PRESENTATION

Q2 2023 — Results presentation

Q2 2023PDF · 48 pages7.9 MB
Investor
Relations
2 0 2 3 Q 2
Reserving and
cohort pricing

-- 1 of 48 --

Information Relevant to this Presentation
Investors are cautioned that certain statements in this presentation and related comments by management during the earnings call not based upon historical fact are forward-looking statements as defined in the Private
Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. These statements often use words such as “estimate,” “expect,” “intend,” “plan,” “believe,” “goal,” “target,” “anticipate,” “will,” “could,” “likely,” “may,” “should,” and other words and terms
of similar meaning, or are tied to future periods, in connection with a discussion of future operating or financial performance. Forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance, are based on current
expectations and projections about future events, and are subject to certain risks, assumptions and uncertainties that could cause actual events and results to differ materially from those discussed herein. These risks and
uncertainties include, without limitation, uncertainties related to:
• 	our ability to underwrite and price risks accurately and to charge adequate rates to policyholders;
• 	our ability to establish accurate loss reserves;
• 	the impact of severe weather, other catastrophe events and climate change;
• 	the effectiveness of our reinsurance programs and the continued availability of reinsurance and
performance by reinsurers;
• 	the secure and uninterrupted operation of the systems, facilities and business functions and the
operation of various third-party systems that are critical to our business;
• 	the impacts of a security breach or other attack involving our technology systems or the systems
of one or more of our vendors;
• 	our ability to maintain a recognized and trusted brand and reputation;
• 	whether we innovate effectively and respond to our competitors’ initiatives;
• 	whether we effectively manage complexity as we develop and deliver products and customer
experiences;
• 	our ability to attract, develop and retain talent and maintain appropriate staffing levels;
• 	the impact of misconduct or fraudulent acts by employees, agents, and third parties to our
business and/or exposure to regulatory assessments;
• 	the highly competitive nature of property-casualty insurance markets;
• 	whether we adjust claims accurately;
• 	compliance with complex and changing laws and regulations;
• 	litigation challenging our business practices, and those of our competitors and other companies;
• 	the success of our business strategy and efforts to acquire or develop new products or enter into
new areas of business and navigate related risks;
• 	how intellectual property rights affect our competitiveness and our business operations;
• 	the possible impairment of our goodwill or intangible assets;
• 	the performance of our fixed-income and equity investment portfolios;
• 	the impact on our investment returns and strategies from regulations and societal pressures relating to environmental,
social, governance and other public policy matters;
• 	the elimination of the London Interbank Offered Rate;
• 	our continued ability to access our cash accounts and/or convert investments into cash on favorable terms;
• 	the impact if one or more parties with which we enter into significant contracts or transact business fail to perform;
• 	legal restrictions on our insurance subsidiaries’ ability to pay dividends to The Progressive Corporation;
• 	limitations on our ability to pay dividends on our common shares under the terms of our outstanding preferred shares;
• 	our ability to obtain capital when necessary to support our business and potential growth;
• 	evaluations by credit rating and other rating agencies;
• 	the variable nature of our common share dividend policy;
• 	whether our investments in certain tax-advantaged projects generate the anticipated returns;
• 	the impact from not managing to short-term earnings expectations in light of our goal to maximize the long-term
value of the enterprise;
• 	the impacts of epidemics, pandemics or other widespread health risks; and
• 	other matters described from time to time in our releases and publications, and in our periodic reports and other
documents filed with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission, including, without limitation, the Risk
Factors section of our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ending December 31, 2022.
Any forward-looking statements are made only as of the date presented. Except as required by applicable law, we
undertake no obligation to update any forward-looking statements, whether as a result of new information, future
events or developments or otherwise.
In addition, investors should be aware that accounting principles generally accepted in the United States prescribe when
a company may reserve for particular risks, including litigation exposures. Accordingly, results for a given reporting
period could be significantly affected if and when we establish reserves for one or more contingencies. Also, our regular
reserve reviews may result in adjustments of varying magnitude as additional information regarding claims activity
becomes known. Reported results, therefore, may be volatile in certain accounting periods.
Safe Harbor Statement Under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995
2

-- 2 of 48 --

Information Relevant to this Presentation
Progressive disseminates information to the public about Progressive, its products, services and other matters through various outlets in order to achieve
broad, non-exclusionary distribution of information to the public. These outlets include its website (progressive.com) and its investor relations website
(investors.progressive.com). We encourage investors and others to review the information Progressive makes public through these outlets, as such
information distributed through these outlets may be considered to be material information.
Regulation FD Disclosure Outlets
Additional Information
Information in this presentation, and related comments by management during the earnings call, should be reviewed together. Additional information can also
be found in Progressive’s annual report on Form 10-K for the year ending December 31, 2022 filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. All information,
statements, and projections in this presentation and the related earnings call speak only as of the date of this presentation and related earnings call. Progressive
assumes no obligation to update any forward-looking or other information included in this presentation or related earnings calls, whether as a result of new
information, future developments or events or otherwise.
3

-- 3 of 48 --

Tricia Griffith
President & CEO
I N V E S T O R R E L A T I O N S Q 2
4

-- 4 of 48 --

5
Our People
I N V E S T O R R E L A T I O N S Q 2

-- 5 of 48 --

Aggregate
rate change
Number
of states
Average rate
change per
state
2021 	Q1 	0% 	- 	-
Q2 	2% 	11 	5%
Q3 	3% 	20 	6%
Q4 	3% 	19 	7%
Total 2021 	8%
2022 	Q1 	7% 	36 	9%
Q2 	2% 	17 	5%
Q3 	2% 	20 	5%
Q4 	2% 	13 	4%
Total 2022 	13%
2023 	Q1 	4% 	31 	6%
Q2 	7% 	27 	12%
We continue to
take rate to stay
ahead of trends
6
I N V E S T O R R E L A T I O N S Q 2
Source: Internal data

-- 6 of 48 --

2022 	2023
COMBINED RATIO IMPACT - ALL LINES
34
44
2022 	2023
CATASTROPHE EVENTS
Catastrophe losses had a significant impact on first half 2023 results
7
I N V E S T O R R E L A T I O N S Q 2
Source: Internal data
31.1 pts
45.4 pts
2022 	2023
COMBINED RATIO IMPACT - PROPERTY
First Half Catastrophe Comparison
5 pts
3 pts
45.9 pts
29.5 pts

-- 7 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
8
Our reserves have historically reflected minimum development
Prior Year Reserve
Change Impact CR Pts—First Half 	CR Pts—Second Half 	CR Pts—Full Year
2018 	0.6 	0.0 	0.3
2019 	1.2 	0.1 	0.6
2020 	0.6 	0.4 	0.5
2021 	0.9 	(0.9) 	0.0
2022 	0.6 	(0.9) 	(0.2)
2018-2022 Average 	0.8 	(0.3) 	0.2
Source: Internal data

-- 8 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
9
Our reserves have historically reflected minimum development
Prior Year Reserve
Change Impact CR Pts—First Half 	CR Pts—Second Half 	CR Pts—Full Year
2018 	0.6 	0.0 	0.3
2019 	1.2 	0.1 	0.6
2020 	0.6 	0.4 	0.5
2021 	0.9 	(0.9) 	0.0
2022 	0.6 	(0.9) 	(0.2)
2018-2022 Average 	0.8 	(0.3) 	0.2
2023 	4.0 	TBD 	TBD
Source: Internal data

-- 9 of 48 --

Property
-$2
Personal Lines
$888
Commercial Lines
$224
-$100
$100
$300
$500
$700
$900
$1,100
$1,300
Category 1
YTD Adverse Development ($MM)
Nearly half of YTD personal lines prior year unfavorable development
is in Florida
10
I N V E S T O R R E L A T I O N S Q 2
PRIOR YEAR RESERVE DEVELOPMENT (YTD thru 6/2023)
PERSONAL LINES
DEVELOPMENT
BREAKDOWN
FL Personal Auto
Development
All other
Source: Internal data

-- 10 of 48 --

Personal Lines Fixing
Vehicle Coverages
Countrywide
Florida Injury Coverages
<1%
All other
CURRENT ACCIDENT
YEAR ACTUARIAL
ADJUSTMENTS
(YTD thru 6/2023)
Current accident year
actuarial adjustments
are primarily driven by
fixing vehicle coverages
11
I N V E S T O R R E L A T I O N S Q 2
Total:
$424M
unfavorable
Source: Internal data

-- 11 of 48 --

Gary Traicoff
Corporate Actuary
Business Leader
Jim Curtis
Personal Lines
Controller
I N V E S T O R R E L A T I O N S Q 2
12
Agenda
01 / 	Reserving
02 / 	Cohort Pricing

-- 12 of 48 --

Reserving
I N V E S T O R R E L A T I O N S Q 2
13

-- 13 of 48 --

-
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
35,000
2013 	2014 	2015 	2016 	2017 	2018 	2019 	2020 	2021 	2022 	Jun-23
Net 	Ceded
R E S E R V I N G
14
Progressive Loss and Loss Adjustment Expense (LAE) reserves over time
$35B
$30B
$25B
$20B
$15B
$10B
$5B
$0B
We have about
in reserves before
reinsurance
$33B
Source: Internal data
Year to date
(June 2023)

-- 14 of 48 --

67%
17%
16%
Loss Case 	Loss IBNR 	LAE
17%
83%
Fixing Vehicles 	Injury/Medical
R E S E R V I N G
15
Distribution of net reserves
NET RESERVES BY
PRODUCT
YEAR END 2022
PERSONAL AUTO
(INJURY/MEDICAL
VS. FIXING VEHICLES)
YEAR END 2022
DISTRIBUTION
OF NET RESERVES
YEAR END 2022
32%
4%
64%
Commerical Lines 	Property
Personal Lines 	Other
Source: Internal data
Less than 1%

-- 15 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
16
2023 reserve review schedule
*Excludes catastrophe reserve reviews. Source: Progressive internal reports
84
292
57
95
123
15
33
0 	50 	100 	150 	200 	250 	300 	350
Property
Injury/Medical
Fixing Vehicles
LAE 	Commercial Lines
Personal Lines
Property
LAE
Fixing Vehicles
Injury/Medical
Property
of reserves are
reviewed monthly
25-30%
of reserves are
reviewed quarterly
~85%
NUMBER OF RESERVE REVIEWS COMPLETED*

-- 16 of 48 --

Review 	Type 	Product 	Coverage 	State
1 	Loss 	Auto 	COLL 	Multiple
2 	Loss 	CL 	PIP 	Countrywide
3 	Loss 	CL 	UMBI 	Countrywide
4 	LAE 	HO 	All 	State G
5 	Loss 	Auto 	BI 	State H
…
68 	Loss 	SL 	PD, UMPD 	Multiple
Review 	Type 	Product 	Coverage 	State
1 	Loss 	CL 	BI 	Multiple
2 	LAE 	Auto 	PIP 	State C
3 	LAE 	Auto 	BI 	State C
4 	Loss 	HO 	HODFCO WH Multiple
5 	Loss 	HO 	HODFCO WH State D
…
60 	Loss 	Auto 	BI 	State E
Review 	Type 	Product 	Coverage 	State
1 	Loss 	Auto 	BI 	State A
2 	Loss 	Auto 	Collision 	Multiple
3 	LAE 	CL 	BI 	Multiple
4 	Loss 	Property 	Wind hail 	Multiple
5 	Loss 	CL 	UMBI 	Multiple
…
57 	Loss 	TNC 	BI 	State B
R E S E R V I N G
17
Our detail-oriented reserve reviews provide a holistic,
in-depth view of the business
MONTH 1* 	MONTH 2* 	MONTH 3*
*Example only. Does not necessarily represent an actual reserve review schedule

-- 17 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
18
How we estimate aggregate reserve levels
ESTIMATING PAID LOSSES
Accident
Period Ending 1 	2 	3 	4
Ultimate
Estimated
Paid Losses
Paid at
June 2023
Total Indicated
Reserve
Dec 2021 	100 	120 	130 	130 	130 	0
Jun 2022 	110 	135 	145 	145 	0
Dec 2022 	115 	160 	160 	13
Jun 2023 	120 	120 	45
57
Loss Development
Factors
Dec 2021 	1.20 	1.08 	1.00
Jun 2022 	1.23 	1.07
Dec 2022 	1.39
Stylized example

-- 18 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
19
How we estimate aggregate reserve levels
ESTIMATING PAID LOSSES
Accident
Period Ending 1 	2 	3 	4
Ultimate
Estimated
Paid Losses
Paid at
June 2023
Total Indicated
Reserve
Dec 2021 	100 	120 	130 	130 	130 	0
Jun 2022 	110 	135 	145 	145 	0
Dec 2022 	115 	160 	160 	13
Jun 2023 	120 	120 	45
57
Loss Development
Factors
Dec 2021 	1.20 	1.08 	1.00
Jun 2022 	1.23 	1.07
Dec 2022 	1.39
Stylized example

-- 19 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
20
How we estimate aggregate reserve levels
ESTIMATING PAID LOSSES
Accident
Period Ending 1 	2 	3 	4
Ultimate
Estimated
Paid Losses
Paid at
June 2023
Total Indicated
Reserve
Dec 2021 	100 	120 	130 	130 	130 	0
Jun 2022 	110 	135 	145 	145 	0
Dec 2022 	115 	160 	160 	13
Jun 2023 	120 	120 	45
57
Loss Development
Factors
Dec 2021 	1.20 	1.08 	1.00
Jun 2022 	1.23 	1.07
Dec 2022 	1.39
Stylized example

-- 20 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
21
How we estimate aggregate reserve levels
ESTIMATING PAID LOSSES
Accident
Period Ending 1 	2 	3 	4
Ultimate
Estimated
Paid Losses
Paid at
June 2023
Total Indicated
Reserve
Dec 2021 	100 	120 	130 	130 	130 	0
Jun 2022 	110 	135 	145 	145 	0
Dec 2022 	115 	160 	160 	13
Jun 2023 	120 	120 	45
57
Loss Development
Factors
Dec 2021 	1.20 	1.08 	1.00
Jun 2022 	1.23 	1.07
Dec 2022 	1.39
Stylized example

-- 21 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
22
How we estimate aggregate reserve levels
ESTIMATING PAID LOSSES
Accident
Period Ending 1 	2 	3 	4
Ultimate
Estimated
Paid Losses
Paid at
June 2023
Total Indicated
Reserve
Dec 2021 	100 	120 	130 	130 	130 	0
Jun 2022 	110 	135 	145 	145 	0
Dec 2022 	115 	160 	160 	13
Jun 2023 	120 	120 	45
57
Loss Development
Factors
Dec 2021 	1.20 	1.08 	1.00
Jun 2022 	1.23 	1.07
Dec 2022 	1.39
Stylized example

-- 22 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
23
How we estimate base reserves
ESTIMATING PAID LOSSES
Accident
Period Ending 1 	2 	3 	4
Ultimate
Estimated
Paid Losses
Paid at
June 2023
Total Indicated
Reserve
Dec 2021 	100 	120 	130 	130 	130 	0
Jun 2022 	110 	135 	145 	145 	0
Dec 2022 	115 	160 	160 	13
Jun 2023 	120 	120 	45
57
Loss Development
Factors
Dec 2021 	1.20 	1.08 	1.00
Jun 2022 	1.23 	1.07
Dec 2022 	1.39
Stylized example

-- 23 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
24
How we estimate aggregate reserve levels
ESTIMATING PAID LOSSES
Accident
Period Ending 1 	2 	3 	4
Ultimate
Estimated
Paid Losses
Paid at
June 2023
Total Indicated
Reserve
Dec 2021 	100 	120 	130 	130 	130 	0
Jun 2022 	110 	135 	145 	145 	0
Dec 2022 	115 	160 	160 	13
Jun 2023 	120 	120 	45
57
Loss Development
Factors
Dec 2021 	1.20 	1.08 	1.00
Jun 2022 	1.23 	1.07
Dec 2022 	1.39
Selected Loss
Development Factors Select 	1.27 	1.08 	1.00
Stylized example

-- 24 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
25
How we estimate aggregate reserve levels
ESTIMATING PAID LOSSES
Accident
Period Ending 1 	2 	3 	4
Ultimate
Estimated
Paid Losses
Paid at
June 2023
Total Indicated
Reserve
Dec 2021 	100 	120 	130 	130 	130 	130 	0
Jun 2022 	110 	135 	145 	145 	145 	145 	0
Dec 2022 	115 	160 	173 	173 	173 	160 	13
Jun 2023 	120 	153 	165 	165 	165 	120 	45
57
Loss Development
Factors
Dec 2021 	1.20 	1.08 	1.00
Jun 2022 	1.23 	1.07
Dec 2022 	1.39
Selected Loss
Development Factors Select 	1.27 	1.08 	1.00
Stylized example

-- 25 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
26
How we estimate aggregate reserve levels
ESTIMATING PAID LOSSES
Accident
Period Ending 1 	2 	3 	4
Ultimate
Estimated
Paid Losses
Paid at
June 2023
Total Indicated
Reserve
Dec 2021 	100 	120 	130 	130 	130 	130 	0
Jun 2022 	110 	135 	145 	145 	145 	145 	0
Dec 2022 	115 	160 	173 	173 	173 	160 	13
Jun 2023 	120 	153 	165 	165 	165 	120 	45
57
Loss Development
Factors
Dec 2021 	1.20 	1.08 	1.00
Jun 2022 	1.23 	1.07
Dec 2022 	1.39
Selected Loss
Development Factors Select 	1.27 	1.08 	1.00
Stylized example

-- 26 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
27
How we estimate aggregate reserve levels
ESTIMATING PAID LOSSES
Accident
Period Ending 1 	2 	3 	4
Ultimate
Estimated
Paid Losses
Paid at
June 2023
Total Indicated
Reserve
Dec 2021 	100 	120 	130 	130 	130 	130 	0
Jun 2022 	110 	135 	145 	145 	145 	145 	0
Dec 2022 	115 	160 	173 	173 	173 	160 	13
Jun 2023 	120 	153 	165 	165 	165 	120 	45
58
Loss Development
Factors
Dec 2021 	1.20 	1.08 	1.00
Jun 2022 	1.23 	1.07
Dec 2022 	1.39
Selected Loss
Development Factors Select 	1.27 	1.08 	1.00
Stylized example

-- 27 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
28
Reserve adjustments in the June 2023 earnings release
CURRENT MONTH 	Personal Lines Business Commercial
Lines Business
Property
Business
Companywide
Total
Agency 	Direct 	Total
Actuarial Adjustments
Reserve Decrease/(Increase)
Prior Accident Years 	$(131)
Current accident year 	(160)
Calendar year actuarial adjustment 	$(135) 	$(149) 	$(283) 	$(24) 	$16 	$(291)
Prior Accident Years Development
Favorable/(Unfavorable)
Actuarial adjustment 	$ (131)
All other development 	(7)
Total Development 	$ (138)
Source: Progressive June 2023 results

-- 28 of 48 --

67%
17%
16%
R E S E R V I N G
29
The pathway of a case reserve example
DATE OF LOSS
December 15
REPORTED
December 19
OPENED IN THE SYSTEM
December 19
$0
$5,000
$10,000
$15,000
$20,000
$25,000
$30,000
December 	January 	February 	March 	April 	May 	June
Adjuster Case
Reserve
Tabular Case
Reserve
Reserve
Liability on
Balance Sheet
IBNR Reserve
of $1,000
Threshold
DISTRIBUTION
OF RESERVES
Loss Case
Stylized example

-- 29 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
30
The pathway of a case reserve example
Inflation and
aging
MONTHLY CHANGE
IN INCURRED LOSSES
+$251
$0
$5,000
$10,000
$15,000
$20,000
$25,000
$30,000
December 	January 	February 	March 	April 	May 	June
Adjuster Case
Reserve
Tabular Case
Reserve
Reserve
Liability on
Balance Sheet
IBNR Reserve
of $1,000
Threshold
PRIOR ACCIDENT YEARS
DEVELOPMENT
Favorable/(Unfavorable)
JAN
Actuarial adjustment 	—
All other development 	$251
Stylized example

-- 30 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
31
The pathway of a case reserve example
Reserve factors
changed
MONTHLY CHANGE
IN INCURRED LOSSES
+$1,124
$0
$5,000
$10,000
$15,000
$20,000
$25,000
$30,000
December 	January 	February 	March 	April 	May 	June
Adjuster Case
Reserve
Tabular Case
Reserve
Reserve
Liability on
Balance Sheet
IBNR Reserve
of $1,000
Threshold
PRIOR ACCIDENT YEARS
DEVELOPMENT
Favorable/(Unfavorable)
FEB
Actuarial adjustment 	$1,124
All other development 	—
Stylized example

-- 31 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
32
The pathway of a case reserve example
Inflation, aging,
plaintiff
attorney
represented
MONTHLY CHANGE
IN INCURRED LOSSES
+$6,550
$0
$5,000
$10,000
$15,000
$20,000
$25,000
$30,000
December 	January 	February 	March 	April 	May 	June
Adjuster Case
Reserve
Tabular Case
Reserve
Reserve
Liability on
Balance Sheet
IBNR Reserve
of $1,000
Threshold
PRIOR ACCIDENT YEARS
DEVELOPMENT
Favorable/(Unfavorable)
MAR
Actuarial adjustment 	—
All other development 	$6,550
Stylized example

-- 32 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
33
The pathway of a case reserve example
Adjuster’s
moves to
threshold
MONTHLY CHANGE
IN INCURRED LOSSES
+$4,950
$0
$5,000
$10,000
$15,000
$20,000
$25,000
$30,000
December 	January 	February 	March 	April 	May 	June
Adjuster Case
Reserve
Tabular Case
Reserve
Reserve
Liability on
Balance Sheet
IBNR Reserve
of $1,000
Threshold
PRIOR ACCIDENT YEARS
DEVELOPMENT
Favorable/(Unfavorable)
APR
Actuarial adjustment 	—
All other development 	$4,950
Stylized example

-- 33 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
34
The pathway of a case reserve example
No adjustments
for inflation,
aging, plaintiff
attorney
represented,
etc.
$0
$5,000
$10,000
$15,000
$20,000
$25,000
$30,000
December 	January 	February 	March 	April 	May 	June
Adjuster Case
Reserve
Tabular Case
Reserve
Reserve
Liability on
Balance Sheet
IBNR Reserve
of $1,000
Threshold
PRIOR ACCIDENT YEARS
DEVELOPMENT
Favorable/(Unfavorable)
MAY
Actuarial adjustment 	—
All other development 	—
Stylized example

-- 34 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
35
The pathway of a case reserve example
$0
$5,000
$10,000
$15,000
$20,000
$25,000
$30,000
December 	January 	February 	March 	April 	May 	June
Adjuster Case
Reserve
Tabular Case
Reserve
Reserve
Liability on
Balance Sheet
IBNR Reserve
of $1,000
Threshold
Claim is paid
for $20,000
and will be
$5,000
favorable
PRIOR ACCIDENT YEARS
DEVELOPMENT
Favorable/(Unfavorable)
JUN
Actuarial adjustment 	—
All other development 	$(5,000)
Stylized example

-- 35 of 48 --

67%
17%
16%
R E S E R V I N G
The pathway of a case reserve example
$0
$5,000
$10,000
$15,000
$20,000
$25,000
$30,000
December 	January 	February 	March 	April 	May 	June 	July 	August
Adjuster Case
Reserve
Tabular Case
Reserve
Reserve
Liability on
Balance Sheet
IBNR Reserve
of $1,000
Threshold
Reopens for a
payment of
$1,500 and IBNR
closes out
MONTHLY CHANGE
IN INCURRED LOSSES
+$500
PRIOR ACCIDENT YEARS
DEVELOPMENT
Favorable/(Unfavorable)
JUL
Actuarial adjustment 	—
All other development 	$500
Loss IBNR
Stylized example

-- 36 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
37
Our relationships with internal business partners provide good
checks and balances
M ONTH L Y	REVIEW
CADENCE
CLAIMS
PRICING
PRODUCT
MANAGEMENT
QU AR TER L Y
BOARD OF
DIRECTORS
Audit committee

-- 37 of 48 --

R E S E R V I N G
38
Report on Loss Reserve
Practices provides
more details on
reserving practices
Report on Loss Reserve Practices

-- 38 of 48 --

Cohort Pricing
Personal Auto
I N V E S T O R R E L A T I O N S Q 2
39

-- 39 of 48 --

LIFETIME COSTS (OR COMBINED RATIO)
C O H O R T P R I C I N G
40
Cohort Pricing
in summary New Business
Term
Renewal
Terms
Target
Combined
Ratio

-- 40 of 48 --

C O H O R T P R I C I N G
41
Policies priced to a lifetime 96
STYLIZED EXAMPLE
First Term 	Five Renewal Terms 	Lifetime
Loss and LAE Exp 	85 	77 	78
Acquisition Exp 	35 	5 	10
Operational Exp 	11 	7 	8
Combined Ratio 	131 	89 	96
*Stylized example does not represent actual numbers. Actual numbers could differ materially from what is displayed.

-- 41 of 48 --

C O H O R T P R I C I N G
42
Indemnity differential
STYLIZED EXAMPLE 	First Term 	Five Renewal Terms 	Lifetime
Loss and LAE Exp 	85 	77 	78
Acquisition Exp 	35 	5 	10
Operational Exp 	11 	7 	8
Combined Ratio 	131 	89 	96
Red Cars 	Blue Cars 	Green Cars
RENEWAL/NEW LOSS RATIO RELATIVITY
STYLIZED EXAMPLE:
RED CARS
First
Term
Four Renewal
Terms Lifetime
Loss and LAE Exp 	90 	73 	76
Acquisition Exp 	20 	10 	12
Operational Exp 	11 	7 	8
Combined Ratio 	121 	90 	96
STYLIZED EXAMPLE:
GREEN CARS
First
Term
Six Renewal
Terms Lifetime
Loss and LAE Exp 	80 	77 	77
Acquisition Exp 	20 	10 	11
Operational Exp 	11 	7 	8
Combined Ratio 	111 	94 	96

-- 42 of 48 --

C O H O R T P R I C I N G
43
Lifetime acquisition economics can vary based on distribution channel
First Term 	Five Renewal Terms 	Lifetime
Loss and LAE Exp 	85 	77 	78
Acquisition Exp 	60 	0 	10
Operational Exp 	11 	7 	8
Combined Ratio 	156 	84 	96
First Term 	Five Renewal Terms 	Lifetime
Loss and LAE Exp 	85 	77 	78
Acquisition Exp 	10 	10 	10
Operational Exp 	11 	7 	8
Combined Ratio 	106 	94 	96
STYLIZED EXAMPLE: DIRECT 	STYLIZED EXAMPLE: AGENCY

-- 43 of 48 --

C O H O R T P R I C I N G
44
Direct channel acquisition economics
STYLIZED EXAMPLE:
DIRECT First Term 	Five Renewal Terms 	Lifetime
LR+LAE 	85 	77 	78
Acquisition ER 	60 	0 	10
Operational Exp 	11 	7 	8
Combined Ratio 	156 	84 	96
Policy #1 	Policy #2
$$s % of
Prem $$s % of
Prem
Policy Premium 	$750 	$750
Policy Life Expectancy 	6 	8
Lifetime Premium 	$4,500 	10% 	$6,000 	8%
Acquisition Costs 	$450 	$450

-- 44 of 48 --

C O H O R T P R I C I N G
45
Agency channel acquisition economics
Policy #1 	Policy #2
$$s % of
Prem $$s % of
Prem
Policy Premium 	$750 	$1,000
Commission Expense 	$75.0 	10% 	$100.0 	10%
Total policy terms 	6 	8
Lifetime Premium 	$4,500 	$6,000
Lifetime Commission Expense 	$450 	10% 	$600 	10%
STYLIZED EXAMPLE:
AGENCY First Term 5 Renewal
Terms Lifetime
LR+LAE 	85 	77 	78
Acquisition ER 	10 	10 	10
Operational Exp 	11 	7 	8
Combined Ratio 	106 	94 	96

-- 45 of 48 --

C O H O R T P R I C I N G
46
Operational Expenses
STYLIZED EXPENSE STRUCTURE 	New 	Renewal 	Total
Operational Expenses 	5% 	1% 	2%
Other 	6% 	6% 	6%
Total 	11% 	7% 	8%
*Stylized example does not represent actual numbers. Actual numbers could differ materially from what is displayed.

-- 46 of 48 --

C O H O R T P R I C I N G
47
Grow as fast as possible at a 96 CR
High Growth 	Low Growth
New Business Application Growth 	30% 	0%
Policy In Force Growth 	12% 	7%
EP Mix 	Target 	EP Mix 	Target
New Business 	20% 	131% 	15% 	131%
Renewal 	80% 	89% 	85% 	89%
Combined Ratio 	97% 	95%
Stylized example

-- 47 of 48 --

I N V E S T O R R E L A T I O N S Q 2
Thank you

-- 48 of 48 --