TRANSCRIPT

Q1 2020 — Earnings call transcript

Q1 2020PDF · 22 pages804 KB
1
Interactive Brokers Group's (IBKR)
Q1 2020 Results - Earnings Call Transcript
April 21, 2020 4:30 PM ET
Executives
Thomas Peterffy - Chairman
Paul Brody - CFO
Nancy Stuebe - Director, IR
Analysts
Will Nance Goldman Sachs
Kyle Voigt Keefe, Bruyette, & Woods
Rich Repetto, Piper Sandler
Chris Harris, Wells Fargo Securities
Chris Allen, Compass Point Research
Mac Sykes, Gabelli
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by, and welcome to the Interactive Brokers Group
First Quarter Financial Results Conference Call. (Operator Instructions) Please be advised that
today's conference is being recorded. (Operator Instructions)
I would now like to hand the conference over to your speaker today, Nancy Stuebe, Director of
Investor Relations. Thank you. Please go ahead, ma'am.
Nancy Stuebe
Good afternoon, and thank you for joining us for our first quarter 2020 earnings conference call.
Once again, Thomas is on the call, but asked me to present his comments on the business. He will
handle the Q&A.

-- 1 of 22 --

2
As a reminder, today's call may include forward-looking statements, which represent the
company's belief regarding future events, which by their nature are not certain and are outside of
the company's control, for actual results and financial condition may differ, possibly materially,
from what is indicated in these forward-looking statements. We ask that you refer to the
disclaimers in our press release. You should also review a description of risk factors contained in
our financial reports filed with the SEC.
In light of the COVID-19 pandemic, we want to emphasize that our focus is on our employees,
clients and communities. Senior management at Interactive Brokers has worked together for
decades, most from before the inception of the electronic broker. We were all here during the
financial crisis. Many were here in 1987 as well. Our company's culture has been one of working
hard independently and together to solve problems and come up with solutions, preferably
automated ones. This strength of management cohesion and long-time experience enabled us to
react to recent events in a coordinated way worldwide, which allowed us to move quickly to a
work-from-home model.
Globally, the majority of our employees are working remotely, and they have the tools needed to
work effectively. Because our systems and processes are highly automated, the bulk of our
employees can work from outside a physical office.
Our long-time focus on automated self-service solutions, like our IBot AI system that can answer
many client questions, served us well during this time. And while the market turbulence, together
with the high volume of new accounts, had at times this quarter challenged our client service call
capacity, we activated plans to address this and have made good progress in reducing wait times.
While the world around us has changed greatly in the past few months, Interactive Brokers'
ability to achieve new records has not. Accounts rose 22% over last year to 760,000, as we added
70,000 net new accounts in the quarter - about the same number of account adds, in one quarter,
as we added over the first 3 quarters of 2019. This implies a 40% annualized account growth rate.
Account growth was seen in all client segments and all geographic regions. There has been no
change in the ability of China accounts to fund. Despite markets down about 9% year-on-year,
our total client equity rose 9% to $161 billion, the second highest quarterly total in our history.

-- 2 of 22 --

3
As our customer base grew, DARTs and DARTs per account also rose significantly, as more
clients traded actively during record-high market volatility. Total DARTs reached over 1.4
million, up 71% from last year, while DARTs per account grew to over 450, their highest level in
about 4 years. And during the month of March, our DARTs exceeded 2 million.
We have spoken many times of our focus on growing our customer base in all segments, so we
can take advantage of volatility in any market scenarios. Our business is strong even with
moderate volatility, but because of the highly automated nature of our platform and our low-cost
structure, higher volatility and trading activity sends a greater proportion of revenues to our
bottom line.
When we're asked, “What led to this strength?”, It is simple, it all leads back to our platform, its
global reach and vast product offering and the strength and reliability of its automation during
busy periods. Because of this, when people anywhere in the world, plus stay at home, as they are
during the recent coronavirus pandemic and they look for something productive to do, Interactive
Brokers can help them find it.
However, we must fess up to the dim outlook for net interest revenue in the new 0 interest
regime. While our net interest income has been slightly over $250 million per quarter, we will be
lucky to get to $150 million per quarter while rates are near 0 and margin loans and short interest
remain at lower levels.
Finally, our total equity reached over $8 billion in the first quarter, our highest amount to date.
With no debt, our balance sheet remains strong. As we continue to grow larger, our equity capital
helps us attract larger customers.
We saw growth in all 5 of the client types that we service. I will now go over our 5 client
segments.
Individual customers, which made up 52% of our accounts, 36% of our client equity and 51% of
our commissions, were particularly strong this quarter with 12-month account growth of 29%,

-- 3 of 22 --

4
client equity growth of 11% and 12% growth in commissions. Despite a background of 9%-plus
drops in most major markets, the increases we saw in client equity and commissions indicate the
strength of our growth in this segment.
While all geographic regions we serve saw double-digit account growth, we saw particularly
strong increases in Europe and Asia, showing the importance of providing a reliable platform to a
global audience that offers wide product choices and worldwide access. This way, clients have
the maximum opportunities to invest in the way they prefer. As mentioned earlier, Interactive
Brokers is a stay-at-home company, with individuals wanting to trade and manage their money
now that they have the time to do so, and the growth we saw in the individual segment reflects
this.
We continue to see growth in the hedge fund customer segment despite world market weakness.
For the 12 months ended March 31, we saw 4% hedge fund account growth, 2% customer equity
growth and 1% commission growth. We continue to benefit from growing word of mouth, our
reputation for best price execution, low margin rates, and from the quality of our platform and the
strength of our balance sheet. Hedge funds represent 1% of our accounts, 8% of our client equity
and 9% of our commissions.
Proprietary trading firms are 2% of our accounts, 12% of client equity, and 15% of commissions.
For the quarter, this group grew by 11% in accounts for the 12-month period, 23% in client
equity and 17% in commissions. Prop trading firms are sensitive to the direction of volatility, and
trade more as volatility increases. This quarter's high volatility led to more active trading
strategies, while accounts and client equity grew due to more traders wanting to be on our
platform, and to capitalize on its reputation for seamlessness and efficient trade executions.
Financial advisers are 14% of our accounts, 20% of our customer equity and 15% of our
commissions. This group grew accounts by 8% for the 12-month period, while customer equity
declined by 6% and commissions were flat. World markets’ declines over the period meant that
client equity did not keep pace with account growth, and commissions for the segment, which
typically tends to trade more conservatively, were flat.

-- 4 of 22 --

5
Our final segment is introducing brokers. These represent 31% of our accounts, 24% of our client
equity and 10% of our commissions. IBroker segment account growth was 19% for the latest 12
months, with 18% in client equity growth and 15% in commissions. Interactive Brokers platform,
and its ability to offer global trading and seamless back-office functionality, are compelling
arguments for brokers who more and more seek a service for a global offering, as people
worldwide seek to trade on recent market volatility and want to be able to access many markets in
order to do so.
We continue to enhance our platform and this quarter expanded our mutual fund offering to close
to 25,000 mutual funds, including additions to our offshore fund offerings for our global client
base. Our new Offshore Fund Scanner allows clients to choose from a wide variety of funds. And
of course, we always aim to be significantly less expensive. We do not charge high custody or
transaction fees for offshore funds. Rather, our fees range in price from free to just under EUR 5.
We have also seen better response from our digital marketing efforts since year-end, a positive
development we hope will continue.
With that, I will turn the call over to our CFO, Paul Brody, who will go through the numbers for
the quarter. Paul?
Paul Brody
Thank you, Nancy. Thanks, everyone, for joining the call. I hope you're all safe and
healthy. First, I'll review our operating results and noncore items. My comments will follow the
format of the earnings release, after which we'll open up the call for questions.
You'll note that starting this quarter, we're no longer presenting separate operating business
segments. After several years of winding down our market making activity, we have reached the
point where it is not contributing materially to our overall results. The streamlined presentation
reflects our management focus on our robust Electronic Brokerage business. We have also
revised the presentation of line items in the revenue section of our income statement, grouping
the interest income and expense lines and splitting other fees and services from other income.

-- 5 of 22 --

6
The former contains recurring items such as market data fees and FDIC Bank Sweep Program
income, while the latter contains currency impacts, U.S. Treasury marks-to-market, principal
trading activities and other investment gains or losses.
Turning to the operating data. The operating metrics reflected record levels of trading and
account openings in a high volatility environment. This was a tumultuous quarter, given the
impact of the coronavirus around the world. Volatility, as measured by the average VIX, nearly
doubled to 30.7 in the current quarter, up from 16.7 in the first quarter last year. In contrast to the
first 3 months of 2019 when the VIX ranged from 15 to 20, this quarter, after showing similar
levels in the first 2 months, the index averaged 57 in March and exploded to a high of over 82
mid-month. This dramatic increase corresponded with higher industry trading volumes in
products across the board.
Compared to the first quarter of 2019, our quarterly total DARTs rose 71% to a record 1.45
million.
Our customer trade volumes rose dramatically in every product class, led by increases of 64%,
59% and 24% in the customer options, futures and stock volumes, respectively. FX dollar
volumes were strong as well, increasing 58%. Total accounts reached 760,000, up 22% over the
prior year, which contributed to customer equity growth of 9% to $160.7 billion at quarter-end
despite a drop of 9% in the S&P 500 Index over the time period.
Our overall average cleared commission per commissionable order fell 10% versus last year to
$3.30. On a product mix, it featured smaller average trade sizes in stocks, futures and ForEx and
higher in options.
Moving on to our net interest margin table. Our net interest margin narrowed from 1.67% to
1.45% in the first quarter, as benchmark interest rates declined and clients delevered, resulting in
a greater proportion of their assets held in cash and less margin lending.

-- 6 of 22 --

7
The Federal Reserve made a series of moves in March to aid the economy in light of the impact
of the coronavirus, the end result of which was a near-0 interest rate policy in the U.S. In light of
the flat yield curve, we kept the duration of our portfolio relatively short and recorded a mark-to-
market gain of $11 million on our holdings of U.S. Treasuries. As always, we plan to hold these
securities to maturity, but as brokers, unlike banks, GAAP rules require us to mark them to
market in our financial reporting.
Outside the U.S., benchmark interest rates were cut in many currencies, as central banks look to
soften the impact from the COVID-19 pandemic, with exceptions in countries where rates were
already 0 or negative. This moderates somewhat our expectations on the impact of U.S. rates on
net interest income, as about 1/4 of customer credit balances are not in U.S. dollars.
Increased customer balances, despite lower rates in this quarter versus last year, generated more
net interest income on cash balances. In addition to the cash from customers liquidating positions,
we continue to have success in asset gathering. Along with the growth in cash balances, our
FDIC Insured Bank Deposit Sweep Program has grown to $2.9 billion, up from $1.9 billion last
year.
Margin lending and segregated cash management continued to be the largest contributors to our
net interest margin. Average margin loan balances rose 6% versus last year, however,
significantly lower interest rates versus last year led to a 20% decline in margin interest income.
Lower rates also reduced our earnings on segregated cash, where despite a 32% increase in
segregated cash balances, interest income fell 22%. Note that effective Fed funds fell nearly in
half over this time period. Several factors caused the yields on our segregated cash to differ from
the changes in Fed funds rates. First, the portion is held in other currencies. And second, given an
average duration of investment in Treasuries of about 44 days during the quarter, re-investments
take place over time, so these amounts would not be expected to follow declines immediately.
The increase in segregated cash balances is also a function of customers' diminished appetite for
risk. That is less investment in stocks, particularly in purchases financed by margin loans leads to
more segregated cash on the sideline to be invested. Note too that the FDIC Sweep Program

-- 7 of 22 --

8
removes funds that would otherwise be included in our segregated cash balances from our
balance sheet for accounting purposes.
Securities lending interest income was up 19% this quarter versus a year ago, as we capitalized
on more hard-to-borrow names that investors were looking to short.
Now for our estimate of the impact of the next 25 basis point increase in rates, however unlikely
that may seem at the time. When calculating the impact of rate changes, we understand that as
the possibility of a future rate increase becomes more certain, this expectation is typically already
reflected in the yields of the instruments in which we invest. Therefore, we attempt to isolate the
impact of an unexpected rise of falling rates, separate from the impact of rate hikes or cuts that
have already been baked into the prices of these instruments.
With that assumption, we would expect the next 25 basis point unanticipated rise in rates to
produce an additional $79 million in net interest income over the next 4 quarters, and $94 million
as the yearly run rate based on our current balance sheet. These numbers are higher than our
typical calculation due to the impact of low benchmark rates on the spread between what we earn
on our segregated cash and what we pay to our customers. As U.S. rates fall below 50 basis
points, the spread compresses as we earn less on our segregated cash. However, the converse is
also true that as rates move back up towards 50 basis points, the spread rises.
The run rate includes the reinvestment of all of our present holdings at the new assumed rate, but
does not take into account any change in how we might manage our segregated cash. If we are
successful in continuing to grow our customer assets, the higher cash and margin lending
balances will provide some offset to the loss of net interest income from low benchmark rates,
should they persist.
As I explained earlier, this quarter we begin reporting our consolidated numbers only without
segments. We define noncore items as those not part of our fundamental operating results.
Noncore items adjusted the numbers versus the year ago quarter as follows: our currency
diversification strategy lost $19 million a year ago versus a loss of $49 million this quarter, so a
comparative decrease in income of $30 million. A shift from $104 million mark-to-market gain to

-- 8 of 22 --

9
$11 million loss on investments reduced income by $115 million. Mark-to-market gains on U.S.
government securities went from $5 million to $11 million, a comparative increase of $6 million.
And unusual customer bad debt expense of $42 million in the year-ago quarter did not recur in
the first quarter. The net effect of these adjustments reduced income by $97 million
comparatively versus last year.
Net revenues were a reported $532 million for the quarter, down 5% versus last year's first
quarter. Excluding noncore items, the net revenue was up 24% to $581 million. Commission
revenue rose 55% on significantly higher volumes in all product categories. Lower average trade
sizes in nearly all product categories reduced our average cleared commission per
commissionable order to $3.30. This is often seen during high volatility periods as traders risk
less in a fast moving market.
Net interest income rose 4% to $256 million despite a 48% decline in the average effective Fed
funds rate versus the year-ago quarter. Other fees and services revenues, which include market
data, exposure, account activity and FDIC Bank Sweep Program fees, as well as order flow
income from options exchange mandated programs, rose $3 million or 9% over last year.
Other income, which includes gains and losses on our investments and currency strategy as well
as principal transactions, was a loss of $31 million. And ex noncore items, other income
increased 29% to $18 million.
Noninterest expenses were $224 million for the quarter, up 2% from last year. Adjusting 2019 for
an unusual margin loss, noninterest expenses were up 27% due primarily to higher execution and
clearing costs in line with higher trade volumes.
At quarter-end, our total headcount stood at 1,702, a 17% increase over last year. Currently, due
to the COVID-19 pandemic, we have about 3/4 of our employees worldwide working remotely.
After a brief pause, we are hiring again to keep up with the influx of new accounts and to
strengthen client services and systems development for the future.
Fixed expenses were $140 million, up 22%, driven by higher compensation and benefits, in line

-- 9 of 22 --

10
with the hiring that supports the growing brokerage business, and G&A expenses, including legal
and compliance costs and reserves.
Customer bad debt expense was a higher than usual $7 million, but it was well contained despite
the dramatic increase in volatility. Reported pretax income was $308 million, down 9% for a 58%
margin. And excluding noncore items, pretax income was $357 million, up 23% for a 61% pretax
margin.
Diluted earnings per share were $0.60 for the quarter versus $0.64 for the same period in 2019.
And ex noncore items, diluted earnings per share were $0.69 versus $0.55 as adjusted last year.
To help investors better understand our earnings, taxes and the split between the public
shareholders and the noncontrolling interests, first quarter numbers are as follows. Starting with
our pretax income of $308 million, we deduct $9 million for income taxes paid by our operating
companies, which are mostly foreign taxes. This leaves $299 million, of which 81.5% or that
$244 million reported on our income statement, is attributable to noncontrolling interests. The
remaining 18.5%, or $55, million is available for the public company shareholders, but as this is a
non-GAAP measure, it is not reported on our income statement.
After we expense remaining taxes of $9 million owed on that $55 million, the public company's
net income available for common stockholders is the $46 million you see reported on our income
statement. Our income tax expense of $18 million consists of this $9 million plus the $9 million
of taxes paid by the operating companies.
Turning to the balance sheet, it consistently remains highly liquid with low leverage, with $8.15
billion in consolidated equity. We are well capitalized from a regulatory standpoint and continue
to deploy our equity capital in the growing brokerage business. We hold excess capital in order to
take advantage of opportunities, as well as to emphasize the strength and depth of our balance
sheet. And we continue to carry no long-term debt.
At March 31, margin loans were $20 billion, a decline of 22% from last year as clients delevered
in a risk-off environment. We continue to expect swings in margin lending balances due to our

-- 10 of 22 --

11
success in attracting institutional hedge fund customers who are more opportunistic in taking on
leverage. We offer the lowest margin lending rates of our competitors, and as we expand our
customer base, we stand well positioned to satisfy customers' risk appetite when it returns.
Now I'll turn it over to moderator, and we can take some questions.
Question and Answer Session
Operator
(Operator Instructions) Our first question comes from the line of Rich Repetto from Piper
Sandler.
Rich Repetto
I guess my question has to do with the press release that you put out after the close about the
provisionary loss you're going to take related to the WTI contract. And I guess the question is,
was this due to customers holding the positions right till close to expiration? Because I'm just
wondering how they could ever fulfill like the physical delivery requirement of holding the
contract.
Thomas Peterffy
So Rich, first of all, I would like to apologize for springing this announcement onto everybody so
unexpectedly, this happened to us just last night. We were up most of the night trying to figure
out what was going on, and we still do not have all of our facts completely in order. But I felt that
we have to put out this notice.
Now as to your question, this was a cash-delivered contract -- cash-settled contract. So it was not
about delivering. The cash-settled contract is priced off of the delivered contract, the CL. So this
is WTI, that is priced off of the CL and the CL settlement price, which is a delivered contract,
determines the settlement price -- sorry, CL trade price in a 2-minute window of between 2:28
and 2:30 Europe time, the volume based at average price in those 2 minutes on the CL contract

-- 11 of 22 --

12
determines the settlement price for this cash settlement contract. So most of the loss came from
WTI, and some of it came from -- Paul, do you remember the name of that future?
Paul Brody
QM, which is the mini crude oil contract.
Thomas Peterffy
QM. E-mini crude oil contract that's trading on the CME.
Rich Repetto
Okay. So -- well, both the contracts are listed contracts on the CME then, is that correct?
Thomas Peterffy
No, no. The WTI is listed on ICE-Europe. So ICE has a European branch, and that's where it is
listed. The bulk of the provision was from that contract.
Rich Repetto
Understood. Okay. I guess the next question is, Paul, on the expected outlook on the net interest
income, and I said going from $250 million, I think, you said per -- I thought you said per quarter
to $150 million. And I guess if you could just sort of walk through sort of the sensitivities there,
so we'd just better understand how you come up with that number?
Paul Brody
Well, naturally, there's a lot of moving parts in there. So you have to make certain assumptions,
some of them are relatively broad, about what rates might do, or that they're going to do nothing,
and then, of course, what balances are likely to be. And the balances are not a small part of the
equation, because we've seen radical increases in cash credit balances as customers unwound
positions. They're happy to leave the cash with us. And then, of course, a big part of the
projection has to do with the spread compression. And what I alluded to when the Fed goes
below 50 basis points is that our base credit rate is Fed funds less 50 basis points, that's a very
good rate versus our competitors, but of course, it become 0 when the benchmark goes below 50

-- 12 of 22 --

13
basis points. So that creates the spread compression, which is also why there's this big elasticity
when you see -- as we talk about rates going back up, if they were to go back up, you get a lot
back quickly, because for a certain portion of it, the customer side that we're paying on still
doesn't go up until it passes 0, right? So there are a lot of moving parts in there. We have to make
certain assumptions at the moment. This is our best projection.
Rich Repetto
Got it. That's very helpful. And I guess, the last thing, Thomas, you've mentioned about this stay-
at-home phenomena, where it seems like you're benefiting from more client activity. And I guess,
the question is, with all this activity, we're still not seeing any -- or could you refresh us in
regards to any material difference in mix of the IBKR Lite versus IBKR Pro? We're still seeing
people still choose IBKR Pro even in this -- even with high trading volatility, and maybe it drives
to even more so, if they require the Smart Router even more so.
Thomas Peterffy
Right. So the more volatile the market is, the more important it is that you get the execution
prices, because in a very volatile market, the execution prices can differ to the prices that you see,
because it changes so often much, much, much more. So yes, people choose IBKR Pro, the
overwhelming majority of them. So far, we have between 20,000 and 21,000 accounts that have
chosen to convert to or open an IBKR Lite account and 760,000 I Pro --. I'm sorry, these are
today's numbers. So I'm sorry, I should have gotten back to the end of last quarter, yes.
Operator
Our next question comes from the line of Chris Allen from Compass Point.
Chris Allen
I was wondering if we could just dig into the net interest income outlook a little bit more. You
gave us kind of the starting point to think about customer margin loans for 2Q, and we can make
some assumptions around that and the cash levels. How are you guys thinking about the
securities lending book? And then also, does it contemplate continued growth in your customer
base from here? Obviously, we can bottom it at a certain level, but then even if rates are stable,

-- 13 of 22 --

14
we should start to see some growth start to drive that higher. So any color on that would be
helpful.
Thomas Peterffy
Right. But you see without growth, if all the numbers were what they are today or at least what
they were at the end of the quarter, the projected interest income would be even lower; most of it
is due to the fact that we get basically 15 basis points on customer cash. And that is the biggest
item there, right, because we have roughly $70 billion of customer cash, of which $20 billion is
lent out in margin loans and $50 billion is lent out in the short-term Treasury market, and that
yields only 15 basis points. So that's the culprit. As far -- otherwise, the fact that the margin loans
came down from close to $30 billion to $20 billion, that's another big drawback. And the third is
that the short book came down from roughly around $10 billion to $7 billion or $8 billion.
Paul Brody
Part of that last point, if I could jump in, is that prices are down, right? But clearly, there's been
some winding down of positions. But let me say what we've talked about before, which is that the
securities lending business is very driven by stocks that get special for a period of time, where
great interest, particularly on the short side, kicks up and they become expensive to borrow and
lend. And if our customers are on the long side of that, it generates a lot of revenue. So there is,
of course, a base of both the shorts and the longs, but it's very much driven by these stocks that
become special for short periods of time.
Chris Allen
Understood. And then just switching over to the provision loss, I appreciate the color there.
Obviously, there's a lot of chatter just around what's going on in oil ETFs. Are you seeing any
other dislocations in markets like there? Any thoughts on the market structure in these products in
terms of things that we have to worry about moving forward from a credit loss perspective?
Thomas Peterffy
Well, hopefully, not on our end, but I think there are other people out there with various problems
having to do with exchange-traded notes and funds and -- that are holding oil futures. And as I

-- 14 of 22 --

15
said on the TV interview, there are folks -- we have 15% of the open interest. So there is 85% out
there in some other folks’ hands. And so a proportionate loss to the percentages. And there is also
a big winner out there, at least one or many, who was holding the opposite side.
Operator
Our next question comes from the line of Will Nance from Goldman Sachs.
Will Nance
Thomas, I was wondering if you can provide some more clarity around the regulatory matters
mentioned in the press release. And if you could provide some more clarity around the findings
around the BSA/AML practices, maybe if you have some sort of idea around what the
shortcomings identified were and what it will take to remedy them? And then, I guess, either
Thomas -- go ahead.
Thomas Peterffy
All I can say about that is that we have been on this topic -- working on this topic for about at
least 2 years. And as you can imagine, that part of the press release was very carefully drafted.
And given the thing is still not -- has not closed, but it's likely to be closed within probably --
certainly by the next quarterly meeting, you just have to wait. I'm sorry, but lawyers are telling
me to be very, very careful in whatever you say about open cases.
Will Nance
Sure. And maybe leaving aside -- and I totally understand that there's probably -- you're probably
limited on what you can say. Maybe leaving the fine aspect aside, can you talk about what you're
thinking about with the third-party consultants and what the kind of scope or what that might
entail from a cost perspective going forward would be?
Thomas Peterffy
Well, we have been working with these consultants for at least a year, I'm sure. And so there will
be the same consultants, and we're working with them very well. And I assume that the cost will
be -- going forward will be similar to what they have been in the past. So I don't think there are

-- 15 of 22 --

16
any surprises coming from there.
Will Nance
Got it. That makes sense. And then maybe switching gears over to expenses. I guess, one, just a
little housekeeping item. Given the strong volumes, I would have thought execution and clearing
might have been a little bit higher. Was there anything to call out that drove that to be a little bit
lower than expected this quarter? And then separately, more bigger picture, given the decline in
net interest income that you expect, given the rate environment, are there any levers to pull on the
cost side that might offset some of this and maybe help you retain some of your best-in-class
margins?
Thomas Peterffy
So -- well, as far as the second question goes, we have always been, throughout our history, been
focusing on growth. And well, sometimes, revenues are low, sometimes they are high. We do not
look at that when we deal with expenses, we always spend as much money as we productively
can to grow the business. That's always been our focus, and we have never looked at expenses.
Now, of course, you hopefully -- so I don't remember the first question, but I remember that the
answer is that trades were generally slow -- smaller in this quarter. Oh, you asked how the trading
-- the expenses on the trades were not higher. It's because trades were generally lower in size than
the previous quarter, even though as you see the volume was much, much, much greater. You
can’t just extrapolate by volume, because you have to include the size of the trade. And if you
look at the monthly releases, you can see that, right?
Will Nance
Right. So if I look at more on shares traded and...
Thomas Peterffy
Right.
Will Nance
Got it, okay. And then if I could squeeze one more, a quick one in just for Paul. If -- I think some

-- 16 of 22 --

17
people are probably a bit surprised by the magnitude of the decline in net interest margin. I think
everyone understood that lower rates pressured the spread, but the absolute size is probably a
little bit larger. Is it a fair statement to say that a big driver of that is just the decline in margin
loans? And could you maybe talk about how sensitive that $150 million run rate could be if we
see kind of a rebound in margin balances over the next several quarters?
Thomas Peterffy
So if I may -- I'm the fellow who is responsible for investing the customer cash. And the fact is
that we do not do anything fancy with it. We are invested in short-term Treasuries. So we
fluctuate with the short-term Treasury rates. And as you know, when Treasury rates go above
0.5%, that extra we return to our customers. So we're only sensitive here where the interest rate is
between 0 and 0.5%. Once we're above 0.5%, we return that excess to the customers, at least to
those whose accounts are larger than $100,000, which I think is over -- only $10 billion of our
customer funds are in accounts that are less than $100,000. As far as the margin balances, as I
said before, they have gone down from $30 billion to $20 billion. And obviously, we do not want
to increase the margin rates, because we hope to work that up back up to $30 billion, $40 billion,
$50 billion. So we're not -- we're never trying to maximize income for the next several quarters.
We are always trying to maximize income for the years to come.
Operator
Our next question comes from the line of Kyle Voigt from KBW.
Kyle Voigt
Sorry to belabor the point on NII, but I just want to ask a couple of more questions. One, you just
mentioned you're responsible for investing that client cash. I remember that back in 2016, I think
over 90% of the securities portfolio at that time was invested in U.S. government securities, and
repos were a really a small part of what you're doing. Now it's kind of inverted, mostly just
overnight repo. Could you take any more duration risk, go out 2 year, 3 year, 4 year or 2 or 5 year
on the Treasury curve? And then the second part of that question is, is there -- could you -- you
were looking previously at potentially expanding the securities that you would be comfortable
investing in for that securities portfolio, I think some other agency securities? Is that on the table

-- 17 of 22 --

18
as well to maybe pick up some additional yield in that book?
Thomas Peterffy
So I think it's basically the same question, whether we do agencies or longer-term Treasuries. My
answer is that especially at these rates, I mean, it's hard to imagine that they can go any further
down. As a matter of fact, the federal government pushing all this money out and more and more
and more and more, I think eventually, that inflation will enter the picture and the fact that you
have to do something to counteract that. So I would not, at this time -- certainly, at this time,
would not go further out on the yield curve.
Kyle Voigt
Got it. And then maybe just a follow-up for Paul. I know you mentioned that $150 million run
rate. Is that a run rate as of today? Because you also mentioned that you still had securities that
had some duration to them, those Treasury securities, but maybe a year or over duration in that
portion of the book that I assume would provide you kind of a more of a gradual landing point to
maybe get to $150 million a couple of quarters or a few quarters out. But it sounded like that's
really the run rate today. Just maybe if you could clarify that.
Paul Brody
Yes. So because the duration is fairly short, the roll-off happens basically in -- if you were to
project out 4 quarters, it all happens in the first quarter, and then your reinvestments happen at
whatever you assume the reinvestment rate is. So depending on the scenario, say, up 25 basis
points, you start to pick that up a little bit of a lag, which is why when I projected $79 million for
the first 4 quarters, but about $94 million full year run rate, that's exactly why, because it assumes
that full investment. Similarly on the downside, we don't have too far to go down. But you have
that greater impact -- as we said before, you have that greater impact, because essentially, you're
not paying anything to customers on their credit balances at the moment. Therefore, any pickup
in the rates go straight to the bottom line, if you will, until you get to that 50 basis points, and
then as Thomas said, it becomes a spread.
Kyle Voigt

-- 18 of 22 --

19
No, I get that. I guess I'm just saying that on the securities book yield, I thought there were some
of the securities book that was invested in Treasuries that may have had a duration of a year or
over, that portion of the book that would have repriced over a year, instead of repriced
immediately. But I guess you're saying everything is essentially repriced already?
Paul Brody
Well, you're right. Some of it is Treasuries owned, that's primarily for the commodities business
to meet regulatory requirements. It's a much smaller piece of the total, and some of those do
mature a bit further out. But we take all that into account when we talk about that overall
duration.
Kyle Voigt
Okay. Got it. And then just the last one from me is just a follow-up on the losses in -- related to
WTI. Just wondering if you could just let us know what -- if those losses were from hedge fund
clients or retail clients or just kind of give us an idea of the client segment?
Thomas Peterffy
There were many clients, but we don't have hedge fund clients or retail clients. We have
institutional clients and individual clients. And my understanding is that most of these are from
individuals. But as you know -- I mean these individual clients tend to be all - traders and people
that usually know what they are doing.
Operator
Our next question comes from the line of Chris Harris from Wells Fargo.
Chris Harris
I'm sorry if I missed it, but can you elaborate a little bit on why do you think account growth
picked up so materially in the quarter?
Thomas Peterffy
“Stay-at-home” company! So I think there are many people who have, for years, been telling

-- 19 of 22 --

20
themselves that one of these days, I'm going to open a brokerage account, I'm going to begin to
manage my finances myself. And they just never get around to it. And so finally, they have the
time and they have the motivation, so they are doing it. It's an educated guess on my part. That's
what I think.
Chris Harris
Okay. And we've been talking a lot about net interest and the impact on your business. One thing
I was thinking about is one of the value propositions of IBKR is the favorable rate you pay the
customers on deposits. But now that everybody is...
Thomas Peterffy
Yes. Unfortunately, that has gone away. I think has gone away.
Chris Harris
Yes, right, exactly. So do you think that's going to have much of an impact on the outlook in
terms of growth? Or are people still going to be attracted to the other parts of your business,
whether it be the Smart Routing order capability or whether it's the lower rate on margin and so
on?
Thomas Peterffy
It remains what it remains. Well, as interest rates were coming down, it became less and less
relevant already in the quarters preceding this. But of course -- now, it is 0, and we will not be
able to give them anything until Fed goes over 0.5%. But to tell you frankly, I do not think that --
I do not hear that, that is as important as the margin rate is. But -- I really don't know. I mean it's
a different type of person who -- it's probably a less vocal person who is worried about receiving
interest on the cash and the person who is trying to get a cheap margin loan.
Operator
(Operator Instructions) Our next question comes from the line of Mac Sykes from Gabelli.
Mac Sykes

-- 20 of 22 --

21
Can you just talk a little bit about the level of volatility, the trade-off between what's good for
commission revenue, but still okay for sustaining your customer base?
Thomas Peterffy
Well, that's hard to -- it's very difficult math. Because the higher the volatility, the more trades we
do, the customers tend to do less well. And I don't think it's that much due to the volatility, as the
volatility tends to be higher when the market goes down, basically. So that's why customers tend
to do less well. And so up until the market turned around in the last 2 or 3 days, things were
looking pretty good. Of course, it's a different story again. I really can't tell you where the balance
is, what is the ideal ratio of volatility and trades.
Mac Sykes
Okay. And then on margin lending, I know you have the card facility. Have you noticed, in the
last month, any kind of additional margin loan that would be suggestive of stress versus kind of
increase in allocation to the market?
Thomas Peterffy
No. So our margin loans have come down drastically, and they maybe picked up just a tiny bit in
the last 2 or 3 weeks, but not much. So no, we haven't seen any of that. No.
Operator
Thank you. At this time, I am showing no further questions. I would like to turn the call back
over to Nancy Stuebe for closing remarks.
Nancy Stuebe
Thank you, everyone, for participating today. As a reminder, this call will be available for replay
on our website, and we will be posting a clean version of our transcript on our site tomorrow.
Thank you again, and we will talk to you next quarter-end.
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes today's conference call. Thanks for participating. You may

-- 21 of 22 --

22
now disconnect.

-- 22 of 22 --