TRANSCRIPT

Q4 2023 — Follow-up call transcript

Q4 2023PDF · 14 pages179 KB
1
Meta Platforms, Inc. (META)
Fourth Quarter 2023 Results Follow Up Call
February 1st, 2024
Operator: Good afternoon. My name is Krista and I’ll be your conference operator
today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Meta Fourth
Quarter and Full Year 2023 Results Follow-up Q&A Call.
All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. After
the speakers’ remarks there will be a question-and-answer session. If you
would like to ask a question, please press star, one on your telephone
keypad. To withdraw your question, again, press star, one.
We ask that you limit yourself to one question. This call will be recorded.
Thank you very much. Ken Dorell, Meta’s Director of Investor Relations, you
may begin.
Kenneth Dorell: Good afternoon and welcome to the follow-up Q&A call. With me on today’s
call are Susan Li, CFO and Chad Heaton, VP of Finance.
Before we get started, I would like to take this opportunity to remind you
that our remarks today will include forward-looking statements. Actual
results may differ materially from those contemplated by these forward-
looking statements. Factors that could cause these results to differ
materially are set forth in today’s earnings press release and in our quarterly
report on Form 10-Q filed with the SEC.
Any forward-looking statements that we make on this call are based on
assumptions as of today and we undertake no obligation to update these
statements as a result of new information or future events.
During this call we will present both GAAP and certain non-GAAP financial
measures. A reconciliation of GAAP to non-GAAP measures is included in
today’s earnings press release. The earnings press release and an
accompanying investor presentation are available on our website at
investor.fb.com. And now, I’d like to turn the call back over to Krista for the
first question.

-- 1 of 14 --

2
Operator: If you would like to ask a question, please press star, one on your telephone
keypad. To withdraw your question, again, press star, one. Your first
question comes from the line of Mark Mahaney from Evercore ISI. Please go
ahead.
Mark Mahaney: Hey, if I could throw in two quick ones. Click-to-message, revenue
contribution, can you give us any sense of where that is? I think it’s close to
10% of your total revenue, but anything you could help with there. And then
Threads, I assume this is still long away from any potential monetization, it
sounds like your priorities near-term are just scale -- improving the features
and scaling up the user base, is that the right interpretation? Is there any
reason to think monetization would begin this year? Thank you.
Susan Li: Hi, Mark. It’s Susan. So first of all, we haven’t provided any further
quantification of the click-to-messaging revenue contribution this quarter, so
I don’t have more specifics to share on that outside of what we said
previously.
On Threads, I would agree with your assumption. We are very much focused
on really making sure that there is strong product market fit in this area,
responding to user feedback in terms of what -- in terms of types of requests
basically that we get for features to add, to make it better and more
valuable, and we want to keep the pace of improvements and growth going.
We’re very happy that it has over 130 million monthly actives now, and
monetization will be later in this playbook for us.
Mark Mahaney: OK, thank you, Susan.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Youssef Squali from Truist
Securities. Please go ahead.
Youssef Squali: Thank you. Hi Susan. Two quick ones please. So growth in average price per
ad turned positive year on year this quarter after I think almost two years of
decline. How much of that may be the impact of AI improvements versus
other things like ad formats, and mix and other things? And does your Q1
guide -- or how should we just be thinking about the potential for further
acceleration that’s now positive?

-- 2 of 14 --

3
And then Mark on the call, on the main call, talked about WhatsApp and how
he’s seeing more broad success in the U.S. Can you maybe just provide a
little more color, and maybe connect it to what product within WhatsApp are
actually resonating more with clients? Thank you.
Chad Heaton: So this is Chad. I can start with the question about the CPMs. So the year
over year growth in average price per ad did improve 8 points from Q3 to
plus 2%. That happened in part because impression grows slowed, so you
have sort of the natural auction dynamics that play through, but of course
we’re continuing to deliver ad performance improvements as well. And so as
we think about opportunities for further improvement going forward, that is
all of the investments that we’re making to improve ad ranking and
optimization, et cetera, so that will continue to be a driver but certainly the
slowdown in impression growth is a key factor as well.
Susan Li: On your second question about WhatsApp, we don’t have any sort of specific
WhatsApp engagement trends to share here. What I would say is for us,
WhatsApp has historically been -- has grown really in markets outside of the
United States, and so I think over the last quarter a few times we’ve
highlighted that we are now seeing strength in North America, and that’s
really what Mark has been alluding to, and obviously it’s something that
we’re very pleased by.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Ken Gawrelski from Wells Fargo.
Please go ahead.
Ken Gawrelski: Thank you. Two questions, if I may. The first on cookie deprecation on
Chrome, I know it’s early days but could you discuss any potential impact
you’re seeing in the business and how you’re thinking about that from both a
targeting and attribution perspective?
And the second question would be on -- you talked about the cross border --
the China cross border impact. Could you talk a little bit -- I just want to
clarify, are you seeing more of that spend now outside of -- outside of North
America and did that shift really occur in the fourth quarter? And would you
expect that continue to continue into the first half of ’24? Thanks.

-- 3 of 14 --

4
Chad Heaton: Yes, this is Chad. I’ll take the cookie deprecation first. So as we’ve said
before, Google’s multi-year initiative is in line with our focus on building
privacy enhancing technologies. We’re encouraged by their collaborative
approach in engaging with the industry to develop technologies that enable
relevant advertizing in ways that are less reliant on individual data.
So we’re feeling confident that we’ll be ready to help businesses navigate
changes that privacy sandbox deploys to minimize disruption while
supporting privacy through increased transparency and privacy enhancing
technologies. So we can’t quantify any expected impact at this time but this
is something that we feel very well prepared for.
Susan Li: And Ken, I will take your second question, which was around China. First, I’d
just point to the fact that growth for us was quite broad-based and we also
saw strength in U.S. advertisers over the quarter.
On the China question specifically, I began citing strength from China based
advertisers actually I think in Q1 of this year. That’s continued through the
year and really I would say there was a longer term trend of growth here that
was impacted by COVID lockdowns and kind of that period of time.
So in ’23 we saw the comp against ’22, which was a period where that was
heavily affected by COVID lockdowns, and higher shipping costs made the
comp easier. So the level of growth in 2023 will probably be hard to
replicate. But we’ll just keep watching this and see how it plays out.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Rob Sanderson for Loop Capital.
Please go ahead.
Rob Sanderson: Thank you. I’m going to stay on the China theme just so I can make sure that
we all understand the disclosures that you offer on the main call. I think you
said that cohort was about 10% of -- and contributed 5% to growth.
So if we look through the disclosure of customer address in your 10Qs, that
cohort of Asia is up 27% through Q3. So should we interpret your comment,
Susan, that 10 points of that 20, whatever it ends up being when we get to

-- 4 of 14 --

5
Q4, is China? The rest of that’s Asia and that of the 16% year-on-year growth,
5 points of that were from that cohort. Is that the correct interpretation?
Susan Li: Rob, I apologize, I don’t think I followed all the -- sort of the detail of the
question. But yes, the China ad revenue is a subset of the Asia-Pac ad
revenue that is disclosed by advertiser location in the 10-K.
And you’ll see that when the K is released. I would also add here that our ad
spend -- ad spend in China, I think we know that spend from a few of our
larger advertisers has been an important contributor to strength in China
broadly. But in fact, two-thirds of our China ad revenue came from
advertisers outside the top 10 spenders in that country in 2023. So even
within that it is a diverse advertiser base.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Justin Patterson from KeyBanc
Capital Markets. Please go ahead.
Justin Patterson: Great, thank you very much. I just wanted to go back to privacy really quick,
maybe from a different angle. Could you talk about just how many of your
advertisers are on CAPI right now? And whether you think just things like the
deprecation of cookies really accelerates that shift? And just a quick aside in
there, I noticed that custom silicon seems to be increasingly in focus over at
Meta. So, as you’re looking at just CapEx contribution, should we think about
just your own silicon representing a larger portion of chip sets in the future?
Thanks so much.
Susan Li: Thanks, Justin. So, the first part of your question was about CAPI. We
haven’t, I think, quantified recently how many of our advertisers are using it.
In general, the feedback on tools that we have, such as CAPI, such AEM and
including the more recent full rollout of app AEM in Q4 has been very
positive and I think they’re very useful for advertisers who adopt them. And
we continue to enhance them, enhance the reporting, make it easier to
understand the impact.
I think we had some launches in Q4 to help advertisers better understand
how many additional conversions they might expect, that sort of thing. So,
these tools, I think, make it easier for advertisers operate in the changing

-- 5 of 14 --

6
data landscape. And I think that will generally continue to be true, as that
landscape continues to evolve.
The second part of your question is on custom silicon. So, broadly we’re very
committed, obviously, to our longstanding partnerships with the industry’s
leading silicon providers. We’ll continue to be purchasing quite a lot of
silicon from them. But we’re exploring alternatives, and have been, to GPUs
for some time and that has included deploying our own custom silicon for
specific AI workloads.
And this year, in particular, we are ramping adoption of our in-house MTIA
Inference chip, particularly for our recommendations work. And we have
found that designing own silicon allows us to optimize specifically for the
kinds of workloads that we know we need to run and to gain control over the
entire stack, from hardware to software and the application layers.
So, we find that GPUs are not always as optimized for running our specific
recommendation workloads at the level of cost and performance efficiency
required at our scale. So, we haven’t quantified the mix. And, certainly, with
the magnitude of our AI ambitions and associated capacity needs, I expect
we will be leveraging all of these avenues of capacity growth in the years to
come.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line Michael Nathanson from
MoffettNathanson. Please go ahead.
Michael Nathanson: Thanks. Hi, Susan. Hi, Chad. I have two. One is, over the past couple
years we spent a lot of time worrying about the loss of signal from the IDFA
changes. I wonder if you could help us all to dimension or benchmark any
type of rollouts or compare now versus then? Have you been able to
recapture where you guys were a few years ago through all the innovations
you’ve made? So, anything you can help us on benchmarking the return or
recapturing signal.
And then, I think Susan, I think one of the questions that happened earlier
was, just asking when you said 5 basis points, 5% from China advertisers, did

-- 6 of 14 --

7
you mean 500 basis points of the growth? Was it 500 basis points or is it 5%
of the overall growth? Thanks.
Susan Li: Thanks, Michael. So on the first question about where ROAS is relative to
pre-ATT, I don’t have a comparison to give you relative to pre-ATT. In
general, we think the landscape has changed so much that it’s kind of hard to
know the counterfactual of what the world would look like without ATT
today.
But we’ve made meaningful improvements to our performance and
measurement in recent periods. We believe that advertising is a relative
performance gain and that we are very well-positioned here because of all of
the investments we’ve made, and we’ve received consistently positive
feedback from advertisers who adopt our tools. On the second question,
China contributed 5 percentage points to overall revenue growth in 2023.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Brent Thill from Jefferies. Please
go ahead.
Brent Thill: Thank you. What are you seeing so far just in Q1 that gives you the
conviction in accelerating revenue growth that’s implied in your guidance,
and has the overall operating environment improved, or is something that’s
just more idiosyncratic or some combination? Thank you.
Susan Li: What we’re really seeing in Q1 so far has been a reflection of the generally
strong and broad-based advertiser demand that we saw in Q4, and that was
spread across verticals, but particularly within online commerce and gaming
for us.
And I would again highlight we get an extra day in this quarter, and I’m telling
you that so that a year from now I’ll remind you that we’re comparing
against a quarter with an extra day. But we recognize that there is a lot of
uncertainty and certainly a lot of different possible macro-outcomes
throughout the year, and those become harder to predict the further out you
go.

-- 7 of 14 --

8
So we are extrapolating from the trends that we saw in Q4, but at the same
time, I want to be clear that we do think, if we’ve learned nothing over the
last two years, it’s just that we’re operating in a highly uncertain
environment.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Rohit Kulkarni. Please go ahead.
Rohit Kulkarni: Hey, thanks. One on Reels and just one broadly on elections. Price per ad
increased this quarter for the first time in several quarters? Maybe comment
on how -- whether Reels contributed to that, or how was Reels pricing versus
the rest of every ad unit.
And then just any broad thoughts you have on elections and election
advertising? There’s a lot of elections globally and no better place than
Facebook to advertise, so just how are you thinking about that?
Chad Heaton: Sure, so I’ll start with the Reels CPM question. So Reels CPMs are lower than
Feed and Stories today, given the relative maturity of Feed and Stories, which
has benefited from years of optimizations. But we already have very strong
demand for Reels ads, we have over three quarters of our advertisers are
using them, and we anticipate that CPMs will be growing over time as we
invest in driving performance through better ranking, interactivity, and ad
formats.
Susan Li: On your second question, which was about elections 2024, it’s certainly a big
year for elections. We’ve already had some around the globe and many more
to come. For us, protecting the elections is a top priority. We’ve invested a
lot in our safety and integrity efforts in this area, we’ve invested more than
$20 billion actually since 2016 in safety and security, and we have
partnerships with nearly 100 fact-checkers globally in more than 80
languages here.
So we’re really focused on doing the work we need to keep our platform
safe. And it’s not really a material contributor to revenue growth for us. We
don’t expect that to be the case in 2024. And even during our last U.S.
presidential election cycle in 2020, the government and politics vertical was
not among our top 10 verticals either globally or in the U.S.

-- 8 of 14 --

9
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of John Blackledge from TD Cowen.
Please go ahead.
John Blackledge: Great. Thanks. Two questions. First, any color on the higher losses at Reality
Labs this year? It could be the peak loss year for that segment. And then
second question on Reels monetization in 2024, we have heard that the
Reels overlay ads have been somewhat incremental in the back half of ’23.
Just curious -- any call out on Reels overlay ads or anything else that will be
helpful to drive Reels monetization in 2024? Thanks.
Susan Li: On your first question, which is about Reality Labs operating losses, the
overall investment portfolio is very broad and I would say we’ve talked a
little bit about the breadth of the ambitions there across current and next
generation VR, MR, and AR devices as well as metaverse social platforms.
And so we really are just investing in a -- both a very broad portfolio and then
within each of those areas I would say that there’s a lot of, for example,
fundamental research that we are invested in in order to help solve a lot of
the physics challenges we’re going to have creating devices that are
comfortable enough for you to wear everyday and have the computational
power that would be required for them to also be a meaningful addition to
your experience.
So these are really, I would say, very ambitious investments. They are
intended to build the next computing platform. We haven’t given any
specifics on the outlook beyond 2024 but it’s an area of long term and
ambitious vision for us and we’ll continue investing against that vision.
Chad Heaton: Yes, so on Reels monetization. So our work to increase Reels monetization
efficiency really fits into two buckets. So first there’s growing supply and then
their second is improving performance.
In terms of the supply, we’ve brought Reels ad load up over the past year
although it generally remains lower on a per time basis than Feed and
Stories. So we’ll look for opportunities to grow that in the future while
balancing it against the user experience in Reels.

-- 9 of 14 --

10
Longer term, we do have sort of the structural issue of Reels, which is it just
has a slower scroll speed than Feed and Stories do. But we’re looking at
creative ways to address those constraints. For instance, putting ads in
organic Reels.
In terms of the second factor I mentioned improving performance. We’re
making improvements in ranking, interactivity and then the different ad
formats on Reels. You mentioned one of them in terms of the overlay ads.
But yes, there’s I think opportunities in each of those three areas.
Operator: Your next question comes from the line of Dan Salmon from New Street
Research. Please go ahead. Dan, your line is open.
Your next question comes from the line of Tom Champion from Piper
Sandler. Please go ahead.
Tom Champion: Hi, good afternoon. Susan, I’m curious if you could talk a little bit about
Advantage+? Do you feel like this is a differentiated product that is altering
market share, especially versus Search? I’m just curious what do you think
there. And then, I’m wondering if you might be able to elaborate -- it seems
like there are a variety of products within Advantage+ that fall under the
product umbrella. Is there any way you could describe those for us or flush
out the major components? Thank you.
Susan Li: Yes, sure. So, on the first part of your question, in terms of kind of the
comparisons versus Search, I’m not sure about Advantage+ specifically. I
think in terms of comparisons relative to Search, I think this is really about
the mix of business and vertical exposure across a more Search or a more
Discovery-oriented ad experience.
And that can put you in a different position in response to different macro
and exogenous factors. For us, online commerce being our largest
advertising vertical, we’ve seen that strength in that category was a tailwind
in 2023, after being a headwind in 2022.

-- 10 of 14 --

11
Now, online commerce is, of course, also an area that Advantage+ shopping
campaigns are particularly well suited to, so this is a very natural transition
into the second part of your question. And so, we certainly are continuing to
see strong momentum with Advantage+ shopping. We shared in Q3 that it
reached a $10 billion annual run rate and that has continued to grow and the
verticals with strongest adoption continue to be e-commerce, retail and CPG,
DTCC brands. And we see the opportunity to scale adoption further among
these segments.
But we’re also testing how we can extend the Advantage – the capabilities of
Advantage+ shopping campaigns to different use cases across our ad
platform to provide end-to-end automation for other objectives. For
example, in Q4 we began testing full campaign automation for lead
generation ads, which allows advertisers to use AI to automatically chose the
audience and where to show the ad, which creative to show, for a new
objective.
Across the Advantage+ suite, we’re continuing to invest in other tools that
automate different steps of the campaign creation process. We launched, in
Q3, the ability for advertisers to add audience inputs as a suggestion rather
than a hard constraint with Advantage+ audience. So, our AI systems can
deliver ads to those types of audiences as well as other people who are
interested or likely to be interested in the ad. And this has now become the
default audience creation experience for the majority of those advertisers.
The Advantage+ catalog ads are another area. We’ve expanded the ability
for advertisers to use product-level videos along with static images for their
catalog ads to 100% of Meta advertisers in Q4. And with these formats our
system dynamically chooses the right product to show and which format to
use, either video or image, across Feeds, Stories, Watch, and Reels and we’re
continuing to rollout background generation as part of this to enable the
creation of multiple backgrounds to complement the advertiser's product
images.
We also have Advantage+ Creative, where in Q4 we made our new Gen AI
features around image expansion globally available. Over half of our

-- 11 of 14 --

12
advertisers were already using our Advantage+ Creative enhancements to
optimize images and text in their ad creative prior to this. So, we’re excited
to now offer additional capabilities. All this is to say, this is really, I think,
becoming a suite of tools that we think really makes the ad creation,
optimization, targeting process better, more streamlined, more automated,
more effective for advertisers. And we intend to continue to iterate and
release new features here.
Operator: Your next question from the line of Barton Crockett from Rosenblatt. Please
go ahead.
Barton Crockett: Well, thank you for taking the question. I was interested in Impressions and
the growth in Impressions and what that does to the user experience. How
much of that is people seeing more ads per minute or per page. How much of
it is just a reflection of growth in users and maybe people spending more
time or clicking more pages?
And is there any risk that you see too many ads on TV or magazine that (it
degrades) the experience that that could start to happen here, just given the
significant growth?
Chad Heaton: Yes, I can take that. I think the growth of impressions, there’s a few things
going on there. One, we’ve been ramping impressions particularly on Reels.
That’s a format where we started with relatively low ad load and then over
the course of the year, as we were looking to close the monetization
efficiency gap, we increased the ad load.
And so that’s a surface where I just think we have a lot of opportunity and we
still have some opportunity. And the other thing I would note is I think we’re
getting better at personalization of ad load over time where we can figure
out which users are most receptive to ads at what points in time and in those
cases serve them higher ad loads, and then we can be more sensitive to
users who might be less open to ads, it might affect their engagement and
we could potentially serve them fewer ads. So I think we’ve just become
smarter and more effective at this over time.
Kenneth Dorell: Krista, we have time for one last question.

-- 12 of 14 --

13
Operator: Our last question comes from the line of Dan Salmon from New Street
Research. Please go ahead.
Dan Salmon: Okay, great. Sorry about that. Thanks for taking my question again. So Susan,
yesterday the company put out a post in conjunction with Mark’s Senate
Judiciary Committee testimony that had some interesting data on your
investments in safety and security. Specifically 40,000 people overall working
on it, 20 billion invested since 2016, and then $5 billion invested over the last
year alone.
Could you just unpack that $5 billion figure a little bit more for us? Is that
entirely an operating expenditure? Is that largely to compensate the 40,000
people? And how do you think that that figure might move either up or down
in the years to come?
Susan Li: Thanks, Dan. So the over $5.5 billion investment is in the privacy program.
I’m just pulling up the blog post to make sure that I am looking at the same
thing as you. Is that what you’re referring to?
Dan Salmon: $5 billion figure.
Susan Li: Yes. Okay. The $5 billion was in the last year alone and we’re referring to the
$20 billion investments since 2016. So this is really investment that
encompasses our work across a number of teams. It includes engineering
teams as well as operational teams. And it really covers the broad array of
investments that we have made in different integrity, safety, and security
efforts; which is an investment that we’ve really began ramping up in earnest
in 2016.
And our expenditures in this area are factored in our upcoming 2024
guidance. We are not providing guidance on this specifically or more
generally for out years. But it’s an area of very high priority for us. We
continue to invest aggressively here. In our integrity, safety and security
efforts, these are just very important efforts for the company, and we’ll
continue to invest here.

-- 13 of 14 --

14
Kenneth Dorell: Great. Thank you for joining us today. We appreciate you taking the time
and we look forward to speaking with you again soon.
Operator: This concludes today’s conference call. Thank you for joining us. And you
may disconnect your lines.

-- 14 of 14 --