TRANSCRIPT

Q4 2021 — Earnings call transcript

Q4 2021PDF · 27 pages201 KB
1
Interactive Brokers Group's (IBKR)
Q4 2021 Results - Earnings Call Transcript
January 18, 2022 4:30 PM ET
Executives
Thomas Peterffy - Chairman and CEO
Paul Brody - CFO
Nancy Stuebe - Director, IR
Analysts
Will Nance Goldman Sachs
Rich Repetto, Piper Sandler
Craig Siegenthaler, BofA
Dan Fannon, Jefferies
Mac Sykes, G. Research
Kyle Voigt KBW
Chris Allen, Compass Point Research
Operator
(Operator Instructions)
Please be advised that today's conference may be recorded. I would now like to hand the call over
to your host, Director of Investor Relations, Nancy Stuebe. Please go ahead.
Nancy Stuebe
Thank you. Good afternoon, and thank you for joining us for our fourth quarter 2021 earnings
call. Once again, Thomas is on the call, but asked me to present his comments on the business.
He will handle the Q&A.

-- 1 of 27 --

2
As a reminder, today's call may include forward-looking statements, which represent the
company's belief regarding future events, which by their nature are not certain and are outside of
the company's control.
Our actual results and financial condition may differ, possibly materially, from what is indicated
in these forward-looking statements. We ask that you refer to the disclaimers in our press release.
You should also review a description of risk factors contained in our financial statements filed
with the SEC.
2021 was a good year for Interactive Brokers. Adjusted revenues were $2.78 billion, up 26% for
the year, and expenses were well controlled, resulting in a pretax profit margin that improved
from 61% to 67%, by far the highest in the industry.
Adjusted diluted earnings per share for the year were $3.37, and that was 35% higher than the
previous year. We look back at 2021 as one with unprecedented global investor engagement with
the market.
The only better year we can see is 2022. Let me explain why.
In 2021, we added more customers, over 600,000, and did more trades, over 2.5 million DARTs
per day, than we ever have before.
We introduced more products and more tools, while also expanding many existing ones.
And to assist with our continuing growth we hired and trained nearly 450 new employees around
the world.
Our year-on-year account growth was 56% this year. I've been saying for some time that, after
this unusually active period we have been experiencing, a period that seems to keep growing
longer, we will see account growth closer to between 30% and 40% a year. But that does not
mean that we will not do almost anything we can think of to try to keep it above those levels.

-- 2 of 27 --

3
We introduced more new products and expanded the capabilities of existing ones.
Recognizing our global customer reach, we introduced GlobalAnalyst, which allows our clients
to discover undervalued companies from a wide database of global stocks.
We introduced our crypto offering. U.S. individuals, RIAs, hedge funds and introducing brokers,
as well as individuals in over 100 different countries, can now all trade crypto through our
partner, Paxos.
Very shortly, we will be offering crypto for our international financial advisers, iBrokers and
Hedge Funds in those countries, and we will add more countries continually.
We charge just 0.12% to 0.18% of trade value, with a minimum $1.75 per trade.
We rolled out our ESG-focused IMPACT app, which brings transparency and a streamlined,
simplified platform to help clients find and invest in companies that share their values. IMPACT
also allows them to make cash donations to thousands of different U.S. charities directly from the
app.
We also introduced U.S. spot gold trading.
And these are just a few of the items we have been working on, and we have other exciting
products and improvements in various stages in advance of being rolled out.
As 2021 drew to a close, IBKR was able to produce its second-best quarter of the year after the
hyperactive meme stock events of the first quarter. But the story of the meme stocks will fade in
the minds of investors, while the most remarkable story of the year, the huge rise in popularity of
options and, more specifically, option spreads, will remain.
As someone who has spent the last 50 years trying to automate the options industry, I very much
welcome this development. For a long time, Interactive Brokers was alone, trying to stir up
industry interest to computerize these markets.

-- 3 of 27 --

4
But now, finally, people are beginning to understand what fantastic versatile instruments options
are.
I am predicting further growth, especially internationally. Option spreads give traders the
opportunity to assume very specific and limited risk-reward profile, for specific periods of time.
Please visit our Probability Lab on the IBKR website for a fun way to think about, learn about
and play with options.
As the year wore on, listed options saw an average daily volume of nearly 40 million contracts,
and Interactive Brokers customers responsible for roughly 10% of daily options volume.
This is even more than in equities, where we are only about 7%.
Execution quality is most important for options traders, especially for options spread traders,
where profits and losses tend to be limited and every penny matters. Even the minimum price
difference of $0.01 amounts to $1 a contract, and bid offer spreads in the market regularly get as
wide as $0.05 to $0.10.
Interactive Brokers does not accept payment for order flow for IBKR Pro customer orders. We
auction off each option order among 16 top market makers. We are always happy to welcome
more to this group.
These auctions last something on the order of 100 milliseconds, and the winner chooses which
exchange it wants to use to trade with the order.
IBKR then posts the order for an exchange auction, and if nobody improves on the agreed-upon
price, the original winner of the auction trades the contract at that price.
This may sound like a rather involved process, but in practice it all happens in a fraction of a
second. All participants use automated processes and they automatically feed the amount of price
improvement they are interested in competing on for any specific option contracts they trade with
at that specific point in time.

-- 4 of 27 --

5
In this way, our customers can take advantage of a leading-edge system designed to get them the
best available price.
Having been the largest market makers and options for over 30 years, IBKR is very well-versed
in these processes, many of which we have retained from our Market Maker Days, and we have
been keeping them up to date over the years.
As new exchanges and new rules are continuously introduced, this is not an easy task, and we
have a team of programmers regularly engaged in this activity.
Imagine if payment for order flow were prohibited, and all brokers are forced to execute their
own customer orders. Sophisticated mechanisms, like the ones we developed and use, would be
expensive and take a long time others to create.
While the idea is interesting to think about, I do not think that it is about to happen anytime soon.
Another notable development for IBKR in 2021 was a 40% increase in margin loans over the
course of the year. I think this growth will also continue into the future. With 7% inflation as the
background, stock prices will have to rise by 7% just to retain their relative values.
I believe inflation will continue at a high rate. There is very little the Fed can do about it.
They may raise interest rates to 1% or 2%. Who would not borrow at that rate and invest in
leveraged assets?
Even if the Fed funds rate rises to 3%, Interactive Brokers will lend at 3.75% to people who want
to buy stock, whether or not they combine it with options strategies.
But 3% is not likely.
A slightly over 3% interest rate would add $1 trillion to annual U.S. debt service and to deficit

-- 5 of 27 --

6
spending, which would just further increase inflationary pressures.
Inflation is here to stay. We'll have to learn to live with it and margin lending will continue to
grow along with it.
We aim to grow our businesses by growing our customer base. We will continue to introduce
new platforms, products and research and trading tools to attract new customers of the type that
fit our target: serious, hard-working and educated investors who come to us to succeed with the
help of our execution quality and products and services.
With that, I will turn the call over to our CFO, Paul Brody. Paul?
Paul Brody
Thank you, Nancy and good afternoon. I’ll review our fourth quarter results, and then open it up
for questions.
I will start with our Revenue items on page 3 of the Release. We are pleased with the record
results we achieved this quarter, and we believe the robust growth in customer accounts positions
us well in both our transactional and financing businesses going forward.
Commissions continue to be strong, returning our second-highest ever quarterly revenues of $320
million, and contributing to a full year record of $1.35 billion, up 21% over the prior year. We
saw substantially higher trading volumes in stocks and options in 2021, coming from our large
base of active traders, investors and advisors, and a wave of new customers on our platform.
Net interest income was strong, generating $295 million in revenues, also our second-highest
quarterly performance, and leading to a record full year NII up 32% to $1.15 billion.
Margin lending continued strong, as investor confidence in the markets continued.
Securities lending also continued its strong run, showing investor demand for a broad range of
securities to borrow, met by a growing supply of inventory held by our customers.

-- 6 of 27 --

7
We generated $58 million in revenues from Other fees and services, and $218 million for the
year, up 25% despite the midyear discontinuation of account inactivity fees. Strong client activity
drove revenues higher in market data fees, risk exposure fees and income from options exchange
liquidity payments. Market data fees reached $20 million, up 18%; risk exposure fees rose over
300% to $18 million; and higher volumes led to 43% higher exchange liquidity payments of $10
million.
Other income includes gains and losses on our investments, our currency diversification strategy
and principal transactions. Many of these non-core items are excluded in our adjusted earnings.
Without those items, Other income was $10 million for the quarter and $64 million for the full
year.
Turning to expenses, Execution, clearing and distribution costs were down, even with the
increases in trading volumes. At $53 million, these costs were down 20% from the year-ago
quarter and down 19% for the full year.
As a percent of commission revenues, execution & clearing costs, which are driven by trading
volume, declined from 22% in 2020 to 13% in 2021.
I've transferred to a headset. I'm hoping that maybe my audio comes over a little bit better.
So this quarter, the execution & clearing costs were also reduced by lower regulatory fees as the
SEC lowered the rate on U.S. stocks and by a temporary fee holiday on U.S. options by the OCC.
Because these benefits are largely passed through to our customers, both costs and commission
revenue decreased accordingly.
As a result of our order routing improvements, which include utilizing our low-cost IBKR ATS
for stock execution, a greater portion of our commission revenue goes to the bottom line.

-- 7 of 27 --

8
Our ratio of compensation and benefits expense to adjusted net revenues was 18% for the quarter
and 15% for the year, relatively unchanged from last year despite a 26% increase in the
headcount.
We continue to focus on expense discipline, while improving our strong top line. Our head count
at year-end was 2,571.
G&A expenses were up 27% from the year ago quarter, though down 25% for the full year,
reflecting lower legal expenses on litigation, partially offset by higher spending on advertising
and required fees.
Our adjusted pretax margin remained a robust 66%, by practicing expense control while also
hiring and investing in the business for accelerated growth, we continue to maintain the operating
leverage in our business.
Finally on the income tax line, of the $35 million shown, the operating company's portion was
$19 million and the public company's portion was $16 million.
Moving to our balance sheet on Page 5 of the release. Our total assets ended the year at $109
billion, with growth driven by margin lending to customers.
Our consolidated equity capital was $10.2 billion, having reached the $10 billion mark for the
first time last quarter. We have no long-term debt.
We continue to deploy our balance sheet to support our growing client business in particular.
More and larger customers want access to margin lending, which our capital base gives us the
ability to provide. We opened 2 offices in Europe in response to Brexit. For those in our other
rapidly growing international locations, our capital base provides the foundation needed today's
operations and for future growth.
Our capital is also used for numerous other growth and investment opportunities we see
worldwide. And finally, an ample capital base helps us win business. by showing the strength and

-- 8 of 27 --

9
depth of our balance sheet to current and prospective clients and partners.
Let's now look briefly at our operating data on Pages 6 and 7 of the release. Page 6 shows
contract and share volumes for all customers rose 46% in options, well above industry growth,
and 19% in futures.
While our stock share volume fell 3%, the product mix produced a 1% increase in commissions.
Activity is strong across client types and geographies. In most securities products, our volumes
are well above the high average activity level of 2020.
Turning to Page 7. Account growth remains robust with over 600,000 net new account adds for
the year.
Total accounts reached 1.68 million, up 56% over the prior year and 9% over the prior quarter.
Customer equity growth reflected strength in new accounts, solid additions to existing accounts
and a generally supportive market environment.
Total customer DARTs reached their second highest quarterly level at over 2.4 million trades per
day. This reflected investor confidence in rising markets, the ongoing global search for yield in
zero and negative interest rate environments, and more customers on our trading platform.
Commission per cleared commissionable order continues to show our success in capturing
rebates paid by exchanges for our clients.
When we route IBKR Pro orders directly to exchanges, we realize these exchange rebates and
pass the savings on to our clients by lowering their commissions.
Our cleared IBKR Pro customers paid $2.38, 3% less per order than they did last year, as our
order routing system found opportunities to maximize rebates while achieving best price
execution.

-- 9 of 27 --

10
Our clients benefit with lower commission costs as we pass our lower execution and clearing
costs on to them. Profitability per order to us remains the same.
Turning to net interest margin. We break down our net interest margin on Page 8. Total GAAP
net interest income was $295 million for the quarter and $1.15 billion for the year, both up over
30% from a year ago, reflecting, in particular, increases in margin lending and securities lending.
Average margin loan balances were up 58% for both the quarter and the full year, leading to
increases in margin loan interest income of 60% and 41% for the fourth quarter and full year,
respectively. Investors remain comfortable taking on leverage in the current rising market
environment.
Securities lending net interest was up 17% and driven by strong client participation in the
markets. As our customer base grows, our opportunities to lend customers’ shares to other
customers who short those stocks also grow.
Together with increasing our profitable securities lending to other broker-dealers, the model
generates expanding revenues. We believe our proprietary system, developed in-house for
securities lending and operated by our team of specialists, is proficient in identifying and lending
out securities in high demand, which drives our revenue from this activity.
Moving to net interest from segregated cash and from customer credit balances.
This continues to reflect the impact of negative benchmark rates in certain countries. When
benchmark rates are very low as they are in the U.S., we pay no interest to customers on their
cash. But in currencies where rates are negative, we earn interest by passing through these
negative rates to customers. We earned $8 million on these balances.
When benchmark rates are positive, we earn interest on depositing, investing our segregated cash
balances. But because of negative rates in some currencies, we had a net cost of $5 million on
these balances.

-- 10 of 27 --

11
Taken together, the net interest income from these balances was $3 million for the quarter.
Now our estimate of the impact of an increase in U.S. interest rates. We expect the next 25 basis
point rise in rates to produce an additional $165 million annually.
The increase from past estimates is driven by higher margin loan balances, and also follows our
introduction of new interest rate tiers and spreads on January 3 of this year.
This does not take into account any change in how we may adjust our investment strategy to take
advantage of newly higher rates or a change in our assets.
About 24% of our customer cash balances are not in U.S. dollars, so estimates of the impact of
U.S. rate changes exclude those currencies.
As forecasted, Federal Reserve rate consensus for 2022 centers around more than one hike. We
can add that a second hike would produce a similar, although somewhat lower, annual benefit to
the first.
In conclusion, we had a strong quarter to close out a record year, reflecting our ability to grow
our customer base and product set, and that shows the attractiveness of our strategy to automate
for growth, expanding what we offer while minimizing what we charge.
Given our progress and performance, we are confident in our ability to grow accounts as Thomas
has indicated, maintain our expense discipline and to capture future opportunities as they arise.
With that, I'll turn it back over to the moderator, and we will field some questions.
Q&A

-- 11 of 27 --

12
Operator
(Operator Instructions)
Our first question comes from the line of Rich Repetto of Piper Sandler.
Rich Repetto
Can you hear me now?
Thomas Peterffy
Yes, we can. Yes.
Rich Repetto
So the stock shares traded quarter-to-quarter were down. I know, only 3% year-over-year, but I
think it was 32% quarter-to-quarter. I suspect that was a lot of low-priced stock trading in 3Q.
But could you sort of verify that, Thomas? And also...
Thomas Peterffy
You're absolutely right. So -- Many years ago, we put in a commission limit, so that we would
never charge more than 50 basis points on a stock trade. And that slowly brought more and more
low-priced stock traders to us.
Eventually, it appears that there are some regulatory concerns about the stock trading, and we
have successfully reduced it. It's got no income impact whatsoever. It's -- those are very tiny
numbers.
Rich Repetto
Got it. Understood. Okay. And then, Paul, you sort of touched on this question, but not just -- 3
rate hikes in 2022 priced in and 3 more in 2023, I guess the question is, you said it -- the second
rate hike would be similar. But I thought you said similar but lower. Any way you could sort of
give us a feel for incremental hikes that -- there's 4 to 6 out there.

-- 12 of 27 --

13
Paul Brody
Yes, sure. So the way we model it, the 1 hike was an increase of an expected $165 million for the
year. We would model 2 hikes. And by that, I mean over the first 2 quarters and then it remains
there, each 25 basis points.
That should add about another, an additional $120 million annually.
And 3 hikes in consecutive quarters would add about another $45 million. And so you have to
understand what -- the dynamic here is that at 2 hikes, so then Fed funds would be around 57 or
58, let's say, basis points, we start to pay interest to our customers at Fed funds less 50 basis
points, whereas right now, that number is 0.
So therefore, after 3 hikes, we then ratchet up our -- the rates that we pay along with Fed funds.
And the same thing happens on margin lending. So then we have a built-in spread, which is what
we always used to have before rates dissolved down to close to zero.
So that's why incrementally, it benefits us, but less and less. And of course, this is keeping all
other things equal, meaning the current balances in margin lending and deposits and so forth.
Rich Repetto
Okay. And the numbers I got -- and you can correct me, I'm sure one of them is wrong. Is $165
the first, $120 the second, incrementally, and then the third $45?
Paul Brody
Yes, those are just estimates, but -- yes. Each one is incremental to the previous. Yes.
Rich Repetto
And beyond 3, incrementally $45 as well?
Paul Brody
We haven't modeled it -- so don't hold me to it, but it would be a number no more than that. It

-- 13 of 27 --

14
depends on where the deposits fall in terms of the tiers. Are they small accounts? Are they
medium-sized accounts? Are they large accounts? And that will dictate what happens as the rates
change. Some are more interest rate sensitive than others.
Rich Repetto
Got it. Thank you.
Operator
Our next question comes from the line of Will Nance of Goldman Sachs.
Will Nance
Maybe I can start with a question on the I think last quarter, you talked a little bit about some of
the introducing broker accounts that were on a fully disclosed basis, and we're going to move
over to an omnibus structure.
I was just wondering if that impacted some of the numbers recently and some of the metrics you
guys have put out? And if you could just put a number of ballpark, how many have moved over
and how much are left?
Thomas Peterffy
Yes. I think in December, an introducing broker went to Omnibus with 2,800 accounts.
Will Nance
Got it. Appreciate it. That's super helpful. And then I appreciate all the color on Rich's questions
around interest rate sensitivity. Just you mentioned that, that didn't contemplate any changes in
the reinvestment strategy.
I was wondering if you could talk kind of more theoretically about what kind of steepness in the
yield curve would you guys look to before you would be more before you would consider taking
a little bit more duration risk in the segregated cash portfolio, are we anywhere near where that's
something you've been thinking about? Or is that still a far way off?

-- 14 of 27 --

15
Thomas Peterffy
No, we are not. I'm extremely worried about much higher interest rates. Not because the Fed will
move it there, but people will realize that they have to borrow money and leverage in order to
keep up with inflation. And so I think that the Fed will lose control.
Operator
Our next question comes from Dan Fannon of Jefferies.
Dan Fannon
I was hoping you could expand upon your confidence around options activity and the
sustainability of it or actually the growth? I think you highlighted that you think will still
continue. Maybe the -- I don't know if it's the profile of customer that is using it that's different
than others across your complex, or is it education or other factors that you think are -- that give
you confidence around the sustainability there?
Thomas Peterffy
So I think the greatest factor here is that these developments that occur in the United States tend
to be followed in other countries with some lag, and that lag is sometimes quite long, like 5, 10
years. And so this huge increase in the U.S. recently is certainly going to be followed by
customers outside of the U.S.
And it is specifically the discovery by more and more people that combined -- option
combination positions can give you very interesting risk profiles and there is more and more of
that based on fundamental analysis.
So people tend to figure out that the stock could rise between $2 and $5, but not likely more and
this type of forecast can be really harvested in the options market, then we just see a very big
increase in these kinds of trades.
And as I've said, I expect that to be followed by foreign investors. And we are going to be very

-- 15 of 27 --

16
large beneficiaries of that.
Dan Fannon
Okay. That's helpful. And then last quarter, when you reiterated confidence around the account
growth and the outlook, you cited some marketing -- new marketing programs and targete,d I
think, campaigns that kind of were part of that confidence.
I guess could you expand a bit upon that if that's expanded, if you're allocating more dollars
towards it or the returns...
Thomas Peterffy
Reallocating more dollars, more resources, more brain power, yes. That's where our future lies,
and we're pushing that very, very hard.
Dan Fannon
Okay. And from a budget perspective, as we think about 2022 or beyond in terms of the spend, is
that something that will be noticeable in the income statement as you spend those dollars?
Thomas Peterffy
Well, unfortunately, I'm really at -- we're willing to spend any amount that makes sense, but we
find very difficult, we find it very difficult to find places that we can throw a lot of money at
because anytime we find a new channel and it works great for, say, $1 million.
But if you double it, your return only goes up by, say, 5% or 10%. That's incredibly frustrating.
So we continuously have to look for new channels and put little bits of money in there. and that is
what we're doing so far. And we hope for a breakthrough, but it hasn't happened yet.
Operator
Our next question comes from Craig Siegenthaler of Bank of America.

-- 16 of 27 --

17
Craig Siegenthaler
Thomas, I hope you're doing well. I'm doing well, too. So I want to come back to margin loan
balances. I believe there were some pricing adjustments in the quarter, especially on your 2
highest tiers, $1 million to $50 million and over $50 million. I wanted to see if you could help us
quantify any impact from a revenue or earnings standpoint that, that could actually drive and
when we could see that result.
Thomas Peterffy
Paul, you (inaudible) -- Sure.
Paul Brody
Absolutely. So we talk firstly about the rate rises. But based on the new policy alone, our
estimates were that it would add annually about $24 million.
And some of that's from putting money into different rate tiers. Some of it is treatment of
negative rate currencies. And there's pass-through of some of those costs. But that's our overall
estimate.
Craig Siegenthaler
I have to ask one on China just because it's been a big source of investor inbound. But -- Can you
update us in terms of the 4Q revenue contribution from Mainland China or the 2 largest
introducing broker clients that are there?
And then based on the evolving stance from the Chinese government,around data and foreign
firms, how do you expect the size of these relationships to trend over the next year?
Thomas Peterffy
So as you know, the 2 largest customers are Futu and Tiger, and they are leaving us. Futu has
practically left us. They have a very few accounts still with us. And Tiger is in the process of
doing that.

-- 17 of 27 --

18
As far as the Chinese -- I don't have a view on that. I'm very, very confused. Inside the company,
we're not in total agreement as to as to how to attack that. So I can't really tell you. I mean, some
of my colleagues are looking more favorably at the Chinese situation than I do.
Operator
(Operator Instructions)
Our next question comes from the line of Kyle Voigt of KBW.
Kyle Voigt
Maybe I could ask first question about the IMPACT, the mobile app launch. Just wondering if
you could help us quantify kind of the uptake or maybe new account growth that it contributed in
the quarter -- in the fourth quarter.
And then also just wondering if you could speak to -- How do you sort of expect revenues related
to that app to kind of show up? I noticed that in app, you are advertising a bit more the Interactive
Advisers and sustainable portfolios that are kind of prebuilt in there. So should we think about
some asset-based fees as being maybe a bigger driver of revenues as this grows over a longer
period of time?
Thomas Peterffy
Well -- No. I mean, our asset base fees, we're only charging 8 basis points. So that will not create
-- that's more like bait to get people to come in. Now as far as the IMPACT app, I mean, we had
40,000 downloads of the IMPACT app. We are not -- we do not break out the revenues, but I
wouldn't think that they would be substantial.
Kyle Voigt
Understood. And then I just sort of -- just want to go back to the interest rate sensitivity
discussion. I believe in the second quarter, you had previously disclosed that roughly 14% of the
customer credit balances, which was about $11 billion at the time, were fully rate sensitive, or I
guess, non-interest-bearing.

-- 18 of 27 --

19
So I'm assuming that's really the cash in those small accounts are below that $10,000 threshold in
total cash balances.
I guess, is that still the right percentage to think about? And that 14% of total credit balances, or
maybe you could provide an update to that $11 billion number, just as we think about modeling,
again, those kind of capturing the rate benefit past those first 2 hikes?
Paul Brody
Yes, sure. So the -- it's still in the 14% to 15% range. The...
Thomas Peterffy
That's not right. So the 14% to 15% range are the monies wherer the account has, let's say,
$100,000 in it, right? So...
Paul Brody
Well, they're in a number of categories. Under $10,000, for example.
Thomas Peterffy
But that's only one of them.
Paul Brody
Yes. We have a number of categories that total up to about 14.5%.
Thomas Peterffy
Yes. But so the bulk of those folks that have half the money get half the interest.
Paul Brody
But only on the one category of under $100,000. The amount between $10,000 and $100,000 gets
a proportionate amount of interest that we would pay.

-- 19 of 27 --

20
Thomas Peterffy
But the bulk of the $11 billion is there.
Paul Brody
No, the bulk is in the very smallest accounts, under $10,000. And commodity accounts where we
don't pay interest actually contribute a non-trivial amount, and...
Thomas Peterffy
So you're saying that we have $11 billion in account under $10,000?
Paul Brody
That number is about $7 billion out of a total of fully interest rate sensitive balances of about $12
billion.
Thomas Peterffy
Okay. I don’t want to argue with you here.
Paul Brody
Commodity balances, they're almost $3 billion. So between the 2 of them, it's most of it.
Kyle Voigt
Okay. Maybe if I can just turn to -- turn to expenses, and then I'll jump back in the queue. Can
you just help us think about the level of fixed expense growth as we're looking out into 2022?
You mentioned that there's only -- you're only going to invest, obviously, if there's positive ROI
on the marketing spend.
So I hear you there. But I guess when you're thinking about that fixed expense base as a whole
and just hiring and everything else that goes into that, can you just talk about the pace of growth
into '22?
Operator

-- 20 of 27 --

21
Next question comes from Rich Repetto of Piper Sandler.
Rich Repetto
Yes. My follow-up I guess, has to do with the holiday, the OCC holiday where they didn't charge
you. And I think it was for 2 months, but -- I guess, Paul, could you tell us how long the holiday -
- was it for the entire quarter?
And how much was it? I know it doesn't impact your profitability at all? And then any way to
estimate how it might impact – how it weighed on your average commission?
Paul Brody
Right. So it wasn't a very big number. It was the last 2 months of the year. OCC over time has
taken various approaches to their fee charging. What they used to do is charge even more about
$0.05, $0.055 contract and then rebate it the next year.
What they did this past year was they started high and then they cut it in the middle of the year,
and then they looked at their financials and cut it to 0 for the last 2 months. The number, it's $2
million plus for us, somewhere in that range. So it's not extensive.
You're right to point out that most of that savings is passed through the customers, however some
of it is not, because for customers who choose fixed as opposed to tiered pricing, we would get
the benefit of that. Probably most of it is passed through.
Operator
Our next question comes from Chris Allen of Compass Point.
Chris Allen
Just wanted to ask on execution and clearing. The fee impact is helpful there. You talked about
the impact of the Smart Order router, internalization on your ATS. And then obviously, there's
been the competitive dynamic among exchanges.

-- 21 of 27 --

22
I'm wondering if you can just walk through maybe over the last 2 years, what's had the biggest
impact in terms of lowering execution and clearing fees as a percentage of commissions.
Any thoughts in terms of maybe on the exchange side, what the impact would be if some of the
lower pricing we've seen now goes away, moving forward?
Thomas Peterffy
I am -- I can't answer you there, but maybe Paul, can you?
Paul Brody
Yes, I can give a little bit of color. So one aspect is that our Smart Router -- the Smart Router has
become better and better at routing orders to places that will still give the best price to the
exchange, but give a better rebate.
And when we talk about the spread between our commission revenue and our direct costs, these
execution and clearing costs going up, that's because $1 saved, or rebated and then passed
through to the customer, has a smaller percentage impact on the commission revenue than it does
on the expense line, which is smaller to begin with.
So each $1 we get, even if we pass the full thing through to the customer, the percentage spread
would continue to increase. Of course, the other thing is that as we attract more and more orders
to our ATS, there's no external cost to executing those at all, and that simply reduces the cost
line.
Chris Allen
Got it. And maybe -- Just one quick one on Other fees and services. I know you talked through it,
but we had a really hard time to understand some of the details there.
Maybe if you can just repeat that real quick just in terms of, I think, what the key growth drivers
were on that were -- the year-over-year perspective?

-- 22 of 27 --

23
Paul Brody
Well, over the current period, the drivers were market data. Market data is also offset by an
expense, and we earned some profit on it, but it's -- When we talk about the Other fees and
services, that's the revenue side of it.
Exposure fees, so we charge, as we've talked about in the past, we run stress scenarios on every
client account. And when the stress scenario, which is a more conservative measure of risk than
the margin system would impose when they reach a certain level, the system begins to charge
fees, which is intended to encourage the customer to reduce their own risk or carry it at --
hopefully proportionately higher fee to us, and we collect those fees over time. So those happen
to have gone up.
And then the options exchange payments the payment programs mandated by the options
exchanges go up with volume. And so that's the third component -- major component of what's
been driving up the Other fees and services.
Operator
We have a follow-up question from Craig Siegenthaler of Bank of America.
Craig Siegenthaler
I have a follow-up here on crypto trading and the partnership with Paxos. Can you just update us
on your progress to add more coins?
And if I think about your 1.7 million accounts, how many of them are active in trading
cryptocurrencies today? And have you seen your crypto offering accelerate organic growth?
Thomas Peterffy
So we are going to add, most probably, 2 currencies and possibly 2 more within a month. The
probable ones will be LINK and MATIC and the possible ones will be UNI and AAVE. We are
also working on SOL, but that we not be added until towards the end of the quarter.
Your question about...

-- 23 of 27 --

24
Craig Siegenthaler
My second question was: Out of your 1.7 million accounts, how many are active in trading crypto
today? And then also, are you seeing crypto drive new clients to Interactive Brokers?
Thomas Peterffy
We are seeing a small number of new clients coming to us because of crypto. And the take-up
among our existing clients is kind of disappointing.
So I think that we have not been successful in driving home the message that our commission
rates are 2/3 lower than the next lowest provider.
And -- or the problem is that we do not have all the popular currencies and people cannot trade
them against each other on our platform.
Craig Siegenthaler
Thomas, and I just had one follow-up here. And this one may be even better for Paul because it's
more of a financials question. But we've seen your clearing and execution costs really decline on
a long-term basis relative to trading activity and commissions and gaining some operating
leverage and some efficiencies. What is your thought on the future of that trend? Will that benefit
continue into the future?
Paul Brody
We certainly hope so. We hope that the marketplace will give us more and better opportunities to
have our Smart Router be better. And we always look for those opportunities and we look to
improve on the software.
And as I said before, the more volume we can attract into our own ATS that will there's no
associated external cost with those executions. And so we hope to be very successful with that.
Operator

-- 24 of 27 --

25
Our next question comes from Mac Sykes of Gabelli.
Mac Sykes
I have 2 questions. I mean, your capital generation continues to be amazing, and then hopefully,
the uptick with the interest revenue. And I assume that you have not changed your stance on
wanting to bolster your balance sheet.
But you had talked in the past about having some more capital for funding foreign margin. Is that
still the case? Are you still seeing demand kind of outside the U.S. to be able to fund those
margin balances?
Thomas Peterffy
Yes. Basically, the answer is yes.
Mac Sykes
Okay. And then on crypto, for those adopters, what are the policies related to using margin? And
are you seeing some customers...
Thomas Peterffy
We are not allowing margin on cryptos. I have heard Mr. Gensler say that if you leverage a
crypto, then it's certainly a security.
Mac Sykes
And are you going to be able to offer short abilities for that and financing off of the currency
holdings in the future?
Thomas Peterffy
As I said, we cannot finance crypto. No, we will not lend.
Operator
Your next question comes from Dan Fannon of Jefferies.

-- 25 of 27 --

26
Dan Fannon
I just, Thomas, wanted to ask about your confidence around the account growth of 30% to 40%
as we look at the Fed futures outlook for the level of hikes that are currently being contemplated,
how do you think that could change your account growth trajectory or as I said earlier, your
confidence around that?
Thomas Peterffy
I think if markets remain at current levels or go lower by less than 10%, and if there is not a huge
international catastrophe like some war, then I think that this rate of increase will continue.
Operator
Our next question comes from Kyle Voigt of KBW.
Kyle Voigt
I just wanted to circle back. I don't know if my audio was coming through previously. I'm just
wondering if you could help us think about the level of fixed expense growth heading into 2022. I
don't know if that's better for Paul or...
Thomas Peterffy
No, I think an assumption of -- so we're basically talking about communications, computers,
salaries and wages, right?
I think about we could assume a 15% growth rate. Paul, you have anything to add here?
Paul Brody
No, I have no other opinion than yours on that topic.
Kyle Voigt
Got it. And then just a clarity question on the fourth quarter margin yields, they compressed to
about 114 basis points. I think last quarter, they were 120 basis points.

-- 26 of 27 --

27
I'm assuming that was just mix in terms of the balanced tiers in the fourth quarter. Is that right,
Paul?
Paul Brody
Actually, Kyle, last quarter, you did mean in the third quarter as a comparative?
Kyle Voigt
Yes, the third quarter was 120 basis points and the fourth quarter, it was 114.
Paul Brody
I've got 113 in the third quarter and 114 in the fourth quarter. Maybe we should both go back and
check.
Operator
At this time, I'd like to turn the call back over to Nancy Stuebe for closing remarks. Nancy?
Nancy Stuebe
Thank you, everyone, for participating today. As a reminder, this call will be available for replay
on our website. and we will also be posting a clean version of our transcript on the site tomorrow.
Thanks again, and we will talk to you next quarter end.
Operator
This concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect.

-- 27 of 27 --