TRANSCRIPT

H1 2020 — Equity analysts meeting transcript

H1 2020PDF · 8 pages191 KB
Transcript
Post Results Call
Half-Year Analyst Meeting
3 September 2020, 08.00am BST
EWEN STEVENSON, GROUP CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER: Morning or afternoon all,
depending on where you are. I’m actually out at our Canary Wharf offices today for a rare day
in the office, but we’re going to try to as an executive team to begin to get back into the office
one or two days a week, although Canary Wharf for us is a particularly challenging building,
given the restrictions on tube travel in London and the inability to cram a large number of
people into this 42-storey tower.
Just a few update comments following our Q2 results. So I guess we last spoke about a
month ago at the beginning of August. On revenues, just as a reminder, interest income will
get progressively impacted by the close to zero interest rate environment we now have in the
UK, US and Hong Kong.
On non-interest income, as I said a month ago, we do expect some of those line items,
particularly Global Markets, to slow down in the second half. The second half of last year was
dramatically lower than first half of this year, so I’d just ask you to pay attention to that. And
on customer activity, I think we’re going to have to watch the path out of COVID globally.
Things like the return of mainland Chinese tourists into Hong Kong is important for our
insurance franchise, but generally customer activity levels continue to be subdued as a result
of COVID, which is impacting some non-interest income lines.
On ECL, there’s nothing really to update post what I said a month ago. On operating
expenses, I guess just watch for the fact that the quite sharp dollar weakness over recent
months, and obviously we’ve got a decent amount of our cost base that will get impacted by
that, i.e. a dollar for dollar comparison will be impacted by dollar weakness.
On income from associates, in the last couple of weeks you will have seen an announcement
out of Saudi British Bank about impairments and goodwill they had from the Alawwal
acquisition. That will have an impact on the way that we account in Q3.
And then, as we look out more broadly, while the shape of ‘21 is becoming clearer, there
continues to be substantial uncertainty as a result of the path out of COVID and how that
differs across different markets. I think some of our fears of very severe second and third
wave lockdowns economically doesn’t appear to be coming through, so downside risks
around COVID have probably moderated and the development of a successful vaccine
continues to progress at pace. Equally, I think the sharper v-shaped recovery that people had
hoped for doesn’t look like it’s going to come through, so it will be a slower recovery out of
COVID.
Then, obviously, we’re still waiting for further news around Brexit. We do expect US-China
tensions to remain to the fore, particularly in the run-up to the US presidential election. So
there continues to be a material amount of uncertainty out there, and I think until later in the
year we won’t really have any good visibility on where we’re sitting in relation to distributions
at the end of this year and into next year. And as I said a month ago, we would expect not to
update you until full-year results.
We’re currently doing a lot of work around what the new environment looks like. I certainly
think we need to accept that interest rates are going to be a lot lower for a sustained period of
time. Consensus now doesn’t really have policy rates moving up or down for about three
years, so we’re doing a lot of work at the moment around the cost structure, but it’s too early
to talk about that in any detail.

-- 1 of 8 --

So I was going to stop there and just open up for your questions. And just as a reminder, I’m
joined today by Richard O’Connor and his team in Investor Relations, and also our CFO in
Asia, Ming Lau.
MANUS COSTELLO, AUTONOMOUS: Morning, afternoon, everyone. I wanted to ask about
ECL, please, just as I had more time to read through the interim report post-results. I was
looking at the post-model adjustments that you made and they seem to be extremely high.
You had, I think, a $4.5 billion reduction in your ECL as a result of the post-model adjustment
and relative to your ECL of $14 billion and a charge of $4 billion in the quarter, that does
seem like a very big number, so I wondered, could you talk us through why you made such a
big manual adjustment and, secondly, more broadly, does it not lead you to question the
models underpinning ECL if you have to manually adjust it by $4.5 billion?
EWEN STEVENSON: Firstly, factually, yes, there was a very large manual adjustment. As
we look at COVID, there is no precedent in terms of historical data going into the models; as
we model out through those ECLs, Manus, there are I think a few things. Firstly, the severity
of the downturn that we saw in Q2 was something that we’d never seen before. Equally, the
strength of the recovery is something that we’ve never seen before and the level of
government intervention globally and central bank intervention, and the speed of that
intervention, is something that we’ve never seen before.
So as we put that through the models there were various outcomes coming out of the models
that just made no sense as we applied some reasonable top-down judgement onto those
models and some of the outcomes were, frankly, quite extreme. I don’t think that challenges
the models themselves. What it does is challenge the fact that the data that we’re using to
underpin the models just needs to be updated. I don’t think what we’re seeing is, based on
conversations I’ve had with several CFOs globally, anything surprising. I think all of us have
had to take fairly substantive what we call underlays into the models as a result of just the
unprecedented nature of the shape of the stress event we saw in the second quarter and,
therefore, we thought it was appropriate, our auditors thought it was appropriate, the
regulators thought it was appropriate that we adjust the model outputs for expert judgement.
MANUS COSTELLO: And does that mean, coming out of this then – you talked about the
recovery – well, mechanically it lowers the possibility of any write-backs, but does it mean
that your potential for reduced ECL charges going forward is diminished? How does that play
in the second half and into ‘21?
EWEN STEVENSON: Obviously, had we taken the higher ECL charges consistent with the
models, there would have been greater degrees of write-back, yes.
MANUS COSTELLO: Okay. And just to follow up on it, just what is the actual process for how
you make that adjustment? Is it done at a business level or is it at the top level? I’m just
confused as to exactly what the governance around that model is.
EWEN STEVENSON: It’s done portfolio by portfolio, country by country. It’s as much
granularity as we can apply on the wholesale side, and on the retail side it tends to be done
much more on a portfolio level by country by product.
MANUS COSTELLO: Thank you very much.
TOM RAYNER, NUMIS: Thank you. Good morning.
EWEN STEVENSON: Good morning.
TOM RAYNER: Hi. Two questions please. First one just on the linkage between the forward-
looking provisions that you’ve made under IFRS 9 and how that will start to link through to
RWAs through changes in probability of default. I’m just wondering if there’s been some sort
of lag where IFRS 9 recognises the situation at an earlier point than you actually do in the
capital model. So that was my first question.
Second question – well, listening to what you said, again, on not commenting on distribution,
but clearly when you do decide to restart it’s going to depend both on capital position and the
level of sustainable profitability. My question is would you expect, when you do resume
distributions, to be starting at a low pay-out ratio with the possibility of then growing or adding
via special dividends and buybacks or are you more likely wait until you’re in a position so

-- 2 of 8 --

that you’re comfortable to go back to your maximum distribution level, which you can then
hold flat, as you had – as you were doing pre-crisis? Thank you.
EWEN STEVENSON: I think there probably is a lag effect in terms of credit rating migration
relative to IFRS 9 provisioning. We do think that we’ve seen, as per our guidance for the full
year, a higher level of ECL charges in the first half than the second half. We think we’ll see
more ratings migration and more RWA pressure in the second half than the first half, if you
were to just look at ratings migration alone.
And in fact, what we’re seeing is actually a slower pace of ratings migration than what we had
anticipated currently. Some of that is probably due to continuing government support
packages globally and we’ll have to see how credit performs, once those support packages
begin to roll off in the next few months, but we do think we’ll see a meaningful amount of
ratings migration into the second half.
TOM RAYNER: And just on the same point, is it the case that as and when we see actual
defaults coming through and a move into stage three that you will then see also a pickup in
RWA procyclicality, because that will then trigger the change on the capital model?
EWEN STEVENSON: No, we do a forward-looking view on ratings, so in some ways they are
anticipating future defaults as well.
TOM RAYNER: Okay. Thanks.
EWEN STEVENSON: On distributions, I think it’s more likely that it’s the former rather than
the latter version of what you said, Tom, i.e. that they will build over time.
TOM RAYNER: Yeah, okay. Thank you.
EWEN STEVENSON: And I think if you apply a regulatory lens over this as well, I think watch
what happens with the Brexit negotiations in the coming months, watch what happens with
COVID, because there will be a natural caution – regulatory caution, I think, as there
continues to be a high degree of uncertainty around the economic impact of COVID and
Brexit in the near term, but the more that we as a sector and the regulator can get
comfortable that there is a tighter band of potential outcomes for ‘21 and ‘22, both in terms of
profitability and capital, then you can be more confident on forward-looking distribution policy.
One of the challenges at the moment is that we’re continuing to face into an environment
where you can plausibly predict quite a broad array of outcomes in ‘21 and the flow through
into capital.
TOM RAYNER: Okay, lovely. Thank you.
ALASTAIR RYAN, BANK OF AMERICA: Thank you. Good morning. I’m probably coming at
things from the opposite side to Manus, not for the first time. On provisioning, there aren’t
actually a lot of bad debts around yet. These moratoria schemes and government guarantees
make it extremely difficult to judge whether they’re actually going to emerge, I suppose, as
well as whether people have really already defaulted and you just can’t see it because of the
moratoria. And that was extended again in Hong Kong, I think, yesterday.
How do you approach that, because at some point governments do keep extending
guarantees and maybe the bad debts aren’t going to happen, rather than a wave that’s
coming when they expire, if they don’t expire, because governments are running bigger
deficits and money is cheap? You’ve done more than you needed to, because you’ve taken a
view that these things will expire and there will be this massive catch-up, and it’s gone into
your capital through your risk-weighted assets as well, so you’ve sort of had a P&L charge
and a capital charge against things that may not emerge. Just a discussion really on how we
think about that from your point of view. Thank you.
EWEN STEVENSON: Yeah, we had a discussion on this internally the other day.
Realistically, if we roll forward to Q3 results, which are less than two months away, I still think
it’s going to be too early to really make strong judgement calls around this. We are beginning
to see globally some schemes roll off, particularly on the retail side. We are able to
benchmark that against what the underlying assumptions were and it’s been modestly better,
if I could describe it as that, from what we’d thought, but too early really to call. The UK in
particular has got very substantive support currently. So realistically, Alastair, I don’t think
we’re going to have a strong view on this until we get full-year results and, you’re right, I think

-- 3 of 8 --

the likely government reaction will be to try to extend this and push it out as long as possible,
but, ultimately, that government support can’t be sustained, given the affordability constraints
certain governments are under.
ALASTAIR RYAN: Thank you. And then just it’s – I mean, absolutely, it’s too early to tell, but
house prices in particular haven’t fallen anywhere when back in March, April it would have
been reasonable to expect that a fall would show up in a lot of places. Does that begin to play
through or, again, you’d just – you’d review that at the full-year?
EWEN STEVENSON: Yeah, in terms of the expected defaults we’d seen, the mortgage book
was not the source of concern for us and never really has been, because we were not
anticipating extreme falls in house prices, so it’s more on the consumer debt side, where
actually, frankly, trends have been reasonably positive, because people are not spending on
their cards and they’re paying down debt.
And on the wholesale side, you can all see the very different cashflow impacts that COVID
has had on different industrial sectors, so there are still a number of sectors that are running
very cashflow negative at this point. And again, you’re getting into speculation, for example,
in the airline sector, of when and how do governments step in to support national flag
carriers. So I think it is too early to tell on a lot of these sectors, and even if we try to think
about our own behaviour and how we’re likely to act as a user of services post COVID, I think
our own behaviour will change. We’ll travel less. We’ll have over the medium term less need
for commercial real estate. We’ll just be spending less on traditional stuff we would have
previously thought we were spending on pre-COVID, so how that then factors into various
industrial sectors and credit, if that’s translated across the sector, I think is still too early to
tell.
ROBERT NOBLE, DEUTSCHE BANK: Morning, yes. A couple of questions – the change in
Fed policy was the other week to allow inflation to overshoot a steep in the US yield curve
and short rates have remained pretty flat. Does that type of shift benefit your balance sheet in
any way or should I only be concerned about the short rates?
EWEN STEVENSON: Well, a positive yield curve is always a good thing, but relative to what
we thought pre-COVID, we’re still looking at an interest rate environment that’s materially
lower. You can read that Fed statement a number of ways, including the fact that interest
rates are going to remain extremely low for a sustained period of time. I still haven’t got my
head around what the trade is that drives inflation in a much different rate environment. So
our current planning assumption is that rates stay low for a sustained period through ‘22, ‘23.
ROBERT NOBLE: Okay. Thanks. You highlighted in your presentation unsecured personal
loans increased in Q2. Is that Hong Kong-driven or UK-driven? And then on the credit card
book, I think you said people are spending less, but my impression was the last two months
post-Q2 results things have been getting better. Is that not the case? Should we not start to
see credit card books grow in Q3 or do we have to wait a bit longer for that?
RICHARD O’CONNOR: We are seeing increased spending on credit cards, but from a much
lower base than our plan and assumptions based at the end of June. And there’s nothing
much to say, Robert, on unsecured personal loans. They are broadly stable when you take
exchange rates into account and you can see that the cards are substantially down, so we
can take that offline. There’s nothing much to say on that front. But, no, we are seeing an
increase in spend, but from a much lower base, and obviously people are spending more on
credit cards but less in cash, so in terms of the impact overall interest income, we’re still
seeing a recovery from a low base.
ROBERT NOBLE: Is it – should the increased spend – should the credit card balance have
shrunk in Q2, I guess is the question?
RICHARD O’CONNOR: I think that’s right. I think the central plan would be we’ll increase as
economies open up, but you can see from the balance that they are substantially down from
the full year and we expect a gentle recovery from the base in June.
ROBERT NOBLE: Thank you. And then just a quick follow-up on previous questions, why
does the credit rating migration seem to wait and not take into account the fact that support
packages will roll off? If you expect RWAs to increase because of your outlook, should you
not immediately take that into account if you already think they’re going to increase? So

-- 4 of 8 --

what’s the trigger? Do you actually need to see actual deterioration in borrowers’ financial
position before you actually see RWA inflation?
RICHARD O’CONNOR: Obviously, we’re revising the model all the time, but there’s always a
lag between companies filing accounts, filing quarterly statements and you can see that in the
published credit ratings. There’s always a lag there and you’ll see that in credit rating
migration. Also, you’ve seen, obviously, credit rating migration so far being dampened by the
fact that companies have raised a substantial amount of cash resource, and that’s been
good, both on the debt and the equity side, but as Ewen said, you’re seeing many companies
and sectors seeing substantially negative cash flow and we think that’ll feed through in that
space, and that feeds into our guidance in terms of RWAs in terms of mid to high single-digit
inflation for the year. You saw RWA inflation in the first half, but it was low single-digit, and so
we’d expect that to continue in the second half and, indeed, into the first quarter or so of next
year as well.
ROBERT NOBLE: Okay. Thank you very much.
RONIT GHOSE, CITIGROUP: I have two questions please. One is a factual one and one is a
more maybe philosophical one. On the factual one, the comment on associates, so Saudi
British, it looks like they took a $2 billion goodwill hit in their second quarter numbers that just
came out. So do we just put in your share, so about $600 million, of the goodwill charge to
reduce the associate line by that? Can you just walk us through the maths please, if you can?
That’d be great.
And secondly, on a more conceptual or philosophical – we think about capital return
distribution and, given everything you’ve said, Ewen, should we start thinking about maybe –
historically, you’ve had for the last decade or so a relatively high DPS pay-out ratio and
you’ve used buybacks selectively to neutralise scrip. Is there a case here to be made for
shifting more towards a buyback heavier mix of capital return vis-à-vis a high dividend?
Thanks.
EWEN STEVENSON: Yeah, so on the second one, look, I don’t want to get drawn into
speculation on what we may or may not do with distribution policy in the future. As I said,
ultimately, it’s got to be driven by a view on medium-term sustainable returns and medium-
term sustainable growth, and then thinking through cash versus cash in stock, and dividends
versus dividends and buybacks, but we’re still working through that at the moment.
On the factual question, we own just under 30%, so the goodwill impairment maths is right,
but there will obviously be offsetting earnings during the quarter, so the actual share of
associate income will be different to that number.
RICHARD O’CONNOR: Let me just add to that. We haven’t worked out the presentation in
Q3 and we haven’t gone through the goodwill calculation at Group level yet, but we will show
you the underlying associate income from SABB and Bank of Communications, and then the
goodwill hit, should we decide to take it, will be shown as an exceptional item.
EWEN STEVENSON: And that won’t have any impact on common equity tier 1.
AMAN RAKKAR, BARCLAYS: A couple from me. One on costs, please – it’s actually quite
interesting, your opening gambit on the office in Canary Wharf. I’m just trying to work out if
your real estate footprint, be it a combination of your branch network and/or your
headquarters property, is that a big part of the cost base? Is there anything that you can give
us to point towards what proportion of your annual expense base that might relate to? I guess
the reason I’m asking is presumably you guys, as part of your broader review and perhaps as
you’re looking to respond to the revenue challenges might be looking to do something on
your go-forward cost base. Is that potentially a source of material cost-saving that’s been
perhaps capitalised by COVID and the structural shifts that you’re seeing, or basically, ‘It’s
not a big expense as it is right now so don’t worry about it’?
The second was just a point of clarification. You mentioned the steep fall in dollar that we’ve
seen in recent weeks, and I just wanted to clarify that. I think you transitioned about a remark
regarding the ECL charge and what that might mean for asset quality, but also in terms of
what that might mean for the other P&L lines. Could you just repeat that comment? I think I
might have just missed it.

-- 5 of 8 --

Third is – you briefly intimated on the Q2 call about a potential funding opportunity and
funding cost opportunity, potentially, in Hong Kong. Can I tease that out a little bit more?
Could you help us understand what your average deposit cost is at H1 in Hong Kong and
what it was at the end of last year? Because when I look at the system-level data, which I
think is the only stuff that’s available, HKD deposits basically look like they were already on
the floor going into COVID and are still at the floor now. I don’t really have visibility on dollar
deposit costs, I guess, that you incur over in Hong Kong, but where is that? Where is the
space to take down your deposit costs there, please?
EWEN STEVENSON: Ming, I’ll come to you for the third one but I’ll take the first two. On
costs, there are two trends out of COVID that we think will enable us over the medium term to
rethink previous assumptions on costs to a lower level. How much lower, we’re still working
through the detail on. The way that we work, i.e. as a workforce, I think will change as a result
of COVID. We think there will be a sustainable improvement in some of the cost line items
such as travel and entertainment; we spent $400 million in 2019, for example, on travel and
entertainment costs. We expect to be able to basically get, now that we’ve proved video at
scale works, we will return to a business model with a lot less travel. Equally, commercial real
estate, we do think that previous assumptions on what we call desk-sharing ratios, we will be
able to materially shift them upwards with more employees spending more time at home.
Again, all of that we’re working through, but on the commercial real estate side the only thing
I’d caution – and I’d use medium-term quite broadly – if I look for example here at Canary
Wharf, we have a lease contract on this building that runs to 2027, so it’s probably more
about optimising other office space we have in London into Canary Wharf in the short to
medium term, rather than rethinking this building up to 2027. And it will be very much building
by building dependent, globally, but we do think over the medium term that we would be able
to save material amounts of money on commercial real estate costs.
The other big trend we’ve seen is obviously customer use of digital channels, so much lower
use of branches, much lower use of cash, engaging with relationship managers on digital
channels rather than face-to-face meetings. All of that, again, we think will allow us to
accelerate previous assumptions about how quickly we can get out of physical distribution
costs, cash handling costs, number of relationship managers, productivity of relationship
managers. Again, we’re working through that. Whether that has a material impact on the
thinking for ’21, not so sure about, but certainly from 2022 onwards we think it will allow us to
push the cost structure down further than what we may previously have thought.
On the dollar comment I was linking it to costs. I know the high sensitivity around single
percentage point movements in our cross-structure, but just noting the fact that not all of our
costs are dollar-based, so with the dollar depreciation you will see some natural inflation in
dollar-based operating expenses in Q3. That’s got nothing to do with our management of the
cost base.
RICHARD O’CONNOR: Two other quick things. Our commercial real estate costs are about
$3 billion out of a cost base of a total of $30 billion, so we can take a big slug out of that over
the medium term. No change to guidance. Obviously a large percent of our loan book is in
dollars. There are exceptions, including the UK, but no, stick to the current guidance, and
obviously that guidance is very sensitive to UK impairments, as you saw in Q2 and Q1.
EWEN STEVENSON: Ming, do you want to take the third question on funding costs in Hong
Kong?
MING LAU, CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER, ASIA PACIFIC: Sure, Ewen. The way I would look
at it for Hong Kong particularly in that comment on funding costs comes from two things. One
I would say is, if you look at the mix of the deposit base, and this is also following industry
trends, right? As rates are coming down we’re seeing a shift in terms of the mix in time
deposits relative to current accounts. Just to give you a sense, the overall Hong Kong market
as a whole was probably at about 50% on time deposits. That’s now come down to about
45%. Naturally for us we’ve historically had a much smaller base on time deposits, so we
were probably at around the high teens in Hong Kong on time deposits, and now that’s
coming down below 10%. That’s one factor that you need to think about in terms of why we
believe, in terms of the costs of funding on deposits, we see that trend continuing down
because of low interest rates.
Secondly, the other bit impacting that is the absolute rates themselves are also falling
materially. If I look at the three-month Hong Kong dollar time deposit rates on new money,
earlier on in the year you’re looking at about 200 basis points for Hong Kong dollar and US

-- 6 of 8 --

dollar time deposits. We’ve recently now dropped that below 30 basis points, so I think if you
take the combination of those two factors on a forward-looking basis, we should still continue
to see the trend of time deposit mix coming down, and I still think there’s an opportunity to
reduce the actual rates themselves.
AMAN RAKKAR: That’s really, really helpful. Actually, it sounds like it must be the US dollar
deposit rates that you guys were paying at the beginning of the year that were more
expensive though, right? Because the HKMA report three-month HKD client deposits at the
beginning of this year at about 25 basis points, so you guys must have been paying a lot for
US dollar deposits at the beginning of the year, right?
MING LAU: Yeah, you’ve got to remember this is on new funds, so not on rollover deposits.
This is for new money.
MARTIN LEITGEB, GOLDMAN SACHS: A few questions from my side. Firstly, just touching
on your opening remarks and on the outlook from here, I was just wondering, is the prime
focus at this stage on costs in order to kind of offset part of the revenue headwind? There
was a consideration to potentially address revenues; in some countries where there have
been lower rates for a prolonged period of time banks started introducing new charges,
charges on current accounts and so forth. Could that be a consideration that one tries to
address part of the lower for longer rate outlook with incremental charges elsewhere?
Specifically, just on the UK ring-fenced bank, it sounded like at the last quarterly results call
that HSBC is being cautious on UK lending, and that includes mortgages. Is that still the
case? Just looking at the excess deposit base you have now in your ring-fenced bank, is it
the case that you would remain cautious there or could that be an incremental opportunity to
accelerate lending there, particularly on the lower-risk mortgage side in order to try to offset
some of the revenue pressures?
The second question was with respect to the non-ring-fenced bank. I was just wondering if
you could update us on the cost and capital progression, how we should think about that from
here going forward. Is everything going according to plan and could there be significant
step-up, potentially, in terms of RWA reduction from here over the coming period?
The final point, just to touch on your comments on Brexit, if your prime concern is here that
Brexit will essentially impact economic outlook and progression and potentially the shape of
the recovery from here, or is this more a concern from an operational perspective or maybe
from a central bank perspective that the Bank of England might become more competitive in
terms of interest rates?
EWEN STEVENSON: I think there were four questions there, Martin, so correct me if I don’t
get them. So on things that we’re looking at to address the shift in interest rates, operating
expenses is clearly something that’s well within our control. As I said, COVID has opened up
opportunity both on the shift in physical to digital with customers, and also just the amount of
money that we need operationally to run the bank as a result of shift in employee patterns as
a result of how we work. We certainly need to think about how we pivot harder into sources of
non-interest income, away from what now looks like an overreliance on net interest income.
Whether that be through how we structurally grow some businesses now or think about
growth and the importance of growth in some businesses that are not net interest income
driven, but also how we think about the economic return of a customer where previously a lot
of that economic return would have come from net interest income and shifting more towards
fees. There have been parts of the world – Europe in particular – that have faced into a lower
interest rate environment for a prolonged period of time, so there’s clearly a well-laid out
playbook there for how those banks have reacted, so I don’t think our responses should be
any different to that.
The third area you didn’t mention is capital allocation. To the extent that we had
underperforming businesses previously, the return challenges on those business have just
become more difficult with the shift in interest rate outlook. Linking that to your comments on
the non-ring-fenced bank, both on capital allocation and costs, we are definitely going to
continue to drive both of them down quite sharply over the coming years.
On the UK ring-fenced bank risk appetite – you will have seen for example in the last couple
of days some speculation or commentary around us cutting back on higher LTV mortgage
lending. We’re certainly comfortably open for business on what we consider to be lower risk
lending, but we’re cautious on some of the higher risk areas in the UK at the moment.

-- 7 of 8 --

On Brexit, it’s not an operational issue, it’s a macro issue. Brexit clearly will have a
compounding negative effect on the UK economy in addition to COVID, and the harder the
version of Brexit the more profound that impact will be on the UK economy. I know there’s
another round of negotiations coming up. There still remains quite broad outcomes as to
where the governments may be able to agree, but it was a comment purely about economics
and not about our operational capacity. In some ways actually the harder the version of Brexit
the better for us competitively, because we’re a diversified bank that’s not reliant on the UK,
unlike some of our peers. We’ve also got a big global network, unlike many of our peers
where, as UK corporates seek to reposition their relationships globally we feel well placed to
do that. But we will be hit on the domestic side with a weaker macro outlook as a result of a
hard version of Brexit.
RICHARD O’CONNOR: Just something to add to that. On the ring-fenced bank on
mortgages, some of the speculation on the high LTV is due to operational issues, i.e. we
need to maintain our service levels, so it’s not just the risk appetite level but the fact that we
need to maintain service levels in the face of very high demand.
On Brexit, when we do our modelling for IFRS 9 on ECLs then Brexit is highly factored in and
is already a factor within those models. As Ewen said, what formal agreement we get will
impact economic growth during ’21, ’22 and ’23, so that will have an impact on the outlook for
the ring-fenced bank in particular.
FAHAD KUNWAR, REDBURN: Just a follow-up on a couple of things, actually. The Hong
Kong question was quite interesting. Is the deposit beta that you’re experiencing in Hong
Kong better than you’d expected when you spoke to us last month? I know the $25 billion
2021 guidance was obviously given at that point, but are you experiencing a better deposit
beta on those dollar deposit or dollar lending rates than you expected at that point, or is it
very much in line with the guidance?
The second question I had is on Global Markets. I appreciate that the second half will be
lower than the fantastic first half, but any sense on what the second half will be versus the
second half last year, which – as you said – was significantly lower than H1 ’19?
EWEN STEVENSON: Yeah, so on the second question, the second half last year did have
some one-off positive events in it, but it’s a much better guide for what we think than the first
half of this year. Certainly in terms of trading, I think what we’ve seen since June has fallen
back very much more in line with what we anticipated at the start of the year versus what we
saw in the first half.
On the deposit beta in Hong Kong, Ming, do you want to handle that?
MING LAU: Yeah, thanks, Ewen. I’d say on that no material change from what we guided a
few weeks ago. The one thing I would say we’re noticing now is probably more on HIBOR
rates themselves over the past week with a lot of the announcements on large IPOs and so
forth, we are seeing a tightening of the rate. There has been a bit of an increase on
short-term HIBOR rates, which would feed through to give us a bit of a benefit in September.
FAHAD KUNWAR: Okay, thank you. Ewen, just to be clear, is the H2 ’19 level flattish on that
kind of level? Obviously there’s going to be puts and takes, but that feels like the right kind of
guide to H2 2019 as it stands at the moment?
EWEN STEVENSON: Well, it’s – we’re two months into six months with a business that’s
highly volatile, so it’s somewhat speculative.
Thanks a lot for your time today, and if you do have any follow-up questions Richard and the
team are fully available. As I said, as we look out at the moment we are very, very focused on
how we need to structurally shift the business model to address what is an increasingly
strong view that interest rates are going to stay low for a prolonged period of time, which is a
mix of non-interest income, costs, capital allocation. On distributions, we critically understand
the importance of distributions. We understand that we need to get back to paying them; it’s
just too early to speculate at the moment, given some of the uncertainty that sits out there,
but a lot of that uncertainty, I think, whether it be Brexit, the path out of COVID, US
presidential election, etc, we will know a lot more in the next few months. I look forward to
talking to you all at the end of October with Q3 results, so thanks for your time.

-- 8 of 8 --