TRANSCRIPT

Q3 2020 — Transcript (analyst call)

Q3 2020PDF · 19 pages284 KB
PayPal Holdings, Inc.
Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call
November 2, 2020

-- 1 of 19 --

1
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
C O R P O R A T E P A R T I C I P A N T S
John Rainey, Chief Financial Officer and Executive Vice President, Global Customer Operations
Gabrielle Rabinovitch, Vice President, Investor Relations
Akila Moorthy, Senior Director, Investor Relations
C O N F E R E N C E C A L L P A R T I C I P A N T S
Colin Sebastian, Baird
Craig Maurer, Autonomous Research
Joseph Vafi, Canaccord
Sanjay Sakhrani, Keefe, Bruyette & Woods, Inc.
George Mihalos Cowen and Co.
Ashwin Shirvaikar, Citigroup
Bob Napoli, William Blair
Timothy Chiodo, Credit Suisse
Josh Beck, KeyBanc Capital Markets
Jamie Friedman, Susquehanna International Group
Brett Huff, Stephens, Inc.
P R E S E N T A T I O N
Operator
Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and thank you for joining PayPal's Quarter Three Analyst Call.
If you would like to ask a question, press star, one on your telephone keypad. To withdraw a question,
press the pound key.
It's now my pleasure to turn the conference over to [PayPal’s] Chief Financial Officer, John Rainey. Mr.
Rainey, I hand it to you.

-- 2 of 19 --

2
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
John Rainey
Thank you, Holly, and thanks, everyone, for joining us this afternoon. We're looking forward to fielding the
questions that you have. As usual, I'm here with my Investor Relations team. And Holly, I'll just kick it
back over to for Q&A.
Operator
Thank you. Once again, to ask a question, press star, one.
And our first question is going to come from the line of Colin Sebastian with Baird.
Colin Sebastian
Great. Good afternoon. How are you doing, John?
John Rainey
Hey, Colin.
Colin Sebastian
So, I just want to come back to the commentary on 2021 since that's seems to where a lot of the
questions are. I think you've said in the past that you expect to be able to grow margins even through the
eBay transition. I just wanted to clarify if that view's changed at all given the pace of that migration as well
as the additional spending initiatives. And then any sort of help factoring in the headwind from credit next
year?
John Rainey
Sure. Well, it's still a little early, which is why we didn't provide the guidance, but longer term we've got a
lot of conviction in the margin profile of our business. Credit is a notable call-out though, because that's a
very high margin product for us, and we would expect to see depressed levels around credit through next
year, and so that certainly is a headwind. eBay, we obviously noted, but offsetting some of that is the
huge tailwinds we see in our business around what's happening with just core PayPal checkout right now.
And as we covered on the call, there are a number of other new products that we're launching next year,
which will be accretive to the bottom line.
So, there's a number of puts and takes. Next year was always going to be the more challenging year from
a growth perspective, but it's probably premature at this point to make any comments around the
directionality of our margins next year.
Colin Sebastian
Okay, that's helpful. And maybe a quick follow-up. I think it was Dan who called out the October trend. I
guess there were a day or two that were the highest level of volume that you've seen, I think. Was that a
result of earlier start to holiday shopping, or any specific event that you can call out there? Thank you.
John Rainey

-- 3 of 19 --

3
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
Well, that's a great question. And that point is one that we're keenly following. Meaning, how much of the
shopping season will be pulled forward. But the holidays are always sort of a more challenging time to
forecast and I think over the last few years you just see more and more come online, which is to our
benefit, but it's more difficult to forecast. And so, in this period, where people are shopping online already,
it's reasonable to assume some sales could be pulled forward, though we've not been able to pinpoint
that in our business. I think, Colin, it stands to reason like you and I certainly don't want to go stand in line
and be metered in and out of a store in a pandemic sort of metered environment at a Best Buy during the
holiday season.
So I would expect there to be just sort of intuitively more online shopping this season, but the curve of
that or how much of that is pulled forward, it's really hard to tell right now. So we've been closely watching
and listening to what retailers are saying. And if I can generalize, I would say most retailers right now are
saying they haven't seen a lot of that and we certainly haven't seen much in our business that we can
specifically call out.
Colin Sebastian
Okay, thank you.
John Rainey
You bet.
Operator
And our next question will come from the line of Dan Perlin with RBC Capital Markets.
Dan Perlin
Thanks. Hey, good evening.
John Rainey
Hey, Dan.
Dan Perlin
There's been a ton of questions, obviously, on 2021, so let me just ask it this way. When you look at the
cohorts, so the 70 million or so net new actives that you're expecting to have by end of year and you look
at those engagement statistics and try and again to kind of maybe weed out what might be some
anomalistic behavior from some of those users, are you finding that the velocity of their transactions are
greater than kind of legacy? And then secondarily, do you think that that pool of net new actives are—are
these new products really purposely built for those types of consumers?
John Rainey
Yes. So, the short answer is yes, we're seeing more engaged cohorts than previous cohorts. But let me
give some context to that. In a typical net new active, there's a maturation curve where someone may
come to us through a first transaction and it may take sometimes several months for that second
transaction and typically it's over a year before they reach an engagement level that is commensurate
with our more engaged customers. And one of the things or two of the things that we're seeing right now
that have been pretty consistent trends over the last six months are the daily active users, which we're up

-- 4 of 19 --

4
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
32% in the third quarter, which is much higher than what we've seen previously. And then the 10 day
adoption rates, which still is a double-digit percentage increase from what they were before. And again, a
10 day adoption rate, as we define it, is when it's a cohort of customers that uses us four times in a 10
day period. And so, that level of engagement is up double-digit percentages versus prior cohorts.
So two good leading indicators about the engagement level of these customers. Offsetting that, and in a
year where you've got 70 million-ish net new actives, you've obviously got to be very concerned about the
churn dynamics of those in the following years. So, that's one of the things that our analytic team is doing
a lot of work to really try to help influence their behavior and keep them engaged with not only offers but
new product opportunities and things like that. And again, as we add additional functionality to the wallet
and you see things like the network effect among users, I think that all bodes well for us, but those are
some of the competing dynamics as we think about the next year there.
Dan Perlin
Okay. And just a brief follow-up, and it was somewhat addressed in the call, but you have—you obviously
have a huge product set that's getting rolled out next year. It sounds like from what Dan said at the end of
the call there that the trajectory of expenses are probably going to fall heavier in the first half of the year
relative to the second half given most of that's going to be completed. I'm just trying to make sure I
understand kind of the cadence a little bit of this expense. Fourth quarter was heavier than what we had
anticipated, and so I just want to make sure as we calibrate our models we're not just going to be way off
base. Thank you.
John Rainey
Yes. I'm glad you asked the question because I don't think that's exactly what he implied on the call. As I
am—we're in the throes of a budget process right now and the last thing that happens in the budget
process is the quarterization of all those expenses and revenue efforts. So it's a little early, but I don't
think there's anything that I would call out necessarily that is going to create a different expense trajectory
for one quarter or the next, with the exception that we're going to see a little bit of a tail of this $300 million
that we earmarked bleed into the first half of the year.
So, maybe the first quarter's affected a little bit more and then we'll just have to gauge what that level of
investment is going forward depending upon the benefit that we're pulling through related to these efforts.
We're pretty rigorous and disciplined in the way that we approach this and it's not just, you know, us
throwing buckets of money at initiatives. So we've got a constant feedback loop on the effectiveness or
the efficacy of that spend, and so that could help influence how things go through the year as well.
Dan Perlin
Okay. Thank you very much.
John Rainey
Mm-hmm.
Operator
Thank you. Our next question will come from the line of Craig Maurer of Autonomous Research
Craig Maurer

-- 5 of 19 --

5
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
Yes. Hi. Thanks for taking the question. John, I hope you're well.
John Rainey
(Multiple speakers) you're well as well.
Craig Maurer
Yes, getting by. Wanted to ask about how we should think about OVAS next year, what are the puts and
takes? And secondarily, how aggressively did Paymentus volume come on in the third quarter? Thanks.
John Rainey
Sure. Well, Craig, you surprised me. I thought surely, given your quote in the Wall Street Journal this
morning, that you'd be asking some questions about the sustainability of P2P trends or something. But
no, it was a good article. With OVAS, we'll see a benefit again from Honey next year as that continues to
grow, and really pleased with the progress of that product and the capabilities that we can offer there.
Credit is going to be a drag still. And honestly, like I would say, if there's something that someone's
missing about our financial modeling, it's probably that, that you probably know as well as anyone, Craig,
sort of the dynamics of that. So that's going to continue to be something that is a headwind for the year.
I guess, adding to that, if we say in a lower interest rate environment, then we're going to see the interest
income on customer balances be more akin to the level that we saw in the third quarter this year. So that
could also be a drag. I'm looking at Gabrielle and Akila. Anything that I'm missing there on that?
Gabrielle Rabinovitch
Yes. The contra revenue adjustment to OVAS that we had in Q1 and Q2 as a result of CECL and the
changed macro outlook will not be recurring most likely if we're more in steady state. So that's a little bit of
an offset to some of that credit impact.
John Rainey
That's a really good point, and we're at a reserve ratio, coverage ratio right now that is 24%, and if we
were to see the economy rebound, testing and vaccines be readily available potentially, that sort of
relaxes some of the pressure around credit. So you could even see some of that reserve reverse over the
next year, potentially, so that's something to consider as well.
With respect to payment, as to the second part of your question, we're 100% ramped on that now. In
terms of through the quarter—and I guess what you're getting to is did we really have a run rate effect in
the quarter. Close to it. Probably 80% is the way that I'd say that without having the math in front of me.
So pretty close to it.
Craig Maurer
Okay. And if you could dimensionalize how much that dragged on take rate would just be helpful because
I think that was a hard thing for us to model.
John Rainey
On bill pay, Paymentus?

-- 6 of 19 --

6
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
Craig Maurer
Yes, bill pay.
John Rainey
So, let's take the 24 basis point decline in total take rate. I would say that's probably kind of four equal
parts of P2P, hedge, credit, and then mix in our business which includes Paymentus.
Craig Maurer
Okay. Thank you. I'll let you move on. Thanks.
Operator
Thank you. Our next question will comes from the line of Joseph Vafi with Canaccord.
Joseph Vafi
Hi, good afternoon, John. Thanks for taking the call.
John Rainey
Hey Joe.
Joseph Vafi
Just a couple of questions. Yes. Hey. Just looking out beyond maybe this year and early next year and
into the future there's a couple of things that I think are probably pretty interesting for your model. Number
one is kind of personal banking initiatives and you alluded to it on the call with more direct deposit and
other things and kind of expanding the customer usage cases just kind of beyond e-commerce. And then
secondly, just maybe a little more drill-down on what potentially transaction margins could look like on
crypto-based transactions if you can do those away from the VISA and MasterCard card networks.
Thanks a lot.
John Rainey
Sure. So, with respect to personal banking, we very much want to partner with others in the ecosystem
here and take our complementary capabilities with issuers and really try to go after the addressable
market that way. So, we are in no way looking to replace one's checking account or personal bank with
PayPal or Venmo. We think that we can provide capabilities that are very much complementary to that.
That said, there are many capabilities that are complementary to that. And we've talked about
subscription services and bill pay, but crypto is actually another one, right.
And it gets to the second part of your question, where I'm glad you asked because the accounting—well,
first of all, on crypto, we're basically providing that as a free service. We monetize that only on any spread
between what it costs us to acquire the currency versus what the consumer purchases and if there
happens to be a transaction involved there. So, when someone uses that to shop at a merchant there's
no additional fee related to that, to the consumer or the merchant. And the accounting on that is such that
it won't be recognized in our TPV—but for buy, sell, hold, I'm just getting corrected here, yes, at a
merchant—when shopped it will, but the buy, sell, hold of the acquisition of the crypto itself is not included
in our TPV. We will account for that on a net basis - meaning that we won't gross it up for what the

-- 7 of 19 --

7
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
consumer is purchasing it for. So, we'll only have the transaction fee for any spread related to the buy and
the sell of that hitting our books.
So at this point it's probably a relatively small financial impact to us. I think the play here though really
goes to the first part of your question, which is, just having more utility in the wallet and as this is maybe
some type of currency that we see more of in the future, we want to be at the forefront of this and make
sure that both our consumers and our merchants have access to this.
Akila Moorthy
So on the purchase with a merchant where crypto is being used in that use case, Joe, we will essentially
have a take rate with the merchant. Again, not an incremental take rate, but the take rate that the
merchant is charged typically and that's how it will flow through our books in that use case.
Gabrielle Rabinovitch
The cost of funds will essentially be very similar to sort of stored balance. The difference being that we
will be paying a fee back to Paxos on essentially the currency conversion from the crypto back to fiat
currency. But overall, from a transaction margin standpoint, the unit economics are good because
essentially it's sort of stored balance funds with a slight fee attached for the conversion.
Joseph Vafi
Great. So it sounds like you would welcome the more crypto-based transaction volume for purchases
relative to where your transaction margins are today.
Gabrielle Rabinovitch
Well, look, I mean, the way we think about is today crypto is really sort of an asset for diversification and
people are not using it in a transactional way necessarily. That said, we think it's important to remove
some of the boundaries there and the friction around people's concerns around volatility. So what we've
done is create an experience for merchants and consumers that eliminate some of the risks around
settlement or volatility and makes it potentially be used in a more ubiquitous way as a transactional
currency, but I still think there's going to have to be consumer adoption around that given the way people
use crypto today relative to what this experience contemplates.
Joseph Vafi
That's great. Thanks everyone for the answers. Much appreciated.
John Rainey
You bet.
Operator
Thank you. Our next question will comes from the line of Sanjay Sakhrani with KBW.
Sanjay Sakhrani
Thanks. Had a quick follow-up question on the eBay headwind, and then one on the credit costs. As far
as the eBay headwind, just want to follow-up on the question asked on the call. That 3.5 percentage point

-- 8 of 19 --

8
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
headwind, does that continue through the third quarter and then abate or can that accelerate or remain
the same for sometime?
John Rainey
Well, Sanjay, the 3.5 point headwind is related to the fourth quarter.
Sanjay Sakhrani
Mm-hmm. Would it continue into next year or?
John Rainey
Yes. Yes, and a lot of that depends upon the rate of adoption throughout the year. But eBay has noted, I
think, that they've migrated 344,000 merchants already. I think it's fair to assume that eBay's focus is
going to be on merchants with greater volume versus lesser volume initially. So, it's not probably correct
to just assume that if you take their entire merchant base that that percentage is the same as the volume.
The volume is probably more outsized than that.
But yes, that'll be a headwind throughout next year.
Sanjay Sakhrani
I guess what I'm thinking about the rest of the pool of volume that's left, how much of it do you expect to
retain, if any?
John Rainey
So, eBay can—they can move everyone if they want through their managed payments experience, if
that's what they like to do, even forcing it upon people that don't want it. We're not in control of that. What
we're focused on is our share of checkout in that managed payments experience. And as I noted on the
call, it's north of 50%. Actually, 59%, 60% in the entities that they've already migrated. So, that's actually
in excess of what our initial expectations were. So, this is, I would say, tracking more or less on par with
what we talked about in January of 2018 when we talked about this.
And so, it certainly presents a headwind to next year but nothing that we think is so significant that we
can't get through it.
Sanjay Sakhrani
Okay. And just to clarify the OVAS or just sort of the credit cost impacts. I know Gabrielle you mentioned
the CECL impact and such. When you're talking about the pressure that's not being contemplated and the
outpaced impact of credit, do you mean just assuming the macro outlook remains the same? So on the
new growth you have to apply high reserve factors against them, or something else? I'm just trying to
make sure I understand how to think about that line and the growth of that line in 2021.
John Rainey
Yes. So, credit, seriously, has been a cash inflow for us this year because of the contraction in the book.
And so, typically, within OVAS, it's one of the areas that grows in the past sometimes faster than the rest
of the business, and if we assume the macro outlook remains pretty constant to what it is today, there's

-- 9 of 19 --

9
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
going to be continual management of that book and so we're not going to see growth in credit like we
have in the past. So, that's going to put a headwind to both revenue growth as well as margin.
Sanjay Sakhrani
Okay. Got it. So you're assuming you're going to shrink and that's why it's going to be a headwind for
revenues.
John Rainey
Well, shrink to not grow and specifically not grow at a rate commensurate with the rest of our business.
Sanjay Sakhrani
Got it. All right. thank you.
John Rainey
Yes.
Operator
And our next question will comes from the line of George Mihalos with Cowen.
George Mihalos
Hey guys. Thanks for taking my question and thanks again for doing this.
John Rainey
Hey, George.
George Mihalos
Wanted to start off, based on the commentary from Dan on the trends that you see more recently with
TPV, John, is is safe to say as you look through the month of October and your performance there that
TPV growth was sort of tracking at the higher end of your fourth quarter guide and you're sort of in the
mid 30s as opposed to the low 30s?
John Rainey
I would say it's pretty much on track with our guide. We've been very encouraged by some of the days
that we've seen that, as we noted, were at all-time high levels. But overall I would say it's consistent with
our guide.
George Mihalos
Okay. And just a quick follow-up. I know it's been asked a couple of different ways, but maybe just to sort
of ask it a bit bluntly. The transaction margin, and obviously, the improvements that you've seen there
over the last two quarters, should we be thinking that this rate of overall transaction margin is sustainable
as we look into '21? And I know you talked about some of these puts going against you but you also have
a lot of these new products that seem to be accretive to the margin.

-- 10 of 19 --

10
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
John Rainey
Transaction margin will largely track with what's happening with the overall trends in our business. So, as
we've seen more volume come from the branded checkout experience that carries a lower transaction
expense and those tend to be higher margin. If you look at some of the areas, like the travel and event
verticals where maybe we do more of the unbranded processing, they've obviously put a significant
headwind into our revenue growth, but they also come at a lower margin.
So, to the extent that that persists, then yes I would expect transaction margin to continue to be at this
level. To the extent that we see travel and events rebound, that's going to put a little bit of pressure there.
But the question I think everyone has is, okay, well, if the core branded experiences still remain at an
elevated level going forward, well, then that's going to bode well for us on transaction margin. And then to
your point, when we add things like Venmo monetization going forward, that's going to be—that's
something that is bringing that down right now, which will start being accretive to that.
So a number of dynamics influencing that. And maybe I didn't specifically answer your question, but tried
to provide some color on the puts and takes there.
George Mihalos
Great. Thank you.
John Rainey
You bet, George.
Operator
Thank you. And our next question will comes from the line of Ashwin Shirvaikar with Citi.
John Rainey
Hey, Ashwin.
Ashwin Shirvaikar
Hey, John. How are you?
John Rainey
Good. I hope you're doing well.
Ashwin Shirvaikar
Yes, thanks. So, my first question was on BNPL. Do you expect maybe a higher rate of losses that should
settle out later as you figure out the type of user that has a tendency to use BNPL? And then, eventually
will you take this off of the balance sheet?
John Rainey

-- 11 of 19 --

11
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
Two very good questions. First, we don't expect a high rate of losses, and that's typically what one would
assume when you launch a new credit product. For example, when we launched the international
consumer product, we saw a higher rate of losses there initially, but fortunately, because of some of our
risk capabilities we're not seeing that in BNPL, nor do we expect to. So, very pleased about that.
And just to add a finer point around the monetization of that. That's very much a product targeted for
share of checkout, because as Dan noted, there's no incremental fee on the merchants related to that
product, which is the normal take rate, while others are charging for that. But, clearly, this is an area of
credit where a lot of people are participating and we believe we've got a better value proposition there.
And then when you get to the fact that it's effectively free, we think that we'll see the benefits there
through a higher share of checkout.
With respect to the second part of your question, which was...
Akila Moorthy
Externalization
John Rainey
Oh yes, yes. So, right now, we don't have any plans to externalize that. One of the interesting things
about this, Ashwin, is that because of the duration of the receivables it's actually much less capital
intensive for the amount of revenue that it brings in, in contrast to some of our other consumer-oriented
products. And so, we don't have anything in the works right now to put that off balance sheet. But that
said, our mantra around this remains the same. We will continue to be very thoughtful around how we use
credit in our business, where it's not too capital intensive or it doesn't become such a large part of our
portfolio of products that it introduces volatility to our earnings that is not desirable.
Ashwin Shirvaikar
Got it. And then the other question was, in terms of just thinking of eBay and the 3.5 points of headwind,
could you kind of bring that down to sort of what the margin impact is and considering eBay's push in
these faster rate of merchant attrition, if you will? Does your tactical objective here change in terms of
how you service eBay?
John Rainey
No, I wouldn't say so. eBay tends to be a higher margin part of our business historically, as they've
enjoyed in the range of a 4% average take rate, and so there's an outsized earnings impact related to that
decline in revenue. We saw some of that in the most recent quarter and look, we're still expanding
margins. So, the impact will be [relatively] contained to 2021 and hopefully when all is said and done it's
not aiming at something that I think is really relevant to our overall financial performance. I guess said
differently, Ashwin, we believe that we can manage the margin impact of that just fine with what's
happening with the rest of our business.
So, it's really going to be the impact on revenue growth that is the only thing that's really, I think,
significant to call out.
Ashwin Shirvaikar
Got it. Okay, thanks.

-- 12 of 19 --

12
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
John Rainey
Yes.
Operator
Thank you. Our next question will come from the line of Bob Napoli with William Blair.
Bob Napoli
Hi. Thank you. Good afternoon.
John Rainey
Hey Bob.
Bob Napoli
John, I guess, probably an impossible question to answer, but that e-commerce has gained massive
market share this year relative to historical trends and as you think about next year and you're looking to
next year, as you start lapping the massive, do you think—what are your thoughts, do you think that e-
commerce market share gives up some of the gains before it starts growing again? Or what are the
thoughts on the trajectory of e-commerce, say, a year from today we have a vaccine and the world starts
to get back to normal?
John Rainey
You're right, Bob, that's an impossible question to answer. I'll share my thoughts with you on this. I think
we've seen a permanent step-up in e-commerce. I notice it from my own personal behavior in my
household and it's validated by the numerous studies that we do on consumers weekly saying that—and
we've all seen figures that 50% of people suggest they're going to continue to shop online. You've got the
CEO of Kroger saying that their customers are telling them that they'll continue to shop, buy groceries
online. And just one vertical after the next. Will things come down from the peak when the entire world
was locked down in a shelter in place? Certainly, because people will have mobility and they've got the
latitude to buy in whatever channel that they want.
So I'm not suggesting that we're going to see the peak levels sustainable, but I absolutely believe that
we've seen a step-up change in e-commerce penetration relative to what we saw prior to the pandemic.
And again, we actually want to put some gasoline on the fire here. This is why we're investing. This is why
we're doing QR code, why we want to give contactless options for our customers, because we think that
we could help shape some of these trends because it's—and I've joked about it earlier in the call, but the
quote that Craig Maurer had in the Journal today was basically essentially saying he sees no reason why
once someone uses a digital product to pay somebody else why they'd never go back to cash. And I
agree with that. And actually history would tell us that that's largely true. So, I do think that we're seeing
sustainable trends here.
Bob Napoli
Thanks. And then just a follow-up. I mean, there's been huge growth in money transfer, digital money
transfer. I wondered how Xoom was doing. And then, how do we track your physical retail progress?
What are the thoughts and what you might give us to be able to track the progress on physical retail?

-- 13 of 19 --

13
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
John Rainey
Sure. Well, Xoom is doing exceptionally well, and I think that that would stand to reason given the
environment that we're in. We don't call out the volume metrics related to that. Look, it's still a pretty small
part of our overall volume in our business.
In terms of tracking the retail metrics, we're early on here, and we will provide some indications around
how we're doing, the success of that. But this is not something that we're going to be able to measure
success in the next quarter or two or three, for that matter. This is going to be a long slog. If it were easy,
it would have already been done, and we just think that this is an opportune moment in history where
there is a real demand among both merchants and consumers to have contactless options. But when
appropriate and when material, we will provide some indication of how we're doing.
Bob Napoli
Thank you.
John Rainey
You bet.
Operator
And our next question will comes from the line of Timothy Chiodo with Credit Suisse.
Timothy Chiodo
Thank you. Okay. I want to ask about—you made the comment on the call that at the February investor
day you'll be raising the medium term guide. So a clarifier there. What would be the base year that the
guide would be based off of?
John Rainey
Well, it'll...
Timothy Chiodo
Would it be 2020 or 2021, I guess, is the question.
John Rainey
You know, I haven't really thought about that, but we'll make it very clear what it is when we do that. I
presume it'll be 2020. But I think our comments, Tim, really is just our bullishness around the business
and it kind of speaks to the answer I just provided to Bob. We do believe that there's some sustainable
tailwinds given what's happening now. We'll also be lapping eBay—or not lapping, but sort of not as
reliant on eBay's volume going forward, which will have a higher growth rate for us.
So, very excited about what the future holds and I think there are strong indications that the business will
be performing at a higher growth rate level than what it was in our previous meeting in terms of guidance.
Timothy Chiodo

-- 14 of 19 --

14
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
Okay, great. Thank you. Yes, and you kind of hit at what I was getting at. When I was saying if it was off
the 2020 base and it would be higher and incorporating the headwinds in 2021, which is very different
than starting in 2021 with kind of those headwinds behind you. So—okay, thank you.
John Rainey
But, Tim, to be clear, I don't want to be overly precise here or prescriptive on this. We're really speaking to
the overall trends in our business over a multiyear period and we're really excited about what that bodes.
Timothy Chiodo
Okay. All right. Point taken. I follow you. On the eBay headwinds, this is a little bit of a minor one, but
when we think about the headwind in Q4, how much of that can we think about as the volume that's gone
- and I apologize if you hit on this earlier - versus the repricing of some of the remaining volume, so the
retained checkout but perhaps under the new agreement?
John Rainey
It's both. It's both the repricing on the branded piece as well as the mix in terms of those moving to their
integrated payments experience.
Timothy Chiodo
Okay.
John Rainey
So not enough to call out one being outsized more than the other necessarily.
Timothy Chiodo
Okay. All right. Very helpful. Thanks a lot for taking my question.
John Rainey
You bet.
Operator
Our next question will comes from the line of Josh Beck with KeyBanc.
Josh Beck
Thanks, John, and team for this. Appreciate it as always.
John Rainey
Hey, Josh.
Josh Beck

-- 15 of 19 --

15
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
Hey, John. So, the BNPL came up and there seems to be a lot of optimism around, obviously not this
quarter, but where that can go over the next couple of years. So would like to hear what's behind that?
And then strategically, obviously, some of those companies charge a premium for that take rate. It seems
like you're going with more of the standard pricing. So do you see this bringing in volume maybe from
someone else's credit card? Just would like to hear how you think about the business case.
John Rainey
Sure. So let me give you a little bit of a lay of this landscape competitively. We get asked a lot of
questions about other payment marks and whether we—how we compete on share of checkout with
those payment marks, and consistently we've said and we still see that we compete very well with them.
We don't see any appreciable shift in share of checkout when a new payment mark, and whatever name
you want to give it, is inserted.
Where we have seen some changes in cases is when these buy now, pay later options are offered, we
see our share of checkout be affected. And so that really informs our strategy on this to where we want to
provide that same offering so we don't jeopardize any of that share of checkout, or, moreover, given the
strong consumer demand among certain demographics for this payment option, we actually see more
payment, more share of checkout, more payment volume. And so, we believe the best strategy is to go in
and offer basically a free offering for this, where the only monetization is just the take rate model that we
have with that merchant that was in place beforehand in probably most cases and there's no incremental
fee that all the others are charging to have this additional product.
And so, early indications have been really—everything's been really well received around that and I think
your comments around this I think are very much consistent with our thoughts. This is something we're
pretty excited about. This is not just the next product that any company has thrown out there. This has the
potential to be pretty meaningful for us.
Gabrielle Rabinovitch
Yes. Just I think the other piece too is that we're really bringing a very innovative solution to a long tail of
merchants that wouldn't be on the road map for a lot of these other sort of single product buy now pay
later programs because there's a sales process involved. And so, essentially very seamlessly we're
bringing this solution to our long tail of merchants and providing the ability to compete for the same sales
on the same basis with those consumers.
Josh Beck
Okay. That's all really helpful context. Thank you both. And then just quickly a follow-up on Tim's last
question there around how much of it is repricing versus volume. So, as we think about next year and as
we think about the path, should we assume that the biggest variable is really going to be the volume and
kind of the merchant piece that, John, you talked about earlier, or as we go through the year maybe does
one of those factors take over? Just any context you can share on just the path and the trajectory there.
John Rainey
I appreciate the question, Josh, though we have not called those out in terms of the materiality of each of
those, and so I can't do it here. They both have an impact and both will be noted in whatever we say the
impact will be next year, but we haven't called them out separately.
Josh Beck

-- 16 of 19 --

16
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
Okay. Okay, makes sense. Thank you both again.
John Rainey
You bet.
Operator
Thank you. Our next question will comes from the line of Jamie Friedman with Susquehanna.
Jamie Friedman
Hi. Thanks guys for doing this call.
John Rainey
Hello, Jamie.
Jamie Friedman
Hi. A couple of questions. So, clearly, great job with the transaction expense at 82 basis points. Record
low. I was wondering though, did you see a similar mix shift to debit [cards] that the networks were calling
out, which was up debit, down some on credit, and is that relevant to the transaction expense
improvement?
John Rainey
So, without being specific in terms of the materiality, we did see a shift to debit. So that certainly has an
impact on our numbers as well. And we called that out in the second quarter as well that it was perhaps
maybe a little more intuitive in the second quarter as there were a lot of stimulus checks being delivered
at that point in time going directly to people's bank accounts. But we have seen a persistent higher level
of debit relative to what we've seen historically. And perhaps, some of that is also just consumer behavior.
Jamie Friedman
Got it. Thank you. And then John, also in your prepared remarks in the previous call or maybe in one of
your answers you had referred to credit as a headwind next year. I just want to make sure I understood, is
that apropos of your prior answer, meaning, as a funding mix or are you talking about credit as it impacts
OVAS?
John Rainey
As it impacts OVAS. And by extension, our overall revenue growth and earnings.
Jamie Friedman
Yes.
John Rainey
And look, I don't want to emphasize that too much. Credit's still a pretty small part of our business, but I'm
simply trying to provide a couple of the things that are moving year-on-year or are the performance is

-- 17 of 19 --

17
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
different than what we've seen historically. And people have noted that eBay, I think we called that out for
sometime is going to have an impact, but credit, our expectation right now, given the macro environment,
is that will continue to be a drag on our revenue growth and earnings.
Jamie Friedman
Got it. Thank you for the perspective.
John Rainey
You bet.
Operator
Thank you. And our last question for the day will comes from the line of Brett Huff with Stephens,
Incorporated.
Brett Huff
Good evening, John, Gabrielle, and Akila. I hope you're all doing well.
John Rainey
Same to you, Brett.
Brett Huff
Two quick questions, all about bigger picture because a lot of the detail was already covered tonight, so
thanks for all that. Number one is, Venmo card, heavy focus on QR codes. Understand the Chinese and
Asian success with QR code and ubiquity there. Could you talk about that versus tap-to-pay and
contactless, etc., and kind of how you're choosing one or the other or straddling? And then the follow-up
is, anything on pricing on just the plain vanilla stuff you guys are offering, or is e-com so in demand that
you're able to raise pricing, hold pricing better, just any change with that? And thanks in advance.
John Rainey
You bet. So, first on QR code, Brett, our goal is to allow our customers to pay in whatever form they want.
And so we don't want to be overly prescriptive on forcing them into a QR code experience. It just so
happens though that I think that is the quickest and easiest to launch and we've seen that success in
China, as you called out, and perhaps the interoperability aspects of that are much greater than some of
the others. And so, that's where our focus has been initially, but longer term you should really hear us talk
more about contactless payments versus QR code, because we want to provide whatever capability it is
for our customers in terms of their preference.
In terms of pricing, I'll start with kind of the same-store sales pricing is basically still constant, flat. We've
not seen any change there. The changes in our take rate are really related to the four items that I called
out earlier on this call. But we do continue to get more sophisticated with how we price, and as we look at
the various products that we provide out there, there are a number of different ways to price around that.
So, every year we've earmarked certain benefits in our annual plan related to pricing changes. And
pricing also goes both ways. We also look at, as I mentioned earlier, with the buy now pay later. I mean,
this is one where we're electing to give something away for free because we think there's a greater

-- 18 of 19 --

18
ViaVid has made considerable efforts to provide an accurate transcription. There may be material errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in the
reporting of the substance of the conference call. This transcript is being made available for information purposes only.
1-888-562-0262 1-604-929-1352 www.viavid.com
PayPal Holdings, Inc. – Third Quarter 2020 Analyst Call, November 2, 2020
opportunity in share of wallet. And so, that certainly cuts both ways, but there are a number of pricing
changes that we've got, both implementing right now, as well as in our plans for next year.
So, thank you for the question, Brett. And Holly, I see that we are right at the end of our time. So, I want
to thank everyone for their question or questions, and I'm sure that we'll be following up with many of you
over the coming days.
So until then, I hope everyone remains healthy and stays well. Take care.
Operator
Once again, we'd like to thank you for participating in PayPal's Quarter Three Analyst call. You may now
disconnect.

-- 19 of 19 --