QUARTERLY REPORT

Q3 2023 — Form 10-Q

Q3 2023PDF · 205 pages1.5 MB
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
Form 10-Q
☒ QUARTERLY REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
For the quarterly period ended September 30, 2023
or
☐ TRANSITION REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
For the transition period from to
Commission File Number: 001-14965
The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.
(Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter)
Delaware 13-4019460
(State or other jurisdiction of
incorporation or organization)
(I.R.S. Employer
Identification No.)
200 West Street, New York, NY 10282
(Address of principal executive offices) (Zip Code)
(212) 902-1000
(Registrant’s telephone number, including area code)
Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act:
Title of each class
Trading
Symbol
Exchange
on which
registered
Common stock, par value $.01 per share GS NYSE
Depositary Shares, Each Representing 1/1,000th Interest in a Share of Floating Rate Non-Cumulative Preferred Stock, Series A GS PrA NYSE
Depositary Shares, Each Representing 1/1,000th Interest in a Share of Floating Rate Non-Cumulative Preferred Stock, Series C GS PrC NYSE
Depositary Shares, Each Representing 1/1,000th Interest in a Share of Floating Rate Non-Cumulative Preferred Stock, Series D GS PrD NYSE
Depositary Shares, Each Representing 1/1,000th Interest in a Share of 6.375% Fixed-to-Floating Rate Non-Cumulative Preferred Stock, Series K GS PrK NYSE
5.793% Fixed-to-Floating Rate Normal Automatic Preferred Enhanced Capital Securities of Goldman Sachs Capital II GS/43PE NYSE
Floating Rate Normal Automatic Preferred Enhanced Capital Securities of Goldman Sachs Capital III GS/43PF NYSE
Medium-Term Notes, Series F, Callable Fixed and Floating Rate Notes due March 2031 of GS Finance Corp. GS/31B NYSE
Medium-Term Notes, Series F, Callable Fixed and Floating Rate Notes due May 2031 of GS Finance Corp. GS/31X NYSE
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant (1) has filed all reports required to be filed by Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 during the
preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to file such reports), and (2) has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90
days. ☒ Yes ☐ No
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has submitted electronically every Interactive Data File required to be submitted pursuant to Rule 405 of Regulation S-T
(§232.405 of this chapter) during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to submit such files). ☒ Yes ☐ No
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a large accelerated filer, an accelerated filer, a non-accelerated filer, a smaller reporting company, or an emerging growth
company. See the definitions of “large accelerated filer,” “accelerated filer,” “smaller reporting company,” and “emerging growth company” in Rule 12b-2 of the
Exchange Act.
Large accelerated filer ☒ Accelerated filer ☐ Non-accelerated filer ☐ Smaller reporting company ☐ Emerging growth company ☐
If an emerging growth company, indicate by check mark if the registrant has elected not to use the extended transition period for complying with any new or revised
financial accounting standards provided pursuant to Section 13(a) of the Exchange Act. ☐
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a shell company (as defined in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act). ☐ Yes ☒ No
As of October 20, 2023, there were 326,112,464 shares of the registrant’s common stock outstanding.

-- 1 of 205 --

THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
QUARTERLY REPORT ON FORM 10-Q FOR THE QUARTER ENDED SEPTEMBER 30, 2023
INDEX
Form 10-Q Item Number Page No.
PART I
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 1
Item 1
Financial Statements (Unaudited) 1
Consolidated Statements of Earnings 1
Consolidated Statements of Comprehensive Income 1
Consolidated Balance Sheets 2
Consolidated Statements of Changes in Shareholders’ Equity 3
Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows 4
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements 5
Note 1. Description of Business 5
Note 2. Basis of Presentation 6
Note 3. Significant Accounting Policies 6
Note 4. Fair Value Measurements 12
Note 5. Fair Value Hierarchy 17
Note 6. Trading Assets and Liabilities 33
Note 7. Derivatives and Hedging Activities 34
Note 8. Investments 40
Note 9. Loans 43
Note 10. Fair Value Option 51
Note 11. Collateralized Agreements and Financings 53
Note 12. Other Assets 57
Note 13. Deposits 61
Note 14. Unsecured Borrowings 62
Note 15. Other Liabilities 65
Note 16. Securitization Activities 66
Note 17. Variable Interest Entities 68
Note 18. Commitments, Contingencies and Guarantees 71
Note 19. Shareholders’ Equity 75
Note 20. Regulation and Capital Adequacy 78
Note 21. Earnings Per Common Share 86
Note 22. Transactions with Affiliated Funds 86
Note 23. Interest Income and Interest Expense 87
Note 24. Income Taxes 87
Note 25. Business Segments 88
Note 26. Credit Concentrations 90
Note 27. Legal Proceedings 91
Page No.
Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm 105
Statistical Disclosures 106
Item 2
Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition
and Results of Operations 108
Introduction 108
Executive Overview 108
Business Environment 109
Critical Accounting Policies 110
Use of Estimates 112
Recent Accounting Developments 113
Results of Operations 113
Balance Sheet and Funding Sources 131
Capital Management and Regulatory Capital 135
Regulatory and Other Matters 139
Off-Balance Sheet Arrangements 140
Risk Management 140
Overview and Structure of Risk Management 140
Liquidity Risk Management 144
Market Risk Management 151
Credit Risk Management 156
Operational Risk Management 165
Model Risk Management 166
Other Risk Management 167
Available Information 169
Forward-Looking Statements 169
Item 3
Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk 173
Item 4
Controls and Procedures 173
PART II
OTHER INFORMATION 173
Item 1
Legal Proceedings 173
Item 2
Unregistered Sales of Equity Securities, Use of Proceeds, and
Issuer Purchases of Equity Securities 174
Item 5
Other Information 174
Item 6
Exhibits 175
SIGNATURES 175
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 2 of 205 --

THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Consolidated Statements of Earnings
(Unaudited)
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
in millions, except per share amounts 2023 2022 2023 2022
Revenues
Investment banking $ 1,555 $ 1,544 $ 4,565 $ 5,487
Investment management 2,409 2,283 7,054 6,747
Commissions and fees 883 992 2,864 3,066
Market making 4,958 4,641 14,742 15,583
Other principal transactions 465 472 699 285
Total non-interest revenues 10,270 9,932 29,924 31,168
Interest income 18,257 8,550 50,031 16,613
Interest expense 16,710 6,507 45,019 11,009
Net interest income 1,547 2,043 5,012 5,604
Total net revenues 11,817 11,975 34,936 36,772
Provision for credit losses 7 515 451 1,743
Operating expenses
Compensation and benefits 4,188 3,606 11,897 11,384
Transaction based 1,452 1,317 4,242 3,878
Market development 136 199 454 596
Communications and technology 468 459 1,416 1,327
Depreciation and amortization 1,512 666 4,076 1,728
Occupancy 267 255 785 765
Professional fees 377 465 1,152 1,392
Other expenses 654 737 1,978 2,003
Total operating expenses 9,054 7,704 26,000 23,073
Pre-tax earnings 2,756 3,756 8,485 11,956
Provision for taxes 698 687 1,977 2,021
Net earnings 2,058 3,069 6,508 9,935
Preferred stock dividends 176 107 468 356
Net earnings applicable to common shareholders $ 1,882 $ 2,962 $ 6,040 $ 9,579
Earnings per common share
Basic $ 5.52 $ 8.35 $ 17.52 $ 27.03
Diluted $ 5.47 $ 8.25 $ 17.39 $ 26.71
Average common shares
Basic 338.7 352.8 342.5 353.0
Diluted 343.9 359.2 347.4 358.6
Consolidated Statements of Comprehensive Income
(Unaudited)
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Net earnings $ 2,058 $ 3,069 $ 6,508 $ 9,935
Other comprehensive income/(loss) adjustments, net of tax:
Currency translation (16) 26 (59) (5)
Debt valuation adjustment 328 673 (283) 2,601
Pension and postretirement liabilities 9 (2) 33 10
Available-for-sale securities 317 (615) 720 (2,410)
Other comprehensive income 638 82 411 196
Comprehensive income $ 2,696 $ 3,151 $ 6,919 $ 10,131
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
PART I. FINANCIAL INFORMATION
Item 1. Financial Statements (Unaudited)
1 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 3 of 205 --

As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents $ 239,879 $ 241,825
Collateralized agreements:
Securities purchased under agreements to resell (includes $190,446 and $225,117 at fair value) 190,695 225,117
Securities borrowed (includes $36,792 and $38,578 at fair value) 196,925 189,041
Customer and other receivables (includes $23 and $25 at fair value) 140,866 135,448
Trading assets (at fair value and includes $97,406 and $40,143 pledged as collateral) 448,060 301,245
Investments (includes $76,307 and $78,201 at fair value, and $8,463 and $9,818 pledged as collateral) 145,530 130,629
Loans (net of allowance of $4,895 and $5,543, and includes $6,448 and $7,655 at fair value) 178,257 179,286
Other assets (includes $324 and $145 at fair value) 36,941 39,208
Total assets $ 1,577,153 $ 1,441,799
Liabilities and shareholders’ equity
Deposits (includes $28,557 and $15,746 at fair value) $ 402,962 $ 386,665
Collateralized financings:
Securities sold under agreements to repurchase (at fair value) 225,679 110,349
Securities loaned (includes $8,178 and $4,372 at fair value) 54,926 30,727
Other secured financings (includes $14,114 and $12,756 at fair value) 14,728 13,946
Customer and other payables 252,342 262,045
Trading liabilities (at fair value) 195,123 191,324
Unsecured short-term borrowings (includes $42,351 and $39,731 at fair value) 70,009 60,961
Unsecured long-term borrowings (includes $73,916 and $73,147 at fair value) 224,024 247,138
Other liabilities (includes $614 and $159 at fair value) 20,083 21,455
Total liabilities 1,459,876 1,324,610
Commitments, contingencies and guarantees
Shareholders’ equity
Preferred stock; aggregate liquidation preference of $11,203 and $10,703 11,203 10,703
Common stock; 922,889,392 and 917,815,030 shares issued, and 326,604,718 and 334,918,639 shares outstanding 9 9
Share-based awards 5,117 5,696
Nonvoting common stock; no shares issued and outstanding – –
Additional paid-in capital 60,233 59,050
Retained earnings 142,743 139,372
Accumulated other comprehensive loss (2,599) (3,010)
Stock held in treasury, at cost; 596,284,676 and 582,896,393 shares (99,429) (94,631)
Total shareholders’ equity 117,277 117,189
Total liabilities and shareholders’ equity $ 1,577,153 $ 1,441,799
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Consolidated Balance Sheets
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 2

-- 4 of 205 --

Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Preferred stock
Beginning balance $ 10,703 $ 10,703 $ 10,703 $ 10,703
Issued 1,500 – 1,500 –
Redeemed (1,000) – (1,000) –
Ending balance 11,203 10,703 11,203 10,703
Common stock
Beginning balance 9 9 9 9
Issued – – – –
Ending balance 9 9 9 9
Share-based awards
Beginning balance 4,931 5,245 5,696 4,211
Issuance and amortization of share-based awards 242 311 2,001 3,811
Delivery of common stock underlying share-based awards (15) (44) (2,501) (2,463)
Forfeiture of share-based awards (41) (33) (79) (80)
Ending balance 5,117 5,479 5,117 5,479
Additional paid-in capital
Beginning balance 60,206 58,993 59,050 56,396
Delivery of common stock underlying share-based awards 30 61 2,527 2,494
Cancellation of share-based awards in satisfaction of withholding tax requirements (5) (23) (1,344) (1,587)
Preferred stock issuance costs 5 – 5 –
Issuance of common stock in connection with acquisition – – – 1,730
Other (3) – (5) (2)
Ending balance 60,233 59,031 60,233 59,031
Retained earnings
Beginning balance 141,798 136,998 139,372 131,811
Net earnings 2,058 3,069 6,508 9,935
Dividends and dividend equivalents declared on common stock and share-based awards (937) (893) (2,669) (2,323)
Dividends declared on preferred stock (166) (107) (458) (356)
Preferred stock redemption premium (10) – (10) –
Ending balance 142,743 139,067 142,743 139,067
Accumulated other comprehensive income/(loss)
Beginning balance (3,237) (1,954) (3,010) (2,068)
Other comprehensive income 638 82 411 196
Ending balance (2,599) (1,872) (2,599) (1,872)
Stock held in treasury, at cost
Beginning balance (97,917) (92,123) (94,631) (91,136)
Repurchased (1,500) (1,000) (4,796) (2,000)
Reissued – 1 28 20
Other (12) (5) (30) (11)
Ending balance (99,429) (93,127) (99,429) (93,127)
Total shareholders’ equity $ 117,277 $ 119,290 $ 117,277 $ 119,290
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Consolidated Statements of Changes in Shareholders’ Equity
(Unaudited)
3 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 5 of 205 --

Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022
Cash flows from operating activities
Net earnings $ 6,508 $ 9,935
Adjustments to reconcile net earnings to net cash provided by operating activities
Depreciation and amortization 4,076 1,728
Share-based compensation 2,008 3,811
Provision for credit losses 451 1,743
Changes in operating assets and liabilities:
Customer and other receivables and payables, net (14,042) 21,453
Collateralized transactions (excluding other secured financings), net 166,067 (3,872)
Trading assets (146,672) (39,764)
Trading liabilities 1,654 48,411
Loans held for sale, net 48 2,041
Other, net (4,327) (3,616)
Net cash provided by operating activities 15,771 41,870
Cash flows from investing activities
Purchase of property, leasehold improvements and equipment (1,770) (2,994)
Proceeds from sales of property, leasehold improvements and equipment 1,151 1,272
Net cash used for business acquisitions (8) (2,113)
Purchase of investments (27,776) (52,989)
Proceeds from sales and paydowns of investments 13,834 8,080
Loans (excluding loans held for sale), net 599 (20,924)
Net cash used for investing activities (13,970) (69,668)
Cash flows from financing activities
Unsecured short-term borrowings, net 246 2,451
Other secured financings (short-term), net 1,459 (1,415)
Proceeds from issuance of other secured financings (long-term) 2,137 1,499
Repayment of other secured financings (long-term), including the current portion (2,221) (2,677)
Proceeds from issuance of unsecured long-term borrowings 28,854 69,620
Repayment of unsecured long-term borrowings, including the current portion (40,286) (35,328)
Derivative contracts with a financing element, net 2,145 1,749
Deposits, net 15,870 39,174
Preferred stock redemption (1,000) –
Common stock repurchased (4,796) (2,000)
Settlement of share-based awards in satisfaction of withholding tax requirements (1,344) (1,591)
Dividends and dividend equivalents paid on common stock, preferred stock and share-based awards (3,124) (2,669)
Proceeds from issuance of preferred stock, net of issuance costs 1,496 –
Other financing, net 348 365
Net cash provided by/(used for) financing activities (216) 69,178
Effect of exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents (3,531) (18,165)
Net increase/(decrease) in cash and cash equivalents (1,946) 23,215
Cash and cash equivalents, beginning balance 241,825 261,036
Cash and cash equivalents, ending balance $ 239,879 $ 284,251
Supplemental disclosures:
Cash payments for interest, net of capitalized interest $ 43,186 $ 9,882
Cash payments for income taxes, net $ 1,815 $ 3,046
See Notes 9, 12 and 16 for information about non-cash activities.
The accompanying notes are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 4

-- 6 of 205 --

Note 1.
Description of Business
The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. (Group Inc. or parent
company), a Delaware corporation, together with its
consolidated subsidiaries (collectively, the firm), is a leading
global financial institution that delivers a broad range of
financial services to a large and diversified client base that
includes corporations, financial institutions, governments
and individuals. Founded in 1869, the firm is headquartered
in New York and maintains offices in all major financial
centers around the world.
The firm manages and reports its activities in the following
three business segments:
Global Banking & Markets
The firm provides a broad range of services to a diverse
group of corporations, financial institutions, investment
funds and governments. Services include strategic advisory
assignments with respect to mergers and acquisitions,
divestitures, corporate defense activities, restructurings and
spin-offs, and equity and debt underwriting of public
offerings and private placements. The firm facilitates client
transactions and makes markets in fixed income, equity,
currency and commodity products. In addition, the firm
makes markets in and clears institutional client transactions
on major stock, options and futures exchanges worldwide
and provides prime financing (including securities lending,
margin lending and swaps), portfolio financing and other
types of equity financing (including securities-based loans to
individuals). The firm also provides lending to corporate
clients, including through relationship lending and
acquisition financing, and secured lending, through
structured credit and asset-backed lending. In addition, the
firm provides commodity financing to clients through
structured transactions and also provides financing through
securities purchased under agreements to resell (resale
agreements). The firm also makes equity and debt
investments related to Global Banking & Markets activities.
Asset & Wealth Management
The firm manages assets and offers investment products
across all major asset classes to a diverse set of clients, both
institutional and individuals, including through a network of
third-party distributors around the world. The firm also
provides investing and wealth advisory solutions, including
financial planning and counseling, and executing brokerage
transactions for wealth management clients. During the third
quarter of 2023, the firm announced an agreement to sell its
Personal Financial Management (PFM) business, which is
expected to close in the fourth quarter of 2023. The firm
issues loans to wealth management clients, accepts deposits
through its consumer banking digital platform, Marcus by
Goldman Sachs (Marcus), and through its private bank, and
provides investing services through Marcus Invest to U.S.
customers. The firm has also issued unsecured loans to
consumers through Marcus. During the first half of 2023, the
firm completed the sale of substantially all of this portfolio.
The firm makes equity investments, which include investing
activities related to public and private equity investments in
corporate, real estate and infrastructure assets, as well as
investments through consolidated investment entities,
substantially all of which are engaged in real estate
investment activities. The firm also invests in debt
instruments and engages in lending activities to middle-
market clients, and provides financing for real estate and
other assets.
Platform Solutions
The firm issues credit cards through partnership
arrangements and provides point-of-sale financing through
GreenSky, Inc. (GreenSky) to consumers. In October 2023,
the firm announced an agreement to sell GreenSky, which is
expected to close in the first quarter of 2024. The firm also
accepts deposits from Apple Card customers. In addition, the
firm provides transaction banking and other services,
including cash management services, such as deposit-taking
and payment solutions for corporate and institutional clients.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
5 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 7 of 205 --

Note 2.
Basis of Presentation
These consolidated financial statements are prepared in
accordance with accounting principles generally accepted in
the United States (U.S. GAAP) and include the accounts of
Group Inc. and all other entities in which the firm has a
controlling financial interest. Intercompany transactions and
balances have been eliminated.
These consolidated financial statements are unaudited and
should be read in conjunction with the audited consolidated
financial statements included in the firm’s Annual Report on
Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2022. References
to “the 2022 Form 10-K” are to the firm’s Annual Report on
Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2022. Certain
disclosures included in the annual financial statements have
been condensed or omitted from these financial statements as
they are not required for interim financial statements under
U.S. GAAP and the rules of the SEC.
These unaudited consolidated financial statements reflect all
adjustments that are, in the opinion of management,
necessary for a fair statement of the results for the interim
periods presented. These adjustments are of a normal,
recurring nature. Interim period operating results may not be
indicative of the operating results for a full year.
All references to September 2023, June 2023 and September
2022 refer to the firm’s periods ended, or the dates, as the
context requires, September 30, 2023, June 30, 2023 and
September 30, 2022, respectively. All references to December
2022 refer to the date December 31, 2022. Any reference to a
future year refers to a year ending on December 31 of that
year. Certain reclassifications have been made to previously
reported amounts to conform to the current presentation.
Note 3.
Significant Accounting Policies
The firm’s significant accounting policies include when and
how to measure the fair value of assets and liabilities,
measuring the allowance for credit losses on loans and
lending commitments accounted for at amortized cost, and
when to consolidate an entity. See Note 4 for policies on fair
value measurements, Note 9 for policies on the allowance for
credit losses, and below and Note 17 for policies on
consolidation accounting. All other significant accounting
policies are either described below or included in the
following footnotes:
Fair Value Measurements Note 4
Fair Value Hierarchy Note 5
Trading Assets and Liabilities Note 6
Derivatives and Hedging Activities Note 7
Investments Note 8
Loans Note 9
Fair Value Option Note 10
Collateralized Agreements and Financings Note 11
Other Assets Note 12
Deposits Note 13
Unsecured Borrowings Note 14
Other Liabilities Note 15
Securitization Activities Note 16
Variable Interest Entities Note 17
Commitments, Contingencies and Guarantees Note 18
Shareholders’ Equity Note 19
Regulation and Capital Adequacy Note 20
Earnings Per Common Share Note 21
Transactions with Affiliated Funds Note 22
Interest Income and Interest Expense Note 23
Income Taxes Note 24
Business Segments Note 25
Credit Concentrations Note 26
Legal Proceedings Note 27
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 6

-- 8 of 205 --

Consolidation
The firm consolidates entities in which the firm has a
controlling financial interest. The firm determines whether it
has a controlling financial interest in an entity by first
evaluating whether the entity is a voting interest entity or a
variable interest entity (VIE).
Voting Interest Entities. Voting interest entities are entities
in which (i) the total equity investment at risk is sufficient to
enable the entity to finance its activities independently and
(ii) the equity holders have the power to direct the activities
of the entity that most significantly impact its economic
performance, the obligation to absorb the losses of the entity
and the right to receive the residual returns of the entity. The
usual condition for a controlling financial interest in a voting
interest entity is ownership of a majority voting interest. If
the firm has a controlling majority voting interest in a voting
interest entity, the entity is consolidated.
Variable Interest Entities. A VIE is an entity that lacks one
or more of the characteristics of a voting interest entity. The
firm has a controlling financial interest in a VIE when the
firm has a variable interest or interests that provide it with (i)
the power to direct the activities of the VIE that most
significantly impact the VIE’s economic performance and (ii)
the obligation to absorb losses of the VIE or the right to
receive benefits from the VIE that could potentially be
significant to the VIE. See Note 17 for further information
about VIEs.
Equity-Method Investments. When the firm does not have
a controlling financial interest in an entity but can exert
significant influence over the entity’s operating and financial
policies, the investment is generally accounted for at fair
value by electing the fair value option available under U.S.
GAAP. Significant influence generally exists when the firm
owns 20% to 50% of the entity’s common stock or in-
substance common stock.
In certain cases, the firm applies the equity method of
accounting to new investments that are strategic in nature or
closely related to the firm’s principal business activities,
when the firm has a significant degree of involvement in the
cash flows or operations of the investee or when cost-benefit
considerations are less significant. See Note 8 for further
information about equity-method investments.
Investment Funds. The firm has formed investment funds
with third-party investors. These funds are typically
organized as limited partnerships or limited liability
companies for which the firm acts as general partner or
manager. Generally, the firm does not hold a majority of the
economic interests in these funds. These funds are usually
voting interest entities and generally are not consolidated
because third-party investors typically have rights to
terminate the funds or to remove the firm as general partner
or manager. Investments in these funds are generally
measured at net asset value (NAV) and are included in
investments. See Notes 8, 18 and 22 for further information
about investments in funds.
Use of Estimates
Preparation of these consolidated financial statements
requires management to make certain estimates and
assumptions, the most important of which relate to fair value
measurements, the allowance for credit losses on loans and
lending commitments accounted for at amortized cost,
discretionary compensation accruals, accounting for
goodwill and identifiable intangible assets, provisions for
losses that may arise from litigation and regulatory
proceedings (including governmental investigations), and
accounting for income taxes. These estimates and
assumptions are based on the best available information, but
actual results could be materially different.
Revenue Recognition
Financial Assets and Liabilities at Fair Value. Trading
assets and liabilities and certain investments are carried at
fair value either under the fair value option or in accordance
with other U.S. GAAP. In addition, the firm has elected to
account for certain of its loans and other financial assets and
liabilities at fair value by electing the fair value option. The
fair value of a financial instrument is the amount that would
be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an
orderly transaction between market participants at the
measurement date. Financial assets are marked to bid prices
and financial liabilities are marked to offer prices. Fair value
measurements do not include transaction costs. Fair value
gains or losses are generally included in market making or
other principal transactions. See Note 4 for further
information about fair value measurements.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
7 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 9 of 205 --

Revenue from Contracts with Clients. The firm
recognizes revenue earned from contracts with clients for
services, such as investment banking, investment
management, and execution and clearing (contracts with
clients), when the performance obligations related to the
underlying transaction are completed.
Revenues from contracts with clients represent
approximately 45% of total non-interest revenues for both
the three and nine months ended September 2023 (including
approximately 85% of investment banking revenues,
approximately 95% of investment management revenues and
all commissions and fees), and approximately 45% of total
non-interest revenues for the three months ended September
2022 (including approximately 90% of investment banking
revenues, approximately 95% of investment management
revenues and all commissions and fees) and approximately
45% of total non-interest revenues for the nine months ended
September 2022 (including approximately 85% of investment
banking revenues, approximately 95% of investment
management revenues and all commissions and fees). See
Note 25 for information about net revenues by business
segment.
Investment Banking
Advisory. Fees from financial advisory assignments are
recognized in revenues when the services related to the
underlying transaction are completed under the terms of the
assignment. Non-refundable deposits and milestone
payments in connection with financial advisory assignments
are recognized in revenues upon completion of the
underlying transaction or when the assignment is otherwise
concluded.
Expenses associated with financial advisory assignments are
recognized when incurred and are included in transaction
based expenses. Client reimbursements for such expenses are
included in investment banking revenues.
Underwriting. Fees from underwriting assignments are
recognized in revenues upon completion of the underlying
transaction based on the terms of the assignment.
Expenses associated with underwriting assignments are
generally deferred until the related revenue is recognized or
the assignment is otherwise concluded. Such expenses are
included in transaction based expenses for completed
assignments.
Investment Management
The firm earns management fees and incentive fees for
investment management services, which are included in
investment management revenues. The firm makes payments
to brokers and advisors related to the placement of the firm’s
investment funds (distribution fees), which are included in
transaction based expenses.
Management Fees. Management fees for mutual funds are
calculated as a percentage of daily net asset value and are
received monthly. Management fees for hedge funds and
separately managed accounts are calculated as a percentage
of month-end net asset value and are generally received
quarterly. Management fees for private equity funds are
calculated as a percentage of monthly invested capital or
committed capital and are received quarterly, semi-annually
or annually, depending on the fund. Management fees are
recognized over time in the period the services are provided.
Distribution fees paid by the firm are calculated based on
either a percentage of the management fee, the investment
fund’s net asset value or the committed capital. Such fees are
included in transaction based expenses.
Incentive Fees. Incentive fees are calculated as a percentage
of a fund’s or separately managed account’s return, or excess
return above a specified benchmark or other performance
target. Incentive fees are generally based on investment
performance over a twelve-month period or over the life of a
fund. Fees that are based on performance over a twelve-
month period are subject to adjustment prior to the end of
the measurement period. For fees that are based on
investment performance over the life of the fund, future
investment underperformance may require fees previously
distributed to the firm to be returned to the fund.
Incentive fees earned from a fund or separately managed
account are recognized when it is probable that a significant
reversal of such fees will not occur, which is generally when
such fees are no longer subject to fluctuations in the market
value of investments held by the fund or separately managed
account. Therefore, incentive fees recognized during the
period may relate to performance obligations satisfied in
previous periods.
Commissions and Fees
The firm earns substantially all commissions and fees from
executing and clearing client transactions on stock, options
and futures markets, as well as over-the-counter (OTC)
transactions. Commissions and fees are recognized on the
day the trade is executed. The firm also provides third-party
research services to clients in connection with certain soft-
dollar arrangements. Third-party research costs incurred by
the firm in connection with such arrangements are presented
net within commissions and fees.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 8

-- 10 of 205 --

Remaining Performance Obligations
Remaining performance obligations are services that the firm
has committed to perform in the future in connection with its
contracts with clients. The firm’s remaining performance
obligations are generally related to its financial advisory
assignments and certain investment management activities.
Revenues associated with remaining performance obligations
relating to financial advisory assignments cannot be
determined until the outcome of the transaction. For the
firm’s investment management activities, where fees are
calculated based on the net asset value of the fund or
separately managed account, future revenues associated with
such remaining performance obligations cannot be
determined as such fees are subject to fluctuations in the
market value of investments held by the fund or separately
managed account.
The firm is able to determine the future revenues associated
with management fees calculated based on committed
capital. As of September 2023, substantially all future net
revenues associated with such remaining performance
obligations will be recognized through 2031. Annual
revenues associated with such performance obligations
average less than $300 million through 2031.
Transfers of Financial Assets
Transfers of financial assets are accounted for as sales when
the firm has relinquished control over the assets transferred.
For transfers of financial assets accounted for as sales, any
gains or losses are recognized in net revenues. Assets or
liabilities that arise from the firm’s continuing involvement
with transferred financial assets are initially recognized at
fair value. For transfers of financial assets that are not
accounted for as sales, the assets are generally included in
trading assets and the transfer is accounted for as a
collateralized financing, with the related interest expense
recognized over the life of the transaction. See Note 11 for
further information about transfers of financial assets
accounted for as collateralized financings and Note 16 for
further information about transfers of financial assets
accounted for as sales.
Cash and Cash Equivalents
The firm defines cash equivalents as highly liquid overnight
deposits held in the ordinary course of business. Cash and
cash equivalents included cash and due from banks of $6.50
billion as of September 2023 and $7.87 billion as of December
2022. Cash and cash equivalents also included interest-
bearing deposits with banks of $233.38 billion as of
September 2023 and $233.96 billion as of December 2022.
The firm segregates cash for regulatory and other purposes
related to client activity. Cash and cash equivalents
segregated for regulatory and other purposes were $17.95
billion as of September 2023 and $16.94 billion as of
December 2022. In addition, the firm segregates securities for
regulatory and other purposes related to client activity. See
Note 11 for further information about segregated securities.
Customer and Other Receivables
Customer and other receivables included receivables from
customers and counterparties of $90.32 billion as of
September 2023 and $67.88 billion as of December 2022, and
receivables from brokers, dealers and clearing organizations
of $50.55 billion as of September 2023 and $67.57 billion as
of December 2022. Such receivables primarily consist of
collateral posted in connection with certain derivative
transactions, customer margin loans and receivables resulting
from unsettled transactions.
Substantially all of these receivables are accounted for at
amortized cost net of any allowance for credit losses, which
generally approximates fair value. As these receivables are
not accounted for at fair value, they are not included in the
firm’s fair value hierarchy in Notes 4 and 5. Had these
receivables been included in the firm’s fair value hierarchy,
substantially all would have been classified in level 2 as of
both September 2023 and December 2022. See Note 10 for
further information about customer and other receivables
accounted for at fair value under the fair value option.
Interest on customer and other receivables is recognized over
the life of the transaction and included in interest income.
Customer and other receivables includes receivables from
contracts with clients and contract assets. Contract assets
represent the firm’s right to receive consideration for services
provided in connection with its contracts with clients for
which collection is conditional and not merely subject to the
passage of time. The firm’s receivables from contracts with
clients were $3.45 billion as of September 2023 and $3.01
billion as of December 2022. As of both September 2023 and
December 2022, contract assets were not material.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
9 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 11 of 205 --

Customer and Other Payables
Customer and other payables included payables to customers
and counterparties of $236.39 billion as of September 2023
and $238.12 billion as of December 2022, and payables to
brokers, dealers and clearing organizations of $15.95 billion
as of September 2023 and $23.93 billion as of December 2022.
Such payables primarily consist of customer credit balances
related to the firm’s prime brokerage activities. Customer
and other payables are accounted for at cost plus accrued
interest, which generally approximates fair value. As these
payables are not accounted for at fair value, they are not
included in the firm’s fair value hierarchy in Notes 4 and 5.
Had these payables been included in the firm’s fair value
hierarchy, substantially all would have been classified in level
2 as of both September 2023 and December 2022. Interest on
customer and other payables is recognized over the life of the
transaction and included in interest expense.
Offsetting Assets and Liabilities
To reduce credit exposures on derivatives and securities
financing transactions, the firm may enter into master netting
agreements or similar arrangements (collectively, netting
agreements) with counterparties that permit it to offset
receivables and payables with such counterparties. A netting
agreement is a contract with a counterparty that permits net
settlement of multiple transactions with that counterparty,
including upon the exercise of termination rights by a non-
defaulting party. Upon exercise of such termination rights,
all transactions governed by the netting agreement are
terminated and a net settlement amount is calculated. In
addition, the firm receives and posts cash and securities
collateral with respect to its derivatives and securities
financing transactions, subject to the terms of the related
credit support agreements or similar arrangements
(collectively, credit support agreements). An enforceable
credit support agreement grants the non-defaulting party
exercising termination rights the right to liquidate the
collateral and apply the proceeds to any amounts owed. In
order to assess enforceability of the firm’s right of setoff
under netting and credit support agreements, the firm
evaluates various factors, including applicable bankruptcy
laws, local statutes and regulatory provisions in the
jurisdiction of the parties to the agreement.
Derivatives are reported on a net-by-counterparty basis (i.e.,
the net payable or receivable for derivative assets and
liabilities for a given counterparty) in the consolidated
balance sheets when a legal right of setoff exists under an
enforceable netting agreement. Resale agreements and
securities sold under agreements to repurchase (repurchase
agreements) and securities borrowed and loaned transactions
with the same settlement date are presented on a net-by-
counterparty basis in the consolidated balance sheets when
such transactions meet certain settlement criteria and are
subject to netting agreements.
In the consolidated balance sheets, derivatives are reported
net of cash collateral received and posted under enforceable
credit support agreements, when transacted under an
enforceable netting agreement. In the consolidated balance
sheets, resale and repurchase agreements, and securities
borrowed and loaned, are not reported net of the related cash
and securities received or posted as collateral. See Note 11 for
further information about collateral received and pledged,
including rights to deliver or repledge collateral. See Notes 7
and 11 for further information about offsetting assets and
liabilities.
Share-Based Compensation
The cost of employee services received in exchange for a
share-based award is generally measured based on the grant-
date fair value of the award. Share-based awards that do not
require future service (i.e., vested awards, including awards
granted to retirement-eligible employees) are expensed
immediately. Share-based awards that require future service
are amortized over the relevant service period. Forfeitures are
recorded when they occur.
Cash dividend equivalents paid on restricted stock units
(RSUs) are generally charged to retained earnings. If RSUs
that require future service are forfeited, the related dividend
equivalents originally charged to retained earnings are
reclassified to compensation expense in the period in which
forfeiture occurs.
The firm generally issues new shares of common stock upon
delivery of share-based awards. In limited cases, as outlined
in the applicable award agreements, the firm may cash settle
share-based compensation awards accounted for as equity
instruments. For these awards, additional paid-in capital is
adjusted to the extent of the difference between the value of
the award at the time of cash settlement and the grant-date
value of the award. The tax effects related to the settlement
of share-based awards and payments of dividend equivalents
are recorded in income tax benefit or expense.
Foreign Currency Translation
Assets and liabilities denominated in non-U.S. currencies are
translated at rates of exchange prevailing on the date of the
consolidated balance sheets and revenues and expenses are
translated at average rates of exchange for the period.
Foreign currency remeasurement gains or losses on
transactions in nonfunctional currencies are recognized in
earnings. Gains or losses on translation of the financial
statements of a non-U.S. operation, when the functional
currency is other than the U.S. dollar, are included, net of
hedges and taxes, in the consolidated statements of
comprehensive income.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 10

-- 12 of 205 --

Recent Accounting Developments
Facilitation of the Effects of Reference Rate Reform on
Financial Reporting (ASC 848). In March 2020, the FASB
issued ASU No. 2020-04, “Reference Rate Reform —
Facilitation of the Effects of Reference Rate Reform on
Financial Reporting.” This ASU, as amended in 2022,
provides optional relief from applying generally accepted
accounting principles to contracts, hedging relationships and
other transactions affected by reference rate reform. In
addition, in January 2021 the FASB issued ASU No. 2021-01,
“Reference Rate Reform — Scope,” which clarified the scope
of ASC 848 relating to contract modifications. The firm
adopted these ASUs upon issuance and elected to apply the
relief available to certain modified derivatives. The adoption
of these ASUs did not have a material impact on the firm’s
consolidated financial statements.
Troubled Debt Restructurings and Vintage Disclosures
(ASC 326). In March 2022, the FASB issued ASU No.
2022-02, “Financial Instruments — Credit Losses (Topic 326)
— Troubled Debt Restructurings and Vintage Disclosures.”
This ASU eliminates the recognition and measurement
guidance for troubled debt restructurings (TDRs) and
requires enhanced disclosures about loan modifications for
borrowers experiencing financial difficulty. This ASU also
requires enhanced disclosure for loans that have been
charged off. The ASU became effective in January 2023
under a prospective approach. Adoption of this ASU did not
have a material impact on the firm’s consolidated financial
statements.
Accounting for Obligations to Safeguard Crypto-
Assets an Entity Holds for Platform Users (SAB 121).
In March 2022, the SEC staff issued SAB 121 (SAB 121) —
“Accounting for obligations to safeguard crypto-assets an
entity holds for platform users.” SAB 121 adds interpretive
guidance requiring an entity to recognize a liability on its
balance sheet to reflect the obligation to safeguard the
crypto-assets held for its platform users, along with a
corresponding asset. The firm adopted SAB 121 in June 2022
under a modified retrospective approach and adoption did
not have a material impact on the firm’s consolidated
financial statements.
Fair Value Measurement of Equity Securities Subject
to Contractual Sale Restrictions (ASC 820). In June
2022, the FASB issued ASU No. 2022-03, “Fair Value
Measurement of Equity Securities Subject to Contractual Sale
Restrictions.” This ASU clarifies that a contractual
restriction on the sale of an equity security should not be
considered in measuring its fair value. In addition, the ASU
requires specific disclosures related to equity securities that
are subject to contractual sale restrictions. The ASU is
effective in January 2024 under a prospective approach. Early
adoption is permitted. Adoption of this ASU is not expected
to have a material impact on the firm’s consolidated financial
statements.
Accounting for Investments in Tax Credit Structures
Using the Proportional Amortization Method (ASC
323). In March 2023, the FASB issued ASU No. 2023-02,
“Investments — Equity Method and Joint Ventures (Topic
323) — Accounting for Investments in Tax Credit Structures
Using the Proportional Amortization Method.” This ASU
expands the proportional amortization method election
currently associated with low-income housing tax credits to
other qualifying tax credits and requires incremental
disclosures for programs in which the proportional
amortization method is elected. This ASU is effective in
January 2024 under a modified retrospective approach. Early
adoption is permitted. Adoption of this ASU is not expected
to have a material impact on the firm’s consolidated financial
statements.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
11 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 13 of 205 --

Note 4.
Fair Value Measurements
The fair value of a financial instrument is the amount that
would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a
liability in an orderly transaction between market
participants at the measurement date. Financial assets are
marked to bid prices and financial liabilities are marked to
offer prices. Fair value measurements do not include
transaction costs. The firm measures certain financial assets
and liabilities as a portfolio (i.e., based on its net exposure to
market and/or credit risks).
The best evidence of fair value is a quoted price in an active
market. If quoted prices in active markets are not available,
fair value is determined by reference to prices for similar
instruments, quoted prices or recent transactions in less
active markets, or internally developed models that primarily
use market-based or independently sourced inputs, including,
but not limited to, interest rates, volatilities, equity or debt
prices, foreign exchange rates, commodity prices, credit
spreads and funding spreads (i.e., the spread or difference
between the interest rate at which a borrower could finance a
given financial instrument relative to a benchmark interest
rate).
U.S. GAAP has a three-level hierarchy for disclosure of fair
value measurements. This hierarchy prioritizes inputs to the
valuation techniques used to measure fair value, giving the
highest priority to level 1 inputs and the lowest priority to
level 3 inputs. A financial instrument’s level in this hierarchy
is based on the lowest level of input that is significant to its
fair value measurement. In evaluating the significance of a
valuation input, the firm considers, among other factors, a
portfolio’s net risk exposure to that input. The fair value
hierarchy is as follows:
Level 1. Inputs are unadjusted quoted prices in active
markets to which the firm had access at the measurement
date for identical, unrestricted assets or liabilities.
Level 2. Inputs to valuation techniques are observable, either
directly or indirectly.
Level 3. One or more inputs to valuation techniques are
significant and unobservable.
The fair values for substantially all of the firm’s financial
assets and liabilities are based on observable prices and
inputs and are classified in levels 1 and 2 of the fair value
hierarchy. Certain level 2 and level 3 financial assets and
liabilities may require valuation adjustments that a market
participant would require to arrive at fair value for factors,
such as counterparty and the firm’s credit quality, funding
risk, transfer restrictions, liquidity and bid/offer spreads.
Valuation adjustments are generally based on market
evidence.
The table below presents financial assets and liabilities
carried at fair value.
As of
September June December
$ in millions 2023 2023 2022
Total level 1 financial assets $ 318,535 $ 270,334 $ 194,698
Total level 2 financial assets 471,365 478,619 485,134
Total level 3 financial assets 24,862 25,945 26,048
Investments in funds at NAV 3,037 3,063 2,941
Counterparty and cash collateral netting (59,399) (55,685) (57,855)
Total financial assets at fair value $ 758,400 $ 722,276 $ 650,966
Total assets $ 1,577,153 $ 1,571,386 $ 1,441,799
Total level 3 financial assets divided by:
Total assets 1.6% 1.7% 1.8%
Total financial assets at fair value 3.3% 3.6% 4.0%
Total level 1 financial liabilities $ 123,428 $ 125,540 $ 119,578
Total level 2 financial liabilities 481,831 469,090 353,060
Total level 3 financial liabilities 27,659 26,159 22,830
Counterparty and cash collateral netting (44,386) (43,276) (47,884)
Total financial liabilities at fair value $ 588,532 $ 577,513 $ 447,584
Total liabilities $ 1,459,876 $ 1,454,893 $ 1,324,610
Total level 3 financial liabilities divided by:
Total liabilities 1.9% 1.8% 1.7%
Total financial liabilities at fair value 4.7% 4.5% 5.1%
In the table above:
• Counterparty netting among positions classified in the
same level is included in that level.
• Counterparty and cash collateral netting represents the
impact on derivatives of netting across levels.
The table below presents a summary of level 3 financial
assets.
As of
September June December
$ in millions 2023 2023 2022
Trading assets:
Trading cash instruments $ 1,753 $ 1,664 $ 1,734
Derivatives 4,657 4,776 5,461
Investments 17,329 18,128 16,942
Loans 972 1,251 1,837
Other assets 151 126 74
Total $ 24,862 $ 25,945 $ 26,048
Level 3 financial assets as of September 2023 decreased
compared with June 2023, primarily reflecting a decrease in
level 3 investments. Level 3 financial assets as of September
2023 decreased compared with December 2022, primarily
reflecting a decrease in level 3 loans and derivatives, partially
offset by an increase in level 3 investments. See Note 5 for
further information about level 3 financial assets (including
information about unrealized gains and losses related to level
3 financial assets and transfers into and out of level 3).
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 12

-- 14 of 205 --

The valuation techniques and nature of significant inputs
used to determine the fair value of the firm’s financial
instruments are described below. See Note 5 for further
information about significant unobservable inputs used to
value level 3 financial instruments.
Valuation Techniques and Significant Inputs for
Trading Cash Instruments, Investments and Loans
Level 1. Level 1 instruments include U.S. government
obligations, most non-U.S. government obligations, certain
agency obligations, certain corporate debt instruments,
certain money market instruments and actively traded listed
equities. These instruments are valued using quoted prices for
identical unrestricted instruments in active markets. The firm
defines active markets for equity instruments based on the
average daily trading volume both in absolute terms and
relative to the market capitalization for the instrument. The
firm defines active markets for debt instruments based on
both the average daily trading volume and the number of
days with trading activity.
Level 2. Level 2 instruments include certain non-U.S.
government obligations, most agency obligations, most
mortgage-backed loans and securities, most corporate debt
instruments, most state and municipal obligations, most
money market instruments, most other debt obligations,
restricted or less liquid listed equities, certain private equities,
commodities and certain lending commitments.
Valuations of level 2 instruments can be verified to quoted
prices, recent trading activity for identical or similar
instruments, broker or dealer quotations or alternative
pricing sources with reasonable levels of price transparency.
Consideration is given to the nature of the quotations (e.g.,
indicative or executable) and the relationship of recent
market activity to the prices provided from alternative
pricing sources.
Valuation adjustments are typically made to level 2
instruments (i) if the instrument is subject to transfer
restrictions and/or (ii) for other premiums and liquidity
discounts that a market participant would require to arrive at
fair value. Valuation adjustments are generally based on
market evidence.
Level 3. Level 3 instruments have one or more significant
valuation inputs that are not observable. Absent evidence to
the contrary, level 3 instruments are initially valued at
transaction price, which is considered to be the best initial
estimate of fair value. Subsequently, the firm uses other
methodologies to determine fair value, which vary based on
the type of instrument. Valuation inputs and assumptions are
changed when corroborated by substantive observable
evidence, including values realized on sales.
Valuation techniques of level 3 instruments vary by
instrument, but are generally based on discounted cash flow
techniques. The valuation techniques and the nature of
significant inputs used to determine the fair values of each
type of level 3 instrument are described below:
Loans and Securities Backed by Commercial Real
Estate
Loans and securities backed by commercial real estate are
directly or indirectly collateralized by a single property or a
portfolio of properties, and may include tranches of varying
levels of subordination. Significant inputs are generally
determined based on relative value analyses and include:
• Market yields implied by transactions of similar or related
assets and/or current levels and changes in market indices,
such as the CMBX (an index that tracks the performance
of commercial mortgage bonds);
• Transaction prices in both the underlying collateral and
instruments with the same or similar underlying collateral;
• A measure of expected future cash flows in a default
scenario (recovery rates) implied by the value of the
underlying collateral, which is mainly driven by current
performance of the underlying collateral and capitalization
rates. Recovery rates are expressed as a percentage of
notional or face value of the instrument and reflect the
benefit of credit enhancements on certain instruments; and
• Timing of expected future cash flows (duration) which, in
certain cases, may incorporate the impact of any loan
forbearances and other unobservable inputs (e.g.,
prepayment speeds).
Loans and Securities Backed by Residential Real
Estate
Loans and securities backed by residential real estate are
directly or indirectly collateralized by portfolios of residential
real estate and may include tranches of varying levels of
subordination. Significant inputs are generally determined
based on relative value analyses, which incorporate
comparisons to instruments with similar collateral and risk
profiles. Significant inputs include:
• Market yields implied by transactions of similar or related
assets;
• Transaction prices in both the underlying collateral and
instruments with the same or similar underlying collateral;
• Cumulative loss expectations, driven by default rates,
home price projections, residential property liquidation
timelines, related costs and subsequent recoveries; and
• Duration, driven by underlying loan prepayment speeds
and residential property liquidation timelines.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
13 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 15 of 205 --

Corporate Debt Instruments
Corporate debt instruments includes corporate loans, debt
securities and convertible debentures. Significant inputs for
corporate debt instruments are generally determined based
on relative value analyses, which incorporate comparisons
both to prices of credit default swaps that reference the same
or similar underlying instrument or entity and to other debt
instruments for the same or similar issuer for which
observable prices or broker quotations are available.
Significant inputs include:
• Market yields implied by transactions of similar or related
assets and/or current levels and trends of market indices,
such as the CDX (an index that tracks the performance of
corporate credit);
• Current performance and recovery assumptions and, where
the firm uses credit default swaps to value the related
instrument, the cost of borrowing the underlying reference
obligation;
• Duration; and
• Market and transaction multiples for corporate debt
instruments with convertibility or participation options.
Equity Securities
Equity securities consists of private equities. Recent third-
party completed or pending transactions (e.g., merger
proposals, debt restructurings, tender offers) are considered
the best evidence for any change in fair value. When these are
not available, the following valuation methodologies are
used, as appropriate:
• Industry multiples (primarily EBITDA and revenue
multiples) and public comparables;
• Transactions in similar instruments;
• Discounted cash flow techniques; and
• Third-party appraisals.
The firm also considers changes in the outlook for the
relevant industry and financial performance of the issuer as
compared to projected performance. Significant inputs
include:
• Market and transaction multiples;
• Discount rates and capitalization rates; and
• For equity securities with debt-like features, market yields
implied by transactions of similar or related assets, current
performance and recovery assumptions, and duration.
Other Trading Cash Instruments, Investments and
Loans
The significant inputs to the valuation of other instruments,
such as non-U.S. government and agency obligations, state
and municipal obligations, and other loans and debt
obligations are generally determined based on relative value
analyses, which incorporate comparisons both to prices of
credit default swaps that reference the same or similar
underlying instrument or entity and to other debt instruments
for the same issuer for which observable prices or broker
quotations are available. Significant inputs include:
• Market yields implied by transactions of similar or related
assets and/or current levels and trends of market indices;
• Current performance and recovery assumptions and, where
the firm uses credit default swaps to value the related
instrument, the cost of borrowing the underlying reference
obligation; and
• Duration.
Valuation Techniques and Significant Inputs for
Derivatives
The firm’s level 2 and level 3 derivatives are valued using
derivative pricing models (e.g., discounted cash flow models,
correlation models and models that incorporate option
pricing methodologies, such as Monte Carlo simulations).
Price transparency of derivatives can generally be
characterized by product type, as described below.
• Interest Rate. In general, the key inputs used to value
interest rate derivatives are transparent, even for most
long-dated contracts. Interest rate swaps and options
denominated in the currencies of leading industrialized
nations are characterized by high trading volumes and tight
bid/offer spreads. Interest rate derivatives that reference
indices, such as an inflation index, or the shape of the yield
curve (e.g., 10-year swap rate vs. 2-year swap rate) are
more complex, but the key inputs are generally observable.
• Credit. Price transparency for credit default swaps,
including both single names and baskets of credits, varies
by market and underlying reference entity or obligation.
Credit default swaps that reference indices, large
corporates and major sovereigns generally exhibit the most
price transparency. For credit default swaps with other
underliers, price transparency varies based on credit rating,
the cost of borrowing the underlying reference obligations,
and the availability of the underlying reference obligations
for delivery upon the default of the issuer. Credit default
swaps that reference loans, asset-backed securities and
emerging market debt instruments tend to have less price
transparency than those that reference corporate bonds. In
addition, more complex credit derivatives, such as those
sensitive to the correlation between two or more
underlying reference obligations, generally have less price
transparency.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 14

-- 16 of 205 --

• Currency. Prices for currency derivatives based on the
exchange rates of leading industrialized nations, including
those with longer tenors, are generally transparent. The
primary difference between the price transparency of
developed and emerging market currency derivatives is that
emerging markets tend to be only observable for contracts
with shorter tenors.
• Commodity. Commodity derivatives include transactions
referenced to energy (e.g., oil, natural gas and electricity),
metals (e.g., precious and base) and soft commodities (e.g.,
agricultural). Price transparency varies based on the
underlying commodity, delivery location, tenor and
product quality (e.g., diesel fuel compared to unleaded
gasoline). In general, price transparency for commodity
derivatives is greater for contracts with shorter tenors and
contracts that are more closely aligned with major and/or
benchmark commodity indices.
• Equity. Price transparency for equity derivatives varies by
market and underlier. Options on indices and the common
stock of corporates included in major equity indices exhibit
the most price transparency. Equity derivatives generally
have observable market prices, except for contracts with
long tenors or reference prices that differ significantly from
current market prices. More complex equity derivatives,
such as those sensitive to the correlation between two or
more individual stocks, generally have less price
transparency.
Liquidity is essential to the observability of all product types.
If transaction volumes decline, previously transparent prices
and other inputs may become unobservable. Conversely, even
highly structured products may at times have trading
volumes large enough to provide observability of prices and
other inputs.
Level 1. Level 1 derivatives include short-term contracts for
future delivery of securities when the underlying security is a
level 1 instrument, and exchange-traded derivatives if they
are actively traded and are valued at their quoted market
price.
Level 2. Level 2 derivatives include OTC derivatives for
which all significant valuation inputs are corroborated by
market evidence and exchange-traded derivatives that are not
actively traded and/or that are valued using models that
calibrate to market-clearing levels of OTC derivatives.
The selection of a particular model to value a derivative
depends on the contractual terms of and specific risks
inherent in the instrument, as well as the availability of
pricing information in the market. For derivatives that trade
in liquid markets, model selection does not involve significant
management judgment because outputs of models can be
calibrated to market-clearing levels.
Valuation models require a variety of inputs, such as
contractual terms, market prices, yield curves, discount rates
(including those derived from interest rates on collateral
received and posted as specified in credit support agreements
for collateralized derivatives), credit curves, measures of
volatility, prepayment rates, loss severity rates and
correlations of such inputs. Significant inputs to the
valuations of level 2 derivatives can be verified to market
transactions, broker or dealer quotations or other alternative
pricing sources with reasonable levels of price transparency.
Consideration is given to the nature of the quotations (e.g.,
indicative or executable) and the relationship of recent
market activity to the prices provided from alternative
pricing sources.
Level 3. Level 3 derivatives are valued using models which
utilize observable level 1 and/or level 2 inputs, as well as
unobservable level 3 inputs. The significant unobservable
inputs used to value the firm’s level 3 derivatives are
described below.
• For level 3 interest rate and currency derivatives, significant
unobservable inputs include correlations of certain
currencies and interest rates (e.g., the correlation between
Euro inflation and Euro interest rates) and specific interest
rate and currency volatilities.
• For level 3 credit derivatives, significant unobservable
inputs include illiquid credit spreads and upfront credit
points, which are unique to specific reference obligations
and reference entities, and recovery rates.
• For level 3 commodity derivatives, significant unobservable
inputs include volatilities for options with strike prices that
differ significantly from current market prices and prices or
spreads for certain products for which the product quality
or physical location of the commodity is not aligned with
benchmark indices.
• For level 3 equity derivatives, significant unobservable
inputs generally include equity volatility inputs for options
that are long-dated and/or have strike prices that differ
significantly from current market prices. In addition, the
valuation of certain structured trades requires the use of
level 3 correlation inputs, such as the correlation of the
price performance of two or more individual stocks or the
correlation of the price performance for a basket of stocks
to another asset class, such as commodities.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
15 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 17 of 205 --

Subsequent to the initial valuation of a level 3 derivative, the
firm updates the level 1 and level 2 inputs to reflect
observable market changes and any resulting gains and losses
are classified in level 3. Level 3 inputs are changed when
corroborated by evidence, such as similar market
transactions, third-party pricing services and/or broker or
dealer quotations or other empirical market data. In
circumstances where the firm cannot verify the model value
by reference to market transactions, it is possible that a
different valuation model could produce a materially
different estimate of fair value. See Note 5 for further
information about significant unobservable inputs used in the
valuation of level 3 derivatives.
Valuation Adjustments. Valuation adjustments are
integral to determining the fair value of derivative portfolios
and are used to adjust the mid-market valuations produced
by derivative pricing models to the exit price valuation. These
adjustments incorporate bid/offer spreads, the cost of
liquidity, and credit and funding valuation adjustments,
which account for the credit and funding risk inherent in the
uncollateralized portion of derivative portfolios. The firm
also makes funding valuation adjustments to collateralized
derivatives where the terms of the agreement do not permit
the firm to deliver or repledge collateral received. Market-
based inputs are generally used when calibrating valuation
adjustments to market-clearing levels.
In addition, for derivatives that include significant
unobservable inputs, the firm makes model or exit price
adjustments to account for the valuation uncertainty present
in the transaction.
Valuation Techniques and Significant Inputs for Other
Financial Assets and Liabilities at Fair Value
In addition to trading cash instruments, derivatives, and
certain investments and loans, the firm accounts for certain
of its other financial assets and liabilities at fair value under
the fair value option. Such instruments include repurchase
agreements and substantially all resale agreements; certain
securities borrowed and loaned transactions; certain
customer and other receivables, including certain margin
loans; certain time deposits, including structured certificates
of deposit, which are hybrid financial instruments;
substantially all other secured financings, including transfers
of assets accounted for as financings; certain unsecured short-
and long-term borrowings, substantially all of which are
hybrid financial instruments; and certain other assets and
liabilities. These instruments are generally valued based on
discounted cash flow techniques, which incorporate inputs
with reasonable levels of price transparency, and are
generally classified in level 2 because the inputs are
observable. Valuation adjustments may be made for liquidity
and for counterparty and the firm’s credit quality. The
significant inputs used to value the firm’s other financial
assets and liabilities are described below.
Resale and Repurchase Agreements and Securities
Borrowed and Loaned. The significant inputs to the
valuation of resale and repurchase agreements and securities
borrowed and loaned are funding spreads, the amount and
timing of expected future cash flows and interest rates.
Customer and Other Receivables. The significant inputs
to the valuation of receivables are interest rates, the amount
and timing of expected future cash flows and funding
spreads.
Deposits. The significant inputs to the valuation of time
deposits are interest rates and the amount and timing of
future cash flows. The inputs used to value the embedded
derivative component of hybrid financial instruments are
consistent with the inputs used to value the firm’s other
derivative instruments described above. See Note 7 for
further information about derivatives and Note 13 for further
information about deposits.
Other Secured Financings. The significant inputs to the
valuation of other secured financings are the amount and
timing of expected future cash flows, interest rates, funding
spreads and the fair value of the collateral delivered by the
firm (determined using the amount and timing of expected
future cash flows, market prices, market yields and recovery
assumptions). See Note 11 for further information about
other secured financings.
Unsecured Short- and Long-Term Borrowings. The
significant inputs to the valuation of unsecured short- and
long-term borrowings are the amount and timing of expected
future cash flows, interest rates, the credit spreads of the firm
and commodity prices for prepaid commodity transactions.
The inputs used to value the embedded derivative component
of hybrid financial instruments are consistent with the inputs
used to value the firm’s other derivative instruments
described above. See Note 7 for further information about
derivatives and Note 14 for further information about
borrowings.
Other Assets and Liabilities. The significant inputs to the
valuation of other assets and liabilities are the amount and
timing of expected future cash flows, interest rates, market
yields, volatility and correlation inputs. The inputs used to
value the embedded derivative component of hybrid financial
instruments are consistent with the inputs used to value the
firm’s other derivative instruments described above. See Note
7 for further information about derivatives.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 16

-- 18 of 205 --

Note 5.
Fair Value Hierarchy
Financial assets and liabilities at fair value includes trading
cash instruments, derivatives, and certain investments, loans
and other financial assets and liabilities at fair value.
Trading Cash Instruments
Fair Value by Level. The table below presents trading cash
instruments by level within the fair value hierarchy.
$ in millions Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total
As of September 2023
Assets
Government and agency obligations:
U.S. $ 96,526 $ 53,900 $ – $ 150,426
Non-U.S. 53,688 20,741 71 74,500
Loans and securities backed by:
Commercial real estate – 1,012 108 1,120
Residential real estate – 7,929 63 7,992
Corporate debt instruments 125 35,751 1,316 37,192
State and municipal obligations – 660 – 660
Other debt obligations 226 3,058 105 3,389
Equity securities 117,588 1,781 87 119,456
Commodities – 4,260 3 4,263
Total $ 268,153 $ 129,092 $ 1,753 $ 398,998
Liabilities
Government and agency obligations:
U.S. $ (20,133) $ (74) $ – $ (20,207)
Non-U.S. (45,748) (2,539) – (48,287)
Loans and securities backed by:
Commercial real estate – (27) – (27)
Residential real estate – (12) – (12)
Corporate debt instruments (77) (14,191) (40) (14,308)
Other debt obligations – (2) – (2)
Equity securities (57,335) (11) (11) (57,357)
Commodities – (106) – (106)
Total $ (123,293) $ (16,962) $ (51) $(140,306)
As of December 2022
Assets
Government and agency obligations:
U.S. $ 75,598 $ 31,783 $ – $ 107,381
Non-U.S. 22,794 15,238 67 38,099
Loans and securities backed by:
Commercial real estate – 1,135 66 1,201
Residential real estate – 9,706 88 9,794
Corporate debt instruments 249 27,555 1,238 29,042
State and municipal obligations – 707 20 727
Other debt obligations 27 2,349 153 2,529
Equity securities 44,909 2,141 100 47,150
Commodities – 5,907 2 5,909
Total $ 143,577 $ 96,521 $ 1,734 $ 241,832
Liabilities
Government and agency obligations:
U.S. $ (23,339) $ (36) $ – $ (23,375)
Non-U.S. (28,537) (2,172) – (30,709)
Loans and securities backed by:
Commercial real estate – (30) – (30)
Residential real estate – (16) – (16)
Corporate debt instruments (64) (14,217) (61) (14,342)
Other debt obligations – (35) (2) (37)
Equity securities (67,591) (488) (1) (68,080)
Total $(119,531) $ (16,994) $ (64) $ (136,589)
Trading cash instruments consists of instruments held in
connection with the firm’s market-making or risk
management activities. These instruments are carried at fair
value and the related fair value gains and losses are
recognized in the consolidated statements of earnings.
In the table above:
• Assets are shown as positive amounts and liabilities are
shown as negative amounts.
• Corporate debt instruments includes corporate loans, debt
securities, convertible debentures, prepaid commodity
transactions and transfers of assets accounted for as
secured loans rather than purchases.
• Other debt obligations includes other asset-backed
securities and money market instruments.
• Equity securities includes public equities and exchange-
traded funds.
See Note 4 for an overview of the firm’s fair value
measurement policies, valuation techniques and significant
inputs used to determine the fair value of trading cash
instruments.
Significant Unobservable Inputs. The table below
presents the amount of level 3 assets, and ranges and
weighted averages of significant unobservable inputs used to
value level 3 trading cash instrument assets.
As of September 2023 As of December 2022
$ in millions
Amount or
Range
Weighted
Average
Amount or
Range
Weighted
Average
Loans and securities backed by real estate
Level 3 assets $ 171 $ 154
Yield 4.2% to 26.3% 16.0% 3.0% to 36.0% 14.2%
Recovery rate 42.7% to 76.0% 48.8% 35.8% to 76.1% 54.7%
Cumulative loss rate N/A N/A 3.7% to 29.9% 10.4%
Duration (years) 0.5 to 12.0 3.0 0.9 to 12.3 4.6
Corporate debt instruments
Level 3 assets $ 1,316 $ 1,238
Yield 3.7% to 40.4% 10.2% 1.1% to 34.3% 6.9%
Recovery rate 7.0% to 70.0% 45.7% 11.5% to 77.0% 48.0%
Duration (years) 1.2 to 11.6 3.2 0.3 to 20.3 4.5
Other
Level 3 assets $ 266 $ 342
Yield 6.2% to 37.5% 16.6% 2.8% to 47.8% 10.0%
Multiples 0.7x to 5.1x 4.5x 3.3x to 4.5x 4.3x
Duration (years) 1.5 to 9.6 4.0 1.2 to 14.4 6.1
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
17 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 19 of 205 --

In the table above:
• Other includes government and agency obligations, state
and municipal obligations, other debt obligations, equity
securities and commodities.
• Ranges represent the significant unobservable inputs that
were used in the valuation of each type of trading cash
instrument.
• Weighted averages are calculated by weighting each input
by the relative fair value of the trading cash instruments.
• The ranges and weighted averages of these inputs are not
representative of the appropriate inputs to use when
calculating the fair value of any one trading cash
instrument. For example, the highest recovery rate for
corporate debt instruments is appropriate for valuing a
specific corporate debt instrument, but may not be
appropriate for valuing any other corporate debt
instrument. Accordingly, the ranges of inputs do not
represent uncertainty in, or possible ranges of, fair value
measurements of level 3 trading cash instruments.
• Increases in yield, duration or cumulative loss rate used in
the valuation of level 3 trading cash instruments would
have resulted in a lower fair value measurement, while
increases in recovery rate or multiples would have resulted
in a higher fair value measurement as of both September
2023 and December 2022. Due to the distinctive nature of
each level 3 trading cash instrument, the interrelationship
of inputs is not necessarily uniform within each product
type.
• Trading cash instruments are valued using discounted cash
flows.
• Cumulative loss rate was not significant to the valuation of
level 3 loans and securities backed by real estate as of
September 2023.
Level 3 Rollforward. The table below presents a summary
of the changes in fair value for level 3 trading cash
instruments.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Assets
Beginning balance $ 1,664 $ 2,080 $ 1,734 $ 1,889
Net realized gains/(losses) 22 40 129 85
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (41) (124) (22) (1,496)
Purchases 295 359 597 1,294
Sales (167) (248) (499) (635)
Settlements (91) (78) (311) (206)
Transfers into level 3 309 326 323 1,277
Transfers out of level 3 (238) (527) (198) (380)
Ending balance $ 1,753 $ 1,828 $ 1,753 $ 1,828
Liabilities
Beginning balance $ (95) $ (182) $ (64) $ (104)
Net realized gains/(losses) (1) (4) 6 (42)
Net unrealized gains/(losses) – 53 (15) 47
Purchases 46 100 52 198
Sales (29) (40) (48) (121)
Settlements 5 5 13 (2)
Transfers into level 3 (15) (86) (3) (103)
Transfers out of level 3 38 43 8 16
Ending balance $ (51) $ (111) $ (51) $ (111)
In the table above:
• Changes in fair value are presented for all trading cash
instruments that are classified in level 3 as of the end of the
period.
• Net unrealized gains/(losses) relates to trading cash
instruments that were still held at period-end.
• Transfers between levels of the fair value hierarchy are
reported at the beginning of the reporting period in which
they occur. If a trading cash instrument was transferred to
level 3 during a reporting period, its entire gain or loss for
the period is classified in level 3.
• For level 3 trading cash instrument assets, increases are
shown as positive amounts, while decreases are shown as
negative amounts. For level 3 trading cash instrument
liabilities, increases are shown as negative amounts, while
decreases are shown as positive amounts.
• Level 3 trading cash instruments are frequently
economically hedged with level 1 and level 2 trading cash
instruments and/or level 1, level 2 or level 3 derivatives.
Accordingly, gains or losses that are classified in level 3 can
be partially offset by gains or losses attributable to level 1
or level 2 trading cash instruments and/or level 1, level 2 or
level 3 derivatives. As a result, gains or losses included in
the level 3 rollforward below do not necessarily represent
the overall impact on the firm’s results of operations,
liquidity or capital resources.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 18

-- 20 of 205 --

The table below presents information, by product type, for
assets included in the summary table above.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Loans and securities backed by real estate
Beginning balance $ 221 $ 184 $ 154 $ 289
Net realized gains/(losses) 3 9 9 17
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (11) (15) (11) (22)
Purchases 13 7 67 44
Sales (43) (8) (53) (111)
Settlements (15) (12) (26) (29)
Transfers into level 3 59 39 63 26
Transfers out of level 3 (56) (39) (32) (49)
Ending balance $ 171 $ 165 $ 171 $ 165
Corporate debt instruments
Beginning balance $ 1,145 $ 1,440 $ 1,238 $ 1,318
Net realized gains/(losses) 14 13 31 44
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (18) (43) (6) (115)
Purchases 216 313 424 558
Sales (71) (126) (263) (363)
Settlements (46) (51) (214) (131)
Transfers into level 3 217 201 212 339
Transfers out of level 3 (141) (395) (106) (298)
Ending balance $ 1,316 $ 1,352 $ 1,316 $ 1,352
Other
Beginning balance $ 298 $ 456 $ 342 $ 282
Net realized gains/(losses) 5 18 89 24
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (12) (66) (5) (1,359)
Purchases 66 39 106 692
Sales (53) (114) (183) (161)
Settlements (30) (15) (71) (46)
Transfers into level 3 33 86 48 912
Transfers out of level 3 (41) (93) (60) (33)
Ending balance $ 266 $ 311 $ 266 $ 311
In the table above, other includes government and agency
obligations, state and municipal obligations, other debt
obligations, equity securities and commodities.
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Three Months
Ended September 2023. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 trading cash instrument assets of $19 million
(reflecting $22 million of net realized gains and $41 million of
net unrealized losses) for the three months ended September
2023 included gains/(losses) of $(36) million reported in
market making and $17 million reported in interest income.
The drivers of net unrealized losses on level 3 trading cash
instrument assets for the three months ended September 2023
were not material.
Transfers into level 3 trading cash instrument assets during
the three months ended September 2023 primarily reflected
transfers of certain corporate debt instruments from level 2
(principally due to reduced price transparency as a result of a
lack of market evidence, including fewer market transactions
in these instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 trading cash instrument assets during
the three months ended September 2023 primarily reflected
transfers of certain corporate debt instruments to level 2
(principally due to increased price transparency as a result of
market evidence, including market transactions in these
instruments).
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Nine Months
Ended September 2023. The net realized and unrealized
gains on level 3 trading cash instrument assets of $107 million
(reflecting $129 million of net realized gains and $22 million
of net unrealized losses) for the nine months ended September
2023 included gains of $61 million reported in market making
and $46 million reported in interest income.
The drivers of net unrealized losses on level 3 trading cash
instrument assets for the nine months ended September 2023
were not material.
Transfers into level 3 trading cash instrument assets during
the nine months ended September 2023 primarily reflected
transfers of certain corporate debt instruments from level 2
(principally due to reduced price transparency as a result of a
lack of market evidence, including fewer market transactions
in these instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 trading cash instrument assets during
the nine months ended September 2023 primarily reflected
transfers of certain corporate debt instruments to level 2
(principally due to increased price transparency as a result of
market evidence, including market transactions in these
instruments).
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Three Months
Ended September 2022. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 trading cash instrument assets of $84 million
(reflecting $40 million of net realized gains and $124 million
of net unrealized losses) for the three months ended
September 2022 included gains/(losses) of $(106) million
reported in market making and $22 million reported in
interest income.
The drivers of net unrealized losses on level 3 trading cash
instrument assets for the three months ended September 2022
were not material.
Transfers into level 3 trading cash instrument assets during
the three months ended September 2022 primarily reflected
transfers of certain corporate debt instruments from level 2
(principally due to reduced price transparency as a result of a
lack of market evidence, including fewer market transactions
in these instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 trading cash instrument assets during
the three months ended September 2022 primarily reflected
transfers of certain corporate debt instruments to level 2
(principally due to increased price transparency as a result of
market evidence, including market transactions in these
instruments).
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
19 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 21 of 205 --

Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Nine Months
Ended September 2022. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 trading cash instrument assets of
$1.41 billion (reflecting $85 million of net realized gains and
$1.50 billion of net unrealized losses) for the nine months
ended September 2022 included gains/(losses) of
$(1.46) billion reported in market making and $53 million
reported in interest income.
The net unrealized losses on level 3 trading cash instrument
assets for the nine months ended September 2022 primarily
reflected losses on certain equity securities (included in other
cash instruments), principally driven by broad
macroeconomic and geopolitical concerns.
Transfers into level 3 trading cash instrument assets during
the nine months ended September 2022 primarily reflected
transfers of certain equity securities (included in other cash
instruments) and corporate debt instruments from both level
1 and level 2 (in each case, principally due to reduced price
transparency as a result of a lack of market evidence,
including fewer market transactions in these instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 trading cash instrument assets during
the nine months ended September 2022 primarily reflected
transfers of certain corporate debt instruments to level 2
(principally due to increased price transparency as a result of
market evidence, including market transactions in these
instruments).
Derivatives
Fair Value by Level. The table below presents derivatives
on a gross basis by level and product type, as well as the
impact of netting.
$ in millions Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total
As of September 2023
Assets
Interest rates $ 112 $ 264,074 $ 511 $ 264,697
Credit – 9,900 2,749 12,649
Currencies – 101,232 299 101,531
Commodities – 19,310 1,405 20,715
Equities 7 48,259 710 48,976
Gross fair value 119 442,775 5,674 448,568
Counterparty netting in levels – (339,090) (1,017) (340,107)
Subtotal $ 119 $ 103,685 $ 4,657 $ 108,461
Cross-level counterparty netting (963)
Cash collateral netting (58,436)
Net fair value $ 49,062
Liabilities
Interest rates $ (126) $(240,782) $ (1,118) $ (242,026)
Credit – (9,161) (1,139) (10,300)
Currencies – (101,326) (151) (101,477)
Commodities – (19,051) (815) (19,866)
Equities (9) (63,540) (2,092) (65,641)
Gross fair value (135) (433,860) (5,315) (439,310)
Counterparty netting in levels – 339,090 1,017 340,107
Subtotal $ (135) $ (94,770) $ (4,298) $ (99,203)
Cross-level counterparty netting 963
Cash collateral netting 43,423
Net fair value $ (54,817)
As of December 2022
Assets
Interest rates $ 69 $ 269,590 $ 700 $ 270,359
Credit – 9,690 2,577 12,267
Currencies – 103,450 494 103,944
Commodities – 38,331 1,609 39,940
Equities 113 49,481 967 50,561
Gross fair value 182 470,542 6,347 477,071
Counterparty netting in levels – (358,917) (886) (359,803)
Subtotal $ 182 $ 111,625 $ 5,461 $ 117,268
Cross-level counterparty netting (1,079)
Cash collateral netting (56,776)
Net fair value $ 59,413
Liabilities
Interest rates $ (32) $ (247,871) $ (1,159) $ (249,062)
Credit – (10,163) (1,117) (11,280)
Currencies – (111,840) (332) (112,172)
Commodities – (32,435) (690) (33,125)
Equities (15) (55,240) (1,528) (56,783)
Gross fair value (47) (457,549) (4,826) (462,422)
Counterparty netting in levels – 358,917 886 359,803
Subtotal $ (47) $ (98,632) $ (3,940) $ (102,619)
Cross-level counterparty netting 1,079
Cash collateral netting 46,805
Net fair value $ (54,735)
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 20

-- 22 of 205 --

In the table above:
• Gross fair values exclude the effects of both counterparty
netting and collateral netting, and therefore are not
representative of the firm’s exposure.
• Counterparty netting is reflected in each level to the extent
that receivable and payable balances are netted within the
same level and is included in counterparty netting in levels.
Where the counterparty netting is across levels, the netting
is included in cross-level counterparty netting.
• Assets are shown as positive amounts and liabilities are
shown as negative amounts.
See Note 4 for an overview of the firm’s fair value
measurement policies, valuation techniques and significant
inputs used to determine the fair value of derivatives.
Significant Unobservable Inputs. The table below
presents the amount of level 3 derivative assets (liabilities),
and ranges, averages and medians of significant unobservable
inputs used to value level 3 derivatives.
As of September 2023 As of December 2022
$ in millions, except inputs
Amount or
Range
Average/
Median
Amount or
Range
Average/
Median
Interest rates, net $ (607) $ (459)
Correlation (10)% to 81% 61%/78% (10)% to 81% 61%/60%
Volatility (bps) 31 to 101 56/49 31 to 101 60/57
Credit, net $ 1,610 $ 1,460
Credit spreads (bps) 8 to 1,966 167/105 5 to 935 149/116
Upfront credit points (2) to 100 24/11 (1) to 100 29/18
Recovery rates 20% to 70% 42%/40% 20% to 50% 40%/40%
Currencies, net $ 148 $ 162
Correlation 20% to 71% 40%/23% 20% to 71% 40%/23%
Volatility 16% to 16% 16%/16% 20% to 21% 20%/20%
Commodities, net $ 590 $ 919
Volatility 29% to 97% 44%/40% 20% to 118% 50%/46%
Natural gas spread $(1.53) to
$8.08
$(0.16)/
$(0.24)
$(3.21) to
$5.85
$(0.20)/
$(0.27)
Oil spread $(5.03) to
$35.79
$12.59/
$12.64
$12.68 to
$48.92
$20.42/
$20.36
Electricity price $3.10 to
$330.34
$46.58/
$34.95
$3.00 to
$329.28
$47.19/
$39.69
Equities, net $ (1,382) $ (561)
Correlation (70)% to 100% 64%/73% (75)% to 100% 66%/75%
Volatility 2% to 123% 15%/12% 2% to 74% 13%/7%
In the table above:
• Assets are shown as positive amounts and liabilities are
shown as negative amounts.
• Ranges represent the significant unobservable inputs that
were used in the valuation of each type of derivative.
• Averages represent the arithmetic average of the inputs and
are not weighted by the relative fair value or notional
amount of the respective financial instruments. An average
greater than the median indicates that the majority of
inputs are below the average. For example, the difference
between the average and the median for credit spreads
indicates that the majority of the inputs fall in the lower
end of the range.
• The ranges, averages and medians of these inputs are not
representative of the appropriate inputs to use when
calculating the fair value of any one derivative. For
example, the highest correlation for interest rate derivatives
is appropriate for valuing a specific interest rate derivative
but may not be appropriate for valuing any other interest
rate derivative. Accordingly, the ranges of inputs do not
represent uncertainty in, or possible ranges of, fair value
measurements of level 3 derivatives.
• Interest rates, currencies and equities derivatives are valued
using option pricing models, credit derivatives are valued
using option pricing, correlation and discounted cash flow
models, and commodities derivatives are valued using
option pricing and discounted cash flow models.
• The fair value of any one instrument may be determined
using multiple valuation techniques. For example, option
pricing models and discounted cash flow models are
typically used together to determine fair value. Therefore,
the level 3 balance encompasses both of these techniques.
• Correlation within currencies and equities includes cross-
product type correlation.
• Natural gas spread represents the spread per million British
thermal units of natural gas.
• Oil spread represents the spread per barrel of oil and
refined products.
• Electricity price represents the price per megawatt hour of
electricity.
Range of Significant Unobservable Inputs. The
following provides information about the ranges of
significant unobservable inputs used to value the firm’s level
3 derivative instruments:
• Correlation. Ranges for correlation cover a variety of
underliers both within one product type (e.g., equity index
and equity single stock names) and across product types
(e.g., correlation of an interest rate and a currency), as well
as across regions. Generally, cross-product type correlation
inputs are used to value more complex instruments and are
lower than correlation inputs on assets within the same
derivative product type.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
21 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 23 of 205 --

• Volatility. Ranges for volatility cover numerous underliers
across a variety of markets, maturities and strike prices.
For example, volatility of equity indices is generally lower
than volatility of single stocks.
• Credit spreads, upfront credit points and recovery
rates. The ranges for credit spreads, upfront credit points
and recovery rates cover a variety of underliers (index and
single names), regions, sectors, maturities and credit
qualities (high-yield and investment-grade). The broad
range of this population gives rise to the width of the
ranges of significant unobservable inputs.
• Commodity prices and spreads. The ranges for
commodity prices and spreads cover variability in
products, maturities and delivery locations.
Sensitivity of Fair Value Measurement to Changes in
Significant Unobservable Inputs. The following is a
description of the directional sensitivity of the firm’s level 3
fair value measurements to changes in significant
unobservable inputs, in isolation, as of each period-end:
• Correlation. In general, for contracts where the holder
benefits from the convergence of the underlying asset or
index prices (e.g., interest rates, credit spreads, foreign
exchange rates, inflation rates and equity prices), an
increase in correlation results in a higher fair value
measurement.
• Volatility. In general, for purchased options, an increase in
volatility results in a higher fair value measurement.
• Credit spreads, upfront credit points and recovery
rates. In general, the fair value of purchased credit
protection increases as credit spreads or upfront credit
points increase or recovery rates decrease. Credit spreads,
upfront credit points and recovery rates are strongly related
to distinctive risk factors of the underlying reference
obligations, which include reference entity-specific factors,
such as leverage, volatility and industry, market-based risk
factors, such as borrowing costs or liquidity of the
underlying reference obligation, and macroeconomic
conditions.
• Commodity prices and spreads. In general, for
contracts where the holder is receiving a commodity, an
increase in the spread (price difference from a benchmark
index due to differences in quality or delivery location) or
price results in a higher fair value measurement.
Due to the distinctive nature of each of the firm’s level 3
derivatives, the interrelationship of inputs is not necessarily
uniform within each product type.
Level 3 Rollforward. The table below presents a summary
of the changes in fair value for level 3 derivatives.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Total level 3 derivatives, net
Beginning balance $ 609 $ 3,174 $ 1,521 $ 440
Net realized gains/(losses) (75) (16) 205 456
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (127) 1,167 (957) 4,413
Purchases 113 156 317 216
Sales (795) (232) (1,117) (1,004)
Settlements 340 491 111 50
Transfers into level 3 3 105 45 (130)
Transfers out of level 3 291 (702) 234 (298)
Ending balance $ 359 $ 4,143 $ 359 $ 4,143
In the table above:
• Changes in fair value are presented for all derivative assets
and liabilities that are classified in level 3 as of the end of
the period.
• Net unrealized gains/(losses) relates to instruments that
were still held at period-end.
• Transfers between levels of the fair value hierarchy are
reported at the beginning of the reporting period in which
they occur. If a derivative was transferred into level 3
during a reporting period, its entire gain or loss for the
period is classified in level 3.
• Positive amounts for transfers into level 3 and negative
amounts for transfers out of level 3 represent net transfers
of derivative assets. Negative amounts for transfers into
level 3 and positive amounts for transfers out of level 3
represent net transfers of derivative liabilities.
• A derivative with level 1 and/or level 2 inputs is classified in
level 3 in its entirety if it has at least one significant level 3
input.
• If there is one significant level 3 input, the entire gain or
loss from adjusting only observable inputs (i.e., level 1 and
level 2 inputs) is classified in level 3.
• Gains or losses that have been classified in level 3 resulting
from changes in level 1 or level 2 inputs are frequently
offset by gains or losses attributable to level 1 or level 2
derivatives and/or level 1, level 2 and level 3 trading cash
instruments. As a result, gains/(losses) included in the level
3 rollforward below do not necessarily represent the overall
impact on the firm’s results of operations, liquidity or
capital resources.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 22

-- 24 of 205 --

The table below presents information, by product type, for
derivatives included in the summary table above.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Interest rates, net
Beginning balance $ (589) $ 1,035 $ (459) $ 183
Net realized gains/(losses) (5) (27) 9 (98)
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (109) 411 (338) 1,370
Purchases 10 8 30 55
Sales (98) (1) (225) (27)
Settlements 88 64 167 111
Transfers into level 3 (14) (15) 25 (7)
Transfers out of level 3 110 (2) 184 (114)
Ending balance $ (607) $ 1,473 $ (607) $ 1,473
Credit, net
Beginning balance $ 1,711 $ 2,164 $ 1,460 $ 1,854
Net realized gains/(losses) 2 (11) (18) 36
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (24) 24 181 92
Purchases 28 64 114 2
Sales (28) (8) (48) (40)
Settlements (64) (144) (192) (105)
Transfers into level 3 – 16 (5) 11
Transfers out of level 3 (15) (439) 118 (184)
Ending balance $ 1,610 $ 1,666 $ 1,610 $ 1,666
Currencies, net
Beginning balance $ 129 $ (239) $ 162 $ (147)
Net realized gains/(losses) 30 28 84 66
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 16 199 (100) 225
Purchases 1 1 2 2
Sales (2) (2) (4) (7)
Settlements (46) 122 (31) 62
Transfers into level 3 7 2 7 (81)
Transfers out of level 3 13 14 28 5
Ending balance $ 148 $ 125 $ 148 $ 125
Commodities, net
Beginning balance $ 666 $ 1,435 $ 919 $ 438
Net realized gains/(losses) (64) (53) (39) (29)
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (202) 209 (435) 1,264
Purchases 19 5 12 4
Sales (16) (16) (68) (23)
Settlements 80 (14) 111 (87)
Transfers into level 3 51 78 131 172
Transfers out of level 3 56 (127) (41) (222)
Ending balance $ 590 $ 1,517 $ 590 $ 1,517
Equities, net
Beginning balance $ (1,308) $ (1,221) $ (561) $ (1,888)
Net realized gains/(losses) (38) 47 169 481
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 192 324 (265) 1,462
Purchases 55 78 159 153
Sales (651) (205) (772) (907)
Settlements 282 463 56 69
Transfers into level 3 (41) 24 (113) (225)
Transfers out of level 3 127 (148) (55) 217
Ending balance $ (1,382) $ (638) $ (1,382) $ (638)
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Three Months
Ended September 2023. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 derivatives of $202 million (reflecting $75
million of net realized losses and $127 million of net
unrealized losses) for the three months ended September 2023
included gains/(losses) of $(204) million reported in market
making and $2 million reported in other principal
transactions.
The net unrealized losses on level 3 derivatives for the three
months ended September 2023 were primarily attributable to
losses on certain commodity derivatives (primarily reflecting
the impact of changes in commodity prices) and losses on
certain interest rate derivatives (primarily reflecting the
impact of an increase in interest rates), partially offset by
gains on certain equity derivatives (primarily reflecting the
impact of a decrease in equity prices).
The drivers of transfers into level 3 derivatives during the
three months ended September 2023 were not material.
Transfers out of level 3 derivatives during the three months
ended September 2023 primarily reflected transfers of certain
equity derivative liabilities to level 2 (principally due to
certain unobservable inputs no longer being significant to the
valuation of these derivatives) and transfers of certain interest
rate derivative liabilities to level 2 (principally due to certain
unobservable volatility inputs no longer being significant to
the valuation of these derivatives).
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Nine Months
Ended September 2023. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 derivatives of $752 million (reflecting $205
million of net realized gains and $957 million of net
unrealized losses) for the nine months ended September 2023
included losses of $742 million reported in market making
and $10 million reported in other principal transactions.
The net unrealized losses on level 3 derivatives for the nine
months ended September 2023 were attributable to losses on
certain commodity derivatives (primarily reflecting the
impact of changes in commodity prices), losses on certain
interest rate and currency derivatives (in each case, primarily
reflecting the impact of an increase in interest rates), and
losses on certain equity derivatives (primarily reflecting the
impact of an increase in equity prices), partially offset by
gains on certain credit derivatives (primarily reflecting the
impact of changes in foreign exchange rates).
Transfers into level 3 derivatives during the nine months
ended September 2023 primarily reflected transfers of certain
commodity derivative assets from level 2 (principally due to
certain unobservable volatility inputs becoming significant to
the valuation of these derivatives), partially offset by
transfers of certain equity derivative liabilities from level 2
(principally due to reduced transparency of certain
unobservable volatility inputs used to value these
derivatives).
Transfers out of level 3 derivatives during the nine months
ended September 2023 primarily reflected transfers of certain
interest rate derivative liabilities to level 2 (principally due to
certain unobservable volatility inputs no longer being
significant to the valuation of these derivatives) and transfers
of certain credit derivative liabilities to level 2 (principally
due to certain unobservable credit spread inputs no longer
being significant to the net risk of certain portfolios).
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
23 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 25 of 205 --

Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Three Months
Ended September 2022. The net realized and unrealized
gains on level 3 derivatives of $1.15 billion (reflecting
$16 million of net realized losses and $1.17 billion of net
unrealized gains) for the three months ended September 2022
included gains of $1.14 billion reported in market making
and $7 million reported in other principal transactions.
The net unrealized gains on level 3 derivatives for the three
months ended September 2022 were primarily attributable to
gains on certain interest rate derivatives (primarily reflecting
the impact of an increase in interest rates), gains on certain
equity derivatives (primarily reflecting the impact of a
decrease in equity prices), gains on certain commodity
derivatives (primarily reflecting the impact of an increase in
commodity prices), and gains on certain currency derivatives
(primarily reflecting the impact of changes in foreign
exchange rates).
The drivers of transfers into level 3 derivatives during the
three months ended September 2022 were not material.
Transfers out of level 3 derivatives during the three months
ended September 2022 primarily reflected transfers of certain
credit derivative assets to level 2 (principally due to certain
unobservable credit spread inputs no longer being significant
to the net risk of certain portfolios), certain equity derivative
assets to level 2 (principally due to increased transparency of
certain unobservable volatility inputs used to value these
derivatives), and certain commodity derivative assets to level
2 (principally due to certain unobservable natural gas spread
and volatility inputs no longer being significant to the
valuation of these derivatives).
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Nine Months
Ended September 2022. The net realized and unrealized
gains on level 3 derivatives of $4.87 billion (reflecting
$456 million of net realized gains and $4.41 billion of net
unrealized gains) for the nine months ended September 2022
included gains of $4.85 billion reported in market making
and $16 million reported in other principal transactions.
The net unrealized gains on level 3 derivatives for the nine
months ended September 2022 were primarily attributable to
gains on certain equity derivatives (primarily reflecting the
impact of a decrease in equity prices), gains on certain
interest rate derivatives (primarily reflecting the impact of an
increase in interest rates), and gains on certain commodity
derivatives (primarily reflecting the impact of an increase in
commodity prices).
Transfers into level 3 derivatives during the nine months
ended September 2022 primarily reflected transfers of certain
equity derivative liabilities from level 2 (principally due to
reduced transparency of certain unobservable volatility
inputs used to value these derivatives) and certain currency
derivative liabilities from level 2 (principally due to certain
unobservable correlation inputs becoming significant to the
valuation of these derivatives), partially offset by transfers of
certain commodity derivative assets from level 2 (principally
due to certain unobservable electricity price inputs becoming
significant to the valuation of these derivatives).
Transfers out of level 3 derivatives during the nine months
ended September 2022 primarily reflected transfers of certain
commodity derivative assets to level 2 (principally due to
certain unobservable natural gas spread and volatility inputs
no longer being significant to the valuation of these
derivatives), certain credit derivative assets to level 2
(principally due to certain unobservable credit spread inputs
no longer being significant to the net risk of certain
portfolios), and certain interest rate derivative assets to level
2 (principally due to increased transparency of certain
unobservable volatility inputs used to value these
derivatives), partially offset by transfers of certain equity
derivative liabilities to level 2 (principally due to increased
transparency of certain unobservable volatility inputs used to
value these derivatives).
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 24

-- 26 of 205 --

Investments
Fair Value by Level. The table below presents investments
accounted for at fair value by level within the fair value
hierarchy.
$ in millions Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total
As of September 2023
Government and agency obligations:
U.S. $ 47,073 $ – $ – $ 47,073
Non-U.S. 2,178 143 – 2,321
Corporate debt securities 160 2,252 6,950 9,362
Securities backed by real estate – 13 772 785
Money market instruments 24 872 – 896
Other debt obligations – 53 249 302
Equity securities 828 2,345 9,358 12,531
Subtotal $ 50,263 $ 5,678 $ 17,329 $ 73,270
Investments in funds at NAV 3,037
Total investments $ 76,307
As of December 2022
Government and agency obligations:
U.S. $ 47,055 $ – $ – $ 47,055
Non-U.S. 2,169 66 – 2,235
Corporate debt securities 145 2,950 7,003 10,098
Securities backed by real estate – 176 827 1,003
Money market instruments 48 957 – 1,005
Other debt obligations – 3 256 259
Equity securities 1,522 3,227 8,856 13,605
Subtotal $ 50,939 $ 7,379 $ 16,942 $ 75,260
Investments in funds at NAV 2,941
Total investments $ 78,201
See Note 4 for an overview of the firm’s fair value
measurement policies, valuation techniques and significant
inputs used to determine the fair value of investments.
Significant Unobservable Inputs. The table below
presents the amount of level 3 investments, and ranges and
weighted averages of significant unobservable inputs used to
value such investments.
As of September 2023 As of December 2022
$ in millions
Amount or
Range
Weighted
Average
Amount or
Range
Weighted
Average
Corporate debt securities
Level 3 assets $ 6,950 $ 7,003
Yield 6.4% to 22.0% 12.5% 5.0% to 21.8% 11.6%
Recovery rate 7.3% to 58.9% 28.1% 10.0% to 70.0% 55.5%
Duration (years) 0.7 to 5.0 3.2 1.3 to 5.7 3.3
Multiples 0.9x to 46.2x 7.1x 1.8x to 83.4x 8.3x
Securities backed by real estate
Level 3 assets $ 772 $ 827
Yield 8.0% to 18.4% 13.3% 8.0% to 20.3% 14.6%
Duration (years) 2.0 to 3.1 3.1 0.6 to 4.2 4.1
Other debt obligations
Level 3 assets $ 249 $ 256
Yield 7.9% to 9.2% 8.4% 5.2% to 8.4% 7.4%
Equity securities
Level 3 assets $ 9,358 $ 8,856
Multiples 0.5x to 36.0x 8.6x 0.5x to 34.3x 8.3x
Discount rate/yield 3.9% to 25.2% 12.6% 5.4% to 38.5% 14.6%
Capitalization rate 4.5% to 10.8% 5.5% 4.0% to 10.8% 5.4%
In the table above:
• Ranges represent the significant unobservable inputs that
were used in the valuation of each type of investment.
• Weighted averages are calculated by weighting each input
by the relative fair value of the investment.
• The ranges and weighted averages of these inputs are not
representative of the appropriate inputs to use when
calculating the fair value of any one investment. For
example, the highest multiple for private equity securities is
appropriate for valuing a specific private equity security
but may not be appropriate for valuing any other private
equity security. Accordingly, the ranges of inputs do not
represent uncertainty in, or possible ranges of, fair value
measurements of level 3 investments.
• Increases in yield, discount rate, capitalization rate or
duration used in the valuation of level 3 investments would
have resulted in a lower fair value measurement, while
increases in recovery rate or multiples would have resulted
in a higher fair value measurement as of both September
2023 and December 2022. Due to the distinctive nature of
each level 3 investment, the interrelationship of inputs is
not necessarily uniform within each product type.
• Corporate debt securities, securities backed by real estate
and other debt obligations are valued using discounted cash
flows, and equity securities are valued using market
comparables and discounted cash flows.
• The fair value of any one instrument may be determined
using multiple valuation techniques. For example, market
comparables and discounted cash flows may be used
together to determine fair value. Therefore, the level 3
balance encompasses both of these techniques.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
25 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 27 of 205 --

Level 3 Rollforward. The table below presents a summary
of the changes in fair value for level 3 investments.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Beginning balance $ 18,128 $ 16,109 $ 16,942 $ 13,902
Net realized gains/(losses) 113 103 344 428
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (346) (407) (904) (1,828)
Purchases 213 445 755 1,385
Sales (111) (236) (621) (741)
Settlements (456) (272) (1,127) (1,461)
Transfers into level 3 942 1,687 3,257 6,425
Transfers out of level 3 (1,154) (475) (1,317) (1,156)
Ending balance $ 17,329 $ 16,954 $ 17,329 $ 16,954
In the table above:
• Changes in fair value are presented for all investments that
are classified in level 3 as of the end of the period.
• Net unrealized gains/(losses) relates to investments that
were still held at period-end.
• Transfers between levels of the fair value hierarchy are
reported at the beginning of the reporting period in which
they occur. If an investment was transferred to level 3
during a reporting period, its entire gain or loss for the
period is classified in level 3.
• For level 3 investments, increases are shown as positive
amounts, while decreases are shown as negative amounts.
The table below presents information, by product type, for
investments included in the summary table above.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Corporate debt securities
Beginning balance $ 7,520 $ 6,576 $ 7,003 $ 4,527
Net realized gains/(losses) 88 69 301 224
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (66) (111) (54) (297)
Purchases 58 137 373 624
Sales (53) (78) (185) (151)
Settlements (274) (143) (735) (810)
Transfers into level 3 415 659 1,049 2,944
Transfers out of level 3 (738) (371) (802) (323)
Ending balance $ 6,950 $ 6,738 $ 6,950 $ 6,738
Securities backed by real estate
Beginning balance $ 878 $ 1,067 $ 827 $ 1,078
Net realized gains/(losses) 1 7 10 21
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (95) (88) (191) (287)
Purchases 7 17 56 76
Sales – (47) (58) (96)
Settlements (19) (23) (38) (140)
Transfers into level 3 – 1 171 269
Transfers out of level 3 – (22) (5) (9)
Ending balance $ 772 $ 912 $ 772 $ 912
Other debt obligations
Beginning balance $ 246 $ 303 $ 256 $ 382
Net realized gains/(losses) 1 3 3 9
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 3 (3) 2 (8)
Purchases 6 4 1 28
Settlements (7) (23) (13) (127)
Ending balance $ 249 $ 284 $ 249 $ 284
Equity securities
Beginning balance $ 9,484 $ 8,163 $ 8,856 $ 7,915
Net realized gains/(losses) 23 24 30 174
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (188) (205) (661) (1,236)
Purchases 142 287 325 657
Sales (58) (111) (378) (494)
Settlements (156) (83) (341) (384)
Transfers into level 3 527 1,027 2,037 3,212
Transfers out of level 3 (416) (82) (510) (824)
Ending balance $ 9,358 $ 9,020 $ 9,358 $ 9,020
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Three Months
Ended September 2023. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 investments of $233 million (reflecting $113
million of net realized gains and $346 million of net
unrealized losses) for the three months ended September 2023
included gains/(losses) of $(385) million reported in other
principal transactions and $152 million reported in interest
income.
The net unrealized losses on level 3 investments for the three
months ended September 2023 primarily reflected losses on
certain equity securities and securities backed by real estate
(in each case, principally driven by commercial real estate
investments).
Transfers into level 3 investments during the three months
ended September 2023 primarily reflected transfers of certain
equity securities and corporate debt securities from level 2 (in
each case, principally due to reduced price transparency as a
result of a lack of market evidence, including fewer market
transactions in these instruments).
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 26

-- 28 of 205 --

Transfers out of level 3 investments during the three months
ended September 2023 primarily reflected transfers of certain
corporate debt securities and equity securities to level 2 (in
each case, principally due to increased price transparency as a
result of market evidence, including market transactions in
these instruments).
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Nine Months
Ended September 2023. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 investments of $560 million (reflecting
$344 million of net realized gains and $904 million of net
unrealized losses) for the nine months ended September 2023
included gains/(losses) of $(1.03) billion reported in other
principal transactions and $470 million reported in interest
income.
The net unrealized losses on level 3 investments for the nine
months ended September 2023 primarily reflected losses on
certain equity securities and securities backed by real estate
(in each case, principally driven by commercial real estate
investments).
Transfers into level 3 investments during the nine months
ended September 2023 primarily reflected transfers of certain
equity securities and corporate debt securities from level 2 (in
each case, principally due to reduced price transparency as a
result of a lack of market evidence, including fewer market
transactions in these instruments, and certain unobservable
yield inputs becoming significant to the valuation of these
instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 investments during the nine months
ended September 2023 primarily reflected transfers of certain
corporate debt securities to level 2 (principally due to
increased price transparency as a result of market evidence,
including market transactions in these instruments, and
certain unobservable yield and duration inputs becoming less
significant to the valuation of these instruments) and
transfers of certain equity securities to level 2 (principally due
to increased price transparency as a result of market
evidence, including market transactions in these instruments).
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Three Months
Ended September 2022. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 investments of $304 million (reflecting
$103 million of net realized gains and $407 million of net
unrealized losses) for the three months ended September 2022
included gains/(losses) of $(427) million reported in other
principal transactions and $123 million reported in interest
income.
The net unrealized losses on level 3 investments for the three
months ended September 2022 primarily reflected losses on
certain equity securities and corporate debt securities (in each
case, principally driven by broad macroeconomic concerns).
Transfers into level 3 investments during the three months
ended September 2022 primarily reflected transfers of certain
equity securities from level 2 (principally due to reduced price
transparency as a result of a lack of market evidence,
including fewer market transactions in these instruments) and
transfers of certain corporate debt securities from level 2
(principally due to reduced price transparency as a result of a
lack of market evidence, including fewer market transactions
in these instruments, and certain unobservable yield and
duration inputs becoming significant to the valuation of these
instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 investments during the three months
ended September 2022 primarily reflected transfers of certain
corporate debt securities to level 2 (principally due to certain
unobservable yield and duration inputs no longer being
significant to the valuation of these instruments).
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Nine Months
Ended September 2022. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 investments of $1.40 billion (reflecting
$428 million of net realized gains and $1.83 billion of net
unrealized losses) for the nine months ended September 2022
included gains/(losses) of $(1.71) billion reported in other
principal transactions and $314 million reported in interest
income.
The net unrealized losses on level 3 investments for the nine
months ended September 2022 primarily reflected losses on
certain equity securities and corporate debt securities (in each
case, principally driven by broad macroeconomic and
geopolitical concerns) and securities backed by real estate
(principally driven by an increase in interest rates).
Transfers into level 3 investments during the nine months
ended September 2022 primarily reflected transfers of certain
equity securities from level 2 (principally due to reduced price
transparency as a result of a lack of market evidence,
including fewer market transactions in these instruments),
and transfers of certain corporate debt securities from level 2
(principally due to certain unobservable yield and duration
inputs becoming significant to the valuation of these
instruments, and reduced price transparency as a result of a
lack of market evidence, including fewer market transactions
in these instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 investments during the nine months
ended September 2022 primarily reflected transfers of certain
equity securities to level 2 (principally due to increased price
transparency as a result of market evidence, including market
transactions in these instruments) and transfers of certain
corporate debt securities to level 2 (principally due to
increased price transparency as a result of market evidence,
including market transactions in these instruments, and
certain unobservable yield and duration inputs no longer
being significant to the valuation of these instruments).
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
27 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 29 of 205 --

Loans
Fair Value by Level. The table below presents loans held
for investment accounted for at fair value under the fair value
option by level within the fair value hierarchy.
$ in millions Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total
As of September 2023
Loan Type
Corporate $ – $ 440 $ 431 $ 871
Real estate:
Commercial – 281 270 551
Residential – 3,977 51 4,028
Other collateralized – 708 142 850
Other – 70 78 148
Total $ – $ 5,476 $ 972 $ 6,448
As of December 2022
Loan Type
Corporate $ – $ 359 $ 637 $ 996
Real estate:
Commercial – 435 711 1,146
Residential – 4,437 74 4,511
Other collateralized – 576 140 716
Other – 11 275 286
Total $ – $ 5,818 $ 1,837 $ 7,655
The gains/(losses) as a result of changes in the fair value of
loans held for investment for which the fair value option was
elected were $(170) million for the three months ended
September 2023, $(168) million for the three months ended
September 2022, $(207) million for the nine months ended
September 2023 and $(363) million for the nine months ended
September 2022. These gains/(losses) were included in other
principal transactions.
Significant Unobservable Inputs. The table below
presents the amount of level 3 loans, and ranges and weighted
averages of significant unobservable inputs used to value such
loans.
As of September 2023 As of December 2022
$ in millions
Amount or
Range
Weighted
Average
Amount or
Range
Weighted
Average
Corporate
Level 3 assets $ 431 $ 637
Yield 8.8% to 12.8% 9.3% 4.1% to 26.9% 9.6%
Recovery rate 2.0% to 95.0% 60.0% 23.1% to 95.0% 66.0%
Duration (years) 0.9 to 4.3 2.3 1.6 to 3.3 2.6
Real estate
Level 3 assets $ 321 $ 785
Yield 5.0% to 20.5% 17.6% 3.0% to 27.0% 16.1%
Recovery rate 4.2% to 99.2% 50.1% 3.6% to 66.2% 54.4%
Duration (years) 0.2 to 6.2 1.8 0.6 to 6.7 2.5
Other collateralized
Level 3 assets $ 142 $ 140
Yield 6.6% to 20.9% 9.8% 5.8% to 12.7% 7.7%
Duration (years) 1.8 to 2.2 1.9 2.5 to 2.9 2.7
Other
Level 3 assets $ 78 $ 275
Yield 9.4% to 15.4% 11.8% 9.4% to 10.0% 9.9%
Duration (years) 2.8 to 5.3 3.8 N/A N/A
In the table above:
• Ranges represent the significant unobservable inputs that
were used in the valuation of each type of loan.
• Weighted averages are calculated by weighting each input
by the relative fair value of the loan.
• The ranges and weighted averages of these inputs are not
representative of the appropriate inputs to use when
calculating the fair value of any one loan. For example, the
highest yield for real estate loans is appropriate for valuing
a specific real estate loan but may not be appropriate for
valuing any other real estate loan. Accordingly, the ranges
of inputs do not represent uncertainty in, or possible ranges
of, fair value measurements of level 3 loans.
• Increases in yield or duration used in the valuation of level
3 loans would have resulted in a lower fair value
measurement, while increases in recovery rate would have
resulted in a higher fair value measurement as of both
September 2023 and December 2022. Due to the distinctive
nature of each level 3 loan, the interrelationship of inputs is
not necessarily uniform within each product type.
• Loans are valued using discounted cash flows.
• The significant unobservable inputs for duration related to
other loans as of December 2022 did not have a range (and
there was no weighted average) as it related to a purchased
portfolio of revolving loans with a single duration.
Level 3 Rollforward. The table below presents a summary
of the changes in fair value for level 3 loans.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Beginning balance $ 1,251 $ 2,347 $ 1,837 $ 2,354
Net realized gains/(losses) 11 17 39 89
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (174) (89) (254) (217)
Purchases 6 7 86 212
Sales (5) (18) (462) (61)
Settlements (95) (156) (254) (429)
Transfers into level 3 – 141 – 272
Transfers out of level 3 (22) (191) (20) (162)
Ending balance $ 972 $ 2,058 $ 972 $ 2,058
In the table above:
• Changes in fair value are presented for loans that are
classified in level 3 as of the end of the period.
• Net unrealized gains/(losses) relates to loans that were still
held at period-end.
• Purchases includes originations and secondary purchases.
• Transfers between levels of the fair value hierarchy are
reported at the beginning of the reporting period in which
they occur. If a loan was transferred to level 3 during a
reporting period, its entire gain or loss for the period is
classified in level 3.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 28

-- 30 of 205 --

The table below presents information, by loan type, for loans
included in the summary table above.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Corporate
Beginning balance $ 543 $ 738 $ 637 $ 672
Net realized gains/(losses) 7 8 20 21
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (76) (10) (134) (30)
Purchases 5 7 47 119
Sales – (18) (47) (53)
Settlements (26) (77) (72) (116)
Transfers into level 3 – 39 – 65
Transfers out of level 3 (22) (19) (20) (10)
Ending balance $ 431 $ 668 $ 431 $ 668
Real estate
Beginning balance $ 490 $ 1,007 $ 785 $ 1,188
Net realized gains/(losses) 2 7 9 47
Net unrealized gains/(losses) (100) (79) (123) (167)
Purchases 1 – 2 73
Sales (5) – (196) (8)
Settlements (67) (70) (156) (249)
Transfers into level 3 – 100 – 128
Transfers out of level 3 – (25) – (72)
Ending balance $ 321 $ 940 $ 321 $ 940
Other collateralized
Beginning balance $ 140 $ 285 $ 140 $ 229
Net realized gains/(losses) 1 1 3 2
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 1 – – (1)
Purchases – – 2 2
Settlements – (1) (3) (26)
Transfers into level 3 – 2 – 13
Transfers out of level 3 – (147) – (79)
Ending balance $ 142 $ 140 $ 142 $ 140
Other
Beginning balance $ 78 $ 317 $ 275 $ 265
Net realized gains/(losses) 1 1 7 19
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 1 – 3 (19)
Purchases – – 35 18
Sales – – (219) –
Settlements (2) (8) (23) (38)
Transfers into level 3 – – – 66
Transfers out of level 3 – – – (1)
Ending balance $ 78 $ 310 $ 78 $ 310
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Three Months
Ended September 2023. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 loans of $163 million (reflecting $11 million
of net realized gains and $174 million of net unrealized losses)
for the three months ended September 2023 included gains/
(losses) of $(172) million reported in other principal
transactions and $9 million reported in interest income.
The net unrealized losses on level 3 loans for the three
months ended September 2023 primarily reflected losses on
certain loans backed by real estate (principally driven by
commercial real estate loans) and corporate loans (principally
driven by company-specific events).
There were no transfers into level 3 loans during the three
months ended September 2023.
The drivers of transfers out of level 3 loans during the three
months ended September 2023 were not material.
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Nine Months
Ended September 2023. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 loans of $215 million (reflecting $39 million
of net realized gains and $254 million of net unrealized losses)
for the nine months ended September 2023 included gains/
(losses) of $(237) million reported in other principal
transactions and $22 million reported in interest income.
The net unrealized losses on level 3 loans for the nine months
ended September 2023 primarily reflected losses on certain
corporate loans (principally driven by company-specific
events) and loans backed by real estate (principally driven by
commercial real estate loans).
There were no transfers into level 3 loans during the nine
months ended September 2023.
The drivers of transfers out of level 3 loans during the nine
months ended September 2023 were not material.
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Three Months
Ended September 2022. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 loans of $72 million (reflecting $17 million of
net realized gains and $89 million of net unrealized losses) for
the three months ended September 2022 included gains/
(losses) of $(83) million reported in other principal
transactions and $11 million reported in interest income.
The drivers of net unrealized losses on level 3 loans for the
three months ended September 2022 were not material.
Transfers into level 3 loans during the three months ended
September 2022 primarily reflected transfers of certain loans
backed by real estate from level 2 (principally due to reduced
price transparency as a result of a lack of market evidence,
including fewer market transactions in these instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 loans during the three months ended
September 2022 primarily reflected transfers of certain other
collateralized loans to level 2 (principally due to certain
unobservable yield inputs no longer being significant to the
valuation of these instruments).
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Nine Months
Ended September 2022. The net realized and unrealized
losses on level 3 loans of $128 million (reflecting $89 million
of net realized gains and $217 million of net unrealized losses)
for the nine months ended September 2022 included gains/
(losses) of $(148) million reported in other principal
transactions and $20 million reported in interest income.
The net unrealized losses on level 3 loans for the nine months
ended September 2022 primarily reflected losses on certain
loans backed by real estate (principally due to the impact of
an increase in interest rates).
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
29 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 31 of 205 --

Transfers into level 3 loans during the nine months ended
September 2022 primarily reflected transfers of certain loans
backed by real estate from level 2 (principally due to reduced
price transparency as a result of a lack of market evidence,
including fewer market transactions in these instruments).
The drivers of transfers out of level 3 loans during the nine
months ended September 2022 were not material.
Other Financial Assets and Liabilities
Fair Value by Level. The table below presents, by level
within the fair value hierarchy, other financial assets and
liabilities at fair value, substantially all of which are
accounted for at fair value under the fair value option.
$ in millions Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total
As of September 2023
Assets
Resale agreements $ – $ 190,446 $ – $ 190,446
Securities borrowed – 36,792 – 36,792
Customer and other receivables – 23 – 23
Other assets – 173 151 324
Total $ – $ 227,434 $ 151 $ 227,585
Liabilities
Deposits $ – $ (25,831) $ (2,726) $ (28,557)
Repurchase agreements – (225,679) – (225,679)
Securities loaned – (8,178) – (8,178)
Other secured financings – (11,380) (2,734) (14,114)
Unsecured borrowings:
Short-term – (38,056) (4,295) (42,351)
Long-term – (60,580) (13,336) (73,916)
Other liabilities – (395) (219) (614)
Total $ – $ (370,099) $ (23,310) $(393,409)
As of December 2022
Assets
Resale agreements $ – $ 225,117 $ – $ 225,117
Securities borrowed – 38,578 – 38,578
Customer and other receivables – 25 – 25
Other assets – 71 74 145
Total $ – $ 263,791 $ 74 $ 263,865
Liabilities
Deposits $ – $ (13,003) $ (2,743) $ (15,746)
Repurchase agreements – (110,349) – (110,349)
Securities loaned – (4,372) – (4,372)
Other secured financings – (10,914) (1,842) (12,756)
Unsecured borrowings:
Short-term – (35,641) (4,090) (39,731)
Long-term – (63,081) (10,066) (73,147)
Other liabilities – (74) (85) (159)
Total $ – $ (237,434) $ (18,826) $ (256,260)
In the table above, assets are shown as positive amounts and
liabilities are shown as negative amounts.
See Note 4 for an overview of the firm’s fair value
measurement policies, valuation techniques and significant
inputs used to determine the fair value of other financial
assets and liabilities.
Significant Unobservable Inputs. See below for
information about the significant unobservable inputs used to
value level 3 other financial liabilities at fair value as of both
September 2023 and December 2022.
Other Secured Financings. The ranges and weighted
averages of significant unobservable inputs used to value level
3 other secured financings are presented below. These ranges
and weighted averages exclude unobservable inputs that are
only relevant to a single instrument, and therefore are not
meaningful.
As of September 2023:
• Yield: 6.8% to 13.3% (weighted average: 9.0%)
• Duration: 0.4 to 5.8 years (weighted average: 1.4 years)
As of December 2022:
• Yield: 4.5% to 9.4% (weighted average: 5.9%)
• Duration: 0.6 to 5.1 years (weighted average: 2.2 years)
Generally, increases in yield or duration, in isolation, would
have resulted in a lower fair value measurement as of period-
end. Due to the distinctive nature of each of level 3 other
secured financings, the interrelationship of inputs is not
necessarily uniform across such financings. See Note 11 for
further information about other secured financings.
Deposits, Unsecured Borrowings and Other Assets
and Liabilities. Substantially all of the firm’s deposits,
unsecured short- and long-term borrowings, and other assets
and liabilities that are classified in level 3 are hybrid financial
instruments. As the significant unobservable inputs used to
value hybrid financial instruments primarily relate to the
embedded derivative component of these deposits, unsecured
borrowings and other assets and liabilities, these
unobservable inputs are incorporated in the firm’s derivative
disclosures. See Note 12 for further information about other
assets, Note 13 for further information about deposits, Note
14 for further information about unsecured borrowings and
Note 15 for further information about other liabilities.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 30

-- 32 of 205 --

Level 3 Rollforward. The table below presents a summary
of the changes in fair value for level 3 other financial assets
and liabilities accounted for at fair value.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Assets
Beginning balance $ 126 $ – $ 74 $ –
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 25 – 77 –
Ending balance $ 151 $ – $ 151 $ –
Liabilities
Beginning balance $ (21,897) $ (19,114) $ (18,826) $ (23,567)
Net realized gains/(losses) (88) (90) (223) (222)
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 1,210 1,538 425 5,977
Issuances (3,036) (3,296) (6,212) (9,486)
Settlements 3,154 2,691 6,380 8,548
Transfers into level 3 (3,656) (1,494) (6,030) (2,562)
Transfers out of level 3 1,003 900 1,176 2,447
Ending balance $ (23,310) $ (18,865) $ (23,310) $ (18,865)
In the table above:
• Changes in fair value are presented for all other financial
assets and liabilities that are classified in level 3 as of the
end of the period.
• Net unrealized gains/(losses) relates to other financial
assets and liabilities that were still held at period-end.
• Transfers between levels of the fair value hierarchy are
reported at the beginning of the reporting period in which
they occur. If a financial instrument was transferred to
level 3 during a reporting period, its entire gain or loss for
the period is classified in level 3.
• For level 3 other financial assets, increases are shown as
positive amounts, while decreases are shown as negative
amounts. For level 3 other financial liabilities, increases are
shown as negative amounts, while decreases are shown as
positive amounts.
• Level 3 other financial assets and liabilities are frequently
economically hedged with trading assets and liabilities.
Accordingly, gains or losses that are classified in level 3 can
be partially offset by gains or losses attributable to level 1,
2 or 3 trading assets and liabilities. As a result, gains or
losses included in the level 3 rollforward below do not
necessarily represent the overall impact on the firm’s
results of operations, liquidity or capital resources.
The table below presents information, by the consolidated
balance sheet line items, for liabilities included in the
summary table above.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Deposits
Beginning balance $ (2,889) $ (2,789) $ (2,743) $ (3,613)
Net realized gains/(losses) – – – (7)
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 73 135 19 466
Issuances (157) (261) (376) (735)
Settlements 232 259 594 1,041
Transfers into level 3 (3) (89) (254) (20)
Transfers out of level 3 18 16 34 139
Ending balance $ (2,726) $ (2,729) $ (2,726) $ (2,729)
Other secured financings
Beginning balance $ (2,817) $ (1,412) $ (1,842) $ (2,566)
Net realized gains/(losses) (3) (13) (3) (18)
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 41 86 13 177
Issuances (158) (406) (676) (545)
Settlements 488 22 875 527
Transfers into level 3 (325) (147) (1,626) (110)
Transfers out of level 3 40 – 525 665
Ending balance $ (2,734) $ (1,870) $ (2,734) $ (1,870)
Unsecured short-term borrowings
Beginning balance $ (4,822) $ (5,209) $ (4,090) $ (7,829)
Net realized gains/(losses) (23) (54) (72) (126)
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 148 286 (178) 1,241
Issuances (1,552) (1,165) (2,968) (3,582)
Settlements 1,853 1,747 3,013 5,443
Transfers into level 3 (204) (528) (174) (470)
Transfers out of level 3 305 411 174 811
Ending balance $ (4,295) $ (4,512) $ (4,295) $ (4,512)
Unsecured long-term borrowings
Beginning balance $ (11,296) $ (9,626) $ (10,066) $ (9,413)
Net realized gains/(losses) (62) (23) (148) (71)
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 945 1,034 556 4,028
Issuances (1,020) (1,464) (2,043) (4,624)
Settlements 581 663 1,898 1,537
Transfers into level 3 (3,124) (730) (3,976) (1,962)
Transfers out of level 3 640 473 443 832
Ending balance $ (13,336) $ (9,673) $ (13,336) $ (9,673)
Other liabilities
Beginning balance $ (73) $ (78) $ (85) $ (146)
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 3 (3) 15 65
Issuances (149) – (149) –
Ending balance $ (219) $ (81) $ (219) $ (81)
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Three Months
Ended September 2023. The net realized and unrealized
gains on level 3 other financial liabilities of $1.12 billion
(reflecting $88 million of net realized losses and $1.21 billion
of net unrealized gains) for the three months ended
September 2023 included gains/(losses) of $1.15 billion
reported in market making, $16 million reported in other
principal transactions and $(4) million reported in interest
expense in the consolidated statements of earnings, and $(44)
million reported in debt valuation adjustment in the
consolidated statements of comprehensive income.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
31 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 33 of 205 --

The net unrealized gains on level 3 other financial liabilities
for the three months ended September 2023 primarily
reflected gains on certain hybrid financial instruments
included in unsecured long-term borrowings (principally due
to an increase in interest rates and a decrease in equity
prices).
Transfers into level 3 other financial liabilities during the
three months ended September 2023 primarily reflected
transfers of certain hybrid financial instruments included in
unsecured long-term borrowings from level 2 (principally due
to reduced price transparency of certain credit spread inputs
used to value these instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 other financial liabilities during the
three months ended September 2023 primarily reflected
transfers of certain hybrid financial instruments included in
unsecured long- and short-term borrowings to level 2
(principally due to increased price transparency of certain
volatility inputs used to value these instruments).
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Nine Months
Ended September 2023. The net realized and unrealized
gains on level 3 other financial liabilities of $202 million
(reflecting $223 million of net realized losses and $425 million
of net unrealized gains) for the nine months ended September
2023 included gains/(losses) of $415 million reported in
market making, $4 million reported in other principal
transactions and $(12) million reported in interest expense in
the consolidated statements of earnings, and $(205) million
reported in debt valuation adjustment in the consolidated
statements of comprehensive income.
The net unrealized gains on level 3 other financial liabilities
for the nine months ended September 2023 primarily reflected
gains on certain hybrid financial instruments included in
unsecured long-term borrowings (principally due to an
increase in interest rates), partially offset by losses on certain
hybrid financial instruments included in unsecured short-
term borrowings (principally due to an increase in equity
prices).
Transfers into level 3 other financial liabilities during the
nine months ended September 2023 primarily reflected
transfers of certain hybrid financial instruments included in
unsecured long-term borrowings from level 2 (principally due
to reduced price transparency of certain credit spread and
volatility inputs used to value these instruments) and
transfers of certain other secured financings from level 2
(principally due to reduced price transparency of certain yield
and duration inputs used to value these instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 other financial liabilities during the
nine months ended September 2023 primarily reflected
transfers of certain hybrid financial instruments included in
other secured financings to level 2 (principally due to
increased price transparency of certain yield and duration
inputs used to value these instruments) and transfers of
certain unsecured long- and short-term borrowings to level 2
(principally due to increased price transparency of certain
volatility inputs used to value these instruments).
Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Three Months
Ended September 2022. The net realized and unrealized
gains on level 3 other financial liabilities of $1.45 billion
(reflecting $90 million of net realized losses and $1.54 billion
of net unrealized gains) for the three months ended
September 2022 included gains/(losses) of $1.13 billion
reported in market making, $69 million reported in other
principal transactions and $(7) million reported in interest
expense in the consolidated statements of earnings, and
$262 million reported in debt valuation adjustment in the
consolidated statements of comprehensive income.
The net unrealized gains on level 3 other financial liabilities
for the three months ended September 2022 primarily
reflected gains on certain hybrid financial instruments
included in unsecured long- and short-term borrowings
(principally due to a decrease in global equity prices and an
increase in interest rates).
Transfers into level 3 other financial liabilities during the
three months ended September 2022 primarily reflected
transfers of certain hybrid financial instruments included in
unsecured long- and short-term borrowings from level 2
(principally due to reduced price transparency of certain
volatility and correlation inputs used to value these
instruments) and transfers of certain other secured financings
from level 2 (principally due to reduced price transparency of
certain yield and duration inputs used to value these
instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 other financial liabilities during the
three months ended September 2022 primarily reflected
transfers of certain hybrid financial instruments included in
unsecured long- and short-term borrowings to level 2
(principally due to increased price transparency of certain
volatility and correlation inputs used to value these
instruments).
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 32

-- 34 of 205 --

Level 3 Rollforward Commentary for the Nine Months
Ended September 2022. The net realized and unrealized
gains on level 3 other financial liabilities of $5.76 billion
(reflecting $222 million of net realized losses and $5.98 billion
of net unrealized gains) for the nine months ended September
2022 included gains/(losses) of $4.69 billion reported in
market making, $155 million reported in other principal
transactions and $(14) million reported in interest expense in
the consolidated statements of earnings, and $924 million
reported in debt valuation adjustment in the consolidated
statements of comprehensive income.
The net unrealized gains on level 3 other financial liabilities
for the nine months ended September 2022 primarily reflected
gains on certain hybrid financial instruments included in
unsecured long- and short-term borrowings and deposits (in
each case, principally due to a decrease in global equity prices
and an increase in interest rates).
Transfers into level 3 other financial liabilities during the
nine months ended September 2022 primarily reflected
transfers of certain hybrid financial instruments included in
unsecured long- and short-term borrowings from level 2
(principally due to reduced price transparency of certain
volatility and correlation inputs used to value these
instruments).
Transfers out of level 3 other financial liabilities during the
nine months ended September 2022 primarily reflected
transfers of certain hybrid financial instruments included in
unsecured short- and long-term borrowings to level 2
(principally due to increased price transparency of certain
volatility and correlation inputs used to value these
instruments) and transfers of certain other secured financings
to level 2 (principally due to certain unobservable yield inputs
no longer being significant to the valuation of these
instruments).
Note 6.
Trading Assets and Liabilities
Trading assets and liabilities include trading cash instruments
and derivatives held in connection with the firm’s market-
making or risk management activities. These assets and
liabilities are carried at fair value either under the fair value
option or in accordance with other U.S. GAAP, and the
related fair value gains and losses are generally recognized in
the consolidated statements of earnings.
The table below presents a summary of trading assets and
liabilities.
Trading Trading
$ in millions Assets Liabilities
As of September 2023
Trading cash instruments $ 398,998 $ 140,306
Derivatives 49,062 54,817
Total $ 448,060 $ 195,123
As of December 2022
Trading cash instruments $ 241,832 $ 136,589
Derivatives 59,413 54,735
Total $ 301,245 $ 191,324
See Note 5 for further information about trading cash
instruments and Note 7 for further information about
derivatives.
Gains and Losses from Market Making
The table below presents market making revenues by major
product type.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Interest rates $ (861) $ (3,043) $ 713 $ (7,699)
Credit 511 (286) 1,160 1,379
Currencies 2,850 5,768 4,946 14,020
Equities 2,029 1,464 6,008 6,052
Commodities 429 738 1,915 1,831
Total $ 4,958 $ 4,641 $ 14,742 $ 15,583
In the table above:
• Gains/(losses) include both realized and unrealized gains
and losses. Gains/(losses) exclude related interest income
and interest expense. See Note 23 for further information
about interest income and interest expense.
• Gains/(losses) included in market making are primarily
related to the firm’s trading assets and liabilities, including
both derivative and non-derivative financial instruments.
• Gains/(losses) are not representative of the manner in
which the firm manages its business activities because
many of the firm’s market-making and client facilitation
strategies utilize financial instruments across various
product types. Accordingly, gains or losses in one product
type frequently offset gains or losses in other product types.
For example, most of the firm’s longer-term derivatives
across product types are sensitive to changes in interest
rates and may be economically hedged with interest rate
swaps. Similarly, a significant portion of the firm’s trading
cash instruments and derivatives across product types has
exposure to foreign currencies and may be economically
hedged with foreign currency contracts.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
33 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 35 of 205 --

Note 7.
Derivatives and Hedging Activities
Derivative Activities
Derivatives are instruments that derive their value from
underlying asset prices, indices, reference rates and other
inputs, or a combination of these factors. Derivatives may be
traded on an exchange (exchange-traded) or they may be
privately negotiated contracts, which are usually referred to
as OTC derivatives. Certain of the firm’s OTC derivatives
are cleared and settled through central clearing
counterparties (OTC-cleared), while others are bilateral
contracts between two counterparties (bilateral OTC).
Market Making. As a market maker, the firm enters into
derivative transactions to provide liquidity to clients and to
facilitate the transfer and hedging of their risks. In this role,
the firm typically acts as principal and is required to commit
capital to provide execution, and maintains market-making
positions in response to, or in anticipation of, client demand.
Risk Management. The firm also enters into derivatives to
actively manage risk exposures that arise from its market-
making and investing and financing activities. The firm’s
holdings and exposures are hedged, in many cases, on either a
portfolio or risk-specific basis, as opposed to an instrument-
by-instrument basis. The offsetting impact of this economic
hedging is reflected in the same business segment as the
related revenues. In addition, the firm may enter into
derivatives designated as hedges under U.S. GAAP. These
derivatives are used to manage interest rate exposure of
certain fixed-rate unsecured borrowings and deposits and
certain U.S. and non-U.S. government securities classified as
available-for-sale, foreign exchange risk of certain available-
for-sale securities and the net investment in certain non-U.S.
operations.
The firm enters into various types of derivatives, including:
• Futures and Forwards. Contracts that commit
counterparties to purchase or sell financial instruments,
commodities or currencies in the future.
• Swaps. Contracts that require counterparties to exchange
cash flows, such as currency or interest payment streams.
The amounts exchanged are based on the specific terms of
the contract with reference to specified rates, financial
instruments, commodities, currencies or indices.
• Options. Contracts in which the option purchaser has the
right, but not the obligation, to purchase from or sell to the
option writer financial instruments, commodities or
currencies within a defined time period for a specified
price.
Derivatives are reported on a net-by-counterparty basis (i.e.,
the net payable or receivable for derivative assets and
liabilities for a given counterparty) when a legal right of
setoff exists under an enforceable netting agreement
(counterparty netting). Derivatives are accounted for at fair
value, net of cash collateral received or posted under
enforceable credit support agreements (cash collateral
netting). Derivative assets are included in trading assets and
derivative liabilities are included in trading liabilities.
Realized and unrealized gains and losses on derivatives not
designated as hedges are included in market making (for
derivatives included in Fixed Income, Currency and
Commodities (FICC) and Equities within Global Banking &
Markets), and other principal transactions (for derivatives
included in Investment banking fees and Other within Global
Banking & Markets, as well as derivatives in Asset & Wealth
Management) in the consolidated statements of earnings. For
each of the three and nine months ended September 2023 and
September 2022, substantially all of the firm’s derivatives
were included in Global Banking & Markets.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 34

-- 36 of 205 --

The tables below present the gross fair value and the notional
amounts of derivative contracts by major product type, the
amounts of counterparty and cash collateral netting in the
consolidated balance sheets, as well as cash and securities
collateral posted and received under enforceable credit
support agreements that do not meet the criteria for netting
under U.S. GAAP.
As of September 2023 As of December 2022
$ in millions
Derivative
Assets
Derivative
Liabilities
Derivative
Assets
Derivative
Liabilities
Not accounted for as hedges
Exchange-traded $ 466 $ 1,122 $ 675 $ 1,385
OTC-cleared 71,438 70,138 74,297 72,979
Bilateral OTC 192,603 170,748 195,052 174,687
Total interest rates 264,507 242,008 270,024 249,051
OTC-cleared 1,056 1,177 1,516 1,802
Bilateral OTC 11,593 9,123 10,751 9,478
Total credit 12,649 10,300 12,267 11,280
Exchange-traded 78 11 1,041 22
OTC-cleared 1,064 1,021 520 589
Bilateral OTC 100,357 100,324 102,301 111,276
Total currencies 101,499 101,356 103,862 111,887
Exchange-traded 6,719 7,275 9,225 9,542
OTC-cleared 539 620 698 838
Bilateral OTC 13,457 11,971 30,017 22,745
Total commodities 20,715 19,866 39,940 33,125
Exchange-traded 24,340 28,860 26,302 26,607
OTC-cleared 133 203 685 19
Bilateral OTC 24,503 36,578 23,574 30,157
Total equities 48,976 65,641 50,561 56,783
Subtotal 448,346 439,171 476,654 462,126
Accounted for as hedges
OTC-cleared – – – –
Bilateral OTC 190 18 335 11
Total interest rates 190 18 335 11
OTC-cleared – – 29 29
Bilateral OTC 32 121 53 256
Total currencies 32 121 82 285
Subtotal 222 139 417 296
Total gross fair value $ 448,568 $ 439,310 $ 477,071 $ 462,422
Offset in the consolidated balance sheets
Exchange-traded $ (28,041) $ (28,041) $ (31,229) $ (31,229)
OTC-cleared (71,745) (71,745) (75,349) (75,349)
Bilateral OTC (241,284) (241,284) (254,304) (254,304)
Counterparty netting (341,070) (341,070) (360,882) (360,882)
OTC-cleared (1,728) – (1,388) (406)
Bilateral OTC (56,708) (43,423) (55,388) (46,399)
Cash collateral netting (58,436) (43,423) (56,776) (46,805)
Total amounts offset $ (399,506) $ (384,493) $ (417,658) $ (407,687)
Included in the consolidated balance sheets
Exchange-traded $ 3,562 $ 9,227 $ 6,014 $ 6,327
OTC-cleared 757 1,414 1,008 501
Bilateral OTC 44,743 44,176 52,391 47,907
Total $ 49,062 $ 54,817 $ 59,413 $ 54,735
Not offset in the consolidated balance sheets
Cash collateral $ (414) $ (1,599) $ (298) $ (1,887)
Securities collateral (15,551) (4,716) (15,229) (4,329)
Total $ 33,097 $ 48,502 $ 43,886 $ 48,519
Notional Amounts as of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Not accounted for as hedges
Exchange-traded $ 3,957,145 $ 4,241,937
OTC-cleared 15,047,281 13,104,682
Bilateral OTC 12,296,079 11,137,127
Total interest rates 31,300,505 28,483,746
Exchange-traded 558 369
OTC-cleared 545,342 529,543
Bilateral OTC 651,836 577,542
Total credit 1,197,736 1,107,454
Exchange-traded 5,538 9,012
OTC-cleared 262,313 150,561
Bilateral OTC 6,525,742 5,304,069
Total currencies 6,793,593 5,463,642
Exchange-traded 352,868 341,526
OTC-cleared 3,434 3,188
Bilateral OTC 220,290 255,208
Total commodities 576,592 599,922
Exchange-traded 1,529,392 1,107,659
OTC-cleared 1,716 1,639
Bilateral OTC 1,225,983 1,026,736
Total equities 2,757,091 2,136,034
Subtotal 42,625,517 37,790,798
Accounted for as hedges
OTC-cleared 240,942 257,739
Bilateral OTC 3,009 3,156
Total interest rates 243,951 260,895
OTC-cleared 966 2,048
Bilateral OTC 8,223 7,701
Total currencies 9,189 9,749
Subtotal 253,140 270,644
Total notional amounts $ 42,878,657 $ 38,061,442
In the tables above:
• Gross fair values exclude the effects of both counterparty
netting and collateral, and therefore are not representative
of the firm’s exposure.
• Where the firm has received or posted collateral under
credit support agreements, but has not yet determined such
agreements are enforceable, the related collateral has not
been netted.
• Notional amounts, which represent the sum of gross long
and short derivative contracts, provide an indication of the
volume of the firm’s derivative activity and do not
represent anticipated losses.
• Total gross fair value of derivatives included derivative
assets of $9.70 billion as of September 2023 and $10.08
billion as of December 2022, and derivative liabilities of
$12.57 billion as of September 2023 and $12.71 billion as of
December 2022, which are not subject to an enforceable
netting agreement or are subject to a netting agreement that
the firm has not yet determined to be enforceable.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
35 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 37 of 205 --

OTC Derivatives
The table below presents OTC derivative assets and liabilities
by tenor and major product type.
$ in millions
Less than
1 Year
1 - 5
Years
Greater than
5 Years Total
As of September 2023
Assets
Interest rates $ 10,904 $14,876 $ 53,107 $ 78,887
Credit 1,427 2,968 2,159 6,554
Currencies 14,384 8,130 5,733 28,247
Commodities 4,156 3,417 1,563 9,136
Equities 4,121 2,868 2,068 9,057
Counterparty netting in tenors (3,015) (2,643) (4,165) (9,823)
Subtotal $ 31,977 $29,616 $ 60,465 $ 122,058
Cross-tenor counterparty netting (18,122)
Cash collateral netting (58,436)
Total OTC derivative assets $ 45,500
Liabilities
Interest rates $ 10,600 $22,287 $ 22,672 $ 55,559
Credit 879 2,277 1,050 4,206
Currencies 12,041 8,607 7,635 28,283
Commodities 3,025 3,305 1,381 7,711
Equities 9,462 8,124 3,613 21,199
Counterparty netting in tenors (3,015) (2,643) (4,165) (9,823)
Subtotal $ 32,992 $41,957 $ 32,186 $ 107,135
Cross-tenor counterparty netting (18,122)
Cash collateral netting (43,423)
Total OTC derivative liabilities $ 45,590
As of December 2022
Assets
Interest rates $ 5,509 $ 16,963 $ 53,943 $ 76,415
Credit 921 2,622 2,142 5,685
Currencies 12,284 7,819 7,085 27,188
Commodities 10,525 7,513 2,574 20,612
Equities 5,346 4,007 1,782 11,135
Counterparty netting in tenors (2,661) (3,942) (4,830) (11,433)
Subtotal $ 31,924 $ 34,982 $ 62,696 $129,602
Cross-tenor counterparty netting (19,427)
Cash collateral netting (56,776)
Total OTC derivative assets $ 53,399
Liabilities
Interest rates $ 9,351 $ 23,589 $ 21,467 $ 54,407
Credit 993 2,635 1,071 4,699
Currencies 18,987 8,736 8,712 36,435
Commodities 6,400 6,135 945 13,480
Equities 7,629 7,249 2,174 17,052
Counterparty netting in tenors (2,661) (3,942) (4,830) (11,433)
Subtotal $ 40,699 $ 44,402 $ 29,539 $114,640
Cross-tenor counterparty netting (19,427)
Cash collateral netting (46,805)
Total OTC derivative liabilities $ 48,408
In the table above:
• Tenor is based on remaining contractual maturity.
• Counterparty netting within the same product type and
tenor category is included within such product type and
tenor category.
• Counterparty netting across product types within the same
tenor category is included in counterparty netting in tenors.
Where the counterparty netting is across tenor categories,
the netting is included in cross-tenor counterparty netting.
See Note 4 for an overview of the firm’s fair value
measurement policies, valuation techniques and significant
inputs used to determine the fair value of derivatives, and
Note 5 for information about derivatives within the fair value
hierarchy.
Credit Derivatives
The firm enters into a broad array of credit derivatives to
facilitate client transactions and to manage the credit risk
associated with market-making and investing and financing
activities. Credit derivatives are actively managed based on
the firm’s net risk position. Credit derivatives are generally
individually negotiated contracts and can have various
settlement and payment conventions. Credit events include
failure to pay, bankruptcy, acceleration of indebtedness,
restructuring, repudiation and dissolution of the reference
entity.
The firm enters into the following types of credit derivatives:
• Credit Default Swaps. Single-name credit default swaps
protect the buyer against the loss of principal on one or
more bonds, loans or mortgages (reference obligations) in
the event the issuer of the reference obligations suffers a
credit event. The buyer of protection pays an initial or
periodic premium to the seller and receives protection for
the period of the contract. If there is no credit event, as
defined in the contract, the seller of protection makes no
payments to the buyer. If a credit event occurs, the seller of
protection is required to make a payment to the buyer,
calculated according to the terms of the contract.
• Credit Options. In a credit option, the option writer
assumes the obligation to purchase or sell a reference
obligation at a specified price or credit spread. The option
purchaser buys the right, but does not assume the
obligation, to sell the reference obligation to, or purchase it
from, the option writer. The payments on credit options
depend either on a particular credit spread or the price of
the reference obligation.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 36

-- 38 of 205 --

• Credit Indices, Baskets and Tranches. Credit
derivatives may reference a basket of single-name credit
default swaps or a broad-based index. If a credit event
occurs in one of the underlying reference obligations, the
protection seller pays the protection buyer. The payment is
typically a pro-rata portion of the transaction’s total
notional amount based on the underlying defaulted
reference obligation. In certain transactions, the credit risk
of a basket or index is separated into various portions
(tranches), each having different levels of subordination.
The most junior tranches cover initial defaults and once
losses exceed the notional amount of these junior tranches,
any excess loss is covered by the next most senior tranche.
• Total Return Swaps. A total return swap transfers the
risks relating to economic performance of a reference
obligation from the protection buyer to the protection
seller. Typically, the protection buyer receives a floating
rate of interest and protection against any reduction in fair
value of the reference obligation, and the protection seller
receives the cash flows associated with the reference
obligation, plus any increase in the fair value of the
reference obligation.
The firm economically hedges its exposure to written credit
derivatives primarily by entering into offsetting purchased
credit derivatives with identical underliers. Substantially all
of the firm’s purchased credit derivative transactions are with
financial institutions and are subject to stringent collateral
thresholds. In addition, upon the occurrence of a specified
trigger event, the firm may take possession of the reference
obligations underlying a particular written credit derivative,
and consequently may, upon liquidation of the reference
obligations, recover amounts on the underlying reference
obligations in the event of default.
As of September 2023, written credit derivatives had a total
gross notional amount of $565.33 billion and purchased
credit derivatives had a total gross notional amount of
$632.41 billion, for total net notional purchased protection of
$67.08 billion. As of December 2022, written credit
derivatives had a total gross notional amount of $528.31
billion and purchased credit derivatives had a total gross
notional amount of $579.14 billion, for total net notional
purchased protection of $50.83 billion. The firm’s written
and purchased credit derivatives primarily consist of credit
default swaps.
The table below presents information about credit
derivatives.
Credit Spread on Underlier (basis points)
$ in millions 0 - 250
251 -
500
501 -
1,000
Greater
than
1,000 Total
As of September 2023
Maximum Payout/Notional Amount of Written Credit Derivatives by Tenor
Less than 1 year $ 127,828 $ 9,876 $ 885 $ 3,750 $ 142,339
1 - 5 years 308,826 18,554 8,957 6,922 343,259
Greater than 5 years 69,235 6,560 2,883 1,052 79,730
Total $ 505,889 $34,990 $ 12,725 $ 11,724 $ 565,328
Maximum Payout/Notional Amount of Purchased Credit Derivatives
Offsetting $ 420,373 $25,763 $ 11,309 $ 10,175 $ 467,620
Other $ 152,511 $ 8,037 $ 2,189 $ 2,051 $ 164,788
Fair Value of Written Credit Derivatives
Asset $ 8,701 $ 638 $ 262 $ 121 $ 9,722
Liability 1,190 774 633 2,312 4,909
Net asset/(liability) $ 7,511 $ (136) $ (371) $ (2,191) $ 4,813
As of December 2022
Maximum Payout/Notional Amount of Written Credit Derivatives by Tenor
Less than 1 year $ 108,703 $ 12,166 $ 1,879 $ 4,135 $126,883
1 - 5 years 306,484 28,188 13,724 9,092 357,488
Greater than 5 years 39,302 2,916 1,416 305 43,939
Total $ 454,489 $ 43,270 $ 17,019 $ 13,532 $528,310
Maximum Payout/Notional Amount of Purchased Credit Derivatives
Offsetting $ 372,360 $ 33,149 $ 14,817 $ 11,757 $432,083
Other $ 128,828 $ 13,211 $ 2,615 $ 2,407 $147,061
Fair Value of Written Credit Derivatives
Asset $ 5,405 $ 460 $ 132 $ 84 $ 6,081
Liability 681 1,081 1,027 2,673 5,462
Net asset/(liability) $ 4,724 $ (621) $ (895) $ (2,589) $ 619
In the table above:
• Fair values exclude the effects of both netting of receivable
balances with payable balances under enforceable netting
agreements, and netting of cash received or posted under
enforceable credit support agreements, and therefore are
not representative of the firm’s credit exposure.
• Tenor is based on remaining contractual maturity.
• The credit spread on the underlier, together with the tenor
of the contract, are indicators of payment/performance
risk. The firm is less likely to pay or otherwise be required
to perform where the credit spread and the tenor are lower.
• Offsetting purchased credit derivatives represent the
notional amount of purchased credit derivatives that
economically hedge written credit derivatives with identical
underliers.
• Other purchased credit derivatives represent the notional
amount of all other purchased credit derivatives not
included in offsetting.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
37 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 39 of 205 --

Impact of Credit and Funding Spreads on Derivatives
The firm realizes gains or losses on its derivative contracts.
These gains or losses include credit valuation adjustments
(CVA) relating to uncollateralized derivative assets and
liabilities, which represent the gains or losses (including
hedges) attributable to the impact of changes in credit
exposure, counterparty credit spreads, liability funding
spreads (which include the firm’s own credit), probability of
default and assumed recovery. These gains or losses also
include funding valuation adjustments (FVA) relating to
uncollateralized derivative assets, which represent the gains
or losses (including hedges) attributable to the impact of
changes in expected funding exposures and funding spreads.
The table below presents information about CVA and FVA.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
CVA, net of hedges $ 101 $ 223 $ (72) $ 523
FVA, net of hedges (53) (74) 22 (465)
Total $ 48 $ 149 $ (50) $ 58
Bifurcated Embedded Derivatives
The table below presents the fair value and the notional
amount of derivatives that have been bifurcated from their
related borrowings.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Fair value of assets $ 332 $ 288
Fair value of liabilities (271) (392)
Net asset/(liability) $ 61 $ (104)
Notional amount $ 7,383 $ 8,892
In the table above, derivatives that have been bifurcated from
their related borrowings are recorded at fair value and
primarily consist of interest rate, equity and commodity
products. These derivatives are included in unsecured short-
and long-term borrowings, as well as other secured
financings, with the related borrowings.
Derivatives with Credit-Related Contingent Features
Certain of the firm’s derivatives have been transacted under
bilateral agreements with counterparties who may require the
firm to post collateral or terminate the transactions based on
changes in the firm’s credit ratings. The firm assesses the
impact of these bilateral agreements by determining the
collateral or termination payments that would occur
assuming a downgrade by all rating agencies. A downgrade
by any one rating agency, depending on the agency’s relative
ratings of the firm at the time of the downgrade, may have an
impact which is comparable to the impact of a downgrade by
all rating agencies.
The table below presents information about net derivative
liabilities under bilateral agreements (excluding collateral
posted), the fair value of collateral posted and additional
collateral or termination payments that could have been
called by counterparties in the event of a one- or two-notch
downgrade in the firm’s credit ratings.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Net derivative liabilities under bilateral agreements $ 30,530 $ 33,059
Collateral posted $ 26,546 $ 27,657
Additional collateral or termination payments:
One-notch downgrade $ 374 $ 343
Two-notch downgrade $ 1,288 $ 1,115
Hedge Accounting
The firm applies hedge accounting for (i) interest rate swaps
used to manage the interest rate exposure of certain fixed-
rate unsecured long- and short-term borrowings, certain
fixed-rate certificates of deposit and certain U.S. and non-
U.S. government securities classified as available-for-sale, (ii)
foreign currency forward contracts used to manage the
foreign exchange risk of certain securities classified as
available-for-sale and (iii) foreign currency forward contracts
and foreign currency-denominated debt used to manage
foreign exchange risk on the firm’s net investment in certain
non-U.S. operations.
To qualify for hedge accounting, the hedging instrument
must be highly effective at reducing the risk from the
exposure being hedged. Additionally, the firm must formally
document the hedging relationship at inception and assess the
hedging relationship at least on a quarterly basis to ensure the
hedging instrument continues to be highly effective over the
life of the hedging relationship.
Fair Value Hedges
The firm designates interest rate swaps as fair value hedges of
certain fixed-rate unsecured long- and short-term debt and
fixed-rate certificates of deposit and of certain U.S. and non-
U.S. government securities classified as available-for-sale.
These interest rate swaps hedge changes in fair value
attributable to the designated benchmark interest rate (e.g.,
Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR), Overnight Index
Swap Rate or Sterling Overnight Index Average), effectively
converting a substantial portion of these fixed-rate financial
instruments into floating-rate financial instruments.
The firm applies a statistical method that utilizes regression
analysis when assessing the effectiveness of these hedging
relationships in achieving offsetting changes in the fair values
of the hedging instrument and the risk being hedged (i.e.,
interest rate risk). An interest rate swap is considered highly
effective in offsetting changes in fair value attributable to
changes in the hedged risk when the regression analysis
results in a coefficient of determination of 80% or greater
and a slope between 80% and 125%.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 38

-- 40 of 205 --

For qualifying interest rate fair value hedges, gains or losses
on derivatives are included in interest income/expense. The
change in fair value of the hedged items attributable to the
risk being hedged is reported as an adjustment to its carrying
value (hedging adjustment) and is also included in interest
income/expense. When a derivative is no longer designated as
a hedge, any remaining difference between the carrying value
and par value of the hedged item is amortized in interest
income/expense over the remaining life of the hedged item
using the effective interest method. See Note 23 for further
information about interest income and interest expense.
The table below presents the gains/(losses) from interest rate
derivatives accounted for as hedges and the related hedged
items.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Investments
Interest rate hedges $ 85 $ 427 $ 266 $ 372
Hedged investments (94) (409) (271) (357)
Gains/(losses) $ (9) $ 18 $ (5) $ 15
Borrowings and deposits
Interest rate hedges $ (2,735) $ (7,820) $ (2,583) $ (22,629)
Hedged borrowings and deposits 2,543 7,741 2,127 22,279
Gains/(losses) $ (192) $ (79) $ (456) $ (350)
The table below presents the carrying value of investments,
deposits and unsecured borrowings that are designated in an
interest rate hedging relationship and the related cumulative
hedging adjustment (increase/(decrease)) from current and
prior hedging relationships included in such carrying values.
$ in millions
Carrying
Value
Cumulative
Hedging
Adjustment
As of September 2023
Assets
Investments $ 14,768 $ (568)
Liabilities
Deposits $ 3,493 $ (190)
Unsecured short-term borrowings $ 12,202 $ (177)
Unsecured long-term borrowings $ 127,643 $ (17,025)
As of December 2022
Assets
Investments $ 10,804 $ (350)
Liabilities
Deposits $ 6,311 $ (280)
Unsecured short-term borrowings $ 7,295 $ (47)
Unsecured long-term borrowings $ 151,215 $ (15,134)
In the table above:
• Cumulative hedging adjustment included $(5.85) billion as
of September 2023 and $5.09 billion as of December 2022
of hedging adjustments from prior hedging relationships
that were de-designated and substantially all were related
to unsecured long-term borrowings.
• The amortized cost of investments was $15.82 billion as of
September 2023 and $11.49 billion as of December 2022.
In addition, cumulative hedging adjustments for items no
longer designated in a hedging relationship were $50 million
as of September 2023 and $111 million as of December 2022
and were primarily related to unsecured long-term
borrowings.
The firm designates foreign currency forward contracts as
fair value hedges of the foreign exchange risk of non-U.S.
government securities classified as available-for-sale. See
Note 8 for information about the amortized cost and fair
value of such securities. The effectiveness of such hedges is
assessed based on changes in spot rates. The gains/(losses) on
the hedges (relating to both spot and forward points) and the
foreign exchange gains/(losses) on the related available-for-
sale securities are included in market making. The gross and
net gains/(losses) on hedges and the related hedged available-
for-sale securities were not material for both the three and
nine months ended September 2023. The net gains/(losses) on
hedges and related available-for-sale securities were
$3 million (reflecting a gain of $189 million related to hedges
and a loss of $186 million on the related hedged available-for-
sale securities) for the three months ended September 2022
and were $(25) million (reflecting a gain of $425 million
related to hedges and a loss of $450 million on the related
hedged available-for-sale securities) for the nine months
ended September 2022.
Net Investment Hedges
The firm seeks to reduce the impact of fluctuations in foreign
exchange rates on its net investments in certain non-U.S.
operations through the use of foreign currency forward
contracts and foreign currency-denominated debt. For
foreign currency forward contracts designated as hedges, the
effectiveness of the hedge is assessed based on the overall
changes in the fair value of the forward contracts (i.e., based
on changes in forward rates). For foreign currency-
denominated debt designated as a hedge, the effectiveness of
the hedge is assessed based on changes in spot rates. For
qualifying net investment hedges, all gains or losses on the
hedging instruments are included in currency translation.
The table below presents the gains/(losses) from net
investment hedging.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Hedges:
Foreign currency forward contract $ 112 $ 1,097 $ (25) $ 2,310
Foreign currency-denominated debt $ 839 $ 551 $ 631 $ 1,147
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
39 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 41 of 205 --

Gains or losses on individual net investments in non-U.S.
operations are reclassified from accumulated other
comprehensive income/(loss) to other principal transactions
in the consolidated statements of earnings when such net
investments are sold or substantially liquidated. The gross
and net gains and losses on hedges and the related net
investments in non-U.S. operations reclassified to earnings
from accumulated other comprehensive income/(loss) were
not material for each of the three and nine months ended
September 2023 and September 2022.
The firm had designated $26.35 billion as of September 2023
and $21.46 billion as of December 2022 of foreign currency-
denominated debt, included in unsecured long- and short-
term borrowings, as hedges of net investments in non-U.S.
subsidiaries.
Note 8.
Investments
Investments includes debt instruments and equity securities
that are accounted for at fair value and are generally held by
the firm in connection with its long-term investing activities.
In addition, investments includes debt securities classified as
available-for-sale and held-to-maturity that are generally held
in connection with the firm’s asset-liability management
activities. Investments also consists of equity securities that
are accounted for under the equity method.
The table below presents information about investments.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Equity securities, at fair value $ 13,742 $ 14,892
Debt instruments, at fair value 13,305 14,075
Available-for-sale securities, at fair value 49,260 49,234
Investments, at fair value 76,307 78,201
Held-to-maturity securities 68,510 51,662
Equity-method investments 713 766
Total investments $ 145,530 $ 130,629
See Note 4 for an overview of the firm’s fair value
measurement policies, valuation techniques and significant
inputs used to determine the fair value of investments, and
Note 5 for information about investments within the fair
value hierarchy.
Equity Securities and Debt Instruments, at Fair Value
Equity securities and debt instruments, at fair value are
accounted for at fair value either under the fair value option
or in accordance with other U.S. GAAP, and the related fair
value gains and losses are recognized in the consolidated
statements of earnings.
Equity Securities, at Fair Value. Equity securities, at fair
value consists of the firm’s public and private equity
investments in corporate and real estate entities.
The table below presents information about equity securities,
at fair value.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Equity securities, at fair value $ 13,742 $ 14,892
Equity Type
Public equity 9% 13%
Private equity 91% 87%
Total 100% 100%
Asset Class
Corporate 72% 71%
Real estate 28% 29%
Total 100% 100%
In the table above:
• Equity securities, at fair value included investments
accounted for at fair value under the fair value option
where the firm would otherwise apply the equity method of
accounting of $5.06 billion as of September 2023 and $5.35
billion as of December 2022. Gains/(losses) recognized as a
result of changes in the fair value of equity securities for
which the fair value option was elected were $(179) million
for the three months ended September 2023, $(118) million
for the three months ended September 2022, $(591) million
for the nine months ended September 2023 and $(189)
million for the nine months ended September 2022. These
gains/(losses) are included in other principal transactions.
• Equity securities, at fair value included $1.22 billion as of
September 2023 and $1.30 billion as of December 2022 of
investments in funds that are measured at NAV.
Debt Instruments, at Fair Value. Debt instruments, at fair
value primarily includes mezzanine, senior and distressed
debt.
The table below presents information about debt
instruments, at fair value.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Corporate debt securities $ 9,362 $ 10,098
Securities backed by real estate 785 1,003
Money market instruments 896 1,005
Other 2,262 1,969
Total $ 13,305 $ 14,075
In the table above:
• Substantially all of the firm's money market instruments
consist of time deposits.
• Other included $1.82 billion as of September 2023 and
$1.64 billion as of December 2022 of investments in credit
funds that are measured at NAV.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 40

-- 42 of 205 --

Investments in Funds at Net Asset Value Per Share.
Equity securities and debt instruments, at fair value include
investments in funds that are measured at NAV of the
investment fund. The firm uses NAV to measure the fair
value of fund investments when (i) the fund investment does
not have a readily determinable fair value and (ii) the NAV of
the investment fund is calculated in a manner consistent with
the measurement principles of investment company
accounting, including measurement of the investments at fair
value.
Substantially all of the firm’s investments in funds at NAV
consist of investments in firm-sponsored private equity,
credit, real estate and hedge funds where the firm co-invests
with third-party investors.
Private equity funds primarily invest in a broad range of
industries worldwide, including leveraged buyouts,
recapitalizations, growth investments and distressed
investments. Credit funds generally invest in loans and other
fixed income instruments and are focused on providing
private high-yield capital for leveraged and management
buyout transactions, recapitalizations, financings,
refinancings, acquisitions and restructurings for private
equity firms, private family companies and corporate issuers.
Real estate funds invest globally, primarily in real estate
companies, loan portfolios, debt recapitalizations and
property. Substantially all private equity, credit and real
estate funds are closed-end funds in which the firm’s
investments are generally not eligible for redemption.
Distributions will be received from these funds as the
underlying assets are liquidated or distributed, the timing of
which is uncertain.
The firm also invests in hedge funds, primarily multi-
disciplinary hedge funds that employ a fundamental bottom-
up investment approach across various asset classes and
strategies. The firm’s investments in hedge funds primarily
include interests where the underlying assets are illiquid in
nature, and proceeds from redemptions will not be received
until the underlying assets are liquidated or distributed, the
timing of which is uncertain.
The firm's investments in funds at NAV includes investments
in “covered funds” as defined in the Volcker Rule of the U.S.
Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection
Act (Dodd-Frank Act). The firm achieved conformance with
the covered fund provisions of the Volcker Rule in July 2023
in accordance with the extension received from the Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve System (FRB).
The table below presents the fair value of investments in
funds at NAV and the related unfunded commitments.
$ in millions
Fair Value of
Investments
Unfunded
Commitments
As of September 2023
Private equity funds $ 815 $ 493
Credit funds 1,814 282
Hedge funds 48 –
Real estate funds 360 66
Total $ 3,037 $ 841
As of December 2022
Private equity funds $ 815 $ 647
Credit funds 1,645 303
Hedge funds 68 –
Real estate funds 413 138
Total $ 2,941 $ 1,088
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
41 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 43 of 205 --

Available-for-Sale Securities
Available-for-sale securities are accounted for at fair value,
and the related unrealized fair value gains and losses are
included in accumulated other comprehensive income/(loss)
unless designated in a fair value hedging relationship. See
Note 7 for information about available-for-sale securities
that are designated in a hedging relationship.
The table below presents information about available-for-
sale securities by tenor.
$ in millions
Amortized
Cost
Fair
Value
Weighted
Average
Yield
As of September 2023
Less than 1 year $ 25,004 $ 24,401 0.37%
1 year to 5 years 23,638 22,194 1.25%
5 years to 10 years 530 478 1.86%
Total U.S. government obligations 49,172 47,073 0.80%
Less than 1 year 10 9 0.01%
1 year to 5 years 1,562 1,296 0.10%
5 years to 10 years 1,083 882 0.84%
Total non-U.S. government obligations 2,655 2,187 0.40%
Total available-for-sale securities $ 51,827 $ 49,260 0.78%
As of December 2022
Less than 1 year $ 8,103 $ 7,861 0.37%
1 year to 5 years 41,479 38,706 0.74%
5 years to 10 years 538 488 1.86%
Total U.S. government obligations 50,120 47,055 0.69%
1 year to 5 years 10 10 0.27%
5 years to 10 years 2,616 2,169 0.40%
Total non-U.S. government obligations 2,626 2,179 0.40%
Total available-for-sale securities $ 52,746 $ 49,234 0.68%
In the table above:
• The weighted average yield for available-for-sale securities
is presented on a pre-tax basis and computed using the
effective interest rate of each security at the end of the
period, weighted based on the fair value of each security.
• The gross unrealized gains included in accumulated other
comprehensive income/(loss) were not material and the
gross unrealized losses included in accumulated other
comprehensive income/(loss) were $2.57 billion as of
September 2023 and primarily related to U.S. government
obligations in a continuous unrealized loss position for
more than a year. The gross unrealized gains included in
accumulated other comprehensive income/(loss) were not
material and the gross unrealized losses included in
accumulated other comprehensive income/(loss) were
$3.52 billion as of December 2022 and primarily related to
U.S. government obligations in a continuous unrealized
loss position for more than a year. Net unrealized gains/
(losses) included in other comprehensive income/(loss) were
$431 million ($317 million, net of tax) for the three months
ended September 2023, $(836) million ($(615) million, net
of tax) for the three months ended September 2022, $945
million ($720 million, net of tax) for the nine months ended
September 2023 and $(3.23) billion ($(2.41) billion, net of
tax) for the nine months ended September 2022.
• Substantially all available-for-sale securities were classified
in level 1 of the fair value hierarchy as of both September
2023 and December 2022.
• If the fair value of available-for-sale securities is less than
amortized cost, such securities are considered impaired. If
the firm has the intent to sell the debt security, or if it is
more likely than not that the firm will be required to sell
the debt security before recovery of its amortized cost, the
difference between the amortized cost (net of allowance, if
any) and the fair value of the securities is recognized as an
impairment loss in earnings. The firm did not record any
such impairment losses during either the three or nine
months ended September 2023 or September 2022.
Impaired available-for-sale debt securities that the firm has
the intent and ability to hold are reviewed to determine if
an allowance for credit losses should be recorded. The firm
considers various factors in such determination, including
market conditions, changes in issuer credit ratings and
severity of the unrealized losses. The firm did not record
any provision for credit losses on such securities during
either the three or nine months ended September 2023 or
September 2022.
The table below presents gross realized gains and the
proceeds from the sales of available-for-sale securities.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Gross realized gains $ 2 $ – $ 8 $ –
Proceeds from sales $ 540 $ – $ 3,161 $ 2
In the table above, the specific identification method is used
to determine realized gains on available-for-sale securities.
Such amounts were reclassified from accumulated other
comprehensive income/(loss) to other principal transactions
in the consolidated statements of earnings.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 42

-- 44 of 205 --

Held-to-Maturity Securities
Held-to-maturity securities are accounted for at amortized
cost.
The table below presents information about held-to-maturity
securities by type and tenor.
$ in millions
Amortized
Cost
Fair
Value
Weighted
Average
Yield
As of September 2023
Less than 1 year $ 16,020 $ 15,859 3.13%
1 year to 5 years 50,391 48,627 3.45%
5 years to 10 years 1,896 1,827 3.87%
Total government obligations 68,307 66,313 3.38%
1 year to 5 years 3 2 7.78%
Greater than 10 years 200 200 5.87%
Total securities backed by real estate 203 202 5.90%
Total held-to-maturity securities $ 68,510 $ 66,515 3.39%
As of December 2022
Less than 1 year $ 5,319 $ 5,282 2.98%
1 year to 5 years 45,154 43,852 3.00%
5 years to 10 years 1,026 966 2.89%
Total government obligations 51,499 50,100 2.99%
5 years to 10 years 2 2 5.63%
Greater than 10 years 161 158 3.18%
Total securities backed by real estate 163 160 3.24%
Total held-to-maturity securities $ 51,662 $ 50,260 2.99%
In the table above:
• Substantially all of the government obligations consist of
U.S. government obligations.
• Substantially all of the securities backed by real estate
consist of securities backed by residential real estate.
• As these securities are not accounted for at fair value, they
are not included in the firm’s fair value hierarchy in Notes
4 and 5. Had these securities been included in the firm’s fair
value hierarchy, government obligations would have been
classified in level 1 and securities backed by real estate
would have been primarily classified in level 2 of the fair
value hierarchy as of both September 2023 and December
2022.
• The weighted average yield for held-to-maturity securities
is presented on a pre-tax basis and computed using the
effective interest rate of each security at the end of the
period, weighted based on the amortized cost of each
security.
• The gross unrealized gains were not material as of both
September 2023 and December 2022. The gross unrealized
losses were $2.00 billion as of September 2023 and
$1.44 billion as of December 2022.
• Held-to-maturity securities are reviewed to determine if an
allowance for credit losses should be recorded in the
consolidated statements of earnings. The firm considers
various factors in such determination, including market
conditions, changes in issuer credit ratings, historical credit
losses and sovereign guarantees. Provision for credit losses
on such securities was not material during either the three
or nine months ended September 2023 or September 2022.
Note 9.
Loans
Loans includes (i) loans held for investment that are
accounted for at amortized cost net of allowance for loan
losses or at fair value under the fair value option and (ii)
loans held for sale that are accounted for at the lower of cost
or fair value. Interest on loans is recognized over the life of
the loan and is recorded on an accrual basis.
The table below presents information about loans.
$ in millions
Amortized
Cost
Fair
Value
Held For
Sale Total
As of September 2023
Loan Type
Corporate $ 34,191 $ 871 $ 1,753 $ 36,815
Commercial real estate 24,382 551 739 25,672
Residential real estate 19,924 4,028 1 23,953
Securities-based 15,053 – – 15,053
Other collateralized 54,175 850 621 55,646
Consumer:
Installment 272 – 6,103 6,375
Credit cards 17,885 – – 17,885
Other 1,332 148 273 1,753
Total loans, gross 167,214 6,448 9,490 183,152
Allowance for loan losses (4,895) – – (4,895)
Total loans $ 162,319 $ 6,448 $ 9,490 $ 178,257
As of December 2022
Loan Type
Corporate $ 36,822 $ 996 $ 2,317 $ 40,135
Commercial real estate 26,222 1,146 1,511 28,879
Residential real estate 18,523 4,511 1 23,035
Securities-based 16,671 – – 16,671
Other collateralized 50,473 716 513 51,702
Consumer:
Installment 6,326 – – 6,326
Credit cards 15,820 – – 15,820
Other 1,723 286 252 2,261
Total loans, gross 172,580 7,655 4,594 184,829
Allowance for loan losses (5,543) – – (5,543)
Total loans $ 167,037 $ 7,655 $ 4,594 $ 179,286
In the table above:
• Loans held for investment that are accounted for at
amortized cost include net deferred fees and costs, and
unamortized premiums and discounts, which are amortized
over the life of the loan. These amounts were less than 1%
of loans accounted for at amortized cost as of both
September 2023 and December 2022.
• During the first half of 2023, the firm completed the sale of
substantially all of the Marcus installment loans portfolio.
• During the third quarter of 2023, in connection with the
planned sale of GreenSky, the firm transferred the entire
GreenSky installment loans portfolio of approximately
$6.0 billion to held for sale. See Note 18 for information
about related commitments that were classified as held for
sale. As a result, the firm recognized net revenues of
$(123) million, which were more than offset by a related
reduction in reserves of $637 million in provision for credit
losses.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
43 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 45 of 205 --

• Substantially all loans had floating interest rates as of both
September 2023 and December 2022.
The following is a description of the loan types in the table
above:
• Corporate. Corporate loans includes term loans, revolving
lines of credit, letter of credit facilities and bridge loans,
and are principally used for operating and general
corporate purposes, or in connection with acquisitions.
Corporate loans are secured (typically by a senior lien on
the assets of the borrower) or unsecured, depending on the
loan purpose, the risk profile of the borrower and other
factors.
• Commercial Real Estate. Commercial real estate loans
includes originated loans that are directly or indirectly
secured by hotels, retail stores, multifamily housing
complexes and commercial and industrial properties.
Commercial real estate loans also includes loans extended
to clients who warehouse assets that are directly or
indirectly backed by commercial real estate. In addition,
commercial real estate includes loans purchased by the
firm.
• Residential Real Estate. Residential real estate loans
primarily includes loans extended to wealth management
clients and to clients who warehouse assets that are directly
or indirectly secured by residential real estate. In addition,
residential real estate includes loans purchased by the firm.
• Securities-Based. Securities-based loans includes loans
that are secured by stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and
exchange-traded funds. These loans are primarily extended
to the firm's wealth management clients and used for
purposes other than purchasing, carrying or trading margin
stocks. Securities-based loans require borrowers to post
additional collateral based on changes in the underlying
collateral's fair value.
• Other Collateralized. Other collateralized loans includes
loans that are backed by specific collateral (other than
securities and real estate). Such loans are extended to
clients who warehouse assets that are directly or indirectly
secured by corporate loans, consumer loans and other
assets. Other collateralized loans also includes loans to
investment funds (managed by third parties) that are
collateralized by capital commitments of the funds'
investors or assets held by the fund, as well as other
secured loans extended to the firm's wealth management
clients.
• Installment. Installment loans are unsecured loans
originated by the firm.
• Credit Cards. Credit card loans are loans made pursuant
to revolving lines of credit issued to consumers by the firm.
• Other. Other loans includes unsecured loans extended to
wealth management clients and unsecured consumer and
credit card loans purchased by the firm.
See Note 4 for an overview of the firm’s fair value
measurement policies, valuation techniques and significant
inputs used to determine the fair value of loans, and Note 5
for information about loans within the fair value hierarchy.
Credit Quality
Risk Assessment. The firm’s risk assessment process
includes evaluating the credit quality of its loans by the firm’s
independent risk oversight and control function. For
corporate loans and a majority of securities-based, real
estate, other collateralized and other loans, the firm performs
credit analyses which incorporate initial and ongoing
evaluations of the capacity and willingness of a borrower to
meet its financial obligations. These credit evaluations are
performed on an annual basis or more frequently if deemed
necessary as a result of events or changes in circumstances.
The firm determines an internal credit rating for the
borrower by considering the results of the credit evaluations
and assumptions with respect to the nature of and outlook
for the borrower’s industry and the economic environment.
Beginning in the first quarter of 2023, the firm also takes into
consideration collateral received or other credit support
arrangements when determining an internal credit rating on
collateralized loans, as management believes that this
methodology better reflects the credit quality of the
underlying loans. In the table below, prior period amounts
have been conformed to reflect the current methodology. The
impact to December 2022 was an increase in loans classified
as investment-grade and a decrease in loans classified as non-
investment-grade of $25.0 billion in real estate (warehouse
loans) and other collateralized loans. For consumer loans and
for loans that are not assigned an internal credit rating, the
firm reviews certain key metrics, including, but not limited
to, the Fair Isaac Corporation (FICO) credit scores,
delinquency status, collateral value and other risk factors.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 44

-- 46 of 205 --

The table below presents gross loans by an internally
determined public rating agency equivalent or other credit
metrics and the concentration of secured and unsecured
loans.
$ in millions
Investment-
Grade
Non-Investment-
Grade
Other Metrics/
Unrated Total
As of September 2023
Accounting Method
Amortized cost $ 88,225 $ 54,179 $ 24,810 $ 167,214
Fair value 1,850 2,441 2,157 6,448
Held for sale 635 2,624 6,231 9,490
Total $ 90,710 $ 59,244 $ 33,198 $ 183,152
Loan Type
Corporate $ 8,296 $ 28,397 $ 122 $ 36,815
Real estate:
Commercial 12,183 13,480 9 25,672
Residential 13,271 5,075 5,607 23,953
Securities-based 11,397 635 3,021 15,053
Other collateralized 44,634 10,932 80 55,646
Consumer:
Installment – – 6,375 6,375
Credit cards – – 17,885 17,885
Other 929 725 99 1,753
Total $ 90,710 $ 59,244 $ 33,198 $ 183,152
Secured 92% 90% 26% 79%
Unsecured 8% 10% 74% 21%
Total 100% 100% 100% 100%
As of December 2022
Accounting Method
Amortized cost $ 88,497 $ 55,122 $ 28,961 $ 172,580
Fair value 2,116 2,968 2,571 7,655
Held for sale 557 3,991 46 4,594
Total $ 91,170 $ 62,081 $ 31,578 $ 184,829
Loan Type
Corporate $ 10,200 $ 29,935 $ – $ 40,135
Real estate:
Commercial 11,922 16,822 135 28,879
Residential 11,994 5,670 5,371 23,035
Securities-based 12,901 764 3,006 16,671
Other collateralized 43,093 8,291 318 51,702
Consumer:
Installment – – 6,326 6,326
Credit cards – – 15,820 15,820
Other 1,060 599 602 2,261
Total $ 91,170 $ 62,081 $ 31,578 $ 184,829
Secured 89% 90% 27% 79%
Unsecured 11% 10% 73% 21%
Total 100% 100% 100% 100%
In the table above:
• Substantially all residential real estate, securities-based,
other collateralized and other loans included in the other
metrics/unrated category consists of loans where the firm
uses other key metrics to assess the borrower’s credit
quality, such as loan-to-value ratio, delinquency status,
collateral value, expected cash flows, FICO credit score
(which measures a borrower’s creditworthiness by
considering factors such as payment and credit history) and
other risk factors.
• For installment and credit card loans included in the other
metrics/unrated category, the evaluation of credit quality
incorporates the borrower’s FICO credit score. FICO credit
scores are periodically refreshed by the firm to assess the
updated creditworthiness of the borrower. See “Vintage”
below for information about installment and credit card
loans by FICO credit scores.
The firm also assigns a regulatory risk rating to its loans
based on the definitions provided by the U.S. federal bank
regulatory agencies. Total loans included 91% of loans as of
September 2023 and 93% of loans as of December 2022 that
were rated pass/non-criticized.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
45 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 47 of 205 --

Vintage. The tables below present gross loans accounted for
at amortized cost (excluding installment and credit card
loans) by an internally determined public rating agency
equivalent or other credit metrics and origination year for
term loans.
As of September 2023
$ in millions
Investment-
Grade
Non-
Investment-
Grade
Other
Metrics/
Unrated Total
2023 $ 569 $ 1,080 $ – $ 1,649
2022 1,577 3,265 – 4,842
2021 1,191 4,531 – 5,722
2020 338 2,439 – 2,777
2019 161 2,328 – 2,489
2018 or earlier 445 2,788 – 3,233
Revolving 3,656 9,823 – 13,479
Corporate 7,937 26,254 – 34,191
2023 458 698 – 1,156
2022 1,254 3,131 – 4,385
2021 1,292 2,867 – 4,159
2020 356 1,262 – 1,618
2019 370 910 – 1,280
2018 or earlier 924 775 – 1,699
Revolving 7,296 2,789 – 10,085
Commercial real estate 11,950 12,432 – 24,382
2023 740 422 598 1,760
2022 841 757 1,254 2,852
2021 834 916 1,305 3,055
2020 4 22 83 109
2019 7 – 91 98
2018 or earlier – 59 220 279
Revolving 9,894 1,877 – 11,771
Residential real estate 12,320 4,053 3,551 19,924
2023 8 – – 8
2022 5 – – 5
2019 6 – – 6
2018 or earlier – 291 – 291
Revolving 11,378 344 3,021 14,743
Securities-based 11,397 635 3,021 15,053
2023 4,723 1,629 – 6,352
2022 2,109 423 10 2,542
2021 2,678 1,400 22 4,100
2020 1,367 621 32 2,020
2019 635 74 10 719
2018 or earlier 485 251 – 736
Revolving 31,740 5,966 – 37,706
Other collateralized 43,737 10,364 74 54,175
2023 55 15 – 70
2022 56 12 – 68
2021 17 70 – 87
2020 – 234 – 234
2019 – 4 4
2018 or earlier – – 7 7
Revolving 756 106 – 862
Other 884 441 7 1,332
Total $ 88,225 $ 54,179 $ 6,653 $ 149,057
Percentage of total 59% 36% 5% 100%
As of December 2022
$ in millions
Investment-
Grade
Non-
Investment-
Grade
Other
Metrics/
Unrated Total
2022 $ 2,607 $ 4,042 $ 2 $ 6,651
2021 1,669 4,273 – 5,942
2020 684 2,595 – 3,279
2019 209 2,779 – 2,988
2018 759 1,911 – 2,670
2017 or earlier 508 2,329 – 2,837
Revolving 3,709 8,746 – 12,455
Corporate 10,145 26,675 2 36,822
2022 805 3,900 2 4,707
2021 771 3,460 – 4,231
2020 407 1,740 – 2,147
2019 480 1,267 – 1,747
2018 212 469 – 681
2017 or earlier 1,238 797 11 2,046
Revolving 7,660 3,003 – 10,663
Commercial real estate 11,573 14,636 13 26,222
2022 1,493 833 1,307 3,633
2021 1,263 888 1,357 3,508
2020 8 6 89 103
2019 7 – 99 106
2018 10 50 138 198
2017 or earlier 31 10 142 183
Revolving 8,065 2,727 – 10,792
Residential real estate 10,877 4,514 3,132 18,523
2022 5 – – 5
2018 1 – – 1
2017 or earlier – 291 – 291
Revolving 12,895 473 3,006 16,374
Securities-based 12,901 764 3,006 16,671
2022 4,556 751 113 5,420
2021 3,339 1,098 146 4,583
2020 1,871 701 36 2,608
2019 523 79 12 614
2018 545 108 6 659
2017 or earlier 487 108 – 595
Revolving 30,669 5,323 2 35,994
Other collateralized 41,990 8,168 315 50,473
2022 44 105 – 149
2021 17 162 – 179
2020 – 29 262 291
2019 – 10 – 10
2017 or earlier – – 5 5
Revolving 950 59 80 1,089
Other 1,011 365 347 1,723
Total $ 88,497 $ 55,122 $ 6,815 $ 150,434
Percentage of total 59% 37% 4% 100%
In the tables above, revolving loans which converted to term
loans were $1.23 billion as of September 2023 and
$725 million as of December 2022, and primarily included
other collateralized loans.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 46

-- 48 of 205 --

The table below presents gross installment loans accounted
for at amortized cost by refreshed FICO credit scores and
origination year and gross credit card loans by refreshed
FICO credit scores.
$ in millions
Greater than or
equal to 660 Less than 660 Total
As of September 2023
2023 $ 82 $ 10 $ 92
2022 140 25 165
2021 or earlier 12 3 15
Installment 234 38 272
Credit cards 11,680 6,205 17,885
Total $ 11,914 $ 6,243 $ 18,157
Percentage of total:
Installment 86% 14% 100%
Credit cards 65% 35% 100%
Total 66% 34% 100%
As of December 2022
2022 $ 4,349 $ 242 $ 4,591
2021 1,080 109 1,189
2020 251 23 274
2019 160 23 183
2018 70 13 83
2017 or earlier 5 1 6
Installment 5,915 411 6,326
Credit cards 10,762 5,058 15,820
Total $ 16,677 $ 5,469 $ 22,146
Percentage of total:
Installment 94% 6% 100%
Credit cards 68% 32% 100%
Total 75% 25% 100%
In the table above, credit card loans consist of revolving lines
of credit.
Credit Concentrations. The table below presents the
concentration of gross loans by region.
$ in millions
Carrying
Value Americas EMEA Asia Total
As of September 2023
Corporate $ 36,815 62% 30% 8% 100%
Commercial real estate 25,672 83% 14% 3% 100%
Residential real estate 23,953 96% 3% 1% 100%
Securities-based 15,053 80% 19% 1% 100%
Other collateralized 55,646 84% 14% 2% 100%
Consumer:
Installment 6,375 100% – – 100%
Credit cards 17,885 100% – – 100%
Other 1,753 91% 9% – 100%
Total $ 183,152 83% 14% 3% 100%
As of December 2022
Corporate $ 40,135 57% 34% 9% 100%
Commercial real estate 28,879 79% 16% 5% 100%
Residential real estate 23,035 96% 3% 1% 100%
Securities-based 16,671 83% 15% 2% 100%
Other collateralized 51,702 86% 12% 2% 100%
Consumer:
Installment 6,326 100% – – 100%
Credit cards 15,820 100% – – 100%
Other 2,261 89% 11% – 100%
Total $ 184,829 81% 15% 4% 100%
In the table above:
• EMEA represents Europe, Middle East and Africa.
• The top five industry concentrations for corporate loans as
of September 2023 were 26% for technology, media &
telecommunications, 17% for diversified industrials, 12%
for real estate, 10% for consumer & retail and 10% for
healthcare.
• The top five industry concentrations for corporate loans as
of December 2022 were 26% for technology, media &
telecommunications, 18% for diversified industrials, 11%
for real estate, 10% for healthcare and 10% for consumer
& retail.
Nonaccrual, Past Due and Modified Loans. Loans
accounted for at amortized cost (other than credit card loans)
are placed on nonaccrual status when it is probable that the
firm will not collect all principal and interest due under the
contractual terms, regardless of the delinquency status or if a
loan is past due for 90 days or more, unless the loan is both
well collateralized and in the process of collection. At that
time, all accrued but uncollected interest is reversed against
interest income and interest subsequently collected is
recognized on a cash basis to the extent the loan balance is
deemed collectible. Otherwise, all cash received is used to
reduce the outstanding loan balance. A loan is considered
past due when a principal or interest payment has not been
made according to its contractual terms. Credit card loans
are not placed on nonaccrual status and accrue interest until
the loan is paid in full or is charged off.
The table below presents information about past due loans.
$ in millions 30-89 days
90 days
or more Total
As of September 2023
Corporate $ – $ 80 $ 80
Commercial real estate 295 543 838
Residential real estate 1 5 6
Securities-based 1 – 1
Other collateralized 33 63 96
Consumer:
Installment 8 6 14
Credit cards 423 424 847
Other 7 11 18
Total $ 768 $ 1,132 $ 1,900
Total divided by gross loans at amortized cost 1.1%
As of December 2022
Corporate $ – $ 92 $ 92
Commercial real estate 47 362 409
Residential real estate 4 6 10
Securities-based 1 – 1
Other collateralized 10 5 15
Consumer:
Installment 46 17 63
Credit cards 291 265 556
Other 17 5 22
Total $ 416 $ 752 $ 1,168
Total divided by gross loans at amortized cost 0.7%
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
47 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 49 of 205 --

The table below presents information about nonaccrual
loans.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Corporate $ 1,614 $ 1,432
Commercial real estate 1,913 1,079
Residential real estate 19 93
Other collateralized 814 65
Other 20 –
Installment 4 41
Total $ 4,384 $ 2,710
Total divided by gross loans at amortized cost 2.6% 1.6%
In the table above:
• Nonaccrual loans included $993 million as of September
2023 and $483 million as of December 2022 of loans that
were 30 days or more past due.
• Loans that were 90 days or more past due and still accruing
were not material as of both September 2023 and December
2022.
• Allowance for loan losses as a percentage of total
nonaccrual loans was 111.7% as of September 2023 and
204.5% as of December 2022.
In certain circumstances, the firm may modify the original
terms of a loan agreement by granting a concession to a
borrower experiencing financial difficulty, typically in the
form of a modification of loan covenants, but may also
include forbearance of interest or principal, payment
extensions or interest rate reductions. These modifications, to
the extent significant, were considered TDRs as of December
2022. In January 2023, the firm adopted ASU No. 2022-02,
which eliminated the recognition and measurement guidance
for TDRs and requires enhanced disclosures for certain loan
modifications. As of December 2022, loans modified in a
TDR were $231 million and commitments related to such
loans were not material. Substantially all of such loans
modified in a TDR were related to corporate and commercial
real estate loans. During both the three and nine months
ended September 2023, the firm provided loan modifications
(in the form of term extensions) to borrowers experiencing
financial difficulty. As of September 2023, the carrying value
of loans modified during the three months ended September
2023 was $172 million and the carrying value of loans
modified during the nine months ended September 2023 was
$755 million. Lending commitments related to such loans
were not material and such loan modifications were
primarily related to corporate and commercial real estate
loans. The impact of these modifications was not material for
either the three or nine months ended September 2023.
During the nine months ended September 2023, the firm
charged-off approximately $100 million of loans that had
defaulted after being modified. Substantially all of the
remaining modified loans were performing in accordance
with the modified contractual terms as of September 2023.
Allowance for Credit Losses
The firm’s allowance for credit losses consists of the
allowance for losses on loans and lending commitments
accounted for at amortized cost. Loans and lending
commitments accounted for at fair value or accounted for at
the lower of cost or fair value are not subject to an allowance
for credit losses.
To determine the allowance for credit losses, the firm
classifies its loans and lending commitments accounted for at
amortized cost into wholesale and consumer portfolios.
These portfolios represent the level at which the firm has
developed and documented its methodology to determine the
allowance for credit losses. The allowance for credit losses is
measured on a collective basis for loans that exhibit similar
risk characteristics using a modeled approach and on an
asset-specific basis for loans that do not share similar risk
characteristics.
The allowance for credit losses takes into account the
weighted average of a range of forecasts of future economic
conditions over the expected life of the loan and lending
commitments. The expected life of each loan or lending
commitment is determined based on the contractual term
adjusted for extension options or demand features, or is
modeled in the case of revolving credit card loans. The
forecasts include baseline, favorable and adverse economic
scenarios over a three-year period. For loans with expected
lives beyond three years, the model reverts to historical loss
information based on a non-linear modeled approach. The
forecasted economic scenarios consider a number of risk
factors relevant to the wholesale and consumer portfolios
described below. The firm applies judgment in weighing
individual scenarios each quarter based on a variety of
factors, including the firm’s internally derived economic
outlook, market consensus, recent macroeconomic
conditions and industry trends.
The allowance for credit losses also includes qualitative
components which allow management to reflect the uncertain
nature of economic forecasting, capture uncertainty
regarding model inputs, and account for model imprecision
and concentration risk.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 48

-- 50 of 205 --

Management’s estimate of credit losses entails judgment
about the expected life of the loan and loan collectability at
the reporting dates, and there are uncertainties inherent in
those judgments. The allowance for credit losses is subject to
a governance process that involves review and approval by
senior management within the firm’s independent risk
oversight and control functions. Personnel within the firm’s
independent risk oversight and control functions are
responsible for forecasting the economic variables that
underlie the economic scenarios that are used in the modeling
of expected credit losses. While management uses the best
information available to determine this estimate, future
adjustments to the allowance may be necessary based on,
among other things, changes in the economic environment or
variances between actual results and the original assumptions
used.
The table below presents gross loans and lending
commitments accounted for at amortized cost by portfolio.
As of
September 2023 December 2022
$ in millions Loans
Lending
Commitments Loans
Lending
Commitments
Wholesale
Corporate $ 34,191 $ 142,270 $ 36,822 $ 137,149
Commercial real estate 24,382 3,286 26,222 3,692
Residential real estate 19,924 1,889 18,523 3,089
Securities-based 15,053 815 16,671 508
Other collateralized 54,175 15,411 50,473 13,209
Other 1,332 883 1,723 944
Consumer
Installment 272 1 6,326 1,882
Credit cards 17,885 68,394 15,820 62,216
Total $ 167,214 $ 232,949 $ 172,580 $ 222,689
In the table above, wholesale loans included $4.38 billion as
of September 2023 and $2.67 billion as of December 2022 of
nonaccrual loans for which the allowance for credit losses
was measured on an asset-specific basis. The allowance for
credit losses on these loans was $708 million as of September
2023 and $535 million as of December 2022. These loans
included $922 million as of September 2023 and $384 million
as of December 2022 of loans which did not require a reserve
as the loan was deemed to be recoverable.
See Note 18 for further information about lending
commitments.
The following is a description of the methodology used to
calculate the allowance for credit losses:
Wholesale. The allowance for credit losses for wholesale
loans and lending commitments that exhibit similar risk
characteristics is measured using a modeled approach. These
models determine the probability of default and loss given
default based on various risk factors, including internal credit
ratings, industry default and loss data, expected life,
macroeconomic indicators, the borrower’s capacity to meet
its financial obligations, the borrower’s country of risk and
industry, loan seniority and collateral type. For lending
commitments, the methodology also considers the
probability of drawdowns or funding. In addition, for loans
backed by real estate, risk factors include the loan-to-value
ratio, debt service ratio and home price index. The most
significant inputs to the forecast model for wholesale loans
and lending commitments include unemployment rates, GDP,
credit spreads, commercial and industrial delinquency rates,
short- and long-term interest rates, and oil prices.
The allowance for loan losses for wholesale loans that do not
share similar risk characteristics, such as nonaccrual loans, is
calculated using the present value of expected future cash
flows discounted at the loan’s effective rate, the observable
market price of the loan or the fair value of the collateral.
Wholesale loans are charged off against the allowance for
loan losses when deemed to be uncollectible.
Consumer. The allowance for credit losses for consumer
loans that exhibit similar risk characteristics is calculated
using a modeled approach which classifies consumer loans
into pools based on borrower-related and exposure-related
characteristics that differentiate a pool’s risk characteristics
from other pools. The factors considered in determining a
pool are generally consistent with the risk characteristics used
for internal credit risk measurement and management and
include key metrics, such as FICO credit scores, delinquency
status, loan vintage and macroeconomic indicators. The most
significant inputs to the forecast model for consumer loans
include unemployment rates and delinquency rates. The
expected life of revolving credit card loans is determined by
modeling expected future draws and the timing and amount
of repayments allocated to the funded balance. The firm also
recognizes an allowance for credit losses on commitments to
acquire loans. However, no allowance for credit losses is
recognized on credit card lending commitments as they are
cancellable by the firm.
Installment loans are charged off when they are 120 days past
due. Credit card loans are charged off when they are 180 days
past due.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
49 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 51 of 205 --

Allowance for Credit Losses Rollforward
The table below presents information about the allowance
for credit losses.
$ in millions Wholesale Consumer Total
Three Months Ended September 2023
Allowance for loan losses
Beginning balance $ 2,497 $ 2,735 $ 5,232
Charge-offs (166) (302) (468)
Recoveries 9 26 35
Net (charge-offs)/recoveries (157) (276) (433)
Provision 149 (37) 112
Other (16) – (16)
Ending balance $ 2,473 $ 2,422 $ 4,895
Allowance ratio 1.7% 13.3% 2.9%
Net charge-off ratio 0.4% 5.1% 1.0%
Allowance for losses on lending commitments
Beginning balance $ 729 $ 48 $ 777
Provision (57) (48) (105)
Other (2) – (2)
Ending balance $ 670 $ – $ 670
Three Months Ended September 2022
Allowance for loan losses
Beginning balance $ 2,458 $ 2,104 $ 4,562
Charge-offs (65) (150) (215)
Recoveries 22 21 43
Net (charge-offs)/recoveries (43) (129) (172)
Provision 78 403 481
Other (25) – (25)
Ending balance $ 2,468 $ 2,378 $ 4,846
Allowance ratio 1.7% 12.6% 2.9%
Net charge-off ratio 0.1% 2.9% 0.4%
Allowance for losses on lending commitments
Beginning balance $ 702 $ 3 $ 705
Provision (10) 44 34
Ending balance $ 692 $ 47 $ 739
Nine Months Ended September 2023
Allowance for loan losses
Beginning balance $ 2,562 $ 2,981 $ 5,543
Charge-offs (350) (893) (1,243)
Recoveries 32 76 108
Net (charge-offs)/recoveries (318) (817) (1,135)
Provision 293 258 551
Other (64) – (64)
Ending balance $ 2,473 $ 2,422 $ 4,895
Allowance ratio 1.7% 13.3% 2.9%
Net charge-off ratio 0.3% 5.1% 0.9%
Allowance for losses on lending commitments
Beginning balance $ 711 $ 63 $ 774
Provision (37) (63) (100)
Other (4) – (4)
Ending balance $ 670 $ – $ 670
Nine Months Ended September 2022
Allowance for loan losses
Beginning balance $ 2,135 $ 1,438 $ 3,573
Charge-offs (237) (348) (585)
Recoveries 48 62 110
Net (charge-offs)/recoveries (189) (286) (475)
Provision 551 1,226 1,777
Other (29) – (29)
Ending balance $ 2,468 $ 2,378 $ 4,846
Allowance ratio 1.7% 12.6% 2.9%
Net charge-off ratio 0.2% 2.5% 0.4%
Allowance for losses on lending commitments
Beginning balance $ 589 $ 187 $ 776
Provision 106 (140) (34)
Other (3) – (3)
Ending balance $ 692 $ 47 $ 739
In the table above:
• The allowance ratio is calculated by dividing the allowance
for loan losses by gross loans accounted for at amortized
cost.
• The net charge-off ratio is calculated by dividing
annualized net (charge-offs)/recoveries by average gross
loans accounted for at amortized cost.
Forecast Model Inputs as of September 2023
When modeling expected credit losses, the firm employs a
weighted, multi-scenario forecast, which includes baseline,
adverse and favorable economic scenarios. As of September
2023, this multi-scenario forecast was weighted towards the
baseline and adverse economic scenarios.
The table below presents the forecasted U.S. unemployment
and U.S. GDP growth rates used in the baseline economic
scenario of the forecast model.
As of September 2023
U.S. unemployment rate
Forecast for the quarter ended:
December 2023 3.9%
June 2024 4.3%
December 2024 4.3%
Growth in U.S. GDP
Forecast for the year:
2023 2.1%
2024 1.2%
2025 1.7%
The adverse economic scenario of the forecast model reflects
a global recession in the fourth quarter of 2023 through the
third quarter of 2024, resulting in an economic contraction
and rising unemployment rates. In this scenario, the U.S.
unemployment rate peaks at approximately 7.4% during the
fourth quarter of 2024 and the maximum decline in the
quarterly U.S. GDP relative to the third quarter of 2023 is
approximately 2.7%, which occurs during the third quarter
of 2024.
In the table above:
• U.S. unemployment rate represents the rate forecasted as of
the respective quarter-end.
• Growth in U.S. GDP represents the year-over-year growth
rate forecasted for the respective years.
• While the U.S. unemployment and U.S. GDP growth rates
are significant inputs to the forecast model, the model
contemplates a variety of other inputs across a range of
scenarios to provide a forecast of future economic
conditions. Given the complex nature of the forecasting
process, no single economic variable can be viewed in
isolation and independently of other inputs.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 50

-- 52 of 205 --

Allowance for Credit Losses Commentary
Three Months Ended September 2023. The allowance
for credit losses decreased by $444 million during the three
months ended September 2023, reflecting a net release related
to the GreenSky loan portfolio (including a reserve reduction
of $637 million related to the transfer of the portfolio to held
for sale) and lower modeled expected credit losses relating to
the wholesale portfolio due to increased stability in the
macroeconomic environment, partially offset by asset specific
provisions in the wholesale portfolio and seasoning of the
credit card portfolio.
Charge-offs for the three months ended September 2023 for
wholesale loans (principally related to term loans originated
in 2021) were primarily related to commercial real estate
loans and charge-offs for consumer loans were primarily
related to credit cards.
Nine Months Ended September 2023. The allowance for
credit losses decreased by $752 million during the nine
months ended September 2023, reflecting a net release related
to the GreenSky loan portfolio (including a reserve reduction
of $637 million related to the transfer of the GreenSky loan
portfolio to held for sale), a reserve reduction of
approximately $440 million associated with the sale of
Marcus loans and lower balances in corporate loans,
partially offset by seasoning of the credit card portfolio.
Charge-offs for the nine months ended September 2023 for
wholesale loans (principally related to term loans originated
in 2021 and 2019) were primarily related to corporate loans
and charge-offs for consumer loans were primarily related to
credit cards.
Three Months Ended September 2022. The allowance
for credit losses increased by $318 million during the three
months ended September 2022, reflecting growth in the firm's
consumer lending portfolio (principally in credit cards) and
higher modeled expected losses due to broad macroeconomic
concerns.
Charge-offs for the three months ended September 2022 for
wholesale loans were primarily related to corporate loans
and charge-offs for consumer loans were primarily related to
credit cards.
Nine Months Ended September 2022. The allowance for
credit losses increased by $1.24 billion during the nine
months ended September 2022, reflecting growth in the firm's
consumer lending portfolio (principally in credit cards) and
higher modeled expected losses due to broad macroeconomic
and geopolitical concerns.
Charge-offs for the nine months ended September 2022 for
wholesale loans were primarily related to corporate loans
and charge-offs for consumer loans were primarily related to
credit cards.
Estimated Fair Value
The table below presents the estimated fair value of loans
that are not accounted for at fair value and in what level of
the fair value hierarchy they would have been classified if
they had been included in the firm’s fair value hierarchy.
Carrying
Value
Estimated Fair Value
$ in millions Level 2 Level 3 Total
As of September 2023
Amortized cost $ 162,319 $ 88,954 $ 74,463 $ 163,417
Held for sale $ 9,490 $ 7,815 $ 1,685 $ 9,500
As of December 2022
Amortized cost $ 167,037 $ 85,921 $ 83,121 $ 169,042
Held for sale $ 4,594 $ 2,592 $ 2,014 $ 4,606
In the table above, level 2 loans held for sale included the
GreenSky installment loans portfolio of approximately
$6.0 billion and the estimated fair value of such loans was
determined based on the bids received during the sales
process. See Note 4 for an overview of the firm’s fair value
measurement policies, valuation techniques and significant
inputs used to determine the fair value of other loans, and
Note 5 for information about loans within the fair value
hierarchy.
Note 10.
Fair Value Option
Other Financial Assets and Liabilities at Fair Value
In addition to trading assets and liabilities, and certain
investments and loans, the firm accounts for certain of its
other financial assets and liabilities at fair value, substantially
all under the fair value option. The primary reasons for
electing the fair value option are to:
• Reflect economic events in earnings on a timely basis;
• Mitigate volatility in earnings from using different
measurement attributes (e.g., transfers of financial assets
accounted for as financings are recorded at fair value,
whereas the related secured financing would be recorded
on an accrual basis absent electing the fair value option);
and
• Address simplification and cost-benefit considerations
(e.g., accounting for hybrid financial instruments at fair
value in their entirety versus bifurcation of embedded
derivatives and hedge accounting for debt hosts).
Hybrid financial instruments are instruments that contain
bifurcatable embedded derivatives and do not require
settlement by physical delivery of nonfinancial assets (e.g.,
physical commodities). If the firm elects to bifurcate the
embedded derivative from the associated debt, the derivative
is accounted for at fair value and the host contract is
accounted for at amortized cost, adjusted for the effective
portion of any fair value hedges. If the firm does not elect to
bifurcate, the entire hybrid financial instrument is accounted
for at fair value under the fair value option.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
51 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 53 of 205 --

Other financial assets and liabilities accounted for at fair
value under the fair value option include:
• Repurchase agreements and substantially all resale
agreements;
• Certain securities borrowed and loaned transactions;
• Certain customer and other receivables and certain other
assets and liabilities;
• Certain time deposits (deposits with no stated maturity are
not eligible for a fair value option election), including
structured certificates of deposit, which are hybrid
financial instruments;
• Substantially all other secured financings, including
transfers of assets accounted for as financings; and
• Certain unsecured short- and long-term borrowings,
substantially all of which are hybrid financial instruments.
See Note 4 for an overview of the firm’s fair value
measurement policies, valuation techniques and significant
inputs used to determine the fair value of other financial
assets and liabilities, and Note 5 for information about other
financial assets and liabilities within the fair value hierarchy.
Gains and Losses on Other Financial Assets and
Liabilities Accounted for at Fair Value Under the Fair
Value Option
The table below presents the gains and losses recognized in
earnings as a result of the election to apply the fair value
option to certain financial assets and liabilities.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Unsecured short-term borrowings $ (111) $ 1,114 $ (2,934) $ 5,379
Unsecured long-term borrowings 1,551 2,445 (890) 8,316
Other (38) 434 (177) 1,255
Total $ 1,402 $ 3,993 $ (4,001) $ 14,950
In the table above:
• Gains/(losses) were substantially all included in market
making.
• Gains/(losses) exclude contractual interest, which is
included in interest income and interest expense, for all
instruments other than hybrid financial instruments. See
Note 23 for further information about interest income and
interest expense.
• Gains/(losses) included in unsecured short- and long-term
borrowings were substantially all related to the embedded
derivative component of hybrid financial instruments.
These gains and losses would have been recognized under
other U.S. GAAP even if the firm had not elected to
account for the entire hybrid financial instrument at fair
value.
• Gains/(losses) included in other were substantially all
related to resale and repurchase agreements, deposits, other
secured financings and other liabilities.
• Other financial assets and liabilities at fair value are
frequently economically hedged with trading assets and
liabilities. Accordingly, gains or losses on such other
financial assets and liabilities can be partially offset by
gains or losses on trading assets and liabilities. As a result,
gains or losses on other financial assets and liabilities do
not necessarily represent the overall impact on the firm’s
results of operations, liquidity or capital resources.
Gains/(losses) on trading assets and liabilities accounted for
at fair value under the fair value option are included in
market making. See Note 6 for further information about
gains/(losses) from market making. See Note 8 for
information about gains/(losses) on equity securities and
Note 9 for information about gains/(losses) on loans which
are accounted for at fair value under the fair value option.
Long-Term Debt Instruments
The aggregate contractual principal amount of long-term
other secured financings, for which the fair value option was
elected, exceeded the related fair value by $256 million as of
September 2023. The related amount was not material as of
December 2022.
The aggregate contractual principal amount of unsecured
long-term borrowings, for which the fair value option was
elected, exceeded the related fair value by $5.91 billion as of
September 2023 and $5.03 billion as of December 2022.
These debt instruments include both principal-protected and
non-principal-protected long-term borrowings.
Debt Valuation Adjustment
The firm calculates the fair value of financial liabilities for
which the fair value option is elected by discounting future
cash flows at a rate which incorporates the firm’s credit
spreads.
The table below presents information about the net debt
valuation adjustment (DVA) gains/(losses) on financial
liabilities for which the fair value option was elected.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Pre-tax DVA $ 443 $ 907 $ (370) $ 3,488
After-tax DVA $ 328 $ 673 $ (283) $ 2,601
In the table above:
• After-tax DVA is included in debt valuation adjustment in
the consolidated statements of comprehensive income.
• The gains/(losses) reclassified to market making in the
consolidated statements of earnings from accumulated
other comprehensive income/(loss) upon extinguishment of
such financial liabilities were not material for each of the
three and nine months ended September 2023 and
September 2022.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 52

-- 54 of 205 --

Loans and Lending Commitments
The table below presents the difference between the
aggregate fair value and the aggregate contractual principal
amount for loans (included in trading assets and loans in the
consolidated balance sheets) for which the fair value option
was elected.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Performing loans
Aggregate contractual principal in excess of fair value $ 2,434 $ 2,645
Loans on nonaccrual status and/or more than 90 days past due
Aggregate contractual principal in excess of fair value $ 2,556 $ 3,331
Aggregate fair value $ 1,955 $ 2,633
In the table above, the aggregate contractual principal
amount of loans on nonaccrual status and/or more than 90
days past due (which excludes loans carried at zero fair value
and considered uncollectible) exceeds the related fair value
primarily because the firm regularly purchases loans, such as
distressed loans, at values significantly below the contractual
principal amounts.
The fair value of unfunded lending commitments for which
the fair value option was elected was a liability of $10 million
as of September 2023 and $22 million as of December 2022,
and the related total contractual amount of these lending
commitments was $176 million as of September 2023 and
$307 million as of December 2022. See Note 18 for further
information about lending commitments.
Impact of Credit Spreads on Loans and Lending
Commitments
The estimated net gain/(loss) attributable to changes in
instrument-specific credit spreads on loans and lending
commitments for which the fair value option was elected was
$(118) million for the three months ended September 2023,
$(75) million for the three months ended September 2022,
$(170) million for the nine months ended September 2023 and
$(182) million for the nine months ended September 2022.
The firm generally calculates the fair value of loans and
lending commitments for which the fair value option is
elected by discounting future cash flows at a rate which
incorporates the instrument-specific credit spreads. For
floating-rate loans and lending commitments, substantially
all changes in fair value are attributable to changes in
instrument-specific credit spreads, whereas for fixed-rate
loans and lending commitments, changes in fair value are
also attributable to changes in interest rates.
Note 11.
Collateralized Agreements and Financings
Collateralized agreements are resale agreements and
securities borrowed. Collateralized financings are repurchase
agreements, securities loaned and other secured financings.
The firm enters into these transactions in order to, among
other things, facilitate client activities, invest excess cash,
acquire securities to cover short positions and finance certain
firm activities.
Collateralized agreements and financings with the same
settlement date are presented on a net-by-counterparty basis
when such transactions meet certain settlement criteria and
are subject to netting agreements. Interest on collateralized
agreements, which is included in interest income, and
collateralized financings, which is included in interest
expense, is recognized over the life of the transaction. See
Note 23 for further information about interest income and
interest expense.
Resale and Repurchase Agreements
A resale agreement is a transaction in which the firm
purchases financial instruments from a seller, typically in
exchange for cash, and simultaneously enters into an
agreement to resell the same or substantially the same
financial instruments to the seller at a stated price plus
accrued interest at a future date.
A repurchase agreement is a transaction in which the firm
sells financial instruments to a buyer, typically in exchange
for cash, and simultaneously enters into an agreement to
repurchase the same or substantially the same financial
instruments from the buyer at a stated price plus accrued
interest at a future date.
Even though repurchase and resale agreements (including
“repos- and reverses-to-maturity”) involve the legal transfer
of ownership of financial instruments, they are accounted for
as financing arrangements because they require the financial
instruments to be repurchased or resold before or at the
maturity of the agreement. The financial instruments
purchased or sold in resale and repurchase agreements
typically include U.S. government and agency obligations,
and investment-grade sovereign obligations.
The firm receives financial instruments purchased under
resale agreements and makes delivery of financial instruments
sold under repurchase agreements. To mitigate credit
exposure, the firm monitors the market value of these
financial instruments on a daily basis, and delivers or obtains
additional collateral due to changes in the market value of the
financial instruments, as appropriate. For resale agreements,
the firm typically requires collateral with a fair value
approximately equal to the carrying value of the relevant
assets in the consolidated balance sheets.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
53 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 55 of 205 --

Repurchase agreements and substantially all resale
agreements are recorded at fair value under the fair value
option. See Note 5 for further information about repurchase
and resale agreements.
Securities Borrowed and Loaned Transactions
In a securities borrowed transaction, the firm borrows
securities from a counterparty in exchange for cash or
securities. When the firm returns the securities, the
counterparty returns the cash or securities. Interest is
generally paid periodically over the life of the transaction.
In a securities loaned transaction, the firm lends securities to
a counterparty in exchange for cash or securities. When the
counterparty returns the securities, the firm returns the cash
or securities posted as collateral. Interest is generally paid
periodically over the life of the transaction.
The firm receives securities borrowed and makes delivery of
securities loaned. To mitigate credit exposure, the firm
monitors the market value of these securities on a daily basis,
and delivers or obtains additional collateral due to changes in
the market value of the securities, as appropriate. For
securities borrowed transactions, the firm typically requires
collateral with a fair value approximately equal to the
carrying value of the securities borrowed transaction.
Securities borrowed and loaned within FICC financing are
recorded at fair value under the fair value option. See Note 5
for further information about securities borrowed and loaned
accounted for at fair value.
Substantially all of the securities borrowed and loaned within
Equities financing are recorded based on the amount of cash
collateral advanced or received plus accrued interest. The
firm also reviews such securities borrowed to determine if an
allowance for credit losses should be recorded by taking into
consideration the fair value of collateral received. As these
agreements generally can be terminated on demand, they
exhibit little, if any, sensitivity to changes in interest rates.
Therefore, the carrying value of such agreements
approximates fair value. As these agreements are not
accounted for at fair value, they are not included in the firm’s
fair value hierarchy in Notes 4 and 5. Had these agreements
been included in the firm’s fair value hierarchy, they would
have been classified in level 2 as of both September 2023 and
December 2022.
Offsetting Arrangements
The table below presents resale and repurchase agreements
and securities borrowed and loaned transactions included in
the consolidated balance sheets, as well as the amounts not
offset in the consolidated balance sheets.
Assets Liabilities
$ in millions
Resale
agreements
Securities
borrowed
Repurchase
agreements
Securities
loaned
As of September 2023
Included in the consolidated balance sheets
Gross carrying value $ 266,438 $ 197,625 $ 301,422 $ 55,626
Counterparty netting (75,743) (700) (75,743) (700)
Total 190,695 196,925 225,679 54,926
Amounts not offset
Counterparty netting (33,556) (6,493) (33,556) (6,493)
Collateral (149,881) (183,674) (189,154) (46,941)
Total $ 7,258 $ 6,758 $ 2,969 $ 1,492
As of December 2022
Included in the consolidated balance sheets
Gross carrying value $ 334,042 $ 199,623 $ 219,274 $ 41,309
Counterparty netting (108,925) (10,582) (108,925) (10,582)
Total 225,117 189,041 110,349 30,727
Amounts not offset
Counterparty netting (15,350) (4,576) (15,350) (4,576)
Collateral (204,843) (171,997) (92,997) (25,578)
Total $ 4,924 $ 12,468 $ 2,002 $ 573
In the table above:
• Substantially all of the gross carrying values of these
arrangements are subject to enforceable netting
agreements.
• Where the firm has received or posted collateral under
credit support agreements, but has not yet determined such
agreements are enforceable, the related collateral has not
been netted.
• Amounts not offset includes counterparty netting that does
not meet the criteria for netting under U.S. GAAP and the
fair value of collateral received or posted subject to
enforceable credit support agreements.
• Resale agreements included in the consolidated balance
sheets of $190.45 billion as of September 2023 and
$225.12 billion as of December 2022 and all repurchase
agreements included in the consolidated balance sheets are
carried at fair value under the fair value option. See Note 4
for further information about the valuation techniques and
significant inputs used to determine fair value.
• Securities borrowed included in the consolidated balance
sheets of $36.79 billion as of September 2023 and
$38.58 billion as of December 2022, and securities loaned
included in the consolidated balance sheets of $8.18 billion
as of September 2023 and $4.37 billion as of December
2022 were at fair value under the fair value option. See
Note 5 for further information about securities borrowed
and securities loaned accounted for at fair value.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 54

-- 56 of 205 --

Gross Carrying Value of Repurchase Agreements and
Securities Loaned
The table below presents the gross carrying value of
repurchase agreements and securities loaned by class of
collateral pledged.
$ in millions
Repurchase
agreements
Securities
loaned
As of September 2023
Money market instruments $ 390 $ –
U.S. government and agency obligations 193,133 293
Non-U.S. government and agency obligations 81,023 2,691
Securities backed by commercial real estate 93 –
Securities backed by residential real estate 573 –
Corporate debt securities 14,746 338
State and municipal obligations 4 –
Other debt obligations 237 –
Equity securities 11,223 52,304
Total $ 301,422 $ 55,626
As of December 2022
Money market instruments $ 10 $ –
U.S. government and agency obligations 112,825 55
Non-U.S. government and agency obligations 87,828 594
Securities backed by commercial real estate 172 –
Securities backed by residential real estate 466 –
Corporate debt securities 11,398 295
State and municipal obligations 143 –
Other debt obligations 108 –
Equity securities 6,324 40,365
Total $ 219,274 $ 41,309
The table below presents the gross carrying value of
repurchase agreements and securities loaned by maturity.
As of September 2023
$ in millions
Repurchase
agreements
Securities
loaned
No stated maturity and overnight $ 114,306 $ 36,693
2 - 30 days 98,557 744
31 - 90 days 32,296 119
91 days - 1 year 42,783 8,603
Greater than 1 year 13,480 9,467
Total $ 301,422 $ 55,626
In the table above:
• Repurchase agreements and securities loaned that are
repayable prior to maturity at the option of the firm are
reflected at their contractual maturity dates.
• Repurchase agreements and securities loaned that are
redeemable prior to maturity at the option of the holder are
reflected at the earliest dates such options become
exercisable.
Other Secured Financings
In addition to repurchase agreements and securities loaned
transactions, the firm funds certain assets through the use of
other secured financings and pledges financial instruments
and other assets as collateral in these transactions. These
other secured financings include:
• Liabilities of consolidated investment entities and
consolidated VIEs;
• Transfers of assets accounted for as financings rather than
sales (e.g., pledged commodities, bank loans and mortgage
whole loans); and
• Other structured financing arrangements.
Other secured financings included nonrecourse
arrangements. Nonrecourse other secured financings were
$7.19 billion as of September 2023 and $7.94 billion as of
December 2022.
The firm has elected to apply the fair value option to
substantially all other secured financings because the use of
fair value eliminates non-economic volatility in earnings that
would arise from using different measurement attributes. See
Note 10 for further information about other secured
financings that are accounted for at fair value.
Other secured financings that are not recorded at fair value
are recorded based on the amount of cash received plus
accrued interest, which generally approximates fair value. As
these financings are not accounted for at fair value, they are
not included in the firm’s fair value hierarchy in Notes 4 and
5. Had these financings been included in the firm’s fair value
hierarchy, substantially all would have been classified in level
3 as of both September 2023 and December 2022.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
55 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 57 of 205 --

The table below presents information about other secured
financings.
$ in millions
U.S.
Dollar
Non-U.S.
Dollar Total
As of September 2023
Other secured financings (short-term):
At fair value $ 5,701 $ 2,632 $ 8,333
At amortized cost 1 348 349
Other secured financings (long-term):
At fair value 2,692 3,089 5,781
At amortized cost 265 – 265
Total other secured financings $ 8,659 $ 6,069 $ 14,728
Other secured financings collateralized by:
Financial instruments $ 4,666 $ 5,059 $ 9,725
Other assets $ 3,993 $ 1,010 $ 5,003
As of December 2022
Other secured financings (short-term):
At fair value $ 3,478 $ 2,963 $ 6,441
At amortized cost 398 – 398
Other secured financings (long-term):
At fair value 3,793 2,522 6,315
At amortized cost 395 397 792
Total other secured financings $ 8,064 $ 5,882 $ 13,946
Other secured financings collateralized by:
Financial instruments $ 3,817 $ 4,895 $ 8,712
Other assets $ 4,247 $ 987 $ 5,234
In the table above:
• Short-term other secured financings includes financings
maturing within one year of the financial statement date
and financings that are redeemable within one year of the
financial statement date at the option of the holder.
• U.S. dollar-denominated short-term other secured
financings at amortized cost had a weighted average
interest rate of 4.64% as of September 2023 and 5.56% as
of December 2022. These rates include the effect of hedging
activities.
• Non-U.S. dollar-denominated short-term other secured
financings at amortized cost had a weighted average
interest rate of 0.47% as of September 2023. This rate
includes the effect of hedging activities.
• U.S. dollar-denominated long-term other secured
financings at amortized cost had a weighted average
interest rate of 3.76% as of September 2023 and 3.54% as
of December 2022. These rates include the effect of hedging
activities.
• Non-U.S. dollar-denominated long-term other secured
financings at amortized cost had a weighted average
interest rate of 0.45% as of December 2022. This rate
includes the effect of hedging activities.
• Total other secured financings included $2.32 billion as of
September 2023 and $1.69 billion as of December 2022
related to transfers of financial assets accounted for as
financings rather than sales. Such financings were
collateralized by financial assets, primarily included in
trading assets, of $2.29 billion as of September 2023 and
$1.64 billion as of December 2022.
• Other secured financings collateralized by financial
instruments included $7.77 billion as of September 2023
and $7.49 billion as of December 2022 of other secured
financings collateralized by trading assets, investments and
loans, and included $1.95 billion as of September 2023 and
$1.22 billion as of December 2022 of other secured
financings collateralized by financial instruments received
as collateral and repledged.
The table below presents other secured financings by
maturity.
As of
$ in millions September 2023
Other secured financings (short-term) $ 8,682
Other secured financings (long-term):
2024 973
2025 1,569
2026 582
2027 215
2028 1,094
2029 - thereafter 1,613
Total other secured financings (long-term) 6,046
Total other secured financings $ 14,728
In the table above:
• Long-term other secured financings that are repayable
prior to maturity at the option of the firm are reflected at
their contractual maturity dates.
• Long-term other secured financings that are redeemable
prior to maturity at the option of the holder are reflected at
the earliest dates such options become exercisable.
Collateral Received and Pledged
The firm receives cash and securities (e.g., U.S. government
and agency obligations, other sovereign and corporate
obligations, as well as equity securities) as collateral,
primarily in connection with resale agreements, securities
borrowed, derivative transactions and customer margin
loans. The firm obtains cash and securities as collateral on an
upfront or contingent basis for derivative instruments and
collateralized agreements to reduce its credit exposure to
individual counterparties.
In many cases, the firm is permitted to deliver or repledge
financial instruments received as collateral when entering
into repurchase agreements and securities loaned
transactions, primarily in connection with secured client
financing activities. The firm is also permitted to deliver or
repledge these financial instruments in connection with other
secured financings, collateralized derivative transactions and
firm or customer settlement requirements.
The firm also pledges certain trading assets in connection
with repurchase agreements, securities loaned transactions
and other secured financings, and other assets (substantially
all real estate and cash) in connection with other secured
financings to counterparties who may or may not have the
right to deliver or repledge them.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 56

-- 58 of 205 --

The table below presents financial instruments at fair value
received as collateral that were available to be delivered or
repledged and were delivered or repledged.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Collateral available to be delivered or repledged $ 918,110 $ 971,699
Collateral that was delivered or repledged $ 794,719 $ 797,919
The table below presents information about assets pledged.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Pledged to counterparties that had the right to deliver or repledge
Trading assets $ 97,406 $ 40,143
Investments $ 8,463 $ 9,818
Pledged to counterparties that did not have the right to deliver or repledge
Trading assets $ 126,626 $ 70,912
Investments $ 19,090 $ 1,726
Loans $ 8,099 $ 6,600
Other assets $ 6,202 $ 7,525
The firm also segregates securities for regulatory and other
purposes related to client activity. Such securities are
segregated from trading assets and investments, as well as
from securities received as collateral under resale agreements
and securities borrowed transactions. Securities segregated by
the firm were $43.51 billion as of September 2023 and
$49.60 billion as of December 2022.
Note 12.
Other Assets
The table below presents other assets by type.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Property, leasehold improvements and equipment $ 13,138 $ 17,074
Goodwill 5,913 6,374
Identifiable intangible assets 1,341 2,009
Operating lease right-of-use assets 2,165 2,172
Income tax-related assets 7,360 7,012
Miscellaneous receivables and other 7,024 4,567
Total $ 36,941 $ 39,208
Property, Leasehold Improvements and Equipment
Property, leasehold improvements and equipment is net of
accumulated depreciation and amortization of $13.82 billion
as of September 2023 and $12.19 billion as of December 2022.
Property, leasehold improvements and equipment included
$6.62 billion as of September 2023 and $7.17 billion as of
December 2022 that the firm uses in connection with its
operations, and $52 million as of September 2023 and
$89 million as of December 2022 of foreclosed real estate
primarily related to distressed loans that were purchased by
the firm. The remainder is held by investment entities,
including VIEs, consolidated by the firm. Substantially all
property and equipment is depreciated on a straight-line basis
over the useful life of the asset. Leasehold improvements are
amortized on a straight-line basis over the shorter of the
useful life of the improvement or the term of the lease.
Capitalized costs of software developed or obtained for
internal use are amortized on a straight-line basis over three
years.
The firm tests property, leasehold improvements and
equipment for impairment when events or changes in
circumstances suggest that an asset’s or asset group’s carrying
value may not be fully recoverable. To the extent the carrying
value of an asset or asset group exceeds the projected
undiscounted cash flows expected to result from the use and
eventual disposal of the asset or asset group, the firm
determines the asset or asset group is impaired and records
an impairment equal to the difference between the estimated
fair value and the carrying value of the asset or asset group.
In addition, the firm will recognize an impairment prior to
the sale of an asset or asset group if the carrying value of the
asset or asset group exceeds its estimated fair value. Any
impairments recognized are included in depreciation and
amortization.
The firm had impairments of $358 million during the three
months ended September 2023, and $1.20 billion during the
nine months ended September 2023, related to commercial
real estate included in consolidated investment entities within
Asset & Wealth Management. In addition, the firm had
impairments of $80 million during the three months ended
September 2023, and $113 million during the nine months
ended September 2023, related to capitalized software
substantially all within Platform Solutions and Asset &
Wealth Management. The firm had impairments of $106
million during the three months ended September 2022 and
$130 million during the nine months ended September 2022,
related to consolidated investment entities within Asset &
Wealth Management.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
57 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 59 of 205 --

Goodwill
Goodwill is the cost of acquired companies in excess of the
fair value of net assets, including identifiable intangible
assets, at the acquisition date.
The table below presents the carrying value of goodwill by
reporting unit.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Global Banking & Markets:
Investment banking $ 267 $ 267
FICC 269 269
Equities 2,647 2,647
Asset & Wealth Management:
Asset management 1,376 1,385
Wealth management 1,340 1,310
Platform Solutions:
Consumer platforms – 482
Transaction banking and other 14 14
Total $ 5,913 $ 6,374
In the table above:
• The decrease in goodwill from December 2022 to
September 2023 was attributable to the impairment of
goodwill associated with Consumer platforms. During the
first quarter of 2023, goodwill for Consumer platforms
increased by $22 million as a result of an updated purchase
price allocation related to the GreenSky acquisition.
During the second quarter of 2023, in connection with the
exploration of a potential sale of GreenSky, the firm
performed a quantitative goodwill test and determined that
the goodwill associated with Consumer platforms was
impaired, and accordingly, recorded a $504 million
impairment.
• During 2022, goodwill increased by $2.09 billion,
substantially all in connection with the acquisitions of
GreenSky and NN Investment Partners (NNIP).
• Wealth management included $35 million of goodwill as of
September 2023 that was classified as held for sale in
connection with the planned sale of PFM.
Goodwill is assessed for impairment annually in the fourth
quarter or more frequently if events occur or circumstances
change that indicate an impairment may exist. When
assessing goodwill for impairment, first, a qualitative
assessment can be made to determine whether it is more
likely than not that the estimated fair value of a reporting
unit is less than its carrying value. If the results of the
qualitative assessment are not conclusive, a quantitative
goodwill test is performed. Alternatively, a quantitative
goodwill test can be performed without performing a
qualitative assessment.
The quantitative goodwill test compares the estimated fair
value of each reporting unit with its carrying value (including
goodwill and identifiable intangible assets). If the reporting
unit’s estimated fair value exceeds its carrying value,
goodwill is not impaired. An impairment is recognized if the
estimated fair value of a reporting unit is less than its
carrying value and any such impairment is included in
depreciation and amortization.
In the fourth quarter of 2022, goodwill was tested for
impairment using a quantitative test. The estimated fair value
of each of the reporting units exceeded its respective carrying
value, and therefore, goodwill was not impaired.
The estimated fair value of each reporting unit was based on
valuation techniques the firm believes market participants
would use to value these reporting units. Estimated fair
values are generally derived from utilizing a relative value
technique, which applies observable price-to-earnings
multiples or price-to-book multiples of comparable
competitors to the reporting units’ net earnings or net book
value, or a discounted cash flow valuation approach, for
reporting units with businesses in early stages of
development. The carrying value of each reporting unit
reflects an allocation of total shareholders’ equity and
represents the estimated amount of total shareholders’ equity
required to support the activities of the reporting unit under
currently applicable regulatory capital requirements.
Based on the evaluation of relevant factors during the first
nine months of 2023, other than the impairment noted above,
the firm determined that it was more likely than not that the
estimated fair value of each of the reporting units exceeded
its respective carrying value as of September 2023.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 58

-- 60 of 205 --

Identifiable Intangible Assets
The table below presents identifiable intangible assets by
type.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Customer lists and merchant relationships
Gross carrying value $ 3,208 $ 3,225
Accumulated amortization (1,904) (1,275)
Net carrying value 1,304 1,950
Acquired leases and other
Gross carrying value 480 486
Accumulated amortization (443) (427)
Net carrying value 37 59
Total gross carrying value 3,688 3,711
Total accumulated amortization (2,347) (1,702)
Total net carrying value $ 1,341 $ 2,009
In the table above:
• The decrease in identifiable intangible assets from
December 2022 to September 2023 was primarily
attributable to the $506 million write-down related to
GreenSky. These identifiable intangible assets, which are
included within Platform Solutions, were classified as held
for sale in connection with the planned sale of GreenSky
and had a net carrying value of $110 million as of
September 2023.
• As of September 2023, identifiable intangible assets of
approximately $165 million (substantially all customer
lists) were classified as held for sale in connection with the
planned sale of PFM. These identifiable intangible assets
are included within Asset & Wealth Management.
• During the nine months ended September 2023, the amount
of identifiable intangible assets acquired by the firm was
not material. The firm acquired approximately
$1.79 billion of identifiable intangible assets (with a
weighted average amortization period of 13 years) during
2022, substantially all in connection with the acquisitions
of GreenSky and NNIP. Substantially all of these
identifiable intangible assets consisted of customer lists and
merchant relationships.
• Substantially all of the firm’s identifiable intangible assets
have finite useful lives and are amortized over their
estimated useful lives generally using the straight-line
method.
The tables below present information about the amortization
of identifiable intangible assets.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Amortization $ 554 $ 54 $ 654 $ 124
In the table above, amortization for both the three and nine
months ended September 2023 included the $506 million
write-down related to GreenSky, which is included in
depreciation and amortization.
As of
$ in millions September 2023
Estimated future amortization
Remainder of 2023 $ 26
2024 $ 99
2025 $ 91
2026 $ 84
2027 $ 84
2028 $ 83
The firm tests identifiable intangible assets for impairment
when events or changes in circumstances suggest that an
asset’s or asset group’s carrying value may not be fully
recoverable. To the extent the carrying value of an asset or
asset group exceeds the projected undiscounted cash flows
expected to result from the use and eventual disposal of the
asset or asset group, the firm determines the asset or asset
group is impaired and records an impairment equal to the
difference between the estimated fair value and the carrying
value of the asset or asset group. In addition, the firm will
recognize an impairment prior to the sale of an asset or asset
group if the carrying value of the asset or asset group exceeds
its estimated fair value. There were no material impairments
during each of the three and nine months ended September
2023 or September 2022.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
59 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 61 of 205 --

Operating Lease Right-of-Use Assets
The firm enters into operating leases for real estate, office
equipment and other assets, substantially all of which are
used in connection with its operations. For leases longer than
one year, the firm recognizes a right-of-use asset representing
the right to use the underlying asset for the lease term, and a
lease liability representing the liability to make payments.
The lease term is generally determined based on the
contractual maturity of the lease. For leases where the firm
has the option to terminate or extend the lease, an assessment
of the likelihood of exercising the option is incorporated into
the determination of the lease term. Such assessment is
initially performed at the inception of the lease and is
updated if events occur that impact the original assessment.
An operating lease right-of-use asset is initially determined
based on the operating lease liability, adjusted for initial
direct costs, lease incentives and amounts paid at or prior to
lease commencement. This amount is then amortized over
the lease term. Right-of-use assets and operating lease
liabilities recognized (in non-cash transactions for leases
entered into or assumed) by the firm were $225 million for
the three months ended September 2023, $52 million for the
three months ended September 2022, $306 million for the
nine months ended September 2023 and $168 million for the
nine months ended September 2022. See Note 15 for
information about operating lease liabilities.
For leases where the firm will derive no economic benefit
from leased space that it has vacated or where the firm has
shortened the term of a lease when space is no longer needed,
the firm will record an impairment or accelerated
amortization of right-of-use assets. There were no material
impairments or accelerated amortizations during each of the
three and nine months ended September 2023 or September
2022.
Miscellaneous Receivables and Other
Miscellaneous receivables and other included:
• Investments in qualified affordable housing projects of
$1.42 billion as of September 2023 and $793 million as of
December 2022. The firm accounts for these investments
using the proportional amortization method such that the
investment is amortized in proportion to the income tax
credits received on such investments. The amortization of
investments and the related income tax credit are recorded
as a component of the provision for taxes. During the nine
months ended September 2023, the firm recognized
amortization of $210 million and related income tax credits
of $257 million, and during the nine months ended
September 2022, the firm recognized amortization of
$88 million and related income tax credits of $117 million.
The amortization and the related tax credits were not
material for either the three months ended September 2023
or September 2022.
• Assets classified as held for sale were $1.68 billion as of
September 2023 and $285 million as of December 2022. See
below for further information.
Assets Held for Sale. During the third quarter of 2023, in
connection with the planned sale of GreenSky, the firm
classified GreenSky (within Platform Solutions) as held for
sale. After a reserve release of $637 million in provision for
credit losses and a markdown of $123 million to reflect the
loan portfolio at the lower of its carrying value or fair value
less cost to sell, the firm wrote down $506 million of net
assets of GreenSky (included in depreciation and
amortization). As of September 2023, the assets of GreenSky
were approximately $6.3 billion and consisted of loans of
approximately $6.0 billion (included in loans), segregated
cash of approximately $130 million (included in cash and
cash equivalents), identifiable intangible assets of
approximately $110 million (included in identifiable
intangible assets within other assets) and other assets of
approximately $190 million (included in miscellaneous
receivables and other within other assets). See Note 9 for
further information about loans classified as held for sale,
above for further information about identifiable intangible
assets, and Note 15 for information about liabilities classified
as held for sale.
In addition, during the third quarter of 2023, in connection
with the planned sale of PFM, the firm classified PFM (within
Asset & Wealth Management) as held for sale. As of
September 2023, assets related to this business were
approximately $200 million. These assets included
identifiable intangible assets of $165 million (included in
identifiable intangible assets within other assets) and
goodwill of $35 million (included in goodwill within other
assets). See above for further information about goodwill and
identifiable intangible assets.
Assets held for sale also included $1.49 billion as of
September 2023 and $285 million as of December 2022 of
assets related to certain of the firm’s consolidated
investments within Asset & Wealth Management.
Substantially all of these assets consisted of property and
equipment and were included in miscellaneous receivables
and other within other assets.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 60

-- 62 of 205 --

Note 13.
Deposits
The table below presents the types and sources of deposits.
$ in millions
Savings and
Demand Time Total
As of September 2023
Consumer $ 117,177 $ 33,392 $ 150,569
Private bank 85,109 6,319 91,428
Brokered certificates of deposit – 33,852 33,852
Deposit sweep programs 32,227 – 32,227
Transaction banking 65,096 2,813 67,909
Other 1,931 25,046 26,977
Total $ 301,540 $ 101,422 $ 402,962
As of December 2022
Consumer $ 98,580 $ 21,330 $ 119,910
Private bank 94,133 11,716 105,849
Brokered certificates of deposit – 32,624 32,624
Deposit sweep programs 44,819 – 44,819
Transaction banking 65,155 5,069 70,224
Other 808 12,431 13,239
Total $ 303,495 $ 83,170 $ 386,665
In the table above:
• Substantially all deposits are interest-bearing.
• Savings and demand accounts consist of money market
deposit accounts, negotiable order of withdrawal accounts
and demand deposit accounts that have no stated maturity
or expiration date.
• Time deposits included $28.56 billion as of September 2023
and $15.75 billion as of December 2022 of deposits
accounted for at fair value under the fair value option. See
Note 10 for further information about deposits accounted
for at fair value.
• Time deposits had a weighted average maturity of
approximately 0.7 years as of September 2023 and 0.9 years
as of December 2022.
• Consumer deposits consist of deposits from both Marcus
and Apple Card customers.
• Deposit sweep programs include long-term contractual
agreements with U.S. broker-dealers who sweep client cash
to FDIC-insured deposits.
• Transaction banking deposits consist of deposits that the
firm raised through its cash management services business
for corporate and other institutional clients.
• Other deposits are substantially all from institutional
clients.
• Deposits insured by the FDIC were $208.03 billion as of
September 2023 and $184.88 billion as of December 2022.
• Deposits insured by non-U.S. insurance programs were
$24.27 billion as of September 2023 and $31.74 billion as of
December 2022. The decline in insured deposits from
December 2022 reflected a change in an insurance program
that became effective in January 2023, which reduced the
population of deposit accounts eligible for insurance
coverage and lowered the applicable insurance limits.
The table below presents the location of deposits.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
U.S. offices $ 313,085 $ 313,598
Non-U.S. offices 89,877 73,067
Total $ 402,962 $ 386,665
In the table above, U.S. deposits were held at Goldman Sachs
Bank USA (GS Bank USA) and substantially all non-U.S.
deposits were held at Goldman Sachs International Bank
(GSIB) and Goldman Sachs Bank Europe SE (GSBE).
The table below presents maturities of time deposits held in
U.S. and non-U.S. offices.
As of September 2023
$ in millions U.S. Non-U.S. Total
Remainder of 2023 $ 15,112 $ 18,317 $ 33,429
2024 45,259 11,472 56,731
2025 4,266 472 4,738
2026 2,719 339 3,058
2027 1,236 187 1,423
2028 669 178 847
2029 - thereafter 945 251 1,196
Total $ 70,206 $ 31,216 $ 101,422
As of September 2023, deposits in U.S. offices included $12.25
billion and deposits in non-U.S. offices included $30.53
billion of time deposits in denominations that met or
exceeded the applicable insurance limits, or were otherwise
not covered by insurance.
The firm’s savings and demand deposits are recorded based
on the amount of cash received plus accrued interest, which
approximates fair value. In addition, the firm designates
certain derivatives as fair value hedges to convert a portion of
its time deposits not accounted for at fair value from fixed-
rate obligations into floating-rate obligations. The carrying
value of time deposits not accounted for at fair value
approximated fair value as of both September 2023 and
December 2022. As these savings and demand deposits and
time deposits are not accounted for at fair value, they are not
included in the firm’s fair value hierarchy in Notes 4 and 5.
Had these deposits been included in the firm’s fair value
hierarchy, they would have been classified in level 2 as of
both September 2023 and December 2022.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
61 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 63 of 205 --

Note 14.
Unsecured Borrowings
The table below presents information about unsecured
borrowings.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Unsecured short-term borrowings $ 70,009 $ 60,961
Unsecured long-term borrowings 224,024 247,138
Total $ 294,033 $ 308,099
Unsecured Short-Term Borrowings
Unsecured short-term borrowings includes the portion of
unsecured long-term borrowings maturing within one year of
the financial statement date and unsecured long-term
borrowings that are redeemable within one year of the
financial statement date at the option of the holder.
The firm accounts for certain hybrid financial instruments at
fair value under the fair value option. See Note 10 for further
information about unsecured short-term borrowings that are
accounted for at fair value. In addition, the firm designates
certain derivatives as fair value hedges to convert a portion of
its unsecured short-term borrowings not accounted for at fair
value from fixed-rate obligations into floating-rate
obligations. The carrying value of unsecured short-term
borrowings that are not recorded at fair value generally
approximates fair value due to the short-term nature of the
obligations. As these unsecured short-term borrowings are
not accounted for at fair value, they are not included in the
firm’s fair value hierarchy in Notes 4 and 5. Had these
borrowings been included in the firm’s fair value hierarchy,
substantially all would have been classified in level 2 as of
both September 2023 and December 2022.
The table below presents information about unsecured short-
term borrowings.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Current portion of unsecured long-term borrowings $ 47,376 $ 38,635
Hybrid financial instruments 19,033 18,383
Commercial paper 1,455 1,718
Other unsecured short-term borrowings 2,145 2,225
Total unsecured short-term borrowings $ 70,009 $ 60,961
Weighted average interest rate 3.55% 3.71%
In the table above, the weighted average interest rates for
these borrowings include the effect of hedging activities and
exclude unsecured short-term borrowings accounted for at
fair value under the fair value option. See Note 7 for further
information about hedging activities.
Unsecured Long-Term Borrowings
The table below presents information about unsecured long-
term borrowings.
$ in millions U.S. Dollar
Non-U.S.
Dollar Total
As of September 2023
Fixed-rate obligations $ 107,989 $ 32,176 $ 140,165
Floating-rate obligations 50,834 33,025 83,859
Total $ 158,823 $ 65,201 $ 224,024
As of December 2022
Fixed-rate obligations $ 118,986 $ 38,538 $ 157,524
Floating-rate obligations 55,689 33,925 89,614
Total $ 174,675 $ 72,463 $ 247,138
In the table above:
• Unsecured long-term borrowings consists principally of
senior borrowings, which have maturities extending
through 2061.
• Floating-rate obligations includes equity-linked, credit-
linked and indexed instruments. Floating interest rates are
generally based on SOFR and Euro Interbank Offered
Rate. In connection with the cessation of USD London
Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR), as of July 1, 2023, the
firm replaced the USD LIBOR rate with term SOFR plus
the statutorily prescribed tenor spread.
• U.S. dollar-denominated debt had interest rates ranging
from 0.86% to 6.75% (with a weighted average rate of
3.62%) as of September 2023 and 0.66% to 6.75% (with a
weighted average rate of 3.51%) as of December 2022.
These rates exclude unsecured long-term borrowings
accounted for at fair value under the fair value option.
• Non-U.S. dollar-denominated debt had interest rates
ranging from 0.25% to 7.25% (with a weighted average
rate of 2.08%) as of September 2023 and 0.13% to 7.25%
(with a weighted average rate of 1.85%) as of December
2022. These rates exclude unsecured long-term borrowings
accounted for at fair value under the fair value option.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 62

-- 64 of 205 --

The table below presents unsecured long-term borrowings by
maturity.
As of
$ in millions September 2023
2024 $ 13,961
2025 38,812
2026 27,758
2027 33,223
2028 24,301
2029 - thereafter 85,969
Total $ 224,024
In the table above:
• Unsecured long-term borrowings maturing within one year
of the financial statement date and unsecured long-term
borrowings that are redeemable within one year of the
financial statement date at the option of the holder are
excluded as they are included in unsecured short-term
borrowings.
• Unsecured long-term borrowings that are repayable prior
to maturity at the option of the firm are reflected at their
contractual maturity dates.
• Unsecured long-term borrowings that are redeemable prior
to maturity at the option of the holder are reflected at the
earliest dates such options become exercisable.
• Unsecured long-term borrowings included $(16.93) billion
of adjustments to the carrying value of certain unsecured
long-term borrowings resulting from the application of
hedge accounting by year of maturity as follows: $(78)
million in 2024, $(999) million in 2025, $(778) million in
2026, $(1.57) billion in 2027, $(1.69) billion in 2028 and
$(11.81) billion in 2029 and thereafter.
The firm designates certain derivatives as fair value hedges to
convert a portion of fixed-rate unsecured long-term
borrowings not accounted for at fair value into floating-rate
obligations. See Note 7 for further information about hedging
activities.
The table below presents unsecured long-term borrowings,
after giving effect to such hedging activities.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Fixed-rate obligations:
At fair value $ 8,121 $ 6,147
At amortized cost 9,798 6,065
Floating-rate obligations:
At fair value 65,795 67,000
At amortized cost 140,310 167,926
Total $ 224,024 $ 247,138
In the table above, the aggregate amounts of unsecured long-
term borrowings had weighted average interest rates of
6.01% (2.79% related to fixed-rate obligations and 6.21%
related to floating-rate obligations) as of September 2023 and
4.97% (4.08% related to fixed-rate obligations and 5.00%
related to floating-rate obligations) as of December 2022.
These rates exclude unsecured long-term borrowings
accounted for at fair value under the fair value option.
The carrying value of unsecured long-term borrowings for
which the firm did not elect the fair value option was $150.11
billion as of September 2023 and $173.99 billion as of
December 2022. The estimated fair value of such unsecured
long-term borrowings was $150.39 billion as of September
2023 and $173.70 billion as of December 2022. As these
borrowings are not accounted for at fair value, they are not
included in the firm’s fair value hierarchy in Notes 4 and 5.
Had these borrowings been included in the firm’s fair value
hierarchy, substantially all would have been classified in level
2 as of both September 2023 and December 2022.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
63 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 65 of 205 --

Subordinated Borrowings
Unsecured long-term borrowings includes subordinated debt
and junior subordinated debt. Subordinated debt that
matures within one year is included in unsecured short-term
borrowings. Junior subordinated debt is junior in right of
payment to other subordinated borrowings, which are junior
to senior borrowings. Long-term subordinated debt had
maturities ranging from 2025 to 2045 as of both September
2023 and December 2022.
The table below presents information about subordinated
borrowings.
$ in millions
Par
Amount
Carrying
Value Rate
As of September 2023
Subordinated debt $ 12,145 $ 10,910 7.70%
Junior subordinated debt 968 985 6.35%
Total $ 13,113 $ 11,895 7.60%
As of December 2022
Subordinated debt $ 12,261 $ 11,882 6.40%
Junior subordinated debt 968 1,054 4.86%
Total $ 13,229 $ 12,936 6.29%
In the table above, the rate is the weighted average interest
rate for these borrowings (excluding borrowings accounted
for at fair value under the fair value option), including the
effect of fair value hedges used to convert fixed-rate
obligations into floating-rate obligations. See Note 7 for
further information about hedging activities.
Junior Subordinated Debt
In 2004, Group Inc. issued $2.84 billion of junior
subordinated debt to Goldman Sachs Capital I, a Delaware
statutory trust. Goldman Sachs Capital I issued $2.75 billion
of guaranteed preferred beneficial interests (Trust Preferred
securities) to third parties and $85 million of common
beneficial interests to Group Inc. As of both September 2023
and December 2022, the outstanding par amount of junior
subordinated debt held by Goldman Sachs Capital I was $968
million and the outstanding par amount of Trust Preferred
securities and common beneficial interests issued by
Goldman Sachs Capital I was $939 million and $29 million,
respectively. Goldman Sachs Capital I is a wholly-owned
finance subsidiary of the firm for regulatory and legal
purposes but is not consolidated for accounting purposes.
The firm pays interest semi-annually on the junior
subordinated debt at an annual rate of 6.345% and the debt
matures on February 15, 2034. The coupon rate and the
payment dates applicable to the beneficial interests are the
same as the interest rate and payment dates for the junior
subordinated debt. The firm has the right, from time to time,
to defer payment of interest on the junior subordinated debt,
and therefore cause payment on Goldman Sachs Capital I’s
preferred beneficial interests to be deferred, in each case up to
ten consecutive semi-annual periods. During any such
deferral period, the firm will not be permitted to, among
other things, pay dividends on or make certain repurchases of
its common stock. Goldman Sachs Capital I is not permitted
to pay any distributions on the common beneficial interests
held by Group Inc. unless all dividends payable on the
preferred beneficial interests have been paid in full.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 64

-- 66 of 205 --

Note 15.
Other Liabilities
The table below presents other liabilities by type.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Compensation and benefits $ 6,534 $ 7,225
Income tax-related liabilities 2,982 2,669
Operating lease liabilities 2,222 2,154
Noncontrolling interests 471 649
Employee interests in consolidated funds 19 25
Accrued expenses and other 7,855 8,733
Total $ 20,083 $ 21,455
Operating Lease Liabilities
For leases longer than one year, the firm recognizes a right-
of-use asset representing the right to use the underlying asset
for the lease term, and a lease liability representing the
liability to make payments. See Note 12 for information
about operating lease right-of-use assets.
The table below presents information about operating lease
liabilities.
$ in millions
Operating
lease liabilities
As of September 2023
Remainder of 2023 $ 54
2024 365
2025 314
2026 278
2027 247
2028 - thereafter 1,585
Total undiscounted lease payments 2,843
Imputed interest (621)
Total operating lease liabilities $ 2,222
Weighted average remaining lease term 12 years
Weighted average discount rate 4.04%
As of December 2022
2023 $ 325
2024 334
2025 283
2026 236
2027 203
2028 - thereafter 1,424
Total undiscounted lease payments 2,805
Imputed interest (651)
Total operating lease liabilities $ 2,154
Weighted average remaining lease term 13 years
Weighted average discount rate 3.66%
In the table above, the weighted average discount rate
represents the firm’s incremental borrowing rate as of
January 2019 for operating leases existing on the date of
adoption of ASU No. 2016-02, “Leases (Topic 842),” and at
the lease inception date for leases entered into subsequent to
the adoption of this ASU.
Operating lease costs were $124 million for the three months
ended September 2023, $111 million for the three months
ended September 2022, $362 million for the nine months
ended September 2023 and $348 million for the nine months
ended September 2022. Variable lease costs, which are
included in operating lease costs, were not material for each
of the three and nine months ended September 2023 and
September 2022. Total occupancy expenses for space held in
excess of the firm’s current requirements were not material
for each of the three and nine months ended September 2023
and September 2022.
Lease payments relating to operating lease arrangements that
were signed but had not yet commenced were $1.10 billion as
of September 2023.
Accrued Expenses and Other
Accrued expenses and other included:
• Liabilities classified as held for sale were approximately
$680 million as of September 2023 and were not material as
of December 2022. As of September 2023, such liabilities
included $270 million related to GreenSky within Platform
Solutions and consisted primarily of customer and other
payables. Substantially all of the remaining $410 million of
liabilities classified as held for sale related to certain of the
firm’s consolidated investments within Asset & Wealth
Management. Substantially all such liabilities consisted of
other secured financings. See Note 12 for further
information about assets held for sale.
• Contract liabilities, which represent consideration received
by the firm in connection with its contracts with clients
prior to providing the service, were $112 million as of
September 2023 and $113 million as of December 2022.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
65 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 67 of 205 --

Note 16.
Securitization Activities
The firm securitizes residential and commercial mortgages,
corporate bonds, loans and other types of financial assets by
selling these assets to securitization vehicles (e.g., trusts,
corporate entities and limited liability companies) or through
a resecuritization. The firm acts as underwriter of the
beneficial interests that are sold to investors. The firm’s
residential mortgage securitizations are primarily in
connection with government agency securitizations.
The firm accounts for a securitization as a sale when it has
relinquished control over the transferred financial assets.
Prior to securitization, the firm generally accounts for assets
pending transfer at fair value and therefore does not typically
recognize significant gains or losses upon the transfer of
assets. Net revenues from underwriting activities are
recognized in connection with the sales of the underlying
beneficial interests to investors.
The firm generally receives cash in exchange for the
transferred assets but may also have continuing involvement
with the transferred financial assets, including ownership of
beneficial interests in securitized financial assets, primarily in
the form of debt instruments. The firm may also purchase
senior or subordinated securities issued by securitization
vehicles (which are typically VIEs) in connection with
secondary market-making activities.
The primary risks included in beneficial interests and other
interests from the firm’s continuing involvement with
securitization vehicles are the performance of the underlying
collateral, the position of the firm’s investment in the capital
structure of the securitization vehicle and the market yield for
the security. Interests accounted for at fair value are
primarily classified in level 2 of the fair value hierarchy.
Interests not accounted for at fair value are carried at
amounts that approximate fair value. See Note 4 for further
information about fair value measurements.
The table below presents the amount of financial assets
securitized and the cash flows received on retained interests
in securitization entities in which the firm had continuing
involvement as of the end of the period.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Residential mortgages $ 6,894 $ 6,128 $ 18,267 $ 25,069
Commercial mortgages 1,798 2,306 3,196 13,820
Other financial assets – 902 996 3,519
Total financial assets securitized $ 8,692 $ 9,336 $ 22,459 $ 42,408
Retained interests cash flows $ 187 $ 125 $ 407 $ 428
The firm securitized assets of $39 million during the three
months ended September 2023, $382 million during the three
months ended September 2022, $149 million during the nine
months ended September 2023 and $781 million during the
nine months ended September 2022, in a non-cash exchange
for loans and investments.
The table below presents information about nonconsolidated
securitization entities to which the firm sold assets and had
continuing involvement as of the end of the period.
$ in millions
Outstanding
Principal
Amount
Retained
Interests
Purchased
Interests
As of September 2023
U.S. government agency-issued CMOs $ 34,962 $ 2,508 $ –
Other residential mortgage-backed 29,302 1,186 71
Other commercial mortgage-backed 60,304 1,236 62
Corporate debt and other asset-backed 8,044 508 40
Total $ 132,612 $ 5,438 $ 173
As of December 2022
U.S. government agency-issued CMOs $ 38,617 $ 1,835 $ –
Other residential mortgage-backed 27,075 1,461 117
Other commercial mortgage-backed 59,688 1,349 82
Corporate debt and other asset-backed 8,750 398 46
Total $ 134,130 $ 5,043 $ 245
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 66

-- 68 of 205 --

In the table above:
• CMOs represents collateralized mortgage obligations.
• The outstanding principal amount is presented for the
purpose of providing information about the size of the
securitization entities and is not representative of the firm’s
risk of loss.
• The firm’s risk of loss from retained or purchased interests
is limited to the carrying value of these interests.
• Purchased interests represent senior and subordinated
interests, purchased in connection with secondary market-
making activities, in securitization entities in which the
firm also holds retained interests.
• Substantially all of the total outstanding principal amount
and total retained interests relate to securitizations during
2018 and thereafter.
• The fair value of retained interests was $5.36 billion as of
September 2023 and $5.03 billion as of December 2022.
In addition to the interests in the table above, the firm had
other continuing involvement in the form of derivative
transactions and commitments with certain nonconsolidated
VIEs. The carrying value of these derivatives and
commitments was a net asset of $133 million as of September
2023 and $72 million as of December 2022, and the notional
amount of these derivatives and commitments was $1.88
billion as of September 2023 and $1.90 billion as of December
2022. The notional amounts of these derivatives and
commitments are included in maximum exposure to loss in
the nonconsolidated VIE table in Note 17. Additionally,
during the nine months ended September 2023, the firm
provided seller financing of approximately $2.7 billion in
connection with the sale of $3.24 billion of Marcus loans. As
of September 2023, the total outstanding principal amount of
such seller financing was $2.18 billion.
The table below presents information about the weighted
average key economic assumptions used in measuring the fair
value of mortgage-backed retained interests.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Fair value of retained interests $ 4,865 $ 4,644
Weighted average life (years) 6.3 6.6
Constant prepayment rate 9.3% 7.7%
Impact of 10% adverse change $ (47) $ (27)
Impact of 20% adverse change $ (91) $ (48)
Discount rate 8.3% 9.5%
Impact of 10% adverse change $ (135) $ (138)
Impact of 20% adverse change $ (265) $ (266)
In the table above:
• Amounts do not reflect the benefit of other financial
instruments that are held to mitigate risks inherent in these
retained interests.
• Changes in fair value based on an adverse variation in
assumptions generally cannot be extrapolated because the
relationship of the change in assumptions to the change in
fair value is not usually linear.
• The impact of a change in a particular assumption is
calculated independently of changes in any other
assumption. In practice, simultaneous changes in
assumptions might magnify or counteract the sensitivities
disclosed above.
• The constant prepayment rate is included only for
positions for which it is a key assumption in the
determination of fair value.
• The discount rate for retained interests that relate to U.S.
government agency-issued CMOs does not include any
credit loss. Expected credit loss assumptions are reflected in
the discount rate for the remainder of retained interests.
The firm has other retained interests not reflected in the table
above with a fair value of $490 million and a weighted
average life of 6.4 years as of September 2023, and a fair
value of $384 million and a weighted average life of 6.4 years
as of December 2022. Due to the nature and fair value of
certain of these retained interests, the weighted average
assumptions for constant prepayment and discount rates and
the related sensitivity to adverse changes are not meaningful
as of both September 2023 and December 2022. The firm’s
maximum exposure to adverse changes in the value of these
interests is the carrying value of $508 million as of September
2023 and $398 million as of December 2022.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
67 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 69 of 205 --

Note 17.
Variable Interest Entities
A variable interest in a VIE is an investment (e.g., debt or
equity) or other interest (e.g., derivatives or loans and lending
commitments) that will absorb portions of the VIE’s expected
losses and/or receive portions of the VIE’s expected residual
returns.
The firm’s variable interests in VIEs include senior and
subordinated debt; loans and lending commitments; limited
and general partnership interests; preferred and common
equity; derivatives that may include foreign currency, equity
and/or credit risk; guarantees; and certain of the fees the firm
receives from investment funds. Certain interest rate, foreign
currency and credit derivatives the firm enters into with VIEs
are not variable interests because they create, rather than
absorb, risk.
VIEs generally finance the purchase of assets by issuing debt
and equity securities that are either collateralized by or
indexed to the assets held by the VIE. The debt and equity
securities issued by a VIE may include tranches of varying
levels of subordination. The firm’s involvement with VIEs
includes securitization of financial assets, as described in
Note 16, and investments in and loans to other types of VIEs,
as described below. See Note 3 for the firm’s consolidation
policies, including the definition of a VIE.
VIE Consolidation Analysis
The enterprise with a controlling financial interest in a VIE is
known as the primary beneficiary and consolidates the VIE.
The firm determines whether it is the primary beneficiary of a
VIE by performing an analysis that principally considers:
• Which variable interest holder has the power to direct the
activities of the VIE that most significantly impact the
VIE’s economic performance;
• Which variable interest holder has the obligation to absorb
losses or the right to receive benefits from the VIE that
could potentially be significant to the VIE;
• The VIE’s purpose and design, including the risks the VIE
was designed to create and pass through to its variable
interest holders;
• The VIE’s capital structure;
• The terms between the VIE and its variable interest holders
and other parties involved with the VIE; and
• Related-party relationships.
The firm reassesses its evaluation of whether an entity is a
VIE when certain reconsideration events occur. The firm
reassesses its determination of whether it is the primary
beneficiary of a VIE on an ongoing basis based on current
facts and circumstances.
VIE Activities
The firm is principally involved with VIEs through the
following business activities:
Mortgage-Backed VIEs. The firm sells residential and
commercial mortgage loans and securities to mortgage-
backed VIEs and may retain beneficial interests in the assets
sold to these VIEs. The firm purchases and sells beneficial
interests issued by mortgage-backed VIEs in connection with
market-making activities. In addition, the firm may enter into
derivatives with certain of these VIEs, primarily interest rate
swaps, which are typically not variable interests. The firm
generally enters into derivatives with other counterparties to
mitigate its risk.
Real Estate, Credit- and Power-Related and Other
Investing VIEs. The firm purchases equity and debt
securities issued by and makes loans to VIEs that hold real
estate (including qualified affordable housing projects),
performing and nonperforming debt, distressed loans, power-
related assets and equity securities. The firm generally does
not sell assets to, or enter into derivatives with, these VIEs.
Corporate Debt and Other Asset-Backed VIEs. The firm
structures VIEs that issue notes to clients, purchases and sells
beneficial interests issued by corporate debt and other asset-
backed VIEs in connection with market-making activities,
and makes loans to VIEs that warehouse corporate debt.
Certain of these VIEs synthetically create the exposure for the
beneficial interests they issue by entering into credit
derivatives with the firm, rather than purchasing the
underlying assets. In addition, the firm may enter into
derivatives, such as total return swaps, with certain corporate
debt and other asset-backed VIEs, under which the firm pays
the VIE a return due to the beneficial interest holders and
receives the return on the collateral owned by the VIE. The
collateral owned by these VIEs is primarily other asset-
backed loans and securities. The firm may be removed as the
total return swap counterparty and may enter into derivatives
with other counterparties to mitigate its risk related to these
swaps. The firm may sell assets to the corporate debt and
other asset-backed VIEs it structures.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 68

-- 70 of 205 --

Principal-Protected Note VIEs. The firm structures VIEs
that issue principal-protected notes to clients. These VIEs
own portfolios of assets, principally with exposure to hedge
funds. Substantially all of the principal protection on the
notes issued by these VIEs is provided by the asset portfolio
rebalancing that is required under the terms of the notes. The
firm enters into total return swaps with these VIEs under
which the firm pays the VIE the return due to the principal-
protected note holders and receives the return on the assets
owned by the VIE. The firm may enter into derivatives with
other counterparties to mitigate its risk. The firm also
obtains funding through these VIEs.
Investments in Funds. The firm makes equity investments
in certain investment fund VIEs it manages and is entitled to
receive fees from these VIEs. The firm has generally not sold
assets to, or entered into derivatives with, these VIEs.
Nonconsolidated VIEs
The table below presents a summary of the nonconsolidated
VIEs in which the firm holds variable interests.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Total nonconsolidated VIEs
Assets in VIEs $ 190,941 $ 181,697
Carrying value of variable interests — assets $ 14,076 $ 12,325
Carrying value of variable interests — liabilities $ 924 $ 659
Maximum exposure to loss:
Retained interests $ 5,438 $ 5,043
Purchased interests 905 861
Commitments and guarantees 3,994 3,087
Derivatives 8,623 8,802
Debt and equity 7,314 6,026
Total $ 26,274 $ 23,819
In the table above:
• The nature of the firm’s variable interests is described in
the rows under maximum exposure to loss.
• The firm’s exposure to the obligations of VIEs is generally
limited to its interests in these entities. In certain instances,
the firm provides guarantees, including derivative
guarantees, to VIEs or holders of variable interests in VIEs.
• The maximum exposure to loss excludes the benefit of
offsetting financial instruments that are held to mitigate the
risks associated with these variable interests.
• The maximum exposure to loss from retained interests,
purchased interests, and debt and equity is the carrying
value of these interests.
• The maximum exposure to loss from commitments and
guarantees, and derivatives is the notional amount, which
does not represent anticipated losses and has not been
reduced by unrealized losses. As a result, the maximum
exposure to loss exceeds liabilities recorded for
commitments and guarantees, and derivatives.
The table below presents information, by principal business
activity, for nonconsolidated VIEs included in the summary
table above.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Mortgage-backed
Assets in VIEs $ 126,178 $ 127,290
Carrying value of variable interests — assets $ 5,187 $ 4,977
Maximum exposure to loss:
Retained interests $ 4,930 $ 4,645
Purchased interests 256 332
Commitments and guarantees 34 64
Derivatives 2 2
Total $ 5,222 $ 5,043
Real estate, credit- and power-related and other investing
Assets in VIEs $ 40,553 $ 29,193
Carrying value of variable interests — assets $ 4,543 $ 4,415
Carrying value of variable interests — liabilities $ 346 $ 2
Maximum exposure to loss:
Commitments and guarantees $ 3,320 $ 2,679
Debt and equity 4,541 4,414
Total $ 7,861 $ 7,093
Corporate debt and other asset-backed
Assets in VIEs $ 19,827 $ 19,428
Carrying value of variable interests — assets $ 4,254 $ 2,817
Carrying value of variable interests — liabilities $ 578 $ 657
Maximum exposure to loss:
Retained interests $ 508 $ 398
Purchased interests 649 529
Commitments and guarantees 638 190
Derivatives 8,621 8,800
Debt and equity 2,681 1,496
Total $ 13,097 $ 11,413
Investments in funds
Assets in VIEs $ 4,383 $ 5,786
Carrying value of variable interests — assets $ 92 $ 116
Maximum exposure to loss:
Commitments and guarantees $ 2 $ 154
Debt and equity 92 116
Total $ 94 $ 270
As of both September 2023 and December 2022, the carrying
values of the firm’s variable interests in nonconsolidated VIEs
are included in the consolidated balance sheets as follows:
• Mortgage-backed: Assets primarily included in trading
assets and loans.
• Real estate, credit- and power-related and other investing:
Assets primarily included in investments and loans, and
liabilities included in trading liabilities and other liabilities.
• Corporate debt and other asset-backed: Assets included in
loans and trading assets, and liabilities included in trading
liabilities.
• Investments in funds: Assets included in investments.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
69 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 71 of 205 --

Consolidated VIEs
The table below presents a summary of the carrying value
and balance sheet classification of assets and liabilities in
consolidated VIEs.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Total consolidated VIEs
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents $ 382 $ 348
Customer and other receivables 333 7
Trading assets 131 103
Investments 77 101
Loans 310 1,177
Other assets 237 336
Total $ 1,470 $ 2,072
Liabilities
Other secured financings $ 774 $ 952
Customer and other payables 2 51
Trading liabilities – 9
Unsecured short-term borrowings 13 58
Unsecured long-term borrowings 15 16
Other liabilities 89 112
Total $ 893 $ 1,198
In the table above:
• Assets and liabilities are presented net of intercompany
eliminations and exclude the benefit of offsetting financial
instruments that are held to mitigate the risks associated
with the firm’s variable interests.
• VIEs in which the firm holds a majority voting interest are
excluded if (i) the VIE meets the definition of a business
and (ii) the VIE’s assets can be used for purposes other than
the settlement of its obligations.
• Substantially all assets can only be used to settle
obligations of the VIE.
The table below presents information, by principal business
activity, for consolidated VIEs included in the summary table
above.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Real estate, credit-related and other investing
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents $ 362 $ 339
Customer and other receivables – 7
Trading assets 38 42
Investments 77 101
Loans 310 1,177
Other assets 237 336
Total $ 1,024 $ 2,002
Liabilities
Other secured financings $ 139 $ 170
Customer and other payables 2 51
Trading liabilities – 9
Other liabilities 89 112
Total $ 230 $ 342
Corporate debt and other asset-backed
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents $ 20 $ 9
Trading assets 4 20
Total $ 24 $ 29
Liabilities
Other secured financings $ 353 $ 482
Total $ 353 $ 482
Principal-protected notes
Assets
Customer and other receivables $ 333 $ –
Trading assets $ 89 $ 41
Total $ 422 $ 41
Liabilities
Other secured financings $ 282 $ 300
Unsecured short-term borrowings 13 58
Unsecured long-term borrowings 15 16
Total $ 310 $ 374
In the table above, creditors and beneficial interest holders of
real estate, credit-related and other investing VIEs do not
have recourse to the general credit of the firm.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 70

-- 72 of 205 --

Note 18.
Commitments, Contingencies and Guarantees
Commitments
The table below presents commitments by type.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Commitment Type
Commercial lending:
Investment-grade $ 103,435 $ 100,438
Non-investment-grade 55,873 53,486
Warehouse financing 9,312 9,116
Consumer 71,077 64,098
Total lending 239,697 227,138
Risk participations 8,651 9,173
Collateralized agreement 107,459 105,301
Collateralized financing 44,667 22,532
Investment 20,745 7,705
Other 7,831 9,690
Total commitments $ 429,050 $ 381,539
The table below presents commitments by expiration.
As of September 2023
Remainder 2024 - 2026 - 2028 -
$ in millions of 2023 2025 2027 Thereafter
Commitment Type
Commercial lending:
Investment-grade $ 3,906 $ 26,191 $ 50,308 $ 23,030
Non-investment-grade 1,227 14,158 26,034 14,454
Warehouse financing 220 5,863 2,973 256
Consumer 69,115 1,962 – –
Total lending 74,468 48,174 79,315 37,740
Risk participations 1,056 2,842 3,731 1,022
Collateralized agreement 99,463 7,230 – 766
Collateralized financing 40,027 4,586 – 54
Investment 15,246 1,474 1,015 3,010
Other 6,720 887 – 224
Total commitments $ 236,980 $ 65,193 $ 84,061 $ 42,816
In the tables above, beginning in the first quarter of 2023, the
firm made certain changes to its methodology for
determining internal credit ratings. See Note 9 for further
information about these changes. Prior period amounts have
been conformed to reflect the current methodology. The
impact to December 2022 was an increase in commercial
lending commitments classified as investment-grade and a
decrease in commercial lending commitments classified as
non-investment-grade of $2.78 billion.
Lending Commitments
The firm’s commercial and warehouse financing lending
commitments are agreements to lend with fixed termination
dates and depend on the satisfaction of all contractual
conditions to borrowing. These commitments are presented
net of amounts syndicated to third parties. The total
commitment amount does not necessarily reflect actual future
cash flows because the firm may syndicate portions of these
commitments. In addition, commitments can expire unused
or be reduced or cancelled at the counterparty’s request. The
firm also provides credit to consumers by issuing credit card
lines and through commitments to provide unsecured
installment loans.
The table below presents information about lending
commitments.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Held for investment $ 232,949 $ 222,689
Held for sale 5,955 3,355
At fair value 793 1,094
Total $ 239,697 $ 227,138
In the table above:
• Held for investment lending commitments are accounted
for at amortized cost. The carrying value of lending
commitments was a liability of $877 million (including
allowance for credit losses of $670 million) as of September
2023 and $1.01 billion (including allowance for credit losses
of $774 million) as of December 2022. The estimated fair
value of such lending commitments was a liability of $5.33
billion as of September 2023 and $5.95 billion as of
December 2022. Had these lending commitments been
carried at fair value and included in the fair value
hierarchy, $2.77 billion as of September 2023 and $3.11
billion as of December 2022 would have been classified in
level 2, and $2.56 billion as of September 2023 and $2.84
billion as of December 2022 would have been classified in
level 3.
• Held for sale lending commitments are accounted for at the
lower of cost or fair value. The carrying value of lending
commitments held for sale was a liability of $58 million as
of September 2023 and $88 million as of December 2022.
The estimated fair value of such lending commitments
approximates the carrying value. Had these lending
commitments been included in the fair value hierarchy,
they would have been primarily classified in level 3 as of
both September 2023 and December 2022.
• Gains or losses related to lending commitments at fair
value, if any, are generally recorded net of any fees in other
principal transactions.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
71 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 73 of 205 --

Commercial Lending. The firm’s commercial lending
commitments were primarily extended to investment-grade
corporate borrowers. Such commitments primarily included
$136.26 billion as of September 2023 and $127.60 billion as of
December 2022, related to relationship lending activities
(principally used for operating and general corporate
purposes), and $6.04 billion as of September 2023 and $7.71
billion as of December 2022, related to other investment
banking activities (generally extended for contingent
acquisition financing and are often intended to be short-term
in nature, as borrowers often seek to replace them with other
funding sources). The firm also extends lending commitments
in connection with other types of corporate lending,
commercial real estate financing and other collateralized
lending. See Note 9 for further information about funded
loans.
To mitigate the credit risk associated with the firm’s
commercial lending activities, the firm obtains credit
protection on certain loans and lending commitments
through credit default swaps, both single-name and index-
based contracts, and through the issuance of credit-linked
notes.
Warehouse Financing. The firm provides financing to
clients who warehouse financial assets. These arrangements
are collateralized by the warehoused assets, primarily
consisting of residential real estate, consumer and corporate
loans.
Consumer. The firm’s consumer lending commitments
includes:
• Credit card lines issued by the firm to consumers were
$68.39 billion as of September 2023 and $62.22 billion as of
December 2022. These credit card lines are cancellable by
the firm.
• Commitments to provide unsecured installment loans to
consumers were $2.68 billion as of September 2023. During
the third quarter of 2023, such commitments were classified
as held for sale in connection with the planned sale of
GreenSky. As of December 2022, commitments to provide
unsecured installment loans to consumers were
$1.88 billion.
Risk Participations
The firm also risk participates certain of its commercial
lending commitments to other financial institutions. In the
event of a risk participant’s default, the firm will be
responsible to fund the borrower.
Collateralized Agreement Commitments/
Collateralized Financing Commitments
Collateralized agreement commitments includes forward
starting resale and securities borrowing agreements, and
collateralized financing commitments includes forward
starting repurchase and secured lending agreements that
settle at a future date, generally within three business days.
Collateralized agreement commitments also includes
transactions where the firm has entered into commitments to
provide contingent financing to its clients and counterparties
through resale agreements. The firm’s funding of these
commitments depends on the satisfaction of all contractual
conditions to the resale agreement and these commitments
can expire unused.
Investment Commitments
Investment commitments includes commitments to invest in
private equity, real estate and other assets directly and
through funds that the firm raises and manages. Investment
commitments included $969 million as of September 2023
and $1.29 billion as of December 2022, related to
commitments to invest in funds managed by the firm. If these
commitments are called, they would be funded at market
value on the date of investment. During the third quarter of
2023, the firm committed to purchase a portfolio of
approximately $15.0 billion of private equity capital call
commitments (including approximately $9.0 billion of funded
loans) from the FDIC’s auction of Signature Bank’s loans.
The firm has made a deposit of approximately $1.0 billion
(included in customer and other receivables) with the FDIC in
connection with this purchase. As of September 2023, the
remaining commitment of approximately $14.0 billion was
included in investment commitments.
Contingencies
Legal Proceedings. See Note 27 for information about legal
proceedings.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 72

-- 74 of 205 --

Guarantees
The table below presents derivatives that meet the definition
of a guarantee, securities lending and clearing guarantees and
certain other financial guarantees.
$ in millions Derivatives
Securities
lending and
clearing
Other
financial
guarantees
As of September 2023
Carrying Value of Net Liability $ 6,894 $ – $ 405
Maximum Payout/Notional Amount by Period of Expiration
Remainder of 2023 $ 46,927 $ 28,159 $ 478
2024 - 2025 216,351 – 3,539
2026 - 2027 29,640 – 2,516
2028 - thereafter 33,683 – 878
Total $ 326,601 $ 28,159 $ 7,411
As of December 2022
Carrying Value of Net Liability $ 7,485 $ – $ 395
Maximum Payout/Notional Amount by Period of Expiration
2023 $ 110,599 $ 20,970 $ 1,634
2024 - 2025 133,090 – 3,308
2026 - 2027 20,252 – 1,837
2028 - thereafter 27,518 – 93
Total $ 291,459 $ 20,970 $ 6,872
In the table above:
• The maximum payout is based on the notional amount of
the contract and does not represent anticipated losses.
• Amounts exclude certain commitments to issue standby
letters of credit that are included in lending commitments.
See the tables in “Commitments” above for a summary of
the firm’s commitments.
• The carrying value for derivatives included derivative
assets of $363 million as of September 2023 and $578
million as of December 2022, and derivative liabilities of
$7.26 billion as of September 2023 and $8.06 billion as of
December 2022.
Derivative Guarantees. The firm enters into various
derivatives that meet the definition of a guarantee under U.S.
GAAP, including written equity and commodity put options,
written currency contracts and interest rate caps, floors and
swaptions. These derivatives are risk managed together with
derivatives that do not meet the definition of a guarantee, and
therefore the amounts in the table above do not reflect the
firm’s overall risk related to derivative activities. Disclosures
about derivatives are not required if they may be cash settled
and the firm has no basis to conclude it is probable that the
counterparties held the underlying instruments at the
inception of the contract. The firm has concluded that these
conditions have been met for certain large, internationally
active commercial and investment bank counterparties,
central clearing counterparties, hedge funds and certain other
counterparties. Accordingly, the firm has not included such
contracts in the table above. See Note 7 for information
about credit derivatives that meet the definition of a
guarantee, which are not included in the table above.
Derivatives are accounted for at fair value and therefore the
carrying value is considered the best indication of payment/
performance risk for individual contracts. However, the
carrying values in the table above exclude the effect of
counterparty and cash collateral netting.
Securities Lending and Clearing Guarantees. Securities
lending and clearing guarantees include the indemnifications
and guarantees that the firm provides in its capacity as an
agency lender and in its capacity as a sponsoring member of
the Fixed Income Clearing Corporation.
As an agency lender, the firm indemnifies most of its
securities lending customers against losses incurred in the
event that borrowers do not return securities and the
collateral held is insufficient to cover the market value of the
securities borrowed. The maximum payout of such
indemnifications was $13.88 billion as of September 2023 and
$12.23 billion as of December 2022. Collateral held by the
lenders in connection with securities lending indemnifications
was $14.37 billion as of September 2023 and $12.62 billion as
of December 2022. Because the contractual nature of these
arrangements requires the firm to obtain collateral with a
market value that exceeds the value of the securities lent to
the borrower, there is minimal performance risk associated
with these indemnifications.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
73 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 75 of 205 --

As a sponsoring member of the Government Securities
Division of the Fixed Income Clearing Corporation, the firm
guarantees the performance of its sponsored member clients
to the Fixed Income Clearing Corporation in connection with
certain resale and repurchase agreements. To minimize
potential losses on such guarantees, the firm obtains a
security interest in the collateral that the sponsored client
placed with the Fixed Income Clearing Corporation.
Therefore, the risk of loss on such guarantees is minimal. The
maximum payout on this guarantee was $14.28 billion as of
September 2023 and $8.74 billion as of December 2022. The
related collateral held was $14.25 billion as of September
2023 and $8.70 billion as of December 2022.
Other Financial Guarantees. In the ordinary course of
business, the firm provides other financial guarantees of the
obligations of third parties (e.g., standby letters of credit and
other guarantees to enable clients to complete transactions
and fund-related guarantees). These guarantees represent
obligations to make payments to beneficiaries if the
guaranteed party fails to fulfill its obligation under a
contractual arrangement with that beneficiary. Other
financial guarantees also include a guarantee that the firm
has provided to the Government of Malaysia that it will
receive, by August 2025, at least $1.4 billion in assets and
proceeds from assets seized by governmental authorities
around the world related to 1Malaysia Development Berhad,
a sovereign wealth fund in Malaysia (1MDB). In connection
with this guarantee, the firm agreed to make a one-time
interim payment of $250 million towards the $1.4 billion if
the Government of Malaysia did not receive at least
$500 million in assets and proceeds by August 2022. The firm
does not believe that any interim payment is required. Any
amounts paid by the firm would, in any event, be subject to
reimbursement in the event the assets and proceeds received
by the Government of Malaysia through August 18, 2028
exceed $1.4 billion.
On October 11, 2023, the firm filed a demand for arbitration
alleging that the Government of Malaysia had, as of August
2022, recovered assets and proceeds well in excess of
$500 million; it had recovered substantial additional assets
and proceeds that should be credited against the guarantee;
and it had not used all reasonable efforts to recover other
assets and proceeds that could be credited against the
guarantee. See Note 27 for further information about matters
related to 1MDB.
Guarantees of Securities Issued by Trusts. The firm has
established trusts, including Goldman Sachs Capital I,
Goldman Sachs Capital II and Goldman Sachs Capital III (the
Trusts), and other entities, for the limited purpose of issuing
securities to third parties, lending the proceeds to the firm
and entering into contractual arrangements with the firm and
third parties related to this purpose. The firm does not
consolidate these entities. See Notes 14 and 19 for further
information about the transactions involving the Trusts.
The firm effectively provides for the full and unconditional
guarantee of the securities issued by these entities. Timely
payment by the firm of amounts due to these entities under
the guarantee, borrowing, preferred stock and related
contractual arrangements will be sufficient to cover payments
due on the securities issued by these entities. No subsidiary of
Group Inc. guarantees the securities of the Trusts.
Management believes that it is unlikely that any
circumstances will occur, such as nonperformance on the part
of paying agents or other service providers, that would make
it necessary for the firm to make payments related to these
entities other than those required under the terms of the
guarantee, borrowing, preferred stock and related
contractual arrangements and in connection with certain
expenses incurred by these entities.
Indemnities and Guarantees of Service Providers. In
the ordinary course of business, the firm indemnifies and
guarantees certain service providers, such as clearing and
custody agents, trustees and administrators, against specified
potential losses in connection with their acting as an agent of,
or providing services to, the firm or its affiliates.
The firm may also be liable to some clients or other parties
for losses arising from its custodial role or caused by acts or
omissions of third-party service providers, including sub-
custodians and third-party brokers. In certain cases, the firm
has the right to seek indemnification from these third-party
service providers for certain relevant losses incurred by the
firm. In addition, the firm is a member of payment, clearing
and settlement networks, as well as securities exchanges
around the world that may require the firm to meet the
obligations of such networks and exchanges in the event of
member defaults and other loss scenarios.
In connection with the firm’s prime brokerage and clearing
businesses, the firm agrees to clear and settle transactions
entered into by clients with other brokerage firms. The firm’s
obligations in respect of such transactions are secured by the
assets in the client’s account and proceeds received from the
transactions cleared and settled by the firm on behalf of the
client. In connection with joint venture investments, the firm
may issue loan guarantees under which it may be liable in the
event of fraud, misappropriation, environmental liabilities
and other matters involving the borrower.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 74

-- 76 of 205 --

The firm is unable to develop an estimate of the maximum
payout under these guarantees and indemnifications.
However, management believes that it is unlikely the firm
will have to make any material payments under these
arrangements, and no material liabilities related to these
guarantees and indemnifications have been recognized in the
consolidated balance sheets as of both September 2023 and
December 2022.
Other Representations, Warranties and
Indemnifications. The firm provides representations and
warranties to counterparties in connection with a variety of
commercial transactions and occasionally indemnifies them
against potential losses caused by the breach of those
representations and warranties. The firm may also provide
indemnifications protecting against changes in or adverse
application of certain U.S. tax laws in connection with
ordinary-course transactions, such as securities issuances,
borrowings or derivatives.
In addition, the firm may provide indemnifications to some
counterparties to protect them in the event additional taxes
are owed or payments are withheld, due either to a change in
or an adverse application of certain non-U.S. tax laws. These
indemnifications, as well as indemnifications provided by the
firm on other contractual or other obligations, generally are
standard contractual terms and are entered into in the
ordinary course of business. Generally, there are no stated or
notional amounts included in these indemnifications, and the
contingencies triggering the obligation to indemnify are not
expected to occur. The firm is unable to develop an estimate
of the maximum payout under these guarantees and
indemnifications. However, management believes that it is
unlikely the firm will have to make any material payments
under these arrangements, and no material liabilities related
to these arrangements have been recognized in the
consolidated balance sheets as of both September 2023 and
December 2022.
Guarantees of Subsidiaries. Group Inc. is the entity that
fully and unconditionally guarantees the securities issued by
GS Finance Corp., a wholly-owned finance subsidiary of the
firm. Group Inc. has guaranteed the payment obligations of
Goldman Sachs & Co. LLC (GS&Co.), GS Bank USA and
Goldman Sachs Paris Inc. et Cie, subject to certain
exceptions. In addition, Group Inc. has provided guarantees
to Goldman Sachs International (GSI) and GSBE related to
agreements that each entity has entered into with certain of
its counterparties. Group Inc. guarantees many of the
obligations of its other consolidated subsidiaries on a
transaction-by-transaction basis, as negotiated with
counterparties. Group Inc. is unable to develop an estimate of
the maximum payout under its subsidiary guarantees.
However, because these obligations are also obligations of
consolidated subsidiaries, Group Inc.’s liabilities as guarantor
are not separately disclosed.
Note 19.
Shareholders’ Equity
Common Equity
As of both September 2023 and December 2022, the firm had
4.00 billion authorized shares of common stock and 200
million authorized shares of nonvoting common stock, each
with a par value of $0.01 per share.
The firm’s share repurchase program is intended to help
maintain the appropriate level of common equity. The share
repurchase program is effected primarily through regular
open-market purchases (which may include repurchase plans
designed to comply with Rule 10b5-1 and accelerated share
repurchases), the amounts and timing of which are
determined primarily by the firm’s current and projected
capital position, and capital deployment opportunities, but
which may also be influenced by general market conditions
and the prevailing price and trading volumes of the firm’s
common stock.
The table below presents information about common stock
repurchases.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
in millions, except per share amounts 2023 2022 2023 2022
Common share repurchases 4.2 3.0 13.5 5.9
Average cost per share $ 354.79 $ 332.32 $ 354.13 $ 337.32
Total cost of common share repurchases $ 1,500 $ 1,000 $ 4,796 $ 2,000
Pursuant to the terms of certain share-based compensation
plans, employees may remit shares to the firm or the firm
may cancel share-based awards to satisfy statutory employee
tax withholding requirements. Under these plans, during the
nine months ended September 2023, 868 shares were remitted
with a total value of $0.3 million and the firm cancelled 3.9
million share-based awards with a total value of $1.34
billion.
The table below presents common stock dividends declared.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
2023 2022 2023 2022
Dividends declared per common share $ 2.75 $ 2.50 $ 7.75 $ 6.50
On October 12, 2023, the Board of Directors of Group Inc.
(Board) declared a dividend of $2.75 per common share to be
paid on December 28, 2023 to common shareholders of
record on November 30, 2023.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
75 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 77 of 205 --

Preferred Equity
The tables below present information about the perpetual
preferred stock issued and outstanding as of September 2023.
Series
Shares
Authorized
Shares
Issued
Shares
Outstanding
Depositary
Shares
Per Share
A 50,000 30,000 29,999 1,000
C 25,000 8,000 8,000 1,000
D 60,000 54,000 53,999 1,000
E 17,500 7,667 7,667 N.A.
F 5,000 1,615 1,615 N.A.
K 32,200 28,000 28,000 1,000
O 26,000 26,000 26,000 25
P 66,000 60,000 60,000 25
Q 20,000 20,000 20,000 25
R 24,000 24,000 24,000 25
S 14,000 14,000 14,000 25
T 27,000 27,000 27,000 25
U 30,000 30,000 30,000 25
V 30,000 30,000 30,000 25
W 60,000 60,000 60,000 25
Total 486,700 420,282 420,280
Series Earliest Redemption Date
Liquidation
Preference
Redemption Value
($ in millions)
A Currently redeemable $ 25,000 $ 750
C Currently redeemable $ 25,000 200
D Currently redeemable $ 25,000 1,350
E Currently redeemable $ 100,000 767
F Currently redeemable $ 100,000 161
K May 10, 2024 $ 25,000 700
O November 10, 2026 $ 25,000 650
P Currently redeemable $ 25,000 1,500
Q August 10, 2024 $ 25,000 500
R February 10, 2025 $ 25,000 600
S February 10, 2025 $ 25,000 350
T May 10, 2026 $ 25,000 675
U August 10, 2026 $ 25,000 750
V November 10, 2026 $ 25,000 750
W February 10, 2029 $ 25,000 1,500
Total $ 11,203
In the tables above:
• All shares have a par value of $0.01 per share and, where
applicable, each share is represented by the specified
number of depositary shares.
• The earliest redemption date represents the date on which
each share of non-cumulative preferred stock is redeemable
at the firm’s option.
• Prior to redeeming preferred stock, the firm must receive
approval from the FRB.
• In August 2023, the firm issued 60,000 shares of Series W
7.50% Fixed-Rate Reset Non-Cumulative Preferred Stock
(Series W Preferred Stock).
• The redemption price per share for Series A through F and
Series Q through W Preferred Stock is the liquidation
preference plus declared and unpaid dividends. The
redemption price per share for Series K through P Preferred
Stock is the liquidation preference plus accrued and unpaid
dividends.
• All series of preferred stock are pari passu and have a
preference over the firm’s common stock on liquidation.
• The firm’s ability to declare or pay dividends on, or
purchase, redeem or otherwise acquire, its common stock is
subject to certain restrictions in the event that the firm fails
to pay or set aside full dividends on the preferred stock for
the latest completed dividend period.
• Series E and Series F Preferred Stock are held by Goldman
Sachs Capital II and Goldman Sachs Capital III,
respectively. These trusts are Delaware statutory trusts
sponsored by the firm and wholly-owned finance
subsidiaries of the firm for regulatory and legal purposes
but are not consolidated for accounting purposes.
In the third quarter of 2023, the firm redeemed all
outstanding shares of its Series J 5.50% Fixed-to-Floating
Rate Non-Cumulative Preferred Stock (Series J Preferred
Stock) with a redemption value of $1 billion ($25,000 per
share), plus accrued and unpaid dividends. The difference
between the redemption value and net carrying value was
$10 million, which was recorded as an addition to preferred
stock dividends in the third quarter of 2023.
The preferred stock issuance costs in the consolidated
statements of shareholders' equity reflects reclassifications of
issuance costs to retained earnings on redemptions, net of
issuance costs relating to new issuances.
The table below presents the dividend rates of perpetual
preferred stock as of September 2023.
Series Per Annum Dividend Rate
A 3 month term SOFR + 1.01161%, with floor of 3.75%, payable quarterly
C 3 month term SOFR + 1.01161%, with floor of 4.00%, payable quarterly
D 3 month term SOFR + 0.93161%, with floor of 4.00%, payable quarterly
E 3 month term SOFR + 1.02911%, with floor of 4.00%, payable quarterly
F 3 month term SOFR + 1.03161%, with floor of 4.00%, payable quarterly
K 6.375% to, but excluding, May 10, 2024;
3 month term SOFR + 3.81161% thereafter, payable quarterly
O 5.30%, payable semi-annually, from issuance date to, but excluding,
November 10, 2026; 3 month term SOFR + 4.09561%, payable quarterly, thereafter
P 3 month term SOFR + 3.13561%, payable quarterly
Q 5.50%, payable semi-annually, from issuance date to, but excluding,
August 10, 2024; 5 year treasury rate + 3.623%, payable semi-annually, thereafter
R 4.95%, payable semi-annually, from issuance date to, but excluding,
February 10, 2025; 5 year treasury rate + 3.224%, payable semi-annually, thereafter
S 4.40%, payable semi-annually, from issuance date to, but excluding,
February 10, 2025; 5 year treasury rate + 2.85%, payable semi-annually thereafter
T 3.80%, payable semi-annually, from issuance date to, but excluding,
May 10, 2026; 5 year treasury rate + 2.969%, payable semi-annually, thereafter
U 3.65%, payable semi-annually, from issuance date to, but excluding,
August 10, 2026; 5 year treasury rate + 2.915%, payable semi-annually, thereafter
V 4.125%, payable semi-annually, from issuance date to, but excluding,
November 10, 2026; 5 year treasury rate + 2.949%, payable semi-annually, thereafter
W 7.50%, payable semi-annually, from issuance date to, but excluding,
February 10, 2029; 5 year treasury rate + 3.156%, payable semi-annually, thereafter
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 76

-- 78 of 205 --

In the table above:
• In connection with the cessation of LIBOR, as of July 1,
2023, the firm replaced the three-month LIBOR rate with
the three-month term SOFR rate plus the statutorily
prescribed tenor spread, consistent with the FRB’s final
rule implementing the Adjustable Interest Rate (LIBOR)
Act.
• Dividends on each series of preferred stock are payable in
arrears for the periods specified.
The table below presents preferred stock dividends declared.
2023 2022
Series per share $ in millions per share $ in millions
Three Months Ended September
A $ 388.88 $ 12 $ 239.58 $ 7
C $ 388.88 3 $ 255.56 2
D $ 383.77 20 $ 255.56 14
E $ 1,600.67 13 $ 1,022.22 7
F $ 1,601.31 2 $ 1,022.22 2
J $ 573.52 23 $ 343.75 13
K $ 398.44 11 $ 398.44 11
P $ 524.58 32 $ – –
Q $ 687.50 14 $ 687.50 14
R $ 618.75 15 $ 618.75 15
S $ 550.00 8 $ 550.00 8
U $ 456.25 13 $ 456.25 14
Total $ 166 $ 107
Nine Months Ended September
A $ 1,076.86 $ 32 $ 710.93 $ 21
C $ 1,076.86 9 $ 758.34 6
D $ 1,061.69 57 $ 758.34 41
E $ 4,447.01 34 $ 3,044.44 23
F $ 4,448.90 7 $ 3,044.44 5
J $ 1,261.02 51 $ 1,031.25 41
K $ 1,195.32 33 $ 1,195.32 33
O $ 662.50 17 $ 662.50 17
P $ 1,479.53 89 $ 625.00 38
Q $ 1,375.00 28 $ 1,375.00 28
R $ 1,237.50 30 $ 1,237.50 30
S $ 1,100.00 16 $ 1,100.00 16
T $ 475.00 13 $ 475.00 13
U $ 912.50 27 $ 942.92 28
V $ 515.63 15 $ 547.14 16
Total $ 458 $ 356
On October 9, 2023, Group Inc. declared dividends of
$407.41 per share of Series A Preferred Stock, $407.41 per
share of Series C Preferred Stock, $402.30 per share of Series
D Preferred Stock, $398.44 per share of Series K Preferred
Stock, $662.50 per share of Series O Preferred Stock, $543.11
per share of Series P Preferred Stock, $475.00 per share of
Series T Preferred Stock and $515.63 per share of Series V
Preferred Stock to be paid on November 10, 2023 to preferred
shareholders of record on October 26, 2023. In addition, the
firm declared dividends of $1,627.56 per share of Series E
Preferred Stock and $1,628.19 per share of Series F Preferred
Stock to be paid on December 1, 2023 to preferred
shareholders of record on November 16, 2023.
Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income/(Loss)
The table below presents changes in accumulated other
comprehensive income/(loss), net of tax, by type.
$ in millions
Beginning
balance
Other
comprehensive
income/(loss)
adjustments,
net of tax
Ending
balance
Three Months Ended September 2023
Currency translation $ (828) $ (16) $ (844)
Debt valuation adjustment 281 328 609
Pension and postretirement liabilities (475) 9 (466)
Available-for-sale securities (2,215) 317 (1,898)
Total $ (3,237) $ 638 $ (2,599)
Three Months Ended September 2022
Currency translation $ (769) $ 26 $ (743)
Debt valuation adjustment 1,417 673 2,090
Pension and postretirement liabilities (315) (2) (317)
Available-for-sale securities (2,287) (615) (2,902)
Total $ (1,954) $ 82 $ (1,872)
Nine Months Ended September 2023
Currency translation $ (785) $ (59) $ (844)
Debt valuation adjustment 892 (283) 609
Pension and postretirement liabilities (499) 33 (466)
Available-for-sale securities (2,618) 720 (1,898)
Total $ (3,010) $ 411 $ (2,599)
Nine Months Ended September 2022
Currency translation $ (738) $ (5) $ (743)
Debt valuation adjustment (511) 2,601 2,090
Pension and postretirement liabilities (327) 10 (317)
Available-for-sale securities (492) (2,410) (2,902)
Total $ (2,068) $ 196 $ (1,872)
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
77 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 79 of 205 --

Note 20.
Regulation and Capital Adequacy
The FRB is the primary regulator of Group Inc., a bank
holding company under the U.S. Bank Holding Company Act
of 1956 and a financial holding company under amendments
to this Act. The firm is subject to consolidated regulatory
capital requirements which are calculated in accordance with
the regulations of the FRB (Capital Framework).
The capital requirements are expressed as risk-based capital
and leverage ratios that compare measures of regulatory
capital to risk-weighted assets (RWAs), average assets and
off-balance sheet exposures. Failure to comply with these
capital requirements would result in restrictions being
imposed by the firm’s regulators and could limit the firm’s
ability to repurchase shares, pay dividends and make certain
discretionary compensation payments. The firm’s capital
levels are also subject to qualitative judgments by the
regulators about components of capital, risk weightings and
other factors. Furthermore, certain of the firm’s subsidiaries
are subject to separate regulations and capital requirements.
Capital Framework
The regulations under the Capital Framework are largely
based on the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision’s
(Basel Committee) capital framework for strengthening
international capital standards (Basel III) and also implement
certain provisions of the Dodd-Frank Act. Under the Capital
Framework, the firm is an “Advanced approaches” banking
organization and has been designated as a global systemically
important bank (G-SIB).
The Capital Framework includes the minimum risk-based
capital and the capital conservation buffer requirements. The
buffer must consist entirely of capital that qualifies as
Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital.
The firm calculates its CET1 capital, Tier 1 capital and Total
capital ratios in accordance with both the Standardized and
Advanced Capital Rules. Each of the ratios calculated under
the Standardized and Advanced Capital Rules must meet its
respective capital requirements.
Under the Capital Framework, the firm is also subject to
leverage requirements which consist of a minimum Tier 1
leverage ratio and a minimum supplementary leverage ratio
(SLR), as well as the SLR buffer.
Consolidated Regulatory Capital Requirements
Risk-Based Capital Ratios. The table below presents the
risk-based capital requirements.
Standardized Advanced
As of September 2023
CET1 capital ratio 13.8% 10.0%
Tier 1 capital ratio 15.3% 11.5%
Total capital ratio 17.3% 13.5%
As of December 2022
CET1 capital ratio 13.3% 9.5%
Tier 1 capital ratio 14.8% 11.0%
Total capital ratio 16.8% 13.0%
In the table above:
• Under both the Standardized and Advanced Capital Rules,
the CET1 capital ratio requirement includes a minimum of
4.5%, the Tier 1 capital ratio requirement includes a
minimum of 6.0% and the Total capital ratio requirement
includes a minimum of 8.0%. These requirements also
include the capital conservation buffer requirements,
consisting of the G-SIB surcharge (Method 2) of 3.0% as of
September 2023 and 2.5% as of December 2022 and the
countercyclical capital buffer, which the FRB has set to
zero percent. In addition, the capital conservation buffer
requirements include the stress capital buffer (SCB) of
6.3% under the Standardized Capital Rules and a buffer of
2.5% under the Advanced Capital Rules.
• The G-SIB surcharge is updated annually based on
financial data from the prior year and is generally
applicable for the following year. The G-SIB surcharge is
calculated using two methodologies, the higher of which is
reflected in the firm’s risk-based capital requirements. The
first calculation (Method 1) is based on the Basel
Committee’s methodology which, among other factors,
relies upon measures of the size, activity and complexity of
each G-SIB. The second calculation (Method 2) uses similar
inputs but includes a measure of reliance on short-term
wholesale funding.
Based on the firm’s 2023 Comprehensive Capital Analysis
and Review submission, the FRB has set the SCB for the firm
at 5.5% under the Standardized Capital Rules for the period
from October 1, 2023 through September 30, 2024.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 78

-- 80 of 205 --

The table below presents information about risk-based
capital ratios.
$ in millions Standardized Advanced
As of September 2023
CET1 capital $ 98,891 $ 98,891
Tier 1 capital $ 109,752 $ 109,752
Tier 2 capital $ 15,193 $ 11,245
Total capital $ 124,945 $ 120,997
RWAs $ 666,860 $ 666,205
CET1 capital ratio 14.8% 14.8%
Tier 1 capital ratio 16.5% 16.5%
Total capital ratio 18.7% 18.2%
As of December 2022
CET1 capital $ 98,050 $ 98,050
Tier 1 capital $ 108,552 $ 108,552
Tier 2 capital $ 15,958 $ 12,115
Total capital $ 124,510 $ 120,667
RWAs $ 653,419 $ 679,450
CET1 capital ratio 15.0% 14.4%
Tier 1 capital ratio 16.6% 16.0%
Total capital ratio 19.1% 17.8%
Leverage Ratios. The table below presents the leverage
requirements.
Requirements
Tier 1 leverage ratio 4.0%
SLR 5.0%
In the table above, the SLR requirement of 5% includes a
minimum of 3% and a 2% buffer applicable to G-SIBs.
The table below presents information about leverage ratios.
For the Three Months
Ended or as of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Tier 1 capital $ 109,752 $ 108,552
Average total assets $ 1,557,715 $ 1,500,225
Deductions from Tier 1 capital (7,216) (8,259)
Average adjusted total assets 1,550,499 1,491,966
Off-balance sheet and other exposures 414,307 375,392
Total leverage exposure $ 1,964,806 $ 1,867,358
Tier 1 leverage ratio 7.1% 7.3%
SLR 5.6% 5.8%
In the table above:
• Average total assets represents the average daily assets for
the quarter adjusted for the impact of Current Expected
Credit Losses (CECL) transition.
• Off-balance sheet and other exposures primarily includes
the monthly average of off-balance sheet exposures,
consisting of derivatives, securities financing transactions,
commitments and guarantees.
• Tier 1 leverage ratio is calculated as Tier 1 capital divided
by average adjusted total assets.
• SLR is calculated as Tier 1 capital divided by total leverage
exposure.
Risk-Based Capital. The table below presents information
about risk-based capital.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Common shareholders’ equity $ 106,074 $ 106,486
Impact of CECL transition 553 829
Deduction for goodwill (5,223) (5,674)
Deduction for identifiable intangible assets (1,102) (1,770)
Other adjustments (1,411) (1,821)
CET1 capital 98,891 98,050
Preferred stock 11,203 10,703
Deduction for investments in covered funds (339) (199)
Other adjustments (3) (2)
Tier 1 capital $ 109,752 $ 108,552
Standardized Tier 2 and Total capital
Tier 1 capital $ 109,752 $ 108,552
Qualifying subordinated debt 10,306 10,637
Allowance for credit losses 4,907 5,331
Other adjustments (20) (10)
Standardized Tier 2 capital 15,193 15,958
Standardized Total capital $ 124,945 $ 124,510
Advanced Tier 2 and Total capital
Tier 1 capital $ 109,752 $ 108,552
Standardized Tier 2 capital 15,193 15,958
Allowance for credit losses (4,907) (5,331)
Other adjustments 959 1,488
Advanced Tier 2 capital 11,245 12,115
Advanced Total capital $ 120,997 $ 120,667
In the table above:
• Beginning in January 2022, the firm started to phase in the
estimated reduction to regulatory capital as a result of
adopting the CECL model. The total amount of reduction
to be phased in from January 1, 2022 through January 1,
2025 (at 25% per year) was $1.11 billion, of which
$553 million had been phased in as of September 2023. The
total amount to be phased in includes the impact of
adopting CECL as of January 1, 2020, as well as 25% of
the increase in the allowance for credit losses from January
1, 2020 through December 31, 2021. The impact of CECL
transition reflects the remaining amount of reduction to be
phased in as of both September 2023 and December 2022.
• Deduction for goodwill was net of deferred tax liabilities of
$690 million as of September 2023 and $700 million as of
December 2022.
• Deduction for identifiable intangible assets was net of
deferred tax liabilities of $239 million as of both September
2023 and December 2022.
• Deduction for investments in covered funds represents the
firm’s aggregate investments in applicable covered funds.
See Note 8 for further information about the Volcker Rule.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
79 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 81 of 205 --

• Other adjustments within CET1 capital and Tier 1 capital
primarily include credit valuation adjustments on
derivative liabilities, the overfunded portion of the firm’s
defined benefit pension plan obligation net of associated
deferred tax liabilities, disallowed deferred tax assets, debt
valuation adjustments and other required credit risk-based
deductions. Other adjustments within Advanced Tier 2
capital include eligible credit reserves.
• Qualifying subordinated debt is subordinated debt issued
by Group Inc. with an original maturity of five years or
greater. The outstanding amount of subordinated debt
qualifying for Tier 2 capital is reduced upon reaching a
remaining maturity of five years. See Note 14 for further
information about the firm’s subordinated debt.
The table below presents changes in CET1 capital, Tier 1
capital and Tier 2 capital.
$ in millions Standardized Advanced
Nine Months Ended September 2023
CET1 capital
Beginning balance $ 98,050 $ 98,050
Change in:
Common shareholders’ equity (412) (412)
Impact of CECL transition (276) (276)
Deduction for goodwill 451 451
Deduction for identifiable intangible assets 668 668
Other adjustments 410 410
Ending balance $ 98,891 $ 98,891
Tier 1 capital
Beginning balance $ 108,552 $ 108,552
Change in:
CET1 capital 841 841
Preferred stock 500 500
Deduction for investments in covered funds (140) (140)
Other adjustments (1) (1)
Ending balance 109,752 109,752
Tier 2 capital
Beginning balance 15,958 12,115
Change in:
Qualifying subordinated debt (331) (331)
Allowance for credit losses (424) –
Other adjustments (10) (539)
Ending balance 15,193 11,245
Total capital $ 124,945 $ 120,997
RWAs. RWAs are calculated in accordance with both the
Standardized and Advanced Capital Rules.
Credit Risk
Credit RWAs are calculated based on measures of exposure,
which are then risk weighted under the Standardized and
Advanced Capital Rules:
• The Standardized Capital Rules apply prescribed risk-
weights, which depend largely on the type of counterparty.
The exposure measures for derivatives and securities
financing transactions are based on specific formulas which
take certain factors into consideration.
• Under the Advanced Capital Rules, the firm computes risk-
weights for wholesale and retail credit exposures in
accordance with the Advanced Internal Ratings-Based
approach. The exposure measures for derivatives and
securities financing transactions are computed utilizing
internal models.
• For both Standardized and Advanced credit RWAs, the
risk-weights for securitizations and equities are based on
specific required formulaic approaches.
Market Risk
RWAs for market risk in accordance with the Standardized
and Advanced Capital Rules are generally consistent. Market
RWAs are calculated based on measures of exposure which
include the following:
• Value-at-Risk (VaR) is the potential loss in value of trading
assets and liabilities, as well as certain investments, loans,
and other financial assets and liabilities accounted for at
fair value, due to adverse market movements over a defined
time horizon with a specified confidence level.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 80

-- 82 of 205 --

For both risk management purposes and regulatory capital
calculations, the firm uses a single VaR model which captures
risks, including those related to interest rates, equity prices,
currency rates and commodity prices. However, VaR used
for risk management purposes differs from VaR used for
regulatory capital requirements (regulatory VaR) due to
differences in time horizons, confidence levels and the scope
of positions on which VaR is calculated. For risk
management purposes, a 95% one-day VaR is used, whereas
for regulatory capital requirements, a 99% 10-day VaR is
used to determine Market RWAs and a 99% one-day VaR is
used to determine regulatory VaR exceptions. In addition,
the daily net revenues used to determine risk management
VaR exceptions (i.e., comparing the daily net revenues to the
VaR measure calculated as of the end of the prior business
day) include intraday activity, whereas the Capital
Framework requires that intraday activity be excluded from
daily net revenues when calculating regulatory VaR
exceptions. Intraday activity includes bid/offer net revenues,
which are more likely than not to be positive by their nature.
As a result, there may be differences in the number of VaR
exceptions and the amount of daily net revenues calculated
for regulatory VaR compared to the amounts calculated for
risk management VaR.
The firm’s positional losses observed on a single day
exceeded its 99% one-day regulatory VaR on one occasion
during both the nine months ended September 2023 and the
year ended 2022. There was no change in the firm’s VaR
multiplier used to calculate Market RWAs;
• Stressed VaR is the potential loss in value of trading assets
and liabilities, as well as certain investments, loans, and
other financial assets and liabilities accounted for at fair
value, during a period of significant market stress;
• Incremental risk is the potential loss in value of non-
securitized positions due to the default or credit migration
of issuers of financial instruments over a one-year time
horizon;
• Comprehensive risk is the potential loss in value, due to
price risk and defaults, within the firm’s credit correlation
positions; and
• Specific risk is the risk of loss on a position that could
result from factors other than broad market movements,
including event risk, default risk and idiosyncratic risk. The
standardized measurement method is used to determine
specific risk RWAs, by applying supervisory defined risk-
weighting factors after applicable netting is performed.
Operational Risk
Operational RWAs are only required to be included under
the Advanced Capital Rules. The firm utilizes an internal
risk-based model to quantify Operational RWAs.
The table below presents information about RWAs.
$ in millions Standardized Advanced
As of September 2023
Credit RWAs
Derivatives $ 145,133 $ 99,815
Commitments, guarantees and loans 249,886 200,225
Securities financing transactions 81,423 25,041
Equity investments 31,703 34,301
Other 75,273 95,330
Total Credit RWAs 583,418 454,712
Market RWAs
Regulatory VaR 16,704 16,704
Stressed VaR 40,343 40,343
Incremental risk 6,779 6,779
Comprehensive risk 2,647 2,647
Specific risk 16,969 16,969
Total Market RWAs 83,442 83,442
Total Operational RWAs – 128,051
Total RWAs $ 666,860 $ 666,205
As of December 2022
Credit RWAs
Derivatives $ 142,696 $ 111,344
Commitments, guarantees and loans 247,026 198,508
Securities financing transactions 73,189 21,659
Equity investments 30,899 33,451
Other 76,335 96,351
Total Credit RWAs 570,145 461,313
Market RWAs
Regulatory VaR 18,981 18,981
Stressed VaR 37,833 37,833
Incremental risk 6,470 6,470
Comprehensive risk 3,641 3,641
Specific risk 16,349 16,349
Total Market RWAs 83,274 83,274
Total Operational RWAs – 134,863
Total RWAs $ 653,419 $ 679,450
In the table above:
• Securities financing transactions represents resale and
repurchase agreements and securities borrowed and loaned
transactions.
• Other includes receivables, certain debt securities, cash and
cash equivalents, and other assets.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
81 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 83 of 205 --

The table below presents changes in RWAs.
$ in millions Standardized Advanced
Nine Months Ended September 2023
RWAs
Beginning balance $ 653,419 $ 679,450
Credit RWAs
Change in:
Derivatives 2,437 (11,529)
Commitments, guarantees and loans 2,860 1,717
Securities financing transactions 8,234 3,382
Equity investments 804 850
Other (1,062) (1,021)
Change in Credit RWAs 13,273 (6,601)
Market RWAs
Change in:
Regulatory VaR (2,277) (2,277)
Stressed VaR 2,510 2,510
Incremental risk 309 309
Comprehensive risk (994) (994)
Specific risk 620 620
Change in Market RWAs 168 168
Change in Operational RWAs – (6,812)
Ending balance $ 666,860 $ 666,205
RWAs Rollforward Commentary
Nine Months Ended September 2023. Standardized
Credit RWAs as of September 2023 increased by
$13.27 billion compared with December 2022, primarily
reflecting an increase in securities financing transactions
(principally due to increased funding exposures), an increase
in commitments, guarantees and loans (principally due to
increased lending activity) and an increase in derivatives
(principally due to increased exposures). Standardized
Market RWAs as of September 2023 were essentially
unchanged compared with December 2022.
Advanced Credit RWAs as of September 2023 decreased by
$6.60 billion compared with December 2022, primarily
reflecting a decrease in derivatives (principally due to reduced
counterparty credit risk). This decrease was partially offset
by an increase in securities financing transactions (principally
due to increased funding exposures) and an increase in
commitments, guarantees and loans (principally due to
increased lending activity). Advanced Market RWAs as of
September 2023 were essentially unchanged compared with
December 2022. Advanced Operational RWAs as of
September 2023 decreased by $6.81 billion compared with
December 2022, reflecting decreased frequency of loss events
estimated by the firm’s risk-based model.
Bank Subsidiaries
GS Bank USA. GS Bank USA is the firm’s primary U.S.
bank subsidiary. GS Bank USA is a New York State-
chartered bank and a member of the Federal Reserve System,
is supervised and regulated by the FRB, the FDIC, the New
York State Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) and
the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and is subject to
regulatory capital requirements that are calculated under the
Capital Framework. GS Bank USA is an Advanced
approaches banking organization under the Capital
Framework. The deposits of GS Bank USA are insured by the
FDIC to the extent provided by law.
The Capital Framework includes the minimum risk-based
capital and the capital conservation buffer requirements
(consisting of a 2.5% buffer and the countercyclical capital
buffer). The buffer must consist entirely of capital that
qualifies as CET1 capital. In addition, the Capital
Framework includes the leverage ratio requirement.
GS Bank USA is required to calculate the CET1 capital, Tier
1 capital and Total capital ratios in accordance with both the
Standardized and Advanced Capital Rules. The lower of each
risk-based capital ratio under the Standardized and Advanced
Capital Rules is the ratio against which GS Bank USA’s
compliance with its risk-based capital requirements is
assessed. In addition, under the regulatory framework for
prompt corrective action applicable to GS Bank USA, in
order to meet the quantitative requirements for a “well-
capitalized” depository institution, GS Bank USA must also
meet the “well-capitalized” requirements in the table below.
GS Bank USA’s capital levels and prompt corrective action
classification are also subject to qualitative judgments by the
regulators about components of capital, risk weightings and
other factors. Failure to comply with the capital
requirements, including a breach of the buffers described
below, would result in restrictions being imposed by the
regulators.
The table below presents GS Bank USA’s risk-based capital,
leverage and “well-capitalized” requirements.
Requirements
“Well-capitalized”
Requirements
Risk-based capital requirements
CET1 capital ratio 7.0% 6.5%
Tier 1 capital ratio 8.5% 8.0%
Total capital ratio 10.5% 10.0%
Leverage requirements
Tier 1 leverage ratio 4.0% 5.0%
SLR 3.0% 6.0%
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 82

-- 84 of 205 --

In the table above:
• The CET1 capital ratio requirement includes a minimum of
4.5%, the Tier 1 capital ratio requirement includes a
minimum of 6.0% and the Total capital ratio requirement
includes a minimum of 8.0%. These requirements also
include the capital conservation buffer requirements
consisting of a 2.5% buffer and the countercyclical capital
buffer, which the FRB has set to zero percent.
• The “well-capitalized” requirements are the binding
requirements for leverage ratios.
The table below presents information about GS Bank USA’s
risk-based capital ratios.
$ in millions Standardized Advanced
As of September 2023
CET1 capital $ 52,216 $ 52,216
Tier 1 capital $ 52,216 $ 52,216
Tier 2 capital $ 6,179 $ 3,021
Total capital $ 58,395 $ 55,237
RWAs $ 375,207 $ 290,941
CET1 capital ratio 13.9% 17.9%
Tier 1 capital ratio 13.9% 17.9%
Total capital ratio 15.6% 19.0%
As of December 2022
CET1 capital $ 46,845 $ 46,845
Tier 1 capital $ 46,845 $ 46,845
Tier 2 capital $ 8,042 $ 5,382
Total capital $ 54,887 $ 52,227
RWAs $ 357,112 $ 275,451
CET1 capital ratio 13.1% 17.0%
Tier 1 capital ratio 13.1% 17.0%
Total capital ratio 15.4% 19.0%
In the table above:
• The lower of the Standardized or Advanced ratio is the
ratio against which GS Bank USA’s compliance with the
capital requirements is assessed under the risk-based
Capital Rules, and therefore, the Standardized ratios
applied to GS Bank USA as of both September 2023 and
December 2022.
• Beginning in January 2022, GS Bank USA started to phase
in the estimated reduction to regulatory capital as a result
of adopting the CECL model at 25% per year through
January 2025. The total amount to be phased in includes
the impact of adopting CECL as of January 1, 2020, as well
as 25% of the increase in the allowance for credit losses
from January 1, 2020 through December 31, 2021.
• The Standardized and Advanced CET1 and Tier 1 capital
ratios and Standardized Total capital ratio increased from
December 2022 to September 2023, primarily reflecting an
increase in capital, principally due to net earnings, partially
offset by an increase in Credit RWAs.
The table below presents information about GS Bank USA’s
leverage ratios.
For the Three Months
Ended or as of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Tier 1 capital $ 52,216 $ 46,845
Average adjusted total assets $ 511,837 $ 499,108
Total leverage exposure $ 709,811 $ 671,215
Tier 1 leverage ratio 10.2% 9.4%
SLR 7.4% 7.0%
In the table above:
• Average adjusted total assets represents the average daily
assets for the quarter adjusted for deductions from Tier 1
capital and the impact of CECL transition.
• Tier 1 leverage ratio is calculated as Tier 1 capital divided
by average adjusted total assets.
• SLR is calculated as Tier 1 capital divided by total leverage
exposure.
The FRB requires that GS Bank USA maintain cash reserves
with the Federal Reserve. As of both September 2023 and
December 2022, the reserve requirement ratio was zero
percent. See Note 26 for further information about cash
deposits held by the firm at the Federal Reserve.
GS Bank USA is a registered swap dealer with the CFTC and
a registered security-based swap dealer with the SEC. As of
both September 2023 and December 2022, GS Bank USA was
subject to and in compliance with applicable capital
requirements for swap dealers and security-based swap
dealers.
GSIB. GSIB is the firm’s U.K. bank subsidiary regulated by
the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) and the Financial
Conduct Authority (FCA). GSIB is subject to the U.K. capital
framework, which is largely based on Basel III. The eligible
retail deposits of GSIB are covered by the U.K. Financial
Services Compensation Scheme to the extent provided by
law.
The table below presents GSIB’s risk-based capital
requirements.
As of
September December
2023 2022
Risk-based capital requirements
CET1 capital ratio 10.1% 9.7%
Tier 1 capital ratio 12.4% 11.9%
Total capital ratio 15.4% 14.9%
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
83 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 85 of 205 --

The table below presents information about GSIB’s risk-
based capital ratios.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Risk-based capital and risk-weighted assets
CET1 capital $ 3,782 $ 3,395
Tier 1 capital $ 3,782 $ 3,395
Tier 2 capital $ 826 $ 828
Total capital $ 4,608 $ 4,223
RWAs $ 16,722 $ 15,766
Risk-based capital ratios
CET1 capital ratio 22.6% 21.5%
Tier 1 capital ratio 22.6% 21.5%
Total capital ratio 27.6% 26.8%
In the table above, the risk-based capital ratios as of
September 2023 reflected profits after foreseeable charges
that are still subject to audit by GSIB’s external auditors and
approval by GSIB’s Board of Directors for inclusion in risk-
based capital. These profits contributed approximately 232
basis points to the CET1 capital ratio as of September 2023.
The table below presents GSIB’s leverage ratio requirement
which became effective in January 2023 and the leverage
ratio.
As of
September 2023
Leverage ratio requirement 3.6%
Leverage ratio 5.8%
In the table above, the leverage ratio as of September 2023
reflected profits after foreseeable charges that are still subject
to audit by GSIB’s external auditors and approval by GSIB’s
Board of Directors for inclusion in risk-based capital. These
profits contributed approximately 59 basis points to the
leverage ratio as of September 2023.
GSIB is subject to minimum reserve requirements at central
banks in certain of the jurisdictions in which it operates. As
of both September 2023 and December 2022, GSIB was in
compliance with these requirements.
GSBE. GSBE is the firm’s German bank subsidiary
supervised by the European Central Bank, BaFin and
Deutsche Bundesbank. GSBE is a non-U.S. banking
subsidiary of GS Bank USA and is also subject to standalone
regulatory capital requirements noted below. GSBE is subject
to the capital requirements prescribed in the amended E.U.
Capital Requirements Directive (CRD) and E.U. Capital
Requirements Regulation (CRR), which are largely based on
Basel III. The deposits of GSBE are covered by the German
statutory deposit protection program to the extent provided
by law. In addition, GSBE has elected to participate in the
German voluntary deposit protection program which
provides insurance for certain eligible deposits not covered by
the German statutory deposit program.
The table below presents GSBE’s risk-based capital
requirements.
As of
September December
2023 2022
Risk-based capital requirements
CET1 capital ratio 10.1% 9.2%
Tier 1 capital ratio 12.1% 11.3%
Total capital ratio 14.9% 14.0%
The table below presents information about GSBE’s risk-
based capital ratios.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Risk-based capital and risk-weighted assets
CET1 capital $ 13,442 $ 9,536
Tier 1 capital $ 13,442 $ 9,536
Tier 2 capital $ 21 $ 21
Total capital $ 13,463 $ 9,557
RWAs $ 36,281 $ 30,154
Risk-based capital ratios
CET1 capital ratio 37.0% 31.6%
Tier 1 capital ratio 37.0% 31.6%
Total capital ratio 37.1% 31.7%
In the table above, the risk-based capital ratios as of
September 2023 reflected profits after foreseeable charges
that are still subject to audit by GSBE’s external auditors and
approval by GSBE’s shareholder (GS Bank USA) for inclusion
in risk-based capital. These profits contributed
approximately 156 basis points to the CET1 capital ratio as
of September 2023.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 84

-- 86 of 205 --

The table below presents GSBE’s leverage ratio requirement
and leverage ratio.
As of
September December
2023 2022
Leverage ratio requirement 3.0% 3.0%
Leverage ratio 10.6% 10.6%
In the table above, the leverage ratio as of September 2023
reflected profits after foreseeable charges that are still subject
to audit by GSBE’s external auditors and approval by GSBE’s
shareholder (GS Bank USA) for inclusion in risk-based
capital. These profits contributed approximately 45 basis
points to the leverage ratio as of September 2023.
GSBE is subject to minimum reserve requirements at central
banks in certain of the jurisdictions in which it operates. As
of both September 2023 and December 2022, GSBE was in
compliance with these requirements.
GSBE is a registered swap dealer with the CFTC and a
registered security-based swap dealer with the SEC. As of
both September 2023 and December 2022, GSBE was subject
to and in compliance with applicable capital requirements for
swap dealers and security-based swap dealers.
Restrictions on Payments
Group Inc. may be limited in its ability to access capital held
at certain subsidiaries as a result of regulatory, tax or other
constraints. These limitations include provisions of
applicable law and regulations and other regulatory
restrictions that limit the ability of those subsidiaries to
declare and pay dividends without prior regulatory approval.
For example, the amount of dividends that may be paid by
GS Bank USA are limited to the lesser of the amounts
calculated under a recent earnings test and an undivided
profits test. As a result of dividends paid in connection with
the acquisition of GSBE in July 2021, GS Bank USA cannot
currently declare any additional dividends without prior
regulatory approval.
In addition, subsidiaries not subject to separate regulatory
capital requirements may hold capital to satisfy local tax and
legal guidelines, rating agency requirements (for entities with
assigned credit ratings) or internal policies, including policies
concerning the minimum amount of capital a subsidiary
should hold based on its underlying level of risk.
Group Inc.’s equity investment in subsidiaries was $133.60
billion as of September 2023 and $134.59 billion as of
December 2022, of which Group Inc. was required to
maintain $95.65 billion as of September 2023 and $82.52
billion as of December 2022, of minimum equity capital in its
regulated subsidiaries in order to satisfy the regulatory
requirements of such subsidiaries.
Group Inc.’s capital invested in certain non-U.S. dollar
functional currency subsidiaries is exposed to foreign
exchange risk, substantially all of which is managed through
a combination of non-U.S. dollar-denominated debt and
derivatives. See Note 7 for information about the firm’s net
investment hedges used to hedge this risk.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
85 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 87 of 205 --

Note 21.
Earnings Per Common Share
Basic earnings per common share (EPS) is calculated by
dividing net earnings to common by the weighted average
number of common shares outstanding and RSUs for which
the delivery of the underlying common stock is not subject to
satisfaction of future service, performance or market
conditions (collectively, basic shares). Diluted EPS includes
the determinants of basic EPS and, in addition, reflects the
dilutive effect of the common stock deliverable for RSUs for
which the delivery of the underlying common stock is subject
to satisfaction of future service, performance or market
conditions.
The table below presents information about basic and diluted
EPS.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
in millions, except per share amounts 2023 2022 2023 2022
Net earnings to common $ 1,882 $ 2,962 $ 6,040 $ 9,579
Weighted average basic shares 338.7 352.8 342.5 353.0
Effect of dilutive RSUs 5.2 6.4 4.9 5.6
Weighted average diluted shares 343.9 359.2 347.4 358.6
Basic EPS $ 5.52 $ 8.35 $ 17.52 $ 27.03
Diluted EPS $ 5.47 $ 8.25 $ 17.39 $ 26.71
In the table above:
• Net earnings to common represents net earnings applicable
to common shareholders, which is calculated as net
earnings less preferred stock dividends.
• Unvested share-based awards that have non-forfeitable
rights to dividends or dividend equivalents are treated as a
separate class of securities under the two-class method.
Distributed earnings allocated to these securities reduce net
earnings to common to calculate EPS under this method.
The impact of applying this methodology was a reduction
in basic EPS of $0.04 for the three months ended September
2023, $0.05 for the three months ended September 2022,
$0.12 for the nine months ended September 2023 and $0.11
for the nine months ended September 2022.
• Diluted EPS does not include antidilutive RSUs, including
those that are subject to market or performance conditions,
of 0.3 million for the three months ended September 2023,
0.4 million for the nine months ended September 2023, and
0.5 million for both the three and nine months ended
September 2022.
Note 22.
Transactions with Affiliated Funds
The firm has formed nonconsolidated investment funds with
third-party investors. As the firm generally acts as the
investment manager for these funds, it is entitled to receive
management fees and, in certain cases, advisory fees or
incentive fees from these funds. Additionally, the firm invests
alongside the third-party investors in certain funds.
The tables below present information about affiliated funds.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Fees earned from funds $ 1,179 $ 1,172 $ 3,496 $ 3,422
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Fees receivable from funds $ 1,369 $ 1,175
Aggregate carrying value of interests in funds $ 4,025 $ 3,801
The firm has waived, and may waive in the future, certain
management fees on selected money market funds to enhance
the yield for investors in such funds. Management fees
waived were $8 million for the three months ended
September 2023, $11 million for the three months ended
September 2022, $24 million for the nine months ended
September 2023 and $110 million for the nine months ended
September 2022.
In accordance with the Volcker Rule, the firm does not
provide financial support to covered funds. However, in the
ordinary course of business, the firm may choose to provide
voluntary financial support to funds that are not subject to
the Volcker Rule, although any such support is not expected
to be material to the results of operations of the firm. Except
for the fee waivers noted above, the firm did not provide any
additional financial support to its affiliated funds during
either the three or nine months ended September 2023 or
September 2022.
In addition, in the ordinary course of business, the firm may
also engage in other activities with its affiliated funds,
including, among others, securities lending, trade execution,
market-making, custody, and acquisition and bridge
financing. See Note 18 for information about the firm’s
investment commitments related to these funds.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 86

-- 88 of 205 --

Note 23.
Interest Income and Interest Expense
Interest is recorded over the life of the instrument on an
accrual basis based on contractual interest rates.
The table below presents sources of interest income and
interest expense.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Deposits with banks $ 3,065 $ 1,107 $ 8,331 $ 1,392
Collateralized agreements 4,287 1,542 11,744 1,712
Trading assets 2,222 1,334 5,990 3,551
Investments 1,001 578 2,729 1,433
Loans 3,797 2,487 10,942 5,937
Other interest 3,885 1,502 10,295 2,588
Total interest income 18,257 8,550 50,031 16,613
Deposits 4,433 1,811 11,959 2,975
Collateralized financings 3,635 990 9,131 1,308
Trading liabilities 633 513 1,769 1,427
Short-term borrowings 317 152 848 333
Long-term borrowings 2,913 1,503 8,285 3,433
Other interest 4,779 1,538 13,027 1,533
Total interest expense 16,710 6,507 45,019 11,009
Net interest income $ 1,547 $ 2,043 $ 5,012 $ 5,604
In the table above:
• Collateralized agreements includes rebates paid and
interest income on securities borrowed.
• Loans excludes interest on loans held for sale that are
accounted for at the lower of cost or fair value. Such
interest is included within other interest.
• Other interest income includes interest income on customer
debit balances, other interest-earning assets and loans held
for sale that are accounted for at the lower of cost or fair
value.
• Collateralized financings consists of repurchase agreements
and securities loaned.
• Short- and long-term borrowings include both secured and
unsecured borrowings.
• Other interest expense includes rebates received on other
interest-bearing liabilities and interest expense on customer
credit balances.
Note 24.
Income Taxes
Provision for Income Taxes
Income taxes are provided for using the asset and liability
method under which deferred tax assets and liabilities are
recognized for temporary differences between the financial
reporting and tax bases of assets and liabilities. The firm
reports interest expense related to income tax matters in
provision for taxes and income tax penalties in other
expenses.
Deferred Income Taxes
Deferred income taxes reflect the net tax effects of temporary
differences between the financial reporting and tax bases of
assets and liabilities. These temporary differences result in
taxable or deductible amounts in future years and are
measured using the tax rates and laws that will be in effect
when such differences are expected to reverse. Valuation
allowances are established to reduce deferred tax assets to the
amount that more likely than not will be realized and
primarily relate to the ability to utilize losses in various tax
jurisdictions. Tax assets are included in other assets and tax
liabilities are included in other liabilities.
Unrecognized Tax Benefits
The firm recognizes tax positions in the consolidated
financial statements only when it is more likely than not that
the position will be sustained on examination by the relevant
taxing authority based on the technical merits of the position.
A position that meets this standard is measured at the largest
amount of benefit that will more likely than not be realized
on settlement. A liability is established for differences
between positions taken in a tax return and amounts
recognized in the consolidated financial statements.
Regulatory Tax Examinations
The firm is subject to examination by the U.S. Internal
Revenue Service (IRS) and other taxing authorities in
jurisdictions where the firm has significant business
operations, such as the United Kingdom, Japan, Hong Kong
and various states, such as New York. The tax years under
examination vary by jurisdiction. The firm does not expect
completion of these audits to have a material impact on the
firm’s financial condition, but it may be material to operating
results for a particular period, depending, in part, on the
operating results for that period.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
87 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 89 of 205 --

The table below presents the earliest tax years that remain
subject to examination by major jurisdiction.
As of
Jurisdiction September 2023
U.S. Federal 2011
New York State and City 2015
United Kingdom 2017
Japan 2017
Hong Kong 2017
The firm has been accepted into the Compliance Assurance
Process program by the IRS for each of the tax years from
2013 through 2023. This program allows the firm to work
with the IRS to identify and resolve potential U.S. federal tax
issues before the filing of tax returns. All issues for the 2011
through 2018 tax years have been resolved and completion is
pending final review by the Joint Committee on Taxation.
All issues for the 2019 and 2020 tax years have been resolved
and will be effectively settled pending administrative
completion by the IRS. Final completion of tax years 2011
through 2020 will not have a material impact on the effective
tax rate. The 2021 and 2022 tax years remain subject to post-
filing review. New York State and City examinations of tax
years 2015 through 2018 commenced during 2021.
All years, including and subsequent to the years in the table
above, remain open to examination by the taxing authorities.
The firm believes that the liability for unrecognized tax
benefits it has established is adequate in relation to the
potential for additional assessments.
Note 25.
Business Segments
The firm manages and reports its activities in three business
segments: Global Banking & Markets, Asset & Wealth
Management and Platform Solutions. See Note 1 for
information about the firm’s business segments.
Compensation and benefits expenses in the firm’s segments
reflect, among other factors, the overall performance of the
firm, as well as the performance of individual businesses.
Consequently, pre-tax margins in one segment of the firm’s
business may be significantly affected by the performance of
the firm’s other business segments.
The firm allocates assets (including allocations of global core
liquid assets and cash, secured client financing and other
assets), revenues and expenses among the three business
segments. Due to the integrated nature of these segments,
estimates and judgments are made in allocating certain assets,
revenues and expenses. The allocation process is based on the
manner in which management currently views the
performance of the segments.
The allocation of common shareholders’ equity and preferred
stock dividends to each segment is based on the estimated
amount of equity required to support the activities of the
segment under relevant regulatory capital requirements.
Net earnings for each segment is calculated by applying the
firmwide tax rate to each segment’s pre-tax earnings.
Management believes that this allocation provides a
reasonable representation of each segment’s contribution to
consolidated net earnings to common, return on average
common equity and total assets. Transactions between
segments are based on specific criteria or approximate third-
party rates.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 88

-- 90 of 205 --

Segment Results
The table below presents a summary of the firm’s segment
results.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Global Banking & Markets
Non-interest revenues $ 7,838 $ 6,933 $ 22,922 $ 24,156
Net interest income 171 631 720 1,812
Total net revenues 8,009 7,564 23,642 25,968
Provision for credit losses 29 63 214 462
Operating expenses 4,791 4,224 13,702 13,628
Pre-tax earnings $ 3,189 $ 3,277 $ 9,726 $ 11,878
Net earnings $ 2,383 $ 2,668 $ 7,460 $ 9,870
Net earnings to common $ 2,250 $ 2,586 $ 7,108 $ 9,602
Average common equity $ 72,517 $ 71,850 $ 70,968 $ 70,006
Return on average common equity 12.4% 14.4% 13.4% 18.3%
Asset & Wealth Management
Non-interest revenues $ 2,544 $ 3,085 $ 7,100 $ 7,210
Net interest income 686 948 2,393 2,605
Total net revenues 3,230 4,033 9,493 9,815
Provision for credit losses 51 (13) (499) 339
Operating expenses 3,005 2,955 9,448 8,187
Pre-tax earnings $ 174 $ 1,091 $ 544 $ 1,289
Net earnings $ 129 $ 905 $ 417 $ 1,071
Net earnings to common $ 93 $ 882 $ 318 $ 990
Average common equity $ 28,601 $ 31,516 $ 30,806 $ 31,238
Return on average common equity 1.3 % 11.2% 1.4% 4.2%
Platform Solutions
Non-interest revenues $ (112) $ (86) $ (98) $ (198)
Net interest income 690 464 1,899 1,187
Total net revenues 578 378 1,801 989
Provision for credit losses (73) 465 736 942
Operating expenses 1,258 525 2,850 1,258
Pre-tax earnings/(loss) $ (607) $ (612) $ (1,785) $ (1,211)
Net earnings/(loss) $ (454) $ (504) $ (1,369) $ (1,006)
Net earnings/(loss) to common $ (461) $ (506) $ (1,386) $ (1,013)
Average common equity $ 4,227 $ 3,944 $ 4,060 $ 3,471
Return on average common equity (43.6)% (51.3) % (45.5)% (38.9) %
Total
Non-interest revenues $ 10,270 $ 9,932 $ 29,924 $ 31,168
Net interest income 1,547 2,043 5,012 5,604
Total net revenues 11,817 11,975 34,936 36,772
Provision for credit losses 7 515 451 1,743
Operating expenses 9,054 7,704 26,000 23,073
Pre-tax earnings $ 2,756 $ 3,756 $ 8,485 $ 11,956
Net earnings $ 2,058 $ 3,069 $ 6,508 $ 9,935
Net earnings to common $ 1,882 $ 2,962 $ 6,040 $ 9,579
Average common equity $ 105,345 $ 107,310 $ 105,834 $ 104,715
Return on average common equity 7.1% 11.0% 7.6% 12.2%
In the table above:
• Revenues and expenses directly associated with each
segment are included in determining pre-tax earnings.
• Net revenues in the firm’s segments include allocations of
interest income and expense to specific positions in relation
to the cash generated by, or funding requirements of, such
positions. Net interest is included in segment net revenues
as it is consistent with how management assesses segment
performance.
• Expenses not directly associated with specific segments are
allocated based on an estimate of support provided to each
segment.
The table below presents depreciation and amortization
expense by segment.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Global Banking & Markets $ 275 $ 257 $ 837 $ 775
Asset & Wealth Management 607 344 1,954 804
Platform Solutions 630 65 1,285 149
Total $ 1,512 $ 666 $ 4,076 $ 1,728
In the table above:
• Asset & Wealth Management included impairments related
to commercial real estate included within consolidated
investment entities of $358 million for the three months
ended September 2023 and $1.20 billion for the nine
months ended September 2023.
• Platform Solutions included the $506 million write-down
related to GreenSky for both the three and nine months
ended September 2023, and an impairment of goodwill of
$504 million related to Consumer platforms for the nine
months ended September 2023.
Segment Assets
The table below presents assets by segment.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Global Banking & Markets $ 1,318,009 $ 1,169,539
Asset & Wealth Management 191,307 214,970
Platform Solutions 67,837 57,290
Total $ 1,577,153 $ 1,441,799
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
89 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 91 of 205 --

Geographic Information
Due to the highly integrated nature of international financial
markets, the firm manages its businesses based on the
profitability of the enterprise as a whole. The methodology
for allocating profitability to geographic regions is dependent
on estimates and management judgment because a significant
portion of the firm’s activities require cross-border
coordination in order to facilitate the needs of the firm’s
clients. Geographic results are generally allocated as follows:
• Global Banking & Markets: Investment banking fees and
Other: location of the client and investment banking team;
FICC intermediation and Equities intermediation: location
of the market-making desk; FICC financing and Equities
financing: location of the desk.
• Asset & Wealth Management (excluding direct-to-
consumer business, Equity investments and Debt
investments): location of the sales team and/or investments;
Direct-to-consumer business: location of the client; Equity
investments and Debt investments: location of the
investment or investment professional.
• Platform Solutions: location of the client.
The table below presents total net revenues and pre-tax
earnings by geographic region.
$ in millions 2023 2022
Three Months Ended September
Americas $ 7,570 64% $ 7,435 62%
EMEA 2,811 24% 3,154 26%
Asia 1,436 12% 1,386 12%
Total net revenues $ 11,817 100% $ 11,975 100%
Americas $ 1,590 58% $ 2,207 59%
EMEA 927 33% 1,277 34%
Asia 239 9% 272 7%
Total pre-tax earnings $ 2,756 100% $ 3,756 100%
Nine Months Ended September
Americas $ 21,565 62% $ 21,749 59%
EMEA 9,263 26% 10,454 29%
Asia 4,108 12% 4,569 12%
Total net revenues $ 34,936 100% $ 36,772 100%
Americas $ 4,209 50% $ 6,271 53%
EMEA 3,391 40% 4,474 37%
Asia 885 10% 1,211 10%
Total pre-tax earnings $ 8,485 100% $ 11,956 100%
In the table above:
• Americas pre-tax earnings for both the three and nine
months ended September 2023 were impacted by
impairments related to commercial real estate included
within consolidated investment entities and a write-down
related to GreenSky. Additionally, Americas pre-tax
earnings for the nine months ended September 2023 were
impacted by an impairment of goodwill related to
Consumer platforms.
• Substantially all of the amounts in Americas were
attributable to the U.S.
• Asia includes Australia and New Zealand.
Note 26.
Credit Concentrations
The firm’s concentrations of credit risk arise from its market-
making, client facilitation, investing, underwriting, lending
and collateralized transactions, and cash management
activities, and may be impacted by changes in economic,
industry or political factors. These activities expose the firm
to many different industries and counterparties, and may also
subject the firm to a concentration of credit risk to a
particular central bank, counterparty, borrower or issuer,
including sovereign issuers, or to a particular clearinghouse
or exchange. The firm seeks to mitigate credit risk by actively
monitoring exposures and obtaining collateral from
counterparties as deemed appropriate.
The firm measures and monitors its credit exposure based on
amounts owed to the firm after taking into account risk
mitigants that the firm considers when determining credit
risk. Such risk mitigants include netting and collateral
arrangements and economic hedges, such as credit
derivatives, futures and forward contracts. Netting and
collateral agreements permit the firm to offset receivables and
payables with such counterparties and/or enable the firm to
obtain collateral on an upfront or contingent basis.
The table below presents the credit concentrations included
in trading cash instruments and investments.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
U.S. government and agency obligations $ 265,459 $ 205,935
Percentage of total assets 16.8% 14.3%
Non-U.S. government and agency obligations $ 77,168 $ 40,334
Percentage of total assets 4.9% 2.8%
In addition, the firm had $205.39 billion as of September 2023
and $208.53 billion as of December 2022 of cash deposits held
at central banks (included in cash and cash equivalents), of
which $122.53 billion as of September 2023 and $165.77
billion as of December 2022 was held at the Federal Reserve.
As of both September 2023 and December 2022, the firm did
not have credit exposure to any other counterparty that
exceeded 2% of total assets.
Collateral obtained by the firm related to derivative assets is
principally cash and is held by the firm or a third-party
custodian. Collateral obtained by the firm related to resale
agreements and securities borrowed transactions is primarily
U.S. government and agency obligations, and non-U.S.
government and agency obligations. See Note 11 for further
information about collateralized agreements and financings.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 90

-- 92 of 205 --

The table below presents U.S. government and agency
obligations, and non-U.S. government and agency obligations
that collateralize resale agreements and securities borrowed
transactions.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
U.S. government and agency obligations $ 114,609 $ 164,897
Non-U.S. government and agency obligations $ 91,398 $ 76,456
In the table above:
• Non-U.S. government and agency obligations primarily
consists of securities issued by the governments of the U.K.,
Japan, Germany, France and Italy.
• Given that the firm’s primary credit exposure on such
transactions is to the counterparty to the transaction, the
firm would be exposed to the collateral issuer only in the
event of counterparty default.
Note 27.
Legal Proceedings
The firm is involved in a number of judicial, regulatory and
arbitration proceedings (including those described below)
concerning matters arising in connection with the conduct of
the firm’s businesses. Many of these proceedings are in early
stages, and many of these cases seek an indeterminate
amount of damages.
Under ASC 450, an event is “reasonably possible” if “the
chance of the future event or events occurring is more than
remote but less than likely” and an event is “remote” if “the
chance of the future event or events occurring is slight.”
Thus, references to the upper end of the range of reasonably
possible loss for cases in which the firm is able to estimate a
range of reasonably possible loss mean the upper end of the
range of loss for cases for which the firm believes the risk of
loss is more than slight.
With respect to matters described below for which
management has been able to estimate a range of reasonably
possible loss where (i) actual or potential plaintiffs have
claimed an amount of money damages, (ii) the firm is being,
or threatened to be, sued by purchasers in a securities offering
and is not being indemnified by a party that the firm believes
will pay the full amount of any judgment, or (iii) the
purchasers are demanding that the firm repurchase securities,
management has estimated the upper end of the range of
reasonably possible loss based on (a) in the case of (i), the
amount of money damages claimed, (b) in the case of (ii), the
difference between the initial sales price of the securities that
the firm sold in such offering and the estimated lowest
subsequent price of such securities prior to the action being
commenced and (c) in the case of (iii), the price that
purchasers paid for the securities less the estimated value, if
any, as of September 2023 of the relevant securities, in each of
cases (i), (ii) and (iii), taking into account any other factors
believed to be relevant to the particular matter or matters of
that type. As of the date hereof, the firm has estimated the
upper end of the range of reasonably possible aggregate loss
for such matters and for any other matters described below
where management has been able to estimate a range of
reasonably possible aggregate loss to be approximately
$2.2 billion in excess of the aggregate reserves for such
matters.
Management is generally unable to estimate a range of
reasonably possible loss for matters other than those included
in the estimate above, including where (i) actual or potential
plaintiffs have not claimed an amount of money damages,
except in those instances where management can otherwise
determine an appropriate amount, (ii) matters are in early
stages, (iii) matters relate to regulatory investigations or
reviews, except in those instances where management can
otherwise determine an appropriate amount, (iv) there is
uncertainty as to the likelihood of a class being certified or
the ultimate size of the class, (v) there is uncertainty as to the
outcome of pending appeals or motions, (vi) there are
significant factual issues to be resolved, and/or (vii) there are
novel legal issues presented. For example, the firm’s potential
liabilities with respect to the investigations and reviews
described below in “Regulatory Investigations and Reviews
and Related Litigation” generally are not included in
management’s estimate of reasonably possible loss. However,
management does not believe, based on currently available
information, that the outcomes of such other matters will
have a material adverse effect on the firm’s financial
condition, though the outcomes could be material to the
firm’s operating results for any particular period, depending,
in part, upon the operating results for such period.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
91 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 93 of 205 --

1MDB-Related Matters
Between 2012 and 2013, subsidiaries of the firm acted as
arrangers or purchasers of approximately $6.5 billion of debt
securities of 1MDB.
On November 1, 2018, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ)
unsealed a criminal information and guilty plea by Tim
Leissner, a former participating managing director of the
firm, and an indictment against Ng Chong Hwa, a former
managing director of the firm. On August 28, 2018, Leissner
was adjudicated guilty by the U.S. District Court for the
Eastern District of New York of conspiring to launder money
and to violate the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act’s
(FCPA) anti-bribery and internal accounting controls
provisions. Ng was charged with conspiring to launder
money and to violate the FCPA’s anti-bribery and internal
accounting controls provisions, and on April 8, 2022, Ng was
found guilty on all counts following a trial.
On August 18, 2020, the firm announced that it entered into a
settlement agreement with the Government of Malaysia to
resolve the criminal and regulatory proceedings in Malaysia
involving the firm, which includes a guarantee that the
Government of Malaysia receives at least $1.4 billion in
assets and proceeds from assets seized by governmental
authorities around the world related to 1MDB. See Note 18
for further information about this guarantee, including
related arbitration proceedings.
On October 22, 2020, the firm announced that it reached
settlements of governmental and regulatory investigations
relating to 1MDB with the DOJ, the SEC, the FRB, the
NYDFS, the FCA, the PRA, the Singapore Attorney General’s
Chambers, the Singapore Commercial Affairs Department,
the Monetary Authority of Singapore and the Hong Kong
Securities and Futures Commission. Group Inc. entered into a
three-year deferred prosecution agreement with the DOJ, in
which a charge against the firm, one count of conspiracy to
violate the FCPA, was filed and will later be dismissed if the
firm abides by the terms of the agreement. In addition, GS
Malaysia pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to violate
the FCPA, and was sentenced on June 9, 2021. In May 2021,
the U.S. Department of Labor granted the firm a five-year
exemption to maintain its status as a qualified professional
asset manager (QPAM).
On December 20, 2018, a putative securities class action
lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern
District of New York against Group Inc. and certain former
officers of the firm alleging violations of the anti-fraud
provisions of the Exchange Act with respect to Group Inc.’s
disclosures and public statements concerning 1MDB and
seeking unspecified damages. The plaintiff filed the second
amended complaint on October 28, 2019. On June 28, 2021,
the court dismissed the claims against one of the individual
defendants but denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss with
respect to the firm and the remaining individual defendants.
On August 4, 2023, the plaintiff filed a third amended
complaint. On September 29, 2023, the plaintiff moved for
class certification.
Mortgage-Related Matters
Beginning in April 2010, a number of purported securities law
class actions were filed in the U.S. District Court for the
Southern District of New York challenging the adequacy of
Group Inc.’s public disclosure of, among other things, the
firm’s activities in the collateralized debt obligation market,
and the firm’s conflict of interest management.
The consolidated amended complaint filed on July 25, 2011,
which named as defendants Group Inc. and certain current
and former officers and employees of Group Inc. and its
affiliates, generally alleges violations of Sections 10(b) and
20(a) of the Exchange Act and seeks monetary damages. The
defendants have moved for summary judgment. On April 7,
2020, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
affirmed the district court’s August 14, 2018 grant of class
certification. On June 21, 2021, the United States Supreme
Court vacated the judgment of the Second Circuit and
remanded the case for further proceedings, and on August 26,
2021, the Second Circuit vacated the district court’s grant of
class certification and remanded the case for further
proceedings. On December 8, 2021, the district court granted
the plaintiffs’ motion for class certification. On March 9,
2022, the Second Circuit granted defendants’ petition seeking
interlocutory review of the district court’s grant of class
certification and, on August 10, 2023, reversed the district
court’s class certification order and remanded with
instructions to decertify the class.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 92

-- 94 of 205 --

Complaints were filed in the U.S. District Court for the
Southern District of New York on July 25, 2019 and May 29,
2020 against Goldman Sachs Mortgage Company and GS
Mortgage Securities Corp. by U.S. Bank National
Association, as trustee for two residential mortgage-backed
securitization trusts that issued $1.7 billion of securities. The
complaints generally allege that mortgage loans in the trusts
failed to conform to applicable representations and
warranties and seek specific performance or, alternatively,
compensatory damages and other relief. On November 23,
2020, the court granted in part and denied in part defendants’
motion to dismiss the complaint in the first action and denied
defendants’ motion to dismiss the complaint in the second
action. On January 14, 2021, amended complaints were filed
in both actions.
Currencies-Related Litigation
GS&Co. is among the defendants named in a putative class
action filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern
District of New York on August 4, 2021. The amended
complaint, filed on January 6, 2022, generally asserts claims
under federal antitrust law and state common law in
connection with an alleged conspiracy among the defendants
to manipulate auctions for foreign exchange transactions on
an electronic trading platform, as well as claims under the
Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act. The
complaint seeks declaratory and injunctive relief, as well as
unspecified amounts of treble and other damages. On May
18, 2023, the court dismissed certain state common law
claims, but denied dismissal of the remaining claims. On July
7, 2023, the plaintiffs filed a second amended complaint.
Banco Espirito Santo S.A. and Oak Finance
Beginning in February 2015, GSI commenced actions against
Novo Banco S.A. (Novo Banco) in the English Commercial
Court and the Bank of Portugal (BoP) in Portuguese
Administrative Court in response to BoP’s decisions in
December 2014, September 2015 and December 2015 to
reverse an earlier transfer to Novo Banco of an $835 million
facility agreement (the Facility), structured by GSI, between
Oak Finance Luxembourg S.A. (Oak Finance), a special
purpose vehicle formed in connection with the Facility, and
Banco Espirito Santo S.A. (BES) prior to the failure of BES. In
July 2018, the English Supreme Court found that the English
courts will not have jurisdiction over GSI’s action unless and
until the Portuguese Administrative Court finds against BoP
in GSI’s parallel action. In July 2018, the Liquidation
Committee for BES issued a decision seeking to claw back
from GSI $54 million paid to GSI and $50 million allegedly
paid to Oak Finance in connection with the Facility, alleging
that GSI acted in bad faith in extending the Facility, including
because GSI allegedly knew that BES was at risk of imminent
failure. In October 2018, GSI commenced an action in Lisbon
Commercial Court challenging the Liquidation Committee’s
decision and has since also issued a claim against the
Portuguese State seeking compensation for losses of
approximately $222 million related to the failure of BES,
together with a contingent claim for the $104 million sought
by the Liquidation Committee. On April 11, 2023, GSI
commenced administrative proceedings against the BoP,
seeking the nullification of the BoP’s September 2015 and
December 2015 decisions on new grounds.
Financial Advisory Services
Group Inc. and certain of its affiliates are from time to time
parties to various civil litigation and arbitration proceedings
and other disputes with clients and third parties relating to
the firm’s financial advisory activities. These claims generally
seek, among other things, compensatory damages and, in
some cases, punitive damages, and in certain cases allege that
the firm did not appropriately disclose or deal with conflicts
of interest.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
93 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 95 of 205 --

Archegos-Related Matters
GS&Co. is among the underwriters named as defendants in a
putative securities class action filed on August 13, 2021 in
New York Supreme Court, County of New York, relating to
ViacomCBS Inc.’s (ViacomCBS) March 2021 public offerings
of $1.7 billion of common stock and $1.0 billion of preferred
stock. In addition to the underwriters, the defendants include
ViacomCBS and certain of its officers and directors. GS&Co.
underwrote 646,154 shares of common stock representing an
aggregate offering price of approximately $55 million and
323,077 shares of preferred stock representing an aggregate
offering price of approximately $32 million. The complaint
asserts claims under the federal securities laws and alleges
that the offering documents contained material
misstatements and omissions, including, among other things,
that the offering documents failed to disclose that Archegos
Capital Management, LP (Archegos) had substantial
exposure to ViacomCBS, including through total return
swaps to which certain of the underwriters, including
GS&Co., were allegedly counterparties, and that such
underwriters failed to disclose their exposure to Archegos.
On December 21, 2021, the plaintiffs filed a corrected
amended complaint. The complaint seeks rescission and
compensatory damages in unspecified amounts. On January
4, 2022, the plaintiffs moved for class certification. On
February 6, 2023, the court dismissed the claims against
ViacomCBS and the individual defendants, but denied the
defendants’ motions to dismiss with respect to GS&Co. and
the other underwriter defendants. On February 15, 2023, the
underwriter defendants appealed the court’s denial of the
motion to dismiss. On March 10, 2023, the plaintiffs
appealed the court’s dismissal of the claims against
ViacomCBS and the individual defendants. On April 18,
2023, the plaintiffs moved for class certification. On June 12,
2023, the court denied the underwriter defendants’ motion to
stay the proceedings pending their appeal of the court's denial
of the motion to dismiss, and on June 27, 2023 the
underwriter defendants appealed.
Group Inc. is also a defendant in putative securities class
actions filed beginning in October 2021 and consolidated in
the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New
York. The complaints allege that Group Inc., along with
another financial institution, sold shares in Baidu Inc.
(Baidu), Discovery Inc. (Discovery), GSX Techedu Inc.
(Gaotu), iQIYI Inc. (iQIYI), Tencent Music Entertainment
Group (Tencent), ViacomCBS, and Vipshop Holdings Ltd.
(Vipshop) based on material nonpublic information
regarding the liquidation of Archegos’ position in Baidu,
Discovery, Gaotu, iQIYI, Tencent, ViacomCBS and Vipshop,
respectively. The complaints generally assert violations of
Sections 10(b), 20A and 20(a) of the Exchange Act and seek
unspecified damages. On June 13, 2022, the plaintiffs in the
class actions filed amended complaints. On March 31, 2023,
the court granted the defendants’ motions to dismiss the
amended complaints without prejudice. In May 2023, the
plaintiffs in the class actions filed second amended
complaints, and on July 18, 2023, the defendants moved to
dismiss the second amended complaints.
On January 24, 2022, the firm received a demand from an
alleged shareholder under Section 220 of the Delaware
General Corporation Law for books and records relating to,
among other things, the firm’s involvement with Archegos
and the firm’s controls with respect to insider trading.
Silicon Valley Bank Matters
GS&Co. is among the underwriters named as defendants in a
putative securities class action filed on April 7, 2023 in the
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California
relating to SVB Financial Group’s (SVBFG) January 2021
public offerings of $500 million principal amount of senior
notes and $750 million of depositary shares representing
interests in preferred stock, March 2021 public offering of
approximately $1.2 billion of common stock, May 2021
public offerings of $1.0 billion of depositary shares
representing interests in preferred stock and $500 million
principal amount of senior notes, August 2021 public offering
of approximately $1.3 billion of common stock, and April
2022 public offering of $800 million aggregate principal
amount of senior notes, among other public offerings of
securities. In addition to the underwriters, the defendants
include certain of SVBFG’s officers and directors and its
auditor. GS&Co. underwrote an aggregate of 831,250
depositary shares representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $831 million, an aggregate of 3,266,108 shares
of common stock representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $1.8 billion and senior notes representing an
aggregate price to the public of approximately $727 million.
The complaint asserts claims under the federal securities laws
and alleges that the offering documents contained material
misstatements and omissions. The complaint seeks
compensatory damages in unspecified amounts. On March
17, 2023, SVBFG filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the U.S.
Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York.
The firm is also cooperating with and providing information
to various governmental bodies in connection with their
investigations and inquiries regarding SVBFG and its
affiliates (collectively SVB), including the firm’s business with
SVB in or around March 2023, when SVB engaged the firm to
assist with a proposed capital raise and SVB sold the firm a
portfolio of securities.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 94

-- 96 of 205 --

Underwriting Litigation
Firm affiliates are among the defendants in a number of
proceedings in connection with securities offerings. In these
proceedings, including those described below, the plaintiffs
assert class action or individual claims under federal and state
securities laws and in some cases other applicable laws, allege
that the offering documents for the securities that they
purchased contained material misstatements and omissions,
and generally seek compensatory and rescissory damages in
unspecified amounts, as well as rescission. Certain of these
proceedings involve additional allegations.
Uber Technologies, Inc. GS&Co. is among the
underwriters named as defendants in several putative
securities class actions filed beginning in September 2019 in
California Superior Court, County of San Francisco and the
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California,
relating to Uber Technologies, Inc.’s (Uber) $8.1 billion May
2019 initial public offering. In addition to the underwriters,
the defendants include Uber and certain of its officers and
directors. GS&Co. underwrote 35,864,408 shares of common
stock representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $1.6 billion. On November 16, 2020, the court
in the state court action granted defendants’ motion to
dismiss the consolidated amended complaint filed on
February 11, 2020, and on December 16, 2020, plaintiffs
appealed. On August 7, 2020, defendants’ motion to dismiss
the district court action was denied. On September 25, 2020,
the plaintiffs in the district court action moved for class
certification. On December 5, 2020, the plaintiffs in the state
court action filed a complaint in the district court, which was
consolidated with the existing district court action on
January 25, 2021. On May 14, 2021, the plaintiffs filed a
second amended complaint in the district court, purporting to
add the plaintiffs from the state court action as additional
class representatives. On October 1, 2021, defendants’
motion to dismiss the additional class representatives from
the second amended complaint was denied, and on July 26,
2022, the district court granted the plaintiffs’ motion for class
certification. On February 27, 2023, the U.S. Court of
Appeals for the Ninth Circuit denied the defendants’ petition
seeking interlocutory review of the district court’s grant of
class certification.
GoHealth, Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters named
as defendants in putative securities class actions filed
beginning on September 21, 2020 and consolidated in the U.S.
District Court for the Northern District of Illinois relating to
GoHealth, Inc.’s (GoHealth) $914 million July 2020 initial
public offering. In addition to the underwriters, the
defendants include GoHealth, certain of its officers and
directors and certain of its shareholders. GS&Co.
underwrote 11,540,550 shares of common stock representing
an aggregate offering price of approximately $242 million.
On February 25, 2021, the plaintiffs filed a consolidated
complaint. On April 5, 2022, the defendants’ motion to
dismiss the consolidated complaint was denied. On
September 23, 2022, the plaintiffs moved for class
certification.
Array Technologies, Inc. GS&Co. is among the
underwriters named as defendants in a putative securities
class action filed on May 14, 2021 in the U.S. District Court
for the Southern District of New York relating to Array
Technologies, Inc.’s (Array) $1.2 billion October 2020 initial
public offering of common stock, $1.3 billion December 2020
offering of common stock and $993 million March 2021
offering of common stock. In addition to the underwriters,
the defendants include Array and certain of its officers and
directors. GS&Co. underwrote an aggregate of 31,912,213
shares of common stock in the three offerings representing an
aggregate offering price of approximately $877 million. On
December 7, 2021, the plaintiffs filed an amended
consolidated complaint, and on May 19, 2023, the court
granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss the amended
consolidated complaint. On July 5, 2023, the court denied the
plaintiffs’ request for leave to amend the amended
consolidated complaint and dismissed the case with
prejudice. On August 4, 2023, plaintiffs appealed to the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.
ContextLogic Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters
named as defendants in putative securities class actions filed
beginning on May 17, 2021 and consolidated in the U.S.
District Court for the Northern District of California,
relating to ContextLogic Inc.’s (ContextLogic) $1.1 billion
December 2020 initial public offering of common stock. In
addition to the underwriters, the defendants include
ContextLogic and certain of its officers and directors.
GS&Co. underwrote 16,169,000 shares of common stock
representing an aggregate offering price of approximately
$388 million. On July 15, 2022, the plaintiffs filed a
consolidated amended complaint, and on March 10, 2023, the
court granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss the
consolidated amended complaint with leave to amend. On
April 10, 2023, the plaintiffs filed a second consolidated
amended complaint, and on June 9, 2023, the defendants
moved to dismiss the second consolidated amended
complaint.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
95 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 97 of 205 --

DiDi Global Inc. Goldman Sachs (Asia) L.L.C. (GS Asia) is
among the underwriters named as defendants in putative
securities class actions filed beginning on July 6, 2021 in the
U.S. District Courts for the Southern District of New York
and the Central District of California and New York
Supreme Court, County of New York, relating to DiDi
Global Inc.’s (DiDi) $4.4 billion June 2021 initial public
offering of American Depositary Shares (ADS). In addition to
the underwriters, the defendants include DiDi and certain of
its officers and directors. GS Asia underwrote 104,554,000
ADS representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $1.5 billion. On September 22, 2021, plaintiffs
in the California action voluntarily dismissed their claims
without prejudice. On May 5, 2022, plaintiffs in the
consolidated federal action filed a second consolidated
amended complaint, which includes allegations of violations
of Sections 10(b) and 20A of the Exchange Act against the
underwriter defendants. On June 3, 2022, the defendants
moved to dismiss the second consolidated amended
complaint.
Vroom Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters named as
defendants in an amended complaint for a putative securities
class action filed on October 4, 2021 in the U.S. District
Court for the Southern District of New York relating to
Vroom Inc.’s (Vroom) approximately $589 million September
2020 public offering of common stock. In addition to the
underwriters, the defendants include Vroom and certain of its
officers and directors. GS&Co. underwrote 3,886,819 shares
of common stock representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $212 million. On December 20, 2021, the
defendants served a motion to dismiss the consolidated
complaint.
Zymergen Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters named
as defendants in a putative securities class action filed on
August 4, 2021 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern
District of California relating to Zymergen Inc.’s (Zymergen)
$575 million April 2021 initial public offering of common
stock. In addition to the underwriters, the defendants include
Zymergen and certain of its officers and directors. GS&Co.
underwrote 5,750,345 shares of common stock representing
an aggregate offering price of approximately $178 million.
On February 24, 2022, the plaintiffs filed an amended
complaint, and on November 29, 2022, the court granted in
part and denied in part the defendants’ motion to dismiss the
amended complaint, denying dismissal of the claims for
violations of Section 11 of the Securities Act. On August 11,
2023, the court granted the plaintiffs’ motion for class
certification. On October 3, 2023, Zymergen and three
affiliates filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy petitions in the U.S.
Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware.
Waterdrop Inc. GS Asia is among the underwriters named
as defendants in a putative securities class action filed on
September 14, 2021 in the U.S. District Court for the
Southern District of New York relating to Waterdrop Inc.’s
(Waterdrop) $360 million May 2021 initial public offering of
ADS. In addition to the underwriters, the defendants include
Waterdrop and certain of its officers and directors. GS Asia
underwrote 15,300,000 ADS representing an aggregate
offering price of approximately $184 million. On February
21, 2022, the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint, and on
February 3, 2023, the court granted the defendants’ motion to
dismiss the amended complaint. On March 6, 2023, plaintiffs
appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.
Sea Limited. GS Asia is among the underwriters named as
defendants in putative securities class actions filed on
February 11, 2022 and June 17, 2022, respectively, in New
York Supreme Court, County of New York, relating to Sea
Limited’s approximately $4.0 billion September 2021 public
offering of ADS and approximately $2.9 billion September
2021 public offering of convertible senior notes, respectively.
In addition to the underwriters, the defendants include Sea
Limited, certain of its officers and directors and certain of its
shareholders. GS Asia underwrote 8,222,500 ADS
representing an aggregate offering price of approximately
$2.6 billion and convertible senior notes representing an
aggregate offering price of approximately $1.9 billion. On
August 3, 2022, the actions were consolidated, and on August
9, 2022, the plaintiffs filed a consolidated amended
complaint. The defendants had previously moved to dismiss
the action on July 15, 2022, with the parties stipulating that
the motion would apply to the consolidated amended
complaint. On May 15, 2023, the court granted the
defendants’ motion to dismiss the consolidated amended
complaint with prejudice, and on June 15, 2023, the plaintiffs
moved for a rehearing or for leave to amend the consolidated
amended complaint and also appealed.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 96

-- 98 of 205 --

Rivian Automotive Inc. GS&Co. is among the
underwriters named as defendants in putative securities class
actions filed on March 7, 2022 and February 28, 2023 in the
U.S. District Court for the Central District of California and
in the Superior Court of the State of California, County of
Orange, respectively, relating to Rivian Automotive Inc.’s
(Rivian) approximately $13.7 billion November 2021 initial
public offering. In addition to the underwriters, the
defendants include Rivian and certain of its officers and
directors. GS&Co. underwrote 44,733,050 shares of common
stock representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $3.5 billion. On March 2, 2023, the plaintiffs
in the federal court action filed an amended consolidated
complaint, and on July 3, 2023, the court denied the
defendants’ motion to dismiss the amended consolidated
complaint. On June 30, 2023, the court in the state court
action granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss the
complaint, and on September 1, 2023, the plaintiffs appealed.
Natera Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters named as
defendants in putative securities class actions in New York
Supreme Court, County of New York and the U.S. District
Court for the Western District of Texas filed on March 10,
2022 and October 7, 2022, respectively, relating to Natera
Inc.’s (Natera) approximately $585 million July 2021 public
offering of common stock. In addition to the underwriters,
the defendants include Natera and certain of its officers and
directors. GS&Co. underwrote 1,449,000 shares of common
stock representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $164 million. On July 15, 2022, the parties in
the state court action filed a stipulation and proposed order
approving the discontinuance of the action without prejudice.
On September 11, 2023, the federal court granted in part and
denied in part the defendants’ motion to dismiss.
Robinhood Markets, Inc. GS&Co. is among the
underwriters named as defendants in a putative securities
class action filed on December 17, 2021 in the U.S. District
Court for the Northern District of California relating to
Robinhood Markets, Inc.’s (Robinhood) approximately $2.2
billion July 2021 initial public offering. In addition to the
underwriters, the defendants include Robinhood and certain
of its officers and directors. GS&Co. underwrote 18,039,706
shares of common stock representing an aggregate offering
price of approximately $686 million. On February 10, 2023,
the court granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss the
complaint with leave to amend, and on March 13, 2023, the
plaintiffs filed a second amended complaint. On May 12,
2023, the defendants moved to dismiss the second amended
complaint.
ON24, Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters named as
defendants in a putative securities class action filed on
November 3, 2021 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern
District of California relating to ON24, Inc.’s (ON24)
approximately $492 million February 2021 initial public
offering of common stock. In addition to the underwriters,
the defendants include ON24 and certain of its officers and
directors, including a director who was a Managing Director
of GS&Co. at the time of the initial public offering. GS&Co.
underwrote 3,616,785 shares of common stock representing
an aggregate offering price of approximately $181 million.
On March 18, 2022, the plaintiffs filed a consolidated
complaint, and on July 7, 2023, the court granted the
defendants’ motion to dismiss the consolidated complaint
with leave to amend. On September 1, 2023, the plaintiffs
filed an amended consolidated complaint, and on October 16,
2023, the defendants moved to dismiss the amended
consolidated complaint.
Oscar Health, Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters
named as defendants in a putative securities class action filed
on May 12, 2022 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern
District of New York relating to Oscar Health, Inc.’s (Oscar
Health) approximately $1.4 billion March 2021 initial public
offering. In addition to the underwriters, the defendants
include Oscar Health and certain of its officers and directors.
GS&Co. underwrote 12,760,633 shares of common stock
representing an aggregate offering price of approximately
$498 million. On December 5, 2022, the plaintiffs filed an
amended complaint. On April 4, 2023, the defendants moved
to dismiss the amended complaint.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
97 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 99 of 205 --

Oak Street Health, Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters
named as defendants in an amended complaint for a putative
securities class action filed on May 25, 2022 in the U.S.
District Court for the Northern District of Illinois relating to
Oak Street Health, Inc.’s (Oak Street) $377 million August
2020 initial public offering, $298 million December 2020
secondary equity offering, $691 million February 2021
secondary equity offering and $747 million May 2021
secondary equity offering. In addition to the underwriters,
the defendants include Oak Street, certain of its officers and
directors and certain of its shareholders. GS&Co.
underwrote 4,157,103 shares of common stock in the August
2020 initial public offering representing an aggregate offering
price of approximately $87 million, 1,503,944 shares of
common stock in the December 2020 secondary equity
offering representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $69 million, 3,083,098 shares of common
stock in the February 2021 secondary equity offering
representing an aggregate offering price of approximately
$173 million and 3,013,065 shares of common stock in the
May 2021 secondary equity offering representing an
aggregate offering price of approximately $187 million. On
February 10, 2023, the court granted in part and denied in
part the defendants’ motion to dismiss, dismissing the claim
alleging a violation of Section 12(a)(2) of the Securities Act
and, with respect to the May 2021 secondary equity offering
only, the claim alleging a violation of Section 11 of the
Securities Act, but declining to dismiss the remaining claims.
Reata Pharmaceuticals, Inc. GS&Co. is among the
underwriters named as defendants in a consolidated amended
complaint for a putative securities class action filed on June
21, 2022 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of
Texas relating to Reata Pharmaceuticals, Inc.’s (Reata)
approximately $282 million December 2020 public offering of
common stock. In addition to the underwriters, the
defendants include Reata and certain of its officers and
directors. GS&Co. underwrote 1,000,000 shares of common
stock representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $141 million. On September 7, 2022, the
defendants moved to dismiss the consolidated amended
complaint. In October 2023, the parties reached a settlement,
subject to court approval, to resolve this action. The
settlement would not require a contribution from GS&Co.
Bright Health Group, Inc. GS&Co. is among the
underwriters named as defendants in an amended complaint
for a putative securities class action filed on June 24, 2022 in
the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York
relating to Bright Health Group, Inc.’s (Bright Health)
approximately $924 million June 2021 initial public offering
of common stock. In addition to the underwriters, the
defendants include Bright Health and certain of its officers
and directors. GS&Co. underwrote 11,297,000 shares of
common stock representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $203 million. On October 12, 2022, the
defendants moved to dismiss the amended complaint.
17 Education & Technology Group Inc. GS Asia is among
the underwriters named as defendants in a putative securities
class action filed on July 19, 2022 in the U.S. District Court
for the Central District of California and transferred to the
U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York in
November 2022 relating to 17 Education & Technology
Group Inc.’s (17EdTech) approximately $331 million
December 2020 initial public offering of ADS. In addition to
the underwriters, the defendants include 17EdTech and
certain of its officers and directors. GS Asia underwrote
12,604,000 ADS representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $132 million. On January 31, 2023, the
plaintiffs filed an amended complaint. On March 31, 2023,
the defendants moved to dismiss the amended complaint. On
August 3, 2023, the plaintiffs filed objections with the district
court to the Magistrate Judge’s July 20, 2023 report
recommending that the defendants’ motion to dismiss the
amended complaint be granted.
LifeStance Health Group, Inc. GS&Co. is among the
underwriters named as defendants in a putative securities
class action filed on August 10, 2022 in the U.S. District
Court for the Southern District of New York relating to
LifeStance Health Group, Inc.’s (LifeStance) approximately
$828 million June 2021 initial public offering of common
stock. In addition to the underwriters, the defendants include
LifeStance and certain of its officers and directors. GS&Co.
underwrote 10,580,000 shares of common stock representing
an aggregate offering price of approximately $190 million.
On December 19, 2022, the plaintiffs filed an amended
complaint, and on April 10, 2023, the defendants’ motion to
dismiss the amended complaint was denied. On September 7,
2023, the court granted the plaintiffs’ motion for class
certification. On October 25, 2023, the court preliminarily
approved a settlement, which would not require a
contribution from GS&Co.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 98

-- 100 of 205 --

MINISO Group Holding Limited. GS Asia is among the
underwriters named as defendants in a putative securities
class action filed on August 17, 2022 in the U.S. District
Court for the Central District of California and transferred to
the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York
on November 18, 2022 relating to MINISO Group Holding
Limited’s (MINISO) approximately $656 million October
2020 initial public offering of ADS. In addition to the
underwriters, the defendants include MINISO and certain of
its officers and directors. GS Asia underwrote 16,408,093
ADS representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $328 million. On April 24, 2023, the plaintiffs
filed a second amended complaint, and on June 23, 2023, the
defendants moved to dismiss the second amended complaint.
Coupang, Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters named as
defendants in a putative securities class action filed on August
26, 2022 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of
New York relating to Coupang, Inc.’s (Coupang)
approximately $4.6 billion March 2021 initial public offering
of common stock. In addition to the underwriters, the
defendants include Coupang and certain of its officers and
directors. GS&Co. underwrote 42,900,000 shares of common
stock representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $1.5 billion. On May 24, 2023, the plaintiffs
filed an amended complaint, and on July 28, 2023, the
defendants moved to dismiss the amended complaint.
Yatsen Holding Limited. GS Asia is among the
underwriters named as defendants in a putative securities
class action filed on September 23, 2022 in the U.S. District
Court for the Southern District of New York relating to
Yatsen Holding Limited’s (Yatsen) approximately
$617 million November 2020 initial public offering of ADS.
In addition to the underwriters, the defendants include
Yatsen and certain of its officers and directors. GS Asia
underwrote 22,912,500 ADS representing an aggregate
offering price of approximately $241 million. On October 4,
2023, the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint.
Rent the Runway, Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters
named as defendants in a putative securities class action filed
on November 14, 2022 in the U.S. District Court for the
Eastern District of New York relating to Rent the Runway,
Inc.’s (Rent the Runway) $357 million October 2021 initial
public offering of common stock. In addition to the
underwriters, the defendants include Rent the Runway and
certain of its officers and directors. GS&Co. underwrote
5,254,304 shares of common stock representing an aggregate
offering price of approximately $110 million. On September
5, 2023, the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint, and on
October 20, 2023, the defendants served a motion to dismiss
the amended complaint.
Opendoor Technologies Inc. GS&Co. is among the
underwriters named as defendants in a putative securities
class action filed on November 22, 2022 in the U.S. District
Court for the District of Arizona relating to, among other
things, Opendoor Technologies Inc.’s (Opendoor)
approximately $886 million February 2021 public offering of
common stock. In addition to the underwriters, the
defendants include Opendoor and certain of its officers and
directors. GS&Co. underwrote 10,173,401 shares of common
stock representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $275 million. On April 17, 2023, the plaintiffs
filed a consolidated amended complaint, and on June 30,
2023, the defendants moved to dismiss the consolidated
amended complaint.
FIGS, Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters named as
defendants in a putative securities class action filed on
December 8, 2022 in the U.S. District Court for the Central
District of California relating to FIGS, Inc.’s (FIGS)
approximately $668 million May 2021 initial public offering
and approximately $413 million September 2021 secondary
equity offering. In addition to the underwriters, the
defendants include FIGS, certain of its officers and directors
and certain of its shareholders. GS&Co. underwrote
9,545,073 shares of common stock in the May 2021 initial
public offering representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $210 million and 3,179,047 shares of common
stock in the September 2021 secondary equity offering
representing an aggregate offering price of approximately
$128 million. On April 10, 2023, the plaintiffs filed a
consolidated complaint, and on May 25, 2023, the defendants
moved to dismiss the consolidated complaint.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
99 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 101 of 205 --

Silvergate Capital Corporation. GS&Co. is among the
underwriters and sales agents named as defendants in a
putative securities class action filed on January 19, 2023 in
the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of
California, as amended on May 11, 2023, relating to
Silvergate Capital Corporation’s (Silvergate) approximately
$288 million January 2021 public offering of common stock,
approximately $300 million “at-the-market” offering of
common stock conducted from March through May 2021,
approximately $200 million July 2021 public offering of
depositary shares representing interests in preferred stock,
and approximately $552 million December 2021 public
offering of common stock. In addition to the underwriters
and sales agents, the defendants include Silvergate and certain
of its officers and directors. GS&Co. underwrote 1,711,313
shares of common stock in the January 2021 public offering
of common stock representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $108 million, acted as a sales agent with
respect to up to a $300 million aggregate offering price of
shares of common stock in the March through May 2021 “at-
the-market” offering, underwrote 1,600,000 depositary shares
in the July 2021 public offering representing an aggregate
offering price of approximately $40 million, and underwrote
1,375,397 shares of common stock in the December 2021
public offering of common stock representing an aggregate
offering price of approximately $199 million. On July 10,
2023, the defendants moved to dismiss the consolidated
amended complaint.
Centessa Pharmaceuticals plc. GS&Co. is among the
underwriters named as defendants in an amended complaint
for a putative securities class action filed on February 10,
2023 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of
New York relating to Centessa Pharmaceuticals plc’s
(Centessa) approximately $380 million May 2021 initial
public offering of ADS. In addition to the underwriters, the
defendants include Centessa and certain of its officers and
directors. GS&Co. underwrote 6,072,000 ADS representing
an aggregate offering price of approximately $121 million.
On June 7, 2023, the defendants moved to dismiss the
amended complaint.
iQIYI, Inc. GS Asia is among the underwriters named as
defendants in a putative securities class action filed on June 1,
2021 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of
New York relating to iQIYI’s approximately $2.4 billion
March 2018 initial public offering of ADS. In addition to the
underwriters, the defendants include iQIYI, certain of its
officers and directors and its controlling shareholder. GS Asia
underwrote 69,751,212 ADS representing an aggregate
offering price of approximately $1.3 billion. On November
30, 2022, the defendants served a motion to dismiss the
amended complaint.
F45 Training Holdings Inc. GS&Co. is among the
underwriters named as defendants in an amended complaint
for a putative securities class action filed on May 19, 2023 in
the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas
relating to F45 Training Holdings Inc.’s (F45) approximately
$350 million July 2021 initial public offering of common
stock. In addition to the underwriters, the defendants include
F45, certain of its officers and directors and certain of its
shareholders. GS&Co. acted as a qualified independent
underwriter for the offering and underwrote 8,303,744 shares
of common stock representing an aggregate offering price of
approximately $133 million. On August 7, 2023, the
defendants filed a motion to dismiss the amended complaint.
Olaplex Holdings, Inc. GS&Co. is among the underwriters
named as defendants in a putative securities class action filed
on April 28, 2023 in the U.S. District Court for the Central
District of California relating to Olaplex Holdings, Inc.’s
(Olaplex) approximately $1.8 billion September 2021 initial
public offering of common stock. In addition to the
underwriters, the defendants include Olaplex, certain of its
officers and directors and selling shareholders. GS&Co.
underwrote 19,419,420 shares of common stock representing
an aggregate offering price of approximately $408 million.
On June 22, 2023, the plaintiffs filed a revised consolidated
complaint. On July 19, 2023, the defendants moved to
dismiss the revised consolidated complaint.
Investment Management Services
Group Inc. and certain of its affiliates are parties to various
civil litigation and arbitration proceedings and other disputes
with clients relating to losses allegedly sustained as a result of
the firm’s investment management services. These claims
generally seek, among other things, restitution or other
compensatory damages and, in some cases, punitive damages.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 100

-- 102 of 205 --

Securities Lending Antitrust Litigation
Group Inc. and GS&Co. were among the defendants named
in a putative antitrust class action and three individual
actions relating to securities lending practices filed in the U.S.
District Court for the Southern District of New York
beginning in August 2017. The complaints generally assert
claims under federal and state antitrust law and state
common law in connection with an alleged conspiracy among
the defendants to preclude the development of electronic
platforms for securities lending transactions. The individual
complaints also assert claims for tortious interference with
business relations and under state trade practices law and, in
the second and third individual actions, unjust enrichment
under state common law. The complaints seek declaratory
and injunctive relief, as well as unspecified amounts of
compensatory, treble, punitive and other damages. Group
Inc. was voluntarily dismissed from the putative class action
on January 26, 2018. Defendants’ motion to dismiss the class
action complaint was denied on September 27, 2018.
Defendants’ motion to dismiss the first individual action was
granted on August 7, 2019. On September 30, 2021, the
defendants’ motion to dismiss the second and third individual
actions, which were consolidated in June 2019, was granted,
and on March 24, 2023, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
Second Circuit affirmed the dismissal. On June 30, 2022, the
Magistrate Judge recommended that the plaintiffs’ motion
for class certification in the putative class action be granted in
part and denied in part. On August 15, 2022, the plaintiffs
and defendants filed objections to the Magistrate Judge’s
report and recommendation with the district court. On
September 1, 2023, the court preliminarily approved a
settlement among the plaintiffs and certain defendants,
including the firm, to resolve this action. The firm had
reserved the full amount of its proposed contribution to the
settlement.
Variable Rate Demand Obligations Antitrust Litigation
Group Inc. and GS&Co. were among the defendants named
in a putative class action relating to variable rate demand
obligations (VRDOs), filed beginning in February 2019 under
separate complaints and consolidated in the U.S. District
Court for the Southern District of New York. The
consolidated amended complaint, filed on May 31, 2019,
generally asserts claims under federal antitrust law and state
common law in connection with an alleged conspiracy among
the defendants to manipulate the market for VRDOs. The
complaint seeks declaratory and injunctive relief, as well as
unspecified amounts of compensatory, treble and other
damages. Group Inc. was voluntarily dismissed from the
putative class action on June 3, 2019. On November 2, 2020,
the court granted in part and denied in part the defendants’
motion to dismiss, dismissing the state common law claims
against GS&Co., but denying dismissal of the federal
antitrust law claims.
GS&Co. is also among the defendants named in a related
putative class action filed on June 2, 2021 in the U.S. District
Court for the Southern District of New York. The complaint
alleges the same conspiracy in the market for VRDOs as that
alleged in the consolidated amended complaint filed on May
31, 2019, and asserts federal antitrust law, state law and state
common law claims against the defendants. The complaint
seeks declaratory and injunctive relief, as well as unspecified
amounts of compensatory, treble and other damages. On
August 6, 2021, plaintiffs in the May 31, 2019 action filed an
amended complaint consolidating the June 2, 2021 action
with the May 31, 2019 action. On September 14, 2021,
defendants filed a joint partial motion to dismiss the August
6, 2021 amended consolidated complaint. On June 28, 2022,
the court granted in part and denied in part the defendants’
motion to dismiss, dismissing the state breach of fiduciary
duty claim against GS&Co., but declining to dismiss any
portion of the federal antitrust law claims. On September 21,
2023, the court granted the plaintiffs’ motion for class
certification.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
101 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 103 of 205 --

Interest Rate Swap Antitrust Litigation
Group Inc., GS&Co., GSI, GS Bank USA and Goldman Sachs
Financial Markets, L.P. are among the defendants named in a
putative antitrust class action relating to the trading of
interest rate swaps, filed in November 2015 and consolidated
in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New
York. The same Goldman Sachs entities are also among the
defendants named in two antitrust actions relating to the
trading of interest rate swaps, commenced in April 2016 and
June 2018, respectively, in the U.S. District Court for the
Southern District of New York by three operators of swap
execution facilities and certain of their affiliates. These
actions have been consolidated for pretrial proceedings. The
complaints generally assert claims under federal antitrust law
and state common law in connection with an alleged
conspiracy among the defendants to preclude exchange
trading of interest rate swaps. The complaints in the
individual actions also assert claims under state antitrust law.
The complaints seek declaratory and injunctive relief, as well
as treble damages in an unspecified amount. Defendants
moved to dismiss the class and the first individual action and
the district court dismissed the state common law claims
asserted by the plaintiffs in the first individual action and
otherwise limited the state common law claim in the putative
class action and the antitrust claims in both actions to the
period from 2013 to 2016. On November 20, 2018, the court
granted in part and denied in part the defendants’ motion to
dismiss the second individual action, dismissing the state
common law claims for unjust enrichment and tortious
interference, but denying dismissal of the federal and state
antitrust claims. On March 13, 2019, the court denied the
plaintiffs’ motion in the putative class action to amend their
complaint to add allegations related to conduct from 2008 to
2012, but granted the motion to add limited allegations from
2013 to 2016, which the plaintiffs added in a fourth
consolidated amended complaint filed on March 22, 2019.
The plaintiffs in the putative class action moved for class
certification on March 7, 2019.
Commodities-Related Litigation
GSI is among the defendants named in putative class actions
relating to trading in platinum and palladium, filed beginning
on November 25, 2014 and most recently amended on May
15, 2017, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District
of New York. The amended complaint generally alleges that
the defendants violated federal antitrust laws and the
Commodity Exchange Act in connection with an alleged
conspiracy to manipulate a benchmark for physical platinum
and palladium prices and seek declaratory and injunctive
relief, as well as treble damages in an unspecified amount. On
March 29, 2020, the court granted the defendants’ motions to
dismiss and for reconsideration, resulting in the dismissal of
all claims, and on February 27, 2023, the U.S. Court of
Appeals for the Second Circuit reversed the district court’s
dismissal of certain plaintiffs’ antitrust claims and vacated
the district court’s dismissal of the plaintiffs’ Commodity
Exchange Act claim. On April 12, 2023, the defendants’
petition for rehearing or rehearing en banc with the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit was denied. On July
21, 2023, the defendants filed a motion for judgment on the
pleadings.
GS&Co., GSI, J. Aron & Company and Metro International
Trade Services (Metro), a previously consolidated subsidiary
of Group Inc. that was sold in the fourth quarter of 2014, are
among the defendants in a number of putative class and
individual actions filed beginning on August 1, 2013 and
consolidated in the U.S. District Court for the Southern
District of New York. The complaints generally allege
violations of federal antitrust laws and state laws in
connection with the storage of aluminum and aluminum
trading. The complaints seek declaratory, injunctive and
other equitable relief, as well as unspecified monetary
damages, including treble damages. In December 2016, the
district court granted defendants’ motions to dismiss and on
August 27, 2019, the Second Circuit vacated the district
court’s dismissals and remanded the case to district court for
further proceedings. On July 23, 2020, the district court
denied the class plaintiffs’ motion for class certification, and
on December 16, 2020 the Second Circuit denied leave to
appeal the denial. On February 17, 2021, the district court
granted defendants’ motion for summary judgment with
respect to the claims of most of the individual plaintiffs. On
April 14, 2021, the plaintiffs appealed to the U.S. Court of
Appeals for the Second Circuit. On May 31, 2022, the two
remaining individual plaintiffs entered into a settlement with
the defendants. The firm has paid the full amount of its
contribution to the settlement.
In connection with the sale of Metro, the firm agreed to
provide indemnities to the buyer, including for any potential
liabilities for legal or regulatory proceedings arising out of
the conduct of Metro’s business while the firm owned it.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 102

-- 104 of 205 --

U.S. Treasury Securities Litigation
GS&Co. is among the primary dealers named as defendants
in several putative class actions relating to the market for
U.S. Treasury securities, filed beginning in July 2015 and
consolidated in the U.S. District Court for the Southern
District of New York. GS&Co. is also among the primary
dealers named as defendants in a similar individual action
filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of
New York on August 25, 2017. The consolidated class action
complaint, filed on December 29, 2017, generally alleges that
the defendants violated antitrust laws in connection with an
alleged conspiracy to manipulate the when-issued market and
auctions for U.S. Treasury securities and that certain
defendants, including GS&Co., colluded to preclude trading
of U.S. Treasury securities on electronic trading platforms in
order to impede competition in the bidding process. The
individual action alleges a similar conspiracy regarding
manipulation of the when-issued market and auctions, as
well as related futures and options in violation of the
Commodity Exchange Act. The complaints seek declaratory
and injunctive relief, treble damages in an unspecified
amount and restitution. Defendants’ motion to dismiss was
granted on March 31, 2021. On May 14, 2021, plaintiffs filed
an amended complaint. Defendants’ motion to dismiss the
amended complaint was granted on March 31, 2022. On
April 28, 2022, plaintiffs appealed to the U.S. Court of
Appeals for the Second Circuit.
Corporate Bonds Antitrust Litigation
Group Inc. and GS&Co. are among the dealers named as
defendants in a putative class action relating to the secondary
market for odd-lot corporate bonds, filed on April 21, 2020 in
the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New
York. The amended consolidated complaint, filed on
October 29, 2020, asserts claims under federal antitrust law
in connection with alleged anti-competitive conduct by the
defendants in the secondary market for odd-lots of corporate
bonds, and seeks declaratory and injunctive relief, as well as
unspecified monetary damages, including treble and punitive
damages and restitution. On October 25, 2021, the court
granted defendants’ motion to dismiss with prejudice. On
November 23, 2021, plaintiffs appealed to the U.S. Court of
Appeals for the Second Circuit. On November 10, 2022, the
district court denied the plaintiffs’ motion for an indicative
ruling that the judgment should be vacated because the wife
of the district judge owned stock in one of the defendants and
the district judge did not recuse himself.
Credit Default Swap Antitrust Litigation
Group Inc., GS&Co. and GSI were among the defendants
named in a putative antitrust class action relating to the
settlement of credit default swaps, filed on June 30, 2021 in
the U.S. District Court for the District of New Mexico. The
complaint generally asserts claims under federal antitrust law
and the Commodity Exchange Act in connection with an
alleged conspiracy among the defendants to manipulate the
benchmark price used to value credit default swaps for
settlement. The complaint also asserts a claim for unjust
enrichment under state common law. The complaint seeks
declaratory and injunctive relief, as well as unspecified
amounts of treble and other damages. On November 15,
2021, the defendants filed a motion to dismiss the complaint.
On February 4, 2022, the plaintiffs filed an amended
complaint and voluntarily dismissed Group Inc. from the
action. On June 5, 2023, the court dismissed the claims
against certain foreign defendants for lack of personal
jurisdiction but denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss
with respect to GS&Co., GSI and the remaining defendants.
Employment-Related Matters
On September 15, 2010, a putative class action was filed in
the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York
by three female former employees. The complaint, as
subsequently amended, alleges that Group Inc. and GS&Co.
have systematically discriminated against female employees
in respect of compensation, promotion and performance
evaluations. The complaint alleges a class consisting of all
female employees employed at specified levels in specified
areas by Group Inc. and GS&Co. since July 2002, and asserts
claims under federal and New York City discrimination laws.
On May 15, 2023, the court preliminarily approved a
settlement among the parties pursuant to which the firm
agreed to a payment of $215 million. The settlement also
provides that the firm will engage an independent expert to
complete standard validation studies of its performance
evaluation and promotion from vice president to managing
director processes, continue or implement certain practices as
part of its performance evaluation and promotion processes,
and engage an independent expert to perform an annual pay
equity analysis for the 2023, 2024 and 2025 year-end
compensation cycles.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
103 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 105 of 205 --

Consumer Investigation and Review
The firm is cooperating with the Consumer Financial
Protection Bureau and other governmental bodies relating to
investigations and/or inquiries concerning GS Bank USA’s
credit card account management practices and is providing
information regarding the application of refunds, crediting of
nonconforming payments, billing error resolution,
advertisements, reporting to credit bureaus, and any other
consumer-related information requested by them.
Regulatory Investigations and Reviews and Related
Litigation
Group Inc. and certain of its affiliates are subject to a number
of other investigations and reviews by, and in some cases
have received subpoenas and requests for documents and
information from, various governmental and regulatory
bodies and self-regulatory organizations and litigation and
shareholder requests relating to various matters relating to
the firm’s businesses and operations, including:
• The securities offering process and underwriting practices;
• The firm’s investment management and financial advisory
services;
• Conflicts of interest;
• Research practices, including research independence and
interactions between research analysts and other firm
personnel, including investment banking personnel, as well
as third parties;
• Transactions involving government-related financings and
other matters, municipal securities, including wall-cross
procedures and conflict of interest disclosure with respect
to state and municipal clients, the trading and structuring
of municipal derivative instruments in connection with
municipal offerings, political contribution rules, municipal
advisory services and the possible impact of credit default
swap transactions on municipal issuers;
• Consumer lending, as well as residential mortgage lending,
servicing and securitization, and compliance with related
consumer laws;
• The offering, auction, sales, trading and clearance of
corporate and government securities, currencies,
commodities and other financial products and related sales
and other communications and activities, as well as the
firm’s supervision and controls relating to such activities,
including compliance with applicable short sale rules,
algorithmic, high-frequency and quantitative trading, the
firm’s U.S. alternative trading system (dark pool), futures
trading, options trading, when-issued trading, transaction
and regulatory reporting, technology systems and controls,
communications recordkeeping and recording, securities
lending practices, prime brokerage activities, trading and
clearance of credit derivative instruments and interest rate
swaps, commodities activities and metals storage, private
placement practices, allocations of and trading in
securities, and trading activities and communications in
connection with the establishment of benchmark rates,
such as currency rates;
• Compliance with the FCPA;
• The firm’s hiring and compensation practices;
• The firm’s system of risk management and controls; and
• Insider trading, the potential misuse and dissemination of
material nonpublic information regarding corporate and
governmental developments and the effectiveness of the
firm’s insider trading controls and information barriers.
The firm is cooperating with all such governmental and
regulatory investigations and reviews.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements
(Unaudited)
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 104

-- 106 of 205 --

To the Board of Directors and Shareholders of The Goldman
Sachs Group, Inc.:
Results of Review of Interim Financial Statements
We have reviewed the accompanying consolidated balance
sheet of The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. and its subsidiaries
(the Company) as of September 30, 2023, the related
consolidated statements of earnings, comprehensive income
and changes in shareholders’ equity for the three and nine
month periods ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, and the
consolidated statements of cash flows for the nine month
periods ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, including the
related notes (collectively referred to as the “interim financial
statements”). Based on our reviews, we are not aware of any
material modifications that should be made to the
accompanying interim financial statements for them to be in
conformity with accounting principles generally accepted in
the United States of America.
We have previously audited, in accordance with the
standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight
Board (United States) (PCAOB), the consolidated balance
sheet of the Company as of December 31, 2022, and the
related consolidated statements of earnings, comprehensive
income, changes in shareholders’ equity and cash flows for
the year then ended (not presented herein), and in our report
dated February 23, 2023, which included a paragraph
describing a change in the manner of accounting for credit
losses on certain financial instruments in the 2020
consolidated financial statements, we expressed an
unqualified opinion on those consolidated financial
statements. In our opinion, the information set forth in the
accompanying consolidated balance sheet as of December 31,
2022, is fairly stated, in all material respects, in relation to the
consolidated balance sheet from which it has been derived.
Basis for Review Results
These interim financial statements are the responsibility of
the Company’s management. We are a public accounting
firm registered with the PCAOB and are required to be
independent with respect to the Company in accordance with
the U.S. federal securities laws and the applicable rules and
regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission and
the PCAOB. We conducted our review in accordance with
the standards of the PCAOB. A review of interim financial
information consists principally of applying analytical
procedures and making inquiries of persons responsible for
financial and accounting matters. It is substantially less in
scope than an audit conducted in accordance with the
standards of the PCAOB, the objective of which is the
expression of an opinion regarding the financial statements
taken as a whole. Accordingly, we do not express such an
opinion.
/s/ PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
New York, New York
November 3, 2023
Report of Independent Registered Public
Accounting Firm
105 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 107 of 205 --

Distribution of Assets, Liabilities and Shareholders’
Equity
The tables below present information about average
balances, interest and average interest rates.
Average Balance for the
Three Months Nine Months
Ended September Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Assets
U.S. $ 140,127 $ 168,084 $ 138,467 $ 149,241
Non-U.S. 130,387 120,200 127,841 112,938
Deposits with banks 270,514 288,284 266,308 262,179
U.S. 210,743 227,090 206,090 249,144
Non-U.S. 155,246 174,042 161,926 173,144
Collateralized agreements 365,989 401,132 368,016 422,288
U.S. 209,673 165,218 196,817 163,125
Non-U.S. 147,591 125,816 140,177 127,958
Trading assets 357,264 291,034 336,994 291,083
U.S. 126,566 106,377 120,499 90,758
Non-U.S. 15,049 13,569 15,138 15,069
Investments 141,615 119,946 135,637 105,827
U.S. 154,948 150,531 154,604 141,455
Non-U.S. 18,777 21,543 19,663 22,861
Loans 173,725 172,074 174,267 164,316
U.S. 85,503 91,188 88,061 98,721
Non-U.S. 54,623 68,052 56,507 64,623
Other interest-earning assets 140,126 159,240 144,568 163,344
Interest-earning assets 1,449,233 1,431,710 1,425,790 1,409,037
Cash and due from banks 5,508 7,619 6,330 8,053
Other non-interest-earning assets 102,421 140,926 110,822 140,390
Assets $ 1,557,162 $ 1,580,255 $ 1,542,942 $ 1,557,480
Liabilities
U.S. $ 307,812 $ 316,845 $ 304,903 $ 300,297
Non-U.S. 85,904 71,787 79,661 75,102
Interest-bearing deposits 393,716 388,632 384,564 375,399
U.S. 166,256 106,562 148,679 110,478
Non-U.S. 102,897 89,191 93,525 87,584
Collateralized financings 269,153 195,753 242,204 198,062
U.S. 58,727 90,801 63,401 84,748
Non-U.S. 77,769 83,924 74,885 86,175
Trading liabilities 136,496 174,725 138,286 170,923
U.S. 50,022 36,371 46,391 32,875
Non-U.S. 25,974 30,263 26,483 29,788
Short-term borrowings 75,996 66,634 72,874 62,663
U.S. 190,429 218,298 200,382 224,555
Non-U.S. 44,613 39,900 44,774 36,047
Long-term borrowings 235,042 258,198 245,156 260,602
U.S. 144,973 166,913 152,537 167,553
Non-U.S. 93,142 100,113 95,673 98,679
Other interest-bearing liabilities 238,115 267,026 248,210 266,232
Interest-bearing liabilities 1,348,518 1,350,968 1,331,294 1,333,881
Non-interest-bearing deposits 4,731 4,509 4,750 4,875
Other non-interest-bearing liabilities 87,615 106,765 90,261 103,306
Liabilities 1,440,864 1,462,242 1,426,305 1,442,062
Shareholders’ equity
Preferred stock 10,953 10,703 10,803 10,703
Common stock 105,345 107,310 105,834 104,715
Shareholders’ equity 116,298 118,013 116,637 115,418
Liabilities and shareholders’ equity $ 1,557,162 $ 1,580,255 $ 1,542,942 $ 1,557,480
Percentage attributable to non-U.S. operations
Interest-earning assets 36.00% 36.55% 36.56% 36.66%
Interest-bearing liabilities 31.91% 30.73% 31.17% 30.99%
Interest for the
Three Months Nine Months
Ended September Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Assets
U.S. $ 1,911 $ 958 $ 5,522 $ 1,330
Non-U.S. 1,154 149 2,809 62
Deposits with banks 3,065 1,107 8,331 1,392
U.S. 2,892 1,176 8,028 1,448
Non-U.S. 1,395 366 3,716 264
Collateralized agreements 4,287 1,542 11,744 1,712
U.S. 1,482 843 3,958 2,282
Non-U.S. 740 491 2,032 1,269
Trading assets 2,222 1,334 5,990 3,551
U.S. 788 458 2,129 1,027
Non-U.S. 213 120 600 406
Investments 1,001 578 2,729 1,433
U.S. 3,403 2,212 9,760 5,160
Non-U.S. 394 275 1,182 777
Loans 3,797 2,487 10,942 5,937
U.S. 2,299 972 6,136 1,777
Non-U.S. 1,586 530 4,159 811
Other interest-earning assets 3,885 1,502 10,295 2,588
Interest-earning assets $ 18,257 $ 8,550 $ 50,031 $ 16,613
Liabilities
U.S. $ 3,580 $ 1,568 $ 9,900 $ 2,522
Non-U.S. 853 243 2,059 453
Interest-bearing deposits 4,433 1,811 11,959 2,975
U.S. 2,526 718 6,291 998
Non-U.S. 1,109 272 2,840 310
Collateralized financings 3,635 990 9,131 1,308
U.S. 246 217 692 649
Non-U.S. 387 296 1,077 778
Trading liabilities 633 513 1,769 1,427
U.S. 305 110 778 241
Non-U.S. 12 42 70 92
Short-term borrowings 317 152 848 333
U.S. 2,842 1,471 8,090 3,333
Non-U.S. 71 32 195 100
Long-term borrowings 2,913 1,503 8,285 3,433
U.S. 3,124 887 8,226 728
Non-U.S. 1,655 651 4,801 805
Other interest-bearing liabilities 4,779 1,538 13,027 1,533
Interest-bearing liabilities $ 16,710 $ 6,507 $ 45,019 $ 11,009
Net interest income
U.S. $ 152 $ 1,648 $ 1,556 $ 4,553
Non-U.S. 1,395 395 3,456 1,051
Net interest income $ 1,547 $ 2,043 $ 5,012 $ 5,604
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Statistical Disclosures
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 106

-- 108 of 205 --

Annualized Average Rate for the
Three Months Nine Months
Ended September Ended September
2023 2022 2023 2022
Assets
U.S. 5.46% 2.26% 5.32% 1.19%
Non-U.S. 3.54% 0.49% 2.93% 0.07%
Deposits with banks 4.53% 1.52% 4.17% 0.71%
U.S. 5.49% 2.05% 5.19% 0.77%
Non-U.S. 3.59% 0.83% 3.06% 0.20%
Collateralized agreements 4.69% 1.52% 4.25% 0.54%
U.S. 2.83% 2.02% 2.68% 1.87%
Non-U.S. 2.01% 1.54% 1.93% 1.32%
Trading assets 2.49% 1.81% 2.37% 1.63%
U.S. 2.49% 1.70% 2.36% 1.51%
Non-U.S. 5.66% 3.50% 5.28% 3.59%
Investments 2.83% 1.91% 2.68% 1.81%
U.S. 8.78% 5.81% 8.42% 4.86%
Non-U.S. 8.39% 5.05% 8.02% 4.53%
Loans 8.74% 5.72% 8.37% 4.82%
U.S. 10.76% 4.22% 9.29% 2.40%
Non-U.S. 11.61% 3.08% 9.81% 1.67%
Other interest-earning assets 11.09% 3.73% 9.49% 2.11%
Interest-earning assets 5.04% 2.36% 4.68% 1.57%
Liabilities
U.S. 4.65% 1.96% 4.33% 1.12%
Non-U.S. 3.97% 1.34% 3.45% 0.80%
Interest-bearing deposits 4.50% 1.84% 4.15% 1.06%
U.S. 6.08% 2.67% 5.64% 1.20%
Non-U.S. 4.31% 1.21% 4.05% 0.47%
Collateralized financings 5.40% 2.00% 5.03% 0.88%
U.S. 1.68% 0.95% 1.46% 1.02%
Non-U.S. 1.99% 1.40% 1.92% 1.20%
Trading liabilities 1.85% 1.16% 1.71% 1.11%
U.S. 2.44% 1.20% 2.24% 0.98%
Non-U.S. 0.18% 0.55% 0.35% 0.41%
Short-term borrowings 1.67% 0.90% 1.55% 0.71%
U.S. 5.97% 2.67% 5.38% 1.98%
Non-U.S. 0.64% 0.32% 0.58% 0.37%
Long-term borrowings 4.96% 2.30% 4.51% 1.76%
U.S. 8.62% 2.10% 7.19% 0.58%
Non-U.S. 7.11% 2.57% 6.69% 1.09%
Other interest-bearing liabilities 8.03% 2.28% 7.00% 0.77%
Interest-bearing liabilities 4.96% 1.91% 4.51% 1.10%
Interest rate spread 0.08% 0.45% 0.17% 0.47%
U.S. 0.07% 0.72% 0.23% 0.68%
Non-U.S. 1.07% 0.30% 0.88% 0.27%
Net yield on interest-earning assets 0.43% 0.56% 0.47% 0.53%
In the tables above:
• Assets, liabilities and interest are classified as U.S. and non-
U.S. based on the location of the legal entity in which the
assets and liabilities are held.
• Derivative instruments and commodities are included in
other non-interest-earning assets and other non-interest-
bearing liabilities.
• Average collateralized agreements included $174.40 billion
of resale agreements and $191.59 billion of securities
borrowed for the three months ended September 2023,
$201.70 billion of resale agreements and $199.43 billion of
securities borrowed for the three months ended September
2022, $175.00 billion of resale agreements and $193.01
billion of securities borrowed for the nine months ended
September 2023, and $228.21 billion of resale agreements
and $194.08 billion of securities borrowed for the nine
months ended September 2022.
• Other interest-earning assets primarily consists of certain
receivables from customers and counterparties.
• Collateralized financings included $215.00 billion of
repurchase agreements and $54.15 billion of securities
loaned for the three months ended September 2023, $158.89
billion of repurchase agreements and $36.86 billion of
securities loaned for the three months ended September
2022, $195.28 billion of repurchase agreements and $46.92
billion of securities loaned for the nine months ended
September 2023, and $156.99 billion of repurchase
agreements and $41.07 billion of securities loaned for the
nine months ended September 2022.
• Substantially all other interest-bearing liabilities consists of
certain payables to customers and counterparties.
• Interest rates for borrowings include the effects of interest
rate swaps accounted for as hedges.
• Loans exclude loans held for sale that are accounted for at
the lower of cost or fair value. Such loans are included
within other interest-earning assets.
• Short- and long-term borrowings include both secured and
unsecured borrowings.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Statistical Disclosures
107 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 109 of 205 --

Item 2. Management’s Discussion and
Analysis of Financial Condition and
Results of Operations
Introduction
The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. (Group Inc. or parent
company), a Delaware corporation, together with its
consolidated subsidiaries, is a leading global financial
institution that delivers a broad range of financial services to
a large and diversified client base that includes corporations,
financial institutions, governments and individuals. Founded
in 1869, we are headquartered in New York and maintain
offices in all major financial centers around the world. We
manage and report our activities in three business segments:
Global Banking & Markets, Asset & Wealth Management
and Platform Solutions. See “Results of Operations” for
further information about our business segments.
When we use the terms “we,” “us” and “our,” we mean
Group Inc. and its consolidated subsidiaries. When we use
the term “our subsidiaries,” we mean the consolidated
subsidiaries of Group Inc.
Group Inc. is a bank holding company and a financial
holding company regulated by the Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System (FRB).
This Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial
Condition and Results of Operations should be read in
conjunction with our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the
year ended December 31, 2022. References to “the 2022 Form
10-K” are to our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year
ended December 31, 2022. References to “this Form 10-Q”
are to our Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarterly
period ended September 30, 2023. All references to “the
consolidated financial statements” or “Statistical
Disclosures” are to Part I, Item 1 of this Form 10-Q. The
consolidated financial statements are unaudited. All
references to September 2023, June 2023 and September 2022
refer to our periods ended, or the dates, as the context
requires, September 30, 2023, June 30, 2023 and
September 30, 2022, respectively. All references to December
2022 refer to the date December 31, 2022. Any reference to a
future year refers to a year ending on December 31 of that
year. Certain reclassifications have been made to previously
reported amounts to conform to the current presentation.
Executive Overview
Three Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. We generated net earnings of $2.06
billion for the third quarter of 2023, compared with $3.07
billion for the third quarter of 2022. Diluted earnings per
common share (EPS) was $5.47 for the third quarter of 2023,
compared with $8.25 for the third quarter of 2022.
Annualized return on average common shareholders’ equity
(ROE) was 7.1% for the third quarter of 2023, compared
with 11.0% for the third quarter of 2022. Book value per
common share was $313.83 as of September 2023, 1.5%
higher compared with June 2023 and 3.4% higher compared
with December 2022.
Net revenues were $11.82 billion for the third quarter of
2023, essentially unchanged compared with the third quarter
of 2022, reflecting significantly lower net revenues in Asset &
Wealth Management, offset by higher net revenues in Global
Banking & Markets and Platform Solutions. Net revenues in
Asset & Wealth Management primarily reflected net losses in
Equity investments compared with net gains in the prior year
period, partially offset by higher Management and other fees.
Net revenues in Global Banking & Markets reflected
improved results in Other and higher net revenues in
Equities, partially offset by lower net revenues in Fixed
Income, Currency and Commodities (FICC) compared with a
strong prior year period. Net revenues in Platform Solutions
reflected significantly higher net revenues in Consumer
platforms.
Provision for credit losses was $7 million for the third quarter
of 2023, compared with $515 million for the third quarter of
2022. Provisions for the third quarter of 2023 reflected net
provisions related to both the credit card portfolio (primarily
driven by net charge-offs) and wholesale loans (driven by
impairments, partially offset by a reserve reduction based on
increased stability in the macroeconomic environment), offset
by a net release related to the GreenSky, Inc. (GreenSky) loan
portfolio (including a reserve reduction related to the transfer
of the portfolio to held for sale). Provisions for the third
quarter of 2022 primarily reflected consumer portfolio
growth, net charge-offs and the impact of continued broad
concerns on the macroeconomic outlook.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 108

-- 110 of 205 --

Operating expenses were $9.05 billion for the third quarter of
2023, 18% higher than the third quarter of 2022, primarily
due to higher compensation and benefits expenses (reflecting
an increase in the quarter in the year-to-date ratio of
compensation and benefits to net revenues, net of provision
for credit losses, and a reduction in the year-to-date ratio in
the prior year period), a $506 million write-down of
identifiable intangible assets related to GreenSky and
impairments of $358 million related to commercial real estate
included within consolidated investment entities. Our
efficiency ratio (total operating expenses divided by total net
revenues) was 76.6% for the third quarter of 2023, compared
with 64.3% for the third quarter of 2022.
During the quarter, we returned a total of $2.44 billion of
capital to common shareholders, including common stock
repurchases of $1.50 billion and common stock dividends of
$937 million. As of September 2023, our Common Equity
Tier 1 (CET1) capital ratio was 14.8% under both the
Standardized and Advanced Capital Rules. See Note 20 to the
consolidated financial statements for further information
about our capital ratios.
Nine Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. We generated net earnings of $6.51 billion
for the first nine months of 2023, compared with $9.94 billion
for the first nine months of 2022. Diluted EPS was $17.39 for
the first nine months of 2023, compared with $26.71 for the
first nine months of 2022. Annualized ROE was 7.6% for the
first nine months of 2023, compared with 12.2% for the first
nine months of 2022.
Net revenues were $34.94 billion for the first nine months of
2023, 5% lower than the first nine months of 2022, reflecting
lower net revenues in Global Banking & Markets and slightly
lower net revenues in Asset & Wealth Management, partially
offset by higher net revenues in Platform Solutions. Net
revenues in Global Banking & Markets reflected lower net
revenues in FICC compared with a strong prior year period
and lower Investment banking fees. Net revenues in Asset &
Wealth Management reflected net losses in Equity
investments compared with net gains in the prior year period
and significantly lower Incentive fees, partially offset by
higher Management and other fees and higher net revenues in
Private banking and lending. Net revenues in Platform
Solutions reflected significantly higher net revenues in
Consumer platforms.
Provision for credit losses was $451 million for the first nine
months of 2023, compared with $1.74 billion for the first nine
months of 2022. Provisions for the first nine months of 2023
reflected net provisions related to both the credit card
portfolio (primarily driven by net charge-offs) and wholesale
loans (primarily driven by impairments), partially offset by a
reserve reduction related to the sale of substantially all of the
Marcus loans portfolio and a net release related to the
GreenSky loan portfolio (including a reserve reduction
related to the transfer of the portfolio to held for sale).
Provisions for the first nine months of 2022 primarily
reflected consumer portfolio growth (primarily in credit
cards) and the impact of broad macroeconomic and
geopolitical concerns.
Operating expenses were $26.00 billion for the first nine
months of 2023, 13% higher than the first nine months of
2022, primarily due to impairments of $1.20 billion related to
commercial real estate included within consolidated
investment entities, higher compensation and benefits
expenses, a $506 million write-down related to GreenSky and
an impairment of goodwill of $504 million related to
Consumer platforms. Our efficiency ratio was 74.4% for the
first nine months of 2023, compared with 62.7% for the first
nine months of 2022.
During the first nine months of 2023, we returned a total of
$7.47 billion of capital to common shareholders, including
common stock repurchases of $4.80 billion and common
stock dividends of $2.67 billion.
Business Environment
During the third quarter of 2023, the operating environment
was generally characterized by continued broad
macroeconomic concerns, including the outlook for
economic growth and global central bank policy. Early in the
quarter, there were positive developments in inflation and
labor market measures, however indicators later in the
quarter led to market expectations of higher interest rates for
a longer period. In addition, geopolitical stresses, including
the war in Ukraine and ongoing tensions with China,
remained elevated. These factors contributed to higher yields
on 10-year government bonds and lower global equity prices
compared with the end of the second quarter of 2023, while
the commercial real estate market remained under pressure.
In October 2023, geopolitical tensions escalated with the
conflict in the Middle East, which has elevated the
uncertainty of economic growth and stability in the U.S. and
around the world. There also remains uncertainty and
concerns about global central bank policy, inflation, the
commercial real estate sector and potential increases in
regulatory capital requirements. See “Results of Operations
— Segment Assets and Operating Results — Segment
Operating Results” for further information about the
operating environment for each of our business segments.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
109 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 111 of 205 --

Critical Accounting Policies
Fair Value
Fair Value Hierarchy. Trading assets and liabilities, certain
investments and loans, and certain other financial assets and
liabilities, are included in our consolidated balance sheets at
fair value (i.e., marked-to-market), with related gains or
losses generally recognized in our consolidated statements of
earnings. The use of fair value to measure financial
instruments is fundamental to our risk management practices
and is our most critical accounting policy.
The fair value of a financial instrument is the amount that
would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a
liability in an orderly transaction between market
participants at the measurement date. We measure certain
financial assets and liabilities as a portfolio (i.e., based on its
net exposure to market and/or credit risks). In determining
fair value, the hierarchy under U.S. generally accepted
accounting principles (U.S. GAAP) gives (i) the highest
priority to unadjusted quoted prices in active markets for
identical, unrestricted assets or liabilities (level 1 inputs), (ii)
the next priority to inputs other than level 1 inputs that are
observable, either directly or indirectly (level 2 inputs), and
(iii) the lowest priority to inputs that cannot be observed in
market activity (level 3 inputs). In evaluating the significance
of a valuation input, we consider, among other factors, a
portfolio’s net risk exposure to that input. Assets and
liabilities are classified in their entirety based on the lowest
level of input that is significant to their fair value
measurement.
The fair values for substantially all of our financial assets and
liabilities are based on observable prices and inputs and are
classified in levels 1 and 2 of the fair value hierarchy. Certain
level 2 and level 3 financial assets and liabilities may require
appropriate valuation adjustments that a market participant
would require to arrive at fair value for factors, such as
counterparty and our credit quality, funding risk, transfer
restrictions, liquidity and bid/offer spreads.
Instruments classified in level 3 of the fair value hierarchy are
those which require one or more significant inputs that are
not observable. Level 3 financial assets represented 1.6% as
of September 2023, 1.7% as of June 2023 and 1.8% as of
December 2022 of our total assets. See Notes 4 and 5 to the
consolidated financial statements for further information
about level 3 financial assets, including changes in level 3
financial assets and related fair value measurements. Absent
evidence to the contrary, instruments classified in level 3 of
the fair value hierarchy are initially valued at transaction
price, which is considered to be the best initial estimate of
fair value. Subsequent to the transaction date, we use other
methodologies to determine fair value, which vary based on
the type of instrument. Estimating the fair value of level 3
financial instruments requires judgments to be made. These
judgments include:
• Determining the appropriate valuation methodology and/
or model for each type of level 3 financial instrument;
• Determining model inputs based on an evaluation of all
relevant empirical market data, including prices evidenced
by market transactions, interest rates, credit spreads,
volatilities and correlations; and
• Determining appropriate valuation adjustments, including
those related to illiquidity or counterparty credit quality.
Regardless of the methodology, valuation inputs and
assumptions are only changed when corroborated by
substantive evidence.
Controls Over Valuation of Financial Instruments.
Market makers and investment professionals in our revenue-
producing units are responsible for pricing our financial
instruments. Our control infrastructure is independent of the
revenue-producing units and is fundamental to ensuring that
all of our financial instruments are appropriately valued at
market-clearing levels. In the event that there is a difference
of opinion in situations where estimating the fair value of
financial instruments requires judgment (e.g., calibration to
market comparables or trade comparison, as described
below), the final valuation decision is made by senior
managers in independent risk oversight and control
functions. This independent price verification is critical to
ensuring that our financial instruments are properly valued.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 110

-- 112 of 205 --

Price Verification. All financial instruments at fair value
classified in levels 1, 2 and 3 of the fair value hierarchy are
subject to our independent price verification process. The
objective of price verification is to have an informed and
independent opinion with regard to the valuation of financial
instruments under review. Instruments that have one or more
significant inputs which cannot be corroborated by external
market data are classified in level 3 of the fair value
hierarchy. Price verification strategies utilized by our
independent risk oversight and control functions include:
• Trade Comparison. Analysis of trade data (both internal
and external, where available) is used to determine the
most relevant pricing inputs and valuations.
• External Price Comparison. Valuations and prices are
compared to pricing data obtained from third parties (e.g.,
brokers or dealers, S&P Global Services, Bloomberg, ICE
Data Services, Pricing Direct, TRACE). Data obtained
from various sources is compared to ensure consistency
and validity. When broker or dealer quotations or third-
party pricing vendors are used for valuation or price
verification, greater priority is generally given to executable
quotations.
• Calibration to Market Comparables. Market-based
transactions are used to corroborate the valuation of
positions with similar characteristics, risks and
components.
• Relative Value Analyses. Market-based transactions are
analyzed to determine the similarity, measured in terms of
risk, liquidity and return, of one instrument relative to
another or, for a given instrument, of one maturity relative
to another.
• Collateral Analyses. Margin calls on derivatives are
analyzed to determine implied values, which are used to
corroborate our valuations.
• Execution of Trades. Where appropriate, market-making
desks are instructed to execute trades in order to provide
evidence of market-clearing levels.
• Backtesting. Valuations are corroborated by comparison
to values realized upon sales.
See Note 4 to the consolidated financial statements for
further information about fair value measurements.
Review of Net Revenues. Independent risk oversight and
control functions ensure adherence to our pricing policy
through a combination of daily procedures, including the
explanation and attribution of net revenues based on the
underlying factors. Through this process, we independently
validate net revenues, identify and resolve potential fair value
or trade booking issues on a timely basis and seek to ensure
that risks are being properly categorized and quantified.
Review of Valuation Models. Our independent model risk
management group (Model Risk), consisting of quantitative
professionals who are separate from model developers,
performs an independent model review and validation
process of our valuation models. New or changed models are
reviewed and approved prior to implementation. Models are
reviewed annually to assess the impact of any changes in the
product or market and any market developments in pricing
theories. See “Risk Management — Model Risk
Management” for further information about the review and
validation of our valuation models.
Allowance for Credit Losses
We estimate and record an allowance for credit losses related
to our loans held for investment that are accounted for at
amortized cost. To determine the allowance for credit losses,
we classify our loans accounted for at amortized cost into
wholesale and consumer portfolios. These portfolios
represent the level at which we have developed and
documented our methodology to determine the allowance for
credit losses. The allowance for credit losses is measured on a
collective basis for loans that exhibit similar risk
characteristics using a modeled approach and on an asset-
specific basis for loans that do not share similar risk
characteristics.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
111 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 113 of 205 --

The allowance for credit losses takes into account the
weighted average of a range of forecasts of future economic
conditions over the expected life of the loans and lending
commitments. The expected life of each loan or lending
commitment is determined based on the contractual term
adjusted for extension options or demand features, or is
modeled in the case of revolving credit card loans. The
forecasts include baseline, favorable and adverse economic
scenarios over a three-year period. For loans with expected
lives beyond three years, the model reverts to historical loss
information based on a non-linear modeled approach. We
apply judgment in weighting individual scenarios each
quarter based on a variety of factors, including our internally
derived economic outlook, market consensus, recent
macroeconomic conditions and industry trends. The
forecasted economic scenarios consider a number of risk
factors relevant to the wholesale and consumer portfolios.
Risk factors for wholesale loans include internal credit
ratings, industry default and loss data, expected life,
macroeconomic indicators (e.g., unemployment rates and
GDP), the borrower’s capacity to meet its financial
obligations, the borrower’s country of risk and industry, loan
seniority and collateral type. In addition, for loans backed by
real estate, risk factors include loan-to-value ratio, debt
service ratio and home price index. Risk factors for
installment and credit card loans include Fair Isaac
Corporation (FICO) credit scores, delinquency status, loan
vintage and macroeconomic indicators.
The allowance for credit losses also includes qualitative
components which allow management to reflect the uncertain
nature of economic forecasting, capture uncertainty
regarding model inputs, and account for model imprecision
and concentration risk.
Our estimate of credit losses entails judgment about
collectability at the reporting dates, and there are
uncertainties inherent in those judgments. The allowance for
credit losses is subject to a governance process that involves
review and approval by senior management within our
independent risk oversight and control functions. Personnel
within our independent risk oversight and control functions
are responsible for forecasting the economic variables that
underlie the economic scenarios that are used in the modeling
of expected credit losses. While we use the best information
available to determine this estimate, future adjustments to the
allowance may be necessary based on, among other things,
changes in the economic environment or variances between
actual results and the original assumptions used. Loans are
charged off against the allowance for loan losses when
deemed to be uncollectible.
We also record an allowance for credit losses on lending
commitments which are held for investment that are
accounted for at amortized cost. Such allowance is
determined using the same methodology as the allowance for
loan losses, while also taking into consideration the
probability of drawdowns or funding, and whether such
commitments are cancellable by us.
To estimate the potential impact of an adverse
macroeconomic environment on our allowance for credit
losses, we, among other things, compared the expected credit
losses under the weighted average forecast used in the
calculation of allowance for credit losses as of September
2023 (which was weighted towards the baseline and adverse
economic scenarios) to the expected credit losses under a
100% weighted adverse economic scenario. The adverse
economic scenario of the forecast model reflects a global
recession in the fourth quarter of 2023 through the third
quarter of 2024, resulting in an economic contraction and
rising unemployment rates. A 100% weighting to the adverse
economic scenario would have resulted in an approximate
$0.8 billion increase in our allowance for credit losses as of
September 2023. This hypothetical increase does not take into
consideration any potential adjustments to qualitative
reserves. The forecasts of macroeconomic conditions are
inherently uncertain and do not take into account any other
offsetting or correlated effects. The actual credit loss in an
adverse macroeconomic environment may differ significantly
from this estimate. See Note 9 to the consolidated financial
statements for further information about the allowance for
credit losses.
Use of Estimates
U.S. GAAP requires us to make certain estimates and
assumptions. In addition to the estimates we make in
connection with fair value measurements and the allowance
for credit losses on loans and lending commitments held for
investment and accounted for at amortized cost, the use of
estimates and assumptions is also important in determining
discretionary compensation accruals, the accounting for
goodwill and identifiable intangible assets, provisions for
losses that may arise from litigation and regulatory
proceedings (including governmental investigations), and
accounting for income taxes.
A substantial portion of our compensation and benefits
represents discretionary compensation, which is finalized at
year-end. We believe the most appropriate way to allocate
estimated year-end discretionary compensation among
interim periods is in proportion to the net revenues, net of
provision for credit losses, earned in such periods. In addition
to the level of net revenues, net of provision for credit losses,
our overall compensation expense in any given year is also
influenced by, among other factors, overall financial
performance, prevailing labor markets, business mix, the
structure of our share-based compensation programs and the
external environment.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 112

-- 114 of 205 --

Goodwill is assessed for impairment annually in the fourth
quarter or more frequently if events occur or circumstances
change that indicate an impairment may exist. When
assessing goodwill for impairment, first, a qualitative
assessment can be made to determine whether it is more
likely than not that the estimated fair value of a reporting
unit is less than its carrying value. If the results of the
qualitative assessment are not conclusive, a quantitative
goodwill test is performed. Alternatively, a quantitative
goodwill test can be performed without performing a
qualitative assessment. Estimating the fair value of our
reporting units requires judgment. Critical inputs to the fair
value estimates include projected earnings and allocated
equity. There is inherent uncertainty in the projected
earnings. The carrying value of each reporting unit reflects an
allocation of total shareholders’ equity and represents the
estimated amount of total shareholders’ equity required to
support the activities of the reporting unit under currently
applicable regulatory capital requirements. During the
second quarter of 2023, in connection with the exploration of
a potential sale of GreenSky, we performed a quantitative
goodwill test and determined that the goodwill associated
with Consumer platforms was impaired, and accordingly,
recorded a $504 million impairment. See Note 12 to the
consolidated financial statements for further information
about goodwill. If we experience a prolonged or severe
period of weakness in the business environment, financial
markets, the performance of one or more of our reporting
units or our common stock price, or additional increases in
capital requirements, our goodwill could be impaired in the
future.
Identifiable intangible assets are tested for impairment when
events or changes in circumstances suggest that an asset’s or
asset group’s carrying value may not be fully recoverable.
Judgment is required to evaluate whether indications of
potential impairment have occurred, and to test identifiable
intangible assets for impairment, if required. An impairment
is recognized if the estimated undiscounted cash flows
relating to the asset or asset group is less than the
corresponding carrying value. In the third quarter of 2023, in
connection with the planned sale of GreenSky, we classified
the related identifiable intangible assets, loans and other
assets and associated liabilities as held for sale and recognized
a $506 million write-down. See Note 12 to the consolidated
financial statements for further information about
identifiable intangible assets.
We also estimate and provide for potential losses that may
arise out of litigation and regulatory proceedings to the
extent that such losses are probable and can be reasonably
estimated. In addition, we estimate the upper end of the
range of reasonably possible aggregate loss in excess of the
related reserves for litigation and regulatory proceedings
where we believe the risk of loss is more than slight. See
Notes 18 and 27 to the consolidated financial statements for
information about certain judicial, litigation and regulatory
proceedings. Significant judgment is required in making these
estimates and our final liabilities may ultimately be
materially different. Our total estimated liability in respect of
litigation and regulatory proceedings is determined on a case-
by-case basis and represents an estimate of probable losses
after considering, among other factors, the progress of each
case, proceeding or investigation, our experience and the
experience of others in similar cases, proceedings or
investigations, and the opinions and views of legal counsel.
In accounting for income taxes, we recognize tax positions in
the financial statements only when it is more likely than not
that the position will be sustained on examination by the
relevant taxing authority based on the technical merits of the
position. We use estimates to recognize current and deferred
income taxes in the U.S. federal, state and local and non-U.S.
jurisdictions in which we operate. The income tax laws in
these jurisdictions are complex and can be subject to different
interpretations between taxpayers and taxing authorities.
Disputes may arise over these interpretations and can be
settled by audit, administrative appeals or judicial
proceedings. Our interpretations are reevaluated quarterly
based on guidance currently available, tax examination
experience and the opinions of legal counsel, among other
factors. We recognize deferred taxes based on the amount
that will more likely than not be realized in the future based
on enacted income tax laws. Our estimate for deferred taxes
includes estimates for future taxable earnings, including the
level and character of those earnings, and various tax
planning strategies. See Note 24 to the consolidated financial
statements in Part II, Item 8 of the 2022 Form 10-K for
further information about income taxes.
Recent Accounting Developments
See Note 3 to the consolidated financial statements for
information about Recent Accounting Developments.
Results of Operations
The composition of our net revenues has varied over time as
financial markets and the scope of our operations have
changed. The composition of net revenues can also vary over
the shorter term due to fluctuations in U.S. and global
economic and market conditions. See “Risk Factors” in Part
I, Item 1A of the 2022 Form 10-K for further information
about the impact of economic and market conditions on our
results of operations.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
113 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 115 of 205 --

Financial Overview
The table below presents an overview of our financial results
and selected financial ratios.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions, except per share amounts 2023 2022 2023 2022
Net revenues $ 11,817 $ 11,975 $ 34,936 $ 36,772
Pre-tax earnings $ 2,756 $ 3,756 $ 8,485 $ 11,956
Net earnings $ 2,058 $ 3,069 $ 6,508 $ 9,935
Net earnings to common $ 1,882 $ 2,962 $ 6,040 $ 9,579
Diluted EPS $ 5.47 $ 8.25 $ 17.39 $ 26.71
ROE 7.1% 11.0% 7.6% 12.2%
ROTE 7.7% 12.0% 8.2% 13.1%
Net earnings to average assets 0.5% 0.8% 0.6% 0.9%
Return on shareholders’ equity 7.1% 10.4% 7.4% 11.5%
Average equity to average assets 7.5% 7.5% 7.6% 7.4%
Dividend payout ratio 50.3% 30.3% 44.6% 24.3%
Our target (through-the-cycle) is to achieve ROE within a
range of 14% to 16% and annualized return on average
tangible common shareholders’ equity (ROTE) within a
range of 15% to 17%.
In the table above:
• Net earnings to common represents net earnings applicable
to common shareholders, which is calculated as net
earnings less preferred stock dividends.
• ROE, ROTE, net earnings to average total assets and
return on average shareholders’ equity are annualized
amounts.
• ROE is calculated by dividing annualized net earnings to
common by average monthly common shareholders’
equity.
• ROTE is calculated by dividing annualized net earnings to
common by average monthly tangible common
shareholders’ equity. Tangible common shareholders’
equity is calculated as total shareholders’ equity less
preferred stock, goodwill and identifiable intangible assets.
We believe that tangible common shareholders’ equity is
meaningful because it is a measure that we and investors
use to assess capital adequacy and that ROTE is
meaningful because it measures the performance of
businesses consistently, whether they were acquired or
developed internally. Tangible common shareholders’
equity and ROTE are non-GAAP measures and may not be
comparable to similar non-GAAP measures used by other
companies.
The table below presents our average equity and the
reconciliation of average common shareholders’ equity to
average tangible common shareholders’ equity.
Average for the
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Total shareholders’ equity $ 116,298 $ 118,013 $ 116,637 $ 115,418
Preferred stock (10,953) (10,703) (10,803) (10,703)
Common shareholders’ equity 105,345 107,310 105,834 104,715
Goodwill (5,934) (6,242) (6,218) (5,546)
Identifiable intangible assets (1,764) (1,987) (1,888) (1,463)
Tangible common shareholders’ equity $ 97,647 $ 99,081 $ 97,728 $ 97,706
• Net earnings to average assets is calculated by dividing
annualized net earnings by average total assets.
• Return on shareholders’ equity is calculated by dividing
annualized net earnings by average monthly shareholders’
equity.
• Average equity to average assets is calculated by dividing
average total shareholders’ equity by average total assets.
• Dividend payout ratio is calculated by dividing dividends
declared per common share by diluted EPS.
Net Revenues
The table below presents our net revenues by line item.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Investment banking $ 1,555 $ 1,544 $ 4,565 $ 5,487
Investment management 2,409 2,283 7,054 6,747
Commissions and fees 883 992 2,864 3,066
Market making 4,958 4,641 14,742 15,583
Other principal transactions 465 472 699 285
Total non-interest revenues 10,270 9,932 29,924 31,168
Interest income 18,257 8,550 50,031 16,613
Interest expense 16,710 6,507 45,019 11,009
Net interest income 1,547 2,043 5,012 5,604
Total net revenues $ 11,817 $ 11,975 $ 34,936 $ 36,772
In the table above:
• Investment banking consists of revenues (excluding net
interest) from financial advisory and underwriting
assignments. These activities are included in Global
Banking & Markets.
• Investment management consists of revenues (excluding net
interest) from providing asset management and wealth
advisory services across all major asset classes to a diverse
set of clients. These activities are included in Asset &
Wealth Management.
• Commissions and fees consists of revenues from executing
and clearing client transactions on major stock, options
and futures exchanges worldwide, as well as over-the-
counter (OTC) transactions. Substantially all of these
activities are included in Global Banking & Markets.
• Market making consists of revenues (excluding net interest)
from client execution activities related to making markets
in interest rate products, credit products, mortgages,
currencies, commodities and equity products. These
activities are included in Global Banking & Markets.
• Other principal transactions consists of revenues
(excluding net interest) from our equity investing activities,
including revenues related to our consolidated investments
(included in Asset & Wealth Management), and debt
investing and lending activities (included across our three
segments).
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 114

-- 116 of 205 --

Operating Environment. During the third quarter of 2023,
the operating environment was generally characterized by
continued broad macroeconomic concerns, including the
outlook for economic growth and global central bank policy,
and elevated geopolitical stresses. These factors contributed
to a decline in market-making activity levels and weighed on
industry-wide investment banking activity levels.
Additionally, global equity and bond prices were generally
lower compared with the end of the second quarter of 2023,
while the commercial real estate market remained under
pressure. In the U.S., inflationary measures improved, the
rate of unemployment remained low and the pace of growth
in consumer spending increased compared with the second
quarter of 2023.
If uncertainty and concerns about geopolitical tensions and
the economic outlook remain elevated or grow, including
those about global central bank policy, inflation, the
commercial real estate sector, and potential increases in
regulatory capital requirements, it may lead to a further
decline in asset prices, a further decline in market-making
activity levels, or a decline in investment banking activity
levels, and net revenues and provision for credit losses would
likely be negatively impacted. See “Segment Assets and
Operating Results — Segment Operating Results” for
information about the operating environment and material
trends and uncertainties that may impact our results of
operations.
Three Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Net revenues in the consolidated
statements of earnings were $11.82 billion for the third
quarter of 2023, essentially unchanged compared with the
third quarter of 2022, reflecting significantly lower net
interest income and lower commissions and fees, offset by
higher market making revenues and investment management
revenues.
Non-Interest Revenues. Investment banking revenues in
the consolidated statements of earnings were $1.56 billion for
the third quarter of 2023, essentially unchanged compared
with the third quarter of 2022, due to higher revenues in debt
underwriting, primarily driven by leveraged finance activity,
and higher revenues in equity underwriting, primarily from
initial public offerings, offset by lower revenues in advisory,
reflecting a decline in completed mergers and acquisitions
transactions.
Investment management revenues in the consolidated
statements of earnings were $2.41 billion for the third quarter
of 2023, 6% higher than the third quarter of 2022, due to
higher management and other fees, primarily reflecting the
impact of higher average assets under supervision (AUS).
Commissions and fees in the consolidated statements of
earnings were $883 million for the third quarter of 2023, 11%
lower than the third quarter of 2022, primarily reflecting the
impact of GreenSky in the prior year period.
Market making revenues in the consolidated statements of
earnings were $4.96 billion for the third quarter of 2023, 7%
higher than the third quarter of 2022, reflecting significantly
higher revenues in financing, partially offset by lower
revenues in intermediation. The increase from financing
activities reflected significantly higher revenues in equity
financing products. The decrease from intermediation
activities reflected significantly lower revenues in
commodities, equity derivatives and currencies, partially
offset by significantly improved results in mortgages and
higher revenues in interest rate products.
Other principal transactions revenues in the consolidated
statements of earnings were $465 million for the third quarter
of 2023, essentially unchanged compared with the third
quarter of 2022, reflecting significantly lower net revenues
from equity investments, largely offset by net gains from
derivatives related to our borrowings and significantly
improved results in relationship lending and acquisition
financing activities.
Net Interest Income. Net interest income in the
consolidated statements of earnings was $1.55 billion for the
third quarter of 2023, 24% lower than the third quarter of
2022, reflecting a significant increase in interest expense
primarily related to other interest-bearing liabilities,
collateralized financings, deposits, and borrowings, each
reflecting the impact of higher average interest rates. The
increase in interest expense was largely offset by a significant
increase in interest income primarily related to collateralized
agreements, other interest-earning assets, deposits with banks
and loans, each reflecting the impact of higher average
interest rates. See “Statistical Disclosures — Distribution of
Assets, Liabilities and Shareholders’ Equity” for further
information about our sources of net interest income.
Nine Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Net revenues in the consolidated
statements of earnings were $34.94 billion for the first nine
months of 2023, 5% lower than the first nine months of 2022,
primarily reflecting lower investment banking revenues,
market making revenues and net interest income, partially
offset by significantly higher other principal transactions
revenues and higher investment management revenues.
Non-Interest Revenues. Investment banking revenues in
the consolidated statements of earnings were $4.57 billion for
the first nine months of 2023, 17% lower than the first nine
months of 2022, due to significantly lower revenues in
advisory, reflecting a significant decline in industry-wide
completed mergers and acquisitions transactions, and lower
revenues in debt underwriting, primarily reflecting lower net
revenues from asset-backed activity, partially offset by
significantly higher revenues in equity underwriting,
primarily reflecting increased activity in secondary offerings.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
115 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 117 of 205 --

Investment management revenues in the consolidated
statements of earnings were $7.05 billion for the first nine
months of 2023, 5% higher than the first nine months of
2022, due to higher management and other fees, primarily
reflecting the impact of higher average assets under
supervision, including the impact of acquiring NN
Investment Partners (NNIP), partially offset by significantly
lower incentive fees, driven by significant harvesting in the
prior year period.
Commissions and fees in the consolidated statements of
earnings were $2.86 billion for the first nine months of 2023,
7% lower than the first nine months of 2022, primarily
reflecting the impact of GreenSky in the prior year period.
Market making revenues in the consolidated statements of
earnings were $14.74 billion for the first nine months of 2023,
5% lower than the first nine months of 2022, reflecting
significantly lower revenues in intermediation, partially offset
by significantly higher revenues in financing. The decrease
from intermediation activities reflected significantly lower
revenues in equity derivatives, currencies and commodities,
partially offset by improved results in mortgages. The
increase from financing activities primarily reflected
significantly higher revenues from equity financing products.
Other principal transactions revenues in the consolidated
statements of earnings were $699 million for the first nine
months of 2023, 145% higher than the first nine months of
2022, primarily reflecting net gains from derivatives related to
our borrowings, partially offset by significantly lower net
revenues from equity investments and net revenues of
approximately $(370) million related to the sale of
substantially all of the Marcus loans portfolio.
Net Interest Income. Net interest income in the
consolidated statements of earnings was $5.01 billion for the
first nine months of 2023, 11% lower than the first nine
months of 2022, reflecting a significant increase in interest
expense related to other interest-bearing liabilities, deposits,
collateralized financings and borrowings, each reflecting the
impact of higher average interest rates. The increase in
interest expense was partially offset by a significant increase
in interest income primarily related to collateralized
agreements, other interest-earning assets, and deposits with
banks and loans, each reflecting the impact of higher average
interest rates. See “Statistical Disclosures — Distribution of
Assets, Liabilities and Shareholders’ Equity” for further
information about our sources of net interest income.
Provision for Credit Losses
Provision for credit losses consists of provision for credit
losses on financial assets and commitments accounted for at
amortized cost, including loans and lending commitments
held for investment. See Note 9 to the consolidated financial
statements for further information about the provision for
credit losses on loans and lending commitments.
The table below presents our provision for credit losses.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Provision for credit losses $ 7 $ 515 $ 451 $ 1,743
Three Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Provision for credit losses in the
consolidated statements of earnings was $7 million for the
third quarter of 2023, compared with $515 million for the
third quarter of 2022. Provisions for the third quarter of 2023
reflected net provisions related to both the credit card
portfolio (primarily driven by net charge-offs) and wholesale
loans (driven by impairments, partially offset by a reserve
reduction based on increased stability in the macroeconomic
environment), offset by a net release related to the GreenSky
loan portfolio (including a reserve reduction of $637 million
related to the transfer of the portfolio to held for sale).
Provisions for the third quarter of 2022 primarily reflected
consumer portfolio growth, net charge-offs and the impact of
continued broad concerns on the macroeconomic outlook.
Nine Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Provision for credit losses in the
consolidated statements of earnings was $451 million for the
first nine months of 2023, compared with $1.74 billion for the
first nine months of 2022. Provisions for the first nine months
of 2023 reflected net provisions related to both the credit card
portfolio (primarily driven by net charge-offs) and wholesale
loans (primarily driven by impairments), partially offset by a
reserve reduction of approximately $440 million related to
the sale of substantially all of the Marcus loans portfolio and
a net release related to the GreenSky loan portfolio (including
a reserve reduction of $637 million related to the transfer of
the portfolio to held for sale). Provisions for the first nine
months of 2022 primarily reflected consumer portfolio
growth (primarily in credit cards) and the impact of
macroeconomic and geopolitical concerns.
Operating Expenses
Our operating expenses are primarily influenced by
compensation, headcount and levels of business activity.
Compensation and benefits includes salaries, estimated year-
end discretionary compensation, amortization of equity
awards and other items such as benefits. Discretionary
compensation is significantly impacted by, among other
factors, the level of net revenues, net of provision for credit
losses, overall financial performance, prevailing labor
markets, business mix, the structure of our share-based
compensation programs and the external environment.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 116

-- 118 of 205 --

The table below presents our operating expenses by line item
and headcount.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Compensation and benefits $ 4,188 $ 3,606 $ 11,897 $ 11,384
Transaction based 1,452 1,317 4,242 3,878
Market development 136 199 454 596
Communications and technology 468 459 1,416 1,327
Depreciation and amortization 1,512 666 4,076 1,728
Occupancy 267 255 785 765
Professional fees 377 465 1,152 1,392
Other expenses 654 737 1,978 2,003
Total operating expenses $ 9,054 $ 7,704 $ 26,000 $ 23,073
Headcount at period-end 45,900 49,100
Three Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Operating expenses in the consolidated
statements of earnings were $9.05 billion for the third quarter
of 2023, 18% higher than the third quarter of 2022. Our
efficiency ratio was 76.6% for the third quarter of 2023,
compared with 64.3% for the third quarter of 2022.
The increase in operating expenses compared with the third
quarter of 2022 primarily reflected higher compensation and
benefits expenses (reflecting an increase in the quarter in the
year-to-date ratio of compensation and benefits to net
revenues, net of provision for credit losses, and a reduction in
the year-to-date ratio in the prior year period), a $506 million
write-down of identifiable intangible assets related to
GreenSky and impairments of $358 million related to
commercial real estate included within consolidated
investment entities (both in depreciation and amortization).
In addition, transaction based expenses were higher. Net
provisions for litigation and regulatory proceedings were $15
million for the third quarter of 2023 compared with $191
million for the third quarter of 2022.
As of September 2023, headcount increased 3% compared
with June 2023, primarily reflecting the timing of campus
hires.
Nine Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Operating expenses in the consolidated
statements of earnings were $26.00 billion for the first nine
months of 2023, 13% higher than the first nine months of
2022. Our efficiency ratio was 74.4% for the first nine
months of 2023, compared with our through-the-cycle target
efficiency ratio of approximately 60%. Our efficiency ratio
was 62.7% for the first nine months of 2022. The ratio of
compensation and benefits to net revenues, net of provision
for credit losses, was 34.5% for the first nine months of 2023,
compared with 34.0% for the first half of 2023 and 32.5% for
the first nine months of 2022.
The increase in operating expenses compared with the first
nine months of 2022 primarily reflected impairments of $1.20
billion related to commercial real estate included within
consolidated investment entities, higher compensation and
benefits expenses, a $506 million write-down related to
GreenSky and an impairment of goodwill of $504 million
related to Consumer platforms (the above impairments and
write-downs were reported in depreciation and
amortization). In addition, transaction based expenses and
technology expenses were higher. Net provisions for
litigation and regulatory proceedings were $106 million for
the first nine months of 2023 compared with $407 million for
the first nine months of 2022.
As of September 2023, headcount decreased 5% compared
with December 2022, primarily reflecting a headcount
reduction initiative during the year. Severance-related costs
included in compensation and benefits expenses were
approximately $275 million for the first nine months of 2023.
Provision for Taxes
The effective income tax rate for the first nine months of
2023 was 23.3%, up from the full year income tax rate of
16.5% for 2022, primarily due to an increase in tax on non-
U.S. earnings. The increase compared with 22.3% for the
first half of 2023, was primarily due to write-offs of deferred
tax assets related to the transfer of GreenSky to held for sale
and changes in the geographic mix of earnings.
In May 2023, the New York State fiscal year 2024 budget was
enacted. The legislation extends the temporary increase in the
New York State corporate income tax rate from 6.5% to
7.25% through calendar year 2026. The legislation is not
expected to have a material impact on our 2023 annual
effective tax rate.
In July 2023, the U.K. Finance (No. 2) Act 2023 was enacted.
The legislation enacts a domestic and multinational top-up
tax to implement the Domestic Minimum Top-up Tax and
Income Inclusion Rule, two of the Organisation for
Economic Co-operation and Development Global Anti-Base
Erosion Model Rules (Pillar Two), which will apply to us
beginning in calendar year 2024. Pillar Two aims to ensure
that multinationals pay a minimum effective corporate tax
rate of 15% in each jurisdiction in which they operate. The
legislation will not impact our 2023 annual effective tax rate
and we are currently evaluating the impact on our 2024
annual effective tax rate.
We expect our 2023 tax rate to be under 23%.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
117 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 119 of 205 --

Segment Assets and Operating Results
Segment Assets. The table below presents assets by
segment.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Global Banking & Markets $ 1,318,009 $ 1,169,539
Asset & Wealth Management 191,307 214,970
Platform Solutions 67,837 57,290
Total $ 1,577,153 $ 1,441,799
The allocation process for segment assets is based on the
activities of these segments. The allocation of assets includes
allocation of global core liquid assets (GCLA) (which consists
of unencumbered, highly liquid securities and cash), which is
generally included within cash and cash equivalents,
collateralized agreements and trading assets on our balance
sheet. Due to the integrated nature of these segments,
estimates and judgments are made in allocating these assets.
See “Risk Management — Liquidity Risk Management” for
further information about our GCLA.
Segment Operating Results. The table below presents our
segment operating results.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Global Banking & Markets
Net revenues $ 8,009 $ 7,564 $ 23,642 $ 25,968
Provision for credit losses 29 63 214 462
Operating expenses 4,791 4,224 13,702 13,628
Pre-tax earnings $ 3,189 $ 3,277 $ 9,726 $ 11,878
Net earnings to common $ 2,250 $ 2,586 $ 7,108 $ 9,602
Average common equity $ 72,517 $ 71,850 $ 70,968 $ 70,006
Return on average common equity 12.4% 14.4% 13.4% 18.3%
Asset & Wealth Management
Net revenues $ 3,230 $ 4,033 $ 9,493 $ 9,815
Provision for credit losses 51 (13) (499) 339
Operating expenses 3,005 2,955 9,448 8,187
Pre-tax earnings $ 174 $ 1,091 $ 544 $ 1,289
Net earnings to common $ 93 $ 882 $ 318 $ 990
Average common equity $ 28,601 $ 31,516 $ 30,806 $ 31,238
Return on average common equity 1.3% 11.2% 1.4% 4.2%
Platform Solutions
Net revenues $ 578 $ 378 $ 1,801 $ 989
Provision for credit losses (73) 465 736 942
Operating expenses 1,258 525 2,850 1,258
Pre-tax earnings/(loss) $ (607) $ (612) $ (1,785) $ (1,211)
Net earnings/(loss) to common $ (461) $ (506) $ (1,386) $ (1,013)
Average common equity $ 4,227 $ 3,944 $ 4,060 $ 3,471
Return on average common equity (43.6)% (51.3) % (45.5)% (38.9) %
Total
Net revenues $ 11,817 $ 11,975 $ 34,936 $ 36,772
Provision for credit losses 7 515 451 1,743
Operating expenses 9,054 7,704 26,000 23,073
Pre-tax earnings $ 2,756 $ 3,756 $ 8,485 $ 11,956
Net earnings to common $ 1,882 $ 2,962 $ 6,040 $ 9,579
Average common equity $ 105,345 $ 107,310 $ 105,834 $ 104,715
Return on average common equity 7.1% 11.0% 7.6% 12.2%
Net revenues in our segments include allocations of interest
income and expense to specific positions in relation to the
cash generated by, or funding requirements of, such
positions. See Note 25 to the consolidated financial
statements for further information about our business
segments.
The allocation of common shareholders’ equity and preferred
stock dividends to each segment is based on the estimated
amount of equity required to support the activities of the
segment under relevant regulatory capital requirements. Net
earnings for each segment is calculated by applying the
firmwide tax rate to each segment’s pre-tax earnings.
Compensation and benefits expenses within our segments
reflect, among other factors, our overall performance, as well
as the performance of individual businesses. Consequently,
pre-tax margins in one segment of our business may be
significantly affected by the performance of our other
business segments. A description of segment operating results
follows.
Global Banking & Markets
Global Banking & Markets generates revenues from the
following:
Investment banking fees. We provide advisory and
underwriting services and help companies raise capital to
strengthen and grow their businesses. Investment banking
fees includes the following:
• Advisory. Includes strategic advisory assignments with
respect to mergers and acquisitions, divestitures, corporate
defense activities, restructurings and spin-offs.
• Underwriting. Includes public offerings and private
placements for both local and cross-border transactions of
a wide range of securities and other financial instruments,
including acquisition financing.
FICC. FICC generates revenues from intermediation and
financing activities.
• FICC intermediation. Includes client execution activities
related to making markets in both cash and derivative
instruments, as detailed below.
Interest Rate Products. Government bonds (including
inflation-linked securities) across maturities, other
government-backed securities, and interest rate swaps,
options and other derivatives.
Credit Products. Investment-grade and high-yield
corporate securities, credit derivatives, exchange-traded
funds (ETFs), bank and bridge loans, municipal securities,
distressed debt and trade claims.
Mortgages. Commercial mortgage-related securities,
loans and derivatives, residential mortgage-related
securities, loans and derivatives (including U.S. government
agency-issued collateralized mortgage obligations and
other securities and loans), and other asset-backed
securities, loans and derivatives.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 118

-- 120 of 205 --

Currencies. Currency options, spot/forwards and other
derivatives on G-10 currencies and emerging-market
products.
Commodities. Commodity derivatives and, to a lesser
extent, physical commodities, involving crude oil and
petroleum products, natural gas, agricultural, base,
precious and other metals, electricity, including renewable
power, environmental products and other commodity
products.
• FICC financing. Includes (i) secured lending to our clients
through structured credit and asset-backed lending,
including warehouse loans backed by mortgages (including
residential and commercial mortgage loans), corporate
loans and consumer loans (including auto loans and private
student loans), (ii) commodity financing to clients through
structured transactions and (iii) financing through
securities purchased under agreements to resell (resale
agreements).
Equities. Equities generates revenues from intermediation
and financing activities.
• Equities intermediation. We make markets in equity
securities and equity-related products, including ETFs,
convertible securities, options, futures and OTC derivative
instruments. We also structure and make markets in
derivatives on indices, industry sectors, financial measures
and individual company stocks. Our exchange-based
market-making activities include making markets in stocks
and ETFs, futures and options on major exchanges
worldwide. In addition, we generate commissions and fees
from executing and clearing institutional client transactions
on major stock, options and futures exchanges worldwide,
as well as OTC transactions.
• Equities financing. Includes prime financing, which
provides financing to our clients for their securities trading
activities through margin loans that are collateralized by
securities, cash or other acceptable collateral. Prime
financing also includes services which involve lending
securities to cover institutional clients’ short sales and
borrowing securities to cover our short sales and to make
deliveries into the market. We are also an active participant
in broker-to-broker securities lending and third-party
agency lending activities. In addition, we execute swap
transactions to provide our clients with exposure to
securities and indices. Financing activities also include
portfolio financing, which clients can utilize to manage
their investment portfolios, and other equity financing
activities, including securities-based loans to individuals.
Market-Making Activities
As a market maker, we facilitate transactions in both liquid
and less liquid markets, primarily for institutional clients,
such as corporations, financial institutions, investment funds
and governments, to assist clients in meeting their investment
objectives and in managing their risks. In this role, we seek to
earn the difference between the price at which a market
participant is willing to sell an instrument to us and the price
at which another market participant is willing to buy it from
us, and vice versa (i.e., bid/offer spread). In addition, we
maintain (i) market-making positions, typically for a short
period of time, in response to, or in anticipation of, client
demand, and (ii) positions to actively manage our risk
exposures that arise from these market-making activities
(collectively, inventory). Our inventory is recorded in trading
assets (long positions) or trading liabilities (short positions)
in our consolidated balance sheets.
Our results are influenced by a combination of
interconnected drivers, including (i) client activity levels and
transactional bid/offer spreads (collectively, client activity),
and (ii) changes in the fair value of our inventory and interest
income and interest expense related to the holding, hedging
and funding of our inventory (collectively, market-making
inventory changes). Due to the integrated nature of our
market-making activities, disaggregation of net revenues into
client activity and market-making inventory changes is
judgmental and has inherent complexities and limitations.
The amount and composition of our net revenues vary over
time as these drivers are impacted by multiple interrelated
factors affecting economic and market conditions, including
volatility and liquidity in the market, changes in interest
rates, currency exchange rates, credit spreads, equity prices
and commodity prices, investor confidence, and other
macroeconomic concerns and uncertainties.
In general, assuming all other market-making conditions
remain constant, increases in client activity levels or bid/offer
spreads tend to result in increases in net revenues, and
decreases tend to have the opposite effect. However, changes
in market-making conditions can materially impact client
activity levels and bid/offer spreads, as well as the fair value
of our inventory. For example, a decrease in liquidity in the
market could have the impact of (i) increasing our bid/offer
spread, (ii) decreasing investor confidence and thereby
decreasing client activity levels, and (iii) widening of credit
spreads on our inventory positions.
Other. We lend to corporate clients, including through
relationship lending and acquisition financing. The hedges
related to this lending and financing activity are also reported
as part of Other. Other also includes equity and debt
investing activities related to our Global Banking & Markets
activities.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
119 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 121 of 205 --

The table below presents our Global Banking & Markets
assets.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Cash and cash equivalents $ 167,366 $ 167,203
Collateralized agreements 370,848 380,157
Customer and other receivables 126,963 122,037
Trading assets 406,267 272,788
Investments 120,043 103,229
Loans 109,328 107,648
Other assets 17,194 16,477
Total $ 1,318,009 $ 1,169,539
The table below presents details about our Global Banking &
Markets loans.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Corporate $ 24,378 $ 25,776
Real estate 33,073 33,215
Securities-based 3,744 3,857
Other collateralized 48,965 45,407
Other 517 561
Loans, gross 110,677 108,816
Allowance for loan losses (1,349) (1,168)
Total loans $ 109,328 $ 107,648
Our average Global Banking & Markets gross loans were
$109.89 billion for the three months ended September 2023,
$108.48 billion for the three months ended September 2022,
$109.75 billion for the nine months ended September 2023
and $103.41 billion for the nine months ended September
2022.
The table below presents our Global Banking & Markets
operating results.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Advisory $ 831 $ 972 $ 2,294 $ 3,296
Equity underwriting 308 244 901 665
Debt underwriting 415 328 1,369 1,526
Investment banking fees 1,554 1,544 4,564 5,487
FICC intermediation 2,654 2,896 8,023 9,916
FICC financing 730 721 2,003 2,073
FICC 3,384 3,617 10,026 11,989
Equities intermediation 1,713 1,608 4,987 5,553
Equities financing 1,248 1,124 3,955 3,362
Equities 2,961 2,732 8,942 8,915
Other 110 (329) 110 (423)
Net revenues 8,009 7,564 23,642 25,968
Provision for credit losses 29 63 214 462
Operating expenses 4,791 4,224 13,702 13,628
Pre-tax earnings 3,189 3,277 9,726 11,878
Provision for taxes 806 609 2,266 2,008
Net earnings 2,383 2,668 7,460 9,870
Preferred stock dividends 133 82 352 268
Net earnings to common $ 2,250 $ 2,586 $ 7,108 $ 9,602
Average common equity $72,517 $ 71,850 $ 70,968 $ 70,006
Return on average common equity 12.4% 14.4% 13.4% 18.3%
The table below presents our FICC and Equities net revenues
by line item in the consolidated statements of earnings.
$ in millions FICC Equities
Three Months Ended September 2023
Market making $ 3,060 $ 1,898
Commissions and fees – 882
Other principal transactions 243 29
Net interest income 81 152
Total $ 3,384 $ 2,961
Three Months Ended September 2022
Market making $ 3,241 $ 1,400
Commissions and fees – 916
Other principal transactions 68 27
Net interest income 308 389
Total $ 3,617 $ 2,732
Nine Months Ended September 2023
Market making $ 8,945 $ 5,797
Commissions and fees – 2,807
Other principal transactions 480 76
Net interest income 601 262
Total $10,026 $ 8,942
Nine Months Ended September 2022
Market making $ 10,208 $ 5,375
Commissions and fees – 2,856
Other principal transactions 305 42
Net interest income 1,476 642
Total $ 11,989 $ 8,915
In the table above:
• See “Net Revenues” for information about market making
revenues, commissions and fees, other principal
transactions revenues and net interest income. See Note 25
to the consolidated financial statements for net interest
income by segment.
• The primary driver of net revenues for FICC
intermediation for all periods was client activity.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 120

-- 122 of 205 --

The table below presents our financial advisory and
underwriting transaction volumes.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in billions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Announced mergers and acquisitions $ 249 $ 177 $ 585 $ 998
Completed mergers and acquisitions $ 312 $ 223 $ 671 $ 989
Equity and equity-related offerings $ 12 $ 10 $ 33 $ 27
Debt offerings $ 39 $ 45 $ 170 $ 184
In the table above:
• Volumes are per Dealogic.
• Announced and completed mergers and acquisitions
volumes are based on full credit to each of the advisors in a
transaction. Equity and equity-related and debt offerings
are based on full credit for single book managers and equal
credit for joint book managers. Transaction volumes may
not be indicative of net revenues in a given period. In
addition, transaction volumes for prior periods may vary
from amounts previously reported due to the subsequent
withdrawal or a change in the value of a transaction.
• Equity and equity-related offerings includes Rule 144A and
public common stock offerings, convertible offerings and
rights offerings.
• Debt offerings includes non-convertible preferred stock,
mortgage-backed securities, asset-backed securities and
taxable municipal debt. It also includes publicly registered
and Rule 144A issues and excludes leveraged loans.
Operating Environment. During the third quarter of 2023,
Global Banking & Markets operated in an environment
generally characterized by continued broad macroeconomic
concerns, including the outlook for economic growth and
global central bank policy, and elevated geopolitical stresses.
These factors contributed to a decline in market-making
activity levels and weighed on industry-wide investment
banking activity levels.
In investment banking, industry-wide completed mergers and
acquisitions transactions remained lower compared with
elevated levels in the prior year, while industry-wide equity
and debt underwriting volumes remained below historical
averages.
In interest rates, the yield on 10-year U.S. Treasury notes
increased by 75 basis points, while in commodities, the price
of crude oil (WTI) increased 29%, compared with the end of
the second quarter of 2023. In equities, the S&P 500 Index
and MSCI World Index both decreased by 4%, compared
with the end of the second quarter of 2023.
In the future, if market and economic conditions deteriorate
further, and market-making activity levels decline further or
investment banking activity levels decline, or credit spreads
related to hedges on our relationship lending portfolio
tighten, net revenues in Global Banking & Markets would
likely be negatively impacted. In addition, if economic
conditions deteriorate further or if the creditworthiness of
borrowers deteriorates, provision for credit losses would
likely be negatively impacted.
Three Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Net revenues in Global Banking &
Markets were $8.01 billion for the third quarter of 2023, 6%
higher than the third quarter of 2022.
Investment banking fees were $1.55 billion, essentially
unchanged compared with the third quarter of 2022, due to
higher net revenues in Debt underwriting, primarily driven by
leveraged finance activity, and higher net revenues in Equity
underwriting, primarily from initial public offerings, offset
by lower net revenues in Advisory, reflecting a decline in
completed mergers and acquisitions transactions.
As of September 2023, our Investment banking fees backlog
decreased compared with June 2023, primarily due to lower
estimated net revenues from potential advisory transactions.
Our backlog represents an estimate of our net revenues from
future transactions where we believe that future revenue
realization is more likely than not. We believe changes in our
backlog may be a useful indicator of client activity levels
which, over the long term, impact our net revenues.
However, the time frame for completion and corresponding
revenue recognition of transactions in our backlog varies
based on the nature of the assignment, as certain transactions
may remain in our backlog for longer periods of time. In
addition, our backlog is subject to certain limitations, such as
assumptions about the likelihood that individual client
transactions will occur in the future. Transactions may be
cancelled or modified, and transactions not included in the
estimate may also occur.
Net revenues in FICC were $3.38 billion, 6% lower than a
strong third quarter of 2022, reflecting lower net revenues in
FICC intermediation, driven by significantly lower net
revenues in currencies and commodities and lower net
revenues in credit products, partially offset by significantly
higher net revenues in interest rate products and mortgages.
Net revenues in FICC financing increased slightly.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
121 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 123 of 205 --

The decrease in FICC intermediation net revenues reflected
significantly lower client activity (as activity in the prior year
period benefited from volatility in the macroeconomic
environment), partially offset by the impact of improved
market-making conditions on our inventory. The following
provides information about our FICC intermediation net
revenues by business, compared with results for the third
quarter of 2022:
• Net revenues in currencies, commodities and credit
products reflected lower client activity.
• Net revenues in interest rate products and mortgages
reflected the impact of improved market-making
conditions on our inventory.
Net revenues in Equities were $2.96 billion, 8% higher than
the third quarter of 2022, due to higher net revenues in
Equities financing, reflecting significantly higher net revenues
in prime financing, partially offset by significantly lower net
revenues from portfolio financing, and higher net revenues in
Equities intermediation, primarily in derivatives.
Net revenues in Other were $110 million, compared with
$(329) million for the third quarter of 2022, primarily
reflecting significantly lower net losses on hedges and the
absence of net markdowns on acquisition financing activities
included in the prior year period.
Provision for credit losses was $29 million for the third
quarter of 2023, compared with $63 million for the third
quarter of 2022. Provisions for the third quarter of 2023
reflected individual impairments on loans, offset by a reserve
reduction based on increased stability in the macroeconomic
environment. Provisions for the third quarter of 2022
primarily reflected the continued impact of broad
macroeconomic concerns.
Operating expenses were $4.79 billion for the third quarter of
2023, 13% higher than the third quarter of 2022, due to
significantly higher compensation and benefits expenses and
higher transaction based expenses, partially offset by
significantly lower net provisions for litigation and
regulatory proceedings. Pre-tax earnings were $3.19 billion
for the third quarter of 2023, 3% lower than the third quarter
of 2022.
Nine Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Net revenues in Global Banking &
Markets were $23.64 billion for the first nine months of 2023,
9% lower than a strong first nine months of 2022.
Investment banking fees were $4.56 billion, 17% lower than
the first nine months of 2022, due to significantly lower net
revenues in Advisory, reflecting a significant decline in
industry-wide completed mergers and acquisitions
transactions, and lower net revenues in Debt underwriting,
primarily reflecting lower net revenues from asset-backed
activity, partially offset by significantly higher net revenues in
Equity underwriting, primarily reflecting increased activity in
secondary offerings.
As of September 2023, our Investment banking fees backlog
decreased compared with December 2022, due to lower
estimated net revenues from potential advisory transactions
and significantly lower estimated net revenues from potential
equity underwriting transactions (primarily from initial
public offerings).
Net revenues in FICC were $10.03 billion, 16% lower than
the first nine months of 2022, primarily reflecting lower net
revenues in FICC intermediation, driven by significantly
lower net revenues in currencies and commodities, partially
offset by significantly higher net revenues in mortgages and
higher net revenues in interest rate products and credit
products. Net revenues in FICC financing were slightly
lower.
The decrease in FICC intermediation net revenues reflected
lower client activity (as activity in the prior year period
benefited from volatility in the macroeconomic
environment). The following provides information about our
FICC intermediation net revenues by business, compared
with results for the first nine months of 2022:
• Net revenues in currencies and commodities primarily
reflected lower client activity.
• Net revenues in mortgages, interest rate products and
credit products reflected the impact of improved market-
making conditions on our inventory.
Net revenues in Equities were $8.94 billion, essentially
unchanged compared with the first nine months of 2022, as
higher net revenues in Equities financing, primarily in prime
financing, were offset by lower net revenues in Equities
intermediation, primarily in derivatives.
Net revenues in Other were $110 million, compared with
$(423) million for the first nine months of 2022, primarily
reflecting the absence of net markdowns on acquisition
financing activities included in the prior year period.
Provision for credit losses was $214 million for the first nine
months of 2023, compared with $462 million for the first nine
months of 2022. Provisions for the first nine months of 2023
primarily reflected net provisions related to the commercial
real estate portfolio. Provisions for the first nine months of
2022 primarily reflected the impact of broad macroeconomic
and geopolitical concerns.
Operating expenses were $13.70 billion for the first nine
months of 2023, essentially unchanged compared with the
first nine months of 2022. Pre-tax earnings were $9.73 billion
for the first nine months of 2023, 18% lower than the first
nine months of 2022.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 122

-- 124 of 205 --

Asset & Wealth Management
Asset & Wealth Management provides investment services to
help clients preserve and grow their financial assets and
achieve their financial goals. We provide these services to our
clients, both institutional and individuals, including investors
who primarily access our products through a network of
third-party distributors around the world.
We manage client assets across a broad range of investment
strategies and asset classes, including equity, fixed income
and alternative investments. We provide investment
solutions, including those managed on a fiduciary basis by
our portfolio managers, as well as those managed by third-
party managers. We offer our investment solutions in a
variety of structures, including separately managed accounts,
mutual funds, private partnerships and other commingled
vehicles.
We also provide tailored wealth advisory services to clients
across the wealth spectrum. We operate globally, serving
individuals, families, family offices, and foundations and
endowments. Our relationships are established directly or
introduced through companies that sponsor financial
wellness programs for their employees.
We offer personalized financial planning to individuals and
also provide customized investment advisory solutions, and
offer structuring and execution capabilities in securities and
derivative products across all major global markets. In
addition, we offer clients a full range of private banking
services, including a variety of deposit alternatives and loans
that our clients use to finance investments in both financial
and nonfinancial assets, bridge cash flow timing gaps or
provide liquidity and flexibility for other needs.
We invest in alternative investments across a range of asset
classes that seek to deliver long-term accretive risk-adjusted
returns. Our investing activities, which are typically longer-
term, include investments in corporate equity, credit, real
estate and infrastructure assets.
We also raise deposits and have issued unsecured loans to
consumers through Marcus. During the first half of 2023, we
completed the sale of substantially all of the Marcus loans
portfolio.
Asset & Wealth Management generates revenues from the
following:
• Management and other fees. We receive fees related to
managing assets for institutional and individual clients,
providing investing and wealth advisory solutions,
providing financial planning and counseling services, and
executing brokerage transactions for wealth management
clients. The majority of revenues in management and other
fees consists of asset-based fees on client assets that we
manage. During the third quarter of 2023, we announced
an agreement to sell our Personal Financial Management
(PFM) business, which is expected to close in the fourth
quarter of 2023. For further information about assets under
supervision, see “Assets Under Supervision” below. The
fees that we charge vary by asset class, client channel and
the types of services provided, and are affected by
investment performance, as well as asset inflows and
redemptions.
• Incentive fees. In certain circumstances, we also receive
incentive fees based on a percentage of a fund’s or a
separately managed account’s return, or when the return
exceeds a specified benchmark or other performance
targets. Such fees include overrides, which consist of the
increased share of the income and gains derived primarily
from our private equity and credit funds when the return
on a fund’s investments over the life of the fund exceeds
certain threshold returns.
• Private banking and lending. Our private banking and
lending activities include issuing loans to our wealth
management clients. We also accept deposits from wealth
management clients, including through Marcus. We also
issued unsecured loans to consumers through Marcus.
During the first half of 2023, we completed the sale of
substantially all of this portfolio. Additionally, we provide
investing services through Marcus Invest to U.S. customers.
Private banking and lending revenues include net interest
income allocated to deposits and net interest income earned
on loans to individual clients.
• Equity investments. Includes investing activities related
to our asset management activities primarily related to
public and private equity investments in corporate, real
estate and infrastructure assets. We also make investments
through consolidated investment entities (CIEs),
substantially all of which are engaged in real estate
investment activities.
• Debt investments. Includes lending activities related to
our asset management activities, including investing in
corporate debt, lending to middle-market clients, and
providing financing for real estate and other assets. These
activities include investments in mezzanine debt, senior
debt and distressed debt securities.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
123 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 125 of 205 --

The table below presents our Asset & Wealth Management
assets.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Cash and cash equivalents $ 48,916 $ 54,065
Collateralized agreements 10,860 23,723
Customer and other receivables 13,903 13,409
Trading assets 27,060 19,860
Investments 25,487 27,400
Loans 47,251 56,338
Other assets 17,830 20,175
Total $ 191,307 $ 214,970
The table below presents details about our Asset & Wealth
Management loans.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Corporate $ 12,437 $ 14,359
Real estate 16,552 18,699
Securities-based 11,309 12,814
Other collateralized 6,681 6,295
Installment 201 4,474
Other 1,201 1,700
Loans, gross 48,381 58,341
Allowance for loan losses (1,130) (2,003)
Total loans $ 47,251 $ 56,338
The average Asset & Wealth Management gross loans were
$49.61 billion for the three months ended September 2023,
$60.36 billion for the three months ended September 2022,
$53.26 billion for the nine months ended September 2023 and
$59.64 billion for the nine months ended September 2022.
The table below presents our Asset & Wealth Management
operating results.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Management and other fees $ 2,405 $ 2,255 $ 7,041 $ 6,533
Incentive fees 24 56 102 320
Private banking and lending 687 675 1,915 1,705
Equity investments (212) 721 (496) 323
Debt investments 326 326 931 934
Net revenues 3,230 4,033 9,493 9,815
Provision for credit losses 51 (13) (499) 339
Operating expenses 3,005 2,955 9,448 8,187
Pre-tax earnings 174 1,091 544 1,289
Provision for taxes 45 186 127 218
Net earnings 129 905 417 1,071
Preferred stock dividends 36 23 99 81
Net earnings to common $ 93 $ 882 $ 318 $ 990
Average common equity $ 28,601 $ 31,516 $ 30,806 $ 31,238
Return on average common equity 1.3% 11.2% 1.4% 4.2%
Our target is to achieve annual firmwide management and
other fees of more than $10 billion (including more than $2
billion from alternatives) in 2024.
Our target is to achieve pre-tax margins in the mid-twenties
and ROE in the mid-teens within the medium term (three to
five year time horizon from year-end 2022) for Asset &
Wealth Management.
The table below presents our Asset management and Wealth
management net revenues by line item in Asset & Wealth
Management.
$ in millions
Asset
management
Wealth
management
Asset & Wealth
Management
Three Months Ended September 2023
Management and other fees $ 1,052 $ 1,353 $ 2,405
Incentive fees 24 – 24
Private banking and lending – 687 687
Equity investments (212) – (212)
Debt investments 326 – 326
Total $ 1,190 $ 2,040 $ 3,230
Three Months Ended September 2022
Management and other fees $ 1,028 $ 1,227 $ 2,255
Incentive fees 56 – 56
Private banking and lending – 675 675
Equity investments 721 – 721
Debt investments 326 – 326
Total $ 2,131 $ 1,902 $ 4,033
Nine Months Ended September 2023
Management and other fees $ 3,114 $ 3,927 $ 7,041
Incentive fees 102 – 102
Private banking and lending – 1,915 1,915
Equity investments (496) – (496)
Debt investments 931 – 931
Total $ 3,651 $ 5,842 $ 9,493
Nine Months Ended September 2022
Management and other fees $ 2,812 $ 3,721 $ 6,533
Incentive fees 320 – 320
Private banking and lending – 1,705 1,705
Equity investments 323 – 323
Debt investments 934 – 934
Total $ 4,389 $ 5,426 $ 9,815
The table below presents our Equity investments net revenues
by equity type and asset class.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Equity Type
Private equity $ (170) $ 503 $ (440) $ 1,307
Public equity (42) 218 (56) (984)
Total $ (212) $ 721 $ (496) $ 323
Asset Class
Real estate $ (129) $ 167 $ (369) $ 1,106
Corporate (83) 554 (127) (783)
Total $ (212) $ 721 $ (496) $ 323
The table below presents details about our Debt investments
net revenues.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Fair value net gains/(losses) $ (2) $ (47) $ (146) $ (289)
Net interest income 328 373 1,077 1,223
Total $ 326 $ 326 $ 931 $ 934
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 124

-- 126 of 205 --

Operating Environment. During the third quarter of 2023,
Asset & Wealth Management operated in an environment
generally characterized by continued broad macroeconomic
concerns, including continued pressure in the commercial real
estate market. Additionally, global equity and bond prices
generally declined compared with the end of the second
quarter of 2023, negatively affecting assets under supervision.
In the future, if market and economic conditions deteriorate
further, it may lead to a further decline in asset prices, or
investors transitioning to asset classes that typically generate
lower fees or withdrawing their assets, and net revenues in
Asset & Wealth Management would likely continue to be
negatively impacted.
Three Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Net revenues in Asset & Wealth
Management were $3.23 billion for the third quarter of 2023,
20% lower than the third quarter of 2022, primarily reflecting
net losses in Equity investments compared with net gains in
the prior year period, partially offset by higher Management
and other fees.
Equity investments reflected net losses from investments in
private equities, due to net losses from real estate investments
and significantly lower net gains from company-specific
events, and net losses from investments in public equities,
both compared to net gains in the prior year period. The
increase in Management and other fees primarily reflected
the impact of higher average assets under supervision.
Incentive fees were lower, driven by more significant
harvesting in the prior year period. Private banking and
lending net revenues were slightly higher as the impact of
higher deposit balances and spreads was largely offset by the
impact of the sale of substantially all of the Marcus loans
portfolio earlier in the year. Net revenues in Debt
investments were unchanged.
Provision for credit losses was $51 million for the third
quarter of 2023, compared with a net benefit of $13 million
for the third quarter of 2022. Provisions for the third quarter
of 2023 reflected net provisions related to wholesale loans,
driven by individual impairments.
Operating expenses were $3.01 billion for the third quarter of
2023, 2% higher than the third quarter of 2022, due to
impairments of $358 million related to commercial real estate
within consolidated investment entities, partially offset by
lower compensation and benefits expenses (reflecting a
decline in operating performance). Pre-tax earnings were
$174 million for the third quarter of 2023, 84% lower than
the third quarter of 2022.
Nine Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Net revenues in Asset & Wealth
Management were $9.49 billion for the first nine months of
2023, 3% lower than the first nine months of 2022, reflecting
net losses in Equity investments compared with net gains in
the prior year period and significantly lower Incentive fees,
partially offset by higher Management and other fees and
higher net revenues in Private banking and lending. Net
revenues in Private banking and lending included net
revenues of approximately $(370) million related to the sale
of substantially all of the Marcus loans portfolio (offset by a
related reserve reduction of approximately $440 million in
provision for credit losses).
Equity investments reflected net losses from investments in
private equities, due to net losses from real estate
investments, compared with net gains in the prior year
period, partially offset by significantly lower net losses from
investments in public equities. The decrease in Incentive fees
was driven by significant harvesting in the prior year period.
The increase in Management and other fees primarily
reflected the impact of higher average assets under
supervision, including the impact of acquiring NNIP. The
increase in Private banking and lending net revenues
primarily reflected the impact of higher deposit spreads and
balances, partially offset by the impact of the sale of
substantially all of the Marcus loans portfolio. Net revenues
in Debt investments were essentially unchanged.
Provision for credit losses was a net benefit of $499 million
for the first nine months of 2023, compared with a provision
of $339 million for the first nine months of 2022. The net
benefit for the first nine months of 2023 reflected reserve
reductions related to the sale of substantially all of the
Marcus loans portfolio and lower balances in corporate
loans, partially offset by individual impairments. Provisions
for the first nine months of 2022 reflected the impact of broad
macroeconomic and geopolitical concerns and growth in the
Marcus loans portfolio.
Operating expenses were $9.45 billion for the first nine
months of 2023, 15% higher than the first nine months of
2022, largely due to impairments of $1.20 billion related to
commercial real estate within consolidated investment
entities. Pre-tax earnings were $544 million for the first nine
months of 2023, 58% lower than the first nine months of
2022.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
125 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 127 of 205 --

Assets Under Supervision. AUS includes our institutional
clients’ assets, assets sourced through third-party distributors
and high-net-worth clients’ assets where we earn a fee for
managing assets on a discretionary basis. This includes net
assets in our mutual funds, hedge funds, credit funds, private
equity funds, real estate funds, and separately managed
accounts for institutional and individual investors. AUS also
includes client assets invested with third-party managers,
private bank deposits and advisory relationships where we
earn a fee for advisory and other services, but do not have
investment discretion. AUS does not include the self-directed
brokerage assets of our clients.
The table below presents information about our firmwide
period-end AUS by asset class, client channel, region and
vehicle.
As of September
$ in billions 2023 2022
Asset Class
Alternative investments $ 267 $ 256
Equity 607 516
Fixed income 1,031 955
Total long-term AUS 1,905 1,727
Liquidity products 775 700
Total AUS $ 2,680 $ 2,427
Client Channel
Institutional $ 924 $ 855
Wealth management 771 667
Third-party distributed 985 905
Total AUS $ 2,680 $ 2,427
Region
Americas $ 1,914 $ 1,751
EMEA 572 497
Asia 194 179
Total AUS $ 2,680 $ 2,427
Vehicle
Separate accounts $ 1,428 $ 1,296
Public funds 891 837
Private funds and other 361 294
Total AUS $ 2,680 $ 2,427
In the table above:
• Liquidity products includes money market funds and
private bank deposits.
• EMEA represents Europe, Middle East and Africa.
The table below presents changes in our AUS.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in billions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Beginning balance $ 2,714 $ 2,495 $ 2,547 $ 2,470
Net inflows/(outflows):
Alternative investments 2 7 2 16
Equity – (2) (5) 13
Fixed income 5 4 26 (1)
Total long-term AUS net inflows/(outflows) 7 9 23 28
Liquidity products 11 18 64 5
Total AUS net inflows/(outflows) 18 27 87 33
Acquisitions – 4 – 316
Net market appreciation/(depreciation) (52) (99) 46 (392)
Ending balance $ 2,680 $ 2,427 $ 2,680 $ 2,427
In the table above, acquisitions for the third quarter of 2022
included inflows from the acquisition of NextCapital Group,
Inc., and acquisitions for the first nine months of 2022 also
included inflows from the acquisition of NNIP and from the
acquisition of the assets of Bombardier Global Pension Asset
Management Inc. For each, substantially all of the inflows
were in fixed income and equity assets.
The table below presents information about our average
monthly firmwide AUS by asset class.
Average for the
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in billions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Asset Class
Alternative investments $ 267 $ 256 $ 266 $ 251
Equity 628 556 606 586
Fixed income 1,054 999 1,044 995
Total long-term AUS 1,949 1,811 1,916 1,832
Liquidity products 768 696 748 681
Total AUS $ 2,717 $ 2,507 $ 2,664 $ 2,513
In addition to our AUS, we have discretion over alternative
investments where we currently do not earn management fees
(non-fee-earning alternative assets).
We earn management fees on client assets that we manage
and also receive incentive fees based on a percentage of a
fund’s or a separately managed account’s return, or when the
return exceeds a specified benchmark or other performance
targets. These incentive fees are recognized when it is
probable that a significant reversal of such fees will not
occur. Our estimated unrecognized incentive fees were
$3.53 billion as of September 2023 and $3.33 billion as of
December 2022. Such amounts are based on the completion
of the funds’ financial statements, which is generally one
quarter in arrears. These fees will be recognized, assuming no
decline in fair value, if and when it is probable that a
significant reversal of such fees will not occur, which is
generally when such fees are no longer subject to fluctuations
in the market value of the assets.
The table below presents our average effective management
fee (which excludes non-asset-based fees) earned on our
firmwide AUS by asset class.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
Effective fees (bps) 2023 2022 2023 2022
Alternative investments 65 64 65 64
Equity 57 58 58 58
Fixed income 17 18 18 17
Liquidity products 15 15 15 13
Total average effective fee 31 31 31 31
In the table above, our average effective management fee for
liquidity products increased during the first nine months of
2023 compared to the first nine months of 2022, primarily
reflecting higher management fee waivers in 2022.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 126

-- 128 of 205 --

The table below presents details about our monthly average
AUS for alternative investments and the average effective
management fee we earned on such assets.
$ in billions Direct
strategies
Fund of
funds Total
Three Months Ended September 2023
Average AUS
Corporate equity $ 29 $ 69 $ 98
Credit 44 2 46
Real estate 11 9 20
Hedge funds and other 42 22 64
Funds and discretionary accounts $ 126 $ 102 $ 228
Advisory accounts 39
Total average AUS for alternative investments $ 267
Effective Fees (bps)
Corporate equity 123 62 80
Credit 79 40 77
Real estate 84 42 66
Hedge funds and other 68 54 63
Funds and discretionary accounts 86 58 73
Advisory accounts 17
Total average effective fee 65
Three Months Ended September 2022
Average AUS
Corporate equity $ 27 $ 61 $ 88
Credit 40 2 42
Real estate 10 8 18
Hedge funds and other 44 22 66
Funds and discretionary accounts $ 121 $ 93 $ 214
Advisory accounts 42
Total average AUS for alternative investments $ 256
Effective Fees (bps)
Corporate equity 139 62 86
Credit 78 55 77
Real estate 82 48 66
Hedge funds and other 63 47 58
Funds and discretionary accounts 86 57 74
Advisory accounts 16
Total average effective fee 64
Nine Months Ended September 2023
Average AUS
Corporate equity $ 29 $ 69 $ 98
Credit 43 2 45
Real estate 11 8 19
Hedge funds and other 42 22 64
Funds and discretionary accounts $ 125 $ 101 $ 226
Advisory accounts 41
Total average AUS for alternative investments $ 267
Effective Fees (bps)
Corporate equity 127 61 81
Credit 79 47 77
Real estate 81 44 65
Hedge funds and other 67 53 62
Funds and discretionary accounts 86 58 73
Advisory accounts 16
Total average effective fee 65
Nine Months Ended September 2022
Average AUS
Corporate equity $ 26 $ 60 $ 86
Credit 35 2 37
Real estate 10 8 18
Hedge funds and other 46 22 68
Funds and discretionary accounts $ 117 $ 92 $ 209
Advisory accounts 42
Total average AUS for alternative investments $ 251
Effective Fees (bps)
Corporate equity 134 60 82
Credit 81 56 80
Real estate 89 50 71
Hedge funds and other 64 48 59
Funds and discretionary accounts 87 56 73
Advisory accounts 16
Total average effective fee 64
In the table above, direct strategies primarily includes our
private equity, growth equity, private credit, liquid
alternatives and real estate strategies. Fund of funds primarily
includes our business which invests in leading private equity,
hedge fund, real estate and credit third-party managers as a
limited partner, secondary-market investor, co-investor or
management company partner.
The table below presents information about our period-end
AUS for alternative investments, non-fee-earning alternative
investments and total alternative investments.
$ in billions AUS
Non-fee-earning
alternative
assets
Total
alternative
assets
As of September 2023
Corporate equity $ 98 $ 80 $ 178
Credit 46 75 121
Real estate 20 32 52
Hedge funds and other 64 2 66
Funds and discretionary accounts 228 189 417
Advisory accounts 39 – 39
Total alternative investments $ 267 $ 189 $ 456
As of September 2022
Corporate equity $ 92 $ 75 $ 167
Credit 41 71 112
Real estate 17 37 54
Hedge funds and other 65 2 67
Funds and discretionary accounts 215 185 400
Advisory accounts 41 – 41
Total alternative investments $ 256 $ 185 $ 441
In the table above:
• Corporate equity primarily includes private equity.
• Total alternative assets included uncalled capital that is
available for future investing of $55 billion as of September
2023 and $49 billion as of September 2022.
• Non-fee-earning alternative assets primarily includes
investments that we hold on our balance sheet, our
unfunded commitments, unfunded commitments of our
clients (where we do not charge fees on commitments),
credit facilities collateralized by fund assets and employee
funds. Our calculation of non-fee-earning alternative assets
may not be comparable to similar calculations used by
other companies.
• Non-fee-earning alternative assets primarily includes our
direct investing strategies, including private equity, growth
equity, private credit and real estate strategies.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
127 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 129 of 205 --

We have announced a strategic objective of growing our
third-party alternatives business, and have established a
target of achieving gross inflows of $225 billion for
alternative investments from 2020 through the end of 2024.
The table below presents information about third-party
commitments raised in our alternatives business from 2020
through the third quarter of 2023.
As of
$ in billions September 2023
Included in AUS $ 146
Included in non-fee-earning alternative assets 73
Third-party commitments raised $ 219
In the table above, commitments included in non-fee-earning
alternative assets included approximately $55 billion, which
will begin to earn fees (and become AUS) if and when the
commitments are drawn and assets are invested.
The table below presents information about alternative
investments in Asset & Wealth Management that we hold on
our balance sheet by asset type.
As of
September December
$ in billions 2023 2022
Loans $ 14.0 $ 19.0
Debt securities 11.5 12.3
Equity securities 13.5 14.7
CIE investments and other 10.3 12.6
Total $ 49.3 $ 58.6
The table below presents further information about our
alternative investments in Asset & Wealth Management that
we hold on our balance sheet.
As of
September December
$ in billions 2023 2022
Client co-invest $ 22.1 $ 23.0
Firmwide initiatives 6.6 5.9
Historical principal investments:
Loans 4.1 8.4
Debt securities 4.2 5.0
Equity securities 4.5 5.6
CIE investments and other 7.8 10.7
Total historical principal investments 20.6 29.7
Total $ 49.3 $ 58.6
In the table above:
• Client co-invest primarily includes our investments in funds
that we raise and manage or where we have invested
alongside the third-party investors.
• Firmwide initiatives primarily includes our investments
related to the Community Reinvestment Act and our
sponsored initiatives, such as One Million Black Women.
• Historical principal investments includes our remaining
balance sheet alternative investments portfolio that we plan
to reduce. Our target is to reduce this portfolio to less than
$15 billion by the end of 2024 and to completely exit this
portfolio over the medium term (three to five year time
horizon from year-end 2022).
The table below presents the rollforward of our alternative
investments categorized as historical principal investments
for the nine months ended September 2023.
Historical
principal
$ in billions investments
Beginning balance $ 29.7
Additions 1.5
Dispositions (8.1)
Net markdowns (2.5)
Ending balance $ 20.6
In the table above, dispositions included approximately $1.2
billion of investments that were transferred out of historical
principal investments, primarily to Global Banking &
Markets.
The table below presents the commercial real estate
investments in Asset & Wealth Management that we hold on
our balance sheet.
As of
$ in billions September 2023
Loans $ 2.1
Debt securities 0.6
Equity securities 3.9
CIE investments, net of financings 3.1
Total $ 9.7
In the table above:
• Office-related investments included in loans were $0.2
billion, in debt securities were $0.1 billion, in equity
securities were $0.3 billion, and in CIE investments, net of
financings, were $0.6 billion.
• Office-related equity securities and CIE investments, net of
financings, were marked down or impaired by
approximately 50% during the nine months ended
September 2023 and non-office-related equity securities and
CIE investments, net of financings, were marked down or
impaired by approximately 15% during the nine months
ended September 2023.
• Commercial real estate investments consisted of
approximately 43% of historical principal investments,
which we intend to exit over the medium term (three to five
year time horizon from year-end 2022).
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 128

-- 130 of 205 --

Loans and Debt Securities. The table below presents the
concentration of loans and debt securities within our
alternative investments by accounting classification, region
and industry.
As of
September December
$ in billions 2023 2022
Loans $14.0 $19.0
Debt securities 11.5 12.3
Total $25.5 $31.3
Accounting Classification
Debt securities at fair value 45% 39%
Loans at amortized cost 50% 49%
Loans at fair value 3% 6%
Loans held for sale 2% 6 %
Total 100% 100%
Region
Americas 52% 51%
EMEA 36% 35%
Asia 12% 14%
Total 100% 100%
Industry
Consumer & Retail 11% 10%
Financial Institutions 6% 7%
Healthcare 15% 13%
Industrials 17% 16%
Natural Resources & Utilities 2% 2%
Real Estate 12% 20%
Technology, Media & Telecommunications 29% 25%
Other 8% 7%
Total 100% 100%
Equity Securities. The table below presents the
concentration of equity securities within our alternative
investments by region and industry.
As of
September December
$ in billions 2023 2022
Equity securities $13.5 $14.7
Region
Americas 68% 67%
EMEA 16% 15%
Asia 16% 18%
Total 100% 100%
Industry
Consumer & Retail 6% 6%
Financial Institutions 11% 10%
Healthcare 6% 9%
Industrials 8% 7%
Natural Resources & Utilities 13% 14%
Real Estate 30% 30%
Technology, Media & Telecommunications 24% 23%
Other 2% 1%
Total 100% 100%
In the table above:
• Equity securities included $12.4 billion as of September
2023 and $13.0 billion as of December 2022 of private
equity positions, and $1.1 billion as of September 2023 and
$1.7 billion as of December 2022 of public equity positions
that converted from private equity upon the initial public
offerings of the underlying companies.
• The concentrations for real estate equity securities as of
September 2023 were 13% for multifamily (9% as of
December 2022), 2% for office (5% as of December 2022),
8% for mixed use (8% as of December 2022) and 7% for
other real estate equity securities (8% as of December
2022).
The table below presents the concentration of equity
securities within our alternative investments by vintage.
Vintage
As of September 2023
2016 or earlier 27%
2017 - 2019 26%
2020 - thereafter 47%
Total 100%
As of December 2022
2015 or earlier 26%
2016 - 2018 26%
2019 - thereafter 48%
Total 100%
CIE Investments and Other. CIE investments and other
included assets held by CIEs of $8.9 billion as of September
2023 and $11.8 billion as of December 2022, which were
funded with liabilities of approximately $5.6 billion as of
September 2023 and $6.3 billion as of December 2022.
Substantially all such liabilities were nonrecourse, thereby
reducing our equity at risk.
The table below presents the concentration of CIE assets, net
of financings, within our alternative investments by region
and asset class.
As of
September December
$ in billions 2023 2022
CIE assets, net of financings $3.3 $5.5
Region
Americas 66% 65%
EMEA 22% 25%
Asia 12% 10%
Total 100% 100%
Asset Class
Hospitality 5% 4%
Industrials 15% 15%
Multifamily 19% 23%
Office 19% 22%
Retail 3% 3%
Senior Housing 19% 14%
Student Housing 9% 7%
Other 11% 12%
Total 100% 100%
In the table above, during the second quarter of 2023, certain
CIE investments included within the other asset class were
reclassified to the industrials asset class. Prior period
amounts have been conformed to the current presentation.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
129 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 131 of 205 --

The table below presents the concentration of CIE assets, net
of financings, within our alternative investments by vintage.
Vintage
As of September 2023
2016 or earlier 10%
2017 - 2019 59%
2020 - thereafter 31%
Total 100%
As of December 2022
2015 or earlier 5%
2016 - 2018 45%
2019 - thereafter 50%
Total 100%
Platform Solutions
Platform Solutions includes our consumer platforms, such as
partnerships offering credit cards and point-of-sale financing,
and transaction banking and other platform businesses.
Platform Solutions generates revenues from the following:
Consumer platforms. Our Consumer platforms business
issues credit cards and provides point-of-sale financing
through GreenSky to consumers to finance the purchases of
goods or services. Consumer platforms revenues primarily
includes net interest income earned on credit card lending
and point-of-sale financing activities. In October 2023, we
announced an agreement to sell GreenSky, which is expected
to close in the first quarter of 2024. We also accept deposits
from Apple Card customers.
Transaction banking and other. We provide transaction
banking and other services, including cash management
services, such as deposit-taking and payment solutions for
corporate and institutional clients. Transaction banking
revenues include net interest income attributed to transaction
banking deposits.
The table below presents our Platform Solutions assets.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Cash and cash equivalents $ 23,597 $ 20,557
Collateralized agreements 5,912 10,278
Customer and other receivables – 2
Trading assets 14,733 8,597
Loans 21,678 15,300
Other assets 1,917 2,556
Total $ 67,837 $ 57,290
The table below presents details about our Platform
Solutions loans.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Installment $ 6,174 $ 1,852
Credit cards 17,885 15,820
Other 35 –
Loans, gross 24,094 17,672
Allowance for loan losses (2,416) (2,372)
Total loans $ 21,678 $ 15,300
The average Platform Solutions gross loans were
$23.04 billion for the three months ended September 2023,
$13.10 billion for the three months ended September 2022,
$20.56 billion for the nine months ended September 2023 and
$11.21 billion for the nine months ended September 2022.
The table below presents our Platform Solutions operating
results.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
Consumer platforms $ 501 $ 290 $ 1,568 $ 743
Transaction banking and other 77 88 233 246
Net revenues 578 378 1,801 989
Provision for credit losses (73) 465 736 942
Operating expenses 1,258 525 2,850 1,258
Pre-tax earnings/(loss) (607) (612) (1,785) (1,211)
Provision/(benefit) for taxes (153) (108) (416) (205)
Net earnings/(loss) (454) (504) (1,369) (1,006)
Preferred stock dividends 7 2 17 7
Net earnings/(loss) to common $ (461) $ (506) $(1,386) $ (1,013)
Average common equity $ 4,227 $ 3,944 $ 4,060 $ 3,471
Return on average common equity (43.6)% (51.3) % (45.5)% (38.9) %
Our target is to achieve pre-tax profitability by the end of
2025 for Platform Solutions.
Operating Environment. The operating environment for
Platform Solutions is mainly impacted by the economic
environment in the U.S., which, during the third quarter of
2023, was generally characterized by improved inflationary
measures, a continued low rate of unemployment and an
increase in the pace of growth in consumer spending
compared with the second quarter of 2023.
In the future, if economic conditions deteriorate, it may lead
to a decrease in consumer spending or a deterioration in
consumer credit, and net revenues and provision for credit
losses in Platform Solutions would likely be negatively
impacted.
Three Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Net revenues in Platform Solutions were
$578 million for the third quarter of 2023, 53% higher than
the third quarter of 2022, reflecting significantly higher net
revenues in Consumer platforms.
The increase in Consumer platforms net revenues primarily
reflected significantly higher average credit card balances,
partially offset by lower net revenues from the GreenSky loan
portfolio, which included a markdown of $123 million
related to the transfer of the portfolio to held for sale.
Transaction banking and other net revenues were lower,
reflecting lower average deposit balances.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 130

-- 132 of 205 --

Provision for credit losses was a net benefit of $73 million for
the third quarter of 2023, compared with a provision of $465
million for the third quarter of 2022. The net benefit for the
third quarter of 2023 reflected a net release related to the
GreenSky loan portfolio (including a reserve reduction of
$637 million related to the transfer of the portfolio to held for
sale), partially offset by net provisions related to the credit
card portfolio (primarily driven by net charge-offs).
Provisions for the third quarter of 2022 reflected growth in
the credit card portfolio and net charge-offs.
Operating expenses were $1.26 billion for the third quarter of
2023, 140% higher than the third quarter of 2022, primarily
due to a $506 million write-down of identifiable intangible
assets related to GreenSky. Pre-tax loss was $607 million for
the third quarter of 2023, essentially unchanged compared
with the third quarter of 2022.
Nine Months Ended September 2023 versus
September 2022. Net revenues in Platform Solutions were
$1.80 billion for the first nine months of 2023, 82% higher
than the first nine months of 2022, reflecting significantly
higher net revenues in Consumer platforms.
The increase in Consumer platforms net revenues primarily
reflected significantly higher average credit card balances.
Transaction banking and other net revenues were slightly
lower.
Provision for credit losses was $736 million for the first nine
months of 2023, compared with $942 million for the first nine
months of 2022. Provisions for the first nine months of 2023
primarily reflected net provisions related to the credit card
portfolio (primarily driven by net charge-offs), partially
offset by a net release related to the GreenSky loan portfolio
(including a reserve reduction related to the transfer of the
portfolio to held for sale). Provisions for the first nine months
of 2022 primarily reflected growth in the credit card portfolio
and net charge-offs.
Operating expenses were $2.85 billion for the first nine
months of 2023, 127% higher than the first nine months of
2022, primarily due to a $506 million write-down related to
GreenSky and an impairment of goodwill of $504 million
related to Consumer platforms. Pre-tax loss was $1.79 billion
for the first nine months of 2023, compared with a pre-tax
loss of $1.21 billion for the first nine months of 2022.
Geographic Data
See Note 25 to the consolidated financial statements for a
summary of our total net revenues and pre-tax earnings by
geographic region.
Balance Sheet and Funding Sources
Balance Sheet Management
One of our risk management disciplines is our ability to
manage the size and composition of our balance sheet. While
our asset base changes due to client activity, market
fluctuations and business opportunities, the size and
composition of our balance sheet also reflects factors,
including (i) our overall risk tolerance, (ii) the amount of
capital we hold and (iii) our funding profile, among other
factors. See “Capital Management and Regulatory Capital —
Capital Management” for information about our capital
management process.
Although our balance sheet fluctuates on a day-to-day basis,
our total assets at quarter-end are generally not materially
different from those occurring within our reporting periods.
In order to ensure appropriate risk management, we seek to
maintain a sufficiently liquid balance sheet and have
processes in place to dynamically manage our assets and
liabilities, which include (i) balance sheet planning, (ii)
balance sheet limits, (iii) monitoring of key metrics and (iv)
scenario analyses.
Balance Sheet Planning. We prepare a balance sheet plan
that combines our projected total assets and composition of
assets with our expected funding sources over a three-year
time horizon. This plan is reviewed quarterly and may be
adjusted in response to changing business needs or market
conditions. The objectives of this planning process are:
• To develop our balance sheet projections, taking into
account the general state of the financial markets and
expected business activity levels, as well as regulatory
requirements;
• To allow Treasury and our independent risk oversight and
control functions to objectively evaluate balance sheet limit
requests from our revenue-producing units in the context
of our overall balance sheet constraints, including our
liability profile and capital levels, and key metrics; and
• To inform the target amount, tenor and type of funding to
raise, based on our projected assets and contractual
maturities.
Treasury and our independent risk oversight and control
functions, along with our revenue-producing units, review
current and prior period information and expectations for the
year to prepare our balance sheet plan. The specific
information reviewed includes asset and liability size and
composition, limit utilization, risk and performance
measures, and capital usage.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
131 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 133 of 205 --

Our consolidated balance sheet plan, including our balance
sheets by business, funding projections and projected key
metrics, is reviewed and approved by the Firmwide Asset
Liability Committee and the Firmwide Risk Appetite
Committee. See “Risk Management — Overview and
Structure of Risk Management” for an overview of our risk
management structure.
Balance Sheet Limits. The Firmwide Asset Liability
Committee and the Firmwide Risk Appetite Committee have
the responsibility to review and approve balance sheet limits.
These limits are set at levels which are close to actual
operating levels, rather than at levels which reflect our
maximum risk appetite, in order to ensure prompt escalation
and discussion among our revenue-producing units, Treasury
and our independent risk oversight and control functions on
a routine basis. Requests for changes in limits are evaluated
after giving consideration to their impact on our key metrics.
Compliance with limits is monitored by our revenue-
producing units and Treasury, as well as our independent
risk oversight and control functions.
Monitoring of Key Metrics. We monitor key balance sheet
metrics both by business and on a consolidated basis,
including asset and liability size and composition, limit
utilization and risk measures. We attribute assets to
businesses and review and analyze movements resulting from
new business activity, as well as market fluctuations.
Scenario Analyses. We conduct various scenario analyses,
including as part of the Comprehensive Capital Analysis and
Review (CCAR) and U.S. Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform
and Consumer Protection Act Stress Tests (DFAST), as well
as our resolution and recovery planning. See “Capital
Management and Regulatory Capital — Capital
Management” for further information about these scenario
analyses. These scenarios cover short- and long-term time
horizons using various macroeconomic and firm-specific
assumptions, based on a range of economic scenarios. We use
these analyses to assist us in developing our longer-term
balance sheet management strategy, including the level and
composition of assets, funding and capital. Additionally,
these analyses help us develop approaches for maintaining
appropriate funding, liquidity and capital across a variety of
situations, including a severely stressed environment.
Balance Sheet Analysis and Metrics
As of September 2023, total assets in our consolidated
balance sheets were $1.58 trillion, an increase of $135.35
billion from December 2022, reflecting increases in trading
assets of $146.82 billion (due to increases in government
obligations and equity securities, reflecting the impact of our
and our clients' activities, partially offset by decreases in
derivative instruments primarily due to commodity
derivatives) and investments of $14.90 billion (primarily due
to an increase in U.S. government obligations accounted for
as held-to-maturity), partially offset by a decrease in
collateralized agreements of $26.54 billion (reflecting the
impact of our activities).
As of September 2023, total liabilities in our consolidated
balance sheets were $1.46 trillion, an increase of $135.27
billion from December 2022, reflecting increases in
collateralized financings of $140.31 billion (primarily
reflecting our activities) and deposits of $16.30 billion (due to
increases in consumer and other deposits, partially offset by
decreases in private bank and deposit sweep program
balances), partially offset by a decrease in borrowings of
$14.07 billion (driven by net maturities) and customer and
other payables of $9.70 billion (primarily reflecting our
clients' activities).
Our total securities sold under agreements to repurchase
(repurchase agreements), accounted for as collateralized
financings, were $225.68 billion as of September 2023 and
$110.35 billion as of December 2022, which were 5% higher
as of September 2023 and 15% lower as of December 2022
than the average daily amount of repurchase agreements over
the respective quarters. As of September 2023, the increase in
our repurchase agreements relative to the average daily
amount of repurchase agreements during the quarter resulted
from higher levels of our and our clients’ activities at the end
of the period.
The level of our repurchase agreements fluctuates between
and within periods, primarily due to providing clients with
access to highly liquid collateral, such as certain government
and agency obligations, through collateralized financing
activities.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 132

-- 134 of 205 --

The table below presents information about our balance
sheet and leverage ratios.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Total assets $ 1,577,153 $ 1,441,799
Unsecured long-term borrowings $ 224,024 $ 247,138
Total shareholders’ equity $ 117,277 $ 117,189
Leverage ratio 13.4x 12.3x
Debt-to-equity ratio 1.9x 2.1x
In the table above:
• The leverage ratio equals total assets divided by total
shareholders’ equity and measures the proportion of equity
and debt we use to finance assets. This ratio is different
from the leverage ratios included in Note 20 to the
consolidated financial statements.
• The debt-to-equity ratio equals unsecured long-term
borrowings divided by total shareholders’ equity.
The table below presents information about our
shareholders’ equity and book value per common share,
including the reconciliation of common shareholders’ equity
to tangible common shareholders’ equity.
As of
September December
$ in millions, except per share amounts 2023 2022
Total shareholders’ equity $ 117,277 $ 117,189
Preferred stock (11,203) (10,703)
Common shareholders’ equity 106,074 106,486
Goodwill (5,913) (6,374)
Identifiable intangible assets (1,341) (2,009)
Tangible common shareholders’ equity $ 98,820 $ 98,103
Book value per common share $ 313.83 $ 303.55
Tangible book value per common share $ 292.37 $ 279.66
In the table above:
• Tangible common shareholders’ equity is calculated as
total shareholders’ equity less preferred stock, goodwill
and identifiable intangible assets. We believe that tangible
common shareholders’ equity is meaningful because it is a
measure that we and investors use to assess capital
adequacy. Tangible common shareholders’ equity is a non-
GAAP measure and may not be comparable to similar non-
GAAP measures used by other companies.
• Book value per common share and tangible book value per
common share are based on common shares outstanding
and restricted stock units granted to employees with no
future service requirements and not subject to performance
or market conditions (collectively, basic shares) of 338.0
million as of September 2023 and 350.8 million as of
December 2022. We believe that tangible book value per
common share (tangible common shareholders’ equity
divided by basic shares) is meaningful because it is a
measure that we and investors use to assess capital
adequacy. Tangible book value per common share is a non-
GAAP measure and may not be comparable to similar non-
GAAP measures used by other companies.
Funding Sources
Our primary sources of funding are deposits, collateralized
financings, unsecured short- and long-term borrowings, and
shareholders’ equity. We seek to maintain broad and
diversified funding sources globally across products,
programs, markets, currencies and creditors to avoid funding
concentrations.
The table below presents information about our funding
sources.
As of
$ in millions September 2023 December 2022
Deposits $ 402,962 36% $ 386,665 40%
Collateralized financings 295,333 27% 155,022 16%
Unsecured short-term borrowings 70,009 6% 60,961 6%
Unsecured long-term borrowings 224,024 20% 247,138 26%
Total shareholders’ equity 117,277 11% 117,189 12%
Total $ 1,109,605 100% $ 966,975 100%
Our funding is primarily raised in U.S. dollar, Euro, British
pound and Japanese yen. We generally distribute our funding
products through our own sales force and third-party
distributors to a large, diverse creditor base in a variety of
markets in the Americas, Europe and Asia. We believe that
our relationships with our creditors are critical to our
liquidity. Our creditors include banks, governments,
securities lenders, corporations, pension funds, insurance
companies, mutual funds and individuals. We have imposed
various internal guidelines to monitor creditor concentration
across our funding programs.
Deposits. Our deposits provide us with a diversified source
of funding and reduce our reliance on wholesale funding. We
raise deposits, including savings, demand and time deposits,
from private bank clients, consumers, transaction banking
clients, other institutional clients, and through internal and
third-party broker-dealers. Substantially all of our deposits
are raised through Goldman Sachs Bank USA (GS Bank
USA), Goldman Sachs International Bank (GSIB) and
Goldman Sachs Bank Europe SE (GSBE). See Note 13 to the
consolidated financial statements for further information
about our deposits, including a maturity profile of our time
deposits.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
133 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 135 of 205 --

Secured Funding. We fund a significant amount of
inventory and a portion of investments on a secured basis.
Secured funding includes collateralized financings in the
consolidated balance sheets. See Note 11 to the consolidated
financial statements for further information about our
collateralized financings, including its maturity profile. We
may also pledge our inventory and investments as collateral
for securities borrowed under a securities lending agreement.
We also use our own inventory and investments to cover
transactions in which we or our clients have sold securities
that have not yet been purchased. Secured funding is less
sensitive to changes in our credit quality than unsecured
funding, due to our posting of collateral to our lenders.
Nonetheless, we analyze the refinancing risk of our secured
funding activities, taking into account trade tenors, maturity
profiles, counterparty concentrations, collateral eligibility
and counterparty rollover probabilities. We seek to mitigate
our refinancing risk by executing term trades with staggered
maturities, diversifying counterparties, raising excess secured
funding and pre-funding residual risk through our GCLA.
We seek to raise secured funding with a term appropriate for
the liquidity of the assets that are being financed, and we seek
longer maturities for secured funding collateralized by asset
classes that may be harder to fund on a secured basis,
especially during times of market stress. Our secured funding,
excluding funding collateralized by liquid government and
agency obligations, is primarily executed for tenors of one
month or greater and is primarily executed through term
repurchase agreements and securities loaned contracts.
Assets that may be harder to fund on a secured basis during
times of market stress include certain financial instruments in
the following categories: mortgage- and other asset-backed
loans and securities, non-investment-grade corporate debt
securities, equity securities and emerging market securities.
We also raise financing through other types of collateralized
financings, such as secured loans and notes. GS Bank USA
has access to funding from the Federal Home Loan Bank.
Our outstanding borrowings from the Federal Home Loan
Bank were $2.00 billion as of September 2023 and we had no
outstanding borrowings as of December 2022. Additionally,
we have access to funding through the Federal Reserve
discount window. However, we do not rely on this funding in
our liquidity planning and stress testing.
Unsecured Short-Term Borrowings. A significant portion
of our unsecured short-term borrowings was originally long-
term debt that is scheduled to mature within one year of the
reporting date. We use unsecured short-term borrowings,
including U.S. and non-U.S. hybrid financial instruments and
commercial paper, to finance liquid assets and for other cash
management purposes. In accordance with regulatory
requirements, Group Inc. does not issue debt with an original
maturity of less than one year, other than to its subsidiaries.
See Note 14 to the consolidated financial statements for
further information about our unsecured short-term
borrowings.
Unsecured Long-Term Borrowings. Unsecured long-term
borrowings, including structured notes, are raised through
syndicated U.S. registered offerings, U.S. registered and Rule
144A medium-term note programs, offshore medium-term
note offerings and other debt offerings. We issue in different
tenors, currencies and products to maximize the
diversification of our investor base.
The table below presents our quarterly unsecured long-term
borrowings maturity profile.
$ in millions
First
Quarter
Second
Quarter
Third
Quarter
Fourth
Quarter Total
As of September 2023
2024 $ – $ – $ – $ 13,961 $ 13,961
2025 $ 12,441 $ 12,134 $ 6,799 $ 7,438 38,812
2026 $ 6,819 $ 4,621 $ 7,566 $ 8,752 27,758
2027 $ 8,650 $ 3,223 $ 6,814 $ 14,536 33,223
2028 $ 10,950 $ 5,998 $ 4,668 $ 2,685 24,301
2029 - thereafter 85,969
Total $ 224,024
The weighted average maturity of our unsecured long-term
borrowings as of September 2023 was approximately seven
years. To mitigate refinancing risk, we seek to limit the
principal amount of debt maturing over the course of any
monthly, quarterly, semi-annual or annual time horizon. We
enter into interest rate swaps to convert a portion of our
unsecured long-term borrowings into floating-rate
obligations to manage our exposure to interest rates. See
Note 14 to the consolidated financial statements for further
information about our unsecured long-term borrowings.
Shareholders’ Equity. Shareholders’ equity is a stable and
perpetual source of funding. See Note 19 to the consolidated
financial statements for further information about our
shareholders’ equity.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 134

-- 136 of 205 --

Capital Management and Regulatory Capital
Capital adequacy is of critical importance to us. We have in
place a comprehensive capital management policy that
provides a framework, defines objectives and establishes
guidelines to assist us in maintaining the appropriate level
and composition of capital in both business-as-usual and
stressed conditions.
Capital Management
We determine the appropriate amount and composition of
our capital by considering multiple factors, including our
current and future regulatory capital requirements, the results
of our capital planning and stress testing process, the results
of resolution capital models and other factors, such as rating
agency guidelines, subsidiary capital requirements, the
business environment and conditions in the financial
markets.
We manage our capital requirements and the levels of our
capital usage principally by setting limits on the balance sheet
and/or limits on risk, in each case at both the firmwide and
business levels.
We principally manage the level and composition of our
capital through issuances and repurchases of our common
stock.
We may issue, redeem or repurchase our preferred stock and
subordinated debt or other forms of capital as business
conditions warrant. Prior to such redemptions or
repurchases, we must receive approval from the FRB. See
Notes 14 and 19 to the consolidated financial statements for
further information about our preferred stock and
subordinated debt.
Capital Planning and Stress Testing Process. As part of
capital planning, we project sources and uses of capital given
a range of business environments, including stressed
conditions. Our stress testing process is designed to identify
and measure material risks associated with our business
activities, including market risk, credit risk, operational risk
and liquidity risk, as well as our ability to generate revenues.
Our capital planning process incorporates an internal capital
adequacy assessment with the objective of ensuring that we
are appropriately capitalized relative to the risks in our
businesses. We incorporate stress scenarios into our capital
planning process with a goal of holding sufficient capital to
ensure we remain adequately capitalized after experiencing a
severe stress event. Our assessment of capital adequacy is
viewed in tandem with our assessment of liquidity adequacy
and is integrated into our overall risk management structure,
governance and policy framework.
Our stress tests incorporate our internally designed stress
scenarios, including our internally developed severely adverse
scenario, and those required by the FRB, and are designed to
capture our specific vulnerabilities and risks. We provide
further information about our stress test processes and a
summary of the results on our website as described in
“Available Information.”
As required by the FRB’s CCAR rules, we submit an annual
capital plan for review by the FRB. The purpose of the FRB’s
review is to ensure that we have a robust, forward-looking
capital planning process that accounts for our unique risks
and that permits continued operation during times of
economic and financial stress.
The FRB evaluates us based, in part, on whether we have the
capital necessary to continue operating under the baseline
and severely adverse scenarios provided by the FRB and those
developed internally. This evaluation also takes into account
our process for identifying risk, our controls and governance
for capital planning, and our guidelines for making capital
planning decisions. In addition, the FRB evaluates our plan to
make capital distributions (i.e., dividend payments and
repurchases or redemptions of stock, subordinated debt or
other capital securities) and issue capital, across the range of
macroeconomic scenarios and firm-specific assumptions. The
FRB determines the stress capital buffer (SCB) applicable to
us based on its own annual stress test. The SCB under the
Standardized approach is calculated as (i) the difference
between our starting and minimum projected CET1 capital
ratios under the supervisory severely adverse scenario and (ii)
our planned common stock dividends for each of the fourth
through seventh quarters of the planning horizon, expressed
as a percentage of risk-weighted assets (RWAs).
Based on our 2023 CCAR submission, the FRB reduced our
SCB from 6.3% to 5.5% for the period from October 1, 2023
through September 30, 2024. As a result, beginning on
October 1, 2023, our Standardized CET1 capital ratio
requirement is 13.0%. See “Share Repurchase Program” for
further information about common stock repurchases and
dividends and “Consolidated Regulatory Capital” for further
information about the global systemically important bank
(G-SIB) surcharge. We published a summary of our annual
DFAST results in June 2023. See “Available Information.”
GS Bank USA is required to conduct stress tests on an annual
basis and publish a summary of certain results. GS Bank USA
published a summary of its annual DFAST results in June
2023. See “Available Information.”
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
135 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 137 of 205 --

Goldman Sachs International (GSI), GSIB and GSBE also
have their own capital planning and stress testing processes,
which incorporate internally designed stress tests developed
in accordance with the guidelines of their respective
regulators.
Contingency Capital Plan. As part of our comprehensive
capital management policy, we maintain a contingency
capital plan. Our contingency capital plan provides a
framework for analyzing and responding to a perceived or
actual capital deficiency, including, but not limited to,
identification of drivers of a capital deficiency, as well as
mitigants and potential actions. It outlines the appropriate
communication procedures to follow during a crisis period,
including internal dissemination of information, as well as
timely communication with external stakeholders.
Capital Attribution. We assess the capital usage of each of
our businesses based on our attributed equity framework.
This framework considers many factors, including our
internal assessment of risks as well as the regulatory capital
requirements related to our business activities. These
regulatory capital requirements take into consideration our
most binding capital constraints. Our most binding capital
constraint is our CET1 capital ratio requirement under the
Standardized Capital Rules. This requirement includes the
SCB which is determined by the FRB based on its own annual
stress test.
Share Repurchase Program. We use our share repurchase
program to help maintain the appropriate level of common
equity. The repurchase program is effected primarily through
regular open-market purchases (which may include
repurchase plans designed to comply with Rule 10b5-1 and
accelerated share repurchases), the amounts and timing of
which are determined primarily by our current and projected
capital position and our capital plan submitted to the FRB as
part of CCAR. The amounts and timing of the repurchases
may also be influenced by general market conditions and the
prevailing price and trading volumes of our common stock.
During the third quarter of 2023, we returned a total of $2.44
billion to shareholders, including common stock repurchases
of $1.50 billion and common stock dividends of $937 million.
The Board of Directors of Group Inc. (Board) approved an
increase in our common stock dividend from $2.50 to $2.75
per share beginning in the third quarter of 2023. Consistent
with our capital management philosophy, we will continue
prioritizing deployment of capital for our clients where
returns are attractive and distribute any excess capital to
shareholders through dividends and share repurchases.
However, given the uncertainty about the FRB's recently
proposed capital rules, we expect to moderate our stock
repurchase levels in the fourth quarter of 2023 relative to the
third quarter of 2023.
In February 2023, the Board approved a new share
repurchase program authorizing repurchases of up to $30
billion (in aggregate value and inclusive of shares repurchased
in 2023) of our common stock. See “Unregistered Sales of
Equity Securities, Use of Proceeds, and Issuer Purchases of
Equity Securities” in Part II, Item 2 of this Form 10-Q and
Note 19 to the consolidated financial statements for further
information about our share repurchase program, and see
above for information about our capital planning and stress
testing process.
Effective January 1, 2023, a one percent non-deductible
federal excise tax (buyback tax) applies to the fair market
value of certain corporate share repurchases. The fair market
value of share repurchases subject to the tax is reduced by the
fair market value of any stock issued during the calendar
year, including stock issued to employees. The buyback tax
did not have a material impact on our financial condition,
results of operations or cash flows for either the three or nine
months ended September 2023.
Resolution Capital Models. In connection with our
resolution planning efforts, we have established a Resolution
Capital Adequacy and Positioning framework, which is
designed to ensure that our major subsidiaries (GS Bank
USA, Goldman Sachs & Co. LLC (GS&Co.), GSI, GSIB,
GSBE, Goldman Sachs Japan Co., Ltd. (GSJCL), Goldman
Sachs Asset Management, L.P. and Goldman Sachs Asset
Management International) have access to sufficient loss-
absorbing capacity (in the form of equity, subordinated debt
and unsecured senior debt) so that they are able to wind
down following a Group Inc. bankruptcy filing in accordance
with our preferred resolution strategy.
In addition, we have established a triggers and alerts
framework, which is designed to provide the Board with
information needed to make an informed decision on
whether and when to commence bankruptcy proceedings for
Group Inc.
We submitted our 2023 resolution plan in June 2023. See
"Available Information" for information about the public
portion of our resolution plan submission.
Rating Agency Guidelines
The credit rating agencies assign credit ratings to the
obligations of Group Inc., which directly issues or guarantees
substantially all of our senior unsecured debt obligations.
GS&Co. and GSI have been assigned long- and short-term
issuer ratings by certain credit rating agencies. GS Bank USA,
GSIB and GSBE have also been assigned long- and short-term
issuer ratings, as well as ratings on their long- and short-term
bank deposits. In addition, credit rating agencies have
assigned ratings to debt obligations of certain other
subsidiaries of Group Inc.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 136

-- 138 of 205 --

The level and composition of our capital are among the many
factors considered in determining our credit ratings. Each
agency has its own definition of eligible capital and
methodology for evaluating capital adequacy, and
assessments are generally based on a combination of factors
rather than a single calculation. See “Risk Management —
Liquidity Risk Management — Credit Ratings” for further
information about credit ratings of Group Inc., GS Bank
USA, GSIB, GSBE, GS&Co. and GSI.
Consolidated Regulatory Capital
We are subject to consolidated regulatory capital
requirements which are calculated in accordance with the
regulations of the FRB (Capital Framework). Under the
Capital Framework, we are an “Advanced approaches”
banking organization and have been designated as a G-SIB.
The capital requirements calculated under the Capital
Framework include the capital conservation buffer
requirements, which are comprised of a 2.5% buffer (under
the Advanced Capital Rules), the SCB (under the
Standardized Capital Rules), a countercyclical capital buffer
(under both Capital Rules) and the G-SIB surcharge (under
both Capital Rules). Our G-SIB surcharge is 3.0% for 2023
and 2024. The G-SIB surcharge and countercyclical capital
buffer in the future may differ due to additional guidance
from our regulators and/or positional changes, and our SCB
is likely to change from year to year based on the results of
the annual supervisory stress tests. Our target is to maintain
capital ratios equal to the regulatory requirements plus a
buffer of 50 to 100 basis points.
See Note 20 to the consolidated financial statements for
further information about our risk-based capital ratios and
leverage ratios, and the Capital Framework.
Total Loss-Absorbing Capacity (TLAC)
We are also subject to the FRB’s TLAC and related
requirements. Failure to comply with the TLAC and related
requirements would result in restrictions being imposed by
the FRB and could limit our ability to repurchase shares, pay
dividends and make certain discretionary compensation
payments.
The table below presents TLAC and external long-term debt
requirements.
As of
September December
2023 2022
TLAC to RWAs 22.0% 21.5%
TLAC to leverage exposure 9.5% 9.5%
External long-term debt to RWAs 9.0% 8.5%
External long-term debt to leverage exposure 4.5% 4.5%
In the table above:
• The TLAC to RWAs requirement included (i) the 18%
minimum, (ii) the 2.5% buffer, (iii) the countercyclical
capital buffer, which the FRB has set to zero percent and
(iv) the G-SIB surcharge (Method 1). The G-SIB surcharge
(Method 1) was 1.5% as of September 2023 and 1.0% as of
December 2022.
• The TLAC to leverage exposure requirement includes (i)
the 7.5% minimum and (ii) the 2.0% leverage exposure
buffer.
• The external long-term debt to RWAs requirement
includes (i) the 6% minimum and (ii) the G-SIB surcharge
(Method 2). The G-SIB surcharge (Method 2) was 3.0% as
of September 2023 and 2.5% as of December 2022.
• The external long-term debt to total leverage exposure is
the 4.5% minimum.
The table below presents information about our TLAC and
external long-term debt ratios.
For the Three Months
Ended or as of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
TLAC $ 277,052 $ 297,100
External long-term debt $ 154,100 $ 172,845
RWAs $ 666,860 $ 679,450
Leverage exposure $ 1,964,806 $ 1,867,358
TLAC to RWAs 41.5% 43.7%
TLAC to leverage exposure 14.1% 15.9%
External long-term debt to RWAs 23.1% 25.4%
External long-term debt to leverage exposure 7.8% 9.3%
In the table above:
• TLAC includes common and preferred stock, and eligible
long-term debt issued by Group Inc. Eligible long-term
debt represents unsecured debt, which has a remaining
maturity of at least one year and satisfies additional
requirements.
• External long-term debt consists of eligible long-term debt
subject to a haircut if it is due to be paid between one and
two years.
• In accordance with the TLAC rules, the higher of
Advanced or Standardized RWAs are used in the
calculation of TLAC and external long-term debt ratios
and applicable requirements. RWAs represent Standardized
RWAs as of September 2023 and Advanced RWAs as of
December 2022.
• Leverage exposure consists of average adjusted total assets
and certain off-balance sheet exposures.
See “Business — Regulation” in Part I, Item 1 of the 2022
Form 10-K for further information about TLAC.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
137 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 139 of 205 --

Subsidiary Capital Requirements
Many of our subsidiaries, including our bank and broker-
dealer subsidiaries, are subject to separate regulation and
capital requirements of the jurisdictions in which they
operate.
Bank Subsidiaries. GS Bank USA is our primary U.S.
banking subsidiary and GSIB and GSBE are our primary non-
U.S. banking subsidiaries. These entities are subject to
regulatory capital requirements. See Note 20 to the
consolidated financial statements for further information
about the regulatory capital requirements of our bank
subsidiaries.
U.S. Regulated Broker-Dealer Subsidiaries. GS&Co.,
our primary U.S. regulated broker-dealer subsidiary, is also a
registered futures commission merchant and a registered
swap dealer with the CFTC, and a registered security-based
swap dealer with the SEC, and therefore is subject to
regulatory capital requirements imposed by the SEC, the
Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc., the CFTC, the
Chicago Mercantile Exchange and the National Futures
Association. Rule 15c3-1 of the SEC and Rules 1.17 and Part
23 Subpart E of the CFTC specify uniform minimum net
capital requirements, as defined, for their registrants, and
also effectively require that a significant part of the
registrants’ assets be kept in relatively liquid form. GS&Co.
has elected to calculate its minimum capital requirements in
accordance with the “Alternative Net Capital Requirement”
as permitted by Rule 15c3-1 of the SEC.
GS&Co. had regulatory net capital, as defined by Rule
15c3-1, of $21.01 billion as of September 2023 and
$22.21 billion as of December 2022, which exceeded the
amount required by $16.25 billion as of September 2023 and
$17.46 billion as of December 2022. In addition to its
alternative minimum net capital requirements, GS&Co. is
also required to hold tentative net capital in excess of
$5 billion and net capital in excess of $1 billion in accordance
with Rule 15c3-1. GS&Co. is also required to notify the SEC
in the event that its tentative net capital is less than $6 billion.
As of both September 2023 and December 2022, GS&Co. had
tentative net capital and net capital in excess of both the
minimum and the notification requirements.
Non-U.S. Regulated Broker-Dealer Subsidiaries. Our
principal non-U.S. regulated broker-dealer subsidiaries
include GSI and GSJCL.
GSI, our U.K. broker-dealer, is regulated by the Prudential
Regulation Authority (PRA) and the Financial Conduct
Authority (FCA). GSI is subject to the U.K. capital
framework, which is largely based on the Basel Committee
on Banking Supervision’s (Basel Committee) capital
framework for strengthening international capital standards
(Basel III).
The table below presents GSI’s risk-based capital
requirements.
As of
September December
2023 2022
Risk-based capital requirements
CET1 capital ratio 9.1% 8.7%
Tier 1 capital ratio 11.0% 10.7%
Total capital ratio 13.6% 13.3%
In the table above, the risk-based capital requirements
incorporate capital guidance received from the PRA and
could change in the future.
The table below presents information about GSI’s risk-based
capital ratios.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Risk-based capital and risk-weighted assets
CET1 capital $ 33,123 $ 31,780
Tier 1 capital $ 38,623 $ 40,080
Tier 2 capital $ 6,877 $ 5,377
Total capital $ 45,500 $ 45,457
RWAs $ 271,452 $ 247,653
Risk-based capital ratios
CET1 capital ratio 12.2% 12.8%
Tier 1 capital ratio 14.2% 16.2%
Total capital ratio 16.8% 18.4%
In the table above, the risk-based capital ratios as of
September 2023 reflected profits after dividends paid and
foreseeable charges that are still subject to verification by
GSI’s external auditors and approval by the PRA for
inclusion in risk-based capital. These profits contributed
approximately 44 basis points to the CET1 capital ratio as of
September 2023.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 138

-- 140 of 205 --

The table below presents GSI's leverage ratio requirement
which became effective in January 2023 and the leverage
ratio.
As of
September 2023
Leverage ratio requirement 3.5%
Leverage ratio 5.1%
In the table above, the leverage ratio as of September 2023
reflected profits after dividends paid and foreseeable charges
that are still subject to verification by GSI’s external auditors
and approval by the PRA for inclusion in risk-based capital.
These profits contributed approximately 16 basis points to
the leverage ratio as of September 2023.
GSI is a registered swap dealer with the CFTC and a
registered security-based swap dealer with the SEC. As of
both September 2023 and December 2022, GSI was subject to
and in compliance with applicable capital requirements for
swap dealers and security-based swap dealers.
GSI is also subject to a minimum requirement for own funds
and eligible liabilities issued to affiliates. This requirement is
subject to a transitional period which began to phase in from
January 2019 and became fully effective beginning in January
2022. As of both September 2023 and December 2022, GSI
was in compliance with this requirement.
GSJCL, our Japanese broker-dealer, is regulated by Japan’s
Financial Services Agency. GSJCL and certain other non-U.S.
subsidiaries are also subject to capital requirements
promulgated by authorities of the countries in which they
operate. As of both September 2023 and December 2022,
these subsidiaries were in compliance with their local capital
requirements.
Regulatory and Other Matters
Regulatory Matters
Our businesses are subject to extensive regulation and
supervision worldwide. Regulations have been adopted or are
being considered by regulators and policy makers worldwide.
Given that many of the new and proposed rules are highly
complex, the full impact of regulatory reform will not be
known until the rules are implemented and market practices
develop under the final regulations.
See “Business — Regulation” in Part I, Item 1 of the 2022
Form 10-K for further information about the laws, rules and
regulations and proposed laws, rules and regulations that
apply to us and our operations.
Basel III Reforms. In July 2023, the U.S. federal bank
regulatory authorities proposed a rule implementing the Basel
Committee’s finalization of the post-crisis regulatory capital
reforms. The proposed effective date is July 1, 2025 with a
three-year transition period for the calculation of Expanded
Risk-Based Approach RWAs. The proposal includes the
replacement of the Advanced Approach with an Expanded
Risk-Based Approach, which eliminates the use of internal
models to calculate RWAs for credit and operational risk.
The proposal also provides that stress capital requirements
through the SCB would be applied to Expanded Risk-Based
Approach capital ratios. The credit risk component of the
Expanded Risk-Based Approach would include new risk
weights for many counterparty and exposure types, a revised
collateral haircut approach for certain collateralized
transactions and additional restrictions for recognizing
collateral in certain securities financing transactions. The
operational RWAs are proposed to be calculated primarily
based on revenues and historical losses. In addition, the
proposal includes the Fundamental Review of the Trading
Book, which replaces the market risk rule for both the
Standardized and Expanded Risk-Based Approach, and
introduces a new credit valuation adjustment (CVA) risk
RWA calculation for the Expanded Risk-Based Approach.
Separately, the Federal Reserve also proposed a rule to revise
the G-SIB surcharge. The proposals are currently open for
comment. We continue to evaluate the impact of the
proposed rules, but we preliminarily estimate that these rules,
if adopted as proposed and if our assets and liabilities remain
largely consistent with those as of September 2023, our
regulatory capital requirements could increase by
approximately 25% on a fully phased-in basis.
Other Matters
Replacement of Interbank Offered Rates (IBORs),
including LIBOR. As of July 1, 2023, the publication of all
LIBOR settings as representative rates has ceased. The FCA
has allowed the publication and use of synthetic rates for
certain GBP LIBOR settings in legacy GBP LIBOR-based
contracts through March 2024 and for certain USD LIBOR
settings in legacy USD LIBOR-based contracts through
September 2024. We have facilitated an orderly transition
from LIBOR to alternative risk-free reference rates for us and
our clients, and our LIBOR-based derivative contracts,
unsecured benchmark debt, preferred stocks and loans have
been transitioned to alternative risk-free reference rates in
accordance with the applicable rules in connection with the
cessation of LIBOR.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
139 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 141 of 205 --

Off-Balance Sheet Arrangements
In the ordinary course of business, we enter into various types
of off-balance sheet arrangements. Our involvement in these
arrangements can take many different forms, including:
• Purchasing or retaining residual and other interests in
special purpose entities, such as mortgage-backed and
other asset-backed securitization vehicles;
• Holding senior and subordinated debt, interests in limited
and general partnerships, and preferred and common stock
in other nonconsolidated vehicles;
• Entering into interest rate, foreign currency, equity,
commodity and credit derivatives, including total return
swaps; and
• Providing guarantees, indemnifications, commitments,
letters of credit and representations and warranties.
We enter into these arrangements for a variety of business
purposes, including securitizations. The securitization
vehicles that purchase mortgages, corporate bonds and other
types of financial assets are critical to the functioning of
several significant investor markets, including the mortgage-
backed and other asset-backed securities markets, since they
offer investors access to specific cash flows and risks created
through the securitization process.
We also enter into these arrangements to underwrite client
securitization transactions; provide secondary market
liquidity; make investments in performing and
nonperforming debt, distressed loans, power-related assets,
equity securities, real estate and other assets; and provide
investors with credit-linked and asset-repackaged notes.
The table below presents where information about our
various off-balance sheet arrangements may be found in this
Form 10-Q. In addition, see Note 3 to the consolidated
financial statements for information about our consolidation
policies.
Off-Balance Sheet Arrangement Disclosure in Form 10-Q
Variable interests and other
obligations, including contingent
obligations, arising from variable
interests in nonconsolidated
variable interest entities
See Note 17 to the consolidated
financial statements.
Guarantees, and lending and other
commitments
See Note 18 to the consolidated
financial statements.
Derivatives See “Risk Management —
Credit Risk Management —
Credit Exposures — OTC
Derivatives” and Notes 4, 5, 7
and 18 to the consolidated
financial statements.
Risk Management
Risks are inherent in our businesses and include liquidity,
market, credit, operational, model, legal, compliance,
conduct, regulatory and reputational risks. For further
information about our risk management processes, see
“Overview and Structure of Risk Management,” and for
information about our areas of risk, see “Liquidity Risk
Management,” “Market Risk Management,” “Credit Risk
Management,” “Operational Risk Management,” “Model
Risk Management” and “Other Risk Management,” as well
as “Risk Factors” in Part I, Item 1A of the 2022 Form 10-K.
Overview and Structure of Risk Management
Overview
We believe that effective risk management is critical to our
success. Accordingly, we have established an enterprise risk
management framework that employs a comprehensive,
integrated approach to risk management, and is designed to
enable comprehensive risk management processes through
which we identify, assess, monitor and manage the risks we
assume in conducting our activities. Our risk management
structure is built around three core components: governance,
processes and people.
Governance. Risk management governance starts with the
Board, which both directly and through its committees,
including its Risk Committee, oversees our risk management
policies and practices implemented through the enterprise
risk management framework. The Board is also responsible
for the annual review and approval of our risk appetite
statement. The risk appetite statement describes the levels
and types of risk we are willing to accept or to avoid in order
to achieve our objectives included in our strategic business
plan, while remaining in compliance with regulatory
requirements. The Board reviews our strategic business plan
and is ultimately responsible for overseeing and providing
direction about our strategy and risk appetite.
The Board, including through its committees, receives regular
briefings on firmwide risks, including liquidity risk, market
risk, credit risk, operational risk, model risk and climate risk,
from our independent risk oversight and control functions,
including the chief risk officer, and on compliance risk and
conduct risk from the chief compliance officer, on legal and
regulatory enforcement matters from the chief legal officer,
and on other matters impacting our reputation from the chair
and vice-chairs of our Firmwide Reputational Risk
Committee. The chief risk officer reports to our chief
executive officer and to the Risk Committee of the Board. As
part of the review of the firmwide risk portfolio, the chief
risk officer regularly advises the Risk Committee of the
Board of relevant risk metrics and material exposures,
including risk limits and thresholds established in our risk
appetite statement.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 140

-- 142 of 205 --

The implementation of our risk governance structure and
core risk management processes is overseen by Enterprise
Risk, which reports to our chief risk officer, and is
responsible for ensuring that our enterprise risk management
framework provides the Board, our risk committees and
senior management with a consistent and integrated
approach to managing our various risks in a manner
consistent with our risk appetite.
Our revenue-producing units, as well as Treasury,
Engineering, Human Capital Management, Operations, and
Corporate and Workplace Solutions, are considered our first
line of defense. They are accountable for the outcomes of our
risk-generating activities, as well as for assessing and
managing those risks within our risk appetite.
Our independent risk oversight and control functions are
considered our second line of defense and provide
independent assessment, oversight and challenge of the risks
taken by our first line of defense, as well as lead and
participate in risk committees. Independent risk oversight
and control functions include Compliance, Conflicts
Resolution, Controllers, Legal, Risk and Tax.
Internal Audit is considered our third line of defense, and our
director of Internal Audit reports to the Audit Committee of
the Board and administratively to our chief executive officer.
Internal Audit includes professionals with a broad range of
audit and industry experience, including risk management
expertise. Internal Audit is responsible for independently
assessing and validating the effectiveness of key controls,
including those within the risk management framework, and
providing timely reporting to the Audit Committee of the
Board, senior management and regulators.
The three lines of defense structure promotes the
accountability of first line risk takers, provides a framework
for effective challenge by the second line and empowers
independent review from the third line.
Processes. We maintain various processes that are critical
components of our risk management framework, including
(i) risk identification and control assessment, (ii) risk
appetite, limit and threshold setting, (iii) risk metrics,
reporting and monitoring, and (iv) risk decision-making.
• Risk Identification and Control Assessment. We
believe the identification of our risks and related control
assessment is a critical step in providing our Board and
senior management transparency and insight into the range
and materiality of our risks. We have a comprehensive data
collection process, including firmwide policies and
procedures that require all employees to report and escalate
risk events. Our approach for risk identification and
control assessment is comprehensive across all risk types, is
dynamic and forward-looking to reflect and adapt to our
changing risk profile and business environment, leverages
subject matter expertise, and allows for prioritization of
our most critical risks. This approach also encompasses
our control assessment, led by our second line of defense,
to review and challenge the control environment to ensure
it supports our strategic business plan.
To effectively assess our risks, we maintain a daily
discipline of marking substantially all of our inventory to
current market levels. We carry our inventory at fair value,
with changes in valuation reflected immediately in our risk
management systems and in net revenues. We do so
because we believe this discipline is one of the most
effective tools for assessing and managing risk and that it
provides transparent and realistic insight into our inventory
exposures.
An important part of our risk management process is
firmwide stress testing. It allows us to quantify our
exposure to tail risks, highlight potential loss
concentrations, undertake risk/reward analysis, and assess
and mitigate our risk positions. Firmwide stress tests are
performed on a regular basis and are designed to ensure a
comprehensive analysis of our vulnerabilities and
idiosyncratic risks combining financial and nonfinancial
risks, including, but not limited to, credit, market, liquidity
and funding, operational and compliance, strategic,
systemic and emerging risks into a single combined
scenario. We also perform ad hoc stress tests in
anticipation of market events or conditions. Stress tests are
also used to assess capital adequacy as part of our capital
planning and stress testing process. See “Capital
Management and Regulatory Capital — Capital
Management” for further information.
• Risk Appetite, Limit and Threshold Setting. We apply
a rigorous framework of limits and thresholds to control
and monitor risk across transactions, products, businesses
and markets. The Board, directly or indirectly through its
Risk Committee, approves limits and thresholds included
in our risk appetite statement at firmwide, business and
product levels. In addition, the Firmwide Risk Appetite
Committee, through delegated authority from the
Firmwide Enterprise Risk Committee, is responsible for
approving our risk limits and thresholds policy, subject to
the overall limits approved by the Risk Committee of the
Board, and monitoring these limits.
The Firmwide Risk Appetite Committee is responsible for
approving limits at firmwide, business and product levels.
Certain limits may be set at levels that will require periodic
adjustment, rather than at levels that reflect our maximum
risk appetite. This fosters an ongoing dialogue about risk
among our first and second lines of defense, committees
and senior management, as well as rapid escalation of risk-
related matters. Additionally, through delegated authority
from the Firmwide Risk Appetite Committee, Market Risk
sets limits at certain product and desk levels, and Credit
Risk sets limits for individual counterparties and their
subsidiaries, industries and countries. Limits are reviewed
regularly and amended on a permanent or temporary basis
to reflect changes to our strategic business plan, as well as
changing market conditions, business conditions or risk
tolerance.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
141 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 143 of 205 --

• Risk Metrics, Reporting and Monitoring. Effective risk
reporting and risk decision-making depends on our ability
to get the right information to the right people at the right
time. As such, we focus on the rigor and effectiveness of
our risk systems, with the objective of ensuring that our
risk management technology systems provide us with
complete, accurate and timely information. Our risk
metrics, reporting and monitoring processes are designed to
take into account information about both existing and
emerging risks, thereby enabling our risk committees and
senior management to perform their responsibilities with
the appropriate level of insight into risk exposures.
Furthermore, our limit and threshold breach processes
provide means for timely escalation. We evaluate changes
in our risk profile and our businesses, including changes in
business mix or jurisdictions in which we operate, by
monitoring risk factors at a firmwide level.
• Risk Decision-Making. Our governance structure
provides the protocol and responsibility for decision-
making on risk management issues and ensures
implementation of those decisions. We make extensive use
of risk committees that meet regularly and serve as an
important means to facilitate and foster ongoing
discussions to manage and mitigate risks.
We maintain strong and proactive communication about
risk and we have a culture of collaboration in decision-
making among our first and second lines of defense,
committees and senior management. While our first line of
defense is responsible for management of their risk, we
dedicate extensive resources to our second line of defense in
order to ensure a strong oversight structure and an
appropriate segregation of duties. We regularly reinforce
our strong culture of escalation and accountability across
all functions.
People. Even the best technology serves only as a tool for
helping to make informed decisions in real time about the
risks we are taking. Ultimately, effective risk management
requires our people to interpret our risk data on an ongoing
and timely basis and adjust risk positions accordingly. The
experience of our professionals, and their understanding of
the nuances and limitations of each risk measure, guides us in
assessing exposures and maintaining them within prudent
levels.
We reinforce a culture of effective risk management,
consistent with our risk appetite, in our training and
development programs, as well as in the way we evaluate
performance, and recognize and reward our people. Our
training and development programs, including certain
sessions led by our most senior leaders, are focused on the
importance of risk management, client relationships and
reputational excellence. As part of our performance review
process, we assess reputational excellence, including how an
employee exercises good risk management and reputational
judgment, and adheres to our code of conduct and
compliance policies. Our review and reward processes are
designed to communicate and reinforce to our professionals
the link between behavior and how people are recognized,
the need to focus on our clients and our reputation, and the
need to always act in accordance with our highest standards.
Structure
Ultimate oversight of risk is the responsibility of our Board.
The Board oversees risk both directly and through its
committees, including its Risk Committee. We also have a
series of committees with specific risk management mandates
that have oversight or decision-making responsibilities for
risk management activities. Committee membership generally
consists of senior managers from both our first and second
lines of defense. We have established procedures for these
committees to ensure that appropriate information barriers
are in place. Our primary risk committees, most of which
also have additional sub-committees, councils or working
groups, are described below. In addition to these committees,
we have other risk committees that provide oversight for
different businesses, activities, products, regions and entities.
All of our committees have responsibility for considering the
impact on our reputation of the transactions and activities
that they oversee.
Membership of our risk committees is reviewed regularly and
updated to reflect changes in the responsibilities of the
committee members. Accordingly, the length of time that
members serve on the respective committees varies as
determined by the committee chairs and based on the
responsibilities of the members.
The chart below presents an overview of our risk
management governance structure.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 142

-- 144 of 205 --

Management Committee. The Management Committee
oversees our global activities. It provides this oversight
directly and through authority delegated to committees it has
established. This committee consists of our most senior
leaders, and is chaired by our chief executive officer. Most
members of the Management Committee are also members of
other committees. The following are the committees that are
principally involved in firmwide risk management.
Firmwide Enterprise Risk Committee. The Firmwide
Enterprise Risk Committee is responsible for overseeing all of
our financial and nonfinancial risks. As part of such
oversight, the committee is responsible for the ongoing
review, approval and monitoring of our enterprise risk
management framework, as well as our risk limits and
thresholds policy, through delegated authority to the
Firmwide Risk Appetite Committee. The Firmwide
Enterprise Risk Committee also reviews new significant
strategic business initiatives to determine whether they are
consistent with our risk appetite and risk management
capabilities. Additionally, the Firmwide Enterprise Risk
Committee performs enhanced reviews of significant risk
events, the top residual and emerging risks, and the overall
risk and control environment in each of our business units in
order to propose uplifts, identify elements that are common
to all business units and analyze the consolidated residual
risks that we face. This committee, which reports to the
Management Committee, is co-chaired by our president and
chief operating officer and our chief risk officer, who are
appointed as chairs by our chief executive officer, and the
vice-chair is our chief financial officer, who is appointed as
vice-chair by the chairs of the Firmwide Enterprise Risk
Committee. The following are the primary committees or
councils that report to the Firmwide Enterprise Risk
Committee (unless otherwise noted):
• Firmwide Risk Council. The Firmwide Risk Council is
responsible for the ongoing monitoring of relevant
financial risks and related risk limits at the firmwide,
business and product levels. This council is co-chaired by
our chief financial officer and our chief risk officer.
• Firmwide New Activity Committee. The Firmwide
New Activity Committee is responsible for reviewing new
activities and for establishing a process to identify and
review previously approved activities that are significant
and that have changed in complexity and/or structure or
present different reputational and suitability concerns over
time to consider whether these activities remain
appropriate. This committee is chaired by our controller
and chief accounting officer, who is appointed as chair by
the chairs of the Firmwide Enterprise Risk Committee.
• Firmwide Operational Risk and Resilience
Committee. The Firmwide Operational Risk and
Resilience Committee is responsible for overseeing
operational risk, and for ensuring our business and
operational resilience. To assist the Firmwide Operational
Risk and Resilience Committee in carrying out its mandate,
other risk committees with dedicated oversight for
technology-related risks, including cybersecurity matters
and artificial intelligence, report into the Firmwide
Operational Risk and Resilience Committee. This
committee is co-chaired by our chief administrative officer
for EMEA and our head of Operational Risk, who are
appointed as chairs by the chairs of the Firmwide
Enterprise Risk Committee.
• Firmwide Conduct Committee. The Firmwide Conduct
Committee is responsible for the ongoing approval and
monitoring of the frameworks and policies which govern
our conduct risks. Conduct risk is the risk that our people
fail to act in a manner consistent with our Business
Principles and related core values, policies or codes, or
applicable laws or regulations, thereby falling short in
fulfilling their responsibilities to us, our clients, colleagues,
other market participants or the broader community. This
committee is chaired by our chief legal officer, who is
appointed as chair by the chairs of the Firmwide Enterprise
Risk Committee.
• Firmwide Risk Appetite Committee. The Firmwide
Risk Appetite Committee (through delegated authority
from the Firmwide Enterprise Risk Committee) is
responsible for the ongoing approval and monitoring of
risk frameworks, policies and parameters related to our
core risk management processes, as well as limits and
thresholds, at firmwide, business and product levels. In
addition, this committee is responsible for overseeing our
financial risks and reviews the results of stress tests and
scenario analyses. To assist the Firmwide Risk Appetite
Committee in carrying out its mandate, a number of other
risk committees with dedicated oversight for stress testing,
model risks, Volcker Rule compliance, as well as our
investments or other capital commitments that may give
rise to financial risk, report into the Firmwide Risk
Appetite Committee. This committee is chaired by our
chief risk officer, who is appointed as chair by the chairs of
the Firmwide Enterprise Risk Committee. The Firmwide
Capital Committee and Firmwide Commitments
Committee report to the Firmwide Risk Appetite
Committee.
Firmwide Capital Committee. The Firmwide Capital
Committee provides approval and oversight of debt-related
transactions, including principal commitments of our
capital. This committee aims to ensure that business,
reputational and suitability standards for underwritings
and capital commitments are maintained on a global basis.
This committee is co-chaired by our head of Credit Risk
and a co-head of our Global Financing Group, who are
appointed as chairs by the chair of the Firmwide Risk
Appetite Committee.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
143 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 145 of 205 --

Firmwide Commitments Committee. The Firmwide
Commitments Committee reviews our underwriting and
distribution activities with respect to equity and equity-
related product offerings, and sets and maintains policies
and procedures designed to ensure that legal, reputational,
regulatory and business standards are maintained on a
global basis. In addition to reviewing specific transactions,
this committee periodically conducts general strategic
reviews of sectors and products and establishes policies in
connection with transaction practices. This committee is
co-chaired by our chief equity underwriting officer for the
Americas, a co-chairman of our Global Financial
Institutions Group, and a co-head of our Global
Investment Grade Capital Markets and Risk Management
Group in Global Banking & Markets, who are appointed
as chairs by the chair of the Firmwide Risk Appetite
Committee.
• Firmwide Reputational Risk Committee. The
Firmwide Reputational Risk Committee is responsible for
assessing reputational risks arising from opportunities that
have been identified as having potential heightened
reputational risk, including transactions identified
pursuant to the criteria established by the Firmwide
Reputational Risk Committee and as determined by
committee leadership. This committee is also responsible
for overseeing client-related business standards and
addressing client-related reputational risk. This committee
is chaired by our president and chief operating officer, who
is appointed as chair by our chief executive officer, and the
vice-chairs are our chief legal officer and the head of
Conflicts Resolution, who are appointed as vice-chairs by
the chair of the Firmwide Reputational Risk Committee.
This committee periodically provides updates to, and
receives guidance from, the Public Responsibilities
Committee of the Board. The Firmwide Suitability
Committee reports to the Firmwide Reputational Risk
Committee.
Firmwide Suitability Committee. The Firmwide
Suitability Committee is responsible for setting standards
and policies for product, transaction and client suitability
and providing a forum for consistency across functions,
regions and products on suitability assessments. This
committee also reviews suitability matters escalated from
other committees. This committee is co-chaired by our
chief compliance officer and the head of Net Zero
Transition Solutions in Global Banking & Markets, who
are appointed as chairs by the chair of the Firmwide
Reputational Risk Committee.
Firmwide Asset Liability Committee. The Firmwide
Asset Liability Committee reviews and approves the strategic
direction for our financial resources, including capital,
liquidity, funding and balance sheet. This committee has
oversight responsibility for asset liability management,
including interest rate and currency risk, funds transfer
pricing, capital allocation and incentives, and credit ratings.
This committee makes recommendations as to any
adjustments to asset liability management and financial
resource allocation in light of current events, risks,
exposures, and regulatory requirements and approves related
policies. This committee is co-chaired by our chief financial
officer and our global treasurer, who are appointed as chairs
by our chief executive officer, and reports to the
Management Committee.
Liquidity Risk Management
Overview
Liquidity risk is the risk that we will be unable to fund
ourselves or meet our liquidity needs in the event of firm-
specific, broader industry or market liquidity stress events.
We have in place a comprehensive and conservative set of
liquidity and funding policies. Our principal objective is to be
able to fund ourselves and to enable our core businesses to
continue to serve clients and generate revenues, even under
adverse circumstances.
Treasury, which reports to our chief financial officer, has
primary responsibility for developing, managing and
executing our liquidity and funding strategy within our risk
appetite.
Liquidity Risk, which is independent of our revenue-
producing units and Treasury, and reports to our chief risk
officer, has primary responsibility for identifying, monitoring
and managing our liquidity risk through firmwide oversight
across our global businesses and the establishment of stress
testing and limits frameworks.
Liquidity Risk Management Principles
We manage liquidity risk according to three principles: (i)
hold sufficient excess liquidity in the form of GCLA to cover
outflows during a stressed period, (ii) maintain appropriate
Asset-Liability Management and (iii) maintain a viable
Contingency Funding Plan.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 144

-- 146 of 205 --

GCLA. GCLA is liquidity that we maintain to meet a broad
range of potential cash outflows and collateral needs in a
stressed environment. A primary liquidity principle is to pre-
fund our estimated potential cash and collateral needs during
a liquidity crisis and hold this liquidity in the form of
unencumbered, highly liquid securities and cash. We believe
that the securities held in our GCLA would be readily
convertible to cash in a matter of days, through liquidation,
by entering into repurchase agreements or from maturities of
resale agreements, and that this cash would allow us to meet
immediate obligations without needing to sell other assets or
depend on additional funding from credit-sensitive markets.
Our GCLA reflects the following principles:
• The first days or weeks of a liquidity crisis are the most
critical to a company’s survival;
• Focus must be maintained on all potential cash and
collateral outflows, not just disruptions to financing flows.
Our businesses are diverse, and our liquidity needs are
determined by many factors, including market movements,
collateral requirements and client commitments, all of
which can change dramatically in a difficult funding
environment;
• During a liquidity crisis, credit-sensitive funding, including
unsecured debt, certain deposits and some types of secured
financing agreements, may be unavailable, and the terms
(e.g., interest rates, collateral provisions and tenor) or
availability of other types of secured financing may change
and certain deposits may be withdrawn; and
• As a result of our policy to pre-fund liquidity that we
estimate may be needed in a crisis, we hold more
unencumbered securities and have larger funding balances
than our businesses would otherwise require. We believe
that our liquidity is stronger with greater balances of highly
liquid unencumbered securities, even though it increases
our total assets and our funding costs.
We maintain our GCLA across Group Inc., Goldman Sachs
Funding LLC (Funding IHC) and Group Inc.’s major broker-
dealer and bank subsidiaries, asset types and clearing agents
to provide us with sufficient operating liquidity to ensure
timely settlement in all major markets, even in a difficult
funding environment. In addition to the GCLA, we maintain
cash balances and securities in several of our other entities,
primarily for use in specific currencies, entities or
jurisdictions where we do not have immediate access to
parent company liquidity.
Asset-Liability Management. Our liquidity risk
management policies are designed to ensure we have a
sufficient amount of financing, even when funding markets
experience persistent stress. We manage the maturities and
diversity of our funding across markets, products and
counterparties, and seek to maintain a diversified funding
profile with an appropriate tenor, taking into consideration
the characteristics and liquidity profile of our assets.
Our approach to asset-liability management includes:
• Conservatively managing the overall characteristics of our
funding book, with a focus on maintaining long-term,
diversified sources of funding in excess of our current
requirements. See “Balance Sheet and Funding Sources —
Funding Sources” for further information;
• Actively managing and monitoring our asset base, with
particular focus on the liquidity, holding period and ability
to fund assets on a secured basis. We assess our funding
requirements and our ability to liquidate assets in a stressed
environment while appropriately managing risk. This
enables us to determine the most appropriate funding
products and tenors. See “Balance Sheet and Funding
Sources — Balance Sheet Management” for further
information about our balance sheet management process
and “— Funding Sources — Secured Funding” for further
information about asset classes that may be harder to fund
on a secured basis; and
• Raising secured and unsecured financing that has a long
tenor relative to the liquidity profile of our assets. This
reduces the risk that our liabilities will come due in
advance of our ability to generate liquidity from the sale of
our assets. Because we maintain a highly liquid balance
sheet, the holding period of certain of our assets may be
materially shorter than their contractual maturity dates.
Our goal is to ensure that we maintain sufficient liquidity to
fund our assets and meet our contractual and contingent
obligations in normal times, as well as during periods of
market stress. Through our dynamic balance sheet
management process, we use actual and projected asset
balances to determine secured and unsecured funding
requirements. Funding plans are reviewed and approved by
the Firmwide Asset Liability Committee. In addition, our
independent risk oversight and control functions analyze, and
the Firmwide Asset Liability Committee reviews, our
consolidated total capital position (unsecured long-term
borrowings plus total shareholders’ equity) so that we
maintain a level of long-term funding that is sufficient to
meet our long-term financing requirements. In a liquidity
crisis, we would first use our GCLA in order to avoid reliance
on asset sales (other than our GCLA). However, we recognize
that orderly asset sales may be prudent or necessary in a
severe or persistent liquidity crisis.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
145 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 147 of 205 --

Subsidiary Funding Policies
The majority of our unsecured borrowings is raised by Group
Inc., which provides the necessary funds to Funding IHC and
other subsidiaries, some of which are regulated, to meet their
asset financing, liquidity and capital requirements. In
addition, Group Inc. provides its regulated subsidiaries with
the necessary capital to meet their regulatory requirements.
The benefits of this approach to subsidiary funding are
enhanced control and greater flexibility to meet the funding
requirements of our subsidiaries. Funding is also raised at the
subsidiary level through a variety of products, including
deposits, secured funding and unsecured borrowings.
Our intercompany funding policies assume that a subsidiary’s
funds or securities are not freely available to its parent,
Funding IHC or other subsidiaries unless (i) legally provided
for and (ii) there are no additional regulatory, tax or other
restrictions. In particular, many of our subsidiaries are
subject to laws that authorize regulatory bodies to block or
reduce the flow of funds from those subsidiaries to Group
Inc. or Funding IHC. Regulatory action of that kind could
impede access to funds that Group Inc. needs to make
payments on its obligations. Accordingly, we assume that the
capital provided to our regulated subsidiaries is not available
to Group Inc. or other subsidiaries and any other financing
provided to our regulated subsidiaries is not available to
Group Inc. or Funding IHC until the maturity of such
financing.
Group Inc. has provided substantial amounts of equity and
subordinated indebtedness, directly or indirectly, to its
regulated subsidiaries. For example, as of September 2023,
Group Inc. had $37.44 billion of equity and subordinated
indebtedness invested in GS&Co., its principal U.S.
registered broker-dealer; $48.77 billion invested in GSI, a
regulated U.K. broker-dealer; $2.29 billion invested in
GSJCL, a regulated Japanese broker-dealer; $55.33 billion
invested in GS Bank USA, a regulated New York State-
chartered bank; and $4.72 billion invested in GSIB, a
regulated U.K. bank. Group Inc. also provides financing,
directly or indirectly, in the form of: $96.60 billion of
unsubordinated loans (including secured loans of
$21.11 billion) and $43.03 billion of collateral and cash
deposits to these entities as of September 2023. In addition, as
of September 2023, Group Inc. had significant amounts of
capital invested in and loans to its other regulated
subsidiaries.
Contingency Funding Plan. We maintain a contingency
funding plan to provide a framework for analyzing and
responding to a liquidity crisis situation or periods of market
stress. Our contingency funding plan outlines a list of
potential risk factors, key reports and metrics that are
reviewed on an ongoing basis to assist in assessing the
severity of, and managing through, a liquidity crisis and/or
market dislocation. The contingency funding plan also
describes in detail our potential responses if our assessments
indicate that we have entered a liquidity crisis, which include
pre-funding for what we estimate will be our potential cash
and collateral needs, as well as utilizing secondary sources of
liquidity. Mitigants and action items to address specific risks
which may arise are also described and assigned to
individuals responsible for execution.
The contingency funding plan identifies key groups of
individuals and their responsibilities, which include fostering
effective coordination, control and distribution of
information, implementing liquidity maintenance activities
and managing internal and external communication, all of
which are critical in the management of a crisis or period of
market stress.
Stress Tests
In order to determine the appropriate size of our GCLA, we
model liquidity outflows over a range of scenarios and time
horizons. One of our primary internal liquidity risk models,
referred to as the Modeled Liquidity Outflow, quantifies our
liquidity risks over a 30-day stress scenario. We also consider
other factors, including, but not limited to, an assessment of
our potential intraday liquidity needs through an additional
internal liquidity risk model, referred to as the Intraday
Liquidity Model, the results of our long-term stress testing
models, our resolution liquidity models and other applicable
regulatory requirements and a qualitative assessment of our
condition, as well as the financial markets. The results of the
Modeled Liquidity Outflow, the Intraday Liquidity Model,
the long-term stress testing models and the resolution
liquidity models are reported to senior management on a
regular basis. We also perform firmwide stress tests. See
“Overview and Structure of Risk Management” for
information about firmwide stress tests.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 146

-- 148 of 205 --

Modeled Liquidity Outflow. Our Modeled Liquidity
Outflow is based on conducting multiple scenarios that
include combinations of market-wide and firm-specific stress.
These scenarios are characterized by the following qualitative
elements:
• Severely challenged market environments, which include
low consumer and corporate confidence, financial and
political instability, and adverse changes in market values,
including potential declines in equity markets and widening
of credit spreads; and
• A firm-specific crisis potentially triggered by material
losses, reputational damage, litigation and/or a ratings
downgrade.
The following are key modeling elements of our Modeled
Liquidity Outflow:
• Liquidity needs over a 30-day scenario;
• A two-notch downgrade of our long-term senior unsecured
credit ratings;
• Changing conditions in funding markets, which limit our
access to unsecured and secured funding;
• No support from additional government funding facilities.
Although we have access to various central bank funding
programs, we do not assume reliance on additional sources
of funding in a liquidity crisis; and
• A combination of contractual outflows and contingent
outflows arising from both our on- and off-balance sheet
arrangements. Contractual outflows include, among other
things, upcoming maturities of unsecured debt, term
deposits and secured funding. Contingent outflows include,
among other things, the withdrawal of customer credit
balances in our prime brokerage business, increase in
variation margin requirements due to adverse changes in
the value of our exchange-traded and OTC-cleared
derivatives, draws on unfunded commitments and
withdrawals of deposits that have no contractual maturity.
See notes to the consolidated financial statements for
further information about contractual outflows, including
Note 11 for collateralized financings, Note 13 for deposits,
Note 14 for unsecured long-term borrowings and Note 15
for operating lease payments, and “Off-Balance Sheet
Arrangements” for further information about our various
types of off-balance sheet arrangements.
Intraday Liquidity Model. Our Intraday Liquidity Model
measures our intraday liquidity needs in a scenario where
access to sources of intraday liquidity may become
constrained. The intraday liquidity model considers a variety
of factors, including historical settlement activity.
Long-Term Stress Testing. We utilize longer-term stress
tests to take a forward view on our liquidity position through
prolonged stress periods in which we experience a severe
liquidity stress and recover in an environment that continues
to be challenging. We are focused on ensuring conservative
asset-liability management to prepare for a prolonged period
of potential stress, seeking to maintain a diversified funding
profile with an appropriate tenor, taking into consideration
the characteristics and liquidity profile of our assets.
Resolution Liquidity Models. In connection with our
resolution planning efforts, we have established our
Resolution Liquidity Adequacy and Positioning framework,
which estimates liquidity needs of our major subsidiaries in a
stressed environment. The liquidity needs are measured using
our Modeled Liquidity Outflow assumptions and include
certain additional inter-affiliate exposures. We have also
established our Resolution Liquidity Execution Need
framework, which measures the liquidity needs of our major
subsidiaries to stabilize and wind down following a Group
Inc. bankruptcy filing in accordance with our preferred
resolution strategy.
In addition, we have established a triggers and alerts
framework, which is designed to provide the Board with
information needed to make an informed decision on
whether and when to commence bankruptcy proceedings for
Group Inc.
Limits
We use liquidity risk limits at various levels and across
liquidity risk types to manage the size of our liquidity
exposures. Limits are measured relative to acceptable levels
of risk given our liquidity risk tolerance. See “Overview and
Structure of Risk Management” for information about the
limit approval process.
Limits are monitored by Treasury and Liquidity Risk.
Liquidity Risk is responsible for identifying and escalating to
senior management and/or the appropriate risk committee,
on a timely basis, instances where limits have been exceeded.
GCLA and Unencumbered Metrics
GCLA. Based on the results of our internal liquidity risk
models, described above, as well as our consideration of
other factors, including, but not limited to, a qualitative
assessment of our condition, as well as the financial markets,
we believe our liquidity position as of both September 2023
and December 2022 was appropriate. We strictly limit our
GCLA to a narrowly defined list of securities and cash
because they are highly liquid, even in a difficult funding
environment. We do not include other potential sources of
excess liquidity in our GCLA, such as less liquid
unencumbered securities or committed credit facilities.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
147 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 149 of 205 --

The table below presents information about our GCLA.
Average for the
Three Months Ended
September June
$ in millions 2023 2023
Denomination
U.S. dollar $ 274,279 $ 290,232
Non-U.S. dollar 131,425 119,417
Total $ 405,704 $ 409,649
Asset Class
Overnight cash deposits $ 243,478 $ 238,560
U.S. government obligations 120,301 138,231
U.S. agency obligations 17,290 12,835
Non-U.S. government obligations 24,635 20,023
Total $ 405,704 $ 409,649
Entity Type
Group Inc. and Funding IHC $ 61,014 $ 72,470
Major broker-dealer subsidiaries 116,077 114,777
Major bank subsidiaries 228,613 222,402
Total $ 405,704 $ 409,649
In the table above:
• The U.S. dollar-denominated GCLA consists of (i)
unencumbered U.S. government and agency obligations
(including highly liquid U.S. agency mortgage-backed
obligations), all of which are eligible as collateral in Federal
Reserve open market operations and (ii) certain overnight
U.S. dollar cash deposits.
• The non-U.S. dollar-denominated GCLA consists of non-
U.S. government obligations (only unencumbered German,
French, Japanese and U.K. government obligations) and
certain overnight cash deposits in highly liquid currencies.
We maintain our GCLA to enable us to meet current and
potential liquidity requirements of our parent company,
Group Inc., and its subsidiaries. Our Modeled Liquidity
Outflow and Intraday Liquidity Model incorporate a
requirement for Group Inc., as well as a standalone
requirement for each of our major broker-dealer and bank
subsidiaries. Funding IHC is required to provide the
necessary liquidity to Group Inc. during the ordinary course
of business, and is also obligated to provide capital and
liquidity support to major subsidiaries in the event of our
material financial distress or failure. Liquidity held directly in
each of our major broker-dealer and bank subsidiaries is
intended for use only by that subsidiary to meet its liquidity
requirements and is assumed not to be available to Group
Inc. or Funding IHC unless (i) legally provided for and (ii)
there are no additional regulatory, tax or other restrictions.
In addition, the Modeled Liquidity Outflow and Intraday
Liquidity Model also incorporate a broader assessment of
standalone liquidity requirements for other subsidiaries and
we hold a portion of our GCLA directly at Group Inc. or
Funding IHC to support such requirements.
Other Unencumbered Assets. In addition to our GCLA,
we have a significant amount of other unencumbered cash
and financial instruments, including other government
obligations, high-grade money market securities, corporate
obligations, marginable equities, loans and cash deposits not
included in our GCLA. The fair value of our unencumbered
assets averaged $278.41 billion for the three months ended
September 2023 and $277.04 billion for the three months
ended June 2023. We do not consider these assets liquid
enough to be eligible for our GCLA.
Liquidity Regulatory Framework
We are subject to a minimum Liquidity Coverage Ratio
(LCR) under the LCR rule approved by the U.S. federal bank
regulatory agencies. The LCR rule requires organizations to
maintain an adequate ratio of eligible high-quality liquid
assets (HQLA) to expected net cash outflows under an acute,
short-term liquidity stress scenario. Eligible HQLA excludes
HQLA held by subsidiaries that is in excess of their minimum
requirement and is subject to transfer restrictions. We are
required to maintain a minimum LCR of 100%. We expect
that fluctuations in client activity, business mix and the
market environment will impact our LCR.
The table below presents information about our average
daily LCR.
Average for the
Three Months Ended
September June
$ in millions 2023 2023
Total HQLA $ 397,758 $ 405,552
Eligible HQLA $ 316,291 $ 330,507
Net cash outflows $ 253,238 $ 262,258
LCR 125% 126%
In the table above, our average quarterly LCR represents the
average of our daily LCRs during the quarter.
We are also subject to a minimum Net Stable Funding Ratio
(NSFR) under the NSFR rule approved by the U.S. federal
bank regulatory agencies. The NSFR rule requires large U.S.
banking organizations to maintain available stable funding
(ASF) above their required stable funding (RSF) over a one-
year time horizon. Total ASF excludes ASF held by
subsidiaries that is in excess of their minimum requirement
and is subject to transfer restrictions. We are required to
maintain a minimum NSFR of 100%. We expect that
fluctuations in client activity, business mix and the market
environment will impact our NSFR.
The table below presents information about our average
daily NSFR.
Average for the
Three Months Ended
September June
$ in millions 2023 2023
Total ASF $ 617,341 $ 621,274
Total RSF $ 529,635 $ 547,907
NSFR 117% 113%
In the table above, our average quarterly NSFR represents the
average of our daily NSFRs during the quarter.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 148

-- 150 of 205 --

The following provides information about our subsidiary
liquidity regulatory requirements:
• GS Bank USA. GS Bank USA is subject to a minimum
LCR of 100% under the LCR rule approved by the U.S.
federal bank regulatory agencies. As of September 2023, GS
Bank USA’s LCR exceeded the minimum requirement. The
NSFR requirement described above also applies to GS
Bank USA. As of September 2023, GS Bank USA’s NSFR
exceeded the minimum requirement.
• GSI and GSIB. GSI and GSIB are subject to a minimum
LCR of 100% under the LCR rule approved by the U.K.
regulatory authorities. GSI’s and GSIB’s average monthly
LCR for the trailing twelve-month period ended September
2023 exceeded the minimum requirement. GSI and GSIB
are subject to the applicable NSFR requirement in the U.K.
As of September 2023, both GSI’s and GSIB’s NSFR
exceeded the minimum requirement.
• GSBE. GSBE is subject to a minimum LCR of 100% under
the LCR rule approved by the European Parliament and
Council. GSBE’s average monthly LCR for the trailing
twelve-month period ended September 2023 exceeded the
minimum requirement. GSBE is subject to the applicable
NSFR requirement in the E.U. As of September 2023,
GSBE’s NSFR exceeded the minimum requirement.
• Other Subsidiaries. We monitor local regulatory
liquidity requirements of our subsidiaries to ensure
compliance. For many of our subsidiaries, these
requirements either have changed or are likely to change in
the future due to the implementation of the Basel
Committee’s framework for liquidity risk measurement,
standards and monitoring, as well as other regulatory
developments.
The implementation of these rules and any amendments
adopted by the regulatory authorities could impact our
liquidity and funding requirements and practices in the
future.
Credit Ratings
We rely on the short- and long-term debt capital markets to
fund a significant portion of our day-to-day operations, and
the cost and availability of debt financing is influenced by our
credit ratings. Credit ratings are also important when we are
competing in certain markets, such as OTC derivatives, and
when we seek to engage in longer-term transactions. See
“Risk Factors” in Part I, Item 1A of the 2022 Form 10-K for
information about the risks associated with a reduction in
our credit ratings.
The table below presents the unsecured credit ratings and
outlook of Group Inc.
As of September 2023
DBRS Fitch Moody’s R&I S&P
Short-term debt R-1 (middle) F1 P-1 a-1 A-2
Long-term debt A (high) A A2 A BBB+
Subordinated debt A BBB+ Baa2 A- BBB
Trust preferred A BBB- Baa3 N/A BB+
Preferred stock BBB (high) BBB- Ba1 N/A BB+
Ratings outlook Stable Stable Stable Stable Stable
In the table above:
• The ratings and outlook are by DBRS, Inc. (DBRS), Fitch,
Inc. (Fitch), Moody’s Investors Service (Moody’s), Rating
and Investment Information, Inc. (R&I), and Standard &
Poor’s Ratings Services (S&P).
• The ratings for trust preferred relate to the guaranteed
preferred beneficial interests issued by Goldman Sachs
Capital I.
• The DBRS, Fitch, Moody’s and S&P ratings for preferred
stock include the APEX issued by Goldman Sachs Capital
II and Goldman Sachs Capital III.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
149 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 151 of 205 --

The table below presents the unsecured credit ratings and
outlook of GS Bank USA, GSIB, GSBE, GS&Co. and GSI.
As of September 2023
Fitch Moody’s S&P
GS Bank USA
Short-term debt F1 P-1 A-1
Long-term debt A+ A1 A+
Short-term bank deposits F1+ P-1 N/A
Long-term bank deposits AA- A1 N/A
Ratings outlook Stable Stable Stable
GSIB
Short-term debt F1 P-1 A-1
Long-term debt A+ A1 A+
Short-term bank deposits F1 P-1 N/A
Long-term bank deposits A+ A1 N/A
Ratings outlook Stable Stable Stable
GSBE
Short-term debt F1 P-1 A-1
Long-term debt A+ A1 A+
Short-term bank deposits N/A P-1 N/A
Long-term bank deposits N/A A1 N/A
Ratings outlook Stable Stable Stable
GS&Co.
Short-term debt F1 N/A A-1
Long-term debt A+ N/A A+
Ratings outlook Stable N/A Stable
GSI
Short-term debt F1 P-1 A-1
Long-term debt A+ A1 A+
Ratings outlook Stable Stable Stable
We believe our credit ratings are primarily based on the
credit rating agencies’ assessment of:
• Our liquidity, market, credit and operational risk
management practices;
• Our level and variability of earnings;
• Our capital base;
• Our franchise, reputation and management;
• Our corporate governance; and
• The external operating and economic environment,
including, in some cases, the assumed level of government
support or other systemic considerations, such as potential
resolution.
Certain of our derivatives have been transacted under
bilateral agreements with counterparties who may require us
to post collateral or terminate the transactions based on
changes in our credit ratings. We manage our GCLA to
ensure we would, among other potential requirements, be
able to make the additional collateral or termination
payments that may be required in the event of a two-notch
reduction in our long-term credit ratings, as well as collateral
that has not been called by counterparties, but is available to
them.
See Note 7 to the consolidated financial statements for
further information about derivatives with credit-related
contingent features and the additional collateral or
termination payments related to our net derivative liabilities
under bilateral agreements that could have been called by
counterparties in the event of a one- or two-notch downgrade
in our credit ratings.
Cash Flows
As a global financial institution, our cash flows are complex
and bear little relation to our net earnings and net assets.
Consequently, we believe that traditional cash flow analysis
is less meaningful in evaluating our liquidity position than the
liquidity and asset-liability management policies described
above. Cash flow analysis may, however, be helpful in
highlighting certain macro trends and strategic initiatives in
our businesses.
Nine Months Ended September 2023. Our cash and cash
equivalents decreased by $1.95 billion to $239.88 billion at
the end of the third quarter of 2023, primarily due to net cash
used for investing activities and the effect of exchange rate
changes on cash and cash equivalents, partially offset by net
cash provided by operating activities. The net cash used for
investing activities primarily reflected net purchases of
investments (primarily U.S. government obligations
accounted for as held-to-maturity securities). The decrease in
net cash and cash equivalents as a result of changes in foreign
exchange rates was due to the U.S. dollar strengthening
during the first nine months of 2023. The net cash provided
by operating activities primarily reflected cash inflows from
collateralized transactions (reflecting both an increase in
collateralized financings and a decrease in collateralized
agreements), partially offset by cash outflows from trading
assets.
Nine Months Ended September 2022. Our cash and cash
equivalents increased by $23.22 billion to $284.25 billion at
the end of the third quarter of 2022, due to net cash provided
by financing and operating activities, partially offset by net
cash used for investing activities and the effect of exchange
rate changes on cash and cash equivalents. The net cash
provided by financing activities primarily reflected cash
inflows from deposits (reflecting increases in transaction
banking, deposit sweep program balances, brokered
certificates of deposit, and consumer deposits, partially offset
by a decrease in other deposits) and net issuance of unsecured
long-term borrowings. The net cash provided by operating
activities primarily reflected cash inflows from trading
liabilities and customer and other receivables and payables,
net (reflecting both an increase in customer and other
payables and in customer and other receivables), partially
offset by cash outflows from trading assets. The net cash
used for investing activities primarily reflected purchases of
investments (primarily U.S. government obligations
accounted for as held-to-maturity) and an increase in net
lending activities (reflecting increases in corporate, consumer
and wealth management loans). The decrease in net cash and
cash equivalents as a result of changes in foreign exchange
rates was due to the U.S. dollar strengthening during the first
nine months of 2022.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 150

-- 152 of 205 --

Market Risk Management
Overview
Market risk is the risk of an adverse impact to our earnings
due to changes in market conditions. Our assets and
liabilities that give rise to market risk primarily include
positions held for market making for our clients and for our
investing and financing activities, and these positions change
based on client demands and our investment opportunities.
We employ a variety of risk measures, each described in the
respective sections below, to monitor market risk. Categories
of market risk include the following:
• Interest rate risk: results from exposures to changes in the
level, slope and curvature of yield curves, the volatilities of
interest rates, prepayment speeds and credit spreads;
• Equity price risk: results from exposures to changes in
prices and volatilities of individual equities, baskets of
equities and equity indices;
• Currency rate risk: results from exposures to changes in
spot prices, forward prices and volatilities of currency
rates; and
• Commodity price risk: results from exposures to changes in
spot prices, forward prices and volatilities of commodities,
such as crude oil, petroleum products, natural gas,
electricity, and precious and base metals.
Market Risk, which is independent of our revenue-producing
units and reports to our chief risk officer, has primary
responsibility for assessing, monitoring and managing our
market risk through firmwide oversight across our global
businesses.
Managers in revenue-producing units, Treasury and Market
Risk discuss market information, positions and estimated
loss scenarios on an ongoing basis. Managers in revenue-
producing units and Treasury are accountable for managing
risk within prescribed limits. These managers have in-depth
knowledge of their positions, markets and the instruments
available to hedge their exposures.
Market Risk Management Process
Our process for managing market risk includes the critical
components of our risk management framework described in
the “Overview and Structure of Risk Management,” as well
as the following:
• Monitoring compliance with established market risk limits
and reporting our exposures;
• Diversifying exposures;
• Controlling position sizes; and
• Evaluating mitigants, such as economic hedges in related
securities or derivatives.
Our market risk management systems enable us to perform
an independent calculation of Value-at-Risk (VaR), Earnings-
at-Risk (EaR) and other stress measures, capture risk
measures at individual position levels, attribute risk measures
to individual risk factors of each position, report many
different views of the risk measures (e.g., by desk, business,
product type or entity) and produce ad hoc analyses in a
timely manner.
Risk Measures
We produce risk measures and monitor them against
established market risk limits. These measures reflect an
extensive range of scenarios and the results are aggregated at
product, business and firmwide levels.
We use a variety of risk measures to estimate the size of
potential losses for both moderate and more extreme market
moves over both short- and long-term time horizons. Our
primary risk measures are VaR, EaR and other stress tests.
Our risk reports detail key risks, drivers and changes for each
desk and business, and are distributed daily to senior
management of both our revenue-producing units and our
independent risk oversight and control functions.
Value-at-Risk. VaR is the potential loss in value due to
adverse market movements over a defined time horizon with
a specified confidence level. For assets and liabilities included
in VaR, see “Financial Statement Linkages to Market Risk
Measures.” We typically employ a one-day time horizon with
a 95% confidence level. We use a single VaR model, which
captures risks, including those related to interest rates, equity
prices, currency rates and commodity prices. As such, VaR
facilitates comparison across portfolios of different risk
characteristics. VaR also captures the diversification of
aggregated risk at the firmwide level.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
151 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 153 of 205 --

We are aware of the inherent limitations to VaR and
therefore use a variety of risk measures in our market risk
management process. Inherent limitations to VaR include:
• VaR does not estimate potential losses over longer time
horizons where moves may be extreme;
• VaR does not take account of the relative liquidity of
different risk positions; and
• Previous moves in market risk factors may not produce
accurate predictions of all future market moves.
To comprehensively capture our exposures and relevant risks
in our VaR calculation, we use historical simulations with
full valuation of market factors at the position level by
simultaneously shocking the relevant market factors for that
position. These market factors include spot prices, credit
spreads, funding spreads, yield curves, volatility and
correlation, and are updated periodically based on changes in
the composition of positions, as well as variations in market
conditions. We sample from five years of historical data to
generate the scenarios for our VaR calculation. The historical
data is weighted so that the relative importance of the data
reduces over time. This gives greater importance to more
recent observations and reflects current asset volatilities,
which improves the accuracy of our estimates of potential
loss. As a result, even if our positions included in VaR were
unchanged, our VaR would increase with increasing market
volatility and vice versa.
Given its reliance on historical data, VaR is most effective in
estimating risk exposures in markets in which there are no
sudden fundamental changes or shifts in market conditions.
Our VaR measure does not include:
• Positions that are not accounted for at fair value, such as
held-to-maturity securities and loans, deposits and
unsecured borrowings that are accounted for at amortized
cost;
• Available-for-sale securities for which the related
unrealized fair value gains and losses are included in
accumulated other comprehensive income/(loss);
• Positions that are best measured and monitored using
sensitivity measures; and
• The impact of changes in counterparty and our own credit
spreads on derivatives, as well as changes in our own credit
spreads on financial liabilities for which the fair value
option was elected.
We perform daily backtesting of our VaR model (i.e.,
comparing daily net revenues for positions included in VaR
to the VaR measure calculated as of the prior business day) at
the firmwide level and for each of our businesses and major
regulated subsidiaries.
Earnings-at-Risk. We manage our interest rate risk using
the EaR metric. EaR measures the estimated impact of
changes in interest rates to our net revenues and preferred
stock dividends over a defined time horizon. EaR
complements the VaR metric, which measures the impact of
interest rate changes that have an immediate impact on the
fair values of our assets and liabilities (i.e., mark-to-market
changes). Our exposure to interest rate risk occurs due to a
variety of factors, including, but not limited to:
• Differences in maturity or repricing dates of assets,
liabilities, preferred stock and certain off-balance sheet
instruments.
• Differences in the amounts of assets, liabilities, preferred
stock and certain off-balance sheet instruments with the
same maturity or repricing dates.
• Certain interest rate sensitive fees.
Treasury manages the aggregated interest rate risk from all
businesses through our investment securities portfolio and
interest rate derivatives. We measure EaR over a one-year
time horizon following a 100-basis point instantaneous
parallel shock in both short- and long-term interest rates.
This sensitivity is calculated relative to a baseline market
scenario, which takes into consideration, among other things,
the market’s expectation of forward rates, as well as our
expectation of future business activity. This scenario includes
contractual elements of assets, liabilities, preferred stock, and
certain off-balance sheet instruments, such as rates of
interest, principal repayment schedules, maturity and reset
dates, and any interest rate ceilings or floors, as well as
assumptions with respect to our balance sheet size and
composition, deposit repricing and prepayment behavior. We
manage EaR with a goal to reduce potential volatility
resulting from changes in interest rates so it remains within
our EaR risk appetite. Our EaR scenario is regularly
evaluated and updated, if necessary, to reflect changes in our
business plans, market conditions and other macroeconomic
factors. While management uses the best information
available to estimate EaR, actual results may differ materially
as a result of, among other things, changes in the economic
environment or assumptions used in the process.
Risk, which is independent of our revenue-producing units,
and Treasury, have primary responsibility for assessing and
monitoring EaR through firmwide oversight, including
oversight of EaR stress testing and assumptions, and the
establishment of our EaR risk appetite.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 152

-- 154 of 205 --

Stress Testing. Stress testing is a method of determining the
effect of various hypothetical stress scenarios. In addition to
EaR, we use other stress tests to examine risks of specific
portfolios, as well as the potential impact of our significant
risk exposures. We use a variety of stress testing techniques
to calculate the potential loss from a wide range of market
moves on our portfolios, including firmwide stress tests,
sensitivity analysis and scenario analysis. The results of our
various stress tests are analyzed together for risk
management purposes. See “Overview and Structure of Risk
Management” for information about firmwide stress tests.
Sensitivity analysis is used to quantify the impact of a market
move in a single risk factor across all positions (e.g., equity
prices or credit spreads) using a variety of defined market
shocks, ranging from those that could be expected over a
one-day time horizon up to those that could take many
months to occur. We also use sensitivity analysis to quantify
the impact of the default of any single entity, which captures
the risk of large or concentrated exposures.
Scenario analysis is used to quantify the impact of a specified
event, including how the event impacts multiple risk factors
simultaneously. For example, for sovereign stress testing we
calculate potential direct exposure associated with our
sovereign positions, as well as the corresponding debt, equity
and currency exposures associated with our non-sovereign
positions that may be impacted by the sovereign distress.
When conducting scenario analysis, we often consider a
number of possible outcomes for each scenario, ranging from
moderate to severely adverse market impacts. In addition,
these stress tests are constructed using both historical events
and forward-looking hypothetical scenarios.
Unlike VaR measures, which have an implied probability
because they are calculated at a specified confidence level,
there may not be an implied probability that our stress testing
scenarios will occur. Instead, stress testing is used to model
both moderate and more extreme moves in underlying
market factors. When estimating potential loss, we generally
assume that our positions cannot be reduced or hedged
(although experience demonstrates that we are generally able
to do so).
Limits
We use market risk limits at various levels to manage the size
of our market exposures. These limits are set based on VaR,
EaR and on a range of stress tests relevant to our exposures.
See “Overview and Structure of Risk Management” for
information about the limit approval process.
Limits are monitored by Treasury and Risk. Risk is
responsible for identifying and escalating to senior
management and/or the appropriate risk committee, on a
timely basis, instances where limits have been exceeded (e.g.,
due to positional changes or changes in market conditions,
such as increased volatilities or changes in correlations). Such
instances are remediated by a reduction in the positions we
hold and/or a temporary or permanent increase to the limit, if
warranted.
Metrics
We analyze VaR at the firmwide level and a variety of more
detailed levels, including by risk category, business and
region. Diversification effect in the tables below represents
the difference between total VaR and the sum of the VaRs for
the four risk categories. This effect arises because the four
market risk categories are not perfectly correlated.
During the first quarter of 2023, we added the currency
exposure on certain debt and equity positions to VaR and
removed certain debt and equity positions (and related
hedges) from VaR as our management believes that the risk
of these positions is more appropriately measured and
monitored using 10% sensitivity measures. Prior period
amounts for average daily VaR, period end VaR and high
and low VaR have been conformed to the current
presentation. The impact of such changes to prior period
total VaR was not material. Substantially all positions in
VaR are included within Global Banking & Markets.
The table below presents our average daily VaR.
Nine Months
Ended September	Three Months Ended
September June September
$ in millions 2023 2023 2022 2023 2022
Categories
Interest rates $ 88 $ 118 $ 111 $ 99 $ 96
Equity prices 28 31 35 29 37
Currency rates 19 25 33 26 29
Commodity prices 18 16 51 19 54
Diversification effect (66) (73) (102) (72) (100)
Total $ 87 $ 117 $ 128 $ 101 $ 116
Our average daily VaR decreased to $87 million for the three
months ended September 2023 from $117 million for the
three months ended June 2023, primarily due to lower levels
of volatility. The total decrease was primarily driven by
decreases in the interest rates, currency rates and equity
prices categories, partially offset by a decrease in the
diversification effect.
Our average daily VaR decreased to $87 million for the three
months ended September 2023 from $128 million for the
three months ended September 2022, due to lower levels of
volatility, partially offset by increased exposures. The total
decrease was primarily driven by decreases in the commodity
prices, interest rates and currency rates categories, partially
offset by a decrease in the diversification effect.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
153 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 155 of 205 --

Our average daily VaR decreased to $101 million for the nine
months ended September 2023 from $116 million for the nine
months ended September 2022, due to lower levels of
volatility, partially offset by increased exposures. The total
decrease was primarily driven by decreases in the commodity
prices and equity prices categories, partially offset by a
decrease in the diversification effect.
The table below presents our period-end VaR.
As of
September June September
$ in millions 2023 2023 2022
Categories
Interest rates $ 78 $ 105 $ 94
Equity prices 24 26 39
Currency rates 18 19 41
Commodity prices 19 18 35
Diversification effect (54) (69) (101)
Total $ 85 $ 99 $ 108
Our period-end VaR decreased to $85 million as of
September 2023 from $99 million as of June 2023, primarily
due to lower levels of volatility. The total decrease was
primarily driven by a decrease in the interest rates category,
partially offset by decrease in the diversification effect.
Our period-end VaR decreased to $85 million as of
September 2023 from $108 million as of September 2022, due
to lower levels of volatility, partially offset by increased
exposures. The total decrease was driven by decreases in the
currency rates, interest rates, commodity prices and equity
prices categories, partially offset by a decrease in the
diversification effect.
During the nine months ended September 2023, the firmwide
VaR risk limit was not exceeded and there were no
permanent changes to the firmwide VaR risk limit. However,
the firmwide VaR risk limit was temporarily changed on four
occasions as a result of changes in the market environment in
the first half of 2023. During 2022, the firmwide VaR risk
limit was exceeded on six occasions (all of which occurred
during March 2022) primarily due to higher levels of
volatility generally resulting from broad macroeconomic and
geopolitical concerns. These limit breaches were resolved by
temporary increases in the firmwide VaR risk limit and
subsequent risk reductions. During this period, the firmwide
VaR risk limit was also permanently increased due to higher
levels of volatility.
The table below presents our high and low VaR.
Three Months Ended
September 2023 June 2023 September 2022
$ in millions High Low High Low High Low
Categories
Interest rates $ 111 $ 78 $ 141 $ 97 $ 137 $ 92
Equity prices $ 49 $ 23 $ 42 $ 22 $ 48 $ 29
Currency rates $ 26 $ 14 $ 36 $ 17 $ 51 $ 20
Commodity prices $ 23 $ 15 $ 21 $ 11 $ 67 $ 35
Firmwide
VaR $ 102 $ 79 $ 142 $ 95 $ 155 $ 102
The chart below presents our daily VaR for the nine months
ended September 2023.
The table below presents, by number of business days, the
frequency distribution of our daily net revenues for positions
included in VaR.
Three Months
Ended September
Nine Months
Ended September
$ in millions 2023 2022 2023 2022
>$100 13 22 47 77
$75 – $100 13 8 32 27
$50 – $75 12 8 40 20
$25 – $50 19 9 34 22
$0 – $25 4 8 14 20
$(25) – $0 2 4 16 10
$(50) – $(25) – 3 2 6
$(75) – $(50) – – 1 2
$(100) – $(75) – 1 – 1
<$(100) – 1 1 3
Total 63 64 187 188
In the table above, the frequency distribution of daily net
revenues reflects the impact of the change in VaR described
above. Prior period amounts have been conformed to the
current presentation.
Daily net revenues for positions included in VaR are
compared with VaR calculated as of the end of the prior
business day. Net losses incurred on a single day for such
positions did not exceed our 95% one-day VaR (i.e., a VaR
exception) during both the three months ended September
2023 and September 2022. There was one VaR exception
during the nine months ended September 2023 and two VaR
exceptions during the nine months ended September 2022.
During periods in which we have significantly more positive
net revenue days than net revenue loss days, we expect to
have fewer VaR exceptions because, under normal
conditions, our business model generally produces positive
net revenues. In periods in which our franchise revenues are
adversely affected, we generally have more loss days,
resulting in more VaR exceptions. The daily net revenues for
positions included in VaR used to determine VaR exceptions
reflect the impact of any intraday activity, including bid/offer
net revenues, which are more likely than not to be positive by
their nature.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 154

-- 156 of 205 --

Sensitivity Measures
Certain portfolios and individual positions are not included
in VaR because VaR is not the most appropriate risk
measure. Other sensitivity measures we use to analyze market
risk are described below.
10% Sensitivity Measures. The table below presents our
market risk by asset category for positions accounted for at
fair value or accounted for at the lower of cost or fair value,
that are not included in VaR.
As of
September June September
$ in millions 2023 2023 2022
Equity $ 1,528 $ 1,527 $ 1,589
Debt 2,662 2,382 2,504
Total $ 4,190 $ 3,909 $ 4,093
In the table above:
• The 10% sensitivity measures for equity and debt positions
reflect the impact of the change in VaR described above.
Prior period amounts have been conformed to the current
presentation.
• As of September 2023, debt positions included
approximately $6.0 billion of GreenSky loans within
Platform Solutions that were classified as held for sale.
Substantially all of the remaining equity and debt positions
in 10% sensitivity measures are included within Asset &
Wealth Management.
• The market risk of these positions is determined by
estimating the potential reduction in net revenues of a 10%
decline in the value of the underlying positions.
• Equity positions relate to private and public equity
securities, which primarily include investments in
corporate, real estate and infrastructure assets.
• Debt positions include mezzanine and senior debt, and
corporate and real estate loans.
• Funded equity and debt positions are included in our
consolidated balance sheets in investments and loans, and
the related hedges are included in our consolidated balance
sheets in derivatives. See Note 8 to the consolidated
financial statements for further information about
investments, Note 9 to the consolidated financial
statements for further information about loans and Note 7
to the consolidated financial statements for further
information about derivatives.
• These measures do not reflect the diversification effect
across asset categories or across other market risk
measures.
Credit and Funding Spread Sensitivity on Derivatives
and Financial Liabilities. VaR excludes the impact of
changes in counterparty credit spreads, our own credit
spreads and unsecured funding spreads on derivatives, as well
as changes in our own credit spreads (debt valuation
adjustment) on financial liabilities for which the fair value
option was elected. The estimated sensitivity to a one basis
point increase in credit spreads (counterparty and our own)
and unsecured funding spreads on derivatives (including
hedges) was a loss of $1 million as of both September 2023
and June 2023. In addition, the estimated sensitivity to a one
basis point increase in our own credit spreads on financial
liabilities for which the fair value option was elected was a
gain of $36 million as of September 2023 and $39 million as
of June 2023. However, the actual net impact of a change in
our own credit spreads is also affected by the liquidity,
duration and convexity (as the sensitivity is not linear to
changes in yields) of those financial liabilities for which the
fair value option was elected, as well as the relative
performance of any hedges undertaken.
Earnings-at-Risk. The table below presents the impact of a
parallel shift in rates on our net revenues and preferred stock
dividends over the next 12 months relative to the baseline
scenario.
As of
September June
$ in millions 2023 2023
+100 basis points parallel shift in rates $ 109 $ 239
-100 basis points parallel shift in rates $ (98) $ (226)
In the table above, the EaR metric utilized various
assumptions, including, among other things, balance sheet
size and composition, deposit repricing and prepayment
behavior, all of which have inherent uncertainties. The EaR
metric does not represent a forecast of our net revenues and
preferred stock dividends. As of September 2023, we expect
our EaR sensitivity to scale approximately linearly with the
size of an instantaneous parallel shock in interest rates of up
to +/-200 basis points.
Other Market Risk Considerations
We make investments in securities that are accounted for as
available-for-sale, held-to-maturity or under the equity
method which are included in investments in the consolidated
balance sheets. See Note 8 to the consolidated financial
statements for further information.
Direct investments in real estate are accounted for at cost less
accumulated depreciation. See Note 12 to the consolidated
financial statements for further information about other
assets.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
155 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 157 of 205 --

Financial Statement Linkages to Market Risk
Measures
We employ a variety of risk measures, each described in the
respective sections above, to monitor market risk across the
consolidated balance sheets and consolidated statements of
earnings. The related gains and losses on these positions are
included in market making, other principal transactions,
interest income and interest expense in the consolidated
statements of earnings, and debt valuation adjustment and
unrealized gains/(losses) on available-for-sale securities in the
consolidated statements of comprehensive income.
The table below presents certain assets and liabilities
accounted for at fair value or accounted for at the lower of
cost or fair value in our consolidated balance sheets and the
market risk measures used to assess those assets and
liabilities.
Assets or Liabilities Market Risk Measures
Collateralized agreements and financings VaR
Customer and other receivables 10% Sensitivity Measures
Trading assets and liabilities VaR
Credit Spread Sensitivity
10% Sensitivity Measures
Investments VaR
10% Sensitivity Measures
Loans VaR
10% Sensitivity Measures
Other assets and liabilities VaR
Deposits VaR
Credit Spread Sensitivity
Unsecured borrowings VaR
Credit Spread Sensitivity
In addition to the above, we measure the interest rate risk for
all positions within our consolidated balance sheets using the
EaR metric.
Credit Risk Management
Overview
Credit risk represents the potential for loss due to the default
or deterioration in credit quality of a counterparty (e.g., an
OTC derivatives counterparty or a borrower) or an issuer of
securities or other instruments we hold. Our exposure to
credit risk comes mostly from client transactions in OTC
derivatives and loans and lending commitments. Credit risk
also comes from cash placed with banks, securities financing
transactions (i.e., resale and repurchase agreements and
securities borrowing and lending activities) and customer and
other receivables.
Credit Risk, which is independent of our revenue-producing
units and reports to our chief risk officer, has primary
responsibility for assessing, monitoring and managing our
credit risk through firmwide oversight across our global
businesses. In addition, we hold other positions that give rise
to credit risk (e.g., bonds and secondary bank loans). These
credit risks are captured as a component of market risk
measures, which are monitored and managed by Market
Risk. We also enter into derivatives to manage market risk
exposures. Such derivatives also give rise to credit risk, which
is monitored and managed by Credit Risk.
Credit Risk Management Process
Our process for managing credit risk includes the critical
components of our risk management framework described in
the “Overview and Structure of Risk Management,” as well
as the following:
• Monitoring compliance with established credit risk limits
and reporting our credit exposures and credit
concentrations;
• Establishing or approving underwriting standards;
• Assessing the likelihood that a counterparty will default on
its payment obligations;
• Measuring our current and potential credit exposure and
losses resulting from a counterparty default;
• Using credit risk mitigants, including collateral and
hedging; and
• Maximizing recovery through active workout and
restructuring of claims.
We also perform credit analyses, which incorporate initial
and ongoing evaluations of the capacity and willingness of a
counterparty to meet its financial obligations. For
substantially all of our credit exposures, the core of our
process is an annual counterparty credit evaluation or more
frequently if deemed necessary as a result of events or
changes in circumstances. We determine an internal credit
rating for the counterparty by considering the results of the
credit evaluations and assumptions with respect to the nature
of and outlook for the counterparty’s industry and the
economic environment. Beginning in the first quarter of 2023,
we also take into consideration collateral received or other
credit support arrangements when determining an internal
credit rating for collateralized loans, as management believes
that this methodology better reflects the credit quality of the
underlying loans and lending commitments. Prior period
amounts have been conformed to reflect the current
methodology. Senior personnel, with expertise in specific
industries, inspect and approve credit reviews and internal
credit ratings.
Our risk assessment process may also include, where
applicable, reviewing certain key metrics, including, but not
limited to, delinquency status, collateral value, FICO credit
scores and other risk factors.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 156

-- 158 of 205 --

Our credit risk management systems capture credit exposure
to individual counterparties and on an aggregate basis to
counterparties and their subsidiaries. These systems also
provide management with comprehensive information about
our aggregate credit risk by product, internal credit rating,
industry, country and region.
Risk Measures
We measure our credit risk based on the potential loss in the
event of non-payment by a counterparty using current and
potential exposure. For derivatives and securities financing
transactions, current exposure represents the amount
presently owed to us after taking into account applicable
netting and collateral arrangements, while potential exposure
represents our estimate of the future exposure that could
arise over the life of a transaction based on market
movements within a specified confidence level. Potential
exposure also takes into account netting and collateral
arrangements. For loans and lending commitments, the
primary measure is a function of the notional amount of the
position.
Stress Tests
We conduct regular stress tests to calculate the credit
exposures, including potential concentrations that would
result from applying shocks to counterparty credit ratings or
credit risk factors (e.g., currency rates, interest rates, equity
prices). These shocks cover a wide range of moderate and
more extreme market movements, including shocks to
multiple risk factors, consistent with the occurrence of a
severe market or economic event. In the case of sovereign
default, we estimate the direct impact of the default on our
sovereign credit exposures, changes to our credit exposures
arising from potential market moves in response to the
default, and the impact of credit market deterioration on
corporate borrowers and counterparties that may result from
the sovereign default. Unlike potential exposure, which is
calculated within a specified confidence level, stress testing
does not generally assume a probability of these events
occurring. We also perform firmwide stress tests. See
“Overview and Structure of Risk Management” for
information about firmwide stress tests.
To supplement these regular stress tests, as described above,
we also conduct tailored stress tests on an ad hoc basis in
response to specific market events that we deem significant.
We also utilize these stress tests to estimate the indirect
impact of certain hypothetical events on our country
exposures, such as the impact of credit market deterioration
on corporate borrowers and counterparties along with the
shocks to the risk factors described above. The parameters of
these shocks vary based on the scenario reflected in each
stress test. We review estimated losses produced by the stress
tests in order to understand their magnitude, highlight
potential loss concentrations, and assess and mitigate our
exposures where necessary.
Limits
We use credit risk limits at various levels, as well as
underwriting standards to manage the size and nature of our
credit exposures. Limits for industries and countries are
based on our risk appetite and are designed to allow for
regular monitoring, review, escalation and management of
credit risk concentrations. See “Overview and Structure of
Risk Management” for information about the limit approval
process.
Credit Risk is responsible for monitoring these limits, and
identifying and escalating to senior management and/or the
appropriate risk committee, on a timely basis, instances
where limits have been exceeded.
Risk Mitigants
To reduce our credit exposures on derivatives and securities
financing transactions, we may enter into netting agreements
with counterparties that permit us to offset receivables and
payables with such counterparties. We may also reduce credit
risk with counterparties by entering into agreements that
enable us to obtain collateral from them on an upfront or
contingent basis and/or to terminate transactions if the
counterparty’s credit rating falls below a specified level. We
monitor the fair value of the collateral to ensure that our
credit exposures are appropriately collateralized. We seek to
minimize exposures where there is a significant positive
correlation between the creditworthiness of our
counterparties and the market value of collateral we receive.
For loans and lending commitments, depending on the credit
quality of the borrower and other characteristics of the
transaction, we employ a variety of potential risk mitigants.
Risk mitigants include collateral provisions, guarantees,
covenants, structural seniority of the bank loan claims and,
for certain lending commitments, provisions in the legal
documentation that allow us to adjust loan amounts, pricing,
structure and other terms as market conditions change. The
type and structure of risk mitigants employed can
significantly influence the degree of credit risk involved in a
loan or lending commitment.
When we do not have sufficient visibility into a
counterparty’s financial strength or when we believe a
counterparty requires support from its parent, we may obtain
third-party guarantees of the counterparty’s obligations. We
may also mitigate our credit risk using credit derivatives or
participation agreements.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
157 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 159 of 205 --

Credit Exposures
As of September 2023, our aggregate credit exposure
decreased slightly compared with December 2022, reflecting a
decrease in OTC derivatives. The percentage of our credit
exposures arising from non-investment-grade counterparties
(based on our internally determined public rating agency
equivalents) decreased slightly compared with December
2022, primarily reflecting a decrease in non-investment-grade
credit exposure related to OTC derivatives. Our credit
exposures are described further below.
Cash and Cash Equivalents. Our credit exposure on cash
and cash equivalents arises from our unrestricted cash, and
includes both interest-bearing and non-interest-bearing
deposits. To mitigate the risk of credit loss, we place
substantially all of our deposits with highly rated banks and
central banks.
The table below presents our credit exposure from
unrestricted cash and cash equivalents, and the concentration
by industry, region and internally determined public rating
agency equivalents.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Cash and Cash Equivalents $221,930 $224,889
Industry
Financial Institutions 7% 6%
Sovereign 93% 94%
Total 100% 100%
Region
Americas 58% 77%
EMEA 32% 19%
Asia 10% 4%
Total 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
AAA 76% 89%
AA 11% 5%
A 13% 6%
Total 100% 100%
The table above excludes cash segregated for regulatory and
other purposes of $17.95 billion as of September 2023 and
$16.94 billion as of December 2022.
OTC Derivatives. Our credit exposure on OTC derivatives
arises primarily from our market-making activities. As a
market maker, we enter into derivative transactions to
provide liquidity to clients and to facilitate the transfer and
hedging of their risks. We also enter into derivatives to
manage market risk exposures. We manage our credit
exposure on OTC derivatives using the credit risk process,
measures, limits and risk mitigants described above.
We generally enter into OTC derivatives transactions under
bilateral collateral arrangements that require the daily
exchange of collateral. As credit risk is an essential
component of fair value, we include a CVA in the fair value
of derivatives to reflect counterparty credit risk, as described
in Note 7 to the consolidated financial statements. CVA is a
function of the present value of expected exposure, the
probability of counterparty default and the assumed recovery
upon default.
The table below presents our net credit exposure from OTC
derivatives and the concentration by industry and region.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
OTC derivative assets $45,500 $53,399
Collateral (not netted under U.S. GAAP) (16,386) (15,823)
Net credit exposure $29,114 $37,576
Industry
Consumer & Retail 3% 3%
Diversified Industrials 13% 8%
Financial Institutions 16% 20%
Funds 24% 19%
Healthcare 1% 1%
Municipalities & Nonprofit 2% 2%
Natural Resources & Utilities 21% 34%
Sovereign 12% 7%
Technology, Media & Telecommunications 6% 4%
Other (including Special Purpose Vehicles) 2% 2%
Total 100% 100%
Region
Americas 46% 49%
EMEA 46% 43%
Asia 8% 8%
Total 100% 100%
Our credit exposure (before any potential recoveries) to OTC
derivative counterparties that defaulted during the nine
months ended September 2023 remained low, representing
less than 2% of our total credit exposure from OTC
derivatives.
In the table above:
• OTC derivative assets, included in the consolidated
balance sheets, are reported on a net-by-counterparty basis
(i.e., the net receivable for a given counterparty) when a
legal right of setoff exists under an enforceable netting
agreement (counterparty netting) and are accounted for at
fair value, net of cash collateral received under enforceable
credit support agreements (cash collateral netting).
• Collateral represents cash collateral and the fair value of
securities collateral, primarily U.S. and non-U.S.
government and agency obligations, received under credit
support agreements, that we consider when determining
credit risk, but such collateral is not eligible for netting
under U.S. GAAP.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 158

-- 160 of 205 --

The table below presents the distribution of our net credit
exposure from OTC derivatives by tenor.
$ in millions
Investment-
Grade
Non-Investment-
Grade / Unrated Total
As of September 2023
Less than 1 year $ 25,194 $ 6,783 $ 31,977
1 – 5 years 23,812 5,804 29,616
Greater than 5 years 55,998 4,467 60,465
Total 105,004 17,054 122,058
Netting (85,702) (7,242) (92,944)
Net credit exposure $ 19,302 $ 9,812 $ 29,114
As of December 2022
Less than 1 year $ 23,112 $ 8,812 $ 31,924
1 – 5 years 26,627 8,355 34,982
Greater than 5 years 58,354 4,342 62,696
Total 108,093 21,509 129,602
Netting (83,531) (8,495) (92,026)
Net credit exposure $ 24,562 $ 13,014 $ 37,576
In the table above:
• Tenor is based on remaining contractual maturity.
• Netting includes counterparty netting across tenor
categories and collateral that we consider when
determining credit risk (including collateral that is not
eligible for netting under U.S. GAAP). Counterparty
netting within the same tenor category is included within
such tenor category.
The tables below present the distribution of our net credit
exposure from OTC derivatives by tenor and internally
determined public rating agency equivalents.
Investment-Grade
$ in millions AAA AA A BBB Total
As of September 2023
Less than 1 year $ 758 $ 4,520 $ 12,323 $ 7,593 $ 25,194
1 – 5 years 1,616 7,044 7,622 7,530 23,812
Greater than 5 years 5,070 16,140 17,548 17,240 55,998
Total 7,444 27,704 37,493 32,363 105,004
Netting (4,779) (24,582) (31,931) (24,410) (85,702)
Net credit exposure $ 2,665 $ 3,122 $ 5,562 $ 7,953 $ 19,302
As of December 2022
Less than 1 year $ 521 $ 2,113 $ 10,516 $ 9,962 $ 23,112
1 – 5 years 1,684 5,383 9,057 10,503 26,627
Greater than 5 years 5,594 16,063 21,060 15,637 58,354
Total 7,799 23,559 40,633 36,102 108,093
Netting (5,025) (20,582) (31,956) (25,968) (83,531)
Net credit exposure $ 2,774 $ 2,977 $ 8,677 $ 10,134 $ 24,562
Non-Investment-Grade / Unrated
$ in millions BB or lower Unrated Total
As of September 2023
Less than 1 year $ 6,325 $ 458 $ 6,783
1 – 5 years 5,719 85 5,804
Greater than 5 years 4,007 460 4,467
Total 16,051 1,003 17,054
Netting (7,193) (49) (7,242)
Net credit exposure $ 8,858 $ 954 $ 9,812
As of December 2022
Less than 1 year $ 8,245 $ 567 $ 8,812
1 – 5 years 8,150 205 8,355
Greater than 5 years 4,232 110 4,342
Total 20,627 882 21,509
Netting (8,436) (59) (8,495)
Net credit exposure $ 12,191 $ 823 $ 13,014
Lending Activities. We manage our lending activities using
the credit risk process, measures, limits and risk mitigants
described above. Other lending positions, including
secondary trading positions, are risk-managed as a
component of market risk. As described above, beginning in
the first quarter of 2023, we take into consideration collateral
received or other credit support arrangements when
determining an internal credit rating for collateralized loans.
Prior period amounts have been conformed to reflect the
current methodology. The impact to December 2022 was to
increase loans and lending commitments classified as
investment-grade and decrease loans and lending
commitments classified as non-investment-grade by
$29.6 billion (loans of $25.0 billion and lending commitments
of $4.6 billion). The impact of this change was in real estate
(warehouse loans) and other collateralized loans and lending
commitments.
The table below presents our loans and lending
commitments.
$ in millions Loans
Lending
Commitments Total
As of September 2023
Corporate $ 36,815 $ 145,340 $ 182,155
Commercial real estate 25,672 3,366 29,038
Residential real estate 23,953 1,932 25,885
Securities-based 15,053 815 15,868
Other collateralized 55,646 16,284 71,930
Consumer:
Installment 6,375 2,683 9,058
Credit cards 17,885 68,394 86,279
Other 1,753 883 2,636
Total $ 183,152 $ 239,697 $ 422,849
Allowance for loan losses $ (4,895) $ (670) $ (5,565)
As of December 2022
Corporate $ 40,135 $ 139,718 $ 179,853
Commercial real estate 28,879 4,271 33,150
Residential real estate 23,035 3,192 26,227
Securities-based 16,671 508 17,179
Other collateralized 51,702 14,407 66,109
Consumer:
Installment 6,326 1,882 8,208
Credit cards 15,820 62,216 78,036
Other 2,261 944 3,205
Total $ 184,829 $ 227,138 $ 411,967
Allowance for loan losses $ (5,543) $ (774) $ (6,317)
In the table above, lending commitments excluded $5.22
billion as of September 2023 and $4.85 billion as of December
2022 related to issued letters of credit which are classified as
guarantees in our consolidated financial statements. See Note
18 to the consolidated financial statements for further
information about guarantees.
See Note 9 to the consolidated financial statements for
information about net charge-offs on wholesale and
consumer loans, as well as past due and nonaccrual loans
accounted for at amortized cost.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
159 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 161 of 205 --

Corporate. Corporate loans and lending commitments
include term loans, revolving lines of credit, letter of credit
facilities and bridge loans, and are principally used for
operating and general corporate purposes, or in connection
with acquisitions. Corporate loans are secured (typically by a
senior lien on the assets of the borrower) or unsecured,
depending on the loan purpose, the risk profile of the
borrower and other factors.
The table below presents our credit exposure from corporate
loans and lending commitments, and the concentration by
industry, region, internally determined public rating agency
equivalents and other credit metrics.
$ in millions Loans
Lending
Commitments Total
As of September 2023
Corporate $36,815 $145,340 $182,155
Industry
Consumer & Retail 10% 14% 13%
Diversified Industrials 17% 20% 20%
Financial Institutions 7% 9% 9%
Funds 4% 4% 3%
Healthcare 10% 10% 10%
Natural Resources & Utilities 9% 17% 16%
Real Estate 12% 5% 6%
Technology, Media & Telecommunications 26% 19% 21%
Other (including Special Purpose Vehicles) 5% 2% 2%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Region
Americas 62% 77% 74%
EMEA 30% 22% 23%
Asia 8% 1% 3%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
AAA – 1% 1%
AA 1% 5% 4%
A 4% 19% 16%
BBB 18% 41% 36%
BB or lower 77% 34% 43%
Total 100% 100% 100%
As of December 2022
Corporate $40,135 $139,718 $179,853
Industry
Consumer & Retail 10% 13% 12%
Diversified Industrials 18% 18% 18%
Financial Institutions 7% 8% 8%
Funds 3% 4% 4%
Healthcare 10% 12% 12%
Natural Resources & Utilities 9% 18% 16%
Real Estate 11% 5% 7%
Technology, Media & Telecommunications 26% 20% 21%
Other (including Special Purpose Vehicles) 6% 2% 2%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Region
Americas 57% 77% 73%
EMEA 34% 21% 24%
Asia 9% 2% 3%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
AAA – 2% 1%
AA 1% 5% 4%
A 5% 21% 18%
BBB 19% 38% 34%
BB or lower 75% 34% 43%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Commercial Real Estate. Commercial real estate includes
originated loans and lending commitments that are directly
or indirectly secured by hotels, retail stores, multifamily
housing complexes and commercial and industrial properties.
Commercial real estate also includes loans and lending
commitments extended to clients who warehouse assets that
are directly or indirectly backed by commercial real estate. In
addition, commercial real estate includes loans purchased by
us.
The table below presents our credit exposure from
commercial real estate loans and lending commitments, and
the concentration by region, internally determined public
rating agency equivalents and other credit metrics.
$ in millions Loans
Lending
Commitments Total
As of September 2023
Commercial Real Estate $25,672 $3,366 $29,038
Region
Americas 83% 76% 82%
EMEA 14% 23% 15%
Asia 3% 1% 3%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
Investment-grade 47% 45% 47%
Non-investment-grade 53% 55% 53%
Total 100% 100% 100%
As of December 2022
Commercial Real Estate $28,879 $4,271 $33,150
Region
Americas 79% 74% 78%
EMEA 16% 17% 16%
Asia 5% 9% 6%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
Investment-grade 42% 35% 41%
Non-investment-grade 58% 64% 59%
Unrated – 1% –
Total 100% 100% 100%
In the table above:
• The concentration of loans and lending commitments by
asset class as of September 2023 was 38% for warehouse
and other indirect, 13% for industrials, 12% for
multifamily, 9% for office, 8% for hospitality, 8% for
mixed use and 12% for other asset classes.
• The net charge-off ratio for commercial real estate loans
was 1.5% for the nine months ended September 2023. The
net charge-off ratio is calculated by dividing annualized net
charge-offs by average gross loans accounted for at
amortized cost.
In addition, we also have credit exposure to commercial real
estate loans held for securitization of $287 million as of
September 2023 and $119 million as of December 2022. Such
loans are included in trading assets in our consolidated
balance sheets.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 160

-- 162 of 205 --

Residential Real Estate. Residential real estate loans and
lending commitments are primarily extended to wealth
management clients and to clients who warehouse assets that
are directly or indirectly secured by residential real estate. In
addition, residential real estate includes loans purchased by
us.
The table below presents our credit exposure from residential
real estate loans and lending commitments, and the
concentration by region, internally determined public rating
agency equivalents and other credit metrics.
$ in millions Loans
Lending
Commitments Total
As of September 2023
Residential Real Estate $23,953 $1,932 $25,885
Region
Americas 96% 86% 95%
EMEA 3% 3% 3%
Asia 1% 11% 2%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
Investment-grade 56% 55% 56%
Non-investment-grade 21% 34% 22%
Other metrics 23% 9% 22%
Unrated – 2% –
Total 100% 100% 100%
As of December 2022
Residential Real Estate $23,035 $3,192 $26,227
Region
Americas 96% 93% 95%
EMEA 3% 7% 4%
Asia 1% – 1%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
Investment-grade 52% 63% 53%
Non-investment-grade 25% 36% 26%
Other metrics 23% 1% 21%
Total 100% 100% 100%
In the table above:
• Credit exposure included loans and lending commitments
of $13.65 billion as of September 2023 and $14.62 billion as
of December 2022 which are extended to clients who
warehouse assets that are directly or indirectly secured by
residential real estate.
• Other metrics category consists of loans where we use
other key metrics to assess the borrower's credit quality,
such as loan-to-value ratio, delinquency status, collateral
value, expected cash flows and other risk factors.
In addition, we also have credit exposure to residential real
estate loans held for securitization of $6.70 billion as of
September 2023 and $8.07 billion as of December 2022. Such
loans are included in trading assets in our consolidated
balance sheets.
Securities-Based. Securities-based includes loans and
lending commitments that are secured by stocks, bonds,
mutual funds, and exchange-traded funds. These loans and
commitments are primarily extended to our wealth
management clients and used for purposes other than
purchasing, carrying or trading margin stocks. Securities-
based loans require borrowers to post additional collateral
based on changes in the underlying collateral's fair value.
The table below presents our credit exposure from securities-
based loans and lending commitments, and the concentration
by region, internally determined public rating agency
equivalents and other credit metrics.
$ in millions Loans
Lending
Commitments Total
As of September 2023
Securities-based $15,053 $815 $15,868
Region
Americas 80% 99% 81%
EMEA 19% 1% 18%
Asia 1% – 1%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
Investment-grade 76% 37% 74%
Non-investment-grade 4% 1% 4%
Other metrics 20% 62% 22%
Total 100% 100% 100%
As of December 2022
Securities-based $16,671 $508 $17,179
Region
Americas 83% 98% 83%
EMEA 15% 2% 15%
Asia 2% – 2%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
Investment-grade 77% 18% 76%
Non-investment-grade 5% 2% 4%
Other metrics 18% 80% 20%
Total 100% 100% 100%
In the table above, other metrics category consists of loans
where we use other key metrics to assess the borrower's credit
quality, such as collateral value, loan-to-value ratio and
delinquency status.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
161 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 163 of 205 --

Other Collateralized. Other collateralized includes loans
and lending commitments that are backed by specific
collateral (other than securities and real estate). Such loans
and lending commitments are extended to clients who
warehouse assets that are directly or indirectly secured by
corporate loans, consumer loans and other assets. Other
collateralized also includes loans and lending commitments
to investment funds (managed by third parties) that are
collateralized by capital commitments of the funds' investors
or assets held by the fund, as well as other secured loans and
lending commitments extended to our wealth management
clients.
The table below presents our credit exposure from other
collateralized loans and lending commitments, and the
concentration by region, internally determined public rating
agency equivalents and other credit metrics.
$ in millions Loans
Lending
Commitments Total
As of September 2023
Other Collateralized $55,646 $16,284 $71,930
Region
Americas 84% 84% 84%
EMEA 14% 15% 15%
Asia 2% 1% 1%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
Investment-grade 80% 76% 79%
Non-investment-grade 20% 22% 20%
Unrated – 2% 1%
Total 100% 100% 100%
As of December 2022
Other Collateralized $51,702 $14,407 $66,109
Region
Americas 86% 93% 87%
EMEA 12% 7% 11%
Asia 2% – 2%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
Investment-grade 83% 83% 83%
Non-investment-grade 16% 14% 16%
Other metrics 1% – –
Unrated – 3% 1%
Total 100% 100% 100%
In the table above, credit exposure included loans and
lending commitments extended to clients who warehouse
assets of $21.36 billion as of September 2023 and $16.89
billion as of December 2022.
Installment and Credit Cards. We originate unsecured
installment loans and credit card loans (pursuant to revolving
lines of credit) to consumers in the Americas. The credit card
lines are cancellable by us and therefore do not result in
credit exposure.
The tables below present our credit exposure from originated
installment and credit card funded loans, and the
concentration by the five most concentrated U.S. states.
$ in millions Installment
As of September 2023
Loans, gross $6,375
Texas 8%
California 7%
New Jersey 5%
Florida 5%
New York 5%
Other 70%
Total 100%
As of December 2022
Loans, gross $6,326
California 10%
Texas 9%
Florida 7%
New York 6%
Illinois 4%
Other 64%
Total 100%
$ in millions Credit Cards
As of September 2023
Loans, gross $17,885
California 17%
Texas 9%
Florida 8%
New York 8%
Illinois 4%
Other 54%
Total 100%
As of December 2022
Loans, gross $15,820
California 16%
Texas 9%
New York 8%
Florida 8%
New Jersey 4%
Other 55%
Total 100%
In addition, we had credit exposure of $2.68 billion as of
September 2023 and $1.88 billion as of December 2022
related to our commitments to provide unsecured installment
loans to consumers.
See Note 9 to the consolidated financial statements for
further information about the credit quality indicators of
installment and credit card loans.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 162

-- 164 of 205 --

Other. Other includes unsecured loans extended to wealth
management clients and unsecured consumer and credit card
loans purchased by us.
The table below presents our credit exposure from other
loans and lending commitments, and the concentration by
region, internally determined public rating agency
equivalents and other credit metrics.
$ in millions Loans
Lending
Commitments Total
As of September 2023
Other $1,753 $883 $2,636
Region
Americas 91% 100% 94%
EMEA 9% – 6%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
Investment-grade 53% 84% 63%
Non-investment-grade 41% 16% 33%
Other metrics 6% – 4%
Total 100% 100% 100%
As of December 2022
Other $2,261 $944 $3,205
Region
Americas 89% 99% 92%
EMEA 11% 1% 8%
Total 100% 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
Investment-grade 47% 93% 60%
Non-investment-grade 26% 7% 21%
Other metrics 27% – 19%
Total 100% 100% 100%
In the table above, other metrics primarily includes consumer
and credit card loans purchased by us. Our risk assessment
process for such loans includes reviewing certain key metrics,
such as expected cash flows, delinquency status and other
risk factors.
In addition, we also have credit exposure to other loans held
for securitization of $1.31 billion as of September 2023 and
$1.76 billion as of December 2022. Such loans are included in
trading assets in our consolidated balance sheets.
Credit Hedges. To mitigate the credit risk associated with
our lending activities, we obtain credit protection on certain
loans and lending commitments through credit default swaps,
both single-name and index-based contracts, and through the
issuance of credit-linked notes.
Securities Financing Transactions. We enter into
securities financing transactions in order to, among other
things, facilitate client activities, invest excess cash, acquire
securities to cover short positions and finance certain
activities. We bear credit risk related to resale agreements
and securities borrowed only to the extent that cash
advanced or the value of securities pledged or delivered to the
counterparty exceeds the value of the collateral received. We
also have credit exposure on repurchase agreements and
securities loaned to the extent that the value of securities
pledged or delivered to the counterparty for these
transactions exceeds the amount of cash or collateral
received. Securities collateral for these transactions primarily
includes U.S. and non-U.S. government and agency
obligations.
The table below presents our credit exposure from securities
financing transactions and the concentration by industry,
region and internally determined public rating agency
equivalents.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Securities Financing Transactions $37,468 $34,762
Industry
Financial Institutions 31% 43%
Funds 41% 23%
Municipalities & Nonprofit 4% 5%
Sovereign 23% 28%
Other (including Special Purpose Vehicles) 1% 1%
Total 100% 100%
Region
Americas 39% 47%
EMEA 44% 34%
Asia 17% 19%
Total 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
AAA 12% 20%
AA 29% 31%
A 36% 31%
BBB 12% 8%
BB or lower 11% 10%
Total 100% 100%
The table above reflects both netting agreements and
collateral that we consider when determining credit risk.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
163 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 165 of 205 --

Other Credit Exposures. We are exposed to credit risk
from our receivables from brokers, dealers and clearing
organizations and customers and counterparties. Receivables
from brokers, dealers and clearing organizations primarily
consist of initial margin placed with clearing organizations
and receivables related to sales of securities which have
traded, but not yet settled. These receivables generally have
minimal credit risk due to the low probability of clearing
organization default and the short-term nature of receivables
related to securities settlements. Receivables from customers
and counterparties generally consist of collateralized
receivables related to customer securities transactions and
generally have minimal credit risk due to both the value of
the collateral received and the short-term nature of these
receivables.
The table below presents our other credit exposures and the
concentration by industry, region and internally determined
public rating agency equivalents.
As of
September December
$ in millions 2023 2022
Other Credit Exposures $47,143 $48,916
Industry
Financial Institutions 81% 80%
Funds 12% 12%
Other (including Special Purpose Vehicles) 7% 8%
Total 100% 100%
Region
Americas 41% 41%
EMEA 46% 49%
Asia 13% 10%
Total 100% 100%
Credit Quality (Credit Rating Equivalent)
AAA 1% 7%
AA 42% 32%
A 33% 33%
BBB 8% 10%
BB or lower 15% 16%
Unrated 1% 2%
Total 100% 100%
The table above reflects collateral that we consider when
determining credit risk.
Selected Exposures
We have credit and market exposures, as described below,
that have had heightened focus given recent events and broad
market concerns. Credit exposure represents the potential for
loss due to the default or deterioration in credit quality of a
counterparty or borrower. Market exposure represents the
potential for loss in value of our long and short positions due
to changes in market prices.
Country Exposures. The Russian invasion of Ukraine has
negatively affected the global economy and increased
macroeconomic uncertainty. The extent and duration of the
war, sanctions and resulting market disruptions, as well as
the potential adverse consequences for our business, liquidity
and results of operations, are difficult to predict. We have
significantly reduced our exposure to Russia and Ukraine and
have curtailed our operations in Russia to those necessary to
meet our legal and regulatory obligations. The overall direct
financial impact to our net revenues for the first nine months
of 2023 from Russian and Ukrainian counterparties,
borrowers, issuers and related instruments was not material.
Our total credit exposure to Russian or Ukrainian
counterparties or borrowers and our total market exposure
relating to Russian issuers was not material as of September
2023. Our total market exposure to Ukraine as of September
2023 was $113 million, primarily to sovereign issuers. Such
exposure consisted of $125 million related to debt and $(12)
million related to credit derivatives. See “Risk Factors” in
Part I, Item 1A of the 2022 Form 10-K for further information
about our risks related to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
Economic challenges persist for the Argentine government
given uncertainty relating to its fiscal and economic policies.
As of September 2023, our total credit exposure to Argentina
was not material. Our total market exposure to Argentina as
of September 2023 was $172 million, primarily to sovereign
issuers. Such exposure consisted of $94 million related to
debt, $7 million related to credit derivatives and $71 million
related to equities.
In addition, economic and/or political uncertainties in
Ethiopia, Ghana, Lebanon, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and
Venezuela have led to concerns about their financial stability.
Our credit exposure to counterparties or borrowers and our
market exposure to issuers relating to each of these countries
was not material as of September 2023.
We have a comprehensive framework to monitor, measure
and assess our country exposures and to determine our risk
appetite. We determine the country of risk by the location of
the counterparty, issuer’s assets, where they generate revenue,
the country in which they are headquartered, the jurisdiction
where a claim against them could be enforced, and/or the
government whose policies affect their ability to repay their
obligations. We monitor our credit exposure to a specific
country both at the individual counterparty level, as well as
at the aggregate country level. See “Stress Tests” for
information about stress tests that are designed to estimate
the direct and indirect impact of events involving the above
countries.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 164

-- 166 of 205 --

Operational Risk Management
Overview
Operational risk is the risk of an adverse outcome resulting
from inadequate or failed internal processes, people, systems
or from external events. Our exposure to operational risk
arises from routine processing errors, as well as
extraordinary incidents, such as major systems failures or
legal and regulatory matters.
Potential types of loss events related to internal and external
operational risk include:
• Execution, delivery and process management;
• Business disruption and system failures;
• Employment practices and workplace safety;
• Clients, products and business practices;
• Damage to physical assets;
• Internal fraud; and
• External fraud.
Operational Risk, which is independent of our revenue-
producing units and reports to our chief risk officer, has
primary responsibility for developing and implementing a
formalized framework for assessing, monitoring and
managing operational risk with the goal of maintaining our
exposure to operational risk at levels that are within our risk
appetite.
Operational Risk Management Process
Our process for managing operational risk includes the
critical components of our risk management framework
described in the “Overview and Structure of Risk
Management,” including a comprehensive data collection
process, as well as firmwide policies and procedures, for
operational risk events.
We combine top-down and bottom-up approaches to manage
and measure operational risk. From a top-down perspective,
our senior management assesses firmwide and business-level
operational risk profiles. From a bottom-up perspective, our
first and second lines of defense are responsible for risk
identification and risk management on a day-to-day basis,
including escalating operational risks and risk events to
senior management.
We maintain a comprehensive control framework designed to
provide a well-controlled environment to minimize
operational risks. The Firmwide Operational Risk and
Resilience Committee is responsible for overseeing
operational risk, and for ensuring the operational resilience
of our business.
Our operational risk management framework is designed to
comply with the operational risk measurement rules under
the Capital Framework and has evolved based on the
changing needs of our businesses and regulatory guidance.
We have established policies that require all employees and
consultants to report and escalate operational risk events.
When operational risk events are identified, our policies
require that the events be documented and analyzed to
determine whether changes are required in our systems and/
or processes to further mitigate the risk of future events.
We use operational risk management applications to capture,
analyze, aggregate and report operational risk event data and
key metrics. One of our key risk identification and control
assessment tools is an operational risk and control self-
assessment process, which is performed by our managers.
This process consists of the identification and rating of
operational risks, on a forward-looking basis, and the related
controls. The results from this process are analyzed to
evaluate operational risk exposures and identify businesses,
activities or products with heightened levels of operational
risk.
Risk Measurement
We measure our operational risk exposure using both
statistical modeling and scenario analyses, which involve
qualitative and quantitative assessments of internal and
external operational risk event data and internal control
factors for each of our businesses. Operational risk
measurement also incorporates an assessment of business
environment factors, including:
• Evaluations of the complexity of our business activities;
• The degree of automation in our processes;
• New activity information;
• The legal and regulatory environment; and
• Changes in the markets for our products and services,
including the diversity and sophistication of our customers
and counterparties.
The results from these scenario analyses are used to monitor
changes in operational risk and to determine business lines
that may have heightened exposure to operational risk. These
analyses are used in the determination of the appropriate
level of operational risk capital to hold. We also perform
firmwide stress tests. See “Overview and Structure of Risk
Management” for information about firmwide stress tests.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
165 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 167 of 205 --

Types of Operational Risks
Increased reliance on technology and third-party
relationships has resulted in increased operational risks, such
as information and cybersecurity risk, third-party risk and
business resilience risk. We manage those risks as follows:
Information and Cybersecurity Risk. Information and
cybersecurity risk is the risk of compromising the
confidentiality, integrity or availability of our data and
systems, leading to an adverse impact to us, our reputation,
our clients and/or the broader financial system. We seek to
minimize the occurrence and impact of unauthorized access,
disruption or use of information and/or information systems.
We deploy and operate preventive and detective controls and
processes to mitigate emerging and evolving information
security and cybersecurity threats, including monitoring our
network for known vulnerabilities and signs of unauthorized
attempts to access our data and systems. There is increased
information risk through diversification of our data across
external service providers, including use of a variety of cloud-
provided or -hosted services and applications. See “Risk
Factors” in Part I, Item 1A of the 2022 Form 10-K for further
information about information and cybersecurity risk.
Third-Party Risk. Third-party risk, including vendor risk, is
the risk of an adverse impact due to reliance on third parties
performing services or activities on our behalf. These risks
may include legal, regulatory, information security,
reputational, operational or any other risks inherent in
engaging a third party. We identify, manage and report key
third-party risks and conduct due diligence across multiple
risk domains, including information security and
cybersecurity, resilience and additional supply chain
dependencies. The Third-Party Risk Program monitors,
reviews and reassesses third-party risks on an ongoing basis.
See “Risk Factors” in Part I, Item 1A of the 2022 Form 10-K
for further information about third-party risk.
Business Resilience Risk. Business resilience risk is the risk
of disruption to our critical processes. We monitor threats
and assess risks and seek to ensure our state of readiness in
the event of a significant operational disruption to the normal
operations of our critical functions or their dependencies,
such as critical facilities, systems, third parties, data and/or
personnel. Our resilience framework defines the fundamental
principles for business continuity planning (BCP) and crisis
management to ensure that critical functions can continue to
operate in the event of a disruption. The business continuity
program is comprehensive, consistent on a firmwide basis,
and up-to-date, incorporating new information, including
updated resilience capabilities as and when they become
available. Our resilience assurance program encompasses
testing of response and recovery strategies on a regular basis
with the objective of minimizing and preventing significant
operational disruptions. See “Business — Business Continuity
and Information Security” in Part I, Item 1 of the 2022 Form
10-K for further information about business continuity.
Model Risk Management
Overview
Model risk is the potential for adverse consequences from
decisions made based on model outputs that may be incorrect
or used inappropriately. We rely on quantitative models
across our business activities primarily to value certain
financial assets and liabilities, to monitor and manage our
risk, and to measure and monitor our regulatory capital.
Model Risk, which is independent of our revenue-producing
units, model developers, model owners and model users, and
reports to our chief risk officer, has primary responsibility for
assessing, monitoring and managing our model risk through
firmwide oversight across our global businesses, and provides
periodic updates to senior management, risk committees and
the Risk Committee of the Board.
Our model risk management framework is managed through
a governance structure and risk management controls, which
encompass standards designed to ensure we maintain a
comprehensive model inventory, including risk assessment
and classification, sound model development practices,
independent review and model-specific usage controls. The
Firmwide Model Risk Control Committee oversees our
model risk management framework.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 166

-- 168 of 205 --

Model Review and Validation Process
Model Risk consists of quantitative professionals who
perform an independent review, validation and approval of
our models. This review includes an analysis of the model
documentation, independent testing, an assessment of the
appropriateness of the methodology used, and verification of
compliance with model development and implementation
standards.
We regularly refine and enhance our models to reflect
changes in market or economic conditions and our business
mix. All models are reviewed on an annual basis, and new
models or significant changes to existing models and their
assumptions are approved prior to implementation.
The model validation process incorporates a review of
models and trade and risk parameters across a broad range of
scenarios (including extreme conditions) in order to critically
evaluate and verify:
• The model’s conceptual soundness, including the
reasonableness of model assumptions, and suitability for
intended use;
• The testing strategy utilized by the model developers to
ensure that the models function as intended;
• The suitability of the calculation techniques incorporated
in the model;
• The model’s accuracy in reflecting the characteristics of the
related product and its significant risks;
• The model’s consistency with models for similar products;
and
• The model’s sensitivity to input parameters and
assumptions.
See “Critical Accounting Policies — Fair Value — Review of
Valuation Models,” “Liquidity Risk Management,” “Market
Risk Management,” “Credit Risk Management” and
“Operational Risk Management” for further information
about our use of models within these areas.
Other Risk Management
In addition to the areas of risks discussed above, we also
manage other risks, including capital, climate, compliance
and conflicts. These areas of risks are discussed below.
Capital Risk Management
Capital risk is the risk that our capital is insufficient to
support our business activities under normal and stressed
market conditions or we face capital reductions or RWA
increases, including from new or revised rules or changes in
interpretations of existing rules, and are therefore unable to
meet our internal capital targets or external regulatory
capital requirements. Capital adequacy is of critical
importance to us. Accordingly, we have in place a
comprehensive capital management policy that provides a
framework, defines objectives and establishes guidelines to
maintain an appropriate level and composition of capital in
both business-as-usual and stressed conditions. Our capital
management framework is designed to provide us with the
information needed to identify and comprehensively manage
risk, and develop and apply projected stress scenarios that
capture idiosyncratic vulnerabilities with a goal of holding
sufficient capital to remain adequately capitalized even after
experiencing a severe stress event. See “Capital Management
and Regulatory Capital” for further information about our
capital management process.
We have established a comprehensive governance structure to
manage and oversee our day-to-day capital management
activities and to ensure compliance with capital rules and
related policies. Our capital management activities are
overseen by the Board and its committees. The Board is
responsible for approving our annual capital plan and the
Risk Committee of the Board approves our capital
management policy, which details the risk committees and
members of senior management who are responsible for the
ongoing monitoring of our capital adequacy and evaluation
of current and future regulatory capital requirements, the
review of the results of our capital planning and stress tests
processes, and the results of our capital models. In addition,
our risk committees and senior management are responsible
for the review of our contingency capital plan, key capital
adequacy metrics, including regulatory capital ratios, and
capital plan metrics, such as the payout ratio, as well as
monitoring capital targets and potential breaches of capital
requirements.
Our process for managing capital risk also includes
independent review by Risk that, among other things,
assesses regulatory capital policies and related
interpretations, escalates certain interpretations to senior
management and/or the appropriate risk committee, and
performs calculation testing to corroborate alignment with
applicable capital rules.
Climate Risk Management
We categorize climate risk into physical risk and transition
risk. Physical risk is the risk that asset values may decline or
operations may be disrupted as a result of changes in the
climate, while transition risk is the risk that asset values may
decline because of changes in climate policies or changes in
the underlying economy due to decarbonization.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
167 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 169 of 205 --

As a global financial institution, climate-related risks
manifest in different ways across our businesses. We have
continued to make significant enhancements to our climate
risk management framework, including steps to further
integrate climate risk into our broader risk management
processes. We have integrated oversight of climate-related
risks into our risk management governance structure, from
senior management to our Board and its committees,
including the Risk and Public Responsibilities Committees.
The Risk Committee of the Board oversees firmwide
financial and nonfinancial risks, which include climate risk,
and, as part of its oversight, receives updates on our risk
management approach to climate risk, including our
approaches towards scenario analysis and integration into
existing risk management processes. The Public
Responsibilities Committee of the Board assists the Board in
its oversight of our firmwide sustainability strategy and
sustainability issues affecting us, including with respect to
climate change. As part of its oversight, the Public
Responsibilities Committee receives periodic updates on our
sustainability strategy, and also periodically reviews our
governance and related policies and processes for
sustainability and climate change-related risks. Senior
management within Risk, in conjunction with senior
management in both our revenue-producing units and our
other independent risk oversight and control functions, is
responsible for the development of our climate risk program.
We have begun incorporating climate risk into our credit
evaluation and underwriting processes for select industries.
Climate risk factors are now evaluated as part of transaction
due diligence for select loan commitments.
See “Business — Sustainability” in Part I, Item 1 and “Risk
Factors” in Part I, Item 1A of the 2022 Form 10-K for
information about our sustainability initiatives, including in
relation to climate transition.
Compliance Risk Management
Compliance risk is the risk of legal or regulatory sanctions,
material financial loss or damage to our reputation arising
from our failure to comply with the requirements of
applicable laws, rules and regulations, and our internal
policies and procedures. Compliance risk is inherent in all
activities through which we conduct our businesses. Our
Compliance Risk Management Program, administered by
Compliance, assesses our compliance, regulatory and
reputational risk; monitors for compliance with new or
amended laws, rules and regulations; designs and implements
controls, policies, procedures and training; conducts
independent testing; investigates, surveils and monitors for
compliance risks and breaches; and leads our responses to
regulatory examinations, audits and inquiries. We monitor
and review business practices to assess whether they meet or
exceed minimum regulatory and legal standards in all
markets and jurisdictions in which we conduct business.
Conflicts Management
Conflicts of interest and our approach to dealing with them
are fundamental to our client relationships, our reputation
and our long-term success. The term “conflict of interest”
does not have a universally accepted meaning, and conflicts
can arise in many forms within a business or between
businesses. The responsibility for identifying potential
conflicts, as well as complying with our policies and
procedures, is shared by all of our employees.
We have a multilayered approach to resolving conflicts and
addressing reputational risk. Our senior management
oversees policies related to conflicts resolution and, in
conjunction with Conflicts Resolution, Legal and
Compliance, and internal committees, formulates policies,
standards and principles, and assists in making judgments
regarding the appropriate resolution of particular conflicts.
Resolving potential conflicts necessarily depends on the facts
and circumstances of a particular situation and the
application of experienced and informed judgment.
As a general matter, Conflicts Resolution reviews financing
and advisory assignments in Global Banking & Markets and
certain of our investing, lending and other activities. In
addition, we have various transaction oversight committees,
such as the Firmwide Capital, Commitments and Suitability
Committees and other committees that also review new
underwritings, loans, investments and structured products.
These groups and committees work with internal and
external counsel and Compliance to evaluate and address any
actual or potential conflicts. The head of Conflicts
Resolution reports to our chief legal officer, who reports to
our chief executive officer.
We regularly assess our policies and procedures that address
conflicts of interest in an effort to conduct our business in
accordance with the highest ethical standards and in
compliance with all applicable laws, rules and regulations.
For further information about our risk management
processes, see “Overview and Structure of Risk
Management” and “Risk Factors” in Part I, Item 1A of the
2022 Form 10-K.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 168

-- 170 of 205 --

Available Information
Our internet address is www.goldmansachs.com and the
investor relations section of our website is located at
www.goldmansachs.com/investor-relations, where we make
available, free of charge, our annual reports on Form 10-K,
quarterly reports on Form 10-Q and current reports on Form
8-K and amendments to those reports filed or furnished
pursuant to Section 13(a) or 15(d) of the Exchange Act, as
well as proxy statements, as soon as reasonably practicable
after we electronically file such material with, or furnish it to,
the SEC. Also posted on our website, and available in print
upon request of any shareholder to our Investor Relations
Department (Investor Relations), are our certificate of
incorporation and by-laws, charters for our Audit, Risk,
Compensation, Corporate Governance and Nominating, and
Public Responsibilities Committees, our Policy Regarding
Director Independence Determinations, our Policy on
Reporting of Concerns Regarding Accounting and Other
Matters, our Corporate Governance Guidelines and our
Code of Business Conduct and Ethics governing our
directors, officers and employees. Within the time period
required by the SEC, we will post on our website any
amendment to the Code of Business Conduct and Ethics and
any waiver applicable to any executive officer, director or
senior financial officer.
Our website also includes information about (i) purchases
and sales of our equity securities by our executive officers and
directors; (ii) disclosure relating to certain non-GAAP
financial measures (as defined in the SEC’s Regulation G)
that we may make public orally, telephonically, by webcast,
by broadcast or by other means; (iii) our DFAST results; (iv)
the public portion of our resolution plan submission; (v) our
Pillar 3 disclosure; (vi) our average daily LCR; (vii) our
People Strategy Report; (viii) our Sustainability Report; and
(ix) our Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures
(TCFD) Report.
Investor Relations can be contacted at The Goldman Sachs
Group, Inc., 200 West Street, 29th Floor, New York, New
York 10282, Attn: Investor Relations, telephone:
212-902-0300, e-mail: gs-investor-relations@gs.com. We use
the following, as well as other social media channels, to
disclose public information to investors, the media and
others:
• Our website (www.goldmansachs.com);
• Our Twitter account (twitter.com/GoldmanSachs); and
• Our Instagram account (instagram.com/GoldmanSachs).
Our officers may use similar social media channels to disclose
public information. It is possible that certain information we
or our officers post on our website and on social media could
be deemed material, and we encourage investors, the media
and others interested in Goldman Sachs to review the
business and financial information we or our officers post on
our website and on the social media channels identified
above. The information on our website and those social
media channels is not incorporated by reference into this
Form 10-Q.
Forward-Looking Statements
We have included in this Form 10-Q, and our management
may make, statements that may constitute “forward-looking
statements” within the meaning of the safe harbor provisions
of the U.S. Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995.
Forward-looking statements are not historical facts or
statements of current conditions, but instead represent only
our beliefs regarding future events, many of which, by their
nature, are inherently uncertain and outside our control.
By identifying these statements for you in this manner, we are
alerting you to the possibility that our actual results, financial
condition, liquidity and capital actions may differ, possibly
materially, from the anticipated results, financial condition,
liquidity and capital actions in these forward-looking
statements. Important factors that could cause our results,
financial condition, liquidity and capital actions to differ
from those in these statements include, among others, those
described below and in “Risk Factors” in Part I, Item 1A of
the 2022 Form 10-K.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
169 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 171 of 205 --

These statements may relate to, among other things, (i) our
future plans and results, including our target ROE, ROTE,
efficiency ratio, CET1 capital ratio and firmwide AUS
inflows, and how they can be achieved, (ii) trends in or
growth opportunities for our businesses, including the
timing, costs, profitability, benefits and other aspects of
business and strategic initiatives and their impact on our
efficiency ratio, (iii) our level of future compensation
expense, including as a percentage of both operating expenses
and net revenues, net of provision for credit losses, (iv) our
Investment banking fees backlog and future results, (v) our
expected interest income and interest expense, (vi) our
expense savings and strategic locations initiatives, (vii)
expenses we may incur, including future litigation expense,
(viii) the projected growth of our deposits and other funding,
asset liability management and funding strategies and related
interest expense savings, (ix) our business initiatives,
including transaction banking, (x) our planned 2023
benchmark debt issuances, (xi) the amount, composition and
location of GCLA we expect to hold, (xii) our credit
exposures, (xiii) our expected provisions for credit losses,
(xiv) the adequacy of our allowance for credit losses, (xv) the
narrowing of our consumer business initiatives, (xvi) the
objectives and effectiveness of our BCP, information security
program, risk management and liquidity policies, (xvii) our
resolution plan and strategy and their implications for
stakeholders, (xviii) the design and effectiveness of our
resolution capital and liquidity models and triggers and alerts
framework, (xix) the results of stress tests, the effect of
changes to regulations, and our future status, activities or
reporting under banking and financial regulation, (xx) our
expected tax rate, (xxi) the future state of our liquidity and
regulatory capital ratios, and our prospective capital
distributions (including dividends and repurchases), (xxii)
our expected SCB and G-SIB surcharge, (xxiii) legal
proceedings, governmental investigations or other
contingencies, (xxiv) the asset recovery guarantee and our
remediation activities related to our 1Malaysia Development
Berhad (1MDB) settlements, (xxv) the effectiveness of our
management of our human capital, including our diversity
goals, (xxvi) our sustainability and carbon neutrality targets
and goals, (xxvii) future inflation, (xxviii) the impact of
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and related sanctions and other
developments on our business, results and financial position,
(xxix) our ability to sell, and the terms of any proposed sales
of, the remaining Marcus loans portfolio and Asset & Wealth
Management historical principal investments, and pending
sales of GreenSky and PFM, (xxx) the impact of the conflict
in the Middle East, (xxxi) our ability to reduce and manage
our commercial real estate exposures, and (xxxii) the timing
of the profitability of Platform Solutions.
Statements about our target ROE, ROTE, efficiency ratio
and expense savings, and how they can be achieved, are
based on our current expectations regarding our business
prospects and are subject to the risk that we may be unable to
achieve our targets due to, among other things, changes in
our business mix, lower profitability of new business
initiatives, increases in technology and other costs to launch
and bring new business initiatives to scale, and increases in
liquidity requirements.
Statements about our target ROE, ROTE and CET1 capital
ratio, and how they can be achieved, are based on our current
expectations regarding the capital requirements applicable to
us and are subject to the risk that our actual capital
requirements may be higher than currently anticipated
because of, among other factors, changes in the regulatory
capital requirements applicable to us resulting from changes
in regulations or the interpretation or application of existing
regulations or changes in the nature and composition of our
activities. Statements about our firmwide AUS inflows targets
are based on our current expectations regarding our
fundraising prospects and are subject to the risk that actual
inflows may be lower than expected due to, among other
factors, competition from other asset managers, changes in
investment preferences and changes in economic or market
conditions.
Statements about the timing, costs, profitability, benefits and
other aspects of business and expense savings initiatives, the
level and composition of more durable revenues, increases in
market share and the narrowing of our consumer business
initiatives are based on our current expectations regarding
our ability to implement these initiatives and actual results
may differ, possibly materially, from our current
expectations due to, among other things, a delay in the timing
of these initiatives, increased competition and an inability to
reduce expenses and grow businesses with durable revenues.
Statements about the level of future compensation expense,
including as a percentage of both operating expenses and net
revenues, net of provision for credit losses, and our efficiency
ratio are subject to the risks that the compensation and other
costs to operate our businesses, including platform initiatives,
may be greater than currently expected.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 170

-- 172 of 205 --

Statements about our Investment banking fees backlog and
future results are subject to the risk that such transactions
may be modified or may not be completed at all, and related
net revenues may not be realized or may be materially less
than expected. Important factors that could have such a
result include, for underwriting transactions, a decline or
weakness in general economic conditions, an outbreak or
worsening of hostilities, including the escalation of the
conflict in the Middle East or the continuation of the war
between Russia and Ukraine, continuing volatility in the
securities markets or an adverse development with respect to
the issuer of the securities and, for advisory transactions, a
decline in the securities markets, an inability to obtain
adequate financing, an adverse development with respect to a
party to the transaction or a failure to obtain a required
regulatory approval. For information about other important
factors that could adversely affect our Investment banking
fees, see “Risk Factors” in Part I, Item 1A of the 2022 Form
10-K.
Statements about the projected growth of our deposits and
other funding, asset liability management and funding
strategies and related interest expense savings, and our
platform solutions business, are subject to the risk that actual
growth, savings and profitability may differ, possibly
materially, from that currently anticipated due to, among
other things, changes in interest rates and competition from
other similar products.
Statements about planned 2023 benchmark debt issuances
and the amount, composition and location of GCLA we
expect to hold are subject to the risk that actual issuances and
GCLA levels may differ, possibly materially, from that
currently expected due to changes in market conditions,
business opportunities or our funding and projected liquidity
needs.
Statements about our expected provisions for credit losses are
subject to the risk that actual credit losses may differ and our
expectations may change, possibly materially, from that
currently anticipated due to, among other things, changes to
the composition of our loan portfolio and changes in the
economic environment in future periods and our forecasts of
future economic conditions, as well as changes in our models,
policies and other management judgments.
Statements about our future effective income tax rate are
subject to the risk that it may differ from the anticipated rate
indicated in such statements, possibly materially, due to,
among other things, changes in the tax rates applicable to us,
changes in our earnings mix, our profitability and entities in
which we generate profits, the assumptions we have made in
forecasting our expected tax rate, the interpretation or
application of existing tax statutes and regulations, as well as
any corporate tax legislation that may be enacted or any
guidance that may be issued by the U.S. Internal Revenue
Service.
Statements about the future state of our liquidity and
regulatory capital ratios (including our SCB and G-SIB
surcharge), and our prospective capital distributions
(including dividends and repurchases), are subject to the risk
that our actual liquidity, regulatory capital ratios and capital
distributions may differ, possibly materially, from what is
currently expected due to, among other things, the need to
use capital to support clients, increased regulatory
requirements resulting from changes in regulations or the
interpretation or application of existing regulations, results of
applicable supervisory stress tests, changes to the
composition of our balance sheet and the impact of taxes on
share repurchases. Statements about the estimated impact of
proposed, but not finalized, capital rules are subject to
change as we continue to analyze the proposals and are
subject to the risk that the final rules may differ from the
proposed rules, our assets and liabilities may change and we
may underestimate the actual impact of the final rules.
Statements about the risk exposure related to the asset
recovery guarantee provided to the Government of Malaysia
are subject to the risk that we may be unsuccessful in our
arbitration against the Government of Malaysia. Statements
about the progress or the status of remediation activities
relating to 1MDB are based on our expectations regarding
our current remediation plans. Accordingly, our ability to
complete the remediation activities may change, possibly
materially, from what is currently expected.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
171 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 173 of 205 --

Statements about our objectives in management of our
human capital, including our diversity goals, are based on
our current expectations and are subject to the risk that we
may not achieve these objectives and goals due to, among
other things, competition in recruiting and attracting diverse
candidates and unsuccessful efforts in retaining diverse
employees.
Statements about our sustainability and carbon neutrality
targets and goals are based on our current expectations and
are subject to the risk that we may not achieve these targets
and goals due to, among other things, global socio-
demographic and economic trends, energy prices, lack of
technological innovations, climate-related conditions and
weather events, legislative and regulatory changes, consumer
behavior and demand, and other unforeseen events or
conditions.
Statements about future inflation are subject to the risk that
actual inflation may differ, possibly materially, due to,
among other things, changes in economic growth,
unemployment or consumer demand.
Statements about the impact of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine
and related sanctions and other developments on our
business, results and financial position are subject to the risks
that hostilities may escalate and expand, that sanctions may
increase and that the actual impact may differ, possibly
materially, from what is currently expected.
Statements about the proposed sales of the remaining Marcus
loans portfolio and Asset & Wealth Management historical
principal investments are subject to the risks that buyers may
not bid on these assets or bid at levels, or with terms, that are
unacceptable to us, and that the performance of these
activities may deteriorate as a result of the pending sales, and
statements about the pending sales of GreenSky and PFM are
subject to the risk that the transactions may not close on the
anticipated timelines or at all, including due to a failure to
obtain requisite regulatory approvals.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC. AND SUBSIDIARIES
Management’s Discussion and Analysis
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 172

-- 174 of 205 --

Item 3. Quantitative and Qualitative
Disclosures About Market Risk
Quantitative and qualitative disclosures about market risk
are set forth in “Management’s Discussion and Analysis of
Financial Condition and Results of Operations — Risk
Management” in Part I, Item 2 of this Form 10-Q.
Item 4. Controls and Procedures
As of the end of the period covered by this report, an
evaluation was carried out by our management, with the
participation of our Chief Executive Officer and Chief
Financial Officer, of the effectiveness of our disclosure
controls and procedures (as defined in Rule 13a-15(e) under
the Exchange Act). Based on that evaluation, our Chief
Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer concluded that
these disclosure controls and procedures were effective as of
the end of the period covered by this report. In addition, no
change in our internal control over financial reporting (as
defined in Rule 13a-15(f) under the Exchange Act) occurred
during the quarter ended September 2023 that has materially
affected, or is reasonably likely to materially affect, our
internal control over financial reporting.
PART II. OTHER INFORMATION
Item 1. Legal Proceedings
We are involved in a number of judicial, regulatory and
arbitration proceedings concerning matters arising in
connection with the conduct of our businesses. Many of these
proceedings are in early stages, and many of these cases seek
an indeterminate amount of damages. We have estimated the
upper end of the range of reasonably possible aggregate loss
for matters where we have been able to estimate a range and
we believe, based on currently available information, that the
results of matters where we have not been able to estimate a
range of reasonably possible loss, in the aggregate, will not
have a material adverse effect on our financial condition, but
may be material to our operating results in a given period.
Given the range of litigation and investigations presently
under way, our litigation expenses may remain high. See
“Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial
Condition and Results of Operations — Use of Estimates” in
Part I, Item 2 of this Form 10-Q. See Notes 18 and 27 to the
consolidated financial statements in Part I, Item 1 of this
Form 10-Q for information about our reasonably possible
aggregate loss estimate and judicial, regulatory and legal
proceedings.
173 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 175 of 205 --

Item 2. Unregistered Sales of Equity
Securities, Use of Proceeds, and Issuer
Purchases of Equity Securities
The table below presents purchases made by or on behalf of
Group Inc. or any “affiliated purchaser” (as defined in Rule
10b-18(a)(3) under the Exchange Act) of our common stock
during the three months ended September 2023.
Total
Shares
Purchased
Average
Price Paid
Per Share
Total Shares
Purchased as
Part of a Publicly
Announced
Program
Dollar Value of
Remaining
Authorized
Repurchases
($ in millions)
July 3,611,548 $ 354.96 3,611,179 $ 25,422
August 616,677 $ 353.83 616,677 $ 25,204
September – $ – – $ 25,204
Total 4,228,225 4,227,856
In the table above, total shares purchased during July 2023
included 369 shares remitted to satisfy statutory withholding
taxes on the delivery of equity-based awards.
In February 2023, our Board approved a new share
repurchase program authorizing repurchases of up to $30
billion (in aggregate value and inclusive of shares repurchased
in 2023) of our common stock. This program replaced our
previous share repurchase program. The repurchase program
is effected primarily through regular open-market purchases
(which may include repurchase plans designed to comply
with Rule 10b5-1 and accelerated share repurchases), the
amounts and timing of which are determined primarily by
our current and projected capital position, but which may
also be influenced by general market conditions and the
prevailing price and trading volumes of our common stock.
The repurchase program has no set expiration or termination
date.
Item 5. Other Information
Amendment and Restatement of By-Laws
Effective November 3, 2023, the Board adopted amendments
to our Amended and Restated By-Laws (By-Laws) to make
certain technical clarifications and conforming revisions
primarily to update the By-Laws in line with developments
related to the SEC's universal proxy rules and recent changes
in Delaware law. Such changes include clarifying that
stockholders must comply with both the firm's advance notice
by-law requirements and the SEC's universal proxy
requirements, that nominating stockholders must disclose any
persons with whom they are acting in concert, the scope of
information to be provided regarding proposed director
nominees to assess eligibility and compliance with law,
including that completion of a questionnaire may be required,
and that the Board determines whether the specified advance
notice requirements are met with respect to a nomination or
proposal. Changes also include clarifying that beneficial
owners of common stock may call a special meeting and that
the Board may adopt rules, regulations and procedures for
the conduct of stockholder meetings, as well as revisions to
the availability of the stockholder list at the annual meeting in
alignment with Delaware law changes. The foregoing
summary does not purport to be complete and is qualified in
its entirety by reference to our By-Laws, which are attached
hereto as Exhibit 3.2 and incorporated by reference herein.
Rule 10b5-1 Trading Plans
During the three months ended September 2023, no directors
or executive officers entered into, modified or terminated,
contracts, instructions or written plans for the sale or
purchase of Group Inc.’s securities that were intended to
satisfy the affirmative defense conditions of Rule 10b5-1 or
that constituted non-Rule 10b5-1 trading arrangements (as
defined in Item 408 of Regulation S-K).
Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q 174

-- 176 of 205 --

Item 6. Exhibits
Exhibits
3.1 Restated Certificate of Incorporation of The
Goldman Sachs Group, Inc., amended as of
September 15, 2023 (incorporated by reference to
Exhibit 3.2 to the Registrant's Current Report on
Form 8-K, filed on September 18, 2023).
3.2 Amended and Restated By-Laws of The Goldman
Sachs Group, Inc., amended as of November 3, 2023.
15.1 Letter re: Unaudited Interim Financial Information.
31.1 Rule 13a-14(a) Certifications.
32.1 Section 1350 Certifications (This information is
furnished and not filed for purposes of Sections 11
and 12 of the Securities Act of 1933 and Section 18 of
the Securities Exchange Act of 1934).
101 Pursuant to Rules 405 and 406 of Regulation S-T, the
following information is formatted in iXBRL (Inline
eXtensible Business Reporting Language): (i) the
Consolidated Statements of Earnings for the three
and nine months ended September 30, 2023 and
September 30, 2022, (ii) the Consolidated Statements
of Comprehensive Income for the three and nine
months ended September 30, 2023 and September 30,
2022, (iii) the Consolidated Balance Sheets as of
September 30, 2023 and December 31, 2022, (iv) the
Consolidated Statements of Changes in Shareholders’
Equity for the three and nine months ended
September 30, 2023 and September 30, 2022, (v) the
Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows for the nine
months ended September 30, 2023 and September 30,
2022, (vi) the notes to the Consolidated Financial
Statements and (vii) the cover page.
104 Cover Page Interactive Data File (formatted in
iXBRL in Exhibit 101).
SIGNATURES
Pursuant to the requirements of the Securities Exchange Act
of 1934, the registrant has duly caused this report to be signed
on its behalf by the undersigned thereunto duly authorized.
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP, INC.
By: /s/ Denis P. Coleman III
Name: Denis P. Coleman III
Title: Chief Financial Officer
(Principal Financial Officer)
Date: November 3, 2023
By: /s/ Sheara J. Fredman
Name: Sheara J. Fredman
Title: Chief Accounting Officer
(Principal Accounting Officer)
Date: November 3, 2023
175 Goldman Sachs September 2023 Form 10-Q

-- 177 of 205 --

EXHIBIT 3.2
As Amended and Restated as of October 28, 2021 November 3, 2023
AMENDED AND
RESTATED BY-LAWS
OF
THE GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP,
INC.
ARTICLE I
Stockholders
Section 1.1 Annual Meetings. An annual meeting of stockholders shall be held for the election of
directors at such date, time and place (if any), either within or without the State of Delaware as may be
designated by the Board of Directors from time to time. Any other business properly brought before the
meeting may be transacted at the annual meeting.
Section 1.2 Special Meetings. (a) Special meetings of stockholders may be called at any time by,
and only by, (1) the Board of Directors or (2) solely to the extent required by Section 1.2(b), the Secretary
of the Corporation. Each special meeting shall be held at such date, time and place (if any) either within
or without the State of Delaware as may be stated in the notice of the meeting.
(b) A special meeting of the stockholders shall be called by the Secretary upon the written
request of the holders of recordstockholders of not less than twenty-five percent of the voting power of all
outstanding shares of common stock of the Corporation (the “Requisite Percent”), subject to the
following:
(1) In order for a special meeting upon stockholder request (a "Stockholder
Requested Special Meeting") to be called by the Secretary, one or more written requests for a
special meeting (each, a "Special Meeting Request," and collectively, the "Special Meeting
Requests") stating the purpose of the special meeting and the matters proposed to be acted upon
thereat must (x) be signed and dated by the Requisite Percent of stockholders, which shall include
either record holders of common stock of the Corporation (or their duly authorized agents),
mustbeneficial holders of such common who can demonstrate to the Corporation such indirect
ownership and entitlement to direct the vote of such stock (each a “Nominee Holder”), (y) be
delivered to the Secretary at the principal executive offices of the Corporation and must(z) set
forth:
(i) in the case of any director nominations proposed to be presented at such
Stockholder Requested Special Meeting, the information required by the third paragraph
of Section 1.11(b)(2);
(ii) in the case of any matter (other than a director nomination) proposed to be
conducted at such Stockholder Requested Special Meeting, the information required by
the fourth paragraph of Section 1.11(b)(3); and
(iii) an agreement by the requesting stockholder(s) to notify the Corporation
immediately in the case of any disposition prior to the record date for the Stockholder
Requested Special Meeting of shares of common stock of the Corporation owned of
record and an acknowledgement that any such disposition shall be deemed a revocation
of such Special Meeting Request to the extent of such disposition, such that the number
of shares
1

-- 178 of 205 --

disposed of shall not be included in determining whether the Requisite Percent has been
reached.
The Corporation will provide the requesting stockholder(s) with notice of the record date for the
determination of stockholders entitled to vote at the Stockholder Requested Special Meeting. Each
requesting stockholder is required to update the notice delivered pursuant to this Section not later than ten
business days after such record date to provide any material changes in the foregoing information as of
such record date.
In determining whether a special meeting of stockholders has been requested by the record
holders of sharesstockholders representing in the aggregate at least the Requisite Percent, multiple Special
Meeting Requests delivered to the Secretary will be considered together only if each such Special
Meeting Request
(i) identifies substantially the same purpose or purposes of the special meeting and substantially the same
matters proposed to be acted on at the special meeting (in each case as determined in good faith by the
Board of Directors), and (ii) has been dated and delivered to the Secretary within sixty days of the earliest
dated of such Special Meeting Requests. If the record holder is not the signatory to the Special Meeting
Request, is not the record holder or the Nominee Holder (if any), such Special Meeting Request will not
be valid unless documentary evidence is supplied to the Secretary at the time of delivery of such Special
Meeting Request (or within ten business days thereafter) of such signatory’s authority to execute the
Special Meeting Request on behalf of the record holder.any such stockholder. Any requesting stockholder
may revoke their or its Special Meeting Request at any time by written revocation delivered to the
Secretary at the principal executive offices of the Corporation; provided, however, that if following such
revocation (or any deemed revocation pursuant to Section 1.2(b)(1)(iii)), the unrevoked valid Special
Meeting Requests represent in the aggregate less than the Requisite Percent, there shall be no requirement
to hold a special meeting. The first date on which unrevoked valid Special Meeting Requests constituting
not less than the Requisite Percent shall have been delivered to the Corporation is referred to herein as the
“Request Receipt Date”.
(2) A Special Meeting Request shall not be valid if:
(i) the Special Meeting Request relates to an item of business that is not a
proper subject for stockholder action under applicable law;
(ii) the Request Receipt Date is during the period commencing ninety days
prior to the first anniversary of the date of the immediately preceding annual meeting and
ending on the date of the next annual meeting;
(iii) the purpose specified in the Special Meeting Request is not the election of
directors and an identical or substantially similar item (as determined in good faith by the
Board of Directors, a "Similar Item") was presented at any meeting of stockholders held
within the twelve months prior to the Request Receipt Date; or
(iv) a Similar Item is included in the Corporation's notice as an item of
business to be brought before a stockholder meeting that has been called but not yet held
or that is called for a date within ninety days of the Request Receipt Date.
(3) A Stockholder Requested Special Meeting shall be held at such date and time as
may be fixed by the Board of Directors; provided, however, that the Stockholder Requested
Special Meeting shall be called for a date not more than ninety days after the Request Receipt
Date.
(4) Business transacted at any Stockholder Requested Special Meeting shall be limited
to (A) the purpose(s) stated in the valid Special Meeting Request(s) received from the Requisite
2

-- 179 of 205 --

Percent of record holders and Nominee Holders and (B) any additional matters that the Board of
Directors determines to include in the Corporation’s notice of the meeting. If none of the
stockholdersrecord holders and Nominee Holders who submitted the Special Meeting Request
appears or sends a qualified representative to present the matters to be presented for consideration
that were specified in the Stockholder Meeting Request, the Corporation need not present such
matters for a vote at such meeting, notwithstanding that proxies in respect of such matter may
have been received by the Corporation.
Section 1.3 Notice of Meetings. Whenever stockholders are required or permitted to take any
action at a meeting, a notice of the meeting shall be given which shall state the place (if any), date and
hour of the meeting, and, in the case of a special meeting, the purpose or purposes for which the meeting
is called. Unless otherwise required by law, the certificate of incorporation or these by-laws, the notice of
any meeting shall be given not less than ten nor more than sixty days before the date of the meeting to
each stockholder entitled to vote at such meeting. Such notice shall be deemed to be given (i) if mailed,
when deposited in the United States mail, postage prepaid, directed to the stockholder at such
stockholder’s address as it appears on the records of the Corporation; (ii) if sent by electronic mail, when
delivered to an electronic mail address at which the stockholder has consented to receive such notice; and
(iii) if posted on an electronic network together with a separate notice to the stockholder of such specific
posting, upon the later to occur of (A) such posting and (B) the giving of such separate notice of such
posting. If given by any other means, notice shall be deemed given as provided by applicable law. Notice
shall be deemed to have been given to all stockholders of record who share an address if notice is given in
accordance with the “householding” rules set forth in Rule 14a-3(e) under the Securities Exchange Act of
1934 (the “Exchange Act”) and Section 233 of the Delaware General Corporation Law.
Section 1.4 Adjournments. Any meeting of stockholders, annual or special, may be adjourned
from time to time, for any reason or no reason, to reconvene at the same or some other place (if any), and
notice need not be given of any such adjourned meeting if the time and place thereof are announced at the
meeting at which the adjournment is taken. or are provided in any other manner permitted by the
Delaware General Corporation Law. At the adjourned meeting the Corporation may transact any business
which might have been transacted at the original meeting. If the adjournment is for more than thirty days,
or If after the adjournment a new record date is fixed for the adjourned meeting, a notice of the adjourned
meeting shall be given to each stockholder of record entitled to vote at the meeting. To the fullest extent
provided by law, the Board of Directors may postpone, reschedule or cancel any previously scheduled
annual or special meeting of stockholders.
Section 1.5 Quorum. At each meeting of stockholders, except where otherwise required by law,
the certificate of incorporation or these by-laws, the holders of a majority of the outstanding shares of
stock entitled to vote on a matter at the meeting, present in person or represented by proxy, shall
constitute a quorum. For purposes of the foregoing, where a separate vote by class or classes is required
for any matter, the holders of a majority of the outstanding shares of such class or classes, present in
person or represented by proxy, shall constitute a quorum to take action with respect to that vote on that
matter. Two or more classes or series of stock shall be considered a single class if the holders thereof are
entitled to vote together as a single class at the meeting. In the absence of a quorum of the holders of any
class or classes of stock entitled to vote on a matter, the meeting of such class or classes may be
adjourned from time to time, by the chair of the meeting or by the affirmative vote of the holders of the
shares of such class or classes which are present in person or by proxy and entitled to vote thereon, in
each case in the manner provided by Sections 1.4 and 1.6 of these by-laws until a quorum of such class
shall be so present or represented. Shares of capital stock shall neither be entitled to vote nor counted for
quorum purposes if such shares belong to
(i) the Corporation, (ii) another corporation, if a majority of the shares entitled to vote in the election of
directors of such other corporation is held, directly or indirectly, by the Corporation or (iii) any other
entity, if a majority of the voting power of such other entity is otherwise controlled, directly or indirectly,
by the
3

-- 180 of 205 --

Corporation; provided, however, that the foregoing shall not limit the right of the Corporation to vote
stock, including but not limited to its own stock, held by it in a fiduciary capacity.
Section 1.6 Organization. Meetings of stockholders shall be presided over by a chair of the
meeting, who shall be the Chairman of the Board, if any, or in the absence of a Chairman of the Board,
the Lead Director, if any, or, in the absence of the Lead Director, a chair of the meeting designated by the
Board of Directors, or in the absence of such designation, by a chair chosen at the meeting. A Secretary,
or in the absence of a Secretary an Assistant Secretary, shall act as secretary of the meeting, but in the
absence of a Secretary and any Assistant Secretary, the chair of the meeting may appoint any person to
act as secretary of the meeting.
The Board of Directors may adopt such rules, regulations and procedures for the conduct of the
meetings of stockholders as it deems appropriate. The order of business at each such meeting shall be as
determined by the chair of the meeting. The chair of the meeting shall have the right and authority to
convene and (for any or no reason) to recess and/or adjourn the meeting of stockholders without a vote of
stockholders and to prescribe such further rules, regulations and procedures and to do all such acts and
things as are necessary or desirable for the proper conduct of the meeting and are not inconsistent with
any rules or regulations adopted by the Board of Directors pursuant to the provisions of the certificate of
incorporation, including the establishment of procedures for the maintenance of order and safety,
limitations on the time allotted to questions or comments on the affairs of the Corporation, restrictions on
entry to such meeting after the time prescribed for the commencement thereof and the opening and
closing of the voting polls for each item upon which a vote is to be taken. The date and time of the
opening of the polls for each matter upon which the stockholders will vote at the meeting shall be
announced at the meeting.
Section 1.7 Inspectors. Prior to any meeting of stockholders, the Board of Directors, a Chairman
of the Board, the Lead Director, or any officer designated by the Board shall appoint one or more
inspectors to act at such meeting and make a written report thereof and may designate one or more
persons as alternate inspectors to replace any inspector who fails to act. If no inspector or alternate is able
to act at the meeting of stockholders, the chair of the meeting shall appoint one or more inspectors to act
at the meeting. Each inspector, before entering upon the discharge of their duties, shall take and sign an
oath faithfully to execute the duties of inspector with strict impartiality and according to the best of their
ability. The inspectors shall ascertain the number of shares outstanding and the voting power of each,
determine the shares represented at the meeting and the validity of proxies and ballots, count all votes and
ballots, determine and retain for a reasonable period a record of the disposition of any challenges made to
any determination by the inspectors and certify their determination of the number of shares represented at
the meeting and their count of all votes and ballots. The inspectors may appoint or retain other persons to
assist them in the performance of their duties. No ballot, proxy or vote, nor any revocation thereof or
change thereto, shall be accepted by the inspectors after the closing of the polls. In determining the
validity and counting of proxies and ballots, the inspectors shall be limited to an examination of the
proxies, any envelopes submitted therewith, any information provided by a stockholder who submits a
proxy by electronic transmission from which it can be determined that the proxy was authorized by the
stockholder, ballots and the regular books and records of the Corporation, and they may also consider
other reliable information for the limited purpose of reconciling proxies and ballots submitted by or on
behalf of banks, brokers, their nominees or similar persons which represent more votes than the holder of
a proxy is authorized by the record owner to cast or more votes than the stockholder holds of record. If the
inspectors consider other reliable information for such purpose, they shall, at the time they make their
certification, specify the precise information considered by them, including the person or persons from
whom they obtained the information, when the information was obtained, the means by which the
information was obtained and the basis for the inspectors’ belief that such information is accurate and
reliable.
4

-- 181 of 205 --

Section 1.8 Voting; Proxies. (a) Unless otherwise provided in the certificate of incorporation,
each stockholder entitled to vote at any meeting of stockholders shall be entitled to one vote for each
share of stock held by such stockholder which has voting power upon the matter in question. If the
certificate of incorporation provides for more or less than one vote for any share on any matter, every
reference in these by-laws to a majority or other proportion of shares of stock shall refer to such majority
or other proportion of the votes of such shares of stock. Each stockholder entitled to vote at a meeting of
stockholders may authorize another person or persons to act for such stockholder by proxy, (which proxy
shall, for the avoidance of doubt, comply with all applicable laws), but no such proxy shall be voted or
acted upon after three years from its date, unless the proxy provides for a longer period. A duly executed
proxy shall be irrevocable if it states that it is irrevocable and if, and only as long as, it is coupled with an
interest sufficient in law to support an irrevocable power, regardless of whether the interest with which it
is coupled is an interest in the stock itself or an interest in the Corporation generally. A stockholder may
revoke any proxy which is not irrevocable by attending the meeting and voting in person or by filing an
instrument in writing revoking the proxy or another duly executed proxy bearing a later date with a
Secretary. Voting at meetings of stockholders need not be by written ballot unless so directed by the chair
of the meeting or the Board of Directors. Any stockholder (including a Nominee Holder) directly or
indirectly soliciting proxies from other stockholders must use a proxy card color other than white, which
color shall be reserved for the exclusive use by the Board of Directors.
(b) In all matters, unless otherwise required by law, rule or regulation applicable to the
Corporation or the certificate of incorporation or these by-laws (including, without limitation, Section
2.2), the affirmative vote of not less than a majority of shares present in person or represented by proxy at
the meeting and entitled to vote on such matter, with all shares of common stock of the Corporation and
other stock of the Corporation entitled to vote on such matter considered for this purpose as a single class,
shall be the act of the stockholders. Where a separate vote by class or classes is required, the affirmative
vote of the holders of not less than a majority (or, in the case of an election of directors, a plurality) of
shares present in person or represented by proxy at the meeting by stockholders in that class or classes
entitled to vote on such matter shall be the act of such class or classes, except as otherwise required by
law, rule or regulation or the certificate of incorporation or these by-laws. For purposes of this Section
1.8, votes cast "for" or "against" and "abstentions" with respect to such matter shall be counted as shares
of stock of the Corporation entitled to vote on such matter, while "broker nonvotes" (or other shares of
stock of the Corporation similarly not entitled to vote) shall not be counted as shares entitled to vote on
such matter.
Section 1.9 Fixing Date for Determination of Stockholders of Record. In order that the
Corporation may determine the stockholders entitled to notice of any meeting of stockholders or any
adjournment thereof, the Board of Directors may fix a record date, which record date will be the same
date for determining stockholders who are entitled to vote at the meeting unless otherwise specified, and
which date shall not precede the date upon which the resolution fixing the record date is adopted by the
Board of Directors, and which record date shall not be more than sixty nor less than ten days before the
date of such meeting. If no record date is fixed by the Board of Directors, the record date for determining
stockholders entitled to notice of or to vote at a meeting of stockholders shall be at the close of business
on the day next preceding the day on which notice is given, or, if notice is waived, at the close of business
on the day next preceding the day on which the meeting is held. A determination of stockholders of
record entitled to notice of or to vote at a meeting of stockholders shall apply to any adjournment of the
meeting; provided, however, that the Board of Directors may fix a new record date (which shall, unless
otherwise specified, be the same date for notice and voting) for the adjourned meeting.
In order that the Corporation may determine the stockholders entitled to receive payment
of any dividend or other distribution or allotment of any rights or the stockholders entitled to exercise any
rights in respect of any change, conversion or exchange of stock, or for the purpose of any other lawful
action, the Board of Directors may fix a record date, which record date shall not precede the date upon
5

-- 182 of 205 --

which the resolution fixing the record date is adopted, and which record date shall be not more than sixty
days prior to the action for which a record date is being established. If no record date is fixed, the record
date for determining stockholders for any such purpose shall be at the close of business on the day on
which the Board of Directors adopts the resolution relating thereto.
Section 1.10 List of Stockholders Entitled to Vote. A Secretary shall prepare and make, at least
ten days before every meeting of stockholders, a complete list of the stockholders entitled to vote at the
meeting, arranged in alphabetical order, and showing the address of each stockholder and the number of
shares registered in the name of each stockholder.; provided, that nothing contained in this section shall
require the Corporation to include electronic mail addresses or other electronic contact information on
such list. Such list shall be open to the examination of any stockholder, for any purpose germane to the
meeting, during ordinary business hours, for a period of at least ten10 days prior to thesaid meeting, either
at(i) on a place within the municipality where the meeting is reasonably accessible electronic network,
provided that the information required to be held, which place shall be specified in gain access to such list
is provided with the notice of the meeting, or, if not so specified, at (ii) during ordinary business hours at
the principal place of business of the Corporation. In the event that the place whereCorporation
determines to make the meeting is to be held. The list shall also be produced and kept atlist available on
an electronic network, the meeting during the whole time thereof andCorporation may be inspectedtake
reasonable steps (as determined by any stockholder who is presentthe Corporation in its sole discretion) to
ensure that such information is available only to stockholders of the Corporation.
Section 1.11 Advance Notice of Stockholder Nominees for Director and Other Stockholder
Proposals. (a) The matters to be considered and brought before any annual or special meeting of
stockholders of the Corporation (other than a Stockholder Requested Special Meeting) shall be limited to
only such matters, including the nomination and election of directors, as shall be brought properly before
such meeting in compliance with the procedures set forth in this Section 1.11 and in Section 1.12, as the
case may be.
(b) For any matter to be properly brought before any annual meeting of stockholders, the
matter must be (1w) specified in the notice of annual meeting given by or at the direction of the Board of
Directors, (2x) otherwise brought before the annual meeting by or at the direction of the Board of
Directors, (3y) brought before the annual meeting in the manner specified in this Section 1.11(b) (i) by a
stockholder that either (i) holds of record stock of the Corporation entitled to vote at the annual meeting
on such matter (including any election of a director) or (ii) byis a person (a “Nominee Holder”) that holds
such stock through a nominee or “street name” holder of record of such stock and can demonstrate to the
Corporation such indirect ownership of, and such Nominee Holder’s entitlement to direct the vote of,
such stock on such matter, or (4z) brought before the annual meeting in accordance with Section 1.12.
(1) In addition to any other requirements under applicable law, (including, without limitation,
Rule 14a-19 under the Exchange Act), the certificate of incorporation and these by-laws, and except as
provided in Section 1.12, persons nominated by stockholders for election as directors of the Corporation
and any other proposals by stockholders shall be properly brought before an annual meeting of
stockholders only if notice of any such matter to be presented by a stockholder at such meeting (a
“Stockholder Notice”) shall be delivered to a Secretary at the principal executive office of the
Corporation not less than ninety nor more than one hundred and twenty days prior to the first anniversary
date of the annual meeting for the preceding year; provided, however, that if and only if the annual
meeting is not scheduled to be held within a period that commences thirty days before and ends thirty
days after such anniversary date (an annual meeting date outside such period being referred to herein as
an “Other Meeting Date”), such Stockholder Notice shall be given in the manner provided herein by the
later of (i) the close of business on the date ninety days prior to such Other Meeting Date or (ii) the close
of business on the tenth day following the date on which such Other Meeting Date is first publicly
announced or disclosed. For the avoidance of
6

-- 183 of 205 --

doubt, the preceding deadlines for a Stockholder Notice shall be operative with respect to any notice to be
delivered to the Corporation pursuant to Rule 14a-19 under the Exchange Act.
(2) Any stockholder desiring to nominate any person or persons (as the case may be) for
election as a director or directors of the Corporation at an annual meeting of stockholders pursuant to this
Section 1.11 shall deliver, as part of such Stockholder Notice, a statement in writing setting forth the
name of the person or persons to be nominated, the number and class of all shares of each class of stock
of the Corporation owned of record and/or beneficially by each such person, as reported to such
stockholder by such person,; the factual information regarding each such person required by paragraphs
(a), (e) and (f) of Item 401 of Regulation S-K adopted by the Securities and Exchange Commission, (and
any other factual information that may be required by duly adopted rules and regulations of the Securities
and Exchange Commission); each such person’s signed consent to serve as a director of the Corporation if
elected,; a questionnaire and representation completed with respect to, and signed by, each such person, in
each case, in the form provided by the Corporation (which such stockholder shall request from the
Corporation and the Corporation shall provide within 10 days after receiving such a request); such
stockholder’s name and address,; the number and class of all shares of each class of stock of the
Corporation owned of record and/or beneficially by such stockholder and,; the names of any other persons
with whom the stockholder is acting in concert (“interested person”), the number and class of all shares of
each class of stock of the Corporation owned of record and/or beneficially by any such interested person,
and a summary of any material arrangements by or among any proposed nominee, the stockholder and/or
any interested person (including any arrangement among such persons or between such persons and any
other person (naming such other person) pursuant to which the nomination or nominations are to be
made); and in the case of a Nominee Holder, evidence establishing such Nominee Holder’s indirect
ownership of stock and entitlement to direct the vote of such stock for the election of directors at the
annual meeting. As used in these by-laws (other than for purposes of Section 1.12), shares “beneficially
owned” shall mean all shares that such person is deemed to beneficially own pursuant to Rules 13d-3 and
13d-5 under the Exchange Act.
The Corporation may require any proposed director nominee to furnish such other information as
it may reasonably require to determine the eligibility of such proposed nominee to serve as an
independent director of the Corporation and to comply with applicable law. otherwise comply with
applicable laws, rules and regulations relating to director qualifications, conflicts of interest, and/or the
disclosure thereof (which, for the avoidance of doubt, may include information of the type referenced in
Sections 1.12(d)(2) (v), (viii), (ix), (x) and/or (xii) below).
If a stockholder is entitled to vote only for a specific class or category of directors at a meeting
(annual or special), such stockholder’sperson’s right to nominate one or more individuals for election as a
director at the meeting shall be limited to such class or category of directors. The number of nominees a
stockholder or Nominee Holder may nominate for election at the annual meeting shall not exceed the
number of directors to be elected at such annual meeting.
(3) Any stockholder who gives a Stockholder Notice of any matter (other than a nomination
for director or as provided in Section 1.12) proposed to be brought before an annual meeting of
stockholders shall deliver, as part of such Stockholder Notice, the text of the proposal to be presented and
a brief written statement of the reasons why such stockholder favors the proposal and setting forth such
stockholder’s name and address, the number and class of all shares of each class of stock of the
Corporation owned of record and/or beneficially by such stockholder, any material interest of such
stockholder in the matter proposed (other than as a stockholder), if applicable, and, in the case of a
Nominee Holder, evidence establishing such Nominee Holder’s indirect ownership of stock and
entitlement to direct the vote of such stock on the matter proposed at the annual meeting.
7

-- 184 of 205 --

As used in these by-laws (other than for purposes of Section 1.12), shares “beneficially owned”
shall mean all shares which such person is deemed to beneficially own pursuant to Rules 13d-3 and 13d-5
under the Exchange Act.
(4) Notwithstanding any provision of this Section 1.11 to the contrary, in the event that the
number of directors to be elected to the Board of Directors of the Corporation at the next annual meeting
of stockholders is increased by virtue of an increase in the size of the Board of Directors and either all of
the nominees for director at the next annual meeting of stockholders or the size of the increased Board of
Directors is not publicly announced or disclosed by the Corporation at least one hundred days prior to the
first anniversary of the preceding year’s annual meeting, a Stockholder Notice shall also be considered
timely under this Section 1.11, but only with respect to nominees to stand for election at the next annual
meeting as the result of any new positions created by such increase, if it shall be delivered to a Secretary
at the principal executive office of the Corporation not later than the close of business on the tenth day
following the first day on which all such nominees or the size of the increased Board of Directors shall
have been publicly announced or disclosed.
(c) For any matter to be properly brought before a special meeting of stockholders, the matter
must be set forth in the Corporation’s notice of such meeting given by or at the direction of the Board of
Directors or by the Secretary of the Company pursuant to Section 1.2(a)(ii). In the event the Corporation
calls a special meeting of stockholders for the purpose of electing one or more directors to the Board of
Directors, any stockholder entitled to vote for the election of such director(s) at such meeting may
nominate a person or persons (as the case may be) for election to such position(s) as are specified in the
Corporation’s notice of such meeting, but only if a Stockholder Notice containing the information
required by the third paragraph of Section 1.11(b) hereof)(2) shall be delivered to a Secretary at the
principal executive office of the Corporation not later than the close of business on the tenth day
following the first day on which the date of the special meeting and either the names of all nominees
proposed by the Board of Directors to be elected at such meeting or the number of directors to be elected
shall have been publicly announced or disclosed.
(d) For purposes of this Section 1.11, a matter shall be deemed to have been “publicly
announced or disclosed” if such matter is disclosed in a press release reported by a national news service
or in a document publicly filed by the Corporation with the Securities and Exchange Commission.
(e) In no event shall the postponement or adjournment of an annual meeting already publicly
noticed or a special meeting, or any announcement thereof, commence a new period (or extend any
period) for the giving of notice as provided in this Section 1.11. This Section 1.11 shall not apply to (1)
any stockholder proposal made pursuant to, and in compliance with, Rule 14a-8 under the Exchange Act,
(2) any nomination of a director in an election in which only the holders of one or more series of
Preferred Stock of the Corporation issued pursuant to Article FOURTH of the certificate of incorporation
are entitled to vote (unless otherwise provided in the terms of such stock), (3) any director nomination
pursuant to Section 1.12 or (4) any Stockholder Requested Special Meeting except as specifically
provided in Section 1.2(b).
(f)
(f) If the Board of Directors determines that any requirement under the by-laws, other governance
documents or policies, or any other applicable law, rule or regulation has not been satisfied as to any
business proposed to be brought before or any nomination proposed to be considered at a meeting of
stockholders, then the Board of Directors may elect, in its sole discretion, to (x) waive such deficiency,
(y) provide the stockholder with an opportunity to cure such deficiency, or (z) decline to allow the
proposed nomination or business to be transacted at the meeting. Regardless of whether the Board of
Directors has made such a determination with respect to a particular proposed nomination or business,
except as otherwise provided by law, the certificate of incorporation or these by-laws, the chair of any
meeting of stockholders,
8

-- 185 of 205 --

in addition to making any other determinations that may be appropriate to the conduct of the meeting
pursuant to Section 1.6, shall have the power and duty to determine whether notice of nominees and other
matters proposed to be brought before a meeting has been duly given in the manner provided in this
Section
1.11 or Section 1.2, as applicable and, if not so given, shall direct and declare at the meeting that such
nominees and other matters shall not be considered.
Section 1.12 Stockholder Nominations Included in the Corporation’s Proxy Materials. (Proxy
Access).
(a) Inclusion of Proxy Access Nominee in Proxy Statement. Subject to the provisions of this
Section 1.12, if expressly requested in the relevant Nomination Notice (as defined below), the
Corporation shall include in its proxy statement for any annual meeting of stockholders (but not at any
special meeting of stockholders):
(1) the name of any person nominated for election (the “Proxy Access Nominee”),
which shall also be included on the Corporation’s form of proxy and ballot, by any Nominating
Stockholder (as defined below);
(2) disclosure about the Proxy Access Nominee and the Nominating Stockholder
required under the rules of the Securities and Exchange Commission or other applicable law to be
included in the proxy statement;
(3) any statement included by the Nominating Stockholder in the Nomination Notice
for inclusion in the proxy statement in support of the Proxy Access Nominee’s election to the
Board of Directors (subject, without limitation, to Section 1.12(e)(ii)), if such statement does not
exceed 500 words; and
(4) any other information that the Corporation or the Board of Directors determines, in
their discretion, to include in the proxy statement relating to the nomination of the Proxy Access
Nominee, including, without limitation, (i) any statement in opposition to the nomination, (ii) any
of the information provided pursuant to this Section 1.12 and (iii) any solicitation materials or
related information with respect to the Proxy Access Nominee.
For purposes of this Section 1.12, any determination to be made by the Board of Directors may be
made by the Board of Directors, a committee of the Board or any officer of the Corporation designated by
the Board of Directors or a committee of the Board and any such determination shall be final and binding
on the Corporation, any Eligible Holder, any Nominating Stockholder, any Proxy Access Nominee and
any other person so long as made in good faith (without any further requirements). The chair of any
annual meeting of stockholders, in addition to making any other determinations that may be appropriate to
the conduct of the meeting, shall have the power and duty to determine whether a Proxy Access Nominee
has been nominated in accordance with the requirements of this Section 1.12 and, if not so nominated,
shall direct and declare at the meeting that such Proxy Access Nominee shall not be considered.
(b) Maximum Number of Proxy Access Nominees.
(1) The Corporation shall not be required to include in the proxy statement for an
annual meeting of stockholders more Proxy Access Nominees than that number of directors
constituting the greater of (i) two or (ii) twenty percent of the total number of directors of the
Corporation on the last day on which a Nomination Notice may be submitted pursuant to this
Section 1.12 (rounded down to the nearest whole number) (the “Maximum Number”). In the
event that one or more vacancies for any reason occurs on the Board of Directors after the
deadline set forth in Section 1.12(d) below but before the date of the annual meeting, and the
Board of Directors
9

-- 186 of 205 --

resolves to reduce the size of the board in connection therewith, the Maximum Number shall be
calculated based on the number of directors in office as so reduced. The Maximum Number for a
particular annual meeting shall be reduced by (i) Proxy Access Nominees who are subsequently
withdrawn, (ii) Proxy Access Nominees that the Board of Directors itself decides to nominate for
election at such annual meeting and (iii) the number of incumbent directors of the Corporation
who had been Proxy Access Nominees with respect to any of the preceding two annual meetings
of stockholders and whose reelection at the upcoming annual meeting is being recommended by
the Board of Directors.
(2) If the number of Proxy Access Nominees pursuant to this Section 1.12 for any
annual meeting of stockholders exceeds the Maximum Number then, promptly upon notice from
the Corporation, each Nominating Stockholder will select one Proxy Access Nominee for
inclusion in the proxy statement until the Maximum Number is reached, going in order of the
amount (largest to smallest) of the ownership position as disclosed in each Nominating
Stockholder’s Nomination Notice, with the process repeated if the Maximum Number is not
reached after each Nominating Stockholder has selected one Proxy Access Nominee. If, after the
deadline for submitting a Nomination Notice as set forth in Section 1.12(d), a Nominating
Stockholder becomes ineligible or withdraws its nomination or a Proxy Access Nominee becomes
unwilling to serve on the Board of Directors, whether before or after the mailing of the definitive
proxy statement, then the nomination shall be disregarded, and the Corporation (i) shall not be
required to include in its proxy statement or on any ballot or form of proxy the disregarded Proxy
Access Nominee or any successor or replacement nominee proposed by the Nominating
Stockholder or by any other Nominating Stockholder and (ii) may otherwise communicate to its
stockholders, including without limitation by amending or supplementing its proxy statement or
ballot or form of proxy, that the Proxy Access Nominee will not be included as a Proxy Access
Nominee in the proxy statement or on any ballot or form of proxy and will not be voted on at the
annual meeting.
(c) Eligibility of Stockholder Nominating StockholderProxy Access Nominees.
(1) An “Eligible Holder” is a person who has either (i) been a record holder of the
shares of common stock used to satisfy the eligibility requirements in this Section 1.12(c)
continuously for the three-year period specified in Section 1.12(c)(2) below or (ii) provides to a
Secretary of the Corporation, within the time period referred to in Section 1.12(d), evidence of
continuous ownership of such shares for such three-year period from one or more securities
intermediaries in a form that the Board of Directors determines would be deemed acceptable for
purposes of a shareholder proposal under Rule 14a-8(b)(2) under the Exchange Act (or any
successor rule).
(2) An Eligible Holder or group of up to fifteen Eligible Holders may submit a
nomination in accordance with this Section 1.12 only if the person or group (in the aggregate) has
continuously owned at least the Minimum Number (as defined below) of shares of the
Corporation’s common stock throughout the three-year period preceding and including the date of
submission of the Nomination Notice, and continues to own at least the Minimum Number
through the date of the annual meeting. Each Eligible Holder or group of up to fifteen Eligible
Holders that submits a nomination in accordance with this Section 1.12 and has satisfied, as
determined by the Board of Directors, all applicable conditions and complied with all applicable
procedures set forth in this Section 1.12 is a “Nominating Stockholder”. A group of funds that are
(i) under common management and investment control, (ii) under common management and
funded primarily by a single employer or (iii) a “group of investment companies,” as such term is
defined in Section 12(d)(1)(G)(ii) of the Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended, shall be
treated as one Eligible Holder if such Eligible Holder shall provide together with the Nomination
Notice
10

-- 187 of 205 --

documentation reasonably satisfactory to the Corporation that demonstrates that the funds meet
the criteria set forth in clauses (i), (ii) or (iii) of this Section 1.12(c)(2). For the avoidance of
doubt, in the event of a nomination by a Nominating Stockholder that includes more than one
Eligible Holder, any and all requirements and obligations for an individual Eligible Holder that
are set forth in this Section 1.12, including the minimum holding period, shall apply to each
individual Eligible Holder comprising the Nominating Stockholder; provided, however, that the
Minimum Number shall apply to the ownership of the Nominating Stockholder in the aggregate.
Should any Eligible Holder withdraw from a group of Eligible Holders constituting a Nominating
Stockholder at any time prior to the annual meeting of stockholders, the Nominating Stockholder
shall only be deemed to own the shares held by the remaining Eligible Holders. As used in this
Section 1.12, any reference to a “group” or “group of Eligible Holders” refers to any Nominating
Stockholder that consists of more than one Eligible Holder and to all the Eligible Holders that
make up such Nominating Stockholder.
(3) The “Minimum Number” of shares of the Corporation’s common stock means
three percent of the number of outstanding shares of common stock as of the most recent date for
which such amount is given in any filing by the Corporation with the Securities and Exchange
Commission prior to the submission of the Nomination Notice.
(4) For purposes of this Section 1.12, an Eligible Holder “owns” only those
outstanding shares of the Corporation as to which the Eligible Holder possesses both (i) the full
voting and investment rights pertaining to the shares and (ii) the full economic interest in
(including the opportunity for profit and risk of loss on) such shares; provided that the number of
shares calculated in accordance with clauses (i) and (ii) shall not include any shares (A) sold by
such Eligible Holder or any of its affiliates in any transaction that has not been settled or closed,
(B) purchased by such Eligible Holder or any of its affiliates but the purchase has not yet been
settled or closed, (C) borrowed by such Eligible Holder or any of its affiliates for any purpose or
purchased by such Eligible Holder or any of its affiliates pursuant to an agreement to resell or
subject to any other obligation to resell to another person, or (D) subject to any option, warrant,
forward contract, swap, contract of sale, other derivative or similar agreement entered into by
such Eligible Holder or any of its affiliates, whether any such instrument or agreement is to be
settled with shares or with cash based on the notional amount or value of outstanding shares of
the Corporation, in any such case which instrument or agreement has, or is intended to have, the
purpose or effect of (x) reducing in any manner, to any extent or at any time in the future, such
Eligible Holder’s or any of its affiliates’ full right to vote or direct the voting of any such shares,
and/or (y) hedging, offsetting, or altering to any degree, gain or loss arising from the full
economic ownership of such shares by such Eligible Holder or any of its affiliates.
An Eligible Holder “owns” shares held in the name of a nominee or other intermediary so
long as the Eligible Holder retains the right to instruct how the shares are voted with respect to
the election of directors and possesses the full economic interest in the shares. An Eligible
Holder’s ownership of shares shall be deemed to continue during any period in which the Eligible
Holder has delegated any voting power by means of a proxy, power of attorney, or other similar
instrument or arrangement that is revocable at any time by the Eligible Holder. An Eligible
Holder’s ownership of shares shall be deemed to continue during any period in which the Eligible
Holder has loaned such shares provided that the Eligible Holder has the power to recall such
loaned shares within a reasonable period of time and will recall such loaned shares as of the date
of the annual meeting. The terms “owned,” “owning” and other variations of the word “own”
shall have correlative meanings. Whether outstanding shares of the Corporation are “owned” for
these purposes shall be determined by the Board of Directors.
11

-- 188 of 205 --

(5) No Eligible Holder shall be permitted to be a part of more than one group of
Eligible Holders constituting a Nominating Stockholder, and if any Eligible Holder appears as a
member of more than one group, such Eligible Holder shall be deemed to be a member of the
group of Eligible Holders that has the largest ownership position as reflected in the Nomination
Notice.
(6) Any Eligible Holder (including each Eligible Holder whose stock ownership is
counted as part of a group for the purposes of qualifying as a Nominating Stockholder) whose
Proxy Access Nominee is elected as a director at the annual meeting of stockholders will not be
eligible to nominate or participate in the nomination of a Proxy Access Nominee for the
following two annual meetings of stockholders pursuant to this Section 1.12 other than
nominating (either individually or as a part of a group constituting a Nominating Stockholder) a
Proxy Access Nominee previously nominated and elected pursuant to this Section 1.12 by such
Eligible Holder or a group of Eligible Holders of which such Eligible Holder was a member.
(d) Proxy Access Nomination Notice. To nominate a Proxy Access Nominee, the Nominating
Stockholder must, no earlier than one hundred and fifty days and no later than one hundred and twenty
days before the anniversary of the date that the Corporation mailed its proxy statement for the prior year’s
annual meeting of stockholders, submit to a Secretary of the Corporation at the principal executive office
of the Corporation all of the following information and documents (collectively, the “Nomination
Notice”); provided, however, that if and only if the annual meeting is scheduled for an Other Meeting
Date, the Nomination Notice shall be given in the manner provided herein by the later of (x) one hundred
and fifty days prior to such Other Meeting Date and (y) the tenth day following the date such Other
Meeting Date is first publicly announced or disclosed:
(1) A Schedule 14N (or any successor form) relating to the Proxy Access Nominee,
completed and filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission by the Nominating
Stockholder as applicable, in accordance with Securities and Exchange Commission rules;
(2) A written notice of the nomination of such Proxy Access Nominee that includes
the following additional information, agreements, representations and warranties by the Nominating
Stockholder (including each group member):
(i) the information required with respect to the nomination of directors
pursuant to Section 1.11(b)(2) of these by-laws;
(ii) the details of any relationship that existed within the past three years and
that would have been described pursuant to Item 6(e) of Schedule 14N (or any successor
item) if it existed on the date of submission of the Schedule 14N;
(iii) a representation and warranty that the Nominating Stockholder did not
acquire, and is not holding, securities of the Corporation for the purpose or with the effect
of influencing or changing control of the Corporation;
(iv) a representation and warranty that the Proxy Access Nominee’s candidacy
or, if elected, Board membership would not violate applicable state or federal law or the
rules of any stock exchange on which the Corporation’s securities are traded;
(v) a representation and warranty that the Proxy Access Nominee:
(A) is not aware of any direct or indirect relationship the Proxy Access
Nominee has with the Corporation other than those relationships that have been
deemed categorically immaterial pursuant to the Corporation’s Policy Regarding
12

-- 189 of 205 --

Director Independence Determinations as most recently published on its website
and otherwise qualifies as independent under the bright-line rules of the primary
stock exchange on which the Corporation’s securities are traded;
(B) is not aware of any information that would make the Proxy Access
Nominee fail to meet the audit committee and compensation committee
independence requirements under the rules of the primary stock exchange on
which the Corporation’s securities are traded;
(C) is not aware of any information that would make the Proxy Access
Nominee fail to be a “non-employee director” for the purposes of Rule 16b-3
under the Exchange Act (or any successor rule); and
(D) is not aware of any information that would make the Proxy
Access Nominee fail to be an “outside director” for the purposes of Section
162(m) of the Internal Revenue Code (or any successor provision); and
(E(D) is not and has not been subject to any event specified in Rule
506(d)(1) of Regulation D (or any successor rule) under the Securities Act of
1933 or Item 401(f) of Regulation S-K (or any successor rule) under the
Exchange Act, without reference to whether the event is material to an evaluation
of the ability or integrity of the Proxy Access Nominee;
(vi) a representation and warranty that the Nominating Stockholder satisfies
the eligibility requirements set forth in Section 1.12(c) and has provided evidence of
ownership to the extent required by Section 1.12(c)(1);
(vii) a representation and warranty that the Nominating Stockholder intends to
continue to satisfy the eligibility requirements described in Section 1.12(c) through the
date of the annual meeting and currently intends in good faith to continue to hold the
Minimum Number of shares for at least one year following the annual meeting; provided,
however, that any Nominating Stockholder that is a registered open-end mutual fund
under the Investment Company Act of 1940, and that seeks to replicate an index, will not
violate this requirement as a result of changes to its common stock holdings in response
to changes in the index or weightings of the securities in the index;
(viii) a statement detailing whether the Proxy Access Nominee is experienced in
matters of risk management for purposes of Regulation YY of the Federal Reserve
Board;
(ix) details of any position of the Proxy Access Nominee as an officer or
director of any competitor (that is, any entity that produces products or provides services
that compete with or are alternatives to the principal products produced or services
provided by the Corporation or its affiliates) of the Corporation, within the three years
preceding the submission of the Nomination Notice;
(x) details of any relationship between the Proxy Access Nominee and any
entity that would require disclosure on Schedule 13D as if the Proxy Access Nominee
was required to file a Schedule 13D with respect to the company;
(xi) details of any shares of the Corporation owned by the Proxy Access
Nominee that are (A) pledged by the Proxy Access Nominee or otherwise subject to a
lien, charge or other encumbrance or (B) subject to any option, warrant, forward contract,
swap,
13

-- 190 of 205 --

contract of sale, other derivative or similar agreement entered into by such Proxy Access
Nominee, whether any such instrument or agreement is to be settled with shares or with
cash based on the notional amount or value of outstanding shares of the Corporation, in
any such case which instrument or agreement has, or is intended to have, the purpose or
effect of (x) reducing in any manner, to any extent or at any time in the future, such
Proxy Access Nominee’s full right to vote or direct the voting of any such shares, and/or
(y) hedging, offsetting, or altering to any degree, gain or loss arising from the full
economic ownership of such shares by such Proxy Access Nominee;
(xii) details of any compensatory, payment or other financial agreement,
arrangement or understanding with any person or entity in connection with service or
action as a director of the Corporation;
(xiii) a representation and warranty that the Nominating Stockholder will not
engage in a “solicitation” within the meaning of Rule 14a-1(l) (without reference to the
exception in Section 14a-(l)(2)(iv)) (or any successor rules) with respect to the annual
meeting, other than with respect to its Proxy Access Nominee or any nominee of the
Board of Directors;
(xiv) a representation and warranty that the Nominating Stockholder will not
use any proxy card other than the Corporation’s proxy card in soliciting stockholders in
connection with the election of a Proxy Access Nominee at the annual meeting;
(xv) if desired, a statement for inclusion in the proxy statement in support of
the Proxy Access Nominee’s election to the Board of Directors, provided that such
statement shall not exceed 500 words and shall fully comply with Section 14 of the
Exchange Act and the rules and regulations thereunder, including Rule 14a-9; and
(xvi) in the case of a nomination by a Nominating Stockholder comprised of a
group, the designation by all such Eligible Holders of one Eligible Holder that is
authorized to act on behalf of the Nominating Stockholder with respect to matters relating
to the nomination, including withdrawal of the nomination;
(3) An executed agreement, in a form deemed satisfactory by the Board of Directors,
pursuant to which the Nominating Stockholder (including in the case of a group, each Eligible
Holder in that group) agrees:
(i) to comply with all applicable laws, rules and regulations in connection
with the nomination, solicitation and election;
(ii) to file any written solicitation or other communication with the
Corporation’s stockholders relating to one or more of the Corporation’s directors or
director nominees or any Proxy Access Nominee with the Securities and Exchange
Commission, regardless of whether any such filing is required under rule or regulation or
whether any exemption from filing is available for such materials under any rule or
regulation;
(iii) to assume all liability stemming from an action, suit or proceeding
concerning any actual or alleged legal or regulatory violation arising out of any
communication by the Nominating Stockholder with the Corporation, its stockholders or
any other person in connection with the nomination or election of directors, including,
without limitation, the Nomination Notice;
14

-- 191 of 205 --

(iv) to indemnify and hold harmless (jointly with all other Eligible Holders, in
the case of a group of Eligible Holders) the Corporation and each of its directors, officers
and employees individually against any liability, loss, damages, expenses or other costs
(including attorneys’ fees) incurred in connection with any threatened or pending action,
suit or proceeding, whether legal, administrative or investigative, against the Corporation
or any of its directors, officers or employees arising out of or relating to a failure or
alleged failure of the Nominating Stockholder to comply with, or any breach or alleged
breach of, its obligations, agreements or representations under this Section 1.12;
(v) in the event that any information included in the Nomination Notice, or
any other communication by the Nominating Stockholder (including with respect to any
Eligible Holder included in a group), with the Corporation, its stockholders or any other
person in connection with the nomination or election ceases to be true and accurate in all
material respects (or due to a subsequent development omits a material fact necessary to
make the statements made not misleading), or that the Nominating Stockholder
(including any Eligible Holder included in a group) has failed to continue to satisfy the
eligibility requirements described in Section 1.12(c), to promptly (and in any event within
48 hours of discovering such misstatement or omission) notify the Corporation and any
other recipient of such communication of the misstatement or omission in such
previously provided information and of the information that is required to correct the
misstatement or omission; and
(4) An executed agreement, in a form deemed satisfactory by the Board of Directors,
by the Proxy Access Nominee:
(i) to provide to the Corporation such other information, including
completion of the Corporation’s director questionnaire, as it may reasonably request;
(ii) that the Proxy Access Nominee has read and agrees, if elected, to serve as
a member of the Board of Directors, to adhere to the Corporation’s Corporate
Governance Guidelines and Code of Business Conduct and Ethics and any other
Corporation policies and guidelines applicable to directors; and
(iii) that the Proxy Access Nominee is not and will not become a party to any
agreement, arrangement or understanding with any person or entity as to how the Proxy
Access Nominee would vote or act on any issue or question as a director.
The information and documents required by this Section 1.12(d) shall be (i) provided with respect
to and executed by each Eligible Holder or, in the case of a Nominating Stockholder comprised of a group
of Eligible Holders, each Eligible Holder in that group; and (ii) provided with respect to the persons
specified in Instruction 1 to Items 6(c) and (d) of Schedule 14N (or any successor item) in the case of a
Nominating Stockholder or Eligible Holder that is an entity. The Nomination Notice shall be deemed
submitted on the date on which all the information and documents referred to in this Section 1.12(d)
(other than such information and documents contemplated to be provided after the date the Nomination
Notice is provided) have been delivered to or, if sent by mail, received by a Secretary of the Corporation.
(e) Exceptions.
(1) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Section 1.12, the
Corporation may omit from its proxy statement any Proxy Access Nominee and any information
concerning such Proxy Access Nominee (including a Nominating Stockholder’s statement in
support) and no vote on such Proxy Access Nominee will occur (notwithstanding that proxies in
15

-- 192 of 205 --

respect of such vote may have been received by the Corporation), and the Nominating
Stockholder may not, after the last day on which a Nomination Notice would be timely, cure in
any way any defect preventing the nomination of the Proxy Access Nominee, if:
(i) the Corporation receives a notice pursuant to Section 1.11(b) of these by-
laws that any stockholder intends to nominate a candidate for director at the annual
meeting;
(ii) if another person is engaging in a “solicitation” within the meaning of
Rule 14a-1(l) under the Exchange Act in support of the election of any individual as a
director at the applicable annual meeting of stockholders other than a nominee of the
Board of Directors and other than as permitted by this Section 1.12;
(iii) the Nominating Stockholder or the designated Eligible Holder that is
authorized to act on behalf of the Nominating Stockholder, as applicable, or any qualified
representative thereof, does not appear at the annual meeting of stockholders to present
the nomination submitted pursuant to this Section 1.12 or the Nominating Stockholder
withdraws its nomination;
(iv) the Board of Directors determines that such Proxy Access Nominee’s
nomination or election to the Board of Directors would result in the Corporation violating
or failing to be in compliance with the Corporation’s by-laws or certificate of
incorporation or any applicable law, rule or regulation to which the Corporation is
subject, including any rules or regulations of any stock exchange on which the
Corporation’s securities are traded;
(v) the Proxy Access Nominee was nominated for election to the Board of
Directors pursuant to this Section 1.12 at one of the Corporation’s two preceding annual
meetings of stockholders and either (A) withdrew or became ineligible or (B) received a
vote of less than twenty percent of the shares of common stock entitled to vote for such
Proxy Access Nominee;
(vi) the Proxy Access Nominee (A) is an officer or director of a competitor, as
defined for purposes of Section 8 of the Clayton Antitrust Act of 1914, as amended or (B)
is a director, trustee, officer or employee with management functions for any depository
institution, depository institution holding company or entity that has been designated as a
Systemically Important Financial Institution, each as defined in the Depository Institution
Management Interlocks Act, provided, however, that this clause (B) shall apply only so
long as the Corporation is subject to compliance with Section 164 of the Dodd-Frank
Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act; or
(vii) the Corporation is notified, or the Board of Directors determines, that a
Nominating Stockholder has failed to continue to satisfy the eligibility requirements
described in Section 1.12(c), any of the representations and warranties made in the
Nomination Notice cease to be true and accurate in all material respects (or omit a
material fact necessary to make the statement not misleading), the Proxy Access
Nominee becomes unwilling or unable to serve on the Board of Directors or any material
violation or breach occurs of the obligations, agreements, representations or warranties of
the Nominating Stockholder or the Proxy Access Nominee under this Section 1.12.
(2) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Section 1.12, the
Corporation may omit from its proxy statement, or may supplement or correct, any information,
16

-- 193 of 205 --

including all or any portion of the statement in support of the Proxy Access Nominee included in
the Nomination Notice, if the Board of Directors determines that:
(i) such information is not true in all material respects or omits a material
statement necessary to make the statements made not misleading;
(ii) such information directly or indirectly impugns character, integrity or
personal reputation of, or directly or indirectly makes charges concerning improper,
illegal or immoral conduct or associations, without factual foundation, with respect to any
person; or
(iii) the inclusion of such information in the proxy statement would otherwise
violate the Securities and Exchange Commission proxy rules or any other applicable law,
rule or regulation.
ARTICLE II
Board of Directors
Section 2.1 Powers; Number; Qualifications. The business and affairs of the Corporation shall be
managed by or under the direction of the Board of Directors, except as may be otherwise required by law
or provided in the certificate of incorporation. The number of directors of the Corporation shall be fixed
only by resolution of the Board of Directors from time to time. Notwithstanding the foregoing, in the
event the holders of any class or series of stock are entitled by the certificate of incorporation to elect one
or more directors, then the number of directors that may be elected by such holders voting separately as a
class shall be in addition to the number fixed by resolution of the Board of Directors. Directors need not
be stockholders at the time of election or appointment.
Section 2.2 Election; Term of Office; Vacancies. Directors elected at each annual or special
meeting of stockholders shall hold office until the next annual meeting of stockholders, and until their
successors are elected and qualified or until their earlier resignation or removal. Subject to the terms of
any one or more series of Preferred Stock, each director shall be elected by a majority of the votes cast for
or against the director at any meeting for the election of directors, provided that if the number of director
nominees exceeds the number of directors to be elected, the directors shall be elected by a plurality of the
votes of the shares present in person or represented by proxy at any such meeting and entitled to vote on
the election of directors. If an incumbent director is nominated at an annual meeting of stockholders but is
not elected, the director shall immediately tender their resignation to the Board of Directors. Vacancies
and newly created directorships resulting from any increase in the authorized number of directors (other
than any directors elected in the manner described in the next sentence) or from any other cause shall be
filled by, and only by, a majority of the directors then in office, although less than a quorum, or by the
sole remaining director. Subject to the terms of any one or more series of Preferred Stock, whenever the
holders of any class or classes of stock or series thereof are entitled by the certificate of incorporation to
elect one or more directors, vacancies and newly created directorships of such class or classes or series
may be filled by, and only by, a majority of the directors elected by such class or classes or series then in
office, or by the sole remaining director so elected. Subject to the terms of any one or more series of
Preferred Stock, any director elected or appointed to fill a vacancy or a newly created directorship shall
hold office until the next annual meeting of stockholders, and until their successor is elected and qualified
or until their earlier resignation or removal.
Section 2.3 Regular Meetings. Regular meetings of the Board of Directors may be held at such
places (if any) within or without the State of Delaware and at such times as the Board may from time to
time determine, and if so determined notice thereof need not be given.
17

-- 194 of 205 --

Section 2.4 Special Meetings. Special meetings of the Board of Directors may be held at any
time or place (if any) within or without the State of Delaware whenever called by the Board, by a
Chairman of the Board, if any, by a Vice Chairman of the Board, if any, by a Chairperson of the
Corporate Governance and Nominating Committee, if any, by a Lead Director, if any, by a Chief
Executive Officer, if any, by a President, if any, by a Chief Operating Officer, if any, or by any two
directors. Reasonable notice thereof shall be given by the person or persons calling the meeting.
Section 2.5 Participation in Meetings by Remote Communication Permitted. Unless otherwise
restricted by the certificate of incorporation or these by-laws, members of the Board of Directors, or any
committee designated by the Board, may participate in a meeting of the Board or of such committee, as
the case may be, by means of conference telephone, video or other communications equipment by means
of which all persons participating in the meeting can hear each other, and participation in a meeting
pursuant to this by-law shall constitute presence in person at such meeting.
Section 2.6 Quorum; Vote Required for Action. Unless the certificate of incorporation or these
by-laws provide otherwise, at each meeting of the Board of Directors, a majority of the number of
directors equal to (i) the total number of directors fixed by resolution of the board of directors (including
any vacancies) plus (ii) the number of directors elected by a holder or holders of Preferred Stock voting
separately as a class, as described in the fourth paragraph of Article EIGHTH of the certificate of
incorporation (including any vacancies), shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of business. The
vote of a majority of the directors present at a meeting at which a quorum is present shall be the act of the
Board unless the certificate of incorporation or these by-laws shall require a vote of a greater number. In
case at any meeting of the Board a quorum shall not be present, the members or a majority of the
members of the Board present may adjourn the meeting from time to time until a quorum shall be present.
Section 2.7 Organization. Meetings of the Board of Directors shall be presided over by a
Chairman of the Board, if any, or in the absence of a Chairman of the Board, by a Lead Director, if any,
or in the absence of a Lead Director, by a chair chosen at the meeting. A Secretary, or in the absence of a
Secretary an Assistant Secretary, shall act as secretary of the meeting, but in the absence of a Secretary
and any Assistant Secretary the chair of the meeting may appoint any person to act as secretary of the
meeting.
Section 2.8 Action by Directors Without a Meeting. Unless otherwise restricted by the certificate
of incorporation or these by-laws, any action required or permitted to be taken at any meeting of the
Board of Directors, or of any committee thereof, may be taken without a meeting if all members of the
Board or of such committee, as the case may be, then in office consent thereto in writing, including by
electronic transmission. After an action is taken, the consent or consents shall be filed with the minutes of
proceedings of the Board or committee in accordance with applicable law.
Section 2.9 Compensation of Directors. Unless otherwise restricted by the certificate of
incorporation or these by-laws, the Board of Directors shall have the authority to fix the compensation of
directors.
Section 2.10 Director Resignation and Removal. (a) Any director may resign at any time upon
notice in writing, including by electronic transmission, to the Board of Directors or to a Chairman of the
Board, a Lead Director, a Chairperson of the Corporate Governance and Nominating Committee or a
Secretary. Such resignation shall take effect at the time specified therein and, unless otherwise specified
therein (and except for a resignation described in Section 2.10(b) below), no acceptance of such
resignation shall be necessary to make it effective. No director may be removed except as provided in the
certificate of incorporation.
18

-- 195 of 205 --

(b) In the case of a resignation required to be tendered under Section 2.2 of these by-laws, the
Board of Directors will determine, through a process managed by the Corporate Governance and
Nominating Committee and excluding the incumbent director in question, whether to accept the
resignation at or before its next regularly scheduled Board meeting after the date of the meeting for the
election of directors. Absent a significant reason for the director to remain on the Board of Directors, the
Board shall accept the resignation. The Board’s decision and an explanation of any determination not to
accept the director’s resignation shall be disclosed promptly in a Form 8-K filed with the United States
Securities and Exchange Commission.
ARTICLE III
Committees
Section 3.1 Committees. The Board of Directors may designate one or more committees, each
committee to consist of one or more of the directors of the Corporation. The Board may designate one or
more directors as alternate members of any committee, who may replace any absent or disqualified
member at any meeting of the committee. In the absence or disqualification of a member of a committee,
the member or members thereof present at any meeting and not disqualified from voting, whether or not
such member or members constitute a quorum, may unanimously appoint another member of the Board to
act at the meeting in the place of any such absent or disqualified member. Any such committee, to the
extent provided in the resolution of the Board of Directors or in these by-laws, shall have and may
exercise all the powers and authority of the Board of Directors in the management of the business and
affairs of the Corporation, and may authorize the seal of the Corporation to be affixed to all papers which
may require it; but no such committee shall have the power or authority in reference to the following
matters: (i) approving or adopting, or recommending to the stockholders, any action or matter expressly
required by law to be submitted to stockholders for approval (other than the election or removal of
directors) or (ii) adopting, amending or repealing these by-laws.
Section 3.2 Committee Rules. Unless the Board of Directors otherwise provides, each committee
designated by the Board may adopt, amend and repeal rules for the conduct of its business. In the absence
of a provision by the Board or a provision in the rules of such committee to the contrary, a majority of the
entire authorized number of members of such committee shall constitute a quorum for the transaction of
business, the vote of a majority of the members present at a meeting at the time of such vote if a quorum
is then present shall be the act of such committee, and in other respects each committee shall conduct its
business in the same manner as the Board conducts its business pursuant to Article II of these by-laws.
ARTICLE IV
Officers
Section 4.1 Officers; Election or Appointment. The Board of Directors shall take such action as
may be necessary from time to time to ensure that the Corporation has such officers as may be necessary
under the Delaware General Corporation Law. In addition, the Board of Directors at any time and from
time to time may elect (i) one or more Chairmen of the Board and/or one or more Vice Chairmen of the
Board from among its members, (ii) one or more Chief Executive Officers, one or more Presidents, one or
more Chief Operating Officers, and/or one or more Chief Financial Officers (iii) one or more Vice
Presidents, one or more Treasurers and/or one or more Secretaries and/or (iv) one or more other officers,
including, without limitation, Assistants or Deputies to any position, in the case of each of (i), (ii), (iii)
and
(iv) if and to the extent the Board deems desirable. The Board of Directors may give any officer such
further designations or alternate titles as it considers desirable. In addition, the Board of Directors at any
time and
19

-- 196 of 205 --

from time to time may authorize any officer of the Corporation to appoint one or more officers of the kind
described in clauses (iii) and (iv) above. Any number of offices may be held by the same person and
directors may hold any office unless the certificate of incorporation or these by-laws otherwise provide.
Section 4.2 Term of Office; Resignation; Removal; Vacancies. Unless otherwise provided in the
resolution of the Board of Directors electing or authorizing the appointment of any officer, each officer
shall hold office until their successor is elected or appointed and qualified or until their earlier resignation
or removal. Any officer may resign at any time upon notice in writing, including by electronic
transmission, to the Board or to such person or persons as the Board may designate. Such resignation
shall take effect at the time specified therein, and unless otherwise specified therein no acceptance of such
resignation shall be necessary to make it effective. The Board may remove any officer with or without
cause at any time. Any officer authorized by the Board to appoint a person to hold an office of the
Corporation may also remove such person from such office with or without cause at any time, unless
otherwise provided in the resolution of the Board providing such authorization. Any such removal shall
be without prejudice to the contractual rights of such officer, if any, with the Corporation, but the election
or appointment of an officer shall not of itself create contractual rights. Any vacancy occurring in any
office of the Corporation by death, resignation, removal or otherwise may be filled by the Board at any
regular or special meeting or by an officer authorized by the Board to appoint a person to hold such
office.
Section 4.3 Powers and Duties. The officers of the Corporation shall have such powers and
duties in the management of the Corporation as shall be stated in these by-laws or in a resolution of the
Board of Directors which is not inconsistent with these by-laws and, to the extent not so stated, as
generally pertain to their respective offices, subject to the control of the Board. A Secretary or such other
officer appointed to do so by the Board shall have the duty to record the proceedings of the meetings of
the stockholders, the Board of Directors and any committees in a book to be kept for that purpose. The
Board may require any officer, agent or employee to give security for the faithful performance of their
duties.
ARTICLE V
Stock
Section 5.1 Certificates; Uncertificated Shares. The shares of stock in the Corporation shall be
represented by certificates, provided that the Board of Directors of the Corporation may provide by
resolution or resolutions that some or all of any or all classes or series of its stock shall be uncertificated
shares. Any such resolution shall not apply to any such shares represented by a certificate theretofore
issued until such certificate is surrendered to the Corporation. Every holder of stock represented by
certificates shall be entitled to have a certificate signed by or in the name of the Corporation by any two
authorized officers, which shall include, without limitation, a Chairman or Vice Chairman of the Board, a
President or Vice President, a Chief Executive Officer, a Chief Financial Officer, a Chief Legal Officer or
General Counsel, a Treasurer or Global Treasurer, an Assistant Treasurer, a Secretary or an Assistant
Secretary, representing the number of shares of stock in the Corporation owned by such holder. In case
any officer, transfer agent or registrar who has signed a certificate shall have ceased to be such officer,
transfer agent or registrar before such certificate is issued, it may be issued by the Corporation with the
same effect as if such person were such officer, transfer agent or registrar at the date of issue. Certificates
representing shares of stock of the Corporation may bear such legends regarding restrictions on transfer or
other matters as any officer or officers of the Corporation may determine to be appropriate and lawful.
If the Corporation is authorized to issue more than one class of stock or more than one series of
any class, the powers, designations, preferences and relative, participating, optional or other special rights
of each class of stock or series thereof and the qualifications or restrictions of such preferences and/or
rights shall be set forth in full or summarized on the face or back of the certificate which the Corporation
shall
20

-- 197 of 205 --

issue to represent such class or series of stock, provided that, except as otherwise required by law, in lieu
of the foregoing requirements, there may be set forth on the face or back of the certificate which the
Corporation shall issue to represent such class or series of stock a statement that the Corporation will
furnish without charge to each stockholder who so requests the powers, designations, preferences and
relative, participating, optional or other special rights of such class or series of stock and the
qualifications, limitations or restrictions of such preferences and/or rights. Within a reasonable time after
the issuance or transfer of uncertificated shares of any class or series of stock, the Corporation shall send
to the registered owner thereof a written notice containing the information required by law to be set forth
or stated on certificates representing shares of such class or series or a statement that the Corporation will
furnish without charge to each stockholder who so requests the powers, designations, preferences and
relative, participating, optional or other special rights of such class or series and the qualifications,
limitations or restrictions of such preferences and/or rights.
Except as otherwise provided by law or these by-laws, the rights and obligations of the holders of
uncertificated shares and the rights and obligations of the holders of certificates representing stock of the
same class and series shall be identical.
Section 5.2 Lost, Stolen or Destroyed Stock Certificates; Issuance of New Certificates. The
Corporation may issue a new certificate of stock in the place of any certificate theretofore issued by it,
alleged to have been lost, stolen or destroyed, and the Corporation may require the owner of the lost,
stolen or destroyed certificate, or such owner’s legal representative, to give the Corporation a bond
sufficient to indemnify it against any claim that may be made against it on account of the alleged loss,
theft or destruction of any such certificate or the issuance of such new certificate.
ARTICLE VI
Miscellaneous
Section 6.1 Fiscal Year. The fiscal year of the Corporation shall be determined by the Board of
Directors.
Section 6.2 Seal. The Corporation may have a corporate seal which shall have the name of the
Corporation inscribed thereon and shall be in such form as may be approved from time to time by the
Board of Directors. The corporate seal may be used by causing it or a facsimile thereof to be impressed or
affixed or in any other manner reproduced.
Section 6.3 Waiver of Notice of Meetings of Stockholders, Directors and Committees. Whenever
notice is required to be given by law or under any provision of the certificate of incorporation or these by-
laws, a written waiver thereof (including by electronic transmission), signed or given by the person
entitled to notice, whether before or after the time stated therein, shall be deemed equivalent to notice.
Attendance of a person at a meeting shall constitute a waiver of notice of such meeting, except when the
person attends a meeting for the express purpose of objecting, at the beginning of the meeting, to the
transaction of any business because the meeting is not lawfully called or convened. Neither the business
to be transacted at, nor the purpose of, any regular or special meeting of the stockholders, directors or
members of a committee of directors need be specified in any waiver of notice unless so required by the
certificate of incorporation or these by-laws.
Section 6.4 Indemnification. The Corporation shall indemnify to the full extent permitted by law
any person made or threatened to be made a party to any action, suit or proceeding, whether civil,
criminal, administrative or investigative, by reason of the fact that such person or such person’s testator or
intestate is or was a member of the Board of Directors of the Corporation, an officer of the Corporation
21

-- 198 of 205 --

appointed by resolution of the Board of Directors, or a member of the Shareholders’ Committee acting
pursuant to the Amended and Restated Shareholders’ Agreement, dated as of May 7, 1999, among the
Corporation and the Covered Persons listed on Appendix A thereto, as amended from time to time.
Expenses, including attorneys’ fees, incurred by any such person in defending any such action, suit or
proceeding shall be paid or reimbursed by the Corporation promptly upon demand by such person and, if
any such demand is made in advance of the final disposition of any such action, suit or proceeding,
promptly upon receipt by the Corporation of an undertaking of such person to repay such expenses if it
shall ultimately be determined that such person is not entitled to be indemnified by the Corporation. The
rights provided to any person by this by-law shall be enforceable against the Corporation by such person,
who shall be presumed to have relied upon it in serving or continuing to serve in such capacity. In
addition, the rights provided to any person by this by-law shall survive the termination of such person as
any such member or officer. No amendment of this by-law shall impair the rights of any person arising at
any time with respect to events occurring prior to such amendment.
Notwithstanding anything contained in this Section 6.4, except for proceedings to enforce rights
provided in this Section 6.4, the Corporation shall not be obligated under this Section 6.4 to provide any
indemnification or any payment or reimbursement of expenses to any person in connection with a
proceeding (or part thereof) initiated by such person (which shall not include counterclaims or
crossclaims initiated by others) unless the Board of Directors has authorized or consented to such
proceeding (or part thereof) in a resolution adopted by the Board of Directors.
To the extent authorized from time to time in a resolution adopted by the Board of Directors
(including a resolution authorizing officers of the Corporation to grant such rights), the Corporation may
provide to any one or more persons, including without limitation any employee or other agent of the
Corporation, or any director, officer, employee, agent, trustee, member, stockholder, partner, incorporator
or liquidator of any subsidiary of the Corporation or any other enterprise, rights of indemnification and/or
to receive payment or reimbursement of expenses, including attorneys’ fees, with any such rights subject
to the terms, conditions and limitations established pursuant to the Board resolution. Nothing in this
Section
6.4 shall limit the power of the Corporation or the Board of Directors to provide rights of indemnification
and to make payment and reimbursement of expenses, including attorneys’ fees, to any person otherwise
than pursuant to this Section 6.4.
Section 6.5 Interested Directors; Quorum. No contract or transaction between the Corporation
and one or more of its directors or officers, or between the Corporation and any other corporation,
partnership, limited liability company, joint venture, trust, association or other unincorporated
organization or other entity in which one or more of its directors or officers serve as directors, officers,
trustees or in a similar capacity or have a financial interest, shall be void or voidable solely for this
reason, or solely because the director or officer is present at or participates in the meeting of the Board of
Directors or committee thereof which authorizes the contract or transaction, or solely because their votes
are counted for such purpose, if: (i) the material facts as to their relationship or interest and as to the
contract or transaction are disclosed or are known to the Board or the committee, and the Board or
committee in good faith authorizes the contract or transaction by the affirmative votes of a majority of the
disinterested directors, even though the disinterested directors be less than a quorum; (ii) the material
facts as to their relationship or interest and as to the contract or transaction are disclosed or are known to
the stockholders entitled to vote thereon, and the contract or transaction is specifically approved in good
faith by a vote of the stockholders; or (iii) the contract or transaction is fair as to the Corporation as of the
time it is authorized, approved or ratified, by the Board, a committee thereof or the stockholders.
Common or interested directors may be counted in determining the presence of a quorum at a meeting of
the Board of Directors or of a committee which authorizes the contract or transaction.
22

-- 199 of 205 --

Section 6.6 Form of Records. Any records maintained by the Corporation in the regular course of
its business, including its stock ledger, books of account and minute books, may be kept on, or by means
of, or be in the form of, any information storage device, method or one or more electronic networks or
data bases (including one or more distributed networks) , provided that the records so kept can be
converted into clearly legible form within a reasonable time and otherwise be compliant with the
requirements of applicable law.
The Corporation shall so convert any records so kept upon the request of any person entitled to
inspect the same.
Section 6.7 Laws and Regulations; Close of Business. (a) For purposes of these by-laws, any
reference to a law, statute, rule or regulation of any governmental body means such law, statute, rule or
regulation (including any successor thereto) as the same may be amended from time to time.
(b) Any reference in these by-laws to the close of business on any day shall be deemed to mean
5:00 P.M. New York time on such day, whether or not such day is a business day.
Section 6.8 Amendment of By-Laws. These by-laws may be amended, modified or repealed, and
new by-laws may be adopted at any time, by the Board of Directors. Stockholders of the Corporation may
adopt additional by-laws and amend, modify or repeal any by-law whether or not adopted by them, but
only in accordance with Article SIXTH of the certificate of incorporation.
23

-- 200 of 205 --

EXHIBIT 15.1
November 3, 2023
Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street, N.E.
Washington, DC 20549
Re: The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.
Registration Statements on Form S-8
(No. 333-80839)
(No. 333-42068)
(No. 333-106430)
(No. 333-120802)
(No. 333-235973)
(No. 333-261673)
Registration Statement on Form S-3
(No. 333-269296)
Commissioners:
We are aware that our report dated November 3, 2023 on our review of the consolidated balance sheet of The
Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. and its subsidiaries (the Company) as of September 30, 2023, the related consolidated
statements of earnings, comprehensive income and changes in shareholders’ equity for the three and nine month
periods ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, and the consolidated statements of cash flows for the nine month
periods ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, including the related notes in the Company’s quarterly report on
Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2023 is incorporated by reference in the registration statements
referred to above. Pursuant to Rule 436(c) under the Securities Act of 1933 (the Act), such report should not be
considered a part of such registration statements, and is not a report within the meaning of Sections 7 and 11 of
the Act.
Very truly yours,
/s/ PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, 300 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10017

-- 201 of 205 --

EXHIBIT 31.1
CERTIFICATIONS
I, David Solomon, certify that:
1. I have reviewed this Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2023 of The Goldman Sachs
Group, Inc.;
2. Based on my knowledge, this report does not contain any untrue statement of a material fact or omit to state a material
fact necessary to make the statements made, in light of the circumstances under which such statements were made, not
misleading with respect to the period covered by this report;
3. Based on my knowledge, the financial statements, and other financial information included in this report, fairly present
in all material respects the financial condition, results of operations and cash flows of the registrant as of, and for, the
periods presented in this report;
4. The registrant’s other certifying officer(s) and I are responsible for establishing and maintaining disclosure controls
and procedures (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(e) and 15d-15(e)) and internal control over financial
reporting (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(f) and 15d-15(f)) for the registrant and have:
a) Designed such disclosure controls and procedures, or caused such disclosure controls and procedures to be
designed under our supervision, to ensure that material information relating to the registrant, including its
consolidated subsidiaries, is made known to us by others within those entities, particularly during the period in
which this report is being prepared;
b) Designed such internal control over financial reporting, or caused such internal control over financial reporting to
be designed under our supervision, to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting
and the preparation of financial statements for external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting
principles;
c) Evaluated the effectiveness of the registrant’s disclosure controls and procedures and presented in this report our
conclusions about the effectiveness of the disclosure controls and procedures, as of the end of the period covered
by this report based on such evaluation; and
d) Disclosed in this report any change in the registrant’s internal control over financial reporting that occurred during
the registrant’s most recent fiscal quarter (the registrant’s fourth fiscal quarter in the case of an annual report) that
has materially affected, or is reasonably likely to materially affect, the registrant’s internal control over financial
reporting; and
5. The registrant’s other certifying officer(s) and I have disclosed, based on our most recent evaluation of internal control
over financial reporting, to the registrant’s auditors and the audit committee of the registrant’s board of directors (or
persons performing the equivalent functions):
a) All significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in the design or operation of internal control over financial
reporting which are reasonably likely to adversely affect the registrant’s ability to record, process, summarize and
report financial information; and
b) Any fraud, whether or not material, that involves management or other employees who have a significant role in
the registrant’s internal control over financial reporting.
Date: November 3, 2023 /s/ David Solomon
Name: David Solomon
Title: Chief Executive Officer

-- 202 of 205 --

CERTIFICATIONS
I, Denis P. Coleman III, certify that:
1. I have reviewed this Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2023 of The Goldman Sachs
Group, Inc.;
2. Based on my knowledge, this report does not contain any untrue statement of a material fact or omit to state a material
fact necessary to make the statements made, in light of the circumstances under which such statements were made, not
misleading with respect to the period covered by this report;
3. Based on my knowledge, the financial statements, and other financial information included in this report, fairly present
in all material respects the financial condition, results of operations and cash flows of the registrant as of, and for, the
periods presented in this report;
4. The registrant’s other certifying officer(s) and I are responsible for establishing and maintaining disclosure controls
and procedures (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(e) and 15d-15(e)) and internal control over financial
reporting (as defined in Exchange Act Rules 13a-15(f) and 15d-15(f)) for the registrant and have:
a) Designed such disclosure controls and procedures, or caused such disclosure controls and procedures to be
designed under our supervision, to ensure that material information relating to the registrant, including its
consolidated subsidiaries, is made known to us by others within those entities, particularly during the period in
which this report is being prepared;
b) Designed such internal control over financial reporting, or caused such internal control over financial reporting to
be designed under our supervision, to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting
and the preparation of financial statements for external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting
principles;
c) Evaluated the effectiveness of the registrant’s disclosure controls and procedures and presented in this report our
conclusions about the effectiveness of the disclosure controls and procedures, as of the end of the period covered
by this report based on such evaluation; and
d) Disclosed in this report any change in the registrant’s internal control over financial reporting that occurred during
the registrant’s most recent fiscal quarter (the registrant’s fourth fiscal quarter in the case of an annual report) that
has materially affected, or is reasonably likely to materially affect, the registrant’s internal control over financial
reporting; and
5. The registrant’s other certifying officer(s) and I have disclosed, based on our most recent evaluation of internal control
over financial reporting, to the registrant’s auditors and the audit committee of the registrant’s board of directors (or
persons performing the equivalent functions):
a) All significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in the design or operation of internal control over financial
reporting which are reasonably likely to adversely affect the registrant’s ability to record, process, summarize and
report financial information; and
b) Any fraud, whether or not material, that involves management or other employees who have a significant role in
the registrant’s internal control over financial reporting.
Date: November 3, 2023 /s/ Denis P. Coleman III
Name: Denis P. Coleman III
Title: Chief Financial Officer

-- 203 of 205 --

EXHIBIT 32.1
Certification
Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 1350, the undersigned officer of The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. (the Company) hereby certifies
that the Company’s Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2023 (the Report) fully complies
with the requirements of Section 13(a) or 15(d), as applicable, of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and that the
information contained in the Report fairly presents, in all material respects, the financial condition and results of operations
of the Company.
Date: November 3, 2023 /s/ David Solomon
Name: David Solomon
Title: Chief Executive Officer
The foregoing certification is being furnished solely pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 1350 and is not being filed as part of the
Report or as a separate disclosure document.

-- 204 of 205 --

Certification
Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 1350, the undersigned officer of The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. (the Company) hereby certifies
that the Company’s Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2023 (the Report) fully complies
with the requirements of Section 13(a) or 15(d), as applicable, of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and that the
information contained in the Report fairly presents, in all material respects, the financial condition and results of operations
of the Company.
Date: November 3, 2023 /s/ Denis P. Coleman III
Name: Denis P. Coleman III
Title: Chief Financial Officer
The foregoing certification is being furnished solely pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 1350 and is not being filed as part of the
Report or as a separate disclosure document.

-- 205 of 205 --