ANNUAL REPORT
FY 2023 — Annual financial statements
FY 2023PDF · 278 pages5.8 MB
STANDARD BANK GROUP
ANNUAL
FINANCIAL
STATEMENTSfor the year ended 31 December 2023
__________
-- 1 of 278 --
CONTENTS
Our reporting suite 1 Standard Bank Group Limited –
Company annual financial
statements
Annual financial
statements
Chief executive and financial director’s
responsibility statement
2 Statement of financial position 191
Statement of comprehensive income 192
Directors’ responsibility for financial reporting 2 Statement of cash flows 193
Group secretary’s certification 3 Statement of changes in equity 194
Report of the group audit committee 3 Notes to the company annual financial statements 196
Directors’ report 7
Independent auditors’ report 10 Annexures to the annual financial
statements
Statement of financial position 20
Income statement 21
Statement of other comprehensive income 22 Annexure A – Subsidiaries, consolidated and unconsolidated
structured entities
200
Statement of cash flows 23
Statement of changes in equity 24 Annexure B – Associates and joint ventures 220
Accounting policy elections and restatement 28 Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures 224
IFRS 171 transition impact 31 Annexure D – Group share incentive schemes 262
Key management assumptions 40 Annexure E – Emoluments and share incentives of directors and
prescribed officers
268
Notes to the financial statements 57
Annexure F – Material accounting policies 288
Annexure G – Six-year review 332
Administrative and contact details ibc
1 International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS®) 17 Insurance Contracts (IFRS 17).
-- 2 of 278 --
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 1
OUR
REPORTING
SUITE
Our suite of reports caters for the diverse needs of our
stakeholders.
Annual integrated report
Sets out our value story and what we want to achieve for
our stakeholders and the Standard Bank Group (SBG or
the group) and assesses our ability to deliver
sustainable growth and value in the short, medium and
long term. It draws information from our supplementary
reports which provide more detailed disclosure.
Annual financial statements (this report)
Sets out the group’s full audited annual financial
statements, including the report of the group audit
committee
Risk and capital management report
Sets out the group’s approach to risk management
and Pillar III disclosures of the Basel Framework.
Governance report
Discusses the group’s governance approach and
priorities.
Remuneration report
Sets out the group’s remuneration policy
and implementation report and includes a background
statement from the remuneration committee chair.
Sustainability disclosures
Provides an overview of how we manage environmental,
social and governance (ESG) risk, including information
regarding ethics and conduct, people and culture,
environmental and social risk management, and tax
governance and policy, together with information about
our sustainable finance activities.
Report to society (RTS)
An assessment of our impact on society, the economy
and the environment, focusing on the four areas in
which we have the most significant impact, namely:
enterprise growth and job creation, infrastructure
development and the energy transition, climate
resilience, and financial inclusion.
Climate-related financial disclosures report
Discusses how the group is managing the risks and
responding to the opportunities presented by climate
change, aligned to the recommendations of the Task
Force on Climate-related Disclosures (TCFD).
Our reporting portal
All our reports, latest results presentations,
booklets, SENS announcements and a glossary
of financial terms, other definitions, acronyms
and abbreviations used in our reports are
available at www.standardbank.com/sbg/
standard-bank-group/investor-relations/
results-and-reports/
Subsidiary annual reports
Our subsidiaries account to their stakeholders
through their own annual and/or other reports
and information, available on their respective
websites, accessible from
www.standardbank.com/sbg/standard-bank-
group/investor-relations/results-and-reports/
subsidiaries
Shareholder information
The invitation to the annual general meeting
(AGM) and notice of resolutions to be tabled at
the AGM are sent to shareholders separately.
Assurance on this report
The consolidated and separate annual financial
statements were audited in terms of the South
African Companies Act 71 of 2008, as amended
(Companies Act).
Preparation of this report
The preparation of The Standard Bank Group
Limited consolidated and separate annual
financial statements was supervised by the
Chief Finance & Value Management Officer,
Arno Daehnke, BSc, MSc, PhD, MBA, AMP.
Release date
These results, together with a summary thereof,
were made publicly available on 14 March 2024.
HOW TO NAVIGATE OUR REPORTS
Refers readers to information elsewhere in
this report.
Refers readers to information in other
reports online.
-- 3 of 278 --
Each of the directors, whose names are stated below, hereby confirm that the annual financial statements set out on pages 20 to 339,
fairly present in all material respects the financial position, financial performance and cash flows of the Standard Bank Group Limited in
terms of IFRS, and that to the best of our knowledge and belief, no facts have been omitted or untrue statements made that would make
the annual financial statements false or misleading. Internal financial controls have been put in place to ensure that material information
relating to the issuer and its consolidated subsidiaries have been provided to effectively prepare the financial statements of the issuer,
the internal financial controls are adequate and effective and can be relied on in compiling the annual financial statements, having
fulfilled our role and function as executive directors with primary responsibility for implementation and execution of controls. Where we
are not satisfied, we have disclosed to the audit committee and the auditors the deficiencies in design and operational effectiveness of
the internal financial controls, and have taken steps to remedy the deficiencies and we are not aware of any fraud involving directors.
Arno Daehnke Sim Tshabalala
Chief finance & value management officer Group chief executive officer
13 March 2024 13 March 2024
DIRECTORS’ RESPONSIBILITY FOR
FINANCIAL REPORTING
In accordance with the Companies Act, the directors are responsible for the preparation of the annual financial statements. These annual
financial statements conform to IFRS as issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB®), the South African Institute of
Chartered Accountants’ (SAICA) Financial Reporting Guides as issued by the Accounting Practices Committee, the JSE Listings
Requirements, and fairly present the affairs of the Standard Bank Group Limited (SBGL or the company) and the Standard Bank Group
(SBG or the group) as at 31 December 2023, and the net income and cash flows for the year then ended.
The directors are ultimately responsible for the internal controls of the company and the group. Management enables the directors to
meet these responsibilities. Standards and systems of internal controls are designed, implemented and monitored by management to
provide reasonable assurance of the integrity and reliability of the annual financial statements and to adequately safeguard, verify and
maintain accountability for shareholder investments as well as company and group assets. Systems and controls include the proper
delegation of responsibilities within a clearly defined framework, effective accounting procedures and adequate segregation of duties.
It is the responsibility of the independent auditors to report on the fair presentation of the financial statements. Based on the information
and explanations provided by management and the group’s internal auditors, the directors are of the opinion that the internal financial
controls are adequate and that the financial records may be relied upon for preparing the annual financial statements in accordance with
IFRS and to maintain accountability for the company and the group’s assets and liabilities. Nothing has come to the attention of the
directors to indicate that a breakdown in the functioning of these controls, resulting in a material loss to the company and the group, has
occurred during the year and up to the date of this report.
The controls over the maintenance and integrity of the SBGL website, for the purpose of establishing and controlling the process for
electronically distributing the annual financial statements and other financial information to shareholders have been put in place, are
adequate and effective and can be relied on.
The directors have a reasonable expectation that the company and the group will have adequate resources to continue in operational
existence and as a going concern in the financial year ahead. The 2023 annual financial statements, which appear on pages 20 to 339,
were approved by the board of directors of Standard Bank Group Limited (the board) on 13 March 2024 and signed on its behalf by:
Nonkululeko Nyembezi Sim Tshabalala
Chairman Group chief executive officer
13 March 2024 13 March 2024
2 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
CHIEF EXECUTIVE AND FINANCIAL
DIRECTOR’S RESPONSIBILITY STATEMENT
-- 4 of 278 --
Compliance with the Companies Act
In terms of the Companies Act and for the year ended 31 December 2023, I certify that Standard Bank Group Limited has filed all returns
and notices required by the Companies Act with the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission and that all such returns and
notices are true, correct and up to date.
Kobus Froneman
Group secretary
13 March 2024
REPORT OF THE GROUP AUDIT COMMITTEE
This report is provided by the audit committee in respect of the
2023 financial year of Standard Bank Group Limited, in
compliance with section 94 of the Companies Act, as amended
from time to time, and in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements.
The committee’s operation is guided by a detailed mandate that
is informed by the Companies Act, the Banks Act, the JSE
Listings Requirements and the King IV Code on Corporate
Governance and is approved by the board. Section 94(2) of the
Companies Act determines that, at each annual general meeting,
a public company must elect an audit committee comprising at
least three members. In terms of 94(1), the bank is exempted
from complying with section 94(2). Accordingly, the appointment
of its members was approved annually by the board. However, in
line with governance best practice, with effect from 2022, the
appointment of members to the group audit committee is
presented to shareholders for approval at the annual general
meeting.
At the end of December 2023, the committee comprised four
independent non-executive directors, all of whom have the
necessary financial literacy, skills and experience to execute their
duties effectively. To ensure that risk-related matters relevant to
the audit committee are considered, the chairman is a member
of and attended the group risk and capital management
committee meetings held during the financial year. Through the
chairman and other audit committee members’ membership on
the risk and capital management committee, SBG information
technology committee and SBG remuneration committee,
collective and integrated oversight of key matters in the
respective committees’ deliberations was ensured.
The committee met seven times during 2023. This included
a meeting with the SARB Prudential Authority following the
publication of the prior year’s group financial results and a
special meeting to approve the appointment of Deloitte as the
group’s external auditors with effect from the financial year
ending 31 December 2026. All members were present for all
meetings held during 2023, except Lwazi Bam who was recused
from the special meeting.
MEETINGS HELD DURING THE YEAR
Information on the committee’s role and responsibilities; its composition, including members’ qualifications and experience; the date
of members’ appointment to the committee; the number of meetings held during the year and attendance at those meetings; as well as
key areas of focus during the reporting period is provided in greater detail in the corporate governance statement which is included in
the group’s governance and remuneration report available at www.standardbank.com/sbg/standard-bank-group/investor-relations/results-and-
reports/.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 3
GROUP SECRETARY’S CERTIFICATION
March 2023
2022 year-end financial
results meeting.
March 2023
Meeting with the
Prudential Authority
following publication of
the prior year’s group
financial results.
August 2023
2023 interim financial
results meeting; and
oversight of Q2 2023
assurance activities.
November 2023
Governance meeting –
oversight of Q3 2023
assurance activities.
February 2023
Governance meeting
– oversight of Q4
2022 assurance
activities.
May 2023
Governance meeting –
oversight of Q1 2023
assurance activities.
August 2023
Special meeting to
approve the group’s new
external auditors with
effect from the 2026
financial year.
2023
-- 5 of 278 --
Execution of functions
The audit committee has executed its duties and responsibilities
during the 2023 financial year in accordance with its mandate as
it relates to the group’s accounting, internal and external
auditing, compliance, internal control and financial reporting
practices.
During the year under review, the committee, among others,
considered the following:
In respect of the external auditors and the
external audit:
■ Approved the final audit fees for the prior financial year ended
31 December 2022.
■ Considered and recommended the reappointment of
KPMG Inc. and PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. as joint external
auditors for the financial year ended 31 December 2023,
in accordance with all applicable legal requirements.
■ Approved the audit plan and budgeted audit fees for the
financial year ending 31 December 2023 of R482 million. This
budgeted fee comprised R6 million for EY, R174 million for
KPMG and R302 million for PwC.
■ Reviewed and considered the draft engagement letters at the
meeting held in August 2023, and mandated the SBG chief
finance and value management officer to sign the final letter.
The committee noted the final letter at the meeting in October
2023.
■ Reviewed the audit process and evaluated the effectiveness
of the audit, taking into consideration the group finance
function’s assessment of the audit and the respective
audit firms.
■ Reviewed the Independent Regulatory Board for
Auditors’ (IRBA’s) firm inspection reports of both the group’s
external auditors, as it pertained to engagement inspections
conducted by IRBA.
■ Assessed and obtained assurance from the external auditors
that their independence was not impaired.
■ Approved amendments to the non-audit services policy, which
governs the use of the group’s external auditors for non-audit
services.
■ Approved pre-approved proposed contracts with external
auditors to provide non-audit services above an agreed-upon
threshold.
■ Considered the nature and extent of all non-audit services
provided by the external auditors.
■ Monitored that the non-audit service fees, which included audit
related fees, for the year ended 31 December 2023 comprised
R12 million for EY, R3 million for KPMG and R25 million for PwC
and were within the threshold the group audit committee set
for such engagements.
■ Confirmed that no reportable irregularities were identified and
reported by the external auditors in terms of the Auditing
Profession Act 26 of 2005.
In respect of the financial statements:
■ Confirmed the going concern basis for the preparation of the
interim and annual financial statements.
■ Examined and reviewed the interim and annual financial
statements prior to submission to and approval by the board.
■ Reviewed external audit’s report on the adequacy of credit
provisions and impairment tests with respect to assets and
considered feedback from the external auditors regarding the
models applied by management in determining such
impairments.
■ Ensured that the annual financial statements fairly present the
financial position of the company and of the group as at the
end of the financial year and the results of operations and cash
flows for the financial year.
■ Ensured that the interim and annual financial statements
conform with IFRS, the requirements of the JSE Listings
Requirements, the Companies Act and all other applicable
accounting guides and pronouncements.
■ Considered accounting treatments, significant transactions
and accounting judgements.
■ Considered the appropriateness of the accounting policies
adopted and changes to it.
■ Considered and made recommendations to the board on the
interim and final dividend payments to shareholders, with due
consideration of
– the results of solvency and liquidity assessment
– the ability of the company to continue as a going concern.
■ Noted that no material adverse reports were received
concerning accounting practices, internal audit, internal
financial controls, content of annual financial statements,
internal controls and related matters.
■ Reviewed any significant legal and tax matters that could have
a material impact on the financial statements.
■ Reviewed the content of the JSE’s annual proactive monitoring
report, including specific considerations in the preparation of
financial statements.
■ Reviewed and discussed the independent auditors’ report.
As part of the audit committee’s responsibilities, notably its
review of financial results, reports from internal and external
audit, finance and internal financial control reports, the group’s
accounting policies, and the annual financial statements, the
audit committee took cognisance of the key audit matters as
reported in the independent auditors’ report. In addition, the
audit committee reviewed management’s judgements on
significant accounting and external reporting issues and
confirmed external audit’s agreement with the treatment thereof.
4 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Report of the group audit committee continued
-- 6 of 278 --
In respect of financial accounting and
reporting developments:
■ Reviewed management’s process and progress with respect to
new financial accounting and reporting developments.
In respect of external reporting:
■ Recommended the annual reporting suite to the board for
approval.
■ Revaluated management’s judgements and reporting
decisions regarding the annual integrated report and ensured
that all material disclosures had been included.
■ Reviewed both financial and non-financial information,
forward-looking statements and sustainability information.
In respect of internal control and internal
audit:
■ Reviewed and approved the internal audit charter and audit
plan and evaluated the independence, effectiveness and
performance of the internal audit department and compliance
with its charter.
■ Considered reports of the internal and external auditors on the
group’s systems of internal control, including internal financial
controls, and maintenance of effective internal control
systems.
■ Reviewed significant issues raised by the internal audit
processes and the adequacy of corrective action taken in
response to such findings.
■ Assessed the independence and effectiveness of the chief
audit officer and the adequacy of the available internal audit
resources and found them satisfactory.
■ Considered the outcome of the group’s external auditors’
annual assessment of internal audit against the requirements
of International Standards on Auditing (ISA) 601, which
confirmed that the external auditors could place reliance on
internal audit’s work for the purpose of external audit
engagements.
■ Reviewed internal audit’s annual report which summarised the
results and themes observed as part of internal audit’s
activities for the financial year under review and noted internal
audit’s assurance statement that the control environment was
effective to ensure that the degree of risk taken by the group
was at an acceptable level and that internal financial controls
were adequate and effective in ensuring the integrity of
material financial information.
■ Based on the above, the committee formed the opinion that, at
the date of this report, there were no material breakdowns in
internal control, including internal financial controls, resulting
in any material loss to the group.
■ Regularly met with the chief audit officer, the chief compliance
officer, the head of anti-financial crime, the chief financial and
value management officer, management, and the external
auditors.
■ Considered quarterly reports from the group’s internal
financial control committee.
In respect of legal, regulatory and
compliance requirements:
■ Reviewed and approved the compliance mandate and
compliance plan.
■ Reviewed, with management, matters that could have a
material impact on the group.
■ Monitored compliance with the Companies Act, the Banks Act,
JSE Listings Requirements, King IV and other applicable
legislation and regulation, and reviewed reports from internal
audit, compliance and external audit in this regard.
■ Reviewed quarterly compliance and group anti-financial crime
reports.
■ Noted that no complaints were received through the ethics
and fraud hotline concerning accounting matters, internal
audit, internal financial controls, contents of financial
statements, potential violations of the law and questionable
accounting or auditing matters.
In respect of risk management and
information technology:
■ Through the chairman and other group audit committee
members’ membership on the group risk and capital
management committee, as well as interaction with the
chairman of the group risk and capital management
committee, considered risks as they pertained to the control
environment, financial reporting and the going concern
assessment.
■ Considered updates on key internal and external audit findings
in relation to the technology control environment and
intangible assets.
In respect of the coordination of assurance
activities:
■ Reviewed the plans and work outputs of the external and
internal auditors, as well as compliance and the internal
financial control function, and concluded that these were
adequately robust to place reliance on the combined
assurance underlying the statements made in external reports.
■ Considered the expertise, resources and experience of the
finance function and senior members of management
responsible for this function and concluded that these were
appropriate.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 5
-- 7 of 278 --
Independence, skills and expertise
of the external auditors:
The audit committee is satisfied that KPMG Inc. and
PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. are independent of the group
and that KPMG Inc. and PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. and
the partners who are responsible for signing the group’s financial
statements have the requisite skills and expertise. This
conclusion was arrived at, inter alia, after considering the
following factors:
■ The representations made by KPMG Inc. and
PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. to the audit committee,
including confirmation of the firms’ and individual auditors’
accreditation on the JSE List of Auditors.
■ The auditors do not, except as external auditors or in rendering
permitted non-audit services, receive any remuneration or
other benefits from the group.
■ The auditors’ independence was not impaired by any
consultancy, advisory or other work undertaken by the
auditors.
■ The auditors’ independence was not prejudiced as a result of
any previous appointment as auditor.
■ The criteria specified for independence by the Independent
Regulatory Board for Auditors and international regulatory
bodies were met.
In January 2022, the audit committee confirmed the group’s
intent to recommend the appointment of Ernst & Young
Incorporated (EY) as one of the joint auditors for the financial
year ending 31 December 2024. Their appointment is subject to
approval by the South African Reserve Bank’s Prudential
Authority in accordance with section 61 of the Banks Act No. 94
of 1990 as amended. In terms of section 90 of the South African
Companies Act No. 71 of 2008, as well as paragraph 3.86 of the
JSE Listings Requirements, the appointment of EY as a joint
auditor for the 2024 financial year will be recommended to the
ordinary shareholders for approval at the annual general meeting
in 2024.
Following a comprehensive tender process, in October 2023, the
audit committee confirmed the group’s intent to recommend the
appointment of Deloitte as the joint auditor for the financial year
ending 31 December 2026. Similar to EY, Deloitte’s appointment
is also subject to approval by the South African Reserve Bank’s
Prudential Authority and recommendation to the ordinary
shareholders for approval at the relevant annual general meeting.
In conclusion, the audit committee is satisfied that it has fulfilled
its responsibilities and complied with the legal, regulatory, and
governance responsibilities set out in its mandate.
On behalf of the group audit committee:
Trix Kennealy
Group audit committee chairman
6 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Report of the group audit committee continued
-- 8 of 278 --
Nature of business
Standard Bank Group Limited is the holding company for the
interests of the group, which is an African financial services
organisation with South African roots. The group is Africa’s
largest financial services group by assets and currently operates
in 20 countries in sub-Saharan Africa. Our strategic position
enables us to connect Africa to other selected emerging markets
and pools of capital in developed markets.
Headquartered in Johannesburg, South Africa, the group’s
primary listing is on the JSE, with secondary listings on A2X
Markets and the Namibian Stock Exchange (NSX). Subsidiary
entities are listed on exchanges in Kenya, Malawi, Namibia,
Nigeria and Uganda.
Refer to annexure A for a simplified group organogram with principal
subsidiaries.
Group results1
Group headline earnings and headline earnings per share
increased by 27% to R42 948 million (2022: R33 853
million) and 26% to 2 590.4 cents (2022: 2 050.4 cents)
respectively.
Net asset value per share increased to 14 269 cents
(2022: 13 172 cents) and group return on equity increased to
18.8% (2022: 16.3%). Total dividends declared for the year is
1 423 cents per share (2022: 1 206 cents per share), an increase
of 18%.
Share capital and other equity
instruments
Ordinary shares
During 2023, the group allotted 239 847 shares (2022: 367 506)
in terms of the group’s share incentive schemes, notably the
Equity Growth Scheme (EGS) and Group Share Incentive
Scheme (GSIS).
Effective from 2017, the group no longer issues EGS and GSIS
awards. Awards are now provided in terms of the group’s other
share schemes, the Deferred Bonus Scheme (DBS) and the
Share Appreciation Rights Plan (SARP), both of which are settled
by the group to employees with shares that the group purchases
from open market participants, and the Cash-Settled Deferred
Bonus Scheme, which is settled in cash. At the end of the year,
the group would need to issue 529 364 (2022: 1 238 352) SBG
ordinary shares to settle the outstanding GSIS options and EGS
rights that were awarded to participants in previous years. The
shares issued to date for the EGS and GSIS together with the
expected number of shares to settle the outstanding options and
rights as a percentage of the total number of shares in issue is
2.0% (2022: 2.1%).
Refer to annexure D for details on the group’s share incentive
schemes.
Preference shares
During 2023 and 2022, no first preference or second preference
shares were issued or redeemed.
Additional tier 1 capital bonds
The group issued R4.5 billion (2022: R7.2 billion) and redeemed
Rnil (2022: R3.5 billion) Basel III compliant
additional tier 1 (AT1) capital bonds that qualify as tier 1 capital.
Analysis of shareholders
Shareholders at the close of the financial year, holding beneficial
interests in excess of 5% of the company’s issued share capital,
determined from the share register and investigations conducted
on the group’s behalf, were as follows:
% held
2023 2022
Ordinary shares
Industrial and Commercial Bank
of China Limited (ICBC) 19.4 19.4
Government Employees
Pension Fund (PIC) 14.5 14.5
6.5% preference shares
AP Macdonald 14.9 13.1
MT Goulding 12.9 12.9
L Lombard 12.2 12.2
Old Sillery Proprietary Limited 9.1 9.1
JS Castle 10.8 8.0
DJ Saks 7.5 7.5
Non-cumulative
preference shares
Prescient Inc. Provider Fund 8.3 8.3
Directors’ and prescribed officers’ changes
and interest in shares
At the date of this report, no directors or prescribed officers
changed their holding in, directly and indirectly, interests in the
company’s ordinary issued share capital or preference share
capital.
Refer to note 15 for share capital and related disclosures.
Directors’ and prescribed officers’
emoluments and share incentives
Directors’ and prescribed officers’ emoluments, as well as
information relating to the determination of their share incentive
allocations and related matters are contained in annexure E.
Refer to annexure E for details relating to directors’ and prescribed
officers’ emoluments and share incentives.
Group secretary and registered office
The group secretary is Kobus Froneman. The address of the
group secretary is that of the registered office; 9th floor,
Standard Bank Centre, 5 Simmonds Street, Johannesburg, 2001.
Insurance
The group protects itself against financial loss by maintaining
banker’s comprehensive crime and professional indemnity cover.
The insurance terms and conditions are reviewed by the group
insurance committee annually to ensure they are ʻfit-for-purpose’
against the group’s risk exposures.
1 Restated. Refer to page 31 to 39 for the IFRS 17 transition impact.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 7
DIRECTORS’ REPORT
for the year ended 31 December 2023
-- 9 of 278 --
Change in group directorate
The following changes in directorate took place during the year ended 31 December 2023 and up to 14 March 2024:
Apointments
S David-Borha As non-executive director 13 March 2024
Retirements
KD Moroka As non-executive director 12 June 2023
JM Vice As independent non-executive director 12 June 2023
Dividends and coupons
Ordinary share capital and preference share capital
DIVIDENDS AT 31 DECEMBER 2023
Ordinary shares
6.5% cumulative
preference shares
(first preference shares)
Non-redeemable,
non-cumulative,
non-participating
preference shares
(second preference
shares)
JSE Limited (JSE)
Share code SBK SBKP SBPP
ISIN ZAE000109815 ZAE000038881 ZAE000056339
Namibian Stock Exchange (NSX)
Share code SNB
ISIN ZAE000109815
2023
Interim
Dividend number 107 108 38
Gross dividend per share (cents) 690 3.25 422.60421
Record date in respect of the cash
dividend Friday, 15 September 2023 Friday, 8 September 2023 Friday, 8 September 2023
CSDP1/broker account credited/
updated (payment date)
Monday, 18 September
2023
Monday, 11 September
2023
Monday, 11 September
2023
Final
Dividend number 108 109 39
Gross dividend per share (cents) 733 3.25 456.09315
Record date in respect of the
cash dividend Friday, 12 April 2024 Friday, 5 April 2024 Friday, 5 April 2024
CSDP1/broker account credited/updated
(payment date) Monday, 15 April 2024 Monday, 8 April 2024 Monday, 8 April 2024
2022
Interim
Gross dividend per share (cents) 515 3.25 294.55181
Final
Gross dividend per share (cents) 691 3.25 367.70036
1 Central Securities Depository Participant.
Additional tier 1 capital bonds
During 2023, coupons to the value of R1 841 million (2022: R968 million) were paid to AT1 capital bondholders. Current tax of
R497 million (2022: R271 million) relating to the AT1 capital bonds was recognised directly in equity resulting in an aggregate net equity
impact of R1 344 million (2022: R697 million). The AT1 capital bonds have been recognised within other equity instruments in the
statement of financial position.
Refer to note 45 for dividend disclosures.
8 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Directors’ report continued
-- 10 of 278 --
Events during 2023
Structural changes
During 2023, the group has made structural changes to better
serve its clients. Our operating model is client led and
structured around our business units, previously referred to as
segments, namely: Personal & Private Banking (PPB),
Business & Commercial Banking (BCB), Corporate &
Investment Banking (CIB) and Insurance & Asset Management
(IAM). Central and other will remain and house group hedging
activities, unallocated capital, liquidity earnings and central
costs.
PPB, BCB, CIB and Central and other together form Banking.
Banking together with IAM and ICBCS, housing the group’s
interest in ICBC Standard Bank Plc (ICBCS), form Standard
Bank Group.
Business unit reporting evolves to reflect changes in reporting
responsibility for individual cost centres and divisions across
the group. The business unit comparative periods resulted
have been accordingly restated.
As a result of these structural changes and the completion
of the group’s acquisition of the remaining non-controlling
ordinary shares in Liberty Holdings Limited through a scheme
of arrangement during 2022, the group has reviewed the
annual financial statements and, from 2023, reports all notes
and related disclosure on either an aggregated group level, or
at a Banking and/or IAM level, as applicable, where these
disclosures were previously segmented between Standard
Bank activities and investment management and life insurance
activities.
Refer to note 49 for business unit disclosures.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 9
-- 11 of 278 --
Report on the audit of the consolidated
and separate financial statements
Opinion
We have audited the consolidated and separate financial
statements of Standard Bank Group Limited (the Group and
Company), set out on pages 20 to 331 which comprise:
■ the statements of financial position as at 31 December 2023;
■ the income statement for the year then ended;
■ the statement of other comprehensive income for the year
then ended;
■ the statement of comprehensive income for the year then
ended;
■ the statements of cash flows for the year then ended;
■ the statements of changes in equity for the year then ended;
and
■ the notes to the financial statements, including material
accounting policies (Annexure F), accounting policy elections
and restatement, IFRS 17 transition impact, key management
assumptions and Annexures A to E, excluding the section
marked as "unaudited" in Annexure C.
In our opinion, the consolidated and separate financial
statements present fairly, in all material respects, the
consolidated and separate financial position of Standard Bank
Group Limited as at 31 December 2023, and its consolidated and
separate financial performance and consolidated and separate
cash flows for the year then ended in accordance with IFRS
Accounting Standards as issued by the IASB (IFRS Accounting
Standards) and the requirements of the Companies Act of
South Africa.
Basis for opinion
We conducted our audit in accordance with International
Standards on Auditing (ISAs). Our responsibilities under those
standards are further described in the Auditors’ responsibilities for
the audit of the consolidated and separate financial statements
section of our report. We are independent of the Group and
Company in accordance with the Independent Regulatory Board
for Auditors’ Code of Professional Conduct for Registered Auditors
(IRBA Code) and other independence requirements applicable to
performing audits of financial statements in South Africa. We
have fulfilled our other ethical responsibilities in accordance with
the IRBA Code and in accordance with other ethical requirements
applicable to performing audits in South Africa. The IRBA Code is
consistent with the corresponding sections of the International
Ethics Standards Board for Accountants’ International Code of
Ethics for Professional Accountants (including International
Independence Standards). We believe that the audit evidence we
have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for
our opinion.
Key audit matters
Key audit matters are those matters that, in our professional
judgement, were of most significance in our audit of the
consolidated and separate financial statements of the current
period. These matters were addressed in the context of our audit
of the consolidated and separate financial statements as a whole,
and in forming our opinion thereon, and we do not provide a
separate opinion on these matters. We have determined that
there are no key audit matters to communicate in respect of the
separate financial statements.
Level Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter
Group –
consolidated
financial
statements
Expected credit losses on Corporate & Investment Banking (CIB) loans and advances
Refer to the key management assumptions section, note 8 – loans and advances, note 39 – credit impairment charges and
the credit risk section of Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures in the financial statements.
We considered the expected credit losses (“ECL”)
assessment of CIB loans and advances (“CIB
exposures”) to be a matter of most significance to our
current year audit due to:
■ the magnitude of CIB exposures in relation to the
consolidated financial statements,
■ the level of subjective judgement applied by
management in determining the ECL on CIB
exposures and the related disclosures, and
■ the effect that the ECL on CIB exposures has on the
Group’s credit risk management processes and
operations.
The ECL of the Group’s CIB exposures is estimated on
each exposure. For these exposures, the key areas of
significant management judgement in determining the
ECL remains inherently high and includes:
■ Evaluation of Significant Increase in Credit Risk
(“SICR”);
■ Incorporation and assessment of macro-economic
inputs and forward-looking information (“FLI”) into
the SICR assessment and ECL measurement;
■ Assessment of ECL recognised for Stage 3
exposures;
■ Assessment of the input assumptions applied to
estimate the probability of default (“PD”), exposure
at default (“EAD”) and loss given default (“LGD”)
within the ECL measurement; and
■ Disclosures related to ECL of CIB exposures.
With the assistance of our economic, credit and actuarial
experts, we performed the following procedures:
Evaluation of SICR
We selected a sample of counterparties and assessed their
assigned credit ratings by:
■ Testing the inputs into the credit rating systems against the
counterparty’s financial information and the Group’s 25-
point master rating scale; and
■ Assessing management’s assumptions made during the
credit risk rating process for reasonability, by obtaining an
understanding of the counterparty and industry factors,
performing an independent assessment of the counterparty
and comparing the results to those used by management.
We selected a sample of Stage 1 and Stage 2 exposures and
assessed whether the stage classification at the reporting date
of these exposures were appropriate in terms of the Group’s
accounting policy for SICR.
We performed a sensitivity analysis of the SICR and ECL
impacts for counterparties to defined migration threshold as
per the credit policy.
10 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
INDEPENDENT AUDITORS’ REPORT
TO THE SHAREHOLDERS OF STANDARD BANK GROUP LIMITED
-- 12 of 278 --
Level Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter
Group –
consolidated
financial
statements
Expected credit losses on Corporate & Investment Banking (CIB) loans and advances continued
Refer to the key management assumptions section, note 8 – loans and advances, note 39 – credit impairment charges and
the credit risk section of Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures in the financial statements.
Evaluation of SICR
For CIB exposures, SICR is evaluated by comparing the
movement in a client’s credit risk grade at the
reporting date to the credit risk grade assigned at the
origination date. Where the change in credit risk grade
exceeds the pre-defined ratings migration thresholds,
these exposures are classified within Stage 2.
The Group applies judgement in determining the pre-
defined ratings migration thresholds which are based
on historical default experience (which indicates that
higher rated risk exposures are more sensitive to SICR
than lower risk exposures).
Incorporation and assessment of macro-economic
inputs and FLI into the SICR assessment and ECL
measurement
Macro-economic expectations are incorporated in
management’s CIB counterparty ratings to reflect the
Group’s expectation of future economic and business
conditions.
In addition to forward-looking macro-economic
information, other types of FLI, such as specific event
risks and industry data, are taken into account in ECL
estimates when required.
Assessment of ECL raised for Stage 3 exposures
Management applies judgement in its internal credit
risk management approach and definitions to
determine the recoverable amounts (including
collateral) and timing of the future cash flows for Stage
3 exposures at a facility level (per counterparty).
Input assumptions applied to estimate the PD, EAD
and LGD within the ECL measurement
Input assumptions applied to estimate the PD, EAD
and LGD as inputs into the ECL measurement are
subject to management judgement and are determined
at a facility level (per counterparty).
Disclosures related to ECL of CIB exposures
The disclosure associated with the ECL on CIB
exposures rely on material data inputs and explain
management judgements, estimates and assumptions
used in determining the ECL.
Incorporation and assessment of macro-economic inputs
and FLI into the SICR assessment and ECL measurement
We assessed the design and implementation of key controls
focusing on:
■ Generation and approval of the base case economic
scenario;
■ Generation and approval of the methodology and output of
alternative scenarios, including the probability weights
assigned to the scenarios; and
■ Production and approval of models used to calculate the
ECL impact of the scenarios.
We also evaluated the governance processes established by
the Group to review and approve the economic scenarios used
in the determination of the forward-looking impact.
We assessed the reasonableness of management’s multiple
probability weighted scenarios.
We independently assessed the forecasted macro-economic
factors, based on the generated scenarios, and compared it to
independent industry data. This was then used to derive
independent macro-economic adjustments by industry which
were totalled and compared to management’s rating-based
impact.
We evaluated the impact of rating movements in
management’s ECL to assess whether the macro-economic
inputs and forward-looking information are appropriately
incorporated into the ECL models.
Assessment of ECL raised for Stage 3 exposures
Where ECL has been raised for Stage 3 exposures, we
assessed the impairment indicators, uncertainties and
assumptions applied by management in their assessment of
the recoverability of the exposure. For a sample of Stage 3
exposures, we independently recalculated the ECL based on
our assessment of the expected cash flows and recoverability
of collateral at an individual counterparty level.
For collateral held (related to the sample selected above), we
inspected legal agreements or other supporting
documentation to confirm the Group’s legal right to the
collateral.
The collateral valuation techniques applied by management
were assessed against the Group’s valuation guidelines.
Input assumptions applied to estimate the PD, EAD and
LGD within the ECL measurement
We assessed the input assumptions applied within the PD,
EAD and LGD models (including forward looking information)
for compliance with the requirements of IFRS 9 – Financial
Instruments (“IFRS 9”). In addition, our procedures included
assessing the appropriateness of the models through
reperformance and validation procedures.
We obtained an understanding and tested the relevant internal
controls relating to the approval of credit facilities, subsequent
monitoring and remediation of exposures, key system
reconciliations and collateral management.
Disclosures related to ECL of CIB exposures
We assessed the appropriateness of the ECL related
disclosures for CIB exposures in the consolidated financial
statements in accordance with IFRS 7 – Financial Instruments:
Disclosures (“IFRS 7”).
We evaluated whether the credit risk disclosures are
consistent with the ECL information tested which included the
ECL data, models, estimates and macro-economic forecasts.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 11
-- 13 of 278 --
Level Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter
Group –
consolidated
financial
statements
ECL on Personal & Private Banking (PPB) and Business & Commercial Banking (BCB) loans
and advances
Refer to the key management assumptions section, note 8 – loans and advances, note 39 – credit impairment charges and
the credit risk section of Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures in the financial statements.
We considered the ECL assessment of PPB and BCB
loans and advances (“PPB and BCB exposures”) to be
a matter of most significance to our current year audit
due to:
■ the magnitude of PPB and BCB exposures in relation
to the consolidated financial statements;
■ the level of subjective judgement applied by
management in determining the ECL on PPB and
BCB exposures and related disclosures; and
■ the effect that the ECL on PPB and BCB exposures
has on the Group’s credit risk management
processes and operations.
A significant portion of the ECL on PPB and BCB
exposures is calculated on a portfolio basis. For Stage
3 exposures in certain portfolios, management
assesses the recoverability of those exposures
individually. The ECL on PPB and BCB exposures also
include out-of-model adjustments where certain
aspects of the ECL are not fully reflected in the model.
Out-of-model adjustments are calculated and
assessed based on management’s judgement.
For PPB and BCB, the key areas of significant
management judgement within the ECL calculation
include:
■ Evaluation of SICR;
■ Incorporation and assessment of macro-economic
inputs and FLI into the SICR assessment and ECL
measurement;
■ Application of out-of-model adjustments into the
ECL measurement;
■ Assessment of the ECL raised for individual
exposures;
■ Assessment of the input assumptions applied to
estimate the PD, EAD and LGD within the ECL
measurement; and
■ Disclosures related to ECL of PPB and BCB
exposures.
Evaluation of SICR
The Group determines the SICR threshold by utilising
an appropriate transfer rate of exposures that are less
than 30 days past due (“DPD”) to Stage 2. The SICR
thresholds are reviewed regularly to ensure that they
are appropriately calibrated to identify SICR by
portfolio vintage and to consequently facilitate
appropriate impairment coverage.
With the assistance of our economic, credit and actuarial
experts, we performed the following procedures:
Evaluation of SICR
Management provided us with a quantitative assessment of
the Group’s calculation of the impact of SICR against the
requirements of IFRS 9. With the assistance of our internal
modelling specialists, we performed an independent
recalculation of the resultant ECL for a sample of portfolios.
Our internal modelling specialists tested the assumptions and
calculations used in the ECL models.
We evaluated the reasonableness of behavioural scores used
to assess the SICR against the Group’s accounting policies.
We evaluated whether the Group have appropriately classified
exposures in Stages 1, 2 and 3 by considering the Group’s
credit reviews, aging of the exposure and arrears status.
We performed sensitivity analysis and key performance
indicator assessments to determine the impact of changes in
credit risk on the ECL recognised.
Procedures have been performed over the renegotiated and
cured loans to assess whether the curing policies were
appropriately applied as per the requirements of the South
African Reserve Bank (SARB) directives.
Incorporation and assessment of macro-economic inputs
and FLI into the SICR assessment and ECL measurement
We assessed the design and implementation of key controls
focusing on the:
■ Generation and approval of the base case economic
scenario;
■ Generation and approval of the methodology and output of
alternative scenarios, including the probability weights
assigned to the scenarios; and
■ Production and approval of models used to calculate the
ECL impact of the scenarios.
We also evaluated the governance processes established by
the Group put in place to review and approve the economic
scenarios used in the determination of the forward-looking
impact.
With the assistance of our internal economic specialists, we
assessed both the base case and alternative scenarios
generated, including the probability weights applied.
We evaluated the appropriateness of forward-looking
economic expectations included in the ECL by comparing to
independent industry data.
We evaluated management’s forward-looking information
models to assess whether the macro-economic inputs are
appropriately incorporated into the ECL models. We made use
of our internal modelling specialists to assess the linkage of
the forecasted macro-economic factors, based on the
generated scenarios, to the ECL.
12 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Independent auditors’ report continued
-- 14 of 278 --
Level Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter
Group –
consolidated
financial
statements
ECL on Personal & Private Banking (PPB) and Business & Commercial Banking (BCB) loans
and advances continued
Refer to the key management assumptions section, note 8 – loans and advances, note 39 – credit impairment charges and
the credit risk section of Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures in the financial statements.
Incorporation and assessment of macro-economic
inputs and FLI into the SICR assessment and ECL
measurement
Forward-looking economic expectations are included
in the ECL based on the Group’s macro-economic
outlook, using models that correlate these parameters
with macro-economic variables. Where modelled
correlations are not viable or predictive, adjustments
are based on judgement to predict the outcomes
based on the Group’s macro-economic outlook
expectations.
Application of out-of-model adjustments into the
ECL measurement
Management identified that due to modelling
complexity, certain aspects of the ECL may not be fully
reflected by the underlying model and out-of-model
adjustments are therefore required for specific
forward-looking information impacts and overlays for
specific events and trends not captured in the model.
Assessment of ECL raised for individual exposures
Impairment is assessed on individual exposures in
Stage 3, and for accounts placed on the watchlist due
to evidence of increased credit risk e.g., potential
security shortfalls, deteriorating financial performance,
etc. This assessment relates primarily to business
lending accounts and incorporates judgement in
determining the foreclosure value of the underlying
collateral.
Input assumptions applied to estimate the PD, EAD
and LGD within the ECL measurement
The ECL is calculated using statistical models which
incorporate observable data, assumptions and
estimates relating to historical default experience. This
also includes the loss experience given default and the
timing and amount of forecasted cash flows related to
the exposures.
Disclosures related to ECL of PPB and BCB
exposures
The disclosure associated with the ECL on PPB and
BCB exposures rely on material data inputs and explain
management judgements, estimates and assumptions
used in determining the ECL.
Application of out-of-model adjustments into the ECL
measurement
We evaluated the reasonableness of a sample of out-of-model
adjustments through assessment of key assumptions,
inspecting the methodology of calculating the out-of-model
adjustments, tracing a sample of out-of-model adjustments to
source data and comparing them to an independent
recalculation.
Assessment of ECL raised for individual exposures
Where ECL has been raised for individual exposures, we
considered the impairment indicators, uncertainties and
assumptions made by management in their assessment of the
recoverability of the exposure. For a sample of Stage 3
exposures, we independently recalculated the impairment
losses based on our assessment of the expected cash flows
and recoverability of collateral at an individual exposure level.
For collateral held, we inspected legal agreements and other
relevant documentation to confirm the legal right to the
collateral.
The collateral valuation techniques applied by management
were assessed against the Group’s valuation guidelines.
Input assumptions applied to estimate the PD, EAD and
LGD within the ECL measurement
Making use of our economic, credit and actuarial experts, we
assessed the assumptions relating to historical default
experience, estimated timing and amount of forecasted cash
flows and the value of collateral applied within the PD, EAD
and LGD models for compliance with the requirements of IFRS
9. In addition, our procedures included assessing the
appropriateness of the statistical models by reperformance
and validation procedures. We also tested a sample of the
data used in the models for accuracy.
Disclosures related to ECL of PPB and BCB exposures
We assessed the appropriateness of the ECL related
disclosures for PPB and BCB exposures in the consolidated
financial statements in accordance with IFRS 7.
We evaluated whether the credit risk disclosures are
consistent with the ECL information tested which included the
ECL data, models, estimates and macro-economic forecasts.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 13
-- 15 of 278 --
Level Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter
Group –
consolidated
financial
statements
Valuation of level 3 financial instruments
Refer to the key management assumptions section, note 2 – derivative instruments, note 3 – trading assets, note 6 –
financial investments, note 17 – trading liabilities, and the market risk section of Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital
management disclosures in the financial statements.
We considered the fair value of level 3 financial
instruments to be a matter of most significance to our
current year audit due to:
■ the combination of inherent subjectivity and
judgement involved in estimating the fair values of
level 3 financial instruments;
■ the various sources of external and internal data and
the sophisticated modelling techniques used to
value the financial instruments; and
■ the material nature of the balances, the valuation of
level 3 financial instruments and the related
disclosure.
The valuation of level 3 financial instruments inherently
contain elements of estimation uncertainty due to
being illiquid and unobservable in nature. These
financial instruments include unlisted equity
investments, trading assets and liabilities and various
derivative financial instruments.
Significant judgement is required to be exercised by
management due to the absence of observable third-
party information to determine key inputs in the
valuation models. Some of these unobservable key
inputs include:
■ discount rates;
■ spot prices of the underlying instrument;
■ bid-offer spreads;
■ credit spreads;
■ correlation factors;
■ volatilities; and
■ valuation multiples and adjustments to these
multiples.
Level 3 unlisted equity investment valuations use a
variety of valuation techniques and unobservable
inputs such as valuation multiples. These multiples are
adjusted to cater for specific risk factors such as
liquidity and size of ownership of the investments.
The fair value of financial instruments significantly
affects the measurement of the Group’s profit or loss
for the year and the related disclosures of financial
risks in the consolidated financial statements.
Our audit effort focused on the following in respect of the
valuation of level 3 financial instruments:
We tested the design, implementation and operating
effectiveness of the relevant controls relating to the valuation
of level 3 financial instruments to assess whether there is
appropriate governance over the development of the valuation
models and methodology policies, assumptions applied, data
used, model change controls, model validations and the
monthly independent price verification process.
For a sample of level 3 financial instruments, we reperformed
the valuation using an independent model, and compared the
fair value results to management’s valuation to assess the
reasonableness of management’s model methodology and the
output of model calculations.
We assessed the appropriateness and sensitivity of a sample
of inputs into the models that have the most significant impact
on the valuations – these include: discount rates, spot prices
of the underlying instrument, bid-offer spreads, credit
spreads, correlation factors, volatilities, valuation multiples
and adjustments to these multiples with reference to
independent market information.
Where independent market information was not available, we
generated theoretical inputs based on other sources,
incorporating assumptions that include proxy pricing
transactions in the market as well as historical data,
correlations and regressions.
In relation to unlisted equity investments, we assessed the
appropriateness of valuation techniques used and the
reasonableness of unobservable inputs and adjustments to
these inputs used in the determination of fair value through
independently challenging whether valuation adjustments fell
within an acceptable range based on industry knowledge and
available market information.
We assessed the appropriateness of the disclosures in the
consolidated financial statements in accordance with
IFRS 13 – Fair value measurement.
14 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Independent auditors’ report continued
-- 16 of 278 --
Level Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter
Group –
consolidated
financial
statements
Transition from IFRS 4 – Insurance Contracts (“IFRS 4”) to IFRS 17 – Insurance Contracts
(“IFRS 17”)
Refer to the key management assumptions section and the IFRS 17 transition impact section
We considered the transition from IFRS 4 to IFRS 17 to
be a matter of most significance to our current year’s
audit due to the following:
■ Judgement applied in assessing the Group’s election
and application of the transition approaches as set
out in IFRS 17.
■ The magnitude of the restated IFRS 17 balances (as
referenced in the IFRS 17 transition impact note to
the consolidated financial statements) in relation to
the total assets and total liabilities of the Group.
In adopting IFRS 17, which became effective on
1 January 2023, the Group restated its insurance
contract balances previously recognised in terms of
IFRS 4. The Group calculated the opening balances on
the transition to IFRS 17 at the transition date, being
1 January 2022.
The full retrospective approach was applied for all
contracts measured under the Premium Allocation
Approach (PAA). For contracts measured under the
General Measurement Model (GMM) or the Variable
Fee Approach (VFA), the full retrospective approach
has been applied for the majority of contracts
recognised from 1 January 2017 onwards.
In respect of contracts entered into prior to
1 January 2017, the Group concluded that it was
impracticable to apply the full retrospective approach.
As a result, the Group has applied either the fair value
approach or modified retrospective approaches for
these contracts as permitted by IFRS 17.
The details of these approaches are set out below:
Fair value approach (FVA)
The fair value approach was used to determine the
transition contractual service margin (CSM) or loss
component (LC). The Group used an income approach
(using a discounted cash flow method), which is based
on future cash flows from a group of insurance
contracts that are discounted to a single current
amount. The Group assumed that the purchaser of a
group of insurance contracts would be required to hold
additional regulatory capital to support these
contracts, therefore included a price adjustment for
the cost of capital required, using a Return on Equity
(ROE) assumption of 20%.
Modified retrospective approach
For the modified retrospective approach, the Group
made use of information and permitted modifications
that would have been used to apply the full
retrospective approach to estimate the value for
fulfilment cash flows (FCF) and the risk adjustment
(RA) at inception to determine the CSM.
We performed the following procedures over the Group’s
accounting for the transition from IFRS 4 to IFRS 17:
■ Assessed the key management assumptions for the
valuation of insurance contracts on the transition date taking
into account the Group’s governance process followed.
■ Assessed and challenged the Group’s justification for
impracticability and its election of the fair value or modified
retrospective transition approaches for the contracts
entered into prior to 1 January 2017.
Using our actuarial experts, we tested the Group’s transition
approaches by performing the following procedures:
■ Obtained an understanding of the valuation methodologies
selected and models used by the Group for transition and
applied our industry knowledge and experience to evaluate
whether the methodologies and models are appropriate.
■ Obtained an understanding of the Group’s judgements in
determining the approaches for transition, the level of
aggregation of groups of insurance contracts and the
measurement of FCF.
■ Evaluated the buildup of the probability-weighted estimate of
future cash flows (BEL) measured under the South African
regulatory capital framework (i.e., SAM) to the IFRS 17
liability for remaining coverage (LRC) BEL at a product level
as at the transition date as well as sample tested across the
full retrospective transition years (i.e., 2017 to 2021). This
was sample tested at a group and cohort level, for new
business and subsequent measurement, across all
measurement models.
■ Evaluated the RA calculations including a comparison of the
SAM risk margin to the IFRS 17 RA buildup as at the
transition date as well as sampled across the full
retrospective transition years (i.e., 2017 to 2021). This was
sample tested at group and cohort level, for new business
and subsequent measurement.
■ The CSM and LC calculations were tested on a sample basis
for the different calculation methodologies across the
transition years (2017 to 2021), which includes:
– New business
– Subsequent measurement of the CSM for insurance
contracts measured under the GMM and VFA.
■ We evaluated the modified retrospective models calculations
up to 2017.
■ In respect of the fair value approach, we tested the Group’s
Return on Equity (ROE) assumption relative to RoE’s
previously published by the largest market participants in
South Africa. We also considered the appropriateness of the
RoE being within but at the upper bound of this range by
considering the nature of the products being valued under
FVA which may call for the acquirer to hold more capital or
achieve a higher RoE.
■ Through inspection of underlying documentation, we tested
the application of the policy and methodology decisions for
a sample of contract classifications and CSM groupings,
including an assessment of the coverage unit model.
We performed the following procedures to assess the
accuracy, completeness and classification in respect of the
Group’s IFRS 17 transition numbers:
■ Evaluated the accuracy of the recognition and measurement
of insurance contracts against the Group’s accounting
policies.
■ Evaluated the Group’s manual controls to address accuracy,
completeness and classification of the information.
■ With the assistance of our IT specialists, we performed tests
of details on a sample basis on the data, rules applied in the
data transformation and the extraction and mapping of
information to the relevant financial statement line items.
We reconciled a sample of the relevant data sources to the
previous years’ audited information to test the consistency of
information used.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 15
-- 17 of 278 --
Group –
consolidated
financial
statements
Valuation of insurance contract liabilities
Refer to the key management assumptions section, note 9.2 – insurance contract assets and liabilities and section 12 of
Annexure F - material accounting policies.
We considered the valuation of insurance contract
liabilities to be a matter of most significance to our
current year’s audit due to the following:
■ Significant management judgement applied in
determining the value of insurance contract
liabilities.
■ The magnitude of the insurance contract liabilities
in relation to the total liabilities of the Group.
As at 31 December 2023, insurance contract
liabilities with a carrying amount of R251 billion was
recognised in the consolidated statement of financial
position. These liabilities were measured in
accordance with IFRS 17 – Insurance Contracts
(“IFRS 17”).
The valuation of insurance contract liabilities
includes the use of significant assumptions and
estimates, regarding future cash flows (FCFs),
discount rates, risk adjustment for non-financial risk
and confidence level as disclosed in the key
management assumptions section to the financial
statements. Any changes to these assumptions, may
result in a material adjustment to the value of
insurance contract liabilities and ultimately the
results of the Group.
IFRS 17 requires probability-weighted cash flows and
that FCFs reflect the perspective of the entity. The
assumptions applied in the determination of the
probability-weighted cash flows and FCFs include
mortality, morbidity, withdrawals, investment return,
expenses, taxation, and expense inflation.
Our audit addressed this key audit matter as follows:
Using our actuarial experts, we assessed the reasonableness of
the valuation of insurance contract liabilities, by performing the
following procedures:
■ We updated our understanding of the actuarial control
environment and governance given the adoption of IFRS 17 in
the current year, including the process for approving the
methodology, assumptions and the valuation results as it
relates to the valuation of insurance contract liabilities.
■ We evaluated the reasonableness of the accounting
considerations and methodology including the application of
management’s assumptions and methodologies against the
Group’s accounting policies, key management assumptions
and the requirements of IFRS 17.
■ We evaluated management’s controls over the valuation of
insurance contract liabilities, which include check and
challenge by management through their own internal review
processes, explanations and analysis of valuation results.
■ We assessed the reasonability of management’s Analysis of
Surplus by analysing the sources of profit and how it relates to
the change in insurance contract liabilities.
■ On a sample basis, we tested the methodologies and
assumptions (non-economic and economic) used in the
insurance contract valuation.
■ We tested the methodology and assumptions applied to
determine the liability for incurred claims (LIC), including the
risk adjustment (RA) and expected claims handling expenses
to settle the LIC.
■ We evaluated the FCF, RA and contractual service margin
(CSM) buildups and assessed movements in the insurance
contract valuations for reasonability.
■ Identified and tested the unit-linked liabilities for contracts
with non-distinct investment components (NDICs) on a
sample basis.
■ Assessed and tested the Group’s methodology applied in
determining directly attributable acquisition costs and
fulfilment cash flows in the valuation of insurance contracts.
■ Assessed the profitability group allocations for new business
and whether there are any unallocated CSM balances or
cohorts.
■ Tested that appropriate discount rates have been applied,
including locked-in discount rates for determining the interest
accretion on the CSM.
■ Assessed the impact of changes to discount rates due to
changes in assets backing insurance liabilities and credit risk
adjustments.
■ Utilised our actuarial tools to independently test on a sample
basis the CSM and its release/amortisation.
■ Assessed the reasonability of experience variances and
assumption changes to adjust the CSM.
Together with our IT specialists, we evaluated the design and
implementation and operating effectiveness of relevant key
controls over the completeness and accuracy of data or data
changes and data transformation. To test the data inputs used in
the valuation models, we performed the following procedures on
a sample basis:
■ Tested the classification of expenses as directly or indirectly
attributable and inspected the source document relating to
the expenses.
■ Traced the policyholder valuation input data, such as
premiums and claims used in the valuation model back to
information contained in the policyholder administration
systems.
Level Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter
16 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Independent auditors’ report continued
-- 18 of 278 --
Group –
consolidated
financial
statements
Valuation of investment property
Refer to the key management assumptions section and note 11 – investment property
We considered the valuation of investment property
as a matter of most significance to our current year
audit due to the:
■ Inherent subjectivity of the key assumptions that
underpin the valuation of investment property;
and
■ Magnitude of the investment property balance
recorded in the consolidated statement of
financial position.
The majority of the Group’s investment property
comprise retail investment property.
At 31 December 2023, the carrying value of the
Group’s total investment property was R30.4 billion.
The Group’s accounting policy is to measure
investment property at their fair value based on
external valuations performed by external valuers
using the discounted cash flow and profit
methodologies.
The inputs made by management in determining
the fair value of the investment properties are set out
in the key management assumptions section in the
consolidated financial statements and include
amongst others the key assumptions relating to
cash flow forecasts, exit capitalisation rates and
discount rates.
We performed the following procedures in relation to the
valuation of the investment property:
■ We obtained an understanding of the approach followed by
management and the external valuers for the valuation of the
Group’s investment property portfolio through discussions
with management and the external valuers, as well as
inspection of minutes of meetings of the board of directors.
■ We have evaluated the external valuer by assessing their
competence, independence, and capabilities with reference to
their qualifications and industry experience.
We obtained an understanding of, and tested the relevant
internal financial controls relating to the valuation of investment
property, which included:
■ Controls in relation to the entering and renewal of leases in
support of contractual rental income which forms the basis
for the cash flows used in the valuation models;
■ Setting and approval of budgets; and
■ Review of the external valuation reports by a management
appointed internal valuer.
■ Board approval of the valuations obtained.
We performed the following procedures on a risk-based sample
of the investment property, in order to assess the acceptability
of the valuation approach as well as the reasonableness of the
inputs into the valuation:
■ We inspected the valuation reports and assessed whether the
valuation approach for each of these properties was suitable
for use in determining the fair value for the purpose of the
consolidated financial statements.
■ We assessed the reasonableness of the cash flows of each of
these properties used by the external valuers in the valuation
models. This involved:
– Agreeing the current year cash flows used in the model to
the actual results for the year ended 31 December 2023.
– Assessing the assumptions used in the preparation of the
forecasted cash flows against market information.
■ Making use of our internal valuation expertise where
necessary, we evaluated the significant assumptions,
including discount rates and exit capitalisation rates, against
appropriate market information in order to assess whether
they were within a reasonable range for the respective
market, sector and asset.
■ Based on the outcome of the evaluation of the significant
assumptions (as noted above) we assessed the reasonability
of the fair value of the sample of investment property.
We inspected the external valuers valuation report and agreed the
values of the respective investment property to the Group’s
accounting records.
Level Key audit matter How our audit addressed the key audit matter
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 17
-- 19 of 278 --
Other information
The directors are responsible for the other information. The other
information comprises the information included in the document
titled “Standard Bank Group Annual financial statements for the
year ended 31 December 2023” which includes the Group
secretary’s certification, Report of the group audit committee
and the Directors’ report as required by the Companies Act of
South Africa, which we obtained prior to the date of this report,
and the document titled “Standard Bank Group Annual
Integrated Report 2023” which is expected to be made available
to us after that date. The other information does not include the
consolidated and separate financial statements and our auditors’
report thereon (but includes the sections marked as ʻunaudited’
in Annexure C).
Our opinion on the consolidated and separate financial
statements does not cover the other information and we do not
and will not express an audit opinion or any form of assurance
conclusion thereon.
In connection with our audit of the consolidated and separate
financial statements, our responsibility is to read the other
information and, in doing so, consider whether the other
information is materially inconsistent with the consolidated and
separate financial statements or our knowledge obtained in the
audit, or otherwise appears to be materially misstated. If, based
on the work we have performed on the other information that we
obtained prior to the date of this auditors’ report, we conclude
that there is a material misstatement of this other information,
we are required to report that fact. We have nothing to report in
this regard.
Responsibilities of the directors for the
consolidated and separate financial
statements
The directors are responsible for the preparation and fair
presentation of the consolidated and separate financial
statements in accordance with IFRS Accounting Standards and
the requirements of the Companies Act of South Africa, and for
such internal control as the directors determine is necessary to
enable the preparation of consolidated and separate financial
statements that are free from material misstatement, whether
due to fraud or error.
In preparing the consolidated and separate financial statements,
the directors are responsible for assessing the Group and
Company’s ability to continue as a going concern, disclosing, as
applicable, matters related to going concern and using the going
concern basis of accounting unless the directors either intend to
liquidate the Group and/or the Company or to cease operations,
or have no realistic alternative but to do so.
Auditors’ responsibilities for the audit of
the consolidated and separate financial
statements
Our objectives are to obtain reasonable assurance about whether
the consolidated and separate financial statements as a whole
are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or
error, and to issue an auditors’ report that includes our opinion.
Reasonable assurance is a high level of assurance but is not a
guarantee that an audit conducted in accordance with ISAs will
always detect a material misstatement when it exists.
Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and are considered
material if, individually or in the aggregate, they could reasonably
be expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken
on the basis of these consolidated and separate financial
statements.
As part of an audit in accordance with ISAs, we exercise
professional judgement and maintain professional scepticism
throughout the audit. We also:
■ Identify and assess the risks of material misstatement of the
consolidated and separate financial statements, whether due
to fraud or error, design and perform audit procedures
responsive to those risks, and obtain audit evidence that is
sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion.
The risk of not detecting a material misstatement resulting
from fraud is higher than for one resulting from error, as fraud
may involve collusion, forgery, intentional omissions,
misrepresentations, or the override of internal control.
■ Obtain an understanding of internal control relevant to the
audit in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate
in the circumstances, but not for the purpose of expressing an
opinion on the effectiveness of the Group’s and the Company’s
internal control.
■ Evaluate the appropriateness of accounting policies used and
the reasonableness of accounting estimates and related
disclosures made by the directors.
■ Conclude on the appropriateness of the directors’ use of the
going concern basis of accounting and, based on the audit
evidence obtained, whether a material uncertainty exists
related to events or conditions that may cast significant doubt
on the Group and the Company’s ability to continue as a going
concern. If we conclude that a material uncertainty exists, we
are required to draw attention in our auditors’ report to the
related disclosures in the consolidated and separate financial
statements or, if such disclosures are inadequate, to modify
our opinion. Our conclusions are based on the audit evidence
obtained up to the date of our auditors’ report. However,
future events or conditions may cause the Group and/or the
Company to cease to continue as a going concern.
■ Evaluate the overall presentation, structure and content of the
consolidated and separate financial statements, including the
disclosures, and whether the consolidated and separate
financial statements represent the underlying transactions and
events in a manner that achieves fair presentation.
■ Obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence regarding the
financial information of the entities or business activities within
the Group to express an opinion on the consolidated financial
statements. We are responsible for the direction, supervision
and performance of the group audit. We remain solely
responsible for our audit opinion.
18 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Independent auditors’ report continued
-- 20 of 278 --
We communicate with the directors regarding, among other
matters, the planned scope and timing of the audit and
significant audit findings, including any significant deficiencies in
internal control that we identify during our audit.
We also provide the directors with a statement that we have
complied with relevant ethical requirements regarding
independence, and to communicate with them all relationships
and other matters that may reasonably be thought to bear on our
independence, and where applicable, actions taken to eliminate
threats or safeguards applied.
From the matters communicated with the directors, we
determine those matters that were of most significance in the
audit of the consolidated and separate financial statements of
the current period and are therefore the key audit matters. We
describe these matters in our auditors’ report unless law or
regulation precludes public disclosure about the matter or when,
in extremely rare circumstances, we determine that a matter
should not be communicated in our report because the adverse
consequences of doing so would reasonably be expected to
outweigh the public interest benefits of such communication.
Report on other legal and regulatory
requirements
In terms of the IRBA Rule published in Government Gazette
Number 39475 dated 4 December 2015, we report that
KPMG Inc. and PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. have been the
joint auditors of Standard Bank Group Limited for 61 years.
PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc. KPMG Inc.
Director: Johannes Grosskopf Director: Joelene Pierce
Registered Auditor Registered Auditor
Johannesburg Johannesburg
13 March 2024 13 March 2024
4 Lisbon Lane KPMG Crescent
Waterfall City 85 Empire Road
Jukskei View Parktown
2090 2193
South Africa South Africa
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 19
-- 21 of 278 --
Group
Note
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
1 January 2022
Restated1
Rm
Assets
Cash and balances with central banks 1 137 787 114 483 91 169
Derivative assets 2 97 419 74 410 63 688
Trading assets 3 316 515 314 918 285 020
Pledged assets 4 20 210 19 308 14 178
Disposal group assets held for sale 5 235 555 1 025
Financial investments 6 758 776 722 494 726 129
Receivables and other assets2 7 33 482 39 647 29 215
Current tax assets 783 757 709
Loans and advances 8 1 608 846 1 504 940 1 424 328
Reinsurance contract assets 9 5 422 5 522 5 902
Insurance contract assets 9 1 631 1 830 1 264
Interest in associates and joint ventures 10 12 173 9 956 7 280
Investment property 11 30 444 29 289 29 985
Property, equipment and right of use assets 12 20 298 20 340 20 619
Goodwill and other intangible assets 13 12 723 15 120 16 909
Deferred tax assets 14 9 001 8 828 6 907
Total assets 3 065 745 2 882 397 2 724 327
Equity and liabilities
Equity 276 920 258 866 242 891
Equity attributable to ordinary shareholders 236 445 218 197 198 873
Ordinary share capital 15 168 168 162
Ordinary share premium 15 26 938 27 341 17 859
Reserves 209 339 190 688 180 852
Equity attributable to other equity instrument holders 24 167 19 667 16 052
Preference share capital and premium 15 5 503 5 503 5 503
Additional tier 1 capital 15 18 664 14 164 10 549
Equity attributable to non-controlling interests 16 308 21 002 27 966
Liabilities 2 788 825 2 623 531 2 481 436
Derivative liabilities 2 103 373 85 049 67 259
Trading liabilities 17 94 468 109 928 81 484
Disposal group liabilities held for sale2 5 96
Provisions and other liabilities2 18 144 594 129 887 145 285
Current tax liabilities 8 063 7 842 7 557
Deposits and debt funding 19 2 001 646 1 889 099 1 776 615
Financial liabilities under investment contracts 9 151 035 136 309 136 622
Insurance contract liabilities 9 251 389 231 849 233 730
Subordinated debt 20 32 227 31 744 30 430
Deferred tax liabilities 14 2 030 1 824 2 358
Total equity and liabilities 3 065 745 2 882 397 2 724 327
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 During 2023, the group reassessed the order of liquidity within the statement of financial position and moved receivables and other assets, previously referred to as
other assets, above the current tax asset line as well as provisions and other liabilities and disposal group liabilities held for sale to above the current tax liability line on
the face of the statement of financial position as these items were found to be more liquid than those that follow them in the above presentation. This had no impact on
the associated amounts within these line items. The reorder has also been applied to the prior year and notes where the line items are listed.
20 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION
as at 31 December 2023
-- 22 of 278 --
Group
Note
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Net interest income 98 188 78 391
Interest income2 26 193 290 134 875
Interest expense 26 (95 102) (56 484)
Non-interest revenue 62 003 54 965
Net fee and commission revenue 35 187 32 621
Fee and commission revenue 27 44 849 41 440
Fee and commission expense 27 (9 662) (8 819)
Trading revenue 28 20 617 17 046
Other revenue 29 3 464 2 860
Other gains and losses on financial instruments 30 2 735 2 438
Net insurance (loss)/income (17 753) 3 178
Insurance service result 8 216 8 302
Net insurance service result before reinsurance contracts held 8 964 8 071
Insurance revenue 31 38 778 35 717
Insurance service expense 32 (29 814) (27 646)
Net (expense)/income from reinsurance contracts held 33 (748) 231
Net insurance finance expenses (25 969) (5 124)
Net finance expenses from insurance contracts issued 34 (26 280) (5 232)
Net finance income from reinsurance contracts held 35 311 108
Non-insurance revenue 35 178 11 583
Investment and other income 36 8 517 7 516
Interest income on financial assets using the effective interest method 37 2 967 2 105
Fair value adjustments to financial assets, investment contract liabilities and third-party mutual
funds 38 23 694 1 962
Total net income3 177 616 148 117
Credit impairment charges2 39 (16 261) (13 343)
Net income before operating expenses 161 355 134 774
Operating expenses4 40 (94 749) (83 533)
Net income before capital items and equity accounted earnings 66 606 51 241
Non-trading and capital related items 41 1 487 328
Share of post tax profit from associates and joint ventures 10 1 648 2 265
Profit before indirect taxation 69 741 53 834
Indirect taxation 42 (3 373) (3 077)
Profit before direct taxation 66 368 50 757
Direct taxation 42 (16 065) (11 717)
Profit for the year 50 303 39 040
Attributable to ordinary shareholders 44 211 34 243
Attributable to other equity instrument holders 1 762 999
Attributable to non-controlling interests 4 330 3 798
Earnings per share
Basic earnings per ordinary share (cents) 43 2 666.6 2 074.1
Diluted earnings per ordinary share (cents) 43 2 635.0 2 059.0
1 Restated. Refer to pages 30 to 39 for further details relating to the restatement and IFRS 17 transition and restatement impact.
2 Restated. Refer to page 30 for details relating to the restatement.
3 Previously referred to as total income. Updated to reflect the nature of the sub total being a net amount.
4 Operating expenses has been aggregated to be disclosed at a group level in line with IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements (IAS 1).
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 21
INCOME STATEMENT
for the year ended 31 December 2023
-- 23 of 278 --
Group
Note
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Profit for the year 50 303 39 040
Other comprehensive (loss) after taxation for the year2 (8 165) (3 616)
Items that may be subsequently reclassified to profit or loss (8 266) (3 014)
Exchange differences on translating foreign operations3 (9 302) (3 161)
Foreign currency hedge of net investment reserve 2 5 32
Movement in the total hedge reserve 2 802 235
Net change in fair value of cash flow hedges 407 (151)
Realised fair value adjustments transferred to profit or loss 395 386
Net change in fair value of debt financial assets measured at fair value through other
comprehensive income (FVOCI) 22 229 (120)
Net change in expected credit loss (ECL) 142 (77)
Net change in fair value 70 (45)
Realised fair value adjustments transferred to profit or loss 17 2
Items that may not be subsequently reclassified to profit or loss 101 (602)
Defined benefit fund remeasurement (37) (336)
Change in own credit risk recognised on financial liabilities designated at fair value
through profit or loss (FVTPL) 22 (24)
Net change in fair value of equity financial assets measured at FVOCI 22 30 (28)
Other 86 (214)
Total comprehensive income for the year 42 138 35 424
Attributable to ordinary shareholders 39 873 30 817
Attributable to other equity instrument holders 1 762 999
Attributable to non-controlling interests 503 3 608
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 Income tax relating to each component of other comprehensive income (OCI) is disclosed in note 42.
3 Most significant contributors for 2023 comprises of Africa Regions operations and International operations. Refer to annexure A for more detail.
22 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
STATEMENT OF OTHER COMPREHENSIVE
INCOME
for the year ended 31 December 2023
-- 24 of 278 --
Group
Note
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Net cash flows from operating activities 48 698 65 287
Cash flows from operations 125 944 71 152
Interest, commission and premium receipts1 352 924 282 268
Interest payments (94 183) (56 788)
Recoveries on loans previously written off 821 1 287
Cash payments to suppliers and employees 46 (133 618) (155 615)
Net movement in operating assets and liabilities (63 744) 6 080
Increase in operating assets2 46 (201 553) (160 796)
Increase in operating liabilities2 46 137 809 166 876
Dividends received 2 389 1 875
Direct taxation paid (15 891) (13 820)
Net cash flows used in investing activities (6 051) (4 600)
Capital expenditure on property and equipment (5 522) (3 695)
Proceeds from sale of property, equipment and non-current asset held for sale 438 314
Capital expenditure on intangible assets (817) (1 142)
Proceeds from sale of intangible asset 114 54
Acquisition of associates and joint ventures (346) (153)
Proceeds from sale of associates and joint ventures 82 26
Net cash flows used in investing activities in disposal group (4)
Net cash flows used in financing activities (26 796) (21 255)
Issuance of ordinary share capital 40 58
Redemption of ordinary share capital (443)
Issuance of other equity instruments 4 500 7 159
Redemption of other equity instruments (3 544)
Equity transactions with non-controlling interests3 (1 223) (3 000)
Release of empowerment reserve 36
Issuance of subordinated debt 46 5 639 3 425
Redemption of subordinated debt 46 (5 900) (2 263)
Principal lease repayments 18 (1 517) (1 529)
Dividends paid 4,5 (27 892) (21 597)
Effect of exchange rate changes on cash and cash equivalents (16 903) (5 960)
Net increase in cash and cash equivalents (1 052) 33 472
Cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the year 206 241 172 769
Cash and cash equivalents at the end of the year 46 205 189 206 241
1 Included in interest, commission and premium receipts is an amount of R190 398 million (2022: R132 046) that relates to interest received.
2 Restated due to IFRS 17 transition, please refer to Note 46.1 and note 46.2 for further detail". This is because the "financial liabilities under investment contracts" in note
46.2 is a new line due IFRS 17.
3 Equity transactions with non-controlling interests primarily relate to the group’s acquisition of its remaining shareholding in Liberty Holdings Limited during 2022.
Refer to annexure A for more detail.
4 Cash flows to non-controlling interests primarily comprise of dividends paid to non-controlling interests.
5 For details on dividends paid to AT1 capital bondholders and the impact on equity and tax paid, refer to note 15.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 23
STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS
for the year ended 31 December 2023
-- 25 of 278 --
GROUP Note
Ordinary
share
capital
and
premium
Rm
Treasury
shares
Rm
Foreign
currency
translation
reserve
Rm
Foreign
currency
hedge
of net
investment
reserve
Rm
Total
hedge
reserve1
Rm
Regulatory
statutory
credit risk
reserve
Rm
Fair value
through
OCI
reserve2
Rm
Own
credit risk
reserve
Rm
Share-
based
payment
reserve
Rm
Other
reserves
Rm
Retained
earnings
Rm
Ordinary
share-
holders’
equity
Rm
Other
equity
instrument
holders3
Rm
Non-
con-
trolling
interests
Rm
Total
equity
Rm
Balance at 1 January 2023 – restated4 27 509 (3 461) (4 716) (950) 90 6 153 226 (23) 2 636 151 190 582 218 197 19 667 21 002 258 866
Total comprehensive income for the year (5 406) 5 802 259 22 44 191 39 873 1 762 503 42 138
Profit for the year 44 211 44 211 1 762 4 330 50 303
Other comprehensive (loss)/income for the year (5 406) 5 802 259 22 (20) (4 338) (3 827) (8 165)
Increase in statutory credit risk reserve 795 (795)
Unincorporated property partnerships capital
reductions and distributions5 (201) (201)
Transactions with shareholders and
non-controlling interests recorded directly in
equity (403) 479 586 (22 287) (21 625) 2 738 (4 996) (23 883)
Equity-settled share-based payment transactions 2 559 (2 347) 212 212
Transfer of vested equity options (1 973) 1 973
Issue of share capital and share premium and
other equity instruments 15 40 40 4 500 4 540
Repurchase of share capital and share premium
and other equity instruments 15 (443) (443) (443)
Deferred tax on share-based payment transactions 309 309 309
Transactions with non-controlling interests 484 484 (2 525) (2 041)
Decrease/(increase) in treasury shares 479 (186) 293 293
Hyperinflation adjustments 641 641 1 642
Redemption of preference shares
Net dividends paid (23 161) (23 161) (1 762) (2 472) (27 395)
Dividends paid to equity holders 45 (23 161) (23 161) (1 762) (2 295) (27 218)
Dividends received from Tutuwa initiative and
policyholders' deemed treasury shares (177) (177)
Balance at 31 December 2023 27 106 (2 982) (10 122) (945) 892 6 948 485 (1) 3 222 151 211 691 236 445 24 167 16 308 276 920
1 The total hedge reserve includes cash flow hedges as well as the foreign currency basis spread and forward element. Refer to note 2.3.6 for more detail.
2 The FVOCI reserve comprises of the FVOCI reserve for debt and equity financial investment. Refer to note 22 for more detail.
3 Other equity holders are holders of preference share capital and AT1 capital. For details on dividends paid to other equity holders refer to note 45.
4 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
5 Where the group owns a majority stake in certain property partnerships and controls the management of those properties, including the power over all significant decisions
around the use and maintenance of those properties, they are classified as businesses and the group consolidates its interest in those property partnerships.
All balances are stated net of tax, where applicable.
Details relating to each reserve are provided in the accounting policies
detailed in annexure F.
24 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 25
STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN EQUITY
for the year ended 31 December 2023
-- 26 of 278 --
GROUP Note
Ordinary
share
capital
and
premium
Rm
Empower-
ment
reserve
Rm
Treasury
shares
Restated7
Rm
Foreign
currency
translation
reserve
Rm
Foreign
currency
hedge
of net
investment
reserve
Rm
Total
hedge
reserve1
Rm
Regulatory
statutory
credit risk
reserve
Rm
Fair value
through
OCI
reserve2
Rm
Own
credit risk
reserve
Rm
Share-
based
payment
reserve
Rm
Other
reserves
Rm
Retained
earnings
Restated7
Rm
Ordinary
share-
holders’
equity
Restated7
Rm
Other
equity
instrument
holders3
Rm
Non-
controlling
interests
Restated7
Rm
Total
equity
Restated7
Rm
Balance at 1 January 2022 – as
previously reported 18 021 (61) (3 199) (1 603) (982) (102) 5 675 486 55 1 650 121 178 771 198 832 16 052 27 965 242 849
Adjustment on initial application of
IFRS 177 840 (799) 41 1 42
Balance at 1 January 2022,
restated7 18 021 (61) (2 359) (1 603) (982) (102) 5 675 — 486 55 1 650 121 177 972 198 873 16 052 27 966 242 891
Total comprehensive (loss)/
income for the year – restated7 — — — (3 197) 32 235 — (268) (24) — (4) 34 043 30 817 999 3 608 35 424
Profit for the year 34 243 34 243 999 3 798 39 040
Other comprehensive (loss)/
income for the year (3 197) 32 235 (268) (24) (4) (200) (3 426) (190) (3 616)
Increase in statutory credit risk
reserve 477 (477) — —
Unincorporated property
partnerships capital reductions
and distributions4 (196) (196)
Transactions with shareholders
and non-controlling interests
recorded directly in equity 9 488 61 (1 102) 84 — (43) 1 8 (54) 986 34 (20 956) (11 493) 2 616 (10 376) (19 253)
Equity-settled share-based payment
transactions5 1 670 (1 330) 340 (285) 55
Transfer of vested equity options (940) 940 — 8 8
Issue of share capital and share
premium and other equity
instruments 15 9 488 9 488 7 159 16 647
Repurchase of share capital and
share premium and other equity
instruments 15 (3 544) (3 544)
Deferred tax on share-based
payment transactions 59 59 59
Transactions with non-controlling
interests 25 (945) 84 (43) 1 8 (54) 256 34 (3 793) (4 427) (6 883) (11 310)
Transactions with non-controlling
interests – restatement 945 (892) 53 53
Net (increase)/decrease in treasury
shares (475) 109 (366) (366)
Net (increase)/decrease in treasury
shares – restatement (627) (41) (668) (668)
Redemption of preference shares 36 36 36
Hyperinflation adjustments6 1 203 1 203 (1) 1 202
Net dividends paid — — — — — — — — — — — (17 211) (17 211) (999) (3 215) (21 425)
Dividends paid to equity holders 45 (17 217) (17 217) (999) (3 215) (21 431)
Dividends received from Tutuwa
initiative 6 6 6
Balance at 31 December 2022 –
restated7 27 509 — (3 461) (4 716) (950) 90 6 153 226 (23) 2 636 151 190 582 218 197 19 667 21 002 258 866
1 The total hedge reserve includes cash flow hedges as well as the foreign currency basis spread and forward element. Refer to note 2.3.6.
2 The FVOCI reserve comprises of the FVOCI reserve for debt and equity financial investment. Refer to note 22 for more detail.
3 Other equity holders are holders of preference share capital and AT1 capital. For details on dividends paid to other equity holders refer to note 45.
4 Where the group owns a majority stake in certain property partnerships and controls the management of those properties, including the power over all significant decisions
around the use and maintenance of those properties, they are classified as businesses and the group consolidates its interest in those property partnerships.
5 Includes hedges of the group’s equity-settled share incentive schemes.
6 Comprises of the hyperinflation adjustments primarily from Zimbabwe. Refer to annexure A for more details.
7 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
All balances are stated net of tax, where applicable.
Details relating to each reserve are provided in the accounting policies
detailed in annexure F.
26 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Statement of changes in equity continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 27
-- 27 of 278 --
The material accounting policies applied in the presentation of
the group and company’s annual financial statements are set out
below. The accounting policy elections below apply to the group
and company, unless otherwise stated.
Basis of preparation
The group’s consolidated and company’s separate annual
financial statements are prepared in accordance with the IFRS
Accounting Standards as issued by the IASB (IFRS Accounting
Standards), its interpretations adopted by the IASB, the SAICA
Financial Reporting Guides as issued by the Accounting Practices
Committee, Financial Pronouncements as issued by the Financial
Reporting Standards Council, the JSE Listings Requirements,
and the South African Companies Act. The annual financial
statements have been approved by the board on 13 March 2024.
The annual financial statements have been prepared on the
historical cost basis except for the following material items in
the statement of financial position:
■ Financial assets classified at FVOCI, financial assets and
liabilities classified at FVTPL and liabilities for cash-settled
share-based payment arrangements.
■ Post-employment benefit obligations that are measured in
terms of the projected unit credit method.
■ Investment property is measured using the fair value model.
■ Insurance contract assets and insurance contract liabilities as
well as its related reinsurance assets and reinsurance contract
liabilities are measured in terms of the General Measurement
Model (GMM) or Variable Fee Approach (VFA) or Premium
Allocation Approach (PAA) as set out in accounting policy 12 –
Insurance Contracts.
■ Investments in associates and joint ventures are equity
accounted. Private equity and venture capital investments,
that are associates, are either designated on initial recognition
at FVTPL or are equity accounted.
The following material accounting policy elections in terms of
IFRS have been made, with reference to the detailed accounting
policies shown in brackets:
■ Purchases and sales of financial assets under a contract
whose terms require delivery of the asset within the time
frame generally established by regulation or convention in the
marketplace concerned are recognised and derecognised
using trade date accounting (accounting policy 3).
■ Commodities acquired principally for the purpose of selling in
the near future or generating a profit from fluctuation in price
or broker-traders’ margin are measured at fair value less cost
to sell (accounting policy 3).
■ Intangible assets and property, equipment and right of use
assets are accounted for at cost less accumulated
amortisation/depreciation and impairment
(accounting policy 6).
■ Where the group has owner-occupied properties that back
policyholder liabilities, these properties are measured using
the fair value model, in line with its investment properties
accounting policy (accounting policy 6).
■ The portfolio exception to measure the fair value of certain
groups of financial assets and financial liabilities on a net basis
(accounting policy 4).
■ Investments in associates and joint ventures are initially
measured at cost and subsequently accounted for using the
equity method in the separate financial statements
(accounting policy 2).
■ Investments in subsidiaries are accounted for at cost less
accumulated impairment losses, where applicable, in the
separate financial statements (accounting policy 1).
■ Investment property is accounted for using the fair value
model (accounting policy 6).
■ Private equity and venture capital investments, including
mutual funds, that are associates, are either designated on
initial recognition at FVTPL or are equity accounted
(accounting policy 2).
■ Cohorts — the group has elected to combine insurance
contracts in the same annual calendar year at initial
recognition (accounting policy 12).
■ Use of the PAA. The group has elected to apply the simplified
model for insurance contracts and reinsurance contracts held
where the coverage period is one year or less. On inception of a
group of contracts where the coverage period is over one year,
and the group meets the eligibility criteria, the group may
choose to apply the PAA. For the periods under review, the
group has elected to apply the PAA where coverage is one year
or less, or where the group meets the required eligibility
criteria. The group applies both a qualitative and quantitative
assessment to determine the eligibility (accounting policy 12).
■ For contracts measured under the PAA, the group has elected
(accounting policy 12):
– To defer the recognition of the acquisition costs over the
coverage period, however disclosure will be included where
the group elects to expense insurance acquisition cash flows
as incurred. The election is made for a group of insurance
contracts.
– To not adjust the carrying amount of the liability for
remaining coverage (LRC) to reflect the time value of money
(TVM) and the effect of financial risk for those contracts
where the coverage period is less than one year, or where
there is no significant financing component for contracts
longer than one year, if at initial recognition the group
expects that the time between providing each part of the
coverage and the related premium due date is no more than
one year.
– Where claims incurred are expected to be paid within a year
of the date that the claim is incurred, to not adjust future
cash flows for the TVM and the effect of financial risk.
■ Presentation and disclosure in the income statement of
insurance finance income or expense (accounting policy 12):
– Regarding the choice of recognition of insurance finance
income or expense for the reporting period in profit or loss
on a portfolio basis, or to recognise a portion of that in OCI,
the group has elected not to disaggregate amounts in OCI
for both those contracts with and those contracts without
direct participation features.
– The group has elected to present the income or expenses
from a group of reinsurance contracts held, other than
insurance finance income or expenses, as a single amount
on the face of the income statement rather than presenting
separately the amounts recovered from the reinsurer and
an allocation of the premiums paid that together give a net
amount equal to that single amount.
– The group has elected to disaggregate the risk adjustment
for non-financial risk between insurance service result and
insurance finance income and expense.
■ Contract boundary choice on the treatment of insurance risk
consequent to an incurred claim on an income protection
policy. The accounting policy choices are for the in-claim
payments to be treated as a liability for incurred claims (LIC)
(i.e. there is one contract and once a policyholder claims, it
becomes a LIC and long-dated fulfilment cash flows (FCF) are
modelled) or the in-claim payments are treated as a liability for
remaining coverage (LRC) (i.e. there is one contract pre-claim
and another contract for the in-payment liability). The latter
would reflect the group's obligation to pay claims in the
uncertain event of the policyholder remaining disabled and
eligible to claim. The group has elected that the in-claim
payments are treated as a LIC (i.e. there is one contract and
once a policyholder claims, it becomes a LIC and long-dated
fulfilment cash flows are modelled) (accounting policy 12).
28 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
ACCOUNTING POLICY ELECTIONS AND
RESTATEMENT
-- 28 of 278 --
■ Application of IFRS 17 and IAS® 21 The Effects of Changes in
Foreign Exchange Rates (IAS 21). A group of insurance
contracts may generate cash flows in more than one currency.
The group considers all risks, including currency exchange rate
risks, when identifying portfolios of insurance contracts in
order to develop an accounting policy to determine on initial
recognition the currency or currencies in which the group of
insurance contracts, including the contractual service margin
(CSM), is denominated. Two approaches for measuring multi-
currency groups of contracts are permitted, i.e. measuring the
group as denominated either: in a single currency, or in the
multiple currencies of the cash flows in the group. The group
has elected to measure the group of insurance contracts
(including the CSM if applicable) as all denominated in a single
currency. Where that currency is a foreign currency to the
reporting entity, the group applies IAS 21 and translates the
balance into its reporting currency at reporting dates
(accounting policy 12).
■ Risk mitigation. The group has elected to apply risk mitigation
(to avoid unintended mismatches in profit or loss) for the VFA
measured contracts post transition. The risk mitigation option
allows for hedged financial risk changes that otherwise would
impact the CSM, to not be recognised against the CSM.
Certain limited risk mitigation has been applied to the group’s
restated earnings for the period ended 31 December 2022
(accounting policy 12).
■ Measurement of the non-distinct investment component
(NDIC) within the scope of IFRS 17. The NDIC is the amount
repayable to the policyholder in all circumstances. Receipts
and repayments of such amounts do not relate to the provision
of insurance services and are excluded from insurance
revenue and insurance service expense. IFRS 17 does not
prescribe what value to use as the NDIC (either unit value or
surrender value). The group has elected to use the unit value
as the amount representing the non-distinct investment
component (NDIC) (accounting policy 12).
■ Application of IFRS 17 to fixed fee service contracts on
a contract-by-contract basis (accounting policy 12).
Refer to annexure F for detailed accounting policies.
Functional and presentation currency
The annual financial statements are presented in South African
rand, which is the presentation currency of the group and the
functional and presentation currency of the company. All
amounts are stated in millions of rand (Rm), unless indicated
otherwise.
Changes in accounting policies and
adoption of new standards effective for
the current financial year
The accounting policies are consistent with those reported in the
prior year, except for the following new and amended standards
that are effective for the current reporting period.
■ IAS 12 Income Taxes (IAS 12) (amendments) introduced a
temporary exception to the requirements to recognise and
disclose information about deferred tax assets and liabilities
related to Pillar Two income taxes and targeted disclosure
requirements for entities affected by GloBE (global anti-base
erosion) model rules. The amendments are effective for annual
periods starting on or after 1 January 2023 and are required to
be retrospectively applied. It was announced in the 2023
budget that it is South Africa’s intention to implement the
related legislation during 2024. The amendments had no
material impact on the group’s annual financial statements for
the current reporting period, as the estimated impact can only
be determined once the tax law is enacted or substantively
enacted, which is expected during the 2024 reporting period.
The following accounting policies have been applied in
preparation of these results as well as the restated 2022 results:
■ IFRS 17, adopted on 1 January 2023, establishes principles for
the recognition, measurement, presentation and disclosure of
insurance contracts, including reinsurance contracts, that an
entity issues, reinsurance contracts held as well as investment
contracts with discretionary participation features (DPF) that
an entity issues (provided the entity also issues insurance
contracts), which are scoped into IFRS 17 measurement from
IFRS 9 Financial Instruments (IFRS 9). Disclosures and
accounting policies have been amended as relevant. Refer to
the IFRS 17 transition impact section below, notes 9, 31, 32, 33,
34 and 35 for disclosure specifically relating to IFRS 17 and
annexure F for the detailed related accounting policies
(accounting policy 12).
Refer to annexure F for detailed accounting policies.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 29
-- 29 of 278 --
Restatement
Stage 3 interest income change in calculation methodology
During the finalisation of the group results, the group amended its calculation of interest income on stage 3 loans and advances for PPB
and BCB clients.
Previously, interest income on stage 3 loans and advances was calculated using a portfolio approach. The interest income on the stage 3
loan portfolio was calculated as the difference between the expected discounted and undiscounted recovery cash flows and was
unwound on a straight-line basis over the expected period to resolution, being either recovery or write-off (“portfolio straight-line
approach”). This modelling approach was utilised as a proxy for the IFRS 9 stage 3 interest recognition requirement.
Going forward, interest income on stage 3 loans and advances will be calculated on a loan-by-loan basis. The change in calculation
methodology is not a change in accounting policy. The interest income on stage 3 loans will be calculated by multiplying the net carrying
amount of each customer balance (after deducting credit impairments) by the effective interest rate of the loan, which is aligned to the
requirements of IFRS 9 (“loan-by-loan outstanding balance approach”).
During the change to the loan-by-loan outstanding balance approach, the group identified that by previously applying the portfolio
straight line approach in calculating stage 3 interest income, interest income and income statement credit impairments were
erroneously understated by R1.3 billion.
The group has restated for this impact. The ECL provision is not impacted by this restatement, as the correction to interest income and
income statement credit impairment each have an equal and opposite impact on the ECL provision. This restatement has no impact on
earnings attributable to ordinary shareholders or headline earnings but does impact the relevant ratios (being net interest margin, credit
loss ratio, cost-to-income ratio and jaws) which have been restated for this change. Furthermore, this change has no impact on gross
loans and advances, balance sheet ECL provisions, coverage or statement of cash flows.
IMPACT ON THE GROUP’S INCOME STATEMENT
2022
As previously
reported Restatement Restated
Rm Rm Rm
Interest income 133 596 1 279 134 875
Credit impairment charges (12 064) (1 279) (13 343)
30 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Accounting policy elections and restatement continued
-- 30 of 278 --
Adoption of IFRS 17
In May 2017, the IASB issued IFRS 17, which replaces
IFRS 4 Insurance Contracts (IFRS 4) for reporting periods
beginning on or after 1 January 2023. In addition, further
amendments were issued in June 2020.
IFRS 4 was an interim standard for insurance contracts and was
meant to limit changes to existing insurance accounting
practices. IFRS 4 allowed insurers to use local accounting
practices to determine the measurement of insurance contracts,
which essentially referred to the local actuarial practices,
resulting in a lack of consistency and comparability across
companies that issued insurance contracts.
IFRS 17 provides comprehensive guidance on accounting for
insurance contracts issued, investment contracts with DPF and
reinsurance contracts. IFRS 17 establishes the principles for
recognition, measurement, presentation and disclosure of
insurance contracts and reinsurance contracts. The standard
introduces defined accounting models that measure insurance
contracts at their current fulfilment estimates using one of three
measurement models, depending on the nature and terms of the
contract. IFRS 17 provides consistent principles for all aspects of
accounting for insurance contracts. IFRS 17 is effective for the
group from 1 January 2023 with the first retrospective
restatement for the group being 1 January 2022, i.e. the IFRS 17
measurement principles need to be applied to all contracts in-
force at 1 January 2022, as if IFRS 17 had always been in place.
IFRS 17 does allow certain transition relief.
The main principle that IFRS 17 introduces is to recognise
revenue, and profit or loss, over the duration of the contracts that
best reflects the delivery of insurance contract services in the
specific reporting period, with no profit recognition on contract
inception. Any losses on onerous contracts are recognised
immediately.
A key change is the creation of the CSM and the establishment of
the non-financial risk adjustment, collectively representing a
deferral of estimated profit, in respect of GMM and VFA
measured contracts. The CSM and risk adjustment (RA), which is
established on initial contract recognition, and the associated
related guidance of future measurement, results in a different
pattern of revenue recognition for many portfolios over the
contract coverage period.
Accounting policies are applied in accordance with the
transitional provisions of IFRS 17.
Overview of the IFRS 17 requirements
that materially impact the group
The key impact to the group’s equity on transition to IFRS 17
relates to the adoption of the new measurement models for
defined insurance contracts issued and reinsurance contracts.
The main revenue recognition principle that IFRS 17 adopts is to
recognise revenue, and consequently profit or loss, over the
duration of the applicable policyholder contracts in a manner that
best reflects the delivery of insurance contract services in the
specific reporting period. This aligns closely to the principles
applied in IFRS 15 Revenue from Contracts with Customers (IFRS
15). However, any anticipated losses on onerous contracts are
recognised immediately in profit or loss. The total recognised
profit or loss outcome of contracts, i.e. the actual cash flows that
emerge over the total contract term, naturally remains
unchanged. However, the year-by-year reporting of profit or loss
outcomes between IFRS 4 and IFRS 17 is often different.
Some contracts include an amount that meets the definition of a
NDIC under IFRS 17. The NDIC is the amount that an insurance
contract requires the group to repay to a policyholder in all
circumstances, regardless of whether an insured event occurs.
Under IFRS 17, the investment components that are highly inter-
related with the insurance contract are not unbundled on
contract inception. Similarly, a contract with equivalent terms
that could not be sold separately in the same market or
jurisdiction is not unbundled. Any such amounts are treated like
deposits and excluded from insurance revenue and insurance
services expenses when they are received from or paid to the
policyholder or beneficiary, as they do not relate to the provision
of insurance services. This is a significant change to current
disclosure which includes these amounts in insurance premiums
and insurance claims respectively.
IFRS 17 measurement principles are ambivalent to the type of
insurance, i.e. life or non-life/general/short-term, and the
permitted measurement model depends on the terms and
conditions of the underlying contracts, including the related
contract boundaries and coverage periods, rather than the
insurance licence type.
Portfolios are established for insurance contracts that have
similar risks and are managed together, however, each portfolio
is disaggregated into groups of contracts, limited to a maximum
of a twelve-month duration between the first contract and the
last contract recognised. At date of inception, the groups are
further divided into distinct and ring-fenced cohort groups that
differentiate the expected profitability of each contract between
onerous, unlikely to become onerous and those that have a
higher risk of becoming onerous over time. These cohort groups
are set at inception and cannot change over time. Subsequent
measurement of insurance contracts is therefore applied to the
cohort groups. The group has elected to have annual cohort
groups per calendar year.
IFRS 17 includes three permitted measurement models, being the
GMM, VFA and PAA. Due to the different types of contracts that
the group issues, it applies all three measurement models. The
measurement approach refers to the model used for valuing the
liabilities and recognising profits in insurance revenue over time
and should be appropriate for the contract being measured. The
allocation of contracts to each measurement approach is
dictated by IFRS 17, although there is an element of judgement in
certain instances, as well as a permitted simplification if
prescribed eligibility criteria are met. All measurement models
include two components, being an LRC and LIC. The LRC relates
to the measurement of the liability where the insured event has
not yet occurred, i.e. the group’s obligation for insured events
related to the unexpired portion of the coverage period. The LRC
also includes any non-distinct investment component values. The
LIC component relates to the measurement of the liability where
the insured event has occurred, or contract maturity triggers a
settlement of a non-distinct investment component, i.e. the
group’s obligation to settle claims for insured events that have
already occurred irrespective of whether they have been
reported, as well as any non-distinct investment components
that need to be settled. The LRC measured component is
dependent on what measurement model is applied. The
measurement of the LIC component is the same under all three
measurement models, except for contracts measured using the
PAA. For contracts under PAA, a simplification is allowed to not
discount claims that are payable within one year.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 31
IFRS 17 TRANSITION IMPACT
-- 31 of 278 --
General measurement model
A GMM is applicable to longer contract duration insurance
contracts that do not have significant investment components,
unless the criteria to use the simplified PAA model is met.
Contracts measured under the GMM approach are also referred
to as insurance contracts without any significant direct
participation features. The GMM is based on FCF which comprise
estimates of future cash flows, and include a risk-adjustment for
non-financial risks and an adjustment to reflect the TVM and the
financial risks related to the future cash flows. GMM is
prescribed by IFRS 17 as the default measurement model for
insurance and reinsurance contracts being predominantly risk
type contracts and annuities.
The GMM requires that future cash flows are estimated on a
best-estimate probability-weighted mean and the use of current
estimates, which are those informed by actual trends and
investment markets, adjusted for the TVM. A risk adjustment is
established as an explicit, current adjustment to compensate the
group for bearing non-financial risk. The risk adjustment is
released over the contract duration in line with the reduction of
the estimated risk. The estimates of future cash flows exclude
expenses that are not assessed as meeting the definition of
directly attributable insurance costs under IFRS 17.
The CSM established by IFRS 17 is measured at initial recognition
and is a component of measuring the LRC in the GMM model. The
CSM represents the unearned profit on the contract which is
expected to be earned in the future and results in no profit at
initial recognition. The CSM is released over the life of the
contract in line with the level of service provided in each period
(expressed as 'coverage units'). The interest rate used to
discount cash flows and determine the initial CSM is locked in at
the rate at inception for that contract, for all future CSM
movements. For onerous groups of contracts, losses are
recognised upfront in profit or loss (i.e. there is no concept of a
negative CSM).
Apart from the CSM, all other probability-weighted estimates of
cash flows contained in the measurement of insurance assets or
liabilities are measured at current values, taking future
expectations into consideration.
Variable fee approach
(insurance contracts only)
For contracts that have a component of significant insurance risk
but are substantially investment-related contracts with direct
participation in a share of underlying items, the GMM is modified
to measure such contracts using the VFA, for example, a
retirement annuity that may include a product benefit of a
minimum return of contributions on death. The VFA is also
referred to as the approach for insurance contracts with
significant direct participating features. The group applies the
VFA to investment contracts with DPF (which are scoped into
IFRS 17), should they meet the eligibility criteria for VFA. This
approach effectively amortises, over the remaining life of the
contract, the impact to the future estimated revenue, for
example, asset-based investment management fees, that have
arisen from changes in investment values at the reporting date. A
key difference to the GMM approach is how the CSM is impacted
over time. The group's share of the fair value returns of the
underlying items is included in the CSM, and the CSM is not
locked in at the original discount rate. The group is required to
justify the classifications into VFA through conditions
demonstrating policyholder participation and analyses of
investment benefits.
Premium allocation approach
An optional simplified PAA is available for contracts with a
coverage period of 12 months or less, or if it is reasonably
expected that the PAA would produce a measurement of the LRC
that would not materially differ from the one produced applying
the GMM. Contracts measured under the PAA approach do not
have a CSM.
The group has elected, as permitted by the standard, to apply the
simplified model for insurance contracts and reinsurance
contracts held where the coverage period is less than 12 months.
On inception of groups of contracts where the coverage period is
over one year and the groups meet the eligibility criteria in that
the measurement result of the PAA and GMM are not materially
different, the group has elected to apply the PAA approach.
For contracts measured under PAA, the group has elected:
■ To defer the recognition of the acquisition costs over the
coverage period.
■ To not adjust the carrying amount of the LRC to reflect TVM
and the effect of financial risk for those contracts where the
coverage period is less than one year, or where there is no
significant financing component for contracts longer than one
year.
■ Where claims incurred are expected to be paid within a year of
the date that the claim is incurred, to not adjust future cash
flows for TVM.
Reinsurance contracts
(GMM or PAA models only)
The group measures reinsurance contracts on the same
principles as for the insurance contracts, adapted to reflect
features that differ between the two types of contracts.
Reinsurance contracts conceptually differ to insurance contracts
as there can be a potential recognition of a day one gain. The
standard allows this day one recognition (even if a gain) to reflect
the commerciality of the transfer of insurance risks to a third
party (particularly to the extent that it may offset a day one
onerous contract loss recognition).
Presentation
Aggregation for presentation references the unit of account
which is a portfolio as defined in IFRS 17. For the statement of
financial position, portfolios that are in a net asset position are
presented separately from those in a net liability position for both
recognised insurance and reinsurance contracts. Income or
expenses from reinsurance contracts held is presented
separately from expenses or income from insurance contracts
issued.
The most significant change to presentation is the construct of
the income statement where IFRS 17 introduces and defines the
following concepts:
■ Insurance revenue depicts the provision of services arising
from a group of insurance contracts at an amount that reflects
the consideration which the group expects to be entitled to in
exchange for those services. Deposit (investment)
components of contractual premiums are excluded from
insurance revenue.
■ Insurance service expenses, which comprise the actual
incurred risk claims (excluding any investment component)
and other incurred insurance service expenses on insurance
contracts relating to the reporting period. In addition, the
insurance service expense includes any losses on the initial
recognition of onerous groups of contracts, as well as
subsequent variations to net onerous contract portfolios and
the recognition of the onerous component of any portfolio
groups that were initially profitable but subsequently have
become onerous.
32 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS IFRS 17 transition impact continued
-- 32 of 278 --
IFRS 17 requires separate presentation of the insurance service
result (insurance revenue less insurance service expenses) from
other business activities. In addition, the presentation also
requires specific disclosure on insurance financing as defined as
follows:
■ Insurance finance income or expenses, which depicts the net
income or expense outcome of the financing activities and
financial risk assumed in the conduct of the insurance
business. This includes the impact to the current value of
estimated future cash flows of insurance contracts, that arises
from changes in the applicable risk-free interest rate
environment.
The group has not elected, as permitted by the standard,
to present any changes in IFRS 17 movements in other
comprehensive income.
Interaction between IFRS 17 and IFRS 9
The measurement of financial investment contracts held at
FVTPL under IFRS 9 did not change on adoption of IFRS 17. There
are some consequential reclassifications between IFRS 17 and
IFRS 9 policyholder liabilities and vice versa, on adoption of IFRS
17 because of minor changes in the interpretation of the
definition of insurance contracts under IFRS 17. These
reclassifications, however, do not have a material impact on the
overall measurement of these portfolios on transition or the
resulting change to deferred acquisition costs and deferred
revenue liability related to financial investment contracts.
The group’s IFRS 17 financial impact and
how it has been recognised
Transition approaches
A fully retrospective application of IFRS 17 prior to the transition
date (for the group) is required, unless it is impracticable to do
so. If it is impracticable, an entity can choose between the
modified retrospective approach or fair value approach to
measure the take-on IFRS 17 balances. For short contract
boundary nature contracts measured under the PAA approach,
these will all be measured using the full retrospective application.
The group used a combination of all three transition methods,
namely, full retrospective, modified retrospective, and fair value,
depending on the historical data that was available per the IFRS
17 defined groups.
The full retrospective approach has been applied for most groups
of insurance contracts recognised from 1 January 2017 onwards.
Given the availability of information, including assumptions,
methodologies and the availability of risk adjustment data,
management’s view was that it was impracticable to perform the
full retrospective calculations for years further back.
Fair value is an approach to determine the transition CSM
through an IFRS 13 Fair Value Measurement (IFRS 13)
assessment of the probable trading price for a similar group of
insurance contracts in a simulated deep and liquid market. The
group has calculated the purchase price by assuming that the
purchaser of a group of insurance contracts would be required to
hold additional regulatory capital to support these contracts and
would therefore include a price adjustment for the cost of capital
required.For the modified retrospective approach, the group has
maximised the use of information that would have been used to
apply the full retrospective approach. The approach valued
liabilities back to inception, replacing expected values with actual
values where known. This enabled an approximate value to be
calculated for the probability-weighted estimate of FCF and RA at
inception, so that a CSM could be calculated.
A summary of the main product lines, transition approaches,
measurement models and reportable groups is as follows:
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 33
-- 33 of 278 --
Main product lines Transition approach Measurement model Reportable group
Non-participating annuities Full retrospective from 2017
onwards. Modified
retrospective from 2012 to
2016. Fair value prior to 2012.
GMM
Life risk measured under GMM
Retail pure risk Mostly full retrospective from
2017 onwards. Fair value prior
to 2017.
GMM
Other life assurance benefits,
covering for death, disability,
critical illness, etc.
Mostly full retrospective GMM
Institutional risk, including
embedded bancassurance
business.
Group life assurance products,
such as funeral products,
corporate income protection
plans and group risk.
PAA – full retrospective
application
PAA – accounting policy
election
Life risk measured under PAA
Retail and corporate
guaranteed annuities,
guaranteed capital bonds.
Full retrospective GMM Annuities and guaranteed
investment products (GIPs)
Unit-linked retirement annuities
and endowments, linked
annuities and contracts that
have direct participating
features.
Mostly full retrospective from
2017 onwards. Modified
retrospective on key product
lines from 2012 to 2016,
otherwise fair value.
Predominantly VFA Participating contracts
The group’s short-term
insurance products, such as
homeowners comprehensive
cover, personal accident cover,
health insurance and car hire
and roadside assistance.
PAA – full retrospective
application
PAA – accounting policy
election
Non-life risk measured under
PAA
Reinsurance on insurance
contracts measured under
GMM noted above
Aligned to transition approach
on underlying insurance
contracts issued
GMM Reinsurance life risk measured
under GMM
Reinsurance on insurance
contracts measured under PAA
noted above
Aligned to transition approach
on underlying insurance
contracts issued
PAA - accounting policy
election
Reinsurance life risk measured
under PAA
Reinsurance non-life risk
measured under PAA
34 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS IFRS 17 transition impact continued
-- 34 of 278 --
Other consequential impacts on transition
The below table sets out a description of the IFRS 17 impact on transition, other than the impact to the group’s primary financial
statements, the overview of the IFRS 17 requirements that materially impact the group:
IFRS 17 impact on transition Description
Impact on opening reserves Refer to the statement of changes in equity for the impact on the
group’s reserves as at 1 January 2022, earliest opening reserves
impact disclosed, and 1 January 2023.
Impact on treasury shares The treasury shares requirements of IAS 32 Financial
Instruments: Presentation (IAS 32) were amended to provide an
exemption from the requirement to be deducted from equity.
Despite the treasury share requirements of IAS 32, an entity may
elect not to deduct from equity a treasury share that is included
in such a fund or is an underlying item when the entity reacquires
its own equity instruments.
The group has elected not to deduct from equity its treasury
shares as described, but to continue to account for these
treasury shares as equity and to measure the reacquired equity
instrument at FVTPL in accordance with IFRS 9. The amendment
has been retrospectively applied in line with the requirements of
IFRS 17 and has been included in the impact on opening reserves.
Refer to page 39 for the impact of the exemption applied on the
group’s treasury shares and note 15 for details on treasury
shares.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 35
-- 35 of 278 --
Overview of the group’s IFRS 17 impact
The tables that follow provide an analysis of the group’s
transition to IFRS 17 and have been prepared in accordance
with the basis of preparation and overview of IFRS 17 for the
group. A summary of the IFRS 17 opening net asset value
(NAV) adjustment and restated earnings for the period ended
31 December 2022 is provided. The restated group’s
summarised statement of financial position (both at
1 January 2022 and 31 December 2022) and the summarised
statement of changes in equity for 31 December 2022 are
presented thereafter.
Opening net asset value as at 1 January 2022
and closing net asset value as at
31 December 2022 from IFRS 4 to IFRS 17
The transition to IFRS 17 has resulted in an increase in the
group’s equity attributable to ordinary shareholders of
R41 million as at 1 January 2022 and a reduction of
R1 067 million as at 31 December 2022. In the group’s
insurance businesses, the negative adjustment to net asset
value of R1 021 million as at 1 January 2022 and R2 437 million
as at 31 December 2022 represents the effect of a more
conservative revenue recognition approach that has resulted
from application of the IFRS 17. This amount is expected to
release to income over the future remaining coverage periods
of the contracts in-force at transition, through the mechanisms
of the CSM and RA. The above mentioned reduction in the
group’s net asset value is offset by an increase in equity of R1
062 million as at 1 January 2022 and R1 370 million as at 31
December 2022 resulting from the reinstatement of the
group’s treasury shares held in Liberty during 2022.
Impact of IFRS 17 on the group’s headline
earnings for the year ended 31 December 2022
Group headline earnings for 2022 on an IFRS 17 basis was
R33 853 million compared to R34 247 million under IFRS 4.
The R394 million reduction in the insurance business headline
earnings for the year ended 31 December 2022 was primarily
due to the following:
■ Liberty Group Limited (LGL) has for some time applied a
hedging strategy, largely against undesirable investment
market risks. Through the conversion to IFRS 17, and the
requirement of derivative hedging to qualify for the risk
mitigation option in IFRS 17, the group was unable to
account for the specific hedges that were achieved through
non-derivative mechanisms in the asset-liability matching
activity over 2022. Going forward, the group has modified its
hedging programme to qualify for the risk mitigation option.
The net impact of this transition was a once-off R140 million
additional expense in 2022.
■ R125 million reduction in earnings for 2022 has been
attributed to the impact of credit rating changes over the
year which under IFRS 4 was offset by discretionary
margins. Under IFRS 17, credit rating changes (positive or
negative), should they occur in a year, will impact earnings to
the full extent of the rating change, as the specific margins
recognised under IFRS 4 cannot be recognised under the
IFRS 17 guidance and hence were released as part of the
transition adjustments to net asset value at 1 January 2022.
■ R290 million reduction in earnings has been attributed to
the impact of margins under IFRS 4 which largely relates to
a product migration of legacy with-profit business. The
margins cannot be recognised under the IFRS 17 guidance
and hence were released as part of the transition
adjustments to net asset value at 1 January 2022, therefore
resulting in a change in 2022 earnings compared to IFRS 4.
■ An estimated R60 million lower earnings relates to the
impact of a more conservative outcome on new business,
partially offset by a higher earnings amortisation of the CSM
relative to the margin release in IFRS 4 on in-force contracts.
■ R243 million higher earnings due to the reinstatement of
treasury shares and the measurement of these treasury
shares at fair value.
Capital implications
The impact on regulatory capital on the long-term insurance
business is minimal, as capital is assessed on a regulatory
basis, which in South Africa refers to the Solvency and
Assessment Management (SAM) framework. The group has
already fully adopted the SAM framework for regulatory capital
purposes.
Tax implications
Within South Africa, National Treasury prepared amended tax
legislation, which was promulgated during January 2023,
related to the adoption of IFRS 17 and any consequential tax
implications. While an ʻadjusted IFRS’ tax basis is retained,
these amendments provide for a six-year phasing-in provision
for long-term insurers and a three-year phasing-in provision for
short-term insurers in order to transition the tax impact of
applying IFRS 17 from 1 January 2023, instead of applying
IFRS 4. The change in tax legislation is effective for years
commencing 1 January 2023. Other than the phasing-in
provisions that creates a timing difference in the recognition of
deferred tax, there are no other material tax implications for
the group on the current basis of tax arising from the adoption
of IFRS 17.
Impact on the group’s statement of financial
position
■ The restatement of financial liabilities under investment
contracts is due to the reclassifications of certain
policyholder contracts between IFRS 9 and IFRS 17 due to
minor changes in the interpretation of the definition of
insurance contracts under IFRS 17.
■ Differences arise from the measurement of insurance
contracts and reinsurance contracts under IFRS 17 in
comparison to IFRS 4. Aggregation for presentation under
IFRS 17 references the unit of account, which is a portfolio as
defined. For the statement of financial position, portfolios
that are in a net asset position are presented separately
from those in a net liability position for both recognised
insurance and reinsurance contracts.
■ Policyholders assets which were previously separately
disclosed as financial instruments, have been reclassified to
insurance contract liabilities (LRC) as IFRS 17 requires all
related policyholder cash flows to be included in the
measurement of insurance contracts (considered integral to
the underlying contract).
■ Under IFRS 4, outstanding premiums debtors and
reinsurance recoveries were included in 'Prepayments,
insurance and other receivables' and outstanding claims,
commission creditors and premiums received in advance
were included in 'Insurance and other payables'. IFRS 17
requires all policyholder related cashflows to be included in
the measurement of insurance/reinsurance contract
assets/liabilities. Certain outstanding claims may relate to
IFRS 9 defined contracts, in which case those balances
remain with 'Provisions and other liabilities'.
■ Deferred tax impact as a result of change in the carrying
amount of assets and liabilities on initial application of IFRS
17 between the new accounting base under IFRS 17 and the
tax base.
■ The key impact to the group’s equity on transition to IFRS 17
relates to the adoption of the new measurement models for
defined insurance contracts issued and reinsurance
contracts.
36 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS IFRS 17 transition impact continued
-- 36 of 278 --
IMPACT ON THE GROUP’S STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION
31 December 2022 1 January 2022
As
previously
reported Restatement Restated
As
previously
reported Restatement Restated
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Assets
Cash and balances with central banks 114 483 114 483 91 169 91 169
Derivative assets 74 410 74 410 63 688 63 688
Trading assets 314 918 314 918 285 020 285 020
Pledged assets 19 308 19 308 14 178 14 178
Disposal group assets held for sale 555 555 1 025 1 025
Financial investments 721 205 1 289 722 494 724 700 1 429 726 129
Receivables and other assets1 46 763 (7 116) 39 647 36 432 (7 217) 29 215
Current tax assets 757 757 709 709
Loans and advances 1 504 941 (1) 1 504 940 1 424 328 1 424 328
Policyholder assets 2 974 (2 974) 2 868 (2 868)
Reinsurance contract assets 5 522 5 522 5 902 5 902
Insurance contract assets 1 830 1 830 1 264 1 264
Interest in associates and joint ventures 9 956 9 956 7 280 7 280
Investment property 29 289 29 289 29 985 29 985
Property, equipment and right of use
assets 20 340 20 340 20 619 20 619
Goodwill and other intangible assets 15 121 (1) 15 120 16 913 (4) 16 909
Deferred tax assets 8 821 7 8 828 6 903 4 6 907
Total assets 2 883 841 (1 444) 2 882 397 2 725 817 (1 490) 2 724 327
Equity and liabilities
Equity2 259 956 (1 090) 258 866 242 849 42 242 891
Equity attributable to ordinary
shareholders 219 264 (1 067) 218 197 198 832 41 198 873
Equity attributable to other equity
instrument holders 19 667 19 667 16 052 16 052
Equity attributable to non-controlling
interests 21 025 (23) 21 002 27 965 1 27 966
Liabilities 2 623 885 (354) 2 623 531 2 482 968 (1 532) 2 481 436
Derivative liabilities 85 049 85 049 67 259 67 259
Trading liabilities 109 928 109 928 81 484 81 484
Disposal group liabilities held for sale 96 96
Provisions and other liabilities1 139 283 (9 396) 129 887 153 784 (8 499) 145 285
Current tax liabilities 7 842 7 842 7 557 7 557
Deposits and debt funding 1 889 099 1 889 099 1 776 615 1 776 615
Policyholder liabilities 358 467 (358 467) 363 023 (363 023)
Financial liabilities under investment
contracts 136 309 136 309 136 622 136 622
Insurance contract liabilities 231 849 231 849 233 730 233 730
Subordinated debt 31 744 31 744 30 430 30 430
Deferred tax liabilities 2 473 (649) 1 824 2 720 (362) 2 358
Total equity and liabilities 2 883 841 (1 444) 2 882 397 2 725 817 (1 490) 2 724 327
1 Receivables and other assets included reinsurance contract assets, and provisions and other liabilities included reinsurance contract liabilities under IFRS 4, which have
been disaggregated and separately presented in the statement of financial position under IFRS 17.
2 Refer to the statement of changes in equity on page 24 for detail on the reserves impacted.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 37
-- 37 of 278 --
IMPACT ON THE GROUP’S INCOME STATEMENT
2022
As reported Restatement Restated
Rm Rm Rm
Net interest income 78 391 78 391
Interest income1 134 875 134 875
Interest expense (56 484) (56 484)
Non-interest revenue 56 242 (1 277) 54 965
Net fee and commission revenue 32 621 32 621
Fee and commission revenue 41 440 41 440
Fee and commission expense (8 819) (8 819)
Trading revenue 17 046 17 046
Other revenue2 4 137 (1 277) 2 860
Other gains and losses on financial instruments 2 438 2 438
Income from investment and life insurance activities 23 566 (23 566)
Insurance premiums received 49 379 (49 379)
Revenue from contracts with customers 3 921 (3 921)
Interest income 2 030 (2 030)
Insurance benefits and claims paid (39 017) 39 017
Investment management and service fee income and gains 2 698 (2 698)
Fair value adjustments to investment management liabilities and third-party fund
interests 4 555 (4 555)
Net insurance income 3 178 3 178
Insurance service result 8 302 8 302
Net insurance service result before reinsurance contracts held 8 071 8 071
Insurance revenue 35 717 35 717
Insurance service expense (27 646) (27 646)
Net (expense)/income from reinsurance contracts held 231 231
Net insurance finance expenses (5 124) (5 124)
Net finance expenses from insurance contracts issued (5 232) (5 232)
Net finance income from reinsurance contracts held 108 108
Non-insurance revenue 11 583 11 583
Investment and other income 7 516 7 516
Interest income on financial assets using the effective interest method 2 105 2 105
Fair value adjustments to financial assets, investment contract liabilities and third-
party mutual funds 1 962 1 962
Total net income 158 199 (10 082) 148 117
Credit impairment charges1 (13 343) (13 343)
Net income before operating expenses 144 856 (10 082) 134 774
Operating expenses (83 533) (83 533)
Operating expenses in Standard Bank Activities (73 274) 73 274
Operating expenses in investment management and life insurance activities (19 247) 19 247
Net income before capital items and equity accounted earnings 52 335 (1 094) 51 241
Non-trading and capital-related items 328 328
Share of post tax profit from associates and joint ventures 2 265 2 265
Profit before indirect taxation 54 928 (1 094) 53 834
Indirect taxation (3 534) 457 (3 077)
Profit before direct taxation 51 394 (637) 50 757
Direct taxation (12 011) 294 (11 717)
Profit for the year 39 383 (343) 39 040
1 As previously reported. Includes the restatement impact as detailed on page 30.
2 IFRS 17 requires insurance revenue to be separately presented in the income statement. Insurance-related revenue under IFRS 4 was previously included in other
revenue, which has subsequently been restated and presented within insurance revenue.
38 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS IFRS 17 transition impact continued
-- 38 of 278 --
IMPACT ON THE GROUP’S FINANCIAL RESULTS, RATIOS AND OTHER STATISTICS1
2022
As previously
reported Restatement Restated
Financial results (Rm)
Headline earnings contribution by business unit1
Profit for the year 39 383 (343) 39 040
Attributable to ordinary shareholders 34 637 (394) 34 243
Attributable to other equity instrument holders 999 999
Attributable to non-controlling interests 3 747 51 3 798
Total comprehensive income for the year1 35 767 (343) 35 424
Attributable to ordinary shareholders 31 211 (394) 30 817
Attributable to other equity instrument holders 999 999
Attributable to non-controlling interests 3 557 51 3 608
Total headline earnings attributable to ordinary shareholders1 34 247 (394) 33 853
Gross 51 066 (637) 50 429
Direct tax (12 078) 294 (11 784)
Attributable to non-controlling interests and other equity instrument holders (4 741) (51) (4 792)
Number of shares
Weighted average number of shares 1 640 863 351 10 149 792 1 651 013 143
Issued number of shares 1 648 374 283 8 178 769 1 656 553 052
Weighted average number of treasury shares2 26 952 097 (10 149 792) 16 802 305
Treasury shares2 29 950 340 (8 178 769) 21 771 571
Share statistics (cents)
Basic earnings per share (EPS) 2 110.9 (36.8) 2 074.1
Headline earnings per share (HEPS) 2 087.1 (36.7) 2 050.4
Diluted EPS 2 095.5 (36.5) 2 059.0
Diluted HEPS 2 071.9 (36.3) 2 035.6
1 The only impact on these items relate to the restatements of profit for the year and taxation thereon, OCI and headline adjustable items were not restated.
2 The treasury shares requirements of IAS 32 were amended, as a result of IFRS 17, to provide an exemption from the requirement to be deducted from equity. The group
has elected to apply this exemption and to measure the reacquired equity instrument at FVTPL in accordance with IFRS 9. The total equity securities held as treasury
shares, as at 31 December 2022, have been restated resulting from the reinstatement of the group’s treasury shares held in Liberty during 2022.
The exemption is available to entities that operate, either internally or externally, an investment fund that provides investors with benefits determined by units in the
fund and recognise financial liabilities for the amounts to be paid to those investors, as well as entities that issue insurance contracts with direct participation features
where those entities hold the underlying items. Refer to note 15 for further details.
Sensitivity of insurance contract balances measured at fair value on transition
to IFRS 17
On transition to IFRS 17, certain insurance contracts, as permitted by the standard, were measured at fair value on 1 January 2022, and
thereafter under IFRS 17. These contracts are considered non-recurring level 3 instruments under IFRS 13. The group has assumed that
the purchaser of a group of insurance contracts would be required to hold additional regulatory capital to support these contracts and
therefore included a price adjustment for the cost of capital required, using a return on equity (ROE) assumption of 20%. ROE is the
most significant unobservable input into the fair value measurement calculation.
The table below shows what the impact would be (gross of tax) on the CSM portion of the total insurance contracts measured at fair
value from a change in the ROE used for the calculation of IFRS 17 balances at initial recognition, being 1 January 2022.
Change in ROE
1 January 20221 +2% increase in ROE -2% decrease in ROE
Rm Rm Rm
CSM portion of IFRS 17 balances measured using the fair
value transition 12 659 13 914 11 202
1 Total CSM as at 1 January 2022 applying an ROE of 20%.
No disclosure is shown for any sensitivities after 1 January 2022 as the balances are measured under IFRS 17 post transition.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 39
-- 39 of 278 --
In preparing the financial statements, estimates and
assumptions are made that could materially affect the reported
amounts of assets and liabilities within the next financial year.
Estimates and judgements, collectively referred to as key
management assumptions, are continually evaluated and are
based on factors such as historical experience and current best
estimates of future events. The estimates and judgements below
have remained unchanged unless otherwise stated. The following
represents the most material key management assumptions
applied in preparing these financial statements. The key
management assumptions below apply to the group and
company, unless otherwise stated.
Expected credit loss (ECL)
During the current reporting period, ECL models have been
enhanced with a change made in the assessment of how
dependent multiple default events have been calculated.
No further material changes to assumptions have occurred.
ECL on financial assets – drivers
For the purpose of determining the ECL:
■ The home services, vehicle and asset finance (VAF), card,
personal, business lending and other products portfolios are
based on the product categories or subsets of the product
categories, with tailored ECL models per portfolio. The
impairment provision calculation excludes post write-off
recoveries (PWOR) from the loss given default (LGD) in
calculating the ECL.
■ Corporate, sovereign and bank exposures are calculated
separately based on rating models for each of the asset
classes.
ECL measurement period
The ECL measurement period for stage 1 exposures is 12 months
(or the remaining tenor of the financial asset relating to
corporate, sovereign and bank exposures, if the remaining
lifetime is less than 12 months).
■ A loss allowance over the full lifetime of the financial asset is
required if the credit risk of that financial instrument has
increased significantly since initial recognition (stage 2).
■ A lifetime measurement period is applied to all credit impaired
(stage 3) exposures.
■ Lifetime includes consideration for dependent multiple default
events, i.e. where defaulted exposures cure and then
subsequently re-default. This consideration increases the
lifetime and the potential ECL.
■ The measurement period for unutilised loan commitments
utilises the same approach as on-balance sheet exposures.
Significant increase in credit risk and low
credit risk
Home services, vehicle and asset finance, card,
personal, business lending and other products
All exposures are assessed to determine whether there has been
significant increase in credit risk (SICR) at the reporting date, in
which case an impairment provision equivalent to the lifetime
expected loss is recognised. SICR thresholds, which are
behaviour score based, are derived for each portfolio vintage of
exposures with similar credit risk and are calibrated over time to
determine which exposures reflect deterioration relative to the
originated population and consequently reflect an increase in
credit risk. Behaviour scorecards are based on a combination of
factors which include the information relating to customers,
transactions and delinquency behaviour (including the backstop
when contractual payments are more than 30 days past due
(DPD)) to provide a quantitative assessment (score), and more
specifically, a ranking of customer creditworthiness. The
creditworthiness of a customer is summarised by a score, with
high scores corresponding to low-risk customers, and
conversely, low scores corresponding to high-risk customers.
These scores are often taken into account in determining the
probability of default (PD) including relative changes in PD.
Credit risk has increased since initial recognition when these
criteria are met.
The group determines the SICR threshold by utilising an
appropriate transfer rate of exposures that are less than 30 DPD
to stage 2. This transfer rate is such that the proportion of the
0-29 DPD book transferred into stage 2 is no less than the
observed 12-month roll rate of 0-29 day accounts into 30 or more
days in arrears. The SICR thresholds are reviewed regularly to
ensure that they are appropriately calibrated to identify SICR by
portfolio vintage and to consequently facilitate appropriate
impairment coverage.
Where behaviour scores are not available, historical levels of
delinquency are applied in determining whether there has been
SICR. For all exposures, the rebuttable presumption of 30 DPD as
well as exposures classified as either debt review or as ʻwatch-
list’ are used to classify exposures within stage 2.
Corporate, sovereign and bank products
(including certain business banking exposures)
The group uses a 25-point master rating scale to quantify the
credit risk for each exposure. On origination, each client is
assigned a credit risk grade within the group’s 25-point master
rating scale. Ratings are mapped to PDs by means of calibration
formulae that use historical default rates and other data for the
applicable portfolio. These credit ratings are evaluated at least
annually or more frequently as appropriate.
All exposures are evaluated for SICR by comparing the credit risk
grade at the reporting date to the origination credit risk grade.
Where the relative change in the credit risk grade exceeds certain
pre-defined ratings’ migration thresholds or, when a contractual
payment becomes more than 30 DPD (IFRS 9’s rebuttable
presumption), the exposure is classified within stage 2. These
pre-defined ratings’ migration thresholds have been determined
based on historic default experience which indicate that higher
rated risk exposures are more sensitive to SICR than lower risk
exposures. Based on an analysis of historic default experience,
exposures that are classified by the group’s master rating scale
as investment grade (within credit risk grade 1 – 12 of the group’s
25-point master rating scale) are assessed for SICR at each
reporting date but are considered to be of low credit risk. To
determine whether a client’s credit risk has increased
significantly since origination, the group would need to determine
the extent of the change in credit risk using the table that follows:
Group master rating scale
band
SICR trigger
(from origination)
SB 1 – 12 Low credit risk
SB 13 – 20 3 rating or more
SB 21 – 25 1 rating or more
From a South African perspective, for SARB D3 qualifying
exposures, the SICR methodology remains unchanged
(comparing the credit risk grading) to determine whether these
exposures are classified within stage 1 or stage 2. The credit risk
grade is assessed at the time of the relief, and subsequent
monthly reviews of the status of the request and client’s
performance are conducted.
40 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
KEY MANAGEMENT ASSUMPTIONS
-- 40 of 278 --
Incorporation of forward-looking information
(FLI) in ECL measurement
The group determines the macroeconomic outlook, over a
planning horizon of at least three years, for each country based
on the group’s global outlook and its view of commodities,
interest rates, exchange rates and other relevant parameters.
For home services, VAF, card, personal, business lending and
other products, these forward-looking economic expectations
are included in the ECL where adjustments are made based on
the group’s macroeconomic outlook, using models that correlate
these parameters with macroeconomic variables. Where
modelled correlations are not viable or predictive, adjustments
are based on expert judgement to predict the outcomes based on
the group’s macroeconomic outlook expectations. In addition to
forward-looking macroeconomic information, other types of FLI,
such as specific event risks and industry data, have been taken
into account in ECL estimates when required, through the
application of out-of-model adjustments. These out-of-model
adjustments are subject to group credit governance committee
oversight.
The group’s macroeconomic outlooks are incorporated in
corporate, sovereign and bank products’ client rating and include
specific forward-looking economic considerations for the
individual client. The client rating thus reflects the expected client
risk for the group’s expectation of future economic and business
conditions. Further adjustments, based on point-in-time market
data, are made to the PDs assigned to each risk grade to produce
PDs and ECL representative of market conditions.
Default
The definition of default, which triggers the credit impaired
classification (stage 3), is based on the group’s internal credit
risk management approach and definitions. While the specific
determination of default varies according to the nature of the
product, it is compliant with the Basel definition of default, and
generally determined as occurring at the earlier of:
■ where, in the group’s view, the counterparty is considered to
be unlikely to pay amounts due on the due date or shortly
thereafter without recourse to actions such as the realisation
of security. This includes the classification of distressed
restructures (including debt review exposures) as default for
minimum of six months, while observing payment behaviour or
■ when the counterparty is past due for more than 90 days (or,
in the case of overdraft facilities, in excess of the current limit).
The group has not rebutted the 90 DPD rebuttable presumption.
Write-off policy
An impaired loan is written off once all reasonable attempts at
collection have been made and there is no material economic
benefit expected from attempting to recover the balance
outstanding (i.e. no reasonable expectation of recovery).
This assessment considers both qualitative and quantitative
information, such as past performance, behaviour and
recoveries. The group assesses whether there is a reasonable
expectation of recovery at an exposure level. As such, once the
criteria that follow are met at an exposure level, the exposure is
written off.
The following criteria must be met before a financial asset can be
written off:
■ the financial asset has been in default for the period defined for
the specific product (i.e. VAF, home services, etc.) which is
deemed sufficient to determine whether the group is able to
receive any further economic benefit from the impaired loan.
The period defined for unsecured products is determined with
reference to post-default payment behaviour such as
cumulative delinquency, as well as an analysis of post write-off
recoveries. Factors that are within the group’s control are
assessed and considered in the determination of the period
defined for each product. The post-default payment period is
generally once the rehabilitation probability (repayment of
instalments) is considered low to zero, and a period between
180 to 360 days in arrears; and
■ at the point of write-off, the financial asset is fully impaired (i.e.
100% ECL allowance) with no reasonable expectation of
recovery of the asset, or a portion thereof.
As an exception to the above requirements:
■ Where the exposure is secured (or for collateralised
structures), the impaired exposure can only be written off once
the collateral has been realised. Post-realisation of the
collateral, the shortfall amount can be written off if it meets the
second requirement listed above.
■ For corporate, sovereign and bank products, write-off is
assessed on a case-by-case basis and approved by the CIB
credit governance committee based on the individual facts and
circumstances.
■ For unsecured exposures, post write-off collection and
enforcement activities include outsourcing to external debt
collection agents as well as collection/settlement
arrangements to assist clients to settle their outstanding debt.
The group continuously monitors and reviews when exposures
are written off, the levels of post write-off recoveries as well as
the key factors causing post write-off recoveries, which ensure
that the group’s point of write-off remains appropriate and that
post write-off recoveries are within expectable levels after
time.
Curing
Continuous assessment is required to determine whether the
conditions that led to a financial asset being considered to be
credit impaired (i.e. stage 3) still exist. Distressed restructured
financial assets (including debt review exposures) that no longer
qualify as credit impaired remain within stage 3 for a minimum
period of six months (i.e. an average of six full monthly payments
per the terms and conditions). In the case of financial assets with
quarterly or longer dated repayment terms, the classification of a
financial asset out of stage 3 may be made subsequent to an
evaluation by the group’s CIB or home services, VAF, card,
personal, business lending and other products credit governance
committees (as appropriate), such evaluation will take into
account qualitative factors in addition to compliance with
payment terms and conditions of the agreement. Qualitative
factors include compliance with covenants and with existing
financial asset terms and conditions.
Where it has been determined that a financial asset no longer
meets the criteria for SICR, the financial asset will be moved from
stage 2 (lifetime ECL model) back to stage 1 (12-month ECL
model) prospectively.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 41
-- 41 of 278 --
The group’s forward-looking economic
expectations applied in the determination of
the ECL at the reporting date
A range of scenarios have been determined for base, bear and
bull forward-looking economic expectations, as at
31 December 2023, for inclusion in the group’s forward-looking
process and ECL calculation.
South African economic expectation
■ Idiosyncratic constraints such as the electricity shortfall, rail
and port infrastructure insufficiencies as well as policy
uncertainty continue to weigh on business and consumer
confidence and weaken economic growth. Fragile global
growth continues to place additional pressure on South
Africa’s terms of trade, reflecting the tight global financial
conditions and rising geopolitical tensions and risks from
ongoing, and potentially further, wars. Many countries are
holding general elections this year. Locally, it is assumed that
the African National Congress will likely not require a large
coalition partner at the national level in the 2024 elections.
This assumed election outcome underpins our expectation for
general continuity in monetary and fiscal policy as well as the
structural reform trajectory. The severe impact of electricity
loadshedding should ease given the expected increase in
Eskom’s electricity supply as well as the ongoing expansion
of private sector electricity generation, though the unreliable
performance of Eskom’s existing fleet remains a major risk.
The impact of logistical challenges will probably ease only
modestly this year, with the operational benefits of the policy
interventions underway likely to prove slow to materialise.
Further slow improvements in the implementation of reforms
should boost potential gross domestic product (GDP) and
economic growth over the medium term.
■ One of the few potential global positives is the interest rate
relief expected from many of the key central banks from
around mid-2024. Domestic demand-driven inflation
pressures remain weak. Gradual further decline in South
Africa’s headline consumer price index (CPI) inflation towards
the mid-point of the inflation target band (by 2025) and lower
inflation risks should see the policy rate reverting to a more
neutral level over time. The prime interest rate is expected to
reduce to 10.75% by the end of 2024. Despite the elevated
fiscal risks, the expected retreat in global bond yield should
support South African bonds. Under these assumptions, there
is a scope for modest rand gains – notwithstanding weak
domestic fundamentals, the widening current account deficit
and possibly remaining on the Financial Action Task Force
(FATF) watchlist for a prolonged period.
■ The bear case scenario sees persistent inflation, with an
overtightening of policy rates leading to a global recession.
Locally, reform momentum wanes due, for example, to a less
benign election outcome than assumed in the base case. The
electricity supply situation is assumed to be worse in this case,
with more frequent and higher stages of loadshedding. Grid
capacity constraints dampen renewable energy investments,
while rail and port infrastructure challenges continue to
hamper trade. Adverse climate-change related events, such as
floods, are also assumed to be a more regular occurrence in
this scenario. In addition to the probability of the bearish
scenario exceeding that of the bullish scenario, the relative
severity of this case reflects the negative asymmetry of
the risks.
■ The bull scenario sees a combination of global inflation quickly
unwinding, policy rates moving lower earlier in 2024, global
growth recovering rapidly and domestic reforms gaining more
momentum. The electricity supply situation is slightly better
than assumed in the base case over the short term and
improves more materially in the medium term with stronger
investment in embedded generation and the unlocking of grid
capacity constraints. Reforms also yield private sector
participation in port and rail infrastructure. Business
confidence is higher, further boosting growth and the
employment intensity thereof.
Africa Regions economic expectation
The Africa Regions base case scenario comprises the following
outlook and conditions:
■ Growth in sub-Saharan Africa is expected to recover to around
4.0% in 2024 from around 3.3% in 2023. Notably, heightened
geopolitical tensions, high debt burdens and weather-related
shocks from the ongoing El Niño event will be the primary
downside risks for growth across sub-Saharan Africa in 2024.
■ El Niño will have a varied impact on growth across Africa,
especially considering technological advancements and
infrastructure improvements in the agricultural sector. East
African economies, such as Kenya, Uganda and Tanzania, are
already experiencing above-normal levels of rainfall, while the
southern parts, such as Malawi, Zambia and Mozambique,
have drier conditions.
■ Growth in most African economies is now approaching or has
already reached pre-pandemic averages, demonstrating their
resilience despite the confluence of recent shocks.
■ Growth in Kenya could ease to 5.1% in 2024 from an expected
5.6% in 2023 due to the impact of El Niño and rising domestic
arrears. In Uganda, growth will likely recover to 5.9% in
2023/24, from 5.2% in 2022/23, largely owing to increased oil
sector investment. For Zambia, growth is expected at 4.4% in
2024, only slightly down from 4.5% in 2023. Positively, the
non-mining economy has supported economic activity amid
weaker mining growth over the past year. Growth in Nigeria
could pick up to 3.4% in 2024 from 2.6% in 2023, due to
higher crude oil production and the government’s ongoing
efforts to curb oil theft, together with new production streams.
Angola, however, remains heavily reliant on its oil sector to
grow. Further, persisting foreign exchange liquidity challenges
informs our forecasts of Angola displaying poor growth
prospects, pointing to further deceleration of GDP growth, to
1.1% in 2024, as both oil sector investment and production will
likely remain subdued.
■ The formation of the G20 common market framework in 2020
following the implosion of debt sustainability of economies that
were already on the cusp prior to the pandemic, was expected
to expedite debt restructuring resolution and boost the journey
to restore debt towards more sustainable positions. Zambia,
Ethiopia and Chad were the first economies initially to apply for
debt restructuring under this framework, with Ghana following
suit in 2022. Now, nearly four years later, questions are arising
whether the common market framework needs to be
significantly refined or shelved altogether, as scepticism
towards its viability/usefulness grows. Further, the broad
diversity in creditors that hold Africa’s external debt has
notably pivoted towards a larger share owed to non-Paris Club
lenders, such as China, over the past two decades or so.
42 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Key management assumptions continued
-- 42 of 278 --
■ The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has advocated for a
proactive application of the IMF’s lending-into-arrears policy,
a strategy involving the IMF continuing to lend to countries
even when they fall behind on debt payments, incentivising
commercial creditors to agree to debt restructuring terms
similar to those accepted by other creditors. This principle
could be applied to Zambia’s current situation and provide
assurances to both creditors and debtors. Under the base case
scenario, Zambia could secure an external debt restructuring
deal in the second half of 2024, and Ghana could finalise an
external debt restructuring deal in the first half of 2024. It is
anticipated that Kenya will repay the USD2.0 billion Eurobond
on maturity in June 2024 and could also look to explore a
Eurobond issuance in the first half of 2024 should they receive
favourable pricing in the context of the current global risk
environment. Although, as they look to test the waters after
Cote d’Ivoire’s issuance in January 2023, their initial
endeavour was to issue a Eurobond in 2024/2025. The
government also remains keen to conduct a buyback of the
USD2.0 billion Eurobond, at par. Furthermore, Nigeria and
Angola may also consider issuing a Eurobond during 2024,
subject to global risk conditions.
■ The outlook for monetary policy in 2024 is somewhat mixed.
Most markets are likely to begin easing monetary policy
conditions from the second half of 2024. However, some
economies such as Kenya, Zambia, Egypt, Angola and even
Nigeria, are likely to tighten monetary conditions further in the
first half of 2024, while other markets, such as Ghana, may
even begin easing rates.
■ Indeed, positively, with a soft-landing scenario now broadly
expected for the global economy, risk appetite could be
restored. This may revive external funding sources, which
could bolster external positions and ease both foreign
exchange volatility and liquidity shortages, while also
anchoring inflation expectations. Enhanced geopolitical risks in
2024 could still bring about external account vulnerabilities.
■ The political calendar will be unusually busy in 2024 with
13 countries expected to hold elections across sub-Saharan
Africa, with Botswana, Mauritius, Mozambique, Ghana and
Namibia among them.
United Kingdom economic expectation
■ In the base case, global growth is around 2.5% in 2024, similar
to 2023 but still low in historical terms. Within this, the United
Kingdom (UK) is particularly weak, with next-to-no growth
predicted for 2024 as higher base rates in previous years
continue to constrain growth, and both business and
consumer sentiment remain weak. A recession, being two
consecutive quarters of negative growth, is possible but is
likely to be mild. Weak growth is expected to deliver further
falls in inflation, although it is likely that the easy part of the
disinflationary process has passed and further declines in
inflation towards the 2% target will be harder to achieve due to
high wage growth levels. Nonetheless, wage pressures will
ease moderately and this, together with the persistence of
weak growth and falls in inflation should allow the Bank of
England to reduce base rates in 2024. Lower base rates could
weaken the currency, but the base case assumes that the
Federal Reserve (the Fed) will be cutting policy rates as well
and the differential between the UK and United States (US) will
not change materially. In the base scenario, an easing in global
financial conditions brought about by Fed easing should lift
asset prices such as bonds and stocks. This is usually an
environment in which ʻriskier’ currencies such as the pound
gain, and ʻsafer’ currencies such as the dollar, fall. The base
case assumes that the 2024 election will be won by the
opposition Labour Party but is unlikely to have a material
impact on the growth and inflation outlook, nor financial
market performance compared to the continuation of a
Conservative government.
■ The bear scenario assumes that inflation is not only stubborn
but starts to re-accelerate. Supply chain stresses caused by
tensions in the Middle East, particularly as they impact
shipping through the Red Sea, are seen as one cause of price
pressure. Russia’s progress in defeating Ukraine could also
create more inflationary pressure, particularly where energy
and food are concerned. Wage persistence and continued
tightness of the labour market also keep inflation high, and the
Bank of England is forced to respond with higher base rates in
2024. Rates can be reduced in the longer-term, but the
increase in 2024 pushes the economy into a deeper recession
and causes more distress in interest-sensitive sectors such as
real estate. The pound falls, particularly against ʻsafe’
currencies such as the dollar even if this scenario does not see
the Fed have to raise policy rates in the same way as the Bank
of England.
■ The bull scenario sees inflation fall much faster than the base
case, causing base rates to be cut sooner and more deeply
than in the base case. Swift rate cuts, in turn, start to rapidly
revive the economy with interest-sensitive sectors such as real
estate recovering fast. And with wages outstripping inflation,
at least early in the forecast period, consumer confidence
improves and consumer spending returns rapidly. The sharp
fall in interest rates and the rebound in the economy leads to
improvement in the budget finances, allowing the new
government to further drive growth with tax cuts and/or
spending increases. The pound gains against the dollar on the
assumption that the rapid fall in inflation and deep cuts in
interest rates are seen in the US as well, with the result that
global economic and financial market optimism increases
significantly and pushes down the dollar as investors shun its
safe-asset attributes.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 43
-- 43 of 278 --
Main macroeconomic factors
The following table shows the main macroeconomic factors used to estimate the forward-looking impact on the ECL provision of
financial assets. Each scenario, namely base, bear and bull scenario, is presented for each identified time period.
Macroeconomic factors – 2023
Base scenario Bear scenario Bull scenario
20231
Next
12 months2
Remaining
forecast
period3
Next
12 months2
Remaining
forecast
period3
Next
12 months2
Remaining
forecast
period3
South Africa4
Inflation (%)* 5.90 5.13 4.47 6.40 5.94 4.74 3.91
Prime (%)* (period end) 11.75 10.75 10.50 12.50 11.50 10.50 10.00
Real GDP7 (%)* 0.60 1.43 1.81 (0.43) 0.70 2.09 2.49
Household credit (%)* 5.93 5.72 6.38 5.02 5.35 6.58 7.69
Exchange rate USD/ZAR* (period end) 18.52 18.10 18.07 21.49 19.49 17.02 16.94
Africa Regions5
(excluding Zimbabwe)
(averages)
Inflation (%)# 14.38 12.38 9.20 15.35 11.49 10.23 7.39
Policy rate (%)* 12.15 12.53 9.96 14.09 11.32 11.05 8.76
3m Tbill rate (%)* 10.79 11.41 9.94 13.68 12.31 9.76 7.58
6m Tbill rate (%)* 11.16 11.90 10.10 13.77 12.19 10.08 7.69
Real GDP7 (%)# 4.15 4.90 4.83 3.04 2.86 5.73 5.75
Africa Regions5 (averages)
Policy rate (%)* 19.60 18.00 12.12 20.21 15.36 11.15 9.02
3m Tbill rate (%)* 10.79 11.41 9.94 13.68 12.31 9.76 7.58
6m Tbill rate (%)* 11.16 11.90 10.10 13.77 12.19 10.08 7.69
Real GDP7 (%)# 3.95 4.57 4.62 2.68 2.54 5.93 6.17
UK6
Inflation (%)* 7.40 3.50 2.90 4.50 3.30 2.30 2.10
Policy rate (%)* 5.25 4.00 4.00 5.75 4.00 2.50 3.00
Exchange rate GBP/USD 1.27 1.30 1.35 1.28 1.22 1.50 1.47
Real GDP7 (%)# 0.30 0.10 1.50 (0.50) 1.60 0.80 2.30
1 Revised as at 31 December 2023. The 2023 (1 January 2023 to 31 December 2023) view disclosed as at 31 December 2022, has been revised due to the changes in the
macroeconomic factors.
2 Next 12 months following 31 December 2023 is 1 January 2024 to 31 December 2024.
3 The remaining forecast period is 1 January 2025 to 31 December 2027.
4 The scenario weighting is: base at 50%, bear at 30% and bull at 20%. The scenario weighting remains unchanged.
5 Where multiple jurisdictions are considered, weighted averages are used. The scenario weighted average is: base at 55%, bear at 28% and bull at 17%. The scenario
weighting remains unchanged.
6 The scenario weighting is: base at 50%, bear at 30% and bull at 20%. The scenario weighting remains unchanged.
7 Gross domestic product.
* Actual rates for 2023.
# Estimated base case rates for 2023 disclosed where 2023 actuals were not available upon release date.
44 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Key management assumptions continued
-- 44 of 278 --
Macroeconomic factors – 2022
Base scenario Bear scenario Bull scenario
20221
Next
12 months2
Remaining
forecast
period3
Next
12 months2
Remaining
forecast
period3
Next
12 months2
Remaining
forecast
period3
South Africa4
Inflation (%)* 6.85 5.60 4.45 7.09 5.20 5.23 3.81
Prime (%)* 10.50 10.75 10.50 11.75 11.00 10.50 10.00
Real GDP (%)* 1.86 1.62 2.01 0.41 1.01 1.99 2.58
Household credit (%)# 6.92 6.37 6.63 5.85 5.50 6.91 7.21
Exchange rate USD/ZAR 17.50 16.00 16.29 17.28 17.54 15.16 15.22
Africa Regions5 (excluding
Zimbabwe) (averages)
Inflation (%)# 12.80 11.19 6.85 13.37 9.02 9.36 5.99
Policy rate (%)* 9.76 11.66 9.80 13.30 10.87 10.51 8.61
3m Tbill rate (%)* 8.75 10.50 8.09 12.81 10.26 8.99 7.45
6m Tbill rate (%)* 9.68 11.89 9.03 13.79 11.47 10.18 8.49
Real GDP7 (%)# 3.40 3.56 4.57 2.31 2.83 4.94 5.95
Africa Regions5 (averages)
Policy rate (%)* 21.65 18.44 13.04 24.97 17.06 12.97 8.80
3m Tbill rate (%)* 8.75 10.50 8.09 12.81 10.26 8.99 7.45
6m Tbill rate (%)* 9.68 11.89 9.03 13.79 11.47 10.18 8.49
Real GDP7 (%)# 3.38 3.50 4.62 1.98 2.75 4.94 6.16
UK6
Inflation (%)* 9.00 7.00 2.50 10.00 1.80 5.00 1.90
Policy rate (%)* 3.50 4.25 2.00 5.00 1.50 3.00 1.60
Exchange rate GBP/USD* 1.21 1.28 1.38 1.10 1.35 1.32 1.45
Real GDP (%)# 4.00 (1.00) 1.60 (2.00) 1.50 1.00 2.20
1 Revised as at 31 December 2022. The 2022 (1 January 2022 to 31 December 2022) view disclosed as at 31 December 2021, has been revised due to the changes in the
macroeconomic factors.
2 Next 12 months following 31 December 2022 is 1 January 2023 to 31 December 2023.
3 The remaining forecast period is 1 January 2024 to 31 December 2026.
4 The scenario weighting is: base at 50%, bear at 30% and bull at 20%.
5 Where multiple jurisdictions are considered, weighted averages are used. The scenario weighted average is: base at 55%, bear at 28% and bull at 17%.
6 The scenario weighting is: base at 50%, bear at 30% and bull at 20%.
7 Gross domestic product.
* Actual rates for 2022.
# Estimated base case rates for 2022.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 45
-- 45 of 278 --
Sensitivity analysis of the forward-looking impact on the total ECL provision on all financial instruments
relating to corporate, sovereign and bank products
The ECL methodology for corporate, sovereign and bank products is based primarily on client specific risk metrics. As such the forward-
looking macroeconomic information is one of the components and/or drivers of the total reported ECL. Rating reviews of each client are
performed at least annually, and entails credit analysts completing a credit scorecard and incorporating FLI at a client level. The
weighting is reflected in both the determination of SICR as well as the measurement of the resulting ECL for the individual client.
Therefore the impact of forward-looking economic conditions is embedded into the total ECL for each client. Therefore the below
sensitivity analysis of the total ECL provision relating to the CIB client franchise excludes the impact of losses directly attributable to
distress experienced on sovereign exposures, held primarily for prudential or liquidity management purposes.
2023 2022
Total income
statement
charge
Rm
Total ECL
provision
Rm
Total income
statement
charge
Rm
Total ECL
provision
Rm
As reported 1 662 10 373 2 530 9 927
Scenarios
Base 1 595 10 306 2 435 9 832
Bear 1 902 10 613 2 856 10 253
Bull 1 474 10 185 2 258 9 655
Sensitivity analysis of the forward-looking impact on the total ECL provision on all financial instruments
relating to home services, VAF, card, personal, business lending and other products
The level of the forward-looking balance sheet provisioning was maintained at 2022 levels due to the challenging macroeconomic
environment, which was underpinned by aggressive monetary tightening, inflation and sharp and frequent changes in interest rates
and other consumer pressures.
The following table shows a comparison of the forward-looking impact on the provision as at 31 December 2023, based on the probability
weightings of the above three scenarios resulting from recalculating each of the scenarios using a 100% weighting of the above factors.
2023 2022
Income
statement
charge/
(release)
Rm
Forward-
looking
component
of ECL
provision
Rm
Income
statement
charge/
(release)
Rm
Forward-
looking
component
of ECL
provision
Rm
Forward-looking impact on the total ECL provision 44 2 182 165 2 172
Scenarios
Base (192) 2 000 (227) 1 780
Bear 754 2 979 1 834 3 840
Bull (493) 1 712 (1 150) 856
46 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Key management assumptions continued
-- 46 of 278 --
Management judgemental adjustments
As mentioned in the sections above in determining the forward-looking impact, from an IFRS 9 perspective, the group has forecast three
possible future macroeconomic scenarios, being the base, bear and bull scenarios, and attributed weightings to these three scenarios.
Determining these scenarios and the assumptions underlying them are complex.
Management judgemental adjustments are required in terms of IFRS 9 to take into account factors that do not form part of the normal
modelling process and/or the above mentioned macroeconomic scenarios. These factors are incorporated as part of management
judgemental adjustments. These factors may result from model or data limitations, recent events or expert credit judgement and are
applied at a segment, industry or client level. These management judgemental adjustments are reviewed as part of the governance
process surrounding credit risk and ECL.
Management judgemental adjustments incorporated in the calculation of ECL as set out below:
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
PPB and BCB industry and macroeconomic adjustments1 951 504
CIB sovereign adjustment2 400 400
Total 1 351 904
1 Additional impairments held to incorporate industry and macroeconomic factors which were not included in the underlying modelling. During 2023, industries
experiencing continued and increased risk, influencing the assumptions applied in determining ECL as discussed above, include the agriculture industry.
2 Additional impairments held to incorporate the credit risk relating to sovereigns.
3 The above disclosures, including comparatives, have been included from 2023 to provide a more appropriate analysis of out-of-model adjustments considering the
nature and characteristics thereof.
Refer to note 8, for the carrying amounts of loans and advances and to annexure C for the group’s assessment of the risk of loss arising out of the failure of
counterparties to meet their financial or contractual obligations when due.
Fair value
Financial instruments
In terms of IFRS, the group is either required to or elects to
measure a number of its financial assets and financial liabilities at
fair value, being the price that would, respectively, be received to
sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction
in the principal (or most advantageous) market between market
participants at the measurement date. Regardless of the
measurement basis, the fair value is required to be disclosed,
with some exceptions, for all financial assets and financial
liabilities. Fair value is a market-based measurement and uses
the assumptions that market participants would use when pricing
an asset or liability under current market conditions. When
determining fair value it is presumed that the entity is a going
concern and that fair value is not an amount that represents a
forced transaction, involuntary liquidation or a distressed sale.
Information obtained from the valuation of financial instruments
is used to assess the performance of the group and, in particular,
provides assurance that the risk and return measures that the
group has taken are accurate and complete.
Valuation process
The group’s valuation control framework governs internal control
standards, methodologies and procedures over its valuation
processes, which include the following.
Prices quoted in an active market
The existence of quoted prices in an active market represents
the best evidence of fair value. Where such prices exist, they are
used in determining the fair value of financial assets and
financial liabilities.
Valuation techniques
Where quoted market prices are unavailable, the group
establishes fair value using valuation techniques that incorporate
observable inputs, either directly, such as quoted prices, or
indirectly, such as those derived from quoted prices, for such
assets and liabilities. Parameter inputs are obtained directly from
the market, consensus pricing services or recent transactions in
active markets, whenever possible. Where such inputs are not
available, the group makes use of theoretical inputs in
establishing fair value (unobservable inputs). Such inputs are
based on other relevant input sources of information and
incorporate assumptions that include prices for similar
transactions, historic data, economic fundamentals, and
research information, with appropriate adjustments to reflect the
terms of the actual instrument being valued and current market
conditions. Changes in these assumptions would affect the
reported fair values of these financial instruments. Valuation
techniques used for financial instruments include the use of
financial models that are populated using market parameters
that are corroborated by reference to independent market data,
where possible, or alternative sources, such as, third-party
quotes, recent transaction prices or suitable proxies. The fair
value of certain financial instruments is determined using
industry standard models such as, discounted cash flow analysis
and standard option pricing models. These models are generally
used to estimate future cash flows and discount these back to
the valuation date. For complex or unique instruments, more
sophisticated modelling techniques may be required, which
require assumptions or more complex parameters such
as correlations, prepayment spreads, default rates and
loss severity.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 47
-- 47 of 278 --
Valuation adjustments
Valuation adjustments are an integral part of the valuation
process. Adjustments include, but are not limited to:
■ credit spreads on illiquid issuers
■ implied volatilities on thinly traded instruments
■ correlation between risk factors
■ prepayment rates
■ other illiquid risk drivers.
In making appropriate valuation adjustments, the group applies
methodologies that consider factors such as bid-offer spreads,
liquidity, counterparty and own credit risk. Exposure to such
illiquid risk drivers is typically managed by:
■ using bid-offer spreads that are due to the relatively low
liquidity of the underlying risk driver
■ raising day one profit or loss provisions in accordance with
IFRS (refer to note 2.4 and note 3.1)
■ quantifying and reporting the sensitivity to each risk driver
■ limiting exposure to such risk drivers and analysing exposure
on a regular basis.
Validation and control
All financial instruments carried at fair value, regardless of
classification, and for which there are no quoted market prices
for that instrument, are fair valued using models that conform
to international best practice and established financial theory.
These models are validated independently by the group’s model
validation unit and formally reviewed and approved by the market
risk methodologies committee. This control applies to both off-
the-shelf models, as well as those developed internally by the
group. Further, all inputs into the valuation models are subject
to independent price validation procedures carried out by the
group’s market risk unit. Such price validation is performed
on at least a monthly basis, but daily where possible given the
availability of the underlying price inputs. Independent valuation
comparisons are also performed and any significant variances
noted are appropriately investigated. Less liquid risk drivers,
which are typically used to mark level 3 assets and liabilities to
model, are carefully validated and tabled at the monthly price
validation forum to ensure that these are reasonable and used
consistently across all entities in the group. Sensitivities arising
from exposures to such drivers are similarly scrutinised, together
with movements in level 3 fair values. They are also disclosed
on a monthly basis at the market risk and asset and liability
committees.
Portfolio exception
The group has, on meeting certain qualifying criteria, elected the
portfolio exception which allows an entity to measure the fair
value of certain groups of financial assets and financial liabilities
on a net basis similar to how market participants would price the
net risk exposure at the measurement date. The total amount of
the change in fair value estimated using valuation techniques not
based on observable market data that was recognised in profit or
loss for 2023 was a net loss of R2 799 million
(2022: R3 198 million net loss). Other financial instruments,
not at level 3, are utilised to mitigate the risk of these changes
in fair value.
Refer to note 22 for the fair value disclosures.
Investment property valuations
Independent external valuers are appointed to conduct interim
and year-end valuations of investment properties. Among other
inputs, the independent valuers applied current market-related
assumptions to risks in rental streams of properties. The key
assumptions in the determination of the fair value are the exit
capitalisation rates and discount rates. Other inputs considered
relate to expense growth, rent reversion factors, rental growth,
existing tenant terms, location, vacancy levels and restrictions,
if any, on the sale or use of the asset.
The group applies judgement regarding the unit of account,
i.e. whether it should be valued as a stand-alone property or as a
group of properties. Determination of fair value also considers
the current use of the property in terms of its highest and best
use, taking into account the use of the asset that is physically
possible, legally permissible and financially feasible. Management
derived discount rates are risk adjusted to factor in liquidity and
asset class risk.
The fair values of the investment properties at
31 December 2023 have been revised in consultation with
external valuators, considering the current economic
environment and the estimated impact on all the valuation
inputs. There have been no changes applied to the unit of
account and derived use.
Refer to note 11 for investment property disclosures and note 22 for
fair value disclosures.
Consolidation of entities
The group controls and consolidates an entity (investee) where
the group has power over the entity’s relevant activities; is
exposed to variable returns from its involvement with the
investee; and has the ability to affect the returns through its
power over the entity, including structured entities (SEs).
Determining whether the group controls another entity requires
judgement by identifying an entity’s relevant activities, being
those activities that significantly affect the investee’s returns,
and whether the group controls those relevant activities by
considering the rights attached to both current and potential
voting rights, de facto control and other contractual rights
including whether such rights are substantive.
Interests in unconsolidated SEs that are not considered to
be a typical customer-supplier relationship are required
to be identified and disclosed. The group regards interest
to be a typical customer-supplier relationship where the level of
risk inherent in that interest in the SE exposes the group to a
similar risk profile to that found in standard market-related
transactions. The group sponsors an SE where it provides
financial support to the SE when not contractually required to
do so. Financial support may be provided by the group to an
SE for events such as litigation, tax and operational difficulties.
Refer to annexure A for detail on subsidiaries, consolidated and
unconsolidated structured entities within the group.
48 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Key management assumptions continued
-- 48 of 278 --
Significant influence – investment funds
The group accounts for its interests in investment funds as
associates where the group is the fund manager, for which there
is an irrevocable fund management agreement, and the group
has a monetary interest in the particular fund. Such associates
are equity accounted unless designated to be measured
at FVTPL.
Refer to annexure B for detail on associates and joint ventures.
Computer software intangible assets
The group reviews its assets under construction and assets
brought into use for impairment at each reporting date and tests
the carrying amount for impairment whenever events or changes
in circumstances indicate that the carrying amount (or
components of the carrying amount) may not be recoverable.
These circumstances include, but are not limited to, new
technological developments, obsolescence, changes in the
manner in which the software is used or is expected to be used,
changes in discount rates, significant changes in macroeconomic
circumstances or changes in estimates of related future cash
benefits. The impairment tests are performed by comparing an
asset’s recoverable amount to its carrying amount.
During 2023, the group’s computer software assets’ recoverable
amounts were not assessed to be lower than their carrying
amounts and were not impaired (2022: R386 million impairment
losses recognised). These impairments are excluded from the
group’s headline earnings.
The recoverable amount is determined as the higher of an asset’s
fair value less cost of disposal and its value in use. The value in
use is calculated by estimating future cash benefits that will
result for each asset and discounting those cash benefits at
an appropriate discount rate.
The review and testing of assets for impairment inherently
require significant management judgement as it requires
management to derive the estimates of the identified assets’
future cash flows in order to derive the asset’s recoverable
amount.
Refer to note 13 for intangible asset disclosure, as well as annexure F
for more detail on the accounting policy relating to computer software,
the capitalisation thereof, as well as amortisation and impairment
policies.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 49
-- 49 of 278 --
Goodwill impairment
In terms of IFRS, the group is required to, on an annual basis and when indicators of impairment are present, test its recognised goodwill
for impairment. The impairment tests are performed by comparing the cash-generating units’ (CGU) recoverable amounts to the
carrying amounts in the functional currency of the CGU being assessed for impairment. The recoverable amount is defined as the higher
of the entity’s fair value less costs of disposal and its value in use.
The review and testing of goodwill for impairment inherently requires significant management judgement as management needs to
estimate the identified CGU’s future cash flows. The principal assumptions considered in determining an entity’s value in use have been
reassessed at 31 December 2023 and include:
■ Future cash flows: the forecast periods adopted reflect a set of cash flows which, based on management’s judgement, external data
sources and expected market conditions, could be sustainably generated over such a period. A forecast period of greater than five
years has been used in order to take into account the level of development and anticipated growth rates relative to those markets and
allow forecasts to normalise for macroeconomic and industry factors. The cash flows from the final discrete cash flow period are
extrapolated into perpetuity to reflect the long-term plans for the entity. It is common valuation methodology to avoid placing too high
a proportion of the total value on the perpetuity value.
■ Discount rates: the cost of equity (COE) discount rates utilised in the equity pricing models are deemed appropriate based on the
entities under review. The risk-free rate used to determine the COE has been derived from appropriate long dated government bonds
adjusted for inflation differential and country risk yield. The future cash flows are discounted using the COE assigned to the
appropriate CGUs and by nature can have a significant impact on their valuations. No additional goodwill impairment loss has been
raised for the year ended 31 December 2023.
The following table summarises the impairment test methodology applied and the key inputs used in testing the group’s goodwill relating
to Stanbic IBTC Holdings PLC and Stanbic Holdings PLC.
Stanbic IBTC Holdings
PLC (Nigeria)
Stanbic Holdings
PLC (Kenya)
2023 2022 2023 2022
Discounted cash flow
Discount rate (nominal, post-tax) (%) 30.4 27 21.7 20.2
Terminal growth rate (nominal, post-tax) (%) 8.2 13.2 7.3 8.7
Forecast period (years)1 10 10 10 10
1 In the instance where the group values subsidiaries where the long-term strategy is to hold and grow the investment, the preferred approach is to value future cash
flows over a longer period in order to take account of periods of non-linear and linear growth and avoid a situation where too great a proportion of the value is derived
from the terminal cash flow period.
No goodwill impairment has been recognised during 2023 or 2022.
Note 13 summarises the group’s impairment test results and the main
components of goodwill.
Current and deferred taxation
The group is subject to direct and indirect taxation in a number of jurisdictions. There may be requirements which are determined with
reference to transactions and calculations for which the ultimate tax determination has an element of uncertainty in the ordinary course
of business. The group recognises provisions for tax based on objective estimates of the amount of taxes that may be due. Where the
final tax determination is different from the amounts that were initially recorded, such differences will impact the income tax and
deferred tax provisions, disclosed in note 14 and note 42, respectively, in the period in which such determination is made.
Uncertain tax positions are provided for in accordance with the criteria defined within IAS 12 and IFRIC® 23 Uncertainty over Income Tax
Treatments (IFRIC 23). Deferred tax assets are only recognised to the extent that sufficient taxable profits will be generated in order to
realise the tax benefit. Deferred tax assets are reviewed at each reporting date and are reduced to the extent that it is no longer probable
that the related tax benefit will be realised.
The most significant management assumption is the forecasts that are used to support the probability assessment that sufficient
taxable profits will be generated by the entities in the group in order to utilise the deferred tax assets.
50 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Key management assumptions continued
-- 50 of 278 --
Post-employment benefits
The group’s post-employment benefits consist of both post-employment retirement funds and healthcare benefits for South African
operations which have been deemed to be most material. The measurement of the group’s obligations to fund these benefits is derived
from actuarial valuations performed by the appointed actuaries taking into account various assumptions. The funds are subject to a
statutory financial review by the group’s independent actuaries at intervals of not more than three years.
The principal assumptions used in the determination of the group’s obligations include the following:
Retirement fund Post-employment medical aid fund
2023 2022 2023 2022
Discount rate Nominal government
bond curve
Nominal government
bond curve
Nominal government
bond curve
Nominal government
bond curve
Return on investments
(discount rate of term equal to
discounted mean term of
liabilities)
Between 10.87% and
13.28%
12.82 % Unfunded liability and
therefore there is no
asset-backing
portfolio
Unfunded liability and
therefore there is no
asset-backing portfolio
Salary/benefit inflation Inflation curve
adjusted upwards by
1% p.a
Inflation curve adjusted
upwards by 1% p.a.
Not applicable to fund Not applicable to fund
Medical cost inflation
(applicable to members who
retired before 1 January 2013)1
Not applicable to fund Not applicable to fund Inflation curve
adjusted upwards by
1% p.a
Inflation curve adjusted
upwards by 1% p.a
Medical cost inflation
(applicable to all other
members)
Not applicable to fund Not applicable to fund Difference between
the nominal and
index-linked bond
yield curve
Difference between the
nominal and index-linked
linked bond yield curve
Consumer price index (CPI)
inflation
Difference between
nominal and index
linked bond yield
curves
Difference between the
nominal and indexed
linked bond yield curve
Difference between
the nominal and
indexed linked bond
yield curve
Difference between the
nominal and indexed
linked bond yield curve
Pension increase in allowance 100% of the inflation
rate
100% of the inflation
rate
Not applicable to fund Not applicable to fund
Remaining service life of
employees (years)
7 years 3 months and
7 years 9 months
8 years and 1 month 3 years and 2 months 3 years and 7 months
Mortality assumption
– pre-retirement
Based on the SA98
Tables (Ultimate
Rates) with allowance
for mortality
improvements
Based on the SA98
Tables (Ultimate Rates)
with allowance for
mortality
improvements
Based on the SA98
Tables (Ultimate
Rates) with allowance
for mortality
improvements
Based on the SA98
Tables (Ultimate Rates)
with allowance for
mortality improvements
Mortality assumption
– post-retirement
Based on the
PA(90)-2 and SA98
Tables (Ultimate
Rates) with allowance
for mortality
improvements
Based on the SA98
Tables (Ultimate Rates)
with allowance for
mortality
improvements
Based on the PA(90) -
2 and SA98 Tables
(Ultimate Rates) with
allowance for
mortality
improvements
Based on the SA98
Tables (Ultimate Rates)
with allowance for
mortality improvements
1 This relates to members within the employment of Liberty Group Limited or Standard Bank of South Africa Limited.
Refer to note 48 for further details regarding the group’s post-
employment benefits.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 51
-- 51 of 278 --
Insurance contracts
Process used to decide on assumptions and
changes in assumptions
The measurement of insurance contract balances includes the
use of significant assumptions or estimates. The section below
provides details on certain significant assumptions regarding,
among others, future cash flows, discount rates, risk adjustment
for non-financial risk and confidence level. Assumptions used to
develop estimates about future cash flows are reassessed each
reporting period and adjusted where necessary.
The current estimate of future cash flows depends on the
assessment of the contract boundary term for the specific
contracts and the determination of expenses that relate directly
to the fulfilment of the contract. The estimates are based on a
probability-weighted mean of the full range of possible
outcomes, determined from the perspective of the group.
Mortality and morbidity
An appropriate base table of standard mortality or morbidity is
chosen depending on the type of contract and class of business.
Industry standard tables are used for smaller classes of
business. Company specific tables, based on graduated industry
standard tables modified to reflect the company specific
experience, are used for larger classes. Investigations into
mortality and morbidity experience are performed at least once
a year for all classes of business. The period of investigation
extends over at least the latest prior three full years.
Assumptions are set as the best estimate taking into account all
relevant information. The results of the investigation are an input
used to set the valuation assumptions, which are applied as an
adjustment to the respective base table. Regarding longevity, for
contracts insuring survivorship, an allowance is made for future
mortality improvements based on expected future trends.
Refer to annexure C for a summary on insurance risk sensitivities
regarding which assumptions are relevant to the respective
reportable groups.
Withdrawal
The withdrawal assumptions are based on the most recent
withdrawal investigations taking into account past as well as
expected future trends. The withdrawal investigations are
performed at least once a year for all classes of business. The
period of investigation extends over at least the latest prior three
full years. Assumptions are set as the best estimate taking into
account all relevant information. The withdrawal rates are
analysed by product type and policy duration as rates vary
considerably by these two factors. The surrender values
assumed are as per the terms and conditions and any other
applicable regulatory restrictions in place at the statement of
financial position date.
Risk adjustment for non-financial risk and
confidence level
The risk adjustment for non-financial risk is the compensation
the group requires for bearing the uncertainty about the amount
and timing of the cash flows arising from insurance risk and
other non-financial risks, such as lapse risk and expense risk. In
estimating the risk adjustment, the group mainly uses the COC
method. The COC method assesses the cost of holding capital
that would be sufficient to cover all non-financial risks over the
lifetime of the insurance contracts. It leverages off the risk
margin approach in SAM. Given the COC method does not rely
on a pre-specified confidence level for its calculation, the implied
confidence level is derived pragmatically by fitting a normal
distribution over a one-year period based off the SAM 99.5%
stress impact and solving for the confidence level that
corresponds to the quantum of the RA.
The risk adjustment confidence level for the COC for contracts
measured under GMM and VFA, as well as some claims in-
payment liabilities, has been derived at approximately 90%. For
short-contract boundary-type business measured under the
PAA, a bootstrapping methodology is utilised which targets a
confidence level of approximately 75%, given that the
uncertainty around non-financial risks is less than what would
exist for more complex, longer-dated contracts.
Expense modelling interpretation for future cash
flows
Fulfilment cash flows applicable to GMM and VFA contracts,
comprise estimates of future cash flows, an adjustment to reflect
the TVM and a risk adjustment for non-financial risk. Estimates
of future cash flows includes identifying all sets of cash flows
within the contract boundary that are directly related to the
fulfilment of a group of contracts. The following cash flows are
assessed with regards to directly attributable expenses (DAE):
acquisition costs (for example, commissions paid to advisors or
intermediaries on entering into new contracts), claims handling
costs, policy administration and maintenance costs, fixed and
variable overheads, costs that the group incurs in providing an
investment return service to investment related services, and
any other costs specifically chargeable under the insurance
contract. The group applies judgement to determine which
expenses meet the definition of DAE and which acquisition costs
are considered incremental to each portfolio. Expenses that
cannot be directly attributed to a portfolio of insurance
contracts, such as some product development and training
costs, sales branch infrastructure costs, general sales
conferences and sales executive team remuneration, are all
expensed to profit or loss as incurred.
The group applies consistent judgement to associated costs
related to applicable portfolios. The group applies the allocation
model based on the nature of the activity between activities
supporting acquisition and those supporting fulfilment and other
activities. For modelling purposes, a cost per policy proxy
approach is used where the expense base is converted to a per
policy loading, based on an analysis of the contracts being
assessed as either complex, simple or basic. The group has
adopted an overhead loading factor as a rational and systematic
method of allocating directly attributable overheads to groups of
contracts. This approach calculates a loading factor based on
the ration of GMM and VFA fulfilment costs to the total fulfilment
costs of all policyholder contracts (IFRS 9 and IFRS 17). This
ratio is then applied to the total qualifying overhead and indirect
support costs to determine the overhead loading factor.
In terms of indirect costs, the group has excluded any costs
related to brand and media, corporate finance activities, generic
product development and strategy related costs from DAE.
52 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Key management assumptions continued
-- 52 of 278 --
Discount rates
Cash flows are discounted using discount curves that reflect TVM, the characteristics of the cash flows and the liquidity characteristics
of the insurance contracts. Under IFRS 17, the discount rates to be applied depend on the nature of the cash flows.
For pure risk, life annuity, disability in payment and guaranteed endowment business, best estimate discount rates are set at risk free
rates consistent with the duration and nature of the cash flows allowing for an average illiquidity premium on the backing assets where
applicable.
For contracts with cash flows which do not vary with the underlying, e.g. guaranteed annuities, guaranteed investment plans, life risk
under GMM, the group has elected to use the top-down approach where the discount rates are derived off the actual backing assets as
the reference portfolio of assets. These backing assets reflect a mix of swap and bond-based assets and hence some tranches of
contracts are valued off a bond curve and some off a swap curve. Under the top-down approach, a risk-free discount rate curve is derived
by bootstrapping and extrapolating the applicable yield curve that reflects the expected return on the backing assets and making
required adjustments to remove credit risk. Given the illiquid nature of guaranteed annuities and guaranteed investment plans and
corresponding reference portfolios which contain illiquid assets, the derived discount rates used in the measurement of these liabilities
is expected to include an illiquid premium.
For contracts with cash flows that vary with the underlying, e.g. unit-linked direct participating contracts, as well as for embedded
derivatives, the group uses risk-neutral modelling, with the swap curve being used as the discount curve. These contracts are by nature
typically highly liquid contracts from which policyholders can easily withdraw and hence no illiquidity premium is expected to be
applicable when valuing them.
The table below shows the rate used to discount cash flows at the various terms, shown separately for the bond and swap curves.
%
1 Year 5 Years 10 Years 20 Years
2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022
Contracts with cash flows that vary with the underlying 8.36 7.95 8.32 8.59 9.82 9.83 10.69 9.92
Contracts with cash flows that do not vary with the
underlying with a swap-based reference asset portfolio 8.36 7.95 8.32 8.59 9.82 9.83 10.69 9.92
Contracts with cash flows that do not vary with the
underlying with a bond-based reference asset portfolio 9.00 8.33 9.69 9.57 12.08 11.85 14.61 12.80
The group's entities within Liberty Africa have used a bottom up approach in calculating discount rates for GMM and VFA measured
contracts.
Expense inflation
Expense inflation is determined with reference to the price of observable market inflation linked instruments. A market inflation curve is
constructed using the same principles as described above, for the discount rates. This compared with the results of the internal bottom-
up budgeting process to determine if any adjustment is needed to market implied inflation. The resultant inflation curve is then applied
to the cost per policy assumption to determine the expenses within the expected fulfilment cash flows.
Taxation
The group deems income minus expense (I-E) taxes, as determined under section 29 of the South African income tax, as specifically
chargeable to the policyholder and therefore includes it in the measurement of FCF. Assumptions as to the amount and timing of future
income tax and capital gains tax (CGT) payments are based upon the applicable tax law and rates effective as at the reporting date and
as set out in the Income Tax Act. Allowance is also made for dividends withholding tax at the rate applicable at the reporting date.
Correlations
The risk adjustment determined under the C0C approach leverages off the SAM risk margin. As part of this a Gaussian approach is used
which requires correlation assumptions to determine the liabilities at a 90% confidence interval. For this, the correlation assumptions
prescribed by the Financial Soundness Standards as issued by the Prudential Authority is used.
Contribution increases
The take-up rate of voluntary premium increases is based on the most recent take-up investigations analysis of past experience adjusted
for expected future changes if anticipated.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 53
-- 53 of 278 --
Judgements and methods used in
determining transition amounts on adoption
of IFRS 17
IFRS 17 became effective for the group on 1 January 2023 and
requires comparatives to be restated. The group determined the
opening balances on adoption of IFRS 17 at the first retrospective
restatement date, being 1 January 2022, as if IFRS 17 had always
been in place.
Where it is impracticable to apply the full retrospective
approach, an entity can choose between the modified
retrospective approach or the fair value approach to measure
the IFRS 17 opening balances on the first retrospective
restatement date. The group used a combination of all three
transition approaches.
IFRS 17 was applied using the full retrospective approach to all
contracts measured under the PAA. For contracts measured
under GMM or VFA, the full retrospective approach has been
applied for the majority of contracts recognised from
1 January 2017 onwards.
For contracts entered into prior to 1 January 2017, the group
concluded that it was impracticable to apply the full
retrospective approach, mainly as a result of the following:
■ The lack of accessibility and reliability of key sources of
historical data at the level of aggregation required for IFRS 17.
■ Assumptions and estimates at initial recognition could not be
determined without the use of hindsight.
■ Undue cost and effort would be required to determine the
specific risk adjustment required to apply in respect of data
prior to 1 January 2017.
Fair value approach
The fair value approach is used to determine the transition CSM
or loss component (LC) through an assessment of the probable
trading price for a similar group of insurance contracts in a
simulated deep and liquid market in terms of IFRS 13. IFRS 13
defines fair value as “the price that would be received to sell an
asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction
between market participants at the measurement date”.
The group assumes that the principal market would be other
registered insurers in the insurance industry in each applicable
territory. Due to regulatory restrictions, international markets for
insurance contracts are uncommon for the territories in which
the group operates. The group has used an income approach,
using a discounted cash flow method, which is based on future
expected cash flows or income and expenses, that are
discounted to a single current amount. The income approach
reflects the market expectations about those future amounts at
date of valuation.
The group has assumed that the purchaser of a group of
insurance contracts would be required to hold additional
regulatory capital to support these contracts, therefore included
a price adjustment for COC required, using an ROE assumption
of 20%. The ROE approach assumes that the acquirer’s view of
the FCF modelled under IFRS 17 will not be different to that
estimated by the group.
For contracts incepted within South Africa, regulatory capital is
referenced to the SAM framework. A point-in-time valuation was
performed as at 1 January 2022 and the CSM was derived as the
difference between the fair value in terms of IFRS 13 and the
IFRS 17 current value of FCF (including a risk adjustment for non-
financial risk). The CSM also includes an allowance for unhedged
market risk and operational risk, both of which are required
under the SAM framework. The group calculated the risk
adjustment by adjusting the SAM risk margin, which utilises COC
approach. The group used the SAM risk-free yield curve
published by the Prudential Authority as at 31 December 2021 in
the fair value calculation.
Contracts were grouped together in portfolios, but not into
annual cohorts for certain lines of business transitioned through
the fair value approach. Due to reasonable and supportable
information not being available to divide groups of contracts into
contracts issued within one year or less, the group of insurance
contracts were assumed to be profitable, unless there was
specific information to assume otherwise.
The fair value approach was applied mainly for:
■ non-participating annuities and investment-linked products
incepted prior to 2012; and
■ retail pure risk, universal and investment-linked products
incepted prior to 2017.
The group calculated the fair value and derived the CSM for the
applicable reinsurance contracts applying the same
methodology.
Modified retrospective approach
The objective of the modified retrospective approach is to
achieve the closest outcome to the full retrospective approach,
using reasonable and supportable information without undue
cost or effort, applying specified modifications.
For the modified retrospective approach, the group maximised
the use of information that would have been used to apply the
full retrospective approach.
The group applied modifications in the following areas:
■ The group classified the contracts into homogenous
portfolios, and, in general, determined which groups of
contracts should be included in the annual cohort groups.
Cash flows that could be sourced without undue cost or effort
and at the level of granularity required to perform the
calculation were used in the assessment of the contracts.
Alternatively, the group applied the modification permitted to
combine groups of contracts issued more than one year apart.
■ Due to impracticability, undue cost and effort to determine the
profitability criterion for each individual contract, the group
applied the modification where the CSM group under the
modified retrospective approach was only classified by
product and cohort period and not by profitability criteria.
■ If groups of insurance contracts, based on portfolio and cohort
period, were profitable or onerous, then either a CSM or LC
was recognised for that group of insurance contracts at the
first retrospective restatement date.
■ Where a discount rate could not be applied at the date of initial
recognition, the group determined a discount rate using an
observable yield curve which approximated the curve used by
the group for at least three years before the transition date.
If an observable yield curve did not exist or was not available
without undue cost and effort, the group estimated the yield
curve using an average spread over three years between the
group's curve and another observable curve that is readily
available.
■ The group applied the risk adjustment at the earliest
application date, adjusting for the expected risk release.
The expected release of risk was determined with reference to
the release of risk for similar contracts issued.
The modified retrospective approach enables an approximate
value at inception to be calculated for future FCF and risk
adjustment at inception to determine the CSM. The CSM is
projected to the transition date using coverage units. Service
provided in each period is determined by comparing the
remaining coverage units at the transition date with those
provided under the group of contracts before the transition date.
The modified retrospective approach was mainly applied to non-
participating annuities and key investment-linked product lines.
54 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Key management assumptions continued
-- 54 of 278 --
Key judgements applied on the application
of IFRS 17
Contracts scoped under IFRS 17 measurement
Definition and classification of contracts
The group assesses whether it accepts significant insurance risk
within the scope of IFRS 17 for each individual contract issued.
Insurance risk is significant if an insured event could cause the
group to incur additional costs that are significant in any single
scenario, excluding scenarios that have no commercial
substance, i.e. no discernible effect on the economics of the
transaction. The possibility of a loss is measured on a present
value basis.
The group applies judgement as to whether there is significant
insurance risk under the terms of contracts issued. For example,
certain contracts issued by the group guarantee a return of
contributions as the minimum death benefit, i.e. the higher of the
policyholder's original contribution or the unit value. The group
also exercises judgement in determining whether any contracts
should be classified as investment contracts with DPFs. An
assessment is made as to whether the investor would receive, as
a supplement to the amount not subject to the discretion of the
issuer, additional amounts that are expected to be a significant
portion of the total contractual benefits. Where it is concluded
that there is significant discretion contractually given to the
issuer; considering policyholders’ reasonable benefit
expectations, past practice by the group, industry practice, as
well as representations made to policyholders, these contracts
are classified as investment contracts with DPFs.
Application of the VFA
In addition to investment contracts with DPFs, insurance
contracts with a significant investment component are required
to be measured under the variable fee measurement approach.
Judgement is applied to the following criteria to assess whether
an insurance contract has a significant investment component
with direct participating features:
■ Investment returns are referenced to defined investment
portfolios or indices.
■ The entity expects to pay the policyholder an amount equal to
a substantial share of the fair value returns on the underlying
referenced investments.
■ A substantial proportion of any change in the amounts to be
paid to the policyholder vary with the change in the fair value
of the underlying items.
These criteria are assessed on a contract-by-contract basis at
contract inception and internally developed guidelines and value
thresholds are applied consistently across all applicable
contracts. If the guidelines are not met, the insurance contracts
are measured under the GMM.
Investment-related service contracts measured in terms of
IFRS 17 due to, for example, the inclusion of a return of
contribution on death benefit and meet the substantial criteria of
investment-related services due to a significant portion of the
total policy benefits arising from investment-related services.
The group determines significance by comparing benefits
derived from an investment return based on underlying items,
i.e. investment-related benefits, to the total policy benefits on a
present value probability-weighted average basis at inception of
the contract. Additional facts and circumstances such as the
intent of the contract when it was priced and sold to customers
as well as the policyholder expectations created at the inception
of the contract through the marketing material are also taken
into account in determining significant investment-related
benefits. In addition, the group assesses whether it expects to
pay the policyholder an amount equal to a substantial share of
the fair value returns on the underlying referenced investments,
where it is assessed that at least 70% of the total policy benefits
would need to be regarded as investment related benefits on a
present value probability weighted average basis at inception of
the contract.
For contracts where the investment benefit is expected to be
lower than 70%, further analysis of the facts and circumstances,
e.g. the intent of the contract when it was priced and sold to
customers as well as the policyholder expectations created at
the inception of the contract through the marketing material,
pertaining to that particular contract is assessed as to whether
these contracts should also be regarded as substantially
investment-related.
Application of the PAA measurement approach
For certain insurance contracts with a coverage period of more
than one year, the group has elected to apply the PAA at
inception of the group of contracts. This election is dependent on
a reasonable expectation that the PAA will provide an LRC
measurement that would not differ materially from the
application of the GMM. The group has developed internal
guidelines which include the use of projection models which
provide outcomes that satisfy pre-defined eligibility range
comparisons.
Use of measuring a combination of contracts
The group applies judgement to measure certain products with a
related annuity and life cover contractual benefit as one
combined contract. While each benefit, e.g. life annuity and
death, can be sold as a separate contract, the group assesses
whether the product is sold and priced as one coupled contract,
without any policyholder choice of cancelling either benefit
separately.
Initial contract assessment
The determination of whether a contract or a group of contracts
is onerous is based on the expectations as at the date of initial
recognition, with fulfilment cash flow expectations determined
on a probability-weighted basis. Contracts are initially allocated
into profitability groups, being onerous contracts, groups with no
significant possibility of becoming onerous, and groups of other
contracts. The group assumes a higher risk adjustment level at
initial recognition and measurement to determine the likelihood
of contracts that are expected to be profitable and that may in
the future become onerous.
If a contract is still profitable under the higher risk adjustment
level, it is deemed to be unlikely to become onerous. Otherwise,
contracts default into “groups of other contracts”. For contracts
measured using the VFA, market risk is also considered in
determining the threshold to differentiate between the
profitability groups.
Contracts with a continuation option
Certain contracts allow a policyholder an option to extend some
or all benefits. Where such option is subject to a repricing, i.e.
current pricing determination at the date of continuation, the
group deems the continuation option as a separate contract, if
elected.
Contracts that bestow annuity benefits that are
triggered through an insured event
Where an insured event establishes a claim liability, even if the
liability is subject to unknown claim eligibility time periods, such
as ill health, the group recognises in-claim payments as a LIC
and not as a separate annuity contract.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 55
-- 55 of 278 --
Coverage units to be utilised for release of the
CSM
For insurance contracts without DPFs and measured under the
GMM, coverage units are mainly referenced to the expected sum
assured in-force. For annuity-type contracts, coverage units are
the expected recurring annuity payments in-force in each period.
For both insurance contracts with DPFs and investment
contracts with DPFs measured under the VFA, the coverage
units are generally referenced to the maximum benefit, i.e. death
benefit, unit value or surrender value, as this incorporates the
insurance contract service provided, comprising insurance
coverage and investment-related service. The group elected to
discount the future coverage units expected to be provided by
the inflation rate, thereby capturing the services being provided
and the buying power of those services over the coverage period.
Coverage units
Coverage units are the mechanism by which the CSM is released
into profit or loss over time and conceptually reflects services
provided within a time interval. The CSM represent the
unrecognised profit for long contract boundary business.
The group has elected to discount using inflation to capture both
the service provided and the buying power of those services.
Investment component
The group reviews all contracts within the scope of IFRS 17 to
determine whether they includes an investment component and
to assess whether such a component would be non-distinct.
The group determines the investment component in an
insurance contract, amounts that the group is required to pay to
a policyholder in all circumstances, as the defined unit value
within the policyholder account. This typically references the
policy investment value at a point in time. Any additional
payments represent the insurance benefits payable if an insured
event occurs. The unit value is the total amount an investment
reflects, including the capital invested, i.e. deposits by the
policyholder, capital appreciation and/or income earned to date,
and reduces by annual charges for fund management. Surrender
values are not used as surrenders of policies are contingent on
policyholder behaviour and are not at the contractual option of
the group.
Refer to note 9 for insurance contract assets and liabilities
disclosures.
Provisions
The principal assumptions taken into account in determining the
value at which provisions are recorded, include determining
whether there is an obligation, as well as assumptions about the
probability of the outflow of resources and the estimate of the
amount and timing for the settlement of the obligation. For legal
provisions, management assesses the probability of the outflow
of resources by taking into account historical data and the status
of the claim in consultation with the group’s legal counsel. In
determining the amount and timing of the obligation once it has
been assessed to exist, management exercises its judgement by
taking into account all available information, including that
arising after the reporting date up to the date of the approval of
the financial results.
Refer to note 18 for provisions and other liabilities disclosures.
56 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Key management assumptions continued
-- 56 of 278 --
1. Cash and balances with central banks
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Coins and bank notes 22 322 21 373
Balances with central banks1 115 465 93 110
Total 137 787 114 483
1 Included in this balance is R91 250 million (2022: R75 971 million) that primarily comprises of reserving requirements held with central banks within the
countries of operation and are available for use by the group subject to certain restrictions and limitations levied by central banks within the respective
countries.
2. Derivative instruments
All derivatives are classified either as held-for-trading or held-for-hedging. A summary of the total derivative assets and
liabilities is shown in the table below.
Fair value of assets Fair value of liabilities
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Held-for-trading 93 959 71 124 (100 859) (82 982)
Held-for-hedging 3 448 3 243 (2 514) (2 067)
Held-for-hedging of a net investment 12 43
Total 97 419 74 410 (103 373) (85 049)
2.1 Use and measurement of derivative instruments
The risks associated with derivative instruments are monitored in the same manner as for the underlying instruments. Risks
are also measured across the product range in order to take into account possible correlations.
In the normal course of business, the group enters into a variety of foreign exchange, interest rate, commodity, credit and
equity derivative transactions in accordance with the group’s risk management policies and practices. Derivative instruments
used by the group are held for both trading and hedging purposes and include swaps, options, forwards, futures and other
similar types of instruments based on foreign exchange rates, interest rates, credit risk and the prices of commodities and
equities.
A summary of the total derivative assets and derivative liabilities are shown in the tables in note 2.2, 2.3.1, 2.3.3 and 2.3.8.
2.2 Derivatives held-for-trading
The group transacts derivative contracts to address client demand, both as a market maker in the wholesale market and in
structuring tailored derivatives for clients. The group also takes proprietary positions for its own account. Trading derivative
products include the following:
Fair value of assets Fair value of liabilities
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Foreign exchange derivatives 20 374 29 121 (15 680) (25 017)
Interest rate derivatives 54 141 32 503 (64 216) (36 166)
Commodity derivatives 392 1 637 (158) (911)
Credit derivatives 602 1 566 (3 123) (2 640)
Equity derivatives 18 450 6 297 (17 682) (18 248)
Total 93 959 71 124 (100 859) (82 982)
2.3 Derivatives and other financial instruments held-for-hedging
Where all relevant criteria are met, derivatives are classified as derivatives held-for-hedging and hedge accounting is applied
to remove the accounting mismatch between the derivative (hedging instrument) and the underlying instruments (hedged
item). All qualifying hedging relationships are designated as either fair value or cash flow hedges for recognised assets or
liabilities and highly probable forecast transactions. The group applies hedge accounting in respect of foreign currency risk,
equity risk and interest rate risk.
Refer to annexure F for more information on these hedging strategies.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2023 57
NOTES TO THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
-- 57 of 278 --
2. Derivative instruments continued
2.3 Derivatives and other financial instruments held-for-hedging continued
2.3.1 Derivatives designated as hedging instruments in fair value hedging relationships
Fair value
Net fair
value
Rm
Maturity
Contract/
notional
amount1
Rm
Fair value
(loss)/
gain
Rm
Assets
Rm
Liabilities
Rm
Less
than one
year
Rm
Between
one to
five
years
Rm
Over five
years
Rm
2023
Interest rate risk fair
value hedging
relationships 2 340 (1 729) 611 (214) (509) 1 334 427 869 (264)
Interest rate swaps 2 340 (1 728) 612 (214) (508) 1 334 427 684 (263)
Cross currency interest rate
swaps (1) (1) (1) 185 (1)
Total 2 340 (1 729) 611 (214) (509) 1 334 427 869 (264)
2022
Interest rate risk fair
value hedging
relationships 3 079 (1 363) 1 716 47 (201) 1 870 361 806 94
Interest rate swaps 3 079 (1 363) 1 716 47 (201) 1 870 361 806 94
Total 3 079 (1 363) 1 716 47 (201) 1 870 361 806 94
1 The notional amount is the sum of the absolute value of all contracts for both derivative assets and liabilities. The amount cannot be used to assess the
market risk associated with the positions held and should be used only as a means of assessing the group’s participation in derivative markets.
2.3.2 Hedged items classified as fair value hedges
Fair value
Accumulated
fair value
(loss)/gain
at
31 December
Rm
Fair value
gain/(loss)
used to
test hedge
ineffectiveness
Rm
Fair value
hedge
adjustments
for the year
Rm
Assets
Rm
Liabilities
Rm
2023
Interest rate risk fair value hedging
relationships
Financial investments 51 469 (723) 411 411
Loans and advances 56 154 55 1 266 1 266
Deposits and debt funding (209 608) 898 (1 230) (1 230)
Subordinated debt (7 347) 99 (158) (158)
Total 107 623 (216 955) 329 289 289
2022
Interest rate risk fair value hedging
relationships
Financial investments 27 775 (1 096) (1 469) (1 469)
Loans and advances 5 531 (1 293) (2 202) (2 202)
Deposits and debt funding1 (174 217) 1 555 3 157 3 157
Subordinated debt (7 057) 255 472 472
Total 33 306 (181 274) (579) (42) (42)
1 Restated. During 2023 it was noted that the fair value of liabilities was erroneously included as R12 741 million instead of R174 217 million in 2022. The
restatement had no impact on the group’s income statement or the group’s statement of financial position.
58 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 58 of 278 --
2.3.3 Hedging instruments in cash flow hedging relationships
Maturity analysis
Fair
value of
assets
Rm
Fair
value of
liabilities
Rm
Net fair
value
Rm
Less
than one
year
Rm
Between
one to
five
years
Rm
Over five
years
Rm
Contract/
notional
amount1
Rm
Fair
value
(loss)/
gain
Rm
2023
Foreign currency risk cash
flow hedging relationships 2 681 (764) 1 917 2 498 9 (590) 12 642 (446)
Cash2 2 523 2 523 2 523 2 523 46
Currency forwards 158 (469) (311) (25) 9 (295) 9 928 (363)
Currency swaps (295) (295) (295) 191 (129)
Equity price risk cash flow
hedging relationships 61 (21) 40 40 440 31
Equity forwards 61 (21) 40 40 440 31
Interest rate risk cash flow
relationships 889 889 (17) 883 23 47 150 938
Interest rate swaps 889 889 (17) 883 23 47 150 938
Total 3 631 (785) 2 846 2 521 892 (567) 60 232 523
2022
Foreign currency risk cash
flow hedging relationships 1 051 (645) 405 626 13 (234) 7 598 (266)
Cash2 912 912 912 912 2
Currency forwards 139 (127) 11 (2) 13 6 179 (90)
Currency swaps (518) (518) (284) (234) 507 (178)
Equity price risk cash flow
hedging relationships 25 (25) (1) 20 (21) 457 66
Equity forwards 25 (25) (1) 20 (21) 457 66
Interest rate risk cash flow
relationships (34) (34) (43) (13) 22 11 450 (46)
Interest rate swaps (34) (34) (43) (13) 22 11 450 (46)
Total 1 076 (704) 370 603 (21) (212) 19 505 (246)
1 The notional amount is the sum of the absolute value for both derivatives assets and liabilities. The amount cannot be used to assess the market risk
associated with the positions held and should be used only as a means of assessing the group’s participation in derivative contracts.
2 The group has executed a hedge using cash as the hedging instrument. The cash is presented within loans and advances on the statement of financial
position.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 59
-- 59 of 278 --
2. Derivative instruments continued
2.3 Derivatives and other financial instruments held-for-hedging continued
2.3.4 Hedge items classified as cash flow hedges
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Fair value gain/(loss) used to test hedge ineffectiveness
Financial investments 621 372
Foreign currency risk cash flow hedging relationships 621 372
Loans and advances (711) 284
Foreign currency risk cash flow hedging relationships 220 241
Interest rate risk cash flow hedging relationships (931) 43
Share scheme liabilities (excludes equity-settled share schemes) (31) (66)
Equity price risk cash flow hedging relationships (31) (66)
Other operating expenses (46) (2)
Foreign currency risk cash flow hedging relationships (46) (2)
Net interest income (199) (239)
Foreign currency risk cash flow hedging relationships (199) (239)
Total (366) 349
2.3.5 Hedge ineffectiveness recognised in profit or loss
Hedge ineffectiveness in qualifying hedge relationships arises predominantly due to the presence of costs contained within
hedging instruments. This ineffectiveness was recognised in profit or loss together with the gains and losses on the underlying
hedged item according to the nature of the risk being hedged as follows:
Trading
revenue
Rm
Net interest
income
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Fair value hedges 25 25
Interest rate risk fair value hedging relationships 25 25
Cash flow hedges1 157 157
Foreign currency risk cash flow hedging relationships 150 150
Interest rate risk cash flow hedging relationships 7 7
Total 157 25 182
2022
Fair value hedges 52 52
Interest rate risk fair value hedging relationships 52 52
Cash flow hedges1 103 103
Foreign currency risk cash flow hedging relationships 106 106
Interest rate risk cash flow hedging relationships (3) (3)
Total 103 52 155
1 Ineffectiveness relating to highly probable forecast transactions no longer expected to occur during both 2023 and 2022 amounted to Rnil. There was no
material ineffectiveness relating to basis in relation to foreign currency hedging relationships during 2023 and 2022.
60 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 60 of 278 --
2.3.6 Reconciliation of movements in the total hedge reserve
Foreign
currency
risk
Rm
Equity
price
risk
Rm
Interest
rate
risk
Rm
Cost of
hedging1
Rm
Total
Rm
Balance at 1 January 2022 (75) (15) 1 (13) (102)
Amounts recognised directly in OCI before tax2 (272) 67 (43) 18 (230)
Amounts released to profit or loss before tax 545 (75) 2 4 476
Interest income (4) (4)
Interest expense 232 232
Trading revenue 132 2 8 142
Other operating expenses 181 (75) 106
Taxation (16) 1 11 (7) (11)
Transactions with non-controlling interests (31) (12) (43)
Balance as at 31 December 2022 151 (22) (29) (10) 90
Balance at 1 January 2023 151 (22) (29) (10) 90
Amounts recognised directly in OCI before tax2 (469) 31 932 26 520
Amounts released to profit or loss before tax 575 14 (10) (39) 540
Interest income (39) (39)
Interest expense 231 231
Trading revenue 422 (10) 412
Other operating expenses (78) 14 (64)
Taxation (7) (6) (248) 3 (258)
Balance at 31 December 2023 250 17 645 (20) 892
1 The cost of hedging includes foreign currency basis risk of R13 million (2022: R9 million) and forward element of R6 million (2022: R1 million) which have
been specifically excluded from the hedge relationships.
2 Includes dividends received on equity forwards during the year.
2.3.7 Hedges classified as cash flow hedges
The forecasted timing of the release of the net cash flows from the total hedge reserve into profit or loss at 31 December
is as follows:
Three
months
or less
Rm
After
three
months but
within
one year
Rm
After
one year
but within
five
years
Rm
More than
five years
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Net cash inflow/(outflow) 103 221 637 (69) 892
2022
Net cash inflow/(outflow) 31 155 (23) (73) 90
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 61
-- 61 of 278 --
2. Derivative instruments continued
2.3 Derivatives and other financial instruments held-for-hedging continued
2.3.8 Derivatives designated as hedging instruments in a hedge of a net investment
Fair value
Net fair
value
Rm
Maturity
Contract/
notional
amount1
Rm
Fair
value
gain2
Rm
Assets
Rm
Liabilities
Rm
Less
than one
year
Rm
2023
Foreign currency risk fair value hedging
relationships 12 12 11 143 7
Currency forwards 12 12 11 143 7
Total 12 12 11 143 7
2022
Foreign currency risk fair value hedging
relationships 43 43 43 85 43
Currency forwards 43 43 43 85 43
Total 43 43 43 85 43
1 The notional amount is the sum of the absolute value of all contracts for both derivative assets and liabilities. The amount cannot be used to assess the
market risk associated with the positions held and should be used only as a means of assessing the group’s participation in derivative markets.
2 This fair value gain has been used to test effectiveness of the net investment hedge. The fair value loss on the hedged item is equal and opposite to the
fair value gain on the hedging instrument and did not result in material ineffectiveness for the net investment hedge.
2.4 Day one profit or loss
The table below sets out the aggregate net day one profit or loss yet to be recognised in profit or loss at the beginning and end
of the year with a reconciliation of changes in the balances during the year.
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Unrecognised net profit at the beginning of the year 787 1 209
Additional net profit on new transactions1 195 121
Recognised in trading revenue during the year (366) (543)
Unrecognised net profit at the end of the year 616 787
1 Transaction price was not the best evidence of fair value due to trade-related market factors that were deemed unobservable in the principal market of
the underlying trades.
3. Trading assets
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Collateral and other 7 857 12 928
Corporate bonds and floating rate notes 25 932 33 154
Government, municipality and utility bonds 110 356 83 799
Listed equities 76 698 90 032
Reverse repurchase and other collateralised agreements 79 969 81 380
Unlisted debt securities 15 703 13 625
Total 316 515 314 918
3.1 Day one profit or loss
The table below sets out the aggregate net day one profit or loss yet to be recognised in profit or loss at the beginning and end
of the year with a reconciliation of changes in the balances during the year.
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Unrecognised net profit at the beginning of the year 471 1 193
Additional net profit on new transactions1 1 603 6
Recognised in trading revenue during the year (815) (728)
Unrecognised net profit at the end of the year 1 259 471
1 Transaction price was not the best evidence of fair value due to trade-related market factors that were deemed unobservable in the principal market of
the underlying trades.
62 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 62 of 278 --
4. Pledged assets
The following table presents details of other financial assets which have been sold or otherwise transferred, but which have not
been derecognised in their entirety or which were partially derecognised together with their associated liabilities. This table
does not disclose the total risk exposure in terms of these transactions, instead it provides disclosures as required by IFRS.
Carrying
amount of
transferred
assets
Rm
Carrying
amount of
associated
liabilities1
Rm
Fair
value of
transferred
assets2
Rm
Fair
value of
associated
liabilities1,2
Rm
Net
fair value2
Rm
2023
Bonds 19 037 (16 029) 19 038 (16 029) 3 009
Listed equities 1 173 1 173 1 173
Total 20 210 (16 029) 20 211 (16 029) 4 182
2022
Bonds3 18 130 (14 103) 18 130 (14 103) 4 027
Listed equities 1 178 1 178 1 178
Total 19 308 (14 103) 19 308 (14 103) 5 205
1 Materially comprises of reverse repo liabilities, which form part of the deposits and debt funding line within the statement of financial position.
2 Where the counterparty has recourse to the transferred asset.
3 Restated. During 2023 it was noted that the carrying amount of associated liabilities, fair value of transferred assets and fair value of associated liabilities
for bonds was erroneously included as R19 200 million instead of R18 130 million in 2022. The restatement had no impact on the group’s income
statement or the group’s statement of financial position.
The assets pledged by the group are strictly for the purpose of providing collateral to the counterparty. To the extent that the
counterparty is permitted to sell or repledge the assets in the absence of default, they are classified in the statement of financial
position as pledged assets.
The majority of other financial investments that do not qualify for derecognition include debt securities held by counterparties as
collateral under repurchase agreements, listed equities held as collateral under scrip lending transactions and financial assets leased
out to third parties. Risks the group remains exposed to include credit and interest rate risks.
During the current financial year, there were no instances of financial assets that were sold or otherwise transferred, but which were
partially derecognised. Further, there were no instances of financial assets transferred and derecognised for which the group had
continuing involvement.
4.1 Collateral accepted as security for assets
As part of the reverse repurchase and securities borrowing agreements, the group has received securities which are not recorded in
the statement of financial position that it is allowed to sell or repledge. The fair value of the financial assets accepted as collateral that
the group is permitted to sell or repledge in the absence of default is R208 017 million (2022: R179 093 million).
The fair value of financial assets accepted as collateral and commodities received through commodity leases that have been sold,
repledged or leased in terms of repurchase agreements or leasing transactions is R30 300 million (2022: R24 621 million).
These transactions are conducted under terms that are usual and customary to reverse repurchase and securities borrowing
activities.
4.2 Assets transferred not derecognised
Securitisations
The group enters into transactions in the normal course of business by which it transfers recognised financial assets directly to third
parties or SEs. These transfers may give rise to full derecognition of the financial assets concerned.
Full derecognition occurs when the group transfers substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership and its contractual right to
receive cash flows from the financial assets or retains the contractual rights to receive the cash flows of the financial assets but
assumes a contractual obligation to pay the cash flows to one or more recipients in an arrangement that meets IFRS derecognition
requirements. The risks include interest rate, currency, prepayment and other price risks. However, where the group has retained
substantially all of the credit risk associated with the transferred assets, it continues to recognise these assets.
2023
During 2023, there we no securitised financial assets that did not qualify for derecognition.
2022
The group invests in securitisation vehicles specifically introduced to provide home service lending collateral against the committed
liquidity facility (CLF). To access the CLF, the SARB requires a portfolio of collateral, which is identified as a portfolio of mortgage
loans. The SARB requires that these assets are ring-fenced in a separate legal entity, supported by a clearly defined note structure.
During 2022, the assets within these SEs were settled and no new transactions have been entered into since, thus the cumulative
carrying amount of securitised financial assets that did not qualify for derecognition, the associated liabilities, as well as any ceded
interests and rights, have reduced to Rnil from 31 December 2022.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 63
-- 63 of 278 --
5. Disposal group assets and liabilities held for sale
2023 2022
Gross
Rm
Remeasurement
Rm
Net
Rm
Gross
Rm
Net
Rm
Insurance & Asset Management 254 (19) 235 290 290
Banking 265 265
Total assets classified as held for sale 254 (19) 235 555 555
Property, equipment and right of use assets 254 (19) 235 300 300
Goodwill and other intangible assets (note 13) 255 255
2023
Intangible asset held for sale
During 2023, this non-current asset held for sale was concluded resulting in the derecognition of the asset. As a result of the
full transaction, SBSA has also recognised an investment in a joint venture which has been appropriately disclosed. The full
transaction resulted in a pre-tax profit of R42 million, which is included in the headline adjustable items for the year. This
transaction was included in the corporate and investment banking segment.
Disposal group assets and liabilities
The group of owner-occupied properties of R254 million, before remeasurement, remained subject to a conditional
agreement of sale and therefore remained classified as non-current assets held for sale and measurement is referenced to
the conditional offer. During 2023, the property was remeasured to the latest offer price of R235 million, resulting in a
remeasurement loss of R19 million being recognised. In addition, certain investment properties in Kenya amounting to
R16 million that were classified as held for sale at 31 December 2021 have subsequently been sold at the measured value.
The appropriate level of management is committed to a plan to sell the owner-occupied properties. The transaction is
expected to be concluded during 2024.
The potential sales are not discontinued operations as defined under IFRS 5 Non-current Assets Held for Sale and Discontinued
Operations (IFRS 5) as they are not disposals of separate major lines of business or geographical areas of operation. Profit or
loss from cash generating units within disposal groups have consequently not been separately identified in the income
statement.
2022
Intangible asset held for sale
During December 2021, the appropriate level of management was committed to a plan to sell an intangible asset (software
system). The transaction was expected to be concluded during 2022. As such, the requirements of IFRS 5 were met during
December 2021 and the intangible asset had been separately disclosed as non-current assets held for sale on the statement
of financial position. However, due to delays caused by the complexity of the externalisation of the intangible asset and the
multiple external stakeholder dependencies, the sale of the intangible asset was not completed during 2022. These delays
were not within the control of the group. As management remains committed to the sale of the intangible asset and the
transaction is due to be completed during 2023, the IFRS 5 classification of the intangible asset as held for sale has been
extended for a further 12 months. The asset is measured at the lower of the carrying amount and fair value less costs to sell.
The fair value less costs to sell is based on an assessment of what management believes a purchaser would value the asset,
considering the current business viability and operations. The intangible asset was not impaired at 31 December 2021 and as
at 31 December 2022 and the carrying value amounted to R255 million. This is included in the corporate and investment
banking segment.
Disposal group assets and liabilities
The Total Health Trust Limited, previously classified as held for sale under IFRS 5, within IAM, was disposed of effective
31 December 2022, whereby Liberty concluded the sale of its entire shareholding in Total Health Trust Limited, for a purchase
considerations of USD7.6 million (R130 million). The sale was concluded at the net asset value of the entity as at 31 December
2022.
A group owned property of R274 million remained subject to a conditional agreement of sale and therefore remained
classified as non-current assets held for sale and measurement is referenced to the conditional offer. In addition, certain
investment properties in Kenya amounting to R71 million that were classified as held for sale at 31 December 2021 have
subsequently been sold at the measured value. One property measured at R16 million remained classified as non-current
assets held for sale.
The potential sales are not discontinued operations as defined under IFRS 5 as they are not disposals of separate major lines
of business or geographical areas of operation. Profit or loss from CGUs within disposal groups have consequently not been
separately identified in the statement of comprehensive income.
64 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 64 of 278 --
6. Financial investments
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Corporate 60 884 84 019
Sovereign 346 365 327 757
Bank2 66 588 62 950
Mutual funds and unit-linked investments 170 501 139 207
Listed equities 87 020 82 832
Unlisted equities 3 189 3 140
Interest in associates held at fair value (annexure B) 21 441 18 661
Other instruments 2 788 3 928
Total 758 776 722 494
Net financial investments measured at amortised cost 266 694 222 843
Gross financial investments measured at amortised cost 267 107 224 119
ECL for financial investments measured at amortised cost3 (413) (1 276)
Financial investments measured at fair value 492 082 499 651
Financial investments measured at FVTPL 420 051 417 038
Debt financial investments measured at FVOCI4,5 70 439 81 708
Equity financial investments measured at FVOCI5 1 592 905
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 Included in bank is an amount of R14 809 million (2022: R14 277 million ) relating to cash balances with banks that qualifies as cash equivalents (note
46.5).
3 Refer to note 39 for the credit impairment release for the current year of R359 million (2022: R1 082 million charge) on financial investments measured
at amortised cost.
4 Refer to note 39 for the credit impairment charge for the current year of R200 million (2022: R265 million release) on debt financial investments
measured at FVOCI.
5 Refer to note 22.5.1 for the reconciliation of FVOCI reserve for equity financial investments and note 22.5.2 for the reconciliation of FVOCI reserve for
debt financial investments.
7. Receivables and other assets
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Financial assets 22 743 26 329
Investment receivables2,3 569 111
Retirement funds (note 48) 1 628 1 400
Trade settlement assets2 19 812 22 593
Operating leases – accrued income (note 11) 564 547
Other financial assets2,4 170 1 678
Non-financial assets 10 739 13 318
Deferred acquisition costs5 520 569
Items in the course of collection 3 375 3 443
Prepayments 5 527 4 504
Properties in possession 493 567
Other non-financial assets 824 4 235
Total 33 482 39 647
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 Due to the short-term nature of these assets, historical experience and FLI, debtors are regarded as having a low PD; therefore ECL is insignificant on
these asset balances and they are disclosed on a net of ECL in the above table.
3 Investment receivables has been updated to better reflect the nature of the balances included (previously referred to as investment debtors).
4 Restated. Accounts receivable has been aggregated into other financial assets to better reflect management’s analysis of the balance. The prior year has
been updated for this aggregation. The aggregation had no impact on the group’s statement of financial position.
5 Restated. Refer to insurance acquisition cashflows on pages 88 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact. Deferred acquisition costs
previously included insurance acquisition cash flows which have now been excluded. The remaining deferred acquisition costs relate to contract costs
for investment management services.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 65
-- 65 of 278 --
8. Loans and advances
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Loans and advances – IAM1 898 2 362
Loans and advances – Banking 1 607 948 1 502 578
Loans and advances measured at fair value 715 665
Net loans and advances measured at amortised cost1 1 607 233 1 501 913
Gross loans and advances measured at amortised cost 1 671 228 1 557 741
Home services 466 734 459 647
Vehicle and asset finance 126 754 119 859
Card and payments 38 934 38 063
Personal unsecured lending 104 741 102 579
Business lending and other 140 604 147 712
Corporate and sovereign 597 373 516 211
Bank2 196 088 173 670
ECL on loans and advances (note 8.1) (63 995) (55 828)
Total loans and advances 1 608 846 1 504 940
1 Loans and advances attributable to the IAM business unit has been disaggregated for a better analysis of the amounts. Due to the nature of these loans
and advances, the loans and advances within IAM are regarded as having a low probability of default. Therefore, ECL has been assessed to be insignificant
on these balances. Refer to note 49 for details relating to business unit reporting.
2 Included in bank is an amount of R52 593 million (2022: R77 481 million) relating to on-demand gross loans and advances to banks that qualify as cash
equivalents (note 46.5).
66 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 66 of 278 --
8.1 Reconciliation of ECL for loans and advances at amortised cost
2023 2022
Stage 1
Rm
Stage 2
Rm
Stage 3
Rm
Total
Rm
Stage 1
Rm
Stage 2
Rm
Stage 3
Rm
Total
Rm
Opening ECL 6 836 10 351 38 641 55 828 6 390 8 879 36 129 51 398
Transfers between stages1 80 (828) 748 615 (492) (123)
Net impairments (released)/
raised5 177 1 687 14 556 16 420 (150) 1 803 11 607 13 260
ECL on new exposure raised2 2 200 1 406 2 443 6 049 2 213 1 285 2 850 6 348
Subsequent changes in ECL5 (1 175) 615 13 275 12 715 (1 891) 814 9 388 8 311
Change in ECL due to
derecognition (848) (334) (1 162) (2 344) (472) (296) (631) (1 399)
Impaired accounts written off 3 (11 632) (11 632) (11 534) (11 534)
Exchange and other movements4,5 (176) (70) 3 625 3 379 (19) 161 2 562 2 704
Closing ECL 6 917 11 140 45 938 63 995 6 836 10 351 38 641 55 828
1 The group’s policy is to transfer opening balances based on the ECL stage at the end of the reporting period. Therefore exposures can appear to be
transferred directly from stage 3 to stage 1 as the curing requirements would have been satisfied during the reporting period. Furthermore, the ECL
recognised on new exposures originated during the reporting period (which are not included in opening balances) are included within the column ʻECL
on new exposure raised’ based on the exposures’ ECL stage as at the end of the reporting period. It is therefore possible to disclose new/originated
exposures in stage 2 and 3.
2 The ECL recognised on new exposures originated during the reporting period (which are not included in opening balances) are included within the rows
ʻECL on new exposures raised’ based on the exposures’ ECL stage as at the end of the reporting period.
3 The contractual amount outstanding on loans and advances that were written off during the year that are still subject to enforcement activities is
R5.8 billion (2022: R4.7 billion).
4 Exchange and other movements includes the net interest in suspense (IIS), TVM unwind, raised and released during the year.
5 Restated. Refer to pages 30 to 39 for further details relating to the restatement.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 67
-- 67 of 278 --
8. Loans and advances continued
8.1 Reconciliation of ECL for loans and advances at amortised cost continued
8.1.1 Reconciliation of the ECL for loans and advances at amortised cost, by product
Opening
ECL
Rm
Transfer between stages Net
impairments
raised/
(released)
Rm
Impaired
accounts
written off
Rm
TVM unwind
and IIS
movements
Rm
Exchange
and other
movements
Rm
Closing
ECL
Rm
(From)/to
stage 1
Rm
(From)/to
stage 2
Rm
(From)/to
stage 3
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Home services 16 429 (185) 100 85 3 014 (1 512) 1 315 (430) 18 816
Stage 1 925 100 85 185 (41) 12 1 081
Stage 2 2 707 (100) (100) 846 (100) 3 353
Stage 3 (including IIS) 12 797 (85) (85) 2 209 (1 512) 1 315 (342) 14 382
Vehicle and asset finance 7 381 (133) 289 (156) 1 827 (1 598) 364 (485) 7 489
Stage 1 810 110 23 133 (202) (106) 635
Stage 2 1 933 (110) (179) (289) 203 (213) 1 634
Stage 3 (including IIS) 4 638 (23) 179 156 1 826 (1 598) 364 (166) 5 220
Card and payments 3 825 (80) 146 (66) 2 200 (1 859) 299 (27) 4 438
Stage 1 724 98 (18) 80 (109) 5 700
Stage 2 1 139 (98) (48) (146) 122 (7) 1 108
Stage 3 (including IIS) 1 962 18 48 66 2 187 (1 859) 299 (25) 2 630
Personal unsecured lending 10 662 136 50 (186) 4 199 (3 615) 1 088 285 12 619
Stage 1 1 480 9 (145) (136) 226 67 1 637
Stage 2 2 424 (9) (41) (50) 226 (152) 2 448
Stage 3 (including IIS) 6 758 145 41 186 3 747 (3 615) 1 088 370 8 534
Business lending and other 8 060 183 242 (425) 3 260 (1 928) 413 (305) 9 500
Stage 1 830 112 (295) (183) 240 (121) 766
Stage 2 1 236 (112) (130) (242) 271 425 1 690
Stage 3 (including IIS) 5 994 295 130 425 2 749 (1 928) 413 (609) 7 044
Corporate and sovereign 9 324 (1) 1 1 928 (1 120) 902 (55) 10 979
Stage 1 1 961 11 (10) 1 92 (49) 2 005
Stage 2 871 (11) 10 (1) (2) (22) 846
Stage 3 (including IIS) 6 492 10 (10) 1 838 (1 120) 902 16 8 128
Bank 147 (8) 16 155
Stage 1 106 (29) 16 93
Stage 2 41 21 62
Total 55 828 (80) 828 (748) 16 420 (11 632) 4 381 (1 002) 63 995
Stage 1 6 836 440 (360) 80 177 (176) 6 917
Stage 2 10 351 (440) (388) (828) 1 687 (70) 11 140
Stage 3 (including IIS) 38 641 360 388 748 14 556 (11 632) 4 381 (756) 45 938
68 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 69
-- 68 of 278 --
8. Loans and advances continued
8.1 Reconciliation of ECL for loans and advances at amortised cost continued
8.1.1 Reconciliation of the ECL for loans and advances at amortised cost, by product continued
Opening ECL
Rm
Transfers Net
impairments
raised/
(released)
Rm1
Impaired
accounts
written off
Rm
TVM unwind
and IIS
movements
Rm1
Exchange
and other
movement
Rm1
Closing
ECL
Rm
(From)/to
stage 1
Rm
(From)/to
stage 2
Rm
(From)/to
stage 3
Rm
Total
Rm
2022
Home services 15 625 (488) (116) 604 1 678 (1 476) 660 (58) 16 429
Stage 1 1 059 173 315 488 (618) (4) 925
Stage 2 2 440 (173) 289 116 139 12 2 707
Stage 3 (including IIS) 12 126 (315) (289) (604) 2 157 (1 476) 660 (66) 12 797
Vehicle and asset finance 6 337 (57) 117 (60) 1 889 (1 196) 236 123 7 389
Stage 1 651 30 27 57 29 73 810
Stage 2 1 131 (30) (87) (117) 894 25 1 933
Stage 3 (including IIS) 4 555 (27) 87 60 966 (1 196) 236 25 4 646
Card and payments 3 885 (126) 34 92 2 014 (2 248) 169 5 3 825
Stage 1 642 45 81 126 (41) (3) 724
Stage 2 1 152 (45) 11 (34) 15 6 1 139
Stage 3 (including IIS) 2 091 (81) (11) (92) 2 040 (2 248) 169 2 1 962
Personal unsecured lending 9 740 197 (68) (129) 4 136 (4 049) 793 42 10 662
Stage 1 1 508 (101) (96) (197) 275 (106) 1 480
Stage 2 1 761 101 (33) 68 524 71 2 424
Stage 3 (including IIS) 6 471 96 33 129 3 337 (4 049) 793 77 6 758
Business lending and other 7 536 (64) 415 (351) 2 264 (1 828) 89 (9) 8 052
Stage 1 943 181 (117) 64 (200) 23 830
Stage 2 1 295 (181) (234) (415) 354 2 1 236
Stage 3 (including IIS) 5 298 117 234 351 2 110 (1 828) 89 (34) 5 986
Corporate and sovereign 7 710 (77) 110 (33) 1 752 (737) 574 25 9 324
Stage 1 1 304 81 (4) 77 624 (44) 1 961
Stage 2 818 (81) (29) (110) 131 32 871
Stage 3 (including IIS) 5 588 4 29 33 997 (737) 574 37 6 492
Bank 65 27 55 147
Stage 1 65 (1) 42 106
Stage 2 28 13 41
Central and other 500 (500)
Stage 1 218 (218)
Stage 2 282 (282)
Total 51 398 (615) 492 123 13 260 (11 534) 2 521 183 55 828
Stage 1 6 390 409 206 615 (150) (19) 6 836
Stage 2 8 879 (409) (83) (492) 1 803 161 10 351
Stage 3 (including IIS) 36 129 (206) 83 (123) 11 607 (11 534) 2 521 41 38 641
1 Restated. Refer to pages 30 to 39 for further details relating to the restatement.
70 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 71
-- 69 of 278 --
8. Loans and advances continued
8.1 Reconciliation of ECL for loans and advances at amortised cost continued
8.1.1 Reconciliation of the ECL for loans and advances at amortised cost, by product continued
Changes in gross exposures relating to changes in ECL
The below is an explanation of significant changes in the gross carrying amount on financial instruments used to determine
the above changes in ECL:
■ The ECL on new exposures raised of R6.1 billion (2022: R6.4 billion) primarily relates to the growth in the gross carrying
amount from new exposures originated of:
– Home services of R52 billion (2022: R73 billion)
– Vehicle and asset finance of R43 billion (2022: R42 billion)
– Personal unsecured lending of R7.7 billion (2022: R13 billion)
– Business lending and other of R46 billion (2022: R38 billion)
– Corporate and sovereign of R60 billion (2022: R66 billion)
■ The increase in ECL due to impaired accounts written off of R11.6 billion (2022: R8.8 billion) resulted in an equal increase to
the gross carrying amount of loans and advances as exposures are 100% provided for before being written off.
The group's policy is to transfer between stages using opening ECL balances based on the exposures’ ECL stage at the end of
the reporting period.
2023
■ home services with a gross carrying amount of R13.5 billion that was in stage 2 was transferred to stage 1.
■ vehicle and asset finance with a gross carrying amount of R1.4 billion that was in stage 2 was transferred to stage 1.
■ vehicle and asset finance with a gross carrying amount of R7 billion that was in stage 3 was transferred to stage 1.
■ card and payments with a gross carrying amount of R757 million that was in stage 2 was transferred to stage 1.
■ personal unsecured lending with a gross carrying amount of R2.1 billion that was in stage 1 was transferred to stage 3.
■ business lending and other with a gross carrying amount of R1.4 billion that was in stage 1 was transferred to stage 3.
■ business lending and other with a gross carrying amount of R2.5 billion that was in stage 2 was transferred to stage 1.
■ business lending and other with a gross carrying amount of R1.5 billion that was in stage 2 was transferred to stage 3.
2022
■ home services with a gross carrying amount of R11.5 billion that was in stage 2 was transferred to stage 1.
■ home services with a gross carrying amount of R3.7 billion that was in stage 3 was transferred to stage 1.
■ home services with a gross carrying amount of R660 million that was in stage 3 was transferred to stage 2.
■ vehicle and asset finance with a gross carrying amount of R876 million that was in stage 2 was transferred to stage 3.
■ card and payments with a gross carrying amount of R853 million that was in stage 3 was transferred to stage 1.
■ personal unsecured lending with a gross carrying amount of R3.4 billion that was in stage 1 was transferred to stage 2.
■ personal unsecured lending with a gross carrying amount of R1.9 billion that was in stage 1 was transferred to stage 3.
■ business lending and other with gross carrying amount of R2.7 billion that was in stage 2 was transferred to stage 1.
■ business lending and other with gross carrying amount of R739 million that was in stage 1 was transferred to stage 3.
■ business lending and other with gross carrying amount of R1.7 billion that was in stage 2 was transferred to stage 3.
■ corporate and sovereign with a gross carrying amount of R4.9 billion that was in stage 2 was transferred to stage 1.
72 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 70 of 278 --
8.2 Modifications on loans and advances measured at amortised cost
Stage 2 Stage 3
Gross
amortised
cost before
modification
Rm
Net
modification
loss/(gain)
Rm
Gross
amortised
cost before
modification
Rm
Net
modification
loss/(gain)
Rm
2023
Home services 5 844 47 3 710 76
Vehicle and asset finance 897 34 493 124
Card and payments 823 29 382 34
Personal unsecured lending 1 261 157 1 355 126
Business lending and other 993 14 55 (1)
Corporate and sovereign* 180 57
Total 9 998 281 6 052 359
2022
Home services 4 645 45 2 652 84
Vehicle and asset finance 943 89 120 2
Card and payments 626 (38) 437 147
Personal unsecured lending 832 43 866 186
Business lending and other 42 6 23
Corporate and sovereign 1 440 48
Total 7 088 145 5 538 467
* The modification gains and losses on the corporate and sovereign restructures in stage 2 and stage 3 have netted off resulting in an insignificant net gain
or loss amount.
In addition to the gross carrying amounts and related modification gains/(losses) disclosed above, modifications during the
reporting period that resulted in no economic gain or loss (i.e. no net modification gain or loss), comprised of gross carrying
amounts of R75 billion (2022: R42 billion).
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 73
-- 71 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities
9.1. Reinsurance contract assets
SUMMARY OF REINSURANCE CONTRACT ASSETS
Life risk
measured
under GMM
Life risk
measured
under PAA
Non-life
measured
under PAA Total
Current
portion
Non-current
portion
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
2023
Reinsurance contract assets 2 288 2 177 957 5 422 2 826 2 596
Net reinsurance contract assets 2 288 2 177 957 5 422 2 826 2 596
2022 - restated1
Reinsurance contract assets 2 414 2 188 920 5 522 2 982 2 540
Net reinsurance contract assets 2 414 2 188 920 5 522 2 982 2 540
Note 9.1.1 9.1.2 9.1.3
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
74 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 75
-- 72 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.1 Reinsurance contract assets continued
9.1.1 Life risk measured under GMM
RECONCILIATION OF THE ASSET FOR REMAINING COVERAGE (ARC) AND THE ASSET RECOVERABLE ON INCURRED CLAIMS (ARIC)
2023 2022
ARC
ARIC Total
ARC
ARIC Total
Excluding
loss recovery
component
Loss
recovery
component Total
Excluding
loss recovery
component
Loss
recovery
component Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Net balance at 1 January 438 128 566 1 848 2 414 503 99 602 2 614 3 216
Opening reinsurance contract assets 438 128 566 1 848 2 414 503 99 602 2 614 3 216
Total recognised in the income statement (1 500) 18 (1 482) 1 409 (73) (1 325) 29 (1 296) 1 316 20
Net income/(expenses) from reinsurance contracts held (1 629) 18 (1 611) 1 387 (224) (1 361) 29 (1 332) 1 323 (9)
Expenses from reinsurance contracts (1 629) (1 629) (1 629) (1 361) (1 361) (1 361)
Claims recovered 1 358 1 358 1 282 1 282
Other income/(expenses) (note 33) 18 18 29 47 29 29 41 70
Net finance income/(expenses) from reinsurance contracts held 129 129 22 151 36 36 (7) 29
Total cash flows 1 373 1 373 (1 426) (53) 1 260 1 260 (2 082) (822)
Premiums paid net of ceding commissions 1 373 1 373 1 373 1 260 1 260 1 260
Recoveries from reinsurance (1 426) (1 426) (2 082) (2 082)
Net balance at 31 December 311 146 457 1 831 2 288 438 128 566 1 848 2 414
Closing reinsurance contract assets 311 146 457 1 831 2 288 438 128 566 1 848 2 414
76 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 77
-- 73 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.1 Reinsurance contract assets continued
9.1.1 Life risk measured under GMM continued
RECONCILIATION OF MEASUREMENT COMPONENTS OF REINSURANCE CONTRACT BALANCES
2023 2022
Present value
of future
cash flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial risk CSM Total
Present value
of future
cash flows
Risk
adjustment for
non-financial
risk CSM Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Net balance at 1 January 282 538 1 594 2 414 1 628 510 1 078 3 216
Opening reinsurance contract assets 282 538 1 594 2 414 1 628 510 1 078 3 216
Total recognised in the income statement (143) 66 4 (73) (524) 28 516 20
Net income/(expenses) from reinsurance contracts held (55) (45) (124) (224) (500) 30 461 (9)
Changes that relate to current service 63 (79) (264) (280) 61 (53) (94) (86)
CSM recognised in profit or loss for services received (264) (264) (94) (94)
Risk adjustment for risk expired (non-financial risk) (79) (79) (53) (53)
Experience adjustments relating to incurred claims and other
incurred directly attributable expenses recovery 63 63 61 61
Changes that relate to future service (147) 34 140 27 (602) 83 555 36
Changes in estimates that adjust the CSM 379 (17) (362) (562) 40 522
Contracts initially recognised in the period (459) 54 451 46 (40) 43 45 48
Changes to loss recovery component on subsequent
measurement of onerous underlying contracts (67) (3) 51 (19) (12) (12)
Changes that relate to past service 29 29 41 41
Adjustments to assets recoverable on incurred claims 29 29 41 41
Net finance income/(expenses) from reinsurance contracts
issued (88) 111 128 151 (24) (2) 55 29
Total cash flows (53) (53) (822) (822)
Premiums paid net of ceding commissions 1 373 1 373 1 260 1 260
Recoveries from reinsurance (1 426) (1 426) (2 082) (2 082)
Net balance at 31 December 86 604 1 598 2 288 282 538 1 594 2 414
Closing reinsurance contract assets 86 604 1 598 2 288 282 538 1 594 2 414
78 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 79
-- 74 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.1 Reinsurance contract assets continued
9.1.1 Life risk measured under GMM continued
IMPACT OF CONTRACTS RECOGNISED DURING THE YEAR
2023 2022
Contracts
originated in
a net cost
Contracts
originated in
a net gain Total
Contracts
originated in a
net cost
Contracts
originated in a
net gain Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Estimates of the present value of future cash outflows (2 484) (162) (2 646) (285) (122) (407)
Estimates of the present value of future cash inflows 2 013 174 2 187 236 131 367
Risk adjustments for non-financial risk 21 33 54 8 35 43
CSM 488 (37) 451 82 (37) 45
Contracts initially recognised in the period 38 8 46 41 7 48
CSM BY TRANSITION METHOD
2023 2022
Contracts
measured
under the full
retrospective
approach at
transition
and
subsequent
measurement
Contracts
measured
under the
fair value
approach
Total Life
risk
measured
under GMM
Contracts
measured
under the full
retrospective
approach at
transition and
subsequent
measurement
Contracts
measured
under the fair
value
approach
Total Life risk
measured
under GMM
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
CSM balance at the beginning of the year 302 1 292 1 594 56 1 022 1 078
Changes that relate to current service (52) (212) (264) 83 (177) (94)
CSM recognised in profit or loss for services received (52) (212) (264) 83 (177)
Changes that relate to future service 502 (362) 140 159 396 (94)
Changes in estimates that adjust the CSM (362) (362) 126 396 522
Changes to loss recovery component on subsequent measurement
on onerous underlying contracts
51 51 (12) (12)
Contracts initially recognised in the period 451 451 45 45
Net finance income from reinsurance contracts held 37 91 128 4 51 55
CSM balance at the end of the year 789 809 1 598 302 1 292 1 594
For details on the methods and assumptions applied in the modified retrospective and fair value approaches on
transition refer to the key management assumptions section on page 40.
80 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 81
-- 75 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.1 Reinsurance contract assets continued
9.1.2 Life risk measured under PAA
RECONCILIATION OF THE ARC AND THE ARIC
2023 2022
ARC ARIC
Total
ARC ARIC
Total
Excluding
loss recovery
component
Loss
recovery
component
Total ARC
for
contracts
under the
PAA
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial
risk
Total ARIC
for
contracts
under the
PAA
Excluding
loss recovery
component
Loss
recovery
component
Total ARC
for
contracts
under the
PAA
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial
risk
Total ARIC
for
contracts
under the
PAA
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Net balance at 1 January (1 144) 7 (1 137) 3 274 51 3 325 2 188 (544) 13 (531) 2 755 40 2 795 2 264
Opening reinsurance contract assets (1 144) 7 (1 137) 3 274 51 3 325 2 188 (544) 13 (531) 2 755 40 2 795 2 264
Total recognised in the income statement (1 182) 2 (1 180) 991 (3) 988 (192) (925) (6) (931) 1 001 11 1 012 81
Net (expenses)/income from reinsurance contracts
held (note 33) (1 182) 2 (1 180) 827 (5) 822 (358) (925) (6) (931) 921 10 931
Expenses from reinsurance contracts (1 182) (1 182) (1 182) (925) (925) (925)
Claims recovered 850 (5) 845 845 885 10 895 895
Other income/(expenses) 2 2 (23) (23) (21) (6) (6) 36 36 30
Net finance income/(expenses) from reinsurance
contracts held 164 2 166 166 80 1 81 81
Investment components
Total cash flows 1 545 1 545 (1 352) (1 352) 193 323 323 (479) (479) (156)
Premiums paid net of ceding commissions 1 545 1 545 1 545 323 323 323
Recoveries from reinsurance (1 352) (1 352) (1 352) (479) (479) (479)
Foreign currency translation and other
movements (6) (6) (6) (6) (12) 2 2 (3) (3) (1)
Net balance at 31 December (787) 9 (778) 2 907 48 2 955 2 177 (1 144) 7 (1 137) 3 274 51 3 325 2 188
Closing reinsurance contract assets (787) 9 (778) 2 907 48 2 955 2 177 (1 144) 7 (1 137) 3 274 51 3 325 2 188
82 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 83
-- 76 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.1 Reinsurance contract assets continued
9.1.3 Non-life risk measured under PAA
RECONCILIATION OF ARC AND ARIC
2023 2022
ARC ARIC
Total
ARC ARIC
Total
Excluding
loss recovery
component
Loss
recovery
component
Total ARC
for
contracts
under the
PAA
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial
risk
Total ARIC
for
contracts
under the
PAA
Excluding
loss recovery
component
Loss
recovery
component
Total ARC
for
contracts
under the
PAA
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial risk
Total ARIC
for contracts
under the
PAA
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Net balance at 1 January 122 3 125 762 33 795 920 120 3 123 288 11 299 422
Opening reinsurance contract assets 122 3 125 762 33 795 920 120 3 123 288 11 299 422
Total recognised in the income statement (843) (843) 673 (2) 671 (172) (790) (790) 1 006 22 1 028 238
Net income/(expenses) from reinsurance contracts
held (note 33) (843) (843) 680 (3) 677 (166) (790) (790) 1 005 25 1 030 240
Expenses from reinsurance contracts (843) (843) (843) (790) (790) (790)
Claims recovered 249 3 252 252 996 20 1 016 1 016
Changes that relate to past service - adjustments to
the ARIC 431 (11) 420 420 9 (1) 8 8
Effect of changes in the risk of reinsurers non-
performance 5 5 5 6 6 6
Net finance income/(expenses) from reinsurance
contracts held (7) 1 (6) (6) 1 (3) (2) (2)
Total cash flows 856 856 (576) (576) 280 789 789 (543) (543) 246
Premiums paid net of ceding commissions 856 856 856 789 789 789
Premiums paid 969 969 969 897 897 897
Ceding commissions receivables (113) (113) (113) (108) (108) (108)
Directly attributable expenses
Recoveries from reinsurance (576) (576) (576) (543) (543) (543)
Foreign currency translation and other
movements (19) (19) (51) (1) (52) (71) 3 3 11 11 14
Net balance at 31 December 116 3 119 808 30 838 957 122 3 125 762 33 795 920
Closing reinsurance contract assets 116 3 119 808 30 838 957 122 3 125 762 33 795 920
84 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 85
-- 77 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.1 Reinsurance contract assets continued
9.1.4 Reinsurance contract balances
EXPECTED RECOGNITION OF THE CSM
Life risk measured
under GMM
As at 31 December
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
CSM recognised in profit and loss within ten years 664 752
Within one year 278 271
Within two to five years 945 915
Within six to ten years 1 193 1 113
Effect of interest accreted on the CSM for zero to ten years (1 752) (1 547)
Combined CSM and interest accreted on CSM beyond ten years 934 842
Total 1 598 1 594
Note 9.1.1
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities
SUMMARY OF INSURANCE CONTRACT ASSETS AND LIABILITIES
Life risk
measured
under GMM
Life risk
measured
under PAA
Annuities
and GIPs
Participating
contracts
Non-life risk
measured
under PAA Total
Current
portion
Non-current
portion
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
2023
Insurance contract assets (1 123) (80) (428) (1 631) (618) (1 013)
Insurance contract liabilities 11 046 8 742 67 157 162 201 2 243 251 389 42 172 209 217
Net insurance contract liabilities 9 923 8 662 67 157 162 201 1 815 249 758 41 554 208 204
2022
Insurance contract assets (1 023) (609) (198) (1 830) (925) (905)
Insurance contract liabilities 10 668 7 976 56 837 154 157 2 211 231 849 38 883 192 966
Net insurance contract liabilities 9 645 7 367 56 837 154 157 2 013 230 019 37 958 192 061
Note 9.2.1 9.2.2 9.2.3 9.2.4 9.2.5
86 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 87
-- 78 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.1 Life risk measured under GMM
RECONCILIATION OF THE LRC AND THE LIC
2023 2022
LRC
LIC Total
LRC
LIC
Total
liability
Excluding
loss
component
Loss
component Total LRC
Excluding
loss
component
Loss
component Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Net balance at 1 January 3 855 1 611 5 466 4 179 9 645 4 999 1 455 6 454 4 762 11 216
Opening insurance contract assets (1 109) (1 109) 86 (1 023) (1 121) (1 121) 180 (941)
Opening insurance contract liabilities 4 964 1 611 6 575 4 093 10 668 6 120 1 455 7 575 4 582 12 157
Total recognised in the income statement (9 509) 196 (9 313) 8 160 (1 153) (9 880) 157 (9 723) 7 833 (1 890)
Insurance service result (9 562) 238 (9 324) 8 080 (1 244) (10 307) 189 (10 118) 7 803 (2 315)
Insurance revenue (10 723) (10 723) (10 723) (11 288) (11 288) (11 288)
Insurance service expense 1 161 238 1 399 8 080 9 479 981 189 1 170 7 803 8 973
Incurred claims 6 899 6 899 6 858 6 858
Directly attributable expenses1 1 031 1 031 994 994
Other expenses (note 32) 238 238 150 388 189 189 (49) 140
Amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows 1 161 1 161 1 161 981 981 981
Net finance expense/(income) from insurance contracts 53 (42) 11 80 91 427 (32) 395 30 425
Investment components (1 218) (1 218) 1 218 (1 070) (1 070) 1 070
Total cash flows 10 311 10 311 (8 866) 1 445 9 805 9 805 (9 488) 317
Premiums received 12 296 12 296 12 296 11 663 11 663 11 663
Claims paid (7 835) (7 835) (8 494) (8 494)
Other attributable expenses paid (1) (1) (1 031) (1 032) (1) (1) (994) (995)
Insurance acquisition cash flows (1 984) (1 984) (1 984) (1 857) (1 857) (1 857)
Foreign currency translation and other movements (2) (12) (14) (14) 1 (1) 2 2
Net balance at 31 December 3 437 1 795 5 232 4 691 9 923 3 855 1 611 5 466 4 179 9 645
Closing insurance contract assets (3 121) (3 121) 1 998 (1 123) (1 109) (1 109) 86 (1 023)
Closing insurance contract liabilities 6 558 1 795 8 353 2 693 11 046 4 964 1 611 6 575 4 093 10 668
1 Directly attributable expenses reported under the LIC includes claims handling, policyholder service and policy administration costs.
88 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 89
-- 79 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.1 Life risk measured under GMM continued
RECONCILIATION OF THE MEASUREMENT COMPONENTS OF INSURANCE CONTRACT BALANCES
2023 2022
Present value
of future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment for
non-financial
risk CSM Total
Present value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment for
non-financial
risk CSM Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Net balance at 1 January (6 345) 4 953 11 037 9 645 (4 203) 4 531 10 888 11 216
Opening insurance contract assets (2 127) 330 774 (1 023) (1 960) 301 718 (941)
Opening insurance contract liabilities (4 218) 4 623 10 263 10 668 (2 243) 4 230 10 170 12 157
Total recognised in the income statement (1 011) 98 (240) (1 153) (2 461) 422 149 (1 890)
Insurance service result (62) (158) (1 024) (1 244) (2 244) 362 (433) (2 315)
Changes that relate to current service 339 (804) (1 394) (1 859) (448) (613) (1 615) (2 676)
CSM recognised in profit or loss for services provided (1 394) (1 394) (1 615) (1 615)
Risk adjustment for risk expired (non-financial risk) (827) (827) (618) (618)
Experience adjustments 339 23 362 (448) 5 (443)
Changes that relate to future service (551) 646 370 465 (1 747) 975 1 182 410
Changes in estimates that adjust the CSM (299) 311 (12) (1 375) 602 773
Changes in estimates that result in additional onerous
contract losses (36) 13 (23)
Changes to loss component on subsequent
measurement (132) 53 31 (48)
Contracts initially recognised in the period (216) 322 382 488 (240) 320 378 458
Changes that relate to past service 150 150 (49) (49)
Adjustments to liabilities for incurred claims 150 150 (49) (49)
Net finance income/(expenses) from insurance
contracts issued (949) 256 784 91 (217) 60 582 425
Total cash flows 1 445 1 445 317 317
Premiums received 12 296 12 296 11 663 11 663
Claims paid (7 835) (7 835) (8 494) (8 494)
Directly attributable expenses paid (1 032) (1 032) (995) (995)
Insurance acquisition cash flows (1 984) (1 984) (1 857) (1 857)
Foreign currency translation and other movements (8) (1) (5) (14) 2 2
Net balance at 31 December (5 919) 5 050 10 792 9 923 (6 345) 4 953 11 037 9 645
Closing insurance contract assets (14 739) 4 553 9 063 (1 123) (2 127) 330 774 (1 023)
Closing insurance contract liabilities 8 820 497 1 729 11 046 (4 218) 4 623 10 263 10 668
90 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 91
-- 80 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.1 Life risk measured under GMM continued
IMPACT OF CONTRACTS RECOGNISED DURING THE YEAR
2023 2022
Profitable
contracts
Onerous
contracts
originated Total
Profitable
contracts
Onerous
contracts
originated Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Estimates of the present value of future cash outflows 1 883 2 049 3 932 1 928 2 003 3 931
Insurance acquisition cash flows 593 925 1 518 656 916 1 572
Claims and other directly attributable expenses 1 290 1 124 2 414 1 272 1 087 2 359
Estimates of the present value of future cash inflows (2 445) (1 703) (4 148) (2 483) (1 688) (4 171)
Risk adjustments for non-financial risk 180 142 322 177 143 320
CSM 382 382 378 378
Contracts initially recognised in the period 488 488 458 458
CSM BY TRANSITION METHOD
2023 2022
Contracts
measured
under full
retrospective
at transition
and
subsequent
measurement
Contracts
measured
under the fair
value
approach
Total Life risk
measured
under GMM
Contracts
measured
under full
retrospective
at transition
and
subsequent
measurement
Contracts
measured
under the
fair value
approach
Total Life
risk
measured
under GMM
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Insurance revenue (note 31) 3 366 7 357 10 723 2 455 8 833 11 288
CSM balance at the beginning of the year 1 858 9 179 11 037 1 315 9 573 10 888
Changes that relate to current service (267) (1 127) (1 394) (120) (1 495) (1 615)
CSM recognised in profit or loss for services provided (267) (1 127) (1 394) (120) (1 495) (1 615)
Changes that relate to future service 352 18 370 555 627 1 182
Changes in estimates that adjust the CSM (37) 25 (12) 162 611 773
Changes to loss component on subsequent measurement 7 (7) 15 16 31
Contracts initially recognised in the period 382 382 378 378
Net finance expenses/(income) from reinsurance contracts 167 617 784 108 474 582
Foreign currency translation (4) (1) (5)
CSM balance at the end of the year 2 106 8 686 10 792 1 858 9 179 11 037
For details on the methods and assumptions applied in the modified retrospective and fair value approaches on
transition refer to the key management assumptions section on page 40.
92 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 93
-- 81 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.2 Life risk measured under PAA
RECONCILIATION OF THE LRC AND LIC
LRC LIC
Total
Excluding
loss
component
Loss
component Total LRC
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial
risk
Total LIC
for
contracts
under the
PAA
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
2023
Net balance at 1 January (29) 22 (7) 7 161 213 7 374 7 367
Opening insurance contract assets (64) (64) (548) 3 (545) (609)
Opening insurance contract liabilities 35 22 57 7 709 210 7 919 7 976
Total recognised in the income statement (9 458) 4 (9 454) 6 032 (12) 6 020 (3 434)
Insurance service result (9 460) 4 (9 456) 5 569 (13) 5 556 (3 900)
Insurance revenue (10 414) (10 414) (10 414)
Insurance service expense 954 4 958 5 569 (13) 5 556 6 514
Incurred claims 4 968 (17) 4 951 4 951
Directly attributable expenses1 914 914 633 (1) 632 1 546
Other expenses (note 32) 4 4 (32) 5 (27) (23)
Amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows 40 40 40
Net finance expense/(income) from insurance contracts 2 2 463 1 464 466
Total cash flows 9 532 9 532 (4 759) (4 759) 4 773
Premiums received 10 498 10 498 10 498
Claims paid (4 127) (4 127) (4 127)
Other directly attributable expenses paid (632) (632) (632)
Insurance acquisition cash flows (966) (966) (966)
Foreign currency translation and other movements (30) 1 (29) (13) (2) (15) (44)
Net balance at 31 December 15 27 42 8 421 199 8 620 8 662
Closing insurance contract assets (80) (80) (1) 1 (80)
Closing insurance contract liabilities 95 27 122 8 422 198 8 620 8 742
1 Directly attributable expenses reported under the LRC represents the acquisition costs expensed including amortisation for the period. Directly attributable expenses reported under the LIC includes claims handling, policyholder service and policy administration costs.
94 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 95
-- 82 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.2 Life risk measured under PAA continued
RECONCILIATION OF THE LRC AND LIC continued
LRC LIC
Total
Excluding
loss
component
Loss
component Total LRC
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial risk
Total LIC for
contracts
under the
PAA
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
2022
Net balance at 1 January (137) 365 228 7 354 157 7 511 7 739
Opening insurance contract assets (340) (340) 29 29 (311)
Opening insurance contract liabilities 203 365 568 7 325 157 7 482 8 050
Total recognised in the income statement (8 682) (343) (9 025) 5 233 56 5 289 (3 736)
Insurance service result (8 685) (354) (9 039) 5 015 56 5 071 (3 968)
Insurance revenue (9 604) (9 604) (9 604)
Insurance service expense 919 (354) 565 5 015 56 5 071 5 636
Incurred claims 4 149 56 4 205 4 205
Directly attributable expenses1 842 842 750 750 1 592
Other expenses (note 32) (354) (354) 116 116 (238)
Amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows 77 77 77
Net finance income from insurance contracts held 3 11 14 218 218 232
Total cash flows 8 794 8 794 (5 438) (5 438) 3 356
Premiums received 9 712 9 712 9 712
Claims paid (4 908) (4 908) (4 908)
Other directly attributable expenses paid (530) (530) (530)
Insurance acquisition cash flows (918) (918) (918)
Foreign currency translation and other movements (4) (4) 12 12 8
Net balance at 31 December (29) 22 (7) 7 161 213 7 374 7 367
Closing insurance contract assets (64) (64) (548) 3 (545) (609)
Closing insurance contract liabilities 35 22 57 7 709 210 7 919 7 976
1 Directly attributable expenses reported under the LRC represents the acquisition costs expensed including amortisation for the period and reported under the LIC includes claims handling, policyholder service and policy administration costs.
96 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 97
-- 83 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.3 Annuities and GIPs
RECONCILIATION OF THE LRC AND LIC
2023 2022
LRC
LIC
Total
liability
LRC
LIC
Total
liability
Excluding
loss
component
Loss
component Total LRC
Excluding
loss
component
Loss
component Total LRC
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Net balance at 1 January 55 549 154 55 703 1 134 56 837 49 160 107 49 267 824 50 091
Opening insurance contract liabilities 55 549 154 55 703 1 134 56 837 49 160 107 49 267 824 50 091
Total recognised in the income statement (1 376) 182 (1 194) 5 882 4 688 (2 892) 48 (2 844) 4 698 1 854
Insurance service result (6 884) 171 (6 713) 5 695 (1 018) (4 878) 43 (4 835) 4 678 (157)
Insurance revenue (7 153) (7 153) (7 153) (5 082) (5 082) (5 082)
Insurance service expense 269 171 440 5 695 6 135 204 43 247 4 678 4 925
Incurred claims 5 652 5 652 4 591 4 591
Directly attributable expenses1 100 100 87 87
Other expenses (note 32) 171 171 (57) 114 43 43 43
Amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows 269 269 269 204 204 204
Net finance expense from insurance contracts 5 508 11 5 519 187 5 706 1 986 5 1 991 20 2 011
Investment components (4 084) (4 084) 4 084 (3 265) (3 265) 3 265
Total cash flows 15 652 15 652 (9 628) 6 024 12 584 12 584 (7 681) 4 903
Premiums received 16 203 16 203 16 203 13 086 13 086 13 086
Claims paid (9 525) (9 525) (7 590) (7 590)
Directly attributable expenses paid (103) (103) (91) (91)
Insurance acquisition cash flows (551) (551) (551) (502) (502) (502)
Foreign currency translation and other
movements (388) (4) (392) (392) (38) (1) (39) 28 (11)
Net balance at 31 December 65 353 332 65 685 1 472 67 157 55 549 154 55 703 1 134 56 837
Closing insurance contract liabilities 65 353 332 65 685 1 472 67 157 55 549 154 55 703 1 134 56 837
1 Directly attributable expenses reported under the LIC includes claims handling, policyholder service and policy administration costs.
98 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 99
-- 84 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.3 Annuities and GIPs continued
RECONCILIATION OF THE MEASUREMENT COMPONENTS OF INSURANCE CONTRACT BALANCES
2023 2022
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial risk CSM Total
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial risk CSM Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Net balance at 1 January 53 422 358 3 057 56 837 47 387 274 2 431 50 092
Opening insurance contract liabilities 53 422 358 3 057 56 837 47 387 274 2 431 50 092
Total recognised in the income statement 3 321 (57) 1 424 4 688 1 146 82 626 1 854
Insurance service result (2 121) (43) 1 146 (1 018) (600) 443 (157)
Changes that relate to current service (495) (27) (636) (1 158) 25 30 (269) (214)
CSM recognised in profit or loss for services provided (636) (636) (269) (269)
Risk adjustment for risk expired (non-financial risk) (28) (28) 30 30
Experience adjustments (495) 1 (494) 25 25
Changes that relate to future service (1 569) (16) 1 782 197 (625) (30) 712 57
Changes in estimates that adjust the CSM (695) (61) 756 234 (67) (167)
Changes to loss component on subsequent measurement 160 (21) 22 161 (24) (31) 16 (39)
Contracts initially recognised in the period (1 034) 66 1 004 36 (835) 68 863 96
Changes that relate to past service (57) (57)
Adjustments to liabilities for incurred claims (57) (57)
Net finance expense/(income) from insurance contracts 5 442 (14) 278 5 706 1 746 82 183 2 011
Total cash flows 6 024 6 024 4 903 4 903
Premiums received 16 203 16 203 13 086 13 086
Claims paid (9 525) (9 525) (7 590) (7 590)
Other directly attributable expenses paid (103) (103) (91) (91)
Insurance acquisition cash flows (551) (551) (502) (502)
Foreign currency translation and other movements (364) (2) (26) (392) (27) 15 (12)
Net balance at 31 December 62 403 299 4 455 67 157 53 409 371 3 057 56 837
Closing insurance contract liabilities 62 403 299 4 455 67 157 53 409 371 3 057 56 837
100 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 101
-- 85 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.3 Annuities and GIPs continued
IMPACT OF CONTRACTS RECOGNISED DURING THE YEAR
2023 2022
Profitable
contracts
Onerous
contracts
originated Total
Profitable
contracts
Onerous
contracts
originated Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Estimates of the present value of future cash outflows 13 845 575 14 420 9 102 234 9 336
Insurance acquisition cash flows 507 21 528 336 19 355
Claims and directly attributable expenses 13 338 554 13 892 8 766 215 8 981
Estimates of the present value of future cash inflows (14 893) (564) (15 457) (10 011) (166) (10 177)
Risk adjustments for non-financial risk 44 25 69 46 28 74
CSM 1 004 1 004 863 863
Contracts initially recognised in the period 36 36 96 96
CSM BY TRANSITION METHOD
2023 2022
Contracts
measured
under full
retrospective
at transition
and
subsequent
measurement
Contracts
measured
under the
modified
retrospective
approach
Contracts
measured
under the
fair value
approach
Total Life
risk
measured
under GMM
Contracts
measured
under full
retrospective
at transition
and
subsequent
measurement
Contracts
measured
under the
modified
retrospective
approach
Contracts
measured
under the
fair value
approach
Total Life
risk
measured
under GMM
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Insurance revenue (note 31) 4 727 280 2 146 7 153 3 432 293 1 357 5 082
CSM balance at the beginning of the year 2 121 459 477 3 057 1 572 446 413 2 431
Changes that relate to current service (499) (55) (82) (636) (278) (51) 60 (269)
CSM recognised in profit or loss for services
provided (499) (55) (82) (636) (278) (51) 60 (269)
Changes that relate to future service 1 098 36 648 1 782 706 22 (16) 712
Changes in estimates that adjust the CSM 72 36 648 756 (173) 22 (16) (167)
Changes to loss component on subsequent
measurement 22
22 16 16
Contracts initially recognised in the period 1 004 1 004 863 863
Net finance expense/(income) from insurance
contracts 208 44
26 278 121 42 20 183
Foreign currency translation (26) (26)
CSM balance at the end of the year 2 902 484 1 069 4 455 2 121 459 477 3 057
For details on the methods and assumptions applied in the modified retrospective and fair value approaches on
transition refer to the key management assumptions section on page 40.
102 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 103
-- 86 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.4 Participating contracts
RECONCILIATION OF THE LRC AND LIC
2023 2022
LRC
LIC
Total
liability
LRC
LIC
Total
liability
Excluding
loss
component
Loss
component Total LRC
Excluding
loss
component
Loss
component Total LRC
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Net balance at 1 January 145 852 1 126 146 978 7 179 154 157 153 163 846 154 009 7 808 161 817
Opening insurance contract liabilities 145 852 1 126 146 978 7 179 154 157 153 163 846 154 009 7 808 161 817
Total recognised in the income statement 14 917 337 15 254 2 681 17 935 (854) 281 (573) 2 194 1 621
Insurance service result (3 884) 302 (3 582) 1 525 (2 057) (3 259) 266 (2 993) 2 060 (933)
Insurance revenue (4 703) (4 703) (4 703) (3 935) (3 935) (3 935)
Insurance service expense 819 302 1 121 1 525 2 646 676 266 942 2 060 3 002
Incurred claims 301 301 684 684
Directly attributable expenses1 1 193 1 193 1 227 1 227
Other expenses (note 32) 302 302 31 333 266 266 149 415
Amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows 819 819 819 676 676 676
Net finance expense from insurance contracts 18 801 35 18 836 1 156 19 992 2 405 15 2 420 134 2 554
Investment components (22 777) (22 777) 22 777 (20 365) (20 365) 20 365
Total cash flows 15 468 15 468 (25 185) (9 717) 13 944 13 944 (23 189) (9 245)
Premiums received 16 612 16 612 16 612 14 945 14 945 14 945
Claims paid (23 884) (23 884) (21 853) (21 853)
Other directly attributable expenses paid (1 301) (1 301) (1 336) (1 336)
Insurance acquisition cash flows (1 144) (1 144) (1 144) (1 001) (1 001) (1 001)
Foreign currency translation and other
movements (173) (9) (182) 8 (174) (36) (1) (37) 1 (36)
Net balance at 31 December 153 287 1 454 154 741 7 460 162 201 145 852 1 126 146 978 7 179 154 157
Closing insurance contract liabilities 153 287 1 454 154 741 7 460 162 201 145 852 1 126 146 978 7 179 154 157
1 Directly attributable expenses reported under the LIC includes claims handling, policyholder service and policy administration costs.
104 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 105
-- 87 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.4 Participating contracts continued
RECONCILIATION OF THE MEASUREMENT COMPONENTS OF INSURANCE CONTRACT BALANCES
2023 2022
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial
risk CSM Total
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial
risk CSM Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Net balance at 1 January 147 054 840 6 263 154 157 154 410 899 6 508 161 817
Opening insurance contract liabilities 147 054 840 6 263 154 157 154 410 899 6 508 161 817
Total recognised in the income statement 18 297 (78) (284) 17 935 1 924 (59) (244) 1 621
Insurance service result (1 213) (186) (658) (2 057) (80) (104) (749) (933)
Changes that relate to current service (1 245) (196) (1 019) (2 460) (114) (166) (1 133) (1 413)
CSM recognised in profit or loss for services provided (1 019) (1 019) (1 133) (1 133)
Risk adjustment for risk expired (non-financial risk) (206) (206) (166) (166)
Experience adjustments (1 245) 10 (1 235) (114) (114)
Changes that relate to future service 1 10 361 372 (115) 62 384 331
Changes in estimates that adjust the CSM 135 (6) (129) (40) 24 16
Changes to loss component on subsequent measurement (16) (58) 107 33 (9) (10) (23) (42)
Contracts initially recognised in the period (118) 74 383 339 (66) 48 391 373
Changes that relate to past service 31 31 149 149
Net finance expense/(income) from insurance contracts 19 510 108 374 19 992 2 004 45 505 2 554
Total cash flows (9 717) (9 717) (9 245) (9 245)
Premiums received 16 612 16 612 14 945 14 945
Claims paid (23 884) (23 884) (21 853) (21 853)
Other directly attributable expenses paid (1 301) (1 301) (1 336) (1 336)
Insurance acquisition cash flows (1 144) (1 144) (1 001) (1 001)
Foreign currency translation and other movements (164) (2) (8) (174) (35) (1) (36)
Net balance at 31 December 155 470 760 5 971 162 201 147 054 840 6 263 154 157
Closing insurance contract liabilities 155 470 760 5 971 162 201 147 054 840 6 263 154 157
106 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 107
-- 88 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.4 Participating contracts continued
IMPACT OF CONTRACTS RECOGNISED DURING THE YEAR
2023 2022
Profitable
contracts
Onerous
contracts
originated Total
Profitable
groups
Onerous
contracts
originated Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Estimates of the present value of future cash outflows
7 644 2 241 9 885 6 776 2 470 9 246
Insurance acquisition cash flows 406 469 875 370 558 928
Claims and directly attributable expenses 7 238 1 772 9 010 6 406 1 912 8 318
Estimates of the present value of future cash inflows (8 058) (1 945) (10 003) (7 181) (2 131) (9 312)
Risk adjustments for non-financial risk 31 43 74 14 34 48
CSM 383 383 391 391
Contracts initially recognised in the period 339 339 373 373
CSM BY TRANSITION METHOD
2023 2022
Contracts
measured
under full
retrospective
at transition
and
subsequent
measurement
Contracts
measured
under the
modified
retrospective
approach
Contracts
measured
under the
fair value
approach
Total Life
risk
measured
under
GMM
Contracts
measured
under full
retrospective
at transition
and
subsequent
measurement
Contracts
measured
under the
modified
retrospective
approach
Contracts
measured
under the
fair value
approach
Total Life
risk
measured
under
GMM
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Insurance revenue (note 31) 3 148 1 100 349 4 597 3 212 1 014 69 4 295
Opening balance at the beginning of the year 1 615 2 271 2 377 6 263 1 438 2 397 2 673 6 508
Changes that relate to current service (295) (262) (462) (1 019) (237) (281) (615) (1 133)
CSM recognised in profit or loss for services provided (295) (262) (462) (1 019) (237) (281) (615) (1 133)
Changes that relate to future service 469 39 (147) 361 349 31 4 384
Changes in estimates that adjust the CSM (2) 39 (166) (129) 50 31 (65) 16
Changes to loss component on subsequent
measurement
88 19 107 (92) 69 (23)
Contracts initially recognised in the period 383 383 391 391
Net finance expense/(income) from insurance
contracts
(69) (114) 557 374 66 124 316 506
Foreign currency translation (5) (3) (8) (1) (1) (2)
CSM balance at the end of the year (note 9.2.4) 1 715 1 934 2 322 5 971 1 615 2 271 2 377 6 263
For details on the methods and assumptions applied in the modified retrospective and fair value approaches on
transition refer to the key management assumptions section on page 40.
108 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS NOTES TO THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS CONTINUED STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 109
-- 89 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.4 Participating contracts continued
COMPOSITION OF UNDERLYING ITEMS
Policyholder contracts that have been recognised as participating contracts (measured under the variable fee approach)
and that are designated as one reportable group, have a significant investment component. This investment component is
recorded as a "unit value", being the contractual share of the fair value of referenced asset portfolios in the contract's terms
at the date of reporting.
These asset portfolios "reference portfolios" are representative of the obligation under the policy but do not necessarily
represent the physical asset held by Liberty. As described in the market risk section of the risk management section of this report,
an asset liability matching capability undertakes activities to determine the optimal physical asset holdings, with
consideration of contractual obligations, liquidity and market risks as well as required regulatory capital.
The reference portfolios are made up of:
■ mutual funds that are accessible to the public (have quoted fund values),
■ listed equities (quoted prices),
■ cash and debt instruments that can be reliably measured at fair value,
■ properties that are fair valued regularly,
■ derivatives or investment structures that provide returns linked to quoted investment indices e.g. JSE top 40 index trackers.
The reference portfolios are updated daily to calculate the fair value of each asset portfolio and are the basis of determining any
investment transaction value under the policy. The table below reflects the "look through" approach to the aggregated unit fair
values of the participating contracts reportable group at the respective reporting dates. In other words, they reflect the
characteristic of the underlying investments that is determining the investment return to the policyholders.
2023 2022
Rm Rm
Equities 76 100 71 355
Debt instruments 33 893 33 296
Cash 22 309 18 711
Properties 9 169 10 551
Index trackers 22 285 22 230
Total underlying items comprise the non-distinct investment component 163 756 156 143
Total present value of future cash flows 157 502 149 074
Adjusted for future cash flows that are not included in the non-distinct investment
component 6 254 7 069
Total present value of future cash flows 157 502 149 074
Portfolios included in annuities and guaranteed investment products reportable group
that are measured under the variable fee approach 2 032 2 020
Present value of future cash flows in the participating reportable group 155 470 147 054
110 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 111
-- 90 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.5 Non-life risk measured under PAA
RECONCILIATION OF THE LRC AND LIC
LRC LIC
Asset for
insurance
acquisition
cash flows Total
Excluding
loss
component
Loss
component Total LRC
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial
risk
Total LIC
for
contracts
under the
PAA
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
2023
Net balance at 1 January 212 72 284 1 712 58 1 770 (41) 2 013
Opening insurance contract assets (243) 3 (240) 79 4 83 (41) (198)
Opening insurance contract liabilities 455 69 524 1 633 54 1 687 2 211
Total recognised in the income statement (4 771) (26) (4 797) 4 062 15 4 077 (720)
Insurance service result (4 786) (27) (4 813) 4 055 13 4 068 (745)
Insurance revenue (5 785) (5 785) (5 785)
Insurance service expense 999 (27) 972 4 055 13 4 068 5 040
Incurred claims 2 985 23 3 008 3 008
Directly attributable expenses1 289 289 737 737 1 026
Other expenses (note 32) (27) (27) 333 (10) 323 296
Amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows 710 710 710
Net finance expense/(income) from insurance contracts 15 1 16 7 2 9 25
Foreign exchange gains or losses
Insurance acquisition cash flows: amounts derecognised on initial
recognition of groups of insurance contracts 21 21
Total cash flows 4 764 4 764 (3 965) (3 965) (44) 755
Premiums received 5 759 5 759 5 759
Claims paid (3 293) (3 293) (3 293)
Other directly attributable expenses paid (268) (268) (672) (672) (940)
Insurance acquisition cash flows (727) (727) (44) (771)
Foreign currency translation and other movements (76) (1) (77) (90) (2) (92) (85) (254)
Net balance at 31 December 129 45 174 1 719 71 1 790 (149) 1 815
Closing insurance contract assets (359) 3 (356) 70 7 77 (149) (428)
Closing insurance contract liabilities 488 42 530 1 649 64 1 713 2 243
1 Directly attributable expenses reported under the LRC represents the acquisition costs expensed including amortisation for the period. Directly attributable expenses reported under the LIC includes claims handling, policyholder service and policy administration costs.
112 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 113
-- 91 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.5 Non-life risk measured under PAA continued
RECONCILIATION OF THE LRC AND LIC continued
LRC LIC
Asset for
insurance
acquisition
cash flows Total
Excluding
loss
component
Loss
component Total LRC
Present
value of
future cash
flows
Risk
adjustment
for non-
financial risk
Total LIC for
contracts
under the
PAA
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
2022
Net balance at 1 January 281 28 309 1 249 57 1 306 (12) 1 603
Opening insurance contract assets (12) (12)
Opening insurance contract liabilities 281 28 309 1 249 57 1 306 1 615
Total recognised in the income statement (4 583) 43 (4 540) 3 852 3 852 (688)
Insurance service result (4 599) 59 (4 540) 3 842 3 842 (698)
Insurance revenue (5 808) (5 808) (5 808)
Insurance service expense 1 209 59 1 268 3 842 3 842 5 110
Incurred claims 3 267 21 3 288 3 288
Directly attributable expenses1 545 545 109 1 110 655
Other expenses (note 32) 59 59 466 (22) 444 503
Amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows 664 664 664
Net finance income from insurance contracts held 16 (16) 10 10 10
Total cash flows 4 535 4 535 (3 420) (3 420) (79) 1 036
Premiums received 5 752 5 752 5 752
Claims paid (3 335) (3 335) (3 335)
Other directly attributable expenses paid (531) (531) (85) (85) (616)
Insurance acquisition cash flows (686) (686) (79) (765)
Foreign currency translation and other movements (21) 1 (20) 31 1 32 (8) 4
Net balance at 31 December 212 72 284 1 712 58 1 770 (41) 2 013
Closing insurance contract assets (243) 3 (240) 79 4 83 (41) (198)
Closing insurance contract liabilities 455 69 524 1 633 54 1 687 2 211
1 Directly attributable expenses reported under the LRC represents the acquisition costs expensed including amortisation for the period and reported under the LIC includes claims handling, policyholder service and policy administration costs.
114 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 115
-- 92 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.6 Insurance contract balances
EXPECTED RECOGNITION OF THE CSM
2023 2022
Life risk
measured
under GMM
Annuities
and GIPs
Participating
contracts Total
Life risk
measured
under GMM
Annuities
and GIPs
Participating
contracts Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
CSM recognised in the income statement within ten years 1 687 228 5 064 6 979 2 355 111 5 074 7 540
Within one year 1 515 646 945 3 106 1 499 421 908 2 828
Within two to five years 5 583 2 328 2 763 10 674 5 498 1 506 2 729 9 733
Within six to ten years 7 768 2 565 1 328 11 661 7 545 1 778 1 421 10 744
Effect of discounting zero to ten years (13 179) (5 311) 28 (18 462) (12 187) (3 594) 16 (15 765)
Combined CSM and interest accreted on CSM beyond ten years 9 105 4 227 907 14 239 8 682 2 946 1 189 12 817
Total 10 792 4 455 5 971 21 218 11 037 3 057 6 263 20 357
CHANGES IN CASH FLOWS THAT ADJUST THE CSM
2023 2022
Life risk
measured
under GMM
Annuities
and GIPs
Participating
contracts Total
Life risk
measured
under GMM
Annuities
and GIPs
Participating
contracts Total
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Changes in estimated cash flows that adjust the CSM (overall
decrease in insurance contract liabilities) (301) (695) 135 (861) (1 376) 234 (40) (1 182)
The primary changes in cash flow estimates arise initially from a net strengthening of persistency assumptions, recognising a overall deterioration in withdrawal and lapse experience. This was evidenced across a number of portfolios in
the life risk under GMM and participating reportable groups. These adjustments were offset by allowing for improved morbidity experience in certain product portfolios included in life risk under GMM. Within annuities and GIPs, net
positive adjustments to cash flow estimates have resulted from the mortality assumptions being adjusted to reflect a slight overall earlier mortality experience across a number of age bands.
In 2022, the significant net cash flow adjustments in life risk under GMM, resulted from the normalisation of the pandemic environment which led to a revision of elevated short -term claim and other expense cash flow assumptions.
EXPECTED TIMING OF INSURANCE ACQUISITION CASH FLOW ASSET
2023 2022
Non-life
measured
under PAA
Non-life
measured
under PAA
Rm Rm
Within one year 29 30
Within two to five years 120 11
Total 149 41
116 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 117
-- 93 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.7 Claims development
LIABILITY FOR INCURRED CLAIMS ANALYSIS
The following table splits the liability for incurred claims between insurance products where there is limited uncertainty in claim
amount or where the uncertainty is typically resolved within 12 months and insurance products where the nature of the product
leads to uncertainty about the amount and timing of claim payments typically extending beyond 12 months. The risk adjustment
is included to obtain the aggregate LIC by reportable group.
Life and non-
life risk
measured
under GMM
Rm
Life and non-
life risk
measured
under PAA
Rm
Annuities
and GIP's
Rm
Participating
contracts
Rm
Reinsurance
contracts
held
Rm
Total net of
reinsurance
Rm
2023
Amounts excluding risk adjustment component
Non-life insurance classes - limited uncertainty in claim amount or uncertainty typically resolved within 12 months 1 1 571 (772) 799
Non-life insurance classes - uncertainty typically extends beyond 12 months 41 (19) (8) 14
Life insurance classes - limited uncertainty in claim amount or uncertainty typically resolved within 12 months 3 081 2 726 1 488 7 445 (2 250) 12 490
Life insurance classes - uncertainty typically extends beyond 12 months 1 547 5 796 (2 516) 4 827
- Income disability claims in payment 2 1 076 5 448 (2 486) 4 038
- Educator claims in payment 3 351 184 535
- Other 120 164 (30) 254
Risk adjustment component 63 276 3 15 (78) 279
Total liability for incurred claims / (asset) recoverable on incurred claims 4 691 10 410 1 472 7 460 (5 624) 18 409
2022
Amounts excluding risk adjustment component
Non-life insurance classes - limited uncertainty in claim amount or uncertainty typically resolved within 12 months 1 1 539 (699) 840
Non-life insurance classes - uncertainty typically extends beyond 12 months 49 (33) 16
Life insurance classes - limited uncertainty in claim amount or uncertainty typically resolved within 12 months 2 752 2 711 1 132 7 163 (2 885) 10 873
Life insurance classes - uncertainty typically extends beyond 12 months 1 390 5 395 (2 265) 4 520
- Income disability claims in payment 2 1 019 5 046 (2 234) 3 831
- Educator claims in payment 3 270 163 433
- Other 101 186 (31) 256
Risk adjustment component 37 270 2 16 (86) 239
Total liability for incurred claims 4 179 9 964 1 134 7 179 (5 968) 16 488
1 Non-life policies offered seldom give rise to incurred claim liabilities where uncertainty is not typically resolved within 12 months.
2 Income disability benefit policies are offered to employers and individuals. These provide regular payments to claimants during periods of disability lasting
longer than the selected waiting period. Claim payments continue until the earliest of recovery, death and selected benefit termination age (collectively
referred to as claim termination).
3 Educator policies are provided to employers and individuals. These policies provide benefits designed to cover a life assured's children's education costs in
the event of the death and/or disability of that life assured.
Expected future payments by year have been shown below for income disability claims in payment as this is the main product
for which uncertainty typically extends beyond 12 months. Typically, the group is informed about income disability claims either
during the waiting period or soon after. The primary uncertainty with this class of business is the future claim termination experience.
Hence rather than show claims development triangles based on historical data, undiscounted future expected cash-flows are
shown based on best estimate claims termination assumptions. Stressed cash flows are also shown to indicate the impact of
claim termination experience being 8% lower than expected.
118 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 119
-- 94 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2 Insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.2.7 Claims development continued
Expected gross of
reinsurance claim
payments
Rm
Expected net of
reinsurance claim
payments
Rm
Stressed gross of
reinsurance claim
payments
Rm
Stressed net of
reinsurance claim
payments
Rm
2023
Within 1 year 1 454 890 1 461 893
1 – 2 years 1 039 637 1 053 645
2 – 3 years 947 583 966 593
3 – 4 years 870 538 892 550
4 – 5 years 805 498 829 512
Over 5 years 8 724 5 606 9 387 6 029
Effect of discounting cash flows (7 315) (4 714) (7 882) (5 078)
Total income disability liability for incurred claims
(excluding risk adjustment component) 6 524 4 038 6 706 4 144
2022
Within 1 year 1 345 857 1 352 861
1 – 2 years 942 587 955 595
2 – 3 years 859 536 876 546
3 – 4 years 793 498 812 510
4 – 5 years 731 461 753 473
Over 5 years 7 835 5 005 8 435 5 381
Effect of discounting cash flows (6 440) (4 113) (7 041) (4 507)
Total income disability liability for incurred claims
(excluding risk adjustment component) 6 065 3 831 6 142 3 859
120 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 121
-- 95 of 278 --
9. Reinsurance and insurance contract assets and liabilities continued
9.3 Financial liabilities under investment contracts
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Balance at beginning of the period 136 309 136 622
Fund inflows from investment contracts (contributions received) 22 412 20 433
Fair value adjustment (investment return from underlying assets) 18 169 1 308
Fund outflows under investment contracts (benefits paid) (23 814) (20 232)
Service fee income (asset management fees charged) (1 909) (1 807)
Foreign currency translation (132) (15)
Balance at end of the period 151 035 136 309
Current 147 252 132 549
Non-current 3 783 3 760
1 Restated, Refer page 31 to 39 for more details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
10. Interest in associates and joint ventures
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Equity accounted associates and joint ventures
Carrying value at the beginning of the year 9 956 7 280
Share of post-tax profits for the year 1 648 2 265
Impairments of associates and joint ventures (note 41)1 (62) (74)
Acquisitions 346 153
Disposals (21) (26)
Reclassification from group assets and liabilities held for sale (note 5) 239
Share of OCI movements 707 486
Foreign currency translation reserve 709 453
Other (2) 33
Distributions received (401) (367)
Carrying value at the end of the year 12 173 9 956
1 During 2023, a subset of the equity accounted associates with a carrying value of R462 million was impaired by R62 million to its recoverable amount of
R400 million mainly due to a significant decline in market factors and operational factors that impacted the performance of these entities.
The recoverable amount is based on the investments’ fair value less costs of disposal and is included in level 3 of the fair value hierarchy. The group
utilises multiple valuation techniques including the market approach, cost approach and income approach to determine a reasonable valuation. Where
relevant, the group applied an average discount rate of 15% based on either internal hurdle rates or the weighted average cost of capital and a forecast
period of between 1-8 years.
There are no significant restrictions on the ability of associates or joint ventures to transfer funds to the group in the form of
cash dividends or in the repayment of loans or advances.
Refer to annexure B for further information on associates and joint
ventures.
122 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 96 of 278 --
11. Investment property
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Fair value at the beginning of the year 29 289 29 985
Revaluations net of lease straight-lining 2 606 (1 315)
Revaluations 2 623 (1 359)
Net movement on straight-lining operating leases (17) 44
Additions – capitalised subsequent expenditure and acquisitions1 348 656
Disposals (574)
Transfers from owner-occupied properties (note 12) 18
Exchange movements (1 817) 537
Fair value at the end of the year 30 444 29 289
Investment property and related operating lease balances comprise the
following
Investment properties at fair value 30 444 29 289
Operating leases – accrued income (note 7) 564 547
Total investment property 31 008 29 836
Amount recognised in profit or loss
Rental income earned 3 344 2 936
Direct operating expenses 1 504 1 191
1 Includes cash and non-cash additions.
11.1 Minimum lease payments receivable from investment properties
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Maturity analysis of undiscounted rental income from investment properties
Up to one year 1 762 1 836
Between one and two years 1 356 1 331
Between two and three years 1 042 930
Between three and four years 696 686
Between four and five year 503 412
Over five years 1 477 1 781
Total 6 836 6 976
11.2 Basis of valuation
The full portfolio of South African located properties was independently valued as at 31 December 2023 by registered
professional valuers, registered in terms of the Property Valuers Professional Act, No. 47 of 2000 and are registered with
the Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors. The Africa Regions located properties were independently valued as at
31 December 2023 by various registered professional valuers in each territory. The valuation of the South African properties
is prepared in accordance with the guidelines of and in accordance with the appraisal and valuation manual of the Royal
Institution of Chartered Surveyors, adapted for South African law and conditions.
The basis of value is "fair value" which is defined as "the price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a
liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date". The objective of a fair value
measurement is to estimate the price at which an orderly transaction to sell the asset or to transfer the liability would take
place between market participants at the measurement date under current market conditions.
The properties have been valued using the discounted cash flow methodology based on significant unobservable inputs and
whereby the forecasted net cash flow and residual value of the asset at the end of the forecasted cash flow period are
discounted back to the valuation date, resulting in a present value of the asset. The residual value is calculated by capitalising
the net income forecasted for the 12-month period immediately following the final year of the cash flow at the exit
capitalisation rate.
Refer to the key management assumptions for details regarding the
valuation of investment property.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 123
-- 97 of 278 --
12. Property, equipment and right of use assets
Property Equipment Right of use assets2
Total
Rm
Freehold
Rm
Leasehold
Rm
Computer
equipment
Rm
Furniture
and fittings
Rm
Office
equipment
Rm
Motor
vehicles1
Rm
Buildings
Rm
Branches
Rm
ATM
spacing
and other
Rm
Net book value at 1 January 2022 7 876 1 231 3 685 2 416 536 914 1 859 1 616 486 20 619
Cost 9 574 3 273 11 448 6 488 1 471 1 466 3 462 4 127 911 42 220
Accumulated depreciation and impairment (1 698) (2 042) (7 763) (4 072) (935) (552) (1 603) (2 511) (425) (21 601)
Movement (75) (107) (260) 8 33 720 (166) (313) (119) (279)
Additions and modifications3 516 257 1 248 591 233 1 135 423 741 124 5 268
Disposals and terminations (14) (9) (46) (59) (13) (134) (95) (64) (30) (464)
Depreciation (347) (304) (1 556) (536) (151) (253) (510) (829) (149) (4 635)
Impairment (note 41) (18) (18)
Exchange and other movements4 (212) (51) 94 12 (36) (28) 16 (161) (64) (430)
Net book value at 31 December 2022 7 801 1 124 3 425 2 424 569 1 634 1 693 1 303 367 20 340
Cost 9 687 3 191 11 764 6 620 1 577 2 329 3 615 4 358 950 44 091
Accumulated depreciation and impairment (1 886) (2 067) (8 339) (4 196) (1 008) (695) (1 922) (3 055) (583) (23 751)
Movement (844) (162) 544 233 (37) 288 17 83 (164) (42)
Additions and modifications3 1 033 229 2 242 854 158 964 465 1 105 249 7 299
Disposals and terminations (110) (4) (34) (29) (3) (275) (27) (237) (131) (850)
Depreciation (247) (354) (1 603) (548) (148) (344) (641) (788) (137) (4 810)
Exchange and other movements (1 502) (33) (61) (44) (44) (57) 220 3 (145) (1 663)
Transfer to investment property (note 11) (18) (18)
Net book value at 31 December 2023 6 957 962 3 969 2 657 532 1 922 1 710 1 386 203 20 298
Cost 8 836 3 155 12 950 7 057 1 569 2 787 4 094 4 928 798 46 174
Accumulated depreciation and impairment (1 879) (2 193) (8 981) (4 400) (1 037) (865) (2 384) (3 542) (595) (25 876)
1 This balance primarily relates to motor vehicles that are leased to third parties under operating leases. The group is the lessor. Refer
to note 12.2.
2 Refer to note 18.3 for more detail relating to leasing activities.
3 Modifications relate to IFRS 16 right of use assets only. Included are modifications which relate to right of use assets of R1 031 million
(2022: R605 million) and additions for property, equipment and right of use assets of R6 268 million (2022: R4 663 million).
4 Line items have been aggregated to ensure the note presents each material movement for the year separately. The aggregation did
not impact the statement of financial position.
Property and equipment include work in progress of R1 929 million (2022: R1 090 million) for which depreciation has
not yet commenced (refer to note 24.2 for details regarding capital commitments). During 2023, it was noted that
included in work in progress was an incorrectly rounded amount of R59 281 million instead of R59 million. This
restatement had no impact on the note, income statement and statement of financial position.
124 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 125
-- 98 of 278 --
12. Property, equipment and right of use assets continued
12.1 Valuation
The fair value of completed freehold property, based on valuations undertaken for the period 2020 to 2023 was estimated
at R8 731 million (2022: R11 618 million).
Registers of freehold property are available for inspection by members, or their authorised agents, at the registered office of
the company and its subsidiaries. Valuations were generally in terms of the investment method whereby net income is
capitalised having regard to tenancy, location and the physical nature of the property.
12.2 Motor vehicles under operating leases future undiscounted lease instalments
Within the
first year
Rm
Within the
second year
Rm
Within the
third year
Rm
Within the
fourth year
Rm
Within the
fifth year
Rm
After five
years
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Motor vehicles 144 261 292 312 230 308 1 547
Total 144 261 292 312 230 308 1 547
2022
Motor vehicles 115 142 276 288 237 278 1 336
Total 115 142 276 288 237 278 1 336
13. Goodwill and other intangible assets
Goodwill
Rm
Computer
software
Rm
Other
intangible
assets
Rm
Total
Rm
Net book value at 1 January 2022 - restated1 2 282 14 614 13 16 909
Cost1 4 257 40 993 78 45 328
Accumulated amortisation and impairment1 (1 975) (26 379) (65) (28 419)
Movements (51) (1 732) (6) (1 789)
Additions 1 247 1 247
Disposals (54) (54)
Amortisation (note 40) (2 674) (6) (2 680)
Exchange movements (51) 135 84
Impairments (refer to the key management assumptions
section and note 41) (386) (386)
Net book value at 31 December 2022 - restated1,2 2 231 12 882 7 15 120
Cost1 4 159 42 164 78 46 401
Accumulated amortisation and impairment1 (1 928) (29 282) (71) (31 281)
Movements (622) (1 773) (2) (2 397)
Additions 6 993 999
Disposals (35) (79) (114)
Amortisation (note 40) (2 491) (2) (2 493)
Exchange movements (593) (196) (789)
Net book value at 31 December 20232 1 609 11 109 5 12 723
Cost 3 016 41 575 10 44 601
Accumulated amortisation and impairment (1 407) (30 466) (5) (31 878)
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 Computer software materially comprises of the SA Core Banking system with a net book value of R5 728 million (2022: R6 816 million) with a remaining
amortisation period of five years and seven months as at 31 December 2023.
R182 million (2022: R105 million) of borrowing costs were capitalised to computer software. Borrowing costs are capitalised
using an average rate of 11.5% (2022: 7.2%). Intangible assets include work in progress of R2 472 million
(2022: R1 986 million) for which amortisation has not yet commenced.
126 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 99 of 278 --
13.1 Goodwill
2023 2022
Gross
goodwill
Rm
Accumulated
impairment
Rm
Net
goodwill
Rm
Gross
goodwill
Rm
Accumulated
impairment
Rm
Net
goodwill
Rm
Stanbic IBTC Holdings PLC 1 099 (580) 519 1 960 (1 033) 927
Stanbic Holdings PLC (Kenya) 875 875 1 019 1 019
Other 1 042 (827) 215 1 180 (895) 285
Total 3 016 (1 407) 1 609 4 159 (1 928) 2 231
Movements in accumulated impairment relates to foreign currency movements of previous impairments.
Stanbic IBTC Holdings PLC
Based on the impairment test performed, no impairment was recognised for 2023 or 2022.
Stanbic Holdings PLC (Kenya)
Based on the impairment test performed, no impairment was recognised for 2023 or 2022.
Goodwill relating to other entities
The remaining aggregated carrying amount of the goodwill of R215 million (2022: R285 million) has been allocated to CGUs
that are not considered to be individually significant. Based on the impairment testing performed, no impairments were
recognised on these CGUs for 2023 or 2022.
13.2 Impairment of computer software
2022
During 2022, as a result of the future-ready technology strategy which introduced significant changes within the technology
landscape, there was a review of card modernisation to realign to the different platforms, which resulted in the relationship
with Network International being terminated, the intangible asset becoming obsolete and consequently being written off by
a total amount of R177 million.
An annual impairment assessment was performed on the High Value Payments (HVP) system. During this assessment it was
determined that certain aspects of HVP have become redundant in its current form, leading to the system being written off
and the recognition of an impairment amounting to R142 million during the financial period to a nil recoverable amount.
The remainder of the group’s computer software assets’ recoverable amounts were determined to be lower than their
carrying values and were impaired by a total of R62 million.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 127
-- 100 of 278 --
14. Deferred taxation
14.1 Deferred tax analysis
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Accrued interest receivable 140 87
Assessed losses2 (528) (600)
Leased assets included in loans and advances 21 40
Capital gains tax 2 084 1 553
Credit impairment charges (6 284) (5 854)
Property, equipment and right of use assets 1 270 1 280
Derivatives and financial instruments (40) 20
Fair value adjustments on financial instruments 1 209 523
Policyholder change in valuation basis (509) (166)
Post-employment benefits 229 176
Share-based payments (1 074) (771)
Special transfer to policyholder tax fund (1 260) (1 553)
Provisions and other items3 (2 229) (1 739)
Deferred tax closing balance (6 971) (7 004)
Deferred tax liabilities 2 030 1 824
Deferred tax assets (9 001) (8 828)
1 Restated. Refer to pages to 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 The group has estimated tax losses of R1 786 million (2022: R1 897 million) which are available for set-off against future taxable income. These tax
losses have arisen from the group entities incurring operational tax losses. This asset is anticipated to be recovered as financial projections indicate
these entities are likely to produce sufficient taxable income in the near future. These deferred tax asset balances were offset against deferred tax
liabilities, refer to annexure F for detailed accounting policies.
3 Intangible asset - present value of in-force life insurance has been aggregated in provisions and other items to better align to how management analyses
and reviews the deferred tax balance related to this item. The prior year comparative disclosures have also been aggregated in line with this change. This
aggregation had no impact on the statement of financial position.
128 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 101 of 278 --
14.2 Deferred tax reconciliation
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Deferred tax at the beginning of the year (7 004) (4 549)
Total temporary differences for the year 33 (2 455)
Accrued interest receivable 53 25
Assessed losses 72 (264)
Leased assets included in loans and advances (19) (16)
Capital gains tax 531 (394)
Credit impairment charges (430) (607)
Property, equipment and right of use asset (10) (135)
Derivatives and financial instruments (60) (19)
Fair value adjustments on financial instruments 686 190
Policyholder change in valuation basis (343) (750)
Post-employment benefits 53 (64)
Share-based payments (303) 152
Special transfer to life fund 293 272
Provisions and other items2 (490) (845)
Deferred tax at the end of the year (6 971) (7 004)
Recognised in OCI 304 (52)
Fair value adjustments on financial instruments 239 (24)
Defined benefit fund remeasurements 59 (20)
Other 6 (8)
Recognised in equity – deferred tax on share-based payments (309) (59)
Recognised in equity-transaction between owners3 130
Recognised in the income statement (303) (2 316)
Exchange differences4 211 (28)
Recognised in OCI (27) (5)
Recognised in the income statement 238 (23)
Total temporary differences 33 (2 455)
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 Intangible asset - present value of in-force life insurance has been aggregated in provisions and other to better align to how management analyses and
reviews the deferred tax balance related to this item. The prior year comparative disclosures have also been aggregated in line with this change. This
aggregation had no impact on the statement of financial position.
3 Refer to annexure A for further information on the buyout of non-controlling shareholders of Liberty Two Degrees Limited.
4 Refer to annexure A for more details relating to foreign currency translation.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 129
-- 102 of 278 --
15. Share capital
15.1 Authorised
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2 billion ordinary shares (2022: 2 billion)1 200 200
8 million first preference shares (2022: 8 million)2 8 8
1 billion second preference shares (2022: 1 billion)3 10 10
Total 218 218
1 Ordinary shares comprise shares of 10 cents each traded on the JSE and A2X Markets under the symbol SBK, and on the NSX under the symbol SNB.
2 First preference shares comprise 6.5% first cumulative preference shares of R1 each traded on the JSE under the symbol SBKP.
3 Second preference shares comprise non-redeemable, non-cumulative, non-participating preference shares of 1 cent each traded on the JSE under the
symbol SBPP. The non-redeemable, non-cumulative, non-participating preference shares are entitled to an annual dividend, if declared, payable in two
semi-annual instalments of not less than 77% of the prime interest rate multiplied by the subscription price of R100 per share.
15.2 Issued
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Equity attributable to ordinary shareholders 27 106 27 509
Ordinary share capital 168 168
Ordinary share premium 26 938 27 341
Equity attributable to other equity instrument holders 24 167 19 667
First preference share capital 8 8
Second preference share capital 1 1
Second preference share premium 5 494 5 494
Additional tier 1 capital (note 15.8) 18 664 14 164
Total 51 273 47 176
Holders of ordinary share capital hold one vote per ordinary share at the group’s AGM.
First preference shareholders and second preference shareholders are not entitled to voting rights unless:
■ the fixed preference dividend payable is in arrears for more than six months, or
■ a resolution to be tabled at the shareholders’ meeting varies or cancels any of the special rights attached to that preference
share or for the reduction of its capital.
In the event that a resolution is tabled at the AGM to authorise, if circumstances are correct, the repurchase of second
preference shares, the shareholders will be permitted to vote on the resolution at the AGM. In terms of paragraph 8.3.9 of the
memorandum of incorporation, at this meeting the preference shareholders will be entitled to the portion of the total votes
which the aggregate amount of the nominal value of the shares held bears to the aggregate amount of the nominal value of all
the shares held.
AT 1 capital holders have no voting rights.
RECONCILIATION OF ORDINARY SHARES IN ISSUE
Number of shares
Shares in issue at 1 January 2022 1 619 976 537
Shares issued during 2022 in terms of the group’s equity compensation plans 367 506
Shares issued as part of the completion of the group’s acquisition of the remaining non-
controlling ordinary shares in Liberty Holdings Limited (annexure A) 57 980 580
Shares in issue at 31 December 2022 1 678 324 623
Treasury shares held by entities within the group1 21 771 571
Shares held by other shareholders1 1 656 553 052
Shares issued during 2023 in terms of the group’s equity compensation plans 239 847
Shares repurchased during 2023 (2 789 239)
Shares in issue at 31 December 2023 1 675 775 231
Treasury shares held by entities within the group 18 701 110
Shares held by other shareholders 1 657 074 121
1 Restated. Refer to page 31 to 39 for details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
All issued shares are fully paid up. There has been no movement in the first and second preference shares during the year.
The number of shares in issue for first and second preference shares are 8 000 000 and 52 982 248 respectively.
130 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 103 of 278 --
15.3 Unissued shares
2023
Number of
shares
2022
Number of
shares
Ordinary unissued shares1 202 163 621 199 374 382
Ordinary shares reserved to meet the requirements of EGS and GSIS2 122 061 148 122 300 995
Ordinary shares reserved in terms of the rules of EGS and GSIS as approved by members’
resolution dated 27 May 2010 155 825 715 155 825 715
Less: issued to date of the above resolution for the EGS and GSIS schemes (33 764 567) (33 524 720)
Unissued ordinary shares 324 224 769 321 675 377
Unissued second preference shares 947 017 752 947 017 752
1 During 2023, 2 789 239 shares were repurchased by Standard Bank Group Limited and have reverted back to authorised unissued shares, the average
price paid for the repurchase was R158.83 per share.
2 During the year, 239 847 (2022: 367 506) ordinary shares were issued in terms of the group’s equity compensation plans, notably the EGS and GSIS. No
surplus capital was used to purchase ordinary shares in 2023 (2022: no shares) to counteract the dilutive impact of the shares issued under the equity
compensation plans. Effective from 2017, the group no longer issues EGS and GSIS awards. The last awards in GSIS were issued in 2011 and for the EGS,
the last award was made in 2016. Awards are now provided in terms of the group’s other share schemes, the DBS, PRP and the SARP, both of which are
settled by the group to employees with shares that the group purchases from external market participants, and the CSDBS, which is settled in cash
(refer to annexure D for further information). At the end of the year, the group would need to issue 529 364 (2022: 1 238 352) SBG ordinary shares to
settle the outstanding GSIS options and EGS rights that were awarded to participants in previous years. The shares issued to date for the EGS and GSIS
together with the expected number of shares to settle the outstanding options and rights as a percentage of the total number of shares in issue is 2.0%
(2022: 2.1%).
15.4 Interest of directors in the capital of the company
Direct beneficial1 Indirect beneficial1
2023
Number of
shares
2022
Number of
shares
2023
Number of
shares
2022
Number of
shares
Ordinary shares5 1 074 029 1 551 123 114 675 (123 325)
LL Bam 900 400
A Daehnke 142 040 132 533 8 650
GJ Fraser-Moleketi 1 890 1 890 14 675 14 675
TS Gcabashe2 43 205
BJ Kruger 200 000 571 886
JH Maree 163 109 163 109
KD Moroka3 44 939 44 939
ANA Peterside CON 100 000 100 000
MJ D Ruck4 25 000
SK Tshabalala 521 151 568 161
Second preference shares 37 122 37 122
BJ Kruger 10 331 26 791
JH Maree 26 791 10 331
1 As per JSE Listings Requirements.
2 Retired as a director on 31 May 2022, 2022 balances are reflected as at 31 May 2022.
3 Retired as a director on 12 June 2023, 2023 balances are reflected as at 12 June 2023.
4 Retired as a director on 31 December 2022, balances are reflected as at 31 December 2022.
5 Shares held by directors under share incentive schemes total 1 495 096 (2022 : 1 359 813).
There have been no changes to directors’ interests in the group’s share capital between 1 January 2024 and 14 March 2024.
15.5 General authority of directors to issue shares1
2023
Number of
shares
2022
Number of
shares
Ordinary shares 41 958 115 40 499 413
Second preference shares 1 324 556 1 324 556
1 The general authority expires at the AGM on 10 June 2024.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 131
-- 104 of 278 --
15. Share capital continued
15.6 Treasury shares
2023
Number of
shares
2022
Number of
shares
Purchased during the year1 225 575 692 147 180 415
Total treasury shares held at the end of year2,3 18 701 110 21 771 571
1 Total number of ordinary shares purchased during the year to facilitate client trading activities as well as share buy-backs to mitigate the dilutive impact
as a result of the group’s share incentive schemes.
2 Total number of ordinary shares held at the end of the year by the group’s banking activities in terms of the transactions mentioned above.
3 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
Cash flows relating to transaction involving shares of the group executed on behalf of clients in respect of brokered
transactions are not included within the group’s financing activities of the statement of cash flows.
15.7 Shareholder analysis
2023 2022
Number of
shares
(million) % holding
Number of
shares
(million) % holding
Spread of ordinary shareholders (million)
Public1 1 091.7 65.1 1 095.8 65.2
Non-public1 584.1 34.9 582.6 34.8
Directors, associates of directors and prescribed officers of
SBG, and its subsidiaries2 1.6 0.2 1.9 0.2
ICBC 325.0 19.4 325.0 19.4
Government Employees Pension Fund
(investment managed by PIC) 243.8 14.5 243.9 14.5
SBG retirement funds 2.2 0.1 1.9 0.1
Restricted from trading for longer than six months 2.4 0.1 0.8 0.1
Tutuwa participants3 9.0 0.6 9.0 0.5
Associates of directors 0.1 0.1
Total 1 675.8 100.0 1 678.4 100.0
2023 2022
Number of
shares % holding
Number of
shares % holding
Spread of first preference shareholders
Public1 8 000 000 100 8 000 000 100
Spread of second preference shareholders 52 982 248 52 982 248
Public1 52 945 126 100 52 945 126 100
Non-public1 37 122 37 122
Directors, associates of directors and prescribed officers of
SBG, and its subsidiaries2 37 122 37 122
Total 52 982 248 100 52 982 248 100
1 As per the JSE Listings Requirements.
2 Excludes indirect holdings of strategic partners, which are included in Tutuwa participants.
3 Includes Tutuwa Community Trust, Tutuwa Strategic Holdings 1 and 2, and Tutuwa Managers’ Trusts.
132 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 105 of 278 --
15.8 Additional tier 1 capital and capital attributed to non-controlling interests
Notional and carrying value
Bond Date issued First callable date
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
SBT103 20 February 2019 31 March 2024 1 942 1 942
SBT104 29 September 2020 30 September 2025 1 539 1 539
SBT105 29 March 2021 31 March 2026 1 800 1 800
SBT106 12 October 2021 31 December 2026 1 724 1 724
SBT107 4 April 2022 8 April 2027 1 559 1 559
SBT108 12 July 2022 13 July 2027 2 000 2 000
SBT109 28 November 2022 31 December 2027 3 600 3 600
SBT110 1 June 2023 30 June 2028 2 500
SBT111 16 November 2023 31 December 2028 2 000
Total 18 664 14 164
During 2023, the group issued additional Basel III compliant AT1 capital bonds amounting to R4 500 million
(2022: R7 159 million) and redeemed Rnil (2022: R3 544 million). The AT1 capital bonds are perpetual, non-cumulative with
an issuer call option after a minimum period of five years and one day and on every coupon payment date thereafter.
Coupons to the value of R1 841 million (2022: R968 million) were paid to AT1 capital bondholders. Current tax of R497 million
(2022: R 271 million) relating to the AT1 capital bonds was recognised directly in equity resulting in an aggregate net equity
impact of R1 344 million (2022: R697 million).
The terms of the Basel III compliant AT1 capital bonds include a regulatory requirement which provides for the write-off, in
whole or in part, on the earlier of a decision by the SARB that a write-off without which the issuer would have become non-
viable is necessary, or a decision to make a public sector injection of capital or equivalent support, without which the issuer
would have become non-viable.
The AT1 capital bonds do not have a contractual obligation to pay cash, hence they have been recognised within equity
attributable to other equity instrument holders on the statement of financial position. Holders of AT1 capital do not have
voting rights at the group’s AGM.
16. Empowerment reserve
SBG and Liberty entered into a series of transactions in 2004 whereby investments were made in cumulative redeemable
preference shares issued by black economic empowerment (BEE) entities which are SEs. The initial investments made by
SBG and Liberty totalled R4 017 million and R1 251 million respectively. The proceeds received were used by the BEE entities
to purchase 99 190 197 ordinary shares of SBG. All participants were subject to a ten-year lock-in period which expired on
31 December 2014.
Since the end of the lock-in period, Tutuwa beneficiaries have been able to exit the scheme and this has seen a progressive
reduction in the value of the group’s investment in these preference shares. All remaining preference shares in the Tutuwa
entities were redeemed prior to the final redemption date of 4 October 2019, thus leaving the only shares in the BEE entities
within the Liberty group.
The preference shares owned by the group do not meet the definition of a financial asset in terms of IFRS and are therefore
treated as a negative empowerment reserve within the statement of changes in equity. The empowerment reserve now
represents Liberty shares held by the SEs that are deemed to be treasury shares in terms of IFRS.
During 2022, the group completed the acquisition of the remaining non-controlling ordinary shares in Liberty Holdings Limited
through a scheme of arrangement in which preference shares to the value of R25 million were redeemed. The remaining
preference shares of R36 million, were also redeemed during 2022. The empowerment reserve opening balance, as at 1
January 2022, of R61 million was thus fully settled during 2022.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 133
-- 106 of 278 --
17. Trading liabilities
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Collateral 4 925 5 556
Credit-linked notes 1 658 5 155
Government, municipality and utility bonds 1 624 5 151
Listed equities 41 596 49 197
Repurchase and other collateralised agreements 32 085 34 297
Unlisted equities and other instruments 12 580 10 572
Total 94 468 109 928
18. Provisions and other liabilities
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Financial liabilities 108 466 98 652
Cash-settled share-based payment liability (annexure D) 848 556
Collateral deposit liabilities and repurchase agreements within IAM 6 212 8 031
ECL for off-balance sheet exposure (note 18.2) 444 394
Payables 3 512 5 859
Lease liabilities (note 18.3) 3 714 3 873
Third-party liabilities arising on consolidation of mutual funds (note 18.1) 69 717 62 058
Trading settlement liabilities 9 148 8 367
Other financial liabilities 14 871 9 514
Non-financial liabilities 36 128 31 235
Deferred revenue liability 242 249
Items in the course of transmission 9 350 9 457
Post-employment benefits (note 48) 1 077 1 081
Staff-related accruals 20 756 16 284
Other non-financial liabilities2 4 703 4 164
Total 144 594 129 887
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 Included in other non-financial liabilities are liabilities of a short-term nature such as accrued expenses and sundry provisions. Sundry provisions’
opening balance is R3 007 million (2022: R2 828 million) and closing balance is R3 032 million (2022: R3 007 million), resulting in a net charge of
R25 million (2022: net charge R179 million).
18.1 Third-party liabilities arising on consolidation of mutual funds
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Balance at the beginning of the year 62 058 72 734
Additional mutual funds classified as subsidiaries 5 256 1 675
Distributions (2 148) (1 751)
Fair value adjustments 13 526 (5 126)
Mutual funds no longer classified as subsidiaries (1 537) (476)
Net capital contribution or change in effective ownership (7 438) (4 998)
Balance at the end of the year 69 717 62 058
The group has classified certain mutual funds as investments in subsidiaries. Consequently, fund interest not held by the
group is classified by the group as third-party liabilities as they represent demand deposit liabilities measured at fair value.
134 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 107 of 278 --
18.2 Reconciliation of ECL for off-balance sheet exposure
Letters of credit, bank acceptances and guarantees
Opening
balance
Rm
Net ECL
raised/
(released)
Rm
Exchange
and other
movements
Rm
Closing
balance
Rm
2023
Stage 1 213 81 (18) 276
Stage 2 88 44 8 140
Stage 3 93 6 (71) 28
Total 394 131 (81) 444
2022
Stage 1 232 (21) 2 213
Stage 2 76 13 (1) 88
Stage 3 280 (74) (113) 93
Total 588 (82) (112) 394
18.3 Reconciliation of lease liabilities
Balance at
1 January
Rm
Additions/
modification
Rm
Terminations
and/or
cancellations
Rm
Interest
expense1
Rm
Payments2
Rm
Exchange
and other
movements
Rm
Balance at
31 December
Rm
2023
Buildings 2 349 354 (27) 121 (685) 4 2 116
Branches 1 269 995 (77) 99 (913) (8) 1 365
ATM spacing
and other 255 138 (13) 17 (156) (8) 233
Total 3 873 1 487 (117) 237 (1 754) (12) 3 714
2022
Buildings 2 305 394 (56) 93 (410) 23 2 349
Branches 1 523 666 (68) 107 (933) (26) 1 269
ATM spacing
and other 502 124 (32) 58 (444) 47 255
Total 4 330 1 184 (156) 258 (1 787) 44 3 873
1 As at 31 December 2023, R212 million (2022: R231 million) of this interest expense is included in net interest income and R25 million (2022: R27 million)
is included in non-insurance revenue.
2 These amounts include the principal lease payments as disclosed in the statements of cash flows of R1 517 million (2022: R1 529 million). The remainder
represents interest expense paid during the year.
The group leases various buildings for offices, branches and ATMs. Rental contracts are typically made for fixed average
periods of between three to ten years but may have extension options. Lease terms are negotiated on an individual basis and
contain a wide range of different terms and conditions. In determining the lease term, management considers all facts and
circumstances that create an economic incentive to exercise an extension option, or not exercise a termination option.
Extension options (or periods after termination options) are considered in the lease term when there is reasonable certainty
that those options will be exercised. The assessment of reasonable certainty is reviewed if a significant event or a significant
change in circumstances occurs which affects this assessment and that is within the control of the lessee. The additions/
modifications during 2023 primarily comprise of new leases entered into and renewals of various building for offices, branch
and ATM space leases. The maturity analysis for the undiscounted lease liability is as follows: R2 751 million within one year
(2022: R2 859 million) and R1 018 million within one to five years (2022: R1 057 million).
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 135
-- 108 of 278 --
19. Deposits and debt funding
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Deposits and debt funding from banks 128 590 134 126
Deposits and debt funding from customers 1 873 056 1 754 973
Current accounts 363 162 357 186
Cash management deposits 267 419 222 883
Call deposits 498 692 496 414
Savings accounts 46 923 45 521
Term deposits 426 640 370 232
Negotiable certificates of deposit 172 804 179 430
Foreign currency funding 85 837 68 688
Other funding 11 579 14 619
Total 2 001 646 1 889 099
.
136 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 109 of 278 --
20. Subordinated debt
Redeemable/
repayable date First callable date
Notional
value1 Carrying value1
Million
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Subordinated debt qualifying as SARB regulatory
banking capital2
Standard Bank Group Limited 25 813 24 440
SBT201 13 February 2028 13 February 2023 ZAR3 000 2 973
SBT202 3 December 2028 3 December 2023 ZAR1 516 1 520
SBT203 3 December 2028 3 December 2023 ZAR484 489
SBT204 16 April 2029 16 April 2024 ZAR1 000 1 023 1 018
SBT205 31 May 2029 31 May 2024 USD400 7 346 6 569
SBT206 31 January 2030 31 January 2025 ZAR2 000 1 949 2 029
SBT207 25 June 2030 25 June 2025 ZAR3 500 3 495 3 503
SBT208 28 November 2030 28 November 2025 ZAR1 500 1 436 1 514
SBT209 29 June 2031 29 June 2026 ZAR1 722 1 723 1 720
SBT210 18 October 2033 18 October 2028 ZAR3 639 3 717
SST201 8 December 2031 8 December 2026 ZAR1 444 1 454 1 453
SST202 31 August 2032 31 August 2027 ZAR1 639 1 654 1 652
SST203 3 March 2033 3 March 2028 ZAR2 000 2 016
Subordinated debt issued to group companies 34
Qualifying as SARB regulatory banking capital 25 813 24 474
Africa Regions’ subordinated debt not qualifying as SARB
regulatory banking capital 1 216 1 155
Stanbic Bank Kenya 21 December 2028 15 February 2024 USD20 387 355
Standard Bank Eswatini 29 June 2028 29 June 2023 E100 105 104
Stanbic Botswana 2029 – 2032 2024 – 2027 BWP516 724 696
Total subordinated debt – Banking 27 029 25 629
Subordinated debt within IAM
Qualifying as regulatory insurance capital 5 198 6 115
LGL 08 28 February 2023 ZAR900 910
LGL 09 28 August 2024 ZAR1 100 1 121 1 133
LGL 10 8 October 2025 ZAR1 000 1 006 1 009
LGL 11 9 September 2026 ZAR1 500 1 554 1 557
LGL 12 4 October 2027 ZAR1 500 1 517 1 506
Total 32 227 31 744
1 The difference between the carrying and notional value represents foreign exchange movements, transaction costs included in the initial carrying
amounts, accrued interest and the unamortised fair value adjustments relating to bonds, where applicable, hedged for interest rate risk.
2 Basel III compliant tier 2 instruments which contain a contractual non-viability write-off feature.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 137
-- 110 of 278 --
21. Classification of assets and liabilities
Accounting classifications and fair values of assets and liabilities
All financial assets and liabilities have been classified according to their measurement category as per IFRS 9 with
disclosure of the fair value being provided for those items.
Fair value through profit or loss
Fair value through other
comprehensive income Total assets
and liabilities
measured at
fair value
Rm
Amortised
cost
Rm1
Other
non-
financial
assets/
liabilities
Rm
Total
carrying
amount
Rm
Fair
value2
Rm Note
Held-for-
trading
Rm
Designated
at fair value
Rm
Default
Rm
Debt
instruments
Rm
Equity
instruments
Rm
2023
Assets
Cash and balances with central banks 1 122 718 122 718 15 069 137 787 137 787
Derivative assets 2 97 419 97 419 97 419 97 419
Trading assets 3 316 515 316 515 316 515 316 515
Pledged assets 4 8 059 4 119 5 105 17 283 2 927 20 210 20 210
Disposal group assets held for sale 5 235 235 235 235
Financial investments 6 8 757 411 294 70 439 1 592 492 082 266 694 758 776 759 456
Other financial assets3 7 22 743 22 743
Loans and advances 8 715 715 1 608 131 1 608 846 1 610 314
Reinsurance contract assets 9 5 422 5 422
Insurance contract assets 9 1 631 1 631
Interest in associates and joint ventures 10 12 173 12 173
Investment property 11 30 444 30 444 30 444
Other non-financial assets 53 544 53 544
Total assets 421 993 8 757 539 081 75 544 1 592 1 046 967 1 915 564 103 214 3 065 745
Liabilities
Derivative liabilities 2 103 373 103 373 103 373 103 373
Trading liabilities 17 94 468 94 468 94 468 94 468
Other financial liabilities3 18 71 733 71 733 36 733 108 466
Deposits and debt funding 19 3 219 3 219 1 998 427 2 001 646 2 008 421
Financial liabilities under investment contracts 9 151 035 151 035 151 035 151 035
Insurance contract liabilities 9 251 389 251 389
Subordinated debt 20 5 198 5 198 27 029 32 227 32 227
Other non-financial liabilities 46 221 46 221
Total liabilities 197 841 231 185 429 026 2 062 189 297 610 2 788 825
1 Includes financial assets and financial liabilities for which the carrying value has been adjusted for changes in fair value due to designated hedged risks.
2 Carrying value has been used where it closely approximates fair values, excluding non-financial assets and liabilities. Refer to the fair value section in
accounting policy 4 – Fair value in annexure F and key management assumptions for a description on how fair values are determined.
3 The fair value of other financial assets and liabilities measured at amortised cost approximates the carrying value due to their short-term nature.
138 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 139
-- 111 of 278 --
21. Classification of assets and liabilities continued
Accounting classifications and fair values of assets and liabilities continued
All financial assets and liabilities have been classified according to their measurement category as per IFRS 9
with disclosure of the fair value being provided for those items.
Fair value through profit or loss
Fair value through other
comprehensive income Total assets
and liabilities
measured at
fair value
Rm
Amortised
cost
Rm1
Other
non-
financial
assets/
liabilities
Rm
Total
carrying
amount
Rm
Fair
value2
Rm Note
Held-for-
trading
Rm
Designated
at fair value
Rm
Default
Rm
Debt
instruments
Rm
Equity
instruments
Rm
2022 – restated3
Assets
Cash and balances with central banks 1 99 758 99 758 14 725 114 483 114 483
Derivative assets 2 74 410 74 410 74 410 74 410
Trading assets 3 314 918 314 918 314 918 314 918
Pledged assets 4 8 375 7 501 2 721 18 597 711 19 308 19 309
Disposal group assets held for sale 5 555 555 555 555
Financial investments3 6 38 564 378 474 81 708 905 499 651 222 843 722 494 721 470
Other financial assets3,4 7 26 329 26 329
Loans and advances3 8 665 665 1 504 275 1 504 940 1 504 933
Reinsurance contract assets3 9 5 522 5 522
Insurance contract assets3 9 1 830 1 830
Interest in associates and joint ventures 10 9 956 9 956
Investment property 11 29 289 29 289 29 289
Other non-financial assets3 58 363 58 363
Total assets 397 703 38 564 486 953 84 429 905 1 008 554 1 768 883 104 960 2 882 397
Liabilities
Derivative liabilities 2 85 049 85 049 85 049 85 049
Trading liabilities 17 109 928 109 928 109 928 109 928
Other financial liabilities3,4 18 72 105 72 105 26 547 98 652
Deposits and debt funding 19 2 822 2 822 1 886 277 1 889 099 1 888 030
Financial liabilities under investment contracts3 9 136 309 136 309 136 309 136 309
Insurance contract liabilities3 9 231 849 231 849
Subordinated debt 20 6 115 6 115 25 629 31 744 33 378
Other non-financial liabilities 40 901 40 901
Total liabilities 194 977 217 351 412 328 1 938 453 272 750 2 623 531
1 Includes financial assets and financial liabilities for which the carrying value has been adjusted for changes in fair value due to designated hedged risks.
2 Carrying value has been used where it closely approximates fair values, excluding non-financial assets and liabilities.
3 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
4 The fair value of the other financial assets and liabilities approximates the carrying value due to their short-term nature. Refer to the fair value section in
accounting policy 4 – Fair value in annexure F and key management assumptions for a description on how fair values are determined.
140 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 141
-- 112 of 278 --
22. Fair value disclosures
22.1 Assets and liabilities measured at fair value – measured on a recurring basis1
2023 2022
Level 1
Rm
Level 2
Rm
Level 3
Rm
Total
Rm
Level 1
Rm
Level 2
Rm
Level 3
Rm
Total
Rm
Financial assets
Cash and balances with
central bank 122 701 17 122 718 97 616 2 142 99 758
Derivative assets 754 94 005 2 660 97 419 506 72 462 1 442 74 410
Trading assets 179 893 114 757 21 865 316 515 170 125 130 435 14 358 314 918
Pledged assets 17 260 23 17 283 18 572 25 18 597
Disposal group assets held
for sale2 235 235 555 555
Financial investments3 238 240 247 547 6 295 492 082 236 595 248 066 14 990 499 651
Loans and advances3 715 715 25 640 665
Investment property 30 444 30 444 29 289 29 289
Total assets at fair value 558 848 456 349 62 214 1 077 411 523 414 453 155 61 274 1 037 843
Financial liabilities
Derivative liabilities 166 96 286 6 921 103 373 180 80 344 4 525 85 049
Trading liabilities 44 633 48 302 1 533 94 468 56 390 48 775 4 763 109 928
Deposits and debt funding 3 219 3 219 2 822 2 822
Financial liabilities under
investment contracts3 151 035 151 035 136 309 136 309
Other financial liabilities3 69 717 2 016 71 733 70 089 2 016 72 105
Subordinated debt 5 198 5 198 6 115 6 115
Total liabilities at fair
value 44 799 373 757 10 470 429 026 56 570 344 454 11 304 412 328
1 Recurring fair value measurements of assets or liabilities are those assets and liabilities that IFRS requires or permits to be measured at fair value in the
statement of financial position at the end of each reporting period.
2 The disposal group is measured on a non-recurring basis.
3 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
Assets and liabilities transferred between level 1 and level 2
During the current year, no financial investments were transferred between level 1 to level 2. During 2022, R3.6 billion of
financial investments was transferred from level 1 to level 2 as these assets were no longer listed or traded in an active market.
During the current year, cash and balances with the central bank was transferred from level 2 to level 1 due to the improved
observability of non-performance risk.
142 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 113 of 278 --
Level 3 assets and liabilities
Reconciliation of level 3 assets
The following table provides a reconciliation of the opening to closing balance for all assets that are measured at fair value
and incorporate inputs that are not based on observable market data (level 3).
Derivative
assets
Rm
Trading
assets
Rm
Financial
investments
Rm
Investment
property
Rm
Loans and
advances
Rm
Total
Rm
Balance at 1 January 2022 1 040 16 311 18 437 29 985 473 66 246
Total gains/(losses) included in
profit or loss 470 (1 189) 533 (1 315) 58 (1 443)
Trading revenue 470 (1 189) (719)
Other revenue 829 58 887
Investment losses (296) (1 315) (1 611)
Total gains included in OCI 162 162
Issuances and purchases 356 245 7 643 656 3 308 12 208
Sales and settlements1 (250) (963) (11 459) (574) (3 673) (16 919)
Transfers into level 32 58 58
Transfers out of level 33 (210) (46) (93) (349)
Exchange and other movements (22) (233) 537 474 756
Balance at 31 December 2022 1 442 14 358 14 990 29 289 640 60 719
Balance at 1 January 2023 1 442 14 358 14 990 29 289 640 60 719
Total (losses)/gains included in
profit or loss (91) 1 591 757 2 606 (214) 4 649
Trading revenue (91) 1 591 1 500
Other revenue 742 (214) 528
Investment gains 15 2 606 2 621
Total gains included in OCI 170 170
Issuances and purchases 2 583 21 106 1 337 366 1 818 27 210
Sales and settlements (415) (11 213) (10 525) (1 529) (23 682)
Transfers into level 32 149 149
Transfers out of level 33 (70) (4 126) (4 196)
Exchange and other movements (789) (434) (1 817) (3 040)
Balance at 31 December 2023 2 660 21 865 6 295 30 444 715 61 979
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 Transfers of financial assets between levels of the fair value hierarchy are deemed to have occurred at the end of the reporting period. During the year,
the valuation inputs of certain financial assets became unobservable. The fair value of these assets was transferred into level 3.
3 During the year, the valuation inputs of certain level 3 financial assets became observable. The fair value of these financial assets was transferred into
level 2.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 143
-- 114 of 278 --
22. Fair value disclosures continued
22.1 Assets and liabilities measured at fair value – measured on a recurring basis continued
Unrealised gains/(losses) recognised in profit or loss on assets measured at level 3 fair value
Derivative
assets
Rm
Trading
assets
Rm
Financial
investments
Rm
Investment
property
Rm
Loans and
advances
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Trading revenue (188) 12 586 12 398
Other revenue 267 (228) 39
Investment gains 19 2 606 2 625
Total (188) 12 586 286 2 606 (228) 15 062
2022
Trading revenue 466 (1 124) (658)
Other revenue 434 58 492
Investment (losses)/gains (290) 309 19
Total 466 (1 124) 144 309 58 (147)
Reconciliation of level 3 liabilities
The following table provides a reconciliation of the opening to closing balance for all liabilities that are measured at fair value
based on the inputs that are not based on observable market data (level 3).
Derivative
liabilities
Rm
Trading
liabilities
Rm
Other
financial
liabilities
Rm
Total
Rm
Balance at 1 January 2022 3 000 2 146 3 069 8 215
Total losses included in profit or loss1 1 740 15 1 755
Issuances and purchases 469 3 135 3 604
Sales and settlements (416) (492) (1 053) (1 961)
Transfers out of level 32 (275) (41) (316)
Transfers into level 33 7 7
Balance at 31 December 2022 4 525 4 763 2 016 11 304
Balance at 1 January 2023 4 525 4 763 2 016 11 304
Trading revenue in profit or loss 1 966 (116) 1 850
Issuances and purchases 763 1 258 2 021
Sales and settlements (144) (4 423) (4 567)
Transfers out of level 32 (189) (189)
Transfers into level 33 51 51
Balance at 31 December 2023 6 921 1 533 2 016 10 470
1 The majority of total losses in profit or loss is recognised within trading revenue.
2 Transfers of financial liabilities between the levels of the fair value hierarchy are deemed to have occurred at the end of the reporting period. During the
year, the valuation inputs of certain financial liabilities became observable. The fair value of these liabilities was transferred into level 2.
3 The valuation inputs of certain financial liabilities became unobservable during the year. The fair value of these financial liabilities was transferred into
level 3.
144 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 115 of 278 --
22. Fair value disclosures continued
22.1 Assets and liabilities measured at fair value – measured on a recurring basis continued
Unrealised losses/(gains) recognised in profit or loss on financial liabilities measured at level 3
fair value
Derivative
liabilities
Rm
Trading
liabilities
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Trading revenue 2 329 (797) 1 532
2022
Trading revenue 1 634 (4) 1 630
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 145
-- 116 of 278 --
22. Fair value disclosures continued
22.1 Financial assets and liabilities measured at fair value on a recurring basis continued
Sensitivity and interrelationships of inputs
The behaviour of the unobservable parameters used to determine fair value level 3 assets and liabilities is not necessarily
independent, and may often hold a relationship with other observable and unobservable market parameters. Where material
and possible, such relationships are captured in the valuation by way of correlation factors, though these factors are, themselves,
frequently unobservable. In such instances, the range of possible and reasonable fair value estimates is taken into account when
determining appropriate model adjustments.
The table that follows indicates the sensitivity of valuation techniques used in the determination of the fair value of the level 3
assets and liabilities measured and disclosed at fair value. The table further indicates the effect that a significant change in one or
more of the inputs to a reasonably possible alternative assumption would have on profit or loss at the reporting date (where the
change in the unobservable input would change the fair value of the asset or liability significantly). The interrelationship between
these significant unobservable inputs (which mainly include discount rates, spot prices of the underlying, correlation factors,
volatilities, dividend yields, earning yields and valuation multiplies) and the fair value measurement could be
favourable/(unfavourable), if these inputs were higher/(lower). The changes in the inputs that have been used in the analysis have
been determined taking into account several considerations such as the nature of the asset or liability and the market within which
the asset or liability is transacted.
Significant unobservable inputs applied1
Change in significant
unobservable input
Effect on profit or loss
Favourable
Rm
(Unfavourable)
Rm
2023
Derivative instruments Discounted cash flow model, Black-Scholes model, combination technique models From (1%) to 1% 233 (234)
Financial investments Discounted cash flow and Black-Scholes models using current market rates for credit, interest,
liquidity, volatility and other risks, combination techniques such as earnings and dividend yields
of the underlying entity
From (1%) to 1% 45 (46)
Trading assets From (1%) to 1% 142 (142)
Loans and advances Discounted cash flow model From (1%) to 1% 6 (6)
Trading liabilities
Discounted cash flow and Black-Scholes models using current market rates for credit, interest,
liquidity, volatility and other risks, combination techniques such as earnings and dividend yields
of the underlying entity From (1%) to 1% 2 (2)
Total 428 (430)
2022
Derivative instruments Discounted cash flow model, Black-Scholes model, combination technique models From (1%) to 1% 250 (250)
Financial investments Discounted cash flow and Black-Scholes models using current market rates for credit, interest, liquidity,
volatility and other risks, combination techniques such as earnings and dividend yields of the underlying
entity
From (1%) to 1% 38 (41)
Trading assets From (1%) to 1% 58 (58)
Loans and advances2 Discounted cash flow model From (1%) to 1% 6 (6)
Trading liabilities
Discounted cash flow and Black-Scholes models using current market rates for credit, interest, liquidity,
volatility and other risks, combination techniques such as earnings and dividend yields of the underlying
entity From (1%) to 1% 31 (31)
Total 383 (386)
1 For more detail of the nature of significant unobservable inputs applied in the valuation of financial assets and liabilities, refer to annexure F,
accounting policy 4.
2 Loans and advances were erroneously excluded from the prior year disclosure. This has been included for 2023 and comparatives have been restated
accordingly.
Financial investments classified as FVOCI
The measurement of financial investments classified as FVOCI would result in a R45 million favourable (2022: R38 million) and
R46 million unfavourable (2022: R41 million) impact on OCI applying a 1% change (both favourable and unfavourable) of the
significant unobservable inputs, listed above, used to determine the fair value. For the nature of significant unobservable inputs
applied in the valuation of financial investments classified as FVOCI refer to annexure F, accounting policy 4.
Investment property
Investment properties’ fair values were obtained from independent valuators who derived the values by determining sustainable
net rental income to which an appropriate exit capitalisation rate is applied. Exit capitalisation rates are adjusted for occupancy
levels, age of the building, location and expected future benefit of recent alterations.
Certain properties are largely linked to policyholder benefits and consortium non-controlling interests, which limit the impact to
group ordinary shareholder comprehensive income or equity for any changes in the fair value measurement. Refer to annexure C
for detail of the property exposure in the Shareholder Investment Portfolio (SIP).
The sensitivities of aggregate market values for 1% changes in exit capitalisation rates are as follows. A 1% increase in the exit
capitalisation rate would result in a decrease in fair value of R2 583 million (2022: R2 534 million). A 1% decrease in the exit capitalisation
rate would result in an increase in the fair value of R3 232 million (2022: R3 303 million).
146 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 147
Refer to key management assumptions and detailed accounting policies in annexure F for more
information about valuation techniques used.
Other financial liabilities
The other financial liabilities categorised as level 3 relate to third-party financial liabilities arising on the consolidation of
mutual funds.
A sensitivity analysis is therefore not provided since a similar sensitivity would arise on the assets that relate to these
liabilities.
-- 117 of 278 --
22. Fair value disclosures continued
22.2 Assets and liabilities not measured at fair value for which fair value is disclosed
2023 2022
Level 1
Rm
Level 2
Rm
Level 3
Rm
Total
Rm
Level 1
Rm
Level 2
Rm
Level 3
Rm
Total
Rm
Assets
Cash and balances
with central banks 14 472 597 15 069 14 103 622 14 725
Pledged assets 2 561 366 2 927 171 541 712
Financial investments 219 600 45 380 2 394 267 374 182 085 35 122 5 901 223 108
Loans and advances 51 557 362 466 1 195 576 1 609 599 25 881 336 729 1 141 658 1 504 268
Total assets 288 190 408 809 1 197 970 1 894 969 222 240 373 014 1 147 559 1 742 813
Liabilities
Deposits and debt
funding 1 146 431 835 459 17 987 1 999 877 1 006 300 870 583 8 325 1 885 208
Subordinated debt 1 216 25 813 27 029 1 192 26 071 27 263
Total liabilities 1 146 431 836 675 43 800 2 026 906 1 006 300 871 775 34 396 1 912 471
22.3 Third-party credit enhancements
There were no significant liabilities measured at fair value that existed during the year which had been issued with inseparable
third-party credit enhancements.
22.4 Financial assets and financial liabilities designated at FVTPL
Financial assets
Maximum
exposure to
credit risk1
Rm
Exposure
mitigated
Rm
Current
year loss on
changes
in fair value
attributable
to changes
in credit risk
Rm
Cumulative
loss on
changes
in fair value
attributable
to changes
in credit risk
Rm
Current year
changes
in fair value
attributable
to related
credit
derivatives
Rm
2023
Financial investments 2 379 61 88
2022
Financial investments 12 955 (188) 21 27 (1)
1 The maximum exposure to credit risk for the sovereign exposures is deemed to be insignificant, thus this balance primarily relates to corporate and bank
exposures. Refer to annexure C for additional information on maximum exposure to credit risk by credit quality.
The changes in the fair value of the designated financial assets attributable to changes in credit risk are calculated by
reference to the implied credit spread derived from the changes in the observable market values of the relevant instruments.
148 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 118 of 278 --
22. Fair value disclosures continued
Financial assets and financial liabilities designated at FVTPL continued
Financial liabilities
Current year
(loss)/gain
on changes
in fair value
attributable
to changes
in credit risk
Rm
Cumulative
gain/(loss)
on changes
in fair value
attributable
to changes
in credit risk1
Rm
Contractual
payment
required
at maturity
Rm
Carrying
amount
Rm
Difference
between
carrying
amount and
contractual
payment
Rm
Credit risk recognised in OCI
2023
Other financial liabilities 71 733 71 733
Deposits and debt funding (2) 14 3 224 3 263 39
Financial liabilities under investment
contracts 151 035 151 035
Subordinated debt 31 67 8 400 8 895 495
Total 29 81 234 392 234 926 534
2022
Other financial liabilities 72 103 72 103
Deposits and debt funding (5) 16 2 873 2 821 (52)
Financial liabilities under investment
contracts2 136 309 136 309
Subordinated debt (30) 36 6 950 7 076 126
Total (35) 52 218 235 218 309 74
1 Gross of taxation. Refer to note 42.2 for detail on tax relating to the above.
2 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
The changes in the fair value of the designated financial liabilities attributable to changes in credit risk are calculated by
reference to the change in the credit risk implicit in the market value of the group's senior notes.
22.5 Reconciliation of FVOCI reserve movements
22.5.1 Equity financial investments
Revaluation
Balance at
the
beginning of
the year
Rm
Gains/
(losses)
Rm
Balance at
the
end of
the year
Rm
2023
Visa shares 638 162 800
STRATE Limited 132 140 272
Other (576) (272) (848)
Total 194 30 224
2022
Visa shares 170 468 638
STRATE Limited 139 (7) 132
Other (87) (489) (576)
Total 222 (28) 194
Strategic equity investments are designated at FVOCI on initial recognition. No gains and losses were transferred to retained
earnings during the year. No dividends were received during the year. Amounts are net of taxation.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 149
-- 119 of 278 --
22. Fair value disclosures continued
22.5 Reconciliation of FVOCI reserve movements continued
22.5.2 Debt financial investments
Balance at the
beginning
of the year
Rm
Net
change in
fair value
Rm
Realised
fair value
adjustments
and reversal
to profit or
loss
Rm
Net ECL
(released)/
raised
during the
period
Rm
Non-
controlling
interests and
other
movements
Rm
Balance
at the end
of the year
Rm
2023
Sovereign 32 70 17 142 261
Total 32 70 17 142 261
2022
Sovereign 264 (45) 2 (77) (112) 32
Total 264 (45) 2 (77) (112) 32
22.5.3 Total reconciliation of the FVOCI reserve
Balance at the
beginning
of the year
Rm
Net
movement
Rm
Non-
controlling
interests
Rm
Balance
at the end
of the year
Rm
2023
Total 226 259 485
2022
Total 486 (148) (112) 226
23. Financial instruments subject to offsetting, enforceable master netting
arrangements or similar agreements
IFRS requires a financial asset and a financial liability to be offset and the net amount presented in the statement of financial
position when, and only when, the group has a current legally enforceable right to set off recognised amounts, as well as the
intention to settle on a net basis or to realise the asset and settle the liability simultaneously. There are no other instances
apart from the cash management accounts, where the group has a current legally enforceable right to offset as well as the
intention to settle on a net basis or to realise the asset and settle the liability simultaneously.
The following table sets out the impact of offset, as well as the required disclosures for financial assets and financial liabilities
that are subject to an enforceable master netting arrangements or similar agreements, irrespective of whether they have been
offset in accordance with IFRS. It should be noted that the information below is not intended to represent the group and
company’s actual credit exposure, nor will it agree to that presented in the statement of financial position.
Assets
Gross
amount of
recognised
financial
assets1
Rm
Financial
liabilities set
off in the
statement of
financial
position2
Rm
Net amount
of financial
assets
subject
to netting
agreements3
Rm
Collateral
received4
Rm
Net
amount
Rm
2023
Derivative assets 95 407 95 407 (75 680) 19 727
Trading assets 53 174 53 174 (53 174)
Loans and advances5 135 865 (21 221) 114 644 (111 778) 2 866
Total 284 446 (21 221) 263 225 (240 632) 22 593
2022
Derivative assets 65 438 65 438 (56 058) 9 380
Trading assets 69 119 69 119 (69 119)
Loans and advances5 107 831 (21 509) 86 322 (82 406) 3 916
Total 242 388 (21 509) 220 879 (207 583) 13 296
Refer to footnotes that follow the liabilities table.
150 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 120 of 278 --
Liabilities
Gross
amount of
recognised
financial
liabilities1
Rm
Financial
assets set
off in the
statement of
financial
position2
Rm
Net amount
of financial
liabilities
subject
to netting
agreements3
Rm
Collateral
pledged6
Rm
Net
amount
Rm
2023
Derivative liabilities 89 397 89 397 (76 513) 12 884
Trading liabilities 31 648 31 648 (31 648)
Deposits and debt funding5 26 347 (21 221) 5 126 5 126
Total 147 392 (21 221) 126 171 (108 161) 18 010
2022
Derivative liabilities 58 707 58 707 (53 384) 5 323
Trading liabilities 33 800 33 800 (33 800)
Deposits and debt funding5 26 232 (21 509) 4 723 4 723
Total 118 739 (21 509) 97 230 (87 184) 10 046
1 Gross amounts are disclosed for recognised financial assets and financial liabilities that are either offset in the statement of financial position or are
subject to an enforceable master netting arrangement or a similar agreement, irrespective of whether the offsetting criteria is met.
2 Gross amounts of recognised financial assets or financial liabilities that qualify for offset in accordance with the criteria per IFRS.
3 Related amounts not offset in the statement of financial position that are subject to an enforceable master netting arrangement or similar agreement.
4 This could include financial collateral (whether recognised or unrecognised), cash collateral as well as exposures that are available to the group to be
offset in the event of default. In most cases the group and company is allowed to sell or repledge collateral received.
5 The most material amounts offset in the statement of financial position pertain to cash management accounts. The cash management accounts allow
holding companies (or central treasury functions) to manage the cash flows of a group by linking the current accounts of multiple legal entities within a
group. It allows for cash balances of the different legal entities to be offset against each other to arrive at a net balance for the whole group. In addition,
all repurchase agreements (for financial liabilities) and reverse repurchase agreements (for financial assets), subject to an enforceable master netting
arrangement (or similar agreement), have been included.
6 In most instances, the counterparty may not sell or repledge collateral pledged by the group.
The table below sets out the nature of agreements and the types of rights relating to items which do not qualify for offset but
that are subject to a master netting arrangement or similar agreement.
Nature of agreement Related rights
Derivative assets and liabilities International swaps and derivatives
association agreement
The agreement allows for offset in the
event of default.
Trading assets and liabilities Global master repurchase agreement The agreement allows for offset in the
event of default.
Loans and advances Customer agreement and Banks Act In the event of liquidation or
bankruptcy, offset shall be
enforceable subject to all applicable
laws and regulations.
Deposits and debt funding Customer agreement and Banks Act In the event of liquidation or
bankruptcy, offset shall be
enforceable subject to all applicable
laws and regulations.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 151
-- 121 of 278 --
24. Contingent liabilities and commitments
24.1 Contingent liabilities
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Letters of credit and bankers’ acceptances 26 990 19 378
Guarantees 95 730 103 061
Total 122 720 122 439
Loan commitments of R105 265 million (2022: R104 782 million) that are irrevocable over the life of the facility or revocable
only in response to material adverse changes are included within the funding and liquidity risks section in annexure C.
24.2 Commitments
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Investment property 1 087 961
Property and equipment 445 465
Other intangible assets 223 190
Total 1 755 1 616
The expenditure will be funded from the group’s internal resources.
Facility commitments of R2.0 billion (2022: R2.7 billion) that were granted subject to compliance with objective and
substantive conditions are included within the IAM related risk sections in annexure C.
24.3 Lease commitments
24.3.1 The future minimum payments payable under low-value assets and short-term leases
Within one
year
Rm
Between
one
and five
years
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Low-value assets and short-term leases1 15 15 30
Total 15 15 30
2022
Low-value assets and short-term leases2 27 14 41
Total 27 14 41
1 Additional short-term lease contracts relate to committed storage leases during 2023.
2 Restated. During 2023 it was noted that the ʻwithin one year’ and total were erroneously overstated by R507 million. This restatement had no impact on
the group’s or company’s statement of financial position or income statement.
Low-value assets comprise IT equipment and small items of office furniture.
152 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 122 of 278 --
24. Contingent liabilities and commitments continued
24.4 Legal proceedings defended
In the ordinary course of business, the group is involved as a defendant in litigation, lawsuits and other proceedings.
Management recognises the inherent difficulty of predicting the outcome of defended legal proceedings. Nevertheless, based
on management’s knowledge from investigation, analysis and after consulting with legal counsel, management believes that
there are no individual legal proceedings that are currently assessed as being ʻlikely to succeed and material’ or ʻunlikely to
succeed but material should they succeed’. The group is also the defendant in some legal cases for which the group is fully
indemnified by external third parties, none of which are individually material. Management is accordingly satisfied that the
legal proceedings currently pending against the group should not have a material adverse effect on the group’s consolidated
financial position and the directors are satisfied that the group has adequate insurance programmes and, where required in
terms of IFRS for claims that are probable, provisions are in place to meet claims that may succeed.
Competition Commission – trading of foreign currency
On 15 February 2017, South Africa’s Competition Commission lodged five complaints with the Competition Tribunal (Tribunal)
against 18 institutions, including one against SBSA and two against a former subsidiary of the group, Standard New York
Securities Inc (SNYS), in which it alleged unlawful collusion between those institutions in the trading of USD/ZAR. The group
conducted its own internal investigations with the help of external counsel and found no evidence to support the complaints.
Various litigation processes took place, with the Competition Commission being ordered to file a new complaint affidavit,
which was done on 1 June 2020. The new complaint affidavit added further respondents, bringing the total to 25, including
Standard Americas. In the group’s view, the new complaint affidavit (and several supplementary affidavits) filed by the
Competition Commission, continued to contain multiple procedural and substantive deficiencies. Further litigation processes
ensued. On 8 January 2024 the Competition Appeal Court (CAC) (a bench of three judges) upheld SBSA’s appeal against the
Tribunal’s decision not to dismiss the complaint referred pre-trial and dismissed the Competition Commission’s complaint in
its entirety. The CAC also dismissed the complaint referred against Standard New York Securities and upheld the appeal of
Standard Americas against the order that it be joined belatedly as a respondent. The court found that neither SBSA nor
Standard New York Securities should have been included in the referral of the complaint as no prima facie case had been
made out against either and that the Tribunal should not have allowed the joinder of Standard Americas after lodging of the
referral at the Tribunal. The Competition Commission delivered a notice of application for leave to appeal to the Constitutional
Court, which excluded Standard New York Securities. SBSA and Standard Americas are opposing this notice. Our legal advice
is that there is no obvious constitutional point to be raised in relation to SBSA and Standard Americas. This is considered as a
non-adjusting event in terms of IAS 10 Events after the Reporting Period.
Indemnities granted following disposal of Standard Bank Plc
Under the terms of the disposal of Standard Bank Plc on 1 February 2015, the group provided ICBC with certain indemnities to
be paid in cash to ICBC or, at ICBC’s direction, to any Standard Bank Plc (now ICBCS) group company, a sum equal to the
amount of losses suffered or incurred by ICBC arising from certain circumstances. Where an indemnity payment is required
to be made by the group to the ICBCS group, such payment would be grossed up from ICBC’s shareholding at the time in
ICBCS to 100%. These payments may, inter alia, arise as a result of an enforcement action, the cause of which occurred prior
to the date of disposal. Enforcement actions include actions taken by regulatory or governmental authorities to enforce the
relevant laws in any jurisdiction. While there have been no material claims relating to these indemnification provisions during
the reporting period, the indemnities provided are uncapped and of unlimited duration as they reflect that the pre-completion
regulatory risks attaching to the disposed-of business remain with the group post-completion.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 153
-- 123 of 278 --
25. Maturity analysis
The group assesses the maturity of its assets and liabilities at 31 December each year. This gives an indication of the
remaining life of these assets at that point in time. The following table illustrates the maturities based on a contractual
discounted basis. For the maturity analysis of financial liabilities on a contractual undiscounted basis, refer to the funding and
liquidity risk section within annexure C.
25.1 Financial assets and liabilities
Note
Redeem-
able on
demand1
Rm
Within one
year
Rm
Within one
to five
years
Rm
After five
years
Rm
Undated2
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Cash and balances with central
banks3 1 22 322 115 465 137 787
Trading assets 3 1 115 88 706 43 948 111 841 70 905 316 515
Pledged assets 4 12 370 6 694 1 146 20 210
Gross financial investments 6 9 075 235 990 125 528 115 057 273 539 759 189
Other financial assets 7 10 505 10 988 646 24 580 22 743
Gross loans and advances4 8 186 388 406 713 542 567 456 249 80 924 1 672 841
Net derivative (liability)/asset 2 (2 128) 3 212 (2 819) (4 219) (5 954)
Trading liabilities 17 (6 055) (36 526) (13 379) (38 429) (79) (94 468)
Other financial liabilities 18 (6 485) (28 050) (1 982) (299) (71 650) (108 466)
Deposits and debt funding 19 (1 316 868) (468 532) (158 907) (57 339) (2 001 646)
Subordinated debt5 20 (10 580) (21 647) (32 227)
2022 - restated6
Cash and balances with central
banks3 1 21 373 93 110 114 483
Trading assets 3 6 844 159 450 54 282 6 139 88 203 314 918
Pledged assets 4 12 809 5 472 1 027 19 308
Gross financial investments 6 4 097 478 797 147 879 74 317 17 404 722 494
Other financial assets6 7 7 710 16 894 285 50 1 390 26 329
Gross loans and advances4 8 145 335 406 122 506 644 439 158 63 509 1 560 768
Net derivative (liability)/asset 2 (3 927) (5 699) 16 (1 029) (10 639)
Trading liabilities 17 (10 557) (45 161) (8 969) (41 198) (4 043) (109 928)
Other financial liabilities6 18 (2 486) (83 769) (6 806) (353) (5 238) (98 652)
Deposits and debt funding 19 (1 195 768) (464 901) (187 062) (41 368) (1 889 099)
Subordinated debt5 20 (6 488) (25 256) (31 744)
1 On-demand includes next-day-maturity instruments.
2 Undated maturity category comprises of regulatory or indeterminate maturity, including any item or position in respect of which no right or obligation in
respect of maturity exists.
3 On-demand cash and balances with central banks include notes and coins.
4 Includes loans and advances measured at FVTPL.
5 The maturity analysis for subordinated debt has been determined as the earlier of the contractual repayment date or the option by the issuer to redeem
the debt.
6 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
154 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 124 of 278 --
25.2 Non-financial assets and liabilities
Note
Less than
12 months
after
reporting
period
Rm
More than
12 months
after
reporting
period
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Disposal group assets held for sale 5 235 235
Other non-financial assets 7 9 675 1 064 10 739
Interest in associates and joint ventures 10 12 173 12 173
Investment property 11 30 444 30 444
Property, equipment and right of use assets 12 471 19 827 20 298
Goodwill and other intangible assets 13 12 723 12 723
Other non-financial liabilities 18 (28 087) (8 041) (36 128)
Current and deferred tax assets 14 * * 9 784
Current and deferred tax liabilities 14 * * (10 093)
2022
Disposal group assets held for sale 5 265 290 555
Other non-financial assets1 7 6 794 6 524 13 318
Interest in associates and joint ventures 10 9 956 9 956
Investment property 11 29 289 29 289
Property, equipment and right of use assets 12 1 290 19 050 20 340
Goodwill and other intangible assets1 13 15 120 15 120
Other non-financial liabilities 18 (23 682) (7 553) (31 235)
Current and deferred tax assets1 14 * * 9 578
Current and deferred tax liabilities1 14 * * (10 315)
* Undated.
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
26. Interest
26.1 Interest income
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Effective interest rate interest income on:
Loans and advances 153 374 109 263
Financial investments 34 615 22 872
Interest income on credit impaired financial assets1 5 301 2 740
Total 193 290 134 875
Interest income on items measured at amortised cost 186 050 130 395
Interest income on debt instruments measured at FVOCI 7 240 4 480
1 Restated, refer to pages 30 to 39 for further details.
26.2 Interest expense
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Interest expense on deposits and debt funding 92 525 54 091
Interest expense on lease liabilities (note 18.3) 212 231
Interest expense on subordinated debt 2 365 2 162
Total 95 102 56 484
Interest expense on items measured at amortised cost 94 890 56 253
Interest expense on lease liabilities 212 231
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 155
-- 125 of 278 --
27. Fee and commission
27.1 Fee and commission revenue
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Account transaction fees 11 026 10 266
Card-based commission 9 350 8 568
Documentation and administration fees 2 681 2 500
Electronic banking fees 6 114 5 584
Foreign currency service fees 3 418 2 688
Insurance fees and commission 2 366 2 393
Knowledge-based fees and commission 1 755 2 495
Other1 8 139 6 946
Total 44 849 41 440
1 Other primarily comprises of fee and commission revenue earned on sundry services such as arrangement, agency and asset management fees as well
as guarantee and commitment commissions.
All fee and commission revenue reported above relate to financial assets or liabilities not carried at FVTPL.
27.2 Fee and commission expense
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Account transaction fees 1 481 1 460
Card-based commission 4 644 4 058
Documentation and administration fees 412 355
Electronic banking fees 608 581
Insurance fees and commission 718 631
Customer loyalty expense 999 958
Other 800 776
Total 9 662 8 819
All fee and commission expenses reported above relates to financial assets or liabilities not carried at FVTPL.
28. Trading revenue
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Commodities 213 470
Equities 4 736 3 446
Fixed income and currencies 15 668 13 130
Total 20 617 17 046
29. Other revenue
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Banking and other 1 270 1 143
Dividend related income2 2 005 1 621
Property related income 189 96
Total 3 464 2 860
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details on the IFRS 17 related restatement. An amount of R1 277 million which was previously included in
other revenue is presented in note 32 insurance revenue related disclosure in terms of IFRS 17.
2 Previously referred to as wealth and insurance related income. The updated description better depicts the nature of the income being disclosed. The
change has no impact on the group or company’s income statements or any related ratios.
156 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 126 of 278 --
30. Other gains and losses on financial instruments
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Derecognition losses on financial assets measured at amortised cost (4) (5)
Fair value gains on debt financial assets measured at FVTPL – default 439 331
Gains on realisation of debt financial assets measured at FVOCI 37 53
Fair value gains on financial instruments designated at FVTPL 2 239 1 744
Fair value gains on equity instruments measured at FVTPL 24 315
Total 2 735 2 438
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 157
-- 127 of 278 --
31. Insurance revenue
Life risk
measured
under GMM
Rm
Life risk
measured
under PAA
Rm
Annuities
and GIPs
Rm
Participating
contracts
Rm
Non-life
measured
under PAA
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Contracts not measured under the PAA 10 723 7 153 4 703 22 579
Amounts relating to changes in liabilities for remaining coverage 9 910 6 733 2 719 19 362
Expected claims and directly attributable expense 7 987 5 920 1 594 15 501
Other amounts, including experience adjustments for premium receipts (71) 169 (30) 68
Change in risk adjustment for non-financial risk for risk expired 827 28 206 1 061
Allocation to loss component (227) (19) (70) (316)
CSM recognised in profit or loss for services provided 1 394 635 1 019 3 048
Income taxes chargeable to the policyholder (348) 151 1 165 968
Recovery of insurance acquisition cash flows 1 161 269 819 2 249
Contracts measured under the PAA 10 414 5 785 16 199
Total 10 723 10 414 7 153 4 703 5 785 38 778
2022
Contracts not measured under the PAA 11 288 5 082 3 935 20 305
Amounts relating to changes in liabilities for remaining coverage 10 164 4 917 3 499 18 580
Expected claims and directly attributable expense 8 257 4 802 2 359 15 418
Other amounts, including experience adjustments for premium receipts (105) (94) (94) (293)
Change in risk adjustment for non-financial risk for risk expired 618 (46) 166 738
Allocation to loss component (221) (13) (65) (299)
CSM recognised in profit or loss for services provided 1 615 268 1 133 3 016
Income taxes chargeable to the policyholder 143 (39) (240) (136)
Recovery of insurance acquisition cash flows 981 204 676 1 861
Contracts measured under the PAA 9 604 5 808 15 412
Total 11 288 9 604 5 082 3 935 5 808 35 717
Note 9.2.1 9.2.2 9.2.3 9.2.4 9.2.5
158 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 159
-- 128 of 278 --
32. Insurance service expense
Life risk
measured
under GMM
Rm
Life risk
measured
under PAA
Rm
Annuities
and GIPs
Rm
Participating
contracts
Rm
Non-life
measured
under PAA
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Incurred claims 6 899 4 951 5 652 301 3 008 20 811
Directly attributable expenses 1 031 1 546 100 1 193 1 026 4 896
Other expenses 388 (23) 114 333 296 1 108
Changes that relate to past service - adjustments to the LIC 150 (27) (57) 31 323 420
Changes to loss component on subsequent measurement (23) 154 33 (30) 134
Losses on onerous contracts at initial recognition 488 62 36 339 34 959
Amortisation of loss component (227) (58) (19) (70) (31) (405)
Amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows 1 161 40 269 819 710 2 999
Total 9 479 6 514 6 135 2 646 5 040 29 814
2022
Incurred claims 6 858 4 205 4 591 684 3 288 19 626
Directly attributable expenses 994 1 592 87 1 227 655 4 555
Other expenses 140 (238) 43 415 503 863
Changes that relate to past service – adjustments to the LIC (49) 116 149 444 660
Changes to loss component on subsequent measurement (48) (343) (40) (42) (8) (481)
Losses on onerous contracts recognised at initial recognition 458 58 96 373 92 1 077
Amortisation of loss component (221) (69) (13) (65) (25) (393)
Amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows 981 77 204 676 664 2 602
Total 8 973 5 636 4 925 3 002 5 110 27 646
Note 9.2.1 9.2.2 9.2.3 9.2.4 9.2.5
160 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 161
-- 129 of 278 --
33. Net expense/(income) from reinsurance contracts held
2023 2022
Life risk
measured
under
GMM
Rm
Life risk
measured
under
PAA
Rm
Non-life
measured
under
PAA
Rm
Total
Rm
Life risk
measured
under
GMM
Rm
Life risk
measured
under PAA
Rm
Non-life
measured
under PAA
Rm
Total
Rm
Contracts not measured under the PAA 1 629 1 629 1 361 1 361
Amounts relating to changes in liabilities for remaining coverage 1 629 1 629 1 361 1 361
Expected recovery for insurance service expenses incurred in the period 1 263 1 263 1 252 1 252
Change in risk adjustment for non-financial risk for risk expired 79 79 53 53
CSM recognised in profit or loss for services provided 264 264 94 94
Reinsurance premium variance 32 32 (31) (31)
Allocation to loss recovery component (9) (9) (7) (7)
Contracts measured under the PAA 1 182 843 2 025 925 790 1 715
Reinsurance expense before recoveries 1 629 1 182 843 3 654 1 361 925 790 3 076
Effect of changes in the risk of reinsurers non-performance (5) (5) (6) (6)
Claims recovered (1 358) (845) (252) (2 455) (1 282) (895) (1 016) (3 193)
Other (income)/expenses (47) 21 (420) (446) (70) (30) (8) (108)
Income on onerous contracts at initial recognition (46) (27) (9) (82) (48) (19) (9) (76)
Changes to loss recovery on subsequent measurement from underlying
onerous contract 19 24
43 12 25 37
Amortisation of loss recovery component 9 9 18 7 9 16
Changes that relate to past service - adjustments to incurred claims (29) 24 (420) (425) (41) (36) (8) (85)
Total 224 358 166 748 9 (240) (231)
162 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 163
-- 130 of 278 --
34. Net finance expense from insurance contracts issued
Life risk
measured
under GMM
Rm
Life risk
measured
under PAA
Rm
Annuities
and GIPs
Rm
Participating
contracts
Rm
Non-life
measured
under PAA
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Changes in fair value of referenced underlying assets 18 047 18 047
Interest accreted on fulfillment cash flows and impact of changes in financial assumptions (692) 466 5 372 19 608 (42) 24 712
Interest accreted on the CSM 783 367 (17 663) (16 513)
Effect of changes in interest rates and other financial assumptions (33) 41 8
Foreign exchange gains or losses 26 26
Total 91 466 5 706 19 992 25 26 280
2022
Changes in fair value of referenced underlying assets 2 531 2 531
Interest accreted on fulfillment cash flows and impact of changes in financial assumptions (157) 232 1 847 2 050 1 3 973
Interest accreted on the CSM 582 183 (2 027) (1 262)
Effect of changes in interest rates and other financial assumptions (28) (8) (36)
Foreign exchange gains or losses 9 17 26
Total 425 232 2 011 2 554 10 5 232
Note 9.2.1 9.2.2 9.2.3 9.2.4 9.2.5
164 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 165
-- 131 of 278 --
35. Net finance income from reinsurance contracts held
Life Risk
measured
under
GMM
Rm
Life Risk
measured
under
PAA
Rm
Non-life
measured
under
PAA
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Interest accreted on fulfilment cash flows and impact of changes in
financial assumptions 24 167 (6) 185
Interest accreted on the CSM 127 127
Foreign exchange gains or losses (1) (1)
Total 151 166 (6) 311
2022
Interest accreted on fulfilment cash flows and impact of changes in
financial assumptions (26) 78 (2) 50
Interest accreted on the CSM 55 55
Foreign exchange gains or losses 3 3
Total 29 81 (2) 108
Note 9.1.1 9.1.2 9.1.4
36. Investment and other income
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Service fee income from long-term financial investment contracts 1 916 1 812
Fee revenue 2 544 2 301
Management fees on assets under management 2 239 2 052
Health administration fees and other fee revenue 305 249
Investment management and service fee income and gain 4 057 3 403
Scrip lending and sundry income 228 107
Rental income from investment property 3 324 2 817
Other revenue 505 479
Total 8 517 7 516
1 Restated. Refer to page 31 to 39 for more details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
IFRS 15 requires disclosure of information relating to the timing of revenue recognised from contracts with customers.
The above revenue is recognised over time. Service fee income from investment contracts comprises of both administration
and asset management services and is recognised over time as services are rendered, with reference to the contract terms
(agreed fee and service). These fees are generally recognised on a daily basis as these services are rendered consistently over
the contract period and include utilisation of skilled professionals' time and applicable support services, including IT systems.
Management fees on assets under management are recognised (with reference to agreed fee terms) as these services are
rendered. This is generally on a daily basis over the duration of the contract as these services (being the utilisation of
professional asset management skills, supported by IT systems and services) are consistently applied over the contract term.
166 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 132 of 278 --
37. Interest income on financial assets using the effective interest method
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Financial assets classified at FVOCI
Interest income from long-term policyholder investment contracts
Term deposits 2 205 1 553
At amortised cost
Loans receivable – interest income 16 22
Interest income on cash and cash equivalents 746 530
Total 2 967 2 105
1 Restated. Refer page 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
38. Fair value adjustments to financial assets, investment management
liabilities and third-party mutual funds
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Fair value adjustments to long-term financial liabilities under investment contracts (18 169) (1 308)
Fair value adjustments to third-party mutual fund interests (13 526) 5 126
Investment properties 338 (207)
Owner occupied properties at fair value through profit or loss (4) 1
Property debtors at FVTPL (21) 32
Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss – default 58 014 999
Financial instruments at FVTPL 57 624 2 524
Financial instruments held for hedging and for trading 390 (1 525)
Financial assets designated at FVTPL 10 8
Fair value of financial liabilities (3 029) (2 716)
Other 81 27
Total 23 694 1 962
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
39. Credit impairment charges
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Net ECL raised 16 442 14 018
Financial investments (note 6) (159) 817
Loans and advances (note 8.1)1 16 420 13 260
Letters of credit and guarantees (note 18.2) 131 (82)
Receivables and other assets 50 23
Recoveries on loans and advances previously written off (821) (1 287)
Modification losses on distressed financial assets 640 612
Total 16 261 13 343
1 Restated. Refer to pages 30 to 39 for further details.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 167
-- 133 of 278 --
40. Operating expenses
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Acquisition costs 4 515 4 362
Amortisation – intangible assets (note 13) 2 493 2 684
Audit fees 542 383
Audit fees – current year 529 359
Fees for other services2 13 24
Communication related expenses 1 294 1 353
Depreciation (note 12) 4 810 4 635
Information technology 12 749 11 048
Marketing and advertising 1 947 2 375
Operating lease charges 331 263
Premises and office costs 7 465 7 233
Professional fees 2 070 2 114
Staff costs 53 465 45 802
Other expenses 14 012 10 269
Total 105 693 92 521
Reallocated to insurance service expense (note 32) 10 944 8 988
Operating expenses as per the income statement 94 749 83 533
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 All fees for services paid to the group’s auditors were considered and approved by the group’s audit committee in terms of its non-audit services policy.
Refer to the report of the group audit committee for further information.
41. Non-trading and capital related items
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Gain on sale of properties and equipment 25 39
Compensation from third parties for assets that were impaired 23 79
Fair value gain on investment property within Banking1 1 482 708
Impairment of associates (note 10) (62) (74)
Impairment of fixed asset (note 12) (18)
Impairment of intangible assets (note 13) (386)
Gain/(loss) on disposal of business 38 (50)
Remeasurement of non-current asset held for sale (note 5) (19) 30
Total 1 487 328
1 The fair value gain on investment property relates to USD denominated properties within Stanbic Bank Zimbabwe (SBZ) as well as the deterioration of
the Zimbabwe RTGS dollar to the USD (see annexure A for further detail on the SBZ functional currency).
168 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 134 of 278 --
42. Direct and indirect taxation
42.1 Indirect taxation
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Value added tax (VAT)2 2 951 2 706
Other indirect taxes and levies 422 371
Total 3 373 3 077
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 The group earns certain amounts of VAT exempt income which result in these amounts of VAT input not being able to be claimed from the revenue
authorities.
42.2 Direct taxation
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
South African normal taxation 14 472 12 776
Current 14 828 12 722
Prior year (356) 54
Deferred taxation (498) (2 054)
Current (728) (1 897)
Prior year 230 (157)
CGT, foreign normal and withholding tax – current year 2 186 879
Current 1 655 1 280
Deferred 531 (401)
Total direct taxation 16 160 11 601
Deferred tax charge/(credit) recognised in OCI2 274 (57)
Deferred tax credit recognised directly in equity (179) (59)
Direct taxation per the income statement 16 065 11 717
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details on the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 Included in this amount is a current tax credit recognised through OCI of R3 million (2022: R0 million current tax charge).
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 169
-- 135 of 278 --
42. Direct and indirect taxation continued
Income tax recognised in OCI
The table below sets out the amount of income tax relating to each component within OCI:
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Items that may be subsequently reclassified to profit or loss
Movement in total hedge reserve1 (258) (11)
Net change in fair value of cash flow hedges (113) 79
Realised fair value adjustments of cash flow hedges transferred to profit or loss (145) (90)
Net change in fair value of debt financial assets measured at FVOCI 36 9
Net change in fair value 33 11
Realised fair value adjustments transferred to profit or loss 3 (2)
Movement in net investment hedge reserve 1 11
Items that may not be subsequently reclassified to profit or loss
Defined benefit fund adjustments (59) 20
Change in own credit risk recognised on financial liabilities designated at FVTPL (7) 11
Net change in fair value of equity financial investments measured at FVOCI 19 9
Other (6) 8
Total OCI tax (charge)/credit (274) 57
1 Included in this amount is a current tax credit recognised through OCI of R3 million current tax charge (2022: R0 million current tax charge).
Tax rate reconciliation
2023
%
2022
%
Direct taxation – statutory rate 27.0 28.0
Prior year tax (0.2) (0.2)
Direct taxation – current year 26.8 27.8
Capital gains tax 1.5 (0.2)
Foreign tax and withholding tax 3.8 3.7
Change in tax rate 0.3
Direct taxation – current year – normal 32.1 31.6
Permanent differences (7.9) (8.5)
Non-taxable income – capital profit (0.2)
Dividends received (3.1) (3.3)
Other non-taxable income – interest1 (4.5) (5.7)
Assessed loss not subject to deferred tax2 (0.8) (0.7)
Non-deductible expenses 1.5 2.2
Effects of profits taxed in different jurisdictions (1.0) (0.8)
Direct effective tax rate3 24.2 23.1
1 Relates to interest income earned from certain governments in Africa Regions which is exempt from tax.
2 The group's assessed losses of R1 929 million (2022: R1 211 million) resulted in recognised deferred tax asset of R521 million (2022: R339 million).
3 Expressed as a percentage of profit before direct taxation.
170 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 136 of 278 --
43. Earnings per ordinary share
The calculations of basic earnings per ordinary share and diluted earnings per ordinary share are as follows:
Number of units
2023
(’000)
20221
(’000)
Earnings attributable to ordinary shareholders (Rm) 44 211 34 243
Weighted average number of ordinary shares in issue
Weighted average number of ordinary shares in issue before adjustments 1 676 549 1 667 815
Adjusted for deemed treasury shares held by entities within the group2 (18 576) (16 802)
Weighted average number of ordinary shares in issue 1 657 973 1 651 013
Basic earnings per ordinary share (cents) 2 666.6 2 074.1
Diluted earnings per ordinary share
Weighted average number of ordinary shares in issue 1 657 973 1 651 013
Potential dilution from share incentive schemes 19 888 12 070
Standard Bank GSIS3 36
Standard Bank EGS4 511 770
Deferred Bonus Scheme 9 854 5 734
Performance Reward Plan 7 096 4 674
Share Appreciation Rights Scheme 439 856
Hybrid share appreciation rights scheme 1 988
Diluted weighted average number of ordinary shares in issue 1 677 860 1 663 083
Diluted earnings per ordinary share (cents) 2 635.0 2 059.0
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
2 The number of shares held by entities within the group are deemed to be treasury shares for IFRS purposes.
3 Zero (2022: 98 250) share options were outstanding at the end of the year in terms of the GSIS.
4 1 587 409 (2022: 2 594 941) rights outstanding at the end of the year in terms of the Standard Bank EGS. These units are convertible into 243 898
(2022: 295 194) ordinary shares at year end.
Dilutive impact of shares issued during the year
Deferred Bonus Scheme
10 243 715 (2022: 10 197 939) units were issued during the year to employees domiciled in South Africa. The dilutive impact of
these units are included in the calculation of diluted earnings per ordinary share.
At the end of the reporting period the group had 12 640 294 (2022: 12 650 450) units hedged, which results in no dilutive
shares being issued by the group, during the current and prior reporting period, and is included in the above dilutive earnings
per ordinary share.
Performance Reward Plan
3 785 840 (2022: 5 479 703) units were issued during the year to employees domiciled in South Africa. The dilutive impact of
these units are included in the calculation of diluted earnings per ordinary share.
At the end of the reporting period 3 520 022 (2022: 2 830 641) units were hedged, which results in nil (2022: nil) dilutive
shares being issued by the group and is included in the above dilutive earnings per ordinary share.
Share Appreciation Rights Scheme
1 271 387 (2022: 1 822 128) rights were issued during the year in terms of the Standard Bank SARP to employees domiciled
in South Africa. The outstanding SARP units are convertible into 1 169 525 (2022: 777 840) ordinary shares. The dilutive
impact of these units are included in the calculation of diluted earnings per ordinary share.
Refer to annexure D for further details on the group’s
share incentive schemes.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 171
-- 137 of 278 --
44. Headline earnings
Gross
Rm
Direct tax
Rm
Attributable
to NCI and
other1
Rm
Profit
attributable
to ordinary
shareholders
Rm
2023
Profit for the year 66 368 (16 065) (6 092) 44 211
Headline adjustable items added (1 487) 217 7 (1 263)
IAS 16 – Gain on sale of property and equipment (25) 6 7 (12)
IAS 16 – Compensation from third parties for assets that were
impaired4 (23) 6 (17)
IAS 27/IAS 28 – Gain on disposal of business (38) 8 (30)
IAS 28/IAS 36 – Impairment of associate 62 (17) 45
IAS 40 – Fair value gain on investment property2 (1 482) 218 (1 264)
IFRS 5 – Remeasurement of disposal group assets held for sale 19 (4) 15
Standard Bank Group headline earnings 64 881 (15 848) (6 085) 42 948
2022 - restated3
Profit for the year 50 757 (11 717) (4 797) 34 243
Headline adjustable items added (328) (67) 5 (390)
IAS 16 – Gain on sale of property and equipment (39) 9 5 (25)
IAS 16 – Compensation from third parties for assets that were
impaired4 (79) 22 (57)
IAS 16/IAS 36 – Impairment of property and equipment 18 (4) 14
IAS 27/IAS 28 – Loss on disposal of business 50 (15) 35
IAS 28/IAS 36 – Impairment of associate 74 (21) 53
IAS 36 – Impairment of intangible assets 386 (108) 278
IAS 40 – Fair value gain on investment property2 (708) 42 (666)
IFRS 5 – Reversal of remeasurement of disposal group assets held
for sale (30) 8 (22)
Standard Bank Group headline earnings 50 429 (11 784) (4 792) 33 853
1 Non-controlling interests and other equity instrument holders.
2 The fair value gain on investment property relates to USD denominated properties within Stanbic Bank Zimbabwe (SBZ) as well as the deterioration of
the Zimbabwe RTGS dollar to the USD (see annexure A for further detail on the SBZ functional currency).
3 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
4 During 2023, compensation of R22 million, gross of tax, was received from third parties for assets that were written off as a result of the floods that
occurred in KwaZulu-Natal in 2022. During 2022, R79 million, gross of tax, was received from third parties for ATMs that were previously written off as a
result of the unrest that occurred in KwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng.
2023
Cents
2022
Restated1
Cents
Headline earnings per ordinary share 2 590.4 2 050.4
Diluted headline earnings per ordinary share 2 559.7 2 035.6
1 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
Headline earnings is calculated in accordance with the circular titled Headline Earnings issued by SAICA, as amended from
time to time.
172 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 138 of 278 --
45. Dividends
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Ordinary shares 23 161 17 217
Final
691 cents per share declared on 09 March 2023 (2022: 511 cents per share declared on
11 March 2022) 11 598 8 574
Interim
690 cents per share declared on 17 August 2023 (2022: 515 cents per share declared on
4 August 2022) 11 563 8 643
Second preference shares 418 302
Final
367.700 cents per share declared on 9 March 2023 (2022: 273.982 cents per share declared
on 11 March 2022) 195 146
Interim
422.604 cents per share declared on 17 August 2023 (2022: 294.552 cents per share
declared on 4 August 2022 ) 223 156
AT1 capital 1 344 697
31 December
SBT 103 45 38
SBT 104 36 30
SBT 105 41 35
SBT 106 39 32
SBT 109 77 28
SBT 110 53
31 October
SBT 107 35 26
SBT 108 45 32
30 September
SBT 102 33
SBT 103 45 33
SBT 104 37 27
SBT 105 42 30
SBT 106 39 28
SBT109 78
SBT 110 72
28 July
SBT 107 33 23
SBT108 42
30 June
SBT 102 32
SBT 103 44 30
SBT 104 35 24
SBT 105 40 28
SBT 106 37 26
SBT 109 74
30 April
SBT107 32
SBT108 39
31 March
SBT 101 30
SBT 102 30
SBT 103 41 29
SBT 104 33 23
SBT 105 38 26
SBT 106 35 24
SBT109 71
31 January
SBT107 29
SBT108 37
Total dividends 24 923 18 216
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 173
-- 139 of 278 --
45. Dividends continued
Final gross cash dividend No. 108 of 733 cents per share declared on 14 March 2024 (2022: 691 cents per share) payable
on Monday, 15 April 2024 to all shareholders registered on Friday, 12 April 2024.
6.5% first cumulative preference shares dividend No. 109 of 3.25 cents per share (2022: 3.25 cents) payable on
Monday, 8 April 2024 to all shareholders registered on Friday, 5 April 2024.
Non-redeemable, non-cumulative, non-participating preference shares dividend No. 39 of 456.09315 cents per share
(2022: 367.70035 cents), payable on Monday, 8 April 2024 to all shareholders registered on
Friday, 5 April 2024.
The AT1 capital bonds have coupon rates of three-month JIBAR plus 565 basis points (SBT 101), JIBAR plus 545 basis points
(SBT 102), JIBAR plus 440 basis points (SBT 103), JIBAR plus 452 basis points (SBT 104), JIBAR plus 423 basis points
(SBT105), JIBAR plus 391 basis points (SBT 106), JIBAR plus 379 basis points (SBT 107), JIBAR plus 370 basis points
(SBT 108). JIBAR plus 350 basis points (SBT 109) and JIBAR plus 338 basis points (SBT110).And JIBAR plus 290 basis points
(SBT111). Interest is payable quarterly. For more information on AT1 capital, refer to note 15.8.
46. Statement of cash flows notes
46.1 Increase in operating assets
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Net derivative assets (4 462) 7 191
Trading assets (5 564) (32 448)
Pledged assets (4 891) (3 263)
Financial investments1 (32 061) (30 364)
Receivables and other assets1 4 012 (13 157)
Loans and advances (158 950) (87 284)
Reinsurance contract assets1 (170) (4)
Investment property 533 (1 467)
Total (201 553) (160 796)
1 Restated. The above note has been disaggregated to align to the restated statement of financial position. An outflow of R2 281 previously included in
financial investments relating to financial liabilities under investment contracts has been disclosed separately, refer to note 46.2, and a R4 million
outflow relating to reinsurance assets previously included in receivables and other assets has been disclosed separately above.
46.2 Increase in operating liabilities
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Trading liabilities (9 758) 29 870
Provisions and other liabilities1 8 334 354
Deposits and debt funding 142 544 138 933
Financial liabilities under investment contracts1 (3 311) (2 281)
Total 137 809 166 876
1 Restated. The above note has been disaggregated to align to the restated statement of financial position. An outflow of R2 281 previously included in
financial investments, refer note 46.1, relating to financial liabilities under investment contracts has been disclosed separately.
46.3 Cash payments to suppliers and employees
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Cash flows to suppliers 82 561 111 275
Cash flows to employees 51 057 44 340
Total 133 618 155 615
174 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 140 of 278 --
46. Statement of cash flows notes continued
46.4 Reconciliation of subordinated debt
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Balance at the beginning of the year 31 744 30 430
Subordinated debt issued 5 639 3 425
Subordinated debt redeemed (5 900) (2 263)
Exchange movements 1 054 363
Decrease/(increase) in subordinated bonds issued to group companies (34) 34
Other movements (276) (245)
Balance at the end of the year (note 20) 32 227 31 744
46.5 Cash and cash equivalents
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Cash and balances with central banks (note 1) 137 787 114 483
On-demand gross loans and advances to banks (note 8) 52 593 77 481
Cash balances with banks within financial investments (note 6) 14 809 14 277
Balance at the end of the year 205 189 206 241
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 175
-- 141 of 278 --
47. Related party transactions
47.1 Key management personnel
Key management personnel include: the members of the SBG board of directors and prescribed officers active for 2023 and
2022. Non-executive directors are included in the definition of key management personnel as required by IFRS. Prescribed
officers are defined by the Companies Act. The definition of key management includes the close family members of key
management personnel and any entity over which key management exercises control or joint control. Close family members
are those family members who may be expected to influence, or be influenced by, that person in their dealings with SBG. They
may include the person’s domestic partner and children, the children of the person’s domestic partner, and dependants of the
person or the person’s domestic partner.
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Key management compensation
Salaries and other short-term benefits paid 214 180
Post-employment benefits 6 5
Value of share options, rights and units expensed 408 181
Total 628 366
Loans and advances1
Loans outstanding at the beginning of the year 20 14
Change in key management structures 1 (1)
Net change in loans during the year (8) 7
Loans outstanding at the end of the year 13 20
Interest income 1 1
Deposit and debt funding2
Deposits outstanding at the beginning of the year 232 165
Change in key management structures (19) 44
Net change in deposits during the year (44) 23
Deposits outstanding at the end of the year 169 232
Net interest income/(expense) 9 (5)
Investment products and third-party funds under management3
Balance at the beginning of the year 2 010 1 397
Change in key management structures (453) 568
Net change in investments during the year 557 45
Balance at the end of the year 2 114 2 010
Net investment return to key management personnel (55) (117)
Shares and share options held4
Shares beneficially owned (number) 1 764 501 1 978 872
Share options held (number) 4 231 108 2 649 208
1 Loans include mortgage loans, vehicle and asset finance and credit cards. All loans and advances in respect of loans granted to key management in the
current or prior year follow the normal ECL processes of the group and company. The mortgage loans and vehicle and asset finance are secured by the
underlying assets. All other loans are unsecured.
2 Deposits and debt funding include cheque, current and savings accounts.
3 Due to the similar nature of investment products and third-party funds under management, the two products have been aggregated into one table.
4 Aggregate details of SBG shares and share options held by key management personnel.
176 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 142 of 278 --
47. Related party transactions continued
47.2 Balances and transactions with ICBCS
Transactions with ICBCS are made in the ordinary course of business and on substantially the same terms, including interest
rates and collateral, as those prevailing at the time for comparable transactions with other third parties. These transactions
also did not involve more than the normal risk of collectability or present other unfavourable features. There were no
significant credit impairments related to balances and transactions with ICBCS. The following significant balances were
entered into between the group and ICBCS, an associate of the group:
Amounts included in the group’s statement of financial position
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Derivative assets 5 915 7 397
Receivables and other assets 26 23
Loans and advances 11 636 4 507
Derivative liabilities (6 333) (7 485)
Other liabilities (179) (136)
Deposits and debt funding1 (10 030) (2 793)
1 Restated. During 2023 it was noted that repurchase agreements of R2 567m was erroneously excluded from this balance in 2022. The restatement had
no impact on the group’s income statement or statement of financial position.
Significant transactions with ICBCS during the reporting period comprise primarily of non-interest revenue of R622 million
(2022: R367 million).
Services
The group entered into certain transitional service level arrangements with ICBCS in order to manage the orderly separation
of ICBCS from the group post the sale of 60% of Standard Bank Plc. In terms of these arrangements, services are delivered
and received from ICBCS for the account of each respective party. As at 31 December 2023, the expense recognised in
respect of these arrangements amounted to R320 million (2022: R219 million).
47.3 Balances and transactions with ICBC
The group has several business relationships with ICBC, a 19.4% shareholder of the group. Transactions with ICBC are made
in the ordinary course of business and on substantially the same terms, including interest rates and collateral, as those
prevailing at the time for comparable transactions with other third parties. These transactions also did not involve more than
the normal risk of collectability or present other unfavourable features. There were no significant credit impairments that
related to balances and transactions with ICBC. The following significant balances were entered into between the group and
ICBC, excluding those with ICBCS.
Amounts included in the group’s statement of financial position
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Loans and advances 6 556 1 795
Trading assets 136 44
Deposits and debt funding (4 201) (9 469)
Letters of credit
The group has off-balance sheet letters of credit exposure issued to ICBC as at 31 December 2023 of R4 447 million
(2022: R2 744 million).
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 177
-- 143 of 278 --
47. Related party transactions continued
47.4 Mutual funds
The group invests in various mutual funds that are managed by Liberty. Where the group has assessed that it has control
(as defined by IFRS) over these mutual funds, it accounts for these mutual funds as subsidiaries. Where the group has
assessed that it does not have control over these mutual funds, but has significant influence, it accounts for them as
associates. The following significant balances and transactions were entered into between the group and the mutual funds
which the group does not control:
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Deposits and debt funding (29 558) (42 372)
Interest expense (954) (1 150)
47.5 Post-employment benefit plans
Material balances with SBG and transactions between SBG and the group’s post-employment benefit plans are listed
below:
Amounts included in the group’s statement of financial position and income statement
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Financial investments held in bonds and money market 789 754
In addition to the above:
■ the group manages R13 464 million (2022: R11 402 million) of the post-employment benefit plans’ assets.
■ the post-employment benefit plans hold SBG ordinary shares to the value of R489 million (2022: R310 million).
Refer to annexure A for more details on subsidiaries and
annexure B for more details on associates and joint ventures.
48. Pensions and other post-employment benefits
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Amount recognised as receivables and other assets in the statement of financial position
(note 7) 1 628 1 400
Total 1 628 1 400
Amounts recognised as provisions and other liabilities in the statement of financial position
(note 18) 1 077 1 081
Total 1 077 1 081
The total amount recognised as an expense for the defined contribution plans operated by the group amounted to
R1 648 million (2022: R1 037 million).
For a summary of key estimates and judgements applied, refer to the key management assumptions section for further detail.
48.1 Retirement funds
The majority of members of the group’s defined benefit schemes reside in South Africa. The South African defined benefit
schemes are regulated by the Pension Funds Act 24 of 1956 (Pension Funds Act), as well as the Financial Services Board.
The fund is subject to a statutory financial review by actuaries at an interval of not more than three years. A full actuarial
valuation was performed at 31 December 2021 where, in the opinion of the actuary, the fund was considered to be financially
sound. The next actuarial valuation will be performed on 31 December 2024.
The majority of employees in South Africa who are not members of the Standard Bank Group Retirement Fund are members
of two other funds designed for their occupational groups. Employees in territories beyond South African jurisdiction are
members of either defined contribution or defined benefit plans governed by legislation in their respective countries.
Description of risks
Post-retirement obligation risk is the risk to the group’s comprehensive income that arises from the requirement to contribute
as an employer to an under-funded defined benefit plan. The group operates both defined contribution plans and defined
benefit plans, with the majority of its employees participating in defined contribution plans. The defined benefit pension and
healthcare schemes (note 48.2) for past and certain current employees, create post-retirement obligations. The group
mitigates these risks through independent asset managers and independent asset and liability management advisors for
material funds. Potential residual risks which may impact the group are managed within the group asset and liability
management process.
178 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 144 of 278 --
48. Pensions and other post-employment benefits continued
48.1 Retirement funds continued
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
The amounts recognised in the statement of financial position in respect
of the retirement funds are determined as follows
Present value of funded obligations (49 148) (43 942)
Fair value of plan assets 51 081 45 598
Surplus 1 933 1 656
Asset ceiling (305) (256)
Included in receivables and other assets in the statement of financial position (note 7) 1 628 1 400
Movement in the present value of funded obligations
Balance at the beginning of the year 43 942 45 375
Current service cost 1 501 1 416
Interest cost 4 971 4 395
Employee contributions 1 300 1 013
Actuarial losses/(gains) 545 (5 568)
Exchange movements 73 (18)
Benefits paid (3 184) (2 671)
Balance at the end of the year 49 148 43 942
Movement in the fair value of plan assets
Balance at the beginning of the year 45 598 46 988
Interest income 5 137 4 537
Contributions received 2 769 2 381
Net return on assets 674 (5 623)
Exchange movements 87 (14)
Benefits paid (3 184) (2 671)
Balance at the end of the year 51 081 45 598
Cash 921 805
Equities 20 282 18 574
Bonds 12 556 12 828
Property and other 17 322 13 391
Plan assets do not include property occupied by the group.
The group expects to pay R1 625 million in contributions to the Standard Bank retirement funds in 2024
(2023: R1 498 million).
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 179
-- 145 of 278 --
48. Pensions and other post-employment benefits continued
48.1 Retirement funds continued
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
The amounts recognised in profit or loss are determined as follows:
Current service cost 1 501 1 416
Net interest income (166) (142)
Included in staff costs 1 335 1 274
The expected long-term rate of return is based on the expected long-term returns on
equities, cash and bonds. The split between the individual asset categories is considered in
setting these assumptions. Adjustments were made to reflect the effect of expenses.
Components of statement of other OCI
Actuarial gain/(loss) under asset management 674 (5 623)
Actuarial (loss)/gain (545) 5 568
Loss from changes in demographic assumptions (1) (4)
(Loss)/gain from changes in financial assumptions (654) 5 464
Gain from changes in experience adjustments 110 108
Asset ceiling (49) (80)
Remeasurements recognised in OCI 80 (135)
Reconciliation of net defined benefit asset
Net defined benefit asset at the beginning of the year 1 400 1 437
Net expense recognised (1 335) (1 274)
Amounts recognised in OCI 80 (135)
Company contributions 1 469 1 368
Change in asset ceiling
Foreign exchange movements 14 4
Net defined benefit asset at the end of the year 1 628 1 400
Sensitivity analysis for post-retirement fund
Assumed inflation rates, discount rates and mortality improvements have a significant effect on the amounts recognised in
profit or loss. A one percentage point change in these would have the following effects on amounts recognised in 2023 and
2022:
2023 2022
1%
increase
Rm
1%
decrease
Rm
1%
increase
Rm
1%
decrease
Rm
Inflation rate
Effect on the defined benefit obligation 296 (239) 337 (275)
Discount rate
Effect on the defined benefit obligation (229) 288 (267) 288
10%
increase
10%
decrease
10%
increase
10%
decrease
Mortality improvements
Effect on the defined benefit obligation (41) 45 (47) 50
+ 1 year - 1 year + 1 year - 1 year
Mortality improvements
Effect on the defined benefit obligation (29) 28 (33) 31
180 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 146 of 278 --
48.2 Post-employment healthcare benefits
The group provides the following post-employment healthcare benefits to its employees. The largest portion of this liability
represents a South African post-employment healthcare benefit scheme that covers employees that retired before
1 March 2000. The liability is unfunded and is valued every year using the projected unit credit method. The latest full actuarial
valuation was performed at 31 December 2023. The next actuarial valuation is to be performed on 31 December 2024.
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
The amounts recognised in the statement of financial position in respect
of post-employment healthcare benefits are determined as follows
Present value of unfunded defined benefit obligations 1 077 1 081
Included in provisions and other liabilities in the statement of financial position (note
18) 1 077 1 081
Movement in the present value of defined benefit obligations
Balance at the beginning of the year 1 081 1 073
Net expense recognised 126 122
Benefits paid (94) (87)
Amounts recognised in OCI (39) (25)
Foreign exchange movements 3 (2)
Balance at the end of the year 1 077 1 081
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
The amounts recognised in profit or loss are determined as follows
Current service cost 7 8
Net interest cost 119 114
Included in staff costs 126 122
Components of statement of other comprehensive income
Actuarial gain arising from changes in financial assumptions (18) (25)
Actuarial gain arising from experience adjustments (21)
Remeasurements recognised in OCI (39) (25)
Assumed medical inflation rates have a significant effect on the amounts recognised in profit or loss. The aggregate current
service cost and interest cost is R126 million (2022: R122 million) and the defined benefit obligation is R1 077 million
(2022: R1 081 million). A one percentage point change in the medical inflation rate would have the following effects on the
amounts recognised:
2023 2022
Sensitivity analysis for post-employment medical aid fund
1%
increase
Rm
1%
decrease
Rm
1%
increase
Rm
1%
decrease
Rm
Effect on the aggregate of the current service cost and interest
cost 15 (13) 15 (13)
Effect on the defined benefit obligation 98 (83) 101 (83)
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 181
-- 147 of 278 --
49. Business unit reporting
49.1 Business units
SBG structure of business units
Our operating model is client led and structured
around our business units as follows:
182 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 183
During 2023, the group has made structural
changes to better serve its clients. Our operating
model is client led and structured around our
business units, previously referred to as
segments, namely: Personal & Private Banking
(PPB), Business & Commercial Banking (BCB),
Corporate & Investment Banking (CIB) and
Insurance & Asset Management (IAM). Central
and other will remain and house group hedging
activities, unallocated capital, liquidity earnings
and central costs.
PPB, BCB, CIB and Central and other together
form Banking. Banking together with IAM and
ICBCS, housing the group’s interest in ICBC
Standard Bank Plc, form Standard Bank Group.
Business unit reporting evolves to reflect
changes in reporting responsibility for individual
cost centres and divisions across the group.
The business unit results have been adjusted,
as noted, and comparative periods restated
accordingly.
As a result of these structural changes and the
completion of the group’s acquisition of the
remaining non-controlling ordinary shares in
Liberty Holdings Limited through a scheme of
arrangement during 2022, the group has
reviewed the annual financial statements and,
from 2023, reports all notes and related
disclosure on either an aggregated group level,
or at a group, Banking and/or IAM level, as
applicable, where these disclosures were
segmented between Standard Bank Activities
and investment management and life insurance
activities previously.
SBG
BUSINESS UNITS
The business units are responsible
for designing and executing
the client value proposition.
Business units own the client
relationship and create multi-
product client experiences
distributed through our client
engagement platforms.
Personal & Private Banking
The Personal & Private Banking (PPB) business unit offers
tailored and comprehensive banking and beyond financial
services solutions. We serve individual clients across Africa
ranging from wealth and investment, to private and personal
banking markets by enabling their daily lives throughout their life
journeys.
BANKING
Business & Commercial Banking
The Business & Commercial Banking (BCB) business unit
provides broad based client solutions for a wide spectrum of
small and medium-sized businesses as well as large commercial
enterprises. Our client coverage extends across a wide range of
industries, sectors and solutions that deliver the necessary
advisory, networking and sustainability support required by our
clients to enable their growth.
Corporate & Investment Banking
The Corporate & Investment Banking (CIB) business unit serves
large companies (multinational, regional and domestic),
governments, parastatals and institutional clients across Africa
and internationally. Our clients leverage our in-depth sector and
regional expertise, our specialist capabilities and our access to
global capital markets for advisory, transactional, risk
management and funding support.
Insurance & Asset Management*
The Insurance & Asset Management (IAM) business unit offers a
wide range of solutions to fulfil clients’ long and short-term
insurance, health, investment, and asset management needs,
through our advice-led distribution force, third-party distribution
channels as well as in partnership with the SBG banking sales
channels. Our clients, who range from individual customers to
corporate and institutional clients across Africa, can leverage our
extensive market leading range of propositions and services to
help build and protect their wealth and lifestyle.
BANKING
PPB BCB CIB
Home
services
Tailored home financing solutions for home buyers and
existing homeowners, across our retail market, including
related value added services.
Retail home
services
Vehicle and
asset finance
Comprehensive finance solutions in instalment credit, fleet
management and related services across our retail,
corporate and business markets.
Retail
VAF
Business
and commercial
Lending Comprehensive suite of lending products provided to
individuals and small and medium-sized businesses.
Personal
unsecured lending
Business
lending
Card and
payments
Credit card facilities to individuals and businesses.
Merchant acquiring services. Enablement of digital payment
capabilities through various products and platforms. Mobile
money and cross-border businesses.
Card
issuing
Card acquiring
and commercial
Transactional Comprehensive suite of cash management, international
trade finance, working capital and investor services
solutions.
PPB
transactional
banking
BCB
transactional
banking
CIB
transactional
banking
Global
markets
Trading and risk management solutions across financial
markets, including foreign exchange, money markets,
interest rates, equities, credit and commodities.
PPB
forex
BCB
forex
Institutional
and corporate
Investment
banking
Full suite of advisory and financing solutions, from term
lending to structured and specialised products across
equity and debt capital markets.
Investment
banking
CENTRAL AND OTHER
■ Banking hedging activities
■ Unallocated capital
■ Liquidity earnings
■ Central costs
INSURANCE & ASSET MANAGEMENT*
Insurance
Life and health insurance
Development, sourcing and management of
life and health (in Africa Regions only)
insurance and contractual savings
propositions distributed via advice-led, third
party and banking distribution channels.
Propositions include health insurance, long-
term insurance products such as life, critical
illness, disability, funeral cover, and various
insurance plans sold in conjunction with
related banking products.
Corporate benefits
Intermediated corporate benefits advice on
competitive employee benefits solutions
through our advice-led and third-party
distribution channels. The proposition
consists of investment and risk solutions
mainly through our umbrella offering as well
as consulting services.
Short-term insurance
Development and management of short-
term insurance solutions to protect against
loss or damage of assets. Propositions are
distributed by banking and brokerage
channels and include homeowners’
insurance, household contents, vehicle
insurance and commercial all risk insurance.
Asset management
Wealth management
Development and maintenance of local and offshore investment
propositions, primarily for high net worth and affluent clients,
accessed via tied adviser and third-party distribution channels.
Propositions include discretionary asset management, stockbroking,
investment platform and discretionary fund management services,
and traditional life company products.
Asset management
Development and maintenance of asset management propositions
for institutional and wholesale clients. Propositions include active,
passive, and private markets investment strategies via segregated
mandate, collective investment schemes, and pension fund
administration.
ICBCS
Equity investment held in terms of strategic partnership agreements with ICBC
■ ICBC Standard Bank Plc (40% associate). * Liberty previously reported separately has been fully integrated into Insurance & Asset Management.
-- 148 of 278 --
49. Business unit reporting continued
49.2 Business unit statement of financial position1
PPB BCB CIB Central and other Banking IAM SBG Franchise ICBCS Standard Bank Group2
2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Assets
Cash and balances with central banks 9 063 9 191 6 423 3 923 119 845 101 563 2 388 (240) 137 719 114 437 68 46 137 787 114 483 137 787 114 483
Trading assets 1 2 318 234 316 226 (2 875) (3 705) 315 360 312 523 1 155 2 395 316 515 314 918 316 515 314 918
Financial investments 45 930 43 067 35 774 33 649 216 115 214 561 14 713 20 168 312 532 311 445 446 244 411 049 758 776 722 494 758 776 722 494
Net loans and advances 661 773 651 027 205 408 209 692 782 641 675 164 (41 874) (33 305) 1 607 948 1 502 578 898 2 362 1 608 846 1 504 940 1 608 846 1 504 940
Loans and advances to banks 24 686 22 210 17 585 17 001 196 105 168 276 (37 786) (32 279) 200 590 175 208 1 888 2 353 202 478 177 561 202 478 177 561
Net loans and advances to customers 637 087 628 817 187 823 192 691 586 536 506 888 (4 088) (1 026) 1 407 358 1 327 370 (990) 9 1 406 368 1 327 379 1 406 368 1 327 379
Gross loans and advances to customers 678 492 664 371 199 275 203 490 597 515 516 211 (4 084) (1 021) 1 471 198 1 383 051 (990) 9 1 470 208 1 383 060 1 470 208 1 383 060
Home services 466 734 459 647 466 734 459 647 466 734 459 647 466 734 459 647
Vehicle and asset finance 71 039 67 003 55 715 52 856 126 754 119 859 126 754 119 859 126 754 119 859
Card and payments 35 978 35 142 2 956 2 921 38 934 38 063 38 934 38 063 38 934 38 063
Personal unsecured lending 104 741 102 579 104 741 102 579 104 741 102 579 104 741 102 579
Business lending 140 604 147 713 140 604 147 713 140 604 147 713 140 604 147 713
Corporate and sovereign lending 597 515 516 211 597 515 516 211 597 515 516 211 597 515 516 211
Centre and other (4 084) (1 021) (4 084) (1 021) (990) 9 (5 074) (1 012) (5 074) (1 012)
Credit impairments (41 405) (35 554) (11 452) (10 799) (10 979) (9 323) (4) (5) (63 840) (55 681) (63 840) (55 681) (63 840) (55 681)
Other assets 27 058 23 817 6 737 7 772 108 424 96 940 31 643 25 684 173 862 154 213 54 254 57 340 228 116 211 553 8 652 6 657 236 768 218 210 2
Reinsurance contract assets 1 631 1 830 1 631 1 830 1 631 1 830
Insurance contract assets 5 422 5 522 5 422 5 522 5 422 5 522
Total assets 743 825 727 104 254 342 255 036 1 545 259 1 404 454 3 995 8 602 2 547 421 2 395 196 509 672 480 544 3 057 093 2 875 740 8 652 6 657 3 065 745 2 882 397
Equity and liabilities
Equity 55 076 51 569 28 335 27 838 99 861 83 236 57 707 58 459 240 979 221 102 27 289 31 107 268 268 252 209 8 652 6 657 276 920 258 866
Liabilities 688 749 675 535 226 007 227 198 1 445 398 1 321 218 (53 712) (49 857) 2 306 442 2 174 094 482 383 449 437 2 788 825 2 623 531 2 788 825 2 623 531
Trading liabilities 95 976 109 886 (74) 145 95 902 110 031 (1 434) (103) 94 468 109 928 94 468 109 928
Deposits and debt funding 423 654 398 003 480 021 453 662 1 174 836 1 102 444 (52 993) (43 033) 2 025 518 1 911 076 (23 872) (21 977) 2 001 646 1 889 099 2 001 646 1 889 099
Deposits from banks 6 659 8 123 4 921 7 159 159 690 152 734 (43 159) (34 399) 128 111 133 617 479 509 128 590 134 126 128 590 134 126
Deposits and current accounts from
customers 416 995 389 880 475 100 446 503 1 015 146 949 710 (9 834) (8 634) 1 897 407 1 777 459 (24 351) (22 486) 1 873 056 1 754 973 1 873 056 1 754 973
Current accounts 79 489 79 343 143 250 135 388 140 949 145 288 (526) (2 833) 363 162 357 186 363 162 357 186 363 162 357 186
Cash management deposits 62 23 59 500 54 807 207 824 181 711 33 30 267 419 236 571 267 419 236 571 267 419 236 571
Call deposits 198 263 186 789 194 881 184 935 132 513 126 800 (2 527) (2 110) 523 130 496 414 (24 438) 498 692 496 414 498 692 496 414
Savings accounts 41 005 39 246 5 732 6 073 59 113 1 46 797 45 432 126 89 46 923 45 521 46 923 45 521
Term deposits 94 622 80 828 65 517 59 100 268 165 240 715 (1 652) 735 426 652 381 378 (11) (508) 426 641 380 870 426 641 380 870
Negotiable certificates of deposit 45 194 2 19 172 756 179 217 1 172 804 179 430 172 804 179 430 172 804 179 430
Other deposits 3 509 3 457 6 218 6 181 92 880 75 866 (5 164) (4 456) 97 443 81 048 (28) (22 067) 97 415 58 981 97 415 58 981
Other liabilities3 265 095 277 532 (254 014) (226 464) 174 586 108 888 (645) (6 969) 185 022 152 987 105 265 103 359 290 287 256 346 290 287 256 346
Financial liabilities under investment
contracts 151 035 136 309 151 035 136 309 151 035 136 309
Insurance contract liabilities 251 389 231 849 251 389 231 849 251 389 231 849
Total equity and liabilities 743 825 727 104 254 342 255 036 1 545 259 1 404 454 3 995 8 602 2 547 421 2 395 196 509 672 480 544 3 057 093 2 875 740 8 652 6 657 3 065 745 2 882 397
1 The business unit statement of financial position has been updated to better align to how management analyses and reviews business units.
The prior year comparative disclosures have also been restated in line with this change.
2 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
3 Other liabilities include inter-divisional funding which fluctuates in line with asset growth.
184 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 185
-- 149 of 278 --
49. Business unit reporting continued
49.3 Business unit income statement1
PPB BCB CIB Central and other Banking IAM SBG Franchise ICBCS Standard Bank Group2
2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022 2023 2022
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Net interest income 39 128 33 002 25 476 20 206 30 781 24 366 2 110 379 97 495 77 953 693 438 98 188 78 391 98 188 78 391
Non-interest revenue 17 985 15 501 12 604 12 025 32 777 29 000 (5 677) (5 923) 57 689 50 603 4 314 4 362 62 003 54 965 62 003 54 965
Net fee and commission revenue 13 512 11 905 8 987 8 780 8 585 7 816 (259) (508) 30 825 27 993 4 362 4 628 35 187 32 621 35 187 32 621
Trading revenue 481 (147) 239 37 20 598 17 957 (786) (801) 20 532 17 046 85 20 617 17 046 20 617 17 046
Other revenue 648 618 686 595 1 085 1 045 (1 178) (1 252) 1 241 1 006 2 223 1 855 3 464 2 861 3 464 2 861
Other gains and losses on financial instruments 222 250 2 509 2 182 (3) 3 2 728 2 435 7 2 2 735 2 437 2 735 2 437
Inter-BU attribution 3 344 3 125 2 470 2 363 (3 451) (3 365) 2 363 2 123 (2 363) (2 123)
Foreign exchange attribution 1 025 1 049 2 426 2 316 (3 451) (3 365)
Insurance attribution 2 319 2 076 44 47 2 363 2 123 (2 363) (2 123)
Net income from Insurance & Asset
Management 17 425 14 761 17 425 14 761 17 425 14 761
Total net income 57 113 48 503 38 080 32 231 63 558 53 366 (3 567) (5 544) 155 184 128 556 22 432 19 561 177 616 148 117 177 616 148 117
Credit impairment charges (11 128) (8 824) (3 454) (2 450) (1 662) (2 530) (18) 492 (16 262) (13 312) 1 (32) (16 261) (13 344) (16 261) (13 344)
Net income before operating expenses 45 985 39 679 34 626 29 781 61 896 50 836 (3 585) (5 052) 138 922 115 244 22 433 19 529 161 355 134 773 161 355 134 773
Operating expenses (30 663) (27 361) (21 362) (18 741) (28 974) (24 927) 1 277 1 733 (79 722) (69 296) (15 027) (14 236) (94 749) (83 532) (94 749) (83 532)
Staff costs (15 584) (13 701) (7 331) (6 080) (12 485) (10 359) (10 676) (9 135) (46 076) (39 275) (46 076) (39 275) (46 076) (39 275)
Amortisation and depreciation (4 630) (4 664) (548) (433) (552) (571) (1 128) (1 174) (6 858) (6 842) (6 858) (6 842) (6 858) (6 842)
Other (10 449) (8 996) (13 483) (12 228) (15 937) (13 997) 13 081 12 042 (26 788) (23 179) (26 788) (23 179) (26 788) (23 179)
Operating expenses from insurance and asset
management (15 027) (14 236) (15 027) (14 236) (15 027) (14 236)
Inter-BU attribution expense (3 451) (3 365) 3 451 3 365
Net income before capital items and equity
accounted earnings 15 322 12 318 13 264 11 040 29 471 22 544 1 143 46 59 200 45 948 7 406 5 293 66 606 51 241 66 606 51 241
Non-trading and capital related items 492 128 464 165 540 143 24 20 1 520 456 (33) (128) 1 487 328 1 487 328
Share of post-tax profit from associates and
joint ventures 343 328 (1) (31) (33) (14) 29 33 338 316 24 32 362 348 1 286 1 917 1 648 2 265
Profit before indirect taxation 16 157 12 774 13 727 11 174 29 978 22 673 1 196 99 61 058 46 720 7 397 5 197 68 455 51 917 1 286 1 917 69 741 53 834
Indirect taxation (1 342) (1 123) (323) (231) (680) (746) (619) (588) (2 964) (2 688) (409) (389) (3 373) (3 077) (3 373) (3 077)
Profit before direct taxation 14 815 11 651 13 404 10 943 29 298 21 927 577 (489) 58 094 44 032 6 988 4 808 65 082 48 840 1 286 1 917 66 368 50 757
Direct taxation (3 034) (2 737) (3 233) (2 899) (5 785) (3 782) (667) (498) (12 719) (9 916) (3 346) (1 801) (16 065) (11 717) (16 065) (11 717)
Profit for the period 11 781 8 914 10 171 8 044 23 513 18 145 (90) (987) 45 375 34 116 3 642 3 007 49 017 37 123 1 286 1 917 50 303 39 040
Attributable to preference shareholders (419) (302) (419) (302) (419) (302) (419) (302)
Attributable to additional tier 1 capital
noteholders (335) (223) (138) (88) (578) (344) (291) (40) (1 342) (695) (1) (2) (1 343) (697) (1 343) (697)
Attributable to non-controlling interests (308) (67) (301) (444) (2 697) (2 457) (170) (52) (3 476) (3 020) (854) (778) (4 330) (3 798) (4 330) (3 798)
Attributable to ordinary shareholders 11 138 8 624 9 732 7 512 20 238 15 344 (970) (1 381) 40 138 30 099 2 787 2 227 42 925 32 326 1 286 1 917 44 211 34 243
Headline adjustable items (417) (150) (398) (152) (458) (151) (23) (30) (1 296) (483) 33 93 (1 263) (390) (1 263) (390)
Headline earnings 10 721 8 474 9 334 7 360 19 780 15 193 (993) (1 411) 38 842 29 616 2 820 2 320 41 662 31 936 1 286 1 917 42 948 33 853
1 The business unit income statement has been updated to better align to how management analyses and reviews business units.
The prior year comparative disclosures have also been restated in line with this change.
This update had no impact on the group’s income statement.
2 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for further details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
186 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 187
-- 150 of 278 --
49. Business unit reporting continued
49.4 Geographic information
South
Africa
Rm
Africa
Regions and
International1
Rm
Eliminations2
Rm
Standard
Bank Group
Rm
2023
Total net income3 103 771 73 985 (140) 177 616
Banking 84 712 70 612 (140) 155 184
IAM 19 059 3 373 22 432
Total headline earnings 19 703 23 259 (14) 42 948
Banking 17 507 21 349 (14) 38 842
ICBCS 1 286 1 286
IAM 2 196 624 2 820
Total assets 2 465 229 877 019 (276 503) 3 065 745
Banking 1 960 803 863 112 (276 494) 2 547 421
ICBCS 8 652 8 652
IAM 504 426 5 255 (9) 509 672
2022
Total net income3 92 613 56 227 (723) 148 117
Banking 76 354 52 924 (722) 128 556
IAM 16 259 3 303 (1) 19 561
Total headline earnings 19 205 14 667 (19) 33 853
Banking 17 506 12 129 (19) 29 616
ICBCS 1 917 1 917
IAM 1 699 621 2 320
Total assets 2 325 540 785 092 (228 235) 2 882 397
Banking 1 851 544 771 885 (228 233) 2 395 196
ICBCS 6 657 6 657
IAM 473 996 6 550 (2) 480 544
1 African Regions and International have been aggregated to better reflect how the chief operating decision makers analyse the segment. The
comparatives have also been updated for this aggregation.
2 Eliminations include intersegmental transactions and balances and also includes central funding and other.
3 Total net income is attributable based on where the operations are located.
188 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 151 of 278 --
50. Interest rate benchmarks and reference interest rate reform
The Financial Stability Board had initiated a fundamental review and reform of the major interest rate benchmarks used
globally by financial market participants. This review seeks to replace existing interbank offered rates (IBORs) with alternative
risk-free rates (ARRs) to improve market efficiency and mitigate systemic risk across financial markets.
During the 2021 financial year, the LIBOR’s administrator, the Intercontinental Exchange Benchmark Administration Limited,
announced it would no longer publish EUR, CHF, JPY and GBP related LIBOR rates for all tenors after 31 December 2021. The
ICE Benchmark Administration Limited (IBA) had adopted a two-stage approach for the cession of the USD LIBOR rates with
the one-week and two-month USD LIBOR rates no longer being published after 31 December 2021 and the remaining being
the overnight, one-month, three-month, six-month and 12-month rates no longer being published after 30 June 2023. The
LIBOR rates which the group was exposed to have predominantly been replaced by Secured Overnight Financing Rate
(SOFR), Sterling Overnight Index Average (SONIA), Euro Short Term Rate (ESTR), Tokyo Overnight Average (TONA) and
Swiss Average Rate Overnight (SARON). In certain instances, other suitable rates are used such as Central Bank Policy Rates.
During the 2022 financial year, the SARB indicated its intention to move away from JIBAR and has identified a successor in
the South African Rand Overnight Index Average Rate (ZARONIA). The new ZARONIA rate was published for observation
during 2022 and was endorsed as a successor rate in 2023. The formal announcement of the cessation of JIBAR as a
reference rate is expected in 2025, allowing ZARONIA market to develop in derivative and cash products during 2023 and
2024. The cessation date of JIBAR as a reference rate is expected to be after 2025.
There are minimal IBOR-linked contracts remaining with transition having taken place predominantly in Q2 and Q3. Synthetic
USD LIBOR is being published for a limited period, to assist the market with tough legacy transactions to be transitioned. Use
of synthetic LIBOR is limited across the group with a focus on transitioning client transactions to the target alternative
reference rates.
Given the materiality reduced exposure to IBORs (mainly USD, EUR and GBP) where cessation has taken place, focus will
shift to the ZAR JIBAR - ZARONIA transition.
The steering committee tracks updates and best market practice recommendations emanating from official sector working
groups established to catalyse transition in relevant jurisdictions.
Communications to clients are ongoing via multiple platforms along with one-on-one engagements to discuss transition where
exposed to USD LIBOR rates that mature post-cessation date.
Reference rate reform introduces a number of risks to the group including, but not limited to:
■ Model risk – risk of the valuation models used within the group not being able to cater for the changes in the intended
manner.
■ Legal risk – risk of being non-compliant to the agreements previously agreed with clients.
■ Operational risk – risk of the group’s systems not being able to accommodate for the changes to the interest rates as
agreed with the clients.
■ Financial risk – risk of not appropriately pricing the deals which will result in a transfer of value between the group and
clients.
■ Compliance/regulatory risk – risk that the bank is exposed to regulatory sanctions due to failing to meet the regulatory
expectations in relation to the transition.
■ Reputational risk – the risk to the bank’s reputation from failing to adequately prepare for the transition.
■ Conduct risk – risk that arises when transitioning existing contracts linked to IBORs as value-transfer may occur, or clients
may be transitioned to inferior rates or on unfair contractual terms, or in circumstances where they do not fully appreciate
the impact of the transition or the alternatives available to them.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 189
-- 152 of 278 --
50. Interest rate benchmarks and reference interest rate reform continued
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS IMPACTED BY THE REFORM WHICH ARE YET TO TRANSITION
2023 2022
USD LIBOR
Rm
USD LIBOR
Rm
Total assets subject to IBOR reform 2 447 173 685 —
Derivative assets1 121 454
Financial investments 17 2 491
Loans and advances2 2 426 39 639
Trading assets 4 10 101
Total liabilities subject to IBOR reform 448 (237 249) —
Derivative liabilities1 (213 770)
Deposits and debt funding (23 816)
Subordinated debt3 448 361
Trading liabilities (24)
Total off balance sheet exposures subject to IBOR reform (2 993) —
Off-balance sheet items (2 993)
1 These balances represent the notional amount directly impacted by the IBOR reform. Where the derivatives have both pay and receive legs with
exposure to the benchmark reform such as cross-currency swaps, the notional amount is disclosed for both legs.
2 Gross carrying amount excluding allowances for ECL.
3 Subordinated debt was erroneously excluded from the prior year disclosure. This has been included for 2023 and comparatives have been restated
accordingly. The restatement had no impact on the group’s income statement or the group’s statement of financial position
190 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Notes to the financial statements continued
-- 153 of 278 --
STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION
as at 31 December 2023
Company
Note
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Assets
Financial investments 51 25 28
Interest in subsidiaries 52 128 847 123 805
Interest in associates 53 10 351 8 335
Deferred tax asset 3 2
Total assets 139 226 132 170
Equity and liabilities
Equity 112 658 106 910
Share capital and premium 15 27 106 27 509
Equity attributable to other equity instrument holders 15 24 167 19 667
Reserves 61 385 59 734
Liabilities 26 568 25 260
Other liabilities1 83 103
Current tax liabilities1 1
Indebtedness by the company to group subsidiaries 52 395 385
Subordinated debt1 54 26 089 24 772
Total equity and liabilities 139 226 132 170
1 During 2023, company reassessed the order of liquidity within the statement of financial position and moved other liabilities and current tax liabilities to above the
indebtedness by the company to group subsidiaries line on the face of the statement of financial position as these items were found to be more liquid than those that
follow them in the above presentation. This had no impact on the associated amounts within these line items. The reorder has also been applied to the prior year and
notes where the line items are listed.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 191
Standard Bank Group Limited –
Company annual financial statements
-- 154 of 278 --
Company
Note
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Interest income 2 365 1 734
Interest expense (2 265) (1 694)
Other (losses)/gains 55 (214) 36
Dividends from subsidiaries 24 853 19 872
Total net income1 24 739 19 948
Operating expenses (31) (81)
Net income before impairments of investment 24 708 19 867
Reversal of impairment of associate 53 84
Reversal of impairment of subsidiaries 52 248
Impairment of subsidiaries 52 (28) (754)
Net income before share of profits from associate 24 928 19 197
Share of profits from associates 53 1 632 2 249
Profit before direct taxation 26 560 21 446
Direct taxation 56 (695) (420)
Profit for the year 25 865 21 026
Other comprehensive income after tax for the year 709 589
Items that may not be reclassified to profit or loss2 100 100
Net change in FVOCI on financial assets 51, 53 9 (27)
Share of associates cash flow hedge adjustment 53 91 127
Items that may be reclassified to profit or loss2 609 489
Exchange differences on translating foreign associate operations 53 609 489
Total comprehensive income 26 574 21 615
Attributable to the ordinary shareholders 24 812 20 617
Attributable to other equity instrument holders 1 762 998
1 Previously referred to as total income. Updated to reflect the nature of the sub total being a net amount.
2 Other comprehensive income has been disaggregated to include the total of items that may and may not be reclassified to profit or loss to better align the nature of the
balances as well as the presentation requirements of IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements. The prior year comparative disclosures have also been disaggregated in
line with this change. This disaggregation had no impact on the statement of comprehensive income.
192 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Standard Bank Group Limited – Company annual financial statements continued
STATEMENT OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME
for the year ended 31 December 2023
-- 155 of 278 --
Company
Note
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Net cash flows from operating activities 23 440 19 482
Interest, fee and commission receipts1 2 306 1 730
Interest payments (2 205) (1 694)
Recoveries on loans previously written off 57
Cash payments to suppliers and employees 57 (31) (86)
Net movement in working capital (20) 83
Decrease in operating assets 57 35
(Decrease)/increase in operating liabilities 57 (20) 48
Dividends received 24 028 19 872
Direct taxation paid (695) (423)
Net cash flows used in investing activities (3 253) (6 579)
Increase in investment in subsidiaries 57 (3 578) (6 904)
Distributions from investments in associates 53 325 325
Net cash flows used in financing activities (20 187) (12 903)
Proceeds from issue of share capital 40 58
Repurchase of share capital (443)
Issuance of other equity instruments 15 4 500 7 159
Redemption of other equity instruments (3 544)
Issuance of subordinated debt 54 5 639 1 639
Redemption of subordinated debt (5 000)
Dividends paid (24 923) (18 215)
Net increase in cash and cash equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents at the beginning of the year
Cash and cash equivalents at the end of the year
1 The description of this line item has been updated to better align to the nature of the balances. The prior year comparative disclosures have also been updated in line
with this change. This change had no impact on the statement of cash flows.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 193
STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS
for the year ended 31 December 2023
-- 156 of 278 --
COMPANY Note
Share
capital and
premium
Rm
Revaluation
reserve
Rm
Cash flow
hedging
reserve
Rm
Foreign
currency
translation
reserve
Rm
Fair value
through OCI
reserve
Rm
Retained
earnings
Rm
Ordinary
share-
holders’
equity
Rm
Other
equity
instrument
holders
Rm
Total
Rm
Balance at 1 January 2022 18 021 3 100 969 50 (54) 52 269 74 355 16 052 90 407
Issue of share capital and share premium and other equity instruments 15 9 488 9 488 3 615 13 103
Total comprehensive income 489 (27) 20 155 20 617 998 21 615
Other comprehensive income1 489 (27) 127 589 589
Profit for the year 20 028 20 028 998 21 026
Dividends paid (17 217) (17 217) (998) (18 215)
Balance at 31 December 2022 27 509 3 100 969 539 (81) 55 207 87 243 19 667 106 910
Balance at 1 January 2023 27 509 3 100 969 539 (81) 55 207 87 243 19 667 106 910
Issue of share capital and share premium and other equity instruments 15 40 40 4 500 4 540
Repurchase of share capital and share premium and other equity instruments 15 (443) (443) (443)
Total comprehensive income 609 9 24 194 24 812 1 762 26 574
Other comprehensive income1 609 9 91 709 709
Profit for the year 24 103 24 103 1 762 25 865
Dividends paid (23 161) (23 161) (1 762) (24 923)
Balance at 31 December 2023 27 106 3 100 969 1 148 (72) 56 240 88 491 24 167 112 658
1 Movements in other comprehensive income relate to the movement in the reserves of ICBCS at 40%.
194 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Standard Bank Group Limited – Company annual financial statements continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 195
STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN EQUITY
FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2023
-- 157 of 278 --
51. Financial investments
Company
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Financial investments held in banking – unlisted equities 25 28
Financial investment measured at FVOCI closing balance
Opening balance 35
Net change in FVOCI (1)
Sale of investment (34)
Financial investment measured at fair value through profit or loss closing balance 25 28
Opening balance 28 28
Fair value adjustments (3)
Financial investments comprise of Business Partners Limited measured at FVTPL. The investment is classified as level 3 in
the fair value hierarchy.
52. Interest in subsidiaries
Company
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Shares at cost1 101 165 96 345
Indebtedness to the company (annexure A) 27 682 27 460
Total before indebtedness by the company 128 847 123 805
Indebtedness by the company (annexure A) (395) (385)
Total 128 452 123 420
1 Investment through equity-settled share incentives has been aggregated into shares at cost to better align the nature of the balances. The prior year
comparative disclosures have also been aggregated in line with this change. This aggregation had no impact on the statement of financial position.
Principal subsidiaries and the related investments and indebtedness are listed in annexure A.
Indebtedness to the company are all current assets and not impaired and have been classified as loans and advances which
are measured on an amortised cost basis. These lending exposure are to entities that forms part of the group’s risk
management framework as such the ECL has been assessed to be insignificant. This is on the basis that the group has
governance and oversight of the risk inherent in these entities and ensures that entities operate within the group’s risk
appetite as approved by the group risk and capital management committee (GRCMC). Changes in the indebtedness during
the year include repayments, new loans, interest accruals and exchange rate differences.
Indebtedness by the company are all liabilities repayable on demand and are measured at amortised cost. The carrying value
approximates fair value and is classified as level 3 in the fair value hierarchy. Changes in the indebtedness during the year
include repayments.
The company’s investments in subsidiaries (measured at cost) are reviewed annually for impairment with reference to
impairment indicators that include the following:
■ Dividends declared by subsidiaries in excess of the subsidiaries’ total comprehensive income earned in the reporting
period.
■ The carrying value of the investment exceeds the subsidiary’s net asset value of the subsidiary, including any associated
goodwill.
When impairment indicators exist the recoverable amount of the company’s investment in the subsidiary is determined as the
higher of the value in use and fair value less costs of disposal. An impairment loss is recognised in profit or loss if the carrying
value exceeds the recoverable amount. A reversal of an impairment loss is recognised in profit or loss if the recoverable
amount has subsequently been determined to be higher than the carrying value.
During 2023, the company’s investments in subsidiaries recoverable value was determined to be higher than its carrying
amount and as a result a net impairment reversal to a total amount of R220 million was recognised. Details of the impairment
and impairment reversal are detailed below. Through the performance of the impairment test, the following investments have
been identified for either impairment reversals or impairments:
■ A previous impairment loss of R248 million on Standard Bank Group International (SBGI) was reversed, mainly due to an
increase in operational factors that impacted its performance;
■ An impairment loss of R28 million on other investments was recognised.
For each of the entities listed above, the net asset value approximates its fair value less costs of disposal. The recoverable
amount for each entity has therefore been determined as its fair value less costs of disposal.
196 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Standard Bank Group Limited – Company annual financial statements continued
-- 158 of 278 --
53. Interest in associates
Company
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Carrying value at the beginning of the year 8 335 5 736
Share of OCI movements 9 (25)
Share of cash flow hedge adjustment 91 127
Share of profit 1 632 2 249
Dividend received (325) (325)
Reversal of impairment on associate 84
Currency translation 609 489
Carrying value at the end of the year 10 351 8 335
The company’s investments in associates include South African Home Loans (Proprietary) Limited (SAHL) and ICBCS.
Refer to annexure B for further detail.
54. Subordinated debt
Nominal
value1
Million
Carrying value1
Company Redeemable/payable date First callable date
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
SBT201 13 February 2028 13 February 2023 ZAR3 000 3 038
SBT202 3 December 2028 3 December 2023 ZAR1 516 1 527
SBT203 3 December 2028 3 December 2023 ZAR484 488
SBT204 16 April 2029 16 April 2024 ZAR1 000 1 023 1 019
SBT205 31 May 2029 31 May 2024 USD400 7 445 6 824
SBT206 31 January 2030 31 January 2025 ZAR2 000 2 036 2 030
SBT207 25 June 2030 25 June 2025 ZAR3 500 3 506 3 504
SBT208 28 November 2030 28 November 2025 ZAR 1 500 1 515 1 514
SBT209 29 June 2031 29 June 2026 ZAR1 722 1 723 1 723
SBT210 18 October 2033 18 October 2028 ZAR3 639 3 717
SST201 8 December 2031 8 December 2026 ZAR1 444 1 454 1 453
SST202 31 August 2032 31 August 2027 ZAR1 639 1 654 1 652
SST203 03 March 2033 03 March 2028 ZAR2 000 2 016
Total 26 089 24 772
1 The difference between the carrying amount and nominal value represents accrued interest.
For the group, these subordinated bonds are hedged items classified as fair value hedges, interest rate swaps are the
derivatives designated as the hedging instruments for these hedge relationships. However, for the company these bonds do
not qualify for hedge accounting as the company does not hold derivative instruments.
Subordinated debt is measured on an amortised cost basis and is classified as level 2 in the fair value hierarchy, with a fair
value of R27.1 billion (2022: R24.4 billion).
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 197
-- 159 of 278 --
54. Subordinated debt continued
54.1 Maturity analysis
2023 2022
Within one
year1
Within one
to five
years1 Total
Within one
year1
Within one
to five
years1 Total
Company Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
Subordinated debt – discounted 8 468 17 621 26 089 5 053 19 719 24 772
Subordinated debt – undiscounted 10 475 20 956 31 431 6 766 22 339 29 105
1 The maturity analysis for subordinated debt has been determined as the earlier of the contractual repayment date or the option by the issuer to redeem
the debt.
55. Other (losses)/gains
Company 2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Foreign exchange movements (275) 33
Other 61 3
Total (214) 36
56. Direct taxation
Company
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Current year
South African normal tax 534 305
Deferred tax charge (1)
Foreign and withholding taxes 162 115
Total direct taxation recognised in statement of comprehensive income 695 420
South African tax rate reconciliation (%)
Direct tax – statutory rate 27.0 28.0
Direct tax – current year 27.0 28.0
Withholding tax 0.6 0.5
Direct tax – current year – normal 27.6 28.5
Permanent differences (25.0) (26.5)
Impairment/(reversal of impairment) of investments (0.2) 0.9
Non-deductible cost 0.5 0.2
Non-taxable income (0.2)
Dividends received (23.4) (24.7)
Equity accounted earnings (1.7) (2.9)
Direct effective tax rate1 2.6 2.0
1 Expressed as a percentage of profit before direct tax. On 23 February 2022, the South African finance minister, as part of his National Budget Speech,
confirmed that the corporate income tax rate will be reduced from 28% to 27% for financial years ending on or after 31 March 2023. The new rate was
therefore applied to deferred tax in 2022 and to current tax in 2023.
198 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Standard Bank Group Limited – Company annual financial statements continued
-- 160 of 278 --
57. Statement of cash flow notes
57.1 Decrease in operating assets
Company
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Financial investments 35
57.2 (Decrease)/increase in operating liabilities
Company
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Other liabilities (20) 48
57.3 Cash payments to suppliers and employees
Company
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Operating expenses (31) (86)
57.4 Increase in investment in subsidiaries
Company
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Increase in investment in subsidiaries (4 601) (5 627)
Movement in indebtedness 1 023 (1 277)
Total (3 578) (6 904)
57.5 Reconciliation of subordinated debt
Company
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Balance at the beginning of the year 24 772 22 641
Subordinated debt issued 5 639 1 639
Subordinated debt redeemed (5 000)
Foreign exchange movement 618 435
Interest accrued 60 57
Balance at the end of the year 26 089 24 772
58. Liquidity, credit and market risk information
Other assets and liabilities consist mainly of non-financial assets and liabilities which are not subject to liquidity, credit and
market risk. The company is exposed to interest rate risk and liquidity risk on subordinated debt. For more detail on the
group's approach to risk management, which also applies to the company, refer to annexure C.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 199
-- 161 of 278 --
The Standard Bank of
South Africa1
Melville Douglas
Investment Management1
Stanbic Africa
Holdings (UK)
Standard Bank Group
International (Isle of Man) ........
Standard Bank
Offshore Group (Jersey)3
Liberty
Holdings1 (100%)1
| | | | |
Diners Club (S.A.)1 Standard Insurance1 Stanbic Bank (Botswana) Stanbic International Insurance
(Isle of Man)
Standard Bank Offshore Trust
Company Jersey Liberty Group1
|
Standard Bank Insurance
Brokers1 Standard Trust1 Stanbic Bank Ghana (99.54%) Standard Finance (Isle of Man) Standard Bank Isle of Man ■ Liberty Two Degrees1, 4
Standard Offshore Finance
Company (Isle of Man) Stanvest1 Standard Holdings
Côte d’Ivoire S.A. (99%)
Standard Bank Trust Company
(Mauritius)
Liberty Kenya Holdings
(73.47%)
|
SBG Securities1 ■ Stanbic Bank S.A.
(Côte d’Ivoire) (99%) Standard Bank Jersey STANLIB1
|
Standard Bank Properties1 Stanbic Uganda Holdings (80%) ■ STANLIB Asset
Management1
■ STANLIB Collective
Investments1
■ STANLIB Fund Managers
Jersey
■ STANLIB Wealth
Management1
|
Standard Lesotho Bank (80%) ■ Stanbic Bank Uganda
(99.99%)
SBN Holdings
(74.90%)
Stanbic Bank Tanzania
(99.99%)
|
Standard Bank Namibia
(99.96%) Stanbic Bank Zambia (99.99%)
Standard Bank Eswatini
(72.22%)
Stanbic Holdings (Kenya)
(74.92%) The diagram above depicts principal subsidiaries only.
A full list of the group’s subsidiaries and consolidated structured entities is available at the company’s registered office.
The holding in subsidiaries is 100% unless otherwise indicated.
|
Standard Bank de Angola, S.A.
(51%) ■ Stanbic Bank Kenya
Standard Advisory (China) Stanbic IBTC Holdings
(Nigeria) (67.55%)
|
Standard Advisory London
(UK)
■ Stanbic IBTC Bank (Nigeria)
(99.99%)
■ Stanbic IBTC Insurance
Brokers (75%)2
Standard New York (US) ■ Stanbic IBTC Pension
Managers (82.24%)
Stanbic Bank Zimbabwe
1 Incorporated in South Africa.
2 Stanbic IBTC Holdings PLC holds 75% and the chief executive of Stanbic IBTC Insurance Brokers Limited holds 25%. It should be noted that 25% of
the shareholding must be held by the chief executive officer of an insurance brokerage business to fulfil Nigerian regulatory requirements; however,
this shareholding is held by the chief executive officer in a nominee capacity not in a personal capacity. Accordingly, the total beneficial shareholding
of Stanbic IBTC Insurance Brokers in relation to Stanbic IBTC Holdings PLC remains at 100%.
3 Standard Bank Offshore Group Limited is owned by Standard Bank Group International Limited (5%) and SBG Limited (95%).
4 The buyout of Liberty Two Degrees minority shareholders was completed in November 2023 and the entity was delisted from the JSE.
Standard Bank RDC S.A. (DRC)
(99.99%)
Standard Bank (Malawi)
(60.18%)
Standard Bank (Mauritius)
1 Refer to footnotes on the following page.
Standard Bank S.A.
(Mozambique) (98.15%)
200 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 201
ANNEXURE A – SUBSIDIARIES, CONSOLIDATED
AND UNCONSOLIDATED STRUCTURED ENTITIES
-- 162 of 278 --
Nominal
issued
share capital
Rm
Effective holding2 Non-controlling interests Book value of shares5 Net indebtedness
Nature of operation
2023
%
2022
%
2023
%
2022
%
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Banking subsidiaries
Stanbic Bank (Botswana) Limited (Botswana)1# Commercial bank 420 100 100
Stanbic Bank Ghana Limited (Ghana)1# Commercial bank 630 99 99 1 1
Stanbic Bank Kenya Limited (Kenya)1# Commercial bank 423 75 75 25 25
Stanbic Bank S.A. (Côte d’Ivoire)1# Commercial bank 974 99 99 1 1
Stanbic Bank Tanzania Limited (Tanzania)1,3# Commercial bank 50 100 100
Stanbic Bank Zambia Limited (Zambia)1,3# Commercial bank 660 100 100
Stanbic Bank Zimbabwe Limited (Zimbabwe)#* Commercial bank 2 100 100 136 136
Stanbic Bank Uganda Limited (Uganda)1# Commercial bank 227 80 80 20 20
Stanbic IBTC Bank Limited (Nigeria)1# Commercial bank 331 68 68 32 32
Standard Bank de Angola S.A (Angola)# Commercial bank 768 51 51 49 49 359 359 409 50
Standard Bank Isle of Man Limited (Isle of Man)1# Commercial bank 25 100 100
Standard Bank Jersey Limited (Jersey)1# Commercial bank 454 100 100
Standard Bank PLC (Malawi)1,4# Commercial bank 23 60 60 40 40
Standard Bank (Mauritius) Limited (Mauritius)1# Commercial bank 342 100 100
Standard Bank Namibia Limited (Namibia)1,5# Commercial bank 2 75 75 25 25
Standard Bank RDC S.A. (DRC)1,3# Commercial bank 944 100 100
Standard Bank S.A. (Mozambique)1# Commercial bank 309 98 98 2 2
Standard Bank Eswatini Limited (Eswatini)# Commercial bank 15 72 72 28 28 94 94
Standard Lesotho Bank Limited (Lesotho)# Commercial bank 21 80 80 20 20 13 13
The Standard Bank of South Africa Limited (SBSA)#5 Commercial bank 60 100 100 68 701 64 200 26 119 26 708
Total banking subsidiaries 69 303 64 802 26 528 26 758
Refer to footnotes on the following page.
* Refer to the further details on subsidiaries section within annexure A for further detail.
202 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure A – Subsidiaries, consolidated and unconsolidated structured entities continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 203
-- 163 of 278 --
Nominal share
capital issued
Rm
Effective holding Non-controlling interests Book value of shares Net indebtedness
Nature of operation
2023
%
2022
%
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Non-banking subsidiaries
Ecentric Payment Systems Proprietary Limited1 Development and marketing
transactions – switching
software and services
54 54 46 46
Liberty Group Limited1 Insurance company 29 100 100 —
Liberty Holdings Limited Insurance holding company 24 100 100 — 19 085 19 085
Liberty Two Degrees Limited1 Real Estate Investment trust 100 58 — 42
Melville Douglas Investment Management Proprietary Limited# Asset and portfolio management 100 100 — 53 53
SBG Securities Proprietary Limited# Stockbroker 100 100 — 323 323
SBN Holdings Limited (Namibia)4 Bank holding company 1 75 75 25 25 348 348
Stanbic Africa Holdings Limited (UK) Investment holding company 1 494 100 100 — 10 572 10 572 92 33
Stanbic Holdings Ghana Limited (Ghana) Investment holding company 182 100 100 —
Stanbic Holdings PLC (Kenya)1,4 Bank holding company 232 75 75 25 25
Stanbic IBTC Holdings PLC (Nigeria)1,4 Bank holding company 331 68 68 32 32
Stanbic Uganda Holdings Limited (Uganda)1,4 Bank holding company 227 80 80 20 20
Standard Advisory (China) Limited (China) Trading company 8 100 100 — 10 10
Standard Advisory London Limited (UK) Arranging and advisory company 1 100 100 — 557 557
Standard Bank Group International Limited (Isle of Man) Investment holding company 100 100 — 555 308 418
Standard Bank Offshore Group Limited (Jersey)2 Investment holding company 17 100 100 — 49 49
Standard Bank Offshore Trust Company Jersey Limited (Jersey)1# Trust company 6 100 100 —
Standard Bank Trust Company (Mauritius) Limited (Mauritius)1# Trust company 100 100 —
Standard Holdings Angola S.A. Investment holding company 39 100 — 39
SML Limited (Isle of Man) Investment holding company 73 100 100 — 47 47
Standard Insurance Limited Short-term insurance 15 100 100 — 30 30
Standard New York, Inc (US) Securities broker/dealer 55 100 100 — 55 55
Standard Trust Limited# Trust company 100 100 — 100
STANLIB Limited1 Wealth and asset management 100 100 —
Miscellaneous Finance companies 39 106 249 284
Total non-banking subsidiaries 31 862 31 543 759 317
Total 101 165 96 345 27 287 27 075
1 Held indirectly, no book value in Standard Bank Group Limited.
2 Effective holding company, comprises direct and indirect holdings.
3 Minorities or nominee shareholders hold 0.5% or less.
4 Listed on a stock exchange.
5 Investment through equity-settled share incentive has been aggregated into book value of SBSA Limited shares to better align the nature of the balances. The prior
year comparative disclosures have also been aggregated in line with this change.This aggregation had no impact on the statement of financial position.
# Standard Bank Group Limited will ensure that the capital adequacy of its subsidiaries denoted by # will meet the requirements of home and host regulators, as
required by section 70(A) of the South African Banks Act.
204 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure A – Subsidiaries, consolidated and unconsolidated structured entities continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 205
-- 164 of 278 --
Further detail on subsidiaries
Overview
The nominal share capital issued of foreign subsidiaries has been stated in the preceding tables at their rand equivalents at the rates of
exchange ruling on the dates of the provision of capital.
The country of incorporation of subsidiaries is South Africa, unless otherwise indicated.
While a full list of the group’s subsidiaries and consolidated structured entities (SE’s) is available at the company’s registered office,
these disclosures include subsidiaries for which either of the following is present:
■ SBGL has provided a capital adequacy statement (denoted by #).
■ There is a non-controlling interest. Refer to page 202 for further detail on the change in holding.
■ There is a net book value as recorded in Standard Bank Group Limited’s financial statements.
■ There is net indebtedness to/from Standard Bank Group Limited.
No significant restrictions exist on the transfer of funds and capital within the group, subject to compliance with the corporate laws of
relevant jurisdictions and appropriate motivation to, and approval by, exchange control authorities.
Foreign currency translation
Rates in the table below are key rates used in calculation of the group’s foreign currency translation reserve (FCTR) when converting to
the group reporting currency. The main contributors of currency depreciation include Nigeria, Zimbabwe, Angola, Zambia, Kenya, and
Malawi, which were offset by currency appreciation within the group GBP and USD entities as well as Mozambique and Uganda. The
group's FCTR decreased further by approximately R4.7 billion post the reporting date due to further currency depreciation in Nigeria and
Zimbabwe. This is considered a non-adjusting event in terms of IAS 10 Events after the Reporting Period.
In certain countries in which the group operates there are dual exchange rates. In most countries the difference between these dual
exchange rates is insignificant.
In assessing which is the most appropriate exchange rate to translate foreign exchange balances and the net investment the following
individual facts and circumstances have been considered:
■ The group’s legal ability to convert currency or to settle transactions using a specific rate.
■ Its intention to use a particular foreign currency exchange, including whether the rate available through that exchange is published or
readily determinable.
■ Whether the supply of the reporting entity’s currency is available and sufficient to cover the amount outstanding for immediate
delivery.
KEY EXCHANGE RATES USED WHEN TRANSLATING THE GROUP’S FOREIGN OPERATIONS
Average Closing
Change
% 2023 2022
Change
% 2023 2022
USD/ZAR 13 18.451 16.300 9 18.520 16.970
GBP/ZAR 14 22.950 20.190 15 23.529 20.420
AOA/ZAR (35) 0.022 0.034 (33) 0.022 0.033
GHS/ZAR (1) 1.553 1.568 (7) 1.552 1.673
KES/ZAR (14) 0.120 0.140 (13) 0.119 0.137
MZN/ZAR 8 0.292 0.271 9 0.290 0.266
MWK/ZAR (35) 0.011 0.017 (35) 0.011 0.017
NGN/ZAR (42) 0.022 0.038 (43) 0.021 0.037
UGX/ZAR — 0.005 0.005 — 0.005 0.005
ZMW/ZAR (24) 0.749 0.982 (23) 0.722 0.942
ZWL/ZAR (88) 0.003 0.026 (88) 0.003 0.025
The direct method of exchange rates have been disclosed to better analyse the conversion of FCTR.
Banking subsidiaries
Stanbic Bank Zimbabwe (SBZ) functional currency
The change in functional currency from USD to ZWL was effective from 1 October 2018. During the 2018 reporting period, the only
exchange mechanism that SBZ had access to was ZWL, which was also the only official exchange mechanism. This led to SBZ
concluding that the appropriate exchange rate to use at the date of the change in functional currency and after the change in functional
currency up until the end of the 2018 reporting period was the official rate of 1:1.
The Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) implemented certain key monetary policy measures during February 2019. The most significant
change was the establishment of a new forex interbank market and this interbank market will complement the existing official foreign
exchange mechanism with the RBZ. The establishment of this interbank market has created an additional legal exchange mechanism
whereby SBZ is able to trade RTGS dollars (official currency). The starting rate of trade in this interbank market was 2.5 RTGS:USD.
The forex interbank market was replaced by the forex auction trading system from 23 June 2020. As at 31 December 2023, the rate
deteriorated to 6 104.72 RTGS:USD from 684.33 RTGS:USD as at 31 December 2022, which resulted in an FCTR loss of R2.1 billion
(2022: R2.6 billion) for the group, after the hyperinflation adjustment translation adjustment per IAS 21 The Effects of Changes in Foreign
Exchange Rates (IAS 21).
206 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure A – Subsidiaries, consolidated and unconsolidated structured entities continued
-- 165 of 278 --
During 2023, the Zimbabwe year-on-year monthly inflation rate moved from 244% to 381% at the end of December 2023. Therefore,
SBZ remains a group entity operating in a hyperinflationary economy and the results for SBZ continue to be adjusted in accordance with
Financial Reporting in Hyperinflationary Economies (IAS 29). The adjustment is based on conversion factors derived from statistical
information published by Zimbabwe National Statistics Agency (ZIMSTAT) such the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and the total poverty
datum line. Some estimation and interpolation was required to derive these factors as ZIMSTAT is publishing a CPI that blends price
information from two currencies, as opposed to standalone CPIs per currency.
The conversions factors used were as follows:
CPI Index
Conversion
Factor
December 2023 65 703.44 1.000
Average 2023 37 050.09 1.773
December 2022 13 672.91 4.805
This resulted in the group’s profit attributable to ordinary shareholders for the year ended 31 December 2023 decreasing by R912 million
(2022: R617 million).The rebasing impact of the opening balances resulted in an increase in retained earnings of R641 billion
(2022: R1.2 billion). The consumer price index at the beginning of the reporting period was 13 673% (2022: 3 977%) and closed at
65 703% (2022: 13 673%).
Insurance & Asset Management
Completion of the group’s acquisition of the remaining non-controlling ordinary shares in
Liberty Holdings Limited through a scheme of arrangement
During 2022, the scheme to acquire the remaining non-controlling ordinary shares (the ordinary share scheme) was not unconditional
at 31 December 2021 as certain scheme conditions, including some requisite regulatory approvals, remained outstanding at
31 December 2021. All of the scheme conditions were fulfilled and became unconditional on 7 February 2022, 100% consolidated from
1 February 2022, the ordinary share scheme was implemented on 28 February 2022 and the Liberty ordinary shares were delisted from
the JSE on 1 March 2022.
The ordinary share scheme participants received a special distribution of R11.10 per Liberty ordinary share and a scheme consideration
for each Liberty ordinary share comprising half an SBK ordinary share (subject to the JSE’s rounding principles) plus an ordinary share
scheme cash consideration of R14.40.
The group accounts for its controlling shareholding in Liberty as an investment in subsidiary, which is measured at cost in Standard Bank
Group Limited’s separate financial statements in terms of IAS 27 Separate Financial Statements (IAS 27). The share issue by the group
under the ordinary share scheme was recognised as an increase in the group’s share capital and share premium. Upon acquiring the
remaining Liberty shares not already owned by the group, the group’s investment in Liberty increased and this increased investment is
measured at the cost of acquisition in the separate financial statements of Standard Bank Group Limited. The group continues to
consolidate Liberty’s results, however, as of 7 February 2022 the total Liberty earnings would be attributable to the group’s ordinary
shareholders instead of attributing a portion of Liberty earnings to the acquired Liberty non-controlling shareholders. Since the
transaction is between group entities, common control accounting principles were applied. The transaction resulted in the premium
above the acquired net asset value attributable to the acquired non-controlling shareholders being recognised directly in retained
earnings.
THE FINANCIAL IMPACT AS A RESULT OF THE ACQUISITION RELATING TO THE ORDINARY SHARE
SCHEME IS AS FOLLOWS:
2022
Rm
Transaction price 12 387
Additional shares issued (note 15) 9 430
Special dividend1 1 287
Cash consideration 1 670
Net asset value attributable to non-controlling shareholders at date of sale1,2 (7 957)
Decrease in retained earnings 4 430
1 The net asset value attributable to non-controlling shareholders at the date of sale, net of the special dividend, resulted in a total movement of R6.6 billion in the group’s
statement of changes in equity.
2 Restated. The net asset value attributable to non-controlling shareholders increased by R53 million as a result of IFRS 17.
Buy-out of non-controlling interests in Liberty Two Degrees Limited
On 27 July 2023, Liberty Group Limited (LGL) and Liberty Two Degrees Limited (L2D) announced Liberty's intention to buyout the non-
controlling shareholders in L2D, in terms of a scheme of arrangements and subsequently delisting of L2D from the JSE. All scheme
conditions were met, with the required approvals in place which finalised the acquisition of L2D non-controlling units by LGL at R5.55 per
unit and resulted in the termination of the listing of L2D units on the JSE on 14 November 2023. It is anticipated that a process to sell the
share of properties currently owned by L2D, to LGL, will commence in early 2024.
Effective 14 November 2023, LGL acquired the remaining non-controlling interest in L2D. A cash consideration of R1 896 million was
paid for the share of the net asset value of R2 525 million, resulting in an increase in ordinary shareholder net asset value on purchase of
R629 million. As a consequence of the transaction, deferred tax of R130 million (refer note 14) was recognised, reflecting a net increase
in ordinary shareholder net asset value of R487 million. This acquisition was accounted for as a transaction between owners.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 207
-- 166 of 278 --
Consolidated structured entities
Banking
Name of the entity Nature of the operations
Amount of support
provided as at1,2,3 Type of support4
Terms of contractual arrangements that require the group to
provide financial support to the SE
Events/circumstances that could expose the group to a loss as
a result of the contractual arrangement
2023
Rm
2022
Rm 2023 2022
Blue Granite Investments
No.2 (RF) Proprietary
Limited (BG2)
Facilitates mortgage backed
securitisations. The group is
the primary liquidity facility
provider to BG2.
28 28 Subordinated
loan
Subordinated
loan
The loans did not have a fixed term or repayment date. The
first loss subordinated loan incurred interest at a rate of prime
plus 5% while the second loss loan incurred interest at a rate of
prime less 1.5% per annum and was only payable when BG2
had sufficient cash reserves.
Should BG 2's customers be unable to meet their contractual
obligations under the mortgage loan agreement and the loans
are classified as non-performing.
Blue Granite Investments
No.3 (RF) Proprietary
Limited (BG3)
Facilitates mortgage backed
securitisations. The group is
the primary liquidity facility
provider to BG3.
58 58 Subordinated
loan
Subordinated
loan
The loan does not have a fixed term or repayment date. The
loan incurs interest at a rate of prime plus 5% per annum and is
only payable when BG3 has sufficient cash reserves.
Should BG 3's customers be unable to meet their contractual
obligations under the mortgage loan agreement and the loans
are classified as non-performing.
Rapvest Investments Proprietary
Limited
Facilitates finance deals for
other group companies and
third parties through
preference share investments
and loans to clients.
693 2 128 Loan Loan The loan is repayable on demand and no interest is
charged on the loan.
In the event that the underlying assets are classified as non-
performing loans.
DAF Financial Services (RF)
Proprietary Limited (DFS)
This SPV facilitates vendor
financing for SMEs.
132 195 Loan Loan The loans bear interest at a rate of prime plus 1%. The maturity
date of the loan is 30 November 2026.
SBSA is exposed to the first-loss risk in the structure as well as
potential losses that may be incurred on the receivables as a
result of residual asset value risk. The residual asset value risk
is, however, limited due to a put option that is in place.
Main Street 367 Proprietary
Limited (Mainstreet)
Facilitates funding to BG2, BG3
and Siyakha. SB Debtors (a
subsidiary of Standard Bank
Group) provides the funding to
Mainstreet to originate the
loans.
340 248 Subordinated
loan
Subordinated
loan
The loan is only repayable to the extent that Mainstreet
receives payment from BG2 and BG3. The interest is charged
at the higher of JIBAR plus 10% and the cash available in terms
of Mainstreet's priority of payments less R15000.
In the event that customers of BG2 and BG3 are unable to
meet their contractual obligations under the mortgage loan
agreement and their loans are classified as non-performing.
Energy Fund Silo (RF) The Energy Fund Silo was set
up in 2023 and invests in
energy loans. SBSA and
Liberty are the main funders.
3 008 Noteholder The tenor of the note will be 1 year and will pay interest of
JIBAR plus 2.2% margin.
In the event that one of the underlying loans defaults.
The following entities have been excluded from the above disclosure as no support has been provided during 2023 or 2022: Blue Banner Securitisation Vehicle RC1 Pty Ltd,
Blue Shield Investments 01 (RF) Ltd, Blue Shield Investments 02 (RF) Ltd, Blue Titanium Conduit Ltd, and Siyakha Fund (RF) Pty Ltd.
See the footnotes below the consolidated structured entities of IAM on the next page.
208 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure A – Subsidiaries, consolidated and unconsolidated structured entities continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 209
-- 167 of 278 --
Consolidated structured entities continued
Insurance & Asset Management
Name of the entity Nature of the operations
Amount of support
provided as at1,2,3 Type of support4
Terms of contractual arrangements that require the group to provide financial
support to the SE
Events/circumstances that could expose the group
to a loss as a result of the contractual arrangement
2023
Rm
2022
Rm 2023 2022
Passives Funding (RF)
Proprietary Limited
Acquire or invest in credit assets, derivative
instruments, preference share instruments,
participatory interests in collective investment
schemes and listed equity instruments and the
related security with regard to such credit
assets, derivative instruments, preference share
instruments and listed equity instruments with
funds raised directly or indirectly through the
issue of notes.
(259) 1 817 Equity-linked
notes (ELN)
and Equity
derivatives
Equity-linked
notes (ELN)
and Equity
derivatives
As at 31 December 2023, R94.07 million (2022: R1.82 billion) of ELNs had been
issued to Liberty Group Limited (LGL). LGL also owns R1.39 billion (2022:
R1.75 billion) preference shares in Passives Funding. LGL provided a R1.5
billion liquidity facility to Passives Funding. Passives Funding will pay interest
to LGL on drawn down amounts calculated on a market related basis as the
SAFEX overnight deposit rate +1,65%. A commitment fee is calculated at 0,4%
per annum of the amount of the available facility. The commitment fees due to
LGL in 2023 was R7 million (2022: R7 million).
Exposure to contingent credit risk of the underlying
assets held in Passives Funding (RF).
1 389 1 752 Preference
share
investment
Preference
share
investment
339 Collateral
deposits and
interest rate
derivatives
Collateral
deposit and
interest rate
derivatives
LibFin Note Issuer 1
(RF) Proprietary
Limited
Acquire or invest in credit assets, derivative
instruments, preference share instruments,
participatory interests in collective investment
schemes and listed equity instruments and the
related security with regard to such credit
assets, derivative instruments, preference
share instruments and listed equity
instruments with funds raised directly or
indirectly through the issue of notes.
Equity-linked
notes (ELN)
Equity-linked
notes (ELN)
As at 31 December 2023, Rnil billion (2022: Rnil billion) of ELNs had been
issued to LGL. LGL also owns R1.34 billion (2022: R1.5 billion) preference
shares in LibFin Note Issuer 1. Liberty Group Limited has provided a R1.5 billion
liquidity facility to LibFin Note Issuer 1. LibFin Note Issuer 1 will pay interest to
LGL on drawn down amounts calculated at the SAFEX overnight deposit rate
+1,65%. A commitment fee is calculated at 0,4% per annum of the amount of
the available facility. The commitment fee due to LGL in 2023 was R6.9 million
(2022: R6.9 million).
Exposure to contingent credit risk of the underlying
assets held in LibFin Issuer 1 (RF).
1 341 1 147 Preference
share
investment
Preference
share
investment
1 189 Collateral
deposit and
interest rate
derivatives
Collateral
deposit and
interest rate
derivatives
Vineyard Road
Investments (RF)
Limited
Vineyard Road Investments (RF) Ltd was
incorporated in South Africa and the principal
activity of the company is to issue notes and
other debt instruments to acquire the rights, title
and interests in any assets. The company may
enter into guarantees in relation to the
obligations of the borrowers and or issuers. The
company may directly or indirectly grant
security for its obligations to investors in respect
of the notes and or debt instruments issued by it
and enter into derivative contracts to manage
risks and hedge exposures.
115 103 Preference
share
investment
Preference
share
investment
LGL owns R105 million (2022: R100 million) in preference shares in Vineyard
Road. Liberty Group Limited has provided a liquidity facility to which the total
amount of the facility is the nominal value of the notes issued by Vineyard
Road and is governed by internal credit risk limits. As 31 December 2023, this
amount was R2.9 billion (2022: R2.9 billion). Vineyard Road will pay interest to
LGL on drawn down amounts calculated at the SAFEX overnight deposit rate
+1,60%. A commitment fee is calculated at 0,4% per annum of the amount of
the available facility. The commitment fee due to LGL in 2023 was R13.1 million
(2022: R12.7 million).
Exposure to contingent credit risk of the underlying
assets held in Vineyard Road.
Blue Diamond
Investments No.3 (RF)
Limited(BD3)
The company is engaged in and mandated to
issue debt instruments to investors. The credit-
linked notes is a replicating portfolio comprising
of a Standard Bank bond and a credit default
swap on Transnet.
174 173 Credit-linked
notes
Credit- linked
notes
The group holds the notes issued by BD3. The group settles BD3's operating
expenses as and when necessary, typically in the event that BD3 has liquidity
constraints. Any payment for such amounts is to be refunded by BD3 to the
group.
In the event of a credit event, the group will suffer a
loss.
1 The amount of support provided includes loans and advances and drawn down credit facilities provided to SEs by the group.
2 During the reporting period, the group did not provide any financial or other support to any subsidiary without having a contractual obligation to do so.
3 This is the amount as reported on the balance sheet as at 31 December 2023 and 2022, respectively.
4 In addition to the financial support provided to the SEs, the group enters into other transactions with SEs in the ordinary course of business. These transactions include loans
and advances, deposits and current accounts and derivatives.
The following represents Insurance & Asset Management’s interest in consolidated structured entities, classified into products.
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Unlisted preference shares 2 835 3 002
Listed term deposits 207 173
Unlisted term deposits 62 1 817
Interest rate derivative liability (382) (990)
Collateral deposits receivable 379 1 156
Total 3 101 5 158
210 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure A – Subsidiaries, consolidated and unconsolidated structured entities continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 211
-- 168 of 278 --
Unconsolidated structured entities
The group has an interest in the following unconsolidated structured entities:
Banking
Name of the entity Nature and purpose of entity
Principal nature
of funding
Principal nature
of assets Terms of contractual arrangements
Events/circumstances that
could expose the group
to a loss
Types of income received by
the group
Blue Diamond Investments
No.1 (RF) Ltd (BD1)
This structure has been designed to
provide third-party investors indirect
exposure to corporate names. The
group obtains credit protection from
BD1 in the form of issuing credit-linked
notes on single or multiple corporate
names. BD1 then obtains credit
protection from third-party investors
by issuing notes to third-party
investors on single or multiple
corporate names.
Credit-linked notes
issued to third-party
investors.
Credit-linked notes
issued by the group
Six years The group settles BD1’s
operating expenses as and
when necessary, typically in
the event that BD1 has liquidity
constraints. Any payment for
such amounts is to be
refunded by BD1 to the group.
In the event of a credit event,
the third-party investors will
suffer a loss. The group is only
exposed to the risk of loss
should it be unable to recover
any unexpected operating
expenses from BD1.
Once-off fee and commission
income earned for structuring
the SE.
Blue Diamond X Investments
(RF) Limited
Loans purchased from SBSA and the
issuance of notes to third-party
investors.
Commercial paper
issued to third-party
investors.
Loans and advances to
various counterparties
Seventeen years SBSA acts as the administrator
and identifies and invests in
suitable financial assets and
facilitates the execution and
settlement of trades.
None Administration fee and upfront
fees for originating the assets.
1nvest ETF Issuer (RF)
Limited1 offering the
following:
• 1nvestPalladium ETF
(JSE code: ETFPLD)
• 1nvestPlatinum ETF
(JSE code: ETFPLT)
• 1nvestGold ETF
(JSE code: ETFGLD)
• 1nvestRhodium ETF
(JSE code: ETFRHO)
The palladium, platinum, gold and
rhodium exchange traded funds (ETFs)
have been established for investors to
participate in changes in the spot price
of underlying commodities. The ETFs
issue debentures to investors with each
debenture backed by the respective
physical commodity. On issuance each
debenture is based on 1/100th of a troy
ounce of the respective commodity. The
physical commodities are stored at
recognised custodian storage vaults in
London. The ETFs are denominated in
rands and are classified as domestic
assets. The ETFs are regulated by the
Financial Markets Act (2012) and the
JSE Listings Requirements.
The unconsolidated
structured entity is
funded by the issue of
non-interest bearing
debentures that are 100%
backed by the underlying
physical commodity.
Physical commodities
(palladium, platinum, gold
and rhodium)
Undated The group established these
structured entities to
accommodate client
requirements to hold
investments in specific
commodity assets. The group
manages the ETFs and also
provides liquidity to the ETFs by
acting as a committed market
maker.
The maximum exposure to loss
is limited to the on-balance
sheet position held by the group
through acting as a committed
market maker for the ETFs. This
exposes the group to the
commodity price risk associated
with the underlying commodity
and is managed in accordance
with the group’s market risk
management policy.
The group earns fees net of
related expenses for managing
the ETFs. These fees are
recognised within non-interest
revenue. Interest income is
recognised on any funding
provided to the SEs. Any trading
revenue, as a result of
transactions with the SEs is
recognised in trading revenue.
1 1nvest ETF Issuer (RF) Ltd was reported as Africa ETF Ltd in prior years.
The following represents the group’s interests in unconsolidated structured entities
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Statement of financial position
Unconsolidated structured entities
Trading assets 54 47
Financial Investments 751
Deposits and debt funding accounts from customers (5 883) (5 745)
Total (5 078) (5 698)
212 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure A – Subsidiaries, consolidated and unconsolidated structured entities continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 213
-- 169 of 278 --
Unconsolidated structured entities continued
Insurance & Asset Management
Calibre Mortgage Fund
Proprietary Limited*
Special purpose vehicle (SPV) set up by
South African Home Loans (Pty) Limited
(SAHL) into which it originates home
loans.
The SPV is funded by debt provided by
Liberty and equity provided by SAHL.
Senior, secured loan SPV set up by SAHL as a
funding vehicle into which
Liberty can lend on a
secured basis, with the
equity provided by SAHL.
Liberty Group Limited (LGL) as debt provider 2 849 2 820 280 209
Merchant West Asset
Rentals
Merchant West provides asset – based
financing to corporates and individuals.
Equipment based securitisation vehicle.
Listed, rated, asset-backed
note
Raising funding in the
securitisation market to
fund vehicles.
Debt funders in the securitisation market 250 255 25 17
SA Securitisation
Programme (RF) Limited
SASFIN securitisation vehicle. Listed, rated, asset-backed
note
Raising funding in the
securitisation market.
Debt funders in the securitisation market 649 229 59 15
SA Taxi Finance Solutions
Proprietary Limited
SPV set up by SA Taxi to raise debt funding
which it in turn uses to originate taxi loans.
Senior, unrated debentures
secured by underlying
assets
SPV set up by SA Taxi to
raise funding in the
securitisation market which
in turn uses the funding to
originate taxi loans.
Debt funders in the securitisation market 93 176 (17) 17
Superdrive Investments
(RF) Limited
SPV set up by BMW Financial Services
South Africa (Pty) Ltd, the main purpose of
which is to acquire the rights, title and
interest in vehicle instalment sale
agreements, pursuant to a securitisation
scheme.
Vehicle loan backed assets Funds of the securitisation
scheme are raised directly
or indirectly by the issue of
debt instruments in order
to manage the assets so
acquired.
Debt funders in the securitisation market 17 48 4
Bayport Securitisation Bayport securitisation vehicle. Private placement, secured
loan
Bayport securitisation
vehicle that focuses its
unsecured personal loan
products at the low- to
middle-income segments.
LGL as debt provider 191 164 19 12
Capital Harvest (RF)
Proprietary Limited
The Issuer, Capital Harvest Finance (RF)
Pty Ltd has been established as an SPV
issuing term notes to investors ranging
between three and five years in the
agricultural sector.
Listed, rated, asset-backed
note
The SPV raises funding in
the securitisation market
which in turn uses the
funding to originate new
loans. The proceeds from
these notes will be used to
purchase eligible assets
from a short-term
warehouse facility that was
established by Capital
Harvest in April 2021 and
from the Originator, Capital
Harvest (Pty) Ltd.
Debt funders in the securitisation market 457 423 43 24
NBC Finance (RF)
Proprietary Limited
NBC Pension Backed Lending Pty Ltd
(NBC) provides home loans to members of
registered retirement funds for their
primary housing requirements including
purchase, extension and alteration. The
members’ retirement fund savings are
used as the security for the loan with the
retirement fund providing a guarantee.
Pension backed lending SPV set up by NBC as a
funding vehicle into which
Liberty can lend on a
secured basis.
LGL as debt provider 650 664 61 23
Transflow RF Proprietary
Limited
Transaction Capital Ltd securitisation
vehicle.
Asset-backed lending The senior facility
agreement is guaranteed by
the security SPV where the
company issues an
indemnity in favour of the
security SPV indemnifying it
against all claims arising
pursuant to the guarantee.
Debt funders in the securitisation market 388 451 (26) 34
Name of the entity Nature and purpose of entity Principal nature of assets Principal activity of entity Principal nature of funding
Carrying value1 Income received2
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
214 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure A – Subsidiaries, consolidated and unconsolidated structured entities continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 215
-- 170 of 278 --
The Thekwini Fund series* SAHL securitisation vehicles Residential mortgage
backed securitisations
SPV is set up by SAHL to
raise funding in the
securitisation market which
it in turn uses to originate
home loans.
Debt funders in the securitisation market
The Thekwini Fund 15 (RF)
Ltd
5
The Thekwini Fund 16 (RF)
Ltd
2 9
The Thekwini Fund 17 (RF)
Ltd
30 30 3 2
The Thekwini Fund 18 (RF)
Ltd
3
Transsec 3 (RF) Ltd SA Taxi securitisation vehicles (taxi loans). Listed, rated, asset-backed
note
Raising funding in the
securitisation market to
fund taxi loans.
Debt funders in the securitisation market 1 7 1
Richefond Circle (RF)
Limited
Commercial mortgage-backed
securitisation issued off Investec's
commercial property portfolio.
Notes secured by
commercial mortgage-
backed assets
SPV set up by Investec as a
funding vehicle into which
investors can lend on a
secured basis, with the
equity provided by Investec.
Different classes of notes
issued to facilitate different
risk appetites while allowing
Investec to free up credit
lines and continue
supporting their clients.
Debt funders in the securitisation market 355 314 33 15
Exeo Finance (RF) Limited Exeo Finance (RF) Ltd is an Issuer SPV
established in 2023 for the purpose of
issuing Notes to investors where the
proceeds of the Notes are used to acquire
instalment sale and operating rental
agreements from the originator and
servicer, Centrafin Proprietary Limited.
Instalment sale and
operating rental agreement
backed note
The SPV raises funding to
acquire instalment sale and
operating rental agreements
from the Originator under a
master sale agreement
and/or to settle existing
lenders in the securitisation.
Debt funders in the securitisation market 181 1
Agri Harvest Investments
(RF) Limited
Agri Harvest securitisation vehicle. Private Placement, secured
loan
The SPV raises funding in
the securitisation market
which in turn uses the
funding to originate new
loans in the Agri sector –
principally in the Northern
Cape region.
LGL as debt provider 472 472 47 14
Total 6 585 6 065 528 392
Name of the entity Nature and purpose of entity Principal nature of assets Principal activity of entity Principal nature of funding
Carrying value1 Income received2
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
1 The carrying value disclosed represents the maximum loss the group would be exposed to, and there are no ongoing capital commitments for any of the above entities
at the end of the reporting period.
2 Income received comprises interest income and investment gains/(losses).
216 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure A – Subsidiaries, consolidated and unconsolidated structured entities continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 217
-- 171 of 278 --
Details of group companies with material non-controlling interests
Africa Regions1
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Non-controlling interests (%) * *
Summarised financial information on an IFRS basis before intercompany eliminations
Total assets 404 086 390 613
Total liabilities 345 971 330 492
Total income 38 793 29 629
Profit/(loss) for the year 16 320 12 031
Change in cash balances 13 320 6 244
Profit/(loss) attributable to non-controlling interests after intercompany eliminations 3 903 3 458
Non-controlling interest within the statement of financial position 12 599 14 769
Dividends paid to non-controlling interests 2 294 1 821
1 All balances, except total assets and total liabilities (translated using the closing exchange rate), have been translated using cumulative exchange rates.
* Refer to page 202 for details on material non-controlling interests’ percentage holding.
218 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure A – Subsidiaries, consolidated and unconsolidated structured entities continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 219
-- 172 of 278 --
South African
Home Loans
Proprietary Limited
ICBC Standard Bank
Plc
Other equity
accounted Joint
ventures and
associates
Total equity
accounted associates
and joint ventures
Ownership structure Associate Associate Associates and joint
ventures
Associates and joint
ventures
Nature of business Finance Banking Various Various
Principal place of business and country of incorporation South Africa London, UK Various Various
Year end February December Various Various
Accounting treatment Equity accounted Equity accounted Equity accounted Equity accounted
Date to which equity accounted 31 December 2023 31 December 2023 31 December 2023 31 December 2023
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Effective holding (%) 50 50 40 40 Various Various Various Various
Income statement
Total comprehensive income 692 664 3 197 4 793
Total comprehensive income attributed to equity holders of the investment1 346 332 1 286 1 917 16 16 1 648 2 265
Distributions received (325) (325)
Statement of financial position2
Non-current assets 35 248 34 809 177 148 63 789
Current assets 5 141 4 789 252 258 320 245
Non-current liabilities (36 811) (36 006) (98 459) (107 869)
Current liabilities (464) (235) (296 328) (247 619)
Net asset value attributed to equity holders of the investment 3 114 3 357 34 619 28 546
Proportion of net asset value based on effective holding 1 557 1 678 13 848 11 418
Accumulated Impairment (2 418) (2 418)
Other 142 (2 778) (2 343)
Carrying value3 (note 10) 1 699 1 678 8 652 6 657 1 822 1 621 12 173 9 956
Share of profits 346 332 1 286 1 917 16 16 1 648 2 265
1 Includes FCTR as reported by the associate or joint venture. Excludes FCTR that originates at a group level as a result of inclusions of the associates and joint ventures
in the group’s results.
2 Summarised financial information is provided based on the latest available management accounts received.
3 Includes FCTR that originates at a group level as a result of accounting for foreign-denominated associates in group’s results.
220 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 221
ANNEXURE B – ASSOCIATES AND JOINT
VENTURES
-- 173 of 278 --
STANLIB
Income Fund
STANLIB
Balanced
Cautious Fund
STANLIB
Money Market
Fund
STANLIB
Corporate
Money
Market Fund
STANLIB
Bond Fund
Agri-Vie Fund II
(Pty) Ltd
STANLIB
Flexible Income
Fund2
STANLIB ALSI
40 Fund Phembani3
Other
fair value
accounted
associates
Total
fair value
accounted
associates
Ownership structure Associate Associate Associate Associate Associate Associate Associate Associate Associate Associate Associates
Nature of business Fund Fund Fund Fund Fund Fund Fund Fund Financial
Company
Various Various
Principal place of
business
South Africa South Africa South Africa South Africa South Africa South Africa South Africa South Africa South Africa Various Various
Year end 31 December
2023
31 December
2023
31 December
2023
31 December
2023
31 December
2023
31 December
2023
31 December
2023
31 December
2023
31 December
2023
Various Various
Accounting treatment Fair value
accounted
Fair value
accounted
Fair value
accounted
Fair value
accounted
Fair value
accounted
Fair value
accounted
Fair value
accounted
Fair value
accounted
Fair value
accounted
Fair value
accounted
Fair value
accounted
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Effective holding (%) 18 16 28 29 7 5 3 2 20 10 36 36 29 25 35 35 Various Various Various Various
Fair value 9 546 8 236 2 612 2 826 1 711 1 088 2 196 1 055 1 194 571 776 529 1 336 613 665 665 2 128 2 355 21 441 18 661
Income statement
Revenue 5 067 3 745 482 569 1 966 1 318 6 486 4 098 574 558 13 22 279
Total profit for the year 4 606 3 300 374 466 1 841 1 195 6 348 3 970 550 528 191 260 81
Total comprehensive
income 4 606 3 300 374 466 1 841 1 195 6 348 3 970 550 528 191 (120) 260 75
Dividend received from
associates 683 464 43 108 3 48 11 7 53 35 1 3 57
Statement of
financial position1
Non-current assets 53 042 52 587 8 981 9 480 23 143 20 913 55 321 53 659 5 913 5 558 2 053 1 436 4 426 2 421 5 748 8 336
Current assets 1 433 440 158 379 248 365 9 558 16 141 19 149 39 36 140 29 88
Non-current liabilities (2 756) (2 381)
Current liabilities (31) (31) (7) (8) (37) (37) (11) (11) (2) (2) (2) (12) (2) (1)
Net asset value 54 444 52 996 9 132 9 851 23 354 21 241 64 868 69 789 5 930 5 705 2 090 1 460 4 564 2 449 3 080 5 955
Total carrying value
including loans measured
at fair value (note 6) 9 546 8 236 2 612 2 826 1 711 1 088 2 196 1 055 1 194 571 776 529 1 336 613 665 665 2 128 2 355 21 441 18 661
1 Summarised financial information of the associates is provided based on the latest available management accounts received.
2 STANLIB Flexible Income Fund was previously disclosed as a mutual fund associate in 2022. During 2023 Liberty increased it’s holdings and it is now considered a mutual fund
subsidiary.
3 The investment in Phembani is part of the group’s venture capital business and is therefore classified and measured at fair value. The fair value of the effective holding cannot be
calculated directly as a function of the percentage holding and the net asset value as it is an exit price at the measurement date.
Equity accounted private equity/venture capital associates1
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Cost 148 105
Carrying value 627 604
Statement of financial position2
Non-current assets 2 469 2 722
Current assets 135
Current liabilities
Income statement
Attributable income before impairment 57 (17)
Fair value
Equity accounted interest in associates 627 604
Fair value 627 604
1 Included in note 10 associates and joint ventures.
2 Summarised financial information of the associates is provided based on the latest available management accounts received.
222 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure B – Associates and joint ventures continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 223
-- 174 of 278 --
Overview
Capital management
The group’s capital management function is designed to ensure
that regulatory requirements are met at all times and that the
group and its principal subsidiaries are capitalised in line with the
group’s risk appetite and target ranges, both of which are
approved by the board.
It further aims to facilitate the allocation and use of capital, such
that it generates a return that appropriately compensates
shareholders for the risks incurred. Capital adequacy is actively
managed and forms a key component of the group’s forecasting
process. The capital plan is tested under a range of stress
scenarios as part of the group’s annual Internal Capital Adequacy
and Assessment Process (ICAAP) and recovery plan.
The capital management function is governed primarily by
management-level subcommittees that oversee the risks
associated with capital management, namely the group asset
and liability committee (ALCO) and one of its subcommittees, the
group capital management committee. The principal governance
documents are the capital management governance framework
and the model risk governance framework.
Risk management
The group’s activities give rise to various financial as well as
insurance risks. Financial risks are categorised into credit,
funding and liquidity and market risk.
The group’s approach to managing risk and capital is set out in
the group’s risk, compliance and capital management (RCCM)
governance framework approved by the group risk and capital
management committee (GRCMC).
The risk management disclosure that follows, separately
discloses the group’s banking operations and investment
management and life insurance activities as the group’s
investment management and life insurance risk is primarily
managed within the Liberty group of companies which houses
the group’s material long-term insurance operations.
Climate-related financial risks
The group recognises the immense scale of the present and
future expected environmental, social and economic impacts of
climate change. Exposure to the risks associated with climate
change arises for the group both in respect of its own activities
and operations, but more materially through the transmission of
climate risk drivers into credit, market, reputational and other
risk exposures from lending to, investing in and otherwise
transacting with clients and counterparties.
The group recognises transition and physical climate risk across
all presence countries and operations, with varying levels of
intensity. Physical climate risk includes the risk of financial loss
arising through increasing severity and frequency of weather
events such as storms, floods, fires, and other physical hazards,
all of which are evident in our countries of operation. Physical
climate risk also includes chronic longer term changes in climate,
such as changing precipitation patterns, rising sea levels and
average temperature rises.
Transition risk includes the risk of financial loss arising through
changes associated with microeconomic (individual and
corporate level) and macroeconomic (economy and country
level) adjustments made in transitioning to a lower carbon
emissions economy and business operating model. Such drivers
include changes in policies, legislation and regulations to reduce
emissions and support decarbonisation, changes due to
technology improvements that support the transition to a lower
carbon economy, changes in market demand for products and
services that support or delay the transition, and reputational
risks associated with changing customer preferences. The
current and future expected costs, including for possible
stranded assets that do not deliver an economic return because
of changes associated with a transition to a lower carbon
economy, are higher for clients and counterparties of the group
that operate in sectors that are more vulnerable to these
transition risk drivers.
In support of Africa’s fair-share contribution to the Paris
Agreement goal of limiting global warming to less than 1.5°C
above pre-industrial levels by 2050, the group has committed to
achieving net zero emissions from its own operations for newly
built facilities by 2030, for existing facilities by 2040, and from its
portfolio of financed emissions by 2050.
Governance
The Standard Bank Group Climate Policy (climate policy) guides
both the management of exposures to businesses in sectors that
are vulnerable to climate-related risks and the direction of
finance towards qualifying transactions that seek to address
Africa’s energy poverty, achieve fair employment opportunities,
and support the just transition to net zero. The board and its
committees are responsible for overseeing both the
implementation of the group’s climate policy and supporting
sector-specific strategies for driving sustainable and transition
finance, and the management of climate-related financial risks
associated with the group’s lending and investing activities,
wherever they are identified. Specifically the board and its
supporting committees are responsible for:
■ Overseeing implementation of the climate policy including
monitoring of progress made to meet targets and
commitments.
■ Reviewing outputs of internal scenario analysis and regulatory
climate risk stress tests, as well as other related risk matters.
■ Assessing executive performance in relation to climate policy
commitments and targets.
The group risk oversight committee (GROC), chaired by the
group chief risk & corporate affairs officer, oversees financial and
non-financial-related risks, including climate-related risks.
GROC is responsible for overseeing the embedment of climate-
related risk-identification, classification, analysis, monitoring and
reporting in the enterprise-wide risk management system.
The group portfolio risk management committee (GPRMC)
assesses the composition of the group’s portfolio including for
lending to sectors more vulnerable to climate-related risks, the
implications thereon of stressed scenarios (including going
forward for climate-related risk scenarios) and sets
concentration limits or thresholds of portfolios and risk appetite
indicator guidelines for group. The refinement of quantified limits
and thresholds for exposures to climate-related risks is ongoing
across impacted portfolios.
224 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
ANNEXURE C – IFRS RISK AND CAPITAL
MANAGEMENT DISCLOSURES
-- 175 of 278 --
Strategy
The group supports a just energy transition that prioritises
environmental sustainability in a manner that creates work
opportunities and social inclusion, addresses Africa’s energy
poverty and acknowledges Africa’s very limited contribution to
global emissions. As part of the efforts to achieve this transition,
the group has committed to reducing its financed emissions
while responsibly managing its exposure to fossil fuels,
specifically where there is a national level energy transition
roadmap that supports cleaner fuels.
The group has adopted a phased and progressive approach to
understanding its climate risk exposures, designing sector-
specific strategies and setting appropriate targets to reduce
exposure and maximise opportunities.The group undertook a
rigorous process of research, internal consultation and expert
engagement designed to develop a clear understanding of risks
and opportunities in each sector, set appropriate strategies and
to determine appropriate targets to manage portfolio risk and
maximise opportunity.
The first phase included the identification of five client sectors
that face material climate-related risk and opportunity, namely:
agriculture, gas, oil, thermal coal and renewable energy. The
group’s climate policy published in March 2022, sets targets and
commitments in respect of these sectors.
The second phase extended targets and commitments to the
residential real estate, commercial real estate and short-term
insurance sectors. These additional sectors are reflected climate
strategy reflects the targets and commitments made in these
sectors published in March 2023.
The climate policy is a group-wide policy with application across
all legal entities in the group. The group’s approach to climate
risk and opportunities is primarily sector-led across all countries,
with business teams developing their climate targets,
commitments and climate risk appetite as part of their sector-
specific business strategies. Country-specific climate risk
assessment capabilities are being developed within the group’s
sovereign risk function.
Risk management
The Climate Risk team in Group Sustainability is driving the
establishment of standards for climate data management and
assurance. Work is underway to automate the reporting of
climate related exposures in selected sectors. The climate risk
team in Group Sustainability is driving the establishment of
standards for climate data management and assurance. Work is
underway to automate the reporting of climate related exposures
in selected sectors. The group continues refining data and
reporting structures within which our counterparties and their
activities are classified. The objective, is to enhance sector
classifications to more accurately reflect the extent to which the
sectors are, or may be, vulnerable to climate-related risks. This
will support reporting for climate metric purposes, as well as the
group’s internal and external portfolio-level scenario analysis.
Responding to regulatory expectations for enhanced risk
management is also a part of the ongoing work across the
continent, including an upcoming stress testing exercises.
The climate risk team in SBSA is working to enhance the
management of climate data for use in risk identification and
measurement as well as for regulatory purposes. SBSA is
preparing for a regulatory climate risk stress test by sourcing and
preparing the data required for modelling a range of different
scenarios expected to stress test credit portfolios. The data
includes client exposure to climate risks, macroeconomic data,
scenario narratives, credit metric data, transition alignment data,
climate hazards and emissions data.
Transition risks
■ Exposure to policy risk over the medium to long term
associated with uncertain long-term demand for fossil fuels,
especially coal, and other high emitting sectors. Key drivers for
this risk include expected policy actions such as more onerous
carbon-pricing regulations to limit emissions on business
activities. Such action could lead to higher risks of stranded
assets and the related financial risks for the group arising from
an impairment in value of clients’ operating assets pledged as
collateral and leading therefore to an increase in the
probability risk of client defaults.
■ Market risk primarily over the short to medium term related to
changing client expectations for greener products and
services, potentially impacting on some of our clients’ future
business opportunities. Likewise, expectations from investors
will also adjust to an appetite for lower financed emissions,
applying pressure on the group to align with low emissions
pathways.
■ Higher reputational risk including in the immediate short-term
arising from negative stakeholder sentiment and adverse
media coverage related to support of projects or activities with
negative impacts on the climate, including oil and gas-related
infrastructure projects.
Physical risks
Acute physical risks such as more frequent and more intense
extreme weather events, pose a risk to the group’s own
operations and those of its customers in sectors the group has
identified as being vulnerable, including agriculture and others.
Chronic physical risks such as rising average temperatures and
changing precipitation patterns over the medium to long term,
that lead to heat stress, droughts, higher wildfire risks and water
shortages, may impact the group’s clients in affected sectors
including mining, industrial, manufacturing and agriculture
through water shortages, labour productivity, economic output
and occupational health.
Opportunities
The group continues to work with its clients and partners to help
them address their climate impacts, lower their emissions and
improve their resilience. The group continues to expand its
offering of sustainability-linked lending solutions, green and
social bonds. The group supports sustainable agricultural
practices that promote reduced carbon emissions and improved
resilience to climate risk. Further information can be found in the
group’s report to society.
Metrics and targets
In setting its targets for reducing exposure concentrations to
affected sectors, setting future origination goals and driving its
offerings, the group referenced the NGFS Net Zero 2050
scenario, publicly available national research and statistics,
including electricity planning forecasts (where available) and
internal economic forecasts and research obtained from credible
external sources. Detailed information in this regard can be found
in the group’s climate-related disclosures report and the climate
policy.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 225
-- 176 of 278 --
Banking
Approach to managing and measuring
credit risk
The group’s credit risk is a function of its business model and
arises from corporate, business and retail loans and advances,
underwriting and guarantee commitments, as well as from the
counterparty credit risk (CCR) arising from derivative and
securities financing contracts entered into with our customers
and trading counterparties. To the extent that equity risk is held
on the banking book, it is managed according to the same
general principles and governance standards as would otherwise
apply to credit risk, except in so far as approval authority rests
with the group equity risk committee (ERC).
Credit risk is managed through:
■ maintaining a culture of responsible lending and a robust risk
policy and control framework.
■ identifying, assessing and measuring credit risk across the
group, from an individual facility level through to an aggregate
portfolio level.
■ defining, implementing and continually re-evaluating risk
appetite under actual and stressed conditions.
■ monitoring the group’s credit risk exposure relative to
approved limits.
■ ensuring that there is expert scrutiny and approval of credit
risk and its mitigation independently of the business functions.
A group’s guideline for credit limits and concentration is
embedded within the group’s enterprise-wide risk management
process. Within the group’s overall risk appetite disciplines, the
credit metrics and concentrations framework includes key credit
ratios and counterparty, sector and country concentration
guidelines. These in turn are cascaded to client segment and
legal entity level where they are monitored against approved
appetite thresholds.
The group distinguishes between through-the-cycle PDs
measures and point-in-time PDs, and utilises both measures in
decision-making. To determine point-in-time PDs for IFRS 9
measurement, through-the-cycle PDs are used as a starting point
and adjusted to determine appropriate point-in-time PDs. PDs
are used to assign credit ratings to counterparties which in turn
are used in pricing decisions regulatory capital calculations, and
expected loss and impairments measurements.
A credit portfolio limit framework has been defined to monitor
and control the credit risk profile within our approved risk
appetite. All primary lending credit limits are set and exposures
measured on the basis of risk weighting in order to best estimate
exposure at default (EAD).
Pre-settlement CCR inherent in trading book exposures is
measured on a potential future exposure (PFE) basis, modelled
at a defined level of confidence using approved methodologies
and models, and controlled within explicit approved limits for the
counterparties concerned.
Credit risk mitigation
Wherever warranted, the group seeks to mitigate credit risk,
including for CCR, to any counterparty, transaction, sector, or
geographic region, so as to achieve the optimal balance between
risk, cost, capital utilisation and reward. Risk mitigation may
include the use of collateral, the imposition of financial or
behavioural covenants, the acceptance of guarantees from
parents or third parties, the recognition of parental support
where that is legally enforceable, and the distribution of risk.
Collateral, parental guarantees, credit derivatives and on- and
off-balance sheet netting are widely used to mitigate credit risk.
Credit risk management policies and procedures ensure that risk
mitigation techniques are acceptable, used consistently, valued
appropriately and regularly, and meet the risk requirements of
operational management for legal, practical and timely
enforcement. Detailed processes and procedures are in place to
guide each type of mitigation used.
In the case of collateral where the group has an unassailable legal
title, the group’s policy requires collateral to meet certain criteria
for recognition in LGD modelling, including but not limited to:
■ being readily marketable and liquid.
■ being legally perfected and enforceable.
■ having a low valuation volatility.
■ being readily realisable at minimum expense.
■ having no material correlation to the obligor credit quality.
■ having an active secondary market for resale.
The main types of collateral obtained for the group’s banking
book exposures include:
■ mortgage bonds over residential, commercial and industrial
properties.
■ cession of book debts.
■ pledge and cession of financial assets.
■ bonds over plant and equipment.
■ the underlying movable assets financed under leases and
instalment sales.
Reverse repurchase agreements and commodity leases to
customers are collateralised by the underlying assets.
Guarantees and related legal contracts are often required,
particularly in support of credit extension to groups of companies
and weaker obligors. Guarantors include banks, parent
companies, shareholders and associated obligors.
Creditworthiness is established for the guarantor as is set for
other obligor credit approvals.
For trading and derivative transactions where collateral support
is considered necessary, the group typically uses recognised and
enforceable International Swaps and Derivatives Association
(ISDA) agreements, with a credit support annexure.
Netting agreements, such as collateral under the credit support
annexure of an ISDA agreement, are obtained only where the
group firstly have a legally enforceable right to offset credit risk
by way of such an agreement, and secondly where we have the
intention of utilising such agreement to settle on a net basis.
ECL is provided even if the exposure is fully covered by collateral.
There have not been any changes to the group’s collateral
policies in the current reporting period.
Other credit protection terms may be stipulated, such as
limitations on the amount of unsecured credit exposure
acceptable, collateralisation if the mark-to-market credit
exposure exceeds acceptable limits, and termination of the
contract if certain credit events occur, for example, downgrade of
the counterparty’s public credit rating.
Wrong-way risk arises in transactions where the likelihood of
default (as measured by the PD) by a counterparty and the size
of credit exposure (as measured by EAD) to that counterparty
tend to increase at the same time. This risk is managed both at
an individual counterparty level and at an aggregate portfolio
level by limiting exposure to such transactions, taking adverse
correlation into account in the measurement and mitigation of
credit exposure and increasing oversight and approval levels. We
have no appetite for wrong-way risk arising where the correlation
between EAD and PD is due to a legal, economic, strategic or
similar relationship (specific wrong-way risk). General wrong-way
risk, which arises when the EAD and PD for the counterparty is
226 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 177 of 278 --
correlated due to macro factors, is closely managed within
existing risk frameworks.
To manage actual or potential portfolio risk concentrations in
areas of higher credit risk and credit portfolio growth, we
implement hedging and other strategies from time to time. This
is done at individual counterparty, sub-portfolio and portfolio
levels through the use of syndication, distribution and sale of
assets, asset and portfolio limit management, credit derivatives
and credit protection.
Use of internal estimates
Our credit risk rating systems and processes differentiate and
quantify credit risk across counterparties and asset classes.
Internal risk parameters are used extensively in risk management
and business processes, including:
■ setting risk appetite.
■ setting concentration and counterparty limits.
■ credit approval and monitoring.
Corporate, sovereign and banking portfolios
Corporate entities include large companies, as well as SMEs that
are managed on a relationship basis or have a combined
exposure to the group of more than R12 million. Corporate
exposures also include specialised lending (project, object and
commodity finance, as well as income-producing real estate
(IPRE)) and public sector entities.
Sovereign and bank borrowers include sovereign government
entities, central banks, local and provincial government entities,
bank and non-bank financial institutions.
The creditworthiness of corporate (excluding specialised
lending), sovereign and bank exposures is assessed based on a
detailed individual assessment of the financial strength of the
borrower. This quantitative analysis, together with expert
judgement and external rating agency ratings, leads to an
assignment of an internal rating to the entity.
Specialised lending’s creditworthiness is assessed at a
transactional level, rather than on the financial strength of the
borrower, in so far as the group relies only on repayment from
the cash flows generated by the underlying assets financed.
Concentration risk management is performed to ensure that
credit exposure concentrations in respect of obligors, countries,
sectors and other risk areas are effectively managed. This
includes concentrations arising from credit exposure to different
entities within an obligor economic group, such as exposure to
public sector and other government entities that are related to
the same sovereign.
The elevated levels of public debt and persistent fiscal deficits
across a number of sub-Saharan Africa countries continues to be
a source of close scrutiny and ongoing portfolio alignment, given
the group's significant sovereign exposures. High borrowing
rates and limited access to international markets, lower tax
revenues and local currency weaknesses have all contributed to
the crisis. Although the group's exposure to this sector remains
material, much of this is non-discretionary in nature, being for
regulatory and liquidity management purposes, the risk of further
sovereign credit ratings downgrades and migrations is a key
indicator and it continues to be closely monitored.
Credit portfolio characteristics and metrics
Maximum exposure to credit risk
Financial assets at amortised cost and FVOCI as well as off-
balance sheet exposure subject to ECL are analysed and
categorised based on credit quality using the group’s master
rating scale. Exposures within stage 1 and 2 are rated between
1 to 25 in terms of the group’s master rating scale. The group
uses a 25-point master rating scale to quantify the credit risk for
each borrower (corporate asset classes) or facility (specialised
lending and retail asset classes), as illustrated in the table below.
These ratings are mapped to PDs by means of calibration
formulae that use historical default rates and other data from the
applicable home services, vehicle and asset finance, card,
personal, business lending and other product portfolios.
Exposures which are in default are not considered in the 1 to 25-
point master rating scale.
The table includes securities held as collateral for exposures in
default.
Default
The internal credit risk management definitions and approaches
are aligned to the group’s definition of default. While the specific
determination of default may vary according to the nature of the
product, it is generally determined (aligned to the Basel
definition) as occurring at the earlier of:
■ where, in the group’s view and based on objective evidence,
the counterparty is considered to be unlikely to pay amounts
due on the due date or shortly thereafter without recourse to
actions such as the realisation of security; or
■ when the counterparty is past due (or in the case of overdraft
facilities, is in excess of the current limit) for more than
90 days on any material credit obligation to the group.
The group has not rebutted IFRS 9’s 90 days past due rebuttable
presumption. Exposures which are overdue for more than
90 days are also considered to be in default.
A financial asset is considered to be in default when there is
objective evidence of impairment. The following criteria are used
in determining whether there is objective evidence of impairment
for financial assets or groups of financial assets:
■ significant financial difficulty of borrower and/or modification
(i.e. known cash flow difficulties experienced by the borrower).
■ a breach of contract, such as default or delinquency in interest
and/or principal payments.
■ disappearance of active market due to financial difficulties.
■ it becomes probable that the borrower will enter bankruptcy or
any other financial reorganisation or insolvency process.
■ where the group, for economic or legal reasons relating to the
borrower’s financial difficulty, grants the borrower a
concession that the group would not otherwise consider and
where this is likely to result in a diminished financial obligation
to the group.
■ where the group stops accruing income in respect of the
counterparty or raises a specific impairment in respect of any
exposure to the counterparty.
■ where the group sells any exposure to a counterparty at a
material credit-related economic loss.
The information disclosed in the tables that follow, in respect of
the credit quality of exposures was derived from the credit risk
and capital systems of the group. The classification of the
exposures into asset classes was determined by reference to
classifications as per note 8.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 227
-- 178 of 278 --
IFRS: MAXIMUM EXPOSURE TO CREDIT RISK BY CREDIT QUALITY
SB 1 – 12 SB 13 – 20 SB 21 – 25 Default
Total gross
carrying
amount
of default
exposures
Rm
Securities
and expected
recoveries
on default
exposures
Rm
Balance sheet
ECL
and IIIS
on stage 3
Rm
Gross default
coverage
%
Non-
performing
exposures
%
Exposure
Rm
Stage 1
Rm
Stage 2
Rm
Stage 1
Rm
Stage 2
Rm
Stage 1
Rm
Stage 2
Rm
Stage 3
Rm
2023
Loans and advances at amortised cost
Home services 466 734 66 742 39 285 250 8 947 11 291 50 675 43 790 43 790 29 409 14 381 33 9.4
Vehicle and asset finance 126 754 42 160 56 493 7 432 4 279 5 806 10 584 10 584 5 364 5 220 49 8.4
Card and payments 38 934 2 184 23 807 223 4 097 4 553 4 070 4 070 1 440 2 630 65 10.5
Personal unsecured lending 104 741 7 149 6 64 981 604 10 793 9 385 11 823 11 823 3 288 8 535 72 11.3
Business lending and other 140 604 31 046 272 85 143 1 677 1 111 9 349 12 006 12 006 4 963 7 043 59 8.5
Corporate and sovereign 597 373 269 406 2 625 279 952 24 023 3 801 2 139 15 427 15 427 7 299 8 128 53 2.6
Bank 196 260 161 823 645 20 677 477 12 120 518
Central and other services (172) (172)
Gross carrying amount of loans and advances at amortised cost 1 671 228 580 338 3 587 816 303 43 383 47 492 82 425 97 700 97 700 51 763 45 937 47 5.8
Less: total ECL for loans and advances (63 995)
Net carrying amount of loans and advances at amortised cost 1 607 233
Financial investments at amortised cost
Corporate and sovereign 253 167 217 170 3 179 21 400 2 241 1 570 7 607
Bank 4 377 4 338 39
Other instruments 1 107 1 107
Gross carrying amount of financial investment at amortised
cost 258 651 222 615 3 179 21 439 2 241 1 570 7 607
Less: total ECL for financial investments (413)
Net carrying amount of financial investment at amortised cost 258 238
Debt financial investments at FVOCI
Corporate and sovereign 41 189 18 712 16 247 6 221 9
Banking 451 227 224
Other instruments 1 831 1 831
Gross carrying amount of financial investments at FVOCI 43 471 20 770 16 471 6 221 9
Off-balance sheet exposure
Letters of credit and bankers’ acceptances 13 445 5 437 7 056 35 867 50
Guarantees 96 757 61 112 42 23 808 6 273 3 862 1 358 302
Unutilised facilities1 200 013 166 097 1 775 29 742 1 450 681 177 91
Total exposure to off-balance sheet credit risk 310 215 232 646 1 817 60 606 7 758 5 410 1 585 393
ECL for off-balance sheet exposures (444)
Net carrying amount of off-balance sheet exposures 309 771
Total exposure to credit risk on financial assets subject to an
expected credit loss 2 218 713
Exposures not subject to ECL
Loans and advances at FVTPL 715
Cash and balances with central banks2 137 719
Derivative assets 87 754
Other financial investments at fair value3 21 863
Trading assets 315 496
Pledged assets 16 091
Other financial assets4 21 181
Total exposure to credit risk 2 819 532
1 The ECL on unutilised facilities is included in the total ECL for loans and advances.
2 Balances with central banks comprise of FVTPL of R122 718 million that are not subject to ECL considerations and amortised cost of R15 069 million, which has a low
probability of default therefore ECL is insignificant. These balances are subject to the rigorous regulatory requirements of these transactions and its link to the underlying
entities’ ability to operate as a bank. Amount represents deposits placed in currencies as issued by the central banks with which they are stored.
3 Other financial investments comprise of FVTPL of 13 544 million and FVOCI of R1 592million (refer note 6) that are not subject to ECL considerations. These balances
include financial investments designated at FVTPL of R2 379 million (refer note 22.4)
4 Due to the short-term nature of these financial assets and historical experience and available forward looking information, other financial assets are regarded as having a
low probability of default. Therefore, the ECL has been assessed to be insignificant.
228 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 229
-- 179 of 278 --
IFRS: MAXIMUM EXPOSURE TO CREDIT RISK BY CREDIT QUALITY CONTINUED
SB 1 – 12 SB 13 – 20 SB 21 – 25 Default
Total gross
carrying
amount
of default
exposures
Rm
Securities
and
expected
recoveries
on default
exposures
Rm
Balance sheet
expected
credit loss
and interest
in suspense
on stage 3
Rm
Gross
default
coverage
%
Non-
performing
exposures
%
Exposure
Rm
Stage 1
Rm
Stage 2
Rm
Stage 1
Rm
Stage 2
Rm
Stage 1
Rm
Stage 2
Rm
Stage 3
Rm
20221
Loans and advances at amortised cost
Home services 459 647 65 072 105 306 626 12 813 7 364 34 682 32 985 32 985 20 188 12 797 39 7
Vehicle and asset finance 119 859 33 100 147 59 064 5 395 5 957 7 647 8 549 8 549 3 911 4 638 54 7
Card payments 38 063 1 367 26 614 443 2 395 4 057 3 187 3 187 1 225 1 962 62 8
Personal unsecured lending 102 579 9 841 68 66 051 481 7 785 8 594 9 759 9 759 3 001 6 758 69 10
Business lending and other 147 712 38 504 388 89 175 1 821 676 7 541 9 607 9 607 3 613 5 994 62 7
Corporate and sovereign 516 211 195 214 1 383 283 754 17 354 2 697 2 456 13 353 13 353 6 861 6 492 49 3
Bank 168 422 134 162 590 27 855 311 2 367 3 137
Central and other service 5 247 5 247
Gross carrying amount of loans and advances at amortised cost 1 557 740 482 507 2 681 859 139 38 618 29 241 68 114 77 440 77 440 38 799 38 641 50 5.0
Less: total ECL for loans and advances (55 828)
Net carrying amount of loans and advances at amortised cost 1 501 912
Financial investments at amortised cost
Corporate and sovereign 216 939 186 156 2 996 20 473 4 371 1 329 1 614
Bank 2 196 2 154 42
Other instruments 1 242 1 181 61
Gross carrying amount of financial investments at amortised
cost 220 377 189 491 2 996 20 576 4 371 1 329 1 614
Less: total ECL for financial investments (1 276)
Net carrying amount of financial investments 219 101
Debt financial investments at FVOCI
Corporate and sovereign 50 632 19 781 28 501 1 647 665 38
Bank 334 292 42
Other instruments 1 418 39 1 245 134
Gross carrying value of financial investments 52 384 20 112 29 788 1 647 665 38 134
Off-balance sheet exposure
Letters of credit and bankers’ acceptances 13 427 4 393 8 148 189 627 65 5
Guarantees 106 286 74 597 40 25 394 5 810 246 152 47
Unutilised facilities2 195 115 156 532 1 701 33 892 2 448 193 209 140
Total exposure to off-balance sheet credit risk 314 828 235 522 1 741 67 434 8 447 1 066 426 192
ECL for off-balance sheet exposures (394)
Net carrying amount of off-balance sheet 314 434
Total exposure to credit risk on financial assets subject to an
ECL 2 087 831
Exposures not subject to ECL
Loans and advances at fair value 665
Cash and balances with central banks3 114 437
Derivative assets 61 799
Other financial investments at fair value4 43 854
Trading assets 312 523
Pledged assets 13 058
Other financial assets5 28 689
Total exposure to credit risk 2 662 856
1 2022 has been restated where applicable, to align to the group’s new structure.
2 The ECL on unutilised facilities is included in the total ECL for loans and advances.
3 Balances with central banks comprise of FVTPL of R99 712million that are not subject to ECL considerations and amortised cost of R14 725 million, which has a low
probability of default therefore ECL is insignificant. These balances are subject to the rigorous regulatory requirements of these transactions and its link to the underlying
entities’ ability to operate as a bank. Amount represents deposits placed in currencies as issued by the central banks with which they are stored.
4 Other financial investments comprise of FVTPL of R417 038 million and FVOCI of R905 million (refer note 6) that are not subject to ECL considerations. These balances
include financial investments designated at FVTPL of R12 955 million (refer note 22.4)
5 Due to the short-term nature of these financial assets and historical experience, other financial assets are regarded as having a low probability of default.
230 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 231
-- 180 of 278 --
Concentration risk
Concentration risk is the risk of loss arising from an excessive concentration of exposure to a single counterparty, an industry, a product,
a geography, maturity, or collateral. The group’s credit risk portfolio is well-diversified. The group’s management approach relies on the
reporting of concentration risk along key dimensions, the setting of portfolio limits and stress testing. 2022 has been restated, where
applicable, to align with the group restructure.
IFRS: INDUSTRY SEGMENTAL ANALYSIS GROSS LOANS AND ADVANCES
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Agriculture 45 222 42 906
Construction 19 838 18 570
Electricity 42 078 31 818
Finance, real estate and other business services 504 102 430 392
Individuals 651 782 645 127
Manufacturing 105 547 98 283
Mining 57 709 56 372
Transport 58 015 64 359
Wholesale 106 159 97 864
Other services 81 491 72 715
Gross loans and advances 1 671 943 1 558 406
IFRS: GEOGRAPHIC SEGMENTAL ANALYSIS GROSS LOANS AND ADVANCES
2023 2022
% Rm % Rm
South Africa 65 1 086 185 64 1 000 758
Africa Regions 22 366 721 22 343 454
International 13 219 037 14 214 194
Gross loans and advances 100 1 671 943 100 1 558 406
IFRS: INDUSTRY SEGMENTAL ANALYSIS OF STAGE 3 CREDIT IMPAIRMENT OF LOANS AND
ADVANCES
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Agriculture 1 784 1 508
Construction 1 256 970
Electricity 761 588
Finance, real estate and other business services 4 300 3 600
Individuals 28 432 24 596
Manufacturing 2 069 1 773
Mining 570 276
Transport 1 429 1 418
Wholesale 3 436 1 940
Other services 1 900 1 972
Credit impairment on non-performing loans 45 937 38 641
IFRS: GEOGRAPHIC SEGMENTAL ANALYSIS OF STAGE 3 CREDIT IMPAIRMENT OF LOANS AND
ADVANCES
2023 2022
% Rm % Rm
South Africa 83 38 120 80 31 058
Africa Regions 16 7 225 20 7 291
International 1 592 1 292
Credit impairment on non-performing loans 100 45 937 101 38 641
232 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 181 of 278 --
Collateral
The table below shows the financial effect that collateral has on the group’s maximum exposure to credit risk. The table is presented
according to Basel asset categories and includes collateral that may not be eligible for recognition under Basel but that management
takes into consideration in the management of the group’s exposures to credit risk. Credit risk management, measurement and
mitigation including the use of collateral, are detailed on pages 226 – 227. All on- and off-balance sheet exposures that are exposed to
credit risk, and non-performing loans, have been included.
Collateral includes:
■ financial securities that have a tradable market, such as shares and other securities
■ physical items, such as property, plant and equipment
■ financial guarantees, suretyships and intangible assets.
Netting agreements, which do not qualify for offset under IFRS but which are nevertheless enforceable, are included as part of the
group’s collateral for risk management purposes. All exposures are presented before the effect of any impairment provisions.
The group does not currently trade commodities that could give rise to physical commodity inventory or collateral exposure with the
exception of precious metals. In the normal course of its precious metal trading operations the group does not hold allocated physical
metal; however, this may occur from time-to-time. Where this does occur, appropriate risk and business approval is required to ensure
that the minimum requirements are satisfied, including but not limited to approval of risk limits and insurance cover.
2022 has been restated, where applicable, to align with the group restructure.
COLLATERAL1
Total
exposure
Rm
Secured
Rm
Netting
agreements
Rm
Secured
exposure
after
netting
Rm
2023
Corporate and sovereign1 1 293 497 334 787 10 315 324 472
Bank 345 596 239 845 55 114 184 731
Retail lending 762 658 635 689 290 635 399
Retail mortgages 472 288 482 999 482 999
Other retail 290 370 152 690 290 152 400
Total 2 401 751 1 210 321 65 719 1 144 602
Add: financial assets not exposed to credit risk2 401 645
Less: impairments for loans and advances (63 995)
Less: unrecognised off-balance sheet items (235 685)
Total exposure 2 503 716
Cash and balances with central banks 137 719
Derivative assets 87 754
Trading assets 315 496
Pledged assets 16 091
Financial investments 316 845
Other financial assets 21 863
Loans and advances 1 607 948
Total 2 503 716
1 Includes business lending and other exposures in note 8 loans and advances.
2 Does not include exposures which are fully covered by collateral.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 233
-- 182 of 278 --
Total
exposure
Rm
Secured
Rm
Netting
agreements
Rm
Secured
exposure
after
netting
Rm
2022
Corporate and sovereign 1 1 211 818 333 757 13 257 320 500
Bank 315 299 228 372 62 647 165 725
Retail lending 741 835 622 805 134 622 671
Retail mortgages 469 623 469 630 469 630
Other retail 272 212 153 175 134 153 041
Total 2 268 952 1 184 934 76 038 1 108 896
Add: financial assets not exposed to credit risk2 382 643
Less: impairments for loans and advances (55 828)
Less: unrecognised off balance sheet items (245 597)
Total exposure 2 350 170
Cash and balances with central banks 114 437
Derivative assets 61 799
Trading assets 312 523
Pledged assets 13 058
Financial investments 316 243
Other financial assets 29 533
Loans and advances 1 502 577
Total 2 350 170
1 Includes business lending and other exposures in note 8 loans and advances.
2 Does not include exposures which are fully covered by collateral.
234 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 183 of 278 --
Insurance & Asset Management
Approach to managing and measuring credit
risk
Credit risks are partially a function of Insurance and asset
management (IAM)’s core business activities, but also part of a
deliberate decision to add credit risk exposures to diversify the
risks on the balance sheet and to generate attractive risk-
adjusted returns. IAM prefers to take credit risk to back its long-
dated and relatively illiquid liabilities due to the risk-adjusted
returns it is able to achieve.
Looking forward, credit risks may be exacerbated by current and
emerging macroeconomic trends, a weakening domestic
business environment and the deterioration of the operational
delivery and credit standing of the state-owned enterprises
which may impact on the contribution of credit risk to IAM’s
profit and loss.
The credit risk policy for IAM is largely in line with the credit
philosophy adopted by the group’s banking activities. IAM
balance sheet management committee (IBSMC), together with
representatives from business, are primarily responsible for the
implementation of the IAM credit policy which is aligned to the
banking credit policy.
Where credit risk is for the risk and reward of policyholders, IAM
is still exposed to indirect consequences of the credit loss such
as possible reputational damage, legal disputes, lower
investment fees and portfolio outflows.
Credit risk originated by business units (BUs) in IAM is managed
by the BU. They are responsible for ensuring that the group
credit risk policy is adopted, and that adequate systems, policies
and procedures are put in place to meet the group life insurer’s
requirements.
Through the investment activities of mandated asset managers,
IAM has largely been exposed to listed and more liquid credit
instruments. However, the STANLIB Credit Alternatives
Franchise mandate requires investment into illiquid credit assets,
including exposure to unlisted and structured instruments, to
benefit from higher returns and diversification. This is in line with
the IAM approved credit strategy and risk appetite for the
business. While IBSMC remains satisfied that the credit portfolio
is sound, well-positioned and within risk appetite levels, it is
recognised that loss events may occur from time-to-time in a
credit portfolio of this nature.
Rating methodology
For the purposes of this report, standard rating classifications
used by external ratings agencies have been applied.
Rating scale
Where applicable, internal ratings are mapped to equivalent
external rating agencies’ (Moody’s, Standard and Poor’s) rating
scales. These external, globally recognisable rating categories
are defined below.
Investment grade
■ A- and above: Strong to extremely strong capacity to meet
financial commitments.
■ BBB: Adequate capacity to meet financial commitments, but
vulnerable to severe adverse economic conditions.
■ Investment grade is the equivalent of internal client ratings
of SB 1 – 12.
Non-investment grade
■ BB: Less vulnerable in the near-term but faces major ongoing
uncertainties to adverse business, financial and economic
conditions.
■ Below BB: Vulnerable to adverse business, financial and
economic conditions. The above ratings may be modified by
the addition of a plus or minus sign to show relative standing
within the major rating categories.
■ Non-investment grade is the equivalent of internal client
ratings of SB 13 – 20.
Not rated
IAM is not restricted from investing purely in rated instruments,
or where counterparties are rated, and accordingly invests in
assets that offer appropriate returns after an internal
assessment of credit risk. For most material investments in
unrated instruments, or through unrated counterparties, internal
ratings were undertaken. However, at any one time there will
always be some unrated exposures, generally entered into
through asset managers, where the internal ratings methodology
has not been applied. This does not imply that the potential
default risk is higher or lower than for rated assets.
Due to the extent of work required to obtain or prepare a credit
rating, certain asset holdings (principally related to the
consolidation of mutual funds) do have assets with underlying
ratings, however, they may be classified as not rated for practical
reasons.
Exposure to prepayments and other receivables is predominantly
not rated due to the large number of counterparties and the short
period of credit exposure. This credit exposure is managed by
business areas
Pooled funds
The group invests in mutual funds through which it is also
exposed to credit risk of the underlying assets in which the
mutual funds are invested. IAM’s exposure to mutual funds is
classified at fund level and not at the underlying asset level.
Although mutual funds are not rated, fund managers are required
to invest in credit assets within the defined parameters stipulated
in the fund’s mandate. These rules limit the extent to which fund
managers can invest in unlisted and/or unrated credit assets and
generally restrict funds to the acquisition of local currency
investment grade assets.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 235
-- 184 of 278 --
Exposure to credit risk
The following table provides information regarding the aggregated credit risk exposure to debt instruments categorised by credit ratings,
if available, as at 31 December 2023.
A- and
above BBB+ BBB BBB- BB+ BB
BB-
and
below
Not
rated
Pooled
funds
Total
exposure
Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm Rm
2023
Debt instruments 11 482 2 059 1 263 17 536 16 017 88 870 33 208 1 182 171 617
Preference shares 6 1 25 55 72 6 90 255
Term deposits 11 476 2 059 1 262 17 511 15 962 88 798 33 202 1 017 171 287
Loans 75 75
Mutual funds - interest-bearing
instruments1 327 3 572 2 108 45 298 48 308
Investment policies 21 21
Reinsurance contract assets 4 535 112 767 5 414
Derivatives and collateral deposits 5 680 13 1 032 7 407 977 129 49 15 287
Prepayments and other receivables 971 308 3 645 4 924
Cash and cash equivalents 5 426 1 479 125 291 512 13 554 3 430 748 25 565
Total assets bearing credit risk2 28 421 3 554 1 388 18 859 24 508 103 401 39 295 6 412 45 298 271 136
Local 15 268 2 480 946 16 924 23 228 94 663 37 107 4 395 33 604 228 615
Foreign 13 153 1 074 442 1 935 1 280 8 738 2 188 2 017 11 694 42 521
2022
Debt instruments 10 650 2 469 958 16 153 18 108 68 546 49 331 3 125 169 340
Preference shares 7 1 20 117 51 28 59 283
Term deposits 10 643 2 469 957 16 133 17 991 68 495 49 303 2 964 168 955
Loans3 102 102
Mutual funds - interest-bearing
instruments1 22 886 1 174 34 826 36 908
Investment policies 14 14
Reinsurance contract assets4 4 866 230 14 443 5 553
Derivatives and collateral deposits 5 324 695 360 5 720 2 714 919 53 15 785
Prepayments and other receivables3 1 278 2 254 1 998 3 532
Cash and cash equivalents 4 607 1 477 124 323 497 17 507 3 956 875 29 366
Total assets bearing credit risk2 26 747 4 871 1 082 16 838 25 225 88 767 55 634 6 508 34 826 260 498
Local 15 654 2 565 798 14 510 23 532 79 123 51 792 3 854 29 069 220 897
Foreign 11 082 2 306 284 2 328 1 693 9 644 3 842 2 654 5 768 39 601
1 Mutual funds are categorised into property, equity or interest-bearing instruments based on a minimum of 80% of the underlying asset composition of the fund by
value being of a like category. In the event of “no one category meeting this threshold” it is classified as "mixed asset classes".
2 Due to practical considerations, credit exposure contained in investments in mutual funds that are classified as "mixed asset classes" is excluded.
3 IFRS 17 requires all policyholder related cashflows to be included in the measurement of insurance/reinsurance contract assets/liabilities, and consequently certain
items previously included in this table have been reclassified as a result of the IFRS 17 transition.
4 Restated. Refer to pages 31 to 39 for more details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
MAIN PARTY EXPOSED TO CREDIT RISK FOR LHL
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Policyholders with investment-linked policies, where Liberty holds matching
assets 121 956 111 705
Third parties, where exposure arises on consolidation of mutual funds 13 761 14 503
Shareholder – other credit risk exposure 131 425 130 094
Total assets bearing credit risk1 267 142 256 302
1 Due to practical considerations, credit exposure contained in investments in mutual funds that are classified as "mixed asset classes" is excluded. The
credit exposure in mixed asset class mutual funds would largely relate to policyholders with investment-linked policies and third party investments.
236 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 185 of 278 --
Funding and liquidity risk
Definition
Liquidity risk is defined as the risk that an entity, although
having a solvent statement of financial position, either has
insufficient cash resources to meet payment obligations as
they fall due, or such resources can only be secured at
materially disadvantageous terms.
Approach to managing liquidity risk
The nature of the group’s activities gives rise to continuous
exposure to liquidity risk. Liquidity risk may arise where
counterparties, who provide the group with short-term
funding, withdraw or do not roll over that funding, or normally
liquid assets become illiquid as a result of a generalised
disruption in asset markets.
Our risk management framework supports the measurement
and management of liquidity, in all geographies across all
sectors to ensure that payment obligations can be met by our
legal entities under both normal and stressed conditions within
the group’s risk appetite framework and that regulatory
minimum requirements are always met. This is achieved
through a combination of maintaining adequate liquidity
buffers, to ensure that cash flow requirements can be met, and
ensuring that our balance sheet is structurally sound and
supportive of our strategy. Liquidity risk is managed on a
consistent basis across our banking subsidiaries, allowing for
local requirements. Liquidity risk management ensures that we
have the appropriate amount, diversification and tenor of
funding and liquidity to always support the group’s asset base.
Refer to the Funding and liquidity risk section of the group’s Risk and
capital management report for additional information.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 237
-- 186 of 278 --
Banking
Maturity analysis of financial liabilities by contractual maturity
The following table analyses cash flows on a contractual, undiscounted basis based on the earliest date on which the group can be
required to pay (except for trading liabilities and the majority of derivative liabilities, which are presented as redeemable on demand)
and will, therefore, not agree directly to the balances disclosed in the consolidated statement of financial position.
Derivative liabilities are included in the maturity analysis on a contractual, undiscounted basis when contractual maturities are essential
for an understanding of the derivatives’ future cash flows. Management considers only contractual maturities to be essential for
understanding the future cash flows of derivative liabilities that are designated as hedging instruments in effective hedge accounting
relationships. All other derivative liabilities, together with trading liabilities, are treated as trading and are included at fair value in the
redeemable on demand bucket since these positions are typically held for short periods of time.
The table also includes contractual cash flows with respect to off-balance sheet items. Where cash flows are exchanged simultaneously,
the net amounts have been reflected.
Redeemable
on demand
Rm
Maturing
within
one month
Rm
Maturing
between
one to six
months
Rm
Maturing
between
six to
twelve
months
Rm
Maturing
between
one to five
years1
Maturing
greater
than five
years1
Total
Rm
2023
Financial liabilities
Derivative financial liabilities 90 305 32 70 59 20 90 486
Instruments settled on a net basis 78 087 32 70 59 20 78 268
Instruments settled on a gross
basis 12 218 12 218
Trading liabilities 95 766 95 766
Deposits and debt funding 1 306 175 133 441 235 423 129 866 181 621 60 083 2 046 609
Subordinated debt 247 8 727 441 17 777 27 192
Other 6 236 19 857 1 018 2 626 2 409 32 146
Total 1 498 482 133 720 264 077 131 384 202 044 62 492 2 292 199
Unrecognised financial liabilities
Letters of credit and bankers’
acceptances 26 990 26 990
Guarantees 95 730 95 730
Irrevocable unutilised facilities 105 265 105 265
Total 227 985 227 985
20221
Financial liabilities
Derivative financial liabilities 73 691 19 (34) (130) (40) 73 506
Instruments settled on a net basis 48 544 19 (34) (130) (40) 48 359
Instruments settled on a gross
basis 25 147 25 147
Trading liabilities 110 002 110 002
Deposits and debt funding 1 211 166 131 175 213 723 149 605 212 521 46 073 1 964 263
Subordinated debt 57 3 982 3 028 23 247 30 314
Other 2 504 14 528 1 433 3 512 5 991 27 968
Total 1 397 363 145 779 217 671 153 936 239 240 52 064 2 206 053
Unrecognised financial liabilities
Letters of credit and bankers’
acceptances 19 378 19 378
Guarantees 103 061 103 061
Irrevocable unutilised facilities 104 782 104 782
Total 227 221 227 221
1 Restated. Maturity greater than 12 months has been disaggregated for better analysis of the maturity of financial liabilities.
238 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 187 of 278 --
Insurance & Asset Management
Maturity analysis of non-insurance financial liabilities by contractual maturity
The table below summarises the maturity profile of the financial instrument liabilities of the group based on the remaining undiscounted
contractual obligations. These figures will be higher than amounts disclosed in the statement of financial position (where the effect of
discounting is taken into account) except for short duration liability.
Zero - three
months1
Rm
Three to
twelve
months
Rm
One to five
years
Rm
Five to ten
years
Rm
Variable2
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Subordinated debt 145 1 456 4 792 6 393
Commercial paper 1 603 1 603
Preference shares related to SBG
bancassurance agreement 2 088 5 2 093
Loan facilities 913 1 764 2 677
Financial liabilities under investment
contracts 146 741 1 341 3 407 147 151 636
Third-party financial liabilities
arising on consolidation of mutual
funds 69 717 69 717
Lease liabilities 24 68 299 391
Repurchase agreements liabilities 2 996 2 996
Collateral deposits payable 3 216 3 216
Other payables 6 952 156 4 7 112
Total 233 482 3 934 10 266 147 5 247 834
2022
Subordinated debt 1 029 343 6 393 7 765
Commercial paper 956 956
Preference shares related to SBG
bancassurance agreement3 2 788 5 2 793
Loan facilities 838 1 739 2 577
Financial liabilities under investment
contracts3 133 185 410 3 022 107 136 724
Third-party financial liabilities
arising on consolidation of mutual
funds 62 058 62 058
Lease liabilities 26 73 329 3 431
Repurchase agreements liabilities 5 140 5 140
Collateral deposits payable 2 891 2 891
Other payables3
6 260 102 13 6 375
Total 214 333 1 766 11 496 110 5 227 710
1 0 – 3 months are either due within the time frame or are payable on demand.
2 The amount shown under ʻVariable’ has no fixed maturity date. However, this instrument is redeemable with a two year notice period at the option of the company or
the holder.
3 Restated. Refer to page 31 to 39 for more details relating to the IFRS 17 transition impact.
The table below breaks down the group’s assets according to time to liquidate. It is worth noting that, in a stressed environment, the
market value of these assets is likely to be negatively affected. Derivative assets are excluded from this table.
FINANCIAL, PROPERTY AND INSURANCE ASSET LIQUIDITY
2023 2022
Restated1
% Rm % Rm
Liquid assets 81 418 365 80 380 740
Medium assets 13 65 478 13 65 561
Illiquid assets 6 30 749 7 30 248
Total 100 514 592 100 476 549
1 IFRS 17 requires all policyholder related cashflows to be included in the measurement of insurance/reinsurance contract assets/liabilities, and consequently certain
items previously included in this table have been reclassified on adoption of IFRS 17.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 239
-- 188 of 278 --
Maturity analysis of insurance financial liabilities by contractual maturity
The table below summarises the maturity profile of the liquidity needs in respect of cash flows required to meet obligations
arising from insurance and investment business.
Undiscounted cash flows are shown and the effect of discounting is taken into account to reconcile to total liabilities.
For investment contracts, insurance contracts measured under the premium allocation approach and for the liability
for incurred claims the cash flows are largely reflected as within one year except in respect of specific liabilities where the
cash flows are modelled for the duration of the claim such as disability income annuities in payment.
Whilst future contract renewals are anticipated in periods beyond one year the approach reflects the short coverage
nature of the underlying business lines.
Life risk
measured under
GMM
Rm
Life risk
measured under
PAA
Rm
Annuities and
guaranteed
investment
plans
Rm
Participating
Rm
Non-life
measured under
PAA
Rm
Reinsurance
contracts held
Rm
Total
Rm
2023
Within one year 1 084 4 036 9 020 21 678 1 492 (2 217) 35 093
One – two years (2 250) 925 6 960 19 366 315 (431) 24 885
Two – three years (1 620) 841 7 717 22 286 55 (249) 29 030
Three – four years (1 493) 777 12 532 31 054 35 (207) 42 698
Four – five years (1 429) 730 14 920 25 927 16 (170) 39 994
Over five years 54 993 7 026 140 130 148 866 27 200 351 242
Effect of discounting cash flows (55 197) (5 853) (128 538) (113 707) (83) (97) (303 475)
Total (5 912) 8 482 62 741 155 470 1 857 (3 171) 219 467
Amount payable on immediate surrender 8 760 482 19 325 156 392 184 959
Insurance
contracts held
Rm
Reinsurance
contracts held
Rm
Total
Rm
2022
Within one year 33 702 (2 470) 31 232
One – two years 24 256 (357) 23 899
Two – three years 25 331 (233) 25 098
Three – four years 35 131 (188) 34 943
Four – five years 35 877 (168) 35 709
Over five years 333 503 (210) 333 293
Effect of discounting cash flows (284 451) 261 (284 190)
Total 203 349 (3 365) 199 984
Amount payable on immediate surrender 203 349 203 349
240 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 241
-- 189 of 278 --
Market risk
Definition
Market risk is the risk of a change in the market value, actual or
effective earnings, or future cash flows of a portfolio of
financial instruments, including commodities, caused by
adverse movements in market variables such as equity, bond
and commodity prices, currency exchange and interest rates,
credit spreads, recovery rates, correlations and implied
volatilities in all of these variables.
The group’s key market risks are:
■ trading book market risk.
■ interest rate in the banking book (IRRBB).
■ equity risk in the banking book.
■ foreign currency risk.
■ own equity-linked transactions.
■ IAM market risk.
Trading book market risk
Definition
Trading book market risk is represented by financial
instruments, including commodities, held in the trading book,
arising out of normal global markets’ trading activity.
Approach to managing market risk in the
trading book
The group’s policy is that all trading activities are undertaken
within the group’s global markets’ operations.
The market risk functions are independent of the group’s
trading operations and are accountable to the relevant legal
entity Asset Liability Committees (ALCOs). ALCOs have a
reporting line into group ALCO, a subcommittee of Group
Leadership Council (GLC).
All value at risk (VaR) and stressed value at risk (SVaR) limits
require prior approval from the respective entity ALCOs. The
market risk functions have the authority to set these limits at a
lower level.
Market risk teams are responsible for identifying, measuring,
managing, monitoring and reporting market risk as outlined in
the market risk governance standard.
Exposures and excesses are monitored and reported daily.
Where breaches in limits and triggers occur, actions are taken
by market risk functions to bring exposures back in line with
approved market risk appetite, with such breaches being
reported to management and entity ALCOs.
VaR and SVaR
The group uses the historical VaR and SVaR approach to
quantify market risk under normal and stressed conditions.
For risk management purposes VaR is based on 251 days of
unweighted recent historical data updated at least monthly, a
holding period of one day and a confidence level of 95%. The
historical VaR results are calculated in four steps:
■ calculate 250 daily market price movements based on 251
days’ historical data. Absolute movements are used for
interest rates and volatility movements; relative for spot,
equities, credit spreads, and commodity prices.
■ calculate hypothetical daily profit or loss for each day using
these daily market price movements.
■ aggregate all hypothetical profits or losses for day one
across all positions, giving daily hypothetical profit or loss,
and then repeat for all other days.
■ VaR is the 95th percentile selected from the 250 days of
daily hypothetical total profit or loss.
Daily losses exceeding the VaR are likely to occur, on average,
13 times in every 250 days.
SVaR uses a similar methodology to VaR, but is based on
251-day period of financial stress which is reviewed quarterly
and assumes a ten-day holding period and a worst-case loss.
The ten-day period is based on the average expected time to
reduce positions. The period of stress for SBG is currently the
2008/2009 financial crisis while, for other markets, more
recent stress periods are used where the group has received
internal model approval, the market risk regulatory capital
requirements are based on VaR and SVaR, both of which use a
confidence level of 99% and a ten-day holding period.
Limitations of historical VaR are acknowledged globally and
include:
■ the use of historical data as a proxy for estimating future
events may not encompass all potential events, particularly
those which are extreme in nature.
■ the use of a one-day holding period assumes that all
positions can be liquidated or the risk offset in one day. This
will usually not fully reflect the market risk arising at times of
severe illiquidity, when a one-day holding period may be
insufficient to liquidate or hedge all positions fully.
■ the use of a 95% confidence level, by definition, does not
take into account losses that might occur beyond this level
of confidence.
VaR is calculated on the basis of exposures outstanding at the
close of business and, therefore, does not necessarily reflect
intra-day exposures. VaR is unlikely to reflect loss potential on
exposures that only arise under significant market
movements.
242 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 190 of 278 --
Trading book portfolio characteristics
VaR for the year under review
Trading book market risk exposures arise mainly from residual exposures from client transactions and limited trading for the group’s
own account. In general, the group’s trading desks have run increased levels of market risk throughout the year for all asset classes when
compared to 2022 aggregate normal VaR and stress VaR with a marginal increase in both levels noted at year end.
TRADING BOOK NORMAL VaR ANALYSIS BY MARKET VARIABLE
Normal VaR
Maximum1
Rm
Minimum1
Rm
Average
Rm
Closing
Rm
2023
Commodities risk 5 1 3 3
Foreign exchange risk 54 18 32 26
Equity position risk 23 7 11 8
Debt securities 78 22 44 24
Diversification benefits2 (29) (20)
Aggregate 109 34 61 41
2022
Commodities risk 4 2 3
Foreign exchange risk 31 10 19 21
Equity position risk 21 8 13 10
Debt securities 54 19 29 27
Diversification benefits2 (26) (22)
Aggregate 62 25 37 39
1 The maximum and minimum VaR figures reported for each market variable do not necessarily occur on the same day. As a result, the aggregate VaR will not equal the
sum of the individual market VaR values, and it is inappropriate to ascribe a diversification effect to VaR when these values may occur on different days.
2 Diversification benefit is the benefit of measuring the VaR of the trading portfolio as a whole, that is, the difference between the sum of the individual VaRs and the
VaR of the whole trading portfolio.
TRADING BOOK SVaR ANALYSIS BY MARKET VARIABLE
SVaR
Maximum1
Rm
Minimum1
Rm
Average
Rm
Closing
Rm
2023
Commodities risk 54 5 24 32
Foreign exchange risk 518 111 303 209
Equity position risk 255 45 112 109
Debt securities 491 171 287 224
Diversification benefits2 — — (278) (281)
Aggregate 788 224 448 293
2022
Commodities risk 40 1 19 25
Foreign exchange risk 543 118 218 188
Equity position risk 224 79 120 100
Debt securities 879 179 355 291
Diversification benefits2 (350) (318)
Aggregate 886 140 362 287
1 The maximum and minimum SVaR figures reported for each market variable do not necessarily occur on the same day. As a result, the aggregate SVaR will not equal
the sum of the individual market VaR values, and it is inappropriate to ascribe a diversification effect to SVaR when these values may occur on different days.
2 Diversification benefit is the benefit of measuring the SVaR of the trading portfolio as a whole, that is, the difference between the sum of the individual SVaRs and the
SVaR of the whole trading portfolio.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 243
-- 191 of 278 --
Approach to managing IRRBB
Banking book-related market risk exposure principally involves managing the potential adverse effect of interest rate movements on
banking book earnings (net interest income and banking book mark-to-market profit or loss) and the economic value of equity.
The group’s approach to managing IRRBB is governed by applicable regulations and is influenced by the competitive environment in
which the group operates. The treasury and capital management team monitors banking book interest rate risk on a monthly basis
operating under the oversight of group ALCO.
Measurement
The analytical techniques used to quantify IRRBB include both earnings and valuation-based measures. The analysis takes into account
embedded optionality such as loan prepayments and accounts where the account behaviour differs from the contractual position.
The results obtained from forward-looking dynamic scenario analyses, as well as Monte Carlo simulations, assist in developing optimal
hedging strategies on a risk-adjusted return basis.
INTEREST RATE SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS1
ZAR2 USD GBP Euro Other Total
2023
Increase in basis points 100 100 100 100 100
Sensitivity of annual net interest income Rm 1 370 1 040 317 47 871 3 645
Decrease in basis points 100 100 100 100 100
Sensitivity of annual net interest income Rm (1 387) (1 226) (289) (57) (932) (3 891)
2022
Increase in basis points 100 100 100 100 100
Sensitivity of annual net interest income Rm 1 745 1 142 450 81 960 4 378
Decrease in basis point 100 100 100 100 100
Sensitivity of annual net interest income Rm (1 783) (1 332) (435) (4) (994) (4 548)
1 Before tax.
2 To provide a consistent disclosure of sensitivities across currencies, the ZAR sensitivity disclosure has been revised from 200 bps to 100 bps. This has resulted in a
decrease in the level of FY22 sensitivity by R1 379 million and R1 454 million under the increasing and decreasing interest rate scenarios, respectively. Furthermore,
the group amended its calculation of interest income on Stage 3 loans and advances for PPB and BCB clients. This has resulted in increased sensitivity of R355 million
in FY22 under the 100 bps increasing and R354 million under the 100 bps decreasing interest rate scenarios. Refer to page 30 for more detail on this restatement.
244 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 192 of 278 --
Equity risk in the banking book
Definition
Equity risk is defined as the risk of loss arising from a decline in the value of an equity or equity-type instrument held on the banking
book, whether caused by deterioration in the underlying operating asset performance, net asset value (NAV), enterprise value of the
issuing entity, or by a decline in the market price of the equity or instrument itself.
Though issuer risk in respect of tradable equity instruments constitutes equity risk, such traded issuer risk is managed under the trading
book market risk framework.
Approach to managing equity risk in the banking book
Equity risk relates to all transactions and investments subject to approval by the group equity risk committee (ERC) in terms of that
committee’s mandate, and includes investments in ordinary equity, debt, quasi-debt and other instruments that are considered to be of
an equity nature.
For the avoidance of doubt, equity risk in the banking book excludes strategic investments in the group’s subsidiaries, associates and
joint ventures deployed in delivering the group’s business and service offerings unless the chief finance & value management officer and
group chief risk officer deem such investments to be subject to the consideration and approval by the group ERC.
MARKET RISK SENSITIVITY OF NON-TRADING EQUITY INVESTMENTS
10%
reduction
in
fair value
Rm
Fair
value
Rm
10%
increase in
fair value
Rm
2023
Equity securities listed and unlisted 2 821 3 134 3 447
Listed 181
Unlisted 2 953
Impact on profit or loss (154) 154
Impact on OCI (159) 159
2022
Equity securities listed and unlisted 2 778 3 087 3 396
Listed 215
Unlisted 2 872
Impact on profit or loss (218) 218
Impact on OCI (91) 91
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 245
-- 193 of 278 --
Foreign currency risk
Definition
The group’s primary non-trading-related exposures to foreign currency risk arise as a result of the translation effect of the group’s net
assets in foreign operations and foreign-denominated financial assets and liabilities.
Approach to managing foreign currency risk
The group foreign currency management committee, a subcommittee of the group capital management committee, manages the risk
according to existing legislation, South African exchange control regulations and accounting parameters. It takes into account naturally
offsetting risk positions and manages the group’s residual risk by means of forward exchange contracts, currency swaps and option
contracts.
Hedging is undertaken in such a way that it does not constrain normal operating activities. In particular, for banking entities outside of
the South African common monetary area, the need for capital to fluctuate with risk-weighted assets is taken into account.
The repositioning of the group’s NAV by currency, which is managed at a group level, is a controlled process based on underlying
economic views and forecasts of the relative strength of currencies, other than foreign operations.
Gains or losses on derivatives that have been designated as either net investment or cash flow hedging relationships in terms of IFRS are
reported directly in OCI, with all other gains and losses on derivatives being reported in profit or loss.
Foreign currency risk sensitivity analysis
The table that follows reflects the expected financial impact, in rand equivalent, resulting from a 10% shock to foreign currency risk
exposures, against ZAR. The sensitivity analysis is based on net open foreign currency exposures arising from foreign-denominated
financial assets and liabilities inclusive of derivative financial instruments, cash balances, and accruals, but excluding net assets in
foreign operations. The sensitivity analysis reflects the sensitivity of profit or loss on the group’s foreign denominated exposures other
than those trading positions for which sensitivity has been included in the trading book VaR analysis.
FOREIGN CURRENCY RISK SENSITIVITY IN ZAR EQUIVALENTS1
USD Euro GBP Other Total
2023
Total net (short)/long position Rm 338 (26) 301 406 1 019
Sensitivity (ZAR depreciation)2 % 10 10 10 10
Impact on profit or loss/equity Rm 34 (3) 30 41 102
2022
Total net long/(short) position Rm (1 382) 50 201 347 (784)
Sensitivity (ZAR depreciation)2 % 10 10 10 10
Impact on profit or loss/equity Rm (138) 5 20 35 (78)
1 Before tax
2 A 10% appreciation in ZAR will have an equal and opposite impact on profit or loss to the amounts disclosed above.
246 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 194 of 278 --
Insurance & Asset Management
Definition
Market risk is the risk of adverse financial impact resulting,
directly or indirectly, from fluctuations in equity prices, interest
rates, foreign currency exchange rates, property values and
inflation as well as any changes in the implied volatility
assumptions associated with these variables.
Ownership and accountability
The group’s market risk standard establishes a set of
governing principles for the identification, measurement,
monitoring, management and reporting of market risk across
group. Therefore, IAM's market risk management policy is
aligned to the principles contained in the group’s market risk
standard.
The asset and liability committee (ALCO), which is a sub-
committee of the IAM global balance sheet management
committee (GBSMC), is charged with ensuring that market risk
remains within approved risk limits. The primary market risk
management activities within
IAM consist of:
■ Assuming outright market risk via activities within the IAM
Shareholder Portfolio.
■ Regular matching of investment performance related
policyholder liabilities with suitable assets; and
■ Hedging explicit, or implicit, guarantees and certain
modelled cash flows within IAM in insurance contract
measurement.
The asset-liability management (ALM) unit within IAM
manages the underlying market risk associated with
investment guarantees, matching asset requirements and
long-dated cashflows within a comprehensive risk
management framework.
The group’s asset managers are responsible for managing
investment asset portfolios and manage investment risks
within their mandates. Oversight of investment performance
risk is provided by the client fund control committee through
the monitoring of asset managers and the setting of
appropriate policyholder fund mandates.
The risk management team provides independent oversight of
the adequacy and effectiveness of market risk management
processes across the group and reports material risks to ALCO
and LRC.
Risk identification, assessment and
measurement
In the case of market risks which arise from an insurance/
investment product, identification and measurement requires
an evaluation of the product’s design, whether it is an existing
product or a new product proposal, to ensure a thorough
understanding of the market risk implications of the product.
Once identified and measured, an assessment of the risk is
performed. Risk assessment classifies the risks into:
■ Market risk exposures which the group wishes to retain as
part of its capital management program. This includes
market risks arising from assets and exposures within the
IAM Shareholder Portfolio; and
■ Market risk exposures which the group does not wish to
retain, but which are an inevitable consequence of other
value adding business activities. Where these risks can be
mitigated (either through improved product design or
through open market hedging activity in the ALM portfolio,
on economically sensible terms), such actions are
implemented. Where this is not possible, limits are placed on
the quantum of the risk that may be taken to ensure that the
business continues to be managed within risk appetite.
Market risk management
The group, through its IAM business unit, offers a range of risk,
savings and investment products. These products result in
market risk exposures due to certain fee revenue being based
on values of investment components, underlying investment
guarantees granted to policyholders that are embedded within
these products, activities of acquiring assets to match benefits
in certain contracts, as well as interest rate risk associated
with long-dated contracted cashflows.
Under IAM's group approved balance sheet management
framework, certain market risk exposures are retained. This is
to broadly deliver regulatory capital coverage ratio stability
whilst limiting earnings volatility.
IFRS 17 insurance contracts and IFRS 9 financial
instruments
The group’s policyholder contracts are, from an accounting
measurement perspective, measured under either IFRS 17 and
IFRS 9 guidance. However, the group does not segregate its
hedging and asset liability matching activities depending on
which IFRS standard applies and manages market exposures
on an aggregate basis across the full financial position,
including all policyholder contracts.
Consequently, insurance finance income or expenses derived
from IFRS 17 measurement application should be analysed
together with IFRS 9 finance income or expense measurement
outcomes for policyholder investment contracts. In addition,
the net financing return will represent the financial outcome of
all shareholder market exposures.
Market exposure
IAM’s market exposures are split between a designated
shareholder portfolio and the exposures managed by the ALM
unit.
IAM’s shareholder portfolio consists of:
■ Net assets, mainly property and cash, held in excess of
assets required to back liabilities (including policyholder
liabilities and IAM listed subordinated debt instruments
issued through an approved debt programme).
■ Retained market risk exposure resulting from unhedged
policyholder liabilities to ensure capital coverage stability
(mostly interest rate risk associated with certain IFRS 17
GMM insurance contracts and a portion of market risk
associated with IFRS 17 participating contracts).
The ALM unit managed exposures consists of:
■ Assets that hedge liabilities, some of which have explicit, or
implicit, guarantees. The assets include equities, debt
instruments and derivatives, that are dynamically
rebalanced to manage the underlying market risk and aimed
at minimising earnings volatility.
■ Illiquid credit assets backing long-term liabilities, which
enables ALM to extract a credit risk margin and illiquidity
premium.
The group elected to apply the risk mitigation option in respect
of exposures hedged in relation to certain participating
contracts measured under the variable fee approach. This is
offset through the fair value adjustments on matching
derivative positions taken.
As mandated, the net exposure to market risk in the ALM unit
is managed close to nil through the IAM hedging programme –
however the ALM is exposed to extreme market volatility.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 247
-- 195 of 278 --
Credit portfolio – Within the ALM unit, commercial debt
instruments are invested in to match policyholder liability cash
flow obligations and manage interest rate risk related to these
cash flows. These commercial debt instruments also generate
a credit margin return to shareholders but introduce credit
risk. Refer to the credit risk section for further information.
In respect of territories within IAM where capital markets are
less developed, the market and credit exposures are managed
at overall balance sheet level through appointed investment
committees. In most territories these committees formulate
investment mandates which are tasked to approved asset
management entities to execute.
Due to the limited investment capital markets in the applicable
jurisdictions outside of South Africa, it is not feasible to utilise
derivative instruments to hedge market risks. Consequently,
these risks are managed through a combination of active asset
liability matching and conservative product constructs and
investment policies. Guaranteed products are kept to a
minimum and only offered where the capabilities to manage
the risks are mature. Liquidity is a key consideration factor in
managing market risk and most assets acquired in
jurisdictions outside of South Africa are sovereign debt
instruments and bank deposits biased towards lower
durations.
Outside of sovereign default risk, credit risk is insignificant,
relative to the overall market and credit risk carried by the
group. Credit risk (outside of sovereign) is largely
concentrated in cash deposits with tier one and two banking
institutions.
Group market sensitivities
Sensitivities indicating the impact of changes in key
assumptions have been prepared by applying stresses at the
financial position date. These sensitivities have been calibrated
to moderately severe (1-in-10 year) stresses. The 1-in-10-year
stresses replace the sensitivities reported in previous years,
which were based on management's judgement of reasonably
likely annual possible changes in respective variables on a
through the economic cycle basis. Each of the presented
sensitivities is applied in isolation with all other assumptions
left unchanged.
Aligned to market exposures being managed through an
overall balance sheet approach that aggregates market
positions and manages these exposures within overall group
risk appetite limits and specific mandates, the sensitivities
disclosed have been applied to all financial instruments
(IFRS 9), insurance contracts (IFRS 17) and investment
properties (IAS 40) where applicable. The sensitivities are
presented in totality including applicable taxation to reflect the
net impact to ordinary shareholder equity.
For long-dated policyholder contracts, the calculation allows
for the change in the fulfilment cash flows (including the risk
adjustment) of the contracts under the stress as well as how
much of this impact adjusts the CSM. This is applicable to
contracts measured under the variable fee approach.
Consistent with the required mechanics of the CSM, the
calculation is performed at a profitability group level and
considers the impact of risk mitigation under market risk
stresses in line with the group's balance sheet management
strategy.
For investment contracts, measured under IFRS 9, the
expected service fees less expenses over the next 12 months
are stressed under each of the applicable stresses. Other than
the impact to the one-year future fees charged, there are no
other significant impacts from the market risk sensitivities as it
is the group’s adopted risk mitigation action to mirror
(i.e. acquire) actual investments that link closely to the
contractually defined referenced assets in the policy. This is
to minimise mismatch risk.
In some cases, for example due to embedded options in
insurance contracts, changes to certain economic
assumptions do not result in linear impacts to policyholder
contract liabilities and ordinary shareholders’ equity.
Sensitivities are therefore generally provided showing both an
increase and decrease in the parameters, where the impacts
may not be symmetrical.
Instantaneous stresses are applied to both liabilities and
assets and their values recalculated due to the change in the
market prices. For interest rate yield curve sensitivities, the
assumptions used in the measurement of policyholder
contract values that are dependent on interest rate curves are
also updated. All the assets held by the group, and not just
assets backing the policyholder contract values, are stressed
to arrive at the expected impact on ordinary shareholders'
equity. Given hedging is typically performed based on net
market risk exposures aggregated across the life insurance
business, it is not practical, and it is not considered relevant or
useful, to disaggregate this information into IFRS 17 defined
reportable groups or any other product segmentation.
The net of reinsurance impacts on shareholder equity and
attributable profit in the table have been presented after
allowing for CSM absorption. Due to the impact of market risks
on reinsurance contracts being immaterial, the table only
shows the net of reinsurance impacts on attributable profit.
The impact on the CSM, increase or (decrease) is also included
in the table to provide additional insights as to the CSM
dynamics and the resultant effective deferral of the impact on
attributable profit to future years.
248 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 196 of 278 --
MARKET SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
2023 2022
Change in
variable1,2
%
Impact on
ordinary
shareholders'
equity and
attributable
profit (net of
reinsurance and
taxation)
Rm
Impact
on CSM (net of
reinsurance and
taxation)
Rm
Impact on
ordinary
shareholders'
equity and
attributable
profit (net of
reinsurance and
taxation)
Rm
Impact
on CSM (net of
reinsurance and
taxation)
Rm
Market assumptions
Interest rate yield curve 12 (742) (12) (805) 55
-12 786 13 449 (61)
Property prices 14 1 590 20 932 41
-14 (1 592) (20) (942) (41)
Equity prices 253 503 409 823 697
-25 (417) (428) (777) (711)
Rand exchange rates 214 727 191 1 007 305
-195 (637) (181) (951) (282)
1 The sensitivities reflect 1-in-10 year stresses.
2 All changes in variables are applied as a relative stress percentage, except for the yield curve stresses which are 1% up or down absolute stresses.
3 Increase in local and global equity prices.
4 Weakening of the rand.
5 Strengthening of the rand.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 249
-- 197 of 278 --
Property market risk
The group is exposed to tenant default, depressed rental markets and vacancies within its investment property portfolio affecting
property values and rental income. The managed diversity of the property portfolio and the existence of multi-tenanted buildings
significantly reduce the exposure to this risk. At 31 December 2023 the proportion of unlet space in the property portfolio was
5.8% (2022: 7.0%).
At 31 December 2022 a portion of IAM’s exposure to property was held in listed shares in Liberty Two Degrees Limited (L2D). To the
extent that policyholders and shareholders were invested in shares, they were exposed to the volatility of the price at which the listed
shares traded.
On 27 July 2023, Liberty Group Limited (LGL) and L2D announced Liberty's intention to buyout the non-controlling shareholders in L2D,
in terms of a scheme of arrangements and subsequently delisting of L2D from the JSE. All scheme conditions were met, with the
required approvals in place which finalised the acquisition of L2D non-controlling units by LGL at R5.55 per unit and resulted in the
termination of the listing of L2D units on the JSE on 14 November 2023. Following the buy-out of non-controlling shareholders in L2D the
group’s property exposure has increased.
Refer to annexure A for further information on the buyout of non-controlling shareholders of L2D.
The group’s direct exposure to property market risk is shown below.
UNOBSERVABLE INPUTS INCLUDED IN VALUATION FOR INVESTMENT PROPERTIES
Rm
Exit cap rate
(%)
Discount rate
(%)
Vacancy rate
(%)
Rental
growth
(%)
Expense
growth
(%)
2023
Office buildings 38 8.5 14.25 1.0 2.0 – 4.75 6.5
Retail – super regional and regional 24 542 7.0 – 7.5 12.0 – 13.25 1.0 - 5.0 4.0 – 6.0 6.5
Retail – other 2 210 8.25 – 8.5 12.5 – 12.75 1.0 – 5.0 2.0 – 5.5 6.5
Hotel 1 531 9.8 14.25
Specialised1 953 8.75 – 10.5 14.25 - 14.75 0.0 - 5.0 6.5
2022
Office buildings 40 8.5 14.0 – 14.25 1.0 1.0 – 8.0 6.0
Retail – super regional and regional 24 046 7.0 – 7.5 12.0 – 13.25 1.5 – 5.0 4.0 – 5.5 6.0
Retail – other 2 147 8.0 – 8.5 12.50 1.0 – 5.0 4.0 – 5.5 6.0
Hotel 1 447 9.75 – 10.0 14.25
Specialised1 945 8.75 – 10.5 14.0 – 14.75 0.0 – 5.0 6.0
1 The vacancy rate indicated in the table above refers to the structural vacancy rate applied over and above that which is already used in the cash flow for existing
vacancies and void periods on expiry of leases.
Inter-relationship between key unobservable inputs and fair value measurements:
The most significant impact on value is an adjustment on metrics whereby the estimated fair value would increase/decrease if:
■ exit capitalisation rate was lower/(higher).
■ discount rate was lower/(higher).
Other inputs that impact the value positively (negatively) but are less significant are:
■ vacancy and rent-free periods were shorter/(longer).
■ expected market rental growth was higher/(lower).
■ expected expense growth was lower/(higher).
250 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 198 of 278 --
Insurance risk
Insurance & Asset Management
Insurance risk arises due to uncertainty regarding the timing
and amount of future cash flows from insurance contracts.
This could be due to variations in mortality, morbidity,
retrenchment, policyholder behaviour or expense experience
in the case of life products, and claims incidence, claim
severity or expense experience in the case of short-term
insurance products. These could have adverse impacts on the
group’s earnings and capital if different from those assumed.
Ownership and accountability
The management and staff in all BUs accepting insurance risk
are responsible for the day-to-day identification, analysis,
pricing, monitoring and management of insurance risk. It is
also management’s responsibility to report any material
insurance risks, risk events and issues identified to senior
management through pre-defined escalation procedures.
The head of the actuarial function and statutory actuaries,
where applicable, and group insurance risk department
provide independent oversight of compliance with the group’s
risk management policies and procedures and the
effectiveness of the group’s insurance risk management
processes.
There are a number of management committees in place
responsible for managing all aspects of insurance risk. These
committees are:
■ IAM group control and risk oversight committee (IROC);
■ IAM group reinsurance, underwriting and claims committee;
■ IAM group product approval committee; and
■ Actuarial control committee.
These committees are sub-committees of the Insurance and
asset management executive committee (IAM exco).
Risk identification, assessment, measurement
and management
Risk management takes place prior to the acceptance of risks
through the product development and pricing processes and
at the point of sale. Risks continue to be managed through the
measurement, monitoring and treatment of risks once the
risks are contracted.
Insurance risk sensitivities
The group’s IAM business’s earnings and available capital are
exposed to insurance risks through its various insurance
operations. Assumptions are made in respect of the insurance
risks in the measurement of insurance contract liabilities.
Sensitivities indicating the impact of changes in key
assumptions related to life insurance risks have been prepared
by applying stresses at the financial position date.
The sensitivities chosen have been calibrated to moderately
severe (1-in-10 year) stresses. The 1-in-10-year stresses
replace the sensitivities reported in previous years, which were
based on management's judgement of reasonably likely annual
possible changes in respective variables on a through the
economic cycle basis. Sensitivities to non-life insurance risks
have not been shown as the impact of 1-in-10 year non-life
stresses on the group’s overall performance is immaterial at
the reporting date.
Comparative stresses have accordingly been restated,
together with a revised format due to the adoption of IFRS 17.
Except where the impact of the sensitivity is not linear, single
direction sensitivities have been supplied. Each of the
presented sensitivities is applied in isolation with all other
assumptions left unchanged.
The sensitivities are applied to contracts measured under IFRS
17 and do not apply to policyholder contracts measured under
IFRS 9.
For long-dated contracts, the impact on the attributable profit
calculation allows for the change in the fulfilment cash flows
(including the risk adjustment) of the contracts under the
stress net of the impact to the applicable CSM. The calculation
differentiates between changes in long-term insurance
assumptions which would be accounted for through the CSM,
as opposed to stressed in-year cash-flows, such as higher
death payments in a mortality epidemic event, which would
flow directly to attributable profit. For short-contract boundary
life business, measured under the PAA, the impacted cash
flows are stressed over the next 12 months. The sensitivities
are applied as a level percentage change in future expectation
in relation to the relevant variable.
The expense sensitivity is limited to directly attributable
expenses used in best estimate cash flow modelling of
insurance contracts and will not include the full recurring
expense base of the business operations.
Separate sensitivities are provided where the stresses are
applied over the contract term, as well as stresses applied only
during the next 12 months.
The gross and net of reinsurance impacts on shareholder
equity and attributable profit in the table have been presented
after allowing for CSM adjustments. The impact on the CSM,
increase or (decrease) is also included in the table to provide
additional insight as to the CSM dynamics and the resultant
effective deferral of the impact on attributable profit to future
years.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 251
-- 199 of 278 --
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS OF RISK VARIABLES
2023 2022
Change in
variable1
%
Impact on ordinary
shareholders' equity and
attributable profit after
taxation
Impact
on CSM (net
of
reinsurance
and
taxation)
Rm
Impact on ordinary
shareholders' equity and
attributable profit after
taxation
Impact
on CSM (net
of
reinsurance
and taxation)
Rm
Gross of
reinsurance
Rm
Net of
reinsurance
Rm
Gross of
reinsurance
Rm
Net of
reinsurance
Rm
Insurance
assumptions
Stress over contract
term
Mortality - insured lives +4.5 (381) (316) (815) (376) (307) (778) — — — — — —
Longevity - annuitants2 +6.5 136 136 (709) 21 21 (587) — — — — — —
Morbidity +10 (487) (344) (873) (497) (339) (898) — — — — — —
Withdrawals +10 (122) (118) (699) (111) (98) (785)
-10 125 118 966 135 118 1 033
Expense per policy +5.5 (137) (137) (306) (143) (143) (309)
Stress the next 12
months only
Mortality - insured lives +10 (557) (448) (5) (508) (404) (19) — — — — — —
Morbidity +19 (423) (301) (1) (423) (295) (4) — — — — — —
Withdrawals +21 (80) (78) (285) (76) (69) (289)
1 The sensitivities reflect 1-in-10 year stresses.
2 Annuitant life expectancy increases i.e. annuitant mortality reduces. Profits are expected under the longevity sensitivity due to the CSM absorption of the stress
impact calculated at locked-in discount rates exceeding the stress impact calculated at current discount rates.
The following table indicates the relative contribution by reportable group to the aggregate of shareholder equity and CSM by sensitivity.
If the impact is not applicable or very low for that reportable group the table has been left blank.
Sensitivity
Reportable Group Mortality Longevity Morbidity Withdrawals Expense per policy
Annuities and GIPs Low Medium-High Low
Life Risk under GMM Medium-High High Medium-High Medium
Life Risk under PAA Medium-High Low-Medium Low Low
Participating contracts Medium Medium
On reportable groups with short-term contract boundaries, particularly PAA contracts, the impact in respect of underwriting, withdrawal
and expenses is lower for a given sum assured as the group is able to review prices in the short term. However, in the longer term, high
retention rates and control of expenses on short-term boundary contracts are important for the continued competitive viability of these
products from a new business perspective.
252 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 200 of 278 --
Insurance exposure by reportable group
The following table provides a measure of insurance exposure by reportable group. Where there is material insurance underwriting risk,
experience ratios have been provided to give an indication of the insurance contracts' performance. The annuities and guaranteed
investment plans reportable group has been split, as the guaranteed investment plan business does not have material underwriting risk
under current market conditions.
Insurance
revenue
Rm
Net of
reinsurance
insurance
revenue1
Rm
South Africa
Net of
reinsurance
insurance
revenue1
Rm
Other African
regions Net
of
reinsurance
insurance
revenue1
Rm
2023
Life risk measured under GMM 10 724 9 094 9 024 70
Life risk measured under PAA 10 414 9 238 8 139 1 099
Life Annuities 5 784 5 784 5 672 112
Non-life risk measured under PAA 5 785 4 943 3 266 1 677
Contracts with material insurance underwriting risk 32 707 29 059 26 101 2 958
Guaranteed investment products 1 370 1 370 1 370 —
Direct participation contracts 4 703 4 703 4 529 174
Other insurance contracts 6 073 6 073 5 899 174
Total insurance contracts 38 780 35 132 32 000 3 132
2022
Life risk measured under GMM 11 288 9 927 9 886 41
Life risk measured under PAA 9 604 8 683 7 775 908
Life Annuities 3 989 3 989 3 924 65
Non-life risk measured under PAA 5 808 5 018 3 051 1 967
Contracts with material insurance underwriting risk 30 689 27 617 24 636 2 981
Guaranteed investment products 1 085 1 085 1 085
Direct participation contracts 3 935 3 935 3 755 180
Other insurance contracts 5 020 5 020 4 840 180
Total insurance contracts 35 709 32 637 29 476 3 161
1 Insurance revenue less "Reinsurance expense before recoveries" as per note "Net income/expense from reinsurance contracts held".
2 Insurance service expense less attributable and amortised costs plus ("Net expense from reinsurance contracts held" less "Reassurance expense before recoveries")
as a ratio of "Net of reinsurance insurance revenue".
3 Insurance service expense plus ("Net expense from reinsurance contracts held" less "Reassurance expense before recoveries") as a ratio of "Net of reinsurance
insurance revenue".
Approach to managing insurance risk
Within insurance product pricing and in the measurement of insurance and reinsurance contracts, assumptions are made on
underwriting, policyholder behaviour and expenses in determining best-estimate cash flows. Risk adjustments are added to the best
estimate liabilities to reflect the level of expected uncertainty in the best estimate assumptions and the required risk adjustment.
For pricing purposes, such risk adjustments are also added to the best estimate liabilities so that the new business value appropriately
reflect the expected value to be generated after allowing for an appropriate level of compensation for the risks that are being borne.
The uncertainty in the insurance assumptions is also reflected in the regulatory capital requirements of the insurance entities.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 253
-- 201 of 278 --
Risk management through product
development, pricing and at the point of sale
The product development and pricing process defines the
terms and conditions on which the risks will be accepted. Once
a policy has been sold, the risk is accepted for the duration of
the contract and the terms and conditions of the policy cannot
be unilaterally changed except where the policy allows for rate
reviews. The product development and approval processes
ensure that:
■ clients' needs and expectations will be met by the product;
■ risks inherent in new products are identified, assessed and
measured and stress tests are performed to enhance
understanding of the inherent risks and appropriateness of
potential mitigating actions;
■ pricing is adequate for the risks undertaken;
■ product design and pricing takes account of all product
features, terms and conditions;
■ reinsurance is used to reduce exposures to some insurance
risks;
■ the controls required to provide the product within risk
appetite are identified and established; and
■ post-implementation reviews are performed to ensure that
intended outcomes are realised and to determine if any
further action is required.
Risk management post-implementation of
products and of in-force policies
The management of insurance risk is effectively the
management of deviations of actual experience from the
assumed experience on which products were priced. The risk
is that these earnings are less than expected due to adverse
actual experience.
Experience investigations are conducted on insurance risks to
ascertain the reason for deviations from assumptions and their
financial impacts. Adjustments to assumptions are made if
considered appropriate to better reflect expected future
experience and are used to inform the product development
and pricing process.
Insurance risk exposure is monitored against any limits set.
Further, insurance risk stresses are assessed and reviewed
against risk appetite and risk target and are included in
processes to access current and future financial conditions.
Mitigating actions are developed for any risks that fall outside
of management’s assessment of risk appetite in order to
reduce the level of risk to within the approved tolerance limits.
Key risk indicators are used to enhance the monitoring and
mitigation of insurance risks and facilitate insurance risk
reporting.
Although risk adjustments, capital requirement and risk
appetite limits are in place in recognition that the actual
experience may differ from expectations, part of ongoing
insurance risk management is implementing controls to help
ensure the actual experience is financially favourably within the
assumptions made.
This ongoing management of insurance risk, once the risk has
been contracted, includes the management of costs; premium
adjustments where permitted and appropriate; management
strategies and training of sales staff to encourage customers
to retain their policies; and appropriate claims management.
The identification of emerging risk and threats to insurance
risks also forms part of this ongoing management.
Feedback from customers is regularly considered to ensure
that sales processes are delivering the right results for
customers, that the contracts remain appropriate for their
needs in the years after sale and that those customers
considering abandoning or surrendering their contracts are
fully informed about the consequences of their choice.
Insurance risks are reported to business area executive
committees and raised to relevant risk committees that
convene quarterly for review and discussion. Major insurance
risks identified are escalated to the relevant board or board-
sub committees. In addition, the IAM actuarial committee
reviews the actuarial methodology and assumptions to
support the IAM risk committee.
As part of the risk management system, own risk and solvency
assessments are performed as reflected in ORSA reporting to
the Prudential Authority.
Underwriting risk
Adverse financial impact caused by future demographic or
claims incidence experience exceeding the expected
experience. Underwriting risks include, among others,
mortality and morbidity risks, longevity risks and non-life
claims incidence and severity insurance risks.
The primary purpose of underwriting is to ensure that an
appropriate premium is charged for each risk and that cover is
not offered to uninsurable risks.
Underwriting risks are risks that are core to the insurance
business. The business continues to monitor and gain insight
from its experience to drive appropriate management actions
in underwriting, claims and pricing and to react timeously to
ensure appropriate risk selection.
The business uses its specialist skills (with assistance from
reinsurers when considered necessary) to enhance risk
selection for the assessment, pricing and management of
these risks to generate favourable shareholder returns. These
risks are diversified by exposure across many different lives,
geographies, and product types and will generally be retained if
they are within risk appetite.
There is a risk that risk selection capabilities fall behind those
of competitors. The business continues to maintain specialist
skills and to actively drive specific risk selection initiatives to
counteract this risk.
The following processes and procedures are in place to
manage underwriting risk:
Pricing
Premium rates are differentiated by factors which have been
determined to have a significant impact on underwriting claim
experience taking into account current market dynamics.
Premium rates and product designs are updated when
required.
Prior to taking on individual risk policies, appropriate
underwriting processes are conducted which influence pricing
on the policy prior to acceptance.
Actual claims experience is monitored regularly so that
deteriorating experience can be timeously identified. Product
pricing and the measurement of insurance contract liabilities
are changed if the deteriorating experience is expected to
continue and cannot be mitigated. Detailed underwriting risk
investigations are conducted at least annually for key
products.
Developing insights to improve risk selection will continue so
as to manage new business experience appropriately within
pricing and long-term expectations where relevant.
254 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 202 of 278 --
Claims management
For mortality, claims are validated against policy terms and
conditions.
For morbidity and retrenchment, experienced claims
assessors determine the merits of the claim in relation to the
policy terms and conditions.
For annuities, claims management ensures that annuitants are
still due payment by verifying that annuitants are still alive. In
the case of income disability annuitants, claim management
ensures the continued eligibility for monthly income and
includes interventions that may result in the full or partial
medical recovery of the claimant. The actual disability
experience is highly dependent on the quality of the claim
assessments.
For non-life claims, experienced claim assessors are used to
assess the validity of claims and claim amounts payable in
relation to the policy terms and conditions.
Reinsurance
Reinsurance is used to reduce underwriting risk exposure to: a
particular line of business; a particular individual; a single
event; and to benefit from the risk management support
services and technical expertise offered by reinsurers. Existing
life reinsurance arrangements include proportional
reinsurance (quota share and surplus type arrangements) on
both a treaty and facultative basis and catastrophe
reinsurance which is renewed annually. Catastrophe
reinsurance excludes certain events such as epidemics,
pandemics and radioactive contamination.
Capital is held for these risks. Within non-life insurance both
proportional and non-proportional arrangements are used with
retention levels and catastrophe cover levels varying by line of
business.
Regular reviews, which consider risk appetite, are conducted
on reinsurance arrangements for new business. On insurance
risks measured under GMM, given that the proportion of
reinsurance is fixed for life at inception of the policy, the overall
reinsurance result is heavily influenced by historic reinsurance
arrangements. Conversely, on insurance risks measured under
PAA where underlying policyholder benefits are typically
annually renewable, reinsurance is annually renewable and the
reinsurance result reflects the performance of recent
arrangements.
Reinsurance credit risk arises where a portion of risk is ceded
to another insurer or reinsurer. The management of
reinsurance credit risk forms part of broader credit risk
management.
Life underwriting risk
Although Covid-19 resulted in significant life underwriting
losses in the short term, such pandemic events are part of the
reason for life insurance with the risk thereof reflected in risk
adjustments and capital calculations. Pricing and underwriting
revisions are regularly made to reflect the latest outlook in
relation to life risks to optimise profitability and maintain
competitiveness.
The following classes of life underwriting are covered:
Mortality risk
Adverse financial impact due to actual mortality
(death) claims being higher than expected
There is a risk that mortality increases in the long-term from a
multitude of factors (e.g. deteriorating health trends,
deteriorating health care, climate-change related excess
deaths, increase frequency of disease). However, to the extent
that the emergence of this risk can be identified early, part of
this risk can be mitigated by revising underwriting and pricing
terms on new business and through exercising the premium
review options available in policy terms and conditions to
mitigate losses on in-force business.
Morbidity risk
Adverse financial impact due to policyholder
health related (disablement and dread disease)
claims being higher than expected
On income disability, lump-sum disability and lump-sum dread
disease benefits, aggregate experience, particularly on long-
term business, has been well within expectation over the last
few years. There are some indications that this aggregate
experience is improving in part as a result of improvements in
risk selection including enhanced underwriting implemented
incrementally since 2015.
Improvements in morbidity experience were observed across
the industry during the pandemic, surmised to be partly as a
result of reduced medical diagnosis of conditions. As a result of
the reduced medical diagnoses, there was a risk of increasing
severities of conditions post-pandemic. However, the impact
of this has been more than offset by the other improving
trends in the experience.
In the event of the risk of long-term morbidity worsening, as in
the case of mortality risk, premiums can be reviewed in line
with policy terms and conditions.
Retrenchment risk
Adverse financial impact due to retrenchment
related claims exceeding expectation
This risk arises from benefits that provide income or premium
waivers on formal retrenchment and on more general loss of
income on some product ranges. The benefit is payable for a
limited fixed period or until re-employment, if earlier. The
exposure to retrenchment business in aggregate is relatively
small.
The aggregate level of retrenchment claims has been quite
volatile over the years given the correlation of retrenchment
levels with the state of the economy. Given the uncertainty of
the economic environment during the pandemic, some
retrenchment benefits were closed to new business. As the
level of uncertainty is deemed to have fallen, some of these
benefits are being reopened on terms such that the risk is
considered within appetite.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 255
-- 203 of 278 --
Longevity risk
Adverse financial impact due to the actual mortality on life annuitants, and actual mortality and recovery on
income disability annuitants in payment, being lower than expected, leading to annuity benefits being
payable for longer than expected
In the longer term, the risk of adverse financial impacts arising from longevity improvements higher than expectations remains. Such
improvements typically arise from better living standards and from medical advances. There is significant uncertainty as to whether the
improvements in life expectancy that have been experienced historically will continue in future, with a general slowing down of
improvements particularly for the last decade in much of the developed world.
The group has shareholding in entities conducting life insurance business as well as non-life insurance business in its Africa Regions
operations, including medical expense cover.
Non-life insurance definitions:
Class of business Definition
Medical expense Cover for personal medical expenses.
Property Cover against loss or damage to property due to fire, explosion, storm, business interruption and
other occurrences customarily included.
Motor Cover for losses arising out of the use of motor vehicles, inclusive of third-party risks but exclusive of
transit risks.
Personal liability Provides indemnity for actual or alleged breaches of professional duty arising out of the insured’s
activities, indemnifies directors and officers of a company against court compensation and legal
defence costs, provides indemnity for the insured against damages consequent to a personal injury
or property damage.
Personal accident and health Provides financial compensation for the insured person sustaining bodily injury, solely and directly
caused by accidental, violent, visible and external means, and which shall within 12 calendar months
result in death, disablement or the incurring of medical expenses.
Other Classes of business not included under those listed above. These include engineering, workmen’s
compensation, marine and aviation, theft, agriculture, bonds, goods in transit and glass.
The following table splits the insurance revenue, net of reinsurance insurance revenue and IFRS 17 related experience ratios for the main
classes of non-life insurance business as reported in the table on page 253 above.
Insurance
revenue
Rm
Net of
reinsurance
insurance
revenue1
Rm
2023
Medical 1 123 982
Property 2 985 2 545
Motor 913 865
Personal liability, accident and health 430 361
Other 334 190
Total 5 785 4 943
2022
Medical 1 409 1 279
Property 2 550 2 300
Motor 890 847
Personal liability, accident and health 521 383
Other 438 208
Total 5 808 5 017
1 Insurance revenue less "Reinsurance expense before recoveries" as per note 33.
256 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 204 of 278 --
Non-life insurance risk strategy
The non-life underwriting strategy seeks diversity to ensure a
balanced portfolio across the above insurance classes, with a
large number of policyholders covered spread over a large
geographical area.
For property classes of business, in areas where there is a
significant geographical concentration risk, this risk is
materially mitigated through the use of reinsurance.
The risks under each insurance contract are the frequency
with which the insured event occurs and the uncertainty of the
amount of the resulting claim. For a pool of insurance
contracts, the principal risks are that the actual claims and
benefit payments exceed the premiums charged for the risks
assumed and that the reserve set aside for policyholders’
liabilities proves to be insufficient.
Within non-life underwriting risk, risk management and
controls are adapted appropriately to each product class of
business. Within each product class of business, the risks
arising are usually considered within the following categories:
Premium risk
Premium risk is the risk of fluctuations in the timing, frequency
and severity of insured events. It includes the risk that
premium provisions turn out to be insufficient to cover claims
or that premium provisions need to be increased.
Premium risk relates to insurance policies to be written or
renewed during the period, and to unexpired risks on existing
policies.
The risk is managed by carefully establishing criteria by which
each potential customer is allocated to the appropriate risk
category, applying the underwriting rules, and by establishing
prices appropriate to each risk category.
Reserving risk
Reserving risk is the risk of fluctuations in the timing and
amount of claim settlements relative to what was expected.
For outstanding claims that have been reported, provisions are
reviewed at least annually by expert assessors. For incurred
claims that have not been reported, provisions are calculated
using appropriate techniques and regulatory prescriptions.
Catastrophic risk
Catastrophic risk is the risk of adverse financial impact due to
a single event or series of extreme or irregular interrelated
events, leading to a significant deviation in actual claims from
the total expected claims.
Significant losses may arise from catastrophic events such as
flood, storm or earthquake damage, as well as large single risk
events. To mitigate this risk, reinsurance is bought across a
diversified panel of reinsurers. Reinsurance provides
protection for individual large claims, accumulations of claims
and catastrophic claims such as hail damage and earthquakes.
Policyholder behaviour risk
Policyholder behaviour risk is the risk that adverse financial
impact is caused by actual policyholders’ behaviour deviating
from expectation.
The primary policyholder behaviour risk is termination risk.
This generally arises when policyholders surrender or lapse
their policies, or discontinue or reduce contributions, at a rate
that is not in line with expectations. This could be due to
regulatory and law changes(including taxation), changes in
economic conditions, changes in policyholders circumstances
and perceptions, policy conditions and practices, selling
practices, advisor behaviour, and competitor behaviour.
Policyholder behaviour risk, in particular surrender and lapse
risk, remains significant with the experience being volatile and
linked in part to the economic cycle. The risk is significant
particularly for life risk measured under GMM and participating
contracts which are valued on longer-term contract
boundaries. However, since it is usually costlier to acquire new
annually renewable business than retaining it, the expected
renewal experience is considered in product pricing as this
affects such business's long-term viability.
The policyholder behaviour risk is managed through frequent
monitoring of experience and actively driving targeted
retention initiatives. Focusing on being customer centric,
including listening to customers to understand the drivers of
the experience, enables appropriate actions to be taken.
An increase in terminations generally gives rise to a loss.
However, with certain products this general principle does not
always apply. For example, for level premium risk products at
certain durations an earnings strain results if actual
terminations are lower than assumed.
Due to the highly intermediated nature of the insurance and
investment markets, experiences, perceptions and behaviour
of financial advisors are key determinants of policyholder
behaviour. The termination experience of each financial
advisor's business is monitored, and appropriate action is
taken when required. In addition, opportunities to switch
to new generation products are periodically made available
to existing policyholders.
The termination experience in the retail investment and non-
affluent life risk segments remains elevated. This is to be
expected under the current poor economic environment with a
historical link between higher terminations and poor economic
conditions having been observed. Long-term termination
assumptions are considered to be an appropriate reflection
of the through-the-economic-cycle terminations expected.
Contrary to the historical economic link, terminations in the
retail affluent life risk customer segment (Lifestyle Protector
product) have remained significantly below pre-Covid-19 levels
in recent years. This is surmised to be as a result of
a combination of factors including industry-wide hardening
of underwriting and pricing through the Covid-19 pandemic,
a reduction of new advisors in the market and an increase in
regulation around replacements likely to have contributed to
a reduced level of policy churn. Although some of these factors
are expected to continue decreasing the impact of
terminations in the long-term, there is a risk that terminations
return to the higher pre-Covid-19 levels.
The group has entered into reinsurance contracts expected
to cover in part the losses incurred under certain catastrophic
termination events (i.e. a severe termination event
that occurs over a period of 12 months) in respect of South
African life insurance termination risk. These arrangements
reduce exposures to catastrophic termination events and are
also for capital management purposes.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 257
-- 205 of 278 --
Expense risk
Expense risk is the risk that adverse financial impact due to the
timing and/or amount of expenses is incurred, differing from
those assumed in the calculation of expected financial
outcomes (i.e. the actual cost per policy differs from that
assumed in the pricing or valuation bases).
Management of expense risk is core to the insurance business.
The expenses expected to be incurred on policies are allowed
for in product pricing. If such expenses are considerably higher
than those of insurers with competing products, the ability to
sell business on a profitable basis will be restricted. This does
not only have capital implications but can also affect the ability
to function as a going concern in the long-term.
Expense risk is managed by:
■ regularly monitoring actual expenses against budgeted
expenses;
■ regularly monitoring new business volumes and mix;
■ regularly monitoring withdrawal rates including lapses; and
■ implementing cost control measures in the event of
expenses exceeding budget or of significant unplanned
reductions in the number of in-force policies.
New business risk
New business risk is the risk of the new business value
deviating from that expected in calculating expected financial
outcomes.
This can arise from actual volume, mix and/or quality of new
business deviating from that expected.
The group’s new business value has been well below long-term
expectations because of lower margins on products sold and
lower than budgeted sales volumes. Although new business
volumes have grown in 2023, the volume of new business on
some key product lines remains below budget expectations.
Various strategic initiatives are in place to address this.
258 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 206 of 278 --
Own equity-linked transactions
Definition
The group has exposure to changes in its share price arising from its equity-linked remuneration contractual commitments.
Depending on the nature of the group’s equity-linked share schemes, the group is exposed to either income statement risk or NAV risk
through equity due to changes in its own share price as follows:
■ Income statement risk arises as a result of losses being recognised in the group’s income statement as a result of increases in the
group’s share price on cash-settled share schemes above the award grant price
■ NAV risk arises as a result of the group settling an equity-linked share incentive scheme at a higher price than the price at which the
share incentive was granted to the group’s employees.
The following table summarises the group’s most material share schemes together with an explanation of which risk (where applicable)
the share scheme exposes the group to, and why, and an indication as to whether the share schemes are hedged.
Share scheme Risk to the group Explanation Hedged1
Hedged
risk
Equity growth
scheme
N/A The EGS is an equity-settled share scheme that
is settled through the issuance of new shares.
Accordingly, the group does not incur any cash
flow in settling the share schemes and hence is
not exposed to any risk as a result of changes in
its own share price.
Since the EGS results in the issuance of new
shares and in order to mitigate the dilutionary
impact on existing shareholders, the group re-
purchases shares from the open market.
No, as there is no
cash flow risk
N/A
Equity-settled
deferred bonus
scheme and
performance
reward plan
NAV risk The DBS and PRP awards that are equity-
settled, are settled through the purchase of
shares from the open market. Accordingly, for
these equity-settled share schemes, increases
in the group’s share price above the grant price
will result in losses being recognised in the
group’s equity.
Yes SBK
share
price
risk
Cash-settled DBS
and PRP
Income statement
risk
The DBS and PRP awards that are cash-settled
result in losses being recognised in the income
statement as a result of increases in the group’s
share price.
Yes SBK
share
price
risk
Share appreciation
rights scheme –
equity settled
NAV risk SARP awards that are issued to individuals in
the employment of a group entity domiciled in
South Africa are classified as equity-settled and
are settled through the purchase of shares from
the open market. Accordingly, changes in the
group’s share price above the grant price will
result in gains and/or losses being recognised
directly in the group’s equity.
No, given the current
low number of
awards that have
been issued to date.
The number of
awards are however
monitored to evaluate
for future hedging
considerations.
N/A
Share appreciation
rights scheme –
cash settled
Income statement
risk
Awards made to individuals of a group entity
outside of South Africa are settled in cash.
Increases in the group’s share price will result in
losses being recognised in the income
statement.
No, given the current
low number of
awards that have
been issued to date.
The number of
awards are however
monitored to evaluate
for future hedging
considerations.
N/A
1 The group partially hedges these exposures.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 259
-- 207 of 278 --
Banking
Capital management
The group manages its capital levels to support business growth, maintain depositor and creditors’ confidence, create value for its
shareholders and ensure regulatory compliance.
The main regulatory requirements to be complied with are those specified in the Banks Act and related regulations, which are aligned
with Basel III.
Regulatory capital adequacy is measured through the following three risk-based ratios:
■ Common equity tier 1 (CET 1): ordinary share capital, share premium, retained earnings, other reserves and qualifying non-controlling
interest less impairments divided by total risk-weighted assets (RWA).
■ Tier 1: CET 1 and other qualifying non-controlling interest plus perpetual, non-cumulative instruments with either contractual or
statutory principal loss absorption features that comply with the Basel III rules divided by total RWA.
■ Total capital adequacy: Tier 1 plus other items such as general credit impairments and subordinated debt with either contractual or
statutory principal loss absorption features that comply with the Basel III rules divided by total RWA. Subordinated debt that complies
Basel III rules is included in total capital.
BASEL III QUALIFYING CAPITAL EXCLUDING UNAPPROPRIATED PROFITS
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Ordinary shareholders’ equity# 236 445 218 197
Qualifying non-controlling interest# 7 144 9 086
Less: regulatory adjustments (22 783) (26 634)
Goodwill (1 609) (2 258)
Other intangible assets (8 914) (10 916)
Investments in financial entities (11 354) (12 144)
Other adjustments (906) (1 316)
Total common equity tier 1 capital (including unappropriated profit) 220 806 200 649
Unappropriated profit (19 738) (18 477)
Common equity tier 1 capital 201 068 182 172
Qualifying other equity instruments# 18 661 14 098
Qualifying non-controlling interests 1 092 1 284
Tier 1 capital 220 821 197 555
Qualifying tier II subordinated debt# 25 682 24 594
General allowance for credit impairments 7 144 6 339
Tier II capital 32 826 30 933
Total regulatory capital 253 647 228 487
The table above is unaudited, except where it is denoted with #.
260 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure C – IFRS risk and capital management disclosures continued
-- 208 of 278 --
Insurance & Asset Management
The capital management strategy is designed to ensure that the group remains within risk appetite with sufficient capital to meet
strategic initiatives, as well as regulatory and working capital requirements. The allocation and use of capital are designed to generate a
return that appropriately compensates the shareholder for the risks incurred. Capital is deployed to each legal entity within the group
such that the available capital exceeds its applicable regulatory capital requirement. Appropriate buffers allow the group to be managed
within its risk appetite.
Available capital is the amount by which the value of the assets exceeds the value of liabilities, both measured on the prescribed basis.
The group ensures that available capital is of suitable quality and is accessible when required, both at an LGL and LHL group level. The
capital buffer is the amount by which available capital exceeds the solvency capital requirement, measured at an individual legal entity
level. As a whole, the group holds a further capital buffer which is managed to support risk target levels, strategic initiative requirements
and the dividend policy of the group. Similarly, individual entities, most notably insurance subsidiaries, maintain buffers in order to
ensure their individual compliance to local regulatory requirements.
Solvency capital requirement coverage1
The following table summarises the available capital (or “own funds”) and the solvency capital requirements
2023 2022
Available capital (or own funds) (Rm) 32 955 32 458
SCR (Rm) 17 760 18 077
SCR coverage ratio (times) 1.86 1.80
Target SCR coverage ratio (times) 1.0 - 2.0 1.0 - 2.0
1 The solvency capital requirement coverage has been disclosed to provide a better analysis of the capital management of IAM entities.
Solvency Capital Requirement (SCR) coverage ratio remains strong at 1.86 times, which is above the revised target range of 1.0 to 2.0
times. The SCR ratio improved because of positive operating and investment earnings and lower equity symmetric adjustments across
all equity classes. These improvements were partially offset by the impacts of credit downgrades, basis changes and an acceleration of
profit share allocations to Standard Bank under bancassurance and other agreements.
Sensitivity analysis on available capital1
The following table provides a sensitivity analysis of IAM’s SCR to various market risk factors. Each sensitivity is applied in isolation with
all other assumptions left unchanged. Sensitivities have been chose to align with the IFRS market risk sensitivities and consequently the
2022 comparatives have been restated to align to the updated sensitivities.
2023 2022
SCR coverage ratio (times)
Base SCR coverage ratio (times) 1.81 - 2.70 1.76 - 2.30
Local listed equity down 25% 1.82 - 2.69 1.75 - 2.28
Rand appreciates by 19% 1.80 - 2.67 1.72 -2.30
Unlisted property down 14% 1.72 - 2.70 1.73 -2.30
Parallel reduction of yield curve by 100 basis points 1.83 - 2.71 1.74 - 2.30
1 The sensitivity analysis has been disclosed to provide a better analysis of the capital management of IAM.
These sensitivities illustrate the stability of IAM's coverage ratio under various market risks. African region insurers are in compliance
with the requirements of their local regulators.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 261
-- 209 of 278 --
Share-based payments
The group’s share incentive schemes enable key management personnel and senior employees to benefit from the performance of the
group and group companies’ share price. For further detail regarding the share schemes refer to the group’s governance and
remuneration report.
2023
Rm
2022
Rm
Expenses recognised in staff cost
Share Appreciation Rights Scheme 60 47
Deferred Bonus Scheme 1 731 1 373
Performance Reward Plan 2 021 728
Cash-Settled Deferred Bonus Scheme 682 445
Liberty Share Incentive Scheme 115 39
Total expenses recognised in staff costs 4 609 2 632
Summary of liabilities recognised in other liabilities
Share Appreciation Rights Scheme 25 10
Deferred Bonus Scheme 22 23
Performance Reward Plan 270 115
Cash-Settled Deferred Bonus Scheme 531 408
Total liability recognised in other liabilities 848 556
Equity Growth Scheme
The EGS is an equity-settled scheme and represents appreciation rights allocated to employees. The converted value of the rights is
effectively settled by issue of shares equivalent to the value of the rights. The scheme has five different subtypes of vesting categories as
illustrated by the table below:
Vesting categories Year % vesting Expiry (Years)
Type A 3,4,5 50,75,100 Ten years
Type B 5,6,7 50,75,100 Ten years
Type C 2,3,4 50,75,100 Ten years
Type D 2,3,4 33,67,100 Ten years
Type E 3,4,5 33,67,100 Ten years
A reconciliation of the movement of share options is detailed below:
Number of rights Average price
range (R)
2023 2023 2022
Movement summary
Rights outstanding at beginning of the year 2 594 941 3 796 352
Exercised (993 747) (1 187 348) 96.68 - 156.96
Lapsed/forfeited (13 785) (14 063) 98.80 - 111.94
Rights outstanding at the end of the year 1 587 409 2 594 941
During 2023, 221 284 (2022: 295 194) SBG shares were issued to settle the appreciated rights value. At the end of the year, the group
would need to issue 529 364 (2022: 1 145 865) SBG shares to settle the outstanding appreciated rights value. The EGS rights are only
awarded to individuals in the employment of a group entity domiciled in South Africa.
The group is required to ensure that employees’ tax arising from benefits due in terms of the scheme is paid in accordance with the
Fourth Schedule of the Income Tax Act of South Africa. Where employees have elected not to fund the tax from their own resources
the tax due is treated as a diminution of the gross benefits due under the scheme. No SBG shares were issued and sold to settle the
employees’ tax due for both 2023 and 2022. This reduces the liability to the employee in respect of the outstanding appreciated
rights value. Share options were exercised regularly throughout the year. The weighted average share price for the year was
R177.59 (2022: R161.11).
262 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
ANNEXURE D – GROUP SHARE INCENTIVE
SCHEMES
-- 210 of 278 --
The following rights granted to employees, including executive directors, had not been exercised at year end:
2023 2022
Option expiry period
Number
of ordinary
shares
Option price
range
(rand)
Weighted
average
price (rand)
Number
of ordinary
shares
Option price
range
(rand)
Weighted
average
price (rand)
Year to 31 December 2023 15 292 62.39- 98.80 98.20 648 998 96.68 - 115.51 100.18
Year to 31 December 2024 97 000 126.87 126.87 320 953 126.87 126.87
Year to 31 December 2025 738 943 156.96 156.96 876 706 156.96 156.96
Year to 31 December 2026 736 174 122.24 122.24 748 284 122.24 122.24
Total 1 587 409 2 594 941
Shares Appreciation Rights Scheme
The SARP is a long-term scheme and represents appreciation rights awarded to employees and is based on the SBG’s share price.
Awards that are issued to individuals in the employment of a group entity domiciled in South Africa are classified as equity-settled and
awards made to individuals of a group entity outside of South Africa are classified as cash-settled. The SARP has replaced the EGS and
hence no further EGS awards will be granted. Share rights were last granted in 2016 under the equity growth scheme. Vesting and expiry
of the rights are as follows:
Year % vesting Expiry
Vesting Category 2,3,4 33,67,100 4,5,6
The converted value of the rights is settled either by purchasing shares for equity-settled awards on an external market and in cash for
cash-settled awards equal to the value of the converted rights.
A reconciliation of the movement of share options is detailed below:
2023 2022
Average
price range
(rand)
Number
of rights
Average
price range
(rand)
Number
of rights
Rights outstanding at the end of the year 6 288 219 4 423 879
Granted1 179.82 1 594 939 160.33 2 106 874
Exercised (1 217 862) (207 826)
Lapsed/forfeited (292 340) (34 708)
Rights outstanding at the end of the year 6 372 956 6 288 219
Outstanding equity-settled units 5 531 174 5 577 273
Outstanding cash-settled units 841 782 710 946
1 Includes 1 271 387 (2022: 1 822 128) units that are equity-settled, the balance will be cash-settled.
During the current year the group purchased 71 844 (2022 : nil) Standard Bank Group shares from the market to settle the appreciated
rights value.
At the end of the year the group would need to purchase 1 169 525 (2022: 777 840) SBG shares to settle the outstanding appreciated
rights value.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 263
-- 211 of 278 --
The following rights granted to employees, including executive directors, had not been exercised as at 31 December 2023:
Option expiry period
2023 2022
Number
of rights
Option price
range
(rand)
Weighted
average
price
(rand)
Number
of rights
Option price
range
(rand)
Weighted
average
price
(rand)
Year to 31 December 2023 9 440 155.95 155.95 2 464 172 110.00 - 220.97 189.08
Year to 31 December 2024 854 791 152.64-220.97 211.71 182 935 152.64 152.64
Year to 31 December 2025 1 080 655 142.00-182.43 172.36 590 502 142.00-152.64 145.92
Year to 31 December 2026 1 258 743 142.00-160.33 153.78 1 273 050 142.00-160.33 153.77
Year to 31 December 2027 1 532 322 142.00-179.82 161.94 1 075 233 142.00-160.33 153.97
Year to 31 December 2028 1 165 545 160.33-179.82 168.21 702 327 160.33 160.33
Year to 31 December 2029 471 460 179.82 179.82
Total 6 372 956 6 288 219
The share appreciation rights granted during the year were valued using a binomial option pricing model. Expected volatility is
determined using historical SBK share price data available and applied over the expected life of the grant. Each grant was valued
separately. The weighted fair value of the options granted per vesting date and the assumptions utilised are as follows:
2023 2022
Tranche 1 Tranche 2 Tranche 3 Tranche 1 Tranche 2 Tranche 3
Number of appreciation rights granted 531 611 531 648 531 680 702 256 702 291 702 327
Weighted average fair value at grant date (rands) 35.88 37.29 37.94 34.26 36.86 39.42
The principal inputs are as follows:
Weighted average share price (rand) 179.82 179.82 179.82 161.11 161.11 161.11
Weighted average exercise price (rand) 179.82 179.82 179.82 161.11 161.11 161.11
Expected life (years) 4.00 5.00 6.00 4.00 5.00 6.00
Expected volatility (%) 33.76 33.76 33.76 34.82 34.82 34.82
Risk-free interest rate (%) 7.69 7.83 8.07 7.89 8.07 8.32
Dividend yield (%) 7.24 7.50 7.66 7.42 7.72 7.89
Deferred Bonus Scheme
All employees granted an annual performance award over a threshold have part of their award deferred. The awards are indexed to the
group’s share price and accrue notional dividends during the vesting period, which are payable on vesting. Awards vest in three equal
amounts at 18 months, 30 months and 42 months from the date of award. The final payout is determined with reference to the group’s
share price on vesting date. Cash settled awards have been partially hedged through the use of equity forwards.
Awards that are issued to individuals in employment of a group entity domiciled in South Africa are classified as equity-settled and
awards that are made to individuals of a group entity outside of South Africa are classified as cash-settled.
Units
2023 2022
Movement summary
Units outstanding at beginning of the year 16 071 882 14 287 945
Units granted during the year1 10 406 776 10 880 490
Exercised (8 315 423) (7 268 367)
Lapsed/forfeited (617 489) (1 828 186)
Units outstanding at end of the year 17 545 746 16 071 882
Outstanding equity-settled units 17 338 695 15 717 571
Outstanding cash-settled units 207 051 354 311
Weighted average fair value at grant date (R) 167.49 153.15
Expected life (years) 2.51 2.51
1 Includes 10 243 715 (2022: 10 197 939) units that are equity-settled, the balance relates to cash-settled rewards.
264 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure D – Group share incentive schemes continued
-- 212 of 278 --
Performance Reward Plan
The PRP is a performance-driven share plan which rewards value delivered against specific targets. The PRP incentivises a group of
senior executives to meet the strategic long-term objectives that deliver value to shareholders, to align the interests of those executives
with those of shareholders and to act as an attraction and retention mechanism in a highly competitive marketplace for skills. The PRP
operates alongside the existing conditional, equity-settled long-term plans, namely the EGS, DBS, and other share incentive schemes.
The awards are indexed to the group’s share price and accrues notional dividends during the vesting period, which are payable on
vesting. Shares that vest (if any), and that are delivered to the employee, are conditional on the pre-specified performance metrics, set
annually by the SBG remuneration committee (refer to the group’s remuneration report for further information). These awards have
been partially hedged through the use of equity forwards.
Awards that are issued to individuals in employment of a group entity domiciled in South Africa are classified as equity-settled and
awards made to individuals of a group entity outside of South Africa are classified as cash-settled.
Units
2023 2022
Movement summary
Units outstanding at beginning of the year 13 406 616 10 457 252
Units granted during the year1 4 306 095 6 033 704
Exercised (4 379 665)
Performance condition uplift/(lapsed) 2 857 770 (2 649 192)
Lapsed/forfeited (2 476 543) (435 148)
Units outstanding at the end of the year 13 714 273 13 406 616
Outstanding equity-settled units 12 115 876 12 046 496
Outstanding cash-settled units 1 598 397 1 360 120
Weighted average fair value at grant date (R) 156.70 151.19
Expected life (years) 3.07 3.07
1 Includes 3 785 840 (2022: 5 479 703) units that are equity-settled, the balance relates to cash-settled rewards.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 265
-- 213 of 278 --
Cash-Settled Deferred Bonus Scheme
Effective for awards made in 2017, employees granted an annual performance award over a threshold and who are in employment of the
group and meet other specific criteria have part of their award deferred.
Awards in rand are indexed to SBG’s share price and accrues notional dividends during the vesting period, which are payable on vesting.
Awards vest in three equal amounts at 18, 30 and 42 months from the date of the award. The maturity value is determined with
reference to the SBG share price on the vesting date. These awards are classified as cash-settled from a group perspective. Awards in
currencies other than rand (being the employee’s host country) are denominated in that currency with the same terms as rand-
denominated awards with the value of the awards, in foreign currency, moving in parallel with changes in the SBG share price. These
awards have been partially hedged through the use of equity forwards.
Currency
Weighted
average fair
value at
grant date
Expected life
at grant date
(years)
2023 2022
Opening
balance Granted Exercised Lapsed Outstanding
Opening
balance Granted Exercised Lapsed Outstanding
AOA 179.82 2.51 2 518 607 2 057 257 (1 124 070) 3 451 794 1 500 751 1 712 046 (679 867) (14 323) 2 518 607
AED 179.82 2.51 24 451 11 698 (11 940) 24 209 17 640 14 053 (7 242) 24 451
BWP 179.82 2.51 49 494 38 926 (33 744) 5 549 60 225 73 226 27 345 (34 173) (16 904) 49 494
CDF 179.82 2.51 128 954 (33 734) (48 355) 46 865 47 400 98 693 (17 139) 128 954
CNY 179.82 2.51 97 327 41 560 (55 556) (3 523) 79 808 93 483 48 772 (44 928) 97 327
EUR 17 (17)
GBP 179.82 2.51 79 643 46 864 (47 804) 5 947 84 650 79 027 44 400 (37 561) (6 223) 79 643
GHS 179.82 2.51 51 973 1 465 (19 926) (9 355) 24 157 28 150 37 898 (13 816) (259) 51 973
HKD 6 266 (6 266)
KES 179.82 2.51 950 327 553 650 (446 087) 173 188 1 231 078 822 898 685 414 (373 810) (184 175) 950 327
LSL 179.82 2.51 11 546 3 841 (3 687) (4 535) 7 165 4 535 5 382 (2 906) 4 535 11 546
MUR 179.82 2.51 54 769 127 974 (27 926) (58 328) 96 489 53 517 28 926 (27 674) 54 769
MWK 179.82 2.51 1 540 936 1 760 519 (632 176) 89 537 2 758 816 651 030 1 322 657 (393 197) (39 554) 1 540 936
MZN 179.82 2.51 249 476 120 396 (93 511) (14 173) 262 188 364 230 159 567 (88 919) (185 402) 249 476
NAD 179.82 2.51 38 303 15 163 (18 954) (5 658) 28 854 51 995 18 966 (32 658) 38 303
NGN 179.82 2.51 14 987 299 9 077 409 (6 683 229) (1 014 046) 16 367 433 12 076 901 8 792 185 (5 746 891) (134 896) 14 987 299
SSP 179.82 2.51 7 821 (7 821) 22 303 (14 482) 7 821
SZL 179.82 2.51 50 014 43 433 (19 258) (4 687) 69 502 24 652 35 061 (9 699) 50 014
TZS 179.82 2.51 1 520 427 3 986 411 (756 570) (1 992 570) 2 757 698 1 412 025 707 522 (538 997) (60 123) 1 520 427
UGX 179.82 2.51 28 253 134 26 745 486 (19 601 090) (988 814) 34 408 716 28 016 319 19 930 815 (13 110 731) (6 583 269) 28 253 134
USD 179.82 2.51 25 292 17 345 (20 163) 4 147 26 621 30 974 16 274 (16 612) (5 344) 25 292
XOF 179.82 2.51 915 276 472 291 (491 806) 50 648 946 409 746 227 478 487 (309 438) 915 276
ZAR 179.82 2.51 1 279 458 734 855 (730 621) 15 626 1 299 318 1 225 080 705 281 (591 717) (59 186) 1 279 458
ZMW 179.82 2.51 71 010 59 415 (28 817) (6 738) 94 870 38 253 51 822 (18 650) (415) 71 010
ZWL 179.82 2.51 36 609 (36 609) 84 953 40 700 (328) (88 716) 36 609
Other share schemes
Scheme Description Classification Stock symbol
2022
Outstanding
units
Group share
incentive
scheme (GSIS)
GSIS conferred rights to employees to acquire shares at the
value of the SBG share price at the date the option was
granted. The scheme had various vesting periods, and
expired ten years after grant date. GSIS awards are no
longer issued (2022: 59 645).
Equity-settled
scheme
SBK 98 250
266 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure D – Group share incentive schemes continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 267
-- 214 of 278 --
Executive directors’ and prescribed officers’ emoluments
SK Tshabalala A Daehnke
2023
R’000
2022
R’000
2023
R’000
2022
R’000
Fixed remuneration 11 670 10 558 8 483 7 000
Salary 9 979 9 041 7 481 6 171
Employer retirement contributions 1 443 1 295 918 767
Other benefits and allowances 248 222 84 62
Short-term Incentive 24 000 19 300 22 000 18 200
Cash incentive1 10 800 8 650 9 900 8 200
Deferred incentive2 13 200 10 650 12 100 10 000
Total remuneration (excluding long-term incentive) 35 670 29 858 30 483 25 200
PRP award vesting3 41 620 22 882 32 830 16 506
Notional dividend on PRP award vesting4 6 014 2 954 4 744 2 131
Total remuneration (including long-term incentive awards) 83 304 55 694 68 057 43 837
AKL Fihla FZ Montjane
2023
R’000
2022
R’000
2023
R’000
2022
R’000
Fixed remuneration 8 790 7 929 7 921 7 370
Salary 7 342 6 875 7 213 6 696
Employer retirement contributions 972 896 552 514
Other benefits and allowances 476 158 156 160
Short-term Incentive 28 875 25 000 22 000 16 800
Cash incentive1 12 987 11 250 9 900 7 550
Deferred incentive2 15 888 13 750 12 100 9 250
Total remuneration (excluding long-term incentive) 37 665 32 929 29 921 24 170
PRP award vesting3 28 168 15 332 25 804 12 375
Notional dividend on PRP award vesting4 4 070 1 979 3 729 1 597
Total remuneration (including long-term incentive awards) 69 903 50 240 59 454 38 142
M Nienaber B Blackie
2023
R’000
2022
R’000
2023
R’000
2022
R’000
Fixed remuneration 8 264 7 351 7 916 7 016
Salary 6 697 6 371 7 135 6 321
Employer retirement contributions 808 722 708 627
Other benefits and allowances 759 258 73 68
Short-term Incentive 22 000 20 000 22 000 17 700
Cash incentive1 9 900 9 000 9 900 7 950
Deferred incentive2 12 100 11 000 12 100 9 750
Total remuneration (excluding long-term incentive) 30 264 27 351 29 916 24 716
PRP award vesting3 25 804 14 430 14 084 8 264
Notional dividend on PRP award vesting4 3 729 1 863 2 035 1 067
Total remuneration (including long-term incentive awards) 59 797 43 644 46 035 34 047
268 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
ANNEXURE E – EMOLUMENTS AND SHARE
INCENTIVES OF DIRECTORS AND
PRESCRIBED OFFICERS
-- 215 of 278 --
Y Maharaj6 DC Munro7
2023
R’000
2023
R’000
2022
R’000
Fixed remuneration 5 404 12 784 7 474
Salary 4 693 2 039 6 601
Employer retirement contributions 629 183 589
Other benefits and allowances 82 10 562 284
Short-term Incentive 8 044 20 000
Cash incentive1 4 218 9 000
Deferred incentive2 3 826 11 000
Total remuneration (excluding long-term incentive) 13 448 12 784 27 474
PRP award vesting3 4 674 12 810
Notional dividend on PRP award vesting4 675 1 851
Liberty Equity Growth Scheme (EGS) award5 6 260 12 306
Total reward (including long-term incentive awards) 25 057 39 751 27 474
1 Performance related short-term incentives payable in cash in March following the financial year under review.
2 Performance related deferred incentive awards issued in March following the financial year under review. These awards are unitised in in terms of the Deferred Bonus
Scheme (DBS) and Cash Settled Deferred Bonus Scheme (CS DBS) using the group's closing share price on the day results are announced.
3 PRP units vesting in March 2024 (disclosed for the performance year 2023) were awarded in March 2021. The value delivered is calculated using the group's closing
share price of R208.10 at 31 December 2023 and the vesting percentage of 160% based on the achievement of performance conditions measured over the three-year
performance period ending 31 December 2023. The value shown under 2022 relates to the March 2020 PRP award which vested in March 2023 at a vesting
percentage of 125%.
4 The PRP notional dividend is calculated by multiplying the units vesting by the cumulative notional dividend accrued over the period between the award date and the
vesting date.
5 As part of the acquisition of the minority shareholding in Liberty Holdings Limited in 2022, Y Maharaj retained his historic Liberty EGS awards granted by the Liberty
Remco in 2020. The performance period ended on 6 November 2023 and half of the award vested on this date. The balance will vest equally in November 2024 and
2025 if the employment condition is met.
6 Y Maharaj was appointed as a prescribed officer on 12 May 2023 and his remuneration is shown from this date.
7 DC Munro was a prescribed officer from 11 March 2022 until he left the group on 31 March 2023 and his disclosed remuneration relates to this period. Included in DC
Munro's other benefits and allowances amount is a statutory payment of R10,5m due to him on his exit.
STANDARD BANK GROUP Annual financial statements 2023 269
-- 216 of 278 --
Non-executive directors
Fixed remuneration
Services as
directors of
Standard
Bank Group
R’000
Standard
Bank Group
committee fees
R’000
Services
as directors
of group
subsidiaries
R’000
Total
compensation
for the year
R’000
2023
LL Bam1 318 1 086 318 1 722
PLH Cook 318 811 318 1 447
GJ Fraser-Moleketi2 318 1 135 318 1 771
Xueqing Guan 1 268 775 1 268 3 311
GMB Kennealy 318 2 177 318 2 813
BJ Kruger3 318 1 900 1 264 3 482
Li Li 318 318 636
JH Maree4 318 1 708 318 2 344
NNA Matyumza 318 1 197 318 1 833
N Nyembezi5 7 619 7 619
ML Oduor-Otieno 1 268 819 1 268 3 355
ANA Peterside CON6 1 268 827 1 268 3 363
Total 13 967 12 435 7 294 33 696
2022
LL Bam1 50 50 100
PLH Cook 299 466 299 1 064
GJ Fraser-Moleketi2 299 798 299 1 396
Xueqing Guan 1 073 703 1 073 2 849
GMB Kennealy 299 2 138 299 2 736
BJ Kruger3 174 437 2 016 2 627
L Li 299 299 598
JH Maree4 299 1 578 825 2 702
NNA Matyumza 299 1 102 299 1 700
N Nyembezi5 4 103 359 125 4 587
ML Oduor-Otieno 1 073 585 1 073 2 731
ANA Peterside CON6 1 073 902 1 073 3 048
Total 9 340 9 068 7 730 26 138
1 LL Bam was appointed to the SBG and SBSA boards on 1 November 2022 and to board committees on 8 March 2023.
2 GJ Fraser-Molekti was appointed as chairman of SBG Social, Ethics and Sustainability committee on 1 January 2023.
3 BJ Kruger was appointed to the SBG and SBSA boards on 6 June 2022 and board committees on 18 August 2022. He was appointed as chairman of the SBG and
SBSA Risk and Capital Management committee and the SBG and SBSA Large Exposure Credit Committee on 1 January 2023. BJ Kruger's fees for services as a
director of group subsidiaries includes fees paid by Stanbic IBTC Holdings. He resigned from Stanbic IBTC Holdings on 30 June 2023.
4 JH Maree’s fees for services as a director of group subsidiaries included fees paid by Liberty Group and Liberty Holdings Limited. He resigned from Liberty Group and
Liberty Holdings boards on 2 March 2022.
5 N Nyembezi was appointed as chairman of SBG and SBSA boards on 1 June 2022.
6 ANA Peterside CON resigned as member of the SBG and SBSA Audit committee on 12 June 2023.
Fees are disclosed excluding VAT
270 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure D – Group share incentive schemes continued
-- 217 of 278 --
Former non-executive directors
Fixed remuneration
Services as
directors of
Standard
Bank Group
R’000
Standard
Bank Group
committee fees
R’000
Services
as directors
of group
subsidiaries
R’000
Total
compensation
for the year
R’000
2023
Adv KD Moroka1 143 326 143 612
JM Vice2 143 655 143 941
Total 286 981 286 1 553
2022
MA Erasmus3 140 113 140 393
TS Gcabashe4 3 102 3 102
Adv KD Moroka1 299 945 299 1 543
MJD Ruck5 299 1 627 698 2 624
JM Vice2 299 1 335 299 1 933
Total 4 139 4 020 1 436 9 595
1 Adv KD Moroka resigned as chairman of the SBG Social, Ethics and Sustainability committee on 31 December 2022 and retired from the SBG and SBSA boards on
12 June 2023.
2 JM Vice retired from the SBG and SBSA boards on 12 June 2023.
3 MA Erasmus resigned from SBG and SBSA boards on 16 February 2022.
4 TS Gcabashe retired as chairman of the SBSA board on 26 May 2022 and as chairman of the SBG board on 31 May 2022.
5 MJD Ruck’s fees for services as director of group subsidiaries included fees paid by Stanbic Ghana. He retired from the SBG and SBSA boards on 31 December 2022
and from the Stanbic Ghana board on 4 January 2023.
Fees are disclosed excluding VAT
Share-linked schemes
Deferred Bonus Scheme
Deferred short-term incentive awards are made in terms of the
Deferred Bonus Scheme (DBS) or Cash Settled Deferred
Bonus Scheme (CS DBS). Awards are converted to units by
referencing the group share price on award. On vesting, units
are either settled in group shares on a one-for-one basis (in
terms of the DBS) or in cash (in terms of the CS DBS). DBS
settlement takes place through shares purchased in the
market to avoid shareholder dilution.
Participants also receive a notional dividend cash payment on
vesting. This amount is equal to the dividends that would have
accrued over the vesting period on the number of shares which
has vested.
Performance reward plan (PRP)
PRP participation is limited to executive directors, prescribed
officers and senior executive roles who make a direct
contribution to the achievement of the group’s long-term
strategy.
Awards vest after three years from the award date if, and to
the extent, performance conditions are met. The performance
conditions include a minimum threshold to start vesting and
subsequent targets for vesting up to 200%. The performance
period over which performance conditions are measured, is
aligned to the group’s financial year. Vested units of South
African participants are settled in shares purchased in the
market to avoid shareholder dilution. The vested awards of
participants outside South Africa are cash settled.
On vesting, participants also receive a cash payment equal to
the dividends that would have accrued over the vesting period
on the number of shares which have vested.
Legacy share-linked schemes
Share appreciation rights plan (SARP)
Previously, employees with deferred STI awards exceeding R1
million (or similar local currency amount) could choose to
receive all or part of their deferral in the form of share
appreciation rights. To the extent that employees elected
SARP awards, they received a premium of 10% of the value of
their award, because of the longer vesting period (equally over
two, three and four years) and the instrument’s inherent risk
profile compared to standard DBS awards. South African
participants can elect to either receive shares (purchased in
the market to avoid shareholder dilution) or the cash
equivalent in settlement of their exercised awards. For
participants outside of South Africa, exercised awards are
settled in cash.The last SARP awards were made in March
2023.
Equity growth scheme (EGS)
EGS awards represented participation rights in the future
growth of the group’s share price. Certain EGS awards issued
prior to March 2014 included performance conditions. The last
EGS awards were made in 2016.
Liberty EGS
As part of the acquisition of the minority shareholding in
Liberty Holdings Limited in 2022, Liberty EGS participants
could retain their historic awards granted by the Liberty
Remco in 2020. The scheme was amended at the time to allow
for settlement in group shares purchased in the market.
Awards represent participation rights in the growth of of the
group’s share price.
The performance period for the awards ended on 6 November
2023 and half of the awards vested on this date. The balance of
the awards will vest equally in November 2024 and 2025 if the
employment condition is met.Vested awards are exercisable
until 6 November 2030.
No further awards will be made under the scheme.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 271
STANDARD BANK GROUP | Annual financial statements 2020
-- 218 of 278 --
Units
Exercise
date
share
price
Value on settlement
Fair value at
year end
Performance year Issue date Award price
Value at
grant date
(R’000)
Vesting
date/vesting
category
Expiry
date/final
vesting date
Opening
balance
Awards
made
during
the year
Number
of awards
exercised
during
the year
Number
of awards
forfeited
during
the year
Balance
of awards
31 December
2023
Award
(R’000)1
Notional
dividend
(R’000)2
Award
(R’000)3
Notional
dividend
(R’000)4
SK Tshabalala
Deferred bonus schemes
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 1 500 2023/09/29 9 828 9 828 183.72 1 806 349
2019* 2020/03/05 152.64 2 742 2023/09/29 17 963 17 963 183.72 3 300 637
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 1 183 2023/09/29 8 333 8 333 183.72 1 531 251
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 1 183 2024/09/30 8 334 8 334 1 734 251
2020* 2021/03/11 142.00 1 200 2023/09/29 8 451 8 451 183.72 1 553 254
2020* 2021/03/11 142.00 1 200 2024/09/30 8 451 8 451 1 759 254
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 850 2024/09/30 10 288 10 288 2 141 142
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 850 2025/09/30 10 288 10 288 2 141 142
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 850 2026/09/30 10 289 10 289 2 141 142
Performance reward plan
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 16 653 2023/03/31 136 375 136 375 173.68 23 686 2 954
20206 2021/03/11 142.00 17 750 2024/03/31 125 000 75 000 200 000 41 620 6 014
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 20 009 2025/03/31 124 800 124 800 25 971 3 004
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 24 006 2026/03/31 133 500 133 500 27 781 1 844
Share appreciation rights plan
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 2024/03/11 2026/03/11 84 694 84 694 4 046
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 0 2025/03/11 2027/03/11 84 695 84 695 4 046
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 — 2026/03/11 2028/03/11 84 695 84 695 4 046
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 — 2025/03/09 2027/03/09 42 403 42 403 1 199
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 — 2026/03/09 2028/03/09 42 404 42 404 1 199
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 — 2027/03/09 2029/03/09 42 404 42 404 1 199
Totals for 2023 92 976 31 876 4 445 121 023 11 793
Refer to footnotes disclosed below the final disclosures of directors’ and prescribed officers’ share incentives.
272 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure E – Emoluments and share incentives of directors and prescribed officers continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 273
-- 219 of 278 --
Units
Exercise
date
share
price
Value on settlement
Fair value at
year end
Performance year Issue date Award price
Value at
grant date
(R'000)
Vesting
date/vesting
category
Expiry
date/final
vesting date
Opening
balance
Awards
made
during
the year
Number
of awards
exercised
during
the year
Number
of awards
forfeited
during
the year
Balance
of awards
31 December
2023
Award
(R’000)1
Notional
dividend
(R’000)2
Award
(R’000)3
Notional
dividend
(R’000)4
A Daehnke
Deferred bonus schemes
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 1 333 2023/09/29 8 736 8 736 183.72 1 605 310
2019* 2020/03/05 152.64 1 950 2023/09/29 12 776 12 776 183.72 2 347 453
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 1 067 2023/09/29 7 512 7 512 183.72 1 380 226
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 1 067 2024/09/30 7 512 7 512 1 563 226
2020* 2021/03/11 142.00 767 2023/09/29 5 399 5 399 183.72 992 162
2020* 2021/03/11 142.00 767 2024/09/30 5 400 5 400 1 124 162
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 000 2023/09/29 6 237 6 237 183.72 1 146 150
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 000 2024/09/30 6 237 6 237 1 298 150
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 000 2025/09/30 6 238 6 238 1 298 150
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 1 306 2023/09/29 8 147 8 147 183.72 1 497 196
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 1 306 2024/09/30 8 147 8 147 1 695 196
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 1 306 2025/09/30 8 148 8 148 1 696 196
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 225 2024/09/30 6 812 6 812 1 418 94
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 225 2025/09/30 6 813 6 813 1 418 94
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 225 2026/09/30 6 813 6 813 1 418 94
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 275 2024/09/30 7 090 7 090 1 475 98
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 275 2025/09/30 7 091 7 091 1 476 98
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 275 2026/09/30 7 091 7 091 1 476 98
Performance reward plan
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 12 013 2023/03/31 98 375 98 375 173.68 17 086 2 131
20206 2021/03/11 142.00 14 001 2024/03/31 98 600 59 160 157 760 32 830 4 744
2021 2022/03/11 160.00 14 013 2025/03/31 87 400 87 400 18 188 2 104
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 16 004 2026/03/31 89 000 89 000 18 521 1 229
Equity growth scheme
Vested
2010 2011/03/04 98.80 A 2023/03/31 12 500 12 500 173.68 936
2010 2011/03/04 98.80 B 2023/03/31 12 500 12 500 173.68 936
2013 2014/03/06 126.87 D 2024/03/31 68 750 68 750 5 585
Share appreciation rights plan
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 2024/03/11 2026/03/11 19 730 19 730 943
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 2025/03/11 2027/03/11 19 730 19 730 943
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 2026/03/11 2028/03/11 19 730 19 730 943
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 2025/03/09 2027/03/09 20 786 20 786 588
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 2026/03/09 2028/03/09 20 786 20 786 588
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 2027/03/09 2029/03/09 20 787 20 787 588
Totals for 2023 77 400 27 925 3 628 97 072 9 733
Refer to footnotes disclosed below the final disclosures of directors’ and prescribed officers’ share incentives.
274 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure E – Emoluments and share incentives of directors and prescribed officers continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 275
-- 220 of 278 --
Units
Exercise
date
share
price
Value on settlement
Fair value at
year end
Performance year Issue date Award price
Value at
grant date
(R'000)
Vesting
date/vesting
category
Expiry
date/final
vesting date
Opening
balance
Awards
made
during
the year
Number
of awards
exercised
during
the year
Number
of awards
forfeited
during
the year
Balance
of awards
31 December
2023
Award
(R’000)1
Notional
dividend
(R’000)2
Award
(R’000)3
Notional
dividend
(R’000)4
FZ Montjane
Deferred bonus schemes
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 1 584 2023/09/29 10 375 10 375 183.72 1 906 368
2019* 2020/03/05 152.64 1 783 2023/09/29 11 684 11 684 183.72 2 147 414
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 767 2023/09/29 5 399 5 399 183.72 992 162
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 767 2024/09/30 5 400 5 400 1 124 162
2020* 2021/03/11 142.00 467 2023/09/29 3 287 3 287 183.72 604 99
2020* 2021/03/11 142.00 467 2024/09/30 3 287 3 287 684 99
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 267 2023/09/29 7 900 7 900 183.72 1 451 190
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 267 2024/09/30 7 901 7 901 1 644 190
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 267 2025/09/30 7 901 7 901 1 644 190
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 1 400 2023/09/29 8 732 8 732
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 1 400 2024/09/30 8 732 8 732 1 817 210
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 1 400 2025/09/30 8 732 8 732 1 817 210
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 600 2024/09/30 8 898 8 898 1 852 123
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 600 2025/09/30 8 898 8 898 1 852 123
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 600 2026/09/30 8 898 8 898 1 852 123
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 483 2024/09/30 8 249 8 249 1 717 114
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 483 2025/09/30 8 249 8 249 1 717 114
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 483 2026/09/30 8 249 8 249 1 717 114
Performance reward plan
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 9 006 2023/03/31 73 750 73 750 173.68 12 809 1 597
20206 2021/03/11 142.00 11 005 2024/03/31 77 500 46 500 124 000 25 804 3 729
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 13 003 2025/03/31 81 100 81 100 16 877 1 952
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 14 008 2026/03/31 77 900 77 900 16 211 1 076
Totals for 2023 70 107 19 909 2 830 78 329 8 529
Refer to footnotes disclosed below the final disclosures of directors’ and prescribed officers’ share incentives.
276 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure E – Emoluments and share incentives of directors and prescribed officers continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 277
-- 221 of 278 --
Units
Exercise
date
share
price
Value on settlement
Fair value at
year end
Performance year Issue date Award price
Value at
grant date
(R'000)
Vesting
date/vesting
category
Expiry
date/final
vesting date
Opening
balance
Awards
made
during
the year
Number
of awards
exercised
during
the year
Number
of awards
forfeited
during
the year
Balance
of awards
31 December
2023
Award
(R’000)1
Notional
dividend
(R’000)2
Award
(R’000)3
Notional
dividend
(R’000)4
W Blackie
Deferred bonus schemes
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 3 860 2023/09/29 25 285 25 285 183.72 4 645 897
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 2 606 2023/09/29 18 354 18 354 183.72 3 372 552
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 2 606 2024/09/30 18 354 18 354 3 819 552
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 333 2023/09/29 8 316 8 316 183.72 1 528 200
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 333 2024/09/30 8 316 8 316 1 731 200
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 333 2025/09/30 8 317 8 317 1 731 200
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 3 021 2023/09/29 18 842 18 842 183.72 3 462 454
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 3 021 2024/09/30 18 842 18 842 3 921 454
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 3 021 2025/09/30 18 842 18 842 3 921 454
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 633 2024/09/30 9 083 9 083 1 890 125
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 633 2025/09/30 9 083 9 083 1 890 125
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 633 2026/09/30 9 084 9 084 1 890 125
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 617 2024/09/30 8 990 8 990 1 871 124
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 617 2025/09/30 8 991 8 991 1 871 124
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 617 2026/09/30 8 991 8 991 1 871 124
Performance reward plan
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 6 014 2023/03/31 49 250 49 250 173.68 8 554 1 067
20206 2021/03/11 142.00 6 007 2024/03/31 42 300 25 380 67 680 14 084 2 035
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 5 002 2025/03/31 31 200 31 200 6 493 751
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 14 008 2026/03/31 77 900 77 900 16 211 1 076
Totals for 2023 62 915 21 561 3 170 63 194 6 469
278 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure E – Emoluments and share incentives of directors and prescribed officers continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 279
-- 222 of 278 --
Units
Exercise
date
share
price
Value on settlement
Fair value at
year end
Performance year Issue date Award price
Value at
grant date
(R'000)
Vesting
date/vesting
category
Expiry
date/final
vesting date
Opening
balance
Awards
made
during
the year
Number
of awards
exercised
during
the year
Number
of awards
forfeited
during
the year
Balance
of awards
31 December
2023
Award
(R’000)1
Notional
dividend
(R’000)2
Award
(R’000)3
Notional
dividend
(R’000)4
AKL Fihla
Deferred bonus schemes
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 1 333 2023/09/29 8 736 8 736 183.72 1 605 310
2019* 2020/03/05 152.64 2 575 2023/09/29 16 872 16 872 183.72 3 100 598
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 1 267 2023/09/29 8 920 8 920 183.72 1 639 268
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 1 267 2024/09/30 8 921 8 921 1 856 268
2020* 2021/03/11 142.00 1 700 2023/09/29 11 972 11 972 183.72 2 199 360
2020* 2021/03/11 142.00 1 700 2024/09/30 11 972 11 972 2 491 360
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 500 2023/09/29 9 356 9 356 183.72 1 719 225
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 500 2024/09/30 9 356 9 356 1 947 225
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 500 2025/09/30 9 356 9 356 1 947 225
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 2 533 2023/09/29 15 801 15 801 183.72 2 903 380
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 2 533 2024/09/30 15 801 15 801 3 288 380
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 2 533 2025/09/30 15 801 15 801 3 288 380
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 867 2024/09/30 10 381 10 381 2 160 143
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 867 2025/09/30 10 381 10 381 2 160 143
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 867 2026/09/30 10 381 10 381 2 160 143
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 2 717 2024/09/30 15 108 15 108 3 144 209
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 2 717 2025/09/30 15 108 15 108 3 144 209
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 2 717 2026/09/30 15 108 15 108 3 144 209
Performance reward plan
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 11 158 2023/03/31 91 375 91 375 173.68 15 870 1 979
20206 2021/03/11 142.00 12 013 2024/03/31 84 600 50 760 135 360 28 168 4 070
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 12 009 2025/03/31 74 900 74 900 15 587 1 803
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 14 008 2026/03/31 77 900 77 900 16 211 1 076
Totals for 2023 84 881 29 035 4 120 90 695 9 843
Refer to footnotes disclosed below the final disclosures of directors’ and prescribed officers’ share incentives.
280 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure E – Emoluments and share incentives of directors and prescribed officers continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 281
-- 223 of 278 --
Units
Exercise
date
share
price
Value on settlement
Fair value at
year end
Performance year Issue date Award price
Value at
grant date
(R'000)
Vesting
date/vesting
category
Expiry
date/final
vesting date
Opening
balance
Awards
made
during
the year
Number
of awards
exercised
during
the year
Number
of awards
forfeited
during
the year
Balance
of awards
31 December
2023
Award
(R’000)1
Notional
dividend
(R’000)2
Award
(R’000)3
Notional
dividend
(R’000)4
Y Maharaj
Deferred bonus schemes
2021 2022/03/01 159.21 455 2023/09/01 2 859 2 859 193.21 552 49
2021 2022/03/01 159.21 63 2024/09/01 398 398 82 10
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 393 2023/09/30 2 449 2 449 193.21 450 59
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 393 2024/09/30 2 449 2 449 509 59
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 393 2025/09/30 2 449 2 449 509 59
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 3 000 2025/03/31 18 711 18 711 3 892 450
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 3 000 2023/09/30 18 711 18 711 193.21 3 438 450
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 450 2024/09/30 8 063 8 063 1 678 111
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 450 2025/09/30 8 064 8 064 1 678 111
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 450 2026/09/30 8 064 8 064 1 678 111
Performance reward plan
20206 2021/03/11 159.21 7 698 2024/03/31 48 354 29 012 77 366 16 093 2 326
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 6 250 2025/03/31 38 982 38 982 8 109 938
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 10 000 2026/03/31 55 611 55 611 11 567 768
2022 2023/05/23 156.80 3 912 2025/03/31 24 949 24 949 5 189 345
Liberty equity growth scheme
2021 2022/03/01 103.36 7 428 2023/11/06 2030/11/06 133 000 133 000 10 803
2021 2022/03/01 103.36 3 714 2024/11/06 2030/11/06 66 500 66 500 5 402
2021 2022/03/01 103.36 3 714 2025/11/06 2030/11/06 66 500 66 500 5 402
Cash remuneration scheme5
2021 2022/03/01 7 295
Totals for 2023 54 763 11 735 558 72 591 5 288
Refer to footnotes disclosed below the final disclosures of directors’ and prescribed officers’ share incentives.
282 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure E – Emoluments and share incentives of directors and prescribed officers continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 283
-- 224 of 278 --
Units
Exercise
date
share
price
Value on settlement
Fair value at
year end
Performance year Issue date Award price
Value at
grant date
(R'000)
Vesting
date/vesting
category
Expiry
date/final
vesting date
Opening
balance
Awards
made
during
the year
Number
of awards
exercised
during
the year
Number
of awards
forfeited
during
the year
Balance
of awards
31 December
2023
Award
(R’000)1
Notional
dividend
(R’000)2
Award
(R’000)3
Notional
dividend
(R’000)4
M Nienaber
Deferred bonus schemes
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 1 333 2023/09/29 8 736 8 736 183.72 1 605 310
2019* 2020/03/05 152.64 1 867 2023/09/29 12 230 12 230 183.72 2 247 434
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 1 167 2023/09/29 8 216 8 216 183.72 1 509 247
2020 2021/03/11 142.00 1 167 2024/09/30 8 216 8 216 1 710 247
2020* 2021/03/11 142.00 1 125 2023/09/29 7 923 7 923 183.72 1 456 238
2020* 2021/03/11 142.00 1 125 2024/09/30 7 923 7 923 1 649 238
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 367 2023/09/29 8 524 8 524 183.72 1 566 205
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 367 2024/09/30 8 524 8 524 1 774 205
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 367 2025/09/30 8 525 8 525 1 774 205
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 1 933 2023/09/29 12 058 12 058 183.72 2 215 290
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 1 933 2024/09/30 12 059 12 059 2 509 290
2021* 2022/03/11 160.33 1 933 2025/09/30 12 059 12 059 2 509 290
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 700 2024/09/30 9 454 9 454 1 967 131
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 700 2025/09/30 9 454 9 454 1 967 131
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 1 700 2026/09/30 9 454 9 454 1 967 131
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 967 2024/09/30 10 937 10 937 2 276 151
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 967 2025/09/30 10 937 10 937 2 276 151
2022* 2023/03/09 179.82 1 967 2026/09/30 10 937 10 937 2 276 151
Performance reward plan
2019 2020/03/05 152.64 10 502 2023/03/31 86 000 86 000 173.68 14 936 1 863
20206 2021/03/11 142.00 11 005 2024/03/31 77 500 46 500 124 000 25 804 3 729
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 12 009 2025/03/31 74 900 74 900 15 587 1 803
2022 2023/03/09 179.82 14 008 2026/03/31 77 900 77 900 16 211 1 076
Totals for 2023 76 209 25 534 3 587 82 256 8 929
Refer to footnotes disclosed below the final disclosures of directors’ and prescribed officers’ share incentives.
284 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure E – Emoluments and share incentives of directors and prescribed officers continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 285
-- 225 of 278 --
Units
Exercise
date
share
price
Value on settlement
Fair value at
year end
Performance year Issue date Award price
Value at
grant date
(R'000)
Vesting
date/vesting
category
Expiry
date/final
vesting date
Opening
balance
Awards
made
during
the year
Number
of awards
exercised
during
the year
Number
of awards
forfeited
during
the year6
Balance
of awards
31 December
2023
Award
(R’000)1
Notional
dividend
(R’000)2
Award
(R’000)3
Notional
dividend
(R’000)4
DC Munro
Deferred bonus schemes SBG
2021 2022/03/01 159.21 1 071 2023/09/01 6 730 6 730 193.21 1 300 116
2021 2022/03/01 159.21 120 2024/09/01 752 752 156 18
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 999 2023/09/30 6 234 6 234 183.72 1 145 150
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 999 2024/09/30 6 234 6 234 1 297 150
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 1 000 2025/09/30 6 235 6 235 1 297 150
Liberty equity growth scheme
2021 2022/03/01 103.36 15 415 2023/11/06 2030/11/06 276 000 276 000 22 419
2021 2022/03/01 103.36 7 707 2024/11/06 2030/11/06 138 000 138 000 11 210
2021 2022/03/01 103.36 7 707 2025/11/06 2030/11/06 138 000 138 000 11 210
Performance reward plan
20206 2021/03/11 159.21 15 910 2024/03/31 99 932 44 969 24 983 119 918 24 944 3 606
2021 2022/03/11 160.33 11 000 2025/03/31 68 608 40 021 28 587 5 947 688
Cash remuneration scheme5
2021 2022/03/01 17 206
Totals for 2023 61 928 19 651 266 78 480 4 612
* Cash settled Deferred Bonus Scheme.
1 Value on settlement is calculated with reference to the share price on the settlement date.
2 Value is calculated by multiplying the notional dividend per unit with the total number of units vesting.
3 Value of awards which have not yet been settled is calculated with reference to the year end SBK share price of R208.10. The 2021 PRP award due to vest in March
2024 is valued with reference to the actual vesting percentage of 160%. The 2022 and 2023 PRP awards are valued at 100% vesting.
4 Value is calculated by multiplying the notional dividend (accumulated from award date to year-end) with the total outstanding units. PRP performance condition
outcomes are applied as described in note 3 above. Notional dividends are subject to the vesting conditions.
5 A new cash-settled remuneration scheme was accounted for by LHL group in 2022 due to the acquisition of the minority shareholding in Liberty Holdings Limited by
SBG. 50% was paid at the time of the transaction in 2022 and the balance in 2023.
6 The vesting percentage for the 2021 grant has been updated to 160% based on the achievement of performance conditions measured over the 3-year performance
period ending 31 December 2023. This uplift has been reflected in the “awards made during the year” column.
The EGS share schemes are disclosed in the following vesting categories:
A: Includes the group leadership council members of Standard Bank Group Limited (for banking only)
B: Includes heads of major business lines.
C: Includes executives whose actions have a material impact on the risk exposure of the group as a whole, based on the ability to:
■ commit significant amount of the group’s risk capital;
■ significantly influence the group’s overall liquidity position; or
■ significantly influence material risks.
D: Includes all other executives receiving any deferred variable remuneration and for whom the variable remuneration award is linked to
personal or business line performance.
286 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure E – Emoluments and share incentives of directors and prescribed officers continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 287
-- 226 of 278 --
The following accounting policies were applied in the preparation of the group and company financial statements. All policies apply to the
group and company, unless otherwise stated.
1. Basis of consolidation
BASIS OF CONSOLIDATION
Subsidiaries Foreign currency translations
| |
Separate financial statements Group companies
Consolidated financial statements Transactions and balances
Subsidiaries
Separate financial statements (including mutual funds in which the group has both an irrevocable
asset management agreement and a significant investment)
Investments in subsidiaries are accounted for at cost less accumulated impairment losses (where applicable) in the separate
financial statements. The carrying amounts of these investments are reviewed annually for impairment indicators and, where
an indicator of impairment exists, are impaired to the higher of the investment’s fair value less costs to sell or value in use.
Consolidated financial statements
The accounting policies of subsidiaries that are consolidated by the group conform to the group’s accounting policies.
Intragroup transactions, balances and unrealised gains/(losses) are eliminated on consolidation. Unrealised losses are
eliminated in the same manner as unrealised gains, but only to the extent that there is no evidence of impairment. The
proportion of comprehensive income and changes in equity allocated to the group and non-controlling interest are
determined based on the group’s present ownership interest in the subsidiary.
Subsidiaries are consolidated from the date on which the group obtains control up to the date that control is lost. Control is
assessed on a continuous basis. For mutual funds the group further assesses its control by considering the existence of either
voting rights or significant economic power.
Common control transactions
Common control transactions, in which the company is the ultimate parent entity both before and after the transaction,
are accounted for at book value.
Foreign currency translations
Group companies
The results and financial position of foreign operations that have a functional currency that is different from the group’s
presentation currency are translated into the group’s presentation currency as follows:
■ assets and liabilities (including goodwill, intangible assets and fair value adjustments arising on acquisition) are translated
at the closing rate at the reporting date.
■ income and expenses are translated at average exchange rates for each month; and
■ all resulting foreign exchange differences are accounted for directly in a separate component of OCI, being the group’s
FCTR.
288 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
ANNEXURE F – MATERIAL ACCOUNTING
POLICIES
-- 227 of 278 --
Transactions and balances
Foreign currency transactions are translated into the respective group entities’ functional currencies at exchange rates
prevailing at the date of the transactions (in certain instances a rate that approximates the actual rate at the date of the
transaction is utilised, for example, an average rate for a month). Foreign exchange gains and losses resulting from the
settlement of such transactions and from the translation of monetary assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currencies
at year-end exchange rates, are recognised in profit or loss (except when recognised in OCI as part of qualifying cash flow
hedges and net investment hedges).
Non-monetary assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currencies that are measured at historical cost are translated
using the exchange rate at the transaction date, and those measured at fair value are translated at the exchange rate at the
date that the fair value was determined. Exchange rate differences on non-monetary items are accounted for based on the
classification of the underlying items.
Foreign exchange gains and losses on equities (debt) classified as fair value through OCI are recognised in the fair value
through OCI reserve in OCI whereas the exchange differences on equities (debt) that are classified as held at fair value
through profit or loss are reported as part of other revenue (trading revenue) in profit or loss.
Foreign currency gains and losses on intragroup loans are recognised in profit or loss except where the settlement of the loan
is neither planned nor likely to occur in the foreseeable future. In these cases the foreign currency gains and losses are
recognised in the group’s FCTR.
The results, cash flows and financial position of group entities which are accounted for as entities operating in
hyperinflationary economies and that have functional currencies different from the presentation currency of the group are
translated into the presentation currency of its parent at the exchange rate at the reporting date. These foreign exchange
gains and losses on a hyperinflationary foreign operation are presented in OCI.
Subsidiaries in hyperinflationary economies
The financial statements of group entities whose functional currencies are the currencies of hyperinflationary economies are
adjusted in terms of the measuring unit at the end of the reporting period following the historic cost approach.
However, as the presentation currency of the group is that of a non-hyperinflationary economy, comparative amounts are not
adjusted for changes in the index in the current year. Differences between these comparative amounts and current year
hyperinflation adjusted amounts are recognised directly in equity.
The carrying amounts of non-monetary assets and liabilities are adjusted to reflect the change in the general price index from
the date of acquisition to the end of the reporting period. On initial application of hyperinflation, prior period gains and losses
are recognised directly in equity. Gains or losses on the net monetary position are recognised in profit or loss. All items
recognised in profit or loss are restated by applying the change in the general price index from the dates when the items of
income and expenses were initially earned or incurred.
At the beginning of the first period of application, the components of equity, except retained earnings, are restated by
applying a general price index from the dates the components were contributed or otherwise arose. These restatements are
recognised directly in equity as an adjustment to opening retained earnings. Restated retained earnings are derived from all
other amounts in the restated statement of financial position. At the end of the first year and in subsequent years, all
components of equity are restated by applying a general price index from the beginning of the year or the date of contribution,
if later, with this restatement being recognised directly in equity. All items in the statement of cash flows are expressed in
terms of the general price index at the end of the reporting period.
Results, cash flows and the financial position of the group's subsidiaries which have been classified as hyperinflationary have
been expressed in terms of the measuring unit current at the reporting date. For further details, refer to annexure A.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 289
-- 228 of 278 --
2. Interest in associates and joint arrangements
INTEREST IN ASSOCIATES AND JOINT ARRANGEMENTS
Associates and joint ventures Private equity and venture capital investments
Associates and joint ventures
Associates and joint ventures are initially measured at cost and subsequently accounted for using the equity method at an
amount that reflects the group’s share of the net assets of the associate or joint venture (including goodwill). Equity
accounting is applied from the date on which the entity becomes an associate or joint venture up to the date on which the
group ceases to have significant influence or joint control.
Equity accounting of losses is restricted to the interests in these entities, including unsecured receivables or other
commitments, unless the group has an obligation or has made payments on behalf of the associate or joint venture. Additional
interests acquired in associates form part of the equity accounted investment to the extent that they give rise to current
access to returns associated with an ownership interest.
Unrealised profits from transactions are eliminated in determining the group’s share of equity accounted profits. Unrealised
losses are eliminated in the same way as unrealised gains (but only to the extent that there is no evidence of impairment).
Where there is an indicator of impairment, the carrying amount of the investment is tested for impairment by comparing its
recoverable amount with its carrying amount. Impairment losses are recognised in non-trading and capital related items.
Impairment losses recognised in prior periods are assessed at each reporting date for any indications that the loss has
decreased or no longer exists. An impairment loss is reversed if there has been a change in the estimates used to determine
the recoverable amount, but only to the extent that the investment’s carrying amount does not exceed the carrying amount
that would have been determined, net of equity accounted losses, if no impairment loss had been recognised.
For a disposal of an associate or joint venture, being where the group loses significant influence over an associate or loses
control over a joint venture, the difference between the sales proceeds and any retained interest and the carrying value of the
equity accounted investment is recognised as a gain or loss in non-trading and capital related items. Any gains or losses in OCI
reserves that relate to the associate or joint venture are reclassified to non-trading and capital related items at the time of the
disposal.
The accounting policies of associates and joint ventures have been changed where necessary to ensure consistency with the
policies of the group.
Private equity and venture capital investments
Private equity and venture capital investments, including mutual funds held by investment-linked insurance funds that are
associates that are either designated on initial recognition at fair value through profit or loss, or are equity accounted. Where
the private equity or venture capital investment is designated at fair value through profit or loss, the investment is presented
within financial investments on the statement of financial position and the fair value movement is recognised within other
gains and losses on financial instruments for banking, and within fair value adjustments to investment contract liabilities and
third-party mutual funds, included in non-insurance revenue, in profit or loss.
290 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 229 of 278 --
3. Financial instruments
Initial measurement
All financial instruments are measured initially at fair value plus directly attributable transaction costs and fees, except for
those financial instruments that are subsequently measured at fair value through profit or loss where such transaction costs
and fees are immediately recognised in profit or loss. Financial instruments are recognised (derecognised) on the date the
group commits to purchase (sell) the instruments (trade date accounting).
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
Financial
assets
Financial
liabilities
Financial
guarantee
contracts
Derivatives
and
embedded
derivatives
Hedge
accounting Other
| | | |
Amortised
cost
Held-for-
trading
Fair value
hedges
Sale and
repurchase
agreements
and lending of
securities
(including
commodities)
Fair value
through OCI
Designated at
fair value
through profit
or loss
Cash flow
hedges
Held-for-
trading
Amortised
cost
Net investment
hedges Offsetting
Designated at
fair value
through profit
or loss
Fair value
through profit
or loss -default
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 291
-- 230 of 278 --
3. Financial instruments continued
Financial assets
Nature
Amortised cost A debt instrument that meets both of the following conditions (other than those
designated at fair value through profit or loss):
■ Held within a business model whose objective is to hold the debt instrument (financial
asset) in order to collect contractual cash flows; and
■ The contractual terms of the financial asset give rise on specified dates to cash flows
that are solely payments of principal and interest on the principal amount outstanding.
This assessment includes determining the objective of holding the asset and whether the
contractual cash flows are consistent with a basic lending arrangement. Where the
contractual terms introduce exposure to risk or volatility that are not considered de
minimis and are inconsistent with a basic lending arrangement, the financial asset is
classified as fair value through profit or loss – default.
Fair value through OCI Includes:
■ A debt instrument that meets both of the following conditions (other than those
designated at fair value through profit or loss):
– Held within a business model in which the debt instrument (financial asset) is
managed to both collect contractual cash flows and sell financial assets; and
– The contractual terms of the financial asset give rise on specified dates to cash
flows that are solely payments of principal and interest on the principal amount
outstanding.
■ This assessment includes determining the objective of holding the asset and whether
the contractual cash flows are consistent with a basic lending arrangement. Where the
contractual terms introduce exposure to risk or volatility that are not considered de
minimis and are inconsistent with a basic lending arrangement, the financial asset is
classified as fair value through profit or loss – default.
■ Equity financial assets which are not held for trading and are irrevocably elected (on an
instrument-by-instrument basis) to be presented at fair value through OCI.
Held-for-trading Those financial assets acquired principally for the purpose of selling in the near term
(including all derivative financial assets) and those that form part of a portfolio of
identified financial instruments that are managed together and for which there is
evidence of a recent actual pattern of short-term profit taking.
Included are commodities that are acquired principally for the purpose of selling in the
near future or generating a profit from fluctuations in price or broker-trader margin.
Designated at fair value
through profit or loss
Financial assets are designated to be measured at fair value through profit or loss to
eliminate or significantly reduce an accounting mismatch that would otherwise arise.
Fair value through profit
or loss – default
Financial assets that are not classified into one of the above mentioned financial asset
categories.
292 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 231 of 278 --
Subsequent measurement
Subsequent to initial measurement, financial assets are classified in their respective categories and measured at either
amortised cost or fair value as follows:
Amortised cost Amortised cost using the effective interest method with interest recognised in interest
income, less any expected credit impairment losses which are recognised as part of credit
impairment charges.
Directly attributable transaction costs and fees received are capitalised and amortised
through interest income as part of the effective interest rate.
Fair value through OCI Debt instrument: Fair value, with gains and losses recognised directly in the fair value
through OCI reserve. When a debt financial asset is disposed of, the cumulative fair value
adjustments, previously recognised in OCI, are reclassified to the other gains and losses
on financial instruments within non-interest revenue. Expected credit impairments losses
are recognised as part of credit impairment charges. However, for these FVOCI debt
instruments the expected credit loss is recognised in OCI and does not reduce the
carrying amount of the financial asset in the statement of financial position. Interest
income on a debt financial asset is recognised in interest income in terms of the effective
interest rate method.
Dividends received are recognised in interest income within profit or loss.
Equity instrument: Fair value, with gains and losses recognised directly in the fair value
through OCI reserve. When equity financial assets are disposed of, the cumulative fair
value adjustments in OCI are reclassified within reserves to retained income.
Dividends received on equity instruments are recognised in other revenue within non-
interest revenue.
Held-for-trading Fair value, with gains and losses arising from changes in fair value (including interest and
dividends) recognised in trading revenue.
Designated at fair value
through profit or loss
Fair value gains and losses (including interest and dividends) on the financial asset are
recognised in the income statement as part of other gains and losses on financial
instruments within non-interest revenue.
Fair value through profit or
loss – default
Debt instruments – Fair value gains and losses (including interest and dividends) on the
financial asset recognised in profit or loss as part of other gains and losses on financial
instruments within non-interest revenue.
Equity instruments – Fair value gains and losses on the financial asset are recognised in
profit or loss as part of other gains and losses on financial instruments. Dividends
received on equity instruments are recognised in other revenue within non-interest
revenue.
Impairment
ECL is recognised on debt financial assets classified as either amortised cost or fair value through OCI, financial guarantee
contracts that are not designated at fair value through profit or loss as well as loan commitments that are neither measured
at fair value through profit or loss nor are used to provide a loan at a below market interest rate.
The measurement basis of the ECL of a financial asset includes assessing whether there has been a SICR at the reporting
date which includes forward-looking information that is available without undue cost or effort at the reporting date about past
events, current conditions and forecasts of future economic conditions. The measurement basis of the ECL, which is set out
in the table that follows, is measured as the unbiased and probability-weighted amount that is determined by evaluating a
range of possible outcomes, the time value of money and forward-looking information.
Stage 1 A 12-month ECL is calculated for financial assets which are neither credit-impaired on
origination nor for which there has been a SICR.
Stage 2 A lifetime ECL is calculated for financial assets that are assessed to have displayed a SICR
since origination and are not considered low credit risk.
Stage 3 (credit-impaired
assets)
A lifetime ECL is calculated for financial assets that are assessed to be credit-impaired.
The following criteria are used in determining whether the financial asset is impaired:
■ default
■ significant financial difficulty of borrower and/or modification
■ probability of bankruptcy or financial reorganisation
■ disappearance of an active market due to financial difficulties.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 293
-- 232 of 278 --
3. Financial instruments continued
Financial assets continued
The key components of the impairment methodology are described as follows:
Significant increase in credit
risk (SICR)
At each reporting date the group assesses whether the credit risk of its exposures has
increased significantly since initial recognition by considering the change in the risk of
default occurring over the expected life of the financial asset.
Credit risk of exposures which are overdue for more than 30 days are also considered to
have increased significantly.
Low credit risk Exposures are generally considered to have a low credit risk where there is a low risk of
default, the exposure has a strong capacity to meet its contractual cash flow obligations
and adverse changes in economic and business conditions may not necessarily reduce
the exposure’s ability to fulfil its contractual obligations.
Default The group’s definition of default has been aligned to its internal credit risk management
definitions and approaches. A financial asset is considered to be in default when there is
objective evidence of impairment. The following criteria are used in determining whether
there is objective evidence of impairment for financial assets or groups of financial assets:
■ significant financial difficulty of borrower and/or modification (i.e. known cash flow
difficulties experienced by the borrower).
■ a breach of contract, such as default or delinquency in interest and/or principal
payments.
■ disappearance of active market due to financial difficulties.
■ it becomes probable that the borrower will enter bankruptcy or other financial
reorganisation.
■ where the group, for economic or legal reasons relating to the borrower’s financial
difficulty, grants the borrower a concession that the group would not otherwise consider.
■ exposures which are overdue for more than 90 days are also considered to be in default.
Forward-looking information Forward-looking information is incorporated into the group’s impairment methodology
calculations and in the group’s assessment of SICR. The group includes all forward-
looking information which is reasonable and available without undue cost or effort. The
information will typically include expected macroeconomic conditions and factors that are
expected to impact portfolios or individual counterparty exposures.
Write-off Financial assets are written off when there is no reasonable expectation of recovery.
Financial assets which are written off may still be subject to enforcement activities.
ECLs are recognised within the statement of financial position as follows:
Financial assets measured at
amortised cost (including
loan commitments)
Recognised as a deduction from the gross carrying amount of the asset (group of assets).
Where the impairment allowance exceeds the gross carrying amount of the asset (group
of assets), the excess is recognised as a provision within other liabilities.
Off-balance sheet exposures
(excluding loan
commitments)
Recognised as a provision within other liabilities.
Financial assets measured at
fair value through OCI
Recognised in the fair value reserve within equity. The carrying value of the financial asset
is recognised in the statement of financial position at fair value.
294 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 233 of 278 --
Cash and balances with central banks
Cash and balances with central banks comprise coins and bank notes and balances with central banks. Included in balances
with central banks are balances that primarily comprise reserving requirements held with central banks within the countries of
operation which are readily convertible to a known amount of cash and available for use by the group within less than three
months since initial deposit, subject to certain restrictions and limitations levied by central banks within the respective
countries, but are subject to an insignificant risk of changes in value.
Coins and bank notes and balances with central banks comprising reserving requirements are measured at fair value through
profit or loss – default. The remainder of balances with central banks are measured at amortised cost and are regarded as
having a low probability of default, therefore the ECL is insignificant.
Cash and cash equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents, for the purpose of the statement of cash flows, comprise cash and balances with central banks as
well as cash balances with other banks and on-demand gross loans and advances to banks which are readily convertible to a
known amount of cash and available for use by the group within less than three months since initial deposit. These on-demand
gross loans and advances to banks are held to meet short-term cash commitments, rather than for investment or other
purposes.
Refer to the policy on financial instruments relating to recognition and measurement of loans and advances (i.e. financial
assets measured at amortised cost).
Financial liabilities
Nature
Held-for-trading Those financial liabilities incurred principally for the purpose of repurchasing in the near
term (including all derivative financial liabilities) and those that form part of a portfolio of
identified financial instruments that are managed together and for which there is evidence
of a recent actual pattern of short-term profit taking.
Designated at fair value
through profit or loss
Financial liabilities are designated to be measured at fair value in the following instances:
■ to eliminate or significantly reduce an accounting mismatch that would otherwise arise
where the financial liabilities are managed and their performance evaluated and reported
on a fair value basis.
■ where the financial liability contains one or more embedded derivatives that significantly
modify the financial liability’s cash flows.
Amortised cost All other financial liabilities not included in the above categories.
Subsequent measurement
Subsequent to initial measurement, financial liabilities are classified in their respective categories and measured at either
amortised cost or fair value as follows:
Held-for-trading Fair value, with gains and losses arising from changes in fair value (including interest and
dividends) recognised in trading revenue.
Designated at fair value
through profit or loss
Fair value, with gains and losses arising from changes in fair value (including interest and
dividends but excluding fair value gains and losses attributable to own credit risk) are
recognised in the other gains and losses on financial instruments as part of non-interest
revenue.
Fair value gains and losses attributable to changes in own credit risk are recognised within
OCI, unless this would create or enlarge an accounting mismatch in which case the own
credit risk changes are recognised within trading revenue.
Amortised cost Amortised cost using the effective interest method recognised in interest expense.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 295
-- 234 of 278 --
3. Financial instruments continued
Financial liabilities continued
Derecognition and modification of financial assets and liabilities
Financial assets and liabilities are derecognised/modified in the following instances:
Derecognition Modification
Financial assets Financial assets are derecognised when the
contractual rights to receive cash flows from the
financial assets have expired, or where the group
has transferred its contractual rights to receive cash
flows on the financial asset such that it has
transferred substantially all the risks and rewards of
ownership of the financial asset. Any interest in the
transferred financial assets that is created or
retained by the group is recognised as a separate
asset or liability.
The group enters into transactions whereby it
transfers assets recognised in its statement of
financial position, but retains either all or a portion of
the risks or rewards of the transferred assets. If all or
substantially all risks and rewards are retained, then
the transferred assets are not derecognised.
Transfers of assets with the retention of all or
substantially all risks and rewards include securities
lending and repurchase agreements.
When assets are sold to a third party with a
concurrent total rate of return swap on the
transferred assets, the transaction is accounted for
as a secured financing transaction, similar to
repurchase transactions. In transactions where the
group neither retains nor transfers substantially all
the risks and rewards of ownership of a financial
asset, the asset is derecognised if control over the
asset is lost. The rights and obligations retained in
the transfer are recognised separately as assets and
liabilities as appropriate.
In transfers where control over the asset is retained,
the group continues to recognise the asset to the
extent of its continuing involvement, determined by
the extent to which it is exposed to changes in the
value of the transferred asset.
In determining whether a modification is
substantial, for a financial asset,
qualitative factors are considered. For a
financial liability, both qualitative and
quantitative factors are considered.
Where an existing financial asset or
liability is replaced by another with the
same counterparty on substantially
different terms, or the terms of an
existing financial asset or liability are
substantially modified, such an exchange
or modification is treated as a
derecognition of the original asset or
liability and the recognition of a new
asset or liability at fair value, including
calculating a new effective interest rate,
with the difference in the respective
carrying amounts being recognised in
other gains and losses on financial
instruments within non-interest revenue.
The date of recognition of a new asset is
consequently considered to be the date
of initial recognition for impairment
calculation purposes.
If the terms are not substantially
different for financial assets or financial
liabilities, the group recalculates the new
gross carrying amount by discounting
the modified cash flows of the financial
asset or financial liability using the
original effective interest rate. The
difference between the new gross
carrying amount and the original gross
carrying amount is recognised as a
modification gain or loss within credit
impairments (for distressed financial
asset modifications) or in other gains and
losses on financial instruments within
non-interest revenue (for all other
modifications).
Financial liabilities Financial liabilities are derecognised when the
financial liabilities’ obligation is extinguished, that is,
when the obligation is discharged, cancelled or
expires.
Financial guarantee contracts and loan commitments below market interest rate
A financial guarantee contract is a contract that requires the group (issuer) to make specified payments to reimburse the
holder for a loss it incurs because a specified debtor fails to make payment when due in accordance with the original or
modified terms of a debt instrument.
A loan commitment is a firm commitment to provide credit under specified terms and conditions. It is a binding promise from
a lender that a specified amount of loan or line of credit will be made available to the named borrower at a certain interest rate,
during a certain period and, usually, for a certain purpose.
Financial guarantee contracts and loan commitments at a below market interest rate are initially recognised when the group
becomes party to the irrevocable commitment at fair value, which is generally equal to the premium received, and then
amortised over the life of the financial guarantee/loan commitment. Financial guarantee contracts (that are not designated at
fair value through profit or loss) and loan commitments at a below market interest rate, are subsequently measured at the
higher of the:
■ ECL calculated for the financial guarantee/loan commitment; or
■ unamortised premium.
296 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 235 of 278 --
Derivatives and embedded derivatives
In the normal course of business, the group enters into a variety of derivative transactions for both trading and hedging
purposes. Derivative financial instruments are entered into for trading purposes and for hedging foreign exchange, interest
rate, inflation, credit, commodity and equity exposures. Derivative instruments used by the group in both trading and hedging
activities include swaps, options, forwards, futures and other similar types of instruments based on foreign exchange rates,
credit risk, inflation risk, interest rates and the prices of commodities and equities.
Derivatives are initially recognised at fair value. Derivatives that are not designated in a qualifying hedge accounting
relationship are classified as held-for-trading with all changes in fair value being recognised within trading revenue. This
includes forward contracts to purchase or sell commodities, where net settlement occurs or where physical delivery occurs
and the commodities are held to settle another derivative contract. All derivative instruments are carried as financial assets
when the fair value is positive and as financial liabilities when the fair value is negative.
Embedded derivatives included in hybrid instruments, where the host is a financial asset, are assessed in terms of the
accounting policy on financial assets. In all other instances (being non-financial host contracts and financial liabilities), the
embedded derivatives are treated and disclosed as separate derivatives when their economic characteristics and risks are not
closely related to those of the host contract, the terms of the embedded derivative are the same as those of a stand-alone
derivative and the combined contract is not measured at fair value through profit or loss. The host contract is accounted for
and measured applying the relevant group accounting policy.
The method of recognising fair value gains and losses on derivatives designated as a hedging instrument depends on the
nature of the hedge relationship.
Hedge accounting
The group continues to apply IAS 39 to its portfolio interest rate risk fair value hedges and applies IFRS 9 to all its other
hedges.
Derivatives, whether accounted for under IAS 39 or IFRS 9, are designated by the group into the following relationships:
Type of hedge Nature Treatment
Fair value hedges Hedges of the fair
value of
recognised
financial assets,
liabilities or firm
commitments.
Where a hedging relationship is designated as a fair value hedge, the hedged
item is adjusted for the change in fair value in respect of the risk being hedged.
Gains or losses on the remeasurement of both the derivative and the hedged
item are recognised in profit or loss. Fair value adjustments relating to the
hedging instrument are allocated to the same line item in profit or loss as the
related hedged item. Any hedge ineffectiveness is recognised in profit or loss.
If the derivative expires, is sold, terminated, exercised, no longer meets the
criteria for fair value hedge accounting, or the designation is revoked, then
hedge accounting is discontinued. The adjustment to the carrying amount of a
hedged item measured at amortised cost, for which the effective interest
method is used, is amortised to profit or loss as part of the hedged item’s
recalculated effective interest rate over the period to maturity.
Cash flow hedges Hedges of highly
probable future
cash flows
attributable to a
recognised asset
or liability, a
forecasted
transaction, or a
highly probable
forecast
intragroup
transaction.
The effective portion of changes in the fair value of derivatives that are
designated and qualify as cash flow hedges is recognised in the cash flow
hedging reserve.
The ineffective part of any changes in fair value is recognised in profit or loss.
Amounts recognised in OCI are transferred to profit or loss in the periods in
which the hedged forecast cash flows affect profit or loss. However, when the
forecast transaction that is hedged results in the recognition of a non-financial
asset or a non-financial liability, the cumulative gains or losses recognised
previously in OCI are transferred and included in the initial measurement of
the cost of the asset or liability.
If the derivative expires, is sold, terminated, exercised, no longer meets the
criteria for cash flow hedge accounting, or the designation is revoked, then
hedge accounting is discontinued. The cumulative gains or losses recognised
in OCI remain in OCI until the forecast transaction is recognised in the case of
a non-financial asset or a non-financial liability, or until the forecast
transaction affects profit or loss in the case of a financial asset or a financial
liability. If the forecast transaction is no longer expected to occur, the
cumulative gains and losses recognised in OCI are immediately reclassified to
profit or loss.
Net investment
hedges
Hedges of net
investments in a
foreign operation.
The designated component of the hedging instrument that relates to the
effective portion of the hedge, is recognised directly in the foreign currency
hedge of net investment reserve. The ineffective part of any changes in fair
value is recognised in profit or loss. The cumulative gains and losses in OCI are
accounted for similarly to cash flow hedges.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 297
-- 236 of 278 --
3. Financial instruments continued
Hedge accounting risk management strategy
Hedge accounting is applied when the hedging relationship meets the following hedge effectiveness requirements:
■ there is an economic relationship between the hedged item and the hedging instrument;
■ the effect of credit risk does not dominate the value changes that result from that economic relationship; and
■ the hedge ratio of the hedging relationship is the same as that resulting from the quantity of the hedged item that the entity
actually hedges and the quantity of the hedging instrument that the entity actually uses to hedge that quantity of hedged
item.
Where the above criteria are met, derivatives are classified as derivatives held-for-hedging and hedge accounting is applied to
remove the accounting mismatch between the derivative (hedging instrument) and the underlying instruments (hedged
item). All qualifying hedging relationships are designated as either fair value or cash flow for recognised financial assets or
liabilities, and highly probable forecast transactions. For hedge relationships, where the critical terms of the hedged item and
hedging instrument match, a qualitative method is considered appropriate for hedge effectiveness testing. Where the
characteristics between the hedged item and hedging instrument are insufficiently correlated, judgement is applied and if
required a qualitative and quantitative method is used for hedge effectiveness testing.
The group and company apply hedge accounting in respect of the following risk categories.
Foreign currency risk
The group operates internationally and is exposed to foreign exchange risk and translation risk. The below applies to both
cash flow hedges and net investment hedges of foreign operations.
Foreign exchange risk arises from recognised assets and liabilities and future highly probable forecast commercial
transactions denominated in a currency that is not the functional currency of the group. The risk is evaluated by measuring
and monitoring the net foreign monetary asset value and the forecast highly probable foreign currency income and
expenditures of the relevant group entity for each respective currency. Foreign currency risk is hedged with the objective of
minimising the earnings volatility associated with assets, liabilities, income and expenditure denominated in a foreign
currency.
Translation risk arises on consolidation from recognised assets and liabilities denominated in a currency that is not the
reporting currency of the group. The risk is evaluated by measuring and monitoring the net foreign non-monetary asset value
of the relevant group entity for each respective currency.
The group uses a combination of currency forwards, swaps and foreign-denominated cash balances to mitigate against the
risk of changes in the future cash flows and functional currency value on its foreign-denominated exposures. Under the
group’s policy, the critical terms of these instruments must align with the foreign currency risk of the hedged item and is
hedged on a 1:1 hedge ratio or where currency is managed on a portfolio basis the weighted expected foreign cash flows are
aligned.
The group elects for each foreign currency hedging relationship, using either foreign currency forwards and swaps, to either
include or exclude the time value or currency forward points (basis) contained in the derivative instrument from the hedging
relationship. This election is based on the currency pair involved, the shape of the yield-curve and the direction of the foreign
currency hedged risk. Basis is determined using the differential between the contracted forward rate and the spot market
exchange rate and is discounted, where material. Where the basis is excluded in the hedging relationship this is recognised as
a cost of the hedge and deferred in other comprehensive income (as a separate reserve within equity). Where the hedged item
subsequently results in the recognition of a non-financial asset or liability, or a firm commitment for a non-financial asset or
liability the group removes the amount from equity and includes it directly in the initial cost or other carrying amount of the
asset or the liability and amortises it to profit or loss on a systematic basis (where applicable). In all other cases, the amount is
reclassified to profit or loss.
Hedge effectiveness between the hedging instrument and the hedged item is determined at the inception of the hedge
relationship and through periodic effectiveness assessments to ensure that an economic relationship exists. For hedges of
foreign currency risk, the group and company enter hedge relationships where the critical terms of the hedging instrument
match exactly with the terms of the hedged item. If changes in circumstances affect the terms of the hedged item such that
the critical terms no longer match exactly with the critical terms of the hedging instrument, the group and company use the
hypothetical derivative method to assess effectiveness. In hedges of foreign currency risk of highly probable forecast
commercial transactions, ineffectiveness may arise if the amount of the forecast transaction changes from what was
originally estimated.
Where the basis is included in the hedging relationship this exposes the hedge relationship to hedge ineffectiveness.
298 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 237 of 278 --
Equity price risk
The group operates share incentive schemes that enable key management personnel and senior employees to benefit from
the performance of SBG’s share price. For further detail regarding the share schemes, refer to annexure D and the group’s
governance and remuneration report. These share incentive schemes expose the group and company to equity price risk due
to volatility in the share price of SBG (SBK:SJ). The group and company have in place appropriate risk management strategies
and reporting processes in respect of this risk.
The group uses a combination of equity forwards and options to mitigate against the risk of changes in the future cash flows
associated with certain cash-settled schemes on a post-attrition and vesting assumption basis. The following scheme
exposures are subject to cash flow hedge accounting at a group level: Deferred Bonus Scheme, Performance Reward Plan and
Cash-Settled Deferred Bonus Scheme. Cash flow hedge accounting is applied to align the timing mismatch of the derivative
hedging instruments to the vesting period of the underlying awards (hedged items) over the applicable vesting period.
Under the group’s policy the critical terms of these instruments must align with equity price risk of the hedged item and is
hedged on a 1:1 hedge ratio. The group elects for each hedging relationship, using either equity forwards and/or options, to
either include or exclude the time value or the forward points (basis) contained in the derivative instrument from the hedging
relationship. Basis is determined using the differential between the contracted forward rate and the spot market exchange
rate and is discounted, where material. Where the basis is excluded in the hedging relationship this is recognised as a cost of
the hedge and deferred in other comprehensive income (as a separate reserve within equity). Where the hedged item
subsequently results in recognition of a non-financial asset or liability, or a firm commitment for a non-financial asset or
liability the group removes the amount from equity and includes it directly in the initial cost or other carrying amount of the
asset or the liability and amortises it to profit or loss on a systematic basis (where applicable). In all other cases, the amount is
reclassified to profit or loss.
Hedge effectiveness between the hedging instrument and the hedged item is determined at the inception of the hedge
relationship and through periodic effectiveness assessments to ensure that an economic relationship exists. For hedges of
equity price risk, the group and company enter hedge relationships where the critical terms of the hedging instrument match
exactly with the terms of the hedged item. If changes in circumstances affect the terms of the hedged item such that the
critical terms no longer match exactly with the critical terms of the hedging instrument, the group and company use the
hypothetical derivative method to assess effectiveness. Refer to note 2.
Where the basis is included in the hedging relationship, this exposes the hedge relationship to hedge ineffectiveness.
Interest rate risk
Banking book-related market risk exposure principally involves managing the potential adverse effect of interest rate
movements on banking book earnings (IRRBB) (net interest income and banking book mark-to-market profit or loss) and the
economic value of equity. The group’s approach to managing IRRBB is governed by applicable regulations and is influenced by
the competitive environment in which the group operates.
The group’s treasury and capital management team monitors banking book interest rate risk on a monthly basis operating
under the oversight of group ALCO. The group and company’s interest rate risk management is predominantly controlled by a
central treasury department (group treasury) under approved policies. Group treasury identifies, evaluates and hedges
financial risks in close co-operation with the group’s operating units. The board provides written principles for overall risk
management, as well as policies covering specific areas, such as foreign exchange risk, interest rate risk, credit risk, use of
derivative financial instruments and non-derivative financial instruments, and investment of excess liquidity.
In adherence to policies regarding interest rate risk management the group applies fair value hedge accounting in respect of
the interest rate risk element only when present within the following exposures:
■ Specifically identified long-term fixed interest rate loans and advances, deposits and debt funding, subordinated debt and
financial investments. To manage the risk associated with such risk exposures the group uses one or more cash
collateralised fixed for floating interest rate swaps that match the critical terms or that exhibit the same duration as the
underlying risk exposure.
■ Specifically identified long-term interest rate basis risk (CPI versus JIBAR) inherent in loans and advances and financial
investments. To manage the basis risk associated with such risk exposures the group uses one or more cash collateralised
floating for floating basis interest rate swaps that match the critical terms or that exhibit the same duration as the
underlying risk exposure.
■ Portfolio interest rate risk present within a designated portfolio of loans and advances and deposits and debt funding.
Portfolio interest rate risk hedging is conducted on an aggregate asset and liability portfolio basis. The hedge ratio and
rebalancing frequency of portfolio hedges are determined using a dynamic approach reflecting the duration of portfolio
exposure in accordance with an exposure bucketing approach. The hedge ratio is monitored on a daily basis and where
necessary the portfolio is rebalanced using a dynamic approach.
The group also applies cash flow hedge accounting in respect of the interest rate risk element only, present within the
following exposures:
■ The bank manages interest rate volatility borne from rate insensitive liabilities and equity through a managed interest rate
hedge. The hedge is accounted for on a cash flow hedging basis using identified term floating interest rate loans and
advances. To manage the risk associated with such risk exposures the group uses one or more cash collateralised floating
for fixed interest rate swaps that aligns to governed risk appetite tenors. The hedge ratio and rebalancing frequency of
portfolio hedges is determined using a dynamic approach reflecting the duration of portfolio exposure in accordance with an
exposure bucketing approach. The hedge ratio is monitored on a daily basis and where necessary the portfolio is rebalanced
using a dynamic approach.
The group observes interest rate risk in respect of these exposures using an unfunded cash collateralised interest rate
derivatives discount curve. Hedge effectiveness between the hedging instrument and the hedged item is determined at the
inception of the hedge relationship and through periodic effectiveness assessments to ensure that an economic relationship
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 299
-- 238 of 278 --
Financial instruments continued
Interest rate risk continued
exists using regression analysis between the hedged items and the hedging instruments for sensitivity of changes to changes
in interest rate risk only. The group uses a combination of interest rate swaps and interest rate basis swaps to mitigate against
the risk of changes in market value of hedged items for changes in interest rates. The group elects for each fair value interest
rate risk hedging relationship, using swaps, to include forward points (basis) contained in the derivative instrument in the
hedging relationship. Where the basis is included in the hedging relationship this exposes the hedge relationship to hedge
ineffectiveness. The extent of hedge ineffectiveness as a result of fair value interest rate risk hedges is disclosed in note 2.3.5.
Other
Sale and repurchase agreements and lending of securities (including commodities)
Securities sold subject to linked repurchase agreements (repurchase agreements) are reclassified in the statement of
financial position as pledged assets when the transferee has the right by contract or custom to sell or repledge the collateral.
The liability to the counterparty is included under deposits and current accounts or trading liabilities, as appropriate.
Securities purchased under agreements to resell (reverse repurchase agreements), at either a fixed price or the purchase
price plus a lender’s rate of return, are recorded as loans and included under trading assets or loans and advances, as
appropriate. For repurchase and reverse repurchase agreements measured at amortised cost, the difference between the
purchase and sales price is treated as interest and amortised over the expected life using the effective interest method.
Securities lent to counterparties are retained in the annual financial statements. Securities borrowed are not recognised in the
annual financial statements unless sold to third parties. In these cases, the obligation to return the securities borrowed is
recorded at fair value as a trading liability. Income and expenses arising from the securities borrowing and lending business
are recognised over the period of the transactions.
Offsetting
Financial assets and liabilities are offset and the net amount reported in the statement of financial position when there is a
legally enforceable right to set off the recognised amounts and there is an intention to settle the asset and the liability on a net
basis, or to realise the asset and settle the liability simultaneously. The legally enforceable right must not be contingent on
future events and must be enforceable in the normal course of business and in the event of default, insolvency or bankruptcy
of the counterparties to the transaction.
300 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 239 of 278 --
4. Fair value
FAIR VALUE
Fair value hierarchy Inputs and valuation
techniques Portfolio valuations Day one profit
or loss
|
Hierarchy levels
Hierarchy transfer policy
In terms of IFRS, the group is either required to or elects to measure a number of its financial assets and financial liabilities at
fair value. Regardless of the measurement basis, the fair value is required to be disclosed, with some exceptions, for all
financial assets and financial liabilities.
Fair value is the price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction in the
principal (or most advantageous) market between market participants at the measurement date under current market
conditions. Fair value is a market-based measurement and uses the assumptions that market participants would use when
pricing an asset or liability under current market conditions. When determining fair value it is presumed that the entity is a
going concern and is not an amount that represents a forced transaction, involuntary liquidation or a distressed sale. In
estimating the fair value of an asset or a liability, the group takes into account the characteristics of the asset or liability that
market participants would take into account when pricing the asset or liability at the measurement date.
Fair value hierarchy
The group’s financial instruments that are both carried at fair value and for which fair value is disclosed are categorised by the
level of fair value hierarchy. The different levels are based on the degree to which the inputs to the fair value measurements
are observable and the significance of the inputs to the fair value measurement.
Hierarchy levels
The levels have been defined as follows:
Level 1
Fair value is based on quoted market prices (unadjusted) in active markets for an identical financial asset or liability. An active
market is a market in which transactions for the asset or liability take place with sufficient frequency and volume to provide
pricing information on an ongoing basis.
Level 2
Fair value is determined through valuation techniques based on observable inputs, either directly, such as quoted prices, or
indirectly, such as those derived from quoted prices. This category includes instruments valued using quoted market prices in
active markets for similar instruments, quoted prices for identical or similar instruments in markets that are considered less
than active or other valuation techniques where all significant inputs are directly or indirectly observable from market data.
Level 3
Fair value is determined through valuation techniques using significant unobservable inputs. This category includes all
instruments where the valuation technique includes inputs not based on observable data and the unobservable inputs have a
significant effect on the instrument’s valuation. This category includes instruments that are valued based on quoted prices for
similar instruments where significant unobservable adjustments or assumptions are required to reflect differences between
the instrument being valued and the similar instrument.
Hierarchy transfer policy
Transfers of financial assets and financial liabilities between levels of the fair value hierarchy are deemed to have occurred at
the end of the reporting period.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 301
-- 240 of 278 --
4. Fair value continued
Inputs and valuation techniques
Fair value is measured based on quoted market prices or dealer price quotations for identical assets and liabilities that are traded in
active markets, which can be accessed at the measurement date, and where those quoted prices represent fair value. If the market
for an asset or liability is not active or the instrument is not quoted in an active market, the fair value is determined using other
applicable valuation techniques that maximise the use of relevant observable inputs and minimise the use of unobservable inputs.
These include the use of recent arm’s length transactions, discounted cash flow analyses, pricing models and other valuation
techniques commonly used by market participants.
Fair value measurements are categorised into level 1, 2 or 3 within the fair value hierarchy based on the degree to which the inputs
to the fair value measurements are observable and the significance of the inputs to the fair value measurement.
Where discounted cash flow analyses are used, estimated future cash flows are based on management’s best estimates and a
market-related discount rate at the reporting date for an asset or liability with similar terms and conditions.
If an asset or a liability measured at fair value has both a bid and an ask price, the price within the bid-ask spread that is most
representative of fair value is used to measure fair value.
The fair value of the following items included in cash and cash equivalents is the same as the amortised cost value, as amortised cost
items are initially measured at fair value: cash and balances with central banks, cash balances with other banks within IAM as well as
on-demand gross loans and advances to banks which are readily convertible to a known amount of cash that hasn’t been adjusted
for expected credit losses. The fair value of these items of cash and cash equivalents as well as deposits and debt funding that are
mostly redeemable on demand does not change, as there are no adjustments made to these items subsequent to initial recognition.
These items are included in level 1 of the fair value hierarchy.
The group’s valuation control framework governs internal control standards, methodologies, and procedures over its valuation
processes, which include the following valuation techniques and main inputs and assumptions per type of instrument:
Item and description Valuation technique Main inputs and assumptions
Derivative financial instruments
Derivative financial instruments
comprise foreign exchange, interest
rate, commodity, credit and equity
derivatives that are either held-for-
trading or designated as hedging
instruments in hedge relationships.
Standard derivative contracts are
valued using market accepted models
and quoted parameter inputs. More
complex derivative contracts are
modelled using more sophisticated
modelling techniques applicable to the
instrument. Techniques include:
■ discounted cash flow model
■ Black-Scholes model
■ combination technique models.
For level 2 and 3 fair value hierarchy
items:
■ discount rate*
■ spot prices of the underlying
■ correlation factors
■ volatilities
■ dividend yields
■ earnings yield
■ valuation multiples
■ credit spreads
■ bid-offer spreads. Trading assets and trading liabilities
Trading assets and liabilities
comprise instruments which are part
of the group’s underlying trading
activities. These instruments
primarily include sovereign and
corporate debt, commodities,
collateral, collateralised lending
agreements and equity securities.
Where there are no recent market
transactions in the specific instrument,
fair value is derived from the last
available market price adjusted for
changes in risks and information since
that date.
Where a proxy instrument is quoted in
an active market, the fair value is
determined by adjusting the proxy fair
value for differences between the proxy
instrument and the financial investment
being fair valued.
Where proxies are not available, the fair
value is estimated using more complex
modelling techniques. These
techniques include discounted cash
flow and Black-Scholes models using
current market rates for credit, interest,
liquidity, volatility and other risks.
Combination techniques are used to
value unlisted equity securities and
include inputs such as earnings and
dividend yields of the underlying entity.
Pledged assets
Pledged assets comprise instruments
that may be sold or repledged by the
group’s counterparty in the absence
of default by the group. Pledged
assets include sovereign and
corporate debt, equities,
commodities pledged in terms of
repurchase agreements and
commodities that have been leased
to third parties.
Financial investments
Financial investments are non-trading
financial assets and primarily
comprise sovereign and corporate
debt, listed and unlisted equity
instruments, investments in
debentures issued by the SARB,
investments in mutual fund
investments and unit-linked
investments.
302 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 241 of 278 --
Item and description Valuation technique Main inputs and assumptions
Loans and advances to banks and
customers
Loans and advances comprise:
■ Home services
■ Vehicle and asset finance
■ Card and payments
■ Personal unsecured lending
■ Business lending and other
■ Corporate and sovereign
■ Bank
For certain loans, fair value may be
determined from the market price of a
recently occurring transaction adjusted for
changes in risks and information between
the transaction and valuation dates. Loans
and advances are reviewed for observed
and verified changes in credit risk and the
credit spread is adjusted at subsequent
dates if there has been an observable
change in credit risk relating to a particular
loan or advance. In the absence of an
observable market for these instruments,
discounted cash flow models are used to
determine fair value. Discounted cash flow
models incorporate parameter inputs for
interest rate risk, foreign exchange risk,
liquidity and credit risk, as appropriate. For
credit risk, probability of default and loss
given default parameters are determined
using credit default swaps (CDS) markets,
where available and appropriate, as well as
the relevant terms of the loan and loan
counterparty such as the industry
classification and subordination of the loan.
For level 2 and 3 fair value
hierarchy items
■ discount rate*
Deposits and debt funding
Deposits from banks and
customers comprise amounts
owed to banks and customers,
deposits under repurchase
agreements, negotiable
certificates of deposit, credit-
linked deposits and other
deposits.
For certain deposits, fair value may be
determined from the market price on a
recently occurring transaction adjusted for
all changes in risks and information
between the transaction and valuation
dates. In the absence of an observable
market for these instruments, discounted
cash flow models are used to determine fair
value based on the contractual cash flows
related to the instrument. The fair value
measurement incorporates all market risk
factors, including a measure of the group’s
credit risk relevant to that financial liability.
The market risk parameters are valued
consistently to similar instruments held as
assets stated in the section above. The
credit risk of the reference asset in the
embedded CDS in credit-linked deposits is
incorporated into the fair value of all credit-
linked deposits that are designated to be
measured at fair value through profit or
loss. For collateralised deposits that are
designated to be measured at fair value
through profit or loss, such as securities
repurchase agreements, the credit
enhancement is incorporated into the fair
valuation of the liability.
For level 2 and 3 fair value
hierarchy items
■ discount rate*
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 303
-- 242 of 278 --
4. Fair value continued
Inputs and valuation techniques continued
Item and description Valuation technique Main inputs and assumptions
Financial liabilities under
investment contracts
Financial liabilities under
investment contracts comprise
unit-linked policies and annuity
certains.
Unit-linked policies: assets which are linked to
the investment contract liabilities are owned
by the group. The investment contract
obliges the group to use these assets to settle
these liabilities. Therefore, the fair value of
investment contract liabilities is determined
with reference to the fair value of the
underlying assets (i.e. amount payable on
surrender of the policies).
The fair value of a unit-linked financial liability
is determined using the current unit price that
reflects the fair values of the financial assets
contained within the group’s unitised
investment funds linked to the financial
liability, multiplied by the number of units
attributed to the policyholder at the
statement of financial position date. If an
investment contract is subject to a put or
surrender option exercisable at the reporting
date, the fair value of the financial liability is
never less than the amount payable on the
put or surrender option. If a unit-linked
investment contract entitles the policyholder
to a share of assets over and above the
product of the number of units and the unit
price, for example a smoothed bonus
contract, this entitlement is included in the
value of the liability.
Annuity certains: discounted cash flow
models are used to determine the fair value of
the stream of future payments.
For level 2 and 3 fair value hierarchy
items
■ discount rate*
■ spot price of underlying
Third-party financial liabilities
arising on the consolidation of
mutual funds (included in
provisions and other liabilities)
These are liabilities that arise on
the consolidation of mutual funds.
The fair values of third-party financial
liabilities arising on the consolidation of
mutual funds are determined using the
quoted put (exit) price provided by the fund
manager and discounted for the applicable
notice period. The fair value of a financial
liability with a demand feature is not less than
the amount payable on demand, discounted
from the first date on which the amount could
be required to be paid.
For level 2 and 3 fair value hierarchy
items
■ discount rate*
* Discount rates, where applicable, include the risk-free rate, risk premiums, liquidity spreads, credit risk (own and counterparty as appropriate), timing of
settlement, storage/service costs, prepayment and surrender risk assumptions and recovery rates/loss given default.
Portfolio valuations
The group has elected the portfolio exception to measure the fair value of certain groups of financial assets and financial
liabilities. This exception permits the group of financial assets and financial liabilities to be measured at fair value on a net
basis, with the net fair value being allocated to the financial assets and financial liabilities.
Day one profit or loss
For financial instruments, where the fair value of the financial instrument differs from the transaction price, the difference is
commonly referred to as day one profit or loss. Day one profit or loss is recognised in profit or loss immediately where the fair
value of the financial instrument is either evidenced by comparison with other observable current market transactions in the
same instrument, or is determined using valuation models with only observable market data as inputs.
Day one profit or loss is deferred (and recognised together with the instrument it relates to) where the fair value of the
financial instrument is not able to be evidenced by comparison with other observable current market transactions in the same
instrument, or is determined using valuation models that utilise non-observable market data as inputs.
The timing of the recognition of deferred day one profit or loss is determined individually depending on the nature of the
instrument and availability of market observable inputs. It is either amortised over the life of the transaction, deferred until the
instrument’s fair value can be determined using market observable inputs, or realised through settlement.
304 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 243 of 278 --
5. Employee benefits
EMPLOYEE BENEFITS
Post-employment benefits Short-term benefits
|
Defined contribution plans
Defined benefit plans
Type and description
Statement of financial
position
Statement of other
comprehensive income Income statement
Defined contributions plans
The group operates a
number of defined
contribution plans. See
note 49 for more
information.
Accruals are recognised for
unpaid contributions.
No direct impact. Contributions are
recognised as an operating
expense in the periods
during which services are
rendered by the employees.
Defined benefit plans
The group operates a
number of defined benefit
retirement and post-
employment medical aid
plans. Employer
companies contribute to
the cost of benefits taking
account of the
recommendations of the
actuaries. See note 49 for
more information.
Assets or liabilities
measured at the present
value of the estimated future
cash outflows, using interest
rates of government bonds
denominated in the same
currency as the defined
benefit plan (corporate
bonds are used for
currencies for which there is
a deep market of high-
quality corporate bonds),
with maturity dates that
approximate the expected
maturity of the obligations,
less the fair value of plan
assets.
A net defined benefit asset is
only recognised to the extent
that economic benefits are
available to the group from
reductions in future
contributions or future
refunds from the plan.
Remeasurements of the net
defined benefit obligation,
including actuarial gains and
losses, the return on plan
assets (excluding interest
calculated) and the effect of
any asset ceiling are
recognised within OCI.
Net interest income/
(expense) is determined on
the defined benefit asset/
(liability) by applying the
discount rate used to
measure the defined benefit
obligation at the beginning
of the annual period to the
net defined benefit asset/
(liability).
Other expenses (including
current service costs)
related to the defined
benefit plans are also
recognised in operating
expenses.
When the benefits of a plan
are changed or when a plan
is curtailed, the resulting
change in benefit that
relates to past service or the
gain or loss on curtailment
is recognised immediately
in operating expenses.
The group recognises gains
and losses on the
settlement of a defined
benefit plan when the
settlement occurs.
Short-term benefits
Short-term benefits
consist of salaries,
accumulated leave
payments, profit share,
bonuses and any non-
monetary benefits such as
medical aid contributions.
A liability is recognised for
the amount expected to be
paid under short-term cash
bonus plans or accumulated
leave if the group has a
present legal or constructive
obligation to pay this
amount as a result of past
service provided by the
employee and the obligation
can be estimated reliably.
No direct impact. Short-term employee
benefit obligations are
measured on
an undiscounted basis and
are expensed in operating
expenses as the related
service is provided.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 305
-- 244 of 278 --
6. Non-financial assets
NON-FINANCIAL ASSETS
Tangible assets Intangible assets Investment property
| |
Property Goodwill
Equipment Computer software
Land Other intangible assets
Type and initial and
subsequent
measurement
Useful lives, depreciation/
amortisation method or fair value
basis Impairment
Tangible assets
(property, equipment and
land)
Property and equipment
are measured at cost
less accumulated
depreciation and
accumulated
impairment losses. Cost
includes expenditure
that is directly
attributable to the
acquisition of the asset.
Land is measured at cost
less accumulative
impairment losses.
Costs that are
subsequently incurred
are included in the
asset’s related carrying
amount or are
recognised as a separate
asset, as appropriate,
only when it is probable
that future economic
benefits will flow to the
group and the cost of the
item can be measured
reliably. Expenditure,
which does not meet
these criteria, is
recognised in operating
expenses as incurred.
Where significant parts
of an item of property or
equipment have
different useful lives,
they are accounted for
as separate major
components of property
and equipment.
Property and equipment are
depreciated on the straight-line basis
over estimated useful lives (see
below) of the assets to their residual
values. Land is not depreciated.
These assets are reviewed for impairment at each
reporting date and tested for impairment
whenever events or changes in circumstances
indicate that the carrying amount may not be
recoverable.
An impairment loss is recognised in non-trading
and capital related items for the amount by which
the asset’s carrying amount exceeds its
recoverable amount. The recoverable amount is
determined as the higher of an asset’s fair value
less costs to sell and value in use.
Fair value less costs to sell is determined by
ascertaining the current market value of an asset
and deducting any costs related to the realisation
of the asset.
In assessing value in use, the estimated future
cash flows are discounted to their present value
using a pre-tax discount rate that reflects current
market assessments of the time value of money
and the risks specific to the asset.
For the purposes of assessing impairment, assets
that cannot be tested individually are grouped at
the lowest CGUs.
Impairment losses recognised in respect of CGUs
are allocated first to reduce the carrying amount
of any goodwill allocated to the CGU, and then to
reduce the carrying amounts of the other assets
in the CGU on a pro rata basis. The carrying
amount of these other assets may, however, not
be reduced below the higher of the CGU’s fair
value less costs to sell and its value in use.
Impairment losses recognised in prior periods are
assessed at each reporting date for any
indications that the loss has decreased or no
longer exists. An impairment loss is reversed if
there has been a change in the estimates used to
determine the recoverable amount. An
impairment loss is reversed through non-trading
and capital related items only to the extent that
the asset’s carrying amount does not exceed the
carrying amount that would have been
determined, net of depreciation or amortisation, if
no impairment loss had been recognised.
Significant
freehold property
Ten years
Buildings 40 years
Computer
equipment
Four to five years
Motor vehicles Four to five years
Office equipment Three to ten years
Furniture Five to 13 years
Leased assets Shorter of useful
life or lease term
(refer section 9)
The residual values, useful lives and
the depreciation method applied are
reviewed, and adjusted if appropriate,
at each financial year end.
306 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 245 of 278 --
Type and initial and subsequent
measurement
Useful lives, depreciation/
amortisation
method or fair value basis Impairment
Goodwill
Goodwill represents the excess of the
consideration transferred and the
acquisition date fair value of any
previously held equity interest over the
group’s interest in the net fair value of the
identifiable assets, liabilities and
contingent liabilities of the acquired
subsidiary, associate or joint venture at
the date of the acquisition. The group’s
interest in acquired subsidiaries takes
into account any non-controlling interest.
Goodwill arising on the acquisition of
subsidiaries (associates) is reported in
the statement of financial position as part
of ʻGoodwill and other intangible
assets’ (ʻInterest in associates and joint
ventures’).
Not applicable. The accounting treatment is
generally the same as that for
tangible assets except as
noted below.
Goodwill is tested annually for
impairment and additionally
when an indicator of
impairment exists.
An impairment loss in respect
of goodwill is not reversed.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 307
-- 246 of 278 --
6. Non-financial assets continued
Type and initial and subsequent
measurement
Useful lives, depreciation/amortisation
method or fair value basis Impairment
Computer software
Costs associated with developing or
maintaining computer software
programmes and the acquisition of software
licences are generally recognised as an
expense as incurred.
However, direct computer software
development costs that are clearly
associated with an identifiable and unique
system, which will be controlled by the group
and have a probable future economic benefit
beyond one year, are recognised as
intangible assets.
Intangible assets are carried at cost less
accumulated amortisation and accumulated
impairment losses from the date that the
assets are available for use.
Expenditure subsequently incurred on
computer software is capitalised only when
it increases the future economic benefits
embodied in the specific asset to which it
relates.
Amortisation is recognised in operating
expenses on a straight-line basis at rates
appropriate to the expected lives of the
assets (two to 15 years) from the date
that the asset is available for use.
Amortisation methods, useful lives and
residual values are reviewed at each
financial year end and adjusted, if
necessary.
Intangible assets that
have an indefinite useful
life are tested annually for
impairment and
additionally when an
indicator of impairment
exists.
The accounting treatment
for computer software
and other intangible
assets is otherwise the
same as for tangible
assets.
Other intangible assets
The group recognises the costs incurred on
internally generated intangible assets such
as brands, customer lists, customer
contracts and similar rights and assets, in
operating expenses as incurred.
The group capitalises brands, customer lists,
customer contracts, distribution forces and
similar rights acquired in business
combinations.
Capitalised intangible assets are measured
at cost less accumulated amortisation and
accumulated impairment losses.
Amortisation is recognised in operating
expenses on a straight-line basis over the
estimated useful lives of the intangible
assets, not exceeding 20 years, from the
date that the asset is available for use.
Amortisation methods, useful lives and
residual values are reviewed at each
financial year end and adjusted, if
necessary.
Derecognition
Non-financial assets are derecognised on disposal or when no future economic benefits are expected from their use or
disposal. The gain or loss on derecognition is recognised in profit or loss and is determined as the difference between the
net disposal proceeds and the carrying amount of the non-financial asset.
Investment property
Initially measured at cost, including
transaction costs.
Subsequently measured at fair value and
included as part of investment management
and service fee income and gains within the
profit or loss.
The fair value is based on valuation
information at the reporting date.
If the valuation information cannot be
reliably determined, the group uses
alternative valuation methods such as
discounted cash flow projections or
recent prices in active markets.
Fair value adjustments recognised in
investment management and service fee
income and gains are adjusted for any
double-counting arising from the
recognition of lease income on the
straight-line basis compared to the
accrual basis normally assumed in the fair
value determination.
Derecognition
Investment property is derecognised on disposal or when no future economic benefits are expected from its use or
disposal. The gain or loss on derecognition is recognised in investment management and service fee income and gains
and is determined as the difference between the net disposal proceeds and the carrying amount of the non-financial
asset.
When the use of a property changes such that it is reclassified as property and equipment, its fair value at the date of
reclassification becomes its cost for subsequent accounting.
When the use of a property changes such that it is reclassified from property and equipment to investment property, the
difference between the carrying value at date of reclassification and its fair value is recognised in OCI.
308 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 247 of 278 --
7. Property developments and properties in possession
PROPERTY DEVELOPMENTS AND PROPERTIES IN POSSESSION
Property developments Properties in possession
Property developments
Property developments are stated at the lower of cost or net realisable value. Cost is assigned by specific identification and
includes the cost of acquisition and where applicable, development and borrowing costs during development.
Properties in possession
Properties in possession are properties acquired by the group which were previously held as collateral for underlying lending
arrangements that, subsequent to origination, have defaulted. The properties are initially recognised at cost and are
subsequently measured at the lower of cost and its net realisable value. Any subsequent write-down in the value of the
acquired properties as well as gains and losses on disposal is recognised as an operating expense. Any subsequent increases
in the net realisable value, to the extent that it does not exceed its original cost, are also recognised within operating expenses.
8. Equity-linked transactions
EQUITY COMPENSATION PLANS
Equity-settled share-based payments Cash-settled share-based payments
Equity-settled share-based payments
The fair value of the equity-settled share-based payments are determined on grant date and accounted for within operating
expenses (staff costs) over the vesting period with a corresponding increase in the group’s share-based payment reserve.
Non-market vesting conditions, such as the resignation of employees and retrenchment of staff, are not considered in the
valuation but are included in the estimate of the number of options expected to vest. At each reporting date, the estimate of
the number of options expected to vest is reassessed and adjusted against operating expenses and share-based payment
reserve over the remaining vesting period.
On vesting of the equity-settled share-based payments, amounts previously credited to the share-based payment reserve are
transferred to retained earnings through an equity transfer. On exercise of the equity-settled share-based payment, any
proceeds received are credited to share capital and premium.
Cash-settled share-based payments
Cash-settled share-based payments are accounted for as liabilities at fair value until the date of settlement. The liability is
recognised over the vesting period and is revalued at every reporting date up to and including the date of settlement. All
changes in the fair value of the liability are recognised in operating expenses (staff costs). The awards vest over the specified
period of service and/or once performance conditions are met.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 309
-- 248 of 278 --
9. Leases
Type and description Statement of financial position Income statement
Lessee accounting policies
Single lessee
accounting model
All leases are
accounted for by
recognising a right
of use asset and a
lease liability except
for:
■ leases of low
value assets and
■ leases with a
duration of twelve
months or less.
Lease liabilities:
Initially measured at the present value of the
contractual payments due to the lessor over
the lease term, with the discount rate
determined by reference to the rate implicit in
the lease unless (as is typically the case for the
group) this is not readily determinable, in
which case the group’s incremental
borrowing(rate of interest that the group
would have to pay to borrow over a similar
term, and with a similar security, the funds
necessary to obtain an asset of a similar value
to the right-of-use asset in a similar economic
environment) on commencement of the lease
is used. The group’s internal funding rate is the
base on which the incremental borrowing rate
is calculated. Variable lease payments are only
included in the measurement of the lease
liability if they depend on an index or rate. In
such cases, the initial measurement of the
lease liability assumes the variable element
will remain unchanged throughout the lease
term. Other variable lease payments are
expensed in the period to which they relate. On
initial recognition, the carrying value of the
lease liability also includes:
■ Amounts expected to be payable under any
residual value guarantee.
■ The exercise price of any purchase option
granted in favour of the group, should it be
reasonably certain that this option will be
exercised.
■ Any penalties payable for terminating the
lease, should the term of the lease be
estimated based on this termination option
being exercised.
Subsequent to initial measurement, lease
liabilities increase as a result of interest charged
at a constant rate on the balance outstanding
and are reduced for lease payments made.
Interest expense on lease liabilities:
A lease finance cost, determined with
reference to the interest rate implicit in the
lease or the group’s incremental borrowing
rate, is recognised within interest expense
over the lease period.
Right of use assets:
Initially measured at the amount of the lease
liability, reduced for any lease incentives
received, and increased for:
■ lease payments made at or before
commencement of the lease;
■ initial direct costs incurred; and
■ the amount of any provision recognised
where the group is contractually required to
dismantle, remove or restore the leased
asset.
The group applies the cost model (refer
section 6) subsequent to the initial
measurement of the right of use assets.
Depreciation and impairment on right of use
assets:
Subsequent to initial measurement, the right
of use assets are depreciated on a straight-
line basis over the remaining term of the lease
or over the remaining economic life of the
asset should this term be shorter than the
lease term unless ownership of the underlying
asset transfers to the group at the end of the
lease term, whereby the right of use assets
are depreciated on a straight-line basis over
the remaining economic life of the asset. This
depreciation is recognised as part of
operating expenses.
The accounting treatment for impairment of
right of use assets is the same as that for
tangible assets (refer section 6).
Termination of leases:
When the group or lessor terminates or
cancels a lease, the right of use asset and
lease liability are derecognised.
Termination of leases:
On derecognition of the right of use asset and
lease liability, any difference is recognised as
a derecognition gain or loss in profit or loss.
310 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 249 of 278 --
Type and description Statement of financial position Income statement
Lessee accounting policies continued
All leases that meet
the criteria as either a
lease of a low value
asset or a short-term
lease are accounted
for on a straight-line
basis over the lease
term.
Accruals for unpaid lease charges, together
with a straight-line lease asset or liability, being
the difference between actual payments and
the straight-line lease expense are recognised.
Payments made under these leases, net of any
incentives received from the lessor, are
recognised in operating expenses on a
straight-line basis over the term of the lease.
When these leases are terminated before the
lease period has expired, any payment
required to be made to the lessor by way of a
penalty is recognised as operating expenses in
the period in which termination occurs.
Reassessment and
modification of leases
Reassessment of lease terms and lease modifications that are not accounted for as a separate lease:
When the group reassesses the terms of any lease (i.e. it reassesses the probability of exercising an
extension or termination option) or modifies the terms of a lease without increasing the scope of the
lease or where the increased scope is not commensurate with the stand-alone price, it adjusts the
carrying amount of the lease liability to reflect the payments to be made over the revised term, which
are discounted at the applicable rate at the date of reassessment or modification. The carrying amount
of lease liability is similarly revised when the variable element of future lease payments dependent on a
rate or index is revised.
For reassessments to the lease terms, an equivalent adjustment is made to the carrying amount of the
right of use asset, with the revised carrying amount being depreciated over the revised lease term.
However, if the carrying amount of the right of use asset is reduced to zero any further reduction in the
measurement of the lease liability is recognised in profit or loss.
For lease modifications that are not accounted for as a separate lease, an equivalent adjustment is
made to the carrying amount of the right of use asset, with the revised carrying amount being
depreciated over the revised lease term. However, for lease modifications that decrease the scope of
the lease the carrying amount of the right of use asset is decreased to reflect the partial or full
termination of the lease, with any resulting difference being recognised in profit or loss as a gain or loss
relating to the partial or full termination of the lease.
Lease modifications that are accounted for as a separate lease:
When the group modifies the terms of a lease resulting in an increase in scope and the consideration
for the lease increases by an amount commensurate with a stand-alone price for the increase in
scope, the group accounts for these modifications as a separate new lease. This accounting
treatment equally applies to leases which the group elected the short-term lease exemption and the
lease term is subsequently modified.
Separating
components of a lease
contract
The group has elected to apply the practical expedient to not separate non-lease components from lease
components, and instead account for each lease component and any associated non-lease components as a
single lease component. The practical expedient is applied to each class of underlying asset.
Lessor accounting policies
Finance leases
Leases, where the
group transfers
substantially all the
risk and rewards
incidental to
ownership, are
classified as finance
leases
Finance lease receivable, including initial direct
costs and fees, are primarily accounted for as
financing transactions in banking, with rentals and
instalments receivable, less unearned finance
charges.
Finance charges earned within interest income
are computed using the effective interest
method, which reflects a constant periodic rate of
return on the investment in the finance lease. The
tax benefits arising from investment allowances
on assets leased to clients are accounted for
within direct taxation.
Operating leases
All leases that do not
meet the criteria of a
financial lease are
classified as operating
leases.
The asset underlying the lease continues to be
recognised and accounted for in terms of the
relevant group accounting policies. Accruals for
outstanding lease charges, together with a
straight-line lease asset or liability, being the
difference between actual payments and the
straight-line lease income are recognised. At the
end of the lease term, these assets are
reclassified from tangible assets to other assets
and measured at the lower of cost and net
realisable value.
Operating lease income net of any incentives
given to lessees, is recognised on the straight-line
basis, or a more representative basis where
applicable, over the lease term and is recognised
in operating income.
When an operating lease is terminated before the
lease period has expired, any payment received/
(paid) by the group by way of a penalty is
recognised as income/(expense) in the period in
which termination takes place.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 311
-- 250 of 278 --
Type and description Statement of financial position Income statement
Lessor lease modifications
Finance leases When the group modifies the terms of a lease resulting in an increase in scope and the
consideration for the lease increases by an amount commensurate with a stand-alone price for
the increase in scope, the group accounts for these modifications as a separate new lease.
All other lease modifications that are not accounted for as a separate lease are accounted for in
terms of IFRS 9, unless the classification of the lease would have been accounted for as an
operating lease had the modification been in effect at inception of the lease. These lease
modifications are accounted for as a separate new lease from the effective date of the
modification and the net investment in the lease becomes the carrying amount of the underlying
asset.
Operating leases Modifications are accounted for as a new lease from the effective date of the modification.
10. Equity
EQUITY
Re-acquired equity
instruments Share issue costs Dividends
Re-acquired equity instruments
Where subsidiaries purchase/(short sell) Standard Bank Group Limited’s equity instruments, the consideration paid/
(received) is deducted/(added) from/(to) equity attributable to ordinary shareholders as treasury shares on consolidation.
Fair value changes recognised by subsidiaries on these instruments are reversed on consolidation and dividends received are
eliminated against dividends paid. Where such shares are subsequently sold or reissued/(re-acquired) outside the group, any
consideration received/(paid) is included in equity attributable to ordinary shareholders.
The group irrevocably elects not to deduct from equity its treasury shares that it issues to subsidiaries that issue insurance
contracts with direct participation features. This election is made on an instrument-by-instrument basis. The group continues
to account for these treasury shares as equity and measures it at fair value through profit or loss (Refer to section 3 for the
policy on financial instruments measured at fair value through profit or loss).
Share issue costs
Incremental external costs directly attributable to a transaction that increases or decreases equity are deducted from equity,
net of related tax. All other share issue costs are expensed.
Dividends
Distributions are recognised in equity in the year in which they are declared. Distributions declared after the reporting date are
disclosed in the distributions note to the annual financial statements.
11. Provisions, contingent assets and contingent liabilities
PROVISIONS, CONTINGENT ASSETS AND CONTINGENT LIABILITIES
Provisions Contingent assets Contingent liabilities
|
Provisions for legal claims
Provisions
Provisions are recognised when the group has a present legal or constructive obligation as a result of past events, it is
probable that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation and a reliable
estimate of the amount of the obligation can be made. Provisions are determined by discounting the expected future cash
flows using a pre-tax discount rate that reflects current market assessments of the time value of money and the risks specific
to the liability. The group’s provisions typically (when applicable) include the following:
Provisions for legal claims
Provisions for legal claims are recognised on a prudent basis for the estimated cost for all legal claims that have not been
settled or reached conclusion at the reporting date. In determining the provision management considers the probability and
likely settlement (if any). Reimbursements of expenditure to settle the provision are recognised when and only when it is
virtually certain that the reimbursement will be received.
312 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 251 of 278 --
Provision for restructuring
A provision for restructuring is recognised when the group has approved a detailed formal plan, and the restructuring either
has commenced or has been announced publicly. Future operating costs or losses are not provided for.
Provision for onerous contracts
A provision for onerous contracts is recognised when the expected benefits to be derived by the group from a contract are
lower than the unavoidable cost of meeting its obligations under the contract. The provision is measured at the present value
of the lower of the expected cost of terminating the contract and the expected net cost of continuing with the contract. Before
a provision is established, the group recognises any impairment loss on the assets associated with that contract.
Contingent assets
Contingent assets are not recognised in the annual financial statements but are disclosed when, as a result of past events, it is
probable that economic benefits will flow to the group, but this will only be confirmed by the occurrence or non-occurrence of
one or more uncertain future events which are not wholly within the group’s control.
Contingent liabilities
Contingent liabilities include certain guarantees (other than financial guarantees) and letters of credit and are not recognised
in the annual financial statements but are disclosed in the notes to the annual financial statements unless they are considered
remote.
12. Insurance Contracts
INSURANCE CONTRACTS
Definition and
classification of
policyholder
contracts
Initial
recognition
Derecognition
and contract
modification
Measurement
approaches for
IFRS 17
insurance
contracts
Subsequent
measurement
| | |
Separating
components of
insurance and
reinsurance
contracts
Contract
modification
Insurance
acquisition cash
flow assets
Level of
aggregation of
insurance
contracts
Derecognition Future fulfilment
cash flows (FCF)
Contract boundary Discount rate
Risk adjustment
(RA)
CSM or loss
components (GMM
and VFA)
Revenue and
expenditure
Presentation
and disclosure Other
| |
Insurance revenue Other payables
Insurance service
expenses
Prepayments and
other receivables
Net income or
expenses from
reinsurance
contracts held
Notional Deferred
Acquisition Costs
(NDAC)
Insurance finance
income and
expenses
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 313
-- 252 of 278 --
IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts
All references to 'insurance contracts' in the accounting policies include insurance contract assets or liabilities and
reinsurance contract assets or liabilities, unless specifically stated otherwise.
Definition and classification of policyholder contracts
Insurance and investment contract classification
The group issues contracts that transfer either insurance risk or financial risk or, in some cases, both of these risk types.
An insurance contract is a contract under which the group (insurer) accepts significant insurance risk from the policyholder
by agreeing to compensate the policyholder if a specified uncertain future event (the insured event) adversely affects the
policyholder. Such contracts may also transfer financial risk.
The group determines insurance risk as significant if, and only if, an insured event could cause the group to pay additional
amounts that are significant in any single scenario, excluding scenarios that have no commercial substance, and that
possibility of a loss is measured on a present value basis.
Investment contracts are those contracts that transfer financial risk with no significant insurance risk. Financial risk is the risk
of a possible future change in one or more of the following variables: specified interest rate, financial instrument price,
commodity price, foreign exchange rate, index of prices or rates, credit rating or credit index or other variables, provided in
the case of a non-financial variable, that the variable is not specific to a party in the contract. Policyholder investments
contracts are recognised under IFRS 9 and are measured at fair value through profit or loss, with the exception of investment
contracts with discretionary participation features.
Insurance contracts with direct participating features are contracts for which, at inception, the contractual terms specify that
policyholders participate in a share of an identified pool of underlying items; the group expects to pay the policyholder a
substantial share of the fair value returns on the underlying items; and the group expects a substantial portion of changes on
the amounts to be paid to policyholders to vary with the change in the fair value of the underlying items.
All other insurance contracts are classified as contracts without direct participation features.
Discretionary participation features (DPF)
A number of insurance and investment contracts contain a DPF feature. This feature entitles the policyholder to receive, as a
supplement to guaranteed benefits, additional benefits at the discretion of the group. The terms and conditions or practice
relating to these contracts are in accordance with the group’s published Principles and Practices of Financial Management
(PPFM). The PPFM stipulates the principles that a long-term insurer must use in order to manage discretionary participation
business though their discretion in managing investments and allocating bonuses (subject to the advice of the head of
actuarial control function). Although a contract that exposes the issuer to financial risk without significant insurance risk is not
an insurance contract, financial investment contracts with DPFs are included in the scope IFRS 17 as these contracts are
deemed to have similar characteristics to insurance contracts and should be measured on the same basis, in the case where
the group also issues insurance contracts. All of the group's investment contracts with DPFs are included in the measurement
scope of IFRS 17.
An investment contract with DPF is defined as: A financial instrument that provides a particular investor with the contractual
right to receive, as a supplement to an amount not subject to the discretion of the issuer, additional amounts:
■ that are likely to be a significant portion of the total contractual benefits;
■ whose amount or timing is contractually at the discretion of the issuer; and
■ that are contractually based on:
– the performance of a specified pool of contracts or a specified type of contact; and /or
– realised and/or unrealised investment returns on a specified pool of assets held by the group; or
– the profit or loss of the entity or fund that issues the contract.
Reinsurance contracts
Reinsurance contracts are insurance contracts issued by a reinsurer to compensate the group for claims arising from one or
more insurance contracts issued by the group (underlying contracts).
The group enters into reinsurance contracts whereby it cedes insurance risk (e.g. mortality and morbidity risks) to the
reinsurer. As the benefit payable under the reinsurance contract is contingent on an uncertain future event that adversely
affects the policyholder, the group is ceding insurance risk to the reinsurer and hence the reinsurance contract falls within the
scope of IFRS 17.
314 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 253 of 278 --
Separating components of insurance and reinsurance contracts
An insurance contract may also contain one or more components that would be within the scope of another IFRS standard if
they were separate contracts, that is there may be a distinct non-insurance component that should be separated from the
contract and accounted for under a separate IFRS standard.
The group has assessed all of its insurance contracts to see if there are any distinct investment components, embedded
derivatives or any promises to provide distinct goods or services other than insurance contract services that need to be
separated from the host contract and accounted for under other standards (for example, IFRS 9 or IFRS 15 Revenue from
Contracts with Customers).
Whilst distinct investment components and/or embedded derivatives are contained in certain insurance contracts issued by
the group, they are deemed to be closely related to the host insurance contract as the distinct investment component and/or
embedded derivative and host insurance contracts are so interdependent that they cannot be measured separately from the
host insurance contract.
The group, besides non-insurance service components included in the group’s Stansure and Home Owners Cover (HOC)
products as well as pension fund administration services provided to pension funds (accounted for under IFRS 15) does not
provide distinct goods or services other than insurance contract services that need to be separated from the host contract
and accounted for under other applicable standards.
Separating investment components for disclosure
Some contracts include an amount that meet the definition of a 'non-distinct investment component' (NDIC) under IFRS 17.
The NDIC is the amount that an insurance contract requires the group to repay to a policyholder in all circumstances,
regardless of whether an insured event occurs. These investment components are highly inter-related with the insurance
contract and are not unbundled on contract inception. The investment component has been determined as amounts
accumulated to the policyholder through deposits that are repaid to the policyholder in all circumstances, either on lapse or
maturity of the contract. The NDIC is included in the measurement of insurance contracts on the statement of financial
position but is excluded from insurance revenue and insurance service expenses in the statement of comprehensive income
when they are paid to the policyholder or beneficiary, as they do not relate to the provision of insurance services. The group
does not have any non-distinct investment components on its reinsurance contracts.
Separating fixed fee service components
The group’s accounting policy choice is to apply IFRS 17 to fixed fee service contracts (i.e. the group will not unbundle services
provided for a fee in terms of IFRS 15, but will include the fixed fee in the IFRS 17 recognition and measurement principles for
each contract). The accounting policy choice is applied on a contract-by-contract basis, with the choice for each contract
being irrevocable.
The group applies this accounting policy as the following conditions are met:
■ The group does not reflect an assessment of the risk associated with an individual customer in setting the price of the
contract with that customer;
■ The contract compensates the customer by providing services, rather than by making cash payments to the customer; and
■ The insurance risk transferred by the contract arises primarily from the customer’s use of services rather than uncertainty
over the cost of those services.
Level of aggregation of insurance contracts
Insurance contracts are allocated to portfolios, which, for the purposes of measurement and disclosure, are then further sub-
divided into groups of insurance contracts and cohorts (as described below) based on the expected profitability or loss of the
contract, and the date of initial recognition.
Portfolios
The group has identified portfolios of insurance contracts, which are those contracts that are subject to similar risks and are
managed together. Judgement is required when determining whether risks are similar and managed together. The group has
generally defined the portfolio at the product line.
For reinsurance, one reinsurance treaty may cover a range of risks and /or benefits. Although the legal form is one contract,
the components can be separated and therefore they are measured at benefit level. Reinsurance contracts within a product
line have similar risks and are managed together and hence the portfolio for reinsurance is aligned to the underlying
product lines.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 315
-- 254 of 278 --
Groups
For the purposes of the measurement calculation, these portfolios need to be further divided into groups, depending on
profitability, with a minimum of:
■ a group of contracts that are onerous on initial recognition;
■ a group of contracts that at initial recognition have no significant possibility of becoming onerous subsequently, if any; and,
■ a group of the remaining contracts in the portfolio, if any.
The group performs a per contract assessment to allocate it to the appropriate profitability grouping. When a new contract is
recognised, it is added to an existing group of contracts or, if the contract does not qualify for inclusion in an existing group, it
forms a new group to which future contracts are added. Groups of contracts are established at initial recognition and not re-
assessed once all contracts have been added to the group. For contracts measured under the premium allocation approach
(PAA), the group has assumed, in line with what is permitted by IFRS 17, that no contracts are onerous at inception, unless
facts and circumstances indicated otherwise.
Regarding reinsurance contracts, the references to onerous contracts are replaced with references to contracts on which
there is a net gain on initial recognition.
IFRS 17 introduces the loss recovery component for reinsurance contracts, which brings an allowable offset through the
income statement between onerous underlying contracts and the reinsurance held on those onerous groups. If at inception,
the reinsurance best estimate fulfilment cash flows plus risk adjustment plus the loss recovery component is negative, the
reinsurance contract is a net gain. If it is positive, then the reinsurance contract is a net loss at inception.
Cohorts
In addition to this required grouping above, the group is not permitted to include contracts issued more than one year apart in
the same group. The group has elected to combine contracts in the same annual calendar year at initial recognition. The
recognition and measurement requirements are then applied to these groups of contracts.
Contract boundary
Cash flows are within the boundary of an insurance contract if they arise from substantive rights and obligations that exist
during the reporting period in which the group can compel the policyholder to pay the premiums or has a substantive
obligation to provide the policyholder with insurance contract services. The identification of contract boundaries determines
which cash flows should be included in the measurement of the insurance contracts.
A substantive obligation ends when the group has the practical ability to reprice the risks of the particular policyholder or
change the level of benefits so that the price fully reflects those risks; or the group has the practical ability to reprice the
contract or a portfolio of contracts so that the price fully reflects the reassessed risk of that portfolio; and the pricing of
premiums for coverage up to the date when risks are reassessed does not reflect the risks related to periods beyond that
reassessment date. IFRS 17 does not limit pricing constraints to contractual, legal and regulatory constraints. Market
competitiveness and commercial considerations are factors that the group typically considers when pricing new contracts
and repricing existing contracts.
For contracts where premiums before the reassessment date are calculated to fund risks beyond the reassessment date, the
boundary on these contracts extends beyond the reassessment date. Thus, for contracts where premiums early on in the
contract are designed to be higher relative to the risk while premiums later on are lower relative to the risk, (e.g. for level
premium payment patterns), even if premiums are reviewed at a reassessment date, the contract will not end at that point but
rather extend beyond the reassessment date.
In assessing the contract boundary for investment contracts with discretionary participation features, cash flows are within
the contract boundary if they result from a substantive obligation of the group to deliver cash at a present or future date. The
substantive obligation ends when the group reprices the contract so that the new price fully reflects the promise to deliver
cash in the future and the related risks.
With the exclusion of embedded bancassurance credit and corporate group risk (as well as property and casualty insurance
business), most of the contracts sold by the group and the corresponding reinsurance have long contract boundaries (i.e.
greater than 12 months). Where there are annual reprice clauses, the contracts and the corresponding reinsurance are
classified as having a short contract boundary (i.e. contract boundary of 12 months or less).
The group does not recognise a liability or an asset for any amounts relating to expected premiums or expected claims
outside the boundary of the insurance contract as these amounts relate to future insurance contracts.
For reinsurance contracts held, cash flows are within the contract boundary if they arise from substantive rights and
obligations of the group that exist during the period in which the group is compelled to pay amounts to the reinsurer or in
which the group has a substantive right to receive insurance contract services from the reinsurer. A substantive right to
receive services from the reinsurer ends when the reinsurer has the practical ability to reassess the risks transferred to the
reinsurer and can set a price or level of benefits for the contract to fully reflect the reassessed risk.
The contract boundary for reinsurance also takes into account the group's substantive right to stop writing new business with
the reinsurer or for the reinsurer to accept business; and the period of time over which the substantive right to receive
services and the substantive obligation to pay amounts to the reinsurer for each underlying policy sold exist. Most of the
group’s reinsurance contracts have a contract boundary of three months, being the notice period for new business, and have
a longer coverage period, which is typically in line with that of the underlying contracts.
316 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 255 of 278 --
Initial recognition
An assessment of significant insurance risk is made only once, being at contract inception. If a contract is deemed to be within
the scope of IFRS 17, it remains an insurance contract until all rights and obligations are extinguished (i.e. discharged,
cancelled or expired) or until the contract is derecognised because of a contract modification.
Groups of insurance contracts issued are initially recognised from the earliest of the following:
a. the beginning of the coverage period of the group of contracts (the period during which the group provides services in
respect of any premiums within the boundary of the contract);
b. the date when the first payment from the policyholder in the group becomes due (or when it is actually received, if there is
no due date); and
c. when the group determines that a group of contracts becomes onerous.
The date of initial recognition for most risk business is when the coverage period starts (for example, contracts where the
group is on risk from the inception date even when no premium has been received yet). Coverage period is the period during
which the group provides coverage for insured events. This period includes the coverage that relates to all premiums within
the boundary of the insurance contract. In limited instances, for example, certain motor warranty products, recognition
occurs at the date when the first payment is contractually due, which is earlier than when the coverage period commences.
For investment type business (that are in scope of IFRS 17, including investment contracts with a return of contribution of
premiums on death), initial recognition is the date when the group becomes a party to the contract, which is usually when the
first premium is received.
For a group of reinsurance contracts held that cover the losses of separate insurance contracts on a proportionate basis the
initial recognition is recognised at the later of:
a. the beginning of the coverage period of the group of reinsurance contracts held; or
b. the initial recognition of any underlying insurance contract.
For a group of reinsurance contracts held that covers aggregate losses from underlying contracts in excess of a specified
amount (non-proportionate reinsurance contracts, such as excess of loss reinsurance), the initial recognition is the earlier of
the date of the beginning of the coverage period of that group of reinsurance contracts held and the date that the group
recognises an onerous group of underlying insurance contracts.
Derecognition and contract modification
Contract modification
Where the terms of an insurance contract are modified, the group derecognises the original contract and recognises a new
contract, applying IFRS 17 or other applicable standard. In order for it to be treated as a modification, it needs to meet certain
conditions, which are assessed based on whether the terms of the modification were included in the original contract, and
whether that would, for example, lead to a different contract boundary. In addition, if the change in terms would impact
whether the original contract was still eligible for the premium allocation approach or changed the analysis of whether the
contract was an insurance contract with a DPF, the modification principles would be applied. If the change in terms does not
meet the modification criteria, any changes on the cash flows caused by the changed terms are treated as changes in
estimates of fulfilment cash flows. In determining estimates of future cash flows at the reporting date, the group reassesses
an insurance contract’s boundary to include the effect of changes in circumstances on the group’s substantive rights and
obligations.
Derecognition
An insurance contract is derecognised when and only when, it meets the modification criteria as above, or it is extinguished,
that is the obligation specified in the contract expires, discharged or is cancelled.
On derecognition of a contract, from within a group of contracts not measured under the PAA, the group eliminates the
present value of fulfilment cash flows and risk adjustment related to the rights and obligations of the insurance contract being
derecognised and adjusts any remaining contractual service margin (if applicable), reducing the number of coverage units in
the group to reflect the remaining number without that specific insurance contract.
On derecognition of a contract, from within a group of contracts measured under the PAA, the difference in fulfilment cash
flows is recognised in profit or loss.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 317
-- 256 of 278 --
Measurement approaches for IFRS 17 insurance contracts
The measurement approaches refer to the models prescribed for valuing the IFRS 17 defined insurance contracts and impact
how the amounts are recognised in the income statement over time. Insurance revenue is recognised over the duration of the
contracts that best reflects the delivery of the contracted obligations in the reporting period.
For all measurement approaches, the total insurance contract asset or liability is the sum of:
a. the LRC, the group's obligation to investigate and pay valid claims under existing insurance contracts for insured events
that have not yet occurred (i.e. the obligation that relates to the unexpired portion of the insurance coverage) and pay
amounts under existing insurance contracts that are not included as above, and relate to insurance contract services not
yet provided (i.e. the obligations that relate to future provisions of insurance contract services) or any investment
components or other amounts that are not related to the future provision of insurance contract services and that have not
been transferred to the LIC.
b. the LIC, which is the group’s obligation to investigate and pay valid claims for insured events that have already occurred,
including events that have occurred but have not been reported and other incurred insurance expenses; and to pay
amounts that relate to insurance contract services that have already been provided, or any investment components or
other amounts that are not related to the provision of insurance contract services and that are not in the LRC).
c. the asset for insurance acquisition cash flows, which is directly attributable acquisition costs in establishing product lines
incurred by the group prior to a group of insurance contracts being recognised.
All components of the LRC are grouped together in the applicable cohorts for initial and subsequent measurement. On initial
recognition, the LRC for GMM and VFA contracts consists of:
■ Fulfilment cash flows (FCF), comprising current estimates of future cash flows (within the boundary of the contract), an
adjustment that reflects the time value of money and the financial risks related to future cash flows to the extent that
financial risks are not included in the estimates of the FCF;
■ An explicit risk adjustment (RA) for non-financial risk; and
■ A contractual service margin (CSM) (if applicable) which represents the unearned profit from the contract which is
recognised in the income statement as the group provides insurance contract services, over the coverage period. The CSM
as defined can never be negative.
On initial recognition, the LRC for PAA contracts consists of:
■ Premiums received at initial recognition, if any;
■ Reduced by any insurance acquisition cash flows at that date;
■ Derecognition gains or losses of the asset or liability for insurance acquisition cash flows that the group incurs or receives
before the group of insurance contracts is recognised; and
■ Any other asset or liability previously recognised for cash flows related to the group of contracts that the group incurs or
receives before the group of insurance contracts is recognised.
For all reinsurance contracts, the total reinsurance contract asset or liability is the sum of:
a. the ARC, if the contract is still in the coverage period; and
b. the ARIC, if the insured event has occurred.
The group measures reinsurance contracts on the same basis as insurance contracts issued (adapted to reflect any different
features related to reinsurance contracts).
The measurement approaches used for insurance and reinsurance contracts is appropriate for the terms and conditions and
the characteristics of the insurance or reinsurance contract held being measured. Consistent assumptions are used to
measure the estimates used in measuring the groups of reinsurance contracts held with those estimates used to measuring
the groups of underlying insurance contracts. The allocation of contracts to each measurement approach is dictated by IFRS
17, although there is an element of judgement in certain cases, as well as a permitted simplification if prescribed eligibility
criteria are met. Due to the different types of contracts that the group issues, it applies all three measurement approaches
described in IFRS 17, being the GMM, the PAA (optional) and the VFA. Once determined, the measurement approach may not
change unless there is a contract modification which results in a change.
When applying IAS 21 The Effects of Changes in Foreign Exchange Rates to a group of insurance contracts that generate cash
flows in a foreign currency, the group treats the group of contracts, including the CSM, as a monetary item.
318 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 257 of 278 --
The table below describes the commonalities and key differences between each approach:
Approach Detail
GMM Methodology prescribed by IFRS 17 for insurance contracts which are not substantially investment related service
contracts i.e. predominantly risk type contracts and annuities. This methodology is also used to measure reinsurance
contracts (unless for both cases, the group may apply the PAA measurement).
On initial recognition, applying the GMM, a group of insurance contracts are measured as the total of
a) The fulfilment cash flows which comprises:
■ Estimates of future cash flows;
■ An adjustment to reflect the time value of money and the financial risks related to the future cash flows, to the extent
that the financial risks are not included in the estimates of the future cash flows; and
■ A risk adjustment (RA) for non-financial risk; and
■ The contractual service margin (CSM).
b) The group recognises a CSM (where appropriate) which is essentially a provision for unearned profit (where the
contract is assessed as profitable) measured on contract inception, and which is released over the contract term in
line with the level of service provided by the group.
If, at inception of a contract, the total fulfilment cash flows result in an expected net outflow, the group of insurance
contracts is considered onerous. A loss from the onerous group is recognised immediately in profit or loss, with no CSM
recognised on initial recognition. The loss component represents losses and reversal of losses on onerous groups and is
consequently excluded from the determination of insurance revenue.
The discount rates determined at the date of initial recognition of a group of contracts is termed the 'locked-in' rate as it
is the rate that is locked-in for accreting the contractual service margin for insurance contracts without participating
features. In order to determine the discount rates at the date of initial recognition of a group of contracts, the group has
used a weighted-average discount rate over the period that contracts in the group are issued. All other probability-
weighted estimates of cash flows contained in the measurement of insurance assets or liabilities are measured at
current discount rates. The discount rate applied in the future fulfilment cash flows reflects the time value of money, the
characteristics of the cash flows and the liquidity characteristics of the insurance contracts, is consistent with
observable current market price (if any) for financial instruments with cash flows whose characteristics are consistent
with those of the insurance contracts, and excludes the effects of factors that influence such observable market prices
but do not affect the future cash flows of the insurance contracts.
VFA The VFA applies only to insurance contracts with direct participating features and is not applicable for the measurement
of reinsurance contracts. The approach is used for contracts that are substantially investment-related service contracts
but are measured under IFRS 17 as they include an integral insurance benefit, for example a retirement annuity that may
include a product benefit of a minimum return of contributions on death. Investment contracts with discretionary
participation features are scoped into the IFRS 17 standard, and the group also applies the VFA measurement model to
measure such contracts, should such contracts meet the criteria for VFA.
Insurance contracts with direct participation features create an obligation to pay policyholders an amount that is equal
to the fair value of the underlying items, less a variable fee to the insurer for service. The variable fee is the amount of the
group’s share of the fair value of the underlying items, less the future cash flows that do not vary based on the returns of
the underlying items.
The VFA approach also includes the total of fulfilment cash flows (future cash flows) discounted to present the time
value of time and financial risks, plus a risk adjustment for non-financial risk, plus a CSM. The main difference between
the VFA and the GMM is how the CSM is impacted over time. The group’s share of the fair value returns on the
underlying items is included in the CSM, and the CSM is updated using current estimates. The group is required to
justify the classification into VFA through conditions demonstrating policyholder participation and an analysis of the
investment benefits versus the total expected benefits.
PAA The PAA is a simplification of the GMM approach for contracts with a coverage periods of 12 months or less, or where
they meet the PAA eligibility criteria (for both insurance and reinsurance contracts). The eligibility criteria is met if, at
inception of the group of contracts, it is expected that the simplification would produce a measurement of the liability for
remaining coverage for that group of contracts that would not differ materially from that had the simplified
measurement approach not been applied. The key difference therefore is how the liability for remaining coverage is
measured, with the PAA. This approach avoids the complexities associated with updating a CSM (as there is no CSM)
and estimating future claims.
Once a contract is eligible for the PAA, it is the group's choice whether to elect it or not (an accounting policy election at
inception of the contract). Although the calculation of the LRC is different to that used for those contracts measured
under the GMM measurement approach, the LIC approach is the same for both measurement models.
If at inception a group of contracts is considered to be onerous, a loss will immediately be recognised in profit or loss
and increase the liability for remaining coverage.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 319
-- 258 of 278 --
Insurance acquisition cash flow assets
Prior to a group of insurance contracts being recognised, the group may incur directly attributable acquisition costs in
establishing product lines (i.e., before the products are launched). Acquisition cash flows are defined as cash flows that arise
from selling, underwriting and starting a group of insurance contracts (issued or expected to be issued) and that are directly
attributable to the portfolio of insurance contracts to which the group belongs. When such costs are considered to be directly
attributable, the allocation to groups of contracts is performed on a systematic and rational basis. These balances are
recognised as insurance acquisition cash flow assets before the related group of insurance contracts is recognised. Any
deferred acquisition cost asset is subsequently derecognised when the underlying contracts are recognised and recognised
as part of the measurement of the LRC. These insurance acquisition cash flows not yet allocated to any specific groups are
assessed for recoverability if facts and circumstances indicate that the asset may be impaired, with any impairment losses
reducing the carrying amount of the assets and recognised in insurance service expenses. Reversals of such impairments are
permitted, to the extent that the impairment conditions are no longer met, and subsequently increase the carrying value of the
deferred acquisition cost asset.
Future fulfilment cash flows (FCF)
Fulfilment cash flows comprise of:
■ Estimates of future cash flows;
■ An adjustment to reflect the time value of money and financial risks related thereto, to the extent that financial risks are not
included in the estimate of future cash flows; and
■ A risk adjustment (RA) for non-financial risk.
The current estimate of future cash flows depends on the assessment of the contract boundary term for the specific
contracts and the determination of expenses that relate directly to the fulfilment of the contract. The estimates are based on
an unbiased and probability-weighted mean of the full range of possible outcomes, determined from a perspective of the
group, provided that where estimates are observable, they are consistent with observable market data. The estimates are
always updated for current assumptions at measurement dates. The estimation of future cash flows includes expected
premiums, expected claims and benefit payments, an allocation of insurance acquisition cash flows attributable to the
portfolio to which the contract belongs, claims handling costs, policy administration costs, an allocation of fixed and variable
overheads directly attributable to fulfilling insurance contracts and transaction-based taxes. The group estimates certain
future cash flows at the portfolio level or higher and subsequently allocates such estimates to group of contracts.
Reinsurance contracts held - fulfilment cash flows
The measurement of cash flows for reinsurance contracts follows the same principles as for insurance contracts, with the
standard requiring consistent assumptions to measure the estimates of the present value of the future cash flows for the
group of reinsurance contracts held and the estimates of the present value of the future cash flows for the group(s) of
underlying insurance contracts. However, it does include an allowance on a probability-weighted basis for the effect of non-
performance by the reinsurer. The reinsurance fulfilment cash flows include reinsurance premiums (including premium
discounts), rebates, reinsurance claims, profit sharing and reinsurance expenses.
Discount rate
The discount rate applied to reflect the time value of money for the FCF reflects the characteristics of the cash flows and the
liquidity characteristics of the insurance contracts. The discount rate applied by the group is consistent with observable
current market prices (if any) for financial instruments with cash flows whose characteristics are consistent with those of the
insurance contract in terms of for example, timing currency and liquidity. IFRS 17 allows for two methods to determine
discount rates for cash flows of insurance contracts that do not vary based on the returns of the underlying items. The
bottom-up approach determines discount rates by adjusting a liquid risk-free yield curve to elect the differences between the
liquidity characteristics of the financial instruments that underlie the rates observed in the market and the liquidity
characteristic of the insurance contracts. The top-down approach determines the appropriate discount rates for insurance
contracts based on a yield curve that reflects the current market rates of return implicit in a fair value measurement for a
reference portfolio of assets.
Risk adjustment (RA)
The RA is an explicit, current adjustment to compensate the group for bearing non-financial risk (that is, insurance risk), that
is a deferral of margin to cover the risk of variation to the estimated cash flows. The risk adjustment is released over the
duration of the coverage period in line with reduction of the estimated risk. An explicit risk adjustment for non-financial risk is
estimated separately from other estimates. The group has adopted in the main the cost of capital approach to determine the
amount of the risk adjustment. Generally longer duration contracts are considered more risky than shorter contracts.
The other methodologies being used by the group to determine the risk adjustment all require a confidence level to be
specified upfront. This includes the provision for adverse deviation on contracts measured under the GMM and the VFA.
Risk adjustment – reinsurance
For reinsurance contracts held, the risk adjustment for non-financial risk represents the amount of risk being transferred to
the reinsurer.
320 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 259 of 278 --
CSM or loss components (GMM and VFA)
The CSM at initial recognition is the component of the insurance contract liability or asset representing the unearned profit
that the group expects to recognise over the period that it provides insurance cover. The CSM is the amount recognised that
results in zero income on day one, after taking into account the measurement of the total FCF.
If, at inception of a contract, the total FCF and RA result in an expected net outflow, the group of insurance contracts is
considered onerous. If an onerous group of contracts is expected at inception, a loss component will be recognised, and the
loss is recognised immediately in the income statement. Accordingly, no CSM is recognised related to those contracts on the
statement of financial position on day one. A loss component is created for this net cash flow, which determines the amounts
that are subsequently presented in profit or loss as reversals on onerous groups. These amounts are not included in insurance
revenue.
When a loss component exists, the group allocates the following between the loss component and the remaining component
of the LRC for the respective group of contracts, based on the ratio of the loss component to the FCF relating to the expected
future cash outflows:
a. expected incurred claims and expenses for the period;
b. changes in the risk adjustment for non-financial risk for the risk expired; and
c. finance income or expenses from insurance contracts issued.
The amounts of loss component allocation in a) and b) above reduce the respective components of insurance revenue and are
reflected in insurance service expenses.
Decreases in the FCF in subsequent periods reduce the remaining loss component and reinstate the CSM after the loss
component is reduced to zero. Increases in the FCF in subsequent periods increase the loss component.
CSM or loss components – reinsurance
For groups of reinsurance held (applicable to GMM), a CSM is raised regardless of whether it results in a positive or negative
value. The CSM represents a net gain or cost that the group will recognise as a reinsurance expense as it receives insurance
contract services from the reinsurer in the future. Reinsurance contracts cannot be onerous, which is a key difference
between measuring reinsurance and the underlying contracts. The reinsurance CSM is the total of the reinsurance FCF and
reinsurance RA at initial recognition. It is measured as the equal and opposite amount of the total of (a) the fulfilment cash
flows, (b) any amount arising from the derecognition of any assets or liabilities previously recognised for cash flows related to
the group, (c) any cash flows arising at that date and (d) any income recognised in profit or loss because of onerous
underlying contracts recognised at that date.
However, if any net cost on purchasing reinsurance coverage relates to insured events that occurred before the purchase of
the group, then the Group recognises the cost immediately in profit or loss as an expense.
Subsequent measurements
Subsequent measurement - GMM and VFA
After initial recognition, the carrying value of insurance contracts is the total of the LRC and LIC.
The carrying value of the LRC for GMM and VFA contracts consists of:
■ The updated measurement of the FCF;
■ The remaining RA for non-financial risk (that is, per groups of contracts, the amount of the RA that has not yet been
released over the contact duration in line with reduction of the estimated risk); and
■ Any remaining CSM (if applicable).
The FCF are updated for current assumptions at the end of each reporting period, incorporating current discount rates.
Changes in estimates related to past or current service are reflected in profit or loss in the income statement, whereas any
changes related to future service are captured in the CSM or the loss component (as applicable) and recognised over the
release of the CSM. Should a group of contracts become onerous during the period, the group recognises a loss in profit or
loss for the net outflow.
For contracts measured under the GMM, certain adjustments are treated as related to future service, resulting in the CSM
being adjusted. These adjustments include:
■ Experience adjustments arising from premiums received in the period that relate to future service, and related cash flows
such as insurance acquisition cash flows and premium-based taxes,
■ Changes in estimates of the present value of the future cash flows in the LRC, except for changes related to the time value
of money and the effect of financial risk and changes in financial risk (the latter which do not result in the CSM being
adjusted),
■ Differences between any investment components expected to become payable in the period and the actual investment
component payable in the period,
■ Changes in the risk adjustment for non-financial risk that related to future service.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 321
-- 260 of 278 --
The CSM is not adjusted for a group of contracts measured under the GMM for the following changes in fulfilment cash flows
because they relate to future services:
■ The effect of the time value of money and changes in the time value of money and the effect of financial risk and changes in
financial risk, changes in estimates of fulfilment cash flows in the LIC; and experience adjustments, except for those
described above which relate to future service.
These adjustments are similar for contracts measured under the VFA, with additional requirements that any fair value
changes in the amount of the group's share on the returns of underlying items and changes in the FCF that do not vary based
on the returns of the underlying items are also treated as adjustments that relate to future cash flows and therefore included
in the CSM.
The VFA approach modifies the treatment of the CSM to accommodate the direct participating contracts. Differences
therefore occur in subsequent measurement of the CSM between the GMM and VFA measurement models. The CSM under
VFA allows for deferring of future fee adjustments linked to current investment returns and effectively smooths out volatility
of fee recognition, i.e. fair value changes are not included in profit or loss but are recognised over the remaining life of the
contract. In particular, the CSM is also adjusted for in-year experience variances and changes in economic variables (unless
the risk mitigation option is elected where hedging is done).
The CSM at the end of each reporting period represents the profit in the group of insurance contracts that has not yet been
recognised as it relates to future service obligations of the group. The balance of the CSM at the end of the reporting period
consists of the opening balance, plus the impact of any new contracts, plus or minus the change in the amount of the entity’s
share of the fair value of the underlying items, except where risk mitigation applies, or the decrease in the amount of the
entity’s share of the fair value of the underlying items exceeds the carrying amount of the CSM, and gives rise to a loss, plus or
minus any changes in any fulfilment cash flows related to future service costs, except where risk mitigation applies, or to the
extent that such increases in the fulfilment cash flows exceed the carrying amount of the CSM, giving rise to a loss; or such
decreases in fulfilment cash flows are allocated to the loss component of the LRC, the effect of any foreign currency
translation differences and less any amounts that are recognised in insurance revenue during the period for the transfer of
insurance service obligations by the group.
The CSM is always measured at a 'locked-in' rate, for GMM measured contracts, which is the prevailing discount rate at the
inception of the contract and not updated for current discount rates, whereas the measurement of the FCF uses a current
discount rate. Interest is accreted on the carrying amount of the CSM at the locked in rate from the inception of the contract.
IFRS 17 introduces the concept of coverage units, which determines how an insurer allocates the expected profit for providing
insurance contract services over the relevant reporting periods. The total number of coverage units in a group is the quantity
of service provided by the contracts in the group over the expected coverage period.
Carrying value of the LIC
For those contracts where the insured event is assumed to have occurred, the liability is recognised in the LIC. The LIC
comprises the FCF related to past service plus a risk adjustment. The LIC also includes the group’s obligation to pay amounts
that relate to insurance contract services that have already been provided and for any investment components that are not
related to the provision of insurance contract services.
For contracts measured under the PAA, unless the contracts are onerous, the explicit risk adjustment for non-financial risk is
estimated for the measurement of the LIC only.
The LIC includes the modelling of the IBNR reserve, outstanding claim reserve (OCR) and any recurring ongoing claims (e.g.
disability income in payment) and claim costs. The LIC includes its own risk adjustment and is adjusted for discounting where
payments are expected to be made more than one year after being incurred. The methodologies being used by the group to
determine the risk adjustment for the LIC includes bootstrapping and fitting a distribution to historical loss rates, typically for
IBNR claims or PAA liabilities on contracts with shorter-dated cash flows.
The group's policy is that the LIC is not discounted if the run-off period is 12 months or less. The group's preferred methods to
measure IBNR claims are the Bornhuetter Ferguson Method and Chain Ladder Method.
Subsequent measurement of reinsurance contracts held
On subsequent recognition of reinsurance contracts held (under GMM and PAA), the total reinsurance contract comprises the
ARC and the ARIC, where the ARIC relates to past service.
Subsequent changes to reinsurance contracts held follows the same principles as those for insurance contracts issued, with
the exception that the CSM at the end of reporting period is adjusted for (contracts measured under GMM):
■ Reversals of a loss-recovery component recognised, to the extent those reversals are not changes in the fulfilment cash
flows of the group of reinsurance contracts held;
■ Changes in the fulfilment cash flows are recognised in profit or loss if the related changes arising from the underlying ceded
contracts have been recognised in profit or loss. Alternatively, changes in the fulfilment cash flows adjust the CSM; and
■ Changes in the fulfilment cash flows that result from changes in the risk of non-performance by the issuer of a reinsurance
contract held do not adjust the contractual service margin as they do not relate to future service.
The reinsurance RA is expected to be negative as the reinsurer will be removing some of the underwriting risk of the insurer.
The reinsurance RA comprises of the RA at initial recognition / beginning of period, less the release of risk adjustment, plus
interest accreted on RA, plus/minus change in estimates (actual versus expected RA), plus/minus change in discount rates.
Where the group has established a loss recovery component, that component is adjusted to reflect changes in the loss
component of the onerous group of underlying contracts on a consistent basis, so that the loss recovery component can
never exceed the portion of the carrying amount of the loss component on the underlying contracts.
322 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 261 of 278 --
Subsequent measurement - PAA
There is no concept of a CSM for PAA measured contracts. The subsequent measurement of the LRC for PAA measured
contracts is further adjusted for any amounts recognised in revenue for insurance services provided over the period. Refer to
accounting policy choices for the various elections the group has adopted with regards to the PAA measurement model. If at
inception of the contract, the group is considered to be onerous, a loss will be recognised in profit or loss and increase the
liability for remaining coverage. The LIC is the same as that for the GMM model.
For reinsurance contracts measured under the PAA approach, the group uses the same principles as applied for the PAA for
insurance contracts issued, however adapted to reflect the features of reinsurance contracts held that differ from insurance
contracts issued, to simplify the measurement of a group of reinsurance contracts held. If the PAA approach is used for
measuring reinsurance, and there is an expected loss on initial recognition, the group adjusts the carrying amount of the ARC
instead of adjusting the CSM as if the reinsurance contracts were measured under the GMM approach.
Revenue and expenditure
Insurance revenue
Contracts measured under GMM and VFA
Insurance revenue is recognised for the pricing/charge by the group for obligations or service delivered during the period
under review. Insurance contract services that the group provides to a policyholder is either: coverage for an insured event;
for insurance contracts without direct participation features, the generation of an investment return; or for insurance
contracts with direct participation features, the management of underlying items on behalf of the policyholder.
Insurance revenue includes the release of the CSM and the risk adjustment (for risk expired) during the period, as well as the
release of expected claims and insurance acquisition cash flows expenses, excluding the financing effect for the time value of
money which is included in insurance finance income or expenses. As revenue is recognised, the LRC is reduced for the
services that have been provided that are related to that contract. The release of the CSM is discussed in more detail in the
key judgements section.
For insurance contracts issued, a portion of the risk adjustment for non-financial risk relating to the LRC is recognised in
insurance revenue as the risk is released.
For investment contracts with DPF, the allocation of the CSM is modified as the group recognises the CSM over the duration
of the group of contracts in a systematic way that reflects the transfer of investment services under the contract.
Contracts measured under PAA
For contracts measured under the PAA, the revenue earned is the allocation of expected premium receipts on the basis of the
passage of time, unless there was judgement applied and the assessment was that the expected pattern of release of risk
during the coverage period differs significantly from the passage of time, in which case it will then be on the basis of the
expected timing of incurred insurance service expenses. The group generally measures revenue earned over the passage of
time.
Insurance service expenses
Insurance service expenses include the following:
a. incurred claims and benefits excluding investment components;
b. other incurred directly attributable insurance service expenses;
c. amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows;
d. changes that relate to past service (i.e. changes in the FCF relating to the LIC);
e. changes that relate to future service (i.e. losses/reversals on onerous groups of contracts from changes in the loss
components); and
f. any insurance acquisition cash flow assets impairment.
For contracts not measured under the PAA, amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows is reflected in insurance service
expenses in the same amount as insurance acquisition cash flows recovery reflected within insurance revenue as described
above.
For contracts measured under the PAA, amortisation of insurance acquisition cash flows is based on the passage of time.
Other expenses not meeting the above categories are included in other operating expenses in the consolidated statement of
profit or loss. For insurance contracts issued, the portion of the risk adjustment for non-financial risk relating to the LIC is
recognised in insurance service expenses.
Net income or expenses from reinsurance contracts held
Reinsurance expenses are recognised on a similar basis to insurance revenue, accounting for the different nature of the
contracts. Reinsurance expenses recognised depict the transfer of received insurance contract services at an amount that
reflects the portion of ceding premiums that the group expects to pay in exchange for those services.
Net income or expenses from reinsurance contracts held comprises reinsurance expenses (including broker fees measured
under PAA), incurred claims recovery, excluding any investment components, other incurred directly attributable expenses
and changes that relate to past service, effects of changes in the risk of reinsurer’s non-performance.
Reinsurance expenses incurred for contracts measured under PAA are recognised over the passage of time over the coverage
period of the contracts.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 323
-- 262 of 278 --
Insurance finance income and expenses
Insurance finance income and expenses comprise the change in the carrying value of the group of insurance contracts (for the
LRC and the LIC) arising from the effect of the time value of money and changes in the time value of money; and the effect of
financial risk and changes in financial risk.
For contracts measured under the GMM approach, insurance finance income or expenses arise from interest accretion on the
FCF and the CSM (CSM at the locked-in inception rate), the effect of changes in interest rates and other financial
assumptions; and foreign exchange differences (if applicable), as well as interest accepted on the LIC.
For contracts measured under the VFA approach, the insurance finance income or expenses comprise changes in the value of
underlying item (excluding additions and disposals).
For insurance contracts measured under the PAA approach, insurance finance income and expenses arise from interest
accreted on the LIC and the effect of changes in interest rates and other financial assumptions.
The group has elected, for all current portfolios, to include all insurance finance income or expenses for all measurement
approaches, in the reporting period in profit or loss (Refer to the accounting policy elections for the group’s current
accounting treatment).
Notional acquisition cash flows - presentation between insurance revenue and insurance service
result
The group categorises insurance expenses either into acquisition and renewal expenses and allocates directly attributable
expenses to insurance contacts. Excluding contracts that are measured under the PAA, insurance acquisition costs are
allocated to existing groups of insurance contracts on a systematic and rational basis. On initial recognition of a group of
contracts, such acquisition costs reduce the CSM (as there is less profit to defer over the life of the contract related to these
expenses). For contracts that are measured under the PAA, the group recognises an asset for acquisition cash flows at initial
recognition and amortises the asset over the group of insurance contracts’ coverage period. For presentation purposes, IFRS
17 requires the group to allocate the direct acquisition costs to insurance service expenses in a systematic way, with an equal
amount recognised as insurance revenue.
Presentation and disclosure
Statement of financial position
The insurance contract liabilities or assets, and reinsurance contract assets or liabilities recognised on the face of the
statement of financial position are disaggregated in the notes to the financial statements according to the measurement
approach applied, and according to what is included in the liability for remaining coverage (LRC) and the liability for incurred
claims (LIC). For reinsurance contact assets or liabilities, this is referred to as the asset for remaining coverage (ARC) and the
asset recoverable on incurred claims (ARIC). The line items on the face of the statement of financial position include all rights
and obligations from a portfolio of insurance contracts. Portfolios that are in an asset position are presented separately from
those in a liability position for both insurance and reinsurance.
Income statement
The group reduces the LRC and recognised insurance revenue as it provides insurance contract services. Line items
presented on the face of the income statement, being an insurance service result, which is the separate recognition of
insurance revenue (that excludes the receipt of any investment component) and insurance service expenses (that excludes
the repayment of any investment components). These line items represent the group’s net insurance service result (before
reinsurance contracts held).
Net income or expenses from reinsurance contracts held on underlying insurance contracts as well as insurance finance
income or expenses are separately presented on the face of the income statement.
Disclosures are further disaggregated into more granular levels if information provided at the level of the measurement model
is determined to be too aggregated to be considered useful to the users of the information. The group has defined this level of
disclosures as its ʻreportable groups’.
Refer accounting policy elections below for more detail on presentation elections.
Other
Other payables
Included in Other payables are balances associated with certain outstanding claims. Where the benefits have not been
claimed by the member or the beneficiary within a 24- month period since the benefit became legally due and payable and
under the South African Pensions Fund Act 24 of 1956, these specific obligations have been transferred to a legally ring-
fenced unclaimed benefit fund. Once in the unclaimed benefit fund, they meet the definition of an investment contract.
Prepayments and other receivables
Other receivables comprise of premiums related to certain IFRS 17 contracts where intermediaries act as agents for the group
and collect premiums on behalf of the group from the policyholders. Where these amounts are still owing to the group at
reporting date, they are disclosed as amounts receivable in terms of IFRS 9 and presented within Other Assets on the group’s
statement of financial position.
324 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 263 of 278 --
Notional Deferred Acquisition Costs (NDAC) (presentation)
Insurance acquisition cash flows are treated in the same way as other cash flows incurred in fulfilling insurance contracts and
is reflected in the CSM or loss component for a group of insurance contracts on initial recognition. In line with the standard, the
group has created an off-balance sheet notional deferred acquisition cost amount, which is used for presentation purposes to
allocate the portion of premiums that relate to the recovery of acquisition cash flows to each reporting period, i.e. increasing
insurance revenue and increasing insurance service expenses. On initial recognition, the NDAC is based on the present value
of all expected future acquisition cash flows net of expected future clawbacks on acquisition commissions.
The NDAC is amortised based on the passage of time but the standard is not prescriptive on the methodology to achieve this.
For long boundary contracts measured under GMM and VFA, the NDAC will be released by applying the same rate of allocation
as for the amortisation of the CSM derived from coverage units. The amortisation of the NDAC in line with coverage units is
aligned to service provided and achieves consistency with the CSM.
For contracts without direct participation features, the insurance revenue is made up of expected claims, expected expenses,
release of the NDAC and release of the CSM in each period where the Notional DAC and CSM accrete interest at locked-in
rates. Consequently, the release of the NDAC and CSM should be adjusted by the ʻlocked-in’ rate when ʻadjusting for the
financing effect’ over the lifetime of the contract.
For contracts with direct participation features, since interest is accreted on the NDAC using current interest rates, the
insurance revenue over the lifetime of the contract must be discounted using current interest rates and must be equal to the
discounted value of the entity’s share of the underlying.
The roll-forward of the expected NDAC is determined at the CSM group level except for the determination of experience
variances. The experience variances on the NDAC arising from differences between expected acquisition costs and actual
acquisition costs is determined at the reportable group level of aggregations and is disaggregated to groups in proportion to
the CSM coverage units for each group relative to the total coverage units at the reportable group level.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 325
-- 264 of 278 --
13. Taxation
TAXATION
Direct taxation
Direct taxation includes all domestic
and foreign taxes based on taxable
profits and capital gains tax
Indirect taxation Dividend tax
|
Current tax
Deferred tax
Type Description, recognition and measurement Offsetting
Direct taxation:
current tax
Current tax is recognised in the direct taxation line in the income statement
except to the extent that it relates to a business combination (relating to a
measurement period adjustment where the carrying amount of the goodwill is
greater than zero), or items recognised directly in equity or in OCI.
Current tax represents the expected tax payable on taxable income for the
year, using tax rates enacted or substantively enacted at the reporting date,
and any adjustments to tax payable in respect of previous years.
Current and
deferred tax assets
and liabilities are
offset if there is a
legally enforceable
right to offset
current tax
liabilities and
assets, and they
relate to income
taxes levied by the
same tax authority
on the same
taxable entity, or
on different tax
entities, but they
intend to settle
current tax
liabilities and
assets on a net
basis or their tax
assets and
liabilities will be
realised
simultaneously.
Direct taxation:
deferred tax
Deferred tax is recognised in direct taxation except to the extent that it relates
to a business combination (relating to a measurement period adjustment
where the carrying amount of the goodwill is greater than zero), or items
recognised directly in equity or in OCI.
Deferred tax is recognised in respect of temporary differences arising between
the tax bases of assets and liabilities and their carrying values for financial
reporting purposes. Deferred tax is measured at the tax rates that are
expected to be applied to the temporary differences when they reverse, based
on the laws enacted or substantively enacted at the reporting date. Deferred
tax is not recognised for the following temporary differences:
■ the initial recognition of goodwill;
■ the initial recognition of assets and liabilities in a transaction that is not a
business combination, which affects neither accounting nor taxable profits
or losses; and
■ investments in subsidiaries, associates and jointly controlled arrangements
(excluding mutual funds) where the group controls the timing of the reversal
of temporary differences and it is probable that these differences will not
reverse in the foreseeable future.
Direct taxation:
deferred tax
The amount of deferred tax provided is based on the expected manner of
realisation or settlement of the carrying amount of the asset or liability and is
not discounted.
Deferred tax assets are recognised to the extent that it is probable that future
taxable income will be available against which the unused tax losses can be
utilised. Deferred tax assets are reviewed at each reporting date and are
reduced to the extent that it is no longer probable that the related tax benefit will
be realised.
Deferred income tax liabilities are provided on taxable temporary differences
arising from investments in subsidiaries, associates and joint arrangements,
except for deferred income tax liability where the timing of the reversal of the
temporary difference is controlled by the group and it is probable that the
temporary difference will not reverse in the foreseeable future. Generally, the
group is unable to control the reversal of the temporary difference for
associates unless there is an agreement in place that gives the group the ability
to control the reversal of the temporary difference.
Deferred income tax assets are recognised on deductible temporary differences
arising from investments in subsidiaries, associates and joint arrangements only
to the extent that it is probable that the temporary difference will reverse in the
future and there is sufficient taxable profit available against which the
temporary difference can be utilised.
326 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 265 of 278 --
Type Description, recognition and measurement Offsetting
Indirect
taxation
Indirect taxes comprising of non-recoverable value added tax (VAT), skills
development levies and other duties for banking, are recognised in the indirect
taxation line in the income statement.
Not applicable
Dividend tax Taxes on dividends declared by the group are recognised as part of the dividends
paid within equity, as dividend tax represents a tax on the shareholder and not
the group. Dividends tax withheld by the group on dividends paid to its
shareholders and payable at the reporting date to the South African Revenue
Service (where applicable) is included in ʻProvisions and other liabilities’ in the
statement of financial position.
Not applicable
14. Revenue and expenditure
REVENUE AND EXPENDITURE
Net interest income# Non-interest
revenue#
Net insurance
income#
Non-insurance
revenue#
| | | |
■ Interest income*
■ Interest expense
■ Net fee and
commission revenue*
■ Fee and commission
expense
■ Trading revenue*
■ Other revenue*
■ Other gains/losses on
financial instruments*
■ Insurance service
result
■ Net expense from
reinsurance contracts
held
■ Net insurance finance
expense
■ Investment income*
■ Management fees on
assets under
management
■ Interest income*
■ Other revenue*
Insurance related revenue and expenditure is included in section 12 of this annexure.
* Gross revenue for the group is defined as the total of interest income, fee and commission revenue, trading revenue, other gains and losses on financial
instruments, other revenue, insurance revenue on both insurance contracts issued and reinsurance contracts held, and finance income from both
reinsurance contracts held and insurance contracts issue.
# Total net income represents the group’s net revenue and constitutes the total of net interest income, non-interest revenue, net insurance income and
non-insurance revenue.
Description Recognition and measurement
Net interest income Interest income and expense (with the exception of borrowing costs that are capitalised on
qualifying assets, that is assets that necessarily take a substantial period of time to get ready for
their intended use or sale and which are not measured at fair value) are recognised in net interest
income using the effective interest method for all interest-bearing financial instruments. In terms
of the effective interest method, interest is recognised at a rate that exactly discounts estimated
future cash payments or receipts through the expected life of the financial instrument or, where
appropriate, a shorter period, to the net carrying amount of the financial asset or financial
liability. Direct incremental transaction costs incurred and origination fees received, including
loan commitment fees, as a result of bringing margin-yielding assets or liabilities into the
statement of financial position, are capitalised to the carrying amount of financial instruments
that are not at fair value through profit or loss and amortised as interest income or expense over
the life of the asset or liability as part of the effective interest rate.
Where the estimates of payments or receipts on financial assets or financial liabilities are
subsequently revised, the carrying amount of the financial asset or financial liability is adjusted to
reflect actual and revised estimated cash flows. The carrying amount is calculated by computing
the present value of the adjusted cash flows at the financial asset or financial liability’s original
effective interest rate. Any adjustment to the carrying value is recognised in net interest income.
When a financial asset is classified as stage 3 impaired, interest income is calculated on the
amortised cost based on the original effective interest rate. The contractual interest income on
the gross exposure is suspended and is only recognised in credit impairments when the financial
asset is reclassified from (out of) stage 3. Dividends received on preference share investments
classified as debt form part of the group’s lending activities and are included in interest income,
recognised as part of net interest income calculated using the effective interest method.
Dividends are recognised in interest income for debt instruments, when the right to receipt is
established. Scrip dividends are recognised as dividends received where the dividend declaration
allows for a cash alternative.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 327
-- 266 of 278 --
Description Recognition and measurement
Net fee and
commission revenue
Fee and commission revenue, including accounting transaction fees, card-based commission,
documentation and administration fees, electronic banking fees, foreign currency service fees,
insurance-based fees and commissions, and knowledge-based fees and commissions are
recognised as the related services are performed. Loan commitment fees for loans that are not
expected to be drawn down are recognised on a straight-line basis over the commitment period.
Loan syndication fees, where the group does not participate in the syndication or participates at
the same effective interest rate for comparable risk as other participants, are recognised as
revenue when the syndication has been completed. Syndication fees that do not meet these
criteria are capitalised as origination fees and amortised to the income statement as interest
income. The fair value of issued financial guarantee contracts on initial recognition is amortised
as income over the term of the contract.
Fee and commission expenses, included in net fee and commission revenue, are mainly
transaction and service fees relating to financial instruments, which are expensed as the services
are received. Expenditure is presented as fee and commission expenses where the expenditure
is linked to the production of fee and commission revenue.
The group’s banking activities operate a customer loyalty programme in terms of which it
undertakes to provide goods and services to certain customers. The reward credits are
accounted for as a separately identifiable component of the fee and commission income
transactions of which they form a part. The consideration allocated to the reward credits is
measured at the fair value of the reward credit and is recognised over the period in which the
customer utilises the reward credits. Expenses relating to the provision of the reward credits are
recognised in fee and commission expenses as and when they are incurred.
Trading revenue Trading revenue comprises all gains and losses from changes in the fair value of trading assets
and liabilities, together with related interest income, expense and dividends.
Investment income Investment income for IAM comprises mainly rental income from properties, interest, hotel
operations’ sales and dividends. Dividends are recognised when the right to receive payment is
established and interest income is recognised using the effective interest method.
Management fees on
assets under
management
Fee income includes management fees on assets under management and administration fees.
Management fees on assets under management are recognised over the period for which the
services are rendered, in accordance with the substance of the relevant agreements.
Administration fees received for the administration of medical schemes are recognised when the
services are rendered.
Other gains/losses
on financial
instruments
Includes:
■ Fair value gains and losses on financial assets that are classified at fair value through profit or
loss (designated and default).
■ The gain or loss on the derecognition of a debt financial asset classified as at fair value through
OCI.
■ Gains and losses arising from the derecognition of financial assets and financial liabilities
classified as at amortised cost.
■ Gains and losses arising from the reclassification of a financial asset from amortised cost to
fair value.
■ Gains and losses arising from the modification of a financial asset (which is not distressed)
and financial liability as at amortised cost.
■ Fair value gains and losses on designated financial liabilities.
■ Fair value gains and losses on private equity or venture capital investments designated at fair
value through profit or loss.
Other revenue Other revenue comprises revenue that is not included in any of the categories mentioned above
this could include dividends on equity financial assets, and remeasurement gains and losses
from contingent consideration on disposals and purchases.
Dividends are recognised in other revenue for equity instruments when the right to receipt is
established. Scrip dividends are recognised as dividends received where the dividend declaration
allows for a cash alternative.
Offsetting
Income and expenses are presented on a net basis only when permitted by IFRS, or for gains and losses arising from a group
of similar transactions.
328 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 267 of 278 --
15. Non-current assets held for sale, disposal groups and discontinued operations
Type and description
Statement of financial
position
Statement of other
comprehensive income Income statement
Non-current assets and
liabilities held for sale and
disposal groups
Comprising assets and
liabilities that are expected
to be recovered primarily
through sale or distribution
to owners rather than
continuing use (including
regular purchases and
sales in the ordinary course
of business).
Immediately before
classification, the assets
(or components of a
disposal group) are
remeasured in accordance
with the group’s
accounting policies and
tested for impairment.
Thereafter, the assets are
measured at the lower of
their carrying amount and
fair value less costs to sell.
Assets and liabilities (or
components of a disposal
group) are presented
separately in the statement
of financial position.
In presenting the group’s
non-current assets and
liabilities as held for sale,
intercompany balances are
eliminated in full.
OCI movements are
presented separately.
Impairment losses on
initial classification as well
as subsequent gains and
losses on remeasurement
of these assets are
recognised in profit or
loss. Property and
equipment and intangible
assets are not
subsequently depreciated
or amortised. Equity
accounting thereafter for
an interest in an associate
is suspended.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 329
-- 268 of 278 --
16. Other significant accounting policies
OTHER ACCOUNTING POLICIES
Segment reporting Fiduciary activities Statutory credit risk
reserve
Non-trading and
capital related items
Segment reporting
An operating segment is a component of the group engaged in business activities, whose operating results are reviewed
regularly by management in order to make decisions about resources to be allocated to segments and assessing segment
performance. The group’s identification of segments and the measurement of segment results is based on the group’s
internal reporting to the chief operating decision makers, comprising of the chief executive and members of the group
leadership council.
Fiduciary activities
The group commonly engages in trust or other fiduciary activities that result in the holding or placing of assets on behalf of
individuals, trusts, post-employment benefit plans and other institutions. These assets and the income arising directly thereon
are excluded from these annual financial statements as they are not assets of the group. However, fee income earned and fee
expenses incurred by the group relating to the group’s responsibilities from fiduciary activities are recognised in profit or loss.
Statutory credit risk reserve
The statutory credit risk reserve represents the amount by which local regulatory authorities within the group’s Africa Regions
operations require in addition to the IFRS impairment provision. Changes in this reserve are accounted for as transfers to and
from retained earnings as appropriate.
Non-trading and capital related items
Non-trading and capital related items primarily include the following:
■ Gains and losses on disposal of subsidiaries joint ventures and associates (including foreign exchange translation gains and
losses).
■ Gains and losses on the disposal of property and equipment and intangible assets.
■ Impairment and reversals of impairments of joint ventures and associates.
■ Impairment of investments in subsidiaries, property and equipment, and intangible assets; and
■ Other items of a capital related nature.
330 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure F – Material accounting policies continued
-- 269 of 278 --
17. New standards and amendments not yet adopted
The following new standards, and amendments are not yet effective for the year ended 31 December 2023 and have not been
applied in preparing these annual financial statements.
Title: IFRS 10 and IAS 28 Sale or Contribution of Assets between an Investor and its
Associate or Joint Venture (amendments)
Effective date: deferred the effective date for these amendments indefinitely
The amendments address an inconsistency between the requirements in IFRS 10 and those in IAS 28, in dealing with the sale
or contribution of assets between an investor and its associate or joint venture. The main consequence of the amendments
is that a full gain or loss is recognised when a transaction involves a business (whether it is housed in a subsidiary or not).
A partial gain or loss is recognised when a transaction involves assets that do not constitute a business, even if these assets
are housed in a subsidiary. The amendments will be applied prospectively and are not expected to have a material impact on
the group’s financial statements.
Title: IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements (amendments)
Effective date: 1 January 2024
The first amendment clarifies how to classify debt and other liabilities as current or non-current. The objective of the
amendment is aimed to promote consistency in applying the requirements by helping entities determine whether, debt and
other liabilities with an uncertain settlement date should be classified as current (due or potentially due to be settled within
one year) or non-current. The amendment also includes clarifying the classification requirements for debt an entity might
settle by converting it into equity. These are clarifications, not changes, to the existing requirements, and so are not expected
to affect entities' financial statements significantly. The impact on the annual financial statements has not yet been fully
determined, however, not expected to have a significant impact on the group.
The second amendment to IAS 1 requires a company to classify debt as non-current only if the company can avoid settling the
debt in the 12 months after the reporting date. However, a company’s ability to do so is often subject to complying with
covenants. For example, a company might have long-term debt that could become repayable within 12 months if the company
fails to comply with covenants in that 12-month period.
The amendments specify that covenants to be complied with after the reporting date do not affect the classification of debt as
current or non-current at the reporting date. Instead, the amendments require a company to disclose information about these
covenants in the notes to the financial statements and the aim of the amendments therefore is to improve the information
companies provide about long-term debt with covenants. The amendments will be applied retrospectively and are not
expected to have a material impact on the group's financial statements.
Title: IFRS 16 Leases (narrow scope amendments)
Effective date: 1 January 2024
The amendments add to requirements explaining how a company accounts for a sale and leaseback after the date of the
transaction. IFRS 16 had not previously specified how to measure the transaction when reporting after that date. The
amendments add to the sale and leaseback requirements in IFRS 16, thereby supporting the consistent application of the
standard. These amendments will not change the accounting for leases other than those arising in a sale and leaseback
transaction. The amendments will be applied retrospectively and are not expected to have a material impact on the group’s
financial statements.
Title: IAS 21 Exchange Rates (amendments)
Effective date: 1 January 2025
The International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) issued ʻLack of Exchangeability’ to require an entity to apply a
consistent approach to assessing whether a currency is exchangeable into another currency and, when it is not, to
determining the exchange rate to use and the disclosures to provide. These amendments will assist companies and investors
by addressing a matter not previously covered in the accounting requirements for the effects of changes in foreign exchange
rates. The amendments will be applied retrospectively. The impact on the annual financial statements has not yet been fully
determined.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 331
-- 270 of 278 --
Consolidated statement of financial position – IFRS 17
2023
USDm*
2023
GBPm*
2023
EURm*
CAGR**
%
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
1 January 2022
Restated1
Rm
Assets
Cash and balances with central banks 7 440 5 856 6 735 20 137 787 114 483 91 169
Financial investments, trading and pledged assets 59 157 46 559 53 548 4 1 095 501 1 056 720 1 025 327
Loans and advances 86 878 68 376 78 640 7 1 608 846 1 504 940 1 424 328
Insurance contract assets 293 230 265 (11) 1 631 1 830 1 264
Reinsurance contract assets 88 69 80 (2) 5 422 5 522 5 902
Current and deferred taxation assets 528 416 478 2 9 784 9 585 7 616
Derivative and receivables and other assets 7 069 5 563 6 398 15 130 901 114 057 92 903
Disposal group assets classified as held for sale 13 10 11 (58) 235 555 1 025
Interest in associates and joint ventures 657 517 595 22 12 173 9 956 7 280
Goodwill and other intangible assets 687 541 622 (16) 12 723 15 120 16 909
Property and equipment 1 096 863 992 20 298 20 340 20 619
Investment property 1 644 1 294 1 488 4 30 444 29 289 29 985
Total assets 165 550 130 294 149 852 3 065 745 2 882 397 2 724 327
Equity and liabilities
Equity 14 954 11 769 13 535 7 276 920 258 866 242 891
Equity attributable to ordinary shareholders 12 768 10 049 11 557 8 236 445 218 197 198 873
Equity attributable to other equity instrument holders 1 305 1 027 1 181 23 24 167 19 667 16 052
Non-controlling interests 881 693 797 (22) 16 308 21 002 27 966
Liabilities 150 596 118 525 136 317 6 2 788 825 2 623 531 2 481 436
Deposit and debt funding 108 089 85 070 97 840 6 2 001 646 1 889 099 1 776 615
Derivative and other liabilities 13 390 10 539 12 121 15 247 967 214 936 212 640
Trading liabilities 5 101 4 014 4 618 (14) 94 468 109 928 81 484
Current and deferred taxation liabilities 545 429 492 4 10 093 9 666 9 915
Financial liabilities under investment contracts 8 156 6 419 7 383 11 151 035 136 309 136 622
Insurance contract liabilities 13 575 10 684 12 288 8 251 389 231 849 233 730
Subordinated debt 1 740 1 370 1 575 2 32 227 31 744 30 430
Total equity and liabilities 165 550 130 294 149 852 3 065 745 2 882 397 2 724 327
* The foreign-denominated results above have been derived from the group’s audited ZAR results by using the closing exchange rates. The
foreign-denominated results above have not been audited and have been presented for illustrative purposes only. This illustration would not be
equivalent to that which would have resulted had the group presented its results in a currency other than ZAR in terms of IAS 21.
** Compound annual growth rate.
1 Restated. Refer to page 31 to 39 for the IFRS 17 transition impact.
For the above table the CAGR was calculated for those years the line item included in the group’s 2023 statement of financial position,
was presented, for example, the CAGR for reinsurance contract assets was calculated between 1 January 2022 to 31 December 2023,
whereas the CAGR for cash and balances with central banks was calculated from 2018 to 2023.
Refer to the following table for 2021 - 2018 comparative disclosures.
332 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 333
ANNEXURE G – SIX-YEAR REVIEW
-- 271 of 278 --
Consolidated statement of financial position – IFRS 4
2021
Rm
2020
Rm
2019
Rm
2018
Rm
Assets
Cash and balances with central banks 91 169 87 505 75 288 85 145
Financial investments, trading and pledged assets 1 023 898 931 906 819 498 749 517
Loans and advances 1 424 328 1 271 255 1 181 067 1 119 547
Current and deferred taxation assets 7 612 7 315 4 868 4 519
Derivative and other assets 100 120 154 310 101 308 74 192
Disposal group assets classified as held for sale 1 025 220 2 599 762
Interest in associates 7 280 6 498 5 423 10 376
Goodwill and other intangible assets 16 913 18 262 22 323 23 676
Property and equipment 20 619 20 702 22 018 19 194
Investment property 29 985 29 917 34 180 33 326
Policyholders’ assets 2 868 5 050 7 017 6 708
Total assets 2 725 817 2 532 940 2 275 589 2 126 962
Equity and liabilities
Equity 242 849 215 272 209 484 199 063
Equity attributable to ordinary shareholders 198 832 176 371 171 229 165 061
Equity attributable to other equity instrument holders 16 052 12 528 10 989 9 047
Non-controlling interests 27 965 26 373 27 266 24 955
Liabilities 2 482 968 2 317 668 2 066 105 1 927 899
Deposit and debt funding 1 776 615 1 624 044 1 426 193 1 357 537
Derivative and other liabilities 221 043 249 471 193 599 164 810
Trading liabilities 81 484 81 261 83 847 59 947
Current and deferred taxation liabilities 10 277 8 302 9 073 8 015
Non-current liabilities held for sale 96 92 246 237
Subordinated debt 30 430 29 306 28 901 26 359
Policyholders’ liabilities 363 023 325 192 324 246 310 994
Total equity and liabilities 2 725 817 2 532 940 2 275 589 2 126 962
Exchange rates (rounded) utilised to convert the 31 December 2023 statement of financial position rand exchange rates (closing):
Currency 2023 2022
USD 18.52 16.30
GBP 23.53 20.19
EUR 20.46 18.08
334 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure G – Six-year review continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 335
-- 272 of 278 --
Consolidated income statement – IFRS 17
2023
USDm*
2023
GBPm*
2023
EURm*
CAGR**
%
2023
Rm
2022
Restated1
Rm
Net interest income 5 274 4 166 4 828 25 98 188 78 391
Non-interest revenue 3 330 2 631 3 048 13 62 003 54 965
Net fee and commission revenue 1 890 1 493 1 730 8 35 187 32 621
Trading revenue 1 107 875 1 014 21 20 617 17 046
Other revenue 186 147 170 21 3 464 2 860
Other gains and losses on financial instruments 147 116 134 12 2 735 2 438 #DIV/0!
Net insurance (loss)/income (953) (754) (873) (659) (17 753) 3 178
Insurance service result 442 348 404 (1) 8 216 8 302
Net insurance service result before reinsurance contracts
held 482 380 441 11 8 964 8 071
Insurance revenue 2 083 1 645 1 907 9 38 778 35 717
Insurance service expense (1 601) (1 265) (1 466) 8 (29 814) (27 646)
Net expense from reinsurance contracts held (40) (32) (37) (424) (748) 231
Net insurance finance expenses (1 395) (1 102) (1 277) 407 (25 969) (5 124)
Net finance expenses from insurance contracts issued (1 411) (1 115) (1 292) 402 (26 280) (5 232)
Net finance income from reinsurance contracts held 16 13 15 188 311 108
Non-insurance revenue 1 889 1 492 1 730 204 35 178 11 583
Investment and other income 457 361 419 13 8 517 7 516
Interest income 159 126 146 41 2 967 2 105
Fair value adjustments to investment contract liabilities and
third-party mutual funds 1 273 1 005 1 165 1108 23 694 1 962
Total net income 9 540 7 535 8 733 20 177 616 148 117
Credit impairment charges (873) (690) (800) 22 (16 261) (13 343)
Income after credit impairment charges 8 667 6 845 7 933 20 161 355 134 774
Operating expenses (5 089) (4 020) (4 659) 13 (94 749) (83 533)
Net income before non-trading and capital related items 3 578 2 825 3 274 30 66 606 51 241
Non-trading and capital related items 80 63 73 353 1 487 328
Share of post-tax profit/(loss) from associates and joint
ventures 89 70 81 (27) 1 648 2 265
Net income before indirect taxation 3 747 2 958 3 428 30 69 741 53 834
Indirect taxation (181) (143) (166) 10 (3 373) (3 077)
Profit before direct taxation 3 566 2 815 3 262 31 66 368 50 757
Direct taxation (863) (682) (790) 37 (16 065) (11 717)
Profit for the year 2 703 2 133 2 472 29 50 303 39 040
Attributable to non-controlling interests and other equity
instrument holders 2 376 1 875 2 173 29 44 211 34 243
Attributable to other equity instrument holders 94 74 86 76 1 762 999
Attributable to non-controlling interests 233 184 213 14 4 330 3 798
Headline earnings
Basic earnings per ordinary share (cents) 143 113 131 29 2 667 2 074
Diluted earnings per ordinary share (cents) 142 112 130 28 2 635 2 059
* The foreign-denominated results above have been derived from the group’s audited ZAR results by using the average exchange rates.
The foreign-denominated results above have not been audited and have been presented for illustrative purposes only. This illustration would not be equivalent to that
which would have resulted had the group presented its results in a currency other than ZAR in terms of IAS 21.
** Compound annual growth rate.
1 Restated. Refer to page 30 for further detail on restatements and pages 31 to 39 for detail on the impact of the IFRS 17 transition.
For the above table the CAGR was calculated for those years the line item included in the group’s 2023 income statement,
was presented, for example, the CAGR for net insurance finance expenses was calculated between 31 December 2022 to 31 December 2023,
whereas the CAGR for share of post-tax profit/(loss) from associates and joint ventures was calculated from 2018 to 2023.
Refer to page 338 for 2021 - 2018 comparative disclosures.
336 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure G – Six-year review continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 337
-- 273 of 278 --
Consolidated income statement – IFRS 4
2021
Rm
2020
Rm
2019
Rm
2018
Rm
Net interest income 62 436 61 425 62 919 59 505
Non-interest revenue 50 862 47 156 47 542 45 826
Net fee and commission revenue 30 355 29 413 30 622 30 375
Trading revenue 14 842 13 874 12 075 10 799
Other revenue 3 648 3 158 4 089 3 863
Other gains and losses on financial instruments 2 017 711 756 789
Income from banking activities 113 298 108 581 110 461 105 331
Income from investment management and life insurance
activities 19 426 15 086 23 573 21 452
Insurance premiums received 44 364 39 202 39 801 38 251
Revenue from contacts with customers 3 542 3 400 4 062 4 073
Interest income 1 541 1 648 1 920 1 516
Insurance benefits and claims paid (67 779) (40 354) (44 309) (26 484)
Investment management and service fee income and gains 2 210 3 271 3 245 3 533
Fair value adjustments to investment management liabilities
and third-party fund interests 35 548 7 919 18 854 563
Total income 132 724 123 667 134 034 126 783
Credit impairment charges (9 873) (20 594) (7 964) (6 489)
Income after credit impairment charges 122 851 103 073 126 070 120 294
Operating expenses in banking activities (65 477) (63 182) (62 335) (59 814)
Operating expenses in insurance activities (16 952) (16 139) (16 486) (16 404)
Net income before non-trading and capital related items 40 422 23 752 47 249 44 076
Non-trading and capital related items (284) (3 956) (2 890) (641)
Share of post-tax profit/(loss) from associates and joint
ventures 1 094 1 084 (512) 912
Net income before indirect taxation 41 232 20 880 43 847 44 347
Indirect taxation (3 024) (2 727) (2 592) (2 609)
Profit before direct taxation 38 208 18 153 41 255 41 738
Direct taxation (10 149) (3 640) (10 559) (9 095)
Profit for the year 28 059 14 513 30 696 32 643
Attributable to non-controlling interests and other equity
instrument holders 2 369 1 352 5 253 5 190
Attributable to group ordinary shareholders 24 865 12 358 25 443 27 453
Headline earnings 25 021 15 945 28 207 27 865
Exchange rates (rounded) utilised to convert the 31 December 2023 income
statement rand exchange rates – (average)
Currency 2023 2022
USD 18.62 16.30
GBP 23.57 20.19
EUR 20.34 18.08
338 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure G – Six-year review continued STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 339
-- 274 of 278 --
Share statistics and market indicators
CAGR**
% 2023
2022
Restated1 2021 2020 2019 2018
Share statistics
Dividend cover times 1.8 1.7 1.8 3.9 1.8 1.8
Dividend yield % 5 6.8 7.2 6.2 1.2 5.9 5.4
Earnings yield % 6 12.8 12.4 7.2 7.9 10.5 9.8
Price earnings ratio times (5) 7.8 8.0 14.0 12.7 9.5 10.2
Price-to-book times (4) 1.5 1.2 1.1 1.1 1.6 1.8
Number of shares traded millions 1 1 675.8 1 678.3 1 620.0 1 619.9 1 650.9 1 618.5
Market capitalisation Rm 4 344 837 271 469 226 813 202 426 268 302 289 723
Market indicators at
31 December
Standard Bank Group share price
High for the year cents (2) 20 900 18 798 14 978 17 224 21 022 23 100
Low for the year cents 6 20 402 14 001 11 338 8 341 15 860 15 392
Closing cents 3 20 810 16 779 14 001 12 708 16 832 17 881
Prime overdraft rate (closing) % 3 11.8 10.5 7.0 7.0 10.0 10.3
JSE All Share Index – (closing) 8 76 893 73 049 73 709 54 116 57 084 52 081
JSE Banks Index – (closing) 4 10 948 9 854 8 823 6 076 8 731 9 162
ZAR exchange rates – (closing)
USD 5 18.52 16.97 15.89 14.67 14.00 14.38
GBP 5 23.53 20.42 21.46 20.04 18.42 18.31
EUR 4 20.46 19.08 18.00 18.01 15.70 16.44
ZAR exchange rates – (average)
USD 7 18.45 16.30 14.77 16.45 14.44 13.23
GBP 5 22.95 20.19 20.32 21.08 18.43 17.63
EUR 5 20.34 17.23 17.47 18.76 16.16 15.60
Results and ratios
CAGR
% 2023
2022
Restated1 2021 2020 2019 2018
Standard Bank Group
Share statistics
Number of ordinary shares listed on
JSE (millions)
Weighted average 1 1 658 1 651 1 591 1 590 1 594 1 594
End of year 1 1 657 1 657 1 620 1 620 1 594 1 590
Share statistics per ordinary
share (cents)
Basic earnings cents 9 2 667 2 074 1 563 777 1 594 1 723
Headline earnings cents 8 2 590 2 050 1 573 1 003 1 767 1 748
Dividends cents 8 1 423 1 206 871 240 994 970
Net asset value cents 7 14 269 13 172 12 493 11 072 10 742 10 380
ROE % 18.8 16.4 13.5 8.9 16.8 18.8
1 Restated. Refer to pages 30 to 39 for further detail.
341 ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Annexure G – Six-year review continued
-- 275 of 278 --
Capital adequacy, employee and other relevant statistics
CAGR**
% 2023
2022
Restated1 2021 2020 2019 2018
Capital adequacy2
Risk-weighted assets Rm 12 1 608 587 1 495 445 1 363 036 1 229 478 1 099 528 923 016
Tier 1 capital3 Rm 8 220 821 197 366 186 577 163 944 147 981 151 925
Total capital3 Rm 8 253 647 228 299 216 301 189 847 169 983 172 289
Tier 1 capital to risk-weighted
assets4 % 1 15 14 15 13 13 14
Total capital to risk-weighted
assets4 % 1 17 17 18 16 15 16
Employee statistics
Number of employees
Banking3 (2) 43 451 42 300 43 607 44 450 44 996 47 419
Group (1) 50 451 49 325 49 224 50 115 50 691 53 178
Normalised headline earnings per
employee Rm 10 851 281 686 325 508 309 318 168 556 450 523 995
Points of representation
ATMs and ANAs* (4) 6 014 6 232 6 600 6 774 8 970 7 239
Banking branches and service
centres 1 206 1 202 1 143 1 124 1 114 1 200
Social investment and
environment
Corporate social investment spend Rm 10 228 177 195 124 114 141
1 Restated. Refer to pages 30 to 39 for further detail.
2 In accordance with Basel II principles relating to the treatment of insurance entities, insurance operations are excluded from the capital base of the banking group and
its related risk-weighted assets. Capital in insurance operations in excess of statutory minimum requirements is not recognised in group capital.
3 South African banking activities only.
4 Capital includes unappropriated profit.
* Automated.
** Compound annual growth rate.
STANDARD BANK GROUP ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
for the year ended 31 December 2023 336
-- 276 of 278 --
STANDARD BANK GROUP
LIMITED
Registration No. 1969/017128/06
Incorporated in the Republic of South
Africa
Website: www.standardbank.com
REGISTERED OFFICE
9th Floor, Standard Bank Centre
5 Simmonds Street, Johannesburg, 2001
PO Box 7725, Johannesburg, 2000
DIRECTORS
NMC Nyembezi (chairman), LL Bam,
S David-Borha3, PLH Cook, A Daehnke*,
GJ Fraser-Moleketi, Xueqing Guan1
(deputy chairman), GMB Kennealy,
BJ Kruger, Li Li1, JH Maree (deputy
chairman), NNA Matyumza,
ML Oduor-Otieno2, ANA Peterside CON3,
SK Tshabalala* (chief executive officer).
* Executive director 1 Chinese 2 Kenyan 3 Nigerian
All nationalities are South African, unless
otherwise specified.
HEAD OFFICE SWITCHBOARD
Tel: +27 11 636 9111
SHARE TRANSFER
SECRETARIES
IN SOUTH AFRICA
Computershare Investor Services
Proprietary Limited
Rosebank Towers, 15 Biermann Ave,
Rosebank, 2196
Private Bag X9000, Saxonwold, 2132,
South Africa
SHARE TRANSFER
SECRETARIES IN NAMIBIA
Transfer Secretaries (Proprietary)
Limited
4 Robert Mugabe Avenue, Windhoek,
Namibia
(Entrance in Burg Street)
PO Box 2401, Windhoek, Namibia
JSE SPONSOR
The Standard Bank of South Africa
Limited
NAMIBIAN SPONSOR
Simonis Storm Securities (Proprietary)
Limited
SHARE AND BOND CODES
JSE share code: SBK
ISIN: ZAE000109815
NSX share code: SNB ZAE000109815
A2X share code: SBK
SBKP ZAE000038881
(First preference shares)
SBPP ZAE000056339
(Second preference shares)
INVESTOR RELATIONS
Sarah Rivett-Carnac
Email:
Sarah.Rivett-Carnac@standardbank.co.za
CHIEF FINANCE & VALUE
MANAGEMENT OFFICER
Arno Daehnke
Email:
Arno.Daehnke@standardbank.co.za
GROUP SECRETARY
Kobus Froneman
Email:
Kobus.Froneman@standardbank.co.za
Direct all customer-related queries and comments to:
Information@standardbank.co.za
Direct all shareholder queries and comments to:
InvestorRelations@standardbank.co.za
WEBSITE:
www.standardbank.com
REFER TO
www.standardbank.com/
sbg/standard-bank-group/
investor-relations/results-
and-reports for a list of
definitions, acronyms and
abbreviations.
DISCLAIMER
This document contains certain statements that are “forward-looking” with respect to certain of the group’s plans, goals and expectations
relating to its future performance, results, strategies and objectives. Words such as “may”, “could”, “will”, “expect”, “intend”, “estimate”,
“anticipate”, “aim”, “outlook”, “believe”, “plan”, “seek”, “predict” or similar expressions typically identify forward-looking statements. These
forward-looking statements are not statements of fact or guarantees of future performance, results, strategies and objectives, and by their
involve risk and uncertainty because they relate to future events and circumstances which are difficult to predict and are beyond the group’s
control, including but not limited to, domestic and global economic business conditions, market-related risks such as fluctuations in interest rates
and exchange rates, the policies and actions of regulatory authorities (including changes related to capital and solvency requirements), the
impact of competition, inflation, deflation, the timing impact and other uncertainties of future acquisitions or combinations within relevant
industries, as well as the impact of changes in domestic and global legislation and regulations in the jurisdictions in which the group and its
affiliates operate. The group’s actual future performance, results, strategies and objectives may differ materially from the plans, goals and
expectations expressed or implied in the forward-looking statements. The group makes no representations or warranty, express or implied, that
these forward-looking statements will be achieved, and undue reliance should not be placed on such statements. The forward looking statements
in this document are not reviewed and reported on by the group’s external assurance providers. The group undertakes no obligation to update the
historical information or forward-looking statements in this document and does not assume responsibility for any loss or damage arising as a
result of the reliance by any party thereon.
www.standardbank.com
ADMINISTRATIVE AND CONTACT DETAILS
-- 277 of 278 --
-- 278 of 278 --