and investment securities, deferred income tax is provided at the rate that would apply to the sale of the assets, i.e. the capital gains tax rate. Presentation Deferred income tax is presented in profit or loss unless it relates to items recognised directly in equity or OCI. Items recognised directly in equity or OCI relate to: ¾ the issuance or buy-back of share capital; ¾ fair value remeasurement of financial assets measured at FVOCI; ¾ remeasurements of defined benefit post-employment plans; and ¾ derivatives designated as hedging instruments in effective cash flow hedge relationships. Tax in respect of share transactions is recognised directly in equity. Tax in respect of the other items is recognised directly in OCI and subsequently reclassified to profit or loss (where applicable) at the same time as the related gain or loss. Deferred tax assets The group recognises deferred income tax assets only if it is probable that future taxable income will be available, against which the unused tax losses can be utilised, based on management’s review of the budget and forecast information. The group reviews the carrying amount of deferred income tax assets at each reporting date and reduces the carrying amount to the extent that it is no longer probable that sufficient taxable profits will be available to allow all or part of the assets to be recovered. -- 50 of 354 -- -B51- 3 INCOME, EXPENSES AND TAXATION continued 3.2 Income tax expenses continued Deferred income tax Substantively enacted tax rates Current tax liabilities (assets) for the current and prior periods shall be measured at the amount expected to be paid to (recovered from) the taxation authorities, using the tax rates (and tax laws) that have been enacted or substantively enacted by the end of the reporting period. Deferred tax assets and liabilities shall be measured at the tax rates that are expected to apply to the period when the asset is realised or the liability is settled, based on the rates (and tax laws) that have been enacted or substantively enacted by the end of the reporting period. Current and deferred tax assets and liabilities are usually measured using the tax rates (and tax laws) that have been enacted. However, in some jurisdictions, announcements of tax rates (and tax laws) by the government have the substantive effect of actual enactment, which may follow the announcement by a period of several months. In these circumstances, tax assets and liabilities are measured using the announced tax rate (and tax laws). 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS The group recognises purchases and sale of financial instruments that require delivery within the timeframe established by regulation or market convention (regular way purchases and sales) at settlement date, which is the date the asset is delivered or received. 4.1 Classification and measurement 4.1.1 Initial measurement All financial instruments are initially measured at fair value including transaction costs, except for those classified as FVTPL, in which case the transaction costs are expensed upfront in profit or loss, usually as part of operating expenses. Any upfront income earned on financial instruments is recognised as detailed under accounting policy 3.1, depending on the underlying nature of the income. Immediately after initial recognition, an ECL allowance is recognised for newly originated financial assets measured at amortised cost or FVOCI debt instruments. -- 51 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B52- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.1.2 Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets Management determines the classification of its financial assets at initial recognition, based on: ¾ the group’s business model for managing the financial assets; and ¾ the contractual cash flow characteristics of the financial asset. Business model The group distinguishes three main business models for managing financial assets: ¾ holding financial assets to collect contractual cash flows; ¾ managing financial assets and liabilities on a fair value basis or selling financial assets; and ¾ a mixed business model of collecting contractual cash flows and selling financial assets. The business model assessment is not performed on an instrument-by-instrument basis, but at a level that reflects how groups of financial assets are managed together to achieve a particular business objective. This assessment is done for each legal reporting entity at least at a franchise level, although franchises will perform the assessment on a portfolio or sub-portfolio level, depending on the manner in which groups of financial assets are managed in each franchise. The main consideration in determining the different business models across the group is whether the objectives of the business model are met primarily through holding the financial assets to collect contractual cash flows, through the sale of these financial assets, by managing assets and liabilities on a fair value basis, or through a combination of these activities. In considering whether the business objective of holding a group of financial assets is achieved primarily through collecting contractual cash flows, among other considerations, management monitors the frequency and significance of sales of financial assets out of these portfolios for purposes other than managing credit risk. For the purposes of performing the business model assessment, the group only considers a transaction a sale if the asset is derecognised for accounting purposes. For example, a repurchase transaction where a financial asset is sold with the commitment to buy back the asset at a fixed price at a future date is not considered a sale transaction, because substantially all the risks and rewards relating to the ownership of the asset have not been transferred and the asset is not derecognised from an accounting perspective. Where the group participates in a National Treasury switch and the participation is voluntary, the transaction will be executed at fair value. When there is a business rationale documented as to why the group has elected to participate in the National Treasury switch, this will not be considered a sale transaction for the purposes of the business model assessment. If sales of financial assets are infrequent, the significance of these sales is considered by comparing the carrying amount of assets sold during the period and cumulatively to the total carrying amount of assets held in the business model. If sales are either infrequent or insignificant, these sales will not impact the conclusion that the business model for holding financial assets is to collect contractual cash flows. In addition, where the issuer initiates a repurchase of the financial assets which was not anticipated in the terms of the financial asset, the repurchase is not seen as a sale for the purposes of assessing the business model of that group of financial assets. -- 52 of 354 -- -B53- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.1.2 Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets continued Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets Business model Determining whether sales are significant or frequent requires management to use its judgement. The significance and frequency of sales are assessed on a case-by-case basis at the business model level. The frequency is assessed on an annual basis and sales of assets that take place once or less per annum are considered to be infrequent. If sales take place more than once per annum it doesn’t mean that the business models are not to collect contractual cash flows, but rather that the reasons for the sales need to be more carefully considered. Management will consider both the volume and number of sales relative to the total assets in the business model to determine whether they are significant. A change in business model only occurs on the rare occasion when the group changes the way in which it manages financial assets. Any change in business models would result in a reclassification of the relevant financial assets from the start of the next reporting period. Cash flow characteristics In order for a debt instrument to be measured at amortised cost or FVOCI, the cash flows on the asset have to be solely payments of principal and interest (SPPI), i.e. consistent with those of a basic lending agreement. The SPPI test is applied on a portfolio basis for retail advances, as the cash flow characteristics of these assets are standardised. This includes the consideration of any prepayment penalties that are limited by consumer credit regulation. They can therefore be considered reasonable compensation, which would not cause these assets to fail the SPPI test. For wholesale advances, the SPPI test is applied to individual advances at initial recognition, based on the cash flow characteristics of the asset. Wholesale advances that do not pass the SPPI test and that have to be measured at FVTPL include advances with equity participation features, convertible bonds and payments linked to commodity or other prices. If the contract contains prepayment penalties, the amount of the prepayment penalty is compared to the present value of the margin that will be earned if the loan is not prepaid. If the amount of the prepayment penalty is lower than or equal to the margin lost due to prepayment, this is considered reasonable compensation and the loan passes the SPPI test. Amortised cost Financial assets are measured at amortised cost using the effective interest rate method when they are held to collect contractual cash flows which are SPPI, and sales of such assets are not significant or frequent. These include the majority of the retail, corporate and commercial advances of the group, as well as certain investment securities utilised for liquidity risk management of the group. For purchased or originated credit- impaired financial assets, the group applies the credit-adjusted effective interest rate. This interest rate is determined based on the amortised cost and not the GCA of the financial asset, and incorporates the impact of ECL in the estimated future cash flows of the financial asset. Cash and cash equivalents Cash and cash equivalents comprise coins and bank notes, money at call and short notice, and balances with central banks. All balances included in cash and cash equivalents have a maturity date of less than three months from the date of acquisition. Money at call and short notice constitutes amounts withdrawable in 32 days or less. Cash and cash equivalents are measured at amortised cost. -- 53 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B54- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.1.2 Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets continued Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets Retail advances Retail advances Business model Cash flow characteristics The FNB, WesBank and Aldermore businesses hold retail advances to collect contractual cash flows. Their business models focus on growing these advances within acceptable credit appetite limits and maintaining strong collection practices. The products under this business model include: ¾ residential mortgages; ¾ vehicle and asset finance; ¾ personal loans; ¾ credit cards; and ¾ other retail products such as overdrafts. The cash flows on retail advances are SPPI. Interest charged to customers compensates the group for the time value of money, credit risk and administrative costs (including a profit margin). Penalties on the prepayment of advances are limited to reasonable compensation for early termination of the contract. Corporate and commercial advances Corporate and commercial advances Business model Cash flow characteristics The business models of FNB, WesBank, RMB and Aldermore are also focused on collecting contractual cash flows on corporate and commercial advances and growing these advances within acceptable credit appetite limits. The products under in this business model include: ¾ trade and working capital finance; ¾ specialised finance; ¾ commercial property finance; and ¾ asset-backed finance. These advances are held primarily to realise the related contractual cash flows over the life of the instruments and earn a lending margin in return. Although the intention is to collect cash flows, not all of the instruments are held to maturity as some financial assets are sold through syndication. These sales are, however, either insignificant in value in relation to the value of advances held to collect cash flows or infrequent, and therefore the held to collect business model is still appropriate. The cash flows on corporate and commercial advances are SPPI. Interest charged to customers compensates the group for the time value of money, credit risk and administrative costs (including a profit margin). Penalties on the prepayment of advances are limited to reasonable compensation for early termination of the contract. -- 54 of 354 -- -B55- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.1.2 Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets continued Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets Corporate and commercial advances Within RMB, debt for large corporates and institutions is structured. These advances are held primarily to realise the related contractual cash flows over the life of the instruments and earn a lending margin in return. Although the intention is to collect cash flows, not all of the instruments are held to maturity as some financial assets are sold in the secondary market to facilitate funding. These sales are, however, insignificant in value in relation to the value of RMB advances held to collect cash flows and therefore the held to collect business model is still appropriate. In other portfolios, RMB originates advances with the intention to distribute. These advances are included under a different business model and are measured at FVTPL (as set out further below). The cash flows on these advances are considered to be SPPI if the loan contract does not contain equity upside features, conversion options, payments linked to equity or commodity prices or prepayment penalties that exceed reasonable compensation for early termination of the contract. Any advances that do contain such features are mandatorily measured at FVTPL. Marketable advances Advances also include marketable advances representing corporate bonds and certain debt investment securities qualifying as high-quality liquid assets (HQLA) that are under the control of the group treasurer, held by RMB. These assets are primarily held to collect the contractual cash flows over the life of the asset. The cash flows on these advances are SPPI. Investment securities Investment securities Group Treasury holds investment securities with lower credit risk (typically government bonds and treasury bills). These investment securities are held in a business model with the objective of collecting contractual cash flows. The cash flows on these investment securities are SPPI. Cash and cash equivalents Cash and cash equivalents Cash and cash equivalents are short-term, highly liquid investments that are readily convertible to known amounts of cash. These assets are held to collect contractual cash flows. The cash flows on these assets are SPPI. Other assets Other assets Other assets are short-term financial assets that are held to collect contractual cash flows. The cash flows on these assets are SPPI. -- 55 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B56- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.1.2 Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets continued Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets Mandatory at FVTPL Corporate advances In certain instances, RMB originates advances with the mandate of distributing an identified portion of the total advances in the secondary market within an approved timeframe. The reason for originating these advances is not to collect the contractual cash flows, but rather to realise the cash flows through the sale of the assets. Any advances which are originated to be distributed or managed on a fair value basis, or are held to collect contractual cash flows but include cash flows related to equity upside features, conversion options, payments linked to equity or commodity prices, or prepayment penalties that exceed reasonable compensation for early termination of the contract, will be included in this category. Marketable advances RMB occasionally invests in notes issued by special purpose vehicles (SPVs), with the intention of selling these notes to external parties. These include notes issued by an SPV to which it sells a portion of corporate and commercial advances that it originates to distribute (detailed above). The collection of contractual cash flows on these notes is merely incidental. Advances which are acquired to distribute are included in this category. Investment securities RMB Global Markets holds portfolios of investment securities (including corporate and government bonds) to hedge risks or for short-term profit realisation. These securities are managed on a fair value basis. All equity investments of the group are managed on a fair value basis, either through FVTPL or designated at FVOCI. Derivative assets Derivatives are either held for trading or to hedge risk. These instruments are managed on a fair value basis. Designated at FVTPL Advances Certain advances with fixed interest rates in RMB have been designated at FVTPL in order to eliminate an accounting mismatch that would otherwise result from measuring these assets on a different basis. The cash flows on these advances are considered to be SPPI. Investment securities Group Treasury holds investment securities (typically treasury bills) for liquidity purposes. -- 56 of 354 -- -B57- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.1.2 Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets continued Classification and subsequent measurement of financial assets Debt instruments at FVOCI Investment securities The treasury division of the group holds certain investment securities for liquidity management purposes. Local regulators require that the bank/branch prove liquidity of its assets by way of periodic outright sales. Therefore, the business model for these investment securities is both collecting contractual cash flows and selling these financial assets. The cash flows on these investment securities are SPPI. Equity investments at FVOCI Investment securities The group has elected to designate certain equity investments not held for trading to be measured at FVOCI. 4.1.3 Classification and subsequent measurement of financial liabilities and compound instruments Financial liabilities and compound financial instruments The group classifies a financial instrument that it issues as a financial liability or an equity instrument in accordance with the substance of the contractual agreement. Tier 2 instruments which have write-down or conversion features are classified based on the nature of the instrument and the definitions. Tier 2 and other funding liabilities are presented in separate lines on the statement of financial position of the group. Compound instruments are those financial instruments that have components of both financial liabilities and equity, such as issued convertible bonds. At initial recognition the instrument and the related transaction costs are split into their separate components and accounted for as a financial liability or equity in terms of the definitions and criteria of IAS 32. Financial liabilities measured at amortised cost The following liabilities are measured at amortised cost using the effective interest rate method, unless they have been designated as measured at FVTPL: ¾ deposits; ¾ creditors; ¾ Tier 2 liabilities; and ¾ other funding liabilities. Financial liabilities measured mandatory at FVTPL The following held for trading liabilities are measured at FVTPL: ¾ derivative liabilities; and ¾ short trading positions. These liabilities are measured at fair value at reporting date as determined under IFRS 13, with fair value gains or losses recognised in profit or loss. -- 57 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B58- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.1.3 Classification and subsequent measurement of financial liabilities and compound instruments continued Financial liabilities designated at FVTPL A financial liability other than one held for trading or contingent consideration that may be paid by an acquirer as part of a business combination may be designated at FVTPL upon initial recognition if: ¾ such designation eliminates or significantly reduces a measurement or recognition inconsistency that would otherwise arise; or ¾ the financial liability forms part of a group of financial liabilities which is managed and its performance evaluated on a fair value basis, in accordance with the group’s documented risk management or investment strategy, and information about the grouping is provided internally on that basis; or ¾ it forms part of a contract containing one or more embedded derivatives, and IFRS 9 permits the entire hybrid (combined) contract to be designated at FVTPL. The financial liabilities that the group designated at FVTPL are the following: ¾ deposits; and ¾ other funding liabilities. Both types of liabilities satisfied the above-mentioned conditions of IFRS 9 for such designation. These financial liabilities are measured at fair value at reporting date as determined under IFRS 13, with any gains or losses arising on remeasurement recognised in profit or loss to the extent that they are not part of a designated hedge accounting relationship. However, for non-derivative financial liabilities that are designated at FVTPL, the amount of change in the fair value of the financial liability that is attributable to changes in the credit risk of that liability is recognised in OCI, unless the recognition of the effects of changes in the liability’s credit risk in OCI would create or enlarge an accounting mismatch in profit or loss. The remaining amount of change in the fair value of liability is recognised in profit or loss. Changes in fair value attributable to a financial liability’s credit risk that are recognised in OCI are not subsequently reclassified to profit or loss. Instead, they are transferred to retained earnings upon derecognition of the financial liability. 4.2 Impairment of financial assets and off-balance sheet exposures subject to impairment This policy applies to: ¾ financial assets measured at amortised cost, including other financial assets and cash; ¾ debt instruments measured at FVOCI; ¾ loan commitments; ¾ financial guarantees; and ¾ finance lease debtors where the group is the lessor. Refer to accounting policy note 9.4 where all risk parameters, scenarios and sources of estimation are detailed more extensively. -- 58 of 354 -- -B59- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.2 Impairment of financial assets and off-balance sheet exposures subject to impairment continued Expected credit losses Loss allowance on financial assets Credit risk has not increased significantly since initial recognition (Stage 1) Credit risk has increased significantly since initial recognition, but asset is not credit-impaired (Stage 2) Asset has become credit-impaired since initial recognition (Stage 3) Purchased or originated credit- impaired 12-month ECL Lifetime expected credit losses (LECL) LECL Movement in LECL since initial recognition Advances SICR since initial recognition In order to determine whether an advance has experienced a SICR, the PD of the asset calculated at the origination date is compared to that calculated at the reporting date (incorporating forward-looking information (FLI)). The origination date is defined as the most recent date at which the group has repriced an advance/facility. Where a change in terms is significant and is deemed to be a substantial modification, it results in derecognition of the original advance/facility and recognition of a new advance/facility. SICR test thresholds are reassessed and, if necessary, updated, on at least an annual basis. Any facility that is more than 30 days past due, or in the case of instalment-based products one instalment past due, is automatically considered to have experienced a SICR. In addition to the quantitative assessment based on PDs, qualitative considerations are applied when determining whether individual exposures have experienced a SICR. One such qualitative consideration is the appearance of wholesale and commercial small and medium-sized enterprise (SME) facilities on a credit watch list. Any up-to-date facility that has undergone a distressed restructure (i.e. a modification of contractual cash flows to prevent a client from going into arrears) will be considered to have experienced a SICR, and will be disclosed within stage 2 at a minimum. The credit risk on an exposure is no longer considered to be significantly higher than at origination if no qualitative indicators of a SICR are triggered, and if comparison of the reporting date PD to the origination date PD no longer indicates that a SICR has occurred. No standard minimum period for transition from stage 2 back to stage 1 is applied across all advances, with the exception of cured distressed restructured exposures that are required to remain in stage 2 for a minimum period of six months before re-entering stage 1, as per the requirements of SARB Directive 7 of 2015. -- 59 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B60- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.2 Impairment of financial assets and off-balance sheet exposures subject to impairment continued Advances Credit- impaired financial assets Advances are considered credit-impaired if they meet the definition of default. The group’s definition of default applied to calculating provisions under IFRS 9 has been aligned to the definition applied to regulatory capital calculations across all portfolios, as well as those applied in operational management of credit and for internal risk management purposes. Exposures are considered to be in default when they are more than 90 days past due or, in the case of amortising products, are more than three instalments in arrears. In addition, an exposure is considered to have defaulted when there are qualitative indicators that the borrower is unlikely to pay their credit obligations in full without any recourse by the group to actions such as the realisation of security. Indicators of unlikeliness to pay are determined based on the requirements of Regulation 67 of the Banks Act. Examples include application for bankruptcy or obligor insolvency. Any distressed restructures of accounts which have experienced a SICR since initial recognition are defined as default events. Retail accounts are considered to no longer be in default if they meet the stringent cure definition, which has been determined at portfolio level based on analysis of re-defaulted rates. Curing from default within wholesale is determined judgementally through a committee process. Purchased or originated credit-impaired Financial assets that meet the above-mentioned definition of credit-impaired at initial recognition and remain classified as such for the duration of the agreement. Write-offs Write-off must occur when it is not economical to pursue further recoveries, i.e. there is no reasonable expectation of recovering the carrying amount of the asset (gross amount less specific impairments raised): ¾ By implication, in both retail and wholesale, for secured as well as unsecured exposures, write-offs cannot occur if there is evidence of recent payment behaviour. Each credit portfolio has articulated a write-off policy that aligns with the principles of IFRS 9 while taking the business context of that portfolio into account. ¾ Within retail portfolios, write-off definitions have been determined with reference to analysis of the materiality of post write-off recoveries. The result of this is that retail secured loans are written off on perfection of collateral, and retail unsecured loans are written off when observation of post-default payment behaviour indicates that further material recoveries are unlikely. Write-off points within retail unsecured portfolios are defined on a per-portfolio basis with reference to cumulative delinquency and/or payment recency. ¾ Within wholesale portfolios, a judgemental approach to write-off is followed, based on case-by-case assessment by a credit committee. ¾ Partial write-offs are not performed within credit portfolios, except in limited circumstances within the wholesale portfolio, where they are assessed on a case-by-case basis. Where required, additional provisions against irrecoverable assets will be raised until such a time as final write-off can occur. -- 60 of 354 -- -B61- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.2 Impairment of financial assets and off-balance sheet exposures subject to impairment continued Advances Collection and enforcement activities post write-off For unsecured advances, post write-off collection strategies include outsourcing of the account to external debt collections (EDCs). In addition, settlement campaigns are run to encourage clients to settle their outstanding debt. For secured advances, any residual balance post the realisation of collateral and post write-off is outsourced to EDCs. Other financial assets Cash and cash equivalents All physical cash is classified as stage 1. Other exposures are classified as stage 1 unless specific evidence of impairment exists, in which case, due to the nature of these assets, they are classified immediately as stage 3. ECL for physical cash is zero. ECL for cash equivalents is calculated using the loss rate approach. Other assets ECL for other assets, i.e. financial accounts receivable and where applicable, contract assets, are calculated using the simplified approach. This results in a LECL being recognised. Investment securities Impairment parameters for investment securities (PD, LGD and EAD) are determined using appropriate models, with the models to be applied determined with reference to the issuer of the security and the nature of the debt instrument. The tests for a SICR and default definitions are then applied and the ECL calculated in the same way as for advances. The SICR thresholds applied for investment securities are the same as those applied within the wholesale credit portfolio, to ensure consistency in the way that a SICR is identified for a particular counterparty and for similar exposures. The group does not use the low credit risk exemption for investment securities, including government bonds. 4.3 Transfers, modifications and derecognition Financial instruments are derecognised when: ¾ the contractual rights or obligations expire or are extinguished, discharged or cancelled, for example an outright sale or settlement; ¾ they are transferred and the derecognition criteria of IFRS 9 are met; or ¾ the contractual terms of the instrument are substantially modified and the derecognition criteria of IFRS 9 are met. Financial assets are derecognised when the group has either transferred the contractual right to receive cash flows from the asset or it has assumed an obligation to pay over all the cash flows from the asset to another entity (i.e. pass-through arrangement). If the contractual cash flows of a financial asset measured at amortised cost are modified (changed or restructured, including distressed restructures), the group determines whether this is a substantial modification, which could result in the derecognition of the existing asset and the recognition of a new asset. If the change is simply a non-substantial modification of the existing terms it would not result in derecognition. -- 61 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B62- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.3 Transfers, modifications and derecognition continued A modification of a financial asset is substantial and will thus result in derecognition of the original financial asset where the modified contractual terms are priced to reflect current conditions on the date of modification and are not merely an attempt to recover outstanding amounts. Where the modification does not result in an accounting derecognition the original asset continues to be recognised. Derecognition of financial liabilities includes a situation of substantial modification of the terms and conditions of an existing financial liability. A substantial modification of the terms occurs where the discounted present value of the cash flows under the new terms, including fees paid net of fees received and discounted using the original effective interest rate, differs by at least 10% from the discounted present value of the remaining cash flows of the original financial liability. The following transactions are entered into by the group in the normal course of business, in terms of which it transfers financial assets directly to third parties or structured entities, or modifies the contractual terms of the asset and either achieves derecognition or continues to recognise the asset: Transaction type Description Accounting treatment Transfers without derecognition Traditional securitisations and other structured transactions Specific advances or investment securities are transferred to a structured entity, which then issues liabilities to third-party investors, for example variable rate notes or investment grade commercial paper. The group's obligations towards the third-party note holders is limited to the cash flows received on the underlying securitised advances or non- recourse investment securities, i.e. the note holders only have a claim to the ring-fenced assets in the structured entity, and not to other assets of the group. The group consolidates these securitisations and SPVs as structured entities in terms of IFRS 10. The transferred assets continue to be recognised by the group in full. Such advances and investment securities are disclosed separately in the relevant notes. The group recognises an associated liability for the obligation towards third-party note holders as a separate category of deposits. These deposits are usually measured at amortised cost. Reverse repurchase agreements Investment securities and advances are sold to an external counterparty in exchange for cash and the group agrees to repurchase the assets at a specified price at a specific future date. The counterpartyʼs only recourse is to the transferred investment securities and advances that are subject to the agreement. The group remains exposed to all the underlying risks on the assets including counterparty, interest rate, currency, prepayment and other price risks. The transferred assets continue to be recognised by the group in full. Such advances and investment securities are disclosed separately in the relevant notes. The group recognises an associated liability for the obligation for the cash received as a separate category of deposits. -- 62 of 354 -- -B63- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.3 Transfers, modifications and derecognition continued Transaction type Description Accounting treatment Securities lending Investment securities are lent to external counterparties in exchange for cash collateral as security for the return of the securities. The groupʼs only recourse in respect of the return of the securities it has lent is to the cash collateral held and as such, the group generally requires cash collateral in excess of the fair value of the securities lent. Transfers with derecognition Where the group purchases its own debt The debt is derecognised from the statement of financial position and any difference between the carrying amount of the liability and the consideration paid is included in fair value gains or losses within NIR. Modification without derecognition Modification of contractual cash flows Debt restructuring is a process that is applied to accounts whereby the new terms of the contract (such as a lower interest rate) are mandated by law and do not have the same commercial terms as a new product that the group would be willing to offer a customer with a similar risk profile. The existing asset is not derecognised. The GCA of the financial asset is recalculated as the present value of the estimated future cash receipts through the expected life of the renegotiated or modified financial asset, discounted at the financial asset’s original effective interest rate. Distressed modifications are included in ECL. Modifications with derecognition (i.e. substantial modifications) Retail advances The process for modifying an advance (which is not part of a debt restructuring) is substantially the same as the process for raising a new advance, including reassessing the customer’s credit risk, repricing the asset and entering into a new legal agreement. The existing asset is derecognised and a new asset is recognised at fair value based on the modified contractual terms. Neither transferred nor derecognised Synthetic securitisation transactions Credit risk related to specific advances is transferred to a structured entity through credit derivatives. The group consolidates these securitisation vehicles as structured entities, in terms of IFRS 10. The group continues to recognise the advances and recognises associated credit derivatives which are measured at FVTPL. -- 63 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B64- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.4 Offsetting of financial instruments and collateral Where the requirements of IFRS are met, the group offsets financial assets and financial liabilities and presents the net amount. Financial assets and financial liabilities subject to master netting arrangements (MNAs) or similar agreements are not offset, if the right of set-off under these agreements is only enforceable in the event of default, insolvency and bankruptcy. Details of the offsetting and collateral arrangements of the group are set out in the following table. Derivative financial instruments The groupʼs derivative transactions that are not transacted on an exchange are entered into under International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) MNAs. Generally, under such agreements the amounts owed by each counterparty that are due on a single day in respect of all transactions outstanding in the same currency under the agreement are aggregated into a single net amount payable by one party to the other. In certain circumstances, e.g. when a credit event such as default occurs, all outstanding transactions under the agreement are terminated, the termination value is assessed and only a single net amount is due or payable in settlement of all transactions (close-out netting). Financial collateral (mostly cash) is also obtained, often daily, for the net exposure between counterparties to mitigate credit risk. Repurchase and reverse repurchase agreements, and securities lending and borrowing transactions These transactions by the group are covered by master agreements with netting terms similar to those of the ISDA MNAs. Where the group has entered into a repurchase and reverse repurchase or securities borrowing and lending transaction, with the same counterparty, the advance and liability balances are offset in the statement of financial position only if they are due on a single day, denominated in the same currency and the group has the intention to settle these amounts on a net basis. The group receives and accepts collateral for these transactions in the form of cash and other investment securities. Other advances and deposits The advances and deposits that are offset relate to transactions where the group has a legally enforceable right to offset the amounts and the group has the intention to settle the net amount. It is the groupʼs policy that all items of collateral are valued at the inception of a transaction and at various points throughout the life of a transaction, either through physical inspection or indexation methods, as appropriate. For wholesale and commercial portfolios, the value of collateral is reviewed as part of the annual facility review. For mortgage portfolios, collateral valuations are updated on an ongoing basis through statistical indexation models. However, in the event of default, more detailed reviews and valuations of collateral are performed, which yield a more accurate financial effect. For asset finance, the total security reflected represents only the realisation value estimates of the vehicles repossessed at the date of repossession. Where the repossession has not yet occurred, the realisation value of the vehicle is estimated using internal models and is included as part of total recoveries. -- 64 of 354 -- -B65- 4 FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued 4.5 Derivative financial instruments and hedge accounting Derivatives are financial instruments that derive their value from the price of underlying items such as equities, interest rates or other indices. Derivatives are recognised initially and are subsequently measured at FVTPL with movements in fair value recognised in fair value gains or losses within NIR in the consolidated income statement. Derivatives are classified as assets when their fair value is positive or as liabilities when their fair value is negative. Derivative instruments are classified either as held for trading or formally designated as hedging instruments. The group elected to adopt IFRS 9 for cash flow and fair value hedges. IAS 39 will continue to be applied to portfolio hedges, which the group refers to as macro hedges, to which fair value hedge accounting has been applied. Hedge accounting Derivatives held for risk management purposes are classified either as fair value hedges or cash flow hedges depending on the nature of the risk being hedged, where the hedges meet the required documentation criteria under IFRS 9/IAS 39 and are calculated to be effective. The group extensively hedges with interest rate swaps, which will be impacted by the Financial Stability Board’s undertaking to fundamentally review and reform major interest rate benchmarks used globally and locally by financial market participants. This review seeks to replace existing global and local interbank offered rates (IBORs) with alternative reference rates (ARRs) to improve market efficiency and mitigate systemic risk across financial markets. The group is monitoring and evaluating developments in the market and the impact thereof on accounting. Fair value hedge accounting Fair value hedge accounting does not change the recording of gains or losses on derivatives, but it does result in recognising changes in the fair value of the hedged item attributable to the hedged risk that would otherwise not be recognised in the income statement. The change in the fair value of the hedged item is taken to non- interest revenue under fair value gains or losses. If a hedge relationship no longer meets the criteria for hedge accounting, hedge accounting is discontinued. The cumulative adjustment to the carrying amount of the hedged item is amortised to the income statement based on a recalculated effective interest rate, unless the hedged item has been derecognised, in which case it is recognised in the income statement immediately. Cash flow hedge accounting For derivatives used in cash flow hedges, the effective portion of changes in the fair value of the hedging derivatives is recognised in the cash flow hedge reserve in OCI, and reclassified to profit or loss in the periods in which the hedged item affects profit or loss. The ineffective portion is recognised immediately in profit or loss as part of fair value gains or losses within NIR. The accumulated gains and losses recognised in OCI are reclassified to the income statement in the same periods in which the hedged item affects profit or loss. When a hedge relationship is discontinued, or partially discontinued, any cumulative gain or loss recognised in OCI remains in equity until the hedged item affects the income statement. -- 65 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B66- 5 OTHER ASSETS AND LIABILITIES 5.1 Classification and measurement Classification Measurement Property and equipment (owned and right of use) Property and equipment of the group include: ¾ assets utilised by the group in the normal course of operations to provide services, including freehold property and leasehold premises and leasehold improvements (owner-occupied properties); ¾ assets which are owned by the group and leased to third parties under operating leases as part of the groupʼs revenue-generating operations; ¾ capitalised leased assets; and ¾ other assets utilised by the group in the normal course of operations, including computer and office equipment, motor vehicles and furniture and fittings. Historical cost less accumulated depreciation and impairment losses, except for land, which is not depreciated. Depreciation is recognised on the straight-line basis over the useful life of the asset, except for assets capitalised under leases where the group is the lessee, in which case it is depreciated per the leases accounting policy 5.3. Freehold property and property held under leasing agreements: ‒ Buildings and structures ‒ Mechanical and electrical ‒ Components ‒ Sundries ‒ Computer equipment ‒ Other equipment 40 ‒ 50 years 14 ‒ 20 years 14 ‒ 20 years 3 – 5 years 3 – 5 years 3 – 10 years Investment properties Investment properties are those held to earn rental income and/or for capital appreciation that are not occupied by the companies in the group. When investment properties become owner- occupied, the group reclassifies them to property and equipment, using the fair value at the date of reclassification as the cost. The fair value gains or losses are adjusted for any potential double counting arising from the recognition of lease income on the straight-line basis, compared to the accrual basis normally assumed in the fair value determination. -- 66 of 354 -- -B67- 5 OTHER ASSETS AND LIABILITIES continued 5.1 Classification and measurement continued Classification Measurement Intangible assets Intangible assets of the group include: ¾ Internally generated intangible assets (including computer software and other assets such as trademarks or patents) are capitalised when the requirements of IAS 38 relating to the recognition of internally generated assets have been met. ¾ External computer software development costs are capitalised when they can be clearly associated with a strategic and unique system which will result in a benefit to the group exceeding the costs incurred for more than one financial period. ¾ Material acquired trademarks, patents and similar rights are capitalised when the group will receive a benefit from these intangible assets for more than one financial period. All other costs related to intangible assets are expensed in the financial period incurred. Cost less accumulated amortisation and any impairment losses. Amortisation is on a straight-line basis over the useful life of the asset. The useful life of each asset is assessed individually. The benchmarks used when assessing the useful life of the individual assets are: ‒ Software development costs 3 years ‒ Trademarks 10 – 20 years ‒ Other 3 – 10 years Goodwill arising from business combinations is recognised as an intangible asset. Refer to accounting policy 2.1. Commodities Commodities acquired for short-term trading purposes include the following: ¾ commodities acquired with the intention to resell in the short term or if they form part of the trading operations of the group; and ¾ certain commodities subject to option agreements whereby the counterparty may acquire the commodity at a future date where the risks and rewards of ownership are deemed to have transferred to the group in terms of IFRS 15. Fair value less costs to sell with changes in fair value being recognised as fair value gains or losses within NIR. Forward contracts to purchase or sell commodities where net settlement occurs, or where physical delivery occurs and the commodities are held to settle a further derivative contract, are recognised as derivative instruments. FVTPL. -- 67 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B68- 5 OTHER ASSETS AND LIABILITIES continued 5.1 Classification and measurement continued Classification Measurement Provisions The group will only recognise a provision measured in terms of IAS 37 when there is uncertainty around the amount or timing of payment. Where there is no uncertainty the group will recognise the amount as an accrual. The most significant provisions are related to litigation and claims, as well as provisions for intellectual property fees that arise because of the use of dealer platforms, databases, systems, brands and trademarks when marketing and promoting motor warranty products as part of the motor value-added products and services (VAPS) business. The group recognises a provision when a reliable estimate of the outflow required can be made and the outflow is probable (i.e. more likely than not). Other assets that are subject to depreciation, and intangible assets other than goodwill acquired as part of a business combination (refer to accounting policy 2.1), are reviewed for impairment whenever objective evidence of impairment exists. Impairment losses are recognised in profit or loss as part of operating expenses. Other assets are derecognised when they are disposed of or, in the case of intangible assets, when no future economic benefits are expected from their use. Gains or losses arising on derecognition are determined as the difference between the carrying amount of the asset and the net proceeds received, and are recorded in profit or loss as part of NIR. 5.2 Non-current assets and disposal groups held for sale If a disposal group contains assets that are outside of the measurement scope of IFRS 5, those assets are remeasured in terms of the relevant IFRS standards and any impairment loss on the disposal group is allocated only to those non-current assets in the disposal group that are within the measurement scope of IFRS 5, until the assets are reduced to zero. The group has elected to recognise any excess impairment on the disposal group that remains after impairing the assets within the measurement scope of IFRS 5 as excess impairment within operating expenses with a corresponding adjustment to the assets whose measurement is outside of the scope of IFRS 5, until those assets are reduced to zero. Any subsequent increases in fair value less costs to sell are recognised in NIR when realised. 5.3 Leases The group leases a variety of properties and equipment. Rental agreements typically include fixed periods over which the item is leased, which are individually negotiated and contain a wide range of different terms and conditions. The group assesses whether a contract is or contains a lease at inception of the contract. Qualifying leases are recognised as a right of use asset (ROUA) and a corresponding liability at the date at which the leased asset is made available for use by the group. -- 68 of 354 -- -B69- 5 OTHER ASSETS AND LIABILITIES continued 5.3 Leases continued Group company is the lessee Group company is the lessor At inception The group recognises a ROUA and a corresponding lease liability with respect to all lease agreements in which it is the lessee, except for short-term leases (defined as leases with a lease term of 12 months or less) and leases of low-value assets (defined as lease assets with a replacement value of R100 000 or less at the inception of the lease). The group recognises assets sold under a finance lease as finance lease receivables included in advances and impair the advances, as required, in line with the impairment of financial assets accounting policy in section 4.2. No practical expedients are applied, and the general model under IFRS 9 is used for impairment calculations on lease receivables. Over the life of the lease Each lease payment is allocated between the lease liability and interest expense. The interest expense is charged to the income statement over the lease period so as to produce a constant periodic rate of interest on the remaining balance of the liability for each period. The ROUA is subsequently measured at cost less accumulated depreciation and impairment losses. The asset is depreciated over the lease term on a straight-line basis, where ownership is not transferred at the end of the lease term. If ownership is transferred at the end of the lease term, the asset is depreciated over the shorter of the lease term or useful life. The group applies IAS 36 to determine whether a ROUA is impaired and accounts for any identified impairment loss. Unearned finance income is recognised as interest income over the term of the lease using the effective interest rate method. Finance lease receivables are assessed for impairment in terms of IFRS 9, as set out in the impairment of financial assets policy section 4.2. Interest on finance lease receivables that are credit-impaired (stage 3) is recognised and calculated by applying the original effective interest rate to the net carrying amount. Presentation The lease liability is presented in other liabilities in the consolidated statement of financial position. The ROUAs are not presented as a separate line in the consolidated statement of financial position, but rather disclosed as ROUA in the property and equipment note. Finance lease receivables are presented as part of advances in the consolidated statement of financial position. -- 69 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B70- 5 OTHER ASSETS AND LIABILITIES continued 5.3 Leases continued Group company is the lessee Group company is the lessor Operating leases For short-term and low-value leases, which the group has defined as all other leases except for property and vehicle leases, the lease payments are recognised as an operating expense, spread on a straight-line basis over the term of the lease. Assets held under operating leases are included in property and equipment and depreciated – refer to accounting policy 5.1. Rental income is recognised as other NIR on a straight-line basis over the lease term. Finance lease agreements (including hire purchases) where the group is the lessor The group regards finance lease agreements (including hire purchases) as financing transactions and includes the total rentals and instalments receivable, less unearned finance charges, in advances. The group calculates finance charges using the effective interest rates as detailed in the contracts and credit finance charges to interest revenue in proportion to capital balances outstanding. 6 CAPITAL AND RESERVES Transaction Liability Equity Shares issued and issue costs Preference shares, where the group does not have the unilateral ability to avoid repayments, are classified as other liabilities. The group’s equity includes ordinary shares, contingently convertible securities, Additional Tier 1 notes and non- cumulative non-redeemable (NCNR) preference shares. Contingently convertible securities, Additional Tier 1 notes and NCNR preference shares are classified as other equity instruments in the financial statements. Any incremental costs directly related to the issue of new shares or options, net of any related tax benefit, are deducted from the issue price. Dividends paid/declared Recognised as interest expense on the underlying liability. Dividends on equity instruments are recognised against equity. A corresponding liability is recognised when the dividends have been approved by the company’s shareholders and distribution is no longer at the discretion of the entity. Distribution of non-cash assets to owners The liability to distribute non- cash assets is recognised as a dividend to owners at the fair value of the asset to be distributed. The carrying amount of the dividend payable is remeasured at the end of each reporting period and on settlement date. The initial carrying amount and any subsequent changes are recognised in equity. -- 70 of 354 -- -B71- 6 CAPITAL AND RESERVES continued Transaction Liability Equity The difference between the carrying amount of the assets distributed and the fair value of the assets on the date of distribution is recognised as NIR in profit or loss for the period. Treasury shares, i.e. where the group purchases its own equity share capital If the group reacquires its own equity instruments, those instruments are deducted from the group’s equity. The consideration paid, including any directly attributable incremental costs, is deducted from total shareholders’ equity as treasury shares until they are reissued or sold. Where the shares are subsequently sold or reissued, any consideration received net of any directly attributable incremental costs is included in shareholders’ equity. Other reserves Not applicable Other reserves recognised by the group include general risk reserves, required to be held by some of the group’s African operations capital redemption reserve funds and insurance contingency reserves. These reserves are required by in-country legislation governing these subsidiaries and are calculated based on the requirements outlined in the relevant legislation applicable in the specific jurisdiction. 7 TRANSACTIONS WITH EMPLOYEES 7.1 Employee benefits The group operates defined benefit and defined contribution schemes, the assets of which are held in separate trustee administered funds. These funds are registered in terms of the Pension Funds Act, 1956, and membership of the pension fund is compulsory for all group employees. The defined benefit plans are funded by contributions from employees and the relevant group companies, taking into account the recommendations of independent qualified actuaries. Defined contribution plans Determination of purchased pension on retirement from defined contribution plan Recognition Contributions are recognised as an expense, included in staff costs, when the employees have rendered the service entitling them to the contributions. Prepaid contributions are recognised as an asset to the extent that a cash refund or a reduction in future payments is available. -- 71 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B72- 7 TRANSACTIONS WITH EMPLOYEES continued 7.1 Employee benefits continued Defined contribution plans Measurement On the date of the purchase, the defined benefit liability and the plan assets will increase for the purchase amount and thereafter the accounting treatment applicable to defined benefit plans will be applied to the purchased pension. It should be noted that the purchase price for the new retiree would be slightly higher than the liability determined on the accounting valuation, as the purchase price allows for a more conservative mortality assumption based on the solvency reserves of the fund. Defined benefit plans Defined benefit obligation liability Recognition The liabilities and assets of these funds are reflected as a net asset or liability in the statement of financial position, i.e. the present value of the defined benefit obligation at the reporting date less the fair value of plan assets. Where the value is a net asset, the amount recognised is limited to the present value of any economic benefits available in the form of refunds from the plan or reductions in future contributions to the plan. Measurement The present value of the defined benefit obligation is calculated annually by independent actuaries using the projected credit unit method. The discount rate used is the rate of nominal and inflation-linked government-issued bonds that are denominated in the currency in which the benefits will be paid and have terms to maturity approximating the terms of the related pension liability. Liability for short-term employee benefits Leave pay The group recognises a liability for employees’ rights to annual leave in respect of past service. The amount recognised by the group is based on the current salary of employees and the contractual terms between employees and the group. The expense is included in staff costs. Bonuses The group recognises a liability and an expense for management and staff bonuses when it is probable that the economic benefits will be paid, and the amount can be reliably measured. The expense is included in staff costs. -- 72 of 354 -- -B73- 7 TRANSACTIONS WITH EMPLOYEES continued 7.2 Share-based payment transactions The group operates a cash-settled and an immaterial equity-settled share-based incentive plan for employees. Awards granted under cash-settled plans result in a liability being recognised and measured at fair value until settlement. An expense is recognised in profit or loss for employee services received over the vesting period of the plans. Awards granted under equity-settled plans result in an expense to be recognised in profit or loss at the fair value of the employee services received in exchange for the grant of the awards over the vesting period of the awards. A corresponding credit to a SBP reserve in the statement of changes in equity is when the expense is recognised. 8 NON-BANKING ACTIVITIES 8.1 Insurance activities Insurance activities include contracts issued by the group, which transfer significant insurance risk or financial risk. Furthermore, the group has entered into reinsurance contracts. Insurance contracts are contracts under which the group, as the insurer, accepts significant insurance risk from the policyholder by agreeing to compensate the policyholder if a specified uncertain future event (the insured event) adversely affects the policyholder. The group defines significant insurance risk as the possibility of having to pay benefits on the occurrence of an insured event that are significantly more (at least 10%) than the benefits payable if the insured event did not occur. The group issues insurance contracts in terms of the Insurance Act 18 of 2017 (Insurance Act) as well as the Short-term Insurance Act 18 of 2017 (Short-term Act). Investment contracts which are linked-fund policies falling within the scope of the Insurance Act are viewed as a form of long-term insurance from a legal perspective. However, as investment contracts do not convey insurance risk upon the company, they are scoped out of IFRS 4 and are accounted for in terms of IFRS 9. Investment contracts are classified as financial liabilities, measured at FVTPL. The group obtains reinsurance in the ordinary course of business for the purpose of limiting its net loss potential through the diversification of its risks on certain long-term and short-term insurance contracts. Reinsurance arrangements do not relieve the group from its direct obligations to policyholders. Insurance contracts Premiums Premiums on insurance contracts are recognised when due. Premiums are recognised gross of commission payable to intermediaries and reinsurance premiums as well as net of eBucks before the deduction of acquisition costs. -- 73 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B74- 8 NON-BANKING ACTIVITIES continued 8.1 Insurance activities continued Short-term insurance contracts Long-term insurance contracts Claims and benefits paid Claims and benefits paid consist of claims and claims handling expenses paid during the financial year and are determined by the market value of the indemnification received by the policyholder. Salvages and third-party recoveries are also included here. The salvage amount is the amount received by the company from the sale of the policyholder’s property which is damaged beyond economic repair. The insurer will purchase new property for the policyholder, while the damaged property will be sold by the insurance company. The income received from the sale of the damaged property will be netted off against the claims paid, which represents the cost of the new property. Recoveries represent the insurer’s recovery for its insured damage from either the insurer of the other party to the loss event, or a third-party which is the insured individual who was involved in the loss event. Claims and benefits paid are recognised when the amounts are paid over to the customers and are determined with reference to the contract entered into with the policyholder. Policyholder liability In terms of IFRS 4, insurance contracts may be measured under existing local practice. The provision for the outstanding claims reserve (OCR) comprises the group’s estimate of settling all claims reported (notified claims) but remains unpaid at year end, and claims incurred but not reported (IBNR). In terms of IFRS 4, measurement of policyholder liabilities arising from insurance contracts are measured using existing local practices. The group utilises the Standards of Actuarial Practice (SAPs) 104 issued by the Actuarial Society of South Africa (ASSA) to determine the policyholder liabilities that are classified as long-term insurance contracts. -- 74 of 354 -- -B75- 8 NON-BANKING ACTIVITIES continued 8.1 Insurance activities continued Short-term insurance contracts Long-term insurance contracts For OCR, each notified claim relating to one of the group’s policies is assessed on a case-by- case basis with due regard to the specific circumstances, information available from the insured and/or loss adjuster and past experience with similar claims. Standardised policies and procedures are applied to claims assessments. The provision for each notified claim includes an estimate of the associated claim handling costs. The ultimate cost of incurred claims may vary as a result of future developments or better information becoming available about the current circumstances. Adjustments to the quantum of claims provisions established in prior years are reflected in the annual financial statements for the period in which the adjustments are made and disclosed separately, if material. A provision is raised for claims incurred but not yet reported (IBNR) based on historical experience. The group determines the IBNR claims by using actuarial modelling. Policyholder liabilities are measured either on a discounted or undiscounted basis, depending on the features of the contracts. Discounted liabilities The valuation is performed on a policy-by-policy basis by discounting the best estimate of future expected premiums, risk benefits, reinsurance and expenses at the risk-free rate. These calculations are performed using best estimate assumptions (lapse, expenses, premium collection, mortality, morbidity, retrenchment, inflation and yield curve) adjusted by compulsory margins as specified in SAP-104 and further discretionary margins where appropriate. Where the policyholder liability calculated above results in an asset, the group elects to zerorise the policyholder liability and as a result, there is no discounted policyholder liability recognised on the statement of financial position. Undiscounted liabilities Undiscounted policyholder liabilities under insurance contracts comprise a provision for claims IBNR and OCR. IBNR and OCR liabilities are measured at the best estimate of the ultimate cost of settling all claims incurred but unpaid at the reporting date, whether reported or not. The IBNR is a retrospective forward-looking insurance liability, taking into account incurred but not yet reported events, using historical data as the main driver in determining the best estimate for the IBNR. OCR is calculated by reviewing individual claims and the effect of both internal and external foreseeable events, such as changes in claims- handling procedures, inflation, judicial trends, legislative changes and past experience and trends. The group does not discount its OCR. -- 75 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B76- 8 NON-BANKING ACTIVITIES continued 8.1 Insurance activities continued Short-term insurance contracts Long-term insurance contracts Changes in the policyholder liabilities Adjustments to the amounts of policyholder liabilities for policies established in prior years are reflected in the financial statements for the period in which the adjustments are made and disclosed separately, if material. Any differences between valuation assumptions and actual experience, and any change in liabilities resulting from changes in valuation assumptions, are recognised in profit or loss as part of insurance income in NIR over the life of the contract. If future experience under a policy contract is exactly in line with the assumptions employed at the initial recognition of the contract, the valuation margins will emerge as profits over the duration of a policy contract. This is known as the unwinding of margins. Liability adequacy test The insurance liability is tested for adequacy by calculating current estimates of all future contractual cash flows and comparing this amount to the carrying value of the liability. Where a shortfall is identified, an additional liability and the related expense are recognised. Liabilities are calculated in terms of the financial soundness valuation (FSV) basis as described in SAP 104. Since the FSV basis meets the minimum requirement of the liability adequacy test, it is not necessary to perform additional adequacy tests on the liability component. Acquisition costs Acquisition costs include all commission and expenses directly related to acquiring new business. Acquisition costs are expensed as they are incurred. Insurance premium receivables and payables Amounts due from policyholders relate to insurance premiums receivable from policyholders whose payments were not received on the due date and are included in other assets. Insurance creditors and accruals include sundry creditors as well as the reinsurer premium due and are included in creditors, accruals and provisions. Collection rates, applicable to the product arrears rules, are applied to amounts that are not successfully collected from premium debtors to determine the amount that is recoverable. In the current year, an overall collection rate of 80% (2022: 83%) was assumed. The recoverable amount is excluded from amounts that are not successfully collected. The unrecoverable amount is then included in the measurement of the impairment provision. The collection rates are determined by using historical information and trends available to the company. The unrecoverable amount is determined on a product level. -- 76 of 354 -- -B77- 8 NON-BANKING ACTIVITIES continued 8.1 Insurance activities continued Reinsurance contracts held Definitions Contracts that give rise to a significant transfer of insurance risk from the group to another insurance entity. Premiums/ insurance claims recovered Premiums paid to reinsurers are recognised as a deduction against premium income at the undiscounted amounts in terms of the contract when they become due for payment. Insurance claims recovered from reinsurers are recognised in profit or loss in the same period as the related claim at the undiscounted amount receivable in terms of the contract. Profit share from reinsurer The entity is party to profit-sharing arrangements with its reinsurers which enable the entity to receive an experience refund. The experience refund is a percentage of the entity’s eligible reinsurance premium, claims paid, and reinsurance claims received (reinsurance profit or loss). The percentages applied to the reinsurance profit or loss are stated and specific to each profit-sharing arrangement. The payment terms of the experience refund are specific to the reinsurance profit-sharing arrangements. Reinsurance assets The benefits to which the group is entitled under its reinsurance contracts are recognised as assets including: ¾ short-term balances due from reinsurers on settled claims (included in other assets); and ¾ receivables that are dependent on the expected claims and benefits arising under the related insurance contracts (classified as reinsurance assets). Amounts recoverable from or due to reinsurers are measured consistently with the amounts associated with the underlying insurance contracts and in accordance with the terms of each reinsurance contract. IFRS 4 requires reinsurance assets to be reduced to the extent of the impairment of such reinsurance assets and specifies the conditions for impairment – objective evidence, the result of an event, and reliably measurable impacts on the amounts that the cedant may not receive from the reinsurer. This is an in accordance with the incurred loss model specified in IAS 39, i.e. an event must have occurred in order for the impairment to be recognised. Whilst IFRS 4 does not include specific guidance as to what types of events would trigger an impairment test, the guidance in IAS 39 for objective evidence of impairment is used. Changes in reinsurance assets Any difference between the carrying amount of the reinsurance asset and the recoverable amount is recognised in profit or loss as an adjustment to premium income included in non- interest revenue. Related reinsurance payables Liabilities relating to reinsurance comprising premiums payable for reinsurance contracts are included in accounts payable and are recognised as an expense when they fall due in terms of the contract. -- 77 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B78- 8 NON-BANKING ACTIVITIES continued 8.1 Insurance activities continued Investment contracts Definitions Contracts that only transfer financial risk with no significant insurance risk and are within the scope of IFRS 9. These comprise linked-fund policies. Contributions Contributions received are recorded as an increase in investment contract liabilities. Benefits Benefits incurred are recorded as withdrawals from investment contract liabilities. Policyholder liabilities These are recognised within policyholder liabilities in the statement of financial position when the group becomes party to the contractual provisions of the contract. These liabilities are designated at FVTPL on initial recognition. The fair value of the financial liability recognised is never less than the amount payable on surrender, discounted for the required notice period, where applicable. Fair value adjustments in policyholder liabilities held under investment contracts The movement in the policyholder liabilities under investment contracts is recognised as a fair value adjustment on the statement of comprehensive income for both linked and non-linked contracts. 8.2 Investment management activities Certain divisions within the group engage in investment management activities that result in managing assets on behalf of clients. The group excludes assets related to these activities from the statement of financial position as these are not assets of the group, but of the client and are held in a fiduciary capacity. However, the group discloses the value of the assets in its notes. The fee income earned and fee expenses incurred by the group relating to these activities are recognised in fee and commission income and expenses within NIR in the period to which the service relates. 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS 9.1 Introduction In preparing the financial statements, management makes estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets and liabilities. Estimates, assumptions and judgements are continually evaluated and are based on historical experience and other factors, including expectations of future events that are believed to be reasonable under the circumstances. Unless stated otherwise, the judgements applied by management in applying the accounting policies are consistent with the prior year. Included below are all the material critical accounting estimates, assumptions and judgements made by the group, except those related to fair value measurement, which are included in note 34. -- 78 of 354 -- -B79- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.2 Subsidiaries, associates and joint arrangements Subsidiaries Only one party can have control over a subsidiary. In determining whether the group has control over an entity, consideration is given to any rights the group has that result in the ability to direct the relevant activities of the investee, and the group’s exposure to variable returns. In operating entities, shareholding is most often the clearest indication of control. However, for structured entities and investment management funds, judgement is often needed to determine which investors have control of the entity or fund. Generally, where the groupʼs shareholding is greater than 50%, the investment is accounted for as a subsidiary. Decision- making power Some of the major factors considered by the group in making this determination include the following: ¾ the purpose and design of the entity; ¾ what the relevant activities of the entity are; ¾ who controls the relevant activities and whether control is based on voting rights or contractual agreements. This includes considering: o what percentage of voting rights is held by the group and the dispersion and behaviour of other investors; o potential voting rights and whether these increase/decrease the group’s voting powers; o who makes the operating and capital decisions; o who appoints and determines the remuneration of the KMP of the entity; o whether any investor has any veto rights on decisions; o whether there are any management contracts in place that confer decision- making rights; o whether the group provides significant funding or guarantees to the entity; and o whether the group’s exposure is disproportionate to its voting rights; ¾ whether the group is exposed to any downside risk or upside potential that the entity was designed to create; ¾ to what extent the group is involved in the setup of the entity; and ¾ to what extent the group is responsible to ensure that the entity operates as intended. Exposure to variable returns Factors considered include: ¾ the group’s rights in respect of profit or residual distributions; ¾ the group’s rights in respect of repayments and return of debt funding; ¾ whether the group receives any remuneration from servicing assets or liabilities of the entity; ¾ whether the group provides any credit or liquidity support to the entity; ¾ whether the group receives any management fees and whether these are market- related; and ¾ whether the group can obtain any synergies through the shareholding that are not available to other shareholders. Benefits could be non-financial in nature, such as employee services, etc. -- 79 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B80- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.2 Subsidiaries, associates and joint arrangements continued Subsidiaries Ability to use power to affect returns Factors considered include: ¾ whether the group is acting as an agent or principal; ¾ whether the group has any de facto decision-making rights; ¾ whether the decision-making rights the group has are protective or substantive; and ¾ whether the group has the practical ability to direct the relevant activities. Associates Joint arrangements Determining whether the group has significant influence over an entity: ¾ Significant influence may arise from rights other than voting rights, for example management agreements. ¾ The group considers both the rights that it has as well as currently exercisable rights that other investors have when assessing whether it has the practical ability to significantly influence the relevant activities of the investee. Determining whether the group has joint control over an entity: ¾ The group considers all contractual arrangements to determine whether unanimous consent is required in all circumstances. ¾ A joint arrangement is classified as a joint venture when it is a separate legal entity, and the shareholders share in the net assets of the separate legal entity which requires consideration of the practical decision-making ability and management control over the activities of the joint arrangement. Structured entities Structured entities are those where voting rights generally relate to administrative tasks only and the relevant activities are determined only by means of a contractual arrangement. When assessing whether the group has control over a structured entity, specific consideration is given to the purpose and design of the structured entity, and whether the group has power over decisions that relate to activities that the entity was designed to conduct. Investment funds The group acts as fund manager to a number of investment funds. In terms of a mandate the group is required to make active investment management decisions in respect of the fund. Determining whether the group controls such an investment fund usually focuses on the assessment of the aggregate economic interests of the group in the fund (comprising any direct interests in the fund and expected management fees), as well as the investors’ right to remove the group as fund manager. If the other investors are able to easily remove the group as fund manager or the group’s aggregate interest is not deemed to be significant, the group does not consolidate the funds as it is merely acting as an agent for other investors. Other investors are considered to be able to easily remove the fund manager if it is possible for a small number of investors acting together to appoint a new fund manager in the absence of misconduct. Where the group has a significant investment and an irrevocable fund management agreement, the fund is consolidated. -- 80 of 354 -- -B81- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.2 Subsidiaries, associates and joint arrangements continued Investment funds Where such funds are consolidated, judgement is applied in determining if the non-controlling interests in the funds are classified as equity or financial liabilities. Where the external investors have the right to put their investments back into the fund, these non-controlling interests do not meet the definition of equity and are classified as financial liabilities. Where such funds are not consolidated or equity accounted, the group accounts for the investments in the funds as investment securities in terms of IFRS 9. Where investments in funds managed by the group meet the criteria for consolidation, but are considered to be financially inconsequential both individually and in aggregate with other inconsequential investments in funds, they are not consolidated by the group, and are recognised as marketable advances. As decisions related to the relevant activities are based on a contractual agreement (mandate) as opposed to voting or similar rights, investment funds that are managed by the group are considered to be structured entities as defined in IFRS 12, except where other investors can easily remove the group as fund manager without cause as this represents rights similar to voting rights. The group receives investment management fees from the funds for investment management services rendered. These fees are typical of supplier-customer relationships in the investment management industry. Where the group provides seed funding or has any other interests in investment funds it manages, and does not consolidate, the investment is considered to represent a typical customer-supplier relationship. Impairment of goodwill The carrying amount of goodwill is tested annually for impairment in accordance with the group’s policy. Goodwill is considered to be impaired when its recoverable amount is less than its carrying amount. The recoverable amount of the CGU is determined as the higher of the value in use or fair value less costs to sell. For impairment testing purposes, goodwill is allocated to CGUs at the lowest level of operating activity to which it relates and is therefore not combined at group level. The group’s goodwill impairment test is performed on the balances as at 31 March annually. In the prior year, balances for Aldermore were tested at 30 June. The goodwill balance as at 30 June is allocated to the following significant CGUs: R million Segment the goodwill is allocated to 2023 2022 Aldermore Aldermore 8 361 7 095 WesBank WesBank 122 345 African operations FNB broader Africa 38 152 Other Various 125 130 Total 8 646 7 722 Refer to Note 3 ‒ Operating expenses for details of the impairment charge recognised in profit or loss. -- 81 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B82- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.2 Subsidiaries, associates and joint arrangements continued Determination of recoverable amount The recoverable amount of all CGUs to which goodwill is allocated was determined using the value in use methodology. The value in use is calculated as the net present value of the discounted cash flows of the CGU. This is determined by discounting the estimated future pre-tax cash flows (cash flow projections) to its present value using a pre-tax weighted average cost of capital discount rate. In the prior year, the recoverable amount of the goodwill attributable to the WesBank segment was determined using fair value less costs to sell. The fair value was determined using the discounted cash flow methodology. Management’s judgement in estimating the recoverable amount of a CGU The cash flow projections for each CGU are based on budgets and forecasts approved by the board as part of the annual budget and forecast process undertaken in April and May each year. The budgets and forecasts are based on historical data adjusted for management’s expectation of future performance. Expected future performance is determined using both internal and external sources of information. The board challenges and endorses planning assumptions in light of the internal capital allocation decisions necessary to support strategy, current market conditions and the macroeconomic outlook. Cash flow projections up to 2028 were prepared for Aldermore, whereas the cash flows projections until 2027 were considered for other CGUs. The terminal cash flows are calculated from the final cash flow period, which is extrapolated into perpetuity, using the estimated growth rates stated below. These growth rates are consistent with economic reports specific to the country in which each CGU operates. To determine the net present value, the cash flows of the CGU are discounted using the weighted average cost of capital for the specific CGU, adjusted for specific risks relating to the CGU. Where fair value less cost to sell has been used to determine the recoverable amount of the CGU, the discounted cash flow valuation technique is adopted. The fair value is determined by discounting future cash flows using the weighted average cost of capital for the specific CGU, which is adjusted for risks specific to the CGU. The cash flow projections, including terminal cash flows, are estimated using the same process as explained above. The key assumptions in determining fair value are the discount rate and growth rate. For the purpose of the fair value hierarchy, the determination of this fair value is categorised as level 3. -- 82 of 354 -- -B83- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.2 Subsidiaries, associates and joint arrangements continued Determination of recoverable amount The table below shows the discount rates and the growth rates used in calculating the value in use for the CGUs. Discount rates Growth rates R million 2023 2022 2023 2022 Aldermore 14.59 14.90 2.00 2.00 WesBank * 19.52 19.80 – 20.50 3.00 4.70 African operations * 15.70 15.45 – 29.53 4.70 4.90 – 8.00 Other 19.52 19.79 3.00 3.00 * In the prior year, WesBank and African operations included more than one CGU. Due to the impairments recognised in the current year, these segments have a single CGU each. Impairment results Other than those CGUs where goodwill has been impaired, a reasonable change in projected cash flows, the discount rate or growth rate of the above-mentioned CGUs results in their recoverable amount being sufficiently in excess of the carrying amount resulting in changes to the assumptions not changing the final outcome of the test. The goodwill attributable to the Aldermore CGU in the current and prior period were not shown to be sensitive to changes in assumptions supporting the recoverable amount, as the recoverable amount calculated is materially higher than the carrying amount attributable to Aldermore. Foreign operations Management has reviewed the economies of the countries where the group’s foreign operations are actively conducted and has not identified any hyperinflationary economies in terms of the requirements of IFRS. The group operates in South Africa, Namibia, Botswana, Eswatini, Mozambique, Zambia, Lesotho, Tanzania, Ghana, Nigeria, Mauritius, Wales, the United Kingdom (UK), Guernsey and India. The group has representative offices in New York, Kenya, Angola and Shanghai. The office in Angola has no lending or deposit-taking activities at this point. -- 83 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B84- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.3 Taxation The group is subject to direct tax in a number of jurisdictions. As such there may be transactions and calculations for which the ultimate tax determination has an element of uncertainty during the ordinary course of business. The group recognises liabilities for uncertain tax positions in accordance with the criteria defined within IAS 12 and IFRIC 23, based on objective estimates of the amount of tax that may be due, which is calculated, where relevant, with reference to expert advice received. Where payment is determined to be possible but not probable, the tax exposure is disclosed as a contingent liability. The group recognises probable liabilities based on objective estimates of the amount of tax that may be due. Where the final tax determination is different from the amounts that were initially recorded, the difference will impact the income tax and deferred income tax provisions in the period in which such determination is made. Within South Africa, changes in tax rates are regarded as substantially enacted from the time they are announced in terms of the Finance Minister’s budget statement. However, this principle only applies when the change in tax rate is not inextricably linked to other changes in the tax laws. Where changes in the tax rate are explicitly aligned to other changes in the tax law, then the change in tax rate is regarded to be substantially enacted when it has been approved by Parliament and signed by the President. The Finance Minister’s budget speech, which indicated the lowering of the corporate tax rate to 27% for years of assessment commencing on or after 1 April 2022, has been substantially enacted as the change in the tax rate is not inextricably linked to other changes in the tax laws. As such, in the prior year deferred tax assets and liabilities had been calculated at the corporate tax rate of 27%. Furthermore, deferred tax assets are reviewed at each reporting date and are reduced to the extent that it is no longer probable that the related tax benefit will be realised. The most significant management assumption is the forecasts that are used to support the probability assessment that sufficient taxable profits will be generated by the entities in the group in order to utilise the deferred tax assets. -- 84 of 354 -- -B85- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets Impairment of advances In determining whether an impairment loss should be recognised, the group makes judgements as to whether there is a measurable decrease in the estimated future cash flows from a portfolio of loans. The objective of the measurement of an impairment loss is to produce a quantitative measure of the group’s credit risk exposure. The group adopts the PD/LGD approach to calculate ECL for advances. ECL is based on a weighted average of the macroeconomic scenarios selected, weighted by the probability of occurrence. Regression modelling techniques are used to predict borrowers’ behaviour and transaction characteristics in accordance with and to align with IFRS 9, based on relationships observed in historical data related to the group of accounts to which the model will be applied. Models are used to estimate impairment parameters (PD, LGD and EAD) based on the predictive characteristics identified through the regression process. Forward-looking information Forward-looking macroeconomic information has been incorporated into expected credit loss estimates through the application of quantitative modelling and expert judgement-based post-model adjustments. Both quantitative models and expert judgement-based adjustments consider a range of macroeconomic scenarios as inputs. Macroeconomic scenarios are defined by taking global and domestic macroeconomic considerations into account, and forecasts are developed for various scenarios. Development of these scenarios is overseen by the FirstRand macroeconomic forum, which is responsible for oversight and is independent of credit and modelling functions. Teams of economists, both locally and within the various subsidiaries, assess micro- and macroeconomic developments to formulate the macroeconomic forecasts. Various internal and external economists are then requested to assign a probability to each scenario. The rationale for probabilities assigned by each respondent is noted and explained at the FirstRand macroeconomic forum. ECL results are calculated as probability-weighted average results across multiple macroeconomic scenarios. The creation of macroeconomic scenarios and the determination of associated probabilities are subjective, with final ECL results dependent on the assumptions applied during the process. Quantitative techniques are applied to estimate the impact of macroeconomic factors on ECL using various techniques. -- 85 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B86- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Forward-looking information continued Within the RMB corporate and investment banking portfolios, macroeconomic stress testing models are applied to estimate the impact of FLI on ECL. These stress testing models are industry-specific and make use of regression techniques, observed macroeconomic correlations and expert judgement, depending on the extent of data available in each industry. The outputs from these models are used to determine the level of stress that a particular industry is expected to experience, and through-the-cycle impairment parameters are scaled accordingly, with scaling factors based on historical Standard & Poors Global Ratings (S&P) default data. Within retail and commercial portfolios, forward-looking ECL is modelled using regression-based techniques that determine the relationship between key macroeconomic factors and credit risk parameters (with industry considerations further applied in the case of commercial portfolios) based on historically observed correlations. Modelled correlations and macroeconomic variable weightings are adjusted on the basis of expert judgement to ensure that the relationships between macroeconomic forecasts and risk parameters are intuitive and that ECL is reflective of forward-looking expectations of credit performance. The approach applied within the UK operations is aligned with the approach applied within domestic retail portfolios, with FLI-adjusted ECL estimates determined on the basis of a combination of regression-based modelling and expert judgement. Where the impact of forward-looking macroeconomic information on ECL is determined based on historical relationships between macroeconomic movements and default rates, and it is not expected for these relationships to hold under current macroeconomic conditions, judgemental post-model adjustments have been applied to ensure that relationships between macroeconomic forecasts and ECL estimates are intuitive, with ECL increasing where macroeconomic conditions are expected to worsen, and reflecting additional relevant information not catered for in models. This approach is followed across all portfolios. For the group’s South African and broader Africa operations, three macroeconomic scenarios are utilised, namely a base scenario, an upside scenario and a downside scenario. An additional stress scenario was added to the macroeconomic scenarios applied to the retail and commercial portfolios at 30 June 2021 and 30 June 2022, given the event-driven uncertainty in the global and South African economy. The reason for limiting the temporary stress scenario to only these portfolios is that the RMB corporate and investment portfolio already incorporated stressed scenarios for high-risk. The scenario was initially introduced to capture the uncertainty around the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic and subsequently to address risks brought about by the impact of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and inflation and interest rate forecasting risks. Since June 2022, the forecasting risk associated with inflation and interest rates, have manifested in actual inflation and interest rate outcomes. This is incorporated in the group’s impairment models, therefore application of this scenario is no longer required as at 30 June 2023. The table below sets out the most significant macroeconomic factors used to estimate the FLI relating to ECL provisions in South Africa and broader Africa. The information is forecast over a period of three years, per major economic region that the group operates in. -- 86 of 354 -- -B87- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Forward-looking information continued Scenario Probability Description Baseline 56% (2022: 54%) x Global economic growth slows below trend level and developed market (DM) inflation falls from current elevated levels but remains high compared to pre- pandemic levels. x South Africa struggles to lift the potential growth rate meaningfully over the forecast horizon. x Confidence remains low resulting in a relative abundance of savings compared to credit demand. x Social unrest remains a feature of the socioeconomic environment but does not significantly impair confidence or operating conditions. x The climate transition progresses slowly and negotiations on the detail of the climate change deal at the United Nations Climate Change conference (COP26 deal) are drawn out, with a lack of meaningful implementation progress. x Sticky inflation limits the potential upside to real disposable income growth. Upside 15% (2022: 14%) x Global growth remains slow towards trend but soon recovers keeping commodity prices elevated through the forecast horizon. x The South African government manages the carbon transition effectively and negotiations on the detail of the COP26 deal make meaningful progress. x Social unrest abates. x Broader fiscal and economic reforms lift the potential growth rate meaningfully over the forecast horizon. x Private sector confidence and related investment lift, resulting in higher credit extension and a reduction in precautionary savings rates. x A combination of global and domestic factors causes inflation to moderate significantly. Downside 29% (2022: 32%) x Global inflation remains above central banks’ comfort levels, resulting in further policy tightening and negative knock-on consequences for global financial conditions and risk appetite. x The South African government experiences significant setbacks in its efforts to manage the energy transition and decarbonisation process. x The country fails to implement growth-enhancing economic reforms. x Real credit extension falls and savings lift. x A combination of global and domestic factors drive inflation significantly higher and real disposable income growth significantly lower. Temporary stress scenario (applied for 30 June 2022) The ECL impact of the temporary stress scenario as well as its impact on staging of the GCA has been tracked separately for classes of advances within the retail and commercial portfolios, where the temporary stress scenario had a material impact. Therefore, for the retail and commercial portfolios a weighting of 8% was attributed to the temporary scenario, 13% to the upside scenario, 29% to the downside and 50% to the baseline scenario for the year ended 30 June 2022. This scenario is no longer applicable for 30 June 2023. x -- 87 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B88- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Forward-looking information continued The following table sets out the scenarios and the probabilities assigned to each scenario for the group’s UK operations at 30 June 2023: Scenario Probability Description Base 60% (2022: 45%) x The UK narrowly avoids a technical recession, but growth slows meaningfully due to the impact of higher interest rates and tight financial conditions. x The Energy Price Guarantee and base effects support a reduction in headline inflation with meaningful falls in core inflation expected from the end of the 2023 calendar year. x Wage growth is expected to soften slowly. x Higher interest rates are expected to result in further weakness in property values. Upside 15% (2022: 5%) x The Energy Price Guarantee and excess savings is successful in alleviating the cost-of-living crisis, and the UK avoids a recession. x Wholesale agriculture and energy risks recede further and lower headline inflation and forward expectations in the near term resulting in the avoidance of an energy price cliff edge. x A tight labour market results in positive nominal wage growth and a strong recovery in real disposable income. x Inflation settles higher than pre-pandemic, and households run down excess savings at a faster pace, raising both productivity and trend growth compared to the post financial crisis period. x Upside resilience in the labour market somewhat offsets falling goods/commodity inflation, but the sustainably higher path of wage growth and forward expectations allows the Bank of England (BoE) to normalise policy. x House prices growth slows but remains positive, with demand supported by mortgage rates falling back quicker. Downside 20% (2022: 35%) x Fiscal support is ineffective at supporting real households and business incomes and the UK enters a 6-quarter long recession. x The slower decline in inflation than forecast and emerging upside risks prompts the BoE to continue hiking the bank rate to 5.25%. Policy stays in restrictive territory for longer than expected. x Tighter financial conditions and lengthened monetary policy lags lead to lower levels of household and business lending. x Brexit legacy issues exacerbate trade disruptions and specific skill segment labour shortages. x The significant rise in housing costs, consumer inflation and debt servicing cause a reduction in spending and investment while net trade declines. x Higher interest rates cause a wave of insolvencies and the return of inactive workers seeking to boost income, results in unemployment rising to 7%. x Rising mortgage rates and unemployment introduce forbearance and forced- selling, causing a 12% fall in house prices. x A cyclical recovery unfolds eventually, with inflation expectations falling back as headline inflation falls. The BoE embarks on a brief easing cycle, cutting the bank rate to 4%, allowing property growth and the labour market to recover in the medium-term. x -- 88 of 354 -- -B89- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Forward-looking information continued Scenario Probability Description Severe downside 5% (2022: 15%) x The cost-of-living crisis and a resurgence of the energy crisis leads to a wage- price spiral and further aggressive action from central banks, resulting in a deep two-year long recession. x Geopolitical tensions and supply chain disruptions intensify further, triggering substantial further upside pressure in commodity, agricultural and energy prices. x An Energy Price Guarantee remains, but at a higher level, with the policy’s cost limiting what other support the government can provide. x The UK fails to secure any significant post Brexit trade deals resulting in much lower trade volumes. x Due to increased fiscal vulnerability, appetite for UK assets falls causing a prolonged depreciation in pound sterling which pushes up imported and producer inflation. x The resurgence in energy prices and risk of a wage price spiral prompt a second flurry of tightening from the BoE, taking the bank rate to 6% and policy stays tighter for longer. x Consumer and investor sentiment falls further and spare capacity in the economy increases significantly, while economic shocks result in permanent economic scarring and lower trend growth. x Unemployment rises considerably to over 9% as business insolvencies surge. x Rising mortgage rates and unemployment drive increased forbearance and forced-selling in a residential property market where affordability metrics are already stretched, causing a substantial correction in house prices (dropping approximately 20%). Overview of forward-looking information included in the 30 June 2023 impairment of advances During the year global economic growth continued to moderate. With the invasion of Ukraine having exacerbated the already elevated cost-of-living pressures in both developed and emerging economies, central banks persisted with aggressive interest rate hikes to stem inflation, resulting in further downward revisions to growth expectations and increased risk aversion. These hikes were coupled with plans to reduce fiscal stimulus, but this had to be balanced with shielding consumers from the impacts of slowing growth and higher inflation. The complexity of these policy actions, combined with a significant increase in geopolitical risk, resulted in ongoing market volatility. South Africa South Africa’s inflation remained above the central bank’s target range, resulting in an interest rate hiking cycle to lower longer-term inflation expectations. Real economic activity continued to slow, with domestic household consumption in particular being impacted by the higher headline inflation. Despite the slowdown in overall activity, household data showed that income levels among the employed remained somewhat resilient, with corporates pay rises more or less offsetting inflation pressures. Severe rolling blackouts and lower commodity prices in the second half of the financial year weighed on economic activity, while the opportunity to invest in their own energy generation capacity provided the basis for further increases in corporate credit demand. -- 89 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B90- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Forward-looking information continued United Kingdom The cost-of-living crisis, stubborn inflation, and higher interest rates continue to dominate as the main themes driving the economic outlook. This has fed through to rising mortgage rates, which are having an increasingly detrimental impact on affordability measures. However, cash buyers and a high prevalence of fixed-rate mortgages means monetary policy will take time to feed through to the housing market and household finances. The energy crisis has subsided, however wage, services and core inflation remain much too high for the BoE. The Monetary Policy Committee’s reaction heightens overtightening risks. However, a higher- for-longer interest rate environment seems increasingly likely, with risks to the peak and hiking cycle duration tilted to the upside. As such, the risks to economic activity are tilted to the downside after a surprising period of resilience. Broader Africa General The operating environment in the group’s broader Africa footprint was largely characterised by high inflation, tight monetary policy and a slow fall in commodity prices. Structural weaknesses pre-dating the pandemic continue to constrain economic activity in the medium term. Namibia Growth in Namibia remained above its pandemic lows, driven by increased mining output and an improvement in SACU revenues. Despite a reduction in commodity prices, these factors should continue to support growth alongside expected investments in renewable energy infrastructure. Despite these improvements, rising inflation remained a constraint on economic activity overall. Due to the currency peg with the South African rand, Namibia’s monetary policy flexibility is constrained during hiking cycles as interest rates must be on par or above those of South Africa in line with Namibia’s official monetary policy framework. High interest rates remain a near-term constraint on growth expectation due to households remaining highly indebted. Botswana The Botswana economy remained somewhat resilient due to good mining production. In the medium term, the mining sector should also be supported by the resumption of local copper mining activity. However, inflation in Botswana remained elevated while a new policy interest rate, named the monetary policy rate (MPR), was implemented. Persistent high inflation and monetary policy risk may limit the upside to economic activity gains. -- 90 of 354 -- -B91- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Significant macroeconomic factors The table below sets out the most significant macroeconomic factors used to estimate the FLI relating to ECL provisions. The information is forecast over a period of three years, per major economic region that the group operates in. The information below reflects the group’s forecasts for each period at 30 June. 30 June 2023 South Africa Upside scenario Baseline scenario Downside scenario (%) 2024 2025 2026 2024 2025 2026 2024 2025 2026 Applicable across all portfolios Real GDP growth 3.50 3.40 3.50 0.30 1.60 1.80 (0.50) (0.50) 1.50 CPI inflation 5.50 4.10 4.00 6.00 4.90 5.00 7.90 6.80 6.00 Repo rate 8.00 6.00 5.75 8.50 7.25 7.00 9.50 8.75 7.75 Retail-specific Retail real income growth 12.00 1.50 1.70 0.90 0.70 0.80 (1.70) - 0.70 House price index growth * 4.70 5.70 8.30 1.50 2.20 3.30 (2.70) (0.70) 2.80 Household debt to income 63.50 64.40 64.80 62.20 62.20 62.20 60.40 59.20 58.60 Employment growth 2.00 1.90 1.50 1.00 0.50 0.40 (0.40) (0.10) 0.30 Wholesale-specific Fixed capital formation 9.00 7.70 8.70 3.10 3.70 4.30 (5.60) (1.10) 3.70 Foreign exchange rate (USD/ZAR) 15.90 14.80 15.20 18.80 17.40 17.90 26.30 20.90 21.50 * Applicable to the secured portfolio. -- 91 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B92- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Significant macroeconomic factors UK Upside scenario Baseline scenario Downside scenario Severe scenario (%) 2024 2025 2026 2024 2025 2026 2024 2025 2026 2024 2025 2026 Real GDP growth 2.00 3.20 2.60 (0.50) 1.40 1.40 (2.40) 0.10 1.60 (3.30) (1.60) 0.60 CPI inflation 3.20 2.00 1.80 3.70 2.10 2.10 4.40 2.60 2.00 5.60 6.10 2.10 BoE rate 4.30 3.10 3.00 4.50 3.50 3.50 5.30 4.80 4.00 5.40 6.00 5.90 Household disposable income growth (0.40) 2.30 2.40 (0.30) 1.70 1.90 (3.10) (0.10) 2.30 (5.00) (2.50) 2.70 House price index growth * 1.30 3.80 3.80 (4.90) 3.00 3.90 (7.70) (2.50) 1.70 (11.50) (7.00) (0.30) Unemployment rate 3.70 3.50 3.50 4.70 4.20 3.90 5.90 6.80 5.90 8.40 9.00 8.30 * Applicable to the secured portfolio. Broader Africa Namibia Upside scenario Baseline scenario Downside scenario (%) 2024 2025 2026 2024 2025 2026 2024 2025 2026 Real GDP growth 5.60 6.30 6.70 2.90 3.00 2.90 0.40 (0.30) - CPI inflation 4.90 4.90 5.10 4.90 4.50 4.70 7.60 7.60 7.80 Policy rate 5.25 5.25 5.25 7.25 7.25 7.00 10.00 7.50 7.50 Botswana Upside scenario Baseline scenario Downside scenario (%) 2024 2025 2026 2024 2025 2026 2024 2025 2026 Real GDP growth 7.50 7.90 8.00 3.80 4.40 4.30 1.00 1.20 1.20 CPI inflation 4.60 4.60 3.80 7.00 4.50 3.50 11.70 9.30 8.50 Policy rate 3.10 3.10 3.10 3.20 3.20 3.20 8.40 8.40 8.40 -- 92 of 354 -- -B93- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Significant macroeconomic factors 30 June 2022 South Africa Upside scenario Baseline scenario Downside scenario (%) 2023 2024 2025 2023 2024 2025 2023 2024 2025 Applicable across all portfolios Real GDP growth 3.50 3.20 3.10 2.00 1.60 1.60 (2.70) 0.90 0.90 CPI inflation 5.60 4.40 4.40 6.40 4.60 4.60 9.90 9.30 5.80 Repo rate 5.75 5.25 5.25 5.75 5.75 5.75 10.00 10.00 7.50 Retail-specific Retail real income growth 2.30 2.40 2.80 1.30 1.20 1.50 (17.00) (0.70) (0.90) House price index growth * 5.90 6.40 7.00 3.40 3.20 3.60 (4.50) (1.70) (2.10) Household debt to income 67.40 68.20 68.60 66.40 66.60 66.70 65.40 64.90 64.60 Employment growth 0.80 0.60 0.90 0.50 0.30 0.50 (0.60) (0.20) (0.30) Wholesale-specific Fixed capital formation 2.10 7.20 6.80 1.20 3.60 3.50 (1.60) (1.90) (2.00) Foreign exchange rate (USD/ZAR) 13.30 13.90 14.50 15.70 16.40 17.10 23.60 23.00 20.50 * Applicable to the secured portfolio. (%) South Africa – significant macroeconomic factors relevant to temporary stress scenario Retail House House- Real real price hold Employ GDP CPI Repo income index debt to ment growth inflation rate growth growth * income growth 2023 (4.10) 13.10 12.50 (2.60) 6.80 64.80 (1.00) 2024 (2.10) 13.80 14.00 (1.60) (4.10) 63.90 (4.00) 2025 (2.10) 11.00 12.00 (2.00) (4.90) 63.20 (0.60) * Applicable to the secured portfolio. -- 93 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B94- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Significant macroeconomic factors UK Upside scenario Baseline scenario Downside scenario Severe scenario (%) 2023 2024 2025 2023 2024 2025 2023 2024 2025 2023 2024 2025 Real GDP growth 4.00 2.70 2.20 0.60 1.70 1.80 (3.00) 0.90 1.50 (3.10) 0.50 1.10 CPI inflation 4.70 2.60 2.30 4.90 1.80 1.80 7.10 1.50 2.00 2.30 0.80 1.20 BoE rate 2.00 2.00 2.00 1.50 1.50 1.50 3.00 2.25 1.75 (0.50) (0.50) 0.50 Household disposable income growth 3.80 2.50 2.20 1.90 3.30 3.30 (2.00) 3.80 4.00 1.50 2.80 2.30 House price index growth * 3.10 3.00 3.00 1.10 2.00 2.00 (6.80) 1.70 2.40 (6.70) 1.10 1.60 Unemployment rate ** 3.40 3.40 3.40 3.90 3.90 3.90 7.80 7.20 6.80 8.80 8.50 8.20 * Applicable to the secured portfolio. ** In the prior year employment growth was used while in the current year unemployment rate was forecast. Broader Africa Namibia Upside scenario Baseline scenario Downside scenario (%) 2023 2024 2025 2023 2024 2025 2023 2024 2025 Real GDP growth 4.75 5.50 5.50 2.90 3.10 3.50 (0.85) (0.50) (0.50) CPI inflation 4.80 4.40 4.20 5.00 4.90 4.70 7.30 7.20 7.20 Repo rate 5.75 5.25 5.25 5.50 5.75 5.75 10.00 8.00 7.00 Botswana Upside scenario Baseline scenario Downside scenario (%) 2023 2024 2025 2023 2024 2025 2023 2024 2025 Real GDP growth 5.25 5.45 5.50 3.70 3.90 4.00 0.90 0.55 0.40 CPI inflation 9.30 5.83 4.50 10.65 6.88 4.90 12.89 9.49 8.22 Repo rate 2.65 2.90 2.90 3.65 3.90 3.90 4.03 4.40 4.40 x -- 94 of 354 -- -B95- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Significant macroeconomic factors The following table reflects the impact on the performing (stage 1 and stage 2) impairment provisions on advances, if the probability weighting assigned to each of the scenarios were increased to 100%. In the prior year, the table below presented only Total. In the current year, as IFRS 9 is embedded in the group’s reporting process, the table has been expanded to provide additional disclosure. % change % change % change IFRS 9 in total in total in total impairment IFRS 9 IFRS 9 IFRS 9 provision Baseline provision Upside provision Downside * provision Total at 30 June 2023 24 197 23 609 (2) 20 914 (14) 26 279 9 Retail 10 749 10 274 (4) 9 101 (15) 11 676 9 Commercial 2 459 2 438 (1) 2 199 (11) 2 618 6 RMB CIB 3 770 3 736 (1) 3 480 (8) 4 044 7 Broader Africa 2 093 2 165 3 1 898 (9) 2 374 13 Centre (including Group Treasury) 521 512 (2) 506 (3) 518 (1) UK operations 4 605 4 484 (3) 3 730 (19) 5 049 10 Total at 30 June 2022 21 379 20 355 (5) 18 436 (14) 24 629 15 Retail 10 085 9 544 (5) 8 767 (13) 11 780 17 Commercial 2 523 2 459 (3) 2 313 (8) 2 797 11 RMB CIB 3 620 3 593 (1) 3 455 (5) 3 793 5 Broader Africa 1 911 2 094 10 1 916 - 2 305 21 Centre (including Group Treasury) 512 510 - 510 - 513 - UK operations 2 728 2 155 (21) 1 475 (46) 3 441 26 * Due to the non-linearity of the temporary stress scenario, the scenario increases to R31 866 million for the period ended 30 June 2022 when a probability weighting of 100% to the temporary stress scenario is added to the downside scenario. The scenario was not applied at 30 June 2023. Please note, the analysis only reflects the impact of changing the probability assigned to each scenario to 100% and does not include any changes to post-model adjustments. -- 95 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B96- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Judgement Retail and retail SME Wholesale and commercial SME Measurement of the 12-month and LECL Parameters are determined on a basis whereby exposures are pooled at a portfolio level (at a minimum). Where appropriate, more granular pooling is applied. The inputs used to determine parameter values include historically observed behaviour, as well as behavioural and demographic information related to individual exposures currently on book. PD parameters are determined through assessment of the influence that various risk drivers have had on historical default rates. EAD parameter estimates are based on product characteristics in addition to historical drawdown and payment behaviour. Parameters are determined based on the application of statistical models that produce estimates based on counterparty-specific financial information and transaction characteristics. These characteristics include the nature of available collateral. Due to the specialised nature of these exposures, parameters produced by models are taken through a robust review and challenge process before being applied to calculate ECL, and are required to be signed off by a committee of wholesale and commercial credit experts who can motivate adjustments to modelled parameters. -- 96 of 354 -- -B97- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Judgement Retail and retail SME Wholesale and commercial SME LGDs are determined by estimating expected future cash flows, adjusted for FLI such as the house price index, prime lending rate and GDP. These cash flows include direct costs and proceeds from the sale of collateral. Collateral recovery rates are based on historically observed outcomes. The statistical models applied implicitly assume that risk drivers that influence default risk, payment behaviour and recovery expectations within historical data will continue to be relevant in the future. Parameters are calibrated for the calculation of 12-month and LECL using term structures that consider borrower risk, account age, historical behaviour, transaction characteristics and correlations between parameters. Term structures have been developed over the remaining lifetime of an instrument. The remaining lifetime is limited to the contractual term of instruments in the portfolio, except for instruments with an undrawn commitment such as credit cards, where there is no contractual expiry date. In such instances the remaining lifetime is determined with reference to the change in client requirements that would trigger a review of the contractual terms, for example an increase in limit. ECL on open accounts is discounted from the expected date of default to the reporting date, using the asset’s original effective interest rate or a reasonable approximation thereof. Determination of whether the credit risk of financial instruments have increased significantly since initial recognition (SICR) SICR triggers continue to be based on client behaviour, client-based behaviour scores and judgemental factors. SICR triggers continue to be determined based on client behaviour and the internal FirstRand client rating or risk score, as well as judgemental factors, which include triggers for industries in distress, potentially resulting in the client being added to the watch-list through the group’s ongoing risk management process. These triggers are determined at a deal and client level and are calibrated over time to determine what level of deterioration is reflective of a SICR. -- 97 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B98- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.4 Impairment of financial assets continued Judgement Retail and retail SME Wholesale and commercial SME Prior and current year: Sensitivity staging The move from 12-month ECL (stage 1) to LECL (stage 2) can result in a substantial increase in ECL. The sensitivity information provided in the table below details the estimated additional ECL charge to the income statement that the group would need to recognise if 5% of the stage 1 GCA of advances suffered a SICR and were moved from stage 1 to stage 2 as at 30 June 2023. A 5% increase in advances categorised as stage 2 can be viewed as a reasonably possible alternative based on the current economic conditions. 30 June 2023 5% increase in gross carrying amount of Increase in the loss R million exposure * allowance Retail 34 634 2 504 Wholesale, commercial and other (including Group Treasury) 36 283 4 411 Total increase in stage 2 advances and ECL 70 917 6 915 30 June 2022 Retail 30 195 2 054 Wholesale, commercial and other (including Group Treasury) 30 731 3 929 Total increase in stage 2 advances and ECL 60 926 5 983 * Includes exposures across the group's exposures in South Africa, broader Africa and UK operations. -- 98 of 354 -- -B99- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.5 Provisions Provisions for litigation The group has a policy and process in place to determine when to recognise provisions for potential litigation and claims. The recognition of such provisions is linked to the ranking of the legal risk of potential litigation on the bank’s litigation database which indicates if outflow is probable. 9.6 Transactions with employees Employee benefits – defined benefit plans Determination of required funding levels Funding levels are monitored on an annual basis and the current agreed contribution rate in respect of the defined benefit pension fund is 21% (2022: 21%) of pensionable salaries (in excess of the minimum recommended contribution rate set by the fund actuary). The group considers the recommended contribution rate as advised by the fund actuary with each actuarial valuation. In addition, the trustees of the fund target a funding position on pensioner liabilities that exceeds the value of the best estimate actuarial liability. The funding position is also considered in relation to a solvency reserve basis, which makes allowance for the discontinuance cost of outsourcing the pensions. As at the last statutory actuarial valuation of the pension fund (during June 2020), all categories of liabilities were at least 100% funded. If the member chooses to buy into the fund, the fair value of plan assets and the value of the plan liabilities on the defined benefit plan are increased by the amount of the initial contribution on the date of the purchase. -- 99 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B100- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.6 Transactions with employees continued Employee benefits – defined benefit plans Determination of present value of defined benefit plan obligations The cost of the benefits and the present value of the defined benefit pension funds and post-employment medical obligations depend on a number of factors that are determined annually on an actuarial basis, by independent actuaries, using the projected unit credit method which incorporates a number of assumptions. The key assumptions used in determining the charge to profit or loss arising from these obligations include the expected long-term rate of return on the relevant plan assets, discount rate and expected salary and pension increase rates. Any changes in these assumptions will impact the charge to profit or loss and may affect planned funding of the pension plans. Cash-settled share-based payment plans Determination of fair value of the award The award is determined using a Black Scholes option pricing model with a zero strike price. The following estimates are included in the model to determine the value: ¾ management’s estimate of future dividends; ¾ the risk-free interest rate; and ¾ staff turnover and historical forfeiture rates as indicators of future conditions. Equity-settled share-based payment plans Determination of fair value of the award The total value of the services received is calculated with reference to the fair value of the award on grant date. The fair value of the award is determined excluding non-market vesting conditions. These vesting conditions are included in the assumptions of the number of awards expected to vest. 9.7 Insurance and investment management activities Long-term insurance contracts Determination/ valuation of policyholder liability for long-term insurance contracts – FSV method Policyholder liabilities under long-term insurance contracts are valued in terms of the FSV method as is required by professional guidance note SAP 104 issued by the ASSA. This methodology is applied to each product type depending on the nature of the contract and the associated risks. Under this method, the liability is determined as the best estimate of the future cash flows relating to the insurance contracts plus certain compulsory and discretionary margins. A repudiation factor is applied when calculating the liability based on historical claim repudiation rates. -- 100 of 354 -- -B101- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.7 Insurance and investment management activities continued Long-term insurance contracts Best estimate of future cash flows The best estimate of future cash flows considers certain assumptions, i.e. expected future experience as well as revised expectations of future income, claims and expenditure. Differences between the assumptions used at the start and end of the period give rise to revised liability quantification. The expected level of terminations is incorporated into the liabilities, irrespective of whether this leads to an increase or a decrease in the liabilities. Discretionary margins The main discretionary margins utilised in the valuation are as follows: ¾ additional prospective margins are held in respect of decrement assumptions and asset-related fees on certain product lines to avoid the premature recognition of profits that may give rise to future losses if the claims experience turns out to be worse than expected; and ¾ where the present value of expected future inflows is greater than the value of expected future outflows, as assessed on a policy-by-policy basis and grouped per product, portfolio and tax fund, results in an asset, the company elects to zeroise the policyholder liability. As a result, there are no discounted policyholder liabilities recognised on the statement of financial position except those relating to positive policyholder liabilities. Liabilities for claims OCR represent claims where the incident giving rise to a claim has occurred and has been reported to the insurer for settlement, but has not yet been finalised and paid by the insurer. The liability is measured at the value assessed for the claim and a repudiation factor is applied when calculating the liability based on historical claim repudiation rates. IBNR claims are claims incurred but not yet reported or paid. The liability is estimated by assuming that future trends in reporting of claims will be similar to the past. The profile of claims run-off (over time) is modelled by using historical data of the group and chain- ladder techniques. The profile is then applied to actual claims data of recent periods for which the run-off is believed to be incomplete. Key assumptions to which the estimation of liabilities is particularly sensitive Material judgement is required in determining liabilities and in the choice of assumptions. Assumptions in use are based on experience, current internal data, external market indices and benchmarks which reflect current observable market prices and other published information. Assumptions and prudent estimates are determined at the date of valuation. Assumptions are further evaluated on a continual basis in order to ensure realistic and reasonable valuations. The key assumptions to which the estimation of liabilities is particularly sensitive are as follows: -- 101 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B102- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.7 Insurance and investment management activities continued Key assumptions to which the estimation of liabilities is particularly sensitive Mortality, retrenchment and morbidity rates Assumptions are based on standard industry tables, national tables, reinsurer tables or internal tables where sufficient data is available, according to the type of contract written and the factors underlying the risk profiles of the insured person. They reflect recent historical experience and are adjusted when appropriate to reflect the group’s own experiences. An appropriate, but not excessive, prudent allowance is made for expected future trends. Assumptions are differentiated by gender, underwriting class and contract types. An increase in actual mortality rates will lead to an increase in claims and related expenditure thereby reducing profits for shareholders. Expenses Operating expense assumptions reflect the projected costs of maintaining and servicing in- force policies and associated overhead expenses. The current level of expenses are taken as an appropriate expense base, adjusted for expected expense inflation if appropriate. An increase in expenses would result in an increase in expenditure thereby reducing profits for shareholders. Lapse and cancellation rates Lapses relate to the termination of policies due to non-payment of premiums. Cancellations relate to the voluntary termination of policies by policyholders. Policy termination assumptions are determined using statistical measures based on the group’s experience and vary by product type, policy duration and sales channel. An increase in lapse rates early in the life of the policy would tend to reduce profits for shareholders, but later increases are broadly neutral in effect. Discount rate Life insurance liabilities are determined as the sum of the discounted value of the expected benefits paid to policyholders and future administration expenses directly related to the contract, less the discounted value of the expected contractual premiums that would be required to meet these future cash outflows. Discount rates are based on risk-free rates published by the Prudential Authority (PA) for the calculation of solvency assessment and management returns. A decrease in the discount rate will increase the asset. -- 102 of 354 -- -B103- 9 CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES, ASSUMPTIONS AND JUDGEMENTS continued 9.7 Insurance and investment management activities continued Investment contracts Valuation of policyholder liability under investment contracts The fair value of investment contracts without fixed benefits and unit-linked contracts is calculated using the current unit price that reflects the fair values of the underlying financial assets and/or derivatives. For unit-linked contracts, the unitised investment funds linked to the financial liability are multiplied by the number of units attributed to the policyholder at the statement of financial position date. For investment contracts with fixed and guaranteed terms, a valuation model is used to establish the fair value at inception and at each reporting date. The valuation model values the liabilities as the present value of the maturity values, using appropriate market-related yields to maturity. For investment contracts with no guaranteed returns, the return is derived from the performance of the underlying unit trust or share portfolio and is valued at fair value at each reporting date. 10 RESTATEMENT OF PRIOR YEAR NUMBERS The group has made the following changes to the presentation of other assets and creditors, accruals and provisions . 10.1 Description of restatement Aldermore applies a dynamic portfolio fair value hedging strategy, refer to note 8 for more detail. IAS 39 requires the change in value of a hedged item (which represents the fair value of the interest rate risk component of the hedged portfolio) to be presented in a manner consistent with the position of the hedged item with a particular repricing period. The group restated its statement of financial position to reflect the change in value of hedged items in an asset position within other assets and in a liability position within creditors, accruals and provisions, respectively. The change in presentation has no impact on the profit or loss or NAV of the group. -- 103 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B104- 10 RESTATEMENT OF PRIOR YEAR NUMBERS continued 10.2 Restated consolidated statement of financial position as at 30 June As previously reported Restated R million 2022 Reclassification 2022 ASSETS Cash and cash equivalents 143 636 - 143 636 Derivative financial instruments 65 667 - 65 667 Commodities 17 580 - 17 580 Investment securities 382 149 - 382 149 Advances 1 334 324 - 1 334 324 ‒ Advances to customers 1 262 083 - 1 262 083 ‒ Marketable advances 72 241 - 72 241 Other assets 9 597 (4 833) 4 764 Current tax asset 624 - 624 Non-current assets and disposal groups held for sale 1 501 - 1 501 Reinsurance assets 583 - 583 Investments in associates 8 178 - 8 178 Investments in joint ventures 2 618 - 2 618 Property and equipment 19 725 - 19 725 Intangible assets 9 459 - 9 459 Investment properties 698 - 698 Defined benefit post-employment asset 35 - 35 Deferred income tax asset 8 028 - 8 028 Total assets 2 004 402 (4 833) 1 999 569 EQUITY AND LIABILITIES Liabilities Short trading positions 14 623 - 14 623 Derivative financial instruments 64 547 - 64 547 Creditors, accruals and provisions 35 761 (4 833) 30 928 Current tax liability 803 - 803 Liabilities directly associated with disposal groups held for sale 824 - 824 Deposits 1 655 972 - 1 655 972 Employee liabilities 13 862 - 13 862 Other liabilities 8 248 - 8 248 Policyholder liabilities 7 424 - 7 424 Tier 2 liabilities 20 937 - 20 937 Deferred income tax liability 692 - 692 Total liabilities 1 823 693 (4 833) 1 818 860 Equity Ordinary shares 56 - 56 Share premium 7 905 7 905 Reserves 156 820 - 156 820 Capital and reserves attributable to equityholders of the group 164 781 - 164 781 Other equity instruments 11 645 - 11 645 Non-controlling interests 4 283 - 4 283 Total equity 180 709 - 180 709 Total equity and liabilities 2 004 402 (4 833) 1 999 569 The value attributable to the dynamic hedging strategy in 2021 was not material. -- 104 of 354 -- -B105- CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT for the year ended 30 June R million Notes 2023 2022 Interest income calculated using effective interest rate 149 269 107 515 Interest on other financial instruments and similar income 2 627 1 452 Interest and similar income 1.1 151 896 108 967 Interest expense and similar charges 1.2 (75 459) (42 592) Net interest income before impairment of advances 76 437 66 375 Impairment and fair value of credit of advances (10 949) (7 080) ‒ Impairment on amortised cost advances 12.2 (11 151) (6 539) ‒ Fair value of credit on advances 12.2 202 (541) Net interest income after impairment of advances 65 488 59 295 Non-interest revenue 2 55 314 48 248 ‒ Net fee and commission income 2.1 36 084 33 396 ‒ Fee and commission income 43 540 39 967 ‒ Fee and commission expense (7 456) (6 571) ‒ Insurance income 2.2 5 393 4 297 ‒ Fair value income 2.3 8 551 6 835 ‒ Fair value gains and losses 17 882 12 790 ‒ Interest expense on fair value activities (9 331) (5 955) ‒ Gains less losses from investing activities 2.4 1 528 515 ‒ Other non-interest income 2.5 3 758 3 205 Income from operations 120 802 107 543 Operating expenses 3 (68 749) (60 769) Net income from operations 52 053 46 774 Share of profit of associates after tax 16 332 895 Share of profit of joint ventures after tax 17 155 596 Income before indirect tax 52 540 48 265 Indirect tax 4.1 (1 632) (1 433) Income before income tax 50 908 46 832 Income tax expense 4.2 (12 196) (12 193) Profit for the year 38 712 34 639 Attributable to Ordinary equityholders 36 366 32 761 Other equity instrument holders 1 119 838 Equityholders of the group 37 485 33 599 Non-controlling interests 1 227 1 040 Profit for the year 38 712 34 639 Earnings per share (cents) ‒ Basic 5 648.7 584.3 ‒ Diluted 5 648.7 584.3 -- 105 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B106- CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF OTHER COMPREHENSIVE INCOME for the year ended 30 June R million 2023 2022 Profit for the year 38 712 34 639 Items that may subsequently be reclassified to profit or loss Cash flow hedges (738) (3 712) Gains/(losses) arising during the year 282 (2 138) Reclassification adjustments for amounts included in profit or loss (1 333) (2 972) Deferred income tax 313 1 398 FVOCI debt reserve 33 (50) Gains/(losses) arising during the year 35 (65) Reclassification adjustments for amounts included in profit or loss 11 (15) Deferred income tax (13) 30 Exchange differences on translating foreign operations 8 081 2 007 Gains arising during the year 7 974 1 997 Deferred income tax 107 10 Share of other comprehensive income of associates and joint ventures after tax and non-controlling interest (3) 13 Items that may not subsequently be reclassified to profit or loss FVOCI equity reserve 33 4 Gains arising during the year 38 10 Deferred income tax (5) (6) Remeasurements on defined benefit post-employment plans 10 41 Gains arising during the year 20 59 Deferred income tax (10) (18) Other comprehensive income/(loss) for the year 7 416 (1 697) Total comprehensive income for the year 46 128 32 942 Attributable to Ordinary equityholders 43 705 31 037 Other equity instrument holders 1 119 838 Equityholders of the group 44 824 31 875 Non-controlling interests 1 304 1 067 Total comprehensive income for the year 46 128 32 942 -- 106 of 354 -- -B107- CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION as at 30 June R million Notes 2023 2022 * ASSETS Cash and cash equivalents 7 175 304 143 636 Derivative financial instruments 8 85 956 65 667 Commodities 9 17 252 17 580 Investment securities 10 419 140 382 149 Advances 11 1 539 375 1 334 324 ‒ Advances to customers ** 1 455 422 1 262 083 ‒ Marketable advances 83 953 72 241 Other assets 13 3 760 4 764 Current tax asset 925 624 Non-current assets and disposal groups held for sale 14 1 359 1 501 Reinsurance assets 15 554 583 Investments in associates 16 10 400 8 178 Investments in joint ventures 17 3 105 2 618 Property and equipment 18 21 155 19 725 Intangible assets 19 10 278 9 459 Investment properties 20 353 698 Defined benefit post-employment asset 21 25 35 Deferred income tax asset 22 8 669 8 028 Total assets 2 297 610 1 999 569 EQUITY AND LIABILITIES Liabilities Short trading positions 23 12 753 14 623 Derivative financial instruments 8 70 354 64 547 Creditors, accruals and provisions 24 43 389 30 928 Current tax liability 471 803 Liabilities directly associated with disposal groups held for sale 14 - 824 Deposits 25 1 923 103 1 655 972 Employee liabilities 21 17 074 13 862 Other liabilities 26 7 033 8 248 Policyholder liabilities 15 8 131 7 424 Tier 2 liabilities 27 16 869 20 937 Deferred income tax liability 22 752 692 Total liabilities 2 099 929 1 818 860 Equity Ordinary shares 28 56 56 Share premium 28 7 860 7 905 Reserves 172 631 156 820 Capital and reserves attributable to equityholders of the group 180 547 164 781 Other equity instruments and reserves 29 12 846 11 645 Non-controlling interests 4 288 4 283 Total equity 197 681 180 709 Total equity and liabilities 2 297 610 1 999 569 * Restated, refer to section 10 of the accounting policies. ** Included in advances to customers are assets under agreements to resell of R79 410 million (2022: R70 617 million). -- 107 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B108- CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN EQUITY for the year ended 30 June Ordinary share capital and ordinary equityholders’ funds Defined Share benefit capital post- Cash flow Share Share and share employment hedge R million capital premium premium reserve reserve Balance as at 1 July 2021 56 7 973 8 029 (597) 1 355 Disposal of subsidiaries - - - - - Additional Tier 1 capital issued during the year - - - - - Movement in other reserves - - - - - Ordinary dividends - - - - - Distributions on other equity instruments - - - - - Transfer to/(from) general risk reserves - - - - - Changes in ownership interest of subsidiaries - - - - - Movement in treasury shares - (68) (68) - - Total comprehensive income for the year - - - 41 (3 712) ‒ Profit for the year - - - - - ‒ Other comprehensive income for the year - - - 41 (3 712) Vesting of share-based payments - - - - - Balance as at 30 June 2022 56 7 905 7 961 (556) (2 357) Acquisition of subsidiaries - - - - - Additional Tier 1 capital issued during the year - - - - - Preference shares redeemed during the year - - - - - Movement in other reserves - - - - - Ordinary dividends - - - - - Distributions on other equity instruments - - - - - Transfer (from)/to general risk reserves - - - - - Changes in ownership interest of subsidiaries - - - - - Movement in treasury shares - (45) (45) - - Total comprehensive income for the year - - - 10 (738) ‒ Profit for the year - - - - - ‒ Other comprehensive income for the year - - - 10 (738) Vesting of share-based payments - - - - - Balance as at 30 June 2023 56 7 860 7 916 (546) (3 095) * Refer to note 28.2 for a breakdown of other reserves. ** Other equity instruments and reserves at 30 June 2023 include Rnil (2022: R4 519 million) of non-cumulative, non-redeemable preference shares and R9 930 million (2022: R7 126 million) of AT1 instruments and R2 916 million (2022: nil) in empowerment fund reserve. -- 108 of 354 -- -B109- Ordinary share capital and ordinary equityholders’ funds Reserves Other Share- Foreign attributable equity based currency to ordinary instruments Non- payment translation Other Retained equity- and controlling Total reserve reserve reserves * earnings holders reserves ** interests equity 44 2 773 1 176 138 837 143 588 11 645 4 625 167 887 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 203 (278) (75) - 29 (46) - - - (17 390) (17 390) - (1 026) (18 416) - - - - - (838) - (838) - - (55) 55 - - - - - - - (364) (364) - (412) (776) - - - 24 24 - - (44) - 1 993 (46) 32 761 31 037 838 1 067 32 942 - - - 32 761 32 761 838 1 040 34 639 - 1 993 (46) - (1 724) - 27 (1 697) - - - - - - - - 44 4 766 1 278 153 645 156 820 11 645 4 283 180 709 - - - - - - 1 1 - - - - - 2 804 - 2 804 - - - - - (4 519) - (4 519) 12 - 295 (170) 137 2 916 2 3 055 - - - (27 991) (27 991) - (1 240) (29 231) - - - - - (1 119) - (1 119) - - 6 (6) - - - - - - - 2 2 - (62) (60) - - - (13) (13) - - (58) - 8 003 64 36 366 43 705 1 119 1 304 46 128 - - - 36 366 36 366 1 119 1 227 38 712 - 8 003 64 - 7 339 - 77 7 416 (29) - - - (29) - - (29) 27 12 769 1 643 161 833 172 631 12 846 4 288 197 681 -- 109 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B110- CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS for the year ended 30 June R million Notes 2023 2022 Cash flows from operating activities Interest and fee commission receipts 191 607 150 467 ‒ Interest received 150 756 113 464 ‒ Fee and commission received 43 540 39 967 ‒ Insurance income received 4 767 3 607 ‒ Fee and commission paid (7 456) (6 571) Trading and other income 3 774 3 539 Interest payments (74 673) (37 778) Other operating expenses (52 376) (45 355) Dividends received 3 557 3 065 Dividends paid (29 110) (18 228) Dividends paid to non-controlling interest (1 240) (1 026) Taxation paid (14 574) (14 984) Cash generated from operating activities 26 965 39 700 Movements in operating assets and liabilities 20 690 (29 899) ‒ Liquid assets and trading securities (27 190) (200) ‒ Advances (157 650) (92 260) ‒ Deposits 210 639 61 655 ‒ Other assets (4 756) (194) ‒ Creditors 9 299 6 930 ‒ Employee liabilities (947) (5 241) ‒ Total other liabilities (8 705) (589) ‒ Other operating liabilities* (9 441) (428) ‒ Reinsurance assets 29 (196) ‒ Policyholder liabilities 707 35 Net cash generated from operating activities 47 655 9 801 Cash flows from investing activities Acquisition of investments in associates 16 (1 110) (236) Proceeds on disposal of investments in associates 16 38 1 Acquisition of investments in joint ventures 17 (653) (92) Proceeds on disposal of investments in joint ventures 17 67 40 Acquisition of investments in subsidiaries 30.1 - 21 Proceeds on disposal of subsidiaries 30.2 42 - Acquisition of property and equipment 18 (4 730) (3 265) Proceeds on disposal of property and equipment 18 458 617 Acquisition of intangible assets and investment properties 19,20 (460) (409) Proceeds on disposal of non-current assets held for sale 14 2 053 25 Net cash outflow from investing activities (4 295) (3 298) * Other operating liabilities consist of various operating liabilities. The most significant balances include short trading positions and derivative financial instruments. -- 110 of 354 -- -B111- CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS continued for the year ended 30 June R million Notes 2023 2022 Cash flows from financing activities Proceeds on the issue of other financing liabilities 26.1 4 614 1 067 Redemption of other financing liabilities 26.1 (5 114) (842) Principal payment towards lease liabilities 26.1 (1 012) (1 030) Proceeds from issue of Tier 2 liabilities 27.1 10 486 2 742 Capital repaid on Tier 2 liabilities 27.1 (15 579) (3 577) Acquisition of additional interest in subsidiaries from non-controlling interest 30.1.1 (170) (866) Redemption of preference shares (4 519) - Proceeds from issue of AT1 equity instruments 29 2 804 - Net cash outflow from financing activities (8 490) (2 506) Net increase in cash and cash equivalents 34 870 3 997 Cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the year 143 636 135 059 Effect of exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents (3 202) 4 631 Transfer to non-current assets held for sale 14 - (51) Cash and cash equivalents at the end of the year 7 175 304 143 636 -- 111 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B112- NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS for the year ended 30 June 1 ANALYSIS OF INTEREST INCOME AND INTEREST EXPENSE 1.1 Interest and similar income R million 2023 2022 Analysis of interest and similar income Debt instruments at fair value through other comprehensive income 3 313 1 187 Instruments at fair value through profit and loss 2 625 1 450 Instruments at amortised cost 145 956 106 328 Non-financial instruments 2 2 Interest and similar income 151 896 108 967 Advances 123 567 87 726 ‒ Overdrafts and cash management accounts 9 359 6 569 ‒ Term loans 7 870 4 740 ‒ Card loans 5 678 4 296 ‒ Instalment sales and hire purchase agreements 21 235 16 250 ‒ Lease payments receivable 675 644 ‒ Property finance 38 689 27 157 ‒ Home loans 32 694 22 968 ‒ Commercial property finance 5 995 4 189 ‒ Personal loans 11 173 9 865 ‒ Preference share agreements 2 742 2 330 ‒ Assets under agreements to resell 1 060 767 ‒ Investment bank term loans 13 936 8 698 ‒ Long-term loans to group associates and joint ventures 67 53 ‒ Other customer advances 3 792 2 160 ‒ Invoice finance 1 499 612 ‒ Marketable advances 5 792 3 585 Cash and cash equivalents 4 279 1 501 Investment securities 19 938 13 209 Accrued on off-market advances 61 49 Interest on derivatives qualifying as hedging instruments 3 894 6 347 Other 157 135 Interest and similar income 151 896 108 967 -- 112 of 354 -- -B113- 1 ANALYSIS OF INTEREST INCOME AND INTEREST EXPENSE continued 1.2 Interest expense and similar charges R million 2023 2022 Analysis of interest expense and similar charges Instruments at fair value through profit or loss * (167) (23) Instruments at amortised cost (75 145) (42 432) Non-financial instruments (147) (137) Interest expense and similar charges (75 459) (42 592) Deposits (81 335) (42 014) Deposits from customers (65 327) (31 021) ‒ Current accounts (8 403) (3 413) ‒ Savings deposits (2 201) (875) ‒ Call deposits (22 619) (10 532) ‒ Fixed and notice deposits (30 504) (15 219) ‒ Other deposits (1 600) (982) Debt securities (13 421) (9 614) ‒ Negotiable certificates of deposit (4 459) (2 021) ‒ Fixed and floating rate notes (8 962) (7 593) Securitisation issuances (932) (467) Repurchase agreements (450) (377) Securities lending (150) (86) Cash collateral and credit-linked notes (1 055) (449) Other funding liabilities (1 263) (239) SARB funding facility due to Covid-19 SME government guarantee (125) (65) Preference shares and other (84) (135) Lease liabilities (146) (143) Tier 2 liabilities (1 628) (1 396) Interest on derivatives qualifying as hedging instruments (162) (4 560) Other (47) 5 Gross interest expense and similar charges (84 790) (48 547) Less: interest expense on fair value activities reallocated ** 9 331 5 955 Interest expense and similar charges (75 459) (42 592) * The analysis of interest expense and similar charges was expanded to separately present instruments at FVTPL from instruments at amortised cost. ** Relates to interest expense accrued on amortised cost financial liabilities. -- 113 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B114- 2 NON-INTEREST REVENUE R million Notes 2023 2022 Analysis of non-interest revenue Fee and commission income 43 540 39 967 ‒ Instruments at amortised cost 35 742 32 907 ‒ Instruments at fair value through profit or loss 79 9 ‒ Non-financial instruments 7 719 7 051 Fee and commission expenses (7 456) (6 571) Net fee and commission income 2.1 36 084 33 396 Insurance income 2.2 5 393 4 297 ‒ Instruments mandatory at fair value through profit or loss 4 797 4 178 ‒ Instruments designated at fair value through profit or loss 2 088 2 467 ‒ Translation gains or losses on instruments not held at fair value through profit or loss 1 666 190 Fair value income 2.3 8 551 6 835 ‒ Instruments at fair value through profit or loss 60 221 ‒ Designated fair value through profit or loss 46 37 ‒ Mandatory fair value through profit or loss 14 184 ‒ Instruments at amortised cost 123 137 ‒ Instruments at fair value through other comprehensive income 2 27 ‒ Non-financial instruments 1 343 130 Gains less losses from investing activities * 2.4 1 528 515 Other non-interest revenue 2.5 3 758 3 205 Total non-interest revenue 55 314 48 248 * The term investing activities used in this note does not have the same meaning as investing activities in the cash flow statement. -- 114 of 354 -- -B115- 2 NON-INTEREST REVENUE continued 2.1 Net fee and commission income R million 2023 2022 Banking fee and commission income 38 462 35 259 ‒ Card commissions 7 224 6 169 ‒ Cash deposit fees 1 823 1 812 ‒ Commitment fees 1 976 1 662 ‒ Electronic transaction fees 892 1 091 ‒ Exchange commissions 2 487 2 280 ‒ Brokerage income 127 154 ‒ Bank charges 23 933 22 091 ‒ Transaction and service fees 8 733 7 767 ‒ Documentation and administration fees 10 931 10 357 ‒ Cash handling fees 3 043 2 944 ‒ Other 1 226 1 023 Knowledge-based fee and commission income 1 455 1 161 Management, trust and fiduciary fees 2 559 2 571 Fee and commission income from service providers 509 503 Other non-banking fee and commission income 555 473 Fee and commission income * 43 540 39 967 Transaction processing fees (2 079) (1 569) Transaction-based fees (180) (166) Commission paid (263) (246) Customer loyalty programmes (2 361) (2 162) Cash sorting, handling and transportation charges (1 252) (1 173) Card and cheque book-related (404) (392) ATM commissions paid (65) (65) Other (852) (798) Fee and commission expenses (7 456) (6 571) Net fee and commission income 36 084 33 396 * Revenue from contracts with customers. 2.2 Insurance income R million 2023 2022 Commissions, brokerage and profit share from third-party cells * 1 471 1 500 Insurance risk-related income 3 922 2 797 ‒ Insurance premiums received 6 528 5 416 ‒ Reinsurance expenses (895) (642) ‒ Insurance benefits and claims paid (2 448) (2 596) ‒ Reinsurance recoveries 531 484 ‒ Transfers from/(to) policyholder liabilities (gross) 225 (136) ‒ Transfers (to)/from policyholder liabilities (reinsurance) (19) 271 Insurance income 5 393 4 297 * Revenue from contracts with customers. -- 115 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B116- 2 NON-INTEREST REVENUE continued 2.3 Fair value gains or losses R million 2023 2022 Dividend income on preference shares held 2 087 1 559 Fair value income 6 464 5 276 Fair value gains or losses 8 551 6 835 2.4 Gains less losses from investing activities R million Notes 2023 2022 Gains on disposal of investment activities 715 132 ‒ Gains on disposal of debt instruments at amortised cost* 715 132 Impairment loss of debt investment securities at amortised cost * (716) (35) Reclassification from other comprehensive income on the derecognition/sale of assets FVOCI (11) 15 Preference share dividends from unlisted investments 124 39 Other dividends received 78 130 Gain on disposal of investments in subsidiaries 25 56 Gain/(loss) on disposal of investments in associates ** 1 246 (40) Gain on disposal of investments in joint ventures - 40 Fair value remeasurements on investment properties 20 (25) (19) Rental income from investment properties 20 88 81 Other gains from investing activities 4 116 Gains less losses from investing activities 1 528 515 * A gain of R715 million was recognised relating to the portion of the loan that was converted to equity. The portion not converted was settled resulting in a loss of R716 million, refer to note 16. ** Includes gain of R1 209 million on disposal of associate shown as held for sale per note 14 in the prior year and gain of R37 million on disposal of associate per note 16. 2.5 Other non-interest revenue R million 2023 2022 Revenue from contracts with customers* 1 769 1 279 ‒ Sales 2 639 2 212 ‒ Cost of sales (1 957) (1 641) ‒ Other income 1 087 708 (Loss)/gain on disposal of property and equipment (43) 8 Rental income ** 1 764 1 701 Other operating lease transactions 268 217 Other non-interest revenue 3 758 3 205 * Revenue from contracts with customers. ** Rental income mainly comprises operating lease income earned from vehicle financing arrangements and speedpoint rentals. -- 116 of 354 -- -B117- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES R million Notes 2023 2022 Auditors’ remuneration (594) (537) ‒ Audit fees (559) (483) ‒ Fees for other services (34) (47) ‒ Prior year under accrual (1) (7) Non-capitalised lease charges (535) (560) ‒ Short-term lease charge (401) (345) ‒ Low-value lease charge (213) (198) ‒ Variable lease charge * (12) (28) ‒ Early termination gains on lease * 91 11 Staff costs (42 336) (36 621) ‒ Salaries, wages and allowances (31 049) (27 319) ‒ Contributions to employee benefit funds (554) (479) ‒ Defined contribution schemes (417) (389) ‒ Defined benefit schemes 21.1 (137) (90) ‒ Social security levies (765) (706) ‒ Share-based payments 32 (2 433) (1 452) ‒ Movement in short-term employee benefit liabilities (6 081) (5 420) ‒ Other staff costs (1 454) (1 245) Other operating costs (25 284) (23 051) ‒ Amortisation of intangible assets 19 (676) (831) ‒ Depreciation of property and equipment 18 (4 045) (3 996) ‒ Impairments incurred (386) (322) ‒ Impairments reversed 17 12 ‒ Insurance (82) (115) ‒ Advertising and marketing (1 921) (1 827) ‒ Maintenance (1 568) (1 425) ‒ Property (1 370) (1 188) ‒ Computer (4 821) (4 199) ‒ Stationery, storage and delivery (277) (267) ‒ Telecommunications (602) (568) ‒ Professional fees (4 136) (3 056) ‒ Donations (340) (342) ‒ Assets costing less than R7 000 (229) (209) ‒ Business travel (488) (240) ‒ Profit share expenses (85) (120) ‒ Bank charges (110) (169) ‒ Legal fee expenses (661) (861) ‒ Entertainment (330) (211) ‒ Subscriptions and memberships (393) (256) ‒ Training expenses (342) (296) ‒ Other operating expenditure (2 439) (2 565) Total operating expenses (68 749) (60 769) * Variable lease charge reflected in the prior year as R17 million has been expanded to separately present early termination gains on leases in the current year. -- 117 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B118- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued Notable impairments incurred during 2023 Goodwill The carrying amount of both CGU’s included in the WesBank segment have been reduced to their recoverable amounts through the recognition of an impairment against goodwill of R223 million in total. The carrying amount a CGU included in the FNB broader Africa segment has been reduced to its recoverable amount through the recognition of an impairment against goodwill of R114 million. Notable impairments incurred during 2022 Goodwill The carrying amount of one CGU included in the WesBank segment has been reduced to its recoverable amount through the recognition of an impairment against goodwill of R60 million. Other Impairments incurred include R132 million impairment losses recognised on properties and equipment held by the group that have been reduced to their respective recoverable amounts. This impairment is included in the FNB segment. Impairments of R30 million was recognised on the Tanzania disposal group and included in the FNB broader Africa reportable segment. Furthermore, ECL of R89 million was raised on non-advances. -- 118 of 354 -- -B119- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued DIRECTORS’ AND PRESCRIBED OFFICERS’ EMOLUMENTS Information relating to director remuneration for the year under review and dealings in FirstRand shares are set out below. Non-executive directors’ remuneration 2023 2022 Services as directors Services as directors R thousand FirstRand Group Total FirstRand Group Total Independent non-executive directors WR Jardine 7 355 396 7 751 7 056 293 7 349 G Gelink 2 871 1 501 4 372 2 621 1 394 4 015 RM Loubser 3 176 2 204 5 380 2 907 1 907 4 814 TS Mashego (Resigned 1 December 2022) 668 421 1 089 1 502 304 1 806 PD Naidoo (appointed 1 April 2022) 1 081 74 1 155 239 - 239 L von Zeuner 2 686 720 3 406 2 647 723 3 370 T Winterboer 1 820 1 235 3 055 1 726 929 2 655 Z Roscherr 2 334 865 3 199 1 738 952 2 690 SP Sibisi 2 141 572 2 713 1 668 86 1 754 Non-executive directors JP Burger 2 281 937 3 218 2 341 877 3 218 F Knoetze (resigned at 2021 AGM) - - - 761 502 1 263 Total non-executive directors 26 413 8 925 35 338 25 206 7 967 33 173 -- 119 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B120- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued Directors’ and prescribed officers’ emoluments Single-figure reporting Cash package, retirement contributions and other allowances reflect what was paid to the prescribed officers during the year ended 30 June 2023. The FirstRand annual remuneration cycle runs from 1 August to 31 July. Short term incentives (STIs) reward both group and individual performance achieved during the year. STIs that exceed a certain threshold are deferred into cash and share price linked awards (eventual payments are linked to the share price). Long-term incentive (LTI) awards are made annually under the conditional incentive plan (CIP) and vesting is dependent on certain corporate targets being met on a cumulative basis over three years. The following analysis provides two amounts per individual to accommodate the King IV alternative single- figure view. For King IV single-figure reporting, the value presented is the LTI settled in the financial year at original award value. The explanation of the basis of preparation of the remuneration tables is disclosed in the FirstRand remuneration report. -- 120 of 354 -- -B121- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued R thousand 2023 2022 AP Pullinger (group CEO)¹ Cash package paid during the year 9 639 9 137 Retirement contributions paid during the year 211 191 Other allowances 320 294 Guaranteed package 10 170 9 622 Performance-related STI: Cash 8 476 7 912 – Within 6 months² 5 984 5 491 – Within 1 year 2 492 2 421 Share price linked – deferred 2 years (BDIP)³ 6 476 5 912 Variable pay 14 952 13 824 Total guaranteed and variable pay 25 122 23 446 Value of LTI awards allocated under the CIP during the financial year⁴ 26 330 24 840 Total reward including LTIs 51 452 48 286 Value of LTI awards allocated under the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁵ - - Single-figure reporting Total guaranteed and variable pay 25 122 23 446 Value of LTI awards settled under the CIP during the financial year⁶ - - Value of LTI awards settled under the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁷ 6 424 6 424 Total reward including settled LTIs (single figure) 31 546 29 870 M Vilakazi (group COO)¹ Cash package paid during the year 8 069 7 596 Retirement contributions paid during the year 162 141 Other allowances 209 193 Guaranteed package 8 440 7 930 Performance-related STI: Cash 6 913 6 407 – Within 6 months² 4 942 4 488 – Within 1 year 1 971 1 919 Share price linked – deferred 2 years (BDIP)³ 4 912 4 406 Variable pay 11 825 10 813 Total guaranteed and variable pay 20 265 18 743 Value of LTI awards allocated under the CIP during the financial year⁴ 15 120 14 000 Total reward including LTIs 35 385 32 743 Value of LTI awards allocated the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁵ - - Single-figure reporting Total guaranteed and variable pay 20 265 18 743 Value of LTI awards settled under the CIP during the financial year⁶ - - Value of LTI awards settled under the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁷ 5 546 5 546 Total reward including settled LTIs (single figure) 25 811 24 289 -- 121 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B122- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued R thousand 2023 2022 HS Kellan (group financial director)1 Cash package paid during the year 8 661 8 182 Retirement contributions paid during the year 71 67 Other allowances 236 193 Guaranteed package 8 968 8 442 Performance-related STI: Cash 7 363 6 837 – Within 6 months² 5 242 4 775 – Within 1 year 2 121 2 062 Share price linked – deferred 2 years (BDIP)³ 5 363 4 838 Variable pay 12 726 11 675 Total guaranteed and variable pay 21 694 20 117 Value of LTI awards allocated under the CIP during the financial year⁴ 16 960 16 000 Total reward including LTIs 38 654 36 117 Value of LTI awards allocated under the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁵ - - Single-figure reporting Total guaranteed and variable pay 21 694 20 117 Value of LTI awards settled under the CIP during the financial year⁶ - - Value of LTI awards settled under the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁷ 4 240 4 240 Total reward including settled LTIs (single figure) 25 934 24 357 J Celliers (CEO FNB)¹ Cash package paid during the year 8 249 7 838 Retirement contributions paid during the year 165 149 Other allowances 287 246 Guaranteed package 8 701 8 233 Performance-related STI: Cash 10 109 9 357 – Within 6 months² 7 073 6 455 – Within 1 year 3 036 2 902 Share price linked – deferred 2 years (BDIP)³ 8 109 7 357 Variable pay 18 218 16 714 Total guaranteed and variable pay 26 919 24 947 Value of LTI awards allocated under the CIP during the financial year⁴ 17 664 16 664 Total reward including LTIs 44 583 41 611 Value of LTI awards allocated under the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁵ - - Single-figure reporting Total guaranteed and variable pay 26 919 24 947 Value of LTI awards settled under the CIP during the financial year⁶ - - Value of LTI awards settled under the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁷ 5 003 5 003 Total reward including settled LTIs (single figure) 31 922 29 950 -- 122 of 354 -- -B123- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued R thousand 2023 2022 E Brown (CEO RMB)¹ , ⁸ Cash package paid during the year 7 025 - Retirement contributions paid during the year 116 - Other allowances 61 - Guaranteed package 7 202 - Performance-related STI: Cash 10 550 - – Within 6 months² 7 367 - – Within 1 year 3 183 - Share price linked – deferred 2 years (BDIP)³ 8 550 - Variable pay 19 100 - Total guaranteed and variable pay 26 302 - Value of LTI awards allocated under the CIP during the financial year⁴ 12 500 - Total reward including LTIs 38 802 - Value of LTI awards allocated under the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁵ - - Single-figure reporting Total guaranteed and variable pay 26 302 - Value of LTI awards settled under the CIP during the financial year⁶ - - Value of LTI awards settled under the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁷ 1 175 - Total reward including settled LTIs (single figure) 27 477 - J Formby (CEO RMB)⁹ Cash package paid during the year 1 775 6 793 Retirement contributions paid during the year 24 88 Other allowances 44 177 Guaranteed package 1 843 7 058 Performance-related STI: Cash - 11 258 – Within 6 months² - 7 722 – Within 1 year - 3 536 Share price linked – deferred 2 years (BDIP)³ - 9 258 Variable pay - 20 516 Total guaranteed and variable pay 1 843 27 574 Value of LTI awards allocated under the CIP during the financial year⁴ 13 780 13 000 Total reward including LTIs 15 623 40 574 Value of LTI awards allocated under the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁵ - - Single-figure reporting Total guaranteed and variable pay 1 843 27 574 Value of LTI awards settled under the CIP during the financial year⁶ - - Value of LTI awards settled under the Covid-19 scheme during the financial year⁷ 2 900 2 900 Total reward including settled LTIs (single figure) 4 743 30 474 -- 123 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B124- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued £ thousand 2023 2022 S Cooper (Aldermore CEO)¹ Cash package paid during the year 757 730 Retirement contributions paid during the year 52 50 Other allowances 277 268 Guaranteed package 1 086 1 048 Performance-related STI: Cash 335 276 – Within 6 months¹⁰ 335 276 – Within 1 year - - Share price linked – deferred¹¹ 827 591 Variable pay 1 162 867 Total guaranteed and variable pay 2 248 1 915 Value of LTI awards allocated under the CIP during the financial year⁴, ¹² 282 542 Total reward including LTIs 2 530 2 457 Single-figure reporting Total guaranteed and variable pay 2 248 1 915 Value of LTI awards settled under the CIP during the financial year⁶ - - Total reward including settled LTIs (single figure) 2 248 1 915 -- 124 of 354 -- -B125- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued 1 FirstRand defines its prescribed officers as the group’s executive directors, and the CEOs of the group’s Retail and Commercial, and Corporate and Institutional segments, as well as the CEO of the Aldermore Group. These officers are members of the group strategic executive committee and attend board meetings. 2 Variable compensation (STI), paid in cash in respect of the year ended June, is paid in three tranches during the following year ending on 30 June, i.e. August, December and June (with interest on the deferred payments). 3 A portion of variable compensation is deferred as share price linked awards and vests after two years. Previously vesting was split equally over two and three years for the executive directors and prescribed officers (2019 and 2020). 4 Long-term incentive awards are made annually under the CIP. Vesting is subject to performance conditions and targets on a cumulative basis over three years. The value presented in the table is the LTI allocated in the financial year and is reflected at award value at grant date. Refer to note 32. 5 The Covid-19 retention instrument was awarded in September 2020. The award is linked to the FirstRand share price and vests in three equal proportions (tranches) over three years (September 2021, 2022 and 2023), if performance conditions are met. 6 For King IV single-figure reporting, the value presented in the table is the LTI vested and settled in the financial year at original award value. It is zero if conditions are not met and awards are forfeited. 7 For King IV single-figure reporting, the value presented in the table under the Covid-19 scheme is the LTI vested and settled at original award value in the financial year. It is zero if conditions are not met and awards are forfeited. 8 Emrie Brown was RMB CEO effective 1 October 2022. 9 James Formby was no longer a prescribed officer effective 1 October 2022, therefore his guaranteed package disclosed is for three months only. 10 The Aldermore performance-related STI cash component is paid in full in August. 11 The Aldermore performance-related STI share price linked component is released in equal annual tranches over the deferral period required by Capital Requirements Directive 5 (CRD V) regulations. 12 The Aldermore LTI allocated amount is the on-target value assumed at 55% of maximum. The LTI is a 50% share price linked award and 50% deferred cash award. -- 125 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B126- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued All executive directors and prescribed officers in South Africa have a notice period of one month. Steven Cooper has a notice period of six months. Non-executive directors are appointed for a period of three years and are subject to the Companies Act, 71 of 2008 provision relating to removal. Ownership of FirstRand Bank Limited FRB is a wholly owned subsidiary of FSR. Covid-19 instrument for executive directors and prescribed officers The Covid-19 health crisis and the resulting economic impact have been evident in FirstRand’s results. This impact has resulted in the 2017, 2018 and 2019 LTI not vesting. In September 2020, Remco introduced a one- off Covid-19 instrument that caters for the retention of employees considered critical to the ongoing sustainability of the business. The value of the Covid-19 instrument was struck at half of the original value of the 2018 and 2019 LTIs and is linked to the FirstRand share price. For FirstRand executive directors and prescribed officers, the award vests in three equal proportions (tranches) over three years (September 2021, 2022 and 2023), if performance conditions are met, including both financial and risk elements. The financial conditions are linked to the group’s ROE being within the target range. In September 2021 and 2022 the first and second Covid-19 tranche vested as the 2018 and 2019 LTI award failed, respectively. Should an employee who receives this award resign within 12 months of a tranche of the award vesting, they will be required to repay the full amount of the vested tranche. Thereby the instrument represents a retention period of up to four-years. At 30 June 2023, the outstanding portion of the Covid-19 award is the last tranche, which will vest in September 2023. Refer to the prescribed officers’ outstanding incentives table on page B128 for details. -- 126 of 354 -- -B127- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued Long-term executive management retention scheme LTEMRS 1 participation award made in December 2016 Designation Awards (thousand) Executive directors AP Pullinger 188 HS Kellan 563 Prescribed officers J Celliers 469 1 In addition to the group’s existing long-term incentive plan, and in order to better align executive interests with those of the group’s shareholders, the group introduced a long-term executive management retention scheme (LTEMRS) in December 2016. This is a five-year scheme in which members of the group’s strategic committee were eligible to participate, on a voluntary basis, by purchasing a predetermined fixed number of participation awards. Participants paid an upfront cash deposit of 10% for their predetermined fixed number of participation awards, with the balance being funded by the group through a facilitated mechanism. The fixed number for each participant was converted into a number of participation awards, determined by the share price of R53.33, being the three-day volume-weighted average price of the FirstRand share price at the date of award, being 15 December 2016. The scheme and the funding mechanism ensure that participants have full risk and potential reward of their participation awards (downside risk and upside potential). Continued employment is a condition for vesting of the cash settled scheme. Early termination before the expiry of three full years of service carries the full cost of early termination, including a full forfeit of any potential benefit, with a sliding scale of forfeiture being applied in years four and five. No cost to the group is associated with the LTEMRS as the scheme is economically hedged. In the 2020 financial year, Remco approved a two-year extension of the scheme, from the original vesting date of September 2021 to September 2023. If the participant leaves after September 2020 but before the amended vesting date of September 2023, the participant will forfeit 20% of the upside of the scheme and carry 100% downside risk in line with the scheme. The extension of the scheme is considered an amendment of terms and therefore an increased rate, linked to the real interest rate, has been applied to the outstanding funding. Prescribed officers’ outstanding incentives The outstanding incentive disclosure has been prepared in the format required by King IV. King IV reporting requires disclosure of the number of units of outstanding incentive schemes, the value of outstanding incentive schemes and value on settlement. The explanation of the basis of preparation of the remuneration tables is disclosed in the FirstRand remuneration report. -- 127 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B128- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued Value at grant date Issue date R thousand Settlement date AP Pullinger Deferred share price linked STI awards 2019 (3-year deferral) September 2019 5 100 September 2022 2020 (2-year deferral) September 2020 1 912 September 2022 2020 (3-year deferral) September 2020 1 913 September 2023 2021 (2-year deferral) September 2021 5 032 September 2023 2022 (2-year deferral) September 2022 5 912 September 2024 2023 (2-year deferral) September 2023 6 475 September 2025 Balance deferred share price linked STIs 26 344 LTI awards under the CIP⁵ 2019 September 2019 20 046 September 2022 2020 September 2020 24 000 September 2023 2021 September 2021 24 840 September 2024 2022 September 2022 26 330 September 2025 Balance LTIs 95 216 LTI awards under the Covid-19 scheme⁶ 2020 September 2020 6 424 September 2022 2020 September 2020 6 425 September 2023 Balance Covid-19 award 12 849 M Vilakazi Deferred share price linked STI awards 2019 (3-year deferral) September 2019 1 938 September 2022 2020 (2-year deferral) September 2020 1 012 September 2022 2020 (3-year deferral) September 2020 1 013 September 2023 2021 (2-year deferral) September 2021 3 325 September 2023 2022 (2-year deferral) September 2022 4 406 September 2024 2023 (2-year deferral) September 2023 4 912 September 2025 Balance deferred share price linked STIs 16 606 LTI awards under the CIP⁵ 2019 September 2019 10 775 September 2022 2020 September 2020 11 184 September 2023 2021 September 2021 14 000 September 2024 2022 September 2022 15 120 September 2025 Balance LTIs 51 079 LTI awards under the Covid-19 scheme⁶ 2020 September 2020 5 546 September 2022 2020 September 2020 5 546 September 2023 Balance Covid-19 award 11 092 -- 128 of 354 -- -B129- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued Units Number Number Closing Value on of awards of awards number of settlement Opening Awards made settled in forfeited awards² , ³ in 2023⁴ balance during year¹ year in year 30 Jun 2023 R thousand 78 221 - (78 221) - - 5 573 48 738 - (48 738) - - 3 182 48 738 - - - 48 738 - 81 658 - - - 81 658 - 95 234 - - - 95 234 - - - - - - - 352 589 - (126 959) - 225 630 8 755 307 455 - - (307 455) - - 611 621 - - - 611 621 - 403 156 - - - 403 156 - - 424 137 - - 424 137 - 1 322 232 424 137 - (307 455) 1 438 914 - 163 719 - (163 719) - - 10 164 163 719 - - - 163 719 - 327 438 - (163 719) - 163 719 10 164 29 716 - (29 716) - - 2 117 25 802 - (25 802) - - 1 685 25 802 - - - 25 802 - 53 965 - - - 53 965 - 70 977 - - - 70 977 - - - - - - - 206 262 - (55 518) - 150 744 3 802 165 261 - - (165 261) - - 285 015 - - - 285 015 - 227 221 - - - 227 221 - - 243 557 - - 243 557 - 677 497 243 557 - (165 261) 755 793 - 141 331 - (141 331) - - 8 774 141 331 - - - 141 331 - 282 662 - (141 331) - 141 331 8 774 -- 129 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B130- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued Value at grant date Issue date R thousand Settlement date HS Kellan Deferred share price linked STI awards 2019 (3-year deferral) September 2019 2 084 September 2022 2020 (2-year deferral) September 2020 1 150 September 2022 2020 (3-year deferral) September 2020 1 150 September 2023 2021 (2-year deferral) September 2021 3 750 September 2023 2022 (2-year deferral) September 2022 4 838 September 2024 2023 (2-year deferral) September 2023 5 362 September 2025 Balance deferred share price linked STIs 18 334 LTI awards under the CIP⁵ 2019 September 2019 13 440 September 2022 2020 September 2020 13 950 September 2023 2021 September 2021 16 000 September 2024 2022 September 2022 16 960 September 2025 Balance LTIs 60 350 LTI awards under the Covid-19 scheme⁶ 2020 September 2021 4 240 September 2022 2020 September 2021 4 240 September 2023 Balance Covid-19 award 8 480 J Celliers Deferred share price linked STI awards 2019 (3-year deferral) September 2019 3 144 September 2022 2020 (2-year deferral) September 2020 2 075 September 2022 2020 (3-year deferral) September 2020 2 075 September 2023 2021 (2-year deferral) September 2021 5 850 September 2023 2022 (2-year deferral) September 2022 7 357 September 2024 2023 (2-year deferral) September 2023 8 109 September 2025 Balance deferred share price linked STIs 28 610 LTI awards under the CIP⁵ 2019 September 2019 15 515 September 2022 2020 September 2020 16 100 September 2023 2021 September 2021 16 664 September 2024 2022 September 2022 17 663 September 2025 Balance LTIs 65 942 LTI awards under the Covid-19 scheme⁶ 2020 September 2021 5 003 September 2022 2020 September 2021 5 003 September 2023 Balance Covid-19 award 10 006 -- 130 of 354 -- -B131- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued Units Number Number Closing Value on of awards of awards number of settlement Opening Awards made settled in forfeited awards² , ³ in 2023⁴ balance during year¹ year in year 30 Jun 2023 R thousand 31 959 - (31 959) - - 2 277 29 306 - (29 306) - - 1 914 29 306 - - - 29 306 - 60 863 - - - 60 863 - 77 924 - - - 77 924 - - - - - - - 229 358 - (61 265) - 168 093 4 191 206 136 - - (206 136) - - 355 530 - - - 355 530 - 259 682 - - - 259 682 - - 273 196 - - 273 196 - 821 348 273 196 - (206 136) 888 408 - 108 053 - (108 053) - - 6 708 108 053 - - - 108 053 - 216 106 - (108 053) - 108 053 6 708 48 217 - (48 217) - - 3 435 52 880 - (52 880) - - 3 453 52 880 - - - 52 880 - 94 946 - - - 94 946 - 118 508 - - - 118 508 - - - - - - - 367 431 - (101 097) - 266 334 6 888 237 961 - - (237 961) - - 410 296 - - - 410 296 - 270 458 - - - 270 458 - - 284 534 - - 284 534 - 918 715 284 534 - (237 961) 965 288 - 127 485 - (127 485) - - 7 914 127 484 - - - 127 484 - 254 969 - (127 485) - 127 484 7 914 -- 131 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B132- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued Value at grant date Issue date R thousand Settlement date E Brown Deferred share price linked STI awards 2020 (2-year deferral) September 2020 4 650 September 2022 2021 (2-year deferral) September 2021 6 350 September 2023 2022 (2-year deferral) September 2022 8 375 September 2024 2023 (2-year deferral) September 2023 8 550 September 2025 Balance deferred share price linked STIs 27 925 LTI awards under the CIP⁶ 2019 September 2019 3 600 September 2022 2020 September 2020 8 000 September 2023 2021 September 2021 8 400 September 2024 2022 September 2022 12 500 September 2025 Balance LTIs 32 500 LTI awards under the Covid-19 scheme⁷ 2020 September 2020 1 175 September 2022 2020 September 2020 1 175 September 2023 Balance Covid-19 award 2 350 S Cooper (£ thousand) Deferred share price linked STI awards⁷ 2021 (3-year deferral) September 2021 32 September 2022-2024 2022 (7-year deferral) September 2022 591 September 2023-2025 2023 (7-year deferral) September 2023 827 September 2024-2026 Balance deferred share price linked STIs 1 450 LTI awards under the CIP⁸ 2020 September 2020 - September 2023 2021 September 2021 542 September 2024 2022 September 2022 282 September 2025 Balance LTIs 824 -- 132 of 354 -- -B133- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued Units⁸ Number Number Closing Value on of awards of awards number of settlement Opening Awards made settled in forfeited awards² , ³ in 2023⁴ balance during year¹ year in year 30 Jun 2023 R thousand 118 502 - (118 502) - - 7 738 103 061 - - - 103 061 - 134 907 - - - 134 907 - - - - - - - 356 470 - (118 502) - 237 968 7 738 55 215 - - (55 215) - - 203 874 - - - 203 874 - 136 333 - - - 136 333 - - 201 353 - - 201 353 - 395 422 201 353 - (55 215) 541 560 - 29 944 - (29 944) - - 1 859 29 944 - - - 29 944 - 59 888 - (29 944) - 29 944 1 859 - - - - - 11 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 11 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 11 -- 133 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B134- 3 OPERATING EXPENSES continued 1 FirstRand share price linked schemes are determined on monetary value and not on the number of shares. The allocation of deferred share price linked STI awards is determined after year end, using the average three-day volume- weighted average price (VWAP) eight days after the results announcement. This means that the number of deferred share price linked STI award units allocated in 2023 is only calculated after the annual financial statements are issued. 2 Deferred share price linked STI awards vesting depends on continued employment over two years. Previously vesting was split equally over two and three years for the executive directors and prescribed officers (2019 and 2020). 3 FirstRand does not apply graded vesting to LTI awards allocated before September 2019, with awards thereafter having graded vesting. For these incentive schemes, LTI vesting depends on performance conditions and targets being met on a cumulative basis over three years. The group does not apply a probability of vesting to the unvested awards and the assumption is 100% vesting up until the final remuneration committee decision, given the current environment and uncertainty in quantifying the probability of vesting. For information purposes, the maximum possible value of the unvested awards as at June 2023 is the market value of the total number of shares at R68.50 per share on the last trading day of the financial year (30 June 2023). 4 The values at settlement date include share price growth and interest earned (deferred share price linked STI awards) from grant date. 5 The 2019 LTIs failed based on the performance conditions not being met on a cumulative three-year basis, up to 30 June 2022. As such the second tranche of the Covid-19 instrument vested and was settled in September 2022, with the performance conditions being tested as at June 2023 (clawback was not applied, as the Covid-19 award performance conditions were met). 6 The Covid-19 retention instrument was awarded in September 2020. The value was converted to share price linked instruments on the award date and will vest in equal proportions (tranches) over three years (September 2021, 2022 and 2023) if the performance conditions are met. 7 The Aldermore performance-related STI share price linked component is released in equal annual tranches over the deferral period required by CRD V regulations. 8 Aldermore incentive awards are not convertible into units. -- 134 of 354 -- -B135- 4 INDIRECT AND INCOME TAX EXPENSE R million 2023 2022 4.1 Indirect tax Value-added tax (net) (1 595) (1 420) Securities transfer tax (24) (10) Other (13) (3) Total indirect tax (1 632) (1 433) 4.2 Income tax expense South African income tax Current (9 354) (10 291) ‒ Current year (9 425) (9 664) ‒ Prior year adjustment 71 (627) Deferred income tax 260 954 ‒ Current year 618 616 ‒ Prior year adjustment (358) 338 Total South African income tax (9 094) (9 337) Foreign company and withholding tax Current (2 642) (2 659) ‒ Current year (2 671) (2 651) ‒ Prior year adjustment 29 (8) Deferred income tax (122) 136 ‒ Current year (83) 138 ‒ Prior year adjustment (39) (2) Total foreign company and withholding tax (2 764) (2 523) South African capital gains tax (323) (69) ‒ Current (345) - ‒ Deferred capital gains tax 22 (69) Total capital gains tax (323) (69) Customer tax adjustment account (15) (1) Change in tax rate adjustment - (262) Withholding tax on dividends - (1) Total income tax expense (12 196) (12 193) In the prior year, the corporate income tax rate was lowered to 27% for companies with years of assessment commencing on or after 1 April 2022. The group viewed this change in tax rate as substantively enacted from the time that it was announced by the Minister of Finance. The group calculated the year-end deferred tax balances at 27% for the current and prior year. -- 135 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B136- 4 INDIRECT AND INCOME TAX EXPENSE continued Tax rate reconciliation % 2023 2022 Standard rate of income tax 27.0 28.0 Total tax has been affected by: Dividend and other exempt income (2.9) (2.7) Other non-taxable income * (0.6) (0.4) Rate difference (1.1) (0.5) Prior year adjustments 0.6 0.7 Tax difference on associates (0.2) (0.6) Tax difference on joint ventures (0.1) (0.4) Disallowed expenditure ** 1.0 1.7 Other 0.3 0.2 Effective rate of tax 24.0 26.0 * The majority of other non-taxable income relates to non-taxable translation (gains)/losses on preference shares. ** The majority of the disallowed expense relates to non-recoverable expenses from foreign operations that are non-deductible. 5 HEADLINE EARNINGS, EARNINGS AND DIVIDENDS PER SHARE Earnings attributable R million Cents per share Notes 2023 2022 2023 2022 Headline earnings ‒ Basic 5.2 36 735 32 817 655.3 585.3 ‒ Diluted 5.2 36 735 32 817 655.3 585.3 Earnings attributable to ordinary equityholders ‒ Basic 5.2 36 366 32 761 648.7 584.3 ‒ Diluted 5.2 36 366 32 761 648.7 584.3 Dividends – ordinary ‒ Interim paid 189.0 157.0 ‒ Final declared/paid 195.0 185.0 Special dividend - 125.0 Dividends – preference * ‒ Interim paid 52.2 270.7 ‒ Final declared/paid - 307.4 * On 25 August 2022, the group’s ordinary and preference shareholders approved the repurchase of FirstRand’s preference shares at par. The scheme consideration, which included the final pro rata preference dividends, was paid on 26 September 2022 and the listing was terminated on 27 September 2022. -- 136 of 354 -- -B137- 5 HEADLINE EARNINGS, EARNINGS AND DIVIDENDS PER SHARE continued 5.1 Weighted average number of shares 2023 2022 Weighted average number of shares before treasury shares 5 609 488 001 5 609 488 001 Less: treasury shares (3 768 649) (2 751 213) ‒ Shares for client trading (3 768 649) (2 751 213) Weighted average number of shares in issue 5 605 719 352 5 606 736 788 Diluted weighted average number of shares in issue 5 605 719 352 5 606 736 788 The same weighted average number of shares was used for the basic and diluted headline earnings per share (HEPS) and basic and diluted earnings per share (EPS) as there are no potential dilutive ordinary shares in issue. 5.2 Headline earnings reconciliation 2023 2022 R million Gross Net Gross Net Earnings attributable to ordinary equityholders 36 366 32 761 Adjusted for: Impairment of non-private equity associates - - 25 25 Gain on disposal of investments in subsidiaries (25) (25) (56) (56) Loss/(gain) on disposal of property and equipment 43 36 (8) (8) Compensation from third parties for impaired/lost property and equipment - - (109) (78) Impairment of goodwill 342 295 60 49 Fair value movement on investment properties 25 18 19 15 Impairment of assets in terms of IAS 36 61 45 136 112 Other - - (3) (3) Headline earnings attributable to ordinary equityholders 36 735 32 817 -- 137 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B138- 6 ANALYSIS OF ASSETS AND LIABILITIES 6.1 Analysis of assets The following table analyses the assets in the statement of financial position per category of financial instrument, according to measurement basis and in order of when the assets are expected to be realised. 2023 At fair value through profit Amortised or loss R million Notes cost Mandatory Designated ASSETS Cash and cash equivalents 7 175 304 - - Derivative financial instruments 8 - 65 389 - Investment securities* 10 226 135 128 708 9 578 Advances 11 1 409 450 117 794 12 131 Other assets 13 8 749 - - Non-current assets and disposal groups held for sale 14 793 - - Non-financial assets - - - Total assets 1 820 431 311 891 21 709 2022 ** Cash and cash equivalents 7 143 636 - - Derivative financial instruments 8 - 57 041 - Investment securities * 10 162 485 159 802 8 436 Advances 11 1 238 641 86 800 8 883 Other assets ** 13 6 215 - - Non-current assets and disposal groups held for sale 14 659 - - Non-financial assets - - - Total assets (restated) 1 551 636 303 643 17 319 * All non-recourse investments are included in the investment securities balance held at mandatory FVTPL. ** Refer to Accounting Policy note 10.1 for restatement of other assets and creditors, accruals and provisions and Note 38 Impact of changes in presentation. -- 138 of 354 -- -B139- 6 ANALYSIS OF ASSETS AND LIABILITIES 6.1 Analysis of assets The following table analyses the assets in the statement of financial position per category of financial instrument, according to measurement basis and in order of when the assets are expected to be realised. 2023 At fair value through Derivatives Non- other comprehensive designated Non- Total current and income as hedging financial carrying non- Debt Equity instruments instruments value Current contractual - - - - 175 304 175 304 - - - 20 567 - 85 956 71 803 14 153 54 333 385 - - 419 140 219 650 199 490 - - - - 1 539 375 465 069 1 074 306 - - - (4 989) 3 760 6 560 (2 800) - - - 566 1 359 1 359 - - - - 72 716 72 716 18 620 54 096 54 333 385 20 567 68 293 2 297 610 958 365 1 339 245 2022** - - - - 143 636 143 636 - - - 8 626 - 65 667 55 444 10 223 51 082 344 - - 382 149 224 243 157 906 - - - - 1 334 324 427 300 907 024 - - - (1 451) 4 764 4 610 154 - - - 842 1 501 1 501 - - - - 67 528 67 528 18 615 48 913 51 082 344 8 626 66 919 1 999 569 875 349 1 124 220 -- 139 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B140- 6 ANALYSIS OF ASSETS AND LIABILITIES continued 6.2 Analysis of liabilities The following table analyses the liabilities in the statement of financial position per category of financial instrument, according to measurement basis and in order of when the liabilities are expected to be settled. 2023 At fair value through profit Amortised or loss R million Notes cost Mandatory Designated LIABILITIES Short trading positions 23 - 12 753 - Derivative financial instruments 8 - 68 909 - Creditors, accruals and provisions 24 30 015 - - Liabilities directly associated with disposal groups held for sale 14 - - - Deposits 25 1 863 525 49 012 10 566 Other liabilities 26 3 923 - 84 Policyholder liabilities 15 - - 6 383 Tier 2 liabilities 27 16 869 - - Non-financial liabilities - - - Total liabilities 1 914 332 130 674 17 033 2022* Short trading positions 23 - 14 623 - Derivative financial instruments 8 - 63 672 - Creditors, accruals and provisions * 24 19 479 - - Liabilities directly associated with disposal groups held for sale 14 747 - - Deposits 25 1 602 414 37 587 15 971 Other liabilities 26 5 343 - 71 Policyholder liabilities 15 - - 5 396 Tier 2 liabilities 27 20 937 - - Non-financial liabilities - - - Total liabilities 1 648 920 115 882 21 438 * Refer to Accounting Policy note 10.1 for restatement of other assets and creditors, accruals and provisions and Note 38 Impact of changes in presentation. -- 140 of 354 -- -B141- 2023 Derivatives designated Non- Total Non-current as hedging financial carrying and non- instruments instruments value Current contractual - - 12 753 12 753 - 1 445 - 70 354 69 662 692 - 13 374 43 389 35 334 8 055 - - - - - - - 1 923 103 1 674 928 248 175 - 3 026 7 033 2 068 4 965 - 1 748 8 131 2 839 5 292 - - 16 869 1 924 14 945 - 18 297 18 297 10 830 7 467 1 445 36 445 2 099 929 1 810 338 289 591 2022* - - 14 623 14 623 - 875 - 64 547 57 412 7 135 - 11 449 30 928 24 390 6 538 - 77 824 824 - - - 1 655 972 1 429 957 226 015 - 2 834 8 248 4 859 3 389 - 2 028 7 424 2 601 4 823 - - 20 937 12 160 8 777 - 15 357 15 357 7 557 7 800 875 31 745 1 818 860 1 554 383 264 477 -- 141 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B142- 7 CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS Restated R million 2023 2022 Coins and bank notes 11 094 11 711 Money at call and short notice * 107 373 95 498 Balances with central banks 56 837 36 427 Mandatory reserve balances with central banks 40 958 34 521 Other balances with central banks * 15 879 1 906 Total cash and cash equivalents** 175 304 143 636 * Other balances with central banks and money at call and short notice was restated in the prior year from R19 631 million to R1 906 million and from R77 773 million to R95 498 million respectively, resulting from a review and subsequently alignment of the line definitions applied by businesses across the group to these respective lines. ** ECL for physical cash is zero. ECL for cash equivalents is calculated using the loss rate approach and is immaterial. Banks across the group are required to deposit a minimum average balance, calculated monthly, with their respective central bank, which is available for use by the group subject to certain restrictions and limitations levelled by the central banks within the countries of operation. These deposits bear little or no interest. 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS Use of derivatives The group transacts in derivatives for two purposes: to create risk management solutions for clients and to manage and hedge the group’s own risk. The group’s derivative activities give rise to open positions in portfolios of derivatives. These positions are managed constantly to ensure that they remain within acceptable risk levels, with offsetting deals being utilised to achieve this where necessary. Derivative instruments are classified either as held for trading or formally designated as hedging instruments. The group applies IFRS 9 for cash flow and fair value micro hedges. IAS 39 is applied to portfolio hedges, which the group refers to as macro hedges, to which fair value hedge accounting has been applied. For further details on the valuation of derivatives refer to note 34. Qualifying for hedge accounting Where all required criteria are met, derivatives are classified as qualifying for hedge accounting. Hedge accounting is applied to remove the accounting mismatch between the derivative (hedging instrument) and the underlying hedged item. All qualifying hedging relationships are designated as either fair value or cash flow hedges. The group applies hedge accounting in respect of specified interest rate risk and equity price risk detailed in this note. The group defines interest rate risk in the banking book (IRRBB) as the sensitivity of the statement of financial position and income statement to unexpected adverse movements in interest rates. IRRBB and equity price risks are managed by Group Treasury and the FirstRand asset, liability and capital committee (ALCCO) under approved policies. Aldermore manages its interest rate risk through its own treasury department and ALCCO. For further details on the group’s approach to managing interest rate risk and market risk, refer to note 37. IRRBB is expected within a banking operation and can be an important source of profitability and shareholder value. It is therefore managed from an earnings approach, with the aim to protect and enhance NII. Therefore, both fair value and cash flow hedge accounting are applied to provide a better reflection of how IRRBB is managed in profit or loss. -- 142 of 354 -- -B143- 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued Qualifying for hedge accounting continued The group is exposed to equity price risk through its obligation under its employee share incentive schemes, the future cash outflows of which are directly impacted by changes in FirstRand Limited’s share price. This equity price risk is managed by purchasing equity derivatives which mitigate the exposure to variability in cash outflows as a result of FirstRand’s share price. Cash flow hedge accounting is employed to provide a better reflection of how equity price risk is managed in profit or loss. IFRS 9 does not specify a method for assessing hedge effectiveness. The group uses the regression analysis approach to quantitively assess hedge effectiveness for all the cash flow and fair value hedges and it considers this approach to accurately capture the characteristics of the hedging relationships and sources of ineffectiveness. The hedge effectiveness results are assessed against the effectiveness range of 80% and 125%. Even though this quantitative measure is not required under IFRS 9, the group believes that this is a benchmark which has been extensively used in the past and is a prudent approach to determining the effectiveness of the hedge relationship in line with the group’s risk management strategy. Held for trading activities Most of the group’s derivative transactions relate to sales activities. Sales activities include the structuring and marketing of derivative products to customers to enable them to take on, transfer, modify or reduce current or expected risks. The following tables reflect the notional and fair values of the derivative instruments that qualify for hedge accounting or are held for trading. The notional amounts for derivative instruments qualifying for fair value hedge accounting include macro hedging portfolios. Derivative financial instruments – assets 2023 2022 R million Notional Fair value Notional Fair value Qualifying for hedge accounting 426 230 20 567 362 720 8 626 Fair value hedge accounting 244 380 17 242 183 925 6 732 ‒ Interest rate derivatives * 244 380 17 242 183 925 6 732 Cash flow hedge accounting 181 850 3 325 178 795 1 894 ‒ Interest rate derivatives * 174 322 1 216 176 632 623 ‒ Equity derivatives 7 528 2 109 2 163 1 271 Held for trading 11 365 703 65 389 4 928 241 57 041 ‒ Currency derivatives 321 084 14 765 293 955 13 375 ‒ Interest rate derivatives * 10 942 087 44 857 4 527 122 36 878 ‒ Equity derivatives 69 434 3 845 57 443 2 357 ‒ Commodity derivatives 27 330 1 731 26 220 1 184 ‒ Energy derivatives 480 59 10 551 3 154 ‒ Credit derivatives 5 288 132 12 950 93 Total derivative assets 11 791 933 85 956 5 290 961 65 667 Exchange traded 15 815 290 38 548 474 Over the counter 11 776 118 85 666 5 252 413 65 193 Total derivative assets 11 791 933 85 956 5 290 961 65 667 * Includes derivatives cleared by central clearing counterparty and whose fair value is reflected on a net basis , although the notional continues to be reflected on a gross basis. -- 143 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B144- 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued Derivative financial instruments – liabilities 2023 2022 R million Notional Fair value Notional Fair value Qualifying for hedge accounting 454 267 1 445 404 484 875 Fair value hedge accounting 124 573 750 85 853 444 ‒ Interest rate derivatives * 124 573 750 85 853 444 Cash flow hedge accounting 329 694 695 318 631 431 ‒ Interest rate derivatives * 329 694 695 316 181 371 ‒ Equity derivatives - - 2 450 60 Held for trading 11 695 263 68 909 4 742 815 63 672 ‒ Currency derivatives 297 827 17 546 275 755 18 288 ‒ Interest rate derivatives * 11 312 700 47 945 4 387 294 39 783 ‒ Equity derivatives 69 949 2 789 63 386 3 331 ‒ Commodity derivatives 10 616 507 2 945 587 ‒ Energy derivatives 508 54 7 419 1 526 ‒ Credit derivatives 3 663 68 6 016 157 Total derivative liabilities 12 149 530 70 354 5 147 299 64 547 Exchange traded 41 068 149 12 003 205 Over the counter 12 108 462 70 205 5 135 296 64 342 Total derivative liabilities 12 149 530 70 354 5 147 299 64 547 * Includes derivatives cleared by central clearing counterparty and whose fair value is reflected on a net basis, although the notional continues to be reflected on a gross basis. Fair value hedges Interest rate risk The group defines interest rate risk, to which fair value hedge accounting is applied, as the potential variations in NII due to the group issuing portfolios of fixed-rate long-dated term financial liabilities and holding investment securities, as well as fixed-rate advances, which may result from: x mismatches in the repricing of assets and liabilities; x increases or decreases in the absolute levels of interest rates and/or changes in the shape of the term structure of interest rates when applied to the group’s balance sheet; and x behavioural uncertainties of the underlying hedged item, for example increased defaults, prepayments or early deposit withdrawals. Where a hedging relationship involves government bonds classified at FVOCI as the designated hedged item, the hedged risk is the change in the fair value due to changes in the benchmark interest rate. However, only the benchmark interest rate component of the coupon cash flows plus the principal are designated as the hedged item. The interest rate swap curve is regarded as the best indicator of the interest rate risk and as such the benchmark interest rate is obtained from the interest rate swap curve denominated in the exposure’s currency. The swap curve enables the measurement of the benchmark interest rate component on designation. The difference between the benchmark rate and the base rate is therefore excluded from the hedge risk designated. -- 144 of 354 -- -B145- 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued Interest rate risk continued As such, the benchmark interest rate risk is the component being hedged, while other risks such as credit risk are managed but not hedged by the group. This benchmark interest rate risk comprises the majority of the hedged items fair value risk. For all other hedged items, the complete cash flow of the underlying financial asset or financial liability is designated as the hedged item, where the credit risk is proven not to dominate the fair value movements as a result of this risk. The following are the identified hedged items subject to fair value interest rate risk hedge accounting and the related hedging instrument: x Specified long-term fixed-rate investment securities, advances and other funding liabilities measured at amortised cost, as well as investment securities measured at and FVOCI. To manage the interest rate risk associated with such risk exposures, the group uses a variety of cash collateralised vanilla fixed-for-floating interest rate swap derivatives. x Interest rate exposure on a portfolio of fixed-rate HQLA measured at amortised cost and FVOCI; and advances and deposits measured at amortised cost in Aldermore, where Aldermore enters into interest rate swaps on a monthly basis. The exposure from these portfolios frequently changes due to new advances, deposits and HQLA being entered into, as well as contractual repayments and early repayments made by or to customers. As a result, Aldermore has adopted a dynamic hedging strategy (macro hedging), to hedge the exposure profile by de-designating and re-designating interest rate swaps agreements at each month end to reach offsetting positions. The designated hedged items attract fixed-interest cash flows, which expose the group to the risk of changes in the hedged item’s fair value attributable to changes in the benchmark interest rate embedded in the hedge item. The group enters into a variety of collateralised fixed-for-floating vanilla interest rate swaps. As such there is an expectation that the changes in fair value of the hedged item would move in the opposite direction to changes in the interest rate swaps as a result of movements in the benchmark interest rate swap curve. The swap prices off the swap curve denominated in the exposure’s currency, which is regarded as the best indicator of the interest rate risk present in the hedged item. -- 145 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B146- 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued Interest rate risk continued In certain circumstances, the economic relationship is evident due to critical terms such as the denominated currency, nominal amount, duration and either the fixed rate on the hedged item or the benchmark rate component of the hedged item and the interest rate swap matching. In other instances, the hedge accounting relationship is designated based on matching the PV01 of the hedging instrument to the hedged item. In both instances, the group uses regression analyses to quantitatively prove the economic relationship. The outcome of this is that for most hedge accounting relationships a 1:1 hedge ratio is maintained throughout the duration of the relationship. Some hedge accounting relationships do not have 1:1 hedge ratios as the designations are not based on matching notional amounts, but rather on matching the PV01 associated with the hedged item to that of the hedging instrument. In the fair value hedge relationships for interest rate risk, the following may lead to ineffectiveness: ● the designated fixed interest rate on the hedged item differs from the offsetting rate of the interest rate swap; ● the unwinding of the time value of money element contained within the fair value of the hedging instrument on designation date; ● prepayment risk on macro hedging portfolios on the date of designating the hedge relationship; ● day 1 gains or losses on the hedging instrument at the inception of the hedge; ● differences in maturities of the interest rate swap and the hedged item; ● where applicable, the effects of the interest rates reforms, as the amendments to the terms of the hedging instrument and the related hedged item could take effect at different times; ● different reset and or settlement dates for the hedging instrument and the hedged items; and ● difference in the notional amounts of the hedging instrument and the hedged items. The USD LIBOR ceased to exist on 30 June 2023 and all the group’s USD LIBOR hedge accounted trades were transitioned to Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR) by year-end. The trades were transitioned on an economically equivalent basis and the group applied the IFRS 9, IAS 39 and IFRS 7 amendments relating to Interest Rate Benchmark Reform to update the impacted hedge relationships and hedge documentation. These amendments provide temporary relief from applying specific hedge accounting requirements to hedge accounting relationships directly affected by an IBOR reform. The impacted hedge relationships were not discontinued and hedge ineffectiveness continued to be measured and recognised as normal. However, any hedge ineffectiveness would continue to be recognised in the income statement. -- 146 of 354 -- -B147- 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued Interest rate risk continued The total notional amount of the derivatives impacted by the IBOR reform that are still to transition are set out below: 2023 2022 R million Notional Notional Fair value hedge ‒ interest rate risk Interest rate derivatives ‒ derivative assets USD LIBOR - 566 Interest rate derivatives ‒ derivative liabilities USD LIBOR - 164 These derivatives were transitioned via ISDA protocols. Refer to Note 37.4.1 ‒ Interest rate risk in the banking book for a detailed explanation on how FirstRand is managing the transition to ARRs. The following table discloses the maturity of the hedging instruments included in fair value hedging relationships excluding the maturity of the macro hedging portfolios. 2023 2022 * Interest rate Interest rate risk risk R million Notional amount Notional amount 4 – 12 months 41 936 23 932 >12 months 29 655 20 502 Total 71 591 44 434 * This table has been restated to correctly reflect the notional as well as the total notional of derivatives held as hedging instruments. The following table discloses the average interest rate of the hedging instruments included in fair value hedging relationships, according to their respective maturity buckets, excluding macro hedging portfolios. 2023 2022 * Average Average interest rate interest rate risk risk (%) (%) Derivative asset 4 ─ 12 months 2 6 > 12 months * 5 4 Derivative liability 4 ─ 12 months - - > 12 months - - * In the prior year, 7% for derivative assets > 12 months and 2% for derivative liabilities > 12 months was presented. The amounts have been restated to correctly reflect the average rate interest rate risk. -- 147 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B148- 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued The following table sets out information about hedged items in fair value hedging relationships. 2023 Advances * Investment Funding R million securities liabilities ** Interest rate risk — hedged items Carrying amount excluding fair value hedge adjustments 182 004 51 124 98 855 Accumulated fair value hedge adjustments for instruments that are actively hedged (10 017) (5 206) 504 Total carrying amount of hedged items 171 987 45 918 99 359 Accumulated fair value hedge adjustments for items that have ceased to be adjusted for fair value hedge gains and losses - (29) - 2022 Interest rate risk — hedged items Carrying amount excluding fair value hedge adjustments 136 759 41 814 73 661 Accumulated fair value hedge adjustments for instruments that are actively hedged (3 984) (2 848) 112 Total carrying amount of hedged items 132 775 38 966 73 773 Accumulated fair value hedge adjustments for items that have ceased to be adjusted for fair value hedge gains and losses - 57 - * Majority of the amounts in advances relate to the macro hedging strategy applied. In the prior year, a portion of the fair value macro hedges failed to qualify for hedge accounting. ** Funding liabilities are included in the deposit and Tier 2 liabilities lines in the statement of financial position. The following amounts were recognised in NII and NIR for the year in respect of fair value hedging relationships (single hedge relationships and macro hedging portfolios). R million 2023 2022 Interest rate risk Changes in fair value for the year arising on hedging instruments 6 680 6 871 – Interest rate derivatives 6 680 6 871 Changes in fair value on the hedged items attributable to the hedged risk (5 979) (6 786) – Advances (4 929) (4 221) – Investment securities — amortised cost 530 (1 020) – Investment securities — FVOCI (1 386) (2 094) – Funding liabilities * (194) 549 Ineffectiveness recognised in NIR 701 85 * Funding liabilities are included in the deposit and Tier 2 liabilities lines in the statement of financial position. -- 148 of 354 -- -B149- 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued Cash flow hedges The group employs cash flow hedge accounting to mitigate changes in future cash flows on variable rate financial instruments with the objective of mitigating variability in future cash flows resulting from changes in market rates. The following are the identified hedged items subject to cash flow hedge accounting: x prime-linked advances (cash flow interest rate risk); x variable Johannesburg Interbank Average Rate-linked (JIBAR-linked) advances (cash flow interest rate risk); x variable overnight financial liabilities (cash flow interest rate risk); and x the group’s share incentive scheme (cash flow equity price risk). Interest rate risk Cash flow hedges of interest rate risk relate to exposures to the variability in future interest cash flows due to the movement of benchmark interest rates on recognised financial assets and financial liabilities. The change in the interest cash flows attributable to the change in benchmark rate is designated as the hedged risk for hedge accounting purposes. This variability in cash flows is hedged by cash collateralised vanilla interest rate swaps, fixing the hedged cash flows. The variable interest rate on JIBAR-linked assets and overnight financial liabilities exposes the group to volatility in interest cash flows as the variable benchmark interest rate varies over time. To manage the cash flow risk, the group enters into interest rate swaps that have similar critical terms as the hedged items, such as reference rates, reset dates, payment dates, maturities and notional amounts. Variable rate assets are hedged with receive fixed pay float interest rate swaps, and variable rate liabilities are hedged with receive float pay fixed interest rate swaps. The changes in the cash flows on the hedging instruments are therefore expected to offset the changes in the cash flows on hedged items, resulting in an economic relationship. A 1:1 hedge ratio is applied as the nominal amount of the hedging instruments and the designated hedged item is the same. -- 149 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B150- 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued In the cash flow hedge of interest rate risk, the main sources of ineffectiveness are: x day 1 gains or losses on the hedging instrument at the inception of the hedge; x benchmark rate differences (basis risk) arising from the use of prime and JIBAR-linked swaps to hedge overnight financial liabilities; and x designation of JIBAR-linked advances between JIBAR fixing dates. Equity price risk Equity price risk exists within the group’s employee share incentive schemes that enable KMP and employees to benefit from the performance of FirstRand’s share price. Refer to note 32 for further details. These share incentive schemes, which are accounted for as cash-settled SBP in terms of IFRS 2, expose the group to cash equity price risk due to volatility in FirstRand’s share price. The fair value of the IFRS 2 liability, which is predominantly driven by movements in the FirstRand share price, is economically hedged with total return swaps (TRS). When the share price increases/decreases, the SBP expense increases/decreases in line with the share price movement. Similarly, the fair value of the TRS will increase/decrease for the share price component of the derivative in line with the increase/decrease in share price. Changes in the cash flows of the hedged item and the hedging instrument are expected to offset each other, resulting in an economic relationship being present between the SBP expense and the TRS. The number of FSR shares covered by the TRS was 143 million (2022: 96 million). In cash flow hedging for equity price risk hedge relationships, the main sources of ineffectiveness are: x mismatches in the critical terms (including differences between the notional amount of the hedging instrument and the actual number of grants vested or expected to vest) of the hedged item and the hedging instrument; x actual number of shares that vest versus the vesting probabilities used in the calculation of the cash-settled SBP; x funding costs associated with the hedging instrument; and x the complete fair value of the hedging instrument at inception as well as the unwinding of the time value of money element contained within the fair value of the hedging instrument on designation date. Due to the IFRS 2 award partially vesting in the prior financial year, the hedging relationship for the schemes no longer qualified for hedge accounting from the date the vesting terms were confirmed. -- 150 of 354 -- -B151- 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued The following table discloses the maturity of the hedging instruments included in cash flow hedging relationships. 2023 2022 * Notional amount Notional amount Interest rate Equity price Interest rate Equity price R million risk risk risk risk 1 ─ 3 months 26 387 - 16 512 - 4 ─ 12 months 136 740 5 409 147 456 - >12 months 340 889 2 119 328 845 4 613 Total 504 016 7 528 492 813 4 613 *This table has been restated to reflect only the total notional of derivatives held as hedging instruments. The following table discloses the average interest rate and share price for which the hedging instruments included in cash flow hedging relationships are based on, according to their respective maturity buckets. 2023 2022 Average rate/share price Average rate/share price Interest rate Equity price Interest rate Equity price risk (%) risk (ZAR) risk (%) risk (ZAR) Derivative assets 1 ─ 3 months 5 - 6 - 4 ─ 12 months 7 56 6 - >12 months 7 56 7 42 Derivative liabilities 1 ─ 3 months 7 - 6 - 4 ─ 12 months 7 - 5 - >12 months 8 - 7 61 -- 151 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B152- 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued The following amounts were recorded in NIR and operating expenses for the year in respect of cash flow hedging relationships. 2023 2022 * Interest Equity Interest Equity rate price rate price R million risk risk Total risk risk Total Changes in fair value for the year On the hedging instruments (685) 683 (2) (2 841) 544 (2 297) – Interest rate derivatives (685) - (685) (2 841) - (2 841) – Equity derivatives - 683 683 - 544 544 On the hedged item subject to the hedged risk 642 (960) (318) 2 682 (452) 2 230 – Advances 614 - 614 7 298 - 7 298 – Other funding liabilities 28 - 28 (4 616) - (4 616) – Share-based payment - (960) (960) - (452) (452) Ineffectiveness in NII and operating expenses * (42) - (42) (159) 92 (67) * In the prior year, the ineffectiveness recognised in NII and operating expenses for interest rate risk and equity risk was incorrectly reflected as nil. The comparative information has been updated to correctly reflect the ineffectiveness recognised. -- 152 of 354 -- -B153- 8 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS continued The following amounts relate to hedging instruments included in cash flow hedging relationships. R million Interest Equity rate risk price risk * Total As at 30 June 2023 Cash flow hedge reserve – opening balance (3 001) 644 (2 357) (Losses)/gains recognised in reserves in the current year (745) 1 027 282 Deferred tax on reserve movement 266 47 313 Transfers to NII and operating expenses (staff costs) (241) (1 092) (1 333) – Hedged item affects profit or loss (145) (1 092) (1 237) – Hedged future cash flows no longer expected to occur (96) - (96) Cash flow hedge reserve – closing balance (3 721) 626 (3 095) Cash flow hedge reserve relating to continuing hedges (3 485) 625 (2 860) Cash flow hedge reserve relating to discontinued hedges (236) 1 (235) Cash flow hedge reserve – closing balance (3 721) 626 (3 095) As at 30 June 2022 Cash flow hedge reserve – opening balance 1 196 159 1 355 (Losses)/gains recognised in reserves in the current year (3 816) 1 678 (2 138) Deferred tax on reserve movement 1 575 (177) 1 398 Transfers to NII, operating staff costs and tax expense (1 956) (1 016) (2 972) – Hedged item affects profit or loss (1 377) (707) (2 084) – Hedged future cash flows no longer expected to occur (579) (309) (888) Cash flow hedge reserve – closing balance (3 001) 644 (2 357) Cash flow hedge reserve relating to continuing hedges (3 330) 600 (2 730) Cash flow hedge reserve relating to discontinued hedges 329 44 373 Cash flow hedge reserve – closing balance (3 001) 644 (2 357) * In the prior year the IFRS 2 award partially vested and the hedging relationship for the non-vested schemes no longer existed. The TRS derivative designated as part of this hedging relationship was therefore classified as held for trading, with fair value movements being recognised in NIR, and the portion of the cash flow hedge reserve which related to this hedge relationship was released to profit or loss. 9 COMMODITIES R million 2023 2022 Agricultural commodities 2 164 2 518 Gold 14 931 14 887 Platinum group metals 157 175 Total commodities 17 252 17 580 -- 153 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B154- 10 INVESTMENT SECURITIES R million 2023 2022 Negotiable certificates of deposit 359 35 Treasury bills 116 578 123 785 Other government and government-guaranteed stock 251 222 204 308 Other dated securities 25 793 29 352 Other undated securities 500 140 Non-recourse investments 3 758 7 013 Equities 15 761 12 470 Other 5 949 5 360 Total gross carrying amount of investment securities 419 920 382 463 Loss allowance on investment securities (780) (314) Total investment securities 419 140 382 149 Analysis of impairment stages of investment securities 2023 Amortised cost FVOCI (debt) Carrying ECL Carrying ECL R million amount allowance amount allowance As at 30 June 2023 Stage 1 226 252 695 54 333 - Stage 3 195 85 - - Stage 4 468 - - - Total investment securities 226 915 780 54 333 - 2022 As at 30 June 2022 Stage 1 162 799 314 51 082 - Stage 3 - - - - Stage 4 - - - - Total investment securities 162 799 314 51 082 - During the current year, the Ghanaian government bonds were restructured. Prior to the restructure, the expected credit loss representing 57% of the face value was raised. The expected credit loss is reflected in impairments of investment securities in investment income. As a result of the restructure, the original instruments were derecognised and new instruments were recognised. The new instruments issued are originated credit impaired (stage 4). In the prior year, a transfer in investment securities at amortised cost from stage 2 to stage 1 was affected due to the improved credit quality of a single counterparty. ECL for FVOCI debt instruments are calculated using the loss rate approach and is immaterial. -- 154 of 354 -- -B155- 10 INVESTMENT SECURITIES continued Non-recourse investments at fair value through profit or loss The group entered into the following transactions with its consolidated structured entities over the course of many years. SPV Type of SPV Instruments iNkotha Investments Limited Call bond programme Overnight high credit quality iVuzi Investments Limited Asset-backed commercial paper programme Short-dated high credit quality iNguza Investments Limited Repack programme Debentures or notes linked to underlying credit exposure The performance on the commercial paper is directly linked to the performance and risk of the underlying portfolio of the SPV. The group has no obligations towards other investors beyond the amount already invested. Information regarding other investments is kept at the group’s registered offices. iVuzi Investments Limited is in the process of winding down. Repurchase agreements and securities lending transactions The table below sets out the details of investment securities that have been transferred in terms of repurchase agreements, but not derecognised. Investment securities (carrying amount) Associated liabilities recognised in deposits (carrying amount) R million 2023 2022 2023 2022 Repurchase agreements 4 705 4 893 3 848 3 518 Both the transferred investments and related deposits under repurchase agreements are either measured at amortised cost or at FVTPL. The fair value of the investment securities transferred under repurchase agreements is R4 006 million (2022: R4 251 million) and that of the associated liabilities is R3 837 million (2022: R4 103 million). Equity investments designated at fair value through other comprehensive income The fair value of strategic equity investments of the group which have been classified as non-trading equity instruments designated on initial recognition as measured at FVOCI is R384 million (2022: R344 million). These strategic investments mainly relate to the group’s investments in African Bank Holdings Limited and CLS Group Holdings Limited. The FVOCI measurement was deemed more appropriate because these are strategic investments that the group does not plan on selling. -- 155 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B156- 11 ADVANCES 11.1 Category analysis of advances R million Notes 2023 2022 Overdrafts and cash management accounts 91 880 80 514 Term loans 97 108 76 436 Card loans 41 725 37 348 Instalment sales, hire purchase agreements and lease payments receivable 11.2 288 284 245 904 Property finance 536 558 473 300 Personal loans 57 425 53 068 Preference share agreements 40 928 40 407 Investment bank term loans 205 380 168 008 Long-term loans to group associates and joint ventures 2 696 2 841 Other 65 100 61 374 Total customer advances 1 427 084 1 239 200 Marketable advances 83 953 72 241 Assets under agreements to resell 79 410 70 617 Gross value of advances 1 590 447 1 382 058 Impairment and credit of fair value advances 12 (51 072) (47 734) Net advances 1 539 375 1 334 324 Gross advances – amortised cost 1 459 196 1 284 777 Impairment of advances – amortised cost (49 746) (46 136) Net advances – amortised cost 1 409 450 1 238 641 Gross advances – fair value 131 251 97 281 Impairment of advances – fair value (1 326) (1 598) Net advances – fair value 129 925 95 683 Net advances 1 539 375 1 334 324 11.2 Analysis of instalment sales, hire purchase agreements and lease payments receivable R million 2023 2022 * Within 1 year 49 450 39 423 Between 1 and 2 years 43 547 35 642 Between 2 and 3 years 37 990 29 042 Between 3 and 4 years 26 980 22 034 Between 4 and 5 years 6 480 6 645 More than 5 years 3 113 2 034 Total gross amount ** 167 560 134 820 Unearned finance charges (25 649) (18 517) Net amount of hire purchase and lease payments receivable 141 911 116 303 Instalment sales 146 373 129 601 Total instalment sales, hire purchase agreements and lease payments receivable 288 284 245 904 * Restated. Refer to note 38.1 Restatement of previously presented information. ** Hire purchase agreements and lease payment receivables relate to leases for motor vehicles and equipment. The agreements do not include contingent rentals. The increase in the gross amount is attributable to growth in motor vehicle leasing as industry supply constraints continue to ease in the UK. -- 156 of 354 -- -B157- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.3 Securitisation transactions The following bankruptcy remote structured entities were created over the course of many years to facilitate traditional securitisation transactions for WesBank retail instalment sale advances (Nitro 6, Nitro Programme and FAST), for MotoNovo retail hire purchase advances (MotoFirst, and MotoWay) and for Aldermore residential mortgage advances (Oak 2, Oak 3 and Oak 4). During the financial year, MotoWay, Oak 2 and Nitro 6 were closed out (notes redeemed and assets repurchased by the relevant servicer) and Oak 4 was launched. These structured entities are consolidated by the FirstRand group. The table below discloses the carrying amount of advances and related assets held by the structured entities at 30 June as well as the financial liabilities incurred to fund the initial acquisitions and other related liabilities. Some structured entities’ financial assets have early-settled and the cash held by the structured entities will be utilised to purchase additional advances post year end. Carrying value of Carrying value of Initial assets liabilities Name of transaction R million R million securitisation Established value 2023 2022 2023 2022 FAST July 2016 R6.8 billion 3 846 7 129 2 772 6 261 MotoFirst October 2017 £400 million - 2 - 2 Nitro 6 April 2018 R2 billion - 23 - - Oak 2 October 2018 £390 million - 1 324 - 1 313 Nitro Programme May 2019 R2 billion 215 477 170 413 Oak 3 September 2019 £344 million 2 602 2 980 2 464 2 891 MotoMore September 2019 £250 million 17 753 14 513 17 400 14 432 MotoWay September 2019 £583 million - 2 003 - 2 209 Turbo Finance 9 October 2020 £583 million 2 626 5 754 2 596 5 705 Oak 4 May 2023 £447 million 9 756 - 9 686 - 11.4 Analysis of advances per class Basis of preparation of the analysis of advances per class In determining classes of advances, the type of client is used as a primary indicator, and then the type of loans provided to that type of client is reflected as sub classes. The UK operations retail portfolio consists of the property finance and motor finance portfolio and commercial represents the structured and specialised finance business. Voluntary changes in presentation Changes in classes ‒ Revolving facilities Revolving facilities have been moved from the retail other segment to personal loans. These revolving facilities are used by customers in meeting longer-term, high-value lending needs. This move will enable a single view of medium-term unsecured lending products and will align the external reporting with how these products are managed internally. The group has voluntarily updated the comparative information. Details of the comparative information that has been restated are included in Note 38.2 Impact due to movements in the classes of advances. -- 157 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B158- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.4 Analysis of advances per class continued Temporary stress scenario An additional stress scenario was introduced during the financial year ended 30 June 2021 and 30 June 2022 given the event-driven uncertainty in the global and South African economy. The scenario was initially introduced to capture the uncertainty around the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic and subsequently to address risks brought about by the impact of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and inflation and interest rate forecasting risks. Since June 2022, the forecasting risk associated with inflation and interest rates, have manifested in actual inflation and interest rate outcomes. This has been incorporated in the group’s impairment models, therefore the application of this scenario is no longer required as at 30 June 2023. 11.5 Reconciliation of the gross advances and loss allowance on total advances per class Basis of preparation of the reconciliation The reconciliation of the GCA and ECL has been prepared using a year-to-date view. This means that the group reports exposures based on the impairment stage at the end of the reporting period. The reconciliation distinguishes between the back book and new business as this provides meaningful information to the user in gaining an understanding of the performance of advances overall. The group transfers opening balances (back book) at the value as at 1 July, based on the impairment stage at the end of the reporting period. Any change in exposure and additional ECL raised or released is included in the impairment stage as at the end of the reporting period. Exposures that are in the back book can move directly from stage 3 to stage 1 if the curing requirements have been met in a reporting period. The opening balances as at 1 July are transferred to the impairment stage at 30 June in the transfers section. The current year movements of the back book are included in changes in exposure and net movement GCA and ECL provided/(released) are reflected separately in the reconciliation. The current year movement in the ECL for stage 2 advances is split between exposure where there has been a change in the measurement basis from 12 months to LECLs and other changes. The movement on GCA is split between: ● additional amounts advanced on the back book and any settlements, with transfers on the back book reflected separately; and ● new business originated during the financial year, the transfers between stages of the new origination and any settlements. Current year ECL provided/(released) relates to: ● an increase/(decrease) in the carrying amount of the back book during the current financial year, as well as the increase/(decrease) in the risk associated with the opening balance of the back book; and ● includes interest on stage 3 advances for stage 3 exposures in the back book and new business. -- 158 of 354 -- -B159- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.5 Reconciliation of the gross advances and loss allowance on total advances per class continued Basis of preparation of the reconciliation continued New business is broadly defined as any new product issued to a new or existing customer during the current financial year, including any increase or decrease during the current financial year. All new business is included in the new business – change in exposure line, based on the impairment stage at the end of the reporting period. Therefore, exposures in the new business lines can be reported in stage 3 at the end of the reporting date. The majority of the fair value advances is originated within the RMB corporate and investment banking portfolio. The decrease in the advance as a result of a write-off is equal to the decrease in the ECL (bad debts written off), as exposures are 100% provided for before being written off. There is however an exception in the RMB corporate and investment banking portfolio, where partial write-offs are permitted on a case-by-case basis. Additional information relating to advances The total contractual amount outstanding on amortised cost advances that were written off during the period and are still subject to enforcement activity is R11 948 million (30 June 2022: R14 663 million). Included in the core lending advances is advances of R1 815 million (30 June 2022: R1 963 million) for which no ECL is raised due to over-collateralisation. These advances are originated in FNB commercial and RMB corporate and investment banking. Advances under agreements to resell also are also fully collateralised and therefore no ECL is raised for these advances either. -- 159 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B160- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.5.1 Reconciliation of the gross carrying amount of total advances per class continued Amortised cost – 30 June 2023 Retail secured Retail secured Retail unsecured and unsecured Temporary Residential WesBank FNB Personal Retail stress R million mortgages VAF card loans other scenario GCA reported as at 1 July 2022 242 757 99 354 32 821 46 623 7 907 - ‒ Stage 1 211 306 82 088 26 914 32 510 6 045 (2 688) ‒ Stage 2 19 649 11 063 2 229 7 149 586 2 688 ‒ Stage 3 11 802 6 203 3 678 6 964 1 276 - ‒ Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Transfers between stages - - - - - - ‒ Transfers to/(from) stage 1 (6 016) (3 071) (1 802) (3 242) (321) - Transfers into stage 1 5 873 2 418 641 1 085 156 - Transfers out of stage 1 (11 889) (5 489) (2 443) (4 327) (477) - ‒ Transfers to/(from) stage 2 2 130 740 96 (195) 69 - Transfers into stage 2 11 272 4 805 1 292 2 628 369 - Transfers out of stage 2 (9 142) (4 065) (1 196) (2 823) (300) - ‒ Transfers to/(from) stage 3 3 886 2 331 1 706 3 437 252 - Transfers into stage 3 5 585 3 242 1 822 4 086 375 - Transfers out of stage 3 (1 699) (911) (116) (649) (123) - Current year movement 17 452 11 256 6 082 8 647 311 - New business – changes in exposure 45 431 43 635 3 467 21 297 1 024 - Back book – current year movement (27 979) (32 379) 2 615 (12 650) (713) - ‒ Exposures with a change in measurement ‒ basis from 12 months to LECL (1 505) (1 992) 185 (1 108) 1 - ‒ Other current year change in ‒ exposure/net movement on GCA (26 474) (30 387) 2 430 (11 542) (714) - Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Acquisition/(disposal) of advances - - - - - - Transfers from/(to) other divisions (11) - - - 11 - Transfers from/(to) non-current assets or disposal groups held for sale - - - - - - Exchange rate differences - - - - - - Bad debts written off (438) (1 777) (1 639) (4 895) (745) - Modifications that did not give rise to derecognition (125) (54) (115) (303) (78) - GCA as at 30 June 2023 259 635 108 779 37 149 50 072 7 406 - ‒ Stage 1 223 096 90 310 30 073 35 024 5 843 - ‒ Stage 2 22 466 12 300 3 019 7 501 639 - ‒ Stage 3 14 073 6 169 4 057 7 547 924 - ‒ Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Core lending advances 259 635 108 779 37 149 50 072 7 406 - Assets under agreements to resell - - - - - - Total GCA of advances at 30 June 2023 259 635 108 779 37 149 50 072 7 406 - -- 160 of 354 -- -B161- Corporate and commercial UK operations RMB Centre Temporary corporate and (including FNB stress WesBank investment Broader Group commercial scenario corporate banking Africa Treasury) Retail Commercial Total 107 711 - 45 128 284 141 67 218 47 271 231 437 72 409 1 284 777 95 656 (130) 39 417 259 862 58 053 47 271 203 370 65 183 1 124 857 7 428 130 4 808 20 974 5 847 - 21 102 6 263 109 916 4 627 - 903 2 572 3 318 - 6 965 963 49 271 - - - 733 - - - - 733 - - - - - - - - - (3 130) - 708 (5 974) (3 280) - 2 151 (1 094) (25 071) 2 388 - 3 070 1 714 1 173 - 9 760 3 002 31 280 (5 518) - (2 362) (7 688) (4 453) - (7 609) (4 096) (56 351) 1 303 - (1 120) 3 675 2 680 - (3 424) 624 6 578 4 591 - 2 025 7 219 4 214 - 6 831 3 639 48 885 (3 288) - (3 145) (3 544) (1 534) - (10 255) (3 015) (42 307) 1 827 - 412 2 299 600 - 1 273 470 18 493 1 894 - 500 2 299 755 - 2 242 749 23 549 (67) - (88) - (155) - (969) (279) (5 056) 9 914 - 9 262 50 565 10 875 (6 423) 9 149 (868) 126 222 18 585 - 22 321 109 953 16 946 578 102 265 26 933 412 435 (8 671) - (13 059) (59 468) (6 071) (7 001) (93 116) (27 801) (286 293) (496) - (2 344) (1 942) (186) - (8 718) (2 441) (20 546) (8 175) - (10 715) (57 526) (5 885) (7 001) (84 398) (25 360) (265 747) - - - 80 - - - - 80 (90) - - (3 932) - - 86 - (3 936) - - - - - - - - - - - - (44) - - (785) - (829) - - - 5 265 (529) 13 47 496 14 425 66 670 (1 612) - (178) (387) (760) - (475) (132) (13 038) 5 - - - - - - - (670) 115 928 - 54 212 335 608 76 804 40 861 286 908 85 834 1 459 196 102 500 - 49 682 311 754 65 913 40 861 259 928 77 780 1 292 764 8 655 - 3 464 19 495 7 346 - 18 256 6 636 109 777 4 773 - 1 066 3 577 3 545 - 8 724 1 418 55 873 - - - 782 - - - - 782 115 928 - 54 212 334 969 76 804 26 456 286 908 85 834 1 444 152 - - - 639 - 14 405 - - 15 044 115 928 - 54 212 335 608 76 804 40 861 286 908 85 834 1 459 196 -- 161 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B162- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.5.2 Reconciliation of the loss allowance on total advances per class continued Amortised cost – 30 June 2023 Retail secured Retail secured Retail unsecured and unsecured Temporary Residential WesBank FNB Personal Retail stress R million mortgages VAF card loans other scenario ECL reported as at 1 July 2022 4 084 5 396 4 361 8 681 1 585 317 ‒ Stage 1 609 802 1 130 2 065 385 156 ‒ Stage 2 939 1 344 620 1 727 147 161 ‒ Stage 3 2 536 3 250 2 611 4 889 1 053 - ‒ Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Transfers between stages - - - - - - ‒ Transfers to/(from) stage 1 123 94 46 (145) 17 - Transfers into stage 1 189 149 171 244 39 - Transfers out of stage 1 (66) (55) (125) (389) (22) - ‒ Transfers to/(from) stage 2 (92) (296) (281) (727) (23) - Transfers into stage 2 238 116 79 360 61 - Transfers out of stage 2 (330) (412) (360) (1 087) (84) - ‒ Transfers to/(from) stage 3 (31) 202 235 872 6 - Transfers into stage 3 171 299 295 1 109 68 - Transfers out of stage 3 (202) (97) (60) (237) (62) - Current year provision created/(released) 640 2 243 2 045 5 468 513 (317) New business – impairment charge/(release) 388 1 501 275 2 831 91 - Back book – impairment charge/(release) 252 742 1 770 2 637 422 (317) ‒ Exposures with a change in measurement ‒ basis from 12 months to LECL 43 (63) 190 (119) 14 - ‒ Other current year impairment charge/(release) 209 805 1 580 2 756 408 (317) Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Acquisition/(disposal) of advances - - - - - - Transfers from/(to) other divisions 70 - - 35 (105) - Transfers from/(to) non-current assets or disposal groups held for sale - - - - - - Exchange rate differences - - - - - - Bad debts written off (438) (1 777) (1 639) (4 895) (745) - ECL as at 30 June 2023 4 356 5 862 4 767 9 289 1 248 - ‒ Stage 1 432 995 1 165 2 069 310 - ‒ Stage 2 1 076 1 879 754 1 901 168 - ‒ Stage 3 2 848 2 988 2 848 5 319 770 - ‒ Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Current year provision created/(released) per impairment stage 640 2 243 2 045 5 468 513 (317) ‒ Stage 1 (370) 100 (10) 112 15 (156) ‒ Stage 2 229 830 415 902 44 (161) ‒ Stage 3 781 1 313 1 640 4 454 454 - ‒ Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - -- 162 of 354 -- -B163- Corporate and commercial UK operations RMB corporate Centre Temporary and (including FNB stress WesBank investment Broader Group commercial scenario corporate banking Africa Treasury) Retail Commercial Total 5 234 55 795 5 576 3 856 510 4 565 1 121 46 136 1 030 23 186 1 200 1 035 361 1 271 529 10 782 1 059 32 193 2 420 876 149 746 182 10 595 3 145 - 416 1 873 1 945 - 2 548 410 24 676 - - - 83 - - - - 83 - - - - - - - - - 98 - 127 32 21 - 224 21 658 192 - 143 74 72 - 279 76 1 628 (94) - (16) (42) (51) - (55) (55) (970) (270) - (113) (178) (48) - (175) (8) (2 211) 91 - 19 36 77 - 110 59 1 246 (361) - (132) (214) (125) - (285) (67) (3 457) 172 - (14) 146 27 - (49) (13) 1 553 215 - 10 146 72 - 101 22 2 508 (43) - (24) - (45) - (150) (35) (955) 1 330 (55) 116 720 927 (11) 1 655 514 15 788 259 - 237 647 543 (21) 900 418 8 069 1 071 (55) (121) (123) 384 10 755 96 7 523 299 - (28) (16) 69 - (107) 30 312 772 (55) (93) (107) 315 10 862 66 7 211 - - - 196 - - - - 196 - - - (723) - 22 - - (701) - - - - - - - - - - - - (36) - - - - (36) - - - 60 117 - 1 121 289 1 587 (1 612) - (178) (387) (760) 10 (475) (132) (13 028) 4 952 - 733 5 210 4 140 531 6 866 1 792 49 746 907 - 228 1 334 1 285 370 2 372 962 12 429 1 213 - 111 2 436 808 151 889 382 11 768 2 832 - 394 1 195 2 047 10 3 605 448 25 304 - - - 245 - - - - 245 1 330 (55) 116 720 927 (11) 1 655 514 15 788 (220) (23) (85) 55 188 (11) 512 268 375 424 (32) 31 189 (23) - 180 155 3 183 1 126 - 170 280 762 - 963 91 12 034 - - - 196 - - - - 196 -- 163 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B164- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.5.3 Reconciliation of the gross carrying amount of total advances per class continued Fair value — 30 June 2023 RMB corporate Centre and (including FNB investment Broader Group R million commercial banking Africa Treasury) Total GCA reported as at 1 July 2022 112 96 655 29 485 97 281 – Stage 1 112 93 082 29 442 93 665 – Stage 2 - 2 691 - 43 2 734 – Stage 3 - 799 - - 799 – Purchased or originated credit impaired - 83 - - 83 Transfers between stages - - - - - – Transfers to/(from) stage 1 - (319) - - (319) Transfers into stage 1 - 1 312 - - 1 312 Transfers out of stage 1 - (1 631) - - (1 631) – Transfers to/(from) stage 2 - 319 - - 319 Transfers into stage 2 - 1 631 - - 1 631 Transfers out of stage 2 - (1 312) - - (1 312) – Transfers to/(from) stage 3 - - - - - Transfers into stage 3 - - - - - Transfers out of stage 3 - - - - - Current year movement (44) 32 270 365 93 32 684 New business – changes in exposure - 19 849 - 194 20 043 Back book – current year movement (44) 12 422 365 (101) 12 642 – Exposures with a change in measurement basis – from 12 months to LECL - 1 016 - - 1 016 – Other current year change in exposure/ – net movement on GCA (44) 11 406 365 (101) 11 626 Purchased or originated credit impaired - (1) - - (1) Acquisition/(disposal) of advances - - - - - Transfers from/(to) other divisions 502 - - (502) - Transfers from/(to) non-current assets or disposal groups held for sale - - - - - Exchange rate differences - 1 557 (139) - 1 418 Bad debts written off (50) (82) - - (132) GCA as at 30 June 2023 520 130 400 255 76 131 251 – Stage 1 520 124 776 255 33 125 584 – Stage 2 - 4 847 - 43 4 890 – Stage 3 - 777 - - 777 – Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - Core lending advances 520 66 289 - 76 66 885 Assets under agreements to resell - 64 111 255 - 64 366 Total GCA of advances at 30 June 2023 520 130 400 255 76 131 251 -- 164 of 354 -- -B165- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.5.4 Reconciliation of the loss allowance on total advances per class continued Fair value — 30 June 2023 RMB corporate Centre and (including FNB investment Broader Group R million commercial banking Africa Treasury) Total ECL reported as at 1 July 2022 3 1 488 - 107 1 598 ‒ Stage 1 3 276 - 102 381 ‒ Stage 2 - 649 - 5 654 ‒ Stage 3 - 481 - - 481 ‒ Purchased or originated credit impaired - 82 - - 82 Transfers between stages - - - - - ‒ Transfers to/(from) stage 1 - 175 - - 175 Transfers into stage 1 - 181 - - 181 Transfers out of stage 1 - (6) - - (6) ‒ Transfers to/(from) stage 2 - (175) - - (175) Transfers into stage 2 - 6 - - 6 Transfers out of stage 2 - (181) - - (181) ‒ Transfers to/(from) stage 3 - - - - - Transfers into stage 3 - - - - - Transfers out of stage 3 - - - - - Current year provision created/(released) (1) (210) - 9 (202) New business – impairment charge/(release) - 189 - 9 198 Back book – impairment charge/(release) (1) (399) - - (400) ‒ Exposures with a change in measurement ‒ basis from 12 months to LECL - 9 - - 9 ‒ Other current year impairment charge/(release) (1) (408) - - (409) Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - Acquisition/(disposal) of advances - - - - - Transfers from/(to) other divisions 99 - - (99) - Transfers from/(to) non-current assets or disposal groups held for sale - - - - - Exchange rate differences - 62 - - 62 Bad debts written off (50) (82) - - (132) ECL as at 30 June 2023 51 1 258 - 17 1 326 ‒ Stage 1 51 295 - 4 350 ‒ Stage 2 - 483 - 4 487 ‒ Stage 3 - 480 - 9 489 ‒ Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - Current year provision created/(released) per impairment stage (1) (210) - 9 (202) ‒ Stage 1 (51) (169) - 1 (219) ‒ Stage 2 - (41) - 1 (40) ‒ Stage 3 50 - - 7 57 ‒ Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - -- 165 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B166- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.5.5 Reconciliation of the gross carrying amount of total advances per class continued Amortised cost – 30 June 2022 Retail secured Retail secured Retail unsecured and unsecured Temporary Residential WesBank FNB Personal Retail stress R million mortgages VAF card loans* other* scenario GCA reported as at 1 July 2021 225 666 100 102 31 249 46 908 8 513 - – Stage 1 196 375 77 514 24 553 30 681 6 175 (1 212) – Stage 2 15 935 12 677 2 662 7 681 846 1 212 – Stage 3 13 356 9 911 4 034 8 546 1 492 - – Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Transfers between stages - - - - - - – Transfers to/(from) stage 1 (2 445) (1 188) (628) (1 970) (90) - Transfers into stage 1 7 678 4 421 1 171 2 116 385 - Transfers out of stage 1 (10 123) (5 609) (1 799) (4 086) (475) - – Transfers to/(from) stage 2 1 711 603 (853) (1 058) (46) - Transfers into stage 2 10 563 5 958 860 2 870 346 - Transfers out of stage 2 (8 852) (5 355) (1 713) (3 928) (392) - – Transfers to/(from) stage 3 734 585 1 481 3 028 136 - Transfers into stage 3 3 905 2 726 1 713 3 632 732 - Transfers out of stage 3 (3 171) (2 141) (232) (604) (596) - Current year movement 17 617 1 752 3 618 5 880 759 - New business – changes in exposure 44 607 36 304 3 239 23 066 642 - Back book – current year movement (26 990) (34 552) 379 (17 186) 117 - – Exposures with a change in measurement – basis from 12 months to LECL (1 486) (3 122) 74 (1 648) 243 - – Other current year change in – exposure/net movement on GCA (25 504) (31 430) 305 (15 538) (126) - Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Acquisition/(disposal) of advances - - - - - - Transfers from/(to) other divisions (9) - - - 9 - Transfers from/(to) non-current assets or disposal groups held for sale - - - - - - Exchange rate differences - - - - - - Bad debts written off (469) (2 412) (1 970) (5 738) (1 329) - Modifications that did not give rise to derecognition (48) (88) (76) (427) (45) - GCA as at 30 June 2022 242 757 99 354 32 821 46 623 7 907 - – Stage 1 211 306 82 088 26 914 32 510 6 045 (2 688) – Stage 2 19 649 11 063 2 229 7 149 586 2 688 – Stage 3 11 802 6 203 3 678 6 964 1 276 - – Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Core lending advances 242 757 99 354 32 821 46 623 7 907 - Assets under repurchase agreements - - - - - - Total GCA of advances at 30 June 2022 242 757 99 354 32 821 46 623 7 907 - * Restated. Refer to Note 38.2 – Impact due to movements in the classes of advances. -- 166 of 354 -- -B167- Corporate and commercial UK operations RMB corporate Centre Temporary and (including FNB stress WesBank investment Broader Group commercial scenario corporate banking Africa Treasury) Retail Commercial Total 97 001 - 41 015 248 091 60 133 35 428 221 188 62 428 1 177 722 83 139 (99) 35 561 219 427 49 929 35 428 198 513 53 163 1 009 147 8 064 99 4 060 25 170 6 677 - 15 803 7 169 108 055 5 798 - 1 394 2 678 3 527 - 6 872 2 096 59 704 - - - 816 - - - - 816 - - - - - - - - - (1 222) - 89 (515) (138) - (4 107) 434 (11 780) 5 103 - 2 728 2 480 1 879 - 7 252 4 193 39 406 (6 325) - (2 639) (2 995) (2 017) - (11 359) (3 759) (51 186) (564) - (198) (248) (92) - 2 781 139 2 175 5 515 - 2 505 3 433 1 879 - 10 480 3 781 48 190 (6 079) - (2 703) (3 681) (1 971) - (7 699) (3 642) (46 015) 1 786 - 109 763 230 - 1 326 (573) 9 605 1 900 - 418 1 300 464 - 2 104 377 19 271 (114) - (309) (537) (234) - (778) (950) (9 666) 12 245 - 4 319 33 807 6 513 11 819 8 179 9 551 116 059 18 177 - 25 287 84 372 16 657 1 863 82 631 29 610 366 455 (5 932) - (20 968) (50 482) (10 144) 9 956 (74 452) (20 059) (250 313) (544) - (1 291) (4 577) 37 - (5 205) (2 828) (20 347) (5 388) - (19 677) (45 905) (10 181) 9 956 (69 247) (17 231) (229 966) - - - (83) - - - - (83) - - - (1 614) - - (93) - (1 707) - - - - - - - - - - - - - 115 - - - 115 - - - 3 983 1 370 24 2 457 602 8 436 (1 540) - (206) (126) (913) - (294) (172) (15 169) 5 - - - - - - - (679) 107 711 - 45 128 284 141 67 218 47 271 231 437 72 409 1 284 777 95 656 (130) 39 417 259 862 58 053 47 271 203 370 65 183 1 124 857 7 428 130 4 808 20 974 5 847 - 21 102 6 263 109 916 4 627 - 903 2 572 3 318 - 6 965 963 49 271 - - - 733 - - - - 733 107 711 - 45 128 283 472 67 218 23 871 231 437 72 409 1 260 708 – – – 669 – 23 400 – – 24 069 107 711 – 45 128 284 141 67 218 47 271 231 437 72 409 1 284 777 -- 167 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B168- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.5.6 Reconciliation of the loss allowance on total advances per class continued Amortised cost – 30 June 2022 Retail secured Retail secured Retail unsecured and unsecured Temporary Residential WesBank FNB Personal Retail stress R million mortgages VAF card loans* other* scenario ECL reported as at 1 July 2021 4 304 5 850 4 683 10 036 1 713 335 – Stage 1 646 743 861 2 043 286 131 – Stage 2 841 1 081 654 2 001 296 160 – Stage 3 2 817 4 026 3 168 5 992 1 131 44 – Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Transfers between stages - - - - - - – Transfers to/(from) stage 1 192 238 130 (1) 13 - Transfers into stage 1 235 292 209 301 47 - Transfers out of stage 1 (43) (54) (79) (302) (34) - – Transfers to/(from) stage 2 (67) (187) (292) (729) 35 - Transfers into stage 2 228 216 64 363 73 - Transfers out of stage 2 (295) (403) (356) (1 092) (38) - – Transfers to/(from) stage 3 (125) (51) 162 730 (48) - Transfers into stage 3 160 203 283 937 143 - Transfers out of stage 3 (285) (254) (121) (207) (191) - Current year provision created/(released) 249 1 958 1 648 4 383 1 201 (18) New business – impairment charge/(release) 347 748 194 2 577 60 - Back book – impairment charge/(release) (98) 1 210 1 454 1 806 1 141 (18) – Exposures with a change in measurement – basis from 12 months to LECL 21 (257) 231 (98) 54 - – Other current year impairment charge/(release) (119) 1 467 1 223 1 904 1 087 (18) Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Acquisition/(disposal) of advances - - - - - - Transfers from/(to) other divisions - - - - - - Transfers from/(to) non-current assets or disposal groups held for sale - - - - - - Exchange rate differences - - - - - - Bad debts written off (469) (2 412) (1 970) (5 738) (1 329) - ECL as at 30 June 2022 4 084 5 396 4 361 8 681 1 585 317 – Stage 1 609 802 1 130 2 065 385 156 – Stage 2 939 1 344 620 1 727 147 161 – Stage 3 2 536 3 250 2 611 4 889 1 053 - – Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - Current year provision created/(released) per impairment stage 249 1 958 1 648 4 383 1 201 (18) – Stage 1 (230) (177) 140 25 83 25 – Stage 2 166 451 257 454 (184) 1 – Stage 3 313 1 684 1 251 3 904 1 302 (44) – Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - - * Restated. Refer to Note 38.2 – Impact due to movements in the classes of advances. -- 168 of 354 -- -B169- Corporate and commercial UK operations RMB corporate Centre Temporary and (including FNB stress WesBank investment Broader Group commercial scenario corporate banking Africa Treasury) Retail Commercial Total 5 761 148 956 6 510 3 901 512 3 571 1 332 49 612 944 124 197 1 636 992 360 805 415 10 183 1 438 24 208 3 285 941 152 685 288 12 054 3 379 - 551 1 499 1 968 - 2 081 629 27 285 - - - 90 - - - - 90 - - - - - - - - - 192 - 149 94 41 - 57 241 1 346 332 - 169 128 110 - 117 260 2 200 (140) - (20) (34) (69) - (60) (19) (854) (359) - (97) (180) (16) - (87) (14) (1 993) 127 - 38 31 104 - 87 83 1 414 (486) - (135) (211) (120) - (174) (97) (3 407) 167 - (52) 86 (25) - 30 (227) 647 255 - 21 128 40 - 109 11 2 290 (88) - (73) (42) (65) - (79) (238) (1 643) 1 016 (93) 45 (837) 641 (2) 1 475 (57) 11 609 187 - 234 695 307 (3) 1 072 263 6 681 829 (93) (189) (1 525) 334 1 403 (320) 4 935 230 - (105) (166) 6 1 (96) (58) (237) 599 (93) (84) (1 359) 328 - 499 (262) 5 172 - - - (7) - - - - (7) (3) - - (39) - - (212) - (254) - - - - - - - - - - - - - 9 - - - 9 - - - 68 218 - 25 18 329 (1 540) - (206) (126) (913) - (294) (172) (15 169) 5 234 55 795 5 576 3 856 510 4 565 1 121 46 136 1 030 23 186 1 200 1 035 361 1 271 529 10 782 1 059 32 193 2 420 876 149 746 182 10 595 3 145 - 416 1 873 1 945 - 2 548 410 24 676 - - - 83 - - - - 83 1 016 (93) 45 (837) 641 (2) 1 475 (57) 11 609 (103) (101) (161) (546) (65) (2) 406 (138) (844) (21) 8 82 (694) (129) - 143 (97) 437 1 140 - 124 410 835 - 926 178 12 023 - - - (7) - - - - (7) -- 169 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B170- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.5.7 Reconciliation of the gross carrying amount of total advances per class continued Fair value – 30 June 2022 RMB corporate Centre and (including FNB investment Broader Group R million commercial banking Africa Treasury) Total GCA reported as at 1 July 2021 91 95 217 220 802 96 330 – Stage 1 91 91 912 47 751 92 801 – Stage 2 - 3 119 173 51 3 343 – Stage 3 - 104 - - 104 – Purchased or originated credit impaired - 82 - - 82 Transfers between stages - - - - - – Transfers to/(from) stage 1 - - - 8 8 Transfers into stage 1 - - - 8 8 Transfers out of stage 1 - - - - - – Transfers to/(from) stage 2 - - - (8) (8) Transfers into stage 2 - - - - - Transfers out of stage 2 - - - (8) (8) – Transfers to/(from) stage 3 - - - - - Transfers into stage 3 - - - - - Transfers out of stage 3 - - - - - Current year movement 21 557 (191) (775) (388) New business – changes in exposure - 17 428 - (520) 16 908 Back book – current year movement 21 (16 872) (191) (255) (17 297) – Exposures with a change in measurement – basis from 12 months to LECL - (361) (173) - (534) – Other current year change in exposure/ – net movement on GCA 21 (16 511) (18) (255) (16 763) Purchased or originated credit impaired - 1 - - 1 Acquisition/(disposal) of advances - - - 458 458 Transfers from/(to) other divisions - - - - - Transfers from/(to) non-current assets - or disposal groups held for sale - - - - - Exchange rate differences - 881 - - 881 Bad debts written off - - - - - GCA as at 30 June 2022 112 96 655 29 485 97 281 – Stage 1 112 93 082 29 442 93 665 – Stage 2 - 2 691 - 43 2 734 – Stage 3 - 799 - - 799 – Purchased or originated credit impaired - 83 - - 83 Core lending advances 112 50 107 29 485 50 733 Assets under repurchase agreements - 46 548 - - 46 548 Total GCA of advances at 30 June 2022 112 96 655 29 485 97 281 -- 170 of 354 -- -B171- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.5.8 Reconciliation of the loss allowance on total advances per class continued Fair value — 30 June 2022 RMB corporate Centre and (including FNB investment Broader Group R million commercial banking Africa Treasury) Total ECL reported as at 1 July 2021 - 895 - 111 1 006 – Stage 1 - 164 - 104 268 – Stage 2 - 630 - 7 637 – Stage 3 - 19 - - 19 – Purchased or originated credit impaired - 82 - - 82 Transfers between stages - - - - - – Transfers to/(from) stage 1 - - - 3 3 Transfers into stage 1 - - - 3 3 Transfers out of stage 1 - - - - - – Transfers to/(from) stage 2 - - - (6) (6) Transfers into stage 2 - - - - - Transfers out of stage 2 - - - (6) (6) – Transfers to/(from) stage 3 - - - 3 3 Transfers into stage 3 - - - 3 3 Transfers out of stage 3 - - - - - Current year provision created/(released) 3 545 - (7) 541 New business – impairment charge/(release) - 716 - - 716 Back book – impairment charge/(release) 3 (171) - (7) (175) – Exposures with a change in measurement – basis from 12 months to LECL - (31) - - (31) – Other current year impairment charge/(release) 3 (140) - (7) (144) Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - Acquisition/(disposal) of advances - - - 3 3 Transfers from/(to) other divisions - - - - - Transfers from/(to) non-current assets or disposal groups held for sale - - - - - Exchange rate differences - 48 - - 48 Bad debts written off - - - - - ECL as at 30 June 2022 3 1 488 - 107 1 598 – Stage 1 3 276 - 102 381 – Stage 2 - 649 - 5 654 – Stage 3 - 481 - - 481 – Purchased or originated credit impaired - 82 - - 82 Current year provision created/(released) per impairment stage 3 545 - (7) 541 – Stage 1 3 105 - (5) 103 – Stage 2 - (21) - (2) (23) – Stage 3 - 461 - - 461 – Purchased or originated credit impaired - - - - - -- 171 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B172- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.6 Analysis of the gross advances and loss allowance on total advances per class continued Breakdown of temporary stress scenario The group no longer applied the temporary stress scenario for the year ended 30 June 2023. 2022 Gross advances Purchased or originated credit- R million Total Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3 impaired Residential mortgages - (2 354) 2 354 - - WesBank VAF - (13) 13 - - Total retail secured - (2 367) 2 367 - - FNB card - (193) 193 - - Personal loans - (99) 99 - - – FNB and DirectAxis - (99) 99 - - – Covid-19 relief - - - - - Retail other - (29) 29 - - Total retail unsecured - (321) 321 - - Total retail secured and unsecured - (2 688) 2 688 - - FNB commercial - (130) 130 - - Total temporary stress scenario impact - (2 818) 2 818 - - -- 172 of 354 -- -B173- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.6 Analysis of the gross advances and loss allowance on total advances per class continued Breakdown of temporary stress scenario The group no longer applied the temporary stress scenario for the year ended 30 June 2023. 2022 Loss allowance Purchased or originated credit- Total Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3 impaired 142 64 78 - - 46 24 23 (1) - 188 88 101 (1) - 58 29 29 - - 52 31 21 - - 51 31 20 - - 1 - 1 - - 19 8 10 1 - 129 68 60 1 - 317 156 161 - - 55 23 32 - - 372 179 193 - - -- 173 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B174- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.7 Modified advances measured at amortised cost The following table provides information on advances that were modified while they had a loss allowance measured at an amount equal to LECL and the modification resulted in a modification gain or loss being recognised. 2023 Stage 2 and stage 3 Gross - carrying Loss amount allowance Amortised before before cost before Modification R million modification modification modification gain/(loss) Residential mortgages 11 612 (137) 11 475 (101) WesBank VAF 1 279 (282) 997 (54) Total retail secured 12 891 (419) 12 472 (155) FNB card 582 (284) 298 (115) Personal loans* 2 619 (921) 1 698 (303) Retail other * 124 (55) 69 (78) Total retail unsecured 3 325 (1 260) 2 065 (496) FNB commercial 208 (9) 199 5 Total 16 424 (1 688) 14 736 (646) * Restated. Refer to Note 38.2 – Impact due to movements in the classes of advances. The GCA in stage 2 or stage 3 of advances that previously had been modified but not derecognised, and whose improvement in credit risk has moved into stage 1, amounted to R341 million (2022: R563 million). -- 174 of 354 -- -B175- 11 ADVANCES continued 11.7 Modified advances measured at amortised cost The following table provides information on advances that were modified while they had a loss allowance measured at an amount equal to LECL and the modification resulted in a modification gain or loss being recognised. 2022 Stage 2 and stage 3 Gross carrying Loss amount allowance Amortised before before cost before Modification modification modification modification gain/(loss) 709 (74) 635 (48) 1 157 (189) 968 (88) 1 866 (263) 1 603 (136) 516 (263) 253 (76) 2 442 (911) 1 531 (462) 192 (92) 100 (10) 3 150 (1 266) 1 884 (548) 257 (32) 225 5 5 273 (1 561) 3 712 (679) -- 175 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B176- 12 IMPAIRMENT OF ADVANCES 12.1 Analysis of the loss allowance closing balance 2023 Loss allowance Purchased or originated credit- R million Total Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3 impaired Amount as at 30 June 2023 51 072 12 779 12 255 25 793 245 Amortised cost 49 746 12 429 11 768 25 304 245 Fair value 1 326 350 487 489 - Included in the total loss allowance – On- and off-balance sheet exposure* 50 848 12 662 12 157 25 784 245 – Letters of credit and guarantees 224 117 98 9 - Components of total loss allowance as at 30 June 2023 – Forward-looking information** 3 640 1 571 1 668 401 - – Model update# (534) 477 (69) (942) - 2022 Amount as at 30 June 2022 47 734 11 163 11 249 25 157 165 Amortised cost 46 136 10 782 10 595 24 676 83 Fair value 1 598 381 654 481 82 Included in the total loss allowance – On- and off-balance sheet exposure* 47 517 11 061 11 146 25 145 165 – Letters of credit and guarantees 217 102 103 12 - Components of total loss allowance as at 30 June 2022 – Forward-looking information** 2 697 1 059 1 421 217 - – Model update# 422 (120) 377 165 - * Includes committed undrawn facilities as the credit risk of the undrawn component is managed and monitored with the drawn component as a single EAD. The EAD on the entire facility is used to calculate the ECL and is therefore included in the ECL allowance. ** This represents the total ECL closing balance as at 30 June that is attributable to incorporating FLI macro economic information into the ECL calculations. For more detail on the process of incorporating FLI into the ECL calculation refer to the accounting policy note 9.4. # This represents the total ECL closing balance as at 30 June that is attributable to model recalibrations or refinements in the impairment methodology used that has been approved by a governance body. The amount reflected is the additional ECL recognised at the point/date that the model update was implemented. -- 176 of 354 -- -B177- 12 IMPAIRMENT OF ADVANCES continued 12.2 Breakdown of ECL created in the reporting period 12.2.1 Breakdown of ECL created in the reporting period per impairment charge 2023 Purchased or originated credit- R million Total Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3 impaired Current year ECL provided 15 586 156 3 143 12 091 196 Interest suspended on stage 3 advances (2 850) - - (2 847) (3) Current year change in ECL provided after interest suspended on stage 3 advances 12 736 156 3 143 9 244 193 Post write-off recoveries (2 457) - - (2 457) - Modification losses 670 24 75 571 - Impairment recognised in the income statement – 30 June 2023 10 949 180 3 218 7 358 193 Amortised cost 11 151 400 3 258 7 300 193 Fair value* (202) (220) (40) 58 - 2022 Current year ECL provided 12 150 (740) 416 12 481 (7) Interest suspended on stage 3 advances (2 993) - - (2 993) - Current year change in ECL provided after interest suspended on stage 3 advances 9 157 (740) 416 9 488 (7) Post write-off recoveries (2 756) - - (2 756) - Modification losses 679 - 118 561 - Impairment recognised in the income statement – 30 June 2022 7 080 (740) 534 7 293 (7) Amortised cost 6 539 (843) 555 6 834 (7) Fair value* 541 103 (21) 459 - * No recoveries of bad debts written off or modification losses are attributable to advances measured at fair value. -- 177 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B178- 12 IMPAIRMENT OF ADVANCES 12.2 Breakdown of ECL created in the reporting period continued 12.2.2 Breakdown of ECL created in the reporting period per key driver The table below provides a breakdown of the change in the ECL impairment recognised in the current period based on the key drivers. The key components of the ECL impairment recognised in the current period are as follows: Income statement component Definition and key drivers Volume change in stage 1 This represents change in the impairment on stage 1 core lending advances assuming that the coverage ratio has remained unchanged from the prior period. It is calculated as the movement in the GCA of stage 1 advances (current year less prior year) multiplied by the prior year stage 1 coverage ratio. The key drivers relate to the change in volume of stage 1 advances due to new business, stage migrations and, loans commencing in the period in stage 1 subsequently written off or curing. Change in stage 1 coverage This represents the change in the impairment on stage 1 core lending advances due to a change in the coverage ratio for stage 1 advances. This is calculated as the GCA of stage 1 advances at the current year end multiplied by the difference in the current year and prior year stage 1 coverage ratio. Volume change in stage 2 This represents change in the impairment on stage 2 core lending advances assuming that the coverage ratio remained unchanged from the prior period. This is calculated as the movement in the GCA of stage 2 advances (current year less prior year) multiplied by the prior year stage 2 coverage ratio. This column therefore represents the change in volume of stage 2 advances due to stage migration, or loans commencing the period in stage 2 subsequently migrating to stage 3 or curing. Change in stage 2 coverage This represents the change in the impairment on stage 2 core lending advances due to a change in the coverage ratio for stage 2 advances. This is calculated as the gross carrying amount of stage 2 advances at the current year end multiplied by the difference in the current year and prior year stage 2 coverage ratio. Change in stage 3 provisions (NPLs) This represents the change in the impairment on stage 3 core lending advances due to a change in the coverage ratio and volume changes due to loans commencing in the period in stage 3 subsequently written off or curing. -- 178 of 354 -- -B179- 12 IMPAIRMENT OF ADVANCES continued 12.2 Breakdown of ECL created in the reporting period continued Income statement component Definition and key drivers Modification gains or losses Gains or losses recognised on modified exposures that are not derecognised. Write-offs and other charges Gross advances written off and other movements (foreign exchange movements, acquisition and disposal of advances and transfers to non-current assets held for sale). -- 179 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B180- 12 IMPAIRMENT OF ADVANCES continued 12.2 Breakdown of ECL created in the reporting period continued 12.2.3 Breakdown of ECL created in the current period per key driver continued 2023 Movement in the balance sheet provisions Volume Change in Volume Change in Performing change stage 1 change stage 2 book R million in stage 1 coverage in stage 2 coverage provisions * Total retail secured 114 (98) 285 387 688 Total retail unsecured 278 (314) 341 (12) 293 Temporary stress scenario (156) - (161) - (317) Total retail secured and unsecured 236 (412) 465 375 664 Total FNB commercial 47 (145) 143 (21) 24 – FNB commercial 70 (145) 175 (21) 79 – Temporary stress scenario (23) - (32) - (55) WesBank corporate 48 (6) (54) (28) (40) RMB corporate and investment banking 405 (252) (47) (103) 3 Total corporate and commercial 500 (403) 42 (152) (13) Broader Africa 124 126 236 (304) 182 Centre (including Group Treasury) 83 (172) - 1 (88) UK operations 432 1 102 94 249 1 877 Total 1 375 241 837 169 2 622 2022 Total retail secured 93 (71) 58 303 383 Total retail unsecured # 224 166 (342) (115) (67) Temporary stress scenario 130 (105) 137 (136) 26 Total retail secured and unsecured 447 (10) (147) 52 342 Total FNB commercial 159 (171) (105) (266) (383) – FNB commercial 120 (31) (113) (266) (290) – Temporary stress scenario 39 (140) 8 - (93) WesBank corporate 21 (32) 38 (53) (26) RMB corporate and investment banking 389 (713) (226) (620) (1 170) Total corporate and commercial 569 (916) (293) (939) (1 579) Broader Africa 129 (86) (124) 59 (22) Centre (including Group Treasury) (335) 334 (25) 20 (6) UK operations 207 373 439 (484) 535 Total 1 017 (305) (150) (1 292) (730) * New sub-total not previously presented. ** Previously presented in gross write-off and other. # Refer to note 38.2 – Impact due to movements in the classes of advances. -- 180 of 354 -- -B181- 2023 Movement in the balance sheet provisions Recognised directly in the income statement Credit Interest Change in provision Gross Current suspended Post stage 3 increase/ write-off year ECL Modification on stage 3 write-off provisions (decrease) and other provided * loss advances ** recoveries Total - 50 738 2 144 2 882 179 (455) (438) 2 168 384 677 7 349 8 026 496 (1 618) (1 327) 5 577 - (317) - (317) - - - (317) 434 1 098 9 493 10 591 675 (2 073) (1 765) 7 428 (313) (289) 1 563 1 274 (5) (464) (190) 615 (313) (234) 1 563 1 329 (5) (464) (190) 670 - (55) - (55) - - - (55) (22) (62) 178 116 - (23) (35) 58 (599) (596) 1 105 509 - (40) (42) 427 (934) (947) 2 846 1 899 (5) (527) (267) 1 100 102 284 644 928 - (201) (232) 495 19 (69) 69 - - - - - 1 095 2 972 (804) 2 168 - (49) (193) 1 926 716 3 338 12 248 15 586 670 (2 850) (2 457) 10 949 2022 (1 057) (674) 2 882 2 208 136 (468) (415) 1 461 (1 738) (1 805) 9 038 7 233 547 (1 764) (1 653) 4 363 (44) (18) - (18) - - - (18) (2 839) (2 497) 11 920 9 423 683 (2 232) (2 068) 5 806 (234) (617) 1 539 922 (4) (450) (114) 354 (234) (524) 1 539 1 015 (4) (450) (114) 447 - (93) - (93) - - - (93) (135) (161) 206 45 - (10) (23) 12 829 (341) 47 (294) - (116) (10) (420) 460 (1 119) 1 792 673 (4) (576) (147) (54) (23) (45) 686 641 - (167) (299) 175 - (6) (1) (7) - - - (7) 248 783 637 1 420 - (18) (242) 1 160 (2 154) (2 884) 15 034 12 150 679 (2 993) (2 756) 7 080 -- 181 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B182- 13 OTHER ASSETS R million 2023 2022 * Items in transit 3 363 2 067 Interest and commission accrued 33 23 Prepayments 2 783 2 246 Properties in possession 72 99 Sundry debtors 1 646 1 317 Fair value hedge liability ** (10 007) (4 282) Dividends receivable 481 306 ‒ Profit share receivable on insurance cells 393 206 ‒ Other dividends receivable 88 100 Variation margin 827 807 Accounts receivable 5 028 2 510 Total gross carrying amount of other assets 4 226 5 093 ‒ Financial 9 215 6 544 ‒ Loss allowance on other financial assets # (466) (329) ‒ Non-financial (4 989) (1 451) Total other assets 3 760 4 764 * Restated. Refer to accounting policy note 10.1 for restatement of other assets and creditors, accruals and provisions and Note 38 Impact of changes in presentation. ** The balance reflected relates to the fair value of the interest rate risk component of the hedged items designated in the group's fair value macro hedge accounting relationship. # No further information is provided on the loss allowance on other assets, as the amounts are immaterial. -- 182 of 354 -- -B183- 14 NON-CURRENT ASSETS AND DISPOSAL GROUPS HELD FOR SALE 2023 2022 R million Total Total Tanzania Other ASSETS Cash and cash equivalents * - 552 552 - Advances * 829 104 104 - Impairment of advances (36) - - - Other assets - 3 3 - Investment in associates 566 842 - 842 Total assets classified as a disposal group held for sale 1 359 1 501 659 842 LIABILITIES Creditors, accruals and provisions * - 16 16 - Deposits * - 596 596 - Other liabilities * - 212 212 - Total liabilities classified as a disposal group held for sale - 824 824 - Net assets of disposal group held for sale 1 359 677 (165) 842 * Carrying amount approximates fair value. 14. 1 Tanzania disposal group held for sale The group took a decision to dispose of its operations in Tanzania in a prior year. The operations were conducted through FNB Tanzania and formed part of the broader Africa geographical segment. The group concluded the sale of the disposal group within FNB Tanzania with an effective date of 7 July 2022. An impairment loss was recognised in operating expenses in the prior year for the write-down of the disposal group to its fair value less cost to sell (see note 3). 14. 2 Investment in associate held for sale The group entered into an agreement to dispose of its 39.23% interest in an associate (Studio 88) to Mr Price Limited in the previous year. The deal was concluded in October 2022. (Refer to note 2.4) In the current year, the group agreed to a share-buy-back initiated by the parent of one of its associates. The completion of the share-buy-back is expected to be finalised in October 2023. The carrying amount of the investment in associate is less than the fair value less cost to sell as per the agreement. 14. 3 Advances The group entered into an agreement to sell its working capital finance loan portfolio held in Aldermore. The sale was completed in July 2023 for a consideration equal to the carrying amount of the loan portfolio. -- 183 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B184- 15 POLICYHOLDER LIABILITIES AND REINSURANCE ASSETS R million Notes 2023 2022 Policyholder liabilities under insurance contracts 15.1 1 748 2 028 Policyholder liabilities under investment contracts 15.2 6 383 5 396 Total gross policyholder liabilities 8 131 7 424 Reinsurance assets 15.1 (554) (583) Total net policyholder liabilities 7 577 6 841 15.1 Policyholder liabilities under insurance contracts and reinsurance assets 2023 Reinsurance R million Notes Gross asset Net Short-term insurance contracts 698 (227) 471 Claims outstanding and claims incurred but not reported 15.1.1 657 (226) 431 Unearned premiums 15.1.2 41 (1) 40 Long-term insurance contracts 15.1.3 1 050 (327) 723 Total policyholder liabilities under insurance contracts and reinsurance assets 1 748 (554) 1 194 2022 Short-term insurance contracts 616 (175) 441 Claims outstanding and claims incurred but not reported 15.1.1 576 (172) 404 Unearned premiums 15.1.2 40 (3) 37 Long-term insurance contracts 15.1.3 1 412 (408) 1 004 Total policyholder liabilities under insurance contracts and reinsurance assets 2 028 (583) 1 445 15.1.1 Reconciliation of outstanding claims, claims incurred but not reported and similar items 2023 Reinsurance R million Gross asset Net Opening balance 576 (172) 404 Increase/(decrease) in current year claims outstanding 166 (84) 82 Increase/(decrease) from prior year claims (30) 20 (10) Claims settled in the year (57) 10 (47) Exchange rate differences 2 - 2 Closing balance 657 (226) 431 2022 Opening balance 431 (98) 333 Increase/(decrease) in current year claims 250 (138) 112 Increase/(decrease) from prior year claims 15 (11) 4 Claims settled in the year (120) 75 (45) Closing balance 576 (172) 404 -- 184 of 354 -- -B185- 15 POLICYHOLDER LIABILITIES AND REINSURANCE ASSETS continued 15.1.2 Reconciliation of unearned premiums and similar items 2023 Reinsurance R million Gross asset Net Opening balance 40 (3) 37 Increase/(decrease) in unearned premiums and similar items 1 2 3 Closing balance 41 (1) 40 2022 Opening balance 35 - 35 Increase/(decrease) in unearned premiums and similar items 5 (3) 2 Closing balance 40 (3) 37 15.1.3 Reconciliation of gross long-term insurance contracts 2023 Reinsurance R million Gross asset Net Opening balance 1 412 (408) 1 004 Transfer (to)/from policyholder liabilities (362) 81 (281) – Claims incurred but not yet reported (88) 23 (65) – Outstanding claims (274) 58 (216) Closing balance 1 050 (327) 723 2022 Opening balance 1 545 (289) 1 256 Transfer to policyholder liabilities (133) (119) (252) – Claims incurred but not yet reported (161) 10 (151) – Outstanding claims 28 (129) (101) Closing balance 1 412 (408) 1 004 15.2 Policyholder liabilities under investment contracts R million 2023 2022 Opening balance 5 396 5 378 Premiums received 1 062 605 Fees deducted from account balances (48) (48) Policyholder benefits on investment contracts (708) (647) Fair value adjustments recognised in fair value 681 108 Closing balance 6 383 5 396 -- 185 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B186- 16 INVESTMENTS IN ASSOCIATES R million 2023 2022 Analysis of the carrying value of associates Shares at cost less impairment 6 932 4 869 Share of post-acquisition reserves 3 468 3 309 Total investments in associates 10 400 8 178 Movement in the carrying value of associates Opening balance 8 178 8 644 Share of profit of associates after tax 332 895 – Income before tax for the year 1 318 1 332 – Net impairments of associates (incurred)/reversed (611) 25 – Tax for the year (375) (462) Net movement resulting from acquisitions, disposals and transfers 2 360 (943) – Acquisition of associates 2 831 281 – Cash consideration 1 110 236 – Non-cash consideration 1 721 45 – Disposal of associates (1) (382) – Transfer to non-current assets and disposal groups held for sale (470) (842) Movement in other reserves (4) 9 Exchange rate differences 21 1 Dividends received for the year (487) (428) Closing balance 10 400 8 178 During the current year R64 million (2022: R47 million) in losses were not recognised. The cumulative share of losses from associates not recognised is R478 million (2022: R537 million). The group has no exposure to contingent liabilities as a result of its relationships with associates. -- 186 of 354 -- -B187- 16 INVESTMENTS IN ASSOCIATES continued Financial information of significant associates Toyota Volkswagen Financial Primedia Financial Services Holdings Services Proprietary Proprietary SA Proprietary Limited Limited Limited Nature of business Vehicle finance Broadcasting Vehicle finance Place of business South Africa South Africa South Africa % ownership 33 22 49 % voting rights 33 22 49 R million 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 Amounts recognised in profit or loss and other comprehensive income of the investee Dividends received 139 97 - - - - Revenue 1 874 3 933 1 954 1 732 1 694 3 396 Profit or loss from continuing operations after tax 410 710 194 (976) 194 354 Total comprehensive income/(loss) 410 710 194 (976) 194 354 Amounts recognised on the statement of financial position of the investee Total assets 46 086 39 677 4 563 4 468 36 221 35 781 – Current assets 13 672 12 113 676 734 18 129 16 972 – Non-current assets 32 414 27 564 3 887 3 734 18 092 18 809 Total liabilities (41 313) (35 033) (2 931) (3 022) (33 495) (33 250) – Current liabilities (13 756) (11 302) (726) (2 602) (14 361) (14 881) – Non-current liabilities (27 557) (23 731) (2 205) (420) (19 134) (18 369) Net asset value 4 773 4 644 1 632 1 446 2 726 2 531 Group’s share of net asset value 1 575 1 533 359 318 1 336 1 240 Other adjustments to net asset value (142) (110) (259) (218) 37 61 Carrying value of investments 1 433 1 423 100 100 1 373 1 301 Acquisitions of associates Total consideration transferred - - - - - - – Discharged by cash - - - - - - -- 187 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B188- 16 INVESTMENTS IN ASSOCIATES continued Financial information of individually immaterial associates Other RMB individually private equity immaterial associates associates R million 2023 2022 2023 2022 Carrying amount 4 216 3 281 3 278 2 073 Group’s share of profit or loss after tax from continuing operations 219 635 (107) 30 Group’s share of other comprehensive loss 8 (5) - (1) Group’s share of total comprehensive income/(loss) 227 630 (107) 29 Acquisitions of associates Acquisition date Various Various Various Various Interest acquired (%) Various Various Various Various Total consideration transferred 960 179 1 871 102 – Discharged by cash 839 179 271 57 – Non-cash consideration and other purchases 121 - 1 600 45 Disposal of associates Disposal date Various Various Various Various Interest disposed (%) Various Various Various Various Total consideration received 38 8 - 334 – Discharged by cash 38 1 - - – Non-cash consideration and other purchases - 7 - 334 Carrying value of the associate on disposal (1) (8) - (374) Gains/(loss) on disposal of associates 37 - - (40) Significant acquisition, disposal and impairment of associates 2023 Impairment of associates In the current year, a private equity investee company implemented a debt-to-equity restructure. As a result, a portion of the investee’s loan was converted to equity while the other was settled according to the contractual terms of the loan. A gain of R715 million was recognised in investment income relating to the portion of the loan that was converted to equity (refer note 2.4) . The portion of the advance settled resulted in R105 million release in impairment on amortised cost advances, with the majority of the loan being written off of R716 million (refer to note 2.4). The impairment of the equity portion resulting from the restructure amounted to R650 million in joint ventures and R149 million in associates.The net earnings impact of this transaction is zero. The remaining impairment recognised relates to the group’s investment in private equity associates and other individually immaterial associates, evidencing continued weakening macro economic conditions in South Africa due to rising interest rates, elevated inflation, a weakening Rand and power shortages. The carrying value of these investments are based on their fair value less costs to sell and was determined using an earnings multiple approach with the key assumptions being the earnings multiples and sustainable earnings. The fair value less costs to sell is level 3 of the fair value hierarchy. Reclassification of investment in associates to non-current assets held for sale The group’s investment in a associate was reclassified to non-current asset held for sale. This investment forms part of the FNB segment. Refer to note 14 for more detail. -- 188 of 354 -- -B189- 16 INVESTMENTS IN ASSOCIATES continued Significant acquisition, disposal and impairment of associates 2022 Disposal of associates Gains and losses related to the disposal of associates that are private equity in nature are included in headline earnings. An associate is private equity in nature if the investment is acquired with the main objective of realizing a return on investment through dividends and capital profit on sale of the investment and where management is involved as directors in taking an active role in helping build and develop the associate. In the prior year, losses of R40 million included under other individually immaterial associates arose from associates of a private equity nature. Impairment and impairment reversal in associates The net reversal of impairment of R25 million is driven by a reversal of an impairment in an investment in associate of R115 million and impairments of R90 million arising from other associates. Impairments arose due to continued economic stress from local disruptions arising from unrests, the KZN floods and loadshedding, as well as the impact of global inflationary supply shock. In determining these investments’ fair value less cost to sell, which is level 3 in the fair value hierarchy, earnings multiples and sustainable earnings determined by management were used. Reclassification of investment in associates to non-current assets held for sale The group’s investment in a RMB private equity associate (Studio 88), a leading independent retailer of branded leisure, lifestyle and sporting apparel and footwear, was reclassified to non-current asset held for sale. This investment forms part of the RMB segment. Refer to note 14 for more detail. 17 INVESTMENTS IN JOINT VENTURES R million 2023 2022 Analysis of carrying value of joint ventures Shares at cost less impairment 454 578 Share of post-acquisition reserves 2 651 2 040 Carrying value of investments in joint ventures 3 105 2 618 Movement in the carrying value of joint ventures Opening balance 2 618 2 116 Share of profit of joint ventures after tax 155 596 – Income before tax for the year 905 804 – Net impairments of joint ventures reversed/(incurred) (650) (119) – Tax for the year (100) (89) Net movement resulting from acquisitions and disposals 639 99 – Acquisition of joint ventures 706 99 – Disposal of joint ventures (67) - Movement in other reserves 1 4 Dividends received for the year (308) (197) Closing balance 3 105 2 618 -- 189 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B190- 17 INVESTMENTS IN JOINT VENTURES continued Financial information of significant joint ventures RMB Morgan Stanley Nature of business Equity sales, trading and research Place of business South Africa % ownership 50 % voting rights 50 R million 2023 2022 Amounts recognised in profit or loss and other comprehensive income of the investee Dividends received 77 77 Revenue 995 1 009 Profit or loss from continuing operations after tax 303 328 Total comprehensive income 303 328 Amounts recognised in the statement of financial position of the investee Total assets 22 908 29 914 – Current assets 21 800 29 035 – Non-current assets 1 108 879 Total liabilities (21 365) (28 519) – Current financial liabilities (14 825) (23 614) – Current non-financial liabilities (5 425) (4 028) – Non-current financial liabilities (1 045) (804) – Non-current non-financial liabilities (70) (73) Net asset value 1 543 1 395 Group’s share of net asset value 772 698 Other adjustments to net asset value 31 37 Carrying value of investment 803 735 Included in total assets, liabilities and comprehensive income Cash and cash equivalents (2 635) (2 216) Depreciation and amortisation (13) (11) Interest income 46 29 Interest expense (757) (639) Income tax (64) (82) -- 190 of 354 -- -B191- 17 INVESTMENTS IN JOINT VENTURES continued Financial information of individually immaterial joint ventures RMB private equity joint ventures Other R million 2023 2022 2023 2022 Carrying amount 2 032 1 675 270 208 Group’s share of profit or loss after tax from continuing operations (57) 392 67 30 Group’s share of other comprehensive income 1 4 - - Group's share of total comprehensive (loss)/income (56) 396 67 30 Acquisition of joint ventures Acquisition date Various Various Various Various Interest acquired (%) Various Various Various Various Total consideration transferred 671 80 35 19 – Discharged by cash 618 73 35 19 – Non-cash consideration 53 7 - - Disposal of joint ventures Disposal date Various Various Various Various Interest disposed of (%) Various Various Various Various Total consideration received 67 - - 40 – Discharged by cash 67 - - 40 Carrying value of the joint venture on disposal date (67) - - - Gain on disposal of joint ventures - - - 40 Gains and losses related to the disposal of joint ventures that are private equity in nature are included in headline earnings. A joint venture is private equity in nature if the investment is acquired with the main objective of realising a return on investment through dividends and capital profit on sale of the investment and where management is involved as directors in taking an active role in helping build and develop the joint venture. In the current year, gains of Rnil million (2022: R40 million) included under other arises from joint ventures of a private equity nature. During the current year losses of R384 million (2022: R72 million) were not recognised as the balance of the investment in the joint venture was Rnil. The cumulative share of losses from joint ventures not recognised is R1 021 million (2022: R735 million). Impairments recognised for other joint ventures of R671 million relates to debt to equity restructure reflected in Note 16. A net reversal of impairment of R21 million was recognised in the current year. The carrying value of the investments are based on their fair value less cost to sell and was determined using an earnings multiple approach, with the key assumptions being the earnings multiples and sustainable earnings. The fair values less cost to sell is level 3 of the fair value hierarchy. The group has exposure to contingent liabilities of R150 million (2022: R150 million) as a result of its relationships with its joint ventures. -- 191 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B192- 18 PROPERTY AND EQUIPMENT Assets held Right of under Right of use leasing Computer Other Freehold use equip- agree- equip- equip- R million property property ment ments ment ment Total Net book value at 1 July 2021 6 999 5 133 445 186 2 641 4 786 20 190 Cost 10 043 9 145 755 343 9 444 9 563 39 293 Accumulated depreciation (3 044) (4 012) (310) (157) (6 803) (4 777) (19 103) Movement for the year (234) (18) 13 (33) 204 (397) (465) Acquisitions* 141 1 058 209 37 1 429 1 225 4 099 Disposals (47) (9) - (8) (114) (440) (618) Acquisitions of subsidiaries 60 58 - - - 2 120 Exchange rate difference 40 26 - (3) 22 1 86 Depreciation charge for the year (316) (1 141) (182) (59) (1 133) (1 165) (3 996) Impairments recognised (112) - - - - (20) (132) Early terminations/modification of leases - (10) (14) - - - (24) Net book value at 30 June 2022 6 765 5 115 458 153 2 845 4 389 19 725 Cost 10 164 9 214 938 344 9 890 9 241 39 791 Accumulated depreciation (3 399) (4 099) (480) (191) (7 045) (4 852) (20 066) Movement for the year 29 580 (55) (26) 632 270 1 430 Acquisitions * 440 1 610 155 18 1 835 1 774 5 832 Disposals (75) (29) - (5) - (374) (483) Acquisitions of subsidiaries - - - - - - - Exchange rate difference (16) 205 4 (6) 12 10 209 Depreciation charge for the year (320) (1 189) (192) (37) (1 215) (1 092) (4 045) Impairments recognised - (17) - - - (48) (65) Early terminations/modification of leases - - (22) - - - (22) Impairments reversed - - - 4 - - 4 Net book value at 30 June 2023 6 794 5 695 403 127 3 477 4 659 21 155 Cost 10 421 10 324 871 319 8 414 9 014 39 363 Accumulated depreciation (3 627) (4 629) (468) (192) (4 937) (4 355) (18 208) * Includes capitalised improvements to property leases of R663 million (2022: R433 million). -- 192 of 354 -- -B193- 19 INTANGIBLE ASSETS Software and Broker develop- relation- ment Trade- R million Goodwill ship costs marks Other Total Net book value as at 1 July 2021 7 726 1 324 646 58 178 9 932 Cost 8 603 2 602 2 269 259 479 14 212 Accumulated amortisation and impairment (877) (1 278) (1 623) (201) (301) (4 280) Movement for the year (4) (431) (3) (11) (24) (473) Acquisitions and capitalisations - - 402 - 7 409 Derecognised - - (131) - - (131) Acquisitions of subsidiaries 2 - - - 73 75 Exchange rate differences 54 21 3 - (9) 69 Amortisation for the year - (452) (277) (10) (92) (831) Impairments recognised (60) - - (1) (3) (64) Net book value as at 30 June 2022 7 722 893 643 47 154 9 459 Cost 8 674 2 633 2 281 338 571 14 497 Accumulated amortisation and impairment (952) (1 740) (1 638) (291) (417) (5 038) Movement for the year 924 (357) 275 (10) (13) 819 Acquisitions and capitalisations - - 454 - 6 460 Exchange rate differences 1 266 120 - - (9) 1 377 Amortisation for the year - (477) (179) (10) (10) (676) Impairments recognised (342) - - - - (342) Net book value as at 30 June 2023 8 646 536 918 37 141 10 278 Cost 9 861 3 161 2 502 346 581 16 451 Accumulated amortisation and impairment (1 215) (2 625) (1 584) (309) (440) (6 173) Acquisitions In the prior year, the group recognised the Slow Lounge brand in the FNB reportable segment for R73 million. There were no material acquisitions in the current year. -- 193 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B194- 20 INVESTMENT PROPERTIES R million Notes 2023 2022 Opening balance 698 659 Fair value remeasurements 2.4 (25) (19) (Disposal)/acquisition of subsidiaries (320) 58 Closing balance 353 698 The following amounts have been disclosed in profit or loss with respect to investment property. R million 2023 2022 Rental income from investment property 88 81 Direct operating expenses on investment property that generated rental income 43 79 In the current and prior year the group has no contractual obligations to purchase, construct or develop investment property nor were there material costs incurred for repairs, maintenance and enhancements of investment property. The latest valuation was performed during the 2023 year. Valuations are performed every two years. The next valuation is scheduled to be performed during the 2025 financial year or in the event that there is an expectation of a significant change in the fair value of investment properties. Refer to note 34 for the significant inputs used to determine the fair value of investment properties. 21 EMPLOYEE LIABILITIES AND RELATED ASSETS R million Notes 2023 2022 Liability for short-term employee benefits 9 353 8 656 Share-based payment liability (detailed in note 32) 6 321 3 901 Defined benefit post-employment liability 21.1 1 335 1 260 Other long-term employee benefit liability 65 45 Defined contribution post-employment liability 21.2 - - Total employee liabilities 17 074 13 862 Defined benefit post-employment asset 21.1 (25) (35) Net amount due to employees 17 049 13 827 -- 194 of 354 -- -B195- 21 EMPLOYEE LIABILITIES AND RELATED ASSETS continued 21.1 Defined benefit post-employment liability The group has financial liabilities in respect of two defined benefit arrangements in South Africa – a plan that provides defined post-retirement medical benefits to retired employees, and a defined benefit pension plan. In terms of these plans, the group is liable to the employees for specific payments on retirement and for any deficit in the provision of these benefits from the plan assets. The liabilities and assets of these plans are reflected as an asset or liability on the statement of financial position. Nature of benefits Pension Medical The pension plan (FirstRand Retirement Fund) provides retired employees with a pension benefit after service. A separate account (the fund) has been established. The account holds assets that are used solely to pay pension benefits. For current pensioners the fund pays a pension to the members and a dependants’ pension to the spouse and eligible children on death of the pensioner. There is also a small number of active members whose benefit entitlement will be determined on a defined benefit basis as prescribed by the rules of the fund. For this small number of defined benefit contributing members in the pension plan (14 members), the group is liable for any deficit in the value of accrued benefits exceeding the assets in the fund earmarked for these liabilities. The liability of the plan in respect of defined contribution members is equal to the member’s share of the fund, which is determined as the accumulation of the member’s contributions (net of deduction for fund expenses and cost of death benefits) as well as any amounts transferred into the fund by the member, increased with the net investment returns earned (positive or negative) on the member’s assets. The fund provides a pension that can be purchased with the member’s fund credit (equal to member contributions at retirement should the member so choose). The medical scheme provides retired employees with medical benefits after service. The employer’s post-employment healthcare liability consists of a commitment to pay a portion of the members’ post-employment medical scheme contributions. This liability is also generated in respect of dependants who are offered continued membership of the medical scheme on the death of the primary member. Members employed on or after 1 December 1998 do not qualify for a post-employment medical subsidy. -- 195 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B196- 21 EMPLOYEE LIABILITIES AND RELATED ASSETS continued Nature of benefits Pension Medical In terms of the existing pensioners in the pension plan, the trustees are responsible for setting the pension increase policy and for granting pension increases subject to the ring-fenced pensioner assets of the fund supporting such increases. Should the pension account in the fund be in deficit to the extent that current pensions in payment cannot be maintained, the group is liable to maintain the nominal value of pensions in payment. The fund also provides death, retrenchment and withdrawal benefits. Governance Pension Medical The pension plan is regulated by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority in South Africa. Responsibility for governance of the plans, including investment decisions, lies with the board of trustees. Contribution categories available to members are jointly determined by the group and board of trustees. The board of trustees must be composed of representatives of the group and plan participants in accordance with the plans’ regulations. The board consists of four representatives of the group and four representatives of the plan participants in accordance with the plans’ regulations. The trustees serve on the board for four years and may be re-elected a number of times. An external auditor performs an audit of the fund on an annual basis and such annual financial statements are submitted to the Registrar of Pension Funds (i.e. to the Financial Sector Conduct Authority). A full actuarial valuation of the pension fund is submitted to the Financial Sector Conduct Authority every three years. The current year’s valuation will be submitted for review. Annual interim actuarial valuations are performed for the trustees and for IAS 19 purposes. At the last valuation date the fund was financially sound. The medical plan is regulated by the registrar of Council for Medical Schemes in South Africa. Governance of the post-employment medical aid subsidy policy lies with the group. The group has established a committee that meets regularly to discuss and review the management of the medical plan scheme and the subsidy. This committee is managed and governed by the FirstRand group financial resources management executive committee and the FirstRand group ALCCO. The committee also considers administration and data management issues and analyses demographic and economic risks inherent in the subsidy policy. -- 196 of 354 -- -B197- 21 EMPLOYEE LIABILITIES AND RELATED ASSETS continued Asset-liability matching strategies The group ensures that the investment positions are managed within an asset and liability matching (ALM) framework that has been developed to achieve long-term investment returns that are in line with the obligations under the schemes. Within this framework, the group’s ALM objective is to match assets to the pension obligations by investing in long-term fixed-interest securities with maturities that match the benefit payments as they fall due. The group actively monitors how the duration and expected yield of the investments match the expected cash outflows arising from the pension obligations. Investments are well diversified so that the failure of any single investment would not have a material impact on the overall level of assets. The trustees of the fund have adopted an investment strategy in respect of the pensioner liabilities that largely follows an 80% exposure in fixed-interest instruments to immunise against interest rate and inflation risk, and 20% exposure to local and foreign growth assets. An overlay comprising 20% exposure of high-quality corporate credit fixed-income instruments is funded through a repo transaction of a portion of the South African government-issued inflation-linked bonds to improve the probability of achieving the performance objective. The fixed-interest instruments consist mainly of long-dated South African government-issued inflation-linked bonds, while the growth assets are allocated to selected local and foreign asset managers. The trustees receive monthly reports on the funding level of the pensioner liabilities and an in-depth attribution analysis in respect of changes in the pensioner funding level. The trustees of the fund aim to apportion an appropriate level of balanced portfolio, conservative portfolio, and inflation-linked and money market assets to match the maturing defined benefit active member liabilities. It should be noted that this is an approximate matching strategy, as elements such as salary inflation and decrement rates cannot be matched. This is, however, an insignificant liability compared to the total liability of the pension fund. Risks associated with the plans Through its defined benefit pension plans and post-employment medical plans, the group is exposed to a number of risks, the most significant of which are detailed below. Asset volatility – Assets are held in order to provide a return to back the plans’ obligations, therefore any volatility in the value of these assets relative to the value of the liabilities would create a deficit. Inflation risk – The plans’ benefit obligations are linked to inflation, and higher inflation will lead to higher liabilities. Consumer price inflation and healthcare cost inflation form part of the financial assumptions used in the valuation. Life expectancy – The plans’ obligations are to provide benefits for the life of the member, so increases in life expectancy will result in an increase in the plans’ liabilities. Demographic movements – The plans’ liabilities are determined based on a number of best estimate assumptions based on the demographic movements of participants, including withdrawal and early retirement rates. This is especially relevant to the post-employment medical aid subsidy liabilities. Should fewer eligible employees withdraw and/or should more eligible employees retire earlier than assumed, the post-employment medical aid liabilities could be understated. -- 197 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B198- 21 EMPLOYEE LIABILITIES AND RELATED ASSETS continued Details of the defined benefit plan assets and fund liability are shown below. 2023 2022 R million Notes Pension Medical * Total Pension Medical * Total Post-employment benefit fund liability Present value of funded obligation 7 784 3 135 10 919 8 453 3 159 11 612 Fair value of plan assets (8 474) (1 818) (10 292) (8 816) (1 915) (10 731) – Listed equity instruments (2 036) - (2 036) (2 460) - (2 460) – Cash and cash equivalents (247) - (247) (234) - (234) – Debt instruments (2 410) - (2 410) (2 561) - (2 561) – Derivatives (13) - (13) (58) - (58) – Qualifying insurance policy - (1 818) (1 818) - (1 915) (1 915) – Other (3 768) - (3 768) (3 503) - (3 503) Total employee (asset)/liability * (690) 1 317 627 (363) 1 244 881 Limitation imposed by IAS 19 asset ceiling 683 - 683 344 - 344 Other - - - - - - Total net post-employment (asset)/liability ** (7) 1 317 1 310 (19) 1 244 1 225 Total amount recognised on the income statement (included in staff costs) 3 (33) 170 137 (39) 129 90 Movement in post-employment benefit fund liability Present value at the beginning of the year (19) 1 244 1 225 13 1 198 1 211 Exchange differences (6) - (6) - - - Current service cost 4 32 36 4 32 36 Net interest (37) 138 101 (43) 97 54 Remeasurements: recognised in OCI 53 (73) (20) 23 (82) (59) – Actuarial gains from changes in demographic - - - 5 - 5 – Actuarial (losses)/gains from financial assumptions (818) (116) (934) (105) 46 (59) – Other remeasurements 871 43 914 123 (128) (5) Benefits paid - (3) (3) (6) (1) (7) Employer contribution (1) (21) (22) (1) - (1) Employee contribution (1) - (1) (9) - (9) Closing balance (7) 1 317 1 310 (19) 1 244 1 225 * The medical plan asset is an insurance policy with a limit of indemnity. The insurance policy is backed by assets held through an insurance cell captive. The excess assets of the cell captive belong to a subsidiary of the group and are recognised in accounts receivable. FirstRand group’s liability is therefore sufficiently funded. ** Total net post-employment (asset) of R7 million (2022: R19 million) reflects the net of a post-employment liability of R18 million (2022: R16 million) and a post-employment asset of R25 million (2022: R35 million) -- 198 of 354 -- -B199- 21 EMPLOYEE LIABILITIES AND RELATED ASSETS continued 2023 2022 R million Pension Medical * Total Pension Medical * Total Movement in the fair value of plan assets: Opening balance 8 816 1 915 10 731 8 823 1 940 10 763 Interest income 895 231 1 126 863 235 1 098 Remeasurements: recognised in OCI (571) (117) (688) (173) (51) (224) Exchange differences 44 - 44 3 - 3 Employer contributions 1 21 22 1 - 1 Employee contributions 1 - 1 9 - 9 Benefits paid and settlements (712) (232) (944) (710) (209) (919) Closing balance 8 474 1 818 10 292 8 816 1 915 10 731 Reconciliation of limitation imposed by IAS 19 asset ceiling Opening balance 344 - 344 425 - 425 Interest income 37 - 37 44 - 44 Change in the asset ceiling, excluding amounts included in interest 302 - 302 (125) - (125) Closing balance 683 - 683 344 - 344 Actual return on plan assets was 12% 11% Included in plan assets were the following: FirstRand Limited ordinary shares with a fair value of 31 - 31 39 - 39 Total 31 - 31 39 - 39 * The medical plan asset is an insurance policy with a limit of indemnity. The insurance policy is backed by assets held through an insurance cell captive. The excess assets of the cell captive belong to a fellow subsidiary of the group and are recognised as an account receivable. FirstRand group’s liability is therefore sufficiently funded. -- 199 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B200- 21 EMPLOYEE LIABILITIES AND RELATED ASSETS continued Each sensitivity analysis is based on changing one assumption while keeping all other remaining assumptions constant. In practice this is unlikely to occur, and changes in some of the assumptions may be correlated. The sensitivity analysis has been calculated in terms of the projected unit credit method and illustrates how the value of the liability would change in response to certain changes in actuarial assumptions. 2023 2022 % Pension Medical Pension Medical The principal actuarial assumptions used for accounting purposes were: Expected rates of salary increases % 8.7 - 8.2 - Discount rate % 12.4 12.1 10.7 12.1 Long-term increase in health costs % - 8.7 - 9.1 The effects of a 1% movement in the assumed health cost rate (medical) and the expected rates of salary (pension) were: Increase of 1% Effect on the defined benefit obligation (R million) 2.6 325.4 3.6 361.0 Effect on the aggregate of the current service cost and interest cost (R million) 0.5 44.3 0.6 49.6 Decrease of 1% Effect on the defined benefit obligation (R million) (2.5) (279.0) (3.4) (305.7) Effect on the aggregate of the current service cost and interest cost (R million) (0.6) (37.8) (0.6) (41.8) The effects of a change in the average life expectancy of a pensioner retiring at age 65: Increase in life expectancy by 1 year Effect on the defined benefit obligation (R million) 237.5 96.9 280.5 104.1 Effect on the aggregate of the current service cost and interest cost (R million) 49.1 12.4 51.3 13.4 Decrease in life expectancy by 1 year Effect on the defined benefit obligation (R million) (236.5) (96.8) (277.9) (103.5) Effect on the aggregate of the current service cost and interest cost (R million) (49.0) (12.4) (50.8) (13.3) Estimated contributions expected to be paid to the plan in the next annual period (R million) 2 - 2 - Net increase in rate used to value pensions, allowing for pension increases (%) 4.9 3.1 3.6 2.8 The weighted average duration of the defined benefit obligation (years) 8.2 10.6 8.9 12.0 -- 200 of 354 -- -B201- 21 EMPLOYEE LIABILITIES AND RELATED ASSETS continued The expected maturity analysis of undiscounted pension and post-employment medical benefits is given below. Between Within 1 and 5 More than R million 1 year years 5 years Total Pension benefits 828 3 468 52 972 57 268 Post-employment medical benefits 217 1 050 22 696 23 963 Total as at 30 June 2023 1 045 4 518 75 668 81 231 Pension benefits 792 3 370 40 607 44 769 Post-employment medical benefits 207 999 24 527 25 733 Total as at 30 June 2022 999 4 369 65 134 70 502 The interest income is determined using a discount rate with reference to high-quality government bonds. Mortality rates The normal retirement age for active members of the pension fund and post-employment medical benefit scheme is between 60 and 65. The mortality rate table used for active members and pensioners of the pension fund and post-employment medical benefits is PA (90)-2. It refers to standard actuarial mortality tables for current and prospective pensioners on a defined benefit plan where the chance of dying after early or normal retirement is expressed at each age for each gender. The two-year age rating allows for the longer than average life expectancy of the retirees compared to general annuitant mortality. In addition, allowance is made for future expected improvements in annuitant mortality based on the income level of the annuitant (on average 0.50% p.a.). The mortality rate table used for the active members of the post-employment medical benefit fund is SA 85-90. It refers to standard actuarial mortality tables for active members on a defined benefit plan where the chance of dying before normal retirement is expressed at each age for each gender. The average life expectancy in years of an employee retiring at age 65 on the reporting date for pension and medical is 17 for males and 21 for females. The average life expectancy of an employee retiring at age 65 in 20 years after the reporting date for pension and medical is 18 for males and 22 for females. -- 201 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B202- 21 EMPLOYEE LIABILITIES AND RELATED ASSETS continued 2023 2022 Pension The number of employees covered by the scheme Active members 2 495 2 387 Pensioners 5 212 5 394 Deferred plan participants 255 260 Total employees 7 962 8 041 Defined benefit obligation amounts due to Benefits vested at the end of the reporting period (R million) 7 784 8 452 Conditional benefits (R million) 257 207 Amounts attributable to future salary increases (R million) 64 69 Other benefits (R million) 7 462 8 175 Medical The number of employees covered by the scheme Active members 2 318 2 545 Pensioners 5 130 5 199 Total employees 7 448 7 744 Defined benefit obligation amounts due to Benefits vested at the end of the reporting period (R million) 2 274 2 266 Benefits accrued but not vested at the end of the reporting period (R million) 861 893 Conditional benefits (R million) 891 930 Other benefits (R million) 2 244 2 229 21.2 Defined contribution post-employment liability R million 2023 2022 Post-employment defined contribution plan Present value of obligation 33 270 30 236 Present value of assets (33 270) (30 236) Net defined contribution liability - - The defined contribution scheme allows active members to purchase a pension on retirement. The purchase price for the pension is determined based on the purchasing member’s demographic details, the pension structure and economic assumptions at time of purchase. Should a member elect to purchase a pension, the group becomes exposed to longevity and other actuarial risks. However, because of the way that the purchase is priced, the employer is not exposed to any asset return risk prior to the election of this option. On the date of the purchase the defined benefit liability and the plan assets will increase for the purchase amount and thereafter the accounting treatment applicable to defined benefit plans will be applied to the purchased pension. It should be noted that the purchase price for a new retiree would be slightly larger than the liability determined on the accounting valuation, as the purchase price allows for a more conservative mortality assumption based on the solvency reserves of the fund. -- 202 of 354 -- -B203- 22 DEFERRED INCOME TAX Movement on the deferred income tax account is shown below. R million 2023 2022 Deferred income tax asset Opening balance 8 028 6 104 Acquisitions of subsidiaries (9) 1 Exchange rate difference 27 40 Release to profit or loss 220 555 Deferred income tax on amounts charged directly to other comprehensive income 394 1 415 Other 9 (87) Total deferred income tax asset 8 669 8 028 Deferred income tax liability Opening balance (692) (887) Disposals of subsidiaries 44 - Exchange rate difference (26) (4) Release to profit or loss (60) 204 Deferred income tax on amounts charged directly to other comprehensive income (2) (1) Other (16) (4) Total deferred income tax liability (752) (692) Net deferred income tax asset 7 917 7 336 -- 203 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B204- 22 DEFERRED INCOME TAX continued Recognised on As at 30 June income statement R million 2023 2022 2023 2022 Deferred income tax asset Tax losses 33 16 9 (10) Provision for loan impairment 4 255 4 234 43 (250) Provision for post-employment benefits 350 328 29 18 Other provisions 1 329 1 467 (138) 591 Cash flow hedges 1 193 880 - 1 Financial instruments 33 16 17 31 Instalment credit assets (200) (186) (15) (9) Accruals 89 59 29 3 Debt instruments designated at FVOCI (124) (103) - - Capital gains tax 365 330 35 93 Equity instruments designated at FVOCI 97 101 - - Foreign currency translation reserve - - (107) (10) Financial Liabilities classified at FVTPL 13 - 13 - Share-based payments 1 471 903 568 370 Deferred revenue liability (276) (153) (123) 26 Intangible assets 61 109 (47) 13 Other (20) 27 (93) (312) Total deferred income tax asset 8 669 8 028 220 555 Deferred income tax liability Provision for loan impairment 147 169 (22) (15) Provision for post-employment benefits 11 13 1 - Other provisions (73) (76) 3 16 Financial instruments - 53 (54) 10 Instalment credit assets (75) (77) 2 240 Accruals (281) (138) (143) (34) Capital gains tax 2 (59) 61 (59) Equity instruments designated at FVOCI 5 3 - - Intangible assets (146) (210) 91 97 Other (342) (370) 1 (51) Total deferred income tax liability (752) (692) (60) 204 Dividends declared by South African entities are subject to shareholders’ withholding tax. The group would therefore incur no additional tax if the total reserves of R172 984 million (2022: R156 820 million) were declared as dividends. The group has not recognised a deferred tax asset amounting to R367 million (2022: R768 million) relating to tax losses because there was insufficient taxable income. None of these losses have an expiry date. The UK has substantially enacted the global minimum Pillar 2 tax regulation, which would impact the UK operations. The group is assessing the impact of applying Pillar 2 tax rules and has applied the mandatory deferred tax exemption in IAS 12. -- 204 of 354 -- -B205- 23 SHORT TRADING POSITIONS R million 2023 2022 Government and government-guaranteed stock 12 480 14 057 Other dated securities 230 553 Undated securities 43 13 Total short trading positions 12 753 14 623 24 CREDITORS, ACCRUALS AND PROVISIONS R million 2023 2022 * - Accounts payable 32 291 21 491 Customer loyalty programme liability ** 2 060 1 981 Fair value hedge interest asset # (504) (551) Withholding tax for employees 848 708 Deferred revenue ** 608 543 Operating lease liability – straight lining of lease payments - (9) Payments received in advance 728 540 Accrued expenses 4 180 3 635 Audit fees accrued 384 297 Contract liabilities ** 100 96 Provisions (including litigations and claims) 2 694 2 197 Total creditors, accruals and provisions 43 389 30 928 * The prior year, fair value hedge liability was reflected as R4 282 million. This amount has been restated, refer to accounting policy note 10.1. ** These balances meet the definition of contract liabilities and a reconciliation of the balance is provided below. The deferred revenue balance relates to service fees that are earned on value-added products provided to customers. These contracts run over a two-year period and the revenue is recognised over the contract period. The customer loyalty programme liability relates to eBucks, and is determined based on the value of unredeemed eBucks in issue that have not been converted to cash or redeemed by the customer. The timing of the customer’s use of these eBucks as reward credits redeemable against future purchases with the group or a loyalty programme strategic partner is purely at the customer’s discretion. # The balance reflected relates to the fair value of the interest rate risk component of the hedged items designated in macro hedge accounting relationships in Aldermore. Reconciliation of contract liabilities R million 2023 2022 Opening balance 2 620 2 476 Increases due to cash received and other increases in contract liabilities 2 475 2 007 Contract modifications - - Revenue recognised that was included in the contract liability balance at the beginning of the period (2 327) (1 863) Closing balance 2 768 2 620 -- 205 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B206- 24 CREDITORS, ACCRUALS AND PROVISIONS continued Reconciliation of provision R million 2023 2022 Opening balance 2 197 1 055 Acquisitions of subsidiaries - - Exchange rate differences 260 (2) Charge to profit or loss 376 1 280 – Additional provisions created 975 1 609 – Unused provisions reversed (599) (329) Utilised (139) (136) Closing balance 2 694 2 197 25 DEPOSITS R million 2023 2022 Category analysis Deposits from customers 1 620 458 1 412 975 – Current accounts 395 075 356 823 – Call deposits 440 392 389 341 – Savings accounts 44 448 34 490 – Fixed and notice deposits 662 525 547 145 – Other deposits from customers 78 018 85 176 Debt securities 209 379 164 366 – Negotiable certificates of deposit 74 522 40 126 – Fixed-rate and floating-rate notes * 132 940 122 825 – Exchange-traded notes 1 917 1 415 Asset-backed securities 34 454 33 206 – Securitisation issuances 30 696 26 193 – Non-recourse deposits 3 758 7 013 Other 58 812 45 425 – Repurchase agreements 19 759 15 183 – Securities lending 4 331 1 526 – Cash collateral and credit-linked notes 32 645 27 213 – SARB funding facility 2 077 1 503 Total deposits 1 923 103 1 655 972 * Included in the balance are two tranches of environmental, social and governance (ESG) bonds of R958 million and R1 017 million which mature on 20 April 2027 and 2029 respectively, and bear interest linked to JIBAR. Under the terms of the ESG bonds, the bank is required to allocate the funding received to ESG projects. If the bank fails to meet these criteria, the interest rate on the ESG bonds is adjusted upwards by 15 bps. -- 206 of 354 -- -B207- 26 OTHER LIABILITIES R million 2023 2022 Lease liabilities 3 026 2 834 Funding liabilities 4 007 5 414 – Preference shares * 935 2 869 – Other 3 072 2 545 Total other liabilities 7 033 8 248 * The preference shares were cumulative, redeemable and non-participating. These preference shares were issued in October 2019 and were redeemed in the current year. 26.1 Other liabilities reconciliation 2023 2022 Funding Funding R million liabilities Lease Total liabilities Lease Total Opening balance 5 414 2 834 8 248 4 860 2 881 7 741 Cash flow movements (1 219) (1 148) (2 367) 2 (1 157) (1 155) – Proceeds from the issue of other liabilities 4 614 - 4 614 1 067 - 1 067 – Redemption of other liabilities (5 114) - (5 114) (842) - (842) – Principal payments towards lease liabilities - (1 012) (1 012) - (1 030) (1 030) – Interest paid (719) (136) (855) (223) (127) (350) Non-cash flow movements (188) 1 340 1 152 552 1 110 1 662 – Fair value movement 21 1 22 34 28 62 – Acquisition of subsidiaries - - - - 106 106 – Transfers to non-current asset and disposal group held for sale - (3) (3) 62 - 62 – Foreign exchange (836) 173 (663) (41) 57 16 – New leases recognised during the year - 1 136 1 136 - 812 812 – Early termination/modification of lease - (113) (113) - (36) (36) – Interest accrued 627 146 773 497 143 640 Total other liabilities 4 007 3 026 7 033 5 414 2 834 8 248 The group’s significant leases relate to property rentals of office premises and the various branch network channels represented by full-service and mini branches, agencies, ATM lobbies as well as Smartboxes. The rentals have fixed monthly payments. Escalation clauses are based on market-related rates and vary between 5% and 12%. The leases are usually for a period of one to five years. The leases are non-cancellable and some of the leases have an option to renew for a further leasing period at the end of the original lease term. Restrictions are more of an exception than the norm and usually relate to the restricted use of the asset for the business purposes specified in the lease contract. For details on the contractual maturity of lease liabilities, refer to Note 37.2.1 – Liquidity risk. -- 207 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B208- 27 TIER 2 LIABILITIES R million Maturity dates Interest rate 2023 2022 Fixed-rate bonds 1 521 12 180 – ZAR denominated 19 April 2026 to 3 June 2026 8.155% – 10.19% 1 430 3 947 – USD denominated 23 April 2023 6.25% - 8 146 – Other currencies 15 December 2026 7.20% 91 87 Floating-rate bonds 15 348 8 757 – ZAR denominated 3 June 2024 to 3-month JIBAR 28 September 2029 +188 bps – 234 bps 14 907 8 340 461 bps – 511 bps above – Other currencies 15 December 2026 relevant reference rate * 441 417 Total Tier 2 liabilities 16 869 20 937 * Monetary policy rate. 27.1 Tier 2 liabilities reconciliation R million 2023 2022 Opening balance 20 937 20 940 Cash flow movements (6 651) (835) – Proceeds from the issue of Tier 2 liabilities 10 486 2 742 – Capital and interest repaid on Tier 2 liabilities * (17 137) (3 577) Non-cash flow movements 2 583 832 – Foreign exchange 815 795 – Fair value hedging adjustment 146 (466) – Interest accrued 1 622 503 Total Tier 2 liabilities 16 869 20 937 * Capital repaid on Tier 2 liability was R15 579 million, and interest repaid was R1 558 million in the current year. -- 208 of 354 -- -B209- 28 SHARE CAPITAL, SHARE PREMIUM AND OTHER RESERVES 28.1 Share capital and share premium Authorised shares 2023 2022 Ordinary shares 6 001 688 450 6 001 688 450 Issued shares 2023 2022 Ordinary Ordinary share Share share Share Number of capital premium Number of capital premium shares R million R million shares R million R million Opening balance 5 609 488 001 56 7 905 5 609 488 001 56 7 973 Shares issued - - - - - - Total issued ordinary share capital and share premium 5 609 488 001 56 7 905 5 609 488 001 56 7 973 Treasury shares (2 900 304) - (45) (2 101 326) - (68) Total issued share capital attributable to ordinary equityholders 5 606 587 697 56 7 860 5 607 386 675 56 7 905 The unissued ordinary shares are under the control of the directors until the next annual general meeting. The shareholding of subsidiaries in FirstRand Limited was 0.05% (2022: 0.04%) of total issued ordinary shares and these shares have been treated as treasury shares. 28.2 Other reserves Other reserves are made up of the following: R million 2023 2022 Regulatory reserves raised by African subsidiaries * 1 205 1 034 General risk reserve raised by African subsidiaries 60 54 Insurance contingency reserve 189 148 FVOCI reserve – debt instruments 329 296 FVOCI reserve – equity instruments (334) (367) Other attributable reserves of associates and joint ventures 101 104 Reserves arising on acquisition of subsidiaries (140) (141) Other reserves 233 150 Total 1 643 1 278 * The balance consists of reserves as required by law in certain jurisdictions where the group operates, namely Eswatini, Mozambique, Nigeria and Tanzania. -- 209 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B210- 29 OTHER EQUITY INSTRUMENTS AND RESERVES Authorised preference shares 2023 2022 A preference shares – unlisted variable rate cumulative convertible redeemable * 198 311 550 198 311 550 B preference shares – listed variable rate non-cumulative non-redeemable 100 000 000 100 000 000 C preference shares – unlisted variable rate convertible non-cumulative redeemable * 100 000 000 100 000 000 D preference shares – unlisted variable rate cumulative redeemable * 100 000 000 100 000 000 * Unissued. Issued preference shares 2023 2022 Ordinary Ordinary equity equity Number of instruments Number of instruments shares R million shares R million B preference shares - - 45 000 000 4 519 Total issued share capital attributable to preference shareholders of the group - - 45 000 000 4 519 Dividends on the B preference shares were calculated at a rate of 75.56% of the prime lending rate of FNB, a division of FirstRand Bank Limited (FRB). Additional Tier 1 capital and other reserves R million Rate 2023 2022 FRB24 3-month JIBAR plus 445 basis points 2 265 2 265 FRB25 3-month JIBAR plus 440 basis points 3 461 3 461 FRB28 3-month JIBAR plus 440 basis points 1 400 1 400 FRB34 3-month JIBAR plus 340 basis points 2 804 - Total additional Tier 1 capital 9 930 7 126 Empowerment Fund Reserve * 2 916 - Total other equity instruments and reserves 12 846 11 645 * The empowerment fund reserve includes the impacts of consolidating the fully vested empowerment vehicles. Refer to Note 35 for more information. -- 210 of 354 -- -B211- 29 OTHER EQUITY INSTRUMENTS AND RESERVES continued FRB24, FRB25, FRB28 and FRB34 FRB’s AT1 capital instruments are perpetual and pay non-cumulative, discretionary coupons on a quarterly basis. The terms and conditions provide for an issuer call option after at least five years, and at every coupon payment date that follows. In addition, at the discretion of the PA, FRB may write off the notes, in whole or in part, with no obligation to pay compensation to the noteholders upon the earlier of: ¾ the PA giving notice that a write-off is required without which the bank will become non-viable; or ¾ a decision being made to inject public sector capital, or equivalent support, without which the bank will become non-viable. The AT1 instruments have been classified as equity, as the terms and conditions do not contain a contractual obligation to pay cash to the noteholders. The total coupon paid during the financial year was R957 million (2022: R593 million). Current tax of R258 million (2022: R166 million) was recognised in the income statement. 30 SUBSIDIARIES AND NON-CONTROLLING INTERESTS The group has a portfolio of integrated financial services businesses comprising FNB, RMB, WesBank and Aldermore. The group operates in South Africa, certain markets in sub-Saharan Africa and the UK and offers a universal set of transactional, lending, investment and insurance products and services. The group’s operations are conducted through its six significant wholly owned subsidiaries: Subsidiary Operation FirstRand Bank Limited SA banking activities and foreign branches in London, Guernsey and India FirstRand EMA Holdings Proprietary Limited Broader Africa subsidiaries FirstRand International Limited (Guernsey) UK banking and hard currency platform FirstRand Insurance Holdings Proprietary Limited Insurance FirstRand Investment Management Holdings Limited Investment management FirstRand Investment Holdings Proprietary Limited Other activities There are no significant restrictions on the ability to transfer cash or other assets to or from entities within the group. -- 211 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B212- 30 SUBSIDIARIES AND NON-CONTROLLING INTERESTS continued 30.1 Acquisitions of subsidiaries Identifiable assets acquired and liabilities assumed at the acquisition date fair value are set out as listed below. Other insignificant acquisitions R million 2023 2022 ASSETS Cash and cash equivalents - 21 Other assets - 14 Property and equipment - 120 Investment property - 58 Deferred income tax asset - 1 Intangible assets - 73 Total assets acquired - 287 LIABILITIES Creditors and accruals - 13 Employee liabilities - 1 Other liabilities - 106 Deferred income tax liability - 1 Total liabilities acquired - 121 Net asset value as at date of acquisition - 166 Total goodwill is calculated as follows: Total cash consideration transferred - - Total non-cash consideration transferred - 168 Less: net identifiable asset value at date of acquisition - (166) Goodwill on acquisition - 2 30.1.1 Transactions that do not result in a change of control in subsidiaries Other insignificant acquisitions R million 2023 2022 Carrying amount of non-controlling interest acquired 67 412 Consideration paid to non-controlling interest acquired (65) (776) – Discharged by cash consideration (170) (866) – Non-cash consideration 105 90 Gain/(loss) recognised directly in equity 2 (364) In the current and prior year, the group increased its shareholding in various subsidiaries of RMB Private Equity Holdings (Pty) Ltd and RMB Private Equity (Pty) Ltd by purchasing the interest previously held by selected non-controlling interests. The gain/(loss) on the transaction was recognised directly in equity as it was a transaction between the owners of the entities in their capacity as owners. -- 212 of 354 -- -B213- 30 SUBSIDIARIES AND NON-CONTROLLING INTERESTS continued 30.2 Disposals of subsidiaries 30.2.1 Disposals of interest in subsidiaries with loss of control Private equity subsidiaries R million 2023 2022 ASSETS Cash and cash equivalents - - Other assets 337 - Total assets disposed of 337 - LIABILITIES Creditors and accruals 11 - Other liabilities 309 - Total liabilities disposed of 320 - Net asset value as at date of disposal 17 - Total gain on disposal is calculated as follows: Total consideration (42) (56) Total cash consideration received (42) - Non-cash consideration - (56) Add: non-controlling share of net asset value at disposal date - - Less: group’s portion of the net asset value on disposal - - Gain on disposal of controlling interest in a subsidiary (25) (56) Cash flow information Discharged by cash consideration 42 - Less: cash and cash equivalents/(overdrafts) disposed of in the subsidiary - - Net cash inflow on disposal of subsidiaries 42 - Disposals in 2023 The group, through is subsidiary RMB Investments and Advisory (RMBIA) (Pty) Ltd, disposed of a private equity subsidiary and realised a profit of R25 million. Disposals in 2022 The group’s subsidiary, RMB Australia (Pty) Ltd was deregistered on 12 March 2022. As such the investment in subsidiary was derecognised. 30.2.2 Disposals that do not result in a change of control The group has not in the current year nor in the prior year disposed of interests in subsidiaries that did not result in a change in control. -- 213 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B214- 30 SUBSIDIARIES AND NON-CONTROLLING INTERESTS continued 30.3 Non-controlling interests The only subsidiaries that give rise to a significant non-controlling interest are FirstRand Namibia Limited and First National Bank of Botswana Holdings Limited. The group holds 100% of the shares in First National Bank of Botswana Holdings Limited. The non-controlling interests recognised by the group result from First National Bank Holdings Botswana Limited’s shareholding in First National Bank Botswana Limited. The non-controlling interests own 30.5% of First National Bank of Botswana Limited. In addition to the above, the group owns less than 100% of the issued share capital of a number of private equity subsidiaries and other investments in the RMB Investments and Advisory (RMBIA) Proprietary Limited subconsolidation. The non-controlling interests recognised by the group result from RMBIA’s shareholding in these subsidiaries. There is no individually significant non-controlling interest. FirstRand Namibia First National Bank of Limited Botswana Limited Country of incorporation Namibia Botswana % ownership held by non-controlling interests 41.0 30.5 % voting rights by non-controlling interests 41.0 30.5 R million 2023 2022 2023 2022 Balances included in the consolidated statement of financial position Total assets 58 326 52 453 41 998 36 536 Balances with central banks * 537 462 719 584 Total liabilities 52 342 46 180 36 718 32 088 Balances included in the consolidated statement of comprehensive income Interest and similar income 4 961 3 327 2 648 1 887 Non-interest revenue 2 278 2 047 2 067 1 881 Profit before tax 2 262 1 867 1 952 1 614 Total comprehensive income 1 567 1 272 1 732 1 150 Amounts attributable to non-controlling interests Dividends paid to non-controlling interests 780 312 290 593 Profit attributable to non-controlling interests 649 527 454 366 Accumulated balance of non-controlling interests 2 421 2 550 1 557 1 314 * Refer to note 7. -- 214 of 354 -- -B215- 31 INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT ACTIVITIES The following table sets out the market value of assets for which the group earns fees as part of providing investment management services but does not recognise on its statement of financial position. R million 2023 2022 Assets under management 212 491 179 905 – Traditional products 185 299 134 826 – Alternative products 27 192 45 079 Traditional products comprise collective investment schemes, exchange-traded funds and discretionary mandates. Alternative products managed by the group include credit funds, private equity funds, structured products and other unregulated funds and mandates. 32 REMUNERATION SCHEMES R million Notes 2023 2022 The charge to profit or loss for share-based payments is as follows: Conditional and deferred incentive plan 2 433 1 452 Amount included in profit or loss 3 2 433 1 452 The purpose of these schemes is to appropriately attract, incentivise and retain managers and employees within the group. In the prior year, the performance vesting conditions attached to the 2019 scheme were not met and part of the obligation relating to awards with market vesting conditions was reversed. -- 215 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B216- 32 REMUNERATION SCHEMES continued Description of the scheme and vesting conditions: Conditional and deferred incentive plans (awards) IFRS 2 treatment Cash settled * Equity settled ** Description The award is a notional share based on the FirstRand Limited share price. The award is a notional share based on the FirstRand Limited share price, which must be settled in FirstRand Limited shares. Vesting conditions These awards vest up to three years after the initial award. The awards vest if the employment and, where applicable, performance conditions are met. Awards which include performance conditions have vesting conditions subject to specified financial performance targets set annually by the group’s remuneration committee. These corporate performance targets (CPTs) are set out below. Valuation methodology The awards are valued using the Black Scholes option pricing model. The awards are cash settled and are repriced at each reporting date. The awards are valued using the Black Scholes option pricing model. The awards are equity settled and measured using the price at grant date. Valuation assumptions Dividend data Management’s estimates of future discrete dividends Market related Interest rate is the risk-free rate of return as recorded on the last day of the financial year, on a funding curve of a term equal to the remaining expected life of the plan. Employee related The weighted average forfeiture rate used is based on historical forfeiture data observed over all schemes. * The UK conditional award for UK-based employees (including Aldermore) differs from the rest of the group. The scheme is based on an initial sterling amount which varies in response to the FirstRand share price. The scheme has a liability of R250 million (2022: R139 million). ** The equity-settled scheme is immaterial, with a SBP reserve of R27 million (2022: R44 million), which all related to Aldermore staff. Corporate performance targets The FirstRand remuneration committee sets the CPTs for each award based on expected macroeconomic conditions, group earnings and returns forecasts over the performance period. These criteria vary from year to year, depending on the expectations for each of the aforementioned variables. For vesting to occur, the criteria must be met or exceeded. If the performance conditions are not met, the award fails. The awards have a graded vesting structure. The level of vesting is correlated to the earnings growth achieved relative to macroeconomic variables or set normalised EPS growth targets and minimum return on equity (ROE) requirements. The vesting outcome is based on the delivery of the performance conditions and this level is finally determined and calculated by the group remuneration committee. The remuneration committee is permitted to adjust the final outcome of the graded vesting level downwards for predetermined issues. In terms of the scheme rules, participants are not entitled to dividends on their conditional share awards during the vesting period. For the 2019 and 2020 awards, 50% of the awards granted to non-senior employees are subject only to continued employment for the award to vest, with the remaining 50% subject to performance conditions. From 2021, awards with only time-based vesting conditions were introduced as a short-term incentive category for staff not eligible for the conditional incentive plans (CIP). These are referred to as the deferred incentive plan (DIP). Awards that include both performance- and time-based vesting conditions are referred to as CIP. The criteria for the expired and currently open schemes are set out below. -- 216 of 354 -- -B217- 32 REMUNERATION SCHEMES continued Expired schemes 2019 (Scheme did not vest at the September 2022 vesting date) – The vesting conditions of the 2019 award are set out below, with the apportionment to vesting without conditions described below. The awards for all top and certain senior management have performance conditions applied to 100% of the award. For all other participants, 50% of the award seeks to drive retention and will vest in three years without performance conditions, provided the participant remains in employment with the group and the remaining 50% of the award remains subject to performance conditions. For the awards subject to performance conditions, graded vesting applies. The awards are subject to the achievement of performance conditions set at award date and these determine the value that will ultimately vest. These performance conditions include a minimum condition to achieve any vesting, a target, a stretch and a super stretch target with linear grading correlated to normalised EPS growth between targets. If the minimum ROE and normalised EPS growth conditions are met, vesting will commence at 70%. If these are not met the award will lapse. Performance conditions Vesting level should both conditions be met ROE target (average over the 3-year performance period)* Normalised earnings per share growth requirement (3-year compound annual growth rate) FirstRand Limited must achieve growth in normalised EPS relative to the South African consumer price index (CPI) plus real GDP growth** on a cumulative basis over the performance period from the base year end, being 30 June 2019, as set out for each vesting level indicated below: Minimum vesting, below which the award lapses 70% ≥20% Cumulative normalised EPS growth rate over 3 years of real GDP growth plus CPI On-target performance 100% ≥20.5% Cumulative normalised EPS growth rate over 3 years of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 1.5% to <3% Stretch target 120% ≥21% Cumulative normalised EPS growth rate over 3 years of real GDP growth plus CPI plus >5% to <7% Super stretch target 120.1 to 150% (maximum vesting) ≥22% Cumulative normalised EPS growth rate over 3 years of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 7% to 10% * The ROE calculation is based on net asset value (NAV) taking into consideration adjustments (if required) resulting from, for example, material dividend policy changes, regulatory changes, IFRS changes or changes in volatile reserves. ** In the event that the three-year compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of real GDP is negative, CPI will be referenced. Linear vesting applies between each vesting level based on the achieved normalised EPS growth rate. The lower of the outcome based on the ROE or the outcome based on earnings growth will apply. During the prior year, it was determined that the group failed to achieve the minimum ROE requirement over the performance period, and the remuneration committee (Remco) notified qualifying employees that the awards with market vesting conditions would consequently not vest. -- 217 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B218- 32 REMUNERATION SCHEMES continued For employees with 50% of the award subject only to continued employment, that portion of the award vested if the employee was still in the employment of the group. Currently open 2020 (Vesting date in September 2023) – The awards for all top and certain senior management have performance conditions applied to 100% of the award. For all other participants, 50% of the award seeks to drive retention and will vest in three years without performance conditions, provided the participant remains in employment of the group. The remaining 50% of the award is subject to performance conditions. For the awards subject to performance conditions, graded vesting applies. The awards are subject to the achievement of performance conditions set at award date and these determine the value that will ultimately vest. These performance conditions include a minimum condition to achieve any vesting, a target, a stretch and a maximum target with linear grading correlated to normalised EPS growth between targets. If the minimum conditions are met, vesting will commence at 70% and if these are not met, the award will lapse. Remco has the right to adjust the vesting level downward by as much as 20% if material negative outcomes for the business occur that are within management control. Examples would include: x issues that materially damaged the group’s businesses, including its reputation; x material enterprise-wide risk and control issues, as recommended to it by the risk, capital management and compliance committee (RCCC); and x concerns regarding adherence to the liquidity and capital management strategies in place. The performance conditions for the 2020 award include prudential targets relating to liquidity and capital ratios, a normalised EPS growth target and an ROE target. The table below further stipulates the performance conditions to be fulfilled by the company and the corresponding vesting level for purposes of calculating the vesting value of the conditional award. To achieve minimum vesting of 70%, the group must exceed the liquidity and capital targets set by the board and measured at 31 March 2023. If the conditions set for 70% vesting are not met, the award lapses and none of the other conditions described below are assessed. For any vesting above 70%, both the ROE and normalised earnings growth targets below must be met. Vesting level* Performance conditions Minimum ROE requirement at 30 June 2023** Normalised earnings per share growth requirement (3-year CAGR) 70.1% to 99.9% For grading above 95%, ROE must be more than cost of equity as at issue date of award, i.e. net income after capital charge (NIACC) positive Grading based on minimum CAGR of 4.3% up to <13.4% 100% ROE must be more than cost of equity as at issue date of award, i.e. NIACC positive Minimum CAGR of 13.4% up to <17.5% (100% vesting only for all growth outcomes in the range above) 100.1% to 119.9% ROE of at least 18% Minimum CAGR of 17.5% up to <22% 120% ROE of at least 20% Minimum CAGR of 22% 120.1% to 150% (maximum vesting of 150%) ROE of at least 22% Minimum CAGR above 22% and up to 28.2% to calculate linear grading up to 150% vesting * Linear grading between these vesting levels based on the growth achieved. ** In the event that the ROE target is not met for the higher vesting level, the vesting outcome will be constrained to the outcome relative to the ROE target even if the earnings growth outcome could result in higher vesting outcomes. -- 218 of 354 -- -B219- 32 REMUNERATION SCHEMES continued 2021 (Vesting date in September 2024) – From 2021, all CIP awards have performance conditions applied to 100% of the award. The group implemented a DIP without performance conditions for certain employees and no longer issues CIP awards with only employment as a condition for vesting. Graded vesting applies to all CIP awards. The awards are subject to the achievement of performance conditions set at award date and these determine the value that will ultimately vest. These performance conditions include a minimum condition to achieve any vesting, a target, a stretch and a maximum (super stretch) target with linear grading correlated to normalised earnings per share growth between targets. Remco has the right to adjust the vesting level downwards by as much as 20% if material negative outcomes for the business occur that are within management control. Examples would include: x issues that materially damaged the group’s businesses, including its reputation; x material enterprise-wide risk and control issues, as recommended to it by the RCCC; x concerns regarding adherence to the liquidity and capital management strategies in place; and x lack of compliance with the group’s climate roadmap over the three-year period. The table below stipulates the performance conditions to be fulfilled by the group and the corresponding vesting level for purposes of calculating the vesting value of the conditional award. If the conditions set for 50% vesting are not met, the award lapses and none of the other conditions described below are assessed. Both performance conditions must be met for vesting to occur. Performance conditions Vesting level should both conditions be met* ROE target Minimum ROE requirement at 30 June 2024 ** Normalised earnings per share growth requirement (3-year CAGR) FirstRand Limited must achieve growth in normalised earnings per share relative to the South African CPI plus real GDP growth # on a cumulative basis over the three-year performance period from the base year end, being 30 June 2021, as set out for each vesting level indicated below: Threshold (minimum vesting, below which the award lapses) 50% ≥17% Cumulative normalised earnings per share growth rate over three years of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 1% On target performance 100% ≥18% Cumulative normalised earnings per share growth rate over three years of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 3% Stretch† 120% ≥20% Cumulative normalised earnings per share growth rate over three years of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 5% Super stretch† 150% ≥20% Cumulative normalised earnings per share growth rate over three years of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 8% * Linear grading between these vesting levels based on the growth achieved. The lower of the vesting outcome based on the ROE or the vesting outcome based on earnings growth will apply. ** The ROE target is measured at 30 June 2024. The ROE calculation is based on NAV taking into consideration adjustments (if required) resulting from, for example, material dividend policy changes, regulatory changes, IFRS changes or changes in volatile reserves. # In the event that the three-year CAGR of real GDP is negative, CPI will be referenced. † For vesting at 120% or above, ROE of ≥20% is required. The vesting level between 120% and 150% will be determined through linear grading linked to the earnings growth CAGR, with the maximum vesting at 150% at a level of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 8% over the three-year period. -- 219 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B220- 32 REMUNERATION SCHEMES continued 2022 (Vesting date in September 2025) ‒ All CIP awards are subject to performance conditions. For all the awards graded vesting applies. The awards are subject to the achievement of performance conditions set at award date and these determine the value that will ultimately vest. These performance conditions include a minimum condition to achieve any vesting, a target, a stretch and a super stretch target with linear grading correlated to normalised earnings per share growth between targets. Remco has the right to adjust the vesting level downwards by as much as 20% if material negative outcomes for the business occur that are within management control. Examples would include: x issues that materially damaged the group’s businesses, including its reputation; x material enterprise-wide risk and control issues, as recommended to it by the risk, capital management and compliance (RCCC) committee; x concerns regarding adherence to the liquidity and capital management strategies in place; and x lack of compliance with the group’s climate roadmap over the three-year period. The table below stipulates the performance conditions to be fulfilled by the group and the corresponding vesting level for purposes of calculating the vesting value of the conditional award. If the conditions set for 50% vesting are not met, the award lapses and none of the other conditions described below are assessed. Both performance conditions must be met for vesting to occur. Performance conditions (both conditions must be met) Vesting level* Minimum ROE requirement** Normalised earnings per share growth requirement (3-year CAGR)# FirstRand Limited must achieve growth in normalised earnings per share relative to the South African CPI plus real GDP growth on a cumulative basis over the three- year performance period from the base year end, being 30 June 2022, as set out for each vesting level indicated below: Threshold (minimum vesting, below which the award lapses) 50% ≥19% Cumulative normalised earnings per share growth rate over 3 years of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 1.5% On-target performance 100% ≥20.5% Cumulative normalised earnings per share growth rate over 3 years of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 2.5% Stretch† 120% ≥22% Cumulative normalised earnings per share growth rate over 3 years of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 5% Super stretch† 150% Cumulative normalised earnings per share growth rate over 3 years of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 9% * Linear grading between these vesting levels based on the earnings growth achieved. The lower of the vesting outcome based on the ROE or the vesting outcome based on earnings growth will apply. ** The ROE target is measured as the average over the three-year performance period. The ROE calculation is based on NAV taking into consideration adjustments (if required) resulting from, for example, material dividend policy changes, regulatory changes, IFRS changes or volatile reserves. # In the event that the three-year CAGR of real GDP is negative, CPI will be referenced. † For vesting at 120% or above, ROE of ≥22% is required. The vesting level between 120% and 150% will be determined through linear grading linked to the earnings growth CAGR, with the maximum vesting at 150% at a level of real GDP growth plus CPI plus 9% over the three-year period. -- 220 of 354 -- -B221- 32 REMUNERATION SCHEMES continued The significant weighted average assumptions used to estimate the fair value of the conditional share awards granted are detailed below. Conditional and deferred incentive plans (FirstRand shares) 2023 2022 Award life (years) 1 – 4 2 – 4 Risk-free rate (%) 8.58 – 9.45 5.03 – 8.44 Conditional and deferred incentive plans (FirstRand shares) Share awards outstanding 2023 2022 Number of awards in force at the beginning of the year (millions) 122.1 103.4 Number of awards granted during the year (millions) 49.1 53.7 Number of awards exercised/released during the year (millions) (16.6) (11.0) – Market value range at date of exercise/release (cents) * 6 017 – 6 726 5 200 – 6 537 – Weighted average (cents) 6 209 6 136 Number of awards forfeited during the year (millions) ** (7.6) (24.0) Number of awards in force at the end of the year (millions) 147.0 122.1 Conditional and deferred incentive plan (FirstRand 2023 2022 Weighted Weighted average average remaining Outstanding remaining Outstanding life awards life awards Awards outstanding # (years) (millions) (years) (millions) Vesting during 2022 - 0.1 0.27 16.8 Vesting during 2023 0.26 66.5 1.33 70.0 Vesting during 2024 1.35 43.4 2.33 35.3 Vesting during 2025 2.39 37.0 - - Total conditional awards 147.0 - 122.1 Number of participants 5 563 5 395 * Market values indicated above include those instances where a probability of vesting is applied to accelerated share award vesting prices due to a no-fault termination, as per the rules of the scheme. ** Scheme vesting during 2022 (i.e. the 2019 award) failed to vest due to the performance conditions attached to the scheme not being achieved. Awards with only service conditions attached to the scheme vested during 2022. # Years referenced in the rows relate to calendar years and not financial years. -- 221 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B222- 33 CONTINGENCIES AND COMMITMENTS R million 2023 2022 Contingencies and commitments Guarantees (endorsements and performance guarantees) 63 894 59 118 Letters of credit 14 108 14 120 Total contingencies 78 002 73 238 Irrevocable commitments 193 026 172 795 Committed capital expenditure* 5 164 5 315 Legal proceedings** 220 219 Other 90 72 Contingencies and commitments 276 502 251 639 * Commitments in respect of capital expenditure and long-term investments approved by the directors. ** There is a small number of potential legal claims against the group, the outcome of which is uncertain at present. These claims are not regarded as material, either on an individual or a total basis, and arise during the normal course of business. On-balance sheet provisions are only raised for claims that are expected to materialise. 33.1 Future minimum lease payments receivable under operating leases where the group is the lessor The group owns various assets that are leased to third parties under non-cancellable operating leases as part of the group’s revenue-generating operations. The minimum future lease payments under non-cancellable operating leases on assets where the group is the lessor are detailed below. 2023 Between More than R million Within 1 year 1 and 5 years 5 years Property 77 270 136 Motor vehicles 1 151 1 927 230 Total operating lease commitments 1 228 2 197 366 2022 Property 86 207 9 Motor vehicles 1 002 1 658 250 Total operating lease commitments 1 088 1 865 259 -- 222 of 354 -- -B223- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS 34.1 Valuation methodology The group has established control frameworks and processes at an operating business level to independently validate its valuation techniques and inputs used to determine its fair value measurements. At an operating business level, valuation specialists are responsible for the selection and implementation of the valuation techniques used to determine fair value measurements, as well as any changes required. Valuation committees comprising representatives from key management have been established within each operating business and at an overall group level. They are responsible for overseeing the valuation control process and considering the appropriateness of the valuation techniques applied in fair value measurement. The valuation models and methodologies are subject to independent review and approval at an operating business level by the required valuation specialists, valuation committees and relevant risk committees annually, or more frequently if considered appropriate. 34.2 Fair value hierarchy and measurements Measurement of assets and liabilities at level 2 and level 3 The table below sets out the valuation techniques applied by the group for recurring fair value measurements of assets and liabilities categorised as level 2 and level 3. Instrument Valuation technique Description of valuation technique and main assumptions Observable inputs ‒ level 2 Unobservable inputs ‒ level 3 Derivative financial instruments Forward rate agreements, forwards and swaps Discounted cash flow Future cash flows are projected using a related forecasting curve or referencing a traded future contract price and then discounted using a market-related discounting curve over the contractual period. The reset date is determined in terms of legal documents. Market interest rates, future contract prices, credit and currency basis curves and spot prices Unobservable market interest rates, credit and currency basis curves Options and equity derivatives Option pricing and industry standard models The models calculate fair value based on input parameters such as share prices, dividends, volatilities, interest rates, equity repo curves and, for multi-asset products, correlations. Unobservable model inputs are determined by reference to liquid market instruments and by applying extrapolation techniques to match the appropriate risk profile. Strike price of the option, market-related discount rate, spot or forward rate, the volatility of the underlying, dividends and listed share prices Volatilities, dividends and unlisted share prices -- 223 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B224- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued Instrument Valuation technique Description of valuation technique and main assumptions Observable inputs ‒ level 2 Unobservable inputs ‒ level 3 Advances to customers Advances under repurchase agreements and other advances Discounted cash flow Future cash flows are discounted using market-related interest rates adjusted for credit inputs over the contractual period. For advances under repurchase agreements, credit inputs are an insignificant input as the advance is fully collateralised. For some advances under repurchase agreements, the amount repayable is referenced to a listed price of an underlying. In the case where the fair value of the credit is not significant year-on-year but may become significant in future, and where the South African counterparties do not have actively traded or observable credit spreads, the group classifies other loans and advances to customers as level 3 in the fair value hierarchy. Market interest rates, credit inputs and listed prices of an underlying Credit inputs and market risk correlation factors Corporate and investment banking book Discounted cash flow Future cash flows are discounted using a market-related interest rates, adjusted for credit inputs. Credit risk is not observable and could have a significant impact on the fair value measurement of these advances. Where credit risk has a significant impact on the fair value measurement, these advances are classified as level 3 in the fair value hierarchy. Market interest rates Credit inputs Investment securities Equities listed in an inactive market Discounted cash flow For listed equities, the listed price is used where the market is active (i.e. level 1). However, if the market is not active and the listed price is not representative of fair value, a valuation technique is used to determine the fair value. The valuation technique will be based on risk parameters of comparable securities and the potential pricing difference in spread and/or price terms with the traded comparable is considered. Future cash flows are discounted using a market-related interest rate. Market interest rates Price earnings (P/E) ratios -- 224 of 354 -- -B225- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued Instrument Valuation technique Description of valuation technique and main assumptions Observable inputs ‒ level 2 Unobservable inputs ‒ level 3 Investment securities continued Unlisted equities P/E model and discounted cash flow For unlisted equities, the earnings included in the model are derived from a combination of historical and budgeted earnings, depending on the specific circumstances of the entity whose equity is being valued. The P/E multiple is derived from current market observations taking into account an appropriate discount rate for unlisted companies. The valuation of these instruments may be corroborated by a discounted cash flow valuation or by the observation of other market transactions that have taken place. Market transactions and market interest rates Growth rates and P/E ratios Unlisted bonds, bonds listed in an inactive market or negotiable certificates of deposit (NCD) Discounted cash flow Future cash flows are discounted using a market-related interest rate adjusted for credit inputs over the contractual period. Where the valuation technique incorporates observable inputs for credit risk or the credit risk is an insignificant input, level 2 of the fair value hierarchy is deemed appropriate. Where the valuation technique incorporates significant inputs for credit risk, level 3 of the fair value hierarchy is deemed appropriate. Market interest rates, credit inputs and market quotes for NCD instruments Credit inputs Treasury bills and other government and government- guaranteed stock Exchange prices; Exchange yields converted into a price using specific debt market bond pricing models; Discounted cash flow Instrument fair values are determined by either marking to exchange traded prices, converting exchange yields into prices by applying the specific debt market trading models, for example JSE/BESA or by discounting the cashflows off an appropriate curve. Market quotes for money market and fixed-income instruments. Market interest rates N/A -- 225 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B226- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued Instrument Valuation technique Description of valuation technique and main assumptions Observable inputs ‒ level 2 Unobservable inputs ‒ level 3 Investment securities continued Non- recourse investments Discounted cash flow Future cash flows are discounted using a discount rate which is determined as a base rate plus a margin. The base rate is determined by legal agreements as either a bond or swap curve. The margin approximates the level of risk attached to the cash flows. When there is a change in the base rate of the market, the valuation is adjusted accordingly. The valuation model is calibrated to reflect transaction price at initial recognition. Market interest rates N/A Investments in funds and unit trusts Third-party valuations For certain investments in funds (such as hedge funds) or unit trusts, where an internal valuation technique is not applied, the group places reliance on valuations from third parties, such as broker quotes or valuations from asset managers. Where considered necessary, the group applies minority and marketability or liquidity discount adjustments to these third-party valuations. Third-party valuations are reviewed by the relevant operating business’s investment committee on a regular basis. Where these underlying investments are listed, third-party valuations can be corroborated with reference to listed share prices and other market data and are thus classified as level 2 of the fair value hierarchy. Equity listed prices Third-party valuations used, minority and marketability adjustments -- 226 of 354 -- -B227- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued Instrument Valuation technique Description of valuation technique and main assumptions Observable inputs ‒ level 2 Unobservable inputs ‒ level 3 Investment securities continued Investment properties Discounted cash flow The fair value of investment properties is determined by obtaining a valuation from an independent professional valuer not related to the group. This fair value is based on a discounted cash flow model which is the sum of the present values of a stream of cash flows into the future, with an appropriate exit or terminal value. Considerations related to above and below market rentals, fluctuating expenses and general property risk are factored into the model. Variables are obtained through surveys and comparable recent market transactions not publicly quoted. Professional valuations are performed every two years and are reviewed internally by management. The fair value was based on unobservable income capitalisation rate inputs. N/A Expected rentals, capitalisation and exit/terminal rates -- 227 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B228- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued Instrument Valuation technique Description of valuation technique and main assumptions Observable inputs ‒ level 2 Unobservable inputs ‒ level 3 Deposits Call and non-term deposits Discounted cash flow or the undiscount ed amount is used Cash flows are discounted with the interest rates derived from the appropriate curve to arrive at the present value. Where the deposit has a demand feature, the undiscounted amount of the deposit is the fair value due to the short-term nature of the instruments. The fair value is not less than the amount payable on demand, i.e. the undiscounted amount of the deposit. Market interest rates N/A Non- recourse deposits and other liabilities Discounted cash flow Future cash flows are discounted using market-related interest rates. Fair value incorporates interest rate risk with no valuation adjustment for own credit risk. Valuation adjustments are affected by changes in the applicable credit ratings of the assets. Where the value of a liability is linked to the performance of an underlying and the underlying is observable, these liabilities are classified as level 2. Market interest rates or performance of underlying Performance of underlying contracts Deposits referencing credit-linked instruments and other deposits Discounted cash flow The related forecasting curve is adjusted for liquidity premiums and business unit margins. The valuation methodology does not take early withdrawals and other behavioural aspects into account. Market interest rates Credit inputs, market risk and correlation factors -- 228 of 354 -- -B229- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued Instrument Valuation technique Description of valuation technique and main assumptions Observable inputs ‒ level 2 Unobservable inputs ‒ level 3 Policyholder liabilities under investment contracts Unit-linked contracts or contracts without fixed benefits Adjusted value of underlying assets The underlying assets related to the contracts are recognised by the group. The investment contracts require the group to use these assets to settle the liabilities. The fair value of investment contract liabilities, therefore, is determined with reference to the fair value of the underlying assets. The fair value is determined using the current unit price of the underlying unitised assets linked to the liability and multiplied by the number of units attributed to the policyholders at reporting date. The fair value of the liability is never less than the amount payable on surrender, discounted for the required notice period where applicable. Spot price of underlying N/A Contracts with fixed and guaranteed terms Discounted cash flow The liability fair value is the present value of future payments, adjusted using appropriate market-related yield curves to maturity. Market interest rates N/A Other Financial assets and liabilities not measured at fair value but for which fair value is disclosed Discounted cash flow Future cash flows are discounted using market-related interest rates and curves adjusted for credit inputs. Market interest rates Credit inputs -- 229 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B230- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued Non-recurring fair value measurements A disposal group and investment in associate were classified as a disposal group held for sale at 30 June 2022. The entirety of the disposal group and investment in associate is subject to IFRS 5 measurement criteria. The disposal group was measured at fair value less costs to sell and categorised as level 3 fair value hierarchy. Further details have been provided in note 14. 34.2.1 Fair value hierarchy The following table presents the fair value hierarchy and applicable measurement basis of assets and liabilities of the group, which are recognised at fair value. 2023 Total fair R million Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 value Assets Recurring fair value measurements Derivative financial instruments 291 84 713 952 85 956 Advances – 63 199 66 726 129 925 Investment securities 122 032 62 590 4 624 189 246 Non-recourse investments 888 2 870 – 3 758 Commodities 17 252 – – 17 252 Investment properties – – 353 353 Non-recurring fair value measurements Disposal groups held for sale – financial assets – – – – Total fair value assets 140 463 213 372 72 655 426 490 Liabilities Recurring fair value measurements Short trading positions 12 273 480 – 12 753 Derivative financial instruments 149 67 728 2 477 70 354 Deposits 1 324 47 656 6 840 55 820 Non-recourse deposits – 3 758 – 3 758 Other liabilities – 78 6 84 Policyholder liabilities under investment contracts – 6 383 – 6 383 Non-recurring fair value measurements Disposal groups held for sale – financial liabilities – – – – Total fair value liabilities 13 746 126 083 9 323 149 152 -- 230 of 354 -- -B231- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued Non-recurring fair value measurements A disposal group and investment in associate were classified as a disposal group held for sale at 30 June 2022. The entirety of the disposal group and investment in associate is subject to IFRS 5 measurement criteria. The disposal group was measured at fair value less costs to sell and categorised as level 3 fair value hierarchy. Further details have been provided in note 14. 34.2.1 Fair value hierarchy The following table presents the fair value hierarchy and applicable measurement basis of assets and liabilities of the group, which are recognised at fair value. 2022 Total fair Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 value 476 64 545 646 65 667 – 48 384 47 299 95 683 109 998 99 613 3 040 212 651 822 6 191 – 7 013 17 580 – – 17 580 – – 698 698 – – – – 128 876 218 733 51 683 399 292 14 614 – 9 14 623 208 62 132 2 207 64 547 1 103 39 821 5 621 46 545 – 7 013 – 7 013 – 68 3 71 – 5 396 – 5 396 – – – – 15 925 114 430 7 840 138 195 -- 231 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B232- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued 34.3 Additional disclosures for level 3 financial instruments 34.3.1 Transfers between fair value hierarchy levels The following represents the significant transfers into levels 1, 2 and 3 and the reasons for these transfers. Transfers between levels of the fair value hierarchy are deemed to occur at the beginning of the reporting period. 2023 Transfers Transfers R million in out Reasons for significant transfers in Level 1 - (679) - Level 2 507 (22) Increased liquidity for derivative financial instruments (options) that are approaching maturity, resulted in transfers from level 3 to level 2 due to the significant inputs becoming more observable during the current period. Level 3 701 (507) Investment securities whose fair value had been observable in a traded market no longer met the criteria for level 1 as the market has become illiquid and the fair value was determined using significant unobservable inputs. Total transfers 1 208 (1 208) -- 232 of 354 -- -B233- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued 34.3 Additional disclosures for level 3 financial instruments 34.3.1 Transfers between fair value hierarchy levels The following represents the significant transfers into levels 1, 2 and 3 and the reasons for these transfers. Transfers between levels of the fair value hierarchy are deemed to occur at the beginning of the reporting period. 2022 Transfers Transfers in out Reasons for significant transfers in 689 (41) The market for certain investment securities has become liquid in the current year which resulted in transfers from level 3 into level 1. 607 (1 405) Increased liquidity in the market for certain investment securities as well as equity-linked deposits that are approaching maturity, resulted in transfers from level 3 to level 2 due to the significant inputs becoming more observable during the current period. 1 446 (1 296) Investment securities and equity-linked deposits whose fair value have been observable in a traded market, no longer met the criteria for level 1 and 2, as the market has become illiquid and the fair value was determined using significant unobservable inputs. 2 742 (2 742) -- 233 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B234- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued 34.3 Additional disclosures for level 3 financial instruments (continued) 34.3.2 Changes in level 3 instruments with recurring fair value measurements The following table shows a reconciliation of the opening and closing balances for assets and liabilities measured at fair value on a recurring basis classified as level 3 in terms of the fair value hierarchy. Derivative financial Investment Investment R million assets Advances securities properties Balance as at 30 June 2021 1 206 34 218 3 165 659 Gains or losses recognised in profit or loss (30) 1 971 256 (19) Losses recognised in other comprehensive income – – 8 – Purchases, sales, issue and settlements (517) 10 394 340 – Acquisitions/disposals of subsidiaries – – (15) 58 Net transfer to level 3 (13) – (702) – Exchange rate differences – 716 (12) – Balance as at 30 June 2022 646 47 299 3 040 698 Gains or losses recognised in profit or loss 1 030 6 145 401 (25) Gains recognised in other comprehensive income – – 38 – Purchases, sales, issue and settlements (334) 12 137 373 – Acquisitions/disposals of subsidiaries – – 15 (320) Net transfer (to)/ from level 3 (390) – 701 – Exchange rate differences – 1 145 56 – Balance as at 30 June 2023 952 66 726 4 624 353 Decreases in level 3 assets and liabilities are included in brackets. Decreases in the value of assets are the result of losses, sales and settlements or the disposal of subsidiaries. Decreases in the value of liabilities are the result of gains, settlements or the disposal of subsidiaries. Gains or losses on advances classified as level 3 of the hierarchy comprise gross interest income on advances, fair value of credit adjustments and adjustments due to changes in currency and base rates. These instruments are funded by liabilities whereby the inherent risk is hedged by interest rate or foreign currency swaps. The corresponding gross interest expense is not disclosed in the fair value, note as these items are typically measured at amortised cost. -- 234 of 354 -- -B235- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued 34.3 Additional disclosures for level 3 financial instruments 34.3.1 Changes in level 3 instruments with recurring fair value measurements The following table show a reconciliation of the opening and closing balances for assets and liabilities measured at fair value on a recurring basis classified as level 3 in terms of the fair value hierarchy. Short term Derivative trading financial Other positions liabilities liabilities Deposits – 1 595 2 4 471 – 1 341 1 122 – – – – 9 (328) – (241) – – – – – (401) – 1 266 – – – 3 9 2 207 3 5 621 – 1 553 5 897 – – – – (9) (1 166) – 312 – – (2) – – (117) – – – – – 10 – 2 477 6 6 840 -- 235 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B236- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued 34.3.2 Unrealised gains or losses on level 3 instruments with recurring fair value measurements The valuation models for level 3 assets or liabilities typically rely on a number of inputs that are not readily observable, either directly or indirectly. Thus, the gains or losses presented below include changes in the fair value related to both observable and unobservable inputs. The table below presents the total gains or losses relating to the remeasurement of assets and liabilities carried at fair value on a recurring basis classified as level 3 that are still held at reporting date. With the exception of interest on funding instruments designated at FVTPL and FVOCI debt instruments, all gains or losses are recognised in NIR. 2023 2022 Gains/(losses) Gains/(losses) Gains/(losses) Gains/(losses) recognised recognised recognised recognised in the in other in the in other income comprehensive income comprehensive R million statement income statement income Assets Derivative financial instruments 640 – 117 – Advances * 5 509 – 1 525 – Investment securities 419 8 515 – Investment properties (25) – (19) – Total 6 543 8 2 138 – Liabilities Derivative financial instruments (1 448) – (1 268) – Deposits (1 053) – (109) – Other liabilities – – 1 – Short trading positions – – (1) – Total (2 501) – (1 377) – * Mainly accrued interest on fair value advances and movements in interest rates and foreign currency that have been economically hedged. These advances are primarily classified as level 3, as credit spreads could be a significant input and are not observable for loans and advances in most of RMB’s key markets. Inputs relating to interest rates and foreign currencies are regarded as observable. -- 236 of 354 -- -B237- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued 34.3.3 Effect of changes in significant unobservable assumptions of level 3 financial instruments to reasonably possible alternatives The table below illustrates the sensitivity of the significant inputs when changed to reasonably possible alternative inputs. Asset/liability Unobservable input to which reasonably possible changes are applied Reasonably possible changes applied Derivative financial instruments Volatilities, yields, interest rates, credit spreads A 10% relative stress [i.e.: (1 ± 10%) * base input] of the following base inputs: Exposure Unobservable Input Options Volatility Nominal Bonds Yield Inflation Bonds Real Yield Currency basis Rate Curve Credit Credit spreads Interest rates Rate Curve Advances Credit migration matrix The PD adjusted either upwards or downwards in relation to the base case. Investment securities Credit, growth rates or P/E ratios of unlisted investments Increased and decreased by between 7% and 10%, depending on the nature of the instrument. Investment properties Escalation rates applied to rentals and discount rates Expected rentals are adjusted for comparable rentals. A range of capitalisation rates was used to assess reasonability of the rate(s) used. Deposits Credit inputs, correlation and devaluation parameters The sensitivity to credit risk has been assessed in the same way as for advances, using the credit migration matrix, with the deposit representing the cash collateral component thereof. -- 237 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B238- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued 34.3.3 Effect of changes in significant unobservable assumptions of level 3 financial instruments to reasonably possible alternatives continued 2023 2022 Reasonably possible Reasonably possible alternative fair value alternative fair value Using Using Using Using more more more more positive negative positive negative Fair assump- assump- Fair assump- assump- R million value tions tions value tions tions Assets Derivative financial instruments 952 1 029 875 646 703 589 Advances 66 726 66 847 66 614 47 299 47 366 47 231 Investment securities 4 624 4 831 4 433 3 040 3 186 2 908 Investment properties 353 389 323 698 703 520 Total financial assets measured at fair value in level 3 72 655 73 096 72 245 51 683 51 958 51 248 Liabilities Derivative financial instruments 2 477 2 394 2 542 2 207 2 114 2 305 Deposits 6 840 6 686 6 995 5 621 5 593 5 648 Short trading positions – – – 9 9 9 Other liabilities 6 5 7 3 3 3 Total financial liabilities measured at fair value in level 3 9 323 9 085 9 544 7 840 7 719 7 965 -- 238 of 354 -- -B239- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued 34.4 Financial instruments not measured at fair value The following represents the fair values of financial instruments not carried at fair value in the statement of financial position, but for which fair value is required to be disclosed. For all other financial instruments, the carrying value is equal to or a reasonable approximation of the fair value. 2023 Total Carrying fair R million value value Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Assets Advances 1 409 450 1 410 802 - 148 220 1 262 582 Investment securities 226 135 219 592 133 289 74 409 11 894 Total financial assets at amortised cost 1 635 585 1 630 394 133 289 222 629 1 274 476 Liabilities Deposits 1 863 525 1 861 259 2 292 1 433 571 425 396 Other liabilities 3 923 3 923 1 305 1 383 1 235 Tier 2 liabilities 16 869 16 953 - 16 953 - Total financial liabilities at amortised cost 1 884 317 1 882 135 3 597 1 451 907 426 631 2022 Assets Advances 1 238 641 1 246 930 - 148 282 1 098 648 Investment securities 162 485 156 639 107 835 38 550 10 254 Total financial assets at amortised cost 1 401 126 1 403 569 107 835 186 832 1 108 902 Liabilities Deposits 1 602 414 1 603 572 567 1 259 157 343 848 Other liabilities 5 343 5 352 - 4 303 1 049 Tier 2 liabilities 20 937 21 111 - 21 111 - Total financial liabilities at amortised cost 1 628 694 1 630 035 567 1 284 571 344 897 34.5 Day 1 profit or loss The following table represents the aggregate difference between transaction price and fair value based on a valuation technique yet to be recognised in profit or loss. R million 2023 2022 Opening balance 343 108 Day 1 profits or losses not initially recognised on financial instruments in the current year 237 369 Amount recognised in profit or loss as a result of changes which would be observable by market participants (369) (134) Closing balance 211 343 -- 239 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B240- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued 34.6 Financial instruments designated at fair value through profit or loss Financial instruments designated at fair value through profit or loss Different methods are used to determine the current period and cumulative changes in fair value attributable to credit risk due to the differing inherent credit risk of these instruments. These are the methods used. Financial assets Advances The change in credit risk is the difference between the fair value of advances, based on the original credit spreads (as determined using the group’s credit spread pricing matrix), and the fair value of advances based on the most recent credit inputs where there has been a change in the credit risk of the counterparty. The group uses its own annual credit review process to determine if there has been a change in the credit rating or PD of the counterparty. Investment securities The change in fair value due to credit risk for investments designated at FVTPL is calculated by stripping out the movements that result from a change in market factors that give rise to market risk. The change in fair value due to credit risk is then calculated as the balancing figure, after deducting the movement due to market risk from the total movement in fair value. Financial liabilities Determined with reference to changes in the mark-to-market yields of own issued bonds. The change in fair value of financial liabilities due to changes in credit risk is immaterial. -- 240 of 354 -- -B241- 34 FAIR VALUE MEASUREMENTS continued 34.6.1 Financial assets designated at fair value through profit or loss The group has designated certain financial assets at FVTPL that would otherwise have been measured at amortised cost or FVOCI. The table below contains details on the change in credit risk attributable to these financial assets. Losses are indicated in brackets. 2023 Change in fair value due to credit risk Fair Mitigated Current R million value credit risk period Cumulative Advances 13 457 772 (79) 273 Investment securities 9 415 - - - Total 22 872 772 (79) 273 2022 Advances 10 480 1 080 (88) 236 Investment securities 8 274 - - - Total 18 754 1 080 (88) 236 Losses are included in brackets 34.6.2 Financial liabilities designated at fair value through profit or loss 2023 2022 Contractually Contractually payable at payable at R million Fair value maturity Fair value maturity Deposits 6 808 6 123 8 959 8 619 Non-recourse deposits 3 758 2 426 7 013 5 283 Other liabilities 84 84 71 71 Policyholder liabilities under investment contracts 6 383 6 383 5 396 5 396 Total 17 033 15 016 21 439 19 369 34.7 Total fair value income included in profit or loss for the year R million 2023 2022 Total fair value income for the year has been disclosed as: Fair value gains and losses included in non-interest revenue * 8 551 6 835 Fair value of credit of advances included in impairment of advances 202 (541) * Refer to note 2.3. -- 241 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B242- 35 SEGMENT INFORMATION 35.1 Reportable segments Segment reporting Group’s chief operating decision maker Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Identification and measurement of operating segments Aligned to internal reporting provided to the CEO and reflects the risks and rewards related to the segments’ specific products and services offered in their specific markets. Operating segments of which total revenue, absolute profit or loss for the period or total assets that constitute 10% or more of all the segments’ revenue, profit or loss or total assets are reported separately. Major customers The FirstRand group has no major customer as defined (i.e. revenue from the customer exceeds 10% of total revenue) and is therefore not reliant on revenue from one or more major customers. Reportable segments RETAIL AND COMMERCIAL Products and services Footprint FNB FNB represents FirstRand’s activities in the retail and commercial segments in South Africa and broader Africa. FNB offers a diverse set of financial products and services to market segments including retail (personal and private), SMEs, business, agriculture, medium corporate, and public sector entities. FNB’s products cover the entire spectrum of financial services – transactional, lending, insurance, investment management and savings. Products include mortgage loans and commercial property finance; credit and debit cards (card issuing); personal loans (including loans offered by DirectAxis); debtor and leveraged finance; securities-based lending; foreign exchange; funeral, credit life, life- and short term insurance policies; and savings and investment products. Services include transactional and deposit taking, card-acquiring, credit facilities, insurance, trust and fiduciary services, rewards programme (eBucks), FNB Connect (a mobile virtual network operator), merchant services (card acquiring) FNB operates in South Africa, Namibia, Botswana, Lesotho, Eswatini, Zambia, Mozambique and Ghana. The operations of FNB Tanzania were taken over by Exim Bank on 7 July 2022. -- 242 of 354 -- -B243- 35 SEGMENT INFORMATION continued Reportable segments Products and services Footprint FNB and cash management solutions. FNB’s distribution channels include the branch network and other physical representation points, ATMs, call centres, an app, cellphone banking (USSD) and online banking. WesBank WesBank represents the group’s asset-based finance activities and in the retail, commercial and corporate segments in South Africa. It is a leading providers of vehicle finance and also provides fleet management services. MotoVantage provides VAPS related to vehicle ownership. These include maintenance and service plans, warranties, and credit life and shortfall cover. WesBank operates in South Africa. CORPORATE AND INSTITUTIONAL RMB RMB represents the group’s activities in the corporate and institutional segments in South Africa and on the broader African continent. In addition it has niche offerings in the UK and India, and a broker-dealer business and representative office in the USA. RMB offers corporate finance, leveraged finance, resource sector solutions, infrastructure sector solutions, real estate finance, debt capital markets, debt trade solutions, sponsor services, corporate broking, loan syndications, coverage, advisory, corporate transactional banking and principal investments. From a markets perspective it offers market making, financial risk management and investment across interest rate, currency, commodity, equity and credit asset classes as well as execution, asset financing, custody and clearing services. The results of Ashburton Investments, the group’s asset management business, are also reported as part of RMB. RMB operates in South Africa, Namibia, Botswana, Eswatini, Lesotho, Mozambique, Zambia, Ghana and Nigeria, and manages FirstRand Bank’s representative offices in Kenya, Angola Shanghai and New York. RMB has niche offerings in the UK (London Branch) and India. It has established a broker-dealer business in the USA. -- 243 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B244- 35 SEGMENT INFORMATION continued ALDERMORE Aldermore The UK operations include Aldermore Bank and MotoNovo (front and back books). The portfolio consists of specialist lending for property finance (individuals and landlords), structured and specialist finance for SMEs, motor finance (provided by MotoNovo), and retail and business savings products. The UK operations are funded mainly by retail deposits from UK savers. With no branch network, Aldermore serves customers and intermediary partners online and telephonically, with motor finance offered through a network of dealerships across the UK. Aldermore and MotoNovo operate in the UK CENTRE (INCLUDING GROUP TREASURY) Centre (including Group Treasury) The Centre represents group-wide functions, including Group Treasury, Group Finance, Group Tax, Enterprise Risk Management (ERM), Group Compliance and Group Internal Audit. The reportable segment includes all management accounting and consolidated entries. The total operational performance of MotoNovo’s back book (i.e. business written prior to the integration with Aldermore. 35.2 Description of normalised adjustments Normalised adjustments The group presents normalised earnings which take into account non-operational and accounting anomalies. Normalised earnings are the measurement basis used by the chief operating decision maker (CODM) to manage the group. Normalised earnings adjustments include reallocation entries where amounts are moved between income statement lines and lines of the statement of financial position, without having an impact on the IFRS profit or loss for the year or total assets and total liabilities reported in terms of IFRS. Other normalised adjustments have an impact on the profit or loss reported for the period. -- 244 of 354 -- -B245- 35 SEGMENT INFORMATION continued Normalised adjustments Consolidated private equity subsidiaries In accordance with IFRS, operating costs of consolidated private equity subsidiaries are included in profit or loss as part of operating expenses. When calculating normalised results, these operating costs are reclassified to NIR, where income earned from these entities is included. This presentation of net income earned from consolidated private equity subsidiaries more accurately reflects the underlying economic substance of the group’s relationship with these entities. FirstRand shares held for client trading activities The group invests in FirstRand shares to offset its exposure as a result of client trading positions. Depending on the nature of the client trading position and resulting risks, FirstRand shares may be held long or sold short by the group. In terms of IAS 32, FirstRand shares held by the group are deemed to be treasury shares for accounting purposes. For the statement of financial position, the cost price of FirstRand shares held long is deducted from equity and the consideration received from selling FirstRand shares short is added back to equity. All gains and losses on FirstRand shares are reversed to profit or loss. In addition, one of the group’s joint ventures also holds FirstRand shares for client trading activities. In terms of IAS 32, profits or losses cannot be recognised on an entity’s own equity instruments. The group’s portion of the fair value change in the FirstRand shares is, therefore, deducted from equity-accounted earnings and the carrying value of the investment recognised using the equity-accounted method. The shares held by the joint venture are not deducted from equity. Changes in the fair value of FirstRand shares and dividends declared on these shares affect the fair value of client trading positions reflected in the statement of financial position, unless the client trading position is itself an equity instrument. The change in the fair value of client trading positions is recognised in profit or loss. However, because of the rules relating to treasury shares and the elimination of upstream and downstream profits when equity accounting is applied, the corresponding fair value changes (or the group’s portion of the fair value changes) in the FirstRand shares held to match client trading positions are reversed or eliminated. This results in a mismatch in the overall equity and profit or loss of the group. For purposes of calculating normalised results, the adjustments described above are reversed and FirstRand shares held for client trading positions are treated as issued to parties external to the group. Where the client trading position is itself an equity instrument, neither gains nor losses on client trading positions, or FirstRand shares held to hedge these, are reflected in profit or loss or in the statement of financial position. -- 245 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B246- 35 SEGMENT INFORMATION continued Normalised adjustments Margin-related items included in fair value income In terms of IFRS, the group is either required to or has elected to measure certain financial assets and liabilities at FVTPL. In terms of the group’s IFRS accounting policies, the gains or losses on these assets and liabilities are included in fair value income within NIR. This results in NIR including gains or losses that are related to lending, borrowing and economic interest rate hedges. In order to reflect the economic substance of these amounts, the amount of fair value income that relates to margin is presented in NII in the normalised results. The amount reclassified from NIR to NII includes the following items: ¾ the margin on the component of the wholesale advances book in RMB that is measured at FVTPL; ¾ fair value gains on derivatives that are used as interest rate hedges but which do not qualify for hedge accounting; and ¾ currency translations and associated costs inherent to the US dollar funding and liquidity pool. IAS 19 remeasurement of plan assets In terms of IAS 19, interest income is recognised on the plan assets and set off against staff costs in the income statement. All other remeasurements of plan assets are recognised in OCI. In instances where the plan asset is a qualifying insurance policy, which has a limit of indemnity, the fair value of the plan asset is limited to that limit of indemnity. The limit of indemnity continually reduces as payments are made in terms of the insurance policy. After the recognition of interest income on the plan asset, any further adjustment required to revalue the plan asset to the limit of indemnity is recognised in OCI. To the extent, therefore, that interest income on plan assets results in an increase in the fair value of the plan asset above the limit of indemnity, a downward fair value measurement is recognised in OCI. Economically, the value of the plan asset has simply reduced with claims paid. Normalised results are adjusted to reflect this by increasing staff costs to the value of the interest on the plan assets and increasing OCI. -- 246 of 354 -- -B247- 35 SEGMENT INFORMATION continued Normalised adjustments Realisations on the sale of private equity subsidiaries In terms of Circular 01/2023 Headline Earnings, gains or losses from the sale of subsidiaries are excluded from headline earnings. The circular includes specific industry rules. Rule 1 allows entities to include in headline earnings gains or losses associated with private equity investments that are associates or joint ventures, which form part of trading or operating activities. This industry rule, however, does not apply to gains or losses associated with private equity investments that are subsidiaries. The group includes gains or losses on the sale of private equity subsidiaries in normalised results to reflect the nature of these investments. Cash-settled share-based payments and the economic hedge The group entered into various TRS with external parties to economically hedge itself against the exposure to changes in the FirstRand share price associated with the group’s share schemes. In accordance with IFRS 2, the expense resulting from these share option schemes is recognised over the vesting period of the schemes. This leads to a mismatch in the recognition of the profit or loss of the hedge and the SBP expense. When calculating normalised results, the group defers a portion of the recognition of the fair value gain or loss on the hedging instrument for the specific reporting period to the period in which the IFRS 2 impact will manifest in the group’s results. This reflects the economic substance of the hedge and associated IFRS 2 impact for the group for the share schemes that are not hedge accounted. In addition, the portion of the SBP expense which relates to the remeasurement of the liability arising from changes in the share price is reclassified from operating expenses into NIR in accordance with the economics of the transaction. The SBP expense included in operating expenses that remains is equal to the grant date fair value of the awards given. Consolidation of fully vested empowerment vehicles In terms of IFRS 10, when assessing if a structured entity is controlled by another entity, it must consider whether the sponsoring entity was instrumental in the design and purpose of the mandate and operational parameters of the entity being evaluated, and whether benefits are obtained. Where both these requirements are met, the sponsoring entity is deemed to have control over the entity. FirstRand’s BEE transaction is fully vested and distributed to the B-BBEE beneficiaries, which include the empowerment trusts. Although the trustees are empowered and responsible for making investment decisions and disbursements to beneficiaries, as FirstRand was instrumental in the initial design, and obtains non-financial benefits, namely BEE ownership points, in terms of IFRS 10, the group is deemed to have control and therefore consolidates the empowerment trusts. For the purpose of calculating normalised results the consolidation of the trusts is reversed as the assets, liabilities and returns within the trusts are not for the benefit of FirstRand shareholders, either on distribution or dissolution. Headline earnings adjustments All adjustments that are required by Circular 01/2023 Headline Earnings in calculating headline earnings are included in normalised earnings on a line-by-line basis based on the nature of the adjustment. The description and amount of these adjustments are provided in the reconciliation between headline earnings and IFRS profit. -- 247 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B248- 35 SEGMENT INFORMATION continued 2023 Retail and commercial FNB FNB Broader R million FNB SA Africa WesBank Net interest income before impairment of advances 39 093 5 139 5 098 Impairment charge (6 373) (371) (1 728) Net interest income after impairment of advances 32 720 4 768 3 370 Non-interest revenue 33 405 4 917 3 504 Net income from operations 66 125 9 685 6 874 Operating expenses (36 880) (6 578) (4 697) Share of profit of associates and joint ventures after tax 85 - 327 Income before tax 29 330 3 107 2 504 Indirect tax (809) (205) (53) Profit for the year before tax 28 521 2 902 2 451 Income tax expense (7 700) (1 003) (580) Profit for the year 20 821 1 899 1 871 The income statement includes Staff expenditure * (23 601) (3 528) (2 145) Depreciation (2 428) (405) (817) Amortisation (61) (20) (20) Net impairment charges (179) (4) 10 Non-interest revenue includes the following external revenue from contracts with customers ** Banking fees and commissions 29 135 4 888 737 Non-banking fees and commissions 773 113 10 Insurance income (excluding risk-related income) 927 139 395 Management, trust and fiduciary fees 1 290 33 537 Other non-interest revenue from customers 1 260 35 550 The statement of financial position includes Investments in associated companies 481 - 2 810 Investments in joint ventures - - 6 Total assets 485 094 62 058 163 851 Total liabilities͓ 458 116 58 142 161 005 The segmental analysis is based on the management accounts for the respective segments. * Staff expenditure has been presented separately in line with the JSE’s report on the proactive monitoring of financial statements recommendation. ** The vast majority of external revenue from contracts with customers was recognised at a point in time. # Total liabilities are net of interdivisional balances. -- 248 of 354 -- -B249- 2023 Corporate and institutional Centre Retail (including FirstRand FirstRand and Group group – Normalised group – commercial RMB Aldermore Treasury) normalised adjustments IFRS 49 330 11 315 13 236 4 735 78 616 (2 179) 76 437 (8 472) (551) (2 415) 489 (10 949) - (10 949) 40 858 10 764 10 821 5 224 67 667 (2 179) 65 488 41 826 14 745 1 357 (4 558) 53 370 1 944 55 314 82 684 25 509 12 178 666 121 037 (235) 120 802 (48 155) (13 171) (7 032) (282) (68 640) (109) (68 749) 412 520 11 (450) 493 (6) 487 34 941 12 858 5 157 (66) 52 890 (350) 52 540 (1 067) (226) (383) 44 (1 632) - (1 632) 33 874 12 632 4 774 (22) 51 258 (350) 50 908 (9 283) (3 275) (1 101) 1 466 (12 193) (3) (12 196) 24 591 9 357 3 673 1 444 39 065 (353) 38 712 (29 274) (7 221) (3 562) (2 553) (42 610) 274 (42 336) (3 650) (172) (202) (21) (4 045) - (4 045) (101) (81) (4) (490) (676) - (676) (173) (8) - 215 34 (403) (369) 34 760 4 983 211 (37) 39 917 - 39 917 896 61 51 58 1 066 - 1 066 1 461 - 3 7 1 471 - 1 471 1 860 701 - (2) 2 559 - 2 559 1 845 (2 270) 53 2 176 1 804 (36) 1 768 3 291 4 626 - 2 483 10 400 - 10 400 6 3 067 - (16) 3 057 48 3 105 711 003 720 698 477 424 385 720 2 294 845 2 765 2 297 610 677 263 706 722 440 574 275 370 2 099 929 - 2 099 929 -- 249 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B250- 35 SEGMENT INFORMATION continued 2022† Retail and commercial FNB FNB Broader R million FNB SA Africa WesBank Net interest income before impairment of advances 34 511 3 969 4 877 Impairment charge (4 770) (168) (1 402) Net interest income after impairment of advances 29 741 3 801 3 475 Non-interest revenue 29 971 4 453 3 378 Net income from operations 59 712 8 254 6 853 Operating expenses (32 948) (5 791) (5 022) Share of profit of associates and joint ventures after tax 59 - 476 Income before tax 26 823 2 463 2 307 Indirect tax (680) (164) (37) Profit for the year before tax 26 143 2 299 2 270 Income tax expense (7 312) (846) (636) Profit for the year 18 831 1 453 1 634 The income statement includes Staff expenditure * (20 161) (3 107) (2 100) Depreciation (2 381) (409) (845) Amortisation (152) (14) (31) Net impairment charges (50) 1 (31) Non-interest revenue includes the following external revenue from contracts with customers ** Banking fees and commissions 27 103 4 285 690 Non-banking fees and commissions 761 91 11 Insurance income (excluding risk-related income) 871 125 403 Management, trust and fiduciary fees 1 323 - 537 Other non-interest revenue from customers 590 21 468 The statement of financial position includes Investments in associated companies 770 - 2 732 Investments in joint ventures - - 16 Total assets # 449 722 56 045 145 798 Total liabilities͓ † 426 894 53 275 144 442 The segmental analysis is based on the management accounts for the respective segments. * Staff expenditure has been presented separately in line with the JSE’s report on the proactive monitoring of financial statements recommendation. ** The vast majority of external revenue from contracts with customers was recognised at a point in time. # Restated. † Total liabilities are net of interdivisional balances. -- 250 of 354 -- -B251- 2022† Corporate and institutional Centre Retail (including FirstRand FirstRand and Group group – Normalised group – commercial RMB Aldermore Treasury) normalised adjustments IFRS 43 357 9 074 10 707 4 718 67 856 (1 481) 66 375 (6 340) 413 (1 159) 6 (7 080) - (7 080) 37 017 9 487 9 548 4 724 60 776 (1 481) 59 295 37 802 12 193 702 (3 841) 46 856 1 392 48 248 74 819 21 680 10 250 883 107 632 (89) 107 543 (43 761) (11 329) (5 852) (82) (61 024) 255 (60 769) 535 1 458 21 (508) 1 506 (15) 1 491 31 593 11 809 4 419 293 48 114 151 48 265 (881) (194) (285) (73) (1 433) - (1 433) 30 712 11 615 4 134 220 46 681 151 46 832 (8 794) (3 252) (939) 858 (12 127) (66) (12 193) 21 918 8 363 3 195 1 078 34 554 85 34 639 (25 368) (6 350) (3 361) (2 002) (37 081) 460 (36 621) (3 635) (136) (214) (11) (3 996) - (3 996) (197) (154) (14) (466) (831) - (831) (80) (5) - (30) (115) (195) (310) 32 078 4 220 154 (32) 36 420 - 36 420 863 58 31 24 976 - 976 1 399 - 70 31 1 500 - 1 500 1 860 713 - (2) 2 571 - 2 571 1 079 250 36 (81) 1 284 124 1 408 3 502 3 669 123 884 8 178 - 8 178 16 2 564 - (16) 2 564 54 2 618 651 565 621 725 365 767 360 588 1 999 645 (76) 1 999 569 624 611 608 635 338 250 247 364 1 818 860 - 1 818 860 -- 251 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B252- 35 SEGMENT INFORMATION continued Geographical segments 2023 South Broader United R million Africa Africa Kingdom Other Total Net interest income after impairment 45 427 8 081 11 482 498 65 488 Non-interest revenue 46 664 7 295 1 803 39 55 801 – Non-interest revenue from contracts – with customers 38 818 6 136 576 58 45 588 – Other non-interest revenue 7 369 1 159 1 216 (18) 9 726 – Share of profits of associates and – joint ventures after tax 477 - 11 (1) 487 Non-current assets * 33 259 2 757 9 272 3 45 291 2022 Net interest income after impairment 42 609 6 440 9 973 273 59 295 Non-interest revenue 41 854 6 532 1 159 194 49 739 – Non-interest revenue from contracts – with customers 37 060 5 323 447 45 42 875 – Other non-interest revenue 3 322 1 209 691 151 5 373 – Share of profits of associates and – joint ventures after tax 1 472 - 21 (2) 1 491 Non-current assets * 29 843 2 525 8 309 1 40 678 * Exclude financial instruments, other assets, deferred income tax assets, current tax assets, post-employment benefit assets and rights arising under insurance contracts. -- 252 of 354 -- -B253- 36 RELATED PARTIES 36.1 Balances with related parties R million 2023 2022 Advances Associates 20 053 17 442 Joint ventures 7 657 7 605 Key management personnel 9 50 Other assets Associates 786 583 Joint ventures 8 596 18 887 Derivative assets Joint ventures 3 2 Investment securities Associates 397 163 Deposits Associates 1 086 1 572 Joint ventures 5 451 5 824 Key management personnel 92 120 Accounts payable Associates 6 4 Derivative liabilities Joint ventures 118 370 Commitments Associates 186 1 839 Joint ventures 5 182 4 711 Refer to the remuneration disclosures on B254 for details of the compensation payable to KMP. Transactions with related parties occur in the ordinary course of business and on substantially the same terms, including interest rates and collateral, as those for comparable transactions with other external parties. These transactions do not involve more than the normal risk of collectability or present other unfavourable features. The amounts advanced to KMP consist of mortgages, instalment finance agreements, credit cards and other loans. The amounts deposited by KMP are held in cheque and current accounts, savings accounts and other term accounts. Market-related rates and terms and conditions apply to transactions with related parties, including KMP. -- 253 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B254- 36 RELATED PARTIES continued 36.2 Transactions with related parties appear below R million 2023 2022 Interest received Associates 965 1 091 Joint ventures 1 390 1 084 Key management personnel 2 2 Interest paid Associates (74) (48) Joint ventures (112) (95) Key management personnel (7) (7) Non-interest revenue Associates 936 1 099 Joint ventures 1 187 1 498 Key management personnel 1 2 Operating expenses Associates (851) (866) Joint ventures - - Dividends received Associates 239 333 Joint ventures 3 100 1 977 Net investment return credited in respect of investments under the co-investment scheme Salaries and other employee benefits Key management personnel 278 250 – Salaries and other short-term benefits 170 154 – Share-based payments 108 96 Deferred compensation of R51 million (2022: R44 million) is due to key management personnel and settlement value is linked to the FirstRand Limited shares. A list of the board of directors of the group is available in the Corporate governance section of this report. During the financial year, no contracts were entered into in which directors or officers of the group had an interest and which significantly affected the business of the group. The directors had no interest in any third party or company responsible for managing any of the business activities of the group. -- 254 of 354 -- -B255- 36 RELATED PARTIES continued 36.3 Post-retirement benefit fund Details of transactions between the group and the group’s post-employment benefit plan are listed below. R million 2023 2022 Dividend income 26 22 Fee expense - (12) Deposits held with the group 737 478 Interest income 46 32 Refer to note 21 for details of the closing balance of the group’s post-employment benefit plan. 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS Risk governance in the group FirstRand believes that effective risk, performance and financial resource management is key to its success and underpins the delivery of sustainable returns to shareholders. These disciplines are, therefore, deeply embedded in the group’s operational, tactical and strategic decision-making. Effective risk management is supported by effective governance structures, robust policy frameworks and a risk-focused culture. Strong governance structures and policy frameworks foster the embedding of risk considerations in business processes and ensure that consistent standards exist across the group. In line with the group’s corporate governance framework, the board retains ultimate responsibility for providing strategic direction, approving risk appetite and ensuring that risks are adequately identified, measured, monitored, managed and reported on. The group’s risk management framework describes the group’s risk governance structures and approach to risk management. Effective risk management requires three lines of control or safeguards that should consistently be applied at various levels throughout the organisation. The primary board committee overseeing risk matters across the group is the FirstRand RCCC. It has delegated responsibility for a number of specialist risk types to various subcommittees. Additional risk, audit and compliance committees exist in the operating businesses, segments and subsidiaries, whose governance structures align closely with that of the group. A detailed overview of the group’s risk governance process is provided in the group’s unaudited Pillar 3 disclosure on the FirstRand website at www.firstrand.co.za/investors/basel-pillar-3-disclosure. -- 255 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B256- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS Overview of financial and insurance risks The financial instruments recognised on the group’s statement of financial position expose the group to various financial risks. The information presented in this note represents the information required by IFRS 7 and sets out the group’s exposure to these financial and insurance risks. This section also contains details on the group’s capital management process. Overview of financial and insurance risks Credit risk The risk of loss due to the non-performance of a counterparty in respect of any financial or other obligation. For fair value portfolios, the definition of credit risk is expanded to include the risk of losses through fair value changes arising from changes in credit spreads. Credit risk also includes credit default, pre-settlement, country, concentration and securitisation risk. Credit risk arises primarily from the following instruments: ¾ advances; ¾ certain investment securities; and ¾ off-balance sheet exposures. Other sources of credit risk are: ¾ reinsurance assets; ¾ cash and cash equivalents; ¾ accounts receivable included in other assets; and ¾ derivative balances. The following information is presented for these assets: ¾ credit assets and concentration risk (37.1.1); ¾ information about the quality of credit assets (37.1.2 and 37.1.3); and ¾ credit risk mitigation techniques and collateral held (37.1.5). Liquidity risk The risk that the group will not be able to effectively meet current and future cash flow and collateral requirements without negatively affecting the normal course of business, financial position or reputation. All assets and liabilities with differing maturity profiles expose the group to liquidity risk. The following information is presented for these assets and liabilities: ¾ undiscounted cash flow analysis of financial liabilities (37.2.1); ¾ discounted cash flow analysis of total assets and liabilities (37.2.2); ¾ collateral pledged (37.2.3). and ¾ concentration analysis of deposits (37.2.4) -- 256 of 354 -- -B257- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Overview of financial and insurance risks Market risk The group distinguishes between traded market risk and non-traded market risk. For non-traded market risk the group distinguishes between interest rate risk in the banking book (IRRBB) and structural foreign exchange risk. Traded market risk is the risk of adverse revaluation of any financial instrument as a consequence of changes in the market prices or rates. Traded market risk (37.3.1) emanates mainly from the provision of hedging solutions for clients, market-making activities and term- lending products, and is taken and managed by RMB. 10-day 99% VaR analysis has been presented for traded market risk. Interest rate risk in the banking book (37.4.1) is the sensitivity of a bank’s financial position and earnings to unexpected, adverse movements in interest rates. It originates from the differing repricing characteristics of balance sheet positions/instruments, yield curve risk, basis risk and client optionality embedded in banking book products. The following information is presented for interest rate risk in the banking book: ¾ projected NII sensitivity to interest rate movements; and ¾ banking book NAV sensitivity to interest rate movements as a percentage of total group capital. Structural foreign exchange risk (37.4.2) is the risk of an adverse impact on the group’s financial position and earnings or other key ratios as a result of movements in foreign exchange rates impacting balance sheet exposures. It arises from balances denominated in foreign currencies and group entities with functional currencies other than the South African rand. Information on the group’s net structural foreign exposures and sensitivity of these exposures are presented. -- 257 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B258- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Overview of financial and insurance risks Equity investment risk The risk of an adverse change in the fair value of an investment in a company, fund or listed, unlisted or bespoke financial instruments. Equity investment risk (37.5) arises primarily from equity exposures from private equity and corporate and investment banking activities in RMB, and strategic investments held by WesBank, FNB, Aldermore and Centre. Ashburton Investments also contributes to equity investment risk through the short-term seeding of new traditional and alternative funds, both locally and offshore, which exposes the group until these investments are taken up by external parties. Long-term seeding is also provided where there is alignment with strategy and the business case meets the internal return hurdle requirements. Any equity investments in any types of funds held in the bank’s banking book, including money market funds, are treated as part of equity investment risk. The following information is presented for equity investments: ¾ investment risk exposure, risk-weighted assets (RWA), and sensitivity analysis of investment risk; and ¾ estimated sensitivity of remaining investment balances. -- 258 of 354 -- -B259- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Insurance risk Insurance risk arises from the inherent uncertainties of liabilities payable under an insurance contract. These uncertainties can result in the occurrence, amount or timing of the liabilities differing from expectations. Insurance risk can arise throughout the product cycle and is related to product design, pricing, underwriting or claims management. The risk arises from the group’s third-party insurance operations housed in FirstRand Insurance Holdings Limited. Currently insurance risk arises from the group’s long-term insurance operations, underwritten through its subsidiary FirstRand Life Assurance Limited (FirstRand Life), and short- term insurance operations, underwritten through its subsidiary FirstRand Short Term Insurance (FirstRand STI). Tax risk The risk of financial loss due to the final determination of the tax treatment of a transaction by revenue authorities being different from the implemented tax consequences of such a transaction, combined with the imposition of penalties, sanction or reputational damage due to: ¾ non-compliance with the various revenue acts; and/or ¾ the inefficient use of available mechanisms to benefit from tax dispensations. Any event, action or inaction in the strategy, operations, financial reporting or compliance that either adversely affects the entity’s tax or business position, or results in unanticipated penalties, assessments, additional taxes, harm to reputation, lost opportunities or financial statement exposure is regarded as tax risk. Capital management The overall capital management objective is to maintain sound capital ratios and a strong credit rating to ensure confidence in the group’s solvency and quality of capital during calm and turbulent periods in the economy and financial markets. The group, therefore, maintains capitalisation ratios aligned with its risk appetite and appropriate for safeguarding operations and stakeholder interests. The key focus areas and considerations of capital management are to ensure an optimal level and mix of capital, effective allocation of resources including capital and risk capacity, and a dividend strategy to provide shareholders with an appropriate, sustainable payout over the long term. -- 259 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B260- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.1 Credit risk Objective Credit risk management objectives are twofold: ¾ Risk control: Appropriate limits are placed on the assumption of credit risk and steps taken to ensure the accuracy of credit risk assessments and reports. Deployed and central credit risk management teams fulfil this task. ¾ Management: Credit risk is taken within the constraints of the group’s risk/return and credit risk appetite framework. The credit portfolio is managed at an aggregate level to optimise the exposure to this risk. Business units and deployed risk functions, overseen by the group credit risk management function in ERM and relevant board committees, fulfil this role. Based on the group’s credit risk appetite, as measured on an ROE, NIACC and volatility-of-earnings basis, credit risk management principles include holding the appropriate level of capital and pricing for risk on an individual and portfolio basis. The scope of credit risk identification and management practices across the group, therefore, spans the credit value chain, including risk appetite, credit origination strategy, risk quantification and measurement, as well as collection and recovery of delinquent accounts. Assessment and management Credit risk is managed through the implementation of comprehensive policies, processes and controls to ensure a sound credit risk management environment with appropriate credit granting, administration, measurement, monitoring and reporting of credit risk exposure. Credit risk management across the group is split into three distinct portfolios, which are aligned to customer profiles. These portfolios are retail, commercial and corporate. The assessment of credit risk across the group relies on internally developed quantitative models for addressing regulatory and business needs. These models are used for the internal assessment of the three primary credit risk components: o PD; o EAD; and o LGD. Management of the credit portfolio is reliant on these three credit risk measures. PD, EAD and LGD are inputs into the portfolio and group-level credit risk assessment where the measures are combined with estimates of correlations between individual counterparties, industries and portfolios to reflect diversification benefits across the portfolio. -- 260 of 354 -- -B261- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued The group employs a granular, 100-point master rating scale, which has been mapped to the continuum of default probabilities, as illustrated in the following table. FirstRand (FR)1 is the lowest PD and FR100 the highest. External ratings have also been mapped to the master rating scale for reporting purposes. These mappings are reviewed and updated on a regular basis. Mapping of FR grades to rating agency scales FR rating Midpoint PD International scale mapping (based on S&P)* 1 – 14 15 – 25 26 – 32 33 – 39 40 – 53 54 – 83 84 – 90 91 – 99 100 0.06% 0.29% 0.77% 1.44% 2.52% 6.18% 13.68% 59.11% 100% AAA, AA+, AA, AA-, A+, A, A- BBB+, BBB(upper), BBB, BBB-(upper), BBB-, BB+(upper) BB+, BB(upper), BB, BB-(upper) BB-, B+(upper) B+ B(upper), B, B-(upper) B- CCC+, CCC D (defaulted) * Indicative mapping to the international rating scales of S&P Global Ratings. The group currently only uses mapping to S&P rating scales. 37.1.1 Credit assets and concentration risk The assets and off-balance sheet amounts included in the table below expose the group to credit risk. For all on-balance sheet exposures, the gross amount disclosed represents the maximum exposure to credit risk, before taking collateral and other credit enhancements into account. Credit concentration risk is the risk of loss to the group arising from an excessive concentration of exposure to a single counterparty, industry, market, product, financial instrument or type of security, country or region, or maturity. This concentration typically exists when a number of counterparties are engaged in similar activities and have similar characteristics that would cause their ability to meet contractual obligations to be similarly affected by changes in economic or other conditions. Concentration risk is managed based on the nature of the credit concentration in each portfolio. -- 261 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B262- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Geographic concentration of significant credit asset exposure The following tables provide a breakdown of credit exposure across geographical areas. 2023 Asia, Americas, South Broader United Other and R million Africa Africa Kingdom Europe Australasia* Total On-balance sheet exposures Cash and short-term funds 64 230 11 431 65 190 10 944 12 415 164 210 Total advances 1 015 147 135 615 394 661 19 841 25 183 1 590 447 Stage 3 advances ** 41 454 5 713 10 149 10 106 57 432 Derivatives 35 932 5 231 33 650 10 885 258 85 956 Debt investment securities # 275 553 38 589 26 463 16 694 43 102 400 401 Other assets 6 154 1 239 717 839 266 9 215 Reinsurance assets 521 33 - - - 554 Off-balance sheet exposures Guarantees, acceptances, and letters of credit 35 819 8 154 24 293 3 401 6 335 78 002 Irrevocable commitments 153 948 13 407 13 466 7 328 4 877 193 026 * Restated. Previously North and South America, Australia and Asia were presented separately. Refer to Note 38.3 – Voluntary changes in presentation. ** Includes purchased credit originated impaired advances. # Excludes non-recourse investments. -- 262 of 354 -- -B263- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Geographic concentration of significant credit asset exposure The following tables provide a breakdown of credit exposure across geographical areas. 2022 Asia, Americas, South Broader United Other and Africa Africa Kingdom Europe Australasia* Total 64 513 9 746 35 585 8 305 13 776 131 925 918 509 106 647 321 624 23 763 11 515 1 382 058 39 416 3 447 7 930 5 88 50 886 35 922 527 23 821 4 869 528 65 667 232 438 32 816 32 992 25 951 38 783 362 980 4 453 945 814 103 229 6 544 569 14 - - - 583 39 964 8 721 20 280 1 273 3 000 73 238 141 508 14 728 13 911 667 1 981 172 795 -- 263 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B264- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued R million 2023 2022 Breakdown of advances per class Gross advances 1 590 447 1 382 058 – Retail secured 368 414 342 111 – Residential mortgages 259 635 242 757 – WesBank VAF* 108 779 99 354 – Retail unsecured** 94 627 87 351 – FNB card 37 149 32 821 – Personal loans# 50 072 46 623 – Retail other# 7 406 7 907 – Corporate and commercial 636 668 533 747 – FNB commercial 116 448 107 823 – WesBank corporate 54 212 45 128 – RMB corporate and investment banking 466 008 380 796 – Broader Africa 77 059 67 247 – Centre (including Group Treasury) 40 937 47 756 – UK operations 372 742 303 846 – Retail 286 908 231 437 – Commercial 85 834 72 409 * Includes public sector. ** Includes acceptances. # Restated. Refer to Note 38.2 – Impact due to movements in the classes of advances. -- 264 of 354 -- -B265- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Sector analysis concentration of advances Advances expose the group to concentration risk in various industry sectors. The following tables set out the group’s exposure to various industry sectors for total advances and credit-impaired advances. 2023 Stage 3 Security held and Total expected R million advances Advances recoveries Impairment Sector analysis Agriculture 59 067 2 578 1 232 1 346 Banks 45 654 - - - Financial institutions 199 191 289 77 212 Building and property development 93 456 1 701 865 836 Government, Land Bank and public authorities 31 047 2 150 1 871 279 Individuals 727 042 41 895 23 272 18 623 Manufacturing and commerce 199 573 4 591 1 904 2 687 Mining 14 249 158 44 114 Transport and communication 50 786 995 610 385 Other services 170 382 3 075 1 519 1 556 Temporary stress scenario - - - - Total 1 590 447 57 432 31 394 26 038 2022 Sector analysis Agriculture 52 102 2 473 1 167 1 306 Banks 48 384 - - - Financial institutions 160 606 338 86 252 Building and property development 80 398 1 430 607 823 Government, Land Bank and public authorities 30 027 191 76 115 Individuals 655 802 37 212 20 145 17 067 Manufacturing and commerce 164 324 4 353 1 307 3 046 Mining 8 045 103 25 78 Transport and communication 40 141 880 486 394 Other services 142 229 3 906 1 666 2 240 Temporary stress scenario - - (1) 1 Total 1 382 058 50 886 25 564 25 322 37.1.2 Quality of credit assets The following table shows the GCA of advances carried at amortised cost and the fair value of advances measured at FVTPL, as well as the exposure to credit risk of loan commitments and financial guarantees per class of advance and per internal credit rating. The amounts in stage 3 that do not have a rating of FR91-100 relate to technical cures (performing accounts that have previously defaulted but do not meet the 12-month curing definition and therefore remain in stage 3) and paying debt-review customers as the PDs on these customers are lower than operational stage 3 advances and the PD drives the FR rating. In addition, where the group holds a guarantee against a stage 3 advance, the FR rating would reflect the same. -- 265 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B266- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 30 June 2023 Retail secured Retail secured Retail unsecured and unsecured Temporary Residential WesBank FNB Personal Retail stress R million mortgages VAF card loans other scenario Total on-balance sheet 259 635 108 779 37 149 50 072 7 406 - FR1-25 on-balance sheet 103 785 - 546 397 1 291 - – Stage 1 103 693 - 542 320 1 285 - – Stage 2 92 - 4 77 - - – Stage 3 - - - - 6 - FR26-90 on-balance sheet 132 655 99 430 31 605 34 566 4 612 - – Stage 1 119 109 90 176 29 350 32 990 4 466 - – Stage 2 13 546 9 254 2 255 1 576 146 - – Stage 3 - - - - - - – Purchased or originated – credit impaired - - - - - - FR91-100 on-balance sheet 23 195 9 349 4 998 15 109 1 503 - – Stage 1 294 134 181 1 714 92 - – Stage 2 8 828 3 046 760 5 848 493 - – Stage 3 14 073 6 169 4 057 7 547 918 - – Purchased or originated — credit impaired - - - - - - Total off-balance sheet 49 166 - - - 589 - FR1-25 off-balance sheet 45 021 - - - 134 - – Stage 1 45 015 - - - 134 - – Stage 2 6 - - - - - – Stage 3 - - - - - - FR26-90 off-balance sheet 4 118 - - - 289 - – Stage 1 4 053 - - - 289 - – Stage 2 65 - - - - - – Stage 3 - - - - - - – Purchased or originated — credit impaired - - - - - - FR91-100 off-balance sheet 27 - - - 166 - – Stage 1 1 - - - 166 - – Stage 2 16 - - - - - – Stage 3 10 - - - - - – Purchased or originated – credit impaired - - - - - - Total advances 308 801 108 779 37 149 50 072 7 995 - – Stage 1 272 165 90 310 30 073 35 024 6 432 - – Stage 2 22 553 12 300 3 019 7 501 639 - – Stage 3 14 083 6 169 4 057 7 547 924 - – Purchased or originated – credit impaired - - - - - - -- 266 of 354 -- -B267- Corporate and commercial UK operations RMB corporate Centre Temporary and (including FNB stress WesBank investment Broader Group commercial scenario corporate banking Africa Treasury) Retail Commercial Total 116 448 - 54 212 466 008 77 059 40 937 286 908 85 834 1 590 447 267 - 9 568 157 951 2 383 5 023 56 711 4 066 341 988 267 - 9 568 157 951 2 262 5 023 56 689 3 977 341 577 - - - - 119 - 22 89 403 - - - - 2 - - - 8 108 483 - 43 021 300 840 67 478 35 914 209 932 76 748 1 145 284 102 643 - 39 865 278 486 62 833 35 871 201 755 72 600 1 070 144 5 785 - 3 156 21 738 4 615 43 8 177 4 148 74 439 55 - - 616 30 - - - 701 - - - - - - - - - 7 698 - 1 623 7 217 7 198 - 20 265 5 020 103 175 110 - 249 93 1 073 - 1 484 1 203 6 627 2 870 - 308 2 604 2 612 - 10 057 2 399 39 825 4 718 - 1 066 3 738 3 513 - 8 724 1 418 55 941 - - - 782 - - - - 782 24 051 - 3 657 146 875 12 134 25 085 2 218 7 252 271 027 - - 3 657 72 350 1 986 - - - 123 148 - - 3 657 72 350 1 986 - - - 123 142 - - - - - - - - 6 - - - - - - - - - 23 891 - - 73 246 9 170 25 085 2 218 7 252 145 269 23 694 - - 71 917 8 916 25 085 2 218 7 252 143 424 197 - - 1 285 254 - - - 1 801 - - - - - - - - - - - - 44 - - - - 44 160 - - 1 279 978 - - - 2 610 5 - - 456 809 - - - 1 437 71 - - 771 149 - - - 1 007 84 - - 52 20 - - - 166 - - - - - - - - - 140 499 - 57 869 612 883 89 193 66 022 289 126 93 086 1 861 474 126 719 - 53 339 581 253 77 879 65 979 262 146 85 032 1 686 351 8 923 - 3 464 26 398 7 749 43 18 256 6 636 117 481 4 857 - 1 066 4 406 3 565 - 8 724 1 418 56 816 - - - 826 - - - - 826 -- 267 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B268- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 30 June 2022 Retail secured Retail secured Retail unsecured and unsecured Temporary Residential WesBank FNB Personal Retail stress R million mortgages VAF card loans * other * scenario Total on-balance sheet 242 757 99 354 32 821 46 623 7 907 - FR1-25 on-balance sheet 100 566 - 362 305 393 - – Stage 1 100 495 - 361 214 389 - – Stage 2 71 - 1 91 - - – Stage 3 - - - - 4 - FR26-90 on-balance sheet 123 457 90 271 28 007 32 511 5 697 - – Stage 1 110 507 81 900 26 403 30 792 5 580 (2 688) – Stage 2 12 950 8 371 1 604 1 719 116 2 688 – Stage 3 - - - - 1 - – Purchased or originated – credit impaired - - - - - - FR91-100 on-balance sheet 18 734 9 083 4 452 13 807 1 817 - – Stage 1 304 188 150 1 504 76 - – Stage 2 6 628 2 692 624 5 339 470 - – Stage 3 11 802 6 203 3 678 6 964 1 271 - – Purchased or originated – credit impaired - - - - - - Total off-balance sheet 50 451 - - - 622 - FR1-25 Off-balance sheet 46 316 - - - 141 - – Stage 1 46 274 - - - 141 - – Stage 2 42 - - - - - – Stage 3 - - - - - - FR26-90 off-balance sheet 4 091 - - - 304 - – Stage 1 4 010 - - - 304 - – Stage 2 81 - - - - - – Stage 3 - - - - - - – Purchased or originated – credit impaired - - - - - - FR91-100 off-balance sheet 44 - - - 177 - – Stage 1 25 - - - 177 - – Stage 2 10 - - - - - – Stage 3 9 - - - - - – Purchased or originated – credit impaired - - - - - - Total advances 293 208 99 354 32 821 46 623 8 529 - – Stage 1 261 615 82 088 26 914 32 510 6 667 (2 688) – Stage 2 19 782 11 063 2 229 7 149 586 2 688 – Stage 3 11 811 6 203 3 678 6 964 1 276 - – Purchased or originated – credit impaired - - - - - - * Restated. Refer to Note 38.2 – Impact due to movements in the classes of advances. -- 268 of 354 -- -B269- Corporate and commercial UK operations RMB corporate Centre Temporary and (including FNB stress WesBank investment Broader Group commercial scenario corporate banking Africa Treasury) Retail Commercial Total 107 823 - 45 128 380 796 67 247 47 756 231 437 72 409 1 382 058 424 - 10 480 126 919 3 214 4 424 7 424 2 456 256 967 424 - 10 467 126 919 3 101 4 424 7 414 2 429 256 637 - - 13 - 113 - 10 27 326 - - - - - - - - 4 100 846 - 32 886 250 874 58 542 43 332 203 522 65 842 1 035 787 95 051 (130) 28 579 225 957 54 394 43 289 195 580 62 009 957 223 5 700 130 4 307 22 862 4 034 43 6 978 3 833 75 335 95 - - 1 392 114 - 964 - 2 566 - - - 663 - - - - 663 6 553 - 1 762 3 003 5 491 - 20 491 4 111 89 304 293 - 371 68 587 - 376 745 4 662 1 728 - 488 803 1 700 - 14 114 2 403 36 989 4 532 - 903 1 979 3 204 - 6 001 963 47 500 - - - 153 - - - - 153 21 131 - 1 807 128 085 9 882 21 081 8 635 4 338 246 032 827 - 1 807 63 715 1 346 - - - 114 152 827 - 1 807 63 715 1 324 - - - 114 088 - - - - 22 - - - 64 - - - - - - - - - 19 864 - - 62 711 8 241 21 081 8 635 4 338 129 265 19 568 - - 61 217 8 182 21 081 8 635 4 338 127 335 296 - - 1 421 59 - - - 1 857 - - - 45 - - - - 45 - - - 28 - - - - 28 440 - - 1 659 295 - - - 2 615 90 - - 98 281 - - - 671 122 - - 1 444 7 - - - 1 583 228 - - 117 7 - - - 361 - - - - - - - - - 128 954 - 46 935 508 881 77 129 68 837 240 072 76 747 1 628 090 116 253 (130) 41 224 477 974 67 869 68 794 212 005 69 521 1 460 616 7 846 130 4 808 26 530 5 935 43 21 102 6 263 116 154 4 855 - 903 3 533 3 325 - 6 965 963 50 476 - - - 844 - - - - 844 -- 269 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B270- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Analysis of impaired advances (stage 3) The following table represents an analysis of impaired advances (stage 3) for financial assets measured at amortised cost, and debt instruments measured at both FVOCI and FVTPL, in line with the manner in which the group manages credit risk. 2023 Security held and expected Stage 3 R million Total recoveries impairment Stage 3 by class Total retail secured 20 242 14 406 5 836 – Residential mortgages 14 073 11 225 2 848 – WesBank VAF 6 169 3 181 2 988 Total retail unsecured 12 528 3 591 8 937 – FNB card 4 057 1 209 2 848 – Personal loans * 7 547 2 228 5 319 – Retail other * 924 154 770 Total retail secured and unsecured 32 770 17 997 14 773 Total corporate and commercial 10 975 5 829 5 146 – FNB commercial 4 773 1 941 2 832 – WesBank corporate 1 066 672 394 – RMB corporate and investment banking 5 136 3 216 1 920 Broader Africa 3 545 1 498 2 047 Centre (including Group Treasury) - (19) 19 UK operations 10 142 6 089 4 053 – Retail 8 724 5 119 3 605 – Commercial 1 418 970 448 Total stage 3 57 432 31 394 26 038 Stage 3 by category Overdrafts and cash management accounts 3 401 679 2 722 Term loans 1 923 860 1 063 Card loans 4 419 1 238 3 181 Instalment sales and hire purchase agreements 11 001 4 471 6 530 Lease payments receivable 376 214 162 Property finance 23 456 18 520 4 936 – Home loans 21 122 16 990 4 132 – Commercial property finance 2 334 1 530 804 Personal loans 7 873 2 264 5 609 Preference share agreements 276 - 276 Investment bank term loans 3 213 2 649 564 Long-term loans to group associates and joint ventures 196 - 196 Other 1 298 499 799 Total stage 3 57 432 31 394 26 038 * Restated. Refer to Note 38.2 – Impact due to movements in the classes of advances. -- 270 of 354 -- -B271- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Analysis of impaired advances (stage 3) The following table represents an analysis of impaired advances (stage 3) for financial assets measured at amortised cost, and debt instruments measured at both fair value through other comprehensive income and fair value through profit or loss, in line with the manner in which the group manages credit risk. 2022 Security held and expected Stage 3 Total recoveries impairment 18 005 12 219 5 786 11 802 9 266 2 536 6 203 2 953 3 250 11 918 3 365 8 553 3 678 1 067 2 611 6 964 2 075 4 889 1 276 223 1 053 29 923 15 584 14 339 9 717 3 637 6 080 4 627 1 482 3 145 903 487 416 4 187 1 668 2 519 3 318 1 373 1 945 - - - 7 928 4 970 2 958 6 965 4 417 2 548 963 553 410 50 886 25 564 25 322 4 082 830 3 252 2 205 794 1 411 4 253 1 108 3 145 9 914 4 033 5 881 190 60 130 19 548 15 198 4 350 17 755 14 153 3 602 1 793 1 045 748 7 290 2 143 5 147 253 - 253 1 212 995 217 655 - 655 1 284 403 881 50 886 25 564 25 322 -- 271 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B272- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.1.3 Quality of credit assets – non-advances The following table shows the GCA of non-advances carried at amortised cost and the fair value of non- advances measured at FVTPL or through OCI per external credit rating. 2023 AAA to R million BBB BB+ to B- CCC Investment securities at amortised cost Stage 1 33 604 182 832 9 816 Stage 3 - - 195 Purchased or originated credit impaired - - 468 Investment securities at fair value through other comprehensive income Stage 1 36 446 17 287 601 Investment securities at fair value through profit or loss 28 167 90 651 335 Total investment securities 98 217 290 770 11 415 Other financial assets Stage 2 567 8 169 328 Stage 3 - 68 83 Total other financial assets 567 8 237 411 Cash and cash equivalents Stage 1 93 152 67 596 3 437 Purchased or originated credit impaired 25 - - Total cash and cash equivalents 93 177 67 596 3 437 Derivative assets 50 480 35 444 32 2022 Investment securities at amortised cost Stage 1 27 766 129 082 5 951 Investment securities at fair value through other comprehensive income Stage 1 38 858 12 222 2 Investment securities at fair value through profit or loss 40 522 108 556 21 Total investment securities * 107 146 249 860 5 974 Other financial assets Stage 2 803 5 535 167 Stage 3 - (16) 54 Total other financial assets 803 5 519 221 Cash and cash equivalents Stage 1 65 792 62 664 3 470 Total cash and cash equivalents 65 792 62 664 3 470 Derivative assets 29 138 31 228 5 301 * Total investment securities has been represented to include investment securities at fair value through profit and loss. -- 272 of 354 -- -B273- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.1.4 Credit risk mitigation and collateral held Since taking and managing credit risk is core to its business, the group aims to optimise the amount of credit risk it takes to achieve its return objectives. Mitigation of credit risk is an important component of this, beginning with the structuring and approval of facilities only for those clients and within those parameters that fall within risk appetite. Although, in principle, credit assessment focuses on the counterparty’s ability to repay the debt, credit mitigation instruments are used where appropriate to reduce the group’s lending risk, which result in security against the majority of exposures. These include financial or other collateral, netting agreements, guarantees or credit derivatives. The collateral types are driven by portfolio, product or counterparty type. Credit risk mitigation instruments: ● Mortgage and instalment sale finance portfolios in FNB, WesBank, MotoNovo and Aldermore are secured by the underlying assets financed. ● FNB and Aldermore commercial credit exposures are secured by the assets of the SME counterparties and commercial property finance deals are secured by the underlying property and associated cash flows. ● Personal loans, overdrafts and credit card exposures are generally unsecured or secured by guarantees and sureties. ● For FNB and WesBank retail customers, insurance against disability, life and retrenchment is prescribed, where applicable. ● Structured facilities in RMB are secured as part of the structure through financial or other collateral, including guarantees, credit derivative instruments and assets. ● Counterparty credit risk is mitigated through the use of netting agreements and financial collateral. For additional information relating to the use of the netting agreements refer to Note 37.1.4. ● Working capital facilities in RMB corporate and investment banking are secured and unsecured. Security is usually taken in the form of financial or other collateral, including guarantees and assets. The group employs strict policies governing the valuation and management of collateral across all business areas. Collateral is managed internally to ensure that title is retained over collateral taken over the life of the transaction. Collateral is valued at inception of the credit agreement and subsequently where necessary through physical inspection or index valuation methods. For corporate and commercial counterparties, collateral is reassessed during the annual review of the counterparty’s creditworthiness to ensure that proper title is retained. For mortgage portfolios, collateral is revalued on an ongoing basis using an index model, and physical inspection is performed at the beginning of the recovery process. For asset finance, the total security reflected represents only the realisation value estimates of the vehicles repossessed at the date of repossession. Where the repossession has not yet occurred, the realisation value of the vehicle is estimated using internal models and is included as part of total recoveries. Concentrations in credit risk mitigation types, such as property, are monitored and managed at a product and segment level, in line with the requirements of the group credit risk/return framework. Collateral is taken into account for capital calculation purposes through the determination of LGD. Collateral reduces LGD, and LGD levels are determined through statistical modelling techniques based on historical experience of the recovery processes. The following table represents an analysis of the maximum exposure to credit risk for financial assets at amortised cost and debt instruments at FVTPL, as well as a breakdown of collateral, both financial and non- financial, held against the exposure along with any other credit enhancements and netting arrangement. -- 273 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B274- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 2023 Gross Off-balance Maximum carrying sheet Loss exposure to R million amount exposure allowance credit risk Residential mortgages 259 635 49 165 (4 356) 304 444 WesBank VAF 108 779 - (5 862) 102 917 FNB card 37 149 - (4 767) 32 382 Personal loans 50 072 - (9 289) 40 783 Retail other 7 406 590 (1 248) 6 748 Temporary stress scenario − retail - - - - FNB commercial 116 448 24 051 (5 003) 135 496 Temporary stress scenario − commercial - - - - WesBank corporate 54 212 3 657 (733) 57 136 RMB corporate and investment banking 466 008 146 875 (6 468) 606 415 Broader Africa 77 059 12 134 (4 140) 85 053 Centre (including Group Treasury) 40 937 25 085 (548) 65 474 UK operations 372 742 9 470 (8 658) 373 554 – Retail 286 908 2 218 (6 866) 282 260 – Commercial 85 834 7 252 (1 792) 91 294 Total advances 1 590 447 271 027 (51 072) 1 810 402 Investment securities ** 400 401 - (780) 399 621 Cash and cash equivalents 164 210 - - 164 210 Other assets 9 215 - (466) 8 749 Derivatives 85 956 - - 85 956 2022 Residential mortgages 242 757 50 451 (4 084) 289 124 WesBank VAF 99 354 - (5 396) 93 958 FNB card 32 821 - (4 361) 28 460 Personal loans # 46 623 - (8 681) 37 942 Retail other# 7 907 622 (1 585) 6 944 Temporary stress scenario − retail - - (317) (317) FNB commercial 107 823 21 131 (5 237) 123 717 Temporary stress scenario − commercial - - (55) (55) WesBank corporate 45 128 1 807 (795) 46 140 RMB corporate and investment banking 380 796 128 085 (7 064) 501 817 Broader Africa 67 247 9 882 (3 856) 73 273 Centre (including Group Treasury) 47 756 21 081 (617) 68 220 UK operations 303 846 12 973 (5 686) 311 133 – Retail 231 437 8 635 (4 565) 235 507 – Commercial 72 409 4 338 (1 121) 75 626 Total advances 1 382 058 246 032 (47 734) 1 580 356 Investment securities ** 362 980 - (314) 362 666 Cash and cash equivalents 131 925 - - 131 925 Other assets 6 544 - (329) 6 215 Derivatives† 65 667 - - 65 667 * Secured represents balances which have non-financial collateral attached to the financial asset. ** Includes debt instruments measured at fair value but excludes equity and non-recourse investments. # Restated. Refer to Note 38 Changes in presentation. † The derivative line has been restated to reflect the netting and financial collateral attached to derivatives. In the prior year, nil values were disclosed in the unsecured column. -- 274 of 354 -- -B275- 2023 Netting and financial collateral Unsecured Secured * 3 641 - 300 803 - - 102 917 - 32 382 - - 40 783 - - 4 282 2 466 - - - 6 724 18 313 110 459 - - - - 47 57 089 3 732 134 141 468 542 4 256 31 696 49 101 (10) 54 939 10 545 - 9 544 364 010 - - 282 260 - 9 544 81 750 18 343 326 127 1 465 932 21 249 364 502 13 870 26 324 137 886 - 3 8 740 6 73 593 12 363 - 2022* 3 817 1 351 283 956 - 48 93 910 - 28 460 - - 37 942 - - 4 724 2 220 - (129) (188) 5 303 17 242 101 172 - (55) - - - 46 140 1 911 108 595 391 311 3 796 20 595 48 882 - 58 521 9 699 - 9 617 301 516 - 27 235 480 - 9 590 66 036 14 827 286 911 1 278 618 31 808 318 751 12 107 29 927 101 998 - 7 6 199 9 56 198 9 469 - -- 275 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B276- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.1.4 Credit risk mitigation and collateral held continued The financial effect of collateral and other credit enhancements has been calculated separately per class of advance. The amounts disclosed above represent the difference between the impairment recognised on the statement of financial position using the actual LGD and a proxy LGD for all secured portfolios. The proxy LGD is based on the LGD used to determine the impairment recognised on the statement of financial position for unsecured portfolios. Where there is no collateral or where collateral is disregarded for provisioning purposes, no financial effect is calculated. Collateral held against derivative positions The table below sets out the cash collateral held against the net derivative position. R million 2023 2022 Cash collateral held 2 795 15 102 The table below reflects the collateral that the group holds where it has the ability to sell or repledge in the absence of default by the owner of the collateral. Collateral held in structured transactions 2023 2022 Fair value Fair value of collateral of collateral sold or sold or repledged repledged in the in the Fair absence of Fair absence of R million value default value default Cash and cash equivalents 20 885 - 14 821 - Advances 79 410 28 202 70 828 24 282 Investment securities 3 828 3 828 1 402 1 402 Total collateral pledged 104 123 32 030 87 051 25 684 Investment securities exclude securities lending transactions where securities are obtained as collateral for securities lent. This is in line with industry practice. Collateral taken possession of When the group takes possession of collateral that is neither cash nor readily convertible into cash, the group determines a minimum sale amount (pre-set sale amount) and auctions the asset for the pre-set sale amount. Where the group is unable to obtain the pre-set sale amount at an auction, it will continue to hold the asset while actively marketing it to ensure an appropriate value is obtained. Properties taken possession of amounted to R72 million (2022: R100 million). -- 276 of 354 -- -B277- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued The financial collateral included in the previous table is limited to the net statement of financial position exposure in line with the requirements of IFRS 7 and excludes the effect of any over-collateralisation. The collateral amount included in the table for IFRS 7 disclosure purposes has been determined at a business unit level. If these limits were determined on a group-wide level, the collateral amount included in this table could increase. The total amount reported on the statement of financial position is the sum of the net amount reported in the statement of financial position and the financial instruments amount not subject to offset or MNA. Structured Other Derivatives transactions advances/deposits R million 2023 2022* 2023 2022* 2023 2022* Assets Offsetting applied Gross amount 161 374 109 578 95 444 84 620 1 540 313 1 263 707 Amount offset ** (75 418) (43 911) (16 034) (14 003) (938) - Net amount reported on the statement of financial position 85 956 65 667 79 410 70 617 1 539 375 1 263 707 Offsetting not applied Financial instruments subject to MNAs and similar agreements (55 284) (49 308) (7 455) (585) - - Financial collateral (18 309) (6 890) - (56 358) - - Net amount 12 363 9 469 71 955 13 674 1 539 375 1 263 707 Liabilities Offsetting applied Gross amount 146 711 109 473 40 123 30 712 1 899 013 1 639 263 Amount offset ** (76 357) (44 926) (16 033) (14 003) - - Net amount reported on the statement of financial position 70 354 64 547 24 090 16 709 1 899 013 1 639 263 Offsetting not applied Financial instruments subject to MNAs and similar agreements (55 284) (49 308) (7 455) (585) - - Financial collateral (14 869) (15 239) (13 085) (12 125) - - Net amount 201 - 3 549 3 999 1 899 013 1 639 263 * The note has been updated and restated. Refer to Note 38 Change in presentation. ** Amounts offset under derivatives are contracts that are set off under netting agreements, such as the ISDA Master Agreement or derivative clearing counterparty agreements, whereby all outstanding transactions with the same counterparty can be offset and close-out netting is applied across all outstanding transactions covered by these agreements. -- 277 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B278- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.2 Liquidity risk Objective Liquidity risk arises from all assets and liabilities with differing maturity profiles, currencies and behaviour. The group’s objective is to maintain and enhance its deposit market share by appropriately pricing and rewarding depositors from diverse and sustainable funding pools, thus creating a natural liquidity buffer. Because of the liquidity risk introduced by its business activities across various currencies and geographies, the group seeks to optimise its funding profile within structural and regulatory constraints to enable businesses to operate in an efficient and sustainable manner. Compliance with the Basel III liquidity ratios influences the group’s funding strategy, particularly as it seeks to price appropriately for liquidity on a risk-adjusted basis. The group continues to offer innovative and competitive products to further grow its deposit franchise whilst also optimising its institutional funding profile. These initiatives continue to improve the funding and liquidity profile of the group. Assessment and management The group focuses on continually monitoring and analysing the impact of potential risks on its funding and liquidity position to ensure business activities are preserved and funding stability is improved. This ensures the group can operate through periods of stress when access to funding is constrained. Mitigation of market and funding liquidity risks is achieved via contingent liquidity risk management. Buffers of HQLA are held either to be sold into the market or to provide collateral for loans to cover any unforeseen cash shortfall that may arise. The group’s approach to liquidity risk management distinguishes between structural, daily and contingency liquidity risk management across all currencies, and various approaches are employed in the assessment and management of these on a daily, weekly and monthly basis, as illustrated in the following table. Daily liquidity risk Structural liquidity risk Contingency liquidity risk Ensuring that intraday and day-to- day anticipated and unforeseen payment obligations can be met by maintaining a sustainable balance between liquidity inflows and outflows. Managing the risk that structural, long- term on- and off-balance sheet exposures cannot be funded timeously or at reasonable cost. Maintaining several contingency funding sources to draw upon in times of economic stress. -- 278 of 354 -- -B279- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Regular and rigorous stress tests are conducted on the funding profile and liquidity position as part of the overall stress testing framework with a focus on: ● quantifying the potential exposure to future liquidity stresses; ● analysing the possible impact of economic and event risks on cash flows, liquidity, profitability and solvency position; and ● proactively evaluating the potential secondary and tertiary effects of other risks on the group. 37.2.1 Undiscounted cash flows The following table presents the group’s undiscounted cash flows of financial liabilities and off-balance sheet amounts, and includes all cash outflows related to principal amounts, as well as future payments. 2023 Term to maturity Undiscounted >12 months carrying Call to 3 4–12 and non- R million amount months months contractual On-balance sheet exposures Deposits and current accounts 2 020 941 1 383 200 311 869 325 872 Short trading positions 12 753 12 753 - - Derivative financial instruments 80 642 65 662 2 996 11 984 Creditors, accruals and provisions 43 815 34 727 878 8 210 Tier 2 liabilities 23 211 - 2 117 21 094 Other liabilities 4 255 215 894 3 146 Lease liabilities 3 411 240 786 2 385 Policyholder liabilities 8 131 1 208 1 630 5 293 Off-balance sheet exposures Financial and other guarantees 78 002 50 873 2 215 24 914 Other contingencies and commitments 5 254 2 039 3 067 148 Facilities not drawn 193 026 193 026 - - 2022 * On-balance sheet exposures Deposits and current accounts 1 740 568 1 233 822 204 092 302 654 Short trading positions 14 623 14 623 - - Derivative financial instruments 65 286 55 559 711 9 016 Creditors, accruals and provisions * 32 267 24 745 930 6 592 Tier 2 liabilities 24 453 2 788 10 023 11 642 Other liabilities 5 461 163 3 734 1 564 Lease liabilities 3 261 287 777 2 197 Policyholder liabilities 7 430 1 256 1 351 4 823 Off-balance sheet exposures Financial and other guarantees 73 238 49 618 1 920 21 700 Other contingencies and commitments 5 606 2 983 2 245 378 Facilities not drawn 172 795 172 795 - - * Restated refer to accounting policy note 10.1. In the prior year, the undiscounted amount was disclosed as R37 100 million and >12 months and non-contractual was disclosed as R11 425 million. -- 279 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B280- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.2.2 Discounted cash flows The following table represents the group’s contractual discounted cash flows of total assets, liabilities and equity. Relying solely on the contractual liquidity mismatch when assessing a bank’s maturity analysis would overstate risk, since this represents a worst-case assessment of cash flows at maturity. Due to South Africa’s structural liquidity position, banks tend to have a particularly pronounced negative gap in the shorter term due to short-term institutional funds representing a significant proportion of banks’ liabilities. These are used to fund long-term assets, e.g. mortgages. The group’s liquidity risk is mitigated by buffer of HQLA which are held either to be sold into the market or to provide collateral for loans to cover any unforeseen cash shortfall that may arise. Discounted cash flow analysis – maturity analysis of total assets, liabilities and equity based on the present value of the expected payment 2023 Term to maturity Discounted > 12 months carrying Call to 3 4 – 12 and non- R million amount months months contractual Total assets 2 297 610 682 421 275 944 1 339 245 Total equity and liabilities 2 297 610 1 503 442 306 896 487 272 Net liquidity gap - (821 021) (30 952) 851 973 Cumulative liquidity gap - (821 021) (851 973) - 2022 * Total assets 1 999 569 621 495 253 854 1 124 220 Total equity and liabilities 1 999 569 1 336 299 218 084 445 186 Net liquidity gap - (714 804) 35 770 679 034 Cumulative liquidity gap - (714 804) (679 034) - * Restated, refer to accounting policy note 10.1. In the prior year total assets and total equity and liabilities were disclosed as R2 004 402 million, and >12 months and non-contractual for total assets and total equity and liabilities were disclosed as R1 129 053 million and R450 019 million respectively. -- 280 of 354 -- -B281- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.2.3 Collateral pledged The group pledges assets under the following terms and conditions: ● assets are pledged as collateral under repurchase agreements with other banks and for security deposits relating to local futures and options; and ● collateral in the form of cash and other investment securities is pledged when the group borrows equity securities from third parties. These transactions are conducted under the terms and conditions that are usual and customary to standard securities lending arrangements. All other pledges are conducted under terms which are usual and customary to lending arrangements. The following assets have been pledged to secure the liabilities set out in the table below. These assets are not available in the normal course of business. R million 2023 2022 Cash 25 444 29 939 Advances 62 455 60 043 Investment securities̶ held under repurchase agreements 4 705 4 893 Investment securities̶ other 5 385 3 658 Total assets pledged 97 989 98 533 The following liabilities have been secured by the group pledging either its own or borrowed financial assets, except for the short-trading positions, which are covered by borrowed securities only. R million 2023 2022 Short-trading positions 12 753 14 623 Total deposits 50 554 38 144 – Deposits under repurchase agreements 19 759 15 183 – Deposits in securities lending transactions * 4 331 1 526 – Other secured deposits 26 464 21 435 Derivative liabilities ** 22 666 30 776 Other 2 069 4 796 Total 88 042 88 339 * Securities lending transactions include only those where cash is placed against the securities borrowed. Transactions where securities are lent and borrowed and other securities placed against the borrowing and lending are excluded. ** The description has been updated to appropriately reflect the nature of the liability. This line was previously: Other. The total amount reflected in the prior year has not changed. -- 281 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B282- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.2.4 Concentration analysis of deposits R million 2023 2022 Sector analysis Deposit current accounts and other loans Sovereigns, including central banks 95 611 102 054 Public sector entities 93 640 89 442 Local authorities 20 106 16 322 Banks 79 862 49 097 Securities firms 29 078 23 945 Corporate customers 942 095 804 504 Retail customers 655 348 565 888 Other 7 363 4 720 Total deposits 1 923 103 1 655 972 Geographical analysis South Africa 1 286 374 1 141 779 Broader Africa 131 974 111 571 UK 451 926 360 301 Other 52 829 42 321 Total deposits 1 923 103 1 655 972 37.3 Market risk 37.3.1 Traded market risk Objective Traded market risk includes interest rate risk in the trading book, traded equity and credit risk, commodity risk, foreign exchange risk and interest rate risk in the RMB banking book, which is managed as part of the trading book. -- 282 of 354 -- -B283- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.3.1 Traded market risk continued Assessment and management Management and monitoring of IRRBB is split between the RMB banking book and the remaining domestic banking book, (which is covered in the IRRBB section on B286). RMB manages the majority of its banking book under the market risk framework, with risk measured and monitored in conjunction with the trading book and management oversight provided by the FirstRand market and investment risk committee. The RMB banking book interest rate risk exposure was R103 million on a 10-day expected tail loss (ETL) basis at 30 June 2023 (2022: R81 million). Market volatility continued as a theme throughout the year. The focus remained on central bank interest rates, the inflationary backdrop and geopolitical concerns which affected international and local policy making. The market risk measurement framework continued to perform well during the volatility, and market risk exposures remained within approved limits. The risk related to market risk-taking activities is measured as the height of the group’s internal ETL measure (a proxy for economic capital) and regulatory capital based on 60-point average of VaR plus stressed VaR (sVaR). ETL The internal measure of risk is an ETL metric at the 99% confidence level under the full revaluation methodology using historical risk factor scenarios (historical simulation method). In order to accommodate the regulatory stress loss imperative, the set of scenarios used for revaluation of the current portfolio comprises historical scenarios which incorporate both the past 260 trading days and at least one static period of market distress (currently 2008/2009). The ETL is liquidity adjusted for illiquid exposures. Holding periods ranging between 10 and 90 days or more, are used in the calculation and are based on an assessment of distressed liquidity of portfolios. The market history of the past 260 trading days has been continually updated to reflect current market volatility. The static period of market stress is periodically reviewed for appropriateness. VaR VaR is calculated at the 99%, 10-day actual holding period level using data from the past 260 trading days. -- 283 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B284- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued VaR analysis by risk type The following table reflects the 1-day VaR, and the 10-day VaR and sVaR at the 99% confidence level. The 10-day VaR calculation is performed using 10-day scenarios created from the past 260 trading days, whereas the 10-day sVaR is calculated using scenario data from the static stress period. 2023* Diversi- Interest Foreign Com- Traded fication Diversified R million Equities rates** exchange modities credit effect total VaR (10-day 99%) Maximum value # 79.3 520.6 114.0 69.5 49.3 - 435.5 Average value 22.9 309.0 54.8 33.1 15.2 - 266.6 Minimum value # 5.8 134.0 13.9 17.4 1.8 - 140.5 Period end 14.0 296.9 91.6 31.6 11.4 (172.2) 273.3 sVaR (10-day 99%) Maximum value # 84.2 553.6 248.7 79.5 211.1 - 479.9 Average value 30.8 349.4 101.2 42.4 72.4 - 296.2 Minimum value # 10.4 168.1 21.9 27.8 2.7 - 173.1 Period end 25.5 225.2 166.7 58.3 12.6 (225.1) 263.1 VaR (1-day 99%)† Maximum value # - - - - - - - Average value - - - - - - - Minimum value # - - - - - - - Period end - - - - - - - * Excludes foreign branches and subsidiaries, which are reported on in the standardised approach for market risk. The sVaR numbers relate to FirstRand Bank South Africa only. ** Interest rate risk in the trading book. # The maximum and minimum VaR figures for each asset class did not necessarily occur on the same day. Consequently, a diversification effect was omitted from the above table. † In the current year, the VaR (1-day 99%) is no longer utilised for limit and management monitoring. -- 284 of 354 -- -B285- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued VaR analysis by risk type The following table reflects the 1-day VaR, and the 10-day VaR and sVaR at the 99% confidence level. The 10- day VaR calculation is performed using 10-day scenarios created from the past 260 trading days, whereas the 10-day sVaR is calculated using scenario data from the static stress period. 2022* Diversi- Interest Foreign Com- Traded fication Diversified Equities rates # exchange modities credit effect total 86.5 329.7 121.4 71.3 33.1 - 277.7 15.7 196.7 43.0 35.8 16.2 - 188.3 4.6 126.8 8.1 9.6 1.5 - 101.2 6.9 257.8 34.6 62.9 2.2 (175.0) 189.4 103.1 446.8 166.3 86.9 40.9 - 439.2 23.7 324.4 64.7 48.2 16.4 - 187.7 8.8 116.4 13.2 16.8 2.3 - 76.7 15.8 365.5 156.9 46.3 7.3 (152.6) 439.2 67.8 198.1 68.5 51.0 11.5 - 146.1 7.3 90.2 18.3 20.8 5.4 - 95.8 3.0 60.2 0.3 4.5 1.0 - 54.6 4.5 100.6 7.1 20.3 1.1 (49.4) 84.2 -- 285 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B286- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.4 Non-traded market risk 37.4.1 Interest rate risk in the banking book Assessment and management FirstRand Bank (South Africa) The measurement techniques used to monitor IRRBB include NII sensitivity/earnings risk and PV01/economic value of equity (EVE) sensitivity. A repricing gap is also generated to better understand the repricing characteristics of the balance sheet. In calculating the repricing gap, all banking book assets, liabilities and derivative instruments are placed in gap intervals based on repricing characteristics. The internal funds transfer pricing process is used to transfer interest rate risk from the operating businesses to Group Treasury. This process allows risk to be managed centrally and holistically in line with the group’s macroeconomic outlook. Management of the resultant risk position is achieved by balance sheet optimisation or through the use of derivative transactions. Derivative instruments used are mainly interest rate swaps, for which a liquid market exists. Where possible, hedge accounting is used to minimise any accounting mismatches that may arise. Interest rate risk from the fixed-rate book is managed to low levels with remaining risk stemming from timing and basis risk. Foreign operations Management of subsidiaries in broader Africa, Aldermore and the bank’s foreign branches is performed by in- country management teams with oversight provided by Group Treasury and Centre Risk Management. For subsidiaries, earnings sensitivity measures are used to monitor and manage interest rate risk in line with the group’s appetite. Where applicable, PV01 and ETL risk limits are also used for endowment hedges. Sensitivity analysis A change in interest rates impacts both the earnings potential of the banking book (as underlying assets and liabilities reprice to new rates) and the economic value/PV01 of an entity (as a result of a change in the fair value of any open risk portfolios used to manage the earnings risk). The role of management is to protect both the financial performance as a result of a change in earnings and the long-term economic value. To achieve this, both earnings sensitivity and economic sensitivity measures are monitored and managed within appropriate risk limits and appetite levels, considering the macroeconomic environment and factors which could cause a change in rates. In the prior year, the earnings and EVE sensitivity analysis were calculated on a contractual basis. For the current year, the sensitivities have been calculated in accordance with amendments to the Banks Act as per Directive 2 of 2023. The Directive is prospective The updated IRRBB methodology ensures that: 1. Client behaviour is considered in the management of IRRBB. Relevant behavioural adjustments that capture modelled customer behaviour (where they have legal discretion to re-pay or withdraw funds) are incorporated into the calculation. This allows for a more effective assessment of IRRBB and aligns with how the group manages this risk. 2. There is a more effective and transparent measure of the risk associated with specific currency exposures which are exposed to different interest rates, and different possible shocks. 3. There is a more explicit consideration of basis risk and credit spread risk. -- 286 of 354 -- -B287- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Earnings sensitivity Earnings models are run monthly to provide a measure of the NII sensitivity of the existing banking book balance sheet to shocks in interest rates. The calculation assumes a constant balance sheet size and product mix over the forecast horizon. A pass-through assumption is applied in relation to non-maturing deposits, which reprice at the group’s discretion. This assumption is based on historical product behaviour. The following tables show the 12-month NII sensitivity to a sustained, instantaneous parallel 400 bps downward and upward shock to interest rates. Most of the group’s NII sensitivity relates to the endowment book mismatch. The group’s average endowment book using the updated IRRBB methodology was R355 billion, excluding Aldermore, for the year ended 30 June 2023 (2022: R310 billion – reported as R335 billion under the previous IRRBB methodology in 2022). Projected ZAR NII sensitivity to interest rate movements 2023 Change in projected 12-month NII R million FirstRand Bank South Africa Subsidiaries in broader Africa and the bank’s foreign branches Total FirstRand Downward 400 bps (2 196) (1 056) (3 252) Upward 400 bps 1 933 822 2 755 Downward 200 bps (1 279) (537) (1 816) Upward 200 bps 1 160 411 1 571 2022 Downward 200 bps (277) (754) (1 031) Upward 200 bps 102 561 663 Assuming no change in the balance sheet and no management action in response to interest rate movements, an instantaneous, sustained parallel 400 bps (2022: 200bps) decrease in interest rates would result in a reduction in projected 12-month NII of R3 252 million (2022: R1 031 million). A similar increase in interest rates would result in an increase in projected 12-month NII of R2 755 million (2022: R663 million). -- 287 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B288- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISK continued 37.4.1 Interest rate risk in the banking book continued Effect of IBOR reform The London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR) were the reference interest rate that underpinned trillions of loans and derivative contracts worldwide. The reform of these reference interest rates and their replacement with ARRs were a priority for global regulators. The group established a steering committee in the 2020 financial year consisting of key finance, risk, IT, treasury, legal and compliance personnel, as well as external advisors to oversee the group’s IBOR reform transition plan. This steering committee developed a transition project for affected contracts and potential future contracts with the aim of minimising the potential disruption to business, mitigating operational and conduct risks and possible financial losses. On 5 March 2021, LIBOR’s administrator, the ICE Benchmark Administration Limited (ICE), announced the cessation of several IBOR settings after 31 December 2021. The publication of EUR, CHF, JPY and GBP LIBOR for all tenors ceased on 31 December 2021. The one-week and two-month USD LIBOR tenors were also discontinued on 31 December 2021. The announcement by ICE noted that the remaining USD LIBOR tenors would be discontinued at 30 June 2023. Although, there is currently no indication as to when JIBAR will be replaced, several proposed ARRs and calculation methodologies were previously released by the SARB. The SARB identified a potential successor to JIBAR in the South African Rand Overnight Index Average Rate (ZARONIA). The new ZARONIA rate began publication for observation in August 2022 however no JIBAR cessation date has yet been announced. The group currently has a number of contracts, including derivatives which reference JIBAR and extend beyond 2023. The group’s established steering committee, detailed above, that has previously overseen the group’s IBOR related reforms and transition planning in respect of USD/GBP LIBOR, will apply the same transitioning policies to affected JIBAR contracts. The table below shows the financial instruments, including derivatives, held for trading or used by the group in fair value hedges, that are subject to IBOR reforms which have not yet transitioned to the replacement rates as at 30 June 2023 and which will not have matured by the related IBOR cessation date. LIBOR cessation occurred on 31 December 2021 for GBP, EUR, JPY, CHF and USD for one-week and two-months tenors. Cessation occurred on 30 June 2023 for all other USD LIBOR tenors. Those exposures that were not transitioned at the date of cessation relate to syndicated exposures where the bank is not the facility agent and is reliant on other counterparties to affect the ARR. These exposures will reference the last published USD Libor rate until the earlier of the next reset date, upon which the exposures will transition to the ARR or will mature. All reset dates fall before 31 December 2023. Refer to note 8, for the impact the IBOR reforms have on hedge accounting. -- 288 of 354 -- -B289- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Financial assets subject to IBOR reform that have not yet transitioned to replacement rates. 2023 USD Other R million LIBOR LIBOR Assets recognised on the balance sheet Advances 13 143 - Total assets recognised on the balance sheet subject to IBOR reform 13 143 - Off-balance sheet items Irrevocable commitments 360 - Total off-balance sheet exposure subject to IBOR reform 360 - Total asset exposure subject to IBOR reform 13 503 - 2022 Assets recognised on the balance sheet Derivative financial instruments (assets) * 62 865 284 Investment securities 76 - Advances 28 080 - Total assets recognised on the balance sheet subject to IBOR reform 91 021 284 Off-balance sheet items Irrevocable commitments 7 238 339 Total off-balance sheet exposure subject to IBOR reform 7 238 339 Total asset exposure subject to IBOR reform 98 259 623 * These balances represent the notional amount directly impacted by the IBOR reform. -- 289 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B290- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Financial liabilities subject to IBOR reform that have not yet transitioned to replacement rates: 2023 USD Other R million LIBOR LIBOR Liabilities recognised on the balance sheet Derivative financial instruments (liabilities) * - - Deposits 1 916 - Other liabilities - - Tier 2 liabilities - - Total liabilities recognised subject to IBOR reform 1 916 - 2022 Liabilities recognised on the balance sheet Derivative financial instruments (liabilities) * 41 282 317 Deposits 20 926 - Other liabilities - - Tier 2 liabilities - - Total liabilities recognised subject to IBOR reform 62 208 317 * These balances represent the notional amount directly impacted by the IBOR reform. -- 290 of 354 -- -B291- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISK continued 37.4.1 Interest rate risk in the banking book continued Economic value of equity An EVE sensitivity measure is used to assess the impact on the total NAV of the group of a shock to underlying rates. Unlike the trading book, where a change in rates will impact fair value income and reportable earnings of an entity when a rate change occurs, the realisation of a rate move in the banking book will impact the distributable and non-distributable reserves to varying degrees and is reflected in the NII margin more as an opportunity cost/benefit over the life of the underlying positions. As a result, a purely forward-looking EVE sensitivity measure is applied to the banking book, and is monitored relative to the total risk limits, appetite levels and current economic conditions. Six EVE shock scenarios are applied based on regulatory guidelines. The most material of the scenarios comprises a sustained, instantaneous parallel downward and upward shock of 400 bps (2022: 200bps) to interest rates. The reported 2023 numbers have been calculated in accordance with amendments to the Banks Act as per Directive 2 of 2023. This shock is applied to all banking book positions. The following table: ● highlights the sensitivity of banking book NAV as a percentage of total capital; and ● reflects a point-in-time view which is dynamically managed and can fluctuate over time. Banking book NAV sensitivity to interest rate movements as a percentage of total group capital 2023 2023 * 2022 * Downward 400 bps 9.74 4.87 3.49 Upward 400 bps (8.22) (4.11) (3.11) * Calculated using 200 bps. -- 291 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B292- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.4.2 Structural foreign exchange risk Objective The group is exposed to foreign exchange risk as a result of on-balance sheet transactions in a currency other than the rand, as well as structural foreign exchange risk from the translation of its foreign operations’ results into rand. Group Treasury is responsible for oversight of structural foreign exchange risk and produces reports that are submitted to group ALCCO, a subcommittee of the RCCC. It is also responsible for reporting on and the management of the group’s foreign exchange exposure and macroprudential limit utilisation. Assessment and management The ability to transact on-balance sheet in a currency other than the home currency (rand) is governed by in- country macroprudential and regulatory limits. In the group, additional board limits and management risk appetite levels are set for this exposure. The impact of any residual on-balance positions is managed as part of the market risk reporting process (see Note 37.3.1 Traded market risk section). Structural foreign exchange risk impacts the current NAV of the group as well as future profitability and earnings potential. Economic hedging is undertaken where viable, given market constraints and within risk appetite levels. The following table provides an overview of the group’s exposure to entities with functional currencies other than the rand, and the pre-tax impact on equity of a 15% change in the exchange rate between the rand and the relevant functional foreign currencies. There were no significant structural hedging strategies employed by the group in the current financial year. -- 292 of 354 -- -B293- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Net structural foreign exposures 2023 2022 Pre-tax Pre-tax impact on impact on equity equity Carrying from 15% Carrying from 15% value of currency value of currency net translation net translation R million investment shock investment shock Functional currency Botswana pula 5 812 872 4 951 743 US dollar 13 429 2 014 10 592 1 589 Sterling 44 678 6 702 34 186 5 128 Nigerian naira 1 777 267 2 433 365 Zambian kwacha 2 251 338 1 324 199 Mozambican metical 1 067 160 670 101 Indian rupee 1 045 157 838 126 Ghanaian cedi 397 60 1 126 169 Tanzanian shilling 51 8 (139) (21) Common Monetary Area (CMA) countries * 7 346 1 102 7 539 1 131 Total 77 853 11 680 63 520 9 530 * Currently Namibia, Eswatini and Lesotho are part of the CMA. Unless these countries decide to exit the CMA, rand volatility will not impact these countries’ rand reporting values. -- 293 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B294- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.5 Equity investment risk Assessment and management The equity investment risk portfolio is managed through a rigorous evaluation and review process from the inception to exit of a transaction. All investments are subject to a comprehensive due diligence process, during which a thorough understanding of the target company’s business, risks, challenges, competitors, management team and unique advantage or value proposition is developed. For each transaction, an appropriate structure is put in place, which aligns the interests of all parties involved through the use of incentives and constraints for management and other investors. Where appropriate, the group seeks to take a number of seats on the company’s board and maintains close oversight through monitoring of operations and financial discipline. The investment thesis, results of the due diligence process and investment structure are discussed at the investment committee before final approval is granted. In addition, normal biannual reviews are performed for each investment and crucial parts of these reviews, such as valuation estimates, are independently peer reviewed. The table below shows the equity investment risk exposure and sensitivity. The 10% sensitivity movement is calculated on the carrying value of investments, excluding those subject to the ETL process, and including the carrying value of investments in associates and joint ventures. Investment risk exposure and sensitivity of investment risk R million 2023 2022 Listed investment risk exposure included in the equity investment risk ETL process 17 4 Estimated sensitivity of remaining investment balances Sensitivity to 10% movement in market value on investment fair value 311 215 -- 294 of 354 -- -B295- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.6 Insurance risk Long-term insurance products Overview and governance The risk arises from the group’s long-term insurance operations, underwritten through its subsidiary, FirstRand Life Assurance Limited (FirstRand Life). FirstRand Life currently underwrites a range of insurance products such as life, disability, funeral, credit life (against FNB credit products) and annuity policies. These policies are all originated through the FNB business. FirstRand Life also writes linked-investment policies. There is, however, no insurance risk associated with these policies as these policies do not have guaranteed benefits. FirstRand Life is exposed to insurance risk from the policies underwritten as indicated in the following table. Catastrophe risk Lapse risk Portfolio Description Core product type Risk Core life products Simple, non-underwritten products that are sold in the open market and are subject to simple sales processes. Funeral policies Mortality Benefit paid upon death of life assured Health cash plans Hospitalisation Benefit paid per day the policyholder is hospitalised Accidental death plans Mortality Benefit paid upon death of policyholder Lifestyle protection plans Morbidity Benefit paid upon death or disability PayProtect policies Morbidity and retrenchment Benefit paid upon disability or retrenchment -- 295 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B296- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Catastrophe risk Lapse risk Portfolio Description Core product type Risk Underwritten life products The underwritten life portfolio comprises Life Simplified and Life Customised. Life Simplified provides death cover up to R1 million after limited underwriting. Life Customised policies provide for more complex needs with cover amounts up to R100 million, R50 million and R5 million on death, disability and critical illness cover respectively. Life cover combined with disability and critical illness. o Mortality o Morbidity Credit life Products that are sold in conjunction with FNB’s credit products. The current offering includes credit cover across credit products within FNB – which include personal loans (compulsory), home loans (compulsory), housing financing, credit cards, overdrafts and revolving loans (voluntary). Credit life policies o Mortality o Morbidity o Retrenchment Business life products Products to business customers. o Key person policies o Grouped funeral policies o Business credit protect o Simplified group schemes o Personal health insurance o Mortality o Morbidity -- 296 of 354 -- -B297- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued As a result of these insurance risk exposures, the group is exposed to catastrophe risk stemming from the possibility of an extreme event linked to any of the above. For all of the above, the risk is that the decrement rates (e.g. mortality rates and morbidity rates) and associated cash flows are different from those assumed when pricing or reserving. Mortality, morbidity and retrenchment risk can further be broken down into parameter risk, random fluctuations and trend risk, which may result in the parameter value assumed differing from actual experience. Policies underwritten by FirstRand Life are available through all of FNB’s distribution channels. Some of these channels introduce the possibility of anti-selection, which also impacts the level of insurance risk. These policies also expose FirstRand Life to lapse risk, which is the risk of the loss of future profits and expenses risks. These risks are classified as business risks but are included in this section as they result from insurance products. The overall responsibility for risk management resides with the board. The board committees of FirstRand Insurance Holdings include an audit and risk committee, which provides oversight over risk management, and the assets, liability and capital committee (ALCCO), which is responsible for: ¾ providing oversight of the product suite; ¾ approving new products; ¾ financial resource management; and ¾ governance and challenging input models and results of pricing valuations. These committees are supported by management committees. Risk management Ensuring that insurance risk is understood and priced correctly is an important component of managing insurance risk. -- 297 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B298- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued This is achieved through: ¾ Rigorous and proactive risk management processes that ensure sound product design and accurate pricing which include: o independent model validation; o challenging assumptions, methodologies and results; o debating and challenging design, relevance, target market and market competitiveness, and treating customers fairly; o identifying potential risks; o monitoring business mix and risk of new business; and o thoroughly reviewing policy terms and conditions. ¾ Underwritten life policies. This allows underwriting limits and risk-based pricing to be applied to manage the insurance risk. Where specific channels introduce the risk of anti-selection, mix of business by channel is monitored. On non-underwritten products insurance risk can be controlled through lead selection for outbound sales. ¾ The design of appropriate reinsurance structures is an important component of the pricing and product design to keep risk exposure within appetite. The assessment and management of insurance risk of the in-force book use the following methodologies: ¾ Monitoring and reporting of claims experience by considering incidence rates, claims ratios and business mix. ¾ The actuarial valuation process involves the long-term projection of in-force policies and the setting up of insurance liabilities. This gives insight into the longer-term evolution of the risks on the portfolio. Adequate reserves are set for future and current claims and expenses. ¾ Experience investigations are performed annually to understand the actual experience compared to the basis used in valuations and pricing. These investigations are signed off by the head of the actuarial function. Where required, changes are made to bases and product design. ¾ There are also reinsurance agreements in place to mitigate various insurance risks and manage catastrophe risk. ¾ Asset/liability management is performed to ensure that assets backing insurance liabilities are appropriate and liquid. ¾ Stress and scenario analyses are performed and provide insights into the risk profile and future capital position. The management of insurance risk is governed by a suite of company policies and processes. Tools and systems are available in the business to assess and manage insurance risk. An own risk and solvency assessment (ORSA) process is performed at least annually. ORSA is defined as the entirety of the processes and procedures employed to identify, assess, monitor, manage and report on short- term and long-term risks that FirstRand Insurance Holdings faces or might face, and to determine the funds necessary to ensure that the overall solvency needs of FirstRand Life are met at all times and are sufficient to achieve its business strategy. An ORSA report is produced annually. -- 298 of 354 -- -B299- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Detailed risk management per risk type: Mortality risk is the risk that mortality rates and the associated cash flows are different from those assumed. The risk is managed as follows: ¾ For underwritten products, underwriting is a key control. ¾ For non-underwritten products the mix of business by various factors is monitored and outbound sales leads are selected to influence the desired mix. ¾ Reinsurance is used to control exposure to large risks. The retention limits vary by portfolio. ¾ Validation and fraud checks are performed at claim stage to ensure only valid claims in line with the terms and conditions of the policy are paid. Morbidity risk is the risk that morbidity rates and the associated cash flows are different from those assumed. The risk is managed as follows: ¾ Quota share reinsurance on underwritten products where there is limited data. ¾ Monitoring of trends in experience on credit life business. ¾ Validation and fraud checks are performed at claim stage to ensure only valid claims in line with the terms and conditions of the policy are paid. Retrenchment risk is the risk that retrenchment rates and the associated cash flows are different from those assumed. The risk is managed as follows: ¾ Selection of retrenchment risk is controlled by FNB’s credit scoring or internal selection models. ¾ Additional margins are allowed in pricing assumptions to allow for potential cyclicality in experience. ¾ Regular monitoring of exposure by industry and employer and feedback into risk selection takes place. ¾ Validation and fraud checks are performed at the claim stage to ensure only valid claims in line with the terms and conditions of the policy are paid. Catastrophe risk is the risk that stems from extreme or irregular events contingent on mortality, morbidity or retrenchment the effects of which are not expected. The risk is managed by catastrophe reinsurance, limiting exposure to mortality and morbidity catastrophes. The entity is, however, not covered for pandemics. The limits are reviewed annually based on the composition of the book and risk appetite. No cover is in place against retrenchment catastrophe as this is not available at a reasonable cost. Additional capital is held in economic capital to cover a retrenchment catastrophe scenario. -- 299 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B300- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Lapse risk is the risk that lapse rates and the associated cash flows are different from those assumed, as well as the risk of a mass lapse in policies. The risk is managed as follows: ¾ Collection strategies are regularly reviewed to ensure they are optimal. ¾ Changes to product lapse rules are made where more lenient lapse rules can benefit both the customer and FirstRand Life. Expenses risk is the risk that expenses and/or expense inflation is different from that assumed in pricing and valuations. The group has a rigorous budgeting process in place to manage the risk. Concentration risk The majority of the portfolio consists of funeral and credit life policies sold to retail customers. There is, therefore, no significant concentration risk, but the mix of portfolios according to various factors impacting different risk types is frequently monitored. Large policies in the underwritten portfolio are reinsured to avoid single large exposures to lives. Catastrophe reinsurance is in place to provide cover against many lives being lost in a single event (excluding pandemics). The following table demonstrates the concentration risk across insurance products for sums assured at risk before and after reinsurance. Before reinsurance Retail sums assured at Mortality risk Morbidity risk Retrenchment risk Total risk R million % R million % R million % R million 2023 1 – 499 999 205 397 44 72 397 56 20 096 100 297 890 500 000 – 999 999 66 258 14 18 249 14 63 - 84 570 1 000 000 – 1 999 999 141 294 30 10 403 8 16 - 151 713 2 000 000 and above 57 741 12 27 581 22 - - 85 322 Total 470 690 100 128 630 100 20 175 100 619 495 2022 1 – 499 999 183 098 44 61 128 57 18 044 100 262 270 500 000 – 999 999 63 331 15 17 155 16 77 - 80 563 1 000 000 – 1 999 999 131 739 31 7 790 7 17 - 139 546 2 000 000 and above 43 036 10 21 846 20 - - 64 882 Total 421 204 100 107 919 100 18 138 100 547 261 -- 300 of 354 -- -B301- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued After reinsurance Retail sums assured at Mortality risk Morbidity risk Retrenchment risk Total risk R million % R million % R million % R million 2023 1 – 499 999 187 747 57 70 179 66 19 957 100 277 883 500 000 – 999 999 48 004 14 14 439 13 13 - 62 456 1 000 000 – 1 999 999 82 660 25 4 107 4 4 - 86 771 2 000 000 and above 13 461 4 18 253 17 - - 31 714 Total 331 872 100 106 978 100 19 974 100 458 824 2022 1 – 499 999 158 386 54 53 989 64 15 345 100 227 720 500 000 – 999 999 46 887 16 12 323 15 16 - 59 226 1 000 000 – 1 999 999 78 885 27 2 186 3 3 - 81 074 2 000 000 and above 9 376 3 15 479 18 - - 24 855 Total 293 534 100 83 977 100 15 364 100 392 875 Assessment and management The assessment and management of insurance risk is influenced by the frequency and severity of claims, especially if actual benefits paid are greater than originally estimated, as well as the subsequent impact thereof on estimated long-term claims. The group manages the insurance risk of its policies through monitoring incidence rates, claims ratios and business mix, as policies are not underwritten and pricing is flat. Any other risk policies sold to a different target market are underwritten. This allows underwriting limits and risk-based pricing to be applied to manage the insurance risk. Where various channels introduce the risk of anti-selection, mix of business by channel is monitored. There is also a reinsurance agreement in place to manage catastrophe risk. Insurance risk mitigation The risk exposure is mitigated by diversification across a portfolio of insurance contracts and geographical areas. The variability of risks is also improved by careful selection and implementation of underwriting strategy guidelines, as well as the use of reinsurance arrangements. The group purchases reinsurance as part of its risk mitigation programme. The reinsurance agreements spread the risk of loss and minimise the effect of losses. The risk retention levels depend on the evaluation of specific risk, subject to certain circumstances, to maximum limits based on the characteristics of coverage. For life insurance products reinsurance ceded is placed on both a proportional and non-proportional basis. The majority of proportional reinsurance is quota share reinsurance, which is taken out to reduce the overall exposure to certain classes of business. Non-proportional reinsurance is primarily excess-of-loss reinsurance designed to mitigate the group’s net exposure to catastrophe losses. Amounts recoverable from reinsurers are estimated in a manner consistent with outstanding claims. -- 301 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B302- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Liability before zerorisation R million 2023 2022 * Liability at the beginning of the year (2 290) (2 025) Data and methodology changes - 18 Final liability at the beginning of the year (2 290) (2 007) Current period projection relating to in-force policies (1 132) (1 984) Experience variance (401) (106) Actual in-force liability at the end of the year (1 533) (2 090) New business and reinstatements (1 006) (1 065) Basis changes 80 939 – Economic basis (222) 186 – Mortality basis (95) 92 – Lapse basis (121) (29) – Retrenchment basis (170) - – Critical illness basis - 17 – Disability basis 17 (83) – New hospital cash basis - (80) – Expense basis 671 836 Liability post basis changes (as previously reported) (2 459) (2 216) Data and modelling changes* - (74) Final liability at the end of the year (2 459) (2 290) * The final liability for the prior year has been re-presented from R2 216 million to R2 290 million. Management identified that the incorrect mortality rate was used on the Life Simplified product and discounting has been incorrectly applied to the Funeral product’s premium. This resulted in a R74 million increase in the negative liability. As the group does not recognise the liability before zerorisation (i.e. the insurance margin asset), this re-presentation does not affect financial results for the prior year. The sensitivity analysis presented below has been re-presented. Sensitivities An analysis was performed in the current year for reasonably possible movements in key assumptions with all other assumptions held constant, showing the impact on the liabilities. R million 2023 2022 * 2022 Previously reported Base reserves (2 459) (2 290) (2 216) Sensitivity to interest rate changes – Interest rate decreased by 1% (2 277) (2 101) (2 031) Sensitivity to other changes in assumptions – Expenses down by 10% (2 876) (2 694) (2 605) – Lapses down by 10% (2 525) (2 357) (2 280) – Mortality and morbidity down by 5% (2 847) (2 660) (2 573) -- 302 of 354 -- -B303- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued The table below sets out what the IBNR liability would be if the key inputs were changed as set out below: IBNR sensitivities R million 2023 2022 Gross IBNR 500 609 Reinsurance asset (83) (105) Net IBNR 417 504 Gross IBNR with sensitivity * 543 667 Reinsurance asset with sensitivity * (90) (115) Net IBNR with sensitivity 453 552 * Sensitivities added to the IBNR reserve were: ‒ 7.5% (2022: 7.5%) on mortality ‒ 10% (2022: 10%) on morbidity ‒ 15% (2022: 15%) on retrenchment ‒ 15% (2022: 15%) on health Short-term insurance products The risk arises from the group’s short-term insurance operations. The terms and conditions of short-term insurance contracts have a material effect on the amount, timing and uncertainty of future cash flows. The key risks associated with general insurance contracts are claims experience. The methodology driving the provisions for these contracts is reviewed at least annually. As claims experience develops, certain claims are settled, further claims are revised and new claims are reported. The reasonableness of the estimation process is assessed by management and reviewed on a regular basis. The group believes that the liability for claims carried at the end of the year is adequate. The short-term insurance products offered by the group include: ● Liability – provides cover for risks relating to the incurring of a liability other than from risk covered more specifically under another insurance contract. ● Motor – provides indemnity cover relating to the possession, use or ownership of a motor vehicle. The cover includes comprehensive cover, third party, fire and theft, and third-party liabilities. ● Personal accident – provides compensation arising from a death or disability directly caused by an accident occurring anywhere in the world, provided that the death or disability occurs within 12 months of this injury. ● Property – provides indemnity relating to movable and immovable property caused by perils such as fire, explosions, earthquakes, acts of nature, burst geysers and pipes, malicious damage, impact, alterations and additions. -- 303 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B304- + Tier 1 capital Tier 2 capital CET1 capital x Share capital and premium x Retained earnings (appropriated) x Accumulated other comprehensive income x Non-controlling interests x Less: Specified regulatory deductions AT1 capital x Additional Tier 1 capital instruments x Instruments issued out of consolidated subsidiaries to third parties x Less: Specified regulatory deductions x Subordinated debt instruments x General provisions under the standardised approach x Provisions in excess of expected losses under the AIRB approach x Instruments issued out of consolidated subsidiaries to third parties x Less: Specified regulatory deductions Total qualif ying capita l and reser ves + = 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued 37.7 Capital management The capital planning process ensures that the CET1, Tier 1 and total capital adequacy ratios remain within or above target ranges and regulatory minimums across economic and business cycles. Capital is managed on a forward-looking basis and the group remains appropriately capitalised under a range of normal and severe stress scenarios. The group aims to back all economic risk with loss-absorbing capital and remains well capitalised in the current environment. The group continues to focus on the quality and mix of capital, as well as optimisation of the group’s RWA. The group’s capital ratios remain strong and above the regulatory minimums and internal targets. The board-approved internal targets are CET1 of 11.0% – 12.0%; Tier 1 of >12.0% and total capital of >14.75%. The following diagram defines the main components of qualifying capital and reserves. -- 304 of 354 -- -B305- 37 FINANCIAL AND INSURANCE RISKS continued Capital adequacy for the group’s regulated subsidiaries and foreign branches The group’s registered banking subsidiaries and foreign branches must comply with PA regulations and those of their respective in-country regulators, with primary focus placed on Tier 1 capital and total capital adequacy ratios. The group’s approach is that all entities must be adequately capitalised on a standalone basis. Adequate controls and processes are in place to ensure that each entity is adequately capitalised to meet in- country regulatory and economic capital requirements. Based on the outcome of detailed stress testing, each entity targets a capital level in excess of in-country regulatory minimums. Capital generated by subsidiaries in excess of targeted levels is returned to FirstRand, usually in the form of dividends unless retained for organic or inorganic growth. No restrictions were experienced on the repayment of dividends during the year under review. RMB Nigeria declared and paid a dividend to FREMA in May 2023. FREMA is in the process of converting the naira dividend into dollars, and this repatriation is expected to be concluded over an extended period given dollar liquidity constraints in Nigeria. Capital management for insurance entities Capital for insurance entities is calculated on a regulatory basis in line with Insurance Act No.18 of 2017 and regulations, as well as on an economic basis. Capital is risk sensitive and is also used to understand the exposure to insurance risk. The insurance group’s ORSA assesses the impact of various stresses on the solvency position of the insurance entities and informs the capital targets. Target levels for capital coverage are specified in the insurance risk appetite statement and have been met over the year under review. Insurance entities remain appropriately capitalised. -- 305 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B306- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION 38.1 Restatement of previously presented information 11.2 Analysis of instalment sales, hire purchase agreements and lease payments receivables The group has restated information previously presented in the annual financial statements. Instalment sales agreements had been incorrectly presented as lease payments receivable. The re-presentation has no impact on amounts previously presented in the statement of financial position and only impact the analysis of instalment sales, hire purchase agreements and lease payments receivable as set out in note 11.2. As previously Presented R million reported Movement in note 11 Within 1 year 69 324 (29 901) 39 423 Between 1 and 2 years 63 832 (28 190) 35 642 Between 2 and 3 years 55 681 (26 639) 29 042 Between 3 and 4 years 41 594 (19 560) 22 034 Between 4 and 5 years 22 159 (15 514) 6 645 More than 5 years 13 253 (11 219) 2 034 Total gross amount 265 843 (131 023) 134 820 Unearned finance charges (45 208) 26 691 (18 517) Net amount of hire purchase and lease payments receivable 220 635 (104 332) 116 303 Instalment sales 25 269 104 332 129 601 Total instalment sales, hire purchase agreements and lease payments receivable 245 904 - 245 904 Restatement of other assets and creditors, provisions and accruals Refer to accounting policy note 10.1 Note 6. Analysis of assets and liabilities 2022 – Restatement of other assets Non- Non- Total current and financial carrying non- R million instruments value contractual Previously reported 3 382 9 597 4 987 Adjustment (4 833) (4 833) (4 833) Restated (1 451) 4 764 154 2022 – Restatement of creditors, provisions and accruals Previously reported 16 282 35 761 11 371 Adjustment (4 833) (4 833) (4 833) Restated 11 449 30 928 6 538 -- 306 of 354 -- -B307- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38.1 Restatement of previously presented information continued Note 13 Other Assets Previously reported Restate R million 2022 Restatement 2022 Items in transit 2 067 - 2 067 Interest and commission accrued 23 - 23 Prepayments 2 246 - 2 246 Properties in possession 99 - 99 Sundry debtors 1 317 - 1 317 Fair value hedge asset 551 (4 833) (4 282) Dividends receivable 306 - 306 ‒ Profit share receivable on insurance cells 206 - 206 ‒ Other dividends receivable 100 - 100 Variation margin 807 - 807 Accounts receivable 2 510 - 2 510 Total gross carrying amount of other assets 9 926 (4 833) 5 093 ‒ Financial 6 544 - 6 544 ‒ Loss allowance on other financial assets (329) - (329) ‒ Non-financial 3 382 (4 833) (1 451) Total other assets 9 597 (4 833) 4 764 -- 307 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B308- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38.1 Restatement of previously presented information continued Note 37 Financial and insurance risks Restatement of net amount reported in the statement of financial position and the financial instruments not subject to offset or MNA. Derivatives As previously Presented R million reported Movement in note 37 Assets Offsetting applied Gross amount 113 434 (3 856) 109 578 Amount offset (43 911) - (43 911) Net amount reported on the statement of financial position 69 523 (3 856) 65 667 Offsetting not applied Financial instruments subject to MNAs and similar agreements (49 308) - (49 308) Financial collateral (6 890) - (6 890) Net amount 13 325 (3 856) 9 469 Financial instruments not subject to offset or MNAs (3 856) 3 856 - Total statement of financial position 65 667 (65 667) - Liabilities Offsetting applied Gross amount 114 776 (5 303) 109 473 Amount offset (44 926) - (44 926) Net amount reported on the statement of financial position 69 850 (5 303) 64 547 Offsetting not applied Financial instruments subject to MNAs and similar agreements (49 308) - (49 308) Financial collateral (15 752) 513 (15 239) Net amount 4 790 (4 790) - Financial instruments not subject to offset or MNAs (5 303) 5 303 - Total as per statement of financial position 64 547 (64 547) - The table has been condensed to reflect movements up to the net amount. -- 308 of 354 -- -B309- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38.1 Restatement of previously presented information continued Note 37 Financial and insurance risks Restatement of net amount reported in the statement of financial position and the financial instruments not subject to offset or MNA. Structured transactions Other advances As As previously Presented previously Presented reported Movement in note 37 reported Movement in note 37 70 946 13 674 84 620 - 1 263 707 1 263 707 (14 003) - (14 003) - - - 56 943 13 674 70 617 - 1 263 707 1 263 707 (585) - (585) - - - (56 358) - (56 358) - - - - 13 674 13 674 - 1 263 707 1 263 707 13 674 (13 674) - 1 263 707 (1 263 707) - 70 617 (70 617) - 1 263 707 (1 263 707) - 26 713 3 999 30 712 - 1 639 263 1 639 263 (14 003) - (14 003) - - - 12 710 3 999 16 709 - 1 639 263 1 639 263 (585) - (585) - - - (12 125) - (12 125) - - - - 3 999 3 999 - 1 639 263 1 639 263 3 999 (3 999) - 1 639 263 (1 639 263) - 16 709 (16 709) - 1 639 263 (1 639 263) - -- 309 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B310- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38.2 Impact due to movements in the classes of advances Revolving facilities have been moved from the retail other segment to personal loans. These revolving facilities are used by customers in meeting longer-term, high-value lending needs. This move will enable a single view of medium-term unsecured lending products and will align the external reporting with how these products are managed internally. The group has voluntarily updated the comparative information. The restated comparatives in note 11 Advances, note 12 Impairments and note 37 Financial and insurance risk have been included below. -- 310 of 354 -- -B311- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38.2 Impact due to movements in the classes of advances continued Note 11 Advances continued 11.5.5 Reconciliation of the gross carrying amount of total advances per class – Amortised cost Personal loans Retail other As As previously Move- Presented previously Move- Presented R million reported ment in note 11 reported ment in note 11 GCA reported as at 1 July 2021 39 709 7 199 46 908 15 712 (7 199) 8 513 – Stage 1 25 176 5 505 30 681 11 680 (5 505) 6 175 – Stage 2 6 987 694 7 681 1 540 (694) 846 – Stage 3 7 546 1 000 8 546 2 492 (1 000) 1 492 – Purchased or originated credit impaired – – – – – – Transfers between stages – – – – – – – Transfers to/(from) stage 1 (1 783) (187) (1 970) (277) 187 (90) Transfers into stage 1 2 005 111 2 116 496 (111) 385 Transfers out of stage 1 (3 788) (298) (4 086) (773) 298 (475) – Transfers to/(from) stage 2 (912) (146) (1 058) (192) 146 (46) Transfers into stage 2 2 735 135 2 870 481 (135) 346 Transfers out of stage 2 (3 647) (281) (3 928) (673) 281 (392) – Transfers to/(from) stage 3 2 695 333 3 028 469 (333) 136 Transfers into stage 3 3 665 (33) 3 632 699 33 732 Transfers out of stage 3 (970) 366 (604) (230) (366) (596) Current year movement 5 575 305 5 880 1 064 (305) 759 New business – changes in exposure 19 345 3 721 23 066 4 363 (3 721) 642 Back book – Current year movement (13 770) (3 416) (17 186) (3 299) 3 416 117 – Exposures with a change in measurement – basis from 12 months to LECL (1 393) (255) (1 648) (12) 255 243 – Other current year change in – exposure/net movement on GCA (12 377) (3 161) (15 538) (3 287) 3 161 (126) – Purchased or originated credit impaired – – – – – – Acquisition/(disposal) of advances – – – – – – Transfers from/(to) other divisions – – – 9 – 9 Transfers from/(to) non-current assets or disposal groups held for sale – – – – – – Exchange rate differences – – – – – – Bad debts written off (4 743) (995) (5 738) (2 324) 995 (1 329) Modifications that did not give rise to derecognition (368) (59) (427) (104) 59 (45) GCA as at 30 June 2022 40 173 6 450 46 623 14 357 (6 450) 7 907 – Stage 1 27 342 5 168 32 510 11 213 (5 168) 6 045 – Stage 2 6 557 592 7 149 1 178 (592) 586 – Stage 3 6 274 690 6 964 1 966 (690) 1 276 – Purchased or originated credit impaired – – – – – – Core lending advances 40 173 6 450 46 623 14 357 (6 450) 7 907 Assets under repurchase agreements – – – – – – Total GCA of advances at 30 June 2022 40 173 6 450 46 623 14 357 (6 450) 7 907 -- 311 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B312- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38.2 Impact due to movements in the classes of advances continued Note 11 Advances continued 11.5.6 Reconciliation of the loss allowance on total advances per class – Amortised cost Personal loans Retail other As As previously Move- Presented previously Move- Presented R million reported ment in note 11 reported ment in note 11 ECL reported as at 1 July 2021 8 630 1 406 10 036 3 119 (1 406) 1 713 – Stage 1 1 611 432 2 043 718 (432) 286 – Stage 2 1 722 279 2 001 575 (279) 296 – Stage 3 5 297 695 5 992 1 826 (695) 1 131 – Purchased or originated credit impaired – – – – – – Transfers between stages – – – – – – – Transfers to/(from) stage 1 (9) 8 (1) 21 (8) 13 Transfers into stage 1 272 29 301 76 (29) 47 Transfers out of stage 1 (281) (21) (302) (55) 21 (34) – Transfers to/(from) stage 2 (633) (96) (729) (61) 96 35 Transfers into stage 2 347 16 363 89 (16) 73 Transfers out of stage 2 (980) (112) (1 092) (150) 112 (38) – Transfers to/(from) stage 3 642 88 730 40 (88) (48) Transfers into stage 3 954 (17) 937 126 17 143 Transfers out of stage 3 (312) 105 (207) (86) (105) (191) Current year provision created/(released) 3 921 462 4 383 1 663 (462) 1 201 New business – impairment charge/(release) 2 262 315 2 577 375 (315) 60 Back book – impairment charge/(release) 1 659 147 1 806 1 288 (147) 1 141 – Exposures with a change in measurement – basis from 12 months to LECL (73) (25) (98) 29 25 54 – Other current year impairment – charge/(release) 1 732 172 1 904 1 259 (172) 1 087 – Purchased or originated credit impaired – – – – – – Acquisition/(disposal) of advances – – – – – – Transfers from/(to) other divisions – – – – – – Transfers from/(to) non-current assets or disposal groups held for sale – – – – – – Exchange rate differences – – – – – – Bad debts written off (4 743) (995) (5 738) (2 324) 995 (1 329) ECL as at 30 June 2022 7 808 873 8 681 2 458 (873) 1 585 – Stage 1 1 785 280 2 065 665 (280) 385 – Stage 2 1 544 183 1 727 330 (183) 147 – Stage 3 4 479 410 4 889 1 463 (410) 1 053 – Purchased or originated credit impaired – – – – – – Current year provision created/(released) per impairment stage 3 921 462 4 383 1 663 (462) 1 201 – Stage 1 183 (158) 25 (75) 158 83 – Stage 2 454 – 454 (184) – (184) – Stage 3 3 284 620 3 904 1 922 (620) 1 302 – Purchased or originated credit impaired – – – – – – -- 312 of 354 -- -B313- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38.2 Impact due to movements in the classes of advances continued Note 11 Advances continued 11.7 Modified advances measured at amortised cost 2022 Stage 2 and stage 3 Gross carrying Loss amount allowance Amortised before before cost before Modification R million modification modification modification gain/(loss) Personal loans Previously reported 2 205 (834) 1 371 (368) Movement 237 (77) 160 (94) Presented in note 11 2 442 (911) 1 531 (462) Retail other Previously reported 429 (169) 260 (104) Movement (237) 77 (160) 94 Presented in note 11 192 (92) 100 (10) -- 313 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B314- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38.2 Impact due to movements in the classes of advances continued Note 12 Impairment of advances 12.2.3 Breakdown of ECL created in the current period – Total retail unsecured 2022 Volume Change in Volume Change in Performing change stage 1 change stage 2 book R million in stage 1 coverage in stage 2 coverage provisions * Previously reported 212 178 (369) (88) - Movement 12 (12) 27 (27) - Presented in note 12 224 166 (342) (115) (67) * New sub-total not previously presented. ** Previously presented in gross write-off and other. Note 37 Financial and insurance risks Credit assets Previously Presented R million reported Adjustment in note 37 Breakdown of advances per class Gross advances 1 382 058 - 1 382 058 Retail secured 342 111 - 342 111 – Residential mortgages 242 757 - 242 757 – WesBank VAF 99 354 - 99 354 Retail unsecured 87 351 - 87 351 – FNB card 32 821 - 32 821 – Personal loans 40 173 6 450 46 623 – Retail other 14 357 (6 450) 7 907 Corporate and commercial 533 747 - 533 747 – FNB commercial 107 823 - 107 823 – WesBank corporate 45 128 - 45 128 – RMB corporate and investment banking 380 796 - 380 796 Broader Africa 67 247 - 67 247 Group Treasury and other 47 756 - 47 756 UK operations 303 846 - 303 846 – Retail 231 437 - 231 437 – Commercial 72 409 - 72 409 -- 314 of 354 -- -B315- 2022 Credit Interest Change in provision Gross Current suspended Post stage 3 increase/ write-off year ECL Modification on stage 3 write-off provisions decrease and other provided * loss advances ** recoveries Total (1 738) (1 805) 7 274 - 547 - (1 653) 4 363 - - 1 764 - - (1 764) - - (1 738) (1 805) 9 038 7 233 547 (1 764) (1 653) 4 363 -- 315 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B316- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38.2 Impact due to movements in the classes of advances continued Note 37 Financial and insurance risks continued 37.1.2 Quality of credit assets FNB personal loans Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3 As As As previously Move- Presented previously Move- Presented previously Move- Presented R million reported ment in note 37 reported ment in note 37 reported ment in note 37 FR 1-25 On-balance sheet 115 99 214 90 1 91 - - - Off-balance sheet - - - - - - - - - FR 26-90 On-balance sheet 25 788 5 004 30 792 1 699 20 1 719 - - - Off-balance sheet - - - - - - - - - FR 91-100 On-balance sheet 1 439 65 1 504 4 768 571 5 339 6 274 690 6 964 Off-balance sheet - - - - - - - - - FNB retail other FR 1-25 On-balance sheet 488 (99) 389 1 (1) - 4 - 4 Off-balance sheet 141 - 141 - - - - - - FR 26-90 On-balance sheet 10 584 (5 004) 5 580 136 (20) 116 1 - 1 Off-balance sheet 304 - 304 - - - - - - FR 91-100 On-balance sheet 141 (65) 76 1 041 (571) 470 1 961 (690) 1 271 Off-balance sheet 177 - 177 - - - - - - Analysis of impaired advances (stage 3) 2022 Security held and expected Stage 3 R million Total recoveries impairment Stage 3 by class Personal loans As previously reported 6 274 1 795 4 479 Movement 690 280 410 Presented in note 37 6 964 2 075 4 889 Retail other As previously reported 1 966 503 1 463 Movement (690) (280) (410) Presented in note 37 1 276 223 1 053 -- 316 of 354 -- -B317- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38. Impact due to movements in the classes of advances continued Note 37 Financial and insurance risks continued 37.1.4 Credit risk mitigation and collateral held FNB personal loans FNB retail other As As previously Presented previously Presented R million reported Movement in note 37 reported Movement in note 37 Gross carrying amount 40 173 6 450 46 623 14 357 (6 450) 7 907 Off-balance sheet exposure - - - 622 - 622 Loss allowance (7 808) (873) (8 681) (2 458) 873 (1 585) Maximum exposure to credit risk 32 365 5 577 37 942 12 521 (5 577) 6 944 Supported as follows: Netting and financial collateral - - - - - - Secured - - - 2 220 - 2 220 Unsecured 32 365 5 577 37 942 10 301 (5 577) 4 724 -- 317 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B318- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38.3 Voluntary changes in presentation The group has made voluntary changes to certain notes presented. To allow the user to compare the restated comparatives provided with the information previously presented, the note previously included in the annual financial statements has been included below. Note 12 Impairment of advances 12.2.3 Breakdown of ECL created in the current period The group has made voluntary changes in the breakdown of ECL created in the current period per key driver. New sub-total columns have been added and interest suspended on stage 3 advances has been split out from the gross write-off and other column. Set out below is the note previously included in the annual financial statements. 2022 Change in Change in Change in Change in volume coverage volume coverage R million stage 1 stage 1 stage 2 stage 2 Total retail secured 93 (71) 58 303 Total retail unsecured 212 178 (369) (88) Temporary stress scenario 130 (105) 137 (136) Total retail secured and unsecured 435 2 (174) 79 Total FNB commercial 159 (171) (105) (266) – FNB commercial 120 (31) (113) (266) – Temporary stress scenario 39 (140) 8 - – WesBank corporate 21 (32) 38 (53) – RMB corporate and investment banking 389 (713) (226) (620) Total corporate and commercial 569 (916) (293) (939) Broader Africa 129 (86) (124) 59 Centre (including Group Treasury) (335) 334 (25) 20 UK operations 207 373 439 (484) Total 1 005 (293) (177) (1 265) -- 318 of 354 -- -B319- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGED IN PRESENTATION continued 38.3 Voluntary changes in presentation The group has made voluntary changes to certain notes presented. To allow the user to compare the restated comparatives provided with the information previously presented, the note previously included in the annual financial statements has been included below. Note 12 Impairment of advances 12.2.3 Breakdown of ECL created in the current period The group has made voluntary changes in the breakdown of ECL created in the current period per key driver. New sub-total columns have been added and interest suspended on stage 3 advances has been split out from the gross write-off and other column. Set out below is the note previously included in the annual financial statements. 2022 Change in Credit Gross Post stage 3 provision Modification write-off write-off provisions increase loss and other recoveries Total (1 057) (674) 136 2 414 (415) 1 461 (1 738) (1 805) 547 7 274 (1 653) 4 363 (44) (18) - - - (18) (2 839) (2 497) 683 9 688 (2 068) 5 806 (234) (617) (4) 1 089 (114) 354 (234) (524) (4) 1 089 (114) 447 - (93) - - - (93) (135) (161) - 196 (23) 12 829 (341) - (69) (10) (420) 460 (1 119) (4) 1 216 (147) (54) (23) (45) - 519 (299) 175 - (6) - (1) - (7) 248 783 - 619 (242) 1 160 (2 154) (2 884) 679 12 041 (2 756) 7 080 -- 319 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B320- 38 IMPACT DUE TO CHANGES IN PRESENTATION continued 38.3 Voluntary changes in presentation Note 37 Financial and insurance risks 37.1.1 Credit assets and concentration risk Geographic concentration of significant credit asset exposure The group has made voluntary changes to the geographical concentration risk information presented in note 37 Financial and insurance risk. North and South America, Australasia and Asia has been collapsed into a single column Asia, Americas, and Australasia. Total advances were used to determine which geographical areas would be presented together. Set out below is the note previously included in the annual financial statements. 2022 North South Broader United Other and South Austra- R million Africa Africa Kingdom Europe America lasia Asia Total On-balance sheet exposures Cash and short- term funds 64 513 9 746 35 585 8 305 12 841 302 633 131 925 Total advances 918 509 106 647 321 624 23 763 4 270 88 7 157 1 382 058 Stage 3 advances 39 416 3 447 7 930 5 1 83 4 50 886 Derivatives 35 922 527 23 821 4 869 494 - 34 65 667 Debt investment securities 232 438 32 816 32 992 25 951 35 212 1 170 2 401 362 980 Other assets 4 453 945 814 103 164 10 55 6 544 Reinsurance assets 569 14 - - - - - 583 Off-balance sheet exposures Guarantees, acceptances, and letters of credit 39 964 8 721 20 280 1 273 23 10 2 967 73 238 Irrevocable commitments 141 508 14 728 13 911 667 1 702 - 279 172 795 -- 320 of 354 -- -B321- 39 STANDARDS AND INTERPRETATIONS ISSUED BUT NOT YET EFFECTIVE The following new and revised standards and interpretations are applicable to the business of the group. The group will comply with these from the stated effective date. Standard Impact assessment Effective date IFRS 16 Lease liability in a sale and lease back – amendments to IFRS 16 The amendment to IFRS 16 specifies the requirements that a seller-lessee uses in measuring the lease liability arising in a sale and lease back transaction, to ensure the seller-lessee does not recognise any amount of the gain or loss that relates to the right of use it retains. Applying these requirements does not prevent the seller-lessee from recognising, in profit or loss, any gain or loss relating to the partial or full termination of a lease, as required by paragraph 46(a) of IFRS 16. The amendment is not expected to have a significant impact on the annual financial statements. Annual periods commencing on or after 1 January 2024 IFRS 17 Background and overview IFRS 17 is the new standard that prescribes the accounting for insurance contracts and will replace the current insurance contracts standard, IFRS 4. The group will apply IFRS 17 from 1 July 2023 and will restate the comparative information in its 30 June 2024 financial statements and adjust its opening balances as at 1 July 2022 i.e. full retrospective application. Appropriate project teams and governance structures have been established for the management and oversight of the group’s IFRS 17 project. The project is in the final stages of internal validation with the finalisation of the external audit to follow thereafter. Types of insurance contracts issued and measurement models applied The group writes insurance contracts without direct participation features and, where the coverage period is less than one year, the premium allocation approach (PAA) will be applied. Similar treatment will be applied for reinsurance contracts held with a coverage period of less than one year. In all other circumstances, the general measurement model (GMM) will be applied. For more information on the types of insurance contracts that the group issues, refer to note 37.6. Annual periods commencing on or after 1 January 2023 -- 321 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B322- 39 STANDARDS AND INTERPRETATIONS ISSUED BUT NOT YET EFFECTIVE continued Standard Impact assessment Effective date IFRS 17 continued General measurement model (including reinsurance contracts held) The insurance asset or liability and the reinsurance asset or liability under IFRS 17 comprise of the sum of the liability for remaining coverage (LRC) and the liability for incurred claims (LIC). The LRC is a prospective reserve that represents the group’s rights and obligations relating to future services not yet provided and comprises of a risk adjustment for non-financial risk (“risk adjustment”), discounted estimates of future cash flows including deferred acquisition cash flows and unearned profit in the form of the contractual service margin (CSM). For groups of insurance contracts that are onerous, a day one loss will be recognised in the income statement instead of the CSM, and a corresponding income will be recognised on the related reinsurance contract held. Under IFRS 4, the group does not recognise any prospective reserves nor the excess of the estimated cash inflows over the estimated cash outflows (referred to as zerorisation i.e effectively not recognising the negative liability). The group furthermore immediately expenses acquisition costs. As a result, the transitional adjustment for contracts measured using the GMM predominately arises due to the differences in the measurement of the LRC. The LIC is similar to the group’s IBNR and OCR, which are part of the group’s policyholder liabilities for insurance contracts and the reinsurance asset for reinsurance contracts. However, unlike the treatment of these balances under IFRS 4, the LIC is discounted and includes a risk adjustment, which is a margin that captures the uncertainty inherent in the valuation of the insurance liability as a result of non-financial risk. These differences are immaterial for the group. Premium allocation approach (including reinsurance contracts held) The LRC for contracts measured using the PAA is based on actual premiums adjusted for revenue recognised (or expenses recognised for reinsurance contracts issued) as the group has elected to immediately expense insurance acquisition cash flows for contracts with a coverage period of one year or less. This is similar to the unearned premium reserve currently recognised by the group as part of policyholder liabilities (reinsurance premium payable for reinsurance contracts held), resulting in a negligible adjustment at transition for contracts under the PAA. The measurement and transitional impact of IFRS 17 on the LIC under the PAA is the same as that described under the GMM. -- 322 of 354 -- -B323- 39 STANDARDS AND INTERPRETATIONS ISSUED BUT NOT YET EFFECTIVE continued Standard Impact assessment Effective date IFRS 17 continued Revenue recognition under IFRS 17 Under IFRS 4, insurance income is recognised based on premiums earned during the period, whereas under IFRS 17 insurance revenue will be recognised based on the release of the LRC to the income statement. For contracts measured under the PAA, insurance revenue will be recognised based on the passage of time, resulting in a similar outcome to the current treatment under IFRS 4 due to the short coverage periods. Insurance revenue for contracts measured under the GMM will reflect the even provision of services over the coverage period, resulting in a smoother recognition of revenue for contracts with long coverage periods compared to the revenue that is currently recognised. Insurance service expenses Under IFRS 4, the group recognises expenses for incurred claims and claims-related costs as part of claims and benefits paid within insurance income. Insurance service expenses under IFRS 17 will comprise of incurred claims and other directly attributable expenses and changes thereto, the amortisation of deferred insurance acquisition cash flows for GMM contracts, insurance acquisition cash flows immediately expensed on PAA contracts and losses and reversals of losses on onerous contracts. The amount presented as insurance service expenses under IFRS 17 will be different due to onerous losses and reversals and the inclusion of directly attributable costs that are currently reflected as part of operating expenses. Reinsurance income and expenses Insurance income under IFRS 17 will comprise of claim recoveries from the reinsurer, similar to the treatment under IFRS 4. Reinsurance expenses will comprise of the amounts released from the reinsurance LRC to the income statement, like the insurance revenue recognised for insurance contracts issued. This will result in a difference for reinsurance contracts with longer coverage periods measured under the GMM. Insurance and reinsurance finance income and expenses The group will recognise insurance finance income and expenses separately, as well as reinsurance finance income and expenses under IFRS 17, which represent the effect of the unwinding of the discounting on the LRC and the LIC. The group has chosen to elect the option to present the portion of the insurance and reinsurance finance income and expenses arising from changes in discount rates in OCI for selected portfolios measured under the general measurement model where the effect of changes in discount rates is material. -- 323 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B324- 39 STANDARDS AND INTERPRETATIONS ISSUED BUT NOT YET EFFECTIVE continued Standard Impact assessment Effective date IFRS 17 continued Tax implications Amendments to the tax legislation as a result of IFRS 17 were promulgated in January 2023, and were substantively enacted as at 31 December 2022. The amendments will not impact the group’s financial results at 30 June 2023. The change in tax legislation will be effective for the group’s financial year commencing on 1 July 2023. Standard Impact assessment Effective date IAS 1 Amendments to classification of liabilities as current or non-current The IAS 1 amendments clarify the requirements for classifying liabilities as current or non-current. More specifically: ¾ The amendments specify that the conditions which exist at the end of the reporting period are those which will be used to determine if a right to defer settlement of a liability exists. ¾ Management expectations about events after the balance sheet date, for example on whether a covenant will be breached, or whether early settlement will take place, are not relevant. ¾ The amendments clarify the situations that are considered settlement of a liability. The group presents its assets and liabilities in order of liquidity in the statement of financial position. The impact of this amendment would impact the disclosure of current versus non-current liabilities in the notes to the financial statements. The group does not expect this amendment to have a significant impact on the annual financial statements. Annual periods commencing on or after 1 January 2024 Disclosure of accounting policies – amendments to IAS 1 and IFRS Practice Statement 2 The IASB issued amendments to IAS 1 and an update to IFRS Practice Statement 2 Making Materiality Judgements to help preparers provide useful accounting policy disclosures. The key amendments to IAS 1 include: ¾ requiring companies to disclose their material accounting policies rather than their significant accounting policies; ¾ clarifying that accounting policies related to immaterial transactions, other events or conditions are themselves immaterial and as such need not be disclosed; and ¾ clarifying that not all accounting policies that relate to material transactions, other events or conditions are themselves material to a company’s financial statements. Annual periods commencing on or after 1 January 2023 -- 324 of 354 -- -B325- 39 STANDARDS AND INTERPRETATIONS ISSUED BUT NOT YET EFFECTIVE continued Standard Impact assessment Effective date IAS 8 Definition of accounting estimates The amendments to IAS 8 introduce a new definition for accounting estimates, clarifying that they are monetary amounts in the financial statements that are subject to measurement uncertainty. The amendments also clarify the relationship between accounting policies and accounting estimates by specifying that a company develops an accounting estimate to achieve the objective set out by an accounting policy. Annual periods commencing on or after 1 January 2023 IAS 12 Deferred tax related to assets and liabilities arising from a single transaction The amendments narrow the scope of the initial recognition exemption so that it does not apply to transactions that give rise to equal and offsetting temporary differences. As a result a deferred tax asset and a deferred tax liability will need to be recognised for temporary differences arising on initial recognition of a lease and decommissioning provision. Annual periods commencing on or after 1 January 2023 -- 325 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND GROUP CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B326- 40 EVENTS AFTER REPORTING PERIOD There were no significant events that occurred between the end of the reporting period and the issue of the annual financial statements. -- 326 of 354 -- -B327- ANNUAL INTEGRATED REPORT 2023 Financial statements for the year ended 30 June 2023 FirstRand Limited -- 327 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B328- STATEMENT OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME for the year ended 30 June R million Notes 2023 2022 Revenue 2 33 732 24 325 Net interest income 3 23 15 Interest and similar income 3 23 15 Income from operations 33 755 24 340 Operating expenses 4 (220) (197) Income before indirect tax 33 535 24 143 Indirect tax 5.1 (12) (9) Income before income tax 33 523 24 134 Income tax expense 5.2 (19) (437) Profit for the year 33 504 23 697 Other comprehensive income - - Total comprehensive income for the year 33 504 23 697 Attributable to Ordinary equityholders 33 342 23 452 NCNR preference shareholders 162 245 Total comprehensive income for the year 33 504 23 697 -- 328 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B329- STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION as at 30 June R million Notes 2023 2022 ASSETS Cash and cash equivalents 7 829 217 Other assets 8 13 194 Investments in subsidiaries 9 80 475 80 275 Total assets 81 317 80 686 EQUITY AND LIABILITIES Liabilities Creditors and accruals 10 224 174 Current tax liability 72 413 Amounts owing to subsidiaries 9 26 8 Employee liabilities 11 270 198 Total liabilities 592 793 Equity Ordinary shares 12 56 56 Share premium 12 8 056 8 056 Reserves 72 613 67 262 Capital and reserves attributable to ordinary equityholders 80 725 75 374 NCNR preference shares 12 - 4 519 Total equity 80 725 79 893 Total equity and liabilities 81 317 80 686 -- 329 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B330- STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN EQUITY for the year ended 30 June Ordinary share capital and ordinary equityholders' funds Share capital Share Share and share R million Notes capital premium premium Balance as at 1 July 2021 56 8 056 8 112 Ordinary dividends 13 - - - Preference dividends 13 - - - Total comprehensive income for the year - - - Balance as at 30 June 2022 56 8 056 8 112 Buyback of NCNR preference shares - - - Ordinary dividends 13 - - - Preference dividends 13 - - - Total comprehensive income for the year - - - Balance as at 30 June 2023 56 8 056 8 112 -- 330 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B331- Ordinary share capital and ordinary equityholders’ funds Reserves Capital attributable NCNR redemption Retained to ordinary preference reserve earnings equityholders shares Total equity 1 61 199 61 200 4 519 73 831 - (17 390) (17 390) - (17 390) - - - (245) (245) - 23 452 23 452 245 23 697 1 67 261 67 262 4 519 79 893 - - - (4 519) (4 519) - (27 991) (27 991) - (27 991) - - - (162) (162) - 33 342 33 342 162 33 504 1 72 612 72 613 - 80 725 -- 331 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B332- STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS for the year ended 30 June R million Notes 2023 2022 Cash flows from operating activities Interest received 23 15 Other income received 104 - Other operating expenses paid (70) (81) Dividends received 33 758 24 428 Dividends paid (28 130) (17 635) Taxation paid (372) (17) Cash generated from operating activities 5 313 6 710 Movement in operating assets and liabilities Other assets 32 - Employee liabilities (64) (53) Creditors and accruals 50 (278) Net cash generated from operating activities 5 331 6 379 Cash flows from investing activities Additional investments in subsidiaries (200) (6 773) Net cash outflow from investing activities (200) (6 773) Cash flows from financing activities Redemption of preference shares (4 519) - Net cash outflow from financing activities (4 519) - Net increase/(decrease) in cash and cash equivalents 612 (394) Cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the year 7 217 611 Cash and cash equivalents at the end of the year 7 829 217 -- 332 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B333- NOTES TO THE ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS for the year ended 30 June 1 SUMMARY OF SIGNIFICANT ACCOUNTING POLICIES 1.1 Revenue and other income Revenue is measured at the fair value of the consideration received or receivable. Revenue within the company comprises fees from subsidiaries and dividend income from investments in subsidiaries. The company recognises revenue from fees when the amount can be reliably measured and it is probable that future economic benefits will flow to the company from it. Dividends are recognised when the company’s right to receive payment is established. 1.2 Other accounting policies The financial statements of FirstRand Limited Company are prepared according to the same accounting policies used in preparing the consolidated financial statements of the group, other than the accounting policies on consolidation, equity accounting and translation of foreign operations that are specific to group financial statements. For detailed accounting policies refer to page B37 and onwards in the 2023 annual financial statements. The financial statements are prepared on the going concern basis in accordance with IFRS. Items included in the financial statements are measured using the currency of the primary economic environment in which the entity operates (the functional currency). Functional and presentation currency of the company South African rand (R) Level of rounding All amounts are presented in millions of rands. The company has a policy of rounding up in increments of R500 000. Therefore, amounts less than R500 000 will round down to Rnil and are presented as a dash. -- 333 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B334- 2 REVENUE R million 2023 2022 Fee and commission income Incremental and directly attributable fee and commission expense (149) (148) Recoveries from subsidiaries 123 46 Total fee and commission (expense) (26) (102) Fair value income Translation losses - (1) Total fair value income - (1) Gains less losses from investing activities Dividends received from subsidiaries – unlisted shares Ordinary dividends 33 758 24 428 Total gains less losses from investing activities 33 758 24 428 Total revenue 33 732 24 325 3 NET INTEREST INCOME R million 2023 2022 Interest and similar income Cash and cash equivalents 23 15 Interest and similar income 23 15 4 OPERATING EXPENSES R million Notes 2023 2022 Advertising and marketing (2) - Directors’ fees (44) (41) Direct staff costs (165) (138) – Salaries,wages and allowances (59) (53) – Share-based payment expense 11 (105) (84) – Social security levies (1) (1) Professional fees - (5) Corporate memberships (4) (4) Other operating expenditure (5) (9) Total operating expenses (220) (197) -- 334 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B335- 5 INDIRECT AND INCOME TAX EXPENSE R million 2023 2022 5.1 Indirect tax Value-added tax (net) (1) (9) Securities transfer tax (11) - Total indirect tax (12) (9) 5.2 Income tax expense South African income tax Normal tax̶ current year (19) (437) – Current tax (22) (9) – Prior year adjustment 3 (428) Total income tax expense (19) (437) Tax rate reconciliation̶ South African normal tax % 2023 2022 Standard rate of income tax 27.0 28.0 Total tax has been affected by: Dividends received (27.1) (28.3) Other 0.2 2.1 Effective rate of tax 0.1 1.8 -- 335 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B336- 6 ANALYSIS OF ASSETS AND LIABILITIES BY CATEGORY The principal accounting policies from page B37 describe how the classes of financial instruments are measured and how income and expenses, including fair value gains and losses, are recognised. The following table analyses the financial assets and liabilities in the statement of financial position per category of financial instrument to which they are assigned, and therefore by measurement basis and according to when the assets are expected to be realised and liabilities settled. 2023 Financial Financial assets at liabilities at Non- amortised amortised financial R million Notes cost cost instruments ASSETS Cash and cash equivalents 7 829 - - Other assets 8 13 - - Investment in subsidiaries 9 - - 80 475 Total assets 842 - 80 475 LIABILITIES Creditors and accruals 10 - 149 75 Current tax liability - - 72 Amounts owing to subsidiaries 9 - 26 - Employee liabilities 11 - - 270 Total liabilities - 175 417 2022 ASSETS Cash and cash equivalents 7 217 - - Other assets 8 - - 194 Investment in subsidiaries 9 - - 80 275 Total assets 217 - 80 469 LIABILITIES Creditors and accruals 10 - 126 48 Current tax liability - - 413 Amounts owing to subsidiaries 9 - 8 - Employee liabilities 11 - - 198 Total liabilities - 134 659 At the reporting date all other assets are considered to be neither past due nor impaired. The carrying value of cash and cash equivalents, other assets, creditors and accruals approximates the fair value. -- 336 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B337- ##6 ANALYSIS OF ASSETS AND LIABILITIES BY CATEGORY The principal accounting policies from page B34 describe how the classes of financial instruments are measured and how income and expenses, including fair value gains and losses, are recognised. The following table analyses the financial assets and liabilities in the statement of financial position per category of financial instrument to which they are assigned, and therefore by measurement basis and according to when the assets are expected to be realised and liabilities settled. 2023 Total carrying value Current Non-current 829 829 - 13 13 - 80 475 - 80 475 81 317 842 80 475 224 171 53 72 72 - 26 26 - 270 86 184 592 355 237 2022 217 217 - 194 194 - 80 275 - 80 275 80 686 411 80 275 174 129 45 413 413 - 8 8 - 198 63 135 793 613 180 -- 337 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B338- 7 CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS R million 2023 2022 Money at call and short notice 829 217 Cash and cash equivalents 829 217 8 OTHER ASSETS R million 2023 2022 Standby liquidity facility - 149 Accounts receivable 13 45 Total other assets 13 194 In a prior year the company provided the Bank of England (BoE) with a financial guarantee to support the qualification of Aldermore Bank (a subsidiary of the group) for a collateral upgrade from the BoE. In order to manage the liquidity risk associated with providing this financial guarantee to the BoE, the company procured a standby liquidity facility from an international bank, in the unlikely event that the company were to be called up to honour the financial guarantee contract with the BoE and would require liquidity at short notice. The liquidity facility attracted a fee which was capitalised to the balance sheet and released to the income statement over the period of the liquidity facility. The following table analyses the financial assets and liabilities in the statement of financial position per category of financial instrument to which they are assigned and therefore by measurement basis and according to when the assets are expected to be realised and liabilities settled. -- 338 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B339- 9 INVESTMENT IN SUBSIDIARIES % % Shares at cost owner- voting Nature of 2023 2022 ship rights business R million R million FirstRand EMA Holdings Limited (FREMA) Financial services Ordinary shares 100 100 7 675 7 675 FirstRand Bank Limited Banking Ordinary shares 100 100 40 194 40 194 FirstRand Investment Holdings Other activities Proprietary Limited Ordinary shares 100 100 4 038 4 038 FirstRand Investment Management Investment Holdings Limited management Ordinary shares 100 100 599 399 FirstRand Insurance Holdings Proprietary Insurance services Limited Ordinary shares 100 100 853 853 FirstRand International Limited (FRI) Banking Ordinary shares 100 100 26 699 26 699 Total 80 058 79 858 Investment through equity-settled share Equity-settled incentive scheme * share scheme 417 417 Total investments in subsidiaries 80 475 80 275 Amounts owing to subsidiaries 26 8 * This related to the share options granted to employees who were employed by companies that remained in the FirstRand Group after the unbundling of a wholly-owned subsidiary transaction. With the exception of FREMA and FRI, which offer financial services across Africa and the UK, the principal place of business for all of the company’s subsidiaries is South Africa. Increases in investments in subsidiaries During the current financial year, the company acquired additional shares in its wholly owned subsidiary FirstRand Investment Management Holdings Limited amounting to R200 million. In the prior year the company acquired additional shares in its wholly owned subsidiaries FirstRand Insurance Holdings Limited and FRI, the cost amounted to R140 million and R6 633 million respectively. -- 339 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B340- 10 CREDITORS AND ACCRUALS R million 2023 2022 Unclaimed dividends 136 113 Accounts payable and accrued liabilities 41 15 Audit fee accrual 7 7 Financial guarantee liability * 40 39 Total creditors and accruals 224 174 * The maximum exposure of the financial guarantee issued to the BoE amounts to R23 954 million (2022: R19 950 million) and FirstRand Short Term Insurance Limited R250 million (2022: R250 million). The full exposures are included in stage 1 ECL. Both guarantees are open-ended until such time as the company cancels the contract and as such the guarantees are long dated. The probability of the guarantees being called upon is considered low and has a credit rating of AA. 11 EMPLOYEE LIABILITIES R million 2023 2022 Liability for short-term employee benefits Opening balance 74 65 Additional provisions created 31 27 Utilised during the year (22) (18) Total liability for short-term employee benefits 83 74 Share-based payment liability Opening balance 124 75 Share-based payment settlement (cash) (42) (35) Charge to profit or loss 105 84 Total share-based payment liability 187 124 Total employee liabilities 270 198 The charge to profit or loss for share-based payments is as follows: FirstRand share appreciation rights scheme 105 84 Amount included in operating expenses 105 84 For a detailed description of share option schemes and trusts in which FirstRand Limited Company participates refer to note 32 of the consolidated annual financial statements. -- 340 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B341- 12 SHARE CAPITAL AND SHARE PREMIUM 12.1 Share capital and share premium classified as equity Authorised shares 2023 2022 Ordinary shares 6 001 688 450 6 001 688 450 A preference shares – unlisted variable rate cumulative convertible redeemable 198 311 550 198 311 550 B preference shares – listed variable rate non-cumulative non-redeemable 100 000 000 100 000 000 C preference shares – unlisted variable rate convertible non-cumulative redeemable 100 000 000 100 000 000 D preference shares – unlisted variable rate cumulative redeemable 100 000 000 100 000 000 Issued shares 2023 2022 Ordinary Ordinary share Share share Share Number of capital premium Number of capital premium shares R million R million shares R million R million Opening balance 5 609 488 001 56 8 056 5 609 488 001 56 8 056 Shares issued - - - - - - Total issued ordinary share capital and share premium 5 609 488 001 56 8 056 5 609 488 001 56 8 056 B preference shares - - - 45 000 000 - 4 519 Total issued share capital attributable to ordinary equityholders 56 8 056 56 12 575 The unissued ordinary shares are under the control of the directors until the next annual general meeting. Dividends on the B preference shares are calculated at a rate of 75.56% of the prime lending rate of FNB, a division of FirstRand Bank Limited. In the current year, the B preference shares were redeemed by FirstRand Limited. -- 341 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B342- 13 DIVIDENDS R million 2023 2022 Ordinary dividends A final dividend of 195.00 cents * (14 September 2022: 185.00 cents ** ) per share was declared on 13 September 2023 in respect of the six months ended 30 June 2023. 17 389 8 583 A special dividend of 125 cents per share was declared on 14 September 2022 **. An interim dividend of 189.00 cents ** (March 2022: 157.00 cents) per share was declared on 1 March 2023 in respect of the six months ended 31 December 2022. 10 602 8 807 Total ordinary dividends paid for the year 27 991 17 390 B preference shares A final pro rata dividend of 52.2 cents** was paid on 26 September 2022 as part of the process to redeem the B preference shares #. 24 A final dividend of 307.4 cents** (August 2021: 273.90 cents) per share was declared on 29 August 2022 in respect of the six months ended 30 June 2022. 138 123 In the prior year an interim dividend of 270.70 cents per share was declared on 28 February 2022 in respect of the six months ended 31 December 2021. - 122 Total preference dividends paid for the year 162 245 * The final dividend is not reflected in the statement of changes in equity as this relates to a dividend declared post year end. ** These dividends are reflected in the statement of changes in equity for the current year. # The B preference shares were redeemed in the current financial year with the final dividend paid on 26 September 2022. -- 342 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B343- 14 RELATED PARTIES 14.1 Balances and transactions with related parties 2023 R million Notes Subsidiaries Net interest income 3 23 Non-interest revenue 2 123 Dividends received 2 33 758 Amounts owing to subsidiaries 9 26 Cash and cash equivalents 7 829 Other assets 8 13 2022 Subsidiaries Net interest income 3 15 Non-interest revenue 2 46 Dividends received 2 24 428 Amounts owing to subsidiaries 9 8 Cash and cash equivalents 7 217 Other assets 8 45 Refer to the remuneration disclosures on page B253 for details of the compensation paid to KMP. During the prior year a financial guarantee was provided to FirstRand Short Term Insurance, as a subsidiary within the FirstRand group, by the company to provide immediate financial support in the event that FirstRand Short Term Insurance solvency capital requirements were to fall below its prudential thresholds. Refer to Note 10. -- 343 of 354 -- FIRSTRAND COMPANY ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 -B344- 15 EVENTS AFTER REPORTING PERIOD Refer to note 40 of the consolidated annual financial statements of the group for further details. 16 RISK MANAGEMENT FirstRand Limited Company is not exposed to significant risks. For details on how financial risk is managed in the group refer to the summary risk and capital management report. For quantitative information about financial risk refer to note 37 of the consolidated financial statements of the group. -- 344 of 354 -- 2023 FIRSTRAND GROUP C Cshareholders’and supplementary information -- 345 of 354 -- shareholders’and supplementary information CShareholders’ and supplementary information Analysis of ordinary shareholders C347 Performance on the JSE C348 Company information C349 Credit ratings C349 Definitions C350 Abbreviations C351 Abbreviations of financial reporting standards C353 -- 346 of 354 -- C347 FIRSTRAND GROUP Shareholders’ and supplementary information continued Analysis of ordinary shareholders as at 30 June 2023 Number of Shares held shareholders (thousands) % Major shareholders Public Investment Corporation 905 840 16.1 Royal Bafokeng Holdings 166 826 3.0 Remgro Limited (Remgro) 99 467 1.8 BEE partners* 274 346 4.9 Subtotal 1 446 479 25.8 Other 4 163 009 74.2 Total 5 609 488 100.0 Shareholder type Corporates (Royal Bafokeng Holdings and Remgro) 266 292 4.7 Pension funds 1 318 731 23.5 Insurance companies and banks 271 803 4.9 Unit trusts 1 852 464 33.0 Individuals 239 146 4.3 BEE partners* 274 346 4.9 Other 1 386 706 24.7 Total 5 609 488 100.0 Public and non-public shareholders Public 95 764 5 058 952 90.2 Non-public - Corporates** (Royal Bafokeng Holdings and Remgro) 5 266 292 4.7 - Directors and prescribed officers# 15 9 898 0.2 - BEE partners* 7 274 346 4.9 Total 95 791 5 609 488 100.0 Geographic ownership South Africa 2 928 270 52.2 International 1 928 628 34.4 Unknown/unanalysed 752 590 13.4 Total 5 609 488 100.0 * Include FirstRand Empowerment Trust, FirstRand Staff Assistance Trust, MIC Investment Holdings, Mineworkers Investment Trust, Kagiso Charitable Trust, WDB Trust No 2 and WDB Investment Holdings. ** The group has two corporate shareholders (Royal Bafokeng Holdings and Remgro), which hold their FirstRand shares in multiple accounts (four in total). # Reflect direct beneficial ownership. -- 347 of 354 -- 2023 FIRSTRAND GROUP C348 Performance on the JSE 2023 2022 Number of shares in issue (thousands) 5 609 488 5 609 488 Market price (cents per share) Closing 6 850 6 237 High 7 100 7 934 Low 5 680 5 180 Weighted average 6 406 6 283 Closing price/net asset value per share 2.13 2.12 Closing price/earnings (headline) 10.45 10.66 Volume of shares traded (millions) 3 356 3 219 Value of shares traded (millions) 214 729 203 812 Market capitalisation (R billion) 384.25 349.86 -- 348 of 354 -- C349 FIRSTRAND GROUP Shareholders’ and supplementary information continued Company information Credit ratings Refer to www.firstrand.co.za/investors/debt-investor-centre/credit-ratings for detail on the group’s credit ratings. Directors WR Jardine (chairman), AP Pullinger (chief executive officer), HS Kellan (financial director), M Vilakazi (chief operating officer), JP Burger, GG Gelink, TC Isaacs, RM Loubser, PD Naidoo, Z Roscherr, SP Sibisi, LL von Zeuner, T Winterboer Company secretary and registered office C Low 4 Merchant Place, Corner Fredman Drive and Rivonia Road Sandton 2196 PO Box 650149, Benmore 2010 Tel: +27 11 282 1808 Fax: +27 11 282 8088 Website: www.firstrand.co.za JSE sponsor Rand Merchant Bank (a division of FirstRand Bank Limited) 1 Merchant Place, Corner Fredman Drive and Rivonia Road Sandton, 2196 Tel: +27 11 282 8000 Namibian sponsor Simonis Storm Securities (Pty) Ltd 4 Koch Street Klein Windhoek Namibia Transfer secretaries – South Africa Computershare Investor Services (Pty) Ltd 1st Floor, Rosebank Towers 15 Biermann Avenue Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2196 Private Bag X9000, Saxonwold, 2132 Tel: +27 11 370 5000 Fax: +27 11 688 5248 Transfer secretaries – Namibia Transfer Secretaries (Pty) Ltd 4 Robert Mugabe Avenue, Windhoek PO Box 2401, Windhoek, Namibia Tel: +264 612 27647 Fax: +264 612 48531 Auditors PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. 4 Lisbon Lane Waterfall City Jukskei View 2090 Deloitte & Touche Deloitte Place 5 Magwa Crescent Waterfall City Johannesburg Gauteng South Africa 2090 -- 349 of 354 -- 2023 FIRSTRAND GROUP C350 Definitions Additional Tier 1 capital (AT1) AT1 capital instruments and qualifying capital instruments issued out of fully consolidated subsidiaries to third parties less specified regulatory deductions Arrears A percentage that expresses the current exposure of the loans with one or more months in arrears to the total current book exposure for the reporting period Capital adequacy ratio (CAR) Total qualifying capital and reserves divided by RWA Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital Share capital and premium, qualifying reserves and third-party capital, less specified regulatory deductions Contingent convertible securities Fixed-rate perpetual subordinated contingent convertible securities issued by Aldermore. These instruments qualify as AT1 capital Core lending advances Total advances excluding assets under agreements to resell Cost-to-income ratio Operating expenses excluding indirect taxes expressed as a percentage of total income including share of profits from associates and joint ventures Credit loss ratio Total impairment charge per the income statement expressed as a percentage of average core lending advances (average between the opening and closing balance for the year) Diversity ratio Non-interest revenue expressed as a percentage of total income including share of profits from associates and joint ventures Dividend cover Normalised earnings per share divided by dividend per share Effective tax rate Tax per the income statement divided by the profit before tax per the income statement Impairment charge Amortised cost impairment charge and credit fair value adjustments Loan-to-deposit ratio Average advances expressed as a percentage of average deposits Loss given default (LGD) Economic loss that will be suffered on an exposure following default of the counterparty, expressed as a percentage of the amount outstanding at the time of default Net income after capital charge (NIACC) Normalised earnings less the cost of equity multiplied by the average ordinary shareholders’ equity and reserves Normalised earnings The group believes normalised earnings more accurately reflect its economic performance. Headline earnings are adjusted to take into account non-operational and accounting anomalies. Normalised earnings per share Normalised earnings attributable to ordinary equityholders divided by the weighted average number of shares including treasury shares Normalised net asset value Normalised equity attributable to ordinary equityholders Normalised net asset value per share Normalised equity attributable to ordinary equityholders divided by the number of issued ordinary shares Price earnings ratio (times) Closing price at end of period divided by basic normalised earnings per share Price-to-book (times) Closing share price at end of period divided by normalised net asset value per share Return on assets (ROA) Normalised earnings divided by average assets Return on equity (ROE) Normalised earnings divided by average normalised ordinary shareholders’ equity Risk weighted assets (RWA) Prescribed risk weightings relative to the credit risk of counterparties, operational risk, market risk, equity investment risk and other risk multiplied by on- and off-balance sheet assets, where applicable Shares in issue Number of ordinary shares listed on the JSE Technical cures Performing accounts that are classified as stage 3/NPL because they have defaulted in the past and do not meet the stringent cure definition of performance for several consecutive months Tier 1 ratio Tier 1 capital divided by RWA Tier 1 capital CET1 capital plus AT1 capital Tier 2 capital Qualifying subordinated debt instruments, capital instruments issued out of fully consolidated subsidiaries to third parties and qualifying provisions less specified regulatory deductions Total qualifying capital and reserves Tier 1 capital plus Tier 2 capital Weighted average number of ordinary shares Weighted average number of ordinary shares in issue during the year as listed on the JSE -- 350 of 354 -- C351 FIRSTRAND GROUP Shareholders’ and supplementary information continued Abbreviations ALCCO Asset, liability and capital committee ALM Asset and liability management ARR Alternative reference rate ASSA Actuarial Society of South Africa AT1 Additional Tier 1 capital BEE Black economic empowerment BoE Bank of England BSE Botswana Stock Exchange CAGR Compound annual growth rate CENTRE FirstRand Corporate Centre CET1 Common Equity Tier 1 capital CGU Cash generating unit CIP Conditional incentive plan CMA Common Monetary Area CODM Chief operating decision maker COP26 United Nations Climate Change Conference deal Covid-19 Coronavirus disease CPI Consumer price index CPT Corporate performance target CSM Contractual service margin DIP Deferred incentive plan DM Developed market EDC External debt collection ECL Expected credit loss EAD Exposure at default EPS Earnings per share ERM Enterprise Risk Management ESG Environmental, Social and Governance ETL Expected tail loss EVE Economic value of equity FLI Forward-looking information FNB First National Bank FR FirstRand FRB FirstRand Bank Limited FREMA FirstRand EMA Holdings (Pty) Ltd FRI FirstRand International Limited FRIHL FirstRand Investment Holdings (Pty) Ltd FSR FirstRand Limited FSV Financial soundness valuation FVOCI Fair value through other comprehensive income FVTPL Fair value through profit or loss GBP British pound GCA Gross carrying amount GDP Gross domestic product HEPS Headline earnings per share HQLA High-quality liquid assets IASB International Accounting Standards Board IBNR Incurred but not reported IBOR Interbank offered rate ICE ICE Benchmark Administration Limited IRBA Independent Regulatory Board for Auditors IRRBB Interest rate risk in the banking book ISA International Standards on Auditing ISDA International Swaps and Derivatives Association JIBAR Johannesburg Interbank Average Rate JSE Johannesburg Stock Exchange KMP Key management personnel LECL Lifetime expected credit losses LGD Loss given default LIBOR London Interbank Offered Rate LIC Liability for incurred claims LRC Liability for remaining coverage LSE London Stock Exchange MAFR Mandatory audit firm rotation MNA Master netting arrangement MoPR Monetary policy rate MPC Monetary Policy Committee MRA Modified retrospective approach NAV Net asset value NCD Negotiable certificate of deposit NCNR Non-cumulative non-redeemable NIACC Net income after capital charge -- 351 of 354 -- 2023 FIRSTRAND GROUP C352 VAF Vehicle asset finance VAPS Value-added products and services VaR Value-at-risk ZARONIA South African Rand Overnight Index Average NII Net interest income NIR Non-interest revenue NOSIA Notice of sums in arrears NPL Non-performing loan NSX Namibian Stock Exchange OCI Other comprehensive income OCR Outstanding claims reserve ORSA Own risk and solvency assessment PA Prudential Authority PAA Premium allocation approach PD Probability of default P/E Price/earnings PwC PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. RCCC Risk, capital management and compliance committee RMB RMB corporate and investment banking division RMBIA RMB Investments and Advisory ROE Return on equity ROUA Right of use asset RWA Risk weighted assets S&P Standard & Poors Global Ratings SACU Southern African Customs Union SAICA South African Institute of Chartered Accountants SAPs Standards of Actuarial Practice SARB South African Reserve Bank SBP Share-based payment SICR Significant increase in credit risk SME Small and medium-sized enterprise SONIA Sterling Overnight Index Average SPPI Solely payments of principal and interest SPV Special purpose vehicles sVaR Stressed VaR TRS Total return swaps TTC Through-the-cycle UK United Kingdom UPS Unearned premiums reserve Abbreviations continued -- 352 of 354 -- C353 FIRSTRAND GROUP Shareholders’ and supplementary information continued Abbreviations of financial reporting standards International Financial Reporting Standards IFRS 1 IFRS 1 – First-time Adoption of International Financial Reporting Standards IFRS 2 IFRS 2 – Share-based Payment IFRS 3 IFRS 3 – Business Combinations IFRS 4 IFRS 4 – Insurance Contracts IFRS 5 IFRS 5 – Non-current Assets Held for Sale and Discontinued Operations IFRS 7 IFRS 7 – Financial Instruments – Disclosures IFRS 8 IFRS 8 – Operating Segments IFRS 9 IFRS 9 – Financial Instruments IFRS 12 IFRS 12 – Disclosure of Interests in Other Entities IFRS 13 IFRS 13 – Fair Value Measurement IFRS 15 IFRS 15 – Revenue IFRS 16 IFRS 16 – Leases IFRS 17 IFRS 17 – Insurance Contracts International Accounting Standards IAS 1 IAS 1 – Presentation of Financial Statements IAS 2 IAS 2 – Inventories IAS 7 IAS 7 – Statement of Cash Flows IAS 8 IAS 8 – Accounting Policies, Changes in Accounting Estimates and Errors IAS 10 IAS 10 – Events After the Reporting Period IAS 12 IAS 12 – Income Taxes IAS 16 IAS 16 – Property, Plant and Equipment IAS 17 IAS 17 – Leases IAS 19 IAS 19 – Employee Benefits IAS 21 IAS 21 – The Effects of Changes in Foreign Exchange Rates IAS 23 IAS 23 – Borrowing Costs IAS 24 IAS 24 – Related Party Disclosures IAS 27 IAS 27 – Consolidated and Separate Financial Statements IAS 28 IAS 28 – Investments in Associates and Joint Ventures IAS 29 IAS 29 – Financial Reporting in Hyperinflationary Economies IAS 32 IAS 32 – Financial Instruments – Presentation IAS 33 IAS 33 – Earnings Per Share IAS 34 IAS 34 – Interim Financial Reporting IAS 36 IAS 36 – Impairment of Assets IAS 37 IAS 37 – Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets IAS 38 IAS 38 – Intangible Assets IAS 39 IAS 39 – Financial Instruments – Recognition and Measurement IAS 40 IAS 40 – Investment Property IFRS Interpretations Committee Interpretations IFRIC 17 IFRIC 17 – Distributions of Non-cash Assets to Owners IFRIC 22 IFRIC 22 – Foreign Currency Transactions and Advance Consideration IFRIC 23 IFRIC 23 – Uncertainty over Income Tax Treatments -- 353 of 354 -- www.firstrand.co.za -- 354 of 354 --